%nu~%"ahaa~%d bd ( Scheffe's Method ) 1

~ ~ ~ W ~ ~ ~ W ¶ J D S $ ~ " ~ O U L L Y U K O ~ JIU d

n378Jbl

1. awfl

1.1 aiu 114 57.6

1.2 99tgS 84 42.4

aau 198 100.0

2. 97:

2.1 i i n i i 45 ?I 74 37.4

2.2 ikkd 45 %kk!d 124 62.6

aa u 198 100.0

3. --@-~iainnul

3.1 da:nuflnw 34 17.2

3.2 G ~ u u @ n ~ a a u < u 56 28.3

3.3 G ~ e ~ u i n w i a o u d m 36 18.2

3.4 f i v a ~ a + B ~ ! ~ ~ 72 36.4

oinninJ 2 u~maiin$uniadi dmnu6aurwcraio Biuau 114 nu Wmr3uiaow:

57.6 U ~ Z L W ~ ~ H ~ J BiuaU 84 nu Walguia 8:: 42.4 nnrmasunl&ijaiqdlnii 45 9 S d l ~ a u

$~k 74 nu ~ n ~ i l u i a s n r 37.4 aflmamn d i n i q t ~ u r i 45 ?$u!d ddiuau 124 flu 6mgu iounr 62.6 nr jun iad i i3~m~nia6nw~f Ku1Ja:nuGnwdQluau w nu 6nr3u?auwc 17.2

az5u~~uu#nwinoufiui~iuau 56 nu I "~r?h.S"tbu wz 28.3 a z ~ u ~ ~ a u ~ n w w a u d ~ i u

idluau 36 nu Wmrilu?af~w:l8.2 72 nu ~ ~ P I ~ ~ U ~ S U B L 36.4

huwufdnn~o-s

Emr!Ju5aun: 10.1

&~~u%I~Jw: 9.1

' S.D.

S.D.

a i n

u7n

u7n

sinmima 4 wuiin7agiau%.auu ssiar~a:~mniaflnwuaanwnaauniaaniuflnw t 2 a d i u u w u ~ i u ~ u b l l m w u n n i a ~ n w ~ w ~ b n n run 2 mwnuaaaniaiiohuniau3~ia~mniardeJa

5u~rwuua;rnniuiinw huniwnuei lus : : B udiunaia (i( = 3.49 ) sdafioirsuiri?unub

wuiiu'o ~iaufisiaminian"i~umulauiu L b inuie~~~a:Gnniabun~aw"wui~nmiwnia~nwi u s a m i d n w r ~ a 2 ~ o i a m i r G u ~ e u n i a r ~ i a k a n w n ~ ~ ~ n ~ a ~ m ~ i ~ w u % w u 7 u'n 3 bGnaiu

P OYI du~aulumaFmfi~i~uw"wuinia~nw ae&.LrHudgYmnml.s=d73~aaaniuflnw M B L C ~ 7 P O*C1 iunnunlanu~iuwsnlsd~uma7umia ~ w ~ a i u ~ l n a a n i a unamiu!nw~a:"bG~o~mo~ru:

P a n n G n w uezuwudpuanianlsrd19uaawniu nwo~lua:Guonn uan&o$ua:Cudiuneio

Sn~taslazn7sQiawiau

I dnulaniw 9 r y w i u a q ~ r y ~ i ~ i o d i u d

aluda:Tuadisni aCwiima:w~n~ci;la"us~

m i u i n ~ i

2.lG'naiurw"uaauci nmazni5'ng~aniAnwi- " a "

~ u w u ~ i u " ~ a s m i u ~ n ~

3.6b09"nai~~Gw0~16ani%~i~um5~uw"fipa"~~n:

qm%n~wnii~Pl~za~6"uadGnfiosa "buanipbfin~i

4.ciJ~a5u aCua~ul%amuAnw~niionaau

maSuuniaasu~6ci;liu~~ngaamiuflnw sau

a

Z

3.41

3.79

3.76

3.70

3.66

S.D.

1.05

.98

.84

.96

.83

a:Guniad

huia u

d i u n a i ~

u in

81in

u in

u in

diuna19

ain

u7n

a7n

diunaia

~'nwmznisiiigvi?d - x S.D.

m%m~s i

oinmim 7 w u4ini-ii&apa~auu5~ia ~ ~ ~ : G ~ n i a $ n w " u a ~ n w n a a u n i a ~ n i p a 4 n ~ 8: 2 A'd YUWUFU h t .~~1w~nni~~nmCiwql6~n L V B ~ 2 ~IS~~PF~IU~IN~MI-~GQ~ISJ~U 4 ~ I U V B J

miu#nul !tY~ri illriiu'r%ini5 ~ u l l r u i m ni~uK115~iuynn~ ~ ~ ~ r n i a u 5 ~ 1 ~ ~ a ~ d ~ ~ e J n i w m ~

silua:Cudiunair( 2 = 3.39) ~ d o f i o i m i ~ i l u n ~ ~ ~ u ~ ~ ~ u l ~ ~ ~ ~ l ~ a : ~ u u ~ n usnpin u'o 9 . ~ ~ o a ~ u n i a i a u ~ 1 ~ " ~ a " ~ f i i ~ ~ " b ~ u a r o n e j o ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ i i u ~ ~ ~ ~ r i ~ ~ ~ ~ a r ~ ~ a 1 n ~ ~ u qluamu dnw a~:~oi2 . iauQu.sruin i~~1sran1~~~aaBou~~~~1~1udnw1 o ~ h r i k u i n

a"nwwznisGdau4au

I . .nimolt~ niw LL~~Pl?~Uin3~in~~d9619 7 ~ d s

~ a s ~ ~ ~ , ~ a s n a i s a G n ~ i 1 3.72 1 1.02 1 uin

G u q u n i . i F i o n i 3 P 3 u u n i ~ 2 . ~ 4 i ~ a ~ ~ u k ~ ~ f i l ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ 7 u n l 3 ~ ~ " a ~ e ~ l n 3 b b ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ i

R

3.83

S.D. gasaiau

.98 uin

w"wui6asAu

2 . r i s r ~ u a a ~ r m W ~ ~ u ~ ~ ~ n i u @ n ' w r ~ u r r w ~ a 5 w ~ i n i a

rrne~C~l?ni3&iu~w 7 rrri~ugu I

3.aniuqu~iquau~s:~3ab"aosa'b6<wii~na~G<a~n'urAa

~aiurnc~fi

3.73

3.80

3.89

.97

.94

.88

uin

uin

uin

disanaia

uin

u1n

uin

~ n ~ m a n ~ a d i a w t a u

1 .~Gnai~rss"uaau~unia~n~ia7uaisa~wniaii~Csaaisadat

- X S.D. dasak u

g: 2 n%a1lln1a~n1u3nw1"uuwuz1u

4Pd *Gpri:u81~~wisananaz&u .05

oinaisls12wuiinia~iauiauu^a'~113 ~a:Caniaflnwaasnwnmunia~niuflnw w A ' 2 d 8 4jUWuz1u 1u~~awuwmaWn w6wqTan t.~a 2 d~t .amaiuaiy nsTmuniwaau unr

PC) d t.~uslu$ayn$a ~ n a i u ~ n ~ i s ~ a ~ i s ~ ~ u ~ $ 1 " ~ ~ 1 s z n m w a z & u .05

sau

I

- x I S.D. / - x I S.D. I

3.28 .64 3.71 .67 -4.40' .OOO

Df MS F Sig.

3 1 .lo7 1.358 .257

n a ~ac~~erunJpumniadaz413"uaanniu aau

flnwi

F

.509

.639

a n ~ w n~aidaw+aarIwn-tap~%~a uazGan1a4nm

8. lnmiu trse niau~vlls rser

&qu~~ia~iyriibs"a"b~"bunia hrGuwiu~kriynaina6au~niu

8n.w

aau

SS

1.696

215.677

217.374

1.160

117.460

118.620

Sig.

.677

.591

rswis~aiu

rsdad~aw

arvl<ian+u niulun+u

aa u

am<ian+u niulundu aa u

Df

3

194

197

3

194

197

MS

.585

1.112

.387

.605

oinains 14 wuiiniaitiau<auu3'~1ia bba:~mnia;nwi aadnwnaaunia " iY '4' d

miuflnw+uwu~iu I n r r a n w u ~ n i a ~ n w i f i ~ ~ T ~ n Law 2 Lnn iwnu wuiinisiisniu

mm%i~o'nnim~uan"unia~m.iiimar~~n~naanioaflnwaaswniu~nwi uwndi~niar i i~ l i i i

Pa"hKyw1d~fiG

~dafiaianri3iu~a w u i i ~ i ; a ~ n ~ a ~ n a ~ u ~ ~ n n ~ ~ ~ K s a a e j i ~ ~ i ~ G u ~ ~ ~ w i ~ ~ ~

un~a"uQa 2 n i a ~ r i n a ~ u ~ ~ u a a u d a m a : ~ ~ n ~ w a n i a ~ n ~ ~ u w u ~ i u a a ~ ~ n i u ~ n wuii and

inaiu~~nndidn"uaeiid~~e~h$rywid~nw~a:~u .05 $C~$dlG.ii immm~ap~~nPae~'~~w" nu ~

naiuuwnh~ao~~iir~~nTmul.a" ?~~ataadbd (Scheffe's Method ) L%ATIU~ dmngrrngd

~uwimdi 15

d m1n9 15 ~ I ~ L ~ P ~ ~ ) E I L ~ ~ ~ ) E I U W ~ I ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ I L Q H ~ ) ~a~n~ailiau+auEPa.vl~a ~~a:$mn~ainw~

8: I I d unsnwn~~un1a~n1u3nw~uwu~1u lunmwu~ln133nww'w~T~n tun 2

~ ~ u m w j d i i ~ ~ n a ~ u f d ~ s n " u luvj 2 I C n a ~ u t A u ~ a u d n m ~ : ~ ~ n ~ m a n ~ ~ 8: X Wnu1uurtu21uua~no1dnv-i

I J a n u 1 L u u l n w I Gsuulnw 1 d3n~ryini

wniwnia~dapdJaar%pdni~~1%ia

ua~ihniaGlnw3

rrw4ma1.u

rrd.snl.sau SS Df MS F Sig.

ina aims 16 w u i i n i a i a i a u i a u G ~ i a u~z<aniaGnwi wasnwnaaunia " 2 ' ~ m u R n w G u w y m ~univmu~uniafi~6iunia~aniab6uan"vb~n~ub~av^ania w v i i

naauniaCld~q9ni~nweiian"uagiiasa"au I FJ dnaiuuandia~uoeiiadGub6~wismRG

$az<v .05

~ d a f i ~ i a m i ~ q u m u ~ a w v i i ~~mv~nGainaiu~~aniis5uaiisGpa"u6i<ywiaw5G

&zgv .05 o n ~ ~ u G a 4 I ~vqunia~mflisiav~mam~~~~b6uan"v4iuau~~"auu d d nianuuinu wniwwicsna~~fiouasquau ab~z$aynouwdibqu !aiuanhscu %dn'PIinia

nawaur~uvr~uunaiubban~iawoc~ib'ib~u~au"b.a' i k a s ~ a d a j l (Scheffe's Method ) b ~ u m u d

d m n g u n & l u a i a i a ~ 17-23

~~a&~niaan~i

8. R % J R ~ k ~ ~ 3 u n i l i s i u i a u r h as6ni~w^.n"n&Sn^s~Gn

rsnlaelral~

a z ~ i i s n $ u niuluntju

ss 13.069

171.092

~f

6

191

MS

4.356

.882

F

4.940*

sig.

.003

~ i n m i ~ i a 4 17 WEI~I~IL~&J " ~ a a n i ~ ~ 6 j a u < a u ~ l 3 ~ 1 ~ ~ ~ w z ~ a n i ~ i n w I u ~ a 2

r i ~ a 6 ~ & ~ l ~ u ~ ~ ~ z ~ m ~ i ~ ~ u u ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ n n d a ~ % u ~ u ~ t i u u ~ ~ ~ ~ i ~ u u a ~ i a ~ a ~ a ~aanwna~a~n13 E I

~ m d n n v i u u w u ~ i u ndd2~f i ryruim~$u1~ ~ ~ ~ O G u f l n i a u u aszid$?OliauuGnw a a d

maudsiu n'u~9~~uufinwimau6ue,ai~~~mneiian"uaeiiaf p a " ~ h ~ ~ w i i ~ a r n a w ~ ~ $ ~ l .05

87fl'97379 18 ' Y I I E ~ ~ I F ~ L Q ~ U 9 1 ~ 9 n 7 3 & ~ ~ ~ < ~ ~ . F I ~ H 7 3 b b ~ ~ < f l f l l 3 6 ~ ' ~ % ~ < a 3

i?uo'nmywn7-i5in w qdmninidnw ~~eekd~~iluduusu"b~~ri$~u~awdu~m~~e,a~a ue- E 3 dcc n u

'birnu7md.smurod6 u s ~ n ~ n ~ ~ u r n ~ r n u ~ n ~ " u ~ w u ~ ~ u ~na~auauuinwnsu6u n'u dcc n u -piaiauuffnwmoudsnu laa~~nar~aunuuinwna'~b~u ~.FI~O~~QJ i n a w u n n h a

end n'Pdoei148$u h < q w ~ ~ ~ n m w a : i ? ~ l .05

uaa<mnixfinui

1. ?~?uniads~~v~rououwuiu~w%

ssd sd 57-14

azwiisn(u

SS

10.187

Df

3

MS

3.396

F

3.616*

Sig.

.014

6 I l T l d 24 (d0) wni~niaQdauh~%unim%ia

uaa-iYmni3flnwi

9. i a u 6 i a ~ T ~ r i i K a l - a ~ncunriaa

~ % m ~ ~ " ~ u A ~ ~ r i n ~ r ~ n : ~ n n i n a ~ u 7 lu ~ n i u G n w i

10. !6%nia11dabw%s~lswuiu"b%

ihuiadunisnPmia$mnia6iunia

'~1%ia$a!d~aa~niuGnwi I Tau 1 228.889 1 197 1 I I

rrwdsaaw rrdmd-ra%

a:vliianqu

niuluntjol

aa u

a:wiian$u m u l u n i u

SS

3.196

172.481

175.677

10.550

21 8.338

Df

3

194

197

3

194

MS

1.065

.889

3.517

1.125

F

1.198

3.125"

Sig.

.312

.027

an~a'PbCa I l6a"un7r~~is~~~i~uau~a7aIGi6apb~a~~Ipbn7au^a~7aCmn7a67Pa^a~7

m r u s ~ m 7 d n w 7 , sin 2 iikuiaa~un~~rl~wumu7a3~7u^a"11~n7nadm7udnw7, $a 3 ii ri?uiaulun~~~~merlu~i(eran"u~m~m3dnm"~a~m~u$n~ . %I 10 l$a"un~3~isnkJv~aa

ua~nu1u1~~ri?uiau1pbn13u~n13Cmn1~&1un~3u~n~a~a~d~as~n~u~nw~, 6 1 1 a iJ~6a .1

~ ~ n r u u l n tu,a s j1~sinw7a7n7r~o1ui YRT n~5mduiasam7u8nw lwiiin dduai iqdqm Lasr $9 12 i a u C ~ u n u i n 7 ~ ~ 1 , n r ~ n 7 ~ bbam$au~as~n7udnw w u a 7 ~ ~ m n d ~ a

~us~~t i i l i u f f in ' ay~~n 'u .05 ~ a l & 4 ~ n 1 3 n m n a u ~ ~ u u ~ ~ u u n a 7 a ~ ~ m n d 7 s " ~ a a d 7 ~ ~ ~ a ~ m u ~ ~ " a %

Y ~ J L T ~ L ~ (Scheffe's Method ) i,%mu$ n1nn~wniYaIum7asi 25-30

Qinms17ma 28 w . u i 7 6 ~ ~ a i u ~ndniaSiau+au.ufwia ~ ~ s : ~ w n 7 a ~ n w I u ~ o 10

%K%".uniaui~& w % u a ~ w u ~ e ~ % ~ ~ ~ a u ~ a u % u n ~ a ~ l ? ~ ~ ~ w n ~ ~ ~ ~ u n ~ m ? w ~ a ~ a ' b d ~ n d m ~ u t 3 d d P U d n w ~e~nwnaaurnaaniuGn~14~uwp.b~1u nu?su~uuGnwweudsiun".ua,&d3:nuGn~7

d d P U ~~a:wu~auauu4nwwouda7un"~1~&~~a~~ia~u!d ina7uwnri7~n"uari7~SCohBT~w7~ a n d anwwa&k .05

m n m l n s 30 wu416i~aiu " ~ a s n i a i ~ a u + a a r ~ l ~ ' ~ ~ i a ~ ~ a z T m n ~ a R n w I~QO 12 t 2 d a ~au~m~ssuiniar~~~:~niw~~am~au4~osaniwfinw"11asnwna~unis~niu~nw"~uwu~iu wu

d& n u a8ois-uuGnmmeudn1un"~l~6dsznuinw7 muacoluauufinwimnud~iun"~a6fi~sMim4~u~E] dci o w dci na- w ~ ~ e u a u u i n w ~ o u ~ u n " ~ ~ ~ d ~ z n u i n w ~ ~ ~ z w u ~ e u a u u ~ n w m o u 6 u n " u ~ 4 f i ~ ~ i m " a ~ u ~ n ~

no d inaiu~~andisKuaeii~iCuhBi~miswnmwaz~u .05

uaz~mniaflnwi radxd-iaw SS Df MS F Sig.

%mm I csau 1 137.091 / 197 1 I I

~mudnwmiunaiudi~du ~ a m a i u 1 csau 1 165.374 1 197 1 I i

~w~damslamqu

4.iaufisiamirrda~ad&nw7~az/

csau

cszaiimt$

136.889

4.792

197

3 1.597 1.930

~ d a f i o i a m i ~ 3 u a i e r C a ~ ~ ~ i i $a 1 dqAnaiu~~u~a~ldunia~m"fmuaiuu~nia

6i~Guaiudaz4i~uaa~niufinnum , $a 3 6b%nai~.l~Gu~au~umeraiuuw niai i ~Guaim a9 xniu

3n.wriausuuarwidommam~u, $a 5 Piat.6~ RUuqu L L B L L ~ U ~ ~ W I ~ G ~ M B ~ ~ ~ ~ B J ~ I ~

!~d~~w~ii!beiiaa~~~~nuniw~uniapdaub~~aii~n~uuaa~niu~nw u ~ z ~ a 7 irinaiu

=hado &~LR%J &uqu nia6i~iiu~iuluni~iiod~niuGnw ~ z C a a d ~ u % ~ i a ~ ~ i u ~ I 6 ~ u

uounu~uoin~d~u~iuKu~an"a~ss"~a~iiauw&~~o ~mndianirarii~iiriuh~yA3zKu .05

umiu 6 2 ~mn~~uz~CiniadQud~a ~~n?luu'nunwioaainni.ihriiusiuuas

~niuf lnw, Q 4 i a u ~ o i a m i l r d a ~ a ~ n i ~ w z ~ ~ ~ ~ n w a y n ~ ~ u n i a m i u n i ~ f i o 9iaamiu

f i n ~ ~ l u ~ a l ~ d l ! , ~ u LL~zFl'218JLMUIZX~ LLQZ $9 6 ~"uw~I~J~~%R'~Iu L%~LLF~ECEI bH~aa~%l' lbl l lT

i i ~ G ~ ~ i ~ m i ~ n i a ~ o ~ ~ ~ a e J s i u G u ~ a n " a ~ a a ~ n i u ~ n w ~ u ~ ~ a u ~ ~ ~ ~ e J !ai~~mndian"u %!n"

~iniannns~1~fiuu~~e~unai~~~~mndia9iaaeii~~~u~ae~"b.a" 3haamrd~d (SchefFels Method )

11nn~ws~aIumimai 34-37