pipeline safety journal.pdf

8/20/2019 pipeline safety journal.pdf

http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/pipeline-safety-journalpdf 1/91

n D s a nc e s F omN a u a G a s T an s m ss o n P p e ne s A P a c c a A p p oa c h o O pe a o Q u a c a o n A c a o s a n d B e e s o u s n g C a h e a Te c hn o o gy o n e n a y n s pe c P o y e hy e n e Ma n a n d Se v c e P o p o se d M e ho d o og y o D e e c n g L o ca z e d E x e na C o O s o n A c v y o n U n de g o u n d P p È n eS y s em s U s ng A c mP ed a nc e a n d Pa e n R e c og n O n A g o h m O P S Re g u a o y Ag e nd aW a ch W P L P u b s he s s n c e 19 8 7 V o u me N n b e A U n n 1 9 9 9 A



Vo ume Numbe Au umn 1999WPLPub she ss nce 1987



mn 1 99 9 J o u na o P p e n e S a e y P ag e 1 F o m h e E d o A e x M a ks 3 S a e S ep a a o n D s a nc e s F omN a u a G a s T an s m ss o n P p e n es J a me s S H a k a a nd R o be D e s n a ck 2 1 A P a c c a A p p oa c h o O pe a o Q u a c a o n J o hn E c k s on 3 5 A p p c a o ns a n d Be n e s o U s n g Ca m e a Te c hn o o gy o n e n a y n s pe c P o y e hy e n e Ma n a n d Se v c e P p n g A n a R o me o 4 1 P o p o se d M e ho d o og y o D e e c n g L oc a z e d Ex e n a C o o s o n Ac v y o n U nd e g o u nd P p e n e S ys e m s Us n g A C m pe d an c e an d P a e n R e co g n o n A g o h m MU q u d M a cd o na d a n d H C as a n ed a 5 7 O P S Re g u a o y Ag e n daW a c h J P S S a



doSusanWakeJounao PpeneSaey spubshedw cepeyeabyWashngonPpeneLee POBox23675LEnanPazaWashngonDC200263675C opygh©1999WashngonPpeneLee A ghsesevedN opa oh spubcaonmaybeepoducednanyo mobyanymeansexcepaspemed undeSecon107o108o he1976U nedSaesC opyghAc w houehe hepo w enpemssono hepubsheThecopyghnoce ndcaeshecopyghhodesconsenha copesmaybemadeopesonao nenauseo o hepesonao nenauseo specccenson hecondonha hecopepayo copyngbeyondhapem edbyawThsconsendoesnoexendoohe kndsocopyngsuchascopyngo geneads buon oadve sngopomoona puposesoc eangnew coecvew okso o esaeSuchpemssonequessandohepemssonnqu esshoudbeaddessedo heJounaoPpeneSae yPemssonsPO Box23675LEnanPazaWashngonDC200263675Subscponp ce19992000Oneyea$299USnUS CanadaandMexco$323ousdeN ohAmeca ApaymensmusbemadenUSdo asC ams oundeveedcopesw



o o ve 1 4 y e a s n ow w n g o h e W a sh n g o n P pe n e L e e w h e e e d o a a n d s u be c v e c omm e n a e a m os e n e y a b s en s a n a b up c h a n ge o m e o w e a n e d o a N e e d e ss o s a y s a p v e g e o m e o s e v e y ou w h h s e d o a o h e s s s u e o h e J o u na o P p e n e S a e y S o s w h a s e ns e o p d e h a w o u d k e o p e se n o y o u h e a u h o s w n g o h s p e m e e s s u e o h e J P S T he s o e pu p o se o h s o u n a s o p o v d e be n e c a n o m a o n o y o u h e e a d e h a w h e p y o u o c o mp y w h h e p p e n e sa e y e g u a o n s an d e n ha n ce p p e n e sa e y o e v e y o n es b e ne M o e o ve h e n o m a o n s p e se n e d h e e w h h e h ou g h h a w h e p y o u o g a n c o n ex a n d pe s p ec v e o n k ey e g u a o y s s ue s be n g d ev e o pe d b y h e O c e o P p e n e Sa e y T h a s o s a y h e J P S s n e n de d o b e a n n s u me n o o p e n s c e n c a n d s ch o a y e x ch a ng e s h a w e s u n e a s o u o n s o e a p p e n e s a e y p ob e m s Mo v n g a on g o h e s a c e D J S H a k a a n d D R o b e D e s na c k ha v e nv e s g a ed g a s a n sm s s o n p pe n e n c d en s h a e s u n u p u e a n d g as g n o n T h e yp o p o se a m e h o d o e va u a n g d s a nc e s h a p p e n es c a n be s a e y se b a c k o m h e c o mm u n y c a e d sa e s e p a a o



semnaa geea eopeaonFna yasandad eauen heJounaoPpeneSae yR eguaoy AgendaWachhasbeenpepaedbyheJPSsa Anovevew ohe aesPpeneSae yeguaoyagenda64FR64851112299spesenedheeoenabe neesedpa esopudenymono andpanhe ppenesaeyeguao ycompanceeos asopovdesJPSauhosw hacommonbaseoaddessngpendngssuesandhow besocompyeecveyande cenyWeam opubshheJPSbannuaya sw hhen enonop oducngaquaeyouna hevoumeandcabeo eseachpapessubmedw suppo TheJPSspcedao dabyoseveab oadspecumo membesoheppe nendusycommunyPacpa onsencouagedomndus yacademaandgovenmenA acesw bepeeevew edbyqua edschoasandhedecsonopubshw bebasedonechncame andconbuon ohegoaso heJPSYouaenvedandencouagedosubmyoucommense eso heedo oopnonsw hchw ewecomeThankyouoeachoheauhos o he meandeo npepang hesempoana cesandoheJPSsupposa w houw homhspubcaonw oudn



mss o n P pe n e s A b s a c J a me s S H a d a P h D P E a n d Ro b e D e s na c k P h D P E N e w Je s e y n s u e o T e c hn o o gy N e wa k N J A c c de n a u p u e o n a u a g a s a n s m s s on p p e n e s w h su b se q ue n g n o n o h e e sc a p ng g a s ca n e s u n h e o s s o e a n d p o pe y A m e h o d o e v a u a n g d s a n ce s a w h c h h e p pe n e s c an b e s a y s e b a ck o m h e c o mm un y c a e d s a s e pa a o n d s a n ce s s p o p o se d h e e n n w h c h h e po n s o u c e me h o d o d e e m n n g he a u x s c o u p e d w h e a o n sh p s o p e d c n g b o h h e m a ss e e a s e a e o m h e u p u e a n d h e a m e h e g h o h e g n e d g a s T h e me h o d s u z e d o d e ve o p c ha s o p e d c n g s a s e pa a o n d s a n ce s b as e d on p p e n e o pe a n g p e s su e a n d n om n a p p e n e d a me e n o d uc o n n c e as e d d ev e o pm e n o o m e y s p a s e y p op u a e d a e as h a s e su e d n n s a n ce s o e n c o ac h me n o n a u a g a s a n s m ss o n p p e n e g h s o w a yR O Ws A c c de n a u p u e s o h e s e p pe n e s w h s ub s eq u en g n o n o h e es c ap n g g as c a n e su n h e o s s o e a n d p o pe y n e a h e s e n e s A d e sc p o n o h e e e c s o s u c h a cc d e n s ca n b e o u nd n h e p p e n



esaddessheesabshmenosepaaondsancesehe decy omdecy houghhedesgnaonova ousocaonopopuaoncassesn hosensancesw heeadenedaow abeROWhasbeenesabshedhew dho heROWomheppecene nese aveysmaesshan100 eeandsgeneay nendedopoec heppeahe hanhepubcSepaaond sanceshaveasobeendeveopedbysomecounesbasedonheconcepo skassessmenThspapedescbeshedeveopmenoamehodoogyoesmaeacua sepaaondsancesequedbaseduponheeecso aupu eoanaua gasansmssonppeneo aspeceddameeandopea ngpessueThemehodoogysdeveopedn pa w hdaacoeced ompo nvesgaonsoacuanaua gasansmssonppeneaccdensLeau eR evewThepuposeohe eaue evewwasogananundesandngopo eseachconcenngbohnaua gasppeneaccdensandhedeemnaono saesepaaondsancesomnaua gasansmssonppenesAcv esassocaedw hhe eaue evew ncudedevew oNTSBesandC ommodyPpeneOccuenceR epospepaedbyheC anadanTanspoaonSaeyBoadT



hemoesuppo ngnomaon ohe moedaedPAR snhePARdockesnWashngonDC speodcaydesoyedTheC ommodyPpeneOccuenceR epospepaedbyheC anadanTSBaesma ohePAR snha heeaeaso nconssencesn heexenon omaonconanedn heseeposBecauseo heaoemenonedeasonsw asconcudedhaanappoachoadvancehesaeo hea nhedscpneo ppene skanaysssodeveopae abeesmaonechnqueoconsevaveypedcsae sepaaondsancesobea cuaedbew eenhepubcandheupu ednauagasppene MehodoogyThesmp edappoachoesma ngsaesepaaondsancesw asdeveopedbaseduponassumponsha hedamageomappeneupu esp maydue ohehema adaonpoducedbyhegn edgasbehavngkeave cae ameThehemaada onw p oduceanmpacaeaheexeno w hchcanbedeennnedhoughheesmaono abumadus Themaovaabesassocaedw h hebunadusesu ngoma ppeneupu eaeheszeo heppeneand sopeangpessuew hchdecy aecs hemassow aen heppeneTheappopaenesso hsappoachnp





0 D d a m e e o h e n p p e o o c e n n c he s a n d P 1 a b s o u ep e s su e n p s a s o m e n ea b y p o n u ps e a m om h e o p e n ng E q ua o n 8 s m o d e d b y e xa m n n g h e a e s o g as o s h o u g h a c ua p p e n e u p u e s se e T ab e 1 a n d co m pa n g h e s e a e s w h va u e s ob a n e d us n g h e eq u a o n B as e d on h s e v a u a o n Eq u a o n 8 wa s m od e d o b e V 1 1 0 0 00 3 4 Y P9 w he e V 1 g a s o w a e s c h D p p e n e d a me e n c he s a n d P n c d e n o pe a n g p e s s u e p s a s h o u d b e no e d h a m u p c a o n b y 1 0 00 n E q u a o n 9c o nv e s M c h o s c Y h E q u a o n 9 e e c s h e a c h a n s e o n o h e m ax m um n a o w a e n o h e p o n s o u ce e q u a o n w n o a c cu a e y e e c h e m a a d a o n c o n d o n s s n ce h e h e a u x a a g v e n e ce p o o c a o n w d e c e as e w h h e d e c ea s n g ga s o w T he e o e V c a n b e c o ns d e e d o b e a e p es e n a v e ga s o w a e D e e m n a o n o F a m e He g h n a m a n ne s m a o h e m e h o d o d e e m n ng h e e x p e ss o n o g a s o w a e h e n o m a o n o b a n e d o m a c u a p pe n e a c c de n s c an b e u se d o e s m a e a m e he g h H a w h o meW e d de a n d H o e 1 9 4 9 de v e op e d a n eq u a o n h a o a g v e n g a s e xp e s se d h e a m e e n g ha s b e ng d e c y p o p o o n a o h e e o n o zz e d a m e



veo hemaada ondamagemaynoonydependonhenensy ohehea uxbuasoon heengho mehahe ecepos ecevnghahea uxFoexampeaa heaux nensyo 9985BuTh2 sponaneousgnon ow oodenbudngoccusaea ewmnuesSma yhemaxmumo eabehea uxosho emexposueo peopes2000Buh 2Theeoe asaesepaaondsancesconsdeedoa odpoec onomace aneveo heaux oaspecc mepeod ha mepeodsexceededdamagemayoccuno deo esmaeasaesepaa ondsanceaeveo poecon schosensuchaspoecng w oodenbudngs omsponaneousgnon oa ewmnuesThecoespondngheauxs oundandnseednoEquaon11asheappopa eKvaueC onsuconoC has oPedcSaeSepaa onD sancesTheoow ngpocedue susedoconsucchas ohe esmaono saesepaaondsancesThe ssepnvovesdecdnghedegeeo hemaada ondamageoconsde Foexampehedamagemghbesponaneousgnonow oodenbudngsae aewmnuesexposueo hegnedgasPoec ono aewmnuesmayaow enoughmeo emegencyesponde



2w hehenonsoa heauxssevea housandBuh 2omssonoh saco w nosgn canyaec heesusC ompasonoMehodo PpeneAccdenD aaandoPevousR eseachEquaon11w asevauaedby scompanghecacuaedvaueso bunad odaa omdocumenedppeneaccdenshaoccued nheU nedS aesThepevousymenonedaccdenhaoccuednEdsonN ew Jeseysp esenedheeasanexampeo heanaysshaw aspeomedThePARNTSB1995oheEdsonN ew Jeseyaccdendescbesheupue oa36nchnaua gasansmssonppeneow nedandopeaedbyheTexasEasenTansmssonC opoaonThe upueoccuedaappoxmaey 1155pmonMach231994 onhepope yoQua yMaeas ncnEdsonN ew Jeseygn ono heescapnggasoccuedw hn2m nuesae heupue poducngames400o500ee hghWhenodeahsw eed ecya buedo heaccdenheupu epoducedexensvedamagencudnghedesucono seveabudngsoaneabyapamen compexTheoacoso hedamageexceeded25mondoas TheNTSBdeemnedha hepobabecausedoheupu ew asmechancadamag



n a d u s by e s s h a n 12 p e c e n c a n h e e o e b e s e en h a h e p e d c e d b u n a d us d o es n a c a p p o x m a e h e d s an c e o h os e b u d n gs w h ch w e e n v o ve d n e a e w m n u es a e h e u p u e A b u n a d u s ca n k e w se b e e s m a ed o d e e m n n g h e d s a n ce b e yo n d wh c h bu d n g s w n o g n e a a F o h e Ed s o n ac c d en h s d s a n ce w o u d ex e n db e yo n d h e o ca o n o h o s e b u d n gs w h ch w e e we e d d o wn n o d e o p e d c h e d s a nc e w h E q ua o n 1 1 a h e a u x o 3 9 6 2 B u h 2 s s e e c e d T h s s h e h e a u x a w h ch p o e d g n o n o w o o d oc c u s s o h a w oo d s n o e x pe c e d o g n e b e ow h s h e a u x F o m e q u a o n1 1 h e b u n a d u s b ec o me s B R 3 6 4 0 3 6 8 29 8 4 7 3 9 62 3 7 5 2 1 1 1 9 e e T he a c u a d s a nc e o m h e u p u e p o n o h e m d p o n o h e b u d n g a h e s o m h e u p u e h a w a s w e e d do w n wa s k e ws e o u nd u s n g h e n o m a o n o m h e N TS B e s o h s a c c de n T h s d s a nc e w as d e e m n e d o b e 1 10 1 e e T h e p e dc e d b u n a d u s s h e e o e v e ys m a o h e a c ua d s a n c e w h a d e e n c e o e ss h a 2 p e c e n T h e o o w ng e x a mp e u s a e s h e a n a y ss o a s a e s e pa a o n d s a n ce o a p p e n e a c c de n o w h c h e s s n o m a o n s a va a b e N TS B 1 9 86 T h e a



adhedsancesesmaedusngEquaon11ThscompasonspesenednTabe4 oa ohena uagasppenes nvovednhesudy canbeseenhaevenousdeheangeod ameesandpessuesow hchEquaon11w asdeveopedha hsea onshpsp oducesesusw hchappoxmaehoseoheB shThehghepecend eenceseecedn heas heeen esoTabe4aep obabydueoheuseo ow opeangpessuesehe sngyo ncombnaonw hsmadamee sw hchaeousde heangeow hchEquaon11w asdeveopedAcompasonw askew semadebew eensepaaonds ancesdeemnedhoughuseoEquaon11andhesepaaonds ancesmposedneguaonsdeveopedbyheD uchTheoow ngdscussonsbasedonnomaon ompesonacommuncaonsw hNVNedeandseGasuneN ovembe301995June211996Sepembe301996The sypeo sepaaondsancew hchheD uchdeveopedscaedap oxmyo budngdsanceThs shedsancebew eenappeneandesdenabu dngsospecas ucuesandcoespondsoa10 ndvdua skThesecondypeodsances caedasuveyoe ecdsanceThsdsancesdee mne



2 P K 3 7 5 2 2 D 1 D 2 1 3 Ta b e s 6 an d 7 e s p ec v e y p e s en h e c o mp a s o n o b u d n g d s an c es o c o n s an p e s s u e a nd d a m e e c a n be s ee n h a b o h h e D u ch a p p o ac h a nd E qu a o n 1 1 p o du c e ve y s m a e n d s e s m a a o s w he h e c o n d o ns o c o ns a n p e s su e o c o n s a n d a me e a e e v a u a ed U n ce a n e s T h e un c e a n e s n h e v a u e o h e b u m ad u s p o d uc e d by E q ua o n 1 1 a e h e e s u o h e a s s um p o n s h a w e e ma d e du n g d e ve o p me n o h s e q u a o n A s n d ca e d p e v o us y a n a s su m p o n wa s ma d e h a h e d a ma g e o m a p p e n e u p u e s p m a y d u e o h e h e m a a d a o n p o d uc e d by h e g n e d g a s O h e da m a ge s u ch a s p o e c e d a ma g e o m p p e n e a g me n s s n o c o ns d e e d T h sa s su m p o n s c on s s e n w h h e e s u s o m n v e s g a o ns o a c u a p p e n e u p u es n w h c h d a ma g e wa s o u n d o b ec a us e d p m a y o m h e e F o d e ve o p me n o E q u a o n 1 1 h e es c ap n g g as s a s s um e d o b e ha v e o nc e g n e d k e a v e c a e a m e A e e a se o m a p e s s u z ed s y s em s u ch a s a p pe n e c a n p od u ce o h e s c e na o s s u ch a s d sp e s o n o h e u n g n e d ga s o m a o n o a e b a d e v e op m en o a a s h e o a v a p o c o u d ex p o s on N F PA 1 9 8 8 H



994Themaada onhazadsombunngvapocoudsaeconsdeedesssgncan hanbaseecs andcombusonassocaedw ha ashe assnomoehanaew ensosecondsATCHE1994Whe ebaspoducehehghesada onnensy heseevenscanbeassumedo asony1030secondsHockeyandR ew1996Fomuaso ebadamee duaonandhazaddsanceshavebeenpubshedACHE1994w hchaeunconsohe massoheue H oweve nhecaseoap peneupue hemassoue nvovedna ebasd cu opedcs nceheeeaseaeva esw h meAhoughheea eunceanesassocaedw hhe deveopmeno Equaon11heanayseshaw eepe omedsevedodemonsae haheassumponsmadedunghedeveopmenoEquaon11aeappop aeEquaon11canbeuse4opovdeesma onsobun ad ovaousppenedamee sandncdenopeangpessuesH oweve musbesessedhasaesepaaon dsancesdeemnedhoughheuseoEquaon11a eesmaonsTheeae numeousvaabesseveaow hchhavebeenconsdeednhschapew hchw nuencehebun adusassocaedw ha ppeneupu eTheadvana



6 5 0C m 5 00 4 50 F G 1 P o n S ou c e Me h od A pp e d o P pe n e Ru p u e F G 2 B u n Ra d us C ha 5 00 6 0 0 7 00 8 00 9 00 1 00 0 1 10 0 n c de n O pe a n g P es su e P S A1 4 A u um n 19 99 J O UR NA L OF P P EL N ES AF ET YD s an ce o m P o n So u ce o R ec ep o D Ru p u ed P p e ne 2 2 1 2 B u n Ra d us B R D H 2 R e ce p o 12 00



n cd en Ac cd en P pe n e Op ea n g so a on T o a Vo um eR ep o n ve s ga n g Da me e P e ss ue m e o G as Nu mb e A ge nc y n ch es h ou s L os s c P9 0H 06 06 T S B 1 27 5 6 9 6 7 2 7 5 3 78 x o 83 0 2 N T SB 2 0 8 34 7 1 4 2 4 68 x O P9 1H 00 41 T S B 2 0 9 33 7 0 7 5 3 1 3x 10 67 9F PO O6 N T SB 3 0 5 74 7 2 8 3 2 01 x 10 8P 90 H1 00 6 T SB 3 0 7 26 7 0 5 8 8 73 x O 95 0 1 N T SB 3 6 9 84 7 2 5 0 2 9 7x 10 8P 94 H0 03 6 T SB 3 6 1 01 4 7 0 6 3 1 48 x o P9 4H 00 03 T S B 4 2 1 22 17 6 67 3 52 x1 08 T AB LE 2 F am e He gh D aa Ac cd en D am ee D a me e R ep o ed F am eR ep o n ve s ga n g D D 12 H eg h HN um be A ge nc y n ch es C D 28 60 09 N TS B 2 0 1 67 3 00 1 80 95 01 N TS B 3 6 3 00 4 50 1 50 77 01 N TS B 2 0 1 6 7 2 0 0 1 20 71 01 N TS B 1 4 1 1 7 1 2 5 1 07 87 0 1 N TS B 3 0 2 5 0 4 5 0 1 80 J OU RN AL O



es H ea F u xB u h 2 k W m2 R e e en ce C on se qu en ce 31 7 1 A C HE 1 99 4 S o a He a u x du n g a ho s u mm e d ay 2 00 0 6 5 C a we y 19 82 M ax m um o e a b eh ea u x o s h o e m e 2 0 s ec on ds e xp os u e o p eo p e 3 96 2 1 2 6 H oc ke y an d Re w 19 96 P o e d gn o n o w oo d ex po se d o h s h ea A C HE 1 99 4 u x o a p o on ge d pe o d A so p a s c T ec hn c a n e na o n a u b ng m e s L d 1 9 88 9 98 5 3 1 5 D ep a m en o H o us n gW oo d en b u d ng s p ap e w n do w d ap es A nd U b an D ev e op me n a nd e e s w s po n an eo u sy g n e a e a 1 97 5 e w mn u es e xp os u e C ac u a ed u s ng h e e a o ns h p 1B u h 2 3 1 54 6 Wa s s qu a e me e W m 2 T AB LE 4 C om pa s o no N a u a Ga s P pe n es P pe n eD a me e P e ss u e S ep a a o nD s an ce s Fe e P e ce n n ch es B a g L a B s h E qu a o n1 1 D e e n ce 42 7 0 1 0 3 0 0 1 3 85 1 4 99 8 2 24 7 0 1 0 3 0 0 8 20 8 57 4 5 16 7 0 1 0 3 0 0 5 64 5 71 1 2 6 7 0 1 0 3 0 0



s oS a eS ep aa o nD s an ce D sa nc e o mP pe n e Fe e S ae S ep aa o nD s an ce F ee F om Du ch Re gu a on s U sn g Eq ua o n1 1D am ee 3 5 Ba 6 5 Ba 9 5B a 3 5B a 6 5B a 9 5B a 5 22 3 s a 9 57 4 ns a 1 39 26 ps a 5 2 23 ps a 9 57 4 vs a 1 20 00 p sa 14 5 6 6 6 8 2 1 84 2 62 2 96 16 6 6 6 6 8 2 2 11 2 99 3 39 18 6 6 8 2 2 37 3 37 3 81 24 8 2 8 2 3 16 4 49 5 08 30 9 8 1 15 3 95 5 61 6 35 36 1 15 1 48 4 74 6 73 7 62 No es D sa nc es co nv e ed o m me e s o ee u sn g he e a o ns hp 1 me e e qu as 3 28 08 e e D s an ce sd ee m ne do n ac as eb yc as eb as s T AB LE 6 Ra o so B u dn g an dS ep a ao n Ds an ce sa V a ou sD am e es C on sa n P es su e R a os o Bu d ng D sa nc es R a os o Se pa a on D sa nc es U sn gD uc hR eg ua o ns U sn gE qu a on 11 Da me e Ra o 3 5B a 6 5B a



ncesaVaousPessues C onsanD ameeRaosoBu dngD sancesU sngD uchR eguaonsR aosoSepaaonD sancesU sngEquaon11APPENDX REFERENCESAkaEnegyR esoucesPpeneR upue&FeNeaCaeA kansas022486N aonaTanspoaonSaeyBoad accdene WashngonDCGudeo PessueR eevngandD epessungSysemsAPRecommendedPacce5211990AmecanPe oeumnsue WashngonDCBzusow skTA andSommeEC J1973 PedcngR adanH eang omFaesF omPoceedngsD vsonoR enng AmecanPeoeumns ueVo 53WashngonDC 865893C aweyFK1982 TheEecso hegnono aMaoFueSp ageL C hemESymposumSeesN o71125145FacuaPpeneAccdenR epoBascR epoARO FTW79FP006U nedTexasTansmssonC o1979N aonaTanspoaonSaeyBoad WashngonDCGudenesoEvauang heC haacescso VapoC oudExposonsFashFesandBLEVEs1994C ene oC hemcaPocessSaeyo heAmecanns ueoC hemcaEngneesN ewYokNYHawhone WR WeddeDS andH oeHC 1949MxngandC ombus



be919691971N a onaTanspoaonSaeyBoad WashngonDCNohenN aua GasC ompanyPpenePuncueExposonandFeH udsonow aNovembe419821983 N aonaTanspoaonSaeyBoad WashngonDCNauaGasPpeneR upueFooh sPpeLnesSaskLd1067M mee42 nchEasenManL neKomeePos 66+ 041MapeC eekSaskachew an15Febuay19941995Tanspoa onSaeyBoadoC anadaH QuebecC anadaOenbngPR andSennanTR May1980 FaeD esgnA eCuen MehodsTooC onsevave?H ydocabonPocessng124129PpeneAccdenncdenSummayRepos1986N a onaTanspoaonSae yBoadWashngonDCPpeLneR ueso ThumbHandbook1993GuPubshngC ompanyH ousonTXSFPEHandbookoFe PoeconEngneeng1988N a onaFePoec onAssocaonQuncyMASaeyC onsdeaonsnS ngH ousngPoecs1975D epamenoHousngandU banD eveopmenWashngonDCTexasEasenGasPpeneC ompanyRupuesandFesa Beaumon KenuckyonAp 271985andLancaseKenuckyonFebuay2119861987N aonaTanspoaon SaeyBoadWashngonDC



n s an d s ym b o s a e u se d n h s p a p e A C HE A m e c an n s u e o C h em c a E n g ne e s A P A m e c an P e o e u m n s u e B R b u m a d us B u B s h T h e m a U n D d a m e e d s a n ce o m am e ce n e o o b s e v e F a c o n o o a h e a a d a e d o o F d e g e es F a h en h e g g a ug e p e s su e d e s g na o n H a m e h eg h h h o u n n c hK a d a n h e a u x Mc h o us a nd c u b c e e NF P A N a o n a F e P o e c o n A ss o c a o nN T SB N a o n a T a ns p o a o n S a e y bo a d P n c d en o p e a n g p e s su e g a ug e o p e a n g p es s u eP 1 a b so u e p e s su e n e a h e o p e nn g PA R P p e n e A cc d e n R ep o p s p o un d s pe s q u a e n c hp s a p o un d s pe s q u a e n c h ab s o u ep s g p o u nd s p e s qu a e n c h g au g eQ o a h e a c o n e n o a e d g a s v o u me c g a s o w a e R O W g h o w a y sc s a n da d c u b c e e a m o sp h e c a n s m ss v y T SB T a n sp o a o n S a e y B o a d Ca n ad a V v o u me c g a s o w a e J a m es S H a k a P h D P E s a n A d un c R o be D e s n a ck P h D P E s a P o e s so P o e s so n h e D ep a m e n o C v a n d o C v a n d E n v o n me n a E n g ne e n g a E nv o n m e n



s a c J o hn E c k s on P E P e s d en S a e y & C o m p a nc e E va u a o n n c S p n g e d V A T h e Op e a o Q u a h c a o n u e p o m u ga e d A ug u s 2 7 1 9 99 s n e n d e d o m p o v e p u b c s a e y b y e ns u n g h a p e s o ns p e o m n g c e a n o p e a n g a n d ma n e n an c e a s ks a e q u a e d o h o se a s k s T he u e w u n da m e n a y ch a ng e h ow p p e n e o p e a o s a n a n d e s e mp o y ee s a nd c o n a c o s T h s pa p e e xa m n es h e h s o y o h e u e e v e w s a cc d e n d a a o e s m a e s p o e n a b e ne s a n d d e sc b e s s e ps h a o p e a o s m us a k e o c o m p y w h h e e g u a o n n A ug u s 2 7 1 9 99 h e D e p a m e n o T a n s p o a o n s O c e o P p e n e sS a e y O PS s s u ed a n a u e h a w e q u e o p e a o s o n a u a g a s u e s g a s a n s m ss o n p p e n es a n d ha z a d ou s q u d p pe n e s o d e ve o p a q ua c a o n p o g a m o e v a ua e a n n d v d ua s a b y o p e o m c o ve e d a s ks a n d o e c o g nz e a nd e a c o a b n o ma o p e a n g c on d o n s h a m a y oc c u wh e p e o m n g c o v e ed a s k s 1 Th e o p e a o mu s m a n a n e c o d s o h e se e v a ua o n s a nd e e v a u a e qu a c a o n s p os a c c d en u p o n e a so n ab e s u sp c o n a nd p e o d c a y E a ch o pe a o s w e n o pe a o q u a c a o n p



dcono ypeoegua onhao w hchboheguaosand heeguaedndusyhavebecomeaccusomedTheOQueesabshesheobecveo aqua edw okocebu eavesvuaya hedecsonsabouhow oaccompshhsgoa ohendvduaopeao sThs exbya ow seachopeaoo ao apogam habes ssunqueneedsbu asochaengeseachopeao opumoe houghno squacaonp ogamhanhadhe ueesabshedanng equemensasDOTnayp oposednmanyw aysheuesesahghe sandado opeaos C ompancenowmeansevauangw haeachempoyeeandconaco needsoknow ndng anngha mpashs know edgeanddeemnnghow equeny eeshe anngs equedahe hanoow ngagovenmenpescbed anngegmeandschedueTheo ow ngpesensapacca ogcaappoachodeveopnganopeaoqua caoncompancepogamSTEPSNCREATNGANOPERATORQUALFCATONCOMPLANCEPROGRAMAssgnR esponsb esOpeaoshaveakenavaeyo appoachesodeveopnganOQcompancepogamSomeopeaoshavedeegaedOQpogamdeveopmeno hea nngdepamensncehso cay



n g me e n g s s o h e s e w a ud s o O Q p a n s w b e a e a n n g ex p e e nc e o b o h o p e a o s an d e g u a o s a n o p e a o d e e m n e s a a sk n o a c o ve e d a s k e a s a n y on e o h e o u e s s h e n he o p e a o h a s no u h e o b g a o n s o h a a s k u nd e h e O Q u e T h e O Q u e d oe s n o h o we v e s u pe s e d e ex s n g q u a c a o n e qu e m e n s o u nd n o h e s e c o n s o P a s 19 2 o 1 9 5 s uc h a s qu a c a o n e q u e m e n s o w e de s a n d p as c p p e o n n gW h e c on s u c o n a s ks a e n o s u b ec o h e O Q u e p e so n s pe o m n g h e s a e y c c a c o n s u c o n a sk s k e p a s c p p e o n n g we d n g a nd w e d n s pe c o n s m u s b e q u a e d u n de e x s n g e g u a o y e q u e me n s E m e g en c y e sp o ns e a n n g n P a 1 9 5 a s o e m a ns n e e c o v e a n d a bo v e he e q u e m e n s o h e O Q u e T he o g c a s s e p n d e v e op n g a c ov e e d as k s s o c o mp e a c o m p e he n s ve s o e v e y a c v y n v o v e d n o pe a n g a n d ma n a n n g a p p e n e n a o n p o e c o s e v e a e g o n a g as a s so c a o n s an d g a sd s b u o n o p e a o s a e v e w o o p e a n g an d m a n en a n ce p a n s o b d es c p o n s u n o nc o n a c s e c d e n e d a b o u 2 2 0 ac v e s a s so c a e d w h o pe a n g a g a s d s b u o n sy s e mS m a e o s a e u n de w a y o g a s a n sm s s o n an d



ma y n o b e a b e o a ns w e w hy a c e a n a s k s o s n o c o v e e d e s u n g n p e s su e o a d d m o e a s ks o h e s o c o v e e d a sk s a s k s h a m ay n o n a c m e e h e o u e s s M a ny o p e a o s a s so c a o n s an d c on s u n g m s h a v e p od u ce d c ov e e d a sk s s M a n y o h e s e s s m s a pp y h e o u p a e s o m a n y a sk s e e c n g h e a c m o s h a v e be e n de v e op e d by n d v d u a s wh o a e n o a m a w h h e n e g o a e d u e ma k n g se s s on s A m on g h e m o e c omm on m s a k es a e n c u d ng c o ns u c o n a s k s n e p e n g h e e g u a ed u n de e s o n c u d e a sk s n ec e ss a y o a n o h e c o ve e d a s k o b e p e o m e d b u n o s p ec c a y m e n o n ed n h e P a 1 9 2 o 1 9 5 F o e x a mp e c e a n g a g h o w a y m ay b e n ec e ss a y o h e c o ve e d a s k o p a o n g o a k e p a c e b u h e a s k o c e a n g a g h o w a y s n o m e n o ne d n e h e P a h e e o e a s h s e s a n d s n o c o ve e d A s su m n g h a a n y a sk p e o m e d o n a p p e n e s c o v e e d g no n g h e o h e h e e e s s A s su m n g h a a ny a s k h a c a n a e c h e n e g y o h e p p e n e s co v e e d g n o n g h e o h e h e e e s s n c u d ng e m e g en c y e sp o n se u n c o ns u n de o p e a n g a n d m a n e n a n ce a s k s As a e s u u s e s o h



aou pa esha canbeappedovaouscondonsha mghoccuonappene odeemne heyaeabnomaopeangcondonssubec oheOQ ueTobeanabnoma1opeangcond onhecondonmus1 possbyndcaeamauncono acomponeno2a devaonomnoma opeaons musaso1ndcaeacond onexceedngdesgnm so2 esuna hazadsopesonspopey o heenvonmenAcondonneednopassa ouess obeanabnomaopeangcondon onymuspassoneohew oc ea neachohe w opasoess N oeveypesonpeom ngacoveedaskneedsobeevauaedneveyabnomaopeangcondonden eddungh spocedueThenegoaeduemakngcommeeageedha pesonsneedonybeevauaedn hoseabnonnaopeangcondonsha coudeasonabyancpaedobeencouneedw hepeo mngaaskTheeoe heogcanexsep nOQpogamdeveopmensodeem newhchabnomacondonscoudbeexpecedw hepeom ngeachcoveedask edeveopamaxo abnomaopeangcondons ocoveedasksThsmaxw beuseunhenex sepodeme heevauaonequemenso eachcoveedaskS



oneo moeess oknow edgeeemensandoneomoeobsevaonsosk sandab eseaed ohe asknoomenon heevauaonsoab yo ecognzeandeac oa heabnomaopeangcondonsheopeao deemnedw eeeaed oeachaskeae nheOQpog amdeveopmenpocessAonemea ow anceo heuseow okpe omancehsoyevew sncudednhe ueasameansoqua ycuen pesonnenasksheypeomed eguayp o oheeec vedaeo heue Thendusyaguedo hspovsononhe goundshahe ueshoudnodecaea 200000ppeneempoyeesunquaedon heeecvedae ohe ueTheysuggesedaow ngaevew oempoymenhsoy peomanceevew sandoheecodsasa meansoevauangcu enpesonnem nghemoeeaboa eevauaonequemenso new hesandpesonssw chngobsSaeandedea eguaosopposedhsasanaemp ogandahe vua yacu enempoyeesponngouco ecyha someohepeopew hoseeosw ee nvovednaccdenscedbyheNTSBweeexpeencedpesonneThecompomsewasoaowwokpeomancehsoy evew onyo ansonaqua caonTheea



quenyw hou eevauanghe esscca aspecsoooen denyPesonsPeo mngCoveedTasksAh ssageo hepocessheopeao hasdened coveedasksandesabshedaseoevauaonsess obsevaonsecTha apesonmuspassobequa edope omhe askonheopeaossysem Nowheopeaomus denya pesonsw homghbecaeduponope omheseasksandensueha heycompeeheequed evauaonsnadd onopesonsw hoouneype omheseasksheopeao shoudasoconsde C onacoempoyeesw hopeom coveedasks Empoyeesoo heopeaosw ho mghbebo ow eddnngan emegency Managemenempoyeesw homghbe u zeddungas keAnyonewhopeomsa coveedaskegadessow ho heyw oko henoma obcasscaono heccumsancesundew hchheyae peomng heaskmushavepassedaheevauaons equedo heaskasspecedn heOQpogamo heppenesysemonwhchheyaew okng Jusbecauseapesonpeo msoneomoecoveedasksdoesnomeanha hepesonmusbeevauaedquaed o asksheoshepeoms haaeno cove



uaonSomehavemsakenyassumedhabymehodoevauaon heue ees ohes osxevauaonmehods sedn hedenono evauaoneg w enexamoaexamobsevaononhe obobsevaonnasmua onobsevaonn anngandw okpeo mancehsoyevewThsmsakeemphaszeshempoanceonvovngexpeencedeguaoycompancepesonneonheOQdeveopmeneamnopesonw hohaspacpaedna ppenesaeyaudw oudexpeche audoso besasedha apesonsqua edw hnohngmoe hannomaonon heoma oheevauaon nac heuegves heaudosw deeew aynow ha heycanevewAmnmum heeguaos canexpeco evew heacuaevauaonsusedoquaypesonneneachcoveedaskSomemayw anoseeheacua esansw esapacuape soncompeednode obequa edooneo moeasksn evauangecodkeepngsysemskeepnmndha naddono heexpcm nmumequemensheea empc ecodkeepngequemenshamusbeaddessedTheopeao musbeabeodocumenha soow nga ohepovsonsw enno sopeaoqua caonpogam omeehesevenmnmu



osesysemsheyw okhow eveassaedpevousy anngaonedoesnosasyhe evauaonequemenso heOQueTheemusbedocumenabeevauaonshapove hepesonundesandsheanngandheseevauaonsmusbe hosesednheopea osOQpanas heevauaonsequedo heaskheconaco w pe om sacommonmsconceponhahe ueequ esconacoso deveopOQpogamsnac conacosmusbequa edaccodngohe equemenshahe ppenecusomesw eno heOQpansAnopeao hasheechoceshow oquayconaco sF s coudevauaeconacopesonneusas esssow npesonneSecond coudaow heconaco ose es sempoyeesusngessspecedbyheopeao Thd heopeaocoudspecyha heconacomus gooa hdpa yobeevauaedThesecondspecassuesmuuaasssanceManyopeaoshaveoma on omaundesandngsw hohe neabyopeaosha nheeveno anemegencypesonnew bemadeavaabeoasss AeOcobe 282002hesebo ow edpesonnemushavebeenevauaedasspeced nheboow ngopeao sOQpan heypeomanyaskshebo



99 C a us e Ac c d en a y C a u se d b y Op e a o C o ns u c o n O p e a n g E o C o o s o nO u s d e Fo c e D am a g eO h e T o a De a s o O u s d e F o c e Da m ag e No s p e c e d F os L a nd s d eW as h ou O h e E a h M o v em e n Su b s de n ce L g h n ng F e N o D a aO p e a o A c o n Th d P a y D a m a ge 6 2 0 9 1 0 1 0 29 2 5 3 1 9 15 8 1 6 1 1 2 70 0 3 8 5 8 1 5 0 90 1 1 0 4 06 6 2 3 6 5 6 1 15 7 2 9 3 8 5 2 0 00 1 0 1 1 6 99 1 1 5 6 1 1 0 0 9 34 2 4 1 8 1 9 1 66 4 30 7 0 7 07 1 6 1 To e s m a e h e o w e b ou n d o n sa e y b e ne s o h e O Q u e s p o ss b e o d e n y n c d e n s o w h c h h e n c de n e p o c o n a n s a m a v e n o m a o n h a h u m an e o w a sn v o ve d T h e s c a e g o y o n c d e n c au s e n c de n s C au s ed b y h e O pe a o c e a y n c ud e s n c de n s h a m g h h a ve b e e ne m n a e d o e d u c ed h a d an O Q u e b e e n ne e c a h e m e o h e n c d e n T h e s ec o nd c a eg o y C o ns u c o n O p e a n g E o s u h e s u b dv d e d n o s x s ub c a us e s o w h ch o n y E o n A p p y n g O pe a n g P o ce d u e s an d O pe a n g P o c e du e n a p p op a e a e c e a y n c u d e d n n cd e n s a n OQ u e m g h h a v e ad d e ss e d S nc e h e O Q u e d oe s n o a pp y o c o ns u c o n h o s e n c d en



ac sncequacaon equemenso hemao asksnvovednppeneconsuconw eene eca hemeo hesencdenshesedaapoveha eguaonsandquacaonpog amswno be100peceneecven emnang ncdensdueohumaneo Theeoeheexpecedbene ohe OQuew besomewhaesshan100peceno heconsequencesoncdensw heehumaneow asoundobe aaco naddon hebeakdow noousdeocencdensbysubcausencudesacaegoyoOpeao Aconha suggesheOQuecoudaddesshesencdensTabe2show sheconsequencesoncdensnhesecaegoesTabe2D s buonncdensAddessedbyOpeaoOua caonn scosbeneanaysso heOQue OPSassgnedavaueo$223m onashevaueoonesa sca eand$500000oeachsascaavodednu yhee oebyOPSsmehodoogyhepoena beneop evennghesencdensw oudbe$105695283o $7046352peyeaove hepas15yeasSnceheexpeencew hexsngqua caonues oconsuconpove hanou ecancompeeyemnaehumaneo heow eboundonacuabeneso aeguaon agenghesencdensw beso



1 9 84 1 9 9 9 C a u se n u e s P o p e y L o ss $ A pp y n g O PS s c o s b en e m e h o d o og y o h e se d a a e s u s n a n e s m a ed u p p e b ou n d sa e y b e n e o m h e O Q u e o a p p o x m a e y $6 4 m o n p e y e a h e e o e h e k e y s a e y b e ne o m h e O Q u e w b e n h e a n g e o $ 7 m o n a n d $ 70 m o n T h s a n a ys s c o ns d e s o n y sa e y b e ne s h e o n y be n e s e e v a n n a p p e n e s a e y u em a k ng s e n g n e a y h e e w b e a d d o n a be n e s h a w h e n o a p p o p a e o c o n s d e a o n n d e e m n ng a e g u a o n s u s e d s h o u d be c o ns d e e d b y op e a o s wh e n de e m n n g h e e v e o e o o p u n o O Q p o g a m de v e op m e n A s s a e de a e h e e a e b e ne s o h e p o c e ss o e v e w n g wh a c a n go w o n g on a p p e n e c on s d e n g h e p o pe e s p o n se a n dd o cu m en n g h s p o c e ss T a n n g a n dp o d u c v y g o ha n d n h a nd s o s o b e e xp e c ed h a m p o v e m en s n a n n g w e s u n p o d u c v y m p o v e me n s n h o s ec o mp a n es h a m a k e a se o u s e o d u n g h s p o ce s s F na y h e d ev e o pm e n o n d us y s a n d a d s o ca e o a n n g a nd e va u a n g h e q ua c a o n s o o p e a n g a n dm a n e na n ce p e s o nn e a n d h d p a y c e c a o n a g e n ce s m





nnuacosw beappoxmaey$125monpe yeaC ompangbenesandcoss sappaenha heOQeguaoncoudno beus edbasedsoeyonpubcsaeybene show evebym nghescopeohe ueoopea onsandmanenancepus eavngopeaoshe exby ouseexsngpogamswheeveappopae hsuepobaby sascoseocose ecveasanyOQuecoudbeands meeheequemens mposedbyCongessonOPSnaddon manyopeaosw ndhagongh oughhesepsodeveopngheOQcompancepogampoducesaddonasaeyandpoducvybene shapa ayo oayo sehedeveopmenandongongcoss 64FR4685346867Augus27199963FR57276Ocobe27 199863FR57276Ocobe271998JohnEcksonspesdenoSaey andC ompanceEvauaonnco Spnged VaAsVcePesdenoOpea ngandEngneengSevcesw hheAmecanGasAssocaono1996hepa cpaednhe deaeddeveopmeno heOpeaoQua caonue JohnhodsaBSn ChemcaEngneengomPudueU nvesyandanMBA omGeogeWashngonU nvesy H esaegse edpoessonaengnee34 Auumn1999JOURNAL



o gy o n e n a y n s p e c P o ye h y e ne M a n a nd S e v c e P p ng A b s a c A n a R o me o D e c o E n g n ee n g S a S o u hw e s G as C o p o a o n L a s Ve g as N V T h e n a u a g a s n du s y c o n n ue s o c o n o n c h a en g e s e a e d o h e o pe a o n s a nd m a n e n a nc e o a g n g p as c d s b u o n s y s e m p p ng E n s u n g sa e e a b e a n d co s e c v e n a u a g a s se v c e s e s se n a o p o m o n g n a u a g as a s h e e n e g y o c ho c e o a e x s n g a n d p o en a c u s o m e s T he n d u s y m us a c e h e s e ch a e n ge s a nd d e v e op n n o va v e s o u o n s o e ns u e c o mp e v e n e ss n h e e n e g y m a ke L S o u hw e s G as C o p o a o n S ou h w es h a s c on o n e d n u me o u s a g ng p a s c p p e d s b u o n s y s em p o b e ms o v e h e p a s 1 0 15 y e a s S ou h w es a c e s h e se c h a e ng e s by e x p o n g d e ve o p n g an d m p e me n n g n n ov a v e a nd c o s e e c v e s o u o ns T h s p a pe o u n e s w o su c h ch a e n ge s n c u d n g ho w S ou h w es o v e c am e h e o b sa c e s o d ev e o p ng a n d a p p yn g n e w ec h no o g y so u o n s C ha e n g e C o d F u so n J o n F a u e s n 19 8 6 S ou h w es b e g an e x pe e n c n g s gn c a n b u u s o n o m a u e s o n 2 a n d



menn hesysemCosesmaeso epaae navesw eed cuasno vabeepamehodexsed haw oudensueconnuedsaeandeabesevce Souhw esneededeyesnsde heppeoe cenynspecden yandocaehesuspeccodusonons naddon avabeepa aena veneededobedeveopedoe ecveyenoced epahe onso ensueconnuedsysemneg yFexpobeSodSa eC ameaDeveopmenTondhe eyesnecessayo ocangheusonon sSouhw eseseachedandocusedonanne nanspeconcameawhhe adenameoFexpobeSodSa eTeevsonSysemPeapon LmedoBodonH ampsheEngandogna ydeveopedhecameao nena nspeconsoagedameesew e nesThecameasopeangpaameescoveed2 hough18ppeszesw h amaxmumneacabedsanceo500ee hemaxmumenghonsa edppesegmensSncehebu usonauesw eeoccu ngon2and4 ppeh scameawasdeemnedobeavabesou ono ocangheuson onsThemossgn canchaengew asmodyngandesnghecameaequpmen npaneshpw h hemanuacue osaeyandeecveyopeae nagaseou



smounedavdeomonovdeoecode anda500w ageneao navanThecameawasequppedw ha specaocangdevceodee mnnghedsancehecameahead avesedhegasmanWh hemonod spaynghecameasvew nsdeheppe heon ocaoncoudbepnponedTheon ocaonsw eehenmakedabovegoundoexcavaonandusonenocemenwh hesp coupngTesesuscon medhsw ashemoseconomcaepa echnqueC haenge2D eem naonoU nknow nSevcePpngMaeaOve meSouhw esssevceaeahasgow nsubsanayasa esuo acqusonsovaousnaua gassysemsFoheacquedpope esdeaedsysemppemaea nomaonw as medpa cuayo sevceppngn someoheacquedaeas hecompanyexpeencedseveacaas ophcsevcenea uesdueo heemb emenoanodep ascmae aSwansonandKeona3306Souhw esevauaedaenaveso mpemenngaseekanddesoypan oepacea3306seyceppng Theoveagoaw asoden ymapandecod hecomposono heunknownsevceppngno deo eecvey mpemena3306epacemenpocessTheoveapanobecves



ncudngaboao yandedexpemens concudedha heenhancedcameawasavabenspecondevceAheemao chaengesw eeesovedThenadesgno heexendedpobecameascapabeobengnseedn oanacvesevcenesaey w hmnma dsupon ohecusomeFed mpemenaonPo oeachsevcenenspecona deaedcameacheckandcompasonesspe omedwhd eensevcemae aypesampesD unghe nena nspeconC osBenesC osbene anaysesw eepeomedomeasuehee ecvenessohesouonsmpemenedo hew ocasesudespesenedThecameaandspeeco usoncoupngechnoogesuzedo enocepoena codusonons povedobeexemeycose ecvew hencompaedohecossoepacng heppe n1998doashecos o enocemenwas$524 compaedo$1557 o epacemenTheeconomcadvanagesompemenng hecameaandspepa coupngechnoogyaeceaSma cossavngsw eeeazeddung hesevcenenspeconpocessThenvauabeandnangbebene o hesevcenvesgaonpoecw as heden caonmappngandecodngo ape nenmaea nomaon p



saeusedo deny esc onsnp peneshamay esun pessuep obemsonpeakdemanddaysT ypcaes consoundw h hecameancudepa ayo compeeycosedvavesw hchshoudbenheopenpos onand debsn hemanosevce neha s nee ngw hhegas ow hough sevceappngeesb ancheesecSouhw eshasdeveopedw odeaedpocedues1 heseupandnspeconpocedueso heFexpobeSodSae C ameaandheeno cemeneecouson ngnsaa onand2hese upandsevcenenspeconpocedueassocaedw hhePoabe WechAynOympuscameaSummayOveme Souhw eshascononednumeousagngpascppep obemsBymeenghechaengesw hcose ecveandnnovaveechnoogydeveopmenSouhw eshasbeenabeo mnmzecusomenconvenencesw heensungsaee abesevceandhuspomongnau agasasheenegyo choceAnaR onÈo sdeco EngneengSa Souhw esGasC opoaonn haposonsheoveseesppenesaeycompanceenvonmenacompance gho w ayacqusonse econcmappngandecodsysemscompessednaua gasvehcepoga



TY



n a Co o s o n A c v y o n Un d e g o un d P p e n e Sy s e ms U s ng A C m pe d a nc e a nd P a e n R e co g n o n A g o h m MU q u d M a c do n a d P h D a n d H C as a n ed a E n g ne e n g S c en c e a nd M e ch a n cs P e nn s y va n a S a e U n ve s y U n v e s y Pa k P A A b s a c T h e de e c s n h e c o a n g ho d a y s o u nd e g o u nd m e a c p p e n e s h a a e e x po s ed o a g g e ss v e e nv o n m en s b e ha v e as a c v e e e c o ch e m ca c e s R e g u a o ns d e ma n d h a p p e n e s y s em s m us b e c a h od c a y p o e c e d n o d e o m g a e c o o s o n a c v y a p a c es w h e e h e co a n g h a p o e c s h e p p e s s b u se d o d a m ag e L s a b e n e o h e p p e n e n d u s y h a h e y b e a b e o a s se s s h e e ve o c a h o d c p o e c o n o a p p e n e s y s em a n d o d e e c a n d as s es s h e g a v y o c o o s o n a c v y o n a p pe n e s y s em s o e q u a m po a n c e h a h e e s h ou d e x s a m e as u n g s ys e mw h c h s e a b e c h ea p a n d c a n co v e a o n g s ec o n o h e p p e s y s emP e s e n e d he e s a m e h o d oo g y o d e e c n g a n d o c a n g de e c s o d s c on n u e s o n h e o u s d e co a n g c ov e n g p p e ne



cppe nesdungopeangcondons saconceno heOceo PpeneSaeynoonybecauseo hehghconsuconcosoppe nesysemsbuasobecauseoanyphyscadamagehacanesu omaccdenseconomcaossesoecoogcadsases nsueec ochemcaechnquesopevenonoexe nacoosono ppenesaew deyusedo manenanceandsecu ypuposesOneohesmpesmehodsusedop edconandcono oppenesundesevces hehace poena echnqueAccodngo ppenesaey eguaonsR eguaon192455exenaco osonconoeques heconducngoessw hchncudeppeo sopoena measuemensw hespecoa eeenceeecodeThsechnqueevauaeshes ucuebypedc nganyeecochemcachangebymonong hepoenad eencesTheadvanagesoh sechnquencudehesmpcyand ow cosopeaon buhe meonspecons sow andeab ysquesonabeTheeo emoee abeandquanaveco osondeeconsequ ed w eaeo deveopeecvemehodsoexendngheuseu emesoou nas ucuesysemsEecochemcampedancespecoscopyhasbeenpoveneabe o hechaacezao



heseveyo haacv yA caN euaN ewoksPa enR ecognonA caneuane w oksANN saemahemaca oosw hexceencapab esopa enmachng ecognonandcasscaonANN saemahemaca oosbasedonbanbehavow hchecognzesandcassespae nsANN smmcbanunconngbyesabshngheavyn econnecedneuonsAcommonyusedagohms heow adandbackw adpopagaonneuanew okSevea ayesone connecedneuonsaeceaedand hew eghsovaueshaa eassgnedoheconneconsaechosenandomybew een1and1Then omaon haa vesaeachneuonsaddedandhenansomedbyappyngadeneduncon Thenpuvecosaepesenedo heneanda ehenpocessedhoughoueachayeopoduceanoupuveco Theoupuvecos compaedoanexpecedoupuomsupevsedanngandane os usedondcae hedeencebew eenhedesedoupu andheoupupoducedbyhene Thspocesssepeaedunanaccepabee o sachevednhesamewayhamanynumecamehodsaeachevednhsp ocesshenomaon ow somnpu ooupuandhe eanngow egho heconne



edahodayahe12ocockposon nada coodnaeshs hodayw as358 1091m omheendo heppeusngasheo gnpon heexemesdeoppe neendng0+ 358 1091mTheszeo hehodayw as1375349cmndamee abou2housw eusedacouneeec odehaconssenyensuedaea veyongpeodo epoducbeeecoy cconacw hso Theeecodew asasopns ackdameex20 ongsanessseeEec caconneconohscoune eecodeo hemeasungdevcew asobanedvamosueo hesoC asew oncudedahodaya he12ocockposonn adacoodnaesand0+ 679 2069m omheendo heppeneTheszeo hehodayw as1254cmndamee Caseheencudedahodaya he12ocockposonn adacoodnaesand0+ 1016 309m omheendo heppeneTheszeo hehodayw as05127cm ndameeEqupmenReeenceEecodeAcommecayavaabecoppecoppesuaee ecodew asempoyedhoughouhssudyTw omodesw eeusedaa poouspugo geneausenso andnw aeappoxmae oveasze 1275349cmdamee x61524cm ongandaconeshapedpoouspugo usensoso sThe



pennw od eena easTheenghohep penew asdvdednoou eenequasegmensandheoow ngexpemensw eepeo medaD upcaempedancespeca5%o esseobew eeneachesw eemeasuedw h hecouneeecodepos onedahesameponashe eeenceeecodeaccodng ohesegmennumbesdepcednFgue1posons3 o11A oao 18mpedancemeasuemensw eepeomedo eachseoexpemensbTheseo measuemensdescbedabovew eepeomedo 2d eenso essv esAh dseo expemensw aspeomedbyow enghe ocaconducvysuoundngahodaycoveng hehodayw ha pachmana nngheeec odesnagvenposonandbymeasunghechangesnmpedancew hmewhenhepachw asThempedancedaaobanedw eedspayedascompexpaneBodeandphaseangeposusngaPC compuecoupedoa pne Aschemeo heexpemenaseup sshow nnFgue1H ghRessvyMeasuemensWeconsdeedsocondonsohavehghessv y heangeo essv esw eebew een50000ohmcmand300000ohmcmTheACposw eeobanedbyascanomh ghoow equencesWemonoedeg



sw eebew een10000ohmcmand50000ohmcm11Fohesesocondonsnnepos onsohecoune andeeenceeecodew eemono ed34 567 89 10and11Anaddonapos onw asbew eenhesgnasouceandhep penew okngeecodeconneconThsposonw asnoconsdeedbeoebecauseheconneconmayn uencehemeasuedmpedanceesponsew henhesohashghess vyH o dayeecondons 1hodayposoneda0+ 358 1091mand2hodaysposoneda0+ 358 1091mand0+ 10163 09mweeesedLowRessvy MeasuemensLocazedC ondonsThempaco hehodayaeaonco osonacvyw assudedusngocaow essvy500ohmcmsuoundnghede ecAhodayw asexposedo3%NaC1eecoyehenaa pachw asusedonsuae hshghconducvymedumom hesuoundngsoenvonmenmedumess vy10000ohmcmo50 000ohmcmApnhoew asmadeonhepachsu ace5daysae hesao heexpemenaea 0091cm2Ae 10daysounnngheexpemen hensuangcoveonhedeec w asemovedandheen edeecsu acew asexposed957cm2ResusandD scussonw hconsanengh d



a sh o ws h e s e ns v y o h e m pe d an c e e sp O ns e o h e s y s em o h e n u m be o h o d a y s a h e s u a c e o h e p p e ne T h e p o a z a o n e s s an c e R p de c e as e s by M o h m a h g h so e s s v y 6 0 00 0 o hm c mw he n a h o d ay s o p e n on a h e p p e co a n g A m e d u m co n du c v y 2 0 0 00 o h m c mwe a s o o bs e v e a sh a p d ec e a se n h e p o a z a o n e s s a n ce w h en a d e e c s c e a ed o n h e p p e c oa n g B y n c e as n g h e n um b e o h o d a ys m o e h a n 1 no a g e c h a ng e s a e e c o de d a s s ho w n n F gu e 2 b b 1 n P o n c a a c 0 1 c B O 6 E ec o d e P os o n a n d h e P e se n ce o a H o d a yF g u e s 3a a n d 3b s h ow o w o d e e n s e s o e x pe m e n s h o w m pe d an c e sp e c a ch a ng e w h h e p o s o n o h e e e e n c e e ec o d e o a p p e n e w h o u a n y ho d a y sa n d a h o da y n d uc e d a h e p o s o n 0+ 1 0 16 3 0 9 m T he e s u s s h ow n n F g u e s 3a a n d bc o e s p on d o a s y s em c a h od c a y p o e c e d Th e h o d ay e e s u a o n e x h b s o a p o s o n s h e s a m e se m c c e s h ap e w h s m a R p o n h e Ny q u s p oW h e n ah o d a y s p e se n h e s e



Pon 4 Pon S 4 P on 6 Po n 7 Po n 8 Po n 9 Po n 10 5 OOE 05 20Hz n 3 U R 4 8 5 Fb 6 0 b d7 4 R un 8 18 R u n 9 Ù Ru u 10 u uu 4w 0 0 00 OOE 06 2 OOE+06 n Fgu es 3a and b mpedance spec ao ah gh ess vyso and ee oho days and b 1 ho day a hepos on 0+10 16 as a unc on o he pos on o he ex e na eec odes The sys em sca hod ca yp o eced 900mV vs CuJCuSO4 Leve oCa hodc P oec on and So Res s vyFgu e4 shows he mpedance measu emen sa hgh a and med



Re ss v yF gu e 5 sh ow s he va a o ns n h em pe da nc es be we en h e pp e ne a o ca y ow e ss v y co nd o ns an dm ed um ho mo ge ne ou s so e s s v ya sa u nc o no m e Th e mp ed an ce sp ec a sh ow ss em E 1 0 0E 40 6N 5 0 0E 40 5c c es o a ge d am e es on h e s d ay s1 5 w h ad u s on k e be ha vo e a a o w e qu en ce s es s ha n1 0m Hz A d ay 5a p nh oe wa sm ad eo n he p a ch c oa n gc ov e ng h e ac v eh o da y We m me da e yd ee ce da o we R pv au e2 00 E9 06 5 0E 40 6 0 N P3 X U P3 X 0 O P 3X 40 0 0 0E 40 6 2 0 05 40 6Z o m 0 0 0 5 00 54 05 o hm Fg u e4 aa nd m pe da nc es pe c a o a me du m an db h gh so e s s v yw h no ho d ay sa nd 4 ev ec on d on so c ah od c po ec o nN P No p o ec o n UP U nd e p oe c on C P Ca h od c po ec o n an dO PO ve p o ec o n o ee c od es n po s on 3 ab y o y 3 o y 4



oussoandocamedumweeexposedpovokngheR pvaueonc easeTabesummazesheR pandC dcacuaedom hempedancemeasuedasauncono meRpsa edoncease omdaysxw henhesosa edodydue ow aeevapoaonno heamospheeanddascaydmn shedaday10w henhehodayw asoayexposedoheenvonmenTheR pdeceasessghyFgue6aandTabe asdoesC dFgue6bandTabe omdaysoneove Thsdeceasesaesuo achangenhesocond onsae headdono w ae Onhe hdayoheexpemen apnhoew asmadeonhecoangohepachseang heacvedeeco w hcha3%NaC1eecoyew asocayaddedundehepachTheR pdeceasedshapyTheC dFgu e6bdoesnoshow anympoanchangeaday6A heendoday10hepach hacoveedheacvedeecw asemovedR pdeceasesshapyandheC dchangesdeecedbecausehesuaceo hehodaysnowmuchage D aysPoena MV1 9003 90164 89985 89966 89858 899910885411 8987Z1HZRpOhm185E+ 05184E+ 05177E+05177E+ 05649E+ 04711E+04905E+ 04755E+ 02OLowH z81618161816181



soa sceaha de encesnmpedancesgnauesaeobaned heeveo poeconchangeso ahodayspesenandbecomesacveLessobvoussheac ha omoneunoanohe w ewno beabeosay apo heobsevedchangesaedueoco osonacvyWecannehe sayw heehaacvy socaedno w hahesevey soha acvy node oexpoew hehehesehngsae possbew eneedou heanayzehedaagaheedandpehapsw ew needochangeheepesenaono hedaa omNyqusandBodedagamsosomehngeseBecauseeachoneohesgnauesepesenng hempedanceconansseveaponsw edecdedochangehedaaep esenedbyheN yqusandBodedagamsoamoecompacomso haw ecoudcapuea hemeasuedchangesompedanceonhesysemFoexampewepoedheN yqusd agamsoeachun andcacuaedheR pandC dandhe equencesaw hchhosevauesoccuedSma yonheBodedagamswecacuaedheb eakngponsandsopeohecuvepo edom hedaameasuedandsedhosevauesandhecoespondngequencesaw hchheyoccuednh sw ayhenpons usedomeas



nvonmenThosevaabesncudesoess vyso pH ambenempeau eppedamee ppedephcoangchaaces cseecodepos onsw hespecoa eeenceandeveo cahodcpoecono poazaonvo ageWedecdedouseapaen ecognonanayssoesabshhehddene aonshpbew eenhenpusgnauesandhe daahaw eween eesednp edcngThapedc eddaaooupu vecoconansheno maonha w ewanooban hsnomaon susedo anana caneuanew okpa enecognonsysem Onceheneeanso eaenpus ooupus heoupuvecosno show nanymoeandhepaenecognon oosexpecedo ndcaeheoupuveco oag vennpuveco nhsw ayw eexpecobeabe oesabshheocaono hedeecsandoassessheseveyo hedamageN euaN ewoksModeWedesgnedanew h3 ayeseachconanng50neuonsEachneuonhadahypebocangen anseunc onWechoseaD eauew hmomenumoupdaehew eghsThenew as anedw h250uns Eachuncoespondedoau mpedancemeasuemeno aw echaace zedsysemWehad17npuscoespondngohechaacescso heN yq



6 g5 S S 4 a z z C 2 $ 1 $ 0 11 2 0 1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 9 Measu edFgu e7 One ho daysys em Measu ed ho zon a ds ance measu ed ove he gound and a ong he p pe ax s om he measu ng e ec odes oone ho day nee ve sus he NNp ed ced ds ance ommeasu ng e ec odes ohe ho days 5 4 5 3 5 5 V S S $ o S 1 V $ 0 1 0 1 2 3 4 5 Measu edF gu e 8 Two ho daysysem Measu ed ho zon a ds ance measu ed ove he gound and a ong he p pe ax s om he measu ng e ec odes ohe second ho day nee ve sus he NNp ed c ed d san



h e s e ve y o h e d am a g e on a s ca e o 0 o 1 0 0 a b a y s c a e Th e n e p e o m s ve y w e n s e p a a n g h e m d co o s o n o m h e s e v e e co o s o n T h e ne c o e c y p e d c s m o e a cc u a e y h e h g he e v e o c o o s o n s ev e y 1 0 0 h a n o we e v e s o c o o s o n se v e y 0 T h s m a y be d u e o h e wa y w e de n e d o u s ca e o C z s m p o a n o m e n o n h a w e u se d a 3 a y e o w a d b a ck w a d p o pa g a o n w h hy p e b o c a ng e n a n s e u n c o n w h c hs u cc e ss u y p e d c s h e o c a o n o h e h o d ay o n h e p p e T he e v e o d a m ag e o n ho s e ho d a y s n d ca e s h a h e e a o n s h p b e we e n n pu s a n d o u pu s s h g h y n o n n e aW e a s o n ve s g a e d wh c h n p u pa a m e e s c on b u e d m o s o h e e a n n g E x p o n g h e va u e s o h e w e gh s h a c o nn e c h e n eu o n s o m h e e s u s d o wn o h e n p u s w e o u nd h a h e e q ue n cy a w h ch C d s m e a su e d s a v e y m p o a n c o o s on s e ve y W e a ss g n ed a z e o c o o s on a e w h e n we v s u a y d d no n o c e c ha n ge s o n h e m e a su a c e e x po s ed h o u g ho u h e h o d a y wh e w a s ex p os e d o h e e nv o n m en s m p o a n o n o c e h a h e n e e a s y p e d c s h e h gh s e ve y c a s e s wh c h a e o m o e n e e s o m a ne n g ne e n g a n d e a b y p o n o v e w v a a b e o d e e n n



pedcaho daysocaonszeandseve yocoosonona sngeanddoubehodaysysemandaseveaeveso cahodcpoeconPSUPaen edThedaaw eepesenedo hene andomyshuedandhene eanedopedc heseveesw ngsohenpuvaabes Whenpesenednpudaao henechangedomoneo heoow ngun becauseeachow onhe npumax epesensacompeeynew expemena unn ea e sysemsaenoexpecedohavebgsw ngsheyw changenhew ayha hehodayw deveopAccodngyw eexpecha ane w hchcanbempemenednpaceoconnuousmono ngo hesysemw beabeopedc changesn hempedancesysemdueoheco osonacvyon heppew hmoeaccuacyThesmachangesonhemagnudeandphaseangebeakponsandsopesonheBodedagamusedo epesenheACmpedanceconnuousmeasuemensw beusedopedc heocaonohe hodaysandhe coosonR eeences1USDepamenoTanspoa onPpeneSaeyR eguaons N auaGasPa 191192p3903942 MKendngF MansedandSTsaD ee mnaono heLongTemCoosonBehavooC oaedSeew hA



JKenneyandL BoneC uenandPoen aD s buononaC oaedPpenew h HodaysPa C ompasonoheE ecsoD sceeandD s buedH odaysC o oson49319936 FMansed LTHanCC LeeandGZhangAnayssoETSandENADaaoPoymeCoaedSee ExposedaR emoeTes MaeasScenceFoum247 5119977FMansed andCHTsaD eem naono C oangD eeoa onw hETAPa Deveopmenoa MehodoFed TesngoPo ecveC oangsC ooson 49919938 PRRobegeandVSSas OnLneC oosonMonong w hEecochemcampedanceSpecoscopyC o oson501019949 MCHMcKubeSC LeachDDMacdonadandSHe aachAS udyoFeasbyo U sngEeccaMehods oD eecD eecsnheC oangso C ahodcayPoecedPpenes FnaR epoPo ec8601bySR198610YAE Tanaw yRCRochaFhoMUqud MacdonadandDDMacdonadD eveopmenoU aowFequencyACmpedanceSpecoscopyU LFACSoDeecngandLocangC o osononR ebanR enocedC oncee FnaR epobySRundeconac SHRP871D 008198911DCS vemanA caN euaN ewokPedc o



JPSSa Anovevew ohePpe neSay eguaoyagendaspesenedheeo enabe neesedpa esopudenyp anhe ppenesaey eguaoycompanceeo sA keyemo ackngohcomngna uemakngssdscussedaongw hsuggesons omono ngpogessonoheagendaems Anohepuposesevedsha o povdngJPSauhosw ha commonbaseopendngssuesandhow besocompy eecveyande cenyD escponTheaes D epamenoT anspoaon SemannuaR eguaoyagendawasssuedonN ovembe22199964FR64851TheagendancudesheOceo PpeneSaeysR eseachandSpecaPogamsAdmnsaonsemannuasummayoacu enandpoeced uemakngsevew soexsngegua onsandcompeedaconsTheseaemaesonw hchaconhasbegunosp oeceddunghe succeedng12monhsosuchongepeod asmaybeancpaedo ow hchaconhasbeencompeedsnceheasagendaTheagendasaebasedonepos submedbyheo cesnang heuemakngandae evew edbyheD epamenReguaonsC ouncTheD epamensas agendaw aspubshednheFedeaR egse



o h s s e s h p e g s do g o v H ow R u em a k ng s A e D es g n a ed S g n c a n P o y T h e a ge n cy h a s c as s e d u e s a s a DO T ag e nc y p o y n h e a ge n da h e y a e e ss e n a y v e y c os y c o n o v e s a o o s u b s a n a p u b c n e e s u n de E x e cu v e O d e 1 2 86 6 A D O T a ge n cy p o y u e m ak n g d oc u me n s a e s ub e c o e v e w b y h e Se c e a y o T a n s po a o n h e O c e o M a na g em e n a n d Bu d ge 0 MB d ec d e s a u e s s u b ec o s e v e w s c a ss e d a s s g n c a n n h e a g en d a Ex p a na o n o n o m a o n o n h e A g e nd a Th e o m a o h s a g en d a s e q u e d b yO c e o M a n a g em e n a nd B u dg e m emo a n d um o J u y 2 1 1 9 99 F s h e ag e nd a s d v d e d by n a n g o c e s T h en h e a g e nd a s d v d e d n o v e c a e go e s 1 p e u e s a g e 2 p o p os e d u e s a ge 3 n a u e s a g e 4 o n g e m a c o n s a nd 5 c om p e e d a c on s F o e a ch e n y h e a g e n da p o v de s h e o o w n g n o m a o n 1 s s g n c a n c e 2 a s h o d e s c p v e e 3 s e g a b a s s 4 h e e a e d e g u a o y c a o n n h e C o de o F e d e a R eg u a o n s 5 an y e g a d ea d n e a nd s o o w h a a c o n e g N P RM n a u e 6 a n a b s a c 7 a m e a b e n c u d n g h e e a e s e xp e c ed d a e o a d e c s o n o n wh e h e o a k e h e a c o n 8 w he h e h e u e m a k n gw a e c s m a



e evdenceoageae needohe eguaoncoudesu naneae pubcaondaeGudenes oD eemn ngFohcomngFnaR uesAkeyndcaoha geneaypedcs haauemakngs ohcomngasa naue savoeonhessuebyheSae yAdvsoyC ommees TheTechncaH azadousLqudPpeneSaeySandadsC ommeeLqudsandheTechncaPpeneSaeySandadsC ommeecu enymee w ceayeausuaynMayandN ovembe sdunghesemeengsha emsaepacedonheagendaodscussonandnsomecasesavoeonhe echncaeasb yeasonabenessandpaccab yo hepoposasecodedOncehecomm eesvoeonheuemaknghe w aysceaedo naue pubcaonsoonheeae nheedea egseU nde heC ommeeschaes sobecvesandduesaeaso ow sTheExecuveD eco shasubm oheC ommeeo sconsdeaonanynoceopoposedhazadousqudppenesaeysandadso gasppenesaeysandadspubshednheFedeaR egse Whn90daysae ecepbyheC ommeeo anysuchpoposaheC omm eeshapepaea epoon heechncaeasb yeasonabenessandpaccab yo hepopo



nDCanddd nacnoe hsemasavoe ssueBohcommeesvoedunanmousyoappovehepoposedueGasandH azadousLqudPpeneR epa ThsemwassubsequenyssuedbyOPSasaFnaR ueonD ecembe4h1999nhe edeaegs e auemakngsdesgnaedasSgn can hemepe odbew eencommeevoeand nauepubca onmaybeaecedbyO ceoManagemenandBudgeevewA eadngoheSae yAdvsoyC ommeemeengmnuesoa endanceoconacngheOPSpesondeangw ha pacua uemakngsnecessayomono ssuesseecedo avoeTheea ew ooheconsdeaons egadnghecommeevo ngssueOnesha dec nauesmayomayno equea omacommeevoe Secondyheuseoma baoso canvasshecommees esponseoapa cuassuedoesnonecessay haveobeepo edaascheduedcommeemeengSuggesonsoMono ngPogessonAgendaemsTheeaecu eny20u emakngemsonheOPSagendaAsmpeandeasyw ayomonodeveopmensoneachem somakeuseoheOPSwebseh p opsdogovandgooheOPSReguaons nkandnoeheOPSReguaonsn



e m n n g h e Ex e n o C o o s o n o n Ex p os e d N S S e p 1 2 1 9 89 G as P p e n e s M a c h 1 99 9 N o e F n a R u e s su e d 1 0 22 9 9 6 4 F R 56 9 78 A do p o n o n d u s y S a nd a d s o L q u e e d N a u a N S M a y 5 1 99 9 Ga s F ac e s 11 1 0 L q u ds 4 9 C FR 1 9 5 R u e ma k n g EP o D os e d S ag e A e a sU n us u a y S en s v e o E n v o n me n a D a ma g e N S US A S+ E me g e n cy F o w Re s c n g D e v ce s S + Re c ox n me n da o n s o C h an g e Ha z a d ou s L q u d S P p e n e Sa e y S a n da d s P e ss u e T es n g O d e P p e n e s n Te m n a s N S V 0 L q u ds 4 9 C FR 1 9 5 R u e ma k n g F n a S a ge + Re s po n se P a n s o O n sh o e O P p e n e s S V 0 G as a n d L qu d s 4 9 CF R 1 90 1 9 9 Ru e m ak n g P o p o se d S a g e Pe o d c U n de w a e n s p ec o n s N S P od u ce o p e a e d O u e C on n e n a N S Sh e G a s a nd H a za d o u sL q u d P p e n es T ha C o s s D e c y n o S a eW a e s Pe o d c U p da e s o P p e n e S a e y N S Re q u e me n s 1 9 99 C o o s on C o n o o n G as a n d Ha z a do u s N S L qu d P p e n e sG a s an d H az a d ou s L q u d P pe n e R e pa



S C ha a c e s c s N o c a o n o S a e A g e n c es P p e n v en o y U nd e w a e A b an d on e d P pe n e F a c e s N S N o v 5 1 99 9 En o c e m en P o c e du e s N S N o v 5 1 99 9 V 0 G a s 49 C F R 19 2 L o ng T e mA c o n S ag e X O L q u d s 4 9 CF R 1 95 1 L o n g Te mA c o n S a g e X 0 Ga s & L q u ds 4 9 C FR 1 9 0 19 9 L o n g Te mA c o n S a g e+ n c e as e d n sp e c o n Re q u e m en s S R eg u a e d Ga s a nd H a za d o u sL q u d N S Ga h e n g L n e s T h e Re g u a o y Ag e n da o h e O c e o P p e n e S a e y S o u ce 6 4 F R 6 48 5 1 1 1 2 2 9 9 P op o se d R u e S ag e 1 0 GA S G AT H ER N G L NE D E F NT O N P o p os e d Ru e S a g e P o y S u b s a n v e N on s g n c a n Le g a A u ho y 4 9 U SC 6 0 10 1 o 6 0 1 25 C FR C a o n 4 9 C F R 19 2 Le g a D ea d n e F n a S a u o y O c o b e 2 4 1 9 94 A b s a c T h e ex s n g d e n o n o g a h e n g n e w o u d be c e a y d e n e d o e m n a e co n u s on n d s n g u s h n g h es e p p e n es o m a n sm s s o n n e s n u a a e a s T h e co s s s ho u d be m nm a s n c e h e de n o n w c o n o m o p e v a n g p a c c es n g o v e nm e n a nd n d u s y 6 2 A u u mn 1 9 99 J O U RN A L OF P P E L NE S A FE T Y



R M 0 9 2 5 9 1 5 6 F R 48 5 05 R eq u es o C o mme n s 0 3 1 1 99 6 4 F R 12 1 47 E e c o n c Pu b c M e e n g 0 4 1 3 9 9E x e ns o n o C o mme n P e o d 0 4 3 0 9 9 6 4 F R 23 2 5 6C o mme n P e o d E nd s 0 7 0 7 99 S NP R M 0 1 0 0 0 0R e gu a o y F e x b y A n a y ss R e qu e d N o S ma E n e s A e c e d B us n e ss e sG o ve n m e n L ev e s A e c e d N on e Ad d o n a n o m a o n D o c ke N o R S P A 98 4 8 6 8 Fo m e y P S 1 2 2 A NA L YS S R e g u a o y Ev a u a o n 0 9 25 9 1 5 6 F R 4 85 0 5A g en c y Co n a c L E H e c k T a n s p o a o n S p ec a s D e p a m e n o T a n s po a o n R e s e a ch a nd S p ec a P o g a m s Ad m n s a o n 4 0 0 S e ve n h S e e S WW a s h n g on D C 2 0 59 0 P h on e 2 0 2 3 66 5 5 23 R JN 2 1 3 7 AB 1 52 0 A R EA S U NU S UA L L YS E NS T V E T OE N V RO N ME N TA L D AMA GE U S AS P o p o se d R u e S ag e P o y S u bs a n v e N o ns g n c a n L eg a A u h o y 4 9 U S C 60 1 01 o 6 0 1 2 5C F RC a o n 4 9 C F R 19 5 Le g a D ea d n e F n a S a u o y O c o b e 2 4 1 9 94 J O UR N AL O F P P EL N E S AF E TY A u u m n 1 9 99 6 3



onw esab shce ao denyngaeasneahazadousqudppe neshaae unusuaysensveoenvonmenadamageappe neaccdenoccusThece aaebengdeveopednconsuaonw hheEnvonmenaPoec onAgencyandoheagencesC ea oden caonounusuaysensveaeasw bepo esedn1999TmeabeAcon D ae FRCeSuppemenaN oce 062294 59FR32178ExendedC ommenPeodEnd 062695NPRM 120099R eguaoyFexbyAnayssR equed N oSmaEnesA ecedBusnessesGovenmenLevesAecedN oneAddonano maonD ockeN oPS140Waso gnayD ockePS130BEnvonmenaySensveA easo pa194 C hangedoaddesspa 195Aseeso pubcw okshopsweeconducedn1996and1997Addonaw okshopsw bescheduedasnecessayPo esngoUSAgudancesnow undew ayncoopeaonw h heAmecanPeoeum nsueAgencyC onacC hs naSamesPeoeumEngneeD epamen oTanspoa onR eseachandSpecaPogamsAdmns aon400SevenhS eeSW WashngonDC20590Phone2023664561RN2137AC3430PE



neFna Sauoy Ocobe241995Absac Thsaconw oudeque opeaoso nauagasandhazadousqudppenes oconducpeodcundew aenspeconsoo shoeppenesandhosennavgabew aewaysThsaconw oudasodenew hacons uesanexposedundew aeppe neandw haconsuesahazadonavgaonT meabeAcon D ae FRCeNPRM 120099R eguaoyFexby AnayssR equedN oSmaEnesA ecedBusnessesGovenmenLevesAecedU ndeemnedAddonan omaon D ockeN oRSPA973001AgencyC onacMeaneBabe TanspoaonSpecas D epamenoT anspoaonR eseachandSpecaPogamsAdmnsaon 400SevenhSeeSW WashngonDC20590Phone2023664595RN2137AC5440PERODCUPDATESTOPPELNESAFETYREOUREMENTS1999PoposedR ueSageN ew emPo ySubsanveN onsgncanR envenngGovenmenThs uemakngspa oheR envenngGovenmene o w evse exn heCFRoeducebudenodupca ono seamne equemens JOURNALOFPPELNESAFETYAuumn199965



9CFR190199LegaD eadneN oneAbsacThspe odcupdaeevsesandupdaesheppenesaey eguaonsopovdeca yandemoveunnecessaybudensoheeguaedp penecommunyR evsonsncudeupdaedeeencesovounayspeccaonsandsandadsncopoa edbyeeencen heppenesaeyegua onsandvaousca caonsandgammacacoec onsThcseupdaeseec hemosecened onsoeachspeccaonandsandadncopoaedby eeenceTheseupdaesenabeppeneopeaos ou zecuen echnoogymaeasandp accesheebyeducngcosandenhancngeconomcgow hTmeabeAcon D ae FRCeNPRM 120099R eguaoyFexbyAnayssR equed N oSmaEnesA ecedN oGovenmenLevesAecedN oneAddonanoma onD ockeN oRSPA996106AgencyC onacRHu auxManageR eguaonsD epa menoTanspoa onR eseachandSpecaPogamsAdmns aon400SevenhSee SWWashngonDC20590Phone2023664565RN2137AD3566Auumn1999JOURNALOFPPELNESAFETY



e p u b s he s o h e J o u n a o P p e n e Sa e y W e h o pe h a s be e n o b e ne o y o u Fo s u b sc p o n n o m a o n o o o d e b y p h on e o a x $ 2 9 9 y p e as e c a u s a p h on e a x 1 8 8 8 7 20 8 1 3 6 OR 2 0 2 63 7 9 7 35 e m a w p b sa a g n e T o o d e b y m a u s s e n d o d e c a d a nd p a ym e n $2 9 9 1y a o n g w h c o mp a ny n a m e a d d es s a nd p ho n e n um b e o J o u n a o P p e n e Sa e y d oW PL P O B o x 2 36 7 5 L E n an P a z a W a sh n g o n D C 20 0 26 3 6 7 5



P O B ox 2 36 75 L E n an P a za W as h ng o n DC 2 00 26 3 67 5 P ho ne F ax 4 03 2 40 0 17 1 E m a w p bs a a g ne E nc o se d s yo u s c om p m en a y s su e o h e Jo u na o P p e n eS a e y We h op e yo u w n d h ea c e s n e e s ng a nd n o m a ve a n d ha h e y w b e o be ne o y ou a nd y ou c om pa ny y ou w ou d k e o c on n u e o e ce v e he P S p e as e o u h e o m b e o wa nd m a o J ou n a o P pe n e Sa e y d o WP L P O B ox 2 36 75 L E n an P a za W as h ng o n DC 2 00 26 3 67 5 O R YO U CA N FA X TH S FO RM T OL L FR EE T O 18 88 7 20 8 13 6 O u n ex s s ue w b e S p ng 2 00 0 a nd s e xp ec e d o be p ub s he d n h e a e sp n g o e a y s um m e T ha nk y ou o e x p es s ng a n n e es n h e J ou n a o P pe n e Sa e y W e we c om e yo u c om m en s o v e ws a a ny m e J PS S a o Y E S w o u d ke o c on n u e o e ce v e he J ou n a o P pe n e Sa e y Y ea y F ee $ 2 99 0 0 2 ss ue s S p ng a nd A u um n 20 0 0 o P a ym en E n co se d 0 B m y Co mp an y



RDOUSLQUDPPELNESPoposedR ueSagePo ySubsanveN onsgncanR envenngGovenmenThs uemakngspa oheR envenngGovenmene o w evse exn heCFRoeducebudenodupca ono seamne equemensLegaAuho y49U sc60101o60125CFRCa on49CFR19249CFR195LegaD eadneN oneAbsacThecoosoncon oegua onsogasandhazadousqudppe nesw be evsedoncopoaehe aessaeys andadsoco osonpoecono seeppe Speccc ea ocoosonpo econw bencopoaedn ohe edeappenesae yeguaons ncudngheadoponovounays andadsoecognzedsandadssengoganza onscompaabesandadsw beappedo bohgasandhazadousqudppenesTmeabeAcon D ae FRCeNoceoPubcMee ng040799 64FR16885NPRMHazadousLqudPpenes 120099NPRMGasPpenes 020000R eguaoyFexby AnayssR equedN oSmaEn esAecedN oGovenmenLevesAecedSa eLocaAddona nomaon D ockeN oRSPA972762N oceopubcmeeng10299762 FR56141AgencyConacLM FuowManage



2460GASANDHAZARDOUSLOUDPPELNEREPARPoposedR ueSagePo ySubsanveN onsgncanR envenngGovenmenThs uemakngspa oheR envenngGovenmene o w evse exn heCFRoeducebudenodupca ono seamne equemensLegaAuhoy 49USC60101o60125CFRCaon49CFR19549CFR192LegaD eadneN oneAbsac Gasppeha sgeneaycoodedovea ageaeao heexenha w ah cknesssunsaemusbeepacedunessn hecaseo ansmssonppeopeangpessues educedSmayanydamageha mpashesevceab yohghs essansmssonppemusbeepaceduness sepaedbya uencc emenwededspseeveThepoposeduew oudpem opeaoso useaenaveco ecvemehodshahavebeendemonsaedopemanenyeso ehepessue negy oco odedodamagedppeByaow ngheuseo essexpensvepovenechnoogeshepoposeduew oudeducecossnhegasppe nendusyw hou educngsaeyTmeabeAcon D ae FRCeNPRM 040799 64FR16882C ommenPeodEnds060799FnaR ue 11009968Auumn1999



AnayssR equedN oGovenmenLevesAeced U ndeemnedAddonanonnaon D ockeN oRSPA984733AgencyConacLM FuowManageR eguaons D epamenoT anspoaonR eseachandSpecaPogamsAdmnsaon 400SevenhSeeSW WashngonDC20590Phone2023664559Fax2023664566Emabucku ow spadogovR 1N2137AD2570PRESSURETESTNGOLDERPPELNESNTERMNALSPoposedR ueSagePo ySubsanveN onsgncanLegaAuho y49USC60101o60125CFRCaon 49CFR195302LegaD eadneN oneAbsacC ean odeppe nesnem nasandankamsmusbep essueesedbeoeD ecembe72003Basedonape onRSPAseconsdengh sesng equemenn ghohe skandow opeangs essoheseppenesRSPAhassayedenocemeno heesngequ emenagansppenesdesgnednooopea eabove20pecenospecedmn mumyedsenghTmeabeNPRM010000JOURNALOFPPELNESAFETYAuumn199969



xb yAnayssR equedN oGovenmenLevesAeced U ndeemnedAddonanoma onD ockeN oRSPA984316N oceequesngcommen2109863FR6677nD ockeN oPS121AgencyConacMke sanGenea EngneeD epameno Tanspoaon R eseachandSpecaPogamsAdmnsa on400SevenhSee SWWashngonDC20590Phone2023664571Emam kesan psadogovRN2137AD2680+ EMERGENCYFLOWRESTRCTNGDEVCESPoposedR ueSagePo yOhe SgncanLegaAuho y49USC60101o60125CFRCaon 49CFR195LegaD eadneFna Sauoy Ocobe241996Absac Thsuemakngw oudspecyhoseccumsancesundew hchopeaosohazadousqudppenesae equedouseemegencyow esc ngdevcesEFRD soohep oceduessysemsandequpmeno deecandocaeppe neupuesandmnm zeeeasesThsaconsconsdeedsgncan becauseosubsana pubcnees TmeabeANPRM 011994 59FR2802ANPRMCommenPe odEnd 041994NPRM 06000070Auumn1999JOURNALOFPPELNESAFETY



n esAecedBusnessesGovenmenLevesAeced N oneAddona nomaon D ockeN oPS133Apubcw okshopw ashedon10199560FR44822Thsacon sbengcoodnaedw ho heu emakngsononshoeo sp esponsepansD ockeN oPS130 RN2137AC3OaeasunusuaysensveoenvonmenadamageD ockeN oPS140RN2137AC34andppeneeakdeec onsysemsDockeN oRSPA972362RN2137ADO5Theseaconsaebengpusuedncoodnaonw handaspa ohe esponseo heEFRDmandaeFs RSPAhasequedppeneopeaos odeveopandcayouonshoeo sp esponsepansundeheO PouonAc o1990D ockeN oPS130RN2137AC3OTheopeaoshaveed esponsepansundeanne mna ueandnumeousabeopexecsesandaeaexecseshavebeenconducedovadae hepannngpocessWokspoceedngona onepanappoachhaw oudaow anopeao o eonyoneo sp esponsepanw h hevaousneesedagencesA naue w bed ecedow admpovngopea osaccdenesponsecapab esandmnmzngaccdenconsequencesSecondRSPApubshedapoposedue oadopheA



TALSHELFGASANDHAZARDOUSLQUDPPELNESTHATCROSSDRECTLYNTOSTATEWATERSPoposedR ueSageN ewemP o ySubsanveN onsgncanLegaAuho y49U sc60101eseqCFRCaon49 FR19249CFR195LegaD eadneN oneAbsacThspoposeduew oud mpemenapovsono heD ecembe10 1996MemoandumoUndesandngMOUbeweenheD epameno hene oDOTandheD epamenoT anspoaonDOTegadngOue ConnenaSheOCSPpenes Thsuew oudaddesspoduceopeaedppenes hacossno Saew aesw hou sconnecngaanspo ngopeaos acyon heocs scompemenayoheD ecFnaR ueDFRhaaddessedOCSoo gasppenesocaedupseamo heponsaw hchopea ngesponsbyo heppenes anses omapoducngopeao oa anspongopeao 62FR61692N ovembe191997and63FR126598Mach161998Thepoposedueasow oudaddesshepoceduesbyw hchpoduceandanspoa onppeneopeaosw oudpe ono pemssonoopeae undeehe DOToDOeguaonsgovenngppenedesgnconsucon opeaonandmanenanceac



ERREGULATORYREVEWGASPPELNESAFETYSTANDARDSPoposedR ueSagePo ySubsanveN onsgncanR envenngGovenmenThs uemakngspa oheR envenngGovenmene o w evseexn heCFRoeducebudenodupcaon os eamneequemensLegaAuho y49USC60101o60125CFRCaon 49CFR192LegaD eadneN oneAbsacThsaconw oudchangemsceaneousgasppenesaeysandadsopovdeca yemnaeunnecessayooveybudensomeequemens andoseeconomcchangeSomeohepoposedchangesesu omRSPAsuhe evew ohesandadso ow ngs19951996evew undehePesdensR eguaoy R envenonn aveOhe changesaebasedonecommendaonsbyheN aonaAssocaono PpeneSaeyR epesenavesNAPSRnsN ovembe1992epoon hesandadsThepoposedchangesw oudeducecossnheppenendusyw houcompomsngsaeyNAPSRandheppenendusy onnedaw oknggoupoconsde heNAPSRpoposasandohessuesOnMay31999 hsgoupsubmed sevauaonsohe poposedchangesnhegasppenesaey eguaonsTmeabeAc





n esAecedBusnessesGovenmenLevesAeced N oneAddona nomaon D ockeN oRSPA972717AgencyC onacLM FuowTanspoa onSpecasD epamen oTanspoa onR eseachandSpecaPogamsAdmns aon400SevenhS eeSW WashngonDC20590Phone2023664559RN2137AD1OFnaRueSage12DETERMNNGTHEEXTENTOFCORROSONONEXPOSEDGASPPELNESFnaRueSageP oy SubsanveN onsgncanLegaAuhony49USC60101o60125CFRCaon 49CFR192LegaD eadneN oneAbsacGasppeneopeao smusnow nspeco coosononbuedme acppe hasexposedbyexcavaon anycoosonsdscoveed hsuemakngw oudeque opeaos onvesgaeu heo deemnehe uexen ohe coosonAsm anvesga onsa eadyequedo hazadousqudppenesNTSBhasecommendedha hspoposabeadopedoesabshanequvaeneve osaey ogasppenes ngh oNTSBnees hsue w be nazedandohe coosonssuesw beaddessednasepaaeuemakngTmeabeAcon D ae FRCeNPRM 062789 54FR27041



Avaab yoD a EnvonmenaAssessmen 052599 64FR28136FnaR ue 102299 64FR56978R eguaoyFexb yAnayssR equedN oSmaEn esAecedBusnessesGovenmenLevesAecedN oneAddona nomaon D ockeN oPS107 Asepaaepoceedngo evew aco osonconoequemens n49CFRpas192and195snow undew ayD ockeN oRSPA97276262FR44436Aug211997A noceoavaab yo heda envonmenaassessmenwaspubshedonMay251999ANALYSSReguaoyEvauaon062789 54FR27041AgencyConacL MFu owTanspoaonSpecas D epamenoT anspoaonR eseachandSpecaPogamsAdmnsaon 400SevenhSeeSW WashngonDC20590Phone2023664559MN2137AB5O13PASSAGEOFNTERNALNSPECTONDEVCESFnaRueS agePo ySubsanveN onsgncanLegaAuho y49USC60101o60125CFRCaon 49CFR19249CFR195LegaD eadneN oneAbsacThsuemakngesabshedmnmumFedeappe nesaeysandadsequ nghanew andepacemengasansmssonandhazadousqudppenesbedesgnedoaccommodae



n o o n sh o e g a s a n sm s s o n n e s n u a a e a s Tm e a b e A c on D a e F R C e NP R M 1 1 2 0 9 2 5 7 F R 54 7 4 5N P RMC omme n P e o d E nd 0 1 1 9 9 3F n a R u e 0 4 1 2 9 4 5 9 F R 17 2 7 5N P RM 0 9 3 0 94 5 9 FR 4 98 9 6N P RMC o e c o n 1 0 1 9 94 5 9 F R 52 8 63 L m e d s us p en s o n o En o c e m en 0 2 0 7 9 5 6 0 F R 71 3 3 Fn a A c o n 1 1 0 0 9 9R e gu a o y F e x b y A n a y s sR e qu e d N o S ma E n e s A e c e d B us n e ss e sG o ve n m e n L ev e s A e c e d N on e Ad d o n a n o m a o n D o c ke N o P S 1 2 6 T he n e g y e s n g p o p os a n P o p o s a s o P p e n e Sa e y R N 2 1 3 7 A B2 7 w a s co n so d a e d n p a n o h s u e m a k n g AN A LY S S R e gu a o y E v a ua o n 0 4 1 2 9 4 5 9 FR 1 7 27 5 Ag e nc y C on a c R H u a u x M a n ag e R e gu a o n s D e pa m e n o T a n s p o a o n R e se a c h a nd S pe c a P o g a ms A d m n s a o n 4 0 0 Se v en h S e e S WW a s h n g o n DC 2 0 59 0 P ho n e 2 0 2 36 6 4 5 65 R T 2 1 3 7 AB 7 1 J O UR N AL O F P P EL N E S AF E TY A u u m n 1 9 99 7 7



E L NE S F n a R u e S a ge P o y O h e S g n c a n L e ga A u h o y 4 9 U s c 6 01 0 1 o 6 01 2 5 CF R c a o n 4 9 C FR 1 9 4L e ga D e a d n e F n a S a u o y A u g us 1 8 1 9 9 2 A bs a c T h e n e m n a u e e s a b s h ed e g u a o n s e q u n g e s po n se p a n s o c e a n o n s ho e o p p e n e s T ho s e e g u a o ns a e m a n da e d b y h e Fe d e aW a e P o u o n c on o A c a s a m en d ed b y h e O P o u o n A c o 1 9 9 0 P ub L 1 0 1 3 8 0 P p e n e o pe a o s e d e s po n se p a ns u n de h s n e m n a u e a n d n u m e ou s a b e o p ex e c s es a n d a e a ex e c s es h a ve b e e nc o nd u c ed o v a d a e h e p a n n ng p o c e ss T h e p u po s e o h e se e q u e m e n s s o m p o v e es p on s e ca p ab e s a nd m nm z e h e m p ac o o n s h o e o s p s o m p p e n e s T h s u e s s g n c a n b ec a us e o s u bs a n a p u b c a n d co n g e ss o n a n e e s T h e n a u e w e e c h e e x pe e n c e g an e d u nd e h e n e m n a u e T m e a b e A c o n D a e F R C e n e m F n a R u e 0 1 0 5 9 3 5 8 F R 24 4 Co mme n P e o d E n d 0 2 1 9 93 N o c e o P ub c M e e n g 0 6 1 5 9 4 5 9 F R 30 7 55 N o c e o P ub c H e a n g 1 1 2 9 96 6 1 F R 60 6 79 C o e c o n 0 1 2 1 9 7 6 2 F R 29 8 9 Fn a A c o n 1 1 0 0 9 9R e gu a o y F e x b y A n a y s sR e qu e



SeeSW WashngonDC20590Phone2023668860RN2137AC3O15ADOPTONOFNDUSTRYSTANDARDSFORLOUEFEDNATURALGASFACLTESFnaRueS agePo ySubsanveN onsgncanLegaAuho y49USC60101o60128CFRCaon 49CFR193LegaD eadneN oneAbsacThsaconw oud epacemosohe exsngDOTsandadsgovennghesngdesgnandconsuc ono queednaua gasac esw hanncopoa onbyeeenceo he1996edono heN aonaFe PoeconAssocaondocumenANSNFPA59APoduconSo ageandH andngoLqueedN au aGas Theaconw hchsbasedonanNFPAuemakngpeon sexpecedoeducecossohe gasppenendusyw houcompomsngsaeyTmeabeAcon D ae FRCeNPRM 122298 63FR70735NPRMCommenPeodEnd 032399FnaR ue 120099R eguaoyFexby AnayssR equedN oSmaEn esAecedBusnessesGovemnenLevesAecedN oneAddona nomaon DockeN oRSPA973002N oceo pubc JOURNALOFPPELNESAFETYAuumn199979



anGenea EngneeD epameno Tanspoaon R eseachandSpecaPogamsAdmnsa on400SevenhSee SWWashngonDC20590Phone2023664571Emam kesan psadogovR JN 2137AD1116+MAPSANDRECORDSOFPPELNELOCATONSANDCHARACTERSTCSNOTFCATONOFSTATEAGENCESPPENVENTORYFnaRue SagePo yOhe SgncanLegaAuho y49USC60101o60125CFRCa on49CFR19249CFR195LegaD eadneFna Sauoy N ovembe1 1989AbsacThsaconp oposesoequazeasaaspossbehe equemenshagasandhazadousqudppeneopeao skeepmapsandecodsoshow heocaonandohechaace scsop penesOpeaosw oudbe equedokeepannvenoyo ppeandpeodcayepo meageandohe acsn addonopea osw oudbeequed opovdecean nomaon oSaeagencesuponequesThssa sgncanac onbecauseocongessonaandSaeconcensabouheneedo appopaepubco casohaveppenen omaonTmeabeAc on D ae FRCeTemnae 090000R eguaoyFexby AnayssR equedN o80Auu



esAecedN oneAddona nonnaon nu heanceohs uemakngheD epameno TanspoaonsO ceoPpeneSae yOPSswokngw ho heFedeaandSae agencesandppenendusyoceaea naonappene mappngsysemThssysemwhencompeew show heocaonandseeceda buesohemao nauagasandhazadousqudppe nesandqueednauagas ac esopeangn heU nedSaesOPSw addaddonadaa ayesnohesysem ncudngayesonpopuaondenses unusuaysensveaeasnaua dsasepobab yandhghconsequenceaeashydogaphyandanspoa onnew oksOPSw usehesysemodepcppenesn eaon ohepubcand heenvonmenandow ok w hohegovenmenagencesandndusydungan ncdenAon govenmenndusyMappngQuayAconTeamMQAT hasdaedna onappenemappngsandadshaw beusedoceae hedga ppeneaye Thesencudesandadsoe econcdaasubmssonspapemapsubmssonsandmeadaadaaonhedaaThe eamhasasodaedsandads haw beusedbyheppenemappngeposoy ecevngheppeneno maonTheeam



nw equeopeaos ogasandhazadousqudppene ac esoepo cean nomaonabouabandonedundew aeppenes ncudngocaonsze daeoabandonmenandcompancew happcabeaw sThenoma onw beava abeo usebyoheFedeaagencesandsaeauho esTmeabeNPRM 083099 64FR47157FnaR ue 030000R eguaoyFexby AnayssR equedU ndeemnedSmaEnesA ecedBusnessesGovenmenLevesAecedU ndeemnedAddonan omaon D ockeN oRSPA972094AgencyC onacMeaneBabe TanspoaonSpecas D epamenoT anspoaonR eseachandSpecaPogamsAdmnsaon 400SevenhSeeSW WashngonDC20590Phone2023664595RN2137AC3318ENFORCEMENTPROCEDURESFnaRueSageP oy SubsanveN onsgncanR envenngGovenmenThsuemakngspa o heR envenngGovenmene o w evseexn heCFRoeducebudenodupca ono seamne equemensLegaAuhoy 49USC60101o60125CFRCaon49CFR19020949CFR19021382Auumn1999JOURNALOFPPELNESAFETY



eRSPAsppenesaeyenocemenpoceduesomnm zepapew oknunconesedcasesw heeapesonpaysapoposedcvpenayo ageesoapoposedcompanceodeThepoceduesw bechangedoshow ha bohesponsesaeconsdeedoensesndeennnngany uuecv penayassessmensThesechangesw s eamneheenocemenp ocessTmeabeAcon D ae FRCeNPRM 081299 64FR43972C ommenPeodEnds 101299FnaR ue 120099R eguaoyFexbyAnayssR equedN oSmaEn esAecedN oGovenmenLevesAecedN oneAddona nomaon D ockeN oRSPA984284Thechangesopa 190modyagencyuesopacceandpocedueAgencyC onacLndaD augheyEnocemenO ceD epameno TanspoaonR eseachandSpecaPogamsAdmnsa on400SevenhSeeSW WashngonDC20590Phone2023664577Emadaughe spadogovRN2137AD22 JOURNALOFPPELNESAFETYAuumn199983



ONREOUREMENTSLongTemAconsP o yOhe SgncanLegaAuho y49U sc60101o60125CFRCaon 49CFR19249CFR195LegaD eadneFnaSa uoyOcobe 241995Absac Thsuemakngw oudaddessheneedoadd onapeodcnspecono gasandhazadousqudppenes nhghdensyenv onmenaysensveo navgabew aewayaeasTheeguaonsw oudpescbeccumsancesundew hchsuchnspeconsmusbeconducedbynenanspecondevcesoequvaenmeansThsacon sconsdeedsgncanbecauseosubsanapubcn eesTmeabeAc on D ae FRCePubcWokshop 101895 60FR44821NPRM 060000R eguaoyFexby AnayssR equedN oSmaEn esAecedBusnessesGovenmenLevesAecedN oneAddonan omaon D ockeN oPS141AgencyC onacL MFuow TanspoaonSpecas D epamenoT anspoaonR eseachandSpecaPogamsAdmnsaon 400SevenhSeeSW WashngonDC20590Phone2023664559RN2137AC3884Auumn1999JOURNALOFPPELNESAFETY



Documents

pipeline safety journal.pdf