No. TC CASE NO. PARTIES EOJ - Court of Appeals of the ...ca.judiciary.gov.ph/images/references_corner/journ-360...Doodle-2011 Page 1 of 54 Disposal_Audited_B#1_Numerical COURT OF APPEALS

Doodle-2011Page 1 of 54 Disposal_Audited_B#1_Numerical

COURT OF APPEALS SC

No. TC CASE NO. PARTIES RESO DEC ACTION EOJ LOT EOJ CASE NO. BRANCH RTC

1 102 CR 05619 P.P., VS. ANGEL B. ALCANTARA 03/29/74 AFFIRMED 01/02/75 08/08/75 06/05/75 II-257 CFI

2 102 CR 05798 04/17/75 AFFIRMED 07/10/75 10/10/75 4811 V

3 101 CR 07015-24 P.P., VS. JAIME OBLENDA 06/15/77 DENIED *NDA 09/10/75 2945-2954 COTABATO CITY

4 97 CR 07924 12/13/74 01/03/75 02/24/75 429-V BULACAN

5 98 CR 08047 P.P., VS. CECILIO LEGASPI 11/26/76 AFFIRMED 12/18/76 02/01/77 N-1246

6 99 CR 08116 P.P., VS. FELIMON REYES 07/16/74 09/19/76 02/11/75 2490 BATANGAS

7 100 CR 08140 P.P., VS. BRENAN DABAN, ET. AL. 05/13/74 AFFIRMED 05/29/74 04/30/75 9516 ILOILO CITY

8 100 CR 08198 P.P., VS. PEDRO A. ADRIATICO 04/29/75 AFFIRMED 06/04/75 10/09/75 09/03/75 567 BANGUED, ABRA

9 92 CR 08359 P.P., VS. CONSTANCIO CORDERO 11/26/76 AFFIRMED 12/29/76 02/01/77 11020 LEYTE TACLOBAN CITY

10 93 CR 08393 P.P., VS. TIMOTEO BERMUNDO 09/29/76 AFFIRMED 10/29/76 01/19/77 9090

11 94 CR 08449 11/29/78 AFFIRMED 02/28/79 11/06/79 2490 I BATANGAS

12 94 CR 08470 P.P., VS. TEODORO HUYO-A 04/16/75 AFFIRMED 05/27/75 07/24/75 560

13 95 CR 08538 P.P., VS. MARIO CARIÑO 09/01/75 AFFIRMED 09/22/75 11/03/75 Q-4564 IV QUEZON CITY

14 95 CR 08543 P.P., VS. REX DUMOL 09/05/75 REVERSED 09/06/75 09/24/75 3781

15 96 CR 08610 P.P., VS. JAIME GUZMAN 11/12/76 12/22/76 02/01/77 677 ABRA BANGUED

16 91 CR 09264-65 P.P., VS. DIONISIO ALONZO 09/26/78 02/14/79 05/02/79 16238-16239 CFI – PASIG CITY

17 90 CR 09323 P.P., VS. JOGIE GAYOSO 06/10/75 DISMISSED 07/08/75 09/30/75 17396 PASIG CFI – RIZAL

18 90 CR 09330 P.P., VS. MAXIMO PAGARAN, ET. AL. 04/16/75 AFFIRMED 05/12/75 07/14/75 89456 MANILA CFI

19 89 CR 09557 P.P., VS. JULIAN VILEÑA 08/15/75 08/16/75 08/27/75 89223 CFI – MANILA

LOC. (Page)

COURT OF ORIGIN

NAME & ADD OF COUNSEL &/OR PARTIES

NATURE OF CASE

ILIGAN CITY,

LANAO DEL

NORTE

P.P., VS. ISIDRO ARANZANZO y VILLANUEVA

CFI – RIZAL (Q.C.)

P.P., VS. ANTONIO CARTEN, ET. AL. CONRADO GUANING, ET. AL.

AFFIRMED W/

MODIFICA-TION

CFI – CAVITE CITY

AFFIRMED W/

MODIFICA-TION

CC – MIS. ORIENTAL,

CAGAYAN DE ORO

P.P., VS. REYNALDO PANA, EDILBERTO DE LOS REYES, ET. AL.

NEGROS OCCIDENTAL

SURIGAO DEL NORTE

AFFIRMED W/

MODIFICA-TION

AFFIRMED IN TOTO

REVERSED AND

ACQUIT-TED


COURT OF APPEALS SC


LOC. (Page)

COURT OF ORIGIN


NATURE OF CASE

20 89 CR 09560 P.P., VS. AQUILINO CARMEN 07/02/75 AFFIRMED 08/25/75 10/16/75 2870 CFI – MASBATE

21 89 CR 09563 P.P., VS. CATALINO RAMOS 03/12/75 AFFIRMED 05/16/75 08/27/75 R-2062

22 88 CR 09572 P.P., VS. MAURO DE LA CRUZ 08/12/75 08/13/75 08/27/75 T-1271

23 88 CR 09616 P.P., VS. GAUDENCIO A. DIGOS 05/15/75 AFFIRMED 06/06/75 07/28/75 57208 MANILA CFI

24 88 CR 09620 P.P., VS. JAIME DOLLENTE 10/22/74 MODIFIED 12/17/74 03/06/75 386-G CFI

25 87 CR 09751 P.P., VS. ABUNDIO MUNCADA 06/06/74 ACQUITTED 06/07/74 11/10/75 3378 CFI

26 87 CR 09819 P.P., VS. LIM LIT 06/04/74 AFFIRMED 09/17/74 02/05/75 11/24/74 7240-P CFI

27 150 CR 10093 P.P., VS. FILOMENO M. LAMIS 10/09/74 MODIFIED 11/19/74 06/26/75 04/02/75 1687

28 151 CR 10144 P.P., VS. BENITO CANO 11/29/76 AFFIRMED 12/21/76 02/01/77 1180-O

29 151 CR 10168 P.P., VS. JOVITA BAMBA 11/29/74 AFFIRMED 01/02/75 03/05/75 452

30 152 CR 10183 P.P., VS. NICOLAS TANAUAN 02/18/74 AFFIRMED 09/25/74 07/28/75 11257

31 152 CR 10221 P.P., VS. FELIPE CORONADO 12/05/74 AFFIRMED 01/27/75 04/08/75 1423 LAGUNA

32 153 CR 10284 P.P., VS. ROMUALDO MOOG 11/05/76 AFFIRMED 12/09/76 01/19/77 2796

33 153 CR 10312 04/26/74 AFFIRMED 05/29/74 08/28/75 1225 MT. PROVINCE

34 154 CR 10325 P.P., VS. MARIO ZALUN 09/23/76 AFFIRMED 11/04/76 01/11/77

35 154 CR 10361 P.P., VS. RAMON CONSTANTINO 07/08/75 AFFIRMED 07/29/75 09/22/75 54903 CFI – MANILA

36 154 CR 10392 P.P., VS. VICTORIANO CARAAN 07/22/75 AFFIRMED 08/12/75 10/07/75 2881 BATANGAS

37 155 CR 10401 P.P., VS. MARIANO LLORENTE 08/22/74 09/10/74 02/03/75 3778 BAGUIO CITY

MASBATE, MASBATE

CFI – ORIENTAL MINDORO, PI-NAMALAYAN

REVERSED AND

ACQUIT-TED

CFI – PANGASINAN

TAYUG

GUIMBA, NUEVA ECIJA

LAONG, NORTHERN SAMAR

RIZAL, PASAY CITY

CFI – GEN. SANTOS CITY,

SOUTH COTABATO

CFI – OLONGAPO

CITY, ZAMBALES

CFI – KIANGAN IFUGAO

CFI – DAVAO CITY

BATANGAS CITY, BATANGAS

P.P., VS. PARACTAO MACHAGSEN, ET AL

CCC-VII-206 (4319)

CCC – PASIG, RIZAL

AFFIRMED W/

MODIFICA-TION


COURT OF APPEALS SC


LOC. (Page)

COURT OF ORIGIN


NATURE OF CASE

38 155 CR 10407 P.P., VS. CRISTITUTO QUINTO 11/19/74 AFFIRMED 12/10/74 02/11/75 2505 BATANGAS CITY

39 155 CR 10442 P.P., VS. FAUSTA D. RIVERA 05/26/75 AFFIRMED 06/14/75 07/29/75 84482 MANILA

40 156 CR 10544 P.P., VS. SALVADOR PASCUA 08/15/75 08/16/75 08/27/75 131474 III

41 157 CR 10584 P.P., VS. FRED MAGDALERA, ET AL 01/23/75 AFFIRMED 03/26/75 09/29/75 05/19/75 391-68 OLONGAPO CITY

42 157 CR 10585 P.P., VS. BENJAMIN CUARESMA 10/29/76 AFFIRMED 11/19/76 01/18/77 92736 CFI – MANILA

43 277 CR 10620-R P.P., VS. MANOLITO CUBAT 06/26/75 AFFIRMED 07/18/75 09/22/75 A-33 SAMAR

44 158 CR 10653 P.P., VS. CARLOS M. LAZANO 02/10/75 03/04/75 05/28/75 6511 PAMPANGA

45 159 CR 10738 P.P., VS. HENRY CASIA 12/09/76 12/29/76 02/01/77 140-N ILOCOS SUR

46 160 CR 10812 P.P., VS. ROLANDO MAGADIA 01/24/75 DISMISSED 02/18/75 04/30/75 17324

47 161 CR 10893 P.P., VS. TASING PENIERO UY 12/03/76 REMANDED 12/28/76 02/01/77 671

48 161 CR 10903 P.P., VS. ELIODORO HERNANDEZ 06/18/75 03/07/75 MODIFIED 07/02/75 07/29/75 2565 BATANGAS

49 162 CR 10916 P.P., VS. ROBERTO PALMA 05/09/75 REMANDED 05/10/75 05/28/75 790

50 163 CR 11002 P.P., VS. DEMOCRITO SEPTIMO 06/19/74 AFFIRMED 08/12/74 02/05/75 1673

51 164 CR 11086 07/05/74 AFFIRMED 09/09/74 02/07/75 10/11/74 E-407351 MANILA

52 165 CR 11180 05/13/75 06/03/75 07/29/75 1452 BATANGAS

53 166 CR 11224 P.P., VS. JOSE CLEMENTE 06/17/75 06/18/75 06/26/75 1885

54 167 CR 11281 P.P., VS. ROMEO MARTINEZ 07/24/75 AFFIRMED 08/12/75 10/07/75 Q-8545 IV

55 86 CR 11389-93 P.P., VS. ANTONIO HERNANDEZ 08/28/75 ACQUITTED 08/29/75 09/10/75 BATANGAS

56 168 CR 11396 P.P., VS. NAPOLEON BOMBITA 09/02/75 AFFIRMED 09/25/75 11/03/75 11392 ILOILO CITY

57 168 CR 11406 P.P., VS. ANGELITO SANCHEZ 11/28/75 ACQUITTED 11/29/75 12/18/75 7309

58 168 CR 11416 P.P., VS. ALEJO M. ABARRA 06/30/75 AFFIRMED 07/24/75 09/29/75 4041 LA UNION

REVERSED & ACQUITTED

CC – QUEZON CITY

AFFIRMED W/

MODIFICA-TION

AFFIRMED W/

MODIFICA-TION

CFI – PASIG, RIZAL

ZAMBOANGA DEL NORTE

NEGROS OCCIDENTAL

CFI – DAET, CAMARINES

NORTE

P.P., VS. VICTOR CORNEJO Y MERCADO

P.P., VS. CATALINA NEPOMUCENO LOPEZ

AFFIRMED W/

MODIFICA-TION

SET ASIDE & DISMISS

MC – VIRAC, CATANDUANES

CFI – QUEZON CITY

CCC-VIII-148-152

MC – TARLAC, TARLAC


COURT OF APPEALS SC


LOC. (Page)

COURT OF ORIGIN


NATURE OF CASE

59 169 CR 11449 P.P., VS. BENJAMIN APELO, ET AL 02/19/74 09/03/74 10/16/75 CCC – MANILA

60 170 CR 11508 P.P., VS. SUSANO GIMORA 12/15/76 ACQUITTED 12/16/76 01/05/77 22393

61 170 CR 11518 P.P., VS. ELPIDIO OCTAVO 07/21/75 AFFIRMED 08/11/75 10/07/75 4140

62 86 CR 11538 P.P., VS. PIO ESTRERA 03/26/75 AFFIRMED 04/24/75 06/30/75 SB-188 CFI – CEBU

63 170 CR 11540 P.P., VS. FELICIANO BALANDRES 07/10/75 02/12/74 AFFIRMED 07/31/75 08/11/75 CCC – MANILA

64 171 CR 11554 04/11/75 MODIFIED 05/05/75 07/29/75 80062 MANILA

65 171 CR 11560 03/17/75 AFFIRMED 05/14/75 11/10/75 07/11/75 17939

66 172 CR 11647 06/23/75 AFFIRMED 07/11/75 09/24/75 CCC-VI-342 MANILA

67 172 CR 11663 02/12/75 07/01/74 AFFIRMED 03/10/75 04/30/75 CCC-VI-62 '70 CCC – MANILA

68 172 CR 11671 P.P., VS. RICARDO MIRANDA 11/05/74 AFFIRMED 02/19/75 04/29/75 NUEVA ECIJA

69 173 CR 11736 P.P., VS. BENJAMIN REGANIT Y MOYA 11/29/74 AFFIRMED 12/24/74 02/13/75 66952 CFI – MANILA

70 174 CR 11871 P.P., VS. BIENVENIDO TALAVER 03/31/75 ACQUITTED 04/01/75 04/22/75 9865

71 175 CR 11916 P.P., VS. ERNANI DESAMERO 03/20/75 MODIFIED 05/28/75 09/24/75 SP-1570 LAGUNA

72 176 CR 11956 P.P., VS. JOSE CUEVAS SALLOMAN 04/18/75 AFFIRMED 06/17/75 08/13/75 36 ISABELA

73 176 CR 11999 P.P., VS. MARGARITO HILAOS 10/16/75 10/17/75 10/29/75 240

74 177 CR 12058 P.P., VS. ENGRACIO ARCAYAN 03/07/75 SET ASIDE 04/05/75 09/29/75 4746

75 178 CR 12128 P.P., VS. GERARDO MATEO 11/29/74 AFFIRMED 01/03/75 04/08/75 93874 MANILA

76 178 CR 12129 P.P., VS. PEDRITO LEYROS 11/17/76 AFFIRMED 12/13/76 01/19/77 CCC-XV-80 BUKIDNON

77 179 CR 12162 P.P., VS. JUAN SAN JUAN Y DE JESUS 03/25/75 RESOLVED 04/19/75 07/14/75 15717

78 180 CR 12269 P.P., VS. ALFONSO TAN 11/10/76 01/31/75 AFFIRMED 12/14/76 01/19/77 93433 CFI – MANILA

79 180 CR 12289 11/28/75 ACQUITTED 11/29/75 12/18/75 II-1085

80 181 CR 12305 P.P., VS. JOSE DEL MUNDO JR. 12/03/76 AFFIRMED 12/28/76 02/01/77 13642

AFFIRMED BUT

REVERSED

CCC-VI-15 (89710)

CC – BACOLOD CITY

CFI – SAN FERNANDO, LA

UNION

CCC-VI-80 (70)

P.P., VS. RUBEN MANGUERRA Y DELA CRUZ

P.P., VS. JACINTO VERGARA Y DIMAUNAHAN


P.P., VS. EDUARDO HERMAN Y MONTANO

P.P., VS. WILLIAM PIÑON Y MILLER , ET AL

OCC-IV-N-101-NE

NEGROS OCCIDENTAL

RESOLVED TO

WITHDRAW

CFI – ILOILO CITY

CFI – BOHOL , TAGBILARAN

CITY

CFI – RIZAL, PASIG

P.P., VS. ALFONSO BONGOLAN , ET AL CAUAYAN, ISABELA

CC – CABANATUAN

CITY


COURT OF APPEALS SC


LOC. (Page)

COURT OF ORIGIN


NATURE OF CASE

81 181 CR 12306 P.P., VS. TEODORO PASCUA, ET AL 05/13/75 AFFIRMED 06/04/75 07/29/75 16191

82 181 CR 12334 02/18/75 AFFIRMED 06/10/75 09/29/75 29

83 181 CR 12341 01/31/75 AFFIRMED 02/24/75 05/20/75 CCC-333-(70) CCC – MANILA

84 182 CR 12355 P.P., VS. RODOLFO R. STA. ROSA 07/02/75 ACQUITTED 07/03/75 07/17/75 83260 MANILA

85 85 CR 12358-59 P.P., VS. DOMINGO CABATINGAN 09/03/74 01/27/75 03/31/75 108067-68 MANILA CC

86 85 CR 12394 P.P., VS. ALFONSO COMILANG 11/25/76 AFFIRMED 12/27/76 01/01/77 25376 BAGUIO CC-BAGUIO CITY

87 182 CR 12398 P.P., VS. FAUSTINO DELA PAZ, ET AL 07/16/77 AFFIRMED 11/05/74 03/06/75 CCC-VI-512 MANILA

88 183 CR 12416 P.P., VS. CRISPIN SAN PABLO 01/13/75 AFFIRMED 03/21/75 07/11/75 06/25/75 V-1125

89 183 CR 12446 P.P., VS. ANTONIO LAURETA Y CHAN 01/15/75 GRANTED 01/16/75 02/07/75 74723 CFI – MANILA

90 183 CR 12447 P.P., VS. RAMON A. BERNAL 07/26/74 MODIFIED 11/12/74 02/07/75 12/21/74 86093 CFI – MANILA

91 183 CR 12450 P.P., VS. MELICANO KUSAIN, ET AL 01/31/75 AFFIRMED 03/03/75 05/28/75 2 COTABATO CITY

92 184 CR 12527 P.P., VS. ROMEO TUPAZ 07/23/75 AFFIRMED 08/27/75 10/16/75 1732 CFI – MANILA

93 185 CR 12561 06/17/75 AFFIRMED 07/17/75 09/23/75 50

94 185 CR 12564 P.P., VS. ERNESTO BALDEROSA 02/18/75 AFFIRMED 03/07/75 05/28/75 27-G

95 185 CR 12599 P.P., VS. REGIE GARELA 07/16/74 AFFIRMED 04/04/75 07/02/75 16104

96 186 CR 12608 04/01/75 04/18/75 06/30/75 E-359729 CC – MANILA

97 186 CR 12612 P.P., VS. ALBERTO ILANO Y SANTERO 02/05/75 AFFIRMED 02/25/75 04/30/75 61824 CC – PASAY CITY

98 187 CR 12650 06/17/75 ACQUITTED 06/18/75 06/26/75 92333 MANILA

99 187 CR 12658 P.P., VS. MAURO ABO 11/18/76 AFFIRMED 12/08/76 01/25/77 4486

100 84 CR 12694 11/25/76 MODIFIED 12/18/76 02/01/77 CCC-XIV-240 CEBU

101 188 CR 12708 07/15/75 AFFIRMED 09/09/75 10/07/75 81552 CFI – MANILA

CC – CABANATUAN

CITY

P.P., VS. BENJAMIN CUNAN Y SAMSON SAN FERNANDO PAMPANGA

P.P., VS. CLARITA LUDIVICA Y ZABALA

AFFIRMED W/

MODIFICA-TION

CFI – VALENZUELA,

BULACAN

P.P., VS. EDDIE CAÑEDA , BERTY HUYO & ROBERTO IYOG

MISAMIS OCCIDENTAL

CFI – GUMAGA, QUEZON


P.P., VS. EMMANUEL FERNANDEZ Y BALTAZAR

AFFIRMED & MODIFIED

P.P., VS. VICENTE E. CORNISTA Y GERILLA

CC – DUMAGUETE

CITY

P.P., VS. FLORENCIO ARDINES, ET. AL.

CEBU CITY

P.P., VS. CELESTINO BERNARDO Y FLORES


COURT OF APPEALS SC


LOC. (Page)

COURT OF ORIGIN


NATURE OF CASE

102 188 CR 12717 01/23/75 AFFIRMED 02/17/75 04/22/75 CCC-III-159-L TACLOBAN CITY

103 188 CR 12735 P.P., VS. NICANOR LAPUZ JR, ET AL 07/12/73 AFFIRMED 08/31/73 05/20/75 03/10/74 463(71) X MANILA

104 188 CR 12736 P.P., VS. NICANOR LAPUZ JR, ET AL 07/12/73 AFFIRMED 08/31/73 05/20/75 466 (71) MANILA

105 189 CR 12752 P.P., VS. BERNARDO VISTA 12/10/74 02/05/75 04/08/75 4481-A CAGAYAN

106 189 CR 12757 P.P., VS. BENITO ALFAFARA 07/05/74 AFFIRMED 10/01/74 02/07/75 12/21/74 11483 V DAVAO DEL SUR

107 190 CR 12799 P.P., VS. ANTONIO MENDOZA 02/12/75 AFFIRMED 03/05/75 05/20/75 1732 CFI – BATANGAS

108 191 CR 12843 P.P., VS. DEMETRIO RODRIGUEZ 04/22/75 AFFIRMED 05/15/75 07/14/75 VII-146811 VII

109 191 CR 12845 P.P., VS. ENGRACIA DOMINGO 07/30/74 AFFIRMED 11/06/74 02/03/75 8909

110 192 CR 12895 P.P., VS. AVELITA GARLIT, ET AL 01/31/77 ACQUITTED 02/01/77 02/08/77 93118 MANILA

111 193 CR 12939 09/01/75 SENTENCED 09/20/75 11/04/75 80504 CFI – MANILA

112 194 CR 12968 02/20/75 AFFIRMED 03/11/75 05/20/75 6668-P

113 194 CR 12970 P.P., VS. ROGER COUSART, ET AL 04/14/75 ACQUITTED 04/15/75 04/30/75 16280 MAKATI

114 195 CR 13026 P.P., VS. SULPICIO GRAN 09/05/74 AFFIRMED 10/18/74 02/07/75 11/22/74 5027

115 195 CR 13032 P.P., VS. RICARDO TRIAS 06/30/75 07/01/75 07/14/75 4483 CFI – MANILA

116 196 CR 13045 P.P., VS. FELIX ACERON Y OBIN 12/06/76 AFFIRMED 01/04/77 02/08/77 167

117 134 CR 13090 08/19/75 AFFIRMED 09/09/75 10/24/75 V-49142 V

118 134 CR 13105 P.P., VS. PACIANO AÑES 12/05/74 AFFIRMED 01/03/75 02/24/75 2785

119 197 CR 13144 P.P., VS. DIONISIO GASPAR 12/24/76 ACQUITTED 12/27/76 01/18/77 SD-351 NUEVA ECIJA

120 197 CR 13146 P.P., VS. GINES DOMINGUEZ 11/26/74 03/11/75 05/28/75 163-S CAGAYAN

121 198 CR 13161 P.P., VS. FERNANDO RUTAQUIO 02/11/75 AFFIRMED 05/27/75 10/20/75 103

P.P., VS. ERBERTO SUELA , ET AL, OSIAS AKA OTING IDANO, ET AL

ABANDONED &

DISMISSED

CC – QUEZON CITY

CFI – CABANATUAN

CITY

P.P., VS. SOFRONIO CHUIDIAN Y ADORNO, ET AL

P.P., VS. BENJAMIN PIMENTEL Y MARCELINO

CFI – PASAY CITY

CFI – TAGBILARAN

CITY


CFI – LEGASPI CITY, ALBAY

P.P., VS. EUFRONIO GETICAN y LAURE

CC – QUEZON CITY

MC – LLORENTE, EASTERN SAMAR

AFFIRMED W/

MODIFICA-TION

CFI – LUCENA CITY


COURT OF APPEALS SC


LOC. (Page)

COURT OF ORIGIN


NATURE OF CASE

122 198 CR 13167 P.P., VS. EDMUNDO VILLANUEVA 11/04/74 AFFIRMED 03/03/75 09/18/75 CCC-XV-14

123 198 CR 13170 P.P., VS. FABIAN L. GUIANG 02/14/75 AFFIRMED 03/10/75 05/20/75 116 TARLAC

124 83 CR 13175–76 08/15/74 AFFIRMED 09/20/74 02/03/75 MANILA


126 199 CR 13301 P.P., VS. ANSELMO CALUYA 01/23/76 AFFIRMED 03/22/76 01/19/77 54-1

127 200 CR 13343 P.P., VS. MARIO A. DEANG Y AGUILA 02/04/75 AFFIRMED 05/27/75 11/03/75 10/03/75 4087 MANILA

128 201 CR 13406 P.P., VS. PEDRO RILVERIA , ET AL 01/31/75 AFFIRMED 07/08/75 09/24/75 06/25/75 D-1954 PANGASINAN

129 201 CR 13407 P.P., VS. ANGELITO MANLUTAC 11/16/76 MODIFIED 12/06/76 01/25/77 CCC-III-0051

130 82 CR 13416 P.P., VS. FELIX SANTOS y TABHADA 08/25/75 ACQUITTED 08/26/75 09/03/75 3333 MANILA

131 202 CR 13437 P.P., VS. MARCOS RAMIREZ 02/17/75 AFFIRMED 03/12/75 05/28/75 842-V

132 348 CR 13488 07/14/75 07/15/75 07/24/75 5210 MANILA

133 348 CR 13524 P.P., VS. CAMILO TEMPLA 04/29/75 AFFIRMED 05/28/75 07/24/75 263 XV

134 347 CR 13532 01/13/75 AFFIRMED 03/26/75 07/17/75 05/19/75 133070 III

135 347 CR 13534 P.P., VS. ALEJANDRO MANAGASE 07/02/75 07/03/75 07/21/75 CCC-XIV-523 CCC – CEBU CITY

136 347 CR 13547 P.P., VS. DIOSDADO ALDA, ET. AL. 12/08/76 12/28/76 02/08/77 13366 ILOILO CITY

137 81 CR 13563 P.P., VS. EVARISTO CABATBAT. SR. 12/20/76 ACQUITTED 12/21/76 01/06/77 SC – 1622 CFI – LAGUNA

138 81 CR 13589 P.P., VS. NEORLIMINIO BACUTANA 03/06/75 04/01/75 06/30/75 A – 884

139 344 CR 13603 P.P., VS. LORENZO IGNACIO, ET. AL. 10/01/75 ACQUITTED 10/02/75 10/23/75 5956-M

140 345 CR 13633 P.P., VS. RICARDO CARABEO 01/23/75 AFFIRMED 02/12/75 04/22/75 4801 RIZAL

141 345 CR 13644 P.P., VS. REYNALDO D. ANSON 02/20/75 AFFIRMED 03/18/75 06/20/75 89784 CFI – MANILA


143 346 CR 13650 P.P., VS. EMMA ANTIGA 02/12/75 SET ASIDE 03/05/75 05/29/75 203

AGUSAN DEL NORTE

P.P., VS. ZENAIDA RAMOS VELASCO, ET. AL.

94416 AND 94417

P.P., VS. ALFONSO LAGUINLIN Y DE JESUS

CFI – LAOAG CITY, ILOCOS

NORTE

CCC – OLONGAPO

CITY

VALENZUELA, BULACAN

P.P., VS. MERCEDES DUMATOL SILVA Y DE LEON

WITHDRAWN

CCC – MISAMIS ORIENTAL,

CAGAYAN DE ORO CITY

P.P., VS. RODOLFO IGNACIO Y MORALES

CC – QUEZON CITY

WITHDRAWN

AFFIRMED W/

MODIFICA-TION

AFFIRMED W/

MODIFICA-TION

CFI – PANGASINAN

CFI – MALOLOS, BULACAN

P.P., VS. RICARDO BULURAN Y IGNACIO

ZAMBOANGA DEL NORTE


COURT OF APPEALS SC


LOC. (Page)

COURT OF ORIGIN


NATURE OF CASE

144 81 CR 13682-83 P.P., VS. ROMEO LOMBOY 04/15/75 AFFIRMED 05/06/75 12/02/75 10/18/75 SCC-167-168 CFI

145 341 CR 13712 P.P., VS. JOSE ANG @ “YAPCHIONG” 07/09/75 MODIFIED 07/30/75 09/23/75 F-142948 CFI – MANILA

146 78 CR 13715 11/29/76 AFFIRMED 12/28/76 02/08/77 2696 RIZAL MC TAYTAY

147 341 CR 13721 P.P., VS. ENRICO JARDIO Y SALAJOG 07/07/75 AFFIRMED 08/04/75 10/09/75 4867-C

148 341 CR 13725 P.P., VS. PROTACIO SALAZAR 12/06/76 AFFIRMED 01/05/77 02/08/77 CCC-XV-262

149 341 CR 13733 P.P., VS. CHESTER UMBLAS 01/20/75 MODIFIED 02/12/75 04/08/75 101-I ILOCOS NORTE

150 342 CR 13751 P.P., VS. GIL ALCOBER Y CELMAR 03/14/75 AFFIRMED 04/03/75 07/01/75 CCC-VI-1024 CCC – MANILA

151 342 CR 13757 P.P., VS. AHMAD SALAYBI 11/14/75 DISMISSED 11/15/75 12/02/75 4774

152 343 CR 13767 P.P., VS. LEONARDO A. VILLARAZO 02/12/75 AFFIRMED 03/06/75 05/28/75 V-13334 CEBU CITY

153 78 CR 13769 P.P., VS. JUANITO SINLAO 02/23/79 REVERSED 02/23/79 04/30/79 SCC – 82

154 343 CR 13781 P.P., VS. BIENVENIDO SECJADAS 02/25/75 03/21/75 05/19/75 V-13032 CFI – CEBU

155 335 CR 13851 P.P., VS. ROSAURO M. ALFONSO 04/18/75 ACQUITTED 04/19/75 05/20/75 6269 CFI – BATAAN

156 335 CR 13859 P.P., VS. ERASMO ABELLANA 06/30/75 ACQUITTED 07/01/75 07/17/75 V-12636 CFI – CEBU CITY

157 336 CR 13887 P.P., VS. JUSITA BAGUE 10/29/76 AFFIRMED 12/04/76 01/25/77 5364-B

158 336 CR 13888 P.P., VS. MINERVA V.ADARME 11/22/76 AFFIRMED 12/13/76 01/26/77 68

159 79 CR 13921-22-23 P.P., VS. FELIMON NAVAL 07/25/75 AFFIRMED 08/18/75 10/23/75 A-829-830- 831 PANGASINAN

160 79 CR 13936-37 01/07/75 AFFIRMED 01/27/75 03/20/75 BULACAN

161 337 CR 13941 P.P., VS. JESUS PABLO 07/03/75 AFFIRMED 08/13/75 12/18/75 11/26/75 353

162 79 CR 13956 09/28/78 DISMISSED 09/28/78 11/22/78 Q-6401 Q.C.

163 338 CR 13984 P.P., VS. HAROLD BEST FIELD 01/28/77 ACQUITTED 01/29/77 02/08/77 1241-70 OLONGAPO CITY

164 339 CR 14021 11/22/76 AFFIRMED 12/09/76 01/25/77 60700 CC – PASAY CITY

SAN CARLOS

CITY, PANGA-SINAN

P.P., VS. CHELLY NAVAL AND LEONCIA SANTOS NAVAL

CC – SILAY, NEGROS

OCCIDENTAL

CAGAYAN DE ORO

BASILAN CITY, ISABELA

CFI – PANGASINAN

RESOLVE TO DISMISS

CC – DAVAO CITY

SAN FERNANDO PAMPANGA

P.P., VS. FEDERICO DE GUZMAN y BUSOC

0317-V AND 0317-A-V

TAGBILARAN CITY, BOHOL

P.P., VS. VICENTE NEUSTRO y TIBAYAN

P.P., VS. PERCIVAL FUENTS Y LONDRES


COURT OF APPEALS SC


LOC. (Page)

COURT OF ORIGIN


NATURE OF CASE

165 79 CR 14022 P.P., VS. ROMEO RIMOCOL 07/01/75 AFFIRMED 07/25/75 09/29/75 136-G

166 339 CR 14037 P.P., VS. PEPITO LUMAGUI 09/23/75 SET ASIDE 10/10/75 11/05/75 TM-535

167 340 CR 14047 P.P., VS. ERIBERTO DELOS SANTOS 04/29/75 AFFIRMED 05/23/75 07/28/75 0536

168 80 CR 14110-11 P.P., VS. ISABELO JABAGAT 01/31/75 DISMISSED 02/03/75 11/05/75 33-34 CFI

169 80 CR 14147 P.P., VS. ROGELIO PECCOCO 03/21/75 AFFIRMED 07/30/75 12/18/75 08/15/75 87 CFI – ANTIQUE

170 333 CR 14187 P.P., VS. ESTELITA D. VILLASE 02/25/75 07/23/75 10/09/75 II-138761 QUEZON CITY

171 334 CR 14211 P.P., VS. RESTITUTO BARBIETO 10/28/76 AFFIRMED 11/20/76 01/19/77 5 BANGUED, ABRA

172 334 CR 14212 11/11/76 AFFIRMED 12/01/76 01/26/77 133025 RIZAL

173 334 CR 14226 P.P., VS. ABUNDIO UY JR. 09/22/75 REVERSED 09/23/75 09/29/75 174

174 332 CR 14269 P.P., VS. PATRICIO SAET,ET. AL. 05/04/75 03/21/75 MODIFIED 05/29/75 07/28/75 2363 MARINDUQUE

175 332 CR 14274 P.P., VS. SILVERIO V. ENOJADO 03/24/80 AFFIRMED 04/17/80 05/13/80 5343 NAGA CITY

176 332 CR 14280 P.P., VS. JOSE ABELLA Y YADAO 10/18/76 AFFIRMED 11/08/76 01/19/77 Q-9527 XVIII CFI – RIZAL, Q.C.

177 332 CR 14291 P.P., VS. PORFERIO MORALDE JR. 04/16/75 ACQUITTED 04/17/75 04/29/75 CCC – CEBU CITY

178 488 CR 14357 P.P., VS. RIZALINO LOPEZ 05/06/75 AFFIRMED 07/10/75 09/03/75 XVI CFI – RIZAL, Q.C.

179 489 CR 14384 P.P., VS. ALEJO PADUA, ET. AL. 10/18/76 AFFIRMED 11/06/76 01/19/77 406 (CC-7706)

180 75 CR 14399-14403 P.P., VS. ERLINDA SINGSON 09/23/76 07/01/76 AFFIRMED 10/18/76 01/26/77 CCC

181 490 CR 14418 P.P., VS. JULIAN PAMILAR 10/27/75 10/28/75 11/10/75 54

182 484 CR 14467 09/12/75 ACQUITTED 09/13/75 10/08/75 Q-1817 XVIII

183 484 CR 14471 P.P., VS. ROLAND JADRAQUE 10/15/75 REVERSED 10/16/75 10/24/75 973 LA UNION

184 485 CR 14495 P.P., VS. DOUGLAS AGATON, ET. AL. 03/19/75 ACQUITTED 03/20/75 03/31/75 CCC – CEBU CITY

CFI – NUEVA ECIJA

CFI – TRECE MARTIRES

CAVITE


OROQUIE-TA CITY

MIS. OCC.

AFFIRMED W/

MODIFICA-TION

P.P., VS. GAUDENCIO MANALO,ET. AL.

CFI – DAVAO DEL SUR

CCC-XIV-558-CEBU

133586 (Q-2075)

CABANATUAN CITY

CCC-XIV; 420 – 424

CEBU CITY


CFI – MISAMIS OCCIDENTAL, OROQUIETA

CITY

P.P., VS. TEODORO AGUSTIN Y CAPITULO

CFI – QUEZON CITY

CCC-XIV-603-C EBU


COURT OF APPEALS SC


LOC. (Page)

COURT OF ORIGIN


NATURE OF CASE

185 486 CR 14527 P.P., VS. ARTURO ONQUIT, ET. AL. 12/16/74 MODIFIED 01/03/75 02/24/75 8616

186 487 CR 14544 P.P., VS. FRANK HATTON 07/23/75 AFFIRMED 08/16/75 10/16/75 8411 SAMAR

187 487 CR 14567 05/29/75 MODIFIED 07/29/75 09/22/75 9225

188 76 CR 14576 10/01/76 AFFIRMED 10/02/76 02/01/77 1430

189 483 CR 14577 P.P., VS. PEDRO CANETE 11/11/74 MODIFIED 12/11/74 02/10/75 R-1627

190 483 CR 14581 P.P., VS. MARIO ANDICO Y MILLOSA 03/25/75 AFFIRMED 04/17/75 07/11/75 8573 CFI – MANILA

191 483 CR 14585 P.P., VS. LORETO HARARIO, ET. AL. 09/24/75 ACQUITTED 09/25/75 10/07/75 35

192 481 CR 14636 P.P., VS. MYRNA T. LOYOLA Y TERSIO 11/10/76 AFFIRMED 12/02/76 02/01/77 1603-71

193 481 CR 14652 P.P., VS. ENRIQUE CANZA 10/18/76 AFFIRMED 11/04/76 01/11/77 B-1450 BIÑAN, LAGUNA

194 481 CR 14655 P.P., VS. JUANITO LUCE 03/10/75 DISMISSED 04/01/75 06/26/75 0103-M QUEZON

195 481 CR 14659 P.P., VS. CEFERINO SORIANO 01/09/75 AFFIRMED 07/12/75 07/24/75 D-248

196 482 CR 14663 P.P., VS. IRENEO PABLO, ET. AL. 10/21/76 AFFIRMED 11/13/76 02/01/77 4289 ISABELA

197 482 CR 14680 P.P., VS. PASCUAL BERAME 06/26/75 AFFIRMED 07/24/75 10/07/75 R-1591

198 482 CR 14683 P.P., VS. PEDRO BELTRAN 11/17/76 MODIFIED 12/11/76 01/26/77 4059

199 480 CR 14757 & 58 10/28/76 AFFIRMED 11/22/76 01/19/77 1231 & 1286 ILIGAN CITY

200 77 CR 14764 P.P., VS. EDUARDO CARPIO 09/24/75 10/18/75 11/28/75 523-N (4962) CFI – RIZAL

201 479 CR 14766 09/30/75 AFFIRMED 10/22/75 12/05/75 3547

202 470 CR 14853 01/24/75 REVERSED 05/14/75 08/27/75 05/28/75 CCC-I-190 CCC – CAGAYAN

203 470 CR 14861 P.P., VS. ABIASON FELIPE 11/12/76 AFFIRMED 12/03/76 01/25/77 339 BAGUIO CITY

CFI – NAGA CITY,

CAMARINES SUR

P.P., VS. SOFIO FRILA JR. Y PELLEGENA

CFI – NAGA CITY,

CAMARINES SUR

P.P., VS. FLORENCIO DAMASCO, ET. AL.

GEN. SANTOS

CITY

SOUTH COTABATO

CC – LAPULAPU CITY

CFI – MAMBUSAO,

CAPIZ

CC – OLONGAPO CITY

CFI – DAGUPAN CITY,

PANGASINAN

CC – LAPULAPU CITY

CFI – ISABELA (ILIGAN)

P.P., VS. ROMULO SIDROME, ETC., ET. AL.

AFFIRMED IN TOTO

P.P., VS. RODOLFO FRANCISCO Y GUINTO

MC – CALAPAN, ORIENTAL MINDORO

P.P., VS. ANDRES DAQUIAL Y GUZMAN, ET. AL.


COURT OF APPEALS SC


LOC. (Page)

COURT OF ORIGIN


NATURE OF CASE

204 77 CR 14862 P.P., VS. CONSTANCIO CANOY 01/14/77 10/05/76 AFFIRMED 11/06/76 01/19/77 711

205 470 CR 14867 P.P., VS. VENANCIO ANTIDA 01/29/75 AFFIRMED 03/03/75 05/20/75 454 DAVAO CITY

206 471 CR 14876 P.P., VS. TOEFILO ANOD 09/12/75 ACQUITTED 09/13/75 09/29/75 CCC-XIV-129 CCC – CEBU CITY

207 472 CR 14903 12/23/75 AFFIRMED 01/29/75 06/20/75 6137

208 473 CR 14978 P.P., VS. LEONARDO YCOY 07/15/75 MODIFIED 08/06/75 10/09/75

209 474 CR 14982 P.P., VS. WENCESLAO MANALANSAN 03/31/75 DISMISSED 04/23/75 07/14/75 5278

210 475 CR 15038 P.P., VS. GUNIGUNDA SANTIAGO 09/02/75 AFFIRMED 09/22/75 11/13/75 4521 MANILA

211 476 CR 15049 P.P., VS. DEMETRIO GABERTAN 06/18/75 AFFIRMED 07/19/75 09/29/75 5979-B

212 477 CR 15082 P.P., VS. RODOLFO VILLANUEVA 06/23/75 AFFIRMED 07/11/75 09/24/75 03/18/76 F-062718 CC CC – MANILA

213 477 CR 15106 P.P., VS. MARCELO MENIOSA 11/11/76 AFFIRMED 12/08/76 01/19/77 2018

214 478 CR 15121 P.P., VS. RAFAEL ESMANE Y ARANA 05/06/75 DISMISSED 05/07/75 05/29/75 9458

215 467 CR 15206 P.P., VS. CONRADO MEJIA Y ANTONIO 01/04/79 AFFIRMED 01/24/79 07/09/79 O-9142 XXVIII

216 468 CR 15217 P.P., VS. PACIFICO ABAD Y LAZARO 08/25/75 ACQUITTED 08/26/75 09/10/75 11581 CFI – MANILA

217 468 CR 15235 P.P., VS. MOISES ADIQUY LOZANO 03/19/75 ACQUITTED 03/20/75 03/31/75 E-287693 MANILA

218 469 CR 15253 P.P., VS. PERFECTO CARLOS 11/17/76 AFFIRMED 12/09/76 01/25/77 CCC-III-0275

219 465 CR 15264 07/18/74 11/26/74 04/03/75 SM-436 BULACAN

220 465 CR 15272 02/10/75 AFFIRMED 03/05/75 05/20/75 2080 QUEZON CITY

221 465 CR 15283 P.P., VS. RESTITUTO ESTRELLA 07/02/75 AFFIRMED 08/04/75 10/09/75 4895

222 466 CR 15327 P.P., VS. JESUS ROMEO VISCAYA 05/31/76 AFFIRMED 06/22/76 01/19/77 6080

223 464 CR 15378 P.P., VS. ANGEL ABRAJANO 03/21/75 07/07/75 10/16/75 277

DUMA-GUETE

NEGROS ORIENTAL

P.P., VS. MARIANO LACSAMANA, ET. AL.

CFI – SAN FERNANDO, PAMPANGA

CCC-III-0119-P

CCC – DAGUPAN CITY,

PANGASINAN


CC – DAVAO CITY

MALAYBALAY, BUKIDNON

NEGROS OCCIDENTAL

CFI – QUEZON CITY

CCC – OLONGAPO

CITY

P.P., VS. ARSENIO HORTALEZA Y PASCUAL, ET. AL.

AFFIRMED W/

MODIFICA-TION

P.P., VS. ANTONIO CLAVERIA, ET. AL. VS. DOMINADOR C. BORAL


CC – LEGASPI CITY

AFFIRMED W/

MODIFICA-TION

CC – SAN JOSE CITY, NUEVA

ECIJA


COURT OF APPEALS SC


LOC. (Page)

COURT OF ORIGIN


NATURE OF CASE

224 464 CR 15389 P.P., VS. RODOLFO G. TABAT 06/17/75 AFFIRMED 07/07/75 09/24/75 71547-CC CC – PASAY CITY

225 464 CR 15394 P.P., VS. MELECIO PICO 11/08/76 UPHOLD 12/02/76 01/26/77 388

226 463 CR 15424 P.P., VS. CHRISTOPHER GOOPIO 05/07/75 05/08/75 06/20/75 CCC-XIV-88 CCC – CEBU CITY

227 463 CR 15429 P.P., VS. FERNANDO GATPANDAN 04/07/75 AFFIRMED 08/12/75 10/29/75 08/29/75 534-V

228 463 CR 15431 P.P., VS. MARIA ESPIRITU 07/21/75 DISMISSED 07/22/75 07/29/75 Q-2836 RIZAL

229 461 CR 15466 P.P., VS. BERT MUSCOSA 11/09/76 AFFIRMED 12/06/76 01/26/77 B-19262

230 461 CR 15470 P.P., VS. SALLY “BOY” SERQUINA 11/20/74 DISMISSED 12/18/74 02/13/75 34

231 461 CR 15490 P.P., VS. CONRAD GLORIA, ET. AL. 07/15/75 ACQUITTED 07/16/75 07/24/75 70405 CC – PASAY CITY

232 461 CR 15497 P.P., VS. ROLANDO LADICHO 12/14/76 SET ASIDE 12/15/76 01/05/77 971-R III CFI -PASAY CITY

233 73 CR 15516 P.P., VS. PATRICK WAYET, ET. AL. 09/16/75 AFFIRMED 10/18/75 12/02/75 250

234 462 CR 15528 12/06/76 AFFIRMED 12/24/76 02/01/77 3352

235 462 CR 15530 P.P., VS. LEONILA BUYA ONG 09/10/75 ACQUITTED 09/11/75 09/23/75 241-A

236 462 CR 15532 P.P., VS. CAMILO TABLANG 04/16/79 AFFIRMED 05/09/79 06/22/79 43(72) CABANATUAN

237 462 CR 15535 P.P., VS. MAURO MARIANO Y ALFARO 11/29/76 AFFIRMED 12/18/76 02/01/77 12833 MANILA

238 460 CR 15568 P.P., VS. ROBERTO SOLIVA 04/02/75 AFFIRMED 04/28/75 07/11/75 135

239 74 CR 15610-12 P.P., VS. MARY ANN G. CHUA 07/24/75 AFFIRMED 08/11/75 10/09/75 MANILA

240 458 CR 15631 P.P., VS. EUGENIO AMPARO 02/25/75 03/31/75 05/28/75 462 CAGAYAN

241 459 CR 15656 P.P., VS. ANTONIA RANJO 10/21/74 DISMISSED 11/12/74 02/03/75 167-11 ILOCOS NORTE

242 456 CR 15679 P.P., VS. MARCELO SABADO 01/30/79 AFFIRMED 02/22/79 05/02/79 Q-1980 XVI

243 456 CR 15686 P.P., VS. NOILE ANG, ET. AL. 09/02/75 ACQUITTED 09/03/75 09/18/75 0944 RIZAL

244 457 CR 15695 P.P., VS. ALBERTO COY, ET. AL. 06/18/75 AFFIRMED 07/19/75 10/07/75 259

ILAGAN, ISABELA

DISMISSED W/

GRANTED

CFI – VALENZUELA,

BULACAN

CC – DIPOLOG CITY,

ZAMBOANGA DEL NORTE

TAYUG, PANGASINAN

MUN. COURT TADIAN, MT.

PROVINCE

P.P., VS. PABLO MAGPANTAY Y ROBLES

MC – CALAPAN, ORIENTAL MINDORO

CFI – PANGASINAN

ZAMBOANGA DEL NORTE

F-143714, ETC.

ABANDONED &

DISMISSED

CFI – QUEZON CITY

CFI – DIGOS, DAVAO DEL SUR


COURT OF APPEALS SC


LOC. (Page)

COURT OF ORIGIN


NATURE OF CASE

245 457 CR 15712 P.P., VS. ROMAN NAJE 10/22/74 DISMISSED 12/03/74 02/11/75 L-200

246 455 CR 15746 P.P., VS. LUCY ORIA 02/03/75 AFFIRMED 09/01/75 11/04/75 CCC-V-784

247 455 CR 15747 P.P., VS. EUGENIO MIRASOL 03/21/75 AFFIRMED 04/16/75 07/11/75 3733

248 451 CR 15872 P.P., VS. SEGUNDO OGALE, ET. AL. 03/25/75 AFFIRMED 04/17/75 07/11/75 118

249 72 CR 15930 P.P., VS. RAMON MAGALONG 11/23/76 07/16/76 AFFIRMED 12/07/76 01/25/77 SCC – 175 PANGASINAN

250 452 CR 15932 P.P., VS. JOSE AÑONUEVO Y JACOB 04/16/75 05/06/75 07/29/79 142786 III

251 453 CR 15954 P.P., VS. FRANCISCO EXCONDE 09/09/75 AFFIRMED 09/29/75 11/13/75 167-SP

252 71 CR 15961 08/29/79 AFFIRMED 10/31/79 12/03/79 D-161 DAGUPAN CITY

253 453 CR 15974 P.P., VS. FELICISIMO SALABAS 02/26/79 AFFIRMED 03/31/79 05/08/79 375

254 454 CR 15986 P.P., VS. LEONIDES ECARMA 01/17/77 DENY *NDA 04/20/77 02/27/77 12832 CFI – MANILA

255 443 CR 16033 06/08/79 ACQUITTED 06/08/79 06/28/79 Z-74

256 71 CR 16034-35 P.P., VS. AQUILINO CUARESMA 08/04/75 AFFIRMED 08/27/75 10/23/75

257 444 CR 16048 P.P., VS. EUFEMIO REYES 12/21/78 AFFIRMED 01/20/79 06/20/79 4708

258 445 CR 16106 P.P., VS. VICTOR EUSEBIO 10/29/75 10/30/75 11/10/75 F-114088 CC – MANILA

259 445 CR 16107 01/31/77 ACQUITTED 02/01/77 02/08/77 85

NAGA CITY, CAMARINES SUR

CCC – SAN FERNANDO, PAMPANGA

CFI - RIZAL, PASIG

CFI – GUIAN, EASTERN SAMAR

SAN CARLOS

ABANDONED &

DISMISSED

CC – QUEZON CITY

CFI – SAN PABLO CITY, LAGUNA

P.P., VS. BENJAMIN VILLNUEVA QUESADA

CFI – CAGAYAN DE ORO CITY,

MISAMIS ORIENTAL

P.P., VS. VICTORIO GONZALVO, ET. AL.

CFI – OCCIDENTAL

MINDORO (MAMBURAO)

CCC-IV – 176 – 177 (71) NE

EATEN BY TERMITES

CFI – DIPOLOG, ZAMBOANGA

DEL NORTE

SET ASIDE & ACQUITTED

P.P., VS. LAMBERTO GUADEZ @ JOVEN GUADEZ

CFI – BATANGAS CITY


COURT OF APPEALS SC


LOC. (Page)

COURT OF ORIGIN


NATURE OF CASE

260 446 CR 16142 07/30/79 AFFIRMED 09/04/75 11/13/75 1117

261 446 CR 16163 P.P., VS. POFERIO ENCELA 05/10/76 AFFIRMED 07/24/76 01/19/77 808-MC

262 447 CR 16189 P.P., VS. COSIM HAMID 04/03/75 05/20/75 07/01/75 1415

263 448 CR 16214 P.P., VS. MARIA ESTIL 12/13/74 DISMISSED 01/20/75 03/31/75 ILIGAN CITY

264 449 CR 16241 P.P., VS. ANGEL PENIS, ET. AL. 11/10/76 AFFIRMED 12/01/76 01/25/77 8196

265 450 CR 16282 P.P., VS. MANUEL JO Y LIBATITI 10/08/76 AFFIRMED 11/06/76 01/11/77 B-275

266 450 CR 16283 P.P., VS. VALERIANO CAMASO 08/04/75 AFFIRMED 09/05/75 11/03/75 467

267 437 CR 16359 P.P., VS. ROGELIO ALFORNON 03/05/75 03/06/75 04/08/75 720 MASBATE

268 70 CR 16379 P.P., VS. ANTNIO APOSTOL 01/31/79 AFFIRMED 02/28/79 05/02/79 C U – 576 CFI – CEBU

269 438 CR 16383 P.P., VS. ANTONIO ANONUEVO 06/04/75 06/05/75 07/14/75 9367

270 438 CR 16386 06/10/75 AFFIRMED 07/07/75 09/24/75 CCC-VI-1466 MANILA

271 439 CR 16408 P.P., VS. PEDRO DUMAGAN, ET. AL. 08/12/76 09/30/76 01/26/77 298

272 439 CR 16410 P.P., VS. POLICARPIO GUANICO 07/11/75 AFFIRMED 08/05/75 10/09/75 12124

273 440 CR 16416 P.P., VS. BIENVENIDO OGNAY 01/31/77 ACQUITTED 02/01/77 02/08/77 11-171 ILIGAN CITY

274 441 CR 16473 P.P., VS. EMILIA BOHOLST 07/03/75 AFFIRMED 07/31/75 10/07/75 B-301 ORMOC CITY

275 442 CR 16497 11/02/78 AFFIRMED 01/23/79 07/09/79 290-A

276 432 CR 16511 P.P., VS. ABDUL MALIK HAMIS 07/24/75 08/22/75 10/23/75 2584-72

277 68 CR 16533 P.P., VS. JAIRO GABAYAN 11/23/76 AFFIRMED 12/24/76 02/01/77 309 PALAWAN P. PRINCESA

278 433 CR 16538 P.P., VS. JORGE MONTECILLO 04/14/75 REVERSED 04/15/75 04/30/75 6429-R CC – CEBU CITY

279 68 CR 16543 P.P., VS. FLORENTINA FELUCHO 11/10/76 AFFIRMED 12/08/76 01/26/77 685-I ZAMBALES

280 433 CR 16545 P.P., VS. MERCEDES CANLAS, ET. AL. 12/03/76 AFFIRMED 12/28/76 02/01/77 F-10379 CC – MANILA

P.P., VS. FORTUNATO TORENCIO, ET. AL.

MC – EASTERN SAMAR,

QUINAPONDAN

MC – GUBAT, SORSOGON

RESOLVE TO DISMISS

CFI – SOUTH COTABATO,

GEN. SANTOS CITY

7460-AF & 7462

NAGA CITY, CAMARINES SUR

CFI – BAYBAY, LEYTE

MALAYBALAY, BUKIDNON

WITHDRAWN

DISMISSED W/

GRANTED

CFI - RIZAL, PASIG

P.P., VS. JOSE MANALANG y CABRERA

AFFIRMED W/

MODIFICA-TION

SURIGAO DEL SUR

CFI – ILOILO CITY

P.P., VS. HEROHITO ORLANDA, ET. AL.

ALAMINOS, PANGASINAN

RESOLVE TO DISMISS

CFI – ZAMBALES, OLONGAPO


COURT OF APPEALS SC


LOC. (Page)

COURT OF ORIGIN


NATURE OF CASE

281 434 CR 16565 P.P., VS. ABELARDO OBRA 12/10/76 AFFIRMED 01/04/77 02/08/77 U-0316 PANGASINAN

282 435 CR 16585 P.P., VS. FRANCISCO GARCIA 06/16/75 GRANTED 06/17/75 07/15/75 274-T

283 435 CR 16611 11/10/76 AFFIRMED 11/27/76 02/08/77 53279

284 436 CR 16620 P.P., VS. LIWAYWAY YAMBAS 07/10/75 07/11/75 07/28/75 Q-2234 QUEZON CITY

285 436 CR 16623 P.P., VS. ROLANDO ALSAAS 07/31/79 AFFIRMED 03/03/79 05/10/79 C-275

286 436 CR 16629 P.P., VS. SIMEON ABALOS 01/22/75 DISMISSED 02/12/75 04/22/75 SCC-203 PANGASINAN

287 436 CR 16635 P.P., VS. CONRADO MEJIA JR. 07/30/79 AFFIRMED 09/02/79 10/25/79 26506 IV

288 431 CR 16699 P.P., VS. CARLOS TAN, ET. AL. 04/02/75 DISMISSED 04/22/75 07/11/75 IV-147493 QUEZON CITY

289 430 CR 16706 03/26/75 REINSTATE 04/21/75 09/03/75 2260

290 428 CR 16742 P.P., VS. EMILIO V. CAMBA JR. 05/21/75 AFFIRMED 06/21/75 09/19/75 0629-M

291 428 CR 16743 P.P., VS. PAROUK BALT Y UMPARA 04/07/75 DISMISSED 04/26/75 07/11/75 496-P

292 428 CR 16745 07/08/75 07/09/75 07/29/75 CCC-VI-1604 MANILA

293 428 CR 16765 P.P., VS. EMMA R. DELGADO, ET. AL. 12/06/76 REVERSED 12/27/76 02/01/77 12/01/86 10235 CFI – MANILA

294 69 CR 16767 06/23/75 DISMISSED 07/19/75 12/18/75 CCC-1-236 CCC – CAGAYAN

295 69 CR 16780 P.P., VS. EUFRONIO S. LAROSA 03/20/79 AFFIRMED 04/12/79 07/12/79 1267 NUEVA ECIJA

296 429 CR 16804 P.P., VS. JUAM MOLINA 07/28/75 DISMISSED 08/16/75 10/23/75 C-3363 RIZAL

297 67 CR 16858 P.P., VS. BENJAMIN ABARA 05/26/75 DISMISSED 07/07/75 09/23/75 0513 RIZAL

298 426 CR 16861 11/08/74 DISMISSED 12/09/74 02/03/75 CCC-VI-1529 IV CCC – MANILA

299 67 CR 16878 P.P., VS. CONRADO TORRES 12/03/76 AFFIRMED 01/03/77 02/08/77 217 ABRA BANGUED

300 426 CR 16884 P.P., VS. JULIA F. INFANTE 10/07/75 DISMISSED 10/30/75 12/02/75 9847 BACOLOD CITY

301 427 CR 16888 P.P., VS. JESUSA CORPUZ 04/29/75 05/26/75 07/24/75 D-479 PANGASINAN

302 67 CR 16900 P.P., VS. EFREN BADAR y DOMULOT 10/22/76 AFFIRMED 12/18/76 02/14/77 693-1 CFI

303 427 CR 16907 P.P., VS. ROBERTO MENDOZA JR. 12/06/76 AFFIRMED 12/27/76 02/01/77 274

304 67 CR 16938-16939 P.P., VS. ZENAIDA SANTOS 01/29/75 DISMISSED 02/18/75 04/30/75 93984-93985 MANILA

CFI – TUAO, CAGAYAN

P.P., VS. LIBERATO M. SAN ANTONIO Y MEDINA

CC – CALOOCAN CITY, RIZAL

WITHDRAWN

CFI – CALAPAN, ORIENTAL MINDORO

CC – BAGUIO CITY

P.P., VS. NICOLASA SONGCO Y CUNANAN



CFI – PASAY CITY

P.P., VS. PATROCINIO YANSON Y ROSAL

WITHDRAWN

P.P., VS. FELIPE SALVADOR MIRANDA

P.P., VS. ROBERTO PAGUIA Y ESTRELIA

RESOLVE TO DISMISS

IBA, ZAMBA-

LES

CFI – TANDAG, SURIGAO DEL

SUR


COURT OF APPEALS SC


LOC. (Page)

COURT OF ORIGIN


NATURE OF CASE

305 424 CR 16955 P.P., VS. ISAIAS ANTONIS 12/27/78 AFFIRMED 01/19/79 05/04/79 177

306 425 CR 16982 P.P., VS. REYNALDO CANASTRA 08/15/79 AFFIRMED 09/13/79 10/25/79 4408 II

307 425 CR 17002 P.P., VS. PABLO RAMOS 07/17/75 DISMISSED 08/11/75 10/23/75 D-663

308 423 CR 17062 P.P., VS. NAZARIO S. SOTTO 02/11/75 DISMISSED 03/06/75 05/21/75 E-492894 CC – MANILA

309 423 CR 17063 P.P., VS. MAXIMINO VASQUEZ, ET. AL. 09/23/75 DISMISSED 09/24/75 10/07/75 C-3907 (73)

310 331 CR 17069-70 P.P., VS. ROMULO MESA, ET. AL. 08/20/75 DISMISSED 09/30/75 11/03/75 8549-50 PASIG, RIZAL

311 331 CR 17093 P.P., VS. RODOLFO SANTOS 12/01/77 AFFIRMED 07/25/78 04/30/79

312 419 CR 17136 P.P., VS. THELMA CARBALLO 11/17/76 AFFIRMED 12/20/76 02/01/77 5840-A DAVAO CITY

313 420 CR 17189 P.P., VS. SILVESTRE MERCADO 04/11/75 05/05/75 07/21/75 3547 LIPA CITY

314 421 CR 17205 P.P., VS. REMEDIOS CUENTAS 06/11/75 DISMISSED 07/07/75 09/24/75 424 ALBAY

315 422 CR 17240 P.P., VS. BASILIO AQUINO 12/10/76 ACQUITTED 12/11/76 01/06/77 0501-M

316 422 CR 17242 P.P., VS. AIDA JOSEF Y BARBACENA 06/11/75 DISMISSED 07/09/75 09/24/75 N-157046 QUEZON CITY

317 65 CR 17250-54 P.P., VS. VALERIANO BELACHO 12/21/76 REVERSED 12/22/76 01/06/77 SF-42-46 CFI–CEBU CITY

318 65 CR 17294 P.P., VS. DIONISIA VERZOSA 03/20/79 AFFIRMED 04/12/79 06/15/79 U-0475

319 65 CR 17305 12/04/78 AFFIRMED 02/21/79 05/04/79 U-10608

320 65 CR 17311-12 P.P., VS. BIENVENIDO TUASTUMBAN 01/09/79 AFFIRMED 05/29/79 09/18/79 155 & 156

321 418 CR 17314 P.P., VS. AGELIO LABAO 11/24/76 AFFIRMED 12/23/76 02/01/77 4704

322 418 CR 17319 P.P., VS. ESPIRIDION TUPAZ Y RADAN 04/29/75 DISMISSED 05/23/75 07/24/75 88541 CC – PASAY CITY

323 65 CR 17326 P.P., VS. RUPERTO C. FRANCISCO 12/21/76 ACQUITTED 12/22/76 01/06/77 Q-754

324 66 CR 17347 06/09/75 DISMISSED 07/08/75 10/07/75 CCC-239

AURORA SUB-PROVINCE,

BALER, QUEZON

CFI – ZAMBOANGA

DEL NORTE (DIPOLOG CITY)

CFI – LINGAYEN, PANGASINAN

CFI – CALOOCAN

CITY

COVEV 710 (SM-446)

CCC – PAMPANGA

RESOLVED TO DISMISS


CFI – PANGASINAN

P.P., VS. HILARION CARBONELI, ET. AL.

CFI – PANGASINAN (LINGAYEN)

OROQUIETA CITY, MIS.

OCCIDENTAL

CFI – MASBATE, MASBATE

CFI – QUEZON CITY

P.P., VS. FELIPE SALVADOR y MIRANDA

CFI – TUGUEGARAO,

CAGAYAN


COURT OF APPEALS SC


LOC. (Page)

COURT OF ORIGIN


NATURE OF CASE

325 417 CR 17382 07/09/75 DISMISSED 07/30/75 09/23/75 14470 CFI – MANILA

326 66 CR 17388 01/03/77 ACQUITTED 01/04/77 01/19/77 IV-51 '70

327 411 CR 17433 P.P., VS. MARIO NAPOLES 06/30/75 DISMISSED 07/23/75 09/22/75 1941

328 411 CR 17444 P.P., VS. ERLINDA JAMERO 09/15/75 DISMISSED 09/16/75 09/29/75 Q-3555 VI QUEZON CITY

329 412 CR 17477 11/05/76 AFFIRMED 01/03/77 02/08/77 242-T CAGAYAN

330 413 CR 17486 P.P., VS. PABLEO LAPAZ 10/19/79 ACQUITTED 10/19/79 10/29/79 CCC – CEBU CITY

331 413 CR 17508 *NDA *NDA *NDA *NDA 02/07/75 1347

332 414 CR 17541 04/24/78 AFFIRMED 09/26/78 05/02/79 C-4366(73) XXXII

333 66 CR 17553 P.P., VS. ABRAHAM MIRALLES 05/04/76 AFFIRMED 09/01/76 01/06/77 11241 MANILA

334 415 CR 17572 P.P., VS. JOSE MAPA 11/11/76 DISMISSED 12/09/76 01/25/77 IR-5 (8636)

335 416 CR 17614 P.P., VS. PEDRO ENCARNACION 04/10/79 AFFIRMED 09/28/79 10/31/79 646 I

336 410 CR 17663 P.P., VS. GUILLERMO MAGADA JR. 12/14/76 ACQUITTED 12/15/76 01/05/77 12831 CFI – MANILA

337 410 CR 17680 P.P., VS. TOMAS P. RENDON 01/03/77 ACQUITTED 01/04/77 01/19/77 R-348

338 408 CR 17736 P.P., VS. SERAFIN PABLO 12/13/76 ACQUITTED 12/14/76 01/05/77 V-114 CFI – ISABELA

339 408 CR 17741 P.P., VS. AGUSTIN TABORA 05/20/75 DISMISSED 07/18/75 09/24/75 197-073

340 409 CR 17760 P.P., VS. JULIO OLHACHAN 01/21/76 DISMISSED 04/20/76 01/21/77 97

341 330 CR 17782 P.P., VS. PEDRO MALANA,ET. AL. 11/29/76 MODIFIED 12/23/76 02/01/77 CCC-1-328

342 404 CR 17915 03/19/79 11/16/78 ACQUITTED 03/21/79 11/12/79 08/31/79 L-148 II

343 404 CR 17920 P.P., VS. BENNING CHESPA 08/21/75 GRANTED 08/22/75 09/10/75 57 ZAMBALES

344 329 CR 17944 P.P., VS. LUISITO DAYRIT 12/14/76 REVERSED 12/15/76 01/05/77 E-484030 CC – MANILA

345 405 CR 17950 P.P., VS. NORBERTO SALDAO Y CRUZ 08/31/76 AFFIRMED 09/23/76 01/19/77 504

P.P., VS. URBESCIO CUCIO Y LINSANGAN

P.P., VS. DOMINADOR FRONDARINA, ET. AL.

ROXAS ISABELA

ISABELA (ROXAS)

CAMARINES SUR

P.P., VS. FRANCISCO VALDEPEÑAS JR., ET. AL.

CCC-XIV-915- CEBU

P.P., VS. ANTONINO MARANAN, ET. AL.

CFI – STA. CRUZ, LAGUNA

P.P., VS. RANULFO MERCADO Y HALUCON

CALOOCAN CITY

CFI – IRIGA CITY, CAMARINES SUR

CFI – GEN. SANTOS CITY,

SOUTH COTABATO

CFI – SAN JOSE, OCCIDENTAL

MINDORO

DAVAO ORIENTAL

CFI – LAGAWE, IFUGAO

CCC – TUGUEGARAO,

CAGAYAN

P.P., VS. ARSENIO MASANGCAY, ET. AL.

CFI – SURIGAO DEL SUR

(LINGGA)

TARLAC, TARLAC


COURT OF APPEALS SC


LOC. (Page)

COURT OF ORIGIN


NATURE OF CASE

346 406 CR 17984 P.P., VS. ROBERTO ADOVE, ET. AL. 04/23/75 04/24/75 05/20/75 475 BATANGAS

347 407 CR 18030 P.P., VS. MAXIMO CORCUERA 02/27/79 AFFIRMED 03/23/79 07/12/79 R-438

348 403 CR 18073 P.P., VS. FELIX O. PEROY 08/16/76 AFFIRMED 12/18/76 02/01/77 670

349 323 CR 18104 P.P., VS. JUANITO MARINAY 12/14/76 ACQUITTED 12/15/76 01/05/77 77-L

350 323 CR 18156 08/29/75 GUILTY 08/30/75 09/17/75 180

351 402 CR 18159 P.P., VS. CONELIO VILLANUEVA 07/13/79 AFFIRMED 03/05/80 05/13/80 8036 SAMAR

352 401 CR 18212 P.P., VS. EDUARDO RAMIREZ 10/24/75 DISMISSED 10/25/75 11/10/75 T-16226 CC – MANILA

353 401 CR 18223 P.P., VS. NAZIM SUBJALI HASSAN 01/30/79 02/22/79 05/10/79 1408-O

354 401 CR 18225 P.P., VS. PABLO CENINA 10/26/76 DISMISSED 11/23/76 01/25/77 5287 RIZAL, PASIG

355 324 CR 18322-23 P.P., VS. AMOR BRINGAS 04/30/80 *NDA *NDA *NDA 345 & 344 ABRA

356 399 CR 18359 P.P., VS. EDGAR BRACIA Y BILLEN 11/25/76 AFFIRMED 12/13/76 01/25/77 90766 CFI – MANILA

357 325 CR 18400 05/28/79 AFFIRMED 09/28/79 10/30/79 8855 IV

358 400 CR 18405 01/17/77 ACQUITTED 01/18/77 01/25/77 0536-V

359 325 CR 18437 P.P., VS. RODRIGO ALEJANDRO 10/14/76 DISMISSED 11/13/76 01/19/77 327-SP

360 398 CR 18438 P.P., VS. ADOLFO TALAVERA 07/23/76 11/20/76 01/19/77 3335

361 398 CR 18452 P.P., VS. ANTONIO MERCADO 12/20/76 11/12/76 AFFIRMED 12/28/76 02/01/77 9540 RIZAL, PASIG

362 397 CR 18499 P.P., VS. ROBERTO VISEY 12/21/76 12/22/76 01/06/77 12867

363 325 CR 18501 P.P., VS. LUIS SUAVERDE 01/30/79 SET ASIDE 02/08/79 11/09/79 1368 III ILOILO CITY

364 396 CR 18521 P.P., VS. CARLOS ROBES 11/09/76 DISMISSED 12/02/76 01/25/77 7699

365 395 CR 18561 P.P., VS. ALEJANDRO ROLLON, ET. AL. 01/05/77 01/06/79 01/19/77 6736-R CC – CEBU CITY

366 394 CR 18627 10/28/76 DISMISSED 11/20/76 01/19/77 8369 PASIG, RIZAL

367 394 CR 18628 P.P., VS. HEROHITO ORLANDA 10/28/76 DISMISSED 11/26/76 01/19/77 291-A PANGASINAN

WITHDRAWN


MINDORO

CFI – SAN JOSE, ANRIQUE

CFI – LEMERY, BATANGAS

P.P., VS. RICARDO PEREZ Y FALCA SANTOS

ZAMBOANGA CITY

ABANDONED &

DISMISSED

CFI – OLONGAPO

CITY

P.P., VS. JESUS LIZARE& DOMINADOR LIZARE

CFI – BACOLOD CITY, NEGROS OCCIDENTAL

P.P., VS. FEDERICO CABILING Y LIWANAG

CFI – BULACAN, VALENZUELA

SAN PABLO CITY, LAGUNA

RESOLVE TO DISMISS

CFI – TARLAC, TARLAC

CC – SAN PABLO CITY


NULL & VOID

P.P., VS. DEMOCRITO NURILLO @ MOCRING


COURT OF APPEALS SC


LOC. (Page)

COURT OF ORIGIN


NATURE OF CASE

368 326 CR 18671-73 P.P., VS. CLENTISIMA PLAZA-REMOJO 01/30/79 AFFIRMED 03/29/79 05/21/79 393,302 & 347

369 326 CR 18704 P.P., VS. JEREMIAS ONCIO 12/17/76 ACQUITTED 12/18/76 01/06/77 3105

370 393 CR 18721 P.P., VS. SAMUEL VILORIA,ET. AL. 10/30/79 ACQUITTED 10/30/79 11/07/79 V-276 V

371 392 CR 18775 10/30/78 AFFIRMED 02/01/79 05/11/79 0773-M

372 327 CR 18818-19 P.P., VS. ALEJANDRO PESCADERO 04/17/79 07/27/79 12/05/79 4213-4214

373 391 CR 18939 P.P., VS. PRUDENCIO INOC 10/28/76 AFFIRMED 11/19/76 01/19/77 215-L

374 391 CR 18947 P.P., VS. ACQUILINO CRIBE Y DAMIS 10/18/76 DISMISSED 11/11/76 02/01/77 19957 MANILA

375 390 CR 19002 P.P., VS. JORGE MASAVILLAY REYES 10/29/76 11/18/76 01/19/77 21067 MANILA

376 390 CR 19008 P.P., VS. NELSON DONIO DERONIO 10/14/76 DISMISSED 12/03/76 01/25/77 337 X

377 390 CR 19013 10/14/76 DISMISSED 11/29/76 02/01/77 1678

378 328 CR 19015 P.P., VS. ALEX DARIAGAN 02/16/79 03/14/79 05/04/79 6238 CC – ROXAS CITY

379 389 CR 19163 09/18/79 AFFIRMED 10/24/79 12/05/79 10782 XXI PASIG, MANILA

380 389 CR 19177 P.P., VS. FERMIN MAR, ET. AL. 01/04/77 ACQUITTED 01/05/77 01/19/77 4640

381 387 CR 19194 P.P., VS. MARCIAL LOROPAY 11/15/76 DISMISSED 12/11/76 01/25/77

382 388 CR 19230 P.P., VS. JOSE ALCONTIN 11/16/76 DISMISSED 12/18/76 01/25/77 407

383 388 CR 19262 P.P., VS. NORBERTO CAMACHO 01/10/77 01/11/77 01/26/77 2402-G

384 384 CR 19303 P.P., VS. EVENICER MAGLUNGSOD 10/02/78 AFFIRMED 11/03/78 05/03/79 716

385 385 CR 19334 P.P., VS. GUALBERTO VILLAR 11/27/79 12/19/79 07/22/80 4457 IRIGA CITY

CFI – SAN FRANCISCO,

AGUSAN DEL SUR

CFI – ILOILO CITY

CFI – ECHAGUE, ISABELA

P.P., VS. CIRIACO MAGSAKAY Y DELA CRUZ


AFFIRMED IN TOTO

CFI – PAGADIAN CITY

LAPULAPU CITY, CEBU CITY

AFFIRMED W/

MODIFICA-TION

NEGROS OCCIDENTAL

P.P., VS. MARCOS SAYCON Y CASAL,ET. AL.

CFI – DAVAO CITY

AFFIRMED IN TOTO

P.P., VS. ANDRES BARUBARU Y ROSALES

CC – TAGBILARAN

CCC-72-QUEZON-74

CCC – LUCENA CITY


(TANDAG)

WITHDRAWN

GUMACA, QUEZON

CFI – MALAYBALAY,

BUKIDNON

AFFIRMED W/

MODIFICA-TION


COURT OF APPEALS SC


LOC. (Page)

COURT OF ORIGIN


NATURE OF CASE

386 322 CR 19354-55 P.P., VS. EMERITA CAPAYAYAN 08/23/79 AFFIRMED 09/21/79 11/26/79 TACLOBAN CITY

387 386 CR 19361 P.P., VS. MARIANO DELA CRUZ 01/12/77 ACQUITTED 01/13/77 01/25/77 559

388 386 CR 19382 P.P., VS. JOSE OVIEDO “JOLLY” 01/15/79 AFFIRMED 02/07/79 05/08/79 D-106

389 386 CR 19384 02/16/79 AFFIRMED 03/14/79 05/08/79 768

390 122 CR 19507 P.P., VS. ANTONIO MACARAEG 01/12/79 02/01/79 05/21/79 1049

391 321 CR 19527 P.P., VS. ABELARDO MIGUEL, ET. AL. 07/31/79 AFFIRMED 09/02/79 11/22/79 MC-23711 MANILA

392 123 CR 19674 11/29/79 ACQUITTED 11/29/79 12/05/79 4358 BAGO CITY

393 320 CR 19739 P.P., VS. ANTONIO LAGARE 06/20/79 AFFIRMED 09/24/79 11/20/79 562-A CAMIGUIN

394 124 CR 19845 P.P., VS. ANASTACIO ORDISTA, ET. AL. 02/28/79 04/06/79 05/08/79 724

395 125 CR 19901 01/12/77 DISMISSED 01/13/77 01/26/77 II 780 LEYTE

396 126 CR 19945 P.P., VS. ARTURO DONDOY 01/19/77 WITHDRAWN 01/20/77 02/01/77 7-851-A

397 319 CR 20055 P.P., VS. MERCUR ALVARAN 09/29/79 AFFIRMED 09/26/79 11/05/79 8059 XIII PASIG, MANILA

398 319 CR 20068 P.P., VS. TEODORO BALATBAT 12/16/76 DISMISSED 12/17/76 01/05/77 23684 CFI – MANILA

399 127 CR 20072 P.P., VS. BERNARDO DOMINGO 05/08/79 AFFIRMED 09/27/79 12/04/79 V-86 V

400 128 CR 20156 P.P., VS. AMANDO MALONZO 11/28/79 11/28/79 12/03/79 413 III

401 129 CR 20180 P.P., VS. YOLANDA LUMAUIG 09/11/79 AFFIRMED 10/06/79 11/26/79 III-148 III

402 130 CR 20288 P.P., VS. ENRIQUE RITOR @ KING 07/31/79 AFFIRMED 09/08/79 09/25/79 570-A

403 318 CR 20342 P.P., VS. LUIS MONDANO 05/31/79 AFFIRMED 06/27/79 12/05/79 533

404 131 CR 20378 05/31/79 ACQUITTED 05/31/79 06/20/79 Q-5117 IX CFI – Q.C.

405 318 CR 20381 P.P., VS. JULIUS VALERA 11/28/79 ACQUITTED 11/28/79 12/05/79 707 I CFI – ABRA

406 318 CR 20462 P.P., VS. FELIPE EMPLEO JR. 09/28/79 AFFIRMED 10/26/79 11/23/79 8620-R VII CEBU

R-16382 & R-16433

CFI – TARLAC, TARLAC

CFI – DAGUPAN CITY,

PANGASINAN

P.P., VS. GREGORIO VILLACORTE, ET. AL.

CFI – TACLOBAN CITY, LEYTE

NULL & VOID

PANIQUI, TARLAC

P.P., VS. REV. FR. STEPHEN MAHONEY

AFFIRMED W/

MODIFICA-TION

MC – ANTEQUERA

(BOHOL)

P.P., VS. MELITON IGNACIO y VILLAMOR

MUNICIPAL COURT LA PAZ

CITY COURT – DAVAO CITY

ECHAGUE, ISABELA

REVERSED & SET ASIDE

TARLAC, TARLAC

CFI – ISABELA (CABAGAN)

MAMBAJAO, CAMIGUIN

CFI – SURIGAO CITY

P.P., VS. ROLANDO MADRINAL y PILENA


COURT OF APPEALS SC


LOC. (Page)

COURT OF ORIGIN


NATURE OF CASE

407 132 CR 20488 P.P., VS. RENATO JA GAPE 02/27/79 AFFIRMED 03/31/79 06/29/79 314-CTR-71 CFI

408 133 CR 20591 P.P., VS. LUIS PANGANIBAN 04/14/80 AFFIRMED 05/03/80 *NDA 22701 MANILA

409 135 CR 20637 05/16/79 ACQUITTED 05/16/79 09/06/79 466 I BANGUED, ABRA

410 136 CR 20693 P.P., VS. OSCAR ONDIVILLA y NOPIA 07/31/79 DISMISSED 08/26/79 10/19/79 C-5953 (75)

411 137 CR 20799 P.P., VS. AVELINO RARA y CAHATOL 04/02/79 DISMISSED 05/04/79 06/25/79 21965

412 138 CR 20817 P.P., VS. CONSUELO MALLARI 02/14/79 AFFIRMED 08/30/79 02/11/80 97909 MANILA

413 138 CR 20825 P.P., VS. ROBERTO P. DELA ROSA 02/16/79 05/19/79 06/20/79 12825 PASIG

414 139 CR 20856 P.P., VS. JUANITO ALVAR, ET. AL. 10/24/79 NOT GUILTY 10/24/79 12/05/79 2050

415 140 CR 20949 P.P., VS. JOVENO TOLETE 01/18/79 AFFIRMED 02/17/79 05/02/79 543

416 141 CR 21006 P.P., VS. PATERNO ESPANTA 04/11/80 *NDA *NDA *NDA 1438 DAVAO CITY

417 141 CR 21017 P.P., VS. ELISEO PAROILLO 07/25/79 AFFIRMED 09/12/79 01/17/80 10518-III III

418 141 CR 21028 P.P., VS. EMILIANO BELTRAN 06/04/79 WITHDRAWN 06/04/79 06/25/79 301 (285)

419 145 CR 21044 P.P., VS. SERGIO SALDUA 06/13/78 AFFIRMED 08/24/78 11/08/79 08/06/79 167(75) V

420 145 CR 21055 07/31/79 AFFIRMED 08/24/79 *NDA 88532

421 145 CR 21056 P.P., VS. ARTURO PEÑAMANTE 11/21/79 DISMISSED 12/09/79 02/06/80 1061 ZAMBALES

422 142 CR 21098 04/19/79 AFFIRMED 07/13/79 11/12/79 10/08/79 19439 CFI – MANILA

423 143 CR 21174 09/30/80 *NDA 10/29/80 01/05/81 C-498

424 143 CR 21178 P.P., VS. BONIFACIO NONOL 03/08/79 04/04/79 11/12/79 CU-2013 XI CFI – CEBU CITY

425 144 CR 21211 P.P., VS. FLORENTINO JESUITAS 09/19/79 AFFIRMED 10/19/79 01/10/80 12335 XX CFI – PASIG CITY

426 146 CR 21367 06/14/79 AFFIRMED 07/25/79 09/06/79 1639 III

427 383 CR 21408 P.P., VS. OSCAR SANTOS & OCA 08/01/79 09/02/79 12/05/79 11123 XI CFI - PASIG

MATI, DAVAO ORIEN-

TAL

P.P., VS. MACTAN PANGANIBAN, ET. AL.

CALOOCAN CITY

CAGAYAN DE ORO CITY

AFFIRMED IN TOTO

BISLIG, SURIGAO DEL SUR

DUMAGUETE CITY

CC – GEN. SANTOS CITY

DUMAGUETE CITY, NEGROS

ORIENTAL

CFI – DAVAO DEL SUR (DIGOS)

P.P., VS. MATEO TUMAOB Y MAGBANUA

CFI – PASAY CITY

P.P., VS. ANTHONY MAGCAL y ANDRADA

P.P., VS. RUDY MARCILLANA Y DE LEON


RESOLVED TO DISMISS

P.P., VS. CASIANO MURRO JR. & RICARDO BACATAN

ZAMBOANGA DEL NORTE

( DIPOLOG CITY )

AFFIRMED IN TOTO


COURT OF APPEALS SC


LOC. (Page)

COURT OF ORIGIN


NATURE OF CASE

428 383 CR 21424 P.P., VS. PAT CECILIO SORIANO 08/15/80 ACQUITTED 08/15/80 08/25/80 0299

429 147 CR 21438 08/02/79 AFFIRMED 09/06/79 11/27/79

430 148 CR 21478 P.P., VS. SAMSON GOROSPE JR. 03/24/80 AFFIRMED 04/12/80 05/14/80 1877-O OLONGAPO CITY

431 149 CR 21582 P.P., VS. FELICULA LAZARRA, ET AL 11/01/79 DISMISSED 04/13/79 06/29/79 5437

432 116 CR 21668 04/17/79 WITHDRAWN 04/17/79 05/08/79 1568

433 117 CR 21699 P.P., VS. MARIANO WERGAS, ET. AL. 03/07/79 DISMISSED 03/07/79 04/30/79 S-164 CFI

434 118 CR 21716 P.P., VS. BENJAMIN MARCOS y REYES 03/27/79 ACQUITTED 03/27/79 05/10/79 E-535289 XI CC – MANILA

435 118 CR 21718 P.P., VS. EMILIO BO. BALILA 09/20/79 AFFIRMED 12/15/79 06/26/80 05/29/80 166552 III CC – MANILA

436 119 CR 21784 P.P., VS. DOLORES MARFARI 12/06/79 ACQUITTED 12/06/79 12/14/79 C-6799 XXXIV

437 120 CR 21793 P.P., VS. EDUARDO ESPIRITU 03/19/79 DISMISSED 04/11/79 06/29/79 20052 RIZAL

438 120 CR 21817 P.P., VS. JULIAN CARDENAS 11/29/79 ACQUITTED 11/29/79 12/04/79 V-241 V

439 120 CR 21818 03/15/79 DISMISSED 03/15/79 06/20/79 73122-M PAMPANGA

440 120 CR 21819 P.P., VS. EMILIO MALICDEM 02/18/80 DISMISSED 03/12/80 05/14/80 CC-950

441 120 CR 21820 P.P., VS. MARINA NUCUM-PEREZ 08/24/79 08/24/79 10/30/79 651 III

442 121 CR 21830 P.P., VS. NESTOR ESPORLAS y RAMOS 10/29/79 ACQUITTED 10/29/79 11/07/79 3084 III

443 121 CR 21834 09/17/79 09/17/79 09/20/79 31770 MANILA

444 115 CR 21905 03/21/79 DISMISSED 04/21/79 06/29/79 C-75-773 CC

445 114 CR 22056 P.P., VS. JAIME CANIZARES y LIMPIA 02/27/78 DISMISSED 02/27/79 05/30/79 30902 MANILA

446 382 CR 22072 P.P., VS. JULIAN LIZARDO 10/24/79 REVERSED 10/24/79 11/07/79 5705 XXIII CFI – PASIG

447 382 CR 22079 10/16/79 AFFIRMED 11/04/79 11/28/79 II

448 112 CR 22108 P.P., VS. MA. R. LOPEZ 02/20/79 DISMISSED 03/21/79 06/20/79 243-II CFI

449 113 CR 22143 P.P., VS. CAROLINA GONZALES 10/17/79 DISMISSED 11/10/79 12/04/79 F-066169 VII MANILA

CCC – PANGASINAN

P.P., VS. JOSE ACORDA & BONIFACIA LANGGAY – ACORDA

CCC-I-436- CAGAYAN

854

CFI – TUGUEGARAO

MC – EASTERN SAMAR

P.P., VS. ALFREDO CONSTANTINO y APOSTOL

PUERTO PRINCESA, PALAWAN

SINILOAN, LAGUNA

CALOOCAN CITY

ECHAGUE, ISABELA

P.P., VS. BERNARDO SALITA. PABUSTAN

SAN CARLOS CITY

REVERSED AND

ACQUIT-TED

CFI – PAMPANGA

(SAN FERNANDO)

CFI – OLONGAPO

CITY

P.P., VS. RODRIGO ESCALONA y CARLOS

SET ASIDE AND

ACQUITTED

P.P., VS. EDUARDO PELAYO y GAMBOA

ANGE-LES CITY

P.P., VS. CONSTANCIO CABALIERO Y SEPULVEDA

CC – DAVAO CITY

LAOAG, ILOCOS NORTE


COURT OF APPEALS SC


LOC. (Page)

COURT OF ORIGIN


NATURE OF CASE

450 111 CR 22265 P.P., VS. LEO MACATANGAY 04/02/79 DISMISSED 04/25/79 06/29/79 C-6026 XXXIV

451 110 CR 22285 11/28/79 ACQUITTED 11/28/79 12/03/79 740 IX SAMAR, BASEY

452 109 CR 22499 P.P., VS. NITHER VARONA 12/14/79 ACQUITTED 12/14/79 12/21/79 2068 VI DAVAO CITY

453 109 CR 22506 P.P., VS. BRAULIO CALIMUTAN 03/28/80 SET ASIDE 04/17/80 05/15/80 SC-1620 LAGUNA

454 109 CR 22516 P.P., VS. ANITA ORONG ALIAS LICLIC 11/28/79 SET ASIDE 12/29/79 02/06/80 928 II

455 108 CR 22568 P.P., VS. NESTOR V. LOPEZ 06/26/79 DISMISSED 07/25/79 12/20/79

456 108 CR 22598 P.P., VS. DANTE BAUTISTA 07/05/79 DISMISSED 08/05/79 09/25/79 173971 IX Q.C.

457 107 CR 22610 P.P., VS. ARCADIO BAJA 06/05/79 06/05/79 07/12/79 1646

458 106 CR 22719 02/13/80 AFFIRMED 03/10/80 05/14/80 37680 MANILA

459 105 CR 22840 P.P., VS. GUILLERMO DE LA MERCED 10/17/79 10/17/79 11/07/79 C-6824 (75) XIV

460 103 CR 22938 P.P., VS. BEBIANO GARAN 01/04/80 DISMISSED 01/04/80 01/17/80 700 I

461 381 CR 22942 P.P., VS. EDDIE SERMANO Y GRANA 07/27/79 DISMISSED 09/22/79 11/12/79 1088

462 103 CR 22949 P.P., VS. HENRY P. MASCUÑANA 03/28/80 DISMISSED 03/28/80 05/14/80 CCC-XII-1149 BACOLOD CITY

463 104 CR 22984 P.P., VS. TESSIE SINGSON 07/29/80 ACQUITTED 20056 MANILA

464 359 CR 8100 01/30/75 AFFIRMED 02/18/75 04/29/75 3774 X ILOCOS SUR

465 307 CV 05525-R 11/05/76 GRANTED 01/28/79 01/25/80 3234 XXX

466 529 CV 07692-R 08/15/80 AFFIRMED 05/09/80 06/10/80 05/09/80 3583

467 293 CV 10574 08/08/80 DENIED 08/27/80 09/26/80 3515 I CFI – SORSOGON

468 530 CV 1118 07/23/80 GRANTED 08/22/80 09/15/80 25849 XX RIZAL, PASIG

469 532 CV 23516 11/04/65 RENDERED 04/16/80 06/19/80 04/16/80 4104 I

470 223 CV 26636 03/16/64 02/07/64 AFFIRMED 04/18/64 *NDA 12/29/77 2367 CFI – DAVAO

CALOOCAN CITY

P.P., VS. SINFOROSO DUCDUCAN AND PACIFICO COLMINAR

OROQUIETA CITY

1735 V (CFI 950)

BALAYAN, BATANGAS

RESOLVED TO GRANT

TAGBILARAN CITY, BOHOL

P.P., VS. EDGARDO DAYAO y PARAS, ET. AL.

SET ASIDE AND

ACQUITTED

CFI – CALOOCAN

CITY

CFI – BUTUAN CITY

CFI – AGUSAN DEL NORTE

P.P., VS. ERNESTO ARQUILADA, ET. AL.

CYNTHIA FLORES, ET. AL. VS. HON. JOSSE CAMPOS JR., ETC., ET. AL.

CFI – PASAY CITY

RAFAEL J. DADIVAS JR., ET. AL. VS. SOCIAL SECURITY SYSTEM

THE COMMISSSIONER CLS. - QUEZON

CITY

JOSE J. BERENGJER JR., ETC., ET. AL. VS. RUSTICO DELOS REYES,ETC., ET.

AL.INTEGRATED REALTY CORP. VS.

BONANZA RESTAURANT INC.MARIA D. DE EVANGELISTA AND

SERGIO EVANGELISTA VS. MARIANO FLOREZA


ALFREDO GIMENO @ DR. LEONARDO GIMENO VS. PRUDENCIO

CARTAGENA


COURT OF APPEALS SC


LOC. (Page)

COURT OF ORIGIN


NATURE OF CASE

471 533 CV 29017 05/10/67 AFFIRMED 11/07/79 02/07/80 11/07/79 4985

472 224 CV 35962 12/18/79 AFFIRMED 04/26/80 06/11/80 B-295

473 225 CV 37824 06/18/70 DENIED *NDA *NDA Q-6345 CFI – RIZAL

474 225 CV 38141 06/09/77 REVERSED *NDA *NDA

475 534 CV 39750 03/05/80 AFFIRMED 03/26/80 06/20/80 5826 IV

476 534 CV 40583 02/14/75 REMANDED 07/28/80 09/15/80 07/28/80 61802 V MANILA

477 226 CV 41589 08/31/77 AFFIRMED *NDA *NDA 65746 CFI – MANILA

478 535 CV 41962 12/13/79 MODIFIED 01/03/80 02/01/80 2630-P VII

479 536 CV 42389 04/12/77 AFFIRMED 04/30/77 12/19/77 60818 MANILA

480 536 CV 42444 09/17/79 AFFIRMED 04/26/80 07/24/80 4818 I

481 376 CV 42488-R 02/19/79 AFFIRMED 03/14/79 04/03/79 67823 X MANILA

482 249 CV 42896-R 03/01/76 AFFIRMED 04/10/76 03/06/79 2436

483 537 CV 43648 06/11/80 07/05/80 08/06/80 Q-6110 V

484 217 CV 43970-R 12/21/78 AFFIRMED 01/18/79 03/07/79 8279

485 537 CV 44370 02/14/80 REVERSED 08/06/80 09/23/80 100-A CFI – LA UNION

486 227 CV 44701 08/23/78 09/14/78 11/28/78 73082 CFI – MANILA

487 227 CV 44951 ZOILO M. ABALOS VS. OSCAR PERLAS 01/12/79 AFFIRMED 02/07/79 03/13/79 2863 CFI – BATAAN

CLARA TORELA , ET. AL. VS. FELIMON TORELA, ET. AL.

CFI – NEGROS OCCIDENTAL

(BACOLOD CITY)

VIVENCIO MORETO , ET. AL. VS. CORNELIO PAMPLONA, ET. AL.

CFI – BIÑAN, LAGUNA

CONRADO G. DE LEON VS. DOMICIANO A. AGUAS, ET. AL.

MANUELA GARCIA , ET. AL. VS. DIRECTOR OF FORESTRY

LAND REG. CASE NO. N-351 LRC REC. NO. N-16688

CFI – CAPIZ (ROXAS CITY)

SOFIA ALQUITRAN VS. ANDRES LOURDES, ET. AL.

CFI -QUEZON CITY

JUAN T. DAVID VS. R. MARINO CORPUS

UNION INSURANCE SOCIETY OF CANTON, LTD. VS. NED LLOYD @

HOEGH LINES, ET. AL.ALEJANDRO V. TENKER VS. BRIGIDA

T. GUINGONA , ET. AL.CFI – PASAY

CITY

ROQUE JAVELLANA, ETC. VS. THE PACIFIC TUG & SALVAGE CORP.

CIRIACO MORATE, ET. AL. VS. FERMINA MORATE, ET. AL.

CFI – CATBALOGA,

SAMAR

PAULINO ESTONINA & TRINIDAD SEPIDOZA VS. UTILITY ASSURANCE &

SURELY CO., INC.

HILARIA SABUERO, ET. AL. VS. SANTOS GO

MISAMIS ORIENTAL (MEDINA)

MARCIAL C. REYES VS. THE BOARD OF TRUSTEES FAR EASTERN

UNIVESITY, INC.


CFI – QUEZON CITY

FELICIA PERALTA VS. AVELINA SAYSON

NEGROS OCCIDENTAL

(BACOLOD CITY)

NATIONAL POWER CORP. VS. DELIA SARMIENTO

CALTEX (PHIL.) INC. VS. E. RAZON INC.



COURT OF APPEALS SC


LOC. (Page)

COURT OF ORIGIN


NATURE OF CASE

488 538 CV 44951 ZOILO M. ABALOS VS. OSCAR PERLAS 01/12/79 AFFIRMED 02/07/79 03/13/79 2863 CFI – BATAAN

489 539 CV 45273 11/08/77 AFFIRMED 04/07/78 11/17/78 09/25/78 280

490 375 CV 45498—R 01/11/79 AFFIRMED 02/17/79 04/03/79 75245 CFI – MANILA

491 228 CV 45620 02/15/78 SET ASIDE 02/25/80 04/30/80 02/25/80 *NDA 19 CFI – ZAMBALES

492 228 CV 45663-R 10/18/72 AFFIRMED 01/02/80 02/06/80 01/02/80 1436 II


494 513 CV 45941 01/08/79 AFFIRMED 02/04/79 03/14/79 2932

495 229 CV 45984 01/28/80 AFFIRMED 04/08/80 05/30/80 7049 CFI – ZAMBALES

496 514 CV 46392 08/03/77 AFFIRMED 09/04/77 12/21/77 7608 ILOILO CITY

497 514 CV 46568 12/17/79 AFFIRMED 01/09/80 02/18/80 D-2030 III DAGUPAN CITY

498 218 CV 46614 04/21/80 AFFIRMED 05/15/80 06/20/80 10524 III CFI – CEBU CITY

499 515 CV 46953 04/03/78 SET ASIDE 07/06/78 12/14/78 Q-8077 CFI – RIZAL, Q.C.

500 218 CV 46957 07/17/79 11/13/78 REVIEW 12/24/79 01/23/80 12/24/79 77366 V CFI – MANILA

501 379 CV 47089-R 12/28/79 MODIFIED 02/09/80 06/26/80 1745 II CFI – LA UNION

502 379 CV 47095-R 12/22/78 AFFIRMED 01/15/79 03/06/79 1492

503 219 CV 47125 05/05/77 AFFIRMED 06/02/77 09/05/77

504 516 CV 47127 07/05/79 AFFIRMED 09/22/79 01/07/80 8706 V

505 219 CV 47179 11/16/77 AFFIRMED 12/03/77 11/17/78 21

506 378 CV 47254-R 10/03/78 AFFIRMED 01/27/79 03/07/79 T-396

FRANCISCO NIFRAS VS. ARTEMIO CASUYON & JESUSA GAYANELO

NEGROS OCC. (HIMALAYAN)

MANILA METAL CONTAINER CORP. VS. LUZON BROKERAGE CORP.

ZAMBALES CHROMITE MINING CO. VS. HON. SEC. OF AGRICULTURE &

NATURAL RESOURCES , ET. AL.

MUNICIPALITY OF DAET VS. LI SENG GIAP @ CO., INC.

CFI – CAMARINES

NORTE

FILOIL MARKETING CORP. VS. MODESTO BAINA CAPITAL

INSURANCE & SURETY CO.,INC.MARCELO BATUYONG, ET. AL. VS.

FRANCISCO PERALTACFI – ILOCOS

NORTE

ALEJANDRINO P. LABIO VS. FEILE PURICACION , ET. AL.

ESPERANZA MAÑOSA, ET. AL. VS. EFRAIN ESCARILLA & ROQUITA

GECOSARSENIO IMBAT VS. CARINA G.

BALTAZARSERAPION CAYETANO , ET. AL. VS.

SULPICIO MARAGOPEOPLE'S HOMESITE & HOUSING

CORP. VS. AMELIA CAMILONLEONARDO MENDOZA VS. TEODOR

GUMATAY, ET. AL. MARCELINA FLORES Y DUMO VS.

CARLOS FLORES, ET. AL. MERCEDES BOISER, ADMINISTRATIX OF THE ESTATE OF CARLOS BOISER

VS. PLACIDO PEREZ, ET.AL.

BOHOL (TAGBILARAN)

GOVERNMENT OF THE PHILIPPINES VS. TORIBIO ABALOS , ET. AL.

NO.6/ 1083 DEGREE

NO.-IR2965 L

CFI – BOHOL (TAGBILARAN

CITY )

FEDERICO ORTALIZ, ET. AL. VS. THE BUENAVISTA SUBD., ET. AL.

CFI – BACOLOD CITY

THE DIRECTOR OF LANDS VS. VICENTE GARAMPIL , ET. AL.

GUIMBA, NUEVA ECIJA

PEDRO LOPEZ, TOMASA LOPEZ & MUN. JUDGE OF TIGAON,

CAMARINES SUR

CAMARINES SUR (TIGAON)


COURT OF APPEALS SC


LOC. (Page)

COURT OF ORIGIN


NATURE OF CASE

507 220 CV 47512-R 12/28/79 AFFIRMED 01/21/80 02/18/80 12084 XI

508 517 CV 47529 08/26/77 AFFIRMED 09/29/77 12/19/77 6019 DAVAO CITY

509 517 CV 47544 09/03/79 AFFIRMED 11/23/79 01/09/80 130-M III

510 556 CV 47772-73 04/26/78 02/03/78 MODIFIED 04/26/78 11/17/78 287 & 440

511 518 CV 47783 09/12/78 SET ASIDE 09/30/78 11/24/78 9636 XI CFI – PASIG

512 221 CV 47821 04/26/77 AFFIRMED *NDA *NDA Q-6714 CFI – RIZAL, Q.C.

513 212 CV 47871 06/26/80 AFFIRMED 08/22/80 10/02/80 Q-13133 XVIII CFI – RIZAL, Q.C.

514 518 CV 47881 09/29/78 SET ASIDE 10/27/78 03/14/79 197-BC CFI – CEBU

515 519 CV 47960 08/03/77 AFFIRMED 08/31/77 01/16/78 375-G

516 519 CV 48017 10/18/79 AFFIRMED 11/07/79 01/09/80 75243 III CFI – MANILA

517 557 CV 48086-87 12/06/79 AFFIRMED 03/05/80 09/29/80 I

518 519 CV 48199 04/15/80 AFFIRMED 08/03/80 10/30/80 R-9939 III CFI – CEBU

519 557 CV 48226-R 04/14/80 AFFIRMED 05/10/80 06/26/80 B-211 VIII CFI – LEYTE

520 373 CV 48228-R 11/23/78 01/05/79 04/03/79 5961

521 213 CV 48308 06/16/80 11/29/80 AFFIRMED 07/14/80 11/12/80 R-124

522 213 CV 48321 12/05/79 AFFIRMED 12/23/79 02/08/80 6482 X PASIG, RIZAL

523 213 CV 48357 08/22/78 AFFIRMED 09/13/78 11/27/78 5026

PRAPAT KRISNACHAN VS. DOMINGO TAN


MAJ. DOMINGO LUNA, ET. AL. VS. FERMIN ABELLA, ETC., ET. A L.REMEDIOS DE LARA, ET. AL. VS.

MUNICIPAL BOARD OF GINGOOG CITY, ET. AL.

CFI – MISAMIS ORIENTAL

VICTIRIO PAJARILLAGA, ET. AL. VS. MIGUEL DELA CRUZ

CFI – NUEVA ECIJA (GAPAN)

A.D SANTOS INC., ET. AL. VS. JOAQUIN GELLANDARIN, ET. AL.

PEOPLES HOMESIDE @ HOUSING CORP. VS. FELISA F. MARAÑON , ET.

AL. , RAFAEL N. DIAZELISEO R. JAMLANG VS. SENTRY PROTECTION & INVESTIGATION ,

INC.GLORIA LADA PANULAYA, ET. AL. VS. MAYOR GUNTRANO GICA, ETC., ET.

AL.SULPICIO DEL MORO, ET. AL. VS.

ROSALITO K. VILLABROZAQUEZON, GUMACA

THE HOME INSURANCE COMPANY VS. SANKYO KAIUN KABUSHIKI, ET. AL. , LUZON STEVEDORING CORP.

AURELIO TOBIAS, ET. AL. VS. CECILIA LUTAO

LRC NOS. 558 & N-617 LRC REC.

NOS. N-8471 & N-9141


EDILBERTO D. COZO VS. PHIL. TEAM NAVIGATION CO., INC., ET AL.

EMILIANO FABULAR, ET. AL. VS. TERESA FULACHE, ET. A.L.

THE CITY OF DAVAO VS. ENGR. DULCISIMO A. PEREZ & TRUST INS.,

CORP., ETC.

CFI – DAVAO CITY

FELICIDACION SAULONG, ET. AL. VS. DEVELOPMENT BANK OF THE

PHILIPPINES , ET. AL.


MINDORO

FELIPE RIPLE , ET. AL. VS. FRANCISCO D. SANTANA , ET. AL.

LUCIA DE LEON , ET. AL. VS. ROLANDO PLOMO, ET. AL.

CFI – CABANATUAN

CITY


COURT OF APPEALS SC


LOC. (Page)

COURT OF ORIGIN


NATURE OF CASE

524 214 CV 48467 02/18/80 AFFIRMED 05/24/80 07/25/80 172-G IV

525 214 CV 48481 09/28/79 AFFIRMED 10/21/79 01/31/79 2533

526 520 CV 48592 08/03/79 SET ASIDE 08/24/79 02/12/80 8398 I PASIG, RIZAL

527 521 CV 48615 07/17/79 DISMISSED 09/19/80 10/30/80 09/19/80 534 CFI – PALAWAN

528 215 CV 48726 11/08/79 SET ASIDE 11/24/79 06/11/80 79922 XXII CFI – MANILA

529 522 CV 48971 09/14/78 AFFIRMED 10/20/78 03/15/79 02/16/79 772 CFI – AGUSAN

530 216 CV 49110 08/29/79 AFFIRMED 09/23/79 01/28/80 12047 VIII

531 216 CV 49188 03/19/80 AFFIRMED 06/06/80 08/06/80 R-255 VIII

532 216 CV 49191 05/05/80 AFFIRMED 06/13/80 07/30/80 77935 XXIII CFI – MANILA

533 523 CV 49250 05/17/80 06/18/78 11/23/78 434

534 206 CV 49295 11/14/79 AFFIRMED 12/02/79 01/15/80 Q-13104 IV CFI – RIZAL,Q.C.

535 523 CV 49334 10/18/78 AFFIRMED 07/23/80 07/30/80 Q-4622 IV

536 206 CV 49338 12/06/78 AFFIRMED 02/02/79 06/20/79 6598

537 374 CV 49456-R 03/10/80 AFFIRMED 05/04/80 06/26/80 1828 I

538 207 CV 49687 03/01/79 MODIFIED 05/20/79 08/30/79 541 V

539 524 CV 49691 10/30/80 REMANDED *NDA *NDA 2209 CFI – SORSOGON

540 208 CV 49741 12/28/79 05/05/80 07/02/80 2500 I

541 525 CV 49782 ANITA T. DIAZ VS. FE DELA PAZ 12/13/79 AFFIRMED 01/03/80 03/05/80 Q-12442 IV

542 208 CV 49788 03/17/80 AFFIRMED 04/16/80 07/25/80 17-B IX BASEY, SAMAR

PEDRO ANGELLANO VS. MOSES ESCOBAR, ET. AL. VS. MELECIO

ANGELLANO, ET. AL.

NUEVA ECIJA (GUIMBA)

MAXIMO MIRANDA VS. ALBINO FERRERAS, ET. AL.


SEVERINO TOBIAS, ET. AL. VS. CORNELIO MELENDES, ET. AL.

FELIDAD CUSTODIO VDA DE SACLET VS. MILAGROS PEÑAFLOR, ET. AL.

HARTFORD FIRE INSURANCE CO., VS. GUACODS INCORPORATION , ET. AL.

ROQUE V. ANDAYA VS. ISMAEL A. ROSALES

AMPARO VASQUEZ VS. AGRIPINA DE LEON, ET. AL.


JOVITA CALIPAYAN , ET. AL. VS. DALMACIO POLIQUIT , ET. AL.

CFI – BAYBAY , LEYTE

JESUS TRANCE VS. AIRPORT TRANSPORTATION CO., INC., ET. EL.

CARLOS PAHAMTANG VS. RESTITUTO SABORDO, ET. AL.

ORDER TO CANCEL

NEGROS OCCIDENTAL,

BACOLOD CITY

LEONCIO GONZALES VS. JESUS T. FRANCO JR.

SIMEONA C. MATIAS, ET. AL. VS. CIPRIANO S. ALLAS

CFI – QUEZON CITY

ANTONIO G. ENRIQUEZ & ALICIA GALA VS. PANTALEON J. REYES &

ELENA ALLAREY

QUEZON, LUCENA CITY

ANTONIA FAUSTINO VDA DE REYES, ET. AL. V S. MANUEL CARPIO, ET. AL.

CFI – SURIGAO DEL NORTE

THE HRS. OF THE LATE PACITA SICIOCO CRUZ, ET. AL. VS. LA

MALLORCA PAMBUSCO CO., INC., ET. AL.

CFI – GAPAN, NUEVA ECIJA

RUSTICO MORA VS. VICENTE BELMONTE, ET. AL.

ESTANISLAO SAMONTE ( SUBS. BY JUAN P. SAMONTE & ROSALIA SAMONTE- TIPON VS. FELIPE

MAGDIRILA


ILOCOS NORTE (LAOAG CITY)

CFI – QUEZON CITY

FERNANDO RAGOT , ET. AL. VS. ANASTACIA SABANYAO, ET. AL.


COURT OF APPEALS SC


LOC. (Page)

COURT OF ORIGIN


NATURE OF CASE

543 209 CV 49822 08/02/77 AFFIRMED 09/10/77 12/19/77 356 CFI – JOLO, SULU

544 526 CV 49872 08/31/78 AFFIRMED 09/22/78 11/23/78 R-70

545 526 CV 49930 04/29/80 DENIED *NDA *NDA 4847 CFI – DAVAO

546 526 CV 49946 05/09/80 AFFIRMED 06/20/80 07/17/80 12966 VIII PASIG, RIZAL

547 558 CV 50120-R 10/18/77 AFFIRMED 11/05/77 03/29/78 476-M (13392) RIZAL, MAKATI

548 210 CV 50190 07/01/80 *NDA *NDA *NDA 140-T

549 527 CV 50205 03/13/80 AFFIRMED 04/05/80 06/19/80 7164 II

550 210 CV 50223 ANITA ANG VS. CESAR B. PADUA 03/03/80 AFFIRMED 06/08/80 10/06/80 C-69 XII


552 558 CV 50267-R 08/01/78 AFFIRMED 08/19/78 11/17/78 63213 I MANILA

553 528 CV 50390 12/26/79 AFFIRMED 01/18/80 02/07/80 60574 XVI CFI – MANILA

554 528 CV 50446 12/05/77 AFFIRMED 04/08/78 01/09/80 10/15/79 884 I

555 503 CV 50521 04/28/78 AFFIRMED 10/05/78 04/25/80 03/13/80 438 II

556 503 CV 50545 07/31/79 AFFIRMED 11/28/79 01/07/80 6491 II CFI – DAVAO

557 366 CV 50559-R 10/19/78 AFFIRMED 11/09/78 12/15/78 79598 MANILA

558 211 CV 50614 10/31/79 AFFIRMED 12/09/79 02/08/80 523 II

559 504 CV 50620 05/15/80 AFFIRMED 06/11/80 07/07/80 III

560 365 CV 50655 & 51081 09/16/76 AFFIRMED 02/03/77 03/16/77

'TEH ASIBIH ALIAS “ CHIN HOCK ” VS. MOHAMMAD JOHAN

DIONISIO L. MERCENE VS. MAMERTA P. MICIANO

ORIENTAL MINDORO,

PINAMALAYAN

LORENZO MABANDOS VS. FEDERICO PAULIN

PRUDENCIO J. TEODORO VS. FRANCISCO TEODORO

PABLO RAYOS, ET. AL. VS. EUFROCINA DEL ROSARIO

RUFINO FERRARIS VS. CESARIO ALCORDO, ET. AL.

CFI – CEBU (TOLEDO)

ARACELI TORRES, ET. AL. VS. SPS. FAUSTO TADY & ESTER ZABALLERO

CFI – LUCENA, QUEZON

CFI – RIZAL, CALOOCAN

CITY

INSURANCE CO. OF NORTH AMERICA VS. UNITED STATES LINES COMPANY

PHIL. INTERNATIONAL SURETY COMPANY INC. VS. GRACIANO BORJA

RP. VS. MUTUAL SECURITY INSURANCE, MANILA SURETY &

FIDELITY CO., INC.

JORGE LUBGUBAN VS. SABDULA AGOONG, ET. AL.

CFI – PAGADIAN CITY,

ZAMBOANGA DEL SUR

NATIONAL POWER CORP. VS. MARY CONCEPCION BAUTISTA, ET. AL.

CFI – LANAO DEL NORTE

NAZARIO GREGIA & CONSTANCIA P. GRECIA VS. DEVELOPMENT BANK OF

THE PHILIPPINESCOMMERCIAL CREDIT CORP. OF Q.C.

VS. MATIAS RANILLO JR., ET. AL.

CIPRIANO LIMAWAN, ET. AL. VS. LUISA LIMAWAN., ET. AL.

CFI – MALAYBALAY,

BUKIDNON

MARCOS TINGICAN VS. THE DIRECTOR OF FORESTRY, ET. AL.

N-200, N-34530

CFI – BAGUIO & BENGUET

HELEN G. GALON THRU HER MOTHER PURIFICACION C.

CALIMPON VS. TORCUATO L. GALON

OZ-288 & OZ-282

CFI – MISAMIS OCCIDENTAL

(OZAMIS CITY)


COURT OF APPEALS SC


LOC. (Page)

COURT OF ORIGIN


NATURE OF CASE

561 211 CV 50676 05/29/80 AFFIRMED 07/05/80 07/24/80 1069-O V CFI – LEYTE

562 504 CV 50705 08/21/78 REVERSED 09/30/78 11/24/78 2182

563 504 CV 50711 02/19/79 AFFIRMED 03/03/80 05/08/80 03/03/80 972-O V


565 205 CV 50856 09/07/78 AFFIRMED 10/04/78 12/04/78 1039-O

566 505 CV 50909 05/16/80 AFFIRMED 06/13/80 07/24/80 8973 VIII

567 505 CV 50921 11/05/79 09/09/80 09/29/80 09/09/80 N-114

568 204 CV 51062 09/27/77 SET ASIDE 10/16/77 12/21/77 75941 MANILA

569 506 CV 51083 07/31/78 DISMISSED 08/30/78 11/23/78 510

570 203 CV 51114 03/27/80 AFFIRMED 04/16/80 06/11/80 82216 V CFI – MANILA

571 507 CV 51133 09/01/77 AFFIRMED 08/04/78 11/23/78 10/06/78 67907 CFI – MANILA

572 203 CV 51146-R 12/29/78 AFFIRMED 08/16/79 05/26/80 03/24/80 R-50 II

573 362 CV 51175-76-R 06/06/78 REVERSED 07/01/78 12/29/78 4332, 4568 RIZAL

574 203 CV 51177 05/31/78 AFFIRMED 09/06/78 11/24/78 6738 DAVAO

575 363 CV 51276-77 06/29/79 AFFIRMED 01/12/80 02/08/80 V QUEZON CITY

576 508 CV 51308 06/03/80 DISMISSED 06/03/80 07/25/80 3472-P XXVIII

577 255 CV 51325 05/12/78 AFFIRMED 10/18/78 12/04/78 83019 CFI – MANILA

ISABEL M. ESMAS, ET. AL. VS. MARIO GUILLEMER, ET AL

TEODORICA VDA DELA SERNA, ET. AL. VS. THE PHILIPPINE COLLEGE,

ET. AL.

CFI – BOHOL (TAGBILARAN

CITY)

PORFERIO AYUYAO VS. JUANA C. VDA DE MIÑUZA & MANUEL TORRES

ORMOC CITY, LEYTE

MONOTOK REALTY INC. VS. SUSAN PEREZ

TRINIDAD PONO VS. MACARIO LUMANGTAD, RESTIOO VILLAMOR,

LUIS VILLENA & FLORENTINO ARASA

CFI – ORMOC CITY

ELIGIO FERNANDEZ VS. GREGORIO UMALI, ET. AL.


SALOME YU SIKE VS. TOMAS YU SIKE, ET. AL.



(TANDAG)

PEDRO ACORDA, ET. AL. VS. FELICIANO DUNGAO, ET. AL.

MORA MAGILA, ET. AL. VS. HADJI DJUBAIRA, ETC.

CFI – BASILAN CITY

DIOSCORO SARILI VS. DELGADO BROTHERS, INC.

IN THE MATTER OF PETITION TO APPROVE THE WILL OF

CONSOLACION A. ADVINCULA, DECEASED EDUARDO A. ADVINCULA

VS. RIZAL ADVINCULA, ET. AL.

CONCEPCION ACEREMO , ET AL., VS. AUREA CABRERA, ET. AL.

CFI – ORIENTAL MINDORO, PI-NAMALAYAN

HRS. OF MARIANO NATIVIDAD VS. LAUREANO NATIVIDAD, ET. AL.SAGNI SAMAL & MABALE VILLA-

ABRILLE VS. RAMON DEL ROSARIORODOLFO CALIMLIM, JESUS DAVID, ET. AL. VS. ROMANA G. GUDELANO,

ET. AL.

Q-12190, Q-12321

WENCESLAO B. TRINIDAD & GREGORIO S. TRINIDAD VS. MANILA

ELECTRIC COMPANY

CFI – PASAY, RIZAL

STA. ROMANA BAKERY, INC. REP. BY ITS PRES. & GEN. MANAGER

CONRADO G. STA. ROMANA VS. HON. W.L. CORNEJO, ETC.


COURT OF APPEALS SC


LOC. (Page)

COURT OF ORIGIN


NATURE OF CASE

578 508 CV 51438 09/27/79 AFFIRMED 11/09/79 01/11/80 9024 IV

579 256 CV 51463 05/30/80 AFFIRMED 07/10/80 09/11/80 6814 I DAVAO CITY

580 256 CV 51464 12/29/78 AFFIRMED 05/26/80 07/11/80 05/26/80

581 256 CV 51496 07/28/80 AFFIRMED 09/03/80 10/02/80 85542 XI CFI – MANILA

582 559 CV 51527-28-R 07/31/78 SET ASIDE 08/23/78 11/24/78 C-392-93

583 256 CV 51541 02/28/80 REVERSED 04/28/80 06/20/80 B-409 VIII CFI – CEBU

584 257 CV 51684 08/31/78 AFFIRMED 10/06/78 11/28/78 R-1599

585 560 CV 51748-R 05/23/78 AFFIRMED 06/21/78 11/17/78 R-12162 CEBU CITY

586 257 CV 51762 05/30/80 AFFIRMED 07/05/80 07/24/80 71857 I CFI – MANILA

587 257 CV 51785 07/24/78 AFFIRMED 08/19/78 11/24/78 K-823 IBASAY, AKLAN

588 509 CV 51835 10/13/78 DISMISSED 10/13/78 11/23/78 75237 MANILA


590 509 CV 51869 10/19/79 AFFIRMED 11/16/79 02/12/80 2450 III


592 259 CV 52307 04/25/80 MODIFIED 05/31/80 07/25/80 84 I

593 510 CV 52326 03/11/77 AFFIRMED 08/05/77 12/09/77 3224

JESUSA L. LLAMAS VS. FLORENCIO CUSTODIO


RAMON C. MUNDA VS. ESSO STANDARD EASTERN INC.

PABLO DEL VILLAR VS. RAMON ALABA, ET. AL.

LAND REG. CASE NO. LRC N-126

REC. NO. N-9418

CFI – CAMARINES

NORTE

CESAR P. UY VS. HON. GREGORIO N. GARCIA, ET. AL.

LORETO MERIADO, ET. AL. VS. PAULINO MALALUAN

CFI – CALAUAG, QUEZON

ALFREDO L. ARNOCO VS. HON. ABELARDO SUBIDO, ET. AL.

MARIA PRIMA VS. PERPETUA JORNALES

SOUTHERN LEYTE (MAASIN)

SABINA CABREROS VS. ISIDRO CABRERA

FILOIL MARKETING CORP. VS. CRESENCIA ANCIANO, ET. AL.,

TRAVELLERS MULTI-INDEMNITY CORP.

PATERNA LACHICA, ET. AL. VS. GAUDENCIO MOPIA, ET. AL.

MERCANTILE FINANCING CORP. VS. BENIGNO C. GUTIERREZM ET. AL.

CLEOTILDE HALILI VDA DE LEODONES, ET. AL. VS. PETRONIO

GUINEA, ET. AL.JULIA P. VDA DE BARANDA, ET. AL.

VS. SENECIO MACABINLARCFI – MISAMIS

ORIENTAL

PIONEER INSURANCE SURETY CORP. VS. E. RAZON, INC.

JULIA GISMA VS. AVELYN ANTONIO & CONRADO ANTONIO

DAVAO DEL NORTE (TAGUM)

JULIO FLORES, ET. AL. VS. WILLIAM JOHN FASSOTH JR., ET. AL.



COURT OF APPEALS SC


LOC. (Page)

COURT OF ORIGIN


NATURE OF CASE

594 259 CV 52363 06/04/80 AFFIRMED 07/12/80 07/25/80 5401

595 511 CV 52398 08/21/78 DISMISSED 09/15/78 11/24/78 1422-A

596 260 CV 52504 06/04/80 AFFIRMED 07/13/80 07/25/80 1034 VI

597 512 CV 52521 08/31/78 SET ASIDE 09/27/78 11/27/78 79308 CFI – MANILA

598 261 CV 52554 06/02/77 DISMISSED *NDA *NDA 87896 CFI – MANILA

599 491 CV 52624 10/02/79 SET ASIDE 11/05/79 01/07/80 4614 III

600 561 CV 52625-26 07/31/80 MODIFIED *NDA *NDA

601 491 CV 52647 TOBACCO CORP. VS. PNR 07/28/78 AFFIRMED 08/17/78 11/24/78 75053 CFI – MANILA

602 491 CV 52734 05/19/78 AFFIRMED 08/18/78 11/24/78 8275

603 262 CV 52756 08/01/78 AFFIRMED 08/27/78 11/27/78 9803 CEBU

604 561 CV 52761-R 02/08/78 AFFIRMED 07/19/78 11/17/78 191-T CAGAYAN

605 492 CV 52763 09/10/80 06/30/80 MODIFIED 07/30/80 09/16/80 3160 II

606 262 CV 52767 08/01/78 AFFIRMED 08/27/78 11/28/78 A-84

607 492 CV 52773 09/10/80 08/31/78 MODIFIED 09/28/78 11/24/78 R-2358

608 561 CV 52838-39 03/22/77 AFFIRMED *NDA *NDA 04/11/80 1784&1785 XIV


610 263 CV 52876-R CIRIACA DIAZ VS. JUAN DIAZ, ET. AL. 06/29/79 AFFIRMED 05/12/80 06/19/80 05/12/80 9616 VI

611 380 CV 52926-R 07/17/78 AFFIRMED 08/09/78 11/27/78 V-2953 CAPIZ

DORITA S. BALATAN & DR. TIRSO DELOS REYES VS. LORENZO

DESQUITADO, ET. AL., MUNICIPALITY OF BULA CAMARINES SUR

CAMARINES SUR (NAGA)

LEONDRO LUCZON VS. BEATO LUCZON

CFI – APARRI, CAGAYAN

AMBROSIA LOYSON-CAÑEDA VS. CONSTANCIO CANRIAS & FLORENCIO

AGUJA

CARIGARA, LEYTE

PEOPLE SURETY & INSURANCE COMPANY INC. VS. REYNALDO C.

CAMPOS,ET. AL.ASIAN SURETY & INSURANCE CO.,

INC. VS. MARTIN TAN, ET. AL.

LUCIA LASOLA, ETC., ET. AL. VS. SALVADOR GRAPA, ET. AL.

CFI – DUMAGUETE

CITY

PILAR NABOR, ET. AL. VS. ULDARICO NILLASCA & TEOFILA NILLASCA

K-772 & K-774

CFI – KALIBO, AKLAN

ANGEL LAVILLA, ETC. VS. FEDERICO R. CASTRO, ET. AL.

CFI – ILOILO CITY

ESTEBAN VALENCIA JR. V S. HON. ERNESTO M. MACEDA, ET. AL.

ARSENIO CRUZ VS. DELFIN CUARESMA

BERNARDINA VDA DE MARAVILLO VS. SILVESTRE BORRAS, ET. AL.

ALBAY (LEGASPI CITY )

JOSE GREGORIO VS. MARCELINO SUBOC, ET. AL.

ALLEN, NORTHERN

SAMAR

EUSERIO GARIZ, ET. AL. VS. ANGEL PAJARDO, ET. AL.


REPUBLIC OF THE PHILIPPINES VS. U & A TORRIJOS ENGINEERING

CORP.

CFI – CALOOCAN

CITY

CAMPOS RUEDA CORP. VS. E. RAZON, INC.


EDITHA DELA CRUZ VS. CESAR AGUILING


COURT OF APPEALS SC


LOC. (Page)

COURT OF ORIGIN


NATURE OF CASE

612 494 CV 53006 02/26/79 *NDA *NDA 03/12/79 1025-O CFI – LEYTE

613 264 CV 53008 11/16/79 10/03/79 AFFIRMED 10/29/79 01/28/80 Q-96-58 V

614 548 CV 53031-R 04/11/78 AFFIRMED *NDA *NDA *NDA *NDA

615 494 CV 53070 06/30/80 AFFIRMED 08/07/80 09/11/80 556-O I

616 495 CV 53116 10/06/78 AFFIRMED 10/28/78 12/14/78 12616 PASIG, RIZAL


618 496 CV 53265 01/15/79 AFFIRMED 02/12/79 03/15/79 802

619 496 CV 53268 04/11/80 *NDA *NDA 8094


621 377 CV 53347-R 08/10/78 09/07/78 11/27/78 7616(7713-A)

622 496 CV 53348 08/07/78 SET ASIDE 08/31/78 11/23/78 1927 I CFI – CAGAYAN

623 497 CV 53388 03/03/80 MODIFIED 03/26/80 04/30/80 7860 XXVI

624 497 CV 53400 08/31/78 AFFIRMED 09/20/78 11/23/78 7462 II CFI – RIZAL

625 251 CV 53441 03/27/80 AFFIRMED 04/23/80 06/11/80 73780 IV CFI – MANILA

626 497 CV 53442 08/10/78 AFFIRMED 08/31/78 11/23/78 10841 RIZAL, PASIG


628 252 CV 53740 03/13/78 DISMISSED 04/06/78 12/26/78 129-R

NEMESIA MAGALLANES, ET. AL. VS. HRS. OF DR. FERNANDO MORAZA, ET.

AL.PEDRO S. AMAPARO VS. JESUS

DELGADOCFI – QUEZON

CITYTHE HRS. OF FRANCISCO BIGORNIA,

REP. BY FILOMENA BIGORNIA PALMONES VS. THE HRS. OF TOMASA BIGORNIA, REP. BY PETRA PURISIMA ASST. BY HER HUSBAND TEODORO

PILARTA

CFI – ABRA, BANGUED

ELADIO CORDIAL, ET. AL. VS. MOISES DES QUITADO, ET. AL.

ZAMBALES (OLONGAPO

CITY)

CONCEPCION CLAUDIO GATMAITAN VS. MANUEL CLAUDIO & PEARO

CLAUDIOLUNETA MOTORS (PHILS.) CORP. VS.

FERNANDO A. HOFILEÑANELLY SUPNET VS. MARCELINO

GURREACFI – BASILAN

CITY

METRO (BACOLOD ) FINANCING & INVESTMENT CORP. VS. ARTURO M.

FERNANDEZ, ET. AL.

AFFIRMED W/

MODIFICA-TION

CFI – ILOILO CITY

FORTUNATO C. IGNACIO VS. SPS. ISABEL IGNACIO & PATRICIO

FAJARDO

EDUARDO Q. SANTOS CAYUGAN VS. ELIGIO TIONAMBA


CFI – DAVAO CITY

MARIA MACARUBBO VS. CARLOS ADDURU, ET. AL.

MARIA SARMIENTO VDA DE LA MADRID, ET. AL. VS. EXEQUIEL C.

REYES,ET. AL.


FRANCISCA C. URRIZA VS. NIEVES RALLOS CUENTO

NORTHERN MOTORS INC. VS. RAYMUNDO TRANSPORTATION CO.,

ET. AL.RAUL CRUZ VS. CARLOS V.

MAGDALUYOFEATI BANK & TRUST COMPANY VS.

ROBERTO TAN, ET. AL.JULIAN E. CASEM , ET. AL. VS.

FRANCISCA ILARDE, ETC.,ET. AL.ROSALES,

PANGASINAN


COURT OF APPEALS SC


LOC. (Page)

COURT OF ORIGIN


NATURE OF CASE

629 498 CV 53747-R 04/30/80 AFFIRMED 05/21/80 06/20/80 85899 V MANILA

630 372 CV 53872-R 09/25/78 AFFIRMED 02/01/79 03/06/79 M-1042 CAVITE CITY

631 499 CV 53881 05/16/80 AFFIRMED 06/12/80 07/29/80 R-9139 CFI – CEBU

632 253 CV 53894 06/30/77 AFFIRMED 08/03/77 12/15/77 10/27/77 654

633 500 CV 53970 10/03/77 DISMISSED 08/13/78 11/23/78 1067-O CFI – LEYTE

634 501 CV 54023 10/31/79 AFFIRMED 11/29/79 02/13/80 16

635 254 CV 54124 08/08/78 AFFIRMED 09/02/78 11/23/78 10701 RIZAL


637 502 CV 54159 09/01/78 AFFIRMED 09/29/78 11/24/78 A-792

638 502 CV 54186 12/08/77 AFFIRMED 01/04/78 11/23/78 3760 XXX

639 242 CV 54228 08/21/80 AFFIRMED 09/26/80 11/12/80 R-54 CFI- CEBU

640 502 CV 54240 09/24/79 AFFIRMED 03/10/80 05/07/80 03/10/80 88101 XXI CFI – MANILA


642 290 CV 54299 08/28/78 REVERSED 09/29/78 11/23/78 4492

643 242 CV 54318 01/08/80 AFFIRMED 04/03/80 06/19/80 72023 XXV CFI – MANILA

644 242 CV 54334 12/07/77 AFFIRMED 03/28/78 11/23/78 09/13/78 90571 MANILA

645 619 CV 54392 08/10/79 AFFIRMED 10/26/79 02/12/80 II

646 243 CV 54405 03/27/80 AFFIRMED 05/02/80 06/20/80 11186 XVI

647 619 CV 54472 11/04/77 AFFIRMED 02/07/78 11/24/78 104-R

KARMAN ENTERPRISES, INC. & PASCUAL T. LEELIN JR. VS. CITIZENS

BANK & TRSUST CO.ELEONOR RAMOS VS. DOMINGO

GUERREROCEBU STEVEDORING TOBACCO

MARKETING CORP., INC. VS. PHIL. VIRGINIA TOBACCO ADM.

OLIVIA PAGRALUNAN VS. LUCIA B. TOLENTINO & REYNALDO C.

TOLENTINO

GAPAN, NUEVA ECIJA

RAMON VARELA JR, ETC. VS. JOSE VENEZUELA, ET. AL.

FEDERICO LACUEVA, ET. AL. VS. PATERNO RUIZ, ET. AL.

CFI – QUIRINO (DIFFUN)

CLEMENCIA A. ANTILLON VS. VICTORIA CABRERA-PEREZ, ET.AL.

NORTHERN MOTORS INC. VS. EUSTAQUIO ABAD

FELICIANA BALAGAT, ET. AL. VS. RUPERTO BALAGAT

CFI – ALAMINOS, PANGASINAN

SOCORRO SONON VS. MARIKINA VALLEY TRANSPORTATION CO. &

VALENTINA DOMAR

CFI – PASAY CITY

SANTOS ALBINO VS. FORTUNATO ASENTISTA

ALFREDO LIGON SR. VS. ERNESTO ABILLO, ET. AL.

ELPIDIA REGIS VS. GERUNDIA REGIS DE TANUDTUD, ET. AL.

ARMAND ARMEÑA VS. CITY OF LEGASPI & GREGORIO S. IMPERIAL

JR., ET. AL.


PHIL. NATIONAL BANK VS. F. AZICATE TRANS. CO., INC.

SAN MIGUEL CORP. VS. BARBER LINES., ET AL

VICTOR DE GUIA VS. ATOK BIG WEDGE MINING CO., INC.

LRC N-310 LRC REC.

NO. N-37031

BAGUIO & BENGUET

ISABEL VDA DE BONGHANOY , ET. AL. VS . SPS. SILVINIA O. YGOT &

ANTONIO YGOT, ET. AL.

CFI – LAPU-LAPU CITY, CEBU

MOISES B. NALOS, ET. AL. VS. EUFRAIME LIWANAG, ET. AL.

ROSALES, PANGASINAN


COURT OF APPEALS SC


LOC. (Page)

COURT OF ORIGIN


NATURE OF CASE

648 244 CV 54560 06/29/79 07/24/79 05/28/80 16255 IV

649 245 CV 54617 03/31/80 AFFIRMED 04/30/80 06/19/80 9247 II

650 618 CV 54644 06/25/80 AFFIRMED 09/18/80 *NDA DC-03

651 246 CV 54720 12/08/78 ORDERED 02/02/78 11/27/78 1892

652 617 CV 54721 10/26/77 AFFIRMED 02/28/78 11/21/78 406-CC SAMAR

653 246 CV 54741 12/02/77 DISMISSED 01/03/78 11/17/78 66225 MANILA

654 247 CV 54766 06/26/80 AFFIRMED 07/24/80 09/29/80 7855

655 617 CV 54774 05/26/78 SET ASIDE 06/26/78 11/24/78 7418

656 616 CV 54835 01/13/78 AFFIRMED 02/02/78 11/21/78 E-01298 JDRC – MANILA

657 615 CV 54883 08/12/77 AFFIRMED 02/09/78 11/21/78 3556

658 615 CV 54942 08/28/80 DISMISSED 08/28/80 09/16/80 1037-O V LEYTE, ORMOC

659 614 CV 54988 02/19/80 AFFIRMED 05/09/80 11/11/80 88171 XXII CFI – MANILA

660 549 CV 55107-R PP. VS. L. ESCAÑO & CO., INC. 04/10/80 AFFIRMED 05/07/80 06/26/80 R-10010 I CFI – CEBU CITY

661 614 CV 55115 05/09/80 AFFIRMED *NDA *NDA 607-M (14426) CFI – RIZAL

662 248 CV 55128 06/23/80 AFFIRMED 07/21/80 10/06/80 226-T

663 613 CV 55139 04/08/80 AFFIRMED 04/30/80 06/19/80 3597 XXX

664 613 CV 55161 01/12/78 AFFIRMED 02/13/78 11/23/78 1995

665 371 CV 55172-R 01/23/78 AFFIRMED 02/15/78 03/27/78 12579 RIZAL, PASIG

666 248 CV 55208 07/03/79 AFFIRMED 08/03/79 06/20/80 121-N XI CFI – CEBU CITY

SPS. ANTONIO CORTEZ , ET. AL. VS. SPS. HERNANDEZ DEL ROSARIO, ET.

AL.


CFI – QUEZON CITY

AMADO PARREÑO JR. VS. TROPICAL COMMERCIAL CO., INC.


ANDRESA NUÑEZ VS. NICANOR NUÑEZ, ET. AL.

CFI – CEBU (DANAO CITY )

SPS. JUAN BAYANG & MARGARITA BAYANG VS. BENIGNO BIONG

CFI – SURIGAO CITY

SUPERIOR OF THE FRANCISCAN FATHERS, ET. AL. VS. IRENEO SABARLUZ JALANDONI VDA DE SERRA, ET. AL. V S. HON. RAFAEL M. SALES . ET.

AL. COLUMBIA CAMPAÑA VS. F.S.

SALAZARDAVAO CITY,

DAVAO

A.S. DIAZ ELEC SERVICES INC. VS. NEGROS NAVIGATION CO., INC.


ALICIA ABLAYA, ETC., ET. AL. VS. AMADO CASTILLO, JR.

MUNICIPALITY OF LUBAO PROVINCE OF PAMPANGA VS. ROMANA VDA DE

SEBASTIAN, ET. AL.

CFI – PAMPANGA

(SAN FERNANDO)

AMADOR CATAAG VS. DOLORES CATAYOC

REP. OF THE PHILIPPINES VS. ALBERTO E. PLANAS JR., ET. AL.

JEREMIAS OCAMPO VS. ABELARDO SUBIDO

DOMINGO CONSTANTINO , ET. AL. VS. EULOGIO CONSTANTINO, ET. AL.

CFI – CAGAYAN, TUAO

MONTEPENCIANO N. CASIS VS. BASIC ENGINEERING SERVICES, INC., ETC.,

ET. AL.

CFI – PASAY CITY

FELIPE LOGRONIO VS. HRS. OF JOSE BAYETA, ETC.

CFI – SURIGAO DEL NORTE

JOSE QUIMBO VS. FELIPE LIWANAG SR. & F. LIWANAG ENTERPRISES, IN

C.GERTRUDES OSAYA , ET. AL,. VS.

APOLONIA TUMAKAY, ET. AL.


COURT OF APPEALS SC


LOC. (Page)

COURT OF ORIGIN


NATURE OF CASE

667 234 CV 55255 10/31/79 AFFIRMED 12/07/79 02/08/80 3878 VIII

668 370 CV 55258-R 05/19/80 AFFIRMED 06/30/80 10/02/80 5681

669 369 CV 55278-R ALHAMBRA INDUSTRIES, INC. VS. 05/03/77 AFFIRMED 06/10/78 06/28/79 79306 CFI – MANILA

670 235 CV 55288 03/10/78 AFFIRMED 03/31/78 11/27/78 258-V

671 612 CV 55294 05/30/80 AFFIRMED *NDA *NDA 89305 CFI – MANILA

672 612 CV 55338 07/20/79 AFFIRMED 01/22/80 02/18/80 86246 VIII CFI – MANILA

673 609 CV 55381 04/25/80 AFFIRMED *NDA *NDA 1875

674 236 CV 55397 12/18/79 AFFIRMED 08/10/80 09/23/80 SM-248

675 236 CV 55433 07/05/80 AFFIRMED 05/05/80 06/20/80 89969 XXII CFI – MANILA

676 236 CV 55436-R 06/07/79 AFFIRMED 05/20/80 07/02/80 C-2339 XII

677 236 CV 55440 11/29/76 AFFIRMED 02/18/77 03/16/77 B-863

678 610 CV 55465 08/08/78 MODIFIED 09/02/78 11/24/78 12832 CFI – CEBU CITY

679 610 CV 55523 01/18/78 MODIFIED 02/26/78 07/26/78 06/16/78 Q-16896 RIZAL, Q.C.

680 610 CV 55524 03/07/78 MODIFIED 03/29/78 11/21/78 C-1516

681 611 CV 55572 09/18/80 DENIED *NDA *NDA 11202


683 611 CV 55639 07/26/78 AFFIRMED 08/18/78 11/23/78 2049

684 530 CV 5578 JOSE BERNAL VS. GLICERIA DIMOG 12/27/77 DISMISSED 01/20/78 09/20/78 74-FL-0010

ESTANISLAO GAGNO VS. JULIO BAGAK, ET. AL.

MISAMIS ORIENTAL

(CAGAYAN DE ORO)

GODOFREDO BELEN VS. HERMANO SEYO

CFI – NEGROS ORIENTAL

RAMON A. TORRES VS. BUENAVENTURA RIVERA, ET. AL.

CFI – BULACAN, VALENZUELA

RESURRECCION DE LEON, ETC., ET. AL. VS. TERESITA Y MEDINA

B & B FOREST DEVELOPMENT CORP. VS. VICENTE G. ACABAN, ET. AL.

ROGELIO LAGMAO VS. CORAZON MANTALA, PIE DRAGOSA

CFI – MARINDUQUE

NATIONAL POWER CORP. VS. DELIA SARMIENTO

CFI – BULACAN, STA. MARIA

ABELARDO LUCERO SR. VS. MANILA YELLOW TAXI CAB CO., INC.

RODRIGO PERNIA , ETC., ET. AL. VS. JUANITO SANTOS & JOHN DOE

CFI – CALOOCAN

CITY

ERNESTO DOMINGUEZ , ET. AL. VS. VICTORIA DOMINGUEZ VDA DE

GARCIA

CFI – LAGUNA (BIÑAN)

FOTCHATIC PHIL-INC. VS. LBC AIR CARGO INC.

LILIA F. ERMUBE VS. ROSITA T. FLORES , ET. AL.

CARIDAD VALVIN VDA DE TOWNSEND VS. LEONIDES C. &

ZENAIDA G. ESGUERRA

RIZAL, CALOOCAN

CITY

NUMERIANO CAPISTRANO VS. TOLENTINA LAGMAN VDA DE

CAPISTRANO

CFI - RIZAL, PASIG

WORKMENS INSURANCE CO., INC. VS. BENNETT THELMO, ET. AL.

ROQUE EROJO VS. GREGORIO EROJO, ET. AL.

CFI – ZAMBOANGA

DEL NORTE

JDRC – BAGUIO CITY & BENGUET (LA TRINIDAD)


COURT OF APPEALS SC


LOC. (Page)

COURT OF ORIGIN


NATURE OF CASE

685 237 CV 55786 10/29/79 AFFIRMED 11/21/79 01/28/80 15965 I CFI – PASIG

686 607 CV 55804 03/01/78 SET ASIDE 03/29/78 11/21/78 Q-17599 RIZAL, Q.C.

687 607 CV 55831 09/28/78 SET ASIDE 10/26/78 12/14/78 4047

688 607 CV 55832 06/30/78 AFFIRMED 07/26/78 11/21/78 83499 XXIII MANILA

689 607 CV 55833 06/25/80 AFFIRMED 07/12/80 09/29/80

690 608 CV 55939 07/31/78 MODIFIED 08/30/78 11/17/78 2355

691 608 CV 56018 11/27/80 DISMISSED *NDA *NDA 2438-P VII

692 238 CV 56023 02/27/78 SET ASIDE 03/17/78 11/24/78 13487 XXI PASIG, RIZAL

693 368 CV 56035-R 01/02/79 AFFIRMED 01/20/79 03/06/79 C-2767

694 367 CV 56165-66-R 07/30/80 09/19/80 10/01/80 332-333 CFI – DAVAO

695 295 CV 56228-R 10/14/77 MODIFIED 04/12/78 09/05/78 08/07/78 15394 VI RIZAL

696 605 CV 56271 09/28/79 DISMISSED 02/28/80 07/18/80 V-3248 IV ROXAS CITY

697 239 CV 56299 07/18/80 AFFIRMED 05/12/80 06/20/80 05/12/80 13152 IV CFI – CEBU CITY

698 240 CV 56424 04/28/80 AFFIRMED 05/18/80 07/16/80 18031 II PASIG, RIZAL

699 240 CV 56505 12/28/79 AFFIRMED 05/05/80 06/19/80 05/05/80 1277-O V

700 550 CV 56533-34 10/09/79 AFFIRMED 12/24/79 02/18/80 III

701 241 CV 56666 08/29/80 AFFIRMED 09/23/80 10/06/80 17690 CFI – RIZAL

702 241 CV 56727 05/19/78 SET ASIDE 06/30/79 05/29/80 11361 VI CFI – CEBU CITY

703 606 CV 56738 02/17/78 SET ASIDE 07/08/78 11/23/78 92025 CFI – MANILA

704 230 CV 56804 05/29/78 AFFIRMED 07/07/78 11/27/78 A-850 CFI – ALAMINOS

LEOPOLDO VILLA DIVINA GRACIA , ET. AL. VS. TEODORO COMPOSANO Y

ETERNON & M.D. TRANSIT & TAXI CO., INC.

JESUS R. FERRER JR., ET. AL. VS. VICTOR PASCUAL

ANIANO SALTING, ET. AL. VS. ISMAEL TOLOSA SR., ET. AL.

CFI – LEGASPI CITY, ALBAY

FERNANDO I. SERRANO VS. SAN MIGUEL CORP., EMPLOYEE UNIONREMIGIA USON LAWIS, ET. AL. VS.

THE DIRECTORS OF LANDSD-1376 , N-

44970CFI –

PANGASINAN

RAUL V. NAMOCATCAT, ET. AL. VS. FELICITA LAURIE VDA DE

NAMOCATCAT, ET. AL.

OROQUIETA CITY

CINDEO IMPERIAL, ET. AL. VS. MILAGROS YUJUICO DEL PILAR, ET.

AL.

CFI – RIZAL, PASAY CITY

ANTONIO TUASON JR. VS. FLORENTINO FORTUNO

YABUT TRANSPORT SYSTEM, INC. VS. MANUEL GREGORIO CAMUS & SONS,

INC.

CALOOCAN CITY

ANDRES BERNARDOS, VS. ELENA FLORES

AFFIRMED IN TOTO

CERILA F. MORALES, ET. AL. VS. PANGASINAN TRANSPORTATION CO.,

INC. ( VTRANCO)FILEMON ARABIA, ET. AL. VS. DAMACENA UMITEN, ET. AL.

CATHAT HARDWARE VS. MARITIME COMPANY OF THE PHILIPPINES A.S.

VELASQUEZJOVITA RELOVA , ET. AL. VS. RUSTAN

SUPERMARKET, INC.INOCENTES MALINAO VS. FAUSTINO

VILLO, ET. AL.CFI – ORMOC CITY, LEYTE

DAMIAN TORRES VS. HRS. OF MANUEL LLAGAS, ET. AL.

108-M & 110-M


JOSE Z. OLEDAN VS. TROPICAL DSITRIBUTORS , INC.

GENERAL BANK &TRUST CO., INC. VS. SPS. DOMINGO CHIA , ET AL

PACIENCIA BOLOS, ET. AL. VS. MARINA D. MIJARES , ET. AL.

SALVADOR U. BRHAGANZA VS. ANTONIO C. REYES


COURT OF APPEALS SC


LOC. (Page)

COURT OF ORIGIN


NATURE OF CASE

705 604 CV 56859 05/05/80 AFFIRMED 05/31/80 07/16/80 12371 XIII PASIG, RIZAL

706 230 CV 56861 01/19/78 DISMISSED 05/24/78 11/27/78 87093 CFI – MANILA


708 551 CV 56883-R 06/23/78 AFFIRMED 10/20/78 12/14/78 82426 CFI – MANILA


710 604 CV 56949 07/17/78 AFFIRMED 10/25/78 12/14/78 M-235

711 317 CV 57019 12/29/77 AFFIRMED 01/25/78 11/24/78 17412 XXXVI MAKATI

712 317 CV 57034 04/27/78 AFFIRMED 05/26/78 11/17/78 H-94-O 41891 OLONGAPO CITY

713 317 CV 57040 03/03/77 AFFIRMED 04/04/77 09/19/77 590

714 317 CV 57113 05/17/78 DENIED 06/09/78 11/17/78 13572 CEBU CITY

715 231 CV 57181 10/17/78 AFFIRMED 11/10/78 01/02/78 Q-19146 RIZAL

716 602 CV 57308 07/28/78 DISMISSED 08/24/78 11/23/78 5632

717 232 CV 57342 12/06/79 AFFIRMED 03/29/80 07/07/80 O-17247 XVIII


719 552 CV 57367-R 07/18/80 AFFIRMED 08/16/80 10/30/80 3288 CFI – ALBAY



722 233 CV 57451 DANTE CRUZ VS. RUBEN CRUZ 07/18/78 AFFIRMED 08/05/78 11/27/78 N-2142 (1567) CFI – CAVITE

723 233 CV 57463 02/23/79 AFFIRMED 03/18/79 09/14/79 07/20/79 201 III CFI- SORSOGON

GREGORIO ABELLA, ET. AL. VS. FRANCISCO GUBALLA, ET. AL.

BAWDEN DRILLING INTRNATIONAL LTD. VS. SOUTH EASTERN SIERRA

MADRE RESOURCES, INC.DEOGRACIA M. LABRA VS.

FLORENCIO LORO JR., ET. AL.THE HOME INSURANCE COMPANY

VS. MARITIME CO. OF THE PHILIPPINES & EASTERN

BROKERAGE CO., INC.PEOPLE'S BANK & TRUST COMPANY

VS. FELISA GUTIERREZCIRPIANA LORENZO, ET. AL. VS. HONORIO FULGENCIO, ET. AL.

MAMBUSAO, CAPIZ

CHEMICAL INDUSTRIES OF THE PHIL. VS. MARIBOJOC AZCUETA

MERCHANDISING CO., ET. AL.LORETA L. RAZON VS. DIRECTOR OF

LANDS, ET. AL.FELICIANO SOLANO, ET. AL. VS. BALTAZAR REMONDE, ET. AL.


JOSE LAPUT SR., ET. AL. VS. ANGELES ELIZONDO

INTEGRATED CREDIT CORP. VS. ANTONIO QUIQUE, ET. AL.

VICTOR ARAGONES VS. MIGUEL CATAN

NEGROS ORIENTAL

(DUMAGUETE CITY )

TAGUMPAY UNITED NEIGHBORHOOD ASSOC., INC. VS. PEOPLE HOMESITE & HOUSING

CORP., ET. AL.

CFI – QUEZON CITY

ST. PAUL FIRE & MARINE INSURANCE VS. MANILA LIGHTER

TRANSPORTATION , INC.FIDELA DE VITERBO, ETC. ET. AL. VS.

MARIANO DE VITERBOASSOCIATED BANKING CORP. VS.

JUAN M. SALANG, ET. AL.SANTIAGO SY YUCO INC. VS.

UNIVERSITY PHYSICIANS SERVICE INC.

ANDRES GUARDIAN VS. LINO ALINDONGAN, ET. AL.


COURT OF APPEALS SC


LOC. (Page)

COURT OF ORIGIN


NATURE OF CASE

724 603 CV 57481 07/19/78 AFFIRMED 09/20/78 11/23/78 16753 XXVI RIZAL, PASIG

725 603 CV 57504 07/19/78 AFFIRMED 08/13/78 11/24/78 R-13940 CEBU CITY

726 603 CV 57515 02/15/78 AFFIRMED 06/16/78 11/17/78 10/16/78 16314 PASIG, RIZAL

727 282 CV 57518 07/15/77 AFFIRMED 08/05/77 12/07/77 N-917-V

728 552 CV 57544-R 01/31/78 AFFIRMED 06/20/78 12/06/78 R-1695


730 282 CV 57549 09/01/78 AFFIRMED 11/23/78 12/15/78 C-68 PAMPANGA

731 282 CV 57608 03/25/80 11/23/79 AFFIRMED 04/07/80 07/24/80 R-12352 XI CFI – CEBU

732 603 CV 57614 11/29/77 AFFIRMED 01/09/78 11/24/78 OZ-338 OZAMIS CITY

733 603 CV 57638 04/03/78 04/21/78 11/21/78 9857

734 283 CV 57668 01/27/78 AFFIRMED 02/19/78 12/15/78 4919

735 600 CV 57683 10/24/80 09/15/80 AFFIRMED *NDA *NDA 76193 CFI – MANILA

736 600 CV 57725 11/12/79 AFFIRMED 01/28/80 02/18/80 378-G IV

737 600 CV 57758 06/22/79 AFFIRMED 11/16/79 01/09/80 297 V CFI – SAMAR


739 601 CV 57802 LA FUERZA INC. VS. YU TIONG 06/01/78 MODIFIED 06/25/78 11/27/78 2928

740 284 CV 57854 12/03/79 AFFIRMED 01/03/80 02/18/80 78-T III

741 601 CV 57875 04/30/80 AFFIRMED 08/29/80 09/29/80 3771 I

742 598 CV 57945 07/28/80 AFFIRMED 08/29/80 10/30/80 4164

743 598 CV 57968 11/27/79 AFFIRMED 12/28/79 02/11/80 II-140(1576) II

744 361 CV 58041-42 05/02/78 05/02/78 11/28/78 427 & 443

ZENAIDA LARIOSA-JACINTO VS. ARSENIO FLORES & LUZ DE LEON

ROSARIO ALQUILOS, ETC., ET. AL. VS. ARTEMIO VILLAMOR

MARY YOAKUM GUEVARRA VS. VICENTE GUEVARRA DE PELAGALLO,

ETC., ET. AL.FELICIANO B. JACINTO VS.

DIRECTOR OF LANDSVALENZUELA,

BULACANCECILIO CASTILLO W/ WIFE

MERCEDES EWAY DE CASTILLO VS. LEONCIO UY & ARSENIO CASILI,

MARTINA GRACE

CFI – MAASIN SOUTHERN

LEYTE

LEO PENALA SR. VS. SAN CARLOS HOSPITAL INC.

MARIANO VITUG VS. NATIONAL POWER CORP.

CEBU OXYGEN & ACETYLENE COMPANY INC. VS. JOHNSON

HARDWARE & AUTO SUPPLY, ET. AL.LORENZO JALALON VS. MERCEDES R.

ROCHA, ET. AL. WELLINGTON C. SOONG VS. GALO AGUÑA JR., MONSERRAT AGUÑA &

ROBERTO SIY

RESOLVED TO DISMISS

CFI - RIZAL, PASIG

ALDRIN ALBALATE , MINOR ASST. BY HER FATHER FRANCISCO ALBALATE

VS. BENJAMIN ALCAZAR, ET. AL.


THE HOME INSURANCE COMPANY VS. E. RAZON, INC.

MARCELINO SINOHIN VS. GODOFREDO DAGDAG, ET. AL.

CFI – GUIMBA, NUEVA ECIJA

GUILLERMO OLAES, ET. AL. VS. FELICITAS DE LOS SANTOS

NEW ZEALAND INSURANCE CO., LTD. VS. E. RAZON INC.

CFI – OROQUIETA

RAYMUNDO VILLACETE VS. JOSEFA ALIAS “ROSALIA” GUZMAN, ET. AL.

TUAO, CAGAYAN

ARTURO R. CARLOS VS. SPS. IRAIDO LEGASPI, ET. AL.

BATAAN, BALANGA

JESUS ABEJO VS. CORNELIO YABA, ET. AL.


ANECITA SABAYLE, ET. AL. VS. FRANCISCA SABAYLE, ET. AL.

CFI – ILIGAN CITY

LUIS SANCHEZ, ET. AL. VS. DAMIAN LOMOSCO,ET. AL.



COURT OF APPEALS SC


LOC. (Page)

COURT OF ORIGIN


NATURE OF CASE

745 361 CV 58048-R 07/14/78 REVERSED 05/05/80 07/31/80 05/05/80 II-122-(1503) II

746 553 CV 58049-R 02/23/77 SET ASIDE 05/12/77 03/27/78 8299 DAVAO CITY

747 599 CV 58050 12/29/78 AFFIRMED 01/22/79 03/14/79 958 CFI – AKLAN

748 599 CV 58060 07/02/79 AFFIRMED 11/30/79 02/07/80 U-2385 V

749 285 CV 58242 07/06/78 AFFIRMED 08/02/78 11/24/78 OZ-437

750 285 CV 58248 05/26/78 AFFIRMED 08/28/78 12/05/78 OZ-254

751 285 CV 58261 05/31/79 AFFIRMED 02/06/80 03/20/80 02/06/80 1356-O II

752 285 CV 58267 08/10/79 04/02/79 AFFIRMED 12/03/79 01/24/80 12/03/79 R-12843 CFI – CEBU

753 285 CV 58274 06/18/80 AFFIRMED 07/26/80 10/06/80 87710 XVI CFI – MANILA

754 285 CV 58293 04/27/78 AFFIRMED 05/21/78 11/27/78 11-EG CFI – LA UNION

755 286 CV 58299 03/28/80 MODIFIED 04/23/80 07/02/80 R-83 II

756 595 CV 58333 07/25/78 AFFIRMED 08/18/78 11/24/78 586 CFI – SILAY CITY

757 554 CV 58349-R 01/06/78 DISMISSED 01/06/78 11/17/78 89955 VIII MANILA

758 286 CV 58369 10/22/79 AFFIRMED 11/16/79 01/11/80 908 II

759 596 CV 58429 07/05/78 AFFIRMED 08/25/78 11/21/78 10/11/78 93884 CFI – MANILA


761 596 CV 58465 10/07/80 *NDA *NDA 349

762 287 CV 58516 08/25/80 AFFIRMED 09/18/80 11/19/80 2264 CFI – SORSOGON

HILARION T. FELICIANO & SON'S INC. VS. TEOFILO CADELANZA

CFI – ILIGAN CITY, LANAO DEL NORTE

BIENVENIDO RAS & SALVACION RAS VS. MARIO GAVARRA & BEATRIZ

GAVARRACANDIDA PARCO, ET. AL. VS.

ANASTACIO PARCOLELIS V. OLARTE & NUMERIANO M. VINLUAN VS. DIOSDADO ILPINDO &

FELICIDAD VILLANUEVA

VILLASIS, PANGSINAN

NUMERIANO NAVARRO, ET. AL. VS. PEDRO PAROJINOG JR., ET. AL.

MISAMIS OCCIDENTAL

JOSE ALIA VS. JOSE A. MORALES, ET. AL.

CFI – OZAMIS CITY

IRENEO BONDOC VS. ERASMO ALVAREZ

OLONGAPO CITY, ZAMBALES

COLUMBIAN MOTORS CORP. VS. MANUEL ASTORGA

NORTHERN LINES INC. VS. PIO TORRES & HARBOR PILOTS ASSOC.

OF DAVAO CITYFRANCISCO G. JOAQUIN JR. V S.

BENITO DUMO. ET. AL.

CLARA B. RESTUA , REP. BY GRACIANO RESTUA & ALFREDO BERNARDO VS. PRISCILLA REY

ORIENTAL MINDORO

(PINAMALAYAN)

LEONARDO HERNAEZ VS. PEDRO C. HERNAEZ

DEVELOPMENT INSURANCE & SURETY CORP. VS. LUZON

STEVEDORING CORP., ET. AL.

ROSARIO VDA DE OPERIANO, ET. AL. VS. RESTITUTO SARTIN, ET. AL.

CFI – SAN JOSE, ANTIQUE

GEN. BANK & TRUST CO. VS. SIBAGAT TIMBER CORP., TENG SU TIOK &

JORGE BARRETONOLAN CHULVO Y FINEZA, ET. AL.

VS. ANTONIO GORDON, ET. AL.HRS. OF RUFO LAMIGO REP. BY

JUANA BAGWASAN DE LAMIGO , LUIS LAMIGO & FELICISIMA LAMIGO VS.

NICOSTRATO LOGNORIO

RESOLVE TO DENY


MARIO G. FORTES VS. EMILIO B. BAYONA


COURT OF APPEALS SC


LOC. (Page)

COURT OF ORIGIN


NATURE OF CASE

763 288 CV 58551 09/29/77 AFFIRMED 10/16/77 12/19/77 Q-18539 XVI

764 288 CV 58554 12/12/78 AFFIRMED 05/16/80 06/20/80 05/16/80 9974 II

765 597 CV 58574 04/25/78 MODIFIED 06/29/78 11/21/78 96487 MANILA

766 360 CV 58583-R 08/04/77 AFFIRMED 01/02/78 12/29/79 10/13/78 4990

767 589 CV 58642 07/20/79 AFFIRMED 10/06/79 02/12/80 8652 III ILOILO CITY

768 265 CV 58696 10/31/79 AFFIRMED 12/13/79 02/08/80 257 X

769 589 CV 58729 11/28/79 AFFIRMED 12/21/79 02/01/80 SC-1148 II

770 265 CV 58794 06/13/80 DISMISSED 07/19/80 09/29/80 IV-94 IV CFI – ISABELA



773 266 CV 58958 05/21/80 AFFIRMED 06/13/80 07/16/80 6278

774 591 CV 58964 09/08/77 AFFIRMED 09/30/77 11/21/78 SCC-348

775 591 CV 59001 07/11/78 08/09/78 11/21/78 2490

776 592 CV 59054 10/11/77 02/07/78 11/17/78 08/07/78 4229

777 310 CV 59065 03/05/80 AFFIRMED 04/15/80 05/30/80 08/27/80 286-T IX

778 267 CV 59130 08/21/78 09/24/78 11/27/78 511-O

779 592 CV 59139 12/06/79 AFFIRMED 12/30/79 02/07/80 2452 IV

780 593 CV 59190 05/25/78 AFFIRMED 07/13/78 11/21/78 19265 CFI – RIZAL

JUANITO CANLAS VS. GLICERIA RAMOS & JAIME VILLARTA

QUEZON CITY, RIZAL

PLACIDA PINGA, ET. AL. VS. DELFIN PINGA, ET. AL.


THE PHILIPPINE GUARANTY CO., INC. VS. BLUE SEA LINE & A.

SORIANO CORP. &/OR E.RAZON INC.VICENTE BRECIO, ET. AL. VS. JESUS

TECSON, ET. AL.TACLOBAN,

LEYTE

ALFREDO VILLARICO, ET. AL. VS. ALFREDO VALENCIA, ET. AL.

ANATOLIO REBELLIZA VS. RAFAEL NADONZA

CFI – MATI, DAVAO

ORIENTAL

BASILIA ARANZA, ET. AL. VS. MARCARIA RANCAP CORDULA

CFI – STA. CRUZ, LAGUNA

GRACIANO MARTIN VS. JOSE MACADANGDANG

SANTIAGO SYJUCO INC. DOING BUSINESS UNDER THE TRADE NAME

OF 7-UP BOTTLING CO. OF THE PHILIPPINES VS. VICTOR BADILLA,

ET. AL.ISABEL FERNANDEZ MORALES VS.

ANGEL L. BAUTISTA CAYETANO DE BORJA , ETC., ET. AL.

VS. LEONCIA A. DIZON, ET. AL.CFI – NUEVA

ECIJA

PEDRO ABAGAT, ET. AL. VS. SPS. JUANA MIJARES & FELIX CASINGAL,

ET. AL.

SAN CARLOS CITY,

PANGASINAN

ALFREDO GARCIA JR. LINER INC. VS. EDUARDO SAMSON, MAHARLIKA

INSURANCE CO., INC.


RIZAL, CALOOCAN

CITY

FILEMON DISALAN VS. ALFREDO CAVETAS & AUREA A. CARRETAS


CAGAYAN DE ORO

ATLAS CONSOLIDATE MINING & DEV. CORP. VS. PATRICIO DELA CERNA

CFI – CEBU, TOLEDO CITY

DEMETRIO TAMAYO VS . FELIZARDO LUCES, ET. AL.

RESOLVE TO DISMISS

CFI – OLONGAPO

CITY

PROCESO J. AREVALO VS. PANGASINAN TRANSPORTATION

COMPANY (PANTRANCO), ET. AL.


TRIUNFO SY VS. ABOITIZ SHIPPING CORP.


COURT OF APPEALS SC


LOC. (Page)

COURT OF ORIGIN


NATURE OF CASE

781 593 CV 59209 01/18/78 AFFIRMED 04/12/78 11/24/78 10/20/78 96287 MANILA

782 593 CV 59223-R 09/14/79 AFFIRMED 10/11/79 01/09/80 14004 XI CFI – CEBU

783 268 CV 59243 10/11/78 DISMISSED 11/04/78 12/15/78 B-0175

784 555 CV 59260-R 11/09/78 AFFIRMED 01/26/79 03/14/79 08/20/79 Q-16081 IX


786 594 CV 59375 09/24/79 AFFIRMED 10/12/79 01/02/80 8936 IV

787 309 CV 59397 08/16/78 AFFIRMED 10/03/78 12/05/78 3724 CFI – BATAAN

788 581 CV 59459 11/16/79 AFFIRMED 12/17/79 02/14/80 11487 IV

789 581 CV 59463 06/20/79 REVERSED 11/14/79 02/07/80 2175 I

790 309 CV 59483 05/02/80 05/25/80 11/12/80 07/31/80 R-11681 CFI – CEBU

791 581 CV 59520 02/29/80 AFFIRMED 04/08/80 04/30/80 OZ-391 II

792 582 CV 59563 11/29/79 AFFIRMED 09/08/80 10/30/80 6518

793 308 CV 59566 12/13/79 AFFIRMED 11/08/79 01/11/80 233 VI

794 308 CV 59622 02/12/79 MODIFIED 06/11/79 10/28/80 12/10/79 13555 CFI – CEBU

795 269 CV 59626 07/05/78 AFFIRMED 08/05/78 11/17/78 10 BASILAN

796 583 CV 59728 07/26/78 08/24/78 11/24/78 2491 DIPOLOG CITY

797 270 CV 59803 *NDA *NDA *NDA 07/10/80 13735 XV CFI – CEBU

798 270 CV 59828 08/03/78 AFFIRMED 08/26/78 11/24/78 2743-V ILOCOS SUR

799 271 CV 59891 11/13/79 AFFIRMED 12/19/79 02/08/80 94713 VIII MANILA

800 271 CV 59943 08/11/78 AFFIRMED 09/06/78 12/14/78 1357

HERMAN “HAP” PARSONS VS. CONSOLIDATED TERMINAL INC.

TERESITA JADULOS VS. WESTERN JADULOS, WESTERN BROADCASTING

SERVIVORS, INC.

MARGARITA BACOLOD VS. CRISPULO PRUDENCIADO

LEYTE (TACLOBAN

CITY)

LAUREANO GRUEZO, ET. AL. VS. ARCADIO MARCELO

CFI – QUEZON CITY

GAUDENCIO LACAMRA, ET. AL. VS. ARCA TRANSPORTATION CORP., ET.

AL.DIOSCORO GUMABAN, ET. AL. VS.

BENITO SALANIO, ET. AL.CFI – ILOILO

CITY

TOMAS FLORES, ET. AL. VS. NAGARIO SAN DIEGO

ERNESTO MONTINOLA, ET. AL. VS. SALUSTIANO MAGALLANES, ET. AL.

CFI – NEGROS OCCIDENTAL

AARON J & STOCKBROKERS VS. ANTONIO AGPAOA


MARCIANA V. YBAÑEZ, ET. AL. VS. THE MERCANTILE INSURANCE CO.,

INC., ET. AL.

REVERSED & RENDERED

DIONISIO ABEJUELA VS. CANUTA DE LEON, ET. AL.

MISAMIS OCC. OZAMIS CITY

DIONISIO GAÑON VS. ANANIAS AVENIR, ET. AL.

CFI – ILOILO CITY

GERARDO A. PABELLO VS. BROTHERS & SISTERS OF MELECIO SALAS

CFI – GUIUAN, EASTERN SAMAR

MARCIANA O. BASCON, ET. AL. VS. DIRECTOR OF LANDS

POLICARPIO HUGO, ET. AL. VS. JESUS HUGO

JOSE BERNARDO ET. AL. VS. ANACLETO Q. OLVIS

WITHDRAWN

ONESIMO PITOGO, ET. AL. VS.DAMIAN NALING, ET. AL.

GUILLERMA USITA VDA DE BONDOC VS. JUANITO HUGO, ET. AL.

FELIX BERNALDEZ JR., ETC., ONG TIAO SENG VS. ONG TIAO SENG, ETC.,

ET. AL., FILIPINO MERCHANTS INSURANCE

BENGUET CONSOLIDATED, INC. VS. SEGUNDO MONANG, ET. AL.

CFI – BAGUIO CITY, BAGUIO &

BENGUET


COURT OF APPEALS SC


LOC. (Page)

COURT OF ORIGIN


NATURE OF CASE

801 271 CV 59991 07/13/78 SET ASIDE 08/23/78 11/17/78 925 BANGUED, ABRA

802 540 CV 60067-R 11/10/81 AFFIRMED 12/04/81 03/29/82 XVI

803 355 CV 60081-R 07/30/80 AFFIRMED NDA NDA IX-Q-10047

804 355 CV 60092-R 12/14/77 12/19/77 12/07/78 5216 X

805 584 CV 60225 07/20/79 10/12/79 02/07/80 R-13799 XIV CEBU CITY

806 272 CV 60259 09/29/78 SET ASIDE 01/12/79 02/07/80 12/17/79 271-B IV


808 358 CV 60410-R 01/05/79 MODIFIED 01/25/79 03/07/79 91963 MANILA

809 585 CV 60497 11/16/77 12/12/77 06/05/78 209-L LAPULAPU CITY

810 585 CV 60530 03/03/80 AFFIRMED 03/28/80 04/30/80 Q-16157 IV QUEZON CITY

811 273 CV 60546 08/20/79 AFFIRMED 09/21/79 02/07/80 190-BC VII CFI – CEBU

812 273 CV 60663 11/12/79 AFFIRMED 12/14/79 01/28/80 921 II CFI – PALAWAN

813 274 CV 60713 07/31/78 AFFIRMED 10/06/78 11/28/78 0313

814 541 CV 60732-R 03/28/78 DISMISSED 04/19/78 11/17/78 11688 RIZAL

815 274 CV 60796 05/08/80 AFFIRMED 08/16/80 10/02/80 84912 XXV CFI – MANILA

816 586 CV 60861 03/10/80 AFFIRMED 04/05/80 05/07/80 Q-19321 IX CFI – RIZAL

817 274 CV 60913 07/20/78 AFFIRMED 09/23/78 06/20/80 03/31/80 Q-18874 XVII

818 275 CV 60970 01/24/78 DISMISSED 02/18/78 12/26/78 Q-15103 RIZAL, Q.C.

819 587 CV 60988 07/11/77 GRANTED 07/27/77 12/19/77 C-19502 XVI RIZAL, Q.C.

820 587 CV 61009 03/21/80 REVERSED 08/14/80 12/09/80 20695 XXII CFI – RIZAL

821 587 CV 61011 11/29/78 AFFIRMED 06/17/79 01/08/80 12/04/79 15130 II

HRS. DIONISIA DOMINGUEZ VS. JUSTA VDA DE BARROGA, ET. AL.

MILAGROS SARABIA, ET. AL. VS. BO METISEN

CFI – QUEZON CITY

REINALDO S. GONZALES VS. IDDECAR INC.

QUEZON CITY, RIZAL

POMPEYO V. TAN VS. FRANCISCO S. ISIDRO, ET. AL.

WITHDRAWN

TACLOBAN CITY (LEYTE)

LUCIA CABRAS DEL MUNDO, ET. AL. VS. TEOPISTA R. PACANA, ET. AL.


PILAR L. RUSTIA & ANICIA L. RUSTIA VS. ERLINDA L. FRANCIA , ET. AL.

BULACAN, BALIWAG

THE CONSOLIDATED BANK & TRUST CORP. VS. HENRY UY, ETC.

THE HOME INSURANCE COMPANY VS. THE EVERET ORIENT LINES, ET.

AL. , ILDEFONSO TIONLOC, INC.CIRILO TUMULAK, ET. AL. VS. LYDIA

MONTEFALCONRESOLVE TO

DISMISS

NIEVES VDA DE ASTUDILLO VS. PEOPLES HOMESITE & HOUSING

CORP. & JULIO DE VERAREGINA C. DE ALACRITO, ET. AL. VS.

EUFROCINA ZABALA, ET. AL.EDGARDO SORCA ARIAS VS. VILMA

MAGALONAIn the MATTER OF THE PROBATE OF

THE WILL OF JANUARIA APAT VS. BASILIO TONGCO, ETC., ET. AL.

CFI -OZAMIS CITY

FE REYES VS. MARIKINA BUS, INC., ET. AL.

PHIL. TANNERT COMPANY, INC. VS. E. RAZON

VIRGILIO VILLANUEVA VS. JACINTO BUNDANG, ETC., ET. AL.

JOSE T. BARTOLOME VS. CONRADO F. ESTRELLA, ET. AL.

CFI – QUEZON CITY

ADALIA FRANCISCO-ROBLES VS. PANTALEON TABORA, ETC.

CECILIO B.R. BUENAFE VS. MUN. JUDGE MOISESA. ALIP

TRANS-PACIFIC STEEL INDUSTRIES INC. VS. VENUSTO DEL ROSARIO,

ETC., ET. AL.NOBERTO V. ZARATE SR., ET. AL. VS.

MARCELINO B. AQUINO, ET. AL.CFI –

PANGASINAN


COURT OF APPEALS SC


LOC. (Page)

COURT OF ORIGIN


NATURE OF CASE

822 587 CV 61026 05/23/78 AFFIRMED 06/30/78 11/21/78 10/16/78 569-V CFI – BULACAN

823 276 CV 61044 05/02/79 AFFIRMED 05/25/79 10/22/79 R-2476

824 588 CV 61247 08/26/77 10/02/77 12/21/77 960

825 357 CV 61276-R PATRICIO SIBE VS. PABLO CUA 07/02/79 AFFIRMED 06/18/80 07/29/80 525

826 571 CV 61357 09/04/80 *NDA *NDA 77644 VIII *NDA

827 571 CV 61431-R 07/09/79 SET ASIDE 05/05/80 06/18/80 05/05/80 D-2989 XII CFI – DAGUPAN

828 311 CV 61545 12/27/79 AFFIRMED 02/02/80 02/19/80 19736 I

829 311 CV 61604 05/17/78 SET ASIDE 07/08/78 11/17/78 654 NAIC, CAVITE


831 294 CV 61635-36 08/10/79 MODIFIED 01/08/80 01/11/80 26&27

832 572 CV 61685 10/23/79 AFFIRMED 01/12/80 02/08/80 R-296 I

833 312 CV 61687 07/26/78 RESOLVED 07/26/78 11/24/78 3873

834 312 CV 61719 07/18/78 GRANTED 07/18/78 12/05/78 1658

835 572 CV 61736 05/31/79 REVERSED 12/23/79 02/18/80 1830 II

836 312 CV 61748 05/21/80 DENIED *NDA 07/15/80 06/13/80 Q-18834 IX

837 573 CV 61806 08/30/78 RENDERED 08/30/78 11/27/78 4238

838 356 CV 61832-R 03/31/81 AFFIRMED 05/07/81 06/22/81 D-1483 PANGASINAN

839 542 CV 61836-R 08/10/78 DISMISSED 09/07/78 11/03/78 262-L CEBU CITY

840 573 CV 61846 07/31/79 AFFIRMED 10/02/79 02/12/80 2670 II CFI – BOHOL

841 574 CV 62003 06/25/79 AFFIRMED 10/28/79 04/25/80 03/31/80 Q-22198 V CFI – RIZAL

RUBEN ALANO, ET. AL. VS. ARTEMIO JURADO, ET. AL.

REMEDIO ADRIATICO GUBALLA VS. FELIX LOPEZ, ET. AL.

CFI – ORIENTAL MINDORO

TITO LOZADA VS. ELIRIA “NENA” GONZALES, ET. AL.

ABANDONED &

DISMISSED

CFI – GUBAT, SORSOGON


ERLANGER &GALINGER, INC. VS. AGNES BARNES, ET. AL.

AFFIRMED& MODIFIED

URBANO UMAGTANG VS. EMILIO BALLESTEROS, ET. AL.

DOÑA FELIZA VILLAGE HOUSING CORP. VS. LUZON CEMENT CORP.


MACARIA TUAZON, ETC. VS. LAUREANA RAMIREZ CATURA

UNITED PHILIPPINE LINES, INC. VS. NATIONAL DEV. COMPANY

ENRIQUETA E. VDA DE ANTONIO VS. JULIO E. ANTONIO,ETC., ET. AL.

CFI – BASILAN, ISABELA

JESUS C. MASANGKAY , ET. AL. VS. SOTERO TEMPLANZA, ET. AL.

CFI – OCCIDENTAL

MINDORO (MAMBURAO)

MENZI & CO., INC. VS. ROMULO KIONISALA, ET. AL.

MISAMIS ORIENTAL

MAURICIO BARCELONA VS. PEDRO BELARMINO

CFI – ZAMBOANGA

HRS. OF DOLORES LIONG, ET. AL. VS. COSMELITA ROMERO, ET. AL.

ZAMBALES DEL NORTE

(DIPOLOG)

ASTER S. SANTELICES & EUSTAQUIO SANTELICES

CFI – QUEZON CITY

GREGORIO PASION, ET. AL. VS. R.L. TRUCKING INC.

CFI – PAMPANGA

BRIGIDA DOLORES VS. THE DIRECTOR OF LANDS

SOLEDAD SOCO VS. CESARIO SILAWAN, ET. AL.

FLORENTINO MAGLAWAY, ET. AL VS. VICENTE EJOC, ET. AL.

NILO B. PICZON VS. EXALTACION R. GARCIA, ET. AL.


COURT OF APPEALS SC


LOC. (Page)

COURT OF ORIGIN


NATURE OF CASE

842 574 CV 62010 11/26/79 AFFIRMED 04/30/80 06/11/80 04/30/80 442811

843 313 CV 62037 10/10/77 APPROVED 10/20/77 03/17/78 75179 MANILA

844 313 CV 62038 02/18/80 REVERSED 05/23/80 06/11/80 969 II

845 574 CV 62093 05/10/78 07/13/78 11/17/78 2687 BAGUIO CITY

846 314 CV 62251 02/01/79 AFFIRMED 12/03/79 02/14/80 12/03/79 99619 XI CFI – MANILA

847 575 CV 62316 11/23/79 RENDERED 02/13/79 01/09/80 6445 III

848 315 CV 62329 03/27/80 DISMISSED 03/27/80 05/30/80 73-76-M III

849 575 CV 62352-R 11/06/80 AFFIRMED *NDA *NDA 10654

850 315 CV 62362 07/10/79 AFFIRMED 08/04/79 07/18/80 87681 VII MANILA

851 576 CV 62454 10/25/79 AFFIRMED 07/14/80 08/20/80 07/14/80 R-14883 V CFI – CEBU

852 316 CV 62671 04/11/78 05/07/78 12/05/78 IR-523 CFI – IRIGA CITY

853 316 CV 62683 08/03/78 DISMISSED 08/26/78 11/24/78 U-5394-P III PASAY CITY

854 577 CV 62705 07/26/78 DISMISSED 08/16/78 12/07/78 Q-21145

855 577 CV 62745 12/05/79 01/03/80 02/25/80 D-3019 VIII

856 543 CV 62754-R 07/28/78 01/21/79 05/12/80 97328 XV CFI – MANILA

857 296 CV 62781 02/16/78 DISMISSED 05/26/78 12/05/78 (B-22) J-21

858 296 CV 62787 05/25/79 DISMISSED 06/27/79 08/30/79 2560 III

859 296 CV 62793 03/15/78 04/17/78 12/05/78 2143-O

860 578 CV 62839 ARMANDO BITO, ET. AL. VS. R.P. 08/28/78 08/28/78 11/26/78 3435

BENITO PARAGUA, ET. AL. VS. PHILIPPINE RABBIT BUS LINES, INC.,

ET. AL.

CFI – LAOAG CITY

V.C. PONCE INC., MINDANAO PORTLAND CEMENT CORP. VS. LORENZO LAGANDAON, ET. AL.

EUGENIO LABAGAN, ET. AL. VS. MARIA HALL, ET. AL.

CFI – BANGUED, ABRA

CASINGAN OS-OSA VS. DONALD CODMAN, ET. AL.

RESOLVE TO DISMISS

THE HANOVER INSURANCE CO., VS. OYUMA LINE & CITADEL LINES, INC.

LUCITA CAJUCOM, ET. AL. PHILIPPINE COMMERCIAL &

INDUSTRIAL BANK, INC.

CFI – CABANATUAN

CITY

LEONARDO LUSUNG, ET. AL. VS. MAHARLIKA INSURANCE CO., INC.

CFI -SAN FERNANDO, PAMPANGA

GUILLERMO BORJA VS. JOSE DELA PAZ, ET. AL.

CFI - RIZAL, PASIG

RAFAEL BAUTISTA, ET. AL. VS. LEOPOLDO BRUNO

VIRGILIO BAGANO, ET. AL. VS. PRESENTACION VDA DE BAGANO, ET.

AL.LUIS YAP VS. DOMINGA CRESCINE,

ET. AL.RESOLVE TO

DISMISS

HAPPY LANDING INC. VS. ANTONIO E. MORILLA, ET. AL.

PACITA ALCANTARA, ET. AL. VS. JUDGE ALOYSIUS ALBAY, ET. AL.

QUEZON CITY, RIZAL

DAGUPAN CITY RURTAL BANK INC. VS. CARMEN VDA DE TORIO, ET. AL.

RESOLVE TO DISMISS

CFI – DAGUPAN CITY

ZACARIAS AMALINGAN, ET. AL. VS. ISMAEL CAPARAS, ET. AL.

RESOLVE TO DISMISS

ALEJANDRO BAYOG, ET. LA. VS. EUGENIO LAMBERANG

CFI – ILIGAN CITY

CELERINO ORIOLA, ET. AL. VS. LYDIO TAN, ET. AL.

CFI – DIPOLOG CITY

ENRIQUE MAGSAYSAY VS. VICENTE MASAYSAY,ET. AL.

RESOLVE TO DISMISS

CFI – OLONGAPO

CITY

ABANDONED &

DISMISSED

CFI – PANGASINAN

(DAGUPAN CITY)


COURT OF APPEALS SC


LOC. (Page)

COURT OF ORIGIN


NATURE OF CASE

861 579 CV 62949 06/06/78 06/23/78 11/21/78 106314 MANILA

862 580 CV 63060 07/24/80 AFFIRMED 08/21/80 10/02/80 6114-I

863 580 CV 63187 08/14/78 DISMISSED 09/12/78 11/24/78 21780 CFI - PASIG

864 297 CV 63328 06/06/79 DISMISSED 06/27/79 08/29/79 VI

865 353 CV 63332-R 04/14/80 AFFIRMED 05/09/80 06/26/80 Q-12417 IX CFI – RIZAL, Q.C.

866 562 CV 63340 09/10/80 05/30/80 AFFIRMED *NDA *NDA 9281

867 544 CV 63359-R 09/18/78 DISMISSED 10/19/78 12/06/78 10328 CFI – PASIG

868 298 CV 63535 12/06/79 AFFIRMED 06/18/80 07/24/80 06/18/80 6123-II II

869 563 CV 63537-R 11/26/79 DISMISSED 12/30/79 07/18/80 1650 & 1688 I

870 563 CV 63634 12/03/79 DISMISSED 01/12/80 02/25/80 9163 IV

871 299 CV 63762 07/27/79 04/18/80 07/25/80 2389 II

872 564 CV 63769 09/10/80 AFFIRMED 10/01/80 10/30/80 10193 XXXVIII CFI – MANILA

873 564 CV 63828 08/13/79 10/17/79 07/24/80 V-3705 I CFI – CAPIZ

874 352 CV 63844-R 04/14/80 AFFIRMED 05/02/80 06/26/80 X

875 300 CV 64046 03/31/80 AFFIRMED 05/07/80 07/07/80 92-V V

876 300 CV 64068 03/21/80 DISMISSED 04/17/80 06/09/80 109367 XXXI CFI – MANILA

CONTINENTAL BANK VS. ANTONIO CONSING

ABANDONED &

DISMISSED

REMEDIOS DELA CRUZ, ET. AL. VS. PEDRO VALENTIN III

CFI – ILOCOS NORTE, LAOAG

CITY

INVESTORS FINANCE CORP., ETC. VS. KURODA INTERNATIONAL TRADING

CO., INC.

VICENTE G. PUYAT VS. PHIL. NATIONAL RAILWAYS

LAND REG. CASE NO. T-720 LRC REC. NO. N-47205

TAYUG, PANGASINAN

VICENTE BUBAN VS. DOLORES OLA, ET. AL.

ANUNCIACION VDA DE HERNANDEZ, ET. AL. VS. RADIO COMMUNICATION

OF THE PHIL., INC. (RCPI)

CFI – ILOILO CITY

ROSARIO G. MERCADER VS. ARTURO A. GUANZON

ANTONIO YABES VS. ROMAN CATHOLIC BISHOP OF LAOAG,ET. AL.

CFI – ILOCOS NORTE

PEDRO JIMENA VS. SOLEDAD PHELAGO, ETC., ET. AL.

CFI – ZAMBOANGA

DEL SUR

RUTH DIOCARES VS. VILLASON TRANSIT INC.


PROCESO CULANCULAN, ET. AL. VS. VICENTE A. ADAZA,ET. AL.

RESOLVE TO DISMISS

ZAMBOANGA DEL NORTE

(DIPOLOG CITY)

LORENZA VILLALUNA VS. NARCISO TOLENTINO, ET. AL.

CATALINO V. USISON VS. SALOME USISON VDA DELA CRUZ, ET. AL.

RESOLVE TO DISMISS

THE DIRECTOR OF LANDS,ET. AL. VS. HRS. OF CORNELIO ANTOP, REP. BY

BONIFACIO OMPANG, ET. AL.

CAD CASE NO. N-7 LRC REC. NO. N-378 LOT NO.

268

CFI – DAVAO ORIENTAL

VIOLETA S. BUCAO VS. ANDRES SINANG & SERGIA BAAY

CFI – ILOCOS NORTE

FILCAPITAL DEVELOPMENT CORP. VS. ROMEO B. CASTILLO,ET. AL.


COURT OF APPEALS SC


LOC. (Page)

COURT OF ORIGIN


NATURE OF CASE

877 300 CV 64087 06/17/80 REVERSED 07/09/80 07/25/80 6297 I

878 565 CV 64225 10/02/79 11/27/79 07/24/80 SF-169 X CFI – CEBU

879 566 CV 64392 03/18/80 05/21/80 07/25/80 R-14871 II CEBU CITY

880 301 CV 64433 05/24/79 06/14/79 08/30/79 104413 XXXVIII CFI – MANILA

881 302 CV 64529 10/17/79 DISMISSED 11/04/79 06/23/80 20835 I CFI - PASIG

882 302 CV 64545 02/29/80 DISMISSED 03/28/80 06/10/80 R-15970 XV CFI – CEBU CITY

883 302 CV 64552 02/29/80 DISMISSED 03/31/80 06/09/80 916 II

884 567 CV 64642 02/27/80 DISMISSED 04/03/80 06/10/80 C-6127 XXXIII

885 303 CV 64834 02/29/80 DISMISSED 04/07/80 06/09/80 1504 VI CFI – CEBU CITY

886 303 CV 64837 04/14/81 DENIED *NDA *NDA 10098 III CFI – MANILA

887 304 CV 64977 03/21/80 DISMISSED 04/13/80 06/09/80 602 I

888 568 CV 65013 02/19/80 RESOLVED 03/20/80 06/10/80 741 XX

889 569 CV 65306 05/22/80 DISMISSED 06/15/80 07/25/80 8228 VII

890 305 CV 65335 11/29/79 GRANTED 11/29/79 02/08/80 III

891 570 CV 65397 04/29/80 GRANTED 04/29/80 05/30/80 117-O III

892 305 CV 65462 02/28/80 DISMISSED 03/26/80 06/10/80 A-907 VII

893 305 CV 65499 03/12/80 DISMISSED 04/06/80 07/25/80 43-L III

894 305 CV 65517 03/26/80 DISMISSED 04/18/80 06/09/80 5281 V

895 306 CV 65676 03/18/80 GRANTED 03/18/80 06/10/80 18246 VI CFI – MANILA

MODESTA TANGUNAN VIERNES VS. ESPERANZA GONZALES VDA DE

BALINTAG

CABANATUAN CITY, NUEVA

ECIJA

SOLEDAD ALVARO, ET. AL. VS. DAMIANO ALVARO, ET. AL.

RESOLVE TO DISMISS

SILVINO MACEREN JR., ET. AL. VS. MARLINDA APANTO, ET. AL.

RESOLVE TO DISMISS

SOCORRO L. DE LIBORO,ETC. VS. FLORENCIO BRIONES

ABANDONED &

DISMISSED

DELTA MOTOR SALES CORP. VS. OSCAR IBAY,ET. AL.

HUGO UN, ET. AL. VS. MARINA CORTES

SOTERO GULLON VS. LEONARDO SANCHEZ, ET. AL.

CFI – GUBAT, SORSOGON

RICARDO MARIANO VS. ANTONIO RODRIGUEZ, ET. AL.

CFI – CALOOCAN

CITY

ANDREW P. SHERFAN VS. CRISTOBAL GASTARDO

PEDRO EGUIA, ET. AL. VS. GUILLERMA CREER,ET. AL.

CELESTINO DE BORJA, ETC. VS. ELADIO BAES, ET. AL.

CFI – NAIC, CAVITE

RITA GARCIANO VS. CESAR PACULANANG SR.

CFI – TAGUM, DAVAO

ALLEN ULYSSES OROZOO, ETC., ET. AL. VS. ALFREDO AMERICA

LUCENA CITY, QURZON

SEGUNDINA AUSTRIA, ET. AL. VS. DIRECTOR OF LANDS, ET. AL.

LRC NO. (BD) N-324-

V-76

BULACAN, VALENZUELA

RURAL BANK OF OLONGAPO INC. VS. GAUDENCIO AUSTERIO, ET. AL.

CFI – OLONGAPO

CITY

SALVADOR ABAD,ET. AL. VS. EDUARDO ROSETE, ET. AL.

CFI – ALAMINOS, PANGASINAN

FELISA CASTRO Y RAMOS VS. GENEROSO MELO & DEMOCRITO

PESTELOS

BATANGAS, LEMERY

FLORANTE S. QUIZON VS. ANGELES UNIVERSITY, ET. AL.


FILCUZAR TRADING INC. VS. ORTIZ GARCIA MARKETING CORP., ET. AL.


COURT OF APPEALS SC


LOC. (Page)

COURT OF ORIGIN


NATURE OF CASE

896 306 CV 65897 LEONORA MATIC VS. SIXTO CRUZ 03/27/80 DISMISSED 04/24/80 06/09/80 701-B IV

897 354 CV 66263-R 08/11/80 DISMISSED 09/05/80 10/25/80 1085 SORSO GON

898 291 CV UDK-5473 11/04/77 12/25/77 06/05/78 434

899 351 CV UDK-6865 08/07/78 DISMISSED 09/14/78 12/08/78 SF-199 CEBU CITY

900 350 CV UDK-6885 07/31/78 DISMISSED 08/24/78 12/07/78 3721-M

901 545 CV UDK-7174 05/30/79 12/28/79 02/13/80 R-15175 V CFI – CEBU

902 349 CV UDK-7859 07/20/79 DISMISSED 08/22/79 10/25/79 1108 II

903 531 CV UDK-7860 02/19/80 03/15/80 06/19/80 9901 IV

904 546 CV UDK-8000 07/26/79 09/15/79 02/07/80 1115 II CFI – ABRA

905 546 CV 02/21/80 DISMISSED 03/27/80 07/02/80 R-16093 XI CFI – CEBU

906 531 CV UDK-9041 03/14/80 DISMISSED 04/13/80 07/02/80 3089 I

907 531 CV UDK-9061 07/17/80 DISMISSED 08/13/80 10/14/80 4334

908 531 CV UDK-9107 03/07/80 04/10/80 06/19/80 BR-V-376 V

909 531 CV UDK-9260 03/06/80 DISMISSED 04/12/80 06/19/80 11673 IV CFI -D AVAO

910 547 CV UDK-9470 04/18/80 DISMISSED 05/14/80 07/07/80 R-15676 XI CFI – CEBU

911 222 CV UDK-9581 03/06/80 DISMISSED 04/03/80 07/02/80 727-CC IV

912 222 CV UDK-9623 03/11/80 DISMISSED 04/03/80 07/02/80 L-112 II

913 8 SP 04067-R 11/16/78 06/27/78 11/22/78 L-124 II

914 8 SP 04402 02/04/76 AFFIRMED 04/12/80 05/30/80 4252 VIII

915 9 SP 04558 11/24/75 DENIED 11/15/79 01/28/80 89692 XXVIII CFI – MANILA

CFI – BALIWAG, BULACAN

CONCHITA FUNGO , ET. AL. VS. FILEMON FORTE, ET. AL.

AMANDO MARIANITO, ET. AL. VS. SPS. ALEJANDRO & REMEDIOS EROY

RESOLVE TO DISMISS

MATI, DAVAO ORIENTAL

CHRISTOPHER MORRE, ET. AL. VS. CONCORDIA KAREN, ET. AL.

ROSA LAUNDIANGCO,ET. AL. VS. MARTA LOPEZ, ET. AL.

MALOLOS, BULACAN

TEODORICO OBIAL, ET. AL. VS. SPS. PEDRO OBIAL, ET. AL.

ABANDONED &

DISMISSED

CAROLITA SARMIENTO, ET. AL. VS. BENIDICTO BARRIETO, ET. AL.

CFI – ABRA,BANGUED

EDILBERTO BERNARDO, ET. AL. VS. VICTORIA SONALAN, ET. AL.

RESOLVE TO DISMISS

CFI – ILOILO CITY

FRANCISCA B. VILLANUEVA VS. ORLINO C. DACANAY, ET. AL.

RESOLVE TO DISMISS

UDK-8122 & UDK-3730

VALERIANA MONTERO VS. SINCERNITA DOSDOS VDA DE

MONTEGRANDE

JUAN SUAN VS. EXEQUIELA GO, ET. AL.

NEGROS OCC. (OROQUIETA

CITY)

GO TAN CHUA VS. FERNANDO ESCAVILLA, ET. AL.

CFI – ALBAY , TABACCO

AURELIO BABANAL, ET. AL. VS. EUGENIA AGGOLUAN, ET. AL.

RESOLVE TO DISMISS

ECHAGUE, ISABELA

INTEGRATED FEED MILL CORP. (IFMC) VS. BENEDCITA BERMUDEZ,

ET. AL.GAUDENCIO MANCAO JR., ET. AL. VS.

OSCAR BONGCALES, ET. AL.

NARCISA CABUNDOC VS. ISAAC DEAN CALBAYOG, SAMAR

JUANA P. CANAL, ET. AL. VS. GREGORIA CANAL , ET. AL.

SURIGAO DEL SUR (LIANGA)

NICASIO DURAN, ET. AL., VS. HON. OTILIO C. ABAYA, ET. AL.

LIFTED & SET ASIDE

SURIGAO DEL SUR

GLORIA Z. LLAMAS, VS. HON. FRANCISCO DELA ROSA, ET. AL.

CFI – PASAY CITY, RIZAL

ELIGIO ROQUE, ET. AL., VS. HON. CARLOS L. SUNDIAM


COURT OF APPEALS SC


LOC. (Page)

COURT OF ORIGIN


NATURE OF CASE

916 10 SP 05125 07/24/78 AFFIRMED 08/12/78 11/24/78 7476

917 11 SP 05395 03/27/79 DISMISSED 01/21/80 01/25/80 25444 IV CFI – RIZAL

918 12 SP 05722-R 08/24/78 AFFIRMED 09/30/78 11/22/78 7782

919 13 SP 06319 06/16/77 DISMISSED 08/20/77 11/17/78 09/18/78 A-855

920 13 SP 06325 02/22/79 DISMISSED 12/17/79 02/13/80 12/17/79 4318 IV CFI – DAVAO

921 13 SP 06344-R 07/25/78 AFFIRMED 08/16/78 11/22/78 2093 1 CAR – DAVAO

922 13 SP 06421-23 02/15/78 ANNULS 03/05/80 06/18/80 03/05/80 1 CFI – DAVAO

923 13 SP 06432-R 11/28/78 DISMISSED 12/20/78 03/15/79 4407-M VI CFI – BULACAN

924 14 SP 06469-R 05/18/78 AFFIRMED 08/12/78 11/22/78 104063 XVI MANILA

925 15 SP 06638 08/09/77 SET ASIDE 09/01/77 03/17/78 C-4091 XII

926 16 SP 06745 09/13/77 DISMISSED 09/30/77 03/17/78 30924 VIII MANILA

927 17 SP 06908 11/21/77 GRANTED 12/09/77 06/05/78 476 VI

928 18 SP 07042 05/21/80 GRANTED *NDA *NDA 15087 VI CFI – CEBU (*NDA – NO DATA AVAILABLE)

929 19 SP 07092 03/17/78 07/13/78 11/17/78 09/04/78 99535 MANILA

930 20 SP 07176-R 01/17/78 DISMISSED 11/20/78 03/15/79 11/20/78 171802 XXXVII CFI – MANILA

931 21 SP 07285 03/15/78 DISMISSED 05/24/78 11/24/78 11910

932 21 SP 07305 07/10/80 AFFIRMED 08/02/80 11/12/80 254

933 22 SP 07358 04/14/78 DISMISSED 05/10/78 11/27/78 10/05/78 24642 XXI PASIG, RIZAL

934 23 SP 07456 05/16/79 AFFIRMED 06/07/79 02/26/80 1157 1 CAR – CEBU

TEOFILO GOLFE, VS. HON. RAFAEL DELA CRUZ, ET. AL.

CFI – CAMARINES SUR

(NAGA)

PACIENCIA M. INGCO, ETC., ET. AL., VS. HON. RICARDO P. TENSUAN,

ET. AL.HAIDE B. VISTA-GUMBA, VS.

CLEMENTS GATMAITAN, ET. AL.CAMARINES SUR

(NAGA)

DOMINGA AQUINO, ET. AL., VS. HON. MAGNO B. PABLO, ET. AL.

ALAMINOS, PANGASINAN

VICENTE ANTONIO, ET. AL., VS AIDA GIL DAMASO, ET. AL.

AGAPITO PACETES AND ILUMINADA PACETES, VS. NAZARIO OAGAS AND

BASILIA PAGASSPOUSES RAMON LOCSIN & MARIETA AFINIDAD ET. AL., VS. HON. VICENTE

N. CUSI, JR., ET. AL.

9101, 9117, 9124

BENIGNA PASCO, ET. AL., VS. HON. FRANCISCO TAMAYO

ZENAIDA GERCIO, ET. AL., VS. HON. LEOCADIO P. MAGAT, JR., ET. AL.CEFERINO DEMABASA, VS. HON.

FERNANDO A. CRUZ, ETC., ET. AL.CALOOCAN

CITY

MARIANO D. BONDOC, JR., VS. HON. AMANTE P. PURISIMA, ETC., ET. AL.

TOMAS SERRANO, ET. AL., VS. HON. ESTEBAN LISING, ET. AL.

PILI, CAMARINES SUR

CLARENCIO S. YUJUICO, PURIFICACION Z. YUJUICO, VS. HON.

RAFAEL MENDOZA, ETC., ET. AL.VALOR INDUSTRIAL CORP., VS.

CITADEL INSURANCE & SURETY CO., INC, & HON. CARLOS SUNDIAM, ETC.

ET. AL.

LIFTED & SET ASIDE

LEONIDES TUMAGE, VS. HON. BIENVENIDO C. EJERCITO

RENATO T. MAGADALUYO, VS. HON. RAMON B. BRITANICO, ET. AL.

NEGROS OCC. (BACOLOD)

TABACALERA INSURANCE CO., INC., VS. THE INSURANCE COMMISSIONER,

ET. AL.

THE INSURANCE COMMISSIONER

CHINA BANKING CORPORATION, VS. HON. GREGORIO G. PINEDA, ET. AL.

TIBURCIO PARDA, ET. AL., VS. GENOVEVA VILLALON


COURT OF APPEALS SC


LOC. (Page)

COURT OF ORIGIN


NATURE OF CASE

935 23 SP 07459-61 05/26/78 DISMISSED 09/17/78 11/17/78 64-65-93

936 24 SP 07549 05/11/78 DENIED 06/23/78 11/17/78 09/25/78 13345 PASIG, M.M.

937 25 SP 07692-R 08/15/80 AFFIRMED 05/09/80 06/10/80 05/09/80 3583 QC

938 26 SP 07719 04/05/78 DISMISSED 07/18/78 11/27/78 10/09/78 80-M XV RIZAL (MAKATI)

939 26 SP 07732-R 05/24/78 DISMISSED 06/21/78 11/22/78 2812 1

940 27 SP 07750 08/08/78 DISMISSED 09/03/78 11/24/78 23733

941 27 SP 07779 10/30/79 AFFIRMED 11/22/79 01/09/80 3173

942 28 SP 07800-R 07/31/78 DISMISSED 09/05/78 11/22/78 5945-P XXX RIZAL (PASAY)

943 29 SP 07876 09/01/78 DISMISSED 09/28/78 12/07/78 3636-P SAN JOSE

944 29 SP 07884-CAR 02/15/79 DISMISSED 05/15/80 06/25/80 04/16/10 625-38 1

945 30 SP 07906 06/07/78 DENIED 06/24/78 11/27/78 009560 MANILA

946 31 SP 07951-R 12/14/78 01/26/79 03/15/79 28031 1

947 289 SP 07995 06/30/78 DENIED 07/26/78 11/27/78 *NDA

948 32 SP 07998 08/20/79 DISMISSED 09/07/79 01/25/80 4634-4637 X CFI – MANILA

949 33 SP 08296 07/30/79 DISMISSED 04/01/80 05/16/80 22811 XXXI-B

950 33 SP 08310-R 03/30/79 DENIED 11/30/79 01/07/80 5938 II

951 34 SP 08445-R 08/30/79 AFFIRMED 10/06/79 01/08/80 2390 SSS, Q.C.

MARTA TUMOLVA, ET. AL., VS. HON. COURT OF FIRST INSTANCE, ETC., ET.

AL.

ISABELA (ROXAS)

HRS. OF THE LATE ISIDORA DE MESA, VS. HON. GREGORIO PINEDA, ETC.,

ET. AL.

RAFAEL J. DADIVAS, JR.,. ET. AL., VS. SOCIAL SECURITY SYSTEM

THE COMMISSIO-NER

CLS

ABELARDO DELA ROSA, VS. LEONARDO B. ORENSE, ET. AL.

GELACIO ABAYA, ET. AL., VS. HON. ANGELA DAQUIGAN, ETC., ET. AL.

SAN FERNANDO (LA UNION)

VICTOR MARALIT, VS. JOSEFINA PALO DEE, ET. AL.

RIZAL (QUEZON CITY)

ALFONSA RAMOS MANALO, VS. ADOLFO DE JESUS

THE COMMISSIO-NER

SSS, DILIMAN, (Q.C.)

MARIA LUISA CRUZ, VS. HON. J. CAMPOS, JR.

ONOFRE B. PADOLINA, ET. AL., VS. BENIGNO DE GUZMAN

EMIDIO FLORENTINO, ET. AL., VS. HON. FLORENCIO CABANOS, ET. AL.

CAR – TUGUEGARAO

BUENAVENTURA GALANZA, ET. AL., VS HON. JOSE B. HERRERA, ETC.,

ET. AL.. RODRIGO C. DOMINGO, JR., VS. HON.

E,ILIO V. SALAS, ET. AL.LIFTED &

DISMISSEDCFI – RIZAL

(PASIG)

ROSALINDA SOLIMAN VS. COLONEL GAUDIOSO SOLOMON, ET. AL.

COURT OF APPEALS – MANILA

NATIVIDAD A. SANCHEZ, VS. HON. CELESTINO C. JUAN, ET. AL.

SPS. CORAZON ADVINCULA TIBIRAN & ILUMINADO LIBIRAN, VS. HON. RODOLFO A. ORTIZ & ANTONIO

TYCHANGCO


FEDERICO DE LA CRUZ, VS. HON. CFI 4TH JUDICIAL DIST. BR. II,

CABANATUAN CITY & MANUEL TINIO

CFI – NUEVA ECIJA

ROBERTO SEGAYA, VS. CARLOS YO, ET. AL.


COURT OF APPEALS SC


LOC. (Page)

COURT OF ORIGIN


NATURE OF CASE

952 34 SP 08446 11/13/79 12/26/79 DISMISSED *NDA *NDA 5801 IV

953 34 SP 08446 06/17/80 12/26/79 DISSOLVED 08/14/80 10/15/80 580 IV

954 34 SP 08448 08/19/86 05/07/80 DENIED 08/22/80 11/12/80 6583 XXXV

955 35 SP 08537-R 07/25/79 DISMISSED 09/12/79 01/08/80 26899 V CFI – RIZAL

956 6 SP 08555 03/27/80 AFFIRMED 04/24/80 07/02/80 1

957 6 SP 08556 07/24/79 REVERSED 08/31/79 03/07/80 01/07/80 115366 XIV MANILA

958 6 SP 08576 10/31/79 AFFIRMED 12/01/79 01/25/80 2239 III CAR – TAYUG

959 36 SP 08636 08/15/79 AFFIRMED 01/28/80 02/15/80 24927 XXXI

960 36 SP 08637 07/21/80 DISMISSED 08/09/80 10/30/80 4154 IV

961 37 SP 08713 01/24/79 *NDA *NDA *NDA *NDA III

962 38 SP 08757 10/31/79 AFFIRMED 12/01/79 02/11/80 24 III

963 39 SP 08819 03/30/79 AFFIRMED 04/26/79 02/11/80 12/19/79 1936 II CAR – LIPA CITY

964 40 SP 08850 07/24/79 GRANTED 01/02/80 02/12/80 01/02/80 941 1

965 40 SP 08876 06/29/79 AFFIRMED 11/05/79 01/25/80 11/05/79 246 V

966 41 SP 08974 09/24/79 DISMISSED 10/14/79 02/04/80 118116 XXV CFI – MANILA

967 41 SP 08977 12/21/79 AFFIRMED 01/12/80 02/18/80 7206 XII CFI – RIZAL

968 42 SP 09017 04/24/79 DISMISSED 06/19/79 05/05/80 03/17/80 115113 XXXV CFI – MANILA

969 43 SP 09052 05/22/80 08/06/80 DISMISSED 08/21/80 10/30/80 G-372 VI

970 45 SP 09080 10/31/79 DISMISSED 06/02/80 07/07/80 16985 II CFI – CEBU

ADELA GOMEZ, ET. AL., VS. HON. ARSENIO G. SOLIDUM, ET. AL.

CFI – ALBAY LEGASPI CITY

ADELA GOMEZ, ET. AL., VS. ROSALINA TUFEXIS VIBAR, ET. AL.

CFI – LEGASPI CITY

SACRED HEART SCHOOL OF MALABON, INC., VS. RICARDO S.

BALATBAT, ET. AL.


CITY

TRI-ARC INVESTMENT & MANAGEMENT CO., INC., VS. EFICIO

B. AGOSTA, ET. AL.FELIX MALAZARTE, VS. SIMPLICIO

SILVANO1696 LEYTE

'78CAR - ORMOC

CITY

LOURDES CATLE, VS. HON. CELESYTINO C. JUAN, ET. AL.

MAXIMO BAUN, VS. ALEJANDRO SIPIN

LEONARDO M. RIVERA, VS. THELMA FIRA


ANGELO CAGUI, VS. HON. JUDGE PAMPANGA, ETC., ET. AL.

CFI – PAMPANGA

BANAGO STO. NIÑO DRIVERS ASSO., VS. HON. RAMON BRITANCIO, ETC.,

ET. AL.

CFI – NEGROS OCC.

DOMINADOR QUIAMBAO, VS. JOAQUIN GOZUN, JR., ET. AL.

CAR – PAMPANGA

SPS. NAZARIO MARQUEZ, ET. AL., VS. RAYMUNDO ALULOD

BENITO IBE, VS. HON. JUDGE HAROLD M. FERNANDO, ET. AL.

CFI – BANGUED, 2ND JUDICIAL

DIST.

SANTOS CAMOCAMO, VS. BELEN LUGOD RAÑESES

CAR – CAGAYAN DE ORO

RAYMUNDO REYES, ET. AL., VS. HON. EMETERIO CUI, ET. AL.

CENIN TAN, VS. HON. FERNANDO A. CRUZ, ET. AL.

MILAGROS C. LIMSON VDA. DE FERRER, VS. HON. ALFREDO M.

LAZARO, ETC., ET. AL.BENITO SANCHEZ, VS. HON. FELIPE

BUENCAMINO, ETC., ET. AL.CFI –

PAMPANGA

AHS PHILIPPINES, INC., ET. AL., VS. HON. FRANCISCO P. BURGOS, ETC.,

ET. AL.


COURT OF APPEALS SC


LOC. (Page)

COURT OF ORIGIN


NATURE OF CASE

971 44 SP 09129-CAR 02/28/80 AFFIRMED 04/16/80 06/23/80 429 II

972 46 SP 09166-R 07/19/79 DISMISSED 10/17/79 01/08/80 6753 XXX CFI – RIZAL

973 50 SP 09218-R 10/16/79 REVERSED 11/27/79 01/09/80 1670 1

974 50 SP 09219 09/07/79 AFFIRMED 10/04/79 05/07/80 02/01/80 1689 P'75 1

975 50 SP 09228 06/15/79 DISMISSED 11/16/79 01/11/80 77-411 1

976 50 SP 09247 11/05/79 DISMISSED 06/09/80 07/07/80 126474 IX

977 47 SP 09321 12/12/79 AFFIRMED 06/20/80 07/09/80 06/20/80 12178 XXXIV

978 47 SP 09323-R 08/09/79 DISMISSED 09/01/79 01/08/80 31909 XXI CFI – RIZAL

979 47 SP 09327 10/18/79 DISMISSED 11/11/79 01/11/80 2251 II

980 48 SP 09346 08/23/79 AFFIRMED 09/15/79 01/08/80 1424 VI CAR – BALIWAG

981 281 SP 09359 08/24/79 DISMISSED 09/16/79 11/06/79 1350-1351 V CFI – RIZAL, Q.C.

982 48 SP 09362 11/15/79 DISMISSED 11/15/79 01/25/80 959 IV CFI – CAPIZ

983 48 SP 09366-68 10/24/79 DISMISSED 11/16/79 02/11/80 D-3994-96 VIII

984 49 SP 09389 11/09/79 DISMISSED 12/01/79 02/11/80 35 IV CFI – PALAWAN

985 49 SP 09418-R 04/21/80 AFFIRMED 05/18/80 06/26/80 6158 XXVIII CFI – RIZAL

986 51 SP 09430 09/14/79 AFFIRMED 10/19/79 01/08/80 640 UP '77 11

987 51 SP 09450-R 09/12/79 AFFIRMED 10/03/79 01/08/80 1

988 51 SP 09458 10/31/79 AFFIRMED 12/16/79 02/11/80 1731 1

CARLOS OLAIVAR, ET. AL., VS. DUEK SAM

CAR – TAGBILARAN

CITY

ANDREA CABRERA, VS. HON. JOSE C. CAMPOS, JR., ET. AL.

POLICARPIO PAREDES & EUGENIA PAREDES, VS. DIONISIO LAPINID,

ET. AL.

CAR - ORMOC CITY

RICARDO M. PINEDA, VS. CESAR GALANG, ET. AL.

CAR – PAMPANGA

FELECISIMO S. PANLILIO, VS. HON. QUIRINO ABAD SANTOS, ET. AL.

CC OF ANGELES CITY

REYNALDO DE CASTRO, ET. AL., VS. HON. JOSE P. CASTRO, ETC., ET. AL.

RIZAL (QUEZON CITY)

MARCELINA SANTOS VDA. DE ESGUERRA, VS. HON. ARTEMON D.

LUNA, ET. AL.


CITY

GOLDEN RIVER MINING CORP., VS. HON. CELSO L. MAGSINO, ET. AL.

SATURNINA MIRANDA, ET. AL., VS. GETULIO NAVAL, ET. AL.

CAR – LAGUNA, SAN PABLO CITY

CARLOS DUNGAO, VS. LEONARDO NOLASCO, ET. AL.

PATIRA, RUBY ANN, MARGARITA, ROSARIO, CYNTHIA, LINDA JOY CAPAY & RAMON GONZALES VS.

HON. EDUARDO G. TUTAANSLVADOR FALCIS, VS. PEOPLE OF

THE PHILIPPINESCATALINA F. CRISOSTOMO, ET. AL., VS. HON. MODESTO S. BASCOS,

ET. AL.

CFI – PANGASINAN

JOSE CARIÑO, ET. AL., VS. MAYOR RICARDO LIM, ET. AL.

JULIAN PAGPAGUITAN, VS. HON. MANUEL V. ROMILLO, JR., ETC.,

ET. AL.

ANDRES MACANAS, ET. AL., VS. JOSE OBEDOZA

CAR – PANGASINAN

CITY

MAXIMO SIBAYAN, VS. AMBROSIO DELA CRUZ

3474- I '77 CAR

CAR – PANGASINAN

CITY

JOSE M. GARCIA, VS. MARTIN ESMERO

CAR - ORMOC CITY


COURT OF APPEALS SC


LOC. (Page)

COURT OF ORIGIN


NATURE OF CASE

989 51 SP 09462-R 10/22/79 SET ASIDE 11/25/79 01/08/80 284 IV

990 52 SP 09503 10/17/79 AFFIRMED 11/08/79 02/12/80 1221 1 CAR – CEBU

991 1 SP 09541 10/31/79 12/26/79 02/15/80 1245 1 CAR – CEBU

992 1 SP 09549 11/19/79 DISMISSED 03/18/80 05/08/80 32077 1 CFI RIZAL PASIG

993 279 SP 09564 10/19/79 AFFIRMED 11/14/79 09/30/80 2798 II

994 53 SP 09568 06/27/80 02/14/80 SET ASIDE 07/03/80 10/30/80 32164 1 CFI – RIZAL

995 53 SP 09572 08/08/79 DENIED 09/02/79 02/18/80 5496-M VI

996 53 SP 09574-R 04/02/80 DISMISSED 05/02/80 06/25/80 123676 XXI CFI – MANILA

997 53 SP 09577 09/03/79 DISMISSED 11/22/79 02/15/80 11/22/79 518 1 CAR – DAET

998 53 SP 09589 11/14/79 DISMISSED 01/27/80 02/12/80 7292 XXXIII CFI – RIZAL

999 54 SP 09640 10/31/79 AFFIRMED 12/19/79 02/11/80 354 II

1000 54 SP 09644-R 02/05/80 AFFIRMED 06/02/80 06/25/80 05/07/80 Q-25640 17-B CFI – RIZAL

1001 54 SP 09660 10/19/79 DISMISSED 11/22/79 01/25/80 Q 2817 XVI-B CFI – RIZAL

1002 4 SP 09674 09/07/79 DENIED 10/27/79 02/07/80 124126 XV MANILA

1003 4 SP 09679 10/18/79 DENIED 02/12/80 05/07/80 30994 VIII

1004 4 SP 09686-CAR 03/21/80 AFFIRMED 05/03/80 06/26/80 350 II

1005 4 SP 09691 10/26/79 AFFIRMED 12/13/79 01/11/80 08/11/80 2156 III CAR – LIPA CITY

1006 4 SP 09731-R 09/17/79 DISMISSED 10/17/79 01/08/80 Q-27779 VI CFI – RIZAL

1007 280 SP 09774 10/11/79 AFFIRMED 11/08/79 01/11/80 298 II

ROBERTO AQUINO, VS. MARTIN BALASABAS, ET. AL.

CAR – DUMAGUETE

CITY

ALEJANDRO UROT, ET. AL., VS. JOSE TIMOG, ET. AL.

SPS. ROMULO DAYON, ET. AL., VS. ANTONIO CANILLO

UPHELD AND

AFFIRMED.

ALAS CONSTRUCTION, INC., VS. BANCOM DEVELOPMENT CORP., ET.

AL.

SPS. PEDRO MEDRANO, ET. AL. VS. SPS. DOMINGO SOTALBO, ET. AL.

CAR – SAN PABLO, LAGUNA

ALEJANDRO PUNLA, VS. HON. EMILIO V. SALAS, ETC., ET. AL.

SAN MIGUEL CONSTRUCTION, INC., VS. HON. ROQUE A. TAMAYO, ET. AL.

CFI – BULACAN (MALOLOS)

RUBEN SIMBULAN, VS. HON. CONRADO M. MOLINA, ETC., ET. AL.

EDUARDO CABUSAS, ET. AL., VS. HON. PEDRO M. DINGLASAN, ET. AL.RAYMUNDA T. LE COMPTE, VS. HON. MARCELINO N. SAYO, ETC., ET. AL.

TEOFILO ANUD, VS. RUFINA VDA. DE BERNADEZ, ET. AL.

CAR – TAGBILARAN

CITY

ROBERTO MORA, VS. LINO AÑOVER, ETC., ET. AL.

ROLLY LAPID, ET. AL., VS. HON. LOURDES K. TAYAO JAGUROS, ETC.,

ET. AL.ANDO GO, VS. HON. ERNESTO S.

TENGCO, ETC., ET. AL.STEVE OSMEÑA, VS. HON. SERAFIN

CAMILLON, ET. AL.CFI PASIG MANILA

MACARIO FERNANDEZ, VS. ESTEBAN HALAS

CAR – LAOAG CITY

FELIX BARADAS, VS. QUIRINO ARCEGA

LUISA COLASTRE, VS. HON. EDUARDO C. TUTAAN, ET. AL.

PORFERIO SUANGCO VS. SIMPROSO CRUZADO & RUSTICA SUANGCO

CAR – SURIGAO, SURIGAO CITY


COURT OF APPEALS SC


LOC. (Page)

COURT OF ORIGIN


NATURE OF CASE

1008 55 SP 09804 11/22/79 DISMISSED 01/03/80 02/11/80 32861 XXXVI CFI – RIZAL

1009 56 SP 09840 11/26/79 GRANTED 12/14/79 02/07/80 7033-P XXVII PASAY

1010 56 SP 09857 11/20/79 AFFIRMED 12/26/79 02/18/80 4525 II

1011 56 SP 09861-R 03/31/80 DISMISSED 04/18/80 06/26/80 1181 II CFI – SORSOGON

1012 56 SP 09867 10/18/79 DISMISSED 04/14/80 07/25/80 04/14/80 II

1013 57 SP 09889-CAR 03/31/80 AFFIRMED 05/13/80 08/05/80 2241 TP'77 III CAR – TAYUG

1014 57 SP 09891 06/02/80 AFFIRMED 09/08/80 10/03/80 09/08/80 682 IV

1015 57 SP 09897 11/29/79 DISMISSED 01/26/80 02/18/80 22832 XX CFI – RIZAL

1016 57 SP 09902 10/31/79 DISMISSED 12/14/79 02/18/80 1852 I

1017 57 SP 09906 11/14/79 DENIED 12/02/79 02/18/80 7557 XXXIV CFI -RIZAL

1018 5 SP 09921 12/20/79 DISMISSED 01/18/80 02/12/80 106570 IV CFI - MANILA

1019 5 SP 09923 02/25/80 DISMISSED 03/20/80 05/02/80 647 IV

1020 58 SP 09962 11/13/79 DENIED 12/02/79 02/11/80 2679 I CFI – RIZAL

1021 58 SP 09981 12/20/79 01/09/80 *NDA 026177 17-B CFI – MANILA

1022 59 SP 09992 12/04/79 DENIED 01/02/80 02/11/80 7413 XXX CFI – RIZAL

1023 60 SP 10133 03/28/80 DISMISSED 04/18/80 10/03/80 08117 IX CFI – RIZAL

1024 2 SP 10156 12/27/79 DISMISSED 01/28/80 05/07/80

1025 2 SP 10178 01/02/80 W/DRAWN N/A 2693 1

1026 2 SP 10213 03/18/80 DISMISSED 08/05/80 10/01/80 7112 XIV CFI RIZAL

KAMIAS (Q.C.) TRANSPORT SERVICE ASSOCIATION, INC., VS. HON. LEO

MEDIALDEA, ET. AL.INTERTECH FABRICATORS, INC.,

ET. AL., VS. HON. MANUEL V. ROMILLO, JR., ET. AL.

ALFONSO DALISAY, ET. AL., VS. FELIX FERNANDO, ET. AL.

CAR – NUEVA ECIJA

NATI VIDAD UY, ET. AL., VS. HON. AQUILINO D. BONTO, ETC., ET. AL.MAXIMIANO LIM, ET. AL., VS. HON.

AQUILINO P. BONTO, ET. AL.1058, 1045 &

1046CFI – GUBAT, SORSOGON

SPOUSES BERNARDO PANER, VS. PATRICIO CABRERA

PRIMITIVO PAMISA, VS. FELIPE DE LA CRUZ

CAR – BATAAN, BALANGA

FRANCISCO RODRIGUEZ, JR., ET. AL., VS. ELVIRA FERNANDO VDA. DE

SANTOS, ET. AL.MAINIT LUMBER DEVELOPMENT

CORP., VS. HON. LAURO L. TAPUCAR, ET. AL.

AGUSAN DEL NORTE

(BUTUAN)

CELSO ORTEGA, VS. HON. JUDGE BERNARDO P. PARDO, ET. AL.

LILIA M. MADERA, VS. SPS. AMPARO STA. ROMANA, ET. AL.

ELUETERIO QUEZON, VS. HON. LUCIANO ELIZAGAM ET. AL.

CFI – BALANGA, BATAAN

HEIRS OF DELFIN CRUZ, VS.HON. PEDRO C. NAVARRO, ET. AL.DR. JESUS DEGALA, VS. HON.

WILLELMO C. FORTUN, ET. AL.RESOLVED TO GRANT

BENJAMIN BALDOZA, ET. AL., VS. HON. JOSE C. CAMPOS, JR., ET. AL.

LEOPOLDO SEBARON, VS. HON. JOSE P. CASTRO, ET. AL.

JULIETA B. SERVITO, VS. (HABEAS CORPUZ) ENRICO S. SERVITO

CITY SHERRIFFS OFFICE

CALOOCAN CITY

MARY E. VENTURANZA, VS. HON. RUSTICO DELOS REYES, ET. AL.

NO EOJ ATTACHED

CFI JUDICIAL DIST. BULACAN

RODRIGO SY, VS. HON. ROMULO S. QUIMBO, ET. AL.


COURT OF APPEALS SC


LOC. (Page)

COURT OF ORIGIN


NATURE OF CASE

1027 61 SP 10223 05/30/80 AFFIRMED 07/02/80 11/12/80 1426 IV

1028 278 SP 10238-CAR 06/27/80 REVERSED 07/31/80 09/26/80 42 II

1029 64 SP 10323 05/28/80 AFFIRMED 06/27/80 11/12/80 1235 I CAR – CEBU

1030 64 SP 10340 04/18/80 DISMISSED *NDA *NDA *NDA *NDA *NDA

1031 292 SP 10350 05/30/80 AFFIRMED 07/05/80 07/30/80 047 II CAR – CAVITE

1032 64 SP 10374 04/07/80 DISMISSED 04/26/80 06/10/80 107873 XXXVII CFI – MANILA

1033 3 SP 10420 05/30/80 AFFIRMED 07/02/80 11/12/80 1303 VI

1034 3 SP 10453 03/05/80 RESOLVED 03/28/80 05/02/80 4408 II BATAAN

1035 62 SP 10484 06/18/80 DISMISSED 07/11/80 09/11/80 8045 XII RIZAL

1036 62 SP 10515 03/27/80 RESOLVED 06/21/80 07/16/80 924 III

1037 63 SP 11313 10/06/80 GRANTED *NDA *NDA *NDA *NDA *NDA

1038 9 SP 09/28/76 AFFIRMED 10/21/76 *NDA 03/03/77 416

1039 7 SP UDK-1196 02/28/80 GRANTED 03/27/80 06/18/80 1272 II

LAZARO SANTIAGO, VS. JACINTO MATIAS, ET. AL.

CAR – GAPAN, NUEVA ECIJA

RAUL BENDOY VS. LANTAWAN DILANGALEN

CAR – COTABATO CITY

PEDRO LOPEZ, ET. AL., VS. BALTAZAR BOLARDE, ET. AL.

CRESENCIA CHAVEZ GO, VS. HON. MARCELINO N. SAYO, ETC., ET. AL.

DANIEL MARTOS VS. FEDERICO RAMIREZ, ET. AL.

PIONEER STRUCTURAL STEEL CO., VS. HON. BIENVENIDO C. EJERCITO,

ET. AL.

ENRIQUE VILLAON, ET. AL., VS. BENJAMIN AGUSTIN

CAR – BALIWAG BULACAN

AGRIPINO B. MALABUTE, ET. AL., VS. HON. PEDRO SANTIAGO, ETC., ET.

AL.MERCEDES CHING, VS. HON.

FERNANDO CRUZ, ETC., ET. AL.PABLO AYSON, VS. HON. AVELINO M.

CONSTANTINO, ET. AL.CFI –

VALENZUELA

AMPARO P. VILLAMOR, VS. NORMA B. FRANCISCO, ET. AL.

4932 and 05022

FORTUNATA DE MAGUISA, VS. RAFAEL PALAD, ET. AL.

CAR – PANGASINAN

ARACELI P. DUPO, ET. AL., VS. HON. LEOPOLDO B. GIRONELLA, ET. AL.

CFI – ABRA, BANGUED

Documents

No. TC CASE NO. PARTIES EOJ - Court of Appeals of the ...ca.judiciary.gov.ph/images/references_corner/journ-360...Doodle-2011 Page 1 of 54 Disposal_Audited_B#1_Numerical COURT OF APPEALS