Upload
brodchato
View
218
Download
0
Embed Size (px)
Citation preview
8/12/2019 Philippines Final Report December 2013 DRAFT
1/58
"
#$%&'() *+,$('- ./+ 0/121,,1&+3
4(1''+& 5) 6(7 8(9&:13:$ ;9+A+2$,=+&'7 ./+ #/9('+(>+:29(+3 '/9' '/+ H'9'+ 3/922 +&:$%(97 .$
,%(3%+ '/13 91=L '/+ #$&3'1'%'1$& :/9(+Q%9'+:$&3%2'9'1$& =+:/9&13=37
The 2010 election of President Aquino, Jr is a clear shift in the priorities of thePhilippines government. Current President Aquino, Jr campaigned on a reform agenda,
seeking to end corruption and poverty. By linking corruption to poverty, Aquino hasdrawn attention to issues of governance. The Philippine government is directly
addressing government corruption as part of its effort to improve the quality ofgovernance; the direct participation and empowerment of citizens is considered a central
component of the effort toward this improvement. There have been a series ofinstitutional reforms over the past three years, as the Aquino governments continues to
build new institutions that foster the opportunity to alter spending patterns and improvegovernance.
Aquinos reform agenda has built upon an array of previous administrations reform
efforts. Thus, the roots of current reform can be found in several arenas:
First, the World Bank was instrumental in bringing a Community-Driven Developmentprogram to rural areas of the country (Labonne and Chase 2008). Community-Driven
Development programs allow citizens to be directly involved in the allocation process ofspecific projects with World Bank Group funding. These programs incorporate
government officials in the programs.
Second, CSOs in the Philippines began experimenting with ways to monitor corruption inthe production of quality implementation. Road Watch is an excellent example of a CSO
that used participatory auditing mechanisms to counter misappropriation and misuse ofpublic goods. Another example is the Alternative Budget Initiative, led by Social Watch
Philippines, which allows CSOs to provide alternative budget arrangements.
8/12/2019 Philippines Final Report December 2013 DRAFT
2/58
C
Finally, reform-oriented governments elected at subnational levels. Naga City is the bestexample of a local government unit embarking on reform. The case of Naga City
demonstrates how its local government was able to make legal provisions of participationat the local level parallel to national legislation. Particularly, the local government sought
to make participation equally available at the local level since participation is primarily
observed in national legislation. Naga Citys 1995 Empowerment Ordinance has theobjective to empower the people through self-organization, thereby, propellingparticipation in responsibility alongside the local government.
The government led by President Benigno Aquino has produced a range of reforms. First,
the government changed the internal structure of the Presidential administration in orderto improve coordination efforts. The Cabinet Cluster on Good Governance and Anti-
Corruption (CGAC) is directly involved in promoting citizen participation inpolicymaking and auditing mechanisms. Second, the government created a series of
reforms that have dramatically increased the amount of information that citizens can
access. The government has committed to creating a Citizens Budget whereby basicbudget information is made accessible to interested citizens. Third, citizens are nowinduced to participate in the national policymaking process. Fourth, at the national level,
the country is supporting the use of direct participation at the local level.
The reforms in the Philippines appear to be consistently aimed at solving two crucialproblems. First, the participatory institutions are geared toward addressing the problem of
low knowledge and limited engagement among CSOs and citizens. There is a deliberateeffort to empower citizens. Second, there is a specific interest in limiting corruption. The
most innovative reforms address both of these issues. These include the Peoples Budget,Empowerment Fund for Participatory Governance, Bottom-Up Budgeting, Budget
Partnership Agreements, Full Disclosure Policy, Seal of Good Housekeeping, and CitizenParticipatory Audits.
8/12/2019 Philippines Final Report December 2013 DRAFT
3/58
E
!"#$%&' )*@&'($>%:'1$&
./+ (+B$(=3 1&1'19'+> 5) 0(+31>+&' RQ%1&$ (+,(+3+&' 9& +BB$(' '$ :$=59' :21+&'+213=L:$((%,'1$&L 9&> +&>+=1: ,$A+(')7 ./+ :%((+&' O9A+ $B (+B$(= 5%12>3 %,$& '/1('))+9(3 $B :1A12 3$:1+') $( ,9(') ,$21'1:3 1& $(>+( '$ ,($>%:+ 9 ,$21'1:92
:$921'1$& :9,952+ $B 5(1& ,$21'1:92 :/9&+('$ %&>+(3'9&> '/+ :%((+&' (+B$(= +BB$('3L '/13 (+,$(' 5+ 5) '/+ B$(=92 3+,9(9'1$& $B ,$O+(3 5+'O++& '/+ +G+:%'1A+L 2+ O1>+ 29'1'%>+ 1& >+A+2$,=+&' ,29&&1&1&< >+:131$&3L 9&>
9,,$1&'=+&'3 $B P+) ,+$,2+ 1& 3'++(1&< '/+ 5%(+9%:(9:)7 V+A+('/+2+33L '/+3+ 9:'1$&3O+(+ 3%5U+:' '$ $A+(31+,+&>+&' #$&3'1'%'1$&92 5$>1+3L 1&:2%>1&< '/+#$==1331$& $& R%>1' 9&> '/+ #1A12 H+(A1:+ #$==1331$&7
H1&:+ "IWXL B(++ +2+:'1$&3 O+(+ /+2> $& 9 (++(3 B($='/+ 0(+31>+&' '$ 2++(=9('192 29O7 R3 9 ,29'B$(= B$( A$1:+ 9&> 9::$%&'95121')L +2+:'1$&3 2+9A+ =%:/ '$ 5+>+31(+>7 ./+ :$=51&9'1$& $B 9 O+9P ,$21'1:92 ,9(') 3)3'+=L ,$$( +2+:'1$&9>=1&13'(9'1$&L 9&> 1&9>+Q%9'+ A$'+(3Y +>%:9'1$& /9A+ 2+> '$ 9 2$O Q%921') $B
>+=$:(9:) 9&> '(9&329'+> 1&'$ 9 B912%(+ '$ :$&A+(' :9=,913:9,+L (+&' 3++P1&< $,,$('%&1'1+3 95$%&> '/($% 5%31&+33:$&'(9:'3 9&> $'/+( :$&:+331$&37 R23$L '/+ ,$21'1:1M+> (+:(%1'=+&' $B +G+:%'1A+3 B$(5%(+9%:(9'1: ,$31'1$&3L B($= '/+ '$, >$O& '$ =1>>2+ =9&9 $&+ %&952+ '$ ,($A1>+ $(>1&9() :1'1M+&3 O1'/ '/+A$1:+ =+:/9&13=3 '$ +G,(+33 '/+1( >+=9&>3 '/+(+5) '/+ :$&'$%(3 $B +2+:'$(92 ,$21'1:3 B($= "IWX
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
4%(B+2 :$&'+&>3 '/9' :1A12 3$:1+') $( '/9' ^+A+& O/+& 9 &+O 1&3'1'%'1$&92 ,($:+33 '/9' O$%2> 5+&+B1' V?T3Z3%:/ 93 '/+ ,9(')N213' +2+:'1$&3[ 9,,+9(3 $& '/+ /$(1M$&L 1' 13 >13'$('+> 5) 9 #$&$=1&9'+> 5) '(9>1'1$&92 ,$21'1:19&37 6+=$:(9'1M9'1$&L 3'122 1&:$=,2+'+L 13 &$' 9&1((+A+(3152+ ,($:+33_ Z4%(B+2L CDDWL ,7 CCC[7
8/12/2019 Philippines Final Report December 2013 DRAFT
5/58
\
09('1:1,9'1$& &>+( >+=$:(9'1: (+) '1'2+> ^a$:92 ?$A+(&9&:+L 6+:+&'(921M9'1$&L 9&>09('1:1,9'1$& 1& '/+ 0/121,,1&+3_ 93 1&:2%>+> 1& '/+ @&'+(&9'1$&92 @6FR S9&>5$$P
H+(1+3 W7 TB ,9('1:%29( 1=,$('9&:+L '/+ a$:92 ?$A+(&=+&' #$>+ $B "II" B$3'+(+>2$:92 9%'$&$=) 9&> 9 >+:+&'(921M+> 3)3'+=7 ./+ :$&:+,'3 $B >+:+&'(921M9'1$& 9&>,9('1:1,9'1$& N1&N/9&>7 .9,92+3 &$'+3 '/9' ,(1$( '$ 9 >+:+&'(921M+> 3)3'+=L'/+ B$(= $B 3 1& "\C" O93:+&'(921M+> Z+73L 9:+&'(921M+> 3)3'+= (+=91&+>L 9&> '/13 :$&'1&%+> 9B'+( 0/121,,1&+ 1&>+,+&>+&:+7S$O+A+(L '/+ >+A+2$,=+&' $B 9 >+:+&'(921M+> 3)3'+= $B + 1&:2%>+> '/+ :$&:+,'3 $B>+A$2%'1$&L B%&>1&< $B 2$:92 :1'1M+& ,9('1:1,9'1$&7
#1'1M+& ,9('1:1,9'1$& ,$21'1:92 9:'1A1')L 9&> :$&'(15%'+> '$ :1'1M+&
+=,$O+(=+&'7 ^a9O $& 1&1'19'1A+3L (+B+(+&>%=3L ,2+513:1'+L 9&> (+:922 O+(+(+1'+(9'+>_ 9&> ^3+:'$(92 (+,(+3+&'9'1$& 1& 2$:92 :$%&:123 Z:922+> H9&_ Z.9,92+3L CDD"L ,7 \"[7 ./+ a?# $B "II" +=,/931M+> 3%:/ 3+:'$(3 93 '/+)$%'/ 9&> /+9>3 $B '/+ 59(9&+( '$ (+,(+3+&' :1'1M+&3L 2$:92 >+A+2$,=+&':$%&:123 Za6#3[ O+(+ B$(=+> 9' '/+ 2$:92 2+A+2 '$ B$(=%29'+ 9&> 1=,2+=+&' ,($U+:'3=91&2) :$=,(13+> $B =+=5+(3 B($= &$&N3 1&:2%>+ '/+ /+92'/ 9&> 3:/$$2 5$9(>37
.9,92+3 ZCDD"[ =9P+3 9& 1=,$('9&' ,$1&' (+1&< :1'1M+& ,9('1:1,9'1$& 1&7 H/+ 122%3'(9'+3 '/9' >%(1&< '/+'1=+ $B ;9(:$3 ,+$,2+ O+(+ B$(:+> '$ 2+%=37 FA+& 9B'+( '/13 (+ ^./+ "IJK#$&3'1'%'1$& 2+ ,+$,2+Y3 ,9('1:1,9'1$&L O/12+ '/+ "II" #$>+ 3,+22+> $%' '/+=+:/9&1:3 B$( 1'_ Z.9,92+3L CDD"L ,7 \"[7
09(') ,$21'1:3L $( '/+ B+9'%(+3 $B ,(+31>+&'192 ,$21'1:3 9B'+( '/+ '(9&31'1$& '$>+=$:(9:)L /9A+ +A1>+&:+> 3'99'1$& $B >+=$:(9:) Z#($1339&'LCDDW[7 FA+& '/$%+=$:(9'1: 1&3'1'%'1$&3 /9A+ 5++& ,%' 1& ,29:+L 3/$(':$=1& ,$21'1:921&'+ /9A+ 5+:$=+ 1&3'(%=+&'3 $B
,$O+(b '/+ +2+:'1$& ,+(1$>3 9(+ (1,+ O1'/ 1&:1>+&:+3 $B A$'+N5%)1&< 9&>=9&1,%29'1$& 9&> +A+& A1$2+&:+ Z#($1339&'L CDDCL 93 :1'+> 1& #($1339&'L CDDW[7 @&+33+&:+L >+=$:(9:) 9&> ,9(') ,$21'1:3 +G,$3+ A%2&+(95121'1+3 '/9' ^(+=91& 93'($& 9&>
8/12/2019 Philippines Final Report December 2013 DRAFT
6/58
X
@& 9>>1'1$&L *$:9=$(9 Z&7>7[ >(9O3 9''+&'1$& '$ '/+ 3'9'+Y3 O+9P&+33+3 1& '/+3'(%:'%(+3 $B 2$:92 9&> &9'1$&92 ,(+31>+&'192 B$(= $B (+2) %,$& '/+ 2$:92 +21'+ '$ $(7 R3 '/+ ,(+31>+&' 13 '/+ 9G13 $B ,$O+( 9&> 9%'/$(1')L '/+ 133%+ $B,9'($&9B$(= $B (+>'/$%39&> ,$31'1$&3 5) 3$=+ +3'1=9'+37 a$:92 ,$21'1:19&3L9&G1$%3 '$ B1&> ,$31'1$&3 1& '/+ 5%(+9%:(9:) B$( '/+1(B$22$O+(3L /9A+ '$ 2$55) O1'/ '/+ ,(+31>+&' cde R2'/$% :$&'($2 $A+( >135%(3+=+&'%:+3 ,$21'1:92 9:'$(3 O/$ :9& 1=,+>+ 3$:1$N+:$&$=1: (+B$(=37 #$==$&2)P&$O& 93 #$==%&1') 6+A+2$,=+&' 8%&>3L '/+ ,$(P 59((+2 O/1:/ 13 922$:9'+> 5) '/+,(+31>+&' '$ '/+ S$%3+ 9&> H+&9'+ =+=5+(3 922$O3 '/+ ,(+31>+&' '$ +G+(' /13 ,$O+($& 2$:92 ,$21'1:19&37 #($1339&' ZCDDW[ 1=,21+3 '/9' ,9(')N3/1B'1&< $::%(3 1&
,(+31>+&'192 ,$21'1:37 ./13 /9,,+&3 O/+& '/$3+ O/$ $,,$3+> '/+ ,$21'1:92 ,9(') $B'/+ ,(+31>+&'L 9&> '/+ ,(+31>+&' /1=3+2BL O$%2> 3/1B' '/+1( =+=5+(3/1, 1B 391> ,9(')O1&3 '/+ +2+:'1$& 3$ 93 '$ (+,$31'1$& 9&> 5+&+B1' B($= ,$(P 59((+2 922$:9'1$&37R&$'/+( 93,+:' $B '/13 ,9(') U%$1&< O+227
@& '+(=3 $B '/+ ,$O+( $B '/+ 2+)&9=1: 9&> '/+ ($2+ $B ,$21'1:92 ,9('1+3_ 9&>^&+7L ,7 \[7
#$((%,'1$& 9&> .(9&3,9(+&:)
@& $(>+( '$ >13:%33 '/+ /13'$() $B B13:92 ,$21:)=9P1&< 9&> 1'3 133%+3L '/+ 1&B2%+&:+ $B3'(%:'%(92 9>U%3'=+&'3 9&> B1&9&:192 (+B$(=3 $& '/+ ^1&'+(9:'1$&_ 5+'O++& =$&+'9()9&> B13:92 ,$21:1+3 $A+( '/+ >+:9>+3 =%3' B1(3' 5+ &$'+> ZS92:$& h 6+ a+$&L CDDW[7 @&'/13 B(9=+L '/+ ,(+A92+&:+ $B :$((%,'1$& 9&> ,9'($&9 1& ]2+:/1&
8/12/2019 Philippines Final Report December 2013 DRAFT
7/58
K
;$&'+3 Z"II"[ >13:%33+3 '/+ B13:92 ,$21:) 1& '/+ 0/121,,1&+3 1& 9 ,$21'1:92 +:$&$=1::$&'+G' 9&> +A92%9'+3 B13:92 (+B$(= >%(1&< 9&> 9B'+( '/+ ;9(:$3 (++:131$&N=9P1&< ,($:+337 ./+/13'$() $B B13:92 ,$21:)=9P1&< =9) 5+ '(9:+> '$ '/+ R=+(1:9& $::%,9'1$& $B '/+
:$%&'() '/($% '/+ 2+1'%(+[L +G+:%'1A+L 9&> U%>1:192 5(9&:/+3 $B +> 5) '/+ ,(+31>+&' /+2> (+3,$&315121') B$( '/+ B13:92 93,+:'L 3,+:1B1:922) '/+5%> 1'3 +:$&$=) 9BB+:'+> '/+ B1&9&:1&< $B '/+3+ ,($U+:'3-
^R2=$3' 922 $B '/+3+ ,($U+:'3 (+Q%1(+> :$%&'+(,9(' B%&>1& >$=+3'1:B%&>1&< '$ :$=,2+'+ '/+3+ ,($U+:'3L O/1:/ O+(+ 5) &9'%(+=%2'1N)+9(L 3$ '/9' '/+1( (+Q%1(+=+&'3 3,122+> $A+( 1&'$3%53+Q%+&' 5%> 5) '/+ &++> '$ (+3,$&> '$ B$(+1+B1:1'L '/%3
8/12/2019 Philippines Final Report December 2013 DRAFT
8/58
J
:(+9'1&< ,(+33%(+ '$ @&:(+93+ (+A+&%+ +G,$(' 1&:+&'1A+3 9:'3L O/1:/ ,($A1>+>
1&:+&'1A+3 '$ ,1$&++(1&< 9&> +G,$('N$(1+&'+> +&'+(,(13+3L O93 '/+ =$3' 31 B13:92 :/9& '/+ ,(1A9'+ B1+2>3 Z;$&'+3L "II"[7
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c61$P&$ "II\L 93 :1'+> 1& 61$P&$L CD"De7@& "IIKL 9 (+B$(= '$ '/+ '9G 3)3'+= O93 ,($,$3+>7 ./+ #$=,(+/+&31A+ .9G *+B$(=
8/12/2019 Philippines Final Report December 2013 DRAFT
9/58
I
0($ 9>>(+33 '/+ '9G 3)3'+=Y3 '9G (9'+3 9&> '9G 9A$1>9&:+ O/12+3'(+9=21&1&< '/+ '9G 3)3'+=Y3 ,($:+>%(+3 9&> '9G 1&:+&'1A+3 Z61$P&$L CD"D[7
R23$L 9B'+( '/+ "IIK R319& 81&9&:192 #(1313L '/+ '9G (+A+&%+3 >1> &$' 1&:(+93+92'/$% 3'952+ 9' 9($%&> "I7Wk
$B ?60 B($= "IIKl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b 1=,($A+=+&'3 1& '9G9>=1&13'(9'1$&L (9'1$&921M9'1$& $B '/+ 5%(+9%:(9:)b 9&> 1=,($A+=+&'3 1& ,%521: >+5'9&> +G,+&>1'%(+ =9&9+:(+93+ '/+ >+5'N'$N?60 (9'1$ '$
\X 9&> 1&'+(+3' ,9)=+&'3 '$ C" ,+(:+&' Z6$(9139=1L CD""L ,7 CI[7
R (+2+A9&' 3%53+' $B B13:92 ,$21:)=9P1&< 13 B13:92 >+:+&'(921M9'1$& O/1:/ :(+9'1&< ,+(3$&921M+> 1&>1'1$&L '/+ @*R 13 9& %&:$&>1'1$&92 52$:P '$ '/+ 9(+9 $B >+A+2$,=+&'7 n9(1$%3 5931: 3+(A1:+ ,($+2) 1=,2+=+&'+> 9' '/+ 2$:92 2+A+27 ./+ &9'1$&92 39B+1&< B13:923%3'91&95121')_ Z6$(9139=1L CD""L ,7 W"[7
@& CD"CL '/+ :$%&'() /9> 9 >+B1:1' $B C7E ,+(:+&' ?60b /$O+A+(L 1' (+=91&33%3'91&952+ >%+ '$ 9 3'($&< +:$&$=)7 ;$(+$A+(L ^9 >+B1:1' $B %, '$ C7K ,+(:+&' $B?60 O$%2> 3'122 5+ 5($9>2) 3%3'91&952+ 9&> U%3'1B1+> 1B 1&:(+=+&'92 +G,+&>1'%(+ 133,+&' $& ,($>%:'1A+ 9:'1A1'1+3L 3%:/ 93 1&B(93'(%:'%(+ 9&> 3$:192 3+(A1:+3L 9&> 1B
(+A+&%+3 923$ 1&:(+93+ :$==+&3%(9'+2)7_ V9'1$&92 >+5' 13 ,($U+:'+> '$ >+:(+93+ 5)CD"\7 R23$L ^c'e$'92 '9G (+A+&%+3 +:9>+3 '/9' :9& 5+ 9''(15%'+>'$ 1=,($A+> '9G 9>=1&13'(9'1$&_ Z4$(2> ]9&PL CD"EL ,7 "I[7
./+ :%((+&' ZCD"E[ B13:92 ,$21:) 31'%9'1$&Y3 $(1+&'9'1$& 1&:2%>+3 (+B$(=3 1&
8/12/2019 Philippines Final Report December 2013 DRAFT
10/58
"D
>+3:(15+3 (+A+&%+ 1&< $& 3$:192 1&B(93'(%:'%(+L 9&> 3$:192 ,($1'1$&92 :93/ '(9&3B+(3 Z##.3[L 9&> 5%>3 '/9' '/+3+ 3/$%2> 5+ 952+ '$ ,($A1>+ ^1[ '1=+2) 9&> :$&313'+&' ,9339 1A[ B%('/+(1=,($A1&< '/+ ,($:%(+=+&' ,($:+33_ ZCD"EL ,7 CK[7 T& '/+ >+=9&> 31>+L 08; >9'99&> 1&B$(=9'1$& 3/$%2> 5+ =9>+ A13152+ '/($%(1A+& >+A+2$,=+&'[ c4$(2> ]9&PL CD"Ee7
H+:'1$& C- #%((+&' =$=+&' $B ,$21:) 9&> ,$21'1:92 :/9& ?$A+(&9&:+ 9&> R&'1N#$((%,'1$& 029&
`&>+( '/13 ,29&L '/+ B$22$O1&< /9A+ 5++& 1>+&'1B1+> 93 :$==1'=+&'3 5) '/+933+33=+&' (+,$('-
p+($ ]93+> ]%> a1:+&31&< H)3'+= H,++>) *+3$2%'1$& $B #$((%,'1$& #93+3 4/13'2+ ]2$O+( 0($'+:'1$& a9O
41'&+33 0($'+:'1$& 0($ 0/121,,1&+ #%3'$=3 H)3'+= Z@0#H[ 0+(9 &< ]9)9&
8/12/2019 Philippines Final Report December 2013 DRAFT
11/58
""
4+ 3/922 B$:%3 $& '/+ B$22$O1& ]%> 9:'1A1'1+37 ./+ 9>=1&13'(9'1$& /93 923$
'%(&+> '$ A9(1$%3 @#. ,29'B$(=3 '$ B%('/+( 1'3 1'%(+ ;9&9 1& '/+ CD"E 0+$,2+Y3 ]%>1%=N'+(=7 @' 3/$%2> 923$ 922$:9'+ O1'/1& ,(1$(1') 9(+93 9&> 921 O1'/ '/+,29&3 1&:2%>+> 1& '/+ 0/121,,1&+ 6+A+2$,=+&' 029&7 a93'2)L '/+ +( '/+ :$3' $B 1'3 3+(A1:+37 8%('/+(=$(+L 0F; /93 '/(++ ,1229(3- '/+ ;+>1%= l.+(= FG,+&>1'%(+ 8(9=+O$(P Z;.F8[L T0@8L 9&> p+($N]93+> ]%>$O& 922$:9'1$& $B (+3$%(:+37 ./+ T0@8 >1(+:'3 $%':$=++G,+&>1'%(+3 1& :$&U%&:'1$& O1'/ =+93%(1&< 9L >+923 O1'/ '/+ +A92%9'1$& 9&> 933+33=+&' $B ,($+:131$&N=9P1&< (+1&< (+3$%(:+ 922$:9'1$&7 ./+3+,($ 933+33=+&' B$( (+2+A9&:) '$ >+A+2$,=+&'$%':$=+37 *+3$%(:+ 922$:9'1$&3 9(+ >+:(+93+>L 1&:(+93+>L $( >13:$&'1&%+> 593+>%,$& '/+ :$%&'()Y3 >+A+2$,=+&' ,(1$(1'1+37 i+) :%'3 1&:2%>+ ,($++=+>%&&+:+339() $( B$%&> ,($&+ '$ :$((%,'1$&7
./+ #951&+' #2%3'+( $& ?$$> ?$A+(&9&:+ 9&> R&'1N#$((%,'1$& Z??R#[ 029& CD"CNCD"X /93 3+A+(92 3'(9'+ 5) '/+ 9:/1+A+=+&' $B '/+3+ 9
8/12/2019 Philippines Final Report December 2013 DRAFT
12/58
"C
W[ ?(+9'+( ,(+A+&'1$& 9&> :$&'($2 $B :$((%,'1$&7
*+3%2'3 B($= T,+& ]%>+(9'+ B$( 9A+(912) 9A912952+9&> 9::+33152+ '$ '/+ ,%521:7 ./+ T,+& ]%>+G $B 9 :$%&'() O/1:/ (9&P3 9 :$%&'()Y3 (+29'1A+'(9&3,9(+&:) 1& 9A91295121') 9&> 9::+3315121') $B 5%> 321,,+> '$ WJ B($= \\ 1& CD"C7 ./133:$(+ 13 :29331B1+> %&>+( ^3$=+ 1&B$(=9'1$&_ $& '/+ 5%> CD"D7 TA+(922L '/+ 3%(A+) &$'+3'/9' ^$&2) CE :$%&'(1+3 ,($A1>+ 31 (9'/+(
3'952+7 ./+ @]0 ZO/1:/ 3%(A+)+> I\ $%' $B 9 "DD :$%&'(1+3[ (9'+ '/13 3:$(+ 93 /119 Z3:$(+ $B "\[L;929)319 ZEI[L ;)9&=9( Z"D[L ./9129&> ZEX[L .1=$(Na+3'+ ZEX[L 9&> n1+'&9= Z"I[L5%' 29 @&>$&+319 ZXC[7
@29 j?%1>+21&+3 $& 09('&+(3/1, 9&> 09('1:1,9'1$& $B #1A12H$:1+') T(
8/12/2019 Philippines Final Report December 2013 DRAFT
13/58
"E
0($,$3923LY cde B$(=921M+> 1&'$ 9 ]%>$:%=+&'37V$'952)L '/+ (+3%2'3 1&>1:9'+ '/9' '/+ 0(+N]%>%:+>B$( 1&'+(&92 %3+7 F33+&'1922)L '/13 >$:%=+&' 1& '/+ 2+_ 3'9'%37 F33+&'1922)L '/+ ,%(,$3+ $B'/+3+ A1'92 >$:%=+&'3 13 '$ ,(+3+&' '/+ ,%521: O1'/ P&$O2+> 93,+:'3 $B1=,2+=+&'9'1$&7
@29 9 ,+(B+:' 3:$(+ $B 9 "DD B$( 5$'/ )+9(37S$O+A+(L '/+ #1'1M+&Y3 ]%> '$ \CB($= WJ7 ./+ (+,$(' %2'1=9'+2) 9(5($9>+&+> '(9&3,9(+&:)7
8%('/+(=$(+L '/+ T,+& ]%>$:%=+&'37 @& B9:'L '/+:$%&'() $&2) ,%5213/+> /92B $B '/+ +1$:%=+&'3 3% ,%521: ,9('1:1,9'1$& 1& '/+ ,($:+33Z@29+&' '$$P /13 3+9'L /+
8/12/2019 Philippines Final Report December 2013 DRAFT
14/58
"W
O93 B9:+> O1'/ 3+A+(92 133%+3 3'+==1&< B($= :$((%,'1$& 9&> ,$A+(')7 S13 99B$( '/+ 0/121,,1&+3 (9& O1'/ '/+ '/+=+ !"#$ &'('#$ )*++",-. &'('#$ /'01+',$( ^&$:$((%,'1$&L &$ ,$A+(')_7 ./+ 0/121,,1&+ 6+A+2$,=+&' 029& ZCD""NCD"X[ '9(+( +G,9&> '/++:$&$=)7 TA+(9(:/1&< >+A+2$,=+&' +BB$('3 9(+ 923$ B(9=+> O1'/1& '/13 :$&'+G'Z0/121,,1&+ ?$A+(&=+&' R:'1$& 029& B$( CD"C[7
;$3' 31=1&13'(9'1$& /1& %,$& ^1&3'1'%'1$&921M1&< 0+$,2+ 0$O+(1& +( '$ +=,/931M+ :1'1M+& +& ]%>+>L R&&%920($:%(+=+&' 029&[7 ./+ (+,$(' 923$ 1>+&'1B1+3 '/9' '/+ &9'1$&92 +( '/+ 0+(B$(=9&:+ ]93+>@&:+&'1A+ H)3'+= ZT,+& ?$A+(&=+&' R33+33=+&' *+,$('L CD"EL ,7 ""[7
8/12/2019 Philippines Final Report December 2013 DRAFT
15/58
"\
./+ ,($52+= '/9' (+=91&3 13 '/+ 2+A+2L $( O1221&+( '$ 9>>(+33 '/+ ,(1$(1'1M9'1$& $B B13:92 '(9&3,9(+&:)L '/+ $B 1&B$(=9'1$& '/9' +9:/ ,(+3+&'3 9&> :$&31>+( O/9' O122 '(%2) 5+(+2+A9&' '$ '/+1( >13:2$3%(+7
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
E7 0%521: R::+33 '$ @&B$(=9'1$& @&1'19'1A+@=,2+=+&'+> 5) '/+ 0(+31>+&'192 #$==%&1:9'1$&3 6+A+2$,=+&' 9&> H'(9'+ '$ /9(&+33 '/13 1&1'19'1A+9&> 1&3%(+ '$,(+33%(+ B$( B%('/+( >13:2$3%(+ $B 1&B$(=9'1$& '$ '/+ ,%521: 9&> %3+B%2 '$$23 Z3%:/ 931&B$(=9'1$& '+:/&$2$ 1=,2+=+&'9'1$&7
./+ &9'1$&92 '$ >13:2$3+1&B$(=9'1$& Z+7 +.R@a3 /9A+ 5++& ,%' 1& ,29:+7 ./+) /9A+ (+:$==+&>+> '/9' '/+ 8(++>$= $B@&B$(=9'1$& R:' (+Q%1(+ 3%,,$(' B($= '/+ +G+:%'1A+ 9&> '/9' $'/+( A1'92 1&B$(=9'1$&B($= 922 5(9&:/+3 $B +> 1& '/+ >13:2$3%(+7
W7 0/121,,1&+ 09('&+(3/1, B$( T,+& ?$A+(&9&:+
8/12/2019 Philippines Final Report December 2013 DRAFT
16/58
"X
`&>+( '/13 +&9:'=+&'L '/+ 0/121,,1&+ T?0 O122 =$&1'$( '/+ 3'9'%3 $B 09('1:1,9'$() ]%> 5) '/+ 6+,9('=+&' $B @&'+(1$( 9&> a$:92 ?$A+(&=+&'L 8%2B122+>
./13 ,9('1:%29( :$==1'=+&' /93 B$:%3+> $& #HT ,9('1:1,9'1$& 1& '/+ 5%> 5) '/+ 6];L 1' 3++P3 '$ +&+> 1& '/+1&1'19'1A+37 *+:+&' 1&B$(=9'1$& 3/$O3 '/9' '/+ ,($7
X7 ]$''$=N`, 09('1:1,9'$() 029&&1&< 9&> ]%> 6+A+2$,=+&'L 6+,9('=+&' $B ]%>
09('&+(3/1, O1'/ A9(1$%3 3'9P+/$2>+(3 13 3++& 9' '/13 2+A+2 Z&9'1$&92 %:'1$& 9&> O122 B$(=%29'+ 9:'1$& ,29&3 '$ 9>>(+33 ,$A+(')7 R3 3%:/L 1' 13
,(+>1:'+> '/9' '/+3+ ,29&3 O122 5+ ,(1$(1'1M+> 5) &9'1$&92 5%>%:'1$& ,29&376(9O1&< B($= (+:+&' >9'9L ,9('1:1,9'$() 5%> =%&1:1,921'1+37 ./+ CD"E V9'1$&92 ]%> =%&1:1,921'1+3 9(+ B$(+:93'+> '$,9('1:1,9'+ 1& 5$''$=N%, ,9('1:1,9'$() ,29&&1&< 9&> 5%> 5) '/+ 6+,9('=+&' $B @&'+(1$( 9&> a$:92 ?$A+(&=+&'L @& 0($+21A+() 93 O+22 93 :9,9:1'9'1&< '/+ =9(7
./+ #HT3 9(+ '93P+> '$ %&>+('9P+ '/+3+ $5U+:'1A+37
J7 09('1:1,9'$() H$:192 R%>1' B$( 0%521: @&B(93'(%:'%(+ 0($U+:'3
8/12/2019 Philippines Final Report December 2013 DRAFT
17/58
"K
@=,2+=+&'+> 5) '/+ #$==1331$& $& R%>1'L 09('1922) 8%2B122+>
./13 ,9('1:1,9'$() 9%>1' B$:%3+3 $& ,($U+:'3 (+29'1&< '$ 1&B(93'(%:'%(+ 9&>91'37 ##R?? /93 ,(+A1$%32) 1>+&'1B1+> :$((%,'1$& 9&> =13%3+ $B B%&>1&< 1& ($9>
,($U+:'37 ./%3L '/13 1&1'19'1A+ 3++P3 '$ B$3'+( /$&+3' %3+ $B ,%521: (+3$%(:+37 ./13 O9329%&:/+> 1& V$A+=5+( $B CD"C 9&> /93 5++& %&>+( ,12$' 1=,2+=+&'9'1$& 5) '/+604S7
I7 S9(=$&1M+ ?$A+(&=+&' ;+93%(+=+&' H)3'+=3@=,2+=+&'+> 5) '/+ 6+,9('=+&' $B ]%>
./13 1&1'19'1A+ 13 (+3%2'N593+> 9&> $,+(9'+3 '/($%+,9('=+&' 9&> 90+(B$(=9&:+ ;9&9 $& '/+ T() /93 9 B(9=+O$(PL 9&> '/+
0+(B$(=9&:+ ]93+> @&:+&'1A+ H)3'+= 13 %&>+(7 R31>+B($= '/+3+ 1&:+&'1A+ 3)3'+=3L :+('1B1:9'1$& :(1'+(19 /9A+ 923$ 5++& B$(=%29'+> B$( :(1'+(19 9(+ 3'122 1& &++> $B A921>9'1$&L9&> '/13 ,9('1:%29( 9(+9 /93 &$' 1>+&'1B1+> #HT ,9('1:1,9'1$& 1& '/9' A921>9'1$&,($:+337
"D7 @=,($A+ #1'1M+&Y3 #/9('+(@=,2+=+&'+> 5) '/+ #1A12 H+(A1:+ #$==1331$&L 09('1922) 8%2B122+>
./13 3++P3 '$ +&/9&:+ :$=,219&:+ '$ :1'1M+&Y3 :/9('+(37 ./13 ,9('1:%29( 1&1'19'1A+ 13
>$&+ '/($% .9,+ R:' ZR*.R[ 49':/ O/1:/ :$&>%:'3 :/+:PN%,3 $&V?R37 ./+ 9%:'3 3+=1&9(3 $& 9&'1N(+> '9,+ 9&> 3+(A1:+ >+21A+()7 ./131&1'19'1A+ 3++P3 '$ ,(+A+&' B133%(+3 9&> +A92%9'+ '/+ 3+(A1:+3 $B '/+3+ 9 9 #1'1M+&g3 H9'13B9:'1$& #+&'+( H+92 $BFG:+22+&:+L 9&> '/$3+ O/$ B912 '$ :$=,2) =%3' %&>+(+21A+( +G:+22+&:+,($ @&'+(&92 #$&'($23@=,2+=+&'+> 5) '/+ 6+,9('=+&' $B ]%>
./13 :$==1'=+&' 3$% '$ /$O 9+A+2$,+>L 1=,2+=+&'+>L 9&>
=$&1'$(+> '/+1( 1&'+(&92 9%>1'3 9&> :$&'($237 ./13 1&1'19'1A+ 923$ :$&'(15%'+> '$ '/+9 ,($%:'+> 1& A9(1$%3 9 O122 5+ +&/9&:+> B%('/+(7
"C7 F=5+> R::$%&'95121') 1& a$:92 ?$A+(&9&:+
8/12/2019 Philippines Final Report December 2013 DRAFT
18/58
8/12/2019 Philippines Final Report December 2013 DRAFT
19/58
"I
@& '(9:1&< '/+ >+A+2$,=+&' $B :1A12 3$:1+') ,9('1:1,9'1$& 1& '/+ 0/121,,1&+3L 8u23:/+(ZCDDK[L :1'1&< ](1229&'+3 ZCDD\[L 9( 1'3 1&95121') '$ >+21A+( 2$:92 3+(A1:+3 ,(1$( '$ "IJX7 RB'+( ;9(:$3L '/+,(+3+&:+ $B :1A12 3$:1+') 1& + 9 ,(1$(1')L ,9('1:%29(2) '/($% 9' A9(1$%3 2+A+23 $B >+:131$&N=9P1&< 1& 3$:192 9&> ,$21'1:92 (+92=37
@& 9>>1'1$&L '/+ a$:92 ?$A+(&=+&' #$>+ $B "II" 922$O3 V?T3 3+9'3 1& '/+ a$:926+A+2$,=+&' #$%&:123L :$==1''++3L 9&> 2$:92 /+92'/ 9&> 3:/$$2 5$9(>37 T&+,9('1:%29( :93+ $B ,9('1:1,9'1$& /93 5++& >$:%=+&'+> 1& V9 /9A+ 923$ :(+9'+> 9 ,9('&+(3/1, Z+7 :9& :1'1M+& ,9('1:1,9'1$&L 8u23:/+( ZCDDK[ $%'21&+3 :1'1M+&
+& =$&1'$(1&< ,($:+33+37 ]+B$(+ 1>+&'1B)1&< :93+3 %&>+( '/+3+ '),+3 $B,9('1:1,9'1$&L '/+ 9%'/$( B1(3' >+B1&+3 '/+3+ ,9('1:1,9'$() 1&1'19'1A+37 6%(1&< '/+5%>(1A+ '$ 9>A9&:+ 9::$%&'95121')7 ./+1((+3,$&315121'1+3 :9'+( '$O9(>3 1&B2%+&:1&< '/+ 3'9'+ 1& +A+2$,=+&' $5U+:'1A+3 9&> '/+ 922$:9'1$& $B (+3$%(:+37 @'=%3' 5+ &$'+> '/9' '/13 >+,+&>3 $& '/+ +&9521&< +&A1($&=+&' 9A912952+ 1& >+:131$&N
=9P1&L :1'1M+&3 1& '/+ >+:131$&N=9P1&< ,($:+33+3L ,9('1:%29(2) 1& '/+5%>1=,2+=+&' ,($U+:'3 Z;:?++L +'7 927L CDDEL 93 :1'+> 1& 8u23:/+(L CDDK[7 ./+ 0/121,,1&+3$BB+(3 9& +G+=,29() :93+ $B 9& 1&1'19'1A+ '/9' B$:%3+> $& 1=,($A1&< '(9&3,9(+&:)9&> 9::$%&'95121')7 ./13 13 ,9('1:%29(2) '(%+ $B :1A12 3$:1+') +&+:131$&N=9P1&< 1& '/+ 5%>+( '$ 9::%(9'+2) B$(=%29'+ B13:92
,(1$(1'1+3 9&> 933+33 A92%952+ 3+(A1:+37 @& 9>>1'1$&L ,+$,2+ &++> '$ %&>+(3'9&> '/+5%> #1'1M+&3 $B R5(9 B$( ?$$> ?$A+(&9&:+ Z##R??[ 13 9(+2+A9&' 1&1'19'1A+ B$:%31&< $& ,9('1:1,9'1$&L '(9&3,9(+&:)L 9&> 9::$%&'95121')7 @&"IJXL '/+ ##R?? O93 :(+9'+> 9&> B$:%3+> $& >+A+2$,=+&'N$(1+&'+> ,($
8/12/2019 Philippines Final Report December 2013 DRAFT
20/58
CD
1&>1A1>%923 O/$ :(+9'+> '/+ ##R?? O+(+ =$(+ B9=1219(1M+> O1'/ '/13 21&+ $B O$(P'/($%+(3'9&>1& CK ,($U+:'3 '/9' /9> 5++& >+:29(+> 5) '/+;1&13'() $B 0%521: 4$(P3 9&> S1
&$' 9:'%922) 5++& 9::$=,213/+> Z8u23:/+(L CDDKb *9=P%=9(L CDDJ[7
./+ (+3,$&3+ $B '/+ ##R?? O93 '$ (+&>+( ,($$B (+1&< '/+ 1&:$=,2+'1$& $B '/+3+,($U+:'3 1& $(>+( '$ $A+('%(& '/+ ,%521: 9&&$%&:+=+&' (+2+93+> 5) '/+ ;1&13'()7 @&,%(3%1' $B '/13 +&>L '/+ =+=5+(3 $B '/+ ##R?? :$22+:'+> ,/$'$+&:+ 9&>>$:%=+&'+> 9::$%&'3 $B :1'1M+&3 1& '/+ >1BB+(+&' ,($U+:' 9(+937 ./+ &9'1$&92 3+A+(92$BB1:1923 9::$%&'952+7 ./+ :93+ B%('/+( >+=$&3'(9'+> '/+ &++> B$( ,($,+( (+:$%(3+:$&:+(&1&< $BB1:192 :$((%,'1$&7 @& $'/+( O$(>3L '/+ ,+$,2+ 1& '/+ :$==%&1') 3+1M+>
'/+ $,,$('%&1') '$ A$1:+ '/+1( $,1&1$&3 (+1&< '/+ =9''+(L 9&> '/+ (+3%2' O93:$((%,' $BB1:1923 9,,($,(19'+2) (+,(1=9&>+> B$( '/+1( 9:'1$&37
.$ +=,/931M+L 1& $(>+( '$ 1>+&'1B) ,($U+:'3 O1'/ 1&:1>+&:+3 $B :$((%,'1$&L '/+ ##R??'%(&+> '$ A$2%&'9() $(>1&9() :1'1M+&3L 3%:/ 93 /$%3+O1A+3 9&> 3'%>+&'3L 1& :2$3+,($G1=1') '$ &+1& (1 9((9&13:$A+(+> '/9' $&+ $B '/+ ,($U+:'3Y B%&>1&< /9> 5++& +=5+MM2+> 5) '/+ :$&'(9:'$(3Z8u23:/+(L CDDK[7
##R?? 13 9 (+,(+3+&'9'1A+ :93+ 5+:9%3+ 1' B+9'%(+3 9 ,9('&+(3/1, O1'/ '/+ 0/121,,1&+3%,(+=+ 9%>1' 1&3'1'%'1$& $& >+A+2$,=+&' ,29&3 1& R5(9 Z*9=P%=9( 9&> i(9B:/1PLCDD\L 93 :1'+> 1& 8u23:/+(L CDDK[7 @& '/+ ##R?? :93+L '/+(+ O93 '/+ 3%,,$(' B$(+&/9&:+> A+('1:92 9::$%&'95121')L O/1:/ (+331&< '/13 :/93=L '$$23 '/9'+&952+ :1'1M+& ,9('1:1,9'1$& =9) O$(P B9A$(952) 1& +&A1($&=+&'3 O/+(+ B9:'$(3 21P+,9'($&9 :$((%,'1$& 9(+ =1&1=92L 5%' 3'122 :9,952+ $B 9:'1A9'1$& '/($% 1& 8u23:/+(L CDDK[7
#1'1M+& ,9('1:1,9'1$& &$' $&2) 1=,($A+3 '(9&3,9(+&:) 9&> B$3'+(3 9::$%&'95121')L 5%'=9) 923$ $,+& A+&%+3 ,(1=+> B$( :1'1M+& 9:'1$& 9&> 1&Q%1() 1& '/+ ,%521: 3,9:+7 @'/93 923$ 5++& +=,/931M+> 1& '/+ :93+ 3'%>1+3 1>+&'1B1+> 5) 8u23:/+('/9' 1&1'19'1A+31& ,9('1:1,9'$() 5%> (+3%2' 1& 1&:(+931&
8/12/2019 Philippines Final Report December 2013 DRAFT
21/58
8/12/2019 Philippines Final Report December 2013 DRAFT
22/58
CC
:1'1M+&()L 9&> +=,$O+( +9:/ 8121,1&$ '$ ,9('1:1,9'+ 1& +:$&$=1: 9:'1A1')_ Z0+$,2+3]%> ,(+A1$%32)L '/13 1&A$2A+33$:192 9::$%&'95121') '$ 5(1&< '$ 9>>(+33 ,+$,2+Y3 &++>37 R3 5(1+B2) >+3:(15+> 95$A+L
9::$%&'95121') 1&:2%>+3 '/+ ,+(B$(=9&:+N593+> 5%>=9&9 '/+ ,+(B$(=9&:+N593+> 1&:+&'1A+ 3)3'+=7
@& 3++P1&< +( ,9('1:1,9'1$& 1& '/+ 5%>7 ./131&A$2A+3 :$&>%:'1&< :$&3%2'9'1$&3 O1'/ :$==%&1') $(+'+(=1&+ &++>+> 3+(A1:+37 ./+ CD"E 0+$,2+Y3 ]%>+> "C >+,9('=+&'39&> 31G R%'/$(1')L a1 1&
$(>+( '$ B9:121'9'+ '/+ =91&'+&9&:+ 9&> >+21A+() $B 3$:192 3+(A1:+3 Z+71&< 9&>=91&'91&1&< 3:/$$2 B9:121'1+3L /%=9& 1&B(93'(%:'%(+ ,($U+:'3[7
R31>+ B($= '/+ 5%> 9>>1'1$&92 :/9&&+23 B$(,9('1:1,9'1$&7 ./+ 6]; (+,$(' =+&'1$&+> '/+ ,($1&< '/+1( :/12>(+& '$ 3:/$$2L 9''+&>1&< J\ ,+(:+&' $B '/+1(:2933+3L 9&> 1&A+3'1&< 1& '/+1( /+92'/7 #HT3L V?T3L 0T3L 9&> $'/+( %:' 3$:192 9%>1'b '$ +&3%(+ '/9' 5+&+B1:19(1+3 B%2B122 '/+:$&>1'1$&3 9&> '$ =$&1'$( ,($L 5%' '/+O+531'+ 9&> 3)3'+= 29:P3 3%3'91&95121')7
8$( :1'1M+&3 '$ ,9('1:1,9'+ 1& '/+ 5%>+ 9A912952+ >%(1&< 5%> >+A+2$,=+&' B$( 1&:2%31$& 1& 922 '/+,/93+3 $B '/+ 5%>+( '$ =9P+ '/13 ,$33152+ Z0+$,2+3 ]%>1'
./+ ]0R3 9(+ 9 '$ '/++G+:%'1$& ,/93+7 R3 &$'+> ,(+A1$%32)L '/+ ]`] /9> 9 ,12$' (%& 1& 3+A+(92=%&1:1,921'1+3 '/($%+> '$ '/+ +G+:%'1$&
8/12/2019 Philippines Final Report December 2013 DRAFT
23/58
CE
,/93+ '$ $A+(3++ ,($U+:' 1=,2+=+&'9'1$&7 ./+ ,%(,$3+ $B '/+ ]`] 13 '$ 3+(A+ 93 9+ B$( ,$A+(') (+>%:'1$& ,($U+:'37 ]$''$=N`, ]%>+(9'1$& 13 >+21A+(1&< 5931: 3$:192 3+(A1:+3 '$'/+ ,$$(7 @& 9>>1'1$&L '/+ 5%>#HT37 TA+(922L '/+) :$=,$3+ '/+ a$:92 0$A+(') *+>%:'1$& R:'1$& .+9=L $( a0*R.7
@&:2%>+> 1& '/+ '+9= 9(+ '/+ a$:92 #/1+B FG+:%'1A+ 9&> V9'1$&92 ?$A+(&=+&'R 1& 6];N6@a?N6H46NVR0# r$1&';+=$(9&>%= #1(:%29( V$7 CL H+(1+3 $B CD"C7
./+ #1'1M+& 09('1:1,9'$() R%>1' 5) '/+ #TR 9&> '/+ 604S 9&> '/+ RBB1219'+>V+'O$(P B$( H$:192 R::$%&'95121') l F93' R319 9&> '/+ 09:1B1: ZRVHR l FR0[ O122
1&A$2A+ :1'1M+&3 1& 9%>1'1&< (9B' ,(+,9(+> 5) r%9& ;9)$ *9 B$%&> $&2) WW $%' $B KW $B '/+ 8?6Y3 ,9('1:1,9&'3 O+(+ 1&A$2A+> 1&'/+ ,($:+337 ./+) O+(+L /$O+A+(L 1&A$2A+> 1& '/+ a0*R. 93 =+=5+(3 $( 93,9('1:1,9&'3 1& 1'3 ,29&&1&< 9:'1A1'1+3 Z*91> &$'9&92)M+ $( (+9> 9&) $B '/+ >$:%=+&'3 (+2+93+> 5) '/+ a?`L 9&> $&2) "\ O+(+1&:$(,$(9'+> 1&'$ 9:'1A1'1+3 21P+ 1=,2+=+&'9'1$&L =$&1'$(1& '$ '/+ ]%(+9% $B a$:92 ?$A+(&=+&' 6+A+2$,=+&'Z]a?6[ 5) '/+ 6@a? TBB1:+ $B @&'+(&92 R%>1' H+(A1:+3 ZT@RH[L #HT3 O+(+ &$' ,(+3+&'1& (+A1+O 9&> =$&1'$( ,($U+:' 9:'1A1'1+3 9&> >1> &$' $53+(A+ 0#8 +21&+3L 5%'3/$O+> 5+''+( +&1&< 1&A$2A+=+&' 1& aH]37./+ a6# O93 (+,$('+> '$ /9A+ '/+ /1'/+ ,+9:+ 9&> $(>+( :$&>1'1$& 93 9 (+93$& Z*9
8/12/2019 Philippines Final Report December 2013 DRAFT
24/58
CW
B%&>1&< 5) '/+ &9'1$&92 >1'1$&L '/+) 923$ :922 B$( ,9('&+(3/1,3 5+'O++& V$&N?$A+(&=+&'92T( '$ >+A+2$, 2$:92 +&'+(,(13+3 >+31'$ 1=,($A+ ,($>%:'1A1') 9&> 1&:$=+L >1A+(31B) 9 V$&N+( '$ 122%3'(9'+ /$O :1'1M+&3 ,9('1:1,9'+L '/+ B$22$O1&< 9(+&93 O122 5+ 5(1+B2)$%'21&+>7
8/12/2019 Philippines Final Report December 2013 DRAFT
25/58
C\
,"-.$/
@& '/+ /+92'/ 3+:'$(L :1'1M+&3 :9& ,9('1:1,9'+ 1& a$:92 S+92'/ ]$9(>3 ZaS]3[7 ./+ aS]/93 '/+ B%&:'1$& ^'$ ,($,$3+d '/+ 9&&%92 5%> =91&'+&9&:+ $B /+92'/ B9:121'1+3 9&> 3+(A1:+3 O1'/1& '/+ =%&1:1,921')L :1') $(,($A1&:+L 93 '/+ :93+ =9) 5+7 @' 3/$%2> 923$ 3+(A+ 93 9& 9>A13$() :$==1''++ '$'/+ 2$:92 39& O/+(+ '/+ ,+$,2+ O+(+ :$&3%2'+>L 9&>=$(+ 9:'1$& B$( /+92'/ O93 %&>+('9P+&7 ./+ :$==%&1') 923$ +G/151'+> /1
8/12/2019 Philippines Final Report December 2013 DRAFT
26/58
CX
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
./+ 604S 9&> '/+ A$2%&'++(3 923$ :$$,+(9'+> O+22 O1'/ +9:/ $'/+( 9&> :1'+> '/+
1=,$('9&:+ $B :$2295$(9'1$&7 ./+ ]9&'9) a9&39&49':/ B9:121'9'+3 :$2295$(9'1A+ +BB$('3 5+'O++& $(>1&9() :1'1M+&3 9&> :$==%&1'1+3 1&'/+ ,($=$'1$& $B '(9&3,9(+&:) 9&> 9::$%&'95121') Z9&39N+9,L CD"D[7
a+ 1&3'1'%'1$&92 9:'$(3L '/+ ,$21'1:92 '+((91&L 9&> 0/121,,1&+>+:+&'(921M9'1$& =%3' 5+ +G,2$(+> B%('/+( ZR5+22+(9L CD""[7
./+ +G'+&' $B ,%521: ,9('1:1,9'1$& 1& 2+7 R' '/+ 2$:922+A+2L '/13 13 9 (+3,$&315121') $B '/+ a?`3 1& :(+9'1&< '/+1( $O& 3$%(:+3 $B (+A+&%+37./$%9'$() 1& '/+ 2+%:' $B 3+(1+3 $B :$&3%2'9'1$&3 9&> ,%521: /+9(1&+> 1& '/+ a$:92?$A+(&=+&' #$>+_ Z;9-
^./+ +G'+&' $B ,+$,2+ ,9('1:1,9'1$& 1& '/+ +&9:'=+&' $B(+A+&%+ :$>+3L /$O+A+(L :9&&$' 5+ Q%9&'1w+>7 ./+(+ 13 &$
,%5213/+> >9'9 93 '$ /$O =9&) ,+$,2+ 9''+&> :$&3%2'9'1$&39&> ,%521: /+9(1& =$(+ 1=,$('9&'2)L '/+9=$%&' $B (+A+&%+3 (913+> 93 '/+3+ &9'1$&92 9&> 2$:92(+A+&%+ :$>+3 9(+ 1=,2+=+&'+>7 61(+:' ,+$,2+ ,9('1:1,9'1$&1& (+A+&%+
8/12/2019 Philippines Final Report December 2013 DRAFT
27/58
CK
./+(+ 13 &$ 29O O/1:/ (+Q%1(+3 ,%521: ,9('1:1,9'1$& 1& '/13 =9''+(7 ;9 $& '/+ 93,+:'3 $B =$&1'$(1& '/+1( O1221&L CDDJb H1(P+(L CDDXb p1(19L CDDJL 93 :1'+> 1& ;9 '$ :1'1M+& ,9('1:1,9'1$& 9&> '/+1( 95121') '$ 9::+33 1&B$(=9'1$&(+1&< 5%>+( '$ >13:+(& '/+ Q%921') 9&> Q%9&'1')$B ,%521: 3+(A1:+3 Z;9+> 1& '/+ a$:92 ?$A+(&=+&' #$>+ $B "II"L '/+ ,$O+(3 $B '/+ 2++A$2%'1$&L '/+ +G+:%'1A+ /93 '/+:9,9:1') ^'$ 1&'($>%:+ 2+ $'/+( 9>=1&13'(9'1A+ =9''+(3 cde 0$O+(3 $B+G+:%'1A+3 O$%2> 1&:2%>+ x3+&>1&< &$'+3 '$ '/+ 2$:92 :$%&:12L %31&< A+'$ ,$O+(L9,,$1&'1&< 9&> (+=$A1&< 3%5$(>1&9'+3L 9&> ,(+,9(1&< '/+ 5%> 1& R5+22+(9L CD""L ,7 CIJ[7 S$O+A+(L B$( '/+ ,%(,$3+ $B '/13 3+:'1$&L O+O122 >13:%33 5%> ,%521: Z+7%:' $A+(3119 Z93 +G'+(&92 9:'$(3[L :9& 5+'9( /93 923$ ^,($A+& '$ 5+ +BB+:'1A+ 1& >+=9&>1&< 9 ,(+A1$%32)L '/+ 5%>7 @' /93 B$:%3+> $& 3$:192 >+A+2$,=+&'7 @& $(>+('$ ,9('1:1,9'+ 1& '/13 3'9 '$ /+9(1&+ B($= H$:192 49':/ 0/121,,1&+3 O/$ /9A+
3%5=1''+> 92'+(&9'1A+ 5%>>1'1$&L ^1& '+(=3 $B (+3,$&3+L 2+ 1&:2%>+ '/+3+ 1& '/+ 9=+&>=+&'3_ Z](1$&+3L CD""L,7 EE[7
R&$'/+( 93,+:' ,($=$'1&< :1'1M+& ,9('1:1,9'1$&L +3,+:1922) 5) #HT3 $( V?T3L 13:$&'91&+> 1& '/+ a?# $B "II"7 09('1:%29( B$:%3 /93 5++& ,29:+> $& '/+1( :9,95121') B$(
8/12/2019 Philippines Final Report December 2013 DRAFT
28/58
CJ
$A+(31+A+2$,=+&' :$%&:123 '$ >1'1$&L #HT3 :9& ,9('1:1,9'+ 1& ,%521: /+9(1&1&9&:+3 1& O/1:/ 2$:92 ,+$,2+j3 A$1:+ 9(+ (+,(+3+&'+> 1& '/+ ,$21:)N=9P1&+&'1B1+3 '/9'^9:'%92 1&:2%31$& $B :1A12 3$:1+')j3 A$1:+ 1& ,$21:)N=9P1&< /93 )+' '$ 5+ (+921M+> 31&:+3$=+ a?`3 $&2) :/$$3+ #HT3sV?T3 '/9' 9(+ 9221+3 $B +G+:%'1A+3 Z+7 /$O :1'1M+&3 :9& ,9('1:1,9'+ 1& $A+(313 '/+ B%&>3 /935++& :1'+> 93 $&+ :$&'(15%'$( '$ '/137 @& 9>>1'1$&L ^'/+ :1A12 3$:1+') :9& O$(P 1&'9&>+= O1'/ 2$:92 =+>19 1& >+=9&>1&< '/+1( (+,(+3+&'9'1A+3 '$ +=,2$) $A+(31 ,$21:1+3_ ZR5+22+(9L CD""L ,7 EC"[7
@& r%&+ CDDIL '/+ 0($A1&:192 F& '$ /9A+ +& 1& #HT3 >+=9&>1&< 9,,($,(19'+ 9:'1$& '$/$2> '/$3+ 1&A$2A+> 1& '/+ :93+ 9::$%&'952+7 @& +BB+:'L ^'/+ ,(+3+&:+ $B 3+A+(92 =+>19
9:'1A1'1+3 5) '/+ :1A12 3$:1+') /93 +&:$%(9 ,($A1&:192 $BB1:1923 '$ 5+=$(+ :9(+B%2 1& '/+1( >+921& '/+ 2+3_ZR5+22+(9L CD""L ,7 EC"[7
R::$(>1&< '$ ;:?++L +'7 927L ZCDDE[L +,1:' 9 (+1&9&:+ O/1:/ O93 ,933+> 9' '/+2$:92 2+A+2 5) '/+ V9 E $B '/+ T(>1&9&:+L :1'1M+&,9('1:1,9'1$& 9' '/+ 2$:92 2++9 '/9' ^'/+ O122 $B '/+ ,+$,2+ 3/922 92O9)3 (+1+( '$ 9>>(+33 '/+3+ :$&:+(&37 H+:'1$& E
8/12/2019 Philippines Final Report December 2013 DRAFT
29/58
CI
122%3'(9'+3 '/+ ,9('&+(3/1,37 ./13 O$%2> 1&A$2A+ 0T3 9&> V?T3 ^1& '/+ :$&:+,'1$&L1=,2+=+&'9'1$& 9&> +A92%9'1$& $B 922 1' @&3'1'%'1$&3
@& '/+ 0/121,,1&+3L '/+(+ O93 9 &$'952+ :93+ 1& '+(=3 $B 9%>1'1& ,($:%(+=+&'7 @& $(>+( '$ 122%3'(9'+ /$O:1'1M+&3 $( #HT3 :9& 5+:$=+ +& #1'1M+&3 $B R5(9 B$( ?$$> ?$A+(&=+&' Z##R??[ 9&> '/+ :93+ $B0($:%(+=+&' 49':/ @&:7 O122 5+ 5(1+B2) $%'21&+>7 ./13 9::$%&' O122 5+ >(9O& /+9A12)B($= '/+ CDDK `V (+,$(' :$&'(15%'+> 5) R&9=L +'7 927 ZCDDK[ '1'2+> 7"31-1#$ 8*+9*)1'( :0'#$4; 7 9-+'-4$5 8*+ :1-11(1-5?
./+ ##R?? 3/$O3 '/9' V?T3 9&> :1'1M+&3 :9& 5+:$=+ +&1' '/($%+923 =$(+ O1'/ '(9&3,9(+&:) 9&> 9::$%&'95121') 1& '/+,($:%(+=+&' ,($:+337 ]$'/ :93+3 >+,1:'+> B$( ,$33152+ (+,21:9'1$& 1& $'/+(1'1&< 9&> =$&1'$(1&< 9:'1A1'1+37 #1'1M+&,9('1:1,9'1$& O93 +BB+:'1A+2) /9(&+33+> 5) /9A1&< =+=5+(3 $B '/+ :$==%&1') 1&:2$3+ ,($G1=1') $B 9 ($9> ,($U+:' +&+&'3N O+(+ :/9( O1'/ '/+ >%') $B (+,$('1& '/+ (+,$('3L '/+ >+'9123 O+(+
(+N+A92%9'+> 9' '/+ 31'+ $B '/+ ,($U+:'7 ./+ V?T 3+(A+> 93 '/+ =91& 1&A+3'1+( '$ =9P+ O9) B$( 9,9('1:1,9'$() 9%>1' $B '/+ 1'+> +'+(=1&+ O/+'/+( '/+ ,($+31(+> (+3%2'3_ Z*9=P%=9( 9&> i(9B:/1PL CDDKL ,7 WD[7 ./13 O93 3%,,$('+> 5) '/+`V60 9&>L O/+& +&>+>L O93 >++=+> '$ /9A+ (+9:/+> '/+ >+31(+> + 9&> ,%5213/+>7 H'122L $53'9:2+3 >%(1&< '/+ ,($:+33O+(+ 1>+&'1B1+>7 81(3'L '/+ #TR >1> &$' O9&' '$ (+A+92 1&1'192 9%>1' B1&>1& '/13 (+3'(1:'+> 9::+33 '$ 1&B$(=9'1$& 5) ^2$31&1& i(9B:/1PL CDDKL ,7 WD[7 ./+ 3+'N%, 9&>'/+ ,9('1:1,9'$() 9%>1' 1'3+2B :$%2> &$' 5+ =9>+ 3%3'91&952+ 9B'+( '/+ #TR9>=1&13'(9'1$& :/9&7 ./+(+B$(+L ,9('1:1,9'$() 9%>1' 9:'1A1'1+3 O+(+ >+,(1$(1'1M+>O/+& $'/+( #TR ,29&3 O+(+ >++=+> =$(+ %(
8/12/2019 Philippines Final Report December 2013 DRAFT
30/58
ED
41'/1& ,($:%(+=+&'L 0($:%(+=+&' 49':/ @&:7 9&> '/+ #TR :$$,+(9'+> O1'/ +9:/$'/+( 1& %&>+('9P1&< 9& 9%>1' $B '/+ ,($:%(+=+&' ,($:+33 9&> ,9331&< ,($:%(+=+&'(+B$(= 29O7 ./+ #TR O93 =91&2) (+3,$&3152+ B$( ,($A1>1&< 04@ A92%952+,($:%(+=+&' >$:%=+&'3 O/1:/ '/+ $(_ 1& ,($:%(+=+&'L :$&'(15%'+> '$ (+1&B$(:1&< '/+ ,+(B$(=9&:+ $B,($:%(+=+&' 9%>1'37
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
./+) :9& 923$ 59:P $& '/+ ,+(B$(=9&:+ $B 197 #1A12 3$:1+') :9& 9((9&192$+21A+() 133%+3 :9& 5+ 29%&:/+>7 ./+ =+>19L $&
'/+ $'/+( /9&>L :9& >133+=1&9'+ 1' 9>A$:9:1+3 9&> :9& >(+33 '/+=7 #1A12 3$:1+')L 1& '/+1( =$&1'$(1&1&%(1&< :$&3%2'9'1$&37 6+A+2$,=+&' ,9('&+(3 9&> >$&$(3L 3%:/ 93 '/+ 4$(2>]9&PL 923$ ,($A1>+ ,(+33%(+ 1& '+(=3 $B ,$21:1+3 (+1&< '/+ 5%>1'L :1A12 3$:1+') $(+,+&>+&' ]%>1' Z#0R[7 FG,+('3 B($= 9:9>+=19 9&> '/1&P '9&P3 :9&,($A1>+ '+:/&1:92 93313'9&:+ '/($%9'9 9&92)313 9&> A92%952+ (+3+9(:/7 @&9>>1'1$&L '/+3+ 9:'$(3 :9& 923$ B$(=%29'+ '(9&3,9(+&:) 9&> ,+(B$(=9&:+ 1&>+:+3 B$(
8/12/2019 Philippines Final Report December 2013 DRAFT
31/58
E"
933+331&< '/+ 1& 1iO+&'9LCD"E[7
0"? ,($U+:'37 ./13 B%&>1&'+&>3 '$ 3%,,$(' ,$A+(') (+>%:'1$& =+:/9&13=3 B$( =9( 3+:'$(3 9&>1=,$A+(13/+> :$==%&1'1+37 @' 3++P3 '$ :9,9:1'9'+ #HT3 9&> $'/+( #HT3 9&> V?T3 B%&:'1$& 93 1&'+(=+>19()
B%&> =9&9 1& $ &$' 5+2$&< '$ 9&) &+'O$(P =9) ,1:P '/+ $(1'9'1$&7 ./($%%= $B R$&$(3 9&> ,(1A9'+ 2$:92 B%&>1&1+3 9&> $'/+( 1&'+(N2$:92 =+:/9&13=37
#HT3 9&> +( '$,($=$'+ '(9&3,9(+&:) 9&> 9::$%&'95121')7 @& +BB+:'L '/+) 3/922 B$(=%29'+L +G+:%'+L9&> =$&1'$( A9(1$%3 9(+93 B$( + '/+ +G,+('13+ $B '/+
9:9>+=+ 9&> =+>19 #HT3 1& $(>+( '$ 5%12> %, +BB$('37 ./+ +21 /951'9'3 B$( %(59& :$==%&1'1+3L1&>1 ,%521: /+92'/7
8/12/2019 Philippines Final Report December 2013 DRAFT
32/58
EC
./+ ,($U+:'3 O/1:/ 9(+ 1&+21 ,($ 5931: 3+(A1:+3L B91'/N593+> 9:'1A1'1+3 O1'/ '/+ ,%(,$3+ $B:$&A+('1&< $( +A9& '$'/+ :922 B$( +&/9&:+> '(9&3,9(+&:)L 9::$%&'95121')L 9&> a?` ,9('1:1,9'1$&7 ./+3+ 9(+(+2+A9&' '$ /+2, 5%12> +'+(=1&+ 9&) 2$$,/$2+3 $( + '/+ 59313 B$( 9,,($,(19'+ ,$21:) (+:$==+&>9'1$&3 9&> ,$31'1A+1&'+(A+&'1$&3 '$ +&/9&:+ 2$:92 3+(A1:+ >+21A+()_ Z]a?HL CD""L ,7 EC[7 ./+ a?0;H3+(A+3 93 9 =+:/9&13= B$( 933+331&< 9&> +A92%9'1&< '/+ ,+(B$(=9&:+ $B 2$:9259:P $& 3+(A1:+>+21A+()7 @' O93 ,12$'+> 1& CD"C 1& K a?`37
./+ #1A12 H$:1+') 09('1:1,9'1$& 8%&> Z#H08[ O122 1&9'1&< :$==1''++39&> 2$:92 3,+:192 5$>1+3 $( aH]37 ./13 ,9('&+(3/1, 923$ 91=3 '$ :9,9:1'9'+ #HT3Y ($2+3
8/12/2019 Philippines Final Report December 2013 DRAFT
33/58
EE
1& :$=,2) O1'/ '/+ 8%22 613:2$3%(+ 0$21:)7 ./13 Q%921B1+3 '/+= '$ 9::+33 '/+0+(B$(=9&:+ #/922+& $( 0#8 O/1:/ ,($A1>+3 B1&9&:192 3%,,$(' '$ 5+ %3+> 1&'/+ (+3,+:'1A+ a?`3Y ,($U+:'37 ./+3+ ,($U+:'3 =%3' ,9(922+2 '/+ ;122+&&1%=6+A+2$,=+&' ?$9237 @& CD"CL &+O :(1'+(19 O93 :(+9'+>L 9&> 1' /93 '/(++ :9'+ 7 ./+ 5($&M+ :9'+ '(9&3,9(+&:)L '/+ 312A+( :9'+ O1'/ 9&+=,/9313 $& 9 ,9('1:1,9'$() 3)3'+= $( =+:/9&13=7 R&&%92 '9( :1'1M+&() (+1&< '/+ 5%> %'121M9'1$&7 @& $(>+( '$ ,($=$'+ '/13L '/+ >$:%=+&'33/$%2> 5+ >13,29)+> 1& '/(++ ,29:+3 9&> 1& '/+ 860 0$('92 ZB$( A1+O1&$O&2$9>1& ,(1&'1& '/($%19 9&> $&21&+ ZO+531'+3[7 ;+=$(9&>%= #1(:%29( V$7 CD""N"EW 3'9'+3 '/9' '/+a$:92 #/1+B FG+:%'1A+3 =%3' =9P+ '/+3+ >$:%=+&'3 9A912952+ '$ '/+ =+>19L :1A1:L5931: 3+:'$(L 9&> 5%31&+33 '/9' 1' =%3' 5+ >133+=1&9'+> 5) 922 6@a? *+ 5) ,$3'1&< '/+1( A1'92 >$:%=+&'3:$&:+(&1&< '/+ %3+ $B '/+1( B%&>3 1& '/+ '/(++ :$&3,1:%$%3 ,29:+3 Z5%22+'1& 5$9(>3L
'(9>1'1$&92 =+>19L 9&> O+531'+3[7 ./+ 8%22 613:2$3%(+ ,$21:) 0$('92 /93 5++&29%&:/+> O/+(+ 5%>13:2$3+> $&21&+7
0+(B$(=9&:+ #/922+&
./+ 0#8 13 9& 1&:+&'1A+ O/1:/ 13 1& '/+1( R&&%92 @&A+3'=+&'
8/12/2019 Philippines Final Report December 2013 DRAFT
34/58
EW
0($+A+2$,=+&' ,(1$(1'1+37 ./13 13 ^B%&>+> $%' $B '/+ CDka$:92 6+A+2$,=+&' 8%&>_ ZV#*N 6@a?L CD"CL ,9(7 "[7 a1P+ '/+ H?SL '/+ B%&> 3/$%2>5+ %3+> '$ B%2B122 '/+ ;6?3 93 O+22 93 ^=91&'91& :$(+ ($9> &+'O$(P '$ 5$$3' '$%(13=9&> 2$:92 +:$&$=1: >+A+2$,=+&'_ Z6@a?NV#*L CD"CL ,9(7 "[7 0#8NB%&>+> ,($U+:'3=9) 5+ 1& '/+ 9(+93 $B 1&B(93'(%:'%(+L /+92'/L '$%(13=L 9&> +&A1($&=+&'L 9=$& %:'1$&L '/+(+ 13 9 &++> B$( :$2295$(9'1$& 9&> :$$,+(9'1$& $&
8/12/2019 Philippines Final Report December 2013 DRAFT
35/58
E\
'/+ 31>+ $B '/+ :+&'(92 + =$(+ 3+2BN3%BB1:1+&' 9&> 2+33 >+,+&>+&' $& '/+ &9'1$&92 7 ./+ 6@a?,($=13+3 ,($ '$ 2$:92 +:$&$=1: >+A+2$,=+&'L
+&A1($&=+&'92 =9&9%:'1$&7 S$O+A+(L '/13:9& $&2) 5+ 9:/1+A+> 1B $'/+( 3+:'$(3L 3%:/ 93 1B 1' 922$O3,9('1:1,9'1$&L 9&> 1&'+(&92 >+A+2$,=+&' :9& 5+ 933+33+> 5) '/+ ,+(B$(=9&:+ $B '/+a?` 9&> 1'3 $BB1:+3 9&> '/+ =9&9+21A+()7 ./13 13 9,($:+33 O/1:/ O122 5+ 9 3%,+(A13$() '93P $B '/+ 6@a?7 @' /93 5++& 1>+&'1B1+> 5) '/+6@a? '/9' ,($ ,($U+:'3 O/1:/ +G/151' '/+ ,(1&:1,2+3 $B 9&> =91&'91&+>7 ./+ ($2+ $B 6@a? 1& +=9&> 1' '$ 3'(+&>(+33 9&) 21=1'9'1$&3 1& 1'3 ,(9:'1:+7
6@a?Y3 $%':$=+ 9(+93 9&> ,($
8/12/2019 Philippines Final Report December 2013 DRAFT
36/58
EX
./+ B$22$O1&< 13 >(9O& B($= '/+ CD"C VR;8*Fa ,($U+:' :$=,2+'1$& (+,$(' $&=+>1:1&+ =$&1'$(1&< (+,$(' C7 8$:%31&< $& ,($:%(+=+&'L =$&1'$(1& >+21A+()$B =+>1:1&+3L VR;8*Fa 9&> '/+ #$921'1$& R 9::$%&'95121') 1& 922 /$3,1'923 9&> /+92'/ :+&'+(3 Z:$A+(1& :+&'+(3 1& '/+ 0/121,,1&+37 ;;0C:$A+(3 '/+ 3+:$&> ,/93+ $B '/+ ,($U+:' O/1:/ 1&:2%>+3 5%>>1&< 3'9+21A+() $B =+>1:1&+3 9&> >(%1&< B($= ,/93+ $&+ O/1:/ 1&:2%>+> '/+1( ,9('1:1,9'1$& 1& '/+
51>>1&< ,($:+33 $B =+>1:1&+3L '/+ ,($:%(+=+&' $B /$3,1'92 3%,,21+3 9&> 3+(A1:+3L '$=$&1'$(1&< /$3,1'923 9&> (++( '/+ ?$A+(&=+&'0($:%(+=+&' *+B$(= R:' $( ?0*R7
./+ ,($U+:' %3+>L 93 B(9=+O$(P '$ =$&1'$( '/+ ,($:%(+=+&' $B =+>1:1&+3L '/+ '$$235) 0($:%(+=+&' 49':L @&:7L &9=+2)L '/+ 0%521: ]1>>1&< #/+:P213' 9&> '/+ 61913:(+,9&:1+3 1& '/+ =+>1:1&+ ,($:%(+=+&' ,($:+33 O1'/ '/+ ?0*R1& 9 )+9(7 @& 922L '/+ '$$2 1>+&'1B1+> Q%+3'1$&952+ ,(9:'1:+3 1& ,($:%(+=+&' 9&> '/+,+(B$(=9&:+ $B '/+ /+92'/ 9%'/$(1'1+3 1& ,($:%(1&< =+>1:1&+3 9&> $'/+( /$3,1'923%,,21+3 9&> +Q%1,=+&'7
./$3+ O/$ A$2%&'++(+> '$ 1=,2+=+&' '/+ ,($U+:' 9''+&>+> 9& $(1+&'9'1$& 9&>'(91&1&< $& ?0*R I"JW 9&> 1'3 *+A13+> @=,2+=+&'1&< *%2+3 9&> *+ 31,($A1>+ '/+= O1'/ 9>+Q%9'+ P&$O2+>>1&< 9&> 9O9(>3 '$ 1&3%(+ :$=,219&:+ O1'/ '/+?0*RL 93 O+22 93 5+1&< '(9&3,9(+&' 9&> 9::$%&'952+ 1& ,($:%(+=+&'7 #$&3%2'9'1$&39&> =++'1&< O1'/ '/+ /$3,1'92 3'9BB ZH%,,2) TBB1:+(3 9&> 0/9(=9:) TBB1:+(3[ 9&> '/+]1>>1&< 9&> RO9(>3 #$==1''++ O93 %&>+('9P+& B($= V$A+=5+( '$ 6+:+=5+(ZCD"D[ 1& $(>+( '$ r%2) CD""L:$&3%2'9'1$&3 O+(+ %&>+('9P+& '$ 933+33 '/+ +G,+(1+&:+3 $B '/+ A$2%&'++(3 >%(1& >%(1&< '/13 :$&3%2'9'1$& '/9',($:%(+=+&' =$&1'$(1&< &++>+> A921>9'1$& '/($%$:%=+&'37
@& 922L '/13 ,($U+:' 91=+> '$ +&/9&:+ '/+ >+21A+() $B /+92'/ 3+(A1:+3 9&> '$ 3++P $%'1&:$&313'+&:1+3 1& ,($:%(+=+&' 9&> =$&1'$(1&+> '$,($=$'+ '/+ ,9('1:1,9'1$& $B :1'1M+&3 1& '/+ ,($:+33+3L +3,+:1922) 1& =$&1'$(1& +BB1:1+&:) $B /$3,1'923 9&> (+
8/12/2019 Philippines Final Report December 2013 DRAFT
37/58
EK
:+&'+(3 9&> '/+1( >+21A+() $B 3+(A1:+37 ./+ ,($U+:' O93 =9>+ ,$33152+ >%+ '$ 1'3,9('&+(3 l #HT3L ,($A1&:192 VR;8*Fa :/9,'+(3L 9&> ,(1A9'+ 3+:'$( +('$$P ,($U+:' 1=,2+=+&'9'1$& O/12+ 5+1&< :$$(>1&9'+> 5) '/+ VR;8*FaH+:(+'9(19'7 n$2%&'++(3 O+(+ 5) '/+ ,9('&+(3 9&> O+(+ =9>+(+3,$&3152+ 1& $53+(A1&< '/+ ]R# 1& '/+ ,($:%(+=+&' ,($:+337 ./+ A$2%&'++(3 /9> '$
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
K $%' $B '/+ C" /$3,1'9237 @& 8+5(%9() $B CD""L '/+ ,($:%(+=+&' 9&> =$&1'$(1& Q%921') /+92'/ 3+(A1:+39&> =+>1:1&+3 93 3,+:1B1+> 1& :$&'(9:'37
./+ A$2%&'++(3 =$&1'$(+> '/+ 51>>1&< ,($:+33 9&> O+(+ '$ :/+:P '/13 O1'/ '/+R&&%92 0($:%(+=+&' 029& $( R00 '$ A+(1B) 1B '/+ >(%1:1&+3 O+(+ 9,,($A+>5) 0/121,,1&+ V9'1$&92 6(%< 8$(=%29() Z0V68[7 @& =$&1'$(1&< >+21A+()L '/+A$2%&'++(3 /9> '$ =$&1'$( 1B '/+(+ O93 9 V$'1:+ '$ 0($:++>L (+A1+O 1B '/+ V$'1:+3 $BRO9(> 213'+> '/+ '$'92 &%=5+( $B Q%9&'1'1+3 9&> '/+ 213' $B >(% '/+ 21P+L (+A1+O
,%(:/93+ $(>+(3L 9&> 9&3O+( '/+ @&3,+:'1$& 9&> R::+,'9&:+ 8$(= O/1:/ 3,+:1B1+>'/+ >(%+21A+() O93 9::$=,213/+>L '/+ A$2%&'++(3 O+(+ (+3,$&3152+ B$( =$&1'$(1&>1&< ,($:+33Y 3'9+> /$3,1'92 >$:%=+&'3L 9&> >1BB1:%2') 1& (+:(%1'1&< A$2%&'++(331&:+ =$&1'$(1&< 13 9 /+9A) '93P '$ %&>+('9P+L 9=$&< $'/+(37 *+3%2'3 $B '/+ B1&92(+,$(' 5) VR;8*Fa B1&> '/9' '/+ ,($U+:' /93 1=,($A+> ,($:%(+=+&' 1& /+92'/3+(A1:+3 9&> /93 :$&'(15%'+> '$ 1'3 +BB1:1+&:) 93 O+227 @& 3%==9()L '/+ (+,$('
1>+&'1B1+3 '/9' ,%521: 51>>1&< /93 5+:$=+ =$(+ '(9&3,9(+&' 9&> :$=,219&' O1'/?0*R I"JW7 8%('/+(=$(+L VR;8*Fa /93 =9>+ '/13 ,($:+33 =$(+ 1&:2%31A+ 9&> /93=9>+ A$2%&'++(3 93 TBB1:192 T53+(A+(3 9&> =+=5+(3 $B '/+ @&'++21A+() $B/+92'/ 3+(A1:+3 3/$O+> '/9' 0/, EDC7\" =1221$& O$('/ $B =+>1:1&+3 O+(+ =$&1'$(+>7./+3+ :$=,21+> O1'/ '/+ :$&'(9:'7 @& 9>>1'1$&L '/+3+ O+(+ >+21A+(+> $& '1=+7 ./+(+,$(' 1>+&'1B1+3 '/9' 93 =%:/ 93 0/, "K\7JI =1221$& O$('/ $B =+>1:1&+3 O+(+
8/12/2019 Philippines Final Report December 2013 DRAFT
38/58
8/12/2019 Philippines Final Report December 2013 DRAFT
39/58
EI
'$ '/+= '/+ ,($:+33 $B 5$$P ,($>%:'1$&L '/+ 5$$P ,(1&'1&< ,($:+33L 9&> '/+:$&3'(91&'3 $( 133%+3 '/9' :$%2> 5+ B$%&> 1& '/+3+7 ./+) O+(+ 923$ '(91&+> 1& '/+1&3,+:'1$& ,($:+337 ./+ '+9=Y3 (+3,$&315121') O93 '$ 1&3,+:' '/+ '/(++ ,(1&'1&L "E,+(:+&' $B '/+ '$'92 &%=5+( ,($:%(+>7 ./+ 1&3,+:'1$&3 2+> '$ '/+ (+,91( $((+,29:+=+&' $B 9,,($G1=9'+2) XCLDDD >+B+:'1A+ '+G'5$$P3L O$('/ 9,,($G1=9'+2) E=1221$& 0/121,,1&+3 0+3$3 Z`H yX"LDDD[_ Z*9=P%=9(L CDDJL ,7 X"[7
R5$%' KX ,+(:+&' $B '/+ 9(+93 B$( '/+ >+21A+() $B '+G'5$$P3 O+(+ =$&1'$(+>5) A$2%&'++(37 @' O93 &$'+> ^9,,($G1=9'+2) KXKLDDD '+G'5$$P3 :$3'1&+29)3 1& >+21A+()L 1&9>+Q%9'+ 1>+&'1B1:9'1$& $B ,$$( Q%921') '+G'5$$P3L9&> '/+ 133%+ $B 1&3%BB1:1+&' B%&>1&< '$ >+21A+( '+G'5$$P3 1& 3:/$$23 2$:9'+> 1& (%(922$:9'1$&37 R :$=,9&)L #$:9 #$29L /93 %&>+('9P+& '/13 >+21A+() 5%' O93 =+' O1'/:(1'1:13=7 R .+G'5$$P 492P O93 29%&:/+> 9B'+( '/+ CDDX .+G'5$$P #$%&' 0($
8/12/2019 Philippines Final Report December 2013 DRAFT
40/58
WD
1& $(>+( '$ /+2, +G'+&> '+G'5$$P >13'(15%'1$&7 ./+ 3:/$$23 9&> '/+ :$==%&1')=+=5+(3 O+(+ =$5121M+> B$( '/13 +&>+9A$(7
8$( '/+ .+G'5$$P 492PL "C >13'(1:'3 O+(+ 3+2+:'+> B($= '/+1( >1A131$&3- H19( 69A9$ T(1+&'92 Z;9'1 V$('/L ;9'1
H$%'/L ;9'1 #+&'(92[L B$%( B($= V+ 'O$ B($= ]9)9O9& #1') Z]9)9O9& F93'L ]9)9O9& 4+3'[ c?$A+(&=+&'49':/NR'+&+$ H:/$$2 $B ?$A+(&=+&'L CDDKe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a:$%&:12$(37 ./+) O$%2> 5+ 1& :/9(13'(1:' 9&> 3:/$$2 2+A+237 @& 9>>1'1$&L A$2%&'++(3 B($= #HT3 O+(+ 1& :$$(>1&9'1$&O1'/ '/+= 9&> /9&>2+> '/+ =$&1'$(1&< $B '+G'5$$P3 93 '/+) O+(+ 5+1&< '(9&3,$('+>'$ '/+ 3:/$$237 ./+ .+G'5$$P 492P O93 923$ 5+1&< (+,$('+> 5) #HT37
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
+&/9&:+ '/+ ,9('1:1,9'$() ,($:+337 @' /93 5++& &$'+> '/9' 9 1&3'1'%'1$&921M9'1$& 3'%>)O(1''+& 1& CDDX 3'9'+> '/9' '/+ 6+,F> T(>+( 13 ^5+&+B1:192 '$ :1A12 3$:1+') 5+:9%3+ 1'^+G,9&>3 '/+ 3:$,+ $B =$&1'$(1&(+ $B ,($:%(+=+&' $53+(A+(3s=$&1'$(3 '$ 1&:2%>+:$&:+(&+> 5%' %&$( :1'1M+&3_ Z?$A+(&=+&' 49':/NR'+&+$ H:/$$2 $B?$A+(&=+&'L CDDKL ,7 CI[7
#$&:+(&+> #1'1M+&3 $B R5(9 B$( ?$$> ?$A+(&9&:+
./+ #$&:+(&+> #1'1M+&3 $B R5(9 B$( ?$$> ?$A+(&9&:+L $( ##R??L 13 9 V?T '/9'+&=1&13'(9'1$&7 ./+ ##R?? =$&1'$(+>1&B(93'(%:'%(+ ,($U+:'3 1& '/+ (+ %'121M+> '/+ :$==%&1')N593+> 9,,($9:/7 @&$(>+( '$ B9:121'9'+ '/13L '/+ V?T 31 9 ;+=$(9&>%= $B `&>+(3'9&>1&< O1'/ '/+V9'1$&92 F:$&$=1: 6+A+2$,=+&' R%'/$(1') ZVF6R[ B$( '/+ ,($U+:' =$&1'$(1& 9:'1A1'1+37
8/12/2019 Philippines Final Report December 2013 DRAFT
41/58
W"
`&>+( '/+ ,($U+:' =$&1'$(1&< 9:'1A1')L A$2%&'++(3 O+(+ '$ $53+(A+ '/+ :$&3'(%:'1$&$B ($9>3 $( 5(1> +3,+:1922) :$&'(9:' :$=,219&:+ 1& 1&B(93'(%:'%(+ ,($U+:'37RB'+( '/+ A$2%&'++(3 (+,$('+> '/+1( B1&>1&7 ##R?? 13 9 &$'952+ :93+ $B ,9('1:1,9'$() 9%>1' 31&:+ 1'
O93 9O9(>+> 9& @&'+13/$&+3') 1& >+A+2$,=+&' ,($U+:'37
##R?? 3'9('+> 1'3 ,($U+:' =$&1'$(1&< 9B'+( '/+ #$(9M$& RQ%1&$ 9>=1&13'(9'1$&1=,2+=+&'+> '/+ #$==%&1') 9&> F=,2$)=+&' 6+A+2$,=+&' 0($+( VF6R7 ./+ ,($ A9(1$%3 ,($U+:'3 91=+> 9' /+92'/L+>%:9'1$&L 9&> 1&B(93'(%:'%(+7 ./$3+ O/$ 5+&+B1'+> B($= '/+3+ ,($U+:'3 O+(+ =9>++=,2$)++37 #HT3 ,9('1:1,9'+> B$( =$&1'$(1&< >%'1+37 T&+ $B '/+3+ O93 '/+ ##R??O/$ 31 '/+ ;+=$(9&>%= $B `&>+(3'9&>1&< Z;T`[ O1'/ VF6R7 ./+ V?T O93'/+& '(91&+> $& ,($U+:' =$&1'$(1&< 9&> ,($A1>+> '/+ &+:+339() 1&B$(=9'1$& '$ 3'9('
'/+1( =$&1'$(1&< 9:'1A1'1+37
##R?? (+,$('+> (+9'1$&3 B$( '/+,($U+:'3 1' =$&1'$(+>7 n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
./+ V?T 3$%+ 9&> ,(+3+&' +A1>+&:+ '/9' '/+3+ ,($U+:'3 /9> &$' 5++&B1&13/+> 5) >$:%=+&'1&< '/+ ,($U+:' 31'+37 @& 9>>1'1$&L '/+ ##R?? +&s$( B1&>1& '/+3+ '$ '/+ &9'1$&92 $BB1:+ $B '/+
604S7 6%+ '$ '/+ (+,$('L '/+ >13'(1:' $BB1:+ $B '/+ 604S O93 1&A+3'11&+('9P+&L 9&> '/$3+ 1&A$2A+> 1& '/+ ,($U+:'3 O+(+,%&13/+>7 S$O+A+(L '/+) 923$ 3$%21&< $B '/+ ,($U+:'37 R3 9 (+3,$&3+ '$ '/13L '/+ ##R?? 93P+> '/+ :1'1M+&3 B$(93313'9&:+7 H,+:1B1:922)L '/+) 3+&' '+2+
8/12/2019 Philippines Final Report December 2013 DRAFT
42/58
WC
604S 1&313'1&< '/9' ,($,+( 9:'1$& 5+ %&>+('9P+&7 ./13 ,($A+> '$ 5+ +BB+:'1A+ 93 '/+"" :1A12 +& +BB$(' 1& 5) '/+ ##R?? 9&> :$==%&1')=+=5+(3 :9'9,%2'+> '/+ #HT '$ '/+ ,$31'1$& $B =$&1'$(1&< 9&) ,($U+:' 5+B$(+ 1'O$%2> +A+&'%922) 5+ B%&>+> 1& '/+ (++(3 :$%2>59:P (+1&< '/+ 5%> 5) A9(1$%3 9
8/12/2019 Philippines Final Report December 2013 DRAFT
43/58
WE
6+,9('=+&' $B 0%521: 4$(P3 9&> S1 '/+ 6+,9('=+&' $B H$:192 4+2B9(+9&> 6+A+2$,=+&'7 #HT ,9('1:1,9'1$& O$%2> 5+ =9>+ ,$33152+ '/($% 1&3'1'%'1$&921M+ #HT,9('1:1,9'1$& 1& 5%> '/13 93 5+1& ,9('1:1,9'+7 8$( +G9=,2+L 1& '/+9 1& 391> 3+:'$(7 ./+ #HT3 O/$ ,($,$3+> 9& 92'+(&9'1A+ 5%>>1'1$&L '/+) 923$ 9(+ 3%,,$('1&< '/+ 1&:2%31$& $B 95%>+ 9&> :(+9'+ 9 3=% '$ 1=,($A+ +BB1:1+&:) 1& '/+ >+21A+() $B 5) '/+ #1A12 H+(A1:+ #$==1331$&Z#H#[7 RB'+( /9A1&< =$&1'$(+> '/+ 3+(A1:+3L '/+ A$2%&'++(3 (+,$(' '/+1( B1&>1&
8/12/2019 Philippines Final Report December 2013 DRAFT
44/58
WW
$BB1:192 3:/$$2 ,9('&+(3 $B ]9&'9)7,/ 9(+ '/+ `&1A+(31') $B '/+ 0/121,,1&+3NV9'1$&92#$22+=1&13'(9'1$&L R'+&+$ >+ ;9&129 `&1A+(31')L 9&> 6+ a9 H922+`&1A+(31')7
./+ ]9&'9)7,/ O+531'+ =9,3 $%' '/+ R*.R :$=,219&:+ $B '/+ $BB1:+3 $B '/+
9'9 A13%923 '$ 31=,21B) '/+ >9'9 '/9' 13 (+,$('+> 5)'/+ A$2%&'++(3 $( 3/9(+> 5) %3+(3 $B '/+ O+531'+7 @& 9>>1'1$&L '/+ O+531'+ 922$O3%3+(3 '$ 3++ 1&3'(%:'1$&3 $& /$O '/+) :9& (+,$(' :93+3 A19 =$512+L 3%5=1' 9 (+,$('$&21&+L ,(1&' 9&> ,$3' 1&B$(=9'1A+ ,$3'+(3 122%3'(9'1&< $&9'+ B1&9&:1922) '$ 3%,,$(' ]9&'9)7,/L 9&>:$==%&1:9'+ B$( ,9('&+(3/1,37
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
8/12/2019 Philippines Final Report December 2013 DRAFT
45/58
W\
+A+2$,=+&' ,29&&1& 3+(A1:+ >+21A+()L 9&> +A+&'%922)
,$21:) >1(+:'1$&7 ;$3' 3113:$%(3+ /93 ,%' #HT3 9&> :1'1M+&3 93 ^=9&9+A+2$,=+&' ,(1$(1'1+37 ./+ 3$:192 :$&'(9:' 93 +3,$%3+> 5) '/+ 9>=1&13'(9'1$& /93=9>+ '/+ 9::$%&'95121') 1& 9& +BB$(' '$:$=59' :$((%,'1$& 9&> >13/$&+3')7
./+ ($2+ $B '+:/&$2$+&'2) ,29)1&< 9 29( >+21A+()7 R22 '/+ =$(+L '/+3+ /9A+ 3+(A+> 93 5+&:/=9(P3 $( :(1'+(19 1&
933+331&< '/+ ,+(B$(=9&:+ $B a?`3 9&> /9A+ ,($A1>+> 1&:+&'1A+3 Z+7 H?SL9=$&< $'/+(3[ '$ '/$3+ O/$ ,($A+ +G+=,29() 1& '/13 B1+2> 9&> O/$ %,/$2> =1&13'(9'1$& /9A+ 5++& '/+1&1'19'1A+3 B$( +G,9&>+> ,9('1:1,9'1$& 1& '/+ 5%>
8/12/2019 Philippines Final Report December 2013 DRAFT
46/58
WX
R3 3++& '/+ 9>=1&13'(9'1$& 13 1&:(+931& ,($:+33 O/1:/ 1&A$2A+3 A9(1$%3 9:'$(3 O/$ 9(+ :$&:+(&+> O1'/ '/+9::$%&'95121') ,($:+337 @& '/+ :$%&'() '/13 /93 5++& >13,29)+> 5) '/+ #1'1M+&309('1:1,9'$() R%>1' $B '/+ #$==1331$& $& R%>1' O/1:/ /93 :(+9'+> 3,+:1B1: 9(+93O/+(+ :1'1M+&3 :9& ,9('1:1,9'+7 ./+ =+>19 /93 923$ 5++& +=,/931M+> 93 /9A1&< 9 ($2+
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
8/12/2019 Philippines Final Report December 2013 DRAFT
47/58
WK
a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
W7W ;$'1A9'1&< ,9('1:1,9'1$&
*+29'+> '$ '/+ 95$A+ 13 '/+ 93,+:' $B =$'1A9'1&< :1'1M+&3 '$ ,9('1:1,9'+7 R3 1>+&'1B1+>1& '/+ 0/121,,1&+3Y T,+& ?$A+(&=+&' 029& 9&> 1& 1'3 ?$$> ?$A+(&9&:+ 9&> R&'1N#$((%,'1$& 029& Z??R#[ (%&&1&< %&'12 CD"XL '/+ :$%&'()Y3 =$'1A9'1$& 1& =9P1&7
R31>+ B($= '/+ :%((+&' 9>=1&13'(9'1$&Y3 '/+=+ !"#$ &'('#$ )*++",-. &'('#$/'01+',L '/+ Q%+3'1$& 3'9&>3- /$O '$ $,+(9'1$&921M+ :1'1M+& +& @"134(1#4A *# 6'+-#4+A01,&1-0 :1B1( 9*)14-5 C+$'#1L #TRY3 #1'1M+&3 09('1:1,9'$() R%>1' /93 ,9A+>'/+ O9) B$( :1'1M+& +&%(1&< '/+ ;9(:$3+(9 9&> '/+ #$(9M$& RQ%1&$ 9>=1&13'(9'1$&7 ./+ $5U+:'1A+ 9' '/+ '1=+ $B '/+>1:'9'$(3/1, O93 '$ $A+('/($O ;9(:$37 RB'+( '/13 ,+(1$>L '/+ "IJK #$&3'1'%'1$&^(+:$ '/+ (1
8/12/2019 Philippines Final Report December 2013 DRAFT
48/58
8/12/2019 Philippines Final Report December 2013 DRAFT
49/58
WI
>+21A+() $B +A+2$,=+&' :$%&:123 :9& :$&'(15%'+ '$ '/13 93,+:'7
./+ B9A$(952+ +&A1($&=+&' B$( ,9('1:1,9'$() ,($:+33+3 =9) 5+ 5+3' %&>+('9P+&>%(1&< '/+ 5%>>13'(15%'1$& $B '/+ 59:P O/+& 5+&+B1'3 9(+>++=+> 1&9>+Q%9'+L /9A+ 5++& 3%5U+:'+> '$ :$((%,'1$&L 1&9>+Q%9:1+3 $B '/+ (+29'+> 93,+:'3 $B '(9&3,9(+&:) 9&> 9::$%&'95121')7 ./+ #1'1M+&309('1:1,9'$() R%>1'L B$( 1&3'9&:+L =9) 5+ $&+ =9U$( :$&'(15%'$( '$ '(9&3,9(+&:) 9&>,9('1:1,9'1$& B$( 1' ,(+3+&'3 /$O ,9('&+(3/1,3 5+'O++& 9:'$(3 13 ,$33152+7 V$' $&2)
>$+3 '/13 >13,29) ,9('1:1,9'1$&L 5%' 923$ =9&1B+3'3 :$2295$(9'1$& '$O9(>3 9 :$==$&$5U+:'1A+7 @& 922L '/+ &++> B$( '/+ +&+3 9 =$(+ +&9521&< +&A1($&=+&' B$( :1'1M+&+&A9&:+3 1& '/+ 9(+9 $B #HT +&$ '/($%+ '/+ =%:/&++>+> :$$,+(9'1A+ =+:/9&13=3 '$ B9:121'9'+ '/+ >+21A+() $B ,($U+:'3 9&>+G,+&>1'%(+ =9&91'1&< $B + =$(+ A13152+ 1& +G9:'1&< 9::$%&'95121') B($=9%'/$(1'1+37 S$O+A+(L >1BB1:%2'1+3 =9) 9(13+ 1& 3%3'91&1&< 9 '(%3'1&< ,9('&+(3/1, $((+29'1$&3/1, O1'/ '/+ :+&'(92
8/12/2019 Philippines Final Report December 2013 DRAFT
50/58
\D
>+A+2$,1&+A+2$,=+&' =9) $::%( O/1:/ =9) :/9&+A+2$,=+&' ,(9:'1'1$&+(3 9&> 9:9>+=1:3 O/$ 9(+5+''+( +Q%1,,+> '$ +G,291& 9&> ,($A1>+ (+2+A9&' >13:$%(3+ $& 93,+:'3 :$&:+(&1&%+ '$ 9& 1&'+(,29) $B B9:'$(3 3%:/ 93 '/+ 5(+9>'/ $B '/+1(,9('1:1,9'1$& $( 9 29:P $B ,$21'1:92 O122L '/+& '/+ /%(>2+ 13 9:'1A9'+>7 S9A1&< 391> '/13L
#HT3 O/$ >$ &$' /9A+ '/+ (+3$%(:+3 '$ B9:121'9'+ '/+=3+2A+3 9&> O/$ 29:P '/+P&$O2+>$1&< 3$ =9) 5+ 2+33 :(1'1:92 9&> >13:+(&1&< $B '/+ $A+(922 ,+(B$(=9&:+7 @&'+(&92 9&> +G'+(&92 #HT 133%+3 931>+L '/+$+3 &$'&+:+339(12) >1=1&13/ '/+ B9:' '/9' #HT3 :9& 1BB1:%2' +&A1($&=+&'37
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
8/12/2019 Philippines Final Report December 2013 DRAFT
51/58
\"
8/12/2019 Philippines Final Report December 2013 DRAFT
52/58
\C
3%F.%&7?-=/4
CD"C 0/121,,1&+ T,+& ?$A+(&=+&' 09('&+(3/1, #$%&'() R33+33=+&' *+,$('7 ZCD"E[7 TBB1:192
?9M+''+ $B '/+ *+,%521: $B '/+ 0/121,,1&+37 *+'(1+A+> r%&+ "\L CD"EL B($=
/'',-ssOOO7{- FG,291&1&< j;92N>+A+2$,=+&'Y $B 09('1+3 1&
'/+ 0/121,,1&+37 F# E48*+/1#$ -04 601(1,,1#4 6*(1-1)'( 6'+-5 95A-4/; F34'A '#3
1#1-1'-1B4A. 34>'-4A '#3 35#'/1)A. ,">(1A043 >5 -04 G+143+1)0 =>4+- 9-18-"#$7 *+'(1+A+>
B($= /'',-ss215(9()7B+37>+s,>BNB12+3s5%+($3s,/121,,1&+&sDK"E"7,>B
R&39N+9,7 ZCD"D[7 HI= 27DH7J K7D97D@7D LEC7M N7H:IO =P6=EF=D:=7 *+'(1+A+> r%2)"\L CD"E B($= /'',-ssOOO79&39N+9,7&+'s933+'3sCDDs\IN"NW|]9&'9)|a9&39&|49':/|FG,+(1+&:+7,>B
R(2+ #$($&+2L r7r7 ZCDDE[7 0/121,,1&+37 F# 6*(1-1)'( 6'+-14A 1# 7A1' 6+*/*-1#$ E48*+/
'#3 :*/>'-1#$ :*++",-1*# 1# =1$0- :*"#-+14A. 431-43 >5 64-4+ Q? Q'#1!'A '#3 K'"+' K?
H0*+#-*#. F92D RSTTURVWSVXSX. D'-1*#'( M4/*)+'-1) F#A-1-"-4 8*+ F#-4+#'-1*#'(
788'1+A7 *+'(1+A+> B($= /'',-ssOOO7&>17$(7[7 I*(3 5*"+ $*B4+#/4#- '))*"#-'>(47 *+'(1+A+> r%2) "EL CD"EL B($=/'',-ssOOO759&'9)7,/
]9(&3L r7 ZCDDE[7 F&$:s$:%=+&'3s%&s%&,9&D"WW"W7,>B
]2+:/1& B($= /'',-ss,>B7%391>7B|>$:3s0VR#.JKI7,>B
](1229&'+3L R7L 9&> H$&:$L r7.7 ZCDD\[7 #1'1M+& 09('1:1,9'1$& 1& H%5N&9'1$&92 029&&1&< 9&>
]%> B($=
/'',-ssOOO7%&,9&7$($:%=+&'3s0%521:9'1$&3s09('1:1,9'
$()kCD029&&1&kCD]%>+B9%2'sB12+3s,%5s"IIIsB
]%&5$&9'1$& 1& R3197 F#
@+*&-0 '#3 @*B4+#'#)4 1# 7A1'. 431-43 >5 J*1)01+* 9'-*. 7A1'S6')181) :4#-4+ 8*+
8/12/2019 Philippines Final Report December 2013 DRAFT
53/58
\E
94)"+1-5 9-"314A? *+'(1+A+> B($=
/'',-ssOOO79,:337$(kCDn$2%=+3s?($O'/?$A+(&9&:+|B12+3s
0%5|?($O'/kCD?$A+(&9&:+s0%5|?($O'/?$A+(&9&:+kCD5$$P7,>B
#/+& '/+ ;92913+ $B F93' R319& V+O
6+=$:(9:1+37[*"+#'( *8 ='A- 7A1'# 9-"314A L VZ"[7 *+'(1+A+> r%&+ CEL CD"ELB($= /'',-ssOOO7+917$(7P(s>9'9s553s+&B
#($1339&'L R7 ZCDDW[7 8($= .(9&31'1$& '$ 6+B+:'1A+ 6+=$:(9:)- ;9,,1&< R319&
6+=$:(9'1M9'1$&7 Z#1B4+A1-\- I4134(>4+$7 *+'(1+A+> B($= /'',-ssOOO7%&1N
/+1>+25+(+s1=,+(19s=>s:$&'+&'sB9P%2'9+'+&sO13$s1,Os:($1339&'s,%521:9'1$&3s
:($1339&'|CDDW|'(9&31'1$&|>+B+:'1A+|>+=$:(9:)7,>B
61$P&$L ]7 ZCD"D[7 0/121,,1&+ 813:92 ]+/9A1$( 1& *+:+&' S13'$()7 601(1,,1#4 E4B14& *8
=)*#*/1)A7 *+'(1+A+> B($=
/'',-ss,(+7+:$&7%,>7+>%7,/s1&>+G7,/,s,(+s9('1:2+sA1+OsXW\
6@a?NV#*7 ZCD"C[7 94'( *8 @**3 I*"A4!4,1#$7 *+'(1+A+> r%2) "EL CD"EL B($=
&:(7>12 H1&+=$:(9'1: '+&>+&:1+37 ;RiR*RL HTH@Ra S`;RV@T*RL nTa7 "CL VT7 C- X\NK"7
*+'(1+A+> B($=
/'',-ss(+,$31'$()7%179:71>s:$&'+&'3sP$2+P31sCs\IXIWJI\JK9X+:B5DW"J:KK5C+JXJK
5XWJ5\C:"J7,>B
8/12/2019 Philippines Final Report December 2013 DRAFT
54/58
\W
8u23:/+(L R7 ZCDDK[7 09('1:1,9'$() ]%>B
?%1&1$L 67 ZCD"C[7 813:92 ,$21:)L ,%521: >+5' =9&9
=9(P+'3- '/+ :93+ B$( '/+ 0/121,,1&+37 2'#! 8*+ F#-4+#'-1*#'( 94--(4/4#-A7 *+'(1+A+>
B($=
/'',-ssOOO75137$(+5'~=9&9~=9(P+'3kER~'/+~:93+~B$(~'/+~,/121,,1&+3h=,},/(93+h|3'}B923+
h:}"Dh35}D
S92:$&L V7R7 9&> 6+ a+$&L a7;7 ZCDDW[7 FBB1:1+&:) $B 813:92 9&> ;$&+'9() 0$21:1+3 1& '/+
0/121,,1&+3- '/+ H'7 a$%13 ;$>+2 R,,($9:/7 2'#$!* 94#-+'( E4B14&7 *+'(1+A+> B($=
/'',-ssOOO753,7$O&2$9>3s,%521:9'1$&3sCDDWs]H*CDDW5|DW7,>B
S+>=9&L F7 F7 ZCD"D[7 6+=$:(9'139'1$& h &+O A$'+( =$512139'1$& 1& H$%'/+93' R319- ]+)$&>
=9:/1&+ ,$21'1:3z- *+B$(=13=L ,$,%213= 9&> 0/121,,1&+ +2+:'1$&37 K9= E4A4'+)0
C#(1#47 *+'(1+A+> B($=
/'',-ss+,(1&'3723+79:7%PsWE\XWs"s6+=$:(9'139'1$&kCDkCXkCD&+OkCDA$'+(kCD
=$512139'1$&kCD1&kCDH$%'/+93'kCDR319|5+)$&>kCD=9:/1&+kCD,$21'1:3kCJ23+
($kCI7,>B
S%':/:($B'L 07L 9&> *$:9=$(9L r7 ZCDDE[7 H'($&< 6+=9&>3 9&> 4+9P @&3'1'%'1$&3- ./+ T(1 FA$2%'1$& $B '/+ 6+=$:(9'1: 6+B1:1' 1& '/+ 0/121,,1&+37[*"+#'( *8 ='A- 7A1'#
9-"314AL VZC[7 *+'(1+A+> r%&+ CEL CD"EL B($=
/'',-ssOOO7+917$(7P(s>9'9s553s+&B
@]07 Z%&>9'+>[7 6'+-#4+1#$ -* /'!4 >"3$4-A &*+!7 *+'(1+A+> r%2) C"L CD"EL B($=
1&'+(&9'1$&925%>
8/12/2019 Philippines Final Report December 2013 DRAFT
55/58
\\
@29 r%2) "DL CD"EL
B($= /'',-ss,:1U7$(B
i9O9&9P9L .7 ZCD"D[7 ./+ `(59& ;1>>2+ #2933 1& '/+ @&3'95121') $B V+O 6+=$:(9:1+37
F#A-1-"-4 *8 M4B4(*,1#$ =)*#*/14A7 *+'(1+A+> B($=
/'',-ss1(71>+73,9:+s51'3'(+9=sCEWWsICCs"sR**@6F|613:%331$&|V$7CXD|P9O
9&9P97,>B
i+%2++(3L 07 ZCDDC[7 ./+ ($2+ $B '/+ ?$A+(&$( 9&> $B '/+ ,($A1&:192 9>=1&13'(9'1$&;
#$=,9(9'1A+ +G,+(1+&:+37 Z#1-43 D'-1*#A M4B4(*,/4#- 6+*$+'//4 2'#$!*! 9ZEG?
*+'(1+A+> B($=
/'',-ssOOO7%&>,7$(71>s,($ 0%521: 81&9&:+ ;9&9 B($=
/'',-ssOOO7%&,9&7$($:%=+&'3s0%521:9'1$&3sR%>1'1& B($=
/'',-ss>1
8/12/2019 Philippines Final Report December 2013 DRAFT
56/58
\X
0+$,2+Y3 ]%> r%2) "\L CD"EL B($=
/'',-ss5%> B($=
/'',-ssOOO7,+(($&:9=,913sB12+3s812+N
X|""|R('1P+2*$%'2+>B
0$$21'1P9&< 01&$) CD"D7 ZCDDI[7 R a$$P 9' 0/121,,1&+ 0$21'1:92 09('1+3 1& 09,+( 9&> 1&
0(9:'1:+7 G+143+1)0 =>4+- 9-18-"#$ 601(1,,1#4A. ^*("/4 R. FAA"4 c; RST? *+'(1+A+> B($=
/'',-ssOOO7B+37$(19s%,2$9>3s>$:%=+&'3s133%+DK|0$0CD"D|>+:DI7,>B
0.87 ZCD"E[7 ='A- 7A1' 6+*d4)-A 8*+ H+'#A,'+4#)57 *+'(1+A+> r%2) "EL CD"EL B($=
/'',-ss,'B%&>7$( '/+ H'9'+ l 0/121,,1&+ 6+=$:(9:)
.$>9)7 *+'(1+A+> B($= /'',-ssOOO7>1+N17>+s#;HN
S$=+,9BzT,+&
*9 B($= /'',3-ss:>179&%7+>%79%s7R0sCDDKN
DJsCDDK|DK|R0|*FH|]*|F93'|R319&|09(')|H)3'+=3sCDDK|DK|R0|*FH|]*|F93'|R319
&|09(')|H)3'+=37,>B
*+,%521: $B '/+ 0/121,,1&+3 0%521: R>=1&13'(9'1$& #$%&'() 0($B12+7 ZCDDW[7 61A131$& B$(
0%521: R>=1&13'(9'1$& 9&> 6+A+2$,=+&' ;9&9
8/12/2019 Philippines Final Report December 2013 DRAFT
57/58
\K
F:$&$=1: 9&> H$:192 RBB91(3 Z6FHR[ `&1'+> V9'1$&37 *+'(1+A+> B($=
/'',-ss%&,9&"7%&7$([7 #1A12 H$:1+') 1& '/+ 0/121,,1&+3- H'(% B($=
/'',-ssOOO73:,17,$21'1:92>9'97$(1>9'+N
#+&'+(+>kCDF2+:'$(92kCDH)3'+=37,>B
H$21=9&L H7 ;7 Z"IIK[7 ./+ 0/121,,1&+3 .(1+3 '/+ 09(')Na13' H)3'+= ZR 0($4+- 9-18-"#$7 *+'(1+A+> B($=
/'',-ss215(9()7,+(>9&97$(B
.++/9&P++L r7 ZCDDI[7 #1'1M+&N09(') a1&P9'-4A '#3
35#'/1)A. ,">(1A043 >5 -04 G+143+1)0 =>4+- 9-18-"#$7 *+'(1+A+> B($=
/'',-ss215(9()7B+37>+s,>BNB12+3s5%+($3s,/121,,1&+&sDK"E"7,>B
./+ 08;0 29%&:/+3 1'3 H'(9'+ r%2) XL CD"EL B($= /'',-ss,B=,7$(+G7,/,s/1>>+&EsIXN
'/+N,B=,N29%&:/+3N1'3N3'(9'+ #2+9A9 B($=
/'',-ssOOOX7:1')%7+>%7/Ps3+9(:s69'9s812+`,2$9>sEE\s40"CI|"C|`B+&7,>B
8/12/2019 Philippines Final Report December 2013 DRAFT
58/58