8/6/2019 Peer Critique for Lit Review Final Sills
1/3
PeerCritiqueForm
LiteratureReviewYourname________________________
Authorsname________________________
Itisimportantthatyou,thecritiquer,actuallygivehonestfeedback.
However,youmustdeliveryourassessmentkindlyandbesensitivetooneanothersfeelings.
Trytocritiqueinapositiveway,inthespiritofhelpfulness.Ifyouarebeingcritiqued,pleasebeasopenasyoucantothehelpfulfeedbackofyourcolleagues.Wewillbeworkingingroupsofthree.Youwillbeassignedtoreadandcritiquetwopapers.Iwillbesendingthesetoyouon2/24.Readthepapersthathavebeenassignedtoyou.Afterreadingoncethroughgobackandbeginyourassessment.Format:
1.
First,doesthepapermeettheminimumformatrequirements?Isthelengthisatleast1250to1500words(5pages)
YesNoIsthereaclearIntroduction?
YesNoIsthereaclearbodyinwhicharticlesarediscussed?
YesNoIsthereaclearconclusion? YesNoIsthereareferencelist? YesNo
2. Lookatthesources:Arethere5sources?
YesNoAretheyallinproperASAformat?
YesNoAreallofthesourcesfromjournalsorotherscholarlysources?
YesNoArethesourcesfromthelastfiveyears? YesNo
Comments:________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________
OverallIwouldgivethispaperan:
8/6/2019 Peer Critique for Lit Review Final Sills
2/3
CMechanics:
3.
Next,Iwouldlikeforyoutodoalineeditofthepaper;thismeanstoproofreadlinebyline.Lookforspellingandpunctuationerrors.Lookforawkwardgrammar,improperwordchoice,andunclearsentences.
Markonthepapercorrectingmistakesandcommentinginthemarginsasneeded.4.
Overall,howwouldyouratethemechanicsofthepaper?
Doesitcontainveryfewspellingerrors(nomorethan1perpage)?
YesNoDoesitcontainveryfewpunctuationerrors(nomorethan1perpage)?
YesNoDoesitcontainveryfewgrammarerrors(nomorethan1perpage)?
YesNoDoesitcontainveryfewparagraphingerrors(nomorethan1perpage)?YesNo
5.
SyntaxandDictionDoesitusesophisticatedlanguagethatengagesthereader(inotherwordsitmakesyouwanttokeepreading)?
YesNoDoesitmanipulatessentencelengthtoenhancethetotaleffect?
YesNoDoesituseprecise,clearlanguagethatexpressescomplexideasclearly?
YesNo
Comments:________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________
