1
•Poor adherence to medication results in $300 billion of unnecessary health care (Vlasnik et al. 2005) •Medication discontinuation and subsequent failure of treatment results in 10% of hospitalizations (Harrold, 2008). •It is estimated that ½ of all patients skip or discontinue long term medical therapy for chronic illnesses and 1 out of 5 patients do not pick up filled prescriptions (Reginster, 2006). •Studies have determined specific factors that effect adherence such as the dosing regimen, side effects, cost, and pill burden. Greater case management that increases patient knowledge and the understanding of patient concerns has been effective in increasing medication adherence (Vlasnik et al. 2005). •Although medications for rheumatic conditions are often directly related to greater mobility and pain relief, patients often discontinue long term therapy (Harrold, 2008) •For patients with rheumatic conditions, the effect of drug class and safety perception on medication adherence is not known. Such knowledge could increase the rate of adherence and minimize the loss of billions of dollars while improving the quality of life of patients with chronic rheumatic diseases. The Effect of Drug Class and Safety Perception on the Medication Adherence of Rheumatology Patients Kathryn C. Fischer, Department of Biological Sciences York College of Pennsylvania Methods Immunosuppressant drugs were discontinued the most. Pain Relievers and Corticosteroids were discontinued the least. However, only 27 of 100 patients described discontinuing their medication. Patients who felt their prescribed medication was dangerous discontinued therapy 100% of the time. However, 75% of patients felt their medication was safe or moderately safe. Similar to past medication adherence studies, the greatest motivation for discontinuing long term medical therapy for patients at AACR is side effects (Vlasnik et al. 2005). It is now known that a significant amount of patients who discontinue prescribed medications at AACR feel the risks of side effects outweigh the benefits of continuing therapy. Factors influencing adherence such as safety perception and motivation to discontinue can be addressed in order to intervene in patients who have concerns about their long term therapy. Further research involving a greater quantity of patients would increase the significance of discontinuation, both within specific drug classes and due to patient safety perception. LITERATURE CITED Harrold, Leslie R., and Susan E. Andrade. "Medication Adherence of Patients with Selected Rheumatic Conditions: A Systematic Review of Literature." Seminars in Arthritis and Rheumatism (2008). Klippel, John H., and Patience H. White, eds. Primer on the Rheumatic Diseases . New York: Springer, 2007. Reginster, Jean-Yves. "Adherence and persistence: Impact on outcomes and health care resources." Bone 38 (2006): 18-21. Vlasnik, Jon J., Sherry L. Aliotta, and Bonnie DeLor. "Medication Adherence Factors Influencing Compliance with Prescribed Medication Plans." The Case Manager 16 (2005): 47-51. Whitley, Heather P., Joli D. Fermo, Kelly Ragucci, and Eleanor C. Chumney. "Assessment of patient knowledge of diabetic goals, self- reported medication adherence, and goal attainment." Pharmacy Practice 4 (2006): 183-90. Results A survey was developed regarding patient disorder and medication, safety perception, media observations, personal conversations, medication discontinuation, and motivation to discontinue. Surveys were distributed to 110 patients at Advanced Arthritis Care and Research in Scottsdale, Arizona over 21 days prior to examination before the physician entered the room. Completed surveys were delivered directly to the receptionist after appointment. New patients were excluded from the study and 10 patients declined to participate. Objective Percentage of D iscontinuation W ithin D rug C lasses 0 10 20 30 Figure 2.Percentage ofm edication discontinuation forall patients surveyed. C hi-Square statistical analysis provided a p value of0.120 which fails to rejectthe null hypothesis.This shows no significantrelationship between drug class and discontinuation. D rug C lass P ercentage of P atien ts Figure 1. Copy of survey distributed to patients at Advanced Arthritis Care and Research in Scottsdale, Arizona. PatientSaftey Perception forD rug C lass Perscribed 0 10 20 30 40 Figure 3.Analysis ofpatientsafety perception forall patients surveyed.C hi-Square statistical analysis provied the p value of less than 0.0001 which supports rejection ofthe null hypothesis. This supports a significantdifference in perception ofsafety within the patientpopulation. Safety Perception P ercen tag e o f P atients PatientM otivation for M edication D iscontinuation 0 10 20 30 40 50 Figure 5.Analysis ofpatientm otivation and m edication discontinuation.A non-param etric C hi-Square testresulted in a p value of0.004 which rejects the null hypothesis.This supports a significantdifference in m otivation ofskipping ordiscontinuing medication. M otivation P ercentage ofP atien ts Data was compiled and statistical analysis was performed using SPSS Percentage of D iscontinuation W ithin Saftey Perception C ategories 0 20 40 60 80 100 Figure 4 .Percentage ofpatients who discontinued m edication within each saftey perception category.C hi-square statistical analysis provided a p value of0.164 which fails to rejectthe null hypothesis.This shows no significantdifference in saftey perception and discontinuation ofdrug prescribed. Safety Perception P ercen tage o f P atien ts ACKNOWLEDGEMENT • I would like to thank Dr. Warren C. Rizzo of Advanced Arthritis Care and Research in Scottsdale, Arizona for my internship experience and guidance. • Also thanks to mentors Dr. Carolyn Mathur and Dr. Joshua Landau for their guidance. • And a special thanks to Peter and Alison Fischer for their ever present inspiration to better the lives of individuals with rheumatic diseases. Conclusion Introduction

Poor adherence to medication results in $300 billion of unnecessary health care (Vlasnik et al. 2005) Medication discontinuation and subsequent failure

Embed Size (px)

Citation preview

Page 1: Poor adherence to medication results in $300 billion of unnecessary health care (Vlasnik et al. 2005) Medication discontinuation and subsequent failure

•Poor adherence to medication results in $300 billion of unnecessary health care (Vlasnik et al. 2005)

•Medication discontinuation and subsequent failure of treatment results in 10% of hospitalizations (Harrold, 2008).

•It is estimated that ½ of all patients skip or discontinue long term medical therapy for chronic illnesses and 1 out of 5 patients do not pick up filled prescriptions (Reginster, 2006).

•Studies have determined specific factors that effect adherence such as the dosing regimen, side effects, cost, and pill burden. Greater case management that increases patient knowledge and the understanding of patient concerns has been effective in increasing medication adherence (Vlasnik et al. 2005).

•Although medications for rheumatic conditions are often directly related to greater mobility and pain relief, patients often discontinue long term therapy (Harrold, 2008)

•For patients with rheumatic conditions, the effect of drug class and safety perception on medication adherence is not known. Such knowledge could increase the rate of adherence and minimize the loss of billions of dollars while improving the quality of life of patients with chronic rheumatic diseases.

•Determine the medication adherence of 8 specific drug classes

•Determine If safety perception for prescribed drug class effects medication adherence

•Determine if there is a specific motivation to discontinue medication

The Effect of Drug Class and Safety Perception on the Medication Adherence of Rheumatology Patients

Kathryn C. Fischer, Department of Biological Sciences York College of PennsylvaniaMethods

•Immunosuppressant drugs were discontinued the most. Pain Relievers and Corticosteroids were discontinued the least. However, only 27 of 100 patients described discontinuing their medication.

•Patients who felt their prescribed medication was dangerous discontinued therapy 100% of the time. However, 75% of patients felt their medication was safe or moderately safe.

•Similar to past medication adherence studies, the greatest motivation for discontinuing long term medical therapy for patients at AACR is side effects (Vlasnik et al. 2005).

•It is now known that a significant amount of patients who discontinue prescribed medications at AACR feel the risks of side effects outweigh the benefits of continuing therapy. Factors influencing adherence such as safety perception and motivation to discontinue can be addressed in order to intervene in patients who have concerns about their long term therapy.

•Further research involving a greater quantity of patients would increase the significance of discontinuation, both within specific drug classes and due to patient safety perception.

LITERATURE CITEDHarrold, Leslie R., and Susan E. Andrade. "Medication Adherence of Patients with Selected Rheumatic Conditions: A Systematic Review of Literature." Seminars in Arthritis and Rheumatism (2008).

Klippel, John H., and Patience H. White, eds. Primer on the Rheumatic Diseases. New York: Springer, 2007.

Reginster, Jean-Yves. "Adherence and persistence: Impact on outcomes and health care resources." Bone 38 (2006): 18-21.

Vlasnik, Jon J., Sherry L. Aliotta, and Bonnie DeLor. "Medication Adherence Factors Influencing Compliance with Prescribed Medication Plans." The Case Manager 16 (2005): 47-51.

Whitley, Heather P., Joli D. Fermo, Kelly Ragucci, and Eleanor C. Chumney. "Assessment of patient knowledge of diabetic goals, self-reported medication adherence, and goal attainment." Pharmacy Practice 4 (2006): 183-90.

Results

A survey was developed regarding patient disorder and medication,

safety perception, media observations, personal conversations, medication discontinuation,

and motivation to discontinue.

Surveys were distributed to 110 patients at Advanced Arthritis Care and Research

in Scottsdale, Arizona over 21 days prior to examination before the physician entered the room.

Completed surveys were delivered directly to the receptionist after appointment. New patients were excluded from the study

and 10 patients declined to participate.

Objective Percentage of Discontinuation

Within Drug Classes

0

10

20

30

Figure 2. Percentage of medication discontinuation for allpatients surveyed. Chi-Square statistical analysis provided a p

value of 0.120 which fails to reject the null hypothesis. This showsno significant relationship between drug class and

discontinuation.

Drug Class

Perc

en

tag

e o

f P

ati

en

ts

Figure 1. Copy of survey distributed to patients at Advanced Arthritis Care and Research in Scottsdale, Arizona.

Patient Saftey Perceptionfor Drug Class Perscribed

0

10

20

30

40

Figure 3. Analysis of patient safety perception for all patientssurveyed. Chi-Square statistical analysis provied the p value ofless than 0.0001 which supports rejection of the null hypothesis.

This supports a significant difference in perception of safety withinthe patient population.

Safety Perception

Perc

en

tag

e o

f P

ati

en

ts

Patient Motivation for Medication Discontinuation

0

10

20

30

40

50

Figure 5. Analysis of patient motivation and medicationdiscontinuation. A non-parametric Chi-Square test resulted in ap value of 0.004 which rejects the null hypothesis. This supportsa significant difference in motivation of skipping or discontinuing

medication.

Motivation

Perc

en

tag

e o

f P

ati

en

ts

Data was compiled and statistical analysis was performed using SPSS

Percentage of DiscontinuationWithin Saftey Perception Categories

0

20

40

60

80

100

Figure 4. Percentage of patients who discontinued medicationwithin each saftey perception category. Chi-square statistical

analysis provided a p value of 0.164 which fails to reject the nullhypothesis. This shows no significant difference in saftey

perception and discontinuation of drug prescribed.

Safety Perception

Perc

en

tag

e o

f P

ati

en

ts

ACKNOWLEDGEMENT • I would like to thank Dr. Warren C. Rizzo of Advanced Arthritis Care and Research

in Scottsdale, Arizona for my internship experience and guidance.• Also thanks to mentors Dr. Carolyn Mathur and Dr. Joshua Landau for their

guidance.• And a special thanks to Peter and Alison Fischer for their ever present inspiration

to better the lives of individuals with rheumatic diseases.

ConclusionIntroduction