39
Kevin Kitzman & Scott Courtney ALCOA, Inc. & Walt Eifert Roux Associates, Inc. Overview Of Alcoas Enhanced Natural Systems (ENS) Project ALCOA Mt. Holly, South Carolina International Applied Phytotechnologies Conference Chicago, Illinois March 3 5, 2003 Presented by:

Overview Of Alcoa™s Enhanced Natural Systems (ENS) Project · 2003-04-25 · Kevin Kitzman & Scott Courtney ALCOA, Inc. & Walt Eifert Roux Associates, Inc. Overview Of Alcoa™s

  • Upload
    others

  • View
    0

  • Download
    0

Embed Size (px)

Citation preview

Page 1: Overview Of Alcoa™s Enhanced Natural Systems (ENS) Project · 2003-04-25 · Kevin Kitzman & Scott Courtney ALCOA, Inc. & Walt Eifert Roux Associates, Inc. Overview Of Alcoa™s

Kevin Kitzman &Scott Courtney

ALCOA, Inc.&

Walt Eifert

Roux Associates, Inc.

Overview Of Alcoa�sEnhanced Natural Systems (ENS)

Project

ALCOAMt. Holly, South Carolina

International AppliedPhytotechnologies Conference

Chicago, IllinoisMarch 3 � 5, 2003

Presented by:

Page 2: Overview Of Alcoa™s Enhanced Natural Systems (ENS) Project · 2003-04-25 · Kevin Kitzman & Scott Courtney ALCOA, Inc. & Walt Eifert Roux Associates, Inc. Overview Of Alcoa™s

Alcoa, Mt. Holly Plant

Page 3: Overview Of Alcoa™s Enhanced Natural Systems (ENS) Project · 2003-04-25 · Kevin Kitzman & Scott Courtney ALCOA, Inc. & Walt Eifert Roux Associates, Inc. Overview Of Alcoa™s

Alcoa, Mt. Holly Plant

Page 4: Overview Of Alcoa™s Enhanced Natural Systems (ENS) Project · 2003-04-25 · Kevin Kitzman & Scott Courtney ALCOA, Inc. & Walt Eifert Roux Associates, Inc. Overview Of Alcoa™s

Purpose Of Mt. Holly ENS Pilot Project

! Identify and evaluate passive �green� technologies that can:"Enhance the stormwater quality

in on-site retention ponds;

"Reduce the quantity of water discharged from stormwater retention ponds;

"Eliminate process water discharges to the local POTW; and

"Enhance the quality of stormwater runoff from the

Page 5: Overview Of Alcoa™s Enhanced Natural Systems (ENS) Project · 2003-04-25 · Kevin Kitzman & Scott Courtney ALCOA, Inc. & Walt Eifert Roux Associates, Inc. Overview Of Alcoa™s

!Demonstrate the viability of using passive

technologies at the Mt. Holly Site;

!Demonstrate the cost-effectiveness of ENS

technologies; and

!Develop full-scale applications for Alcoa sites

world-wide.

Purpose Of Mt. Holly ENS Pilot Project (continued)

Page 6: Overview Of Alcoa™s Enhanced Natural Systems (ENS) Project · 2003-04-25 · Kevin Kitzman & Scott Courtney ALCOA, Inc. & Walt Eifert Roux Associates, Inc. Overview Of Alcoa™s

Zero Water Program Update

Goal: To develop/test/demonstrate zero water natural treatment systems, technologies, and minimization approaches for Alcoa use worldwide.

Focus on zero water discharge and protection of groundwater through chemical sequestration/degradation.

Partnerships between ATC, Primary Metals, Mt Holly, EHS Services, EHS Science & Technology

July 25, 2002

Page 7: Overview Of Alcoa™s Enhanced Natural Systems (ENS) Project · 2003-04-25 · Kevin Kitzman & Scott Courtney ALCOA, Inc. & Walt Eifert Roux Associates, Inc. Overview Of Alcoa™s

Water Management Current Condition

WaterIntake

Rain

ProcessWater

Treatment$$$NPDES

Discharge

Treatment$$$

Storm SurgeBasins

$$$

NPDESDischarge

ContaminatedRunoff

River/LakePotential

Liability

Potential

Liability

Page 8: Overview Of Alcoa™s Enhanced Natural Systems (ENS) Project · 2003-04-25 · Kevin Kitzman & Scott Courtney ALCOA, Inc. & Walt Eifert Roux Associates, Inc. Overview Of Alcoa™s

Alcoa�s Zero Water Discharge Conceptual Approach (Process and Storm Waters) Future Condition

POTW

Sanitaryww

Recycle

Minimize Runoff�Green Roofs�Grass Filter Strips�Porous Pavement

ReducedMake-up Permitted

DischargeDuring

ExtremeStormEvent

Rain

Natural Treatment Systems�Trees�Constructed wetland

Cooling Water Treatment & Discharge

�Non-chemical treatment

Note: Elimination of Contaminated Sewer Lines

Page 9: Overview Of Alcoa™s Enhanced Natural Systems (ENS) Project · 2003-04-25 · Kevin Kitzman & Scott Courtney ALCOA, Inc. & Walt Eifert Roux Associates, Inc. Overview Of Alcoa™s

Components Of Mt. Holly ENS Project

! East Pond Area� Constructed Treatment Wetlands (CTW

! Former Spray Field Area� Phyto Pilot Plot� Grass Pilot Plot

! Pot Line Courtyard Areas� Vegetative Filter Strip� Control Plot

Page 10: Overview Of Alcoa™s Enhanced Natural Systems (ENS) Project · 2003-04-25 · Kevin Kitzman & Scott Courtney ALCOA, Inc. & Walt Eifert Roux Associates, Inc. Overview Of Alcoa™s

Locations Of Pilot ENS Components

Process Lagoon

Constructed Wetlands Pilot PlotPotline Courtyards

East Pond

Trees

BufferBuffer

GrassGrassFormer Spray Field Area

Phytotechnology Phytotechnology Pilot PlotsPilot Plots

Page 11: Overview Of Alcoa™s Enhanced Natural Systems (ENS) Project · 2003-04-25 · Kevin Kitzman & Scott Courtney ALCOA, Inc. & Walt Eifert Roux Associates, Inc. Overview Of Alcoa™s

East Pond ENS Pilot

CTW for Fluoride/Metals

Removal

Page 12: Overview Of Alcoa™s Enhanced Natural Systems (ENS) Project · 2003-04-25 · Kevin Kitzman & Scott Courtney ALCOA, Inc. & Walt Eifert Roux Associates, Inc. Overview Of Alcoa™s
Page 13: Overview Of Alcoa™s Enhanced Natural Systems (ENS) Project · 2003-04-25 · Kevin Kitzman & Scott Courtney ALCOA, Inc. & Walt Eifert Roux Associates, Inc. Overview Of Alcoa™s

East Pond CTW Design

Key Design Elements:! No. Test Cells: 2

! Cell Size (each): 75� x 150� (11,250 ft2)

! Cell Types: Sub-Surface Flow

! Constituents Of Interest: Fl, As, Al, Mn, Ni, Zn

! Treatment Sequencing and Removal Mechanisms:

# Cell 1: Fluoride removal via adsorption

# Cell 2: Metals removal via sulfate reduction

/co-precipitation

! Design Flow: 10 gpm (14,400 gpd)

! Water Source: East Pond

! Discharge To: East Pond

Page 14: Overview Of Alcoa™s Enhanced Natural Systems (ENS) Project · 2003-04-25 · Kevin Kitzman & Scott Courtney ALCOA, Inc. & Walt Eifert Roux Associates, Inc. Overview Of Alcoa™s

Outfall 002

Constructed Wetlands Pilot Plot

East Pond

Cell 1Cell 2

Page 15: Overview Of Alcoa™s Enhanced Natural Systems (ENS) Project · 2003-04-25 · Kevin Kitzman & Scott Courtney ALCOA, Inc. & Walt Eifert Roux Associates, Inc. Overview Of Alcoa™s

Basis For Design

! Bench Testing To Evaluate:

" the effectiveness of experimental media to remove fluoride from stormwater;

" the effectiveness of spent-mushroom compas a metals treatment media;

" design hydraulic retention times;

" pilot cell sizing requirements; and

" sequencing requirements.

Page 16: Overview Of Alcoa™s Enhanced Natural Systems (ENS) Project · 2003-04-25 · Kevin Kitzman & Scott Courtney ALCOA, Inc. & Walt Eifert Roux Associates, Inc. Overview Of Alcoa™s

East Pond Bench Testing Program

Page 17: Overview Of Alcoa™s Enhanced Natural Systems (ENS) Project · 2003-04-25 · Kevin Kitzman & Scott Courtney ALCOA, Inc. & Walt Eifert Roux Associates, Inc. Overview Of Alcoa™s

East Pond CTW Pilot Layout

Page 18: Overview Of Alcoa™s Enhanced Natural Systems (ENS) Project · 2003-04-25 · Kevin Kitzman & Scott Courtney ALCOA, Inc. & Walt Eifert Roux Associates, Inc. Overview Of Alcoa™s
Page 19: Overview Of Alcoa™s Enhanced Natural Systems (ENS) Project · 2003-04-25 · Kevin Kitzman & Scott Courtney ALCOA, Inc. & Walt Eifert Roux Associates, Inc. Overview Of Alcoa™s
Page 20: Overview Of Alcoa™s Enhanced Natural Systems (ENS) Project · 2003-04-25 · Kevin Kitzman & Scott Courtney ALCOA, Inc. & Walt Eifert Roux Associates, Inc. Overview Of Alcoa™s

Potline Courtyard

Grass Filter Strips For

Fluoride Removal

Page 21: Overview Of Alcoa™s Enhanced Natural Systems (ENS) Project · 2003-04-25 · Kevin Kitzman & Scott Courtney ALCOA, Inc. & Walt Eifert Roux Associates, Inc. Overview Of Alcoa™s

Potline Courtyard ENS Design

Key Design Elements:

! No. Test Plots: 2# ENS Plot (3 grass filter strips)# Control Plot (gravel)

! Plot Size: 750� x 60� (45,000 ft2)

! Vegetation: Buffalo and Bahia Grass

! Water Source: Roof Drainage from PotlineArea

! Constituents Of Interest: Fluoride, Aluminum,

TSS

! Treatment Objective:# Enhance storm water runoff quality

and reduce quantity of runoff

Page 22: Overview Of Alcoa™s Enhanced Natural Systems (ENS) Project · 2003-04-25 · Kevin Kitzman & Scott Courtney ALCOA, Inc. & Walt Eifert Roux Associates, Inc. Overview Of Alcoa™s

Roadway

Existing Catch Basin

Courtyard Vegetated Filter Strips

Vegetated Grass Filter Strip Pilot Plot

Page 23: Overview Of Alcoa™s Enhanced Natural Systems (ENS) Project · 2003-04-25 · Kevin Kitzman & Scott Courtney ALCOA, Inc. & Walt Eifert Roux Associates, Inc. Overview Of Alcoa™s
Page 24: Overview Of Alcoa™s Enhanced Natural Systems (ENS) Project · 2003-04-25 · Kevin Kitzman & Scott Courtney ALCOA, Inc. & Walt Eifert Roux Associates, Inc. Overview Of Alcoa™s
Page 25: Overview Of Alcoa™s Enhanced Natural Systems (ENS) Project · 2003-04-25 · Kevin Kitzman & Scott Courtney ALCOA, Inc. & Walt Eifert Roux Associates, Inc. Overview Of Alcoa™s
Page 26: Overview Of Alcoa™s Enhanced Natural Systems (ENS) Project · 2003-04-25 · Kevin Kitzman & Scott Courtney ALCOA, Inc. & Walt Eifert Roux Associates, Inc. Overview Of Alcoa™s

Sprayfield

Phyto Plots For Water Consumption/Metals

Retention

Page 27: Overview Of Alcoa™s Enhanced Natural Systems (ENS) Project · 2003-04-25 · Kevin Kitzman & Scott Courtney ALCOA, Inc. & Walt Eifert Roux Associates, Inc. Overview Of Alcoa™s

Alcoa-Mt. Holly Sprayfield Area & Process Lagoon

Page 28: Overview Of Alcoa™s Enhanced Natural Systems (ENS) Project · 2003-04-25 · Kevin Kitzman & Scott Courtney ALCOA, Inc. & Walt Eifert Roux Associates, Inc. Overview Of Alcoa™s

Spray Field Phyto Pilot Plot Design

Key Design Elements:!No. Test Plots: 2!Plot Size (each): 258� x 225� (58,000 ft2)!Vegetation:‣ Plot 1: Tree/Grass Mix ‣Plot 2: Grass

! Irrigation Water: Retrofit of Existing Lagoon System

!Preliminary Application Rate‣ 16,000 gpd/plot

! Constituents Of Interest (COIs):Fl, Cu, Mn, Ni, Zn

! Treatment Mechanisms:‣ Consumptive water use through ET Loss

‣ COIs are retained in root zone

Page 29: Overview Of Alcoa™s Enhanced Natural Systems (ENS) Project · 2003-04-25 · Kevin Kitzman & Scott Courtney ALCOA, Inc. & Walt Eifert Roux Associates, Inc. Overview Of Alcoa™s

Spray Field Phyto Plot Layout

Page 30: Overview Of Alcoa™s Enhanced Natural Systems (ENS) Project · 2003-04-25 · Kevin Kitzman & Scott Courtney ALCOA, Inc. & Walt Eifert Roux Associates, Inc. Overview Of Alcoa™s

Sprayfield Phytotechnology Pilot Plots

Grass Pilot Plot

Hybrid Poplar Tree Plot

Irrigation Lines from Process Lagoon

Page 31: Overview Of Alcoa™s Enhanced Natural Systems (ENS) Project · 2003-04-25 · Kevin Kitzman & Scott Courtney ALCOA, Inc. & Walt Eifert Roux Associates, Inc. Overview Of Alcoa™s

Basis For Design

! Rooting Test Experiments To Determine:

" the ability of site soils to support and sustain

a viable vegetative community;

" appropriate tree and grass species to be usedat the site; and

" the form and amount of soil supplements

required to support the selected species.

Page 32: Overview Of Alcoa™s Enhanced Natural Systems (ENS) Project · 2003-04-25 · Kevin Kitzman & Scott Courtney ALCOA, Inc. & Walt Eifert Roux Associates, Inc. Overview Of Alcoa™s
Page 33: Overview Of Alcoa™s Enhanced Natural Systems (ENS) Project · 2003-04-25 · Kevin Kitzman & Scott Courtney ALCOA, Inc. & Walt Eifert Roux Associates, Inc. Overview Of Alcoa™s
Page 34: Overview Of Alcoa™s Enhanced Natural Systems (ENS) Project · 2003-04-25 · Kevin Kitzman & Scott Courtney ALCOA, Inc. & Walt Eifert Roux Associates, Inc. Overview Of Alcoa™s
Page 35: Overview Of Alcoa™s Enhanced Natural Systems (ENS) Project · 2003-04-25 · Kevin Kitzman & Scott Courtney ALCOA, Inc. & Walt Eifert Roux Associates, Inc. Overview Of Alcoa™s
Page 36: Overview Of Alcoa™s Enhanced Natural Systems (ENS) Project · 2003-04-25 · Kevin Kitzman & Scott Courtney ALCOA, Inc. & Walt Eifert Roux Associates, Inc. Overview Of Alcoa™s

Spray Field Phytotechnology (Tree) Plot Cross Section

1-year old hybrid cultivar polesExisting topsoil

2� wide x 4� deep planting trench (TYP.)

Irrigation spray head (TYP.)

Page 37: Overview Of Alcoa™s Enhanced Natural Systems (ENS) Project · 2003-04-25 · Kevin Kitzman & Scott Courtney ALCOA, Inc. & Walt Eifert Roux Associates, Inc. Overview Of Alcoa™s
Page 38: Overview Of Alcoa™s Enhanced Natural Systems (ENS) Project · 2003-04-25 · Kevin Kitzman & Scott Courtney ALCOA, Inc. & Walt Eifert Roux Associates, Inc. Overview Of Alcoa™s

! Cost Advantages:" Cost savings of 50-80% can be realized in capital

investment stage; and

" Cost savings exceeding 90% are typical in the operation & maintenance stage.

! Other Advantages Include:" Simplicity of operation and maintenance;

" Tolerance to wide fluctuations in hydraulic and constituent loading rates; and

" Aesthetic attributes.

Projected ENS Benefits

Page 39: Overview Of Alcoa™s Enhanced Natural Systems (ENS) Project · 2003-04-25 · Kevin Kitzman & Scott Courtney ALCOA, Inc. & Walt Eifert Roux Associates, Inc. Overview Of Alcoa™s

Enter TitleThe Far Side

�Well, actually, Doreen, I rather resent being called a �swamp thing.�

�I prefer the term �wetlands-challenged mutant.��