Prohibited Protest

7/30/2019 Prohibited Protest

1/9

_WHCNGN\JL_WH\JQ\

@ku Jbfhwajdjb| Kz|chwn|njq Wjq|wna| |cj Fwjjlhd hf Jspwjqqnhb hf _wh|jq|hwq keknbq| |cj Dn`n|kw~ Hffjbqnvj nb Ek}k


2/9

_"H" Ghs 3>7; Cknfk 1;?>? Nqwkj` \j`= #>57.$:?$;6;? Fks= #>57.$:?$1;? " 3 > 7 ; > : ? ; 6 ; ?$? < > : ? 1 ; < ?$?<

1 ; ? > ?,""3 > 7 ; ? < $ > : ? ; 6 ; ? ? < $ > : ? 1 ; < ? Jdkn`= klk`kcOklk`kc"hwe c||p=((uuu"klk`kc"hwe

_WHCNGN\JL_WH\JQ\

@ku Jbfhwajdjb| Kz|chwn|njq Wjq|wna||cj Fwjjlhd hf Jspwjqqnhb hf

_wh|jq|hwq keknbq| |cj Dn`n|kw~Hffjbqnvj nb Ek}k

Uwn||jb G~=Klk`kc K||hwbj~q Kgjjw Gkijw kbl Wkbk Kqk`n


5/9

kf|jw 71 lk~q hf ghdgnbe kbl qcj``nbe fwhd |cj knw, qjk kbl`kbl, nb ucnac ;,65, Wnackwl Fk`i, Czdkb Wnec|qQn|zk|nhb nb _k`jq|nbj kbl h|cjw Haazpnjl Kwkg \jwwn|hwnjq , ;; Fjgwzkw~ 7??>, K(CWA(;?(7?, p" 59c||p=((uuu"hackhp|"hwe(ek}kawnqnq(nbljs"pcp8nl4$;&_kej47&wpp4;? " Hb > Qjp|jdgjw 7??>, G\qj`jd

pzg`nqcjl q`nec|`~ lnffjwjb| fnezwjq" G\qj`jd q|k|jl |ck| nb |cj ahzwqj hf |cj dn`n|kw~ hpjwk|nhb, > Nqwkj`nq ujwjk`qh in``jl $ 1 anvn`nkbq uch ujwj in``jl g~ [kqqkd kbl Ewkl whaij|q, kbl 6 dn`n|kw~ pjwqhbbj`" < klln|nhbk`qh`lnjwq ujwj in``jl nb kb Nqwkj`n 'fwnjbl`~$fnwj' nbanljb|" Qjj=c||p=((uuu"g|qj`jd"hwe(Lhub`hkl(7??>?>?>XAkq|X@jklXFk|k`n|njqXCjg"plf


6/9

:

\cnq wjphw|qchuq |ck| nb k`dhq| jvjw~ kwjbk ucjwj |cjwj ujwj pwh|jq| ka|nvn|njq,|cj kz|chwn|njq% k||n|zlj ukq hbj hf }jwh |h`jwkbaj keknbq| lnqqjb|jwq |h |cj hpjwk|nhb" \cj dkmhwn|~hf kwwjq|q ujwj dklj nb p`kajq ucjwj |cj pwh|jq|q ujwj bhb vnh`jb| " \cj ph`naj, |cj Q|k|j _whqjaz|hwqHffnaj kbl |cj ahzw|qzqjl |cj kwwjq| pwhajlzwj kqkdjkbq hf lj|jwwnbe |cj awhulq fwhd ahdnbe hb|h |cj q|wjj|q" N| nq uj`` ibhub |ck| lj|jwwjbaj ahbqnljwk|nhbq wj`k|j |h |cj pjbk`|njq zqjl keknbq| k pjwqhb kf|jw jek` ahbvna|nhb, kbl |ck| |cj lj|jb|nhb pwhajlzwj dzq| bh| gjahdj k |hh` fhwzqj g~ |cj ku jbfhwajdjb| kz|chwn|njq

|h pwjvjb| pjhp`j fwhd pjwfhwdnbe kb~ ka|nhb, ajw|knb`~ bh| pwh|jq| ka|nvn|~" \ck| nqbh| chu |cj kz|chwn|njq gjckvjl nb |cj pwjqjb| dk||jw" \cj zqj hf kwwjq|fhw|cj pzwphqj hf lj|jwwjbaj, k`qh ibhub |h zq fwhd |cj pjwnhl hf |cj fnwq|kbl qjahbl Nb|nfklkq, fwhd |cj Bkigk Lk~, |cj @kbl Lk~ kbl ucjwjvjw pwh|jq|q kwj cj`l keknbq| |cj ljdh`n|nhb hf chzqjq, ahb|wkvjbjq k`` pwnbanp`jq hf awndnbk` `ku" \cnq wjphw|pwhvnljq js|jbqnvj a`kwnfnak|nhbhb |cnq phnb|"Qzddkw~ hf fnezwjq= \cj fnezwjq ah``ja|jl lzwnbe kbl kf|jw |cj hpjwk|nhb nblnak|j k dj|chl hf ah``ja|nvj kbl lnqpwhphw|nhbk|j kwwjq|=

317 pjwqhbq ujwj lj|knbjl g~ |cj ph`naj lzwnbe |cj dn`n|kw~hpjwk|nhb9

1


7/9

6

\cj Q|k|j _whqjaz|hwq Hffnaj kbl |cj ph`naj kppjk`jl jvjw~ ljanqnhb |h wj`jkqj k lj|knbjj fwhd lj|jb|nhb kbl uhb jvjw~ hbj hf |cj kppjk`q |cj~ qzgdn||jl" G~ kllnbe k zbnfhwd nb|whlza|hw~ pkwkewkpc |h k`` nblna|djb|q qzgdn||jl lzwnbe |cj hpjwk|nhb, |cj Q|k|j _whqjaz|hwqHffnaj kbl |cj ph`naj qhzec| |h dkij jvjw~ pwh|jq| jvjb|, wjekwl`jqq hf n|qackwka|jw, nb|h kb jsnq|jb|nk` |cwjk| |h |cj qjazwn|~ hf |cj q|k|j" Zqj hf |cnqkbezkej awjk|jl fhw |cj Q|k|j _whqjaz|hwq Hffnaj kbl |cj ph`naj kb kwezdjb| mzq|nf~nbelj|jb|nhb fhw k fju lk~q hwzb|n` ahdp`j|nhb hf pwhajjlnbeq un|c bh nblnvnlzk` jskdnbk|nhb hf jkac lj|knbjj kbl

un|chz| wj`k|nbe |h jkac pwh|jq| kbl |cj anwazdq|kbajq |cjwjhf" _kwklhsnak``~ kbl jvjb nwhbnak``~,|cj ph`naj ahbqnljwjl |cj pwh|jq|q keknbq| |cj dn`n|kw~ hffjbqnvj k lnq|zwgkbaj hf |cj pjkaj " Bju ewhzblq fhwkwwjq|q,qzac kq '|cj pwh|jq|q kwj lj|wndjb|k` |h pzg`na dhwk`j', ujwj zbcjqn|k|nbe`~ zqjl g~ |cj ph`naj" Nbqhdj akqjq |cj kpp`nak|nhbq fhwkwwjq| jskeejwk|jl |cj kaazqk|nhbq qpjanfnak``~ nb hwljw |h mzq|nf~|cj kwwjq| kbl wjdhvj |cj pjwqhb fwhd cnqjbvnwhbdjb|" \cj Ahzw|q=Ujwj n| bh| fhw |cj ahzw|q%k||n|zlj, ucnac jek`n}jl |cj ch`lnbe hf lj|knbjjq gjcnbl gkwqzb|n` |cj ahdp`j|nhb hf pwhajjlnbeq, nba`zlnbe dnbhwq un|c bh awndnbk` wjahwl, |cj fnezwjqpwjqjb|jl nb |cnqwjphw|uhz`l ckvj gjjb {zn|j lnffjwjb|" \cj ahzw|q kgkblhbjl |cj pwnbanp`j hf nblnvnlzk` jskdnbk|nhb, qpjanfna |h |cj jb|nwj awndnbk` `jek` q~q|jd, pwjfjwwnbe|cj uch`jqk`j kwwjq| hf qzqpja|q , a`kndnbe 'hffjbqjq qpjanfna |h |cj |ndjq' kbl 'bh ackbej ckq ~j| haazwwjl nb wjqpja| |cjwjhf'" Ahb|wkw~|h k`` awn|jwnkhf lhdjq|na kbl nb|jwbk|nhbk` `ku kbl un|c |cj gkainbe hf |cj Qzpwjdj Ahzw|, |cj |wjk|djb| hf dnbhwq ukq nljb|nak` |h |ck| hf klz`|q, un|c bh lnq|nba|nhb gj|ujjb |cjd" Qhdj mzlejq lnl bh| ahbajk` |cjnw qzpphw| fhw |cj dn`n|kw~ hffjbqnvj" Nb |cj Bk}kwj|c Dkenq|wk|jq Ahzw|,fhw nbq|kbaj, |cj wjphw|lnqa`hqjq |uh ljanqnhbq, ahdp`j|j`~ nljb|nak`, uhwl fhw uhwl, ahbajwbnbe fhzwlnffjwjb| qzqpja|q" \jq|ndhb~ g~ Ljdhbq|wk|hwq uch ujwj Kwwjq|jl kbl Qzgmja|jl |h _h`naj Vnh`jbaj= \cnq wjphw| k`qh pwjqjb|q dkb~ |jq|ndhbnjq g~ ljdhbq|wk|hwq uch pkw|nanpk|jl nb |h|k``~ {znj| pwh|jq|q kbl ljdhbq|wk|nhbq, gz| bjvjw|cj`jqq jbahzb|jwjl qjwnhzq vnh`jbaj hb |cj pkw| hf |cj ph`naj, uch lnqpjwqjl |cj ljdhbq|wk|hwq g~ fhwaj kbl zb`kufz``~, kbl kwwjq|jl dkb~ hf |cjd" \cj |jq|ndhbnjq pwjqjb|jl nb |cj wjphw| qcjl nec| hb |cj dj|chlq zqjl g~|cj ph`naj nb lnqpjwqnbe jek` ljdhbq|wk|nhbq kbl pwh|jq|q" Ljdhbq|wk|hwq ujwj kwwjq|jl qh`j`~ lzj |h |cjnw pwjqjbaj hb |cj qajbj" \cj kwwjq|q ujwj zqjl kq k wkpnl dj|chl hf lnqpjwqnbe |cj ljdhbq|wk|nhbq, nb hwljw |h awjk|j pkbna kbl kq k lj|jwwjb|" \cj wjphw| wjvjk`q |ck| qpjanfna eznlj`nbjq ujwj nqqzjl |h ljk` un|c pwh|jq|q kbl lj|knbjjq,

ucnac|cj

ph`naj

wjfzqjl

|h

lnqa`hqj

|h

Klk`kc"

Eznlj`nbjq

hf

|cnq

inbl

un``

gj

wjdjdgjwjl

fwhd |cj jvjb|q hf Ha|hgjw 7???, nb ucnac |cj Q|k|j _whqjaz|hwq Hffnaj ljvh|jl wjqhzwajqkbl jffhw|q |h fnblnbe uk~q hf gjnbe dhwj qjvjwj un|c lj|knbjjq, ucn`j k`|hej|cjw lnqwjekwlnbe |cj {zjq|nhb hf chu ;1 Kwkg ljdhbq|wk|hwq ujwj in``jl kbl uch qchz`l gjkwwjqphbqngn`n|~fhw|cj in``nbeq" Nb dkb~ kwjkq ucjwj |cj pwh|jq|q ujwj cj`l, |cj ph`naj akdj un|c wjnbfhwajdjb|q kbl lnqpjwqjl |cj ljdhbq|wk|hwq g~ fhwaj, hb |cj pwj|js| |ck| |cj~ ujwj pkw|nanpk|nbe nb kfhwgnlljb ek|cjwnbe" Qzac ukq |cj akqj un|c |cj pwh|jq|q cj`l k| \j` KvnvZbnvjwqn|~, CknfkZbnvjwqn|~, Gjb Ezwnhb Zbnvjwqn|~ nb Gjjw Qcjvk, hb Gjb Ezwnhb G`vl" nb Cknfk hb Bju jkw%q


8/9

5

Jvj, kbl |cj pwh|jq|q cj`l nb vkwnhzqp`kajq nb Gjjw Qcjvk kbl \j` Kvnv"\cjqj jvjb|q un`` gj ljqawngjl js|jbqnvj`~ nb |cj wjphw|" \cj |jq|ndhbnjq ah``ja|jl qchu a`jkw`~ |ck| bhbj hf |cj ljqawngjl pwh|jq|q wj{znwjl kpjwdn| fwhd |cj ph`naj , n"j" |cj ku lhjq bh| dkij n| dkblk|hw~ |h hg|knb k pjwdn| nb |chqj akqjq, kqqck``gj jsp`knbjl `k|jw"Bjvjw|cj`jqq, |cj ph`naj dklj hg|knbnbe kpjwdn| k|cwjqch`l ahbln|nhb fhw ahb|nbznbe |h ch`l |cjd" Nbdkb~ akqjq |cj ph`naj lnqpjwqjl |cj

pwh|jq|q gkqjl hb |cj f`ndq~ kwezdjb| hf 'ahbajwb fhw wnh|nbekbl lnq|zwgnbe |cj pjkaj'" \cj hb`~ wjkqhb fhw |cnq ka|nhb ukq |cj pwjqjbaj hf ahzb|jw ljdhbq|wk|hwq uch qzpphw|jl |cj ukw" \cj ljdhbq|wk|nhbq ujwj lnqpjwqjl vnh`jb|`~, kbl |cj~ hf|jb qzffjwjl qjvjwj nbmzwnjq"Gzqjq hb |cj uk~ |h k pwh|jq| ujwj ahbfnqak|jl kbl |cj pjhp`j uch ckl cnwjl |cjd ujwj fhwajl |h wj|zwb chdj" \cj ph`naj fhwjqku nb ehhl |ndj kbl gjfhwjckbl |ck| |cj pkqqjbejwq hb |cj gzqjq ujwj nb|jblnbe |h pkw|nanpk|j nb kb n``jek` ek|cjwnbe" \czq, nbq|jkl hf fz`fn``nben|q lz|~ |h dknb|knb hwljw kbl |h jbqzwj |cj fwjjlhd hf jspwjqqnhb nb |ndjq hf zpcjkvk` kbl pjwnhlq hf qhank`, ph`n|nak` kbl bk|nhbk` ahb|whvjwq~, |cj ph`naj achqj |h zqj fhwaj nb kb jffhw| |h qn`jbaj |cj vhnajq hf pwh|jq| kbl pwjvjb| |cjd fwhd gjnbe cjkwl" \cj Qckgki%q Ckwkqqdjb| kbl Qzwvjn``kbaj hf _h`n|nak` Ka|nvnq|q=\cj Qckgki k`qh fh``hujl n|q ckgn| hf |kinbe pkw| nb qn`jbanbe |cj vhnajq hf pwh|jq|" Lh}jbq hf ph`n|nak` ka|nvnq|q uch hwekbn}jl |cj pwh|jq|q ujwj ak``jl nb fhwnbvjq|nek|nhb g~ |cj Qckgki" \cj ph`naj dnqwjpwjqjb|jl |cnq ka| |h |cj ka|nvnq|q, qk~nbe |ck| n| ukq k ph`naj nbvjq|nek|nhb" Zphb |cjnw kwwnvk`k| |cj ph`naj q|k|nhb, |cj~ ujwj wzqcjl |h |cj Qckgki nbvjq|nek|hwq, uch gjekb |h {zjq|nhb |cjd kbl |cwjk|jbjl |h pwhqjaz|j |cjd nf |cj~ lnl bh| ajkqj |cjnwph`n|nak` ka|nvn|njq" \cjqj ka|nvnq|q |jq|nfnjl |h Klk`kc |ck| |cj Qckgki kqijl |cjd ph`n|nak`{zjq|nhbq kbl |cwjk|jbjl |h pwhqjaz|j |cjd kbl ch`l |cjd wjqphbqng`j fhw jvjw~ hffjbqj |ck| dnec| gj ahddn||jl lzwnbe |cj ljdhbq|wk|nhbq, jvjb nf |cj~ ckl bh| ahddn||jl |cjd pjwqhbk``~" \cj K||hwbj~ Ejbjwk` gkaijl |cj Qckgki%q dj|chl hf {zjq|nhbnbe kbl |cwjk|q kbl n|q nbvh`vjdjb|, kweznbe |ck| n| ukq bjajqqkw~ nb hwljw |h ak`d |cj qn|zk|nhb kbl |h pwjvjb| k wjpj|n|nhb hf jvjb|q qzac kq nbHa|hgjw 7??? kbl nbKiik #Kawj. nbHa|hgjw 7??3" Kakljdna Nbvh`vjdjb| nb Qzpphw|nbe |cj Ukw kbl Wjpwjqqnbe Fwjjlhd hf Jspwjqqnhb=\cj wjphw|jsphqjq |cj dkbbjw nb ucnac kakljdnaq kbl vkwnhzq kakljdna nbq|n|z|nhbq wjqphbljl, hw dhwj kaazwk|j`~, lnl bh| wjqphbl, jn|cjw |h |cj g`hhl~ jvjb|q nb Ek}k hw |h |cj ukvj hf ah``ja|nvj kwwjq|qun|cnb Nqwkj`"Vjw~ fju ja|zwjwq ujwj gh`l jbhzec |h pwh|jq| pzg`na`~ keknbq| |cj dn`n|kw~hpjwk|nhb nb Ek}k" Kakljdnaq uch ckl ahdp`knbjl nb |cj pkq|

kghz||cj

ah``ja|nvj

kwwjq|

hf

dnbhwq

fwhd

kdhbe

|cj

qj||`jwq,

dklj

bh

ahddjb|

ahbajwbnbe

|cj ukw awndjq ucnac |cj Nqwkj`kwd~ nqq|whbe`~ qzqpja|jl |h ckvj pjwpj|wk|jl nb |cj Ek}k Q|wnp,hwnbvnju hf |cj ah``ja|nvj kwwjq|qkbl js|jbqnhb hf kwwjq|q,jqpjank``~ hf dnbhwq"Kakljdna nbq|n|z|nhbq qzac kq |cj Cknfk Zbnvjwqn|~ lja`kwjl pwhdnbjb|`~ nb qnebq nbq|k``jl kghvj gzn`lnbeq kbl nb pknl klvjw|nqjdjb|q nb |cj pwjqq |cj bk|nhbk` pwnlj |cj~ fj`| fwhd |cj dn`n|kw~hpjwk|nhb" K| |cj qkdj |ndj, |cj Zbnvjwqn|~ lnl bh| cjqn|k|j |h hwekbn}j |cj jb|w~ hf lh}jbq hf ph`naj kbl chwqjdjb nb|h |cj Zbnvjwqn|~ akdpzq nb hwljw |h vnh`jb|`~ lnqpjwqj ek|cjwnbeq hf Kwkgq|zljb|q uch qhzec| |h lnqahb|nbzj |cj q|zlnjq fhwk fju chzwq nb pwh|jq| keknbq| |cj dn`n|kw~ hpjwk|nhb" \cj jskeejwk|jl vnh`jbaj jsjw|jl keknbq| |cj q|zljb|q, |cj


9/9

3

fk`qj kwwjq|q kbl wjpwjqqnhb hf |cjnw pwh|jq| lnl bh| j`nan| kb~ ahbljdbk|nhb hb |cj pkw| hf |cj Zbnvjwqn|~" Hb |cj ahb|wkw~, k fju lk~q `k|jw, |cj Zbnvjwqn|~ ukq {znai |h ndphqj lnqanp`nbkw~ka|nhb hb |cj q|zljb|q lzj |h zbqjjd`~ ahblza| kbl pkw|nanpk|nhbnb zbkppwhvjl pzg`na ka|nvn|~+Hvjwk``, |cj wjphw|qchuq chu |cj ukvj hf pwh|jq| keknbq| |cj dn`n|kw~ hpjwk|nhb ukq pjwajnvjl kq kb nb|h`jwkg`j bznqkbaj g~ |cj ph`naj, |cj Q|k|j _whqjaz|hwq Hffnaj, |cj ahzw|q

kbl qhdj hf |cj kakljdna nbq|n|z|nhbq nb |cj Q|k|j" Wjq|wna|nhbhf Fwjjlhd hf Jspwjqqnhb lzj |h k Chq|n`j Kzlnjbaj= Fwjjlhd hf jspwjqqnhb kbl |cj wnec| |h kqqjdg`j, ek|cjw kbl ljdhbq|wk|j fwjj`~ kwj |uh hf |cj fzblkdjb|k` czdkb wnec|q"1\cj qpjanfnajspwjqqnhb hf |cnqwnec| nq |cj fwjjlhd |h pwjqjb| hpnbnhbq ahbqnljwjl ahb|whvjwqnk`, gjnbe hz|qnlj |cj ejbjwk` ahbqjbqzq" \cj js|jb| hf q~dpk|c~ hwkbejw kwhzqjl g~ |cj ahb|jb| hf |cj pwh|jq| nqbh| qzpphqjl |h gj k awn|jwnhbfhwlj|jwdnbnbe |cj js|jb| hf |cj wnec| |h jspwjqq hbjqj`f" Ahb|wkw~|h |cj |jq|q qj| fhw|c nb Qzpwjdj Ahzw| mzledjb|q kbl |cj hena hf ahddhb qjbqj, |cj ph`naj lnqpjwqjl k pwh|jq| hb`~ lzj |h |cj fka| |ck| kwhzbl |cjd ujwj k ewhzp hf pjhp`j ahbqnljwjl k chq|n`j kzlnjbaj" Nb|cnq |cj ph`naj k`qh jwwjl nb lnqwjekwlnbe |cj a`jkw wz`nbeqckbljl lhub g~|cj ahzw|, ucnac ukwbjl keknbq| |cnq |~pj hf gjckvnhw g~ |cj ph`naj"K``hunbe k ajw|knb chq|n`j ewhzp #|cj pwhUkw ljdhbq|wk|hwq. |cj ij~ fhwjsjwanqnbe |cj wnec|hf ljdhbq|wk|nhb kbl kqqjdg`~, kbl ewkb|nbe |cjd |cj wnec| hf vj|h, |czq kukwlq |cjd kpwn}jfhw|cjnw keewjqqnhb"

Documents

Prohibited Protest