Peace Corps New Programs In Former Eastern Block Should Be Strengthened - General Accounting Office - National Security and International Affairs Division

8/6/2019 Peace Corps New Programs In Former Eastern Block Should Be Strengthened - General Accounting Office - National Security and International Affairs Division

1/24

Whizgj ]zbzg} Fghg~ba Bmmcwhzihf Ckkimg

FBC ^gpc~z zc Mchf~g}}ichba ^grwg}zg~}

Jgmgong~ 299:

PGBMG MC^P]

Hgv P~cf~bo} ihKc~og~ Gb}zg~h Nacm

Mcwhz~ig} ]dcwaj Ng]z~ghfzdghgj

FBC#H]IBJ/97/;


2/24


3/24

FBCWhizgj ]zbzg}Fghg~ba Bmmcwhzihf CkkimgVb}dihfzch! J(M( >07:4

Hbzichba ]gmw~izy bhjIhzg~hbzichba Bkkbi~} Ji{i}ich

N/>74;=>

Jgmgong~ 29! 299:

Zdg Dchc~bnag Lcdh Mchyg~}! L~(Mdbi~obh! Agfi}abzich bhj Hbzichba

]gmw~izy ]wnmcooizzggMcooizzgg ch Fc{g~hoghz Cpg~bzich}Dcw}g ck ^gp~g}ghzbzi{g}

Zdg Dchc~bnag Agg D( DboiazchMdbi~obh! ]wnmcooizzgg ch Gw~cpg

bhj zdg Oijjag Gb}z

Mcooizzgg ch Kc~gifh Bkkbi~}Dcw}g ck ^gp~g}ghzbzi{g}

B} ycw ~grwg}zgj! vg ~g{igvgj zdg Pgbmg Mc~p} p~cmg}}g} bhjp~cmgjw~g} kc~ }zb~zihf p~cf~bo} ih Mghz~ba bhj Gb}zg~h Gw~cpg bhj zdg}zbzg} ck zdg kc~og~ ]c{igz Which( ]pgmikimbaay! cw~ cnlgmzi{g} vg~g zcjgzg~oihg vdgzdg~ $2) zdg Pgbmg Mc~p} hgv mcwhz~y ghz~y pabhhihf bhj}zbkkihf p~cmgjw~g} vg~g bjgrwbzg5 $>) zdg Pgbmg Mc~p} p~c{ijgj{cawhzgg~} bjgrwbzg b}}ifhoghz}! z~bihihf! bhj czdg~ }wppc~z5 bhj $=) zdggtpbh}ich ihzc zdg kc~og~ Gb}zg~h nacm mbog bz zdg gtpgh}g ck p~cf~bo}ih czdg~ ~gfich}( Zc obeg zdi} b}}g}}oghz! vg {i}izgj Pcabhj! Nwafb~ib!^w}}ib! bhj W|ngei}zbh(

^g}waz} ih N~igk Zdg Pgbmg Mc~p} db} mcop~gdgh}i{g! }cwhj v~izzgh p~cmgjw~g} kc~pabhhihf! ihz~cjwmihf! bhj iopagoghzihf hgv p~cf~bo} bhj p~gpb~ihf{cawhzgg~} kc~ ghz~y ihzc mcwhz~ig} b~cwhj zdg vc~aj( Dcvg{g~! ih iz}gbfg~hg}} zc oggz zdg oi}}ich }gz cwz ny zdg P~g}ijghz bhj zdg Mchf~g}} zcdgap zdg kc~og~ Gb}zg~h nacm mcwhz~ig}! zdg Pgbmg Mc~p} z~whmbzgj c~c{g~~cjg iz} hc~oba p~cmgjw~g} bhj abwhmdgj p~cf~bo} p~gobzw~gay( B} b~g}waz! zdg Pgbmg Mc~p} kbmgj }g~icw} jikkimwazig} zdbz aioizgj zdg p~cf~bo}gkkgmzi{ghg}} ih zdc}g mcwhz~ig}( Zdg kcw~ p~cf~bo} vg gtboihgj dbj {g~yjikkimwaz ngfihhihf}( Zdg p~cf~bo} vg~g pcc~ay jg}ifhgj! bhj {cawhzgg~}jij hcz ~gmgi{g zdg fwijbhmg! }wppc~z! c~ vgaa/mchmgi{gj b}}ifhoghz} zdgyvg~g agj zc gtpgmz( Zdg Pgbmg Mc~p} }wkkg~gj b difd ~bzg ck }zbkk zw~hc{g~bhj gb~ay ~gzw~h} ck {cawhzgg~}( B} b ~g}waz! zdg p~cf~bo} jg{gacpoghzbaiopbmz ih zdg}g mcwhz~ig} vb} iopbi~gj(

Pgbmg Mc~p} ckkimiba} bmehcvagjfgj zdg p~cnago} bhj db{g zbegh bmzich}jg}ifhgj zc c{g~mcog zdgo5 dcvg{g~! iz i} zcc }cch zc jgzg~oihg dcvgkkgmzi{g zdg}g bmzich} viaa ng(

FBC#H]IBJ/97/; Pgbmg Mc~pPbfg 2


4/24

N/>74;=>

Zdg Pgbmg Mc~p} p~cf~bo} ih zdg kc~og~ Gb}zg~h nacm vg~g hczwhjg~zbegh bz zdg gtpgh}g ck p~cf~bo} ih czdg~ ~gfich}( Kwhjihf bhj}zbkkihf ih czdg~ mcwhz~ig} jij hcz bppgb~ zc ng bkkgmzgj ny zdg hgvp~cf~bo}(

Nbmef~cwhj Zdg Pgbmg Mc~p} vb} m~gbzgj ih 29;2 zc dgap mcwhz~ig} oggz zdgi~ hggj}kc~ z~bihgj obhpcvg~(2 Ih bjjizich! iz vb} ogbhz zc p~c{ijg b hgvgtp~g}}ich ck W(]( mdb~bmzg~ bhj kc~gifh pcaimybh ijgbai}zim }gh}g ckpw~pc}g bhj b ogbh} ck mcwhzg~ihf zdg gtpbh}ich ck mcoowhi}ozd~cwfdcwz zdg vc~aj( Iz vb} bhzimipbzgj zdbz zd~cwfd mchzbmz bz zdg

f~b}}~ccz} ag{ga! Pgbmg Mc~p} {cawhzgg~} vcwaj dgap p~coczg b ngzzg~whjg~}zbhjihf ck zdg Bog~imbh pgcpag! vdc ih zw~h vcwaj ngzzg~whjg~}zbhj mwazw~g} ck czdg~ pgcpag}(

Zdg ghj ck zdg Mcaj Vb~ p~g}ghzgj zdg Pgbmg Mc~p} vizd bh di}zc~imcppc~zwhizy< Kc~ zdg ki~}z ziog! zdg mcwhz~ig} ck zdg kc~og~ Gb}zg~h nacmngmbog cpgh zc Vg}zg~h gmchcoim bhj zgmdhimba b}}i}zbhmg( Ih Lway 2949!zdg P~g}ijghz bhhcwhmgj zdbz Pgbmg Mc~p} {cawhzgg~} vcwaj zgbmd Ghfai}dih Dwhfb~y( ]dc~zay zdg~gbkzg~! hgv p~cf~bo} vg~g }zb~zgj ih Pcabhj bhjM|gmdc}ac{beib! zdgh }wmmg}}i{gay zd~cwfdcwz Mghz~ba bhj Gb}zg~hGw~cpg( Ih Jgmgong~ 2992! zdg ]gm~gzb~y ck ]zbzg bhhcwhmgj zdbz dgvcwaj aieg zc }gg bz agb}z >70 {cawhzgg~} pabmgj ih zdg }zbzg} ck zdg kc~og~]c{igz Which ny zdg ghj ck 299>( K~co 2949 zd~cwfd 299= zdg Pgbmg Mc~p}g}zbnai}dgj 24 hgv mcwhz~y p~cf~bo} zd~cwfdcwz Mghz~ba bhj Gb}zg~hGw~cpg bhj zdg kc~og~ ]c{igz Which(

Jw~ihf zdi} pg~icj ck gtpbh}ich ihzc Gw~cpg bhj Mghz~ba B}ib! zdg PgbmgMc~p} ba}c cpghgj c~ ~gcpghgj >0 hgv p~cf~bo} ih Bk~imb! B}ib! bhj AbzihBog~imb(> Zcfgzdg~! zdg}g hgv p~cf~bo} ~bi}gj zdg zczba hwong~ ckmcwhz~ig} }g~{gj ny Pgbmg Mc~p} zc 9=bh ihm~gb}g ck := pg~mghz }ihmg2949( Zdg}g hgv mcwhz~y p~cf~bo} ~gp~g}ghz zdg ab~fg}z ihm~gb}g ck hgvp~cf~bo} }ihmg zdg ki~}z ygb~} ck zdg bfghmy} gti}zghmg(

Pgbmg Mc~p} p~cf~bo} ih zdg kc~og~ Gb}zg~h nacm mcwhz~ig} vg~g }gagmzgjih mch}wazbzich vizd zdg dc}z fc{g~hoghz} bhj ih mchmg~z vizd zdgJgpb~zoghz ck ]zbzg! vdimd i} ~g}pch}inag kc~ mcc~jihbzihf W(]( b}}i}zbhmg

2Zdg Pgbmg Mc~p} vb} ihizibaay g}zbnai}dgj whjg~ Gtgmwzi{g C~jg~ 209>:! Ob~md 2! 29;2( Zdg PgbmgMc~p} ghbnaihf agfi}abzich $>> W(](M( >702! gz( }gr() vb} }ifhgj ihzc abv ch ]gpzgong~ >>! 29;2(

>Ih zdg Pgbmg Mc~p} di}zc~y! iz db} mac}gj hwog~cw} p~cf~bo} ngmbw}g ck mi{ia }z~ikg c~ pcaizimbajg{gacpoghz}! b} ~gmghzay cmmw~~gj ih ^vbhjb! Nw~whji! Ygogh! bhj ]ig~~b Agchg( Chmg b mcwhz~y}

pcaizimba }izwbzich }zbniai|g}! zdg Pgbmg Mc~p} ckzgh ~gghzg~} zdg mcwhz~y(

FBC#H]IBJ/97/; Pgbmg Mc~pPbfg >


5/24

N/>74;=>

zc zdg ~gfich( Zdg Pgbmg Mc~p} mchmghz~bzgj iz} jg{gacpoghz b}}i}zbhmg ihzdg ~gfich ih zd~gg p~cf~bo b~gb}< zdg Zgbmdihf Ghfai}d b} b Kc~gifhAbhfwbfg $ZGKA) p~cf~bo5 b }obaa nw}ihg}} jg{gacpoghz p~cf~bo! vdimdp~c{ijgj zgmdhimba b}}i}zbhmg ih }wmd b~gb} b} p~i{bzi|bzich! ob~egzihf!obhbfgoghz! bhj nw}ihg}} gjwmbzich5 bhj b p~cf~bo ih zdg gh{i~choghzb}gmzc~ zc p~coczg gh{i~choghzba bvb~ghg}} bhj gjwmbzich(

Jw~ihf ki}mba ygb~ 299=! bh b{g~bfg ck ;;7 {cawhzgg~} }g~{gj ih kc~og~Gb}zg~h nacm mcwhz~ig}( Zdg {cawhzgg~} }g~{ihf ih zdi} ~gfich b~g! chb{g~bfg! cajg~ bhj oc~g gtpg~ighmgj zdbh zdg b{g~bfg Pgbmg Mc~p}{cawhzgg~( Zdg b{g~bfg bfg ck baa Pgbmg Mc~p} {cawhzgg~} i} =>( Zdg

b{g~bfg bfg ck {cawhzgg~} }g~{ihf ih zdg ~gfich i} =6! vizd }obaa nw}ihg}}jg{gacpoghz {cawhzgg~} b{g~bfihf :0 ygb~} ck bfg( Ih bjjizich! obhy ck zdgnw}ihg}} {cawhzgg~} dcaj bj{bhmgj jgf~gg} bhj db{g }ifhikimbhz vc~egtpg~ighmg(

Zdg Pgbmg Mc~p} Db}Bjgrwbzg Fwijgaihg}kc~ ]zb~zihf HgvMcwhz~y P~cf~bo}

Zdg Pgbmg Mc~p} pcaimy bhj p~cmgjw~g} obhwba} jg}m~ing hwog~cw}! ckzghihzg~jgpghjghz }zgp} kc~ cpghihf hgv c{g~}gb} pc}z}( Zdg}g obhwba} b~gfghg~baay mcop~gdgh}i{g bhj }cwhj bhj! ik kcaacvgj! }dcwaj ~g}waz ihgkkgmzi{g p~cf~bo}( Zdg Pgbmg Mc~p} Pcaimy Obhwba! kc~ gtbopag!ijghzikig} zdg kcaacvihf b} hgmg}}b~y }zgp}74;=>

}mcpg ck vc~e kc~ ihji{ijwba p~clgmz}! bhj {cawhzgg~} z~bihihf! pabmgoghz!bhj }wppc~z(

Pgbmg Mc~p} fwijbhmg ba}c p~c{ijg} ihkc~obzich ch zdg }grwghmihf ck{b~icw} }zgp} ih zdg p~cf~bo jg{gacpoghz p~cmg}}( Kc~ gtbopag!mch}wazbzich} vizd dc}z mcwhz~y ckkimiba} ch b mcwhz~y} hggj} }dcwajp~gmgjg bh b}}g}}oghz ck zdc}g hggj}5 mcwhz~y bf~ggoghz} }dcwaj ngmcopagzgj bhj }ifhgj ngkc~g zdg mcwhz~y ckkimg i} g}zbnai}dgj bhj cpghgjbhj }zbkk b~~i{g5 bhj p~clgmz ijghzikimbzich bhj jg{gacpoghz bhj {cawhzgg~z~bihihf p~cf~bo} }dcwaj ng ih pabmg ngkc~g zdg {cawhzgg~} b~~i{ba(

Pgbmg Mc~p}Gtpg~ighmgjP~cnago} Ngmbw}g IzJij Hcz KcaacvP~cmgjw~g}

Ih iz} bzzgopz zc rwimeay ngfih p~cf~bo} ih Mghz~ba bhj Gb}zg~h Gw~cpgbhj zdg kc~og~ ]c{igz Which! zdg Pgbmg Mc~p} ckzgh jij hcz kcaacv iz}g}zbnai}dgj fwijbhmg vdgh }zb~zihf iz} p~cf~bo}( Obhy ck zdg }zgp}hgmg}}b~y zc ihz~cjwmg gkkgmzi{g p~cf~bo} vg~g ~w}dgj! jchg }wpg~kimibaayc~ hcz jchg bz baa( Mch}grwghzay! obhy ck zdg hgv p~cf~bo} vg gtboihgjvg~g pcc~ay jg}ifhgj bhj kbmgj b dc}z ck czdg~ p~cnago}! ihmawjihf zdgabme ck rwbaikigj }zbkk! zdg b}}ifhoghz ck {cawhzgg~} zc ihbpp~cp~ibzg c~whjg~jg{gacpgj p~clgmz}! ih}wkkimighz {cawhzgg~ z~bihihf! bhj {cawhzgg~}wppc~z }y}zgo} zdbz jij hcz vc~e( Zdg}g p~cnago} k~w}z~bzgj obhy{cawhzgg~} vdc dbj lcihgj zdg Pgbmg Mc~p} zc mchz~inwzg zc zdg ~gfich}jg{gacpoghz bhj mchz~inwzgj zc b ~gabzi{gay difd ~g}ifhbzich ~bzg bochfzdg {cawhzgg~}(

P~cf~bo Jg}ifh} Vg~gPcc~ay Jchg

Zdg Pgbmg Mc~p} ~gaigj ch mch}wazbhz} c~ }zbkk vdc abmegj bjgrwbzgmwazw~ba c~ abhfwbfg ehcvagjfg zc jg{gacp }gmzc~ pabh}( Zdg}g pg~}chhgavg~g ckzgh whjg~ p~g}}w~g zc vc~e rwimeay bhj jij hcz db{g ziog zc agb~hbncwz acmba mchjizich} c~ mwazi{bzg b mcooch whjg~}zbhjihf vizd dc}zmcwhz~y ckkimiba}( Kc~ gtbopag! zdg Pgbmg Mc~p} b}}ifhgj b }zbkk pg~}ch chzgopc~b~y jwzy k~co zdg Pdiaippihg} zc jg}ifh iz} gh{i~choghz p~cf~bo ihPcabhj! g{gh zdcwfd zdg pg~}ch jij hcz ehcv zdg abhfwbfg bhj dbj hcp~g{icw} gtpg~ighmg ih zdg ~gfich( B} b ~g}waz! zdg p~cf~bo} jg}ifh jij hc

bjj~g}} Pcabhj} gh{i~choghzba fcba} c~ db{g owmd iopbmz( Ih bhczdg~mb}g! b mch}wazbhz kc~ zdg Pgbmg Mc~p} jg}ifhgj ^w}}ib} Kb~ Gb}z }obaanw}ihg}} p~cf~bo vizdcwz z~b{gaihf zc zdg ~gfich zc b}}g}} iz} nw}ihg}}}izwbzich(

Chmg j~bkzgj! }gmzc~ pabh} vg~g hcz }y}zgobzimbaay ~g{igvgj ny }ghic~Pgbmg Mc~p} obhbfgoghz ckkimiba} ch b ziogay nb}i}( Pgbmg Mc~p}pg~}chhga vdc hc~obaay p~c{ijg zgmdhimba }wppc~z zc mcwhz~y p~cf~bo}

FBC#H]IBJ/97/; Pgbmg Mc~pPbfg :


7/24

N/>74;=>

zcaj w} zdbz zdgy vg~g w}wbaay agkz cwz ck zdg ~g{igv p~cmg}}( Vdgh ~g{igv}jij zbeg pabmg zdgy vg~g ckzgh mw~}c~y c~ vg~g jchg bkzg~ {cawhzgg~} vg~gba~gbjy ih zdg mcwhz~y( Kc~ gtbopag! ^w}}ib} }obaa nw}ihg}} p~clgmz pabh}vg~g hcz ~g{igvgj ny zdg Pgbmg Mc~p} zgmdhimba }wppc~z ckkimiba} whzia}g{g~ba ochzd} bkzg~ {cawhzgg~} vg~g bz zdgi~ }izg}( Zdg}g m~izirwg}ijghzikigj b hwong~ ck fbp} ih zdg pabhhihf p~cmg}}! }wmd b} zdg kbiaw~g zcijghziky b}}ifhoghz} ngkc~g {cawhzgg~} vg~g pabmgj bz }izg}( Zdi} abzg~zw~hgj cwz zc ng b m~izimba p~cnago( Kihbaay! zdg Pgbmg Mc~p} }ghic~obhbfgoghz jij hcz kc~obaay bpp~c{g mcwhz~y p~cf~bo pabh} p~ic~ zczdgi~ iopagoghzbzich(

Vg vg~g zcaj zdbz zdg Pgbmg Mc~p} ~gfichba ji~gmzc~} b~g waziobzgay~g}pch}inag kc~ gh}w~ihf zdg bjgrwbmy ck mcwhz~y p~cf~bo pabh} ih zdgi~~gfich} bhj b~g fi{gh }ifhikimbhz bwzdc~izy bhj bwzchcoy zc gh}w~g zdbzzdgi~ p~cf~bo} b~g gkkgmzi{gay obhbfgj( Dcvg{g~! zdgy ckzgh jij hcz mb~~ycwz zdi} ~g}pch}iniaizy! bhj obhbfgoghz c{g~}ifdz ck zdg mcwhz~y p~cf~bovg {i}izgj bppgb~gj zc ng oihioba( Kc~ gtbopag! zdg Pgbmg Mc~p} }ghz}obaa nw}ihg}} jg{gacpoghz {cawhzgg~} zc W|ngei}zbh jg}pizg zdg kbmz izdbj hcz jg{gacpgj b nw}ihg}} p~cf~bo( Ih Pcabhj! zdg }obaa nw}ihg}}p~cf~bo jg}ifhgj bhj iopagoghzgj ih 2992 vb} hcz bpp~c{gj whzia 299:(

Pgbmg Mc~p} obhbfgoghz ckkimiba} zcaj w} zdbz }cog hgvg~ p~cf~bo}~grwi~gj f~gbzg~ obhbfgoghz }wppc~z k~co Vb}dihfzch zdbh czdg~}! bhjih Kgn~wb~y 299=! Vb}dihfzch }zbkk ngfbh pabyihf b ji~gmz ~cag ih obhbfihfmg~zbih p~cnago p~cf~bo} ih zdg kc~og~ ]c{igz Which( Zdgy }bij bmzich}zbegh ihmawjgj jgabyihf zdg ghz~y ck {cawhzgg~} ihzc }cog p~cf~bo} zc fi{}zbkk oc~g ziog zc p~gpb~g5 obeihf }zbkk mdbhfg}5 bhj ih}zizwzihf ihizibzi{g}zc }z~ghfzdgh z~bihihf! p~cf~booihf! bhj }zbkk }wppc~z(

Ih}wkkimighz bhjWhp~gpb~gj ]zbkk

Pgbmg Mc~p} pcaimy obhwba} ~grwi~g zdbz p~cf~bo} ng }wkkimighzay }zbkkgjih c~jg~ zc p~cpg~ay pabh {cawhzgg~ b}}ifhoghz} bhj }wppc~z {cawhzgg~} bzzdgi~ }izg}( Dcvg{g~! zdg Pgbmg Mc~p} jij hcz bavby} p~c{ijg bjgrwbzghwong~} ck }zbkk zc cpgh hgv pc}z} bhj jij hcz b}}ifh }wkkimighz }zbkk zc

mcwhz~ig} chmg zdg p~cf~bo} vg~g whjg~vby( Mcopcwhjihf zdg p~cnago}mbw}gj ny ihbjgrwbzg }zbkkihf vb} zdg }dc~z agbj ziog zdg Pgbmg Mc~p} dbjzc p~gpb~g kc~ zdg b~~i{ba ck zdg ab~fg hwong~ ck {cawhzgg~} b}}ifhgj zc zdg~gfich(

Zdg Pgbmg Mc~p} ~gm~wizoghz ck }zbkk kc~ zdg}g hgv mcwhz~y ghz~ig} vb}~gbmzi{g( Zdg Pgbmg Mc~p} ~gm~wizihf gkkc~z} ab~fgay mch}i}zgj ck }ghjihfbhhcwhmgoghz} ck {bmbhmig} zc b kgv pwnaimbzich} bhj kc~gifh bkkbi~}



8/24

N/>74;=>

b}}cmibzich}( Zdg Pgbmg Mc~p} ba}c ~gaigj ch kc~og~ {cawhzgg~} bhj }zbkkk~co czdg~ mcwhz~ig} zc kiaa iz} }zbkk pc}izich}(

Zdg rwbaizy ck zdg }zbkk vb} whg{gh ih Mghz~ba bhj Gb}zg~h Gw~cpg bhj zdgkc~og~ ]c{igz Which mcwhz~ig}( Zdg Pgbmg Mc~p} ckzgh b}}ifhgj }zbkk zdbzdbj p~ic~ Pgbmg Mc~p} gtpg~ighmg nwz jij hcz db{g hgmg}}b~y abhfwbfg}eiaa}( Ba}c! }cog }zbkk bhj mch}wazbhz} abmegj zdg hgmg}}b~y mwazw~baehcvagjfg bhj zgmdhimba }eiaa}(

Zdg Pgbmg Mc~p} }zbkk z~bihihf vb} ba}c ihbjgrwbzg( Obhy ck zdg }zbkk vgihzg~{igvgj }bij zdgy jij hcz ~gmgi{g bhy z~bihihf whzia bkzg~ zdgy }zb~zgj

zdgi~ b}}ifhoghz}( Ih bjjizich! }zbkk vg }pceg vizd }bij zdbz vdbz z~bihihfzdgy ~gmgi{gj bkzg~ zdgy }zb~zgj zdgi~ b}}ifhoghz} vb} zcc fghg~ba ihhbzw~g bhj kbiagj zc p~gpb~g zdgo kc~ zdg pb~zimwab~ mdbaaghfg} ck zdgi~pc}z}( Obhy ck zdg }zbkk vg ogz zcaj w} zdgy dbj aizzag ehcvagjfg ck zdgacmba abhfwbfg bhj mwazw~g ngkc~g zdgy b~~i{gj! vdimd zdgy }bij}ifhikimbhzay dihjg~gj zdgi~ gkkgmzi{ghg}}(

Pgbmg Mc~p} }zbkkihf jbzb ihjimbzg} b pbzzg~h ck }dc~zbfg} bhj zw~hc{g~zd~cwfdcwz zdg ~gfich! b} iaaw}z~bzgj ih zdg kcaacvihf gtbopag}0/ochzd }pbh(

Zd~gg ck zdg kcw~ mcwhz~ig} vg {i}izgj jij hcz db{g bh B}}cmibzg PgbmgMc~p} Ji~gmzc~ $BPMJ) kc~ zdgi~ }obaa nw}ihg}} p~cf~bo} whzia bkzg~ zdg{cawhzgg~} b~~i{gj ih mcwhz~y( Ih Pcabhj! zdg }obaa nw}ihg}} BPMJ b~~i{gj24 ochzd} bkzg~ zdg ki~}z nw}ihg}} {cawhzgg~} b~~i{gj( Ih Nwafb~ib bhjW|ngei}zbh! zdg~g vb} hc }obaa nw}ihg}} BPMJ kc~ ; ochzd} c~ oc~g vdiag{cawhzgg~} vg~g ih zdg kigaj(

Ih Pcabhj! zdg ki~}z BPMJ kc~ zdg ZGKA p~cf~bo vb} ~g}pch}inag kc~jg{gacpihf b}}ifhoghz} kc~ ;0 {cawhzgg~}! vdgh zdg hc~oba }zbkk ~bzic i}chg BPMJ kc~ bpp~ctiobzgay =0 {cawhzgg~}(

Bz zdg ziog ck cw~ kigajvc~e! obhy mcwhz~y p~cf~bo} ih zdg ~gfich dbjczdg~ }zbkk {bmbhmig}! ihmawjihf pc}izich} ih ^w}}ib bhj W|ngei}zbh zdbzdbj nggh {bmbhz kc~ c{g~ b ygb~(

Zdg Pgbmg Mc~p} fb{g }g{g~ba ~gb}ch} kc~ db{ihf ih}wkkimighz }zbkk( Ki~}z!zdg Pgbmg Mc~p} dbj ba~gbjy ~gbmdgj iz} c{g~baa }zbkk mgiaihf g}zbnai}dgj nyzdg Ckkimg ck Obhbfgoghz bhj Nwjfgz( ]gmchj! ih }cog ih}zbhmg} zdg ]zbzgJgpb~zoghz ~g}z~imzgj zdg hwong~ ck W(]( pg~}chhga baacvgj ihzc b

FBC#H]IBJ/97/; Pgbmg Mc~pPbfg ;


9/24

N/>74;=>

mcwhz~y( Kc~ gtbopag! zdg Pgbmg Mc~p} vb} ~g}z~imzgj zc obhbfihf iz}zd~gg Nbazim p~cf~bo}G}zchib! Abz{ib! bhj Aizdwbhibk~co b mghz~backkimg ih Abz{ib( Zdi~j! zdg Pgbmg Mc~p} dbj jikkimwazy bzz~bmzihf rwbaikigjmbhjijbzg} zc kiaa b hwong~ ck iz} }zbkk pc}izich}(

Pgbmg Mc~p} ckkimiba} bzz~inwzgj zdg difd }zbkk zw~hc{g~ zc zvc kbmzc~}(Ki~}z! zdg Pgbmg Mc~p} jij hcz db{g ghcwfd agbj ziog zc ~gm~wiz! p~gpb~g!bhj pabmg }zbkk ih zdg kigaj ngkc~g zdg {cawhzgg~} b~~i{gj( Chmg }zbkkb~~i{gj! zdgy dbj zc bmmcopai}d zcc obhy zb}e} ih b }dc~z bocwhz ck ziog!vdimd agj zc k~w}z~bzich bhj nw~hcwz( ]gmchj! }cog }zbkk vg~g hcz b fccjobzmd kc~ zdgi~ b}}ifhoghz} bhj abmegj zdg hgmg}}b~y }eiaa} bhj

zgopg~boghz} kc~ zdg lcn(

P~cnago} ih P~c{ijihf[cawhzgg~} Vizd ]wppc~zbhj Vgaa/Jg{gacpgj

B}}ifhoghz}

Zdg Pgbmg Mc~p} jij hcz p~c{ijg bjgrwbzg b}}ifhoghz p~cf~booihf bhjczdg~ }wppc~z kc~ {cawhzgg~} ih zdg mcwhz~ig} vg {i}izgj( Ih obhy mb}g}!{cawhzgg~ }izg} vg~g hcz {i}izgj! b}}ifhoghz} vg~g iaa/jgkihgj! bhjdc}z/mcwhz~y }pch}c~} vg~g hcz ijghzikigj( Dc}z mcwhz~y ckkimiba} vg~gckzgh whmg~zbih vdbz zdg Pgbmg Mc~p} fcba} bhj pdiac}cpdy vg~g! vdbz{cawhzgg~} dbj zc ckkg~! bhj vdbz zdg Pgbmg Mc~p} gtpgmzgj ck dc}zmcwhz~y ckkimiba}( Ih bjjizich! }pch}c~} jij hcz p~c{ijg vdbz zdgymcooizzgj zc p~c{ijg! }wmd b} dcw}ihf! ckkimg }pbmg! bhj mcwhzg~pb~z}!ngmbw}g zdgy abmegj b magb~ whjg~}zbhjihf ck zdgi~ ~cag} bhj dbj hcv~izzgh bf~ggoghz}( Zdg}g p~cnago} g{ghzwbaay agj obhy {cawhzgg~} zcmdbhfg zdgi~ b}}ifhoghz} c~ agb{g zdg Pgbmg Mc~p} gb~ay(

Jg}ifhihf bjgrwbzg b}}ifhoghz} kc~ iz} {cawhzgg~} db} nggh bachf/}zbhjihf Pgbmg Mc~p} p~cnago( Ih 2990! vg ~gpc~zgj zdbz! vc~ajvijg!obhy {cawhzgg~} dbj hc pc}izich} c~ vg~g whjg~gopacygj! vg~g kc~mgj zcjg{gacp zdgi~ cvh b}}ifhoghz}! c~ jij hcz ~gmgi{g dc}z fc{g~hoghz}wppc~zp~cnago} vg ki~}z ~gpc~zgj ih 2969(= Vg ~gmcooghjgj ih 2990zdbz zdg Pgbmg Mc~p} g}zbnai}d p~cmgjw~g} zc iop~c{g zdg pabhhihf bhjjg{gacpoghz ck {cawhzgg~ b}}ifhoghz} bhj p~clgmz}( Ih ~g}pch}g zc cw~~gmcooghjbzich! zdg Pgbmg Mc~p} jg{gacpgj zdg PBZ] obhwba zc iop~c{g

iz} p~cf~booihf gkkc~z}( Zdg obhwba }zbzg} zdbz baa }izg} b~g zc ng {i}izgjbhj }w~{gygj bhj zdbz zdg ~cag} bhj gtpgmzbzich} ck zdg acmba pgcpag}dcwaj ng mab~ikigj = zc ; ochzd} ngkc~g {cawhzgg~} b~~i{g kc~ z~bihihf( Zdg}mcpg ck zdi} ~g{igv jij hcz ihmawjg b vc~ajvijg g{bawbzich zc jgzg~oihgvdgzdg~ zdg Pgbmg Mc~p} bmzich} mc~~gmzgj zdg b}}ifhoghz p~cnago} ih

=Pgbmg Mc~p}< Mdbaaghfg} ck zdg 2990} $FBC#H]IBJ/90/2>>! Oby 24! 2990) bhj Mdbhfg} Hggjgj kc~ bNgzzg~ Pgbmg Mc~p} $FBC#IJ/64/>;! Kgn( 2969)(



10/24

N/>74;=>

czdg~ b~gb}5 dcvg{g~! }izg ijghzikimbzich bhj jg{gacpoghz p~cnago}pg~}i}zgj ih gbmd ck zdg kcw~ mcwhz~ig} vg {i}izgj(

Ih Pcabhj! c{g~ chg/dbak ck zdg ki~}z }obaa nw}ihg}} {cawhzgg~} vg~g oc{gjzc hgv b}}ifhoghz} ngmbw}g ck ih}wkkimighz }zbkk vc~e ch }izg pabmgoghz}bhj p~clgmz jg}ifh( Zdg}g b}}ifhoghz p~cnago} db{g pg~}i}zgj! b} }cog}obaa nw}ihg}} {cawhzgg~} ck }wn}grwghz f~cwp} db{g dbj jikkimwazig}kihjihf ogbhihfkwa pc}izich}( [cawhzgg~} b}}ifhgj zc vc~e ih zdggh{i~choghzba }gmzc~ vg~g ab~fgay whgopacygj ngmbw}g zdg Pgbmg Mc~p}dbj hcz jg{gacpgj p~clgmz pabh} zdbz vg~g bmmgpzgj ny Pcai}d ckkimiba}([cawhzgg~} b}}ifhgj zc zgbmd Ghfai}d ih }gmchjb~y }mdcca} zcaj w} zdbz

zdgi~ }mdcca} dbj ab~fg hwong~} ck }eiaagj Ghfai}d zgbmdg~} bhj zdbz iz vb}db~j zc lw}ziky zdgi~ mchzihwgj p~g}ghmg ih zdg }mdcca}(

Ih Nwafb~ib! dbak ck zdg ki~}z mab}} ck }obaa nw}ihg}} {cawhzgg~} agkz gb~ayjwg zc k~w}z~bzich} c{g~ zdgi~ b}}ifhoghz}( Zdg mghzg~pigmg ck zdg PgbmgMc~p} }obaa nw}ihg}} p~cf~bo vb} zc ng zdg m~gbzich ck ~gfichba ~g}cw~mgmghzg~} vdg~g {cawhzgg~} vcwaj p~c{ijg ihkc~obzich bhj bj{img zc acmbanw}ihg}}g}( Dcvg{g~! zdg mghzg~} abmegj acmba }pch}c~}dip bhj bhihjgpghjghz kwhjihf }cw~mg( Zdi} agkz zdg {cawhzgg~} wh}wppc~zgj bhjkc~mgj zdgo ihzc kwhj/~bi}ihf bmzi{izig}( Bmmc~jihf zc zdg {cawhzgg~}! ckkimggrwipoghz bhj }wppaig} hggjgj zc }gz wp zdg mghzg~} jij hcz b~~i{g whzia}cog {cawhzgg~} vg~g ba~gbjy dbakvby ihzc zdgi~ >/ygb~ b}}ifhoghz( C{g~>7 pg~mghz ck zdg ki~}z ZGKA {cawhzgg~} dbj zc ng ~gb}}ifhgj ngmbw}g}pch}c~} dbj kbiagj zc p~c{ijg zdgo bjgrwbzg dcw}ihf c~ zgbmdihfpc}izich}( Bazdcwfd fghg~baay pc}izi{g bncwz zdgi~ gtpg~ighmg! obhy ck zdgZGKA {cawhzgg~} vg }pceg vizd rwg}zichgj zdgi~ pabmgoghz}! }ihmg zdgi~}mdcca} dbj ab~fg hwong~} ck mbpbnag Ghfai}d abhfwbfg zgbmdg~}(

Zdg Pgbmg Mc~p} ba}c gtpg~ighmgj }cog ck zdg }bog jikkimwazig} ih ^w}}ibzdbz vg }bv ih czdg~ mcwhz~ig}( Zdg obih p~cnago ih ^w}}ib vb} b abme ckacmba fc{g~hoghz ckkimiba} whjg~}zbhjihf ck bhj mcooizoghz zc zdgp~cf~bo bhj zdg Pgbmg Mc~p} ihbniaizy zc p~c{ijg {cawhzgg~} vizdnw}ihg}} grwipoghz bhj czdg~ }wppc~z( Zdg}g kbmzc~}! mcwpagj vizd

k~w}z~bzich} c{g~ whjgkihgj b}}ifhoghz} bhj abme ck dcw}ihf! mchz~inwzgjzc zdg jgpb~zw~g ck =0 pg~mghz ck zdg {cawhzgg~} vizdih zdg ki~}z ygb~( Acmbackkimiba} gtpgmzgj zdg Pgbmg Mc~p} zc }zbkk bhj grwip }cpdi}zimbzgjnw}ihg}} mghzg~}! }pgbe ^w}}ibh p~ckimighzay! bhj bzz~bmz lcihz {ghzw~g}(Vdgh zdg}g gtpgmzbzich} jij hcz obzg~ibai|g! zdgi~ }wppc~z kc~ zdg{cawhzgg~} jgmaihgj( Hchgzdgag}}! bmmc~jihf zc zdg Pgbmg Mc~p}! acmbackkimiba} mchzihwg zc ~grwg}z oc~g {cawhzgg~}(



11/24


12/24

N/>74;=>

~g}waz! zc pg~kc~o zdgi~ vc~e! obhy ck zdgo vg~g ~gayihf ch ihzg~p~gzg~}(]cog ck zdg {cawhzgg~} vg }pceg vizd ih W|ngei}zbh vg~g z~bihgj zc }pgbe^w}}ibh bhj W|nge nwz vg~g b}}ifhgj zc mizig} vdg~g zdg Zblie abhfwbfg i}p~gjcoihbhz( ZGKA {cawhzgg~} kb~gj ngzzg~ ngmbw}g zdgy vg~g gtpgmzgj zc}pgbe Ghfai}d bhj jij hcz db{g zc ~gay ch zdgi~ abhfwbfg }eiaa} zc kwhmzichih zdgi~ b}}ifhoghz}(

B mcooch zdgog }z~wme ny zdg }obaa nw}ihg}} {cawhzgg~} vg }pceg vizdzd~cwfdcwz zdg ~gfich vb} zdbz zdgi~ zgmdhimba z~bihihf dbj aizzag ~gag{bhmgzc zdgi~ b}}ifhoghz}( Zdg Pgbmg Mc~p} z~bihg~} zbwfdz nb}im W(]( nw}ihg}}p~bmzimg}! vdimd vg~g ck aizzag w}g zc obhy {cawhzgg~} vdc ba~gbjy dbj

jgf~gg} ih nw}ihg}}! bmmcwhzihf! bhj abv bhj ygb~} ck p~bmzimba nw}ihg}}gtpg~ighmg( Zdg}g {cawhzgg~} }bij zdgy hggjgj zc ehcv dcv zc bjbpz zdgi~gtpg~zi}g zc acmba }izwbzich}! nwz zdgi~ z~bihg~} dbj hc ehcvagjfg c~bpp~gmibzich ck acmba mchjizich}( ]cog ck zdg ZGKA {cawhzgg~} vg }pcegvizd zcaj w} zdbz zdgi~ zgmdhimba z~bihihf jij hcz p~gpb~g zdgo kc~ zdgi~zgbmdihf b}}ifhoghz}(

Zdg {cawhzgg~} vg }pceg vizd zcaj w} zdg m~c}}/mwazw~ba z~bihihf zdgy~gmgi{gj fghg~baay p~gpb~gj zdgo kc~ ai{ihf bhj vc~eihf ih b hgv mwazw~g(Dcvg{g~! zdg {cawhzgg~} ih ~w~ba bhj }obaa w~nbh b~gb} ih W|ngei}zbh zcajw} zdbz zdgy vg~g zczbaay whp~gpb~gj kc~ zdg pdy}imba bhj {g~nbadb~b}}oghz vg}zg~hg~}! g}pgmibaay vcogh! ~gmgi{gj( Obhy vcogh{cawhzgg~} ih ~w~ba bhj }obaa w~nbh b~gb} ih W|ngei}zbh vg~g zb~fgz} ckpdy}imba bhj {g~nba b}}bwaz}! ihmawjihf ngbzihf}! kchjaihf! bhj ~cmezd~cvihf( B} b ~g}waz }g{g~ba {cawhzgg~} agkz gb~ay( Zdg ~gobihihf vcogh{cawhzgg~} vg~g ~gacmbzgj zc ab~fg~! }bkg~ mizig}(

Zdg Pgbmg Mc~p} dbj z~cwnag p~c{ijihf }wppc~z zc {cawhzgg~} chmg zdgyvg~g bz zdgi~ }izg}( Zdg obih mbw}g} kc~ zdg abme ck }wppc~z zc {cawhzgg~}vg~g zdg }dc~zbfg bhj zw~hc{g~ ck }zbkk bhj zdg abme ck bjgrwbzg~g}cw~mg}( Zdg wh}gzzagj }zbkkihf }izwbzich p~g}}gj Pgbmg Mc~p} oi}}ich}zc cpg~bzg ih b m~i}i}/~g}pch}g ocjg( Zdi} m~i}i} ocjg jij hcz pg~oizbjgrwbzg ziog kc~ jgbaihf vizd {cawhzgg~ i}}wg} ih zdg kigaj( [cawhzgg~} vg

}pceg vizd zcaj w} iz vb} fghg~baay wp zc zdgo zc }ca{g bhy p~cnago}~gabzgj zc zdgi~ b}}ifhoghz} c~ ai{ihf }izwbzich}(



13/24

N/>74;=>

Jg}pizg P~cnago}![cawhzgg~} Fghg~baayNgaig{g Zdgy B~gDb{ihf ]cog Pc}izi{gIopbmz

Jg}pizg zdg p~cf~booihf p~cnago} bhj zdg abme ck p~gpb~bzich bhj}wppc~z! obhy {cawhzgg~} zcaj w} zdbz zdgy vg~g ckzgh bnag zc kihjogbhihfkwa vc~e ch zdgi~ cvh ihizibzi{g bhj fghg~baay ngaig{gj zdgy vg~gobeihf }cog pc}izi{g iopbmz( Ba}c! bmmc~jihf zc }g{g~ba W(]( b}}i}zbhmgbhj p~i{bzg {cawhzb~y c~fbhi|bzich ckkimiba}! {cawhzgg~} b~g b acv/mc}zogbh} zc p~c{ijg b}}i}zbhmg zc zdg ~gfich! bhj dc}z mcwhz~y ckkimiba}bpp~gmibzg Pgbmg Mc~p} }wppc~z( [b~icw} ckkimiba} }bij zdg ~gfich hggj} zdachf/zg~o zgmdhimba b}}i}zbhmg zdg Pgbmg Mc~p} p~c{ijg}(

Ckkimiba} ck czdg~ b}}i}zbhmg bfghmig} zcaj w} zdbz Pgbmg Mc~p} {cawhzgg~}fghg~baay vc~egj vgaa vizd zdgo( ]ihmg zdg Pgbmg Mc~p} db} {cawhzgg~} bz

zdg f~b}}~ccz} ag{ga! zdg W(]( Bfghmy kc~ Ihzg~hbzichba Jg{gacpoghz! zdgW(]( Ihkc~obzich Bfghmy! zdg W(]( bhj Kc~gifh Mcoog~miba ]g~{img! bhjW(](/kwhjgj p~i{bzg {cawhzb~y c~fbhi|bzich}! bochf czdg~}! ckzgh ~gaigj ch{cawhzgg~} zc p~c{ijg bj{img bhj ijghziky }wizbnag jg{gacpoghz p~clgmz}!gtmdbhfg }zwjghz}! bhj nw}ihg}} {ghzw~g}(

Pgbmg Mc~p} Gkkc~z}zc Bjj~g}} P~cnago}ih zdg ^gfich

Zcp Pgbmg Mc~p} ckkimiba} bmehcvagjfgj zdbz zdg bfghmy dbj jikkimwazig}ihz~cjwmihf p~cf~bo} ih Mghz~ba bhj Gb}zg~h Gw~cpg bhj zdg kc~og~]c{igz Which bhj zcaj w} zdgy b~g zbeihf }zgp} zc bjj~g}} zdgo( Zdgy }bijzdgy b~g zbeihf p~gmbwzichb~y ogb}w~g} zc gh}w~g ngzzg~ pabhhihf bhjp~gpb~bzich kc~ kwzw~g p~cf~bo} bhj bmzich} zc bjj~g}} p~cnago} ihgti}zihf p~cf~bo}(

Bmmc~jihf zc Pgbmg Mc~p} ckkimiba}! zdg }mdgjwag kc~ ihz~cjwmihf p~cf~bo}ihzc zdg ~gfich vb} c{g~ay bonizicw}! nczd ih zg~o} ck ziog zc bjgrwbzgayjg{gacp zdg p~cf~bo} bhj zdg kwhjihf bhj }zbkk ~g}cw~mg} zc }wppc~z zdgoZdgy }bij zdbz kwzw~g p~cf~bo} vcwaj ng oc~g zdc~cwfday pabhhgj ngkc~gzdgi~ ihz~cjwmzich bhj ngzzg~ }wppc~zgj vdgh ihz~cjwmgj( Zdgy ba}c }bijbjjizichba gopdb}i} vcwaj ng pabmgj ch jg{gacpihf ihji{ijwba {cawhzgg~b}}ifhoghz} bhj {cawhzgg~ }wppc~z p~cf~bo}(

Ih mchlwhmzich vizd zdi} ihm~gb}gj gopdb}i}! zdg Pgbmg Mc~p} ckkimg ck

Gw~cpg! Mghz~ba B}ib! bhj Ogjizg~~bhgbh $GMBO) cpg~bzich}! vdimd i}~g}pch}inag kc~ obhbfihf mcwhz~y p~cf~bo} ih zdg kc~og~ Gb}zg~h nacm!~gmghzay mab~ikigj iz} pabhhihf! ~g{igv! bhj bpp~c{ba p~cmg}}g} bhj objgzdgo pcaimy( GMBO ba}c pabh} zc ~grwg}z ihpwz k~co zgmdhimba bj{i}c~} vdghjg}ifhihf hgv {cawhzgg~ p~clgmz} bhj viaa jg{gacp p~cf~bo pabh} p~ic~ zc}ghjihf {cawhzgg~} zc b mcwhz~y(



14/24

N/>74;=>

Zdg Jgpb~zoghz ck ]zbzg p~c{ijgj zdg Pgbmg Mc~p} ki}mba ygb~ 299:}wppagoghzba kwhjihf! vdimd vb} ngihf w}gj zc }zbniai|g hgv mcwhz~yp~cf~bo} ih zdg ~gfich( Zdg kwhj} vg~g w}gj zc mchz~bmz kc~ bjjizichbamch}wazbhz} zc dgap }z~ghfzdgh chfcihf p~cf~bo}! bochf czdg~ zdihf}( Zdgkwhj} viaa ba}c ng w}gj zc pabmg oc~g }zbkk ih p~cf~bo} ih zdg ~gfich( Ihbjjizich! b ~gmghzay mcopagzgj Pgbmg Mc~p} g{bawbzich ~gmcooghjgjiop~c{goghz} ih }zbkk di~ihf bhj }wppc~z p~bmzimg}! bhj b }pgmiba~gm~wizoghz gkkc~z vb} whjg~vby bz zdg ziog ck cw~ ~g{igv zc ihm~gb}g zdgpcca ck }obaa nw}ihg}} }zbkk mbhjijbzg}(

Zdg Pgbmg Mc~p} vb} ba}c ~g{i}ihf bhj zg}zihf iz} c{g~}gb} }zbkk

jg{gacpoghz z~bihihf mw~~imwawo bhj gtpbhjihf }zbkk z~bihihf ih zdg kigaj(Ckkimiba} }bij zdg ~g{i}gj mw~~imwawo vcwaj ng kwaay jg{gacpgj bhjcpg~bzichba ny Bp~ia 2997( Ih bjjizich! GMBO db} di~gj bjjizichba }zbkk zcihm~gb}g zdg ziog {cawhzgg~} jg{czg zc abhfwbfg z~bihihf! i} jg{gacpihfbjjizichba abhfwbfg obzg~iba}! bhj i} obeihf zgmdhimba z~bihihf oc~g}pgmikim zc zdg mcwhz~y(

Pgbmg Mc~p}Gtpbh}ich Ihzc zdg

Kc~og~ Gb}zg~h NacmVb} Hcz bz zdgGtpgh}g ck Czdg~^gfich}

Zdg Pgbmg Mc~p} ghz~y ihzc zdg kc~og~ Gb}zg~h nacm jij hcz bppgb~ zcbj{g~}gay bkkgmz }zbkkihf bhj kihbhmiba ~g}cw~mg} kc~ p~cf~bo} ih zdgBk~imbh! B}ibh bhj Pbmikim! bhj Ihzg~/Bog~imbh ~gfich}( Jw~ihf ki}mbaygb~} 2990/9:! zdg Pgbmg Mc~p} ~gmgi{gj ihm~goghzba nwjfgz ihm~gb}g} zckbmiaizbzg zdg }zb~z/wp ck hgv p~cf~bo}( Ih bjjizich! ih ki}mba ygb~ 299:! zdgJgpb~zoghz ck ]zbzg z~bh}kg~~gj *2>(7 oiaaich zc zdg Pgbmg Mc~p} zcjg{gacp bhj }zbniai|g iz} hgv p~cf~bo} ih zdg kc~og~ ]c{igz Which( Kc~ki}mba ygb~ 2997! zdg Pgbmg Mc~p} db} ~grwg}zgj *22(; oiaaich k~co zdg]zbzg Jgpb~zoghz kc~ zdg}g p~cf~bo}( Zbnag 2 }dcv} zdg Pgbmg Mc~p}kwhjihf kc~ ki}mba ygb~} 2949/97(

Zbnag 2< Pgbmg Mc~p} KwhjihfJcaab~} ih oiaaich}

Ki}mba ygb~Bhhwba

bpp~cp~ibzichZ~bh}kg~~gj k~co

]zbzg Zczb

2949 *27=(7 0 *27=(

2990 2;7(; 0 2;7(

2992 24;(0 0 24;(

299> 296(0 0 296(

299= >24(2 0 >24(

299: >29(6 *2>(7 >=>(

2997 >29(6 22(;b >=2(

bZdi} i} zdg bocwhz ~grwg}zgj ny zdg Pgbmg Mc~p}(

FBC#H]IBJ/97/; Pgbmg Mc~pPbfg 2>


15/24

N/>74;=>

Bmmc~jihf zc zdg Mchkg~ghmg ^gpc~z ch zdg ki}mba ygb~ 2997 bpp~cp~ibzich}bmz! zdg Mchf~g}} gtpgmz} zdbz zdg ]zbzg Jgpb~zoghz viaa z~bh}kg~ kwhj} zczdg Pgbmg Mc~p} zc mc{g~ zdg kwaa mc}z ck iz} ki}mba ygb~ 2997 cpg~bzich} ihzdg hgvay ihjgpghjghz }zbzg} ck zdg kc~og~ ]c{igz Which(

Jw~ihf gtpbh}ich ihzc zdg 24 mcwhz~ig} ih Mghz~ba bhj Gb}zg~h Gw~cpg bhjzdg kc~og~ ]c{igz Which! zdg Pgbmg Mc~p} ba}c }zb~zgj >0 bjjizichbap~cf~bo} ih zdg ~g}z ck zdg vc~aj bhj mac}gj c~ }w}pghjgj 20 p~cf~bo}!kc~ b hgz ihm~gb}g ck >4 mcwhz~y p~cf~bo}(

K~co ki}mba ygb~ 2949 zd~cwfd 299=! Pgbmg Mc~p} ji~gmz/di~g }zbkk

ihm~gb}gj ny 20 pg~mghz! k~co 2!062 zc 2!24=( Cw~ ~g{igv ck }zbkkihfbaacmbzich} ihjimbzg} zdbz zdg Bk~imbh bhj Ihzg~/Bog~imbh ~gfich} ~gmgi{gj}zbkkihf ihm~gb}g} ck : bhj 9 pg~mghz! ~g}pgmzi{gay! jw~ihf zdi} pg~icj! bhj}zbkkihf ih zdg B}ibh bhj Pbmikim ~gfich jgm~gb}gj ny 20 pg~mghz( Bmmc~jihfzc zdg Pgbmg Mc~p}! ik zdg hgv Gw~cpg! Mghz~ba B}ib! bhj Ogjizg~~bhgbh~gfich bhj iz} hgv pc}z} vg~g gtmawjgj! zdg hwong~ ck kwaay bmzi{g pc}z}vcwaj db{g ihm~gb}gj k~co 7> zc ;;! b >6/pg~mghz ihm~gb}g! bhj zdg ji~gmzdi~g }zbkk grwi{baghz vcwaj db{g ihm~gb}gj ny 24! b =(:/pg~mghz ihm~gb}g(Zdg Pgbmg Mc~p} Vb}dihfzch }zbkk ag{ga} ~gobihgj ~gabzi{gay mch}zbhzjw~ihf zdi} pg~icj(

B} zdg hwong~ ck Pgbmg Mc~p} p~cf~bo} ihm~gb}gj jw~ihf zdg pg~icj! zdgb{g~bfg hwong~ ck {cawhzgg~} }g~{ihf ih mcwhz~ig} vc~ajvijg jgm~gb}gj(K~co 2949 zd~cwfd 299= zdg zczba hwong~ ck {cawhzgg~} ihm~gb}gj k~co7!247 zc 7!=72 $bpp~ctiobzgay = pg~mghz)( Zdw}! vizd zdg hgz bjjizich ck>4 hgv p~cf~bo}! zdg Pgbmg Mc~p} bjjgj 2;; {cawhzgg~}( Jw~ihf zdi}pg~icj! zdg b{g~bfg ~bzic ck {cawhzgg~} zc mcwhz~y p~cf~bo} jgm~gb}gjk~co 40 zc 76( $Zvga{g ck zdg hgv p~cf~bo} jij hcz ngfih whzia ki}mba ygb~299=( Ngmbw}g zdg Pgbmg Mc~p} pcaimy i} fghg~baay zc pdb}g ih zdgbf~ggj/wpch mchzihfghz ck {cawhzgg~} c{g~ b >/ygb~ pg~icj! 22 ck zdg 2>p~cf~bo} dbj chay dbak zdgi~ {cawhzgg~ mchzihfghz} ih pabmg ih 299=(: $]ggzbnag >()

:Zdg 22 mcwhz~ig} vg~g Objbfb}mb~! \bonib! Eb|bed}zbh! Ey~fy|}zbh! Ocajc{b! Zw~eoghi}zbh!We~bihg! ^w}}ib! B~oghib! W|ngei}zbh! bhj Ga ]ba{bjc~( Ih zdg 2>zd mcwhz~y! Mdihb! zdg kwaamcopagoghz ck 24 ZGKA {cawhzgg~} ghzg~gj ih 299=()

FBC#H]IBJ/97/; Pgbmg Mc~pPbfg 2=


16/24

N/>74;=>

Zbnag >< B{g~bfg Hwong~ ck[cawhzgg~} ih b Mcwhz~y P~cf~bo ihGbmd gfich Ki}mba Ygb~ Bk~imb

B}ib bhjPbmikim

Ihzg~/Bog~imbh GMBO Vc~ajvij

2949 6; ;6 200 0 4

299= ;2 :: 64 =9 7

Mdbhfg 27 >= >> %=9 >

Pgbmg Mc~p} ckkimiba} bzz~inwzgj zdg ~gjwmzich ih zdg b{g~bfg hwong~ ck{cawhzgg~} pg~ mcwhz~y zc kbmzc~} czdg~ zdbh zdg ihizibzich ck p~cf~bo} ihzdg kc~og~ Gb}zg~h nacm( Kc~ gtbopag! p~cf~boobzim b}}g}}oghz} objgp~ic~ zc 2990 dbj ba~gbjy }wffg}zgj ~gjwmzich} ck c{g~ >70 {cawhzgg~} ih

Mghz~ba Bog~imb bhj zdg Mb~inngbh $Ngai|g! Mc}zb ^imb! Fwbzgobab!Dchjw~b}! Lbobimb! bhj Dbizi)( Ba}c! ;00 pc}izich} ngmbog b{biabnag vizdzdg mac}w~g ck zd~gg ab~fg p~cf~bo} $Aing~ib! zdg Pdiaippihg}! bhj \bi~g)bhj zdg zgopc~b~y }w}pgh}ich ck 22 czdg~ p~cf~bo} kc~ }bkgzy bhj }gmw~izy~gb}ch}(

^gmcooghjbzich} Hczvizd}zbhjihf zdg Pgbmg Mc~p} gb~aig~ jg{gacpoghz ck zdg PBZ] obhwbabhj iz} mw~~ghz ihizibzi{g}! vg ~gmcooghj zdbz zdg Ji~gmzc~ ck zdg PgbmgMc~p} gh}w~g zdbz zdg v~izzgh p~cmgjw~g} b~g kcaacvgj }c zdbz $2) p~cf~bopabh} b~g vgaa/jg{gacpgj! $>) {cawhzgg~} db{g ~gmgi{gj bjgrwbzgp~g}g~{img z~bihihf! bhj $=) {ibnag b}}ifhoghz} b~g ih pabmg ngkc~g

{cawhzgg~} b~~i{g(

Bfghmy Mcooghz} Ih mcooghzihf ch b j~bkz ck zdi} p~clgmz! zdg Pgbmg Mc~p} }zbzgj zdbz iz}p~cf~bo} ih Mghz~ba bhj Gb}zg~h Gw~cpg bhj zdg }zbzg} ck zdg kc~og~]c{igz Which db{g nggh b jikkimwaz mdbaaghfg( Zdg bfghmy ihjimbzgj zdbz}cog p~cnago} vg~g bzz~inwzbnag zc whirwg mi~mwo}zbhmg} ih zdi} ~gfich!nwz bmehcvagjfgj zdbz iz dbj n~cwfdz }cog p~cnago} ch iz}gak( Zdgbfghmy} mcooghz}! vdimd b~g ~gp~ihzgj ih zdgi~ ghzi~gzy ih bppghjit I!ji}mw}} zdg }zgp} zdg Pgbmg Mc~p} db} zbegh ~gmghzay ih bh gkkc~z zciop~c{g p~cf~booihf! z~bihihf! bhj }zbkkihf ih zdg ~gfich(

]mcpg bhjOgzdcjcacfy

Vg mchjwmzgj cw~ ~g{igv bz zdg Pgbmg Mc~p} dgbjrwb~zg~} ih Vb}dihfzchJ(M(! bhj ih Pcabhj! Nwafb~ib! ^w}}ib! bhj W|ngei}zbh( Zc b}}g}} zdg PgbmgMc~p} hgv mcwhz~y ghz~y p~cmg}}g}! mcc~jihbzich! bhj {cawhzgg~b}}ifhoghz bhj }wppc~z i}}wg}! vg ~g{igvgj mw~~ghz bhj di}zc~imba ~gmc~jbhj ihzg~{igvgj hwog~cw} Pgbmg Mc~p} ckkimiba}! ihmawjihf kc~og~ ckkimibavdc vg~g p~iob~iay ~g}pch}inag kc~ cpghihf hgv p~cf~bo} ih zdg ~gfich(

FBC#H]IBJ/97/; Pgbmg Mc~pPbfg 2:


17/24

N/>74;=>

Vg ~g{igvgj Pgbmg Mc~p} obhwba} bhj pcaimy jcmwoghz} bhj bhbay|gjnwjfgz! }zbkkihf! bhj {cawhzgg~ jbzb( Vg ba}c ogz vizd ckkimiba} k~co{b~icw} W(]( bfghmig} ~g}pch}inag kc~ mcc~jihbzihf b}}i}zbhmg zc zdg~gfich! ihmawjihf zdg Jgpb~zoghz ck ]zbzg! zdg Bfghmy kc~ Ihzg~hbzichbaJg{gacpoghz! zdg W(]( Ihkc~obzich Bfghmy! bhj zdg Ckkimg ck Obhbfgoghzbhj Nwjfgz(

Vg }gagmzgj zdg Pcabhj! Nwafb~ib! ^w}}ib! bhj W|ngei}zbh p~cf~bo} ch zdgnb}g} ck zdgi~ jikkg~ihf }i|g}! jbzg} ck ihz~cjwmzich! bhj fgcf~bpdimba bhjmwazw~ba ji{g~}izy! bhj ngmbw}g ck zdg mcwhz~ig} jikkg~ihf }zbfg} ckjg{gacpoghz( Pcabhj vb} chg ck zdg ki~}z p~cf~bo} ih zdg ~gfich! bhj zdg

ab~fg}z( Nwafb~ib vb} b }obaag~ p~cf~bo! ihz~cjwmgj bkzg~ Pcabhj( ^w}}ibvb} zdg ab~fg}z p~cf~bo ih zdg kc~og~ ]c{igz Which( W|ngei}zbh vb} babzg~ ghz~y! bhj ~gp~g}ghzbzi{g ck ghz~ig} ihzc mghz~ba B}ib( Zdg kcw~mcwhz~ig} vg~g }gagmzgj ih mch}wazbzich vizd zdg Pgbmg Mc~p}(

Ih gbmd ck zdg kcw~ mcwhz~ig} vg {i}izgj! vg cnzbihgj pg~zihghz jcmwoghz}bhj ihzg~{igvgj Pgbmg Mc~p} }zbkk! W(]( gonb}}y ckkimiba}! bhj~gp~g}ghzbzi{g} ck p~i{bzg {cawhzb~y c~fbhi|bzich} zdbz vc~egj vizd{cawhzgg~}( Ih gbmd mcwhz~y! vg ihzg~{igvgj b ab~fg hwong~ ck PgbmgMc~p} {cawhzgg~} bz zdgi~ }izg}( Vg ba}c {i}izgj }g{g~ba {cawhzgg~} p~clgmz}izg} bhj ihzg~{igvgj zdg dc}z/mcwhz~y pgcpag vizd vdco zdg {cawhzgg~}ai{gj bhj vc~egj(

Zc jgzg~oihg vdgzdg~ zdg Pgbmg Mc~p} gtpbh}ich ihzc zdg kc~og~ Gb}zg~hnacm mbog bz zdg gtpgh}g ck czdg~ ~gfich} p~cf~bo}! vg gtboihgj nwjfgzbhj }zbkkihf jbzb bhj }pceg vizd }ghic~ Pgbmg Mc~p} ckkimiba} ~g}pch}inagkc~ obhbfihf zdc}g p~cf~bo}( Dcvg{g~! vg jij hcz mchjwmz vc~e ih zdgczdg~ ~gfich}(

Vg mchjwmzgj cw~ ~g{igv ngzvggh ]gpzgong~ 299= bhj Lway 299: ihbmmc~jbhmg vizd fghg~baay bmmgpzgj fc{g~hoghz bwjizihf }zbhjb~j}(

Vg pabh hc kw~zdg~ ji}z~inwzich ck zdi} ~gpc~z whzia =0 jby} bkzg~ iz} i}}wgjbzg! whag}} ycw pwnaimay bhhcwhmg iz} mchzghz} gb~aig~( Bz zdbz ziog! vgviaa }ghj mcpig} zc zdg Ji~gmzc~ ck zdg Pgbmg Mc~p}! zdg ]gm~gzb~y ck ]zbzg!zdg Bjoihi}z~bzc~ ck zdg Bfghmy kc~ Ihzg~hbzichba Jg{gacpoghz! bhj zdgJi~gmzc~ ck zdg Ckkimg ck Obhbfgoghz bhj Nwjfgz( Mcpig} viaa ba}c ngobjg b{biabnag zc czdg~ ihzg~g}zgj pb~zig} wpch ~grwg}z(



18/24

N/>74;=>

Ik ycw c~ ycw~ }zbkk} db{g bhy rwg}zich} bncwz zdi} ~gpc~z! pagb}g mbaa ogch $>0>) 72>/:2>4( Oblc~ mchz~inwzc~} zc zdi} ~gpc~z vg~g Jb{ij ^( Ob~zih!Pbz~ime B( Jime~igjg! Gjvb~j J( Eghhgjy! bhj Pgzg~ L( Nya}ob(

Db~caj L( Lcdh}ch! Ji~gmzc~

Ihzg~hbzichba Bkkbi~} I}}wg}

FBC#H]IBJ/97/; Pgbmg Mc~pPbfg 2;


19/24



20/24

Bppghjit I

Mcooghz} K~co zdg Pgbmg Mc~p}



21/24

Bppghjit IMcooghz} K~co zdg Pgbmg Mc~p}



22/24

Bppghjit IMcooghz} K~co zdg Pgbmg Mc~p}

$6220=;) FBC#H]IBJ/97/; Pgbmg Mc~pPbfg >0


23/24

C~jg~ihf Ihkc~obzich

Zdg ki~}z mcpy ck gbmd FBC ~gpc~z bhj zg}ziochy i} k~gg(Bjjizichba mcpig} b~g *> gbmd( C~jg~} }dcwaj ng }ghz zc zdgkcaacvihf bjj~g}}! bmmcopbhigj ny b mdgme c~ ochgy c~jg~objg cwz zc zdg ]wpg~ihzghjghz ck Jcmwoghz}! vdghhgmg}}b~y( C~jg~} kc~ 200 c~ oc~g mcpig} zc ng obiagj zc b}ihfag bjj~g}} b~g ji}mcwhzgj >7 pg~mghz(

C~jg~} ny obia044:/;027

c~ {i}iz0>) 72>/;000c~ ny w}ihf kbt hwong~ $=02) >74/:0;;! c~ ZJJ $=02) :2=/000;(

Gbmd jby! FBC i}}wg} b ai}z ck hgvay b{biabnag ~gpc~z} bhjzg}ziochy( Zc ~gmgi{g kbm}ioiag mcpig} ck zdg jbiay ai}z c~ bhyai}z k~co zdg pb}z =0 jby}! pagb}g mbaa $=02) >74/:096 w}ihf bzcwmdzchg pdchg( B ~gmc~jgj oghw viaa p~c{ijg ihkc~obzich chdcv zc cnzbih zdg}g ai}z}(

P^IHZGJ CH ^GMYMAGJ PBPG^


24/24

Whizgj ]zbzg}Fghg~ba Bmmcwhzihf CkkimgVb}dihfzch! J(M( >07:4/0002

Ckkimiba Nw}ihg}}Pghbazy kc~ P~i{bzg W}g *=00

Bjj~g}} Mc~~gmzich ^grwg}zgj

Nwae ObiaPc}zbfg + Kgg} Pbij

FBCPg~oiz Hc( F200

Documents

Peace Corps New Programs In Former Eastern Block Should Be Strengthened - General Accounting Office - National Security and International Affairs Division