The ChronicleThe independenT daily aT duke universiTy

friday, november 13, 2009 one HUndred and fifTH year, issUe 59www.dukechronicle.com

Duke opens against UNC-G without Nolan, Mason, Page 9

Duke begins NCAA tournament versus Rutgers, Page 9

onTherecord“At the Smart Home, your home is a huge lab”

—Senior Andrew First on living in the Smart Home. See story page 3

Council OKs provisional pass/fail policy

Council releases RGAC scores

Barnes’ visit emphasized academics

by Zachary TracerThe chronicle

Selective living groups, including frater-nities, will be choosing new sections next week, after campus council determined a new slate of available sections Thursday.

The release of a new set of sections comes at the end of the three-year residen-tial group assessment process, designed to evaluate the impacts of selective living groups on campus.

“Tonight was the culmination of a whole lot of work, both on the part of campus council and on the part of [residence life and housing Services],” said campus coun-cil President Stephen Temple, a junior.

in the assessment process, groups were divided into three groups based on mem-bership and evaluated yearly in categories such as section management and member-ship experience. campus council released scores from the final round of the process Thursday night.

Groups scoring higher than the average score in their size categories have the abil-ity to remain in their current sections—they must choose whether they will do so by Mon-day night. After eligible groups have chosen

by Lindsey RuppThe chronicle

At its meeting Thursday, The Arts & Sciences council tentatively approved a new pass/fail policy and discussed faculty reaction to the courserank Web site.

Because Peter Feaver, Alexander F. hehmeyer profes-sor of political science and the chair of the committee that designed the new policy, was not present at the meeting, Arts & Sciences council chair ruth Day, associate profes-sor of psychology and neuroscience, identified several in-consistencies. These included how the new designations—satisfactory/unsatisfactory rather than pass/fail—would appear on students’ transcripts and affect their GPAs.

The new policy would require students to earn at least a c-minus to receive a “satisfactory” designation, up from a

by Samantha BrooksThe chronicle

Today, harrison Barnes will make a decision that could shape the course of Duke men’s basketball for the next four seasons.

Barnes, this year’s no. 1 basketball recruit in the coun-try on scout.com, will publicly announce his college deci-sion at a ceremony held in his high school gymnasium at 3 p.m., according to DesMoinesregister.com.

The recruit’s oct. 23 visit to Duke, which included a meeting with the dean of the Fuqua School of Business, the senior associate dean for Academic Affairs, the secre-tary of Veteran Affairs, a stay at the Washington Duke inn and Golf club and a lobster and steak dinner at head basketball coach Mike Krzyzewski’s house, reflects the University’s treatment of high-profile recruits.

“it was just great to see more of the academic side [of Duke] and develop closer relationships with the players and spend more time with them,” Barnes wrote in an online diary on highschoolhoop.com—a Web site that follows high school basketball and college recruiting. Barnes added that dining with Krzyzewski was “just a re-ally cool time,” and that the Washington Duke inn was a “really nice hotel.”

The recruitment process was especially tailored to in-corporate Barnes’ academic and athletic interests. Fuqua Dean Blair Sheppard met with Barnes to discuss how an undergraduate degree at Duke could prepare the basket-ball player to achieve his goal of starting his own business. Sheppard said he was asked to speak with Barnes by an alumnus friend.

“As i understood the goal, it was to help [Barnes] think through how you could achieve the same things at Duke that you could at a school with an undergraduate business major,” Sheppard said. “i was in the best position to say what he needs to achieve that.”

According to the office of Undergraduate Financial Aid, Duke gave $13.4 million in athletic aid last academic year.

Dean of Undergraduate Admissions christoph Gut-tentag described the admission process for varsity athletes as similar to that of non-athletes with a stronger emphasis on extracurricular athletics.

“Athletics is one of the many things that is taken into account in the admission process for all students,” Guttentag said. “it is true that one of the many things

See council on PAGe 5

See pass/fail on PAGe 6 See barnes on PAGe 7

CAMPUS COUNCIL

Basketball recruit met with Fuqua dean, VA Secretary Shinseki

Blue Devils look to spring upsetby Andy Margius

The chronicle

Following the toughest loss of its season last week against north carolina, Duke looks to bounce back tomorrow against the Acc’s top team in no. 7 Georgia Tech.

The Blue Devils (5-4, 3-2 in the Acc) enter this week’s matchup still hoping to become bowl eligible with two more wins. however, as large underdogs, pulling off the upset against the Yellow Jackets (9-1, 6-1) will prove to be a difficult task. Geor-gia Tech enters this week sporting the best offense in the conference, averaging 34.7 points a game.

Still, Duke has an advantage play-ing at home in Wallace Wade Stadium, where the team has performed well all year. The last time a top-10 opponent came to Durham in the form of then-no. 6 Virginia Tech, the Blue Devils man-aged to hang tough the entire game and only lose by a single score.

head coach David cutcliffe remains optimistic about his team’s chances in its toughest matchup of the year.

“it’s one of those great challenges,” cut-cliffe said. “But it comes down, like it always does, to players making plays.”

The big question on the table for Duke will be its ability to stop Georgia Tech on the defensive end. The Yellow Jackets come

See fooTball on PAGe 10

zachary tracer/chronicle file photo

The Blue Devils welcome the highest-scoring offense in the conference to Wallace Wade Stadium Sat-urday at 12 p.m. A victory over Georgia Tech would bring Duke to within one win of bowl eligibility.

DUKE vs. GEORGIA TECHWallace Wade • Saturday • 12 p.m. • ESPN2

ArTS & SCIeNCeS COUNCIL

2 | FRIDAY, NOVEMBER 13, 2009 ThE ChRONIClE

Biology 46Aids and Other Emerging Diseases

Wednesday and Friday 1:15-2:30Instructor: Sherryl Broverman

Back by Popular Demand

In Home Depot & Kohl’s Shopping Center

Patterson Place 15-501 & Mt. Moriah

chill with your friends

Bagels, Breads and Pastries!

Freshly Tossed Salads!

Breakfast Sandwiches!

Delicious Soups!

Espresso Drinks!

Hearty Sandwiches!

Phone: 419-6300 | Fax: 419-6334 Mon-Sat: 6:30am-9:00pm Sun: 7:30am-9:00pm

worldandnationtrincoMalee, Sri lanka — Six months

after Sri lanka’s decades-old civil war ended with a final assault, about 200,000 people remain trapped in overcrowded government-run camps that were once safe havens for those fleeing the conflict.

facing pressure from the president Ba-rack obama’s administration and the euro-pean Union, the Sri lankan government last month launched a campaign to resettle tens of thousands of the minority tamil detainees. But interviews in the country’s war-ravaged north reveal that many civilians have merely been shuffled from the large camps to small-er transit ones and are being held against their will. others have been released, only to be taken from their homes days later with no indication of where they have gone.

after the army defeated the tamil rebels in May, top government officials paraded their success on the streets of colombo,

the capital, and the country’s leaders made noble promises about ensuring national harmony. now analysts say the real test of Sri lanka’s success in building a stable, post-conflict society lies in the fate of these scores of thousands of detainees.

human rights groups say the govern-ment is lying about its resettlement ef-forts; authorities concede they are using the camps as a tool to uncover any re-maining tamil militants but deny they are deliberately stalling civilians’ return home.

“We thought this war was over. But for tamils, it’s like going from the frying pan and into the fire,” said Devander Kumar, whose brother was released, only to be taken away by police without explanation, one of 30 men in this seaside city who have disappeared soon after their homecoming. “Do we tamils have to prove every second of the day that we are not terrorists?”

“ ”All men are caught in a network of mutuality.— Martin L. King Jr.

TODAY IN HISTOrY1997:Pedro Martinez wins

NL Cy Young Award

WaShinGton, D.c. — president Barack obama plans to hold a White house forum on job creation next month, an attempt to signal his concern about the growing ranks of the unemployed and build consensus on future action to stoke the economy.

the summit will bring together small business owners, corporate executives, economists, financial experts and union leaders to discuss ideas for accelerating job creation amid the worst labor market condi-tions in a generation, obama said thursday.

“We all know there are limits to what government can and should do even during such difficult times,” obama said at the White house before leaving on a nine-day trip to asia. “But we have an obligation to consider every addi-tional, responsible step that we can to encourage and accelerate job creation in this country.”

Senate faces oppositionWaShinGton, D.c. — the nation’s

largest health insurance carrier is urg-ing its employees to lobby the Senate against reform proposals that would hurt the firm’s bottom line, according to copies of e-mails released thursday by a liberal advocacy group.

Unitedhealth Group, which is based in Minnesota, e-mailed its 75,000 em-ployees tuesday, asking them to write their senators and local newspapers in opposition to a public insurance option, alleging that “government-run health care” will force “millions of americans” to drop their current cov-erage.

proposed form letters from the com-pany also lay out opposition to cuts in the costly Medicare advantage pro-gram. the e-mail was sent by United for health reform.

toDay:

5447

SatUrDay:

6847

Sri Lankans still in brutal living conditions, no gov’t help

Obama announces summit to battle unemployment

Marvin JoSeph/the WaShinGton poSt

John robinson, of Severna Park Md., was awarded the Bronze Star Medal with valor for his actions during the Battle of the Bulge in World War II. Medals such as the Bronze and Silver Stars are reviewed by an Army decorations board but first need a recommendation from a member of Congress. The Army receives about 200 of these requests annually.

ThE ChRONIClE FRIDAY, NOVEMBER 13, 2009 | 3

Embrace the Universe ofLatin American Literature

Prof. Ariel Dorfman

SPANISH 121AD * LIT 161AD * ICS 131CD

SPRING 2010

This class, taught by the renowned playwright Ariel Dorfman, is only offered every 4-5 years, and enrollment is limited.

Explore the crucial themes, obsessions, genres and stylistic strategies of Latin American culture. Organized as an introductory course, students who are already familiar with this sort of literature may find these explorations provocative and stimulating. Readings include canonical authors such as Sarmiento, Garcia Marquez, Lispector, Cortazar, with more recent writers who address contem- porary issues. Ethical and political dilemmas will be constantly examined. Knowledge of Spanish not necessary.

Latin American Literature in Translation

Tuesdays-Thursdays 10:05-11:20 a.m.

GERRE AND JUDITH HANCOCKSunday, November 15, 20095:00 p.m.Duke ChapelFree admission

Gerre Hancock, one of America’s most highly acclaimed concert organists, returns to Duke this season with his wife, Judith Hancock, for a program of solo and duo organ works. Gerre, lauded as “a legend among organ recitalists and a titan among improvisers” (American Record Guide), will conclude the recital with a large-scale improvisation. Judith, acclaimed as a “virtuoso performer” (The Cleveland Press), assisted him at St. Thomas Church in New York City for many years. Both have now joined the faculty at the University of Texas, where they direct the Sacred Music Center.

Duke University Chapel

October 18, 2009 Catherine Rodland

November 15, 2009 Gerre and Judith Hancock

January 24, 2010 David Arcus

February 21, 2010 Michael Radulescu

March 21, 2010 Robert Parkins

ORGAN RECITALS 2009-10Duke University Chapel Sundays at 5:00 p.m.

Organ Recitals 2009-10

OrganRecital_Hancock.indd 1 11/5/2009 4:26:45 PM

DUPD puts officer on unpaid leave

by Julius JonesThe chronicle

A Duke University Police officer charged with raping an Alabama woman is no longer being paid by the University, DUPD chief John Dailey confirmed Thursday night.

Webster Delenn Simmons, 37, was arrested by the houston county Sheriff’s Department oct. 26 on first-degree rape and sodomy charges. Simmons was placed on paid leave following his arrest until he was placed on unpaid leave last Wednesday.

DUPD is currently conducting a standard investi-gation into Simmons’ conduct during his time with the department to see if he committed any crimes during time on the force.

Dailey declined to comment on whether or not a change in the investigation prompted the change in Simmons’ status, citing the University’s policy of not commenting on personnel issues.

“The fact is he’s still an employee, with unpaid status, and we are continuing our investigation,” Dailey said.

Simmons is accused of assaulting a 34-year-old woman after leaving a local nightclub with her the morning of oct. 24.

by Will HyungThe chronicle

The Duke Smart home Program celebrated the two-year anniversary of its completion of the home Depot Smart home Thursday.

The house, which received a lead-ership in energy and environmental Design Platinum certification from the U.S. Green Building council in 2008, has provided a place for students to live while they work on innovative tech-nology projects.

The initial idea of a ‘smart house’ was proposed by Mark Younger, Pratt ’03, during his independent study course, said Jim Gaston, Smart home program director. Although ‘smart rooms’ existed for students where they could showcase inventions, Younger came up with an idea of a place where students would live and work on projects at the same time, Gaston added. After graduation, Younger took his idea to the admin-istration and was hired as the project manager, overseeing construction, fundraising and student teams. The Smart home, operated by the Pratt School of engineering, was complet-ed in 2007 and the first student resi-dents moved in January 2008.

Today the Smart home has 10 resi-dents and approximately 100 students involved in the various projects that are constantly being brought up and worked on, said junior Kelvin Gu, pres-ident of Smart home.

Gaston said Smart home strives to involve students and faculty not only from Pratt, but also from the Trinity college of Arts and Sciences, the Terry

Sanford School of Public Policy, the School of law and the Fuqua School of Business.

“one of the goals of Smart home is to give students project experience outside of the classroom,” Gaston said. “We encourage students to have diver-sity in [their] teams.... Students aim to tackle problems not just from a techni-cal point of view but from an interdisci-plinary perspective.”

Gu said Smart home currently fo-cuses on two categories of invention—green technology and cutting-edge high-tech solutions. At the present time, there are nine active projects, with anywhere between three to five

people working on each, he added. Smart home provides a unique

opportunity to work innovatively in teams, especially for the residents, said senior Andrew First, vice president of Smart home.

“At the Smart home, your home is a huge lab,” said First, who is a current resident. “So many things are going on and it is a convenient place to test out technologies and their practicality on other people and yourself. You can tin-ker around with the environment that you live in.”

Gu said that for every project,

Smart Home celebrates 2nd birthday

Michael naclerio/chronicle file photo

The Home Depot Smart Home, completed in 2007, celebrated its second birthday Thursday. Certified as LeeD Platinum by the U.S. Green Building Council, the Smart Home currently houses 10 students.

See smarT home on PAGe 7

COrreCTION a nov. 12 story “Merger elicits student outcry” incorrectly identified senior abby tinsley. tinsley is the former co-director of common Ground, an im-mersion retreat program organized by the center for race relations. the chronicle regrets the error.

4 | FRIDAY, NOVEMBER 13, 2009 ThE ChRONIClE

by Shaoli ChaudhuriThe chronicle

Parents who hope to see their daughters grow up to become lawyers should take note of a recent study co-au-thored by a Duke alumnus.

A study conducted by researchers at clemson Univer-sity and George Mason University found that women with masculine names are more successful in the legal pro-fession. The study looked specifically at members of the South carolina Bar and their names as they relate to their success in law, including those women who ultimately be-came judges.

Bentley coffey, Grad ’04, said the idea for the study evolved out of his wife’s assertion that giving their identi-cal twin daughters hyper-feminine names would hurt them in the future.

“i seriously doubt that,” coffey, an assistant professor of economics at clemson, said in response to his wife, who is a lawyer.

But after examining the genders and names of local judges and members of the South carolina Bar, coffey said shocked to learn how important the masculinity of a name could be.

The study found that naming one’s daughter Kelly in

lieu of Sue increases her chances of becoming a judge by 5 percent—the name cameron triples her chances, and Bruce quintuples them.

Patrick Mclaughlin, the study’s other author, was un-available for comment.

A follow-up study coffey led, which has yet to be pub-lished, also found that, based on the survey responses of 1,000 different lawyers in South carolina, a female law-yer’s nominal masculinity is correlated with the amount of money she makes. That is, the more masculine a female lawyer’s name, the more money she earns.

Although coffey and Mclaughlin have found a cor-relation between nominal masculinity and success in the legal field, coffey said the cause of this phenom-enon is unknown.

“The theory varies from something subtle and psycho-logical to just basic ignorance,” he said.

one possible factor, at least where a judge’s election is concerned, is that voters wrongly identify a female candi-date’s masculine name on a ballot as belonging to a man.

hence, given these theoretical circumstances, vot-ers could cast their ballots for a female candidate they

Study finds manly names useful in law

chriStina pena/the chronicle

Members of Delta Gamma, Kappa Kappa Gamma and Omega Phi Beta Sororities perform in the “Blaze the Stage” Stroll Show 2009 Thurs-day night. The dance competition, held in Page Auditorium, was sponsored by Fraternity & Sorority Life and the Inter-Greek Council.

Blazing the stage

See names on PAGe 8

DPS on track to unite campus service groups

by Shaoli ChaudhuriThe chronicle

This year, DPS is behind the wheel for social action.Formed last March, Duke Partnership for Service

is the new social action governance organization that oversees more than 70 service groups on campus, in-cluding circle K, nourish international, camp Kesem, habitat for humanity and Women’s institute for Sec-ondary education and research.

DPS was established after the Duke community Ser-vice center dissolved last Spring. As a new completely student-run umbrella organization, DPS has taken strides to improve social action groups’ visibility on campus, initiate collaboration and assist with funding and student recruitment.

“in a sector of student organizations that was so dysfunctional and uncoordinated, just a little of as-sistance goes a long way,” said DPS President Adam nathan, a senior.

nathan said earlier in the semester, DPS conducted a needs assessment of student service groups to iden-tify internal issues. The organization plans to launch a transportation fund and assume the Student organi-zation Finance committee’s role in allocating funds to student service groups.

“everything we’re doing is crucial to the health of our groups,” he said.

Another goal is to redefine social action on campus. one measure is a happy Service hour, during which students and groups can socialize outside of “picking up trash together or tutoring,” nathan said. This would help pave the way to better relations in the service

See Dps on PAGe 8

ThE ChRONIClE FRIDAY, NOVEMBER 13, 2009 | 5

Office of Health Professions Advising

Medical School Application for 2011 Matriculation

KICKOFF MEETING

If you are planning to submit an application to medical school for 2011 matriculation, this is a required meeting. Dean Scheirer will present an overview of the application process, including timelines and deadlines.

Two identical sessions.

Wednesday, November 18, 2009 Thursday, November 19, 2009 7:00PM 7:00PM French Science Center 2231 French Science Center 2231

Office of Health Professions Advising

prehealth.duke.edu

whether to squat, all groups not remaining in their current locations will choose their new homes on the basis of how they scored within their size categories.

At its Thursday night meeting, cam-pus council chose the set of sections that will be available to groups from a pair of options for the arrangement of sections across West campus. The two slates of sec-tions were prepared by campus council members and rlhS staff.

The slates were designed to distribute selective living groups more evenly across quads, limit the number of groups placed near each other in individual buildings and avoid placing small clumps of independent students near groups, Temple said.

no new groups will be given housing and no groups will lose their housing as a result of the process.

Jen Frank, assistant director of accom-modations for rlhS, said fewer sections will have dedicated common rooms.

Some sections that groups currently live in have been altered or eliminated.

in the chosen slate, one of Wannamaker Quadrangle’s two large sections has been removed—a small group section is now available on the building’s second floor and a medium section is available on its third and fourth floors. craven Quadrangle will now hold four groups, down from five—a medium section was eliminated.

A small section in edens Quadrangle has been replaced with a large section, increasing the number of selective living group members who will live in that quad.

“i think that the result that we ended up with at the end of the day is the best one we could have chosen,” Temple said, adding that the new sections will be beneficial for both independent and affiliated students.

Some selective living groups may receive warnings for receiving low scores on the assess-ment process. campus council passed a resolu-tion Thursday stating that groups with overall scores lower than one standard deviation below the mean will be placed on probation.

According to the resolution, groups may also be placed on probation for receiving a score lower than one standard deviation be-low the mean in the assessment’s fundamental categories—section management, group con-duct, quad interaction and membership expe-rience—or if the group’s section management and group conduct scores combined are lower than one standard deviation below average.

“This is essentially a warning,” Temple said. “You need to get it together or you risk having your section taken away.”

Groups will be told they need to improve in specific areas and will be given a year to make changes before reporting back to campus council, Temple said. it is unclear what progress groups need to make in or-der to avoid losing their housing.

campus council will release a list of groups on probation today, after informing the groups’ leaders. According to scores released Thursday night, Sigma nu fraternity, Delta Sigma Phi fraternity and Scott house will be among the groups placed on probation.

in other business:Bob Johnson, senior director of commu-

nications infrastructure for the office of information Technology, said the Universi-ty is working to improve cell phone service across campus. Duke will add additional cellular nodes by the end of the month to West campus. no plans were made to im-prove cell service on central campus be-cause Duke intended to renovate it.

now that plans for new campus have been postponed indefinitely, “we’re going back to see what we can do about that,” Johnson said.

COUNCIL from page 1

inDU raMeSh/the chronicle

Campus Council president Stephen Temple leads the discussion on restructuring SLG and fraternity sections at Thursday’s Campus Council meeting. The new arrangement will be based on the groups’ rGAC scores.

6 | FRIDAY, NOVEMBER 13, 2009 ThE ChRONIClE

MessiahG. F. Handel’s

Friday, December 4, 7:30 p.m.Saturday, December 5, 2:00 p.m.Sunday, December 6, 3:00 p.m.

Duke University Chapel Durham, North Carolina

Rodney Wynkoop,conductor

David Arcus, Continuo

-Soloists-Lisa Saffer, soprano

Martha Hart, mezzo-sopranoDann Coakwell, tenor

Grant Youngblood, bass

Tickets: $15 general admission, $5 Duke students (free for fi rst 200) Tickets from University Box Offi ce:

919-684-4444ww.tickets.duke.edu

Performed by the Duke Chapel Choir & Orchestra

Messiah_2009.indd 1 11/10/2009 3:32:30 PM

TICKETS ON SALE NOW!

800 W. Main St. • 682-4197 4600 Durham Chapel Hill Blvd • 489-6468

25% discount with Duke ID*

*Discount for Main St. & Chapel Hill Blvd only. Excludes alcohol and Fiesta Platter. Dine in only.

Authentic Mexican Cuisine The Dining Place for Students

Voted “2008 Best of the Triangle” ~ The Independent

Welcome Duke Students and Employees � Daily Drink Specials � Catering Available

Call us at 641-3872 to cater your next event.

(next to TJ Maxx)

D-minus under the previous policy. Despite concerns, the council decided to

take a provisional vote on the new proposal. Members approved opening the policy

to freshmen. Students may also be allowed to take prerequisite and co-requisite cours-es for majors on a satisfactory/unsatisfac-tory basis if approved by the academic de-partment and the student’s dean.

Members also overwhelmingly voted to re-quire students to declare that they are taking a course on a satisfactory/unsatisfactory basis by the end of the course correction period, which is a week after the drop/add period.

lee Baker, dean of academic affairs of Trinity college, said he is happy with the vote’s outcome, particularly with the deci-sion to allow freshmen to take advantage of the policy.

“We have already had careful and deliber-ate and long conversations,” Baker said. “This is basically the end of the road, even though ruth [Day] picked up on some inconsisten-cies, [we] trust the process and [the executive committee of the Arts & Sciences council].”

Members also discussed the Duke Student Government-sponsored courserank site.

George Mclendon, dean of the faculty of Trinity college, questioned the site’s ef-fectiveness, pointing to course evaluations compiled by the office of Assessment that appear with some courses on AceS as an alternative.

But Provost Peter lange said admin-istrators anticipated that students would develop a site like courserank when it was decided that professors could “opt-in” to making course evaluations available online, rather than creating an “opt-out” policy.

Members voted to ask the ecASc to re-visit the current opt-in policy.

Duke Student Government President Awa nur, a senior, said she would also sug-gest re-evaluating the policy.

“i would say in this economy, it’s a tre-mendous waste of money that we have the office of Assessment [compiling evalua-tions] and the student body doesn’t feel it’s filling their needs” she said in the meeting.

in other business:Day reviewed the results of the Arts & Sci-

ences Priorities Poll with the council. The poll saw responses from 29 of 31 representatives who were asked to rank the importance of is-sues that come before the council’s purview.

The budget was prioritized significantly higher than other issues. Several anonymous comments from faculty representatives showed concern for the effects cuts could have as well as the transparency of budget changes, calling for more faculty participation.

“What will be cut and who decides?” one

respondent commented. Another expressed concern for the “effect

of Arts & Sciences budget on instructional budgets and [teaching assistant] support.”

Day said the budget was a “big standout” in the poll, and said she anticipated faculty concerns being addressed in a future meet-ing, but did not know when.

Baker said the faculty does have input on cuts.

“We do consult with faculty,” he said. “i think George [Mclendon] in particular has been very transparent—maybe they want more involvement because they know [the situation].”

in addition, the council voted unanimous-ly to approve changing the Study Abroad committee name to the committee on Glob-al education for Undergraduates. Members also approved a change to that committee’s charge so that it oversees the domestic proj-ects in new York city and los Angeles.

PASS/FAIL from page 1

Dianna liU/the chronicle

Council chair ruth Day elaborates on the proposal to update Duke’s pass/fail policy. Changes included raising the passing grade from a D- to a C-, and setting the deadline to declare pass/fail a week after drop/add ends.

ThE ChRONIClE FRIDAY, NOVEMBER 13, 2009 | 7

Family #7 – Partial blindness and a recent eye surgery have sidelined this mother of three from her job. While she awaits approval for disability income, her family struggles to make ends meet. Holiday gifts of (list a few) will be a ray of hope for this family.

Family #48 – This mother fled domestic violence to find safety for herself and her two children. She is now searching for a job and a home of her own. The family has few belongings now and needs household items and clothes to make a new beginning.

Family #87 – The godparents of an 11 year-old with severe mental illness now provide a loving and supportive home for him. They want nothing for themselves this holiday, but would be very grateful if their godchild receives new clothes for Christmas.

Family #180 – This single father is struggling to provide for his two children and a nephew on a very small monthly income, You can help him make this a memorable Christmas for all his boys this year with gifts of basic clothing, a digital camera and action figures.

Family #208 – Two sets of twin grandchildren, ages 3 and 11, now live with their grandmother. Her love and support for them is boundless, but her income is limited. You can help her make this a Christmas for them to remember fondly with gifts of clothes, games and bikes.

Brightleaf Square Main St. Durham

683-DUKE

www.zspotlight.com/satisfaction • email: satisfaction@nc.rr.com

ESPN Full Court • NHL Center Ice • NBA League Pass ESPN Full Court • NHL Center Ice NBA League Pass

we look carefully at is the ability to con-tribute to our athletic program. We pay very careful attention to the recommen-dation of coaches and their interests. For athletes that have accomplished at the level that they’re going to catch the interest of a program at Duke, their ex-tracurricular activities are going to show some impressive areas in athletics.”

not every athlete is recruited with the same vigor as harrison Barnes. Freshman Alyssa ogle, a member of the women’s la-crosse team, said her visit involved attend-ing a basketball game and a lacrosse team practice and dinner.

ogle said other women’s lacrosse play-ers were recruited in the same way.

“it’s different for basketball and football because they’re the revenue sports for the

school,” she said. Students’ opinions of the athletic re-

cruitment process are not always as enthu-siastic as those of the athletic department.

“The sports add an atmosphere, but then again [a non-athlete] may work harder than [an athlete] while [the ath-lete] gets special treatment,” said fresh-man Bennie Padgett. “i think it should be more equal.”

ogle said the work level of athletes is of-ten misunderstood.

“A lot of the [non-athletes] think that everything is handed to athletes which is not the case. Being an athlete is like hav-ing a full time job,” she said. “We work so hard. harrison Barnes had to work so hard to get where he is now, the special treatment is the reward he’s getting. he’s obviously earned that treatment. he’s the no. 1 recruit, i want him here so we win a national championship.”

BArNeS from page 1

Special to the chronicle (left), chriStina pena/chronicle file photo (riGht)

During his official visit, basketball recruit Harrison Barnes met with both Blair Sheppard, dean of the Fuqua School of Business, (left) and Secretary of Veterans Affairs eric Shinsheki (right) to discuss the academic opportunities available to him at Duke.

Smart home guides the students through the organization pro-cess. From budgeting to meeting challenges on goals to match-making each project with a fac-ulty or a client who wants the innovative technologies made, Smart home provides leadership and resources.

This year, Gu said he has fo-cused on improving the funda-mentals of the organization.

“[in] previous years we did not have a strong sense of com-munity,” he said. “This year, i’ve focused on having students meet every week for training and work-shops. We have also started docu-menting all of our work.”

Gu said Smart home has kept true to its original goals, which are to allow a place and oppor-tunity for students to showcase their inventions. First added that some of the house’s other goals include gaining more attention from the Duke community, be-coming a model for similar ini-tiatives at other universities, and participating in the surrounding community to apply the technol-ogies in Smart home to influence ordinary homes.

“We want to become an inte-grator for inventors and entre-preneurs in technology,” Gu said. “We want to network students to industries so that people who come out of the program know each other and other people in the industry.”

SMArT HOMe from page 3

8 | FRIDAY, NOVEMBER 13, 2009 ThE ChRONIClE

believe is a man.Katharine Bartlett, A. Kenneth Pye professor

and former dean at the School of law, agreed that it is difficult to establish cause and effect, but em-phasized the importance of looking beyond out-side factors or ignorance and instead at the subtle psychological factors.

“rather than having it all determined by how other people view you, it can be about how you view yourself,” she said, adding that having a more masculine name might give a woman confidence in the male-dominated world of law. “Parents who are going to push their kids to be male-type figures

will give them male-type names.”Such was the case with coffey and his wife,

who ended up giving one of his daughters a tra-ditional feminine name, but named the other collins, referring to this decision as “our own little experiment.”

But ranjana Khanna, Margaret Taylor Smith director of women’s studies and professor of english and literature, said she found the deci-sion to give one’s daughter a more masculine name compliant to misogyny, and in no way a solution to the problem.

“if you see the problem as a devaluing of the feminine or of women... then you’re not going to think you solved the problem by giving your daugh-ter a male name,” she said.

RELIGIOUS DIRECTORY

Trinity United Methodist Church

In the heart of Downtown Durham Between Mangum and Roxboro Streets

215 N. Church Street

Sunday Early Worship: 8:45 a.m. Sunday School: 9:45 a.m. Sunday Worship: 11:00 a.m.

Rev. Duke Lackey, Senior Pastor

E-mail: church@trinitydurham.org Web Site: www.trinitydurham.org Phone: (919) 683-1386

Come as you are— leave different!

The Muslim Students Association at Duke University is a place where students can learn about and discuss the

teachings of Islam. We serve to spread knowledge of Islam to non-Muslims who are interested in the religion and

sponsor a wide variety of social events and educational forums throughout the year-ranging from lectures and

discussions to artistic demonstrations.

Muslim Student Association & Muslim Life @ Duke.

Jumu’ah on Campus--Join us for our weekly Friday Service: 12:45 in the York Room; refreshments will be

served after the service.

11/13 Friday Meeting 6:30 at Center for Muslim Life

Sisters’ Discussion Group: Thursdays at 9 in the prayer room

Volunteering Opporunity: Project Downtown Durham 12/6

NOW ACCEPTING SUBMISSIONS FOR MSA SPOKEN WORD NIGHT! Contact nsk7@duke.edu for more info

Join MSA Listserv to find out more about these and other events in the future

Center for Muslim Life: 406 Swift Ave. OPEN TO ALL!

www.dukemsa.org ~ Duke Search: Muslim Life @ Duke

Everyone Welcome!

Morning Meditation

When: Mondays, Tuesdays & Thursdays from 8:30 - 9AM

Where: Chapel Crypt (stairs left to altar)

evening Meditation & dharMaZen Mind, Beginner’s Mind

When: Monday from 7-8:30pmWhere: Multicultural Center in the

Bryan Center

www.duke.edu/web/meditation

Come explore faith with us:

Sunday Worship and dinner 4:00pm

Wednesday Bible study 7:00pm (Link Classroom #2)

All are welcome!

505 Alexander Ave. (Off Campus Dr.) www.episcopalatduke.org

Resisting Simplistic Theology since 1789

Imagine a religion... that welcomes your

questions and makes room for your beliefs!!!

Unitarian Universalism is a liberal religion that believes in the inherent worth of every person, the authority of reason

and conscience in religion, freedom of religious belief, and a faith that is

manifested in justice and love.

Join us in your spiritual quest for truth and meaning!

The Unitarian Universalist Fellowship @ Duke

www.duke.edu/web/uu

Honor God. Love the Community.

Live like Family. Sundays at 5pm

Downtown Chapel Hill (919) 360-4320

www.greenleafvineyard.org

Sunday Mass Schedule

11am Richard White Lecture Hall, East Campus

9pm Duke Chapel

Daily Mass Schedule

Monday 5:15pm Goodson Chapel, Duke Divinity School

Tuesday 12 noon Duke Hospital Chapel (6th Floor)

Wednesday 5:15pm Duke Chapel Crypt

Thursday 11:30am Yoh Football Center, Team Meeting Room

Friday 5pm Fuqua School of Business, Seminar B

catholic.duke.edu (919) 684-8959

037 Duke Chapel Basement (office) & 402 N. Buchanan Blvd.

HINDU STUDENTS ASSOCIATION

Come Join Us For Weekly Gita Discussion • Diwali Puja • Shivratri Puja • Temple Trips • Hinduism 101 • Yoga • Ram Navami

• Garba • Meditation • Open Discussions and Speakers on issues that deal with campus life and

Hinduism and many other events!

November Events 1) Weekly Sunday Discussion, 12pm, Graduate Student Lounge - Gray Building

(2nd floor) 2) Bhutanese Empowerment Project - tutoring every Thursday 5:30-9:30pm 3) Open Exec Meeting every Wednesday at 8:30pm in OSAF. We’re looking for

new people to brainstorm and plan new events, so stop by if you’re interested! ALL members of the Duke community are welcome to join HSA

If you have any opinions regarding the recent merger of the MCC and IHouse and want them to be represented at future meetings,

please email them to ym15@duke.edu. Email ym15@duke.edu to RSVP for these events

Join our Facebook Group: Hindu Students Association @ Duke University or visit our website: www.duke.edu/web/hsa for frequent updates!

Temples in the Area we visit: 1.) HSNC Temple 309 Aviation Parkway, Morrisville, NC 27560 2.) Sri Venkateswara (Balaji) Temple 121 Balaji Place, Cary NC 27513

Genevieve Werner/the chronicle

Brooklyn-based dance group Urban Bush Women performs Thursday in the Bryan Center. The performance was the culmination of the group’s three-day residency at Duke.

Modern troubadours NAMeS from page 4

group circles and increase the number of long-term service projects, he added.

Senior Sam Bowler, president of Purple, a new non-profit student organization that seeks to raise awareness about various social issues, said DPS aims to redefine social action as well.

“We’re an inspiration business, and we’re going to work with DPS to inspire students to come back into these student groups,” he said.

Bowler noted that students sometimes have dif-ficulty committing to service groups on campus.

“every student has a whole lot on their plate... and with our social lives and academic lives… it’s difficult to look up sometimes,” he said.

Junior Joyce Kim, a member of Purple, said the group hopes to make activism and volunteering a

more “organic” part of students’ lifestyles.Although DPS was only launched a few months

ago, the organization has already made headway in ad-vancing the service aspect of Duke life, nathan noted.

“There was just nothing like this going on be-fore,” he said.

As a new organization, however, DPS still has a ways to go, said circle K President George hernan-dez, a sophomore. he added that DPS is still not 100-percent organized and has yet to effect con-crete changes.

“i think there’s potential in DPS, but i feel like we did all this before last semester,” hernandez said.

But Steve nowicki, dean and vice provost of un-dergraduate education, praised nathan and Bowler for their visions of service and recruitment on cam-pus, noting the importance of fresh ideas for Duke.

“Duke wants to create an environment where that diversity of models can flourish,” nowicki said.

DPS from page 4

DUKE UNC-GFRIDAY • 7 p.m. • CAMERON INDOOR STADIUM • FSS

Depleted Duke tips off seasonby Danny Vinik

The chronicle

Basketball season has finally arrived.no. 9 Duke opens the 2009-2010 season

Friday night at 7 p.m. in cameron indoor Stadium against Unc-Greensboro. After reaching the Sweet 16 for the first time in three years last season, the Blue Devils look to begin this campaign with a victory.

head coach Mike Krzyzewski is in his 30th year at the helm for the Blue Devils as Duke kicks off its 105th season, ready to make a run deep into March. The cam-eron crazies will be out in full force after waiting months for their beloved Blue Dev-ils to take the floor.

“it’s a fresh start for us and we’re very excited. it’s a lot of fun for us,” junior Kyle Singler said.

Unc-Greensboro struggled last year, go-ing 4-16 in the Southern conference and 5-25 overall. The Spartans return four of their five starters—including leading scor-ers Mikko Koivisto and Ben Stywall—but the team lacks depth, as only one player other than Koivisto and Stywall averaged more than six points per game last season.

Duke will be without two of its starters. Junior guard nolan Smith will serve the first of a two-game suspension for playing in an unsanctioned basketball league this summer, and freshman Mason Plumlee is out with a fractured wrist. Without Smith, the Blue Devils will have to rely on senior

michael naclerio/chronicle file photo

Junior Kyle Singler will lead the Blue Devil scoring attack in Duke’s regular season opener Friday night.See m. BasketBall on PAGe 11

MEN’S BASKETBALL

Barnes to announce decision

harrison Barnes, the 6-foot-6, 190-lb. swingman considered by many to be one of the top high school players in the country, will announce where he will play college basketball today at 3 p.m. on eSPnU.

Barnes is listed as the best small for-ward in the country according to scout.com, and the third-best player in the se-nior class. Duke is one of several finalists to snag Barnes, along with Kansas, iowa State, oklahoma, UclA and north carolina.

The iowa native made his official visit to Duke’s campus the weekend of oct. 23, when he met with the basketball team as well as christoph Guttentag, Dean of Ad-missions. The cameron crazies came out in full force for Barnes’ arrival, even creat-ing a life-size cutout of the recruit in a no. 40 Duke jersey.

Barnes, who will announce his decision in the Ames high School gymnasium, is prized for his ability to score both from the permieter and near the basket. he can play a variety of different positions. As a junior, Barnes averaged 19.7 points and 8.8 re-bounds per game, leading his high school to an undefeated season and a state title.

Duke already has three verbal commits for the class of 2010. Point guard Kyrie ir-ving—the no. 2 point guard in his class—currently highlights a group that includes guard Tyler Thornton and forward Josh hairston. Sophomore transfer Seth curry will also be available for the Blue Devils next season after sitting out this year as per ncAA regulations.

-from staff reports

Dianna liU/chronicle file photo

Freshman Nicole Lipp and the Blue Devils will have their work cut out for them against a stingy Rutgers defense.

woMEN’S SoccER

Duke hopes to extend NCAA tourney success

by Nicholas SchwartzThe chronicle

come ncAA tournament time, Duke student-athletes live by a collective creed:

survive and advance. This particular set of Blue Devils has been repeating the line since Septem-ber, when a rocky start to the schedule combined with the losses of key players to injury left even

head coach robbie church questioning whether his team would advance to post-season play.

“We were a bit of a mess in August, los-ing players, and we hit a tough stretch of games in September,” church said. “But once we started making some personnel

changes, we really turned it around.” Thanks to strong senior leadership, and

outstanding play from five freshman start-ers, Duke (8-8-4) now has a fresh start in the ncAA tournament, and a first-round matchup with no. 12 rutgers (13-3-4) Fri-day at 4:30 p.m. in columbia, S.c.

After battling through the regular sea-son gauntlet of powerful Acc squads, Duke will look to continue the recent suc-cess it has had in the ncAA tournament. The Blue Devils have been selected to play the last seven years, and have advanced to the elite eight the past two seasons.

To advance, Duke must find a way to break down a stalwart Scarlet Knight de-fense, which was one of the best in the Big east. rutgers has only allowed 10 goals all year, and is ranked seventh nationally in

See w. soccer on PAGe 11

FRIDAY, 4:30 p.m.Columbia, S.C.

No. 12 Rutgers

Duke

vs.

SportsThe Chronicle

www.dukechroniclesports.com

FRIDAYNovember 13, 2009

>> VOLLEYBALL The Blue Devils head on their last road trip of the year to take on Virginia and Virginia Tech, needing two wins to stay alive in the race for the ACC regular season crown

10 | FRIDAY, NOVEMBER 13, 2009 ThE ChRONIClE

woMEN’S BASKETBALL

Duke opens with homecoming game in Texas

XaVier WatSon/chronicle file photo

Junior Karima christmas gets a chance to play in her hometown in the Blue Devils’ first game of the season.

by Rachel ApostolesThe chronicle

When traveling to an away game, teams do not usually expect an exceedingly warm reception. The Blue Devils, however, re-ceived just that, as they kick off their regu-

lar season in hous-ton—the hometown of junior Karima christmas.

Upon arriving in houston Thursday evening, the team ex-perienced a taste of Texan hospitality, vis-iting the christmas home and sharing a meal with her family. however, after this brief period of re-pose, the Blue Devils will have to get down to business as they commence regular season play.

no. 6 Duke will face houston Baptist University Friday at 8:30 p.m. and will take on no. 16 Texas A&M Sunday afternoon at 3 p.m.

“This will be a great opportunity to bring Karima home and spend some time with her family,” head coach Joanne P. Mccallie said.

christmas, an explosive rebounder and defender, said that playing in Texas will be like reliving her high school days. A slew of the players on both opposing squads were previously her opponents in high school

FRIDAY, 8:30 p.m.Houston, TX

Houston Baptist

No. 6 Duke

vs.

SUNDAY, 3 p.m.College Station, TX

No. 16 Texas A&M

No. 6 Duke

vs.

and AAU contests. “it’s going to be a lot of fun because

we spent the majority of our high school careers playing against each other and we got to know each other on a person-al level,” christmas said. “it will be fun to see familiar faces and to play against them again.”

if the Blue Devils maintain the trend of domination that they showed in their exhi-bition games, christmas and her teammates

will fare well against the Texan teams. Duke breezed past Wingate 99-31 and Alaska An-chorage 100-32 last week.

Mccallie was pleased by the perfor-mances she saw at the exhibition games and anticipates dynamic play from her team this season.

“i am excited. excited about our poten-tial. excited about playing harder. excited about getting better, particularly defensive-ly,” Mccallie said. “i loved our balance in

scoring. it was just a good start. A good start to get going and see our possibilities.”

That being said, Mccallie and her staff noted numerous areas that she would like the team to improve on during the regu-lar season, emphasizing transition defense, passing and taking care of the ball.

it will be vital for the Blue Devils to rem-edy these weaknesses, as they face more ex-acting challenges from both houston Bap-tist and Texas A&M.

“The key is just to focus on playing off each other, playing aggressively and dictat-ing the physicality of both games,” Mccallie said. “it will be a great test for us.”

Duke is approaching the game against the Aggies with a particular hunger. The last time the two teams met, Texas A&M knocked the Blue Devils out of the Sweet 16 of the 2008 ncAA Tournament. This time around, however, Duke is looking to reverse the outcome.

“of course it’s in the back of our minds, because that was a game we really wanted. But in the same sense, we aren’t the same team and they aren’t the same team,” christmas said. “it’s just going to be that mindset of who wants it more.”

Mccallie said that she intentionally scheduled the Texas A&M game to chal-lenge her team.

“You go after teams that have done good things and they are an excellent program,” Mccallie said. “[But] it’s more about us than the opponent. We are really trying to put together 40 minutes of what we do in terms of aggressive defense, running, and rebounding.”

FooTBALL from page 1

aDDiSon corriher (left) anD ian SoileaU (right)/chronicle file photoS

Senior Thaddeus Lewis (left), sophomore wideout Johnny williams (right) and the Blue Devil offense will have to improve upon a subpar performance against the Tar Heels in order to beat No. 7 Georgia Tech Saturday.

into Saturday’s game with the nation’s top-ranked rushing offense, averaging 314.9 yards a game. They also lead the country in rushing touchdowns with 36.

combine that with last week’s abysmal performance stopping the run and Duke could be in for a long game. last week, Tar heel backup running back ryan houston rushed for 164 yards on 37 carries, averaging an embar-rassing 4.4 yards per carry. A similar performance against an even more experienced rushing team like Georgia Tech could have disastrous results for the Blue Devils.

offensively, Duke will also need a significantly better performance than against north carolina, in which the team was held to a pair of field goals. The ground game—which has been the weak spot for the Blue Devils all year—was held to 12 total yards, while senior Thaddeus lewis

threw for 113 yards. For Duke to win Saturday, the running game will need to improve to open up passing lanes for lewis. Fortunately, Georgia Tech’s defense is not as strong as north carolina’s, as the Tar heels boast the confer-ence’s top-rated defense. The Yellow Jackets come in with a middle-of-the-pack rushing defense, but an unimpressive passing defense, ranked 10th in the conference.

Georgia Tech’s suspect pass defense may play right into Duke’s strength as a predominantly passing offense. it will allow lewis to take more control of the game and relax more in the pocket than last week. if lewis can pull out the kind of game he did against the weak pass defense of n.c. State, in which he threw for 459 yards and five touch-downs, the Blue Devils could have a big game.

cutcliffe reiterated that the game will be a shootout in which both defenses will have trouble.

“They have the same issues [on defense],” cutcliffe said. “We put the ball and spray the ball all over the place

and run screens and do this and that. And if they don’t execute and play their techniques to their full capabilities, we’re going to bust some big plays, so it comes down to the execution on Saturday.”

The bottom line for Duke is that this matchup against Georgia Tech might as well be a must-win if they want any shot at a bowl game. next week is a road game against no. 14 Miami, a game which will be equally challenging, plus the added pressure of playing on the road. To play in the postseason, the Blue Devils will need to take down one of these two ranked opponents, in addition to winning their season finale against Wake Forest on nov. 28.

As for Saturday, the game holds many big questions for Duke. if the defense can hold Georgia Tech to a respectable number of yards, and if the offense can come through, there may be a chance. if either unit doesn’t perform, then Satur-day will be another long game at Wallace Wade, and the Blue Devils can say goodbye to the possibility of going bowling.

ThE ChRONIClE FRIDAY, NOVEMBER 13, 2009 | 11

Duke Eye Center Main Lobby • 684-4012

M-Th 8:30-4:30, F 8:30-4

14 Consultant Place 493-3668

M-Th 9-7, F 9-6, Sat 9-3

Northgate Mall 286-7732

M-Th 8-7, F 8-6, Sat 9-6

Shamir Autograph ® . ReCreating Perfect Vision® Just For You. • Shamir Autograph ® is designed to provide you with unsurpassed visual

acuity up-close, at a distance and everything in-between.

• Shamir Autograph ® incorporates your personal preferences to provide a lens exclusively designed for you.

Treat yourself to the most advanced lenses. Ask your eye care professional for Shamir Autograph ® lenses.

Shamir Autograph® Designed Perfection, One Lens At A Time™.

Did you know that not all progressive lenses are custom-made just for you? Previously, most lenses were designed to meet the needs of the average patient. Just like “off-the-rack” clothing, these lenses provide a visual solution for the average individual. Because “off-the-rack” lenses don’t provide a personalized, tailor-made solution for patients, Shamir created the Autograph. ® This premium progressive lens incorporates patented Freeform Technology ® giving you a personalized visual solution unlike any other.

Since Autograph ® lenses are customized, they are never made until an order is placed; this enables us to incorporate your personal Rx variables and needs to the production of the lens.

Payroll Deduction Available for Duke Faculty and Staff Duke Eye Center Location Only

Accepting Spectera Vision Plan

EYE CARE S UPER O PTICS S

682-0128 • www.fishmongers.net

Oysters $7/dozen • Friday 2-6pm $1 Mini Mexican Beers Every Night.

• King Crab • Tuna • Catfish • Calamari • Mahi Mahi • Clams • Scallops • Live Lobster • Certified Angus Beef®

FISHMONGER’S Restaurant & Oyster Bar

The place to meet your friends or bring your parents.

806 W. Main Street • Durham (across from Brightleaf Square) Open 7 days Lunch and Dinner

No reservation needed • Full Bar & All ABC Permits

Free Wireless

The largest selection of fresh seafood, vegetables and BBQ.

Jon Scheyer and freshman Andre Dawkins to do much of the ball handling.

“We do have a lack of guards and with nolan not play-ing, we have to be more aware of staying out of foul trouble and just being smart,” Singler said.

Along with Dawkins, freshman ryan Kelly will also get his first taste of Division-i basketball. Kelly, lance Thomas, Miles Plumlee and Brian Zoubek will be relied upon to establish the inside game, particularly in the absence of Mason Plumlee.

“We’ll try to pass the ball high and get the ball down the court,” Singler said. “With that bigger unit we have, the main thing we have to do is not get rushed as a team. We have to stay poised and make good passes.”

Singler, who was chosen as the preseason Acc Player of the Year and named to the AP preseason All-Ameri-can team, leads the Blue Devil scoring attack while Miles Plumlee looks to overpower the Spartans inside. no play-er on Unc-Greensboro is taller than 6-foot-8 while Duke boasts a lineup that includes five active players who are 6-foot-8 or taller.

“our strength is the big guys around the court,” Schey-er said. “When [the big lineup] is in there, we need to be strong inside and get the ball in there.”

Friday’s game marks the first of four games in nine days for Duke. The Blue Devils take on coastal carolina Monday and the winner of the charlotte-elon matchup Tuesday in the niT Season Tip-off Tournament. Duke finishes the stretch by playing host to radford next Sat-urday afternoon.

But first, the Blue Devils have to take care of business against the Spartans. The team knows that upsets can hap-pen at any moment and must therefore play hard.

“it’s exciting to see where we can go from here and we still have a lot of work to do, but we’re looking forward to it,” Singler said.

M. BASKETBALL from page 9

laWSon KUrtZ/chronicle file photo

Freshman Andre Dawkins will have increased ball-handling duties Fri-day against UNc-Greensboro due to junior Nolan Smith’s suspension.

w. SoccER from page 9

goals-against-average with a 0.47 mark.“if we come out slow, they’re going to place a lot of

players behind the ball, and it’s going to be tough to score,” church said.

The Blue Devils boast a solid back line as well, and al-lowed only nine goals in 10 Acc contests. While possibly overmatched in terms of defense, Duke has a definite advantage in attack over the Scarlet Knights. The Blue Devils have scored four more goals and have tallied 25 more assists than rutgers this season.

Junior Ashley Jones poses the biggest threat to the young Duke defense. Jones leads the Scarlet Knights with eight goals in 15 games.

The Blue Devils are led offensively by senior captains KayAnne Gummersall and elisabeth redmond, who hold team-high totals in goals and assists with 11 and 12, respectively. Duke will look to put pressure on the Scarlet Knights from the opening whistle, and not allow

the rutgers offense time to execute. if the Blue Devil midfielders can beat their opponents in 50-50 situations and provide service to the attackers, church expressed confidence that his players can finish in the final third, something they’ve been focused on all week.

in a win-or-go-home environment, the Blue Devils are determined to extend the season, and give their senior teammates one extra game.

“it’s so exciting, because you know you have to put ev-erything out there. it could be your last game, nothing is guaranteed,” freshman midfielder nicole lipp said. “We just want to give the seniors one more game, and keep winning for them.”

With a victory on Friday, Duke would face the winner of no. 2 seed South carolina and Davidson.

Given a fresh slate, a hungry Blue Devil team has all the tools necessary to make a run in the postseason.

“i’m excited to see what our team can do,” church said. “We were a little nervous in the Acc tournament, but we’ve got some great leaders on the field, and i’m looking forward to seeing how we come together.”

12 | FRIDAY, NOVEMBER 13, 2009 ThE ChRONIClE

OPERATION: Stores Administration PUBLICATION: ChronicleHEADLINE: Hoops Shootout DATES: 11/11/09COLOR: CMYK

Tuesday, November 1711am - 2pm • West Campus Plaza

3-Point Shooting ContestFree Throw Shooting Contest

FREE Domino’s® Pizza & Buffalo Hot WingsFREE Chick-fil-A® Chicken Salad Sandwiches

FREE Fountain Drinks & Bottled Water

This event is open to all students* and employees.Prizes will be awarded to the top 3 contestants in each division.

*Due to NCAA® regulations, NCAA scholarship athletes are not eligible to participate in this event.In the case of inclement weather, this event will be held on Wednesday, November 18.

The Chronicleclassified advertising

www.dukechronicle.com/classifiedsrates

All advertising - $6.00 for first 15 words10¢ (per day) additional per word

3 or 4 consecutive insertions - 10 % off5 or more consecutive insertions - 20 % off

special featuresonline and print

all bold wording - $1.00 extra per day bold heading - $1.50 extra per day

bold and sub headline - $2.50 extra per dayonline only

attention getting icon - $1.00 extra per ad spotlight/feature ad - $2.00 per day

website link - $1.00 per admap - $1.00 per ad

hit counter - $1.00 per adpicture or graphic - $2.50 per ad

deadline12:00 noon 1 business day prior to publication

paymentPrepayment is required

Master Card, VISA, Discover, American Express, cash or checkad submission

online: www.dukechronicle.com/classifiedsemail: advertising@chronicle.duke.edu

fax to: 919-684-8295phone orders: (919)-684-3811

No refunds or cancellations after first insertion deadlineADVERTISERS: Please check your advertisement for errors on the first day of pub-lication. If you find an error, please call 919-684-3811. The Chronicle only accepts responsibility for the first incorrect day for ads entered by our office staff. We cannot offer make-good runs for errors in ads placed online by the customer.

ANNOUNCEMENTS

DUKE SUMMER SESSION 2010! It’s not too early to plan your summer. View projected summer course offerings at www.sum-mersession.duke.edu. Questions? Contact us at summer@duke.edu. Registration for Summer 2010 opens on February 22

RESEARCh STUDIES

EATINg IN COllEgE PACE: Path-way to Awareness in College Eat-ing is an online research study for the prevention and early inter-vention of eating problems. Spon-sored by UNC School of Medicine and offered at no-cost to eligible college students. See www.pace.unc.edu.

hElp WANTED

BARTENDERS ARE IN DEMAND!!!

Earn $20 - $35 per hour. 1 or 2 week classes & weekend classes. 100% Job Placement Assistance. RALEIGH’S BARTENDING SCHOOL. Have Fun! Make Money! Meet People! CALL NOW (919)676-0774 www.cocktailmixer.com

EARN ExTRA MONEY Students needed ASAP Earn up to $150 per day being a mystery shopper No Experience Required Call 1-800-722-4791 Egg DONORS NEEDED Egg Do-nors needed to help build fami-lies. Travel to India. Cash compen-sation and 3 week trip to India planned around your academicschedule. Ages 20 - 29 only. For more information, please call877-IVF- EGGS, www.proactive-familysolutions.com or 727-213-2450. Youngwomen of all ethnicities are en-couraged...childless families need you!! SURvEY TAKERS NEEDED: Make $5-25 per survey. www. GetPaid-ToThink.com

TRAvEl/vACATION

BAHAMAS SPRING BREAK

$189 for 5-DAYS or $239 for 7-DAYS. All prices include: Round-trip luxury cruise with food. Ac-commodations on the island at your choice of thirteen resorts. Appalachia Travel www. Baha-maSun.com 800-867-5018.

Europe 70 Days

www. Utrekjourneys.comTravel through 11 countries, sum-mer or fall and see all the hotspots along the way. Utrekjourneys.com Starts at $10,950.

If Little Bo Peep had put a classified ad in The Chronicle, she would have found her sheep much faster.

www.dukechronicle.com/classifieds

fromstaffreportsBlue Devils sign five to score nation’s top recruiting class Duke announced the signing of five top high school

prospects Wednesday, giving the Blue Devils the no. 1 recruiting class in the country, according to eSPn hoopGurlz. The class of 2010 is Duke’s best incoming group in the program’s history.

“it really is one of those incredible team deals—every-body coming together, everybody playing their role to re-cruit these great women,” head coach Joanne P. Mccallie said. “it’s truly been one of the most amazing and unique experiences i’ve gone through in recruiting and i think that this class has an opportunity to have an incredible ca-reer together.”

Four of the five recruits are ranked in the top 33 of the eSPn hoopGurlz rankings, led by no. 4 chel-sea Gray from St. Mary’s high School in Manteca, ca-lif. and no. 6 richa Jackson from Midwest city high School in Midwest city, okla. The rest of the group

includes chloe Wells of colton, calif., Tricia liston of river Forest, ill. and haley Peters from red Bank, n.J. Peters is the younger sister of Duke men’s basketball walk-on casey Peters.

The newest group of Blue Devils is backcourt-heavy as four of the five commits are listed as guards.

“We’ve got incredible guards in this class,” Mccallie said. “The group together just speaks of versatility, work ethic, commitment to Duke, excitement for the future in pursuing championships.”

snyderwine named semifinalist for lou Groza award Junior walk-on kicker Will Snyderwine has been named

one of the 20 semifinalists for the lou Groza Award, which is given to college football’s top placekicker each year.

The Duke kicker is seventh nationally with a .917 field-goal percentage and has connected on all of his 18 extra points. Snyderwine had his best game of the 2009 season oct. 31 against Virginia. The junior was 5-for-5 on field goals to lead the Blue Devils to a 28-17 victory, and was named Acc Specialist of the Week.

ThE ChRONIClE FRIDAY, NOVEMBER 13, 2009 | 13

DiversionsShoe Chris Cassatt and Gary Brookins

Dilbert Scott Adams

Ink Pen Phil Dunlap

Doonesbury Garry Trudeau

Sudoku Fill in the grid so that every row, every col-umn and every 3x3 box contains the digits 1 through 9. (No number is repeated in any column, row or box.)

Answer to puzzle

www.sudoku.com

The Chronicle evolucion:

micro or macro?: ............................................................ hon, charlieno thanks. intel design for me: .............................. will+emz, juliusof revolucion?: ....................................................................... brooks caribbean darwinism: ................................................................sushi#107: .............................................................................joe, sabreenaof course we’ll be there: ............................ cpena, crod, cian, cfoto4square: ..............................................................................klein, carter...i’m so confused: ................................ tracer, lindSAY, other peeps Barb Starbuck created the world in 3.5 days: .......................... Barb

Student Advertising Manager: ..............................Margaret PotterAccount Executives: ........................... Chelsea Canepa, Liza Doran

Lianna Gao, Ben MasselinkAmber Su, Mike Sullivan, Jack Taylor

Quinn Wang, Cap YoungCreative Services: ...............................Lauren Bledsoe, Danjie Fang

Christine Hall, Megan Meza Hannah Smith

Business Assistant: ........................................................Joslyn Dunn

Solo cups are red, Crazies are blue, Place your ad here So it gets many views!

Call to place your ad today

684.3811

Citizens in the fictitious Gotham City rely on Batman to fight crime when the justice sys-tem cannot.

The legendary ar-cher Robin Hood took his egalitarian convictions to the road by stealing from the rich and giving to the poor. Although the Eng-lish hero probably didn’t exist, the ro-mantic notion of a justice-minded out-law so entranced us that the story of Robin Hood continues to be retold, over and over again.

Facing injustice, vigilantes take action into their own hands with disregard for their own safety. They inspire an oft-imaginary Manichean world of right and wrong that people crave, and generate the con-veniently perfect hero who fights against evil for the good of the common people, the law and the natural order when the proper authorities can’t, or won’t.

A more diluted and common version of the vigi-lante’s modus operandi is the Neighborhood Watch group, which gives ordinary citizens responsibility to protect their respective communities. Three years ago, Duke students voted in a University-wide referen-dum that overwhelmingly approved a similar commit-ment on campus, and appended the pithy but power-ful eight-word line to the Community Standard—“I shall act if the Standard is compromised.”

Since Fall 2007, incoming students sign a pledge to act with integrity both on and off cam-pus, regarding “every aspect of undergraduate life.” When encountering anti-Standard behavior, “students are… expected to take action—to do something—as a responsibility of membership in the Duke Community.”

On paper, the new addition gives the Standard more oomph, but does it give students more moti-vation to act? Perhaps anticipating confusion about what said action entails, Student Conduct offers suggestions on its Web site that include speaking directly to the offending person, publicly calling at-tention to the behavior, alerting a residential assis-tant or the associate dean for judicial affairs.

But disciplinary statistics show that students initi-ated only 11 out of 934 adjudicated cases, and zero of the 107 academic complaints taken since the new clause was adopted. None of the cases were initiated through The Chronicle, only five by an academic dean and around 15 percent by a residence coordi-nator, graduate assistant or resident assistant. Com-plaints from these four groups have not changed from numbers before 2007.

It doesn’t seem then, that the new clause is in-spiring students to act, at least not in the ways that Student Conduct recommends.

But not only that, the new Standard may be un-intentionally lending a minority population great-er justification to act above or against the law.

Cases in point: A fellow student who comes from a poor family consistently steals food from the Great Hall because he believes other, wealthier Duke students should pay for his meals and coun-ter the massive wealth imbalance on campus.

Outside Duke, Student Two feels that stealing from stores like Walmart is morally justifiable be-cause theft is an active form of protest rather than passive ones such as boycotting. Student Three ful-filled his commitment to act by humiliating class-mates on the former JuicyCampus.com because he thought they behaved poorly.

If we take Turgenev’s argument that all people can be categorized as Hamlets or Don Quixotes, the vigilantes fall into the latter and the majority of the student population, the former.

Both are dangerous—Hamlet’s paralysis re-sults in missed opportunities for community im-provement, and Don Quixote’s headstrong and rash decisions can lead to socially destructive consequences.

For both extremes, the impetus to act, or not act, hinges not on what is considered “right” in a higher sense, but by how the consequences of action will affect the individual. Hamlets might hesitate to snitch because they prioritize protect-ing each other over protecting the institution and its institutionally-issued standards. For Don Quix-otes, the claim to action is attractive because it generates instant gratification and a sense of self-affirmation for contributing “to the greater good.” But again, their sacrifices are often actions thinly disgusted over desires to satisfy a personal injury, not duty to a higher law.

Ad-hoc, covert moral judgments and punish-ments are too vulnerable to personal biases and lack of information. Vigilantes who take responsi-bility into their own hands may work as superhe-roes and in fables, but in Duke’s reality--at least in the examples I’ve encountered--vigilantes are too frequently self-rationalists, not martyrs of justice.

We could better fulfill the obligation to act we voted for by seeking the mean between Ham-let and Don Quixote. There’s nothing wrong with Duke students taking action in informal spaces that feel more comfortable than official proceedings, but in this community, there’s no need to break the law. Duke vigilantes, I hope you are reading this.

Courtney Han is a Trinity senior. Her column runs every other Friday.

commentaries14 | FRIDAY, NOVEMBER 13, 2009 thE chRONIclE

the c

hron

icle

The

Ind

epen

dent

Dai

ly a

t D

uke

Uni

vers

ity

editorial

Last Spring, the Univer-sity announced that the Ca-reer Center would ultimate-ly be relocating to a new and larger space in the Smith Warehouse.

Since then, the University has continued to consolidate auxiliary groups and offices on cam-pus to the warehouse. The list now includes the Global Education Office (formerly Study Abroad) and the Duke Center for Civic Engage-ment, which houses the Du-keEngage program.

While we are happy to see that the University has improved access to Smith Warehouse with the recent addition of a bus route be-tween the building and West Campus, the relocation of

offices so central to students’ lives to a location so periph-eral to students’ everyday milieu is concerning in the short term.

The migration of campus entities to the more spacious Smith Ware-

house makes sense for some departments, such as the Of-fice of the University Regis-trar and Duke Performances. Others, like the Career Cen-ter and the Center for Civic Engagement, are hurt by the lack of casual student foot traffic that is more common in busier venues like Page or Campus Drive.

The original plan for some Smith Warehouse relocations was that the building would be a temporary measure—a place where various offices could set

up shop before the completion of New Campus. But with last year’s economic collapse, many of the offices that temporarily moved to the Smith Warehouse are there to stay.

Realistically, the location has one advantage over prime West Campus real estate—an abundance of space. Further-more, the Smith Warehouse will allow for more comfort-able interview rooms, instead of the current cramped inter-rogation-style cells in the base-ment of Page Auditorium.

One concern with moving student-oriented offices like the Career Center and the DCCE to the Smith Warehouse is that the location is simply in-convenient. Even with the ad-dition of a dedicated bus, few students will casually visit the building, with most trips the

result of a necessity.But more importantly, the

way that offices have been re-located is incoherent and in-consistent with institutional priorities. It seems like de-partments have been moved around willy-nilly without any sensible overall plan. And that Global Education and DukeEngage—two of the University’s defining pro-grams—have been relegated to Smith Warehouse, away from the center of student life, is equally puzzling.

Because the offices have already been moved, the Uni-versity should pursue possible solutions to the problem of de-creased traffic to Smith Ware-house. Buses are a good first start, but it might be a good idea for student-centered de-partments in Smith to have

satellite offices in more promi-nent, busier campus locations like the Bryan Center. Satellite locations would establish a visi-ble presence as well as provide interested students with in-formation about services pro-vided at main offices at Smith. Also, increasing signage within the warehouse’s many bays would help students who are making the trek for the first time find their way around the cavernous building.

When all is said and done, these measures will likely be necessary only for a few years. Over time, students will adjust to the new reality, and start-ing with next year’s freshman class, the office locations won’t be “new” at all. In the short term, however, administrators should not let current students fall through the cracks.

Vigilantes and snitch

Out of sight, out of mind

”“ onlinecomment

As a fellow American Muslim, thanks for writing this.

—“haahaamagician” commenting on the column “An open letter to Major Hasan .” See more at www.dukechronicle.com.

Letters PoLicyThe Chronicle welcomes submissions in the form of letters

to the editor or guest columns. Submissions must include the author’s name, signature, department or class, and for purposes of identification, phone number and local address. Letters should not exceed 325 words; contact the editorial department for information regarding guest columns.

The Chronicle will not publish anonymous or form letters or letters that are promotional in nature. The Chronicle reserves the right to edit letters and guest columns for length, clarity and style and the right to withhold letters based on the discretion of the editorial page editor.

Direct submissions to:

E-mail: chronicleletters@duke.eduEditorial Page DepartmentThe ChronicleBox 90858, Durham, NC 27708Phone: (919) 684-2663Fax: (919) 684-4696

Inc. 1993Est. 1905 the chroniclewill robinson, Editor

Hon lung CHu, Managing Editoremmeline ZHao, News Editorgabe starosta, Sports Editor

miCHael naClerio, Photography EditorsHuCHi ParikH, Editorial Page EditormiCHael blake, Editorial Board Chair

alex klein, Online EditorjonatHan angier, General Manager

lindsey ruPP, University Editor ZaCHary traCer, University Editorsabreena merCHant, Sports Managing Editor julia love, Features Editorjulius jones, Local & National Editor toni wei, Local & National Editorjinny CHo, Health & Science Editor raCHna reddy, Health & Science EditorCourtney douglas, News Photography Editor ian soileau, Sports Photography Editorandrew Hibbard, Recess Editor austin boeHm, Editorial Page Managing Editor emily bray, Editorial Page Managing Editor rebeCCa wu, Editorial Page Managing EditorasHley Holmstrom, Wire Editor naureen kHan, Senior Editor CHarlie lee, Design Editor dean CHen, Lead DeveloperCHelsea allison, Towerview Editor ben CoHen, Towerview Editoreugene wang, Recess Managing Editor maddie lieberberg, Recess Photography EditorCHase olivieri, Multimedia Editor lawson kurtZ, Towerview Photography EditorZaCHary kaZZaZ, Recruitment Chair Caroline mCgeougH, Recruitment Chairtaylor doHerty, Sports Recruitment Chair andy moore, Sports Recruitment Chairmary weaver, Operations Manager CHrissy beCk, Advertising/Marketing Directorbarbara starbuCk, Production Manager rebeCCa diCkenson, Chapel Hill Ad Sales Manager

the Chronicle is published by the duke student Publishing Company, inc., a non-profit corporation independent of duke university. the opinions expressed in this newspaper are not necessarily those of duke university, its students, faculty, staff, administration or trustees. unsigned editorials represent the majority view of the editorial board. Columns, letters and cartoons represent the views of the authors.

to reach the editorial office at 301 Flowers building, call 684-2663 or fax 684-4696. to reach the business office at 103 west union building, call 684-3811. to reach the advertising office at 101 west union building call 684-3811 or fax 684-8295. visit the Chronicle online at http://www.dukechronicle.com.

© 2009 the Chronicle, box 90858, durham, n.C. 27708. all rights reserved. no part of this publication may be repro-duced in any form without the prior, written permission of the business office. each individual is entitled to one free copy.

courtney han the good life?

commentariesthE chRONIclE FRIDAY, NOVEMBER 13, 2009 | 15

In the eternal drama of global dominion, masters are somehow indelible and short-lived. The specters of such bygone powers as ancient Rome, imperial China

and industrial Britain still loom, almost legendarily, as ever-present reminders of nation and empire in their grandest forms.

Yet though the empires of old are eternal in our historical consciousness, the extent of their global dominance is usually finite. Thus, our pressing ques-tion, especially in a time of perceived economic and so-cial deterioration, becomes not if but when will American dominance end?

Popular columnist and TV personality Fareed Zakaria addressed this and other questions regarding America’s place in a new global community in a compelling lecture here at Duke Monday. In his estimation, the stagnation of American investment in education and growth industries smacks of a potential death knell to our throne atop the world, just as it has for the crowned rulers of the past. If that is the case, then we, the next productive generation and members of a spectacularly educated class of poten-tial future leaders, hold in our hands the keys to American destiny: no pressure, but our time is now.

The validity of Zakaria’s warning is no more apparent than here on campus, where the best and brightest upon whom a nation pins its hopes overwhelmingly choose paths of personal stability at the risk of broader stagnation. With-

out slighting those here who are at the forefront of fueling education and innovation, it is clear that those who opt for old guard careers such as finance, consulting and special-ized medicine are still numerous. It perpetuates a trend of major talent flocking to established, internalized sectors largely devoid of the sort of global productive power that molds great nations.

The problem, as Zakaria would put it, is that there is no growth. Finance pushes money around, producing only “financial instruments” that most recently were the root of a near-collapse in global economics. Consulting en-hances the rigidity of finance hegemony by advising said institutions in strong-armed market power brokering and consolidation. And apart from the extent to which Ameri-can doctors can treat the patients of the world (only the obscenely wealthy at this point), health care remains an ever-ballooning, intranationally financed drag upon earn-ings and production in comparison with the rest of the developed world.

The merits of growth in one sector over another need not be debated because the facts are clear: these are exam-ples of professions in sectors that are indeed essential, but whose dogmatic centrality to the new American economy has weakened its capacity for adaptation and true growth. It would be more illuminating to discuss the propensity for our generation to overwhelmingly flock to the safety of those established fields or, perhaps more accurately, our hesitance to take the bull by the horns and forge some-thing new in the way that Zakaria advocates.

Zakaria had his own historical take on this as well, re-minding us that the Cold War generated a social mandate for personal contributions to the advancement of science, education and technology in the 1950s and 60s, which

largely contributed to our current (or former) dominance in those fields. The 2009 analog to that mandate would seem to be a selfish desire to take what’s ours in the form of safe employment, driving us in the opposite direction. Say what you will about the right to choose one’s own path, but there’s something a little unsettling about our genera-tion’s conspicuous consumption culture in contrast with the sacrifices of past generations.

Then again, maybe the onus falls upon our nation’s leadership to make it “safe” to invest our labor in the coun-try’s future as opposed to the future of Goldman Sachs (with the hope that they are independent of each other). Just as a cold war government invested heavily and propa-gandized shamelessly for the sake of a unified fight for su-periority, perhaps their contemporaries can make it worth our while to participate in the recovery of “American dyna-mism,” as Zakaria put it). Unfortunately, that hasn’t hap-pened yet, and therein lies our generation’s greatest chal-lenge: If it doesn’t ever happen, will we choose of our own accord to make America’s business our own business?

There is no doubt that our generation is up to the challenge. More young people are service oriented than ever before, with a desire to effect real, beneficial change. Shrinking job markets in traditional sectors have encour-aged us to look elsewhere for opportunities, and some of those that we find will undoubtedly make strides in the right direction. Even better, if we choose to make a con-certed effort to work for our collective benefit as a nation, then we may yet embody the greatest generation of our time. Now is the time to make our choice.

Mike Meers is a Trinity senior. His column runs every other Friday.

America’s Generation Next

Look for Nathan Freeman’s newest

column in Monday’s edit pages.

A disservice to serviceIf one were to list the distinctive experiences char-

acteristic of Duke undergraduate life, Duke Dining horror stories do not come immediately to mind.

Yet, for a striking number of students, the frequency of these bad service experiences has been startlingly con-sistent over time.

Indeed, the service prob-lem at the Marketplace, and to a lesser extent the Great Hall, has been around as long as most people can remember. To be sure, the majority of Duke Dining employees do an excellent job. Some are true models of character that students could benefit to learn from and emulate. Still, there seems to be a dispropor-tionately high concentration of persistently rude (if not outright insulting) employees in a few campus eateries (primarily the Marketplace and, to a lesser extent, the Great Hall). That these are union eateries does not ap-pear to be a coincidence.

According to Duke Student Government Chief of Staff Mike LeFevre, a junior, who served as last year’s DSG vice president for athletics and campus services, the annual dining survey has consistently shown student appraisals of overall service quality as “disgusting.” The service prob-lem, he said, consisted in student reports of being outright “harassed and mistreated” as well as unsanitary conduct by employees. Several sources report students being yelled at or insulted by employees for asking simple questions. Sophomore Pete Schork, the current vice president for athletics and campus services, noted that this year’s dining survey reflects similarly poor reviews of the service quality in these eateries.

So by “horror stories,” I don’t mean the petty com-plaints you sometimes hear about employees being less-than-exuberant towards every student with whom they in-teract. What for a student is just a passing moment may be what an employee does all day. That reality qualifies the intensity of student complaints somewhat, and upfront, is something with which students should (and by all ac-counts it would seem, do) sympathize.

Nonetheless, as most any student can tell you and the survey results show, the kinds of service complaints most students bother reporting are instances of behavior which would be inappropriate in any situation involving other

human beings, not just a student-employee interaction. A basic problem is that there is little to no accountabil-ity for underperforming employees, since managers have few tools for disciplining employees and the required evidence threshold to take action is unreasonably high, Schork said.

“It’s unfair to have any situation where you can’t be held responsible for behavior that is in most venues very inappropriate,” Schork explained. “I’m not saying we should have to fire people. In my experience… the [Local 77] union hasn’t even been proactive in addressing any of our concerns. They haven’t even said they’ll take proactive steps, to say that we’ll talk to those people, and I think that’s the very least we deserve as students.”

Currently, students can report complaints by filling out comment cards after their meal. But identifying employ-ees by name can be difficult, since it is common for em-ployees to switch name tags, according to multiple student sources. Moreover, LeFevre said, the union will “go to bat for employees every time” without exception, creating an enormously high burden of proof for student complaints. This situation, in addition to a significant problem of em-ployee absenteeism (which former Chronicle columnist Elliott Wolf alluded to in his February 2008 column, “At-tention, Duke Employees”), led to the installation of 12 surveillance cameras in the Marketplace and a monitoring screen so that employees know where their behavior can be observed, LeFevre said. That the situation has deteriorated to this point reflects the extent to which administrators are fearful of engaging the union on these issues. Director of Dining Services Jim Wulforst could not be reached for comment on this issue.

Schork and LeFevre were keen to point out that they have no problem with unions in general and believe that they can serve a valuable role against a bad employer. But Duke, both observed, is far from a bad employer, with its payment of a living wage and numerous employee benefits.

If students were being systematically disrespectful to-wards employees, then perhaps cases of employee miscon-duct would be more understandable. However, although there are surely exceptions, students generally go out of their way to be polite and respectful to employees, LeFe-vre said. Positive student-employee relations is a two-way street, and it’s not unreasonable to expect that an effort be made by all parties involved.

High-performing unionized employees lose out under the current system as well. Existing union policies base promotions and raises on seniority rather than perfor-mance, whereas non-union eateries utilize merit-based

performance reviews, LeFevre said. It’s not hard to infer how these different incentive structures might contribute to an explanation of the variation in service quality be-tween union and non-union locations.

One problem, Schork and LeFevre both suggested, may be in Duke-Durham relations overall. No doubt, the politi-cal sensitivity of these issues restrains how administrators can deal with it. Recognizing the intractability of this prob-lem, Schork offered the partial solution of creating more dialogue between students and employees at these facili-ties in the hope of generating greater mutual understand-ing. For his part, LeFevre suggested that students should be more diligent about submitting comment cards rather than venting privately.

Fair enough. But although such efforts certainly couldn’t hurt, I am less optimistic about how far they will go. The problem here is not the union per se, but particu-lar factors in the University’s agreement with the union that limit the accountability of employees. Until that is ad-dressed, it seems that little will change.

Absent a commitment from administration to address students’ service grievances when they confront Local 77, these provisions will continue to neuter the effectiveness with which student complaints can be remedied. And that is a real disservice—both to students, and those employees who take their jobs seriously and excel in them.

Vikram Srinivasan is a Trinity senior. His column usually runs every other Thursday.

vikram srinivasanuncommon conviction

nathan freemangood night,

and good luck

mike meers mike check

16 | FRIDAY, NOVEMBER 13, 2009 thE chRONIclE