1
TRENDS in Parasitology Vol.18 No.4 April 2002 http://parasites.trends.com 1471-4922/02/$ – see front matter © 2002 Elsevier Science Ltd. All rights reserved. 150 News & Comment Ovalocytosis, the occurrence of red blood cells with an oval biconcave shape and varying degrees of elliptical aberration, is associated with protection against malaria. It was often said that once a genotypic marker for the occurrence of ovalocytosis in Papua New Guinea (PNG) was found, the whole story of protection provided against falciparum malaria would be unravelled. That seemed to be the case when a 27-bp deletion in Band 3 (the major red blood cell transmembrane anion transporter) was associated with ovalocytosis in many coastal, malaria- endemic areas of PNG. However, in another area of PNG, the Wosera, where ovalocytosis is also common, Patel et al., have found that only one out of 1019 individuals had this 27-bp deletion [1]. Instead, another deletion in exon 3 of the glycophorin C gene, which is homologous to glycophorin A (a major receptor for Plasmodium falciparum) and encodes a sialoglycoprotein found on the surface of red blood cells, achieved a gene frequency of 0.465. This deletion also leads to the ovalocytosis phenotype. The genotype frequencies of the normal glycophorin C heterozygote and homozygote were in Hardy–Weinberg equilibrium, which argues against the selective advantage of this genotype in malaria. However, even more striking, was the identification of individuals who possessed ovalocytic red blood cells but did not have a mutation in Band 3 or the glycophorin C gene. This would indicate that there could be other genetic causes for ovalocytic cells. Over a seven- month period, Patel et al., examined the blood films of between 325 and 696 individuals monthly, but were unable to show any difference in the prevalence or density of P.falciparum and Plasmodium vivax infections in the different glycophorin C genotypes. However, examining individuals who either develop severe disease or die would reveal more information. This fascinating story of ovalocytosis in PNG continues to unravel and, in doing so, has exposed more than expected. The story is far from complete – so watch this space! 1 Patel, S.S. et al. (2001) The association of the glycophorin C exon 3 deletion with ovalocytosis in malaria susceptibility in the Wosera, Papua New Guinea. Blood 98, 3489–3491 Geoffrey Pasvol [email protected] Ovalocytosis in Papua New Guinea Four aspartic proteases occur in the Plasmodium falciparum food vacuole Hemoglobin (Hb) is a major food source for the malaria parasite during the intraerythrocytic blood stage. Hb is ingested into a specialized acidic compartment, the food vacuole (FV), where it is broken down into short peptides and the released haem is incorporated into hemozoin. Amino acids are then liberated from these peptides outside the FV and used by the parasite. This Hb proteolysis process is catalyzed by a series of enzymes, including plasmepsins. Plasmepsins are aspartic protease enzymes, two of which, plasmepsin (PM) I and PM II, have been well characterized. These enzymes are capable of cleaving native Hb. A cysteine protease enzyme, falcipain, and a metalloprotease, falcilysin, are involved in further degrading the protein to short peptides. Given the central role of these processes in the blood stage, these enzymes represent an important potential drug target for novel antimalarials. Indeed, several protease inhibitors exhibit activity both in vitro and in vivo. In the current climate of resurgent malaria and serious problems of drug resistance, a deeper understanding of these processes is vital. The sequence of the Plasmodium falciparum genome has revealed ten aspartic protease genes, including nine plasmepsins (I, II, IV–X) and histo-aspartic protease (HAP). Two key questions then arise. Which of these genes are expressed in the blood stage? Which play a role in the FV and what is their enzymatic activity? These questions have been addressed by Banerjee et al. [1]. They have shown that seven of these genes are expressed during the blood stage (PM I, II, IV, V, IX, X and HAP), but only four of these proteins are localized in the FV (PM I, II, IV and HAP). Interestingly, these enzymes are closely related. Their genes occur as a cluster on chromosome 14, exhibit 50–70% amino acid sequence homology and are initially expressed as 51-kDa proenzymes and are cleaved into 37-kDa active enzymes. Two active-site motifs are conserved in these plasmepsins, but HAP exhibits two conservative amino acid substitutions and one aspartate is replaced by histidine. PM IV and HAP are expressed somewhat later in the life cycle than PM I and II. PM IV, although similar to PM I and II in many respects, exhibits significantly reduced activity against native Hb, although it shows a marked synergistic effect with PM II. The authors also addressed whether HAP is an active enzyme given that it lacks one active-site aspartate moiety. Although recombinant HAP is inactive, the native protein is shown to have strong proteolytic activity against globin (although not against native Hb). Similar to PM IV, HAP also exhibits a synergistic effect with PM II against native Hb. The study has thus shown that four aspartic proteases probably act in concert in breaking down Hb in the FV. The emerging picture suggests that PM I and II probably initiate hemoglobin proteolysis, releasing globin that is then proteolyzed further by PM IV and HAP, and subsequently by falcipain and falcilysin. What is also significant is the unique active site and unusual inhibitor profile of HAP, which marks this enzyme as a particularly interesting candidate for novel antimalarial drugs. 1 Banerjee, R. et al. (2002) Four plasmepsins are active in the Plasmodium falciparum food vacuole, including a protease with an active-site histidine. Proc. Natl. Acad. Sci. U. S. A. 99, 990–995 Timothy J. Egan [email protected]

Ovalocytosis in Papua New Guinea

Embed Size (px)

Citation preview

Page 1: Ovalocytosis in Papua New Guinea

TRENDS in Parasitology Vol.18 No.4 April 2002

http://parasites.trends.com 1471-4922/02/$ – see front matter © 2002 Elsevier Science Ltd. All rights reserved.

150 News&Comment

Ovalocytosis, the occurrence of red bloodcells with an oval biconcave shape andvarying degrees of elliptical aberration, isassociated with protection against malaria.It was often said that once a genotypicmarker for the occurrence of ovalocytosis in Papua New Guinea (PNG) was found, the whole story of protection providedagainst falciparum malaria would beunravelled. That seemed to be the casewhen a 27-bp deletion in Band 3 (the major red blood cell transmembrane anion transporter) was associated withovalocytosis in many coastal, malaria-endemic areas of PNG. However, in another area of PNG, the Wosera, whereovalocytosis is also common, Patel et al.,have found that only one out of 1019individuals had this 27-bp deletion [1].Instead, another deletion in exon 3 of the

glycophorin C gene, which is homologousto glycophorin A (a major receptor forPlasmodium falciparum) and encodes asialoglycoprotein found on the surface ofred blood cells, achieved a gene frequencyof 0.465. This deletion also leads to theovalocytosis phenotype.

The genotype frequencies of the normalglycophorin C heterozygote and homozygotewere in Hardy–Weinberg equilibrium, which argues against the selective advantageof this genotype in malaria. However, evenmore striking, was the identification ofindividuals who possessed ovalocytic redblood cells but did not have a mutation inBand 3 or the glycophorin C gene. This wouldindicate that there could be other geneticcauses for ovalocytic cells. Over a seven-month period, Patel et al., examined theblood films of between 325 and 696

individuals monthly, but were unable to show any difference in the prevalence ordensity of P. falciparum and Plasmodiumvivax infections in the different glycophorin Cgenotypes. However, examining individuals who either develop severedisease or die would reveal moreinformation. This fascinating story ofovalocytosis in PNG continues to unraveland, in doing so, has exposed more thanexpected. The story is far from complete – sowatch this space!

1 Patel, S.S. et al. (2001) The association of the glycophorin C exon 3 deletion withovalocytosis in malaria susceptibility in theWosera, Papua New Guinea. Blood 98,3489–3491

Geoffrey Pasvol

[email protected]

Ovalocytosis in Papua New Guinea

Four aspartic proteases occur in the Plasmodium falciparum foodvacuoleHemoglobin (Hb) is a major food source for the malaria parasite during theintraerythrocytic blood stage. Hb is ingested into a specialized acidiccompartment, the food vacuole (FV), where it is broken down into short peptidesand the released haem is incorporated into hemozoin. Amino acids are thenliberated from these peptides outside the FV and used by the parasite. This Hbproteolysis process is catalyzed by a series of enzymes, including plasmepsins.Plasmepsins are aspartic protease enzymes, two of which, plasmepsin (PM) I and PM II, have been wellcharacterized. These enzymes are capable of cleaving native Hb. A cysteineprotease enzyme, falcipain, and ametalloprotease, falcilysin, are involved infurther degrading the protein to shortpeptides. Given the central role of theseprocesses in the blood stage, theseenzymes represent an important potentialdrug target for novel antimalarials. Indeed, several protease inhibitors exhibitactivity both in vitro and in vivo. In thecurrent climate of resurgent malaria andserious problems of drug resistance, adeeper understanding of these processes is vital.

The sequence of the Plasmodiumfalciparum genome has revealed tenaspartic protease genes, including nineplasmepsins (I, II, IV–X) and histo-asparticprotease (HAP). Two key questions thenarise. Which of these genes are expressed inthe blood stage? Which play a role in the FVand what is their enzymatic activity? Thesequestions have been addressed by Banerjeeet al. [1]. They have shown that seven ofthese genes are expressed during the bloodstage (PM I, II, IV, V, IX, X and HAP), but onlyfour of these proteins are localized in the FV(PM I, II, IV and HAP). Interestingly, theseenzymes are closely related. Their genesoccur as a cluster on chromosome 14,exhibit 50–70% amino acid sequencehomology and are initially expressed as51-kDa proenzymes and are cleaved into37-kDa active enzymes. Two active-sitemotifs are conserved in these plasmepsins,but HAP exhibits two conservative aminoacid substitutions and one aspartate isreplaced by histidine. PM IV and HAP areexpressed somewhat later in the life cyclethan PM I and II.

PM IV, although similar to PM I and II in many respects, exhibits significantlyreduced activity against native Hb, althoughit shows a marked synergistic effect with

PM II. The authors also addressed whetherHAP is an active enzyme given that itlacks one active-site aspartate moiety.Although recombinant HAP is inactive, thenative protein is shown to have strongproteolytic activity against globin (althoughnot against native Hb). Similar to PM IV, HAP also exhibits a synergistic effect withPM II against native Hb.

The study has thus shown that fouraspartic proteases probably act in concert in breaking down Hb in the FV. Theemerging picture suggests that PM I and II probably initiate hemoglobinproteolysis, releasing globin that is then proteolyzed further by PM IV and HAP, and subsequently by falcipain andfalcilysin. What is also significant is theunique active site and unusual inhibitorprofile of HAP, which marks this enzyme as aparticularly interesting candidate for novelantimalarial drugs.

1 Banerjee, R. et al. (2002) Four plasmepsins areactive in the Plasmodium falciparum foodvacuole, including a protease with an active-sitehistidine. Proc. Natl. Acad. Sci. U. S. A. 99,990–995

Timothy J. Egan

[email protected]