26
, 27 , 2 , 2015 1436 203 , 27 , 2 , 203 228 , 2015 1436 1 03 08 1435 ; 08 11 1435 : , , 30 , , , : , : , : , : , : , : 80 % , , : , , , __________________________ _______________________________________________ ________ The Evaluation of the Instructional Practices among Science Teachers in Elementary School in light of Trends Based on Cognitive Economy in KSA Muneerah Mohammed Fahad Al-Rasheed (1) Princess Nora Bint Abdul Rahman University (Received 01/06/2014; accepted 03/09/2014) Abstract: This study aimed at: 1) preparing a list of standards for evaluating the instructional practices among elementary school science teachers in light of trends based on cognitive economy in KSA, 2) defining the level of the instructional practices in light of these standards, and 3) clarifying the statistical differences among the instructional practices of science female teachers.The sample of the study consisted of (30) elementary school science female teachers distributed throughout the northern, western, southern and middle centers of Riyadh. The tool of the study was an observation card. After applying the tool and analyzing the results of the study, the study reached six standards for evaluating instructional practices. The results revealed that 1) the level of practicing the first, second, third and fifth standards, i.e. the ethical pillar, preparing female pupils for getting knowledge, developing thinking skills and cooperative work, was high; 2) the level of practicing the fourth and sixth standards, i.e. information and communication technology and leadership, was intermediate; 3) the level of practicing the standards as a whole was high but it did not reach the level of precision (80%); and there were no statistically significant differences among the instructional practices of science female teachers due to the scientific qualification and instructional experience variables. Keywords: Evaluating, instructional practices, science female teachers, cognitive economy. _________________________________________________________________________ ________ 1 , , , , 225858 , 11342 (1) Associate Professor, Faculty of Education, Princess Nora Bint Abdul Rahman University. Riyadh, Saudi Arabia, P.O. Box (225858) , Postal Code: (11342) : [email protected] e-mail:

New 311 . %/ $0 · 2017. 2. 11. · ! 1436 ˝ 2015 ˘ , 2 , 27 , – 203 – ! 1436 ˝ 2015 ˘ , 228 − 203 " " , 2 , 27 , ˘ˇ ˆˇ ˙˘ ˝˛ ˘˜ ) $ ˚ ˚ ˜ ! "# $ ˝ %& ' (

  • Upload
    others

  • View
    2

  • Download
    0

Embed Size (px)

Citation preview

  • �� �������� ���� ���� ,27 ���� ,�2� ������ ,�2015��1436 !�

    – 203 –

    �� �������� ���� ���� ,27 ���� ,�2�" " , 203 − 228 ������ ,�2015��1436 !�

    �������� ����� ����� ���� ��� ��������� ������ �����

    ���� �� �!� "# �$����� ��%&���� '�( � �������� ������� �)$� �

    *+,� -,���.��� �%/ �$0113

    %&���'( )* +,�- +./0� ��/�1 � 2 3*�� �403�08�1435; !3*�� 6'47 2 08�11�1435 !�

    45���: 8 ( � 9:�;�� �� ?� @ 2 � A:�>B� ��C��� ������ �� 4B� �����F�� �A���� �P�9�� 2,.����� LM! ?�@ 2 F/ �Q7 , R7�S�� %( TUP��7 �� ��7 �A�� ]^��/ 8( B� ��C� �� ������

  • A��� =N 9 +.*/: �A:�>B� ��C��� ������ �� � ���N` gU*�7 e/7 ���uA N���� �� g+,�n�� �I

    e����O>4B� e+�A� C�*/ e�AN�;n��7 e�A(D>1B�7 e�AG�AF��7 e�����7,8( g��'�� g�0� � w�^ M�� g�/0� �� ����� −\�]I �/7 − �� (W � N��� �� =� !,Dn> G�7 �=SA�I7 �N���� �>-J 8( +,;�� �� 6A1 ;�

    � 9*� �F A:��� ,��O �� % / + C�7 � gq�;A'bI7 g�N����N B i� A��( i�FN�*/ ��7�� w�PI >C7 ,����� ��O>4B� ,� N���� ��� bI 2 � A�(�S e�^,�U �� 8( i+,��4 w�PI w` � A!�N��� KJ � � 4 D � �S�>f�� 1B�� XActionaid, 2003, p. 66�X w�F �A- V 47�(Nelson, 2010 �� =S/ w`

    6PU ��� \� l� u / � = 2���� ��O>4B� ,i� /�9( � N���� 8 ( L|� S- g9> � � ,o>�� %/ �1 e6 ��Q ~ ( Y;N sA� +�4 /7 +7� ,O/ �=��17 �7�� �� � A��( +,� b>/ */ KJ � q�Ab�/ e �

    B� �q�| �N���� �-�*AP� i�}�` 6 ,�AI�GB�7 ��O>4 j:� >- )o @7`7 ,� A��( �A-�F-J �A9*I *( �=Sh�

    r �� \� 1 �G�,� Gal Breath, 1999) � ��O >4B� w` g��O >4B� � ! %�3���7 ��� w�;�� 2 g��FAG M��

    2����,�| T:� ��� 8 ( g9> � g� �� y -` < ̂ ` D^ e<� A->�� ,� 10�7 ,�bAF '�� e � I +�� T:����, 77| � �� ;� >�� \D (0� �/`7 ,HA��>��7 ,�G*�7

    +� PS�� eF/ ��S�� HAA;I H>AG7 w` uAb>F

      e��� �/ ,�;/ 8( sA�7 ,H��>�X

  • �� �������� ���� ���� ,27 ���� ,�2� ������ ,�2015��1436 !�

    – 205 –

    g,Dn> GB�7 ,+� A� E / %��9>F �� ¥�,>��7 HA��>�� � PS�� e\� �� x`, � !,�'>(� ��3'�� �,��9�� 6(�S�� ��>��7 r�o>�� KJ i�A�G g.A{>��7 g���b>��7 , 2����7

    6^�A�7 T:���� T�>¦ 2�9�;�� ��,��W� � X 9��7�]���7, 2007 �7�Z���, 2004�X

    � � �G�,� )*A7�2003 � � (�9� � *! w` 2� ��� ��O >4B� gH g( I >�� §�*��� %/ ,� =*/7 : � A*

    E�>F �� e� �A>Q % / )--W� ��f>G� ,6A!¤>�� %/ ¨���� � © 6 'e4

    � N��/ Hª � � N��/ «�* gh ��17 ,w�PF�� %/ ��G�7 ,� n�� �A1��� *P>�� Z��A>G�7 \¬� F>�� 8( +,47 �A1���*PI7 H�(7 ���bI7 ro e�/�c*/ g��17 �M^7

    «�� X � � ,�`7�2009" ,3 � w` KJ � ! HA ��>��

    \d l % / � N���� ( \�l � ,7��� g®�>S/ � A9*I � A�9��� ,� �g� M �� 3 '�� \��� x`�� �A;A;C Y'I� / � N���� ��O>4� u9>� w` �| *��7 ;�A9A��>�� H��> A� �� S�� i� h�N gA >� M�� HA��>�� u9>� ��=S9 a ;oA� Hg��> �7 ,6 9�� w`   H��>�7 , g � � � TA^

    I�| X �A¯¤ !�7 HA��>�� ,7�

    , A E�1` rAC �N���� ��O>4� �o- 1�>�� 2 �2007 � 2 2� ��� ��O >4B� ,7� % ( eTUP�� KJ )N! i�G�,�

    � G�,�� u9>� w� PI7 ,w�,0� 2 ��� ��c*�� ���bI � A�� ��7 ,,� ¡w` KJ �G�,�� )�h�I7 � A�P�� ea;o>�� �1 � �B� e4B� ��=S� a ;Q � 1, � h�t� �A�F� �� V �A:�OCJ / F /7 lB E] �gI �� =S��

    �G�,���6!�� ,� A'�,>�� 4d� � A�9( |D - ?� *7 ,� N���� +,��W ��( ,�°J ,� AP��/0� + o>�� F/ \�C �A*A1.N

    / %/ �G�,�� u9>� w�PI7� �B��� 2 x,� �� �� , E9 �7�7]>� w` KJ �1�o MA/d>�� w` j:�>*�� �� � A*;>�� \dl %/ +�N��>��

  • A��� =N 9 +.*/: �A:�>B� ��C��� ������ �� � >�� �����F�� �A���� H!�( VA9���^0� %/ �A:��U( �*A( 8( �G�,�� );'g°

    �160� �� H !` w` KJ � G�,�� )� h�I7 ,� 2 6n9>I �����² : �A-7P�W� �G,�� �o- \�o>��

    E-School u/ ³���>��7 �-�*AP�� H��>�� �o- \�o>�� H ,�N���� ,�P>�7 �>-J �o- \�o>�� H ,%��l�X �� ( +o>�� H/0� �9c*/ ���;I ¡V7�2002 � w`

    ] A^�� g¥¡�b>� HA��>�� 2 2���� ��O>4B� o* / aA'bI H��>�� 8( i�N�^ G��o ,L,7� ]�]�I7 , � ��C � C�IJ7

    � 69��� , \�� 'I7 ,\�O IB� 6:� G7 > ��f>G�7 � A�4�7 6 P �� �A�9��� 2 �q�;A'bI7 �� , ] A9>I w` ¥ µ >�� �9=�� e�� E� ¶A�o>��7 g4�*�� g.PS>��7 9���� ro'�� 6 9��� � G,�v7 ,��7 ,Hª � (� W� u / gH� F *� D j j!� *�� g�A* w�PI w` *�9 ;2���� ��O>4B� ��7 ,2���� ��O>4B�

    F�,ILMA/d>� ,¹�� '�� LM! %/7 : (� gH � N�{�� � pA

  • �� �������� ���� ���� ,27 ���� ,�2� ������ ,�2015��1436 !�

    – 207 –

    ?� *'��7 4�*�� . PS>�� V � A-7��>�� S/ °��;9�� HA c*I7 ��7 ,MA/d>�� HA ��>�� ?� *` HA!� S�� ��� bI7 ,Hq� ^�| 2 � =*�]¢ GB� Z��G0� ��f>G�

    ��

    �,� 6P��/ � 4 ;N �N���� 2009) Michael Barber, � iDA��I iD��>/ MA9�>�� w�P� w¤ ��O;�� �/ @�I i�����/

    A1 i�, ¨�>��^: Well educated = E (K+T+L).U I rAC E

    KJ � /�(�� � A4dl0�, 7K ,� N���� KJ .U I7 T KJ.PS>��, �/`L +�� A;�� KJ .U>N g+�� A4 *�I7 M A9�>��

    �M 7 ,%�� l¼�7 FS*� w½ N Barber _7� ¾ ] A^�� A�;>�� 8( �N���� .PS>��7 4�*�� KJ E /u G7` 69U A� e� ,� PN0�

    +����� KJ , �G�F \��N` H:�(�� �M^7 �A4dl0� >�� \� Q .¤ >�� ��O � u 9>���X � �F ��

    »7��7 ,2012�X HA ��>�� � ���¿ �� e�� ¡wJ eN�7, C` �=>SO ������ j!�*/ 2 �n�� e��7 iD=N ,�b� w` ������ H��/ 8( )@�N ,2���� ��O>4B� F � w`7 ,�� LM �ÀA�9(

    s�,>�� *( �A�(�S +]=10�7 , 2 i�. A{I ) @�N D^j=* 9�� ;A;� gM S*g�� �=N ;/�=/7 ������ H��/ ,�7�` X

    ¡TO�� 6l�� 6(�SI g�A�9( s�,>�� w` D7 7` ´�,�� \d l %/ �AG�,�� +����7 MA/d>��7 H���� V 1,�l 1�I w` � S�� % 9N � S�>f�� � N���� ,��O / 2���� ��O>4B� ( 2 V9��9�� �AF�,>�� ��7 «�W� �o- ,a��S�� ®7� 69���7 X Ml0� u/7 �� �M �AF �,>��

    ?� * � g]�>F � 2� ��� ��O >4B� ? � @ 2 ������ 9��� H> � r Ao ������ 9��� �� �� �A�9( 2 +��� wD}� g6A'F��H��> � , !7 j/�� HA9OI *( g��GB� H>� M�� ,�°W� ��n9 �o@�7 .���/ ?�@ 2 H>� M�� H��;>��N ,H���� ��(J

    9A��I ��c- ` ���bI 2 +.'^ �A¯` �X

  • A��� =N 9 +.*/: �A:�>B� ��C��� ������ �� 4B� ������ E>*/ ̧ g� l ;��2009 � e�� %/ �( KJ ������ I,7� 2 e\� o> e�;��>��

    �� LM ! % /7 ;2� ��� ��O >4B� �o- �P�9�� �/�c*/ ®dhJ7 ,2���� ��O>4d� �A*°��� �*���� ?�U-J

    ¥�, >��7 HA ��>�� , r o'�� 8 ( R� S-W� +�� �_7��� b>��7 , �� � A*'�� .N� I�YAbf>��7 ��O>4B� +,�_7 ,2010X�

    ] A^�� \d l %/ �| aA;o>� �P�9�� )�G7HA��>�� 8( ,U � HA ��>�� w` KJ g� bg t� g.U I r AC 6P

    M �� � /0� ;u 9>��� 2 �N���� 3*� �FA:��� �/�c*�� ��� b> a ��>I ���} ;�� % / � (�9� � ��/ g¥ �b>� ,� A9*>�� HA ��>�� Y ,7 ,+� A� E/ H¡��>��7 ,j!�*�� T �>¦ 2 HA ��>�� � /�c*/ ��� bI7 ,� N���� ¥���I7

    ¥ �b>I >�� +�P'�� ���Sb�� ��C�/ %/ i?�>� �=�C��/�=1 M �� �/� � � � / HA��>�� i?�=>-�7 ,+.'^ i��

    ~^` i�/D>!�7 i��G�I ¥�b>�� Xa�G u1��� ,2010�X «73 / ,�� LM �D> !B� �!� c/ %/7 ,] �]��� '( % Á�'( ��� VS�3�� V/�� ���l

    ,Á� cSC���bI 2 �A(�- ��;- aA;Q KJ �F� M�� HA ��>�� j!� */ V 9��>�� � D

    +�� (J KJ �} �` «73 ��   ª7 , ��� -7 u / w7� �>�� �|7 ,+,� b�� �� ���� j!�*/ �P�9�� LM ! ga A'bI 6 9>^� r AC ,� A����� 6 A!7�1�/ �^

    �� ( 2 �A:�>B� ��C�9�� j!�*��1432 !�1433 ! X Â� o'�� A�J )� h�I � /  C¤ M l0� H I7

    ,��7 \dl %/ H��>��7 HA��>�� �A�9( 2 ����� ��7 6/¤>�� g6 P U g�7 ,�A9���� +�D�� �7�*I Z��G`7 +�� ������ ,� o�� � (�*>��7 �S�>f�� I�,�=9 9���� ?�O;>GB� �=*A9} I KJ �N� @W� j=* �� �bU -` u A 2 sA:���

  • �� �������� ���� ���� ,27 ���� ,�2� ������ ,�2015��1436 !�

    – 209 –

    ��1 � A*;>�� H ���� gY , � dl % / H> � � A;A'bI ¥- 8( i��>/ TA}� M�� �/0� ,MA9�>�� �A/�A�� �G,D��7 ¥A�� G` �} �` j!� *�� LM ! 9>�I7 ,H��> �� � A�9(

    �(�*>/ H��;I a:��°7� X ,?�G¬���7 n�7���1433 !�X

  • A��� =N 9 +.*/: �A:�>B� ��C��� ������ �� � �AG�G0� �*'��� g6 P UgI >��7 6 C���� 2 ��O >4B� ��=S/ ��C KJ �N�@W� ,�;Cd�� �AG�,�� >�� � A��� � G�,�� e?�� 1W i�,~ / 1 7̀ �v ,2����

    VA��>�� V��F�� �=>�PU/ �� F/ �/

    �� ?� @ 2 � A:�>B� ��C��� ������ 4B� 8( �9:�;

    m�n�� \�F�� : V i�A:�OCJ ���� R7�N 1�I 6! � �C��� �� ���� �� F/ ��O >4B� 8 ( � 9:�;�� �� ?� @ 2 �A:�>B�

    .{>� E ] �gI 2�����9���� 6!�� ,�A9A��>�� +~t��? ������� ���(�/:

    � �A @�S��K70 : � �B� gB� ��C��� ������

    �AF�,>�� +~t� .{>� E ] �gI 2���� ��O>4B�X � A-�n�� �A @�S�� : � �B� gF / V �A:�O CJ �� B� ��C��� ������

    6!�� .{>� E ] �gI 2���� ��O>4B�X � n��n�� �A @�S�� : F / g6O � B

    ?� @ 2 � A:�>B� � �C��� �� ���� ���>F / KJ 2� ��� ��O >4B� 8 ( � 9:�;�� �� E

    w�;IJ�80X�% ������� :��;4B� 8( �9:�;�� �� ?�@X 2 X �� F/ g�Q

    ;�� �� ?�@ 2 �A:�>B� ��C��� ������ 8( �9:�2���� ��O>4B�X

    3 X E�>F / V �A:�OCW� eR7�S�� e%( gTUP�� � A:�>B� � �C��� ������ �� 4B� 8( �9:�;�� �� ?�@ 2

    .{>���AF�,>�� +~t�7 ,9���� 6!��X� ������� �=��:

    1 X� ���� B� � �C�9�� � TO�� % G , g� %v ,������ �;b*9� ,s/�t�7 ,u����

    x��F��7 �:�>B�X 2 X HI >�� .����� B� � �C��� �� ���� �� e) ;'g°7 ,2� ��� ��O >4B� 8 ( � 9:�;�� ��

    l g�G�,�� ´�, �� �� ��� m� n�� ´�,�� 6OS�� \d1435 !− 2014�X

    ������� >%,�:

    2 Sh��� gj=*�� � efg>G� �G�,�� ��A'b� i�;N7

  • �� �������� ���� ���� ,27 ���� ,�2� ������ ,�2015��1436 !�

    – 211 –

    % / % Pv , 4 ~ ^` 8 ( \�O o�� �AoF �� I,�h �� ���� �� 4B�X

    ������� ��?@ �:

    H��;>�� : �AF �,>�� B� ��C��� ������ 4B� 8( �9:�;��

    �G�,�� LM! 2 ��{�� �M < e(g̀X �AF�,>�� f�� x, �� iE�>F / � dl % / ga ;o>� ,� A��( +?� SP � bt� 2

    � Ç` � A��� � G�,�� 2 � g O ; g�7 ,M A9�>�� 6}N` :D ��/ �= G,�È >�� ¥A�� G0� %/ �(�9� �� ���� g<

    +,� b�� �� ���� j!� */ s�,I ?�*` �A:�>B� ��C��� LM �*9} �� 2� ��� ��O >4B� 4B� : e]:� ^��� C` � g� £9A��I ��c-

    � A*;>��7 ������ ^ �� % / . n^ 2 � 9=��� g ª7 +� �>�� � N���

    ,�=SA�I7 ,�=/�f>G�7 ,�=AN �^,�U��7 ,MA/d>�� E��!,�P>�7 , i��A'° (�W�7 9���� g.PS>�� 'O� P�

    i��3 i� 4�° �� g-�P� w` %/ H g=*P9� �v ,Hª� i�'F>P/ /

    i�N�^ �S�>f��X �'��&A������� �:

    B=< :C$�D �%�,�#= �������:

    �� ���� � w �PI ]^��/ wDn� ���>�� �A/�P� x,��� �A:�>B� ��C���

    !7 �� ���� � ;b*9 � A9A��I� : ,Z� *� ,\DU �����'�� ,�7��� ,�}=*�� ,Z�{�� ,YG��� ,�SU��� HI7 ,

    �*A( g,�A>l� �!���N` �( ��O4 30 �� � A:�>B� x,� �� �' �� ����

    � A��>�� � A9A��>��� : \DU HA ��>��7 � A�� ¥ >P/�� ���� Y G77 Z�*�7 ,Z�{�� ¥>P/7 ,������ �

     �SO �� % G ,g� %¡v :x��F �� , u ����7 s/� t�7:�>B� X �*A( g,�A>l� HI7 �A9A��>�� ]^���� w0 ;��O4

    a°�*/ wDn� �9F;/ , a°� */ u ,` ,� A>l� H I ¨� >��7�G�,�� +��` aA'bI ���>/ .FA>� , � 9��/ 6 ^ wJ grAC

    KJ  �} � ,VI� / � q,��_ � G�,�� +��` aA'bI ¥¡�bI � �1W�7 , i� 9��/ w�d �!�( �G�,�� �*A( w` �|

    � G�,�� I �= @7�N7 �AF �,>�� +~ t�7 ,6 !��^ ;�*A��� �*A�/ ̧ :�Ol ,

    �G�,�� �*A( ̧ :�Ol V'� ¨�>�� \7�7X

  • A��� =N 9 +.*/: �A:�>B� ��C��� ������ �� �� ?� @ 2 �AF �,>��

    �A��>�� B� X

    Z−� 9:�;�� �� (J ,��O / �Q : <*> G� G�,�� 4B� ��=S/X 2 X ( 2 H��> ��7 HA ��>�� � A�9( ¸:�Ol

    2���� ��O>4B�X 3 X2���� ��O>4B� ( 2 H���� ,�7�`X 4 X+,�b�� j!�*�� -

    2���� ��O>4B� ( 2 HA��>��X −E� >o�� R h % / a ;o>�� : g�� ( H I

    V 9 ¡Po�� % / � (�9� 8( �A�70� �q,�h 2 e�9:�;��R�°7 j!�*�� \�� 2 H=*/ ��,` % / Âd7 s�,>��

    r AC % / H=:�,Ë 8(  ��>�� �|7 ;������ cCd/X � −,� A�/ 6 P � h�t�

  • �� �������� ���� ���� ,27 ���� ,�2� ������ ,�2015��1436 !�

    – 213 –

    �� 8( �=@�15 � HAPo> ��/�4 %�M�� V9 Po�� .[ iDP R�°7 j!�*�� \�� 2 H=*/ ��FI ,�9:�;�� �A�70� +,�O�� E / % / ^¤>�� ;�� ���� ��

    d ,>� i�;N7 G��� ^2 � w� A'� �'G�*/ E/,� A�/ 6P �h�t� ��7 ;.�� �/ �>G\70� ,� A��� :� A4dl0� � /�(�� , ,� A���7

    m�n�� :��� 8 ( \�O o�� �� �pAq� N� , ,� A���7r��n�� :u ���� ,� A��� ,.PS>�� G� �(�9� 8( �cCd�� �4�b– ���N` %( T�>¢ �G�,�� �*A( − ������ *� �!�(

    �>B� x,� �� � 2 �A:�>B� ��C��� � A/�P� � A:�A��>�� ���[0� aA;o>� �|7 ;������ �;b*9:

    − � 4�b'�� a A'bI %/_ �Q: Y G�>/ w` V ' I�� \7� V'/ �|7:

    E=�&123FV�PQ=�W �7�< ��PS�� H���� �%W �!�@P�= �!�@P�� +���� X� ����� H)�F

    ,�A��� \70� m�n�� r��n�� u���� s/�t� x��F��

  • A��� =N 9 +.*/: �A:�>B� ��C��� ������ �� �� \7� V'/ �! D^ w�G.:

    E=�&133 F�!�@P� ��)�� �&����� �!�@P�� +���� X� ����� HW Y� Z�P��� �U����F

    ,�A��� \70� m�n�� r��n�� u���� s/�t� x��F�� º�'I,B� 6/��/ 0.794** 0.879** 0.904** 0.922** 0.846** 0.569**

    º� 'I,� ��� i�A=È j:�>*��X

    B����L :���5��� ���� �\� K����]�:

    E / w� A'� ���P G � ^ u �/ ��f> G� H I,�A�/ 6P �h�t� G� H I � G�,��

    T.test independent sample,,� '>l�7 T.test One

    Sample, ,�'>l�7 One Way AnovaX �� F/ �o>�7

    >�� ,� A��� 9g>(� �� ���� ¥F C E�>F �� �� ;>� ¨� x� A;�� + N \� ° �Q HI rAC ,É�F� YG�>��

    �� A���� �7 �7 �A- �� �7 � � LM ! 2 �f>F �� %/ �G�,��� KJ �Sh3� , E�� Z�FC HI7� �9A4 ~^`

    – �9A4 64` =3 – 0= 3� � �|7 ;�SO�� !7 x�A;�� 2 �9A4 ,�� \7�7:

  • �� �������� ���� ���� ,27 ���� ,�2� ������ ,�2015��1436 !�

    – 215 –

    E=�&143 F^��_� `���� K�� �!�@P�� ����7� ��������� ������ �����F

    ����� �&�� ����� �&���� ^��_� `���� ����� �����

    �/�*/ 0 %/ 64`0.75 �/�*/ �SA�@ 1 %/0.75 %/ 64` KJ 1.5 �SA�@

    �bG�>/ 2 %/1.5 %/ 64` KJ2.25 �bG�>/ +.'^ 3 %/2.25 KJ 3.00 +.'^

    w�;IW� E�>F/ �Q HI7�80 �% aN��I 8( i?�*

    �M�� V9 ¡Po�� ?�,Ë H�� ;I .�� �/ �9:�4 HAPo> ��/�4 %�AF�,>�� ���Q:

    � G�,�� j:� >*� i� @�( g?] � �M ! g\7� *>� ,�=>�p G` 6F �F>� i� ;N7 �= g@ � ( E� 17 ,�=>U 4�*/7

    ¨�>�� �o*�� 8( �|7:

    B=< :�%�9!�,�= E=]� E�I���� ����� >���,��:

    �G,D�� E�>F/ �/ �� ���� �� < 8 ( � 9:�;�� �� ?� @ 2 � A:�>B� ��C���

    ?2���� ��O>4B� g�� )' eF gC \70� \�F�� %( ��1�

    ,�A�/ 6P �h�t� �� \7�X

    E=�&153 FE=]� ����$� ��������� ������ �����= �����_� ��@���� :��!UL]� ���#���F

    � *��7�� `����

    ^��_�

    :��?Q�

    a�����

    �����

    �����

    1 �9���� _]�I �A/dGW� �*>��! %/ �;n'*�� �� T4���� 2 �°�'}�� ���� �o- �� �9���� 1�IX 2.40 0.62 .'^ 8 �� 1�IÉ�µJ 6PU )--B� �P' 8( ro'�� GB �� �9�� X 2.10 0.75 YG�>/ \70� ,�A���

  • A��� =N 9 +.*/: �A:�>B� ��C��� ������ �� F / w` a�F �� \7 � %/ }>�� A4dl0� � /�(�� ,� A�/ � B %=} �7 ,/

    6 +��  ,��9�� \�h���   +�� ��7 ,��� %/ � À�1 �9���� �N�I������ X 2.57 0.57 .'^ m�n�� ,�A��� F / w` a�F �� \7 � %/ }>�

    ,�A�/ G� ,.'^ �^ ,�A���7

    w` KJ �| E ] � g�7 ,YG�>/ D=>G,�v E�>F9N +,�_7

  • �� �������� ���� ���� ,27 ���� ,�2� ������ ,�2015��1436 !�

    – 217 –

    � A'�,I l� % / :��;�� H=S�� / ���F �� +�;S�� �G,�v E�>F/7 i�}�` ,u1�� 47 \� � 2 � G,D�� LM ! ��C KJ �|

    Z� �b�� �D>!B� 8( 6OQ y ¨�>��7 ,������ s�,I w` KJ �| gu 1�� D ,7 , *9}>� D Y'I�I +,�=�� LM! �G,�v % �A@��, !� �9���� .n>FI� 8( �A9A��>�� _�{�0� � ®�°\�n�� 6A'GX� 2.30 0.88 .'^ 2 ������ ,�;/ s�,I 2 9���� ?�O;>GB� �9���� �f>FIX 2.53 0.63 .'^

    3 4�*�� .PS>�� � �'G�*/ ¥A��G` �9���� �f>FI� � N��/ ,.F S>�� ,lB�7 'U�� 17` ]AAÈ ,º�'*>GB� ,^B�7 ro'�� 8( u�UI �A9A��I T4��/ 2 �� �9���� 3IX 2.43 0.68 .'^ 6 �>*>GB�7 ,�PN0� ®�° 8( �� �9���� ]SQX 2.53 0.68 .'^

    7 �� FI�HA!� S�� Y:��l , 6 C ,� �B�� � b��l

    ;�� H��>�� ,/

    9 �AI�AC T4��/ 2 �'F>P�� ������ HA!�S/ aA'b>� �� 1�IX 2.10 0.76 YG�>/ r��n�� ,�A��� G,�v E�>F 9N �� G�>��7 �*/�n�� VI�;S�� ?�*n>G

    +,� b�� j!�*�� ��A'b� �| u1��7 ,YG�>/ � 9(��7�bU -0� �� �� "��40�7 , ��p G` % / >*9} I � /7

  • A��� =N 9 +.*/: �A:�>B� ��C��� ������ �� ^�7 ¨B>GB�7 4�*�� .PS>��- e��] A9>��7 «� W� � o , )*9} I i�} �`7

    2 � q�;A'bI7 �N���� gT�� D +�A� u4�7 %/ ?�O;>G� �( �� �� H>� �/ idA�47 H g=S��7 g�^M>�� grAC %/ ,

    ��=S�� aA'bI ��C��X

    E=�& 183 F�����_� ��@���� C����� ����$� ��������� ������ �����= :�� ��= ������ ��&���,)�F

    � *��7�� `����

    ^��_�

    :��?Q�

    �a���� ����� �����

    1 ������ s�,I 2 +��>�� Y:�G��� �9���� �f>FI���AS�� ,�� +]=10� ��f>G� *(X 2.77 0.57 .'^

    4 ,�U�� �A-7P�W� u4���� 8( «d°d� )--W� 2 ro'�� � ��f>GB �� �9���� 1�I

    ,�;�� Z�>P�� �=A�JX 2.17 0.83 YG�>/

    5 2 �A9A��>�� j/�~�� �h�l +]Av �A-7P�J u4��9 �� �9���� �7]I>A º�U* ̂������ s�,I X 1.43 0.90 TA�@

    6 � d� �� �G,D�� �G,� 9�� E�>F/ VI� ;N7 ,YG�>/ � �G,D�� E�>F/ ,� A��� �G,D� ¶P�� E�>F�� w�^ �M� ��A>-7 ,TA�@

    i�bG�>/ , �� +,��W� �bU -` KJ . '^ E�>F / 8(

    % / HA ��>�� � i�/D>!� )�7` >�� ������ �;b*9 �� Y:� G��� ��f> G�7 ,

    s�,>�� ?�*` X +,� �_ \d l Å eC� g� � / �^M �� ��17� x,� �� ,��O��  �[ ¡w` aA'b>�� ?�*` x,��� +] =

    +��>�� Y:�G��� , A >� � v ,� A^M�� +,�'F�� i�h�Ol7\� �N 6PU s�,>�� �G,�v X w� ^ ;N ������ +�;S�� �/`

    � w` KJ �| u1�� 47 ,YG�>/ �=>G,�v E�>F/

  • �� �������� ���� ���� ,27 ���� ,�2� ������ ,�2015��1436 !�

    – 219 –

    �A-7P�W� u4���� KJ �� «�1, w` E�I P�� �*9}>�� %= g}� g6 ¡}S�

    \� C %q� /���/ ?��W �!�o- �� A1�I �l��AG�,�� +���� X E�>F / 8 ( �F /�t� +� ;S�� )�OC7

    u 4���� w¤ P�� �A-7P�W�

    8 ( �1 ? ¥e( �G,D�� LM! w¤ )�O C7 ,F / 8 ( �G��F�� +�;S�� � =*( % e� (g̀ H���� e/ �! �/ ?�@ 2X 2.47 0.68 .'^

    4 69��� P�� � N���� ?�� J   �Ano ��X 2.20 0.96 YG�>/

    6 ;*��7 ����� A1�>� sA�7 HA��>�� "�N �Ç` 8( H��>�� 2 / D=> G,�v E�>F 9N �F /�t�7 ������ VI�;S��

    ��� �(�*;� �| u1��7 g g-�^ ,m7� �>�� 69��� �A¯¤ �� � A*/]�� + S�� % / 6 �;�7 ,� (D� ®7, �A9*I 8( 6AO o>�� �A9*I 2 H=F� D ��7 � A�µW� �� �9=�� ¹��'�� C` w�A^2003) (Quion, 2 6}N` H��I aA;Q 8( 69�I >��

  • A��� =N 9 +.*/: �A:�>B� ��C��� ������ �� �� 4B� ( � �1��/7 ��7 ,MA/d>�� V

    ,Hq�^�| 2 �=9Ac*I7 �=*�]¢d °B� HI7 +,� �_ \d l « �� m7� �>�� H��>�� �bU-` %/ �( 8( x,���

    � A9A��>�� |D* ��7 Y:� � �SAo h7 �A4,��� �� � A'�,>�� �� ��f> G� 8 ( �� ���� � HA��>��7

    s�, >�� 2 m7� �>�� X���� +� ;S�� � /` E�>F 9N � � / �=>G,�v �,� ���7 ��� *�� 2 �^,�U �� 8 ( ] ASo>�� w` E�I

    � G,�� +,��J7 º�U *�� � 9��/ "�O>l� %/ �A9���� , �| u1��7 , YG�>/ �=>G,�v E�>F/ �F/�t� +�;S��7 � A9���� B� ��C��� %/ 8(` i���9( i��C�X

    E=�&1103F g����� ����$� ��������� ������ �����= �����_� ��@���� :*������F

    � *��7�� ^��_� `���� :��?Q�

    a�����

    �����

    �����

    1 %��l� �(�U/ +�(��/ �A¯` �9���� _]�IX 2.30 0.79 .'^ 2 ���� «_�I�A��pF�� 69Q 8( %q,4 9*� D �� 8( ,�7�0� �9X 1.60 0.77 YG�>/ 3 / 7 %=�l� �*/�P�� / x��F�� ,�A��� /

    �=�^ �4�b'�� 2.33 0.36 .'^

    � G,�v E�>F / w` a� F �� \7� %/ }>�

    ,�A�/ / �^ ,�A���7 �F /�t�7 K70� VI� ;S�� ?�*n> G� ,TA�}�� E�>F�� H c�/ w` KJ �| u 1��7 , . '^ D=> G,�v E�>F9N ��C��� %/ `'� +��A;�� 8( ¥�,>�� w` % ̂ , g� ,7 �� , H[��� � o- � 9=�� �� % / +�� A;�� � G,�v w` % / w7� �=> G,�v % P9� +,� =�� LM =N ,2� ��� ��O >4B� � G,�v w` KJ �N� @J ,L���bI ,�c>-� 7` j=*�� x�F��

    � LM! � ��*� �� ¥ !��/  �U>^� ¥�b>I +,�=� %/ i�.'^ i�=1 ¥�b>� �M!7 ,�=>'!�/ ¥FC +MA9�I 6^

  • �� �������� ���� ���� ,27 ���� ,�2� ������ ,�2015��1436 !�

    – 221 –

  • A��� =N 9 +.*/: �A:�>B� ��C��� ������ �� CB� � 9A;�� w` a�F �� \7� %/ }>� %/ ~^`�0.01 � 27 � 4�b'�� .�� �/ % / ,� A�/ 6 ^ 2

    �=�^ �4�b'�� ,| R7�N ��17 �( 8( \� �v � �B� F / *( �A:�O CJ�0.01� ,�0.05 � V

    �� � f>�� ��

    %q�, 47 %q� -�P/W , � = g��*/ +~ t� w` KJ i�N� @J �(�*>/ ��F>^� "�N7 +��>/X

    � A-�n�� �A @�S�� :B� ��C��� ������

    9���� 6 !�� . {>� E] �gI 2���� ��O>4B�� ,�� ��.>F 1�/ ,x��,��� P X� �A @�S�� �o h ,� '>lB7

    �� C0� %�� '>�� 6 A�Q � efg>G�One Way Anova , }>�7¨�>�� \7� �|:

    E=�&1123 F �$�!= ������ `����= ������ k�$D= X��P��� �� �l:m j$��� H;I� +n� �o��F

    ����� X��P��� �� � ������ k�$D ���_� ��&�� `����

    ������ F Sig. ����� �����

  • �� �������� ���� ���� ,27 ���� ,�2� ������ ,�2015��1436 !�

    – 223 –

    C��� p E=�&1123F

    ����� X��P��� �� � ������ k�$D ���_� ��&�� `����

    ������ F Sig. ����� �����

    F/ *( �A:�OCJ ��B� � E ] �gI

    9A��>�� 6!������� ,.>F1�/ ,x��,���P� �M 7 ,�G�,�� �7�N %/ m�n�� ��S�� a;o>� , �| u1�� 47

    ?� @ 2 �AF �,>�� �� � A'�,>�� !� >�� � +,�_���

    2���� ��O>4B� XD���� w` KJ �| u1�� 47 ��& %/ <� G,D�� \d l %/ �AF�,>�� �� �9���� �>Q 4 − � / C KJ − % /

    % / � n^` w` �| H ( �7 , 9���� 6 !�� / +,�O �cCd�� � 4�b'�� 27 .����� LM! 2 9���� 6!9�� E ] �gI i�A:�OCJ 2 � =A�J 6 h�>�� H I >�� � �A>*�� LM ! T �>¢7 ,�=�^

    �G�,� %( V>;�F�� V>A@�S�� ,A�2007 � % / w�^ >�� V �A:�O CJ � �B� - ��O >4B� ��=S/ a;Q �1, �h�t� �A�F� ��

    � G�,�� /  d> lB E] �I 2� ����6 !�� ,+~t��,7 ���� R7�N ��17 �}�` a�F�� \7� %/ }>�

    ,�A���7 r��n�� ,�A�9�� À�A:�OCJ ��B� E�>F/ *( s/�t��0.05 � .�� ��� LM ! 2 R7� S�� LM ! L� ¾� 8(  ��>��7

    ¨�>�� \7� 2 �| A@�I7 ,ASA ,�'>l� � efg>G�: E=�&1133 Ff��N� �����= e��S�� ����� ��@���� Y� h=�7�� q�r� "# :���� a��P�� s�7�. ��P�L�F

    ����� H;I� ����

    � =18.500

    g������)�

    �= 21.105

    +��&��

    � =25.400

    ���� � =18.500 − 2,605 6,900* � x��,���P= 21.105 − − 4,294 r��n�� ,�A���

    � .>F1�/ =25.400

  • A��� =N 9 +.*/: �A:�>B� ��C��� ������ �� F1�/ =20.600 * ��B� E�>F/ *( �����0.05�

    � ��� R7� N �� 17 a�F �� \7 � %/ }>�

    � �B� E�>F/ *( i�A:�OCJ�0.05 �r ��n�� ,� A��� 2 : ��� �� / V . PS>�� F1��� 6!/ ��O� .>F1�� , w¤ �| ¿ S�7 �AOO¢ +,�O �=A�( ]A^�� H>� .PS>�� �A9*I F1��� +§� ��� s�, >�� ��X

    B�S��R :�%�9!�,�= �S��S�� ��(�7��� ����� >���,��:

    �� F/ 6O� B 8( �9:�;�� �� ?�@ 2 �A:�>B� ��C��� ������

    w� ;IJ E�>F / KJ 2� ��� ��O>4B��80�% ,� '>lB7 ,�o h,� '>l� � efg> G� �A @�S�� �T. Test One-Sample� � 4�b'�� .�� �� Ï�NB� YG�>�� ¥ eF gC7 ,

    ¨�>�� �o*�� 8( �|7 ,�=�^ �4�b'��7: ���>G� 8(`�3*�80=% 2,4* 6^ �7 ,Ï�NB� YG�>��¨�>��:

    E=�&1143 F �$�!= ��@����l�m�� �%W �!�@P��= �!�@P�� +��� u���\� ����� ���?�� *���= �,�F

    ����� ����7�� ��# `����

    v�w/�

    `����

    ^��_�

    h=�/

    ��@����

    :��?Q�

    a����� �$�!l�m

    �$����

    ������� ����� �����

    \70� 8 19.20 21.13 1.93 3.21 3.295 0.003 *( ����0.01 m�n�� 9 21.60 22.16 0.566 4.27 0.726 0.474 \�� .[

  • �� �������� ���� ���� ,27 ���� ,�2� ������ ,�2015��1436 !�

    – 225 –

    C��� p E=�&1143F

    ����� ����7�� ��# `����

    v�w/�

    `����

    ^��_�

    h=�/

    ��@����

    :��?Q�

    a����� �$�!l�m

    �$����

    ������� ����� �����

    r��n�� 9 21.60 21.30 − 0.30 4.20 0.388 0.701 \�� .[ u���� 6 14.40 12.83 − 1.56 2.85 3.007 0.005 *( ����0.01

    s/�t� 7 16.80 16.93 0.13 3.4 0.210 0.835 \�� .[ x��F�� 7 16.80 12.90 − 3.90 3.04 7.018 0.00 *( ����0.01

    �=�^ �4�b'�� 46 110.40 107.03 − 3.36 16.75 1.100 0.280 \�� .[

    ¶� �/ a�F�� \7� %/ }>�: \70� ,�A��� : ;�A:�OCJ ��B� CB� �9A;�� w0�0.01� R7� S�� )-�^7 , �� ��O �

    �AF �,>�� w� ;IW� E�>F � )� h7 \70� ,� A�9���80�%X

    m� n�� ,� A��� : � �B� CB� �9A;�� w0 ;�A:�OCJ %/ ~^` �A�D�0.01� �|7 ,

    LM ! ) -�^7 ,� ��!�1 )F A�7 � ��!� R7�S�� w0���!�c�� R7�S�� w` *�� � v ;�F� YG�>�� ��O�

    E�>F � )� h7 m� n�� ,� A�9�� �AF �,>�� �� ��O�

    E�>F � 6OI y r��n�� ,�A�9�� �AF�,>�� F/ %/ i�'��4 )-�^ �=*P�7X u���� ,�A��� :OCJ ��B� CB� �9A;�� w0�0.01� R7� S�� ) -�^7 , �� ��O �

    �AF �,>�� w� ;IW� E�>F � 6O I y u ���� ,� A�9���80X�%

    s/� t� ,� A��� : � �B� CB� �9A;�� w0 ;�A:�OCJ�0.01� �|7 ,

    S�� w0 LM ! ) -�^7 ,� ��!�1 )F A�7 � ��!� R7� w` *�� � v ;�F� YG�>�� ��O� ���!�c�� R7�S�� E�>F � )� h7 s/�t� ,�A�9�� �AF�,>�� �� ��O � R7� S�� w` *�� � v ;� NB� Y G

    �AF�,>�� F � 6O I y x��F�� ,�A�9�� w�;IW��80X�%

  • A��� =N 9 +.*/: �A:�>B� ��C��� ������ �� �� F/ %/ i�'��4 )-�^ �=*P�7 ,

    � G�,�� �7� N %/ r��n�� ��S�� N, HI �M7 X \7 � % / � =A�J 6h�>�� HI >�� j:�>*�� LM!7�14 �

    1W� 2 � =A�J 6 h�>�� H I >�� j:�>*�� H(I % ( � � i� /D>!� ) �7` HA ��>��7 � A�� +,�_�N ;\70� \�F�� M AS*I � ��>/ 8( (� '�,I �A>CB i�/ w7� DN YG�>/ �G,�v E�>F/

    ������ F/ �A'�,I j/�� ��(J +,7 �� � �/t� ?�*` ������2���� ��O>4B� 8( �9:�;�� ��X

    4. 8 ( �A'�,I �� a°�*�� E�>F/ �AF�,>�� ��

    �� ?� @ 2 �� ���� ^� e�_d ��>4B� 8( �9:�;��2���� ��OX

    5 . x,� �� HA ��>��7 � A�� +,�_7 �7] I w` �� � 0� � G�,� ��O>4B� HA!� S/7 �/f>F�� �n�� s�,>�� a:��°

    2����X * * *

  • �� �������� ���� ���� ,27 ���� ,�2� ������ ,�2015��1436 !�

    – 227 –

    �$��!= ��� �C&���

    B=< : ������� C&���:

    .FAI ,x�7,-`X�2010� X� HA��I �o-( *'/ ´,/ ��O>4B� 82����Xu ���� É� ��� �È �� �\70� ¨7 ��� X HA ��>��

    6';>F �� 4B� ,7�w�,0� 2 ���L�,�>^� ���G, , X � �/�1 ,� A�� �A�^

    0� ,�/.��w�,X + o>�� H/0� �9c*/ ���;IX� 2002� X� HA ��>�� ®d hJ «73 /

    uA9��� HA��>�� �A*°��� �bt� ,2���� ��O>4B�7 ,wD( ,w�,0�X

    AG 9 ,��X� 2009� X� ��O >4� ?� * 2 L,7�7 HA��>�� ���bI \70� �È 9�� � ;/ ro ,�N����� m7 P�W� HA ��>�

    � %( H��>��7 :(�*h6';>F�� � %/ +S�� ������ ,7−9x,�/ X

    ��� 1 % G�G ,9 ��X� 2006� X� ¥ >^ 2 � A*;>�� /d�� w�,0� 2 i�n� C ,� b�� ´� G0� u���� TO�� j!�*/

    2� ��� ��O >4B� o*/ u / � =;N��I E /7X ��� G,w�,0� ,,J ,�/.�� ��/�1 ,.>F1�/X

    H �! ,� �X� 2003� X� y� ��� ��O >4B� KJ \� o>�� (7²�/����� ,�AI�/����� ¤'*�� �P':

    http://www.annabaa.org/nbanews/25/119.htm

    .FAI ,+���t�;���]��7 ,1�/X� 2012� X�� �� �� c*�� 2 �n��n�� �AS�0� 2 w�,0�X,wD( /�� �'>P/ X

    Z��� ,9 X�2004� X� ? */ % o- %�` �N���� 4� � ��É����)��P�� , ,46 , ,233−258 X

    wD�J ,n�7���;m�q ,?�G7���7 X� 1433 ! X� �� \70� TO�� ,�;/ s�,I 2 ������

    ,s�,>�� �C;/sS* �� H�(7 �A�� ���G, ,42 ,93−116X

    +]�]( ,�F��;�A! ,»7��7 X� 2012� X� HA!�S/ 69( �,7 s �� \7� 2 I��Q7 I�;A'bI7 2� ��� ��O >4B� A1�I 2 HA��>�� 8(0� s���� ��=1 ,�A�t� w7��>��

    2� ��� ��O >4B� �o- �b4 ��7 HA��>�� X % / � C7��10−11��>^` X

    Z�' 1�/ ,/�{��X� 2012� X� �� ���� ¥ >^ E� > H�� ;I ?� @ 2 � A:�>B� � �C��� %/ �A-��  �SO�� +,�b��

    +,� >¦ .���/.>F 1�/ ��� G, , , � �/�1 ,� A�� � A�^ E�;�� �`X

    A'( % \�M! ,A=S��X� 2011� X� ������ H��;I ?� @ 2 �����F �� � A���� �P�9�� 2 �A:�>B� ��C��� �� ���� 2 � A�7�� �� � G�,� */ u:� 47��O>4B� : ,�� ���� ,�/�>F / ����O >4� � A9*I � o-

    �����F�� �A���� �P�9��X %&��� '( ,9 ��;+]:� N ,7�] ���7 X� 2007� X� j=* ��

    2���� ��O>4B�7wD( , ,u�_�>��7 3*�� +.F�� ,��X

  • A��� =N 9 +.*/: �A:�>B� ��C��� ������ �� 4B� +,�_7YA bf>��7 ��X� 2010� X� �� G�>�� � A9*>�� � bl2010−2014 ,YA bf>��7 ��O >4B� +,�_7 ��7 �A�� +,�_7X� 2003� X� �A�';>F / � �¬, � o-

    w�,0� 2 ��� ��c*�� E >*/ KJ � /;/ 69( �4,7 ,,6';>F�� w�,` 2 HA��>��w�,0� ,wD( X

    +,�_7 �A�� HA��>��7. ��3 ��� � bt� ,�����F�� �A���� �P�9�� HA��>���2005− 2015 X�8( ®�>/:

    http://www.ed.edu.sa/gproject B��Q�R :��P,&]� C&���:

    Actionaid .(2003). Knowledge and Progress Section: An

    Introduction. Available on Line:

    http;//www.use.ac.uk/d196/actionaid/sectionna/intr

    oduction.Htm

    Bonal, X., & Ramba, X. (2003). Captured by the Totally

    pedagogies society: Teacher and Teaching in the

    knowledge Economy. Globalization, Societies and

    Education, 11(2) 169-184.

    Galbreath, J. (1999) preparing the 21st century worker: the

    link between computer based technology, nov. des.

    14_22.http:www//etext. Virginia, Edu/ journal

    Malhotra, Y.(2003). Measuring national knowledge assets

    of nation, knowledge system for development,

    expanding public space for development of

    knowledge society: Department of economic and

    social affairs division for public administration and

    development management, United Nation, New

    York, 68-128.

    Molebash, P. (1999). Technology and Education: Current

    and Education: current and Trends. IT. Journal.

    (On-line). Available:

    http://etext.virginia.edu/gournal.

    Nelson, M. (2010). The adjustment of national education

    systems to a knowledge – based economy: a new

    approach, Comparative Education, 46(4),463-486.

    Peters, M. (2002). Education Policy Research and the

    Global knowledge Economy, Educational, 34(1),

    pp.91-102.

    Quion, J. (2003). Staff Development for the knowledge

    Economy. Ontario Institute for Studies in

    Education, Canada.

    Salinger, T. (1995): IRA, Standards, The Education

    Reform. The Reading Teacher, 49(4), 290-297.

    * * *