43
1 Physician Burnout and IT Experience Design May 10, 2018 Rasu B. Shrestha, MD MBA Chief Innovation Officer, UPMC Chair, HIMSS Innovation Committee Santosh Mohan, MMCi CPHIMS FHIMSS Head, More Disruption Please Labs, athenahealth Member, HIMSS HIT User Experience Committee

Physician Burnout and IT Experience Design 10/Shrestha and Mohan... · Physician Burnout and IT Experience Design May 10, 2018 Rasu B. Shrestha, ... Structured documents do ... From

  • Upload
    others

  • View
    6

  • Download
    0

Embed Size (px)

Citation preview

Page 1: Physician Burnout and IT Experience Design 10/Shrestha and Mohan... · Physician Burnout and IT Experience Design May 10, 2018 Rasu B. Shrestha, ... Structured documents do ... From

1

Physician Burnout and IT Experience Design

May 10, 2018

Rasu B. Shrestha, MD MBA

Chief Innovation Officer, UPMC

Chair, HIMSS Innovation Committee

Santosh Mohan, MMCi CPHIMS FHIMSS

Head, More Disruption Please Labs, athenahealth

Member, HIMSS HIT User Experience Committee

Page 2: Physician Burnout and IT Experience Design 10/Shrestha and Mohan... · Physician Burnout and IT Experience Design May 10, 2018 Rasu B. Shrestha, ... Structured documents do ... From

2

Speakers

Rasu B. Shrestha MD MBA

Chief Innovation Officer, UPMC

Executive VP, UPMC Enterprises

Chair: HIMSS Innovation Committee

@RasuShrestha

Santosh Mohan MMCi FHIMSS

Head, More Disruption Please Labs

athenahealth

Member: HIMSS User Experience Committee

@santoshSmohan

Page 3: Physician Burnout and IT Experience Design 10/Shrestha and Mohan... · Physician Burnout and IT Experience Design May 10, 2018 Rasu B. Shrestha, ... Structured documents do ... From

3

Is Physician Burnout Real? 1

UX Approaches and Techniques2

Case Studies3

Discussion:

What Top Actions Can Move Value Forward?4

Road Map

Road Map

Page 4: Physician Burnout and IT Experience Design 10/Shrestha and Mohan... · Physician Burnout and IT Experience Design May 10, 2018 Rasu B. Shrestha, ... Structured documents do ... From

4

It’s a whole new world. The old way of practicing medicine is just that

– an old way of doing things… Many of us got into medicine to be

independent…, and now we’re being asked to join group practices,

follow protocols, and take advice from a computer. We’ve always

treated sick people, but now we are trying harder than ever to keep

them well. We used to bill for single services, but now we have to

look at the whole continuum of care. Things have changed.”

Toby Cosgrove, MD, CEO, The Cleveland Clinic

What Does it Mean to Practice Medicine Today?

Source: “Saying Goodbye to the Old World of Healthcare”, LinkedIn Blog of Toby Cosgrove, March 2014, available

at https://www.linkedin.com/pulse/20140305130248-205372152-saying-goodbye-to-the-old-world-of-healthcare,

accessed January 26, 2016.

Page 5: Physician Burnout and IT Experience Design 10/Shrestha and Mohan... · Physician Burnout and IT Experience Design May 10, 2018 Rasu B. Shrestha, ... Structured documents do ... From

5

Source: Gartner-AMDIS Survey of US CMIOs, 2016

The Mood and Attitude of Physicians, 2016

Page 6: Physician Burnout and IT Experience Design 10/Shrestha and Mohan... · Physician Burnout and IT Experience Design May 10, 2018 Rasu B. Shrestha, ... Structured documents do ... From

“I realized that my beloved profession was being turned upside down by technology.”Dr @Bob_Wachter

The Digital Doctor: Hope, Hype, and Harm at the Dawn of Medicine's Computer Age

6

Page 7: Physician Burnout and IT Experience Design 10/Shrestha and Mohan... · Physician Burnout and IT Experience Design May 10, 2018 Rasu B. Shrestha, ... Structured documents do ... From

7

7

Concept by Sachin Jain, Art by Matthew Hayward

Page 8: Physician Burnout and IT Experience Design 10/Shrestha and Mohan... · Physician Burnout and IT Experience Design May 10, 2018 Rasu B. Shrestha, ... Structured documents do ... From

8

Emergency department physicians spent 44 percent of

their time entering data into electronic medical records, clicking

up to 4,000 times during a 10-hour shift.

-Becker’s Health IT & CIO Review magazine, October 11, 2013

8

Page 9: Physician Burnout and IT Experience Design 10/Shrestha and Mohan... · Physician Burnout and IT Experience Design May 10, 2018 Rasu B. Shrestha, ... Structured documents do ... From

9

1. Changes in Burnout and Satisfaction With Work-Life Balance in Physicians and the General US Working Population Between 2011 and 2014, Mayo Clinic Proceedings

2. Academy of Integrative Health & Medicine 2014 Annual Conference Survey

3. Mchugh, Matthew et al. “Nurses’ Widespread Job Dissatisfaction, Burnout, and Frustration With Health Benefits Signal Problems For Patient Care.” Health Affairs, 30, no.2 (2011): 202-210

Image Credit: W. Eugene Smith, Country Doctor An exhausted Dr. Ernest

Ceriani holding a cup of coffee, still in scrubs. August, 1948. LIFE Magazine

Burnout… and Its ImpactThree Dimensions of Burnout Captured by Maslach Burnout Inventory

CYNICISM

EMOTIONAL

EXHAUSTION

INEFFECTIVEN

ESS

50% Physicians admit at least one symptom of burnout1

39% Screened positive for depression

57%Clinicians said they feel more attached to their

computer than their patients on "most days.”2

02%Decrease in likelihood of patient recommendations

for every 10% of nurses reporting job

dissatisfaction3

Page 10: Physician Burnout and IT Experience Design 10/Shrestha and Mohan... · Physician Burnout and IT Experience Design May 10, 2018 Rasu B. Shrestha, ... Structured documents do ... From

10

Medical errors now third leading cause of death in United States

Ineffective communication is associated

with approximately 95% of malpractice

suits and 2/3 of sentinel events

The Joint Commission

Page 11: Physician Burnout and IT Experience Design 10/Shrestha and Mohan... · Physician Burnout and IT Experience Design May 10, 2018 Rasu B. Shrestha, ... Structured documents do ... From

11

8-Hour Clinic Day + After-Hours

Multiple clicks required

Templates may

affect data quality

Structured documents do

not match thought process

Context & reasoning

difficult to communicate

Document the

same information in

multiple places

HIT Design

Fit to workflow

Handoffs

Interoperability

Lack of information

that supports the

process of care

2014 HIMSS Physician EHR

Pain Point Survey

2016 HIMSS Nursing UX

Pain Points & Solutions Research

UX Clinical Documentation Issues Nursing UX Pain Points

Source: "Allocation of Physician Time in Ambulatory Practice: A Time and Motion

Study in 4 Specialties”, The Annals of Internal Medicine, published 9/6/2016.

http://annals.org/aim/article/2546704/allocation-physician-time-ambulatory-practice-

time-motion-study-4-specialties; 2014 HIMSS Physician EHR Pain Point Survey;

2016 HIMSS Nursing UX Pain Points & Solutions Research

Exam room clinic time:

4.1 hours (43% of work day)

• 53% spent in direct patient

face time

• 37% spent on EHR + desk

work

Non-exam room clinic time:

3.9 hours (41% of work day)

• 62% spent in EHR

• 38% spent on admin +

other

After-hours time:

1.5 hours (16% of work day)

• “Mostly EHR tasks”

Top 5 Problems

Usability and the Role of IT

Page 12: Physician Burnout and IT Experience Design 10/Shrestha and Mohan... · Physician Burnout and IT Experience Design May 10, 2018 Rasu B. Shrestha, ... Structured documents do ... From

12

Page 13: Physician Burnout and IT Experience Design 10/Shrestha and Mohan... · Physician Burnout and IT Experience Design May 10, 2018 Rasu B. Shrestha, ... Structured documents do ... From

13

Is Physician Burnout Real? 1

UX Approaches and Techniques2

Case Studies3

Discussion:

What Top Actions Can Move Value Forward?4

Road Map

Road Map

Page 14: Physician Burnout and IT Experience Design 10/Shrestha and Mohan... · Physician Burnout and IT Experience Design May 10, 2018 Rasu B. Shrestha, ... Structured documents do ... From

14

“Human Centered Design is a creative approach to problem solving that starts with the people you’re designing for and ends with solutions tailor made to suit their needs.”

- from the IDEO Design Kit

Non-functional Functional Delight?

What’s Human Centered Design?

Page 15: Physician Burnout and IT Experience Design 10/Shrestha and Mohan... · Physician Burnout and IT Experience Design May 10, 2018 Rasu B. Shrestha, ... Structured documents do ... From

15

HCD aims to cut through superfluous details to get to the user’s core needs.

Human Centered Design

Page 16: Physician Burnout and IT Experience Design 10/Shrestha and Mohan... · Physician Burnout and IT Experience Design May 10, 2018 Rasu B. Shrestha, ... Structured documents do ... From

16

• Observing a user in context and asking structured questions to better understand why they’re doing what they’re doing. Contextual Inquiry:

• Enhancing user satisfaction by improving usability, accessibility and efficiency in the interaction between the user and the product.UX Design:

• Evaluating design concepts with representative users. Typically, participants will try to complete tasks while observers collect data and determine the participant's satisfaction with the product.

Usability Testing:

• After testing with users, design is typically refined to align with their feedback.Refine:

Human Centered Design

Page 17: Physician Burnout and IT Experience Design 10/Shrestha and Mohan... · Physician Burnout and IT Experience Design May 10, 2018 Rasu B. Shrestha, ... Structured documents do ... From

17

17

Design Thinking

Page 18: Physician Burnout and IT Experience Design 10/Shrestha and Mohan... · Physician Burnout and IT Experience Design May 10, 2018 Rasu B. Shrestha, ... Structured documents do ... From

Source: Brené Brown on Empathy, available at

https://youtu.be/1Evwgu369Jw accessed December 5, 2016.

Page 19: Physician Burnout and IT Experience Design 10/Shrestha and Mohan... · Physician Burnout and IT Experience Design May 10, 2018 Rasu B. Shrestha, ... Structured documents do ... From

19

Intro

Yourself

Intro

Project

Evoke

Stories

Explore

Emotions

Confirm

Statements

Thank &

Wrap-upBuild

Rapport

Time

Empathy Interviewing

Source: Adapted from Stanford Design School Empathy Interviewing

Technique; “Method: Interview for Empathy”, Stanford Design School, available

at http://dschool.stanford.edu/wp-content/themes/dschool/method-

cards/interview-for-empathy.pdf, accessed December 5, 2016.

Active

Listening

Zone

60%

Interviewing

Time

Page 20: Physician Burnout and IT Experience Design 10/Shrestha and Mohan... · Physician Burnout and IT Experience Design May 10, 2018 Rasu B. Shrestha, ... Structured documents do ... From

20

The end user journey is the complete sum of experiences

that end users go through when interacting with IT. Instead

of looking at just a part of a transaction or experience, the

journey documents the full experience of being a customer.

Journey Mapping

What Does Delivering a Great End User Experience Mean?

Source: Flores, R. (2016, December 3). Telephone interview; “How well do you know your

end users?”, Citrix Synergy 2016 Workshop, May 2016, available at

https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=gSf3_3uM7-M, accessed December 5, 2016.

Page 21: Physician Burnout and IT Experience Design 10/Shrestha and Mohan... · Physician Burnout and IT Experience Design May 10, 2018 Rasu B. Shrestha, ... Structured documents do ... From

21

From Touchpoints to Journeys…

Seeing the World as Customers Do

Source: Flores, R. (2016, December 3). Telephone

interview; “How well do you know your end users?”,

Citrix Synergy 2016 Workshop, May 2016, available

at https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=gSf3_3uM7-

M, accessed December 5, 2016.

Designing Experiences That Matter

Page 22: Physician Burnout and IT Experience Design 10/Shrestha and Mohan... · Physician Burnout and IT Experience Design May 10, 2018 Rasu B. Shrestha, ... Structured documents do ... From

22

Begins entering

patient data

into EMR

Begins entering

patient data

into EMR

Experiences

a power

surge, PCs

go black!

Experiences

a power

surge, PCs

go black!

Hears

respiratory

monitor alarms

Hears

respiratory

monitor alarms

Uses

respiratory bag

to

stabilize

patient

Uses

respiratory bag

to

stabilize

patient

Manually

restarts

computers;

20mins!

Manually

restarts

computers;

20mins!

Logs-in to

EMR system

at nurse’s

station

Logs-in to

EMR system

at nurse’s

station

Spends 30 mins

re-submitting

data

Spends 30 mins

re-submitting

data

Enters

patient room

to pass meds

Enters

patient room

to pass meds

Can’t log-in

to EMR,

locked out!

Can’t log-in

to EMR,

locked out!

Goes back

to nurse’s

station,

logs out

Goes back

to nurse’s

station,

logs out

Goes back

to patient

room,

logs in

Goes back

to patient

room,

logs in

Calls I.T.

support

about login

issues

Calls I.T.

support

about login

issues

Waits on

hold 20

mins

Waits on

hold 20

mins

Hears

respiratory

monitor

alarms

Hears

respiratory

monitor

alarms

Experiences a

power surge,

PCs

go black!

Experiences a

power surge,

PCs

go black!

Begins

entering

patient data

into EMR

Begins

entering

patient data

into EMR

Uses

respiratory bag

to stabilize

patient

Uses

respiratory bag

to stabilize

patient

Manually

restarts

computers;

20mins!

Manually

restarts

computers;

20mins!

Logs-in to

EMR system

at nurse’s

station

Logs-in to

EMR system

at nurse’s

station

Can’t log-in

to EMR,

locked out!

Can’t log-in

to EMR,

locked out!

Spends 30

mins re-

submitting

data

Spends 30

mins re-

submitting

data

Goes back

to nurse’s

station,

logs out

Goes back

to nurse’s

station,

logs out

Goes back

to patient

room,

logs in

Goes back

to patient

room,

logs in

Calls I.T.

support

about login

issues

Calls I.T.

support

about login

issues

Waits on

hold 20 mins

Waits on

hold 20 mins

Enters

patient room

to pass meds

Enters

patient room

to pass meds

Is told login

conflict is

resolved

Is told login

conflict is

resolved

Is told login

conflict is

resolved

Is told login

conflict is

resolved

Digging for Stories

Sharon’s Experience

Page 23: Physician Burnout and IT Experience Design 10/Shrestha and Mohan... · Physician Burnout and IT Experience Design May 10, 2018 Rasu B. Shrestha, ... Structured documents do ... From

23

Source: Flores, R. (2016, December 3). Telephone interview; “How well do you know your

end users?”, Citrix Synergy 2016 Workshop, May 2016, available at

https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=gSf3_3uM7-M, accessed December 5, 2016.

Hears

respiratory

monitor

alarms

Hears

respiratory

monitor

alarms

Experiences a

power surge,

PCs

go black!

Experiences a

power surge,

PCs

go black!

Begins

entering

patient data

into EMR

Begins

entering

patient data

into EMR

Uses respiratory

bag to stabilize

patient

Uses respiratory

bag to stabilize

patient

Manually

restarts

computers;

20mins!

Manually

restarts

computers;

20mins!

Logs-in to

EMR system

at nurse’s

station

Logs-in to

EMR system

at nurse’s

station

Can’t log-in

to EMR,

locked out!

Can’t log-in

to EMR,

locked out!

Spends 30

mins re-

submitting

data

Spends 30

mins re-

submitting

data

Goes back

to nurse’s

station,

logs out

Goes back

to nurse’s

station,

logs out

Goes back

to patient

room,

logs in

Goes back

to patient

room,

logs in

Calls I.T.

support

about login

issues

Calls I.T.

support

about login

issues

Waits on

hold 20 mins

Waits on

hold 20 mins

Enters

patient room

to pass meds

Enters

patient room

to pass meds

Is told login

conflict is

resolved

Is told login

conflict is

resolved

Desktop PCDesktop PC

Other

nurses

Other

nurses

Other

nurses

Other

nurses

PatientsPatientsResp.

therapy

Resp.

therapy

Resp.

monitors

Resp.

monitorsWeahter

lightneing

Weahter

lightneing

Resp.

bag

Resp.

bag

Nurse

station PC

Nurse

station PC

EMR

system

EMR

system

MedsMedsRoom

PC

Room

PC

Nurse

station

PC

Nurse

station

PC

EMR

system

EMR

system

I.T. support

system

I.T. support

system

PhonePhone

Support

system

queue

Support

system

queue

Charge

nurse

Charge

nurse

ON

STA

GE

Report

sheets

Report

sheets

PatientPatient

FamilyFamily

EMR

system

EMR

system

Room

PC

Room

PC

EMR

system

EMR

systemHold

muzak

Hold

muzak

I.T. help

desk

I.T. help

desk

FamiliesFamilies

Other

nurses

Other

nurses

Other

nurses

Other

nursesPatientPatient

FamilyFamily

Nurse

station

PCs

Nurse

station

PCs

Nurse

station PC

Nurse

station PC

Report

sheets

Report

sheets

Other

nurses

Other

nurses

Room

PCs

Room

PCs

Knowing Processes Surrounding End User

What and who did Sharon interact with during her experience?

People, processes, technology Onstage

Journey Mapping

Page 24: Physician Burnout and IT Experience Design 10/Shrestha and Mohan... · Physician Burnout and IT Experience Design May 10, 2018 Rasu B. Shrestha, ... Structured documents do ... From

24

Backstage

Hears

respiratory

monitor

alarms

Hears

respiratory

monitor

alarms

Experiences a

power surge,

PCs

go black!

Experiences a

power surge,

PCs

go black!

Begins

entering

patient data

into EMR

Begins

entering

patient data

into EMR

Uses respiratory

bag to stabilize

patient

Uses respiratory

bag to stabilize

patient

Manually

restarts

computers;

20mins!

Manually

restarts

computers;

20mins!

Logs-in to

EMR system

at nurse’s

station

Logs-in to

EMR system

at nurse’s

station

Can’t log-in

to EMR,

locked out!

Can’t log-in

to EMR,

locked out!

Spends 30

mins re-

submitting

data

Spends 30

mins re-

submitting

data

Goes back

to nurse’s

station,

logs out

Goes back

to nurse’s

station,

logs out

Goes back

to patient

room,

logs in

Goes back

to patient

room,

logs in

Calls I.T.

support

about login

issues

Calls I.T.

support

about login

issues

Waits on

hold 20

mins

Waits on

hold 20

mins

Enters

patient room

to pass meds

Enters

patient room

to pass meds

Is told login

conflict is

resolved

Is told login

conflict is

resolved

EMR sys

admins

EMR sys

admins

Clinical

analyst

Clinical

analyst

I.T.

support

I.T.

support

Cardio

pulmon-

ary Dir.

Cardio

pulmon-

ary Dir.

Resp.

monitor

system

Resp.

monitor

system

Power

mgmt

system

Power

mgmt

system

Meds

policies

Meds

policiesEMR

database

EMR

database

EMR

database

EMR

database

I.T./telco

routing

policy

I.T./telco

routing

policy

VOIP

system

VOIP

system

I.T.

SLAs

I.T.

SLAs

I.T.

Director

I.T.

Director

BA

CK

STA

GE

Pharm-

acists

Pharm-

acists

Security

policies

Security

policies

EMR

database

EMR

database

I.T.

security

I.T.

security

Network &

databases

Network &

databases

GeneratorGenerator

I.T. supportI.T. support

EMR sys

admins

EMR sys

adminsI.T.

security

I.T.

security

EMR

database

EMR

database

Others in

support

queue

Others in

support

queue

I.T.

SLAs

I.T.

SLAs

People, processes, and technologies that Sharon didn’t come into

direct contact with, but that still play a role in her experience.

Source: Flores, R. (2016, December 3). Telephone interview; “How well do you know your

end users?”, Citrix Synergy 2016 Workshop, May 2016, available at

https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=gSf3_3uM7-M, accessed December 5, 2016.

Journey Mapping

Page 25: Physician Burnout and IT Experience Design 10/Shrestha and Mohan... · Physician Burnout and IT Experience Design May 10, 2018 Rasu B. Shrestha, ... Structured documents do ... From

25

From Touchpoints to Journeys…

Seeing the World as Customers Do

Source: Flores, R. (2016, December 3). Telephone

interview; “How well do you know your end users?”,

Citrix Synergy 2016 Workshop, May 2016, available

at https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=gSf3_3uM7-

M, accessed December 5, 2016.

Designing Experiences That Matter

Page 26: Physician Burnout and IT Experience Design 10/Shrestha and Mohan... · Physician Burnout and IT Experience Design May 10, 2018 Rasu B. Shrestha, ... Structured documents do ... From

26

Talk to your end users

Understand the role of empathy

Design customer experiences that matter

Measure how your end users think and feel about your IT services

Igniting the Shift to User Centricity

Page 27: Physician Burnout and IT Experience Design 10/Shrestha and Mohan... · Physician Burnout and IT Experience Design May 10, 2018 Rasu B. Shrestha, ... Structured documents do ... From

27

IT Thinks … The Business Thinks …

Incident Volumes:

“Yay we have dealt with 4000 incidents this month”“Oh, you have failed us 4000 times this month”

First Contact Resolution:

“We have achieved a stellar 70% FCR rate in

December”

“If you can’t help me, please pass me onto

someone who can … I don’t have 45 minutes for

you to try things”

Call Response Time:

“We answer 90% of calls within 20 seconds”

“Why does it take me 3 minutes to get through the

interactive options before I speak to a human?”

(FCR-driven?)

Availability:

“We have 99.97% availability on critical services”

“It’s a shame the 0.03% is when we really need it

to be working”

Staff training:

“100% of our service desk agents are ITIL trained”

“I don’t need to ask them a question on ITIL I need

them to help me. Yes, me the customer”

How is IT Measuring Success?

Source: Mann, S. (2013, Feb 1). “We Do A Great Job In IT, Our Metrics Dashboard Is

A Sea Of Green.” Really?. Retrieved from http://blogs.forrester.com/stephen_mann/13-

02-01-we_do_a_great_job_in_it_our_metrics_dashboard_is_a_sea_of_green_really

Page 28: Physician Burnout and IT Experience Design 10/Shrestha and Mohan... · Physician Burnout and IT Experience Design May 10, 2018 Rasu B. Shrestha, ... Structured documents do ... From

28

Net Promoter Score

3. Measuring Experience

“IT Consistently Provides Me a Premium Experience”

Page 29: Physician Burnout and IT Experience Design 10/Shrestha and Mohan... · Physician Burnout and IT Experience Design May 10, 2018 Rasu B. Shrestha, ... Structured documents do ... From

29

The New Killer Internal Customer Experience Metric?

Source: “Time to Smile: the new killer internal customer

experience metric?”, Klever Blog by Phil Verghis, Feb 2016, available at

https://getklever.com/2016/02/05/time-to-smile-the-new-killer-internal-

customer-experience-metric/, accessed December 5, 2016.

Page 30: Physician Burnout and IT Experience Design 10/Shrestha and Mohan... · Physician Burnout and IT Experience Design May 10, 2018 Rasu B. Shrestha, ... Structured documents do ... From

30

Is Physician Burnout Real? 1

UX Approaches and Techniques2

Case Studies3

Discussion:

What Top Actions Can Move Value Forward?4

Road Map

Page 31: Physician Burnout and IT Experience Design 10/Shrestha and Mohan... · Physician Burnout and IT Experience Design May 10, 2018 Rasu B. Shrestha, ... Structured documents do ... From

31

31

Ease of use may be invisible, but its absence sure isn't.

Ease of use may be invisible, but its absence sure isn't.

©2017 UPMC: PROPRIETARY

Page 32: Physician Burnout and IT Experience Design 10/Shrestha and Mohan... · Physician Burnout and IT Experience Design May 10, 2018 Rasu B. Shrestha, ... Structured documents do ... From

32

DISEASE-BASED JOURNEYS ORGANIZE HEALTH SYSTEM OPERATIONS

BUT HUMAN-BASED EXPERIENCE JOURNEYS REMAIN HIDDEN

Defined.

Standardized.

Measured.

Ambulatory Pre-Op Surgery Transition Recovery

Invisible.

Happenstance.

Unknown.

PAST EXPERIENCE PREPARATIONSELECTION CARE DELIVERY TRANSITION

• New patient or

returning

patient?

• Was past

experiences

positive or

negative?

• Why did the

patient

choose us?

• What is this

patient most

concerned

about?

• Have we

educated the

patient about

their condition

and care?

• Are care

logistics clearly

understood?

• Who and

what

influences

patient

emotions

during care?

• How are

families cared

for?

• What does

the next

caregiver

need to know

about this

experience?

Docent Health

Helping Care Teams Couple “Great Care” with “Great Experience”

Case in Brief: Docent Health

• Headquartered in Boston, MA

• Partners with health systems

with data-driven and human-

guided approach to manage

personalized service

journeys for patients

• “Docents” serve as patient

liaisons, capturing individual

needs, helping patients

navigate clinical experience,

and surfacing contextual

information to care team

• Analytics driven platform

captures patient profiles,

organizes service journeys,

and coordinates workflow

management

Page 33: Physician Burnout and IT Experience Design 10/Shrestha and Mohan... · Physician Burnout and IT Experience Design May 10, 2018 Rasu B. Shrestha, ... Structured documents do ... From

33

Company in Brief: Augmedix

• Founded in 2012 and

headquartered in

San Francisco, CA

• Offers HIPAA-compliant

Google Glass-powered remote

scribe service to improve

physician productivity

• 200+ providers across 6 health

systems and 32 states

• Raised over 60M in funding till

date. Customers and investors

include Dignity Health, Sutter

Health, TriHealth, and

Catholic Health Initiatives.

• Over 425,000 notes created

to-date; average time savings

of 2 hours per clinic day;

98% patient acceptance

Augmedix

On a Mission to Re-Humanize Doctor-Patient Relations

Physician wears

Glass during

patient exams

Glass streams

audio/visual

information to an

offsite scribe in a

HIPAA secure

location

Augmedix-certified

scribe creates notes

in real-time and

presents to physician

immediately after

each visit

Physician

reviews and

approves notes

Page 34: Physician Burnout and IT Experience Design 10/Shrestha and Mohan... · Physician Burnout and IT Experience Design May 10, 2018 Rasu B. Shrestha, ... Structured documents do ... From

34

We all want our doctors to focus on our

needs rather than taking notes on a

computer. What we’ve discovered through

our partnership with Augmedix is that

beyond helping doctors to more quickly and

accurately complete patient charts, the

service is actually making patients feel that

their doctors are more attentive to

their needs.”

Albert Chan, MD

VP of Digital Patient Experience, Sutter Health

Augmedix

10%Boost in provider

productivity

Note completion rate

97%

Reduction in

documentation time

64%

Average increase in

provider satisfaction

with balance between

EHR and patient care

120%

Case Study: TriHealth Orthopedic & Sports Institute - Kenwood

Page 35: Physician Burnout and IT Experience Design 10/Shrestha and Mohan... · Physician Burnout and IT Experience Design May 10, 2018 Rasu B. Shrestha, ... Structured documents do ... From

35

Medicomp Systems

Technology in Brief:

Quippe Clinical Documentation

• Developed by Medicomp Systems

headquartered in Chantilly, VA

• Co-designed with physicians,

web-based modular set of

documentation tools

• EHR and device agnostic

• Can create notes, forms, and

visual documentation that support

billing and compliance criteria and

are recognizable to clinicians

• Fast, familiar, and works the way

clinicians think without forcing

excessive steps

Creating Great UX with Intuitive UI

Case in Brief:

Phoenix Children’s Hospital

• Wanted to increase

documentation efficiency by

making the experience faster,

better and more compliant

• Embedded Quippe into

existing Allscripts SCM EHR

30%Average drop

in documentation

time per encounter

Increase in

productivity (more patients seen)

27%

Page 36: Physician Burnout and IT Experience Design 10/Shrestha and Mohan... · Physician Burnout and IT Experience Design May 10, 2018 Rasu B. Shrestha, ... Structured documents do ... From

36

NewYork–Presbyterian Hospital

Source: Singh, C. (2016, November 21). Telephone interview. NewYork–Presbyterian

Hospital; “Rising to the Digital Business Challenge”, Citrix Blog, June 2016, available

at https://www.citrix.com/blogs/2016/06/29/rising-to-the-digital-business-challenge/,

accessed December 5, 2016.

Employs Empathy

Staff hired for empathy or trained where

required; “active listeners” encouraged to

lead the IT rounds

Drives Top-Down Innovation

Reintroducing technology to business in

a never-seen-before avatar a key IT

innovation imperative

Dedicated, Enigmatic CX Executive

Serves as face of IT and owns UX;

drives weekly IT Rounds and strives to

convert non-IT colleagues into IT

advocates by engaging in their terms

Captures the Wins

Building on success and popularity to do

more: setting up “Tech Stops” and

creating mini commercials for apps

Facilitates Bottom-Up Engagement

Keeping pulse on IT adoption and driving

continual improvements to support

operational goals

Focus on Experience – not Tickets

Staff get Ritz Carlton style training and are

coached to represent all of IT; provide

follow up letters with “shopping cart”

of issues &“fulfillment dates”

Ensuring outstanding IT

experience is my Job #1.

We took bold steps to pivot

from an internal-facing team to

an external facing team. We

started really getting to know

the business and spent time

with our clinicians to

understand how IT can

complement care workflows.

The result has been greater

health care worker productivity

and a new, digitally enabled

model for patient care.”

Christine Ooro Singh,

Director of Customer Experience

Key Program Features

User Experience and Customer Service a Cornerstone of Innovation Efforts

Customer Experience (CX)

Page 37: Physician Burnout and IT Experience Design 10/Shrestha and Mohan... · Physician Burnout and IT Experience Design May 10, 2018 Rasu B. Shrestha, ... Structured documents do ... From

37

Articulates central philosophy in a few meaningful words:

“Building loyalty through premium experiences” an IT imperative

Reinforces commitment continually:

Rounding stories shared at daily huddles and All-Hands meetings

reinforce mission and inculcate higher sense of purpose

Supports central philosophy with core values:

“C-I-CARE” service philosophy applied to internal interactions

Makes core philosophy the focus of orientation:

C-I-CARE and IT Rounding training offered to new hires

Makes it visual:

IT Rounding Cards serve as visual touch points

Provides customer centric training and support:

Staff equipped and encouraged to perform regular rounds

Training and follow up metrics are captured and measured

Stanford Health Care

Key Features of Stanford’s “IT Rounding” Approach

Source: Stanford Health Care, December 2016.

Page 38: Physician Burnout and IT Experience Design 10/Shrestha and Mohan... · Physician Burnout and IT Experience Design May 10, 2018 Rasu B. Shrestha, ... Structured documents do ... From

***Notes visible to customer

***Notes visible to IT only

Stanford’s enhanced incident

management workflow allows

for logging and tracking issues

identified during IT Rounds

Customized approach

facilitates effective internal IT

follow up and external follow

through with customers

Source: Stanford Health Care, December 2016.

Page 39: Physician Burnout and IT Experience Design 10/Shrestha and Mohan... · Physician Burnout and IT Experience Design May 10, 2018 Rasu B. Shrestha, ... Structured documents do ... From

39Medical City Healthcare

(formerly HCA North Texas)

Source: Miller, L. (2016, November 21). Telephone interview; Gregory, C. (2016). “Interprofessional

Collaboration Creates IT Rounding.” Advance for Nurses. July 2016, 23-24. Miller, L., & Gregory, C.

(2016, August). “Patients are at the Heart of IT&S and Nursing” Medical City Healthcare. Poster

session presented at the Studer What’s Right in Health Care Conference, Chicago, IL.

Case in Brief: “Partner Rounds” Program

• Program launched in response to survey results that surfaced IT

related frustrations and pain points from nurses

• IT and nursing leadership deployed proactive rounding in the spirit of

hourly rounding and Studer Group leader rounds

• A partner round is an operational blitz where IT and nursing staff all

round on a unit together for proactive problem solving

We (as in nursing) have struggled with IT in the

past, and for the first time I can see and feel

the difference it makes partnering with IT.

When people can understand and relate to one

another in their own environments, it makes all

the difference in the world.”

Cassidi Roberts, Chief Nursing Officer

Medical Center of McKinney

We took some of the Studer Group Nurse

Leaders Rounding principles and we created

Partner Rounding.”

Leah Miller, Chief Information Officer

Our patients are safer, nurses are happier,

efficiency has improved and both disciplines

have a greater understanding of the

importance of their contributions.”

Carol Gregory, Chief Nursing Executive

31,008hrs(Per Year)

Reduced high

priority issues by

82.5% = 2,584 fewer

patient impeding

issues a month

Time Savings

85.1%2016

Physician Satisfaction

76.9%2015

IT Work Order Requests (Per Month)

Employee Engagement

52%fewer requests

1500Before

713After

79%2016

IT Engagement Ratio

% RN Engagement

3.562016

3.062015

78%2015

Page 40: Physician Burnout and IT Experience Design 10/Shrestha and Mohan... · Physician Burnout and IT Experience Design May 10, 2018 Rasu B. Shrestha, ... Structured documents do ... From

40

Is Physician Burnout Real? 1

UX Approaches and Techniques2

Case Studies3

Discussion:

What Top Actions Can Move Value Forward?4

Road Map

Page 41: Physician Burnout and IT Experience Design 10/Shrestha and Mohan... · Physician Burnout and IT Experience Design May 10, 2018 Rasu B. Shrestha, ... Structured documents do ... From

41

Design for regulations Design for empowerment

Burnout Joy

Add Simplify

Bureaucracy Meritocracy

Application centric Patient centric

Interpretation centric Outcomes centric

Doing digital Being digital

Old world vs. New world

Page 42: Physician Burnout and IT Experience Design 10/Shrestha and Mohan... · Physician Burnout and IT Experience Design May 10, 2018 Rasu B. Shrestha, ... Structured documents do ... From

42

Ignite the Shift to User Centricity

Talk to your end users

• Engage patients, consumers & clinicians BEFORE starting a program or writing code

• Always close the loop. Always iterate.

Action Steps

Understand the role of empathy

• Listen & understand (2 ears/ one mouth)

• Always put yourself in their shoes

Action Steps

Design customer experiences that matter

• Use design thinking principles in your next challenge!

• Focus on experiences, not tickets.

Action Steps

Measure how your end users think and feel about your IT services

• Benchmarks are important, but customer centricity more so. Start measuring satisfaction and experience.

• Proactive rounding works. Do it, now.

Action Steps

Support the People, Not the Technology

Page 43: Physician Burnout and IT Experience Design 10/Shrestha and Mohan... · Physician Burnout and IT Experience Design May 10, 2018 Rasu B. Shrestha, ... Structured documents do ... From

43

Contact Information

Rasu B. Shrestha, MD MBA

Chief Innovation Officer, UPMC

Exec VP, UPMC Enterprises

Twitter: @RasuShrestha

LinkedIn.com/in/[email protected]

Santosh Mohan, MMCi FHIMSS

Head, More Disruption Please Labsathenahealth

Twitter: @santoshSmohan

LinkedIn.com/in/[email protected]