Upload
sonalee-parmar
View
1.472
Download
81
Embed Size (px)
Citation preview
8/19/2019 Performance Appraisal at Jindal Brothers Pvt. Ltd
1/51
8/19/2019 Performance Appraisal at Jindal Brothers Pvt. Ltd
2/51
Declaration
I hereby declare that the work presented herein is genuine work done originally by me and
has not been published or submitted elsewhere for the requirement of a degree programme.
Any literature, data or works done by others and cited within this dissertation has been given
due acknowledgement and listed in the reference section.
Signature of the candidate
(Ashutosh Pandey)
8/19/2019 Performance Appraisal at Jindal Brothers Pvt. Ltd
3/51
Acknowledgement
In the completion of this project report, I have received
encouragement and support from various quarters, which need
special mention.
I wish to acknowledge my indebtedness to Mrs. Esha athla,
Institute of Management ! "echnology, #ashipur, under whom this
work has been completed, for e$tending all possible cooperation.
I am also thankful to all those people of Institute of Management !
"echnology, who helped me directly or indirectly during this period.
ME%E A'()*E+EME'" MA- '(" %E+EEM "E +E" I
()E "( M- /A%E'"0 1(% "EI% +I%E&"2I'+I%E&" 03//(%"
+3%I' "E E'"I%E &(3%0E (1 "I0 /%(4E&".
A03"(0 /A'+E-
8/19/2019 Performance Appraisal at Jindal Brothers Pvt. Ltd
4/51
TABLE OF CONTENTS
Title
1. Chapter I
Acknowledgement
Profile of the Project uide
!"ecutive Summary
#. Chapter II
$ompany profile
Scope % &bjective
'. Chapter III
(esearch methodology
4. Chapter IV
Performance management
5. Chapter V
)ata analysis
*. Chapter VI
+indings
. Chapter VII
(ecommendations
-. Chapter VIII
imitations
/. Chapter IX
0ibliography
12. Chapter XAppendi"
8/19/2019 Performance Appraisal at Jindal Brothers Pvt. Ltd
5/51
I'"%(+3&"I('
PEFO!ANCE APPAISAL
Performance appraisal may be defined as a structured formal interaction between a subordinate
and supervisor, that usually takes the form of a periodic interview 3annual or semi4annual5, in
which the work performance of the subordinate is e"amined and discussed, with a view to
identifying weaknesses and strengths as well as opportunities for improvement and skills
development. Performance appraisal, also known as employee appraisal, is a method by which
the job performance of an employee is evaluated 3generally in terms of quality, quantity, cost and
time5. Performance appraisal is a part of career development.
Performance appraisals are regular reviews of employee performance within organi6ations.
enerally, the aims of a performance appraisal are to7
• ive feedback on performance to employees.
http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Job_performancehttp://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Employeehttp://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Qualityhttp://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Quantityhttp://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Costhttp://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Timehttp://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Career_developmenthttp://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Career_developmenthttp://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Employeehttp://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Qualityhttp://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Quantityhttp://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Costhttp://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Timehttp://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Career_developmenthttp://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Job_performance
8/19/2019 Performance Appraisal at Jindal Brothers Pvt. Ltd
6/51
• Identify employee training needs.
• )ocument criteria used to allocate organi6ational rewards.
• +orm a basis for personnel decisions7 salary increases, promotions, disciplinary actions,
etc.
• Provide the opportunity for organi6ational diagnosis and development.
• +acilitate communication between employee and administration
8alidate selection techniques and human resource policies to meet federal !qual !mployment
&pportunity requirements.
Per"or#ance Apprai$al S%##ar&
Performance appraisal, while enabling a manager to identify the training needs of employees,
and evolving a training plan for them, also, serves to meet other objectives. Performance
appraisal satisfies the psychological needs individuals have to know how they are performing
their job and increases employees9 job satisfaction and morale by letting them know that the
manager is interested in their progress and development. Systematic performance appraisal also
provides both the firm and the employee a careful evaluation, rather than a snap judgement of an
employee9s performance. :any firms use performance appraisals to plan placements and
transfers and to provide input into decisions regarding salary increases, promotions, and
transfers. +inally, performance appraisals may be used as a basis for the coaching and
counselling of individual employees by their superiors. ;o summari6e the uses of performance
appraisal7
• Performance improvement
• $ompensation
• Placement
http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Traininghttp://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Documenthttp://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Rewardhttp://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Salaryhttp://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Salaryhttp://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Promotion_(rank)http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Promotion_(rank)http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Disciplinehttp://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Equal_Employment_Opportunityhttp://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Equal_Employment_Opportunityhttp://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Traininghttp://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Documenthttp://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Rewardhttp://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Salaryhttp://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Promotion_(rank)http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Disciplinehttp://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Equal_Employment_Opportunityhttp://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Equal_Employment_Opportunity
8/19/2019 Performance Appraisal at Jindal Brothers Pvt. Ltd
7/51
• ;raining % development needs assessment
• $areer planning
•
8/19/2019 Performance Appraisal at Jindal Brothers Pvt. Ltd
8/51
e+%lar an* ro%tine =hile an appraisal system is e"pected to be formal in a structured
manner, informal contacts and interactions can also be used for providing feedback to
employees.
Participator& an* open An effective appraisal system should necessarily involve the
employee9s participation, usually through an appraisal interview with the supervisor, for feedback
and future planning. )uring this interview, past performance should be discussed frankly and
future goals established. A strategy for accomplishing these goals as well as for improving future
performance should be evolved jointly by the supervisor and the employee being appraised. Such
participation imparts a feeling of involvement and creates a sense of belonging.
e,ar*$ e,ar*$ 4 both positive and negative 4 should be part of the performance appraisal
system. &therwise, the process lacks impact.
Fee*)ac- $ho%l* )e ti#el& >nless feedback is timely, it loses its utility and may have only
limited influence on performance.
I#per$onal "ee*)ac- +eedback must be impersonal if it is to have the desired effect.
Personal feedback is usually rejected with contempt, and eventually de4motivates the employee.
Fee*)ac- #%$t )e noticea)le ;he staff member being appraised must be made aware of the
information used in the appraisal process. An open appraisal process creates credibility.
eleance an* re$pon$iene$$ Planning and appraisal of performance and consequent
rewards or punishments should be oriented towards the objectives of the programme in which the
employee has been assigned a role. +or e"ample, if the objectives of a programme are directed
towards a particular client group, then the appraisal system has to be designed with that
orientation.
Co##it#ent e$pon$i)ilit& for the appraisal system should be located at a senior level in
the organi6ation so as to ensure commitment and involvement throughout the management
hierarchy.
/'AT IS T'E OLE OF PEFO!ANCE APPAISAL0
8/19/2019 Performance Appraisal at Jindal Brothers Pvt. Ltd
9/51
=e9ve seen from previous discussions, that people are one of a company9s most valuable assets.
=hile most assets depreciate over time, people, viewed as assets, may actually appreciate. &ne
of the manager9s major responsibilities is to improve and update the knowledge and skills of
employees 44 appreciation of assets. Performance appraisal plays a significant role as a tool and
technique of organi6ational development and growth. In essence, effective appraisal systems
provide both evaluation and feedback.;he main aim of the evaluation is to identify performance
gaps 44 when performance does not meet the organi6ational standards 44 whereas feedback is
necessary to inform employee about those performance gaps.
+rom the employee9s perspective, performance appraisal informs them about what is required of
them in order to do their jobs, it tells them how well they have achieved those objectives and
helps them take corrective action to improve their performance, and, finally, it may reward themfor meeting the required standards.
;he firm, on the other hand, needs a performance appraisal system in order to establish
principles of managerial accountability. $learly, where employees are given responsibilities and
duties, they need to be held accountable. &ne of the functions of performance appraisals is to
ensure that people are accountable for their organi6ational responsibilities.
Perhaps the most significant benefit of performance appraisals is the opportunities they providesupervisors and subordinates to have one4on4one discussions of important work issues. )uring
appraisals, subordinates and supervisors can focus on work activities and goals, identify and
correct e"isting problems, and encourage better future performance.
Per"or#ance Apprai$al an* !otiation
:otivational research has recogni6ed the power of recognition as an incentive 3see :aslow and
the !"pectancy ;heory of :otivation5. Performance appraisals provide employees with
recognition for their work efforts. ;he appraisal system provides the supervisor with an
opportunity to indicate to employees that the organi6ation is interested in their performance and
development. ;his recognition can have a positive motivational influence. on the individual9s
sense of worth, commitment and belonging.
8/19/2019 Performance Appraisal at Jindal Brothers Pvt. Ltd
10/51
Per"or#ance Apprai$al an* Trainin+ an* Deelop#ent
Performance appraisals identify performance gaps. As such, they provide an e"cellent
opportunity for a supervisor and subordinate to recogni6e and agree upon individual training and
development needs. Performance appraisal discussion may identify the presence or absence of
work skills. +urther, the need for training can be made more relevant if attaining the requisite job
skills is clearly linked to performance outcomes. $onsolidated appraisal data can also help form
a picture of the overall organi6ational training requirements.
Per"or#ance Apprai$al an* ecr%it#ent
(ecruitment and selection procedures need to be evaluated. Appraisal data can be used to
monitor the success of a firm9s recruitment and selection practices. +rom this data, the firm can
determine how well employees who were hired in the past are performing.
Per"or#ance Apprai$al an* E#plo&ee Eal%ation
!mployee evaluation is a major objective of performance appraisal. iven the major functions of
management 44 planning, organi6ing, leading and controlling 44 it is clear that evaluations
3controlling5 need to be done.
At its most basic level, performance appraisal is the process of e"amining and evaluating the
performance of employees. ?owever, the need to evaluate is also a source of tension as
evaluative and developmental priorities appear to clash. Some management e"perts have argued
that appraisal cannot serve the needs of evaluation and development at the same time.
Per"or#ance Apprai$al an* Total %alit& !ana+e#ent 2T!3
=ith the advent of ;@: 3;otal @uality :anagement5 and the e"tensive use of teams, traditional
performance appraisal systems have come under some criticism. +or e"ample, rather than
motivating employees, conflict may be created when appraisals are tied to merit pay and when
that merit pay is based on a forced ranking.
8/19/2019 Performance Appraisal at Jindal Brothers Pvt. Ltd
11/51
=. !dwards )eming, the founder of total quality management 3;@:5 has long been associated
with the view that performance appraisals ought to be eliminated. :any ;@: proponents claim
that performance appraisals are harmful.
PEFO!ANCE APPAISAL POCESS !AP
8/19/2019 Performance Appraisal at Jindal Brothers Pvt. Ltd
12/51
PEFO!ANCE APPAISAL !ET'ODS
1. raphic rating scale
8/19/2019 Performance Appraisal at Jindal Brothers Pvt. Ltd
13/51
#. Paired $omparison
'. +orced choice approach
.!asy Appraisal
B.'*22 appraisal
raphic atin+ Scale 6 A performance appraisal that rates the degree to which the employee
has achieved various characteristics.
15;he graphic rating scale is the most common type of appraisal used.
#58arious characteristics such as job knowledge or punctuality are rated by the degree of
achievement.
'5;he rate usually receives a score of 1 to B , with B representing e"cellent performance.
5Some forms allow for additional comments.
Paire*co#pari$on Approach6 A performance appraisal that measures the relative
performance of employees in a group.
15;his is a method of performance evaluation that results in a rank ordering of employees tocome up with a best employee.
#5;his type of approach measures the relative performance of employees in a group.
Force*choice Approach 6 A performance appraisal that presents the appraiser with sets of
statements describing employee behaviorC the appraiser must choose which statement is most
characteristic of the employee and which is least characteristic.
Ea$& Apprai$al6 Sometimes the supervisor must write a description of the employeeDs
performance. ;he easy appraisal is often used along with other types of appraisals, notably
graphic rating scales. ;hey provide an opportunity for supervisors to describe aspects of
performance not thoroughly covered by an appraisal questionnaire.
8/19/2019 Performance Appraisal at Jindal Brothers Pvt. Ltd
14/51
789*e+ree Per"or#ance Apprai$al6 Evaluating Employees 1rom All
Angles
;raditional performance appraisals, as discussed above, can be both subjective and simplistic.
At times, they can also be deemed to be EpoliticalE. In an attempt to improve this methodology,some companies have turned to '*24degree appraisals. '*2 appraisals pool feedback from a
department9s internal and e"ternal customers to ensure a broader, more accurate perspective of an
employee9s performance.
'*24degree performance appraisal is an attempt to answer the question7 E?ow can a supervisor
evaluate an employee he or she sees only a few hours each weekFE
Bene"it$ o" Per"or#ance apprai$al
For the or+ani:ation 6
;he organi6ation comes to know the true position of the employees working capacities and the
problems they face while working in the organi6ation. ;his performance appraisal system also
acts as a motivating factor for the employees, which helps the organi6ation to get better results.
For the apprai$e 6;he appraise fells themselves an important part of the organi6ation, they get a chance to e"press
their views in front of their superiorsC they get a platform to e"press their ideas. ;he employee
comes to know the truth about7
;o what e"tent they have achieved their objectives.
In what respect their work has been most successful.
Are there any aspects of their work, which they have not completedF
Are #an& other ;%e$tion< ,hich #a-e the# a$$e$$ ri+htl&. ..
%i*eline$ "or e""ectie per"or#ance eal%ation interie,$...
• emphasi6e positive aspects of employee performance
8/19/2019 Performance Appraisal at Jindal Brothers Pvt. Ltd
15/51
• tell employee that the purpose is to improve performance, not to discipline
• conduct the review in private
• review the performance formally at least annually 3more frequently for those performing poorly5
• make criticisms specific
• focus on performance, not personality
• stay calmC do not argue
• identify specific actions the employee can take to improve performance
• emphasi6e the evaluatorDs willingness to assist the employeeDs efforts to improve performance
• end by stressing positive
Apprai$al Proce$$
In order to obtain a better understanding of how the performance appraisal has been put together
by ;he $orporation, the researcher has provided an overview of the companyDs performance
appraisal process. ;he researcher felt that the overview of the performance appraisal process
would be necessary, since the process provided a framework for the performance appraisal.
PEAPPASIAL STEPS
;he performance evaluation can be made for variety of reasons counseling, promotions, salary
increases, administration or combination of these. It becomes very necessary to begin by stating
the objectives of evaluation programs very clearly and precisely. ;he personal appraisal system
should address the question who, what, how of performance appraisal.
;hese questions are the components of these appraisal systems which are discussed below
individually.
8/19/2019 Performance Appraisal at Jindal Brothers Pvt. Ltd
16/51
8/19/2019 Performance Appraisal at Jindal Brothers Pvt. Ltd
17/51
>nder this, the organi6ation must decide what different kinds of methods are available and which
of these may be used for performance appraisal. &n the basis of comparative advantages and
disadvantages, the nature and philosophy of management and the needs of an organi6ationC the
method of appraisal is decided.
CO!PAN( POFILE
8/19/2019 Performance Appraisal at Jindal Brothers Pvt. Ltd
18/51
;he
8/19/2019 Performance Appraisal at Jindal Brothers Pvt. Ltd
19/51
;he
8/19/2019 Performance Appraisal at Jindal Brothers Pvt. Ltd
20/51
8/19/2019 Performance Appraisal at Jindal Brothers Pvt. Ltd
21/51
Location Client
=ashim
I;$
rain odown
$afeteria
)ept. Store
0awal JKK 3S:$$ $onstruction5
8/19/2019 Performance Appraisal at Jindal Brothers Pvt. Ltd
22/51
PEFO!ANCE APPAISAL AT INDAL BOT'ES
=hile on the job, performance reviews of every employee are done every quarter. ;he reviews
are done with a view to helping the individual e"cel at hisGher workplace. In case there are any
training requirements, these are noted and acted upon in the coming quarter. Also, the goals and
objectives for the employee are re4visited for
;he performance appraisal mechanism is carried out at
8/19/2019 Performance Appraisal at Jindal Brothers Pvt. Ltd
23/51
e5 ;he appraisal is then discussed with the employees.
f5 And finally, if need arises corrective action is initiated. +or this purpose the corrective action
is actually identified through brainstorming e"ercises initiated by the departmental heads at
all the
8/19/2019 Performance Appraisal at Jindal Brothers Pvt. Ltd
24/51
. 789 De+ree Fee*)ac-
;his feedback system involves the participation of ;op :anagement.
;hus the feedback given by these members at
8/19/2019 Performance Appraisal at Jindal Brothers Pvt. Ltd
25/51
• ;o identify how the performance of the employees is improved and enhanced
• ;o provide suggestions % recommendations to improve their Performance Appraisal
ESEAC' !ET'ODOLO(
In order to accomplish the objectives of the study, it is essential to articulate the manner in which
it is to be conducted, i.e., the research process is to be carried4out in a certain framework. ;he
research methodology, which follows, is the backbone of the study.
Data Collection So%rce$
(esearch work was done from two sources7 4
213 Pri#ar& *ata
23 Secon*ar& *ata
Primary data was collected by questionnaire and interview in the organi6ations. ;he
questionnaire comprised of closed and attitude questions. ;he opinion on e"isting Performance
Appraisal practices and their affectivity were collected through questionnaire which was
8/19/2019 Performance Appraisal at Jindal Brothers Pvt. Ltd
26/51
circulated to all the employees at all levels and the results have been analysed on the basis of
agree and disagree. ;he methodology for collection of data also included interviews and
discussion with the top management of the organi6ation.
Secondary data7 It was collected by reviewing different literatures, from published books,management journals, articles published by the other researchers on '*2 )egree Appraisal.
Sa#plin+6
;he total sample si6e for this project was ?( people at
8/19/2019 Performance Appraisal at Jindal Brothers Pvt. Ltd
27/51
De$criptie e$earch6;o poetry accurately the characteristics of the particular individual
situation or a group.
Dia+no$tic e$earch6;o determine the frequency with which something occurs or with which it
is associated with something else.
'&pothe$i$ Te$tin+ e$earch6;o test a hypothesis of casual relationship between variables.
;he present project is De$criptie c%# Eploratie in nature. It is done to poetry accurately
the characteristics of a particular individual situation or a group. ;he major purpose of the
descriptive research is the description of the state of the affairs as it e"its at resent. ;he main
characteristics of this method are that the researcher has no control over the variablesC he can
only report what has happened or what is happening.
LITEATGE EVIE/
&rgani6ations e"ist to achieve goals. oals are only met when individual employees efforts
matches with policy of the organi6ation and thus bringing out success and effectiveness. ;he
assessment of how successful employees have been at meeting their individual goals therefore
becomes a critical part of ?(: and here comes Performance Appraisal System.
Performance appraisal is an important component of the information and control system. In
todayDs fle"ible organi6ations, performance evaluation provides an important way for managers
to clarify performance goals and standards and to enhance future individual performance. ;hus
the purpose of performance appraisal is to improve the organi6ationDs performance through the
enhanced performance of individuals.
;he performance appraisal system7
8/19/2019 Performance Appraisal at Jindal Brothers Pvt. Ltd
28/51
• Is an organi6ational necessity
• Is based on well defined objective criteria
• Is based on careful job analysis
• >ses only job related criteria
• Is supported by adequate studies
• Is applied by trained qualified raters
• Is applied objectively throughout the organi6ation
• $an be shown non discriminatory as defined by law
PEFO!ANCE APPAISAL AND !ANAE!ENT<
Journal of Performance Appraisal Techniques o!ember "#$%%&'olo"pp"&* +y
,letcher -
Performance appraisal has widened as a concept and as a set of practices and in the form of
performance management has become part of a more strategic approach to integrating ?(
activities and business policies. As a result of this, the research on the subject has moved beyond
the limited confines of measurement issues and accuracy of performance ratings and has begun
to focus more of social and motivational aspects of appraisal. ;his article identifies and discussesa number of themes and trends that together make up the developing research agenda for this
field. It breaks these down in terms of the nature of appraisal and the conte"t in which it
operates. ;he former is considered in terms of contemporary thinking on the content of appraisal
3conte"tual performance, goal orientation and self awareness5 and the process of appraisal
3appraiserNappraisee interaction, and multi4source feedback5. ;he discussion of the conte"t of
appraisal concentrates on cultural differences and the impact of new technology.
Per"or#ance Apprai$al a$ E""ectie !ana+e#ent or Dea*l& !ana+e#ent Di$ea$e
Journal of Performance Appraisal .anagement Jan$%%/' ol*%# Pages&* by Gregory H 0obbins
>nderstanding person and system sources of work variation is fundamental to performance
appraisal. ;wo divergent perspectives on this issue, the traditional human resource management
view and the statistical process control view 3)eming, 1/-*5, are contrasted. ;wo studies are
reported that investigate two specific questions that arise from a broader view of the appraisal
8/19/2019 Performance Appraisal at Jindal Brothers Pvt. Ltd
29/51
process. (esults indicate that managers and subordinates believe that typical poor performance
has different causes and that actual productivity levels far outweigh person or system sources of
performance variance in appraisal judgments.
A Contin+enc& Approach to Apprai$al Sati$"action Journal of Performance Appraisal Approaches#July$%%1#ol"1#Pages2/ by Gregory H
0obbins
;he present study e"plored the moderating effects of organi6ational variables on the appraisal
characteristic4appraisal satisfaction relationship. Analyses indicated that the appraisal
characteristics of action plans, frequency, and rater training were more positively related to
appraisal satisfaction when subordinates e"perienced role conflict, were not closely monitored,
and supervisors had a large span of control. ;he results provide substantial support for
conceptuali6ing appraisal satisfaction as a contingent function of both appraisal characteristics
and organi6ational variables. Implications of the findings for the design of appraisal systems,appraisal effectiveness, and future research are discussed.
Di""erential Per"or#ance Apprai$al Criteria
Journal of Performance Appraisal -riteria#3ct$%&%#ol&*# pages 4$ by Taylor -o5
Performance appraisal ratings of 1#B first4level managers were analy6ed to investigate the degree
to which the criteria used to evaluate the overall job performance of black managers differs from
that used to evaluate white managers. ;he performance appraisal form included items that
measured both the social behavior dimension and taskGgoal accomplishment dimension of job performance. ;he appraisal ratings of both groups on each dimension were correlated with
measures of overall job performance and promote ability. (esults indicated that social behavior
factors are more highly correlated with the overall job performance of black ratees than for white
ratees. Implications of these results for both black managers and organi6ations are discussed.
A e$tate#ent o" the Sati$"action
Journal of Performance Hypothesis#ol/1#6ept $%&%#Pages "/ by 0ennis 7 3rgan#
;his article reviews recent evidence in support of &rganDs 31/5 argument that satisfaction more
generally correlates with organi6ational prosaically or citi6enship4type behaviors than with
traditional productivity or in4role performance. An attempt is then made to interpret just what it is
in satisfaction measures that provides this correlation, leading to the suggestion that fairness
cognitions comprise the major factor. Implications of this interpretation for theory, research, and
management practice are offered.
8/19/2019 Performance Appraisal at Jindal Brothers Pvt. Ltd
30/51
ANAL(SIS H INTEPETATION
;his chapter deals in tabular presentation results and their analysis for the purpose of easy
reading the section has been divided into two parts.
1O ;abular form of (esponse
#O Inference
'O (emarks on each question
8/19/2019 Performance Appraisal at Jindal Brothers Pvt. Ltd
31/51
8/19/2019 Performance Appraisal at Jindal Brothers Pvt. Ltd
32/51
. There are #echani$#$ that help e#plo&ee$ *eelop their potential "or the net ro%n* o"
o)0
e$pon$e Cate+or& No. o" re$pon$e$ Percenta+e
8ery true2 2
;rueB 12
Partly true#B B2
Hot true #2 2
No. of responses Percentage
0
5
10
15
20
25
30
35
4045
50
Very true True Partly true Not true
In"erence6 @uite a large number of respondents 32L5 shared the view that the appraisal system
did not give a clear understanding of all appraisals, job to both appraiser and appraise by saying
that it was Hot ;rueD. &nly B2L and 12L of the respondents felt that the statement was ;rueD
and Partly ;rueD respectively.
e#ar-$6 Although the appraise does not have a clear understanding of what is e"pected of him
at the beginning of the year 3Inference I5, both appraise and the appraiser know what his job is all
about. ;his also shows that although an employee knows what his current to do to be rated
higher by the reporting officer. ;he responsiveness in category of Partly ;rue and Hot ;rue may
be due to the face that job content in
8/19/2019 Performance Appraisal at Jindal Brothers Pvt. Ltd
33/51
7. E#plo&ee$ re+%larl& receie "ee*)ac- a)o%t their potential "or hi+her leel o)$0
e$pon$e Cate+or& No. o" re$pon$e$ Percenta+e
8ery true 2 2
;rue - 1*
Partly true 1
Hot true 'B 2
No. of responses Percentage
0
10
20
30
40
50
60
70
Very true True Partly true Not true
In"erence6 2L of the respondents agreed that the appraisal system did not helped them to know
their potential to perform at higher levels. Plan their performance well by saying that it was Hot
;rueD. &nly 1*L and 1L people felt that this statement was ;rueD and Partly ;rueD.
e#ar-$6 ;he above inference shows that the PA system in
8/19/2019 Performance Appraisal at Jindal Brothers Pvt. Ltd
34/51
4. o) rotation i$ practice* ,i*el& to help people *eelop their potential in ne, area$0
e$pon$e Cate+or& No. o" re$pon$e$ Percenta+e
8ery true 1
;rue 1- '*
Partly true #B B2
Hot true 2 2
No. of responses Percentage
0
5
10
15
20
25
30
35
40
45
50
Very true True Partly true Not true
In"erence7 About B2L of the respondents felt that the above statement was Partly ;rueD. It was
followed by '*L people feeling that it was ;rueD with 1L believing that it was 8ery ;rueD.
e#ar-$6
8/19/2019 Performance Appraisal at Jindal Brothers Pvt. Ltd
35/51
5. The apprai$al $&$te# proi*e$ an opport%nit& "or $el"reie, an* re"lection0
e$pon$e Cate+or& No. o" e$pon$e$ Percenta+e
8ery true2 2
;rue2 2
Partly true1' #*
Hot true '
No. of Responses Percentage
0
10
20
3040
50
60
70
80
Very true True Partly true Not true
In"erence 7 ;here is a general agreement on then fact that the PA system in
8/19/2019 Performance Appraisal at Jindal Brothers Pvt. Ltd
36/51
8. Pro#otion$ are )a$e* $trictl& on nee* rather than to re,ar* in*ii*%al$0
e$pon$e Cate+or& No. o" e$pon$e$ Percenta+e
8ery true 2 2
;rue -
Partly true #B B2
Hot true#1 #
No. of Responses Percentage
0
5
10
15
20
25
3035
40
45
50
Very true True Partly true Not true
In"erence 6 B2L of the respondents believe that the above statement is Partly ;rueD
;his was closely followed by #L of the respondents rating it as Hot
;rueD and -L of the respondents feeling that it was ;rueD.
e#ar-$ 6 ;he performance appraisal is completely need based the organi6ation
recogni6es and promotes high achievers only if there are vacancies
available in the organi6ation. ;his has a negative impact on people who
are not rewarded and promoted duly for their good performance. ;hereshould be a system of rewarding employees either in monetary terms or
in terms of recognition.
. The apprai$al $&$te# +ie$ each apprai$ee an i*ea o" ,hat i$ epecte* o" hi# net &ear0
e$pon$e Cate+or& No. o" e$pon$e$ Percenta+e
8/19/2019 Performance Appraisal at Jindal Brothers Pvt. Ltd
37/51
8ery true 2 2
;rue 12 #2
Partly true #* B#
Hot true 1 #-
No. of Responses Percentage0
10
20
30
40
50
60
Very true True Partly true Not true
In"erence 6 B#L of the respondents felt that the above statement was Partly
;rueD. ;his was followed by #-L and #2L of the respondents
feeling that it was Hot ;rueD and ;rueD respectively.
e#ar-$ 6 !ach employee needs to have an idea as to what accountabilities
will he have if his appraisal is given a good remark for working at
higher levels. ;he appraisee should know his potential, which
will go a long way in his higher level jobs.
8/19/2019 Performance Appraisal at Jindal Brothers Pvt. Ltd
38/51
J. It i$ *e$i+ne* to ai* the apprai$ee an* apprai$er ointl& %n*er$tan* the "or#er$ o)0
e$pon$e Cate+or& No. o" e$pon$e$ Percenta+e
8ery true 2 2
;rue 1 #-
Partly true ##
Hot true1 #-
No. of Responses Percentage
0
5
10
15
20
25
30
35
40
45
Very true True Partly true Not true
In"erence 6 ;here was a mi"ed response to the given statement. L of the responses
consisted of QPartly ;rueD ratings. #-L respondents believed that this wasHot ;rueD whereas #-L believed that this was ;rueD.
e#ar-$ 6 ;he above inference implies that
8/19/2019 Performance Appraisal at Jindal Brothers Pvt. Ltd
39/51
K. The per"or#ance apprai$al proi*e$ an opport%nit& "or $el" reie, an* re"lection0
e$pon$e Cate+or& No. o" e$pon$e$ Percenta+e
very true 2 2true #
partly true #B B2
not true #' *
No. of Responses Percentage
0
5
1015
20
25
30
35
40
45
50
v er y true true
partly true not true
In"erence 6 :ost of the respondents agreed that the appraisal system catered to their
development needs 3B2L believed that it was QPartly ;rue5 and it was very
closely followed by *L saying it was QHot ;rue. ;here were L cases, which
believed that it was ;rueD.
e#ar-$ 6 Although the inference indicates that the PA system allowed mutuality, trust and
open communication between superior and subordinates, there may be chances
of biases in employees while rating this statement. ;he answers may have
varied depending on pro"imity etc.
19. The apprai$al proce*%re allo,$ the apprai$ee to epre$$ hi$ *eelop#ental nee*$0
e$pon$e Cate+or& No. o" e$pon$e$ Percenta+e
very true 2 2
8/19/2019 Performance Appraisal at Jindal Brothers Pvt. Ltd
40/51
;rue - 1*
partly true 1* '#
not true #* B#
No. of Responses Percentage
0
10
20
30
40
50
60
v ery true True
partly true not true
In"erence 6 ;he most common response on above statement was an astounding Hot
;rueD with B#L people agreeing that the PA system was free of any biases. It
was followed by '#L saying that it was ;rueD and 1*L saying that it was
Partly ;rueD.
e#ar-$ 6 ;he above inference implies that people are satisfied with the PA system in
8/19/2019 Performance Appraisal at Jindal Brothers Pvt. Ltd
41/51
11. The $&$te# ha$ $cope to correct the )ia$e$ o" the a$$e$$or thro%+h a $%per reie,0
e$pon$e Cate+or& No. o" e$pon$e$ Percenta+e
very true 2 2
true#
partly true1 #-
not true' *-
No. of Responses Percentage
0
10
20
30
40
50
60
70
v er y true true
partly true not true
In"erence 6 *-L of the people rated the above statement as Hot ;rueD #-L believed it was
Partly ;rueD with L disagreeing by saying that it was ;rueD.
e#ar-$ 6 A performance appraisal system, which is perceived as bias 4freeD by its
e"ecutives, is an achievement for the organi6ation. In the PA system the
reporting officer appraises a section of people whereas the reviewing officer
appraises the performance of an entire department. also the reviewing officer is
the immediate superior of reporting officer. Any disagreement between the
assessments of an employee has to be duly discussed and recorded. Also, anynoticeable difference of opinion between self appraisal and appraisal by
reporting officer has to be accounted for. All the above factors help in correcting
the biases,. if any, of reporting officer.
1. The apprai$al $&$te# proi*e$ "or a "ran- *i$c%$$ion )et,een apprai$er an* apprai$ee0
8/19/2019 Performance Appraisal at Jindal Brothers Pvt. Ltd
42/51
e$pon$e Cate+or& No. o" e$pon$e$ Percenta+e
very true2 2
;rue* 1#
partly true2 2
not true --
No. of Responses Percentage
0
10
20
30
40
50
60
70
80
0
v er y true True
partly true not true
In"erence6 An astounding --L rated the above statement as not true with 1#L that it was
true.
e#ar-$ Although, most of the people felt that there was mutuality and trust between
appraiser and appraise, it may again depend on the pro"imity and relationship
shared by an employee and hisGher boss. ;he ratings may be based, as the
employees may have felt that a negative answer may adversely affect them. ;he
reason behind this conclusion is that a low score on e"tent of communication and
discussion between appraisers and appraise and high score on mutuality and trust
give a contradictory view.
17. /hat -in* o" an apprai$al $&$te# ,ill )rin+ o%t the )e$t o" an e#plo&ee0
e$pon$e Cate+or& No. o" e$pon$e$ Percenta+e
appraisal by all superiors 12 #2
8/19/2019 Performance Appraisal at Jindal Brothers Pvt. Ltd
43/51
appraisal by immediate
superior
B 12
appraisal by reference team 1B '2
appraisal by reference teamand self.
#2 2
No. of Re sponse s Perce ntage
0
5
10
15
20
25
30
35
40
appra!sal "y all super!ors
appra!sal "y !##e$!ate super!or
appra!sal "y reference tea#
appra!sal "y reference tea# an$ self.
e#ar-$ 6 ;his shows that the relationship between appraiser and appraise, in
8/19/2019 Performance Appraisal at Jindal Brothers Pvt. Ltd
44/51
#4 ;he company is well aware of the dynamic environment of software, it is operating and
in order to keep it with the pace of the environment it believes in constant up gradation of
courses. &rgani6ation structure and design of the company is such that it supports this
change.
'4
8/19/2019 Performance Appraisal at Jindal Brothers Pvt. Ltd
45/51
%E&(MME'+A"I('0
1. ;o improve attendance there should be rewards for those employees who attains above/BL attendance.
#. ;here should be training sessions to improve team building.
'. ;here should be proper training for appraisal to the employees.
. In the beginning of the year employee must know the performance standards on which
hisGher performance will be judged in end of year.
B. :ore stress relieving packages should be offered to the mentally stressed staff.
*. &vertime should be taken care of at time of performance appraisal, which would motivate
the employees to perform better for longer hours.
. Performance appraisal should after at proper span of time .
-. Performance appraisal should be done by e"pert person.
8/19/2019 Performance Appraisal at Jindal Brothers Pvt. Ltd
46/51
CONCLGSION
Performance appraisal is the process of reviewing employee performance vis4R4vis the set
e"pectations in a realistic manner, documenting the review, and delivering the review verbally in
a face4to4face meeting, to raise performance standards year over year through honest andconstructive feedback. In the process management e"pects to reinforce the employeeDs strengths,
identify improvement areas so that one can work on them and also set stretched goals for the
coming year.
!ffective performance management requires a good deal of face4to4face supervisor4employee
interaction. 0y knowing the subordinates, a supervisor can steer them onto a path of greater
productivity and optimi6ed output. It is one of the most significant and indispensable tool for an
organi6ation as it helps in getting to know the people who work for them. provides information,
which helps in taking important decisions for the development of an individual and the
organi6ation.
8/19/2019 Performance Appraisal at Jindal Brothers Pvt. Ltd
47/51
53E0"I(''A'I%E
I have undertaken a project on PERFORMANCE APPRAISAL SYSTEM. The
information furnished by you will help knowing the eectiveness of the present
appraisal and reward system and if need be designing of a new appraisal system.
The data will be kept condential and will be used for academic purpose only.
6. In your company, the key competencies required for each job are
already identi7ed.
a) Very true b) true
c) artly true d) not true
8. "here are mechanisms that help employees develop their potential for
the ne$t rung of job.
a) very true b)true
c) partly true d) not true
9. Employees regularly receive feedback about their potential for higher
level jobs
a) very true b)true
c) partly true d) not true
:. 4ob rotation is practiced widely to help people develop their potential in
new areas.
a) very true b)true
c) partly true d) not true
;. -our company
8/19/2019 Performance Appraisal at Jindal Brothers Pvt. Ltd
48/51
c) partly true d) not true
=. /romotions are based strictly on need rather than to rewardindividuals>
a) very true b)true
c) partly true d) not true
?. "he appraisal system gives each appraisee an idea of what is e$pected
of him ne$t year>
a) very true b)true
c) partly true d) not true
@. It is designed to aid the appraisee and appraisers jointly understand the
former
a) very true b)true
c) partly true d) not true
. "he performance appraisal provides an opportunity for self review and
reBection>
a) very true b)true
c) partly true d) not true
6C. "he appraisal procedure allows the appraisee to e$press hisdevelopmental needs>
a) very true b)true
c) partly true d) not true
8/19/2019 Performance Appraisal at Jindal Brothers Pvt. Ltd
49/51
66. "he system has scope to correct the biases of the assessor through a
super review>
a) very true b)true
c) partly true d) not true
68. "he appraisal system provides for a frank discussion between
appraiser and appraisee>
a) very true b)true
c) partly true d) not true
69. "he procedure allows for the communication of &E(Ds goal to the
workforce>
a) very true b)true
c) partly true d) not true
6:. "he appraisal system brings out the training needs of the employees.
a) very true b)true
c) partly true d) not true
6;. "he performance appraisal system clari7es the career prospects,
aspirations and intentions.
a) very true b)true
c) partly true d) not true
6=. "he appraisal system provides a rational basis for salary
recommendations.
a) very true b)true
8/19/2019 Performance Appraisal at Jindal Brothers Pvt. Ltd
50/51
c) partly true d) not true
6?. "he company relates reward to your performance.
a) very true b)true
c) partly true d) not true
6@. )hat kind of an appraisal system will bring out the best of an
employee>
a) appraisal by all superiors b) appraisal by immediate
superior
c) appraisal by reference team c) appraisal by reference
team and self.
6. ow do you support your subordinates>
!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!
!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!
!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!.
8/19/2019 Performance Appraisal at Jindal Brothers Pvt. Ltd
51/51
Bi)lio+raph&
A$,athappa < '%#an e$o%rce H Per$onnel !ana+e#ent< Tata !cra, 'ill
P%)li$hin+ Co. Lt*.< Ne, Delhi< Sith e*ition 991
othari C..< e$earch #etho*olo+& #etho*$ H techni;%e$< /i$h,a Pra-a$an %)li$hin+
Co. Lt*.< Ne, Delhi< Sith e*ition 991.
'%#an e$o%rce$ !ana+e#ent )& P.S%)arao
Search en+ine$
1. www.google .co#
. citehr.co#
7.,,,.#$n.co#
4.,,,.,i-ipae*i.co#
http://www.google/http://www.google/