37
Phenotyping the forest-concepts and progress Heidi Dungey, Dave Pont, Jonathan Dash, Mike Watt, Toby Stovold, Emily Telfer

Phenotyping the forest-concepts and progress · PDF file07.05.2016 · Phenotyping the forest-concepts and progress Heidi Dungey, Dave Pont, Jonathan Dash, Mike Watt, Toby Stovold,

Embed Size (px)

Citation preview

Page 1: Phenotyping the forest-concepts and progress · PDF file07.05.2016 · Phenotyping the forest-concepts and progress Heidi Dungey, Dave Pont, Jonathan Dash, Mike Watt, Toby Stovold,

Phenotyping the forest-concepts and progressHeidi Dungey, Dave Pont, Jonathan Dash, Mike Watt, Toby Stovold, Emily Telfer

Page 2: Phenotyping the forest-concepts and progress · PDF file07.05.2016 · Phenotyping the forest-concepts and progress Heidi Dungey, Dave Pont, Jonathan Dash, Mike Watt, Toby Stovold,

A national aim to double forest productivity

Static forest area

Page 3: Phenotyping the forest-concepts and progress · PDF file07.05.2016 · Phenotyping the forest-concepts and progress Heidi Dungey, Dave Pont, Jonathan Dash, Mike Watt, Toby Stovold,

Phenotyping the forest

• What is it?• What can we do?

• What have we done?• Next steps

Page 4: Phenotyping the forest-concepts and progress · PDF file07.05.2016 · Phenotyping the forest-concepts and progress Heidi Dungey, Dave Pont, Jonathan Dash, Mike Watt, Toby Stovold,

What is Phenotyping ?

“the goal is to automate the acquisition of plant images, and other

physical data that can be used to quantify genotype by phenotype by

environment interactions”(Fahlgren et al. 2015)

“extracting biologically meaningful signal from environmental and

experimental noise” (Cobb et al. 2013)

Controlled environment

High throughputNon-destructiveImage analysis

Slide: Dave Pont

Page 5: Phenotyping the forest-concepts and progress · PDF file07.05.2016 · Phenotyping the forest-concepts and progress Heidi Dungey, Dave Pont, Jonathan Dash, Mike Watt, Toby Stovold,

Phenotyping trees – in the forest

Page 6: Phenotyping the forest-concepts and progress · PDF file07.05.2016 · Phenotyping the forest-concepts and progress Heidi Dungey, Dave Pont, Jonathan Dash, Mike Watt, Toby Stovold,
Page 7: Phenotyping the forest-concepts and progress · PDF file07.05.2016 · Phenotyping the forest-concepts and progress Heidi Dungey, Dave Pont, Jonathan Dash, Mike Watt, Toby Stovold,
Page 8: Phenotyping the forest-concepts and progress · PDF file07.05.2016 · Phenotyping the forest-concepts and progress Heidi Dungey, Dave Pont, Jonathan Dash, Mike Watt, Toby Stovold,
Page 9: Phenotyping the forest-concepts and progress · PDF file07.05.2016 · Phenotyping the forest-concepts and progress Heidi Dungey, Dave Pont, Jonathan Dash, Mike Watt, Toby Stovold,
Page 10: Phenotyping the forest-concepts and progress · PDF file07.05.2016 · Phenotyping the forest-concepts and progress Heidi Dungey, Dave Pont, Jonathan Dash, Mike Watt, Toby Stovold,
Page 11: Phenotyping the forest-concepts and progress · PDF file07.05.2016 · Phenotyping the forest-concepts and progress Heidi Dungey, Dave Pont, Jonathan Dash, Mike Watt, Toby Stovold,
Page 12: Phenotyping the forest-concepts and progress · PDF file07.05.2016 · Phenotyping the forest-concepts and progress Heidi Dungey, Dave Pont, Jonathan Dash, Mike Watt, Toby Stovold,
Page 13: Phenotyping the forest-concepts and progress · PDF file07.05.2016 · Phenotyping the forest-concepts and progress Heidi Dungey, Dave Pont, Jonathan Dash, Mike Watt, Toby Stovold,

?

Page 14: Phenotyping the forest-concepts and progress · PDF file07.05.2016 · Phenotyping the forest-concepts and progress Heidi Dungey, Dave Pont, Jonathan Dash, Mike Watt, Toby Stovold,
Page 15: Phenotyping the forest-concepts and progress · PDF file07.05.2016 · Phenotyping the forest-concepts and progress Heidi Dungey, Dave Pont, Jonathan Dash, Mike Watt, Toby Stovold,

Cambium 1° Xylem

Page 16: Phenotyping the forest-concepts and progress · PDF file07.05.2016 · Phenotyping the forest-concepts and progress Heidi Dungey, Dave Pont, Jonathan Dash, Mike Watt, Toby Stovold,

Who’s your Daddy?

Page 17: Phenotyping the forest-concepts and progress · PDF file07.05.2016 · Phenotyping the forest-concepts and progress Heidi Dungey, Dave Pont, Jonathan Dash, Mike Watt, Toby Stovold,

Pedigree Reconstruction1. Progeny Trial 2. Parental Seed Orchard Trees

1 2 3 4 5 6

3. Select Best Progeny

6. Selected Breeding with 4. DNA Fingerprint generated

4. DNA Fingerprint generated

7. Improved Progeny

4 5

Page 18: Phenotyping the forest-concepts and progress · PDF file07.05.2016 · Phenotyping the forest-concepts and progress Heidi Dungey, Dave Pont, Jonathan Dash, Mike Watt, Toby Stovold,

875 -345

850-055

$

Page 19: Phenotyping the forest-concepts and progress · PDF file07.05.2016 · Phenotyping the forest-concepts and progress Heidi Dungey, Dave Pont, Jonathan Dash, Mike Watt, Toby Stovold,

What can we do?

• We can use the platform to identify outstanding families, trees and clones

• Adding coupe-level genetic information will allow us to models for optimal deployment

Page 20: Phenotyping the forest-concepts and progress · PDF file07.05.2016 · Phenotyping the forest-concepts and progress Heidi Dungey, Dave Pont, Jonathan Dash, Mike Watt, Toby Stovold,

GF+ 26

Clone x

GF+ 19

Page 21: Phenotyping the forest-concepts and progress · PDF file07.05.2016 · Phenotyping the forest-concepts and progress Heidi Dungey, Dave Pont, Jonathan Dash, Mike Watt, Toby Stovold,

Nursery picture

Page 22: Phenotyping the forest-concepts and progress · PDF file07.05.2016 · Phenotyping the forest-concepts and progress Heidi Dungey, Dave Pont, Jonathan Dash, Mike Watt, Toby Stovold,

Where are we up to?

Page 23: Phenotyping the forest-concepts and progress · PDF file07.05.2016 · Phenotyping the forest-concepts and progress Heidi Dungey, Dave Pont, Jonathan Dash, Mike Watt, Toby Stovold,

LAI and forest health/nutrition

Page 24: Phenotyping the forest-concepts and progress · PDF file07.05.2016 · Phenotyping the forest-concepts and progress Heidi Dungey, Dave Pont, Jonathan Dash, Mike Watt, Toby Stovold,

Tree detection over the trial

Page 25: Phenotyping the forest-concepts and progress · PDF file07.05.2016 · Phenotyping the forest-concepts and progress Heidi Dungey, Dave Pont, Jonathan Dash, Mike Watt, Toby Stovold,

Single tree detection and crown metrics

Page 26: Phenotyping the forest-concepts and progress · PDF file07.05.2016 · Phenotyping the forest-concepts and progress Heidi Dungey, Dave Pont, Jonathan Dash, Mike Watt, Toby Stovold,

Correlations

Size Form Wood quality Disease

Height H

DiameterDBH

Volume V

StraightnessS

Branchiness B

MalformationM

Stiffness A

Basic density ρ

Dothistroma D38

TH 0.90 0.77 0.82 0.26 0.17 0.20 0.15 0.00 -0.49 CVF 0.72 0.82 0.84 0.22 0.15 0.16 -0.02 -0.01 -0.50 SHV 0.18 -0.16 -0.09 0.04 0.02 0.06 0.22 0.02 0.08 RU 0.01 -0.14 -0.10 0.05 0.06 0.07 0.12 0.08 0.15

Pearson's r >=0.75 >=0.50 >=0.25

Strong correlations:

H r=0.90

DBH r=0.82

V r=0.84

Page 27: Phenotyping the forest-concepts and progress · PDF file07.05.2016 · Phenotyping the forest-concepts and progress Heidi Dungey, Dave Pont, Jonathan Dash, Mike Watt, Toby Stovold,

Small changes in heritabilities were found from LiDAR-derived height and DBH

0.3

0.2

0.1

0.0

Height               DBH

AFTER

BEFORE

GROUND

Page 28: Phenotyping the forest-concepts and progress · PDF file07.05.2016 · Phenotyping the forest-concepts and progress Heidi Dungey, Dave Pont, Jonathan Dash, Mike Watt, Toby Stovold,

Ongoing Work

• Database for phenotyping platform

• Statistics and method adaptation

• Spectral: colour and multispectral cameras

• UAV as a test bed to evaluate other sensors

• UAV as a tool to carry out evaluations of trials, plots and stands (including wood properties)

• Methods to phenotype lower stem and branching

Page 29: Phenotyping the forest-concepts and progress · PDF file07.05.2016 · Phenotyping the forest-concepts and progress Heidi Dungey, Dave Pont, Jonathan Dash, Mike Watt, Toby Stovold,

Heatmap of DBH and terrain map of trial area

Page 30: Phenotyping the forest-concepts and progress · PDF file07.05.2016 · Phenotyping the forest-concepts and progress Heidi Dungey, Dave Pont, Jonathan Dash, Mike Watt, Toby Stovold,

Remote sensing and phenotyping are core elements of a multi-year forestry research programme

Scion (2014). Growing Confidence in Forestry's Future: Research Programme 2013-2019. Rotorua, New Zealand: Forest Research Institute Ltd

Page 31: Phenotyping the forest-concepts and progress · PDF file07.05.2016 · Phenotyping the forest-concepts and progress Heidi Dungey, Dave Pont, Jonathan Dash, Mike Watt, Toby Stovold,

Where we up to

GCFF Research Programme

https://gcff.nz/the‐programme/

Page 32: Phenotyping the forest-concepts and progress · PDF file07.05.2016 · Phenotyping the forest-concepts and progress Heidi Dungey, Dave Pont, Jonathan Dash, Mike Watt, Toby Stovold,

Where we up to

2015First estimate of utility of phenotyping platform for genetics trials And tree breeding

Page 33: Phenotyping the forest-concepts and progress · PDF file07.05.2016 · Phenotyping the forest-concepts and progress Heidi Dungey, Dave Pont, Jonathan Dash, Mike Watt, Toby Stovold,

Where we up to

2016‐2018Utility of phenotyping platform to assess trees that have better disease resistance has been examined and unique individuals selected

Page 34: Phenotyping the forest-concepts and progress · PDF file07.05.2016 · Phenotyping the forest-concepts and progress Heidi Dungey, Dave Pont, Jonathan Dash, Mike Watt, Toby Stovold,

Where we up to

2016‐2018Phenotyping platform has been used to better understand the drivers of growth and quality in radiata pine

Page 35: Phenotyping the forest-concepts and progress · PDF file07.05.2016 · Phenotyping the forest-concepts and progress Heidi Dungey, Dave Pont, Jonathan Dash, Mike Watt, Toby Stovold,

Outputs

International conferences• Pont, D., H., Watt, M.S., Morgenroth, J., & Dungey, H. S. (2016) Correlating tree size and quality with crown metrics from airborne

laser scanning. WoodQC, Quebec, Canada, 12-17 June.• Pont, D. (2016). The use of LiDAR for Phenotyping Trees. Keynote paper at the international conference: Forest Genetics for

Productivity, the next generation, Rotorua, New Zealand, 14-18 March.• Telfer, E J, Pont, D, Dash, J, Dungey, H S, & Moore, J R. (2015) Whole forest modelling: Reconstructing the past, present and

future performance of trees with big data. Paper presented at Queenstown Research Week, QMB Computational Genomics Satellite meeting. Queenstown, New Zealand, 3-4 September.

• Pont, D., Morgenroth, J., & Watt, M.S. (2013). Tree-based analysis of ALS to estimate tree size and quality. In, MeMoWood -Measurement Methods and Modelling Approaches for Predicting Desirable Future Wood Properties. Nancy, France, 1-4 October.

• Dungey, H., S, Pont, D., Li, Y., Wilcox, P., L, Telfer, E., J, Watt, M., S, Jefferson, P., A. (2013). Novel remote sensing phenotyping platform and genomic selection will boost the delivery of genetic gain of radiata pine in New Zealand. In, Forest Genetics 2013.Whistler, British Columbia, Canada, 22-25 July.

National conferences• Pont, D., Dungey, H., Watt, M.S., & Morgenroth, J. (2016). Phenotyping the forest: concepts and progress. Presented at the: Third

annual GCFF conference. Auckland, New Zealand, 12-13 May.• Pont, D., Watt, M.S., Morgenroth, J., Dungey, H., & Stovold, G.. (2016). Individual tree phenotyping. Presented to the:

Phenotyping Innovation Cluster meeting, Auckland, New Zealand, 11 May.• Pont, D., Watt, M.S., Morgenroth, J., Dungey, H., & Stovold, G. (2015). Phenotyping from remote sensing. Presented to the

Radiata Pine Breeding Company, Rotorua, New Zealand, 21 May.• Pont, D., Dungey, H., Watt, M.S., Morgenroth, J., & Stovold, G. (2015). Can we remotely sense phenotypic information from

genetics trials? Presented at the: Second Annual Conference of the GCFF research programme - “First glimpse at results”, Christchurch, New Zealand, 24-25 March.

• Pont, D., Watt. M.S., Dash, J., & Brownlie, R. (2014). Remote Sensing for Phenotyping. Presented to the: Forest Owners Association, Forest Growing Research Conference “More income, less risk”, Rotorua, New Zealand, 29-31 October.

Page 36: Phenotyping the forest-concepts and progress · PDF file07.05.2016 · Phenotyping the forest-concepts and progress Heidi Dungey, Dave Pont, Jonathan Dash, Mike Watt, Toby Stovold,

Dissemination of research

PublicationsYongjun Li, Mari Suontama, Rowland Burdon, Heidi Dungey. Towards targeted deployment for capturing genetic gain with genotype by environment interaction in the forest estate: perspectives on research and application. Submitted to Trees Genetics and Genomes.

Two papers underway.

Technical reports• Pont, D., Watt, M.S., Morgenroth, J., Dungey, H., Brownlie, R.K., & Stovold, G. (2015). Locating individual

trees within a forest genetics trial. (GCFF TN-06). Rotorua, New Zealand; Growing Confidence in Forestry’s Future.

Page 37: Phenotyping the forest-concepts and progress · PDF file07.05.2016 · Phenotyping the forest-concepts and progress Heidi Dungey, Dave Pont, Jonathan Dash, Mike Watt, Toby Stovold,

http://research.nzfoa.org.nz/www.scionresearch.com/gcff

Heidi Dungey, David Pont, Jonathan Dash, Mike Watt, Emily Telfer

[email protected]

Date: March 2016