147
Program 60-610—Plastic Gear Geometry and Load Analysis Introduction The primary purpose of this model is to provide an accurate set of coordinates for use in plotting the final form of external involute spur and helical gears. In addition to a plot of the teeth, the model furnishes numerical results for many of the design parameters of interest to the designer. The model can be used for the design of a gear set and the necessary tooling or as a “final visual” check of the detailed design processes that were used to produce the design. If load and material data is entered, an analysis of the load capacity will be made. Geometry The gears may be hobbed with non-topping, semi-topping, tip relief or topping hobs, shaped with pinion type cutters or defined by a basic rack form for molding. (If molded, four different depth racks defined by the AGMA Plastic Gear Committee are built into the model as default values.) If the gears are post processed after hobbing or shaping, provision has been made to accommodate the finishing stock. It is assumed that no steps were cut in the involute or fillet by the finish tools. The model will warn you if the finish stock on the side of the tooth is greater than the protuberance but the step produced on the plot of the tooth is not necessarily at the actual location of the step produced by the finish tool. Only if there is enough natural undercut (small pinions) will a satisfactory gear be produced under these conditions. These conditions must be checked by programs such as UTS Program 500. The hob (or basic rack) flank angle is measured from a normal to the hob (or basic rack) reference line. The shaper cutter tooth thickness is at the shaper reference pitch diameter, the protuberance and the tip radius are measured in the normal plane. The model will produce coordinates at intervals of about 0.050 times the Operating Normal Module (near the fillet/involute intersection the fillet coordinates are about one tenth of this). For example, a gear set with an operating normal module of one the coordinates would be spaced at about 0.050 mm intervals. For an operating normal module of 0.10 the coordinates would be spaced at about 0.005 mm intervals. The intersection between the involute flank and the fillet of the tooth and the intersection of the involute flank and any tip radius or modification will be calculated and marked on the plot of the tooth (if “Mark inv/fil intersections? and/or “Mark mod/inv intersections?” are set to 'y). (These diameters will also be displayed in the output column on the variable sheet.

Program 60-610—Plastic Gear Geometry and Load Analysis ...Program 60-610—Plastic Gear Geometry and Load Analysis Introduction The primary purpose of this model is to provide an

  • Upload
    others

  • View
    1

  • Download
    0

Embed Size (px)

Citation preview

  • Program 60-610—Plastic Gear Geometry and Load Analysis

    Introduction The primary purpose of this model is to provide an accurate set of coordinates for use in plotting the final form of external involute spur and helical gears. In addition to a plot of the teeth, the model furnishes numerical results for many of the design parameters of interest to the designer. The model can be used for the design of a gear set and the necessary tooling or as a “final visual” check of the detailed design processes that were used to produce the design. If load and material data is entered, an analysis of the load capacity will be made. Geometry

    The gears may be hobbed with non-topping, semi-topping, tip relief or topping hobs, shaped with pinion type cutters or defined by a basic rack form for molding. (If molded, four different depth racks defined by the AGMA Plastic Gear Committee are built into the model as default values.) If the gears are post processed after hobbing or shaping, provision has been made to accommodate the finishing stock. It is assumed that no steps were cut in the involute or fillet by the finish tools. The model will warn you if the finish stock on the side of the tooth is greater than the protuberance but the step produced on the plot of the tooth is not necessarily at the actual location of the step produced by the finish tool. Only if there is enough natural undercut (small pinions) will a satisfactory gear be produced under these conditions. These conditions must be checked by programs such as UTS Program 500. The hob (or basic rack) flank angle is measured from a normal to the hob (or basic rack) reference line. The shaper cutter tooth thickness is at the shaper reference pitch diameter, the protuberance and the tip radius are measured in the normal plane. The model will produce coordinates at intervals of about 0.050 times the Operating Normal Module (near the fillet/involute intersection the fillet coordinates are about one tenth of this). For example, a gear set with an operating normal module of one the coordinates would be spaced at about 0.050 mm intervals. For an operating normal module of 0.10 the coordinates would be spaced at about 0.005 mm intervals. The intersection between the involute flank and the fillet of the tooth and the intersection of the involute flank and any tip radius or modification will be calculated and marked on the plot of the tooth (if “Mark inv/fil intersections? and/or “Mark mod/inv intersections?” are set to 'y). (These diameters will also be displayed in the output column on the variable sheet.

  • UTS Integrated Gear Software

    2

    The coordinates for spur gears are the actual coordinates of the gears produced by the specified tools. For helical gears the coordinates are produced for the virtual spur gears in the operating normal plane. (In some very low tooth number helical pinions the error between the tooth thickness at the effective outside diameter or the involute-fillet tangent point and the virtual spur tooth will affect the accuracy of the plot of the teeth. In this case it is suggested that models 60-411, 60-104 and 60-410 also be used to analyze the geometry of the gear set. The model will notify you of this condition.) The model contains some warning messages that may stop execution of the program. (such as “Root Interference”) If it is desired to “visually” check the gears when these messages appear it is only necessary to temporarily cancel the rule or statement producing the message. (The rule or statement producing the message will be marked with > in the status column.) Some messages occurring at the end of model execution will cause TK to indicate that the model is not resolved. This will be the case if the gear set has an undesirable condition or a condition making the set useless. The solution indicator on the Status Bar at the bottom of the screen will not read “OK” if this is the case. You will still get valid data on the variable sheet and, usually, a plot of the teeth. Other warning messages may appear that only halt execution to notify you of some condition. You need only press the enter key to continue execution.

    Load Analysis

    Many fine pitch gears in today's market place are made of plastic. Plastics used as gear materials present some design problems not encountered with metal gears. However, plastic has some advantages that cannot be realized with metal gears.

    The main disadvantages of plastic as a gear material are:

    1. Load capacity due to wear and bending strength is low 2. Load capacity for pitting not well defined 3. Load capacity is reduced with increasing temperatures 4. High accuracy of form hard to achieve with molding 5. Form can change with time 6. Physical properties change appreciably with temperature 7. High thermal coefficients of expansion 8. High moisture coefficients of expansion for some materials 9. High tooling costs if molded 10. Difficult to mold in coarser pitches

  • Plastic Gear Geometry & Load Analysis 60-610

    3

    The main advantages are: 1. Very low cost when injection molded 2. Low modulus of elasticity allows high aspect ratios 3. Low modulus of elasticity can reduce transmission error 4. Quieter than metal gears for same accuracy 5. Can be run without lubricants (with lower capacity) 6. Complex mechanical features can be molded with gear 7. Can tolerate chemical environments that metal cannot 8. Light weight and low inertia

    For many plastic gear applications the following problems are of primary importance:

    1. Low load capacity Difficult to design adequate gears in required space 2. Difficulty in obtaining adequate contact ratio Low contact ratio at max effective center distance 3. Oil bath lubrication is unusual in plastic gear applications due to cost constraints, etc 4. Grease on open gears would contaminate environment Food processors, printers, copiers, etc

    If the same plastic (or plastics with nearly the same thermal and moisture coefficients of expansion) can be used for the gears and support elements the problem of large differences between maximum and minimum effective center distance due to thermal and moisture changes become much easier to control. The tooth geometry of coarse and fine pitch gears has been standardized by the AGMA and others. For many non-demanding applications the standard tooth proportions work well. However, if large center distance variations, high load capacity or smoother operation are required the standard tooth proportions may not be adequate. "Standard” hobs are, of course, desirable from a lead time and cost standpoint. However, on gear sets that must run with the possibility of large changes in center distance, large temperature ranges or changes in humidity the use of “non-standard” tooth proportions may well be a practical solution to the profile contact ratio problem.

  • UTS Integrated Gear Software

    4

    Strict attention to the tools to be used and a good analysis of the tooth form they are to produce will avoid many of the tooling problems associated with plastic gears. Any geometry problems inherent in the tooling can be found and corrected before the gears are cut. (Of course, if the gears are to be molded, the question of cutting tools would apply only to prototype parts.) In general, gears with high contact ratios will be quieter and smoother and will have higher load capacity. This reference may be helpful in the design and application of plastic gears and the data they furnish are used in this model: Bulletin B.1.1 - Spur Gears and Gearwheels Made From Hostaform® POM, Celanex® PBT and Gur® UHMWPE

    Ticona GmbH Postfach 1561 65444 Kelsterbach Germany

    U.S.A. Properties and Data from

    Ticona 90 Morris Avenue Summit, NJ 07901-3956

    Gearing standards: • DIN 3990 Calculation of Load Capacity of Cylindrical Gears December 1987 • ISO 6336 Calculation of Load Capacity of Spur and Helical Gears 1991

    Note: Calculation of tooth load intensity is in accordance with ISO 6336 as modified by Ticona Bulletin B.1.1, Ticona and the Universal Technical Systems staff.

    • AGMA 2001-B88 Fundamental Rating Factors and Calculation Methods for Involute Spur and Helical Gear Teeth June 1990

  • Plastic Gear Geometry & Load Analysis 60-610

    5

    The following are the Celcon® acetal copolymer equivalents to the Hostaform® acetal copolymer products listed in Ticona Bulletin B.1.1:

    HOECHST AG HOECHST CELANESE CORP Hostaform C 9021 Celcon M90™ Hostaform C 2521 Celcon M25 Hostaform C 27021 Celcon M270 Hostaform C 13021 Celcon M140 Hostaform C 9021 K Celcon LW90 Hostaform S 9063 Celcon TX90 Hostaform S 9064 Celcon TX90+

    The data provided here is as indicated in Bulletin B.1.1. Some of the data has been updated with input from Ticona as provided by Dr. Zan Smith, Engineering Associate, Ticona. Hostaform Celcon, Celanex and GUR are registered trademarks of Ticona. Data on the following materials has been added based on the available information at this time. The allowable flank and root stresses given are engineering judgments, however, and are not based on actual gear testing.

    Celcon GC25A™ Glass Reinforced Acetal Copolymer (4-94) Celanese® Nylon 1000 General Purpose Nylon 6/6 (5-94) Celanese® Nylon 1503 Heat Stabilized, 33% Glass Nylon 6/6 (5-94)

    Celanese is a registered trademark of Celanese International

  • UTS Integrated Gear Software

    6

    Data has been included on the following Delrin® acetal resins from DuPont Engineering Polymer:

    Delrin® 100P Delrin® 500P Delrin® 500TL Delrin® 500CL Delrin® 500AL

    The Delrin® resins are acetal polymers. Delrin® 100P and 500P are both general-purpose and unmodified (no additional lubrication for wear characteristics). The properties of Delrin® 100P are representative of other high-viscosity grades of Delrin®, such as Delrin® 111DP. The properties of Delrin® 500P are representative of other medium-viscosity grades Delrin®, such as 311DP and 511P. The other Delrin® polymers whose properties are included all have their own added lubrication. Delrin® 500TL contains Teflon®, 500CL contains a special chemical lubricant, and 500AL has a package of advanced lubricants. Data on these materials is based on engineering judgments made after a review of test data. Delrin® and Teflon® are registered trademarks of E. I. du Pont de Nemours and Company.

  • Plastic Gear Geometry & Load Analysis 60-610

    7

    The engineering properties of plastic materials are quite sensitive to temperature. This is accounted for in the model by calculating the flank temperature of the gear teeth and altering the “room temperature” properties accordingly. The flank temperature of the teeth depends on:

    1. Ambient temperature 2. Power transmitted 3. Lubrication (if any) 4. Dynamic coefficient of friction 5. Ratio 6. Number of teeth in pinion and gear 7. Pitch line velocity 8. Face width 9. Heat conduction properties of gear materials 10. Sliding velocity between teeth 11. Heat transfer characteristics of housing or surroundings

    The dynamic elastic modulus of the gear material varies with the operating temperature. The dynamic elastic modulus affects the deflection and both the flank stress and the root stress of the gears. Each material in the material data table has an elastic modulus temperature curve, an allowable flank stress temperature curve and an allowable root stress temperature curve. These curves are used to calculate the change in modulus of elasticity, allowable flank stress and allowable root stress with a change in operating temperature. The temperature curve number identifies the proper curve for the material being used. These curves are used to calculate a temperature factor for adjusting the modulus of elasticity, allowable flank stress and allowable root stress for the difference between the reference temperature and the operating temperature. The curves were developed by normalizing data from laboratory tests of the above materials. (The curves for steel are included but consist only of values of one.)

  • UTS Integrated Gear Software

    8

    Fig. L1

    Figure L1 is a typical normalized temperature vs. elastic modulus curve for a plastic material.

  • Plastic Gear Geometry & Load Analysis 60-610

    9

    Fig. L2

    Figure L2 is a typical normalized temperature vs allowable contact stress curve for a dry running plastic material. Note that the value remains at 1 until a temperature of about 60 degrees C is reached. This is because the allowable contact stress is based on wear of 20% of tooth thickness and NOT on pitting failure. This wear rate is fairly constant below 60 degrees C. This allowable contact stress does not, of course, apply to fully or continuously lubricated gears. The pitting contact stress limits for lubricated plastic gears have not been established. Most lubricated plastic gears fail by tooth breakage, not pitting. However, gears with a calculated flank stress safety factor less than one should be tested before assuming that pitting failure is not possible.

  • UTS Integrated Gear Software

    10

    Fig. L3

    Figure L3 is a typical normalized temperature vs. bending stress curve for a plastic material. This curve applies to dry running or lubricated gears. Calculation of tooth load contact and bending stress numbers is in accordance with ISO (Draft) 6336 as modified by Hoechst AG. Bulletin B.1.1, the Hoechst Celanese Advanced Materials Group and the Universal Technical Systems staff. Since the gear tests run by Hoechst Aktiengesellschaft were on “standard” proportion gears the model makes adjustments for the actual gear set being analyzed. These include, among others, adjustment of tooth tip deflection by comparison of tooth length and thickness, comparison of area under the specific sliding curves for heat input and adjustment of the stress by the face load factors for contact and bending stress. (The face load factors are based on tooth alignment along the length of the tooth.) The modulus of elasticity, deflection, wear capacity and strength of plastic gears are dependent on the operating temperature of the gear mesh. The model will calculate the tooth flank temperature of a dry running or greased plastic gear using a formula that has been verified by testing. The model will calculate the tooth bending stress with the load applied at the tooth tip or further down on the tooth depending on the valves of the deflection, the base pitch error and the tip relief.

  • Plastic Gear Geometry & Load Analysis 60-610

    11

    If the gear is oil lubricated the temperature depends on the oil temperature which must be entered as the ambient temperature for the gears. The model will add 5 degrees C to the ambient temperature for the flank temperature for oil lubricated gears. If you wish, you may enter the flank temperature directly for each gear if it is known.

  • UTS Integrated Gear Software

    12

    Examples The following examples are meant to aid in learning to use this model. Many design factors must be considered to optimize a design. Therefore, these examples are not meant to be optimized designs and should not be used as rigid “patterns” for actual designs. The gear data to audit a design should be available from your production data. The hob or shaper data is available from the tool supplier. Example 1 Example 1 is a spur gear set with a “high-addendum” 12 tooth steel pinion cut on a 13 tooth blank meshed with a “standard” 36 tooth plastic gear. We will check the gear geometry first and then the load capacity. The pinion is hobbed with a topping “standard” finish hob. The pinion is the driver. We will check for undercut and interference at the first and last points of contact. Since the pinion is the driver the first point of contact will be at the pinion root (gear tip) and the last point of contact will be at the pinion tip (gear root). Open a new analysis in 60-610. For this example, select metric units. Enter the input data as shown in Figure 1A. (You will need to change defaults for standard center distance, driven outside diameter, and finished tooth thickness at reference PD for driver.) Click “Yes” for all dialog boxes except for entering radial tip champfer, tip relief and load data. The inputs and outputs for the solved model are shown in Report 1A.

  • Plastic Gear Geometry & Load Analysis 60-610

    13

    Fig. 1A

  • UTS Integrated Gear Software

    14

    Report 1A

    Model Title : Program 60-610 Unit System: Metric Description Value Unit Comment

    DRIVER, number of teeth 12

    Hobbed ('hob), Shaped ('shp), Formed hob ('frm)

    DRIVEN, number of teeth 36

    Hobbed ('hob), Shaped ('shp), Formed frm ('frm)

    NORMAL PLANE

    Module 2.000000 mm `

    Diametral Pitch 12.700000 1/in `

    Nominal pressure angle 20.000000 deg

    Base pitch 5.904 mm

    NORMAL PLANE DRIVER

    Finished tooth thickness at Ref PD 3.870 mm

    Total normal circular finish stock on tooth 0.000 mm thickness

    NORMAL PLANE DRIVEN

    Finished tooth thickness at Ref PD 3.112 mm

    Total normal circular finish stock on tooth 0.000 mm Thickness

  • Plastic Gear Geometry & Load Analysis 60-610

    15

    Model Title : Program 60-610 Unit System: Metric Description Value Unit Comment TRANSVERSE PLANE

    Module 2.000000 mm `

    Diametral_Pitch 12.700000 1/in `

    Nominal_pressure angle 20.0000 deg

    Base_pitch 5.904 mm

    Tooth_thickness, Driver 3.870 mm

    Tooth_thickness, Driven 3.112 mm

    COMMON

    Helix angle 0.000000 deg

    Base_helix angle 0.0000 deg

    Axial pitch mm

    Operating_center distance 49.000 mm

    Standard_center distance 48.0000 mm

    Net face width 26.000 mm

    Aspect ratio 1.061

    COMMON DRIVER

    Outside Diameter 30.002 mm

    Normal_top land width 0.569 mm

    Start_Tip Modification mm

    Roll_at_start of tip modification deg

    Normal_OD tip relief mm

    Normal_circular OD tip relief mm

  • UTS Integrated Gear Software

    16

    Transverse_circular_OD tip relief mm

    Model Title : Program 60-610 Unit System: Metric Description Value Unit Comment

    Effective_outside diameter 30.002 mm

    Normal_effective OD tip relief mm

    Normal_tooth_thickness_at_Eff OD 0.569 mm

    Load_angle with tooth CL at eff OD 49.82 deg

    Pointed tooth diameter (No tip mod) 30.642 mm

    Reference PD 24.000 mm

    Inv/fillet intersection dia (TIF) 22.621 mm

    Roll_at_inv/fill intersection dia 4.453 deg

    Normal_TT_at_inv/fill intersection d 3.981 mm

    Minimum_fillet radius 0.663 mm

    Root diameter 21.002 mm

    LA 4.500 mm

    Base_diameter 22.553 mm

    Lead mm

    Area of space (Normal section) 16.336 mm^2

    Area of tooth (Normal section) 13.708 mm^2

    COMMON DRIVEN

    Outside Diameter 76.000 mm

    Normal_top land width 1.320 mm

    Start_Tip Modification mm

    Roll_at_start of tip modification deg

    Normal_OD tip relief mm

    Normal_circular OD tip relief mm

  • Plastic Gear Geometry & Load Analysis 60-610

    17

    Model Title : Program 60-610 Unit System: Metric Description Value Unit Comment

    Transverse_circular_OD tip relief mm

    Effective_outside diameter 75.863 mm

    Normal_effective OD tip relief mm

    Normal_tooth_thickness_at_Eff OD 1.541 mm

    Load_angle with tooth CL at eff OD 64.27 deg

    Pointed tooth diameter (No tip mod) 78.710 mm

    Reference PD 72.000 mm

    Inv/fillet intersection dia (TIF) 68.739 mm

    Roll_at_inv/fill intersection dia 10.285 deg

    Normal_TT_at_inv/fill intersection d 3.866 mm

    Minimum_fillet radius 0.950 mm

    Root diameter 66.600 mm

    Whole depth of tooth (from Eff OD) 4.700 mm

    Base_diameter 67.658 mm

    Lead mm

    Area of space (Normal section) 14.165 mm^2

    Area of tooth (Normal section) 15.080 mm^2

    OPERATING DATA

    Change in Operating CD from "Std" CD 1.000 mm

    Working depth of active flanks 3.933 mm

    Total_working depth 4.001 mm

    Normal_circular_backlash 0.084 mm

    Transverse_circular backlash 0.084 mm

  • UTS Integrated Gear Software

    18

    Model Title : Program 60-610 Unit System: Metric Description Value Unit Comment

    Normal_module 2.041667 mm `

    Transverse_module 2.041667 mm `

    Normal_pressure angle 22.998 deg

    Transverse_pressure angle 22.998 deg

    Helix_angle 0.000 deg

    OPERATING DATA DRIVER

    Pitch_diameter 24.500 mm

    Normal_tooth thickness 3.751 mm

    Transverse_tooth thickness 3.751 mm

    Start of active profile (SAP) 22.900 mm

    Root_clearance 0.499 mm

    Max_specific sliding ratio 1.879

    OPERATING DATA DRIVEN

    Pitch_diameter 73.500 mm

    Normal_tooth thickness 2.579 mm

    Transverse_tooth thickness 2.579 mm

    Start of active profile (SAP) 70.142 mm

    Root_clearance 0.699 mm

    Max_specific sliding ratio 2.208

    PLOT CONFIGURATION

    Mark inv/fil intersections? y

    Mark mod/inv intersections? y

    Number of teeth on plot 1

  • Plastic Gear Geometry & Load Analysis 60-610

    19

    Model Title : Program 60-610 Unit System: Metric Description Value Unit Comment

    Driver_contact roll angle of deg

    Driver tooth number 1

    DRIVER ROLL ANGLES

    Start_of_active profile-No Undercut 10.093 deg

    Actual_start of active profile 10.093 deg

    Lowest_single contact-LCR Spur 20.269 deg

    Lowest_double contact-HCR Spur deg

    Operating pitch point 24.319 deg

    Highest_single contact-LCR Spur 40.093 deg

    Highest_double contact-HCR Spur deg

    Actual_end of active profile 50.269 deg

    Effective outside diameter 50.269 deg

    DRIVEN ROLL ANGLES

    Start_of_active profile-No Undercut 15.669 deg

    Actual_start of active profile 15.669 deg

    Lowest_single contact-LCR Spur 19.061 deg

    Lowest_double contact-HCR Spur deg

    Operating pitch point 24.319 deg

    Highest_single contact-LCR Spur 25.669 deg

    Highest_double contact-HCR Spur deg

    Actual_end of active profile 29.061 deg

    Effective outside diameter 29.061 deg

  • UTS Integrated Gear Software

    20

    Model Title : Program 60-610 Unit System: Metric Description Value Unit Comment

    CONTACT DATA

    Total_arc of contact, driver 40.176 deg

    Arc_of_approach 14.225 deg

    Arc_of_recess 25.951 deg

    Approach action 35.41 %

    Recess action 64.59 %

    Profile contact ratio (SAP > TIF) 1.339

    Actual profile contact ratio 1.339

    Contact below finished involute? No

    Helical contact ratio 0.000

    Total_contact ratio 1.339

    Unmodified (light load) profile CR

    Profile_contact ratio

    Helical contact ratio

    Total_contact ratio

    FORMED DRIVEN

    Flank angle 20.0000 deg

    Tip to reference line 2.660 mm

    Tooth thickness at reference line 3.142 mm

    Tip_radius 0.860 mm

    Radial_tip chamfer (w/o mod) 0.000 mm

    Normal_tip radius 0.125 mm

    Normal_tip_relief exponent

  • Plastic Gear Geometry & Load Analysis 60-610

    21

    Model Title : Program 60-610 Unit System: Metric Description Value Unit Comment

    DRIVER HOB

    Hob type t

    Flank angle 20.0000 deg

    Tip to Reference Line 2.500 mm

    Tooth thickness at Reference Line 3.142 mm

    Tip_radius 0.600 mm

    Protuberance 0.000 mm

    Protuberance_angle from flank deg

    Protuberance_pressure angle deg

    Tip_to_flank/prot intersection mm

    Reference_Line_to Start Mod Ramp mm

    Pressure Angle of Mod Ramp deg

    Reference_Line_To Hob Tooth Root 2.000 mm

    Radius in Hob Tooth Root 0.628 mm

    Ref_Line to Hob SAP 0.979 mm

    Normal_Space Width at Hob SAP 2.429 mm Contact should start on the pinion at 10.094 degrees roll angle if there is no contact below the finished involute profile. (There isn't; “Contact below finished involute?” is “No” on the report.). We will plot 3 teeth on each gear with tooth #1 on the driver at the start of contact. On the Plot Configuration tab of the input form (Figure 1B), click the radio button for SAP with a roll angle of 10.094 degrees. Enter 3 teeth to be plotted and tooth #1 at the driver SAP. The plot should look like Figure 1C. The small “tic” marks indicate the intersection of the involute and fillet and involute and tip radius.

  • UTS Integrated Gear Software

    22

    Fig. 1B

    Fig. 1C

    Note that contact is just taking place at the root of the driver (pinion) and the start of the tip radius of the driven (gear). One base pitch away down the line of action a second tooth is also in contact.

  • Plastic Gear Geometry & Load Analysis 60-610

    23

    We wish to visually check the driver tooth at the first point of contact for undercut and interference. To do this, toggle to TK Solver and go to the plot subsheet for “mesh”. Put the cursor anywhere on the plot and click the right mouse button. Enter yes for “Display Scale:” and “Display Grid:”, as shown in Figure 1D: Fig. 1D

  • UTS Integrated Gear Software

    24

    The plot should then look like Figure 1E. Fig. 1E

    From the plot grid we see that the area we are interested in is bounded by -4, -2 on the X-Axis and 0, 2 on the Y-Axis. Enter these values on the subsheet, as shown in Figure 1F. The plot is shown in Figure 1G.

  • Plastic Gear Geometry & Load Analysis 60-610

    25

    Fig. 1F

    From the plot, Figure 1G, we see that there is no undercut on the driver and the driven tooth tip is contacting on the involute profile. Now we will take a quick look at the start of active profile on the driven gear, although, with “standard” proportions we expect no difficulty here. The lowest point of single tooth contact on the pinion for driver tooth #1 will place driver tooth #2 in contact at the tooth tip. This is also the start of active profile on the driven. Make this selection from the Plot Configuration tab (Figure 1B).

    Fig. 1G

  • UTS Integrated Gear Software

    26

    Enter 2 teeth to be plotted and set the driver tooth number to 1. (The same thing could be accomplished by choosing the driver roll angle to 50.269 degrees (outside diameter) and the driver tooth number to 2.) You will also need to toggle to TK Solver and bring up the subsheet for the plot “mesh”. Set “Display Scale” to “No” and blank the X and Y axis minimum-maximum on the plot subsheet. The plot is shown in Figure 1H. Fig 1H

    As a matter of interest we will confirm that at the operating pitch point, 24.319 degrees, we only have one tooth in contact. (The zone of single tooth contact, of course, extends from 20.269 to 40.093 degrees.) Solve the model again, then choose this option on the Plot Configuration tab. (See Figure 1B.) Figure 1I shows the teeth in contact at the operating pitch point.

  • Plastic Gear Geometry & Load Analysis 60-610

    27

    Fig. 1I

    Now we are ready to check the load capacity of the gears. The load and material specification is as follows:

    Power = 500 W Pinion Speed = 3600 RPM Housing shaft alignment: Parallel = 0.0010 mm/mm Plane = 0.0010 mm/mm Pinion is steel made to AGMA Quality Class Q9. The pinion shaft is solid. Gear is Celanese Celcon M90 Acetal made to AGMA Quality Class Q7 Gears are greased. The gear rim diameter is 52 mm. Ambient temperature = 40 deg C

    If you have saved the earlier analysis, open it now; otherwise start a new analysis and enter the inputs in Figure 1J. When the dialog asks “Do you want to enter load data?” click yes this time. Choose “power,” not “torque,” then enter the power and pinion speed as given above. The housing shaft alignment figures are both defaults. Enter the ambient temperature and pick “grease” from the pick list. Choose “no” for entering the driver bore/diameter data, but “yes” for driven, and enter 52. Neither gear is an idler.

  • UTS Integrated Gear Software

    28

    The completed input form is shown in Figure 1J and the input and output values for the solved model in Report 1B. Fig. 1J

  • Plastic Gear Geometry & Load Analysis 60-610

    29

    Report 1B

    Model Title : Program 60-610 Unit System: Metric Description Value Unit Comment

    DRIVER, number of teeth 12

    Hobbed ('hob), Shaped ('shp), Formed hob ('frm)

    DRIVEN, number of teeth 36

    Hobbed ('hob), Shaped ('shp), Formed frm ('frm)

    NORMAL PLANE

    Module 2.000000 mm `

    Diametral Pitch 12.700000 1/in `

    Nominal pressure angle 20.000000 deg

    Base pitch 5.904 mm

    NORMAL PLANE DRIVER

    Finished tooth thickness at Ref PD 3.870 mm

    Total normal circular finish stock on tooth 0.000 mm thickness

    NORMAL PLANE DRIVEN

    Finished tooth thickness at Ref PD 3.112 mm

    Total normal circular finish stock on tooth 0.000 mm Thickness

  • UTS Integrated Gear Software

    30

    Model Title : Program 60-610 Unit System: Metric Description Value Unit Comment TRANSVERSE PLANE

    Module 2.000000 mm `

    Diametral_Pitch 12.700000 1/in `

    Nominal_pressure angle 20.0000 deg

    Base_pitch 5.904 mm

    Tooth_thickness, Driver 3.870 mm

    Tooth_thickness, Driven 3.112 mm

    COMMON

    Helix angle 0.000000 deg

    Base_helix angle 0.0000 deg

    Axial pitch mm

    Operating_center distance 49.000 mm

    Standard_center distance 48.0000 mm

    Net face width 26.000 mm

    Aspect ratio 1.061

    COMMON DRIVER

    Outside Diameter 30.002 mm

    Normal_top land width 0.569 mm

    Start_Tip Modification mm

    Roll_at_start of tip modification deg

    Normal_OD tip relief mm

    Normal_circular OD tip relief mm

  • Plastic Gear Geometry & Load Analysis 60-610

    31

    Transverse_circular_OD tip relief mm

    Model Title : Program 60-610 Unit System: Metric Description Value Unit Comment

    Effective_outside diameter 30.002 mm

    Normal_effective OD tip relief mm

    Normal_tooth_thickness_at_Eff OD 0.569 mm

    Load_angle with tooth CL at eff OD 49.82 deg

    Pointed tooth diameter (No tip mod) 30.642 mm

    Reference PD 24.000 mm

    Inv/fillet intersection dia (TIF) 22.621 mm

    Roll_at_inv/fill intersection dia 4.453 deg

    Normal_TT_at_inv/fill intersection d 3.981 mm

    Minimum_fillet radius 0.663 mm

    Root diameter 21.002 mm

    LA 4.500 mm

    Base_diameter 22.553 mm

    Lead mm

    Area of space (Normal section) 16.336 mm^2

    Area of tooth (Normal section) 13.708 mm^2

    COMMON DRIVEN

    Outside Diameter 76.000 mm

    Normal_top land width 1.320 mm

    Start_Tip Modification mm

    Roll_at_start of tip modification deg

    Normal_OD tip relief mm

    Normal_circular OD tip relief mm

  • UTS Integrated Gear Software

    32

    Model Title : Program 60-610 Unit System: Metric Description Value Unit Comment

    Transverse_circular_OD tip relief mm

    Effective_outside diameter 75.863 mm

    Normal_effective OD tip relief mm

    Normal_tooth_thickness_at_Eff OD 1.541 mm

    Load_angle with tooth CL at eff OD 64.27 deg

    Pointed tooth diameter (No tip mod) 78.710 mm

    Reference PD 72.000 mm

    Inv/fillet intersection dia (TIF) 68.739 mm

    Roll_at_inv/fill intersection dia 10.285 deg

    Normal_TT_at_inv/fill intersection d 3.866 mm

    Minimum_fillet radius 0.950 mm

    Root diameter 66.600 mm

    Whole depth of tooth (from Eff OD) 4.700 mm

    Base_diameter 67.658 mm

    Lead mm

    Area of space (Normal section) 14.165 mm^2

    Area of tooth (Normal section) 15.080 mm^2

    OPERATING DATA

    Change in Operating CD from "Std" CD 1.000 mm

    Working depth of active flanks 3.933 mm

    Total_working depth 4.001 mm

    Normal_circular_backlash 0.084 mm

    Transverse_circular backlash 0.084 mm

  • Plastic Gear Geometry & Load Analysis 60-610

    33

    Model Title : Program 60-610 Unit System: Metric Description Value Unit Comment

    Normal_module 2.041667 mm `

    Transverse_module 2.041667 mm `

    Normal_pressure angle 22.998 deg

    Transverse_pressure angle 22.998 deg

    Helix_angle 0.000 deg

    OPERATING DATA DRIVER

    Pitch_diameter 24.500 mm

    Normal_tooth thickness 3.751 mm

    Transverse_tooth thickness 3.751 mm

    Start of active profile (SAP) 22.900 mm

    Root_clearance 0.499 mm

    Max_specific sliding ratio 1.879

    OPERATING DATA DRIVEN

    Pitch_diameter 73.500 mm

    Normal_tooth thickness 2.579 mm

    Transverse_tooth thickness 2.579 mm

    Start of active profile (SAP) 70.142 mm

    Root_clearance 0.699 mm

    Max_specific sliding ratio 2.208

    PLOT CONFIGURATION

    Mark inv/fil intersections? y

    Mark mod/inv intersections? y

    Number of teeth on plot 1

  • UTS Integrated Gear Software

    34

    Model Title : Program 60-610 Unit System: Metric Description Value Unit Comment

    Driver_contact roll angle of 10.094 deg

    Driver tooth number 1

    DRIVER ROLL ANGLES

    Start_of_active profile-No Undercut 10.093 deg

    Actual_start of active profile 10.093 deg

    Lowest_single contact-LCR Spur 20.269 deg

    Lowest_double contact-HCR Spur deg

    Operating pitch point 24.319 deg

    Highest_single contact-LCR Spur 40.093 deg

    Highest_double contact-HCR Spur deg

    Actual_end of active profile 50.269 deg

    Effective outside diameter 50.269 deg

    DRIVEN ROLL ANGLES

    Start_of_active profile-No Undercut 15.669 deg

    Actual_start of active profile 15.669 deg

    Lowest_single contact-LCR Spur 19.061 deg

    Lowest_double contact-HCR Spur deg

    Operating pitch point 24.319 deg

    Highest_single contact-LCR Spur 25.669 deg

    Highest_double contact-HCR Spur deg

    Actual_end of active profile 29.061 deg

    Effective outside diameter 29.061 deg

  • Plastic Gear Geometry & Load Analysis 60-610

    35

    Model Title : Program 60-610 Unit System: Metric Description Value Unit Comment

    CONTACT DATA

    Total_arc of contact, driver 40.176 deg

    Arc_of_approach 14.225 deg

    Arc_of_recess 25.951 deg

    Approach action 35.41 %

    Recess action 64.59 %

    Profile contact ratio (SAP > TIF) 1.339

    Actual profile contact ratio 1.339

    Contact below finished involute? No

    Helical contact ratio 0.000

    Total_contact ratio 1.339

    Unmodified (light load) profile CR

    Profile_contact ratio 1.344

    Helical contact ratio 0.000

    Total_contact ratio 1.344

    FORMED DRIVEN

    Flank angle 20.0000 deg

    Tip to reference line 2.660 mm

    Tooth thickness at reference line 3.142 mm

    Tip_radius 0.860 mm

    Radial_tip chamfer (w/o mod) 0.000 mm

    Normal_tip radius 0.125 mm

    Normal_tip_relief exponent

  • UTS Integrated Gear Software

    36

    Model Title : Program 60-610 Unit System: Metric Description Value Unit Comment

    DRIVER HOB

    Hob type t

    Flank angle 20.0000 deg

    Tip to Reference Line 2.500 mm

    Tooth thickness at Reference Line 3.142 mm

    Tip_radius 0.600 mm

    Protuberance 0.000 mm

    Protuberance_angle from flank deg

    Protuberance_pressure angle deg

    Tip_to_flank/prot intersection mm

    Reference_Line_to Start Mod Ramp mm

    Pressure Angle of Mod Ramp deg

    Reference_Line_To Hob Tooth Root 2.000 mm

    Radius in Hob Tooth Root 0.628 mm

    Ref_Line to Hob SAP 0.979 mm

    Normal_Space Width at Hob SAP 2.429 mm

    LOAD

    Power 0.50000 kW

    Driver Speed 3600.0 rpm

    Driver Torque 1.326 N-m

    Driven Speed 1200.0 rpm

    Driven Torque 3.928 N-m

    Tangential Load 108.269 N

  • Plastic Gear Geometry & Load Analysis 60-610

    37

    Model Title : Program 60-610 Unit System: Metric Description Value Unit Comment

    Unit_Tangential Load 4164.180 N/m

    Efficiency 98.7 %

    COMMON

    Peripheral Speed 4.618 m/sec

    Shafts Maximum Out of Parallel 0.001 mm/mm

    Shafts Maximum Out of Plane 0.001 mm/mm

    Root_Mean Square Face Mismatch 0.035 mm

    Running-In Factor 0.55

    Eff RMS Face Mismatch (Run-In) 0.019 mm

    Transverse Tooth Tip Deflection 0.024 mm

    Root_Mean_Square Base Pitch Error 0.043 mm

    Mesh Linear Stiffness (AGMA 2001) 8406921 N/m

    Line of Action Deflection 0.014 mm

    Relative Wear for Mat`l Combination

    Ambient Temperature 40 C

    Lubrication ('dry, 'grease, 'oil) grease

    Coefficient of Friction 0.05

    Material_Combination Factor 1.0000

    Lube/Housing/Air Circulation Factor 0

    Surface Area of Gear Housing mm^2

    TOOTH FLANK (CONTACT) STRESS

    Shape Factor 1.63

    Material_Factor 42.97

  • UTS Integrated Gear Software

    38

    Model Title : Program 60-610 Unit System: Metric Description Value Unit Comment

    Contact_Ratio Factor 0.941

    Face Load Factor 1.742

    Flank_Contact Stress 41503331.71 Pa

    K factor 226622.017 Pa

    Unit Load 2082089.784 Pa

    TOOTH ROOT (BENDING) STRESS

    Helix_Angle Factor 1.00

    Face Load Factor 1.582

    TOOTH ROOT (BENDING) STRESS DRIVER

    Load Applied at Tooth Tip? Yes

    Tooth_Shape Factor

    Fillet Radius @ Critical Section mm

    YF Valid? (Fil Rad >.25*module)

    Stress correction factor

    Bore/Rim Diameter UNKNOWN mm

    Rim Thickness Factor 1.000

    Backup Ratio UNKNOWN

    Root_Bending Stress Pa

    TOOTH ROOT (BENDING) STRESS DRIVEN

    Load Applied at Tooth Tip? Yes

    Tooth_Shape Factor 2.57

    Fillet Radius @ Critical Section 1.201 mm

    YF Valid? (Fil Rad >.25*module) Yes

  • Plastic Gear Geometry & Load Analysis 60-610

    39

    Model Title : Program 60-610 Unit System: Metric Description Value Unit Comment

    Stress correction factor 1.00

    Bore/Rim Diameter 52.000 mm

    Rim Thickness Factor 1.000

    Backup Ratio 1.576

    Root_Bending Stress 8283628.86 Pa

    MATERIALS/QUALITY CLASS DRIVER

    Material # 1

    AGMA Quality Class 9

    Tooth_Alignment (Lead) Error 0.010 mm

    Tooth_Flank Temperature C

    Material_Heat Index

    Dynamic Elastic Modulus 207000000000 Pa

    Temperature Curve # 1.0000

    Temperature_Factor

    Poisson`s Ratio 0.3000

    Sliding Velocity at Tooth Tip 2.567 m/sec

    Allowable_Flank Stress (10^7 cy) Pa

    Temperature Curve #

    Temperature_Factor

    FLANK SAFETY FACTOR

    Allowable_Root Stress (10^7 cy) Pa

    Idler? 'y/'n

    Same Flank Contacts/Rev

    Temperature Curve #

  • UTS Integrated Gear Software

    40

    Model Title : Program 60-610 Unit System: Metric Description Value Unit Comment

    Temperature_Factor

    ROOT SAFETY FACTOR

    MATERIALS/QUALITY CLASS DRIVEN

    Material # 2

    AGMA Quality Class 7

    Tooth_Alignment (Lead) Error 0.015 mm

    Tooth_Flank Temperature 42.35 C

    Material_Heat Index 0.4000

    Dynamic Elastic Modulus 2578139103 Pa

    Temperature Curve # 2.0000

    Temperature_Factor 0.87

    Poisson`s Ratio 0.3500

    Sliding Velocity at Tooth Tip 1.407 m/sec

    Allowable_Flank Stress (10^7 cy) 19000000.0 Pa

    Temperature Curve # 2.0000

    Temperature_Factor 1.00

    FLANK SAFETY FACTOR 0.46

    Allowable_Root Stress (10^7 cy) 34632832.3 Pa

    Idler? 'y/'n n

    Same Flank Contacts/Rev 1.0000

    Temperature Curve # 2.0000

    Temperature_Factor 0.81

    ROOT SAFETY FACTOR 4.18

  • Plastic Gear Geometry & Load Analysis 60-610

    41

    With this load applied the tooth tip deflection is 0.024 mm. The RMS base pitch error with the pinion made to AGMA Q9 and the gear made to AGMA Q7 is 0.0431 mm. Since the base pitch error is larger than the tooth tip deflection (and there is no tip relief) the tooth shape factor for bending, 2.57, is calculated with all load applied at the tip of the gear tooth. This results in a root bending stress of 8.28 N/mm2. The contact stress is 41.5 N/mm2. Note that the rim thickness factor for the gear is one. This indicates that the thickness of the rim below the root of the teeth is sufficient (1.2 times the tooth depth) to avoid an increase in root stress due to a thin rim. Since the pinion is made of steel, which has a high thermal conductivity, and the coefficient of friction is low, 0.05, because of the lubrication, the flank temperature of the gear is only 42.35 C. The temperature factor for the gear modulus of elasticity is 0.87. See Figure 1K. Fig. 1K

    The temperature factor for the gear allowable flank contact stress is 1.00. See Figure 1L.

  • UTS Integrated Gear Software

    42

    Fig. 1L

    The temperature factor for the gear allowable root bending stress is 0.81. See Figure 1M. Fig. 1M

  • Plastic Gear Geometry & Load Analysis 60-610

    43

    The values from the table for Celcon M90 (Material #2) are:

    Modulus of Elasticity = 2950 N/mm2 Allowable Flank Stress = 19 N/mm2 Allowable Root Stress = 43 N/mm2

    After applying the temperature factors the values are:

    Modulus of Elasticity = 2578 N/mm2 Allowable Flank Stress = 19 N/mm2 Allowable Root Stress = 34.6 N/mm2

    This results in a root safety factor of 4.18 and a flank safety factor of 0.46. The root bending safety factor is more than ample but the flank stress safety factor is less than one.

    The allowable flank stress, however, is based on wear of dry running plastic gears and does not apply to continuously lubricated gears. This design is probably sufficient since most lubricated plastic gears fail in root bending, not pitting. (Gear load data for lubricated pitting failure is not yet available.) It is essential that a set of test gears be made and tested to insure that pitting will not occur with a flank safety factor less than one.

  • UTS Integrated Gear Software

    44

    Example 2 Example 2 is a 25/45 tooth, 16 pitch, 20 degree pressure angle, high addendum spur gear set running on 0.0225 inch “spread” centers. The gears will be extra depth and will have full trochoidal fillets using a basic rack form to preclude tip-root interference. The rack form will be the AGMA Plastic Rack XPT-3. (The practice of using circular arcs for the fillets on external involute gears will lead to interference between the fillet and the tooth tip of the mating gear in many cases. The is especially true when meshing with master gears at minimum tooth thickness conditions.) We wish to use full radius fillets to keep the root bending stress to a minimum. The gears will have a radius at the tooth tips of 0.004 inch. In addition, tip relief is required to hold noise to a minimum. We will first design the gears and check the load capacity without the tip relief. Then, after the tooth tip deflections have been found, we will apply the tip relief. The gears must carry 1.25 HP at a driver speed of 3600 RPM. The shafts can be 0.001 in/in out of parallel and out of plane. The gears will run dry in an ambient temperature of 105 deg F. The housing is partially open with good air circulation. The exposed area of the housing is about 120 in2. The pinion material will be Celanese Celcon M25 made to AGMA Quality Class Q7. The pinion bore is 0.5 inch. The gear material will be Celanese Celcon TX90 made to AGMA Quality Class Q7. The gear rim diameter is 2.0 inches. Change the units in the model to “US”. Enter the input data shown in Figure 2A.

  • Plastic Gear Geometry & Load Analysis 60-610

    45

    Fig. 2A

    When solving, we got a message that the tooth tip deflection (0.0049 inch) was greater than the backlash (0.0030 inch). We must increase the backlash or the teeth will contact on the back (non-driving) side. This could cause wear, noise and jamming. We will increase the backlash by changing the tooth thickness of the driver and driven to 0.1065 inch and 0.1020 inch.

  • UTS Integrated Gear Software

    46

    The tooth tip deflection is about 0.0049 inch which is well below the allowable limit for smooth operation of 0.1/NDP - 0.0062 inch. We will apply tip relief of about 0.003 inch to both gears to further ease contact at the start and end of the mesh cycle. The tip relief will start at a diameter of 1.665 inches on the driver and 2.913 inches on the driven to keep a profile contact ratio of about 1.05 when the set is lightly loaded and the modified portions of the teeth are not in contact (use the cursor to enter the tip relief data). (See UTS Model 60-1111 for further data on tip relief.)

    We will plot two teeth in mesh at the first point of contact on the driver. (Use the selection in the Plot Configuration tab of the input form.)

    Figure 2B is the input form with the new inputs. The solved model is shown in Report 2B.

  • Plastic Gear Geometry & Load Analysis 60-610

    47

    Fig. 2B

  • UTS Integrated Gear Software

    48

    Report 2B

    Model Title : Program 60-610 Unit System: US Description Value Unit Comment

    DRIVER, number of teeth 25

    Hobbed ('hob), Shaped ('shp), Formed frm ('frm)

    DRIVEN, number of teeth 45

    Hobbed ('hob), Shaped ('shp), Formed frm ('frm)

    NORMAL PLANE

    Module 1.587500 mm `

    Diametral Pitch 16.000000 1/in `

    Nominal pressure angle 20.000000 deg

    Base pitch 0.1845 in

    NORMAL PLANE DRIVER

    Finished tooth thickness at Ref PD 0.1065 in

    Total normal circular finish stock on tooth 0.0000 in thickness

    NORMAL PLANE DRIVEN

    Finished tooth thickness at Ref PD 0.1020 in

    Total normal circular finish stock on tooth 0.0000 in Thickness

  • Plastic Gear Geometry & Load Analysis 60-610

    49

    Model Title : Program 60-610 Unit System: US Description Value Unit Comment TRANSVERSE PLANE

    Module 1.587500 mm `

    Diametral_Pitch 16.000000 1/in `

    Nominal_pressure angle 20.0000 deg

    Base_pitch 0.1845 in

    Tooth_thickness, Driver 0.1065 in

    Tooth_thickness, Driven 0.1020 in

    COMMON

    Helix angle 0.000000 deg

    Base_helix angle 0.0000 deg

    Axial pitch in

    Operating_center distance 2.210 in

    Standard_center distance 2.1875 in

    Net face width 1.6250 in

    Aspect ratio 1.029

    COMMON DRIVER

    Outside Diameter 1.7477 in

    Normal_top land width 0.0076 in

    Start_Tip Modification 1.6650 in

    Roll_at_start of tip modification 30.637 deg

    Normal_OD tip relief 0.003 in

    Normal_circular OD tip relief 0.004 in

    Transverse_circular_OD tip relief 0.004 in

  • UTS Integrated Gear Software

    50

    Model Title : Program 60-610 Unit System: US Description Value Unit Comment

    Effective_outside diameter 1.7445 in

    Normal_effective OD tip relief 0.003 in

    Normal_tooth_thickness_at_Eff OD 0.0140 in

    Load_angle with tooth CL at eff OD 57.99 deg

    Pointed tooth diameter (No tip mod) 1.7762 in

    Reference PD 1.5625 in

    Inv/fillet intersection dia (TIF) 1.4714 in

    Roll_at_inv/fill intersection dia 3.757 deg

    Normal_TT_at_inv/fill intersection d 0.1221 in

    Minimum_fillet radius 0.0242 in

    Root diameter 1.3880 in

    LA 0.1798 in

    Base_diameter 1.4683 in

    Lead in

    Area of space (Normal section) 0.0185 in^2

    Area of tooth (Normal section) 0.0169 in^2

    COMMON DRIVEN

    Outside Diameter 2.9848 in

    Normal_top land width 0.0177 in

    Start_Tip Modification 2.9130 in

    Roll_at_start of tip modification 26.558 deg

    Normal_OD tip relief 0.003 in

    Normal_circular OD tip relief 0.003 in

  • Plastic Gear Geometry & Load Analysis 60-610

    51

    Model Title : Program 60-610 Unit System: US Description Value Unit Comment

    Transverse_circular_OD tip relief 0.003 in

    Effective_outside diameter 2.9812 in

    Normal_effective OD tip relief 0.003 in

    Normal_tooth_thickness_at_Eff OD 0.0244 in

    Load_angle with tooth CL at eff OD 63.03 deg

    Pointed tooth diameter (No tip mod) 3.0380 in

    Reference PD 2.8125 in

    Inv/fillet intersection dia (TIF) 2.6875 in

    Roll_at_inv/fill intersection dia 10.572 deg

    Normal_TT_at_inv/fill intersection d 0.1320 in

    Minimum_fillet radius 0.0225 in

    Root diameter 2.6257 in

    Whole depth of tooth (from Eff OD) 0.1796 in

    Base_diameter 2.6429 in

    Lead in

    Area of space (Normal section) 0.0175 in^2

    Area of tooth (Normal section) 0.0176 in^2

    OPERATING DATA

    Change in Operating CD from "Std" CD 0.0225 in

    Working depth of active flanks 0.1529 in

    Total_working depth 0.1563 in

    Normal_circular_backlash 0.0049 in

    Transverse_circular backlash 0.0049 in

  • UTS Integrated Gear Software

    52

    Model Title : Program 60-610 Unit System: US Description Value Unit Comment

    Normal_module 1.603829 mm `

    Transverse_module 1.603829 mm `

    Normal_pressure angle 21.546 deg

    Transverse_pressure angle 21.546 deg

    Helix_angle 0.000 deg

    OPERATING DATA DRIVER

    Pitch_diameter 1.5786 in

    Normal_tooth thickness 0.1015 in

    Transverse_tooth thickness 0.1015 in

    Start of active profile (SAP) 1.4884 in

    Root_clearance 0.0236 in

    Max_specific sliding ratio 2.143

    OPERATING DATA DRIVEN

    Pitch_diameter 2.8414 in

    Normal_tooth thickness 0.0920 in

    Transverse_tooth thickness 0.0920 in

    Start of active profile (SAP) 2.7292 in

    Root_clearance 0.0233 in

    Max_specific sliding ratio 1.490

    PLOT CONFIGURATION

    Mark inv/fil intersections? y

    Mark mod/inv intersections? y

    Number of teeth on plot 2

  • Plastic Gear Geometry & Load Analysis 60-610

    53

    Model Title : Program 60-610 Unit System: US Description Value Unit Comment

    Driver_contact roll angle of 9.574 deg

    Driver tooth number 1

    DRIVER ROLL ANGLES

    Start_of_active profile-No Undercut 9.515 deg

    Actual_start of active profile 9.515 deg

    Lowest_single contact-LCR Spur 22.365 deg

    Lowest_double contact-HCR Spur deg

    Operating pitch point 22.622 deg

    Highest_single contact-LCR Spur 23.915 deg

    Highest_double contact-HCR Spur deg

    Actual_end of active profile 36.765 deg

    Effective outside diameter 36.765 deg

    DRIVEN ROLL ANGLES

    Start_of_active profile-No Undercut 14.765 deg

    Actual_start of active profile 14.765 deg

    Lowest_single contact-LCR Spur 21.904 deg

    Lowest_double contact-HCR Spur deg

    Operating pitch point 22.622 deg

    Highest_single contact-LCR Spur 22.765 deg

    Highest_double contact-HCR Spur deg

    Actual_end of active profile 29.904 deg

    Effective outside diameter 29.904 deg

  • UTS Integrated Gear Software

    54

    Model Title : Program 60-610 Unit System: US Description Value Unit Comment

    CONTACT DATA

    Total_arc of contact, driver 27.250 deg

    Arc_of_approach 13.107 deg

    Arc_of_recess 14.143 deg

    Approach action 48.10 %

    Recess action 51.90 %

    Profile contact ratio (SAP > TIF) 1.892

    Actual profile contact ratio 1.892

    Contact below finished involute? No

    Helical contact ratio 0.000

    Total_contact ratio 1.892

    Unmodified (light load) profile CR 1.049

    Profile_contact ratio 1.914

    Helical contact ratio 0.000

    Total_contact ratio 1.914

    FORMED DRIVER

    Flank angle 20.0000 deg

    Tip to reference line 0.0987 in

    Tooth thickness at reference line 0.0982 in

    Tip_radius 0.0187 in

    Radial_tip chamfer (w/o mod) 0.0000 in

    Normal_tip radius 0.0040 in

    Normal_tip_relief exponent 1.5000

  • Plastic Gear Geometry & Load Analysis 60-610

    55

    Model Title : Program 60-610 Unit System: US Description Value Unit Comment

    FORMED DRIVEN

    Flank angle 20.0000 deg

    Tip to reference line 0.0987 in

    Tooth thickness at reference line 0.0982 in

    Tip_radius 0.0187 in

    Radial_tip chamfer (w/o mod) 0.0000 in

    Normal_tip radius 0.0040 in

    Normal_tip_relief exponent 1.5000

    LOAD

    Power 1.25000 HP

    Driver Speed 3600.0 rpm

    Driver Torque 21.8838 lbf-in

    Driven Speed 2000.0 rpm

    Driven Torque 36.9832 lbf-in

    Tangential Load 27.7261 lbf

    Unit_Tangential Load 17.0622 lbf/in

    Efficiency 93.9 %

    COMMON

    Peripheral Speed 1487.7685 ft/min

    Shafts Maximum Out of Parallel 0.001 in/in

    Shafts Maximum Out of Plane 0.001 in/in

    Root_Mean Square Face Mismatch 0.002 in

    Running-In Factor 0.25

  • UTS Integrated Gear Software

    56

    Model Title : Program 60-610 Unit System: US Description Value Unit Comment

    Eff RMS Face Mismatch (Run-In) 0.001 in

    Transverse Tooth Tip Deflection 0.005 in

    Root_Mean_Square Base Pitch Error 0.002 in

    Mesh Linear Stiffness (AGMA 2001) 14876 lbf/in

    Line of Action Deflection 0.002 in

    Relative Wear for Mat`l Combination GOOD

    Ambient Temperature 105 F

    Lubrication ('dry, 'grease, 'oil) dry

    Coefficient of Friction 0.33

    Material_Combination Factor 2.5000

    Lube/Housing/Air Circulation Factor .04

    Surface Area of Gear Housing 120.0000 in^2

    TOOTH FLANK (CONTACT) STRESS

    Shape Factor 1.69

    Material_Factor 19.34

    Contact_Ratio Factor 0.834

    Face Load Factor 1.146

    Flank_Contact Stress 1444.03 psi

    K factor 16.8134 psi

    Unit Load 272.9954 psi

    TOOTH ROOT (BENDING) STRESS

    Helix_Angle Factor 1.00

    Face Load Factor 1.129

  • Plastic Gear Geometry & Load Analysis 60-610

    57

    Model Title : Program 60-610 Unit System: US Description Value Unit Comment

    TOOTH ROOT (BENDING) STRESS DRIVER

    Load Applied at Tooth Tip? No

    Tooth_Shape Factor 1.59

    Fillet Radius @ Critical Section 0.0349 in

    YF Valid? (Fil Rad >.25*module) Yes

    Stress correction factor 1.00

    Bore/Rim Diameter 0.5000 in

    Rim Thickness Factor 1.000

    Backup Ratio 2.491

    Root_Bending Stress 484.66 psi

    TOOTH ROOT (BENDING) STRESS DRIVEN

    Load Applied at Tooth Tip? No

    Tooth_Shape Factor 1.52

    Fillet Radius @ Critical Section 0.0337 in

    YF Valid? (Fil Rad >.25*module) Yes

    Stress correction factor 1.00

    Bore/Rim Diameter 2.0000 in

    Rim Thickness Factor 1.000

    Backup Ratio 1.760

    Root_Bending Stress 463.48 psi

    MATERIALS/QUALITY CLASS DRIVER

    Material # 4

    AGMA Quality Class 7

  • UTS Integrated Gear Software

    58

    Model Title : Program 60-610 Unit System: US Description Value Unit Comment

    Tooth_Alignment (Lead) Error 0.001 in

    Tooth_Flank Temperature 201.65 F

    Material_Heat Index 0.4000

    Dynamic Elastic Modulus 142874 psi

    Temperature Curve # 3.0000

    Temperature_Factor 0.36

    Poisson`s Ratio 0.3500

    Sliding Velocity at Tooth Tip 531.3442 ft/min

    Allowable_Flank Stress (10^7 cy) 1742.0 psi

    Temperature Curve # 2.0000

    Temperature_Factor 0.63

    FLANK SAFETY FACTOR 1.21

    Allowable_Root Stress (10^7 cy) 2347.6 psi

    Idler? 'y/'n n

    Same Flank Contacts/Rev 1.0000

    Temperature Curve # 2.0000

    Temperature_Factor 0.38

    ROOT SAFETY FACTOR 4.84

    MATERIALS/QUALITY CLASS DRIVEN

    Material # 7

    AGMA Quality Class 7

    Tooth_Alignment (Lead) Error 0.001 in

    Tooth_Flank Temperature 166.24 F

  • Plastic Gear Geometry & Load Analysis 60-610

    59

    Model Title : Program 60-610 Unit System: US Description Value Unit Comment

    Material_Heat Index 0.4000

    Dynamic Elastic Modulus 157039 psi

    Temperature Curve # 5.0000

    Temperature_Factor 0.52

    Poisson`s Ratio 0.3500

    Sliding Velocity at Tooth Tip 492.4290 ft/min

    Allowable_Flank Stress (10^7 cy) 2814.0 psi

    Temperature Curve # 2.0000

    Temperature_Factor 0.84

    FLANK SAFETY FACTOR 1.95

    Allowable_Root Stress (10^7 cy) 2447.7 psi

    Idler? 'y/'n n

    Same Flank Contacts/Rev 1.0000

    Temperature Curve # 2.0000

    Temperature_Factor 0.53

    ROOT SAFETY FACTOR 5.28 Figure 2C is the plot of the teeth. (Use the Plot Configuration tab of the data input form to obtain the mesh plot, as described in Example 1.) Plots should be made at various stages of mesh to insure that no fillet interference exists. (The root clearance should be large enough to avoid jamming if small amounts of debris collect in the root area of the gears.)

  • UTS Integrated Gear Software

    60

    Fig. 2C

    The lowest flank stress safety factor is 1.21 for the driver and limits the power capacity of the set. The lowest root stress safety factor is 4.84, also for the driver. This is mostly due to the higher flank temperature for the driver. In any event, the gear rating is much higher in root bending than in flank wear. This is to be expected since the limiting condition for dry running plastic gears is usually the contact stress.

  • Plastic Gear Geometry & Load Analysis 60-610

    61

    Example 3 Example 3 is a 16/64 spur gear set, with a module of 1 mm, molded from thermoplastic materials. The housing is made from unfilled polycarbonate and the gears are molded from unfilled acetal (Celanese Celcon M90). The range of operating temperatures ranges from -34 degrees C to +60 degrees C. The gears will be greased. The relative humidity will range from dry to 100% for long periods. The design must be capable of operation at minimum effective center distance without running out of backlash and without root-tip interference. The design must also retain a contact ratio over 1.3 at the maximum effective center distance. The load is 50 watts at 3600 RPM of the pinion. Assume that the out-of-parallel and out of plane for the shafts are both 0.001 mm/mm. The gears are to be made to AGMA quality class 7. The first step is to find the maximum and minimum effective center distances under the ambient conditions. For design purposes the gear dimensions are subjected to tolerance variations at an assembly temperature of 20 degrees C but not to dimensional changes due to temperature changes and moisture absorption. All such changes are accounted for in the “effective” center distance. The maximum and minimum “effective” center distances will not actually occur but are used to check the gear set for interference and contact ratio under conditions which would have the same effect as the actual operating conditions. The nominal (and “standard”) center distance for this gear set is 40 mm. For the above ambient conditions the maximum effective center distance is found to occur at cold and dry conditions. The maximum effective center distance is 40.391 mm. The minimum effective center distance, under hot and humid conditions, is 40.027 mm. (See Reports 3 MAX and 3 MIN from UTS Model 60-146.)

  • UTS Integrated Gear Software

    62

    Report 3 MAX

    Model Title : Program 60-146 Unit System: Metric Description Value Unit Comment

    External or Internal Set e

    ASSEMBLY CONDITIONS

    Normal_Diametral Pitch 25.400000 1/in `

    Normal_Module 1.000000 mm `

    Helix Angle 0.000000 deg

    Operating Transverse Pressure Angle 20.000000 deg

    Temperature 20 C

    Relative Humidity 50.00 %

    HOUSING

    Material_Number-See Material Table 12

    Material_Code PCUF

    Thermal Coefficient of expansion 0.00 1/degC

    Moisture Coefficient of expansion 0.00 cm/cm

    Basic or nominal center distance 40.0000 mm

    Minimum center distance tolerance -0.0500 mm

    Maximum center distance tolerance 0.0500 mm

    Pinion total composite tolerance 0.08636 mm

    Gear total composite tolerance 0.09906 mm

    Pinion_bearing runout (TIR) 0.0300 mm

  • Plastic Gear Geometry & Load Analysis 60-610

    63

    Model Title : Program 60-146 Unit System: Metric Description Value Unit Comment

    Gear_bearing runout (TIR) 0.0300 mm

    Pinion_bearing_radial play, max 0.1200 mm

    Pinion_bearing_radial play, min 0.0900 mm

    Gear_bearing_radial play, max 0.1200 mm

    Gear_bearing_radial play, min 0.0950 mm

    Minimum_assembled CD, absolute 40.0125 mm

    Maximum_assembled CD, absolute 40.3854 mm

    Minimum_assembled CD, statistical 40.0886 mm

    Maximum_assembled CD, statistical 40.3093 mm

    PINION

    Material_Number-See Material Table 9

    Material_Code Acetal UF

    Number of teeth 16

    AGMA Quality Class 7

    Thermal Coefficient of expansion 0.00 1/degC

    Moisture Coefficient of expansion 0.00 cm/cm

    Nominal_operating pitch diameter 16.0000 mm

    GEAR

    Material_Number-See Material Table 9

    Material_Code Acetal UF

    Number of teeth 64

    AGMA Quality Class 7

    Thermal Coefficient of expansion 0.00 1/degC

  • UTS Integrated Gear Software

    64

    Model Title : Program 60-146 Unit System: Metric Description Value Unit Comment

    Moisture Coefficient of expansion 0.00 cm/cm

    Nominal_operating pitch diameter 64.0000 mm

    OPERATING CONDITIONS

    Housing_temperature -34 C

    Pinion_temperature -34 C

    Gear_temperature -34 C

    Relative_humidity 0.00 %

    Change_in relative humidity -50.00 %

    EFFECTIVE CENTER DISTANCE

    Change in CD (Thermal, Moisture) 0.0813 mm

    Approximate change in backlash 0.0597 mm

    EFFECTIVE CD, ABSOLUTE

    Minimum_effective center distance 40.0938 mm

    Maximum_effective center distance 40.4667 mm

    Mean effective center distance 40.2802 mm

    CD Range 0.37292 mm

    EFFECTIVE CD, STATISTICAL

    Standard deviations, +/- 3.0000

    Range of deviations 6.0000

    Amount of assemblies included in the 99.7300 % range

    Number_of assemblies included in range 370 per assembly outside range

  • Plastic Gear Geometry & Load Analysis 60-610

    65

    Model Title : Program 60-146 Unit System: Metric Description Value Unit Comment

    Minimum_effective center distance 40.1698 mm

    Maximum_effective center distance 40.3906 mm

    Mean effective center distance 40.2802 mm

    CD Range 0.22076 mm Report 3 MIN

    Model Title : Program 60-146 Unit System: Metric Description Value Unit Comment

    External or Internal Set e

    ASSEMBLY CONDITIONS

    Normal_Diametral Pitch 25.400000 1/in `

    Normal_Module 1.000000 mm `

    Helix Angle 0.000000 deg

    Operating Transverse Pressure Angle 20.000000 deg

    Temperature 20 C

    Relative Humidity 50.00 %

    HOUSING

    Material_Number-See Material Table 12

    Material_Code PCUF

    Thermal Coefficient of expansion 0.00 1/degC

  • UTS Integrated Gear Software

    66

    Model Title : Program 60-146 Unit System: Metric Description Value Unit Comment

    Moisture Coefficient of expansion 0.00 cm/cm

    Basic or nominal center distance 40.0000 mm

    Minimum center distance tolerance -0.0500 mm

    Maximum center distance tolerance 0.0500 mm

    Pinion total composite tolerance 0.08636 mm

    Gear total composite tolerance 0.09906 mm

    Pinion_bearing runout (TIR) 0.0300 mm

    Gear_bearing runout (TIR) 0.0300 mm

    Pinion_bearing_radial play, max 0.1200 mm

    Pinion_bearing_radial play, min 0.0900 mm

    Gear_bearing_radial play, max 0.1200 mm

    Gear_bearing_radial play, min 0.0950 mm

    Minimum_assembled CD, absolute 40.0125 mm

    Maximum_assembled CD, absolute 40.3854 mm

    Minimum_assembled CD, statistical 40.0886 mm

    Maximum_assembled CD, statistical 40.3093 mm

    PINION

    Material_Number-See Material Table 9

    Material_Code Acetal UF

    Number of teeth 16

    AGMA Quality Class 7

    Thermal Coefficient of expansion 0.00 1/degC

    Moisture Coefficient of expansion 0.00 cm/cm

  • Plastic Gear Geometry & Load Analysis 60-610

    67

    Model Title : Program 60-146 Unit System: Metric Description Value Unit Comment

    Nominal_operating pitch diameter 16.0000 mm

    GEAR

    Material_Number-See Material Table 9

    Material_Code Acetal UF

    Number of teeth 64

    AGMA Quality Class 7

    Thermal Coefficient of expansion 0.00 1/degC

    Moisture Coefficient of expansion 0.00 cm/cm

    Nominal_operating pitch diameter 64.0000 mm

    OPERATING CONDITIONS

    Housing_temperature 60 C

    Pinion_temperature 60 C

    Gear_temperature 60 C

    Relative_humidity 100.00 %

    Change_in relative humidity 50.00 %

    EFFECTIVE CENTER DISTANCE

    Change in CD (Thermal, Moisture) -0.0611 mm

    Approximate change in backlash -0.0442 mm

    EFFECTIVE CD, ABSOLUTE

    Minimum_effective center distance 39.9514 mm

    Maximum_effective center distance 40.3243 mm

    Mean effective center distance 40.1379 mm

  • UTS Integrated Gear Software

    68

    Model Title : Program 60-146 Unit System: Metric Description Value Unit Comment

    CD Range 0.37292 mm

    EFFECTIVE CD, STATISTICAL

    Standard deviations, +/- 3.0000

    Range of deviations 6.0000

    Amount of assemblies included in the 99.7300 % range

    Number_of assemblies included in range 370 per assembly outside range

    Minimum_effective center distance 40.0275 mm

    Maximum_effective center distance 40.2482 mm

    Mean effective center distance 40.1379 mm

    CD Range 0.22076 mm

    We will design the gear set at minimum effective center distance and tooth tip radius along with maximum tooth thickness and outside diameters. The backlash will be set to 0.030 mm, as this is the tightest mesh condition. (We can not set the backlash too low, because if the backlash is less than the tooth tip deflection the teeth will contact on the nondriving side.) These conditions will produce the greatest chance of interference. Because we will lose contact ratio when we go to maximum effective center distance, we will use the nominal default outside diameters as maximum for the design and use a negative tolerance to obtain the minimum ODs.

    The tooth tip radius will be 0.10 mm to 0.15 mm. At minimum effective center distance we need to use a tip radius of 0.10 mm to get the largest effective outside diameters.

    Open an analysis in 60-610 and enter the data in the input form, shown in Figure 3A. Override the defaults when necessary. We will use the AGMA XPT4 plastic rack form to keep the profile contact ratio as high as possible with the large difference in effective center distance necessary with these design requirements. The inputs and outputs for the solved model are shown in Report 3A. Figures 3A1 and 3A2 are plots of the pinion and gear tooth.

  • Plastic Gear Geometry & Load Analysis 60-610

    69

    Fig. 3A

  • UTS Integrated Gear Software

    70

    Report 3A

    Model Title : Program 60-610 Unit System: Metric Description Value Unit Comment

    DRIVER, number of teeth 16

    Hobbed ('hob), Shaped ('shp), Formed frm ('frm)

    DRIVEN, number of teeth 64

    Hobbed ('hob), Shaped ('shp), Formed frm ('frm)

    NORMAL PLANE

    Module 1.000000 mm `

    Diametral Pitch 25.400000 1/in `

    Nominal pressure angle 20.000000 deg

    Base pitch 2.952 mm

    NORMAL PLANE DRIVER

    Finished tooth thickness at Ref PD 1.580 mm

    Total normal circular finish stock on tooth 0.000 mm thickness

    NORMAL PLANE DRIVEN

    Finished tooth thickness at Ref PD 1.550 mm

    Total normal circular finish stock on tooth 0.000 mm Thickness

  • Plastic Gear Geometry & Load Analysis 60-610

    71

    Model Title : Program 60-610 Unit System: Metric Description Value Unit Comment TRANSVERSE PLANE

    Module 1.000000 mm `

    Diametral_Pitch 25.400000 1/in `

    Nominal_pressure angle 20.0000 deg

    Base_pitch 2.952 mm

    Tooth_thickness, Driver 1.580 mm

    Tooth_thickness, Driven 1.550 mm

    COMMON

    Helix angle 0.000000 deg

    Base_helix angle 0.0000 deg

    Axial pitch mm

    Operating_center distance 40.027 mm

    Standard_center distance 40.0000 mm

    Net face width 15.000 mm

    Aspect ratio 0.937

    COMMON DRIVER

    Outside Diameter 18.743 mm

    Normal_top land width 0.070 mm

    Start_Tip Modification mm

    Roll_at_start of tip modification deg

    Normal_OD tip relief mm

    Normal_circular OD tip relief mm

    Transverse_circular_OD tip relief mm

  • UTS Integrated Gear Software

    72

    Model Title : Program 60-610 Unit System: Metric Description Value Unit Comment

    Effective_outside diameter 18.661 mm

    Normal_effective OD tip relief mm

    Normal_tooth_thickness_at_Eff OD 0.232 mm

    Load_angle with tooth CL at eff OD 54.39 deg

    Pointed tooth diameter (No tip mod) 18.972 mm

    Reference PD 16.000 mm

    Inv/fillet intersection dia (TIF) 15.101 mm

    Roll_at_inv/fill intersection dia 5.351 deg

    Normal_TT_at_inv/fill intersection d 1.712 mm

    Minimum_fillet radius 0.462 mm

    Root diameter 12.666 mm

    LA 3.039 mm

    Base_diameter 15.035 mm

    Lead mm

    Area of space (Normal section) 5.233 mm^2

    Area of tooth (Normal section) 4.137 mm^2

    COMMON DRIVEN

    Outside Diameter 66.711 mm

    Normal_top land width 0.316 mm

    Start_Tip Modification mm

    Roll_at_start of tip modification deg

    Normal_OD tip relief mm

    Normal_circular OD tip relief mm

  • Plastic Gear Geometry & Load Analysis 60-610

    73

    Model Title : Program 60-610 Unit System: Metric Description Value Unit Comment

    Transverse_circular_OD tip relief mm

    Effective_outside diameter 66.596 mm

    Normal_effective OD tip relief mm

    Normal_tooth_thickness_at_Eff OD 0.497 mm

    Load_angle with tooth CL at eff OD 64.99 deg

    Pointed tooth diameter (No tip mod) 67.608 mm

    Reference PD 64.000 mm

    Inv/fillet intersection dia (TIF) 61.499 mm

    Roll_at_inv/fill intersection dia 12.246 deg

    Normal_TT_at_inv/fill intersection d 2.211 mm

    Minimum_fillet radius 0.312 mm

    Root diameter 60.583 mm

    Whole depth of tooth (from Eff OD) 3.064 mm

    Base_diameter 60.140 mm

    Lead mm

    Area of space (Normal section) 4.691 mm^2

    Area of tooth (Normal section) 4.881 mm^2

    OPERATING DATA

    Change in Operating CD from "Std" CD 0.027 mm

    Working depth of active flanks 2.087 mm

    Total_working depth 2.700 mm

    Normal_circular_backlash 0.031 mm

    Transverse_circular backlash 0.031 mm

  • UTS Integrated Gear Software

    74

    Model Title : Program 60-610 Unit System: Metric Description Value Unit Comment

    Normal_module 1.000675 mm `

    Transverse_module 1.000675 mm `

    Normal_pressure angle 20.106 deg

    Transverse_pressure angle 20.106 deg

    Helix_angle 0.000 deg

    OPERATING DATA DRIVER

    Pitch_diameter 16.011 mm

    Normal_tooth thickness 1.577 mm

    Transverse_tooth thickness 1.577 mm

    Start of active profile (SAP) 15.035 mm

    Root_clearance 0.339 mm

    Max_specific sliding ratio 3.649

    OPERATING DATA DRIVEN

    Pitch_diameter 64.043 mm

    Normal_tooth thickness 1.535 mm

    Transverse_tooth thickness 1.535 mm

    Start of active profile (SAP) 62.354 mm

    Root_clearance 0.364 mm

    Max_specific sliding ratio 1.685

    PLOT CONFIGURATION

    Mark inv/fil intersections? y

    Mark mod/inv intersections? y

    Number of teeth on plot 1

  • Plastic Gear Geometry & Load Analysis 60-610

    75

    Model Title : Program 60-610 Unit System: Metric Description Value Unit Comment

    Driver_contact roll angle of deg

    Driver tooth number 1

    DRIVER ROLL ANGLES

    Start_of_active profile-No Undercut 0.000 deg

    Actual_start of active profile 5.351 deg

    Lowest_single contact-LCR Spur 19.625 deg

    Lowest_double contact-HCR Spur deg

    Operating pitch point 20.974 deg

    Highest_single contact-LCR Spur 27.851 deg

    Highest_double contact-HCR Spur deg

    Actual_end of active profile 42.125 deg

    Effective outside diameter 42.125 deg

    DRIVEN ROLL ANGLES

    Start_of_active profile-No Undercut 15.686 deg

    Actual_start of active profile 15.686 deg

    Lowest_single contact-LCR Spur 19.255 deg

    Lowest_double contact-HCR Spur deg

    Operating pitch point 20.974 deg

    Highest_single contact-LCR Spur 21.311 deg

    Highest_double contact-HCR Spur deg

    Actual_end of active profile 24.880 deg

    Effective outside diameter 27.252 deg

  • UTS Integrated Gear Software

    76

    Model Title : Program 60-610 Unit System: Metric Description Value Unit Comment

    CONTACT DATA

    Total_arc of contact, driver 42.125 deg

    Arc_of_approach 20.974 deg

    Arc_of_recess 21.151 deg

    Approach action 49.79 %

    Recess action 50.21 %

    Profile contact ratio (SAP > TIF) 1.872

    Actual profile contact ratio 1.634

    Contact below finished involute? Yes

    Helical contact ratio 0.000

    Total_contact ratio 1.634

    Unmodified (light load) profile CR

    Profile_contact ratio

    Helical contact ratio

    Total_contact ratio

    FORMED DRIVER

    Flank angle 20.0000 deg

    Tip to reference line 1.680 mm

    Tooth thickness at reference line 1.571 mm

    Tip_radius 0.248 mm

    Radial_tip chamfer (w/o mod) 0.000 mm

    Normal_tip radius 0.100 mm

    Normal_tip_relief exponent

  • Plastic Gear Geometry & Load Analysis 60-610

    77

    Model Title : Program 60-610 Unit System: Metric Description Value Unit Comment

    FORMED DRIVEN

    Flank angle 20.0000 deg

    Tip to reference line 1.680 mm

    Tooth thickness at reference line 1.571 mm

    Tip_radius 0.248 mm

    Radial_tip chamfer (w/o mod) 0.000 mm

    Normal_tip radius 0.100 mm

    Normal_tip_relief exponent Fig 3A1

  • UTS Integrated Gear Software

    78

    Fig 3A2

    Note that the 16 tooth pinion is intentionally undercut. The tip of the gear will project into the undercut in the pinion root area when the gears are at low center distance and will not interfere with the pinion root fillet. The contact ratio is controlled, under these conditions, by the OD of the pinion and the involute/fillet intersection diameter on the pinion. (The profile contact ratio may be calculated by subtracting the roll angle at the inv/fil intersection from the roll angle at the pinion OD and dividing by the angle between pinion teeth.) The actual contact ratio is 1.634. This condition will cause no harm if the fillet profile was generated by a basic rack form. However, if the fillet profile is a circular arc starting at the involute-fillet intersection point or a straight radial line starting at the base diameter (if contact extends down to the base diameter), interference is inevitable and the gear set is not usable. Interference must be checked, in any event, by plotting the tooth forms in the proper relation to each other and checking for contact between the tooth tips and fillets.

  • Plastic Gear Geometry & Load Analysis 60-610

    79

    To help equalize the bending strength between the pinion and gear, we will increase the pinion tooth thickness by 0.25 mm and reduce the gear tooth thickness by 0.25 mm. This should make the tooth thickness at the involute/fillet intersections about the same. ((2.211-1.712)/2 = .25) We must also decrease the basic rack tooth thickness of the pinion and increase the rack tooth thickness of the gear by the same amount to keep the root diameters where they are. Enter a large number for the tip radii of the racks and the model will give you the rack maximum tip radii so we will have full fillet radii in the gears. Figure 3B and Report 3B are the model after making these changes. Fig. 3B

  • UTS Integrated Gear Software

    80

    Report 3B

    Model Title : Program 60-610 Unit System: Metric Description Value Unit Comment

    DRIVER, number of teeth 16

    Hobbed ('hob), Shaped ('shp), Formed frm ('frm)

    DRIVEN, number of teeth 64

    Hobbed ('hob), Shaped ('shp), Formed frm ('frm)

    NORMAL PLANE

    Module 1.000000 mm `

    Diametral Pitch 25.400000 1/in `

    Nominal pressure angle 20.000000 deg

    Base pitch 2.952 mm

    NORMAL PLANE DRIVER

    Finished tooth thickness at Ref PD 1.830 mm

    Total normal circular finish stock on tooth 0.000 mm thickness

    NORMAL PLANE DRIVEN

    Finished tooth thickness at Ref PD 1.300 mm

    Total normal circular finish stock on tooth 0.000 mm Thickness

  • Plastic Gear Geometry & Load Analysis 60-610

    81

    Model Title : Program 60-610 Unit System: Metric Description Value Unit Comment TRANSVERSE PLANE

    Module 1.000000 mm `

    Diametral_Pitch 25.400000 1/in `

    Nominal_pressure angle 20.0000 deg

    Base_pitch 2.952 mm

    Tooth_thickness, Driver 1.830 mm

    Tooth_thickness, Driven 1.300 mm

    COMMON

    Helix angle 0.000000 deg

    Base_helix angle 0.0000 deg

    Axial pitch mm

    Operating_center distance 40.027 mm

    Standard_center distance 40.0000 mm

    Net face width 15.000 mm

    Aspect ratio 0.937

    COMMON DRIVER

    Outside Diameter 18.743 mm

    Normal_top land width 0.363 mm

    Start_Tip Modification mm

    Roll_at_start of tip modification deg

    Normal_OD tip relief mm

    Normal_circular OD tip relief mm

    Transverse_circular_OD tip relief mm

  • UTS Integrated Gear Software

    82

    Model Title : Program 60-610 Unit System: Metric Description Value Unit Comment

    Effective_outside diameter 18.661 mm

    Normal_effective OD tip relief mm

    Normal_tooth_thickness_at_Eff OD 0.523 mm

    Load_angle with tooth CL at eff OD 55.28 deg

    Pointed tooth diameter (No tip mod) 19.351 mm

    Reference PD 16.000 mm

    Inv/fillet intersection dia (TIF) 15.125 mm

    Roll_at_inv/fill intersection dia 6.270 deg

    Normal_TT_at_inv/fill intersection d 1.949 mm

    Minimum_fillet radius 0.336 mm

    Root diameter 12.666 mm

    LA 3.039 mm

    Base_diameter 15.035 mm

    Lead mm

    Area of space (Normal section) 4.552 mm^2

    Area of tooth (Normal section) 4.818 mm^2

    COMMON DRIVEN

    Outside Diameter 66.711 mm

    Normal_top land width 0.056 mm

    Start_Tip Modification mm

    Roll_at_start of tip modification deg

    Normal_OD tip relief mm

    Normal_circular OD tip relief mm

  • Plastic Gear Geometry & Load Analysis 60-610

    83

    Model Title : Program 60-610 Unit System: Metric Description Value Unit Comment

    Transverse_circular_OD tip relief mm

    Effective_outside diameter 66.596 mm

    Normal_effective OD tip relief mm

    Normal_tooth_thickness_at_Eff OD 0.236 mm

    Load_angle with tooth CL at eff OD 64.77 deg

    Pointed tooth diameter (No tip mod) 67.086 mm

    Reference PD 64.000 mm

    Inv/fillet intersection dia (TIF) 61.646 mm

    Roll_at_inv/fill intersection dia 12.902 deg

    Normal_TT_at_inv/fill intersection d 1.943 mm

    Minimum_fillet radius 0.476 mm

    Root diameter 60.583 mm

    Whole depth of tooth (from Eff OD) 3.064 mm

    Base_diameter 60.140 mm

    Lead mm

    Area of space (Normal section) 5.419 mm^2

    Area of tooth (Normal section) 4.153 mm^2

    OPERATING DATA

    Change in Operating CD from "Std" CD 0.027 mm

    Working depth of active flanks 2.039 mm

    Total_working depth 2.700 mm

    Normal_circular_backlash 0.031 mm

    Transverse_circular backlash 0.031 mm

  • UTS Integrated Gear Software

    84

    Model Title : Program 60-610 Unit System: Metric Description Value Unit Comment

    Normal_module 1.000675 mm `

    Transverse_module 1.000675 mm `

    Normal_pressure angle 20.106 deg

    Transverse_pressure angle 20.106 deg

    Helix_angle 0.000 deg

    OPERATING DATA DRIVER

    Pitch_diameter 16.011 mm

    Normal_tooth thickness 1.827 mm

    Transverse_tooth thickness 1.827 mm

    Start of active profile (SAP) 15.035 mm

    Root_clearance 0.339 mm

    Max_specific sliding ratio 2.932

    OPERATING DATA DRIVEN

    Pitch_diameter 64.043 mm

    Normal_tooth thickness 1.285 mm

    Transverse_tooth thickness 1.285 mm

    Start of active profile (SAP) 62.354 mm

    Root_clearance 0.364 mm

    Max_specific sliding ratio 1.685

    PLOT CONFIGURATION

    Mark inv/fil intersections? y

    Mark mod/inv intersections? y

    Number of teeth on plot 1

  • Plastic Gear Geometry & Load Analysis 60-610

    85

    Model Title : Program 60-610 Unit System: Metric Description Value Unit Comment

    Driver_contact roll angle of deg

    Driver tooth number 1

    DRIVER ROLL ANGLES

    Start_of_active profile-No Undercut 0.000 deg

    Actual_start of active profile 6.270 deg

    Lowest_single contact-LCR Spur 19.625 deg

    Lowest_double contact-HCR Spur deg

    Operating pitch point 20.974 deg

    Highest_single contact-LCR Spur 28.770 deg

    Highest_double contact-HCR Spur deg

    Actual_end of active profile 42.125 deg

    Effective outside diameter 42.125 deg

    DRIVEN ROLL ANGLES

    Start_of_active profile-No Undercut 15.686 deg

    Actual_start of active profile 15.686 deg

    Lowest_single contact-LCR Spur 19.025 deg

    Lowest_double contact-HCR Spur deg

    Operating pitch point 20.974 deg

    Highest_single contact-LCR Spur 21.311 deg

    Highest_double contact-HCR Spur deg

    Actual_end of active profile 24.650 deg

    Effective outside diameter 27.252 deg

  • UTS Integrated Gear Software

    86

    Model Title : Program 60-610 Unit System: Metric Description Value Unit Comment

    CONTACT DATA

    Total_arc of contact, driver 42.125 deg

    Arc_of_approach 20.974 deg

    Arc_of_recess 21.151 deg

    Approach action 49.79 %

    Recess action 50.21 %

    Profile contact ratio (SAP > TIF) 1.872

    Actual profile contact ratio 1.594

    Contact below finished involute? Yes

    Helical contact ratio 0.000

    Total_contact ratio 1.594

    Unmodified (light load) profile CR

    Profile_contact ratio

    Helical contact ratio

    Total_contact ratio

    FORMED DRIVER

    Flank angle 20.0000 deg

    Tip to reference line 1.680 mm

    Tooth thickness at reference line 1.321 mm

    Tip_radius 0.070 mm

    Radial_tip chamfer (w/o mod) 0.000 mm

    Normal_tip radius 0.100 mm

    Normal_tip_relief exponent

  • Plastic Gear Geometry & Load Analysis 60-610

    87

    Model Title : Program 60-610 Unit System: Metric Description Value Unit Comment

    FORMED DRIVEN

    Flank angle 20.0000 deg

    Tip to reference line 1.680 mm

    Tooth thickness at reference line 1.821 mm

    Tip_radius 0.427 mm

    Radial_tip chamfer (w/o mod) 0.000 mm

    Normal_tip radius 0.100 mm

    Normal_tip_relief exponent Figures 3B1 and 3B2 are plots of the pinion and gear teeth. Figure 3B1

  • UTS Integrated Gear Software

    88

    Fig 3B2

    Figures 3B3 and 3B4 are plots of the pinion and gear in mesh at the first point of contact at the pinion root and gear tip and at the last point of contact at the pinion tip and gear root.

  • Plastic Gear Geometry & Load Analysis 60-610

    89

    Fig 3B3

    Fig 3B4

  • UTS Integrated Gear Software

    90

    No interference is occurring at these points. However, plots of the gears in mesh should be made at enough contact points along the line of action to be sure than no interference exists at any position. (Save the max temperature, min eff CD Variable Sheet to a file for use in checking the load data later without typing the data into the model again.) The set must also be checked at maximum effective center distance and tip radius along with minimum ODs and tooth thickness. This condition will produce the lowest contact ratio and the maximum backlash. By further optimization we reduce the thickness of the driver and driven teeth, increase the backlash by .076 mm, and reduce the outside diameters by .140 mm each. Figure 3C shows the inputs and Report 3C the results at the maximum effective center distance and maximum temperature.

  • Plastic Gear Geometry & Load Analysis 60-610

    91

    Fig. 3C

  • UTS Integrated Gear Software

    92

    Report 3C

    Model Title : Program 60-610 Unit System: Metric Description Value Unit Comment

    DRIVER, number of teeth 16

    Hobbed ('hob), Shaped ('shp), Formed frm ('frm)

    DRIVEN, number of teeth 64

    Hobbed ('hob), Shaped ('shp), Formed frm ('frm)

    NORMAL PLANE

    Module 1.000000 mm `

    Diametral Pitch 25.400000 1/in `

    No