Upload
others
View
1
Download
0
Embed Size (px)
Citation preview
New York City Salt Marsh Restoration and Protection, Post-Hurricane Sandy Christopher Haight, Marit Larson, Rebecca Swadek, and Ellen K. Hartig
New York City Department of Parks & Recreation
Forestry, Horticulture, and Natural Resources Super Storm Sandy: Five Years Later Meadowlands Conference October 26, 2017
Super Storm
Sandy Conference 2017
Urban Coastal Wetlands
• Coastal wetlands are a critical part of a livable NYC
o Resilient coastal natural areas
o Aesthetic, recreational and educational value
o Ecosystem services (fisheries, bird communities, water quality)
• Coastal wetlands are at risk
o Sea-level rise and storm surge
• Planning, management and restoration can help
protect our wetlands for the future
Super Storm
Sandy Conference 2017
Project Goals
• Assess current condition of
natural marshes
• Evaluate vulnerability to sea-
level rise (SLR)
• Identify opportunities for
protection, conservation &
restoration
Prioritize restoration & protection opportunities
Super Storm
Sandy Conference 2017
Ecological Assessment at 25 salt marshes across NYC
Long
Island
Sound
Staten
Island
Jamaica Bay
Desktop Analysis
o Historic Loss Analysis
o Sea Level Affecting
Marshes Model (SLAMM)
Rapid Ecological
Assessments
o Mid-Atlantic Tidal Rapid
Assessment Method
(MidTRAM)
o NAC Salt Marsh
Assessment (NACSMA)
Conditions and
vulnerability indices
Super Storm
Sandy Conference 2017
Marsh Loss Analysis
6
• 1,011 acres were
assessed
• 160 acres, or 18
percent of salt marsh
was lost in the
waterward direction
(shoreline, ditch,
creek) between 1974-
2012
• Alley Creek lost 12
acres or 23%
Alley Creek, Queens
Long Island Sound
Super Storm
Sandy Conference 2017
Site Scores: Condition and Vulnerability
-2 -1.5 -1 -0.5 0 0.5 1 1.5
Marsh Area
Percent Developed
Native Species Richness
Total Vegetated Cover
Low Marsh Soil Strength
Salt Marsh Breeding Bird Count
Bare Peat Coverage
Trend in Pool Size
Ditch Density
Total Score
Z-Score
Saw Mill Creek Outer: Condition
-1.5 -1 -0.5 0 0.5 1 1.5
Marsh Area
Potential Marsh Loss to SLR
Potential Marsh Gain from Migration
Trend in Waterward Marsh Loss
Edge Density
Percent High Marsh
Total Score
Z-Score
Saw Mill Creek Outer: Vulnerability
-2 -1.5 -1 -0.5 0 0.5 1 1.5
Marsh Area
Percent Developed
Native Species Richness
Total Vegetated Cover
Low Marsh Soil Strength
Salt Marsh Breeding Bird Count
Bare Peat Coverage
Trend in Pool Size
Ditch Density
Total Score
Z-Score
Lemon Creek Outer: Condition
-1.5 -1 -0.5 0 0.5 1 1.5
Marsh Area
Potential Marsh Loss to SLR
Potential Marsh Gain from Migration
Trend in Waterward Marsh Loss
Edge Density
Percent High Marsh
Total Score
Z-Score
Lemon Creek Outer: Vulnerability
Super Storm
Sandy Conference 2017
Alley Creek Inner
Alley Creek Outer
Hutchinson Inner
Hutchinson Outer
Pelham Bay Cove
Pugsley Creek Marsh
Turtle Cove
Udall's Cove Marsh
Westchester Creek
Four Sparrow
Fresh Creek Marsh Idlewild Marsh Inner
Idlewild Marsh Outer
Spring Creek Arlington Marsh
Fresh Kills Marsh
Lemon Creek Inner
Lemon Creek Outer
Neck Creek Inner
Neck Creek Outer
Richmond Creek
Saw Mill Creek Inner Saw Mill Creek Outer
W. T. Davis Inner
W. T. Davis Outer
-1
-0.8
-0.6
-0.4
-0.2
0
0.2
0.4
0.6
0.8
-1.5 -1 -0.5 0 0.5 1 1.5 2
Long Island Sound
Jamaica Bay
Staten Island
Lower Condition / Lower Vulnerability Lower Condition / Higher Vulnerability
Higher Condition / Lower Vulnerability Higher Condition / Higher Vulnerability
Priority site for
protection
Priority site for restoration
Co
nd
itio
n
Vulnerability
Super Storm
Sandy Conference 2017
Actions
Long Term
Viability &
Function
of NYC
Saltmarsh
in Study
Area
Acquisition/
Transfer
Restore flooded
hard surfaces
Increase Marsh
Surface Elevation Erosion and
Decreased Size
Restore Eroded
Marsh Edge
Opportunities for Restoration and Protection
Threats Targets
Obstacles to
Marsh Migration
Reduced Capacity
for Vertical
Growth
Large Scale Marine
Debris Removal
Marine Debris
Super Storm
Sandy Conference 2017
Acquisition/
Transfer
Restore flooded
hard surfaces
All Sites (25)
Owner Current
Marsh (ac) Future
Marsh (ac)
NYC Parks 864 +204
Private 21 +29
Other Govt.
37 +24
0
50
100
150
200
250
300
Private Public
Siz
e (
acre
s)
Property Type Additional Future WetlandCurrent WetlandNon Wetland Area in Parcel
Future flooded hard surfaces
Parking Lots* = 29 ac
Roads** = 7 ac
Other Hard Surfaces = 6 ac
Total = 42 ac
* Mostly Orchard Beach parking lot in Pelham Bay Park
**Includes Brookville Blvd. in Queens and Travis Ave in
Staten Island
Future flooding in Pelham Bay Park, Bronx
Super Storm
Sandy Conference 2017
8.9
4.8
2.1 0.7 0.7
0
2
4
6
8
10
IdlewildMarshOuter
LemonCreekOuter
SpringCreek
IdlewildMarshInner
TurtleCoveP
riority
Are
a (
acre
s)
Increase Marsh
Surface Elevation
Field Data
• % low marsh
• % bare ground
• Breeding birds
Desktop data:
• Future marsh loss (SLAMM)
• Accessible for sediment
placement
Photo: Patty Doer, TNC-NJ Idlewild, Queens
Super Storm
Sandy Conference 2017
8.4
5.7 5.6
2.7 1.5 1.5 1.2 1.2
0
2
4
6
8
10
Pri
ority
Are
a (
acre
s)
Restore Eroded
Marsh Edge
Desktop data:
• High area, width, and % marsh loss
(1974-2012)
• Future marsh loss (SLAMM)
• Accessible for sediment placement
Alley Creek Loss
Analysis 1974- 2012
Alley Creek, Queens Super S
torm Sandy C
onference 2017
13
Large Scale Marine
Debris Removal
Before
After
Example Site: Four Sparrow Marsh, Brooklyn
Before
After
Super Storm
Sandy Conference 2017
• Pilot new approaches to wetland
protection and restoration:
Shoreline protection and
waterward restoration
Elevation / sand
enhancement
• Continue debris removal
• Protect future marsh migration
areas (reduce impervious area in
parks, use existing regulations,
acquisition, easements)
• Expand assessment approach to
include non-Parks properties
Recommendations
Marsh loss at Idlewild, Queens
Clean-up in Four Sparrow, Brooklyn
Super Storm
Sandy Conference 2017
•http://naturalareasnyc.org/in-print
Towards a Salt Marsh Management Report for NYC
Super Storm
Sandy Conference 2017
16
Goal: Restore salt marsh area lost to
interior marsh pond expansion
Approach:
• Coir logs placement to form new edge
• Sand placement behind coir into
expanded pool
• Volunteer planting
Interior Marsh Restoration in Alley Pond Park, Queens
Super Storm
Sandy Conference 2017
17
Goal: Increase salt marsh surface
elevation to improve salt marsh
sparrow habitat and resilience to SLR
Approach:
• Thin layer sediment application (10-
20cm in depth) onto existing low
marsh and depressions
• Monitor salt marsh sparrows
Thin Layer Sediment Application in Idlewild Park, Queens
Super Storm
Sandy Conference 2017
18
Goal: Restore eroded marsh and
establish a reinforced shoreline edge
Approach:
• Sand placement and planting in
eroded area
• Establish a front facing armored toe
or breakwater structure on restored
marsh edge (e.g. oyster castles, reef
balls, coir log)
Reinforced Shoreline Project in Alley Pond Park, Queens
Super Storm
Sandy Conference 2017
Acknowledgements
NYC Parks - Natural Resources Group
Marit Larson
Rebecca Swadek
Ellen K. Hartig
Novem Auyeung
Jennifer Greenfeld
Natural Areas Conservancy
Helen M. Forgione
Sarah Charlop-Powers
Bram Gunther
The Nature Conservancy
Nicole Maher
Stephen Lloyd
Lauren Alleman
Funding from U.S. EPA Region 2,
Wetlands Protection Program
Development Grant
Kathleen Drake
Contact: [email protected]
Super Storm
Sandy Conference 2017