planning decisions 1st June 2009

WEEKLY PLANNING BULLETIN Date: 1 June 2009 Section 3: Decision List The Weekly Planning Bulletin is divided into 3 sections sorted by Electoral Ward. Section 1 is the list of recently registered applications, section 2 is the list of Proposal of Application Notices and section 3 is the list of recent decisions. If there are no applications or notices in a ward, the ward name will appear and there will be a blank space underneath. Applications contained in this Decision List were determined during the week ending 16 March 2009. Full details of the decision and the application report can be found on the Planning and Building Standards Portal at www.edinburgh.gov.uk Ward A1 - Almond Ward A2 – Pentland Hills Ward A3 – Drum Brae/Gyle Ward A4 – Forth Ward A5 – Inverleith Ward A6 – Corstorphine/Murrayfield Ward A7 – Sighthill/Gorgie Ward A8 – Colinton/Fairmilehead Ward A9 – Fountainbridge/Craiglockhart Ward A10 – Meadows/Morningside Ward A11 – City Centre Ward A12 – Leith Walk Ward A13 – Leith Ward A14 – Craigentinny/Duddingston Ward A15 – Southside/Newington Ward A16 – Liberton/Gilmerton Ward A17 – Portobello/Craigmillar

If you have any questions about the decisions please contact the Planning Help Desk on 0131 529 3550 or email [email protected]

Page 1

http://www.edinburgh.gov.uk/

mailto:[email protected]

Consultations from Other Authorities Consultations from East Lothian Council

Consultations from Midlothian Council Consultations from West Lothian Council Consultations from Other Authorities Outwith the Lothians Planning Applications within Edinburgh Ward No.A01 – Almond

09/00127/ADV (Advert Application)

Various fixed display sign boards in two locations at the boundary of the site at Land Adjacent To 34 Cramond Road North Edinburgh

AMA ( New Town ) Ltd., 15 Coates Crescent Edinburgh EH3 7AF

Delegated Decision

GRANTED 29 May 2009

Community Council: Cramond


Halo illuminated fascia letters, projecting internally illuminated sign, plant box, vinyl manifestation and illuminated menu displays at 10 High Street South Queensferry EH30 9PP

Mr Wilson, Renaissance Ecosse Ltd 10-17 High Street South Queensferry EH30 9PP

Delegated Decision

GRANTED 26 May 2009

Community Council: Queensferry & District


Series of 12 vinyl adverts, applied to both long sides of wooden shrouds covering concrete blocks at Edinburgh Airport Jubilee Road Edinburgh

BAA Edinburgh, Development Department Administration Building Edinburgh Airport Edinburgh EH12 9DN

fastrack delegated

GRANTED 29 May 2009

Community Council: Ratho

09/00839/FUL (Full Planning Application)

Add 2 storey extension to rear and side of property to form new family room, sitting room, utility room and 2 bedrooms at 96 Cammo Grove Edinburgh EH4 8HD

Mr + Mrs Bennett, 96 Cammo Grove Edinburgh EH4 8HD

Delegated Decision

GRANTED 26 May 2009

Community Council: Cramond

Page 2


Alteration to house and garage to extend existing lounge, new timber garage at 186 Whitehouse Road Edinburgh EH4 6DB

Mr + Mrs MacMichael, 186 Whitehouse Road Edinburgh EH4 6DB

Delegated Decision

GRANTED 29 May 2009

Community Council: Cramond Ward No. A02 – Pentland Hills


Erection of 2 (two) dwelling houses at 303 Lanark Road Edinburgh EH14 2LL

Venlaw Properties Ltd., 20 - 28 Braid Road Edinburgh EH10 6AD

Delegated Decision

REFUSED 29 May 2009

Community Council: Longstone


Erection of new detached dwelling house and garage and formation of driveway and hardstanding area at Land 295 Metres Southwest Of 1A Clifton Road Newbridge

Mr Grant, 1A Clifton Road Newbridge EH28 8LQ

Delegated Decision

REFUSED 29 May 2009

Community Council: Ratho


One-and-a-half storey extension, sun room and replace existing single with double garage at 12 Lovedale Crescent Balerno EH14 7DP

Mr + Mrs Strachan, 12 Lovedale Crescent Balerno EDINBURGH EH14 7DP

Delegated Decision

REFUSED 29 May 2009

Community Council: Balerno


Extension to side of existing house at 513A Lanark Road West Edinburgh EH14 7DH

Mr + Mrs Peutherer, 513A Lanark Road West Edinburgh EH14 7DH

Delegated Decision

REFUSED 29 May 2009

Community Council: Balerno


Extension to rear and roofspace including dormers and balcony of existing house at 521A Lanark Road Edinburgh EH14 5DQ

J Dewar., 521A Lanark Road Edinburgh EH14 5DQ

Delegated Decision

GRANTED 26 May 2009

Community Council: Juniper Green (Not Active)

Page 3


Demolition of existing sheds and construction of new one and a half storey garage building at East Gateside 10 Dalmahoy Edinburgh EH27 8EB

B Harshall., East Gateside 10 Dalmahoy Edinburgh EH27 8EB

Delegated Decision

GRANTED 26 May 2009

Community Council: Ratho Ward No.A03 – Drum Brae/Gyle


Extend existing house at rear at 33 North Gyle Road Edinburgh EH12 8EX

Mr + Mrs Marshall, 33 North Gyle Road Edinburgh EH12 8EX

Delegated Decision

GRANTED 29 May 2009

Community Council: Corstorphine Ward No. A04 – Forth


Erection of conservatory and house alterations at 72 South Trinity Road Edinburgh EH5 3NX

Mr + Mrs Jefferies, 72 South Trinity Road Edinburgh EH5 3NX

Delegated Decision

GRANTED 26 May 2009

Community Council: Trinity


Alter attic and install velux windows to rear of house at 11 York Road Edinburgh EH5 3EJ

Mr + Mrs Lawson, 11 York Road Edinburgh EH5 3EJ

fastrack delegated

GRANTED 28 May 2009

Community Council: Trinity


Erection of extension to rear of property at 8 Laverockbank Avenue Edinburgh EH5 3BU

G Sinclair., 8 Laverockbank Avenue Edinburgh EH5 3BU

fastrack delegated

GRANTED 28 May 2009

Community Council: Trinity Ward No. A05 – Inverleith

09/00184/LBC (Listed Building Consent Application)

Install balustrades to entrance platt, new doors to north side entrance and remodel south side fire exit at 7B Saxe-Coburg Street Edinburgh EH3 5BN

Stockbridge Parish Church., 7B Saxe-Coburg Street Edinburgh EH3 5BN

Delegated Decision

MIXED DECISION 28 May 2009

Community Council: Stockbridge/Inverleith

Page 4


Extend at side and rear of property and convert existing attic space into habitable space with dormers at the front and rear at 621 Ferry Road Edinburgh EH4 2TT

J Black., 621 Ferry Road Edinburgh EH4 2TT

Delegated Decision

GRANTED 28 May 2009

Community Council: Drylaw/Telford


Extend property to form a single storey family bathroom and alter existing attic room to form two bedrooms with dormer and roof light windows at 49 Telford Road Edinburgh EH4 2AY

Mr + Mrs Coyle, 49 Telford Road Edinburgh EH4 2AY

fastrack delegated

GRANTED 27 May 2009

Community Council: Silverknowes (Not Active)


Remove 2no timber sash and case windows (W1 and W2) remove single glazing and replace with slim line double glazing units in exist, sashes at 13A Inverleith Place Edinburgh EH3 5QE

J Le Page., 17A Inverleith Place Edinburgh EH3 5QE

Delegated Decision

REFUSED 27 May 2009

Community Council: Stockbridge/Inverleith


Alterations to existing cupboard at third floor level to form reduced cupboard and new en-suite shower room, accessed from existing bedroom at 2F 5 Eton Terrace Edinburgh EH4 1QE

Mr + Mrs Wickramasuriya, 2F 5 Eton Terrace Edinburgh EH4 1QE

fastrack delegated

PERMISSION IS NOT REQUIRED

29 May 2009

Community Council: Stockbridge/Inverleith Ward No. A06 – Corstorphine/Murrayfield


Alter and extend day nursery to increase day nursery places, currently 29, to 58, with 5 additional members of staff. Rearrange existing decking and form new two-storey extension with glazed conservatory link, and relocate two existing car parking spaces at 58 Saughton Crescent Edinburgh EH12 5SP

Edinburgh Childcare Ltd., 58 Saughton Crescent Edinburgh EH12 5SP

Delegated Decision

REFUSED 27 May 2009

Community Council: Murrayfield

Page 5

Ward No. A07 – Sighthill/Gorgie


Erection of retail park directory signage at Hermiston Gait Retail Park 41 Cultins Road Edinburgh EH11 4DF

Clerical Medical Investment Group., Per Invista Real Estate Management Exchequer Court 33 St Mary Axe London EC3A 8AA

fastrack delegated

GRANTED 27 May 2009

Community Council: Sighthill/Broomhouse/Parkhead


Access sign to display the business name in English and Chinese and to show the location of the entrance from Inglis Green Road (in retrospect) at Land 38 Metres Northwest Of 30A Inglis Green Road Edinburgh

Mathew Foods ( Scotland ) Ltd., Unit 1, Barratt Trading Estate 230 / 260 Garscube Road Glasgow G4 9RR

fastrack delegated

GRANTED 29 May 2009

Community Council: Longstone Ward No. A08 – Colinton/Fairmilehead


Install velux balcony system at the rear and 3no velux windows at the front to the existing roof at 36 Colinton Mains Terrace Edinburgh EH13 9AS

Ms McWhirr, 36 Colinton Mains Terrace Edinburgh EH13 9AS

Delegated Decision

GRANTED 26 May 2009

Community Council: Firrhill


Convert existing public toilet to form a house at 300 Colinton Road Edinburgh EH13 0LE

ECO Logical Developments., 19 Cumberland Street Lane N/E Edinburgh EH3 6SB

fastrack delegated

WITHDRAWN 26 May 2009

Community Council: Colinton (Not Active)


Proposed white UPVC conservatory construction to property rear at The Coach House 27 Woodhall Road Edinburgh EH13 0DT

Mr + Mrs Brown, The Coach House 27 Woodhall Road Edinburgh EH13 0DT

Delegated Decision

REFUSED 29 May 2009

Community Council: Colinton (Not Active)

Page 6


Proposed upper storey extension to rear of house at 5 Buckstone Circle Edinburgh EH10 6XB

J Breslin., 5 Buckstone Circle Edinburgh EH10 6XB

Delegated Decision

REFUSED 26 May 2009

Community Council: Fairmilehead


Build single storey extension to rear at 16 Buckstone Lea Edinburgh EH10 6XE

J Damen., 16 Buckstone Lea Edinburgh EH10 6XE

Delegated Decision

GRANTED 29 May 2009

Community Council: Fairmilehead

Ward No. A09 – Fountainbridge/Craiglockhart


Replace french doors and new windows to rear at 209 Colinton Road Edinburgh EH14 1BJ

A Forsyth., Woodhall House 184 Woodhall Road Edinburgh EH13 0PJ

fastrack delegated

PERMITTED DEVELOPMENT

28 May 2009

Community Council: Craiglockhart


Proposed new garden shed at 9 North Meggetland Edinburgh EH14 1XG

The University Court Of The University Of Edinburgh., Old College, South Bridge Edinburgh EH8 9YL

Delegated Decision

GRANTED 29 May 2009

Community Council: Craiglockhart

Ward No. A10 – Meadows/Morningside


Demolition of the rear extensions to, and the refurbishment of, the original Chalmers Hospital building and the addition of a new three storey extension to the south of the original building (as amended) at Chalmers Hospital 55 Lauriston Place Edinburgh EH3 9HQ

Mr Brown, Administration Block Astley Ainslie Hospital 133 Grange Loan Edinburgh EH9 2HL

Committee Decision (Other Item)

GRANTED 25 May 2009

Community Council: Tollcross


Alterations and change of use from office to nursery and school at 42 Colinton Road Edinburgh EH10 5BT

Morningside Montessori Nursery., 3 Greenhill Park Edinburgh EH10 4DW

Delegated Decision

GRANTED 29 May 2009

Community Council: Merchiston

Page 7


Installation of replacement windows at 3F2 24 Morningside Road Edinburgh EH10 4DA

Mr + Mrs Allen, 3F2 24 Morningside Road Edinburgh EH10 4DA

fastrack delegated


29 May 2009

Community Council: Merchiston


Proposed 2 storey, sides and rear extension at 16 Braid Mount Edinburgh EH10 6JP

Mr + Mrs Cameron, 16 Braid Mount Edinburgh EH10 6JP

fastrack delegated


Community Council: Morningside Ward No. A11 – City Centre


Erect office annexe at 24 Canning Street Edinburgh EH3 8EG

Balcarres Investments LTD., CBC House 24 Canning Street Edinburgh EH3 8EG

fastrack delegated


Community Council: West End


Erect office annexe at 24 Canning Street Edinburgh EH3 8EG

Balcarres Investments LTD., CBC House 24 Canning Street Edinburgh EH3 8EG

fastrack delegated


Community Council: West End


Retail and hotel development, including alterations to 123 Princes Street, substantial demolition of 121 - 122 Princes Street, and demolition of 129 and 131 - 133 Rose St Lane South (as amended) at 121, 122, 123 Princes Street Edinburgh EH2 4AD

Deramore Property Group., Montgomery House 29 - 33 Montgomery Street Belfast BT1 4NX

Committee Decision (Presentation Item)

GRANTED 25 May 2009

Community Council: New Town/Broughton


Formation of two lift shafts and extension of mezzanine bridge at Waverley Station 4 Waverley Bridge Edinburgh

Network Rail Infrastructure Limited., Kings Place, 90 York Way London N1 9AG


GRANTED 26 May 2009

Community Council: Old Town

Page 8


Alterations to Waverley Steps to form new entrance, improve steps, form escalators and roof canopy at Waverley Steps Edinburgh

Network Rail Infrastructure Limited., Kings Place, 90 York Way London N1 9AG


GRANTED 26 May 2009



The fixture of two external condenser to the rear of the building on the second floor as indicated on the enclosed plans (as amended) at 41 Thistle Street South West Lane Edinburgh EH2 1EW

Data Explorers., 3 Melville Crescent Edinburgh EH3 7HW

fastrack delegated

GRANTED 25 May 2009



Phase 2 internal alterations, repair and refurbishment, stonework repairs, services replacement at 2 - 11 Parliament Square Edinburgh EH1 1RQ

Scottish Court Service ( Gillian Jewell )., Hayweight House 23 Lauriston Street Edinburgh EH3 9DQ

fastrack delegated

GRANTED 27 May 2009



2no flagpoles over existing doorways in existing building at 23 - 27 Waterloo Place Edinburgh EH1 3BH

Apex Hotels Ltd., 217 Gilmerton Road Edinburgh EH16 5UD

Delegated Decision

GRANTED 29 May 2009



Alterations from garage to bedroom with en-suite at 4A Nelson Place Edinburgh EH3 6LH

E Cramond., 4A Northumberland Place Lane Edinburgh

Delegated Decision

REFUSED 27 May 2009



Alterations to garage to form bedroom with en-suite at 4A Nelson Place Edinburgh EH3 6LH

E Cramond., 4A Northumberland Place Lane Edinburgh

Delegated Decision

REFUSED 27 May 2009


Page 9


Convert existing static advert units to 1 side scrolling, 1 side static (replacing existing unit) at Princes Street Edinburgh

Clear Channel UK Ltd., 119 Deerdykes View Westfield Ind Estate Cumbernauld G68 9HN

fastrack delegated

GRANTED 28 May 2009



Display of letters 'Elgin Cashmere' for new shop front at 302 - 310 Lawnmarket Edinburgh EH1 2PH

B Landa., 324 - 326 Lawnmarket Edinburgh EH1 2PH

fastrack delegated

GRANTED 29 May 2009



Internal alterations to the basement to improve the toilet facilities and increase the number of cubicles at 1F 62 - 66 George Street Edinburgh EH2 2LR

Mr Manley, Wetherspoon House Watford WD1 1HQ

fastrack delegated


27 May 2009



Minor internal alterations carried out in 1995 (retrospective) at 2F 9 Doune Terrace Edinburgh EH3 6DY

H Wallace., Per Agent

fastrack delegated


28 May 2009

Community Council: New Town/Broughton Ward No. A12 – Leith Walk Ward No. A13 – Leith


Installation of new timber shopfront (in retrospect) at 5 Bernard Street Edinburgh EH6 6PW

William Hill Organisation., Construction Department PO Box 170, Leeds West Yorkshire LS2 8JF

fastrack delegated

GRANTED 27 May 2009

Community Council: Leith Harbour And Newhaven


Installation of new timber shopfront and signage in conjunction with internal refit (in retrospect) at 5 Bernard Street Edinburgh EH6 6PW


fastrack delegated

GRANTED 28 May 2009


Page 10


Externally illuminated fascia signage and projecting sign at 5 Bernard Street Edinburgh EH6 6PW


fastrack delegated

GRANTED 29 May 2009


Ward No.A 14 – Craigentinny/Duddingston


Alter roof over dwelling house to create dormer to front elevation, positioned above first floor window at 49 Hamilton Drive Edinburgh EH15 1NP

Mrs Kitching, 49 Hamilton Drive Edinburgh EH15 1NP

fastrack delegated

GRANTED 27 May 2009

Community Council: Northfield/Willowbrae


Partial change of use from residential to nursery at 72 Inchview Terrace Edinburgh EH7 6TH

M+ T Veitch., 72 Inchview Terrace Edinburgh EH7 6TH

Delegated Decision

GRANTED 28 May 2009

Community Council: Craigentinny/Meadowbank


Extend front, form new window and roller shutter at 60 Duddingston Road Edinburgh EH15 1SG

A Oliver., 77 Milton Road West Edinburgh EH15 1QZ

fastrack delegated

GRANTED 28 May 2009



Proposed extension to form utility area at 50 Kekewich Avenue Edinburgh EH7 6TY

F Craig., 50 Kekewich Avenue Edinburgh EH7 6TY

fastrack delegated

GRANTED 25 May 2009

Community Council: Craigentinny/Meadowbank


Erection of a conservatory at 30 Meadowfield Terrace Edinburgh EH8 7NR

Mr + Mrs McKinnon, 30 Meadowfield Terrace Edinburgh EH8 7NR

Delegated Decision

GRANTED 29 May 2009


Page 11

Ward No. A15 – Southside/Newington


Replacement panels and roof to existing conservatory, replacement single door at 131 Whitehouse Loan Edinburgh EH9 2AT

S Higgins., 131 Whitehouse Loan Edinburgh EH9 2AT

fastrack delegated

GRANTED 26 May 2009

Community Council: Marchmont/Sciennes


Alterations to rear outshot to form garden room. New French doors to be formed in north wall, door to west to be replaced with frameless fixed glass screen. at GF 11 Grange Road Edinburgh EH9 1UQ

R Philips., GF 11 Grange Road Edinburgh EH9 1UQ

fastrack delegated

GRANTED 28 May 2009



Alterations to rear outshot to form garden room. New French doors to be formed in north wall, door to west to be replaced with frameless fixed glass screen. Minor internal alterations. at GF 11 Grange Road Edinburgh EH9 1UQ

R Philips., GF 11 Grange Road Edinburgh EH9 1UQ

fastrack delegated


28 May 2009



Installation of replacement windows (in retrospect) at 39 Lauder Road Edinburgh EH9 1UE

Mr + Mrs Spark, 39 Lauder Road Edinburgh EH9 1UE

fastrack delegated

GRANTED 25 May 2009


Ward No. A16 – Liberton/Gilmerton


Removal of existing conservatory, extension to rear of property to form enlarged kitchen and additional bedroom accommodation at 5 Gracemount Avenue Edinburgh EH16 6SJ

T Murphy., 5 Gracemount Avenue Edinburgh EH16 6SJ

fastrack delegated

REFUSED 25 May 2009

Community Council: Liberton

Page 12


Erection of a conservatory at 5 Alnwickhill Court Edinburgh EH16 6YG

Mrs McCann, 5 Alnwickhill Court Edinburgh EH16 6YG

fastrack delegated

GRANTED 25 May 2009



Alter and extend house at 7 Moredunvale Way Edinburgh EH17 7RG

Mr + Mrs Lumsden, 7 Moredunvale Way Edinburgh EH17 7RG

fastrack delegated

REFUSED 28 May 2009

Community Council: Gilmerton/Straiton/Inch (Not Active)


Single storey extension to side and rear of property at 20 Howden Hall Court Edinburgh EH16 6UT

Mr Deuchar, 20 Howdenhall Court Edinburgh EH16 6UT

Delegated Decision

GRANTED 25 May 2009


09/00959/CON (Conservation Area Consent)

Demolition of existing buildings to courtyard as indicated on plans at Land Adjacent To 73 Drum Street Edinburgh

A Wright., 44 2F2 Pitt Street Edinburgh EH6 4DA

fastrack delegated

GRANTED 27 May 2009



Erection of three town houses and parking at Land Adjacent To 73 Drum Street Edinburgh

A Wright., 44 2F2 Pitt Street Edinburgh EH6 4DA

Delegated Decision

GRANTED 28 May 2009



Take down existing structure and erect new UPVC conservatory at 80 Liberton Brae Edinburgh EH16 6LB

Mr + Mrs Hood, 80 Liberton Brae Edinburgh EH16 6LB

fastrack delegated

GRANTED 25 May 2009


Page 13

Ward No. A17 – Portobello/Craigmillar


Proposed alterations and single storey extension to ground floor flat at side elevation, formation of parking area with dropped kerb to footpath at Flat 2 11 Magdalene Place Edinburgh EH15 3BJ

H McPhillips., Flat 2 11 Magdalene Place Edinburgh EH15 3BJ

Delegated Decision

GRANTED 29 May 2009

Community Council: Craigmillar


Change of use from storage to Class 2 office and excavate pavement to provide basement lightwell with balustrade and stair at 3 Bath Street Edinburgh EH15 1EZ

ARC Services Limited., Unit 4, Block 4 Inveresk Industrial Estate MUSSELBURGH EH21 7UL

Delegated Decision

GRANTED 29 May 2009

Community Council: Portobello


Alterations and change of use to create three dwellings at 7 Brunstane Road North Edinburgh EH15 2DL

Mr Pye, 7 Brunstane Road North Edinburgh EH15 2DL

fastrack delegated

GRANTED 29 May 2009



Roof alterations with dormer windows and balcony at 291 Milton Road East Edinburgh EH15 2LA

Steve Cornish., 291 Milton Road East Edinburgh EH15 2LA

Delegated Decision

MIXED DECISION 28 May 2009



Replace existing aluminium framed double glazed windows with new white UPVC framed double glazed to the rear elevation. at Flat 3 21A Regent Street Edinburgh EH15 2AY

E Clark., Flat 3 21A Regent Street Edinburgh EH15 2AY

Delegated Decision

GRANTED 29 May 2009


Page 14

Documents

planning decisions 1st June 2009