The [csm 1$1 .\aDClml coanruUee arm.: Faculty of~- but ""h I .. Id< lIIelllbenhop _ m. dt:ntaI SfICCUUIU ,ba mcludel m. tin<! =opill.ed I/'iIlnml bodies III !be Stale [!be....., domaI sdIooII III Oublm me! CM and ,"'" ReSI), tbt:)nsh De .... 1 ADcaallOG. rqnM'1IWI'CS "r,he ro\c,aN IpCaaIISl and..onsuitlnl r;re>up< III bcIlb ClBl SurrttY and Onl><>doauCi, the a".r Dental Officer and """ Chairm.an or,he JCSTD Each "f,he mcm~hlp caI,,~n"", requited '0 decIde upon 11> o .. n

'''''"''''11) I, i. important '0 note t.h, .. -ilhin 'he .p«ilJ~t. ud <un. ulta n' grou p" " ominalions. pro, -isjon bal!>Ha m.d. 10 (0'" uc~ " flhe nt.,-.. , u'..,o riC'! - lr. OftC . ... d~mi< <"n!~ltant., o. e ,...ponll <UlIS ult .. , ud Ont l"l'IistcrPd . ..... il lio<' •• d thet. I rt t\t(-,ed from " uhl . 'hrir 0". J ubtrou ps.

WII!"" d .. IC:STD. twO __ ... ,:1.'150<} eo...runrcs bI-e been at.abIu.haIlO ",~'-Kk 11II""tar "* 10 IbItt ofll>< S"'C. of t.ho .kt1Dl. Co",,,,,,,. From ""w DII.. atI} 1nl'''''' facllltoes whlCb art 10 be $;dIIm.ed .. JrelRd III nber Or;d SUf!'Cf} Of 0nh0d0at1CS.1IIUSI be t:IISp<>ded 1»- thae Ad..-..lf) Comlllluees aod obuIII JPP"""- t.broup!be ICSlD Post~c pm~ "hlCh do not lla\lI tile approval of \be ICSlD .. ill IlOl lit ~"'~ .lbe dent, .... 11o potIllC\plle III """h prtIJrDUIIC'I .... U no! P'" CIIIHJcIllCIII ,,, Iu. ... IhclllllOlII." .... ~ tn Re"""", oCDcntal Spcc.lhSIS

"I"'bo P'O'-"_ of=OJlllSOd t.rJ.in.UI,,,,1I .... ure IlOl 0111} IM' 0\11 Ijfadl.llll<" "'ll be , .. "tcd 1.0 t.be hl",C'!t.level but. " w,U llso IUO'" our ",,'lCnt, 10 ,COCI,"" tlte h.abcst. st.andardl of car. Tb ... is, aRe. all, whit "''''YO .... ,,-ould ,,,ob 10 ""hoe,,,

Onh lKlo.'iu,

It IS a m:rtJ"me!lli.llldcr Iht E~ uooon DmIaI DlrKt, ..... 1bItt our "P<",ah~ In Onbudolllllcs on: ttamed to "' ....... me.peed IIIIIIlmll'" Ellle>peaa ~ The Eoropeaa UDIOII Ad""",} Comm~!ee on t.he '~IM" of Drnr.lPrxt1l.1OIIIOf"S bat; ,tSUCd pKlehllcs on speaahSl ....... m, aMI ,t.. DUc.:Il"" requua spccWlSl O'aOnut& 10 be oCl ", .. "",,1111 of 3)QI"S till"'t.lOII The Denial Councd has adJpt~ lire EuropuII moxIel for ope<'latl$l ,r..,nilll,n IItland Therefore_ t.be CUl'n<ul\llll for t.rJ.IIIUlIInd tllo: re~'11IIt.,OOIS fi .... , ....... ,"".;u I.id do»n b~ Iht COIIIIC,I folIO» !hn form» In ,bill

< .... ,""

I . Tbe "lit} pD,m '1110 <peeial15l trauun, "wob '* been Irncd b~ ll>! thttc ,n~ 1>«1, .. is

2 ,.~o1l'S lI<'"enl prof .... "'rW lnunon, ~-qual,llcaliOllI"d pDsscu,on of'he M~,~be..tt,p 0(,"" Fa.: uhy ofD~m .. ny. R.CSI dIploma (MFORCSI) or equi'lllen,

2 TIw: counc conIml bmIdIy cor=ponds 10 11",' ... "d~h,," for I~ UK ' ra, • .nr JIfOCrJIIIfIICS '" Orthodontic> fur specqlist n'l(ISIrJfl and olloe. ".....,..· \ Ap"·1 (999) Ind Mills !be reqw.........,rs Of lhe ,.,.1 .. ';>1>1 EU Do_li-c

~. The cow ... IoaI,,,,, bas also been.,m ,a 1Nl !lIOn' I_ 6O%(\f!be . _IO~ 11 .... ""'" be IpmI "'. 0anaJ ",hooI "",,",.100 di ........ " .... n i$lol

-' 11 .. ( ' .. · ... Iwl' """.et 4 n.c n.n,nc lime "ill loo 3)ars after"boch an un q",,~Il~"'" ",11 b< lam ~I specI.lIhsl Ic-''I!I

~ If rr~,"".,. .. ,>11 ", CO'!I"'''' 10 Ccnoullanl 1 ..... 1. • fu" her 2 )~ars 'rammg " '':4",,,,<1 ("Il~"'lI\g .. h,eh the Inl~'c~Il~lli3l. SI'" ... losl Fello" sh,p ,,·,11 be """ ....... f). TI", 'eIIUi,enlClIIS (<If coosultam oppoonm",nls h:I.c already been 1Ir""" II,p.Old _greed bet"'otn.be COO., tloe DCl'arnMnl ofHe.ol'h ood Oooldten anJ the Foe"l.y

Tbe ,r;"n'Q~ de.cnbcd 1Iloo.... m,rrors the SOl""'"","" SlMd>. p<nem ,n doe 1;[0; The F ....... , ronsodon ~ ~ 10 be essetIb<Il for.he .... '1« _, ",11 be ,ec"ploed as ID equ:ol_Jlus.ber Europcaro coIlc~,..es. fOf !be: p.U",n'..-!Ie ",11 reel'''" the best IrUUDCnI aod {Of.he profeuKoa .. hi"i. ",0"",.,1", a..wd cfbcaltbttrc '" Il:u. caunny

~\, C'haIrmaa.I .. ""ld _I"'" doL, short Jft$COUII .... bysa," lnac!loo F ..... I) ofDenllstr} ",ouId _ ""'lfa,; baVIllj: DO dIrea rok III '"""' , .. t.o,nj/ 10 ,7WIpOVo"" III 1l1li COUIIIr} t...1'*Ihcr as. pDllpadual. """"

",I'N In lb. 'nalllleaan<:e "ftlle IIiAhosI Si.1Idafds In pDllpaol .... __ D<nll>lr:- In Iroland IllllClg ",ub!be DenlII COUIICoIlIld IM UD"cnll'''I

I) r. r~l or( u"n o.~n. Fu uh)' " rOoM;'I !,}. ReSI

~Dl>IT"'_'" ..---•. -._ .... ,"'.-p .. .... , .. " ... -- . ... -

Submission by the Dublin Den'tal School & Hospital to the

Joint Committee on Health & Children ofthe Oireachtas in re lation to Orthodontics

_uot JoM Cl.orkson. D .. n

Mr. erlan "u,.,..~. CIoieI h ..::uiIYoo 0II\c .. Or. TlIer ... G ..... ~. Sonlor lKtIJ ... rIConoukenl In Onhodontlc1o

Or. P..,I DowI I"9. Senlot- LKI..,.rtc:o...ultllm In ~

fI" Decem_ 2001

Dublin o.ntal School & Hospital submluion to the .Joint Commltt .. on He~lth & Chlldr.n of the OIl'NChtu

In .. I.tion 10 Orthodontics

n._d .. ___ ~_._""' _ _ ... ~ ... ~_. __ IO ... _..­_ IN _dll-.(;oomuIly -~ ......... _tolO __ I'IoIIi'fIr_..-y~ ... 1coto;I "-'*'11, _ ..... .-, .-- _ 01 IN _ -... ~ _. _"-""to. _ ruseo __ .. -..

, Edt.aOt .......... _ .. ~_~ ......... d __ ..

_""_0I"'~ _~ ___ Iot"_d"' __

ear-_ .. _--= _____ ""_ """"""ond ........ _ oI_ond~ IM< ___ .. _____ 10 .. _01 ...

-...., .. __ ........ _ ... ,..-dhognquolC\f-"'O_ ---_. __ ~........,.IO_~_ .... _ ____ .. _ ..... _"""-"" .... , ; 16 •

..... _"'~d"'-d _

_ .. _ .... _ .. .--._ ............ oI"9<qo.w,OIOII

Tho SdooOI_~ ............... __ ..... :-"10 .. _-. ... -.,;w.E._o.-(SI 129""i<II3~boo....",..,.IO .. ___ d ... O-U:~_..-___ ... _""" .. -..1iofI ....... :.---,. d 0.-. r......,. C<*got

Tho SdooOI_ ~ --'Y '- 2C5U __ npotl __

To __ ....- .. SdooOI.-.I __ """ .. ~ -T .. chlng

......... " d_l-...oe Thou_go ' ____ ... ho __ ~IO .. _d. __ .. 0... Sa.- (IH .... LSe. cIoo;r-= d .. ~ 01 0.-. Tho -.. ~ .. ...--. _~ __ ~_j ___ 1

FOtIJ_ ... _IO"' ___ , 01"""""' .... """'_'"

,

~ u.... The _ 01 ... ~ '*"*' ~ ...,..-. ... ~OUIoI~prKIaI by_.

,....._T~

The""-I>MI~ ._0I~ __ ___ -n._it ... ...., ~_ ..... --r __ 0I~ ___ "'fUI_oI~" __ -n. HOorIiIoI ~ __ dollme hoIni'ICI WI • _ '" __ NI ~ "' ___ ... eIIgibiot Ie<. __ 01--' II'MWIgIe<

_"'....-_oI ... EU_ .. .." ... _ ......... ""_"' ... DontIII CounolI by trIO I<lol1 CorrvMI .. le< ~ T~ In Doo>I!oIr'/ '" ... Ro,ooI CoIIooo 01 ~ r

~oIICI\IfJI"Pl"II"""~ Thooo __ IO __ ~_",."..I'OoInorIg ... __ IO _

_ .--..- ... _ """'""" ..... _ ..... _ Of 10 _...--. __ In _1tIiIwIg n. _____ ......- Ie< _ _ 10< ___

HiIfW~_o... n. __ ""-I>MI ~ too -.. 10 _._ ~

~--..-.-~----c..ndnuIftI~far __

ThoScN:d _____ '_IO_ .......... oI

-----~--, "'-,-...-1ocUM .. .--___ ..-... ............... _....-. ---.- ... ~ ..... ---L-... Progtoommo_A m<>nII'II\' ~ ~ ____ ~ • .,...-Ior_ ..... _ ... ""'-"""Y

~_~·A~~ __ ~_ Io~ ~_ .. ~lprKIaI ___ .3_ ,... --Tho _ ..... _ ~ _.._.n; ___ n _ '-"", --- ..... -~ CIoNoI~· AIuI _____ ~.._.n;Ior ... _"'. _ oodI_ Tho ___ .. ~ "' ... DontIII c.o..ncI_ ""*-""'*'IIn ______ .......,.,

00nI0t T~' A fUII _______ ""'- 10< .... .-

oIuplOe_oodI_

,

00<1l0I __ • "IUII _____ .._ hoWI9 ..... _ aI:IQ ...,,_ n. ___ olUll ____ .. '- .. - .. ____ ...... __ al_~ The <XIIn. __ "' __

_ Sc!uaI """14ooPMoI_1O ..... """-.. .. ____ ...... -~.--hlrq-~--The S<:hoaI """ toooroIoI __ ""'" ___ kif _ 1IVOUgI1 "'"

~aI_"""_""~_IO"'--"""'-.gIO"" _ 0I~, DoI>I<><Mo. ~ __ ..... ~ n • ....oIJ 01 -The _""'" Hoop111I_"- _10 _ fYoo.9'I_IO...-v .. __ .. __ ........... ~ __ ~on:I

_., ~""'Ok

~----,. ,.. .. _ .... _ .... ~0I~_1n .... E...- _ ___ 0I..-y ..... ~ ____ ~

--..-"' .... -..-_ ... _ ..... _-...; ---~ __ 01 __ Caurd. CoIIo9o ~ and .... '--"1' 01 _ s.-. Tnnocr CoIIo9o ~ CcIogoooal~ lno.-.. ~ oa.go.. ..... ~ ~_""o...I-.a. ----~ EU ---,~ "" "'" T_oIDenooI _ __ F_oIOo<IIoI~ __ "'*'" * _ IoIodcoI _ DenooI _ _ .... Cloft1oI_ ",e..apo "----­~_alDoooI __ US __ .... DoooI_c..-.F __ ---In _ ..... __ onil ... _ .., Hoop111I __ .. __ """"""' __ .... ..--01 ___ _ -_ .... .,.,

•

~d\!C8t~_ .0Jd _Tf!I/llnQ P!'OQf!I!TIIIIeS • JlurnlMl!L..u~ .. .".

•

",~ _____ ._""",,-,"""'_<A000lIi0I __ "'~000lIi0I_ n.. __ .-,..-_ .. "'~_~oI __ ~o,. ... _._ .. ____ jIIUnOiO of IJ"OC "*"*"11 _ ... _.- The

do ...... C 01 ... _ Doooal.......- & _ --.-. ...... T......,. CcIoo;oo ---pnooooIod.--. .... _---_ ... -01 _ .... __ 10 ~ _ -.....;. ... Sctoooor. __

_ .......... _1*I00:I

n.. .... ..........,.._,...,_a1_....--... _~ _ ... _ ... -c..n-o _ ..... _1"0 0.-. Doooal_ ' _

~-­""" ...... -... en! 0I00M0I_ 0!101 -.. -----$ohio _ .......,. GIotod _ ....

~-__ 0.--,& __ s-.:.

~--n... __ ._o,._ .. _...- .. __

-~ -- .. --.-_&~- .. ~ ____ III-* n... __ _ <A ... _ .... ____ -...bIy ___ .....

_~..., .. E~ n...~<A ... ..., __ ~ ....... ____ ..

_a1 ... _<A __ orodorIIoI<Oi'i ..... _&~ .. 1no:k.OIo __ M ___ ,-"'~"" __ ""

_ tw.py f~, .. ~ MW .... <A __ .... " .... 'g .. ......-val_ .. _<:Ioat_. __ .... ...... _ ...... --_ ..... -....... -...................... _<A ___ ~.TloIo __ • _ _ a1 __ oI.a.n11oo1_ ..... __ _ .....-n-.ol ____ a1 _____ '"

-----~ n... __ 1O_'_0)_~_

(00000IE0I) 10 -.....co .. W _ <A ~ ____ ~ <A _ ......... __ --..".,..cE_ MW_ .. ___ o,. -,. _____ .no._ioI_",.

DG DUI <A ... eo.ovo-

•

r.bIo2..R~ __

, , , .-- • , , ~ _.- , .. , , ,

• --• ---

Clinical Servlen -ThoScNd_ ............. _ ... ..-,. ___ ~ __ __. __ -"" ___ .... \Ir ---n.. ........ ~._...,_ ... _II'I_"-~mF-, tOO .",. ·500 p"'- _ .. primariy ___ .. _ . ~

......--,....-~....,-""-II'I- ............ ...,. -~.-"'~"' __ ~""autol""'""' __ Ior ... ...­_~,.......,._\lr~Ihe~~ n. _____ Ol00~ ___ .. ~~~ _

_ -,.. ~ _ ... ~ "' ... HOopiIoIIIor 2 ....... .-y _ _ "'3 __ .-y$Alurday_s...,.,.,.m __ ~ A..- • ..........,.""""'_ofN_ ....... _IO __ •• -.-,. .. ~_ .. __ on ... _cIurinII_"",. ~_ ........ "" ... _Cl .00 ___ OII00 ___ "'IIII'I .. _ ... ___ -"" ""-""*'" _ ... 00tMI ~~. --..-_t5CI1 ___ _ ---"'.~- ... ItooIIUI_~_ ...... m._oI_ ....., ... _0\" _______ 00.,....,. ... _ ... _ __ Ior ... ~of_~, n.._ ... __ .. ___ Ihe~_oI-..-._\lr~~'" ~-~~ _ .. ~"-._oI _ _.dng ... _, ... _ -.-"""'...-- ........ ~.....,-"- .. ~ "-"'_II'I".HDopaI.lorooaolOf ____ ... _\lr ..... m_~ ___ r....., __ _

~ .. _er..a --n..",,",,*,,_ ... _~ ... ___ ,.... _ _ Ior"'_of~""" ______ _ _ ~ lr.o~ ___ ...

(hi -.. (hi ~ to<! (hi RIdaIogy -. ... __ .... .....,. -..... _ "''''-'''''I' ~ lIII_ll,x.. ___ _

•

1 tll I1

j Ill~ i

f"l : I

1;; i

I il

I ! if • Ilfl

i If • I

f li: n

I in, I j i l4 I h Hr

11} I H t tl'~

I; i!'1 H

tit If ill

i I ~~. i ,Ut i I ilj. if ij 'j!

idil I i 11'11 J liB ,'H Ihii it HI I'l

l~ III } i ~ii ~ If!!

l n lnt! Illil ill

!i flfl i I lil i i liifl I fJ JI1ii 11 !fl I jilt •

--n-._~~. __ ""'OI""_""'" " ......... ~d ..... __ .~(~llIl,I)~ __

-~ ,,_ ......... n.. __ MoopIIoI~. __ "'2_'_1or --", ... -~ ......... -....",-­.... otSl v.-..-. ~

SlW<o.~

n-. __ ~ __ """" __ ""_"""'Sl L ... ·• ~~-.py---

SI~.~-

..... -..... ___ 5_. __ -"_"" ___ _ lA __ "OnoI~

,,~ .• ~ ... ~ __ III_Iot ... _d ___ ., __ ...... ......, v-r_dlho ___ bo _ _ 01"---",,, _______ _ <Iey __ .... DonIoI ~ --Ono ____ .~"".pnldonot .. __ "" 1>O __ ..... _ .... tnUCONI~

T ___ por_ •• ~for"'""_td_"";'" -.g --.. ..... __ -..... CenIrw..., .... -., """' .... _ .... bono ____ '-\IU'Ig~

&1_·0-'" AfuI __ ............ ",..~ ____ ......... ___ .... _ ID !he 1 __ "*'0, ~ ___ .... ~ ___ T_\JtIto_ .. _-......c-. Ono ____ oIOnoI_ .... _._"'1ho Gl-"ICIo'IC ........ d __ .... cuo;' • __ HlV_

....... .....,--o..r.....,... HooIpoItI .... _ 0II0nn. ~

The ....... _ • ---.: .....- _ Crurn .... ~ _ ...", -----

--A .. ___ .,-..,.God.SI_·.T_ ...... _ .. ____ n._."--..,. .... ~d _.~_ .... __ ~farll ___ __

VoIurary---Fao ... _10 _IN 0...... i'tDopIIIIr-~ .. ~ _IO_VHI "_l*'IoI"'-~_ n. __ • ..-.._ .. ~ .... -...,...---,-.. - .... ...-_.,~_ .. __ .. _01 _____ -.~ ..... oa.Ir9olO .... VI<I -, ""~_._ ...... __ ""'IIHI,Io~Ior8UP"- ~ --

"

-... _&~-- ..... ---"',---~,.~-- .... -----... ,_ .. ......--~ .... ........,.,o __ -.-_ ..... _ n. _ _ ..............,_ ...... ~af._"-"' .. _

-~-ThoJc>onte.c.-_"","""_ •• '9_oI_~ ___ Iho----n~ __ ._-1_'111 Tho S<:I'II>oI' tIoocIOI ~ 1ho!J...,g 01 ~ _ orOcaol>o< ,_ W. __ 1ho ........ _1or ........ _ .... ~~ ___ "'-"'Ior __ nlho~_

ThoJc>ont~""boo __ "'_""o....I~_,,,·o.-.g ___ bt' .... ~Fo. __ ...... _""~af. _-.c. ... 1IQN ..., .... __ .... __ .. _----.- .... -~--~. ,..-01 .... ______ .. ..- ..... '-"' ___ .. _W~_£_ .... ThoE...-er........-...~ ... _..- .. "" ..... ___ _ .. __ .... __ --. Tho _____ ,...

...... ~ 01 ~ ur-s.ty c-go CGtI< _ .... RD,III c-go 01

"'-Tho~_ ..... ___ .... -..,._ ..... oI ... .-,. ____ n-.. .... __ Hoo!>iIaI

""""" ~ 01 • """'"" from Iho s.-.....,--, ~ 01 ........... ~ .... H9'* T~ n o..tIOIr)I 01 .... Roy.I ~ 01 s..,.......

Tho~~~(SAC)~_I1'IO_oI ....-........-...., ........ boo""""""'- -... .... 0W>IeI_1O ........... _----_oI.-..oI....-.. __ nlho[)o<gj __ n ... _ _ ........... poo'IOd ,_,M 1Nl _ & __ ....,_ .. ~'O ___ hln5~ .. __

,-... , ..... ~0I_ &~. orioroo ............. RopoorI_ ... ___ .01... ' h ... « af. ___ ,..,.. .. ~ __ I1'IOSIIC .. ___ - ..... ~ ThoaAC"-"~"'_ ...- ... _ ..... ......-af __ ._oI •• ..., .... _

... ..-...... 0110", 12(~"" INI_ afIho ~ 0tI>0d0:0nec -,

"

AI ... _ 01 ... SAC _ .. , ___ ~_ ... E.-n_ -.. __ m_lI>eorrogoanal ___ ..

..... '_lrOoo'Io'IIoo_m_N"-";_ ~ __ _ N _____ oI ____ _

~_ .. ~1_ 1 ___ "' __ -.--__ ~ __ .. N~~-""_"Io .. 2OIXI.1 ___ "'_.1rOoo'Io'II __ .... __ 1_ .... _-u.g_o.. ___ o. __ 10_ -v.g _ 0. _ 0...- ..... _ E-.. ___ 0. PalIoIcSP*'}'

.... _ e....... __ .1_ po::ou;bIo '" _0_100._1 -Thono _~.~_ .. ~_ .... ~" 2002_. """"" _ will or-It .. 2000 Fe< "" .... .... ,.. ... _ ... .".,.. training ____ . ___ bMoi _10 ~. "'""'"' 20-30 -s.r.:. ... _oI ... Sp«:IoIoI ~ .. ~ .. ~ ... ,_ .. , ...... __ oI~1fWotI\I ~ ___ ... SAC

10'" o.oIiII c:.o..d ................. ea...- fool ~ T_ .. ~ ThoI C--"',.... __ .00- 01 SQooc.- T ....... _ ... too ... _1O.-w-.._ .... ___ oI --" ,....,..,... ... ..., _ ... __ ... _ .. _.I • ....-.. .. _-..,lorbrf'o>o'Cl ... -"'~_IoI ___ _

Tho o.oIiII_ ......... _ ""'_ .... eo.-__ _ -... ~...,-Tho~_too __ Ir-....g .. ..-,.._ .... N_ 01 __ ..... __ ..... -*_ '_I01000''' __ "' .. _ ..- ....... ~ __ . ~ "'Y 0!IIMgu00 __ Or ~ _ 0. ~. _ 0.. 8 _. M _ N UcGo.ornooIs J. 0...- _ P Mo;Shooory In N rogoanaI ~1Ic ...... ..., ___ ~ __ IO __ -.nv~ 0... __

_ . ...-~ .. ....-. ... __ - QuIOIoIy 01 ... ~ ......-~ _ .......... tome....-.; ......... U_1OIcIWIil ~IO ___ ..,IO_..".... __ _

__ .r ... ea...- .... , '_ ...... too_ .... I • .-....,._ .. ....... __ .. ~_~~IO ....... '~. n. ___ ..... _oI....-q-...v ___ •

-.g""'-''''_'''_'''~_c.n __ _ Tho_-...v _____ .. _ ... _-...~

__ ~ ........... """'*- - - --"' - '-' 10 .-..-___ A _____ ..... ~"'_&

CHI!rw>.-.,. '" __ ""'-"-"" 10 _ .. _ .. ..., __ 000-

___ nIoq _ en. ~'. "'--' ....... _ too ~

~)

Gfooooo -. -.; __ ,."., ...... -.. -.... 01"'-""' __ ~""'~"""'_1O_1o.11~" ..,.--~-~.-..~-..-.".,----... _ ...... ..,...,_10"-' __ 10..-_ .......... __ ... _10_ • ....-01--.., .. = W ..... ..,_IO_ ... ~_.-y _____ by ... DenIOI CouncIl M .... __ 01 ... _ .... _ & 00b00I\

W._~ .. _ ... ~ .. _ ... ~d_'~ "'~Mr T,,",~ .... Dt Goor.-dGloM"" .. ___ ---___ ."""""""D.

u ______ .

~ _______ II>;oeIIIef ...... __ d"'"

........ ______ ._ ... ~ .. ona._ ... _'"

------.. ....r.g. .......... ..- ... _"'--., .... __ ..... ..--.. .. _ ... _~oI~ _____ .. _ .. _on"'~ ___ . ,..._-........... _ .. _ ... _ .. -..--- .. eo .... "",_pemoI.t>Mnng" ___ "_"''''_

"'_~b-_ ... _IO~

~.-------... ..-..-..,

I'~nlalion b) Iht Cork ~Dlal School alld lIospilallD Ihe

Joint ()inadlolas Comminee on Health and Cllildnn

6110 DecemtN.r 2001

1l\ank you ChIIlnnan and members of the c:ommillf<' for )'OUI" invitalion

10 mak~ I presentation 10 you on the pro'o'i.ion of orthodontic ...,.".ices in

ltl1land. Our preKnw,on today ",ill clarify the f'Ol~oflhc Con: c;;ntal

Schoolllld Iloopital in dtntal ~on lAd lninin:a. It bath

~ and ~ 1",~I • ...J I bapc!hat i1 "'ill be of

~ 10 you in )"OUI" dellbemions.

The Con: l;n,,'cnily Dental School and 1I0.pig] ~,olved &om the

orilinal dental hoopitallhal had been ntablimed in 191)~' the Nonh

Charitlble Intlrmary. In 1968. Uni'o'ef"Sily College Con: lOOk over the

a.dminiw.tion and ~uol of the dmtal hospital and ......... Dental School

and Hospilal. buik on. ,i", adjacent ID the Con: Universily Hosp,1al in

\\,,1101\. ", .. opened in 19!Q. The &rili')' functions primarily ••

\C8I:hini iNlJl>IIion uncIoo< the dirtaion ofl:ni"ft'lil) ColJe&e Cod: ond it

recei'D ~ly 75 per ""'" of ilS fundina !Tom lhc Depanmax of

Eduo;aIj ... ond~ T~isdern-mdlO"'--Or~,

dcntoIlI)," .... .rid dcntoI ~ aDd """"",;"""el) 130 lIudmu "'"

mrolled III1nYone time

l ndf'1ndull~ Tnining

The Cook DemaI SchooI.IIId Hospilal "",,ides ~ derdaI

..tuc.tion..-cl train"" Ieodina 10 !be • .....rd of!he depft of &<hdot of

o..n.l S.....-y by !be I'lI1iona1 Uni"crsity of In,1.u>d. ThiI '" .... of!be

1\00 qualilic:atJOIII .warded in the State !hilt <enf ... enullement 10

lqistralion in !be Rtgi ..... of DerJists and the suboequem n&hl to ~

dmtist!,),""" The main function oftbe r:>mlal School and Hospilal i'l(I

""",ide education and trRining 10 students of dentiSU')" 10 Iluo, on r

~tion they ha,'e the reqUISIte knowledac ond compet""'" 10 Jll""'ide

t.....unmt 111 primII1y aft Jr..el and tbr ~ will to ~f ... ~

furtpeeW ... -. Inorder IOtnin 1IIIIiqrad_1Otm. Jr.."eI. bo<h

primal') IO'Id specialise dernI can: ..... be provided '" IIhin tbo k'-I and

hD:opillll and 10 this end JI&If and studm!s "",,ide • wide ..... of dental

u...unen", fur pItieous from !be Soutbom. South E-.m ond Mid

Weotem IImth Board area.

The smior suffofCorIt. Dental School at>d HOS9itall. compriStOd of

spc<:wisls In pKdiatric: dentisuy, 1nI.111d tDL<illof..:ial Mie1Y.1nI

1UfFf)'. resronti~e denU$lJy and MhodonIics. TlICSO stiff. in Idditioon '"

ibeir oo:ademic duties, provide .. '1IIPIlfUnl t;:O<I$UllanI oervice ... ithin

ibeir __ of opecialiAlion. An o.atnpIc of tbis llef'\'in is tho: _ of

CIf1bopIItlUc $I.II'JiCal can in !be region. This ....... tbaall ~ "ilb

onbodonuc probItmI requirin& sucgical i!ltcr,cntion, for example: pMiems

.. t.o.c .i&"''' Med 10 be repositioned. CUI ha,~ their trftunml P"O"KIed by

COIISIIltant ml! of the Dental School ond Hospital.

SpKi.l li~1 Training

A KttInIIIary. bill \01')' impon2m. I\mctionof .... Con. Oerttal School and

""'-Piuol is 10 prm ide posl~ dinie&lltalnin& 10 opecwist and

COI\IU.II.W l .... el_ Prior 10 !be de\eKJpmml ofd>e l-IcaJth Boerd

onhodontic 1ft\'K:es and I .. orally!be ~Il up of the Resister ofDemal

Sp«ialisa. ~ dinic:al1Rining in IIIthodontics Wall pro'Oided

l"'idy on • demand t-iJI. The bull< of orthodonti<: trI:aIJMnl W1IJ

pnwided through prh .. te prKti= and demists oouWtIIr'ain'na ",ith a

Sp«,aliSl uaming waJ",'e=cn by ibt UK bued Join! CO<MIill~ for

SpecLllist Tra.nina in DomISlry but this fun<-tion is now the raponsibilil}

of the Irish Com .... 1ICC for Special,", T..uu.. in Dontult)-.

0... of!be C\m'ml ~IJ fu. 'P""iallJt ItIiruna ~ i, m. Ital.-s"" supen,Kd .-.d ItI.ined try 11 ~ IWO Wll5lJllanl$. AI presenl

the Dental School and Hospiuol employ, just one oonsultan, '"

onhodontics and <X>lUC<luently cannoIRI this IilM Ipf'ly for ~tion of

.ua,mn8P~

Senior """""",,i<: _IW1l orIbodonlic stalT on: in Ihon supply .. -orId­

... ilk Ind I number of tlToru by tbr School 10 rec:nriI ,wr a\ this level in

the fKCOI F-' ha>.., unfoo:tunRel) pR>'"Cd 10 be unsuo:cnsM.

In 1998 !be DmuI School olTered III appoln\lDen'aI. ,wli", pro~

of ortho<Ionlics "" a onloodomist from 'J'_ Zealand. Howc:o.'er. due 10

per..w rcuons. he unfonunately couklllOl w.c up ibe .ppointmftlllnd

our ~IIO commence a ~ of opeci&li .. uaini"1 in tbr

disc,pline had 10 beabandoned.

In 1999 .. ..,piQlioa IQ IM [)rpo:UI>enlofHralth...t CItiIdrm rot

asawnce "ith the fund:inr, of. pmIIOJ1COII ProfesIoonhip in Orthodonncs

.... appmwd...t IM post was.t.-atisaI. Then: wa..: "''0 ~ Iu.

Millwr IQ! cIeemed I(J SII,tabl~ for ~ at Ihi.J Ic\d The pool t.

apm Men "".enut<\ !his ynr.d ~~ "'" .,hcdulcd 10 lake pI~

in mid Febnwy, From the numboZ"ofinquiri"", made todat. I om

~ootidmt that the posI "'ill be ftlled in 2002 ond ,,'e should be in.

JlC*ition to re-coonnten<;. ,pedalist trainina in orthodontiu ber~ the md

oflMl ....

TrainillllO opecwill..- coasuItw 1e>l'I iavol ..... the -=qubitlOn of

d~ ..cl clinical skills as .. en .. IM pinina of uperience in

~...t audit It is i.mponIInt tlAI funuTdi=tors of the clth,ery of

heal!h care .... not .1 ..... IWlt c..'tpCriencc:l in all Uf>eC1S of their own

JPeOialty but al ... Jmoo.>lqeoble about ~llItd specialtin. They murt

"ork ~Iosely with DlherJPeOialties wilhindeo!i$lry ond medicine:, and

IUOh a facilily is .~.ilabl. in • multidisdplinary dentalschoolsiud next

10 • major SI/tleTal hotpilll. The n.p.runcnl of HeoIth Md ChildTm

ad ..... ,,1cd&cd thcotherm[Uimnmu.. IlUC:h" ~Iinical...t CCIOIIJI'lWII

fa,:iliti" ,,-en: ",..wml for pooI&raIIuate JearniD& IDd in 1999 J"'O"'MIed the ---r funclinllO hr." !hew put in plate

Plan, for 2002

The C<:ri:. DanaI SdIooI...! Hospitll~...t KCq>U iumni,lO

prt/'idt!ipKimsl tratJtiD&. The Den!aI ScbooI .. wkl welame \be

<IJ'I'C'I'I"";I)' o( ... 'Oric~ closely .. ,Ib !be local hoallll bowd in !be

deo.elopmenl of sp«iali .. ttaining in oModo.uics. Tbe Dc-ntaI S<:hooI is

O\Iff· •• lIly unabl.1O provi<k """",;>ri~ tninina in "nhodol'ni~1 becIIuse it

doos nQI ha,-c • se<:Ond onhodon1.o oomulunt In post.

I~ 1002 Ih Cork D .... ' 5<"001 aad lloopital .~ptt" 10:

Employ • speriolisl orthodontist.

Appoim • J>rof.,.". ofOrtbodoraics.

I:kam .opoci./I .. u-ainid& ~ for~'" onbodoouic IraineeL

W ,Ill ~'on from Rrgiroal ConOI/.lllnlJ. and ""il1l \be "f'I"""'al oflhc ICSTO.\be num~ofoaiDces """'" tno......lO pabaps6-8

pcr&MLIm commC1>O;ng in 2003.

Fran •• U_" ....... OIrndow c...iI ... _ H .. II ... 6010 ..... nprdbol F.bIk H ... 1dI On._ .... WI .... 2

I •• O'o..1iII1o Couah ••• 01'1..,.....11 .. .

"""-.. The NMionaI 0nh0cI0nIic s..rv;ec is dililllepl .... lb& ....... Iioct for 1ra ...... It.., """"iI\a. "'" _ilin,lime for onhocIooIlic: _ - 11 the lime: &om be .. plo.ced ... me liII and reooivirla ..... tment bu inoreued 1O...eh an ....... 1 tIw _ po.icnls """" require IU~I')' In onIcr 10 ICh~ "'" _ .1Indan:l of """It tlW """Id Ill"" been ICh~ ifth<)' wm trailed II III eullet oee. w~ find OUJRives in tIt.io ptII~ion bto:l_ of"'" ;".,o",peI&''''''' of "'" Dtp.I:tmenl ofHcollh &lid Chlkmrt ond the areo;d ofllle I,ktolll SchooII ofCorit and OIIblil>. Tbue an: four problem. facinl 1tI~ """ice- •

I. DrI~ .. bo'llooo eI£I!p>ilily rOO' ._1 ..... 1. T ........ eI , •• nll. J,. T .. I,II ... &, TIoo In~r dtecu Ir 1100 SAC ' -M I. I"'.

Dd_IaII'" of F.n.tbIllly r...-lral.eol I. 1915 "'" [)epwImenlofHeili iosu<d pdclinco bucd 011 .... oevaityof • child'. prob ...... The ~.-e "'"IlK IIId Ibo MOtU Repon. ..toidl looked. "'" 1'I.rrure""' .. lopmemofonhodoooai< ....... iccI.~. spcoc:iro.;: inddt,lhe IOTN. This ~Iion bill not been implemmted by the DepuIOIeIIt &lid In June 2000 and (ldobrr 200 I; two 1'I>Mer _ of ",.Iines ....... iuI>ed by the ~t Then: 11 IIOw • ...:h confllsion. tlw u Consuhlnt I do not know wIw ",idelinn ....., 10 be ..... cI ..to.., u_in& tltildrm 10 determine ""'i" ~li&ibi1Jty (or _ ...... t The ~L .... 1ok1irLa ~ by Lhe DepIrtmmt ...., ... oevttC thol I rrmly believe Chilcftn will be ~ by ~X(lusion r ............. "'e iflom forocd 10 hp ......... tbom.

T_' ... ' ... , ....... The 0rLly -r ..., _l.ipiflcoouly 8aase" IIUIDber ofpotlenu ......... IraIllOenl, iI u employ ....., stiff. •

c_ Spec"" 0nh0d0ati$I.

~o..ulSurpoao PrivJIc 0nI00d0aliIl$

..... illaria

Duo 10 die IKk ofltUloed persorIIIOl ... abilay 10 IIUK! C_lIancIa ~~ IOdIe~e~CU"""1y liaitcd. The_ ..,;ontyol_ilpr<I'"ided""~DcnIaIs..-.....-....! by die c-borII.. ne I'rivJI1: Onb .... •• """'"' I won: ........... , 10 ...:epI poI._ ........ 1be '-rdsalslq;.......,IiIII. Onbodoatit"Tbonp;p. .. "iD 1IOt I'CII!uu wail .. IiIu.

T ..... I •• The (utun! oftlw Sft'"iooe depends Oft our.bi!ily 10 lnIin our ... "10 be<:omr Speoilh" .. in onhociomiool. In mOl~ Counlrin 1I is ~istd!hll 1I"IIinin& propanorMI tore orprIi$ed Ihr<HIa:h Den .. 1 Scboolo. We .... w IwoSehooIt in Ihill Slale. """ in Dublin. """ in C<>rl<. The scl!ool in Dubhn illbo 01>/:1' .:hool within the l1li0 recocniH<! for post~. lnIinina in OrIhodonlico. I1 hu brm .,..,ioo~"'1y lIDhelpful in dn-.topmIInliDIII,~ fa IlIooc -u.a ... iChin !he pubIlc healIh system ond conavy 10 ..­

lUdo: Ity Jobn CIIrboo. • spe<:d"1CalIy ..,,,,,11iac IQ ""'"PI ~ &000 Cork. The odoooI in Cut looI .. m:optirion .. 1996 oaoI ~ die ..... .af._o.-_ba::n_ ... ~ iIJ""""II"IioL The ...... or 1999. "'1ocrebJ die C_1IaaI 0nI00d0atiM widtin die ............. ed IMIIhq were rndy ""Ilinc'" obl< IQ proovido pool ......... _, few ..,.SIdT_~IarIy~" ID 1999, fed "P.~lbelldtof ouppon ftooo Ibe Dentll Schools, Ibe RqioGal C ..... 1IIru ... poIII­~ II"II ..... ..........-oflbeir ....... Thit lnIirlinj.,...,.,..... was M ... be_sed .. 1999by ID SAC viI_ r ...... \he RO)'Il College of Surpm in London. R.....,ilionof. troin .... 1"fDSI1III1nC iI_.-,.lf onc ill to be ollowed "k !be If'OOiaIist euminalion or membership of Onhodonlita of .... of!he Royal Collq:eI.. AIIhe req .... ohhe D<porIIIlOllt Md WOO*" !he IMerlc=ooe or Ihe Denlll Schoolt IIIe lnIinlll, ~me ..... nfllscd ncolMiu! and cou.p.ed in May '99.

TH .he. 111"1"«11 of I'" SAC .lail ill I", .... EIfed .. SUn-.

R ........ ioftofSatf DilMtisfKlioft 1II'ith _job~ cu:. ~".-bmol_poliOIItI_ .. _

Siftl:e 1999 !he pubbc onhodo<Itic ocr;i<C: has bcCII very ....:II"'*''' ....... orb: ~I Sdw>oIo Md Ihe 0q00ruDeal. Yooo...m ~ IIeen:I ,. c~..cI Robm ~1",r ...... _tplCirlC c ___ 11 is aDosI .. iflbe J:laIlaI Scbooll hive IIIfF'ed w.... pen;o:ulot CoaulDaa .. briII& in..- ...,..lIfIS1IPPO'\iveorlllU CI_. We kDow IhII Triona Mc!' ___ hora&ed Md buUied by -...-. willl" Ihe

IlasIem 11 .. 1dI s-d. tnd IhII she """ pmocnled fnln> doin& her job propn1y We k,now thl! oamp .. :.. ..... oenior mantlCft'lCn11l>d indocd ... !he MiniolCf were I WIll. of lu..e. 11 is ._!ha! ... &Romp! ""'. made 10 rom: IX mipa1iM ofTrionI MoNomua .. C""",1Lln< 10 !he Eastern Health ...., .

.... 1InI!he LAC ...... irwed for further C ..... ulwll poRI in .... EosIcm II .. th BoIrd._iIhia&lYT ........ McNomara _IIotOlllhc iDlCrv .... t...nI.. HOMWf ....... ConouUnts .... Ihe too.d ~ Ihe DubliII o...u.I School. Cr.c.rty Ihe Dublin Da!W Scbool ... _ in • posIIiOIIlO

prOYidc • ....p hold .... COftl.llltont ~ in !be EuI .... Bath ..... Thn'c illlimple ooIwiM 10 !he problems rcprdm, pidelinel. Iflh. C""",lwlu wort.in& .. ilhin the Ser>;"c """Id ",CC! .. ilk !he Minlsltt rOt Health II>d kil ofT'ocialf in die t:lq>IrtrnmIlhcn very quidtly f;OfUeI!AII CM be IfI"'N 011 ,,'/IM pidclin .. arc to Ix UKd. Tbil will m .... IhII .... same J.cI ofcrilttill ~ in Ihe same mannerilllKd in.u bollldl boatdo. II_er, I do !lOt bcJ.evo IhIIlbc praeDCC ofw CbitfDel!lIlQfrnr would _ be oonducive ... Jflting...,...,..,.t

Tbc iJou!, reprdlq niniII& is"""" .... pIa. Hown..-if doe MiDiIIu _ !be EU dte<tiws. .... be .. decide ""'* tnJQinl ~ on: ~ iffOt ~ple_afkrnoua be"""'lOtbeCEO·. oraD Ibe Ilallh BoorOI """ .... them IO<:CIIUd -inJ inlu.1ItionJ .. lhc U-K tnd Nonhem Irr!Md. dial I bclltve th.oiltlinin, J>f'OII'II1IIII CIa be Id up. In

IM _'lIIIClM DubI .. SdlOOlc:.o ~ iIf_.-"" UUI"'IODd !tie xboolioo Cort..-d _ be forced ..... oppoinllnc ....-puoble and ...... 10 IM p05I ofPror..- ofOnhocloDl.ic:a.

lbo:tc..c pn>bIomt ODd \bore: ..c .......... buI ... leoo !tie ~ ....... otJd diocovu IM courqe to ogppoot!be P'ublic: H~aIdI Seni« in ..... 1raII1O lIIppOfI..,ewo Ourtal SC .............. b= win _ be ......... 10

"' ....... ""'" '"'

...." ,,,. New P. . Tra IlU. ' COfIIP"'. lleall 1112 947 3lH

JoI_ 0Irft0I:_ eo-..itIft ... lloallll ... CWIdrooI J.....", 1.". 1011

il iI ~ ... 10 dleh ..... ""'" quaIiIy.".. dfc.:Im: ~ ~

l' .... btao ... _il .. bo:_ ......

11 iI-,"" by evcryoo< 1110, IDCIDO)' .. DDI doe p!tIbIcno.

~ if.1OIutlon. 1, .. 1lmpIe _ .... no""" itnpIau-.

no.. onhodoaoc ......,.,... ... "h.in 1bo: ~ of Health. ..., _od &om &be Comt111IIII'Y C..., __ to tbo: Hoopi"" c;.., JCC!iooL

The ~ oclucMId much-=- wllb dIio policy 1tOOII19lS '" 1999. w .... n_UlCO~ __ ~""'''''''-_.

DuriatI "'" 1'.yat pcnod im"",,'emcnll 0<CWTed la OI'fhodonllC oeMc:a. I>MioIIIlly, every year

The ........... or ehikftD JOIIinI .,wily onbodonIic __ "';d! fnecl

opplianca "'=-<L

Hoabh BoenII ........ ,tod --. onbocIocDc IIlIiu -= \IIIil~ tuIr ... ...., ~

A' "'" _ ua.. _ otalf ......., 1niDcd. 1IIq1 -= will .... 10 d<aI wilt! 0IIh0d00>I>c ......... _ ID .. dfccti'''' oM dIIaeaI _ ........ ill """"""" or chiloftd ........ IrCalmeIIIIhrou.bouI !be 00UDItY

Satellite <IIthocIao>Ik ...... iceo ~ ~ in order 10 ......... < local _ .... for .. ~. !'UbI., maney bq.aa ID ~ lponI m<n dIkJ"'~y lU>d !he: IqII&ndtn"l of)lllblic _ OIl onbcdoDlic:t. whic:b was ~ ill _ Health a-dJ, .... OIl

the doel ....

While not icIcaI ~ ... rencnI ...copolioa _ onhodonuc...,.i«o "...., ""P"OI .... IIIIionaUy. and _ "'" ~ ...... tllir.

I"robIaJoo "'" Old!. """'" ..,.;n ~ '" k <k- bo:JI III .... ovcnIl ~ we ............ III "'" nJIII <Ii=tioII,IJatJ<>DOlIy, ",do ~ ..........

n...e ........... _ ....... op=aIioI~ .........

no. cl .. ", by" Dq.rtmcm. 1hII1be spcaaIist oolbodoooUtta· """,.,.,. per .. ,..,n 001"" 0<It probIemIio ....,...

llIiI !)'pO of Im""'I _ ha foiItd .. Ho ......... MlIOIIaliy ..... win foil .........

la raI>I)' iI ~ poIiooIIa' ~

lI ......... ~.~_a:aIdbc-... __ ..... JCI _...",. die...,., I],,, yeIB.

Mc. ...... 1laood) u tmIIIYeS .... a.Iy ~ • cIoaI ... ..,. ...... ...... 1 ....... " will deIq -r.ID'" _ Md bode ... 1999. by IS ID M_

n...e iI ....... '" ·"""'· ...... Ibe sugeoIJOII of...,.tiJrt ~ ",co Ibe pri'''' -All "'- ..,.wled 'new' .y ...... hr. .. b=I tned by the J)qIarvnctlI Ho .. ..... and ha"" foiled .. and tbo= i.o ovidc:a<:c cverywhen: IbII they .. ill tail .. . ~ My ~ 000:11 weIcooooc .. ~ ofooUoodoolbc IIWhar-. tu _~ .... 1ack.~by .. o.,:--ofchrir.cdL

SbooIld ali;w.n.... iI-. b< iIIEroob:cd ....... _ -......d ny • .. ber.ua. c!--. eYeD ....... .-. if; il>c\itaIok.

no. ~"""'-"_ lIooopcciabsl ............ bdp .........

llIiI rqiSO<t ~ 0I'Ib00I0atIc p<aeDoe.

~Iy I broe pr<Mdod .,.mry cffic:J-. ....- .......... ill both !loo w-.. _ Boetd _ ~ HeoIdI -.! ,.Jwq ~ b)I !loo

~or""'\Io.(I991·19'J9)

W .. I .... 1I..t1~ a...n! &: EMUno Heah.II ..... n!: '",1· "",

For !he We:sc .... H""lth BoArd, I _ -1inI ~n>CI f'rom "' .... 6 re- 10 2 ,..,...., r Ir$Incd four denli< .. ODd supt1Visod I ",Ut.JO.d or ov ... 3.000 pIbcDII in fued oppIoan<a aMUally. I lCSIablishcd and "'" • =l1"1li unil id Ma11l1 """' lioopllal. Golway _ -'11", oervi=I in c.tIcbar. R""""""", C1oromorria, "itb ~_ ........ 1ft Clif<krl ond 8aIIinL

w .... "'" "'PI'O<' or UIIIVCRlI) c..Ilqre Gol",-\,. I ~ id .. ~ ... !he Medical Foo::ulIy opao up doar M....,.. · or Medical Sciota prOp1IIlIIIIe, wild .......... _ .. maIIcaI ~CIlIy.

No! .... 1I dus ~ _ ...... opal"""" built .. oI.>_ le> p/wmIcists..d od.... ~ rohtrd pDOl.~

I bcpa w<d f'cr \he E-= IIcohb _ in 1996. W,1h;a 1 ,..... 1 mduccd ......... lisIs fn:Im _ 18.000 le> 6.600""" .. I ti ............ !he ........... fc:rrsI rue ODI(J "- li$U .... 2,000 pMoenll.

All C.tqOfy IlisQ wore _, ,..,th Ill<! I esLabllsbod • outCCUM fytICm ... berd!y

.n CII<IQI'JI I ~,!Ct". for the R_ ........ seen il11ll1<>diotcly ond ItIned ......un.em wi,I1I" ,; . ......... of their IUOSSlnenl. 1 redooed ...,.;tl.,. tin>oII for CoIqory n ~ by 3.')""'IS ond proYided_ """ics lO .. n c.ea<>rY III poricnu. ! .....:ned 8 deotIaII and hid ....... '.000 pooIIeDIO '" filed oppr,.,.. """""'"'"

As .... U. ~ .... 0<:Ea'I0I onbo>dI:JaDc ~ id 51. J ..... • .. l ~ ODd .., -une tcni<:ef fo< pMioI8 iD W.,_ -... &11'-. C(1OIoot, .... eIlmouaI ond Ballypl in fiDps.. _lnro.. Kdt.nck. LMI<bd~ C .......... AIby."_ond~.

As ill do<: .... ......" JlcaIt!t a-d, lily 5Iaff o<'ld. 1 ~ WIth II1II" """""'Y _ eone."... .nd bold ~ dmoco III .... n:~ """- ""hI> ...

poIioooto 0I11i11f.

"T'bo ___ ............ doffi::ulbet. """""""" ~ ... ill .. _ _ , .. ~ __ ..... 1_""'_ •. """' ...... oouId

be boiIl .... if. ""'1teJiaL

"' __ .... ~.,.w otn1oe .... ~ ... ~ ...... ".er: .... o.,>u1=" "'U...wo. .... _.IOlIy,.an ,._ • ., ,. ""' __ J'I'OIr. It .... I ~HJ IIoppy _ prodacdw _ loo .... LH.a.. Jot" • 11 ~oot ..... " loo .... W.II.8. 1t,,· .. aIJOfair"'C>'~

~ ... " ..... 'mY much p.¥t of thiJ .-fW procea NuneJ, ~ clerical Jlaff. all. w= provi<kd ",iob "Pf>')I'tImiu.. for .... ninS """ staIl"devdopmml N_! tniD<dha\.., """'.., 10 do fannaI MSc', ..-:\O<>e""'" "'" IIrot Lnsh onbodonuc ...... '" otala. • prize 11 • Briush c:Jonbodo:mic

''"'-All ..n: boIh duooc:aI ..:I _ ,h ..... l. w= ~ 10 IdUIOIod ___ ..:I ................ ~ I pDck>ddiaialstall"lOdo _.-do """'" _Ihq­ptIbIiMcd """ pr-.! _ 11 SciaI<dic C...rer.- boIh ~ .,., --At ... eJ.Ira "'* =, ' ..:I "'" Dq>ortmo:a: or tIe8hb .... IiDc qItIIIt)' ..,.,._ for ...... oIpmoooa iDlbeEHB:£R1tA Rep.. At"'" _ time. ICMCa ....... ,..,...o.d. ...,. IraID<cS n:.:a_ npcn IkIIII ..:I "'" oppOrtImtI)' ""

develop !btu ~ ..:I ~ !btu ........ c:&pKi1)'. ~ .... IICCI alto hmcfilOll .. lite It '*' «>It .....,. 000.000 10 obIain onhodoootic: tI1!IDi", and qu.hficMion AJ ."".oo,d_ r henefilCd by beiaI iD...,..... 1D ...w,. .,., iDl<n!;tint: \O,ob ,.,..... keen. morivaled """""'"

Tilt De ... " ..... , of 11 .. 1,11 .... __ III IlK«Uf.1 pOIky loo I"'. TIob 'poIItlcal ..-bIII· l1.li ......... 11._ &ad """rllOloD rw n' • ..,.ono, pa,ltata, ....... to. .... 1tIe ....... __ n. ............ "' ......... I.... It 11&0 ...... _

tn __ •• '.1 ...... be ~."""-.I"'" n'HJOM.

All .. ~ dI&I Ud bcctI1nCd ..:I1ailed iD ....... .., _ -~~ ~ .,111 &0"""';'::" __ ....,.,.. ....... ll!c M! 11. Jp(OIIbot

..,.,.""'" dI&I t.d boa ~ ill ~ Ib/d! IkNord looM "'" E.a.H.A.'"

... ·\Iel ...... 'rIo· i ........ wkIe.

Ilo:opk 011 .. ""In -r. <:lIfII......t.a. ""Ita opcaaI.-. c:otno ~ """"' ~ le> the,..,.... _. c:otno-. ......... Jt-.... _ ......... ..,.nIIIJ ..u.cIoottk _ .... .....-. Iloe ..... ry . ..... bad< .. , ....

a-ae .. .....,.!od wilhia .... ~ of H..tIlL All .... dtffioubs ~ by orthodoatics CIIII be uxed t.k le> Ihollq)onmelll oflteallh.

~ fi..c ~p fot 0<1b0daDlic .... icet happened boIek In .... 1980' .. when ~Jy, onIIod.onllcI iD Health s-do ..... oepInUld ond...-l from ............... "y eatt: JII'OI>'.mIC 10" HoopiIaJ prosnmmt.

The Depwneat ofHeal1b .. Ibc <mIy pIax .'hac thiI-=!**_ hoo _ UIkaa .... 11 .. __ le> """",,"",'" """",*"'" ___ ...-....... a- do::

C.-..ty ....moo. 01 doe o..p..m... tJl HoaIIb ond ~ it le> .. H ... 1aJ ~

T1IonI< ,.:. for ., .............. oppot1UOICy le> ........... pt I _ J wtIh )<11&

__ ill Ionnprot -....lily*" .. ~

TrIoIuI\1." ... n C_aaIOrt ........ I .. ,

JoIooo ou-..~ _ __ 00IW ....

n. .... :r 14-J--:r lMl.

'wUII .. _' __ io.~~_ .. ..-...""' _ _ .... , ...... _-."'''' .... ''' ___ 1ot_1-'-".... t_ """"""" Oorat s-.- ill Ma,..,. ,_ ..... )'11 _ ~ ill onbodontIco -..I from 199) ..... "'lCIivdy .. ..,,-' _ Il1o Rop..! ~ Depor-.." oat .... y_ My ebrucat ....... ....r_ .. -.. III t99a t ... .-, _ <Jl ModIeat Sclooooe "" l.wy <Jllllo ~ ono! _ -.. .- <Jl ctdt bp IOId potaco ... _ .. "'" "'OIl <Jllreiooll. ..

UIOUl 1993 ~ -.. buo<aIIy,.. --=......,.. ioo .... W_ tkoIdI_ """'" _ ... __ by iIIdi __ ill pR..,..-. Thoy ""' ...... -'_lkII"' ... -..IOO~"tIoo ___ '-~ ..... "' __ .. __ ' r EE .e t t _,.. .... .... ____ 1iII, __ ..... _<Jl_(~oo. __ ~.t....,. .... ......"Ihoy .... ~_ ........... "" ___ • lot ._ ..... boo; .... if Il1o _ .... _ ....... IOId ... "" ... ",--<'OIIId_"'~_"'~~ ... _ooI_ ---O"'<JlGJfi .. _ .. IWlII_· ..... poot_ ...... ~~t939 _ .. ......., _ ~ """""I ..... MIJ"> -..I __ .... cto __ .... fIoIIi""" .... ee:-- <JlHoolth t98SebJibit", I:I'I1IIfIo. ,. Ma)'O ... IIo<I __ "'. __ ... _ ... ..,., 'O'IiWII .... _ .... woitin ....... I .. __

"'- OIl )'MtI, boo In -1 • oipifi<oal ~ <Jl _ ctu_ """'" _~ onIIodarIIlc ~

In _ 1992 Dr_ Tnou M.:,,,_ -1IJIPlilIIOd ........ - """"""'" '" .... W ..... Jbhh _ -' ....... _ -me up ..... -.... •• I Rep..! 0.- Som<&t ..... _co.lIOO Ma,..,. cw..., ... __ SIlo .... 1be_ .......... Mi<!\\' __ -.t, ___ ..............

by .... _ Mr Tool Mt."-&- 1 _ .. _ .. It _ """'_ ..-w,td .... Mr_ Tool ___ ..... la .... _ .. pub/ie ...-... ~_ ._100_ E ,,_-..1-'<01

-" ................. i<d ~ 0.-.. ~ I .. die r-P* '" ,.......... I .., ......" lliply ,,-..'fC ... off>eioaII .......... ,... ~ Hoit .... ~ ..... qooIifi<d_ ........ , ..... ..-"""' .. tc.....-_~.dIe ____ ~_io ~ 1Ii .... field <Jl __ loo "- boa! ....... , _ ... .;.., _ or

__ la Ibe ....... <Jl_ <Jldle'-": 1.-..11 -..I _1 <Jllhe Jp:CioIIoOI: _ ....... """'*')'- All""' ... __ .. U_ .... ,w,_.n..

..... """"".....-..""""""'

no ....,. ft. 1I.c.,..ol 0.-~ io. GoIWI)' _ o/'IIciaIIr ...- ia I~. 1100 elfod .. d>< _ ill .... rq;a. _ -..y_ W ..... _ "" _*""""' • ....-,..d ....... y...-... __ "' ...... ..... quaIII}' _.....-. ...... _ 19904 ID 19\16,."'" '" '.llJ ......... _ ..-.",. ..... .....,. "' .... _..--..,........-­~ ..... Bdl .. 1997). AI d>< Lm< "' ............ J_ 1996 ... "",_ f« ___ !WO _1OId ... -. f« ....- --. Mr \\I,u- MonD dID _ Ocaonl ~ fiIr GU.a, Rc:~ ikIopUaII ....... 01 Or I.kN .... "Yoo hne do .. kIpod. _ ......... os""'",1')' of oIllOld)'Oll ....... onouIdod.1DOII --. otllled IOId ............... ..,..,"_ Ho t\ItIIIor ....... "11 .... _ • _

pInouro f« .. ,..11 1OId ... Ut .... ~ T ..... "' ...... _ted ""111)'011 ..... upetlollood Iho """"'f'" wart wbio:b )'011 ha .. OI:hieveor'.

Tht n ... Mlr ~ ~ ,..;m • hiPlY _ ................... .." W<I<b<I 10 , ___ In- 1!l97. Tht ~ __ IQ fuooaioo oomCocIOrily

..w __ .... e..:I of 19911 lbcII.........,.,. bopo 10 .... a,,\Iho" 11>0 w .... _ .. _____ -.,_ .. 01 ____ _

... __ dlpblo' ... _ prior 10 L99'iI --= _ boI •• ___ no _ ...... for_ ..... bepoo 1O_1OId _____ _ -ThIS '-.-. _ "*- fGr ~ -.I PIft'III ."j .. ' ... 00Il00.- hb

.. ,...u ................. iII""'-I .. pruoDa. <I"Ihodoru: _ ...... ,.;0. .. b __ dIooaIc ...., 01 r-.. _ Ibo ,.- ]' ...... pII<eIo '" .... _ 01_ ........ JI<OOII'riIJ' "'"' claldmllrl Ibo W .. 01 _ .... f\odiIrc it _

"' ........ -..-~ Tho ............. IOId .... ~ 01 .... r. ... """"""'" .......,. .... IIod boo been very dill'lNh 10 """'-- ,.. previou&Ly _ ] ... "" _ ,_),-, __ ""Ill ....

W....,.. Ilooalth Ba.d IOId ha ........ ""'. of.""", to doaI"';lII _. ] 110 .... ~ .... pri.R fee por il..... It is lID! "'* .ffectl .. ,CO" , He&IIIt -. ..... lnclopaw;Lolll onaI)Oio 01 .... «lOI "' .... !WO .,...... _.........:I ... I ..... W...,.., tIeoIdo &o-d. Fur •• ~ "'"' dol<! _ Ut .... pri ... ....,., "P '" __ caoIdbo _ ~"" __ Iodl<l"l« ... !>od. Tbo .... _ .... _ .... ___ .... lDOIIclfeai ............... __

.. .....-. .... ~-_ for .... 1I$ _hod, ~"lOpqooob'r""""-__ for ~ Th< ','"'' Iloo _ -....- ........ 11 iI ....... "'"' --'r*-"irrt __ .... ~ .. "'t:..LIOId_bcioI_ .... r __ cntrodoooo< _ ~ 01 ~ ..,. puom1aL ..- iI DotrIia. 1_ ~"'"'tho~oI_.a.....ddMo ..........

s,""'" /..J..~ I ": AIo..uIl.._. l'nt>:I!'* 00tuL $wpoo.

PII.ESE~'T ATIO~ BY

TilE ORTItOOO''TIC SOCIETY OF IRELA1\O

TO

Till': JOI" OIREACHTAS CO\l\1ITfEE 0-; ilEAL Tit ASDCIIILDRF.'

24TH JANliARY 2002

'Oor ~ So<"')' oIl_ .... ooIy ~ 1IocIy._..- ...... _.111 ... ",_""""", -....,~...-..-. _ . .- .. ,... __ """_""'JdoIi<_ .... ..-_ ... _ ...... poon_ 'Oor0Sl" oIf~_ ...... """ortd F_"'~ ....... __ of .... """'1 of 111< [_ r_ 0I0nh0d00000< Spoc ..... Aaooc:_

n.. OSI __ -'_ pn>f"""'" .. ~ ror , .......... ~ ... y 0(

_ ............ "_ -. "'" ....a<\d •• ..- ........... ..,..u... ., , .. "'.-&

I ............. _..,~ IOC'Id)o _ .............. __ "' .. 91)\.01

~ ........... h_ ~""'_~"'_~ ...... " -' ... !Ioo_plllad .. ~oI........., __ .. .,..,_ ..... ......,_ .... .....- .... ___ TIooosr_ ... _

~ '" l1li ~ 01 _ "'" C'IIikha. ...... ~ .. !loo _·Ied -..,"' ..... I« ........ --... ~~

~ ...... ~o(.-...y_..,"''''"...,........., ................ ""'f""""',",,,_""~ __ or,,,,,, __ ~ _ ........ y ........ _ballllcot< .... o.:e_h....r ....... _..-or _hll .... ...r IY..r <l<r""",'Y. IIoo<d 00 Ill< ptmoioo "'"' _ IS _>dod 10)

.<11 odtaIocI. "',11ed. ....r .. pcrien<Q:I ~ .....

0nI0>d00Ib<t " • ___ opo<ioIooo _ 01 -, • <Iof\8ooI ..,. [_

Doto<to,. "'''' ... __ ..... _!loo ~ C_I .. 1_ ......

~oISpocloII .. (en-1 ~""'-"_""""'-oI

~-----.~-. .. -~ .. ""---.--....... """"" .. ____ ... ..,.TIoor .... C_"'S"O-T_. r-, 1K";W) ""- _ .. ~ o.r.a. ... Ibc t.- ""'"" ... 0:>0II_ ...... ",IoN b. '.,.. _,~1Ioo<d __ .............. .:1-..1

- .... --,..- l;'-EI;_,.-oI __ _

_"""oI~ .. .......-._W_ Th<0SI f~ -""-.~_0I __ ""_0I'" ICSTO "1_" __ do __ tboE_,...uIoo_ .. _1CSTD

---' ....... _ .. ~ .......... or~ .... _ ... ...- ...... ,.. ...

~of_ ...,."' .... Ir<!IIId."'()Nol ......... Do _~ ~

0<Ih0d0c0i< _- 111_ T~1I1 >o>J ~l"'" ~ .. ..,Iootp< """.-""

- ...... ~"'- .... ,.:.,,<~--TIo< 0-.1 _ Soo:;"y ... ...:<to! puI:IIt<oboII ... -. .............. ',

..t...ood .... -.....,.- ... ...,..., 1tNIy ............... __ -..

......-......... -"- .. ...-.-.... ..-C ........ ""*"""" __ ...... _(;ryol ........... _ .... ·"' ... _ ....

... u..dtnory_ r .. ~f.-llle~dooIIaIl) ...... __ 01

_".n ........ "' ........ _, .. ) . .... --..<r "'" .... _oo.I\tIIl dot,,' ...... to;Jb qool,,>, rr.. .......... " .......... .... -. .... "' .............. hoopttaI_"", ""'..poll)' _ ... do ... The ......... . ____ ....... _ .... ~0I~_ ... .--..,_ .. _ .... ...-.,....,. ......... -.............. -1'lIa-< ... _ ... _ ....... ~,...1h<_..,.0I __ ... ,...., _ ...... _ ... ..-____ .. od_,_ ... 1oeoI.M! oat! r __ .lIy f_ ..... "" _ 0(" /\rot ........

c_ .. 191', • _ 01 -'I« doh....,. _ ooIopoooI _ .. _ ___ ol,....... __ TIIiII_... . __ ___ ........... __ IO...,.. ........... IOtI'Pl'lI> _

__ ... ~ ..... 0I_~0I ........ _.

_ .. p"'_ .... ,....... _. h_adopIaI .... ,...,....... _oo ....... EHO _ .. _, .. 19'J6" .. dlt.do<_oI~ __ "'"

--'1-""'" !Cl do< -'Y __ RqOooIl' .. ~ ........... fool"'" quoI,lIa! _ioI .................. ~Ioo""'"'_ia""'MI ___ ~al .... FHO

........ _I_IhoI,; .. '

S-.:kn_ ... __ b<_iII' .... ~a-_ ... _ .. ___ 1ho,.-.,,) 01_.- ___ ... ,..-. • .,. 01 ... ..-

...-.~ill~~" ... __ .. ooIal .... .........

_ .. r .. nll_pUbb<_'"-. ... _-...~ .... _ h ...... b< _0100lii0i ......... _ ....... alltK _ ......... -'< .... , .......... .. ___ Iy ....... -..pboc -. ia Ih<UHA <" __ ' .1.-01 , ...... --.Iy __ .... ____ ia

__ "'0"""- _...- <I' ..... _~_,.-Id _ho"ll. 1l>Ilo<d, ....

~~of ........ ____ """"'H __ .. ~lf_ .-.Ih<_of ___ bblcb-'1<t' __

~ ...... r ...... _ .. _ .... Sonoor, .... _ al ... pUbI _

__ H ___ ....... _ ............... prooIu<tI.d'al ...

or- ...... n.o ~ _ ... '" ........... ".,. of .......... _-..""_.tloo __ ~_ ...... __ OIId

... ""....._'''~of ........ IO_ ..... __

_~OIII"'l' __ boo4i<U"_.""_."'. __ --~. b.-. io. 19'JII. IM a.p..I ~ o.s--." f.-. ........ ____ ""_ .. oth.a...aI_ofl.~

Tlus ..... iIIc _ lIIoI i/I< M""", Report _ ,I> _""" OIl pn:IIIu<'''''Y -.""" 1Iw _ of nO.400 ___ ... per l"X'l- po!" 1_

w...oof_ outr,.--ty __ ~ _ ....... __

..... _of_,.,.. ..... '..,. ______ --ay_

.... Ilodprof.-..rr ... _of_

lboo<~ ... _ ...... "'" --....roll ............. _ ... hoto!My

..- be. ,01 ___ ....... okIi,ayof_ pnnorydmlol ... _-.po ..

_ .. L A" rife."". -,. .."...;n, ...- OIl .... 11"",_ ptltIUf)" ""'" ___ ........... _,_ of __ ~ ",-,>of _

__ pn-r ___ ..,j ....ay trl_ Id .... boopoloI ........ " I, .... 01 ..... _ .... 1 ooIr __ Id ""'~ • ...........,. _ ... ___ ... _ ""

pr-.y .... ~-.

""" ... r,...a ......... _ .. _s..:..r,...""'--"'"'-...-_~_...,. ____ ........ aoo,..-.iC

po-...,.. _be __ :!OO.---_,.. __ -u.'

n.. __ .. l<c~_b) "",r._,.. ............ so<..,-b) ~

_ "' ...... _ 000lE< ........ ..c .... ...,...... A_'- _ ....... """"" .....-- ...... __ """"1""'_ .... poJot _ n.e.--.l .. fOl'ld __ CanI -. .. doe """* _ .. Ill. _ '" OJIOO __ ..

___ pu<.- ..... Sl_ikJo!IoIaI1.ioil<Jf ___ .-yC._

.. -,. .......... <Of doe """"tAl on-.....: -'><'<. _ .... .0001 _ ....

~~ ......... ....t ... _r ... <loI'_ho ... __ C1DOI

Il-..nI ha< .. flo:t ",,,.«1 10 ... Ih< awooit<. "Ill< .)"t-. """" (91'. 11>0 ...... _1 Mol ~ _,-. ond _ failoo! .. """, <Iott>ond ~ .......

............... (;..,--"'_11 __ ....

k,._ .... ,..,....af_"""""'"..,. ........ ..--. ....... full_

- -,.-- -.-,......- ,..-...,ty."" - ....... ~"' .... -~- ....... -----,,-_""' ...... I"l' ___ -h ..... _"' .... OSl .......... .,...

-.1_.-..... _ p<f~ C __ ... " .... IO ... _<Jf _ ... ,1_ .. _ "", __ 1IAIl.1O r __ "-"""r

s",... .............. ..,..... __ cty r .... ondlll<r< .. ""-",,,_

~ __ '""" .:...,.....,..-.- .... __ ~ r"",,, far

Im-I ___ ....... .....-I)' 79 _oaI_d,JII>i< ..... __ ,"""..-.

1..- 1BW.<. (Ion-.y_llooIy. lOO),

•

TAIU: ,

~ac"'---------'---------" L~"""'---------- -",,_so...... ·1 .,

hobhc S«1of I'· --"~l'iIiIOiJ_ III

Acadonl< t'-..honi.

r---r.oni>oyC"C~

n.. __ ", __ "IM~" __ """'I __ IO ....... __ ...., __ ~-.dlloo.-"'..-Il

---~-......."",.. TABUl

,~.~ -.:.;~

10-1) I II

TIll -" +---W

RATIO

1017

in

TIoo .. pnoII" 01 ___ .. ,.,.....,. 60"\. ...... _ 20,...",

_. __ .... _""-""'_29...-_ .. _ ... __ I!.,....-OW ........ ~ ....... 20 ____ '"

_f __ ..... oI __ ._ ......... ...

... _'_· .. _ .... 01_ ........... _ .... 01_ ... 111 ___ •• _ poIobc: -..I pn.... """"'" __ ,.....t -, The DaIoioo o....a kbooI ~ "'-y Ill< ..,. ~ __ b ~ .E ___ oaI_ .. *.-. "" ___ " ....... __ ... __ .1'" IIyDrs.y., __ ~""ll..,... ... '_ ............ , ..... __ III o ___ ' ___ .oI ____ .... ...m.. .. cI&.

\be......,.. __ ""'_oIa...-~_' __ "" dr.o_,.-IO~ __ "' .. IO ............ _ ..

.....-y "' ...... n... ___ .. COfIOI>I< "....-. .... _y..o ,,·Q ......... _oI_~ __ ~yifr ...... ".....x ..... 1abI< .... pOnd "'" C",*, !)moo[ _ r.:ililieI

ro .. " .. ....-11"" .-.... 10 "'" ~,.;'Y or topotoaI ~ ... , ........ _u· ~oI"'_1< ..... ...-ioh_O'., ... ll,-.....,. .... n... __ ,.,.,....L""'yS ___ ..... __

Of .... IO..-_ ...... "' .. __ .......... -""~_

-. -..I ... -""" .... __ for _,-. --.-nc.-. Of Ill< I! ___ ,...."'lOOl_., ...... op:-..d..,. __ .... aon.dy~

-""'"",,",-

_O"-.......,.<JK __ .... o...I~_,....... _ ___ " .. ..,.,... ............ _ .. ooody._<JK ....... __ k --

""-...... -"-I r .......... <JK .... _ ......... ...-. -.cI_ -". ...... <Lilo< ... <>od ,1_ "- cl"",..-w,Ic.qooul ~

T_ t"onloll<l __ .. otafror...,;o..a! ................ '" ___ ...

_ ..... lOoerv"'.~

sa..-of_ ror6yan _l_ondl P'* ...... ,1I0:.0I ....

lD- ,.-...~1 ...... "-

l~ .. ____ ........ ..-*""..,."'-oII" ........ "'.-ol -------"'-""'-""'--,......, ........... ;p ... _..- .. _poOdo< .. ..,.-. ...... _-

R~ oI'_apoc ........ IS '''''_1 _ IIWCU .. __ • __ .... _Or .... " ... __ .... --. .. 'C.

lbm:_...,..,u) I' I"*" poolIfnd __ .... """ on Ul(;lIs.<.. _of",""", _to.~"' ...... ",,,,,,_ ~_ia ____ "' _ __ <JK .................. iold<d' ..... ---__ ..-tlI_ ....,....1:1:: l...-__ E ___ "'~'"

_of.....,ao,.- _ --"" .... _ ... _puIob< _ .... _.-r .. -. .......... _....,. ....... _ .. __ .......t...- C-,.

................. ~....,. .... """" 10 <pI:CW1i1S _10 1IiIr1ed .... .......".. I IritIo. ~ lit. 1 l:S __ l ~ __ a_ of ~ otafr hoo _ .. '" ...:n

- .. ~ ....... _-- ............... _,..,.-,....,.,.. ... """- ...... - ....... "" .. ""~.......,..,. ..... --n..,......""""'IoID ... _ ... ...- .... _ ... _ot ....... ot ~ __ .-...-~_"'" _____ poor .. tO .. Io. . ...

• ~ poIb,.~ ....... _ .... ~ poor __ oft"_!or""'''' __ ~..,. .. d.ff ..... _. The """" ~ ... _ """iohoI .....- .......... «1

_ ID lie ..... "" lho _;_ ... """oolia.,. ......... _ !u,-. """"Iy .................... ,111 110< USf-A ID _1Iw _"'1"_ ...... ...".. ..... _ ....... p<*. Tb< ...... ~ for. ruu ...... 01,..,.1 __ otOlOlT

......... ID ... oil ,-. •• .-y ~y 7""' ............. ___ 11" ID

... 1oopo<I'" _ •••• ~I:.' __ • .....u _.me.. .. __ .... __ ".._

1t_ ... -'_ ........ -... .... _ .... __ «I"' .. H~fA. ..... ... )'<I_~ ............ ~ott; __ CWoIt-.n..OSI_ ...... ~ID...-_ .. _ ...... t

~ ... ,_-.......~, ... """'*""' ____ ot

c.rc ...... _PfOO'_ .. ~ .. ""'_ ... __ ... ...,. .. ........ 1Iot ...... __ ~ ....... _

o.t-. "'">I,,,. ... _ of ____ ...... _ 100'. ot

_ ........... ______ ..... ._ ... _ n.....- ..... _ _ .. ___ "" .n.a -.. -. .......... ..-...,. ____ .. --- .. ..,. ..... ,..,.~"' ..... ---. ___ or-"""'1omdiI. (st.- .... 1981)

n.....,....,. ... __ iommod_IIot .... ___ ......

.... '-:Io ........... poo~, __ ~iI_ .. _'"".-doo>d lst.-oI

.. 1 ..... 1'IIII...-.iI. ___ ..,_ .. ____ carry

..,. ,..,..,.,...,.. --. T1ouo __ • __ b<W_iII_of~"""'_. __ ____ .. .--."'· __ b_ .. _ ..

............. tor· ...... " ......... f..-~_~..s·_

... __ DtouId lor"- """'..- _ ~y r-. .. ho)lhcr ID "''""'

__ "_I.....mo...t. __ :ZOOI~OIIIImoy~-. .... __

......... ~ i. r .... __ '" -'''''"' h"..-...w..,..n.n<e ............ _ for

onlIodo<I<.: _ boo Ih< ~ .., ""~ .... "1*01 of ~>« '"

.......... ..s .... __ ............ bcohII_ .. _, ... _k."""_ ~ .. --.r)_IO~ ___ .-I-._-"~'"

.-do_IodID ...... .......-of_..-of~~"""' .. ,m _._ ...... ~~ ____ ..... J01".'_.oIl"ll

_..,.,."....bodIo ... _..s ____ of-- n.. OSI r.._ ... _ of .. -. ""'" .. 10Th ... pOlII>< ___ -.. ;, ..

-.....u, _",*"" .. _ ODd ",1"'- .. _...,.~ "'....,. . ..s_ I>< _ ~"".....".,..- "b,oc'",'y _ Ih< _..- oflh< 0.,.- or H .. h".-I~ [1i~"'I"y __ Dopon""",,..;.:Id_"-y .. _ID -"'" 11-201<001

12·~ <>Id l""I"'l* ..... or 10.000.12.000 <hlli\>l< <Md "'"" y_ "I*'"*<'" ol ....

""~ ....... ( ... oII1OT~ C_"'" moy~ell.,to;h'y ... '(n~of 12_

-. .. 11.000 -211.000 -=- per year_ n.. ..,.. ...... of _ -'<I to< _tooI_ n.. ................ ol""" ..... _ .... ",011_. IOT'o _ • ...t j _ .... __ olLl6,OOO'OOO

........ ol ... Io..ood ...... ~u to b< p;o.ad _ .......... of """_ aod .... _

_ ...... IN) bt_IO_._o!i_of ......... I"l'~'" __ .. _of .... ,..-.·.I, .... pOy ____ ..... _.

~ ..... of .... _ Ao:I aroM_"" '9!ij.

So .......... .,~

ThcOS(_"'-"I~oL ____ ","_,,_ ---Lo.t .... __ rI-"I

2_ M __ of ...... IoI ... Io<aI ............. ..-_by .......

.....- -'"'., ......... ''''' ( ... "" ..... -no. ~ _ ......... ICnI<IIft 01 ... ,.- ...- .... "'" _ be

pI...d ........ lot ... loo'doL ...... ""'._y_ ..... __ ... _ ~boIo_be_by __ s...-. ..... _< __ coIJ ____ ._ ... '-'-'"

__ r._""'Iov<i ..... _~ __ ....... __ ..

-"'Ry.,......,.. ... _,'e"cIo;:_ """"'1'"1....- lot deh.<t)" 01_0« .e;

"-',"'"' ........ _or .... .,. .. .....,""'Alancdpubl"' .......... ho<h_ roquo .. _-er _ on pr«Ii>:Il.,ty of200 ,_ pot ~_ pot~""'"

or)(l(l p<f )'COr .. ben tbo.,.m.bll .. ....,...xI«l by .. -""'-

I. ,...,\AI P""'''''''' of scn-i;:e .. rt!>io tbo "", .. _ ....... l>I~ I>y u.. <t<M>OCI

o(.~ 0(,........ <l.p..blty_ .. .-..-it .. ",."". .. ~.

L ,, __ oIno..-__ ,

n.._ ...... ",of"'" Hoopo!;oI....;.;." ... _""'_lot_ ... .-..! ... _ ..... __ --. ..... _ofll.6l6 ... __ _

".'I"IS_-._

"

Kooioio BOoinI· ...... " ...... "- A ...... y ....... --. - IUilt - + ~

~~ -S:96l-- + -",4'10

r ..... I,""~ -'>;Qnb... ,-, '1.173

W ........ '" 1~ --;

Mrdfw; - ",--~ ,;,-- .., ---l

'"""" ~ .,

~ .. --..... .. -.. ~ ..... "''''''-- ........... --_1'112 .... .,,""'_ ................. __ "'IIonIlw_'" = t=I.~ ....... , .. _ ..... "c""_",,,,-, __ ;,,, ~u ... _"" ___ It .. _I)~ __ ~

olIcpI .. 01"'" """_ .. .-"" ." .......... Jor~ ..... _~ .... <111) .. don)- ...... _ .... to,. _ '" ~;poilil)l. If _01 pi<I<Imoo _ '" be _ ..

...... poo ..... ",Ill ....,.. .... <d ..... _.,. "- .... __ be "",,_

.. ,lllo~ " M '" OM<>ths of ... fernl

T_ " .. , ........... ~, --.,w. _ oIodot ..... ~"" .. ,--.. .,'-"c_-,"' ... toqo;...t .... __ <-'I)-

"' ...... u..l_ ......

I.~"'~~

n. .. _ ... SOW __ be.-..J.lOOl .... r-._ ...... __ .............. __ s.do __ ....... be

comod _ to,. .--...,_ .. _ odooII) be pnWIoIod 11) '_'

"

_tltlf ....... __ .... ~~uf_U" __ _ .. ""' ... _---n. .. _ ... ____ ....... _ L .... r...C __ _

_ IUUlA) ... ..1) __ .--____ ""' .. ~

ML. _I» "'mduf~ JJO.Z. ilwill .. · • ..-tIoII' __ .. _

__ I>fI 01 .... l.soo. ... ,_. full ............. 01 ......... IlaIf I .....

....... H •• ltlo -....,.-. .... .,... __ -oioI "" ..... 1) l.S6J -.I ....... ~)I>o,Iatod'd' __ fnme..

~~~"Oi!!II..Il!!!..

_-....for __ dfeclmdudo:

•

~~oI~ ... ""- ..... I_ot_~ ~ 110) "'.-\HD .. _ ......., __ ........ _ of poIoio<

f..- ... r...""' ___ ot-..5u<Io_ ...... _ _ 01 ... ,.-01 ___ 01 __ "'""

""'-__ ""'p" .... _ .........

Foil f ....... ofJlri, __ re.. forol,,,,,"_

IJ_ .. Md lot c., .... poo_ .-y '" IkIoIIIo 10<1. ....

OIO)"iIc ~I<lhrao>p _oaI lI'oIr.....).''''' Rodo<'" f .. ID p"' .... If'«- """oil"" -. .. H_ -.J fO«l_ ~ dotecI ~ ... lot __

.... "" ........ _ ....... ~""_uf_ ....

........... --Ntr __ .. _ ..... c ""',....... __ to< _ed ...

.--I __ .. ~ 5GadJ 0I1maIoI_ to<...". .. __ ~_..,.oodo_l>o_

"

no..- __ ~,,' __ a

-"'-~~~--rr __ or _ op«ioI_ ~ Iloo """""_ ..-..: ~

pook~ ill """"""'" ""'" ...pao.oI_

c_""'_ ... ...- .... _"'_"'" pt<ICIio<u,~)or""' ...... __ .

~~ot_JO<"' ___ ot_ ... ~_

........... _"'_ ................ ..-.1 ... _.' ...... Iitb ...... _ •• ,......,

blf_ ...... _"'''''.-..,.. __ <!l:

11 ~ .... .....,.tyotpokl><_ ~) 1It< ...... ""' __ IIjI~.....-l_

"

Ill*< \.I, C"""OJ' \.IT. HcoIy B ,m], ..... l'fld* .. 0.-"- iIo _

_ of~'J'-

-'OJ,._I~A..II!I9oI)Th<_r.w~_ .. "",_

......-of""'l; ...... K ....... f __ of~ 16, J9S,19\I

_\\ 0<t!I0d00b< s.r.. ...... ___ =~ __ of "'" R..-.... 0....., .. Cbirf

E>-...otIlo>ottolH __ 0<t0!><t199&.

Protf ... ", Il,Fo<Ido,H\\ Imllc~~ .. )"~SlI_ -SbP,\\",C.\kIIt,S,[ .. _~D,S,II;/!(I):,,>""-... __ allIIo:

_of ___ -'IIi-IIn"""-oI~'.'$.

• su., .. 11 .(.11'181) F.n. ..... ......-. raaaldob",,,ynlbo,,,,,...ofrKiol

pooj"""'., 811,I0Il_1 or PIooto< Soqo<)'. lO. 2)1·206,

-.. liT hlloaoDd S 0'_ K-D. -.. P. 0<Id ~co 11991/ QoIobIy _ .. _ .. _of _______ ~

.-...&.11'0, In2·lll

_*A ~s..._."f-. __ ,A __ ~,-

PRESENTATION BY "

THE IRISH CONSULTANT ORTHODONTISTS' GROUP

TO

THE JOINT OIREACHTAS COMMITTEE ON HEALTH and CHILDREN

24th January 2002

~,,"""br.dloI~ __ "" ___ ol""'-'''''''''''' ol ... jroos.OIIII .... _oI __ ............ _____ "-

<ldlIipOllll,.... ... .....,... .. -.....*of ..... _jr<rt..OIIII __

"'--. ............ "''''''-. n.. ___ pobbc:_..-.:o-,· .. -....;p_".C ....... "' .... _ ..... ___ ~OIIII""') r...-poapI<_--.t>- ....... _ V __ rr- .... ~ __ "-"'"l' ........ ...-

S_ in .... IIc\cI or_ poydIoIoIy _ "-. oi&niJ\cooI ..... "'_ piII_ tI< __ from """""""'" .--. SIlo ..... oJ (19S0) i<I •• od)' ol_ldre<> .. ....,.." 1hIo..--. 0IIII ""'~ about 0tctII .... ,..". burtIUI __ ....... ""'"' bodil~ r ...... RMISIId .... (Im~_ .... (I9S0. 19I1~ Spolu .. "(19'))1 __ _ .. YIr) ... ~orimpn!>.....,.inodf ___ otlIlI,OIId-'_ i<I~ __ Jo-I...-_,O"' .... (IWS)f..-IlhooI~·odr­

....:cpI ...................... _.--....whil< !db<no .... (1'19', r-.d ..... _,..-._.OIIIIodf~oI_ .. _-...._~ ~ __ lIdr ___ affenod.

n.. __ oII""-"'&o<_ ........ -,..--..I .... (I9'ICII __ 1l.oll ........ _ .... (-.lKIIof~,..........-II) ........ _) _.-.60'lI0''' .......... __ • Itldo<~iI ____ ~..-...Iia ...... ..., __ "--

1JeIp*_-.r"...........-io.._ol_il_,..... .... ",' ....... _.Id; .. "'"l'-tAllcly ..... 19U.AdoIy .... 1990: 0.-..... 1-.~ ..... 19'iO>;Hdm_I'--.I'1I"*; ____ I_). ~ ~"'"'""""'.bMbllko __ ~bInmoI~ ___ &ooo: _t""'"'~ _, .. ___ .. "- IIIurdos>. 1995; 1ioI1OIIII ..... 1911. H_ et ".I990~"'" I·Nor .... I"'!"' __ i~ __ ("e)'._").or"lu<II 12"-~ '*l, ... ""-or~., .......... ol .... odi- -a. (&- _ K,..,., 1917", Eri<DlwI K""" 19171». Emomelydoopb. ...... __ '" .... __ mII ........ buI ... -...1~ .... dontal boaIth ....-ormolotcllllion .. ---. '" 10)' .... _

(Si.oo ...... 1991)

lloclft'--.ol..-..... __ "'III<df ... o(lbaidc ................. _

~y ..... .-.- _ .......... oi«a) (0''-1-. ..... 1996~ IIri>oo _ 1960', ___ .... _ialmlt,...... ___ boooI_ThB ..-.......... " ............... - .. _ ..... _ ......... _ .....

,_""""'""'''' .. ~find)_of .... _,.........-.....,. ____ .. I<-_~,,"".-y. _dIotdI~. ~"' .... ..,...III_il .... __ .s.-____ ._oI _ • .....-...,.-..ny.IIIII_ ...... ___ iI poroDd .........

1 •• -.o)' .. ~,_._--.nlpIoob ___ _ _ n. __ I.,.I~rf .. • .... _., __ ~_ --.

_tor __ II_<I9900I_ .... {199:S).aado..dooof I99:l1 .. do<UK __ oK_...,ia __ oK __ ~ _ __ ... _aad ___ .......... _ ......

_o(~ T_ )<;....J()(JTh.~ Tloio..-""'fip<II_*t·s.\", PubIi< , ...... $en_ill::.,.. 1917; l'r<Iftit,200n

1a ... 1tepobIl< Q(II'OlIoMI.".ooo cIIildteo..., """'"''«)'".-_ ............. ...-..., '" _0("""'""-'0: _Ib-.ld __ 11.000 ......... ioI_ r ....... _ ... ..,.r-....... IIoo_of~ .... -.ld_.,I:Ic _ __ .. an)' poruo:uIor ""'" -.Id b<~) ~.OOO, C ........ ~_""AC"' IhII __ I~ lD.OOOpoo;..oa .... ___ .... """"""

c:w...Iy ......... ~77lfOO1i6od~ ....................... ~ n.. """"""'of~(45)_IIIpgm,pri_prKtio<. lb<# .. ~ 1/>.10 .......... .....n.,. .. ,_""' _____ ..,..10 __ ia

.................. I __ .O<ni&-y<*'<'lo:od.aad4~

n.._oK ............. ___ io',.., ______ ... IIooEooo ---

1"'- ..... efllw ......... '....-...

n.._ ........... · .......... ..-ry ___ ofpoo;aa_ r.- ........... .-... ""_fto.-_ .......... ....-__ ...... _ JpO<ioI1oI:Q11OIi __ .. ...,. ____ ~_dot __ _

~~~ .. do __ ~ .. _ ... __ p&.. ..

......... .....-.aad.,_~~

, ~r.jm"'''-'' '''' ~20.j")~_) __ _

n._ ... ~ .... __ ;.r..n.-","""",._ I

J_ -TlIo_\oacdI.,r_",,_W __ "''' 11 24-.

-.. • .-.,.._oy<lt ...... _ ........ 200,....por~_"" _ ~ (o.d .......... __ .... b _~ 0iYidutI2O,00II by:1lJl

rauI ..... /!pr< of 100

~. 100 'fI« ... "" ",!bin!llo ..... -;.,. ........ b< ~ '" .... tbo ..... 1hinI of"'" """"",,,,,,,,,,",",,,Io....,jof_

n..cIill",.,...... ........... _...- .. _ ........ fWdIlIoMd_

-----.... -.-....,.~Poy ..... ..--......... --~ .. ill> _ ill. po;... JI'O"I<".

TlIc_ol ____ ri' ! .. _~IOd_ ... _ ..... __ _ _ ilr. ... ,...~ ....... _._-r __ ,..........,.~ ........ _....-vl ..... _n. ... .....". .. r_Yil:. \., __ ........ _ .. ____ -.. ___ ..,.il00_...,. __ l1li:)" __ .. -..---. ....... _

.. )od.oI_;,,~_~ .. cIuo: .. ___ •

(b)lr-" __ ............. _Ihoy_"""" ................. ~ ...... _ 1O ................. _ony

(0) 'I."..,~_IJ.... .... i-.ced, ","0001 u.,I-.oaoof"*"",, "'" dril'lUall.,-or ~ .... __ 1qbIy pud thoo """ OIIoor, ...,... "'" Iho _ -. .... u ~ btooomc: """"- Ie> ____

Id) .......... _____ Dt __ .. -.._ol~ _ .... ~~_-.dil_,~_ ... _.~_ ....... -'1- ... -. ..... _ ... _-' ••• -.. -&ory.

T ..... ., __ ._

c..-d)- .. <III1y ..... """"'" io IhoIUpoNic: lboI._otr.rl~ ~ InIiIIiRI: _ 111............-. is Ih< 0abliII. "-"I _ Tho Con: c-.. SdooaI _oIf ....... _'*-ilo... __ ....ft\o;coo_nf ....... _ .-.u; ___ .wr", ~ to (........0,. ........ OBIt .... full-time _ ....... _ '" ","c.n. no..! S<IIc>oI~

• AI-. ................... ___ itl ....... ia .... Dubbo 000taI S--r..... .......... -...~_ ... w'*"'_Bc.d._ia~ ......... SWAH8. ___ ECAHlI. __ CKII .. illla.IIo-aIB-.I $El1D. T __ ..... rua.-___ F_ol_ .. lII ....... __ .. lG02

(...,. ....... _t- ..... "HInll;.~It.o __ ""U_ .......... l(I(I2

no: ,..,.......:1 ..ttia "'" DaWio ~ ScIDoI ... ....-,. ........ .-. _ ........ _..tI_lObo:~IIIII __ fIoil.u<o .............. .. ............... ~ ....... A_ellbo:...--*-' __ """'"",..,. ........... _ ..... ~-. .... 0IiI .. ..,..""'"~ __ 1i>t fuIkimo ~ otaIt Seoio< ruff ____ ..... _ ... be _ id "'" Con: J)o,otoI Soboc>.1n ...... _ .opocIOboI ....... ___

In_f",.-... .. -... .~_ .,...,iQoI"~ I:wcpcan __ ~ ._~ __ ""'-____ EDIr)' .. IOI<h.....ar- .. oompctiIi .. , Tbo _whyadl_ hov<"'«IIDJII1_ EU~ "'ID o! ..... _.........- ... _h_ ..... ·~r..ao-I ..... ,r ___ IO_r-__ .... EUolqooolil'lod"' .... ' h

hnoldlt_ .. "-......... ...-_lIIIIpon .. I ... ~ __ . ~_b.~·.depw __ ... wiII __ .............

_ol_al"'RoroIC<>li<F'ol~oI"l'KIIIII_Io>~"" DadoIC_ot_"""""" .. ,.-ol_....._ .......... -<il __ """UJ'"7 n..--r .. o ____ "-"_'" ,.-.. ~ ..... ___ .. _Iido:""""'" TIoo Spo<ioIiA """"-t C_..,.. ...... ctMdo-.! 0IlI000t (1999) , ' • ~ of 11) InIII>iIIII "'*" in "'" DabIio. 0.....1 SdIDoI, ..all." .... Cork DonaoI SclIooI.-'" tM...mc-IOaff-..: ___ TbilWOlOld reP, ia ..... ..- ofl. """ .............. ~.....,.) )'<*01"" ............ ot6cverr,.-).1a ..... ..r .... 1'1<11boc 10_ ~ __ for .... _~ ...... _aplImiob<

IOm:aol, i1 """'" ................. of Il ycon ID tn.a .... ...-. "' .. oIIio ~ If -" • ..-... Iid!y....-.. IDII oaournintI1IIoI aIllrainm ..... boalth .......,..tr ond ~"d"'lh< .... iee_~·"'..,.a..IiIo""""

11« ... _. of~u f ........... lrtbad

A_ol ...... eo-k_.--.t .. _~ia~ __ .... ___ .. 60 __ ....... ~ __ ....... y--. ...... 1I ..... _ .... ,..Qia"'" ........ II1 ......... ____ ",. .... ~ __

S_J ..... I __ o--t-... ... SWAlIB"' .. E1lHA

Lp .. _ .... l'" ... __ ... .-_ ... --._ ... _adf_ ~ ... _n. ......... _"'_._$t I--'~'" _1nIiIIiIot~ •• ~ DI~. n. 1InmII0000000000Soaccy Ill' __ ~(lOCI;) "-'d ..... 1Ioe ................. "'_.doo ut.:._;,_, ......... ""'~_..-...

v. ... sud:I.~ ........ "'Ih<UK.;,io..bbly_II __ ....... ~'"

=--fot~----.

I .... ~ .. doon: ... t:S-~

A ....... "'I ......... _....-Iy--..d .. _ .. .,I.:K.~..,._lo -" .. ""'l'X.,_..-......... llS._io __ ..,~

AlSwl ..... __ ......... ""_; ..... l'SA.~ .. blldy_.r...,..-..101M Md_ .. lm.t. .... ...,...;a ... ~_"""" ........ __ I ...... ' ... ., ... , • ..... It< • • d •• ~I.poriol;rioo

lD_ror.~ ... .,..lC.IO .................... ~_"'<iooo<aI ........ _ Mdloobonllor>' """"'" MlI>Id ... ....dod.

" f ... -:lollP«ool ...... __ ..... _ ......... IO_ ...... Eo<b ~_ ..................... lOa/toad .... ...,.....,."-' ........ --.ol

~ .............. -. s.~~ .... _--.dopeciailly .......................... __ .... ___ .............. _' f '-tDY_s.a..:. .............. ol., --_ ........ _--pr;..--'"- ....... ....--• ...;or __ .""'_ofpooi«O_....,. .. ~fot_r..- ...... -. ___ ....... -.oadb ... _ol...- .......... .... ;-....., for obo _ ol_ ddiormiIy. I'I\lIIIiI (19901) _ ... "" 10 O.~ol .... -..........--_-<OI1KOI~.....,.-"'"' __ lo __ J

l5O_...-_""'~"""'71*("'~""'_-.n 'J'bo_"' ..... """'....,.,J~ ___ .... _of...-_ _ oad ..... -.. ______ ..... ~ ..........

____ ~ JIIIJlC"IJpOO ........ oudo .. ....,..,..,....,~..."..,., ENT

-.aY, ond p;o.ic: .....,.

'J'bo __ lOpop;dolioII'- "l : l~.aoo._"" ~""bod!."" __ US ~olOnol_~;'] S.--. 1ft ltdood, "'"" __

lo~_ ..... oad~lw.n.I_~ .... """""'Y.ewn..dJ,tho:n: .. ft", _-......) iooDob];,o,_ "'Cork_ I .. L __

SOLlTlO'1i

I kECkLTnol£:o,TOf~P£ClAlJSTI; :t TRAC>NG OF SPEClAUSTIl 1 RECklJTTloCE'oTOfAlIXIUA1UE5 • PkIORJnSISUI'Ane.~fOll11lEATloIUoT ,. I;T1l.1sc-:GnIEP'lUVATE~ 6. r-.:SIJaA.'lCESCHEMES

IlECRI'I]MOOOf 5PfClAlISTIl

~-... prionl,' _ "" .. _ k> ~ oatf...- .... ben or onbodonI!oa..; ..... ,,,,land. h I. ""',<dy 1hoI._llUlllbeBof """""""", ......... "'""""'" fr<m...-.de I!>c s... to, 10 '-1. ooJ.,. .................... oad ~ hov< 001 been -.... .... f<o­~MoIl~_oIf<t-._ .... ~_ 1a1llo ...... _Iht_tyol_IrisII __ ...,._ ....... _-.~ _.--" • ...,.......IIIOdaIit3-._....-,.-idIio~u ---\1.'_ • .,.,."....., -r .... ~..;n_ ....... .-. ~iado< _ ........... __ A_~}I __ ...,..!(I_rl 1 .,"

...... ia__. ..... __ -ol, ... ------__ . """''-'1_ ioI __ _

1 UAI:-I:sGOEstEC!AUSTIl

1'00 1I"IiIIIrII-"1 .... doo Republic: islimnod, E_ ..-ill> dIO ..--.... ...,m..-,.-., .. bo<h Dmto! S<t-Io (-.. __ ..... _..n-...... p/oa-). • ..-

tB, lJ , ....... "'" _ opWIIl_ f<>r<a<l. '" InIiII ",fIk_ opociaI .... rot IN pubbc:

~"'''''_'''''<IJ''''''''''''''_IN'-IIh ..... 'ioo'''''''InUIIinI:('''~ "

1 RECB.\.!!I1otOO or AI'Xl! MRIES

Or-.c'~ __ ""'_"_~_oadio""'USA'" c-.- TkM ... ......-fr<ma.dmIoI-.u. ...... .." ......... _,- ...... _ ""' ... _~ .. __ ""_ ..... ol .... _ ....... ....-"",.....·-. __ --. .... ........-01 ............... --. ~, .. __ IO ....... ~~oad_bo-'""'.oII_ c........,.~ ............. _ ...... It<Iood. .... a. o.-! c_ .... ...-• ~ 10 "" M-""-' blbldo blheU ~

, 4. "IQBmm;a 'ATJI::'iU; fOB IBEATMfXI

L'p .. .-...Iy, ... ..., ........ "* IIos '-'..- ill ...., 10 whocIo _ ....... __ ilia ...... rr- .. o.q.-...ofHaldo~-,.n-'9U ....... 1Ir.""·~·n._ ..... aripIoI~ .... ..-..,--........... b -. n...._l....,n..-....,.,. "' __ ,--..... _ Op .... ~......,.9. __ pm-.widol_......,..., __ I,~C-_.__ - 'MM ), _____ fII1_"'IIoplo<ed ..

... -~-1 • ...,...,.... ........ _Ia~"""""' .. -rtoo...p-riIo .. """"""-SornoIiool"'-.t ..... bo ... ......m._<Jl.rn._""_ ....... :u .... ll& fOt_ o(_.-Iy ..... ~ . .....,1<_ t.v.. _ ..... 1i .. fbt_or l,OOO poti<nIt. ... i!h .. _ ""' .... timo or"" '" , .... ~ SD<b kq: ,.,.11."$ lia ... ~ ........... ill pot-. with...,. ...... .,_ .. boiDi h", ,.,," .......... I!ao .. tth IeuorptolllomoteC1<lve_ 'llIteoo..ll-.Oroop __ ...... ...,. ... ~_Socl«ym. ......... ~"" .......... liotfar _ ~_..,. .. _likdylO,,"<aIIod r..t_if ____ .

n.._ .. ___ ~ ... -I'or_,---_"' ...... ............... _....,. ... __ ..... ""~_bu .......... _ __ .... oorIy ... _ ... ooood ... ;.-_ o.o...hol._;'-i1

----~----- .. ---_ .... --"'of .... ,......~dfco:u...,...m.- .......... _ .... _ '"-- ...... ""' ...... _ otdlc j..'l-

n..19IJ.-u-_b.o __ ~by ... IriIII~~· ~""" .... 0qJL O(_ .... ~ .... IIocI.-..,....y_""""""_ .. prionIioe.- .. ___ .......... ....t.'I ___ _

--'>' 1 '.10% of""""'",,--*' be pIo«d oa ........ tirlllioo ___ ~ ThiI -'" ollow ..... .,......., '" cop< with .. _1IIIfl\beq;,

IdoooIly, _ btI<motiDnIll)' ""'" "'" ,lIb4aoooI_ {m ...... I""",, of~ T_Need,IOT1'I)_bt-. .......... _~lm ... ryJImI .. ""' ......... 1ImO. r .... ...,. ~ .... (lOO]) ............ "I'1060'4O(oIJ __ £all1om "..~~"""51_ .. __ ol_) ........ IOTh' ThiI ......... __ by ... "'- ... '",_ Ho.hIo _ (2O)OJ~

S ':Jl1JSl:s<j DI~ PllYAfE ru:IOIt

tuil..-.I) .. ~-..O(~ ... bo...........t .............. -. $ ........... _ .. IIIiIioqIlM:_ol ... pm .. _. n.. _ _ -.d ..... ~_~io""" ......... I\eOWoao-L_.. ... _btl .. ~ ...... ,_-.. ....... .-..Iy.doe:<_ ............ _

A _ olpc*lbo ...... """' .. _ ~...- ... jII'i>-._

(.)1'IIIIf'Ioodio(Iol __ IIJ<p" .... _

(to),.,... --.oe_..-lIJ<pi .... _ i<)_",p""' __ ""' __ _

1.1 foCI C $' qC,

ThIoboo.....,t- ....... _._olta.hlo ___ .......,. __ ... ·' .. _I .... _ .. _lSGpotiaIIoftuoa __ ...... boL n.._ .. Ji_ ....... ol"'llP"""l .. _....,.,., """ ....... IIIopi .... opoeiaIiaoldocit _. n.. P"'- op«:ioIi. """ ;~"""' ...... , __ ....... tbd: _

Tb< ~ of .... or- io IIioo u IS popuIor both .... It! "'" 1* ..... "'" _ pr;..... _tea. Thmio U!tl<d,lIkultyin~""'Ihca-.boo -... wdl

.~ "

(b) 1'1 .... " t eh o """"" "....ol_ ........ ---nboo.-,. t- JO!OPOOOII ......... _...,.I __ K::Iote>~.:IIo ___ .K __ .. b< .-., " .. HootiII Aa. 1911

Qn,.o. __ 1""P"""'I.~£laoo(&nlll70) ___ ptO¥idod" _..-.. ...... £2000(Emo~ ____ .. 1II<IIh<oI ~ Tb< ___ IIn~.......sod .. pi ... -........ol ...... -. 11-'- m.v. r- .... ..-. ___ poid ... _ .... .-.... ...

miol" ... "'" ~oe .. __ ...., -wdllr."lIOd" PIll

s.dI. __ boe ___ ' .. _ ......... (.),_.il __ •

"'-" "' 11>0 H<.IlIt!}.<I. '" -. ,, ___ r, ....,.; ... IIOIOitrility fOIl .. ~

A ~_otEL' _1In. fUIl«portiol_..,. ....... ~1_ioI---. ... __ ( .... Ncwwoy.S---.o...n. rinlorllll.Otbcnfllod...-x_pwdy ......... _ioI--.{_iD ,*-)OIIpn'" ____ (_..,.,.,..ul).AlIJIIdI __ 1ooI<-. qC.......,. ___ kvoIol~,.....b_

I <) AI_ 1"'* __ iD HcaId! 8gwd r·

~...-.rr_b<""'''' .. '''''''''I'ri''''''' __ ''_ I'ri"""' __ .... __ ""-... ___ .... ol-.

s.dI", ... r... .. ....w.....r. .. b<. -. SO%ot ...... pn .... ~. fipfto _ .. ~ Soc1<ry ofI""-lIOSl)_ ..... _ SO'IOof. pn ... __ p1ICtIC>O., __ iD ar-o (II1II". tuppboI. -. balot. d«;oncny • .-. __ ... ~ ..................... illlUcd.IIM_'*"_ I.....-.,·~~

• ~ •• .....-_ iaoalopncl>C<...w...,. _~"""""""'1600 re-16O) foo ..... ".. •• _ .... _ ... .........,. J'MI-.. cL Q.j(J(I

(£.0)110)

_pnaocoill ____ bt ..... ~_a(..__. _~_..._.Idbc ... _ .... __ ~....,.

A. IM1U:sa SCHEMES

No_~~.rut iDdlilooomlry Jorlhoflnliolof _ _ (VIl1 IItr .. A<Io ____ ~Son.l"""'_"_

.... in "'" Nnbn1ondo ODd Germoo<y, .. bid> «MO """"""'" _ .. ..- or iD ... c

~ ..... ,' ................ -;.,plat<iD .... UI( .... _...._ ~ .... __ lIwohold .... ...,-,...... ... II1II0-. ... -..." .......... -.bIbc:_ .. ~_[f __ ._-w._ .... ___ 10<-.1 .. --. ...

r.-y __ ~ -..:aa .... .--(So. ..... -.. on. -.... ...... d<) 0l10I_ ... _ .. pori of"'" mol <JL.-. To. rrbJ Io,...;w,a., ...... _of ... r-. ew-t,,_moof._( ...... ~Nl .. __ 11._11,­"'"~ !Iio<>aycll __ .... """oI __ it [1.100;-

1,:<Olpadoyfottwo),.. ......... _.

" sn'~IAR \

~ ~.-> .. ~ot..-:t.aoIIo<t __ )O.~ot ""'_ ....... __ - ..... is~....,....t .. IO)' .......

....... "' ......... dioc:ipIB

n.. ........ .,.0I ______ ... __ _

1( ............ _ ...-..... ""!<I/IIl'IIooflhc""""'UO'.......w

-" Cumndy la 1I._!het< ... i ... "trkieol • .....t>orI or .......... ~ _ .. _IIIoJl"hbo: __ oo....tr_.........r

""""".-I,l00_~--. ...... ""' __ {IO,.. '-hIoboood_)_bo_ .. """ ..... ,... __ ... , .......... __ .....,n.sof ....... -.

n.._oI .... _..,.....rim .. _ ...... N~ .... ___ .. __ ...................... n..--..-.ot _ oc--.: -.If .. _ .. _ "'" o.bIiIo -' Coo1< ~ SdooaII iI -a...w.ot,....~ ... ""' ...... or.......u,- .. -'"''''--.... _"ittI""'_ ...-cIiIoi<oI ___ ~-.

O'_ .... l...n.d_..-...... __ .. ""'~IIID<. _ ..... _or""'_P"J""l.Ili<!ro.".,._ ... i. i~_ The J)q!t. .f!l<o.ltb III!d Cllildrm ha ...... !!us oloot '" 011 -...... JWb<O - poti<aIa. poIi'icimo MOl _ ~

n.. _01....- io.~i.o 1bo-r_lOlltdooolllod. .. 1IlI .. ____ .. __ -"_

~ __ "' .. _il_,. ........ n_ ... _b .... ......-ot ..... 2l_ ...... ___ ....., .. dooI .... .......... _......-"''''''_.rn.c ... __ ''''''' ... _ ..... __ Suc:b_---- .. -~--_ ...... -.._ot ... __ !oo<. ____ ~ ... .............. _ ....... .....,..01 ___

ll,ldQI otthr PII'" _ iD 1ho .... '" IIICdnIIn IenllIO Ikal ... ...... ......... _... 2. wilb.-""'_ ... fIoIl,... ... ""'_af ..... -iII-eodlO ~ TloisIiD:r,_. ~ r<qWt ........ "' ....

--~

" ~ Of JftIIOl"D<'I' Klom>oo with tax <dOor should be _ 10 Ill." __ lies .. ilh bia\I<f iD<:omn .. <>pi fat pri .... ~--.

Th< 1rpI;..;.",.1Jailuni ..... =-of ~ .axil .... -.Id bdp ., reduo< tb< wai"", lioq .. 1Iflif'an<ly. It ...... be "",p/IulJcd,..., w:b ..... iliari<o caDDOI wod<~ .............. .". .... _fot.,.;niDaof~_ be .... "..- Alto. tb< produ<;thil). of.., ou:cilio<y .. iU "'" bo .... _ .. a _ ~I . ....... _iliory __ bo _ ... IUbstin.o. far.

"",,001;<1-

'" ALL PUBLIC HEAL TIl CARE SYsnMS

I DEMAND> NEED > ~==,

" .......,. M, GnflIIho.GS .0.--. r.loLotol419A)Tht __ _

........,.-'~ '_~_..- .. II·ll_...,_ 1." __ hwoNl</-'I,,16-U

AdoIy. \I . .-. 'M _ ~. M.L, ......... A.. SMw. v. C (l990) The d'I'oaot _ ..... ,.......,.. It """""'-.-. __ .......... _01 pIoqIoo._ ....... _~;,,_ .............. _...ty.C~ _ H_. 1,1Jr-Jn

A_.J,£.N.~S.O .. Todooo<o.l..A.(19'Jol)~ __ ..tre<uO( ~_J_.,.nm._M_,.I' .• I.H ~~ ..... ~Soci«Y{200I) U.K. W""",,"SWy. Willln<>!. D. [)ecwDbcr2001

c -.OJ .. InIII-.A.(!9'i'I)n.._6><...-x_ ...... <IIoId. __ of"'UI>iwd~E_lMmwI",_I~J'j.J"

s.-... DJ.(I'I9flSO<d b"-_ .-.\tdoooIt C-"'>" -.y_0rwI~.lJ. U-J.

-.OJ.(lm)""-......-ot ... __ "-:!<' ..... bp_. __ ~ .. ...-ma... ~hw-'''~l1.J/J-Sn C-S,C .. ..,.I.K-.fJ 19SIi}OAldl<()o,oraI.-......-I .... ~"'_

c.." "'"' t.'SA

0... C .. I'biIIIpo,C .• 8t0<\0r. KL. T-'J.f_~ (lm) s.tf...",..,.,_ tl_ ..doorly-.A,.". ~ 'S. 1/1-41'

o.-,? M.O!, ..... SJ., llo<u..lL. ~A... Mily, M. ShPI, W.C·O_)· Facoon Wlu<nriGJ ","..ne. .. porieoc< of. _ of chiIdra .. "'" _ of 11-11, ... "" I S-16 r-> fGIItor.- .......... ~_. __ 'f/~.I •. Jl-f'

0.-. P M Ot'''''.SJ .. H.: .... R.. KiJIe.b. A., A<lcIy.M.._. w.e {l99Ol>} FOCI<n ~"'" .... _of __ ... !IpO<ili<_..r.o.o(.4-,-poriocI _Il00 ",0(1 1-11,-.'" 1S-t6"-'-.-.....'!fDo--,.. I" /"'/"

~s._ , __ J '1'll1)_~.--IIot'--"""'A~ ouI! ... .,._ J1, JJ~

~S.t:. ....... ; (19I7)~~o(~",-~· __ A_".....a.-_~~'I.#.1-fl H<im.S._,"-P.E (19tOaIc..l~ __ I __ _

ACIIo~Snoo"""'_#1.ZI1-l11

Hd<n. S • """ "-- , E- (19191» c-J ",lotioPIbp ~ ___ daIIoI

_A<M<NM~~_47,2JU

" IWoo. S. (199O)~oIdo< ......... Kot ~_ f'hO ....... u...-my .~

1-. T.O-~ D.~ I.O'If.uy.S,..t "...,1{ 11911)T..- .. ~_<1I __ "I2._IS .. I.-&.~I/_~I, I~"

11_. loU.lI_. B .1< ...... A,AcIcI)_M. ~.I'MIL SIIroo'. Wc. (1990) T_..,.., .. _illary __ it> __ ofSoudl , ..... ~

~_IH.-Jr~, I.l_26l

1(.1I~.l.Ii .. (1977)An_oflbc:<><d_oC)'UIIIb. 12·17 ~ {'_s-. ~1101 _ H _ _ rn._ 11 ..... Ill. P_ ",.,.,_, ""''''tI-. D.e:

z.-. J P (I99JIOn/oodoollctia E-po, 199L F;_~o/"~JS. 1']41'

0''''_. DJ.t., "'''-'11 P .• eo.IIo<.P .. a.\<. D,Mcoa-. S (19%1110' _ _ "IrcI.oiI,C~_H~/J...,t.1.~1

1'r..tIil.".It-.... .". .... "l990IWIIo_ .......... ' t ,,-",_

~1/_~_~~J../-3

I'r..tIil. W,It,FoeIok,HI\ (2OO1)C_~)"£4,oo-. W 11.20. SI.. Laoio Maob)o.

R-.T.o.-.E.._."(;,{l99S)~~"'io~_ " ... _______ of~dd'l bp ODd '*"'" I. ~

~ood ....... _J_"'<f1t~S"'P'1_H ... ~ s-,..,. 19,2J/·151

R"""""",,-S (200IIC ....... ""o>«I,. U>ilioct, (_If. ~lOO1

_. Ill' ,C. (IQfll) The Iatboon<o olEilil<ftD', __ ...,.....,. Od d>eit_1a!

_'_.JI"'IJe<I..,.""""..tIrt_A_'--I<f~"'.JJf. m

_. III'C .• Add). \I,.~C,(l"'o....I"'ooc:iaI_"' __

~oI"""""_.~ c--/o'Dt-,_ONI ~."~J

_.". C., -. SC __ .-. os. ,l9lO) .. .a-.-... ___ .... _oI_'-""_ ....... chi-. _lMmwI"'~ 7, ,_

Sbooo. W C, (1"1) FoIlJot.o ~ &aaI cIrfornul)' -'do< oripII .. r.c..t ~ _, J.-.I '" "- s..~.).I, 1J' ·Uf

.. _"'C,a8noalU>, ~s.._p '1\I9I)Quoh" __ "'~ ...... _ ' ............. _~11I.JJ..'

Spdu.ML,~K_.o-IoIl.E-"'.~S,JC_(I99J)P>J' '; .. ,.,........ o:IrOIdto<IwiIh ~ ..-... ..... _-.: _ ... _loIoillfMq .. _ <m), CIt/I-.c_..,..., '--I..H. UJ-4J ~-,

" "rl'L'DIX I _ r...;.....l .......... _",lis< , ...... 10 ........ '100 l'U -lm __ , ................ ..- (l)oobIIoo .... Coft)

2001 ~ 2007 2010 2013 26t6 20'8 21122 ~ 21128

TlIiII ___ ......... --........

t., ........ DobIioIDIMoI SdIooI ..-.11_10 ..... IO .......... ~l,... (1)) ..... dM con. 0.-1 Sdo<>aI ..uJ -.. ~ ........ _ .. lOOllilr!be:

"""'""-"PP" .... 1<)""" ... ~ .. iU"'_1bc: __ ~ ..... KOdIo.~.-I ..... 11 ayia Ihc_