28
…«Zbc ¶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¶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

Plurality of Pluralisms

  • Upload
    doobas

  • View
    234

  • Download
    1

Embed Size (px)

Citation preview

Page 1: Plurality of Pluralisms

¼«Z�c ¶°�T]2Q�WKH�3OXUDOLW\�RI�5HOLJLRXV�3OXUDOLVPV

+DMM�0XKDPPDG�/HJHQKDXVHQ7KH�,PDP�.KRPHLQL�(GXFDWLRQ�DQG�5HVHDUFK�,QVWLWXWH���0DUFK�����$EVWUDFW7KHUH�LV�DQ�RYHUZKHOPLQJ�SOXUDOLW\�RI�YDULHWLHV�RI�SOXUDOLVP��,Q�WKLV�SDSHU�W\SHV�RI�SOXUDOLVP� DUH GLVWLQJXLVKHG� VR� WKDW� ZH� FDQ� XQGHUVWDQG� ZKDW� LV� PHDQW� E\� UHOLJLRXVSOXUDOLVP�� (YHQ� DIWHU� UHOLJLRXV� SOXUDOLVP� LV� GLVWLQJXLVKHG� IURP� RWKHU� VRUWV� RI�SOXUDOLVP��D�YDULHW\�RI�SRVLWLRQV�FRXOG�EH�FRQVLGHUHG�YHUVLRQV�RI�UHOLJLRXV�SOXUDOLVP��$PRQJ�WKH�GLIIHUHQW�VRUWV�RI�UHOLJLRXV�SOXUDOLVP��ZH�PD\�GLVWLQJXLVK�UHGXFWLYH�IURP�QRQ�UHGXFWLYH YDULHWLHV�� 7KH� SURSRQHQWV� RI� UHGXFWLYH� IRUPV� RI� UHOLJLRXV� SOXUDOLVP�DWWHPSW�WR�LGHQWLI\�D�FRPPRQ�HOHPHQW�DPRQJ�GLIIHUHQW�UHOLJLRQV�RQ�WKH�EDVLV�RI�ZKLFK�WKH�UHOLJLRQV�DUH�VXFFHVVIXO�LQ�VRPH�VSHFLILHG�ZD\��ZKLOH�QRQ�UHGXFWLYH�SOXUDOLVWV�KROG�WKDW�*RG¶V�JXLGDQFH� WKURXJK� WKH�YDULRXV� UHOLJLRQV�QHHG�QRW�EH�FRQILQHG� WR�HOHPHQWV�FRPPRQ� WR� WKHP�� 5HOLJLRXV� SOXUDOLVPV� PD\� DOVR� EH� GLYLGHG� EHWZHHQ� HTXDOLW\SOXUDOLVPV�DQG�GHJUHH�SOXUDOLVPV��3OXUDOLVPV�PD\�EH�IRFXVHG�RQ�GRFWULQHV��SUDFWLFHV��LQVWLWXWLRQV�� FRPPXQLWLHV�� RU� LQGLYLGXDO� EHOLHYHUV�� 6HYHQ� PDMRU� W\SHV� RI� UHOLJLRXV�SOXUDOLVP� DUH� GLYLGHG� ZLWK� UHJDUG� WR� WKH� W\SHV� RI� YDOXHV� WKDW� DUH� GLVSXWHG��VRWHULRORJLFDO�� QRUPDWLYH�� HSLVWHPRORJLFDO�� DOHWKLF�� HWKLFDO�� GHRQWRORJLFDO�� DQG�KHUPHWLF�.H\ZRUGV�� UHOLJLRXV� SOXUDOLVP�� QRQ�UHGXFWLYH� UHOLJLRXV� SOXUDOLVP�� VRWHULRORJLFDO�SOXUDOLVP�� QRUPDWLYH� SOXUDOLVP�� HSLVWHPRORJLFDO� SOXUDOLVP�� DOHWKLF� SOXUDOLVP�� HWKLFDO�SOXUDOLVP��GHRQWRORJLFDO�SOXUDOLVP��KHUPHWLF�SOXUDOLVP�

,��,QWURGXFWLRQ7KHUH� LV� DQ� RYHUZKHOPLQJ�SOXUDOLW\� RI� YDULHWLHV� RI� SOXUDOLVP�� ,Q�ZKDW� IROORZV�� ,�ZLOO�DWWHPSW� WR�GLVWLQJXLVK�DPRQJ�WKHP�VR�WKDW�ZH�FDQ�XQGHUVWDQG�ZKDW�LV�PHDQW�E\�UHOLJLRXV SOXUDOLVP�� ,�ZLOO� DUJXH� WKDW� HYHQ� DIWHU� UHOLJLRXV� SOXUDOLVP� LV� GLVWLQJXLVKHG�IURP�RWKHU�VRUWV�RI�SOXUDOLVP��D�YDULHW\�RI�SRVLWLRQV�FRXOG�EH�FRQVLGHUHG�YHUVLRQV�RI�UHOLJLRXV� SOXUDOLVP�� $PRQJ� WKH� GLIIHUHQW� VRUWV� RI� UHOLJLRXV� SOXUDOLVP�� ZH� PD\�GLVWLQJXLVK�UHGXFWLYH�IURP�QRQ�UHGXFWLYH YDULHWLHV��7KH�SURSRQHQWV�RI UHGXFWLYH�IRUPV�RI�UHOLJLRXV�SOXUDOLVP�DWWHPSW�WR�LGHQWLI\�D�FRPPRQ�HOHPHQW�DPRQJ�GLIIHUHQW�UHOLJLRQV�RQ�WKH�EDVLV�RI�ZKLFK�WKH�UHOLJLRQV�DUH�VXFFHVVIXO�LQ�VRPH�VSHFLILHG�ZD\��$FFRUGLQJ�WR�QRQ�UHGXFWLYH�UHOLJLRXV�SOXUDOLVP��WR�WKH�FRQWUDU\��*RG�JXLGHV�ZKRPHYHU�+H�ZLOO�� QRW�RQO\� E\� YLUWXH� RI� IHDWXUHV� FRPPRQ� WR� VHYHUDO� UHOLJLRQV�� EXW� E\� WKHLU� XQLTXH� GLYLQH�

� �7KHLU�JXLGDQFH�LV�QRW�\RXU�UHVSRQVLELOLW\��EXW�$OODK�JXLGHV�ZKRPVRHYHU�+H�ZLOO� ��������

Page 2: Plurality of Pluralisms

TXDOLWLHV�� DV� ZHOO�� 0RUH� VSHFLILFDOO\�� ZKLOH� UHGXFWLYH� SOXUDOLVP� LV� WKH� SRVLWLRQ� WKDW�ZKDW�LV�JRRG�DERXW�UHOLJLRQV�LV�ZKDW�LV�FRPPRQ�WR�D�SOXUDOLW\�RI�WKHP��QRQ�UHGXFWLYH�SOXUDOLVP�LV�WKH�YLHZ�WKDW�HDFK�RI�D�QXPEHU�RI�UHOLJLRQV�KDV�XQLTXH�IHDWXUHV�WKURXJK�ZKLFK�*RG�PD\�JXLGH�SHRSOH��HYHQ�LI�WKHUH�LV�QR�FRPPRQ�HVVHQFH�WR�DOO�UHOLJLRQV��,,��+LVWRU\�RI�3OXUDOLVP

7KH�WHUP�SOXUDOLVP ZDV�ILUVW�XVHG�WR�VLJQLI\�D�PHWDSK\VLFDO�GRFWULQH�E\�&KULVWLDQ�:ROII��������������DQG�ODWHU�SRSXODUL]HG�E\�:LOOLDP�-DPHV��������������$�GLIIHUHQW�EXW�UHODWHG�VHQVH�RI�SOXUDOLVP�LV�PRUDO�SOXUDOLVP��:KLOH�PHWDSK\VLFDO�SOXUDOLVWV�KROG�WKDW� WKHUH� LV� DQ� LUUHGXFLEOH� SOXUDOLW\� RI� W\SHV� RI� VXEVWDQFH�� WUXWKV�� RU� RULJLQDO�SULQFLSOHV��PRUDO�SOXUDOLVWV KROG� WKDW� WKHUH� LV�DQ� LUUHGXFLEOH�SOXUDOLW\� RI� LQGHSHQGHQW�PRUDO� YDOXHV�� 7KH� WZR� VRUWV� RI� SOXUDOLVP�� PHWDSK\VLFDO� DQG� PRUDO�� DUH� HORTXHQWO\�OLQNHG� LQ� WKH� ZRUN� RI� ,VDLDK� %HUOLQ� ������������� %HUOLQ� GHIHQGHG� PRUDO� SOXUDOLVP�WKURXJKRXW� KLV� ORQJ� FDUHHU�� 3ROLWLFDO� WKHRULVWV� XVH� WKH� WHUP� IRU� V\VWHPV� LQ� ZKLFK� D�YDULHW\� RI�ZD\V�RI� OLIH� DUH�SHUPLWWHG� WR� FRH[LVW� RU� DUH� HQFRXUDJHG��3HUKDSV� WKH�EHVW�SODFH�WR�ORRN�IRU�D�GLVFXVVLRQ�RI�SOXUDOLVP�LQ�WKLV�VHQVH�LV�LQ�WKH�PRUH�UHFHQW�ZULWLQJV�RI� WKH� ODWH� -RKQ�5DZOV� ������������� SDUWLFXODUO\� LQ� KLV�3ROLWLFDO� /LEHUDOLVP�� 5DZOV�VSHDNV� RI� FRPSHWLQJ� FRPSUHKHQVLYH� V\VWHPV� RI� WKRXJKW� DQG� YDOXH� �IRU� H[DPSOH��YDULRXV� UHOLJLRXV� V\VWHPV�� YDULRXV� WKHRULHV� RI� VRFLDOLVP�� HWKLFDO KXPDQLVP�� HWF���ZKRVH� GLIIHUHQFHV� FDQ� EH� H[SHFWHG� WR� SHUVLVW� LQ� GHPRFUDWLF� VRFLHWLHV�� 5DZOV� WKHQ�DWWHPSWV�WR�VKRZ�WKDW�UHDVRQDEOH�SHRSOH�ZKR�KROG�GLIIHULQJ�FRPSUHKHQVLYH�YLHZV�ZLOO�GHYHORS�DQ�RYHUODSSLQJ�FRQVHQVXV�ZLWK�UHJDUG�WR�EDVLF�SURFHGXUDO�SULQFLSOHV�RI�MXVWLFH�DV� IDLUQHVV�� )LQDOO\�� WKHUH� LV� UHOLJLRXV� SOXUDOLVP�� RU� UDWKHU�� WKHUH� DUH� UHOLJLRXV�SOXUDOLVPV��IRU�WKH�ODEHO�KDV�EHHQ�XVHG�IRU�GLIIHUHQW�DQG�RIWHQ�FRQIXVHG�FODLPV��6RPH�ZULWHUV�XVH�WKH�WHUP�³UHOLJLRXV�SOXUDOLVP´�IRU�D�WKHRORJLFDO�YLHZ�WKDW�DOORZV�VDOYDWLRQ�IRU� WKH� DGKHUHQWV� RI� GLIIHUHQW� UHOLJLRQV� DQG� FRQFHGHV� VRPH� VRUW� RI� YDOLGLW\� WR� D�SOXUDOLW\�RI�UHOLJLRQV��0DQ\�RWKHU�ZULWHUV��KRZHYHU��XVH�WKH�WHUP�LQ�D�SROLWLFDO�VHQVH��IRU� D� SRVLWLRQ� WKDW� DGYRFDWHV� WKH� DFFHSWDQFH� RI� DQG� UHVSHFW� IRU� WKH� IROORZHUV� RI�GLIIHUHQW�UHOLJLRQV��$OO�WRR RIWHQ��WKH�GLIIHUHQW�XVHV�RI�WKH�WHUP�DUH�FRQIXVHG��� -RKQ�5DZOV��3ROLWLFDO�/LEHUDOLVP��1HZ�<RUN��&ROXPELD�8QLYHUVLW\�3UHVV���������������� )RU� DQ� RYHUYLHZ� RI� GHILQLWLRQV� JOHDQHG� E\� VXUILQJ� WKH� LQWHUQHW�� VHH� %�� $�� 5RELQVRQ�� ³4XRWDWLRQV�6KRZLQJ�9DULRXV�'HILQLWLRQV�RI�WKH�7HUP�µ5HOLJLRXV�3OXUDOLVP�¶´85/� �KWWS���ZZZ�UHOLJLRXVWROHUDQFH�RUJ�UHOBSOXU��KWP��

Page 3: Plurality of Pluralisms

,,,��(TXDOLW\�DQG�'HJUHH�3OXUDOLVPV:H�FDQ�JLYH�D�UDWKHU�DEVWUDFW�GHILQLWLRQ�RI�UHOLJLRXV�SOXUDOLVP�E\�VD\LQJ�WKDW�LW�LV�D�GRFWULQH� DFFRUGLQJ� WR� ZKLFK� VRPH� VRUW� RI� IDYRUDEOH� DWWULEXWLRQ� LV� DVFULEHG� WR� D�SOXUDOLW\�RI�UHOLJLRQV��7KLV�GHILQLWLRQ�KDV�WKH�DGYDQWDJH�RI�PDNLQJ�LW�FU\VWDO�FOHDU�WKDW�ZH�FDQ�H[SHFW�WR�ILQG�D�ZLGH�YDULHW\�RI�SRVLWLRQV�WKDW�FRXOG�EH�GHVFULEHG�E\�WKH�WHUP�UHOLJLRXV� SOXUDOLVP�� 7KH� YDULHW\� LV� VR� ZLGH� WKDW� WKH� FODLP� WKDW� VRPHRQH� DFFHSWV�UHOLJLRXV�SOXUDOLVP�LQ�WKLV�VHQVH�LV�DOPRVW�WULYLDO�7R�KROG�WKDW�VRPH�IDYRUDEOH�DWWULEXWLRQ�LV�SURSHUO\�DVFULEHG�WR�D�UHOLJLRQ�LV�WR�VD\�WKDW� WKHUH�LV�VRPH�YDOXH�RI�ZKLFK�WKH�UHOLJLRQ�SDUWDNHV��2QH�FRXOG��IRU�H[DPSOH��VD\�WKDW� WKH� UHJXODU� SUDFWLFH� RI� VRPH� UHOLJLRQ� LV� JRRG� IRU� RQH¶V�SV\FKRORJLFDO�KHDOWK�� ,Q�WKLV�FDVH�ZH�FRXOG�VD\�WKDW�WKHUH�LV�D�YDOXH��SV\FKRORJLFDO�KHDOWK��DQG�WKDW�WKH�UHOLJLRQ�LQ�TXHVWLRQ�SDUWDNHV�RI�WKLV�YDOXH�RU�KDV�D�VDOXWDU\�HIIHFW�LQ�DFKLHYLQJ WKLV�YDOXH��6RPH� IRUPDOLVP� ZLOO� KHOS� WR� DGG� SUHFLVLRQ� WR� WKH� W\SHV� RI� SOXUDOLVP� DQG�H[FOXVLYLVP�GLVFXVVHG��DQG�WR�VFDUH�DZD\� WKH�IDLQWKHDUWHG���7KH�PDLQ�SXUSRVH�RI�WKH�ORJLF� LV� QRW� WR� SURYH� VSHFLILF� WKHVHV� DERXW� SOXUDOLVP� DQG� H[FOXVLYLVP�� EXW� DV� DQ�LQVWUXPHQW� WR� KHOS� NHHS� WKH� YDULHWLHV� IURP� EHLQJ� OXPSHG� WRJHWKHU�� VR�� UXOHV� RI�LQIHUHQFH�DQG�RWKHU�QLFHWLHV�ZLOO�QRW�EH�LQWURGXFHG��7KH�IRUPDOLVP�LV�WKDW�RI�D�VWDQGDUG�VHFRQG� RUGHU� ORJLF� ZLWK� VHFRQG� RUGHU� TXDQWLILFDWLRQ� OLPLWHG WR�PRQDGLF� SUHGLFDWHV��4XDQWLILHUV� DUH� UHVWULFWHG� LQ� WKH�PDQQHU� VWLSXODWHG�ZLWK� WKH� LQWURGXFWLRQ� RI�GLIIHUHQW�NLQGV�RI�YDULDEOHV��8QERXQG�YDULDEOHV�DUH�XVHG�DV�FRQVWDQWV�7KH�FODLP�WKDW�D�UHOLJLRQ��U��LV�VXEMHFW�WR�D�IDYRUDEOH�HVWLPDWLRQ�GXH�WR�VRPH�YDOXH��9��ZLOO�EH� DEEUHYLDWHG�DV 9U��:H�PD\� WKHQ� IRUPXODWH�D�PLQLPDO� UHOLJLRXV�SOXUDOLVP��053��DV�IROORZV�053���U��Uc �UzUc����9�9U��9Uc�+HUH� ZH� OHW� U ZLWK� RU� ZLWKRXW� SULPHV� EH� XVHG� IRU� UHOLJLRQV� DQG�9 IRU� YDOXHV�� 7KH�GHILQLWLRQ� MXVW� VD\V� WKDW� WKHUH� DUH� DW� OHDVW� WZR� UHOLJLRQV� WKDW� VKDUH� VRPH�YDOXH�� ,� DP�WHPSWHG� WR� VD\� WKDW� QR� RQH� ZRXOG� GHQ\� PLQLPDO� UHOLJLRXV� SOXUDOLVP�� EXW� VLQFH�IDQDWLFLVP�LV�QRW�UDWLRQDO��FDXWLRQ� LV� WR�EH�DGYLVHG��:H�PD\��KRZHYHU��DVVHUW� WKDW�QR�RQH� FRXOG� UHDVRQDEO\� GHQ\� PLQLPDO� UHOLJLRXV� SOXUDOLVP �JLYHQ� WKH� IDLUO\� REYLRXV�DVVXPSWLRQV� WKDW� WKHUH� LV� PRUH� WKDQ� RQH� UHOLJLRQ�� DQG� WKDW� PRUH� WKDQ� RQH� LV� QRW�FRPSOHWHO\�GHYRLG�RI�DQ\�YDOXH���

Page 4: Plurality of Pluralisms

,Q�RUGHU� WR� JR�EH\RQG�PLQLPDO UHOLJLRXV�SOXUDOLVP WRZDUG�YHUVLRQV�RI�SOXUDOLVP�DERXW�ZKLFK�WKHUH�PD\�EH�UHDVRQDEOH�GLIIHUHQFHV�RI�RSLQLRQ��WZR�SDUDPHWHUV�PXVW�EH�VSHFLILHG�� ���� WKH� VRUW� RI� YDOXH� WR� EH� FRQVLGHUHG�� DQG� ���� WKH� VFRSH� RI� WKH� SOXUDOLW\�DWWDFKHG�WR�WKLV�YDOXH��7KHUH�DUH�DOO�VRUWV�RI�SRVLWLYH�VWDWXV�WKDW�FDQ�EH�FODLPHG�IRU�RQH�RU�PRUH�UHOLJLRQV��5HOLJLRQV�DUH�VDLG�WR�FRQWULEXWH�WR�PHQWDO�KHDOWK��WR�IDFLOLWDWH�VRFLDO�DUUDQJHPHQWV�� WR�OHDG�WR�VDOYDWLRQ��WR�EH�WUXH��WR�EH�RUGDLQHG�E\�*RG��WR�KDYH�D�ORQJ�DQG�ULFK�WUDGLWLRQ��DQG�PDQ\�RWKHU WKLQJV��,I� 9 LV� VRPH� YDOXH� WKDW� LV� FRQVLGHUHG� SDUWLFXODUO\� FUXFLDO� WR� D� UHOLJLRQ� E\� LWV�IROORZHUV� ZH�FRXOG�IRUPXODWH�D�PLQLPDO�UHOLJLRXV�SOXUDOLVP�ZLWK�UHVSHFW�WR�WKDW�YDOXH�DV�IROORZV�0539 ���U��Uc �UzUc����9 U��9 Uc�7KLV�PHUHO\� VD\V� WKDW� DW� OHDVW� WZR� UHOLJLRQV� KDYH� WKH� IDYRUHG� YDOXH��7KLV�� KRZHYHU��ZRXOG�EH�FRQVLVWHQW�ZLWK�DQ�HFXPHQLVP�WKDW�KROGV�WKDW�VDOYDWLRQ��IRU�H[DPSOH��FDQ�EH�JDLQHG� WKURXJK� YDULRXV� HYDQJHOLFDO� FKXUFKHV�� EXW� QRW� WKURXJK� WKH� &DWKROLF� &KXUFK��DQG� QRW� WKURXJK� -XGDLVP�� ,VODP�� +LQGXLVP� RU� %XGGKLVP�� 5HOLJLRXV� SOXUDOLVP� ZLWK�UHJDUG�WR�VDOYDWLRQ�LV�QRUPDOO\�XQGHUVWRRG�WR�DOORZ�WKDW DOO�WKH�PDMRU�IDLWK�WUDGLWLRQV�SURYLGH�DYHQXHV�WR�VDOYDWLRQ�539 ���U9 U6RPH�RI� WKH�SRVLWLYH� WKLQJV�VDLG�DERXW� UHOLJLRQV�PDNH�VSHFLILF� UHIHUHQFH� WR� WKHLU�DGKHUHQWV��ZKLOH�RWKHU�DWWULEXWLRQV�DSSO\�WR�WKH�GRFWULQHV��ULWXDOV�RU�KLVWRULFDO�IHDWXUHV�RI� UHOLJLRQV� ZLWKRXW� PDNLQJ� DQ\� FODLPV� DERXW� WKHLU� IROORZHUV�� )RU� H[DPSOH�� ZLWK�UHJDUG� WR� DGKHUHQWV� LW�KDV�EHHQ�FODLPHG� WKDW� VRPH� UHOLJLRQV�SURYLGH�D� IUDPHZRUN�RI�EHOLHIV�DQG�SUDFWLFHV�ZLWKLQ�ZKLFK�VRPH�WKHLU�IROORZHUV�KDYH�P\VWLFDO�H[SHULHQFHV�RI�YDULRXV�NLQGV��$ GLIIHUHQW�VRUW�RI�H[DPSOH�LV�WKH�FODLP�WKDW�WKH�DGKHUHQWV�RI�GLIIHUHQW�UHOLJLRQV� DUH� HQWLWOHG� WR� FHUWDLQ� ULJKWV�� H�J��� ULJKWV� RI� ZRUVKLS�� :LWK� UHJDUG� WR� WKH�FRQWHQW� RI� UHOLJLRQV� LW� LV� VDLG� WKDW� VRPH� UHOLJLRQV� SUHVFULEH� EHDXWLIXO� FHUHPRQLHV�� RI�VRPH�LW�LV�VDLG�WKDW�WKHLU�FUHHGV�DUH�WUXH��DQG�RI�VRPH�WKDW�WKH�UXOHV�WKH\�SUHVFULEH�DUH�PRUDOO\�FRPPHQGDEOH�$Q�LPSRUWDQW�ZD\�RI�VWRSSLQJ�VKRUW�RI�SOXUDOLVP�LV�WR�FODLP�WKDW�DOWKRXJK�HDFK�RI�VHYHUDO� UHOLJLRQV� KDV� VRPH� SDUWLFXODU� SRVLWLYH� VWDWXV�� WKH\� GR� QRW� KDYH� WKH� VWDWXV�HTXDOO\��)RU�H[DPSOH��D�%XGGKLVW�PLJKW�KROG�WKDW�DOO�WKH�PDMRU�UHOLJLRQV�RI�WKH�ZRUOG�SURYLGH�PHDQV�WR�REWDLQ�SHDFH�RI�PLQG��EXW�WKDW�WKH�PHDQV�SURYLGHG�E\�%XGGKLVP�LV�PRUH�HIILFLHQW��RU�OHDGV�WR�D�GHHSHU�VHQVH�RI�SHDFH�RI�PLQG��RU�EULQJV�TXLFNHU�RU�ORQJHU�

Page 5: Plurality of Pluralisms

ODVWLQJ�SHDFH�RI�PLQG��,�GRQ¶W�NQRZ�RI�D�QDPH�WKDW�DQ\RQH�KDV�JLYHQ�IRU� WKLV�VRUW�RI�SRVLWLRQ��DOWKRXJK�LW�KDV�EHHQ�KHOG�E\�PDQ\�SKLORVRSKHUV�DQG�WKHRORJLDQV��:H�PLJKW�FDOO�LW�GHJUHH�SOXUDOLVP��EXW�ZH�VKRXOG�NHHS�LQ�PLQG�WKDW�PDQ\�PRGHUQ�GHIHQGHUV��DV�ZHOO�DV�RSSRQHQWV��RI�UHOLJLRXV�SOXUDOLVP�ZRXOG�QRW�FDOO�WKLV�D�IRUP�RI�SOXUDOLVP�DW�DOO��7KH\�GHILQH�SOXUDOLVP�LQ�WHUPV�RI�D�VWULFW�HTXDOLW\ RI�VWDWXV��3HWHU�%\UQH��IRU�H[DPSOH�GHILQHV�UHOLJLRXV�SOXUDOLVP�DV�D�WKUHH�SDUW�FODLP�����$OO�PDMRU�UHOLJLRXV�WUDGLWLRQV�DUH�HTXDO�LQ�UHVSHFW�RI�PDNLQJ�FRPPRQ�UHIHUHQFH�WR�D�VLQJOH�WUDQVFHQGHQW��VDFUHG�UHDOLW\�����$OO�PDMRU� WUDGLWLRQV�DUH� OLNHZLVH� HTXDO� LQ� UHVSHFW�RI�RIIHULQJ� VRPH�PHDQV�RU�RWKHU�WR�KXPDQ�VDOYDWLRQ����� $OO� PDMRU� WUDGLWLRQV� DUH� HTXDO� LQ� WKHLU� LQDELOLW\� WR� SURYLGH� D� QRUP� IRU�LQWHUSUHWLQJ� WKH�RWKHUV�� DQG�RIIHU� OLPLWHG�� UHYLVDEOH�DFFRXQWV�RI� WKH�QDWXUH�RI� WKH�VDFUHG��%\UQH¶V�SRVLWLRQ�PLJKW�EH�GHVFULEHG�DV�D�NLQG�RI�HTXDOLW\�SOXUDOLVP��DV�RSSRVHG�WR�GHJUHH�SOXUDOLVP��:H�PLJKW� DEEUHYLDWH� WKH� FODLP WKDW� UHOLJLRQV� U�DQG� Uc DUH� HTXDO� LQ� WKH�GHJUHH� WR�ZKLFK� WKH\� KDYH� WKH YDOXH� 9� DV� G�9U� G�9Uc�� 0LQLPDO� HTXDOLW\� SOXUDOLVP� �0(3��FRXOG�WKHQ�EH�GHILQHG�DV�IROORZV�0(3���U��Uc �UzUc����9�G�9U� G�9Uc�z���%\UQH¶V� HTXDOLW\� SOXUDOLVP� PHQWLRQHG� DERYH� LV� DFWXDOO\� D� IRUP� RI� HTXDOLW\�SOXUDOLVP�GHILQHG�ZLWK�UHIHUHQFH�WR�WKUHH�VSHFLILF�YDOXHV��EXW�ZLWK�WKH�UHOLJLRQV�EHLQJ�UHVWULFWHG� WR� WKH� ³PDMRU� WUDGLWLRQV´�� 6R��%\UQH¶V� HTXDOLW\� SOXUDOLVP� �%(3�� VWLSXODWHV�WKDW�IRU�DQ\�U�DQG�Uc��LI�HDFK�RI�WKHP�LV�D�PDMRU�WUDGLWLRQ��07���WKHQ�ZLWK�UHVSHFW�WR�WKH�YDOXHV�PHQWLRQHG� LQ� KLV� WKUHH� FODXVHV� �9���9���9���� ERWK� U�DQG� Uc ZLOO� KDYH� DOO� WKUHH�YDOXHV�WR�WKH�VDPH�SRVLWLYH�GHJUHH�%(3�� �U�Uc��07U� 07Uc�o�G�9�U� G�9�Uc�z�� G�9�U� G�9�Uc�z�� �G�9�U� G�9�Uc�z��,W�ZRXOG�VHHP�WR�EH�DQ�XQOLNHO\�FRLQFLGHQFH�LI�DOO�WKH�PDMRU�UHOLJLRQV�FRLQFLGHG�RQ�WKHVH�WKUHH�YDOXHV��UHIHUULQJ�WR�D�WUDQVFHQGHQW�UHDOLW\��RIIHULQJ�D�ZD\�WR�VDOYDWLRQ��DQG�

� 6HH� 3HWHU� %\UQH��3UROHJRPHQD� WR� 5HOLJLRXV� 3OXUDOLVP�� 5HIHUHQFH� DQG� 5HDOLVP� LQ� 5HOLJLRQ �1HZ�<RUN�� 6W�� 0DUWLQ¶V� 3UHVV�� ������� ���� ,� KDYH� FKDQJHG� WKH� ZRUGLQJ� RI� WKH� WKLUG� FODXVH� WR� VWUHVV� WKH�HTXDOLW\�FRQGLWLRQ�

Page 6: Plurality of Pluralisms

JLYLQJ�QRUPV�DQG�DQ�DFFRXQW�RI�WKH�VDFUHG��2QH�FRXOG�VWLOO�EH�DQ�HTXDOLW\�SOXUDOLVW�E\�KROGLQJ�WKDW�WKH�DYHUDJH�GHJUHH�RI�WKH�YDOXHV�RI�DOO�WKH�PDMRU�UHOLJLRQV�DUH�WKH�VDPH��2QH�PLJKW�EH�EHWWHU�DW�VDOYDWLRQ��DQG�DQRWKHU�DW�QRUPV��DQG�DQRWKHU�DW�GHVFULELQJ�WKH�VDFUHG��EXW�RQ�DYHUDJH�� WKH�PHULWV�DQG�GHILFLHQFLHV�RI�HDFK�DYHUDJH�RXW� WR� WKH�H[DFW�VDPH�YDOXH��:KLOH�WKLV�VRUW�RI�YLHZ�ZRXOG�EH�PRUH�SODXVLEOH�WKDQ�%(3��LW�VWLOO�VHHPV�WR� UHTXLUH�D� OHDS�RI� IDLWK��:K\�VKRXOG�ZH�H[SHFW� WKH�DYHUDJH�YDOXH�RI�DOO� WKH�PDMRU�WUDGLWLRQV� WR�EH�H[DFWO\� WKH�VDPH"�,W�ZRXOG�EH�DQRWKHU� WKLQJ� WR�VD\� WKDW�DQ� LPSDUWLDO�REVHUYHU� VXEMHFW� WR� FHUWDLQ� UHVWULFWLRQV� RU� OLPLWHG� LQIRUPDWLRQ�PLJKW�EH� LQFDSDEOH�RI�GHFLGLQJ� ZKLFK� RI� FRPSHWLQJ� WUDGLWLRQV� KDV� JUHDWHU� DYHUDJH� YDOXH�� EXW� ZH� ZLOO�H[DPLQH�WKLV�HSLVWHPRORJLFDO�YHUVLRQ�RI�UHOLJLRXV�SOXUDOLVP�LQ�JUHDWHU�GHWDLO�EHORZ�0(3 LV�D�QRW�UHDOO\�D VWURQJHU�FODLP�WKDQ�053��EHFDXVH�IRU�DQ\�YDOXH�9 ZH�FRXOG�GHILQH�DQ�DEVROXWH�YHUVLRQ�RI�WKLV�YDOXH� 9c� DV�IROORZV�9cU�LI�DQG�RQO\�LI�G�9U�!��$�GHJUHH�SOXUDOLVP��'3��ZLWK�UHVSHFW�WR�VRPH�YDOXH�9�FRXOG�EH�GHILQHG�E\�VD\LQJ�WKDW�WKHUH�DUH�D�SOXUDOLW\�RI�UHOLJLRQV�HDFK�RI�ZKLFK�KDV�WKH�YDOXH�9�LQ�H[FHVV�RI�GHJUHH�Q���+HUH�DQG�LQ�ZKDW�IROORZV�ZH�FDQ�FRQVLGHU�U WR�UDQJH�RYHU�VRPH�FODVV�RI�UHOLJLRQV��VXFK�DV�%\UQH¶V�³PDMRU�WUDGLWLRQV´�ZLWK�UHVSHFW�WR�ZKLFK�FODLPV�RI�UHOLJLRXV�SOXUDOLVP�DUH�GHEDWHG���:H�DEEUHYLDWH�WKH�FODLP�WKDW�U�KDV�YDOXH�9�H[FHHGLQJ GHJUHH�Q��G�9U�!Q�'3���U��Uc �UzUc���G�9U�!Q �G�9Uc�!Q�:KHWKHU�RU�QRW�RQH DGPLWV WR�D�GHJUHH�SOXUDOLVP�ZLWK�UHVSHFW�WR�D�JLYHQ�YDOXH�IRU�D�YDULHW\�RI�UHOLJLRQV��RQH�PD\�KROG�WKDW�D�XQLTXH IDYRUHG�UHOLJLRQ��U ��KDV�WKLV�YDOXH�WR� D� GHJUHH� QRW�PDWFKHG� E\� DQ\� RWKHU� UHOLJLRQ�� 7KLV� FRXOG� EH� FRQVLGHUHG� D� NLQG� RI�UHOLJLRXV� H[FOXVLYLVP�� 7KLV� VRUW� RI� FODLP PD\� EH� FRQVLGHUHG� D� YHUVLRQ� RI� GHJUHH�H[FOXVLYLVP �'(��� WKH�YLHZ� WKDW�D� IDYRUHG UHOLJLRQ�KDV� VXSHULRULW\� WR�DOO�RWKHUV ZLWK�UHVSHFW�WR�WKH�YDOXH�9��DQG�LW�FRXOG�EH�IRUPXODWHG�DV�IROORZV�'(��G�9U �!Q �a�U�G�9UtG�9U ���7KLV�VD\V�WKDW�RQH¶V�IDYRUHG�UHOLJLRQ��U H[FHHGV�VRPH�GHJUHH�RI�WKH�YDOXH�9 XQGHU�FRQVLGHUDWLRQ��DQG�WKDW�WKHUH�LV�QR�UHOLJLRQ�WKDW�H[FHHGV�RU�HTXDOV�WKH�GHJUHH�WR�ZKLFK�U �SRVVHVVHV�9� '(�DQG�'3� DUH� FRPSDWLEOH�� WKDW� LV�� RQH� FRXOG� KROG� WKDW� WKHUH� DUH� D�YDULHW\�RI�UHOLJLRQV�WKDW�H[FHHG�D�VWDQGDUG�GHJUHH�RI�YDOXH��DOWKRXJK�RQH�UHOLJLRQ�KDV�WKDW�YDOXH�WR�D�JUHDWHU�GHJUHH�WKDQ�DQ\�RWKHU��7KLV�PD\�EH�IRUPXODWHG�DV�IROORZV�'( ��'3��G�9U �!Q �U���UzU ���G�9U�!Q���a�U�G�9UtG�9U ���

Page 7: Plurality of Pluralisms

7KH�IDYRUHG�UHOLJLRQ�H[FHHGV�WKH�VWDQGDUG�GHJUHH�RI�YDOXH�9��DQRWKHU�UHOLJLRQ�DOVR�H[FHHGV� WKLV� VWDQGDUG�� EXW� QR� UHOLJLRQ� KDV�9� WR� DQ� HTXDO� RU� JUHDWHU� GHJUHH� WKDQ� WKH�IDYRUHG�UHOLJLRQ�$�PRUH�VXEVWDQWLYH�IRUP�RI�GHJUHH�SOXUDOLVP��6'3��WKDW�UHPDLQV�FRQVLVWHQW�ZLWK�'(�FRXOG�EH�IRUPXODWHG�E\�VWLSXODWLQJ�WKDW�IRU�VRPH�VWDQGDUG�GHJUHH�RI�YDOXH��Q��DOOWKH�PDMRU�UHOLJLRQV�KDYH�WKH�YDOXH��RU�YDOXHV��LQ�TXHVWLRQ�WR�D�GHJUHH�VXUSDVVLQJ�Q�6'3���U G�9U�!Q�(YHQ�LI�DOO� WKH�PDMRU� UHOLJLRQV�PHHW� WKH�VDPH�YDOXH�VWDQGDUGV�� LW�FRXOG�VWLOO�EH�WKH�FDVH�WKDW�RQH�RI�WKHP�IDU�RXWVKLQHV�WKH�RWKHUV��7KLV�ZRXOG�VHHP�WR�FKDUDFWHUL]H�WKH�YLHZ�RI�,EQ�µ$UDEL �����±������ZKR�ZURWH��$OO� WKH� UHYHDOHG� UHOLJLRQV� >VKDUDµL@� DUH� OLJKWV�� $PRQJ� WKHVH� UHOLJLRQV�� WKH�UHYHDOHG�UHOLJLRQ�RI�0XKDPPDG�LV�OLNH�WKH�OLJKW�RI�WKH�VXQ�DPRQJ�WKH�OLJKWV�RI�WKH� VWDUV��:KHQ� WKH� VXQ� DSSHDUV�� WKH� OLJKWV� RI� WKH� VWDUV� DUH� KLGGHQ�� DQG� WKHLU�OLJKWV� DUH� LQFOXGHG� LQ� WKH� OLJKW� RI� WKH� VXQ�� 7KHLU� EHLQJ� KLGGHQ� LV� OLNH� WKH�DEURJDWLRQ� RI� WKH� RWKHU� UHYHDOHG� UHOLJLRQV�� WKDW� WDNHV� SODFH� WKURXJK�0XKDPPDG¶V�UHYHDOHG�UHOLJLRQ��1HYHUWKHOHVV�� WKH\�GR� LQ� IDFW�H[LVW�� MXVW�DV� WKH�H[LVWHQFH�RI�WKH�OLJKW�RI�WKH�VWDUV�LV�DFWXDOL]HG��7KLV�H[SODLQV�ZK\�ZH�KDYH�EHHQ�UHTXLUHG� LQ� RXU� DOO�LQFOXVLYH� UHOLJLRQ� WR� KDYH� IDLWK� LQ� WKH� WUXWK� RI� DOO� WKH�PHVVHQJHUV�DQG�DOO�WKH�UHYHDOHG�UHOLJLRQV��7KH\�DUH�QRW�UHQGHUHG�QXOO��EDWLO��E\�DEURJDWLRQ�² WKDW�LV�WKH�RSLQLRQ�RI�WKH�LJQRUDQW��-XVW� DV� ZH� GHILQHG� DQ� DOPRVW� WULYLDO� YHUVLRQ� RI� UHOLJLRXV� SOXUDOLVP� �053��� ZH�FRXOG� DOVR� GHILQH� D� PLQLPDO� YHUVLRQ� RI� UHOLJLRXV� H[FOXVLYLVP� �05(��� DFFRUGLQJ� WR�ZKLFK�WKHUH�LV�DW�OHDVW�RQH�YDOXH�WKDW�WKH�IDYRUHG�UHOLJLRQ�SRVVHVVHV�XQLTXHO\�05(���9�9U ��U�9UoU U ���7KLV�VD\V�WKDW�WKH�IDYRUHG�UHOLJLRQ�KDV�VRPH�YDOXH�WKDW�QR�RWKHU�UHOLJLRQ�KDV��L�H���WKDW�IRU�DQ\�UHOLJLRQ��LI�LW�KDV�WKLV�YDOXH��WKHQ�LW�LV�WKH�IDYRUHG�RQH���-XVW�DV�053�DQG�0(3�DUH�HTXLYDOHQW��DV�ORQJ�DV�ZH�FDQ�GHILQH�RXU�YDOXHV�DV�ZH�OLNH���VR�WRR��PLQLPDO�UHOLJLRXV� H[FOXVLYLVP� LV� HTXLYDOHQW� WR� ZKDW� PLJKW� EH� FDOOHG� PLQLPDO� VXSHULRULW\�H[FOXVLYLVP��06(��06(���9�U�UzU oG9U !G9U��2EYLRXVO\��05(� LPSOLHV�06(�� EHFDXVH� LI� U �KDV� D� YDOXH� WKDW� QR� RWKHU� UHOLJLRQ�KDV�� WKHQ� LW� KDV� WKDW� YDOXH� WR� D� GHJUHH� JUHDWHU� WKDQ� WKDW� RI� DQ\� RWKHU� UHOLJLRQ��06(�LPSOLHV�05(�EHFDXVH�LI�U KDV�D�GHJUHH�Q�RI�9 WKDW�LV�QRW�PDWFKHG�RU�H[FHHGHG�E\�DQ\�� )XWXKDW��,,,����������WUDQVODWHG�LQ�:LOOLDP�&KLWWLFN�� ,PDJLQDO�:RUOGV��,EQ�DO�µ$UDEL�DQG�WKH�3UREOHP�RI�5HOLJLRXV�'LYHUVLW\���$OEDQ\��681<�3UHVV�������������

Page 8: Plurality of Pluralisms

RWKHU�UHOLJLRQ��ZH�PD\�GHILQH�DQRWKHU�YDOXH�9c VXFK�WKDW�9cU LI�DQG�RQO\�LI�G9UtQ��DQG�WKHQ�9c ZLOO�VDWLVI\�WKH�GHILQLWLRQ�RI�05(�,W�LV�QRW�SODXVLEOH�WR�GHQ\�05(�DQG�06(��(DFK�UHOLJLRQ�WKDW�KDV�DQ\�YDOXH�DW�DOO�SUREDEO\�KDV�LWV�RZQ�XQLTXH�YDOXHV��5HFDOO�WKDW�YDOXH�LV�WR�EH�XQGHUVWRRG�KHUH�DV�WKDW�LQ�YLUWXH�RI�ZKLFK�DQ\�SRVLWLYH�DWWULEXWLRQ�LV�PDGH�DERXW�D�UHOLJLRQ��2QH�PLJKW�KROG�WKDW� D� JLYHQ� UHOLJLRQ� LV� YDOXDEOH� EHFDXVH� RI� WKH� KRO\� GD\V� RU� FHUHPRQLHV� WKDW� DUH�XQLTXH�WR�WKDW�UHOLJLRQ��,Q�RUGHU�WR�JR�EH\RQG�VXFK�HPSW\�IRUPDOLVP��RQH�PXVW�PRYH�EH\RQG�WKHVH�FRQVLGHUDWLRQV�WR�H[DPLQH�VSHFLILF�YDOXHV�DQG�WKHLU�PHULWV�$V�PHQWLRQHG� HDUOLHU�� %\UQH� GRHV� QRW� VSHDN� RI� WKH� HTXDOLW\� RI� UHOLJLRQV�� EXW� RI�UHOLJLRXV� WUDGLWLRQV�� 7KH� GLIIHUHQFH� FDQ� EH� FUXFLDO�� )RU�0XVOLPV�� UHOLJLRQ�� RU�GvQ�� LV�ZKDW�*RG�KDV�UHYHDOHG�WR�JXLGH�XV�WR�+LP��5HOLJLRXV�WUDGLWLRQV��KRZHYHU��LQFOXGH�DOO�VRUWV� RI� WKLQJV� WKDW� KXPDQV� KDYH� JDWKHUHG� LQ� WKHLU� DWWHPSWV� WR� IROORZ� UHOLJLRQ��2QH�PLJKW�EH�DQ�HTXDOLW\�SOXUDOLVW�DERXW�UHOLJLRXV�WUDGLWLRQV��ZLWK�UHJDUG�WR�VRPH�VSHFLILF�YDOXH��ZKLOH� WDNLQJ� D�PRUH� H[FOXVLYLVW� YLHZ�DERXW� UHOLJLRQV�� WKDW� LV�� RQH� FRXOG�KROG�WKDW�*RG¶V�JXLGDQFH�IRU�PDQ�LV�WR�EH�IRXQG�LQ�D�VLQJOH�UHOLJLRQ��EXW�WKDW�WKH�UHOLJLRXV�WUDGLWLRQV� RI� PDQNLQG� IDOO� VR� IDU� VKRUW� RI� ZKDW� *RG� RIIHUV� XV� WKDW� QRQH� RI� WKHVH�PDQPDGH�WUDGLWLRQV�FDQ�EH�VDLG�WR�EH�DQ\�EHWWHU�WKDQ�DQ\�RI�WKH�RWKHUV��2Q�WKH�RWKHU�KDQG�� RQH� FRXOG� WDNH� WKH� UHYHUVH� VRUW� RI� SRVLWLRQ� DQG� KROG� WKDW� DOWKRXJK� *RG� KDV�UHYHDOHG�VHYHUDO�GLVWLQFW�IRUPV�RI�JXLGDQFH�IRU�KXPDQ�EHLQJV��VR�WKDW�WKHUH�DUH�VHYHUDO�WUXH� DQG� GLYLQHO\� UHYHDOHG� UHOLJLRQV�� WKH� IROORZHUV� RI� DOO� EXW� RQH� RI� WKHVH� UHOLJLRQV�KDYH� JRQH� DVWUD\� E\� DGGLQJ� DQG� VXEWUDFWLQJ� WR� DQG� IURP� GLYLQH� JXLGDQFH� LQ� WKHLU�FXPXODWLYH�WUDGLWLRQV��ZKLOH WKHUH�LV�RQH�UHOLJLRXV�WUDGLWLRQ�WKDW�KDV�UHPDLQHG�IDLWKIXO�WR�GLYLQH�JXLGDQFH� LQ�D�PDQQHU�VXSHULRU� WR� WKH�RWKHU�PDMRU� UHOLJLRXV� WUDGLWLRQV�� ,�GR�QRW�LQWHQG�WR�GHIHQG�HLWKHU�RI�WKHVH�SRVLWLRQV��EXW�WKH�GLIIHUHQFH�EHWZHHQ�WKHP�QHHGV�WR�EH�NHSW�FOHDU�ZKHQ�ZH�DWWHPSW�WR�HYDOXDWH�UHOLJLRXV�SOXUDOLVP�%HIRUH�ZH�GHFLGH�ZKHWKHU�WR�EH�LQ�IDYRU�RI�UHOLJLRXV�SOXUDOLVP�RU�QRW��ZH�KDYH�WR�GHWHUPLQH�H[DFWO\�ZKDW�YDOXH LV�EHLQJ� DWWULEXWHG� WR�ZKDW�PXOWLSOLFLW\�RI� UHOLJLRQV�RU�UHOLJLRXV�WUDGLWLRQV��$OWKRXJK�SHRSOH�KDYH�VDLG�VRPH�SUHWW\�VLOO\�WKLQJV�DERXW�UHOLJLRQ��QR�RQH�ZRXOG�UHDVRQDEO\�DJUHH�WR DEVROXWH�UHOLJLRXV�SOXUDOLVP��$53���WKDW�LV��QR�RQH�KDV�HYHU�FODLPHG�WKDW�DQ\WKLQJ�JRRG�WKDW�FDQ�EH�VDLG�RI�DQ\�UHOLJLRQ�FDQ�EH�VDLG�RI�DOO�RI�WKHP��ZLWK�D�IHZ�LPSRUWDQW�H[FHSWLRQV��6RPH�DWKHLVWV�FRQWHQG�WKDW�WKLV�LV�YDFXRXVO\�WUXH�RI�DOO�UHOLJLRQV��6RPH�UHOLJLRXV�EHOLHYHUV�GHILQH�UHOLJLRQ DQG�UHOLJLRXV LQ�VXFK�DQ�

Page 9: Plurality of Pluralisms

H[FOXVLYH� PDQQHU� WKDW� WKH\� FRQWHQG� WKDW� WKHUH� LV� RQO\� RQH� UHOLJLRQ� DQG� RQO\� RQH�UHOLJLRXV�WUDGLWLRQ��DQG�VR�ZRXOG�DJUHH�WKDW�ZKDWHYHU�LV�JRRG�DERXW�RQH�LV�JRRG�DERXW�DOO� UHOLJLRQV�� MXVW� EHFDXVH� WKH\� WKLQN� WKHUH� DUH�QR�RWKHUV��2WKHU�SHRSOH�ZLWK� D�PXFK�PRUH�HPEUDFLYH�DWWLWXGH�UHDFK�WKH�VDPH�FRQFOXVLRQ�E\�KROGLQJ�WKDW�WKHUH�LV�RQO\�RQH�UHOLJLRQ��ZKLFK� LQFOXGHV� DOO� RI�ZKDW� DUH� FRPPRQO\� FDOOHG� ³UHOLJLRQV´� DQG� RQO\� RQH�UHOLJLRXV� WUDGLWLRQ�� ZKLFK� LV� WKH� UHOLJLRXV� KHULWDJH� RI� DOO� PDQNLQG��0RVW� UHDVRQDEOH�SHRSOH�� KRZHYHU�� ZLOO� DJUHH� WKDW� YDULRXV� JRRG� WKLQJV� FDQ� EH� VDLG� DERXW� GLIIHUHQW�UHOLJLRQV� DQG� DERXW� GLIIHUHQW� UHOLJLRXV� WUDGLWLRQV�� 7KH\� ZLOO� GLIIHU� DERXW� ZKDW� JRRG�WKLQJV�FDQ�DQG�FDQQRW�EH�VDLG�DERXW�WKHP��,PSODXVLEOH�DEVROXWH�UHOLJLRXV�SOXUDOLVP�PD\�EH�IRUPXODWHG�DV�IROORZV��$53����9�U�Uc�9Uo9Uc�ZKLFK�LV�HTXLYDOHQW�WR��9�U�Uc�G�9U� G�9Uc���*LYHQ�WKH�DVVXPSWLRQ�WKDW�WKHUH�DUH�DW�OHDVW�WZR�UHOLJLRQV��05(�LPSOLHV�WKH�GHQLDO�RI�$53� ,I�$53�LV� WUXH��DOO�UHOLJLRQV�KDYH� WKH�VDPH�YDOXHV��VR�� LI�DQ\� UHOLJLRQV�KDYH�DQ\� YDOXHV�� DQG� WKHUH� DUH� DW� OHDVW� WZR� UHOLJLRQV�� WKHUH�ZLOO� QRW� EH� DQ\� YDOXH� WKDW� LV�SRVVHVVHG�H[FOXVLYHO\�E\� MXVW�RQH�UHOLJLRQ��6R�$53�LPSOLHV�D�GHQLDO�RI�05(��JLYHQ�SODXVLEOH�DVVXPSWLRQV�2QH� FRXOG� DOVR�GHILQH� DQ� LPSODXVLEOH� DEVROXWH� UHOLJLRXV� H[FOXVLYLVP� �$5(�� WKDW�XQGHU�SODXVLEOH�DVVXPSWLRQV�LV�LQFRPSDWLEOH�ZLWK�PLQLPDO�UHOLJLRXV�SOXUDOLVP�$5(���U�9�9UoU U � ��9�9U �7KLV�VD\V�WKDW�DQ\�UHOLJLRQ�WKDW�KDV�DQ\�YDOXH�ZLOO�EH�WKH�IDYRUHG�UHOLJLRQ��DQG�WKDW�WKHUH� LV� VRPH� YDOXH� WKDW� WKH� IDYRUHG� UHOLJLRQ� GRHV� KDYH��$5(� LPSOLHV� WKDW�053� LV�IDOVH�� DQG� VLQFH�053� LV� SODXVLEOH��$5(� LV� LPSODXVLEOH��7KH� GHQLDO�RI�$5(� LPSOLHV�035�XQGHU�WKH�DVVXPSWLRQ�WKDW�WKH�IDYRUHG�UHOLJLRQ�GRHV�KDYH�VRPH�YDOXH�:H�PLJKW�VWUHQJWKHQ�PLQLPDO�UHOLJLRXV�SOXUDOLVP�WR�VWDWH�QRW�PHUHO\�WKDW�WKHUH�DUH�GLIIHUHQW� UHOLJLRQV� ZLWK� VKDUHG� SRVLWLYH� FKDUDFWHULVWLFV� RU� YDOXHV�� EXW� WKDW� WKHUH� DUH�UHOLJLRQV�RWKHU� WKDQ� WKH� IDYRUHG� UHOLJLRQ� WKDW�VKDUH�YDOXHV�ZLWK� LW��7KLV� LV�VWLOO�SUHWW\�XQFRQWURYHUVLDO���9�U�UzU ��9U� 9U �:H�DUULYH�DW�D�PRUH�UREXVW�YHUVLRQ�RI�SOXUDOLVP��553��LI�ZH�DUH�ZLOOLQJ�WR�DOORZ�WKDW�DQ\�YDOXH�WKDW�WKH�IDYRUHG�UHOLJLRQ�KDV�LV�VKDUHG�ZLWK�DQRWKHU�UHOLJLRQ�553���9�9U o�U�UzU ��9U��

Page 10: Plurality of Pluralisms

��

,�GRQ¶W�WKLQN�LW�LV�YHU\�OLNHO\�WKDW�WKLV�YHUVLRQ�RI�UHOLJLRXV�SOXUDOLVP�ZLOO�EH�ZLGHO\�DFFHSWHG��EHFDXVH�EHOLHYHUV�JHQHUDOO\�KROG�WKDW�WKHLU�RZQ�WUDGLWLRQV�KDYH�VRPH�XQLTXH�YDOXDEOH� IHDWXUHV�� HYHQ� LI� WKH\� DUH� SOXUDOLVWV� 3URI�� %\UQH REVHUYHV�� ³:H� VKRXOG� EH�FOHDU�IURP�WKH�RXWVHW�WKDW�SOXUDOLVP�LV�QRW�DV�VXFK�FRPPLWWHG�WR�VD\LQJ�WKDW�DOO�PDMRU�UHOLJLRQV� DUH� HTXDO� LQ� HYHU\� DVSHFW� RI� FRJQLWLYH� HQGHDYRXU�����´� %\UQH� FODLPV� WKDW�ZKDW� LV� UHTXLUHG� E\� UHOLJLRXV� SOXUDOLVP� LV� WKH� WKUHH� SDUW� HTXDOLW\� FODLP� PHQWLRQHG�DERYH��ZKLOH�UHODWLYH�VXSHULRULW\�LQ�RWKHU�UHVSHFWV�PD\�EH�DOORZHG��2WKHU�DGYRFDWHV�RI�UHOLJLRXV� SOXUDOLVP� KDYH� GHILQHG� WKHLU� YHUVLRQV� RI� SOXUDOLVP� ZLWK� UHJDUG� WR� RWKHU�IHDWXUHV��-RKQ�+LFN��IRU�H[DPSOH��SODFHV�FRQVLGHUDEO\�PRUH�HPSKDVLV� WKDQ�%\UQH�RQ�WKH�PRUDO�IXQFWLRQ�RI�UHOLJLRQ�� ZKLOH�)ULWMRI�6FKXRQ�FRQWHQGV�WKDW�WKH�WUDQVFHQGHQWDO�XQLW\�RI�UHOLJLRQV�LV�WR�EH�IRXQG�LQ�WKHLU�HVRWHULF�GLPHQVLRQV�� $OO�RI�WKHP��KRZHYHU��VHHP�WR�IDYRU�D�IRUP�RI�HTXDOLW\�SOXUDOLVP�$�PRUH�UHDVRQDEOH�IRUP�RI�SOXUDOLVP�ZRXOG�EH�RQH�EDVHG�RQ�6'3��GHILQHG�HDUOLHU�WR� VWDWH�PHUHO\� WKDW�DOO� WKH� UHOLJLRQV�XQGHU� FRQVLGHUDWLRQ�H[FHHG�VRPH�VWDQGDUG�ZLWK�UHVSHFW�WR�VRPH�VHOHFWLRQ�RI�YDOXHV��,9��3OXUDOLVPV�'LYLGHG�E\�6HYHQ�7\SHV�RI�9DOXH2IWHQ��ZKHQ� UHOLJLRXV�SOXUDOLVP� LV�GLVFXVVHG�� WKH�YDOXH DWWULEXWHG� WR� D�YDULHW\�RI�UHOLJLRQV� LV� OHIW� VRPHZKDW� YDJXH�� :RUVH� WKDQ� WKLV� LV� HTXLYRFDWLRQ� WKDW� EHJLQV� E\�SRLQWLQJ�RXW�VRPH�FRPPRQ�IHDWXUH�DPRQJ�UHOLJLRQV�DQG�FRQFOXGHV�ZLWK�WKH�FODLP�WKDW�WKH�UHOLJLRQV�DUH�DOO�WKH�VDPH�LQ�UHODWLRQ�WR�VRPH�RWKHU�IHDWXUH��,Q�RUGHU�WR�DYRLG�WKLV�VRUW�RI�IDOODF\��DW�OHDVW�WKH�IROORZLQJ�VHYHQ�VRUWV�RI�SOXUDOLVP�VKRXOG�EH�GLVWLQJXLVKHG��2WKHU�GLPHQVLRQV�RI�UHOLJLRXV�SOXUDOLVP�FRXOG�DOVR�EH�GHILQHG��EXW�WKH�IROORZLQJ�VHHP�PRUH�SHUWLQHQW�WR�FRQWHPSRUDU\�GLVFXVVLRQV�RI�UHOLJLRXV�SOXUDOLVP�

��� 6RWHULRORJLFDO� UHOLJLRXV� SOXUDOLVP �653�� LV� GHILQHG� LQ� WHUPV� RI� VDOYDWLRQ��$FFRUGLQJ�WR�DQ�HTXDOLW\�VRWHULRORJLFDO�SOXUDOLVP��D�SOXUDOLW\�RI�UHOLJLRQV�DUH�HTXDOO\�HIIHFWLYH�LQ�JXLGLQJ�SHRSOH�WR�VDOYDWLRQ��$�GHJUHH�SOXUDOLVW�LQ�WKLV�UHJDUG�ZRXOG�KROG�WKDW�SHRSOH�PD\�EH�JXLGHG�WR�VDOYDWLRQ�WKURXJK�D�SOXUDOLW\�RI�UHOLJLRQV��DOWKRXJK�VRPH�� %\UQH������������ 7KH� GHILQLWLYH� VWDWHPHQW� RI� +LFN¶V� YLHZ� LV� VSHOOHG� RXW� LQ� KLV�$Q� ,QWHUSUHWDWLRQ� RI� 5HOLJLRQ��1HZ�+DYHQ��<DOH�8QLYHUVLW\�3UHVV��������� )ULWKMRI� 6FKXRQ�� 7KH� 7UDQVFHQGHQWDO� 8QLW\� RI� 5HOLJLRQV�� UHYLVHG� HGLWLRQ�� �1HZ� <RUN�� +DUSHU�7RUFKERRNV��������

Page 11: Plurality of Pluralisms

��

ZD\V�ZLOO�EH�PRUH�HIIHFWLYH�WKDQ�RWKHUV��HLWKHU�E\�SURYLGLQJ�JXLGDQFH�WKDW�LV�HDVLHU�WR�IROORZ��RU�WKDW�OHDGV�WR�D�KLJKHU�GHJUHH�RI�VDOYDWLRQ��RU�WKDW�LV�PRUH�VXLWDEOH�WR�JXLGH�D�JUHDWHU� QXPEHU� RI� SHRSOH�� RU� E\� VRPH� RWKHU� FULWHULRQ� FRXOG� EH� MXGJHG� VXSHULRU� LQ�EULQJLQJ�SHRSOH�WR�VDOYDWLRQ�653�PD\�EH�GHILQHG�DV�D�YHUVLRQ�RI�'3��'3653��VLPSO\�E\�OHWWLQJ�9�VWDQG�IRU�WKH�YDOXH� RI� OHDGLQJ� WR� VDOYDWLRQ�� '3653� VWDWHV� WKDW� WKHUH� LV� VRPH� VWDQGDUG� GHJUHH� RI�JXLGDQFH�WR�VDOYDWLRQ�WKDW�DW�OHDVW�WZR�GLIIHUHQW�UHOLJLRQV�VXUSDVV� $�VWURQJHU�IRUP�RI�653�ZRXOG�UHVXOW�IURP�LWV�FRPELQDWLRQ�ZLWK�6'3�WR�VWDWH�WKDW�DOO�WKH�PDMRU�UHOLJLRQV�SDVV� D� FHUWDLQ� VWDQGDUG� LQ� WKH� DELOLW\� WR� JXLGH� SHRSOH� WR� VDOYDWLRQ� 7KLV� ZRXOG� EH�FRQVLVWHQW�ZLWK�D�PRGHUDWH�H[FOXVLYLVP��WR�WKH�H[WHQW�WKDW�PLJKW�FODLP�WKDW�RQH¶V�RZQ�UHOLJLRQ�LV�PRUH�HIIHFWLYH�DW�OHDGLQJ�WR�VDOYDWLRQ�WKDQ�RWKHUV�$�ZRUG�RI�FDXWLRQ�LV�UHTXLUHG�KHUH�ZLWK�UHJDUG�WR�DLPV�DQG�JRDOV��1RW�DOO�RI� WKH�PDMRU� UHOLJLRXV� WUDGLWLRQV� DLP� DW� ZKDW� &KULVWLDQV� FDOO� ³VDOYDWLRQ´�� 2QH� PLJKW� ILQG�DQDORJXHV� LQ� RWKHU� UHOLJLRQV� WR� VDOYDWLRQ�� VXFK� DV� QLUYDQD�� EXW LW� ZRXOG� EH� D JUDYH�PLVWDNH� WR�SXW� WKHP�RQ�D�SDU��$�%XGGKLVW�PLJKW� DJUHH� WKDW�&KULVWLDQLW\��E\� LWV� RZQ�OLJKWV��SURYLGHV�D�EHWWHU�YHKLFOH�WR�VDOYDWLRQ�WKDQ�%XGGKLVP�SURYLGHV�LWV�DGKHUHQWV�WR�QLUYDQD��%XW� WKH�%XGGKLVW�PLJKW� DUJXH� WKDW� QLUYDQD� LV� D�PXFK�PRUH ORIW\� JRDO� WKDQ�PHUH� VDOYDWLRQ�� 6R�� LI� WKH� VRWHULRORJLFDO� YDOXH� LQ� WHUPV� RI� ZKLFK� UHOLJLRQV� DUH�FRPSDUHG� LV� WDNHQ� WR�EH�WKH�XOWLPDWH�JRDO�RI� WKH�UHOLJLRQ��ZKDWHYHU� WKDW�PD\�EH�� WKH�IDFW�WKDW�RQH�UHOLJLRQ�FODLPV�WR�SURYLGH�DQ�HDV\�ZD\�WR�LWV�JRDO�GRHV�QRW�VKRZ�WKDW�WKLV�UHOLJLRQ�LV�VXSHULRU�WR�RQH�WKDW�DLPV�DW�D�PRUH�GLIILFXOW�JRDO�ZLWK�D�ORZHU�VXFFHVV�UDWH�,Q�&KULVWLDQ�GLVFXVVLRQV�RI� UHOLJLRXV�SOXUDOLVP�� LW� RIWHQ� VHHPV� WKDW� LW� LV� DVVXPHG�WKDW�RWKHU�UHOLJLRQV�DLP�DW�VRPHWKLQJ�DQDORJRXV�WR�VDOYDWLRQ��DQG�SOXUDOLVWV�FODLP�WKDW�DOO� WKH� PDMRU� WUDGLWLRQV� DUH� DERXW� HTXDO� LQ� WHUPV� RI� HIIHFWLYHQHVV� LQ� JXLGLQJ� WKHLU�IROORZHUV�WR�WKHLU�UHVSHFWLYH�JRDOV��7KLV�LV�D�EL]DUUH�FODLP��VLQFH�QRQH�RI�WKH�UHOLJLRQV�UHFRJQL]H�WKH�JRDOV�RI�DOO�WKH�RWKHUV��7KLV�VRUW�RI�VRWHULRORJLFDO�SOXUDOLVP�ZRXOG�WKHQ�VHHP�WR�UHTXLUH�FRPPLWPHQW�WR�EHOLHIV�WKDW�DUH�UHMHFWHG�E\�DOO�WKH�PDMRU�WUDGLWLRQV�:KHQ�3HWHU�%\UQH�GHILQHV�UHOLJLRXV�SOXUDOLVP�DV�LQFOXGLQJ�WKH�FODXVH��³$OO�PDMRU�WUDGLWLRQV� DUH� OLNHZLVH� HTXDO� LQ� UHVSHFW� RI� RIIHULQJ� VRPH�PHDQV� RU� RWKHU� WR� KXPDQ�VDOYDWLRQ�´� URRP� LV� OHIW� RSHQ� IRU� LQHTXDOLWLHV� LQ�ZKDW� LV� DFKLHYHG� LQ� WKH� DIWHUOLIH�� ,I�EHLQJ�VDYHG�PHDQV�HVFDSLQJ�WKH�ILUH�RI�KHOO��WKHUH�DUH�VWLOO�WUDGLWLRQDOO\�VHYHQ�KHDYHQV��RU�YDULRXV�OHYHO�RI�GLYLQH�UHZDUG�IRU�ZKLFK�RQH�PD\�KRSH��:RXOG�%\UQH�VXJJHVW�WKDW�D�VRWHULRORJLFDO�SOXUDOLVP�LV�WUXH�RQO\�IRU�WKH�EDUH�PLQLPXP�RI�VDOYDWLRQ��RU�PLJKW�WKH�KRO\�PHQ�DQG�ZRPHQ�RI�GLIIHUHQW�IDLWKV�ILQG�WKHPVHOYHV�HQMR\LQJ�ILUVW�FODVV�ORGJLQJV�

Page 12: Plurality of Pluralisms

��

LQ�WKH�DIWHUOLIH"�7KLV�ZD\�RI�SXWWLQJ�WKH�SUREOHP�LV�UDWKHU�FUXGH��EXW�WKHUH�LV�D�VHULRXV�SRLQW�KHUH��$ULVWRWOH�VSHDNV�RI� WKH�JRDO�RI�PDQ�DV�D�KDSS\� OLIH��DQG�&KULVWLDQLW\�DQG�,VODP�KDYH�XVHG�WKH�WHUP�IHOLFLW\��VDµDGDW� IRU�XOWLPDWH�VXFFHVV��6RPHWLPHV�&KULVWLDQV�KDYH�XVHG�WKH�WHUP�EHDWLILF�YLVLRQ IRU�WKH�KLJKHVW�JRDO�WR�EH�DWWDLQHG�E\�WKH�VDLQW��DQG�0XVOLPV�VSHDN�RI�D�GLYLQH�HQFRXQWHU��OLTD�$OODK���%RWK�&KULVWLDQLW\�DQG�,VODP�FODLP�WR� RIIHU� D� SURJUDP� RI� OLYLQJ� WKURXJK� ZKLFK� WKH� EHOLHYHU� LV� VDQFWLILHG RU� SXULILHG��WD]NL\\DK� DO�QDIV��� DQG�ZKLOH� LW� LV� SRVVLEOH� WKDW�ZKDW� WKH�0XVOLP� DFKLHYHV� WKURXJK�WKLV�SURJUDP�PLJKW�EH�FRQVLGHUHG�VDQFWLILFDWLRQ�E\�WKH�&KULVWLDQ��HDFK�SURJUDP�KDV�LWV�RZQ�XQLTXH�IHDWXUHV�DQG�HPSKDVHV��7KH�TXHVWLRQ�LV�QRW�PHUHO\�RQH�RI�EHLQJ�NHSW�RXW�RI�VDFUHG�SUHFLQFWV�EHFDXVH�RQH�GRHV�QRW�KDYH�WKH�ULJKW�VRUW�RI�PHPEHUVKLS�FDUG��EXW�WKDW� WKH� ZD\V� RI� OLIH� SUHVFULEHG� E\� WKH� GLIIHUHQW� UHOLJLRQV� \LHOG� GLIIHUHQW� VRUWV� RI�VSLULWXDO�UHVXOWV�+RZHYHU��ZH�FRXOG�DOVR�ORRN�DW�WKH�TXHVWLRQ�RI�SOXUDOLVP�ZLWK�UHVSHFW�WR�D�VSHFLILF�JRDO�GHILQHG�ZLWKLQ�D�SDUWLFXODU�WUDGLWLRQ��2IWHQ�SOXUDOLVWV�WDNH�KHDYHQ�WR�EH�WKH�JRDO��DQG�DVN�ZKHWKHU�*RG�LV�JRLQJ�WR�DOORZ�%XGGKLVWV�LQ��3OXUDOLVWV�FODLP�WKDW�*RG�LV�YHU\�OLEHUDO� DQG� ZLOO� DOORZ� %XGGKLVWV� WR� UHDFK� WKH� &KULVWLDQ� JRDO� RI� IHOLFLW\�� (TXDOLW\�SOXUDOLVWV� ZLOO� WKHQ� KDYH� WR� PDNH� WKH LQFUHGLEOH� FODLP� WKDW� %XGGKLVP� SURYLGHV� DQ�HTXDOO\� HIIHFWLYH�PHDQV� IRU� JXLGLQJ� LWV� IROORZHUV� WR� D� JRDO� WKDW� WKH\� GR� QRW� VHHN� DV�&KULVWLDQLW\�SURYLGHV�IRU�LWV�IROORZHUV�WR�D�JRDO�WKDW�WKH\�GR�VHHN� 9HU\�VHOGRP�LV�WKLV�TXHVWLRQ�SRVHG�ZLWK�UHVSHFW�WR�WKH�SHUVSHFWLYH�RI�D�UHOLJLRQ�RWKHU�WKDQ�&KULVWLDQLW\�RU�,VODP�� ,W� LV� H[SHFWHG� WKDW� &KULVWLDQV� DQG� 0XVOLPV� VKRXOG� DOORZ� WKDW� %XGGKLVP�SURYLGHV� D�ZD\� WR� VDOYDWLRQ�� EXW� LW� LV� QRW� H[SHFWHG� WKDW�%XGGKLVWV� VKRXOG�DGPLW� WKDW�&KULVWLDQLW\�DQG�,VODP�SURYLGH�DQ�HIIHFWLYH�ZD\�WR�UHDFK�QLUYDQD� ,QGHHG��LW�ZRXOG�EH�DEVXUG� WR� WKLQN� WKDW�D� UHOLJLRXV� OLIH� WKDW�GRHV�QRW�SURYLGH�DQ�HIIHFWLYH�PHDQV�IRU� WKH�H[WLQFWLRQ�RI�GHVLUH� �DFFRUGLQJ� WR�VHFWV�RI�%XGGKLVP��DW� OHDVW���PLJKW�SURYLGH�D�ZD\�IRU�&KULVWLDQV�DQG�0XVOLPV�WR�UHDFK�QLUYDQD�(YHQ� LI� ZH� FRPSDUH� &KULVWLDQLW\� ZLWK� ,VODP�� ZH� ILQG� WKDW� WKHUH� LV� PXFK� PRUH�HPSKDVLV�RQ�VDOYDWLRQ DPRQJ�&KULVWLDQV�WKDQ�DPRQJ�0XVOLPV��3HUKDSV�WKH�UHDVRQ�IRU�WKLV�LV�EHFDXVH�RI�WKH�&KULVWLDQ�GRFWULQH�RI�RULJLQDO�VLQ��$FFRUGLQJ�WR�PDQ\�&KULVWLDQV��DV�D�UHVXOW�RI�RULJLQDO�VLQ��RQH�FDQQRW�JDLQ�HQWUDQFH�LQWR�WKH�NLQJGRP�RI�KHDYHQ�XQOHVV�RQH� LV� EDSWL]HG� LQWR� WKH� FKXUFK�� )RU� 0XVOLPV�� KRZHYHU�� PDQ� PD\� EH� ORVW� ZLWKRXW�UHOLJLRXV� WUDLQLQJ��EXW� WKLV� LV�TXLWH�GLIIHUHQW� WKDQ�QHHGLQJ� WR�KDYH�RQH¶V� VLQV�ZDVKHG�DZD\� LQ� WKH� EORRG� RI� WKH� ODPE�� ,VODP� HPSKDVL]HV� WKH� QHHG� IRU� JXLGDQFH�� ZLWKRXW�

Page 13: Plurality of Pluralisms

��

GHQ\LQJ� WKDW� D� VDYLRU� ZLOO� FRPH� DW� WKH� HQG� RI� WLPH�� ZKLOH� &KULVWLDQLW\� HPSKDVL]HV�VDOYDWLRQ��ZLWKRXW�GHQ\LQJ�WKH�QHHG�IRU�JXLGDQFH�,I�WKH TXHVWLRQ�RI�VRWHULRORJLFDO�SOXUDOLVP�LV�UDLVHG H[FOXVLYHO\�ZLWKLQ�&KULVWLDQ�RU�0XVOLP�WKHRORJLHV��RQH�PD\ DVN�ZKHWKHU�WKH�DGKHUHQWV�RI�GLIIHUHQW�GHQRPLQDWLRQV�RU�HYHQ� WKRVH�ZKR� IROORZ� QR� UHOLJLRXV� SDWK� DW� DOO�PD\� EH� JUDQWHG� VRPH� VRUW� RI� GLYLQH�UHZDUG DFFRUGLQJ� WR� WKH� WKHRORJLHV�RI�&KULVWLDQLW\� DQG� ,VODP��7KH�VWURQJHVW�FDVH� IRU�SOXUDOLVP�RQ�WKLV�LQWHUSUHWDWLRQ�FRXOG�EH�PDGH�E\�DUJXLQJ�WKDW�*RG�UHZDUGV�DOO�WKRVH�ZKR�GR�JRRG�UHJDUGOHVV�RI�WKHLU�UHOLJLRXV�EHOLHIV� 6RPHWKLQJ�DORQJ�WKHVH�OLQHV�VHHPV�WR� EH� LQGLFDWHG� LQ� WKH� IROORZLQJ� D\DK RI� WKH� *ORULRXV� 4XU¶DQ�� DOWKRXJK� WKHUH� LV�FRQWURYHUV\�DERXW�WKH�SURSHU�LQWHUSUHWDWLRQ��DQG�ZKDW�NLQG�RI�UHZDUG�FDQ�EH�H[SHFWHG�E\�QRQ�0XVOLPV�LQ�WKH�QH[W�OLIH���,QGHHG�WKH�IDLWKIXO��WKH�-HZV��WKH�&KULVWLDQV��DQG�WKH�6DEDHDQV²WKRVH�RI�WKHP�ZKR�KDYH�IDLWK�LQ�$OODK�DQG�WKH�/DVW�'D\�DQG�DFW�ULJKWHRXVO\²WKH\�VKDOO�KDYH� WKHLU� UHZDUG�QHDU� WKHLU�/RUG��DQG� WKH\�ZLOO�KDYH�QR� IHDU��QRU�ZLOO�WKH\�JULHYH�� ������

��� 1RUPDWLYH� UHOLJLRXV� SOXUDOLVP SHUWDLQV� WR� KRZ� DGKHUHQWV� DUH� WR� WUHDW� WKH�IROORZHUV�RI�UHOLJLRQV�RWKHU�WKDQ�WKHLU�RZQ��+HUH�LW�PLJKW�EH�VXSSRVHG�WKDW�D�UHOLJLRQ�KDV�D�SHFXOLDU�VRUW�RI�YDOXH�E\�YLUWXH�RI�ZKLFK�D�FHUWDLQ�NLQG�RI�UHVSHFW�LV�WR�EH�VKRZQ�WR�LWV�DGKHUHQWV��+RZHYHU��WKLV�GRHV�QRW�VHHP�WR�EH�ZKDW�WKH�UHOLJLRXV�SOXUDOLVW�KDV�LQ�PLQG��7KH�SOXUDOLVW�LV�QRW�DUJXLQJ�WKDW�HTXDO�UHVSHFW�VKRXOG�EH�VKRZQ�WR�WKH�IROORZHUV�RI� WKH� PDMRU� WUDGLWLRQV� EXW� QRW� WR� PHPEHUV� RI� ZHLUG� FXOWV� RU� DWKHLVWV�� UDWKHU�� WKH�SOXUDOLVW� DUJXHV� WKDW� GLIIHUHQFH� LQ� UHOLJLRXV� EHOLHI� VKRXOG� QRW� EH� UHDVRQ� WR� GHQ\� WKH�KXPDQ�GLJQLW\� RI� WKH�RWKHUV��7KH�QRUPDWLYH� H[FOXVLYLVW�PLJKW� EH�XQGHUVWRRG� DV�RQH�ZKR�KROGV� WKDW� WKH� IDYRUHG� UHOLJLRQ�KDV�D�SDUWLFXODU�YDOXH� WKDW�FRQIHUV�GLJQLW\�RQ� LWV�PHPEHUV�RU� WKDW�FUHDWHV�REOLJDWLRQV� WR� WKHP��2WKHU� UHOLJLRQV� ODFN� WKLV�YDOXH��DQG� VR�WKHLU�DGKHUHQWV�PLJKW�EH�GHQLHG�ULJKWV�JLYHQ�WR�WKH�IROORZHUV�RI�WKH�SUHIHUUHG�UHOLJLRQ��1RUPDWLYH� H[FOXVLYLVP� �1(�� PD\� EH� GHILQHG� JHQHUDOO\� LQ� WHUPV� RI� SHUVRQV�� [�� WR�ZKRP�REOLJDWLRQV RU�ULJKWV �2��RI�VRPH�VRUW�DUH�QRW�GXH�LI�[�LV�D�QRW�D�IROORZHU�RI�D�UHOLJLRQ�U��)[U WKDW�KDV�D�FHUWDLQ�YDOXH��1(� �9��[�a�U�9U� )[U�oa2[����U�9UlU U ��$FFRUGLQJ� WR�1(�� WKHUH�LV�VRPH�YDOXH�VXFK�WKDW�QR�SHUVRQV�ZKR�GR�QRW�IROORZ�D�UHOLJLRQ�ZLWK� WKLV�YDOXH�DUH�GXH�REOLJDWLRQV��$Q�HTXDOLW\�SOXUDOLVW� LQ� WKLV�UHJDUG�GRHV�

Page 14: Plurality of Pluralisms

��

QRW�FODLP�WKDW�DOO�WKH�PDMRU�WUDGLWLRQV�KDYH�WKH�VRUW�RI�YLUWXH�WKDW FUHDWHV�REOLJDWLRQV��VR�DV�WR�DGYRFDWH�WKH�UHSODFHPHQW�RI�WKH�VHFRQG�FRQMXQFW�RI�1(�E\��U9U��UDWKHU�WKH\�GHQ\�WKDW�WKHUH�LV�DQ\�YDOXH�RI�D�UHOLJLRQ�VXFK�WKDW WKRVH�ZKR�GR�QRW�IROORZ�D�UHOLJLRQ�ZLWK� WKLV� YDOXH� KDYH� QR� ULJKWV� RU� REOLJDWLRQV� GXH� WR� WKHP�� $� QRUPDWLYH� HTXDOLW\�SOXUDOLVP� �1(3��PLJKW WKXV� EH� GHILQHG� DV� WKH� GHQLDO� RI� WKH� ILUVW� FODXVH� RI�1(��7KH�QRUPDWLYH�HTXDOLW\�SOXUDOLVW�ZLOO�KROG�WKDW�WKHUH�LV�QR�YDOXH VXFK�WKDW�IDLOXUH�WR�EHOLHYH�LQ�D�UHOLJLRQ�WKDW�KDV�LW�LPSOLHV�WKDW�RQH�KDV�QR�ULJKWV�RU�REOLJDWLRQV�GXH�WR�WKHP�1(3��a�9�U�[�2[o�9U� )[U��$�SURSRQHQW�RI�1(3�ZRXOG�FODLP�WKDW�WKHUH�VKRXOG�EH�QR�GLIIHUHQFH�DW�DOO�LQ�RQH¶V�EHKDYLRU� WRZDUG� SHUVRQV� RI� GLIIHUHQW� UHOLJLRXV� EHOLHIV�� ,I� FDUULHG� RXW� VWULFWO\�� WKLV�ZRXOG�SUHYHQW�DQ\�VRUW�RI�SDUWLFLSDWLRQ�LQ�D�SDUWLFXODU�UHOLJLRXV�FRPPXQLW\��IRU�VXFK�SDUWLFLSDWLRQ�UHTXLUHV�D�VSHFLDO�VRUW�RI�FRRSHUDWLRQ�EDVHG�RQ�UHOLJLRXV�DIILOLDWLRQ� ,W�LV�VXSSRVHG� WKDW� PHPEHUV� RI� D� UHOLJLRXV� FRPPXQLW\� KDYH� VSHFLDO� REOLJDWLRQV� WR� RQH�DQRWKHU�� DQG� UHFRJQL]H� VSHFLDO� ULJKWV� IRU� RQH� DQRWKHU� XQGHU� YDULRXV� FRQGLWLRQV� 7KH�RSSRVLWH�H[WUHPH�IURP�HTXDOLW\�SOXUDOLVP�ZRXOG�EH�WKH�YLHZ�WKDW�VHHPV�WR�KDYH�EHHQ�KHOG�� XQIRUWXQDWHO\�� E\� VRPH� 0XVOLPV� DV� ZHOO� DV� &KULVWLDQV�� WKDW� RQH� KDV� QR�REOLJDWLRQV�ZKDWVRHYHU�WRZDUG�WKRVH�ZKR�DUH�QRW�RI�RQH¶V�RZQ�IDLWK��WKDW�WKHLU�EORRG�LV�SHUPLWWHG�WR�EH�VKHG�DQG�WKHLU�SURSHUW\�WDNHQ��0RUH�UHDVRQDEOH�ZRXOG�EH�WKH�YLHZ�WKDW�ZH�DUH�ERXQG�E\�FHUWDLQ�REOLJDWLRQV�WRZDUG�DOO�KXPDQ�EHLQJV��DOWKRXJK�ZH�PD\�KDYH�DGGLWLRQDO�VSHFLDO�REOLJDWLRQV�WR�RXU�FR�UHOLJLRQLVWV��(YHQ�ZLWKLQ�D� VSHFLILF� UHOLJLRQ��GLIIHUHQW� ULJKWV� DQG�REOLJDWLRQV� IRU�PHPEHUV�DUH�SUHVFULEHG��&DWKROLFV�KROG�WKDW�WKH�ULJKW�WR�DGPLQLVWHU�VRPH�VDFUDPHQWV�LV�UHVWULFWHG�WR�SULHVWV��+LQGXLVP�LV�QRWRULRXV�IRU�LWV�FDVWH�UHVWULFWLRQV�DQG�SULYLOHJHV��DQG��DW�WKH�YHU\�OHDVW�� RQO\� WKH� DGPLQLVWUDWRUV� RI� VSHFLILF� UHOLJLRXV� RUJDQL]DWLRQV� DUH� SHUPLWWHG� WR�DWWHQG� FHUWDLQ� PHHWLQJV�� 6R�� ZKDW� LV� DW� LVVXH� ZLWK� UHJDUG� WR� QRUPDWLYH� UHOLJLRXV�SOXUDOLVP�LV�WKH�VRUW�RI�ULJKWV�DQG�REOLJDWLRQV�WKDW�DUH�RZHG�WR�SHRSOH�ZLWK�UHJDUG�WR�WKHLU� UHOLJLRXV�DIILOLDWLRQV� ,Q�RWKHU�ZRUGV��ERWK�1(3�DQG�1(�PD\�EH�DFFHSWDEOH� IRU�GLIIHUHQW�LQWHUSUHWDWLRQV�RI�2�,W�LV�UHDVRQDEOH�WR�KROG�WKDW�ZLWK�UHVSHFW�WR�EDVLF�ULJKWV��1(3�LV�FRUUHFW��DQG�ZLWK�UHVSHFW�WR�VSHFLILF�ULJKWV�DQG�GXWLHV�SHUWDLQLQJ�WR�VSHFLDO�REOLJDWLRQV�RZHG�WR�PHPEHUV�RI�RQH¶V�UHOLJLRXV�FRPPXQLW\��1(�ZRXOG�EH�FRUUHFW��0DQ\�MXULVWV�KROG�WKDW�DFFRUGLQJ�� )RU�PRUH�RQ�WKH�QRWLRQ�RI�VSHFLDO�REOLJDWLRQV��VHH�WKH�HQWU\ E\�'LDQH�-HVNH��³6SHFLDO�2EOLJDWLRQV¶��LQ�7KH� 6WDQIRUG� (QF\FORSHGLD� RI� 3KLORVRSK\� �:LQWHU� ����� (GLWLRQ��� (GZDUG� 1�� =DOWD� �HG���� 85/� �KWWS���SODWR�VWDQIRUG�HGX�DUFKLYHV�ZLQ�����HQWULHV�VSHFLDO�REOLJDWLRQV��

Page 15: Plurality of Pluralisms

��

WR� ,VODP��GLIIHUHQW� ULJKWV�DFFRUG�WR�0XVOLPV��RWKHU�³3HRSOHV�RI� WKH�%RRN´��DQG�RWKHU�KXPDQ� EHLQJV� UHJDUGOHVV� RI� WKHLU� UHOLJLRXV� YLHZV�� 2QH� PLJKW� DFFRUGLQJO\� FRQVLGHU�,VODP� WR� SUHVFULEH� D� VRUW� RI� QRUPDWLYH� GHJUHH� SOXUDOLVP� E\� LVVXLQJ� GXWLHV� LQ� DFFRUG�ZLWK� OHYHOV� RI� UHOLJLRXV� YDOXH�� ,I� EDVLF� KXPDQ� ULJKWV DQG� GXWLHV� GXH� WR� SHUVRQV� DUH�UHSUHVHQWHG� E\�2E�� ULJKWV� DQG� REOLJDWLRQV� GXH� IRU� 3HRSOH� RI� WKH� %RRN� DUH�2S�� DQG�ULJKWV�DQG�GXWLHV�IRU�0XVOLPV�DUH�2P��DQG�LI�WKH�GHJUHH�RI�YDOXH�DVVLJQHG�E\�,VODP�WR�UHOLJLRQV�RI�3HRSOH�RI�WKH�%RRN�LV�S DQG�WKH�GHJUHH�DVVLJQHG�WR�,VODP�LWVHOI�LV�P��WKH�SRVLWLRQ�FRXOG�EH�IRUPXODWHG�E\�WKH�WKUHH�FODXVHV�EHORZ��[�2E[��$OO�SHUVRQV�KDYH�EDVLF�ULJKWV���U��G�9U�tSo�[�)[Uo2S[�����U��G�9U�tPo�[�)[Uo2P[���1RWLFH�WKDW�GHVSLWH�WKH�KLVWRULFDO�IDFWV�OLQNLQJ�H[FOXVLYLVW�YLHZV�RQ�VDOYDWLRQ�ZLWK�LQWROHUDQFH�� VRWHULRORJLFDO� SOXUDOLVP� DQG� QRUPDWLYH� SOXUDOLVP� DUH� ORJLFDOO\�LQGHSHQGHQW�� �DOWKRXJK� WKLV� LV� QRW� WR� GHQ\� WKDW� WKHUH� PD\� EH� VRFLDO�SV\FKRORJLFDO�LQIOXHQFHV�RU�WHQGHQFLHV���9DULRXV�IRUPV�RI�QRUPDWLYH�UHOLJLRXV�SOXUDOLVP�KDYH�EHHQ�WKH�IRFXV�RI�DWWHQWLRQ�RI�D�QXPEHU�RI�ZULWHUV��VRPH�RI�ZKRP�XVH�WKH�WHUP�UHOLJLRXV�SOXUDOLVP H[FOXVLYHO\� IRU�YDULRXV� IRUPV� RI� QRUPDWLYH� UHOLJLRXV� SOXUDOLVP�� )RU� H[DPSOH�� )UDQoRLVH� &KDPSLRQ�XQGHUVWDQGV� UHOLJLRXV�SOXUDOLVP WR�EH� D�SROLWLFDO�SULQFLSOH�� DQG�GHVFULEHV�KRZ� LW� KDV�JDLQHG�FXUUHQF\�DV�VXFK�LQ�)UDQFH�RYHU�WKH�ODVW�ILIWHHQ�RU�WZHQW\�\HDUV�DPRQJ�VRFLDO�VFLHQFH� UHVHDUFKHUV�� SROLWLFDO� DQDO\VWV� DQG� VRFLRORJLVWV�� 6KH� GLVWLQJXLVKHV� WZR�PDLQ�W\SHV� RI� �ZKDW� ,� ZRXOG� FDOO�� QRUPDWLYH� UHOLJLRXV� SOXUDOLVP�� ZKLFK� VKH� WHUPV�HPDQFLSDWRU\�SOXUDOLVP DQG� LGHQWLW\�EDVHG�SOXUDOLVP��(PDQFLSDWRU\�SOXUDOLVP�LV� WKH�FODLP� WKDW� WKH� DGKHUHQWV� RI� GLIIHUHQW� UHOLJLRQV� VKRXOG� EH� JUDQWHG� HTXDO� LQGLYLGXDO�ULJKWV�� ,GHQWLW\�EDVHG� SOXUDOLVP� LV� DQ� DWWHPSW� WR� JR� EH\RQG� WKH� OLEHUDOLVP� RI�HPDQFLSDWRU\� SOXUDOLVP� E\� UHFRJQL]LQJ� DQ� HTXDOLW\� RI� JURXS� ULJKWV�� DV� KDV EHHQ�VXJJHVWHG�E\�VRPH�FRPPXQLWDULDQ�WKLQNHUV���&KDPSLRQ� LV� FRQFHUQHG�ZLWK�SROLWLFDO YHUVLRQV�RI�QRUPDWLYH� UHOLJLRXV�SOXUDOLVP��EXW�ZH�VKRXOG�DOVR�FRQVLGHU�PRUDO�YHUVLRQV�DQG�UHOLJLRXV YHUVLRQV��:H�PD\�FRQVLGHU�ZKHQ�GLIIHUHQFHV�LQ�EHKDYLRXU�WRZDUG�RWKHUV�DUH�PRUDOO\�DQG�UHOLJLRXVO\� MXVWLILHG�RQ�

�� )UDQoRLVH� &KDPSLRQ�� ³7KH� GLYHUVLW\� RI� UHOLJLRXV� SOXUDOLVP�´� 0267� -RXUQDO� RQ� 0XOWLFXOWXUDO�6RFLHWLHV��9RO�����1R�������������85/� �KWWS���ZZZ�XQHVFR�RUJ�PRVW�Y��Q�FKD�KWP��

Page 16: Plurality of Pluralisms

��

WKH�EDVLV�RI�UHOLJLRXV�EHOLHIV��2QH�PD\�KROG�WKDW�PHPEHUV�RI�VRPH�GHYLDQW�UHOLJLRXV�JURXS�VKRXOG�EH�VKXQQHG�DFFRUGLQJ�WR�RQH¶V�RZQ�UHOLJLRXV EHOLHIV��2QH�PD\�KROG�WKDW�LW� LV� PRUDOO\� MXVWLILDEOH� WR� JLYH� SUHIHUHQWLDO� WUHDWPHQW� WR� PHPEHUV� RI� RQH¶V� RZQ�UHOLJLRXV� FRPPXQLW\� ZLWK� UHVSHFW� WR� SHUVRQDO� UHODWLRQV�� EXW� QRW� LQ� D� PDQQHU� WKDW�FDXVHV� KDUP� RU� VLJQLILFDQW� RIIHQFH� WR� RWKHUV�� HYHQ� ZKHQ� VXFK� WUHDWPHQW� GRHV� QRW�YLRODWH�DQ\�ODZ��7KH�UHODWLRQV�EHWZHHQ�OHJDO��UHOLJLRXV��DQG�PRUDO�FRQVLGHUDWLRQV�DUH�FRPSOH[��1RUPV�WR�EH�DGRSWHG�PD\�DOVR�EH�VWXGLHG�GHVFULSWLYHO\�RU�SUHVFULSWLYHO\��:H�FRXOG� DVN�� IRU� H[DPSOH��ZKDW� OHJDO� SULYLOHJHV� DUH� JLYHQ� WR� WKH� HVWDEOLVKHG�FKXUFK� LQ�(QJODQG��ZKLFK�ZRXOG�EH�GHVFULSWLYH��RU�ZKDW�ODZV�VKRXOG�EH�HQDFWHG�LQ�(QJODQG�ZLWK�UHJDUG�WR�HVWDEOLVKPHQW��ZKLFK�ZRXOG�EH�D SUHVFULSWLYH�TXHVWLRQ��/LNHZLVH��RQH�PD\�DVN� GHVFULSWLYH� TXHVWLRQV� DERXW� WKH�PRUDO� QRUPV� LQ� D� JLYHQ� VRFLHW\�� RU� DUJXH� DERXW�ZKDW�PRUDOLW\�VKRXOG�EH�XQGHUVWRRG�WR�UHTXLUH�RI�XV��$JDLQ��ZH�FRXOG�DVN�DERXW�ZKDW�UHOLJLRXV� UXOHV� WKHUH� DUH� UHJDUGLQJ� WKRVH� RXWVLGH� RQH¶V� GHQRPLQDWLRQ�� RU� RQH� FRXOG��SUHVFULSWLYHO\��PDNH�D�WKHRORJLFDO�DUJXPHQW�LQ�IDYRXU�RI�WKH�DEURJDWLRQ�RU�DGRSWLRQ�RI�VRPH�UXOH���� 2IWHQ� GLVFXVVLRQV� RI� UHOLJLRXV� SOXUDOLVP� IRFXV� RQ� HSLVWHPRORJLFDO� LVVXHV���(SLVWHPRORJLFDO�UHOLJLRXV�SOXUDOLVP LV�WKH�YLHZ�WKDW�DOO�WKH�PDMRU�UHOLJLRXV�FUHHGV�DUH�HTXDOO\� MXVWLILHG�DFFRUGLQJ� WR�VRPH�SURSRVHG�FULWHULD�RI�HSLVWHPRORJLFDO� MXVWLILFDWLRQ�RU�ZDUUDQW��7KLV�ZD\� RI�SXWWLQJ� WKH�PDWWHU� IRFXVHV�RQ� WKH�EHOLHIV� UHJDUGOHVV�RI�ZKR�KROGV� WKHP�� DV� WKRXJK� WKH� EHOLHIV� WKHPVHOYHV� KDYH� WKH� FDSDFLW\� IRU� EHLQJ� KHOG� DV�MXVWLILHG�RU�ZDUUDQWHG�EHOLHIV��:H�FRXOG�FDOO�WKLV�HSLVWHPRORJLFDO�EHOLHI�SOXUDOLVP�DQG�FRQWUDVW�LW�WR�HSLVWHPRORJLFDO�DJHQW�SOXUDOLVP��ZKLFK�ZRXOG�EH H[SUHVVHG�E\�WKH�FODLP�WKDW�WKH�IROORZHUV�RI�QR�SDUWLFXODU�UHOLJLRQ�KDYH�DQ\�HSLVWHPRORJLFDO�DGYDQWDJH�LQ�WKHLU�EHOLHIV�RYHU�WKH�IROORZHUV�RI�RWKHU�UHOLJLRQV��7KLV�FRXOG�EH�DQ�HTXDOLW\�SOXUDOLVP��VLQFH�ZH�VKRXOG�QRW� WKLQN� WKDW� WKH� IROORZHUV�RI� DQ\� RI� WKH�PDMRU� UHOLJLRQV� DUH� D�EXQFK�RI�GXPPLHV�� EXW� DUH�� JHQHUDOO\� VSHDNLQJ�� HSLVWHPLF� SHHUV�� $Q� HSLVWHPRORJLFDO� GHJUHH�SOXUDOLVW ZRXOG�KROG� WKDW� WKH�DGKHUHQWV�RI� VHYHUDO� UHOLJLRQV�GLIIHU� WR� VRPH�GHJUHH� LQ�EHLQJ�MXVWLILHG�RU�ZDUUDQWHG�LQ�KROGLQJ�WKHLU�EHOLHIV��EXW WKDW�WKHVH�GLIIHUHQFHV�DUH�QRW�VXIILFLHQW�IRU�RQO\�RQH�JURXS�WR�EH�MXVWLILHG�DQG�WKH�UHVW�XQMXVWLILHG��$JDLQ��WKLV�FRXOG�EH�GHILQHG�DV�D�EHOLHI�SOXUDOLVP�RU�DV�DQ�DJHQW�SOXUDOLVP�� ,W�ZRXOG�EH� UHDVRQDEOH� WR�H[SHFW� WR� ILQG� GLIIHUHQFHV� LQ� GHJUHH� RI� DYHUDJH� LQWHOOLJHQFH� RI� WKH� IROORZHUV� RI�

�� $Q�LVVXH�RI�WKH�MRXUQDO�RI�WKH�6RFLHW\�RI�&KULVWLDQ�3KLORVRSKHUV��)DLWK�DQG�3KLORVRSK\��9RO������1R�����-XO\�������ZDV�GHYRWHG�WR�³7KH�(SLVWHPRORJLFDO�&KDOOHQJH�RI�5HOLJLRXV�3OXUDOLVP�´�E\�-RKQ�+LFN�

Page 17: Plurality of Pluralisms

��

GLIIHUHQW� GHQRPLQDWLRQV�� EXW� WKHVH� GLIIHUHQFHV� GR� QRW� VHHP� VR� JUHDW� WKDW� ZH� FRXOG�UHDVRQDEO\�FODLP�WKDW�WKH�DGKHUHQWV�RI�RQH�IDLWK�DORQH�KDYH�MXVWLILHG�EHOLHIV�ZKLOH�WKH�UHVW�GRQ¶W�NQRZ�KRZ�WR�WKLQN�SURSHUO\��7KH�LVVXH�EHFRPHV�PRUH�FRQWHQWLRXV�ZKHQ�ZH�FRQVLGHU� EHOLHI� SOXUDOLVP�� 6RPH� UHOLJLRXV� EHOLHIV� VHHP� WR� EH� LQWULQVLFDOO\� KDUGHU� WR�MXVWLI\�WKDQ�RWKHUV��3HUKDSV�HYHU\�UHOLJLRQ�KDV�LWV�GLIILFXOW�EHOLHIV�DQG�HDV\�EHOLHIV��DQG�SHUKDSV�WKH\�EDODQFH�RXW�LQ�WKH�HQG��%XW�LW�ZRXOG�QRW�EH�XQUHDVRQDEOH�WR�VXVSHFW�WKDW�WKHUH�FRXOG�ZHOO�EH�GLIIHUHQFHV�RQ�WKH�ZKROH�LQ�WKH�MXVWLILDELOLW\�RI�GLIIHUHQW�FUHHGV�6XSSRVH� WKDW�S� LV� D� SDUW� RI� WKH� GRFWULQHV� RU� UHOLJLRXV� WHDFKLQJV� RI� U�� /HW� WKLV� EH�DEEUHYLDWHG�DV�7US��$Q�RSWLPLVWLF�YLHZ�RI�WKH�MXVWLILFDWLRQ�RI�RQH¶V�IDYRULWH�UHOLJLRQ¶V�GRJPDV�ZRXOG�EH��S�7U So-S�$WKHLVWV�KROG�WKDW�UHOLJLRXV�EHOLHIV�DUH�IDOVH��QRW�WKDW�WKH\�DUH�QHYHU�MXVWLILHG��%XW�VRPH� DWKHLVWV� DOVR� KDYH� DUJXHG� WKDW� UHOLJLRXV� EHOLHIV� DUH� XQMXVWLILHG�� 7KLV� IRUP� RI�DWKHLVP�PLJKW�EH LQLWLDOO\�IRUPXODWHG�DV�IROORZV��U�7USoa-S�+RZHYHU��EHOLHYHUV�DQG�DWKHLVWV�PLJKW�DJUHH�RQ�VRPH�WHDFKLQJV��H�J���WKDW�PXUGHU�LV�ZURQJ��$Q� DWKHLVW�PLJKW� KROG� WKDW� LW� LV� GRFWULQHV� DERXW�ZKLFK� UHOLJLRXV� EHOLHYHUV�GLIIHU� WKDW� DUH� QRW� MXVWLILHG�� EXW� VRPH� UHOLJLRXV� EHOLHYHUV�� VXFK� DV� 7KHUHYDGD�%XGGKLVWV�� GR� QRW� EHOLHYH� LQ� *RG�� DQG� DWKHLVWV� ZRXOG� QRW� VD\� WKDW� WKLV� EHOLHI� LV�XQMXVWLILHG��3HUKDSV�WKH�DWKHLVW�SRVLWLRQ�LV�EHWWHU�FDSWXUHG�E\�WKH�VWDWHPHQW�WKDW�VRPH�UHOLJLRXV� WHDFKLQJV� RI� DOO� WKH� UHOLJLRQV� DUH� XQMXVWLILHG�� :H� FRXOG� FDOO� WKLV� SRVLWLRQ�HSLVWHPLF�EHOLHI�DWKHLVP��(%$��(%$���U�S�7US��a-S�2QH� PD\� EH� FKDUDFWHUL]HG� E\� HSLVWHPLF� EHOLHI� H[FOXVLYLVP� �(%(�� LI� RQH� LV� DQ�HSLVWHPLF�EHOLHI�DWKHLVW�ZLWK�UHVSHFW�WR�HYHU\�UHOLJLRQ�EXW�RQH¶V�RZQ�(%(���U�UzU o�S�7US �a-S��$Q� LPSODXVLEOH�SOXUDOLVP�ZRXOG�EH�XQLYHUVDO�HSLVWHPLF�EHOLHI�SOXUDOLVP �8(%3��DFFRUGLQJ�WR�ZKLFK�DOO�WKH�EHOLHIV�RI�DOO�WKH�UHOLJLRQV�DUH�MXVWLILHG�8(%3���U�7USo-S�$�PRUH�UHVWULFWHG�IRUP�RI�HSLVWHPLF�SOXUDOLVP�ZRXOG�KROG�WKDW�WKH�WHDFKLQJV�RI�DOO�DQG� RQO\� WKRVH� UHOLJLRQV� WKDW� KDYH� D� FHUWDLQ� HSLVWHPLF� YDOXH��9H�� DUH� VXFK� WKDW� WKHLU�PDLQ� EHOLHIV� DUH� MXVWLILHG�� DQG� WKDW� WKH� PDMRU� UHOLJLRXV WUDGLWLRQV DOO� IDOO� LQWR� WKLV�FDWHJRU\� (SLVWHPLF�EHOLHI�H[FOXVLYLVP�FRXOG�WKHQ�EH�IRUPXODWHG�DV�WKH�SRVLWLRQ�WKDW�LW�

Page 18: Plurality of Pluralisms

��

LV�RQO\�WKH�IDYRUHG�UHOLJLRQ�WKDW�KDV�WKH�YDOXH�9H��2QH�PLJKW�KROG�D�GHJUHH�SOXUDOLVP�DFFRUGLQJ� WR�ZKLFK�KLJKHU�GHJUHHV�RI�9H FRUUHVSRQG� WR�EHWWHU�MXVWLILFDWLRQ�RI�EHOLHIV��2QH�PLJKW�WKHQ�KROG�D�GHJUHH�SOXUDOLVP�LQ�WKLV�UHJDUG�E\�FODLPLQJ�WKDW�DOO�WKH�PDMRU�UHOLJLRXV� WUDGLWLRQV¶� PDLQ� EHOLHIV� DUH� MXVWLILDEOH� WR� VRPH� GHJUHH� SDVW� D� VWDQGDUG�� $�GHJUHH�H[FOXVLYLVW�FRXOG�KROG�WKDW�WKHUH�LV�RQH�UHOLJLRQ�ZKRVH�GHJUHH�RI�9H VXUSDVVHV�WKDW�RI�DOO�RWKHUV�7KH�FDOFXODWLRQ�RI�GLIIHUHQW�YDOXHV�RI�9H LV�FRPSOLFDWHG�E\�WKH�IDFW�WKDW�WKHUH�DUH�VHYHUDO�VFDOHV�RQ�ZKLFK�LW�PLJKW�EH�PHDVXUHG��WKH�GHJUHH�RI�MXVWLILFDWLRQ��WKH�QXPEHU�RI�MXVWLILHG�EHOLHIV��RU�WKH�QXPEHU�RI�MXVWLILHG�LPSRUWDQW�RU�HVVHQWLDO�EHOLHIV��6XSSRVH�WKDW�RQH�GHFLGHV�WR�HYDOXDWH�9H LQ�VXFK�D�ZD\�WKDW�G�9HU�!��LI�DQG�RQO\�LI�DOO�HVVHQWLDO�EHOLHIV� RI� U DUH� MXVWLILHG�� DQG� WKH� YDOXH� RI� G�9HU�� LV� JUHDWHU� ZKHQ� WKHVH� EHOLHIV� DUH�EHWWHU�MXVWLILHG��DQG�LV�JUHDWHU�ZKHQ�DGGLWLRQDO�QRQ�HVVHQWLDO�EHOLHIV�DUH�DOVR�MXVWLILHG��7KHUH�LV�QR�UHDG\�UXOH�RQ�WKH�EDVLV�RI�ZKLFK�RQH�FRXOG�VD\�WKDW�D�EHOLHI�V\VWHP�ZKRVH�HVVHQWLDO� EHOLHIV� PHHW� VRPH� PLQLPDO� VWDQGDUG� RI� MXVWLILFDWLRQ� EXW� LQ� ZKLFK� DOO�SHULSKHUDO�EHOLHIV�DUH�DOVR�MXVWLILHG�LV�LQ�EHWWHU�RU�ZRUVH�HSLVWHPLF�VKDSH�WKDW�D�EHOLHI�V\VWHP�LQ�ZKLFK�WKH�HVVHQWLDO�EHOLHIV�DUH�MXVWLILHG�WR�D�YHU\�KLJK�GHJUHH�DOWKRXJK�D�IDLU�QXPEHU� RI� SHULSKHUDO� EHOLHIV� DUH� QRW� MXVWLILHG��7KHQ� WKHUH� LV� WKH� SUREOHP�RI� KRZ� WR�GLVWLQJXLVK� DPRQJ� DQG� FRXQW� EHOLHIV�� )XUWKHUPRUH�� WKH� GLVWLQFWLRQ� EHWZHHQ� HVVHQWLDO�DQG�QRQ�HVVHQWLDO�EHOLHIV�PD\�EH�YDJXH�RU EH�EHWWHU�YLHZHG�DV�D�VSHFWUXP�RI�EHOLHIV�ZLWK�YDU\LQJ� GHJUHHV�RI� LPSRUWDQFH�RU� FHQWUDOLW\� $GGLWLRQDOO\��RQH� VKRXOG� FRQVLGHU�WKDW� WKH�HSLVWHPLF�YDOXH�RI�D� V\VWHP�RI�EHOLHIV�PD\�EH� IDU�PRUH� WKDQ� WKH� VXP�RI� LWV�SDUWV� )LQDOO\��GXH� FRQVLGHUDWLRQ� VKRXOG� EH� JLYHQ� WR� WKH� VXVWDLQHG� DUJXPHQWDWLRQ� E\�:LOOLDP�$OVWRQ� WKDW� HSLVWHPLF� HYDOXDWLRQV�PD\� EH�PDGH� DFFRUGLQJ� WR� D� QXPEHU� RI�GLIIHUHQW�FULWHULD�WKDW�DUH�RIWHQ�FRQIXVHG�XQGHU�WKH�ODEHO�³MXVWLILFDWLRQ�´��&RPSOLFDWLRQV� EHFRPH� LQFUHDVLQJO\� PDQLIROG� ZKHQ� ZH� VZLWFK� IURP� EHOLHI�SOXUDOLVP�WR�DJHQW�SOXUDOLVP��,I�ZH�VHHN�WR�XQGHUVWDQG�ZKHWKHU�WZR�UHOLJLRQV�DUH�RQ�DQ�HSLVWHPLF�SDU�E\�FRQVLGHULQJ�WKH�MXVWLILFDWLRQ�WKDW�EHOLHYHUV�KDYH�RU�ODFN�ZLWK�UHVSHFW�WR� WKH� WHDFKLQJV� RI� WKH� UHOLJLRQ�� ,W�PD\� EH� WKDW� EHOLHYHUV� LQ� RQH� GHQRPLQDWLRQ� KDYH�EHWWHU� MXVWLILFDWLRQ� IRU� WKHLU� UHOLJLRXV� EHOLHIV� WKDQ�EHOLHYHUV� LQ� DQRWKHU� GHQRPLQDWLRQ�EHFDXVH�WKH\�DUH�EHWWHU�HGXFDWHG��:H�PLJKW�GHFLGH��WKHQ�WR�H[DPLQH�RQO\�WKH�EHOLHIV�RI�WKH�WRS�WKHRORJLDQV�LQ�WKH�YDULRXV�GHQRPLQDWLRQV��7KH�H[FOXVLYLVW�PLJKW�FODLP�WKDW�WKH�KLJKHVW� MXVWLILFDWLRQ� IRU� UHOLJLRXV�EHOLHIV� LV� IRXQG� LQ� WKH� MXVWLILFDWLRQ� WKDW� WKH� WRS��� :LOOLDP� 3�� $OVWRQ��%H\RQG�³-XVWLILFDWLRQ´��'LPHQVLRQV� RI� (SLVWHPLF�(YDOXDWLRQ���,WKDFD�� &RUQHOO�8QLYHUVLW\�3UHVV��������

Page 19: Plurality of Pluralisms

��

VFKRODUV�RI�WKH�IDYRUHG�UHOLJLRQ�KDYH�IRU�WKHLU�UHOLJLRXV�EHOLHIV��3HUKDSV�WKH�H[FOXVLYLVW�FRXOG�SURSRVH�D�UDWKHU�3LHUFHDQ�IRUP�RI�UHOLJLRXV�H[FOXVLYLVP�ZLWK�WKH�FODLP�WKDW�WKH�IDYRUHG�UHOLJLRQ�LV�HSLVWHPLFDOO\�VXSHULRU� WR�DOO�RWKHUV�LQ�WKH�VHQVH�WKDW�D�FRPPXQLW\�RI�LPSDUWLDO�LQYHVWLJDWRUV�ZRXOG�FRPH�WR�DFFHSW�WKH�HVVHQWLDO�EHOLHIV�RI�WKDW�UHOLJLRQ�LQ�WKH�ORQJ�UXQ�LI�WKH\�GHYRWHG�WKHPVHOYHV�WR�D�TXHVW�IRU�UHOLJLRXV�WUXWK��� 7KLV��KRZHYHU��ZRXOG� RQO\� EH� D� K\SRWKHVLV�� DQG� IRU� WKH� WLPH� EHLQJ�� WKHUH� LV� QR� FRQYHUJHQFH� RI�UHOLJLRXV�RSLQLRQV�LQ�VLJKW�:KDW�LV�YLVLEOH�LV�WKH�RSSRUWXQLW\�IRU�UDWLRQDO�GLVFXVVLRQ�DERXW�SRLQWV�RI�UHOLJLRXV�GLIIHUHQFH�� ,Q� RUGHU� IRU� VXFK� GLVFXVVLRQ� WR� DGYDQFH� IUXLWIXOO\�� LW� LV� QHFHVVDU\� IRU�SDUWLFLSDQWV�WR�WUHDW�RQH�DQRWKHU�ZLWK�D�FHUWDLQ�OHYHO�RI�HSLVWHPLF�UHVSHFW��DW�OHDVW�LQ�WKH�VHQVH�WKDW�ZH�VKRXOG�QRW�DVVXPH�WKDW�VRPHRQH�GRHV�QRW�DGMXGLFDWH�EHOLHIV�UDWLRQDOO\�PHUHO\�EHFDXVH�WKH\�DGKHUH�WR�D�GLIIHUHQW�UHOLJLRQ�WKDQ�ZH�DFFHSW��6R��WKHUH�LV�D�SULPD�IDFLH�PRUDO�UHDVRQ�IRU�KROGLQJ�WKDW�WKH�IROORZHUV�RI�WKH�PDMRU�WUDGLWLRQV�VKRXOG�QRW�EH�DVVXPHG� WR� EH� XQUHDVRQDEOH� LQ� WKHLU� EHOLHIV�� 7KLV� PD\� EH� FRQVLGHUHG� D� YHUVLRQ� RI�QRUPDWLYH�HSLVWHPLF�DJHQW�SOXUDOLVP���� $OHWKLF� UHOLJLRXV� SOXUDOLVP LV� DERXW� WKH� WUXWK� RI� EHOLHIV� UDWKHU� WKDQ� WKHLU�MXVWLILFDWLRQ�� 8QOLNH� HSLVWHPRORJLFDO� SOXUDOLVP�� WKHUH� LV� QR� GLYLVLRQ� KHUH� EHWZHHQ�EHOLHI�SOXUDOLVP�DQG�DJHQW�SOXUDOLVP��$Q�HTXDOLW\�SOXUDOLVP�KHUH�ZRXOG�EH�WKH�SRVLWLRQ�WKDW� DOO� WKH�PDMRU� UHOLJLRQV� DUH� HTXDOO\� WUXH��7KLV� SRVLWLRQ� FRXOG� EH� LQWHUSUHWHG� LQ� D�QXPEHU�RI�GLIIHUHQW�ZD\V��,W�ZRXOG�QRW�PDNH�PXFK�VHQVH�WR�VD\�WKDW�DOO�WKH�VWDWHPHQWV�LQ� WKH� FUHHGV� RI� HYHU\� PDMRU� UHOLJLRQ� DUH� HTXDOO\� WUXH�� EHFDXVH� WKH\� FRQWUDGLFW� RQH�DQRWKHU��2I� FRXUVH�� RQH� FRXOG� DGRSW� D� UHODWLYLVW� SRVLWLRQ� RQ� WUXWK�� EXW� WKDW� VHHPV� D�SUHWW\�KHDY\�SULFH�WR�SD\��$QRWKHU�ZD\�WR�DFFHSW�FRQWUDGLFWRU\�UHOLJLRXV�FODLPV�ZRXOG�EH�WR�DGRSW�ZKDW�ORJLFLDQV�FDOO�GLDOHWKHLVP��WKH�YLHZ�WKDW�VRPH�SURSRVLWLRQV�DUH�ERWK�WUXH� DQG� IDOVH��� $OWKRXJK� GLDOHWKHLVP� VHHPV� WR� EH� DFFHSWHG� E\� WKH� JUHDW� 6XIL�WKHRUHWLFLDQ� ,EQ� µ$UDEL��� LW� GRHV� QRW� DSSHDU� WR� EH� DQ� HVSHFLDOO\� SURPLVLQJ� ZD\� WR�UHVROYH� LQWHUUHOLJLRXV� FRQWUDGLFWLRQV�� 7KH� RUGLQDU\� ZD\� WR� EH� DQ� HTXDOLW\� SOXUDOLVW�DERXW� WUXWK� LV� WR�FODLP�WKDW� WKH�VDPH�DPRXQW�RI� WUXWK� LV� WR�EH� IRXQG� LQ� WKH�FUHHGV�RI�

�� 6HH�&KDUOHV�6DQGHUV� 3HLUFH�� ³6RPH�&RQVHTXHQFHV� RI� )RXU� ,QFDSDFLWLHV�´� LQ�7KH� (VVHQWLDO� 3HLUFH��9RO�����HG��1DWKDQ�+RXVHU�DQG�&KULVWLDQ�.ORHVHO���%ORRPLQJWRQ��,QGLDQD�8QLYHUVLW\�3UHVV�������������� 6HH�*UDKDP�3ULHVW��³'LDOHWKHLVP�´�7KH�6WDQIRUG�(QF\FORSHGLD�RI�3KLORVRSK\��:LQWHU������(GLWLRQ���(GZDUG�1��=DOWD��HG����85/� KWWS���SODWR�VWDQIRUG�HGX�DUFKLYHV�ZLQ�����HQWULHV�GLDOHWKHLVP���� 6HH�:LOOLDP�&��&KLWWLFN��7KH�6XIL�3DWK�RI�.QRZOHGJH��$OEDQ\��681<��������������������������

Page 20: Plurality of Pluralisms

��

HYHU\�UHOLJLRQ��7KH�REYLRXV�SUREOHP�KHUH�LV�WKDW�ZH�KDYH�QR�ZD\�WR�PHDVXUH�UHODWLYH�DPRXQWV�RI�WUXWK��:H�FDQQRW�MXVW�DGG�XS�WKH�EHOLHIV�DQG�VHH�KRZ�PDQ\�FRPH�RXW�WUXH�RQ�HDFK�OLVW�-RKQ� +LFN� KDV� VXJJHVWHG� DQRWKHU� ZD\� WR� GHIHQG� DOHWKLF� HTXDOLW\� SOXUDOLVP� E\�UHJDUGLQJ�DOO�RI�WKH�GLIIHUHQW�UHOLJLRQV�DV�LPSHUIHFW�UHIOHFWLRQV�RI�DQ�LQHIIDEOH�UHDOLW\���+LFN¶V� YLHZ� KDV� EHHQ� FULWLFL]HG� E\� $OVWRQ� DQG� 3ODQWLQJD��� 7KH� GLIILFXOWLHV� LQ� WKH�YDULRXV�DWWHPSWV�WR�UHFRQFLOH�WKH�FRQWUDGLFWLRQV�LQ�GRFWULQH�DPRQJ�WKH�YDULRXV�PDMRU�UHOLJLRXV�WUDGLWLRQV�VKRXOG�QRW�EOLQG�XV�WR�WKH�IDFW�WKDW�WKHUH�DUH�PDQ\�LPSRUWDQW�FODLPV�WKDW�DUH�VKDUHG�E\�WKH�EHOLHYHUV�RI�GLIIHUHQW�IDLWKV��VXFK�DV�WKH�UHMHFWLRQ�RI PDWHULDOLVP�DQG� WKH� DFFHSWDQFH� RI� D� YDULHW\� RI� FRPPRQ� PRUDO� WUXWKV�� 7KH� LQWHUSUHWDWLRQ� RI�VWDWHPHQWV�PDGH�LQ�YHU\�GLIIHUHQW�UHOLJLRXV�WUDGLWLRQV�FDQ�EH�VR�SHUSOH[LQJ�WKDW�$OVWRQ�XUJHV�KLV�UHDGHUV�³WR�H[HUFLVH�FDXWLRQ�LQ�VXSSRVLQJ�WKDW��HYHQ�JUDQWLQJ�FRPPRQDOLW\�RI�VXEMHFW��ZKDW� LV� VDLG�RI�*RG� LQ�+LQGX�SHUFHSWXDO� UHSRUWV� FRQWUDGLFWV�ZKDW� LV� VDLG�RI�*RG�LQ�&KULVWLDQ�SHUFHSWXDO�UHSRUWV�´��:H� PLJKW� EHJLQ� WR� FKDUDFWHUL]H� DQ� DWKHLVWLF� SRVLWLRQ� DV� RQH� WKDW� GHQLHV� DOO�UHOLJLRXV�WHDFKLQJV��EXW�DV�ZH�VDZ�LQ�WKH�GLVFXVVLRQ�RI�HSLVWHPRORJLFDO�SOXUDOLVP��WKLV�ZRXOG� QRW� EH� WHQDEOH� EHFDXVH� RI� WKH� H[LVWHQFH� RI� WUXWKV� DIILUPHG� E\� ERWK� UHOLJLRXV�EHOLHYHUV�DQG�DWKHLVWV��%\�DQDORJ\�WR�HSLVWHPLF�EHOLHI�DWKHLVP��ZH�PLJKW�GHILQH�DOHWKLF�DWKHLVP��$$��DV�WKH�YLHZ�WKDW�DOO�UHOLJLRQV�WHDFK�VRPH�IDOVHKRRGV�$$���U�S�7US��aS�)ROORZLQJ� WKH�DQDORJ\��RQH�PD\�EH�FKDUDFWHUL]HG�E\�DOHWKLF�H[FOXVLYLVP� �$(�� LI�RQH�LV�DQ�DOHWKLF�DWKHLVW�ZLWK�UHVSHFW�WR�HYHU\�UHOLJLRQ�EXW�RQH¶V�RZQ�$(���U�UzU o�S�7US��aS��,W�PD\� EH� DUJXHG� WKDW� WKLV� LV� D� FRQVHTXHQFH� RI� WKH� DVVHUWLRQ� RI� WKH� WUXWK� RI� WKH�WHDFKLQJV�RI�RQH¶V�RZQ�UHOLJLRQ�DQG�UHFRJQLWLRQ�WKDW�VRPH�RI�WKHVH�WHDFKLQJV�ZLOO�EH�LQ�FRQWUDGLFWLRQ�ZLWK�VRPH�RI�WKH�WHDFKLQJV�RI�HYHU\�RWKHU�UHOLJLRQ��IRU�RWKHUZLVH�WKH\�ZRXOG�QRW�EH�GLIIHUHQW�UHOLJLRQV �WKH�UHOLJLRXV�WHDFKLQJV�RI�QR�UHOLJLRQV�DUH�D�VXEVHW�RI�WKH�WHDFKLQJV�RI�DQ\�RWKHU�UHOLJLRQ���,I�VR��$(�FRXOG�DOVR�EH�IRUPXODWHG�DV�$(����S�7U SoS��� 6HH�+LFN����������� 6HH�:LOOLDP�3��$OVWRQ��3HUFLHYLQJ�*RG��7KH�(SLVWHPRORJ\�RI�5HOLJLRXV�([SHULHQFH� �,WKDFD��&RUQHOO�8QLYHUVLW\� 3UHVV�� ������ ��������� DQG� $OYLQ� 3ODQWLQJD�� :DUUDQWHG� &KULVWLDQ� %HOLHI�� �1HZ� <RUN��2[IRUG�8QLYHUVLW\�3UHVV����������������,�KDYH�DOVR�FULWLFL]HG�+LFNnV�YLHZ�RI�WKLV�LVVXH�LQ�0XKDPPDG�/HJHQKDXVHQ��,VODP�DQG�5HOLJLRXV�3OXUDOLVP���/RQGRQ��$O�+RGD������������������� $OVWRQ�������������

Page 21: Plurality of Pluralisms

��

2QH�PLJKW�GHQ\�$(� ZKLOH�FRQWLQXLQJ�WR�SURIHVV�EHOLHI�LQ�U ��DOWKRXJK�WKLV�ZRXOG�VHHP�WR�LQYROYH�VRPHWKLQJ�OLNH�WKH�SUHIDFH�SDUDGR[��+RZHYHU��WKHUH�DUH�YDULRXV�ZD\V�WR� GHIHQG� WKH� UDWLRQDOLW\� RI� DGPLVVLRQV� WKDW� WKH� WRWDOLW\� RI� ZKDW� RQH� DVVHUWV� PD\�FRQWDLQ�HUURUV��HYHQ�ZKHQ�RQH�DIILUPV�HDFK�DVVHUWLRQ�LQGLYLGXDOO\��,I�RQH� LV�JRLQJ� WR�DGPLW�WKDW�RQH¶V�RZQ�UHOLJLRXV�VFKRRO�RI�WKRXJKW�SURSDJDWHV�HUURUV �H�J���KDGLWKV�PD\�EH� DFFHSWHG� LQ� RQH¶V� VFKRRO� WKDW� DUH� QRW� DFFXUDWH��� FDXWLRQ�ZLOO� EH� QHHGHG� WR� DYRLG�GHQ\LQJ�RQH¶V� UHOLJLRQ��2QH�PLJKW� FODLP� WKDW� WKH�EDVLF� WHDFKLQJV�RI� WKH� UHOLJLRQ� DUH�VHFXUH�IURP�HUURU��EXW�DGPLW�WKDW�VFKRODUV�PD\�PDNH�PLVWDNHV�DERXW�WKH�ILQHU�SRLQWV�RI�VRPH�GRFWULQHV RU�KLVWRULFDO�GHWDLOV�8QLYHUVDO� DOHWKLF� SOXUDOLVP� �8$3��ZRXOG�EH�XQWHQDEOH�EHFDXVH� LW�ZRXOG� UHTXLUH�WKH�DIILUPDWLRQ�RI�FRQWUDGLFWRU\�VWDWHPHQWV�8$3���U�7USoS�$� WULYLDO� IRUP�RI� DOHWKLF�SOXUDOLVP� �7$3��PLJKW�EH� IRUPXODWHG� DV� WKH� FODLP� WKDW�HYHU\�PDMRU�UHOLJLRQ�WHDFKHV�VRPH�WUXWKV�7$3���U�S�7US��S�$� PRUH� VXEVWDQWLDO IRUP� RI� DOHWKLF� SOXUDOLVP� �6$3�� PLJKW� FODLP� WKDW� HYHU\�UHOLJLRXV� GHQRPLQDWLRQ� IDLOV� WR� WHDFK� VRPH� WUXWKV� WKDW� DUH� WDXJKW� LQ� RWKHU� UHOLJLRQV��DOWKRXJK�LW�LV�GLIILFXOW�WR�LPDJLQH�KRZ�VXFK�D�YLHZ�FRXOG�EH�GHIHQGHG�6$3���U�Uc�S�a7US��7UcS��S����5HOLJLRQV�DUH�QRW� WKHRULHV��QRU�FDQ� WKH\�EH� UHGXFHG� WR� WKHLU�FUHHGV��7KH\�DOVR�KDYH� D� SUDFWLFDO� VLGH�� 7KH� SUDFWLFDO� DVSHFW� RI� UHOLJLRQ� FDQ� JLYH� ULVH� WR� WZR� VRUWV� RI�SOXUDOLVP�� )LUVW�� RQH� PLJKW� FODLP� WKDW� WKH� PDMRU� UHOLJLRQV� FRXQVHO� HTXDOO\� QREOH�PRUDOLWLHV��HLWKHU�ZLWK�UHJDUG�WR�WKH�YDOXHV�WKH\�LQVWLOO��WKH�REOLJDWLRQV�WKH\�SODFH�XSRQ�WKHLU� DGKHUHQWV� RU� WKH� YLUWXHV� WKH\� HQFRXUDJH�� /HW¶V� FDOO� WKLV� HWKLFDO� UHOLJLRXV�SOXUDOLVP��/LNH�HSLVWHPRORJLFDO�SOXUDOLVP��HWKLFDO�SOXUDOLVP�PD\�WDNH�WKH�IRUP�RI�DQ�DJHQW� SOXUDOLVP RU� D� SUHFHSW� SOXUDOLVP�� $JHQW� HWKLFDO� SOXUDOLVP� KROGV� WKDW� WKH�DGKHUHQWV� RI� QR� SDUWLFXODU� UHOLJLRQ� KDYH� DQ\� VLJQLILFDQW� PRUDO� GLVWLQFWLRQ� RYHU� WKH�DGKHUHQWV� RI� DQ\� RWKHU�PDMRU� UHOLJLRQ��3UHFHSW� SOXUDOLVP� LV� WKH� FODLP� WKDW� WKH�PRUDO�SUHFHSWV�WDXJKW�E\�WKH�PDMRU�IDLWK�WUDGLWLRQV�DUH�HTXDOO\�ULJKW��2QFH�DJDLQ��WKLV�VRUW�RI�SOXUDOLVP�FDQ�EH�IRUPXODWHG�DV�DQ�HTXDOLW\�SOXUDOLVP�RU D�GHJUHH�SOXUDOLVP� 7KHUH�DUH�WZR�PDLQ� DSSURDFKHV� WR� HWKLFDO� SUHFHSW� HTXDOLW\� SOXUDOLVP��2QH�ZD\� LV� WR� DFFHSW� D�YHUVLRQ� RI�PRUDO� UHODWLYLVP��(DFK� UHOLJLRQ¶V�PRUDOLW\� LV� H[FHOOHQW� E\� LWV� RZQ� OLJKWV��

Page 22: Plurality of Pluralisms

��

DQG�WKHUH�LV�QR�DEVROXWH�SRVLWLRQ�IURP�ZKLFK�RQH�FRXOG�EH VDLG�WR�EH�EHWWHU�WKDQ�DQ\�RWKHU�� 7KH� RWKHU� ZD\�� ZKLFK� LV� PRUH� FRPPRQO\� SURSRVHG�� LV� WR� FODLP� WKDW� WKH�IXQGDPHQWDO�PRUDO�SULQFLSOHV�RI�DOO� WKH�PDMRU� UHOLJLRQV�ERLO�GRZQ� WR� VRPH�FRPPRQ�VHW�RI�PRUDO�SULQFLSOHV�VXFK�DV� WKH�JROGHQ�UXOH��DQG�WKDW� WKH�SDUWLFXODU�GLIIHUHQFHV� LQ�PRUDO�V\VWHPV�DUH�UHODWLYH�RU�RI�OHVV�VLJQLILFDQFH�WKDQ�ZKDW�LV�FRPPRQ����7KH�VHFRQG�VRUW�RI�SOXUDOLVP�WKDW�DULVHV�LQ�FRQVLGHUDWLRQ�RI�WKH�SUDFWLFDO�DVSHFW�RI�UHOLJLRQ�SHUWDLQV�WR�VSHFLILFDOO\�UHOLJLRXV�REOLJDWLRQV�LQVWHDG�RI�PRUDO�REOLJDWLRQV��,V�LW�SRVVLEOH�WR�IXOILOO�RQH¶V�UHOLJLRXV�REOLJDWLRQV�HTXDOO\�WKURXJK�DGKHUHQFH�WR�DQ\�RI�D�SOXUDOLW\�RI�UHOLJLRQV"�$�QHJDWLYH�DQVZHU�LV�JLYHQ�E\�WKRVH�ZKR�UHMHFW�GHRQWRORJLFDO�UHOLJLRXV�SOXUDOLVP��7KH\�KROG�WKDW�*RG�KDV�FRPPDQGHG�DOO�RI�PDQNLQG�DW WKH�SUHVHQW�WLPH� WR� DFFHSW� D� VSHFLILF� UHOLJLRQ�� &KRLFH� RI� UHOLJLRQ� LV� QRW� D� PDWWHU� RI� SHUVRQDO�SUHIHUHQFH��EXW�RI�REHGLHQFH�WR�GLYLQH�SUHVFULSWLRQ��+HUH�ZH�VKRXOG�DOVR�PHQWLRQ�D�GLVWLQFWLRQ�WKDW�PD\�EH�PDGH�EHWZHHQ�GLDFKURQLF�UHOLJLRXV�SOXUDOLVP�DQG�V\QFKURQLF UHOLJLRXV�SOXUDOLVP��$OWKRXJK�WKLV�GLVWLQFWLRQ�FRXOG�EH�DSSOLHG�WR�DQ\�RI�WKH�YDULRXV�W\SHV�RI�UHOLJLRXV�SOXUDOLVP�PHQWLRQHG�LQ�WKLV�SDSHU��LW�LV�SDUWLFXODUO\�UHOHYDQW�WR�GHRQWRORJLFDO�UHOLJLRXV�SOXUDOLVP��EHFDXVH�PDQ\�RI�WKH�PRVW�VWDXQFK� H[FOXVLYLVWV� ZLOO� DFFHSW� VRPH� IRUP� RI� GLDFKURQLF� UHOLJLRXV� SOXUDOLVP��DFFRUGLQJ� WR� ZKLFK� WKH� YDOXH� RI� D� UHOLJLRQ� PD\� EH� MXGJHG� GLIIHUHQWO\� DW� GLIIHUHQW�WLPHV�� VR� WKDW�� IRU� H[DPSOH�� &KULVWLDQLW\�PLJKW� KDYH� WKH� YDOXH� RI� EHLQJ� UHTXLUHG� E\�*RG�IRU�D�SHRSOH�IRU�D�VSHFLILF�SHULRG�RI�WLPH��EXW�QRW�SULRU�WR�WKDW�WLPH��'LDFKURQLF�UHOLJLRXV� SOXUDOLVP� LV� PRUH� HDV\� WR� DFFHSW� IRU� WKRVH� ZLWK� H[FOXVLYLVW� WHQGHQFLHV�EHFDXVH� WKHUH� LV� QR� TXHVWLRQ� RI� UHOLJLRXV� FKRLFH� EHLQJ� DUELWUDU\�� :KDW� VHHPV� WR�PRWLYDWH� PXFK� H[FOXVLYLVW� WKLQNLQJ� LV� WKH� LGHD� WKDW� WKH� FKRLFH� RI� RQH¶V� UHOLJLRXV�FRPPLWPHQWV� VKRXOG�EH�PDGH� LQ�DFFRUGDQFH�ZLWK�ZKDW�*RG�SUHVFULEHV�DQG�QRW�DV�D�PDWWHU�RI�SHUVRQDO�WDVWH�RU�ZKLPVLFDO�SUHIHUHQFH�7KRVH�ZKR�GHIHQG�UHOLJLRXV�SOXUDOLVP�XVXDOO\�WDNH�UHOLJLRXV�FKRLFH�WR�EH�D�PDWWHU�RI�SHUVRQDO�SUHIHUHQFH�EHFDXVH�RI� WKH�QRUPDWLYH�SOXUDOLVWLF�FODLP�WKDW�QR�RQH�VKRXOG�LPSRVH� RU� IRUFH� DQ\� UHOLJLRQ� RQ� DQ\RQH�� +RZHYHU�� QRUPDWLYH� DQG� GHRQWRORJLFDO�SOXUDOLVP� VKRXOG� QRW� EH� FRQIXVHG�� 2QH� PD\� HQGRUVH� QRUPDWLYH� SOXUDOLVP� ZKLOH�GHQ\LQJ�GHRQWRORJLFDO�SOXUDOLVP��WKDW�LV��RQH�PD\�DIILUP�WKDW�SHRSOH�VKRXOG�PDNH�WKHLU�UHOLJLRXV�FRPPLWPHQWV�LQ�DFFRUG�ZLWK�WKHLU�RZQ�SHUVRQDO�FRQVFLHQFHV��DQG�UHMHFW�WKH�QRWLRQ� WKDW� ZKDWHYHU� WKH\� GHFLGH� LV� LQ� DFFRUG� ZLWK� WKH� FRPPDQGV� JLYHQ� E\� *RG�

Page 23: Plurality of Pluralisms

��

WKURXJK�UHYHODWLRQ��,QGHHG� ,�ZRXOG DUJXH�WKDW�WKLV�VRUW�RI�SRVLWLRQ�LV�PRUH�FRQVLVWHQW�ZLWK�D�VRXQG�,VODPLF�WKHRORJ\�WKDQ�D�EODQNHW�DFFHSWDQFH�RI�SOXUDOLVP�(SLVWHPLF� DJHQW� SOXUDOLVP� LV� FORVHO\� UHODWHG� WR� GHRQWRORJLFDO� SOXUDOLVP��'HRQWRORJLFDO�H[FOXVLYLVP�KROG�WKDW�LW�LV�RQO\�E\�DGKHUHQFH�WR�D�IDYRUHG�UHOLJLRQ�WKDW�RQH�LV�DEOH�WR�IXOILOO�RQH¶V�UHOLJLRXV�GXWLHV��7KHUH�PD\�EH�D�JHQHUDO�REOLJDWLRQ�LPSRVHG�E\�*RG�WR�KXPDQLW\�WR�DFFHSW�D�JLYHQ�UHOLJLRQ��ZKLOH�DW�WKH�VDPH�WLPH�WKH�REOLJDWLRQ�PD\� EH� VXVSHQGHG� XQGHU� FHUWDLQ� FLUFXPVWDQFHV�� :H� 0XVOLPV� EHOLHYH� WKDW� ZH� DUH�REOLJHG�WR�REVHUYH�FHUWDLQ�GLHWDU\�UHVWULFWLRQV��IRU�H[DPSOH��EXW�WKDW�WKHVH�UHVWULFWLRQV�PD\�EH�ODZIXOO\�YLRODWHG�LQ�FDVH�RQH�LV�G\LQJ�RI�WKLUVW�RU�KXQJHU��2QH�LV�QRW�REOLJDWHG�WR�GR�ZKDW�LV�QRW�SRVVLEOH�IRU�RQH�WR�DFFRPSOLVK��,I�RQH�LV�XQDEOH�WR�SURYLGH�HSLVWHPLF�MXVWLILFDWLRQ�IRU�EHOLHI�LQ�,VODP��DQG�KHQFH�LV�XQDEOH�WR�EHOLHYH��WKHQ�ZH�FDQQRW�H[SHFW�WKH�REOLJDWLRQ�WR�EHOLHYH�WR�DSSO\�WR�WKLV�SHUVRQ��2XJKW�LPSOLHV�FDQ��,I�RQH�FDQQRW��DQ\�REOLJDWLRQ�LV�VXVSHQGHG�,Q�FRQVLGHUDWLRQ�RI�WKH�HSLVWHPLF�IDFWRUV�FRQFHUQLQJ�WKH�REOLJDWLRQ�WR�EHOLHYH��ZH�FDQ� FRQVLGHU� D� GLVWLQFWLRQ� EHWZHHQ� GHRQWRORJLFDO� EHOLHI� SOXUDOLVP� DQG� GHRQWRORJLFDO�DJHQW� SOXUDOLVP�� $FFRUGLQJ� WR� GHRQWRORJLFDO� EHOLHI� SOXUDOLVP� �'%3��� *RG� SHUPLWV�KXPDQ�EHLQJV�WR�SLFN�IURP�DPRQJ�WKH�PDMRU�WUDGLWLRQV�DQ\�UHOLJLRQ�WKH\�OLNH��7KHUH�LV�QR� UHOLJLRQ� WR�ZKLFK�*RG�FRPPDQGV�DGKHUHQFH� WR� WKH�H[FOXVLRQ�RI�DQ\� RWKHU��/HW¶V�VD\�WKDW�UHOLJLRQ�U�LV�SHUPLWWHG E\�*RG�IRU�KXPDQLW\�DW�WLPH�W�DQG�ORFDWLRQ�O�ZLWK�WKH�DEEUHYLDWLRQ�3UWO��'%3���U�W QRZ� O RXU�ORFDWLRQo 3UWO�7KLV�IRUPXODWLRQ�LV�FRQVLVWHQW�ZLWK�WKH�LGHD�WKDW�*RG�PD\�KDYH�DOORZHG�RQO\�RQH�UHOLJLRQ� WR�EH� DGRSWHG� LQ� WKH�(J\SW�RI�0RVHV�RU� LQ� WKH�3XQMDE�RI�1DQDN�� EXW� DW� WKH�SUHVHQW�WLPH�DQG�ORFDOH��DOO�WKH�PDMRU�UHOLJLRXV�WUDGLWLRQV�DUH�DFFHSWDEOH�'HRQWRORJLFDO�EHOLHI�H[FOXVLYLVP �'%(��� WR� WKH�FRQWUDU\��KROGV� WKDW�DW�DQ\�JLYHQ�WLPH�DQG�ORFDOH��WKHUH�LV�RQH�UHOLJLRQ�WKDW�*RG�UHTXLUHV�IRU�DOO�RI�KXPDQLW\��'%(���W�O�U�Uc�3UcWOlU Uc�'HRQWRORJLFDO�DJHQW�SOXUDOLVP��RQ�WKH�RWKHU�KDQG� LV�D�YLHZ�RI�ZKDW�*RG�SHUPLWV�IRU� D� JLYHQ� DJHQW� ZLWK� UHVSHFW� WR� WKH� DGRSWLRQ� RI� D� UHOLJLRQ�� JLYHQ� WKH� DJHQW¶V�HSLVWHPLF� VLWXDWLRQ� DQG� RWKHU� OLPLWDWLRQV�� /HW¶V� DEEUHYLDWH� WKH� SURSRVLWLRQ� WKDW� *RG�SHUPLWV�[ WR�DGRSW�UHOLJLRQ�U DW�W�DQG�O�DV�3[UWO��:H�FDQ�GLVWLQJXLVK�WZR�VRUWV�RI�DJHQW�SOXUDOLVP��$FFRUGLQJ�WR�WKH�ILUVW�W\SH��'$3����*RG�DOORZV�VRPH�DJHQWV�WR�SLFN�IURP�DQ\�RI�WKH�PDMRU�WUDGLWLRQV��

Page 24: Plurality of Pluralisms

��

'$3����[�U�W�O �3[UWO�$FFRUGLQJ� WR� WKH� VHFRQG� W\SH� �'$3���� *RG�PHUHO\� DOORZV� WKDW� GLIIHUHQW� DJHQWV�PD\�EH�SHUPLWWHG�WR�DGRSW�GLIIHUHQW�UHOLJLRQV�JLYHQ�WKHLU�FLUFXPVWDQFHV��'$3����[�\�W�O�U�Uc�3[UWO��3\UcWO��UzUc�1RWH�WKDW�'%(�LV�FRPSDWLEOH�ZLWK�'$3���,W�PD\�EH�WKH�FDVH�WKDW�*RG�FRPPDQGV�,VODP�IRU�DOO�RI�KXPDQLW\�DW�D�JLYHQ�WLPH�DQG�ORFDWLRQ��ZKLOH�DOORZLQJ�LQGLYLGXDOV�ZKR�DUH�XQDEOH�IRU�VRPH�UHDVRQ�WR�DFFHSW�,VODP�WR�EH�JXLGHG�E\�+LP�WKURXJK�VRPH�RWKHU�IDLWK�WUDGLWLRQ�2WKHU� YDULDQWV� FRXOG� DOVR� EH� IRUPXODWHG�� H�J��� DFFRUGLQJ� WR� ZKLFK� *RG� DOORZV�VRPH�DJHQWV� WR�SLFN�IURP�D� OLPLWHG�QXPEHU�RI� UHOLJLRQV��RU�DFFRUGLQJ WR�ZKLFK�*RG�UHTXLUHV�GLIIHUHQW�UHOLJLRXV�EHOLHIV�IURP�D�VLQJOH�LQGLYLGXDO�LQ�GLIIHUHQW�FLUFXPVWDQFHV��DV��DFFRUGLQJ�WR�,VODP��*RG�UHTXLUHG�&KULVWLDQLW\�RI�VRPH�SHRSOH�EHIRUH�WKH�DGYHQW�RI�,VODP��DQG�,VODP�DIWHUZDUG����7KH�VRUW�RI�SOXUDOLVP�DGYDQFHG�E\ ZULWHUV� VXFK�DV�5DPDNULVKQD� �������������0DGDPH� %ODYDWVN\� ������������� 5HQp� *XpQRQ ������������ DQG� )ULWKMRI� 6FKXRQ�������������FRXOG�EH�FDOOHG�KHUPHWLF�UHOLJLRXV�SOXUDOLVP��$FFRUGLQJ� WR� WKLV�VRUW�RI�UHOLJLRXV�SOXUDOLVP��DOWKRXJK�UHOLJLRQV�DUH�GLIIHUHQW�H[RWHULFDOO\��WKH\�VKDUH�D�FRPPRQ�HVRWHULF�FRUH��$OWKRXJK�WKH�WKHVLV�RI�KHUPHWLF�SOXUDOLVP�LV�FKDUDFWHULVWLFDOO\�OHIW�UDWKHU�YDJXH��LW�LV�RIWHQ�SUHVHQWHG�DV�WKH�FODLP�WKDW�WKH�PDMRU�UHOLJLRQV�OHDG�WR�WKH�VDPH�JRDO��ZKLFK�LV�D�FHUWDLQ�SHUHQQLDO�ZLVGRP�WKDW�FRPSULVHV�YDULRXV�PHWDSK\VLFDO�SULQFLSOHV��$�KHUPHWLF� SOXUDOLVW� FRXOG� FODLP� WKDW� WKH� UHOLJLRQV� DUH� HTXDOO\� HIIHFWLYH� PHDQV� IRU�UHDFKLQJ�WKLV�NQRZOHGJH��RU�PHUHO\�WKDW�WKH�XOWLPDWH�ZLVGRP�LV�WKH�VDPH��RU�WKDW�VRPH�HVVHQWLDO�SRUWLRQ�RI�LW�LV�FRPPRQ�WR�WKH�HVRWHULF�WUDGLWLRQV�RI�WKH�PDMRU�UHOLJLRQV�

9��5HGXFWLYH�DQG�1RQ�5HGXFWLYH�3OXUDOLVPV5HOLJLRXV� SOXUDOLVPV� RI� DQ\� RI� WKH� YDULHWLHV� GHVFULEHG� DERYH� PD\� EH� HLWKHU�UHGXFWLYH� RU� QRQ�UHGXFWLYH�� 5HGXFWLYH� SOXUDOLVWV� KROG� WKDW� DOO� WKH� PDMRU� UHOLJLRXV�WUDGLWLRQV�RU�DW�OHDVW�VRPH�SOXUDOLW\�RI�GHQRPLQDWLRQV�VKDUH�VRPH�GHJUHH�RI�D�YDOXH�LQ�WHUPV�RI�ZKLFK�GLIIHUHQW�VRUWV�RI�SOXUDOLVP�DUH�GHILQHG�EHFDXVH�RI�VRPH�HOHPHQW�WKDW�LV�FRPPRQ� WR� WKHP��6R�� IRU� H[DPSOH�� WKH� KHUPHWLF� UHOLJLRXV� SOXUDOLVWV� JHQHUDOO\� FODLP�WKDW�GLIIHUHQW�UHOLJLRQV�OHDG�WR�WKH�VDPH�JRDO�EHFDXVH�RI�FRPPRQ�HVRWHULF�SULQFLSOHV��7KLV� VRUW� RI� UHOLJLRXV� SOXUDOLVP� LV� UHGXFWLYH EHFDXVH� LW� UHGXFHV� WKH� HVVHQFH� RI� D�

Page 25: Plurality of Pluralisms

��

UHOLJLRQ� WR� WKH� FRPPRQ� HOHPHQWV� LW� VKDUHV�ZLWK�RWKHU� UHOLJLRQV��:KDW� LV� QRW� KHOG� LQ�FRPPRQ� ZLWK� WKH� RWKHU� UHOLJLRQV� LV� VHHQ� DV� ZLQGRZ� GUHVVLQJ� RU� FXOWXUDO�DFFRXWUHPHQWV��1RQ�UHGXFWLYH�UHOLJLRXV�SOXUDOLVP��RQ�WKH�RWKHU�KDQG��KROGV�WKDW�ZKDW�LV�XQLTXH�WR�D� YDULHW\� RI� UHOLJLRQV� PD\� EH� ZKDW� JLYHV� WKHP� YDOXH�� $Q� H[WUHPH� IRUP� RI� QRQ�UHGXFWLYH�UHOLJLRXV�SOXUDOLVP�ZRXOG�KROG�WKDW�ZKDWHYHU�YDOXH�DQ\�UHOLJLRQ�KDV�PXVW�EH�GXH�WR�HOHPHQWV�XQLTXH�WR�LW�7KHUH� LV�QR�UHDVRQ� IRU� WKLQNLQJ� WKDW� WKLV�VRUW�RI�SOXUDOLVP�PLJKW�EH� WUXH� ,QGHHG��YHU\�JRRG�D�SULRUL�UHDVRQV�FDQ�EH�IRXQG�IRU�UHMHFWLQJ�H[WUHPH�QRQ�UHGXFWLYH�UHOLJLRXV�SOXUDOLVP� 6XSSRVH� WKDW�RQH�KROGV� WKDW�D YDOXH� LQ� WHUPV�RI�ZKLFK�UHOLJLRQV�DUH� WR�EH�MXGJHG� LV� WKHLU� HQFRXUDJHPHQW� RI� WKHLU� IROORZHUV� WR� OHDG�PRUDO� OLYHV�� ([WUHPH� QRQ�UHGXFWLYH�UHOLJLRXV�SOXUDOLVP�ZRXOG�EH�FRPPLWWHG�WR�WKH�YLHZ�WKDW�WKHUH�FRXOG�EH�QR�FRPPRQ�HOHPHQWV�LQ�WKH�PRUDO�V\VWHPV�VXSSRUWHG�E\�GLIIHUHQW�UHOLJLRQV�WKDW�KDYH�WKLV�YDOXH��DQG�VXFK�D�YLHZ�LV�SDWHQWO\�DEVXUG�$�PRUH�PRGHUDWH�IRUP�RI�QRQ�UHGXFWLYH�UHOLJLRXV�SOXUDOLVP�ZRXOG�KROG�WKDW�*RG�JXLGHV�SHRSOH� WKURXJK�WKH�XQLTXH�IHDWXUHV�RI� WKH�YDULRXV�UHOLJLRQV�+H�SUHVFULEHV�IRU�WKHP LQ�FRPELQDWLRQ�ZLWK�IHDWXUHV�WKDW�DUH�VKDUHG�E\�RWKHU�UHOLJLRQV���:KHQ� WKH�YDULHWLHV�RI� UHOLJLRXV�SOXUDOLVP�DUH� VHW�RXW�DQG�DQDO\]HG�� LW� VHHPV� WKDW�WKHUH�DUH�PDQ\�IRUPV�WKDW�ZLOO�QRW�VWDQG�XS�WR�DQDO\VLV��:LWK�UHJDUG�WR�VRWHULRORJLFDO�SOXUDOLVP��IRU�H[DPSOH��WKH�SUREOHPV�RI�WKH�GLYHUVLW\�RI�UHOLJLRXV�JRDOV�VHHPV�WR�PDNH�WKH� TXHVWLRQ� TXLWH� SUREOHPDWLF�� ,W� ZRXOG� VHHP� WKDW� ERWK� H[FOXVLYLVP� DQG� SOXUDOLVP�ZLWK� UHJDUG� WR� VRWHULRORJ\� UHTXLUH�D� UDWKHU�FKLOGLVK�YLHZ�RI� WKH� UHOLJLRXV� OLIH�DQG� LWV�JRDOV��:H�PLJKW�DIILUP�SOXUDOLVP�DV�D�UHMHFWLRQ�RI�WKH�VLPSOLVWLF�YLHZ�WKDW�RQH�ZLOO�EH�GDPQHG� E\� *RG� IRU� ODFNLQJ� PHPEHUVKLS� LQ� VRPH� IDYRUHG� FRQJUHJDWLRQ�� %XW� WKLV�VKRXOG� QRW� EH� FRQIXVHG�ZLWK� WKH� LGHD� WKDW� LW�PDNHV�QR� GLIIHUHQFH�ZKDW� UHOLJLRQ� RQH�KROGV� WR�ZKHUH�RQH�ZLOO� HQG�XS� LQ� WKH� DIWHUOLIH��6XUHO\�� WKH� FKRLFHV�RQH�PDNHV�ZLWK�UHVSHFW�WR�UHOLJLRXV�DIILOLDWLRQ�ZLOO�KDYH�DQ�HIIHFW�RI�ZKDW�RQH�XOWLPDWHO\�PDNHV�RXW�RI�RQH¶V�OLIH��0RUH�WKDQ�WKLV��ZH�FDQ�RQO\�OHDYH�WR�*RG¶V�PHUF\�DQG�ZLVGRP�:LWK� UHVSHFW� WR� QRUPDWLYH� UHOLJLRXV� SOXUDOLVP�� ,� ZRXOG� XUJH� D� QRQ�UHGXFWLYH�UHOLJLRXV� SOXUDOLVP��5HVSHFW� VKRXOG� EH� VKRZQ� WR� WKH�PHPEHUV� RI� GLIIHUHQW� UHOLJLRXV�WUDGLWLRQV�QRW�PHUHO\�EHFDXVH�RI�RXU�FRPPRQ�KXPDQLW\��EXW�EHFDXVH�RI�ZKDW�LV�XQLTXH��� 7KLV�YLHZ�LV�GHIHQGHG�LQ�/HJHQKDXVHQ��������

Page 26: Plurality of Pluralisms

��

LQ� HDFK� FRPPXQLW\�� 7KLV� LV� FRPSOHWHO\� FRQVLVWHQW� ZLWK� DQ� DGPLVVLRQ� WKDW� ZH� RZH�PHPEHUV�RI�RXU�RZQ�FRPPXQLW\�VSHFLDO�REOLJDWLRQV�:LWK� UHJDUG� WR� HSLVWHPRORJLFDO� UHOLJLRXV� SOXUDOLVP�� LI� ZH� WDNH� LQWR� DFFRXQW� WKH�YDULRXV�VWDQGDUGV�RI�UDWLRQDOLW\�WKDW�PD\�EH�IRXQG�LQ�FRPPXQLWLHV�WKDW�KDYH�GLIIHUHQW�VWDQGDUGV�RI�ORJLFDO�UHDVRQLQJ��H�J���1\D\D��$ULVWRWHOLDQ�ORJLF�LQ�WKH�,VODPLF�WUDGLWLRQ��PRGHUQ�V\PEROLF�ORJLF��HWF���D�FDVH�FRXOG�EH�PDGH�IRU�D�QRQ�UHGXFWLYH�LQWHUSUHWDWLRQ�RI� WKH� QRUPDWLYH� HSLVWHPLF� DJHQW� SOXUDOLVP� VXJJHVWHG� HDUOLHU�� %HOLHYHUV� LQ� GLIIHUHQW�WUDGLWLRQV�PD\�KDYH�MXVWLILFDWLRQV�IRU�WKHLU�EHOLHIV�WKDW�DW�OHDVW�LQ�SDUW�DUH�GHSHQGHQW�WR�FRJQLWLYH�VWDQGDUGV�WKDW�DUH�XQLTXH�WR�WKHLU�RZQ�WUDGLWLRQV���:LWK�UHVSHFW�WR�DOHWKLF�SOXUDOLVP��,�DP�VNHSWLFDO�RI�WKH�DWWHPSWV�PDNH�E\�+LFN�DQG�RWKHUV� ZKR� KDYH� VRXJKW� WR� UHFRQFLOH� FRQIOLFWLQJ� UHOLJLRXV� WUXWKV�� ,� WKLQN� LW� LV� QRW�XQUHDVRQDEOH�QRU�WKHRORJLFDOO\�XQDFFHSWDEOH�WR�DOORZ�WKDW�6$3�PD\�EH�WUXH��DOWKRXJK�,�ZRXOG�EH�FDXWLRXV�DERXW�VXFK�DQ�DIILUPDWLRQ��EHFDXVH�LW�VHHPV�WR�PH�WKDW�LW ZRXOG�EH�DQ�LPSRVVLEO\�GLIILFXOW�WDVN�WR�ILQG�VXIILFLHQW�HYLGHQFH�IRU�LW�$�QRQ�UHGXFWLYH�YHUVLRQ�RI�6$3��6$153��ZRXOG�KROG�WKDW�HYHU\ UHOLJLRQ�WHDFKHV�VRPH�WUXWKV�XQLTXH�WR�LW�6$153���U�S�7US��S���Uc�7UcSoU Uc��3HUKDSV�WKLV�YLHZ�FRXOG�EH�GHIHQGHG�LQ ,VODPLF� WKHRORJ\�E\�DUJXLQJ�WKDW� LQ�HDFK�UHOLJLRXV� WUDGLWLRQ� WKHUH� DUH� WUXWKV� WDXJKW�DERXW� WKH� IRXQGHU�RI� WKDW� WUDGLWLRQ� WKDW�DUH�QRW� WDXJKW� LQ�DQ\�RWKHU� WUDGLWLRQ��$\DWXOODK�0LVEDK�� IRU�H[DPSOH��KDV�VXJJHVWHG� WKDW�WKHUH�PLJKW�EH�VRPH�WUXWKV�DERXW�-HVXV��SHDFH�EH�ZLWK�KLP��WKDW�DUH� WDXJKW�E\�VRPH�&KULVWLDQV�EXW�WKDW�FDQQRW�EH�IRXQG�WKH�QDUUDWLRQV�DERXW�-HVXV�LQ�WKH�6KLµL�FROOHFWLRQV��7KLV�PD\�EH�VR HLWKHU�EHFDXVH�WKH�,PDPV�DQG�WKH�3URSKHW��VDOXWDWLRQV�XSRQ�KLP DQG�KLV�SURJHQ\��FRQVLGHUHG�WKHVH�WUXWKV XQQHFHVVDU\� RU�EHFDXVH�WKH�QDUUDWLRQV�ZHUH�ORVW�RU� IRU� VRPH� RWKHU� UHDVRQ NQRZQ� RQO\� WR� *RG�� 7KLV� LQVLJKW� FRXOG� EH� H[SUHVVHG� E\�VSHFXODWLQJ�WKDW�ZKDW�PLJKW�EH�FRUUHFW�PD\�EH D�PRUH�PRGHUDWH�IRUP�RI�DOHWKLF�QRQ�UHGXFWLYH�SOXUDOLVP��0$153��WKDW�ZRXOG�PHUHO\�FODLP�WKDW�WKHUH�DUH�VRPH�GLIIHUHQW�UHOLJLRQV�HDFK�RI�ZKLFK�WHDFKHV�WUXWKV�XQLTXH�WR�LW��0$153�� �U�Uc�S�T�UzUc � 7US�� S� � �Ucc�7UccSoU Ucc�� � 7UcT�� T���Ucc�7UccToUc Ucc���� 7KLV�VRUW�RI�SRLQW�PD\�EH�VXSSRUWHG�WR�VRPH�H[WHQW�E\�WKH�VRUW�RI�DUJXPHQWDWLRQ�RQH�ILQGV�LQ�$ODVGDLU�0DF,QW\UHnV�:KRVH�-XVWLFH"�:KLFK�5DWLRQDOLW\"��1RWUH�'DPH��8QLYHUVLW\�RI�1RWUH�'DPH�3UHVV��������

Page 27: Plurality of Pluralisms

��

$V� IRU� HWKLFDO� UHOLJLRXV� SOXUDOLVP�� WKH� DJHQW� YDULHW\� WKLV� ZRXOG� VHHP� WR� EH�H[SOLFLWO\�GHQLHG�E\�FODLPV�RI�WKH�PRUDO�VXSHULRULW\�RI�WKH�3URSKHW��V��RYHU�DOO�KXPDQ�EHLQJV��7KLV�ZRXOG� VWLOO� EH� FRPSDWLEOH�ZLWK� D� QRQ�UHGXFWLYH� DJHQW� HWKLFDO� SOXUDOLVP�DFFRUGLQJ�WR�ZKLFK�HDFK�SURSKHW�KDV�VRPH�SHFXOLDU�SUDLVHZRUWK\�PRUDO�FKDUDFWHU�WUDLW�WKDW�LV�XQLTXH�WR�KLP�DORQH��$V�IRU�SUHFHSW�SOXUDOLVP��LW�ZRXOG�QRW�EH�KDUG�WR�VKRZ�WKDW�D� GLDFKURQLF� YHUVLRQ� RI� QRQ�UHGXFWLYH� SUHFHSW� SOXUDOLVP� LV� FRQVLVWHQW� ZLWK� WKH�WHDFKLQJV� RI� ,VODP�� ,I� D� V\QFKURQLF� YHUVLRQ� LV� WR� EH� GHIHQGHG�� WKH� PRVW� SODXVLEOH�SRVLWLRQ�ZRXOG EH�D�GHJUHH�SOXUDOLVP�LQ�ZKLFK�YDULRXV�PRUDO�V\VWHPV�DUH�DFFHSWHG�DV�SDVVLQJ�VRPH�PLQLPDO�VWDQGDUG��DOWKRXJK�LW� LV�DOORZHG�WKDW� WKH�PRUDOV� WDXJKW�E\�RXU�RZQ� UHOLJLRQ� DUH� VXSHULRU� WR� DOO� ULYDOV�� 7KLV� FRXOG� EH� IRUPXODWHG� LQ� D� QRQ�UHGXFWLYH�YHUVLRQ� DFFRUGLQJ WR�ZKLFK�HDFK�PRUDO� V\VWHP� WKDW�SDVVHV� WKH� VWDQGDUG�KDV� IHDWXUHV�XQLTXH�WR�LW�:LWK�UHJDUG�WR�GHRQWRORJLFDO�UHOLJLRXV�SOXUDOLVP��D�QRQ�UHGXFWLYH�YHUVLRQ�RI�'$3��ZRXOG�VHHP�SODXVLEOH�$� QRQ�UHGXFWLYH� IRUP� RI� KHUPHWLF� SOXUDOLVP� FRXOG� EH� IRUPXODWHG� DFFRUGLQJ WR�ZKLFK�WUXWKV�DUH�GLYLGHG�LQWR�WKH�HVRWHULF�DQG�H[RWHULF�DQG�0$153�LV�KHOG�WR�EH�WUXH�ZKHQ�WKH�SURSRVLWLRQDO�YDULDEOHV�DUH�WDNHQ�WR�UDQJH�RYHU�HVRWHULF�WUXWKV�,Q�FRQFOXVLRQ��D�VXUYH\�RI�WKH�UDQJH�RI�W\SHV�RI�UHOLJLRXV�SOXUDOLVP�WKDW�FRXOG�EH�GHEDWHG� E\ UHDVRQDEOH� WKHRORJLDQV� RI� YDULRXV� WUDGLWLRQV� ZRXOG� LQGLFDWH� WKDW� LW� LV� D�PLVWDNH�IRU�RQH�WR�FKDUDFWHUL]H�RQH¶V�SRVLWLRQ�DV�DQ�HQGRUVHPHQW�RU�GHQLDO�RI�UHOLJLRXV�SOXUDOLVP�� ,QGHHG�� WKH� DUHD� WKDW� KDV� EHHQ� JLYHQ� WKH�PRVW� DWWHQWLRQ� LQ� SKLORVRSKLFDO�WKHRORJ\��VRWHULRORJLFDO� SOXUDOLVP�� LV� RQH� LQ�ZKLFK�SOXUDOLVWLF� DQG� H[FOXVLYLVW� FODLPV�RIWHQ�WXUQ�RXW�WR�EH�DEVXUG��:LWK�UHJDUG�WR�WKH�RWKHU�DUHD�WKDW�KDV�JHQHUDWHG�WKH�PRVW�GLVFXVVLRQ�� QRUPDWLYH� SOXUDOLVP�� ZKDW� LV� PRVW� VLJQLILFDQW� LV� QRW� ZKHWKHU� RQH� LV� D�SOXUDOLVW� RU� QRW�� EHFDXVH� HYHU\RQH� ZLOO� DJUHH� ZLWK� SOXUDOLVP� ZLWK� UHVSHFW� WR� VRPH�ULJKWV�DQG�REOLJDWLRQV��7KH�TXHVWLRQ�WR�FRQVLGHU�LV�ZKDW�ULJKWV�DQG�REOLJDWLRQV�DUH�WR�EH� FRQVLGHUHG� VSHFLDOO\� GR� WR� RQH¶V� FRUHOLJLRQLVWV�� DQG� ZKHWKHU� VXFK� VSHFLDO�REOLJDWLRQV�FDQ�MXVWLI\�SROLWLFDO�PHDVXUHV�WR�HVWDEOLVK�D�SDUWLFXODU�GHQRPLQDWLRQ�DV�WKH�RIILFLDO�UHOLJLRQ�RI�WKH�VWDWH��6XFK�DUJXPHQWV�ZLOO�WDNH�GLIIHUHQW�IRUPV�ZKHQ�WKH\�DUH�EDVHG�RQ�(QJOLVK�ODZ�DQG�$QJOLFDQ�WKHRORJ\�DQG�ZKHQ�WKH\�DUH�EDVHG�RQ�,VODPLF�ODZ�DQG� WKHRORJ\�� 7KH� GLIIHUHQFHV�� KRZHYHU�� VKRXOG� QRW� EH� FDVW� DV� D� GHEDWH� EHWZHHQ�SOXUDOLVP�DQG�H[FOXVLYLVP�)RUPV� RI� UHOLJLRXV� SOXUDOLVP� WKDW� ORRN� SURPLVLQJ� RU� DW� OHDVW� ZRUWK\� RI� IXUWKHU�FRQVLGHUDWLRQ� LQFOXGH� WKH� YHUVLRQV� RI� QRQ�UHGXFWLYH� UHOLJLRXV� SOXUDOLVP� PHQWLRQHG�

Page 28: Plurality of Pluralisms

��

DERYH�� LQFOXGLQJ� YHUVLRQV� RI� QRQ�UHGXFWLYH� QRUPDWLYH� SOXUDOLVP�� QRQ�UHGXFWLYH�QRUPDWLYH� HSLVWHPLF� DJHQW� SOXUDOLVP�� HSLVWHPLF� GHJUHH� SOXUDOLVP� ZLWK� UHVSHFW� WR�YDULRXV� IRUPV� RI� MXVWLILFDWLRQ�� 6$153� DV� D� YHUVLRQ� RI� DOHWKLF� SOXUDOLVP�� DQDORJRXV�IRUPV� RI� QRQ�UHGXFWLYH HWKLFDO� SOXUDOLVP�� GLDFKURQLF� GHRQWRORJLFDO� SOXUDOLVP� DQG�'$3���ERWK�RI�ZKLFK�ZRXOG�EH�QRQ�UHGXFWLYH�LQ�WKH�VHQVH�WKDW�WKH\�DUH�QRW�EDVHG�RQ�VRPH�FRPPRQ�HOHPHQW�WKDW�LV�VXIILFLHQW�WR�VHFXUH�WKH�UHOHYDQW�SHUPLVVLELOLW\��DQG�DQ�HVRWHULF�YHUVLRQ�RI�6$153�6R��DOWKRXJK�,�KDYH�DUJXHG�WKDW�VHYHUDO�SODXVLEOH�IRUPV�RI�QRQ�UHGXFWLYH�UHOLJLRXV�SOXUDOLVP�PLJKW�EH�GHIHQGHG��WKH�PDLQ�FRQWRXUV�WKDW�GHEDWHV�DERXW�UHOLJLRXV�SOXUDOLVP�KDYH� WDNHQ� DUH� PLVOHDGLQJ� EHFDXVH� WKH\� JORVV� RYHU� LPSRUWDQW� GLVWLQFWLRQV�� ZKLFK��ZKHQ� XQFRYHUHG�� UHYHDO� WKDW� WKH� PRUDO� DQG� WKHRORJLFDO� SRVLWLRQV� WKDW� PRWLYDWH� WKH�GHEDWH� ZRXOG� EH� PRUH� DSSURSULDWHO\� DGGUHVVHG� E\� FRQVLGHULQJ� VXFK� LVVXHV� DV� WKH�QDWXUH� RI� VDOYDWLRQ�� GLYLQH� JXLGDQFH� DQG� WKH� ULJKWV� DQG� REOLJDWLRQV� IRU� UHOLJLRXV�JURXSV� LQ�YDULRXV� VRFLHWLHV��:LWK� UHJDUG� WR� VXFK�TXHVWLRQV�� UHOLJLRXV�SOXUDOLVP� WXUQV�RXW�WR�EH�OHVV�VLJQLILFDQW�WKDQ�LV�RIWHQ�LPDJLQHG�