Upload
thanos
View
45
Download
0
Tags:
Embed Size (px)
DESCRIPTION
Partnering for Public Works. Dave Zelenok, City of Centennial Peter Cohlmia, CH2M HILL November 10, 2011. Presentation outline. City of Centennial CH2M HILL Partnering Process Partnering Cost Savings and Awards Lessons Learned Questions. City of Centennial. City of Centennial. - PowerPoint PPT Presentation
Citation preview
Partnering forPublic Works
Dave Zelenok, City of CentennialPeter Cohlmia, CH2M HILL
November 10, 2011
OM090210072927DEN
Presentation outline City of Centennial CH2M HILL Partnering Process Partnering Cost Savings and Awards Lessons Learned Questions
2
City of Centennial
OM090210072927DEN
City of Centennial Incorporated
February 7, 2001 Key Vision Elements:
• Efficient and effective government
• Contract for city services at all levels unless there is a provable advantage to doing otherwise
4
OM090210072927DEN
Outsourcing in Centennial Building Inspection Animal Services Sales Tax Collection Licensing Development Plan Review –
(2008 Reverted to City Staff) CIP Management Fire Districts Law Enforcement – IGA
Parks Districts Water & Sewer Districts Stormwater Districts Public Works
5
OM090210072927DEN
Centennial population
Denver 588,349Colorado Springs 376,427Aurora 311,794Lakewood 140,305Fort Collins 133,899Thornton 110,880Arvada 106,328Westminster 106,195Pueblo 103,805
CENTENNIAL ~100,000 - 110,000
Largest cities in Colorado – US Census Bureau
US Census Bureau: http://www.census.gov/popest/cities/SUB-EST2007.html
6
OM090210072927DEN
Centennial comparison toother cities City contracts
• Many public works departments already contract 50% to 80% (think: asphalt, fuel, construction contracts)
Many researched City budgets for contracted services• 5% – 25% typical city expenditures for services
(customer service, inspectors, engineers, managers)
City of Centennial budget for contracted services• 81.4% of general fund expenditures for contracted services• Centennial contracts 99% of its public works
Typical city of 100,000 ~ 500-1,000 employees• Centennial ~ 53
7
OM090210072927DEN
City of CentennialApproximately 30 square miles and 1,500 lane miles
DENVER
Colorado Springs , AF Academy & Pikes Peak ~ 38 MILES
15 MILESLITTLETON
AURORA
I-25
8
CH2M HILL
OM090210072927DEN
Founded on valuesEstablished in 1946 by three engineers and a professor, CH2M HILL operated from its very
beginning on four simple values: take care of clients, deliver great work, do right by
employees, and stay true to our integrity and honesty.
Clair HillHolly Cornell James Howland Burke Hayes Fred Merryfield
10
OM090210072927DEN
CH2M HILL is a global project delivery company, helping our clients build a better and more sustainable world
Fortune 400
Headquartered in Douglas County, Colorado
Operations on all continents
More than 24,000 employees
Employee-owned
Broadly diversified
$6.3 billion in revenue
11
OM090210072927DEN
CH2M HILL today
London 2012 Olympic and Paralympic Games
Panama Canal Expansion Program
U.S. Forces Korea Base Relocation in South Korea
Masdar City—the 1st carbon neutral, fully sustainable city in Abu Dhabi, UAE
Design-build of a new reverse osmosis water treatment plant in Bonita Springs, Florida
First offshore development on North Slope in Prudhoe Bay, Alaska
Centennial, Colorado – largest transition of Public Works to private operations in the US
Extraordinary projects
12
OM090210072927DEN
“Everyday Excellence” values drive our business
People first Safety Quality Integrity Citizenship Respect
13
The “Little Yellow Book”
Partnering Process
OM090210072927DEN
History and selection 2001 - City incorporated from Arapahoe County
• IGA for County Sheriff and public works
September 2007 – Decision to end County public works support in 8 months
October 2007 - Merrick & Co. hired to manage transition January 24, 2008 – Request for Qualifications February 19, 2008 – Request for Proposals March 10, 2008 – Selection recommendation to Council April 2008 – Contract negotiated with CH2M HILL July 1, 2008 – Contract public works service began
15
OM090210072927DEN
Service level analysis Merrick & Company retained in October
2007 to evaluate Arapahoe County’s level of service and the RFQ/RFP process
Merrick reviewed existing County services, including:• Snow and ice control management• Street sweeping• Tons of potholes patched• Signs replaced• Citizen requests – call volumes• Emergency response
16
OM090210072927DEN
RFQ – January 24, 2008 Identified three proposers qualified to respond to an RFP:
• CH2M HILL• Parsons Commercial Technology Group• RG Consulting Engineers
17
OM090210072927DEN
RFP - February 19, 2008 RFP requested two separate submittals:
• Written proposal• Cost proposal
City “in-house” model/cost prepared City price sealed
18
OM090210072927DEN
RFP process Step 1 – Quality-based selection
• Proposals ranked independent of costs
Step 2 – Costs reviewed separately Step 3 – Costs were compared to the City’s in-house estimate Step 4 – Presentation and interviews Step 5 – Selection
19
OM090210072927DEN
N.P.V. Financial Analysis Net present value
• All proposals adjusted for NPV over 5-year term• City credited with assets
Equipment Capital reserve Materials, fuel and other purchases
• No adjustment for contractor costs since City does not obtain assets in those scenarios
• Final comparison – NPV basis• No significant advantage to in-house operation
2020
Scope of Work
OM090210072927DEN
Pavement maintenance 85% of potholes in 24 hours 1,000 tons of patching/year 45,000 lbs of crack filling 300 tons of gravel City pays for asphalt materials
22
OM090210072927DEN
Snow plowing One pass on 689 lane-miles
in 12 hours 815 lane miles of non-plowed
Residential roads 60 12-hour call-outs per year $24,882 per additional call-out Real-time GPS tracking mandatory City pays for deicing chemicals and materials
23
OM090210072927DEN
Road work Concrete maintenance Asphalt patching – 3 types Street cut permits
• + $500,000
Pedestrian Ramp Concrete Radius
24
OM090210072927DEN
Traffic engineering 500 new signs per year 7-year replacement of existing signs 15,400 feet of preformed stop bars 1.1 million feet of latex striping 10 signal warrants 16 NTMP requests evaluated
25
OM090210072927DEN
Traffic services Intersection improvements Traffic impact studies School safety assessment Crash analysis Central system operations Timing plans Inventory Warrant studies Annual traffic count program Traffic calming
26
OM090210072927DEN
Signs and pavement markings Engineering studies for signing
and striping plans Annual inspection program Maintenance program
27
OM090210072927DEN
Performance measures Priority 1 – 24 hrs Priority 2 – 72 hrs Priority 3 – 7-10 days Priority 4 – Maximize
materials and efficiency
Request Priority
Average Time to Close (days)
1 0.422 1.213 3.874 N/A
Example of February 2009 PerformanceTraffic Services
Quarterly/annual reviews “Compass Report” in Council packets
28
OM090210072927DEN
Transportation planning Coordinate with other agencies
• Active cooperation with MPO, CDOT, local counties and cities
Provide support to city capital program management• Recommendations for 5- and 10-year projects
Identify funding sources and prepare federal, state and local grant submissions
Conduct transportation and traffic engineering reviews for development plans
Conduct traffic study reviews for development plans
29
OM090210072927DEN
Traffic services Traffic signals
• Provide operational oversight of 70 signals• Signal timing, coordination and maintenance
Traffic studies • Evaluate intersection signal warrant studies • Evaluate safety-related concerns - school districts’ requests
Traffic sign inventory and maintenance • Inspect and replace on a 7-year schedule• Apply current MUTCD standards
Pavement markings • Crosswalks, stop bars, striping, other thermoplastic markings
30
OM090210072927DEN
Traffic services Neighborhood traffic safety
• Manage and prioritize citizen requests • Make recommendations for improvements
Traffic accident analysis • Analyze severity and identify trends• Use GIS to visually represent trends
Intersection improvement program • Inspected for type and condition of traffic control devices, geometric
issues, and sight distance issues• Recommended improvements prioritized and categorized as major or
minor improvements
31
Professional Services Agreement
OM090210072927DEN
Terms Five-year term July 1, 2008 to June 30, 2013 Renewable for up to 5 additional 1-year terms Cost control and risk management
• Fuel and material purchases• Snow removal• Required to manage to a fixed budget
33
OM090210072927DEN
Performance measurements Performance standards, reporting and oversight
incorporated into contract Examples of performance standards:
• 400 tons of pothole patching per year• Primary and secondary snow routes clear in 12 hours• Emergency response as soon as safely practical, but
not to exceed 2 hours; crews on site in 4 hours• Customer calls answered within 2 minutes, 80% of the time
Penalties apply for unsatisfactory and non-performance Work within the contract may be traded/exchanged
34
OM090210072927DEN
Benefits Pre-determined costs mitigate future cost increases City redirects snow removal resources in localized storms “Reach-back” to CH2M HILL corporate resources Contractor can flex work force to changing demands Contract allows for work trade-offs per citizen demand One contract and one point of contact NO PERSONNEL WORRIES – no discipline
35
OM090210072927DEN
Value exchange table2009 EQUIVALENT VALUES OF MAINTENANCE ACTIVITIES
2009 Number of units in these columns are cost equivalent to 1.00 units in the Maintenance Activity Column Unit Example: 0.091 CY of curb and gutter replacement costs the same as 1.00 T of major patching
Value
Maintenance Pothole Patch Major Crack Gravel ADA Xpan CGSW Curb &
Activity Patch Back Patch Seal Maint Ramp Apron Comb Gutter Sidewalk
Units T T T T T CY CY CY CY CY
Pothole patch T $ 93.00 1.000 1.500 1.755 0.058 3.720 0.175 0.204 0.175 0.160 0.171
Patch Back T $ 62.00 0.667 1.000 1.170 0.039 2.480 0.117 0.136 0.117 0.107 0.114
Major Patch T $ 53.00 0.570 0.855 1.000 0.033 2.120 0.100 0.116 0.100 0.091 0.097
Crack seal T $ 1,600.00 17.204 25.806 30.189 1.000 64.000 3.019 3.501 3.008 2.754 2.941
Gravel maint T $ 25.00 0.269 0.403 0.472 0.016 1.000 0.047 0.055 0.047 0.043 0.046
ADA ramps CY $ 530.00 5.699 8.548 10.000 0.331 21.200 1.000 1.160 0.996 0.912 0.974
Crosspans & Aprons CY $ 457.00 4.914 7.371 8.623 0.286 18.280 0.862 1.000 0.859 0.787 0.840
C,G & SW Comb. CY $ 532.00 5.720 8.581 10.038 0.333 21.280 1.004 1.164 1.000 0.916 0.978
Curb & Gutter CY $ 581.00 6.247 9.371 10.962 0.363 23.240 1.096 1.271 1.092 1.000 1.068
Sidewalk CY $ 544.00 5.849 8.774 10.264 0.340 21.760 1.026 1.190 1.023 0.936 1.000
Street Sweeping LM $ 40.00 0.430 0.645 0.755 0.025 1.600 0.075 0.088 0.075 0.069 0.074
Mowing & ROW AC $ 310.00 3.333 5.000 5.849 0.194 12.400 0.585 0.678 0.583 0.534 0.570
Lane Striping MI $ 3,696.00 39.742 59.613 69.736 2.310 147.840 6.974 8.088 6.947 6.361 6.794
Thermo markings SF $ 13.00 0.140 0.210 0.245 0.008 0.520 0.025 0.028 0.024 0.022 0.024
New sign Install EA $ 194.00 2.086 3.129 3.660 0.121 7.760 0.366 0.425 0.365 0.334 0.357
36
OM090210072927DEN
Contract “values”
37
OM090210072927DEN
Performance Standards – Citizen Requests
OM090210072927DEN
Work – Plan vs Actual
Our Partnership Cost Savings and Awards
OM090210072927DEN
Our Partnership
Partners in Public Works since 2008
Providing CIP support at no cost Code Compliance Synergies with Public Works
• CIP and Code efficiencies provide City of Centennial 2012 Fiscal Budget Savings - $422,000
Capital Asphalt and Concrete Program Management Computerized Modeling of Snow routing
• Optimizing Routes for greater efficiency in time, materials and fuel
41
OM090210072927DEN
Our Awards Public Works Administration for Innovative Customer Service Call
Center from American Public Works Association Colorado Chapter
National Council for Public Private Partnerships (NCPPP) - The partnership for public works services – one of the largest of its kind in the nation – selected in the Service Award category
Two articles in American and City County Magazine
National League of Cities Municipal Excellence finalist and presentation with City Manager at NLC
Our Centennial partnership will be featured in April next year at the Alliance for Innovation Transforming Local Governments conference
42
Lessons Learned
OM090210072927DEN
Lessons learned Companies do not enjoy government immunity Performance standards are the key: tons, miles, hours, etc. Incentives, self-auditing, reporting & GPS tracking Eliminate uncertainties for bidders – fuel, asphalt, de-icers Allow flexibility to adjust quantities – trade-offs Lock-in experienced team up-front Eliminate “nickel & dime” changes in scope QA/QC program – clearly define how to monitor scope delivery Simplify how minor amendments are negotiated Define monthly and annual report contents Meet regularly – you cannot over-communicate Establish a true partnership with your contractor
44
Questions?