8
414 Vol.13 No.6 November 2016 Research & Development CHINA FOUNDRY Optimization of flow control devices in a ten- strand billet caster tundish * S h u - g u o Z h en g Male, born in 1979, Ph. D., Associate Professor. His research interests mainly focus on clean steel technology and solidification segregation in steel. His academic research has lead to the publication of more than 80 papers. E-mail: [email protected] R ec ei ved : 2016- 08 - 11; A c c ep t ed : 2016- 09 - 29 *Shu-guo Zheng and Miao-yong Zhu School of Metallurgy, Northeastern University, Shenyang 110819, China I n the conti nu ou s casti ng of steel, the tu nd i sh i s u sed as an i ntermed i ate vessel placed b etw een the lad le and the mou ld , recei vi ng the molten steel f rom the lad le and d i stri b u ti ng i t to the mou ld s. I n ad d i ti on to i ts role as a d i stri b u ti on vessel, the tu nd i sh i s also u sed as a reactor to prod u ce clean steel and assu re smooth operati on. F or a conventi onal conti nu ou s casti ng process to prod u ce steel b looms or b i llets, a tu nd i sh w i th three to ei g ht strand s i s u su ally employ ed . T he overall perf ormance of a tu nd i sh i s d omi nated b y the melt f low w i thi n i t. M elt f low control is particularly difficult in multi-strand tundishes. The shortest circuit flow, towards the strand nearest to the lad le shrou d , carri es not only hi g her temperatu re molten steel b u t also many i nclu si ons ex i sti ng i n the steel towards the closest mould in a multi-strand tundish, w hereas the strand s f u rther aw ay f rom the lad le shrou d recei ve cleaner and low er temperatu re molten steel. S o Abstract: The physical model of a ten-strand billet caster tundish was established to study the effects of various flow control devices on the melt flow. Before and after the optimization of the melt flow, the inclusion removal in the tundish was evaluated by plant trials. The physical modeling results show that when combined with a baffle, the turbulence inhibitor, instead of the impact pad, can significantly improve the melt flow. A turbulence inhibitor with a longer length of inner cavity and without an extending lip at the top of the sidewall seems to be efficient in the improvement of the melt flow. Various types and designs of baffles all influence the flow characteristics significantly. The “V” type baffles are better than the straight baffles for flow control. The “V” type baffle with four inclined holes at the sidewall away from the stopper rods is better in melt flow control than the one with one inclined hole at each sidewall. The combination of a well-designed turbulence inhibitor and an appropriate baffle shows high efficiency on improving the melt flow and an optimal proposal was presented. Plant trials indicate that, compared with the original tundish configuration in prototype, the inclusions reduce by 42% and the inclusion distribution of individual strands is more similar with the optimal one. The optimal tundish configuration effectively improves the melt flow in the ten-strand billet caster tundish. Key words: billet continuous casting; ten-strand caster tundish; flow control device; physical modeling; plant trials CLC numbers: TP391.9 Document code: A Article ID: 1672-6421(2016)06-414-08 the non-uniformities of steel cleanliness and output temperatu res f rom strand to strand ex i st as a resu lt of the poor similarity among the strands in a multi-strand tu nd i sh [ 1 , 2 ] . T he strand d i ssi mi lari ty can b e red u ced and controlled effectively by incorporating appropriate flow control devices within a given multi-strand tundish d esi g n [ 2 , 3 ] . T heref ore, b oth the i nclu si on removal and the strand si mi lari ty need to b e tak en i nto accou nt w hen modifying the melt flow in a multi-strand tundish. To achieve the desired melt flow result, flow control d evi ces need to b e i nstalled i n the tu nd i sh. F low control devices are generally dams, weirs, baffles, impact pads, tu rb u lence i nhi b i tors or some comb i nati on of these. T he analy si s f or the resi d ence ti me d i stri b u ti on ( RT D) cu rve is one of the most important and effective approaches to study the melt flow in the tundish. Much work has been reported u si ng a phy si cal mod eli ng approach or/ and numerical investigation to study the melt flow through the RTD curves in a multi-strand tundish [2-15] . H ow ever, these stu d i es w ere li mi ted to those caster tu nd i shes w i th 3 to 8 strand s. T hu s, very li ttle i nf ormati on i s avai lab le on the melt flow in a multi-strand caster tundish with more than 8 strands. Obviously, more strands in a multi- strand caster tu nd i sh lead s to a more seri ou s strand dissimilarity. Therefore, the melt flow control in a multi- DOI: 10.1007/s41230-016-6082-y

Optimization of flow control devices in a ten- strand ... · devices on the melt flow in a ten-strand billet caster tundish was investigated by physical modeling to find an optimal

  • Upload
    others

  • View
    9

  • Download
    0

Embed Size (px)

Citation preview

Page 1: Optimization of flow control devices in a ten- strand ... · devices on the melt flow in a ten-strand billet caster tundish was investigated by physical modeling to find an optimal

414

Vol.13 No.6 November 2016Research & DevelopmentCHINA FOUNDRY

Optimization of flow control devices in a ten-strand billet caster tundish

* S h u - g u o Z h en gMale, born in 1979, Ph. D., Associate Professor. His research interests mainly focus on clean steel technology and solidification segregation in steel. His academic research has lead to the publication of more than 80 papers.

E-mail: [email protected]

R ec ei ved : 2016- 08 - 11; A c c ep t ed : 2016- 09 - 29

*Shu-guo Zheng and Miao-yong ZhuSchool of Metallurgy, Northeastern University, Shenyang 110819, China

I n the conti nu ou s casti ng of steel, the tu nd i sh i s u sed as an i ntermed i ate vessel placed b etw een the lad le and

the mou ld , recei vi ng the molten steel f rom the lad le and d i stri b u ti ng i t to the mou ld s. I n ad d i ti on to i ts role as a d i stri b u ti on vessel, the tu nd i sh i s also u sed as a reactor to prod u ce clean steel and assu re smooth operati on. F or a conventi onal conti nu ou s casti ng process to prod u ce steel b looms or b i llets, a tu nd i sh w i th three to ei g ht strand s i s u su ally employ ed . T he overall perf ormance of a tu nd i sh i s d omi nated b y the melt f low w i thi n i t . M elt f low control is particularly difficult in multi-strand tundishes. The shortest circuit flow, towards the strand nearest to the lad le shrou d , carri es not only hi g her temperatu re molten steel b u t also many i nclu si ons ex i sti ng i n the steel towards the closest mould in a multi-strand tundish, w hereas the strand s f u rther aw ay f rom the lad le shrou d recei ve cleaner and low er temperatu re molten steel. S o

Abstract: The physical model of a ten-strand billet caster tundish was established to study the effects of various flow control devices on the melt flow. Before and after the optimization of the melt flow, the inclusion removal in the tundish was evaluated by plant trials. The physical modeling results show that when combined with a baffle, the turbulence inhibitor, instead of the impact pad, can significantly improve the melt flow. A turbulence inhibitor with a longer length of inner cavity and without an extending lip at the top of the sidewall seems to be efficient in the improvement of the melt flow. Various types and designs of baffles all influence the flow characteristics significantly. The “V” type baffles are better than the straight baffles for flow control. The “V” type baffle with four inclined holes at the sidewall away from the stopper rods is better in melt flow control than the one with one inclined hole at each sidewall. The combination of a well-designed turbulence inhibitor and an appropriate baffle shows high efficiency on improving the melt flow and an optimal proposal was presented. Plant trials indicate that, compared with the original tundish configuration in prototype, the inclusions reduce by 42% and the inclusion distribution of individual strands is more similar with the optimal one. The optimal tundish configuration effectively improves the melt flow in the ten-strand billet caster tundish.

Key words: billet continuous casting; ten-strand caster tundish; flow control device; physical modeling; plant trials

CLC numbers: TP391.9 Document code: A Article ID: 1672-6421(2016)06-414-08

the non-uniformities of steel cleanliness and output temperatu res f rom strand to strand ex i st as a resu lt of the poor similarity among the strands in a multi-strand tu nd i sh [ 1 , 2 ] . T he strand d i ssi mi lari ty can b e red u ced and controlled effectively by incorporating appropriate flow control devices within a given multi-strand tundish d esi g n [ 2 , 3 ] . T heref ore, b oth the i nclu si on removal and the strand si mi lari ty need to b e tak en i nto accou nt w hen modifying the melt flow in a multi-strand tundish.

To achieve the desired melt flow result, flow control d evi ces need to b e i nstalled i n the tu nd i sh. F low control devices are generally dams, weirs, baffles, impact pads, tu rb u lence i nhi b i tors or some comb i nati on of these. T he analy si s f or the resi d ence ti me d i stri b u ti on ( RT D) cu rve is one of the most important and effective approaches to study the melt flow in the tundish. Much work has been reported u si ng a phy si cal mod eli ng approach or/ and numerical investigation to study the melt flow through the RTD curves in a multi-strand tundish [2-15]. H ow ever, these stu d i es w ere li mi ted to those caster tu nd i shes w i th 3 to 8 strand s. T hu s, very li ttle i nf ormati on i s avai lab le on the melt flow in a multi-strand caster tundish with more than 8 strands. Obviously, more strands in a multi-strand caster tu nd i sh lead s to a more seri ou s strand dissimilarity. Therefore, the melt flow control in a multi-

DOI: 10.1007/s41230-016-6082-y

Page 2: Optimization of flow control devices in a ten- strand ... · devices on the melt flow in a ten-strand billet caster tundish was investigated by physical modeling to find an optimal

415

Vol.13 No.6 November 2016Research & Development CHINA FOUNDRY

F i g . 1: G eomet ry d i men s i on s of i n d u s t ri a l t u n d i s h u s ed i n t h i s s t u d y ( mm)

strand caster tundish with more than 8 strands is more difficult and need s to b e f u rther i nvesti g ated . M oreover, i n contrast to the wealth of data available for melt flow in a multi-strand tundish b y phy si cal mod eli ng or/ and mathemati cal mod eli ng , plant tri als on melt flow in a multi-strand tundish are relatively scarce.

I n the present stu d y , the i nf lu ence of d i f f erent f low control devices on the melt flow in a ten-strand billet caster tundish was investigated by physical modeling to find an optimal proposal. F ur thermore, the i nclus i on removal i n the tundi sh be f ore and af ter the opti mi z ati on w as also stu d i ed b y plant tri als to evalu ate the melt flow control in the tundish.

1 Experimental procedure1.1 S i mi la ri t y c on s i d era t i on s a n d ex p eri men t a l

met h od A ten-s t rand bi l le t caster tundish was selected as a prototy pe. Du ri ng the practi cal conti nu ou s casti ng process, t w o s y mmetr i ca l t u n d i shes ( w i t h f i ve s t ran d s each )

recei vi ng molten steel f rom one lad le b y tw o lad le shrou d s si mu ltaneou sly , w ere u sed to d i stri b u te molten steel to ten mou ld s at the same ti me. C onsi d eri ng that the tw o tu nd i shes are sy mmetri cal, one of the tw o tu nd i shes, w i th a capaci ty of 3 4 tonnes, w as mod eled and i ts phy si cal d i mensi ons are show n i n F i g . 1 . I n a phy si cal mod eli ng sy stem, w ater i s a su i tab le li q u i d to replace li q u i d steel at 1 , 8 2 3 K , b ecau se the k i nemati c viscosities of the two are comparable. To ensure the liquid flow si mi lari ty b etw een the mod el and prototy pe, g eometri cal and dynamic similarities must be satisfied. In the present study, the rati o of g eometri cal si mi lari ty of mod el tu nd i sh to the prototy pe was chosen to be 1:2.5, and Fig. 2 shows the photograph of mod el tu nd i sh. I n the sy stem of a tu nd i sh, the phy si cal mod el shou ld have the same F rou d e nu mb er as the prototy pe [16-18] . Therefore, the relations of liquid flow rates between the model and prototy pe can b e ex pressed as f ollow s:

where λ is the geometrical scale factor, Qm and Qp are the liquid flow rates of the model and the prototype, respectively.

F i g . 2: P h ot og ra p h of mod el t u n d i s h

T o ob tai n the RT D cu rves, the sti mu lu s response techni q u e consi sti ng of an i nstantaneou s ad d i ti on of tracer w as employ ed . When a steady state flow condition was obtained in the model tu nd i sh, 2 0 0 ml of a 2 0 % sod i u m chlori d e solu ti on, as a tracer, w as i nj ected i nto the w ater stream f low i ng throu g h the lad le shrou d . M eanw hi le, f i ve cond u cti vi t y prob es, w hi ch w ere connected to f i ve cond u cti vi ty meters, w ere i nstalled b elow strands 1 to 5 of the tundish to measure the instantaneous

concentrati on of the tracer as a f u ncti on of ti me at each strand . T he measu rement d ata w ere i npu t i nto a compu ter and then a g rou p of RT D cu rves w ere ob tai ned .

1.2 A n a ly s i s of R T D c u rvesB y analy z i ng the RT D cu rve, the melt f low i n a tu nd i sh can b e characteri z ed . C ommonly , the melt f low i n a tu nd i sh can b e d i vi d ed i nto the plu g f low , mi x ed f low and d ead volu mes.

( 1)

Page 3: Optimization of flow control devices in a ten- strand ... · devices on the melt flow in a ten-strand billet caster tundish was investigated by physical modeling to find an optimal

416

Vol.13 No.6 November 2016Research & DevelopmentCHINA FOUNDRY

In a multi-strand tundish, the accuracy of the melt flow characteri z ati on d epend s on the rati onali ty of the analy si s mod el f or RT D cu rves. I n ou r previ ou s w ork s [ 2 , 1 9 ] , an analy si s mod el to characterize the melt flow in multi-strand tundishes has been proposed and its reasonability has also been verified. With this analy si s mod el, the three volu mes can b e calcu lated as f ollow s:

w here Vp/ V, Vm/ V and Vd / V, are the fractions of plug flow, mixed f low , and d ead volu me respecti vely . θimi n i s the d i mensi onless time of the first appearance of tracer at strand i ( i=1 to 5), ic i s the d i mensi onless mean resi d ence ti me of strand i ( i=1 to 5), Qia/Qi is the fractional flow rate through the active volume of strand i, w hi ch i s nu meri cally eq u al to the area u nd er the d i mensi onless RT D cu rve ( the plot of the d i mensi onless concentrati on C ag ai nst the d i mensi onless ti me θ) of strand i as θ f rom 0 to 2 , as show n i n F i g . 3 ( i=1 to 5).

( 2)

Fig. 3: Schematic of a group of typical RTD curves in a five-s t ra n d t u n d i s h

As the similarity among the strands affects the uniformities of b oth steel cleanli ness and ou tpu t temperatu res among the strand s in multi-strand tundishes, besides those parameters related to the inclusion removal such as plug flow, mixed flow, and dead volu mes, the strand si mi lari ty also need s to b e consi d ered when optimizing the melt flow in multi-strand tundishes. An approach for quantifying the strand similarity in multi-strand tu nd i shes [2, 20-21] i s u sed , i . e. , all the stand ard d evi ati ons, those of d i mensi onless concentrati ons ( Ci ( tj ) , i=1 to 5, j = 1 to Z ) of strands 1 to 5 at instantaneous time tj ( j= 1 to Z) , are averag ed as f ollow s:

w h e r e i s t h e t o t a l m e a n s t a n d a r d d e v i a t i o n o f dimensionless concentrations of strands 1 to 5, tj i s the

i nstantaneou s ti me, Ci ( tj ) i s the d i mensi onless concentrati on of strand i at i nstantaneou s ti me tj , ( i=1 to 5, j = 1 to Z ) . Z i s the nu mb er o f i nstantaneou s t i me tj . C( tj) i s the mean of the dimensionless concentrations of strands 1 to 5 at i nstantaneou s ti me tj ( j = 1 to Z ) . F or b etter si mi lari ty among the strand s, the low er total mean stand ard d evi ati on 5 S i s d esi red .

1.3 Various flow control arrangementsV i a a lad le shrou d , the metal stream f rom the lad le enters i nto the tu nd i sh at a very hi g h veloci ty and g reat tu rb u lence. T he i mpact of the stream at the tu nd i sh b ottom may cau se severe ref ractory erosi on prob lems, so an i mpact pad or a tu rb u lence i nhi b i tor, placed at the b ottom, i s necessary to w i thstand the erosi ve f orce of the lad le stream. M oreover, i n the multi-strand tundish, the appropriate baffle with inclined holes can avoid the short circuiting flow of the strand nearest to the lad le shrou d [ 2 ] . As the effect of a turbulence inhibitor or an impact pad on flow control in the multi-strand tundish i s w eak i n the area f ar f rom the i mpact z one ( f or ex ample, i n the present ten-strand caster tundish, strand 5 is 5,500 mm aw ay f rom the lad le shrou d ) , the comb i nati on of a tu rb u lence inhibitor (or an impact pad) and a baffle with inclined holes, properly d esi g ned , may i mprove the melt f low ef f i ci ently . Therefore, for the present ten-strand caster tundish, the comb i nati on of a tu r b u lence i nhi b i tor ( or an i mpact pad ) and a b af f le w i th i ncli ned holes w as ad opted to opti mi z e the melt f low . T he ty pi cal f low control arrang ements are shown in Fig. 4, and Fig. 5 shows the flow control devices. B af f les A to C are “ V ” ty pe b af f les, w hi le b af f les D and E are straight baffles. Case I is the original case in prototype. Cases I to IV had the same baffle (baffle A) but different flow control d evi ces i n the i mpact z one ( an i mpact pad i n C ase I and tu rb u lence i nhi b i tors A to C i n cases I I to I V i n tu rn) . C omb i ned w i th the same tu rb u lence i nhi b i tor ( t u r b u lence inhibitor C), baffles B to E were arranged in cases V to VIII i n seq u ence.

1.4 O p t i mi z a t i on p ri n c i p lesFor the multi-strand tundish, both the inclusion removal and the strand si mi lari ty are of concern w hen opti mi z i ng the melt f low . T heref ore, to g ai n the max i mu m i nclu si on separati on ratio and the good strand similarity by installing flow control devices in a multi-strand tundish, it is necessary to ensure the f ollow i ng opti mi z ati on pri nci ples [ 2 , 1 6 , 2 2 ] :

(і) minimum dead volume; (іі) large ratio of plug to dead volume; (ііі) surface-directed flow; (іv) contained regions of mixing; ( v ) m i n i m u m total mean stan d ar d d ev i a t i on o f the

dimensionless concentrations of strands 1 to 5; (vі) the most important principle in the cleanness of

tundish product is ensuring there are no short circuit flows. T he ti me f or f i rst appearance of tracer, parti cu larly at the nearest strand , strand 1 , shou ld b e as long as possi b le.

( 3)

( 4)

( i=1 to 5, j= 1 t o Z) (5)

Page 4: Optimization of flow control devices in a ten- strand ... · devices on the melt flow in a ten-strand billet caster tundish was investigated by physical modeling to find an optimal

417

Vol.13 No.6 November 2016Research & Development CHINA FOUNDRY

Fig. 4: Schematic of various flow control arrangements

Fig. 5: Geometry and dimensions of flow control devices (mm)

Page 5: Optimization of flow control devices in a ten- strand ... · devices on the melt flow in a ten-strand billet caster tundish was investigated by physical modeling to find an optimal

418

Vol.13 No.6 November 2016Research & DevelopmentCHINA FOUNDRY

2 Results and discussion 2.1 E x p eri men t a l res u lt s The flow characteristics for different tundish configurations are show n i n T ab le 1 , and F i g . 6 show s the ty pi cal RT D cu rves. Then, combined with the above-mentioned optimization pri nci ples, the f ollow i ng poi nts can b e ob served :

( i ) W hen comb i ned w i th a b af f le, the tu rb u lence i nhi b i tor i nstead of the i mpact pad can si g ni f i cantly i ncrease the plu g volume, improving the melt flow. The designs of the turbulence i nhi b i tors ( the lengt h of i nner cavi ty of tur bul ence i nhi bi tors, w i th or w i thou t ex tend i ng li p at the top of the si d ew all) all have an effect on the melt flow in the tundish. The turbulence i nhi b i tor w i th a long er i nner cavi ty leng th has a larg er rati o of plu g to d ead volu me, w hi le the one w i th an ex tend i ng li p at the top of the si d ew all w orsens the strand si mi lari ty . S o, tu rb u lence i nhi b i tor C i s the opti mal one f or controlli ng the melt f low among the three k i nd s of tu rb u lence i nhi b i tors.

( i i ) T he “ V ” t y pe b a f f le w i th f ou r i ncli ned holes at the sidewall away from the stopper rods (baffles B and C) is better i n controlli ng the melt f low than the b af f le w i th one i ncli ned hole at each sidewall (baffle A). An inclined hole, arranged on the si d ew all near the stopper rod s, i s so close to strand s 1 and 2 that the time of the first appearance of tracer at strands 1 and 2 is very short. Therefore, the “V” type baffle with one inclined hole at each si d ew all has smaller plu g volu me and rati o of plu g to dead volume than the baffle with four inclined holes at the si d ew all aw ay f rom the stopper rod s.

(iii) Though both baffle types have four inclined holes away f rom the stopper rod s, the “ V ” ty pe b af f les, w i th larg er plu g volume and smaller dead volume, show a higher efficiency in improving the melt flow than the straight baffles. Furthermore, the appropri ate d esi g n of the hori z ontal d i recti on of tw o of the f ou r i ncli ned holes near the stopper rod s can i mprove the melt flow in both types of baffles. Cases VI and VIII (with the two i ncli ned holes near the stopper rod s poi nti ng to j u st ab ove strand

Table 1: Flow characteristics for different tundish configurations

C a s e S t ra n d Simi n Vp / V Vm/ V Vd / V Vp / Vd

1 0.04192 0.0375

I 3 0.0591 0.0755 0.6947 0.2298 0.3285 0.04414 0.07225 0.16661 0.04352 0.0570

II 3 0.0721 0.0948 0.6790 0.2262 0.4191 0.04604 0.10965 0.19171 0.03582 0.0451

III 3 0.0728 0.0925 0.6905 0.2170 0.4263 0.05684 0.10375 0.20521 0.06072 0.0721

IV 3 0.0630 0.0997 0.6722 0.2281 0.4371 0.04224 0.10105 0.20151 0.20732 0.1091

V 3 0.0640 0.1291 0.6359 0.2350 0.5494 0.05774 0.10595 0.15911 0.19382 0.1091

VI 3 0.0656 0.1450 0.6351 0.2199 0.6594 0.04914 0.12385 0.23241 0.16562 0.1059

VII 3 0.0630 0.1213 0.6085 0.2702 0.4489 0.05114 0.12655 0.14541 0.19872 0.0765

VIII 3 0.0598 0.1242 0.6178 0.2580 0.4814 0.05704 0.10645 0.1796

5 S

Page 6: Optimization of flow control devices in a ten- strand ... · devices on the melt flow in a ten-strand billet caster tundish was investigated by physical modeling to find an optimal

419

Vol.13 No.6 November 2016Research & Development CHINA FOUNDRY

4) show better control on the melt flow in “V” type baffles (cases V and VI) and straight baffles (cases VII and VIII). Therefore, the baffles with two of the four inclined holes near the stopper rod s poi nti ng to j u st ab ove S trand 4 show g ood control on the melt flow in the tundish. Furthermore, Baffle C is the best one for melt flow control among the five baffles.

(iv) The combination of a well-designed turbulence inhibitor and an appropriate baffle shows high efficiency on improving the melt flow in the ten-strand caster tundish. Compared with the other cases, C ase V I ( the comb i nati on of the opti mal tu rb u lence i nhi b i tor and b af f le) has the larg est plu g volu me and rati o of plu g to d ead volu me, and a relati vely small d ead volu me and S5 . ( I t can also b e seen f rom F i g . 6 that the g ood u ni f ormi ty among RT D cu rves of i nd i vi d u al strand s means the g ood strand si mi lari ty i n C ase V I . ) O n the w hole, accord i ng to the opti mi z ati on pri nci ples, i t seems that C ase V I i s the b est one f or i nclu si on removal and strand si mi lari ty .

2.2 R es u lt s of t ri a l a p p li c a t i onTo evaluate the effect of inclusion removal before and after the

F i g . 6: R T D c u rves f or C a s e VI

optimization of the melt flow in the ten-strand caster tundish, plant tri als w ere cond u cted . T he ori g i nal case ( C ase I ) i n prototy pe and the opti mal case ( C ase V I ) w ere respecti vely i nstalled i n the tw o sy mmetri cal tu nd i shes d u ri ng the prod u cti on of hi g h q u ali ty carb on stru ctu ral steel 6 0 . I n a casti ng seq u ence, b i llet samples w i th d i mensi ons of 1 6 0 mm × 1 6 0 mm w ere tak en f rom the i n d i v i d u al strand of the t w o s y mmetri cal tu nd i shes ( one w i th C ase I , the other w i th C ase V I ) , and then 15 mm × 15 mm samples were taken from the quarter thickness f rom the i nner arc su rf ace and center w i d th posi ti ons of each b i llet sample. A f ter the samples w ere mou nted i n b ak eli te and poli shed , a mi croscope w as u sed to q u anti f y the nu mb er and si z e of i nclu si ons.

F i g u res 7 and 8 show the opti cal mi crog raphs of i nclu si ons i n i nd i vi d u al strand s i n ori g i nal and opti mal cases, respecti vely . T he compari son of i nclu si on removal of each strand i n the tw o cases i s show n i n F i g . 9 . I t can b e seen that the i nclu si on nu mb er of each strand i n the opti mal case i s mu ch smaller ( red u ced b y 4 2 % ) than that i n the ori g i nal case. F u rthermore, the i nclu si on d i stri b u ti on i n the i nd i vi d u al strand s i n the opti mal case i s more si mi lar than that i n the ori g i nal case. T heref ore, the opti mal case i s mu ch b etter than the ori g i nal case f or the i nclu si on removal and the i nclu si on d i stri b u ti on si mi lari ty among the strand s.

3 Conclusions( 1 ) W hen comb i ned w i th a b af f le, the tu rb u lence i nhi b i tor

instead of the impact pad can significantly improve the melt flow in the ten-strand caster tundish. The designs of the turbulence inhibitors have an effect on the melt flow in the tundish; the tu rb u lence i nhi b i tor w i th long er i nner cavi ty leng th and w i thou t ex tend i ng li p at the top of the si d ew all i s b etter.

( 2 ) B oth the ty pes and the d esi g ns of b af f les i nf lu ence the

F i g . 7 : O p t i c a l mi c rog ra p h s of i n c lu s i on s i n i n d i vi d u a l s t ra n d s i n ori g i n a l c a s e: ( a ) S t ra n d 1; ( b) S t ra n d 2; ( c ) S t ra n d 3; ( d ) S t ra n d 4 ; ( e) S t ra n d 5

Page 7: Optimization of flow control devices in a ten- strand ... · devices on the melt flow in a ten-strand billet caster tundish was investigated by physical modeling to find an optimal

420

Vol.13 No.6 November 2016Research & DevelopmentCHINA FOUNDRY

F i g . 8 : O p t i c a l mi c rog ra p h s of i n c lu s i on s i n i n d i vi d u a l s t ra n d s i n op t i ma l c a s e: ( a ) S t ra n d 1; ( b) S t ra n d 2; ( c ) S t ra n d 3; ( d ) S t ra n d 4 ; ( e) S t ra n d 5

F i g . 9 : C omp a ri s on of i n c lu s i on remova l of ea c h s t ra n d i n ori g i n a l a n d op t i ma l c a s es

f low characteri sti cs si g ni f i cantly . T he “ V ” ty pe b af f les show higher efficiency on improving the melt flow than the straight baffles. And the “V” type baffle with four inclined holes at the si d ew all aw ay f rom the stopper rod s i s b etter at controlli ng the melt flow than the one with one inclined hole at each sidewall. The baffles, with two of the four inclined holes near the stopper rod s poi nti ng to j u st ab ove strand 4 , show g ood control on the melt flow in the tundish.

(3) The combination of a well-designed turbulence inhibitor and an appropriate baffle shows high efficiency in improving the melt flow in the ten-strand caster tundish. Case VI is the best for i nclu si on removal and strand si mi lari ty . T he i nclu si on nu mb er i s red u ced b y 4 2 % and the i nclu si on d i stri b u ti on of i nd i vi d u al strand s i s more si mi lar af ter u si ng the opti mal comb i nati on.

References[1] Fan C M, Pan S M, Wang H S, et al. Design of single element

flow control device in twin strand billet tundish for continuous casting of steel using flow simulation model. Ironmaking and Steelmaking, 2002, 29(5): 376-382.

[2] Zheng Shuguo and Zhu Miaoyong. Optimization of baffles in six strands round bloom continuous casting tundish: a physical modeling study. Ironmaking and steelmaking, 2006, 33(5): 398-406.

[3] Mazumdar D, Yamanoglu G, and Guthrie R I L. Hydrodynamic performance of steelmaking tundish systems: A comparative study of three different tundish designs. Steel Research, 1997, 68(7): 293-300.

[4] He Fei, Zhang Ling-ying and Xu Qi-yan. Optimization of flow control devices for a T-type five-strand billet caster tundish: water modeling and numerical simulation. China Foundry, 2016, 13(3): 166-175.

[5] Wang Min, Zhang Chaojie and Li Rui. Uniformity evaluation and optimization of fluid flow characteristics in a seven-strand tundish. International Journal of Minerals, Metallurgy and Materials, 2016, 23(2): 137-145.

[6] Ray S K, Isac M, and Guthrie R I L. Modelling performance of four-strand, 12t, delta shaped continuous casting tundish fitted with different flow modifying arrangements for better steel quality. Ironmaking and Steelmaking, 2011, 38(3): 173-180.

[7] Chang Sheng, Zhong Liangcai, and Zou Zongshu. Simulation of flow and heat fields in a seven-strand tundish with gas curtain for molten steel continuous-casting. ISIJ International, 2015, 55(4): 837-844.

[8] Kumar A, Mazumdar D, and Koria S C. Modeling of fluid flow and residence time distribution in a four-strand tundish for enhancing inclusion removal. ISIJ International, 2008, 48(1): 38-47.

[9] Li Yihong, Bao Yanping, Zhao Lihua, et al. Effect of diversion hole on flow trajectory of steel in multi-strand tundish. Iron and Steel, 2014, 49(6): 37-42. (In Chinese)

Page 8: Optimization of flow control devices in a ten- strand ... · devices on the melt flow in a ten-strand billet caster tundish was investigated by physical modeling to find an optimal

421

Vol.13 No.6 November 2016Research & Development CHINA FOUNDRY

[10] Chattopadhyay K, Isac M, and Guthrie R I L. Effect of flow modifiers on liquid metal cleanliness in four-strand delta shaped billet caster tundish. Ironmaking and Steelmaking, 2012, 39(6): 454-462.

[11] Lei Hong. New insight into combined model and revised model for RTD curves in a multi-strand tundish. Metallurgical and Materials Transactions B, 2015, 46(6): 2408-2413.

[12] Mishra S K, Jha P K, Sharma S C, et al. Effect of blockage of outlet nozzle on fluid flow and heat transfer in continuously cast multistrand billet caster tundish. Canadian Metallurgical Quarterly, 2012, 51(2): 170-183.

[13] Sun Yanhui, Xiong Huihui, Wang Xiaosong, et al. Research on simulation of liquid steel flow in a ASF billet 8-strand continuous casting tundish. Steelmaking, 2012, 28(2): 60-64. (In Chinese)

[14] Jiang Jing, Li Jingshe, Wu Huajie, et al. Water modeling of molten steel flow in a multi-strand tundish with gas blowing. International Journal of Minerals, Metallurgy and Materials, 2010, 17(2): 143-148.

[15] Zhong Liangcai, Li Baokuan, Zhu Yingxiong, et al. Fluid flow in a four-strand bloom continuous casting tundish with different flow modifiers. ISIJ International, 2007, 47(1): 88-94.

[16] Sahai Y and Ahuja R. Fluid f low and mixing of melt in

This work was supported by the National Natural Science Foundation of China (No. 51474059, No. 51204042), the Program for Liaoning Excellent Talents in University (No. LJQ2014031), and the Fundamental Research Funds for the Central Universities (No. N140205003).

steelmaking tundishes. Ironmaking and Steelmaking, 1986, 13(5): 241-247.

[17] Singh S and Koria S C. Physical modeling of steel flow in continuous casting tundish. Ironmaking and Steelmaking 1993, 20(3): 221-230.

[18] Singh S and Koria S C. Model study of the dynamics of flow of steel melt in the tundish. ISIJ International, 1993, 33(12): 1228-1237.

[19] Zheng S G and Zhu M Y. Analysis model for flow characteristics in multi-strand continuous casting tundish. Acta Metallurgica Sinica, 2005, 41(10): 1073-1076. (In Chinese)

[20] Zheng S G and Zhu M Y. Criteria on the similarity of melt flow among strands in multi-strand continuous casting tundish. The Chinese Journal of Process Engineering, 2006, 6(4): 522-526. (In Chinese)

[21] Sengupta A, Mishra P, Singh V, et al. Physical modeling investigat ion of inf luence of strand blockage on RTD characteristics in a multistrand tundish. Ironmaking and Steelmaking, 2013, 40(3): 159-166.

[22] Mazumdar D and Guthrie R I L. The physical and mathematical modelling of continuous casting tundish systems. ISIJ International, 1999, 39(6): 524-547.