Upload
others
View
1
Download
0
Embed Size (px)
Citation preview
2R L
0 l Yr) El-Y 43- 9 REV
Mm sN (M2) (1~i Uc ffJsNNC
N N4 RE IRmmNARTFII~NTSk JUFN (A)PI FTLHN I ~ LO R
O-A TUL r Y o ~ n A ~ C NT C E J C ~ A T s pri oli~~~r F Y A ~ c x s
N _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ ~ __ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ $ ~ )M O AIr 9N -N --- --- --- A J I N
f N4 P [C T L I
Y
-
r3GE7
GRA ampND -4 ~ ~N
(A) AM E 0~ohcHR IL)ItL or O~~IVI~
____________________
1DRAF ER ~TAT4~~laae
ui (F~iATI
~ IC
I[TLE
CLEARANCE
7 -
i~N~
CONDITIONS OF APPROVAL
IV PfOJECT
7
AUTHORIZATION N
F
N77
AN CR0FFI
N Yi
7
EDIE
oN a-1--1NrN
7)
amp
)-
N N N
P-V
NNN~t~ I T
f
NNN r t- E
N
January 18 1973
MEMORANDUM TO AATA Mr Joel Bernstein
FROM TAPM David G Mathiasen
SUBJECT PROP Educational Outputs Measurement
Transmitted herewith is the PROP Educational Outputs Measurements This project was reviewed at theGTSC meeting on December 7 1972 and the PROP has been circulated to all members
We received favorable and supporting comments from each regional bureau and central engineering There are no major problems Some suggestions were made and Bob Schmeding has assured us that in each case he will take the appropriate action to respond to bureau request
TAPM recommends that you assign the attached PROP
Attachment as
16shy
and co erct ng euaoJ LDtihfIcc)c
2n a1utn~an o e
i7 - I is2 1) e Isaj iS lkI[ 1n I la
iricre)cai f f-ic
lG3CrUU1oS UCpeopl )1
1
Lwo 1)C
me-ig eaJIihiamp and~-i~ kh~ t
exrn1~ dscite statemnts~rogra
drirh IScuenr
C~id~~ ari
te cAy~~0~mi~at
-~3
ttarge bLrC1s Ioa VieaclYQO1 -shyIr ao thPr lyia ol rdc ta ~~itr
li-itinc cofeene convene in atl1e pole 1D-s02 j~se iiru posec l sewati hg By p174tihtsars toi~u
~~~~~~~~~~~~~ twoorassumedDtha SteraiaanoD dcainl6Jc2e~a l lrvkal be)rsu-tnith 2 1i~ard V1en~fetve and soa1endgtT~
~ 47 cd~cataon -i6cadma~rmna ipenaches ireexre ope andepliel r
~~~~Thel proeotha diojc Iis 1PROP-i to 13~ore t-rp s oprv loll E nessi C
ludrsadigorm _oa- Mdctba- ofir~ so h
~~hn~4education~iprbrm -asnd1aabe) of beeft deiaiero edd r f -
~ts eStadthen t te ndo thprogrmoumnato the t31 om- t
gta
~uemn ~ fd6inanc andl besem nwl b comeediff yiC arlY1973 In
9 P S
43T ~- ~ z~p
01d4~C 7-C 721a j0 44Q
rIxv - Of P~to IcZt ~ ~~VtUc
5 ~ at~ 01z -
~~A a~ ralla zva to E-1en~ ci
Nil
-9 MkC ~
Th1a t~a ~of for o ~ tb- pvoject -to o 1 TUESin igas LUc Lb f oI ~~e9~~
I C I
x e t - 4 v 5 M I i 1$-Qfl~~~~~- 4Lj~af 2 1it amp amp ti c tl~laampi ~L ~cin~o~areducatioricto the Pc O oo tp ) U 0 iK Jtshy
coateeAIi Valleetckepl o cn
Our rPoan will be produce ei~ ~ st~o ~itrrt naC~fl~ence to of 6e r - pa o t rreo~onfe re 0n tbb t h cc 1l c 4MveS C-0 it djb- u e i
- - d b)- ge iit
-MR47
h4 Z
_ __b ~~~OfX 1-plusmnlfl 6 1 ~ LCz U ~ 1 C
~~eci1co~neo h Ae11t tbOUITS at~oLciic nst uLiona The r---otft ~T 2 bC
~vUX~b of rmoj cct aceozfiur E3chedJe bo1e
P d J IA V I - -T
L hY 6ar
-AI be 5h - t i~c T ins u ion odbe hae i
nos j -c goeren the cllbornti or11 moreover tiCth iw0ver tLfo wy fCo1 ~o -ve c1et-cng et b h 10b
ti~oacan vcih~ nsr i ~dctIt i~sonne2-Jriao h
L rtA~a tl~at 0h b Coitrctr 220 5 h a Up th intiLn01tro 1fC hi C C1it1c
m- 3f i yoriy itiLaon w1it- atica3 iteducaicn1 1-71 Cary0th
o the mroiucpo ~rtL VIJ ttterjet
ou fot-biU beo idntife dCton advplusmni hve iolpsx tnr~gC-it1in srshysetox czuia22 nsef of teio~rt~cisiaditnthe
poundecn ~r~~oferiduyc oi whs conwshym~m0 prtcprogrinmc 1y 5 2-a a V c t1-nL1t6
tnu theddcL Ox fino2-tl~b Ccn aoinbofre yUSR~~~1ona1Onrato rLeaz IrAl~p~on-Dlie
vmn rr J0 ~~i~~1 ~APy O
)fltht manCn~L~lr
n momtl
V C4
7~or 00 eso
~L7-O
C 2
VXO742-gOOw
40 -
8~i
Mh
-axtgt1)i
n-r
e a
--shy 1 y
betwee Us VTrAXLir D~estilnte5dY ~ X L0
0C-her ConsViant trave) mid par d~ri vr00 i~oub-Totalt
25O0VF 50
Tranvelt~~shy
j~2j~Forboth 4
S 4
=d I)C offices -
-~~ -~- ~ ~n2--000
~ 3
ftA0verb -~0Vshy-Mall
7 - N
e hsre ~ t o~ a il~
ng g
~
e r o r an em s pound 1px
~~ e ne d poundor 3 ~e n t o 3-I4e uzvU~ a u tj o ncz~esed ra
etuti-Is~o nt On Nort Th a ea
Pr
Ps c- T
~ns On 4he ore ~h thc skia-r s n a i n
I neti e ) -ch ~ earerSof cer t J
t eIe h )lSihas t oi poundR-4_ ethasr~h~~Lrm2tc soni Prqie~ri- thsrcns on ed~ ht ~ ~~~to~7 ecamcvesic iacre-ea ts ofdu J 6 at L6e~Oneen d c t a t 0 t
el t 11p1aydref Omu-ts ean1gth s c es c 0 _J-r atqundat giad aeshret he e o svf(re u ar e ~Ait1J~~gransothe phleel -an onA ecevra
1 b ipernasons eterjcje_ the~~
a1mand pe oniis av ~h calLlatons af 0t-poundrt~n Creflofe tan ft r
css onditions- astered ciigh6an eTh cScp lme a nt id tocn toe
IJ t vi~br~ a s te yo r e u
r u w rn 1 d d ollclo s ~ ~ 1 ~~~int A
n C l u at o s t f ric r e l ~ ne erVaLuesv_60 ra he es tr t h gh t~ ticaddede andftdetermiZnJation educa 0~~i6t27 edu(7romatii~ ati f ra
EvLICt elaluation utu o - A i i ntt~ct beo madhtca -hthd soji hsonetins n requiresth e~tasa outhuil c) y o1wchebsznniafji ost~c~ prdcin rCeintoeolionize avauc thI sch s itn cae poduc at -e1 l prd hei prco
ln10Md -achpu~ij ed[n4tg
IMIS
~~ ~ t~ 6~ s~ffe f Fnil nr r F E71I
s 0or ate ~ frcou cI secre c D~oi thex rdci~avt-~ g711sructi 1n
6 U le ratavel3y untrained teac er curren Jyaaa e~~ora erse ih e mryd e0nb TScin oC Min)
gIrtof thibereduc -shy trarc ec rSc h e
avaf_ be as for example oru lit DytO~fSUPer_shyZ9~~1de vsor and chagsi scculI -Tirdt I-ri e among edcinal
OUtpu1its can~be r3eordered so~ thi the education~ productio rcesT~ ~ ofo~ those y-ie - figh1 -Us E oe ithbscsseL Uene urcncrcd
bVe reahzl througnh iivc stent in-s~na _10opp 1 - ochn1ia1 vci~oi9lto hgheedaib hioaonveAmcril intne ond
coiidr edUcation b (r o r Vestme 1t11igcnrIrc)roiid r (dutio
SAll of these concer1)ed witth the matter (d Snt~crnal ofDic cY)ncyr e I 10 to the product or output ofthtIeducationial~sy stem i an d to bctc cvaludlte Vi zIM output i-to provide a Mor usPefuJ_ beic imark for -mprovrjng_-yStOm efficiencyl
cth~ iwords l eII and a plusmn i ~ ictp y~~ esi~md need to 1know f the value of t 1e outputs has beei erih~ncedamp gt
-ofererpcc to svlttem efficiency is in )mrtan~tfor po di igoom n -~in shy
dta41costs lin O-Cra u n o ratc iofn programS- c CBeUoation is 1CIIL-Lnre rigly -larger 0--rcntages of ni Uih1bid~imperati~ dis n~cce
t - learn if the money being speit is producing desired- resuits and doing so is econr-n4cally as possible
On the other hanid wdth reeec oh bene6fits edacation measzes -are needed to better inform us if inv~estmnents in education are compettivee41ithj~ alternative investments in other sector~s One coznhci~si~n ofrte-freunstudie ~ in scveral countries is that returnsto education in most Cases Cx returns fo ot 1plusmnr k r~is of investments the payoff for ilinvesting in men seems to be higrner~ tha tratl for investinri inYrnzchinest What is rieededAampispoundurther- rfinerit o6f
measures to helpD us detcermine 1which typcs of cogitie i~-aamph-b ~ mastn prodes the highest yieldl- or pay-off in the mrkt--1hc A~dit on-
allyjwo canproft from better Pnsiireqf the aititd~~ S- ohascrr I thl~m) and the exteritto which such-attituides affect succesi laiif~n
~~~ro~tiero rance injbai ~ ~doi ing moden health~ ititio6nal and poundawmily~ planning practices and asuigm r sponsibe izen~larip3le
puppesofoitut vauaaoexpert in the f ield Sugge s+ that t atr fsse efficincy impli~sthatsonie formof$ measurement instruments
can cFrae th itaI d s(adgous
~ ~i~aio~~)Aexprience rFurther eprtssurgFY ha iteasres of- ~its sufficient i ormato a eotie rl E (ucatona C1cifiputsS6 eesr~ eseniay2))4Isin he sus
uein D-ote iec hdtathees1sof meCrn edc14p~C uef i an -iec- Itl
-a etrr ionopound -Fansr th-ogh edluca -on5-sQfo at nF toepor b-g 0go hndingi iampJ
Spat-Qrai up)ward p ~ec s~ etcot cnb ~L~iiampe l n a C I 4 Qben Peaheemno orirsaidta ents innnco ivareas opound 1vhZ Ir c)I-sued
~iTh prnstI e c veityave1b~ 4wt 1 -aespe and1 mil Wou ut2n_es i djehooJhge
the b)sduc forma t lio cirrdbook__Y la tedd i Wpa~ryic~i~~a v~ltt~Jkainahd si ta ofl respc o oth us a on r~e-irc rjidin to he pag 1 0 aieioritdon meth2 d i 2A
Cou idDC plFn St- at lshycrctcticV
1 Im~eeto Pln Seej attached RT Chrir L- ~shy
OC1urse of~Action Tiie CUSCplusmnO0_ rp3entativ es o~ti~IC with astn aas t- geniceiS ill which th FA a- cptd led Lo -the deampelophin 0O~
apr oposal by the International -istituteforEducationaJ Plling Paris propJosal received by us in~Novemnber l971lprojectedan interntionalns 1n~~-on out-Frts evaluation forJuly 1973f 1rith pre-paia g etiiiparis onamp~sectJz uarv 2973 The proposali enVisaged full represntaton of LDC oa~ti cimtr(5toLC eds ate ymposium should be fuly reF~
Siibsequent discussions with thampII-TE P led to the ~conclusibn oniour partthat the IIP1woul~d not have sufficientL staCC shyto 6ranz and carry b6ut thear 44proposed project anid it was Telt that mor Sharpened anid substaitiy--wor cwouija of outputs evaluat ion this focusiig of fort wsotc prvddritielE
-proposal Moreover AIDIF plolicy of inore directly engaging LD n titio n - -4t1 +chnlcal assistance Projects an engagehient we did 4notT6e 1plusmn~coujampd bo ataie 4 -through the IMP~ activity lead us~ to 4 eevL t a mu dijcc~
4and shiould be fLoril t ed r 4 ~ i~~ shy
4~
Moile centrllyaod scstsraivelvw tr tani morecentaU~nd sb~~~j~r~byarraanging for-a CoJlaborativp- undertinofLDCa titition withthe US instLti
het pjchs riuebee wit m e brso the Task o aa~mci~i ts dgr z ben iec poundrnHrad ri7ayedcLan~
1~ ~ orr~t nolectvida dvonry c s onu bpan ~~UV
on5-nbr 2 ofi-1r wi- jexprr-tilnto cof7 ynPany CIp-Ite ~c Cofl a
to ~ ~cteyoand~ ds~1 __
trbduing pierivh~ meho eaFun- leel-snev f ontit-s1Tr LDs f d ren I typb of
ed cation~an 11yzind Strrlgthdan6i wa sse s an shiowIig me- 0 cI u~ e~pT4~Suu6hi Ththod C) coyp n-ne~poundLDCOeducaticnalof ndor ocshy
~CieweV reseac sc to~e~d the papers an rihe relevce fLIN -1othefri rethz~ds of 6upit1is9ialuatlTh presenit (3 the Coiferccf vwulds~ gg tjn for needo highP
e-v~~~rirt aluinAri1o- cepiI euo 2thS~eL researchproj ectsdeemed to have hi~ghes priority e
The roject shoulJd be designed to rqaent r h 1 ot m 2XAr~ pJshpan is gien here The iirstf~ i-tsen to the
r~gtd~l~fiat o ad ra-ment of coll)a ~ ~ i ~i~tiitiop- 0tnd~wti s--C b et y~i rctsonand aettii gct~r iw~~~~rtolyig 5 or tiiig t perI a V(iactio th thidnic t cb tande itt t Ioii-ii there~e mon hswou2 d PAbe 16o1
-al ii lor ri a yrddnl-thse _nd preparaticn of sevzeral prodt~cts iinb1 ampscrabang-difiirr6iitl-iitoylyjJ4
-easzrement metchodologies projet and1 cofercnicefancamp reportsiia set of dconlresearch ~deigns and a plan forh noSt effectiVe dseMaicn fe1hndc4k nvovng such posibiities as a series of regi6hal seirnarr6the cxr5iiz -tion ofIt travelin- sem~inar N~ is ipratthat th-isdisseivintdoi plahn adressat leayst these two questions )How can the handbook b~i dis~tributed Thitirj~ly
fahin2) How with a reasonable degree of certainty can we get-copies- of the~ hpabook into the hands of tho~eLDC eople who can make bcstuseoIt9 This SeCol~a ut~rt is essentia1ly the question of audience Inasmuch as the han~dbook isi-Lendcieto be an inforinationcl resource for LDCPeducaticn dc ison ekIe~1pLanners~jy
ma ranagers i E vifal ihat th~kinds of Vorac uitaoner6 haveaccess to the
G Scial Mani6mentProwsijon
Linsclecting the LDC organizationwith which it oroposes t- 1abo r t he US orgaiiizai n (Contractor)Shall notify-thi PoetMnce of
AIWA who0shall take the necessary~stepsto obtain RcgioItn IBureau andUSAID ampapprc 1 for the inVolement of the LDC or aflization The wor1kiing out of final
arrangements between the two collaboatii organizations Shallbecontingentshyupon ~re C61pt ofILsuch apprboval
~p ~ ~ J-
Vgt~
k T
DoCr(ioriton-n
Pro-c s A grt
64 DO unvriy
On--~ u ~
1 S Ieu P Te -w-- ran 4 z-
15--C~~nHndok k
C (r-- planinshy
-D-) Io confrenc r 03on
(B) ~~ 2f ~ar ~ ~ FiaAll-boo draft ----- -4~Y
6 (C D) Wo~~~~~0rkoncnrrner orP- -i c
9 (F)lFinal projecth reot
Pro- 6 dd -
------- j Woc ocoia
9T-e ~(F 1Proect report-nan Ci Ca-~f6-l -yad+a
Vp A- J
etal 4-1
0 shy
0lfl~
~0
-44h
~ d
~ -
4
r~sg
h
4
--I ca
4
44
)4
~K~
v j
T to4
to4 ~
)4 I ~~ 6Y
~
W
9-
V
~~
~~
~
E
~4
7K
IOr4
cisect
L~
n
4444~
~
o44w
44444
u4
4K
tV
4
44
shyX
4
444
4bo4
4~
I
C9~-)1U
444
~~4-444-~~ tr
-
I Il 13 0I
r 5
4
44A
44~
~~
~
c 0
01-1 r4
iM
L
J l
4 jr-~
i-
-
~(Jw~y
444
4
oil54 G
aJ
44
4-
C)1
04-1[ 5
H H
~
n 4
I
0r4 4
3444444
~~
94
~ 4
3
~
(l~
4
lb
-r-
4 ~
LtC
I4 ~~~~~~~
Cl
9
tr
i~~
444
~
U
4 t3A9 C
I ~~
in
44
~)4 4
~ 4 ( U
~4
4 4
~ 4
it5
4 4
)4j
J4
414K
-i4~ 4
4
3
44T
CQ
U
-t
4 7-1
~
1A
2fJ
4
~f
d4444
4~
I 4
44440
~
04
~
~
~~
-~a
i ci
0~
~
~
44444 ~
U
44
~ ~
CL
4 -
4~~ 44~
~~
~~
4~
t
gL 44 4
4
44 5
449 ~41
~~
~
-~
~
~~
04 0
44444444444444
rFP
-~5~1444
amp
t+oj
44
4~
7~
-
~ ~
tz tn
G
- D
)Q
co
i 444
U41
i4
j~_j
0 g
tz44~
444A
4 j449f
~~
4
i~(4~
lt 0-vr~
U(
~ ~
24
tj 4
2
4ii~
~~
0
~~414 4
44 4
44
~ 34
(7r4
-4
~~4444~~~~4 4 p~
~~
~C
A 4
4J )1
4
444
4
4
4
4
4444
W
H
10
4 4~44iC
Ocl0r13
~44444~
474
4~U
4~~
V-
444
44
~
2 4 0 4~ C
~
~
4
44 ~
44
444
4~ Hl
~Y
T-4
4
4
4M
Y
4
-44
PriWZampATC L0IbTP
C~~l~1~~ F~~ F R~~~ OE T VA U T iWCVUP
Cl x~ )13 0ec i Oof0e o onl 2d1 uctgo (fa0c 1 L 6 ) md aQ ~ ~ S ~ ~ Eu- L~inr~i
SiUcL a~i~tzix dotoB ~ i~I -
~ woopo~o~ eu YQ50 oojrarchv fOr qua1Jitative~ im~~~iV 2~VG~eard tyDpeo 0oudc1tio
-a among oCn thee nrb
3) i-h
9~ ~tamp a $~a
Arab CN4
Atjh flziobi Go~neroccon TL3 10 _ lTbo causesJ of tbOd VixS~t(euc 6antd Varie-dl ltTIh L tnampt of0 te zWocjuoyo
rc~11an gven~tetshavor aJrob iached the 3lzit ~OL Vhbapoundiobail2SL Cr Bu I Or ts byaIhiriaJ is o rieanr
V31ropily o 1iso alsogt to n oncTh liutlitioL blawed6i 12 Ofnnn[ ___
(p (Fuca1
~~~~~ ~~ M a~0prPz~ l~~lo)c d onthe iieed t~a~ f~0Cetv t a
of the clneat f~cacod byr educa-L6til~ ai ofn~n orzn t he
-- -9
Co ruo~~ 5t ~ n oIis~ehri
oT L v3 r) at ~cn
Dj
p~o~~r~X ryc
i
L-oof t r
44-
1 a
0111A Ofa4iC
~~~iooIy -ght 1A)
c i r
01
b 6
in 10 7-noiorshy
o
in c az e s
n l
~~
Aa
J -Ir1O
~44--
d loo to cIdu1e~ L -al emu-L)1 b a4444oa 1J i ~~ l--iO
c~u~ 11 )_2~ 2 0OJanot
Dio 11 mCtlCcLOxr OJ n v
i1i 4-1 )_
V
nLla t o n
x nm
4
4
c
6i pl
IRCl 4 n1 n V V
i17 $ 42lv
CofiUsnc1
--shy L~s~otoojn b4
cnfrece all
t 3-4A44~C--
hg p4pqtin of
tr0inperj- iIdnt~Li ntConoeu4Y X e V 4
u~~~-a lou 1
~ ~ ~ 4 ~
4
tho tcdovolop-mentl of Pan e cect~rc machiinery4 forthe1o ecdufat0ion and for4a~S~l on a continui bai the
niAZ oafo v
LT
At
4 Alea-ve
of o co-tin --
drojgtout grac repatitio land c
hic by7 anr xlj the a- 0idntv ti1u(h to bo de~rd~Gri-shyd shol~fu ub an intE-ua pat o
hi1nc ih 1~Ic~~o nr~ In rio aneiiatlo~ 2ydeeo- i~
OfA44Jllit n O4a at o4xam 44
pr M s U -- L
dnaticn alu~ec ntuet
v1e oi -iuiUu~~er L-3trictont
_l uti L -n 44o
(oCnji~poundr ~n~i~ni
1477port Third PL Qnal Con7a e cshyo 4 --3 4 P
shy
4 -~ ~4 - 44VV43p
kl- Cp 31p4a _ T 4~n o- ~
4 7424pi
~ -4 4~lt
6
4 77 4
I 81J
~ n
JY
444
h F1~~V011V-i~m)ya3ofOuet
- -MA
4 u
c u -- a - ao 4((A voi co~t111 nl t ororc -4- 44i44
d~44 4~~44~~4~4
djr4444n 44 u otP-00 (Yt O aos n
I Iitu shy
r a)-raIthm-- eh
ndfore -ou So4 as
~ ~ v at~aoi$ib~aoi8imampT m~~ t r4 411A-tio i h abe b4 - wi iie
S~~~V a I icau i1~ic
e ~~filhi O tdlS 4 ~ ~ ~ oqecL andh ~ th
4)1 ~ 4-1411-1~ o~be~ ~ 1 mlbi viuCLO2Ul Dt rtlfiP1111
c i l
lw r6 -tr cnb~~~ tf2 ~~~~ ~ ~ ~ b-~~~~t co~ i nt~rro ojtvnab ~ci~e~~
-~t~i~w ~ ~ ~iVtiot~catdc-~
tcr Cdo4 g C-a n l hg rampthdi1uh3 401 0- c a y i
t~ d
-z-~7~~ cost flCe1~ ~--
aa~ha~g K2-atnaampit~rB~U~-~v02 nojaJ rl-4 bt)o 1i
as tcjwainJcvatso isD6t iampifwt htof lbprta
urie oli achleavaiuaeto iSurh meansure ao usualc y -a is-c
an4- t Q)- A
-- ----ao
-Lr
cZ a no--shy4~ 4c
-Ala-~1610
Y Ln-ob 0
c Cn ereo~m - - 9-I
anld dveX~ 12b fljt l
i ~unat ~ O ~ ri- -10f~ ~ 9jiOr( r LO(v) j 0- f ui1Ahht~C~~tiwCdfLo^ ir
O~ r-si~ tc- uvc O tciaicn in vie oicny
0y ator sy on lxgcr- tcaampi c CTshyoitnm tnonvcay A~ilf-iea~e v a~nd cocia1 iiiamp=anfco oppO II
UO9 sshy
-~-~- - ~-b~at the quaity of thoro i~ho hold cortificatev
tha1oi da o d~roDushoaliaJo be su t tor0 shyu 993 9UP
o9 m- o icr n9Inaucon
9 2
cushy
ml m~6v )c~ar
f-~ C) LJri Z)~u )
vc C r 71 shy
TG- 0111 u
(b)Scol D3 or- (re U 17-
-i C ntatoi e~ic~ S~c~illum~ 6A -J-Oq
-OfIhstrurz ton cl qpro ss1 g obecti-miamp Jishy~e1doogiesWO(ii
- ~~---- -rt~cl to studei -lv1p2nve tachrV f~s
~$ ~iv) Lrolcveift 7ad--Ttati oi aUdIo-vismn1 Mdia prga d
7ial r7 a w t7ni
4 7 7
iv
t
(rii)~~~~~~
of
~
uoclc
Iff C 7
~
ediULACCampJOLU
- i4
~--~~
I~lCosu3ai
1shy
~d
a1O
I
41~3~rh
W~=12X
Ul
I -
I II~I~i
ti-vos~~~~~~~~~~~~r oo-t ~
anacdU
t
ied iltio
alfe-tlh 0 in iC ar
(1) cj ptvo-a~~ i1tof 4 ex c-~1~r gtI1~f
441444Y14141iII4 outputs
c- v1 t-cD-cc aniti lo 1~f
1 5-
61k
kc oj -i
-u
-7C
Ushy
fc l CI r V- 4 Tv U
~uIT p1 iPobTZ U 0-p atoao 4u L 1) )c
odcvI n o t (S
~ W-
spie- Mt irm (0 ) of-110
UNITED STATES GOVERNMENT
Memorandum TO AATAPM - Mr David Mathiasen DATmrebrUs~y 21 1973
FROM TAEIM - John F i ard
SUBJECT OYB Funding for TAEHR Projects
We have been advised that the funding for the proposed new GTS project Education Outputs Measurement (total $225000 6f which $150000 is scheduled for FY 1973 and $75000 for FY 1974) is inadequate to meet the contractors budget (Georgetown University $252000) We therefore want to shift $27000 to this project from the $2500O allotted for the Educational Technology Field Support Project reducing the FY 1973 fumnding
level for the latter to $223000
TAEHRRSchmedingsd
Bs US Savings Bonds Replarly on the PayrollSavings Plan I
January 18 1973
MEMORANDUM TO AATA Mr Joel Bernstein
FROM TAPM David G Mathiasen
SUBJECT PROP Educational Outputs Measurement
Transmitted herewith is the PROP Educational Outputs Measurements This project was reviewed at theGTSC meeting on December 7 1972 and the PROP has been circulated to all members
We received favorable and supporting comments from each regional bureau and central engineering There are no major problems Some suggestions were made and Bob Schmeding has assured us that in each case he will take the appropriate action to respond to bureau request
TAPM recommends that you assign the attached PROP
Attachment as
16shy
and co erct ng euaoJ LDtihfIcc)c
2n a1utn~an o e
i7 - I is2 1) e Isaj iS lkI[ 1n I la
iricre)cai f f-ic
lG3CrUU1oS UCpeopl )1
1
Lwo 1)C
me-ig eaJIihiamp and~-i~ kh~ t
exrn1~ dscite statemnts~rogra
drirh IScuenr
C~id~~ ari
te cAy~~0~mi~at
-~3
ttarge bLrC1s Ioa VieaclYQO1 -shyIr ao thPr lyia ol rdc ta ~~itr
li-itinc cofeene convene in atl1e pole 1D-s02 j~se iiru posec l sewati hg By p174tihtsars toi~u
~~~~~~~~~~~~~ twoorassumedDtha SteraiaanoD dcainl6Jc2e~a l lrvkal be)rsu-tnith 2 1i~ard V1en~fetve and soa1endgtT~
~ 47 cd~cataon -i6cadma~rmna ipenaches ireexre ope andepliel r
~~~~Thel proeotha diojc Iis 1PROP-i to 13~ore t-rp s oprv loll E nessi C
ludrsadigorm _oa- Mdctba- ofir~ so h
~~hn~4education~iprbrm -asnd1aabe) of beeft deiaiero edd r f -
~ts eStadthen t te ndo thprogrmoumnato the t31 om- t
gta
~uemn ~ fd6inanc andl besem nwl b comeediff yiC arlY1973 In
9 P S
43T ~- ~ z~p
01d4~C 7-C 721a j0 44Q
rIxv - Of P~to IcZt ~ ~~VtUc
5 ~ at~ 01z -
~~A a~ ralla zva to E-1en~ ci
Nil
-9 MkC ~
Th1a t~a ~of for o ~ tb- pvoject -to o 1 TUESin igas LUc Lb f oI ~~e9~~
I C I
x e t - 4 v 5 M I i 1$-Qfl~~~~~- 4Lj~af 2 1it amp amp ti c tl~laampi ~L ~cin~o~areducatioricto the Pc O oo tp ) U 0 iK Jtshy
coateeAIi Valleetckepl o cn
Our rPoan will be produce ei~ ~ st~o ~itrrt naC~fl~ence to of 6e r - pa o t rreo~onfe re 0n tbb t h cc 1l c 4MveS C-0 it djb- u e i
- - d b)- ge iit
-MR47
h4 Z
_ __b ~~~OfX 1-plusmnlfl 6 1 ~ LCz U ~ 1 C
~~eci1co~neo h Ae11t tbOUITS at~oLciic nst uLiona The r---otft ~T 2 bC
~vUX~b of rmoj cct aceozfiur E3chedJe bo1e
P d J IA V I - -T
L hY 6ar
-AI be 5h - t i~c T ins u ion odbe hae i
nos j -c goeren the cllbornti or11 moreover tiCth iw0ver tLfo wy fCo1 ~o -ve c1et-cng et b h 10b
ti~oacan vcih~ nsr i ~dctIt i~sonne2-Jriao h
L rtA~a tl~at 0h b Coitrctr 220 5 h a Up th intiLn01tro 1fC hi C C1it1c
m- 3f i yoriy itiLaon w1it- atica3 iteducaicn1 1-71 Cary0th
o the mroiucpo ~rtL VIJ ttterjet
ou fot-biU beo idntife dCton advplusmni hve iolpsx tnr~gC-it1in srshysetox czuia22 nsef of teio~rt~cisiaditnthe
poundecn ~r~~oferiduyc oi whs conwshym~m0 prtcprogrinmc 1y 5 2-a a V c t1-nL1t6
tnu theddcL Ox fino2-tl~b Ccn aoinbofre yUSR~~~1ona1Onrato rLeaz IrAl~p~on-Dlie
vmn rr J0 ~~i~~1 ~APy O
)fltht manCn~L~lr
n momtl
V C4
7~or 00 eso
~L7-O
C 2
VXO742-gOOw
40 -
8~i
Mh
-axtgt1)i
n-r
e a
--shy 1 y
betwee Us VTrAXLir D~estilnte5dY ~ X L0
0C-her ConsViant trave) mid par d~ri vr00 i~oub-Totalt
25O0VF 50
Tranvelt~~shy
j~2j~Forboth 4
S 4
=d I)C offices -
-~~ -~- ~ ~n2--000
~ 3
ftA0verb -~0Vshy-Mall
7 - N
e hsre ~ t o~ a il~
ng g
~
e r o r an em s pound 1px
~~ e ne d poundor 3 ~e n t o 3-I4e uzvU~ a u tj o ncz~esed ra
etuti-Is~o nt On Nort Th a ea
Pr
Ps c- T
~ns On 4he ore ~h thc skia-r s n a i n
I neti e ) -ch ~ earerSof cer t J
t eIe h )lSihas t oi poundR-4_ ethasr~h~~Lrm2tc soni Prqie~ri- thsrcns on ed~ ht ~ ~~~to~7 ecamcvesic iacre-ea ts ofdu J 6 at L6e~Oneen d c t a t 0 t
el t 11p1aydref Omu-ts ean1gth s c es c 0 _J-r atqundat giad aeshret he e o svf(re u ar e ~Ait1J~~gransothe phleel -an onA ecevra
1 b ipernasons eterjcje_ the~~
a1mand pe oniis av ~h calLlatons af 0t-poundrt~n Creflofe tan ft r
css onditions- astered ciigh6an eTh cScp lme a nt id tocn toe
IJ t vi~br~ a s te yo r e u
r u w rn 1 d d ollclo s ~ ~ 1 ~~~int A
n C l u at o s t f ric r e l ~ ne erVaLuesv_60 ra he es tr t h gh t~ ticaddede andftdetermiZnJation educa 0~~i6t27 edu(7romatii~ ati f ra
EvLICt elaluation utu o - A i i ntt~ct beo madhtca -hthd soji hsonetins n requiresth e~tasa outhuil c) y o1wchebsznniafji ost~c~ prdcin rCeintoeolionize avauc thI sch s itn cae poduc at -e1 l prd hei prco
ln10Md -achpu~ij ed[n4tg
IMIS
~~ ~ t~ 6~ s~ffe f Fnil nr r F E71I
s 0or ate ~ frcou cI secre c D~oi thex rdci~avt-~ g711sructi 1n
6 U le ratavel3y untrained teac er curren Jyaaa e~~ora erse ih e mryd e0nb TScin oC Min)
gIrtof thibereduc -shy trarc ec rSc h e
avaf_ be as for example oru lit DytO~fSUPer_shyZ9~~1de vsor and chagsi scculI -Tirdt I-ri e among edcinal
OUtpu1its can~be r3eordered so~ thi the education~ productio rcesT~ ~ ofo~ those y-ie - figh1 -Us E oe ithbscsseL Uene urcncrcd
bVe reahzl througnh iivc stent in-s~na _10opp 1 - ochn1ia1 vci~oi9lto hgheedaib hioaonveAmcril intne ond
coiidr edUcation b (r o r Vestme 1t11igcnrIrc)roiid r (dutio
SAll of these concer1)ed witth the matter (d Snt~crnal ofDic cY)ncyr e I 10 to the product or output ofthtIeducationial~sy stem i an d to bctc cvaludlte Vi zIM output i-to provide a Mor usPefuJ_ beic imark for -mprovrjng_-yStOm efficiencyl
cth~ iwords l eII and a plusmn i ~ ictp y~~ esi~md need to 1know f the value of t 1e outputs has beei erih~ncedamp gt
-ofererpcc to svlttem efficiency is in )mrtan~tfor po di igoom n -~in shy
dta41costs lin O-Cra u n o ratc iofn programS- c CBeUoation is 1CIIL-Lnre rigly -larger 0--rcntages of ni Uih1bid~imperati~ dis n~cce
t - learn if the money being speit is producing desired- resuits and doing so is econr-n4cally as possible
On the other hanid wdth reeec oh bene6fits edacation measzes -are needed to better inform us if inv~estmnents in education are compettivee41ithj~ alternative investments in other sector~s One coznhci~si~n ofrte-freunstudie ~ in scveral countries is that returnsto education in most Cases Cx returns fo ot 1plusmnr k r~is of investments the payoff for ilinvesting in men seems to be higrner~ tha tratl for investinri inYrnzchinest What is rieededAampispoundurther- rfinerit o6f
measures to helpD us detcermine 1which typcs of cogitie i~-aamph-b ~ mastn prodes the highest yieldl- or pay-off in the mrkt--1hc A~dit on-
allyjwo canproft from better Pnsiireqf the aititd~~ S- ohascrr I thl~m) and the exteritto which such-attituides affect succesi laiif~n
~~~ro~tiero rance injbai ~ ~doi ing moden health~ ititio6nal and poundawmily~ planning practices and asuigm r sponsibe izen~larip3le
puppesofoitut vauaaoexpert in the f ield Sugge s+ that t atr fsse efficincy impli~sthatsonie formof$ measurement instruments
can cFrae th itaI d s(adgous
~ ~i~aio~~)Aexprience rFurther eprtssurgFY ha iteasres of- ~its sufficient i ormato a eotie rl E (ucatona C1cifiputsS6 eesr~ eseniay2))4Isin he sus
uein D-ote iec hdtathees1sof meCrn edc14p~C uef i an -iec- Itl
-a etrr ionopound -Fansr th-ogh edluca -on5-sQfo at nF toepor b-g 0go hndingi iampJ
Spat-Qrai up)ward p ~ec s~ etcot cnb ~L~iiampe l n a C I 4 Qben Peaheemno orirsaidta ents innnco ivareas opound 1vhZ Ir c)I-sued
~iTh prnstI e c veityave1b~ 4wt 1 -aespe and1 mil Wou ut2n_es i djehooJhge
the b)sduc forma t lio cirrdbook__Y la tedd i Wpa~ryic~i~~a v~ltt~Jkainahd si ta ofl respc o oth us a on r~e-irc rjidin to he pag 1 0 aieioritdon meth2 d i 2A
Cou idDC plFn St- at lshycrctcticV
1 Im~eeto Pln Seej attached RT Chrir L- ~shy
OC1urse of~Action Tiie CUSCplusmnO0_ rp3entativ es o~ti~IC with astn aas t- geniceiS ill which th FA a- cptd led Lo -the deampelophin 0O~
apr oposal by the International -istituteforEducationaJ Plling Paris propJosal received by us in~Novemnber l971lprojectedan interntionalns 1n~~-on out-Frts evaluation forJuly 1973f 1rith pre-paia g etiiiparis onamp~sectJz uarv 2973 The proposali enVisaged full represntaton of LDC oa~ti cimtr(5toLC eds ate ymposium should be fuly reF~
Siibsequent discussions with thampII-TE P led to the ~conclusibn oniour partthat the IIP1woul~d not have sufficientL staCC shyto 6ranz and carry b6ut thear 44proposed project anid it was Telt that mor Sharpened anid substaitiy--wor cwouija of outputs evaluat ion this focusiig of fort wsotc prvddritielE
-proposal Moreover AIDIF plolicy of inore directly engaging LD n titio n - -4t1 +chnlcal assistance Projects an engagehient we did 4notT6e 1plusmn~coujampd bo ataie 4 -through the IMP~ activity lead us~ to 4 eevL t a mu dijcc~
4and shiould be fLoril t ed r 4 ~ i~~ shy
4~
Moile centrllyaod scstsraivelvw tr tani morecentaU~nd sb~~~j~r~byarraanging for-a CoJlaborativp- undertinofLDCa titition withthe US instLti
het pjchs riuebee wit m e brso the Task o aa~mci~i ts dgr z ben iec poundrnHrad ri7ayedcLan~
1~ ~ orr~t nolectvida dvonry c s onu bpan ~~UV
on5-nbr 2 ofi-1r wi- jexprr-tilnto cof7 ynPany CIp-Ite ~c Cofl a
to ~ ~cteyoand~ ds~1 __
trbduing pierivh~ meho eaFun- leel-snev f ontit-s1Tr LDs f d ren I typb of
ed cation~an 11yzind Strrlgthdan6i wa sse s an shiowIig me- 0 cI u~ e~pT4~Suu6hi Ththod C) coyp n-ne~poundLDCOeducaticnalof ndor ocshy
~CieweV reseac sc to~e~d the papers an rihe relevce fLIN -1othefri rethz~ds of 6upit1is9ialuatlTh presenit (3 the Coiferccf vwulds~ gg tjn for needo highP
e-v~~~rirt aluinAri1o- cepiI euo 2thS~eL researchproj ectsdeemed to have hi~ghes priority e
The roject shoulJd be designed to rqaent r h 1 ot m 2XAr~ pJshpan is gien here The iirstf~ i-tsen to the
r~gtd~l~fiat o ad ra-ment of coll)a ~ ~ i ~i~tiitiop- 0tnd~wti s--C b et y~i rctsonand aettii gct~r iw~~~~rtolyig 5 or tiiig t perI a V(iactio th thidnic t cb tande itt t Ioii-ii there~e mon hswou2 d PAbe 16o1
-al ii lor ri a yrddnl-thse _nd preparaticn of sevzeral prodt~cts iinb1 ampscrabang-difiirr6iitl-iitoylyjJ4
-easzrement metchodologies projet and1 cofercnicefancamp reportsiia set of dconlresearch ~deigns and a plan forh noSt effectiVe dseMaicn fe1hndc4k nvovng such posibiities as a series of regi6hal seirnarr6the cxr5iiz -tion ofIt travelin- sem~inar N~ is ipratthat th-isdisseivintdoi plahn adressat leayst these two questions )How can the handbook b~i dis~tributed Thitirj~ly
fahin2) How with a reasonable degree of certainty can we get-copies- of the~ hpabook into the hands of tho~eLDC eople who can make bcstuseoIt9 This SeCol~a ut~rt is essentia1ly the question of audience Inasmuch as the han~dbook isi-Lendcieto be an inforinationcl resource for LDCPeducaticn dc ison ekIe~1pLanners~jy
ma ranagers i E vifal ihat th~kinds of Vorac uitaoner6 haveaccess to the
G Scial Mani6mentProwsijon
Linsclecting the LDC organizationwith which it oroposes t- 1abo r t he US orgaiiizai n (Contractor)Shall notify-thi PoetMnce of
AIWA who0shall take the necessary~stepsto obtain RcgioItn IBureau andUSAID ampapprc 1 for the inVolement of the LDC or aflization The wor1kiing out of final
arrangements between the two collaboatii organizations Shallbecontingentshyupon ~re C61pt ofILsuch apprboval
~p ~ ~ J-
Vgt~
k T
DoCr(ioriton-n
Pro-c s A grt
64 DO unvriy
On--~ u ~
1 S Ieu P Te -w-- ran 4 z-
15--C~~nHndok k
C (r-- planinshy
-D-) Io confrenc r 03on
(B) ~~ 2f ~ar ~ ~ FiaAll-boo draft ----- -4~Y
6 (C D) Wo~~~~~0rkoncnrrner orP- -i c
9 (F)lFinal projecth reot
Pro- 6 dd -
------- j Woc ocoia
9T-e ~(F 1Proect report-nan Ci Ca-~f6-l -yad+a
Vp A- J
etal 4-1
0 shy
0lfl~
~0
-44h
~ d
~ -
4
r~sg
h
4
--I ca
4
44
)4
~K~
v j
T to4
to4 ~
)4 I ~~ 6Y
~
W
9-
V
~~
~~
~
E
~4
7K
IOr4
cisect
L~
n
4444~
~
o44w
44444
u4
4K
tV
4
44
shyX
4
444
4bo4
4~
I
C9~-)1U
444
~~4-444-~~ tr
-
I Il 13 0I
r 5
4
44A
44~
~~
~
c 0
01-1 r4
iM
L
J l
4 jr-~
i-
-
~(Jw~y
444
4
oil54 G
aJ
44
4-
C)1
04-1[ 5
H H
~
n 4
I
0r4 4
3444444
~~
94
~ 4
3
~
(l~
4
lb
-r-
4 ~
LtC
I4 ~~~~~~~
Cl
9
tr
i~~
444
~
U
4 t3A9 C
I ~~
in
44
~)4 4
~ 4 ( U
~4
4 4
~ 4
it5
4 4
)4j
J4
414K
-i4~ 4
4
3
44T
CQ
U
-t
4 7-1
~
1A
2fJ
4
~f
d4444
4~
I 4
44440
~
04
~
~
~~
-~a
i ci
0~
~
~
44444 ~
U
44
~ ~
CL
4 -
4~~ 44~
~~
~~
4~
t
gL 44 4
4
44 5
449 ~41
~~
~
-~
~
~~
04 0
44444444444444
rFP
-~5~1444
amp
t+oj
44
4~
7~
-
~ ~
tz tn
G
- D
)Q
co
i 444
U41
i4
j~_j
0 g
tz44~
444A
4 j449f
~~
4
i~(4~
lt 0-vr~
U(
~ ~
24
tj 4
2
4ii~
~~
0
~~414 4
44 4
44
~ 34
(7r4
-4
~~4444~~~~4 4 p~
~~
~C
A 4
4J )1
4
444
4
4
4
4
4444
W
H
10
4 4~44iC
Ocl0r13
~44444~
474
4~U
4~~
V-
444
44
~
2 4 0 4~ C
~
~
4
44 ~
44
444
4~ Hl
~Y
T-4
4
4
4M
Y
4
-44
PriWZampATC L0IbTP
C~~l~1~~ F~~ F R~~~ OE T VA U T iWCVUP
Cl x~ )13 0ec i Oof0e o onl 2d1 uctgo (fa0c 1 L 6 ) md aQ ~ ~ S ~ ~ Eu- L~inr~i
SiUcL a~i~tzix dotoB ~ i~I -
~ woopo~o~ eu YQ50 oojrarchv fOr qua1Jitative~ im~~~iV 2~VG~eard tyDpeo 0oudc1tio
-a among oCn thee nrb
3) i-h
9~ ~tamp a $~a
Arab CN4
Atjh flziobi Go~neroccon TL3 10 _ lTbo causesJ of tbOd VixS~t(euc 6antd Varie-dl ltTIh L tnampt of0 te zWocjuoyo
rc~11an gven~tetshavor aJrob iached the 3lzit ~OL Vhbapoundiobail2SL Cr Bu I Or ts byaIhiriaJ is o rieanr
V31ropily o 1iso alsogt to n oncTh liutlitioL blawed6i 12 Ofnnn[ ___
(p (Fuca1
~~~~~ ~~ M a~0prPz~ l~~lo)c d onthe iieed t~a~ f~0Cetv t a
of the clneat f~cacod byr educa-L6til~ ai ofn~n orzn t he
-- -9
Co ruo~~ 5t ~ n oIis~ehri
oT L v3 r) at ~cn
Dj
p~o~~r~X ryc
i
L-oof t r
44-
1 a
0111A Ofa4iC
~~~iooIy -ght 1A)
c i r
01
b 6
in 10 7-noiorshy
o
in c az e s
n l
~~
Aa
J -Ir1O
~44--
d loo to cIdu1e~ L -al emu-L)1 b a4444oa 1J i ~~ l--iO
c~u~ 11 )_2~ 2 0OJanot
Dio 11 mCtlCcLOxr OJ n v
i1i 4-1 )_
V
nLla t o n
x nm
4
4
c
6i pl
IRCl 4 n1 n V V
i17 $ 42lv
CofiUsnc1
--shy L~s~otoojn b4
cnfrece all
t 3-4A44~C--
hg p4pqtin of
tr0inperj- iIdnt~Li ntConoeu4Y X e V 4
u~~~-a lou 1
~ ~ ~ 4 ~
4
tho tcdovolop-mentl of Pan e cect~rc machiinery4 forthe1o ecdufat0ion and for4a~S~l on a continui bai the
niAZ oafo v
LT
At
4 Alea-ve
of o co-tin --
drojgtout grac repatitio land c
hic by7 anr xlj the a- 0idntv ti1u(h to bo de~rd~Gri-shyd shol~fu ub an intE-ua pat o
hi1nc ih 1~Ic~~o nr~ In rio aneiiatlo~ 2ydeeo- i~
OfA44Jllit n O4a at o4xam 44
pr M s U -- L
dnaticn alu~ec ntuet
v1e oi -iuiUu~~er L-3trictont
_l uti L -n 44o
(oCnji~poundr ~n~i~ni
1477port Third PL Qnal Con7a e cshyo 4 --3 4 P
shy
4 -~ ~4 - 44VV43p
kl- Cp 31p4a _ T 4~n o- ~
4 7424pi
~ -4 4~lt
6
4 77 4
I 81J
~ n
JY
444
h F1~~V011V-i~m)ya3ofOuet
- -MA
4 u
c u -- a - ao 4((A voi co~t111 nl t ororc -4- 44i44
d~44 4~~44~~4~4
djr4444n 44 u otP-00 (Yt O aos n
I Iitu shy
r a)-raIthm-- eh
ndfore -ou So4 as
~ ~ v at~aoi$ib~aoi8imampT m~~ t r4 411A-tio i h abe b4 - wi iie
S~~~V a I icau i1~ic
e ~~filhi O tdlS 4 ~ ~ ~ oqecL andh ~ th
4)1 ~ 4-1411-1~ o~be~ ~ 1 mlbi viuCLO2Ul Dt rtlfiP1111
c i l
lw r6 -tr cnb~~~ tf2 ~~~~ ~ ~ ~ b-~~~~t co~ i nt~rro ojtvnab ~ci~e~~
-~t~i~w ~ ~ ~iVtiot~catdc-~
tcr Cdo4 g C-a n l hg rampthdi1uh3 401 0- c a y i
t~ d
-z-~7~~ cost flCe1~ ~--
aa~ha~g K2-atnaampit~rB~U~-~v02 nojaJ rl-4 bt)o 1i
as tcjwainJcvatso isD6t iampifwt htof lbprta
urie oli achleavaiuaeto iSurh meansure ao usualc y -a is-c
an4- t Q)- A
-- ----ao
-Lr
cZ a no--shy4~ 4c
-Ala-~1610
Y Ln-ob 0
c Cn ereo~m - - 9-I
anld dveX~ 12b fljt l
i ~unat ~ O ~ ri- -10f~ ~ 9jiOr( r LO(v) j 0- f ui1Ahht~C~~tiwCdfLo^ ir
O~ r-si~ tc- uvc O tciaicn in vie oicny
0y ator sy on lxgcr- tcaampi c CTshyoitnm tnonvcay A~ilf-iea~e v a~nd cocia1 iiiamp=anfco oppO II
UO9 sshy
-~-~- - ~-b~at the quaity of thoro i~ho hold cortificatev
tha1oi da o d~roDushoaliaJo be su t tor0 shyu 993 9UP
o9 m- o icr n9Inaucon
9 2
cushy
ml m~6v )c~ar
f-~ C) LJri Z)~u )
vc C r 71 shy
TG- 0111 u
(b)Scol D3 or- (re U 17-
-i C ntatoi e~ic~ S~c~illum~ 6A -J-Oq
-OfIhstrurz ton cl qpro ss1 g obecti-miamp Jishy~e1doogiesWO(ii
- ~~---- -rt~cl to studei -lv1p2nve tachrV f~s
~$ ~iv) Lrolcveift 7ad--Ttati oi aUdIo-vismn1 Mdia prga d
7ial r7 a w t7ni
4 7 7
iv
t
(rii)~~~~~~
of
~
uoclc
Iff C 7
~
ediULACCampJOLU
- i4
~--~~
I~lCosu3ai
1shy
~d
a1O
I
41~3~rh
W~=12X
Ul
I -
I II~I~i
ti-vos~~~~~~~~~~~~r oo-t ~
anacdU
t
ied iltio
alfe-tlh 0 in iC ar
(1) cj ptvo-a~~ i1tof 4 ex c-~1~r gtI1~f
441444Y14141iII4 outputs
c- v1 t-cD-cc aniti lo 1~f
1 5-
61k
kc oj -i
-u
-7C
Ushy
fc l CI r V- 4 Tv U
~uIT p1 iPobTZ U 0-p atoao 4u L 1) )c
odcvI n o t (S
~ W-
spie- Mt irm (0 ) of-110
UNITED STATES GOVERNMENT
Memorandum TO AATAPM - Mr David Mathiasen DATmrebrUs~y 21 1973
FROM TAEIM - John F i ard
SUBJECT OYB Funding for TAEHR Projects
We have been advised that the funding for the proposed new GTS project Education Outputs Measurement (total $225000 6f which $150000 is scheduled for FY 1973 and $75000 for FY 1974) is inadequate to meet the contractors budget (Georgetown University $252000) We therefore want to shift $27000 to this project from the $2500O allotted for the Educational Technology Field Support Project reducing the FY 1973 fumnding
level for the latter to $223000
TAEHRRSchmedingsd
Bs US Savings Bonds Replarly on the PayrollSavings Plan I
and co erct ng euaoJ LDtihfIcc)c
2n a1utn~an o e
i7 - I is2 1) e Isaj iS lkI[ 1n I la
iricre)cai f f-ic
lG3CrUU1oS UCpeopl )1
1
Lwo 1)C
me-ig eaJIihiamp and~-i~ kh~ t
exrn1~ dscite statemnts~rogra
drirh IScuenr
C~id~~ ari
te cAy~~0~mi~at
-~3
ttarge bLrC1s Ioa VieaclYQO1 -shyIr ao thPr lyia ol rdc ta ~~itr
li-itinc cofeene convene in atl1e pole 1D-s02 j~se iiru posec l sewati hg By p174tihtsars toi~u
~~~~~~~~~~~~~ twoorassumedDtha SteraiaanoD dcainl6Jc2e~a l lrvkal be)rsu-tnith 2 1i~ard V1en~fetve and soa1endgtT~
~ 47 cd~cataon -i6cadma~rmna ipenaches ireexre ope andepliel r
~~~~Thel proeotha diojc Iis 1PROP-i to 13~ore t-rp s oprv loll E nessi C
ludrsadigorm _oa- Mdctba- ofir~ so h
~~hn~4education~iprbrm -asnd1aabe) of beeft deiaiero edd r f -
~ts eStadthen t te ndo thprogrmoumnato the t31 om- t
gta
~uemn ~ fd6inanc andl besem nwl b comeediff yiC arlY1973 In
9 P S
43T ~- ~ z~p
01d4~C 7-C 721a j0 44Q
rIxv - Of P~to IcZt ~ ~~VtUc
5 ~ at~ 01z -
~~A a~ ralla zva to E-1en~ ci
Nil
-9 MkC ~
Th1a t~a ~of for o ~ tb- pvoject -to o 1 TUESin igas LUc Lb f oI ~~e9~~
I C I
x e t - 4 v 5 M I i 1$-Qfl~~~~~- 4Lj~af 2 1it amp amp ti c tl~laampi ~L ~cin~o~areducatioricto the Pc O oo tp ) U 0 iK Jtshy
coateeAIi Valleetckepl o cn
Our rPoan will be produce ei~ ~ st~o ~itrrt naC~fl~ence to of 6e r - pa o t rreo~onfe re 0n tbb t h cc 1l c 4MveS C-0 it djb- u e i
- - d b)- ge iit
-MR47
h4 Z
_ __b ~~~OfX 1-plusmnlfl 6 1 ~ LCz U ~ 1 C
~~eci1co~neo h Ae11t tbOUITS at~oLciic nst uLiona The r---otft ~T 2 bC
~vUX~b of rmoj cct aceozfiur E3chedJe bo1e
P d J IA V I - -T
L hY 6ar
-AI be 5h - t i~c T ins u ion odbe hae i
nos j -c goeren the cllbornti or11 moreover tiCth iw0ver tLfo wy fCo1 ~o -ve c1et-cng et b h 10b
ti~oacan vcih~ nsr i ~dctIt i~sonne2-Jriao h
L rtA~a tl~at 0h b Coitrctr 220 5 h a Up th intiLn01tro 1fC hi C C1it1c
m- 3f i yoriy itiLaon w1it- atica3 iteducaicn1 1-71 Cary0th
o the mroiucpo ~rtL VIJ ttterjet
ou fot-biU beo idntife dCton advplusmni hve iolpsx tnr~gC-it1in srshysetox czuia22 nsef of teio~rt~cisiaditnthe
poundecn ~r~~oferiduyc oi whs conwshym~m0 prtcprogrinmc 1y 5 2-a a V c t1-nL1t6
tnu theddcL Ox fino2-tl~b Ccn aoinbofre yUSR~~~1ona1Onrato rLeaz IrAl~p~on-Dlie
vmn rr J0 ~~i~~1 ~APy O
)fltht manCn~L~lr
n momtl
V C4
7~or 00 eso
~L7-O
C 2
VXO742-gOOw
40 -
8~i
Mh
-axtgt1)i
n-r
e a
--shy 1 y
betwee Us VTrAXLir D~estilnte5dY ~ X L0
0C-her ConsViant trave) mid par d~ri vr00 i~oub-Totalt
25O0VF 50
Tranvelt~~shy
j~2j~Forboth 4
S 4
=d I)C offices -
-~~ -~- ~ ~n2--000
~ 3
ftA0verb -~0Vshy-Mall
7 - N
e hsre ~ t o~ a il~
ng g
~
e r o r an em s pound 1px
~~ e ne d poundor 3 ~e n t o 3-I4e uzvU~ a u tj o ncz~esed ra
etuti-Is~o nt On Nort Th a ea
Pr
Ps c- T
~ns On 4he ore ~h thc skia-r s n a i n
I neti e ) -ch ~ earerSof cer t J
t eIe h )lSihas t oi poundR-4_ ethasr~h~~Lrm2tc soni Prqie~ri- thsrcns on ed~ ht ~ ~~~to~7 ecamcvesic iacre-ea ts ofdu J 6 at L6e~Oneen d c t a t 0 t
el t 11p1aydref Omu-ts ean1gth s c es c 0 _J-r atqundat giad aeshret he e o svf(re u ar e ~Ait1J~~gransothe phleel -an onA ecevra
1 b ipernasons eterjcje_ the~~
a1mand pe oniis av ~h calLlatons af 0t-poundrt~n Creflofe tan ft r
css onditions- astered ciigh6an eTh cScp lme a nt id tocn toe
IJ t vi~br~ a s te yo r e u
r u w rn 1 d d ollclo s ~ ~ 1 ~~~int A
n C l u at o s t f ric r e l ~ ne erVaLuesv_60 ra he es tr t h gh t~ ticaddede andftdetermiZnJation educa 0~~i6t27 edu(7romatii~ ati f ra
EvLICt elaluation utu o - A i i ntt~ct beo madhtca -hthd soji hsonetins n requiresth e~tasa outhuil c) y o1wchebsznniafji ost~c~ prdcin rCeintoeolionize avauc thI sch s itn cae poduc at -e1 l prd hei prco
ln10Md -achpu~ij ed[n4tg
IMIS
~~ ~ t~ 6~ s~ffe f Fnil nr r F E71I
s 0or ate ~ frcou cI secre c D~oi thex rdci~avt-~ g711sructi 1n
6 U le ratavel3y untrained teac er curren Jyaaa e~~ora erse ih e mryd e0nb TScin oC Min)
gIrtof thibereduc -shy trarc ec rSc h e
avaf_ be as for example oru lit DytO~fSUPer_shyZ9~~1de vsor and chagsi scculI -Tirdt I-ri e among edcinal
OUtpu1its can~be r3eordered so~ thi the education~ productio rcesT~ ~ ofo~ those y-ie - figh1 -Us E oe ithbscsseL Uene urcncrcd
bVe reahzl througnh iivc stent in-s~na _10opp 1 - ochn1ia1 vci~oi9lto hgheedaib hioaonveAmcril intne ond
coiidr edUcation b (r o r Vestme 1t11igcnrIrc)roiid r (dutio
SAll of these concer1)ed witth the matter (d Snt~crnal ofDic cY)ncyr e I 10 to the product or output ofthtIeducationial~sy stem i an d to bctc cvaludlte Vi zIM output i-to provide a Mor usPefuJ_ beic imark for -mprovrjng_-yStOm efficiencyl
cth~ iwords l eII and a plusmn i ~ ictp y~~ esi~md need to 1know f the value of t 1e outputs has beei erih~ncedamp gt
-ofererpcc to svlttem efficiency is in )mrtan~tfor po di igoom n -~in shy
dta41costs lin O-Cra u n o ratc iofn programS- c CBeUoation is 1CIIL-Lnre rigly -larger 0--rcntages of ni Uih1bid~imperati~ dis n~cce
t - learn if the money being speit is producing desired- resuits and doing so is econr-n4cally as possible
On the other hanid wdth reeec oh bene6fits edacation measzes -are needed to better inform us if inv~estmnents in education are compettivee41ithj~ alternative investments in other sector~s One coznhci~si~n ofrte-freunstudie ~ in scveral countries is that returnsto education in most Cases Cx returns fo ot 1plusmnr k r~is of investments the payoff for ilinvesting in men seems to be higrner~ tha tratl for investinri inYrnzchinest What is rieededAampispoundurther- rfinerit o6f
measures to helpD us detcermine 1which typcs of cogitie i~-aamph-b ~ mastn prodes the highest yieldl- or pay-off in the mrkt--1hc A~dit on-
allyjwo canproft from better Pnsiireqf the aititd~~ S- ohascrr I thl~m) and the exteritto which such-attituides affect succesi laiif~n
~~~ro~tiero rance injbai ~ ~doi ing moden health~ ititio6nal and poundawmily~ planning practices and asuigm r sponsibe izen~larip3le
puppesofoitut vauaaoexpert in the f ield Sugge s+ that t atr fsse efficincy impli~sthatsonie formof$ measurement instruments
can cFrae th itaI d s(adgous
~ ~i~aio~~)Aexprience rFurther eprtssurgFY ha iteasres of- ~its sufficient i ormato a eotie rl E (ucatona C1cifiputsS6 eesr~ eseniay2))4Isin he sus
uein D-ote iec hdtathees1sof meCrn edc14p~C uef i an -iec- Itl
-a etrr ionopound -Fansr th-ogh edluca -on5-sQfo at nF toepor b-g 0go hndingi iampJ
Spat-Qrai up)ward p ~ec s~ etcot cnb ~L~iiampe l n a C I 4 Qben Peaheemno orirsaidta ents innnco ivareas opound 1vhZ Ir c)I-sued
~iTh prnstI e c veityave1b~ 4wt 1 -aespe and1 mil Wou ut2n_es i djehooJhge
the b)sduc forma t lio cirrdbook__Y la tedd i Wpa~ryic~i~~a v~ltt~Jkainahd si ta ofl respc o oth us a on r~e-irc rjidin to he pag 1 0 aieioritdon meth2 d i 2A
Cou idDC plFn St- at lshycrctcticV
1 Im~eeto Pln Seej attached RT Chrir L- ~shy
OC1urse of~Action Tiie CUSCplusmnO0_ rp3entativ es o~ti~IC with astn aas t- geniceiS ill which th FA a- cptd led Lo -the deampelophin 0O~
apr oposal by the International -istituteforEducationaJ Plling Paris propJosal received by us in~Novemnber l971lprojectedan interntionalns 1n~~-on out-Frts evaluation forJuly 1973f 1rith pre-paia g etiiiparis onamp~sectJz uarv 2973 The proposali enVisaged full represntaton of LDC oa~ti cimtr(5toLC eds ate ymposium should be fuly reF~
Siibsequent discussions with thampII-TE P led to the ~conclusibn oniour partthat the IIP1woul~d not have sufficientL staCC shyto 6ranz and carry b6ut thear 44proposed project anid it was Telt that mor Sharpened anid substaitiy--wor cwouija of outputs evaluat ion this focusiig of fort wsotc prvddritielE
-proposal Moreover AIDIF plolicy of inore directly engaging LD n titio n - -4t1 +chnlcal assistance Projects an engagehient we did 4notT6e 1plusmn~coujampd bo ataie 4 -through the IMP~ activity lead us~ to 4 eevL t a mu dijcc~
4and shiould be fLoril t ed r 4 ~ i~~ shy
4~
Moile centrllyaod scstsraivelvw tr tani morecentaU~nd sb~~~j~r~byarraanging for-a CoJlaborativp- undertinofLDCa titition withthe US instLti
het pjchs riuebee wit m e brso the Task o aa~mci~i ts dgr z ben iec poundrnHrad ri7ayedcLan~
1~ ~ orr~t nolectvida dvonry c s onu bpan ~~UV
on5-nbr 2 ofi-1r wi- jexprr-tilnto cof7 ynPany CIp-Ite ~c Cofl a
to ~ ~cteyoand~ ds~1 __
trbduing pierivh~ meho eaFun- leel-snev f ontit-s1Tr LDs f d ren I typb of
ed cation~an 11yzind Strrlgthdan6i wa sse s an shiowIig me- 0 cI u~ e~pT4~Suu6hi Ththod C) coyp n-ne~poundLDCOeducaticnalof ndor ocshy
~CieweV reseac sc to~e~d the papers an rihe relevce fLIN -1othefri rethz~ds of 6upit1is9ialuatlTh presenit (3 the Coiferccf vwulds~ gg tjn for needo highP
e-v~~~rirt aluinAri1o- cepiI euo 2thS~eL researchproj ectsdeemed to have hi~ghes priority e
The roject shoulJd be designed to rqaent r h 1 ot m 2XAr~ pJshpan is gien here The iirstf~ i-tsen to the
r~gtd~l~fiat o ad ra-ment of coll)a ~ ~ i ~i~tiitiop- 0tnd~wti s--C b et y~i rctsonand aettii gct~r iw~~~~rtolyig 5 or tiiig t perI a V(iactio th thidnic t cb tande itt t Ioii-ii there~e mon hswou2 d PAbe 16o1
-al ii lor ri a yrddnl-thse _nd preparaticn of sevzeral prodt~cts iinb1 ampscrabang-difiirr6iitl-iitoylyjJ4
-easzrement metchodologies projet and1 cofercnicefancamp reportsiia set of dconlresearch ~deigns and a plan forh noSt effectiVe dseMaicn fe1hndc4k nvovng such posibiities as a series of regi6hal seirnarr6the cxr5iiz -tion ofIt travelin- sem~inar N~ is ipratthat th-isdisseivintdoi plahn adressat leayst these two questions )How can the handbook b~i dis~tributed Thitirj~ly
fahin2) How with a reasonable degree of certainty can we get-copies- of the~ hpabook into the hands of tho~eLDC eople who can make bcstuseoIt9 This SeCol~a ut~rt is essentia1ly the question of audience Inasmuch as the han~dbook isi-Lendcieto be an inforinationcl resource for LDCPeducaticn dc ison ekIe~1pLanners~jy
ma ranagers i E vifal ihat th~kinds of Vorac uitaoner6 haveaccess to the
G Scial Mani6mentProwsijon
Linsclecting the LDC organizationwith which it oroposes t- 1abo r t he US orgaiiizai n (Contractor)Shall notify-thi PoetMnce of
AIWA who0shall take the necessary~stepsto obtain RcgioItn IBureau andUSAID ampapprc 1 for the inVolement of the LDC or aflization The wor1kiing out of final
arrangements between the two collaboatii organizations Shallbecontingentshyupon ~re C61pt ofILsuch apprboval
~p ~ ~ J-
Vgt~
k T
DoCr(ioriton-n
Pro-c s A grt
64 DO unvriy
On--~ u ~
1 S Ieu P Te -w-- ran 4 z-
15--C~~nHndok k
C (r-- planinshy
-D-) Io confrenc r 03on
(B) ~~ 2f ~ar ~ ~ FiaAll-boo draft ----- -4~Y
6 (C D) Wo~~~~~0rkoncnrrner orP- -i c
9 (F)lFinal projecth reot
Pro- 6 dd -
------- j Woc ocoia
9T-e ~(F 1Proect report-nan Ci Ca-~f6-l -yad+a
Vp A- J
etal 4-1
0 shy
0lfl~
~0
-44h
~ d
~ -
4
r~sg
h
4
--I ca
4
44
)4
~K~
v j
T to4
to4 ~
)4 I ~~ 6Y
~
W
9-
V
~~
~~
~
E
~4
7K
IOr4
cisect
L~
n
4444~
~
o44w
44444
u4
4K
tV
4
44
shyX
4
444
4bo4
4~
I
C9~-)1U
444
~~4-444-~~ tr
-
I Il 13 0I
r 5
4
44A
44~
~~
~
c 0
01-1 r4
iM
L
J l
4 jr-~
i-
-
~(Jw~y
444
4
oil54 G
aJ
44
4-
C)1
04-1[ 5
H H
~
n 4
I
0r4 4
3444444
~~
94
~ 4
3
~
(l~
4
lb
-r-
4 ~
LtC
I4 ~~~~~~~
Cl
9
tr
i~~
444
~
U
4 t3A9 C
I ~~
in
44
~)4 4
~ 4 ( U
~4
4 4
~ 4
it5
4 4
)4j
J4
414K
-i4~ 4
4
3
44T
CQ
U
-t
4 7-1
~
1A
2fJ
4
~f
d4444
4~
I 4
44440
~
04
~
~
~~
-~a
i ci
0~
~
~
44444 ~
U
44
~ ~
CL
4 -
4~~ 44~
~~
~~
4~
t
gL 44 4
4
44 5
449 ~41
~~
~
-~
~
~~
04 0
44444444444444
rFP
-~5~1444
amp
t+oj
44
4~
7~
-
~ ~
tz tn
G
- D
)Q
co
i 444
U41
i4
j~_j
0 g
tz44~
444A
4 j449f
~~
4
i~(4~
lt 0-vr~
U(
~ ~
24
tj 4
2
4ii~
~~
0
~~414 4
44 4
44
~ 34
(7r4
-4
~~4444~~~~4 4 p~
~~
~C
A 4
4J )1
4
444
4
4
4
4
4444
W
H
10
4 4~44iC
Ocl0r13
~44444~
474
4~U
4~~
V-
444
44
~
2 4 0 4~ C
~
~
4
44 ~
44
444
4~ Hl
~Y
T-4
4
4
4M
Y
4
-44
PriWZampATC L0IbTP
C~~l~1~~ F~~ F R~~~ OE T VA U T iWCVUP
Cl x~ )13 0ec i Oof0e o onl 2d1 uctgo (fa0c 1 L 6 ) md aQ ~ ~ S ~ ~ Eu- L~inr~i
SiUcL a~i~tzix dotoB ~ i~I -
~ woopo~o~ eu YQ50 oojrarchv fOr qua1Jitative~ im~~~iV 2~VG~eard tyDpeo 0oudc1tio
-a among oCn thee nrb
3) i-h
9~ ~tamp a $~a
Arab CN4
Atjh flziobi Go~neroccon TL3 10 _ lTbo causesJ of tbOd VixS~t(euc 6antd Varie-dl ltTIh L tnampt of0 te zWocjuoyo
rc~11an gven~tetshavor aJrob iached the 3lzit ~OL Vhbapoundiobail2SL Cr Bu I Or ts byaIhiriaJ is o rieanr
V31ropily o 1iso alsogt to n oncTh liutlitioL blawed6i 12 Ofnnn[ ___
(p (Fuca1
~~~~~ ~~ M a~0prPz~ l~~lo)c d onthe iieed t~a~ f~0Cetv t a
of the clneat f~cacod byr educa-L6til~ ai ofn~n orzn t he
-- -9
Co ruo~~ 5t ~ n oIis~ehri
oT L v3 r) at ~cn
Dj
p~o~~r~X ryc
i
L-oof t r
44-
1 a
0111A Ofa4iC
~~~iooIy -ght 1A)
c i r
01
b 6
in 10 7-noiorshy
o
in c az e s
n l
~~
Aa
J -Ir1O
~44--
d loo to cIdu1e~ L -al emu-L)1 b a4444oa 1J i ~~ l--iO
c~u~ 11 )_2~ 2 0OJanot
Dio 11 mCtlCcLOxr OJ n v
i1i 4-1 )_
V
nLla t o n
x nm
4
4
c
6i pl
IRCl 4 n1 n V V
i17 $ 42lv
CofiUsnc1
--shy L~s~otoojn b4
cnfrece all
t 3-4A44~C--
hg p4pqtin of
tr0inperj- iIdnt~Li ntConoeu4Y X e V 4
u~~~-a lou 1
~ ~ ~ 4 ~
4
tho tcdovolop-mentl of Pan e cect~rc machiinery4 forthe1o ecdufat0ion and for4a~S~l on a continui bai the
niAZ oafo v
LT
At
4 Alea-ve
of o co-tin --
drojgtout grac repatitio land c
hic by7 anr xlj the a- 0idntv ti1u(h to bo de~rd~Gri-shyd shol~fu ub an intE-ua pat o
hi1nc ih 1~Ic~~o nr~ In rio aneiiatlo~ 2ydeeo- i~
OfA44Jllit n O4a at o4xam 44
pr M s U -- L
dnaticn alu~ec ntuet
v1e oi -iuiUu~~er L-3trictont
_l uti L -n 44o
(oCnji~poundr ~n~i~ni
1477port Third PL Qnal Con7a e cshyo 4 --3 4 P
shy
4 -~ ~4 - 44VV43p
kl- Cp 31p4a _ T 4~n o- ~
4 7424pi
~ -4 4~lt
6
4 77 4
I 81J
~ n
JY
444
h F1~~V011V-i~m)ya3ofOuet
- -MA
4 u
c u -- a - ao 4((A voi co~t111 nl t ororc -4- 44i44
d~44 4~~44~~4~4
djr4444n 44 u otP-00 (Yt O aos n
I Iitu shy
r a)-raIthm-- eh
ndfore -ou So4 as
~ ~ v at~aoi$ib~aoi8imampT m~~ t r4 411A-tio i h abe b4 - wi iie
S~~~V a I icau i1~ic
e ~~filhi O tdlS 4 ~ ~ ~ oqecL andh ~ th
4)1 ~ 4-1411-1~ o~be~ ~ 1 mlbi viuCLO2Ul Dt rtlfiP1111
c i l
lw r6 -tr cnb~~~ tf2 ~~~~ ~ ~ ~ b-~~~~t co~ i nt~rro ojtvnab ~ci~e~~
-~t~i~w ~ ~ ~iVtiot~catdc-~
tcr Cdo4 g C-a n l hg rampthdi1uh3 401 0- c a y i
t~ d
-z-~7~~ cost flCe1~ ~--
aa~ha~g K2-atnaampit~rB~U~-~v02 nojaJ rl-4 bt)o 1i
as tcjwainJcvatso isD6t iampifwt htof lbprta
urie oli achleavaiuaeto iSurh meansure ao usualc y -a is-c
an4- t Q)- A
-- ----ao
-Lr
cZ a no--shy4~ 4c
-Ala-~1610
Y Ln-ob 0
c Cn ereo~m - - 9-I
anld dveX~ 12b fljt l
i ~unat ~ O ~ ri- -10f~ ~ 9jiOr( r LO(v) j 0- f ui1Ahht~C~~tiwCdfLo^ ir
O~ r-si~ tc- uvc O tciaicn in vie oicny
0y ator sy on lxgcr- tcaampi c CTshyoitnm tnonvcay A~ilf-iea~e v a~nd cocia1 iiiamp=anfco oppO II
UO9 sshy
-~-~- - ~-b~at the quaity of thoro i~ho hold cortificatev
tha1oi da o d~roDushoaliaJo be su t tor0 shyu 993 9UP
o9 m- o icr n9Inaucon
9 2
cushy
ml m~6v )c~ar
f-~ C) LJri Z)~u )
vc C r 71 shy
TG- 0111 u
(b)Scol D3 or- (re U 17-
-i C ntatoi e~ic~ S~c~illum~ 6A -J-Oq
-OfIhstrurz ton cl qpro ss1 g obecti-miamp Jishy~e1doogiesWO(ii
- ~~---- -rt~cl to studei -lv1p2nve tachrV f~s
~$ ~iv) Lrolcveift 7ad--Ttati oi aUdIo-vismn1 Mdia prga d
7ial r7 a w t7ni
4 7 7
iv
t
(rii)~~~~~~
of
~
uoclc
Iff C 7
~
ediULACCampJOLU
- i4
~--~~
I~lCosu3ai
1shy
~d
a1O
I
41~3~rh
W~=12X
Ul
I -
I II~I~i
ti-vos~~~~~~~~~~~~r oo-t ~
anacdU
t
ied iltio
alfe-tlh 0 in iC ar
(1) cj ptvo-a~~ i1tof 4 ex c-~1~r gtI1~f
441444Y14141iII4 outputs
c- v1 t-cD-cc aniti lo 1~f
1 5-
61k
kc oj -i
-u
-7C
Ushy
fc l CI r V- 4 Tv U
~uIT p1 iPobTZ U 0-p atoao 4u L 1) )c
odcvI n o t (S
~ W-
spie- Mt irm (0 ) of-110
UNITED STATES GOVERNMENT
Memorandum TO AATAPM - Mr David Mathiasen DATmrebrUs~y 21 1973
FROM TAEIM - John F i ard
SUBJECT OYB Funding for TAEHR Projects
We have been advised that the funding for the proposed new GTS project Education Outputs Measurement (total $225000 6f which $150000 is scheduled for FY 1973 and $75000 for FY 1974) is inadequate to meet the contractors budget (Georgetown University $252000) We therefore want to shift $27000 to this project from the $2500O allotted for the Educational Technology Field Support Project reducing the FY 1973 fumnding
level for the latter to $223000
TAEHRRSchmedingsd
Bs US Savings Bonds Replarly on the PayrollSavings Plan I
9 P S
43T ~- ~ z~p
01d4~C 7-C 721a j0 44Q
rIxv - Of P~to IcZt ~ ~~VtUc
5 ~ at~ 01z -
~~A a~ ralla zva to E-1en~ ci
Nil
-9 MkC ~
Th1a t~a ~of for o ~ tb- pvoject -to o 1 TUESin igas LUc Lb f oI ~~e9~~
I C I
x e t - 4 v 5 M I i 1$-Qfl~~~~~- 4Lj~af 2 1it amp amp ti c tl~laampi ~L ~cin~o~areducatioricto the Pc O oo tp ) U 0 iK Jtshy
coateeAIi Valleetckepl o cn
Our rPoan will be produce ei~ ~ st~o ~itrrt naC~fl~ence to of 6e r - pa o t rreo~onfe re 0n tbb t h cc 1l c 4MveS C-0 it djb- u e i
- - d b)- ge iit
-MR47
h4 Z
_ __b ~~~OfX 1-plusmnlfl 6 1 ~ LCz U ~ 1 C
~~eci1co~neo h Ae11t tbOUITS at~oLciic nst uLiona The r---otft ~T 2 bC
~vUX~b of rmoj cct aceozfiur E3chedJe bo1e
P d J IA V I - -T
L hY 6ar
-AI be 5h - t i~c T ins u ion odbe hae i
nos j -c goeren the cllbornti or11 moreover tiCth iw0ver tLfo wy fCo1 ~o -ve c1et-cng et b h 10b
ti~oacan vcih~ nsr i ~dctIt i~sonne2-Jriao h
L rtA~a tl~at 0h b Coitrctr 220 5 h a Up th intiLn01tro 1fC hi C C1it1c
m- 3f i yoriy itiLaon w1it- atica3 iteducaicn1 1-71 Cary0th
o the mroiucpo ~rtL VIJ ttterjet
ou fot-biU beo idntife dCton advplusmni hve iolpsx tnr~gC-it1in srshysetox czuia22 nsef of teio~rt~cisiaditnthe
poundecn ~r~~oferiduyc oi whs conwshym~m0 prtcprogrinmc 1y 5 2-a a V c t1-nL1t6
tnu theddcL Ox fino2-tl~b Ccn aoinbofre yUSR~~~1ona1Onrato rLeaz IrAl~p~on-Dlie
vmn rr J0 ~~i~~1 ~APy O
)fltht manCn~L~lr
n momtl
V C4
7~or 00 eso
~L7-O
C 2
VXO742-gOOw
40 -
8~i
Mh
-axtgt1)i
n-r
e a
--shy 1 y
betwee Us VTrAXLir D~estilnte5dY ~ X L0
0C-her ConsViant trave) mid par d~ri vr00 i~oub-Totalt
25O0VF 50
Tranvelt~~shy
j~2j~Forboth 4
S 4
=d I)C offices -
-~~ -~- ~ ~n2--000
~ 3
ftA0verb -~0Vshy-Mall
7 - N
e hsre ~ t o~ a il~
ng g
~
e r o r an em s pound 1px
~~ e ne d poundor 3 ~e n t o 3-I4e uzvU~ a u tj o ncz~esed ra
etuti-Is~o nt On Nort Th a ea
Pr
Ps c- T
~ns On 4he ore ~h thc skia-r s n a i n
I neti e ) -ch ~ earerSof cer t J
t eIe h )lSihas t oi poundR-4_ ethasr~h~~Lrm2tc soni Prqie~ri- thsrcns on ed~ ht ~ ~~~to~7 ecamcvesic iacre-ea ts ofdu J 6 at L6e~Oneen d c t a t 0 t
el t 11p1aydref Omu-ts ean1gth s c es c 0 _J-r atqundat giad aeshret he e o svf(re u ar e ~Ait1J~~gransothe phleel -an onA ecevra
1 b ipernasons eterjcje_ the~~
a1mand pe oniis av ~h calLlatons af 0t-poundrt~n Creflofe tan ft r
css onditions- astered ciigh6an eTh cScp lme a nt id tocn toe
IJ t vi~br~ a s te yo r e u
r u w rn 1 d d ollclo s ~ ~ 1 ~~~int A
n C l u at o s t f ric r e l ~ ne erVaLuesv_60 ra he es tr t h gh t~ ticaddede andftdetermiZnJation educa 0~~i6t27 edu(7romatii~ ati f ra
EvLICt elaluation utu o - A i i ntt~ct beo madhtca -hthd soji hsonetins n requiresth e~tasa outhuil c) y o1wchebsznniafji ost~c~ prdcin rCeintoeolionize avauc thI sch s itn cae poduc at -e1 l prd hei prco
ln10Md -achpu~ij ed[n4tg
IMIS
~~ ~ t~ 6~ s~ffe f Fnil nr r F E71I
s 0or ate ~ frcou cI secre c D~oi thex rdci~avt-~ g711sructi 1n
6 U le ratavel3y untrained teac er curren Jyaaa e~~ora erse ih e mryd e0nb TScin oC Min)
gIrtof thibereduc -shy trarc ec rSc h e
avaf_ be as for example oru lit DytO~fSUPer_shyZ9~~1de vsor and chagsi scculI -Tirdt I-ri e among edcinal
OUtpu1its can~be r3eordered so~ thi the education~ productio rcesT~ ~ ofo~ those y-ie - figh1 -Us E oe ithbscsseL Uene urcncrcd
bVe reahzl througnh iivc stent in-s~na _10opp 1 - ochn1ia1 vci~oi9lto hgheedaib hioaonveAmcril intne ond
coiidr edUcation b (r o r Vestme 1t11igcnrIrc)roiid r (dutio
SAll of these concer1)ed witth the matter (d Snt~crnal ofDic cY)ncyr e I 10 to the product or output ofthtIeducationial~sy stem i an d to bctc cvaludlte Vi zIM output i-to provide a Mor usPefuJ_ beic imark for -mprovrjng_-yStOm efficiencyl
cth~ iwords l eII and a plusmn i ~ ictp y~~ esi~md need to 1know f the value of t 1e outputs has beei erih~ncedamp gt
-ofererpcc to svlttem efficiency is in )mrtan~tfor po di igoom n -~in shy
dta41costs lin O-Cra u n o ratc iofn programS- c CBeUoation is 1CIIL-Lnre rigly -larger 0--rcntages of ni Uih1bid~imperati~ dis n~cce
t - learn if the money being speit is producing desired- resuits and doing so is econr-n4cally as possible
On the other hanid wdth reeec oh bene6fits edacation measzes -are needed to better inform us if inv~estmnents in education are compettivee41ithj~ alternative investments in other sector~s One coznhci~si~n ofrte-freunstudie ~ in scveral countries is that returnsto education in most Cases Cx returns fo ot 1plusmnr k r~is of investments the payoff for ilinvesting in men seems to be higrner~ tha tratl for investinri inYrnzchinest What is rieededAampispoundurther- rfinerit o6f
measures to helpD us detcermine 1which typcs of cogitie i~-aamph-b ~ mastn prodes the highest yieldl- or pay-off in the mrkt--1hc A~dit on-
allyjwo canproft from better Pnsiireqf the aititd~~ S- ohascrr I thl~m) and the exteritto which such-attituides affect succesi laiif~n
~~~ro~tiero rance injbai ~ ~doi ing moden health~ ititio6nal and poundawmily~ planning practices and asuigm r sponsibe izen~larip3le
puppesofoitut vauaaoexpert in the f ield Sugge s+ that t atr fsse efficincy impli~sthatsonie formof$ measurement instruments
can cFrae th itaI d s(adgous
~ ~i~aio~~)Aexprience rFurther eprtssurgFY ha iteasres of- ~its sufficient i ormato a eotie rl E (ucatona C1cifiputsS6 eesr~ eseniay2))4Isin he sus
uein D-ote iec hdtathees1sof meCrn edc14p~C uef i an -iec- Itl
-a etrr ionopound -Fansr th-ogh edluca -on5-sQfo at nF toepor b-g 0go hndingi iampJ
Spat-Qrai up)ward p ~ec s~ etcot cnb ~L~iiampe l n a C I 4 Qben Peaheemno orirsaidta ents innnco ivareas opound 1vhZ Ir c)I-sued
~iTh prnstI e c veityave1b~ 4wt 1 -aespe and1 mil Wou ut2n_es i djehooJhge
the b)sduc forma t lio cirrdbook__Y la tedd i Wpa~ryic~i~~a v~ltt~Jkainahd si ta ofl respc o oth us a on r~e-irc rjidin to he pag 1 0 aieioritdon meth2 d i 2A
Cou idDC plFn St- at lshycrctcticV
1 Im~eeto Pln Seej attached RT Chrir L- ~shy
OC1urse of~Action Tiie CUSCplusmnO0_ rp3entativ es o~ti~IC with astn aas t- geniceiS ill which th FA a- cptd led Lo -the deampelophin 0O~
apr oposal by the International -istituteforEducationaJ Plling Paris propJosal received by us in~Novemnber l971lprojectedan interntionalns 1n~~-on out-Frts evaluation forJuly 1973f 1rith pre-paia g etiiiparis onamp~sectJz uarv 2973 The proposali enVisaged full represntaton of LDC oa~ti cimtr(5toLC eds ate ymposium should be fuly reF~
Siibsequent discussions with thampII-TE P led to the ~conclusibn oniour partthat the IIP1woul~d not have sufficientL staCC shyto 6ranz and carry b6ut thear 44proposed project anid it was Telt that mor Sharpened anid substaitiy--wor cwouija of outputs evaluat ion this focusiig of fort wsotc prvddritielE
-proposal Moreover AIDIF plolicy of inore directly engaging LD n titio n - -4t1 +chnlcal assistance Projects an engagehient we did 4notT6e 1plusmn~coujampd bo ataie 4 -through the IMP~ activity lead us~ to 4 eevL t a mu dijcc~
4and shiould be fLoril t ed r 4 ~ i~~ shy
4~
Moile centrllyaod scstsraivelvw tr tani morecentaU~nd sb~~~j~r~byarraanging for-a CoJlaborativp- undertinofLDCa titition withthe US instLti
het pjchs riuebee wit m e brso the Task o aa~mci~i ts dgr z ben iec poundrnHrad ri7ayedcLan~
1~ ~ orr~t nolectvida dvonry c s onu bpan ~~UV
on5-nbr 2 ofi-1r wi- jexprr-tilnto cof7 ynPany CIp-Ite ~c Cofl a
to ~ ~cteyoand~ ds~1 __
trbduing pierivh~ meho eaFun- leel-snev f ontit-s1Tr LDs f d ren I typb of
ed cation~an 11yzind Strrlgthdan6i wa sse s an shiowIig me- 0 cI u~ e~pT4~Suu6hi Ththod C) coyp n-ne~poundLDCOeducaticnalof ndor ocshy
~CieweV reseac sc to~e~d the papers an rihe relevce fLIN -1othefri rethz~ds of 6upit1is9ialuatlTh presenit (3 the Coiferccf vwulds~ gg tjn for needo highP
e-v~~~rirt aluinAri1o- cepiI euo 2thS~eL researchproj ectsdeemed to have hi~ghes priority e
The roject shoulJd be designed to rqaent r h 1 ot m 2XAr~ pJshpan is gien here The iirstf~ i-tsen to the
r~gtd~l~fiat o ad ra-ment of coll)a ~ ~ i ~i~tiitiop- 0tnd~wti s--C b et y~i rctsonand aettii gct~r iw~~~~rtolyig 5 or tiiig t perI a V(iactio th thidnic t cb tande itt t Ioii-ii there~e mon hswou2 d PAbe 16o1
-al ii lor ri a yrddnl-thse _nd preparaticn of sevzeral prodt~cts iinb1 ampscrabang-difiirr6iitl-iitoylyjJ4
-easzrement metchodologies projet and1 cofercnicefancamp reportsiia set of dconlresearch ~deigns and a plan forh noSt effectiVe dseMaicn fe1hndc4k nvovng such posibiities as a series of regi6hal seirnarr6the cxr5iiz -tion ofIt travelin- sem~inar N~ is ipratthat th-isdisseivintdoi plahn adressat leayst these two questions )How can the handbook b~i dis~tributed Thitirj~ly
fahin2) How with a reasonable degree of certainty can we get-copies- of the~ hpabook into the hands of tho~eLDC eople who can make bcstuseoIt9 This SeCol~a ut~rt is essentia1ly the question of audience Inasmuch as the han~dbook isi-Lendcieto be an inforinationcl resource for LDCPeducaticn dc ison ekIe~1pLanners~jy
ma ranagers i E vifal ihat th~kinds of Vorac uitaoner6 haveaccess to the
G Scial Mani6mentProwsijon
Linsclecting the LDC organizationwith which it oroposes t- 1abo r t he US orgaiiizai n (Contractor)Shall notify-thi PoetMnce of
AIWA who0shall take the necessary~stepsto obtain RcgioItn IBureau andUSAID ampapprc 1 for the inVolement of the LDC or aflization The wor1kiing out of final
arrangements between the two collaboatii organizations Shallbecontingentshyupon ~re C61pt ofILsuch apprboval
~p ~ ~ J-
Vgt~
k T
DoCr(ioriton-n
Pro-c s A grt
64 DO unvriy
On--~ u ~
1 S Ieu P Te -w-- ran 4 z-
15--C~~nHndok k
C (r-- planinshy
-D-) Io confrenc r 03on
(B) ~~ 2f ~ar ~ ~ FiaAll-boo draft ----- -4~Y
6 (C D) Wo~~~~~0rkoncnrrner orP- -i c
9 (F)lFinal projecth reot
Pro- 6 dd -
------- j Woc ocoia
9T-e ~(F 1Proect report-nan Ci Ca-~f6-l -yad+a
Vp A- J
etal 4-1
0 shy
0lfl~
~0
-44h
~ d
~ -
4
r~sg
h
4
--I ca
4
44
)4
~K~
v j
T to4
to4 ~
)4 I ~~ 6Y
~
W
9-
V
~~
~~
~
E
~4
7K
IOr4
cisect
L~
n
4444~
~
o44w
44444
u4
4K
tV
4
44
shyX
4
444
4bo4
4~
I
C9~-)1U
444
~~4-444-~~ tr
-
I Il 13 0I
r 5
4
44A
44~
~~
~
c 0
01-1 r4
iM
L
J l
4 jr-~
i-
-
~(Jw~y
444
4
oil54 G
aJ
44
4-
C)1
04-1[ 5
H H
~
n 4
I
0r4 4
3444444
~~
94
~ 4
3
~
(l~
4
lb
-r-
4 ~
LtC
I4 ~~~~~~~
Cl
9
tr
i~~
444
~
U
4 t3A9 C
I ~~
in
44
~)4 4
~ 4 ( U
~4
4 4
~ 4
it5
4 4
)4j
J4
414K
-i4~ 4
4
3
44T
CQ
U
-t
4 7-1
~
1A
2fJ
4
~f
d4444
4~
I 4
44440
~
04
~
~
~~
-~a
i ci
0~
~
~
44444 ~
U
44
~ ~
CL
4 -
4~~ 44~
~~
~~
4~
t
gL 44 4
4
44 5
449 ~41
~~
~
-~
~
~~
04 0
44444444444444
rFP
-~5~1444
amp
t+oj
44
4~
7~
-
~ ~
tz tn
G
- D
)Q
co
i 444
U41
i4
j~_j
0 g
tz44~
444A
4 j449f
~~
4
i~(4~
lt 0-vr~
U(
~ ~
24
tj 4
2
4ii~
~~
0
~~414 4
44 4
44
~ 34
(7r4
-4
~~4444~~~~4 4 p~
~~
~C
A 4
4J )1
4
444
4
4
4
4
4444
W
H
10
4 4~44iC
Ocl0r13
~44444~
474
4~U
4~~
V-
444
44
~
2 4 0 4~ C
~
~
4
44 ~
44
444
4~ Hl
~Y
T-4
4
4
4M
Y
4
-44
PriWZampATC L0IbTP
C~~l~1~~ F~~ F R~~~ OE T VA U T iWCVUP
Cl x~ )13 0ec i Oof0e o onl 2d1 uctgo (fa0c 1 L 6 ) md aQ ~ ~ S ~ ~ Eu- L~inr~i
SiUcL a~i~tzix dotoB ~ i~I -
~ woopo~o~ eu YQ50 oojrarchv fOr qua1Jitative~ im~~~iV 2~VG~eard tyDpeo 0oudc1tio
-a among oCn thee nrb
3) i-h
9~ ~tamp a $~a
Arab CN4
Atjh flziobi Go~neroccon TL3 10 _ lTbo causesJ of tbOd VixS~t(euc 6antd Varie-dl ltTIh L tnampt of0 te zWocjuoyo
rc~11an gven~tetshavor aJrob iached the 3lzit ~OL Vhbapoundiobail2SL Cr Bu I Or ts byaIhiriaJ is o rieanr
V31ropily o 1iso alsogt to n oncTh liutlitioL blawed6i 12 Ofnnn[ ___
(p (Fuca1
~~~~~ ~~ M a~0prPz~ l~~lo)c d onthe iieed t~a~ f~0Cetv t a
of the clneat f~cacod byr educa-L6til~ ai ofn~n orzn t he
-- -9
Co ruo~~ 5t ~ n oIis~ehri
oT L v3 r) at ~cn
Dj
p~o~~r~X ryc
i
L-oof t r
44-
1 a
0111A Ofa4iC
~~~iooIy -ght 1A)
c i r
01
b 6
in 10 7-noiorshy
o
in c az e s
n l
~~
Aa
J -Ir1O
~44--
d loo to cIdu1e~ L -al emu-L)1 b a4444oa 1J i ~~ l--iO
c~u~ 11 )_2~ 2 0OJanot
Dio 11 mCtlCcLOxr OJ n v
i1i 4-1 )_
V
nLla t o n
x nm
4
4
c
6i pl
IRCl 4 n1 n V V
i17 $ 42lv
CofiUsnc1
--shy L~s~otoojn b4
cnfrece all
t 3-4A44~C--
hg p4pqtin of
tr0inperj- iIdnt~Li ntConoeu4Y X e V 4
u~~~-a lou 1
~ ~ ~ 4 ~
4
tho tcdovolop-mentl of Pan e cect~rc machiinery4 forthe1o ecdufat0ion and for4a~S~l on a continui bai the
niAZ oafo v
LT
At
4 Alea-ve
of o co-tin --
drojgtout grac repatitio land c
hic by7 anr xlj the a- 0idntv ti1u(h to bo de~rd~Gri-shyd shol~fu ub an intE-ua pat o
hi1nc ih 1~Ic~~o nr~ In rio aneiiatlo~ 2ydeeo- i~
OfA44Jllit n O4a at o4xam 44
pr M s U -- L
dnaticn alu~ec ntuet
v1e oi -iuiUu~~er L-3trictont
_l uti L -n 44o
(oCnji~poundr ~n~i~ni
1477port Third PL Qnal Con7a e cshyo 4 --3 4 P
shy
4 -~ ~4 - 44VV43p
kl- Cp 31p4a _ T 4~n o- ~
4 7424pi
~ -4 4~lt
6
4 77 4
I 81J
~ n
JY
444
h F1~~V011V-i~m)ya3ofOuet
- -MA
4 u
c u -- a - ao 4((A voi co~t111 nl t ororc -4- 44i44
d~44 4~~44~~4~4
djr4444n 44 u otP-00 (Yt O aos n
I Iitu shy
r a)-raIthm-- eh
ndfore -ou So4 as
~ ~ v at~aoi$ib~aoi8imampT m~~ t r4 411A-tio i h abe b4 - wi iie
S~~~V a I icau i1~ic
e ~~filhi O tdlS 4 ~ ~ ~ oqecL andh ~ th
4)1 ~ 4-1411-1~ o~be~ ~ 1 mlbi viuCLO2Ul Dt rtlfiP1111
c i l
lw r6 -tr cnb~~~ tf2 ~~~~ ~ ~ ~ b-~~~~t co~ i nt~rro ojtvnab ~ci~e~~
-~t~i~w ~ ~ ~iVtiot~catdc-~
tcr Cdo4 g C-a n l hg rampthdi1uh3 401 0- c a y i
t~ d
-z-~7~~ cost flCe1~ ~--
aa~ha~g K2-atnaampit~rB~U~-~v02 nojaJ rl-4 bt)o 1i
as tcjwainJcvatso isD6t iampifwt htof lbprta
urie oli achleavaiuaeto iSurh meansure ao usualc y -a is-c
an4- t Q)- A
-- ----ao
-Lr
cZ a no--shy4~ 4c
-Ala-~1610
Y Ln-ob 0
c Cn ereo~m - - 9-I
anld dveX~ 12b fljt l
i ~unat ~ O ~ ri- -10f~ ~ 9jiOr( r LO(v) j 0- f ui1Ahht~C~~tiwCdfLo^ ir
O~ r-si~ tc- uvc O tciaicn in vie oicny
0y ator sy on lxgcr- tcaampi c CTshyoitnm tnonvcay A~ilf-iea~e v a~nd cocia1 iiiamp=anfco oppO II
UO9 sshy
-~-~- - ~-b~at the quaity of thoro i~ho hold cortificatev
tha1oi da o d~roDushoaliaJo be su t tor0 shyu 993 9UP
o9 m- o icr n9Inaucon
9 2
cushy
ml m~6v )c~ar
f-~ C) LJri Z)~u )
vc C r 71 shy
TG- 0111 u
(b)Scol D3 or- (re U 17-
-i C ntatoi e~ic~ S~c~illum~ 6A -J-Oq
-OfIhstrurz ton cl qpro ss1 g obecti-miamp Jishy~e1doogiesWO(ii
- ~~---- -rt~cl to studei -lv1p2nve tachrV f~s
~$ ~iv) Lrolcveift 7ad--Ttati oi aUdIo-vismn1 Mdia prga d
7ial r7 a w t7ni
4 7 7
iv
t
(rii)~~~~~~
of
~
uoclc
Iff C 7
~
ediULACCampJOLU
- i4
~--~~
I~lCosu3ai
1shy
~d
a1O
I
41~3~rh
W~=12X
Ul
I -
I II~I~i
ti-vos~~~~~~~~~~~~r oo-t ~
anacdU
t
ied iltio
alfe-tlh 0 in iC ar
(1) cj ptvo-a~~ i1tof 4 ex c-~1~r gtI1~f
441444Y14141iII4 outputs
c- v1 t-cD-cc aniti lo 1~f
1 5-
61k
kc oj -i
-u
-7C
Ushy
fc l CI r V- 4 Tv U
~uIT p1 iPobTZ U 0-p atoao 4u L 1) )c
odcvI n o t (S
~ W-
spie- Mt irm (0 ) of-110
UNITED STATES GOVERNMENT
Memorandum TO AATAPM - Mr David Mathiasen DATmrebrUs~y 21 1973
FROM TAEIM - John F i ard
SUBJECT OYB Funding for TAEHR Projects
We have been advised that the funding for the proposed new GTS project Education Outputs Measurement (total $225000 6f which $150000 is scheduled for FY 1973 and $75000 for FY 1974) is inadequate to meet the contractors budget (Georgetown University $252000) We therefore want to shift $27000 to this project from the $2500O allotted for the Educational Technology Field Support Project reducing the FY 1973 fumnding
level for the latter to $223000
TAEHRRSchmedingsd
Bs US Savings Bonds Replarly on the PayrollSavings Plan I
-MR47
h4 Z
_ __b ~~~OfX 1-plusmnlfl 6 1 ~ LCz U ~ 1 C
~~eci1co~neo h Ae11t tbOUITS at~oLciic nst uLiona The r---otft ~T 2 bC
~vUX~b of rmoj cct aceozfiur E3chedJe bo1e
P d J IA V I - -T
L hY 6ar
-AI be 5h - t i~c T ins u ion odbe hae i
nos j -c goeren the cllbornti or11 moreover tiCth iw0ver tLfo wy fCo1 ~o -ve c1et-cng et b h 10b
ti~oacan vcih~ nsr i ~dctIt i~sonne2-Jriao h
L rtA~a tl~at 0h b Coitrctr 220 5 h a Up th intiLn01tro 1fC hi C C1it1c
m- 3f i yoriy itiLaon w1it- atica3 iteducaicn1 1-71 Cary0th
o the mroiucpo ~rtL VIJ ttterjet
ou fot-biU beo idntife dCton advplusmni hve iolpsx tnr~gC-it1in srshysetox czuia22 nsef of teio~rt~cisiaditnthe
poundecn ~r~~oferiduyc oi whs conwshym~m0 prtcprogrinmc 1y 5 2-a a V c t1-nL1t6
tnu theddcL Ox fino2-tl~b Ccn aoinbofre yUSR~~~1ona1Onrato rLeaz IrAl~p~on-Dlie
vmn rr J0 ~~i~~1 ~APy O
)fltht manCn~L~lr
n momtl
V C4
7~or 00 eso
~L7-O
C 2
VXO742-gOOw
40 -
8~i
Mh
-axtgt1)i
n-r
e a
--shy 1 y
betwee Us VTrAXLir D~estilnte5dY ~ X L0
0C-her ConsViant trave) mid par d~ri vr00 i~oub-Totalt
25O0VF 50
Tranvelt~~shy
j~2j~Forboth 4
S 4
=d I)C offices -
-~~ -~- ~ ~n2--000
~ 3
ftA0verb -~0Vshy-Mall
7 - N
e hsre ~ t o~ a il~
ng g
~
e r o r an em s pound 1px
~~ e ne d poundor 3 ~e n t o 3-I4e uzvU~ a u tj o ncz~esed ra
etuti-Is~o nt On Nort Th a ea
Pr
Ps c- T
~ns On 4he ore ~h thc skia-r s n a i n
I neti e ) -ch ~ earerSof cer t J
t eIe h )lSihas t oi poundR-4_ ethasr~h~~Lrm2tc soni Prqie~ri- thsrcns on ed~ ht ~ ~~~to~7 ecamcvesic iacre-ea ts ofdu J 6 at L6e~Oneen d c t a t 0 t
el t 11p1aydref Omu-ts ean1gth s c es c 0 _J-r atqundat giad aeshret he e o svf(re u ar e ~Ait1J~~gransothe phleel -an onA ecevra
1 b ipernasons eterjcje_ the~~
a1mand pe oniis av ~h calLlatons af 0t-poundrt~n Creflofe tan ft r
css onditions- astered ciigh6an eTh cScp lme a nt id tocn toe
IJ t vi~br~ a s te yo r e u
r u w rn 1 d d ollclo s ~ ~ 1 ~~~int A
n C l u at o s t f ric r e l ~ ne erVaLuesv_60 ra he es tr t h gh t~ ticaddede andftdetermiZnJation educa 0~~i6t27 edu(7romatii~ ati f ra
EvLICt elaluation utu o - A i i ntt~ct beo madhtca -hthd soji hsonetins n requiresth e~tasa outhuil c) y o1wchebsznniafji ost~c~ prdcin rCeintoeolionize avauc thI sch s itn cae poduc at -e1 l prd hei prco
ln10Md -achpu~ij ed[n4tg
IMIS
~~ ~ t~ 6~ s~ffe f Fnil nr r F E71I
s 0or ate ~ frcou cI secre c D~oi thex rdci~avt-~ g711sructi 1n
6 U le ratavel3y untrained teac er curren Jyaaa e~~ora erse ih e mryd e0nb TScin oC Min)
gIrtof thibereduc -shy trarc ec rSc h e
avaf_ be as for example oru lit DytO~fSUPer_shyZ9~~1de vsor and chagsi scculI -Tirdt I-ri e among edcinal
OUtpu1its can~be r3eordered so~ thi the education~ productio rcesT~ ~ ofo~ those y-ie - figh1 -Us E oe ithbscsseL Uene urcncrcd
bVe reahzl througnh iivc stent in-s~na _10opp 1 - ochn1ia1 vci~oi9lto hgheedaib hioaonveAmcril intne ond
coiidr edUcation b (r o r Vestme 1t11igcnrIrc)roiid r (dutio
SAll of these concer1)ed witth the matter (d Snt~crnal ofDic cY)ncyr e I 10 to the product or output ofthtIeducationial~sy stem i an d to bctc cvaludlte Vi zIM output i-to provide a Mor usPefuJ_ beic imark for -mprovrjng_-yStOm efficiencyl
cth~ iwords l eII and a plusmn i ~ ictp y~~ esi~md need to 1know f the value of t 1e outputs has beei erih~ncedamp gt
-ofererpcc to svlttem efficiency is in )mrtan~tfor po di igoom n -~in shy
dta41costs lin O-Cra u n o ratc iofn programS- c CBeUoation is 1CIIL-Lnre rigly -larger 0--rcntages of ni Uih1bid~imperati~ dis n~cce
t - learn if the money being speit is producing desired- resuits and doing so is econr-n4cally as possible
On the other hanid wdth reeec oh bene6fits edacation measzes -are needed to better inform us if inv~estmnents in education are compettivee41ithj~ alternative investments in other sector~s One coznhci~si~n ofrte-freunstudie ~ in scveral countries is that returnsto education in most Cases Cx returns fo ot 1plusmnr k r~is of investments the payoff for ilinvesting in men seems to be higrner~ tha tratl for investinri inYrnzchinest What is rieededAampispoundurther- rfinerit o6f
measures to helpD us detcermine 1which typcs of cogitie i~-aamph-b ~ mastn prodes the highest yieldl- or pay-off in the mrkt--1hc A~dit on-
allyjwo canproft from better Pnsiireqf the aititd~~ S- ohascrr I thl~m) and the exteritto which such-attituides affect succesi laiif~n
~~~ro~tiero rance injbai ~ ~doi ing moden health~ ititio6nal and poundawmily~ planning practices and asuigm r sponsibe izen~larip3le
puppesofoitut vauaaoexpert in the f ield Sugge s+ that t atr fsse efficincy impli~sthatsonie formof$ measurement instruments
can cFrae th itaI d s(adgous
~ ~i~aio~~)Aexprience rFurther eprtssurgFY ha iteasres of- ~its sufficient i ormato a eotie rl E (ucatona C1cifiputsS6 eesr~ eseniay2))4Isin he sus
uein D-ote iec hdtathees1sof meCrn edc14p~C uef i an -iec- Itl
-a etrr ionopound -Fansr th-ogh edluca -on5-sQfo at nF toepor b-g 0go hndingi iampJ
Spat-Qrai up)ward p ~ec s~ etcot cnb ~L~iiampe l n a C I 4 Qben Peaheemno orirsaidta ents innnco ivareas opound 1vhZ Ir c)I-sued
~iTh prnstI e c veityave1b~ 4wt 1 -aespe and1 mil Wou ut2n_es i djehooJhge
the b)sduc forma t lio cirrdbook__Y la tedd i Wpa~ryic~i~~a v~ltt~Jkainahd si ta ofl respc o oth us a on r~e-irc rjidin to he pag 1 0 aieioritdon meth2 d i 2A
Cou idDC plFn St- at lshycrctcticV
1 Im~eeto Pln Seej attached RT Chrir L- ~shy
OC1urse of~Action Tiie CUSCplusmnO0_ rp3entativ es o~ti~IC with astn aas t- geniceiS ill which th FA a- cptd led Lo -the deampelophin 0O~
apr oposal by the International -istituteforEducationaJ Plling Paris propJosal received by us in~Novemnber l971lprojectedan interntionalns 1n~~-on out-Frts evaluation forJuly 1973f 1rith pre-paia g etiiiparis onamp~sectJz uarv 2973 The proposali enVisaged full represntaton of LDC oa~ti cimtr(5toLC eds ate ymposium should be fuly reF~
Siibsequent discussions with thampII-TE P led to the ~conclusibn oniour partthat the IIP1woul~d not have sufficientL staCC shyto 6ranz and carry b6ut thear 44proposed project anid it was Telt that mor Sharpened anid substaitiy--wor cwouija of outputs evaluat ion this focusiig of fort wsotc prvddritielE
-proposal Moreover AIDIF plolicy of inore directly engaging LD n titio n - -4t1 +chnlcal assistance Projects an engagehient we did 4notT6e 1plusmn~coujampd bo ataie 4 -through the IMP~ activity lead us~ to 4 eevL t a mu dijcc~
4and shiould be fLoril t ed r 4 ~ i~~ shy
4~
Moile centrllyaod scstsraivelvw tr tani morecentaU~nd sb~~~j~r~byarraanging for-a CoJlaborativp- undertinofLDCa titition withthe US instLti
het pjchs riuebee wit m e brso the Task o aa~mci~i ts dgr z ben iec poundrnHrad ri7ayedcLan~
1~ ~ orr~t nolectvida dvonry c s onu bpan ~~UV
on5-nbr 2 ofi-1r wi- jexprr-tilnto cof7 ynPany CIp-Ite ~c Cofl a
to ~ ~cteyoand~ ds~1 __
trbduing pierivh~ meho eaFun- leel-snev f ontit-s1Tr LDs f d ren I typb of
ed cation~an 11yzind Strrlgthdan6i wa sse s an shiowIig me- 0 cI u~ e~pT4~Suu6hi Ththod C) coyp n-ne~poundLDCOeducaticnalof ndor ocshy
~CieweV reseac sc to~e~d the papers an rihe relevce fLIN -1othefri rethz~ds of 6upit1is9ialuatlTh presenit (3 the Coiferccf vwulds~ gg tjn for needo highP
e-v~~~rirt aluinAri1o- cepiI euo 2thS~eL researchproj ectsdeemed to have hi~ghes priority e
The roject shoulJd be designed to rqaent r h 1 ot m 2XAr~ pJshpan is gien here The iirstf~ i-tsen to the
r~gtd~l~fiat o ad ra-ment of coll)a ~ ~ i ~i~tiitiop- 0tnd~wti s--C b et y~i rctsonand aettii gct~r iw~~~~rtolyig 5 or tiiig t perI a V(iactio th thidnic t cb tande itt t Ioii-ii there~e mon hswou2 d PAbe 16o1
-al ii lor ri a yrddnl-thse _nd preparaticn of sevzeral prodt~cts iinb1 ampscrabang-difiirr6iitl-iitoylyjJ4
-easzrement metchodologies projet and1 cofercnicefancamp reportsiia set of dconlresearch ~deigns and a plan forh noSt effectiVe dseMaicn fe1hndc4k nvovng such posibiities as a series of regi6hal seirnarr6the cxr5iiz -tion ofIt travelin- sem~inar N~ is ipratthat th-isdisseivintdoi plahn adressat leayst these two questions )How can the handbook b~i dis~tributed Thitirj~ly
fahin2) How with a reasonable degree of certainty can we get-copies- of the~ hpabook into the hands of tho~eLDC eople who can make bcstuseoIt9 This SeCol~a ut~rt is essentia1ly the question of audience Inasmuch as the han~dbook isi-Lendcieto be an inforinationcl resource for LDCPeducaticn dc ison ekIe~1pLanners~jy
ma ranagers i E vifal ihat th~kinds of Vorac uitaoner6 haveaccess to the
G Scial Mani6mentProwsijon
Linsclecting the LDC organizationwith which it oroposes t- 1abo r t he US orgaiiizai n (Contractor)Shall notify-thi PoetMnce of
AIWA who0shall take the necessary~stepsto obtain RcgioItn IBureau andUSAID ampapprc 1 for the inVolement of the LDC or aflization The wor1kiing out of final
arrangements between the two collaboatii organizations Shallbecontingentshyupon ~re C61pt ofILsuch apprboval
~p ~ ~ J-
Vgt~
k T
DoCr(ioriton-n
Pro-c s A grt
64 DO unvriy
On--~ u ~
1 S Ieu P Te -w-- ran 4 z-
15--C~~nHndok k
C (r-- planinshy
-D-) Io confrenc r 03on
(B) ~~ 2f ~ar ~ ~ FiaAll-boo draft ----- -4~Y
6 (C D) Wo~~~~~0rkoncnrrner orP- -i c
9 (F)lFinal projecth reot
Pro- 6 dd -
------- j Woc ocoia
9T-e ~(F 1Proect report-nan Ci Ca-~f6-l -yad+a
Vp A- J
etal 4-1
0 shy
0lfl~
~0
-44h
~ d
~ -
4
r~sg
h
4
--I ca
4
44
)4
~K~
v j
T to4
to4 ~
)4 I ~~ 6Y
~
W
9-
V
~~
~~
~
E
~4
7K
IOr4
cisect
L~
n
4444~
~
o44w
44444
u4
4K
tV
4
44
shyX
4
444
4bo4
4~
I
C9~-)1U
444
~~4-444-~~ tr
-
I Il 13 0I
r 5
4
44A
44~
~~
~
c 0
01-1 r4
iM
L
J l
4 jr-~
i-
-
~(Jw~y
444
4
oil54 G
aJ
44
4-
C)1
04-1[ 5
H H
~
n 4
I
0r4 4
3444444
~~
94
~ 4
3
~
(l~
4
lb
-r-
4 ~
LtC
I4 ~~~~~~~
Cl
9
tr
i~~
444
~
U
4 t3A9 C
I ~~
in
44
~)4 4
~ 4 ( U
~4
4 4
~ 4
it5
4 4
)4j
J4
414K
-i4~ 4
4
3
44T
CQ
U
-t
4 7-1
~
1A
2fJ
4
~f
d4444
4~
I 4
44440
~
04
~
~
~~
-~a
i ci
0~
~
~
44444 ~
U
44
~ ~
CL
4 -
4~~ 44~
~~
~~
4~
t
gL 44 4
4
44 5
449 ~41
~~
~
-~
~
~~
04 0
44444444444444
rFP
-~5~1444
amp
t+oj
44
4~
7~
-
~ ~
tz tn
G
- D
)Q
co
i 444
U41
i4
j~_j
0 g
tz44~
444A
4 j449f
~~
4
i~(4~
lt 0-vr~
U(
~ ~
24
tj 4
2
4ii~
~~
0
~~414 4
44 4
44
~ 34
(7r4
-4
~~4444~~~~4 4 p~
~~
~C
A 4
4J )1
4
444
4
4
4
4
4444
W
H
10
4 4~44iC
Ocl0r13
~44444~
474
4~U
4~~
V-
444
44
~
2 4 0 4~ C
~
~
4
44 ~
44
444
4~ Hl
~Y
T-4
4
4
4M
Y
4
-44
PriWZampATC L0IbTP
C~~l~1~~ F~~ F R~~~ OE T VA U T iWCVUP
Cl x~ )13 0ec i Oof0e o onl 2d1 uctgo (fa0c 1 L 6 ) md aQ ~ ~ S ~ ~ Eu- L~inr~i
SiUcL a~i~tzix dotoB ~ i~I -
~ woopo~o~ eu YQ50 oojrarchv fOr qua1Jitative~ im~~~iV 2~VG~eard tyDpeo 0oudc1tio
-a among oCn thee nrb
3) i-h
9~ ~tamp a $~a
Arab CN4
Atjh flziobi Go~neroccon TL3 10 _ lTbo causesJ of tbOd VixS~t(euc 6antd Varie-dl ltTIh L tnampt of0 te zWocjuoyo
rc~11an gven~tetshavor aJrob iached the 3lzit ~OL Vhbapoundiobail2SL Cr Bu I Or ts byaIhiriaJ is o rieanr
V31ropily o 1iso alsogt to n oncTh liutlitioL blawed6i 12 Ofnnn[ ___
(p (Fuca1
~~~~~ ~~ M a~0prPz~ l~~lo)c d onthe iieed t~a~ f~0Cetv t a
of the clneat f~cacod byr educa-L6til~ ai ofn~n orzn t he
-- -9
Co ruo~~ 5t ~ n oIis~ehri
oT L v3 r) at ~cn
Dj
p~o~~r~X ryc
i
L-oof t r
44-
1 a
0111A Ofa4iC
~~~iooIy -ght 1A)
c i r
01
b 6
in 10 7-noiorshy
o
in c az e s
n l
~~
Aa
J -Ir1O
~44--
d loo to cIdu1e~ L -al emu-L)1 b a4444oa 1J i ~~ l--iO
c~u~ 11 )_2~ 2 0OJanot
Dio 11 mCtlCcLOxr OJ n v
i1i 4-1 )_
V
nLla t o n
x nm
4
4
c
6i pl
IRCl 4 n1 n V V
i17 $ 42lv
CofiUsnc1
--shy L~s~otoojn b4
cnfrece all
t 3-4A44~C--
hg p4pqtin of
tr0inperj- iIdnt~Li ntConoeu4Y X e V 4
u~~~-a lou 1
~ ~ ~ 4 ~
4
tho tcdovolop-mentl of Pan e cect~rc machiinery4 forthe1o ecdufat0ion and for4a~S~l on a continui bai the
niAZ oafo v
LT
At
4 Alea-ve
of o co-tin --
drojgtout grac repatitio land c
hic by7 anr xlj the a- 0idntv ti1u(h to bo de~rd~Gri-shyd shol~fu ub an intE-ua pat o
hi1nc ih 1~Ic~~o nr~ In rio aneiiatlo~ 2ydeeo- i~
OfA44Jllit n O4a at o4xam 44
pr M s U -- L
dnaticn alu~ec ntuet
v1e oi -iuiUu~~er L-3trictont
_l uti L -n 44o
(oCnji~poundr ~n~i~ni
1477port Third PL Qnal Con7a e cshyo 4 --3 4 P
shy
4 -~ ~4 - 44VV43p
kl- Cp 31p4a _ T 4~n o- ~
4 7424pi
~ -4 4~lt
6
4 77 4
I 81J
~ n
JY
444
h F1~~V011V-i~m)ya3ofOuet
- -MA
4 u
c u -- a - ao 4((A voi co~t111 nl t ororc -4- 44i44
d~44 4~~44~~4~4
djr4444n 44 u otP-00 (Yt O aos n
I Iitu shy
r a)-raIthm-- eh
ndfore -ou So4 as
~ ~ v at~aoi$ib~aoi8imampT m~~ t r4 411A-tio i h abe b4 - wi iie
S~~~V a I icau i1~ic
e ~~filhi O tdlS 4 ~ ~ ~ oqecL andh ~ th
4)1 ~ 4-1411-1~ o~be~ ~ 1 mlbi viuCLO2Ul Dt rtlfiP1111
c i l
lw r6 -tr cnb~~~ tf2 ~~~~ ~ ~ ~ b-~~~~t co~ i nt~rro ojtvnab ~ci~e~~
-~t~i~w ~ ~ ~iVtiot~catdc-~
tcr Cdo4 g C-a n l hg rampthdi1uh3 401 0- c a y i
t~ d
-z-~7~~ cost flCe1~ ~--
aa~ha~g K2-atnaampit~rB~U~-~v02 nojaJ rl-4 bt)o 1i
as tcjwainJcvatso isD6t iampifwt htof lbprta
urie oli achleavaiuaeto iSurh meansure ao usualc y -a is-c
an4- t Q)- A
-- ----ao
-Lr
cZ a no--shy4~ 4c
-Ala-~1610
Y Ln-ob 0
c Cn ereo~m - - 9-I
anld dveX~ 12b fljt l
i ~unat ~ O ~ ri- -10f~ ~ 9jiOr( r LO(v) j 0- f ui1Ahht~C~~tiwCdfLo^ ir
O~ r-si~ tc- uvc O tciaicn in vie oicny
0y ator sy on lxgcr- tcaampi c CTshyoitnm tnonvcay A~ilf-iea~e v a~nd cocia1 iiiamp=anfco oppO II
UO9 sshy
-~-~- - ~-b~at the quaity of thoro i~ho hold cortificatev
tha1oi da o d~roDushoaliaJo be su t tor0 shyu 993 9UP
o9 m- o icr n9Inaucon
9 2
cushy
ml m~6v )c~ar
f-~ C) LJri Z)~u )
vc C r 71 shy
TG- 0111 u
(b)Scol D3 or- (re U 17-
-i C ntatoi e~ic~ S~c~illum~ 6A -J-Oq
-OfIhstrurz ton cl qpro ss1 g obecti-miamp Jishy~e1doogiesWO(ii
- ~~---- -rt~cl to studei -lv1p2nve tachrV f~s
~$ ~iv) Lrolcveift 7ad--Ttati oi aUdIo-vismn1 Mdia prga d
7ial r7 a w t7ni
4 7 7
iv
t
(rii)~~~~~~
of
~
uoclc
Iff C 7
~
ediULACCampJOLU
- i4
~--~~
I~lCosu3ai
1shy
~d
a1O
I
41~3~rh
W~=12X
Ul
I -
I II~I~i
ti-vos~~~~~~~~~~~~r oo-t ~
anacdU
t
ied iltio
alfe-tlh 0 in iC ar
(1) cj ptvo-a~~ i1tof 4 ex c-~1~r gtI1~f
441444Y14141iII4 outputs
c- v1 t-cD-cc aniti lo 1~f
1 5-
61k
kc oj -i
-u
-7C
Ushy
fc l CI r V- 4 Tv U
~uIT p1 iPobTZ U 0-p atoao 4u L 1) )c
odcvI n o t (S
~ W-
spie- Mt irm (0 ) of-110
UNITED STATES GOVERNMENT
Memorandum TO AATAPM - Mr David Mathiasen DATmrebrUs~y 21 1973
FROM TAEIM - John F i ard
SUBJECT OYB Funding for TAEHR Projects
We have been advised that the funding for the proposed new GTS project Education Outputs Measurement (total $225000 6f which $150000 is scheduled for FY 1973 and $75000 for FY 1974) is inadequate to meet the contractors budget (Georgetown University $252000) We therefore want to shift $27000 to this project from the $2500O allotted for the Educational Technology Field Support Project reducing the FY 1973 fumnding
level for the latter to $223000
TAEHRRSchmedingsd
Bs US Savings Bonds Replarly on the PayrollSavings Plan I
vmn rr J0 ~~i~~1 ~APy O
)fltht manCn~L~lr
n momtl
V C4
7~or 00 eso
~L7-O
C 2
VXO742-gOOw
40 -
8~i
Mh
-axtgt1)i
n-r
e a
--shy 1 y
betwee Us VTrAXLir D~estilnte5dY ~ X L0
0C-her ConsViant trave) mid par d~ri vr00 i~oub-Totalt
25O0VF 50
Tranvelt~~shy
j~2j~Forboth 4
S 4
=d I)C offices -
-~~ -~- ~ ~n2--000
~ 3
ftA0verb -~0Vshy-Mall
7 - N
e hsre ~ t o~ a il~
ng g
~
e r o r an em s pound 1px
~~ e ne d poundor 3 ~e n t o 3-I4e uzvU~ a u tj o ncz~esed ra
etuti-Is~o nt On Nort Th a ea
Pr
Ps c- T
~ns On 4he ore ~h thc skia-r s n a i n
I neti e ) -ch ~ earerSof cer t J
t eIe h )lSihas t oi poundR-4_ ethasr~h~~Lrm2tc soni Prqie~ri- thsrcns on ed~ ht ~ ~~~to~7 ecamcvesic iacre-ea ts ofdu J 6 at L6e~Oneen d c t a t 0 t
el t 11p1aydref Omu-ts ean1gth s c es c 0 _J-r atqundat giad aeshret he e o svf(re u ar e ~Ait1J~~gransothe phleel -an onA ecevra
1 b ipernasons eterjcje_ the~~
a1mand pe oniis av ~h calLlatons af 0t-poundrt~n Creflofe tan ft r
css onditions- astered ciigh6an eTh cScp lme a nt id tocn toe
IJ t vi~br~ a s te yo r e u
r u w rn 1 d d ollclo s ~ ~ 1 ~~~int A
n C l u at o s t f ric r e l ~ ne erVaLuesv_60 ra he es tr t h gh t~ ticaddede andftdetermiZnJation educa 0~~i6t27 edu(7romatii~ ati f ra
EvLICt elaluation utu o - A i i ntt~ct beo madhtca -hthd soji hsonetins n requiresth e~tasa outhuil c) y o1wchebsznniafji ost~c~ prdcin rCeintoeolionize avauc thI sch s itn cae poduc at -e1 l prd hei prco
ln10Md -achpu~ij ed[n4tg
IMIS
~~ ~ t~ 6~ s~ffe f Fnil nr r F E71I
s 0or ate ~ frcou cI secre c D~oi thex rdci~avt-~ g711sructi 1n
6 U le ratavel3y untrained teac er curren Jyaaa e~~ora erse ih e mryd e0nb TScin oC Min)
gIrtof thibereduc -shy trarc ec rSc h e
avaf_ be as for example oru lit DytO~fSUPer_shyZ9~~1de vsor and chagsi scculI -Tirdt I-ri e among edcinal
OUtpu1its can~be r3eordered so~ thi the education~ productio rcesT~ ~ ofo~ those y-ie - figh1 -Us E oe ithbscsseL Uene urcncrcd
bVe reahzl througnh iivc stent in-s~na _10opp 1 - ochn1ia1 vci~oi9lto hgheedaib hioaonveAmcril intne ond
coiidr edUcation b (r o r Vestme 1t11igcnrIrc)roiid r (dutio
SAll of these concer1)ed witth the matter (d Snt~crnal ofDic cY)ncyr e I 10 to the product or output ofthtIeducationial~sy stem i an d to bctc cvaludlte Vi zIM output i-to provide a Mor usPefuJ_ beic imark for -mprovrjng_-yStOm efficiencyl
cth~ iwords l eII and a plusmn i ~ ictp y~~ esi~md need to 1know f the value of t 1e outputs has beei erih~ncedamp gt
-ofererpcc to svlttem efficiency is in )mrtan~tfor po di igoom n -~in shy
dta41costs lin O-Cra u n o ratc iofn programS- c CBeUoation is 1CIIL-Lnre rigly -larger 0--rcntages of ni Uih1bid~imperati~ dis n~cce
t - learn if the money being speit is producing desired- resuits and doing so is econr-n4cally as possible
On the other hanid wdth reeec oh bene6fits edacation measzes -are needed to better inform us if inv~estmnents in education are compettivee41ithj~ alternative investments in other sector~s One coznhci~si~n ofrte-freunstudie ~ in scveral countries is that returnsto education in most Cases Cx returns fo ot 1plusmnr k r~is of investments the payoff for ilinvesting in men seems to be higrner~ tha tratl for investinri inYrnzchinest What is rieededAampispoundurther- rfinerit o6f
measures to helpD us detcermine 1which typcs of cogitie i~-aamph-b ~ mastn prodes the highest yieldl- or pay-off in the mrkt--1hc A~dit on-
allyjwo canproft from better Pnsiireqf the aititd~~ S- ohascrr I thl~m) and the exteritto which such-attituides affect succesi laiif~n
~~~ro~tiero rance injbai ~ ~doi ing moden health~ ititio6nal and poundawmily~ planning practices and asuigm r sponsibe izen~larip3le
puppesofoitut vauaaoexpert in the f ield Sugge s+ that t atr fsse efficincy impli~sthatsonie formof$ measurement instruments
can cFrae th itaI d s(adgous
~ ~i~aio~~)Aexprience rFurther eprtssurgFY ha iteasres of- ~its sufficient i ormato a eotie rl E (ucatona C1cifiputsS6 eesr~ eseniay2))4Isin he sus
uein D-ote iec hdtathees1sof meCrn edc14p~C uef i an -iec- Itl
-a etrr ionopound -Fansr th-ogh edluca -on5-sQfo at nF toepor b-g 0go hndingi iampJ
Spat-Qrai up)ward p ~ec s~ etcot cnb ~L~iiampe l n a C I 4 Qben Peaheemno orirsaidta ents innnco ivareas opound 1vhZ Ir c)I-sued
~iTh prnstI e c veityave1b~ 4wt 1 -aespe and1 mil Wou ut2n_es i djehooJhge
the b)sduc forma t lio cirrdbook__Y la tedd i Wpa~ryic~i~~a v~ltt~Jkainahd si ta ofl respc o oth us a on r~e-irc rjidin to he pag 1 0 aieioritdon meth2 d i 2A
Cou idDC plFn St- at lshycrctcticV
1 Im~eeto Pln Seej attached RT Chrir L- ~shy
OC1urse of~Action Tiie CUSCplusmnO0_ rp3entativ es o~ti~IC with astn aas t- geniceiS ill which th FA a- cptd led Lo -the deampelophin 0O~
apr oposal by the International -istituteforEducationaJ Plling Paris propJosal received by us in~Novemnber l971lprojectedan interntionalns 1n~~-on out-Frts evaluation forJuly 1973f 1rith pre-paia g etiiiparis onamp~sectJz uarv 2973 The proposali enVisaged full represntaton of LDC oa~ti cimtr(5toLC eds ate ymposium should be fuly reF~
Siibsequent discussions with thampII-TE P led to the ~conclusibn oniour partthat the IIP1woul~d not have sufficientL staCC shyto 6ranz and carry b6ut thear 44proposed project anid it was Telt that mor Sharpened anid substaitiy--wor cwouija of outputs evaluat ion this focusiig of fort wsotc prvddritielE
-proposal Moreover AIDIF plolicy of inore directly engaging LD n titio n - -4t1 +chnlcal assistance Projects an engagehient we did 4notT6e 1plusmn~coujampd bo ataie 4 -through the IMP~ activity lead us~ to 4 eevL t a mu dijcc~
4and shiould be fLoril t ed r 4 ~ i~~ shy
4~
Moile centrllyaod scstsraivelvw tr tani morecentaU~nd sb~~~j~r~byarraanging for-a CoJlaborativp- undertinofLDCa titition withthe US instLti
het pjchs riuebee wit m e brso the Task o aa~mci~i ts dgr z ben iec poundrnHrad ri7ayedcLan~
1~ ~ orr~t nolectvida dvonry c s onu bpan ~~UV
on5-nbr 2 ofi-1r wi- jexprr-tilnto cof7 ynPany CIp-Ite ~c Cofl a
to ~ ~cteyoand~ ds~1 __
trbduing pierivh~ meho eaFun- leel-snev f ontit-s1Tr LDs f d ren I typb of
ed cation~an 11yzind Strrlgthdan6i wa sse s an shiowIig me- 0 cI u~ e~pT4~Suu6hi Ththod C) coyp n-ne~poundLDCOeducaticnalof ndor ocshy
~CieweV reseac sc to~e~d the papers an rihe relevce fLIN -1othefri rethz~ds of 6upit1is9ialuatlTh presenit (3 the Coiferccf vwulds~ gg tjn for needo highP
e-v~~~rirt aluinAri1o- cepiI euo 2thS~eL researchproj ectsdeemed to have hi~ghes priority e
The roject shoulJd be designed to rqaent r h 1 ot m 2XAr~ pJshpan is gien here The iirstf~ i-tsen to the
r~gtd~l~fiat o ad ra-ment of coll)a ~ ~ i ~i~tiitiop- 0tnd~wti s--C b et y~i rctsonand aettii gct~r iw~~~~rtolyig 5 or tiiig t perI a V(iactio th thidnic t cb tande itt t Ioii-ii there~e mon hswou2 d PAbe 16o1
-al ii lor ri a yrddnl-thse _nd preparaticn of sevzeral prodt~cts iinb1 ampscrabang-difiirr6iitl-iitoylyjJ4
-easzrement metchodologies projet and1 cofercnicefancamp reportsiia set of dconlresearch ~deigns and a plan forh noSt effectiVe dseMaicn fe1hndc4k nvovng such posibiities as a series of regi6hal seirnarr6the cxr5iiz -tion ofIt travelin- sem~inar N~ is ipratthat th-isdisseivintdoi plahn adressat leayst these two questions )How can the handbook b~i dis~tributed Thitirj~ly
fahin2) How with a reasonable degree of certainty can we get-copies- of the~ hpabook into the hands of tho~eLDC eople who can make bcstuseoIt9 This SeCol~a ut~rt is essentia1ly the question of audience Inasmuch as the han~dbook isi-Lendcieto be an inforinationcl resource for LDCPeducaticn dc ison ekIe~1pLanners~jy
ma ranagers i E vifal ihat th~kinds of Vorac uitaoner6 haveaccess to the
G Scial Mani6mentProwsijon
Linsclecting the LDC organizationwith which it oroposes t- 1abo r t he US orgaiiizai n (Contractor)Shall notify-thi PoetMnce of
AIWA who0shall take the necessary~stepsto obtain RcgioItn IBureau andUSAID ampapprc 1 for the inVolement of the LDC or aflization The wor1kiing out of final
arrangements between the two collaboatii organizations Shallbecontingentshyupon ~re C61pt ofILsuch apprboval
~p ~ ~ J-
Vgt~
k T
DoCr(ioriton-n
Pro-c s A grt
64 DO unvriy
On--~ u ~
1 S Ieu P Te -w-- ran 4 z-
15--C~~nHndok k
C (r-- planinshy
-D-) Io confrenc r 03on
(B) ~~ 2f ~ar ~ ~ FiaAll-boo draft ----- -4~Y
6 (C D) Wo~~~~~0rkoncnrrner orP- -i c
9 (F)lFinal projecth reot
Pro- 6 dd -
------- j Woc ocoia
9T-e ~(F 1Proect report-nan Ci Ca-~f6-l -yad+a
Vp A- J
etal 4-1
0 shy
0lfl~
~0
-44h
~ d
~ -
4
r~sg
h
4
--I ca
4
44
)4
~K~
v j
T to4
to4 ~
)4 I ~~ 6Y
~
W
9-
V
~~
~~
~
E
~4
7K
IOr4
cisect
L~
n
4444~
~
o44w
44444
u4
4K
tV
4
44
shyX
4
444
4bo4
4~
I
C9~-)1U
444
~~4-444-~~ tr
-
I Il 13 0I
r 5
4
44A
44~
~~
~
c 0
01-1 r4
iM
L
J l
4 jr-~
i-
-
~(Jw~y
444
4
oil54 G
aJ
44
4-
C)1
04-1[ 5
H H
~
n 4
I
0r4 4
3444444
~~
94
~ 4
3
~
(l~
4
lb
-r-
4 ~
LtC
I4 ~~~~~~~
Cl
9
tr
i~~
444
~
U
4 t3A9 C
I ~~
in
44
~)4 4
~ 4 ( U
~4
4 4
~ 4
it5
4 4
)4j
J4
414K
-i4~ 4
4
3
44T
CQ
U
-t
4 7-1
~
1A
2fJ
4
~f
d4444
4~
I 4
44440
~
04
~
~
~~
-~a
i ci
0~
~
~
44444 ~
U
44
~ ~
CL
4 -
4~~ 44~
~~
~~
4~
t
gL 44 4
4
44 5
449 ~41
~~
~
-~
~
~~
04 0
44444444444444
rFP
-~5~1444
amp
t+oj
44
4~
7~
-
~ ~
tz tn
G
- D
)Q
co
i 444
U41
i4
j~_j
0 g
tz44~
444A
4 j449f
~~
4
i~(4~
lt 0-vr~
U(
~ ~
24
tj 4
2
4ii~
~~
0
~~414 4
44 4
44
~ 34
(7r4
-4
~~4444~~~~4 4 p~
~~
~C
A 4
4J )1
4
444
4
4
4
4
4444
W
H
10
4 4~44iC
Ocl0r13
~44444~
474
4~U
4~~
V-
444
44
~
2 4 0 4~ C
~
~
4
44 ~
44
444
4~ Hl
~Y
T-4
4
4
4M
Y
4
-44
PriWZampATC L0IbTP
C~~l~1~~ F~~ F R~~~ OE T VA U T iWCVUP
Cl x~ )13 0ec i Oof0e o onl 2d1 uctgo (fa0c 1 L 6 ) md aQ ~ ~ S ~ ~ Eu- L~inr~i
SiUcL a~i~tzix dotoB ~ i~I -
~ woopo~o~ eu YQ50 oojrarchv fOr qua1Jitative~ im~~~iV 2~VG~eard tyDpeo 0oudc1tio
-a among oCn thee nrb
3) i-h
9~ ~tamp a $~a
Arab CN4
Atjh flziobi Go~neroccon TL3 10 _ lTbo causesJ of tbOd VixS~t(euc 6antd Varie-dl ltTIh L tnampt of0 te zWocjuoyo
rc~11an gven~tetshavor aJrob iached the 3lzit ~OL Vhbapoundiobail2SL Cr Bu I Or ts byaIhiriaJ is o rieanr
V31ropily o 1iso alsogt to n oncTh liutlitioL blawed6i 12 Ofnnn[ ___
(p (Fuca1
~~~~~ ~~ M a~0prPz~ l~~lo)c d onthe iieed t~a~ f~0Cetv t a
of the clneat f~cacod byr educa-L6til~ ai ofn~n orzn t he
-- -9
Co ruo~~ 5t ~ n oIis~ehri
oT L v3 r) at ~cn
Dj
p~o~~r~X ryc
i
L-oof t r
44-
1 a
0111A Ofa4iC
~~~iooIy -ght 1A)
c i r
01
b 6
in 10 7-noiorshy
o
in c az e s
n l
~~
Aa
J -Ir1O
~44--
d loo to cIdu1e~ L -al emu-L)1 b a4444oa 1J i ~~ l--iO
c~u~ 11 )_2~ 2 0OJanot
Dio 11 mCtlCcLOxr OJ n v
i1i 4-1 )_
V
nLla t o n
x nm
4
4
c
6i pl
IRCl 4 n1 n V V
i17 $ 42lv
CofiUsnc1
--shy L~s~otoojn b4
cnfrece all
t 3-4A44~C--
hg p4pqtin of
tr0inperj- iIdnt~Li ntConoeu4Y X e V 4
u~~~-a lou 1
~ ~ ~ 4 ~
4
tho tcdovolop-mentl of Pan e cect~rc machiinery4 forthe1o ecdufat0ion and for4a~S~l on a continui bai the
niAZ oafo v
LT
At
4 Alea-ve
of o co-tin --
drojgtout grac repatitio land c
hic by7 anr xlj the a- 0idntv ti1u(h to bo de~rd~Gri-shyd shol~fu ub an intE-ua pat o
hi1nc ih 1~Ic~~o nr~ In rio aneiiatlo~ 2ydeeo- i~
OfA44Jllit n O4a at o4xam 44
pr M s U -- L
dnaticn alu~ec ntuet
v1e oi -iuiUu~~er L-3trictont
_l uti L -n 44o
(oCnji~poundr ~n~i~ni
1477port Third PL Qnal Con7a e cshyo 4 --3 4 P
shy
4 -~ ~4 - 44VV43p
kl- Cp 31p4a _ T 4~n o- ~
4 7424pi
~ -4 4~lt
6
4 77 4
I 81J
~ n
JY
444
h F1~~V011V-i~m)ya3ofOuet
- -MA
4 u
c u -- a - ao 4((A voi co~t111 nl t ororc -4- 44i44
d~44 4~~44~~4~4
djr4444n 44 u otP-00 (Yt O aos n
I Iitu shy
r a)-raIthm-- eh
ndfore -ou So4 as
~ ~ v at~aoi$ib~aoi8imampT m~~ t r4 411A-tio i h abe b4 - wi iie
S~~~V a I icau i1~ic
e ~~filhi O tdlS 4 ~ ~ ~ oqecL andh ~ th
4)1 ~ 4-1411-1~ o~be~ ~ 1 mlbi viuCLO2Ul Dt rtlfiP1111
c i l
lw r6 -tr cnb~~~ tf2 ~~~~ ~ ~ ~ b-~~~~t co~ i nt~rro ojtvnab ~ci~e~~
-~t~i~w ~ ~ ~iVtiot~catdc-~
tcr Cdo4 g C-a n l hg rampthdi1uh3 401 0- c a y i
t~ d
-z-~7~~ cost flCe1~ ~--
aa~ha~g K2-atnaampit~rB~U~-~v02 nojaJ rl-4 bt)o 1i
as tcjwainJcvatso isD6t iampifwt htof lbprta
urie oli achleavaiuaeto iSurh meansure ao usualc y -a is-c
an4- t Q)- A
-- ----ao
-Lr
cZ a no--shy4~ 4c
-Ala-~1610
Y Ln-ob 0
c Cn ereo~m - - 9-I
anld dveX~ 12b fljt l
i ~unat ~ O ~ ri- -10f~ ~ 9jiOr( r LO(v) j 0- f ui1Ahht~C~~tiwCdfLo^ ir
O~ r-si~ tc- uvc O tciaicn in vie oicny
0y ator sy on lxgcr- tcaampi c CTshyoitnm tnonvcay A~ilf-iea~e v a~nd cocia1 iiiamp=anfco oppO II
UO9 sshy
-~-~- - ~-b~at the quaity of thoro i~ho hold cortificatev
tha1oi da o d~roDushoaliaJo be su t tor0 shyu 993 9UP
o9 m- o icr n9Inaucon
9 2
cushy
ml m~6v )c~ar
f-~ C) LJri Z)~u )
vc C r 71 shy
TG- 0111 u
(b)Scol D3 or- (re U 17-
-i C ntatoi e~ic~ S~c~illum~ 6A -J-Oq
-OfIhstrurz ton cl qpro ss1 g obecti-miamp Jishy~e1doogiesWO(ii
- ~~---- -rt~cl to studei -lv1p2nve tachrV f~s
~$ ~iv) Lrolcveift 7ad--Ttati oi aUdIo-vismn1 Mdia prga d
7ial r7 a w t7ni
4 7 7
iv
t
(rii)~~~~~~
of
~
uoclc
Iff C 7
~
ediULACCampJOLU
- i4
~--~~
I~lCosu3ai
1shy
~d
a1O
I
41~3~rh
W~=12X
Ul
I -
I II~I~i
ti-vos~~~~~~~~~~~~r oo-t ~
anacdU
t
ied iltio
alfe-tlh 0 in iC ar
(1) cj ptvo-a~~ i1tof 4 ex c-~1~r gtI1~f
441444Y14141iII4 outputs
c- v1 t-cD-cc aniti lo 1~f
1 5-
61k
kc oj -i
-u
-7C
Ushy
fc l CI r V- 4 Tv U
~uIT p1 iPobTZ U 0-p atoao 4u L 1) )c
odcvI n o t (S
~ W-
spie- Mt irm (0 ) of-110
UNITED STATES GOVERNMENT
Memorandum TO AATAPM - Mr David Mathiasen DATmrebrUs~y 21 1973
FROM TAEIM - John F i ard
SUBJECT OYB Funding for TAEHR Projects
We have been advised that the funding for the proposed new GTS project Education Outputs Measurement (total $225000 6f which $150000 is scheduled for FY 1973 and $75000 for FY 1974) is inadequate to meet the contractors budget (Georgetown University $252000) We therefore want to shift $27000 to this project from the $2500O allotted for the Educational Technology Field Support Project reducing the FY 1973 fumnding
level for the latter to $223000
TAEHRRSchmedingsd
Bs US Savings Bonds Replarly on the PayrollSavings Plan I
7 - N
e hsre ~ t o~ a il~
ng g
~
e r o r an em s pound 1px
~~ e ne d poundor 3 ~e n t o 3-I4e uzvU~ a u tj o ncz~esed ra
etuti-Is~o nt On Nort Th a ea
Pr
Ps c- T
~ns On 4he ore ~h thc skia-r s n a i n
I neti e ) -ch ~ earerSof cer t J
t eIe h )lSihas t oi poundR-4_ ethasr~h~~Lrm2tc soni Prqie~ri- thsrcns on ed~ ht ~ ~~~to~7 ecamcvesic iacre-ea ts ofdu J 6 at L6e~Oneen d c t a t 0 t
el t 11p1aydref Omu-ts ean1gth s c es c 0 _J-r atqundat giad aeshret he e o svf(re u ar e ~Ait1J~~gransothe phleel -an onA ecevra
1 b ipernasons eterjcje_ the~~
a1mand pe oniis av ~h calLlatons af 0t-poundrt~n Creflofe tan ft r
css onditions- astered ciigh6an eTh cScp lme a nt id tocn toe
IJ t vi~br~ a s te yo r e u
r u w rn 1 d d ollclo s ~ ~ 1 ~~~int A
n C l u at o s t f ric r e l ~ ne erVaLuesv_60 ra he es tr t h gh t~ ticaddede andftdetermiZnJation educa 0~~i6t27 edu(7romatii~ ati f ra
EvLICt elaluation utu o - A i i ntt~ct beo madhtca -hthd soji hsonetins n requiresth e~tasa outhuil c) y o1wchebsznniafji ost~c~ prdcin rCeintoeolionize avauc thI sch s itn cae poduc at -e1 l prd hei prco
ln10Md -achpu~ij ed[n4tg
IMIS
~~ ~ t~ 6~ s~ffe f Fnil nr r F E71I
s 0or ate ~ frcou cI secre c D~oi thex rdci~avt-~ g711sructi 1n
6 U le ratavel3y untrained teac er curren Jyaaa e~~ora erse ih e mryd e0nb TScin oC Min)
gIrtof thibereduc -shy trarc ec rSc h e
avaf_ be as for example oru lit DytO~fSUPer_shyZ9~~1de vsor and chagsi scculI -Tirdt I-ri e among edcinal
OUtpu1its can~be r3eordered so~ thi the education~ productio rcesT~ ~ ofo~ those y-ie - figh1 -Us E oe ithbscsseL Uene urcncrcd
bVe reahzl througnh iivc stent in-s~na _10opp 1 - ochn1ia1 vci~oi9lto hgheedaib hioaonveAmcril intne ond
coiidr edUcation b (r o r Vestme 1t11igcnrIrc)roiid r (dutio
SAll of these concer1)ed witth the matter (d Snt~crnal ofDic cY)ncyr e I 10 to the product or output ofthtIeducationial~sy stem i an d to bctc cvaludlte Vi zIM output i-to provide a Mor usPefuJ_ beic imark for -mprovrjng_-yStOm efficiencyl
cth~ iwords l eII and a plusmn i ~ ictp y~~ esi~md need to 1know f the value of t 1e outputs has beei erih~ncedamp gt
-ofererpcc to svlttem efficiency is in )mrtan~tfor po di igoom n -~in shy
dta41costs lin O-Cra u n o ratc iofn programS- c CBeUoation is 1CIIL-Lnre rigly -larger 0--rcntages of ni Uih1bid~imperati~ dis n~cce
t - learn if the money being speit is producing desired- resuits and doing so is econr-n4cally as possible
On the other hanid wdth reeec oh bene6fits edacation measzes -are needed to better inform us if inv~estmnents in education are compettivee41ithj~ alternative investments in other sector~s One coznhci~si~n ofrte-freunstudie ~ in scveral countries is that returnsto education in most Cases Cx returns fo ot 1plusmnr k r~is of investments the payoff for ilinvesting in men seems to be higrner~ tha tratl for investinri inYrnzchinest What is rieededAampispoundurther- rfinerit o6f
measures to helpD us detcermine 1which typcs of cogitie i~-aamph-b ~ mastn prodes the highest yieldl- or pay-off in the mrkt--1hc A~dit on-
allyjwo canproft from better Pnsiireqf the aititd~~ S- ohascrr I thl~m) and the exteritto which such-attituides affect succesi laiif~n
~~~ro~tiero rance injbai ~ ~doi ing moden health~ ititio6nal and poundawmily~ planning practices and asuigm r sponsibe izen~larip3le
puppesofoitut vauaaoexpert in the f ield Sugge s+ that t atr fsse efficincy impli~sthatsonie formof$ measurement instruments
can cFrae th itaI d s(adgous
~ ~i~aio~~)Aexprience rFurther eprtssurgFY ha iteasres of- ~its sufficient i ormato a eotie rl E (ucatona C1cifiputsS6 eesr~ eseniay2))4Isin he sus
uein D-ote iec hdtathees1sof meCrn edc14p~C uef i an -iec- Itl
-a etrr ionopound -Fansr th-ogh edluca -on5-sQfo at nF toepor b-g 0go hndingi iampJ
Spat-Qrai up)ward p ~ec s~ etcot cnb ~L~iiampe l n a C I 4 Qben Peaheemno orirsaidta ents innnco ivareas opound 1vhZ Ir c)I-sued
~iTh prnstI e c veityave1b~ 4wt 1 -aespe and1 mil Wou ut2n_es i djehooJhge
the b)sduc forma t lio cirrdbook__Y la tedd i Wpa~ryic~i~~a v~ltt~Jkainahd si ta ofl respc o oth us a on r~e-irc rjidin to he pag 1 0 aieioritdon meth2 d i 2A
Cou idDC plFn St- at lshycrctcticV
1 Im~eeto Pln Seej attached RT Chrir L- ~shy
OC1urse of~Action Tiie CUSCplusmnO0_ rp3entativ es o~ti~IC with astn aas t- geniceiS ill which th FA a- cptd led Lo -the deampelophin 0O~
apr oposal by the International -istituteforEducationaJ Plling Paris propJosal received by us in~Novemnber l971lprojectedan interntionalns 1n~~-on out-Frts evaluation forJuly 1973f 1rith pre-paia g etiiiparis onamp~sectJz uarv 2973 The proposali enVisaged full represntaton of LDC oa~ti cimtr(5toLC eds ate ymposium should be fuly reF~
Siibsequent discussions with thampII-TE P led to the ~conclusibn oniour partthat the IIP1woul~d not have sufficientL staCC shyto 6ranz and carry b6ut thear 44proposed project anid it was Telt that mor Sharpened anid substaitiy--wor cwouija of outputs evaluat ion this focusiig of fort wsotc prvddritielE
-proposal Moreover AIDIF plolicy of inore directly engaging LD n titio n - -4t1 +chnlcal assistance Projects an engagehient we did 4notT6e 1plusmn~coujampd bo ataie 4 -through the IMP~ activity lead us~ to 4 eevL t a mu dijcc~
4and shiould be fLoril t ed r 4 ~ i~~ shy
4~
Moile centrllyaod scstsraivelvw tr tani morecentaU~nd sb~~~j~r~byarraanging for-a CoJlaborativp- undertinofLDCa titition withthe US instLti
het pjchs riuebee wit m e brso the Task o aa~mci~i ts dgr z ben iec poundrnHrad ri7ayedcLan~
1~ ~ orr~t nolectvida dvonry c s onu bpan ~~UV
on5-nbr 2 ofi-1r wi- jexprr-tilnto cof7 ynPany CIp-Ite ~c Cofl a
to ~ ~cteyoand~ ds~1 __
trbduing pierivh~ meho eaFun- leel-snev f ontit-s1Tr LDs f d ren I typb of
ed cation~an 11yzind Strrlgthdan6i wa sse s an shiowIig me- 0 cI u~ e~pT4~Suu6hi Ththod C) coyp n-ne~poundLDCOeducaticnalof ndor ocshy
~CieweV reseac sc to~e~d the papers an rihe relevce fLIN -1othefri rethz~ds of 6upit1is9ialuatlTh presenit (3 the Coiferccf vwulds~ gg tjn for needo highP
e-v~~~rirt aluinAri1o- cepiI euo 2thS~eL researchproj ectsdeemed to have hi~ghes priority e
The roject shoulJd be designed to rqaent r h 1 ot m 2XAr~ pJshpan is gien here The iirstf~ i-tsen to the
r~gtd~l~fiat o ad ra-ment of coll)a ~ ~ i ~i~tiitiop- 0tnd~wti s--C b et y~i rctsonand aettii gct~r iw~~~~rtolyig 5 or tiiig t perI a V(iactio th thidnic t cb tande itt t Ioii-ii there~e mon hswou2 d PAbe 16o1
-al ii lor ri a yrddnl-thse _nd preparaticn of sevzeral prodt~cts iinb1 ampscrabang-difiirr6iitl-iitoylyjJ4
-easzrement metchodologies projet and1 cofercnicefancamp reportsiia set of dconlresearch ~deigns and a plan forh noSt effectiVe dseMaicn fe1hndc4k nvovng such posibiities as a series of regi6hal seirnarr6the cxr5iiz -tion ofIt travelin- sem~inar N~ is ipratthat th-isdisseivintdoi plahn adressat leayst these two questions )How can the handbook b~i dis~tributed Thitirj~ly
fahin2) How with a reasonable degree of certainty can we get-copies- of the~ hpabook into the hands of tho~eLDC eople who can make bcstuseoIt9 This SeCol~a ut~rt is essentia1ly the question of audience Inasmuch as the han~dbook isi-Lendcieto be an inforinationcl resource for LDCPeducaticn dc ison ekIe~1pLanners~jy
ma ranagers i E vifal ihat th~kinds of Vorac uitaoner6 haveaccess to the
G Scial Mani6mentProwsijon
Linsclecting the LDC organizationwith which it oroposes t- 1abo r t he US orgaiiizai n (Contractor)Shall notify-thi PoetMnce of
AIWA who0shall take the necessary~stepsto obtain RcgioItn IBureau andUSAID ampapprc 1 for the inVolement of the LDC or aflization The wor1kiing out of final
arrangements between the two collaboatii organizations Shallbecontingentshyupon ~re C61pt ofILsuch apprboval
~p ~ ~ J-
Vgt~
k T
DoCr(ioriton-n
Pro-c s A grt
64 DO unvriy
On--~ u ~
1 S Ieu P Te -w-- ran 4 z-
15--C~~nHndok k
C (r-- planinshy
-D-) Io confrenc r 03on
(B) ~~ 2f ~ar ~ ~ FiaAll-boo draft ----- -4~Y
6 (C D) Wo~~~~~0rkoncnrrner orP- -i c
9 (F)lFinal projecth reot
Pro- 6 dd -
------- j Woc ocoia
9T-e ~(F 1Proect report-nan Ci Ca-~f6-l -yad+a
Vp A- J
etal 4-1
0 shy
0lfl~
~0
-44h
~ d
~ -
4
r~sg
h
4
--I ca
4
44
)4
~K~
v j
T to4
to4 ~
)4 I ~~ 6Y
~
W
9-
V
~~
~~
~
E
~4
7K
IOr4
cisect
L~
n
4444~
~
o44w
44444
u4
4K
tV
4
44
shyX
4
444
4bo4
4~
I
C9~-)1U
444
~~4-444-~~ tr
-
I Il 13 0I
r 5
4
44A
44~
~~
~
c 0
01-1 r4
iM
L
J l
4 jr-~
i-
-
~(Jw~y
444
4
oil54 G
aJ
44
4-
C)1
04-1[ 5
H H
~
n 4
I
0r4 4
3444444
~~
94
~ 4
3
~
(l~
4
lb
-r-
4 ~
LtC
I4 ~~~~~~~
Cl
9
tr
i~~
444
~
U
4 t3A9 C
I ~~
in
44
~)4 4
~ 4 ( U
~4
4 4
~ 4
it5
4 4
)4j
J4
414K
-i4~ 4
4
3
44T
CQ
U
-t
4 7-1
~
1A
2fJ
4
~f
d4444
4~
I 4
44440
~
04
~
~
~~
-~a
i ci
0~
~
~
44444 ~
U
44
~ ~
CL
4 -
4~~ 44~
~~
~~
4~
t
gL 44 4
4
44 5
449 ~41
~~
~
-~
~
~~
04 0
44444444444444
rFP
-~5~1444
amp
t+oj
44
4~
7~
-
~ ~
tz tn
G
- D
)Q
co
i 444
U41
i4
j~_j
0 g
tz44~
444A
4 j449f
~~
4
i~(4~
lt 0-vr~
U(
~ ~
24
tj 4
2
4ii~
~~
0
~~414 4
44 4
44
~ 34
(7r4
-4
~~4444~~~~4 4 p~
~~
~C
A 4
4J )1
4
444
4
4
4
4
4444
W
H
10
4 4~44iC
Ocl0r13
~44444~
474
4~U
4~~
V-
444
44
~
2 4 0 4~ C
~
~
4
44 ~
44
444
4~ Hl
~Y
T-4
4
4
4M
Y
4
-44
PriWZampATC L0IbTP
C~~l~1~~ F~~ F R~~~ OE T VA U T iWCVUP
Cl x~ )13 0ec i Oof0e o onl 2d1 uctgo (fa0c 1 L 6 ) md aQ ~ ~ S ~ ~ Eu- L~inr~i
SiUcL a~i~tzix dotoB ~ i~I -
~ woopo~o~ eu YQ50 oojrarchv fOr qua1Jitative~ im~~~iV 2~VG~eard tyDpeo 0oudc1tio
-a among oCn thee nrb
3) i-h
9~ ~tamp a $~a
Arab CN4
Atjh flziobi Go~neroccon TL3 10 _ lTbo causesJ of tbOd VixS~t(euc 6antd Varie-dl ltTIh L tnampt of0 te zWocjuoyo
rc~11an gven~tetshavor aJrob iached the 3lzit ~OL Vhbapoundiobail2SL Cr Bu I Or ts byaIhiriaJ is o rieanr
V31ropily o 1iso alsogt to n oncTh liutlitioL blawed6i 12 Ofnnn[ ___
(p (Fuca1
~~~~~ ~~ M a~0prPz~ l~~lo)c d onthe iieed t~a~ f~0Cetv t a
of the clneat f~cacod byr educa-L6til~ ai ofn~n orzn t he
-- -9
Co ruo~~ 5t ~ n oIis~ehri
oT L v3 r) at ~cn
Dj
p~o~~r~X ryc
i
L-oof t r
44-
1 a
0111A Ofa4iC
~~~iooIy -ght 1A)
c i r
01
b 6
in 10 7-noiorshy
o
in c az e s
n l
~~
Aa
J -Ir1O
~44--
d loo to cIdu1e~ L -al emu-L)1 b a4444oa 1J i ~~ l--iO
c~u~ 11 )_2~ 2 0OJanot
Dio 11 mCtlCcLOxr OJ n v
i1i 4-1 )_
V
nLla t o n
x nm
4
4
c
6i pl
IRCl 4 n1 n V V
i17 $ 42lv
CofiUsnc1
--shy L~s~otoojn b4
cnfrece all
t 3-4A44~C--
hg p4pqtin of
tr0inperj- iIdnt~Li ntConoeu4Y X e V 4
u~~~-a lou 1
~ ~ ~ 4 ~
4
tho tcdovolop-mentl of Pan e cect~rc machiinery4 forthe1o ecdufat0ion and for4a~S~l on a continui bai the
niAZ oafo v
LT
At
4 Alea-ve
of o co-tin --
drojgtout grac repatitio land c
hic by7 anr xlj the a- 0idntv ti1u(h to bo de~rd~Gri-shyd shol~fu ub an intE-ua pat o
hi1nc ih 1~Ic~~o nr~ In rio aneiiatlo~ 2ydeeo- i~
OfA44Jllit n O4a at o4xam 44
pr M s U -- L
dnaticn alu~ec ntuet
v1e oi -iuiUu~~er L-3trictont
_l uti L -n 44o
(oCnji~poundr ~n~i~ni
1477port Third PL Qnal Con7a e cshyo 4 --3 4 P
shy
4 -~ ~4 - 44VV43p
kl- Cp 31p4a _ T 4~n o- ~
4 7424pi
~ -4 4~lt
6
4 77 4
I 81J
~ n
JY
444
h F1~~V011V-i~m)ya3ofOuet
- -MA
4 u
c u -- a - ao 4((A voi co~t111 nl t ororc -4- 44i44
d~44 4~~44~~4~4
djr4444n 44 u otP-00 (Yt O aos n
I Iitu shy
r a)-raIthm-- eh
ndfore -ou So4 as
~ ~ v at~aoi$ib~aoi8imampT m~~ t r4 411A-tio i h abe b4 - wi iie
S~~~V a I icau i1~ic
e ~~filhi O tdlS 4 ~ ~ ~ oqecL andh ~ th
4)1 ~ 4-1411-1~ o~be~ ~ 1 mlbi viuCLO2Ul Dt rtlfiP1111
c i l
lw r6 -tr cnb~~~ tf2 ~~~~ ~ ~ ~ b-~~~~t co~ i nt~rro ojtvnab ~ci~e~~
-~t~i~w ~ ~ ~iVtiot~catdc-~
tcr Cdo4 g C-a n l hg rampthdi1uh3 401 0- c a y i
t~ d
-z-~7~~ cost flCe1~ ~--
aa~ha~g K2-atnaampit~rB~U~-~v02 nojaJ rl-4 bt)o 1i
as tcjwainJcvatso isD6t iampifwt htof lbprta
urie oli achleavaiuaeto iSurh meansure ao usualc y -a is-c
an4- t Q)- A
-- ----ao
-Lr
cZ a no--shy4~ 4c
-Ala-~1610
Y Ln-ob 0
c Cn ereo~m - - 9-I
anld dveX~ 12b fljt l
i ~unat ~ O ~ ri- -10f~ ~ 9jiOr( r LO(v) j 0- f ui1Ahht~C~~tiwCdfLo^ ir
O~ r-si~ tc- uvc O tciaicn in vie oicny
0y ator sy on lxgcr- tcaampi c CTshyoitnm tnonvcay A~ilf-iea~e v a~nd cocia1 iiiamp=anfco oppO II
UO9 sshy
-~-~- - ~-b~at the quaity of thoro i~ho hold cortificatev
tha1oi da o d~roDushoaliaJo be su t tor0 shyu 993 9UP
o9 m- o icr n9Inaucon
9 2
cushy
ml m~6v )c~ar
f-~ C) LJri Z)~u )
vc C r 71 shy
TG- 0111 u
(b)Scol D3 or- (re U 17-
-i C ntatoi e~ic~ S~c~illum~ 6A -J-Oq
-OfIhstrurz ton cl qpro ss1 g obecti-miamp Jishy~e1doogiesWO(ii
- ~~---- -rt~cl to studei -lv1p2nve tachrV f~s
~$ ~iv) Lrolcveift 7ad--Ttati oi aUdIo-vismn1 Mdia prga d
7ial r7 a w t7ni
4 7 7
iv
t
(rii)~~~~~~
of
~
uoclc
Iff C 7
~
ediULACCampJOLU
- i4
~--~~
I~lCosu3ai
1shy
~d
a1O
I
41~3~rh
W~=12X
Ul
I -
I II~I~i
ti-vos~~~~~~~~~~~~r oo-t ~
anacdU
t
ied iltio
alfe-tlh 0 in iC ar
(1) cj ptvo-a~~ i1tof 4 ex c-~1~r gtI1~f
441444Y14141iII4 outputs
c- v1 t-cD-cc aniti lo 1~f
1 5-
61k
kc oj -i
-u
-7C
Ushy
fc l CI r V- 4 Tv U
~uIT p1 iPobTZ U 0-p atoao 4u L 1) )c
odcvI n o t (S
~ W-
spie- Mt irm (0 ) of-110
UNITED STATES GOVERNMENT
Memorandum TO AATAPM - Mr David Mathiasen DATmrebrUs~y 21 1973
FROM TAEIM - John F i ard
SUBJECT OYB Funding for TAEHR Projects
We have been advised that the funding for the proposed new GTS project Education Outputs Measurement (total $225000 6f which $150000 is scheduled for FY 1973 and $75000 for FY 1974) is inadequate to meet the contractors budget (Georgetown University $252000) We therefore want to shift $27000 to this project from the $2500O allotted for the Educational Technology Field Support Project reducing the FY 1973 fumnding
level for the latter to $223000
TAEHRRSchmedingsd
Bs US Savings Bonds Replarly on the PayrollSavings Plan I
IMIS
~~ ~ t~ 6~ s~ffe f Fnil nr r F E71I
s 0or ate ~ frcou cI secre c D~oi thex rdci~avt-~ g711sructi 1n
6 U le ratavel3y untrained teac er curren Jyaaa e~~ora erse ih e mryd e0nb TScin oC Min)
gIrtof thibereduc -shy trarc ec rSc h e
avaf_ be as for example oru lit DytO~fSUPer_shyZ9~~1de vsor and chagsi scculI -Tirdt I-ri e among edcinal
OUtpu1its can~be r3eordered so~ thi the education~ productio rcesT~ ~ ofo~ those y-ie - figh1 -Us E oe ithbscsseL Uene urcncrcd
bVe reahzl througnh iivc stent in-s~na _10opp 1 - ochn1ia1 vci~oi9lto hgheedaib hioaonveAmcril intne ond
coiidr edUcation b (r o r Vestme 1t11igcnrIrc)roiid r (dutio
SAll of these concer1)ed witth the matter (d Snt~crnal ofDic cY)ncyr e I 10 to the product or output ofthtIeducationial~sy stem i an d to bctc cvaludlte Vi zIM output i-to provide a Mor usPefuJ_ beic imark for -mprovrjng_-yStOm efficiencyl
cth~ iwords l eII and a plusmn i ~ ictp y~~ esi~md need to 1know f the value of t 1e outputs has beei erih~ncedamp gt
-ofererpcc to svlttem efficiency is in )mrtan~tfor po di igoom n -~in shy
dta41costs lin O-Cra u n o ratc iofn programS- c CBeUoation is 1CIIL-Lnre rigly -larger 0--rcntages of ni Uih1bid~imperati~ dis n~cce
t - learn if the money being speit is producing desired- resuits and doing so is econr-n4cally as possible
On the other hanid wdth reeec oh bene6fits edacation measzes -are needed to better inform us if inv~estmnents in education are compettivee41ithj~ alternative investments in other sector~s One coznhci~si~n ofrte-freunstudie ~ in scveral countries is that returnsto education in most Cases Cx returns fo ot 1plusmnr k r~is of investments the payoff for ilinvesting in men seems to be higrner~ tha tratl for investinri inYrnzchinest What is rieededAampispoundurther- rfinerit o6f
measures to helpD us detcermine 1which typcs of cogitie i~-aamph-b ~ mastn prodes the highest yieldl- or pay-off in the mrkt--1hc A~dit on-
allyjwo canproft from better Pnsiireqf the aititd~~ S- ohascrr I thl~m) and the exteritto which such-attituides affect succesi laiif~n
~~~ro~tiero rance injbai ~ ~doi ing moden health~ ititio6nal and poundawmily~ planning practices and asuigm r sponsibe izen~larip3le
puppesofoitut vauaaoexpert in the f ield Sugge s+ that t atr fsse efficincy impli~sthatsonie formof$ measurement instruments
can cFrae th itaI d s(adgous
~ ~i~aio~~)Aexprience rFurther eprtssurgFY ha iteasres of- ~its sufficient i ormato a eotie rl E (ucatona C1cifiputsS6 eesr~ eseniay2))4Isin he sus
uein D-ote iec hdtathees1sof meCrn edc14p~C uef i an -iec- Itl
-a etrr ionopound -Fansr th-ogh edluca -on5-sQfo at nF toepor b-g 0go hndingi iampJ
Spat-Qrai up)ward p ~ec s~ etcot cnb ~L~iiampe l n a C I 4 Qben Peaheemno orirsaidta ents innnco ivareas opound 1vhZ Ir c)I-sued
~iTh prnstI e c veityave1b~ 4wt 1 -aespe and1 mil Wou ut2n_es i djehooJhge
the b)sduc forma t lio cirrdbook__Y la tedd i Wpa~ryic~i~~a v~ltt~Jkainahd si ta ofl respc o oth us a on r~e-irc rjidin to he pag 1 0 aieioritdon meth2 d i 2A
Cou idDC plFn St- at lshycrctcticV
1 Im~eeto Pln Seej attached RT Chrir L- ~shy
OC1urse of~Action Tiie CUSCplusmnO0_ rp3entativ es o~ti~IC with astn aas t- geniceiS ill which th FA a- cptd led Lo -the deampelophin 0O~
apr oposal by the International -istituteforEducationaJ Plling Paris propJosal received by us in~Novemnber l971lprojectedan interntionalns 1n~~-on out-Frts evaluation forJuly 1973f 1rith pre-paia g etiiiparis onamp~sectJz uarv 2973 The proposali enVisaged full represntaton of LDC oa~ti cimtr(5toLC eds ate ymposium should be fuly reF~
Siibsequent discussions with thampII-TE P led to the ~conclusibn oniour partthat the IIP1woul~d not have sufficientL staCC shyto 6ranz and carry b6ut thear 44proposed project anid it was Telt that mor Sharpened anid substaitiy--wor cwouija of outputs evaluat ion this focusiig of fort wsotc prvddritielE
-proposal Moreover AIDIF plolicy of inore directly engaging LD n titio n - -4t1 +chnlcal assistance Projects an engagehient we did 4notT6e 1plusmn~coujampd bo ataie 4 -through the IMP~ activity lead us~ to 4 eevL t a mu dijcc~
4and shiould be fLoril t ed r 4 ~ i~~ shy
4~
Moile centrllyaod scstsraivelvw tr tani morecentaU~nd sb~~~j~r~byarraanging for-a CoJlaborativp- undertinofLDCa titition withthe US instLti
het pjchs riuebee wit m e brso the Task o aa~mci~i ts dgr z ben iec poundrnHrad ri7ayedcLan~
1~ ~ orr~t nolectvida dvonry c s onu bpan ~~UV
on5-nbr 2 ofi-1r wi- jexprr-tilnto cof7 ynPany CIp-Ite ~c Cofl a
to ~ ~cteyoand~ ds~1 __
trbduing pierivh~ meho eaFun- leel-snev f ontit-s1Tr LDs f d ren I typb of
ed cation~an 11yzind Strrlgthdan6i wa sse s an shiowIig me- 0 cI u~ e~pT4~Suu6hi Ththod C) coyp n-ne~poundLDCOeducaticnalof ndor ocshy
~CieweV reseac sc to~e~d the papers an rihe relevce fLIN -1othefri rethz~ds of 6upit1is9ialuatlTh presenit (3 the Coiferccf vwulds~ gg tjn for needo highP
e-v~~~rirt aluinAri1o- cepiI euo 2thS~eL researchproj ectsdeemed to have hi~ghes priority e
The roject shoulJd be designed to rqaent r h 1 ot m 2XAr~ pJshpan is gien here The iirstf~ i-tsen to the
r~gtd~l~fiat o ad ra-ment of coll)a ~ ~ i ~i~tiitiop- 0tnd~wti s--C b et y~i rctsonand aettii gct~r iw~~~~rtolyig 5 or tiiig t perI a V(iactio th thidnic t cb tande itt t Ioii-ii there~e mon hswou2 d PAbe 16o1
-al ii lor ri a yrddnl-thse _nd preparaticn of sevzeral prodt~cts iinb1 ampscrabang-difiirr6iitl-iitoylyjJ4
-easzrement metchodologies projet and1 cofercnicefancamp reportsiia set of dconlresearch ~deigns and a plan forh noSt effectiVe dseMaicn fe1hndc4k nvovng such posibiities as a series of regi6hal seirnarr6the cxr5iiz -tion ofIt travelin- sem~inar N~ is ipratthat th-isdisseivintdoi plahn adressat leayst these two questions )How can the handbook b~i dis~tributed Thitirj~ly
fahin2) How with a reasonable degree of certainty can we get-copies- of the~ hpabook into the hands of tho~eLDC eople who can make bcstuseoIt9 This SeCol~a ut~rt is essentia1ly the question of audience Inasmuch as the han~dbook isi-Lendcieto be an inforinationcl resource for LDCPeducaticn dc ison ekIe~1pLanners~jy
ma ranagers i E vifal ihat th~kinds of Vorac uitaoner6 haveaccess to the
G Scial Mani6mentProwsijon
Linsclecting the LDC organizationwith which it oroposes t- 1abo r t he US orgaiiizai n (Contractor)Shall notify-thi PoetMnce of
AIWA who0shall take the necessary~stepsto obtain RcgioItn IBureau andUSAID ampapprc 1 for the inVolement of the LDC or aflization The wor1kiing out of final
arrangements between the two collaboatii organizations Shallbecontingentshyupon ~re C61pt ofILsuch apprboval
~p ~ ~ J-
Vgt~
k T
DoCr(ioriton-n
Pro-c s A grt
64 DO unvriy
On--~ u ~
1 S Ieu P Te -w-- ran 4 z-
15--C~~nHndok k
C (r-- planinshy
-D-) Io confrenc r 03on
(B) ~~ 2f ~ar ~ ~ FiaAll-boo draft ----- -4~Y
6 (C D) Wo~~~~~0rkoncnrrner orP- -i c
9 (F)lFinal projecth reot
Pro- 6 dd -
------- j Woc ocoia
9T-e ~(F 1Proect report-nan Ci Ca-~f6-l -yad+a
Vp A- J
etal 4-1
0 shy
0lfl~
~0
-44h
~ d
~ -
4
r~sg
h
4
--I ca
4
44
)4
~K~
v j
T to4
to4 ~
)4 I ~~ 6Y
~
W
9-
V
~~
~~
~
E
~4
7K
IOr4
cisect
L~
n
4444~
~
o44w
44444
u4
4K
tV
4
44
shyX
4
444
4bo4
4~
I
C9~-)1U
444
~~4-444-~~ tr
-
I Il 13 0I
r 5
4
44A
44~
~~
~
c 0
01-1 r4
iM
L
J l
4 jr-~
i-
-
~(Jw~y
444
4
oil54 G
aJ
44
4-
C)1
04-1[ 5
H H
~
n 4
I
0r4 4
3444444
~~
94
~ 4
3
~
(l~
4
lb
-r-
4 ~
LtC
I4 ~~~~~~~
Cl
9
tr
i~~
444
~
U
4 t3A9 C
I ~~
in
44
~)4 4
~ 4 ( U
~4
4 4
~ 4
it5
4 4
)4j
J4
414K
-i4~ 4
4
3
44T
CQ
U
-t
4 7-1
~
1A
2fJ
4
~f
d4444
4~
I 4
44440
~
04
~
~
~~
-~a
i ci
0~
~
~
44444 ~
U
44
~ ~
CL
4 -
4~~ 44~
~~
~~
4~
t
gL 44 4
4
44 5
449 ~41
~~
~
-~
~
~~
04 0
44444444444444
rFP
-~5~1444
amp
t+oj
44
4~
7~
-
~ ~
tz tn
G
- D
)Q
co
i 444
U41
i4
j~_j
0 g
tz44~
444A
4 j449f
~~
4
i~(4~
lt 0-vr~
U(
~ ~
24
tj 4
2
4ii~
~~
0
~~414 4
44 4
44
~ 34
(7r4
-4
~~4444~~~~4 4 p~
~~
~C
A 4
4J )1
4
444
4
4
4
4
4444
W
H
10
4 4~44iC
Ocl0r13
~44444~
474
4~U
4~~
V-
444
44
~
2 4 0 4~ C
~
~
4
44 ~
44
444
4~ Hl
~Y
T-4
4
4
4M
Y
4
-44
PriWZampATC L0IbTP
C~~l~1~~ F~~ F R~~~ OE T VA U T iWCVUP
Cl x~ )13 0ec i Oof0e o onl 2d1 uctgo (fa0c 1 L 6 ) md aQ ~ ~ S ~ ~ Eu- L~inr~i
SiUcL a~i~tzix dotoB ~ i~I -
~ woopo~o~ eu YQ50 oojrarchv fOr qua1Jitative~ im~~~iV 2~VG~eard tyDpeo 0oudc1tio
-a among oCn thee nrb
3) i-h
9~ ~tamp a $~a
Arab CN4
Atjh flziobi Go~neroccon TL3 10 _ lTbo causesJ of tbOd VixS~t(euc 6antd Varie-dl ltTIh L tnampt of0 te zWocjuoyo
rc~11an gven~tetshavor aJrob iached the 3lzit ~OL Vhbapoundiobail2SL Cr Bu I Or ts byaIhiriaJ is o rieanr
V31ropily o 1iso alsogt to n oncTh liutlitioL blawed6i 12 Ofnnn[ ___
(p (Fuca1
~~~~~ ~~ M a~0prPz~ l~~lo)c d onthe iieed t~a~ f~0Cetv t a
of the clneat f~cacod byr educa-L6til~ ai ofn~n orzn t he
-- -9
Co ruo~~ 5t ~ n oIis~ehri
oT L v3 r) at ~cn
Dj
p~o~~r~X ryc
i
L-oof t r
44-
1 a
0111A Ofa4iC
~~~iooIy -ght 1A)
c i r
01
b 6
in 10 7-noiorshy
o
in c az e s
n l
~~
Aa
J -Ir1O
~44--
d loo to cIdu1e~ L -al emu-L)1 b a4444oa 1J i ~~ l--iO
c~u~ 11 )_2~ 2 0OJanot
Dio 11 mCtlCcLOxr OJ n v
i1i 4-1 )_
V
nLla t o n
x nm
4
4
c
6i pl
IRCl 4 n1 n V V
i17 $ 42lv
CofiUsnc1
--shy L~s~otoojn b4
cnfrece all
t 3-4A44~C--
hg p4pqtin of
tr0inperj- iIdnt~Li ntConoeu4Y X e V 4
u~~~-a lou 1
~ ~ ~ 4 ~
4
tho tcdovolop-mentl of Pan e cect~rc machiinery4 forthe1o ecdufat0ion and for4a~S~l on a continui bai the
niAZ oafo v
LT
At
4 Alea-ve
of o co-tin --
drojgtout grac repatitio land c
hic by7 anr xlj the a- 0idntv ti1u(h to bo de~rd~Gri-shyd shol~fu ub an intE-ua pat o
hi1nc ih 1~Ic~~o nr~ In rio aneiiatlo~ 2ydeeo- i~
OfA44Jllit n O4a at o4xam 44
pr M s U -- L
dnaticn alu~ec ntuet
v1e oi -iuiUu~~er L-3trictont
_l uti L -n 44o
(oCnji~poundr ~n~i~ni
1477port Third PL Qnal Con7a e cshyo 4 --3 4 P
shy
4 -~ ~4 - 44VV43p
kl- Cp 31p4a _ T 4~n o- ~
4 7424pi
~ -4 4~lt
6
4 77 4
I 81J
~ n
JY
444
h F1~~V011V-i~m)ya3ofOuet
- -MA
4 u
c u -- a - ao 4((A voi co~t111 nl t ororc -4- 44i44
d~44 4~~44~~4~4
djr4444n 44 u otP-00 (Yt O aos n
I Iitu shy
r a)-raIthm-- eh
ndfore -ou So4 as
~ ~ v at~aoi$ib~aoi8imampT m~~ t r4 411A-tio i h abe b4 - wi iie
S~~~V a I icau i1~ic
e ~~filhi O tdlS 4 ~ ~ ~ oqecL andh ~ th
4)1 ~ 4-1411-1~ o~be~ ~ 1 mlbi viuCLO2Ul Dt rtlfiP1111
c i l
lw r6 -tr cnb~~~ tf2 ~~~~ ~ ~ ~ b-~~~~t co~ i nt~rro ojtvnab ~ci~e~~
-~t~i~w ~ ~ ~iVtiot~catdc-~
tcr Cdo4 g C-a n l hg rampthdi1uh3 401 0- c a y i
t~ d
-z-~7~~ cost flCe1~ ~--
aa~ha~g K2-atnaampit~rB~U~-~v02 nojaJ rl-4 bt)o 1i
as tcjwainJcvatso isD6t iampifwt htof lbprta
urie oli achleavaiuaeto iSurh meansure ao usualc y -a is-c
an4- t Q)- A
-- ----ao
-Lr
cZ a no--shy4~ 4c
-Ala-~1610
Y Ln-ob 0
c Cn ereo~m - - 9-I
anld dveX~ 12b fljt l
i ~unat ~ O ~ ri- -10f~ ~ 9jiOr( r LO(v) j 0- f ui1Ahht~C~~tiwCdfLo^ ir
O~ r-si~ tc- uvc O tciaicn in vie oicny
0y ator sy on lxgcr- tcaampi c CTshyoitnm tnonvcay A~ilf-iea~e v a~nd cocia1 iiiamp=anfco oppO II
UO9 sshy
-~-~- - ~-b~at the quaity of thoro i~ho hold cortificatev
tha1oi da o d~roDushoaliaJo be su t tor0 shyu 993 9UP
o9 m- o icr n9Inaucon
9 2
cushy
ml m~6v )c~ar
f-~ C) LJri Z)~u )
vc C r 71 shy
TG- 0111 u
(b)Scol D3 or- (re U 17-
-i C ntatoi e~ic~ S~c~illum~ 6A -J-Oq
-OfIhstrurz ton cl qpro ss1 g obecti-miamp Jishy~e1doogiesWO(ii
- ~~---- -rt~cl to studei -lv1p2nve tachrV f~s
~$ ~iv) Lrolcveift 7ad--Ttati oi aUdIo-vismn1 Mdia prga d
7ial r7 a w t7ni
4 7 7
iv
t
(rii)~~~~~~
of
~
uoclc
Iff C 7
~
ediULACCampJOLU
- i4
~--~~
I~lCosu3ai
1shy
~d
a1O
I
41~3~rh
W~=12X
Ul
I -
I II~I~i
ti-vos~~~~~~~~~~~~r oo-t ~
anacdU
t
ied iltio
alfe-tlh 0 in iC ar
(1) cj ptvo-a~~ i1tof 4 ex c-~1~r gtI1~f
441444Y14141iII4 outputs
c- v1 t-cD-cc aniti lo 1~f
1 5-
61k
kc oj -i
-u
-7C
Ushy
fc l CI r V- 4 Tv U
~uIT p1 iPobTZ U 0-p atoao 4u L 1) )c
odcvI n o t (S
~ W-
spie- Mt irm (0 ) of-110
UNITED STATES GOVERNMENT
Memorandum TO AATAPM - Mr David Mathiasen DATmrebrUs~y 21 1973
FROM TAEIM - John F i ard
SUBJECT OYB Funding for TAEHR Projects
We have been advised that the funding for the proposed new GTS project Education Outputs Measurement (total $225000 6f which $150000 is scheduled for FY 1973 and $75000 for FY 1974) is inadequate to meet the contractors budget (Georgetown University $252000) We therefore want to shift $27000 to this project from the $2500O allotted for the Educational Technology Field Support Project reducing the FY 1973 fumnding
level for the latter to $223000
TAEHRRSchmedingsd
Bs US Savings Bonds Replarly on the PayrollSavings Plan I
-a etrr ionopound -Fansr th-ogh edluca -on5-sQfo at nF toepor b-g 0go hndingi iampJ
Spat-Qrai up)ward p ~ec s~ etcot cnb ~L~iiampe l n a C I 4 Qben Peaheemno orirsaidta ents innnco ivareas opound 1vhZ Ir c)I-sued
~iTh prnstI e c veityave1b~ 4wt 1 -aespe and1 mil Wou ut2n_es i djehooJhge
the b)sduc forma t lio cirrdbook__Y la tedd i Wpa~ryic~i~~a v~ltt~Jkainahd si ta ofl respc o oth us a on r~e-irc rjidin to he pag 1 0 aieioritdon meth2 d i 2A
Cou idDC plFn St- at lshycrctcticV
1 Im~eeto Pln Seej attached RT Chrir L- ~shy
OC1urse of~Action Tiie CUSCplusmnO0_ rp3entativ es o~ti~IC with astn aas t- geniceiS ill which th FA a- cptd led Lo -the deampelophin 0O~
apr oposal by the International -istituteforEducationaJ Plling Paris propJosal received by us in~Novemnber l971lprojectedan interntionalns 1n~~-on out-Frts evaluation forJuly 1973f 1rith pre-paia g etiiiparis onamp~sectJz uarv 2973 The proposali enVisaged full represntaton of LDC oa~ti cimtr(5toLC eds ate ymposium should be fuly reF~
Siibsequent discussions with thampII-TE P led to the ~conclusibn oniour partthat the IIP1woul~d not have sufficientL staCC shyto 6ranz and carry b6ut thear 44proposed project anid it was Telt that mor Sharpened anid substaitiy--wor cwouija of outputs evaluat ion this focusiig of fort wsotc prvddritielE
-proposal Moreover AIDIF plolicy of inore directly engaging LD n titio n - -4t1 +chnlcal assistance Projects an engagehient we did 4notT6e 1plusmn~coujampd bo ataie 4 -through the IMP~ activity lead us~ to 4 eevL t a mu dijcc~
4and shiould be fLoril t ed r 4 ~ i~~ shy
4~
Moile centrllyaod scstsraivelvw tr tani morecentaU~nd sb~~~j~r~byarraanging for-a CoJlaborativp- undertinofLDCa titition withthe US instLti
het pjchs riuebee wit m e brso the Task o aa~mci~i ts dgr z ben iec poundrnHrad ri7ayedcLan~
1~ ~ orr~t nolectvida dvonry c s onu bpan ~~UV
on5-nbr 2 ofi-1r wi- jexprr-tilnto cof7 ynPany CIp-Ite ~c Cofl a
to ~ ~cteyoand~ ds~1 __
trbduing pierivh~ meho eaFun- leel-snev f ontit-s1Tr LDs f d ren I typb of
ed cation~an 11yzind Strrlgthdan6i wa sse s an shiowIig me- 0 cI u~ e~pT4~Suu6hi Ththod C) coyp n-ne~poundLDCOeducaticnalof ndor ocshy
~CieweV reseac sc to~e~d the papers an rihe relevce fLIN -1othefri rethz~ds of 6upit1is9ialuatlTh presenit (3 the Coiferccf vwulds~ gg tjn for needo highP
e-v~~~rirt aluinAri1o- cepiI euo 2thS~eL researchproj ectsdeemed to have hi~ghes priority e
The roject shoulJd be designed to rqaent r h 1 ot m 2XAr~ pJshpan is gien here The iirstf~ i-tsen to the
r~gtd~l~fiat o ad ra-ment of coll)a ~ ~ i ~i~tiitiop- 0tnd~wti s--C b et y~i rctsonand aettii gct~r iw~~~~rtolyig 5 or tiiig t perI a V(iactio th thidnic t cb tande itt t Ioii-ii there~e mon hswou2 d PAbe 16o1
-al ii lor ri a yrddnl-thse _nd preparaticn of sevzeral prodt~cts iinb1 ampscrabang-difiirr6iitl-iitoylyjJ4
-easzrement metchodologies projet and1 cofercnicefancamp reportsiia set of dconlresearch ~deigns and a plan forh noSt effectiVe dseMaicn fe1hndc4k nvovng such posibiities as a series of regi6hal seirnarr6the cxr5iiz -tion ofIt travelin- sem~inar N~ is ipratthat th-isdisseivintdoi plahn adressat leayst these two questions )How can the handbook b~i dis~tributed Thitirj~ly
fahin2) How with a reasonable degree of certainty can we get-copies- of the~ hpabook into the hands of tho~eLDC eople who can make bcstuseoIt9 This SeCol~a ut~rt is essentia1ly the question of audience Inasmuch as the han~dbook isi-Lendcieto be an inforinationcl resource for LDCPeducaticn dc ison ekIe~1pLanners~jy
ma ranagers i E vifal ihat th~kinds of Vorac uitaoner6 haveaccess to the
G Scial Mani6mentProwsijon
Linsclecting the LDC organizationwith which it oroposes t- 1abo r t he US orgaiiizai n (Contractor)Shall notify-thi PoetMnce of
AIWA who0shall take the necessary~stepsto obtain RcgioItn IBureau andUSAID ampapprc 1 for the inVolement of the LDC or aflization The wor1kiing out of final
arrangements between the two collaboatii organizations Shallbecontingentshyupon ~re C61pt ofILsuch apprboval
~p ~ ~ J-
Vgt~
k T
DoCr(ioriton-n
Pro-c s A grt
64 DO unvriy
On--~ u ~
1 S Ieu P Te -w-- ran 4 z-
15--C~~nHndok k
C (r-- planinshy
-D-) Io confrenc r 03on
(B) ~~ 2f ~ar ~ ~ FiaAll-boo draft ----- -4~Y
6 (C D) Wo~~~~~0rkoncnrrner orP- -i c
9 (F)lFinal projecth reot
Pro- 6 dd -
------- j Woc ocoia
9T-e ~(F 1Proect report-nan Ci Ca-~f6-l -yad+a
Vp A- J
etal 4-1
0 shy
0lfl~
~0
-44h
~ d
~ -
4
r~sg
h
4
--I ca
4
44
)4
~K~
v j
T to4
to4 ~
)4 I ~~ 6Y
~
W
9-
V
~~
~~
~
E
~4
7K
IOr4
cisect
L~
n
4444~
~
o44w
44444
u4
4K
tV
4
44
shyX
4
444
4bo4
4~
I
C9~-)1U
444
~~4-444-~~ tr
-
I Il 13 0I
r 5
4
44A
44~
~~
~
c 0
01-1 r4
iM
L
J l
4 jr-~
i-
-
~(Jw~y
444
4
oil54 G
aJ
44
4-
C)1
04-1[ 5
H H
~
n 4
I
0r4 4
3444444
~~
94
~ 4
3
~
(l~
4
lb
-r-
4 ~
LtC
I4 ~~~~~~~
Cl
9
tr
i~~
444
~
U
4 t3A9 C
I ~~
in
44
~)4 4
~ 4 ( U
~4
4 4
~ 4
it5
4 4
)4j
J4
414K
-i4~ 4
4
3
44T
CQ
U
-t
4 7-1
~
1A
2fJ
4
~f
d4444
4~
I 4
44440
~
04
~
~
~~
-~a
i ci
0~
~
~
44444 ~
U
44
~ ~
CL
4 -
4~~ 44~
~~
~~
4~
t
gL 44 4
4
44 5
449 ~41
~~
~
-~
~
~~
04 0
44444444444444
rFP
-~5~1444
amp
t+oj
44
4~
7~
-
~ ~
tz tn
G
- D
)Q
co
i 444
U41
i4
j~_j
0 g
tz44~
444A
4 j449f
~~
4
i~(4~
lt 0-vr~
U(
~ ~
24
tj 4
2
4ii~
~~
0
~~414 4
44 4
44
~ 34
(7r4
-4
~~4444~~~~4 4 p~
~~
~C
A 4
4J )1
4
444
4
4
4
4
4444
W
H
10
4 4~44iC
Ocl0r13
~44444~
474
4~U
4~~
V-
444
44
~
2 4 0 4~ C
~
~
4
44 ~
44
444
4~ Hl
~Y
T-4
4
4
4M
Y
4
-44
PriWZampATC L0IbTP
C~~l~1~~ F~~ F R~~~ OE T VA U T iWCVUP
Cl x~ )13 0ec i Oof0e o onl 2d1 uctgo (fa0c 1 L 6 ) md aQ ~ ~ S ~ ~ Eu- L~inr~i
SiUcL a~i~tzix dotoB ~ i~I -
~ woopo~o~ eu YQ50 oojrarchv fOr qua1Jitative~ im~~~iV 2~VG~eard tyDpeo 0oudc1tio
-a among oCn thee nrb
3) i-h
9~ ~tamp a $~a
Arab CN4
Atjh flziobi Go~neroccon TL3 10 _ lTbo causesJ of tbOd VixS~t(euc 6antd Varie-dl ltTIh L tnampt of0 te zWocjuoyo
rc~11an gven~tetshavor aJrob iached the 3lzit ~OL Vhbapoundiobail2SL Cr Bu I Or ts byaIhiriaJ is o rieanr
V31ropily o 1iso alsogt to n oncTh liutlitioL blawed6i 12 Ofnnn[ ___
(p (Fuca1
~~~~~ ~~ M a~0prPz~ l~~lo)c d onthe iieed t~a~ f~0Cetv t a
of the clneat f~cacod byr educa-L6til~ ai ofn~n orzn t he
-- -9
Co ruo~~ 5t ~ n oIis~ehri
oT L v3 r) at ~cn
Dj
p~o~~r~X ryc
i
L-oof t r
44-
1 a
0111A Ofa4iC
~~~iooIy -ght 1A)
c i r
01
b 6
in 10 7-noiorshy
o
in c az e s
n l
~~
Aa
J -Ir1O
~44--
d loo to cIdu1e~ L -al emu-L)1 b a4444oa 1J i ~~ l--iO
c~u~ 11 )_2~ 2 0OJanot
Dio 11 mCtlCcLOxr OJ n v
i1i 4-1 )_
V
nLla t o n
x nm
4
4
c
6i pl
IRCl 4 n1 n V V
i17 $ 42lv
CofiUsnc1
--shy L~s~otoojn b4
cnfrece all
t 3-4A44~C--
hg p4pqtin of
tr0inperj- iIdnt~Li ntConoeu4Y X e V 4
u~~~-a lou 1
~ ~ ~ 4 ~
4
tho tcdovolop-mentl of Pan e cect~rc machiinery4 forthe1o ecdufat0ion and for4a~S~l on a continui bai the
niAZ oafo v
LT
At
4 Alea-ve
of o co-tin --
drojgtout grac repatitio land c
hic by7 anr xlj the a- 0idntv ti1u(h to bo de~rd~Gri-shyd shol~fu ub an intE-ua pat o
hi1nc ih 1~Ic~~o nr~ In rio aneiiatlo~ 2ydeeo- i~
OfA44Jllit n O4a at o4xam 44
pr M s U -- L
dnaticn alu~ec ntuet
v1e oi -iuiUu~~er L-3trictont
_l uti L -n 44o
(oCnji~poundr ~n~i~ni
1477port Third PL Qnal Con7a e cshyo 4 --3 4 P
shy
4 -~ ~4 - 44VV43p
kl- Cp 31p4a _ T 4~n o- ~
4 7424pi
~ -4 4~lt
6
4 77 4
I 81J
~ n
JY
444
h F1~~V011V-i~m)ya3ofOuet
- -MA
4 u
c u -- a - ao 4((A voi co~t111 nl t ororc -4- 44i44
d~44 4~~44~~4~4
djr4444n 44 u otP-00 (Yt O aos n
I Iitu shy
r a)-raIthm-- eh
ndfore -ou So4 as
~ ~ v at~aoi$ib~aoi8imampT m~~ t r4 411A-tio i h abe b4 - wi iie
S~~~V a I icau i1~ic
e ~~filhi O tdlS 4 ~ ~ ~ oqecL andh ~ th
4)1 ~ 4-1411-1~ o~be~ ~ 1 mlbi viuCLO2Ul Dt rtlfiP1111
c i l
lw r6 -tr cnb~~~ tf2 ~~~~ ~ ~ ~ b-~~~~t co~ i nt~rro ojtvnab ~ci~e~~
-~t~i~w ~ ~ ~iVtiot~catdc-~
tcr Cdo4 g C-a n l hg rampthdi1uh3 401 0- c a y i
t~ d
-z-~7~~ cost flCe1~ ~--
aa~ha~g K2-atnaampit~rB~U~-~v02 nojaJ rl-4 bt)o 1i
as tcjwainJcvatso isD6t iampifwt htof lbprta
urie oli achleavaiuaeto iSurh meansure ao usualc y -a is-c
an4- t Q)- A
-- ----ao
-Lr
cZ a no--shy4~ 4c
-Ala-~1610
Y Ln-ob 0
c Cn ereo~m - - 9-I
anld dveX~ 12b fljt l
i ~unat ~ O ~ ri- -10f~ ~ 9jiOr( r LO(v) j 0- f ui1Ahht~C~~tiwCdfLo^ ir
O~ r-si~ tc- uvc O tciaicn in vie oicny
0y ator sy on lxgcr- tcaampi c CTshyoitnm tnonvcay A~ilf-iea~e v a~nd cocia1 iiiamp=anfco oppO II
UO9 sshy
-~-~- - ~-b~at the quaity of thoro i~ho hold cortificatev
tha1oi da o d~roDushoaliaJo be su t tor0 shyu 993 9UP
o9 m- o icr n9Inaucon
9 2
cushy
ml m~6v )c~ar
f-~ C) LJri Z)~u )
vc C r 71 shy
TG- 0111 u
(b)Scol D3 or- (re U 17-
-i C ntatoi e~ic~ S~c~illum~ 6A -J-Oq
-OfIhstrurz ton cl qpro ss1 g obecti-miamp Jishy~e1doogiesWO(ii
- ~~---- -rt~cl to studei -lv1p2nve tachrV f~s
~$ ~iv) Lrolcveift 7ad--Ttati oi aUdIo-vismn1 Mdia prga d
7ial r7 a w t7ni
4 7 7
iv
t
(rii)~~~~~~
of
~
uoclc
Iff C 7
~
ediULACCampJOLU
- i4
~--~~
I~lCosu3ai
1shy
~d
a1O
I
41~3~rh
W~=12X
Ul
I -
I II~I~i
ti-vos~~~~~~~~~~~~r oo-t ~
anacdU
t
ied iltio
alfe-tlh 0 in iC ar
(1) cj ptvo-a~~ i1tof 4 ex c-~1~r gtI1~f
441444Y14141iII4 outputs
c- v1 t-cD-cc aniti lo 1~f
1 5-
61k
kc oj -i
-u
-7C
Ushy
fc l CI r V- 4 Tv U
~uIT p1 iPobTZ U 0-p atoao 4u L 1) )c
odcvI n o t (S
~ W-
spie- Mt irm (0 ) of-110
UNITED STATES GOVERNMENT
Memorandum TO AATAPM - Mr David Mathiasen DATmrebrUs~y 21 1973
FROM TAEIM - John F i ard
SUBJECT OYB Funding for TAEHR Projects
We have been advised that the funding for the proposed new GTS project Education Outputs Measurement (total $225000 6f which $150000 is scheduled for FY 1973 and $75000 for FY 1974) is inadequate to meet the contractors budget (Georgetown University $252000) We therefore want to shift $27000 to this project from the $2500O allotted for the Educational Technology Field Support Project reducing the FY 1973 fumnding
level for the latter to $223000
TAEHRRSchmedingsd
Bs US Savings Bonds Replarly on the PayrollSavings Plan I
1~ ~ orr~t nolectvida dvonry c s onu bpan ~~UV
on5-nbr 2 ofi-1r wi- jexprr-tilnto cof7 ynPany CIp-Ite ~c Cofl a
to ~ ~cteyoand~ ds~1 __
trbduing pierivh~ meho eaFun- leel-snev f ontit-s1Tr LDs f d ren I typb of
ed cation~an 11yzind Strrlgthdan6i wa sse s an shiowIig me- 0 cI u~ e~pT4~Suu6hi Ththod C) coyp n-ne~poundLDCOeducaticnalof ndor ocshy
~CieweV reseac sc to~e~d the papers an rihe relevce fLIN -1othefri rethz~ds of 6upit1is9ialuatlTh presenit (3 the Coiferccf vwulds~ gg tjn for needo highP
e-v~~~rirt aluinAri1o- cepiI euo 2thS~eL researchproj ectsdeemed to have hi~ghes priority e
The roject shoulJd be designed to rqaent r h 1 ot m 2XAr~ pJshpan is gien here The iirstf~ i-tsen to the
r~gtd~l~fiat o ad ra-ment of coll)a ~ ~ i ~i~tiitiop- 0tnd~wti s--C b et y~i rctsonand aettii gct~r iw~~~~rtolyig 5 or tiiig t perI a V(iactio th thidnic t cb tande itt t Ioii-ii there~e mon hswou2 d PAbe 16o1
-al ii lor ri a yrddnl-thse _nd preparaticn of sevzeral prodt~cts iinb1 ampscrabang-difiirr6iitl-iitoylyjJ4
-easzrement metchodologies projet and1 cofercnicefancamp reportsiia set of dconlresearch ~deigns and a plan forh noSt effectiVe dseMaicn fe1hndc4k nvovng such posibiities as a series of regi6hal seirnarr6the cxr5iiz -tion ofIt travelin- sem~inar N~ is ipratthat th-isdisseivintdoi plahn adressat leayst these two questions )How can the handbook b~i dis~tributed Thitirj~ly
fahin2) How with a reasonable degree of certainty can we get-copies- of the~ hpabook into the hands of tho~eLDC eople who can make bcstuseoIt9 This SeCol~a ut~rt is essentia1ly the question of audience Inasmuch as the han~dbook isi-Lendcieto be an inforinationcl resource for LDCPeducaticn dc ison ekIe~1pLanners~jy
ma ranagers i E vifal ihat th~kinds of Vorac uitaoner6 haveaccess to the
G Scial Mani6mentProwsijon
Linsclecting the LDC organizationwith which it oroposes t- 1abo r t he US orgaiiizai n (Contractor)Shall notify-thi PoetMnce of
AIWA who0shall take the necessary~stepsto obtain RcgioItn IBureau andUSAID ampapprc 1 for the inVolement of the LDC or aflization The wor1kiing out of final
arrangements between the two collaboatii organizations Shallbecontingentshyupon ~re C61pt ofILsuch apprboval
~p ~ ~ J-
Vgt~
k T
DoCr(ioriton-n
Pro-c s A grt
64 DO unvriy
On--~ u ~
1 S Ieu P Te -w-- ran 4 z-
15--C~~nHndok k
C (r-- planinshy
-D-) Io confrenc r 03on
(B) ~~ 2f ~ar ~ ~ FiaAll-boo draft ----- -4~Y
6 (C D) Wo~~~~~0rkoncnrrner orP- -i c
9 (F)lFinal projecth reot
Pro- 6 dd -
------- j Woc ocoia
9T-e ~(F 1Proect report-nan Ci Ca-~f6-l -yad+a
Vp A- J
etal 4-1
0 shy
0lfl~
~0
-44h
~ d
~ -
4
r~sg
h
4
--I ca
4
44
)4
~K~
v j
T to4
to4 ~
)4 I ~~ 6Y
~
W
9-
V
~~
~~
~
E
~4
7K
IOr4
cisect
L~
n
4444~
~
o44w
44444
u4
4K
tV
4
44
shyX
4
444
4bo4
4~
I
C9~-)1U
444
~~4-444-~~ tr
-
I Il 13 0I
r 5
4
44A
44~
~~
~
c 0
01-1 r4
iM
L
J l
4 jr-~
i-
-
~(Jw~y
444
4
oil54 G
aJ
44
4-
C)1
04-1[ 5
H H
~
n 4
I
0r4 4
3444444
~~
94
~ 4
3
~
(l~
4
lb
-r-
4 ~
LtC
I4 ~~~~~~~
Cl
9
tr
i~~
444
~
U
4 t3A9 C
I ~~
in
44
~)4 4
~ 4 ( U
~4
4 4
~ 4
it5
4 4
)4j
J4
414K
-i4~ 4
4
3
44T
CQ
U
-t
4 7-1
~
1A
2fJ
4
~f
d4444
4~
I 4
44440
~
04
~
~
~~
-~a
i ci
0~
~
~
44444 ~
U
44
~ ~
CL
4 -
4~~ 44~
~~
~~
4~
t
gL 44 4
4
44 5
449 ~41
~~
~
-~
~
~~
04 0
44444444444444
rFP
-~5~1444
amp
t+oj
44
4~
7~
-
~ ~
tz tn
G
- D
)Q
co
i 444
U41
i4
j~_j
0 g
tz44~
444A
4 j449f
~~
4
i~(4~
lt 0-vr~
U(
~ ~
24
tj 4
2
4ii~
~~
0
~~414 4
44 4
44
~ 34
(7r4
-4
~~4444~~~~4 4 p~
~~
~C
A 4
4J )1
4
444
4
4
4
4
4444
W
H
10
4 4~44iC
Ocl0r13
~44444~
474
4~U
4~~
V-
444
44
~
2 4 0 4~ C
~
~
4
44 ~
44
444
4~ Hl
~Y
T-4
4
4
4M
Y
4
-44
PriWZampATC L0IbTP
C~~l~1~~ F~~ F R~~~ OE T VA U T iWCVUP
Cl x~ )13 0ec i Oof0e o onl 2d1 uctgo (fa0c 1 L 6 ) md aQ ~ ~ S ~ ~ Eu- L~inr~i
SiUcL a~i~tzix dotoB ~ i~I -
~ woopo~o~ eu YQ50 oojrarchv fOr qua1Jitative~ im~~~iV 2~VG~eard tyDpeo 0oudc1tio
-a among oCn thee nrb
3) i-h
9~ ~tamp a $~a
Arab CN4
Atjh flziobi Go~neroccon TL3 10 _ lTbo causesJ of tbOd VixS~t(euc 6antd Varie-dl ltTIh L tnampt of0 te zWocjuoyo
rc~11an gven~tetshavor aJrob iached the 3lzit ~OL Vhbapoundiobail2SL Cr Bu I Or ts byaIhiriaJ is o rieanr
V31ropily o 1iso alsogt to n oncTh liutlitioL blawed6i 12 Ofnnn[ ___
(p (Fuca1
~~~~~ ~~ M a~0prPz~ l~~lo)c d onthe iieed t~a~ f~0Cetv t a
of the clneat f~cacod byr educa-L6til~ ai ofn~n orzn t he
-- -9
Co ruo~~ 5t ~ n oIis~ehri
oT L v3 r) at ~cn
Dj
p~o~~r~X ryc
i
L-oof t r
44-
1 a
0111A Ofa4iC
~~~iooIy -ght 1A)
c i r
01
b 6
in 10 7-noiorshy
o
in c az e s
n l
~~
Aa
J -Ir1O
~44--
d loo to cIdu1e~ L -al emu-L)1 b a4444oa 1J i ~~ l--iO
c~u~ 11 )_2~ 2 0OJanot
Dio 11 mCtlCcLOxr OJ n v
i1i 4-1 )_
V
nLla t o n
x nm
4
4
c
6i pl
IRCl 4 n1 n V V
i17 $ 42lv
CofiUsnc1
--shy L~s~otoojn b4
cnfrece all
t 3-4A44~C--
hg p4pqtin of
tr0inperj- iIdnt~Li ntConoeu4Y X e V 4
u~~~-a lou 1
~ ~ ~ 4 ~
4
tho tcdovolop-mentl of Pan e cect~rc machiinery4 forthe1o ecdufat0ion and for4a~S~l on a continui bai the
niAZ oafo v
LT
At
4 Alea-ve
of o co-tin --
drojgtout grac repatitio land c
hic by7 anr xlj the a- 0idntv ti1u(h to bo de~rd~Gri-shyd shol~fu ub an intE-ua pat o
hi1nc ih 1~Ic~~o nr~ In rio aneiiatlo~ 2ydeeo- i~
OfA44Jllit n O4a at o4xam 44
pr M s U -- L
dnaticn alu~ec ntuet
v1e oi -iuiUu~~er L-3trictont
_l uti L -n 44o
(oCnji~poundr ~n~i~ni
1477port Third PL Qnal Con7a e cshyo 4 --3 4 P
shy
4 -~ ~4 - 44VV43p
kl- Cp 31p4a _ T 4~n o- ~
4 7424pi
~ -4 4~lt
6
4 77 4
I 81J
~ n
JY
444
h F1~~V011V-i~m)ya3ofOuet
- -MA
4 u
c u -- a - ao 4((A voi co~t111 nl t ororc -4- 44i44
d~44 4~~44~~4~4
djr4444n 44 u otP-00 (Yt O aos n
I Iitu shy
r a)-raIthm-- eh
ndfore -ou So4 as
~ ~ v at~aoi$ib~aoi8imampT m~~ t r4 411A-tio i h abe b4 - wi iie
S~~~V a I icau i1~ic
e ~~filhi O tdlS 4 ~ ~ ~ oqecL andh ~ th
4)1 ~ 4-1411-1~ o~be~ ~ 1 mlbi viuCLO2Ul Dt rtlfiP1111
c i l
lw r6 -tr cnb~~~ tf2 ~~~~ ~ ~ ~ b-~~~~t co~ i nt~rro ojtvnab ~ci~e~~
-~t~i~w ~ ~ ~iVtiot~catdc-~
tcr Cdo4 g C-a n l hg rampthdi1uh3 401 0- c a y i
t~ d
-z-~7~~ cost flCe1~ ~--
aa~ha~g K2-atnaampit~rB~U~-~v02 nojaJ rl-4 bt)o 1i
as tcjwainJcvatso isD6t iampifwt htof lbprta
urie oli achleavaiuaeto iSurh meansure ao usualc y -a is-c
an4- t Q)- A
-- ----ao
-Lr
cZ a no--shy4~ 4c
-Ala-~1610
Y Ln-ob 0
c Cn ereo~m - - 9-I
anld dveX~ 12b fljt l
i ~unat ~ O ~ ri- -10f~ ~ 9jiOr( r LO(v) j 0- f ui1Ahht~C~~tiwCdfLo^ ir
O~ r-si~ tc- uvc O tciaicn in vie oicny
0y ator sy on lxgcr- tcaampi c CTshyoitnm tnonvcay A~ilf-iea~e v a~nd cocia1 iiiamp=anfco oppO II
UO9 sshy
-~-~- - ~-b~at the quaity of thoro i~ho hold cortificatev
tha1oi da o d~roDushoaliaJo be su t tor0 shyu 993 9UP
o9 m- o icr n9Inaucon
9 2
cushy
ml m~6v )c~ar
f-~ C) LJri Z)~u )
vc C r 71 shy
TG- 0111 u
(b)Scol D3 or- (re U 17-
-i C ntatoi e~ic~ S~c~illum~ 6A -J-Oq
-OfIhstrurz ton cl qpro ss1 g obecti-miamp Jishy~e1doogiesWO(ii
- ~~---- -rt~cl to studei -lv1p2nve tachrV f~s
~$ ~iv) Lrolcveift 7ad--Ttati oi aUdIo-vismn1 Mdia prga d
7ial r7 a w t7ni
4 7 7
iv
t
(rii)~~~~~~
of
~
uoclc
Iff C 7
~
ediULACCampJOLU
- i4
~--~~
I~lCosu3ai
1shy
~d
a1O
I
41~3~rh
W~=12X
Ul
I -
I II~I~i
ti-vos~~~~~~~~~~~~r oo-t ~
anacdU
t
ied iltio
alfe-tlh 0 in iC ar
(1) cj ptvo-a~~ i1tof 4 ex c-~1~r gtI1~f
441444Y14141iII4 outputs
c- v1 t-cD-cc aniti lo 1~f
1 5-
61k
kc oj -i
-u
-7C
Ushy
fc l CI r V- 4 Tv U
~uIT p1 iPobTZ U 0-p atoao 4u L 1) )c
odcvI n o t (S
~ W-
spie- Mt irm (0 ) of-110
UNITED STATES GOVERNMENT
Memorandum TO AATAPM - Mr David Mathiasen DATmrebrUs~y 21 1973
FROM TAEIM - John F i ard
SUBJECT OYB Funding for TAEHR Projects
We have been advised that the funding for the proposed new GTS project Education Outputs Measurement (total $225000 6f which $150000 is scheduled for FY 1973 and $75000 for FY 1974) is inadequate to meet the contractors budget (Georgetown University $252000) We therefore want to shift $27000 to this project from the $2500O allotted for the Educational Technology Field Support Project reducing the FY 1973 fumnding
level for the latter to $223000
TAEHRRSchmedingsd
Bs US Savings Bonds Replarly on the PayrollSavings Plan I
k T
DoCr(ioriton-n
Pro-c s A grt
64 DO unvriy
On--~ u ~
1 S Ieu P Te -w-- ran 4 z-
15--C~~nHndok k
C (r-- planinshy
-D-) Io confrenc r 03on
(B) ~~ 2f ~ar ~ ~ FiaAll-boo draft ----- -4~Y
6 (C D) Wo~~~~~0rkoncnrrner orP- -i c
9 (F)lFinal projecth reot
Pro- 6 dd -
------- j Woc ocoia
9T-e ~(F 1Proect report-nan Ci Ca-~f6-l -yad+a
Vp A- J
etal 4-1
0 shy
0lfl~
~0
-44h
~ d
~ -
4
r~sg
h
4
--I ca
4
44
)4
~K~
v j
T to4
to4 ~
)4 I ~~ 6Y
~
W
9-
V
~~
~~
~
E
~4
7K
IOr4
cisect
L~
n
4444~
~
o44w
44444
u4
4K
tV
4
44
shyX
4
444
4bo4
4~
I
C9~-)1U
444
~~4-444-~~ tr
-
I Il 13 0I
r 5
4
44A
44~
~~
~
c 0
01-1 r4
iM
L
J l
4 jr-~
i-
-
~(Jw~y
444
4
oil54 G
aJ
44
4-
C)1
04-1[ 5
H H
~
n 4
I
0r4 4
3444444
~~
94
~ 4
3
~
(l~
4
lb
-r-
4 ~
LtC
I4 ~~~~~~~
Cl
9
tr
i~~
444
~
U
4 t3A9 C
I ~~
in
44
~)4 4
~ 4 ( U
~4
4 4
~ 4
it5
4 4
)4j
J4
414K
-i4~ 4
4
3
44T
CQ
U
-t
4 7-1
~
1A
2fJ
4
~f
d4444
4~
I 4
44440
~
04
~
~
~~
-~a
i ci
0~
~
~
44444 ~
U
44
~ ~
CL
4 -
4~~ 44~
~~
~~
4~
t
gL 44 4
4
44 5
449 ~41
~~
~
-~
~
~~
04 0
44444444444444
rFP
-~5~1444
amp
t+oj
44
4~
7~
-
~ ~
tz tn
G
- D
)Q
co
i 444
U41
i4
j~_j
0 g
tz44~
444A
4 j449f
~~
4
i~(4~
lt 0-vr~
U(
~ ~
24
tj 4
2
4ii~
~~
0
~~414 4
44 4
44
~ 34
(7r4
-4
~~4444~~~~4 4 p~
~~
~C
A 4
4J )1
4
444
4
4
4
4
4444
W
H
10
4 4~44iC
Ocl0r13
~44444~
474
4~U
4~~
V-
444
44
~
2 4 0 4~ C
~
~
4
44 ~
44
444
4~ Hl
~Y
T-4
4
4
4M
Y
4
-44
PriWZampATC L0IbTP
C~~l~1~~ F~~ F R~~~ OE T VA U T iWCVUP
Cl x~ )13 0ec i Oof0e o onl 2d1 uctgo (fa0c 1 L 6 ) md aQ ~ ~ S ~ ~ Eu- L~inr~i
SiUcL a~i~tzix dotoB ~ i~I -
~ woopo~o~ eu YQ50 oojrarchv fOr qua1Jitative~ im~~~iV 2~VG~eard tyDpeo 0oudc1tio
-a among oCn thee nrb
3) i-h
9~ ~tamp a $~a
Arab CN4
Atjh flziobi Go~neroccon TL3 10 _ lTbo causesJ of tbOd VixS~t(euc 6antd Varie-dl ltTIh L tnampt of0 te zWocjuoyo
rc~11an gven~tetshavor aJrob iached the 3lzit ~OL Vhbapoundiobail2SL Cr Bu I Or ts byaIhiriaJ is o rieanr
V31ropily o 1iso alsogt to n oncTh liutlitioL blawed6i 12 Ofnnn[ ___
(p (Fuca1
~~~~~ ~~ M a~0prPz~ l~~lo)c d onthe iieed t~a~ f~0Cetv t a
of the clneat f~cacod byr educa-L6til~ ai ofn~n orzn t he
-- -9
Co ruo~~ 5t ~ n oIis~ehri
oT L v3 r) at ~cn
Dj
p~o~~r~X ryc
i
L-oof t r
44-
1 a
0111A Ofa4iC
~~~iooIy -ght 1A)
c i r
01
b 6
in 10 7-noiorshy
o
in c az e s
n l
~~
Aa
J -Ir1O
~44--
d loo to cIdu1e~ L -al emu-L)1 b a4444oa 1J i ~~ l--iO
c~u~ 11 )_2~ 2 0OJanot
Dio 11 mCtlCcLOxr OJ n v
i1i 4-1 )_
V
nLla t o n
x nm
4
4
c
6i pl
IRCl 4 n1 n V V
i17 $ 42lv
CofiUsnc1
--shy L~s~otoojn b4
cnfrece all
t 3-4A44~C--
hg p4pqtin of
tr0inperj- iIdnt~Li ntConoeu4Y X e V 4
u~~~-a lou 1
~ ~ ~ 4 ~
4
tho tcdovolop-mentl of Pan e cect~rc machiinery4 forthe1o ecdufat0ion and for4a~S~l on a continui bai the
niAZ oafo v
LT
At
4 Alea-ve
of o co-tin --
drojgtout grac repatitio land c
hic by7 anr xlj the a- 0idntv ti1u(h to bo de~rd~Gri-shyd shol~fu ub an intE-ua pat o
hi1nc ih 1~Ic~~o nr~ In rio aneiiatlo~ 2ydeeo- i~
OfA44Jllit n O4a at o4xam 44
pr M s U -- L
dnaticn alu~ec ntuet
v1e oi -iuiUu~~er L-3trictont
_l uti L -n 44o
(oCnji~poundr ~n~i~ni
1477port Third PL Qnal Con7a e cshyo 4 --3 4 P
shy
4 -~ ~4 - 44VV43p
kl- Cp 31p4a _ T 4~n o- ~
4 7424pi
~ -4 4~lt
6
4 77 4
I 81J
~ n
JY
444
h F1~~V011V-i~m)ya3ofOuet
- -MA
4 u
c u -- a - ao 4((A voi co~t111 nl t ororc -4- 44i44
d~44 4~~44~~4~4
djr4444n 44 u otP-00 (Yt O aos n
I Iitu shy
r a)-raIthm-- eh
ndfore -ou So4 as
~ ~ v at~aoi$ib~aoi8imampT m~~ t r4 411A-tio i h abe b4 - wi iie
S~~~V a I icau i1~ic
e ~~filhi O tdlS 4 ~ ~ ~ oqecL andh ~ th
4)1 ~ 4-1411-1~ o~be~ ~ 1 mlbi viuCLO2Ul Dt rtlfiP1111
c i l
lw r6 -tr cnb~~~ tf2 ~~~~ ~ ~ ~ b-~~~~t co~ i nt~rro ojtvnab ~ci~e~~
-~t~i~w ~ ~ ~iVtiot~catdc-~
tcr Cdo4 g C-a n l hg rampthdi1uh3 401 0- c a y i
t~ d
-z-~7~~ cost flCe1~ ~--
aa~ha~g K2-atnaampit~rB~U~-~v02 nojaJ rl-4 bt)o 1i
as tcjwainJcvatso isD6t iampifwt htof lbprta
urie oli achleavaiuaeto iSurh meansure ao usualc y -a is-c
an4- t Q)- A
-- ----ao
-Lr
cZ a no--shy4~ 4c
-Ala-~1610
Y Ln-ob 0
c Cn ereo~m - - 9-I
anld dveX~ 12b fljt l
i ~unat ~ O ~ ri- -10f~ ~ 9jiOr( r LO(v) j 0- f ui1Ahht~C~~tiwCdfLo^ ir
O~ r-si~ tc- uvc O tciaicn in vie oicny
0y ator sy on lxgcr- tcaampi c CTshyoitnm tnonvcay A~ilf-iea~e v a~nd cocia1 iiiamp=anfco oppO II
UO9 sshy
-~-~- - ~-b~at the quaity of thoro i~ho hold cortificatev
tha1oi da o d~roDushoaliaJo be su t tor0 shyu 993 9UP
o9 m- o icr n9Inaucon
9 2
cushy
ml m~6v )c~ar
f-~ C) LJri Z)~u )
vc C r 71 shy
TG- 0111 u
(b)Scol D3 or- (re U 17-
-i C ntatoi e~ic~ S~c~illum~ 6A -J-Oq
-OfIhstrurz ton cl qpro ss1 g obecti-miamp Jishy~e1doogiesWO(ii
- ~~---- -rt~cl to studei -lv1p2nve tachrV f~s
~$ ~iv) Lrolcveift 7ad--Ttati oi aUdIo-vismn1 Mdia prga d
7ial r7 a w t7ni
4 7 7
iv
t
(rii)~~~~~~
of
~
uoclc
Iff C 7
~
ediULACCampJOLU
- i4
~--~~
I~lCosu3ai
1shy
~d
a1O
I
41~3~rh
W~=12X
Ul
I -
I II~I~i
ti-vos~~~~~~~~~~~~r oo-t ~
anacdU
t
ied iltio
alfe-tlh 0 in iC ar
(1) cj ptvo-a~~ i1tof 4 ex c-~1~r gtI1~f
441444Y14141iII4 outputs
c- v1 t-cD-cc aniti lo 1~f
1 5-
61k
kc oj -i
-u
-7C
Ushy
fc l CI r V- 4 Tv U
~uIT p1 iPobTZ U 0-p atoao 4u L 1) )c
odcvI n o t (S
~ W-
spie- Mt irm (0 ) of-110
UNITED STATES GOVERNMENT
Memorandum TO AATAPM - Mr David Mathiasen DATmrebrUs~y 21 1973
FROM TAEIM - John F i ard
SUBJECT OYB Funding for TAEHR Projects
We have been advised that the funding for the proposed new GTS project Education Outputs Measurement (total $225000 6f which $150000 is scheduled for FY 1973 and $75000 for FY 1974) is inadequate to meet the contractors budget (Georgetown University $252000) We therefore want to shift $27000 to this project from the $2500O allotted for the Educational Technology Field Support Project reducing the FY 1973 fumnding
level for the latter to $223000
TAEHRRSchmedingsd
Bs US Savings Bonds Replarly on the PayrollSavings Plan I
etal 4-1
0 shy
0lfl~
~0
-44h
~ d
~ -
4
r~sg
h
4
--I ca
4
44
)4
~K~
v j
T to4
to4 ~
)4 I ~~ 6Y
~
W
9-
V
~~
~~
~
E
~4
7K
IOr4
cisect
L~
n
4444~
~
o44w
44444
u4
4K
tV
4
44
shyX
4
444
4bo4
4~
I
C9~-)1U
444
~~4-444-~~ tr
-
I Il 13 0I
r 5
4
44A
44~
~~
~
c 0
01-1 r4
iM
L
J l
4 jr-~
i-
-
~(Jw~y
444
4
oil54 G
aJ
44
4-
C)1
04-1[ 5
H H
~
n 4
I
0r4 4
3444444
~~
94
~ 4
3
~
(l~
4
lb
-r-
4 ~
LtC
I4 ~~~~~~~
Cl
9
tr
i~~
444
~
U
4 t3A9 C
I ~~
in
44
~)4 4
~ 4 ( U
~4
4 4
~ 4
it5
4 4
)4j
J4
414K
-i4~ 4
4
3
44T
CQ
U
-t
4 7-1
~
1A
2fJ
4
~f
d4444
4~
I 4
44440
~
04
~
~
~~
-~a
i ci
0~
~
~
44444 ~
U
44
~ ~
CL
4 -
4~~ 44~
~~
~~
4~
t
gL 44 4
4
44 5
449 ~41
~~
~
-~
~
~~
04 0
44444444444444
rFP
-~5~1444
amp
t+oj
44
4~
7~
-
~ ~
tz tn
G
- D
)Q
co
i 444
U41
i4
j~_j
0 g
tz44~
444A
4 j449f
~~
4
i~(4~
lt 0-vr~
U(
~ ~
24
tj 4
2
4ii~
~~
0
~~414 4
44 4
44
~ 34
(7r4
-4
~~4444~~~~4 4 p~
~~
~C
A 4
4J )1
4
444
4
4
4
4
4444
W
H
10
4 4~44iC
Ocl0r13
~44444~
474
4~U
4~~
V-
444
44
~
2 4 0 4~ C
~
~
4
44 ~
44
444
4~ Hl
~Y
T-4
4
4
4M
Y
4
-44
PriWZampATC L0IbTP
C~~l~1~~ F~~ F R~~~ OE T VA U T iWCVUP
Cl x~ )13 0ec i Oof0e o onl 2d1 uctgo (fa0c 1 L 6 ) md aQ ~ ~ S ~ ~ Eu- L~inr~i
SiUcL a~i~tzix dotoB ~ i~I -
~ woopo~o~ eu YQ50 oojrarchv fOr qua1Jitative~ im~~~iV 2~VG~eard tyDpeo 0oudc1tio
-a among oCn thee nrb
3) i-h
9~ ~tamp a $~a
Arab CN4
Atjh flziobi Go~neroccon TL3 10 _ lTbo causesJ of tbOd VixS~t(euc 6antd Varie-dl ltTIh L tnampt of0 te zWocjuoyo
rc~11an gven~tetshavor aJrob iached the 3lzit ~OL Vhbapoundiobail2SL Cr Bu I Or ts byaIhiriaJ is o rieanr
V31ropily o 1iso alsogt to n oncTh liutlitioL blawed6i 12 Ofnnn[ ___
(p (Fuca1
~~~~~ ~~ M a~0prPz~ l~~lo)c d onthe iieed t~a~ f~0Cetv t a
of the clneat f~cacod byr educa-L6til~ ai ofn~n orzn t he
-- -9
Co ruo~~ 5t ~ n oIis~ehri
oT L v3 r) at ~cn
Dj
p~o~~r~X ryc
i
L-oof t r
44-
1 a
0111A Ofa4iC
~~~iooIy -ght 1A)
c i r
01
b 6
in 10 7-noiorshy
o
in c az e s
n l
~~
Aa
J -Ir1O
~44--
d loo to cIdu1e~ L -al emu-L)1 b a4444oa 1J i ~~ l--iO
c~u~ 11 )_2~ 2 0OJanot
Dio 11 mCtlCcLOxr OJ n v
i1i 4-1 )_
V
nLla t o n
x nm
4
4
c
6i pl
IRCl 4 n1 n V V
i17 $ 42lv
CofiUsnc1
--shy L~s~otoojn b4
cnfrece all
t 3-4A44~C--
hg p4pqtin of
tr0inperj- iIdnt~Li ntConoeu4Y X e V 4
u~~~-a lou 1
~ ~ ~ 4 ~
4
tho tcdovolop-mentl of Pan e cect~rc machiinery4 forthe1o ecdufat0ion and for4a~S~l on a continui bai the
niAZ oafo v
LT
At
4 Alea-ve
of o co-tin --
drojgtout grac repatitio land c
hic by7 anr xlj the a- 0idntv ti1u(h to bo de~rd~Gri-shyd shol~fu ub an intE-ua pat o
hi1nc ih 1~Ic~~o nr~ In rio aneiiatlo~ 2ydeeo- i~
OfA44Jllit n O4a at o4xam 44
pr M s U -- L
dnaticn alu~ec ntuet
v1e oi -iuiUu~~er L-3trictont
_l uti L -n 44o
(oCnji~poundr ~n~i~ni
1477port Third PL Qnal Con7a e cshyo 4 --3 4 P
shy
4 -~ ~4 - 44VV43p
kl- Cp 31p4a _ T 4~n o- ~
4 7424pi
~ -4 4~lt
6
4 77 4
I 81J
~ n
JY
444
h F1~~V011V-i~m)ya3ofOuet
- -MA
4 u
c u -- a - ao 4((A voi co~t111 nl t ororc -4- 44i44
d~44 4~~44~~4~4
djr4444n 44 u otP-00 (Yt O aos n
I Iitu shy
r a)-raIthm-- eh
ndfore -ou So4 as
~ ~ v at~aoi$ib~aoi8imampT m~~ t r4 411A-tio i h abe b4 - wi iie
S~~~V a I icau i1~ic
e ~~filhi O tdlS 4 ~ ~ ~ oqecL andh ~ th
4)1 ~ 4-1411-1~ o~be~ ~ 1 mlbi viuCLO2Ul Dt rtlfiP1111
c i l
lw r6 -tr cnb~~~ tf2 ~~~~ ~ ~ ~ b-~~~~t co~ i nt~rro ojtvnab ~ci~e~~
-~t~i~w ~ ~ ~iVtiot~catdc-~
tcr Cdo4 g C-a n l hg rampthdi1uh3 401 0- c a y i
t~ d
-z-~7~~ cost flCe1~ ~--
aa~ha~g K2-atnaampit~rB~U~-~v02 nojaJ rl-4 bt)o 1i
as tcjwainJcvatso isD6t iampifwt htof lbprta
urie oli achleavaiuaeto iSurh meansure ao usualc y -a is-c
an4- t Q)- A
-- ----ao
-Lr
cZ a no--shy4~ 4c
-Ala-~1610
Y Ln-ob 0
c Cn ereo~m - - 9-I
anld dveX~ 12b fljt l
i ~unat ~ O ~ ri- -10f~ ~ 9jiOr( r LO(v) j 0- f ui1Ahht~C~~tiwCdfLo^ ir
O~ r-si~ tc- uvc O tciaicn in vie oicny
0y ator sy on lxgcr- tcaampi c CTshyoitnm tnonvcay A~ilf-iea~e v a~nd cocia1 iiiamp=anfco oppO II
UO9 sshy
-~-~- - ~-b~at the quaity of thoro i~ho hold cortificatev
tha1oi da o d~roDushoaliaJo be su t tor0 shyu 993 9UP
o9 m- o icr n9Inaucon
9 2
cushy
ml m~6v )c~ar
f-~ C) LJri Z)~u )
vc C r 71 shy
TG- 0111 u
(b)Scol D3 or- (re U 17-
-i C ntatoi e~ic~ S~c~illum~ 6A -J-Oq
-OfIhstrurz ton cl qpro ss1 g obecti-miamp Jishy~e1doogiesWO(ii
- ~~---- -rt~cl to studei -lv1p2nve tachrV f~s
~$ ~iv) Lrolcveift 7ad--Ttati oi aUdIo-vismn1 Mdia prga d
7ial r7 a w t7ni
4 7 7
iv
t
(rii)~~~~~~
of
~
uoclc
Iff C 7
~
ediULACCampJOLU
- i4
~--~~
I~lCosu3ai
1shy
~d
a1O
I
41~3~rh
W~=12X
Ul
I -
I II~I~i
ti-vos~~~~~~~~~~~~r oo-t ~
anacdU
t
ied iltio
alfe-tlh 0 in iC ar
(1) cj ptvo-a~~ i1tof 4 ex c-~1~r gtI1~f
441444Y14141iII4 outputs
c- v1 t-cD-cc aniti lo 1~f
1 5-
61k
kc oj -i
-u
-7C
Ushy
fc l CI r V- 4 Tv U
~uIT p1 iPobTZ U 0-p atoao 4u L 1) )c
odcvI n o t (S
~ W-
spie- Mt irm (0 ) of-110
UNITED STATES GOVERNMENT
Memorandum TO AATAPM - Mr David Mathiasen DATmrebrUs~y 21 1973
FROM TAEIM - John F i ard
SUBJECT OYB Funding for TAEHR Projects
We have been advised that the funding for the proposed new GTS project Education Outputs Measurement (total $225000 6f which $150000 is scheduled for FY 1973 and $75000 for FY 1974) is inadequate to meet the contractors budget (Georgetown University $252000) We therefore want to shift $27000 to this project from the $2500O allotted for the Educational Technology Field Support Project reducing the FY 1973 fumnding
level for the latter to $223000
TAEHRRSchmedingsd
Bs US Savings Bonds Replarly on the PayrollSavings Plan I
PriWZampATC L0IbTP
C~~l~1~~ F~~ F R~~~ OE T VA U T iWCVUP
Cl x~ )13 0ec i Oof0e o onl 2d1 uctgo (fa0c 1 L 6 ) md aQ ~ ~ S ~ ~ Eu- L~inr~i
SiUcL a~i~tzix dotoB ~ i~I -
~ woopo~o~ eu YQ50 oojrarchv fOr qua1Jitative~ im~~~iV 2~VG~eard tyDpeo 0oudc1tio
-a among oCn thee nrb
3) i-h
9~ ~tamp a $~a
Arab CN4
Atjh flziobi Go~neroccon TL3 10 _ lTbo causesJ of tbOd VixS~t(euc 6antd Varie-dl ltTIh L tnampt of0 te zWocjuoyo
rc~11an gven~tetshavor aJrob iached the 3lzit ~OL Vhbapoundiobail2SL Cr Bu I Or ts byaIhiriaJ is o rieanr
V31ropily o 1iso alsogt to n oncTh liutlitioL blawed6i 12 Ofnnn[ ___
(p (Fuca1
~~~~~ ~~ M a~0prPz~ l~~lo)c d onthe iieed t~a~ f~0Cetv t a
of the clneat f~cacod byr educa-L6til~ ai ofn~n orzn t he
-- -9
Co ruo~~ 5t ~ n oIis~ehri
oT L v3 r) at ~cn
Dj
p~o~~r~X ryc
i
L-oof t r
44-
1 a
0111A Ofa4iC
~~~iooIy -ght 1A)
c i r
01
b 6
in 10 7-noiorshy
o
in c az e s
n l
~~
Aa
J -Ir1O
~44--
d loo to cIdu1e~ L -al emu-L)1 b a4444oa 1J i ~~ l--iO
c~u~ 11 )_2~ 2 0OJanot
Dio 11 mCtlCcLOxr OJ n v
i1i 4-1 )_
V
nLla t o n
x nm
4
4
c
6i pl
IRCl 4 n1 n V V
i17 $ 42lv
CofiUsnc1
--shy L~s~otoojn b4
cnfrece all
t 3-4A44~C--
hg p4pqtin of
tr0inperj- iIdnt~Li ntConoeu4Y X e V 4
u~~~-a lou 1
~ ~ ~ 4 ~
4
tho tcdovolop-mentl of Pan e cect~rc machiinery4 forthe1o ecdufat0ion and for4a~S~l on a continui bai the
niAZ oafo v
LT
At
4 Alea-ve
of o co-tin --
drojgtout grac repatitio land c
hic by7 anr xlj the a- 0idntv ti1u(h to bo de~rd~Gri-shyd shol~fu ub an intE-ua pat o
hi1nc ih 1~Ic~~o nr~ In rio aneiiatlo~ 2ydeeo- i~
OfA44Jllit n O4a at o4xam 44
pr M s U -- L
dnaticn alu~ec ntuet
v1e oi -iuiUu~~er L-3trictont
_l uti L -n 44o
(oCnji~poundr ~n~i~ni
1477port Third PL Qnal Con7a e cshyo 4 --3 4 P
shy
4 -~ ~4 - 44VV43p
kl- Cp 31p4a _ T 4~n o- ~
4 7424pi
~ -4 4~lt
6
4 77 4
I 81J
~ n
JY
444
h F1~~V011V-i~m)ya3ofOuet
- -MA
4 u
c u -- a - ao 4((A voi co~t111 nl t ororc -4- 44i44
d~44 4~~44~~4~4
djr4444n 44 u otP-00 (Yt O aos n
I Iitu shy
r a)-raIthm-- eh
ndfore -ou So4 as
~ ~ v at~aoi$ib~aoi8imampT m~~ t r4 411A-tio i h abe b4 - wi iie
S~~~V a I icau i1~ic
e ~~filhi O tdlS 4 ~ ~ ~ oqecL andh ~ th
4)1 ~ 4-1411-1~ o~be~ ~ 1 mlbi viuCLO2Ul Dt rtlfiP1111
c i l
lw r6 -tr cnb~~~ tf2 ~~~~ ~ ~ ~ b-~~~~t co~ i nt~rro ojtvnab ~ci~e~~
-~t~i~w ~ ~ ~iVtiot~catdc-~
tcr Cdo4 g C-a n l hg rampthdi1uh3 401 0- c a y i
t~ d
-z-~7~~ cost flCe1~ ~--
aa~ha~g K2-atnaampit~rB~U~-~v02 nojaJ rl-4 bt)o 1i
as tcjwainJcvatso isD6t iampifwt htof lbprta
urie oli achleavaiuaeto iSurh meansure ao usualc y -a is-c
an4- t Q)- A
-- ----ao
-Lr
cZ a no--shy4~ 4c
-Ala-~1610
Y Ln-ob 0
c Cn ereo~m - - 9-I
anld dveX~ 12b fljt l
i ~unat ~ O ~ ri- -10f~ ~ 9jiOr( r LO(v) j 0- f ui1Ahht~C~~tiwCdfLo^ ir
O~ r-si~ tc- uvc O tciaicn in vie oicny
0y ator sy on lxgcr- tcaampi c CTshyoitnm tnonvcay A~ilf-iea~e v a~nd cocia1 iiiamp=anfco oppO II
UO9 sshy
-~-~- - ~-b~at the quaity of thoro i~ho hold cortificatev
tha1oi da o d~roDushoaliaJo be su t tor0 shyu 993 9UP
o9 m- o icr n9Inaucon
9 2
cushy
ml m~6v )c~ar
f-~ C) LJri Z)~u )
vc C r 71 shy
TG- 0111 u
(b)Scol D3 or- (re U 17-
-i C ntatoi e~ic~ S~c~illum~ 6A -J-Oq
-OfIhstrurz ton cl qpro ss1 g obecti-miamp Jishy~e1doogiesWO(ii
- ~~---- -rt~cl to studei -lv1p2nve tachrV f~s
~$ ~iv) Lrolcveift 7ad--Ttati oi aUdIo-vismn1 Mdia prga d
7ial r7 a w t7ni
4 7 7
iv
t
(rii)~~~~~~
of
~
uoclc
Iff C 7
~
ediULACCampJOLU
- i4
~--~~
I~lCosu3ai
1shy
~d
a1O
I
41~3~rh
W~=12X
Ul
I -
I II~I~i
ti-vos~~~~~~~~~~~~r oo-t ~
anacdU
t
ied iltio
alfe-tlh 0 in iC ar
(1) cj ptvo-a~~ i1tof 4 ex c-~1~r gtI1~f
441444Y14141iII4 outputs
c- v1 t-cD-cc aniti lo 1~f
1 5-
61k
kc oj -i
-u
-7C
Ushy
fc l CI r V- 4 Tv U
~uIT p1 iPobTZ U 0-p atoao 4u L 1) )c
odcvI n o t (S
~ W-
spie- Mt irm (0 ) of-110
UNITED STATES GOVERNMENT
Memorandum TO AATAPM - Mr David Mathiasen DATmrebrUs~y 21 1973
FROM TAEIM - John F i ard
SUBJECT OYB Funding for TAEHR Projects
We have been advised that the funding for the proposed new GTS project Education Outputs Measurement (total $225000 6f which $150000 is scheduled for FY 1973 and $75000 for FY 1974) is inadequate to meet the contractors budget (Georgetown University $252000) We therefore want to shift $27000 to this project from the $2500O allotted for the Educational Technology Field Support Project reducing the FY 1973 fumnding
level for the latter to $223000
TAEHRRSchmedingsd
Bs US Savings Bonds Replarly on the PayrollSavings Plan I
Co ruo~~ 5t ~ n oIis~ehri
oT L v3 r) at ~cn
Dj
p~o~~r~X ryc
i
L-oof t r
44-
1 a
0111A Ofa4iC
~~~iooIy -ght 1A)
c i r
01
b 6
in 10 7-noiorshy
o
in c az e s
n l
~~
Aa
J -Ir1O
~44--
d loo to cIdu1e~ L -al emu-L)1 b a4444oa 1J i ~~ l--iO
c~u~ 11 )_2~ 2 0OJanot
Dio 11 mCtlCcLOxr OJ n v
i1i 4-1 )_
V
nLla t o n
x nm
4
4
c
6i pl
IRCl 4 n1 n V V
i17 $ 42lv
CofiUsnc1
--shy L~s~otoojn b4
cnfrece all
t 3-4A44~C--
hg p4pqtin of
tr0inperj- iIdnt~Li ntConoeu4Y X e V 4
u~~~-a lou 1
~ ~ ~ 4 ~
4
tho tcdovolop-mentl of Pan e cect~rc machiinery4 forthe1o ecdufat0ion and for4a~S~l on a continui bai the
niAZ oafo v
LT
At
4 Alea-ve
of o co-tin --
drojgtout grac repatitio land c
hic by7 anr xlj the a- 0idntv ti1u(h to bo de~rd~Gri-shyd shol~fu ub an intE-ua pat o
hi1nc ih 1~Ic~~o nr~ In rio aneiiatlo~ 2ydeeo- i~
OfA44Jllit n O4a at o4xam 44
pr M s U -- L
dnaticn alu~ec ntuet
v1e oi -iuiUu~~er L-3trictont
_l uti L -n 44o
(oCnji~poundr ~n~i~ni
1477port Third PL Qnal Con7a e cshyo 4 --3 4 P
shy
4 -~ ~4 - 44VV43p
kl- Cp 31p4a _ T 4~n o- ~
4 7424pi
~ -4 4~lt
6
4 77 4
I 81J
~ n
JY
444
h F1~~V011V-i~m)ya3ofOuet
- -MA
4 u
c u -- a - ao 4((A voi co~t111 nl t ororc -4- 44i44
d~44 4~~44~~4~4
djr4444n 44 u otP-00 (Yt O aos n
I Iitu shy
r a)-raIthm-- eh
ndfore -ou So4 as
~ ~ v at~aoi$ib~aoi8imampT m~~ t r4 411A-tio i h abe b4 - wi iie
S~~~V a I icau i1~ic
e ~~filhi O tdlS 4 ~ ~ ~ oqecL andh ~ th
4)1 ~ 4-1411-1~ o~be~ ~ 1 mlbi viuCLO2Ul Dt rtlfiP1111
c i l
lw r6 -tr cnb~~~ tf2 ~~~~ ~ ~ ~ b-~~~~t co~ i nt~rro ojtvnab ~ci~e~~
-~t~i~w ~ ~ ~iVtiot~catdc-~
tcr Cdo4 g C-a n l hg rampthdi1uh3 401 0- c a y i
t~ d
-z-~7~~ cost flCe1~ ~--
aa~ha~g K2-atnaampit~rB~U~-~v02 nojaJ rl-4 bt)o 1i
as tcjwainJcvatso isD6t iampifwt htof lbprta
urie oli achleavaiuaeto iSurh meansure ao usualc y -a is-c
an4- t Q)- A
-- ----ao
-Lr
cZ a no--shy4~ 4c
-Ala-~1610
Y Ln-ob 0
c Cn ereo~m - - 9-I
anld dveX~ 12b fljt l
i ~unat ~ O ~ ri- -10f~ ~ 9jiOr( r LO(v) j 0- f ui1Ahht~C~~tiwCdfLo^ ir
O~ r-si~ tc- uvc O tciaicn in vie oicny
0y ator sy on lxgcr- tcaampi c CTshyoitnm tnonvcay A~ilf-iea~e v a~nd cocia1 iiiamp=anfco oppO II
UO9 sshy
-~-~- - ~-b~at the quaity of thoro i~ho hold cortificatev
tha1oi da o d~roDushoaliaJo be su t tor0 shyu 993 9UP
o9 m- o icr n9Inaucon
9 2
cushy
ml m~6v )c~ar
f-~ C) LJri Z)~u )
vc C r 71 shy
TG- 0111 u
(b)Scol D3 or- (re U 17-
-i C ntatoi e~ic~ S~c~illum~ 6A -J-Oq
-OfIhstrurz ton cl qpro ss1 g obecti-miamp Jishy~e1doogiesWO(ii
- ~~---- -rt~cl to studei -lv1p2nve tachrV f~s
~$ ~iv) Lrolcveift 7ad--Ttati oi aUdIo-vismn1 Mdia prga d
7ial r7 a w t7ni
4 7 7
iv
t
(rii)~~~~~~
of
~
uoclc
Iff C 7
~
ediULACCampJOLU
- i4
~--~~
I~lCosu3ai
1shy
~d
a1O
I
41~3~rh
W~=12X
Ul
I -
I II~I~i
ti-vos~~~~~~~~~~~~r oo-t ~
anacdU
t
ied iltio
alfe-tlh 0 in iC ar
(1) cj ptvo-a~~ i1tof 4 ex c-~1~r gtI1~f
441444Y14141iII4 outputs
c- v1 t-cD-cc aniti lo 1~f
1 5-
61k
kc oj -i
-u
-7C
Ushy
fc l CI r V- 4 Tv U
~uIT p1 iPobTZ U 0-p atoao 4u L 1) )c
odcvI n o t (S
~ W-
spie- Mt irm (0 ) of-110
UNITED STATES GOVERNMENT
Memorandum TO AATAPM - Mr David Mathiasen DATmrebrUs~y 21 1973
FROM TAEIM - John F i ard
SUBJECT OYB Funding for TAEHR Projects
We have been advised that the funding for the proposed new GTS project Education Outputs Measurement (total $225000 6f which $150000 is scheduled for FY 1973 and $75000 for FY 1974) is inadequate to meet the contractors budget (Georgetown University $252000) We therefore want to shift $27000 to this project from the $2500O allotted for the Educational Technology Field Support Project reducing the FY 1973 fumnding
level for the latter to $223000
TAEHRRSchmedingsd
Bs US Savings Bonds Replarly on the PayrollSavings Plan I
I 81J
~ n
JY
444
h F1~~V011V-i~m)ya3ofOuet
- -MA
4 u
c u -- a - ao 4((A voi co~t111 nl t ororc -4- 44i44
d~44 4~~44~~4~4
djr4444n 44 u otP-00 (Yt O aos n
I Iitu shy
r a)-raIthm-- eh
ndfore -ou So4 as
~ ~ v at~aoi$ib~aoi8imampT m~~ t r4 411A-tio i h abe b4 - wi iie
S~~~V a I icau i1~ic
e ~~filhi O tdlS 4 ~ ~ ~ oqecL andh ~ th
4)1 ~ 4-1411-1~ o~be~ ~ 1 mlbi viuCLO2Ul Dt rtlfiP1111
c i l
lw r6 -tr cnb~~~ tf2 ~~~~ ~ ~ ~ b-~~~~t co~ i nt~rro ojtvnab ~ci~e~~
-~t~i~w ~ ~ ~iVtiot~catdc-~
tcr Cdo4 g C-a n l hg rampthdi1uh3 401 0- c a y i
t~ d
-z-~7~~ cost flCe1~ ~--
aa~ha~g K2-atnaampit~rB~U~-~v02 nojaJ rl-4 bt)o 1i
as tcjwainJcvatso isD6t iampifwt htof lbprta
urie oli achleavaiuaeto iSurh meansure ao usualc y -a is-c
an4- t Q)- A
-- ----ao
-Lr
cZ a no--shy4~ 4c
-Ala-~1610
Y Ln-ob 0
c Cn ereo~m - - 9-I
anld dveX~ 12b fljt l
i ~unat ~ O ~ ri- -10f~ ~ 9jiOr( r LO(v) j 0- f ui1Ahht~C~~tiwCdfLo^ ir
O~ r-si~ tc- uvc O tciaicn in vie oicny
0y ator sy on lxgcr- tcaampi c CTshyoitnm tnonvcay A~ilf-iea~e v a~nd cocia1 iiiamp=anfco oppO II
UO9 sshy
-~-~- - ~-b~at the quaity of thoro i~ho hold cortificatev
tha1oi da o d~roDushoaliaJo be su t tor0 shyu 993 9UP
o9 m- o icr n9Inaucon
9 2
cushy
ml m~6v )c~ar
f-~ C) LJri Z)~u )
vc C r 71 shy
TG- 0111 u
(b)Scol D3 or- (re U 17-
-i C ntatoi e~ic~ S~c~illum~ 6A -J-Oq
-OfIhstrurz ton cl qpro ss1 g obecti-miamp Jishy~e1doogiesWO(ii
- ~~---- -rt~cl to studei -lv1p2nve tachrV f~s
~$ ~iv) Lrolcveift 7ad--Ttati oi aUdIo-vismn1 Mdia prga d
7ial r7 a w t7ni
4 7 7
iv
t
(rii)~~~~~~
of
~
uoclc
Iff C 7
~
ediULACCampJOLU
- i4
~--~~
I~lCosu3ai
1shy
~d
a1O
I
41~3~rh
W~=12X
Ul
I -
I II~I~i
ti-vos~~~~~~~~~~~~r oo-t ~
anacdU
t
ied iltio
alfe-tlh 0 in iC ar
(1) cj ptvo-a~~ i1tof 4 ex c-~1~r gtI1~f
441444Y14141iII4 outputs
c- v1 t-cD-cc aniti lo 1~f
1 5-
61k
kc oj -i
-u
-7C
Ushy
fc l CI r V- 4 Tv U
~uIT p1 iPobTZ U 0-p atoao 4u L 1) )c
odcvI n o t (S
~ W-
spie- Mt irm (0 ) of-110
UNITED STATES GOVERNMENT
Memorandum TO AATAPM - Mr David Mathiasen DATmrebrUs~y 21 1973
FROM TAEIM - John F i ard
SUBJECT OYB Funding for TAEHR Projects
We have been advised that the funding for the proposed new GTS project Education Outputs Measurement (total $225000 6f which $150000 is scheduled for FY 1973 and $75000 for FY 1974) is inadequate to meet the contractors budget (Georgetown University $252000) We therefore want to shift $27000 to this project from the $2500O allotted for the Educational Technology Field Support Project reducing the FY 1973 fumnding
level for the latter to $223000
TAEHRRSchmedingsd
Bs US Savings Bonds Replarly on the PayrollSavings Plan I
4)1 ~ 4-1411-1~ o~be~ ~ 1 mlbi viuCLO2Ul Dt rtlfiP1111
c i l
lw r6 -tr cnb~~~ tf2 ~~~~ ~ ~ ~ b-~~~~t co~ i nt~rro ojtvnab ~ci~e~~
-~t~i~w ~ ~ ~iVtiot~catdc-~
tcr Cdo4 g C-a n l hg rampthdi1uh3 401 0- c a y i
t~ d
-z-~7~~ cost flCe1~ ~--
aa~ha~g K2-atnaampit~rB~U~-~v02 nojaJ rl-4 bt)o 1i
as tcjwainJcvatso isD6t iampifwt htof lbprta
urie oli achleavaiuaeto iSurh meansure ao usualc y -a is-c
an4- t Q)- A
-- ----ao
-Lr
cZ a no--shy4~ 4c
-Ala-~1610
Y Ln-ob 0
c Cn ereo~m - - 9-I
anld dveX~ 12b fljt l
i ~unat ~ O ~ ri- -10f~ ~ 9jiOr( r LO(v) j 0- f ui1Ahht~C~~tiwCdfLo^ ir
O~ r-si~ tc- uvc O tciaicn in vie oicny
0y ator sy on lxgcr- tcaampi c CTshyoitnm tnonvcay A~ilf-iea~e v a~nd cocia1 iiiamp=anfco oppO II
UO9 sshy
-~-~- - ~-b~at the quaity of thoro i~ho hold cortificatev
tha1oi da o d~roDushoaliaJo be su t tor0 shyu 993 9UP
o9 m- o icr n9Inaucon
9 2
cushy
ml m~6v )c~ar
f-~ C) LJri Z)~u )
vc C r 71 shy
TG- 0111 u
(b)Scol D3 or- (re U 17-
-i C ntatoi e~ic~ S~c~illum~ 6A -J-Oq
-OfIhstrurz ton cl qpro ss1 g obecti-miamp Jishy~e1doogiesWO(ii
- ~~---- -rt~cl to studei -lv1p2nve tachrV f~s
~$ ~iv) Lrolcveift 7ad--Ttati oi aUdIo-vismn1 Mdia prga d
7ial r7 a w t7ni
4 7 7
iv
t
(rii)~~~~~~
of
~
uoclc
Iff C 7
~
ediULACCampJOLU
- i4
~--~~
I~lCosu3ai
1shy
~d
a1O
I
41~3~rh
W~=12X
Ul
I -
I II~I~i
ti-vos~~~~~~~~~~~~r oo-t ~
anacdU
t
ied iltio
alfe-tlh 0 in iC ar
(1) cj ptvo-a~~ i1tof 4 ex c-~1~r gtI1~f
441444Y14141iII4 outputs
c- v1 t-cD-cc aniti lo 1~f
1 5-
61k
kc oj -i
-u
-7C
Ushy
fc l CI r V- 4 Tv U
~uIT p1 iPobTZ U 0-p atoao 4u L 1) )c
odcvI n o t (S
~ W-
spie- Mt irm (0 ) of-110
UNITED STATES GOVERNMENT
Memorandum TO AATAPM - Mr David Mathiasen DATmrebrUs~y 21 1973
FROM TAEIM - John F i ard
SUBJECT OYB Funding for TAEHR Projects
We have been advised that the funding for the proposed new GTS project Education Outputs Measurement (total $225000 6f which $150000 is scheduled for FY 1973 and $75000 for FY 1974) is inadequate to meet the contractors budget (Georgetown University $252000) We therefore want to shift $27000 to this project from the $2500O allotted for the Educational Technology Field Support Project reducing the FY 1973 fumnding
level for the latter to $223000
TAEHRRSchmedingsd
Bs US Savings Bonds Replarly on the PayrollSavings Plan I
-Lr
cZ a no--shy4~ 4c
-Ala-~1610
Y Ln-ob 0
c Cn ereo~m - - 9-I
anld dveX~ 12b fljt l
i ~unat ~ O ~ ri- -10f~ ~ 9jiOr( r LO(v) j 0- f ui1Ahht~C~~tiwCdfLo^ ir
O~ r-si~ tc- uvc O tciaicn in vie oicny
0y ator sy on lxgcr- tcaampi c CTshyoitnm tnonvcay A~ilf-iea~e v a~nd cocia1 iiiamp=anfco oppO II
UO9 sshy
-~-~- - ~-b~at the quaity of thoro i~ho hold cortificatev
tha1oi da o d~roDushoaliaJo be su t tor0 shyu 993 9UP
o9 m- o icr n9Inaucon
9 2
cushy
ml m~6v )c~ar
f-~ C) LJri Z)~u )
vc C r 71 shy
TG- 0111 u
(b)Scol D3 or- (re U 17-
-i C ntatoi e~ic~ S~c~illum~ 6A -J-Oq
-OfIhstrurz ton cl qpro ss1 g obecti-miamp Jishy~e1doogiesWO(ii
- ~~---- -rt~cl to studei -lv1p2nve tachrV f~s
~$ ~iv) Lrolcveift 7ad--Ttati oi aUdIo-vismn1 Mdia prga d
7ial r7 a w t7ni
4 7 7
iv
t
(rii)~~~~~~
of
~
uoclc
Iff C 7
~
ediULACCampJOLU
- i4
~--~~
I~lCosu3ai
1shy
~d
a1O
I
41~3~rh
W~=12X
Ul
I -
I II~I~i
ti-vos~~~~~~~~~~~~r oo-t ~
anacdU
t
ied iltio
alfe-tlh 0 in iC ar
(1) cj ptvo-a~~ i1tof 4 ex c-~1~r gtI1~f
441444Y14141iII4 outputs
c- v1 t-cD-cc aniti lo 1~f
1 5-
61k
kc oj -i
-u
-7C
Ushy
fc l CI r V- 4 Tv U
~uIT p1 iPobTZ U 0-p atoao 4u L 1) )c
odcvI n o t (S
~ W-
spie- Mt irm (0 ) of-110
UNITED STATES GOVERNMENT
Memorandum TO AATAPM - Mr David Mathiasen DATmrebrUs~y 21 1973
FROM TAEIM - John F i ard
SUBJECT OYB Funding for TAEHR Projects
We have been advised that the funding for the proposed new GTS project Education Outputs Measurement (total $225000 6f which $150000 is scheduled for FY 1973 and $75000 for FY 1974) is inadequate to meet the contractors budget (Georgetown University $252000) We therefore want to shift $27000 to this project from the $2500O allotted for the Educational Technology Field Support Project reducing the FY 1973 fumnding
level for the latter to $223000
TAEHRRSchmedingsd
Bs US Savings Bonds Replarly on the PayrollSavings Plan I
cushy
ml m~6v )c~ar
f-~ C) LJri Z)~u )
vc C r 71 shy
TG- 0111 u
(b)Scol D3 or- (re U 17-
-i C ntatoi e~ic~ S~c~illum~ 6A -J-Oq
-OfIhstrurz ton cl qpro ss1 g obecti-miamp Jishy~e1doogiesWO(ii
- ~~---- -rt~cl to studei -lv1p2nve tachrV f~s
~$ ~iv) Lrolcveift 7ad--Ttati oi aUdIo-vismn1 Mdia prga d
7ial r7 a w t7ni
4 7 7
iv
t
(rii)~~~~~~
of
~
uoclc
Iff C 7
~
ediULACCampJOLU
- i4
~--~~
I~lCosu3ai
1shy
~d
a1O
I
41~3~rh
W~=12X
Ul
I -
I II~I~i
ti-vos~~~~~~~~~~~~r oo-t ~
anacdU
t
ied iltio
alfe-tlh 0 in iC ar
(1) cj ptvo-a~~ i1tof 4 ex c-~1~r gtI1~f
441444Y14141iII4 outputs
c- v1 t-cD-cc aniti lo 1~f
1 5-
61k
kc oj -i
-u
-7C
Ushy
fc l CI r V- 4 Tv U
~uIT p1 iPobTZ U 0-p atoao 4u L 1) )c
odcvI n o t (S
~ W-
spie- Mt irm (0 ) of-110
UNITED STATES GOVERNMENT
Memorandum TO AATAPM - Mr David Mathiasen DATmrebrUs~y 21 1973
FROM TAEIM - John F i ard
SUBJECT OYB Funding for TAEHR Projects
We have been advised that the funding for the proposed new GTS project Education Outputs Measurement (total $225000 6f which $150000 is scheduled for FY 1973 and $75000 for FY 1974) is inadequate to meet the contractors budget (Georgetown University $252000) We therefore want to shift $27000 to this project from the $2500O allotted for the Educational Technology Field Support Project reducing the FY 1973 fumnding
level for the latter to $223000
TAEHRRSchmedingsd
Bs US Savings Bonds Replarly on the PayrollSavings Plan I
iv
t
(rii)~~~~~~
of
~
uoclc
Iff C 7
~
ediULACCampJOLU
- i4
~--~~
I~lCosu3ai
1shy
~d
a1O
I
41~3~rh
W~=12X
Ul
I -
I II~I~i
ti-vos~~~~~~~~~~~~r oo-t ~
anacdU
t
ied iltio
alfe-tlh 0 in iC ar
(1) cj ptvo-a~~ i1tof 4 ex c-~1~r gtI1~f
441444Y14141iII4 outputs
c- v1 t-cD-cc aniti lo 1~f
1 5-
61k
kc oj -i
-u
-7C
Ushy
fc l CI r V- 4 Tv U
~uIT p1 iPobTZ U 0-p atoao 4u L 1) )c
odcvI n o t (S
~ W-
spie- Mt irm (0 ) of-110
UNITED STATES GOVERNMENT
Memorandum TO AATAPM - Mr David Mathiasen DATmrebrUs~y 21 1973
FROM TAEIM - John F i ard
SUBJECT OYB Funding for TAEHR Projects
We have been advised that the funding for the proposed new GTS project Education Outputs Measurement (total $225000 6f which $150000 is scheduled for FY 1973 and $75000 for FY 1974) is inadequate to meet the contractors budget (Georgetown University $252000) We therefore want to shift $27000 to this project from the $2500O allotted for the Educational Technology Field Support Project reducing the FY 1973 fumnding
level for the latter to $223000
TAEHRRSchmedingsd
Bs US Savings Bonds Replarly on the PayrollSavings Plan I
-7C
Ushy
fc l CI r V- 4 Tv U
~uIT p1 iPobTZ U 0-p atoao 4u L 1) )c
odcvI n o t (S
~ W-
spie- Mt irm (0 ) of-110
UNITED STATES GOVERNMENT
Memorandum TO AATAPM - Mr David Mathiasen DATmrebrUs~y 21 1973
FROM TAEIM - John F i ard
SUBJECT OYB Funding for TAEHR Projects
We have been advised that the funding for the proposed new GTS project Education Outputs Measurement (total $225000 6f which $150000 is scheduled for FY 1973 and $75000 for FY 1974) is inadequate to meet the contractors budget (Georgetown University $252000) We therefore want to shift $27000 to this project from the $2500O allotted for the Educational Technology Field Support Project reducing the FY 1973 fumnding
level for the latter to $223000
TAEHRRSchmedingsd
Bs US Savings Bonds Replarly on the PayrollSavings Plan I
spie- Mt irm (0 ) of-110
UNITED STATES GOVERNMENT
Memorandum TO AATAPM - Mr David Mathiasen DATmrebrUs~y 21 1973
FROM TAEIM - John F i ard
SUBJECT OYB Funding for TAEHR Projects
We have been advised that the funding for the proposed new GTS project Education Outputs Measurement (total $225000 6f which $150000 is scheduled for FY 1973 and $75000 for FY 1974) is inadequate to meet the contractors budget (Georgetown University $252000) We therefore want to shift $27000 to this project from the $2500O allotted for the Educational Technology Field Support Project reducing the FY 1973 fumnding
level for the latter to $223000
TAEHRRSchmedingsd
Bs US Savings Bonds Replarly on the PayrollSavings Plan I