Upload
kate-kim
View
222
Download
6
Embed Size (px)
DESCRIPTION
sdfser
Citation preview
PLDT VS CAPLDT vs. CAFacts: On July, 30, 1968, respn!ent spuses "ste#an $a! t$e%r &eep ran ver a san! ' eart$ an! 'ell %nt an pen trenc$, an e(cavat%n alle)e!ly un!erta*en #y PLDT 'r t$e %nstallat%n ' %ts un!er)run! cn!u%t syste+. ,espn!ent Antn% "ste#an 'a%le! t nt%ce t$e pen trenc$ -$%c$ -as le't uncvere! #ecause ' t$e creep%n) !ar*ness an! t$e lac* ' -arn%n) l%)$t r s%)ns. ,espn!ent spuses su''ere! p$ys%cal %n&ur%es an! t$e%r &eeps -%n!s$%el! -as s$attere!. PLDT alle)e! t$at t$e respn!ents -ere ne)l%)ent an! t$at %t s$ul! #e t$e %n!epen!ent cntractr L.,. .arte an! C+pany -$%c$ un!ert* sa%! cn!u%t syste+ t #e t$e ne l%a#le.T$e latter cla%+e! t $ave c+pl%e! -%t$ %ts cntract an! $a! %nstalle! necessary #arr%ca!es./ssue: 0O1 PLDT an! L.,. .arte an! C. are l%a#le.,ul%n): Pr%vate ,espn!ent2s ne)l%)ence -as nt +erely cntr%#utry #ut )es t t$e very cause ' t$e acc%!ent, $ence $e $as n r%)$t t recver !a+a)es 'r t$e %n&ur%es -$%c$ $e an! $%s -%'e su''ere!. Pr%vate respn!ent cannt recver nt-%t$stan!%n) t$e ne)l%)ence $e %+putes n PLDT cns%!er%n) t$at $e $a! 3t$e last clear c$ance3, t av%! t$e %n&ury. One -$ cla%+s !a+a)es 'r t$e ne)l%)ence ' ant$er $as t$e #ur!en ' pr' t s$- e(%stence ' suc$ 'ault r ne)l%)ence causat%ve t$ere'.PHOENIX CONSTRUCTION VS IACPhoenix Construction v IAC4 !r%ver ' !u+p truc* par*e! sl%)$tly n t$e part ' t$e ra!.5l*s-a)en -%t$ n $ea!l%)$ts cll%!e! -%t$ !u+p truc*. Art 6180 %s nly cntr%#utryne)l%)ence. T$e %+prper par*%n) ' truc* create! an unreasna#le r%s* 'r anyne !r%v%n) n t$atstreet 'r -$%c$ t$e truc* !r%ver s$ul! #e $el! respns%#le as t$e ne)l%)ence ' a car !r%ver#u+p%n) t$at truc*-as n+re t$an a 'reseea#le cnse7uence ' t$e r%s* create! #y t$etruc* !r%ver. Dctr%ne' last clearc$ance%nc++nla-cannt #eappl%e!asa)eneral rule%nne)l%)ence cases %n ur c%v%l la- syste+. O' t$e 'un!a+ental %+prtance are t$e nature ' t$ene)l%)ent act r +%ss%n ' eac$ party an! t$e c$aracter an! )rav%ty ' t$e r%s*s create! #ysuc$ act r +%ss%n 'r t$e rest ' t$e c++un%ty.P8O"1/9 CO1:T,;CT/O1, an! A,6?69?