28
1 Sustainability and Climate Models for the Intermountain West ‐An Annotated Bibliography‐ Marianne A. Buehler & William E. Brown, Jr. November 2011 Johnson's California, with Utah, Nevada, Colorado, New Mexico, and Arizona (1867). Courtesy of the University of Nevada, Las Vegas Libraries Special Collections

New Sustainability and Climate Models for the Intermountain West · 2019. 12. 21. · the Intermountain West is not immune to climate shifts ... in the protection, conservation, use

  • Upload
    others

  • View
    0

  • Download
    0

Embed Size (px)

Citation preview

Page 1: New Sustainability and Climate Models for the Intermountain West · 2019. 12. 21. · the Intermountain West is not immune to climate shifts ... in the protection, conservation, use

1

SustainabilityandClimateModelsfortheIntermountainWest‐AnAnnotatedBibliography‐

MarianneA.Buehler&WilliamE.Brown,Jr.November2011

Johnson'sCalifornia,withUtah,Nevada,Colorado,NewMexico,andArizona(1867).

CourtesyoftheUniversityofNevada,LasVegasLibrariesSpecialCollections

Page 2: New Sustainability and Climate Models for the Intermountain West · 2019. 12. 21. · the Intermountain West is not immune to climate shifts ... in the protection, conservation, use

2

TABLEOFCONTENTS

Introduction 3Websites&Blogs 4

ArizonaColoradoIdahoNevadaNewMexicoUtahWesternStates

ScholarlyArticles&Books 16Graduate&InstitutionalResearch20 GovernmentResearch 21Reports&Studies 25SecondarySources:Newspaperarticles 28

Page 3: New Sustainability and Climate Models for the Intermountain West · 2019. 12. 21. · the Intermountain West is not immune to climate shifts ... in the protection, conservation, use

3

SustainabilityandClimateModelsfortheIntermountainWest

Introduction

ThisresourceonclimatemodelsandsustainabilityintheIntermountainWest,aregionthatincludesthestatesofArizona,Colorado,Idaho,Nevada,NewMexico,andUtah,isacollaborativeeffortbetweentheUNLVLibraries(http://library.unlv.edu/)andBrookingsMountainWest(http://brookingsmtnwest.unlv.edu/).Theselectedcitationsincludeacademic,government,andnon‐profitinformationthathighlightongoingresearchonclimatemodelsandsustainabilityeffortsintheregion.Thewebsites,governmentstudies,independentreports,scholarlyarticles,andmediareportsreflectthediversityandcomplexityofclimatechangeandsustainabilityissuesinaregionthatcontainswidelyvaryingecosystems.TheIntermountainWest,withitsdeserts,basins,mountains,metropolitancenters,andruralareasisamicrocosmofournation’sterrain,withtheobviousandnotableexceptionofacoastalregion.Although,asstudiesshow,theIntermountainWestisnotimmunetoclimateshiftsoriginatinginnearbycoastalareas.Thecitationsprovidedhereinincludeannotateddescriptionsdesignedtoassistthereaderinevaluatingtheutilityofeachresource.Itisourintentiontoupdatethisinformationonaregularbasis,asnewinformationandresourcesareidentified.BrookingsMountainWeststaffproposedthecreationofthisresourceinSpring2011andMarianneBuehler,UrbanSustainabilityLibrarianfortheUNLVLibraries,ledtheresearchefforttoidentifyandevaluateavailableresourcesonthesetopics.Buehler,inpartnershipwithBillBrown,DirectorofPlanningandCommunicationatBrookingsMountainWest,refinedthelistandannotations,withtheinvaluableassistanceofChrisGalvan,asociologydoctoralcandidateatUNLV.

Page 4: New Sustainability and Climate Models for the Intermountain West · 2019. 12. 21. · the Intermountain West is not immune to climate shifts ... in the protection, conservation, use

4

Websites&BlogsArizona

Hoover(notBoulder)DamfromtheArizonaside(1937or1938?).

CourtesyoftheUniversityofNevada,LasVegasLibrariesSpecialCollections:http://digital.library.unlv.edu/objects/lv_water/865

1. ArizonaWaterInstitute:Arizona’sthreeuniversitiesfocusedonsustainability.

http://www.azwaterinstitute.org/

2. CollaborativeResearch:AssessingDecadalClimateChangeImpactsonUrbanPopulationsintheSouthwesternUSAhttp://sustainability.asu.edu/research/project.php?id=5173. DecisionCenterforaDesertCityhttp://dcdc.asu.edu/index.phpConductingclimate,water,anddecisionresearchanddevelopinginnovativetoolstobridgetheboundarybetweenscientistsanddecisionmakersandputourworkintothehandsofthosewhoseconcernisforthesustainablefutureofGreaterPhoenix.4.SustainableTucson:Waterarticlesandotherresourceshttp://www.sustainabletucson.org/affinity/water/5.TheWaterPlightofPhoenixhttp://www.columbia.edu/~kk2534/Phoenix%20Water/index.html.This

Page 5: New Sustainability and Climate Models for the Intermountain West · 2019. 12. 21. · the Intermountain West is not immune to climate shifts ... in the protection, conservation, use

5

websiteservesasasourceofinformationregardingthepast,presentandfutureofthisvanishingwaterresourceinthedesert.Itwillalsoexplorethevastpopulation'sdependenceonwaterandpotentialoutlooksfromcurrentstatistics.6.WaterResourcesResearchCenter,UniversityofArizona:Publications,newsletters,andmorehttp://www.ag.arizona.edu/azwater/

Page 6: New Sustainability and Climate Models for the Intermountain West · 2019. 12. 21. · the Intermountain West is not immune to climate shifts ... in the protection, conservation, use

6

Colorado

LakeGranbyMarina,Colorado,BillGreen.WithpermissionfromWaterResourcesArchive,ColoradoStateUniversity,ArchivesandSpecialCollections:

http://hdl.handle.net/10217/37843.

1. ClimatePreparednessProjecthttp://www.coloadaptationprofile.org/TheColoradoClimatePreparednessProjectwasundertakenbytheWesternWaterAssessmentfortheStateofColorado.TheprimarypurposeofthisprojectistoassistColoradoincontinuingtoprepareitselfforclimatevariabilityandchangebyprovidingacatalogofclimatevulnerabilitiesandcurrentactivities,includingpersonnel,productsandprojectsfromColoradoandotherappropriateentities.Theprojectfocusesonfivesectors:agriculture,electricity,forests/wildlife/ecosystems,tourism/recreation,andwater.Providesawealthofinformationfromnumerousprojectsunderthe“projects,”“organizations,”and“products”tab.“TheColoradoClimatePreparednessProjectwasundertakenbytheWesternWaterAssessmentfortheStateofColorado.TheprimarypurposeofthisprojectistoassistColoradoincontinuingtoprepareitselfforclimatevariabilityandchangebyprovidingacatalogofclimatevulnerabilitiesandcurrentactivities,includingpersonnel,productsandprojectsfromColoradoandotherappropriateentities.”2. TheColoradoClimateCenterwasestablishedbythestatein1974,throughtheColoradoStateUniversityAgriculturalExperimentStation,toprovideinformationandexpertiseonColorado'scomplexclimate.ThroughitsthreefoldprogramofClimateMonitoring(dataacquisition,analysis,andarchiving),ClimateResearchandClimateServices,theCenterisrespondingtomanyclimaterelatedquestionsandproblemsaffectingthestatetoday.http://ccc.atmos.colostate.edu/3. ColoradoDivisionofWaterResourceshttp://water.state.co.us/Home/Pages/default.aspx

Page 7: New Sustainability and Climate Models for the Intermountain West · 2019. 12. 21. · the Intermountain West is not immune to climate shifts ... in the protection, conservation, use

7

AlsoknownastheOfficeoftheStateEngineer,administerswaterrights,issueswaterwellpermits,representsColoradoininterstatewatercompactproceedings,monitorsstream‐flowandwateruse,approvesconstructionandrepairofdamsandperformsdamsafetyinspections,issueslicensesforwelldrillersandassuresthesafeandproperconstructionofwaterwells,andmaintainsnumerousdatabasesofColoradowaterinformation.4. ColoradoRiverDistricthttp://www.crwcd.org/Toleadintheprotection,conservation,useanddevelopmentofthewaterresourcesoftheColoradoRiverbasinforthewelfareoftheDistrict,andtosafeguardforColoradoallwatersoftheColoradoRivertowhichthestateisentitled.5. U.S.GeologicalSurvey:ColoradoDroughtWatchhttp://co.water.usgs.gov/drought/BureauofReclamationhttp://www.usbr.gov/uc/feature/drought.html6. TheWaterInformationProgramforSouthwestColoradohttp://www.waterinfo.org/indian.htmlCompetingwaterusesfromtheColoradoRiversystemhavedefinedColoradohistoryforover100years.ThelegalrighttodivertandusewaterinColoradohasbeendeliberatedanddefinedfrombeforethetimeofstatehoodin1876.7. WesternWaterAssessment:IntermountainWestClimateSummaryhttp://wwa.colorado.edu/IWCS/.“Providesthelatestclimateinformationinasimple,compactdocumentaimedatwatermanagers,planners,andpolicymakerswithwater‐relatedinterests.”“Acool,wetAprildelayedmeltandaddedtothesnowpackacrossmostoftheregion’smountains.Asaresult,May1stsnowpacksinthethree‐stateregionincreasedfromtheApril1stlevels,andaremuchaboveaverageinallbutsoutheasternUtahandsouthernColorado.ThemostdramaticincreaseshavebeeninWyoming,northernUtah,andnorthernColorado.”Alsoincludesdroughtandprecipitationpredictions,visualaids,andawealthofinformationonclimateconditionsintheIntermountainWest.

Page 8: New Sustainability and Climate Models for the Intermountain West · 2019. 12. 21. · the Intermountain West is not immune to climate shifts ... in the protection, conservation, use

8

Idaho

Mesadamandditchtake‐offonMiddleForkWeiserRiver,Idaho,locatedapproximately7milesbyroadaboveU.S.95.Mesadamandditchtake‐off(08‐24‐1941).CourtesyoftheUniversityofOregonLibraries:http://oregondigital.org/cdm4/item_viewer.php?CISOROOT=/streamsurve&CISOPTR=5.

1. IdahoWaterCenterhttp://www.uidaho.edu/boise/aboutus/idahowatercenterIdaho’scenterofcollaborationamonggovernment,businessandhighereducation,isdedicatedtoresearch,scholarshipandservicetoIdahoandthenation.2. IdahoWaterResourceBoardhttp://www.idwr.idaho.gov/waterboard/WaterPlanning/StateWaterPlanning/State_Planning.htmTheIdahoWaterResourceBoardischargedwiththedevelopmentoftheIdahoComprehensiveStateWaterPlan.Theplanincludesthestatewidewaterpolicyplanandassociatedcomponentbasinandwaterbodyplanswhichcoverspecificgeographicareasofthestateandyears:1972‐currentplans.3. ManagingWaterintheWest:FinalBoise/PayetteWaterStorageAssessmentReport2006,U.S.DepartmentoftheInteriorBureauofReclamationPacificNorthwestRegion.ThisassessmentisjustoneactivityandoneaspectofthemanyactivitiesthatmultipleagenciesareconductingtoaddresswatersupplyandwatermanagementissuesintheBoiseandPayetteRiverBasins.http://www.usbr.gov/pn/programs/srao_misc/bp.../FinalBoisePayetteRpt.pdf

4. WaterResourcesinaChangingClimate(Idahoclimatechange):EPScORresearch.Goalistoimprovethestatewideresearchinfrastructureforunderstandingtheeffectsofclimatechangeonwaterresourcesinourregionandtheimpactoftheseeffectsofecological,humanandeconomicsystems.http://www.idahoclimatechange.org/

Page 9: New Sustainability and Climate Models for the Intermountain West · 2019. 12. 21. · the Intermountain West is not immune to climate shifts ... in the protection, conservation, use

9

Nevada

TelephotoviewofHooverDamfromtheupstreamsideshowingthecompletedintaketowers(1936?).CourtesyoftheUniversityofNevada,LasVegasLibrariesSpecialCollections:http://digital.library.unlv.edu/objects/lv_water/678.

1. “Climatemodeling”DesertResearchInstitute(Reno)http://climatemodeling.blogspot.com/2011/04/integrated‐system‐model‐framework‐and.htmlJohnMejia.Developmentandimplementationof“statistical”andRegionalClimateModeldownscalingtechniquesusingGlobalClimeModelingoutputfromtheCMIP3andCMIP5intospacescalesrelevantforregionalandlocalimpactstudies.2. “It’sAllWater:DemonstrationofanInnovativeTreatmentTechnologyforWaterBankinginNevada.”VijaySundaram,P.E.andJohnP.Enloe,P.E.,ECO:LOGICEngineeringhttp://nvwea.org/sswe‐newsletters‐detail/3034‐its‐all‐waterWatershortagesforecastforthewestandthepossibilityofextendeddroughtposeseriouschallengesforNevada.Potentialwatershortagescanbeaddressedintheimmediatefuturebyinsightfulmanagementofavailablefreshwaterresources,andrecyclingorbanking“onceused”waterresources(e.g.,reuseofmunicipaleffluent).3.NevadaClimateChangePortal:Thefocusofthiswebsiteistoadvancethequality,andquantityofinfrastructureanddatacollectionforclimate,hydrologicalandecologicalinformationpertainingtothestateofNevada.ThiswebsiteprovidesinformationontheNevadaClimateChangeProjectandaccesstoboththeNevCAN(NevadaClimate‐ecohydrologyAssessmentNetwork)andclimatemodelingoutput.http://www.sensor.nevada.edu/NCCP/

Page 10: New Sustainability and Climate Models for the Intermountain West · 2019. 12. 21. · the Intermountain West is not immune to climate shifts ... in the protection, conservation, use

10

NewMexico

AncientirrigationditchnearRuidosoCreek,SouthernNewMexico.Byoneestimate,theditchmaybeasmuchas2000yearsold.Photodate:1929.Moreinformationandpermissions:http://econtent.unm.edu/cdm4/item_viewer.php?CISOROOT=/NMWaters&CISOPTR=3506.

1. EvaluatingtheSustainabilityoftheAlbuquerqueWaterSupply.http://www.challenge.nm.org/archive/00‐01/FinalReports/013/Thepeopleofthisstateusetoomuchwaterfromtheaquiferfromwhichmostofthestate’swaterispumped.Asthewatersupplydwindles,thepopulationgrows.Howlonguntilthisissuebecomesaseriousproblem?InAlbuquerque,NewMexico,thegovernmenthasseenthisproblemandistakingstepstofixit.2. Water,GrowthandSustainability:Planningforthe21STCentury(SantaFe)NewMexico:WaterResourcesResearchInstitute12‐2000http://wrri.nmsu.edu/publish/watcon/proc45/ohare.pdf“IthinkweprobablyhavethemostseverewatershortageemergencyofanylargecitywithinthestateandhaveimplementedwateruserestrictionsIwanttosharewithyou.”3. NewMexicoEPSCoRandClimateModeling:AcentralresearchchallengeofNMEPSCoRistounderstandhowfuturechangesinseasonaltemperatureandprecipitationwillimpactsnowpack,snowmeltandspringrunoffinthemountainousregionofnorthcentralNewMexico.Thisregion,thesouthernmostextentoftheRockyMountainrange,servesastheheadwatersforriversystemsofcrucialimportancetoNM,includingtheRioGrande.http://nmepscor.org/content/hydrology‐and‐climate‐modeling

Page 11: New Sustainability and Climate Models for the Intermountain West · 2019. 12. 21. · the Intermountain West is not immune to climate shifts ... in the protection, conservation, use

11

4. UniversityofNewMexicoLibGuide:USGSandEPAMexicowaterresourcedata,snowsurvey,climateinformation,andmore.http://libguides.unm.edu/content.php?pid=15497&sid=199424

Page 12: New Sustainability and Climate Models for the Intermountain West · 2019. 12. 21. · the Intermountain West is not immune to climate shifts ... in the protection, conservation, use

12

Utah

LakePowell(1954‐1972).CourtesyofColoradoStateUniversityLibraries:http://hdl.handle.net/10217/26288.

1. ClimateResearchGroup:UniversityofUtahstudiesclimateandclimatechangewithafocusonatmosphericdynamicsincludeprojects,presentations,andpublications.http://www.inscc.utah.edu/~reichler/research/research.shtmlAdditionalpostersandtalks:http://www.inscc.utah.edu/~reichler/talks/tjr_talks.shtml2. LeagueofWomenVotersofUtahWaterStudy,September2009.http://www.lwvutah.org/AirWaterIssues/lwvutWaterStudy_10‐10‐19.pdf“In2008theLeagueofWomenVotersofUtahdecidedtodoastudyofUtahwatersothatwecouldbetteradvocateforourmembers’deepconcernsaboutwaterforpeopleandwaterfortheenvironment.Thispaperisconcernedwithaccountingforourwaterandhowwemanageit,notwithwaterqualityeitherforhumanusesorforwildlife…Utahistheseconddrieststateinthenation;Utahhasthesecondhighestpercapitawateruse.However,wearetoldtoexpectmorepeople,andtheclimatesectionwillshowthatUtahcanmostlikelyexpectlonger,hotterdroughtsattheleastandmorelikelyahotter,drierclimateoverall.Theoutcomesfromthemodelsvaryfromseveredroughtwithdireconsequencestomoremoderatedeclinesinprecipitationthat,althoughserious,maybemanageable.ScientistsandmostwatermanagersagreethatglobalwarmingwillbringhighertemperaturestoallofUtah.MostofUtah’susablewatercomesfromsnowpack.Thestate’ssystemofreservoirsfillsinlatespringandearlysummerfromtheslowsnowmelt.Thewaterlevelinthereservoirsstartstobedrawndownbeginninginlatesummer,throughtherestoftheyearandintothenextspring.Thesystemdependsuponasubstantialsnowfallandthetimingofthespringsnowmelt.LittlesnowormoreprecipitationfallingasraindoesnotallowfortimelystorageinUtah’shighmountainreservoirsorforefficientseasonalallocation.IfUtahhasahotteranddrierclimate,therewillbelesswaterinanyform,asmallersnowpack,andprobablyhigherhumanusagetocounterthehotter,drierweather.EvenifUtah

Page 13: New Sustainability and Climate Models for the Intermountain West · 2019. 12. 21. · the Intermountain West is not immune to climate shifts ... in the protection, conservation, use

13

weretobewarmerbutwetter,thereareproblems.Moreprecipitationwillfallasrainratherthansnow,filteringthroughthegroundtoouraquifersnottoourreservoirs,whereitismoreaccessibletothewaterdeliverysystemnowinplace.Thesmallersnowpackwillmeltearly,andsinceUtahreceiveslittlesummermoisture,itislikelythatsummerwaterusewillstillbehighandlong….TheGovernor’sOfficeofPlanningandBudgetprojectsthatthepopulationwillgrowfrom2,833,337in2010to5,368,567in2050,mostlyontheWasatchFront(GOPB,2009).”“Waterusageishighestindrystatesduetoprecipitation,whichhasincreasedduetoglobalwarming.Tucsonhaslowpercapitawateruse,andUtah’sdroppedfrom293gpcdin2000to260gpcdin2005(UDWR(2009)WeberR.Basin,p.47).Botharelargelyattributabletoefficienciesachievedbybothsuppliersandconsumersofwater.” 3. UtahStateUniversityClimateCenterhttp://climate.usurf.usu.edu/ThemissionoftheUtahClimateCenter(UCC)istofacilitateaccesstoclimatedataandinformation,andtouseexpertiseinatmosphericsciencetointerpretclimateinformationinanaccurateandinnovativefashionforthepublic.Themissionincludesthedesignofnewproductstomeetpresentandfutureneedsofagriculture,naturalresources,government,industry,tourism,andeducationalorganizationsinUtahandtheintermountainregion.4. UniversityofUtah‐SCI(ScientificComputingandImaging)Institutehttp://www.sci.utah.edu/TheScientificComputingandImaging(SCI)InstituteisapermanentresearchinstituteattheUniversityofUtah.DirectedbyProfessorChrisJohnson,theInstituteisnowhometoover190faculty,students,andstaff.Thefaculty,drawnprimarilyfromtheSchoolofComputing,DepartmentofBioengineering,andDepartmentofElectricalandComputerEngineering,isnotedforitsbreadthofcollaborationsbothnationallyandinternationally.TheSCIInstitutehasestablisheditselfasaninternationallyrecognizedleaderinvisualization,scientificcomputing,andimageanalysis.Theoverarchingresearchobjectiveistocreatenewscientificcomputingtechniques,tools,andsystemsthatenablesolutionstoproblemsaffectingvariousaspectsofhumanlife.AcorefocusoftheInstitutehasbeenbiomedicine,butSCIInstituteresearchersalsosolvechallengingcomputationalandimagingproblemsinsuchdisciplinesasgeophysics,combustion,moleculardynamics,fluiddynamics,andatmosphericdispersion.

Page 14: New Sustainability and Climate Models for the Intermountain West · 2019. 12. 21. · the Intermountain West is not immune to climate shifts ... in the protection, conservation, use

14

WesternStates1. SouthwestClimateChangeNETWORK:Climate,impacts,solutions,articlesfeaturedandlibrarytabswithmoreinformation.Recognizingthegrowingneedforinformationaboutourchangingclimate,theInstituteoftheEnvironmentandtheClimateAssessmentfortheSouthwest(CLIMAS)atTheUniversityofArizonadevelopedandjointlyadministertheSouthwestClimateChangeNetwork.TheInstituteoftheEnvironmentisacross‐campusandcommunityresourceandacatalystintheareaofenvironmentandsociety;itpromotesbothdisciplinaryandinterdisciplinaryresearchrelatingtotheEarth’senvironment,fromlocaltoglobalscales,andhowthisenvironmentislikelytochangeincomingseasons,years,anddecades.CLIMASisaprojecthousedwithintheInstituteandfundedbytheU.S.NationalOceanicandAtmosphericAdministrationtocarryoutstakeholder‐driveninterdisciplinaryclimateresearch.Since1998,CLIMAShascontributedtotheSouthwest’sabilitytorespondsufficientlyandappropriatelytoclimaticeventsandclimatechanges.http://www.southwestclimatechange.org/

3.UnitedStatesGlobalChangeResearchProgramhttp://www.globalchange.gov/Integratingfederalresearchandsolutionsforclimateandglobalchange:TheU.S.GlobalChangeResearchProgram(USGCRP)coordinatesandintegratesfederalresearchonchangesintheglobalenvironmentandtheirimplicationsforsociety.Containsreportsandpublications.

4.U.S.DepartmentoftheInterior.BureauofReclamation.WaterSmartProgram.West‐WideClimateRiskAssessments.http://www.usbr.gov/WaterSMART/wwcra.html5. TheWest‐WideClimateRiskAssessments(WWCRA)areacomplementaryactivitywiththeBasinStudiesandtheLandscapeConservationCooperativeswithintheWaterSMARTInitiative,inaccordancewithSecretarialOrder3289(andmeettheauthorizationsoftheSecureWaterAct.Asawhole,thesethreeactivitiesrepresentacomprehensiveapproachtoincorporatethebestavailablescienceintoplanningactivitiesforclimatechangeadaptationplanning.6. WesternStatesWaterLawshttp://www.blm.gov/nstc/WaterLaws/Thiswebsitereviewsthewaterlawsofelevenwesternstates(Alaska,Arizona,California,Colorado,Idaho,Montana,Nevada,NewMexico,Oregon,Utah,andWyoming).Specialattentionispaidtothestates’waterrightssystems,theapplicationprocesses,groundwaterregulations,thegeneraladjudicationprocesses,andthestates’in‐streamflowprograms.7.LinkstoavarietyofWesternWaterResourcesIssues:Waterresourcecenters,waterplans,dams,drought,groundwater,waterquality,statewaterresources,environmentalorganizations,federalagencies,andconservation.http://web.hwr.arizona.edu/globe/h2oissues.html

Page 15: New Sustainability and Climate Models for the Intermountain West · 2019. 12. 21. · the Intermountain West is not immune to climate shifts ... in the protection, conservation, use

15

ScholarlyArticles&Books

1.“AregionalclimatemodelforthewesternUnitedStates,”RobertE.Dickinson,RonaldM.Errico,FilippoGiorgi,andGaryT.Bates.ClimaticChange,Volume1,1977,Volume106,2011,pp.383‐422.http://www.springerlink.com/content/v112217p34405205/Anumericalapproachtomodelingclimateonaregionalscaleisdevelopedwherebylarge‐scaleweathersystemsaresimulatedwithaglobalclimatemodel(GCM)andtheGCMoutputisusedtoprovidetheboundaryconditionsneededforhigh‐resolutionmesoscalemodelsimulationsovertheregionofinterest.Inourexample,weusetheNationalCenterforAtmosphericResearch(NCAR)communityclimatemodel(CCM1)andthePennsylvaniaStateUniversity(PSU)/NCARMesoscaleModelversion4(MM4)toapplythisapproachoverthewesternUnitedStates(U.S.).Thetopography,asresolvedbythe500‐kmmeshoftheCCM1,isnecessarilyhighlydistorted,butwiththe60‐kmmeshoftheMM4themajormountainrangesaredistinguished.Toobtainadequateandconsistentrepresentationsofsurfaceclimate,weusethesameradiationandlandsurfacetreatmentsinbothmodels,thelatterbeingtherecentlydevelopedBiosphere‐AtmosphereTransferScheme(BATS).OuranalysisemphasizesthesimulationatfourCCM1pointssurroundingYuccaMountain,NV,becauseoftheneedtodetermineitsclimatologypriortocertificationasahigh‐levelnuclearwasterepository.WesimulateglobalclimateforthreeyearswithCCM1/BATSanddescribetheresultingJanuarysurfaceclimatologyovertheWesternU.S.Thedetailsoftheprecipitationpatternsareunrealisticbecauseofthesmoothtopography.SelectingfiveJanuaryCCM1stormsthatoccuroverthewesternU.S.withatotaldurationof20daysforsimulationwiththeMM4,wedemonstratethatthemesoscalemodelprovidesmuchimprovedwintertimeprecipitationpatterns.ThestormsinMM4areindividuallymuchmorerealisticthanthoseinCCM1.AsimpleaveragingprocedurethatinfersameanJanuaryrainfallclimatologycalculatedfromthe20daysofMM4simulationismuchclosertotheobservedthanistheCCM1climatology.Thesoilmoistureandsubsurfacedrainagesimulatedover3–5dayintegrationperiodsofMM4,however,remainstronglydependentontheinitialCCM1soilmoistureandthusarelessrealisticthantherainfall.Adequatesimulationofsurfacesoilwatermayrequireintegrationsofthemesoscalemodelovertimeperiods. 2.“Anapproachtowardarationalclassificationofclimate.”C.W.Thornthwaite. GeographicalReview,Vol.38,No.1(Jan.,1948),pp.55‐94.Publishedby:AmericanGeographicalSociety.IncludesWesternclimaticcharts/graphs.Thesumoftheclimaticelementsthathavebeenunderobservationdoesnotequalclimate.http://www.jstor.org/stable/2107393. “ClimateChange,Water,andRisk:CurrentWaterDemandsAreNotSustainable,"NaturalResourcesDefenseCouncil,July2010.Climatechangewillhaveasignificantimpactonthesustainabilityofwatersuppliesinthecomingdecades.Anewanalysis,performedbyconsultingfirmTetraTechfortheNaturalResourcesDefenseCouncil(NRDC),examinedtheeffectsofglobalwarmingonwatersupplyanddemandinthecontiguousUnitedStates.Thestudyfoundthatmorethan1,100counties—one‐thirdofallcountiesinthelower48—willfacehigherrisksofwatershortagesbymid‐centuryastheresultofglobalwarming.www.nrdc.org/globalwarming/watersustainability/files/WaterRisk.pdf4.“DryTimesAhead,”JonathanOverpeckandBradleyUdall,Science,Vol.328,p.1642,25June2010.http://www.sciencemag.org/content/328/5986/1642.short

Page 16: New Sustainability and Climate Models for the Intermountain West · 2019. 12. 21. · the Intermountain West is not immune to climate shifts ... in the protection, conservation, use

16

“Inthepastdecade,ithasbecomeimpossibletooverlookthesignsofclimatechangeinwesternNorthAmerica.Theyincludesoaringtemperatures,declininglate‐seasonsnowpack,northward‐shiftedwinterstormtracks,increasingprecipitationintensity,theworstdroughtsincemeasurementsbegan,steepdeclinesinColoradoRiverreservoirstorage,widespreadvegetationmortality,andsharpincreasesinthefrequencyoflargewildfires.Theseshiftshavetakenplaceacrossaregionthatalsosawthenation'shighestpopulationgrowthduringthesameperiod.”5. ”GlobalWarmingComingHometoRoostintheAmericanWest”(CA).RichardA.Kerr.Science21December2007:http://www.sciencemag.org/content/318/5858/1859.full6. "Human‐InducedChangesintheHydrologyoftheWesternUnitedStates"TimP.Barnett,etal.ScienceMagazineReport.Science22February2008:Vol.319no.5866pp.1080‐1083.DOI:10.1126/science.1152538.ObservationshaveshownthatthehydrologicalcycleoftheWesternUnitedStateschangedsignificantlyoverthelasthalfofthe20thcentury.Wepresentaregional,multivariableclimatechangedetectionandattributionstudy,usingahigh‐resolutionhydrologicmodelforcedbyglobalclimatemodels,focusingonthechangesthathavealreadyaffectedthisprimarilyaridregionwithalargeandgrowingpopulation.Includesadditionalfull‐textarticlescitingthisarticle.http://www.sciencemag.org/content/319/5866/1080.short7. “HydroclimateoftheWesternUnitedStatesBasedonObservationsandRegionalClimateSimulationof1981–2000“JournalofClimate,V16,Issue12.PartI:SeasonalStatisticsL.RubyLeung,YunQian,andXindiBian.PacificNorthwestNationalLaboratory,Richland,Washington.Providesdetailedanalysesofobservationsandregionalclimatesimulationstoimproveourunderstandingandmodelingoftheclimateofthisregion.http://journals.ametsoc.org/doi/full/10.1175/1520‐0442%282003%29016%3C1892%3AHOTWUS%3E2.0.CO%3B28."IdentifyingandevaluatingrobustadaptivepolicyresponsestoclimatechangeforwatermanagementagenciesintheAmericanwest,"RobertJ.LempertandDavidG.Groves.TechnologicalForecastingandSocialChange,Volume77,Issue6,July2010,Pages960‐974.ClimatechangepresentsasignificantplanningchallengeforwatermanagementagenciesintheWesternUnitedStates.Changingprecipitationandtemperaturepatternswilldisrupttheirsupplyandextensivedistributionsystemsoverthecomingdecades,buttheprecisetimingandextentoftheseimpactsremaindeeplyuncertain,complicatingdecisionsonneededinvestmentsininfrastructureandothersystemimprovements.Adaptivestrategiesrepresentanobvioussolutioninprinciple,butareoftendifficulttodevelopandimplementinpractice.ThispaperdescribesworkhelpingtheInlandEmpireUtilitiesAgency(IEUA)explicitlydevelopadaptivepoliciestorespondtoclimatechangeandintegratingthesepoliciesintotheorganizations'long‐rangeplanningprocesses.TheanalysisemploysRobustDecisionMaking(RDM),aquantitativedecision‐analyticapproachforsupportingdecisionsunderconditionsofdeepuncertainty.RDMstudiesusesimulationmodelstoassesstheperformanceofagencyplansoverthousandsofplausiblefutures,usestatistical“scenariodiscovery”algorithmstoconciselysummarizethosefutureswheretheplansfailtoperformadequately,andusetheseresultingscenariostohelpdecisionmakersunderstandthevulnerabilitiesoftheirplansandassesstheoptionsfor

Page 17: New Sustainability and Climate Models for the Intermountain West · 2019. 12. 21. · the Intermountain West is not immune to climate shifts ... in the protection, conservation, use

17

amelioratingthesevulnerabilities.ThispaperdemonstratestheparticularvalueofRDMinhelpingdecisionmakerstodesignandevaluateadaptivestrategies.ForIEUA,theRDManalysissuggeststheagency'scurrentplancouldperformpoorlyandleadtohighshortageandwaterprovisioningcostsunderconditionsof:(1)largedeclinesinprecipitation,(2)larger‐than‐expectedimpactsofclimatechangeontheavailabilityofimportedsupplies,and(3)reductionsinpercolationofprecipitationintotheregion'sgroundwaterbasin.Includingadaptivityinthecurrentplaneliminates72%ofthehigh‐costoutcomes.Acceleratingeffortsinexpandingthesizeofoneoftheagency'sgroundwaterbankingprogramsandimplementingitsrecyclingprogram,whilemonitoringtheregion'ssupplyanddemandbalanceandmakingadditionalinvestmentsinefficiencyandstorm‐watercaptureifshortagesareprojectedprovidesonepromisingrobustadaptivestrategy—iteliminatesmorethan80%oftheinitially‐identifiedhigh‐costoutcomes.http://www.sciencedirect.com/science/article/pii/S004016251000074010.“Mid‐centuryensembleregionalclimatechangescenariosfortheWesternUnitedStates,”L.RubyLeung,etal.ClimaticChange,Volume62,Numbers1‐3,75‐113,2004.Describestheregionalsimulationsandfocusesonthehydro‐climateconditionsintheColumbiaRiverBasin(CRB)andSacramento‐SanJoaquinRiver(SSJ)Basin.Fromfws.gov:http://www.fws.gov/filedownloads/ftp_region6_upload/FOIA%20READING%20ROOM/FOIA%202010/American%20Pika%2012%20Month/12%20month%20status%20review%20citations/Leung%20et%20al%202004.pdf11.“Multi‐decadalRegimeShiftsinU.S.Streamflow,Precipitation,andTemperatureattheEndoftheTwentiethCentury.”Mauget,StevenA.,2003:J.Climate,16,3905–391.Coversyears:1896–2001.Duringthelate1980sandearly1990s,asignificantincidenceoflow‐rankedannualflowconditionsthroughouttheWestwasroughlycoincidentwiththeonsetofWesternwarmthduringthemid‐1980s.Evidenceofhighlysignificanttransitionstowetterandwarmerconditionsnationally,andconsistentvariationinstreamflowanalyses,suggeststhatincreasedhydrologicalsurplusintheCentralandEasternUnitedStatesandincreasedhydrologicaldeficitintheWestmayberepresentativeoftheinitialstagesofclimatechangeoverthecontinentalUnitedStates.http://journals.ametsoc.org/doi/abs/10.1175/1520‐0442%282003%29016%3C3905%3AMRSIUS%3E2.0.CO%3B2ResolvingtheWaterDilemma:PastProblemsandFutureTrends(withRichardActon),inPublicPolicyinNevada:LookingTowardstheYear2000andBeyond(DennisL.SodenandEricHerzik,eds.).Dubuque:Kendall‐HuntPublishers,1997.12.“Water,GrowthandSustainability:Planningforthe21STCentury,”EluidMartinez,WaterIssuesintheWest.December2000.NewMexicoWaterResourcesResearchInstitute.http://wrri.nmsu.edu/publish/watcon/proc45/martinez.pdf13.TheWaterChallenge:ContemporaryIssuesinNorthernNevada(withRichardActon),inPublicPolicyinNevada:TheNewMillennium(DennisL.SodenandEricHerzik,eds.).Dubuque:Kendall‐HuntPublishers,2000.14.“TrendsintheHydrologyoftheWesternU.S.BeartheImprintofManmadeClimateChange.”BarbaraGossLevi,physicstoday,April2008.http://physicstoday.org/resource/1/phtoad/v61/i4/p16_s1

Page 18: New Sustainability and Climate Models for the Intermountain West · 2019. 12. 21. · the Intermountain West is not immune to climate shifts ... in the protection, conservation, use

18

15.ColoradoRiverBasinWaterManagement:EvaluatingandAdjustingtoHydroclimaticVariability,CommitteeontheScientificBasesofColoradoRiverBasinWaterManagement,NationalResearchCouncil,222pages.Recentstudiesofpastclimateandstream‐flowconditionshavebroadenedunderstandingoflong‐termwateravailabilityintheColoradoRiver,revealingmanyperiodswhenstream‐flowwaslowerthanatanytimeinthepast100yearsofrecordedflows.Thatinformation,alongwithtwoimportanttrends—arapidincreaseinurbanpopulationsintheWestandsignificantclimatewarmingintheregion—willrequirethatwatermanagersprepareforpossiblereductionsinwatersuppliesthatcannotbefullyavertedthroughtraditionalmeans.http://www.nap.edu/catalog.php?record_id=118516.UniversityofNevada,LasVegasfacultyresearcharticlesonwater,drought,andstream‐flowintheWesternU.S.http://digitalcommons.library.unlv.edu/fac_articles/

Page 19: New Sustainability and Climate Models for the Intermountain West · 2019. 12. 21. · the Intermountain West is not immune to climate shifts ... in the protection, conservation, use

19

Graduate&InstitutionalResearchGraduateResearch

1. ClimatechangeinruralNevada:Theinfluenceofvulnerabilityonriskperceptionandenvironmentalbehavior,AhmadSafi.Dissertation,2011.http://digitalcommons.library.unlv.edu/thesesdissertations/906/2. Groundwater:SolutiontotheLasVegaswaterproblem?RosaPerezandChristopherRuiz.Poster,2011.http://digitalcommons.library.unlv.edu/focs_ug_research/2011/april16/41/

InstitutionalResearchNevadaNSFEPSCoRClimateChangeProject(2008‐2013)

1. ClimateChangeSeminarSeries:(Lectures&PowerPointpresentations):http://digitalcommons.library.unlv.edu/climate_change/

2. EPSCoRConference(PowerPointpresentations&researchposters):http://digitalcommons.library.unlv.edu/epscor/

Page 20: New Sustainability and Climate Models for the Intermountain West · 2019. 12. 21. · the Intermountain West is not immune to climate shifts ... in the protection, conservation, use

20

GovernmentResearch1.ArizonaDepartmentofEnvironmentalQuality,ArizonaClimateChangeInitiatives.TheGovernor'sPolicyonClimateChange,ExecutiveOrder2010‐06,recognizestheimportanceofreducinggreenhousegasemissionswhilemaintainingArizona'seconomicgrowthandcompetitiveness.Increasedgreenhousegasemissions,akeydriverinfluencingclimatechangemayresultasArizona'spopulationandeconomyexpands,butArizonahassignificantstrengthsonwhichtobuild,includingstringentrenewableenergystandardsandoneofthenation'smostaggressiveenergyefficiencystandards.TheGovernor'spolicysupportsArizona'scontinuedcollaborationinregionalandnationalendeavorstoadvancecleanenergyandimplementcost‐effectivesolutionstoclimatechangewhilesafeguardingitsuniquestateinterests.TheArizonaDepartmentofEnvironmentalQualityhasanimportantroleinensuringcleanair,safewater,andbetterprotectedlandforallArizonans.TogetherwithArizonabusinessesandcommunities,westriveforpragmatic,pro‐activeapproachestoclimatechangebyadvancingcleanrenewableenergy,smartgrowth,fuelefficienttransportationandenergyefficiencypoliciesandpracticesthatmakesenseforArizona.http://www.azclimatechange.gov/az_initiatives.html2."ClimateChange,Water,andRisk:CurrentWaterDemandsAreNotSustainable,"NaturalResourcesDefenseCouncil,July2010.Climatechangewillhaveasignificantimpactonthesustainabilityofwatersuppliesinthecomingdecades.Anewanalysis,performedbyconsultingfirmTetraTechfortheNaturalResourcesDefenseCouncil(NRDC),examinedtheeffectsofglobalwarmingonwatersupplyanddemandinthecontiguousUnitedStates.Thestudyfoundthatmorethan1,100counties—one‐thirdofallcountiesinthelower48willfacehigherrisksofwatershortagesbymid‐centuryastheresultofglobalwarming.Somestateshaveanextremeorhighrisktowatersustainability,orarelikelytoseelimitationsonwateravailabilityasdemandexceedssupplyby2050.TheseareasincludepartsofArizona,Arkansas,California,Colorado,Florida,Idaho,Kansas,Mississippi,Montana,Nebraska,Nevada,NewMexico,Oklahoma,andTexas.Inparticular,intheGreatPlainsandSouthwestUnitedStates,watersustainabilityisatextremerisk.Twooftheprincipalreasonsfortheprojectedwaterconstraintsareshiftsinprecipitationandpotentialevapotranspiration(PET).Evapotranspirationisthesumofevaporativelossofwaterfromthegroundsurfaceandtranspirationlossesthroughvegetation.”www.nrdc.org/globalwarming/watersustainability/files/WaterRisk.pdf3.“Climate:Waitingtobattlewarming“imprudent”NASwarnsCongress(05/12/2011.)LaurenMorello,E&Ereporter.Climatechangeisrealandposes"significantrisks"tosociety,theNationalAcademyofSciencessaidtoday,warningthatdelayingcutsingreenhousegasemissionswillmakedealingwiththeproblemharderinthefuture."Eachadditionaltonofgreenhousegasesemittedcommitsustofurtherchangeandgreaterrisks,"thereportsays.Theplain‐spokendocument,preparedinresponsetoCongress'requestfor"actionoriented"advice,sayswaitingtocombatwarmingis"imprudent."ItcallsforthefederalgovernmenttotakealeadroleincombatingclimatechangeintheUnitedStates—whichitsaidcannotbeaddressedeffectivelywithpiecemealeffortsbystateandlocalgovernments—andabroad."Therisksassociatedwithdoingbusinessasusualareamuchgreaterconcernthantherisksassociatedwithengaginginstrongresponseefforts,"thereportadds."Thisisbecausemanyaspectsofan'overlyambitious'policyresponsecouldbereversedifneeded,throughsubsequentpolicychange;

Page 21: New Sustainability and Climate Models for the Intermountain West · 2019. 12. 21. · the Intermountain West is not immune to climate shifts ... in the protection, conservation, use

21

whereasadversechangesintheclimatesystemaremuchmoredifficult(indeed,onthetimescaleofourlifetimes,maybeimpossible)to'undo.'”Theanalysis,preparedbyateamofscientists,economistsandengineers,alsoweighsinonthestateofclimatescience,whichitdeemssound—thoughitsayssomedegreeofuncertaintyabouttherateandseverityoffutureclimatechangeisinevitable."Giventheinherentcomplexitiesoftheclimatesystem,andthemanysocial,economic,technological,andotherfactorsthataffecttheclimatesystem,wecanexpectalwaystobelearningmoreandtobefacinguncertaintiesregardingfuturerisks,"thereportsays."Thisisnot,however,areasonforinaction."http://www.eenews.net/eenewspm/rss/2011/05/12/14.CollaborativeManagementandResearchintheGreatBasin–ExaminingtheIssuesandDevelopingaFrameworkforAction.JeanneC.Chambers,NoraDevoe,andAngelaEvenden,editors.http://www.cabnr.unr.edu/GreatBasinWatershed/Issues_Papers.pdf“ThisGTRistheproductoftheworkshopon“CollaborativeWatershedResearchandManagementintheGreatBasin”thatwasheldinReno,NevadaonNovember28‐30,2006.CosponsorsincludedUniversityofNevada,Reno,DesertResearchInstitute,GreatBasinCooperativeEcosystemsStudiesUnit,UtahStateUniversity,AgriculturalResearchService,BureauofLandManagement,StateofNevada,DepartmentofWildlifeandGame,USDAForestService,Region4,USDAForestService,RockyMountainResearchStation,USGeologicalSurvey.”ThisfilecontainsanumberofreportsregardingclimatechangeandsustainabilityintheSouthwesternU.S.Insummation:“BecausetheGreatBasinisasemi‐aridregion,thechangingclimateislikelytohaveagreaterinfluencethaninmoremesicregions.TheGreatBasinwarmedby0.6to1.1Finthelast100yearsandisprojectedtowarmbyanadditional3to6Fbytheendofthiscentury(EnvironmentalProtectionAgency1998,Wagner2003).Precipitationincreased6‐16%inthelast50years;itisprojectedtocontinuetoincreaseinthefuture(Baldwinandothers2003).However,snowpackhasdeclinedandthedecreasesintheGreatBasinhavebeenamongthelargestinthenation(Moteandothers2005).Boththeonsetofspringandthetimingofspringsnowmelt‐drivenstreamflowarenowabout10‐15daysearlierthan50yearsago(Cayanandothers2001,Baldwinandothers2003,Stewartandothers2004).Inthefutureitislikelythatspringpeakflowswillbereducedandevenearlierasmorewinterprecipitationfallsasrain.Thefrequencyofdroughtsandfloodsispredictedtoincrease.Thesechangesinflowregimeswillresultinmanagementchallengesrelatedtowaterstorage,channelmaintenance,floodsanddroughts,pollutants,andbiodiversity(Baldwinandothers2003).Waterresourcesnowusedforhydropower,irrigation,riparianandaquatichabitatandfisheriesallmaybenegativelyaffected.”Thisreportprovidesaplethoraofsourcesandlinkstorelatedorganizations.5.“GlobalClimateChangeImpactsintheUnitedStates,”ThomasR.Karl,JerryM.Melillo,andThomasC.Peterson,(eds.).July2009.CambridgeUniversityPress.(inpublicdomain).ThisreportsummarizesthescienceofclimatechangeandtheimpactsofclimatechangeontheUnitedStates,nowandinthefuture.ItislargelybasedonresultsoftheU.S.GlobalChangeResearchProgram(USGCRP)andintegratesthoseresultswithrelatedresearchfromaroundtheworld.downloads.globalchange.gov/usimpacts/pdfs/climate‐impacts‐report.pdf

Page 22: New Sustainability and Climate Models for the Intermountain West · 2019. 12. 21. · the Intermountain West is not immune to climate shifts ... in the protection, conservation, use

22

“ThisreportsummarizesthescienceofclimatechangeandtheimpactsofclimatechangeontheUnitedStates,nowandinthefuture.ItislargelybasedonresultsoftheU.S.GlobalChangeResearchProgram(USGCRP)andintegratesthoseresultswithrelatedresearchfromaroundtheworld….Watersuppliesareprojectedtobecomeincreasinglyscarce,callingfortrade‐offsamongcompetinguses,andpotentiallyleadingtoconflict.”p.129beginsthediscussionoftheSouthwest.6.IdahoPayetteRiverBasinComprehensiveStateWaterPlan:Issues,considerations,andgoalshttp://www.idwr.idaho.gov/waterboard/WaterPlanning/CompBasinPlanning/Payette/PDF/Payette%20Resource%20Issues‐Goals.pdf7.SECUREWaterActSection9503(c)–ReclamationClimateChangeandWater2011,preparedbytheU.S.Dept.oftheInteriorBureauofReclamation.http://www.usbr.gov/climate/SECURE/docs/SECUREWaterReport.pdf“ArecentpaperbytheCongressionalBudgetOfficesummarizesthecurrentunderstandingoftheimpactsofclimatechangeintheUnitedStates,includingthatwarmingwilltendtobegreaterintheinteriorofthecontiguousUnitedStates.TemperatureandprecipitationconditionsoverWesternUnitedStatesregionaldrainagesareprojectedtochangeastheeffectsofglobalclimatechangearerealized.ProjectionsoffuturetemperatureandprecipitationarebasedonmultipleGlobalCirculation(orClimate)Models(GCMs)andvariousprojectionsoffuturegreenhousegasemissions(GHG),technologicaladvancements,andglobalpopulationestimates.Asurveyofthesemodelsoveranyoftheregionaldrainagesshowsthatthereismodelconsensusagreementreportedbetweenclimatemodelprojection.”ThereportdiscussesindetailthemajorWesternBasinsandrelevantpredictions.Italsoprovidesanumberofgreatvisuals.Inmylimitedresearch,thisisthebestresourceavailable.8.UniversityofNevada,LasVegasInstitutionalRepository–variousgovernmentreportsrelatedtowaterintheMountainWestregion,1945‐2009.http://digitalcommons.library.unlv.edu/water_pubs/9.UtahDepartmentofEnvironmentalQuality:ClimateChangeWorkGroup.TheDivisionofAirQualityreceivedagrantfromtheHewlettFoundationtohelpdevelopspecificpolicyandprogramoptionstodocumentandreducegreenhousegasemissionsinUtah.ThegrantwillhelpsupportastakeholderworkgroupthathasbeenestablishedandprovidesanalyticalsupporttotheGovernor’sBlueRibbonCouncilonClimateChange.TheworkgroupalsoassiststheCouncilinidentifyingpolicyandprogramoptions.http://www.deq.utah.gov/Issues/Climate_Change/index.htm10.”WateravailabilityfortheWesternUnitedStates—Keyscientificchallenges:U.S.GeologicalSurveyCircular1261”Anderson,MarkT.,andWoosley,LloydH.,Jr.,2005,85p.IntheWesternUnitedStates,theavailabilityofwaterhasbecomeaseriousconcernformanycommunitiesandruralareas.Nearpopulationcenters,surface‐watersuppliesarefullyappropriated,andmanycommunitiesaredependentupongroundwaterdrawnfromstorage,whichisanunsustainablestrategy.http://pubs.usgs.gov/circ/2005/circ1261/11.“Water,GrowthandSustainability:Planningforthe21stCentury,”Eluid Martinez, WaterIssuesintheWest.December2000.NewMexicoWaterResourcesResearchInstitute.http://wrri.nmsu.edu/publish/watcon/proc45/martinez.pdf

Page 23: New Sustainability and Climate Models for the Intermountain West · 2019. 12. 21. · the Intermountain West is not immune to climate shifts ... in the protection, conservation, use

23

12."West‐WideClimateRiskAssessments:Bias‐CorrectedandSpatiallyDownscaled"SurfaceWaterProjectionsDiscussesthetechnicalaspectsofmodelingpredictions.Thisdiscussionisveryinformativeifthereaderisinterestedinlearningsuchmethodologies.ThereportalsoprovidestheevidenceusedintheSECUREwaterreportlistedaboveandarangeofvisualaids.http://www.usbr.gov/WaterSMART/wwcra.html13.U.S.DepartmentoftheInterior,BureauofReclamation:ManagingwaterintheWest.http://www.usbr.gov/14.EPAClimatewebsite:Climateeconomics,Regulatoryinitiativesforgreenhousegasemissions,U.S.climatepolicy,andmore.http://www.epa.gov/climatechange/

Page 24: New Sustainability and Climate Models for the Intermountain West · 2019. 12. 21. · the Intermountain West is not immune to climate shifts ... in the protection, conservation, use

24

Reports&Studies1.“ClimateChangeandItsImplicationsforNewMexico’sWaterResourcesandEconomicOpportunities,”TechnicalReport45.BrianH.HurdandJulieCoonrod.NewMexicoStateUniversity,LasCruces,NewMexico,August,2008.Social,economicandenvironmentalsystemsinwater‐scarceNewMexicoandthroughoutthearidsouthwestarevulnerabletodisruptionsinwatersuppliesthatarelikelytoaccompanyfutureclimatechanges.WithaparticularfocusonpotentialeconomicconsequencesforNewMexico,thisstudyusesahydro‐economicmodeloftheRioGrandewatershedtointegrateplausiblechangesinclimatewithhydrologicresponsesandwaterdemandswithinaframeworkthatoptimizeswater‐useallocationsforthegreatesteconomicbenefit.Thestudyusesthreeclimatechangescenariosacrosstwofuturetimeperiodsselectedtorepresenttherangeofeffectsindicatedbytheoutputsacrosseighteenglobalclimatemodels(GCMs)usingtheSRESA1Bemissionsscenario.ThesesixclimatechangescenarioswerethenusedtomodelrunoffchangesusingtheWATBALhy‐drologicmodel(Yates,1996),whichintegratesclimateandhydrologicvariables,andtochangewaterdemandparametersinthehydro‐economicmodel.Primaryfind‐ingsconfirmthatecosystemsareatgreatestriskinNewMexico,followedbyagriculturalwaterusers,aswaterisincreasinglytransferredtomaintainurbanandindustrialusers,whoseeconomicproductivityisgreater.Whiletotalannualeconomiclossesareestimatedinthevicin‐ityof$300million,undersevereclimatechanges,whererunoffisreducedbynearly30%,botheconomicandnon‐economiclossesarelikelytobesignificantlyhigher.Thisisdueprimarilytotheeffectsofsomestronglyoptimisticmodelassumptions,e.g.,assumingnocon‐flictsoverwaterrightsorwatertransfersandtoseveralsignificantandvaluableomissionsintheanalysis,e.g.,theenvironmentalandsocialservicesthatagricultureandtheenvironmentprovide.http://www.law.arizona.edu/adaptationconference/PDFs/HurdCoonrodTR45.pdf2."ClimateChangeandUtah:TheScientificConsensus,"BlueRibbonAdvisoryCouncilonClimateChange(BRAC),SaltLakeCity,Utah,September2007.AsdirectedbyGovernorJonHuntsman’sBlueRibbonAdvisoryCouncilonClimateChange(BRAC),thisreportsummarizespresentscientificunderstandingofclimatechangeanditspotentialimpactsonUtahandthewesternUnitedStates.PreparedbyscientistsfromtheUniversityofUtah,UtahStateUniversity,BrighamYoungUniversity,andtheUnitedStatesDepartmentofAgriculture,thereportemphasizestheconsensusviewofthenationalandinternationalscientificcommunity,withdiscussionofconfidenceanduncertaintyasdefinedbytheBRAC.http://www.deq.utah.gov/BRAC_Climate/docs/Final_Report/Sec‐A‐1_SCIENCE_REPORT.pdf3.“EconomicImpactsofClimateChangeonColorado,”July2008.AReviewandAssessmentConductedbytheCenterforIntegrativeEnvironmentalResearch,UniversityofMaryland.Policymakersacrossthecountryarenowseekingsolutionstocurbgreenhousegasemissionsandtohelpusadapttotheimpendingimpactstriggeredbypastemissions.Thedebatetodatehasprimarilyfocusedontheperceivedcostsofalternativesolutions,yettherecanalsobesignificantcostsofinaction.Climatechangewillaffectourwater,energy,transportation,andpublichealthsystems,aswell

Page 25: New Sustainability and Climate Models for the Intermountain West · 2019. 12. 21. · the Intermountain West is not immune to climate shifts ... in the protection, conservation, use

25

asstateeconomiesasclimatechangeimpactawiderangeofimportanteconomicsectorsfromagriculturetomanufacturingtotourism.Thisreport,partofaseriesofstatestudies,highlightstheeconomicimpactsofclimatechangeinColoradoandprovidesexamplesofadditionalrippleeffectssuchasreducedspending inothersectorsandresultinglossesofjobs,wages,andeventaxrevenues.http://www.cier.umd.edu/climateadaptation/Colorado%20Economic%20Impacts%20of%20Climate%20Change.pdf4.“EconomicImpactsofClimateChangeonNevada,”July2008.AReviewandAssessmentConductedbytheCenterforIntegrativeEnvironmentalResearch,UniversityofMaryland.Policymakersacrossthecountryarenowseekingsolutionstocurbgreenhousegasemissionsandtohelpusadapttotheimpendingimpactstriggeredbypastemissions.Thedebatetodatehasprimarilyfocusedontheperceivedcostsofalternativesolutions,yettherecanalsobesignificantcostsofinaction.Climatechangewillaffectourwater,energy,transportation,andpublichealthsystems,aswellasstateeconomiesasclimatechangeimpactawiderangeofimportanteconomicsectorsfromagriculturetomanufacturingtotourism.Thisreport,partofaseriesofstatestudies,highlightstheeconomicimpactsofclimatechangeinNevadaandprovidesexamplesofadditionalrippleeffectssuchasreducedspendinginothersectorsandresultinglossesofjobs,wages,andeventaxrevenues.http://www.cier.umd.edu/climateadaptation/Nevada%20Economic%20Impacts%20of%20Climate%20Change.pdf5.“GrowthandSustainabilityintheLasVegasValley”SonoranInstitute,Tucson,AZ,January2010.http://climatechange.education.unlv.edu/sites/default/files/FinalLasVegasReport12‐17‐09lores.pdf6.LeagueofWomenVotersofUtahWaterStudy,September2009.In2008theLeagueofWomenVotersofUtahdecidedtodoastudyofUtahwatersothatwecouldbetteradvocateforourmembers’deepconcernsaboutwaterforpeopleandwaterfortheenvironment.Thispaperisconcernedwithaccountingforourwaterandhowwemanageit,notwithwaterqualityeitherforhumanusesorforwildlife.http://www.lwvutah.org/AirWaterIssues/lwvutWaterStudy_10‐10‐19.pdf

7.“TheLastDrop:ClimateChangeandtheSouthwesternWaterCrisis”FrankAckermanandElizabethA.Stanton,StockholmEnvironmentInstitute(SEI)–U.S.Center,Sommerville,MA,February,2011.http://sei‐us.org/Publications_PDF/SEI‐WesternWater‐0211.pdf8.Nevada:2010‐2011PolicyandProgramReport:WaterResources,April2010‐Nevadawaterlaw,charts,etc.http://www.leg.state.nv.us/Division/Research/Publications/.../33‐WR.pdf9.“NevadaInfrastructureforClimateChange:Science,Education,andOutreach”February2009.Thevisionofthisprojectistocreateastatewideinterdisciplinaryprogramthatstimulatestransformativeresearch,education,andoutreachontheeffectsofregionalclimatechangeonecosystemservices(especiallywaterresources)andsupportuseofthisknowledgebypolicymakersandstakeholders.http://www.nevada.edu/epscor/nsf/ertab/aaas/Piechota_Project%20overview.pdf

10.NewMexicoClimateChangeInitiatives:BackgroundInformationonNewMexicoClimateChangeInitiatives(5):Recognizingtheprofoundimplicationsthatglobalwarmingandclimatevariationcould

Page 26: New Sustainability and Climate Models for the Intermountain West · 2019. 12. 21. · the Intermountain West is not immune to climate shifts ... in the protection, conservation, use

26

haveontheeconomy,environmentandqualityoflifeintheSouthwest,NewMexicoGovernorBillRichardsonsignedexecutiveorder.http://www.nmenv.state.nm.us/cc/

11.Reclamation:ManagingWaterintheWest.SECUREWaterActSection9503(c)–ReclamationClimateChangeandWater2011.U.S.DepartmentoftheInteriorPolicyandAdministrationBureauofReclamationDenver,ColoradoApril2011.http://www.usbr.gov/climate/SECURE/docs/SECUREWaterReport.pdf12.“RenegotiatingUrbanWaterManagementinFlagstaff,Arizona:OriginsandImplicationsofConservationPolicies.KristenE.Reed,Geography&RegionalDevelopment,”UniversityofArizona.Drawingfromarchivaldata,ItracesocioeconomicandbiophysicalfactorsthatledtotheimplementationofconservationmeasuresinFlagstaff,Arizona.Acontentanalysisofcontemporarywaterproblems,theircauses,andpotentialmanagementresponsesinformedbysemi‐structuredinterviewswithkeywaterpolicymakersinthearea,representativesfromcommunityinterestgroups,andscientistsindicatesthatmorethanthreetimesasmanyinformants,includingthosewithhistoricallyopposingviewpoints,preferconservationmeasuresoversupplyaugmentationpolicies.http://www.usbr.gov/lc/.../09_CL1‐04ThesisFlagstaffH20Mngmnt.pdf13.“MunicipalDeliveriesofColoradoRiverBasinWater:NewReportExamines100CitiesandAgencies,”PacificInstitute.MichaelJ.Cohen,June2011.ThePacificInstituteisoneoftheworld’sleadingindependentnonprofitsconductingresearchandeducationtocreateahealthierplanetandsustainablecommunitiesdocumentspopulationandwaterdeliveryinformationandtrendsfor100citiesandagenciesthatdeliverwaterfromtheColoradoRiverbasin.Since1990,thenumberofpeopleintheUnitedStatesandMexicowhouseColoradoRiverbasinwaterhasincreasedbymorethan10million‐–buttheiroverallpercapitawaterusedeclinedbyanaverageofatleastonepercentperyearfrom1990to2008.http://www.pacinst.org/reports/co_river_municipal_deliveries/crb_water_8_21_2011.pdfAspreadsheetofdatacompiling water use and population data and calculating per capita use rates. It also lists the sources for the data used in this report: http://www.pacinst.org/reports/co_river_municipal_deliveries/

Page 27: New Sustainability and Climate Models for the Intermountain West · 2019. 12. 21. · the Intermountain West is not immune to climate shifts ... in the protection, conservation, use

27

SecondarySources:NewspaperArticles1.“ClimatechangetohitAmericanWestwatersupply.”AlertNet(Reuters)25April2011ClimatechangecouldcutwaterflowinsomeoftheAmericanWest'sbiggestriverbasins—includingtheRioGrandeandtheColorado—byupto20percentthiscentury,theInteriorDepartmentreportedonMonday.“Irrigation,drinkingwatertobeaffectedby2100…Driestareasarealsosomeofmostheavilypopulated…InteriorDepartmentcallsforconservation,efficiency.”http://www.trust.org/alertnet/news/climate‐change‐to‐hit‐american‐west‐water‐supply2."No,thesnowdoesnotdisproveglobalwarming"EzraKlein.TheWashingtonPost,February10,2010.“Intheaggregate,Earth'satmosphereisgettingwarmer.Butthataffectsparticularclimatesindifferentways.What'sdifficultaboutgettingittosnowisn'ttemperature,butprecipitation.Andglobalwarmingisexpectedtoincreaseprecipitation.”http://voices.washingtonpost.com/ezra‐klein/2010/02/no_the_snow_does_not_disprove.html3.“QuenchingLasVegasThirst”PhoebeSweet.LasVegasSun.WithexpectedchangesinclimateandnochangeinwaterusageLakeMeadcouldrundryby2021.http://www.lasvegassun.com/news/topics/water/4.“Report:ClimatechangetosapUtahwatersupply”UtahNews.TheSaltLakeTribune.April25,2011.TheColoradoRiverBasinlikelywillloseabout9percentofitsannualrunoffbymid‐centurybecauseofawarmingclimate,furthersqueezingUtahanditsneighborsinaregionthatalreadyexpectstostrugglegettingwatertoitsgrowingpopulation,accordingtoaU.S.InteriorDepartmentreportreleasedMonday.http://www.sltrib.com/sltrib/politics/51690000‐90/report‐colorado‐river‐climate.html.csp5."TheFutureIsDryingUp"JonGertner.TheNewYorkTimes,October21,2007.http://www.nytimes.com/2007/10/21/magazine/21water‐t.html?pagewanted=print“ThesnowpackintheSierraNevada,whichprovidesmostofthewaterforNorthernCalifornia,wasatitslowestlevelin20years.Chunotedthateventhemostoptimisticclimatemodelsforthesecondhalfofthiscenturysuggestthat30to70percentofthesnowpackwilldisappear.AcatastrophicreductionintheflowoftheColoradoRiver—whichmostlyconsistsofsnowmeltfromtheRockyMountains—hasalwaysservedasakindofthoughtexperimentforwaterengineers,arisksituationfromtheouteredgeoftheirpracticalimaginations.Some30millionpeopledependonthatwater.Agreatlyreducedriverwouldwreakchaosinsevenstates:Colorado,Utah,Wyoming,NewMexico,Arizona,NevadaandCalifornia.Almostwithoutexception,recentclimatemodelsenvisionreductionsthatrangefromthemodesttothecatastrophicbythesecondhalfofthiscentury.Onestudyinparticular,byMartinHoerlingandJonEischeid,suggeststheregionisalready“pastpeakwater,”amilestonethatmeanstheriver’swatersupplywillnowforevertrenddownward.”Theauthorcontinueswithadiscussionofeconomicimpacts,includingmassout‐migration,ofwatershortages.6."SteadyState:ASustainableEconomyfortheSouthwest"StevenKotler.Ecohearth,July2,2010.“WesternstatesrelyontheColoradoRiver,buttheriverisnolongerviable.Lastyear,astudydoneattheScrippsInstitutionofOceanography(publishedinWaterResourcesResearch)comparedwaterusage

Page 28: New Sustainability and Climate Models for the Intermountain West · 2019. 12. 21. · the Intermountain West is not immune to climate shifts ... in the protection, conservation, use

28

topopulation,thenfactoredinavarietyofglobal‐warmingpossibilities.Itconcludedthereisnowa50‐50chancebothLakeMeadandLakePowell—theColorado’smajorfeeders—willbebonedryby2021.Andsincetheentirearearunsonhydroelectricpower,thestudyalsofoundthatthisenergytapcouldbeturnedoffby2017.”http://ecohearth.com/eco‐op‐ed/482‐steady‐state‐a‐sustainable‐economy‐for‐the‐southwest.html7.“ColoradoRiverwaterpolicyfacesanageoflimits”TheSaltLakeTribune:April20,2010Climatescientistsarepredictinga10‐to‐30percentreductioninflowfortheColorado—astarkcontrasttotherosyassumptionsthatunderlaytheColoradoRiverCompactwhenitwassigned88yearsago.ResearchersfromtheScrippsInstitutionofOceanographyrecentlypredictedthatLakeMeadandLakePowellhavea50percentchanceofgoingdryby2021.Thesedays,LakeMeadisat45percentcapacityandLakePowellisat57percent.http://www.sltrib.com/opinion/ci_14921852