Papa’s Signature 16oz

Premium Drinks $7.99

Salty Papa (Premium Margaritas)

Premium Margaritaville tequila and Grand Marnier liquer, blended with real lime, lemon

and orange juices; served on the rocks OR frozen with a salt OR sugar rim.

Traditional • Strawberry • Mango • Watermelon

Snowbirds (Frozen Rum Drinks)

All natural fruit purees frozen with locally-made Wicked Dolphin rums, topped with a dark rum

float, whipped cream and fruit. Pina Colada • Banana • Strawberry

Lemonade • Passionfruit • Watermelon Mango • Blueberry-Pomegranate

Racing the Waves (Mojitos)

Wicked Dolphin silver rum highlights this Cuban specialty of muddled fresh mint, lime slices, cane

sugar with sparkling soda. Traditional • Strawberry • Mango • Watermelon

Kentucky Wildcat

Chilled can of Kentucky-made Ale-8 ginger ale, side shot of premium Buffalo Trace bourbon, and a big glass of shaved ice...mix your own strength!

Shark Slayers (Moonshine)

Real summer fruit flavors spiked with 151 proof, pure grain “white lighting” and served on ice.

Sweet Tea • Watermelon • Strawberry Lemonade

Sanibel Key Lime Pie

Blue Chair key lime rum, locally-made Wicked Dolphin vanilla bean rum, real lime juice, and ice

cream. Chilled and served with a sugar rim.

Palm Tree Punch

Real passionfruit, mango and banana mixed with Wicked Dolphin spiced rum, served with fruit and a dark rum float frozen OR on the rocks.

Bayside Sunrise (Bloody Mary)

Your choice of premium vodka mixed with our blend of tomato juice, spices and horseradish. Tito’s • Absolut • Ketel One • Grey Goose

Dirty Arnold Palmer

Southern flavors of Firefly sweet tea vodka and all-natural lemonade served frosty cold over

ice...chill out after that 18th hole!

Blue Mermaid

Wicked Dolphin coconut rum and blue curacao with coconut cream and pineapple juice, topped by fruit and rum float frozen OR on the rocks.

Non-Alcoholic

Beverages

Bottomless Beverages $2.50 Pepsi • Diet Pepsi • Sierra Mist

Tropicana Lemonade Dr. Pepper • Root Beer • Mountain Dew

Fresh Brewed Iced Tea + Sweet Tea Regular or Decaf French Roast Coffee

Bottle or Can Selections $2.50

San Pellegrino Sparkling Water Kentucky’s Ale-8 Ginger Ale

Frozen Fruit Smoothies $3.99

Your choice of all natural fruit purees frozen and topped with whipped cream and fruit.

Pina Colada • Banana • Lemonade Strawberry • Passionfruit

Mango • Blueberry-Pomegranate

Bar Selections

All Day Happy Hour Prices Single Liquor House Brand Drinks $3.00

Domestic Draft Beer Pints $3.00 House Wines by the Glass $3.50

Daily 1/2 Price Signature Premium Drink

Draft Beers 16oz Pints Domestic $3.00/Pitchers $10.00

Budweiser Light • Yuengling Craft $5.25/Pitchers $18.00

Blue Moon and ask your server about our daily selections of Florida made craft beers.

By the Bottle/Can Domestic $3.25 Specialty $4.25

Michelob Ultra • Angry Orchard Cider Budweiser • Corona Extra

Coors Light • Florida Cracker BWA Miller Lite • Salt Life Lager

Odoul’s Amber N/A

Wines by the Glass $3.50 Moscato • Pinot Grigio • Chardonnay White Zinfandel • Cabernet • Merlot

(see our wine list for wines by the bottle)

Sangrias by the Glass $5.00 We start with Woodbridge wines, then add

real juices, spirits, sparkling soda, muddled fruit, and serve tall over ice.

White Peach Sangria or Red Fruit Sangria

Proper ID Required • Must Be 21

• Please Drink Responsibly •

Homemade Appetizers

Farmer’s Market Bread - Fresh bakery baguette toasted with garlic butter, fresh tomatoes, parmesan, blue cheese. $6.99

Chicken & Waffle - Southern fried chicken breast atop a sweet waffle, with

maple-bourbon syrup. $7.99

Southern Pimento Cheese Spread - Our recipe featuring cheddar, pimentos and a touch of onion and jalapeno, served with celery sticks and crusty bread slices. $6.99

Shrimp Starters - Lighter portions of our shrimp favorites with side of sauce. $8.99

Crispy Fried • Coconut Fried • Grilled

Peel-n-Eat Shrimp - 1/2 pound of large shrimp steamed in the shell. $11.99

Hot or Chilled with Old Bay • Spicy Cajun Butter • Key Lime Sunset Butter •

Drunken (simmered in beer, spices and butter)

Louisiana Gator Tail - Bite sized pieces of gator marinated, lightly-floured and fried,

served with our Cajun remoulade. $7.99

Lobster Cake - Our traditional recipe loaded with decadent wild caught lobster meat, sautéed golden brown, served over

greens with Cajun remoulade. $12.99

Fried Green Tomatoes - Southern fried in seasoned flour, sprinkled with parmesan

and bacon crumbles, served on fresh greens with side of homemade blue cheese. $7.99

Note: green tomatoes are not the same flavor as red tomatoes; the taste/texture is similar to a cross between tomatoes and artichoke hearts.

Jumbo Chicken Wings - Fresh, meaty jumbo wings, naked fried crispy, and tossed

in choice of sauce or specialty butter: Honey Pepper • Cajun Butter • Island Jerk

Garlic Butter/Parmesan • Ghost Pepper Buffalo Mild or Regular • Beer BBQ

Includes celery, side house ranch dressing. 1/2 Dozen $6.99 Dozen $12.99

Raw Oysters on the Half Shell *** Brought in fresh daily from the Gulf states

and hand-shucked when you order! 1/2 Dozen $7.99 Dozen $15.99

Atlantic Calamari OR Gulf Oysters - Lightly floured and flash-fried when you

order, with side of homemade sauce. $8.99

Olde Florida Smoked Fish Dip - Our daily fresh fish smoked in-house, and made into a creamy cool dip, garnished with diced red onions, red and jalapeno peppers, with celery sticks and crusty bread slices. $8.99

Onion Rings - Hand-cut and breaded to order, with side of ranch for dipping. $5.99

Crunchy Puppies - Sweet corn meal batter fried up crispy, served with side of

homemade Cajun remoulade. $5.99

From Scratch Soups

Cup $3.99 Bowl $6.99 Soup & Side Salad $6.99 cup / $9.99 bowl

Southern Style Clam Chowder - Fresh diced clams simmered in real cream and butter, with sweet corn, onions, bell peppers, potatoes, and a touch of bacon.

Salty Papa’s Gumbo - Chicken and andouille sausage simmered in a spicy

tomato stock with celery, onion and green peppers, topped with yellow rice.

Freshly Made Salads

Ranch • Blue Cheese • Honey Mustard Fresh Herb Vinaigrette • Caesar

Garden Salad - Fresh chopped romaine, tomato wedges, red onion slices, shredded

carrots, sliced cucumbers, and croutons. Side Salad $3.99 Large $6.99

Caesar Salad - Fresh chopped romaine lettuce tossed with shredded parmesan, croutons and creamy parmesan dressing. (anchovies on request .50 small/1.00 large)

Side Salad $3.99 Large $6.99

Everglades Salad - Our Cajun-spiced pecans, bacon crumbles, tomato wedges,

sweet red onion slices, hearts of palm, and blue cheese over a bed of fresh romaine

lettuce and mixed baby greens. Large $8.99

Southern Salad – Sweet Florida strawberries and Georgia pecans served over

bed of fresh romaine and mixed baby greens, with palm hearts, red onion,

croutons, goat cheese crumbles. Large $8.99

Add to Salad: Chicken Breast $6.00 Shrimp $7.00 Fresh Gulf Catch $12.00

(Grilled • Blackened • Fried)

Use care when eating oysters, crab and other shellfish as they may have shell particles present. Consuming raw or undercooked

meats, poultry, seafood, shellfish or eggs may increase your risk of foodborne illness, especially if you have certain medical conditions.

Chicken • Beef • Pasta

All Choices Include 2 Side Orders (unless noted)

Bacon Wrapped Petite Filet Mignon - Two cuts of tender, choice tenderloin, brushed

with garlic butter and grilled. $18.99

Steak & Shrimp Grill - Make our tender petite filet mignons even better with a skewer

of large shrimp added on the grill. $24.99

Southern Fried Chicken & Gravy - Two boneless breasts dredged in our seasoned

flour, fried golden brown and smothered with our andouille sausage white gravy. $14.99

Coconut Fried Chicken - Boneless strips lightly floured and coated with coconut, fried golden brown, side pina colada sauce. $13.99

Chicken & Waffles - Waffles stacked with two spice marinated, southern fried breasts,

topped with sweet potato fries and bacon, with bourbon maple syrup (no extra sides.) $15.99

Charleston Chicken & Grits - Creamy cheddar cheese grits topped with sautéed

chicken, spicy andouille sausage, white wine, peppers, and our signature Low Country

seasonings - with garlic bread (no extra sides.) $15.99 Regular or SPICY Ghost Pepper

Large Pasta Bowls - your choice of sauce over pasta, served with fresh garlic bread.

Cheddar & Cream Elbow Mac & Cheese

Ghost Pepper/Jalapeno Fire Mac & Cheese

Heavy Cream & Parmesan Linguine

Tomato & Herb Red Sauce Linguine

Garlic Butter & Wine Scampi Linguine

Pasta Only $10.99 Chicken Breast $16.99

Shrimp $17.99 Scallops or Catch $22.99

Florida Fish Entrees

Atlantic Flounder “Fish & Chips” - Mild, flaky whitefish, is tossed in crispy breadcrumbs lightly fried, served with fries and slaw. $15.99

Fresh Catches of the Day - A generous 1/2 pound of our delivered-daily fresh Florida fish

selections , cooked to your specification. $24.99 Grilled • Blackened • Fried • Sauteed • Broiled

Pecan Encrusted - Your choice of fresh fish pan sautéed in a light coating of crushed

pecans, with side of pina colada sauce. $25.99

Nawlins - Your choice of fresh fish blackened New Orleans style, and topped with our

homemade creamy Cajun pepper sauce. $25.99

Use care when eating oysters, crab and other shellfish as they may have shell particles present. Consuming raw or undercooked

meats, poultry, seafood, shellfish or eggs may increase your risk of foodborne illness, especially if you have certain medical conditions.

Sandwiches,

Po’ Boys & Wraps

All Choices Include 2 Side Orders

Black Angus Burger - 1/2 pound of fresh U.S. certified Black Angus beef grilled to order with lettuce, tomato and red onion. $10.99 ***

Breakfast Burger - Our 1/2 pound burger topped with a fresh egg fried over easy, white sausage gravy, bacon and cheddar and served

on two sweet waffles. $13.99 ***

Bayou Burger - 1/2 pound burger topped with a tower of homemade pimento cheese

spread, and topped with fresh jalapenos and a stack of hand breaded onion rings. $13.99 ***

Chicken Breast - Boneless white meat chicken breast prepared your way and served

with lettuce, tomato, onion. $9.99 Grilled • Blackened • Fried • Buffalo • BBQ • Jerk

Fresh Fish Catches - Fresh, Florida fish brought in daily, cooked your way and served

on roll with lettuce, tomato, onion. $18.99 Grilled • Blackened • Fried

Atlantic Flounder - Mild, flaky whitefish lightly fried in crispy crumbs, on bakery roll with

lettuce, tomato, onion, tartar. $12.99

Pan-Fried Lobster Cake - Our handmade recipe lobster cake, sautéed and served on bakery roll with creamy coleslaw, tomato,

lettuce, onion, and Cajun remoulade. $16.99

Jumbo Po’ Boys - Fresh bakery long roll served with your choice of crispy fried fresh protein. Served fully “dressed” with chopped

lettuce, tomato and Cajun remoulade. Oysters • Clam Strips • Shrimp $15.99

Scallops $17.99 Chicken $13.99

Fresh Market Wraps - Lettuce, tomatoes, onions, and grated cheddar in a grilled flour tortilla wrap, with your choice of dressing or

sauce on the side. Chicken Breast $10.99 Shrimp $14.99 Fresh Catch Wrap $20.99

Sandwich Customizers

Cheddar • Swiss • Blue Cheese • Goat Cheese • Bacon • Jalapeno • BBQ Sauce

Ranch • Country Gravy • Coleslaw .50 each

Southern Pimento Cheese 2.00 scoop

Salty Papa’s Shrimp

Includes 2 Side Orders (unless noted)

Peel-n-Eat Steamed Shrimp - Large wild-caught shrimp steamed in the shell.

Hot or Chilled with Old Bay Seasoning Spicy Cajun Butter • Key Lime Sunset Butter Drunken (simmered in beer, spices and butter)

1/2 Pound $14.99 Full Pound $23.99

Charleston Shrimp and Grits - Creamy cheddar cheese grits topped with an olde

south recipe of sautéed shrimp, spicy andouille sausage, white wine, peppers, and our signature Low Country seasonings - with

fresh garlic bread (no extra sides.) $18.99 Regular or SPICY Ghost Pepper

Bacon Wrapped Shrimp - Large shrimp wrapped in hickory smoked bacon, grilled and brushed with beer BBQ sauce. $18.99

Coconut Fried Shrimp - Half pound of large shrimp lightly floured and coated with coconut then fried golden brown, with pina

colada dipping sauce. $17.99

City Creole Jambalaya - Large shrimp, andouille sausage and chicken in a rich, spicy tomato stew with celery, peppers and onions,

thickened with dark roux and topped with rice, with garlic bread (no extra sides.) $18.99

Regular or SPICY Ghost Pepper

Fried Shrimp - Lightly coated in crispy bread crumbs and fried to a golden brown,

served with cocktail sauce for dipping. $17.99

Honey Pepper Shrimp - Grilled shrimp brushed with a glaze of orange blossom

honey and spicy chili peppers. $17.99

Naked Shrimp - Skewers of large shrimp brushed with garlic butter and grilled. $17.99

Bourbon & Peach Grilled Shrimp - Our glaze made from Georgia peaches and Kentucky bourbon that produces a sweet, caramelized flavor during grilling. $17.99

Lobster Stuffed Shrimp - Large shrimp baked with real wild-caught lobster meat

stuffing, a splash of white wine, and served with garlic-herb butter. $19.99

Caribbean Jerk Shrimp - Large shrimp skewers grilled, with our smoky sweet jerk

seasoning rub, served with fresh lime. $17.99

Shellfish Selections

All Entrees Include 2 Side Orders

Gulf Oysters - Plump “select” oysters brought in fresh daily from the Gulf states, lightly dredged in our seasoned flour and

flash fried until crisp. $16.99

Lobster Cakes - Our traditional recipe filled with chunks of real wild-caught lobster

meat, tossed with fresh herbs, and bread crumbs then pan-fried golden brown. $22.99

Atlantic Sea Scallops - A generous portion of fresh, large, and sweet sea scallops

cooked the way you like them. $22.99 Grilled • Blackened • Fried • Pan-Seared

Clams - We use fresh, never frozen Atlantic clam strips and toss them in a light dusting of

our seasoned flour, then flash fry so they’re crispy but stay tender. $14.99

Shellfish Combo Platter - Choice of two selections of shrimp, scallops, oysters, or

clams cooked the way you like them. $18.99 Grilled • Blackened • Fried • Sautéed

Florida Blue, Soft & Stone Crabs - We offer local Florida whole blue crabs (hard-

shell and soft-shell) and stone crab claws as harvest seasonality allows (ask your server.)

Snow Crab Legs - Since Florida crabs are very seasonal, we ship in Canadian snow crab to satisfy your crab craving year-round. Full pound of legs with drawn butter. $24.99

Side Orders $2.50 each

Creamy Coleslaw Cheesy Grits Hand-Cut Fries Garlic Bread Mashed Potatoes Baked Beans Sweet Potato Fries Hushpuppies Fresh Vegetable Yellow Rice Black Beans Small Bean & Rice

A small garden or Caesar salad may be

substituted for the two side orders included with entrées and sandwiches.

Always use care when eating oysters, crab and other shellfish as they may have shell particles present.

Retail Merchandise

Gift Cards - Available in any amount and refillable, give the gift of a great meal to someone who deserves a night out or a break from cooking! Shipping available.

T-Shirts - Full color design by Sanibel cartoonist Dave Horton printed front and

back on white 100% cotton t-shirts. (samples can be seen by front entry doors.)

SM • MD • LG • XL $15.99 XXL • XXL $18.99

Our Methods...

Why We Only Use Seafood Caught

& Harvested in America? It costs more, so why do we use only American-sourced and wild-caught seafood? As a Florida-

based restaurant that pays homage to the cooking influences of the south, supporting the hardworking seafood industry of the Gulf states and Atlantic seaboard is important to us. Only

using wild-caught seafood harvested in America (never farm-raised or imported from other

countries) ensures you safe and amazing quality seafood; we know our seafood is being caught

and handled in safe, proper conditions by licensed harvesters subject to U.S. inspections and regulations, and that sustainable, safe and

environmentally-sound practices are being followed, such as the use of sea turtle exclusion devices on shrimp boats, catch limits/restrictions and harvest area rotations, and rigorous testing

of oyster harvest areas.

Homemade With Love Like the

Good Olde Days in SW FloridaWe opened in 2014 with the mission to return cooking to how it used to be in this area; real

Florida seafood and a southern-influenced menu all made from scratch, served in a casual

atmosphere where shorts and flip flops are welcome. “Where the Bayou Meets the Beach” is the union of Cajun-Creole influences, southern

comfort food, and the tropical offerings of Florida. Using healthy, quality ingredients means

you can enjoy an indulgent meal and still be eating well. Our open kitchen means you can

watch us prepare your meal; you will never see bags and boxes of processed, frozen junk food in our kitchen. Our chefs and cooks prepare all

the base ingredient fresh from scratch daily, and your meals are cooked when you order.

Our food is not fast food; from-scratch

cooking takes a little longer, so enjoy a cold drink and some laughs, and know that your food is being made with love...we hope you

taste the difference!

Kids’ Meals

(12 and Under only)

Served with One Side Order $5.99

Cheeseburger - A quarter pound of fresh beef cooked medium-well with cheddar.

Chicken Breast - All white meat chicken

breast fried fingers or grilled slices.

Crispy Fish - Mild, flaky Flounder lightly coated in crispy crumbs and fried golden.

Shrimpies - Kid sized portion of our large shrimp served grilled or fried.

Pasta Bowl - Elbow macaroni pasta bowl with choice of mac and cheese OR tomato

sauce OR plain butter.

Kid’s Mix & Match Plate

Make a Meal with 3 Side Orders

Hand-Cut French Fries Creamy Coleslaw Fresh Vegetable Baked Beans Mashed Potatoes Garlic Bread Sweet Potato Fries Cheesy Grits Hushpuppies Yellow Rice Black Beans Bean & Rice

Desserts

Florida Key Lime Pie - Huge slice of our homemade pie, featuring real Key West lime juice and heavy cream, served in a graham cracker crust with fresh Florida strawberry

drizzle and whipped cream. $5.99

Mud Puppy - Rich and creamy, whipped peanut butter and cream cheese, with a grain-free pecan pie crust, drizzled with

homemade dark chocolate ganache. $5.99

Love Boat Ice Creams - Four scoops of our favorite ice cream made locally here in

Ft. Myers (several flavor choices daily.) $5.99

Puppy Meals

Served on the patio for our furry friends, and all pups get ice water and dog treats!

Small Pupper $3.99 Large Doggo $5.99

Ground Beef - sautéed with fresh vegetables or yellow rice.

Cubed Chicken Breast - steamed with fresh vegetables or yellow rice

Pup “Ice Cream” - peanut butter and banana combine for a yummy treat. $1.00

Gluten-Free Options

YES! We have a designated deep fryer so you CAN have fries and wings!

Salads

Garden Salads • Caesar Salads • Everglades Salad • Strawberry-Pecan Salad

(ask for no croutons on any of our salads)

All Salad Dressings: Ranch • Blue Cheese • Honey Mustard • Herb Vinaigrette • Caesar

Appetizers

Peel & Eat Shrimp (regular, Cajun or Sunset)

Chicken Wings All Flavors (ask for gluten-free frying)

Oysters on the Half Shell

Pimento Cheese Spread (ask for celery instead of bread)

Smoked Fish Dip (ask for celery instead of bread)

Entrees

All Fish, Shrimp, Shellfish, Chicken, or Beef Prepared:

Grilled • Blackened • Broiled • Sauteed

Shrimp (or) Chicken & Grits (ask for GF side order instead of garlic bread)

Bourbon & Peach Grilled Shrimp

Honey Pepper Grilled Shrimp

BBQ Bacon Wrapped Shrimp (ask for plain/gluten free BBQ sauce)

Dips & Sauces

Tartar Sauce • Cocktail Sauce • Pina Colada Sauce • Cajun Remoulade

Side Orders

French Fries • Sweet Potato Fries • Mashed Potatoes • Coleslaw

Baked Beans • Black Beans • Yellow Rice • Fresh Vegetable

Desserts

Homemade Mud Puppy

Love Boat Ice Cream Made in Fort Myers, FL

(ask your server for the GF flavor as some flavors may have cookies or crumbs added)

Allergens/Dietary Restrictions

Allergens

Please notify your server if you have a severe food allergy and they will consult with the

kitchen regarding ingredients and safe food handling for your meal. Since our food is

homemade and cooked to order, we know what goes into it and can check ingredients for

you. Please note that cooks must go through extra steps for allergen safety, so please only

use this designation for actual allergies and not for dietary restrictions or preferences (for

example having actual celiac disease gluten allergy vs. choosing not to eat wheat products.)

Dietary Restrictions/Preferences

If you are on a restricted eating style such as grain-free, pescatarian or paleo, you can look

through our menu and work with your server to prepare a meal that will suit your needs.