Power, N. Marx, Feuerbach and Non-Philosophy

8/13/2019 Power, N. Marx, Feuerbach and Non-Philosophy.

1/14

Marx, Feuerbach and Non-Philosophy

Nina Power

[DRAFT VERSION: THE PAPER WILL BE SIGNIFICANTLY SHORTER!]

no"erin# $%e one&$'a( a))'*&$ion) +e%in, ,e+a$e) a+o'$ %'*ani)* a-$er $%e *i,./$%en$'r0 re1'ire) re$'rnin# $o $%e &o)$2He#e(ian &%i(o)o&%ie) an, non2&%i(o)o&%ie) o-$%e .345) a) i$ i) %ere6 in $%e wa7e o- $%e )'e)) o- &%i(o)o&%e*e) (')$ere, aro'n,

He#e(8) 9a+)o('$e )&iri$8 in eno,in# a &ar$i'(ar %i)$oria( narra$i"e in$o $%e (o#i o-

&%i(o)o&%0 i$)e(-6 $%a$ $%e )$a$') o- 9*an8 )ee*e, $o +e ei$%er in eo&ar,0 ;a) )eon,ar0 $o$%e &ro#re)) o- Geist


2/14

wo*an o'(, +e $%e )'+e$6 a) a $0&ia( 9&er)ona(i)$8 *i#%$ J in,ee,6 $%i) i) w%a$ %i)

C%ri)$ian $%eo(o#ia( ,e$ra$or)6 )'% a) S$a%(6 -o'n, )o &ro+(e*a$i= In He#e(8) (a$er an,

(a)$ *aor $e?$6 $%e Philosophy of Right-ro* .3.6 9&er)on)8 o'&0 $%e rea(*6 +e$ween$%e &ri"a$e )&%ere an, $%e )$a$e6 o- +o'r#eoi) ;or i"i(< )oie$0 [brgerliche Gesellschaft]=

W%a$ &er)on) %a"e in o**on6 %owe"er6 i) no$ $%eir rea)on6 nor -ee(in# ;a) in $%e -a*i(0ar? wi(( *a7e e?&(ii$ $%e narrowne)) o- He#e(8) one&$ion o-

$%e 'ni"er)a( an, a$$a7 $%e i,ea $%a$ $%e 9'ni"er)a( in$ere)$8 )%o'(, +e o**en)'ra$e

wi$% $%e $a)7 o- '&%o(,in# (e#a(i$0=..

T%e ni"er)a( i) re&ea$e,(0 1'a(i-ie, +0 He#e( inThe Philosophy of Right: 9$%e &roe)) o- (e#i)(a$ion )%o'(, no$ +e re&re)en$e, *ere(0 +0

$%a$ one o- i$) *o*en$) w%ere+0 )o*e$%in# i) ,e(are, $o +e "a(i, -or e"er0one *ore

i*&or$an$ $%a$ $%i) i) $%e inner an, e))en$ia( *o*en$6 na*e(0 cognition of the contentini$) determinate uniersality8=. E"er0w%ere in He#e( $%e 'ni"er)a( i) #i"en6 +'$

ir'*)ri+e,: e"er0one $%in7)6 in &rini&(e6 +'$ on(0 &%i(o)o&%06 an,Mor6 $%e (aw2a+i,in#

&ro&er$02owner $%in7) 'ni"er)a((0= T%i) i) w%0 a ri$i1'e o- &%i(o)o&%06 )'% a)

'n,er$a7en in Fe'er+a%8) a$$e*&$ $o ina'#'ra$e a 9non2&%i(o)o&%08 i) a()o a ri$i1'e o-$%e +o'r#eoi)6 9o#ni)in#8 )'+e$ $%a$ 'n,er&in) i$= E"er0one %a) an a+)$ra$ re(a$ion $o

Ri#%$6 0e$ one *')$ %a"e o#ni@ane [die !enntnis] o- $%e on$en$ o- $%e (aw in or,er $o

&ar$a7e o- i$= A) >ar? &'$) i$: 9$%e 'ni"er)a( a&&ear) e"er0w%ere a) a ,e$er*ina$e

&ar$i'(ar6 w%i(e $%e in,i"i,'a( ne"er a%ie"e) i$) $r'e 'ni"er)a(i$0=8

.

Lwi$% no$e) $%a$6 -or He#e(6 9*an i) -ar -ro* +ein# onei"e, a) a *e*+er o- a

#enera( (a)) ra$%er $%e (i-e o- $%i) (a)) i$)e(-6 )oie$06 i) onei"e, a) a -ra*ewor7e?$erna( $o $%e in,i"i,'a()6 a re)$ri$ion '&on $%eir ori#ina( in,e&en,ene= T%e on(0 +on,

%o(,in# $%e* $o#e$%er i) nee, an, &ri"a$e in$ere)$=8.4T%o)e $%in7er) $%a$ -o((owe,

He#e(6 no$ on(0 >ar?6 +'$ $%o)e w%o >ar? rea,6 re)&e$e, an, ar#'e, wi$% in $%e ear(00ear)6 *o)$ e)&eia((0 L',wi# Fe'er+a%6 orien$e, $%eir &roe$) $owar,) a )erie) o-

o*&(e? $a)7): %ow $o re)'e $%e 'ni"er)a( -ro* i$) He#e(ian (i*i$a$ion) an, $%') ren,er

i$ $r'(0 'ni"er)a( %ow $o re,ee* >an ;'n,er)$oo, a) *en an, wo*en< wi$%o'$ )i*&(0

re,ee*in# $%e +o'r#eoi) *an o- &ro&er$0 an, )e'ri$0 %ow $o (earn $%e (e))on) o- $%e,ia(e$i6 an, $o ri$ii)e i$6 withoutre$rea$in# $o a &re2He#e(ian &ro+(e*a$i $%a$ o'(,

ea)i(0 +e ri$ii)e, an, )'+)'*e, +0 $%e )'+$(e$ie) o- $%e a((2on)'*in# He#e(ian )0)$e*=

A) Fe'er+a% )'in$(0 &'$ i$ in .346 9T%e culminationo- *o,ern &%i(o)o&%0 i) $%eHe#e(ian &%i(o)o&%0= T%e historical necessity an,"ustification o- $%e new &%i(o)o&%0

*')$ $%ere-ore +e ,eri"e, *ain(0 -ro* a criti#ue of $egel%s=8.

T%ere are a n'*+er o- -a$or) $o +ear in *in, %ere= B0 $%e ear(0 .345)6 no$ on(0,i, $%e ori#ina( 'ni-0in# -ore o- $%e 9ra$iona(i)$8 He#e(ian )0)$e* a&&ear $o %a"e +een

,i))o("e, in i$) a&&aren$ o&&o)i$ion $o $%e rea(i$0 o- $%e &o(i$ia( )$a$e ;na*e(06 $%e

a)en)ion o- Pie$i)$ in# Fre,eri7 Wi(%e(* IV an, $%e &o(i$ia( an, aa,e*i %o)$i(i$0

$owar,) He#e(iani)*


4/14

)&(in$erin# o-- o- *0ria, He#e(ian -a$ion)=.Pra$ia((06 $%i) *ean$ $%a$ ri$ii)*) o-

$%eo(o#0 were ine?$ria+(0 in$er*in#(e, wi$% $%o)e o- &o(i$i) ;$%eore$ia( or e?i)$in#ar?8)ear(0 %'*ani)* re&re)en$) *ore $%an a )i*&(e $ran)*'$a$ion o- $%e "enera$ion o- $%e

.Le-$6 Ri#%$6 Yo'n#6 an, $%e *o"e*en$ +e$ween "ario') &o)i$ion)6 a) in Ba'er8) $'rn -ro* a re(a$i"e(0or$%o,o? He#e(ian $o a 7in, o- '$o&ian )oia(i)$6 a) we(( a) non2He#e(ian ri#%$2win# an, $%eo(o#ia(

ri$i1'e) o- He#e(= T%e 9Yo'n# He#e(ian)8 were 7nown a) $egelinge;He#e(i)$)< a) o&&o)e, $o$egelitern

;He#e(ian)


5/14

$ran)en,en$ ;Go,6 i,ea(i)*< $o a "enera$ion o- $%e i**anen$ ;*an6 *a$eria(i)*ar?8) )'+)e1'en$ i,en$i-ia$ion o-

)oia(i)* wi$% $%e &ro(e$aria$8) )$r'##(e a$'a((0 *i(i$a$e) a#ain)$ $%e ore o- Fe'er+a%8)

own e*ani&a$or0 &roe$= Fe'er+a% ne"er i,en$i-ie, $%e &ro(e$aria$ a) $%e 'ni"er)a((a)) w%o)e e*ani&a$ion wo'(, (i+era$e a(( *an7in,= In)$ea, %e re*aine, o**i$$e, $o

$%e $a)7 o- $%e 'ni"er)a( e*ani&a$ion o- %'*ani$0 a) )'%6 an, $%i) *')$ in(',e

&ro(e$aria$ an, a&i$a(i)$ a(i7e= In $%i) )en)e6 Fe'er+a% i) a$$e*&$in# $o *a7e #oo, $%e&ro*i)e o- $%e 'ni"er)a( $%a$ He#e( ne"er arrie, o'$= Howe"er6 we 7now $oo $%a$ $%e

'ni"er)a( &(a0) a (ar#e ro(e in >ar?8) .34244 wor7 on He#e(= T%e -or*a$ion o- a (a))

wi$% 9ra,ia( %ain)86 $%e &ro(e$aria$6 i) &rei)e(0 a negatiely uniersal(a)): i$) )'--erin#i) 'ni"er)a(6 i$) $o$a( 9(o)) o- %'*ani$08 i) a 'ni"er)a( (o))= I$ i) a) i- >ar?6 wi$% $%i)

no$ion o- $%e &ro(e$aria$6 i) $a7in# %i) 'e -ro* Fe'er+a%8) (ai* $%a$ 9on(0 %e w%o %a)

$%e o'ra#e $o +e a+)o('$e(0 ne#a$i"e %a) a()o $%e &ower $o rea$e )o*e$%in# new=8 I- i$

i) on(0 one &ar$ o- %'*ani$0 $%a$ e*ani&a$e) i$)e(-6 ne"er$%e(e)) $%i) 9one &ar$i'(ar (a))'n,er$a7e) -ro* i$) particular situation$%e 'ni"er)a( e*ani&a$ion o- )oie$08= >ar?

%a) %ere $a7en '& Fe'er+a%8) 9o*&(e$e, He#e(iani)*8 an, a,,e, $%e +e#innin#) o- a

*ore *a$eria( &o(i$ia( ri$i1'e6 wi$%o'$ 0e$ ,ro&&in# $%e (an#'a#e o- $%e 'ni"er)a(= T%ere(a$ion)%i& +e$ween $%e re-or*'(a$ion o- $%e 'ni"er)a( +e$ween Fe'er+a% an, >ar? i)

ri$ia(: i$ i) %ere6 ra$%er $%an on $%e 1'e)$ion o- %'*ani)* &er )e6 $%a$ $%e0 wi((

'($i*a$e(0 ,i"er#e6 a) >ar? +eo*e) (e)) an, (e)) on"ine, +0 )$ri$(0 9&%i(o)o&%ia(8

Fro* System of Economic Contradictions+ 1r, Philosophy of Poerty;.34


6/14

one&$ion) o- &o(i$i) an, %'*ani$0= Howe"er6 a) wi(( +e ,i)'))e, -'r$%er on6 $%e

1'e)$ion o- %ow an, in w%i% wa0) $%i) %'*ani$0 in,i"i,'a$e) i$)e(- i) a()o a$ )$a7e:

w%i()$ Fe'er+a% wi(( re*ain in $%e rea(* o- $%a$ w%i% +in,) a$ $%e (e"e( o- $%e #eneri;$%o'#%$6 (o"ear? wi((6 &ar$i'(ar(0 in $%e wa7e o- S$irner8) a$$a7 on Fe'er+a%6 #i"e

*'% *ore &ro*inene $o $%e ro(e o- $%e o*&(e? 9in,i"i,'a(8 ;no$ $o +e 'n,er)$oo, a) a

)'+)$an$i"e 9&er)on8 in He#e(8) )en)e


7/14

;we an )ee ')$ %ow &reo'&ie, Fe'er+a% wa) wi$% 1'e)$ion) o- -'$'ri$0 an,

$e*&ora(i$06 an, $%e i**e,ia$e nee, -or a new 7in, o- $%in7in# -ro* &er')in# $%e $i$(e) o-

%i) wor7): 9Prini&(e) o- $%e P%i(o)o&%0 o- $%e F'$'re86 9T%e Nee))i$0 o- a Re-or* o-P%i(o)o&%086 9Pre(i*inar0 T%e)e) on $%e Re-or* o- P%i(o)o&%08


8/14

%o*o(o#0 +e$ween $%e &er)ona( Go, an, &er)ona( *onar%0 an, &ri"a$e &ro&er$0 in

$%o)e on)er"a$i"e a$$a7) on He#e(6 -or e?a*&(e6 G)%e(8) 9&o(i$ia( C%ri)$o(o#08 w%i%

,eri"e, $%e &rini&(e o- *onar%ia( a'$%ori$0 -ro* $%e ,i"ine &er)ona(i$0 o- C%ri)$=Fe'er+a% ar#'e, $%a$ an e#oi)$ia( +e(ie- in &er)ona( i**or$a(i$0 re)'($e, in $%e ,e(ine

o- anien$ &o(i$ia( (i-e6 a) we(( a) +o()$erin# $%e en$ra(i$0 o- $%e i)o(a$e, )e(-2)ee7in#

+o'r#eoi) o- i"i( )oie$0 ;%ere we a(rea,0 #(i*&)e $%e +e#innin#) o- %i) wor7 ona(iena$ionar? wa) a$i"e(0 rea$in# %i*)e(- a) a Fe'er+a%ian6 >a? S$irner45

-(a$(0 ,enie) $%e &o))i+i(i$0 o- )&eie) ;or #eneraan8 i) $%') no$%in# o$%er$%an a 9)o(e*n (i%86 no$ an o+e$ o- $%o'#%$6 no$ a #oa( $o +e a$$aine,6 nor a a$e#or0

$o +e re)'e, -ro* i$) a(iena$ion in $ran)en,ene6 a) Fe'er+a% wo'(, )ee i$= Ye$6 e"en

$%o'#% >ar? wi(( ,i)$ane %i*)e(- -ro* Fe'er+a% on $%i) &oin$6 a) So&er 1'i$e ri#%$(0

C-= Fe'er+a%8) )i*i(ar(0 ironi6 (a$er ri$ii)* o- He#e(8) )0)$e*a$i $e(eo(o#0: 9I) i$ a$ a(( possible$%a$ a)&eie) rea(i@e) i$)e(- in one in,i"i,'a(6 ar$ a) )'% in one ar$i)$6 an, &%i(o)o&%0 a) )'% in one

&%i(o)o&%er86 9Towar,) a Cri$i1'e o- He#e(8) P%i(o)o&%08 ;.3/


9/14

&'$) i$6 9we *i#%$ no$e6 %owe"er6 $%a$ $%o'#% $%ere i) a ,ei)i"e )%i-$ awa0 -ro*

Fe'er+a%ian %'*ani)* in The German 3deology6 $%ere i) no +rea7 wi$% %'*ani)$

ar#'*en$ a) )'%=84T%e 1'e)$ion i) ra$%er %ow $%e in,i"i,'a( ;$%e e#o6 or $%e )e(-6 -orS$irner< (i"e) in a )oia( rea(* in w%i% eono*i an, &o(i$ia( e(e*en$) ,i)$ane *en

an, wo*en -ro* $%eir own a&ai$ie)=

>ar? an, En#e() wi(( )a"a#e S$irner in The German 3deology6 in or,er $o )$a7eo'$ a &o)i$ion $%a$ re*ain) )$ri$(0 9o**'ni)$8 in $%e )en)e $%a$ )o*e -or* o- o((e$i"e

i,en$i-ia$ion i) &o))i+(e6 in,ee,6 nee))ar0= T%e0 ,e(are $%a$ )'% a $%in7er 9+0

&ro(ai*in# %i) own $%o'#%$ a) $%e en, o- &%i(o)o&%0 an, i$) $ri'*&%an$ en$rane in$oor&orea( (i-e8 &re)en$) an '$$er(0 i*&o"eri)%e, ;no$ $o *en$ion +o'r#eoi)< a1'i)i$i"e

in,i"i,'a(i)* $%a$ '&%o(,) $%e 'rren$ or,er6 e"en a) i$ ,enie) $%a$ $%i) or,er %a) no$%in#

$o ,o wi$% $%e in,i"i,'a(8) )'&&o)e,(0 9anar%i8 an$i2-o'n,a$iona(i)*=4 I$ i) (ear6

%owe"er6 $%a$ S$irner8) anar%i)$i 'n,er*inin# o- Fe'er+a% )%a7e) >ar? an, En#e()1'i$e )e"ere(0: $%e German 3deologyi)6 a-$er a((6 a $e?$ in w%i% $%ree %'n,re, an, ei#%$0

&a#e) are ,e"o$e, $o S$irner ;o*&are, $o a *ere )e"en$0 $o Fe'er+a%6 an, $wen$0 $o

Br'no Ba'er


10/14

W%i()$ A($%'))er +e(ie"e %e 'no"er) a re(iane on (o"e in Fe'er+a%8) ana(0)i) $%a$

'n,er&in) %i) $%eore$ia( (ai*)6 we &er%a&) ,o no$ nee, $o #o )o -ar= I$ i) no$ on(0 or

&ara,i#*a$ia((0 in 9(o"e8 $%a$ Fe'er+a% in,ia$e) GattungswesenJ i$ i) -o'n, a()o in%i) ,i)'))ion) o- (an#'a#e6 -or e?a*&(e in 9Towar,) a Cri$i1'e o- He#e(8) P%i(o)o&%08

;.3/< w%ere %e ar#'e): 9Lan#'a#e i) no$%in# o$%er $%an $%e reali(ation of the species

i=e=6 $%e KI i) *e,ia$e, wi$% $%e KYo' in or,er6 +0 e(i*ina$in# $%eir in,i"i,'a()e&ara$ene))6 $o *ani-e)$ $%e 'ni$0 o- $%e )&eie)=84A($%'))er ar#'e) $%a$ Fe'er+a% owe)

$o He#e( 9the intersub"ectiity of the 5we%= B'$ i$ i) (ear $%a$ Fe'er+a% re$ain) $%i)

e(e*en$ o- re(a$iona(i$0 $%a$ He#e( -ir)$ i,en$i-ie, in or,er $o ,e*on)$ra$e *an8) a&ai$0-or transcending%i*)e(- a) an in,i"i,'a(=W%a$ Fe'er+a% '($i*a$e(0 )ee*) $o ,o i)

on-(a$e $%e )$a#e) $%a$ He#e( 7e&$ ,e(i+era$e(0 )e&ara$e: %e *er#e) ;a=< $%e #eneri

a--ini$0 o- $%e )e?e) a) *ani-e)$e, ei$%er in &%0)ia(i$0 or *arria#e wi$% ;+=< $%e in-ini$e

$%o'#%$ $%a$ He#e( ,e)ri+e) in $%e 1'o$e +e(ow6 $o rea$e6 ;=< a )en)'o')2in$e((e$'a(w%o(e ;9rea( non2a(iena$e, *an8


11/14

,e"o$ion=8n(i7e He#e(6 -or Fe'er+a%6 (o"e ;ra$%er $%an )oie$02)an$ione, *arria#e< i)

a &ar$ner)%i& o- e1'a(i$0 ;an, no$ )i*&(0 $%e -')ion o- %e$ero)e?'a( &ar$ner)ar?8) in $%e -ir)$ &(ae6 an, $%a$ $%e (a$$er8) $a7e2'& o- Fe'er+a%ianr%e$ori6 in $%e -ae o- +o$% %i) &o)i$i"e an, ne#a$i"e ')e $%ereo-6 ne"er -'((0 ae&$e, $%e

-'n,a*en$a( &re*i)e) o- $%e )%e*a= >ar?8) Fe'er+a%ian r%e$ori ne"er o**i$$e, %i*$o Fe'er+a%8) &%i(o)o&%ia( an$%ro&o(o#0=

W%i()$ we are in,e+$e, $o A($%'))er8) ana(0)i) o- $%e re(a$ion)%i& +e$ween >ar?

an, Fe'er+a%6 we anno$ a#ree wi$% %i) (ai* $%a$ 9a(( $%e e?&re))ion) o- >ar?8) i,ea(i)$9%'*ani)*8 are Fe'er+a%ian=8.. Nor $%a$ 9>ar? wa) *ere(0 a&&(0in# $%e $%eor0 o-

a(iena$ion6 $%a$ i) Fe'er+a%8) $%eor0 o- 9%'*an na$'re86 $o &o(i$i) an, $%e onre$e

a$i"i$0 o- *an6 +e-ore e?$en,in# i$ ;in (ar#e &ar$< $o &o(i$ia( eono*0 in $%e

.anuscripts=8.W%a$ A($%'))er *i))e) in $%e (a$$er (ai* i) $%e 'ne"en )&(i$ in $%e %ear$o- Fe'er+a%8) wor7 i$)e(-6 w%i% ,e$er*ine) $%e wa0 a $%eor0 o- 9%'*an na$'re8

;'n,er)$oo, a) &%i(o)o&%ia( an$%ro&o(o#0< an +e e?$ra$e, -ro* %i) $%eor0 o-

a(iena$ion= For Fe'er+a%6 $%e $wo are no$ $%e )a*e6 w%i% *a7e) i$ $%e a)e $%a$ >ar?6')in# Fe'er+a%ian (an#'a#e $o $a(7 a+o'$ *an8) a(iena$ion6 en,) '& *eanin# )o*e$%in#

1'i$e ,i--eren$ $o Fe'er+a%ar?8) re(a$ion $o one o- o*&e$in# -or*) o-

%'*ani)* ;an, an$i2%'*ani)*< o"er ino*&a$i+i(i$0 o- on)io')ne))Mna$'ra(i)*=

F'r$%er*ore6 +0 $rea$in# %'*ani)* an, an$%ro&o(o#0 a) )0non0*o') $er*)6 %e o+)'re)an0 &o))i+(e ,i--eren$ia$in# %ara$eri)$i) +e$ween $%e*: 9Fe'er+a% re&(ae) He#e(8)

a+)o('$e o+e$i"e i,ea(i)* wi$% an a+)o('$e an$%ro&o(o#i)* or %'*ani)* %e re&(ae)

$%e a+)o('$e i,ea(i)* o- $%e I,ea wi$% an a+)o('$e *a$eria(i)* o- *an=8 .T%i) i) ar#'a+(0w%a$ >ar? ,e(i+era$e(0 ,oe) a()o w%en %e $'rn) $o ri$ii)e Fe'er+a% J +0 wi((-'((0

Bre7*an6.ar/, the 0oung $egelians and the 1rigins of Radical Social Theory6 &= /=39Fra#*en$) Conernin# $%e C%ara$eri)$i) o- >0 P%i(o)o&%ia( De"e(o&*en$86 The 'iery )roo*6 &= =/Economic and Philosophical .anuscripts6 EW6 &= /=.59Fe'er+a%8) KP%i(o)o&%ia( >ani-e)$oe)86 &= 4=..I+i,=6 &= 4=.I+i,=6 &= 4=.I+i,=6 &= 5=

..


12/14

*i)$a7in# $%e +e#innin#) o- $%e ri$ia( &roe$ -or an 'n-ini)%e, &ra$ia( )e$ o-

on(')ion): 9[Fe'er+a%] ,oe) no$ #ra)& $%e )i#ni-iane o- 9re"o('$ionar086 o-

9&ra$ia(2ri$ia( a$i"i$08 ;T%e)i) Iar? i) aware6 %e anno$ ,o $%i) &rei)e(0+ea')e $%e &o(i$ia( a)&e$) o- %i) &roe$ ,o no$ in an0wa0 +ear '&on $%e &ra$ia(

a$i"i$0 o- *an= Here a -'r$%er ,i)$in$ion +e$ween >ar? an, Fe'er+a% %in#e) '&on $%e

ro(e &(a0e, +0 a$i"i$06 or6 in o$%er wor,)6 w%ere *an8) 9e))ene8 $r'(0 *ani-e)$) i$)e(- Jin $%o'#%$6 or in &ra?i)

How ,ee&(0 ,i, $%e 'ne"en Fe'er+a%ian -or*'(a$ion o- $%e a+)$ra$2)en)'o')

one&$ion o- 9>an8 a) $%e on(0 &o)$2He#e(ian )$ar$in# &oin$ -or a &%i(o)o&%0 o- $%e-'$'re ;w%i% i) a$ $%e )a*e $i*e a non2&%i(o)o&%0< &er*ea$e $%e wri$in#) o- >ar? in $%e

.345) >ore &rei)e(06 ,i, a -or* o- ra,ia( non2Fe'er+a%ian %'*ani)* ;an, no$ an

an$%ro&o(o#i)*< 'n,er&in $%e $%ree *aor wor7) o- $%e >ar? o- .34424 ;one o- w%i%

wa) o- o'r)e o2wri$$en wi$% En#e()ar? ar#'e) $%a$ 90o'

anno$ $ran)en, [aufheben] &%i(o)o&%0 wi$%o'$ rea(i)in# [erwir*lichen] i$8 in %i) .342

44 Cri$i1'e o- He#e(6 we an &er%a&) -'r$%er ar#'e $%a$ %e o'(, no$ $ran)en,

Fe'er+a%8) 9non2&%i(o)o&%08 wi$%o'$ a()o rea(i)in# i$6 w%i% e?&(ii$(0 in"o("e, #oin#+e0on, $%e &'re one&$ion o- *an a) ,e-ine, +0 %i) a&ai$0 $o $%in7 $%e in-ini$e ;w%i(e

re"er)in# He#e(8) i,ea(i)$ (ai*)6 Fe'er+a% ne"er$%e(e)) re*ain) He#e(ian in $%i) en$ra(a)&e$


13/14

$%e on$rar06 in $%e $er*) o- $%e .3424 $e?$6 i$ no (on#er e"en *a7e) )en)e $o a)7

w%e$%er $%i) o"ero*in# o- $%e I8) in,i"i,'a(i$0 in $%o'#%$ %a) an0 i**e,ia$e re(e"ane

w%a$)oe"er6 a) w%a$ i) in)$ea, a$ )$a7e i) $%e 9&ra$ia( o"er$%row o- $%e a$'a( )oia(re(a$ion) w%i% #a"e ri)e $o $%i) i,ea(i)$i %'*+'#8=.Here >ar? %a) )%i-$e, )o $%a$

i,eo(o#0 (ie) no$ wi$% $%e #enera(i)e, a(iena$ion o- on)io')ne))6 +'$ i) a &ro,'$ o- $%e

Ger*an &%i(o)o&%er) an, Ger*an &%i(o)o&%0 i$)e(-: %ene 9$%e Ger*an ideology%i) $%a$o- $%e Yo'n# He#e(ian)6 no$ o- Ger*an0 a) a w%o(e6 $%o'#% Ger*an )oie$0 i)6 a$ $%e

)a*e $i*e6 a+)o('$e(0 on)$i$'$e, +0 i$) $%eore$ia((0 i,eo(o#ia( i,en$i$0=

Di, >ar? e"er rea((0 $a7e on +oar, $%e a)&e$ o- Fe'er+a% $%a$ onern) $%ea&ai$0 o- $%o'#%$ $o 9$%in7 $%e in-ini$e8 E"en w%en %e i) )ee*in#(0 *o)$ 'n,er %i)

)&e((6 in $%e 6788 .anuscripts6 %e ,e(inea$e) %i) 'n,er)$an,in# o- Gattungswesen in

$er*) o*&(e$e(0 ,i--eren$ -ro* $%o)e o- Fe'er+a%=.3Here w%a$ ,i)$in#'i)%e) *an -ro*

9ani*a()8 a) a Gattungsweseni) no$ a ,i--erene in *ind6 a) i$ %a) $o +e -or Fe'er+a%6 +'$a ,i--erene o- degree: 9S&eie)2(i-e6 +o$% -or *an an, -or ani*a()6 on)i)$) physicallyin

$%e -a$ $%a$ *an6 (i7e ani*a()6 (i"e) -ro* inor#ani na$'re an, +ea')e *an i) *ore

'ni"er)a( $%an ani*a()6 )o $oo i) $%e area o- inor#ani na$'re -ro* w%i% %e (i"e) *ore

'ni"er)a( To )a0 $%a$ *an8) &%0)ia( an, *en$a( (i-e i) (in7e, $o na$'re )i*&(0 *ean)$%a$ na$'re i) (in7e, $o i$)e(-6 -or *an i) a &ar$ o- na$'re8=./We )ee %ow >ar? o((a&)e)

Fe'er+a%8) )%ar& ,i)$in$ion +e$ween *an8) inner an, o'$er (i-e in -a"o'r o- a#ra,'a(i)$6 *ore in$e#ra$e, re(a$ion)%i& $o na$'re=5 B'$ Fe'er+a%8) 'n,er)$an,in# o-

*an8) e))ene ,oe) no$ ,e&en, '&on a re(a$ion $o an0$%in# o'$)i,e o- i$)e(-= In $%i) )en)e

i$ i) a &ro-o'n,(0 an$i2na$'ra(i)$ )$ane6 e"en a +a)e2(ine 7in, o- ra$iona(i)*6 ,e&en,in# a)i$ ,oe) on $%e a))er$ion $%a$ $%e e))ene o- *an i) %i) a&ai$0 $o $a7e %i) own e))ene 9a)

*an8 a) an o+e$ ;an, a$ $%e )a*e $i*e *an i) 'ni"er)a( +ea')e i$ $a7e) $%e 'ni"er)e -or

i$) own o+e$ in $%e )a*e wa0ar? o- The German 3deologywi(( ,e(are $o +e i*&o))i+(e $oonei"e wi$%o'$ -ir)$(0 ;an, )o(e(0< 'n,er)$an,in# $%e K)oia( onne$ion) an, Ke?i)$in#

on,i$ion) o- (i-e $%a$ an on(0 +e a,e1'a$e(0 re)&on,e, $o +0 9a $ran)-or*a$ion +o$% o-

in,')$r0 an, o- $%e )oia( )$r'$'re8=.T%i) ,e-inin# ,i--erene in a$$i$',e) )%ow) $%a$6,e)&i$e %i) ')e o- Fe'er+a%ian r%e$ori -ro* $%e ear(0 ri$i1'e) o- He#e( $o The German

3deologyan, $%e Theses6 >ar? wa) ne"er a$'a((0 Fe'er+a%ian in the first place= Hi)

one&$ion o- a(iena$ion wa) a(wa0) 1'e)$ion o- *an8) a(iena$ion -ro* %i) productie&ower)6 an, no$ %i) ra$iona( one)= Wi$%o'$ Fe'er+a%8) +a)e(ine ra$iona(i)*6 >ar?

e"a'a$e) $%e )'+)$ane o- >an8) 'ni"er)a(i$06 e"en $%o'#% $%i) i) &rei)e(0 nee))ar0 -or

$%e in"en$ion6 or ,i)o"er06 in The German 3deology6 o- $%e 9rea( %i)$or08 o- 9rea( *en8=

I$ i) $%ere-ore in'*+en$ '&on >ar? $o ea)e ')in# 9>an8 a$ a(( in $%i) $e?$6 w%i%%e ,'(0 ,oe)6 &re-errin# in)$ea, 9rea(6 a$i"e6 *en8 a) 9in,i"i,'a()8 wre)$e, awa0 -ro*

.The German 3deology6 &= /=

.3

An, %ere we on'r a+)o('$e(0 wi$% C== Ar$%'r8) (ai* $%a$: 9One )%o'(, no$ +e ,i)$'r+e, +0 >ar?8)+orrowin# $%e $er* 9)&eie) +ein#8 ;Gattungswesen< -ro* Fe'er+a%= T%e on$en$ i) ,i--eren$=82ialectics

of Labour+ .ar/ and his Relation to $egel;O?-or,: B(a7we((6 ./3an')ri&$)86Early &ritings6 &&= 236 *0 e*&%a)i)=5>an a$ one &oin$ in %i) %i)$or0 %a) a on)io')ne)) $%a$ i) on(0 9)%ee&2(i7e86 aor,in# $o >ar?=.The German 3deology6 &= = A) o(o7ow)7i &'$) i$: 9T%e on$en$ion o- >ar? an, En#e() wa) $%a$ $%e ,i)$in#'i)%in# *ar7 o-

%'*ani$06 $%a$ w%i% &ri*ari(0 %ara$eri)e) *en a) o&&o)e, $o +ea)$)6 i) no$ $%a$ $%e0 $%in7 +'$ $%a$ $%e0

*a7e $oo()86 .ain Currents of .ar/ism, 69 The 'ounders6 $ran)= +0 P= S= Fa((a ;O?-or,: OP6 ./3.


14/14

$%eir rea$i"e6 &ro,'$i"e a&ai$ie)6 w%i%6 in an0 a)e6 are a(wa0) *ore )&ei-i $%an

Fe'er+a%8) #eneri 'ni"er)a(i)*: 9>an *')$ +e "iewe, in %i) rea( %i)$oria( a$i"i$0 an,

e?i)$ene8=I- $%i) )o'n,) (i7e %i)$oria( e*&irii)*6 $%en >ar? i) 1'i7 $o a))'re ') $%a$%e i) no$ onerne, wi$% $%e 9,ea, -a$)8 o- &re"io') e*&irii)$) ;$%a$6 -'r$%er*ore re*ain

a+)$ra$ar? ,i)$in#'i)% %i) new )e$ o- onern)

B'$ one o- $%e *o)$ "i$a( &rini&(e) o- o**'ni)*6 w%i% ,i)$in#'i)%e) i$ -ro*

a(( rea$ionar0 )oia(i)*6 i) i$) e*&iri "iew6 +a)e, on a 7now(e,#e o- *en6 $%a$

,i--erene o- +rain6 o- in$e((e$'a( a&ai$06 ,o no$ i*&(0 an0 ,i--erenew%a$)oe"er in $%e na$'re o- $%e )$o*a% an, o- &%0)ia( nee,) $%ere-ore $%e -a()e

$ene$6 +a)e, '&on e?i)$in# ir'*)$ane)6 K$o ea% aor,in# $o %i) a&ai$06

*')$ +e %an#e,6 in )o -ar a) i$ re(a$e) $o eno0*en$ in i$) narrower )en)e6 in$o $%e

$ene$6 K$o ea% aor,in# $o %i) nee,

Fe'er+a%8) ai*6 +e-ore >ar?6 wa) $o )'&er)e,e &%i(o)o&%0= >ar?6 a,o&$in# $%a$ ai* a)

%i) own6 in$ro,'e) ano$%er $er* in$o Fe'er+a%8) &ro+(e*a$i: %i)$or0= 9Hi)$or0 i) $%e

$r'e na$'ra( %i)$or0 o- *an8=

I$ i) (ear $%a$ $%e r'ia( )%i-$ $%a$ $a7e) &(ae %ere&rei)e(0 en$re) aro'n, $%e re(a$ion)%i& +e$ween *an an, na$'re -or Fe'er+a%6 an,

*an6 na$'re and history6 -or >ar?= T%e -'r$%er 1'e)$ion $%en &o)e) i$)e(-: %ow an >ar?on)i)$en$(0 *ain$ain a 'ni"er)a(i)$ one&$ion o- *an and %i)$orii@e *an8) )oia(

on,i$ion) F'r$%er*ore6 %ow wi(( $%e e*er#in# (an#'a#e o- $%e ,i"i)ion o- (a+o'r

;ar#'a+(0 a(rea,0 &re)en$ in $%e ear(ier ri$i1'e) o- He#e( in $%e -or* o- $%e )e&ara$ion o-a )'--erin# 9'ni"er)a(8 (a)) an, $%e +o'r#eoi)ie< $ro'+(e $%e on$ra,i$ion2(e))6 $%o'#%

a(iena$e,6 na$'re o- *an a) onei"e, 'n,er $%e Fe'er+a%ian )%e*a=

The German 3deology6 &= .=4I+i,96 &= .=The German 3deology6 &&= .3/2./5=Economic and Philosophical .anuscripts6 &= /.=

.4

Documents

Power, N. Marx, Feuerbach and Non-Philosophy