Upload
others
View
1
Download
0
Embed Size (px)
Citation preview
LOS ANGELES2321 Rosecrans AvenueSuite 2250El Segundo, California 90245310.297.1777 telephone310.297.0878 facsimile
WURTS & ASSOCIATES
SEATTLE999 Third AvenueSuite 3650Seattle, Washington 98104206.622.3700 telephone206.622.0548 facsimile
October 17, 20083rd Quarter Research Conference Call
Eric J. Petroff, CFADirector of [email protected]
2
Agenda for Today’s Call
1. What Just Happened?• A brief recap of market activity from an historical perspective
• What caused recent market volatility?
• What are our options?
2. Looking Forward• Domestic vs. international equities
• Currency considerations
• US large vs. small & value vs. growth
• US fixed income markets
• Distressed debt
3. Concluding Remarks
3
What Just Happened?
4
Summary of Recent Events: Irrationality & Panic!
800
900
1000
1100
1200
1300
1400
1500
1600S&P 500 Daily Values (as of October 13, 2008)
Government induced psychological turnaround
Source: Yahoo Finance
Irrationality & Panic!
5
Market Behavior is by No Means Unprecedented
6 5
15
32
74
125
0
20
40
60
80
100
120
140
Down >50% Down 40-50% Down 30-40% Down 20-30% Down 10-20% Down 0-10%
History of Rolling 1 Year Losses: # of Observations
S&P 500 = -33.8%(Oct. 13, ‘08)
S&P 500 = -22%(Sept. ‘08)1 Jun-32 -37.7
2 Sep-31 -33.6
3 Dec-29 -27.8
4 Sep-74 -25.2
5 Dec-87 -22.5
6 Dec-37 -21.4
7 Jun-62 -20.6
8 Mar-38 -18.6
9 Sep-46 -18.0
10 Jun-70 -18.0
11 Jun-30 -17.7
12 Sep-02 -17.3
13 Jun-40 -16.9
14 Mar-39 -16.1
15 Dec-30 -15.8
16 Sep-01 -14.7
17 Mar-33 -14.1
18 Dec-31 -13.8
19 Sep-90 -13.7
20 Jun-02 -13.4
38 Sept. '08 -8.4
Top 20 Worse Quarterly Losses for the
S&P 500
1 Sep‐31 ‐29.72 Mar‐38 ‐24.93 May‐40 ‐22.94 May‐32 ‐22.05 Oct‐87 ‐21.56 Apr‐32 ‐20.07 Oct‐29 ‐19.78 Feb‐33 ‐17.79 Jun‐30 ‐16.310 Aug‐98 ‐14.511 Sep‐37 ‐14.012 Dec‐31 ‐14.013 Oct‐32 ‐13.514 Mar‐39 ‐13.415 Sep‐30 ‐12.816 May‐31 ‐12.817 Nov‐29 ‐12.518 Mar‐32 ‐11.619 Sep‐74 ‐11.520 Jul‐34 ‐11.331 Sept. '08 ‐8.9
Top 20 Worse Monthly Losses for the
S&P 500
S&P 500 Month to date/4th QTR to date(Oct. 13 ‘08) -13.8%
Source: Ibbotson; Wurts & AssociatesSource: Ibbotson; Wurts & Associates
6
Changing by the Day…by the Minute
Source: MSCI; S&P; Wurts & Associates
This is why we shouldn’t focus on the short term.
09/30/0810/10/2008 (estimate)
10/13/2008 (estimate)
P/E RatiosS&P 500 22 17 19MSCI EAFE 11 8 9MSCI Emerging 11 8 9Dividend YieldsS&P 500 2 3 3MSCI EAFE 4 6 5MSCI Emerging 3 4 4Earnings YieldsS&P 500 5 6 5MSCI EAFE 9 12 11MSCI Emerging 9 13 11Prospective ReturnsS&P 500 6.9 9.0 8.0MSCI EAFE 13.5 18.0 15.6MSCI Emerging 12.5 17.5 14.4
Huge intra-month fluctuations in return expectations
-50
-30
-10
10
30
50
70S&P 500 Rolling 1 Year Returns (Sept. '08)
Strong corrections are typically followed by strong recoveries.
7
The Root of the Problem: A Debt Driven Society
Source: Federal Reserve; Wurts & Associates
0.0%
0.5%
1.0%
1.5%
2.0%
2.5%
3.0%
3.5%
8%
9%
10%
11%
12%
13%
14%
15%
16%
17%Household and Non-Profit Cash & Deposits as % of Total Assets
Cash Instruments as % of Total Assets Cash as % of Total Assets
0.0
0.2
0.4
0.6
0.8
1.0
1.2
1.4
1.2
1.4
1.6
1.8
2.0
2.2
2.4Societal Debt to GDP Ratios: Financial & Non-Financial (June 2008)
Ratio of Domestic Non-Financial Debt to GDP Ratio of Domestic Financial Debt to GDP
Source: Federal Reserve; Wurts & Associates
Source: Federal Reserve; Wurts & Associates
0.78
0.8
0.82
0.84
0.86
0.88
0.9Household and Non-Profit Net Worth (June 2008)
An 11-12 fold increase in financial debt!
An ever diminishing cash position
Steady erosion of net worth.
8
Credit Markets Tightened Strongly
0
2
4
6
8
10
12
14
16
18
20Annualized Growth Rate in Home Mortgages (June 2008)
Annualized Growth Rate in Home Mortgages Average
Source: Federal Reserve Source: Federal Reserve
0
1000
2000
3000
4000
5000
6000Total Lending/Borrowing in Credit Markets – Billions (June 2008)
1.0
1.5
2.0
2.5
3.0
3.5
4.0
4.5
TED Spread: 3 Month LIBOR Less 3 Month T-Bills(October 9, 2008)
Source: Freelunch.com; Wurts & Associates
A 60% drop in lending through June alone
An unprecedented drop in mortgage growth
9
The Cause for Pessimism: As Goes Demand so Goes GDP
Source: Bureau of Economic Analysis; Wurts & Associates
Source: Bureau of Economic Analysis; Federal Reserve; Wurts & Associates
-4.0
-2.0
0.0
2.0
4.0
6.0
8.0
10.0Rolling 1 Year GDP & Aggregate Demand (June 2008)
Aggregate Demand - Rolling 1 Year GDP - Rolling 1 Year
-15%
-10%
-5%
0%
5%
10%
15%
20%
25%
30%
35%
0.0
1.0
2.0
3.0
4.0
5.0
Growth in Lending vs. Growth in Aggregate Demand over Rolling 5 Year Periods (June 2008)
Rolling 5 Year Aggregate Demand Rolling 5 Year Growth in Lending
Debt growth is essential to aggregate demand
Growth in demand is essential to GDP
10
What are Our Options?
1. Abandon Asset Allocation/Market Timing
• Inconsistent with Fiduciary responsibility
• Committees are ill-equipped for such practices
• Difficult for even the best and brightest
2. Do nothing
• Akin to abandoning asset allocation
• Ignores opportunity to acquire discounted assets
3. Rebalance
• Integral to maintaining asset allocation guidelines
• Bolsters prospective returns through acquisition of discounted assets
• Takes advantage of market irrationality
• Positively participates in wealth redistribution
4. Incorporate Recent Events into Portfolio Structure
• When conditions change, portfolio strategy should change
• Opportunities always arise as a result of market dislocations
• Now is no exception
• Rational long term investing is not marketing timing
YTD ReturnTargeted
Volatility
Mellon Global Alpha II -12.6% 5%
First Quadrant GTAA 0.9% 30%
AQR Absolute Return 1.0% 20%
Goldman Sach GTAA -8.2% 15%
Select GTAA1 Managers - Sept. '08 YTD Estimates
1 GTAA – Global Tactical Asset Allocation
11
Looking Forward
12
1.5
10.8
6.4
4.2
13.4
2.2
16.5
9.2
2.4
8.4
1.8
10.7
6.8
3.2
12.6
0
4
8
12
16
20
Price/Book Value Price/Earnings Price/Cash Earnings
Dividend Yield Earnings Yield + Dividend
MSCI Global Valuation Ratios: EAFE, Emerging, & US (September 2008)
MSCI EAFE U.S.A EMERGING MARKETS
Equities Have Become More Attractive
Source: MSCI
Dec. 2007 TTM Sept. '08 TTMOctober 13, '08
TTM
Price to Earnings Ratio 22.2 23.0 19.8
Earnings Yield 4.5% 4.3% 5.1%
Dividend Yield 1.9% 2.5% 2.9%
Implied Expected Return 6.4% 6.8% 8.0%
Source: Standard & Poors; Wurts & Associates
S&P 500 Domestic Large Cap Valuations
Source: Yale/Schiller data; Wurts & Associates
0.0%
5.0%
10.0%
15.0%
20.0%
25.0%
30.0%S&P 500 Dividend & Earnings Yield vs. Subsequent Rolling 10 Year Return
Dividend + Earnings Yield Subsequent Rolling 10 Year Return
0
5
10
15
20
25
MSCI EAFE Earnings & Dividend Yield vs. Subsequent Returns (September 2008)
Earnings Yield + Dividend Subsequent Rolling 10 Year Returns
Source: MSCI, Ibbotson, Wurts & Associates
Earnings Yield = 1/PE Ratio
13
Does History Back Up Return Expectations?
16.8
14.7
13.513.0
9.4
7.8
9.5
4.4
0
2
4
6
8
10
12
14
16
18
6-10 10-12 12-14 14-16 16-18 18-20 20-25 25-30
Trailing 12 Month S&P 500 P/E Range vs. Subsequent Average 10 Year Returns (since 1946)
Source: Yale/Schiller; Ibbotson; Wurts & Associates
Price to Earnings Ratio Ranges
Current range of valuations
14
The Caveat to International Equities: Currency
Source: Federal Reserve; Freelunch.com; Wurts & Associates
-8
-6
-4
-2
0
2
4
6
8
10
12
75
85
95
105
115
125
135
US Dollar Real Valuation (Major Currency Index) vs. Subsequent Returns (September 2008)
Price Level Average Price Level Subsequent 5 Year Annualized Return
Dollar appreciation subtracted 6.5%from US investors return in the MSCIEAFE index during the 3rd quarter.
US Dollar Price Level
Scenarios:
10 Year Outlook
Current PriceAverage Price
Level
Estimated
2018 Price
Level
Subsequent
10 Year
Annualized %
Return
Reverts to Average 86 95 95 1.1
Reverts to 2002 Levels 86 95 115 3.3
Reverts to 1985 Levels 86 95 125 4.3Source: Federal Reserve; Freelunch.com; Wurts & Associates
Sensitivity Analysis for US Dollar Appreciation - September 30, 2008
-17% -19%
-11%-15%
-33%
2% 0%
-17%
6%
-19%
-50.0%
-40.0%
-30.0%
-20.0%
-10.0%
0.0%
10.0%
20.0%
British Pound Euro Japanese Yen Australian Dollar
Swiss Franc
Current & Historic US Dollar PPP Premium/Discount (September 2008)
Current PPP Discount/Premium
Historic Average PPP Discount/Premium
Source: Organization for Economic Cooperation and Development 2007 data PPP data; Federal Reserve; Freelunch.com; Wurts & Associates
15
Relative Opportunities Within Domestic Equities
-13
-8
-3
2
7
12
0.7
0.9
1.1
1.3
1.5
1.7Russell 1000 vs. Russell 2000 P/E Ratio Comparison (September 2008)
Small P/E as % of Large P/E Average Relative Comparison Subsequent 5 Year Rolling Returns
Small Expensive
Source: Russell; Wurts & Associates
Sept. Price/Earnings
Ratio
Sept. Price/Book
Ratio
Russell 1000 (large) 15.0 2.3
Russell 2000 (small) 21.8 1.8
Comparative Ratio (2000/1000) 145% 80%
Historic Average 123% 81%
Source: Russell; Wurts & Associates
Russell US Large vs. Small Cap: Current & Historic Comparison
Small Cheap
Small outperforms
Small underperforms
Sept. Price/Earnings
Ratio
Sept. Price/Book
Ratio
Russell 1000 Value 14.0 1.7
Russell 1000 Growth 16.1 3.4
Comparative Ratio (Value/Growth) 87% 49%
Historic Average 68% 42%
Source: Russell; Wurts & Associates
Russell US Large Value Vs. Growth: Current & Historic Comparison
Large value looks expensive Small caps look expensive
16
Opportunities Within Fixed Income Markets
0.40.8
0.4
2.7
0.91.8
0.9
5.7
1.8
3.8
1.4
10.2
0
2
4
6
8
10
12
Lehman Aggregate Index
Lehman Credit Index Lehman MBS Index Lehman High Yield Index
Option Adjusted Spreads Relative to US Treasuries (September 2008)
Dec-06 Dec-07 Sep-08Source: Lehman
4.9 5.4 5.6 5.6
7.9
3.74.9
5.6 5.4
9.7
3.0
5.2
7.2
5.5
13.9
0
2
4
6
8
10
12
14
16
Lehman Treasury Index
Lehman Aggregate Index
Lehman Credit Index
Lehman MBS IndexLehman High Yield Index
Nominal Fixed Income Rates (September 2008)
Dec-06 Dec-07 Sep-08Source: Ibbotson
The compensation for bearing credit risk has risen substantially
17
TIPs – The Best Risk Free Exposure
Source: Bureau of Labor Statistic; Wurts & Associates
Source: Federal Reserve; Bloomberg; Wurts & Associates
Average Rolling Value
% of Rolling Periods < 1.6%
% of Rolling Periods > 1.6%
Rolling 10 Year Periods
CPI (since 1948) 4.0 8% 92%
CPI x-F&E (since 1958) 4.6 0% 100%
Average Rolling Value
% of Rolling Periods < 1.0%
% of Rolling Periods > 1.0%
Rolling 5 Year Periods
CPI (since 1948) 3.9 1% 99%
CPI x-F&E (since 1958) 4.3 0% 100%
Historic Inflation Data (August 2008)
0.0
1.0
2.0
3.0
4.0
5.0
5 Year Treasury
5 Year TIP 10 Year Treasury
10 Year TIP 5 Year Implied Inflation
10 Year Implied Inflation
Nominal vs. Inflation Indexed (TIPS) Treasury Yields & Implied Inflation
Jun-08Sep-08October 13, 2008
Seemingly silly valuations for TIPs… a compelling opportunity
18
An Opportune Time for Distressed Debt
Source: Moody’s
0
2
4
6
8
10
12
Moody's Issuer Weighted Speculative Default Rates
Trading Strategies
Impact theReorganization
Control Class ofSecurities
AcquireIssuer
Distressed Investment Spectrum
Hedge Fund Oriented Private Equity Oriented
Passive Involvement Active Involvement
A reversal in this credit cycle seems likely
19
Concluding Remarks
20
Concluding RemarksRecap
• Concerns over prospective economic growth drove markets lower
• Though severe, recent market activity is not unprecedented
• The US economy is driven by debt
• Low interest rates and ample access to credit are essential
• Unfortunately high money supply ultimately leads to inflation
• Capital markets have changed
• Prospective equity returns have risen
• Relative opportunities exist in global and domestic equity markets
• Credit risk is being handsomely reward
• TIPS offer a compelling risk free fixed income investment
• The best window for distressed debt investing in years
• Inflation is on the horizon
Recommendations
• Maintain existing portfolio structure and rebalance
• Adapt asset allocation in light of changing capital market conditions