25
Observations of SNR RX J0852.0-2644 with CANGAROO-II telescope Kyoto, Dec., 16, 2003 H. Katagiri, R. Enomoto, M. Mori, L. Ksenofontov Institute for cosmic ray research (ICRR)

Observations of SNR RX J0852.0-2644 with CANGAROO-II telescope Kyoto, Dec., 16, 2003 H. Katagiri, R. Enomoto, M. Mori, L. Ksenofontov Institute for cosmic

Embed Size (px)

Citation preview

Page 1: Observations of SNR RX J0852.0-2644 with CANGAROO-II telescope Kyoto, Dec., 16, 2003 H. Katagiri, R. Enomoto, M. Mori, L. Ksenofontov Institute for cosmic

Observations of SNR RX J0852.0-2644 with

CANGAROO-II telescope

Kyoto, Dec., 16, 2003

H. Katagiri, R. Enomoto,

M. Mori, L. Ksenofontov

Institute for cosmic ray research (ICRR)

Page 2: Observations of SNR RX J0852.0-2644 with CANGAROO-II telescope Kyoto, Dec., 16, 2003 H. Katagiri, R. Enomoto, M. Mori, L. Ksenofontov Institute for cosmic

Introduction

But claimed by Butt et al. and Reimer et al. …

TeV detection from SNRs SN1006 (CANGAROO) => e or p Cas-A (HEGRA) => p RX J1713.2-3946 (CANGAROO) => p

RX J1713.2-3946

Inconclusive problem

Need further evidence

NANTEN supports our results (Fukui et al.)

Page 3: Observations of SNR RX J0852.0-2644 with CANGAROO-II telescope Kyoto, Dec., 16, 2003 H. Katagiri, R. Enomoto, M. Mori, L. Ksenofontov Institute for cosmic

ROSAT X-ray image

8o

Vela SNR Maximum X-ray emission

2oSNR RX J0852.0-4622

Flu

x (p

hoto

ns/s

ec/k

eV)

(0.4<E<2.0keV)

Energy (keV)

1 5 10

Page 4: Observations of SNR RX J0852.0-2644 with CANGAROO-II telescope Kyoto, Dec., 16, 2003 H. Katagiri, R. Enomoto, M. Mori, L. Ksenofontov Institute for cosmic

Radio

Parkes 4.85GHz survey image(gray scale)

Weak emissionSν at 1GHz =47±12Jy=>same as RXJ1713,SN1006.

Spectral index=0.400.15

Page 5: Observations of SNR RX J0852.0-2644 with CANGAROO-II telescope Kyoto, Dec., 16, 2003 H. Katagiri, R. Enomoto, M. Mori, L. Ksenofontov Institute for cosmic

Molecular clouds

Vela SNR taken by NANTEN and soft X-ray image(gray scale) taken by ROSAT.

Around Vela Molecular ridge taken by the Colombia University 1.2m millimeter-wave telescope.

Vela region8

CO integratedIntensity map

NANTEN

Page 6: Observations of SNR RX J0852.0-2644 with CANGAROO-II telescope Kyoto, Dec., 16, 2003 H. Katagiri, R. Enomoto, M. Mori, L. Ksenofontov Institute for cosmic

EGRET

No point sourcein CANGAROO FOV

Effected by Vela SNRand pulsar (2.5deg. distance)

Page 7: Observations of SNR RX J0852.0-2644 with CANGAROO-II telescope Kyoto, Dec., 16, 2003 H. Katagiri, R. Enomoto, M. Mori, L. Ksenofontov Institute for cosmic

Profiles of RX J0852.0-4622

On the galactic plane => molecular clouds(l,b)=(266.2,-1.2)

Type II SNR Density within SNR

n<2.9×10-2 D1-1/2 f--1/2 (g cm-2)

low => stellar-wind cavity

Ti lineColumn density from X-rayangular size

Distance < 500pc Age 1000 yr

Page 8: Observations of SNR RX J0852.0-2644 with CANGAROO-II telescope Kyoto, Dec., 16, 2003 H. Katagiri, R. Enomoto, M. Mori, L. Ksenofontov Institute for cosmic

CANGAROO observations

NW rim with maximum X-ray emission (,)=(132.25,-45.65) Minimum zenith angle 14.6o

=> Energy threshold 500GeV

Observation term 2002 and 2003 ON 97h OFF(background) 89hStereoscopic observation with 2 telescopes (2003) => under analysis

CANGAROO-II 10m IACT in Australia

%30E

Page 9: Observations of SNR RX J0852.0-2644 with CANGAROO-II telescope Kyoto, Dec., 16, 2003 H. Katagiri, R. Enomoto, M. Mori, L. Ksenofontov Institute for cosmic

Procedure of analysis

1.Select clustered event

=>remove N.S.B.2.Arrival time of signal Almost the same

time at shower event

3.Cut cloudy data4.Cut low elevation

data 5.Cut hot pixels

N.S.B.

Page 10: Observations of SNR RX J0852.0-2644 with CANGAROO-II telescope Kyoto, Dec., 16, 2003 H. Katagiri, R. Enomoto, M. Mori, L. Ksenofontov Institute for cosmic

Image analysis

Source position

Distance

Width

Length

Alpha

Width and Length are theR.M.S. of the ADC countson each axis.

In order to reject cosmic ray events as a noise

Page 11: Observations of SNR RX J0852.0-2644 with CANGAROO-II telescope Kyoto, Dec., 16, 2003 H. Katagiri, R. Enomoto, M. Mori, L. Ksenofontov Institute for cosmic

Gamma-ray signal

(ON-OFF)8.0

Results

Page 12: Observations of SNR RX J0852.0-2644 with CANGAROO-II telescope Kyoto, Dec., 16, 2003 H. Katagiri, R. Enomoto, M. Mori, L. Ksenofontov Institute for cosmic

Morphology

Consistent with X-ray and radio

PSFSeems to be Point source

Blue:our dataRed:ASCA X-ray dataGreen:4850MHz continuum

Page 13: Observations of SNR RX J0852.0-2644 with CANGAROO-II telescope Kyoto, Dec., 16, 2003 H. Katagiri, R. Enomoto, M. Mori, L. Ksenofontov Institute for cosmic

max

2

2exp)(

E

E

cm

EAEQ e

e

ee

(-function approximation)

1

)(4

11)(

4

1~

)(

2

2

dE

dEEQ

d

VdE

dEEVQddE

EdF

ee

ee

Synchrotron/inverse Compton model

Source spectrum

Differential flux of photonsfrom the energy loss of electron

:

:

:

:

:

:

:

max

d

V

E

m

E

e

e Electron energyMass of the electronSpectral indexMaximum accelerated energy of electronsVolume of emission regionDistance from the earthAverage time that an electron ( ) emits a photon ( )eE E

Page 14: Observations of SNR RX J0852.0-2644 with CANGAROO-II telescope Kyoto, Dec., 16, 2003 H. Katagiri, R. Enomoto, M. Mori, L. Ksenofontov Institute for cosmic

Inverse Compton process

CMBe EE 2

CMB

CMBTCMBeT

IC

e

IC

E

cc

E

dt

dE

E

3

4

3

41

1~

1

2

2

1

max

2

2

1

2

2

3

222

exp

3

2

4

)(

CMB

e

ee

CMBCMBT

e

IC

IC

E

E

E

cm

cm

E

cm

Ec

cm

A

d

V

dE

EdF

:

:

:

CMB

T

e

Lorentz factor of electrons

Cross section of Thomson scatteringEnergy density of CMB

Page 15: Observations of SNR RX J0852.0-2644 with CANGAROO-II telescope Kyoto, Dec., 16, 2003 H. Katagiri, R. Enomoto, M. Mori, L. Ksenofontov Institute for cosmic

Synchrotron process

hcm

eBEE

esyncCMB 422

329.0

2

1

max

2

2

1

2

2

3

222

exp

3

2

4

)(

sync

e

ee

syncBT

e

sync

sync

E

E

E

cm

cm

E

cm

Ec

cm

A

d

V

dE

EdF

8

2BBCMB

Page 16: Observations of SNR RX J0852.0-2644 with CANGAROO-II telescope Kyoto, Dec., 16, 2003 H. Katagiri, R. Enomoto, M. Mori, L. Ksenofontov Institute for cosmic

One-zone model: syncIC VV

EGRET:Diffuse emissionUpper limits (counts + 2)

Page 17: Observations of SNR RX J0852.0-2644 with CANGAROO-II telescope Kyoto, Dec., 16, 2003 H. Katagiri, R. Enomoto, M. Mori, L. Ksenofontov Institute for cosmic

Two-zone model:

V

X

TeVsyncIC V

VVV

51074

X

TeV

V

V

“Simple”

Page 18: Observations of SNR RX J0852.0-2644 with CANGAROO-II telescope Kyoto, Dec., 16, 2003 H. Katagiri, R. Enomoto, M. Mori, L. Ksenofontov Institute for cosmic

Difficulty in two-zone model

54

3

max

3

max

1074104.2

'5.0

24.0

X

TeV

X

TeV

V

V

Page 19: Observations of SNR RX J0852.0-2644 with CANGAROO-II telescope Kyoto, Dec., 16, 2003 H. Katagiri, R. Enomoto, M. Mori, L. Ksenofontov Institute for cosmic

410

X

TeV

V

VTeVE 4max

5.2GB 2500

X-ray

TeV

0.2GB 10

Need Chandra, XMM-newton results (filaments ?)and more exact discussion (escape time, energy loss process)

(Aharonian, Atoyan, and Kifune)

Too many parameters!!!

Two-zone model:

Page 20: Observations of SNR RX J0852.0-2644 with CANGAROO-II telescope Kyoto, Dec., 16, 2003 H. Katagiri, R. Enomoto, M. Mori, L. Ksenofontov Institute for cosmic

model (Naito-Takahara model)0

22min2

mE

EFdEF

E

20

0

dE

EEdEjdEnEF pE

EE pppp

p

p

,4

max

min

ppp nEj )( to

Page 21: Observations of SNR RX J0852.0-2644 with CANGAROO-II telescope Kyoto, Dec., 16, 2003 H. Katagiri, R. Enomoto, M. Mori, L. Ksenofontov Institute for cosmic

max500 exp

10 p

pppp E

EE

erg

E

V

KEj

Intensity of protons

Differential cross section

dE

EEdNE

dE

EEd pp

p ,,

Low energy: isobar modelHigh energy: scaling model

Page 22: Observations of SNR RX J0852.0-2644 with CANGAROO-II telescope Kyoto, Dec., 16, 2003 H. Katagiri, R. Enomoto, M. Mori, L. Ksenofontov Institute for cosmic

Fitting parameters

0.2 maxE2

30

500

5.0/10

kpc

d

cmprotons

n

erg

EA

Data CANGAROO EGRET diffuse (upper limits)

DOF/2

DOFDOF // 2min

2

TeVE

A

1.3

8.1

max Best fit

Page 23: Observations of SNR RX J0852.0-2644 with CANGAROO-II telescope Kyoto, Dec., 16, 2003 H. Katagiri, R. Enomoto, M. Mori, L. Ksenofontov Institute for cosmic

8.15.0/10

2

30

500

kpc

d

cmprotons

n

erg

EA

30 /505000 cmprotonsn

ergE 50480 1010/

Best fit model

:solid angle of the observed part

Page 24: Observations of SNR RX J0852.0-2644 with CANGAROO-II telescope Kyoto, Dec., 16, 2003 H. Katagiri, R. Enomoto, M. Mori, L. Ksenofontov Institute for cosmic

SummaryOur data strongly favour gamma rays

from neutral pions and low flux from synchrotron/inverse Compton.NANTEN data will give us more

physics.Fine structure allow two-zone model.

Chandra and XMM-newton resutlts are needed.

Page 25: Observations of SNR RX J0852.0-2644 with CANGAROO-II telescope Kyoto, Dec., 16, 2003 H. Katagiri, R. Enomoto, M. Mori, L. Ksenofontov Institute for cosmic

Check of approximation

TeVE 73max TeVE 100max Factor is 1.5, but it does not change conclusion.

RX J1713.2-3946

Full calculation Delta function approximation