Nothing is New Under the Sun - Prof. Rubbia

8/12/2019 Nothing is New Under the Sun - Prof. Rubbia

http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/nothing-is-new-under-the-sun-prof-rubbia 1/4

"

!"#$%&' %) &*+ ,&-*. #$* /,& 0

#$%&' ($' ($' )*$+% ,-../*01/234/&/1 (/$214%$5 6374/4-42 &%$ 89:*3129 0-74*/3*./+/4; 04-9/27 2'<'

#%479*=5 >2$=*3;

"#$$%&'()*+), -%$.&/)0 0% 12%34 5.66+(78 9/*)%0/ (--2/88 -.2+), 0:/ ;2- <++ </8/20

=)/2,* >%)3/2/)$/ ?@/2A+)B C%D/&6/2 E"F GHIGJ4

?@2 .2A/33/3A %& 4@2 B$*14/1*+ -72 %& 7%+*$ B%C2$ A%27 .*1D 7%=2 EF1234-$/27 *A% C/4@ 8$1@/=2927 %& 0;$*1-725 GEHI J) 4% E"E J)K /3 7-33; 0/1/+;'L*4@2=*4/1/*35 B@;7/1/745 23A/322$5 /3:234%$ *39 *74$%3%=2$5 @2 @*7 .223 %32 %& 4@2+2*9/3A 71/234/747 %& 4@2 1+*77/1*+ *34/M-/4;' ?@2 C$/4423 C%$D %& 8$1@/=2927 @*7 3%47-$:/:29 *7 C2++ *7 4@*4 %& N-1+/95 *39 72:23 %& @/7 4$2*4/727 *$2 D3%C3 4% @*:2 2O/7429%3+; 4@$%-A@ $2&2$23127 =*92 4% 4@2= .; %4@2$ *-4@%$7' P3+; &2C 924*/+7 *$2 D3%C3'Q%C2:2$5 4@2 $2+*4/:2+; &2C 1%B/27 %& 8$1@/=2927R C$/4423 C%$D 4@*4 7-$:/:294@$%-A@ 4@2 L/99+2 8A27 C2$2 *3 /3&+-234/*+ 7%-$12 %& /92*7 &%$ 71/234/747 9-$/3A 4@2,23*/77*312'

Q/7 1%34$/.-4/%37 /3 =*4@2=*4/17 @*:2 .223 /==2372S 4@2 /3/4/*4%$ %& 4@2/3&/3/427/=*+75 *34/1/B*4/3A 4@2 =%92$3 1*+1-+-7 %& 4@2 $*4/% .24C223 4@2 7M-*$2 %& 4@2$*9/-7 *39 4@2 *$2* %& * 1/$1+25 4@2 M-*9$*4-$2 %& * B*$*.%+* *7 4@2 7%+-4/%3 %& *3/3&/3/42 72$/275 4@2 1234$2 %& A$*:/4; %& A2%=24$/1 &/A-$27 *39 7% %3' ?@2 T/2+97 L29*+54@2 2M-/:*+234 %& 4@2 U%.2+ /3 =*4@2=*4/17 1*$$/27 @/7 B%$4$*/4 *+%3A C/4@ * 1*$:/3A/++-74$*4/3A @/7 B$%%& %3 4@2 7B@2$2 *39 4@2 1;+/392$' ?@2 /371$/B4/%3 /7 * M-%42*44$/.-429 4% @/=5 C@/1@ $2*97 /3 V*4/3S KL2()8+2/ 8..& '/$0.8 &.)-%M./ '%0+2+K G1%)*

23"4* "&*)*56 2&- '.2)7 #$* +".5-K'

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

Q/7 1%34$/.-4/%3 4% 4%9*;Y7 4%B/1 %& 9/71-77/%3 /7 4@2 K#2$:+&/-/8 :/(0 2(*PB 3*=2+; 4@2 9/71%:2$; 4@*4 1%31234$*4/3A 7%+*$ +/A@4 1%-+9 .2 * =*Z%$ 7%-$12 %& @/A@42=B2$*4-$2 @2*4' Q2 D32C C2++ 4@2 B$%B2$4/27 %& 4@2 B*$*.%+*' 8 +*$A2 *$$*; %&@/A@+; B%+/7@29 .$%3[2 %$ 1%BB2$ 7@/2+97 *14/3A 1%++214/:2+; *7 1%31234$*4/3A =/$$%$7@*:2 .223 2=B+%;29 4% &%1-7 7-3+/A@4 *11%$9/3A 4% 4@2 B$/31/B+2 %& 4@2 B*$*.%+/1$2&+214%$ *39 /3 * =*332$ 7/=/+*$ 4% 4@2 %32 %& * 7%+*$ &-$3*12' ?@/7 B$/31/B+2 @*7.223 $2+*4/:2+; C2++ 9/&&-729 /3 4@2 *34/M-/4;' T%$ /374*312 $2&+214%$7 %& 7-3+/A@4 C2$2-729 /3 7-33; ?/.24 4% @2*4 C*42$ /3 %$92$ 4% B$%9-12 &%$ /374*312 @%4 42*'

63 4@2 E39 1234-$; 8( 4@2 \0;$/*3] V-1/*3 %& 0*=%7*4* G8( "E^ _ *&42$ 8( "H`KC$%42 /3 >$22D 4@*45 9-$/3A 4@2 0/2A2 %& 0;$*1-72 GE"abE"E J)K5 8$1@/=2927 @*9*14-*++; -729 &%1-729 7-3+/A@4 4% 9274$%; ,%=*3 7@/B7 C/4@ &/$2' )234-$/27 +*42$5834@2=/-7 %& ?$*++27 G8( aIa _ .2&%$2 ^^HK5 * >$22D B$%&277%$ %& )%374*34/3%B+2GB$27234_9*; 674*3.-+K =234/%329 *7 C2++ 8$1@/=2927R C2*B%37'



E

0/312 4@2 ,23*/77*3125 4@/7 C2*B%3 @*7 .223 4@2 7-.Z214 %& *3 %3A%/3A 92.*42*.%-4 /47 1$29/./+/4;' (271*$427 $2Z21429 /4 *7 &*+72' L%92$3 $272*$1@2$7 @*:2*442=B429 4% $21$2*42 4@2 2&&214 -7/3A %3+; 4@2 =2*37 *:*/+*.+2 4% 8$1@/=2927' ?2747-7/3A * C%%923 .%*4 C2$2 B2$&%$=29 /3 >$2212 /3 "cIF .; 6%*33/7 0*DD*75 4@23 /3

E``^ .; * A$%-B %& 74-92347 &$%= 4@2 L6? /3 0*3 T$*31/71% .*; *39 /3 (212=.2$E`"` .; * 7B21/*+ 42+2:/7/%3 7@%C &2*4-$/3A 3%4 +277 4@*3 J*$*1D P.*=* *39 234/4+29\#$27/9234R7 )@*++23A27]' 64 C*7 A232$*++; 1%31+-929 4@*4 4@2 92:/12 C*7 * &2*7/.+2C2*B%3 -392$ 4@272 1%39/4/%37 *+4@%-A@ 4@2 M-274/%3 $2=*/37 2:/9234+; %B23'

Historians continue to doubt the Archimedes story, 7/312 1%3:234/%3*+ C2*B%3$;57-1@ *7 &+*=/3A *$$%C7 %$ .%+47 &$%= * 1*4*B-+45 C%-+9 @*:2 .223 * &*$ 2*7/2$ C*; %&7244/3A * 7@/B %3 &/$2 *4 7@%$4 9/74*3127' 8 =%$2 +/D2+; 2&&214 %& 4@2 =/$$%$7 C%-+9@*:2 .223 .+/39/3A5 9*[[+/3A5 %$ 9/74$*14/3A 4@2 1$2C %& 4@2 232=; 7@/B'U%4C/4@74*39/3A5 4@2 *./+/4; %& 1%31234$*4/3A 7%+*$ +/A@4 $2=*/37 *7 * :2$;&-39*=234*+ /92* C/4@ /=B%$4*34 1%372M-23127'

?@2 =%92$3 92:2+%B=234 %& 7%+*$ B%C2$ @*7 74*$429 /3 "IdI C@23 4@2 0C/7771/234/74 Q%$*12_J2329/14 92 0*-77-$2 1$2*429 4@2 &/$74 7%+*$ 1%++214%$ b 4@$22 +*;2$7%& A+*77 4% *.7%$. @2*4 232$A;' 0*-77-$2Y7 .%O .21*=2 C/92+; D3%C3 *7 4@2 &/$747%+*$ %:235 $2*1@/3A 42=B2$*4-$27 %& EF` eT' 63 "HFc *3%4@2$ =*Z%$ =/+274%32 /3 4@22:%+-4/%3 %& 7%+*$ 232$A; @*7 .223 4@2 9/71%:2$; %& 4@2 B@%4%:%+4*/1 2&&214 .; 4@2T$231@ 71/234/74 N9=%39 J21M-2$2+ -7/3A 4C% 2+214$%927 B+*129 /3 *3 2+214$%+;42' 83/=B%$4*34 +277%3 C*7 +2*$329 b 4@*4 *3 *BB$%B$/*42 7%+/9 1%-+9 1%3:2$4 +/A@4 /34%2+214$/1/4; C/4@%-4 @2*4 %$ =%:/3A B*$47' ?@2 9/71%:2$; +*/9 * 74$%3A .*72 &%$ &-4-$292:2+%B=2347 /3 4@2 @/74%$; %& 7%+*$ B%C2$' 631/9234*++; 8+.2$4 N/3742/3 $212/:29 4@2"cEE U%.2+ #$/[2 B-.+/7@/3A /3 "c`^ @/7 B*B2$ &%$ @/7 \9/71%:2$; %& 4@2 +*C %& 4@2B@%4%2+214$/1 2&&214Wb *39 3%4 &%$ >232$*+ ,2+*4/:/4; GXK' ,%.2$4 L/++/D*35 "cEF U%.2+

V*-$2*42 W&%$ @/7 C%$D %3 4@2 2+2=234*$; 1@*$A2 %& 2+214$/1/4; *39 %3 4@2B@%4%2+214$/1 2&&214]5 92=%374$*429 /4 2OB2$/=234*++; /3 "c"d'

?@2 7B21/&/1 92:2+%B=234 %& )%31234$*429 0%+*$ #%C2$ G)0#K .2A*3 /3 "HddC@23 4@2 T$231@ /3:234%$ 8-A-742 L%-1@%-4 -729 * B*$*.%+/1 4$%-A@ 4% B$%9-12742*= &%$ 4@2 &/$74 7%+*$ 23A/325 1%3:2$4/3A 7%+*$ 232$A; /34% =21@*3/1*+ 742*=B%C2$' 63 "HHd /3 >23%* 4@2 64*+/*3 8+277*39$% J*44*A+/* B-.+/7@29 4@2 &/$74 B*4234&%$ * 7%+*$ 1%++214%$'

63 4@2 &%++%C/3A ;2*$75 =*Z%$ B$%A$277 C*7 *1@/2:29 .; 4@2 8=2$/1*3/3:234%$ T$*3D 0@-=*3' 63 "c"F5 @2 $2*+/[29 * ^^ Q# B*$*.%+/1 7%+*$ 4@2$=*+ 232$A;74*4/%3 /3 NA;B45 32*$ L**9/5 &%$ /$$/A*4/%3 &$%= 4@2 U/+2' 0@-=*3 @*9 * $2=*$D*.+2

:/7/%3 &%$ * =*3 C@%5 *+4@%-A@ B%77277/3A * 74$%3A 927/$2 4% +2*$3 *39 B$*14/1271/23125 +2&4 B-.+/1 71@%%+ *&42$ %3+; 4@$22 ;2*$7' P32_1234-$;_%+9 T$*3D 0@-=*3Y79$2*=7 C2$2 /31$29/.+; 1+%72 4% 4@2 %327 1-$$234+; 9/71-7729 @2$2 *4 4@2 (N0N,?N)

1%3&2$2312. f-%4/3AS

NQ/ RS:.&()T :%'/- 0% 6.+A- GH U GVH 8M.(2/ &+A/8 %3 2/3A/$0%28 +) 0:/ S(:(2(B

,+D+), 0:/ W%2A- +) '/2'/0.+0* 0:/ GEH &+AA+%) :%28/'%W/2 '/2 */(2 0% /M.(A (AA 0:/

R$%(AT 3./A &+)/- +) IFHFP

?%9*;5 /4 @*7 .223 +*$A2+; &%$A%4423 @%C 1+%72 T$*3D 0@-=*3 1*=2 4% A244/3A4@2 C%$+9 4% -72 7%+*$ B%C2$ %3 * B$*14/1*+5 1%==2$1/*+ 71*+2 Z-74 .2&%$2 g%$+9 g*$

P32' T2C B2%B+2 D3%C @%C 4@2 D2; 421@3%+%A; &%$ 4@2 @-A2 7%+*$ B%C2$ B+*3474%9*; B+*3329 &%$ 4%=%$$%C5 4@2 4$%-A@_7@*B29 $2&+214%$7 4@*4 1%31234$*42 4@2



F

7-3Y7 @2*4 %34% * B/B2 /3 4@2/$ 1234$2 1*=2 &$%= 4@2 @*$9 C%$D %& * @-=.+2 *39 =%74+/D*.+2 =*3 C@% 32:2$ 2:23 1%=B+2429 @/A@ 71@%%+' 6392295 C@23 +*42$ %&&2$29 *@%3%$*$; =*742$7 92A$22 .; )%$32++ h3/:2$7/4; &%$ @/7 B/%322$/3A C%$D %3 7%+*$232$A;5 T$*3D 0@-=*3 921+/329 /45 7*;/3A 4@*4 @2 1%-+9 3%4 *112B4 7-1@ *3 @%3%-$

.21*-72 @2 32:2$ 1%=B+2429 *3; 29-1*4/%3*+ 92A$22.

0@-=*3 *$$*3A29 =/$$%$7 /34% $%C75 $27-+4/3A /3 4@2 4$%-A@_7@*B29 7%+*$1%++214%$75 C@/1@ B$%:29 4% .2 7% 2&&/1/234 4@*4 4@2; @*:2 .223 -729 72:234; ;2*$7+*42$ *7 4@2 .*7/7 &%$ 4@2 0N>0 B+*347' 0@-=*Y7 1%++214%$75 72:23 $%C7 /3 4%4*+5 1%-+9C/4@74*39 A*+2 &%$12 C/3975 *39 $27429 %3 $2/3&%$129 1%31$242' <2$; @%4 C*42$ +2&42*1@ B/B2 *39 2=B4/29 /34% * =*/3 9-14 +2*9/3A 4% * 7B21/*++; 927/A329 =%4%$ 4@*4$-3 %3 +%C_B$277-$2 742*=' 8&42$ +2*:/3A 4@2 =%4%$5 * 1%392372$ 1%3:2$429 4@2742*= .*1D /34% C*42$ 4@*4 $24-$329 4% 4@2 1%++214%$7' NO1277 @%4 C*42$ C*7 74%$29/3 * +*$A2 /37-+*429 4*3D5 G* &/$74 232$A; 74%$*A2K5 23*.+/3A 4@2 B+*34 4% %B2$*42 Ea@%-$7 * 9*;5 *39 %3 %:2$1*74 %$ $*/3; 9*;7'

P3 4@2 A$*39 %B23/3A %& 4@2 B+*34 %& 0@-=*3Y7 0-3 #%C2$ )%=B*3; /3 i-+;"c"F5 4@2 1$2*= %& J$/4/7@ 1%+%3/*+ 7%1/24; /3 NA;B4j/31+-9/3A Z%-$3*+/7475 $*3D/3A1/:/+ 72$:*3475 *39 9/B+%=*47jA*4@2$29 /3 L**9/ 4% C/43277 * =%74 -3-7-*+/$$/A*4/%3 B+*34' 8=%3A 4@2 9/74/3A-/7@295 C2++_9$27729 1$%C95 4@2 =%74 9*[[+/3A.; &*$ C*7 </71%-34 Q%$*4/% Q2$.2$4 k/41@232$ %& k@*$4%-=5 * =/+/4*$; @2$% &*=%-7&%$ .$/3A/3A 0-9*3 -392$ J$/4/7@ 1%34$%+ /3 4@2 "Hc`7' ?*++5 C/4@ * 4@/1D C*+$-7=%-74*1@2 *39 B/2$1/3A 2;275 k/41@232$ @*9 *112B429 *3 *BB%/34=234 4C% ;2*$72*$+/2$5 /3 "c""5 *7 1%37-+_A232$*+ *39 =/3/742$ B+23/B%4234/*$; /3 NA;B45 =*D/3A@/= 4@2 =%74 B%C2$&-+ =*3 /3 4@2 1%-34$;' V%$9 k/41@232$ %&&2$29 0@-=*3Y71%=B*3; * F`Y``` *1$2 1%44%3 B+*34*4/%3 /3 4@2 J$/4/7@ 0-9*3 %3 C@/1@ 4% 4274 7%+*$_B%C2$29 /$$/A*4/%3' 839 >2$=*3; %&&2$29 0@-=*3 l E``Y``` %& 4@2 2B%1@ 4% B*; &%$* 7/=/+*$ B+*34 /3 C@*4 C*7 4@23 >2$=*3 0%-4@C274 8&$/1* GB$27234_9*; U*=/./*K'

P3 8-A-74 a "c"a5 >$2*4 J$/4*/3 921+*$29 C*$ %3 >2$=*3;' 0%+*$ B%C2$=/A@4 @*:2 7-$:/:29 4@2 1@*%7 %& g%$+9 g*$ P325 .-4 &%$ * 4@$22 +2442$7 C%$9S ,")7 )@2*B *39 B+234/&-+ 32C+; 9/71%:2$29 %/+ 9/==29 7%+*$ B%C2$Y7 B$%7B2147 2:23C@2$2 /4 =/A@4 @*:2 .223 1%74_2&&214/:2 4% -72' L%$2%:2$5 C/4@ 4@2 >2$=*37 /392&2*4 *39 4@2/$ 8&$/1*3 1%+%3/27 4*D23 %:2$5 4@2 B$%=/727 =*92 4% 4@2 0-3 #%C2$)%=B*3; C2$2 *7 C%$4@+277 *7 4@2 (2-471@=*$D7 %&&2$29 4% /4' 839 4@2 J$/4/7@5 4%%5@*9 +%74 /342$274 /3 7%+*$ B%C2$'

64 C*7 %3+; ^^ ;2*$7 +*42$5 /3 "cdH5 4@*4 >/%:*33/ T$*31/* G"c""b"cH`K

927/A329 *39 .-/+4 *3%4@2$ 1%31234$*429_7%+*$ B+*345 C@/1@ 2342$29 /34% %B2$*4/%3/3 0*34R6+*$/%5 32*$ >23%*5 64*+;' ?@/7 B+*34 @*9 4@2 *$1@/4214-$2 %& 4%9*;R71%31234$*429_7%+*$ B+*347 C/4@ * 7%+*$ $212/:2$ /3 4@2 1234$2 %& * &/2+9 %& 7%+*$1%++214%$7' ?@2 B+*34 C*7 *.+2 4% B$%9-12 " Lg C/4@ 7-B2$@2*429 742*= *4 "`` .*$*39 ^`` 92A$227 )2+7/-7'

63 "cIH C@23 %/+ B$/127 /31$2*729 7@*$B+; *A*/35 -$A234 32C *442=B47 C2$2=*92 4% $27-71/4*42 7%+*$ B%C2$' ?@2 "` Lg 0%+*$ P32 B%C2$ 4%C2$ C*7 92:2+%B29/3 0%-4@2$3 )*+/&%$3/* /3 "cH"5 .-4 4@2 B*$*.%+/1_4$%-A@ 421@3%+%A; %& 4@2 32*$.;0%+*$ N32$A; >232$*4/3A 0;742=7 G0N>0K5 .2A-3 /3 "cHa5 C*7 =%$2 C%$D*.+2'

Q%C2:2$5 *+4@%-A@ 4@272 2&&%$47 $27-+429 /3 0N>05 4@2; 74/++ +*1D29 4@2

7-74*/329 1%==/4=234 4% B$%9-12 * $2+/*.+2 7%+*$ B%C2$ /39-74$;' 63 &*145 4@21%=B*3; 4@*4 .-/+4 4@2 &/$74 0N>0 B+*347 C234 .*3D$-B4 .21*-72 &-2+ B$/127 B+-3A29



a

*A*/3 /3 4@2 +*42 "cH`7 *39 2*$+; "cc`7' J-45 927B/42 4@/75 4@2 B+*347 4@2; .-/+4 @*:21%34/3-29 4% A232$*42 F^a Lg %& 2+214$/1/4; *4 * B$%&/4' 8395 +/D2 0@-=*3Y7 L**9/B+*34 32*$+; * 1234-$; *A%5 4@2 7-9923 $24-$3 %& 1@2*B %/+5 32*$+; 2/A@4; ;2*$7 +*42$5

9274$%;29 4@2 1%=B*3; .-/+9/3A 4@2 C%$+9Y7 +*$A274 7%+*$ B%C2$ B+*34' From 1990

to 2007 no additional CSP plants were built worldwide. P3+; C/4@ 4@2 /=B239/3A 7B214$-= %& A+%.*+ C*$=/3A *39 4@2 A$%C/3A 1%74 %&

P/+ *4 "`` lm.*$$2+ @*7 7%+*$ 232$A; .223 &/3*++; C/92+; 1%==2$1/*+/[295 *7 .%4@ )0#*39 #<' ?%9*;Y7 )0# 1*B*1/4/27 *$2 E'"F >g %B2$*4/%3*+5 E'aH >g -392$1%374$-14/%3 *39 "`'"Fa >g *33%-3129 G^" Gh08K n "'`H G0B*/3K *39 a'^a G%4@2$1%-34$/27KK' 0%+*$ #< @*7 A$%C3 ^com;2*$ 4% * 4%4*+ A+%.*+ 1*B*1/4; %& dc'I >g *44@2 239 %& E`""' 87 * 1%=B*$/7%3 C/39 B%C2$ /7 A$%C/3A *4 4@2 $*42 %& Edo*33-*++;5 C/4@ * C%$+9C/92 /374*++29 1*B*1/4; %& EFH >g /3 E`""' 87 * $2&2$2312 4@22OB+%/429 @;9$% 1*B*1/4; /7 IEF >g'

U% 9%-.45 $232C*.+2 232$A/27 *$2 *9:*31/3A M-/42 $*B/9+;S .-4 C/++ 4@2; .2

*.+2 4% .$/9A2 4@2 A*B *4 4@2 $*42 321277*$; /3 %$92$ 4% =*/34*/3 A+%.*+ C*$=/3A-+4/=*42+; C/4@/3 4@2 $2*7%3*.+2 +/=/4 %& E e) p ?C% =*/3 B$%.+2=7 =-74 .2 4*1D+29 8 ?@2 &/$74 /7 1%74S 4@2 1@2*B274 232$A; /7 *+C*;7 4@2 .274 232$A;' ?@2 1%74 %&$232C*.+2 232$A/27 =-74 .2 7-.74*34/*++; $29-129' ?@2 721%39 /7 *:*/+*./+/4;S232$A; =-74 .2 *:*/+*.+2 C@232:2$ /4 /7 322929' ?@2 74%$*A2 %& 4@2 B$%9-129 232$A;/7 * 321277/4; 4@*4 92=*397 32C 7%+-4/%37'

,2=%42 $232C*.+2 232$A; 7%-$127 B$/=2 2+214$/1/4; %:2$ 4@2$=*+ 232$A;*39 $2M-/$2 *3 2&&/1/234 4$*37&2$ %& 2+214$/1*+ 232$A; %:2$ +%3A 9/74*3127' 63 %$92$ 4%%B4/=/[2 1%747 *39 *:*/+*./+/4;5 @/A@ B%C2$ 2+214$/1 +/327 C/++ @*:2 +23A4@7 %& =%$24@*3 72:2$*+ 4@%-7*39 D=' 83 /=B%$4*34 32C 92:2+%B=234 =*; .2 4@2 -72 %&

0-B2$1%39-14/:/4;5 C@/1@ 237-$27 74$/14+; [2$% %@=/1 +%7727 /3 4@2 4$*37B%$4'Q%C2:2$5 7% &*$ 2O/74/3A 7-B2$1%39-14/3A =*42$/*+7 *39 1$;%A23/1 1%=B%32347 9%3%4 92+/:2$ * 1%=B24/4/:2 *+42$3*4/:2 4% 2O/74/3A 421@3%+%A/27' J-4 $21234 B$%A$277*39 %3_A%/3A $272*$1@ B$%=/72 4% /=B$%:2 B2$&%$=*312 *39 $29-12 1%747 7% 4@*4 *1%=B24/4/:2 B*$/4; C/4@ 1%3:234/%3*+ 4$*37=/77/%3 /7 2OB21429 /3 * &2C ;2*$7Y 4/=2'?@2 $2+*4/:2+; $21234 GE``"K 92:2+%B=234 %& LAJE 7-B2$1%39-14%$7 *BB2*$7 *927/$*.+2 7%+-4/%35 C@/1@ =*; B$%:/92 * +%C 1%74 1*.+2 *39 * 7-&&/1/234+; @/A@1$;%A23/1 42=B2$*4-$2 G-B 4% a` kK' 631/9234*++; /4 =*; .2 $21*++29 4@*4 /4 C*7 /3"c"^ 4@*4 k*=2$+/3A@_P=3275 4@$22 ;2*$7 *&42$ @/7 9/71%:2$; %& 0-B2$1%39-14/:/4;5@*9 B$%B%729 * &/$74 B2$7/74234 1-$$234 +%%B 4% 1*$$; 2+214$/1/4; .24C223 #*$/7 *39V%39%3'

?@2$2 /7 M-/42 +/42$*++; 3%4@/3A 234/$2+; 32C -392$ 4@2 0-3X J-4 4@2$2 /7 74/++* +%4 4% 9% 4% =*D2 /4 7@/32X

Documents

Nothing is New Under the Sun - Prof. Rubbia