1
Open-Access, Web-Based Interna3onal Health Regula3on (IHR) Cos3ng Tool In 2016, the World Health OrganizaKon (WHO) adopted the voluntary Joint External EvaluaKon (JEE) process to help countries strengthen their capaciKes to prevent, detect, and respond rapidly to public health events under the InternaKonal Health RegulaKons (2005) (IHR). The JEE Tool, a data collecKon instrument, is used as part of this collaboraKve process to assess IHR- and Global Health Security Agenda (GHSA)-relevant capaciKes, and to idenKfy and prioriKze capacity-building needs. TargeKng resources effecKvely to build and sustain capaciKes requires stakeholders to develop plans that are acKonable and contain sufficient cosKng informaKon to support raKonal and sustainable implementaKon efforts. Since the IHR entered into force in 2007, naKonal stakeholders and their internaKonal partners have struggled to define the costs of strengthening and maintaining health security systems that cross levels and agencies and rely on mulK- sectoral coordinaKon for acKon. Based on a methodology developed by our research team in case study countries spanning mulKple WHO regions, we have developed a publicly available, web-based cos2ng tool to support countries in developing costed ac2on plans to achieve capaci2es priori2zed under the JEE process. The IHR cosKng tool integrates user-supplied, country-specific data into a template derived from field pracKces and best guidance for achieving specific capabiliKes that contribute to IHR core capaciKes. This cosKng tool, in combinaKon with the JEE and financing tools already available, represent a significant step in helping naKonal and internaKonal decision makers develop pracKcal plans to improve global health security. INTRODUCTION Rebecca Katz 1 , Ellie Graeden 2 , JusKn Kerr 2 , and Julie Fischer 1 1, Georgetown Center for Global Health Science & Security | 2, Talus AnalyKcs METHODOLOGY This work builds on cosKng templates, previously developed by our research team, based on a review of IHR implementaKon in 14 case study countries and further refined through country feedback collected while supporKng WHO in developing and pilot-tesKng an earlier conceptual framework for IHR cosKng in 6 countries. Since the JEE contains more indicators than the previous IHR Core Capacity Monitoring Framework, we reviewed published guidance from WHO, OIE, and other internaKonal authoriKes to address the new indicators. In addiKon, published JEE evaluaKons were reviewed to idenKfy the specific capabiliKes required to achieve a given score for each indicator, and the acKviKes necessary to build each capability. We developed an interacKve, web-based user interface to guide users through the process of esKmaKng costs for a user-specified step increase in JEE capacity score. A back-end database of cost calculaKons covers cosKng for each capability and acKvity idenKfied in the above analysis. CalculaKons include mulKpliers for each administraKve level, where applicable, because IHR requires capaciKes to detect, assess, and report unusual events from the local, intermediate, and naKonal levels. To support summary analysis and planning efforts, each cost is tagged with a specific JEE indicator, funcKonal category, and whether it represents a start-up, capital, or recurring cost. Indicators for which cosKng tools have already been determined elsewhere are linked and aligned where possible to help prevent duplicaKon or confusion. Acknowledgements: We thank the enKre Center for Global Health Science and Security research team for their research support in developing the tool. IniKal efforts supported by the U.S. Defense Threat ReducKon Agency - CooperaKve, Biological Engagement Program and the Department of State Biosecurity Engagement Program. The conceptual framework was strengthened through collaboraKon with the WHO and its technical partners. Current efforts were supported by Open Philanthropy Project and Georgetown University Medical Center. We are grateful to our partners and colleagues at the World Health OrganizaKon, the Centers for Disease Control and PrevenKon, the World Bank, McKinsey and Company, the GHSA Private Sector Roundtable, Tom Frieden, Peter Sands, Anas El Turabi, and Phil Saynisch for their feedback and support. Contact Informa3on: [email protected] |hPps:ghss.georgetown.edu OTHER INFORMATION RESULTS CONCLUSIONS Country experiences were used to develop an open access, web-based tool to esKmate country-level costs for strengthening IHR compliance No sensiKve user data stored by the tool MulKple opKons for use include storing data between sessions and working offline in a spreadsheet template Cost calculaKons align to the JEE and use country-specific data Includes JEE score upload from JEE Technology Tool (developed by the PSRT and powered by Qlik Technologies) InteracKve visualizaKons to explore costs by category, funcKon, core capacity, and over 1, 3, and 5 years Export detailed cosKng results to Microsoe Excel IdenKfies the costs associated with pracKcal steps to improve global health security 1. Home Page: Introduc3on 2. Choose Country: Interac3ve Map 3A. Assessment: File Upload Op3ons 3B. Assessment: Enter and Review JEE Scores 4A. Cos3ng: Country-Specific Inputs 4B. Cos3ng: Enter Costs 5A. Results: Cost Summary 5B. Results: Interac3ve Graph(s) 5B. Results: Interac3ve Graph(s) WWW.GHSCOSTING.ORG

Open-Access, Web-Based Interna3onal Health Regula3on (IHR ... · Poster template courtesy Faculty & Curriculum Support (FACS), Georgetown University School of Medicine Open-Access,

  • Upload
    others

  • View
    0

  • Download
    0

Embed Size (px)

Citation preview

Page 1: Open-Access, Web-Based Interna3onal Health Regula3on (IHR ... · Poster template courtesy Faculty & Curriculum Support (FACS), Georgetown University School of Medicine Open-Access,

PostertemplatecourtesyFaculty&CurriculumSupport(FACS),GeorgetownUniversitySchoolof

Medicine

Open-Access,Web-BasedInterna3onalHealthRegula3on(IHR)Cos3ngTool

In 2016, the World Health OrganizaKon (WHO) adopted the voluntary Joint ExternalEvaluaKon(JEE)processtohelpcountriesstrengthentheircapaciKestoprevent,detect,and respond rapidly to public health events under the InternaKonalHealthRegulaKons(2005) (IHR). The JEE Tool, a data collecKon instrument, is used as part of thiscollaboraKveprocess toassess IHR-andGlobalHealthSecurityAgenda (GHSA)-relevantcapaciKes, and to idenKfy and prioriKze capacity-building needs. TargeKng resourceseffecKvelytobuildandsustaincapaciKesrequiresstakeholderstodevelopplansthatareacKonableandcontainsufficientcosKnginformaKontosupportraKonalandsustainableimplementaKonefforts. Since the IHRentered into force in2007,naKonal stakeholdersandtheir internaKonalpartnershavestruggledtodefinethecostsofstrengtheningandmaintaining health security systems that cross levels and agencies and rely on mulK-sectoral coordinaKon for acKon. Based on a methodology developed by our researchteam in case study countries spanning mulKple WHO regions, we have developed apublicly available, web-based cos2ng tool to support countries in developing costedac2onplanstoachievecapaci2espriori2zedundertheJEEprocess.TheIHRcosKngtoolintegrates user-supplied, country-specific data into a template derived from fieldpracKcesandbestguidanceforachievingspecificcapabiliKesthatcontributetoIHRcorecapaciKes. This cosKng tool, in combinaKon with the JEE and financing tools alreadyavailable, represent a significant step in helping naKonal and internaKonal decisionmakersdeveloppracKcalplanstoimproveglobalhealthsecurity.

INTRODUCTION

RebeccaKatz1,EllieGraeden2,JusKnKerr2,andJulieFischer11,GeorgetownCenterforGlobalHealthScience&Security|2,TalusAnalyKcs

METHODOLOGYThis work builds on cosKng templates, previously developed by our researchteam,basedona reviewof IHR implementaKon in14case studycountriesandfurther refined through country feedback collected while supporKng WHO indevelopingandpilot-tesKnganearlierconceptualframeworkforIHRcosKngin6countries. Since the JEE contains more indicators than the previous IHR CoreCapacity Monitoring Framework, we reviewed published guidance fromWHO,OIE,andother internaKonalauthoriKes toaddress thenew indicators. InaddiKon, published JEE evaluaKons were reviewed to idenKfy the specificcapabiliKesrequiredtoachieveagivenscoreforeachindicator,andtheacKviKesnecessarytobuildeachcapability.We developed an interacKve,web-based user interface to guide users throughtheprocessofesKmaKngcosts forauser-specifiedstep increase inJEEcapacityscore.Aback-enddatabaseofcostcalculaKonscoverscosKngforeachcapabilityand acKvity idenKfied in the above analysis. CalculaKons includemulKpliers foreach administraKve level, where applicable, because IHR requires capaciKes todetect, assess, and report unusual events from the local, intermediate, andnaKonal levels. To support summary analysis and planning efforts, each cost istagged with a specific JEE indicator, funcKonal category, and whether itrepresentsastart-up,capital,orrecurringcost.IndicatorsforwhichcosKngtoolshavealreadybeendeterminedelsewhereare linkedandalignedwherepossibletohelppreventduplicaKonorconfusion.

Acknowledgements:We thank the enKre Center for Global Health Science and Security research team for theirresearchsupport indevelopingthetool. IniKaleffortssupportedbytheU.S.DefenseThreatReducKonAgency-CooperaKve,BiologicalEngagementProgramandtheDepartmentofStateBiosecurity Engagement Program. The conceptual framework was strengthened throughcollaboraKonwiththeWHOanditstechnicalpartners.CurrenteffortsweresupportedbyOpenPhilanthropy Project and Georgetown University Medical Center. We are grateful to ourpartnersandcolleaguesattheWorldHealthOrganizaKon,theCentersforDiseaseControlandPrevenKon, theWorld Bank, McKinsey and Company, the GHSA Private Sector Roundtable,TomFrieden,PeterSands,AnasElTurabi,andPhilSaynischfortheirfeedbackandsupport.

ContactInforma3on:[email protected]|hPps:ghss.georgetown.edu

OTHERINFORMATION

RESULTS

CONCLUSIONS•  Countryexperienceswereused todevelopanopenaccess,web-based tool toesKmatecountry-levelcostsforstrengtheningIHRcompliance

•  NosensiKveuserdatastoredbythetool•  MulKple opKons for use include storing data between sessions and workingofflineinaspreadsheettemplate

•  CostcalculaKonsaligntotheJEEandusecountry-specificdata•  IncludesJEEscoreuploadfromJEETechnologyTool(developedbythePSRTandpoweredbyQlikTechnologies)

•  InteracKve visualizaKons to explore costs by category, funcKon, core capacity,andover1,3,and5years

•  ExportdetailedcosKngresultstoMicrosoeExcel•  IdenKfies the costs associated with pracKcal steps to improve global healthsecurity

1.HomePage:Introduc3on 2.ChooseCountry:Interac3veMap 3A.Assessment:FileUploadOp3ons

3B.Assessment:EnterandReviewJEEScores 4A.Cos3ng:Country-SpecificInputs 4B.Cos3ng:EnterCosts

5A.Results:CostSummary

5B.Results:Interac3veGraph(s)

5B.Results:Interac3veGraph(s)

WWW.GHSCOSTING.ORG