Perceptual Cognition & Kant

7/28/2019 Perceptual Cognition & Kant

http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/perceptual-cognition-kant 1/14

3HUFHSWXDO&RJQLWLRQ$1\Ã\D.DQWLDQ$SSURDFK$XWKRUV0RQLPD&KDGKD5HYLHZHGZRUNV6RXUFH3KLORVRSK\(DVWDQG:HVW9RO1R$SUSS3XEOLVKHGE\University of Hawai'i Press

6WDEOH85/http://www.jstor.org/stable/1400000.

$FFHVVHG

Your use of the JSTOR archive indicates your acceptance of the Terms & Conditions of Use, available at .http://www.jstor.org/page/info/about/policies/terms.jsp

.JSTOR is a not-for-profit service that helps scholars, researchers, and students discover, use, and build upon a wide range of

content in a trusted digital archive. We use information technology and tools to increase productivity and facilitate new forms

of scholarship. For more information about JSTOR, please contact [email protected].

.

University of Hawai'i Press is collaborating with JSTOR to digitize, preserve and extend access to Philosophy East and West.



3(5&(378$/&2*1,7,21$1<$<$.$17,$1$3352$&+

0RQLPDKDGKD

'HSDUWPHQWI3KLORVRSK\RQDVKQLYHUVLW\

:HILQGHUWDLQKLQJVERXWHHLQJX]]OLQJHFDXVHZHGRQRWLQGKHZKROHXVLQHVVIHHLQJX]]OLQJHQRXJK /XGZLJ:LWWJHQVWHLQ

,QWURGXFWLRQ

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

,WVFRPPRQO\HOLHYHGKDWKHLYHQRQVLVWVISDUWLFXODUVKDWUHFRJQL]HGVVXFKQSHUFHSWXDO[SHULHQFHVJDLQVWKLVRSXODUHOLHIVKDOOUJXHKDWKHUHV

QRFRKHUHQWRWLRQISHUFHSWXDORJQLWLRQISDUWLFXODUVHUFHSWXDORJQLWLRQXVWEHUHVWULFWHGRXQLYHUVDOHDWXUHVISDUWLFXODUVDVVXFKRQRWHYHQTXDOLI\VREMHFWVISHUFHSWXDORJQLWLRQKHQKHUHVQRSRVVLELOLW\INQRZLQJDUWLFXODUVDVVXFKQSHUFHSWXDO[SHULHQFHVKXVWHHPVRIROORZKDWHUFHSWLRQDQQRWHDVRXUFHINQRZOHGJHISDUWLFXODUVKLVODLPVKDUGRGLJHVW:HKDYHDOZD\VWKRXJKWKDWHUFHSWLRQVWKHSULPDU\HUKDSVKHRQO\RXUFHRINQRZOHGJHISDUWLFXODUVHDUHIRUFHGRFRQFOXGHKDWDUWLFXODUVDQQRWHREMHFWVIRJQLWLRQRUNQRZOHGJHKLVFRQFOXVLRQVFRXQWHULQWXLWLYHWKLQNKDWKHFRQWHULQWXLWLYHFRQFOXVLRQDQEHDYRLGHGE\UHFRQVLGHULQJXUQWXLWLYHRWLRQINQRZOHGJHISDUWLFXODUV

7KHDUJXPHQWQWKLVVVD\GUDZVQGLVFXVVLRQVPRQJQFLHQWQGLDQKLORVRSKHUVVSHFLDOO\DPRQJ%XGGKLVWVQG1DL\D\LNDVQWKHFKDUDFWHULVWLFRQWHQWI

SHUFHSWXDO[SHULHQFHV$OWKRXJKKHUHUHFRQVLGHUDEOHGLVDJUHHPHQWVKHDQFLHQW,QGLDQSKLORVRSKHUVJUHHRQRQHFUXFLDOPDWWHUHUFHSWXDO[SHULHQFHVUHDWWKHYHU\HDVWFRJQLWLYHQFKDUDFWHUWKLQNKH\UHULJKWKHFRQWHQWVISHUFHSWXDO

3KLORVRSK\DVW:HVW9ROXPH1XPEHU$SULO

" E\8QLYHUVLW\I+DZDLL3UHVV



H[SHULHQFHVUHWOHDVWRWHQWLDOO\EMHFWVIFRJQLWLRQUDZDUHQHVVIWHUOOWKHZKROHSRLQWIQWURGXFLQJKHQRWLRQIKHRQWHQWISHUFHSWXDO[SHULHQFHVVWR

H[SODLQSHUFHLYHUVDSDFLW\RJDLQNQRZOHGJHISHUFHLYHGEMHFWVKLVPLQLPDOFODLPVEHHIHGSE\KH1\D\DKLORVRSKHUV\GGLQJKDWOOFRJQLWLRQQGWKXV

SHUFHSWXDORJQLWLRQHTXLUHVRQFHSWXDOL]DWLRQKLVVWKHRFXVIKHRQWURYHUV\EHWZHHQXGGKLVWVQG1DL\G\LNDVKH%XGGKLVWQFRQWUDVWQVLVWVKDWHUFHSWXDOFRJQLWLRQXVWHWRWDOO\HYRLGIRQFHSWXDOL]DWLRQHUFHSWLRQVFRQFHSWLRQIUHHDZDUHQHVVISDUWLFXODUDVVXFKKLVUDGLFDOKHVLVVEDVHGRQDSODXVLEOHQWXLWLRQSHUFHSWXDO[SHULHQFHVQOLNHWKHURJQLWLYHSLVRGHVPXVWHFRQVWUDLQHG

E\FDXVDOLQWHUDFWLRQHWZHHQKHVHQVHIDFXOW\QGWKHJLYHQ)RUKH%XGGKLVWFRQFHSWXDOL]DWLRQHTXLUHVLPDJLQDWLYHRQVWUXFWLRQ\WKHPLQGKDWVXQFRQVWUDLQHG\KHJLYHQ

,QKHLUVWHFWLRQHVKDOORQVLGHUKHHQWUDOUJXPHQWVIIHUHG\KH1\D\DDJDLQVWXFKFRQFHSWLRQIUHHZDUHQHVVISDUWLFXODUQKLVHFWLRQZLOO[WHQGWKH1\D\DUJXPHQWVRUHYHDOKHQFRKHUHQFHQKHYHU\GHDRIFRQFHSWLRQIUHHDZDUHQHVVISDUWLFXODUVKLVGRHVQRWPHDQKDWUHMHFWKHSODXVLEOHQWXLWLRQKDW

JXLGHVKH%XGGKLVWKHRQWHQWISHUFHSWXDO[SHULHQFHVPXVWHFRQVWUDLQHG\

WKHFDXVDOLQWHUDFWLRQHWZHHQKHVHQVHVQGWKHJLYHQ:KDWGRUHMHFWVWKHVWURQJHUODLPWKDWKH%XGGKLVWHIHQGVQWKLVDVLVQDPHO\KDWKHFRQWHQWI

SHUFHSWXDO[SHULHQFHVXVWKHUHIRUHHUHVWULFWHGRSDUWLFXODUVKHUHVQRWKLQJQHZRWKLVHVSRQVHWVXVWUHVWDWHPHQWIKHDPRXVDQWLDQLFWXPQWXLWLRQVZLWKRXWRQFHSWVUHEOLQG

,QWKLVVVD\VKDOOGHIHQGKHLPSOH.DQWLDQKHVLVERXWWKHQDWXUHISHUFHSWXDOFRJQLWLRQHUFHSWXDO[SHULHQFHVHTXLUHRRSHUDWLYHFWLYLW\HWZHHQVHQVHIDFXOWLHVQGWKHPLQGXWKLVLPSOLFLW\RPHVWWKHRVWRIYDJXHQHVVQWKHVHFRQGVHFWLRQVKDOOSXWIRUWKSUHFLVHODLPWKDWJLYHVXEVWDQFHRWKH.DQWLDQKHVLVERYHSHUFHSWXDORJQLWLRQHTXLUHVKHSRVVLELOLW\IUHFRJQLWLRQ7KHVXEVWDQWLDOKHVLVZLOOSURYLGHKHUJXPHQWRUKHODLPKDWHUFHSWXDORJQLWLRQPXVWHUHVWULFWHGRXQLYHUVDOHDWXUHVHZLOOEHJLQ\XQSDFNLQJKHQRWLRQ

RIFRQFHSWXDOL]DWLRQULPDJLQDWLYHRQVWUXFWLRQVLQYROYHGQSHUFHSWXDOH[SHULHQFHV\EXLOGLQJQVRPHXJJHVWLYHHPDUNV\KH1DL\D\LNDKLORVRSKHUVDQG.DQWRUKHPRQFHSWXDOL]DWLRQULPDJLQDWLYHRQVWUXFWLRQVDQHFHVVDU\LQJUHGLHQWISHUFHSWXDO[SHULHQFHXWWVQRWRWDOO\QFRQVWUDLQHG\KHJLYHQ$V.DQWZRXOGD\FRQFHSWVZLWKRXWQWXLWLRQVUHHPSW\KXVKHSODXVLEOHQWXLWLRQXLGLQJKH%XGGKLVWDQEHVDYHG7KHFODLPKDWHUFHSWXDORJQLWLRQXVWHUHVWULFWHGRXQLYHUVDOHDWXUHVVVXUSULVLQJRUWHHPVRUXOHXWKHSRVVLELOLW\I

NQRZOHGJHISDUWLFXODUVQWKHKLUGQGILQDOHFWLRQVKDOOKRZKDWKLVRXQWHULQWXLWLYHRQVHTXHQFHDQEHDYRLGHGE\WKLQNLQJERXWRXUQWXLWLYHRWLRQIWKHNQRZOHGJHISDUWLFXODUV

3HUFHSWXDO&RJQLWLRQI3DUWLFXODUV

:HEHJLQZLWKKHUDGLFDOSRVLWLRQHIHQGHGE\%XGGKLVWKLORVRSKHUVFFRUGLQJWRZKLFKWKHFRQWHQWISHUFHSWXDO[SHULHQFHVVWRWDOO\HYRLGRIDQ\SUROLIHUDWLRQ

3KLORVRSK\DVW:HVW



RIFRQFHSWV%XGGKLVWKLORVRSKHUVQWKH'LQQGJD'KDUPDN7UWLFKRROKROGWKDW

SHUFHSWLRQUHHLQJWUXO\VIUHHURPPDJLQDWLYHRQVWUXFWLRQNDOSDQD1RVHHLQJLVVHHLQJDVLQFHWKHODWWHUHFHVVDULO\QYROYHVKHLQWHUYHQWLRQIFRQFHSWXDOFRQVWUXFWLRQKH%XGGKLVWODLPVKDWSHUFHSWXDOXGJPHQWUDYHUEDOL]DWLRQIVXFKDFRQFHSWLRQIUHH[SHULHQFHVVWULFWO\SHDNLQJPSRVVLEOHRUYHUEDOL]DWLRQ

QYDULDEO\HTXLUHVRQFHSWXDOL]DWLRQQGWKDWEULQJVQPRUHKDQZKDWV

JLYHQQSHUFHSWXDOZDUHQHVVKHJLYHQRUKH%XGGKLVWRQVLVWVIGLVWLQFWXQLTXHPRPHQWDU\HOIFKDUDFWHUL]HGDUWLFXODUVVYDODNDQDV

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

VKDSHEXWKHUHVQRPDQJRREHVHHQ3HUFHSWLRQHVXOWVURPHQVHREMHFWRQWDFWQGWKXVPXVWHSHQGROHO\QWKHFDXVDOSRZHUVISDUWLFXODUVRUGVQG

FRQFHSWVUHQRWQJUDLQHGQSDUWLFXODUVQGWKXVSHUFHSWLRQDQRQO\UHVXOWQ

FRQFHSWLRQIUHHZDUHQHVVISDUWLFXODUVIKLVHVWULFWLRQVLJQRUHGWZLOOHDGWRDEVXUGRQVHTXHQFHVRUKHQHUFHSWXDOZDUHQHVVDQUHSUHVHQWKLQJVKDWUHQQRZD\FRQQHFWHGZLWKKHSHUFHSWXDOFFDVLRQQGWKHLPDJLQDWLYHLQGDQ

UHSUHVHQWQ\WKLQJQGHYHU\WKLQJ7KH1DL\G\LNDHMHFWVKHODLPKDWRQVWUXFWLYHZDUHQHVVQYROYLQJRQFHSWV

LVQRWSHUFHSWXDOLQFHWVPHUHO\ILJPHQWIRXUPDJLQDWLRQHUFHSWLRQVD

FRJQLWLYHSLVRGHWULJJHUHG\FDXVDOLQWHUDFWLRQHWZHHQHQVHDQGREMHFW7KLVLQWHUDFWLRQLYHVULVHRDSUHOLPLQDU\ZDUHQHVVIQXQVWUXFWXUHGKROH7KHQLU

YLNDOSDNDKDWVFRQFHSWLRQIUHHZDUHQHVVVDQHFHVVDU\WDJHQWKHSURFHVVI

SHUFHSWLRQXWKLVXQVWUXFWXUHGZDUHQHVVVRQO\ILUVWWHSWVLQYDULDEO\ROORZHGE\VWUXFWXUHGZDUHQHVVVDQHFHVVDU\RQVHTXHQFHQKHDPHHTXHQWLDOVHULHVKHILUVWZDUHQHVVRHVQRWGHVWUR\KHSHUFHSWXDOKDUDFWHUIKHHFRQGUDWKHUWIDFLOLWDWHVW7KHQLUYLNDOSDNDUWKHHQVRU\ZDUHQHVVQWKHPPHGLDWHO\SUHFHGLQJPRPHQWVDQLQGLVSHQVDEOHDXVDOIDFWRURUKHJHQHUDWLRQIDVDYL

NDOSDNDUFRQVWUXFWLYHZDUHQHVVOWKRXJKPHPRU\RQFHSWLRQQGFROODWHUDOLQIRUPDWLRQUHDOVRUHTXLUHGFRJQLWLRQKDWVLQGHSHQGHQWIWKHSUHOLPLQDU\VHQVRU\ZDUHQHVVDQQRWHVXOWQDSHUFHSWXDOXGJPHQWRU[DPSOHKHXGJPHQW7KLVVDFROOHFWLRQIHSWRQVQGTXDUNVKDWVPDGHRQVHHLQJWDEOHPD\EHOHJLWLPDWHWKHROODWHUDOQIRUPDWLRQVVXSSOLHG\SK\VLFVXWWFDQQRWHD

SHUFHSWXDOXGJPHQWLQFHWKHQHFHVVDU\HSHQGHQFHQDQDSSURSULDWHHQVRU\DZDUHQHVVLV

PLVVLQJ%XGGKLVWVUHMHFWWKLVDQDO\VLVRIWKHSHUFHSWXDOSURFHVV7KH\DUJXHWKDWWKHVHTXHQWLDOSURFHVVRISHUFHSWLRQVGHVFULEHGE\WKH1DL\D\LNDKDWVVHQVH

REMHFWFRQWDFWUHVXOWLQJQXQVWUXFWXUHGRQFHSWLRQIUHHZDUHQHVVIROORZHGE\

0RQLPDKDGKD



WKHWUXFWXUHGRQFHSWXDOZDUHQHVVQYROYHVPLVWDNHQUDQVIHUIKHSURSHUW\I

SHUFHSWLRQKRRGURPKHILUVWZDUHQHVVRWKHHFRQG8GD\DQDQHRIWKHPRVWIDPRXVDY\D1\D\DWKDWVKHQHZRUDWHU1\D\DFKRROSKLORVRSKHUVDNHV

VXUSULVLQJRXQWHUFODLPQUHVSRQVHRWKLV%XGGKLVWUJXPHQWHUFHSWLRQKRRGV

UHDOO\FKDUDFWHULVWLFIWKHVHFRQGWUXFWXUHGZDUHQHVVWVPLVWDNHQO\UDQVIHUUHGRWKHILUVWQVWUXFWXUHGZDUHQHVVKLVEULQJVVWRWKHUX[IKHPDWWHU

,QGHQ\LQJKHSHUFHSWXDOKDUDFWHUIFRQFHSWLRQIUHHZDUHQHVVKH1DL\D\LNDVUHDOO\XHVWLRQLQJWVRJQLWLYHVSHFW7KHXVHRIKHHUPDZDUHQHVVQWKLVRQWH[WRQIXVHVKHVVXHRUZDUHQHVVVQHFHVVDULO\FRJQLWLYHHODWLRQRIUDPHKHLVVXHOHDUO\ZLOOQWURGXFHKHHUPJUDVSRVLJQLI\QHXWUDOHODWLRQKDWVQRW

QHFHVVDULO\RJQLWLYHQFKDUDFWHUROORZLQJ0DWLODOZHFDQVD\WKDWKHGLVSXWHEHWZHHQKH1DL\D\LNDQGWKH%XGGKLVWKLORVRSKHUVQRWERXWKHFFXUUHQFHIDSXUHHQVRU\UDVSISDUWLFXODURUVWKHGLVSXWHERXWKHSK\VLFDORQFRPLWDQWIXFKVHQVRU\UDVSKHVVXHVFDQZHUHJDUGKHRQFHSWLRQIUHHHQVRU\JUDVSISDUWLFXODUVFRJQLWLYH"

7KH%XGGKLVWVZHOOVWKH1DL\D\LNDHJDUGVHUFHSWLRQVDFRJQLWLYHSLVRGH5HMHFWLQJKHRJQLWLYHKDUDFWHUIVHQVRU\UDVSISDUWLFXODUVQRWSUREOHP

IRUKH1DL\D\LNDLQFHWVPHUHO\QLQWHUPHGLDWHWHSQWKHSURFHVVKHUHVXOWIZKLFKVDVWUXFWXUHGHUFHSWXDOZDUHQHVVKH1DL\D\LNDROGVKDWDXVDOLQWHUDFWLRQEHWZHHQHQVHIDFXOWLHVQGDQREMHFWUHVXOWVQDVHQVRU\PSUHVVLRQKDWVQRPRUHKDQPHUHK\VLRORJLFDOKDQJH7KHDZDUHQHVVIKHPSUHVVLRQULVHVDWWKHXEVHTXHQWWDJHVDUHVXOWIKHQILOWUDWLRQIRQFHSWVQGRQO\KLVHFRQGDZDUHQHVVVVWULFWO\SHDNLQJSHUFHSWXDORJQLWLRQRZHYHUXGGKLVWVXVWVKRZKDWKHSUHOLPLQDU\HQVRU\UDVSVFRJQLWLYHQFKDUDFWHULQFHIRUKHPKH

SURFHVVISHUFHSWLRQHUPLQDWHVWWKLVWDJHKDWVKH%XGGKLVWHHGVFULWHULRQIRULVWLQJXLVKLQJFRQFHSWIUHHHQVRU\UDVSIDSDUWLFXODUURPPHUHK\VLRORJLFDOKDQJH$QGWKH%XGGKLVWDVDFULWHULRQQHVVHQWLDOPDUNIDZDUHQHVVKRRGLVWKHSUHVHQFHIUHIOH[LYHHOIDZDUHQHVVHDUHUHIOH[LYHO\HOIDZDUHIDFRQFHSWLRQIUHHHQVRU\UDVSKHQWXLWLYHGHDLVQRWQO\KDWVHQVRU\UDVS

UHVXOWVQWKHRFFXUUHQFHIDSK\VLRORJLFDOKDQJHEXWQDGGLWLRQKDWXFKDFKDQJHVUHJLVWHUHGQVRPHSDUWIWKHPLQGKH%XGGKLVWVVXJJHVWLQJKDWKH

VHQVRU\UDVSISDUWLFXODUVVDFRJQLWLYHYHQW\YLUWXHIKLVHJLVWUDWLRQKDWVUHIOH[LYHHOIDZDUHQHVVIKHHQVRU\UDVS

7KHUHVSRQVHRXQGVSODXVLEOHXWWIDOOVKRUWIKLWWLQJKHPDUNXGGKLVWVFDQQRWIIHUVDWLVIDFWRU\QVZHURWKHXHVWLRQKDWVLWKDWZHUHJLVWHUVDUH

VXOWIXFKSHUFHSWXDOSLVRGH"RHQVXUHKHRJQLWLYHKDUDFWHUIXFKVHQ

VRU\UDVSISDUWLFXODUKH\RFXVQWLUHO\QWKHZDUHQHVVVSHFWIKHHQVRU\JUDVSWWKHFRVWRIFRPSOHWHO\JQRULQJWVQWHQWLRQDOVSHFWKDWVWKHREMHFWGLUHFWHGQHVVXWKH\RQRWHQ\KHQWHQWLRQDOVSHFWISHUFHSWXDO[SHULHQFHVIRUSHUFHSWXDORJQLWLRQHVXOWVQDQDZDUHQHVVIGLVWLQFWLQTXHPRPHQWDU\SDUWLFXODUVVYDODNLQDV

7KHUHDOSUREOHPIRUKH%XGGKLVWVLQZKDWVHQVHDUHZHDZDUHRIDXQLTXHGLVWLQFWDUWLFXODUQDSHUFHSWXDOSLVRGH"7KH%XGGKLVWLVDOORZVDQ\GLIIHUHQWLDWLRQRUFKDUDFWHUL]DWLRQISDUWLFXODUVVDUHVXOWISHUFHSWXDORJQLWLRQ:HFDQQRW

3KLORVRSK\DVW:HVW



FKDUDFWHUL]HKHSDUWLFXODUVLQJWKLVULWRUYHQKLVPLQLPDOKDUDFWHUL]DWLRQFRXQWVVPLVLGHQWLILFDWLRQKH%XGGKLVWDVDUHDVRQRUHQ\LQJQ\NLQGIGLIIHUHQWLDWLRQULGHQWLILFDWLRQLQFHWQHFHVVDULO\ULQJVQFRQFHSWVRQFHSWVUH

UHTXLUHGVDSUHFRQGLWLRQRWRQO\IRUNLQGLGHQWLW\XWDOVRIRUEMHFWLGHQWLW\7KHUHVQRLGHQWLILFDWLRQQVHQVRU\UDVSIKHEMHFWLGHQWLILFDWLRQVDEVHQWQ

VHQVRU\UDVS

WDQQRWULVHPDJLFDOO\QWKHUHIOH[LYHHOIDZDUHQHVVIKHHQVRU\JUDVS%XWKHQQHPD\VNKRZGRHVWKH%XGGKLVWFFRXQWRUKHQWHQWLRQDODVSHFWKDWVKHEMHFWGLUHFWHGQHVVISHUFHSWXDOSLVRGHV"

$VZHVDLGDERYHWKH%XGGKLVWRHVQRWGHQ\KHREMHFWGLUHFWHGQHVVISHUFHSWXDOSLVRGHVQRUGHURDFFRXQWRUKHQWHQWLRQDOVSHFWRISHUFHSWXDOSLVRGHVZHFDQQRWHPDQGKDWKHRJQL]HUPXVWHLQDSRVLWLRQRRIIHUHFHVVDU\DQGVXIILFLHQWULWHULDRUGHQWLILFDWLRQIGLVWLQFWQLTXHSDUWLFXODUVLYHQQVXFK

H[SHULHQFHVKDWVDVNLQJRURRPXFK7KHLQWHQWLRQDOVSHFWRISHUFHSWXDOH[SHULHQFHVDQEHDFFRXQWHGRUQWHUPVIWKHFRJQL]HUVFTXLVLWLRQIVRPH

DELOLW\RGLIIHUHQWLDWHHWZHHQLVWLQFWDUWLFXODUVRUKDWURYLGHVVZLWKPLQLPDOEDVLVIRUHJDUGLQJKHJLYHQQVXFKH[SHULHQFHVVFRQVLVWLQJIGLVWLQFWQG

XQLTXHSDUWLFXODUVWKHUZLVHWVLPSRVVLEOHRPDNHHQVHRIDQ\DONERXWGLV

WLQFWQGXQLTXHSDUWLFXODUVFFRUGLQJRWKH%XGGKLVWKHUHVQRFRQFHSWXDOLQWHUYHQWLRQQSHUFHSWXDORJQLWLRQVDUHVXOWKHRJQL]HURVHVRXWQRWQO\QWKHELOLW\RGHQWLI\SDUWLFXODUDWXPWKHLYHQVEHORQJLQJRDFHUWDLQLQGRULQVWDQWLDWLQJFRQFHSWUFODVVFKDUDFWHULVWLFXWOVRRQWKHELOLW\RGHQWLI\WVDGLVWLQFWQLTXHSDUWLFXODUOWRJHWKHUKH%XGGKLVWQDO\VLVISHUFHSWXDORJQLWLRQIDLOVRPHHWKHQWXLWLYHHTXLUHPHQWKDWFFRXQWVRUKHQWHQWLRQDOVSHFWRI

SHUFHSWXDORJQLWLRQRVDYHWKHFRJQLWLYHKDUDFWHUIDSHUFHSWXDOSLVRGHWKH%XGGKLVWHOLQNVKHDZDUHQHVVVSHFWIURPWVQWHQWLRQDOVSHFWRIWKHVHQVRU\JUDVS%XWKLVRPHVDWDFRVWRUKH%XGGKLVWDQQRWFFRXQWRUKHQWHQWLRQDO

DVSHFWRISHUFHSWXDORJQLWLRQKHVHQVRU\UDVSRJHWKHULWKWVUHIOH[LYHHOIDZDUHQHVVDFXRXVO\HVXOWVQDQDZDUHQHVVXWWFDQQRWHVXOWQDQDZDUHQHVVRIDSDUWLFXODUKXVKH%XGGKLVWDQQRWODLPWKDWKHVHQVRU\UDVSHVXOWVQD

SHUFHSWXDORJQLWLRQRUSHUFHSWXDOZDUHQHVV\KLVRZQOLJKWVVHVVHQWLDOO\DQDZDUHQHVVIGLVWLQFWQLTXHSDUWLFXODUVKLVKRZVKDWKHYHU\QRWLRQID

FRQFHSWLRQIUHHRJQLWLRQISDUWLFXODUVQFRKHUHQW%HIRUHHFORVHWKLVHFWLRQHWXVSDXVHWRQRWHKHWDWXVIFRQFHSWLRQIUHH

DZDUHQHVVQ1DY\D1\D\DKLORVRSK\LUVWO\QOLNHKHHDUOLHU1DL\D\LNDVKHODWHU1DL\G\LNDVOORZHGRQFHSWLRQORDGHGZDUHQHVVYHQQWKHILUVWRPHQWIVHQVHREMHFWRQWDFWKHUHKHHQVHIDFXOW\QGWKHPLQGRRSHUDWHPPHGLDWHO\DVLQKHDVHRIKDELWXDWHGQGUHFXUULQJHUFHSWLRQRU[DPSOHQWKHZD\RP\RIILFHYHU\PRUQLQJDPXVHGWRORRNLQJQWRP\PDLOER[GRQRWLUVWUDVSHQVRU\DUWLFXODUVLNHRORUKDSHQGVRIRUWKLQVWDQWDQHRXVO\HHDPDLOER[QWKHYHU\ILUVWPRPHQWIVHQVHREMHFWFRQWDFW,QVRPHFDVHVDFRQFHSWLRQORDGHGDZDUHQHVV

PD\EHPHGLDWHG

E\DFRQFHSWLRQIUHHUDVS

RIDSDUWLFXODU

XWWKLVLQWHUPHGLDWHUDVSLVQRWORJLFDOO\UHTXLUHGIRUSHUFHSWXDODZDUHQHVVVLQFHLWLVFDXVDOO\LPSRWHQWQGWKLVEULQJVVWRWKHVHFRQGSRLQWKH1DY\D1\\DSRVLWLRQRQWKHVWDWXVIWKHFRQFHSWLRQIUHHUDVSRISDUWLFXODUVVWKDWXFKDJUDVSVRUPD\

0RQLPDKDGKD



EHIDFWXDOO\UHVHQWXWWVQRWQLQGLVSHQVDEOHOHPHQWQSHUFHSWXDOZDUHQHVV

%\UHMHFWLQJKHQHFHVVLW\IXFKFRQFHSWLRQIUHHUDVSVDSUHOLPLQDU\WHSQKH

SURFHVVISHUFHSWLRQKH1DY\D1\D\DHFXUHVWVSRVLWLRQJDLQVWKHGDQJHUILQFRKHUHQFHKLFKVOXUNLQJQWKHQRWLRQIWKHFRQFHSWLRQIUHHUDVSISDUWLFXODUVKHILUVWRLQWVLPSRUWDQWHFDXVHWGUDZVXUWWHQWLRQDFNWRWKH.DQWLDQWKHVLVKLFKVSUHHPSWHG\1DL\D\LNDKLORVRSKHUVKHPLQGQGVHQVHIDFXOWLHV

FRRSHUDWHLPPHGLDWHO\QWKHFWRISHUFHSWLRQQWKHQH[WHFWLRQKRSHWRJLYHVRPHXEVWDQFHRWKLVRWLRQIRRSHUDWLRQHWZHHQKHPLQGQGVHQVHIDFXOWLHV7KLVQXUQDYHVKHSODXVLEOHQWXLWLRQKDWXLGHVKH%XGGKLVWKDWVSHUFHSWXDOH[SHULHQFHVPXVWHFRQVWUDLQHG\FDXVDOLQWHUDFWLRQHWZHHQHQVHIDFXOWLHVQGUHDOSDUWLFXODUV

3HUFHSWXDOZDUHQHVVI8QLYHUVDOHDWXUHV

7KHUHHHPVREHDQLQWXLWLYHRQWUDVWHWZHHQHHLQJQGVHHLQJV7KLQNIKHIDPLOLDU[SHULHQFHIPHHWLQJQROGDFTXDLQWDQFHRPHRQHRXKDYHQRWHHQIRU

\HDUVRXVHHWKHSHUVRQOHDUO\XWDLORUHFRJQL]HLPXGGHQO\RXUHPHPEHU

KLPRXVHHWKHOGIDFHQKHOWHUHGQH)LUVWRXKDYHKH[SHULHQFHIHHLQJDQGWKHQKH[SHULHQFHIHHLQJV7KHQXPEHUI[DPSOHVIKLVUHQXPHURXVDQGWKH%XGGKLVWLOOEHWKULOOHGLWKKHPKHILUVW[SHULHQFHDQEHUHJDUGHGVWKDWIHHLQJUXO\KHUHDVKHHFRQGVDGXOWHUDWHGLWKHFRJQLWLRQDOELOLWLHVQZKLFKUHDOSDUWLFXODUVLGHQWLILHGVVRPHRQHQGWKLVQYDULDEO\ULQJVQFRQ

FHSWV%XWQHPD\VNVWKHLUVW[SHULHQFHHDOO\RQFHSWXDOO\QQRFHQW"DQZH

UHJDUGWVDFDVHRISXUHHHLQJ"1R7RVHHZK\RQWUDVWKLVDVHZLWKQRWKHUIDPLOLDULVXDO[SHULHQFHXSSRVH\RXDUHWDNLQJZDONQDGHVHUWWGXVN<RXDUHORRNLQJWDVROLWDU\DOPUHHQWKHGLVWDQFHXW\RXVHHLWVDSROH$V\RXZDONRZDUGWRXHHLWV\RXQRUPDOO\RXOGVDWUHHQKLV[DPSOHRRVLQWKHILUVWQHWKHUHVWKH[SHULHQFHIVHHLQJSDUWLFXODUQDQHZDVSHFW8QOLNHWKHLUVWDVHWKHUHVQRVXGGHQDZQLQJIQDVSHFWDWKHUKHUHVRQO\JUDGXDO

FKDQJHQVSHFWV\RXSSURDFKKHUHHLUVWRXKDYHKH[SHULHQFHIHHLQJWDVDSROHQGWKHQKH[SHULHQFHIHHLQJWVDWUHHKHVHFRQGDVHEULQJVR

OLJKWKHXQFRQWURYHUVLDORLQWKDWLVXDO[SHULHQFHVDQSUHVHQWLIIHUHQWVSHFWV

SDUWLFXODUEMHFWDQEHVHHQQRZVRQHWKLQJRZVDQRWKHUXWHWJDLQVWKHILUVWDVHWKLVKRZVKDWKHXGGHQDZQLQJIDQDVSHFWIDYLVXDOO\UHVHQWHGSDUWLFXODUHUHO\UDPDWL]HVRUVDIHDWXUHKDWVSUHVHQWQSHUFHSWLRQHQHUDOO\QDPHO\HHLQJV,QRWKHURUGVKHQWXLWLYHRQWUDVWHWZHHQHHLQJQGVHHLQJVLVDIDOVHQH$OOVHHLQJVVHHLQJV7KLVJHQHUDOL]DWLRQVLQVWDUNRQWUDVWRWKH%XGGKLVWODLPQRVHHLQJVVHHLQJV

,QWKHSUHYLRXVHFWLRQZHVDZWKDWXFKDFRQFHSWLRQIUHHHQVRU\UDVSRUDZDUHQHVVRIDSDUWLFXODUDQQRWEHUHJDUGHGVDSHUFHSWXDORJQLWLRQIDSDUWLFXODU3XUHHHLQJGRHVQRWUHVXOWQSHUFHSWXDORJQLWLRQISDUWLFXODUVRUKHUHVQR

FRKHUHQWQRWLRQRID FRQFHSWLRQIUHHHQVRU\JUDVSRIDSDUWLFXODUKHIROORZLQJTXHVWLRQEHFRPHVSUHVVLQJWWKLVSRLQWZKDWH[DFWO\GRZHQHHGWRDGGWRWKH

VHQVRU\UDVSRWKDWWRXQWVVDSHUFHSWXDORJQLWLRQISDUWLFXODU"RGRXEWKH

3KLORVRSK\DVW:HVW



SHUFHSWXDO[SHULHQFHISDUWLFXODUVVWULJJHUHG\DFDXVDOLQWHUDFWLRQHWZHHQVHQVHIDFXOWLHVQGSDUWLFXODUVXWZHQHHGRJREH\RQGZKDWVPPHGLDWHO\LYHQWKDWVIOHHWLQJHQVRU\PSUHVVLRQVKXVZHLQYRNHKHPLQGV+XPHZRXOGD\IRUKHPLQGRRNVIXUWKHUKDQZKDWVLPPHGLDWHO\LYHQRLW7KHQHFHVVDU\LQWHUYHQWLRQIKHPLQGRUHUFHSWXDO[SHULHQFHRUFHVVWRFRPSURPLVHQWKH

SULVWLQHXULW\IHHLQJ

QGUHSODFHWZLWKKHRQFHSWXDOO\RDGHGQRWLRQIHHLQJDV7KDWVWRVD\SHUFHSWXDORJQLWLRQHTXLUHVKHRDFWLYLW\IHQVHIDFXOWLHVQGWKHPLQG

'LVFUHWHOHHWLQJHQVRU\PSUHVVLRQVDQQRWEHUHJDUGHGVSHUFHSWLRQVQ.DQWVHUPV$FRPELQDWLRQIWKHPIOHHWLQJHQVRU\PSUHVVLRQV@XFKDVWKH\FDQQRWKDYHLQVHQVHLWVHOIVGHPDQGHGIRUHUFHSWXDORJQLWLRQ@$HP

SKDVLVPLQHKHLQWHUYHQWLRQIWKHPLQGULQJVQFRQFHSWVKDWUHYHKLFOHVRU

SURYLGLQJKHV\QWKHVLVHPDQGHGRUSHUFHSWXDORJQLWLRQDQWQWURGXFHVKHQRWLRQIDFRQFHSWVDSULQFLSOHRUQLI\LQJUV\QWKHVL]LQJLVFUHWHHQVRU\P

SUaHVVLRQVRQFHSWVKDYHDSSOLFDWLRQQH[SHULHQFHHFDXVHWKH\HUYHROLQNUFRPELQHLVWLQFWOHHWLQJHQVRU\PSUHVVLRQVVGLIIHUHQWHUFHSWLRQVIWKHVDPH

REMHFW7KHSRLQW.DQWZDQWVRHPSKDVL]HVWKDWRPHFRQFHSWVUHQHFHVVDU\RU

WKHYHU\RVVLELOLW\ISHUFHSWXDORJQLWLRQKLVGHDRIRQFHSWVVDSULQFLSOHRUV\QWKHVLVRQWDLQVKHJHUPRUSUHFLVHRUPXODWLRQIWKH.DQWLDQKHVLVKDWZHVKDOO[SORUHQWKHUHVWIKLVHFWLRQRJQLWLRQHTXLUHVKHRVVLELOLW\IUHFRJQLWLRQKH.DQWLDQRWLRQIDFRQFHSWULQJVQWKHSRVVLELOLW\IUHFRJQLWLRQKLVWKHVLVQXUQURYLGHVQDUJXPHQWRUKHODLPKDWHUFHSWXDOZDUHQHVVPXVWHUHVWULFWHGRXQLYHUVDOHDWXUHV

7KLVNLQGIUHDVRQLQJLOOEHUHMHFWHGXWULJKW\KH%XGGKLVWRUZRUHDVRQV)LUVWKHKHVLVKDWRJQLWLRQHTXLUHVKHSRVVLELOLW\IUHFRJQLWLRQVPHWDSK\VLFDOO\ORDGHGLQFHWVVXPHVKDWHDOLW\RQVLVWVISHUVLVWLQJEMHFWVKDWQGXUHYHUWLPHKLVPHWDSK\VLFDOVVXPSWLRQVTXHVWLRQHG\KH%XGGKLVWQGWKLVRUPVKHEDVLVIRUKHRXWULJKWHMHFWLRQIWKHSLVWHPRORJLFDOKHVLVFFRUGLQJRWKH%XGGKLVWHDOLW\RQVLVWVIYDODN"DQDVKLFKUHXQLTXHLVFUHWHRPHQWDU\DUWLF

XODUVGRQWKLQNHQHHGWRJHWQWRPHWDSK\VLFDOXLEEOHRUKHKHVLVERYHGRHVQRWUHTXLUHQ\GHEDWDEOHPHWDSK\VLFDOVVXPSWLRQKHWKHVLVVZHVKDOOPDNHFOHDUDWWKHHQGRIWKLVHFWLRQVPHUHO\QHSLVWHPRORJLFDOKHVLVKDWVQHXWUDOHJDUGLQJQ\PHWDSK\VLFDORPPLWPHQWQGVHFRQGKH%XGGKLVWRHVQRWZDQWRDOORZPLQLPDOPRVWWKHUVZRXOGVD\LQHYLWDEOHLQWHUYHQWLRQURPWKHPLQGEHFDXVHRQFHFRQFHSWVQGZRUGVUHDOORZHGKHUHVDWHQGHQF\RUWKHREVHVVLYHUROLIHUDWLRQIXQQHFHVVDU\RQFHSWVKHSRLQWVWKDWVVRRQDVZHDOORZWKHPLQGRLQWHUYHQHWKDVWKHHQGHQF\RWDNHRYHURWKH[WHQWIFRP

SOHWHO\JQRULQJKHQSXWURPKHHQVHVQGWKHQZHDUHIRUFHGQWRSRVLWLRQZKHUHZHFDQSHUFHLYHQ\WKLQJQGHYHU\WKLQJIZKLFKKHPLQGDQFRQFHLYH7KH%XGGKLVWVULJKWQZDUQLQJXVDERXWWKLVGDQJHUEXWJRHVWRRIDUQUHVWULFWLQJWKHFRQWHQWI

SHUFHSWXDO[SHULHQFHVRWKH

SULVWLQHXULW\IWKH

JLYHQUHDO

SDUWLFXODUV$VD UHVXOWKH%XGGKLVWDLOVWRRIIHU VDWLVIDFWRU\FFRXQWRISHUFHSWXDOFRJQLWLRQISDUWLFXODUV

,QDQDWWHPSWRRIIHUVDWLVIDFWRU\FFRXQWRISHUFHSWXDORJQLWLRQEHJLQKHUH

0RQLPDKDGKD



ZLWKQLJPDWLFQVLJKWVIWKH1DY\D1\M\DKLORVRSKHUVVZHVDLGDERYHLQ

GHQ\LQJKHDXVDOQHFHVVLW\IFRQFHSWLRQIUHHZDUHQHVVISDUWLFXODUVQWKHSURFHVVRISHUFHSWLRQKH1DY\D1\D\DKLORVRSKHUVIIHUQRYHOQVLJKWERXWKHQDWXUHIVRPHSHUFHSWXDO[SHULHQFHVKHUHUHLQVWDQFHVKHUHHQVHIDFXOWLHVDQGWKHPLQGRRSHUDWHPPHGLDWHO\QKHLUVWRPHQWISHUFHSWLRQHVXOWLQJQ

FRQFHSWLRQORDGHGZDUHQHVVQVWDQWDQHRXVO\VLQWKHDVHRIKDELWXDWHGQGUH

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

,QWKHYHU\LUVWRPHQWISHUFHSWLRQKHUHVLPPHGLDWHRRSHUDWLRQHWZHHQWKHHQVHVQGWKHPLQGZKLFKHVXOWVQDQLQVWDQWDQHRXVEVWUDFWLRQIWUXFWXUHWKHZDUHQHVVVWKDWISDUWLFXODUVDSURWRW\SLFDOQVWDQFHIVLPSOHQLYHUVDORUSURSHUW\KHLPPHGLDWHRRSHUDWLRQIWKHPLQGVHVVHQWLDOLQFHZKDWRQH

SHUFHLYHVULVDZDUHRILVEH\RQGZKDWVLPPHGLDWHO\UHVHQWKXVWKHVDPHPRGHOFDQEHH[WHQGHGRH[SODLQRXUSHUFHSWLRQISDUWLFXODUVKDW[HPSOLI\SURSHUWLHVLWKZKLFKZHKDYHSULRUFTXDLQWDQFHKHPLQGHODWHVKHSDUWLFXODUSUHVHQWHGQDFHUWDLQFFDVLRQRRWKHUDVWQGIXWXUHHQVRU\PSUHVVLRQVQGQWKHFDVHRIQHZSURSHUWLHVRWKHSRVVLELOLW\IIXWXUHHQVRU\PSUHVVLRQVKHVH

LPSUHVVLRQVUHQRWSUHVHQWQWKHSHUFHSWXDOFFDVLRQKHUHIRUHKH\UHQRWHQ

VRU\PSUHVVLRQVHLWKHUUHKHVHRWDOO\LFWLWLRXVKHVHUHUHDOSRVVLELOLWLHVQKHVHQVHWKDWKH\PD\KDYHEHHQDFWXDOL]HGQKLVWRU\UWWKHYHU\HDVWKDYHWKH

SRWHQWLDOREHDFWXDO/HWXVFDOOWKHPPDJHVPDJHVQWKLVHQVHUHQRWXUHO\LPDJLQDU\UILFWLWLRXVKHQWURGXFWLRQIKLVHUPULQJVVWRH[SODLQKHQRWLRQRIPDJLQDWLYHRQVWUXFWLRQVLQYROYHGQSHUFHSWXDORJQLWLRQRUKLVZHVKDOOQRZXUQR.DQW

7RVHWKHWDJHRULVFXVVLRQHWXVEHJLQZLWKTXRWHIURPDQW3V\FKRORJLVWVKDYHKLWKHUWRDLOHGRUHDOL]HKDWPDJLQDWLRQVDQHFHVVDU\QJUHGLHQWI

SHUFHSWLRQWVHOI$.DQWQWURGXFHVKHQRWLRQILPDJLQDWLRQSHFLILFDOO\IRUKHRERI\QWKHVL]LQJKHGLVWLQFWQGIOHHWLQJHQVHPSUHVVLRQVQWRRKHUHQW

SHUFHSWLRQVKLV\QWKHVLVHUYHVGXDOSXUSRVHRU.DQWLQFHWOVRVKRZVKDW

FRQFHSWVDYHDSSOLFDWLRQQH[SHULHQFHVZHKDYHDOUHDG\DLGWUDQVLHQWQG

IOHHWLQJHQVRU\PSUHVVLRQDQQRWHUHJDUGHGVDSHUFHSWLRQRUWRFRXQWVDSHUFHSWLRQWPXVWEHUHODWHGRRWKHUSDVWDQGIXWXUHHQVRU\PSUHVVLRQVIRWKHU

SDUWLFXODUVIWKHVDPHNLQGRURIWKHVDPHSDUWLFXODU.DQWQYRNHVKHIDFXOW\ILPDJLQDWLRQ[DFWO\WWKLVSRLQW7KHFRJQLWLRQRUUHFRJQLWLRQIDQLPPHGLDWHO\SUHVHQWSDUWLFXODUQDSHUFHSWXDORFFDVLRQUHTXLUHVKDWRWKHUSDVWDQGRUXWXUH

3KLORVRSK\DVW:HVW



LPDJHVISDUWLFXODUVIWKHVDPHNLQGUHUHSUHVHQWHGUEURXJKWOLYHQRQHVLPDJLQDWLRQQ.DQWLDQHUPLQRORJ\KHDFXOW\IPDJLQDWLRQURYLGHVVFKHPDIRUKHRQFHSWRWKDWWDQEHDSSOLHGQ[SHULHQFHKHFWLYLW\IQYRNLQJWKHUUHDOPDJHVQGFRPELQLQJUOLQNLQJXFKLPDJHVZLWKKHPPHGLDWHO\UHVHQWVHQVRU\PSUHVVLRQVHVVHQWLDORUHUFHSWXDORJQLWLRQKLVVZKDWVPHDQW\LPDJLQDWLYHRQVWUXFWLRQKLFKQYROYHVRQFHSWVVYHKLFOHVRU

ULQJLQJOLYH

RWKHUPDJHVIKHDPHNLQGRPHRIZKLFKPD\YHQEHRIKHDPHSDUWLFXODUIWKHSDUWLFXODUQGXUHVYHULPHKHWKRXJKWHUHVXVWQRWKHU[SUHVVLRQIKHLGHDIORDWHG\*DQJHVDVHHLQJSDUWLFXODUVDSURSHUW\LQVWDQFHKHUHVQRQRWLRQIFRJQL]LQJSDUWLFXODUDVVXFKQHFDQRQO\RJQL]HXQLYHUVDOHDWXUHVWKDWUHH[HPSOLILHG\SDUWLFXODUVKHVHIHDWXUHVUHFRJQL]HG\DVXEMHFWQWKHVHQVHWKDWKHXEMHFWFTXLUHVKHELOLW\RUHFRJQL]HKHVHHDWXUHVQRWKHUHUFHSWXDOFFDVLRQV2QDSHUFHSWXDOFFDVLRQZHDUHFRQIURQWHGLWKSDUWLFXODUGDWXPXWZKDWZHUHJLVWHUVWKHSRVVLELOLW\IUHFRJQL]LQJWKHUDWDRIKHDPHNLQG

7KRXJKKH1DL\D\LNDKLORVRSKHUHVWULFWVKLVODLPRVRPHSHUFHSWXDOFFDVLRQVWKLQNROORZLQJDQWKDWZHFDQH[WHQGKLVGHDWRDOOLQVWDQFHVISHU

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

SURSHUW\UWKHXQLYHUVDO6RPHRIP\UHDGHUVPD\EMHFWKDWQGLVFXVVLQJDQWQG1DL\G\LNDVQWKH

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

1\D\D.DQWLDQKHVLVV

RQO\DQHSLVWHPRORJLFDO

ODLP7KHDUJXPHQW

QWKHIROORZLQJSDUDJUDSKZLOOUHYHDOWVPHWDSK\VLFDOHXWUDOLW\KLVZLOODOVRKHOSLQFODULI\LQJWKHWKHVLVIXUWKHU

,WPD\VHHPWKDWKH%XGGKLVWZRUOGYLHZFFRUGLQJRZKLFKUHDOLW\RQVLVWVI

0RQLPDKDGKD



XQLTXHLVWLQFWRPHQWDU\DUWLFXODUVRQIOLFWVLWKKHXEVWDQWLDOKHVLVKDWVWKDWRJQLWLRQHTXLUHVKHSRVVLELOLW\IUHFRJQLWLRQIKHSDUWLFXODU[LVWVQO\RU

PRPHQWWFDQQRWHUHFRJQL]HGQDIXWXUHFFDVLRQ7KHVXEVWDQWLDOKHVLVRHVQRWUHTXLUHKDWDUWLFXODUVXVWQGXUHYHUSHULRGIWLPHKHUHTXLUHPHQWV

PHWYHQIRJQL]HUVRQO\RQIURQWHGLWKPRPHQWDU\DUWLFXODUVKHFRJQL]HUVHHVWKHPRPHQWDU\DUWLFXODUVDQLQVWDQWLDWLRQIKHRPHSURSHUW\KH%XGGKLVW

ZLOOREMHFWRVXFKDFRJQLWLRQIXQLYHUVDOHDWXUHVQDSHUFHSWXDOFFDVLRQRUHDFKGLVWLQFWDUWLFXODUVDVHOIFKDUDFWHUL]HGVYDODN"DQDQLTXHDUWLFXODUQHRILWVNLQGLQFHUHDOLW\RQVLVWVIGLVWLQFWQLTXHPRPHQWDU\DUWLFXODUVKHUHVQRIXWXUHFFDVLRQRQZKLFKKHFRJQL]HUVSUHVHQWHGLWKQLGHQWLFDOHQVRU\P

SUHVVLRQKLVRQIOLFWVLWKKHXEVWDQWLDOKHVLVHFDXVHWHHPVKDWKHSRVVLELOLW\IUHFRJQLWLRQVUXOHGXW7KHVHHPLQJRQIOLFWULVHVHFDXVHRIKHPELJXLW\LQWKHXVHRIWKHWHUPSRVVLELOLW\KDWQIHFWVKHVXEVWDQWLDOKHVLVKHWKHVLVFODLPVKDWRJQLWLRQVUHVWULFWHGRXQLYHUVDOHDWXUHVKDWKDUDFWHUL]HKHSDUWLFXODUVLYHQQSHUFHSWXDO[SHULHQFHVQWKHHQVHWKDWKH\RQVWLWXWHKHEDVLVIRULVWLQJXLVKLQJPRQJLVWLQFWDUWLFXODUVVDUHVXOWISHUFHSWXDORJQLWLRQRUNQRZOHGJHKHRJQL]HUFTXLUHVQDELOLW\RLGHQWLI\UGLIIHUHQWLDWHSDUWLFXODU

JLYHQQDSHUFHSWXDOFFDVLRQ7KHDFTXLVLWLRQIWKLVELOLW\PDQLIHVWVKHSRVVLELOLW\IUHFRJQLWLRQIKH%XGGKLVWPHWDSK\VLFDOLHZLVWKHWUXHGHVFULSWLRQI

UHDOLW\KHQKHUHVQRIXWXUHFFDVLRQRQZKLFKKHRJQL]HUVSUHVHQWHGLWKQLGHQWLFDOHQVRU\PSUHVVLRQXWKDWXVWPHDQVKDWKHELOLW\FTXLUHGE\FRJQL]HUVQSHUFHSWXDO[SHULHQFHVVQRW[HUFLVHGKHSRLQWHPDLQVKDWKHUHDQEHQRFRJQLWLRQISDUWLFXODUDVVXFKRJQLWLRQVRISDUWLFXODUVDQLQVWDQFHIDSURSHUW\

.QRZOHGJHI3DUWLFXODUV

,QWKHSUHYLRXVHFWLRQZHFRQFOXGHGKDWHUFHSWXDORJQLWLRQXVWHUHVWULFWHGWRXQLYHUVDOHDWXUHVKLVRQFOXVLRQHHPVRKDYHFRXQWHULQWXLWLYHRQVHTXHQFHV

,IDUWLFXODUVDQQRWYHQTXDOLI\VREMHFWVISHUFHSWXDORJQLWLRQKHUHVQRSRVVLELOLW\INQRZLQJDUWLFXODUVQSHUFHSWXDO[SHULHQFHVKXVWVHHPVWRIROORZWKDWHUFHSWLRQDQQRWHDVRXUFHINQRZOHGJHISDUWLFXODUVQWKHWKHUDQGKRZHYHUWHHPVSODXVLEOHKDWHUFHSWLRQVWKHSULPDU\HUKDSVKHQO\RXUFHRINQRZOHGJHISDUWLFXODUVKLVFRQVHTXHQFHVXQDFFHSWDEOHQGZLOOIRUFHVRPHRIP\UHDGHUVRUHMHFWUDWOHDVWUHFRQVLGHUKHRQFOXVLRQIWKHSUHYLRXVVHFWLRQQWKLVHFWLRQZLOOVKRZWKDWKHFRXQWHULQWXLWLYHRQVHTXHQFHDQEH

DYRLGHGIZHSD\VRPHDWWHQWLRQRRXUFRPPRQVHQVHRWLRQIWKHNQRZOHGJHRISDUWLFXODU

,QWKHILUVWHFWLRQHVDZWKDWKHQRWLRQIFRJQLWLRQISDUWLFXODUDVVXFKLVQFRKHUHQWKLVHVXOWVQGHHSHUUREOHPFFRUGLQJRWKH%XGGKLVWRUOGYLHZ,QWKHDEVHQFHRIDQ\LGHQWLILFDWLRQUGLIIHUHQWLDWLRQWGRHVQRWPDNHVHQVHWRWDONDERXWWKHSDUWLFXODUDWXP7KH%XGGKLVWKDVQREDVLVIRUKHXQLTXHQHVVRUGLVWLQFWQHVVIUHDOSDUWLFXODUVQGLVWKXVIRUFHGRJLYHXSWKHLGHDWKDWGLVWLQFWHDO

SDUWLFXODUVUHJLYHQLQSHUFHSWXDORJQLWLRQ7KHJLYHQQSHUFHSWXDOZDUHQHVVLV

3KLORVRSK\DVW:HVW



UHGXFHGRDQLQGLVWLQJXLVKDEOHHDSRUPDVVIUHDOLW\KRVHRQVWLWXHQWVDQQRWH

GLVWLQJXLVKHGKH%XGGKLVWRWLRQIVYDODNVLQDRXQGVP\VWLFDOWWKHYHU\HDVW7KLVXJJHVWVKDWXURUGLQDU\RWLRQIDSDUWLFXODUDQQRWEHWKDWIDXQLTXHGLVWLQFWRPHQWDU\HOIFKDUDFWHUL]HGDUWLFXODUDVVXFK

7KHXQLTXHQHVVIGLVWLQFWDUWLFXODUVVDFRPPRQVHQVHVVXPSWLRQKDWDQ

RQO\EHDFFHSWHG

VDQDUWLFOHIIDLWK:HGRQRWLQIDFWEHOLHYHZHFDQQRWKDYHFRPSUHKHQVLYHQRZOHGJHIZKDWHYHUWVWKDWFFRXQWVRUKHXQLTXHQHVVRIGLVWLQFWDUWLFXODUVRZHYHUVZHVDZLQWKHDVWHFWLRQKHSDUWLFXODUVUHFKDUDFWHUL]HG\XQLYHUVDOHDWXUHVKLFKFRQVWLWXWHKHEDVLVIRUGLVWLQJXLVKLQJDPRQJLVWLQFWDUWLFXODUVQFRJQL]LQJSDUWLFXODUVDQLQVWDQWLDWLRQIRPHSHFLILFSURSHUW\RUJURXSISURSHUWLHVHKDYHVRPHKROGRQIHDWXUHVKDWDQEHRIIHUHGVJURXQGVRULVWLQJXLVKLQJKHSDUWLFXODUQTXHVWLRQXWKHVHHDWXUHVDQQHYHURQVWLWXWHHFHVVDU\QGRUXIILFLHQWURXQGVRGHQWLI\KHSDUWLFXODUWKDWVGLVWLQJXLVKWIURPYHU\WKLQJOVH)RUWXQDWHO\XUQWXLWLYHRWLRQIWKHNQRZO

HGJHRISDUWLFXODUVRHVQRWGHPDQGFRPSUHKHQVLYHUDVSIIHDWXUHVKDWKDUDFWHUL]HWXQLTXHO\:HVHWWOHRUPXFKZHDNHUULWHULDQZKLFKWXIILFHVRGLV

WLQJXLVKKHSDUWLFXODUQTXHVWLRQURPWKHUEMHFWVQDJLYHQLWXDWLRQ:KDW

ZRUNVQDJLYHQLWXDWLRQHSHQGVQWKHRQWH[WKDWVGHWHUPLQHG\FRJQL]HUVLQWHUHVWVWWLWXGHVHHGVQGVRRQ7KHSHUFHSWXDORJQLWLRQQGWKXVNQRZOHGJHRISDUWLFXODUVQWKLVZHDNHUHQVHVSRVVLEOHQWKH1\D\D.DQWLDQUDPHZRUN7KHUHIRUHWKLQNKHRXQWHULQWXLWLYHRQVHTXHQFHKDWZHFDQKDYHQRNQRZOHGJHRISDUWLFXODUVDQEHDYRLGHG

1RWHV

/XGZLJ:LWWJHQVWHLQKLORVRSKLFDOQYHVWLJDWLRQV

,QKHEVHQFHIQH[SOLFLWHILQLWLRQIFRQFHSWVKDOOEHZRUNLQJLWK

PLQLPDOLVWODLPDERXWFRQFHSWVKDWVXQFRQWURYHUVLDOKDWHYHUOVHWKH\PD\HFRQFHSWVUHWHDVWHKLFOHVRVWUXFWXUHKHQSXWURPHQVHREMHFWFRQWDFWKLVZRUNLQJHILQLWLRQVQHXWUDOQWKHUHDOLVWQRPLQDOLVWHEDWHZKLFKVFHQWUDORWKHGLVDJUHHPHQWHWZHHQXGGKLVWVQG1DL\G\LNDVR,VKDOOWDNHWKHLEHUW\RXVHWKHQRWLRQVIFRQFHSWLRQIUHHZDUHQHVVQGXQVWUXFWXUHGZDUHQHVVQWHUFKDQJHDEO\QWKLVVVD\

,WPXVWHQRWHGKDWKHQGLDQKLORVRSKHUVHUHZRUNLQJLWKWKHRU\I

ODQJXDJHZKHUHKHGHPDUFDWLRQHWZHHQZRUGVQGFRQFHSWVVYHU\LQHIQRWSUDFWLFDOO\RQH[LVWHQW0DWLODOHUFHSWLRQ7KLVDQEHDWWULEXWHGWRWKHQIOXHQFHIKHQGLDQUDPPDULDQVRWDEO\KDUWUKDUL

0\SRVLWLYHFFRXQWQWKHQH[WVHFWLRQZLOOSURSRVHQDQVZHURWKLV

TXHVWLRQ.DQWHJDUGHGXFKFRQFHSWVVWUDQVFHQGHQWDOQGKRSHGWRKDYHLGHQWLILHG

WKHPGRQWJUHHZLWKKH.DQWLDQKHVLVHFDXVHLWUHVWVQDGLVWLQFWLRQ

0RQLPDKDGKD



EHWZHHQUDQVFHQGHQWDORQFHSWVXUHFRQFHSWVQGHPSLULFDORQFHSWV6XFKGLVWLQFWLRQVXQWHQDEOHQGFDQEHTXHVWLRQHGQYDULRXVURXQGVRUWKHSXUSRVHVIKLVVVD\ZLOOYRLGKDWHEDWHWKLQNHFDQHQGRUVHKHEURDG.DQWLDQODLPWKDWRPHFRQFHSWVURWKHUUHQHFHVVDU\RUKHYHU\SRVVLELOLW\I[SHULHQFHLWKRXWODLPLQJKDWZHFDQLGHQWLI\XFKFRQFHSWVDWWKLVWDJH

7KH1\D\DSKLORVRSKHUVSKROGKHREYLRXVGLVWLQFWLRQHWZHHQLPSOHQGFRPSOH[QLYHUVDOVQWKHKRSHWKDWKLVIIHUVVDFULWHULRQHWZHHQHDOXQLYHUVDOVQGPLQGGHSHQGHQWQHVDPVNHSWLFDOIKHHQDELOLW\IQ\XFKFODLPQWKHVDPHYHLQDVLQ.DQWVLVWLQFWLRQHWZHHQUDQVFHQGHQWDOQG

HPSLULFDORQFHSWVGRQWKLQNQ\XVHIXOLVWLQFWLRQDQEHPDGHEHWZHHQNLQGVISURSHUWLHVUXQLYHUVDOVQGFRQFHSWV

*DQJHVD7DWWYDFLQWDPDQLUDW\DNVDROS

,WLVLPSRUWDQWRQRWHWKDWKHWHUPLPDJHDVLQWURGXFHGHUHVQRWQWKHVHQVHRIIDQFLIXOPDJHU\KLFKVXVXDOO\VVRFLDWHGZLWKDOVHEHOLHIVPLVWDNHQHPRU\UHDPVHOXVLRQVQGFUHDWLYHULJLQDOQVLJKWKHWHUP

LPDJHKDVDQRWKHUVHDOVRLQWKHVHQVHRIDPHQWDOPDJHUSLFWXUHQRQHVPLQGRUXUSXUSRVHVHUHZHZLOOUHVWULFWXUVHOYHVRWKHDWWHUVH

,WVLPSRUWDQWRQRWHKDW.DQWUHDWVQGHUVWDQGLQJQGLPDJLQDWLRQVWZRGLVWLQFWDFXOWLHVXWKHGLVWLQFWLRQVQRWPSRUWDQWRUXUSXUSRVHVHUH%RWKIKHPDQEHWUHDWHGVPHQWDODFXOWLHVQGWKXVKHGLVWLQFWLRQIQ\LVUUHOHYDQWHUH

7KLVSDUHQWKHWLFDOXDOLILFDWLRQVLPSRUWDQWREHIDLUR.DQWXWWZLOOEH

GURSSHGKHQFHIRUWKDQWQVLVWVQRWKHUHQVRU\PSUHVVLRQVIWKHVDPH

SDUWLFXODUHFDXVHKHLVWU\LQJRGHIHQGKHFRPPRQVHQVHVVXPSWLRQKDW

SHUFHSWLRQHSUHVHQWVKHSDUWLFXODUVVGLVWLQFWQGHQGXULQJEMHFWV$VZH

KDYHDOUHDG\RWHGKLVZLOOEHJWKHVVXHJDLQVWKH%XGGKLVWKLORVRSKHUV6RZHZLOOFLUFXPYHQWKLVPHWDSK\VLFDOHEDWHE\IRFXVLQJQSDUWLFXODUVV

H[HPSOLILHUVINLQGV

5HIHUHQFHV

*DQJHVD7DWWYDFLQWDPDQLGLWHGZLWK'LGKLWLQGMDJDGLVLRI-DJDGLVD\6

1\D\DRSDGK\D\DDUDQDVLKRZNDPEKD

.DQWPPDQXHOKH&ULWLTXHI3XUH5HDVRQ7UDQVODWHG\1RUPDQHPSPLWK/RQGRQ0DFPLOODQ

0DWLODOLPDO.ULVKQDHUFHSWLRQQ(VVD\Q&ODVVLFDOQGLDQKHRULHVI.QRZOHGJH2[IRUGODUHQGRQUHVV

3KLORVRSK\DVW:HVW



5XVVHOOHUWUDQG7KH3KLORVRSK\I/RJLFDO$WRPLVPQ%HUWUDQGXVVHOORJLFDQG.QRZOHGJHVVD\VHGLWHGE\5REHUWKDUOHV0DUVKRQGRQ

*HRUJH$OOHQQG8QZLQ

6WUDZVRQ),PDJLQDWLRQQG3HUFHSWLRQQ3)6WUDZVRQUHHGRPQG5HVHQWPHQWQG2WKHUVVD\VRQGRQ0HWKXHQ

:LWWJHQVWHLQXGZLJKLORVRSKLFDOQYHVWLJDWLRQVUDQVODWHG\*(0$QVFRPEH2[IRUGODFNZHOO

0RQLPDKDGKD

Documents

Perceptual Cognition & Kant