Upload
others
View
0
Download
0
Embed Size (px)
Citation preview
InconclusionPPTscommonlyoccurandasillustratedbythiscasestudycanbesuccessfullyidentifiedbysimpleclinicaltestsandultrasound.Concomitantinterspacelesionscanalsobecharacterized.TheabilitytoaccuratelydifferentiatebetweenatearandMorton’sneuromaisparticularlyadvantageousasitindicatesthecorrecttreatmentoptionandavoidstheinappropriateadministrationofasteroidinjectionwhenthepathologyisatear.
1.Umans,H.,Srinivasan,R.,Elsinger,E.&Wilde,G.(2014)'MRIoflessermetatarsophalangealjointplantarplatetearsandassociatedadjacentinterspacelesions',SkeletalRadiology;JournaloftheInternationalSkeletalSocietyAJournalofRadiology,PathologyandOrthopedics,43(10),pp.1361-1368.2.Fernandes,E.d.A.,Mann,T.S.,Puchnick,A.,Tertulino,F.d.F.,Cannato,C.T.,Nery,C.&Fernandes,A.d.R.C.(2014)'Canultrasoundofplantarplatehavenormalappearancewithapositivedrawertest?',EuropeanJournalofRadiology,84(3),pp.443-449.3.Yao,L.,Do,H.M.,Cracchiolo,A.&Farahani,K.(1994)'Plantarplateofthefoot:findingsonconventionalarthrographyandMRimaging'AmericanJournalofRoentgenology,163pp.641-644.4.Baravarian,B.&Redkar,A.(2016)'ExpertInsightsOnTreatingPlantarPlateTearsAvailableat:http://www.podiatrytoday.com/expert-insights-treating-plantar-plate-tears(Accessed:27/10/2016)5.Thompson,F.&Hamilton,W.(1987)'ProblemsoftheSecondMetatarsophalangealJoint',Orthopedics,10(1),pp.83-89.6.Doty,J.,Coughlin,M.,Jastifer,J.,Weil,L.&Nery,C.(2014)'EvaluationandTreatmentofLesserMetatarsophalangealJointInstability:TheRepairofPlantarPlateInsufficiencyThroughaDorsalApproach',OperativeTechniquesinSportsMedicine,22(4),pp.339-347.7.Bouché,R.T.&Heit,E.J.(2008)'CombinedPlantarPlateandHammertoeRepairwithFlexorDigitorumLongusTendonTransferforChronic,SevereSagittalPlaneInstabilityoftheLesserMetatarsophalangealJoints:PreliminaryObservations',TheJournalofFootandAnkleSurgery,47(2),pp.125-1378.Gregg,J.,Silberstein,M.,Schneider,T.,Kerr,J.&Marks,P.(2006a)'Sonographyofplantarplatesincadavers: correlationwithMRIandhistology',AmericanJournalofRoentgenology,186pp.948-955.9.Bianchi,S.(2014)'PracticalUSoftheforefoot',JournalofUltrasound;theOfficialJournaloftheItalianSocietyforUltrasoundinMedicineandBiology,17(2),pp.151-164.
10.Macias,D.&Coughin,M.(2015)'Lessermetatarsophalangealjointinstability:Diagnosisandtreatmentofplantarplatetears',OrthopedicsToday,35(10),pp.14-17.11.Gregg,J.,Silberstein,M.,Schneider,T.&Marks,P.(2006b)'SonographicandMRIevaluationoftheplantarplate:aprospectivestudy',EuropeanRadiology,16(12),pp.2661-2669.12.Klein,E.E.,WeilJr,L.,WeilSr,L.S.&Knight,J.(2013)'MusculoskeletalUltrasoundforPreoperativeImagingofthePlantarPateAprospectiveAnalysis',Foot&AnkleSpecialist,6(3),pp.196-20013.Carlson,R.M.,Dux,K.&Stuck,R.M.(2013)'UltrasoundImagingforDiagnosisofPlantarPlateRupturesoftheLesserMetatarsophalangealJoints:ARetrospectiveCaseSeries',TheJournalofFoot&AnkleSurgery,52(6),pp.786-788.14.Klein,E.E.,WeilJr,L.,WeilSr,L.S.&Knight,J.(2012)'Magneticresonanceimagingversusmusculoskeletalultrasoundforidentificationandlocalizationofplantarplatetears',Foot&AnkleSpecialist,5(6),pp.359-36515.Ganguly,A.,Aniq,H.&Skiadas,B.(2013)'Lumpsandbumpsaroundthefootandankle:anassessmentoffrequencywithultrasoundandMRI',SkeletalRadiology;JournaloftheInternationalSkeletalSocietyAJournalofRadiology,PathologyandOrthopedics,42(8),pp.1051-1060.16.Khoury,V.,Guillin,R.,Dhanju,J.&Cardinal,E.(2007)'UltrasoundofAnkleandFoot: OveruseandSportsInjuries',SeminarsinMusculoskeletalRadiology2007,11(02),pp.149-161.
CasestudyDiscussion
A66yearoldfemalewithmetatarsalgiaintheregionoftheleft2nd toewasreferredbyanMSKpodiatristforultrasoundassessmentofthepain.AsteroidinjectionwasalsorequestedtobeperformedatthetimeofthescanifaMorton’sneuromawasdetected.
Abriefclinicalexaminationoftheaffectedtoewasperformedbeforethescan.Thepatientwasfirstobservedwiththefootuncovered,inthestandingposition,toassessformedialtoedrift.Clinicaltestsfora PPTwerethenundertakentoassessforanyreducedplantarpurchaseand/orapositivemetatarsophalangeal‘drawertest’(Seeclinicaltestsbelow).ThefootwasalsoassessedforaMulderclickbyusingsonopalpation andsimultaneouslysqueezingtheforefoot.
TheleftforefootwasthenscannedonaPhilipsiu22machineusinga17MHzlineartransducerwithamusculoskeletalpreset.Longitudinalandtransverseassessmentwasmadeofthe2nd MTPJ,theplantarplateandtheadjoiningtoeinterspaces.Colour Dopplerwasthenappliedtoassessforabnormalvascularitywithinthejointand/orinterspaces.
ThereisnothingintheliteraturetosuggestguidelinesoradefiniteconsensusonimagingofsuspectedPPTs;thatsaidthereisageneraltrendtowardsMRIasthepreferrednon-invasiveimagingmodality(10). ThefirststudiestoevaluatePPTswithultrasoundwereconductedbyGreggetalin2006(8,11)andshowedslightlybetterdetectionratescomparedwithMRI.Laterstudiesindicatedthatalthoughultrasoundhadexcellentsensitivity,thespecificityislowerthanMRI,anditgiveslessaccuratelocalization(12,13).MRIisalsobetteratdetectingsofttissuepathologyaroundthejointsuchasco-lateralligamenttears(14).Ultrasoundishoweverbetteratdetectinginterspacelesionssuchasganglions,neuromas(15)andinter-metatarsalbursitis(16).
ThesestudiesindicatethatultrasoundismoresensitivethanMRIindetectingplantarplatetearsandthis,togetherwithitslow-costandflexibility,suggestthatultrasoundissuitableasthefirstlinetest.AstheyalsoshowthatultrasoundhasapoorerspecificitythanMRI,thismightsuggestthatultrasoundalonemaynotsufficeforsurgicalplanning,andinsomecasesfollow-upMRIimagingmayberequired.
Clinicalassessmentiscommonplaceinforefootimaging(9)andthespecifictestsforMTPJstabilitydescribedhereareespeciallyusefulinassistingdetectionofaPPTincombinationwithultrasound,asinthiscasestudy.HoweveritshouldbenotedthattheplantarplatepresentschallengesforbothMRIandultrasoundscanningasitisasmallcurvedstructurewhichcanbedifficulttoaccesswithanMRIcoil,andsusceptibletoanistropy withultrasound(8).Inaddition,sometearsarenoteasilyvisualised onultrasoundashypoechoicareas,astherecanbeaninfilloflooseconnectivetissueasrepaircommences(8).
Paperpull-outtest'ThissecondtestmeasuresplantarflexionstrengthandwasfirstdescribedbyBouché andHeit (7).Astripofpaper(1x6cm)isplacedbeneaththetipoftheaffectedtoeandthepatientisaskedtoperformplantarflexionoftheforefoot,andtopressdownonthepaperwiththetoe.(Seephotograph). Thetestispositivewhenthedigitisunabletogripthepaperandthestripcanbepulledoutwithoutripping. Findingsfromthistesthavebeencombinedwiththe'Drawertest'toprovideclinicalstaging(6).
Anothersignofaplantarplatetearismedialtoedriftwhichpresentsbecausethetearoccursmostcommonlyonthelateraledge,allowingtheflexortendontopullthetoemedially.Thisisbestobservedwiththepatientstandingatthestartoftheultrasoundexamination(asdemonstratedinthecasestudyfindings).
ClinicaltestforplantarplatetearsTherearetworecognizedclinicaltestsforPPTs,themetatarsophalangeal'drawertest'andthe'paperpullouttest'.
Metatarsophalangeal'drawertest'DevisedbyThompsonandHamilton(5),the'drawertest'oftheMTPJisdesignedtotestjointstability,andaccordingtoDotyetal(2014)(6)has 80.6%sensitivityand99.8%specificityforPPT. Thetoehasverticalstressappliedinadorsaldirectionandtheamountofsubluxationandpainproducedbythetestcanbegraded1-4 (seefigurebelow).
GO,stablejointsG1,mildinstability(subluxation<50%);G2,moderateinstability(subluxation<50%);G3,severeinstability(capacityforjointdislocation)G4,dislocatedjoint
References
ClinicalandscanfindingsAphysicalexaminationofthefootidentifiedswellingofthe2nd MTPJaswellasmedialtoedrift,whichthepatientconfirmedwasarecentdevelopment.Thepaperpullouttestanddrawertestwerebothpositive.NoMulderclickwasidentified.
Thescanconfirmedthepresenceofapartial,laterallylocatedplantarplatetear. OsteophyteswithintheMTPJandaprobableMTPJganglionwerealsoidentified.TherewasnoMorton'sneuromainevidence. Noabnormalvascularitywasnotedwithinthejoint,orinthetoeinterspaceseithersideofthe2nd toe.
Followup
Asteroidinjectionwasnotperformedduetothepresenceofatear.
Thereferringpodiatristoptedinitiallyforconservativetreatmentusingstrappingandorthotics,andfollowupafteronemonthindicatedanimprovementinsymptoms.
2.TSsectionoftheplantarplate1.LSsectionof2nd toeplantarplate
4.TSsectiondemonstratingcysticmass3.TSsectionoftheplantarplate
PhotobyAngelaClough
DiagrambyAngelaCloughDiagrambyAngelaClough
PhotobyAngelaClough
FigurebykindpermissionofDotyetal
DiagramofLSsectionofplantaraspectofMTPJ U/SimageofLSsectionofplantaraspectofMTPJ DiagramofTSsectionofplantaraspectofMTPJ
Plantarplatetears(PPTs)areacommonbutsometimesoverlookedcauseofforefootpain,asshownina2014studywhichidentifiedthat40%ofpatientswithmetatarsalgiahaddetectablePPTs(1).UltrasoundhasavaluableroleindiagnosingPPTsandismosteffectivewhencombinedwithsimpleclinicaltestsatthetimeoftheexamination,asdemonstratedinthiscasestudy.
Theplantarplateisafibrocartilaginousstructurewhichstabilizestheplantaraspectofthemetatarsophalangealjoint(MTPJ).Itpreventsdorsi-extensionofthetoeandispartofacomplexofsupportstructuresfortheMTPJasseenintheLSandTSsectionsbelow
Theplantarplateissusceptibletopartialorcompletetearsduetochronicoverload,ageortrauma.Tearstypicallypresentwithburning,throbbingortinglingandarecommonlymisdiagnosedasaMorton’sneuroma,stressfractureorarthropathy. ThesecondMTPJismostcommonlyaffectedasithasthelongestmetatarsalbone(2).
TheincidenceofmetatarsalgiarelatingtosymptomaticPPTsmaybeexplainedbyassociatedpathologysuchascapsularinflammationwhichcanoccursecondarytoatear,asdescribedinanearlystudyin1994byYaoetal(3). AmorerecentMRIstudyin2014(1)lookingatadjacentinterspacelesionsinpatientswithPPTs,foundthatasignificantnumberofsymptomaticsecondtoePPTshadcoexistingnon-neuromatous secondinterspacelesions. Themostcommonpathologyidentifiedwasperi-capsularfibrosisfollowedbyinter-metatarsalbursitisandganglions,andinterestingly,noconcomitantsecondinterspaceMorton'sneuromasweredetected.
TreatmentsofPPTsincludetheuseofstrappingand/ororthoticstostabilise andoff-loadthejoint,andnon-steroidalanti-inflammatorymedicationwheninflammationispresent(4). Steroidinjectionisnotrecommendedasthiscanfurtherweakenorrupturetheplantarplate,andthismakesdifferentiationbetweenplantarplatetearsandaMorton’sneuromaparticularlyimportantasthisisacommontreatmentforthelatter (4).
Theplantarplatedoesnotreadilyrepairitselfasitismadeoftype1collagen,andwhereconservativetreatmenthasbeenexhausted,surgerymayberequiredtoachievesatisfactoryMTPJalignment,stabilityandpainreduction(1).
3 Ultrasound assessment of a common cause of forefoot pain: Plantar plate tear of the 2nd-5thmetatarsophalangeal joint
Angela Clough - Advanced Practitioner Sonographer
Photosofpatient’sfootdemonstratingmedialdriftofthe2nd toe
Acknowledgement:IwouldliketothankDr PeterGStoddart forhiscontinuedsupportandtrainingwhilstatWestonGeneralHospital
ClinicalandscanfindingsIntroduction