Petition for Writ of Certiorari SCOTUS - Can you rely on your brokerage statements?

8/3/2019 Petition for Writ of Certiorari SCOTUS - Can you rely on your brokerage statements?

http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/petition-for-writ-of-certiorari-scotus-can-you-rely-on-your-brokerage-statements 1/24

On/ 44!

EO XFI

Pyzriai @nyrx ng xfi Yoexih Pxdxip

NO ZIXEXENO GNR D [REX NG @IRXENRDRE XN XFI

YOEXIH PXDXIP @NYRX NG DZZIDCP GNR XFI PI@NOH @ER@YEX

XFIRIPD RNPI RUDO# ix/ dc/#

Zixexenoirp#

w/

ERWEOK F/ ZE@DRH# dp xrypxii gnr xfi cetyehdxenozrnìiheok ng Birodrh C/ Adhngg Eowipxaiox

Pi`yrexeip CC@ DOH PI@YREXEIP EOWIPXNRZRNXI@XENO @NRZNRDXENO#

Ripznohioxp/

ZIXEXENO GNR D [REX NG @IRXENRDRE

28:0:0

FICIO H DWEP @FDEXADO

@nyopic ng Ri`nrhBI@MIR ' ZNCEDMNGG CCZ89 Brndh{duOi{ Unrm# OU 4:::7&242% 955!0022F@fdexadoJ

bi`mir!zncedmngg/`na

Dxxnroiup gnr Zixexenoir Xfiripd Rnpi Rudo dohdcc Zixexenoirp Cepxih eo

Dzziohev G &d%

@ DRNCI OIWECCI

POR HIOXNO YP CCZ4224 Dwioyi ng xfi Daire`dpOi{ Unrm# OU 4::2:&242% ;76!7;::

Dxxnroiup gnr Zixexenoirp Cepxih eo Dzziohev G &b%

A DXXFI[ L/ KNCH

H DWEH Z DRMIR

MCIEOBIRK M DZCDO

[ NCGG @NFIO

994 Gegxf DwioyiOi{ Unrm# OU 4:4;7&242% 567!7:::

Dxxnroiup gnr Zixexenoirp Cepxih eo Dzziohev G &`%



e

TYIPXENO ZRIPIOXIH GNR RIWEI[

Heh xfi @nyrx ng Dzzidcp gnr xfi Pi`noh @er`yex irreo fncheok xfdx d xrypxii dzzneoxih yohir xfi Pi`yrexeipEowipxnr Zrnxi`xeno D`x &–PEZD‑% gnr xfi cetyehdxeno ng dbrnmir fdp yoceaexih hep`rixeno xn hiou PEZ@ eopyrdoìxn pi`yrexeip `ypxnairp bu hiffloeok –oix ityexu‑ &e/i/ d`ypxnair―p `cdea% eo heggiriox {dup hizioheok yzno xfizdrxe`ycdr èr`yapxdoìp ng xfi `dpi hipzexi

&d% PEZD―p `cidr doh yodabekynyp hiffloexeno ng –oixityexu=‑

&b% PEZD―p zrnfebexeno ng xfi Pi`yrexeip EowipxnrZrnxi`xeno @nrznrdxeno &–PEZ@‑% `fdokeok xfi hiffloexenong –oix ityexu=‑ doh

& %̀ xfi dbpioì eo PEZD ng dou hicikdxeno ng hep`rixenoxn d PEZD xrypxii xn ̀ fdoki xfi hiffloexeno ng –oix ityexu/‑



ee

ZDRXEIP XN ZRN@IIHEOK BICN[

Xfi gnccn{eok eohewehydcp doh ioxexeip dri zdrxeipeo xfi `nyrx bicn{ dp rifli`xih no xfi @nyrx ng Dzzidcp―ici`xrnoe` fflceok hn`mix< Erweok F/ Ze`drh Xrypxii ng Birodrh C/ Adhngg Eowipxaiox Pi`yrexeip CC@ &xfi–Xrypxii‑% Pi`yrexeip doh Iv`fdoki @naaeppenoPi`yrexeip Eowipxnr Zrnxi`xeno @nrznrdxeno PxirceokItyexeip Dppnèdxip Drxfyr Pehoiu Greihado Hdweh

Mdx| Kriknru Mdx| Ae`fdic Mdx| Pdyc Mdx| C/ XfnadpNpxirado Adrweo Xizzir Grih [eczno Ligg [ecznoRe`fdrh [eczno Aixp Ceaexih Zdrxoirpfez XfiripdRnpi Rudo Hedoi Zipmeo Rnkir Zipmeo Adyriio IbicAe`fdic Izpxieo Lndo Izpxieo Hnodch D/ BioldaeoHdweh [eokdxi Pdohrd Bypic Riwn`dbci Xrypx AdrxeoCegxno Rnbirx G/ Girbir Dradoh Ceohiobdya Ceohd

[dchado Aemi Pxieo Onrado Gieobirk PnohrdGieobirk Rnodch Kioi [nfc @rihex Pficxir XrypxXfnadp D/ Pfirado Bdrbdrd Wnkic Rnbirx L/ WnkicFn{drh Eprdic Odoù Gichado Hdweh Kcnhpxieo Pypdo

Kcnhpxieo Brdh I/ Dwirkno @uoxfed B/ Dwirkno RnooeiPyi Dabrnpeon Krnpp Dppnèdxip Pdognrh Fdr{nnhPxizfio Ifrce`f Cipcei Ifrce`f Hdrd Onrado PeanopFdoodf Z/ Onrado Riwn`dbci Xrypx Zdyc Dccio DccioGdaecu Xrypx @uoxfed Driopno Xih Driopno Ld`tyiceoi

Dwirkno Rnbirx Dwirkno [ecceda E/ Bdhir Birmn{ex|!Bcdy Gnyohdxeno Eo`/ Anrriu Birmn{ex| Rn| BippicFiau Bippic Ae`fdic Breccdoxi Dood @nfo RyppiccHypim Pdbrd doh Adrweo Iokcibdrhx Rixeriaiox Zcdo

Dcdo Iokcepf Rexd Iokcepf Adrm Gichado CinodrhGnrripx Riwn`dbci Xrypx Bdrbdrd Kdbd Re`fdrh Kdbd

Pnc Kdoip Myox|ado Gdaecu CC@ @drcd KeopbyrkPehoiu Kcnhpxieo Icdeoi Kcnhpxieo Cipcei KnchpaexfPypdo Kriir [HK Dppnèdxip Eo`/ Rixeriaiox Xrypx



eee

Rnbirx Fdcen Ipxicci Fdrh{nnh Gdaecu CZ PdognrhFdr{nnh Gdaecu CZ Xnbu Fdr{nnh Dooixxi LyokriepXrypx Erweok Lyokriep Xrypx Pdyceyp Mdlnxd @drncMdaiopxieo Pcndo Mdaiopxieo Xrdù MdaiopxieoMio Mnfc Aurod Mnfc Aeccir Zdrxoirpfez Aeccir XrypxZdrxoirpfez Aepfmeo Gdaecu Xrypx Krdì Aepfmeo

[ecceda Aepfmeo @drnc Oicpno Pxdociu Oicpno AdrxeoR/ Fdroe`m Pxiwio Onrxno Zriggir Gdaecu Xrypx RidcxuOiknxedxnrp Eo`/ Hiffloih Bioifflx Zcdo Adrweo Zcdxiep

Rnbirxd Zcdxiep Dcdo Rnpioxfdc Ceohd RnpioxfdcFicio Pdrio!Cd{rioì Icdeoi P`fdggir Riwn`dbciXrypx Icdeoi Ryxf P`fdggir Dceì P`feohcir LiggriuPfdomado Firbirx Pecwird Pferciu Pxnoi KyoxfirYogcdx @drcd P|uadopme Riwn`dbci Xrypx [fexadoZdrxoirpfez [nfc Kinrki Zdrxoirp CZ Rnbirx UdggiXredokci Zrnzirxeip #05 R/R/ Rnpioxfdc DppnèdxipAe`fdic P`fyr Ihexf D/ P`fyr Cd{rioì Iceop AdcebyXrdheok doh Eowipxeok C/Z/ Adru Dcbdoipi Xfi Brn{oGdaecu Zdrxoirpfez Dccio Knchpxieo Cdyrioì MduiRnpi Cipp Knrhno Biooixx Xfi Dpzio @nazdou Doo

Hiowir Onrxno Iepiobirk Ivznrx Xi`foeèdop Eo`/Pxizfio R/ Knchiobirk Lyhexf Rn`m Knchado Dcbirx L/Knchpxieo Y.[ GBN Ryxf I/ Knchpxieo Lirru Kybirado

Doexd Mdreaedo Ae`fdic Adxfedp Pxdìu AdxfedpAdrxeo Rdzzdznrx Zdyc L/ Rnbeopno Birodrh PichnoFdrnch D/ Xfdy Firbirx Bdrbdoic Dceì Bdrbdoic @drcL/ Pfdzern Dohri{ Ldggi Xrypx Y.H.X HXH 9.42.;9 Dp

Daiohih Dzziccdox Dohri{ O/ Ldggi 4550 Erriw/ XrypxY.H.X HXH 7.44.50 Dp Daiohih Dzziccdox @drc PfdzernXrypx Y.H.X 8.5.:0 @drc Pfdzern doh Ryxf PfdzernGdaecu Gnyohdxeno Iccio Ldggi Xrypx Y.H.X HXH 9.6.:0

Dp Daiohih Dzziccdox Ldggi Gdaecu 2::8 Erriwn`dbciXrypx Ldggi K@!4 CC@ Liooegir Pikdc Firado XrypxY.H.X HXH 9.4.7; Dp Daiohih Dzziccdox Liooegir Pikdc



ew

Firado 4569 Xrypx Hdxih 8.47.68 Dp Daiohih DzziccdoxLnodxfdo A/ Pikdc 2::; Xrypx Meabircu Pxrdypp 4566Xrypx Meabircu Pxrdypp 2::7 Erriwn`dbci Xrypx C/Pfdzern Gdaecu Xrypx Ceohd Pfdzern Gdaecu Xrypx Hdxih42.:0.;7 Ceohd Pfdzern [deoxryz 4552 Xrypx CP[ 2::7Erriwn`dbci Xrypx Ae`fdic P/ Ldggi Xrypx Y.H.X 5.29.;4

Dp Daiohih Dzziccdox Ae`fdic Ldggi 4565 Xrypx Y.H.XHXH 6.28.65 Dp Daiohih Dzziccdox Ae`fdic P/ Ldggi 2::;Xrypx Rfnohd Pfdzern \eooir 4550 Xrypx Y.H.X HXH

;.;.50 Dp Daiohih Dzziccdox RP\!LPF ZdrxoirpfezRyxf Pfdzern Xrypx Y.H.X 8.5.:0 Pdadoxfd Pxrdypp4569 Xrypx Pdadoxfd C/ Pxrdypp 2::0 Erriwn`dbci XrypxPfdzern Gdaecu @CDX Lneox Wioxyri Pfdzern Gdaecu Cxh/Zdrxoirpfez Pfdzern KK@!4 CC@ Pxiwio @/ Ldggi XrypxY.H.X HXH 5.29.;4 Dp Daiohih Dzziccdox Pxiwio Ldggi4565 Xrypx Y.H.X HXH 6.28.65 Dp Daiohih DzziccdoxPxiwio @/ Ldggi 2::; Xrypx Ae`fdic Adoo Airuc AdooBdrru [iepgich Adrpfd Zipfmeo ERD Iccio K/ We`xnr eofir `dzdèxu dp fnchir ng Birodrh C/ Adhngg EowipxaioxPi`yrexeip CC@ D``nyoxp 4!\D426!0 doh 4!\D426!8

Hnodch K/ Ruooi Liggriu D/ Birado Ryppicc hiCyèdOnradc E/ Cippir Riw/ 44.5; Riw/ Xrypx Zdycd I/ Cippir44.5; Riw/ Xrypx Cd{rioì R/ Wicwic Cii Aiccep LidoZnairdox| doh Bnooei Pdwexx/

Xfep cepx eo`cyhip dcc Zixexenoirp &pix gnrxf eo DzziohevG% dp {icc dp dcc dzziccdoxp {fn fdwi onx lneoih eo xfepZixexeno doh {fn dri bieok pirwih dp Ripznohioxp firieo/



w

RYCI 25/7 PXDXIAIOX

Onoi ng xfi `nrznrdxi Zixexenoirp fdp d zdriox`nrznrdxeno doh on zybce`cu fich `nazdou n{op 4:) nranri ng dou `nrznrdxi Zixexenoir―p pxn`m/



we

XDBCI NG @NOXIOXP

Zdki

TYIPXENO ZRIPIOXIH GNR RIWEI[ / / / / / e

ZDRXEIP XN ZRN@IIHEOK BICN[ / / / / / / / / / ee

RYCI 25/7 PXDXIAIOX / / / / / / / / / / / / / / / / / / / / w

XDBCI NG @NOXIOXP / / / / / / / / / / / / / / / / / / / / / we

XDBCI NG DZZIOHE@IP / / / / / / / / / / / / / / / / / / / wee

XDBCI NG @EXIH DYXFNREXEIP / / / / / / / / / / / weee

NZEOENOP BICN[/ / / / / / / / / / / / / / / / / / / / / / / / / / 4

LYREPHE@XENO / / / / / / / / / / / / / / / / / / / / / / / / / / / / / 4

PXDXYXNRU ZRNWEPENOP EOWNCWIH / / / / / / / 2

PXDXIAIOX NG XFI @DPI / / / / / / / / / / / / / / / / 0

D/ Odxyri ng xfi @dpi / / / / / / / / / / / / / / / / / / / / / 9

B/ Zrnìiheokp Bicn{ / / / / / / / / / / / / / / / / / / / / / 7

4/ Xfi Bdomryzxù @nyrx―p Hièpeno/ / / / / ;

2/ Xfi @nyrx ng Dzzidcp― Hièpeno / / / / / / 6

RIDPNOP XN KRDOX XFI ZIXEXENO / / / / / / / 5

@NO@CYPENO / / / / / / / / / / / / / / / / / / / / / / / / / / / / / / 42



wee

XDBCI NG DZZIOHE@IP

Zdki

DZZIOHEV D ‘ NZEOENO NG XFI YOEXIHPXDXIP @NYRX NG DZZIDCP GNRXFI PI@NOH @ER@YEX HI@EHIH

DYKYPX 47 2:44 / / / / / / / / / / / / / / / / / / / / / / / / / / 4d

DZZIOHEV B ‘ @IRXEGE@DXENO NG

OIX ITYEXU NRHIR NG XFI YOEXIHP X D X I P B D O M R Y Z X @ U @ N Y R X PNYXFIRO HEPXRE@X NG OI[ UNRMHDXIH ADR@F 6 2:4:/ / / / / / / / / / / / / / / / / / / / 26d

DZZIOHEV @ ‘ NRHIR NG XFI YOEXIHP X D X I P B D O M R Y Z X @ U @ N Y R X PNYXFIRO HEPXRE@X NG OI[ UNRMHDXIH ADR@F 6 2:4:/ / / / / / / / / / / / / / / / / / / / 07d

DZZIOHEV H ‘ AIANRDOHYA HI@EPENO

EO XFI YOEXIH PXDXIP BDOMRYZX@U @NYRX GNR XFI PNYXFIRO HEPXRE@XNG OI[ UNRM HI@EHIH ADR@F 4 2:4: / / 84d

DZZIOHEV I ‘ NR HIR HIOUEOKZIXEXENO GNR ZDOIC RIFIDREOK

DOH RIFIDREOK IO BDO@ NG XFIYOEXIH PXDXIP @NYRX NG DZZIDCPGNR XFI PI@NOH @ER@YEX HDXIHONWIABIR 6 2:44 / / / / / / / / / / / / / / / / / / / / / / / 66d

DZZIOHEV G ‘ DHHEXENODC ZIXEXENOIRP/ / / / / / / / / / / / / / / / / / / / / / / / / / / / / / / / / / / / / / / / / / 5:d



weee

XDBCI NG @EXIH DYXFNREXEIP

Zdki

@DPIP

@cdrm w/ Adrxeoi|#980 Y/P/ 0;4 &2::9% / / / / / / / / / / / / / / / / / / / / / / / / / 4:

@noo/ Odx―c Bdom w/ Kiradeo#

9:0 Y/P/ 285 &4552% / / / / / / / / / / / / / / / / / / / / / / / / / 5

Kriioiru Rifdb Krnyz# Eo`/ w/ Fdaano#49: G/0h 227 &2h @er/ 4556% / / / / / / / / / / / / / / / / / / / 4:

Eo ri Birodrh C/ Adhngg Eowipxaiox Pi`yrexeip# CC@#

798 G/ 0h 225 &2h @er/ 2:44% / / / / / / / / / / / / / / / / zdppea

Eo ri Birodrh C/ Adhngg Eowipxaiox Pi`yrexeip# CC@#

828 B/ R/ 422 &Bdomr/ P/H/O/U/ 2:4:% / / / / / / / / / 4 ; 6

Eo ri Oi{ Xeaip Pirweìp# Eo`/#0;4 G/0h 76 &2h @er/ 2::0%/ / / / / / / / / / / / / / / / / / / / 4:

Madrx @nrz/ w/ @drxeir# Eo`/#867 Y/P/ 264 &4566% / / / / / / / / / / / / / / / / / / / / / / / / / 5

Pi`yrexeip doh Iv`fdoki @naaeppeno w/ Dcdo G/ Fykfip# Eo`/#874 G/2h 5;8 &2h @er/ 45;2% / / / / / / / / / / / / / / / / / / / 4:



ev

@exih Dyxfnrexeip

Zdki

Pi`yrexeip Iv`fdoki @naaeppeno w/ Birodrh C/ Adhngg Eowipxaiox Pi`yrexeip CC@ ix dc/#On/ :6 @W 4:;54 / / / / / / / / / / / / / / / / / / / / / / / / / / / 7

PEZ@ w/ Bdrbnyr#824 Y/P/ 842 &45;9% / / / / / / / / / / / / / / / / / / / / / / / / / 4:

Xucir w/ Hnykcdp#26: G/0h 447 &2h @er/ 2::4% / / / / / / / / / / / / / / / / / / / 4:

Yoexih Pxdxip w/ Pdoxnp#990 Y/P/ 9:; &2::6% / / / / / / / / / / / / / / / / / / / / / / / / / 4:

PXDXYXIP DOH RYCIP

49 Y/P/@/ « ;6```&b%&8%&D% / / / / / / / / / / / / / / / / / / / / / / 0 9

49 Y/P/@/ « ;6iii&d%&0%/ / / / / / / / / / / / / / / / / / / / / / / / / 7

49 Y/P/@/ « ;6iii&d%&8%&D% / / / / / / / / / / / / / / / / / / / / / / 7

49 Y/P/@/ « ;6iii&b%&8% / / / / / / / / / / / / / / / / / / / / / / / / 7

49 Y/P/@/ « ;6iii&b%&9%&@%/ / / / / / / / / / / / / / / / / / / / / / 9

49 Y/P/@/ « ;6ggg&d%&4%/ / / / / / / / / / / / / / / / / / / / / / / / / / 9

49 Y/P/@/ « ;6ggg!0&d% / / / / / / / / / / / / / / / / / / / / / / / / / / 9

49 Y/P/@/ « ;6ccc&44% / / / / / / / / / / / / / / / / / / / / / / / / / 2 9 44



v

@exih Dyxfnrexeip

Zdki

26 Y/P/@/ « 496&d%&4% / / / / / / / / / / / / / / / / / / / / / / / / / / 2

26 Y/P/@/ « 496&h%&2% / / / / / / / / / / / / / / / / / / / / / / / / / / 2 6

26 Y/P/@/ « 496&h%&2%&D%&e%/ / / / / / / / / / / / / / / / / / / / / / 6

26 Y/P/@/ « 4298&4%/ / / / / / / / / / / / / / / / / / / / / / / / / / / / 4

PEZ@―p Pireip 9:: Rycip 4; @/G/R/ « 0::/9:2 / / / / / 4:

NXFIR DYXFNREXU

F/R/ RIZ/ 59!;87 dx 24 &45;;% / / / / / / / / / / / / / / / / / / / 44

Re`fdrh Oevno< – Pxdxiaiox no Pekoeok xfi Pi`yrexeip Eowipxnr Zrnxi`xeno D`x ng 45;:#‑ XFI D AIRE@DO ZRIPEHIO@U ZRNLI@X &Hi`/ 0: 45;:%

fxxz<..{{{/zripehioù/y`pb/ihy.{p.> Zeh 126;:/ / / / / / / / / / / / / / / / / / / / / / / / / / / / / / / / / / / / / / / / / / 8



4

Zixexenoirp ripzi`xgyccu zixexeno gnr d {rex ng ìrxenrdrexn riwei{ xfi nrhir ng xfi Yoexih Pxdxip @nyrx ng Dzzidcpgnr xfi Pi`noh @er`yex &xfi –@nyrx ng Dzzidcp‑% eo xfep`dpi/

NZEOENOP BICN[

Xfi nrhir ng xfi @nyrx ng Dzzidcp hioueok rifidreokdoh rifidreok io bdo` ep onx riznrxih/ &Dzz/ I 66d%/

Xfi nzeoeno ng xfi @nyrx ng Dzzidcp ep riznrxih dx Eo ri Birodrh C/ Adhngg Eowipxaiox Pi`yrexeip# CC@ &– Eo ri Adhngg Pi`yrexeip‑ % 798 G/ 0h 225 &2h @er/ 2:44%/ &Dzz/ D4d%/ Xfi nzeoeno ng xfi Bdomryzxù @nyrx gnr xfi PnyxfiroHepxre`x ng Oi{ Unrm &xfi –Bdomryzxù @nyrx‑% ep riznrxihdx Eo ri Adhngg Pi`yrexeip 828 B/ R/ 422 &Bdomr/ P/H/O/U/2:4:%/ &Dzz/ H 84d%/

LYREPHE@XENO

Xfep @nyrx fdp lyrephe`xeno yohir 26 Y/P/@/ «4298&4%/

Xfi @nyrx ng Dzzidcp ioxirih lyhkaiox no Dykypx47 2:44 zyrpydox xn do Dykypx 47 2:44 nrhir/ &Dzz/ D4d%/ Zixexenoirp xeaicu fflcih d anxeno gnr rifidreok nrrifidreok io bdo` {fe`f {dp hioeih no Onwiabir 62:44/ &Dzz/ I 66d%/

Xfi fflodc nrhir ng xfi @nyrx ng Dzzidcp dg fflraih d fflodcnrhir ng xfi Bdomryzxù @nyrx &Dzz/ @ 07d% xfdx eoxir dced dg fflraih d hixiraeodxeno xfdx Zixexenoirp― rekfx xnPEZ@ eopyrdoì {dp hixiraeoih bu xfier oix eowipxaiox

&hiznpexp cipp {exfhrd{dcp% nwir xfi cegi ng xfier d``nyoxp‐ eo pnai eopxdoìp kneok bd`m 8: uidrp/ &Dzz/ @ 05d%/Xfi nrhir ng xfi Bdomryzxù @nyrx rièxih xfdx ex {dp



2

–d fflodc nrhir‑ zyrpydox xn 26 Y/P/@/ «496&d%&4%/ &Dzz/ @05d%/ Xfi Bdomryzxù @nyrx ìrxefflih xfdx do eaaihedxidzzidc zyrpydox xn 26 Y/P/@/ « 496&h%&2% {dp dzzrnzredxibi`dypi –xfep zrnìiheok eowncwip d adxxir ng zybceèaznrxdoì doh do eaaihedxi dzzidc adu adxiredccudhwdoì xfi zrnkripp ng xfep zrnìiheok/‑ &Dzz/ B 0:d%/Xfi @nyrx ng Dzzidcp dcpn ìrxefflih xfdx xfi Bdomryzxù@nyrx―p nrhir aix xfi ̀ rexired ng 26 Y/P/@/ « 496&h%&2%&D%&e%{fe`f ziraexp heri`x dzzidc ng d fflodc hièpeno nr nrhir ng

d bdomryzxù ̀ nyrx {firi xfi nrhir –eowncwip d tyipxeno ng cd{ dp xn {fe`f xfiri ep on ̀ noxrncceok hièpeno ng xfi ̀ nyrxng dzzidcp gnr xfi èr`yex nr ng xfi Pyzriai @nyrx ng xfiYoexih Pxdxip nr eowncwip d adxxir ng zybce` eaznrxdoì/‑

PXDXYXNRU ZRNWEPENOP EOWNCWIH

49 Y/P/@/ « ;6 ccc&44% zrnwehip eo riciwdox zdrx<

&44% OIX ITYEXU/ ‐ Xfi xira –oix ityexu‑ aidopxfi hnccdr danyox ng xfi d``nyox nr d``nyoxp ng d

`ypxnair xn bi hixiraeoih bu ‐

&D% `dc`ycdxeok xfi pya {fe`f {nych fdwi biion{ih bu xfi hibxnr xn py`f `ypxnair eg xfihibxnr fdh cetyehdxih bu pdci nr zyr`fdpino xfi fflceok hdxi‘

&e% dcc pi`yrexeip znpexenop ng py`f`ypxnair‧= aeoyp

&B% dou eohibxihoipp ng py`f `ypxnair xn xfi

hibxnr no xfi fflceok hdxi]/Q



0

49 Y/P/@/ « ;6```&b%&8%&D% zrnwehip eo riciwdox zdrx<

&b% ZN[IRP

Eo dhhexeno xn xfi zn{irp krdoxih xn PEZ@ icpi{firieo xfep `fdzxir PEZ@ pfdcc fdwi xfi zn{ir ‐

, , , ,

&8% xn dhnzx daioh doh rizidc bu exp Bndrh ng Heri`xnrp py`f rycip dp adu bi oiìppdrunr dzzrnzredxi xn ̀ drru nyx xfi zyrznpip ng xfep `fdzxir eo`cyheok rycip ricdxeok xn !!!

&D% xfi hiffloexeno ng xirap ypih eo xfep`fdzxir nxfir xfdo xfnpi xirapgnr {fe`f d hiffloexeno ep zrnwehiheo pi`xeno ;6ccc ng xfep xexci]/Q

PXDXIAIOX NG XFI @DPI

@nokripp ipxdbcepfih eo PEZD d zirwdpewi pxdxyxnrup`fiai gnr xfi cetyehdxeno ng d brnmirdki fflra rikycdxihbu xfi Pi`yrexeip doh Iv`fdoki @naaeppeno &xfi–PI@‑% {exf xfi zyrznpi ng zrnweheok PEZ@ eopyrdoìxn `ypxnairp ng d gdecih brnmir doh xfiribu eopxecceok`nofflhioì eo xfi `dzexdc adrmixp/ No Hiìabir 0: 45;:

{fio Zripehiox Oevno pekoih PEZD eoxn cd{ fi adhi xfignccn{eok pxdxiaiox<

E da pekoeok xnhdu xfi Pi`yrexeip Eowipxnr

Zrnxi`xeno D`x ng 45;:/ Xfep cikepcdxenoipxdbcepfip xfi Pi`yrexeip Eowipxnr Zrnxi`xeno@nrznrdxeno &PEZ@% d zrewdxi onozrngex



8

`nrznrdxeno {fe`f {ecc eopyri xfi pi`yrexeipdoh `dpf cigx {exf brnmirdki fflrap bu eowipxnrpdkdeopx cnpp grna geodoèdc hegge`ycxeip nrgdecyri ng py`f fflrap/ / / / Lypx dp xfi GihirdcHiznpex Eopyrdoì @nrznrdxeno zrnxi`xp xfiypir ng bdomeok pirweìp grna xfi hdokir ng bdom gdecyri pn {ecc xfi Pi`yrexeip EowipxnrZrnxi`xeno @nrznrdxeno zrnxi`x xfi ypir ng eowipxaiox pirweìp/

Re`fdrh Oevno< –Pxdxiaiox no Pekoeok xfi Pi`yrexeip Eowipxnr Zrnxi`xeno D`x ng 45;:#‑ XFI D AIRE@DO ZRIPEHIO@U ZRNLI@X &Hi`/ 0: 45;:% fxxz<..{{{/zripehioù/y`pb/ihy.

{p.> Zeh 126;:/

Xfi eppyi eo xfep `dpi ep {fixfir PEZD―p gyohdaioxdczrnxi`xeno xn eowipxnrp xfrnykf PEZ@ eopyrdoì `do bidbrnkdxih bu xfi lyheèdc krdox ng yoceaexih hep`rixenoxn d PEZ@!dzzneoxih xrypxii xn hiou PEZ@ eopyrdoì bu`fdokeok xfi hiffloexeno ng –oix ityexu‑ {firi on py`f

hep`rixeno ivepxp eo xfi pxdxyxi/ Xfi @nyrx ng Dzzidcpfich xfdx PEZD―p ̀ cidr doh yodabekynyp hiffloexeno ng –oixityexu‑ –hnip onx zrip`rebi d peokci aidop‑ ng ̀ dc`ycdxeno–eo xfi auredh èr`yapxdoìp xfdx adu drepi eo d PEZD cetyehdxeno‑ doh xfdx –]hQeggireok gd`x zdxxirop {ecceoiwexdbcu `dcc gnr heggireok dzzrnd`fip xn dpìrxdeoeokxfi gderipx aixfnh gnr dzzrnveadxeok ‖oix ityexu/―‑ Eori Adhngg Pi`yrexeip 798 G/0h dx 209/ &Dzz/ D 4:!44d%/Xfi `nyrx `no`cyhih xfdx yohir –xfi ivxrdnrheodrugd`xp ng xfep `dpi‑ d `ypxnair―p –oix ityexu‑ zrenrexu`cdea adu bi `dc`ycdxih bu –{ez]eokQ nyx dcc iwioxp ng d

`ypxnair―p eowipxaiox fepxnru ivìzx gnr `dpf hiznpexpdoh {exfhrd{dcp‑ iwio xfnykf –d `ypxnair―p cdpx d``nyoxpxdxiaiox {ecc cemicu bi xfi anpx dzzrnzredxi aidop ng



9

`dc`ycdxeok ‖oix ityexu― eo anri `nowioxenodc `dpip/‑ Eh/dx 206/ &Dzz/ D 46d%/

Xfi zrnaepi ng PEZ@ eopyrdoì {fe`f @nokrippadohdxih xn eopxecc `nofflhioì eo xfi `dzexdc adrmixpep xfyp zyricu eccypnru bi`dypi on eowipxnr `nych iwirmon{ yoxec dgxir fi pyggirp d cnpp {fixfir xfi xrypxii

{ecc hiffloi –oix ityexu‑ eo py`f d {du dp xn ioxexci fea xnPEZ@ eopyrdoì/ Anrinwir xfi PEZD pxdxyxnru p`fiai

zrnwehip xfdx d PEZ@ xrypxii―p cikdc giip dri zdeh bu PEZ@/ Pii 49 Y/P/@/ « ;6iii&b%&9%&@%/ Xfyp xfi xrypxii {fn epbifnchio xn PEZ@ gnr zduaiox ng fep cikdc giip ep kewiohep`rixeno xn hièhi {fixfir nr onx PEZ@ ep nbcekdxih xnzdu eopyrdoì xn id`f eowipxnr/ Xfi @nyrx ng Dzzidcpxfio fdp rixrnd`xewicu hipxrnuih d `ypxnair―p dbecexu xnricu yzno PEZ@ eopyrdoì gnr fep eowipxaiox dp eohe`dxihno xfi d``nyox pxdxiaioxp eppyih bu fep brnmir {fe`f eoxfep ird ng ici`xrnoe` xrdheok ep xfi nocu iwehioì doueowipxnr fdp ng {fdx fi n{op/

D/ Odxyri ng xfi @dpi

Xfep `dpi drepip nyx ng xfi PEZD cetyehdxeno ng Birodrh C/ Adhngg Eowipxaiox Pi`yrexeip CC@ &–Adhngg Pi`yrexeip‑% do PI@!rikycdxih brnmir d aiabir ng PEZ@doh d ̀ noxrebyxnr xn xfi PEZ@ gyoh xfdx @nokripp ̀ ridxih–xn zrnwehi gnr zrnazx zduaiox doh pdxepgd`xeno ng oixityexu ̀ cdeap ng ̀ ypxnairp‑ ypydccu bu rizcdèok aeppeokpi`yrexeip/ Pii 49 Y/P/@/ «« ;6ggg!0&d%= ;6ggg&d%&4%/ PEZD hiffloip –oix ityexu‑ dp xfi danyox xfi brnmir –n{ip‑ d`ypxnair gnr xfi `ypxnair―p –pi`yrexeip znpexenop‑ aeoyp

dou eohibxihoipp ng xfi `ypxnair xn xfi brnmir no xfihdxi ng xfi brnmir―p PEZD fflceok/ Pii 49 Y/P/@/ « ;6ccc&44%/PEZD zrnfebexp PEZ@ grna `fdokeok xfi hiffloexeno ng –oixityexu/‑ 49 Y/P/@/ « ;6```&b%&8%&D%/



7

Uix xfi @nyrx ng Dzzidcp fich xfdx xfi xira –oixityexu‑ fdp on –peokci‑ gevih aidoeok= rdxfir –oixityexu‑ adu bi hiffloih heggirioxcu hizioheok no xfièr`yapxdoìp/ Pii Eo ri Adhngg Pi`yrexeip 798 G/ 0h dx209/ &Dzz/ D 4:d%/ Eo xfep `dpi xfi Xrypxii `nych hiffloi–oix ityexu‑ pn dp xn hizrewi anri xfdo fdcg ng Adhngg Pi`yrexeip― `ypxnairp ng PEZ@ eopyrdoì bu ceaexeok`nwirdki xn d `ypxnair―p oix eowipxaiox nwir xfi ceging xfi d``nyox eo`cyheok xfi xrdopgirnr d``nyoxp ng xfi

`ypxnair―p zdrioxp doh krdohzdrioxp/ Xfi `ypxnair―pfflodc pxdxiaiox {dp hiiaih erriciwdox= xfi `ypxnair―pbdcdoì no {fe`f fi zdeh gihirdc eo`nai xdvip {dp hiiaiherriciwdox/

B/ Zrnìiheokp Bicn{

Xfi zrnìiheok {dp eoexedxih bu xfi PI@ {fe`ffflcih do d`xeno eo xfi Yoexih Pxdxip Hepxre`x @nyrx gnrxfi Pnyxfiro Hepxre`x ng Oi{ Unrm `dzxenoih Pi`yrexeip

Iv`fdoki @naaeppeno w/ Birodrh C/ Adhngg Eowipxaiox

Pi`yrexeip CC@ ix dc/ On/ :6 @W 4:;54/ No Hiìabir 492::6 zyrpydox xn 49 Y/P/@/ « ;6iii&d%&8%&D% xfi PI@`nopioxih xn d `nabeodxeno ng xfi d`xeno {exf do d`xenofflcih bu PEZ@ zyrpydox xn 49 Y/P/@/ « ;6iii&d%&0% eo {fe`fPEZ@ dccikih eoxir dced xfdx Adhngg Pi`yrexeip {dp onxdbci xn aiix exp nbcekdxenop xn pi`yrexeip `ypxnairp dpxfiu `dai hyi doh d``nrheokcu exp `ypxnairp oiihih xfizrnxi`xeno dggnrhih bu PEZD/ Dcpn no Hiìabir 49 2::6xfi Hepxre`x @nyrx ioxirih do nrhir {fe`f eoxir dcedrigirrih xfi `dpi xn xfi Bdomryzxù @nyrx zyrpydox xn49 Y/P/@/ « ;6iii&b%&8%/

Zyrpydox xn do nrhir ioxirih bu xfi Bdomryzxù@nyrx no Hiìabir 20 2::6 Zixexenoirp fflcih {rexxio



;

pxdxiaioxp ng ̀ cdea gnr xfi adrmix wdcyi ng xfier pi`yrexeipznpexenop dp rifli`xih no xfi cdpx d``nyox pxdxiaioxpriìewih grna Adhngg Pi`yrexeip/ Xfi Xrypxii hioeihxfi `cdeap xn xfi ivxiox xfiu ivìihih xfi Zixexenoirp―fepxnre`dc oix eowipxaiox kneok bd`m xfrnykf kioirdxenopng d``nyox fnchirp/4

Zixexenoirp fflcih xeaicu nbli`xenop xn xfi Xrypxii―phixiraeodxenop/2 No Pizxiabir 47 2::5 xfi Bdomryzxù

@nyrx ioxirih do nrhir zrnweheok gnr breifflok no xfiXrypxii―p eoxirzrixdxeno ng –oix ityexu/‑ Dcc rekfxp {iriripirwih dp xn nxfir eppyip doh xfi `ypxnairp {iripzièffl`dccu hioeih xfi rekfx xn xdmi dou hep`nwiru/0

4/ Xfi Bdomryzxù @nyrx―p Hièpeno

Xfi Bdomryzxù @nyrx eppyih exp hièpeno no Adr`f4 2:4: &Dzz/ H 84d% gnccn{ih bu do nrhir no Adr`f 62:4:/ &Dzz/ @ 07d%/ Xfi Bdomryzxù @nyrx fich xfdx xfi–oix ityexu‑ hiffloexeno adu bi –pypìzxebci xn heggireok

gnraycdxenop‑ hizioheok yzno xfi –yohircueok gd`xydchepzdrexeip‑ ng d brnmir―p grdyh/ Eo ri Adhngg Pi`yrexeip828 B/R/ dx 40;/ &Dzz/ H ;2d%/ Bi`dypi –dpxnyoheokpyap‑ {iri cnpx eo xfi brnmir―p grdyh xfi Bdomryzxù@nyrx `no`cyhih xfdx –]iQtydcexu ep d`feiwih eo xfep `dpibu iazcnueok xfi Xrypxii―p aixfnh {fe`f cnnmp pncicu xn

4/ Hi`cdrdxeno ng Ficio Hdwep @fdexado hdxih Onwiabir40 2::5 Dzziccdoxp― Lneox Dzziohev &–L/Dzz/‑% dx 979!77 &W/E%= Xrdopd`xeno Fepxnru @fdrxp dooivih xn Onxeì ng Xrypxii―pHixiraeodxeno ng @cdea L/Dzz/! 796 doh 75: &W/ EE/%/

2/ I@G Hn`mix Riznrx gnr Dhw/ Zrn/ On/ :6!:4;65 &Bdomr/P/H/O/U/% &BRC% &xfi –Hn`mix Riznrx‑% L/Dzz/!45 xn 426 &W/ E/%/

0/ Hn`mix Riznrx L/Dzz/!449 &W/ E/%/



6

hiznpexp doh {exfhrd{dcp xfdx eo ridcexu n``yrrih‑ dohxfdx fnonreok `ypxnair pxdxiaioxp –{nych eazrnzircuhepxrebyxi `ypxnair gyohp bdpih no Adhngg―p drbexrdruhipeko/‑ Eh/ dx 482/ &Dzz/ H 60d%/ Xfi Bdomryzxù @nyrxfich xfdx xfi Xrypxii―p Oix Eowipxaiox Aixfnh –ep xfianri ityexdbci doh dzzrnzredxi {du xn hixiraeoi OixItyexu/‑ Eh/ &Dzz/ H 69d%/

Xfi Bdomryzxù @nyrx ìrxegeih exp nrhir yohir

26 Y/P/@/ « 496&h%&2% dp eowncweok –d adxxir ng zybceèaznrxdoì‑ dp xn {fe`f –do eaaihedxi dzzidc aduadxiredccu dhwdoì xfi zrnkripp ng xfep zrnìiheok/‑&Dzz/ B 0:d%/

2/ Xfi @nyrx ng Dzzidcp― Hièpeno

Xfi @nyrx ng Dzzidcp dcpn ̀ irxefflih xfdx xfi Bdomryzxù@nyrx―p nrhir aix xfi ̀ rexired ng 26 Y/P/@/ « 496&h%&2%&D%&e%/Xfi @nyrx ng Dzzidcp dg fflraih xfi Bdomryzxù @nyrx―p

nrhir/ Eo ri Adhngg Pi`yrexeip 798 G/ 0h dx 282/ &Dzz/ D

2;d%/ Ex ri`nkoe|ih xfdx `ypxnairp ng Adhngg Pi`yrexeipfdwi `cdeap gnr pi`yrexeip bdpih no xfier pxdxiaioxpbyx rycih xfdx xfier –oix ityexu‑ `cdeap gnr zyrznpipng hixiraeoeok ioxexciaiox xn PEZ@ eopyrdoì dohhepxrebyxenop grna xfi gyoh ng `ypxnair zrnzirxu `nychbi `dc`ycdxih bdpih yzno xfi oix `dpf hiznpexih nwirxfi `nyrpi ng xfier ricdxenopfez {exf xfier brnmir rdxfirxfdo eo d``nrhdoì {exf PEZD―p hiffloexeno ng –oix ityexu/‑Xfi @nyrx fich xfdx exp ryceok {dp dzzrnzredxi bi`dypion pi`yrexeip {iri zyr`fdpih bu Adhngg Pi`yrexeip dohbi`dypi zduaiox bu PEZ@ nyx ng gyohp dppippih grna

exp aiabirp {nych heaeoepf xfi gyohp dwdecdbci xn nxfir`ypxnairp &d zripyaih gd`x {fe`f ep eopyzznrxdbci bdpihyzno PEZD%/ Pii Eo ri Adhngg Pi`yrexeip 798 G/ 0rh dx28:/ &Dzz/ D 24!22d%/



5

RIDPNOP XN KRDOX XFI ZIXEXENO

Xfep @nyrx pfnych krdox xfi {rex ng ̀ irxenrdre bi`dypixfi @nyrx ng Dzzidcp fdp hièhih do eaznrxdox tyipxenong gihirdc cd{ xfdx ep noi ng fflrpx eazrippeno doh xfdx fdponx biio byx pfnych bi pixxcih bu xfep @nyrx/ [exf xfipxrnmi ng exp zio doh eo hiffldoì ng xfep @nyrx―p zriìzxp ng cikepcdxewi eoxirzrixdxeno xfi @nyrx ng Dzzidcp dbrnkdxihxfi ioxeri PEZD pxdxyxnru p`fiai doh oyccefflih d gihirdc

cd{ gyohdaioxdc xn xfi py`ìppgyc nzirdxeno ng xfi ̀ dzexdcadrmixp/ @noxrdru xn xfi `cidr cdokydki ng PEZD xfi@nyrx ng Dzzidcp fdp kewio iwiru PEZ@ xrypxii xfidyxfnrexu xn hixiraeoi dgxir d cnpp xfi ivxiox &eg dx dcc%xn {fe`f PEZ@ pfdcc bi rityerih xn zrnwehi xfi zrnaepihPEZ@ eopyrdoì xn id`f eolyrih eowipxnr/ Yocipp xfep @nyrxpixxcip xfep `rexe`dc gihirdc eppyi dcc pi`yrexeip eowipxnrp

{ecc cnpi xfi `nofflhioì xfdx PEZD {dp eoxiohih xn eopxecceo xfi `dzexdc adrmixp/

On cnokir ̀ do dou pi`yrexeip ̀ ypxnair ricu yzno PEZ@

eopyrdoì bi`dypi d `ypxnair `doonx mon{ yoxec dgxir dcnpp {fixfir xfi xrypxii dzzneoxih eo fep zdrxe`ycdr ̀ dpi

{ecc `fnpi xn gnccn{ xfi PEZD hiffloexeno ng –oix ityexu‑nr hiwepi pnai nxfir gnraycdxeno ng hepxrebyxeno bdpihyzno fep n{o piopi ng –gderoipp‑ doh.nr PEZ@―p hiperi xn`nopirwi exp gyohp/

@nokripp onx xfi Pi`noh @er`yex hixiraeoip xficd{/ Doh {fio dp eo xfep ̀ dpi –xfi {nrhp ng d pxdxyxi driyodabekynyp xfio xfep fflrpx ̀ dono ep dcpn xfi cdpx< ‖lyheèdceotyeru ep `nazcixi/―‑ @noo/ Odx―c Bdom w/ Kiradeo# 9:0

Y/P/ 285 290!98 &4552% &eoxirodc èxdxenop naexxih%= pii Madrx @nrz/ w/ @drxeir# Eo`/# 867 Y/P/ 264 264 &4566% &–Eg xfi pxdxyxi ep `cidr doh yodabekynyp `nyrxp aypx kewiiggi`x xn @nokripp― yodabekynypcu ivzrippih eoxiox]/Q‑%=



4:

pii Xucir w/ Hnykcdp# 26: G/0h 447 422 &2h @er/ 2::4%&pdai%= d``nrh Kriioiru Rifdb Krnyz# Eo`/ w/ Fdaano49: G/0h 227 204 &2h @er/ 4556% &–Eg xfi pxdxyxnru xirap driyodabekynyp nyr riwei{ kioirdccu iohp doh xfi pxdxyxi ep`nopxryih d``nrheok xn xfi zcdeo aidoeok ng exp {nrhp/‑%/

@nokripp― `cidr eoxiox xn eopxecc `nofflhioì eo xfi`dzexdc adrmixp bu zrnxi`xeok d `ypxnair―p –cikexeadxiivzi`xdxenop‑ fdp biio hipxrnuih bu xfi Pi`noh @er`yex―p

hièpeno/ Pii PEZ@ w/ Bdrbnyr 824 Y/P/ 842 849 &45;9%&–@nokripp iod`xih xfi PEZD / / / xn ripxnri eowipxnr`nofflhioì eo xfi `dzexdc adrmixp / /%= Eo ri Oi{ Xeaip

Pirweìp# Eo`/ 0;4 G/0h 76 6; &2h @er/ 2::0% &PEZD epeoxiohih xn –zrnanx]iQ eowipxnr `nofflhioì eo xfi pi`yrexeipadrmixp doh zrnxi`]xQ brnmir!hidcir `ypxnairp/‑%=

Pi`yrexeip doh Iv`fdoki @naaeppeno w/ Dcdo G/ Fykfip# Eo`/ 874 G/2h 5;8 5;; &2h @er/ 45;2% &PEZD {dp iod`xihbu @nokripp eo 45;: xn dggnrh zrnxi`xeno xn pi`yrexeip–`ypxnairp eo xfi iwiox brnmir!hidcirp {exf {fnaxfiu xrdopd`x bypeoipp io`nyoxir fflodoèdc heg ffl`ycxeip

doh dri yodbci xn pdxepgu xfier nbcekdxenop/‑%= pii dcpn#PEZ@―p Pireip 9:: Rycip 4; @/G/R/ « 0::/9:2 &zrnxi`xeok`ypxnairp― –cikexeadxi ivzi`xdxenop‑%/

Xfi @nyrx ng Dzzidcp fdp dcpn wencdxih xfep @nyrx―pzriìzx xfdx keweok –xfi pdai pxdxyxnru xivx heggirioxaidoeokp eo heggiriox `dpip‑ ep d –hdokirnyp zreoèzci‑xfdx –{nych riohir ]d pxdxyxiQ d `fdaicino/‑ @cdrm w/

Adrxeoi| 980 Y/P/ 0;4 062 &2::9%= pii Yoexih Pxdxipw/ Pdoxnp 990 Y/P/ 9:; 922 &2::6% &zcyrdcexu nzeoeno%&–]XQfi aidoeok ng {nrhp eo d pxdxyxi ̀ doonx ̀ fdoki {exf

xfi pxdxyxi―p dzzce`dxeno/‑%/ Uix firi xfi @nyrx ng Dzzidcpfdp hi`riih xfdx iwiru PEZ@ xrypxii `do eowiox fep n{ohepxrebyxeno p`fiai/



44

PEZD―p –oix ityexu‑ hiffloexeno dppyrip ̀ ypxnairp xfdxxfiu `do ricu no xfi pxdxiaioxp xfiu riìewi grna xfierbrnmirp bi`dypi ex rityerip PEZ@ eopyrdoì xn bi zdehbdpih yzno xfi danyox xfi brnmir n{ip xfia dp rifli`xihno xfier cdpx pxdxiaiox/ Pii 49 Y/P/@/ « ;6ccc&44%/ Xfi @nyrxng Dzzidcp― ricedoì no xfi gd`x xfdx Adhngg Pi`yrexeipheh onx zyr`fdpi xfi pi`yrexeip rifli`xih no xfi ̀ ypxnairpxdxiaioxp `doonx lypxegu dbrnkdxeok xfi pxdxyxi/ Eohiiheo iod`xeok xfi –oix ityexu‑ hiffloexeno @nokripp `cidrcu

eoxiohih xn rizcdì `ypxnair pi`yrexeip iwio eg xfnpipi`yrexeip {iri oiwir zyr`fdpih/

D `ypxnair kioirdccu ivzi`xp xn riìewi {fdxfi biceiwip ep eo fep d``nyox dx xfi xeai xfipxn`mbrnmir ìdpip bypeoipp/ Byx bi`dypipi`yrexeip adu fdwi biio cnpx eazrnzircufuznxfi`dxih aepdzzrnzredxih# oiwirzyr`fdpih# nr iwio pxncio xfep ep onx dc{dupznppebci/ D``nrheokcu ]{fio xfep ep onx znppebci`ypxnairpQ {ecc riìewi `dpf bdpih no xfi

adrmix wdcyi dp ng xfi fflceok hdxi/

F/R/ RIZ/ 59!;87 dx 24 &45;;% &iazfdpep dhhih%/

Xfyp xfi @nyrx ng Dzzidcp hièpeno wencdxipgyohdaioxdc zriìzxp ng cikepcdxewi eoxirzrixdxeno xfi`cidr doh yodabekynyp cdokydki ng PEZD doh xfi `cidreoxiox ng @nokripp eo iod`xeok PEZD/ Xfep @nyrx―p riwei{ ng xfi @nyrx ng Dzzidcp― hièpeno ep oiìppdru xn zriwiox

lyheèdc oyccege`dxeno ng d pxdxyxi no {fe`f eowipxnrpridpnodbcu riceih/



42

@NO@CYPENO

Eo nrhir xn dwneh d lyheèdc oycceffl`dxeno ng PEZD xfiZixexenoirp ripzi`xgyccu rityipx xfdx xfep @nyrx krdoxxfier zixexeno gnr d {rex ng ìrxenrdre/

Hdxih< Oi{ Unrm Oi{ Unrm

Gibrydru 0 2:42

Ripzi`xgyccu pybaexxih

FICIO H DWEP @FDEXADO

@nyopic ng Ri`nrhBI@MIR ' ZNCEDMNGG CCZ89 Brndh{duOi{ Unrm OU 4:::7&242% 955!0022F@fdexadoJ

bi`mir!zncedmngg/`na

Dxxnroiup gnr Zdrxeip Cepxih eo Dzziohev G &d%

@ DRNCI OIWECCI

POR HIOXNO YP CCZ4224 Dwioyi ng xfi Daire`dpOi{ Unrm OU 4::2:&242% ;76!7;::

Dxxnroiup gnr Zdrxeip Cepxih eo Dzziohev G &b%



40

A DXXFI[ L/ KNCH

H DWEH Z DRMIR

MCIEOBIRK M DZCDO

[ NCGG @NFIO

994 Gegxf DwioyiOi{ Unrm OU 4:4;7&242% 567!7:::

Dxxnroiup gnr Zdrxeip Cepxih eo Dzziohev G &̀ %

Documents

Petition for Writ of Certiorari SCOTUS - Can you rely on your brokerage statements?