uttlt 5

apJHa ofi :J:rurua uas{orruouuv

&la a ,. ,i , r,a d idn r: ? 0uR t.tu [lJ1r n 1: flnu 1n1?v4u 1fl'l: [lJ 0uur[:J 0 { 10 r RlJ: }1 1t fl 0'l u fln! 1Yt lr

t A a v a I v--fla0010.tf,o]uflnu1 fl{frod1uflt lu[1nlruyrfl'r5flflu1lrtuuf,nu1 [In l7 crt4?nux0dlufla

-toRlltlufln uns t 1o[duo[[us n{u

J AU? 9t fitl: v d.tfi.u o { n 1: xo u

A a . ,.i t e a < a dl. [fl oflnu r:rfrun 1?crJu ]n15[In uuu n{10lrJU:141:fl611uf,nu 19t1lJn?1!nn I ul; 4 e 4

10{RsHdOU d':nn dlun i 1Ul,ti9tvruTn'l:flnu ]!f ulJflnu1 [10t l7Aa ! A

2. llloflflll:vn !:Cd tHn1o{do',rufln!',1d.:nod1uflt1u[ln uTn'ltflnu'luru!fln!'l

r10 17

i a s v i t e. r.i t ,t a d3. [Y{ of,nu'ln ?'llJ dlrllu !:slJ 2'l tfl'l']e ru 1n1: [ua uu[[I n tlo{4x:111: f,o ]uf,nu 1

l; a vnu :ydYl! a10{do lufl nu'l d{nnd'lufl {'lut,uglYluYlfl l:fl nu'llttu!flnu1 [19t l 7

4. rutrofinurnraydrirnr:uJ6uuuila.iro.rriu3ilrrd0rudnufi.i{narioil:sfiyrr'nrat;

r,0.tflo1uflfl!'l fl.:nndruntlurl0tfluTnl:flnuurgrJflnu1 [19r l7

?tolluunttl0u, .L_tvnlfltnlir l nt:20u, -ioya ashe' e svcv d.i d s 4:rTln:m tT tunl:'ltu tnrrfl n: alou d.:nad1 n.: lualgllruT nl:flnHlu tul]flnu1

IA[19] l7 tU nl:flnU] 2557 r'',ru2u 1,200 ftu (ri'lun,:lulufl umnltflnulututlfln! 1 rln 17.

2558:17)

n ii u fra od r.r ifl ff lu n r :?o'a

' io yo l;n 0u 0t ?ou1':Yl t, tu n 1: ?n0 tnttn fl :Hd0u d inod tu n{1unJ9tyIlJfl n15dnu1

s4"oo,olJrurJflfl!l rxer l7 tu nlrflnur 2557 fi'rfiua1u1010.rnarJ0t?ou1{ lnu1.i9t1:ltrylu!14'l,it

n{ rL eri:o drr t o.:rn, nqudc!o; lrnu (Krejcie and Morgan.t970 : 607 - 610) n1n :vninrdtu?u

1,200 nu ldrfnrrurtndufinr:f,nurt-roldnur rrjn 17.2558 : rz)'ldturondln-:odr,t91 9t4

291 nu un?duou'r{ ilu9r t!dnd?u10 {n; qJd0uun a, do tudnu 1

6l

2 glou o':u

i a .L-tn:o{tJoYtltl nlt?ou

zi a io ero d e o !' lre , ' dlln5otlovl ti tu n1t [nu:']u:'uJ.[oxa tunl:2tun5.:u tnllfl ulllJdouo'lu [[1Jl[tJu

i e" ,i t e a <n0uvr I uuud0uolrJn12v4uln1:[uauuulja{10.l4utt4 rtfl01uflfl!1 fl{nn

t A A c < I 9 9 n9 | 9 ,/ ddtunllur19r11uvtnl:flnutlJtt lJfln!'l [1j9 l7 lJ:vnouf, ?u 4 nlu lnufl l ) fllufl ltd:llu'l:lJ

9 9 - v 9 q,a dq '

o I 42) n1 n1rd51.rur.:1Juo1n tn 3) 6run1:n:velu tfl[nnlYl?uUiuiul 4) n'run1tfl1u.to.r

unrnnlnRn) , Cl 4

9rouyr 2 urJlJdorfl llrrJ:sf, vriH010'1d01uflnu1 fl {nadlun{rulxnfl umnl:flnu1

n-turf,nur rxer 17 ilrynoudau 4 dru lduri t) drunrr!dltrrtol nufla^nu-niiouhifi- I . I qea'

ndrqyltyll':nr5[tuu0{1u 2) nlun?1!dlx1:n tunltfl glu run[:uu tfi u flfl nYl1i!?n,-rid9c9{

3) 6]Un21!d1U1:O tUnlt :UI AUUUnC OIUI tt{[:UU 4) n1Un2llJd',ll|l:O tUnlllrnlliU]'11

nroluI:.r6ouav

RlflnU:',lUt?tt,t 0 a

e,osheo ^ " - -l10U t6nl[UUnlt 9t1!Alnu n{U

l,l 4 4 ,ol. rr?n uljoltu { dot 1flljfucvl9r?Ytulnu ! 'l'lltulau:lYR0:1tvl :t0l o{flo'lu'lun'lt

t:{r:uu tud.:flfrdlufl{1urua uYtnlSflflu"tlJf uuflfl!1 nJ 9t l7 rvl01ofl?'lut?ul.lo tufllt

fl1?nu.u . 9 . o au r a I I

2. rd?nuuluuud01Jfi 1ri :0!d1[u'rfi uId010n?1uI?1ru0 tufl 1:Yl'l?rufl { tfl un

do1uf,flu 1 lvt010n?1!:?!!on1fl f]a!n?0u'l{ 1u n r: eror r rr r dor o rno d .ra u . a d

3. nl uolu tu n1: lnll : ?1r r ?r.r [[uurl0uo llJ uaSrJ?0u0'lruu n1:rfl lJ: ?1Jr?lJ

lrlr x doll 0 1!d'tugru [o{a ay

fl1r?tnr13fi10 4ltl. n:?0floun?tuf,!u:0ru0{u]lUf,ouo'lLtunayauu

z. rirnr:ar:ria{oXalunoln'lnof rrocfi lrird6nlnul#1il:un:ldrri rgrJ4 ?9 i - 9o

'.i I I a a'3. ?rn:1gfi10tJntflu?nun1'l3il1J1n1:nlau rn la{'uo'tfl 1t:1.11: dft1 flfl}r"r d.rflo

l; . '- . ' j " , )tirrinlrunrnfiuffnr: Anurfr uuFnur rrn l7 lnunr: rrirrq6u ( x ) drurfiu.rruu!tn:glu

(s.o.)rflu:rudruuaE:turloufl?drrirrq6u1ilriliuurfiou6'lrnorqilunr:u afl?tul.trru

tllun?'rnsrruu

62

a ?e i - { c. e q s ! A4. 1ro5 rs14xOrArfl U?nr :vflYlIHn1,o.ldo]ufl nu1 dInndlun.: lu[19llru1l

nrr Anu ru-r uuftn!'r u,n l7 lnunr:rrrirrc6u ( x ) riaurfiurruu! rfr: ! lu (s.o.t ri.lu:rudruinrs .d t cr ,

runs:ruiorlii? '1flllqau l [ :urlYluunulnor.n [unt:llu nn?lufiululuua?{fliuuua J v v 4 r ," ,i t 9 - a

5. ?[nt]vt4fi?'ludtJY{uf tt?t?1.:R1'tu4u1n'l:[Unuuulln{1o.t4x5fi'l:dn1 fln!1lAaoasnu ::rimtfla10{dnlufinut ri{nedlun{lurxgrYluYln'ltdnuluru!flfl!1[1sl l7 tnufil

- I o q 4 a avritilil:g dmt ar duuutitolttttlidu (Pearson's Product Moment Correlation Coefficient)a ? ,. ,; , e a < i '6. ltn:ls nr?sfi ]nr:r au rr n.:10't,iu: fi 15 d01ufln! lylfllHan 0u:vdTt Ha

! A d s 4 s st txo,:d01udflu"t d{nori'lunt'lu[10t11u?1fl]:flnu"[trulJfln!t tun I tou lYdun'ltlI0lnt

otir.r.iru (Y =a+bx)

oluflonrt?o0

" ,i t e a 4 ian1nnl: dnulfl r'ls ri 1nl:r nuurl n{10.1r{u:1.,l1: fln]uflnu lYlll9{anou t e dYlI Ha

j j 4 s '. r -vny- jr,0'1flo1udn!1 d{nn6lrun.:1ur1nY{umn1:flfl!1!!ulJflflu1 [1n l7 fl!uHanl:']tu tnn{u

,j , ,a 4 - d 9l.:cquRl?vtJulnl:[unuu[[lJ0.11o{rJU5?t]td01uflnu'l9lltJfl?1unalfiu1o{ng4d8u

drn-n drrin r ru rr nntru fi n t: f ns r!-t u!f,nu 1 tr n t z loo:rrrtast{lu: rudtuo{lu:ro'ulrn

(x:+.tol fic,rnrlrirrqduornrilnlililrtiou: duniuu:n 6o drunr:n:v{ul#rfinrlrirlqqr

tx=+.:r)drunr:n'rfirdrrJrrsnqnnn(x=+.to)uavdrunt:dit{u:{fu61d1i(x:4.0s)t'Leeolunldn nlunDdrl.lulrlJ unnaau ( x = 3.92) srl!.irniu

,. ra r rr - < - d In1'rsri ln1:r auurr a{10{9i 1l:141: dfnuflflu'l 011!n?'l!flnl u10lfltHd0u"i

, a a .' e e s c sri{n6rilun{1u[1nfluYrn1tf,flu1ututJflnu1 [1n l7 n lun1: dt'1.:[t: luun'ld tn tnutllJ[[nvdt e ; h | , a 9alilu:luioou lu:uoutJ'ln (x:4.08) [: u{n lla a ut]fllrlfl tlJfilu0u 3 ounuusn flo fllj:11'15

4 a A- , a qY q dl t rttx rtJ'll.t u 1u tunr:vrl r'rum Ynrou (x=4.32) rJUsHllt a ?'luflu tiru unl:d ?u9l ?[tn 4 5 ?1r.rlu

'a 6 I 9' s c 4 aunarR ( X :4. t 8) {ui u1:rj0uersl0{:11l {lu lnufi'lu {o{n?luunnn1{rvfi? 1{!flnn ( X - 4.13)

. ,.i | , a e9tr nro1rft1unr23ruu1fl1:11tnuuulta.:1a.:fltJ:l,t1:flfl1ufln!1911!n?tuflfilU0.:n:Hfloul; 4 , aia' ;:

d{na dlun{ ru lfl9rllur n'l:flnu lut ulJfln! 1 [1,9] I7 nlun1:6111{u:.tuuq ta tnTlJntlnou n1(o.r 9A oerd I e-a ,j c oi,o d 'n-o {.u:vr:rrao rbirfiudrnrr!sl-': trou'r.:uu?rlumnsm'r{ru t d1[r 0nrlJfifirilun ( x = 3.87)

,. I ^ 4 a d tfl'l?vr.lu]n1:t nu ttu n {10.:}l1l: fi l: flolu flng 10t1ufl'l'lltftotl.t ula {fl l r.l dou

drnhdrrinrrurtornjufinr:f,nsrrt-r0r,dnui rler tz drunr:n:sdul#rnoryr{{kurur loa:.:rdt e,

lunsluu:'lu,i,o0u tu: yn u! 1n ( x:4.31) Guifilrq6uornurnlilH',lriuo : ,r''r6',r,,rn 6u,va -.;,,{uinr:rirra3lhi{irrr':ru:rrliltgnrlnronr:1#nrqnarrron'itn'n!6nr#uriruil": tx=c.ct)

63

, a I q yir't 9 a I c 991l{u:r1:n:vr_{u trli:'r!.:]uuo.lljEufl1tu nluu':rlu (x:4.41)4u: 1:n:sq tlr4:x!{1

,j,lJO{X11ltUH14nOU1{tJ?t [[n t1 (x 4.35) d?UR]?U4U',ln1: runUUrluA r1O{'JU:H]:dO]Uf,nu r

l; 4 sn1!n2]!na10{ft: r,r6rou fl{ nn fl'ru n {'ru rlJn umn15fln!]rJt0!frnu1 [1er l7 Fllunlrntsdu

hirfinrnirlrgryrfifirirro6oer'rqo 6o {riur:n:vdu1#{irlrrunri6nl:1flrj 1lr1#lunr:rJfrr5lru ti:+.zo)

,i,ra4aden r?cfl u rfl r:rrauurrrjaltordrir 1: d0rudnur rnufl ?rrlfl nlfi uto{nt fl fl ou"a, . '

d.:flod'rufl{rurllsruumnr:flnurl-r u!f,nu1 [1n tz rirunt:airrrr:i ]nu:':ruuastflu:rurlo

o{1u:vniulrn (i::.sz)Gu{rirrq6urrn!rn'lilfirrJou so'uniuu:n do nr:rirr:rruto'r

{1uinr:rilufiuoriurolqfielrru r x =q.zal {uinr:1#1onra{drluu}{6uu$dr1rrj r,'"'rorlrdoon.,l: ti=aorl {d'll.:ruliarllolunr:ilfrrior-.rrutos{rirr:1i:+.oolt tt " ,i t I a 4 a )

d?uR't?s Eu 1n rt [I auu [[U aw0{HUtlrlrdn]uflnuln1un?r!nn10.:R; td0u d{n6d1un{1uJ : "

- qr ara , i I[1n11Umnr:flfl!1Uf UUdflUl [1n l7 n1Un1tfli1{U"t: YrrJfl',rlqnUnlqn nO n',lrlr'l{'ruflo{

a' A- a,iu:r.r1:[ uYrUuooro':ri: ?!t1u ( x : 3.67)

nr':sr?rirnr:uldouurln.:to.r#r3r r:aoruf; nur nrrunarrrnor# uto.:n: flaou"J,

a @ . t

, o<d eflnna rilun {'lu[lJgtltuYln t: flnu'lut u!flnu'l [1n l7 Frlunt:nlu.:0{ nltnqRnn [ou:?!tlovd' e, ) s' ,'ltJutlul00qlurvfiutJ]n(x=4.10)[:u{nlrqnu0ln!1ntu lu0u30 nu[r5fi fr0 4u:lJr:

f - s^ ' ,' |/ a - I ^ , o 9rttJfluelel04s?u{lu4nnun?Un?llJqnr::u(X=4.28)4u:fi'l:n:squt 4:2u{ lu Yll.tluflu

rij u fi l ldo d r { fi il : v A m ; n lv{ ( x : +. t r) dr u n r : n" r u' r d r il o ro n rl n o a fi i ri r n6 trel' r q n 6 o

{ui u r: aulu aq u 1u n r : uior u r 1 nri u r 0 { au ro.: ( x : 4.09)

z. il: v?vrinato{doruf,n! r drn-n dru-nr rurt,nj,fin-,, flnr lr-n ulf;nur rrn t7

lntr:rrruavrflu:rudru o{lu:vnillrn ( x: +.oo) Gu{rirrqduornurnhJnrr?ou : oiu6'ru:noqd - I . t s ,

n0 alufi?]lJ dlu 1:0 tun ltY{oru 1ufllt uu tll!Hafl!fl?rrml{n1:r:uu(J{rJu tFru:']tJu0u:luI0

oqjlu:rri'ulrn (r= 4.24\ drunarrraur:olunr:rJirnJiuur(ruuraorufinur 1i: +.otl, o 9cf,lUfi?1udru150 tunl:un1qfilRlu tudolufln!1 (x- 3.92) d?uu: u flyrt fln10,:dnluflnu'l

! A a e a aad.: n n fl 1 u n.: r u lr.i el yl u yt fi t t fl n u r n-r u u f, n s r [x n l 7 dr u il : s d yr t- n a r o l a o r u Fin u r fi i],i:ae

rirrqdueirflo n-o drunrruarrr:olunr:niorurtinGuu}4!n?uno^vn.:u?n ( x:3.84)

il : y fi yr i H o t o.: a o r u fi n u r d.r rin d r u-n.: ru o sr du fi n r : fi n u r n-r u u dn s r rl n l z

e q qra - ! . f s c' en1ufl?1ufl'DJr:o tuflrsTtolulunr:uu tt4 rJHn riuqr !yn.:nl: Ii uu0,!1iu [au:']urlnylilu 5]utio

oqjlu:rn"'ulrn ( x: +.za) 6u.:eirrqduornurn'hJfirrlou : o'udilu:n fio dn6uuarlt:oe;rJil:;rduornnr:6oufrrnvil:raunr:oildodr.:qndo,:(x-+.qz)u-nriuufim-nuylunr:

64

eu 4 e ' j

rld?{firnxirli fn nr: G trufuo rnioru rnuro{ otir{ciorfio r ( x:4.43) fn6ou e u r: orirnrn

"-'.iirriuriun ouuac Ha.:rufir;ornrn ( i = +. t s) riaurJ:s?vrG naror eoruffnu r f,ln-ndrrin.rruj i A e 4 e .id , ; ;

[ln1ruYlnlt flnu tllIUlJf,flu 1 [t n l7 6]un?1r,dlut:o lunltllflulunttuuyllrfiltnounlqn no4 a a s, t -gnaSuurl drirqrryn.:nr:aiuu lunqud'l:vnrra:u 5en.l dl d.iiu ( x : 3.98)

:J:yfiyrGnotorcnruenur frrrind rrin r rurrnncufinr: finu rn-t ulAn! r rxn l79 o ordu dt ,f,'tufl't1!d11J150 tufl151{glulun[5 uu trulrflufln 1iu']n t6ut2lJrrngruut rux0 0q tutgou!tn

(x= :.s+) Gflrrirrndurrnurn'[rJnrriou I o'uriru:n 6o rinrsuufinrnHa rrncuoufuf,{

nrruFouluto.r{du ( x = 4.09) rinGourr1url:;lorrirrnnr:dru ,,urn,r,,orur, or',rg, - . tia - ai i n r --fi?ua [0r ( X - 3.94) unr:uurlrJquudrJv{urronur ou n; unvlnnor? trJ ( x: 3.80)

t;d2utJ:vdYltr.talJ0.tdoluflnul d.tfl9d1un{1u[l0tltuYlnt:?lnututt uf,n!1 tln l7.id' i I 4 u d la c,

frlufl?'llJ 6I'llJ'l:o [u n'ltY{oru'lunr:uuYlljfl'ltanun 1qo n0 un[:uu1rfl'] lu:uHntouYln tun'lua q, .i.in c,.n1:r:uuunrvilvrr'[fiiu!0 flr,]u (x: 3.70)

rJ:v?vri Hnroreoruen!r drfietirrinlrunndufi nr:fr nurn-tu!Anu1 rxn l7

drunrrlarrr:o1unr:rJfur:J6ouuieruranrufinsr lno:aluasrilu:rur?oo{1u:vfiururn, ; ' a oe d, i(x = 4.01) r: u{fi In n unrn!]n tufi]u0u 3 ouolJrltfl fr0 dnluflnuldrld:! tl1fli1urJlro,r0u

4-116Y?U:'rlt tUnr:rnnnfl5:lJfl15[:UUfl1:fl0Ufit0fl1t06fl1:flnU110{dn1UflnU1 (x = 4.20)

dorufin!rfinr:drilanr:ilrvru^uluflfirirulrrfluriorynlunr:niorutanrufrn!1 (x: +.r:tv a h, i I q , , a

do'luflnut!nt:nnfl]fi0flqfl:d0luf,nultn0ultdoanaotnun?'lu9to{n'l:10tYl0.l0u

(x = +.ou) rirurl:s?rir.rntoraorudnsr #ln-ndrfn{rurrrrdufi nr:f,nurn-torf,nur rtn l7,.i s 4 i- , i : a 4

n'lufl?1ltd'tln:n tun15utut auullflu"td0lltflnulr!n1[qaufl'ldn flo do]uflnu'tor,,j

inr:niruuirrnsr.liurJ;riinr:n'rrfiurulu1n 1 riru otirrriorfio'radrrflilo (x:3.76)

rJ : v ? vr r- n a t o l e 0 r u e n u r #'r d'n d r rin r r u rt n nju d n r : fi n u r rir u tL f, n ! r rr er l 7

9 6l 'edrun rrr arr r: olunr:uri rur rn rolu eo ruf, nu r Inu:ruuncrfl u:rur?o o{1u:rniurn

(x::.qz)Gu{rito6ro',nr,rnl,lrlr?ou:duriuu:n60 dotuf,nuteirrciunr:irirujruto.l, A a 9.

pJruuayyro.! ou tun'rruRtJru14lIrnr y.tflu'l atoludnu 1 ( x = 4.12) ,iu: fi ]t ua, fl:: ?uri 0nu

lunr:rJfrri6rruuayuri'lxilrunlsir.r 1 lueorufinur (x- 4.06) aoruf,nurfi:surnrra

rirurun-oriniiuuo0r.rI rJ]sd!unyciorfiol (x = 3.82) eiaurl:sfryrinoro{flo'lufin!'tl; 4 q

drrindrrinrrurtflfluff nr:finuru ru!flnu t rln t7 nlun?lrd'rln:o1unt:urirlnrnrnrulu

aorudnurfifirirrn6oerlrqo 6o {u3nr:arlr:ouriltilqnreir.r 1 luanruf,nrrldniu

65

, a9 0 461Ufr1: tirancnrdoluflnul n1: nan0nl l!n1:r: tJufl1: dou fi:olrqnn::l.lxo{un[:uu

( x : 3.80)

,.i , aetR',t1vHUlnl:r nUUu a.:fl 0': U:141:dtillufln!lfl 115vdYtf nnondfi 'l fln!1

" c, . e a ad{norilu n{ ru [1n11urn15fl nulr,ru!f,nu1 [1n 17 !R?1tJdullu! tu :rauu1 nn1.r

odr.ririudra"turrifl6rrfitsriu .01 (r : .623)[ravrl'on'nr:nrrr{Ju:rud'ru u'jl,-" . !

lJfi?llJdtJlltJtfl U fi{Ut;t. nrsrY:1{tl5nuuflla tt flU1l:vdyrf nll0{d0tufln!1 dnfl9dlunnlultgltrl]fl

e s 4d --f,n]tflnu1!tutJflnut [t,n l7 un?1udlt uf tu:rnuIlunnl{0 u'].tlluudln6uyt1t dfin tgou

.01 (r-.. - .+6t) rdon-r r: or rrilu: rudru v{u'i'l t) nr: dir rrrrluiunra 1o rirnaruerur:nX,Y

. 4 . { a s uralunl: grurunr:uu hilJflaai!qYliTrrnl:rtuuqrt,u 1rfl?'rudlrlrur [u:vnuulunnlr- --.ioul.:rJuudlnoiytl{flonfl:rnu .01 ( r .. : .516) 2) n1:dflr{ur{fun1n1! niun?,llJfl'ru1r0

:- o'^'"'a s v,alunltvt0ru'lunr:uu tt4uYlflu an Yl1.flJ 1n un?luduflu, tu:cnu luflat.: 0u1.:uuutllfltu

vrrra6n^fi:caiu .0t ( r- - : .481) 3) nl:flfr{u:{fun1a10 nirnauarlr:n1unr:llriflruu'l- x, Y,

auedo---iRlU tUdOlUf,n!',lUfr',tltJdullUt tU: snu u ]u n a1{ oul{lJuudlnruml{donm:vn1,| .01

'i-a( r : .332t 4\ nr:dir.ru:.:u:unrnh fiin:ru e rr r: olu n r:rji:L rrjfiuuvr"oru rdnrufinu lX, Y.

Yo - l, -^i,n?r! durut lu: soueir ourrtUurirfiiuTrrdosryr:vnu .01 ( rx.y, : .292)

ra a a o o q t A2. n'lt n:equ trlrna[t'r']lJiu6ulnu rydYrrfl nlo.:6Yo ruf, nul d{nndlu n{'rurlglvruYr

vvJa-:---;fl1:flnuluruuflnu'r [,un lT rn?rrdlJllu! tuTUflunl0 u1{uuudlnf}111{d0nYl:v6u .01

,l - & 9 ' 9 o r- d.( r- -: .299) [U oY{ i15 ol]llJul lun ]u Ull l) n1:n:squ tll lnnlX'l?U€Ugu lnun? l! dlUlt o

- 4 . I a . oiolunl:r.r0nun[tuu tfiuflad!qyltyll{n1:rtuuq{1u un?'rudrJlrut lutyfilltlluflal{

- -^i o e aea tcodr.rfirititirflqill{f,finfi:rri"il .01 (r. - = .533) 2)nr5n5ye{uh{rfinrllir1qryt6'uX,Y,

q ,a a q e 4a - ;R?1lJf,11r',rtfr tUnl:[[R]lrUfi1n1U tUdO',rUflnUl !n?',lu6lU11Ur tU:yAUei"t 0U1{!uUrllfiq

vrr.ra6cr-fi:s6'! .01 (r. . : .254) 3) n1:nrsdul#rfinrrr{rltrlrgrri'lnarle ur:nlunr:'X,Y.e e da - : - --iflu luflrtut-t t14lJylf,uflgtyll.lu?n un?1! dlty{u f tu:3o119i1 oul.:uu udlniuT'l,ldft0tyt53nu

.0I (r- - = .226) 4)nrrn:cdul#rnnrrri'flqoJtriufl?tudt!r:o1unr:rJiuuJ6uun-orur-X,Y.

1 I s o ?q - '. -^jdorudnurin?rudruniuilu:snfueir odr,rfiriudrrityvn.:ao6fi:cniu.0l (r" , = .074)

v d Z)l. n15 r'r.:u'l:u fl1Jlj:ydylt fla10.:do1uflnu 1 d{ nndlu n llu [1,nfrufrn lrEn!1u 4 a v q tq - -^;lJDUUflnU',l [19t l7 !n?lUdUy{U! tU:sfiUtJlUnAl{ 0 UltUllUiitn€uyll{d6nfr:ydu .01

. --- ,l - <tt I 9 av( r_ _ - .507) [1Joyrn1r0l1[1ju:1u61u U?',1 t)n1:d51{u1:' nun?]r,dMtolunl:fldnuhGu

66

s6rJ:raruaI t^, c . . -i e e" An1:0nut1u afl1r?iufi:.:u 11lJ: yrnu rilRqrnu?nuR'l?r 4rj tn 1: r nuuu:Jnl10t

e - a ia ! ;llu:fi'r: doluflnu lYr!Hnfl 01o.:do'1uflfl! 1 d{nndlun{lu[1nflumn1:dn!lrrur,finu1

nrn rz niciolilii- ,t. rd t ) a < a dl. nl?utu1n1t[lJauuu a.:10.tHlJ: Itdo'luflnu19l1ufl?'nJfl6lfiu10{ng,i3you

rY{nod'1ufl.:]u119ryluylfl1:fln!lxru!fln!1ltn l7 [n u: ?uuavlilu:1u61u o glu tgdlMn^i-i^^^.<r-..-..---r-"--he,vL<r,,-41r{u0lirrju[]1r'ly4utl. rdo'lufln!t t6fl]un150 5UnOldonlli tli]u,iui ]5do.lufrnu1

ord - / . t a v o ratr4!flad!qrrvrlinl:[:uuIJ.r1u !n?'Drf,u11ut lu:v9uulunnl{ ou1.:uuudlnq l{dnn

fi:co"'u.ot (r... = .637) z) nr:airrur:i dun:rr arr r: olunr: ufifl€u rnrulueorufinur' x,Y

- td - ^^f,lJfl ?llJ dUllUD tU: gnUUlU nn l{ OU'l{UUUd'1fl fliYl 1{dOnYl:CGU .01 ( r : .4651

.-o"oro-^''--'"2) n1:d:1iu1t! nun2t!d'lu'tto lufl'l:Y{aulunr:uu t}1lJflflunnm1{u?n ufl?ludlJv{u!

1u : s n-u r u n n r r o ti r r i riu ti rn"'ry yl r r d 6 6 fi : s n-u .0 1 ( r*,", : .457) 3) n1: dir.:u r: fi fiu

';-vsdd-:,fr?'l!d'lu1:n tun1:ulurunuuYt0ru'ldo]uf,flu'llrfl?'llJdlJ u, tu:vnunl 0u'l'llJu ud'tfltlJ

vrr.:aih^fi:roiu.or (r.... = .235)'x,Y,IA

4. n15fllu': ntnnqflnn nu :udYlrr.rot o{doluflnut d.:nod1un{lutIn1tuYla u rd --.in1:fln! 1r,n u!f,nu 1 rrin 17 !n?1!f,rJYIu, tu:3auUlufla1r ou'r{uu0dlnEuvrl{donflrvnx .01

i - & e ' 04 q(r- . : .623) riiofirr:rurriiu:rudr yruir l) n r:filfr{tlnronq nn oriun?r! drur: o1u n r:- 4 . I a v cia

HAnUn[:UU t?J!Hnd!q tYt1{n1:[tUU0':1U fi?lUdlJltUt t1DE9U(J{ 0U',l{UUUfl]nq

vrrra6nfi:vn"'r .01 ( r" , = .706) 2) nr: rirfi':rhronrlnn o rir aerrarr i:nlu n r:nh u rX.Y r

@ q td --.iunmuu tl4lrflflunnm r.:u ?n lJn?lrJdll11u! tu:voxtJ't nnt{ 0u1{!uud1nq 1rd0n rvou. { o 9a q a

.01 ( r.. .. = .561) 3) n'l:n 1u 'ltJ tlnnq nna nun'lllldlU'lto tu nl: un]l fu?t ln1u tudo'luflnu1-X.Y,

taqt-^-ilJfl2'llldUltUt lUtsnU 'lUnCl.l OUl{UUUrilfliuYll'tdO9lYl:CFl .0l (r*_r.: .543) 4) nl:fl'lU {

:loronqnnn ri'rnarruarrr:nlunr:r.lirui6uuniruurdoruf,nulfin?rldtniuflu:sniu runar'r

^^iouliu urilniuYrlido9rYr:sfiu.0l (r, _ - .381)

eo ,i t e a 4 i'R',t?s,i 1n1:I nuuu n{to{ llt1{1tdo]uflnu'l1ltY{Hoeto :edYl!fl o10'!

IAdo"r1.rflfl u1 d{nqd1 n{1ur19r}11tmnl:fl fl !llJttjl'lflns1 [10t l 7 9.rfl 1lnl:

, ,i to 'iY = 2.U4 + .515Xt4U?U [1r0 X fr0 n110'tR1?eryU1fl',t:I nUUuUA{ uAv Yd',r u :vdmnHnflo.tduluflnu1

67

eej',i1t:141:nirn nr?{ uastn'l:v{0ru'lf,nuR11I',lr0.:9rulo.t6?u'lrnl: nln nlu tiu9a a i c s s a 4 .i ,

ruir;un r:dnu rero 1u:vriuu-tuqinflnu rlfi!Uun ?]r,5 n1t I rtu fl1:ou:ufrluur :vnoldld@d,,i,reqnrlrnriurtluqoxo{nr:r Auuu n {?lno{rinr: 0sdo{rHi[Uliudn1?vn Iit Auuu a i

vrnortinr:6rinrrurirrilufiossiorinr:ril6uurr:Jal d.rrlof'urd':fifi6vrGnacioil:s?ylt^Ha, , r,,10.:otflflt: !0yl511nn0n1: 0uglrtlu:?u11.:d{fiaa0nlt1IOlu'lf,nuRlv{lJo{Inalnta t . - ". a v. A t I v dtuo{nnl: rl r ruuufioR l?s}lu'1fl'l:[1l nuu[[1lo.t f,onfln0{nu { lu?nu10.t !?1YU 110lJU1ll[0u

rnya --.1 e. A t e a 1 !' l(2548 : UmnnUo) tafrn!1?n0$0'l nl?&4u1n'l:[UoUuuIa{10lrJU:11'l:dn1uflnU11u11u!1u

I ; d aq , 4 ,/.6i{nndlun{lurl,nlIuTn'ltdfl!1H 0{a]u [10 2 Hanl:x0u111r?1 nlnnl:flf]u1nl?s4u1

fl1:nJouuu 0itJ0{flut1l'l:doluflnu11ullu!'lu tnunl1lt?ul'lu2'l 4u:fi1:doluflnu1g. ,; t

rir soun 1lu4u 1n1:ru auuuua {og tusvolllJ rfl

z. rJ: c ?mi Ha! orrror;f, nur d.rrin drrinqunrnnjufi nr:fl nu rrir u An! i rtn t7a df - !'! A 4 1lout2uuavltju : luri ru 0q [utufr u!ln vr {u 01 tlu 0.uJ'lt 1n d0'lu fl nu'lurl; [[nc I na ]n:.id , t , 9 a -i<-- - ea q .r afr Ifl '11!5n'llud DJ r:n :snou6lu,{u:11 1:Ylx?duYtfl ulJnnue Iun]:ut]1 1: {'lu

d.lrn.lr.',r".,,,^unaqmf,nr:rJfid6errrluHuir{lu:cu:r:?!fi{r-nselunr:udilcuil1 rj.rvr-nrur

o ,d I I . e 1 id U q qlf!U:Ed tnrnurnru rin;{douunslnnln:m'1nfl1:fln!lYlun?rrl9r{ [n [ufl1:lrflrurI I C s a . cY I a a 4

xtflr:uu lfi:..]fi'r1rJ5 rir4fl!s tu nl5 rt uu:0u'l't [0tlJflnun11I n{fl'l tfilJ5eflvl, t^la10lflo]uflf]! 1

j" - -J - o , hr4og [u:3o1rlJ]n ry{doafl60{nu{'ru?0u1o{r10111: lfru9r:r?Yru (2554 : uflnnu0) tnf,nur

,.i , ea j, < c 4n1?si1i1nr:nlnuurrtla{tio.:H1t:}1'l:Yld.:Hano:gdnnHato'!do'lufln!1tufln!ollnodnn

t ; a , < 4s J asd.:nodrun{tulxgn{u1lfl t:flnuI tso1lfln!tq::riu [un 4 Han]:'1t0v{u?1 :soutJ:sdvttr{n

as99r'10.rdo]uflnur tnus ?u[[ast 1u6]uqnn lu0q tu:!nuuln

3. nlis#lilnrinJ6uuurja{ro.irir3r1:d0rufinur nitrj:v?vriHoto{d0lufinu r

lA a v u vrfl{na riru n{ 1u[10r11u ylnl: f,fl! lrJt u1lflnu'r [1n l7 ufi?]!dlllIu, vl.ltu?n tuSufrulj'lufla1.r

--i - '. !a, de0u'I.:lJuudlni}lll{do9r1l:&nu.0l 11{uruu[Y{ 5]y?101nfl]:'lrflt'lslJt0{ nflu?'t n'trr1J:u0udl

e. ,i , .i - d, i I zl . n , I v s t10{R1?sflU]fl1:[UnUUlrUn{U1{n'] UnlrQAUd'l U1{n?Ufl1[AAUn1 [U0U'l tlJfilnrdfid! Un

otir'r'irurirrJ:vlvrGr.ratorcorufinsr drf,?urj:dou'l ro.:il:sAm;,.rnro{flotuf,n!'rI , .i I a . o r' v | @ s J

u'l{0r?r[lJ:rJfl1[enuq{u1{ 019r?uu:rJfl'rlq0u911 r.ryrl tt4fildlllJ:udytf dl4duylut:811?'lt

nrls{lirnr:ril6 uuu:J o.rtor{ui n r: nilrJ:y ?vrt-HntB.:do'ruf;nu tirilo{1u:roiurJrunat- !, a c) yo

'j 'n.:uu 0't9ro.:?{gru r9l ?[tll: uou dl 10,1R't?u,{ 1n1:[ nuuu ailn "l 61u ltng tgdll!fla1ot- 4- , qedt i a v e tafloluflfluryln 1 ntu tH ntla0u0i dl rltuounu n'ldlt :ed , dlt riuflu, t.: nyl,n l5gnug i

dY | 9tru 0 'l n H n n 1: 'r lfi r 1s l.t t 0tJ0rsytlJ't"t olu u r e dylt fla10t d0 tudn! ln ?uu t uou lr1J?1

68

nz rudrlr r: olun r:r,rinru rrinGuul#irniauncrmr{u:n niun?rrtd M:olunr: rulilrgnrnrulu

to.:eoruf,nuririr,qdugir,,Finrev{rirnr:ril6uuu n.:Inu:rlirirrn6o:;n,uq'r6.:rirbi

Eirf,rlrJ:cimGailfrlniu6oonlr o{1u:;durJrunnrrr{lueiaulrqj uriiu-odrflryvrxa66A n , e u . ' - Aa e otsr'[rjaoondorriur{anrrid'uxo.r rr: rnuo:r?yl-u (2554: ryreint,io) fifinurnrrr{rir

,.i , ea i,fl'rt[lJ0uuuUa{fl0.:riu:fi1tYld{Han0U5uflYlrn11110rflo1uflnu1[ nqudlrR0dnn fl.:fln

J ; "

. 4e t t s e rdtun.:tu[19]11uvtfl'l:f,nut :v0ufln!]u:t!u t19t 4 flon1:'t0u1I1J?'l fr?ltJdlJlturt,0t

,6 ,; , e ^

a v e 4eR1?gHUlnltt nUUtt A{10'lr,t1l:l.t1: fl1111:sfYmtr{n10.:dn1ufln!1 tftu: ?lJltfl l'li.tdullut nu

":t :cnu (': 0 u]{ ! uudln€u 711{ f,ngr

4. n1?s dli rn1:nJ6ouurJ a lt or{u3 r r: aoruf, nu rfi ri rHnd oil:v?yr; fl ax o {lA a u 4 @ t t

dnlufln!1 dinodlu n{lut.U9tt{uT n1:f,flu lut ulJflfl! l tlt0t l7 0 tdlJfl l511d1n: oul{':1u fio

i - z.uq + .515 x fi!lun?ru'ir ocuuunrrvririrnr:ulduuurjnrto.r{uirr:aorudnur

ril 6 u u 1 il r r.r ri r u lir1 #il : s ? r i n a t o.: a o 1 u dn ! r f .r nh d r rin r r u rr n du d n r : fi n u r

u-ruldnsr rrn l7 rilAuu'lilrvirrir z.oca +.51s x r ?u udo{'irnr?urllirnlruJ6uuuilo.r,a a - { y^ 4xo'r{u3rr:dolufinurri.:Halnurr:lsiorJ:cRyrr-ilnro.rdoruFin!r n-s riu {ui u r: o- r n r:

A e. ,i e. ,i ,

Y{t1t0r 1R 1?y4u lfl'l: [U auuuU a I t d0luf,fl! rn ]ulru ?noR 1?vrdu'ln1:r auu[[ n{10{rlud

uarol?aIo (Bass and Avoli. 1990 : 120 - 123) #{ + dru n'o drunt:aYr.rrr:ru'unroloe, a9^ 4a I s I I o 4 4 a :l oVn'lun'l:n:3flu tfi rflnls'l?uutl,E!,'l nlunttdt l.lu ltlr lrasn'lufl'l: fl'lu'1o {u unnunn a t 0 tl1

ti, r, a ui o rJ : r ?r G fl a r o { fl o r; fi;u rl u dru + dr u 6 o dr u n a r u m u r : o lu n r : ar a n u-n G u ucea - 4 . .L .tH!HAd!qYrr?r1.:nr:[tuufl {1u nlun?'DJd'rrj'rro tufl 1:1rflrulun[:uu tfi lJTf,nnTliu?fl

drua:udrr r: olunr: rJirril6uuuayn-orurI: r13ou uaydrun:rr arl: o1u n r: ru{r1qr rAyara?

R1U lt{[:UU cr{ dof]fi60{nU{lU?!U10lliy{U?:5 il qlUEuUyt (2551 : XylnflU0) td1Ilnl:dnU1,. ,i

oYrrfl oro{n1?sHu r nlsnJ auuurjarto.rdu3nr:siorl:c?r!^ilarorI:rGounrro6n

"

"- 4 , J t 9cd{na 1un1tflfl!'tofl: dn!r!olcyl n nI.ltyllt,l ltn 6 11un]:flnu1?T otn :ynouloiR1?u,{ t

,e t ya i-- -n l:[I nuultlJ 0 {10 t'.lu: tJ1: ytuo?trltan0u:gdTn HalD.t [: {t: uuft'lylo afl d{fln 1ufl1:dnu1

o'n:#rrra.ma n!{rytll"r lxn 6 fi 3 o,rriil:enou lduri nr:air.ru:{u-unrolo (xr) drunr:9aait.rrt:i (xr) unsn'ltrirfi{dlronrlnna (xJ rrayflon-uRt?;{rirnr:nJ6uuu:Jawo{du3ilt:

sdrrr9t5':[:uun1ufl1:d:'1.:rr:.:uuo1a tn (xr) nlunl:d5'l,tu15lJ (xr) [[ngnl:fi]lj.id{t0nunoa. /, a a(x!) dlUlrn1lUrn: u:Udytf flnr0i l:{r:uufi'llloandldnr.lruni:f,nu1 d'flrd{E!nmn

nl.:n1rr.1 tr0l 6 lfluriuulugrJalnr:ldn-.rd i: sr: * o.:sr (x,) + 0.182 (x4) + 0.180 (x,) +

0.182 (x4) + 0.180 (xr) uasdonndo.:niulrui,fr'urotlr0llrr [n!nrl?fiu (2554 : urn-ado)

69

r/r 94 9. ,i , , a i 'toflnulnl?v4u1n1:[unuuuun.:1o'r4u:1r'r:Yrd{fla9rolJ:vdmrflalo':doluflnul tunQrJ

tirrnoacr'n drrin rirrin.run,nniufin r: f,nu rrJ:vorLf,nu rqi il ti rrn + Hanr:ifuuu'ira @ r tr. ,i , , a s s t

fl ?lUdlJYlUtrJO{nr?r41-rlnr:rua0ull a{1o{4u:H1::lun1unuu:sdYrt,.ra tudfrluflnulu c te . --.iIou:rufinrrldrvluririuodrrfiriudrrYtynr.:a6erfi:caiu .os lno:aroqjlu:vn-rq'r

lnuriurnr!rirnaruri'uniu#1r.,) ornurn}Jrloo 6o nr:n:v{unr:1#rlr1rUr (xr) flqn'n::u

{{n?1! dlrlru t: r0qnn a (x4) nr:fl:'l.ru'Hu (xr) [[0&n1r d:1{u: {uun'ra t0 (xr) nlualaue. ri t 9 - .id. /, a a a

rr0 s R 1?v H u ]n 1:ru n 0u rru a {10{HU: fi15yrlr 0]u 1nlrotn: u:vflvtt fin10{floluflfl! 1

- tAaA 4 y qe{tau:1rl [ru.:0r'rralnunlnn?Y{uln:Eu nmqn Ro n'r:n:rqufll: tYuruful (xJ lrqnn::1ltvvi-4vo?

rJ{n?'r!drJfl un r luq nna (x, unrfl lr d5'r.:u1ru (x,) !9un1d!u:sd t drd! urvrl0ol

to.:sr-rnorn:ni(n')or'uroRaun-uu:l:torrJ:s?vrinarorl:rfiould3ocras47.10 ri0uodluiiltn ,t - i

drfl1:nl5flU lfl:0r to o.l'lJ

dunr:fl u1n:oflilgrlnvuuuir

i : 1.292 +0.412(x,)*+0.166(x.)r+0.054(x,)

d!nr:fl urn:oilug:JRruuuurn:nru

Zr : 0.472(X,)x +0.198(X.)*+0.068(X,)

,t otduottuc4 4 e. ,.i , e a 4 i<

nlnn1:flnu'ln1tf,nutn1?u4u]n1:r a0 [[ a{10'14u:fi 1:flo1ufln!1yr!Han0t0.t4 v v . , ! A a e d rae < e - ' . ,i

dnluflnul d{nndrufl {]urxnllufln r:flnu1![urJf,nu ] ltn l7 t?nuulolduouusn {n0 luuc, -u rl,0tduotl sfl? lu

a t. ,; t I a d t 9 tn1nnl:f,nu1nl1c Hu 1fl1: [1l nuult!] a.:u o.:HU:111: f,o1uf,nu 1 YIlJ?1 ntunltd:'l':

A e) A - { *- d o , <r ' -!ulru rJflrlaauuoumdn 6.:uut?0u0t101olduouuu tutJ:urnuuou dl o{u. e- oed' i- d ,t

I . n 1 : Yl',t't lu I o i tdu: 1,1'l : tfi luu Ylu u 0 0x o { rJt ?u t'tur/ a e a A dy ,2. 4U:11r:n0tq f,nulTlo tlr.rluu:: QlrjlrlJ1u

n ln n'r : fi n u 1 : y ?mr' ru nt o r ao ru fl n u r n r.r'i r dru R a rl a rl r : n lu n r : yr-or u rqedv , j y .i - t- *- a - , r',J

un[:uu lfiuYlflunnrl{u?n xnlranul]ouyldn n{uuH?nun{10[flu ouuy n{n0 l ua q i,t ' d f,,a y a y .ir y-l. flird:tttfiufll:uurn2ltJruflftsouTl{[un'lunl:[:uuune lyllfrSuuo! rJ]u

4l2. d.:rd:u trun[: uu! 1d01udn!1ryri1[d!0 inn 1t,t uulrdrril.rlu: ?!nu'160u'1.r,

fl?1lldtl

jj3. U I l.t 1: d O 11J f, n U',l d {nn d"tU n { "tU 11 0 1I U T n',l : fl nU 1lJ t UIJ fl fl ! 1 11 sl I 7

i,-4n ?: r11 11 lJ : s dyr t ,'l n lJ o i do ru fl n u r Io u n 1 : fl n fi u n [t uu tli u r{ a du q m n r 1 I n 1 : r: uu

1 e' ttunq ! dl: c n 1: [: uu! n 1{ 1 (J.r1u

la < , < a4. HUt 14',t: flO',tUflnUt d{fln dlun{lurlnlruYlfl',l:fln! lut uuflnu'l [1n l7 fr?:lylrJ

,A-rJ: yfrrr-n nto ranrufinur 1u nr::JirLr:16uuyr-oru rcnruFinu run vrJfrrJl'ri6nr:rirrfiurruo rt'21 :tuufi 1 filu0ut{a0[u0'tflu1[dlJ0

!; a @ a ^5. rdx:x1:do1ufln!1 d{n6dlun{1ulInlru n1:flnu1!fu!flnu1 rln l7 fl']:rlllJd o 9- I I I o9 0

1J:rf,Ylf HAiJ0.tfloluflnu'l t nt:tln gufl1n1{ "l Rlu tudoluflnul [Yu olunl: li anfln:4q

doluflnur n15nofl in::u nlrrtuufl ltd0u rtofl fl9tfl ::tJ10{unrtguvA10r6ruo!rusr onr:robni'rgiou

l. n?rinlsf,nu116urnirlo.rrirJ:vnouxo{nr2s{drnr:rilduurriln{dru6u 1i,aylf, tu150d{H0nou:gflYttfl a10nd01uflnu1

A . a i o ytry2. n'l : 1l n'l : fl n u'l't 0 u[5 i q ol R 111 [n u'] n u : g d Yt i H n t o't d il 1u fl nu llYro tfi t fl

drua^oa.iar0{nn?'r ; lurliafl 'r[1]: uu[1r uu nu {'ru ?nu [ulY'rlJrrJlfu l.r:orlro[:J n1:duudliu.1'r!?ru

rilriilror

10