Peace Researcher Vol2 Issue21 June 2000

8/9/2019 Peace Researcher Vol2 Issue21 June 2000

1/26

2(see page 11)

Murry Horon. Anti-Bases Cmpigner nd Uncle Sm Host nd Chief Spokesmn for the Undemocrtic Repulic of UKUSAdete the fine points of stellite spying t the formidle front gte of the Wihopi spy sttion Uncle Sm (nd the Police)llowed protestrs to gther t the gte fo speeches nd protest during the Jnury demonstrtions (Photo: /boxss

h :

Dvid defets GolithCll for Inqry into politicl spy1g"Whtever Hppened to the Serpent poem y Mrgret BremnrWihopi Seriously pecefulF ootenote How to uy the oo The Power of PeopleEchelon US nd Brtin use it to spy on their liesInelligence nd Security ommittee New memers sme od storyow to complin out spyingUS Ar Force continues to volte AoteroNZ sovereigntyUS militry c in Philipp1es

Junk VFA wi joins protestOtry Mrgret Hesoert odv Unsung eroMercenries might gt c into ierr LeoneAustrlin spies n sheep's clothing in osovoCops fing U ecre Sevice s hch nne hees

13

15

6

46


2/26

fm 996 SIS bk-!

n Jly 6 o agen o he NZ Secy InllgncSevce (IS ee cagh n he c o bkng no hChchch home o GATT Wachdog cv AzzChody dng acve oong h A Pacc Eco-nomc Cooeon (APEC) Tde Mn Mng.Az ed e Govnmen o 300000 dmg n ae a lenghy legal nd olcl ag h Nonal govenmen eled h c o o co o nndclod amon, l co and bgdgglyaologed o Az (e hvng changed h la o gale ncldng oecvely l SIS bkn B Idg

Th mn ho cagh on o h gn nd oo hvehcl egaon nmbe hch dend hm SIS, D Dvd Small, a Unvey o Cnby lce nd one o he eke a he Tdng Wh Ove conenc hch a beng held o cone hAPEC Mne' Meeng A he me o cchng hook, Davd eng h coneenc nm aghch dened hm a Davd Small, Coo (one o hgence volved n Tadng Wh O ve.

A eek ae ahng he agen, Davd hom aadd by lce lokng o bomb mkng me-al (A home had ledy been add by h coHe aay accomanyng a Mecn ek omTdng W O Lve, on nonal ekng oThee ad ao om ll nexlaned vy elcake bomb le a he Chchch Cy Concl bldng(he Cy Concl had odeed GATT Wchdog o e-move evoly aoved anAPEC ndo dlyom he Concl bldng Incdbly, he bomb n cadboad box abeld n hndng APEC BombEven ange he bomb a lned e he APECMne Meeng a ove hn h Mne b-eaca jonl and ecy men hd gone homeNedle o y nohng a eve ond n h dnd nobody a e chaged h nyhng

Davd Smll alo ed he Govenmn, cclly hPolce He dd no ake co acon vo-loly b only ae he had exhed hoe channel. ly he comlnd ohe Ineco Genel o Inellgnce ndSecy A h Az comln o hme oce no ongdong a deced.Unlke Azz he alo comlned o h Po-lce Comlan Ahoy Sme l In Ocob he led h clm h he Chchch Hgh Co nghe Con o 00000 damg llgng nd

beach o h gh nd h Bll o Rgh Th mdGT :; Genra! Agrmet o Tarifs and ade; nw he Wrld eOraaon, eaded by New Zeaand' ver w M Mre d ecan ae m

Muay oro

l kd hm hy he ed o h mch one eaon h o g head n he Hgh Co (hch hned n eeence o h Dc Co yo hve o o 00000

The c cme o al n Al 000 The heng beoJc Wlle Yong ook hee ll day ( hd been edon o o) I able o end all b he nl aenoon eon

e k Azz B A V B

Th e h mmol od eed by h co

ldng he le ngh d on Az Chody' home, oh bmemen o h lame

Th nd hole lo moe ee among he gem e-vd n h evdene n Dvd e I a on ohoe ho eoly dobed he dom o h ee-enng hmel (A a eeened by leadng Acklnd Qeen' Conl odny Haon) needn' heoed Dvd dd an ab lely bllan ob and n-dd, h eeenng hml eemd o ok n h a-vo a h jdg concened He a alloedo ke h cae no aea ha nkly ed m(nd hm) no o mnon aoly hoyng he eo boh h Polce and he SS Davd lay he game he oe nce and he ad Yo Hono hegh nme o me o k h jdg he an' m e he ddn loe h me hn co emnng co ho abolly bld h anagonmod hm (o ho ddely dloed ma amne- nd mo moanly he ck doggdly o heon bcked by ad o h Plc nd S doc-mn eced dng he dcoey o He e-omd ebly, n on o a vy need blc gal-ly h nclded h aen hogho evalblng ndhe chlden H yng he Polce nkno dced h glley o lod laghe moe hnonc omhng hch dleaed he dge

Th he o o ae h he AnBae Camagn (ABC) ha laydemed o mnn agan he Govnmen Commncaon Secy Be(GCSB hch n he Waho ybe) b ha neve been able o do oThe ccal deence o he

nmo Who co cae Davd a he lan- no h dendan He hd he Sae on he back oo( Az hd done n h landmak ae agn h SIS)

Th n' hng hee eole deendn

mnocmnl chge (nvaably ea ed o n no bod l o n ong beng eaed a Who (n och h h ly been eced by

eace Reearcher 2 May 2000 ag 2


3/26

he Behem jdge who has sised o eepig hehearigs o he very arrow maers ro o himraher ha ooig a he bgger crme beig commiedby he spybase. This was ha rare occasio were aidivida had every ega righ o cosey exame heworigs o he secre ae ad sbjec o very riica scriy

evera acors wored D avd s avor zs casehad o aready creaed a major ega ad poca me

soe, he his sbseqe case wod o have go ohe gro d o mc h o wod have bee mere coecre ad speca B s ow a maer o idispabe ac ha was he whom Davd cagh heac o breaig o zs hose (aogh severa o hePo ice wiesses Davd s case persised reerrig oaoher agecy ad he socaed severa ohe imes ha Davd reerred o he brgary a shese cops objeced ha here was o brgary or hemo vesgae as he were acig awy der oeo heir ow arras The P oice preerred o ca heeves cors e. a s zzs case esabshed he ages were o acig awy becase heir warras

gave hem o eg a righ o brea ad eer) he reorehe jdge was happy or Davd o probe reeessy omay aspecs o he Poce reaioship

No oy ha b Davd he ega yro wo a coe overy mpora ega pis igh a he ose o he hearg The aw reaig o maera prodced he dscoery process say prohibs berg sed ay ohecase Davd sccessy apped o be aowed o maese o doc me s covered zs case. hesehe sed ih eig eec agais Poe wiessesheir e was ha ha hey d d ow he dey ohe perso who cagh he ages ha obody a

ceray o he had od hem was Davd adha heir s bseqe raids o hi ad zs hoes werereaed o ha B Davd was abe o prodce a repor deai how he deiied age ha dbe cagh by someoe weag a coerece ameag ceary deiyg him a s Davd ma Corso

The oher ega pi he wo washe igh o cross exae hiPoce wiesses He oy diered days beore he hearg hahe hapess Crow awyer did oed caig speciic cops ha

Davd cosidered ia o hs caseHe sccessy aped or aadjorme he had o have hereeva cops sbpoeaed ( oecase, haig o be a he Chschurch Centra l Po lice Station be-

ore a m. o he arday beorehe case saed o persoayserve a sbpoea o a very srprised cop) The res o evdecesay preve a awyer cross ex amiig hi ow wiesses. hicase he jdge aowed . cighi ow eesive experiece odeag ih hosie wesses(ad some o hee cops were ds

cy hosie o Davd der cross examiaio The jdge he sa bac ad e Davd g hese eows ohors a a srech was aiaig o observe heirbody agage o he wiess sad Repeaedy heyooed owards he jdge beore aswerig a qesopresmaby waiig or a rig rom h ha hey ddhave o aswer The jdge gored hem ea ig hemo recay aswer he edess probig qesios Thejdge oy sopped Davd o a cop e o occasios (addeie d h i reqes o prese addoa edece o hi

ow beha He was oceay ogher o h e rowawyer er rpi g hi m sevea es o as qes ioad qe ry he drecio o i argme No oy hab he jdge ordered e Crow o podce a addioa Poce wess or cross eamiaio: e ordered aPoice srveace phoograph o Davd meioed by aPoce wess o be pdced a d, whe he a ocaedwo days had i shed rescheded h gs so ha a d day was avabe o sh he case

e hig eeds o be caed Davd made o aempo id o wha he was p o a s pace haae gh ccodigy we ae oe he wiser

sors o specaive scearios have bee sggesede e pv P E ega o dey ay member o he excep he Direcor so he ages caghby Davd have ever bee deied ! ay way odhave bee very dic o ave had ayoe he prodced cor as a wiess ad Da haded h e Car goveme wo d ave ogh hrogevery cor avaabe. The had od s oe day he Chsch rch H ig h Co r 99 s case siey ramac o wara a scae cosioabae by e hpey goveme o preve ay rherega scriy o s acives. The prospec o s spiesbeg cross examied ad her opeaos scrsedwod have dced cardiac ares Davd isey deideda he dd eed ha gh ad coied ega aco o he Poice. B he was a ghosy presecehrogho Whe Davds broher aivey oo phoos e cor he was ha ed p beore h e Bech The

jdges qesio o he Crow awyer was eg. re

& D gy Pk

Rh 3


4/26

y ccrd at aye c havg h phta h aer a ad the eg rthera t f th a arg

T Dvd Sm A Fk A

he r th mmta rd ttrd y e Pcet havg jt grd at grat gth t a-thr atg t gv vdec (premay thg that he a t f pc earht hat gve y a

raay vvd apht f Pce eact t hagthr drty t crt pcy xped ver three gday Prmay thy decdd t fght the cm(rathr tha eg t f cr a happed thz cae they mt hav thght that thy had aarga cae ad ca thy are d t ther prat prcedr ad tgce gatherg meth-d g crtd p crt If thy ady mcacatd

avd had trmp card h had thtac f Pce rep ht ad amar f thr dcmtat that he had

crd der th prtra dcvery prce He ad ever cp the tadhthr thy cd rmmer attdg va pcfc Pce metg ad rfg tdc mar cectd th th he cha fevt Ivaray thy a ad that t a fr yarag thy cdt remmr etc tc h prze get the cp h ttfd that hed t h te th v ver drg a qt cd ferach cp had camed ama avd d pr-dce th revat Pce dcmt t prv that thet had ded atteded th mtg Oe cpa adamat that h cag h had recrded hm

a preet a mta ad that he cd defteyrememr t aedg ay ch mtg he jdgea trgd ag hm that f h cdt rememra maer f ther thg that h a pped thave d h cme h cd ceary rmemrmethg that he hadt d

avd patet t etrmy tt cr xama-t f the Pc te xtractd admthat thyd dcd th vdec drg th cre fth ca (a ega h qrd at gth cvrheet revt f that appared t have tamperd th t remv mt f the SIS. he

jdge aed the r ayr t prvd a epaat h cd

Th Pce vdec ectd dr h cr xamt a aty facatg ad raed mre thaa f eyr the crt tf ad hrght thectry The ra ad fe frmd pd h at t t vtgate avd rga rgarycmpat teted that actg a hch hedecdd t chec ary mt fr the rgar(avd had prvdd the gtaay car regtrat mer t had t f t regtratpate hch the meda atr famy traced ta SI S frt cpay Wegt he cpdy cated t a ary mt here aevr ay drct ctact et the Pc ad

he SIS agt Th cp ad r ac p ad addta car r t th p h gt a rad m-age t rg tr teretgy h t h car admade the ca frm a pc phe a hppremay that th e rpr g ca-er td t Pc rad cha dt hearat the SIS vvmt H pr td hm tdrp th h mattr hch he dy dd

he cmmadr f th ma Itgc Srvc

IS f the hrtchrch Pc tetfd that h gt aca at hm that gh frm tr ag f ay f hdercver agt ere p t ay fy tc erped ad hat h a td he deddthat the dr dd t ft the trtyp f rgaravd aed h h h e p tt a thaer (ct tracrpt ma rgar ar r-

gar ad thee gy ddt r-gar ( d He a prd fr mr partcar H pd that the rgar eredrvg a at md vhc (t t SIStrag ffcr mae r yr p tatted Mar ad that thy dve d

rtcet h they gt aay ththe cp amg that thy ar cmm rgard rgar H dy rag th hrt-chrch had f th S h regar ctact

the atr' cphe ad ad f the pep thmt r h agt H a td y He frraed Mr X f the aget r actg accrdaceth a SIS arra Oc aga he a td yavd ad f ay Pce cr ad t th ar-rat r dd they mpy tae th rd f the SIS eatter hch appar t adard Pce prcedr deag th the SIS Th IS cmmadr th -trcted th cp t aad the prat t appr-

hed the rgar Lght a a hd th rathp e th IS ad grart cp Svraday ar the cdet cp frm the Hy PceStat (th ct t zz h ctactd rt try ad arrag acce t the h (zz a thh ad t fgerprt t a part f a rt r-gary qy (r td thm t t rr a thy hada far dea f h a rpe Whe qtdat th th IS cmmadr cfed that t eepa arge amt f t r ecrt frm thr cp e thad t ffcay tatd that t that th rgarere SIS aget Ided cp td avd thday after the cd that hed ee td t p

yr dy e t f t y IS (h dd aygtha he cr xamd

ther dtctve ttfd that that ameght he recevd a ca frm h SIS ctact ( that eparate ca acdged t ad frm the SI Stht ght h p aed fr hp cag f th

cp h re at t pce th mtehg h aget That mag a d ypaed p the cha f cmmad ad carrd H htd at th md y dcrg thS ma a far frm cmfrta drg thercverat ad cmfrta at rprt-g thr predcamt t th cp he dgeaed th dtctve Hma atre eg hatt , ppe that y ad (t ther detc

Peace Resarche My 2000 Page


5/26

tives would have had a ew laughs about the predicaet the Securit Itelligece Service got ito swe Yes that correct" (court trascrpt I thi weca tae it as read that the cops would have bee rolg about the loor screaig with laughter ad that twould soo have becoe the hot gossp i the copshop He ar about the SI Sses The cat eve pull oa brea wihout gettg caught ad havig our gusset ater the" ou bet the would have had a ewlaughs The probabl still are

W D

zizs case had ot ivolved the Policead accordgl their role i the wholeaar had ever bee exaied up utilow. Davds case opeed a ver wrigglca o wors. His arguet was thatthere was o reaso other tha his havigcaught the SIS agets or hi to havecome to Police attetio He had o covictos o crial record Cop ater cop

testied that es the had o reaso to be coceredabout hi th eir argo he was a perso o o sgicace The oicer i charge o securit at the 99PEC iisters eetg accepted that Davd had beegrated edia accreditatio to the coerece soethig which would have ivolved h passig a securitvettig (ad soethig which was withdraw o securit grouds ro Corso's oe Davies dug the 999PEC iisters' eetig i Christchurch The copstestiied that beore a evet such as the PEC iis-ters' eetig several speciic Christchurch houses adpreises would be placed uder routie surveillaceThe coired that ziz's house was such a targetad that the were ot surprsed to lear that t wasalso a SIS targe The testiied that the ew all thepeople who cae ad wet ro the ChrstchurchCorso buildi (ro which all sorts o protests havebee orgaised

The testiied that he was ot regarded as a sort o

rs The testied that the ew the peop le volved CFCFI (Capag gaist Foreig Cotrolo otearoactio For a Idepedet otearoa aur cogloerate protest group which the believedto be the asterid behid all aer o protestsad to be located the Corso buildig (a quite wrogassuptio o their behal I ght add CFC adFI were etrel separate orgaisatios with verdieret terests ad goals. CFC has ever beebased i the Corso buildig. David's witesses aedthe orgaisers o Tradig With Our ives as the theGTT Watchdog coittee o egh Cooso zNel Wright ad sel David ever has bee o thecottee or eve a GTT Watchdog eber I terestigl apart ro ziz oe o the other three orga-isers was ever eve cotacted b the Police let aloeraided i coectio with the hoax bob or athigelse I put out the iitial GTT Watchdog press release(the ol oe thats ever goe out i ae igerig the SIS as beg resposi flbe or the breai at zizs place ad sa ' . . ' iig that the Police raids

.

were a drt triCkS '. "capaig to sear us as terrorists I ever saw or heard a dic brd ro the StateThe Police issued our search warrats ater the hoaxbob i court the testiied that ziz was the priesuspect ad David was Nuber Two The other twowere ot aed court but it is a atter o act thateither o the was i a wa ivolved with GTTWatchdog or orgasg Tradig Wth Our ves(ideed I'd ever heard o oe o the

Nor was there a suggesto that David had acted ia other tha a proper wa atteptig to apprehedburglars ad reportig the to the Police. Do't tae word or it tr this ro a letter that David re-ceived ro the Director o the SIS I ote our cocer as to the perceptio that the Service a have oou For what it is wrth persoal perceptio is thatour actios as described above were etirel appropri-ate ad what I would expect o a resposible citizeWhile the Service was ot pleased about what hap

peed its displeasurehas bee drected at itsel ot ou (99quoted i court trascript

So how did David Sallsuddel becoe thebac up prie suspect ithis hoax bob aarccordig to the Policetesses because o hisassociatio with ziz Thecops who routiel sproouced zizs surae as Chowdr described h as surl ahabitual coplaier aboutthe pol ice ad a

perso who lved a o v e r g r o w p r e ses (people do't live ihouses accordg to po

Peace Reeache21 Ma 2000 Pae 5


6/26

Iicespe pesons occup pemses. It ws smplstted s given, Poce witnesses tht ssocitionwth zz ws suet cuse fo suspicon tht Dvidws nvoved in cime Even moe so then if he wszzs ltmte hs ws the thust of Police evdence tht the sten elieved tht Dvd lved t zizspce sed on the fct tht t ws he whocught the SIS gents thee hee ws extemel comicl testimon given of thei ttemptsto fnd hm once the niti d o ' house

estished tht Dvd dd not live thee hescoued electc suppl ecods (n teestingevelion of Polce modus opedi) oce thed estshed tht he lved n Rccton Rod the consd-eed doo noc of tht od (the md bogges.Dvid sed gg ovous ueston dd ouoo me up n the phone boo? Becuse I ws n it.ppetl the ddn' Even stge wh did thesech zs oong fo Dvid whe his compint tothe Polce out the ugls the pevious weeedlsted his Rccon Rod ddess?

he most bze testimon out wh the thought tht

Dvd lved t s (he hs neve spet so much sone nght thee ws tht of the gssoots plod whows instucted CS to dve up nd down zz'ssteet oce onl on wee d efoe the PEC Mistel to obseve n pesons o vehcles upon thepemses" B wondefu coincidence mle Cucsi on cce cme pedig out t tht exct mo-ment nd tht infomton eled to CS ws cted(th stght fce s possible evdece of Dvidlvng thee. hen pessed fo moe convincing den-tifctio the cop uthe stted tht the iccle hdtwo whees" In hs cosng ddess Dvd ssledths stng of Polce evidence tht csul sseted tht

mee ssocton wth ths othewise blmeessctzen ws eough to convet Dvd into mo sus-pec he cops mde t undntl cle tht the hvehd t in fo fo ong tme ut Dvd mde the tel-ing pont tht the hd o eso to be inteested inzz ethe He s not cmn n Polce nteest spuel potc suence the cimnlstio of dis-sen

One cops evdence ws in st cotst to ths wehd no pevous nteest n ou" line He ws the CISdetectve who hd een ung o the night of the bun-gled SS en hs SS cotc He ws upfot

nd unepentnt out his tude to Dvid sttg ththe hd een we of hm fo 1 01 5 es dting cto ces tht Dd hd witen n Cosos Ovevew the mid 1 980s hese ces wee nothng to do wthfee tde ut wee out the Kn dependenestuggle in New ledon (Kn. Dvids then wfeSusnn Oune s Kn nd hd hgh pofile noth he homend nd New eld s n dvocte ofindependence. Bth Dvd nd Susnn wee publicfgues n New Zed n the 1980s ecuse of this

ssue (eg Dvid stged theewee hunge stie outside theFench Embss in eligtonwhen efused pemission to visitKn nd his wife he Policehd efused Dvid fiems licence

becuse the wee pent d of Susn gettng ccess to wepons Dvd wo the se on p-pel so he's bete th Poce cou efoe. He sobet coupe of chges ising fom potests duingthe 981 Spngo ou) Susn hs ee livgbc i Kn fo nume of es. his sme cop

testifed tht he hd photo of vd on fie dt-ing fom 1989 tng D potest t OinsB ( Bs Pensu ths ws the photo thtthe udge odeed poduced n cou Futhe tht

Dvds file ncuded etes such s the fct ththe ws noted tendg 1 995 nfomtion on

Ielnd quz nght Chstchuch pub. his evidenceof sstemtc suvellnc spnnng moe th decde includng montong ces d soc nghts oused eebows nd ws put on the font pge thePess he judge sed the detecve wh the Poicehold file on Dvid gve tht he hs o cimnl e-cod. I dont now ws the ep ccomped bwffle out how peope wth o cimnl ecod some-tmes hve diving ofences tht ed to them eng onPolice les Cp hs s ncontovee poof of politcl suvelce the ntegence wng of the Police

(which othe counes functos s ful blow Specil Bnch)

Dvid sed ths detetve f he eeved tht he owedDvd poog he cop epied tht he hd eewong eleving Dvd to ve wth zz ut st believe ou to be peson who m hve hd nowedgeof the plcng of tht device e x b E becuse of ou ssoctons th M Choud nd vous potest ognstions Becuse we ddnt nd n-thig doesnt necess me to me on pesonl -sis tht ou hd othng to do wth (cou tnscipt)Dvid: So ou e sng ou elef of s tht m

the sot of peson ou woud suspect of cmnl ctvitnd tht the on eso hve no cmn convctons tht hve een ceve enough ot to hve beencught et Detectve Not necess. I eeve outo e peson who hd nowedge of the pcng of thedevice I ddt s ou mde t o pcedt (ibid o sum up to ths d tht

fpticul cop consdes Dvd suspect 6'.:in the hox bom f

o d T o?

his is one of the wo mo unsweed questons

isng fom ths whoe stnge chn of events heothe one s of couse wht wee the SS gets up tot zizs the night Dv cught them No expntiohs eve een fohcomng on tht one nd we'e stlloe the wse

So who did plnt he hox om t the ChstchuchCit Council udng s ed deted, t lest oneCI S detective ws hpp to test tht he stl thoughttht Dvd hd somethng to do with i the cops whogve evidence mde much of the fct tht zz hdbee descibed s "ng" when G tchdog wstod b the Counc to emove its pevousl ppovedntiPEC dsp fom the font wndow of the Councilbulding (the Councl hs ened ts esson evng mil wndow dsp we lone dung the 1 999

Pa Rsa 21 May 2000 Pag /


7/26

EC Mss Mg Chschu rch) So hs aary as ough o ma A h rm susca Da h umr To y of hs assocaoh s orh og ha y h m of h olcra o as hous h ofc g sgaas ffcy o logr ayhg o o h omshoax or ohs u h much lssr o of asgolc m (y mag hm sga a oa ahoax om cas as a ra o

A a Da r rgar as m suscs -cas of hr ag om GATT WachogSo GA Wachog as a susc r s As a GATTWachog comm mmr 1 6 a o youca a fm m ha ha ohg o o h E f you o m so a h haol ho o ga y caryg ou such a acoWou o our aaag or saaag Th asr oous E h cos ' rss ha o aa fom A, o ohr mmr of h GATT Wach-og comm as aroach y h oc

Cou ha xrmss from our s of h

fc rsumay ha as h rasog h hcos ssug o ohr sarch arras for o hoha ohg o o h GATT Wachog Al our ours aru h olcal sc ha com u hohg h o oo or h ohr s ofh fc

Da has o ou ho a h SS Th ug hghgh hcocuso h rag Dasrf of c Da cofrm u sa ha as o cra o hscas caus h ha o ay of

rg o ay or aohr as cray a susousy ma hoax om oc sss scr as sohsca a as goo ough oool h xoss x ca o h sc o xam- H orr oa, a oy ar ha h oouc a hoax Th cocuso as ha asma y omoy ho ha sh as oga ho ha h ay o ma a ral om Mos x-raorarly h caroar ox coag ha hors AEC Bom har o (hargsams r amog h ms sough y olc hr sarch of a Da's houss Of al hhgs ha GATT Wachog mgh horcay ha

r o a hoax om AEC Bom os o rahghly

Da ha ursu h mar H ro o h Commssor of oc a h Msr of oc amogohrs asg ha urs ha h oc ma osalsh h hraous of h SS ags (h osh augh) h h hoax om as a. Fuyough hy ma ay a sm u ah suggso

GATT Wachog has o such uams s rss ras afr h ugm sa: From ay oGATT Wachg corrcy f h urgars a MrChourys ho as SS ags W ha cossly r corrc a gay ca cours of

la or h as four yas, s of g offcallysoa a h ay urs of h uh Whoos ha ou ha ha ha o h u ha as oousy a oyoascr Sa ry rcs orao Th hoa om so ao has a h halmars of classc g vcte accs ss ras W Wr Rgh Aga GATT Wachog o AEC SSoc Dacl' 85 as rag a log o o xc aug o acc hs argum a sur-

rs surrs h Bu mar h cox of h cas. Thhoax om so rmas uso ha our o ry srog suscosaou ho s rsos

Ck Up O CpT Jud u W T m

Th gs of Das clam as ha h as h occm of a cosracy h SS a h ocha h as ush y a rum u oc ra cas h ha ay cugh h SS ags n

agnt cto a ha h SS ha go hr mas h cos o g hm caus h marrass hss Th s as aays gog o a fcu cas oro caus h ha ay smog gu c a as r y o g ay

rsgy may rss h cou cas as a ocos caus h Cro ayr am olc -aly from h ous, accg ha h sach aga caus of a ac of grous Sra ms hsa ha h c as o uso a hah oy hg o c as ho much comsao shoul a o Da (h offr $1 h

cosg arss H aoogs o haf of hCro Th ug oo a hs o oar a a cou ofms so a ayg ha as hs rso ofs as acc y oh ss hr as o o cross xam oc sss aou h as ofh sarch of hs hous (for xam Bu h Croascr a h s o coc u rcg ury aymac aforhough oars Da a fy r-cg ay suggso of a cosracy oc acosr scr y h Cr ayr as smy a ggc Pre scuao a rror" , a summary a hos msa Hurg h ug o o aar xmay amags asa ha s a uaaa fac ha som sgrous ha o ur suac H suggs ha ohs Chrschurch cou f slffag h sam of srous c sorr ha hascom o as h Ba of Sa (h mas ross ha shu o h Dcmr 1 Wor TraOrgasaos lfa Mlum Rou mg)

Th ug rs hs cso H a og oma u hs m us or a fogh ( Azzs aros cass rsr csos oo a moh Th ag ugm as r May H rc cosracy (surs surr a acccoc u ruay ry ara hr hr r offr xlaaos h ga h oc h f ofh ou

Pea Rea 21 May 2000 Pag 7


8/26

Te dgeent w qutingtere is n evidence tat Dr Sall antng ter tan a law abding tizen bt suc nvlveent as e adit GA TT Waog was at a

level wic cld nt fairl sggest nvlveent in tea bb ncident Te prcedre epled t b-an te secnd searc warrant o eac av'oe was n defen sible Te udge fund tat it

wrngl descrbed David as ziz's flatate wc adnever been true and tat it prded n factua basisfr an edence tt Davd ad antng t d wt tea bb Te baining f te searc warrant wasslap das t sa te least He fnd tat te relevantfficer did nt act t f alice Te nl sensible e-planan fr is beavur in relatin t te btainng fa searc warrant tat e was acting n autatic lt But avg fund tat e ruled tat Davd culdt seek daages fr trespass because te 50Crwn rceedings ct eepts Crwn dical icersfr lablt n tese srs f circstances. On legalgrnds e als declined t ake a rulng as t

weter te warrant was inva lid

Te dge rled tat altg Davids catcing te SSagents and te lce raid n s use were causalllinked. e cld find n evidence t suppt David'scla i tat te r ad was pa back fr catcin g te spiesHe descrbed te uneplained altering f lice filecver seets as all ver nsatsfact bt nt sinis-er e accepted tat te lce were dut bund ttake an nterest n tse w gt be ppsed t teEC insters eeting but n cntrast te axbb ncident nl invlved an ence f wasting -lice e rater tink tat tis is w te i dentificatinf sspects was carried t in sc an unspisticatedwa

n assessng te aunt f cpensatin te udgerled tat David ad crted pblicit abt te wleting t prvded Dr Sall and is frends wt an pprunt t tweak te tails f bt nstittins e SSa e Poice ndeed te nrespnsiveness ftse nsttutins t cplaints and inquiries b rCdr and D r Sa ll and te paqeness f suc answers as were given seed t prvide frter pprtu-nities fr tail eaking But t case nt just t b eswept under te carpe Te udge rled tat David

was entitled t resen" te searc tat e saw it asnstified arassent f i as an activst w baccident ad bece cagt up n an SS cve peratn ll f ti was eacerbated b te stnewall-ing respnses e receved t is n quiries t was understandable tat e tk te view tat e was beings). lied t

:"r; ,J _ n


9/26

dnce n th hrng of hs cse cnfrmdh h hd ben nwd durng th nesgton nd hs ws h fcwhos ednce n he hrng d thudg concud n effct tht the srchws unusfb ptc hrssmn

h cncudd h t ws not unresnb r h ce o suspec m f nomn nhe ho bmb bcuse n n ntrw I cnfrmd

ose ssctn wh Gt Wtchdg mphsedwh ts prncps nd ngged n some cts ncudng spkng o metngs nd tkng prt n dm-onsron cnductd n the wk f h summ cmng the cncuson t dd th tsefseem ppre of th knd o poc hrssmnthat usc ung consdrd he wrs spct of hscse he I nspcrGnr f negnc nd cu-r ws skd n but h ctons f th I nd noh c b he nerthess unered he ewh t ws nt unresnb for he c to ncuder n h e pp cn for srch wrrn

th se nstgns wr bsed on usnbe ssumpns nd wd prcesss nd nt surprng thrfre rchd wrong concusons s rsu f m prc I h n confdence t nhr of hese cmpns prcedures

ok g acn gnst he rwn on s s resor te ehusng ee othr chnne b m. Un rcnt wod h bn stsfed wthn hons epnn nd smp pog herwns prssn dectu nd subbrn rfus tocncede n wongdng hs ndd u p wsngn errdna munt m m nd energ nd nrrspnsb rg mun f pubc mon nwhen t the s mn th rwn fn cknowdged g b he s red t cm h t ws us n hones mske nd wud no proper nggn stmnt n gns

Que prt frm the oton of m rgh be freefrm unresnabe srch t s dsgrcfu tht shoudh hd nd ur th mn ngus h nd fnncrsk rt gn gns he rown bn sc n h m

o de he Gernmnt hs on poogsdr w has bn cmng ws n honstmske. Hwer s Jusc Yungs judg-men mks cr hre ws much worse hnn honest msk nd n th c dc-sn o srch m hus hrfr do ntaccpt th Grnmns pog I c on heGrnmnt o cknowdg th udgs rungnd pogs m fr th poc hrssment thrsud n the n f m rghs o rdm fhugh pressn nd ssocton nd o m rght ob r frm nresnb srch uher drw hGrnmens non o h bren nrepentn

ude hbed b snor mebrs of h mn Integnce rce f h e ce n rton h sure-nce f pc ddnts nd I c on th Gorn-men nsr ht c ffcers r mde wr

of th drenc ben pc nd cm

I s c n h Gernmen o w nd erhe trms of rfrnc nd procedu mehdpted b th and he nspecorGner Inegenc nd cur (d m prss reaseur dcrs c serched cdmcs hs becus h s soc usc cst 800)

Is worth rrtng h hodr s comp

t th InspcrGnr f Ingnce nd ecurbout the I bekng n hs hous Wh eeonce confrmng n nement th specorGenr rud tht nhng unwfu hd ken pace(cde ngug f he sps hd warrn s sO wn t ct nd go h hsc rng thth I hd ner hd he eg rght rk n nons pc he nspcGnr the dmd hs fndng bsed on hs mskn nterpre f tew ws wrng h z nd d wen tproper chnns bh wre mucked d andhose uhrts pn wrng n he subsuen rcses. Wh shoud nn s he ose

propr chnns

d ws skd b he med hw he fe b sungfr 300000 nd beng wrdd 20000 eedtht th cse hd nr ben bou mon. I wsbout ndcon cerng hs nme f beg susecn h murk h bmb fr an gttng h rhbu dsturbng chn f ns

A W S Em O T S?

G Wchdgs egh ksonso reesd staemen tds press cnference rdctb he meda gnrd hs worth otng

hs chn of nts k pce n h cn G Wchdg orgnsng cs pposed heGoernmnts ssh dherence to trm pes oun resrcted free trde nd foregn nsmnt us pror 6s rde nsrs ngresumb the Nn grnmn regdd GWchdog nd sscs s enms of he e Wedmnd to knw h prsnt Grnmen st odsto h w nd f s n wh grunds

Now ht h nerntn penduum s swngng sfrm wrds G Wchdgs pn of ew on gosn wh re orgnsns such s urss tbng tred s nms f he ? ress ese We Wre gh gn G Wcdg o c bc 8 500

prt from n rper ds press neenceskng f t sn fr enugh r th t mnr tc ctsts (bcuse nobod hd hrd of e hm bomber bfrhnd eth md corge

ws r god nd w run for gd wh hs sn sor h hs ben gng strng r f rs nds nowhere ner fnshd ruce nse re hrd htg e dor O ecu 0

Peae Reseae 21 May 2000 Page


10/26

b h ugmn as las

s Small an h Polc slugg ou n cou SIlan's Inaonal nsu fo Managmn Dvl-omn ouc n ol comvnss angs Zalan a num on o lac o ocon-sm lack o c conols an accss ofogn nanc W a na oom fo an an o go cun ac-coun aanc an omsc savngs D

s a ca of h ols mos a-vanc conom fom manamong h ols mos conomcally chal-ng. ou mgh conclu ha h na-n s lang conomc suvsvs anoh na h couooms h Choury

an Small. u s avc o hos masmns olsn fo clcks on h ln k hos mnsaouss lock a all ms an alays ak a ha hao Washngon Ta us h hol hng vy suc-ncly no conx an no scv Th nmso h alan ol a nly no hos n

h Chschuch Coso ulng; hy a o foun n much mo saluous suoun-ngs alhough som of h mo cackhan hnchmn can somms

caugh flounng aou n ushs Inav-nly Dav ma a vry g cac Fosomon fghng Golah Dav Small asgo a cnmacally aoa nam In hscas Small has on a vy g y

On mma sul of Dav Small's cout vcory as a oaas call fo a Palamnay Slc Commtu no olcal syng y h Polcs Cmnal Inllgnc Svc (CS Th aal as ha y Aucklannvsys Pofsso Jan lsy a omnn an on y a aft of gous an nv uals a unongoungs chuchs acamcs suns c c (Muay Horton nos on half of oh CAFCA an ABC) aal no ha h Small cas val a h CIS uas lgma xaalamnay olcal oos-on h mnal acvy an ha h CIS oas as a uasnllgnc agncy hou vn h mnmal offalv ao h SS o GCSB

Th aal as c o Tm Ban M P (Laou Chschuch Cnal) n hs caacy as cha of h Jusc anElcoal Slc Cmmt Tha com s alay nung no Polc acons agans F T oss ung h 1999 Sa vs of Chns Psn Jang mn an h ol of h Govnmn scfcally h hnPm M ns J nny S h ly n cng hos Polc acons

., ' "._ ,,,

:WHATEVRHAPENDTOSPN?i

They meet in a sunlt paddock The other One urbane n a dark sut Wthout beneft of suit iWrapped n authorty Shvers Ot o place Clothng hs nakednesIn charge. n a protest lagHe sles behnd dark glasses Thus clad he

Welcomes te other Faes the utureProvsonally Cast ou butTo vew but not to touch Sustaned by the knowledgeWhat lourses n hs doman, O good ad evil.Guarded by fery gatesAnd steel ences-The alen fruits

Knowng who the real trespasser sHe shvers

O the Tee f KnowledgesPower But stands irm

old wnd blowsSurreal globest ll n ths reen valley.

Pa Rsa 21 May 2000 Pag 0

Margaret BremneWaihopa.

Novembe


11/26

WAIHOP . 0 -SRV PECFUL

f counlss monsraons a Wahoa

nc 188 ou n an of fomnrsns smly o hs mo" an h olc a on o us Our frs acon of h 2Cnury as hl n h usual lac n husual monh (January ) I n ohr ors r c Polc nrcon gan a cll hon (a no a fully mon xonary forc) as h BC olc lason sons o norha oarKakoua Rc on as a as alays unlssyou ar cam un on of h ors Bu manag o unsan h mssag from h offcr nBlnh m h an o kno ha u o So ol h m s u cam nah as on Fay -

nng hol hug acons n Blnhm an a Wahoaon Sauray, f ach ohr nlssly n cam onSunay mong an sr s W ma no guaran -s aou arsal acons H sm sa -on aou ha

W cam n a n an ry connn locaon juson h roa fom h as h ya coursy of lo-cal anonrs Thy n la on rmly hgh-rssu a fo us I as an a nur us flln g acu u as much aca Oganng h caman all s al as n h caal hans of nnBoy of Rs an h mas Sh such a on

rful o of ha sh arn h uous honour ofng ask o o all or agan n yar

Ths ya as a ll ffrn n ano hr sc BCChrschuch a a cam h som al lansfor fun ms on Sauay No ha an o omna h aco, u ha gn som hough naly monng akfas an fng for h assmlhong a cam as follo y a rfrshng alk ono h as o look a h on h oms Th alkas lsuly h halfaak camrs nng hray on h ualyusln Wahoa Vally oahl h MPacss among us sho hr sklls aalkng on cll hons an alkng smulanouslyOu h fam fnc fsoon h mnacng sgnsou clma a fnc you ga us) Ncky Hagranly ga hs chncal sch on h as shoson) an an sr usons Fu ll y f anaak y o, rurn o cam o ra for hay

May acs n Blnhm Sralcams a cam H arly ck ou nhr fns sy gar o sru scally rar amhls on Wahoa o nnsly cuous shors n h Cy Mall Th nn han a lunchm as o nol h ol ofBlnhm n h nasy ssus of syng u n alghhar man n Symou Sua r oos

Bob Leonrd

h famla sc courhous as h nu

for our sausag sl nclung gaanoons) an BsDrss Sy Cons Tok us r so slghly on g, Mohr Naur connually han o ash us ou

snc h only co as a f rs an h ny saca h as of h a mmoral clock orPassrsy cuous aou h colourful sy cos-ums, lacars an anns an many so for asausag an a cha aou ss Uncl S am as ho rrsn h US Naonal Scury gncy USNS) an o y o sna a f romsng ss for usou a h as Th local ma oo lo h amosh an ha som goo hoo os h ss hng

n rs an hn nchs

Whn cam m a on oclock shar o sa hBsDss Sy Cons h ll h o chmlouy an on cam h ran, as f on cu Bu hcom of h cons oc ayay an h ranso aa of sooks of all ags mrg ona a m, fom ah h clock o o an ug y h cro an Uncl Sam) Th fnalcson on h nn as lf o Uncl Sam, ho haarr jus ha monng a Chschurch o on aU S r Foc Salfr H chos a masrfully s-gus Blnhm local rss n classc nchcoa,

rakshly l mm ha an sns ak glasss orc h o , a manual on syng chnusrn y nny Shly Mns n chag of Wahoa (Th nn as mmay ushr no a aklmo an hsk aay) Sral young sooks for h unor rs hch urn ou hghalusurllanc ks n so n ha may ha nBCs mos unu su al os acy n Bln h m Bumor as o com

T

No ay n Malorough oul coml hou as o h Dfnc Sall Communcaons Saon,Blnhm Wahoa fo shor In ancaon of hss BC mmrs ha sru Passors for hUnmocrac Rulc of UUS urng h sausagsl Thos ho oul s Wahoa oul n aasso o gan ny o US NS rroy as al lry carfully lann, h Uncl Sam layng a oal rol as commanr n chf of h hol all of

a h as, Uncl Sam go off on a USgummn or r sursn h samngof assors an conroll ng accss o h nomally haly gua roa lang o h

n mor haly forf nn sancum of

h sy as h n mhgh chan l nkfncng o h rao an an nnrlcc fnc Rmoly conroll o

Pa Rsarh 21 May 2000 Pag 11


12/26

camera paced traegy ag t ; iI e;fence cmpleted te ecurty enemle. T Illu tratethe effectene f Wapa epene a nd IntmIdatng ecurty Ncky Ha ger and TV3 reprter JnCampell managed t penetrate It ne nght In 996whle carryng a tall ladder and a TV camera n rdert fm te Interr f te cmputer cntr rmtrug a wndw . Tey departed ttally undetectedEtene cerage f ther adenture appeared nnatna TV rtly tereater

Unce Sam wuld nt alw u nde te fence ande wa acked up y an artment f NZ pce andCSB ecur ty taff n te Ind e Te taff nclu dedWah pa' Offcer n Carge We had t e cntentt cnduct u r peece utde te gate UncleS reluctantly welcmed te tr t the frntgate and uggeed qte clearly a prtet act-te were detrmenta t the mth functnng fWapa T depte te fact that we had actuallyrugt a thrd dme t cntrute t te ae Un -frtunately t had een uled y a numer f antae cmment wrtten al er t urface UnceSam. n the rt f ltenng t te ce f the NZpepe agreed t put e dme and meage nte frt Sarlfter ack t NS eadquarter In Mary-land Wee had n feedack n th ne

T te aemled ma f er 50 meme f tepu meda and prteter Green MP Keth Lckeannunced e wuld take tep t ntate a eectcmmttee nquY nt the peratn f the ae andte GCSB Th wa well receed y a ut UncleSam fer a few mre hr harp gly rtcalpeeche frm the ke f Green MP Rd Dnadan d Ncky Hager Sam t patence t u andtld u t ugger f NS terrtry. We tk he hntand left peacefuly fr camp t pan fr the eenngack n Benhem

Vie enin n enei

T fn a uccefu day and afer a de hmecked me al at camp we returned t the Cmmnty Tru Centre wn a 8.0pm f mede ftage an d dn The man featue waa 1 999 utraan TV dcumentary entled BgBrther tenn g" played t a packed he memer f the pulc, and BC upprer anmemer The de ncuded me ecelent ceage f Wa hpa ncudng the famu HageCampe ll n a n and gae a rad pcture f thegla netwrk f aelte pyae run y te US

Natna Sec u r t y g e n c yT meetngwa ne fte ery fewpprtuntefr te NZpulc t eet mprtant dcum e n a r ynce t h unlkely eert e aredn NZ na-nal TV

B C H P a n n n gD I n were generay pleaed Mhana hldng n f thwith the infamousUKUSA pap

ort

day actte fter all we gt me f the et meda cer-age eer ncludng te lead try n TVOne newtat eenn g The try een mana ged t cneycnderae utance aut te eru Iue fWapa and the GC SB Th wa argely due tKeh Lcke elect cmmttee ppa . a prpat e taken eruy nce Ket t n te reeanelect cmmttee Fregn ffar Defence andTrade Nt e underrated were the cu, thegd humur and he nnhreaenng fun n Ben

hem and a the ae

he ack f cnfrntatn and aretae actn waae fr me crm BCer tk ne f thecmmen and we dd make It clea all preterat ur pan were neer Itended t eclude therdng ter wn th ng Bu we d d egtate meemprary cndtn h the plce fr acce heae gae that we dd nt want t each

nyway mt agreed hey had a gd t an ap we hul d t a er agan ne year n hehe hand we mght d mehng cmpetey fnt n fac te place mgh nt een eXt net yeaepe are egnnng t ten t what we hae eenayng aut Wahpa nce 1 88 nd they dn tke I

A AOLOGY TO WLL FOOTE

Here's how to buy a copy of Will Foote's lates book - Te Pow o Peo ,In our last editio n of PR, w e faled to let our readers knw bt y \The Power of ople' Copies can be obtaned through

Page and Blamoe Bookle, Tafalga St Nlo. I o 9.9

Pae eahe 21 May Pag

O) s


13/26

ABCs Januay 2000 pos aon

a h Waihopai spyas ( lwhr thi i f tal E ni ih anoh upsug ofinnaonal laions aou hEhlon po of hih Wahopaiis u a small pa. Vy iflyEhlon inols h salli in

pion spy ass n h U USA Agmn ounis US U Cana a Ausalia an N auomaiallysahng illions of mssags simulanously anoninuously fo ky os n h as of h i play-s suh as h N Gonmn Communiaions S Buau GCSB, his a maial is oll in a

ull auoma poss a Waihopa an sn ungs o Big Boh namly h US Naional SuyAgny (NSA h ols iggs inllign agny

Ehlons xisn as fis al in iky Hag'ssmnal 16 ook S Po an ha sa hall ol ng n a y ig ay Th shokas a aoun h ol Fuh laions am hh 998 puliaion of h Euopan Paliamns Sinfi an Thnologial Opions Assssmn Gouppo nil An Appaisal of Thnologis of PolialCono Eh lon fau pominnly n ha Thpnpal sah an auho as h longsaning

ol xp on suh sus, Biish ounalis unan Campll (ho isi N alan in 1 67) n h sam Goup appo anoh po fomampll nil npion Capailiis 2000 Thisam fo h Euopan Paliamns Commi onCins Foms an Righs in Fuay 2000 Ah sam im Ehlons xisn as offiially onim o h fis im in lassifi US fnspamn oumns pulish on h nn (hNSA islf oninus o fus o onfim o ny Ehlon)

This as all oo muh fo h Fnh, ho ha

sis a y un Amian amps o ominaEuop i poliially miliaily o uluallyMonals ug as n o g gulaly ashy angy Fnh fams) Ehlon i s sn as y an-oh AngloSaxon o opaion o spy on an akaanag of Ama an Biain's nominal Euopanallis' Pais lays ann oun a lass aon sui

agans h Amian an Biish gonmns foah of Fans y si piay las. Simply amping o np ommuniaions is an offn inan (i n h i nss of alan shoul saha Fan is on among sal Euopan ounisih hi on salli inpon spying noksuh nllign has us gon ino h nssCousy of is ol nok of olons n lu ingsal n h Paifi Fan has a gloal nok)

ua HrJuial an Paliamnay insigaions ha n

launh in aly Gman paliamnaians ha man an nuiy. In h US islf a Congssionalinsigaion ino Ehlons implaions fo piayighs gins la h ya Th Blgan Foign Minis sai n f moai sas an a mm oh Euopan Union (Biain) oul ha oganislag sal sponag opaions n o o nfohi onomi inss o h imn of Blgiuman oh Euopan ounis ( Wahgt 24/200 Euopans y U S loni n ps

OK Sp T H Ck T D D

Th Euopans a spally agg y Ehlonus fo ommial sponag, o h saanagFnh MPs laim o ha in ha h EuopaAius onsoium los an $N10+ illion Saui Aaianona o Boing of h US as a sul of EhlonThomson CSF of Fan miss ou on an N2 illion Bailian ona o Rayhon of h US Thsallgaions am all h ay ak o h N alanPaliamn h Gn MP ih Lok ask hPim Mis Hln Clak if sh as onnaou hm. Pious PMs ha fu all ommnon mas of naional suiy u Clak (h Minisnomin ally in hag of h GCSB h is no suh

pofolio as slighly mo fohoming. Sh plha sh as onn u ha sh ha i assuans a Waihopai isn us fo ommial spionag ih y N alan o y h oh UUSApans W a no auhois o an o nopo inllign ousi gonmn hannls. Wpoi inllign infomaion only o h UniSas gonmn fo h pupos of aising in fo-mulaing poliy fghing oism, an poingUni Sas fos Spifially o no poinllign infomaion o Uni Sas ompans foommial o ompii aanag (P 24/200Conn o spying inuiy Sh i h NSA as

h sou of h assuans ( ia h GCSB) W oously oul no xp h NSA o l i o us so ha o ap h assuan in h asn of anyn o h onay () So h you ha fom h hos's mouh spis on' li o i hpoliial mass En h onsai mansamN mia n happy aou all his h Waiato ioialis (25/2/00 Spoligh gos on spyas" ha Hln Clak shoul g Waihopa ou oEhlon (a iky on) an onlu f N alanoms ou of his ih a minimum of mu on fa ill y luky Espionag is a y gam sp-ially hn you g augh ou

Th mansam Amian mia ono h soyno, an n Fuay 2000 CBSs flagship 60 Mm-

Pa Rear 2 May 2000 Pag 3


14/26

u rod e oer gy mi w od er e NZ edi f 6 Mnu or ye wo e e m etter de og dmery frmr C Ne Sunay progrmme ere ig ew ideed r progrmme rke w gdgeg r i dmii frm piipigpy gey e U U grme y e

d eei Nw Zed ewe 6 Mnu d ig o r) od were e gre mjriy of meri ge eir w from ( e fiig Hywd me e Iidr" fr grippg d r of 0 r p i f 6 Minu i i g d i dedy d mr m-p N w mped epod o peeded p epre dig eer o Cgrme rerig m of de oerg of i pr orme pk reed rg ded e ere ee f er g profie mpg

g d mi r er p mety Ieri Cr d dGrpe r i p f iero errr

ere Fom CIA D S:W J" Y, W Do Sp O Ou A. So: W?Gerge e irr f Cer Ieggey CI d irer f Cer Iigeeoer ed f U iege gei deied e U p i rp frm fr e mmer

dg f U ri rpri e w fy rdid y i predeer frmrCI reor Jm Woy i rrdry rie Wa Sr Joua 7300; Wy we py or i I w ig i f

W e r fp regrdig eo d Upyg rop idri We giwi me dr from e mer de Ye myoe rpe frid we e ped o yd i re w mper ot rgd y g kywrd e rope rimeree reprt o e write y rii ri

Cmp prked gy ifm oe rpe U ieige i ded gy frm rp ompe we ge i g i meri mp d p em mpee y rp friedge e. r df f re rope ogy rp mer o y i gey I e mr f re i ry ey erym rpe eogy i wr reg

Wy e w ped y e wr iie ppre frm e C mp rpt i e d f e y two e i w ropmpe gedy ee rge of meriere igee oeo Of omC e

repr y e ompy w gd e rd memer of e rzii germ eei p Of r y w fd ir g wr fferig ri di fi ' fr y f rp pr repor rig my oe d wee pid yo e y rie Yor

mpie prod re fe mre y e eiy ded r o yor m m

peir re y rie ompii reyr germe eer rpe rere r ddie

We we g y y mg ereed we d wrd U mp ie ompei Ied we g germeyo're rig d i ffii we d kedy rrpi pe yo d meim ree rerimi etwe yr rierd e r y r d i oyeme pi d We e Wy d yore? I o e yr mp r rey

more rrp Nor y r reye eed gy I ee yr eom pr i p Crt ( 1 7Cnu Fnch Fnanc Mn an a "a! E wre r i d m mi h hioohica fahof o ak caa E I pe f fwree rfrm yr grm rgy i dme yor omie y m grer dy we g ergg r miy redg rig p fmigyog i d dpg ky gigeom i rm Yd rer g rg e f mig wrd digim a Fnch

ouhy ang onanc of h a E I' m ier kep pyig ri

Cr Ig gy or m eige mry f i i o re pirw Cmmiio foryr g fd 5% f U m ieigee om frm p r W r eo r i dd rry tp we e ded epig i O mpe i m mpi efr o e rfrof de egy W fw f permper d eri em ey ec y

e ed o y fr mmr prp fre prdi f wep f m dri. er i eom iiy je i eri kig Iri mggg

d we oe r e rt er ge fore ef of pefi mri mpe er Cmpe dm we d g e rg mf o y eep wi d egI gr irr e p i r o w C o m m i w mr epii U Iege gire ked egg i idpoge e ig rd refor e eefi of U mpy or mpe e re germ i frm

Pece Reshe 2 M 2000 Pge 14


15/26

g a mmss t k it a this he themmers me t Washigt Weshu rgaize t semiars r them. Oeu ver ur Freg Crrut raties Ata h e use it te eevey, t isurage S m aes rm riig reig gver-et A se u er hy Aam Smth

. i. ..... . .- , reguate iterata teemmuatis es-iageBd EEhe urse reresets the reseta as the ast r the sy agees hey

are aays kg t imrve their raf August

1 the NSA atete a e tehgy r autmatti sig a aeig ata. h is a ita stetars autmatiay aaysg huma seeh iu-ig ve regiti Ehe rks keyrs tes r seeh as suh) rita, the y KSAmemer sti t hae a Offia Serets At istea a Oa rmati At takes a raze arah teetriay syig its itizes a the rest ther. M the ritish itera seurity a iteigeeagey) is uiig a $N mii emai surveiaeetre i L that i hae the er t mitra emais a teret trafi set a reee rit-ai A e a i me a teret serie rviers

eratig ta t rute the traf thrugh theseiy ame Gvermet ehia AssstaeCetre a ha ver the keys t ee erytemessages s that everythig i e mitre. he ias eates a e ffee that t rg thrmati t the Gverme

a eter ge tha Ce r 1 stetury e

es Get serius, E ureas. St amig us a re-rm yu stast emi iies. he yurmaes a eme mre eiiet a ivativea they t ee t resrt t riery t mete the e t ee t sy yu

S tee e have it E he is use t sy aies,t etet a revet the r ime rruti a te a ee ag ie r the har e y Ameri-a trasatas ts retty imsy As ua Cam-e utere yu i eviee rgigery yur uty is t g thrugh the ega resst use it r the eeit S maies here are

mehasms r ega erati etee u-tes NC News Wesite, 14400) Nr as thereay mmet rm Hee Cark aut the rmer CAretr aty a ruy traitg hat she haee t y the NSA ia the GCS )

Ne this aate agry Eurea ariamet Ms,te the site Marh 17 them ut )sge a etiti aig r a iuiry it ritish i-emet i sg Eurea i aies hisas eugh t ge t it eate ritai trie t ki the e-ate eause es that it u re a hieetee yay t the S a Eurea aers a

eause iteigee a seurity maters are rmaystrty ff m ts ithi the Eu rea i ut theEurea ariamet ats the eate t reeus there are es t ame iteratia a t

M yu smetimes e get the ast augh h e Sunday Telegrah rere 1 1 00) that mre tha 1 00sta at the Germet Cm muiatis H eauaersGCHQ the ther mar SAEhe agey) haee mesate y the ritish gemet r hear-g ss ause y t muh eavesrig eemy

trasmisss hst earig auty heahes er-has M eter get i a truk a gasses r use reag eeryys mai

he teigee a Seurity Cmmittee SC) is, mst eieratey t a ariametary Seet Cmmitee. t isa mmiee Gvermet, havig mia ersight the Seurity teigee Seie SS) a Ger-

met Cmm uiatis Seurity u reau GCS) Create y the 1 SS Amemet At it is aays haey the me Miister, h as aays the Mister i Charge the S S a the GCS , athugh there suh ri) he M iks memers; the Leaer the Osit sits it a as iks e memer

h e 1 eeti hage the Germet afer ie years Natia Ne eaa First a varius rag ag eeets he aurAiae at tas Ms a Misters h hae reusy strgy -se the S S a the he emme sy ageies S it as ith iterest that e aaite the e a-itmets t the SC Cark ike her rightha a Rghtig) ma, Mihae Cue the Miister FiaeAiae eaer Jim Aert is y it eg euty M. ey Shiey ike AC eaer, Riharree S ur aes are the Cmmttee Laur Aiae Natia, AC), ut uiy eugh rmas u r the Grees, a Ositi arty ray sutg the Gvermet, a the arty mst mmit-te t g Waiha aishig the GCS a uttig the t t the S S Nt t meti getg theSC tse

h e Aiae Ae u themsees i a et stik hey ha te agast the o 1 0s SS Ame-met Ats a agaist the reati the SC hey ha ee trehat rits the SS a t a esser ex

Cu pg )

Peace Researher 2 - May 2000 Page 5


16/26

(Cnued f g o GSB a Wahoa hr as m gog oo h S a v mor g Ag Msr ag o h SS ars ass H uy ro s y sayg a h s oos h SS uou srv o omm aus ou gor h ray o g Duy ar a Govrm om h SS a S a aus h ou oay rsos or SS o a rguar ass RoDoa. G oar a a ormr Aa M mss o ooruy o sr Jm ovr s

To s r Aro ry o o somhg aou Fruary roam ms avour o a u aramary S omm ma u o Ms rom a ars o ovrs h SS om u ags Ts go sor shrf rom H ar (aour ha uamousy vo aoa avour o os o 99s SS Amm As S a aour ar u y omm o h S a s ovrsgh" Zaa F rsa Wso rs hms a ormr Ag SS Msr rom s 199s go ays a ar ou ave ay o rso o h omm Pess 1 a or mor ass o SS ormao"

Bu s a ssu h oa o v h oao oao Agrm os ao m o uy sagr Mar a osur B govrg raoommuaos aus aour a h Aa o vo agasa or or rs m Th B gav SS or o r org ho a ra ommuaos h Aa a Grs vo agas aour ur o aoa AT a Zaa Frs o g hrougT a ur asy Jy Shy arg H (Ao s a u rso o vr s o S H a u rso o vr o h arra as Ag Msr or SS" (Pess Gov s ovr SS ro ors"

Gr M o as u u a rva Mmr's B g a Sury omm A Ra B a a survv ao ross or rva Mmrs Bs a ro o a Th B ou avsru h S a hav s uos a ovr y a or S omm aour o ours a sagas Th B as May y 1 vos o 16. To s r h Aa o Grs vogor B

Govrm usss as u su a as a r as our" sy ags ar or

Hav you vr or ho ooma aou Wahoa or h Gov-rm ommuaos SuryBurau GSB ouv roay

ar ha h h sg um a Wahoa aa o rg a o your raoa -r ommuaos mas ho as xsas o s o y soog o sray sga srom sa sas ha hovr ovr aSo you may or as o o you ou vro ha you r g s uo Th a s youa o uss h soos you so A as

o oo y vhss you a oma aou you sus s gog o

T O o sorGra o g a S-ury as ra y a sa a ass 1996 y aoa Govrm as ar o a rar ah am o mrov ovrsgh o our soag ags So 1 1 ( 1 o G Asas ha u os o sorGrasa o r o ay oma y a aa rso a ha rso as or may av avrsy y ay a omsso rao or our o a g a suryagy Sou s rasoa u you aou ha susa your oma mgh Srags ar ry goo a g ha hy o a

Bob Leondaugh h a yg Th vry h gh roass o A houry a Dav Sma om o mmmay Bo o hs gm av o ouvors agas govm ags afr Davaugh o Sury g Srv ss ao rag o As hom 1 996 T as hav u sh y a am ar o you T s ho y ar vr o a a sy a o vy

A you ar vr gog o ah h GSB h ao rg your ro ommuaos Tror you ou x may omas rom hu aou Wahoa a h GSB Bu h G Mraur Grg ma h oog amag sam o rs ag o hs 1 999 aua ror Th a hrar vry omas a or ay uryo h avs o Z SS or h GSB as v a rforma o r avs oso mg avrsy o Zaa s

So I ro a r o h G sayg am a a oss oursa o you a ra su a oo aousrv orgasaos hos avs y hr vry

aur ar amos ry h rom u og a sruy rsumay s v oavrs s o m rom GSB syg ou rur o orm h ass or a va oma o your

a Rsarhr 21 May 2000 ag 16


17/26

oce lea e tel l me how I would obtain such evidence If thee is some othe bass fo a complantabout the activties of the GCS whch affect me pesonally wou ld appecate you advice as to what thatbass mght be

In hs espone M Geg did not tell me how to gathehyscal evidence of Waihopai's inteception of my pesonal commu ni cations Fankly I doubt the GCSwould dvulge uch infomation to Geig hmsel but he

clams t would He did ay I n the fist instance acomplainant would need to have a ational belief ofsuch an advese affect o its likelihood in the past outue [Emp has s added] Futhe on he said The degee of factual and othe cicumstantial suppot to theclam the moe easily I can bae an nq uy [sic Thelat sentence doesn t ead vey well but I get the gist of

So thee you have i If you hold a ational belie' youae beng sp ed upo n you can compla n to the IG Itwould be an inteeting eecise fo some indvduals toask the IG f in fact the GCS holds nfomaton in any

fom on them and fom what souces Yeas ago seveal people asked fo the SIS files and a few evensucceeded in getting the li until a change of policdied u p the ouce

f you wish to fle a complaint aganst the GCS andyou can convnce the IG a fome High Cout udgethat you comp lain t is not tivial fivolous veatious oo t made n good faith we suggest you give it a go

hose wth the best chance of some success mght bethose with a ecod polce of potest at the Wahopabase o who have otheise made known he pption to it If you send voice o digtal communcationsoveseas va satellite n which you use vaous temso phases of nteest to the spooks thee ae hundeds if not thousand of such tigge tems in theictonay of the Waihopa system you ae lkely tohave been spied upon Whethe o not you ae of suffcent inteest to the GCS fo them to keep a fle on

you is anothe quetion

Make you complaint n wtng addessed o the I nspectoGeneal of Intelligence and Secuity thoughthe Regta of the Hi gh Cou Wellington And f youget a esponse please let AC know about t LaueGeigs vey lim ted ecod of dealing with complants appallng He concluded that the beakin of AChoudys home ws legal The Appeal Cou sad twas illega so the Shpley govt pomptly changed thelaw Geig also concluded that the police seach ofavid Smalls home a week late lookng fo bombmaking eqpment wa legal The High Cout n

Chstchuch has ust awaded avd $20000 n damages fo the i llegal polce seach

In summay the govenment would like the people ofNew Zealand to thnk we have some avenue of appealand complaint against the eceses of the spie If wedont actually complain then we havent fully teted thesystem Pleae gve it a go and keep us infomedabut the esults

FC C

Y F / W Z Th aticle updates flight data on US militay and Ant-actic logistics use of Chtchuch Intenational Aipot contnues the compilation of flight data fo the 1 990sPeace Researchers No 5 une 1995 and No 14ecembe 1 99 povided data fo the peiod une1 990 though May 1 997 AC monitos the flght using monthly flight summaies poded by the Ministy ofFoeign Affai and Tade MFAT unde povisions ofthe Offical Infomat ion Ac

Since May 1 995 MFAT has povided AC with complete flight data fo SkHecule C130 aicaft flownby US Navy cews and n ecent yeas by the New YokA i N a t o n a l G u a dNYANG io to thattme we only eceived dataon US A Foce Staliftesand Galays TialNYANG flight actually be-gan in 1988 P No. 17 1seie Feb 1 988 p 9 andwee spoad n mot Antactic seaon fo some

yeas theeafe ut byealy 1998 the Navy wasfomally gone fom Antac

7 1

38

47

28

3 137

63

Bo Leonrd

tic suppo ate 4 yeas i n Chitchuch NYAN G abanch of the US Ai Foce now flie all kiHecules nAntactic sevce

n PR No 15 we gave wo main eaon why we thinkthe Ai Foce intead of the Nav y now uns the how 1 I n addition to it logtic flght fo Antactic eseach the Ai Foce alo conducts Channel flights onmi litayntelligence bunes to Austala the Navyhad but a single ole logisti fo Opeaton eep

Feeze Thu the Navy wa ependabl e sup posedlyto save money and the A Foce could contnue sChannel flights unquestoned by the NZ govenmen

97 1 8

85 1 '_J 9 , I3 1 1 0 57 .3

8 9 1 37

79 1 0 73 8

78 1 0 7 l 1 3 \37 100 370

Mltay buiness asuual

The table shown heeeveals the popotionsof US Ai Foce Stalifte and Galay busness thoughout th edecade Thee lagecago planes have vis

ted Chstchuch onm i l i t a y i n t e l l i g e n c ebusness an aveage

Peace Reseache 21 May 2000 Page 17


18/26

f 3% f t ti e li gt Ieate i t t Atat pga a e a ty 37 Ofple gifa teap p peetage fltay fligt I 199899Tty peet I y fate lwt ppt I 1 0ya A pel ia y lk atflgt ata ie May 1999 (tw ee Iate tat telw te I tiug t teyea 2000 T t tflgtyea ata 1999000wll pule lat ti ya P

T eae Calgt atiity ay flt twig w f atty at tuge US Ai atllttig ae at Nuuga

45

4 5C

Vt 5[

' 0 15E: 1z

5

997

I Sut Autala P N 1 9/20 p . 20 f Ifati te fate f Nuu ga pat yea appatly alf t Cael flgt Nuuga a egula weekly ul I wi te fgt wetft t Nuuga f te US (ia Pag Pag ate pa tug Ctu Aipt tei etu t te US . A le aaly f t tg f I ual flgt ay e ligt t qut

T tly flgt patte w t a gapa l a t te f peu ya Blak a wt gula yeau it f litaYItlligeeStal fte a Ga la y aiaft Nte t a p p Iiltay fligt egi i g De 998 Te Atat atgy (wt a Ilu all SkHuleStalfte a Galay flgt ttly ate t Atat lgiti a fa a we a ete e Ota Nee te Atat flgt a paly ute wt te lageapaty Ai weleag plae w a la pg te e uway at Wa iel a MMu

ir Force and Nvy Flightsat Christchurch Ap

998 999

T S kHule flgt e Nay a N ANGLC1 30 a w a a l te gap

Ou gty I g late at Ct Apt y t US Ai e W a ula fee I aely Ou ua fe law I t fe at u ap Mltaytllge u a ee uteu t f Atat a y te US ge t t 1 90. Stalfte a Gala y tat u aipt al ti pe t wt tl te tet Ty a apal f ayig age f ula wap tug u uty ut NwZealae a tei gt wult ae aa f kig aut I Altug ti ul kly tapp g t pt US ulea ptue I tpat f te wl t a tgy t at te US ltayuly wat t kep pe . T a f tea ABC ea te eate a paeta f al US litay pee at Ctu Ap

ABC Commitee Mmbers Bb Lenard, Murray Horon an Yani Johanson tak Laor MP Tm Baet on a our of Harwoo.

Pac Rsearch ay . Pa 8


19/26

usMLTARY BA(K IN PH ESF r sra yars P has wdth prgrss and th tantass ppstn t th VstngFrcs Agrnt (VFA) btwnth US and th Phppns whchwas nay ratd by th PhppnsSnat n 999 n th wrdsst succssu antbass ca

pagns rcd ut th cntury d US bass SubcCark and c) n 99 /92 ut th VFA aws th Pnagn n th back dr wthut any nd t antanprannt US bass n th Phpns. Essntay thVFA pns up a th Phppns t th US tary h nxt bst th ng t actua bass wth spa rghtsat 22 pts and thr acts And t gs ct t th 9 USPh p ns Mutu a ns raty whch hadbn rn snc th 99 Snat t t nt rnwth bass traty

t aws n thusands US trps at a t r ntxrcss whst ssntay xptng th r caaw h rst such arg sca n t xrcs und r thuspcs th VFA was akatan 2000 hd ranuary unt March 2000 th sa sca aancPstn xrcs was hd n ctbr 999)akatan" wh ch ans shudr t shudr") n

d 200 US trps and 2300 Fpn trps. Itsscp xcdd that any prus nt xrswth US rcs xrcng n th prncs NuaEa arac Papanga Zabas ataan Catand Paawan th grnnts dnd that th USprsnc had anythng t d wth th SnPhppnsrw r th dsputd Spraty Isands but th US tarys rst stp was n Pa awan th Php pn prnccsst t th Spratys. t startd wth harts andnds dca and dnta cncs but th bnss nd th xrcs was sra wks uatd jungwaar ara cbat and aphbus naa andngscunatng n a suatd naa assaut n a bachsuth Man a

Unsurprsngy th xrs cntrd n th rr US

bass at Subc (naa) and Cark (ar rc) hr hstcts ngap and Angs usd t b nausr thr xtns sx ndustry t catr r th Gsrth kprs rubbd thr hands wth g agan n2000 thnkng that th gd d days wr back hrAngs hts wr rsd r th trps rst andcratn Un cnnc ngy tary candrs rbth natns sad that th trps wud b undr strctcurw Ph p pn ns M nstr ry Mrcadsad W ha agrd that thy w b prdd wthatrnat actts sty sprts actts n thcaps t kp thr tststrn s dwn (CNew 300) Cd shwrs prhaps Prtstrs n

Mana wrnt cnvncd n a d utd th USEbass thy wad undwar n whch thy hadwrttn prbs assatd wth th rturn UncSa AIS prsttutn abtn and t wast

h US and th Phppns st upMurry Hoo

a spca grup t cuntr adrs pubty and tanag prVFA prpaganda ths ars ut badpubty drng a at 999 U S warshp t t CbuCty) A tta ght USPh ppn s war gas habn schdud r 200 0 an

Pntagn dghtd t gt back nt th Phppns ts gas ar spd ut n th US s patnts 99 Eat ian Sraegy Repo a UStrp 0000 0 ust b antand thr ustb rward dpy nt US rcs n th rgn thrust b accss and basng rghts r US rcs thrgn th US ust antan ts abty t act thcurs nts n Asa

h rst ga tst r th VFA w c wth th cas thr US sars wh wr arrstd n Cbu Ctydu rng a p ca atr akatan 2000 hy wr arrstd and chargd wth assautng a tax dr by thPhppn authrts (bcaus thy wr duty atth t. US authrts ha usdctn r crscttd n duty Thy ac a axu nths prsn cnctd. h udg t th sa wththr warshp atr thr candng cr pdgdthat thy w rturn r a cu sssns h U S Nayapgsd r th ncdn

h Phppns s st grap png wth th txc gacy a cntury hstng ar US bass ApprXaty 80rsdnts ha dd r th cts txc wastsarund thrr Cark Ar as n Fbruary 2000 Xyar d Cr an Vanca dubbd th ch tXwarrr" dd r acut ukaa S h and h r ay drank th watr r th ara surrundng Carkthr chdrn ar srusy Lbra Pary prsntat Wgbrt anada has urgd th Ph pp ns grnnt t su th US at th Wrd Curt t cpth US t can up th ss Snatr Lrn Lgardahas td a gur US bn as bg th pssbcst th can up h US s dnyng any rspnsbty r canng up what an ntrnatna awyr has

crrcty abd t bbs Phlippi Daily Inqu 2/3/00) h ptnta r utur har ns nt n y t ths wh ar arady cts r arn th prcss bcng cts th rr USbass. ngap and Angs ar satd t bcth sts ar cnc ns wth hug US transnatnas such as Fdra Exprss and Arca nLn tutd as ky t st up shp thr. h ntrnana awyr adsd th t stay away: h rsk sns t such crpratns and thr wrkrc. And thr nsurrs ar awar th stuatn thr w bn cr spcay th crpratn r th UntdStats (bd) Arady txns ar spng nt th bas

nts budngs bng rctd n a awans I ndustra Park rght n tp Subc's rr and whch a cckta dupd txc wasts h bass ghtha gn thr psns ngr n

Pac Rsachr 21 Ma Pag


20/26

J V F W P

Nck cBd

. _ " ,. , "Fo he fis rme n nealy a decade. a New Zeaandehas aken pa in pes activities the Phppnes toconn he US 1ia Nick McBde of Wegon membe of the Phippines Soida Newok oAoteaa (PSN) was he Phiippines Febuay, on hoida He took pa In pess agas he' akaan " ex eise and he VF The foowing ish account th hanks to Kapaan the newsee ofPSN Ed

n Monay Feb ay 2 2000 ne i Bayan aoen oe peoples movemens an osans of

omaes esimaes ange fom 20000000) In amoblsaon agans e Vsng Foes AgeemenVFA sgne beween e USA an e Pilppnes

Befoe seing o eeive wo wanngs e fis ae pole g be waing i wae annons. eseon a bes be pepae o ge pele sonesby loals osle o e poes aon ly my eslng feas ne o o be nfone e few polie ep a isee sane an was ly o noeem a all. Hosile loals wee also no appaen nfa e only eaenng nen was a onfonaoni a vey nen Amean man wo obee o my

pesene a e anAmean even Have yo evefog In a feign wa son? e sle a me asyo ay eve fog In a foeign wa was In Viena m '

We sae In Qeon iy (Meo Manla) a 8 a.m an4 veles fome a olofl onvoy wi mae eee o ive o a pon one lomee away fom efome la Ai Base now e la fee ae one)Fom 1 0 a m on I was I os of speeessongs an ans along e lines of ea o e US'Te ay onle w an exemely long mamaybe eig lomees) o e own ene of Angeles

an a ople of wap pspeees eveyngfnally oming o an enafe 9 p m Alogno fo eveyone someo a e p fomMan la msse eianspo ba an weesane n Angeles

Te ne ay eeall e loal papes fonews of e even Teos sympaei alyimae o of0.000 an an sa4 ( I

ea fom one of e oganises was 2000) wleoe newspapes ae no oveage. n any even Iwas a magnifien aevemen o ge seveal osanpeople o aen os of poes a e begnnng ofe wong wee (no one seeme o leave espie eepeve speema ng Wle e ensasm anenegy. ove anAmeanism an e sympaepess wee welom an efesng ompae w polal aivies In New Zealan e ge amon of le an gaffi lef bein was less posve

W w

Te US mliay bases wee lose by eson of eSenae In 1 1 Te VFA oweve poies fo een of US mlay foes fo e ppose of wagames US foes w ll ave aess o 22 pos as wellas aisps an lanng faliies

egal siion ove e Ing pesonnel wll beee o e Amean aies Pl pne aiyoes no even exen o eng passpos o vngpems of US oops Te P lpp nes also as no go nspe sing US failiies no even fo aninepposes no ae US pesonnel lable fo any loal

axes o es Te ageemen effeively ns ePlppines no a liay faly fo e US an nliee fome bases US pesonnel ave aess o a ieange o pos an failes. n anowlegemen of soneseness e ageemen allows smla pvlegesfo Plppine oops ng e US a meannglessonesson

Te ey easons wy Flpin oppose e VFA ae I a sene of Plpne soveeigny maes e Plppnes a pay o US mpeialis

an aggession opens e oo o nlea weapons I wases

a n o e a ng e semembe e neieonfm no eny poli) I l wosen iapoblems s as posiion e easons foi ae selfeven

Tee I no ob vsAmeian oops ll bemae o feel nwelomeHopeflly e moblsa

ons ill onne anevenally p pesson Flipo polns on e vr "

t at a Cak Ecz1 ( U Aba)

Peae Reseahe - Ma Pa


21/26

UYMAGET HLE Murray oro

Magare Haes died n New Pymoh in Noember aged 8 Margare was one o he re heroes ohe New Zeaand peace moemen n a s broadescone and ahogh no an ABC member was we

known o s and ook par n ABC aciies A 72 shewas he odes person who came on he enday ong0 ochng the Bases or whch spanned bohsands an cded New Zeaaders Asraians in and Pacc sanders She was one o hose whocmbed 00 meres n snow and appaing weaherp o he (now cosed) US Naa Obseraory on BackBrch n Marborogh Margare was he second member o ha or o de n See PR /2 or heobary o Dana ngram o Sydney She ook par nsome o o eay proes aces a Wahopa

n 8 Mar gare and were amongs he New Zea

anders and a whoe o o Asraans) n he monong nernaona Peace Brgade o he Phneswhere we oregners and hosands o ipnos drecyconroned h e masse US bases Margare was n-domabe hae a VVd memory o or bs bengopped a oe o he nnmerabe roadbocks p nor pah by he Phppne mary o ry and sop sgeng o Angees Cy and he Amercans Cark ArForce Base A F pn soder came on boad wegheddown by h e side arms bayone and grenadesMargare proceeed o berae hm abo how he shodbe ashamed o hmse she hogh hs was spposedo be a democracy ec ec The gh o a whe hared

grandmoher scodng him n pb was oo mch orhe gy he rned a and ed She reaned an nee n he Phppnes eer snce and was a membe o

he Phppnes Sodariy Nework o Aoearoa ni herdeah as saw Ma rgare n 1 994 when addressed aNew Pymouh pbc meeing on beha o he Campagn Agans oregn Conro o Aoearoa CACA)

She inrodced me o her husband Sam wh hersa orhrghness hs is Sam Hes dyng

Se was inoed n a aspecs o he peace moe-men or decades and was aso inoed n anibasescampaigns bere he AC was born She and Samme n he Engish anwar moemen and once nNew Pymo uh hey onded he Norh aanak Peacerop whch organised many oca aces or yearspacay reoing arond Hiroshma ay hey organised a angimoana Peace Picnic n he eary1980s o poes a ha spybase one ha is negecedby he Chrschurchbased ABC n he s weeks o

her ie she was organsg sympahy cards or Mordechai ann he mprsoned sraei nucear whsebower Her ndamena bees were paciism wordsce and nonracism She was a member o he Regos Socey o rends Qakers hrogho her enre ie

Margare Haes ed a ascnaing and ery ie Sh ewas born Peggy Pee Shangha n 8 he aherwas a maser mariner who ook a shre ob n Shangha Asa aways nrged her she and Sam hodayedmany mes n ndonesia; she was a commee mem-ber o he NZChna riendshp Sociey and raeed o

Chna wih a grop ha was here a he me o Char-man M ao Zeongs 6 deah she was greaymoed by e mass oporng o gre ha she w-nessed)

Aer spendng wo years New Zeaad as a chdher amy moed o Engand were she wen o aQaker schoo She raned as a prmary eacher andagh a aernae schos n New Zeaand se wasamongs he rs o gradae eramray romMassey Uersy wh a BA and she wen on o ge aBEd She and Sam had seen chdren once heywere grown she rerned o eachng workng as a

eacher o Engsh and apanese a New Pymohrs Hgh Schoo Her da ghe Bryony wres eneres n earnng is edenced by he papers o aendance a nmeros semnars or exame on conseng yoh de and parcipaion in oca poeryreadng grops Egsh erare dscsson raeoerseas on cra ors and adenre ors (one owhch saw her narrowy mssng beg nked by he86 Chenoby ncear power pan dsaser n heSoe Unon she was n e a he me She aodeeoped her ars and cras de workng as an apprence poer h a we known Engish sdio poerShe earn cagraphy eaded saned gass and de

gned he amy Chrsmas cards eery year rom tmd s onwards

Peace Reeache Ma 2000 P 2 1


22/26

Sa an Maae Hae ae o New Zeaan n 95 Inay Sa woe a a pine a e Ccc P n e 90 ey pen oe ie ae Rvee Cony in Moea b evenalySa o wo a a pne n New yo an awa ei oe o e e o e ive Sa ie aew yea beoe Maae Se eveope a coen o e woen oveen an wa a voneewoe a an ppoe o e New yoWoen Cene o i ncepon n e 90 Se

wa a vonee o e Rape C Cene an a ee n e boa o e SAFER Cene e aanaoanaon conein an ecain on ea anay abe n e 1950 an 0 e an a ween aene n encoae oe b on beoe wa an accepabe ocia en ine oeb wee en a aneoy caco by e eca poeon an ociey a ae Maae eveope a a ay we an eane a on eavocae o oe bi Se oowe o i ocaconcion an becae an avocae o e oeea oveen caenn e cono o yin anea by ne a eco eave yo conoence a

e oo" e o e nea eco wo e aowe o cay e wie o Sa nea. Fo eown nea e ay aw o a e wa aewee wi a a y on pay e ay n be an wacovee wi pn owe by a wo cae o ee

Maae wa ao a pacone o n Gobay Acocay Se wa vey nvove n oca co n iy ie Ove e yea e eveope n an enp wi Maoi o bo no an o aanaan wa a eqen vio o even a Owae Maae

Waaa n ecen yea e wa vey voca n ppoo e I a eabiiaon cene o ecenyeeae Maoi pone bein e p n e aeSee Hopia ie in e cony epie nobecon o e ne b oo I wen aea an now eabe He na oec wa o oaniean pay o e naaion o payon eqipen ne Waace ace Reeve a a nebooopa ae by e nee o a payon o ocaMaoi pecooe

O conoence o o e cien Cp n acVai Anony yony an an poiica aciv n n e ay Fo eape yony becae awe nown Weinon aci an wa ioaeby Mon n i nao i o coni anbveive wo e an e SIS caie wee ben e ooion o e 9 Spnbo o)

Maae Hae wa a iny oce woan o o e poin o bnne coaeo eneeican a ceaee woe o e e o aniy be n e ae ee o aco e wo i woen e

e a ae e New Zeaan peace oveen eabe oce a becae

T bity wld t b bl tut tgoity d c b Lggt, flt d Mgt cild Ci Cicg(bt tly tcig t t Jty f Ct-bu f f d By lgt Myks t t

BET DVII< - U N U NG H E

Yo on ave o be ea o e ncen a abo yo in Pc R Fo e o ie we nee oacnowee oe wo ep eayn wo ean eenay anonyoSc a oe a en inoaionNoboy en oe an Robe Rvi o a ii Cobia n Canaa

He been enin o o on awe can' eebe ow we o inoc eac e Fo e i eve oany yea e en ey enveope o cippno Canaian an Aecan newpape an aaine bo anea an oveen

en e bo a cope an wen no e IneneNoboy a a an y eep ince Fo e pa copeo yea e a bobae a n a woe o oepeope beie) wi a ee o aeia ce oe eecn newpape V new e an ine e wo Evey eae coe cpee a pe

ona ay pene inocion o Robe ey ae coeco ie n eeve He en a oe aeia an we can eve e o a o

e eevance o a OK awa e eee bn o

He pay an nv a abe oe See e aice eewee n i ie abo ewowie pe o inee n Eceoneae yea A ea ea o a cae coey o Robe e en

aea o Canaa e US ianSnapoe In ia yo nae We ae aea ea bee noe abo e

woe ibac aain Ece n becae o

Weve neve e . now non abo peonay an ave neve poen o So we ee ao iae be pece abo nenaiona an yey we wane a poo i He wen coy on cain o be e nviibe Man an no aveone. Evenay e aee o en 20 yea opap p ae e e o Ea Gean pyae o wo e ny nwn po wa a any

e on o aen n e 950 Wee e e ancane a b Goo n y Robe

Pac sac 21 Ma 2 Pag 22


23/26

RS MGH G ET BACK INO S I E Rb ll1tR( EO (HASE SANDLlBSS UT FwnsH U ' LEON' wEHELP N'VfS,O" Murra Hoon

Suel the enghte n mpverheet f tte f Serr Lene the

ew It h me f the wrt enm n qult le ttt nwhere n the wrl verge lfe epe m the lw 0 fr emple t h eewrke ptulrl vu vl wr fr the ptee he reel pele n h kng the lm f n wh get n ther w nlung hlre Therl h tken nte eue the UN peekeepnge the rget n the wrl mpre f frn h rl trp h prve ngulrl eptn he Gret Whte ther h h t me t theeue the frm f rtn the frmer lnl mte e peekeepng the th m ltr h verrpl turne nt rtn fghtng the reel n ehlf

f the Serr Lenen gvernment etl the t fgut plm tht rtn prte n fr nthrughut the Empre nlung New Zeln urnghe 19 entur New Zeln h uenl tken ne Serr Lene eue we hve uplel terll f l er tngle up n the UN pert

revul Serr Lene w the pernl plgruf the meren rme wh revel n the ttle Theg f Wr the Mngrel f M ure" mght e mrepprprte Thee kller rprtn nmelS lne n Eeutve Outme EO emehuehl n me reult f ther tru 1 997

tempt t lerte" ugnvlle n t frl legun mne n ehlf f the pu New Gunengvernment The were gnmnul rune up the NG mltr n huke ut f the untr therew mr vl unret n pltl uphevl n NG reult Th w ll ull etle n R 1 The e-rur 997 Harpers mgne ere hw EeutveOutme fune prthe er frmer Suth f-rn mltr fer perte n Serr Lene On n w p mue fun frm the Interntnl Mnetry un r mre mmnl the -e mptnt ept f l mn pperet the fulu welth f ugnvlle' pper me

w efnte nentve fr the merere llfteventure there arrs reprt hw n 1 99 tSuth frn merenr plt pprhe SerrLene ml try m mner ut ther fulte tellngthe reel frm the vln n ther r ttk runreetw the ptl ll everne w the nwern tht wht the In 199 t tk 00 mn EOfre ke fur helpter tw mth t uppre the reel t t t the Gvernmet fUS 1 m ll n per mnth plu me mnn g nen fter tht t requre 90 EO merenre t ntn the reel t $US000 per

The glr r hul tht e the gr ?ene fr Eeutve Outme n 1 997 when the Serr Lee gvernment w fre the Wrl nk

t pene wth t erve eue thet f the ntrt The merenre went

t pl ther el tre elewhere fr epellgl n me hrrl untuk n NG u , 000 wth the reumpt f vl wr n Serr Lenethe expert" re llng fr Eeutve Outme t ellwe k n Wrtng n Busmss Day mgneSuth frn jurnlt Smn rer ke Wul rell hve een wful t let EO tke t p m mg nen? ht w t let Serr Lenemnerl welth mght hve een ve well tef thu mtl wmen hlren frm ethmputtn rpe IS fetn n exul enlvement qute n New Zealand rad, 1 //00 mee mre t whtle up the g f wr? Nte tht

m nerl welth rk the tp prrt Sn le lnel Tm Sper frmer th rm er tht Wetern gvernment re t pltl rre t ue mpne uh h . S negn thee l g re hmpng t the leh t getk t ne f ther fvurte kll ng fel

ut f Sper n re hvng thng ther wn w net f nt n h hmeln In Nvemer1 999 utrge tuent frm the Unvert f Wle ertwth lee the wrl tht n few tme Tm Sper w ue t gve p ul leture t theInterntnl lt eprtment H tp w t e

The R le f rvtel Owne rme re Glle Wrl The lle fr nfrmn thgngter n h rket eml 111/99 n fr l t prtet h v h the pwer f the nternetWthn the ertwth tuent h eefle wth nterntnl nfrmtn we emlethem everthng n the uet tht we' pulhe nPR n the uvert h g rethnk. It h feleme nque frm fr fel f n Oen It w wrre ut mltnt em n mpuetth tuent hve he the Queen w n prevu em S urpre urpre t nellethe nttn t Sper ue t unfreeen ru

tne eml 1 /1 19 9 I n h we wn erhpSper rememere the vey rugh tme he h pernll eperene t the hn f the NG ler whete hm then epelle hm hng me vele t kllng hm n thught tht elh tuentmght e eve wre

e re plee t hve ple mll pt n ength glrfe htmn repetle em leternfrm whh t epun upn the neet fr merenr rme n the gll enm rt Wrl prvterme kllng fr prft n me f the pret n wrrvge untre f the Thr Wrl tht the reltf The New rl Ore It nee t e ppe tever turn

a Ra 21 May 2000 ag 23


24/26

AUSTRALlASP I E 1 H EEP'( LOH NNkOOYO

tute eade of wi ae noticed tat mao wa come and go in countie uc a Iaqand te ome eubic of ugoaa a ngua at aconm fo a count bunt b

wa afe wa wtout an mention fom u Te eaon me we ae a e ecait eace moemenub ication not an a u oe one. We do not atemtto be a e acement fo te ate amented lik

ut now and again ometing fom one of tee catatoic wa catce ou eciait attention One ucwa te aet tia and imionment of two utaan umantaan aid woke b Sobodan oeic Seba wat et of ugoaa). Te cagewa ng te wee eeaed afe a few mont non. Natua te men emoe te tannaona ad agenc C) te utaian goenmen

and NTO wc wa bombng Kooo and Seba atte time of tei aet a ind ignant denied i ut teo of ting ou d eect a atbag ike ioec to aege

unni enoug it tun out toae been tue Te wo adnitie miita mateia in teoeion at te time of teiae One of tem made a teeied confeion on Sebian TV

t wa dcouted at te time atoug e owedno obou ig n of totue o coecion) i own mote

tod te utaia media tat e'd ad to eae i e aignme nt in te e enitie Kudi notof Iaq n a geat u becaue of mia aegationb te aqi goenmen of ti eidence wabued off but fute eeation came fom te eto

ome utai an To Pim e inite acom ae te caiman of C utaia In a ebua 2000utaian T inteiew e admitted tat C ad acontact wit te goenment of Canada a NTOmembe to ecuit a team of Oganation fo Secuitand Cooeation in uoe OSC) monito to ef

te ceaefe n Kooo wic wa n ace befoNTO taed it 1 bombing camaign) Te ogamme eeaed tat te monito conited age ofemita eoe endng infomation b ateiteone to NTO but not aing t wt Sebia Indeedone of te aeted utaian wa a fome mao inte utaian m and a fome eection candidatefo ae ibea Pat In fact ed got te Koooob at ae ee eque e mut be one ewe connected fome m office to be and ckedb an ePme inte t wot beang in mind tatutaia unke NZ doe ae an oeea integence gateg agenc name te utaian Secet

Inteigence Sece SIS) wic oeate e mucon miita ie and wc a egua woked ingoba otot fo Weten inte igence ae ao

admtted tat te two menad in tei oeion wenaeted nfomaton on toomoement tank tion

and mnefied a wtten in wat ae decibed a miita anguage"Tee eeation o oified aeC P mnde tat one tied to coect im on ai ae euted onot nteut wen I am being inteewed and do noee inteut agan o ou undetand SSTVD quoted on Wod Sociat Web Ste [ wwog /2/00 New infomation on te cae of wojaied utaia n aid woke)

T Bdd Fm T CIA

Te ikeiood of tee ae uie being e n ceae damatca we ou dig nto te eat of teOSC miion Conide te fact tat t bo wa temeican Wiiam Wake a Centa Inteigencegenc CI) man wit a ong and bood tack ecodtoug te meican cane oue of centameica in te 1 80 Te foowing i fom an eectonic oting entited eet aace om Saado To Kooo Te US ood Tai ak me& att Tabibi 304

ccoding to aou newae eot Wake began i diomatc caee in 161 in Peu e ten e

oed ent mot of i ong caee in te foeigneice in Centa and Sout meca incudng aig contoeia oting a eut Cief of ionn ondua in te ea 180 eact te tme andace wee te Conta ebe foce wa fomed TeConta foce wa te conetone of tenCI ectoWiiam Cae adine antCommunit diectie andondua wa conideed aong wit Saado tefont ine in te wa wit te Soiet Union om teeWake wa omoted in 1 85 to te ot of eutitant Seceta of State fo Centa meica. Tomotion made im a cia aitant to tantSeceta of State iot bam a figue woe name

woud oon be making it wa nto te eadine on ada bai n connecton wit a new canda te ewa caing te IanConta afai

Wake woud oon bif jn i bo unde te ubic mcocoe coding to infomation contaned nIndeend ent Coune Lawence Wa engt ndctment of bam and Oie Not Wake wa eonibe fo etting u a on umanitaian oeaton atan abae in Iango Saado. Ti e oganaton wa ued to funne gun ammuntion and ue to te Conta ebe n Ncaagua

eite aing been named in Wa ndctmentatoug e wa nee caged imef and outed nte ntenatona e a a gununne Wake dio

eace esearcher 21 " May 2000 " age 24


25/26

ma ae o as oe mgh hae pe aa u o he ose Ol eough p o aag I e as ame ambassao o El Salao a sae hh a he me as sll he gp o Spoe Sae eo

Was eo as Ambassao o El Saao s salg p ee oa lgh o hs ee mge o he ol spolgh as a ouageoum o as haemes s ue posue

moal sgus oa Seba eh leasg masem og oa bu ha o squa h helmos omall alous ee he osselhbe oa eal he same s o hae mshl eg El Salao

I la 99 he Salaoa soles eeue esu pess he houseeepe a he 1 eaolaghe bg he heas off h shogus Waleae bae a eel Whe ase a a pess oee abo eee lg he llgs o he Salaoa gh omma he o o hs a o apolog o he o saf Ree Emlo Poe. smg he

us as a so o ogabl opoae glh leg o o eo oe Ma agm e ool poblms a es hese s o hese s o suaos sa

I sussg he e poblem o sae olee apsso hh El Salao he as a eas oess spea ha he Seba he mooe omOob 99 Mah 1 999 Wale as emaabl umspe Im o oog b mes lehs o gea emoo a gea age hgs le hshapp he sa appael hag o e ee oauo o he OSCE ob

all. ha ma be he mos amazg saeme oall ge h ue oupao Wale quesoe heab o a peso o ogazao o assg blame ha me ases Shuggg of es o eeess

epos ha he esu mues ha beeomme b me Salaoa amuoms Wale ol Massahusesogessma Joe Moale ha aoea ge uoms Th a ha he eeesse mla uoms as o

poo ha h ee ma

Lae Wale ol eomme o Seea o Sae ames Bae ha he Saes o eopaze' s eaoshp h El Salao b esgagpas ahs hoee heo us Ths al a o omme omg oma ma ho oul lae eomme ha he eSaes go o a oe heous eahs

Oe al gug bogaphal oe Wale 99hose a eemo Washgo hel hoo 000 Amea soles ho ough seel El Saao Whle Wale as Ambassao o El Salaohe S goemes offal so as ha he eeol 50 mla asos he ou agP Ma 6 996 The o ha Wale ashage h moog Seba huma ghs abuses Kosoo a hs ulg ha he Jaua 999 RaaMassae" o Albaas beame he usao o heollog a b NATO Se ha me hee has beeoseabe eee o opeaoal ls beee h

CIA a ohe Wese ellgee agees h hKosoo Lbeao Am (LA) hh as ghg Mose s Sebs Thee hae bee Wese mea soes ha he Albaa peasas massae a Raaee auall ea ghes esse lalohes o popagaa pu poses

OSE ha ohe ls o he A The S eaoeam as ompose o emploees o Dop A he1 992 Seae heag o appo James Woolse as CADeo (see he Ehelon ale elsehee h ssueo Woolse's eaa amo o S ommeal espoage agas s alles ) he ommee ha

h as a shaehole a ha hae hasome IA oas hh as auall oe o Colomba a Peu)

I all as up o a ugl pe o spes a he mlausg a agees as oopeae oe o ug espoag opeaos a oes o ohe aeas hhhe hemseles oul hae ouble aessg. Those humaaa GOs ho ae alas s oh see he ouble eups ma e el o beha he seem

ABOUT PEE RESERHER

Pace eahe pu blshe hee ms a ea b he ABases ampag Ch shuh The eos aeMua oo a Bob Leoa Ou laou as Melae Thomso Ou oua oes a age o peaessues h emphass o oeg ma bases a ellge ops Cobue ales ll be oeo pubao base o sube mae a spae eqemes We ae paulal eese epos ogal eseah o peae Aoeaoa a h ego o Ausalasa a he a

O aes SPeace Researhr

P,O Box 58

ChistchucAaoa/New Zeaan d-ml: [email protected]

Rh 21 My 2 2


26/26

s eale a gea lengh elsewhee n hs sse see

he so on a Smalls sccessl co caseagans he Polce he cops ae e poece oohe sc agences he Sec Inellgence See ha case. oncall enogh he haepblc name he US Sece Sece as pme sspec n he nsole hef of a poes banne ngPesen Clnons Sepembe 999 Sae s oChschch see PR 1920 fr verage B C rs ug s sit. Ed)

e solen banne belonge o he Sen ChsanMoemen o oeaoa I ea Clnon ame nonesan lles hs was a he hegh of he Eas mo

ss) an he fee n o el he sh o she nnocen bloo I was n he capaof Chschch Cenal's Labo MP m ane whose offce s eclose o he Caheal Sae hoelwch was he base o Clnon anhs flng ccs olnee n hsoffce wnesse he hef an escbe he hef as a well esseman weang a hee pece blac s Ma 000 he Polce eleasehe e on he mae o ane ann It he negang offce con

cle obless afe hang elm-nae ohe blac se sspecssh as Momons neaes an

eas offcals) ang eewe he fle wol

appea o me he banne was emoe b one of heSece Sece saff aache o he Clnos Press 8500 US agen sspece of hefane sa ha he wll as he US Embass f amecan offal was nole n sealng h e ban ne

In hs case we congalae he Polce n leg hechps all whee he ma n shame on he paanos who ae esponsble fo he US Pesens sec. Soopng o seal a poes banne n peacefllle ol New Zealan whch wen embaassnglgaga oe Clnons s eall clos We eman an I paae of all men n he Whe ose

weang hee pece blac ss Snglasses eapeces an blgng amps aeohe geawa sgns. We sha he Polce ll ollow henew fon zeal o he mecan polce ph losoph o eooleance fo pe cme anchase hs well esse hewh he fll go of he lawOhewse hese gs wllgaae o walng aonwh conceae weapons analng no he wswaches

whls fxng eebo wh a 000 a sae Fl l blowpschos n sho

Subscribe to Pa RahPeae Researher he newslee an ona of he Chschch nases Campa gn I o wolle o on C please fll n he om below l l C membes ecee Peae Researher Membeshp!Sbscpon s $0 pe ea fo hee sses. PR no GS egsee Chees paable o Peae Re

earhe Sen o ox 58 Chschch New Zealan

Nm

Add-SuDoo $$To $___

onaons welcome Oeseas sbs amal) sala NZ$5 Ohe NZ$0

Documents

Peace Researcher Vol2 Issue21 June 2000