Upload
jorge-gautam
View
220
Download
0
Embed Size (px)
Citation preview
8/9/2019 Project Execution from POME by Gautam Koppala VT
1/127
1
1
Kanaka maha lakshmi Thalli
Be bold when you loose and be calm when youBe bold when you loose and be calm when you
win.win.
POMEPOMEPOMEPOMEPOMEPOMEPOMEPOME0707070707070707
"Changing the Face" can change nothing."Changing the Face" can change nothing.
But "Facing the Change" can change everything.But "Facing the Change" can change everything.
8/9/2019 Project Execution from POME by Gautam Koppala VT
2/127
22
8/9/2019 Project Execution from POME by Gautam Koppala VT
3/127
3
2007,POME,Gautam_Koppala,AllRightsRe
served
KANAKAMAHAL
AKSHMITHALLI
THIS
BOOKISDEDICATED
TOTHEALMIGHTY,WHO
A
LWAYSSH
OWERSHE
RBLESSIN
GSONHER
CHILD
REN.
8/9/2019 Project Execution from POME by Gautam Koppala VT
4/127
4
2007,POME,Gautam
_Koppala,AllRightsReserved
P
ROJECTSAND
OPERATIONS
MANA
GEMEN
TEXPOSED
(POME)
PartPROJECTEXE
CUTION
ACOLLECTIONAMELIORATEDBY
GAUTAMKOPPALAV.T.
8/9/2019 Project Execution from POME by Gautam Koppala VT
5/127
5
2007,POME,Gautam
_Koppala,AllRightsReserved
8/9/2019 Project Execution from POME by Gautam Koppala VT
6/127
6
6
8/9/2019 Project Execution from POME by Gautam Koppala VT
7/127
7
2007, POME, Gautam_Koppala, All Rights Reserved
You are the only person who can revolutionise your life.
You are the only person who can influence your happiness,
your realisation and your success.You are the only person who can help yourself.
Your life does not change, when your boss changes,
when your friends change, when your parents change,
when your partner changes, when your company changes.Your life changes when YOU change,
when you go beyond your limiting beliefs,
when you realize that you are the only one responsible for your life.
8/9/2019 Project Execution from POME by Gautam Koppala VT
8/127
8
2007,POME,Gautam
_Koppala,AllRightsReserved
Copyright2007POME
Allrightsreserved.Nopartofth
isproductmaybereproducedorutilizedinanyform
orbyany
means,
electronicormechanical,includingphotocopy,recording,broadcasting,or
byanyinformationst
orageor
retrievalsy
stem,withoutpermis
sioninwritingfrom
t
heauthorGautam
Ko
ppala.
Allknowled
geinPOMEbookiss
ervicemarksand/ortrademarksoftheaut
horGautam
Koppala.
Exceptasotherwisespecified,names,marks,logosa
ndthelikeusedinth
eeducational/teachin
g
contentof
thesematerialsarein
tendedtobe,andto
thebestofLicensors
[Gautam
Koppalas]
knowledge
andbeliefare,fictitio
us.Noneofthenames,marks,orlogosus
edhereinisintended
to
depictany
pastorpresentindividualorentity,orany
trademark,servicem
ark,orotherprotectable
markofan
yindividualorentity.
Anylikeness,similarityorsamenessbetw
eenanyname,mark,
orlogo
usedhereinbyLicensorandthe
name,mark,orlogo
ofanyindividualore
ntity,pastorpresent
,is
merelycoincidentalandunintentional.Anysuchnames,marks,andlogosusedinthe
educationa
l/teachingcontentof
thesematerialsareu
sedonlytoprovideexamplesforpurposes
of
teachingth
eeducationalcontentofthematerials,andareinnowayintendedtobeusedinany
trademark
senseormanner.
Thenames
ofactualpastorpresentindividuals,entit
ies,trademarks,servicemarks,logosand
thelike
(otherthan
thoseofLicensorusedintheeducational/teachingcontentofthesematerialsareus
edonly
toprovide
examples(includinginsomeinstancesactualcasestudiesbaseduponfactualevents
or
circumstan
cesinvolvingtheindividuals,entities,marks,orlogos)forpurposesofteachingthe
educationa
lcontentofthematerials.Anysuchnames
,marks,andlogosusedinthe
educationa
l/teachingcontentof
thesematerialsarein
tendedandusedsolelyforthepurposeof
providinge
xamplesandcasestu
dies,andareinnow
ayintendedtobeusedinanytrademarks
enseor
manner.
8/9/2019 Project Execution from POME by Gautam Koppala VT
9/127
9
2007,POME,Gautam
_Koppala,AllRightsReserved
VITA:FROMTHEAUTHOR:
Academically,Iam
acum
laude
graduatewithaBach
elorofTechnologydegreeinElectricaland
Electronics
Engineering(B-Tech
E.E.E.)andapostgraduateinMastersinHumanResources
Manageme
nt(M.H.R.M.)andMa
stersofForeignTrade(M.F.T.),allfrom
In
dia.
Myenginee
ringcompletedinar
emotevillageinIndia
,Srikakulam,andits
beenalongjourney
from
there,and
journeystillcontinues.Ifeelthisbookde
monstratesmyability
tomaintaindedication,
motivation
andenthusiasm
fora
projectmanagementoveralongperiodo
ftime.Ibelievethat
in
combinatio
nwithmyextensivebroad-basedoperationsworkexperiencealongwithmydrive,
8/9/2019 Project Execution from POME by Gautam Koppala VT
10/127
8/9/2019 Project Execution from POME by Gautam Koppala VT
11/127
8/9/2019 Project Execution from POME by Gautam Koppala VT
12/127
12
2007,POME,Gautam
_Koppala,AllRightsReserved
8/9/2019 Project Execution from POME by Gautam Koppala VT
13/127
13
2007,POME,Gautam
_Koppala,AllRightsRes
erved
GRA
CEF
U
LEX
ITS
FR
O
MTR
OUB
LED
PRO
J
ECTS
8/9/2019 Project Execution from POME by Gautam Koppala VT
14/127
14
2007,POME,Gautam
_Koppala,AllRightsRes
erved
Gracef
ulExitsfromT
roubledProjects
Projectscanfailforanynumber
ofreasons...poorde
finition,poorplanning,lackofcommitmen
t....and
thelistgoe
son.Nomatterthereason,whenyoufind
yourselfinthemidstofatroubledproject,you
needaway
out---quickly,clean
lyandwithminimaldamage.
But,beforeyourushtocancelanyproject,youneedtobecertaint
hatcancellationisthebest
andmost
viableoption.
Assumption
:Towarrantatroubledprojectassessmen
t,youshouldhaveclearandcrediblesignsthata
projectisin
trouble-i.e.youarebehindschedule,de
liverablesarenotworkingoutasplanned,
the
projectteam
isnotworkingwelltogether.Toconductaneffectivereviewofthetroubledproject,the
followingquestionsmustbeconsideredandaddressed.
Whyistheprojectfailing?
Aswehave
alreadynoted,proje
ctsmaybeheadedto
wardsfailureforany
numberorcombinationof
reasons.Ifyouaretoreactproperly,youmustbeab
letoreadilyidentifythosereasonsasthey
applyto
aprojectathand.
Thefollowinglistprovidesafewillustrationsofthenum
erouspotentialproblems...
PoorConcept
PoorPlanning
Lack
ofResources
Lack
ofFunding
OverlyAggressiveSchedules
TechnicalProblems
VendorFailures
BusinessPrioritiesHaveC
hanged
Lack
ofSkills
PoorlyDefinedScope,De
liverablesorObjectives
Insu
fficientManagement
Oversight
Lack
ofTeam
Commitment
Lack
ofManagementSup
port
Other.....
Canthisp
rojectbesavedby
anyofthefollowingactions....
Re-workingprojectplans?
Reducingprojectscope?
Reviseddeliverables?
8/9/2019 Project Execution from POME by Gautam Koppala VT
15/127
15
2007,POME,Gautam
_Koppala,AllRightsRes
erved
Staf
fchanges?
Changingmanagement?
Revisedschedules?
Addingmorefunds?
Reorganizingtheprojectteam?
Stre
ngtheningmanagementoversight?
Som
eothermethod.....?
Iscancellationpossible?
Itmaybed
ifficult,ifnotimpossible,tocancelcertain
projects,nomatterh
owtroubledtheymaybe.
Theseproje
ctsmayjustbetooc
riticalortoovisible.
Inthisinstance,you
willneedtolooktowa
rds
repairasa
solution....takingall
possiblestepstosalv
agetheprojectinlieuofcancellation.
Whatare
thebenefitsofcancellation?
Whenyoucancelaproject,youneedtobesurethatcancellationisthebes
tcourseofaction.Project
cancellation
canyieldmanybenefits,eventhoughits
ignalstheendofapr
eviouslychosenproje
ct
initiative.Whenaprojectiscancelleditcansavemoney,time,andfreeup
resourcestoworkonmore
important,
potentiallysuccessfulprojects.
Doyouha
vecancellationcon
sensus?
Projectmanagersrarelyhavetheabilitytocancelaprojectunilaterally,andeveniftheydid,itwouldbe
unwisetoe
xercisethatpowerwithoutconsultationan
dconsensus.Acance
lledprojectisnotnecessarily
amanagem
entfailure,particularlywhenthecancellat
ionisappropriateandtimely.Butitisimp
ortant
tohavethe
buy-inofallkeyprojectparticipants-spo
nsors,management,
end-usersandteam
members.
Whatisth
ecancellationimpactonthefollowing
....?
ProjectStaff
End-Users
ContractualObligations
RegulatoryRequirements
ITC
redibility
Inte
rnalPolitics
OtherProjectsUnderway
OtherImpactConsiderations....?
8/9/2019 Project Execution from POME by Gautam Koppala VT
16/127
16
2007,POME,Gautam
_Koppala,AllRightsRes
erved
Willcance
llationbetemporaryorpermanent?
Itmaybep
ossibletoreviveatroubledprojectatalaterdate,whentiming
andcircumstancemayyield
betterresults.
PLANNING
THECANCELLATION:
Shouldyou
rassessmentshowth
atcancellationisthe
best,mostappropriatecourseofaction,th
at
cancellation
shouldbeconducted
inastructured,orde
rlyfashion.....
Prep
areaProjectCancellationStatement,explainingwhy,howand
whentheprojectisto
be
canc
elled.
Consultwithsupportingd
epartmentsasneede
d....(i.e.LegalandH
umanResources)toensure
that
yourcancellationapp
roachisappropriate.
Obtainallnecessarymanagementapprovals.
Informtheprojectteam
andallmajorstakeholders.
Form
allyannouncethepr
ojectcancellationasneededaccordingtothenatureandvisibilityofthe
projectathand.
Re-a
ssignprojectteam
m
emberstootherprojectsortoreturntore
gularworkassignments.
Rele
asecontractorsandt
emporarystaffasneeded.
Com
pleteapostprojectr
eview.
Fina
lizeprojectdocumentationandretainasneededforfutureproje
cts,orforanypotential
projectrevitalization.
ConcludedNote:
Itisimportanttorememberthatprojectcancellationandfailurearenotthesamething,whyyo
umay
sometimes
needtocanceltroubleprojects,thatveryactofrecognitioncan
beasignofmanagement
strengthan
dsuccess.
8/9/2019 Project Execution from POME by Gautam Koppala VT
17/127
17
2007,POME,Gautam
_Koppala,AllRightsRes
erved
POMEPrescribe:
Givemorethanyou
plannedto.
G
POMEPrescribe
8/9/2019 Project Execution from POME by Gautam Koppala VT
18/127
18
2007,POME,Gautam
_Koppala,AllRightsRes
erved
PRO
JECT
ME
THOD
OLO
GY
8/9/2019 Project Execution from POME by Gautam Koppala VT
19/127
8/9/2019 Project Execution from POME by Gautam Koppala VT
20/127
20
2007,POME,Gautam
_Koppala,AllRightsRes
erved
methodolog
ylowerscost,reduce
sresourcerequireme
ntsforsupport,minim
izespaperwork,and
eliminatesduplicatedefforts.
Figure:Integratedprocesses
(past,present,andfu
ture).
Thecharacteristicsofagoodmethodologybasedupon
integratedprocessesinclude:
Arecommendedlevelofd
etail
Use
oftemplates
Stan
dardizedplanning,sc
heduling,andcostco
ntroltechniques
Stan
dardizedreportingformatforbothin-hous
eandcustomeruse
Flexibilityforapplicationt
oallprojects
Flexibilityforrapidimprovements
Easy
forthecustomertounderstandandfollow
Readilyacceptedandusedthroughouttheentirecompany
Use
ofstandardizedlife-cyclephases(whichca
noverlap)andendofphasereviews
Base
duponguidelinesratherthanpoliciesand
procedures
Base
duponagoodworkethic
Methodolog
iesdonotmanagepr
ojects;peopledo.Itisthecorporateculturethatexecutesthe
methodolog
y.Seniormanagementmustcreateacorp
orateculturethatsup
portsprojectmanagement
anddemonstratesfaithinthemethodology.Ifthisisdonesuccessfully,the
nthefollowingbenefitscan
beexpected:
Faster"timetomarket"throughbettercontroloftheproject'sscope
Loweroverallprojectrisk
8/9/2019 Project Execution from POME by Gautam Koppala VT
21/127
21
2007,POME,Gautam
_Koppala,AllRightsRes
erved
Betterdecision-makingpr
ocess
Grea
tercustomersatisfac
tion,whichleadstoincreasedbusiness
More
timeavailableforva
lue-addedefforts,ratherthaninternalpoliticsandinternalcompetition
Onecompanyfoundthatitscustomerslikeditsmetho
dologysomuchandthattheprojectswere
so
successful,
thattherelationshipbetweenthecontractorandthecustomerimprovedtothepoint
where
thecustomersbegantreatingthecontractorasapartnerratherthanasas
upplier.
POMEhase
stablishedprojectandworkforcemanagem
ent,projectengineeringandprojectcontr
olsas
coreprofessionalcompetency,whichisneededtoaccomplishstrategicbusinessobjectivesanda
competitive
advantageinourma
rketplace.Theseare
combinedintotheProjectMethodology(PM
)to
providethe
frameworkthatwillf
acilitateindividualandcorporatesuccessinprojectexecution.P
Mhas
evolvedove
rtimetakingthebes
tofestablishedproce
duresfrom
pastprojecteffortsandexperiences,
combiningt
hem
withadvancedc
onceptsandstate-of-
the-artpracticesthat
retainsourstatusof
best-in-
classcompaniesinprojectexecu
tion.ThePMapproachtoprojectexecution
addressesthefollow
ing
aspects:
Developingandassigning
professionalprojectmanagers,engineers
andprojectcontrols
spec
ialists.
8/9/2019 Project Execution from POME by Gautam Koppala VT
22/127
22
2007,POME,Gautam
_Koppala,AllRightsRes
erved
Establishingandusingac
onsistentprocessand
acommonapproach
toprojectmanagem
ent,
engineeringandcontrolsforallprojectteams
Addr
essingprojectengine
eringdisciplinesinclu
dinghardwareandsiteservices,systems
engineering,processcont
rolapplicationsinclud
ingbatchandadvanc
edapplications,safety
systemengineering,operatoreffectiveness,asseteffectiveness,plantbusinessprocess
effec
tivenessexpandinga
sneededtocoverCo
mpany'sportfolio
Clearidentificationofresu
ltingdeliverablesand
thestakeholders'rolesandresponsibilitie
s
Prov
idinganalysisofdata,productionofinform
ation,standardrepor
tingandaccuratepre
diction
ofpr
ojectcost,scheduleandperformance
Prov
idingeffectivetools,techniques,training,performancemeasure
sandcontinuous
impr
ovement
Align
ingprojectmanagem
entservicestoprovideoversightandongo
ingsupportforproject
man
agersandmaintenanceofthePMmethodo
logy
PMisamaj
orpartoftheoverall
methodologyrespons
iblefortheanalysiso
fdata,productionof
information
andtheaccuratepre
dictionofprojectcost,scheduleandperformance.ProjectContr
ols
assistsprojectmanagementwith
theestablishmentan
dcontrolledadjustmenttotheprojectbas
elines.
ProjectControlsistheinterfacet
oAccountingFinance
toensuretheprojectisfollowingcorrect
accounting
procedures.TheAcco
untingProceduresan
dbasicsareillustrate
dinAccountingChapters.
Haveagrip
onit.ProjectManage
rsstrengthisingras
pingthecommercialaspectsratherthanany
others.
PMProces
sMaps
Theoverallprojectdeliveryprocessisdefinedbyphas
es,supportingproces
sesandinterfacesas
shown
below.The
projectdeliveryproce
ssiscommonlydescribedbyahighlevel,
4-PhasemodelofConcept,
Planning,Im
plementationandCloseout.Theterm
LeadershipTeamisused
toincludetheProject
ManagerplustheLeadsassigned
from
ProjectControlsandProjectEnginee
ringwhoeachhavea
rolein
theoverallmanagementandcon
troloftheproject.Th
eseactivitiesaresho
wninyellow.Thetechnical
efforttobe
supportedbyEngineeringDisciplinesthatproviderefinedtools,
bestpractices,exam
plesand
acommunitythatownsandmain
tainsthisdisciplines
pecificcontent.Theo
verallprojectdelivery
processiss
hownbelow:
8/9/2019 Project Execution from POME by Gautam Koppala VT
23/127
23
2007, POME, Gautam_Koppala, All Rights Reserved
8/9/2019 Project Execution from POME by Gautam Koppala VT
24/127
24
2007,POME,Gautam
_Koppala,AllRightsReserved
POMEPrescribe:
AboutAcros
sBorders-It'sagloba
lworld!
Whet
herworkingwithoffshoreteamsorjustadiverse
groupathome,today'sprojectenvironmentis
multicultural.Beopentoandawareofyourprojectsta
keholders'cultures.Not
onlyshouldwerespectour
collea
gues'cultures,butweshouldunderstandandEXPERIENCEthem.Goo
utforDimsumwiththeteamor
learn
anewphraseinanotherlanguage.(allpm.com)
Cross-culturalglobalrelations
:
a)Planextratimetomodelrequirementswhenworkingcross-culturally.
While
modelingisanexcellen
ttoolforovercomingsomecross-culturalcommu
nicationissues,multi-cu
ltural
projectmanagementmaystill
takeextratimetogettherequirementsandensu
rethatimportantfactsa
re
captu
red.
b)Itisimportanttoplanmo
retimeforcapturingreq
uirementswhenworking
inmulti-culturalenvironments.
c)MeetinginPersontoDevelopRelationshipsSavesTimeandMoneyinth
eLongRun.Insomecultures
tasks
arecompletedbasedon
establishedrelationship
sand,ultimately,trust,ratherthansimplybeing
drivenby
schedules.Attemptingtoforgeaheadwithtasksbeforespendingsocialtimew
ithclientscanwellleadto
incom
pleterequirements.Whileitmaynotbestandardpracticealloverthewo
rld,whenPMsareworkingin
some
otherculturestakingthetimetomeetface-to-facecansavetimeandmo
neyforyourprojectand
organ
ization.
POMEPrescribe
8/9/2019 Project Execution from POME by Gautam Koppala VT
25/127
25
2007,POME,Gautam
_Koppala,AllRightsReserved
Enjoylifetoday
yesterd
ayisgone,
tomorrowmay
nevercome.
EPOMEPrescribe
8/9/2019 Project Execution from POME by Gautam Koppala VT
26/127
26
2007,POME,Gautam_Koppala,AllRightsReserved
OU
TSOU
RCED
PR
O
JECT
WORK:
C
HOICE
OR
NE
CESS
ITY?
8/9/2019 Project Execution from POME by Gautam Koppala VT
27/127
27
2007,POME,Gautam_Koppala,AllRightsReserved
Outsou
rcedProjectW
ork:Choiceo
rNecessity?
Projectsma
ybeoutsourcedfora
nynumberofreasons,eitherbychoiceor
necessity.Butonethingis
clearoutsourcingdoesnotequalsimplicity.Whileou
tsourcingmayeliminatecertainin-house
headaches,
theaddedoutsourcin
goverheadcreatesa
newlayerofcomplex
ityandresponsibility
forthe
internalprojectmanager.Justco
nsidertheseexample
s:
Whenyouo
utsourceaproject(in
part,orasawhole),
youwillhaveto.....
Make
theoutsourcingdecision.
Find
therightcontractor/c
onsultant.
Nego
tiateandmanageproposals,bidsandcontracts.
Rely
onanexternaloperationwhereyouhavelittleinfluence.
Clearlydefinethe"visionthing"(youwonthav
etheluxuryofinternalfamiliarityand"cultural"
assumption).
Manageanadministrative
overheadforaccountspayablepurposes.
Educ
atethecontractor/consultantoninternalp
rocedures,goalsand
operationalrequirements..
Trackprojectprogresswit
houtdirectauthority,
relyingonprojectstaffthatmaynotbe"v
isible"
toyo
u.
Manageinternalmoraleandlackof"in-houseo
wnership"issues.
Plan
forknowledgetransfertomaintaindeliverablesonanoperation
albasis.
Asthislistillustrates,theoutsourcedprojectpresents
alitanyofuniquecha
llenges,whichmustbe
recognizedandaddressedtoensuresuccessfulresults.Aswithmostmanag
ementdecisions,
"outsourcing"viabilitycanbestbedeterminedthrough
astructuredprocessforanalysisandplanning.
TheOutsourcingDecision
8/9/2019 Project Execution from POME by Gautam Koppala VT
28/127
28
2007,POME,Gautam_Koppala,AllRightsReserved
Manyprojec
tsareoutsourcedfor
avarietyofreasonssometimesoutofchoice,andsometimes
,outof
necessity.W
henoutsourcingisa
matterofnecessity,thereasonswillusual
lybeobviousandclear-cut:
Lack
of"in-house"timedu
etootherprojectsandworkloaddemands
.
Higher"in-house"costsdu
etolearningcurvesandconflictingworkplacepriorities.
Lack
ofrequiredinternals
kills,resourcesande
xperience.
Politicalconsiderations(i.e.thesensitivenatureofaproject).
Whenprojectoutsourcingisama
tterofchoice,thede
cisioncomesdownto
abalancingofcosts
and
benefits.Th
iscost/benefitanalysiscanbesummarized
viathefollowingseriesofdefiningquestio
ns:
Willoutsourcinghelpyoutodelivertheproject
onafastertimetable,andisafaster"time
to
mark
et"animperativefor
thisproject?
Willoutsourcinghelpyoutodelivertheproject
atlowercosts,andis
"lowestcost"aprimarygoal
forthisproject?
Willoutsourcinghelpyoutodeliverbetterresults(improveddelivera
bles)?
Willoutsourcinghelpyoutorealizeshortterm
productivitybenefits?
Willoutsourcinghelpyoutorealizelongterm
p
roductivitybenefits?
Whataretherisksanddrawbacksofoutsourcin
g?
How
dotherisksofoutsourcedprojectdelivery
comparewiththerisksof"in-house"proje
ct
delivery?
Asthesequestionsareappliedan
dconsideredintheo
utsourcingdecisionp
rocess,project
characteristicsmustalsobeexam
ined.Certaintypeso
fprojectswillbemor
esuitedtooutsourcin
gthan
others.Whileindividualcircumsta
nceswillvary,thefo
llowingelementscan
beusedasanalytical
benchmarks
:
Expertise.Whatisthelevelofexpertiserequiredtocompletetheproject.In-housestaff
may
lackthenecessaryskillsfo
rahigh-techprojects.
Nov
elty.Whatistheleve
lofinnovationrequiredtocompletethispr
oject?In-housestaff
maybe
need
edforhighlyuniqueprojects,leavingmore
routineprojectstoo
utsourcedproviders.
OrganizationalReach.H
owdeepisthe"orga
nizationalreach"ofthisproject?Projectsh
aving
anextensiveimpactoninternaloperationsmay
betoocomplexforo
utsourcingintheentirety.
Dep
endencies:Whatisthelevelofdependencyon,andconnection
with,otherprojects?
Linked
proje
ctsmaynotbewells
uitedtoindividualizedoutsourcing.
OutsourcingOptions
8/9/2019 Project Execution from POME by Gautam Koppala VT
29/127
29
2007,POME,Gautam_Koppala,AllRightsReserved
Considering
theissues,character
isticsandinternalinfluences,outsourcingdoesnothavetobeanallor
nothingproposition.Outsourcing
canbeusedasanop
erationalalternative,
oritcanbeusedast
rategic
toolforprojectdelivery.Forexam
ple,youmaychoose
tooutsourceanentireproject(managementand
all),andjus
tmaintainan"in-hou
se"coordinationresponsibility.Or,youcan
choosetooutsource
specific
projectelem
ents,bydeliverableorphase,basedonne
eds,benefits,costsa
ndtiming.
Tofacilitate
thisdecision-making
process,projectscan
beviewedasaserie
sofoperationalcomp
onents:
TheVisionThing(StrategiesandTactics)
DaytoDayManagement(
IssuesTrackingandResolution,Baselines,ResourceManageme
nt)
Plann
ing(Scheduling,TasksandResourceAlloc
ation)
Deliv
erablesDesignandD
evelopment
Testi
ng(DeliverablesVerification)
Docu
mentation(ProjectDocumentsandTechnicalDocuments)
Administration(Logistics,Purchasing,Paperwor
k)
Implementation(Installation,SupportandOwn
ershipTransition)
Eachofthes
ecomponentsmustbeexaminedtodetermineoutsourcingviab
ility:
1.Canthiscomponentbeou
tsourced?
2.Shou
ldthiscomponentbe
outsourced?
3.How
willanypartiallyouts
ourcedcomponentsb
eintegratedintothe
projectasawhole?
Outsourcin
gforSuccess
Outsourcing
successisnotguaranteedwhentheinitialoutsourcingdecision
ismade.Managemen
t
standardsandbestpracticesmus
tbeappliedtotheou
tsourcedprojectwith
thesamedegreeof
enthusiasm
asthetraditionalin-h
ouseproject.Thefollowingguidelinesprovideyouwithabestp
ractices
snapshotfortheoutsourcedproject:
Make
fullyinformedoutsourcingdecisions,analyzingneeds,costsan
dbenefits.
Cons
idertheoutsourcingintangibles(employee
moraleandprideof
ownership).
Clearlydefineallprojectg
oals,requirementsan
ddeliverables.
Choo
setherightoutsourcingpartnerconsiderin
gprojectneeds,experience,andcapabilities.
Docu
mentallexpectations
andobligationsinfo
rmalcontractsandStatementofWorkdoc
uments.
Identifyalllikelyrisksand
developprojectcont
ingencyplansshould
outsourcingproblemsarise.
Keep
projectchangestoa
minimum.Continualchangescanwreckhavoconanoutsource
d
proje
ctwhere"requirements"aredefinedaspa
rtofacontractualobligation.
Sche
duleandholdregular
statusmeetingswith
contractorsandconsultants.Makesureth
at
week
lystatusreportsare
includedinallcontractsandagreements.I
ftheprojectworkisbeing
done
off-site,schedulereg
ularvisitstocontractorlocationsifatallp
ossible.
8/9/2019 Project Execution from POME by Gautam Koppala VT
30/127
30
2007,POME,Gautam_Koppala,AllRightsReserved
Keep
in-housestaffinform
edofalloutsourcing
issuesthatmayimpa
ctinternalprojectwo
rk.
Besu
retoconductanin-h
ousereviewofalloutsourcedprojectstoidentifysuccesspoints
,
problemsandtolearnfrom
theexperience.
Insummary
,outsourcingisatoo
lforprojectdelivery,
andaswithanyothe
rtool,itsusemustbe
carefullywe
ighed,plannedandm
anagedforsuccess
8/9/2019 Project Execution from POME by Gautam Koppala VT
31/127
31
2007,POME,Gautam_Koppala,AllRightsRese
rved
TIME
SHE
ETS
3 TTmicceLtTeTfaNSTdNrttT
8/9/2019 Project Execution from POME by Gautam Koppala VT
32/127
32
2007,POME,Gautam_Koppala,AllRightsRese
rved
TimeSheetsMonitoring:
Thefollowingformatmethodologyhasbeenenclosed.
Rulesrelatedtothetimereporting(bymeansof
man-hourstobechargedtoproje
cts)areanimportantpreconditionforproperProjectControlling.This
isusedform
onitoringthe
Pr
oductivityandtheusageoftheindividualresources.Thisisab
asefor
costandPro
ductivityvariancesanalysis.Internalcostofdeputationshall,th
erefore,becalculatedand
chargedtot
heorder,basedondefinedcoststructuringandmonthlytimesheetspreparedbythe
engineers,inlinewiththeratesc
ircular.Theseshould
beauthorizedbythe
ProjectManager/Group
Leader.The
costestimationmust
beguidedbyTimePlanCatalogue,previousexperience/repea
tjobs
takennoteo
f.
Themonthly
timesheetsfillingin
&monitoringbygrou
pleaderswillassistinstreamliningthecost
estimation/a
ctualcostduringoffe
rstage&alsoorderstage.
Theenginee
rshouldkeepatrack
ofthetimespentfor
thevariousactivities
onadaytodaybasisand
fillupthesa
mefrom
theserecord
swhilefillingupthe
timesheet.Theextra
hoursarealsotobe
filledin
aspertheir
classificationforeffec
tivemonitoring.
Normally,timesheetsbeenfilled
andsentthroughPMISorsomeotherERP.
Startwithth
erecordingofeveryo
nestime.
Timerecordingalsohastheadvantagethatitappliest
oeveryoneintheorg
anization,from
theC
EO
downtothe
shopfloorassistant.
Ifthepresidentdoes
it,thenwhyshouldn
tI?
Nowtimere
cordingalsoisntallt
hatsimple,becausethereshouldbesome
uniformityinwhatpe
ople
recordtime
against.Anecdote:I
mbuildingacathedralvs.Im
haulingbricks.Recordingtime
thereforerequiresacentraldefinitionofwhatpeoplecanrecordtimeagains
t:approvedprojects,
or
tacticalaims
,orwhatever,tosay
whattheyhavebeen
busywith.
TimeSheetsSampleFormat:
3 P
8/9/2019 Project Execution from POME by Gautam Koppala VT
33/127
33
2007,POME,Gautam_Koppala,AllRightsRese
rved
POMEPrescribe:
Dontgiveu
panddont
give
in.
D
POMEPrescribe
3
8/9/2019 Project Execution from POME by Gautam Koppala VT
34/127
34
2007,POME,Gautam_
Koppala,AllRightsRese
rved
ISSU
ES
MA
NAGEMEN
T
3
IsIsoLodansumOwitdreJuthA
8/9/2019 Project Execution from POME by Gautam Koppala VT
35/127
5
2007,POME,Gautam_
Koppala,AllRightsRese
rved
ssuesManagement
ssueshap
pen.Asanyprojec
tproceeds,questio
nsandproblemsarise,andifthecour
seor
outcomeoftheprojecthangs
inthebalance,thenan"issue"isborn
.
ookingatthisdefinition,itappea
rsasifprojectissues
andrisksareonean
dthesame.Althoughthe
istinctionsmaybesubtleinnatu
re,issuesdifferfrom
risksintermsofpred
ictabilityandmanagement
pproach.T
hefactthatissueswillariseispredictable,
butthespecificsubs
tanceofanygivenissueis
ot.Risksa
repredictablecircumstances,thosewhich
shouldbeidentifiedb
eforeaprojectbegins.As
uch,longtermstrategiescanbe
developedtoavoids
aidrisks,allowingfor
theapplicationofdefined
managemen
tsolutionsshouldthe
riskberealized.
Ontheotherhand,issuescanpopupatanytimedurin
gaproject,andmus
tbedealtwithquickly,
withoutthebenefitofpre-defined
solutions.Typically,
projectissuesinvolvetheprojectdeliverable
tself,inthe
form
ofunexpectedt
echnicalproblems,incompatibilities,bugsorotherconflicts.Ho
wever,
uringthecourseofaproject,itislikelythatotherissueswillalsoarise,relatingtoprojectsched
ules,
esources,m
aterials,finances,or
otherunexpectedchangesintheprojecte
nvironment.
ustbecause
youcan'tpredictissues,doesn'tmeanyo
ushouldn'tbeprepar
edtohandleissueso
nce
heyarrive.
Everyprojectshould
beginwithadefined
processforissuesma
nagement.
Aneffective
issuesmanagementprocessshouldcoverthefollowingbases:
ProjectPartneringFramework
36
A
tomloPWa
nIsprIs
an
IsIsIsIsIs
8/9/2019 Project Execution from POME by Gautam Koppala VT
36/127
6
2007,POME,Gautam_
Koppala,AllRightsRese
rved
Goals:whatareyoutryingtoaccomplishwiththeprocess?Inalllik
elihood,yourissuesprocess
shouldbedesignedtoensurethatallissuesare
identifiedandresolvedinatimelyfashion,
keepingallpartiesinforme
dasneededtogetth
ejobdone.
Capabilities:whattoolsw
illbeusedtoraise,r
esolve,andtrackissu
esastheyariseandasthey
areclosed?
Orig
ination:howwillissu
esberaisedtothepr
ojectmanager?
Evaluation:howwillissue
sbereviewedandas
signed?
Trac
king:howwillissues
bemonitoredandtra
ckedfortimelyresolu
tion?
Esca
lation:howwillissue
sbeescalatedinthe
eventtheycannotbe
resolvedandclosed?
lloftheserequirementsshouldbereflectedinyourissuesmanagementmechanism,consistingofthe
oolsandproceduresbywhichiss
uesareraised,resolv
edandmanaged.Yo
urissuesmanagement
mechanism
willhavetwoelements....aphysicalelement(software,onlineform,paperform)anda
ogicalelement(managementstrategiesandprocedure
s).
hysicalIs
sueManagementM
echanisms:
Whetheryou
trackprojectissues
onapieceofpaper,o
rinadatabasesyste
m,youwillneedtocollect
ndtrackthefollowingtypesofin
formation:
ssueType:tocategorizeissues
foreasierassignmen
tandtracking.Issue
categoriesmayvary
be
rojecttype,butcanusuallyinclu
dethefollowing:
Technical:anissuerelatingtothetechnicalaspectsoftheprojectprocessordeliverable.
Finan
cial:anissuerelating
toprojectfunding,s
pendingorbudget.
Resource:anissuerelatin
gtoprojectresources(equipmentorpeop
le).
Schedule:anissueinvolvingtheprojecttimeline.
Other:auniqueissuespec
ifictotheprojectathand.
ssueDesc
ription:toidentifythespecificnatureand
impactoftheissue(whatistheissueallabout
ndhowdoe
sitimpacttheprojec
tintermsofdelivera
bles,schedule,costs,
scopeorotherparam
eter?).
ssueOriginator:whofirstraise
dtheissue?
ssueDate:thedatetheissuew
asraised.
ssueOwn
er:whoisresponsible
forissueresolution?
ssueIden
tifier:auniquecode
ornumbertotrackissuestatus.
ssueStatus:totrackissuestatus:
Open
:Issueresolutionha
snotyetbegun.
InProgress:Issueresolut
ionisunderway.
Close
d:Theissuehasbee
nresolved.
Escalated:Theissuehasbeenescalatedforfur
thermanagementaction.
37
IscoTaRe
On
na
un
ca
ha
mof
Amca
An
firgiv
pe
ac
we
Co
As
imreprP
O
8/9/2019 Project Execution from POME by Gautam Koppala VT
37/127
7
2007,POME,Gautam_
Koppala,AllRightsRese
rved
ssuePriority:toensurethatis
suesaredealtwithappropriatelyconsideringimpactand
onsequence
s:
High
Priority:Issueshavin
gamajorimpactontheproject,requiring
immediateattention.
Mediu
m:Issueshaveam
oderateimpactontheproject,requiringat
tentioninthenearfu
ture.
Low:
Issueshavinganinsi
gnificantimpactonth
eproject,requiringa
ttentionatsomefutu
redate
iftim
epermits,ornotata
ll.
argetCom
pletionDate:toest
ablishatimeframefo
rresolution.
esolution
Description:toidentifythestepstakentoaddressandresolvetheissue.
nceanissu
eisraisedanddocum
ented,resourceassignmentsmustbemade.Dependingonthe
atureoftheissue,anyprojectte
ammemberorresou
rcemaybeinvolved.
Forexample,an
nexpectedbuginapieceofsoftwarewilllikelybeass
ignedtoatechnicalteam
member,whomaybe
alledupontoresolvetheproblem
,orwhomayhavet
otracktheproblem
w
ithavendor.Onthe
other
and,anissueofanadministrativ
enature(i.e.thelackofavailablefacilities
forstagingnewequipment)
aybeassignedtoafacilitiesma
nager,whomayothe
rwisehavelimitedinvolvementinotheras
pects
ftheprojec
t.
keychallengeinissuesmanage
mentisknowinghow
tomakeeffectiveissuesassignments.Sin
ce
ostissues
mustberesolvedquickly,withlittlefanfare,itisimportanttoassignissuestothosewho
anhittheg
roundrunningwhene
verpossible.
notherkey
challengeintheissuesprocessistotrack
issuestatus,from
thepointatwhichissuesare
rstraiseda
ndassigned,through
toresolution.Depen
dinguponthecomplexityandvisibilityofany
venproject,youmayneedtoholdongoingissuesme
etings..Issuesmeetingscanbringanimportant
erspectivetotheprojectprocess
,providingtheoppor
tunityfortheentireteam
toconsiderissue
s,plan
ctionsandtakea"bigpicture"perspective.Theseme
etingscantakeplace
asneeded,onadaily,
eeklyormonthlybasis,toensur
ethatissuesareproperlytrackedandmanaged.
oncluded
Note:
syouwork
toresolveissues,youneedtolookatsolu
tionsthatcansolvetheproblem,withthe
least
mpactonth
eprojectschedule,budgetandscope.Whenhandledquickly,is
suesoffertheopportunityto
efineandim
proveprojectresults
.Inaddition,anyorganizedissuesmanag
ementrecordwilllike
ly
rovidevaluableinsightsandexperiencesforyournextproject.
OMEPrescr
ibe
38
8/9/2019 Project Execution from POME by Gautam Koppala VT
38/127
8
2007,POME,Gautam_
Koppala,AllRightsRese
rved
C
onsiderthingsfrom
every
angle.
C
POMEPrescri
be
39
8/9/2019 Project Execution from POME by Gautam Koppala VT
39/127
2007,POME,Gautam_
Koppala,AllRightsRese
rved
PRO
JECT
EVAL
UATI
ON(FOR
MA
C
RO
PRO
JE
CTS)
40
Pr
Pu
The
ope
lea
Do
The
orig
#
8/9/2019 Project Execution from POME by Gautam Koppala VT
40/127
2007,POME,Gautam_
Koppala,AllRightsRese
rved
roject
EvaluationTemplates(forMacroProjects):
Initiating,
Planning,
Executing,
Controlling
EvaluateKeyAspects
ofProject
TransitionProjectto
Operations
DocumentLessons
Learned
Closing
Project
Evaluation
rposeof
theProjectEvaluationTemplates
epurpose
oftheProjectEvalua
tiontemplatesistoevaluatetheproject,transitiontheprojectt
o
erations,p
rovideabasisforfee
dbacktotheprojectteam
andmanagement,todocumentthelessons
rnedtoim
provetheprocessan
dfutureprojectpotential.
ocumentChangeActivity
efollowingisarecordofthech
angesthathaveoccu
rredonthisdocumen
tfrom
thetimeofits
ginalappr
oval
Change
Description
Auth
or
Date
41
This
add
DE
Doc
Inte
egreeof
attainmentofobjective
uccessFactors
atureandcausesofvariances
GREEOF
ATTAINMENTOFB
UDGETOBJECTIVES
atethePla
nnedCostandFundin
gfortheproject,asapprovedintheInteg
ratedProjectPlan.S
tate
eActualCostandFundingatcompletion.Document
andexplainallcostandfundingvariances,
ludingapp
rovedchangestothe
costbaseline.
42
Exp
Int
Se
So
Ha
Ma
Su
Fa
Te
sTra
Co
To
Fun
Ge
No
Ce
Ot
To
DEG
Com
any
8/9/2019 Project Execution from POME by Gautam Koppala VT
42/127
2007,POME,Gautam_
Koppala,AllRightsReserved
penditur
es($000)
Planned
Actual
Variance
Explanation
ternalSta
ffLabor
ervice
oftwareTo
ols
ardware
aterialsan
d
upplies
cilities
elecommunication
aining
ontingency(Risk)
otal
ndingSo
urce($000)
Planned
Actual
Variance
Explanation
eneralFun
d
on-Genera
lFund
entral
ther
otal
GREEOF
ADHERENCETOSC
HEDULE
mparethe
approvedscheduleb
aselineagainsttheactualcompletiondates.Documentandexp
lain
yschedule
variances,including
approvedchangesto
theschedulebaseline.
43
DEG
Doc
Sch
DEG
Doc
DEG
Indi
decr
DEG
List
cont
1.
2.
3.TR
A
8/9/2019 Project Execution from POME by Gautam Koppala VT
43/127
2007,POME,Gautam_
Koppala,AllRightsReserved
GREEOF
SATISFACTIONOF
USERREQUIREMEN
TS
cumentan
ychangestotheReq
uirementsandtheirimpactonPerformanc
e,Cost,Qualityor
eduleBaselines.
GREEOF
REALIZATIONOFANTICIPATEDBENE
FITS
cumentth
eprimarybenefitsob
tainedbytheproject.
GREEOF
PRODUCTIVITY-EXPERIENCED
icatethe
productivityleveloftheprojectandfactorsthatcausedincreasedperformance,aswellas,
reasedpe
rformance.
GREEOF
DELIVERYPROJECTDELIVERABLES
themajo
rProjectDeliverables
andthedateeachw
asacceptedbytheuser.Identifyany
tingenciesorconditionsrelatedtotheacceptance.
D
eliverable
Date
Accepted
Contingencieso
rConditions
ANSITIO
NTOSERVICESANDMAINTENANCE
44
Desc
belo
serv
wha
Sam
8/9/2019 Project Execution from POME by Gautam Koppala VT
44/127
2007,POME,Gautam_Koppala,AllRightsReserved
cribethe
planforservicesandmaintenanceofthe
product,good,orser
vicedeliveredbythe
project
ow.Inad
dition,statetheprojectedannualcosttoo
perateandmaintain
theproduct,good,or
vice.Ifth
eoperationandmain
tenanceplanisnotinplace,whatistheta
rgetdatefortheplanand
tistheimpactofnothavingo
perationsandmainte
nancefortheproduct,good,orservicesin
place.
mpleFormatofProjectsHanidng
overfromProjectstoS
ervices:
Gautam Koppala ORG
8/9/2019 Project Execution from POME by Gautam Koppala VT
45/127
45
2007, POME, Gautam_Koppala, All Rights Reserved
Project Name:
JOB HANDOVER TO FACILITIES/ SERVICES GROUP
TO: Service Manager DATE:
CC(on e-mail): AMS Head, Operations Head FROM(name): Gautam Koppala
JOB NUMBER CUSTOMER
Operations must prepare the following documents for handing over the job to Facilities/ Services. This
document and Project handover to Customer Form to be sent to Service Support/ Facility Manager for
Records and Installed Base Updation
S.N. DOCUMENTS LIST Attached Y/N Remarks/ Give reason if any
item is NOT attached
1
Customer P.O. with all subsequent
amendments, add-on orders, Spare Orders,
Operation Contract/services
2
Project Close-out form with all attachments :
Duly signed by client/consultants and
concerned Proj. Engr/Manager.
3Billing BreakUp Cum BOQ with complete part
8/9/2019 Project Execution from POME by Gautam Koppala VT
46/127
46
2007, POME, Gautam_Koppala, All Rights Reserved
3nos. for Main, Add ON and Spares orders.
4Copy of complete set of Engineering
Documentation, 'As Built' drawings.
5
Operations Manuals / Maintenance
Manuals/catalogs/specs of various field
instruments as submitted to customer.
6
Complete System Software and Application
Software on CD /Drivers/Any other & ALL
PASSWORDS
7
List of spares available at site &
Recommended list of spares, if any given to
the customer
8Statutory Approvals (such as NOC< Fire
Officer's approvals etc.) ,if any.
9
All important communications (e-mail/letter
copies to/from customer) during project
execution
Verbal / unrecorded commitments or understanding with customer/ consultants or any other important info. which may be
useful for AMS to provide better service to customer/including any scope for add-on etc.
8/9/2019 Project Execution from POME by Gautam Koppala VT
47/127
47
2007, POME, Gautam_Koppala, All Rights Reserved
Is Handover to customer done with a snaglist?
No Is there an internal snag list? No
Date committed by PM to clear the snag list Date committed to clear internal snag
list
Has one set of this document & Project close-
out form duly signed by customer given to
Service/ Facility Support Manager for records
YES RSM must confirm this from SSM Sharjah before signing this Handover
document.
(Signature ) (Signature)
Date of HandOver agreed
by PM and
RSM
Project Manager Regional Service/ Facilty Manager ( RSM)
48
SERV
Defin
theap
priori
what
Eme
Expe
Inte
Serv
Softw
othe
Hard
Mate
Supp
Facil
Tele
sTrain
Cont
Tota
Fund
8/9/2019 Project Execution from POME by Gautam Koppala VT
48/127
2007,POME,Gautam_Koppala,AllRightsReserved
VICEAN
DMAINTENANCEP
LAN:
ewhatwillbemaintained,wh
owillberesponsible
formaintaining,how
changeswillbemadeto
pplicatio
n,howregularupgra
destoinfrastructure,
software,utilities,an
dhardwarewillbe
itized,whatbusinessunitisresponsibleandanyot
herserviceagreemen
ts.Youmaywantto
define
arefun
ctionalityenhanceme
nts,Operationsenh
ancements,Defect
enhancementsand
ergencyFixesandhowthese
requestswillbeprioritizedinthefuture.
OperationsandMaintenanceCost
enditures($000)
Yr1
Yr2
Yr3
Yr4
Yr5+
E
xplanation
rnalSta
ffLabor
vices
wareTo
ols/
ers
dware
erialsan
d
plies
lities
communication
ning
tingency
(Risk)
al
dingSo
urce($000)
49
Gene
Non-
Fede
Othe
Tota
RELE
Listth
wastr
8/9/2019 Project Execution from POME by Gautam Koppala VT
49/127
2007,POME,Gautam_Koppala,AllRightsReser
ved
Yr1
Yr2
Yr3
Yr4
Yr5+
E
xplanation
eralFun
d
-Genera
lFund
eral
er
lASEOFPROJECTRESOURCES
heResourcesusedbythepro
ject.Identifytowhomeachresourcewas
transferredandwhen
it
ransferr
ed.Accountforallprojectresourcesutilizedbytheproject.
Resou
rce
(Desc
ribeornamethere
source
used)
Personor
OrganizationWho
ReceivedResource
TurnoverDate
ProjectTeam
Custom
erSupport
Facilities
50
TRAN
Identi
typeo
8/9/2019 Project Execution from POME by Gautam Koppala VT
50/127
2007,POME,Gautam_Koppala,AllRightsReser
ved
Equipment
Softw
areTools/Others
Other
NSITIO
NOFPROJECTDOCUMENTATION
fyallprojectdocumentation
materialsstoredinth
eprojectlibraryorotherrepository.Identifythe
ofmediausedandthedispos
itionoftheprojectdo
cumentation(seeCommunicationsPlan).
Report(s
)an
d
Docume
nt(s
)
MediaUsed
Storage
Lo
cation
Disposition
51
LESSO
Identif
andC
include
Statemen
1.
2.
3.
4.
8/9/2019 Project Execution from POME by Gautam Koppala VT
51/127
2007,POME,Gautam_Koppala,AllRightsReser
ved
ONSLEARNED
fyprim
aryLessonsLearned.
LessonsLearnedshouldbestatedintermsofProblems(or
issues)
CorrectiveActionstaken.
S
iteanyreferencesthatprovideaddition
aldetail.
Reference
smay
eprojectreports,plans,issu
elogs,changemanagementdocuments,o
rLesson-learnedchecklist.
ntofLesson
Refer
ences
Correctiv
eActions
52
Proj
Comp
addre
appli
colum
8/9/2019 Project Execution from POME by Gautam Koppala VT
52/127
2007,POME,Gautam_Koppala,AllRightsReser
ved
ectCloseoutTransitionC
hecklist
pletetheStatusandCommentscolumn.IntheStatuscolumnindicat
e:Yes,iftheitemha
sbeen
esseda
ndcompleted;No,if
itemhasnotbeenaddressed,orisincomplete;N/A,iftheitem
isnot
icabletothisproject.
Prov
idecommentsorde
scribetheplantoresolvetheiteminthelast
mn.
Item Status Comments/
8/9/2019 Project Execution from POME by Gautam Koppala VT
53/127
53
2007, POME, Gautam_Koppala, All Rights Reserved
Plan to Resolve
1 Have all the product or service deliverablesbeen accepted by the customer?
1.1 Are there contingencies or conditions related
to the acceptance? If so, describe in the
Comments.
2 Has the project been evaluated against each
objective established in the product
description and Integrated Project Plan?
3 Has the actual cost of the project been tallied
and compared to the approved budget?
3.1 Have all approved changes to the cost baseline
been identified and their impact on the project
documented?
4 Have the actual milestone completion dates
been compared to the approved schedule?
4.1 Have all approved changes to the schedule
baseline been identified and their impact on
the project documented?
Item Status Comments/
8/9/2019 Project Execution from POME by Gautam Koppala VT
54/127
54
2007, POME, Gautam_Koppala, All Rights Reserved
Plan to Resolve
5 Have all approved changes to the projectrequirement been identified and their impact
on the performance, cost, and schedule
baselines documented?
6 Has operations management formally accepted
responsibility for operating and maintaining
the product(s) or service(s) delivered by the
project?
6.1 Has the documentation relating to operation
and maintenance of the product(s) or
service(s) been delivered to, and accepted by,
operations management?
6.2 Has training and knowledge transfer of the
operations organization been completed?
6.3 Has the projected annual cost to operate and
maintain the product(s) or service(s) been
approved and funded? If not, note and
explain who is responsible to resolve.
7 Have the resources used by the project been
reassigned to other units or projects?
Item Status Comments/
8/9/2019 Project Execution from POME by Gautam Koppala VT
55/127
55
2007, POME, Gautam_Koppala, All Rights Reserved
Plan to Resolve
8 Has the project documentation been archivedor otherwise disposed as described in the
project communication plan?
9 Have the lessons learned been filed with the
Project Management Office? Projects
Department?
56
Appro
Proje
Proje
Maint
Mana
Mana
POME
8/9/2019 Project Execution from POME by Gautam Koppala VT
56/127
2007,POME,Gautam_K
oppala,AllRightsReserved
ovals
Pos
ition/Title
Signature/Printed
Name/Title
Date
ectManager
ectSponsor
tenance/Service
ager/Agency
ageme
nt
ELIG
HTERVEI:
57
POME
8/9/2019 Project Execution from POME by Gautam Koppala VT
57/127
2007,POME,Gautam_K
oppala,AllRightsReserved
EPrescribe
B
elieveiny
ourself.
B
POMEPrescribe
58
8/9/2019 Project Execution from POME by Gautam Koppala VT
58/127
2007,POME,Gautam_K
oppala,AllRightsReserved
PER
CENT
AGEOF
CO
MPLE
TION
(POC)
59
Perc
Forab
qualify
project
tothem
accoun
expens
Forsuc
estimat
Priorto
passes
beene
Therea
method
expens
isassc
Ifexpe
soonas
expens
expecta
simply
Thenth
estimat
exactly
accoun
shifting
thistyp
Howto
JonesB
estimat
transac
1.
2.
3.
8/9/2019 Project Execution from POME by Gautam Koppala VT
59/127
2007,POME,Gautam_K
oppala,AllRightsReserved
entageofCompletion
bookstoreitiseasytotellw
henacustomerhas
takenpossessionofthemerchandise,thus
ingth
etransactionasasa
le.However,considerlong-term
projectss
uchaslargeconstruc
tion
ts.Is
itrighttowaituntilthelastbrickislaidbe
forerecognizingthesale?Remember,according
matchingprinciplerevenuesandtheirassociate
dexpensesshouldbe
recognizedinthesame
tingperiod.Thecontractorhasexpensesthroughoutthecourseofth
eproject.Shouldthe
se
sesbeheldoffthebooksu
ntiltheprojectiscom
pletedaswell?
chprojects,thematchingp
rincipleisessentially
turnedaroundandtheexpensesareused
to
tetheassociatedrevenues
.Thisprocessiscalle
dthepercentageofc
ompletion(PoC)method.
othe
projectsstartthecon
tractorestimatesthe
costsateachstageo
ftheproject.Astime
and
thestagesarecompleted,thecontractorrecognizesanestimateoftherevenuethat
has
arnedbasedonthepercen
tageoftheestimated
coststhathavealreadybeenincurred.
aretw
opotentialissuesforinvestorsincompan
iesthatusetheperce
ntageofcompletion
d.Botharisefrom
thefact
thatthecontractoris
recognizingrevenue
onthebasisofestimated
ses.O
fcourse,actualexpe
nsesmaybehighero
rlowerthantheestim
ate,evenifthecont
ractor
crupu
lousaspossible.
enses
turnouttobehigher
thanestimated,thepastexpensesrecogn
izedwillbetoolow.A
s
sthe
contractorrealizesth
ereisacostoverrun
hemustrecognizealloftheunderstatedp
ast
seinthecurrentreporting
period.Thiscancausesignificantearnings
shortfallsrelativeto
ations.Itisverydifficultfo
rinvestorstoanticipatesuchevents,soin
steadmanyinvestors
disco
untthepricetheyarewillingtopayforacompanythatextensivelyusesthePoCme
thod.
hereisthepossibilitythat
thecontractorisnotentirelyscrupulous.Inadditiontothediffic
ultyin
tingc
ostsattheprojectsoutset,atanystagea
longthewayitcanb
edifficulttodetermin
e
yhow
muchoftheprojectiscomplete.Ifthecontractorwantstoboo
strevenueinthecurrent
tingperiodhecouldmake
anaggressiveestima
teastohowmuchoftheworkiscomplete
,
grevenuethatshouldberecognizedlaterintothecurrentperiod.Inv
estorsmaybeableto
spot
peof
activitybymonitoringtheunbilledreceivablesaccountforsuddenspikes.
oUs
ePercentage-of-Co
mpletionAccountin
g
Buildersjustobtainedacontractfor$500,000tobuildahomeforMr.&Mrs.Smith.Jones
teshistotalcostonthejobtobe$400,000.Duringthefirstmontho
fthejob,thefollowin
g
ctions
occur:
Cash
of$10,000ispaidfo
rpermits,feesandotherstartupcosts.
Anin
voiceisreceivedfrom
theexcavationsubc
ontractorfor$10,000
.
Thefirstprogressbillingispreparedfor$60,00
0.
60
Ifthea
undere
Re
Gross
Undert
($60,00
1.
2.
Byexam
reflects
receive
5%com
Howeve
month.
($100,0
Howeve
outcom
Fewcor
estimat
Percent
8/9/2019 Project Execution from POME by Gautam Koppala VT
60/127
2007,POME,Gautam_K
oppala,AllRightsReserved
above
transactionswereth
eonlyonesJonesBuildershadforthemonth,itsincomestatem
ents
each
accountingmethodw
ouldlooklikethis:
Cash
Accr
ualCompleted
Contract
%of
C
ompletion
venue
$0
$60,000
$0
$25,000
Cos
ts
10,000
20,000
0
20,000
Pro
fit$(10,000)
$40,000
$0
$5,000
thea
ccrualmethod,revenueearnedequalsthe
amountinvoicedont
hefirstprogressbillin
g
00).Revenueunderthepe
rcentage-of-completionmethodwascomp
utedasfollows:
Calc
ulatewhatpercent
ageofthejobisco
mplete.
Calc
ulatetheamounto
frevenuetobeear
ned.
Coststodate/totalestim
atedcosts=%comp
lete
$20,000/$400,000=5%
complete
Cont
ractamountx%com
plete=revenueearn
ed
$500
,000x5%=$25,000
minin
gthefourincomesta
tements,youseetha
tthepercentage-of-completionmethodbe
st
sthe
company'srevenue,costsandgrossprofit
fortheperiod.Ifthe
presidentofJonesBu
ilders
dan
accrual-basisstatement,hemightthinkth
ecompanyisreallyp
rospering(thejobis
only
mplet
e,andthecompanyalreadymade$40,000).
er,th
isstatementdoesnotgiveatruepictureo
fthecompany'sprofitabilityasoftheend
ofthe
Becausethejobwasonly
5%complete,only5
%($5,000)ofthetotalprojectedgrosspr
ofit
000)
hasbeenearned.
er,th
ecostsandrevenues
calculatedinthisme
thodareatbeststillestimatesofthejob's
true
me.Fo
rthisreason,caresh
ouldbetakenwhendeterminingjobprogr
ess.
rpora
teutilizesastandard
processmakingchan
gestotheconventionalPOCforallproject
tesatcompletionorITC(I
ndicatedTotalCost).
tage
ofCompletion(POC)P
rocessandisdesigne
dto:
bea
GlobalProcessforallofprojects,leanedbyPOME.
establishaStandardTerm
inologyforthePOCp
rocess
61
ThePOC
ofappro
revenue
from
co
standar
pending
identify
systema
PoCPo
POMEs
(PBS).
project
Inaddit
thePBS
Projects
policyw
ThePro
PoCadj
system,
(Monthl
Allproje
Deta
Doc
Deta
follo
CC
8/9/2019 Project Execution from POME by Gautam Koppala VT
61/127
2007,POME,Gautam_K
oppala,AllRightsReserved
CPro
cessisdesignedtom
eetthemanagementandinternalcontrolrequirementsforthe
level
oval
ofchangesinaprojectPOCcostbasedon
thefinancialimpactt
otheapprovedcosta
nd
ebud
get(controlbudget)
oftheproject.Thep
rocessrequiresthatt
heProjectPOCbede
rived
ostandscheduleanalysispertheProjectManag
ementandProjectCo
ntrolsmethodsand
rdsin
ordertorepresentthemostlikelycostou
tcomeoftheproject(excludingthebenefitof
gcha
ngeordersuntilthey
arebooked,unlessrequiredbycontractto
bepaidifincurred)and
variationsasquicklyasp
ossible.Theprocess
alsorequiresthatallProjectPOCsbe
atica
llyreviewedthroughtheMonthly,Executiv
eandGatingReview
processes.
olicy
:
PoC
requiresthatallprojectsmeetingthecrite
riaforinputintotheProjectBalancedScorecard
Forprojectsmeetingthis
criteria,noPOCcost
adjustmentmaybeb
aselinedinthelocal
acco
untingsystem
priort
oobtainingallofthe
requiredapprovalsof
thePOCcostadjustm
ent.
tion,
everyprojectPOCco
stbudgetmustbeva
lidatedeachmonthbytheProjectManagerin
Sand
thereviewdatesfor
Monthly,ExecutiveandGatingReviewsmustbeupdatedinthe
PBS.
sfallingbelowthecriteria
forinputintothePBS
arestillrequiredtofollowtheguidelinesinthis
withrespecttodetermination,reviewandappro
valofPoCs.
oject
ManagerisresponsibleforthevalidityoftheirprojectPoCcostbudget,ensuringthat
every
ustm
enttotheirprojecth
astherequiredappro
valspriortobaselininginthelocalaccoun
ting
,and
thattheirprojectissystematicallyreviewedinthethreeprojec
treviewprocesses
y,ExecutiveorGating).
ectP
oCadjustmentsrequirethefollowinganaly
sistobecompletedb
eforeapproval:
ailhoursandcostbymajo
rEstimateToComplete(ETC)task
umentedmitigationaction
stakenand/orplannedwithresponsibility
andduedatesidentified
ailof
hoursandcostchangebymajorPoCtask,includingreasonsforchangecategorized
as
ows:
ContractT&C's
Customer
62
ECPHQSSST
Process
TheProj
complet
Manage
Thisapp
adjustm
required
financia
represen
Shoulda
totheo
cannotb
Financia
theproj
Project
Project
regardle
takepla
Leaderl
pre-defi
requirem
8/9/2019 Project Execution from POME by Gautam Koppala VT
62/127
2007,POME,Gautam_K
oppala,AllRightsReserved
Estim
ate
CustomerExpectations
Proposal
Hard
ware/Software
Quality/re-work
Sche
dule
Scop
e
SubContractorsor3rdparty
Technology
sDescription:
ject
Managerisresponsibleforinitiatinganden
suringcompletionof
thePoCprocess.Upon
tionofthePBSinputsthe
requireddocumentsaretobesubmittedt
otheProjectControls
men
tfortheirrequiredfu
nctionalreviewanda
pproval.
provalistoverifythatthe
standardmethodsan
dtoolswereeffectivelyusedtoderivethe
POC
ment.
UponapprovaltheP
oCadjustmentisforwardedtoCompanyM
anagementfortheir
dbusinessreviewandapp
rovals.TheBusiness
Reviewersmustdete
rminetheultimate
ltreatmentofPoCadjustmentsfrom
taskingprojectteamswithrecoverytargetsand
ntingthepotentialriskin
quarterlyrepresentat
ionletterstotakingt
headjustmenttothe
P&L.
any
approverfindsufficientreasonnottoapprovethePOCcostadju
stmentitistobereturned
rigin
atorforre-workand
re-submittalortobe
filedintheprojectarchiveasrejectedifit
bere-worked.OncetheP
oCadjustmenthasfinalapprovalitistob
esubmittedtothelo
cal
alAn
alyst/Accountantforentryintothelocalpr
ojectaccountingsystemandre-baselining
of
ectbudget.
tRe
views:
Managementisresponsibletoensurethatprojectreviewsareoccurringonasystematicbasis,
esso
fwhetheranadjustm
entisdeemedcurren
tlynecessary.Atlea
st3levelsofreview
must
ace.
Thefirst,monthlyreviewsaretoincludem
anagementupthrou
ghtheRegionalProje
ct
level.Thesecond,gating
reviews,areconduct
edwhenlargeprojectsincontractvaluere
ach
ned
stagesofprojectexe
cution.ThisprocessismaintainedbyProjectControls.Participation
mentsforgatingreviewsa
redocumented.The
third,quarterlyreviews,areconductedbasedon
63
theselec
ProjectC
basedon
PoCAdj
Cur
Presiden
CFO
GlobalO
Contract
Regiona
Regiona
PoleCon
PoleProj
Regiona
Program
ProjectM
PoleEng
PoleFina
Regiona
LocalFin
GlobalP
PoleProj
GlobalP
PoleProj
8/9/2019 Project Execution from POME by Gautam Koppala VT
63/127
2007,POME,Gautam_K
oppala,AllRightsReserv
ed
ctionofthePoleFinanceManagerincoordinationwiththePoleProjectDirectorandPole
ControlManager.Criteria
aredocumentedbut
flexibilityexiststose
lectadditionalprojects
ntherequestoftheregio
nalorglobalmanagementteams.
justmentSampleApprovalMatrix:
rrentquarterPOCadjustm
entimpact(+/-)
Very
La
rge
Projects
Large
Projects
M
edium
Projects
Small
Projects
nt
X
X
OperationsVP/GM
X
tsVP
X
lVP/GM
X
lGe
neralManager
X
ntractsDirector
X
ject
Director
X
lPro
jectLeader
X
m
Ma
nager/PMCManager
X
Manager
X
gineeringDirector
X
ance
Director
X
lFin
anceManager
X
nanc
ialAnalyst
X
Proje
ctFinanceDirector
X
ject
FinanceManager
X
Proje
ctControlsDirector
X
ject
ControlsManager
X
64
ProjectC
Theexpe
review(m
following
Project
Concurre
X%(Xst
managem
Project
8/9/2019 Project Execution from POME by Gautam Koppala VT
64/127
2007,POME,Gautam_K
oppala,AllRightsReserv
ed
Cont
rolsLead
X
ecta
tionisthattheindividualapprovingtheseadjustmentsmustatt
endanappropriateproject
mon
thly,gating,quarterly)andhasreviewedthePOCchangeapprovalform.Inaddition
,the
gspecificfunctionalroles
andresponsibilitiesm
ustbeinoperationd
uringthereview:
Ma
nagement
ence
withtheprojectRev
enue,MarginandPer
centageofCompletio
n(PoC)confidenceof+/-
tand
sfortheprojectsacc
eptabledeviation)andthatthebusinessstrategyandproject
men
tmethodologybeing
employedontheprojectensureeffectiveprojectmanagement.
Controls
65
Concurre
toolsbein
accurate
Finance
Concurre
thedeter
Reviewed
FinanceP
Engineer
Concurre
appropria
Regional
Toasses
ProjectM
Contracts
Toensur
optimize
orders.
Complia
PoChmo
metrics:
Average
%ofProj
%ofPlan
%ofPlan
Inadditio
analysis
followed-
8/9/2019 Project Execution from POME by Gautam Koppala VT
65/127
2007,POME,Gautam_K
oppala,AllRightsReserv
ed
ence
withtheprojectPoC
confidenceof+/-X%
andthattheprojectcontrolprocessesan
d
ngemployedontheprojecteffectivelytrackprojectperformance,facilitateprojectcontroland
lyforecasttheprojectes
timatetocomplete.
ence
thatthePoCpresentedisreasonableconsideringallknownitems.Alsoresponsible
for
rminationofhowtoaccountforanyPoCadjus
tmentinthefinancialswithinapprovedpolicy.
dallitemsincludedonPr
ojectBalancedScorecardaswellasaddressedrelevantitemsfr
om
ProjectReviewChecklist.
ring
Management
ence
withthetechnicals
tateoftheprojectandthatthetechnicalaspectsoftheproje
ctare
atel
yaccountedforinthe
projectPoC.
Ma
nagement
sth
efullrangebusiness
impactofPoCadjustmentsandforecasts
andworkwithFinanceand
Managementtodeterminehowtotheyarereflectedintheregionalbusinessforecast.
srethePoC
reflectsthe
requirementsofthe
contractualtermsandconditions,asw
ellas
theProjectspositionundertheagreementforissuessuchasscheduledelaysandc
hange
anceReporting:
onth
,ProjectControlssha
llbepublishinganPO
CScorecardthatmustincludethefollowin
g
PoC
AdjustmentandStandardDeviation
Monthly
jectswithPoCValidated
byProjectManageme
ntandProjectContro
ls
Monthly
nvs
.ActualofProjectsw
ithscheduledExecutiveReviews
Quarterly
nvs
.ActualofProjectsw
ithscheduledGating
Reviews
Quarterly
on,
ProjectControlsmustmaintaindocumenta
tionofPoCapprovals
includingtherequire
d
and
reviewparticipation/
signatures.Inaddition,actionlogsmustb
eprepared,publishedand
-up.
66
Checksa
ThePOC
balances
responsib
ProjectC
isbeingd
functioni
withProje
POCAud
Toensure
tomateri
ofprojec
checksa
processa
POMEPr
8/9/2019 Project Execution from POME by Gautam Koppala VT
66/127
2007,POME,Gautam_K
oppala,AllRightsReserv
ed
andBalances:
andProjectReviewProcessesaredesignedto
ensurethateffective
businesschecksand
are
institutionalizedwith
intheimpliedProjects.TheProjectManagementfunctionis
blefordeliveringtheprojectsafely,ontime,w
ithinbudget,andperclientrequirements.
The
ont
rolsfunctionisresponsibleforensuringthattheprojectplanning,trackingandforeca
sting
don
eincompliancewiththeProjectControlss
tandardsandtools.TheProjectFinance
isresponsibleforensurin
gthatthefinancialrepresentationofthep
rojectisinaccordanc
e
ect
FinancialTermsandCorporatePolicies.
dit:
eth
erearenosystemic
failuresintheexecutionofthePOCPolicy
thatwouldexposePr
ojects
ialfinancialrisk,theProjectFinancefunctionmustconductbothsc
heduledandrandom
audits
ctsonaglobalbasis.
Inadditiontotheprimaryobjective,these
auditsmustreinforcethe
nd
balancesintheorganization,andidentify
opportunitiestocon
tinuouslyimprovethePOC
and
theexecutionofproj
ects.
res
cribe:
Av
oidnega
tivesour
ces,
people,places,thin
gs
andhabits.
A
POMEPrescribe
67
PCO
8/9/2019 Project Execution from POME by Gautam Koppala VT
67/127
2007,POME,Gautam_K
oppala,AllRightsReserv
ed
PERC
ENTA
GEO
F
MPL
ETIO
N(PoC)
VS.CONT
RACT
COM
PLETION
METHO
DS
68
Percen
Inthecon
uncomple
onlyrepor
balancesh
billings.W
asincome
incomest
ofworkco
ofcostsin
projectwa
expected
$1,000,00
$200,000
8/9/2019 Project Execution from POME by Gautam Koppala VT
68/127
2007,POME,Gautam_Koppala,AllRightsReserv
ed
ntageOfCompletion(PoC)Vs.completed-c
ontractMethods
ntextofprivateconstruc
tionfirms,particularproblemsariseinthe
treatmentof
ted
contractsinfinancia
lreports.Underthe"
completed-contract"method,incomeis
rte
dforcompletedproje
cts.Workonprojects
underwayisonlyrep
ortedonthe
heet,representinganas
setifcontractbillings
exceedcostsoralia
bilityifcostsexceed
Whe
naprojectiscomple
ted,thetotalnetprofit(orloss)isreportedinthefinalperiod
e.U
nderthe"percentage
-of-completion"meth
od,actualcostsarereportedonthe
tate
mentplusaproportionofallprojectreven
ues(orbillings)equa
ltotheproportion
om
pletedduringtheperiod.Theproportionofworkcompletediscomputedastheratio
ncu
rredtodateandthetotalestimatedcosto
ftheproject.Thus,if
twentypercentofa
as
completedinaparticularperiodatadirect
costof$180,000andonaprojectwith
revenuesof$1,000,000
,thenthecontractre
venuesearnedwould
becalculatedas
00(
0.2)=$200,000.Thisfigurerepresentsa
profitandcontributiontooverheadof
-$180,000=$20,000fortheperiod.Notethatbillingsandactualreceiptsmightbe
69
inexcess
organizati
billingsan
Asanothe
contract"
flowfora
Thesuper
year2.Un
(60%of$
contract"
The"perce
representi
resultingp
occurwith
of-comple
obscureth
observers
untilamin
statement
thereare
taxesone
theprojec
offorty-se
millionint
method.
Itshouldb
estimateo
accounting
exampleo
accounting
8/9/2019 Project Execution from POME by Gautam Koppala VT
69/127
2007,POME,Gautam_Koppala,AllRightsReserv
ed
or
lessthanthecalculat
edrevenuesof$200,
000.Onthebalancesheetofan
on
usingthepercentage
-of-completionmethod,anassetisusually
reportedtoreflect
ndtheestimatedorcalculatedearningsinexc
essofactualbillings.
re
xampleofthediffere
nceinthe"percentag
e-of-completion"and
the"completed-
me
thods,considerathr
eeyearprojecttocon
structaplantwithth
efollowingcash
co
ntractor:
YearContractExpensesPaymentsReceived
123Tota
l
$700,000
180,000
320,000
$1,200,000
$900,000
250,000
150,000
$1,300,000
rvis
ingarchitectdeterminesthat60%ofthef
acilityiscompleteinyear1and75%in
nde
rthe"percentage-of-completion"method,
thenetincomeinye
ar1is$780,000
$1,300,000)lessthe$70
0,000inexpensesor
$80,000.Underthe
"completed-
me
thod,theentireprofitof$100,000wouldbereportedinyear3.
entage-of-completion"m
ethodofreportingperiodearningshastheadvantageof
ing
theactualestimated
earningsineachperiod.Asaresult,theincomestream
and
pro
fitsarelesssusceptib
letoprecipitateswin
gsonthecompletion
ofaprojectascan
hthe"completedcontractmethod"ofcalculat
ingincome.However,the"percentage-
tio
n"hasthedisadvantageofrelyingupones
timateswhichcanbe
manipulatedto
he
actualpositionofacompanyorwhichare
difficulttoreproduce
byoutside
.T
herearealsosubtletiessuchasthedeferralofallcalculatedincomefrom
aproject
nim
um
thresholdofthe
projectiscompleted.
Asaresult,interpretationoftheincome
tandbalancesheetofa
privateorganizationisnotalwaysstraightforward.Finally,
taxdisadvantagesfrom
usingthe"percentag
e-of-completion"met
hodsincecorporate
exp
ectedprofitsmaybecomedueduringtheprojectratherthanbeingdeferreduntil
ctc
ompletion.Asanexa
mpleoftaximplicatio
nsofthetworeportingmethods,astudy
eve
nconstructionfirmsconductedbytheGen
eralAccountingOfficefoundthat$280
tax
esweredeferredfrom
1980to1984throu
ghuseofthe"completed-contract"
be
apparentthatthe"percentage-of-completion"accountingprovidesonlyarough
oftheactualprofitorstatusofaproject.Also
,the"completedcontract"methodof
gisentirelyretrospectiv
eandprovidesnogu
idanceformanageme
nt.Thisisonlyone
oft
hetypesofallocation
sthatareintroduced
tocorrespondtogen
erallyaccepted
gp
ractices,yetmaynotfurtherthecauseof
goodprojectmanage
ment.Another
70
commone
purchasec
severecha
profitover
Today'sm
organizatio
relevantfo
Manageme
reducecos
theyrequi
variancest
Themanag
distributed
notrepres
Exa
Asanexam
completing
jobsaresh
of-complet
Asshown
Underthe
8/9/2019 Project Execution from POME by Gautam Koppala VT
70/127
2007,POME,Gautam_Koppala,AllRightsReserv
ed
exa
mpleistheuseofeq
uipmentdepreciation
schedulestoallocate
equipment
costs.Allocationsofcostsorrevenuestoparticularperiodswithinaprojectmaycause
angesinparticularindicators,buthavenorealmeaningforgoodm
anagementor
rtheentirecourseofaproject.AsJohnsonandKaplanargue:
an
agementaccounting
information,drivenbytheproceduresand
cycleofthe
on'sfinancialreportingsystem,istoolate,to
oaggregatedandtoo
distortedtobe
ormanagers'planninga
ndcontroldecisions..
..
entaccountingreportsa
reoflittlehelptooperatingmanagersastheyattemptto
sts
andimproveproductivity.Frequently,the
reportsdecreasepro
ductivitybecause
re
operatingmanagers
tospendtimeattemp
tingtounderstandan
dexplainreported
thathavelittletodowiththeeconomicandtechnologicalrealityo
ftheiroperations...
ge
mentaccountingsyst
emalsofailstoprovideaccurateproductc
osts.Costare
dtoproductsbysimplisticandarbitrarymeasures,usuallydirectlaborbased,thatdo
en
tthedemandsmade
byeachproductonthefirm'sresources.
am
ple:Calculatingne
tprofit
mp
leofthecalculationofnetprofit,suppose
thatacompanybega
nsixjobsinayear,
gt
hreejobsandhaving
threejobsstillunder
wayattheendofthe
year.Detailsofthes
ix
howninTablebelow.Whatwouldbethecom
pany'snetprofitunder,first,the"percentage-
tio
n"and,second,the"
completedcontractm
ethod"accountingco
nventions?
TABLE1
2-7ExampleofFinancialRecordsofProje
cts
NetProfitonCompletedContracts(A
mountsinthousandsofdollars)
Job1
Job2
Job3
TotalNetProfiton
CompletedJobs
$1,436
356
-738
$1,054
StatusofJobsUnderway
Job4
Job5
Job6
OriginalContractPrice
ContractChanges(C
hangeOrders,etc.)
TotalCosttoDate
PaymentsReceivedorDuetoDate
EstimatedCosttoCo
mplete
$4,200
400
3,600
3,520
500
$3
,800
600
1
,710
1
,830
2
,300
$5,630
-300
620
340
5,000
in
Tableabove,anetprofitof$1,054,000wa
searnedonthethreecompletedjobs.
"c
ompletedcontract"m
ethod,thistotalwouldbetotalprofit.Und
erthepercentage-
71
ofcomplet
thisamoun
ContrEs
Esti
Similarcal
forJob5a
completion
theevento
yearwere
.
8/9/2019 Project Execution from POME by Gautam Koppala VT
71/127
2007,POME,Gautam_Koppala,AllRightsReserv
ed
ionmethod,theyear's
expectedprofitontheprojectsunderwayw
ouldbeaddedto
nt.Forjob4,theexpectedprofitsarecalcula
tedasfollows:
Currentcontract
rice=Oriinalcontract
rice+ContractCha
nes
=4,200+400=4
,600
Creditordebittoda
te=Totalcoststoda
te-Paymentsreceive
dorduetodate
=3,600-3,520=
-80
ac
tvalueofuncompleted
work =Currentcontract
price-Paymentsreceivedordue
=4,600-3,520=
1,080
Creditordebittocom
e=Contractvalueo
funcompletedwork-
EstimatedCostto
Complete
=1,080-500=580
stimatedfinalgrossprofit=Creditordebitto
date+Creditordeb
ittocome
=-80.+580.=5
00
m
atedtotalroectcos
ts=Contract
rice-Gross
rofit
=4,600-500=4,100
EstimatedProfittoda
te=Estimatedfinalg
rossprofitxProportionofworkcomplete
=500.(3600/4100
))=439
cu
lationsfortheotherjobsunderwayindicat
eestimatedprofitsto
dateof$166,000
nd-$32,000forJob6.
Asaresult,thenetprofitusingthe"percentage-of-
n"
methodwouldbe$1,
627,000fortheyear.Notethatthisfigure
wouldbealteredin
of
multi-yearprojectsin
whichnetprofitson
projectscompletedo
runderwayinthis
claimedinearlierperiods
72
8/9/2019 Project Execution from POME by Gautam Koppala VT
72/127
2007,POME,Gautam_Koppala,AllRightsReserved
73
Estimat
8/9/2019 Project Execution from POME by Gautam Koppala VT
73/127
2007,POME,Gautam_Koppala,AllRightsReserved
ESTIMATINGA
ND
T
RACKIN
G
PR
O
JECT
COS
TS
t
ingandTracki
ngProjectCosts
74
Duringthee
recordkeep
Managemen
thatoccura
withaproje
projectas"
budgetand
andtheext
Inthischap
monitoring
managemen
straightforw
managemen
Hence,man
projectman
discusssom
toprovidea
TheCostC
Thelimited
primarilyin
areasforco
becomesim
anddesign
projectand
fulfillingthe
searchingfo
Finally,the
Projectman
usedinman
activities.F
aresult,pro
reportsont
toinferthe
process.Co
usefulpurpo
controlproc
8/9/2019 Project Execution from POME by Gautam Koppala VT
74/127
2007,POME,Gautam_Koppala,AllRightsReserved
executionofaproject,
proceduresforprojectcontrol,Percentage
ofCompletionand
pingbecomeindispensabletoolstomanager
sandotherparticipan
tsintheProject
ntprocess.Thesetools
servethedualpurpo
seofrecordingthefinancialtransactions
as
wellasgivingmanagersanindicationoft
heprogressandprob
lemsassociated
ec
t.Theproblemsofpr
ojectcontrolareaptlysummedupinanolddefinitionofa
a
nycollectionofvague
lyrelatedactivitiesthatareninetypercentcomplete,over
late."Thetaskofpro
jectcontrolsystemsistogiveafairindicationoftheexistence
e
ntofsuchproblems.
pt
er,weconsidertheproblemsassociatedw
ithresourceutilization,accounting,
a
ndcontrolduringaproject.Inthisdiscussion,weemphasizetheproject
ntusesofaccountinginformation.Interpretationofprojectaccou
ntsisgenerallynot
warduntilaprojectisc
ompleted,andthenitistoolatetoinfluenceproject
nt.Evenaftercompletionofaproject,theaccountingresultsmay
beconfusing.
na
gersneedtoknowhowtointerpretaccountinginformationforthepurposeof
nagement.Intheproce
ssofconsideringmanagementproblems,however,weshall
meofthecommonacco
untingsystemsandc
onventions,although
ourpurposeisnot
a
comprehensivesurve
yofaccountingproce
dures.
ControlProblem
o
bjectiveofprojectco
ntroldeservesempha
sis.ProjectCostcontrolproceduresare
tendedtoidentifydeviationsfrom
theprojectplanratherthanto
suggestpossible
os
tsavings.Thischaracteristicreflectstheadvancedstageatwhichprojectcontrol
mp
ortant.Thetimeatw
hichmajorcostsavin
gscanbeachievedisduringplanning
fortheproject.During
theactualprojectex
ecution,changesare
likelytodelaythe
leadtoinordinatecostincreases.Asaresult,thefocusofprojec
tcontrolison
eoriginaldesignplansorindicatingdeviationsfrom
theseplans,r
atherthanon
orsignificantimprovem
entsandcostsavings.
issuesassociatedwith
integrationofinform
ationwillrequiresom
ediscussion.
na
gementactivitiesandfunctionalconcerns
areintimatelylinked,
yetthetechniques
nyinstancesdonotfac
ilitatecomprehensive
orintegratedconsiderationofproject
o
rexample,scheduleinformationandcostaccountsareusuallyk
eptseparately.As
ojectmanagersthemselvesmustsynthesize
acomprehensivevie
wfrom
thedifferent
th
eprojectplustheiro
wnfieldobservations.Inparticular,manag
ersareoftenforced
c
ostimpactsofschedulechanges,ratherth
anbeingprovidedwithaidsforthis
om
municationorintegrationofvarioustypes
ofinformationcanserveanumberof
oses,althoughitdoes
requirespecialattent
ionintheestablishmentofproject
ce
dures.
75
Themanage
projectman
overallfate
Toid
Toes
Totr
Step#1Id
Whilecostf
projectcost
ResourceCo
Salar
Bene
Outs
Temp
Over
AssetCosts
implementp
Hard
Softw
Perip
Infra
Telec
Insta
OverheadC
completion,
Offic
Prem
Supp
ProjectSpec
caninclude:
Trave
Meal
Meet
Step#2Co
8/9/2019 Project Execution from POME by Gautam Koppala VT
75/127
2007,POME,Gautam_Koppala,AllRightsReserved
ementofprojectcosts
canbethemostcom
plicated,political,(an
dtedious)elementofthe
na
gementprocess.But
,costshavetobecon
trolled,forthesakeofITcredibility,andt
he
o
fcurrentandfutureprojects.
Therearet
hreeprimarystepsto
projectcostestimating:
dentifyprojectcostfactors.
stimatecostvaluesan
dcreateabudget.
ra
ckcostsandmonitor
variances.
dentifyingCostFactors:
a
ctorswillvarybased
onprojectcharacteristicsandbusinesscirc
umstances,ingeneral,
s
canbeviewedfrom
fourbasicperspective
s:
osts:thecostsinvolve
dinstaffingaproject,whichcaninclude:
ryefits
o
urcingContracts
p
oraryStaffing
rt
ime
:
thecostsofassetac
quisition,usuallyinvolvingtangibleassets
thatareusedtocrea
teor
projectdeliverables,w
hichcaninclude:
dw
are
w
are
pherals
as
tructure
communicationsEquipment
allationTools
o
sts:thecostsinvolvedinmaintainingthe
projectenvir