Operations Research - 1

Spring 2012

Instructor: Sungsoo Park (sspark@kaist.ac.kr), Building E2-2, room 4112, Tel: 3121

Office hour: Tue, Thrs, 14:30 – 17:00 or by appointment

TA: Kiho Seo (emffp1410@kaist.ac.kr), Office hour: Mon, Wed, 15:00 – 17:00 or by appointment

Ilhoon Cho (cih112@kaist.ac.kr), Office hour: Mon, Wed, 15:00 –

17:00 or by appointment

Building E2-2, room 4113, Tel: 3161

Homepage: http://solab.kaist.ac.kr/, download class notes, homeworks.

Text: “Linear Programming”, Vasek Chvatal, Freeman, 1983 and class handouts  

OR-1 2012 2

Grading: Midterm 30 - 40%, Final 40 - 50%, Homework 10 - 20% (Including computer assignments, CPLEX/Xpress-MP)

Class codesNo copying of homeworks. You may consult with others on homework problems,

but writing should be your own. Copying will be penalized.No passing grade for 5 or more classes missing. Random check of attendance. Give

advance notices for unavoidable situations.

OR-1 2012 3

OR-1 2012 4

Origins of OR Contributions of scientists and engineers during world war II.

Battle of Britain (radar site selection and control), Submarine warfare, Design of B-29, ..

Battle of Britain: integration of radar(hardware) and warning and control system. Addition of radar sites causes problems.

(the name operational research (research in (military) operations)

Maintenance of aircraft: For 350 flying hours, need 7 minor inspections( 2-5 days each) and a major inspection (14 days). Each aircraft had a devoted aircrew and a ground crew

change to central garage system.

: Flying hour increased by 61% over previous best record.

OR-1 2012 5

Submarine warfare:

Used patrol airplanes to detect surfaced U-boats and attack.

Needed 170 man-hours by maintenance and ground staff to produce one hour of operational flying.

More than 200 hours of flying to produce one attack on a surfaced U-boat. (34,000 man-hours for an attack)

In 1941, attack kill probability was 2% - 3%

1.1M 1.7M man-hours needed to destroy one U-boat. (needed improvements)

Important decision variables:1. Depth (time) setting for depth charge explosion (30/45m -> 8m)

2. Lethal radius (Use large or small bombs?)

3. Aiming errors in dropping the stick (aim ahead?)

4. Orientation of the stick with respect to the U-boat. (along U-boat track)

5. Spacing between successive depth charges in the stick (12m -> 33m)

6. Low level bombsights

OR-1 2012 6

Overall effect: By 1945, the attack kill probability had risen to over 40%.

OR-1 2012 7

After the war, methodologies used by the scientists adopted by government, industry.

Called Operations Research (US), Operational Research(UK, Europe) ( 운용과학 ), Management Science ( 경영과학 )

Characteristics: Use of mathematical models to solve decision problems arising in management of industry, government, military, ….

E=mC2, F=ma, …

OR-1 2012 8

Nature of OR “research on operations”

Applied mathematics + computer science + management

Models : Deterministic models ( 확정적 모형 , OR-I)

Stochastic models ( 확률적 모형 , OR-II)

Needed background: Algebra, calculus, discrete mathematics, probability, statistics, data structure, algorithm, data base, programming skills, …)

Important thrusts in early stages

  1. Technical progress (Simplex method for linear programming, Dantzig, 1947)

2.  Invention of computer and PC

OR-1 2012 9

Study areas Deterministic models

Linear programming( 선형계획법 , linear optimization):1975, Nobel prize, Kantorovich, Koopmans (efficient allocation of resources)

Nonlinear programming( 비선형계획법 ):1990 Nobel prize, Markowitz (portfolio selection)

21 2min xx

1023 21 xx

32 21 xx

0,0 21 xx

321 max xxx

axxxxxx 313221 222

0,0,0 321 xxx

OR-1 2012 10

Integer Programming( 정수계획법 ), Combinatorial optimization ( 조합최적화 )

• Knapsack problem

• Traveling Salesman Problem ( 외판원문제 )

Given n cities, and distances cij between city i and j. What is the shortest sequence to visit each city exactly once and return to the starting city?

( Applications: PCB assembly, Off-shore drilling, vehicle routing (delivery/pick-up problem), bio, …)

web site: http://www.tsp.gatech.edu/

4321 352 max xxxx

62362 4321 xxxx

ixi allfor }1,0{

OR-1 2012 11

Networks and graphs

• Shortest path to move from Inchon to Kangnung? (Shortest path problem)

– Logistics, Telecommunication routing, …

• Connect the cities with roads (or communication lines) in a cheapest way. (Minimum spanning tree problem)

• How much commodities (or packets) can we send from Kwangju to Daegu if edges have limited capacities? (maximum flow problem)

SeoulInchon

Kangnung

Daejeon

Kwangju

Pusan

Daegu

OR-1 2012 12

Dynamic programming

• If a system changes in time and the status of the system in the next period depends on the current status and decisions made, what is the best decision in each stage to optimize our goal in the end?

• Not the formalized problems, but refer the structured steps (methods) used to solve problems involving many stages.

Game theory

• Investigate the best strategy when the outcome of cooperation and/or competition between people or groups depends on the collective decisions made by individual person/group.

• Economics, Marketing (1994, Nobel prize, Nash, Harsanyi, Selten)

Computational complexity: Theory that investigate the inherent difficulty of problems. Turing machine model of computation.

NP-completeness.

• NP-complete (NP-hard) problems: Knapsack problem, Traveling salesman problem, …

• Easily solvable problems: shortest path problem, minimum spanning tree problem, …

– Problems for which polynomial running time algorithms exist.

• A little bit of changes in the problem structure may make the problem hard.

– Minimum spanning tree problem vs. Steiner tree problem

• Useful tool when we try to solve some new problems.

Note that the basic models may appear as subproblems in a big problem. Also the models may be hidden in the real problem in some unexpected way. Identifying the hidden model may be crucial.

OR-1 2012 13

OR-1 2012 14

Stochastic models (OR-II)Markov chainQueueing theoryDecision analysisSimulationReliability

Recently, uncertainties of data are reflected in the optimization modelsStochastic ProgrammingRobust Optimization