Upload
others
View
3
Download
0
Embed Size (px)
Citation preview
Algonquin FHT
Atikokan FHT
Barrie CHC
Barrie FHT
Bramalea CHC
Brighton Quinte West FHT
Burk’s Falls and District FHT
Centretown CHC
City of Lakes FHT
Ear Falls FHT
East Ottawa FHT
East Wellington FHT
Elliot Lake FHT
Four Villages CHC
Grandview Medical Centre FHT
Greenstone FHT
Guelph FHT – Dawson Site
Halton Hills FHT
Hamilton FHT – Rosedale Site
London Centre of Hope FHT
Maitland Valley FHT
Maple FHT – Clergy Site
Merrickville CHC
North Hastings FHT
North Huron FHT
North Kingston CHC
North Lambton CHC
North Lanark CHC
North Perth FHT
North Shore FHT
North York FHT
Owen Sound FHT
Petawawa Centennial FHT
Points North FHT(formerly Machin FHT)
Port Hope CHC
Rapids FHT
Red Lake FHT
Seaton House FHT
Smithville Family Medical Centre FHT
South Riverdale CHC
Southlake FHT
Summerville FHT – Harbon Site
Wawa FHT
Windsor FHT
Woolwich CHC
Participating Teams From...
2
“Congress is not so much a graduation, but a commencement.”Nick Kates, QIIP Provincial Lead
Over a 14-month period, 51 primary healthcare teams from across Ontario participated inQuality Improvement and Innovation Partnership’s Learning Collaborative 3. While keepingpatient outcomes and experiences at the forefront, teams were able to demonstratesignificant breakthroughs in the domains of chronic disease management, preventativecare and office practice redesign. This is the story of their quality improvement journey.
MissionThe Quality Improvement and Innovation Partnership willbe the provincial leader in quality improvement methods
for primary healthcare.
VisionOntario’s primary healthcare system will be recognized as
providing exemplary primary healthcare driven by acommitment to continuous quality improvement.
GoalTo advance the development of a high performing
primary healthcare system.
3
The conclusion of Learning Collaborative 3 marks an
important milestone for the 51 teams that engaged in
improvements related to diabetes management, colorectal
cancer screening and office practice redesign. This report
reflects the efforts that teams have made to test, study
and implement changes in the interest of improving
outcomes of care for the patients they serve in
communities across the province.
This report also marks another milestone with the end of
the first three Learning Collaboratives that QIIP launched
in early 2008, when we began the exciting journey of
introducing quality improvement to primary healthcare
practices in Ontario. As we learn together, we have
benefited immensely from all 121 teams, across three
Learning Collaboratives that have been willing to share
their improvement journey with us.
It has always been our goal to build capability and
capacity for a made-in-Ontario approach to quality
improvement that would advance a high-performing
primary healthcare system. Our experience with the
Learning Collaboratives has confirmed our belief that
Ontario is poised to lead the way in the implementation
and spread of quality improvement approaches that will
help transform the foundation of our healthcare system,
which is primary healthcare. We have had the privilege of
seeing teams demonstrate the benefits of a team-based
approach to care, embrace rapid cycle tests and
measurement as a way of doing their daily work and
redesign their processes to ensure patients receive care
on their day of choice. It has been these experiences
shared during breakout sessions, on storyboards, as part
of regular team meetings and via the listservs that has
provided us with the motivation to explore new ways to
continue to support and spread the improvement efforts
of primary healthcare teams.
As we transition to the Learning Community, we look
forward to working together to learn, share, innovate and
improve in the spirit of Excellent Care for All.
Important Milestones for QIIPand Primary Healthcare TeamsMessage from Brenda Fraser, Executive Director
QIIP is a provincial organization funded by the Ministry of
Health and Long-Term Care with the goal of advancing
the development of a high-performing primary healthcare
system. This goal is supported by three interrelated
strategies: networking and partnerships, resources and
supports, and improvement and innovation methods.
QIIP’s vision1 for a long-term system of improvement in
primary healthcare recognizes the need to engage and
leverage strategic partnerships with other key
organizations and individuals at a regional, provincial,
national and international level. In this way, QIIP’s
activities can build, with others, toward shared outcomes
related to a healthier population, improved patient and
care team experience and more effective use of resources.
Primary healthcare renewal 2 has been identified in
Canadian policy and by most health reformers as the
foundation in a sustainable healthcare system. The
opportunity for primary healthcare to coordinate,
integrate and expand systems of care is defined by the
following:
■ Collaborative care teams
■ Sickness prevention, population health and health
promotion
■ Informed research, knowledge translation and quality
improvement
The need to build capacity and capability for quality
improvement in primary healthcare in Ontario is being
advanced by QIIP, initially through the implementation of
three Learning Collaboratives based on the IHI
Breakthrough Series3 methodology. Continued
engagement of primary healthcare teams in quality
improvement will be supported by the Learning
Community model and will include a virtual workspace
(see page 10) for teams to learn, collaborate, innovate and
measure their improvements. The Learning Community
was launched in spring 2010 with six content-specific
Action Groups. Participants will work towards sustaining
their improvements and will take on the challenge of
additional areas of focus in primary healthcare.
The focus on learning and building knowledge are the
underpinnings of quality improvement. Since May 2008,
QIIP has supported over 120 Family Health Teams (FHT)
and Community Health Centres (CHC) from across
Ontario. The collaboration of teams has provided a
structure for learning, sharing and action as they make
system-level changes that lead to improvements in care.
Before quality improvement work began, a primary
healthcare team had to be created. For it to be a true
collaboration, many different roles within the team
needed to be represented. The core teams were
composed of:
The Physician Champion (principal leader at the practice
site)
Clinical/Technical Experts (allied health team
members/front office staff)
Team Lead (day-to-day leadership and coordination)
Reporting Lead (monthly data collection, reporting and
communication)
A learning collaborative not only brings teams together
around shared goals, but more importantly, it is a highly
effective way to accelerate widespread improvement. A
Quality Improvement Coach provided external coaching
to the team around the integration and application of
relevant frameworks to support quality improvement.
The teams have engaged in quality improvement work
in three areas of focus:
Chronic Disease Care – Diabetes
Preventive Care – Colorectal Cancer screening
Office Practice Redesign – Access & Efficiency
Through the application of the Model for Improvement4
and the integration of the Plan-Do-Study-Act (PDSA)
Cycle for testing change, the participating teams have
realized innovative improvements in provider
satisfaction, processes and patient outcomes.
Collaborative Team
About QIIP
4
The Frameworks for ChangeThree frameworks supported the quality improvement
efforts of the teams: the Learning Model3, the Model for
Improvement4 and Chronic Disease and Prevention
Management Model.5 The frameworks assisted in closing
gaps that existed in the systems of care of the
participating teams and in doing so, built the capacity to
innovatively move towards planned care, panel
management and a population health focus.
Designed on the Institute for Healthcare Improvement’s
Breakthrough Series Model3, the QIIP collaborative
incorporated the following elements of the Learning
Model:
■ Three Learning Sessions, which included workshops,
teachings, didactic speakers, storyboard presentations
and team meetings
■ Action periods between each learning session where
teams tested change ideas using the improvement
methodology of the Plan-Do-Study-Act Cycle
■ Information technology was used to help manage the
flow of information, learning and activities. Teams were
encouraged to post their reports and data on the virtual
office and to communicate with one another through a
listserv, regularly scheduled teleconferences, and
phone and email correspondence
■ Quality Improvement Coaches well versed in the models,
frameworks, tools and data analysis were assigned to
each team to assist members throughout their
participation
THE ORIGINAL IHI LEARNING MODEL3
“BREAKTHROUGH SERIES”
5
MODEL FOR IMPROVEMENT4
CHRONIC DISEASE PREVENTION & MANAGEMENT FRAMEWORK5
Used during the Learning Collaborative, The Model for Improvement methodology is a strategy for testing,
implementing, and spreading practice innovations. It includes the use of PDSA cycles or rapid cycle tests
of change to drive improvement.
The Chronic Disease Prevention and Management Framework guides our work to affect system change. It
conceptualizes an approach to care by showing how interactions and relationships between various parts
of a system aim to improve population health outcomes
6
The Frameworks for Change
Not sacrificing quality for quantity is just one suggestion
from the City of Lakes FHT for building a culture of
quality improvement within an organization. Using a
simple reminder to book an annual diabetic visit has
resulted in a staggering 97% compliance rate among City
of Lakes FHT patients. The development of their Happy
Birthday Initiative and diabetic group visits, was
developed by surveying diabetic patients within the FHT.
Results from the survey guided the team in developing a
program based on the needs and wants of their diabetic
patient population and resulted in a cooperative
relationship with their local Diabetes Education Centre.
Pilot Population:Diabetic patients of Dr. Jack Ceaser
On the month of their birth, diabetic patients are called
with a reminder to book their annual diabetes review
appointment. Happy Birthday packages are mailed to
these patients, complete with a lab requisition, enabling
them to complete their blood work prior to the visit.
During patient visits, physicians are able to easily review
recent lab values, past visits and chart in the electronic
medical record, using the Annual Diabetes Review stamp.
Patients are given a copy of the Diabetes Passport and
referred to appropriate healthcare providers within the
team and community.
In an effort to spread this initiative staff disseminated
the information to the remaining physicians.
The focus on chronic disease management gave teams the necessary resources for proactive and planned care for
selected diabetic patients. Using a survey to develop their Diabetes Happy Birthday Initiative and diabetic group
appointments, City of Lakes FHT were able to increase the percentage of retinopathy screening and documented
patient self-management goals among their diabetic population.
Diabetes
CITY OF LAKES FAMILY HEALTH TEAM74% INCREASE IN DOCUMENTED SELF-MANAGEMENT GOALS
PERCENT OF DM PATIENTS WITH DOCUMENTED SELF-MANAGEMENT GOALS IN THE LAST 12 MONTHS FOR DR. JACK CEASER
“Real improvements occur when teams and systems are aligned.” David Courtemanche, Executive Director, City of Lakes Family Health Team
City of Lakes Family Health Team - Staying Focused on the Patient Experience
7
RETINOPATHYSCREENINGRATES ALSO
INCREASE FROM
23% to 83%
8
Addressing a mass mailing to patients 50 to 74 years of
age with the notice “Important Message from your Family
Doctor” enabled Barrie and Community FHT – Team 2 to
educate their patients regarding the importance of
colorectal screening with a simple at-home testing kit –
Fecal Occult Blood Test (FOBT).
Letters with an FOBT screening kit were mailed to
patients along with the request to complete the test
within seven days. Patients who did not complete the test
were sent a follow-up letter, and returned results were
documented in the Health Maintenance Category of the
electronic medical record.
Success Story
Through mail screening, two Barrie and Community FHT
patients were detected with positive FOBT results. One
patient in particular, who did not come into the office on
a regular basis, responded to the
letter and completed the screening.
The test was positive and as a
result, underwent surgery. Using a
quality improvement approach and
adapting a program that is targeted,
resulted in early detection and life
saving surgery.
Screening Approach Spread to Other Areas
Successful FOBT screening rates led Barrie and
Community FHT to spread preventative screening
measures to other domains (pap tests, mammograms,
flu shots and other immunizations) with 89% to 96%
successful screening rates.
“When a team talks and shares, things change.”Laura Back, Registered Nurse
“Through FOBTscreening wesaved two lives.”Dr. Andrew Wozniak,Physician, Barrie andCommunity FHT– Team 2
The improvement efforts in the colorectal cancer screening domain focused on prevention through the development of
screening processes. Testing changes and incorporating self-management techniques, to improve screening rates, has
demonstrated that increased numbers of patients could effectively receive education and preventative screening.
Colorectal Cancer Screening
BARRIE AND COMMUNITY FAMILY HEALTH TEAM AN INCREASE OF 29% TO 86% OF PATIENTS SCREENED
FOBT FOR THOSE >=50 AND <=74 YEARS WITHIN THE PRECEDING 2 YEARS OR COLONOSCOPYSCREENING FOR DR. ANDREW WOZNIAK
Barrie and Community Family Health Team – Positive Patient Outcomes
“Working with the Barrie and Community FHT –Team 2 was very inspiring to me. Thisteam found the balance between quality patient care and efficient office practices. This isevidenced by their impressive FOBT screening completion numbers and their statistics forcompletion of pap smear and mammograms. The winners in this improvement journey
are the patients and the healthcare team.” Dora-Lynn Davies, Quality Improvement Coach
9
Office Practice RedesignPrimary healthcare providers across Ontario are
redesigning how they deliver services to provide care that
is focused on “doing today’s work today”. Teams are
implementing changes that are improving access that is
effective, efficient, patient-centered and team based. The
results are significant as teams have enabled patients to
receive timely access to the care they need. Applying
principles that include measuring for third next available
appointment (TNA), cycle time and red zone time
(efficiency), has demonstrated an improvement in the
flow of work, created efficiencies and balanced the supply
of care to meet the demand.
SMITHVILLE FAMILY HEALTH TEAMREDUCTION IN THIRD NEXT AVAILABLE APPOINTMENT FROM 31-0 DAYS
AVERAGE TIME TO THIRD NEXT AVAILABLE APPOINTMENT FOR DR. PAUL CANO
Smithville Family Health Team – Improving Access and Efficiency for PatientsWith the goal of reducing the average time to the TNA,
the Smithville FHT made tremendous improvements in
the practice of Dr. Paul Cano.
Reducing Backlog
Adapting the methodology of ‘doing today’s work today’,
Dr. Cano and his team worked hard at understanding,
evaluating and reducing the appointment backlog by
incorporating the following changes prior to launching
advanced access:
■ Addressing patient needs at the time of their
appointments – initially made for longer days, but
reduced the amount of future follow-up visits
■ Tracked supply and demand by using an Institute for
Clinical Evaluative Sciences tool to determine if current
schedule could meet demand
■ Added extra clinic time and extended two daily clinics
over a three-month period
Informing Patients
Three months prior to the start of
advanced access, patients of Dr.
Paul Cano received a letter and
frequently asked questions
sheet, notifying them of the
new booking method, patient
advantages and the success of
advanced access in other
practices across Ontario.
Improved Outcomesand Successful Spread
The official launch of advanced access in October 2009,
has since seen improvements in a reduction of TNA from
31-0 days, reduced no-show appointments and increased
staff satisfaction. Advanced Access was successfully spread
to three other physicians within the FHT.
“Advanced access has dramatically improved my patients’ ability to see me at thestarting point of their health problem. Only having to wait one day has decreased
their stress, as well as the stress of me and my staff.”Dr. Paul Cano, Physician, Smithville Family Health Team
SIGNIFICANTIMPROVEMENT SMITHVILLE FAMILYHEALTH TEAMA REDUCTION IN THIRDNEXT AVAILABLEAPPOINTMENT FROM 31DAYS TO 0 DAYS
In spring 2010, QIIP launched Wave 1 of the Learning
Community – a place for primary healthcare teams in
Ontario to come together to learn, share, innovate and
improve. The goal of the Learning Community is to
support teams in building capability and capacity to
improve clinical, functional and population health
outcomes in primary healthcare in Ontario. The
participation response has been tremendous.
There are six content-specific Action Groups: Asthma,
COPD, Diabetes, Hypertension, Integrated Cancer
Screening (breast, cervical, colorectal), and Office Practice
Redesign being rolled out during this first wave. Similar
to the Collaborative format, teams are expected to report
and post their data, and will incorporate a newly designed
web-based infrastructure called the GATEWAY. Teams
will also be supported by an external Quality
Improvement Coach.
The opportunity to partner with The Lung Association,
Heart and Stroke Foundation of Ontario and Cancer Care
Ontario has been invaluable in supporting the
development of the Asthma, COPD, Hypertension and
Integrated Cancer Screening actions groups.
LearnModel of Improvement,Chronic Disease Preventionand ManagementFramework, evidence-basedClinical Practice Guidelines
SharePDSAs (tests of change),ideas, outcomes,challenges, strategies,successes, and developedresources
InnovateChange, improve, andcreate new processes / oldprocesses, and tools andsystem of care
ImproveRegular measurement of acommon set of measuresthat will indicate whetherchanges made are resultingin improvement
The Learning CommunityThe Next Step in the Advancement of Primary Healthcare in Ontario
News & Events
Keep up-to-date andinformed with thelatest news andevents pertaining toyour Action Group.
Team Reporting Centre
Customize team –created documents foryour practice.
Group Discussions
An important part ofsharing andinnovating, the GroupDiscussions area willallow teams to shareknowledge, ideas andresources with oneanother.
For more information on the Learning Community, or to view the Action Group Charters, go to
www.qiip.ca and click on the Learning Community GATEWAY tab.
The Learning Community GATEWAY – A Virtual Workspace Example
10
Charter, ChangeConcepts, MonthlyReport Templates,Pre-Work Manual,PDSA/Progress ScoreTemplates, TreeDiagram
Action Groups arefounded on evidence-based ClinicalPractice Guidelines.Supporting documentsare available to assistteams in testingchanges, measuringoutcomes andsustaining gains.
Acknowledgment
References1. Quality Improvement and Innovation Partnership (QIIP) website: www.qiip.ca
2. Commission on the Future of Healthcare in Canada, 2002; Standing Senate Committee on Social Affairs, Scienceand Technology, 2002; Health Council of Canada, 2005
3. IHI Breakthrough Series, A collaborative model for Achieving Breakthrough Improvement. Innovation Series, 2003,www.ihi.org
4. Model of Improvement: The Plan-Do-Study-Act (PDSA) cycle was originally developed by Walter A. Shewhart as thePlan-Do-Check-Act (PDCA) cycle. Langley GL, Nolan KM, Nolan TW, Norman CL, Provost LP. “The ImprovementGuide: A Practical Approach to Enhancing Organizational Performance.”
5. Ontario’s Chronic Disease Prevention and Management Framework:www.toronto.ca/health/resources/tcpc/pdf/conference_lee.pdf
ResourcesAssociation of Ontario Health Centres (AOHC) www.aohc.org
Health Council of Canada www.healthcouncilcanada.ca
Please note our new address and phone number.
CollaborativePlanning Group
Co-ChairsPeter McKenna, Merrickville and District CHC
Anne DuVall, Barrie and Community FHT
Anne Marie Graham, Southlake FHT
FacultyCheryl Levitt, Cancer Care Ontario
Eileen Patterson, Ontario Health Quality Council
Hertzel Gerstein, McMaster University
Mike Hindmarsh, Hindsight Healthcare Solutions
MembersLynda Chilibeck, Peterborough FHT
Johanne Mousseau, Anson General FHT
Jamie Read, Sherbourne FHT
David Wallik, Caroline FHT
Kathi Carroll, Hamilton FHT
Andrew Oakes, MOHLTC
ConsultantsRoger Chaufournier, CSI Solutions
Christine St. Andre, CSI Solutions
QIIP StaffNick Kates
Brian Hutchison
Brenda Fraser
Trish O'Brien
Susan Wheeler
QIIP Quality Improvement CoachesCheryl Chapman
Nancy Dahmer
Dora-Lynn Davies
Ruth Dimopoulos
Maria Ferguson
Evelyn Gillson
Tracy Howson
Liz Jackson
Michele Mach
Milo Mitchell
Karen Palmer
David Smith
Erica Snippe-Juurakko
Mary Sylver
Tanya Spencer
Alice Strachan
Tricia Wilkerson
Lorri Zagar
Melissa Brink
Pierrette Price Arsenault
Julie Baird
Ashley Campbell
11
Special thanks to:Event Masters Digital Imaging, Fairmont Royal York Hotel,Frontenac Media Incorporated and Masahiro Design.
2345 Argentia Road, Suite 101 Mississauga, ON L5N 8K4T: 905-363-0490 | Toll Free: 1-877-794-7447 | Email: [email protected] | www.qiip.ca