Political Identity: territory Political Identity: territory and regions in Europeand regions in Europe

Alistair ColeAlistair Cole

Three ways of understanding regions Three ways of understanding regions and regionalismand regionalism

Ethno-territorial mobilisationEthno-territorial mobilisation Multi-level governanceMulti-level governance New Regionalism? New Regionalism?

Three approaches that might be ‘tested’ in Three approaches that might be ‘tested’ in relation to a broad variety of casesrelation to a broad variety of cases

Identity and ethno-territorial Identity and ethno-territorial mobilisationmobilisation

MorenoMoreno Ethno-territorial identities have developed as a result of the decline of the Nation- Ethno-territorial identities have developed as a result of the decline of the Nation-State, hollowed to the core by economic globalisation and political integration. State, hollowed to the core by economic globalisation and political integration.

The new politics in Europe is that of ethno-territorial mobilisation. This reflects itself in sub-The new politics in Europe is that of ethno-territorial mobilisation. This reflects itself in sub-state political institutions, distinctive party systems, language rights movements and cultural state political institutions, distinctive party systems, language rights movements and cultural traditions and specific forms of elite accommodation. traditions and specific forms of elite accommodation.

There has been renewed interest in minority nationalism, ethno-territorial mobilisation and There has been renewed interest in minority nationalism, ethno-territorial mobilisation and how identity has an impact upon institutional arrangements . how identity has an impact upon institutional arrangements .

In Spain, in theory a unitary state, there has developed a State of Autonomies, where three In Spain, in theory a unitary state, there has developed a State of Autonomies, where three ‘nations’ – Catalonia, Basque Country and Galicia – are recognised as historic nationalities in ‘nations’ – Catalonia, Basque Country and Galicia – are recognised as historic nationalities in the 1978 constitution and given extended devolved powers. the 1978 constitution and given extended devolved powers.

In the UK, the minority nationalist’ question has been nested in a broader class cleavage: in In the UK, the minority nationalist’ question has been nested in a broader class cleavage: in both Scotland and Wales, ‘ national’ identity came as a result of a specific feeling of class both Scotland and Wales, ‘ national’ identity came as a result of a specific feeling of class identity and of being different from the rest of the UK. identity and of being different from the rest of the UK.

If there are fashions, this is one. In Italy, a move to regional evolution has accompanied more If there are fashions, this is one. In Italy, a move to regional evolution has accompanied more assertive regional claims, such as that of Padania in the north. assertive regional claims, such as that of Padania in the north.

But are there other explanations. Is identity overplayed? But are there other explanations. Is identity overplayed?

Multi-level governance?Multi-level governance? A different approach – but one which focusses on regions – is that of multi-level governanceA different approach – but one which focusses on regions – is that of multi-level governance

Initially developed by Marks (1992), this approach views the European policy process as ‘a Initially developed by Marks (1992), this approach views the European policy process as ‘a system of continuous negotiation among nested governments at several territorial tiers’ system of continuous negotiation among nested governments at several territorial tiers’ (Marks, 1993: p392). (Marks, 1993: p392).

One of the strongest arguments by supporters of multi-level governance is that One of the strongest arguments by supporters of multi-level governance is that EU cohesion EU cohesion policy has policy has transformed territorial policy styles across Europe, by encouraging and transformed territorial policy styles across Europe, by encouraging and facilitating facilitating the development of new political strategies and networks, bypassing State administrations and the development of new political strategies and networks, bypassing State administrations and creating new alliances between the European Commission and sub-state players. creating new alliances between the European Commission and sub-state players.

This perspective This perspective views the multi-level game played jointly by the European Commission (and views the multi-level game played jointly by the European Commission (and latterly the European Parliament) and regional actors as a normative one, designed to ‘by-latterly the European Parliament) and regional actors as a normative one, designed to ‘by-pass’ or ‘evade’ the centre qua central government, and result in an overall strengthening of pass’ or ‘evade’ the centre qua central government, and result in an overall strengthening of both supranational and regional tiers. both supranational and regional tiers.

The multi-level governance perspective is in part a decentralisation narrative that emphasises The multi-level governance perspective is in part a decentralisation narrative that emphasises the financing of regional and structural programmes, the institutionalisation of regional the financing of regional and structural programmes, the institutionalisation of regional representation at EU level and the transnational activity of the regions representation at EU level and the transnational activity of the regions

Regions are functional spaces, in this model, more than harbingers of a post-nation-state Regions are functional spaces, in this model, more than harbingers of a post-nation-state futurefuture

New Regionalism? Be careful..New Regionalism? Be careful.. The norm in Europe is for an ‘asymmetrical configuration of government The norm in Europe is for an ‘asymmetrical configuration of government

and a multiplicity of institutional regimes…(Majone, 2003). and a multiplicity of institutional regimes…(Majone, 2003).

Regions are strengthened not just because of identity, or strategy of the Regions are strengthened not just because of identity, or strategy of the EU, but also because they represent functionally appropriate levels of EU, but also because they represent functionally appropriate levels of government, especially for economic planning. government, especially for economic planning.

Loughlin and Keating (2003): there has been a transformation of regions in Loughlin and Keating (2003): there has been a transformation of regions in Europe, from functional outposts of central government... to genuine Europe, from functional outposts of central government... to genuine political spaces, with directly elected institutions and developed forms of political spaces, with directly elected institutions and developed forms of capacitycapacity

Strengthening regions in a counterpart to the emasculation of the stateStrengthening regions in a counterpart to the emasculation of the state

But how accurate is this? The response lies in empirical investigation and But how accurate is this? The response lies in empirical investigation and comparisoncomparison

Identity... Against instrumentalismIdentity... Against instrumentalism

When considering the new regionalism debate above, When considering the new regionalism debate above, we drew a basic distinction between identity-based we drew a basic distinction between identity-based forms of sub-state mobilisation capacity building and forms of sub-state mobilisation capacity building and more instrumental considerations of competencies more instrumental considerations of competencies and inter-governmental relations. and inter-governmental relations.

Instrumental models are more likely to focus on Instrumental models are more likely to focus on levelslevels as being the appropriate ones for the delivery as being the appropriate ones for the delivery or co-ordination of a range of services, while identity or co-ordination of a range of services, while identity models look to regions as historic, cultural and models look to regions as historic, cultural and political entities and argue for an institutional focus political entities and argue for an institutional focus for identity-based loyalties. for identity-based loyalties.

A word of cautionA word of caution In some states, regions are weak or non-existent, especially where there is a In some states, regions are weak or non-existent, especially where there is a

tradition of strong local government, as in the Netherlands, the Scandinavian tradition of strong local government, as in the Netherlands, the Scandinavian countries or – for much of its history – the United Kingdomcountries or – for much of its history – the United Kingdom

In some of the smaller European Union countries, such as Portugal, Greece or In some of the smaller European Union countries, such as Portugal, Greece or Ireland, there is a tradition of centralisation that has difficulties in accommodating Ireland, there is a tradition of centralisation that has difficulties in accommodating regions. In the countries of central and Eastern Europe, there is no tradition of regions. In the countries of central and Eastern Europe, there is no tradition of autonomous regional level administration (Marcou, 2003). autonomous regional level administration (Marcou, 2003).

During the EU enlargement negotiations, there was much opposition from within During the EU enlargement negotiations, there was much opposition from within these countries to creating new decentralised structures, with the new entrants these countries to creating new decentralised structures, with the new entrants fearful lest irredentist national minorities try and break away and create their own fearful lest irredentist national minorities try and break away and create their own states. states.

Though the European Commission started off by advocating decentralisation, it Though the European Commission started off by advocating decentralisation, it swiftly moved to the idea of centralised ‘regional’ economic planning. In some swiftly moved to the idea of centralised ‘regional’ economic planning. In some countries, regions are principally city regions, based around large cities and their countries, regions are principally city regions, based around large cities and their hinterland (Parkinson, 1992). hinterland (Parkinson, 1992).

Spain: an attractive model for Spain: an attractive model for devolutionistsdevolutionists

The move to democracy in Spain from 1975 onwards The move to democracy in Spain from 1975 onwards was closely linked with accommodating Spain’s was closely linked with accommodating Spain’s historic nations and regions and rallying everybody to historic nations and regions and rallying everybody to the democratic cause. the democratic cause.

The ‘State of Autonomies’ embodied in the 1978 The ‘State of Autonomies’ embodied in the 1978 Constitution represented the most radical Constitution represented the most radical regionalisation of any European state at the time. It regionalisation of any European state at the time. It created 17 Autonomous Communities with far created 17 Autonomous Communities with far reaching devolved powers. Catalonia, the Basque reaching devolved powers. Catalonia, the Basque Country and Galicia were recognised early on as Country and Galicia were recognised early on as ‘historic nationalities’, facilitating their support for ‘historic nationalities’, facilitating their support for the plural Spanish nation. the plural Spanish nation.

Spain: identity or institutions? Spain: identity or institutions?

The Spanish state is neither federal nor unitary.. here there is a strong The Spanish state is neither federal nor unitary.. here there is a strong institutional argument. No-one wants to be left behind and ACs are institutional argument. No-one wants to be left behind and ACs are discovering ancient identitiesdiscovering ancient identities

Until recently, Apart from one or two exceptions (such as the Basque tax-Until recently, Apart from one or two exceptions (such as the Basque tax-raising powers) in theory all autonomous communities have the right to raising powers) in theory all autonomous communities have the right to exercise the powers of the strongest communities. exercise the powers of the strongest communities.

Since 1995, the weakest communities have caught up with the stronger Since 1995, the weakest communities have caught up with the stronger ones in terms of competencies. The precise list of competencies depends ones in terms of competencies. The precise list of competencies depends on the organic laws in existence in each of the autonomous communities. on the organic laws in existence in each of the autonomous communities.

In some policy areas, the autonomous community has complete legislative In some policy areas, the autonomous community has complete legislative and regulatory powers, not dependent upon the Spanish State. In some and regulatory powers, not dependent upon the Spanish State. In some areas, there are shared powers, and in still others exclusive Spanish state areas, there are shared powers, and in still others exclusive Spanish state responsibility. responsibility.

Spain Institutional incentives to ‘identivise’Spain Institutional incentives to ‘identivise’ There is an inherent tension between recognising historic identities and There is an inherent tension between recognising historic identities and

providing the opportunity for all Spanish regions to develop their own providing the opportunity for all Spanish regions to develop their own institutional capacity within the Union State. institutional capacity within the Union State.

In some important respects, the Spanish model does In some important respects, the Spanish model does notnot favour the historic favour the historic nationalities over other regions. The constitution does not establish a hierarchy nationalities over other regions. The constitution does not establish a hierarchy between the historic communities and the others. In legal terms, any autonomous between the historic communities and the others. In legal terms, any autonomous community can call itself a nation, if it so desires. community can call itself a nation, if it so desires.

While during the 1980s, only the three historic nationalities plus Andalusia had While during the 1980s, only the three historic nationalities plus Andalusia had proclaimed themselves to be nations, by 1999 eight out of 17 autonomous proclaimed themselves to be nations, by 1999 eight out of 17 autonomous communities were recognised as nationalities. communities were recognised as nationalities.

Weaker regions have pointedly developed their ‘national’ identities in order to Weaker regions have pointedly developed their ‘national’ identities in order to prevent incorporation by stronger neighbours (the case for Valencia in relation to prevent incorporation by stronger neighbours (the case for Valencia in relation to Catalonia). Devolution in Spain has somewhat artificially provoked a wide range Catalonia). Devolution in Spain has somewhat artificially provoked a wide range of regionalist demands.of regionalist demands.

In the case of Spanish devolution, then, In the case of Spanish devolution, then, we can identify a clear institutional we can identify a clear institutional effect.effect. Institutions create a spiral effect and have introduced a race for autonomy, Institutions create a spiral effect and have introduced a race for autonomy, a lesson policy-makers in the UK would be advised to take on board. a lesson policy-makers in the UK would be advised to take on board.

Slippery slope…Slippery slope… New Catalan statute approved by the Catalan parliament in New Catalan statute approved by the Catalan parliament in

2006, setting out Catalonia as a nation. Eventually approved 2006, setting out Catalonia as a nation. Eventually approved by the Spanish lower house on 30th March 2006. The Catalan by the Spanish lower house on 30th March 2006. The Catalan statute involves:statute involves:

Recognition of Catalan national identityRecognition of Catalan national identity ‘‘national reality as a nationality’national reality as a nationality’ Control over legal affairsControl over legal affairs Strengthens Catalonia in relation to the EU and foreign policy: Strengthens Catalonia in relation to the EU and foreign policy: Catalan parliament to raise 50% of income tax and VAT and Catalan parliament to raise 50% of income tax and VAT and

create a revenue agencycreate a revenue agency Catalan examples followed by Valencia, Andalucia and Catalan examples followed by Valencia, Andalucia and

Basque country.Basque country. Identity is exaggerated by institutions... Identity is exaggerated by institutions...

Germany: instrumentalism ovder Germany: instrumentalism ovder identity identity

GermanyGermany provides a contrast both to Spanish asymmetry and Belgian provides a contrast both to Spanish asymmetry and Belgian communautarianism. The Federal Republic of Germany provides the communautarianism. The Federal Republic of Germany provides the interesting case of a federal system that does not allow great room for interesting case of a federal system that does not allow great room for policy diversity. policy diversity.

By imposing federalism upon western Germany in 1949, the occupying By imposing federalism upon western Germany in 1949, the occupying powers sought to reduce the power of central government and ensure a powers sought to reduce the power of central government and ensure a stable democracy. stable democracy.

Even after sixty years of operation, there remains something artificial Even after sixty years of operation, there remains something artificial about German federalism. Unlike in a country such as Canada, German about German federalism. Unlike in a country such as Canada, German federalism does not reflect the organisation of a society with specific federalism does not reflect the organisation of a society with specific minorities. There are no significant ethnic, cultural, social or religious minorities. There are no significant ethnic, cultural, social or religious tensions in Germany. tensions in Germany.

Moreover, the 16 state governments (the Moreover, the 16 state governments (the länderländer) are artificial units that do ) are artificial units that do not correspond to historic German regions and do not reflect cultural, not correspond to historic German regions and do not reflect cultural, historic or linguistic differences within Germany. historic or linguistic differences within Germany.

Even after sixty years of institutional existence, Germans feel themselves Even after sixty years of institutional existence, Germans feel themselves to be members of a local or a national community rather than a to be members of a local or a national community rather than a landland. Their . Their real attachment to regions is to those based on dialects, customs and real attachment to regions is to those based on dialects, customs and culture such as the Rhineland, Palatinate, Badenia, or Franconia. culture such as the Rhineland, Palatinate, Badenia, or Franconia.

GermanyGermany There is a very close interdependency between the federal and the state There is a very close interdependency between the federal and the state

((länder)länder) governments, the system of ‘interlocking politics’ described by governments, the system of ‘interlocking politics’ described by Scharpf. Scharpf.

The The länderländer are legally bound into a system of joint decision-making and are legally bound into a system of joint decision-making and revenue-sharing, and share a strong normative commitment to policy revenue-sharing, and share a strong normative commitment to policy uniformity. uniformity.

The The länderländer co-operate closely with the federal government in matters of co-operate closely with the federal government in matters of regional economic policy, agriculture and the planning of universities. regional economic policy, agriculture and the planning of universities.

The The länderländer are closely involved in decision-making at the federal level are closely involved in decision-making at the federal level through the composition of the second chamber, the through the composition of the second chamber, the bundesratbundesrat, which has a , which has a veto on federal legislation in around 50% of cases. veto on federal legislation in around 50% of cases.

Unlike in Belgium or even Spain, there is a strict system of fiscal Unlike in Belgium or even Spain, there is a strict system of fiscal redistribution and most resources for federal governments and the redistribution and most resources for federal governments and the länderländer come from joint taxes. come from joint taxes.

For all these reasons, there is a greater uniformity of policy in Germany For all these reasons, there is a greater uniformity of policy in Germany than might be expected in a federal system. than might be expected in a federal system.

Identity is squeezed out by institutionsIdentity is squeezed out by institutions……

Belgium: linguistic fractureBelgium: linguistic fracture The case of Belgium is the most eloquent in terms of demonstrating the centrifugal The case of Belgium is the most eloquent in terms of demonstrating the centrifugal

effects of linguistic divisionseffects of linguistic divisions . . Belgium was created as an independent state in 1830… domination of the French-Belgium was created as an independent state in 1830… domination of the French-

speaking Walloons in the south.. at the expense of the Dutch speaking Flemish, speaking Walloons in the south.. at the expense of the Dutch speaking Flemish, mainly in the north. In the course of the mid 20th century, the economic and mainly in the north. In the course of the mid 20th century, the economic and linguistic balance began to shift: so that the downtrodden Flemish now became the linguistic balance began to shift: so that the downtrodden Flemish now became the majority of the population and the more dynamic economic community. majority of the population and the more dynamic economic community.

The only solution discovered to prevent the complete dissolution of the Belgian The only solution discovered to prevent the complete dissolution of the Belgian state: the policy of separate language communities (from 1963), to deal with issues state: the policy of separate language communities (from 1963), to deal with issues of education and culture, for the different communities. of education and culture, for the different communities.

The language issue has had a profound impact in Belgium, to the extent of The language issue has had a profound impact in Belgium, to the extent of changing the party system and replacing Belgian-wide parties - e.g. Socialists, with changing the party system and replacing Belgian-wide parties - e.g. Socialists, with specific parties for each community. Here: language has had the effect of a specific parties for each community. Here: language has had the effect of a cleavagecleavage

Institutions have encouraged linguistic identities and language performs the Institutions have encouraged linguistic identities and language performs the role of a key cleavagerole of a key cleavage. .

FranceFrance Comparison with other EU states reveals the persistence of this belief in equality as Comparison with other EU states reveals the persistence of this belief in equality as

uniformity and how this constricts local and regional capacity building. uniformity and how this constricts local and regional capacity building. In comparative perspective, FIn comparative perspective, France still appears as the most resistant of the five rance still appears as the most resistant of the five

major European nations to asymmetrical territorial development on its mainland. major European nations to asymmetrical territorial development on its mainland. Germany, Spain, the UK and Italy have each undergone developments that can in Germany, Spain, the UK and Italy have each undergone developments that can in some senses be labelled as federal, quasi-federal or asymmetrical (different parts of some senses be labelled as federal, quasi-federal or asymmetrical (different parts of the ‘national’ territory developing more or less advanced forms of autonomy). the ‘national’ territory developing more or less advanced forms of autonomy).

In the case of France, a distinctive form of sub-national governance has evolved. In the case of France, a distinctive form of sub-national governance has evolved. But there are no equivalents to the strong regions with fiscal and/or legislative But there are no equivalents to the strong regions with fiscal and/or legislative powers, such as Scotland, the Belgian and Italian regions, the Spanish Autonomous powers, such as Scotland, the Belgian and Italian regions, the Spanish Autonomous Communities, or the German länder. France’s 22 regions have a shared general Communities, or the German länder. France’s 22 regions have a shared general competency, some tax-varying powers but no hierarchical control over other layers competency, some tax-varying powers but no hierarchical control over other layers of local government. Governance might challenge the state, but not the unitary of local government. Governance might challenge the state, but not the unitary state form. state form.

Given its reaction to the Corsican example, it is highly likely that any attempt to Given its reaction to the Corsican example, it is highly likely that any attempt to derogate too seriously from the norm of uniformity will be resisted by the Council derogate too seriously from the norm of uniformity will be resisted by the Council of State, the guardian of France’s conservative public law tradition. of State, the guardian of France’s conservative public law tradition.

Institutions have, in the main, squeezed out identities Institutions have, in the main, squeezed out identities

Lesser Used languages as sources of identityLesser Used languages as sources of identityThere is a strong argument that recent moves to more There is a strong argument that recent moves to more

differentiated forms of regional and local governance are differentiated forms of regional and local governance are likely to encourage linguistic pluralism (see, for example, likely to encourage linguistic pluralism (see, for example, Keating, Loughlin and Deschouwer, 2003). Keating, Loughlin and Deschouwer, 2003).

In countries such as Spain, Belgium and Italy, the move to In countries such as Spain, Belgium and Italy, the move to enhanced regional self-consciousness in the 1980s and 1990s enhanced regional self-consciousness in the 1980s and 1990s was associated with a rediscovery of the value of lesser-used was associated with a rediscovery of the value of lesser-used languages and cultures and the adoption of new policy languages and cultures and the adoption of new policy instruments to plan language revival. instruments to plan language revival.

In the age of ‘think global, act local’, language can exercise a In the age of ‘think global, act local’, language can exercise a useful signalling function, demonstrating clearly the useful signalling function, demonstrating clearly the distinctiveness and value-added identity of specific regions. distinctiveness and value-added identity of specific regions.

Some examplesSome examples

Catalonia, Basque country, Galicia: ability to Catalonia, Basque country, Galicia: ability to speak the ‘regional’ language essential for speak the ‘regional’ language essential for self-promotionself-promotion

Ireland: Gaelic speakers 2-3% of the Ireland: Gaelic speakers 2-3% of the population, but mastery essential for higher population, but mastery essential for higher officeoffice

Wales: Welsh Language Act (1993) introduces Wales: Welsh Language Act (1993) introduces bilingualism. Welsh an official langiuage of bilingualism. Welsh an official langiuage of the EUthe EU

The Welsh Language: Identity, The Welsh Language: Identity, institutionsinstitutions

In broad socio-economic terms, Welsh has expanded its usage In broad socio-economic terms, Welsh has expanded its usage considerably in the past two decades and the language is now considerably in the past two decades and the language is now used widely in education, the media, leisure and selected used widely in education, the media, leisure and selected public services.public services.

Language survey data suggests that social context, family Language survey data suggests that social context, family language transmission and exposure to formal bilingual language transmission and exposure to formal bilingual education are the key factors in language reproduction. education are the key factors in language reproduction.

In the case of Wales, community and family are less powerful In the case of Wales, community and family are less powerful agents of language reproduction than they were previously, agents of language reproduction than they were previously, but formal bilingual education and language planning has but formal bilingual education and language planning has slowed the rate of absolute decline. slowed the rate of absolute decline.

Welsh Identity: languageWelsh Identity: language Analysis of family/household composition patterns by Analysis of family/household composition patterns by

Aitchison and Carter (1997) show that an extremely high Aitchison and Carter (1997) show that an extremely high proportion of Welsh speakers is linguistically isolated within proportion of Welsh speakers is linguistically isolated within their home environments. their home environments.

Many communities of the northern and western heartland Many communities of the northern and western heartland seem to be fragmenting irretrievably, threatening the seem to be fragmenting irretrievably, threatening the transmission of the Welsh language. Welsh is not secure as a transmission of the Welsh language. Welsh is not secure as a community language despite its official status. community language despite its official status.

Fluent and good Welsh-speakers manifesting a high proclivity Fluent and good Welsh-speakers manifesting a high proclivity towards Welsh identity, as do the intermediate and basic towards Welsh identity, as do the intermediate and basic speakers, when contrasted with the non-Welsh speakers.speakers, when contrasted with the non-Welsh speakers.

Rather like in Spain, devolved instituions create a space for a Rather like in Spain, devolved instituions create a space for a linguistic identitylinguistic identity

Welsh Identity: ClassWelsh Identity: Class

There are clearly sociological differences in bases to identity.There are clearly sociological differences in bases to identity.

Cole and Evans (2007): Individuals residing in the Valleys showing a Cole and Evans (2007): Individuals residing in the Valleys showing a much greater propensity towards Welsh identity than the Cardiff reference. much greater propensity towards Welsh identity than the Cardiff reference. A Class Identity (Wyn Jones and Scully, 2003)?A Class Identity (Wyn Jones and Scully, 2003)?

In terms of occupational class belonging, two classes stand out – the petty In terms of occupational class belonging, two classes stand out – the petty bourgeoisie, with the highest probability of British identity, and workers bourgeoisie, with the highest probability of British identity, and workers with conversely the highest level of Welsh identity. with conversely the highest level of Welsh identity.

Interestingly, even in areas of reputed ‘Welshness’ such as the North-West Interestingly, even in areas of reputed ‘Welshness’ such as the North-West of Wales and mid-Wales, there is no significant difference from the capital of Wales and mid-Wales, there is no significant difference from the capital – indeed North-West Wales is slightly more British in its identification.– indeed North-West Wales is slightly more British in its identification.

Welsh Identity: AgeWelsh Identity: Age

Cole and Evans (2007): There is an almost monotonic Cole and Evans (2007): There is an almost monotonic relationship between age categories and identity, with relationship between age categories and identity, with the two youngest strata identifying most strongly with the two youngest strata identifying most strongly with the Welsh identity, decreasing in the 55 and older the Welsh identity, decreasing in the 55 and older categories. categories.

Educationally, a similarly clear profile emerges. Educationally, a similarly clear profile emerges. Individuals with the lowest educational attainment Individuals with the lowest educational attainment have the highest level of Welsh identity, following by have the highest level of Welsh identity, following by the mid-level group. the mid-level group.

ConclusionConclusion

Moreno and ethno-terriorital mobilisation: mixing up Moreno and ethno-terriorital mobilisation: mixing up normative and empirical evidence. Appropriate for a normative and empirical evidence. Appropriate for a minority of cases? But how representatives are these?minority of cases? But how representatives are these?

Multi-level governance? Useful as a metaphor, but Multi-level governance? Useful as a metaphor, but regions contsructed in instrumental sensesregions contsructed in instrumental senses

New Regionalism? In places.. Nut not as a general New Regionalism? In places.. Nut not as a general trendtrend

Comparsion: creates a spectrum. When does identity Comparsion: creates a spectrum. When does identity drive institutions? What do institutions confine drive institutions? What do institutions confine identities? How do we explain variation? identities? How do we explain variation?