Nevyas v. Morgan Docket 031100946

No Items in Cart

Civil Docket Report

A $5 Convenience fee will be added to the transaction at checkout.

Case Description

Case ID: 031100946

Case Caption: NEVYAS ETAL VS MORGAN

Filing Date: Friday , November 07th, 2003

Court: MAJOR NON JURY

Location: City Hall

Jury: NON JURY

Case Type: EQUITY - NO REAL ESTATE (TRO)

Status: FINDING FOR PLAINTIFF

Related Cases No related cases were found. Case Event Schedule No case events were found. Case motions No case motions were found. Case Parties

Seq # Assoc Expn

Date Type Name

1 21-JUL-

2005

ATTORNEY

FOR PLAINTIFF

LAPAT, ANDREW

Address: STEIN&SILVERMAN PC

230 S BROAD ST 18TH

FL

PHILADELPHIA PA

19102

(215)985-0255

Aliases: none

2 13 PLAINTIFF NEVYAS MD,

https://fjdefile.phila.gov/efsfjd/zk_fjd_prvt_efile_00.secured_logon?tid=&redir=_Mn

HERBERT J

Address: 1528 WALNUT ST

PHILADELPHIA PA

19102

Aliases: none

3 13 PLAINTIFF NEVYAS-

WALLACE MD,

ANITA


PHILADELPHIA PA

19102

Aliases: none

4 13 PLAINTIFF NEVYAS EYE

ASDSOCIATES


PHILADELPHIA PA

19102

Aliases: none

5 15 DEFENDANT MORGAN,

DOMINIC

Address: PO BOX 1011

MARLTON NJ 08053 Aliases: none

6 16 19-AUG-

2004

ATTORNEY

FOR

DEFENDANT

FRIEDMAN,

STEVEN A

Address: 850 W CHESTER PIKE

HAVERTOWN PA 19083

(610)789-0568

Aliases: none

7 DEFENDANT NEVYAS,

HERBERT J


PHILADELPHIA PA

19102

Aliases: none

8 DEFENDANT NEVYAS-

WALLAC, ANITA


PHILADELPHIA PA

19102

Aliases: none

9 DEFENDANT NEVYAS EYE

ASSOCIATES


PHILADELPHIA PA

19102

Aliases: none

10 11 DEFENDANT FRIEDMAN,

STEVEN A

Address: NONE GIVEN

PHILADELPHIA PA

19100

Aliases: none

11 ATTORNEY

FOR

DEFENDANT

ALBERT,

JEFFREY B

Address: 48 OAKWOOD DRIVE

DRESHER PA 19025

(215)641-1718

Aliases: none

12 19-OCT-

2005

ATTORNEY

FOR

DEFENDANT

FRIEDMAN,

STEVEN A

Address: 850 W CHESTER PIKE

HAVERTOWN PA 19083

(610)789-0568

Aliases: none

13 ATTORNEY

FOR PLAINTIFF

SILVERMAN,

LEON W

Address: 230 S. BROAD STREET

17TH FLOOR

PHILADELPHIA PA

19102

(215)985-0255

Aliases: none

14 28-SEP-

2010

JUDGE MAIER, EUGENE

E

Address: 392 CITY HALL

PHILADELPHIA PA

19107

(215)686-7551

Aliases: none

15 ATTORNEY

FOR

DEFENDANT

HANZELIK, CARL

Address: 1121 WESTBURY ROAD

JENKINTOWN PA 19046

(215)884-0847

Aliases: none

16 ATTORNEY

FOR

DEFENDANT

HOFFMAN,

PETER J

Address: ECKERT SEAMANS

CHERIN MELLOTT

TWO LIBERTY PLACE

50 SOUTH 16TH ST

22ND FLOOR

PHILADELPHIA PA

19102

(215)851-8400

Aliases: none

17 16 ATTORNEY

FOR

DEFENDANT

FITZGERALD,

MAUREEN P

Address: MARSHALL,

DENNEHEY

620 FREEDOM

Aliases: none

BUSINESS CENTER

SUITE 300

KING OF PRUSSIA PA

19106

(610)354-8270

18 PRO SE FILER MORGAN,

DOMINIC J

Address: PO BOX 1011

MARLTON NJ 08053

(610)364-3367

Aliases: none

19 28-SEP-

2010

JUDGE FOX, IDEE C

Address: 656 City Hall

PHILADELPHIA PA

19107

(215)686-4222

Aliases: none

20 28-SEP-

2010

JUDGE ROGERS, PETER F

Address: STE 1408 CJC

PHILADELPHIA PA

19107

Aliases: none

21 JUDGE DINUBILE, JR.,

VICTOR J


PHILADELPHIA PA

19107

(215)686-4214

Aliases: none

22 JUDGE MANFREDI,

WILLIAM J


PHILADELPHIA PA Aliases: none

19107

(215)686-2606

23 JUDGE MOSS, SANDRA

M


PHILADELPHIA PA

19107

(215)686-7910

Aliases: none

Docket Entries

Filing

Date/Time Docket Type Filing Party

Disposition

Amount

Approval/

Entry Date

07-NOV-2003

11:37 AM

COMMENCEMENT OF

CIVIL ACTION

LAPAT,

ANDREW

10-NOV-2003

12:00 AM

Docket

Entry: none.

07-NOV-2003

11:37 AM

COMPLAINT FILED

NOTICE GIVEN

LAPAT,

ANDREW

10-NOV-2003

12:00 AM

Docket

Entry:

COMPLAINT WITH NOTICE TO DEFEND WITHIN TWENTY (20)

DAYS AFTER SERVICE IN ACCORDANCE WITH RULE 1018.1 FILED.

07-NOV-2003

11:37 AM

SHERIFF'S SURCHARGE

1 DEFT

LAPAT,

ANDREW

10-NOV-2003

12:00 AM

Docket

Entry: none.

07-NOV-2003

11:37 AM

WAITING TO LIST

STATUS CONF

LAPAT,

ANDREW

10-NOV-2003

12:00 AM

Docket

Entry: none.

07-NOV-2003

01:46 PM

ACTIVE CASE 07-NOV-2003

01:47 PM

Docket

Entry: none.

10-NOV-2003

09:45 AM

PRELIMINARY

INJUNCTION

LAPAT,

ANDREW

10-NOV-2003

12:00 AM

Docket

Entry:

09-03110609 EMERGENCY PETITION FOR TRO AND PRELIMINARY

INJUNCTION FILED.

10-NOV-2003

09:47 AM

MOTION ASSIGNED 10-NOV-2003

09:47 AM

Docket

Entry:

09-03110609 EMERGENCY PETITION FOR TRO AND PRELIMINARY

INJUNCTION ASSIGNED TO JUDGE SYLVESTER, 11-10-03.

12-NOV-2003

09:34 AM

CORRECTIVE ENTRY 12-NOV-2003

12:00 AM

Docket

Entry:

PROTHONOTARYS ENTRY....PLEASE DISREGARD ABOVE ENTRY

OF SHERIFF SURCHARGE ENTERED IN ERROR. MFS

18-NOV-2003

12:13 PM

ORDER ENTERED/236

NOTICE GIVEN

SYLVESTER,

ESTHER R

18-NOV-2003

12:15 PM

Docket

Entry:

09-03110609 UPON CONSIDERATION OF PLAINTIFFS' VERIFIED

COMPLAINT, PLAINTIFFS' PETITION FOR TEMPORARY

RESTRAINING ORDER AND FOR PRELIMINARY INJUNCTION,

DEFENDANT'S RESPONSE THERETO, IT IS ORDERED AND

DECREED THAT THESE PETITIONS FOR TEMPORARY

RESTRAINING ORDER AND FOR PRELIMINARY INJUNCTION ARE

DENIED. BY THE COURT...SYLVESTER, J. 11/17/03

26-NOV-2003

12:25 PM

PETITION FOR

RECONSIDERATION

NEVYAS MD,

HERBERT J

28-NOV-2003

12:00 AM

Docket

Entry: 81-03112181 PETITION FOR RECONSIDERATION FILED.

28-NOV-2003

12:26 PM


12:26 PM

Docket

Entry:

81-03112181 PETITION FOR RECONSIDERATION ASSIGNED TO

JUDGE SYLVESTER ON 12-1-03.

03-DEC-2003

12:51 PM

AMENDED COMPLAINT

FILED

LAPAT,

ANDREW

04-DEC-2003

12:00 AM

Docket

Entry:

AMENDED COMPLAINT WITH NOTICE TO DEFEND WITHIN

TWENTY(20) DAYS AFTER SERVICE IN ACCORDANCE WITH RULE

1018.1 FILED.

08-DEC-2003

01:39 PM

ENTRY OF

APPEARANCE FILED

FRIEDMAN,

STEVEN A

10-DEC-2003

12:00 AM

Docket

Entry:

ENTRY OF APPEARANCE OF STEVEN A. FRIEDMAN FILED ON

BEHALF OF DFT DOMINIC MORGAN.

08-DEC-2003

03:46 PM

ANSWER TO

COMPLAINT FILED

FRIEDMAN,

STEVEN A

15-DEC-2003

12:00 AM

Docket

Entry:

ANSWER TO PLAINTIFF'S COMPLAINT WITH NEW MATTER AND

COUNTERCLAIM FILED BY DEFENDANT DOMINIC MARGAN.

12-DEC-2003

03:57 PM

CORRECTIVE ENTRY 12-DEC-2003

12:00 AM

Docket

Entry:

PROTHONOTARY CORRECTIVE ENTRY: PLEASE NOTE THAT THE

AMENDED COMPLAINT ENTERED ON 12/3/03 WAS ENTERED IN

ERROR, THE AMENDMENT SHOULD HAVE BEEN REJECTED

UNDER RULE 1033...RFW

15-DEC-2003

01:41 PM

ANSWER

(MOTION/PETITION)

FILED

MORGAN,

DOMINIC

16-DEC-2003

12:00 AM

Docket

Entry: 81-03112181 ANS FILED TO PETITION FOR RECONSIDERATION

19-DEC-2003

10:18 AM

ANSWER

(MOTION/PETITION)

FILED

NEVYAS MD,

HERBERT J

05-JAN-2004

12:00 AM

Docket

Entry: 81-03112181 ANS FILED TO CROSS-MOTION FOR SANCTIONS

13-JAN-2004

10:50 AM

SUPPLEMENTAL

PLEADING FILED

NEVYAS MD,

HERBERT J

15-JAN-2004

12:00 AM

Docket

Entry:

81-03112181 PLAINTIFFS' SUPPLEMENT MOTIN FOR

RECONSIDEDRATION FILED.

14-JAN-2004

08:48 AM

LISTED FOR STATUS

CONFERENCE

14-JAN-2004

08:48 AM

Docket

Entry: none.

16-JAN-2004

01:00 AM

NOTICE GIVEN 16-JAN-2004

01:00 AM

Docket

Entry: none.

23-JAN-2004

01:18 PM

REPLY FILED LAPAT,

ANDREW

23-JAN-2004

12:00 AM

Docket

Entry:

PLAINTIFF(S) REPLY TO NEW MATTER & COUNTERCLAIM OF

DEFENDANT

26-JAN-2004

08:51 AM

PARTIAL

DISCONTINUANCE

FILED

LAPAT,

ANDREW

27-JAN-2004

12:00 AM

Docket

Entry:

ORDER TO DISCONTINUE PLTFS' CLAIMS WITHOUT PREJUDICE

FILED BY PLAINTIFF(S) ATTORNEY.

27-JAN-2004

12:10 PM

ANSWER

(MOTION/PETITION)

MORGAN,

DOMINIC

27-JAN-2004

12:00 AM

FILED

Docket

Entry:

81-03112181 ANSWER TO SUPPLEMENTAL MOTION FOR

RECONSIDERATION FILED.

27-JAN-2004

01:44 PM

SUPPLEMENTAL

PLEADING FILED

MORGAN,

DOMINIC

27-JAN-2004

12:00 AM

Docket

Entry: 81-03112181 SUPPLEMENT TO RECONSIDERATION FILED.

02-FEB-2004

04:27 PM

MOTION TO STRIKE MORGAN,

DOMINIC

03-FEB-2004

12:00 AM

Docket

Entry: 10-04012510 RESPONSE DATE 2-23-04.

06-FEB-2004

01:00 PM

REPLY FILED FRIEDMAN,

STEVEN A

09-FEB-2004

12:00 AM

Docket

Entry:

DEFENDANT DOMINIC MORGAN'S REPLY TO PLAINTIFFS' NEW

MATTER AND AFFIRMATIVE DEFENSES WHICH PLAINTIFFS

INCLUDEED IN THEIR ANSWER TO DEFENDANT'S NEW MATTER

AND COUNTERCLAIM

09-FEB-2004

10:26 AM

NOTICE OF

COURTROOM CHANGE

09-FEB-2004

10:26 AM

Docket

Entry: none.

09-FEB-2004

04:28 PM

MOTION FOR

SUMMARY JUDGMENT

NEVYAS MD,

HERBERT J

11-FEB-2004

12:00 AM

Docket

Entry: 93-04020393 RESPONSE DATE: 3-10-04.

11-FEB-2004

01:00 AM

NOTICE GIVEN 11-FEB-2004

01:00 AM

Docket none.

Entry:

13-FEB-2004

11:31 AM

ORDER ENTERED/236

NOTICE GIVEN

SYLVESTER,

ESTHER R

13-FEB-2004

11:32 AM

Docket

Entry:

81-03112181 AND NOW, THIS 2ND DAY OF FEBRUARY, 2004, IT IS

HEREBY ORDERED AND DECREED THAT DEFENDANT'S CROSS

MOTION FOR SANCTIONS IS DENIED AND PLAINTIFFS' MOTION

FOR RECONSIDERATION IS DENIED. ...BY THE COURT: ESTHER

SYLVESTER, J. 2-2-04

24-FEB-2004

09:54 AM

STATUS HEARING

DISPOSED

ACKERMAN,

NORMAN

24-FEB-2004

09:55 AM

Docket

Entry:

It is hereby ORDERED and DECREED as follows: 1. Development of Joint

Statement of Uncontested and Contested Facts. (a) Plaintiff's Proposed

Findings of Fact, Conclusions of Law and Legal Issues for Trial. By 8/25/04,

plaintiff shall provide the Court with a narrative statement listing all facts

proposed to be proved by him or her at trial in support of his or her claim(s) as

to liability and damages. Additionally, plaintiff shall provide the Court with

all relevant conclusions of law based upon his or her proposed findings of fact

and any and all legal issues presented thereto. (b) Defendant's Response and

Proposed Facts. By 9/25/04, defendant shall provide the Court a statement: (1)

indicating the extent to which defendant contests and does not contest the

plaintiff's proposed facts: (2) listing all additional facts proposed to be proved

by defendant at trial in opposition to, or in special defense of, the plaintiff's

claim(s) as to liability and damages; (3) listing all facts proposed to be proved

by defendant at trial in support of any counterclaim(s), and/or third-party

claim(s) if such claims exist; (4) listing any and all conclusions of law which

arise from all contested and uncontested facts as proposed by the plaintiff;

and, (5) listing for the Court all legal issues presented based upon proposed

facts and conclusions of law. (c) Statement of Uncontested Facts. By 8/25/04,

the same date as that listed in paragraph 1 (a) of this order, the parties shall

submit a joint statement of uncontested facts. This statement is separate and

distinct from any other submitted. As such, agreement or disagreement, which

terms are defined below, with any proposed fact by a defendant does not

obviate the requirements of this paragraph. 2. Identification of Witnesses and

Exhibits. (a) Plaintiff's Witnesses. By 8/25/04, plaintiff shall provide the Court

with a list of all possible witnesses, including a brief narrative of each

respective witness's expected testimony. (b) Plaintiff's Exhibits. By 8/25/04,

plaintiff shall provide the Court with a list of all possible exhibits which he or

she may use during the course of trial. (c) Defendant's Witnesses. By 9/25/04,

defendant shall provide the Court with a list of all possible witnesses,

including a brief narrative of each respective witness's expected testimony. (d)

Defendant's Exhibits. By 9/25/04, defendant shall provide the Court with a list

of all possible exhibits which he or she may use during the course of the trial.

3. Definitions. (a) Narration of Proposed Facts. In stating facts proposed to be

proved, counsel shall do so in simple, declarative, self contained,

consecutively numbered sentences. In a case with multiple parties, if a fact is

to offered against fewer than all parties, counsel shall indicate the parties

against which the fact will (or will not) be offered. (The facts to be set forth

include not only ultimate facts, but also all subsidiary and supporting facts

except those offered solely for impeachment purposes.) (b) Agreement and

Disagreement. Defense counsel shall indicate that he or she does not contest a

proposed fact if at trial they will not controvert or dispute that fact. In

indicating disagreement with a proposed fact, defense counsel shall so set

forth those disagreement(s) as explained above. (c) Objections. Objections to

the admissability of a proposed fact (either as irrelevant or on other grounds)

may not be used to avoid indicating whether or not the party contests the truth

of that fact. (Counsel shall, however, indicate any objections, both to the facts

which they contest and those which they do not contest.) (d) Individual

Positions. To the extent feasible, counsel with similar interests are expected to

coordinate their efforts and express a joint position with respect to the facts

they propose to prove and to the facts other parties propose to prove. Subject

to the time limits above, each party may, however, list additional proposed

facts to cover positions unique to it. 4. Annotations. For each proposed fact,

the parties shall, at the time of proposing to prove the fact, list the witnesses

(including expert witnesses), documents, and (with line-by-line references)

any depositions and answers to interrogatories or requests for admissions that

they will offer to prove that fact. In his or her response, defense counsel shall,

if he or she objects to any such proposed fact or proposed proof, state

precisely the grounds of their objections and, if they will contest the accuracy

of the proposed fact, similarily list the witnesses, documents, depositions,

interrogatories, or admissions that they will offer to controvert that fact.

Except for good cause shown, a party will be precluded at trial from offering

any evidence on any fact not so disclosed and from making any objection not

so disclosed. 5. Effect. (a) Preclusion of other facts. Except for good cause

shown, parties shall be precluded at trial from offering proof of any fact not

disclosed in their listing of proposed facts (except purely for impeachment

purposes). 6. Sanctions. Unjustified refusal to admit a proposed fact or to limit

the extent of disagreement with a proposed fact shall be subject to sanctions.

Excessive listing of proposed facts (or of the evidence to be submitted in

support of or denial of such facts) which imposes obvious burdens on

opposing parties shall also be subject to sanctions. BY THE COURT: Norman

Ackerman, Coordinating Judge

24-FEB-2004 LISTED FOR 24-FEB-2004

09:55 AM SETTLEMENT CONF 09:55 AM

Docket

Entry: none.

24-FEB-2004

09:56 AM

LISTED FOR TRIAL 24-FEB-2004

09:56 AM

Docket

Entry: none.

27-FEB-2004

09:28 AM

ANSWER

(MOTION/PETITION)

FILED

03-MAR-2004

12:00 AM

Docket

Entry:

10-0312510 ANS FILED TO MOITON TO STRIKE (FILED BY HERBERT

J. NEVYAS, M.D. AND DR. ANITA NEVYAS-WALLACE)

01-MAR-2004

12:51 PM

ANSWER

(MOTION/PETITION)

FILED

MORGAN,

DOMINIC

02-MAR-2004

12:00 AM

Docket

Entry: 10-04012510 ANS TO MOTION TO STRIKE FILED.

02-MAR-2004

12:29 PM

MOTION ASSIGNED 02-MAR-2004

12:29 PM

Docket

Entry:

10-04012510 MOTION TO STRIKE ASSIGNED TO JUDGE

CARRAFIELLO ON 3-3-04

03-MAR-2004

09:50 AM

MEMORANDUM FILED NEVYAS MD,

HERBERT J

04-MAR-2004

12:00 AM

Docket

Entry:

10-04012510 SUPPLEMENTAL MEMO IN SUPPORT TO PETITION TO

STRIKE OFF DISCONTINUANCE FILED.

08-MAR-2004

05:17 PM

ANSWER

(MOTION/PETITION)

FILED

MORGAN,

DOMINIC

09-MAR-2004

12:00 AM

Docket

Entry: 93-04020393 ANS TO SUM JUDGMENT FILED.

11-MAR-2004

11:40 AM

REPLY FILED LAPAT,

ANDREW

12-MAR-2004

12:00 AM

Docket

Entry: 93-04020393 REPLY MEMO IN SUPPORT OF MOTION FOR SJ FILED.

15-MAR-2004

09:19 AM

REPLY FILED MORGAN,

DOMINIC

17-MAR-2004

12:00 AM

Docket

Entry: 93-04020393 SUR-REPLY TO PLTF'S MOTION FOR SJ FILED.

15-MAR-2004

02:19 PM

REPLY FILED MORGAN,

DOMINIC

16-MAR-2004

12:00 AM

Docket

Entry: 93-04020393 SUR-REPLY TO PLTF'S SJ FILED.

15-MAR-2004

02:51 PM


02:51 PM

Docket

Entry:

93-04020393 MOTION FOR SUMMARY JUDGMENT ASSIGNED TO

JUDGE CARRAFIELLO ON 3-16-04

24-MAR-2004

10:51 AM

MOTION TO REINSTATE 25-MAR-2004

12:00 AM

Docket

Entry:

55-04032355 RESPONSE DATE 4-13-04. FILED BY PLAINTIFFS,

NEVYAS ETAL/PLAINTIFFS.

31-MAR-2004

11:35 AM

ORDER ENTERED/236

NOTICE GIVEN

CARRAFIELLO,

MATTHEW D

31-MAR-2004

11:37 AM

Docket

Entry:

10-04012510 IT IS ORDRED THAT THE DEFENDANT'S PETITION TO

STRIKE OFF PLAINTIFF'S DISCONITUANCE, AND PLAINTIFF'S

RESPONSE THERETO, IT IS HEREBY ORDERED AND DECREED

THAT SAID MOTION IS DENIED. ....BY THE COURT: CARRAFIELLO,

J. 3-30-04.

01-APR-2004

01:51 PM

ORDER ENTERED/236

NOTICE GIVEN

CARRAFIELLO,

MATTHEW D

01-APR-2004

01:52 PM

Docket

Entry:

93-04020393 IT IS ORDERED THAT PLAINTIFF'S MOTION FOR

SUMMARY JUDGMENT, AND DEFENDANT'S RESPONSE THERETO,

IT IS HEREBY ORDERED AND DECREED THAT SAID MOTION IS

DENIED. ....BY THE COURT: CARRAFIELLO, J. 3-31-04.

12-APR-2004

12:34 PM

ANSWER

(MOTION/PETITION)

FILED

MORGAN,

DOMINIC

12-APR-2004

12:00 AM

Docket

Entry: 55-04032355 ANS FILED TO MOTION TO REINSTATE

15-APR-2004

12:55 PM

MOTION ASSIGNED 15-APR-2004

12:55 PM

Docket

Entry:

55-04032355 MOTION TO REINSTATE ASSIGNED TO JUDGE

CARRAFIELLO ON 4-16-04

19-MAY-2004

10:35 AM

ORDER ENTERED/236

NOTICE GIVEN

CARRAFIELLO,

MATTHEW D

19-MAY-2004

10:38 AM

Docket

Entry:

55-04032355 AND NOW, THIS 17TH DAY OF MAY, 2004, UPON

CONSIDERATION OF PLAINTIFFS DR. HERBERT NEVYAS AND DR.

ANITA NEVYAS-WALLACE'S MOTION TO REINSTATE CLAIM AND

AMEND COMPLAINT, AND DEFENDANT'S RESPONSE THERETO, IT

IS HEREBY ORDERED AND DECREED THAT SAID MOTION IS

GRANTED IN PART AND DENIED IN PART AS FOLLOWS: 1. THE

REQUEST FOR LEAVE TO REINSTATE IS GRANTED. PLAINTIFFS

MUST FORMALLY REINSTATE THEIR COMPLAINT. 2. THE

REQUEST FOR LEAVE TO AMEND IS DENIED. PLAINTIFFS ARE

GRANTED LEAVE TO REQUEST RELIEF UNDER PA.R.C.P. 2232. ...BY

THE COURT: CARRAFIELLO, J. 5-17-04

20-MAY-2004

02:04 PM

REINSTATE/REISSUE

CIVIL ACTION

21-MAY-2004

12:00 AM

Docket

Entry:

COMPLAINT WITH NOTICE TO DEFEND WITHIN TWENTY (20)

DAYS AFTER SERVICE IN ACCORDANCE WITH RULE 1018.1

REINSTATED.

07-JUN-2004

03:54 PM

MOTION TO JOIN

ADDTIONAL DFT

08-JUN-2004

12:00 AM

Docket

Entry:

87-04060587 RESPONSE DATE 6-28-04. (FILED BY PLFS, HERBERT J.

NEVYAS, M.D., ANITA NEVYAS-WALLACE, M.D. AND NEVYAS EYE

ASSOCIATES, P.C.)

28-JUN-2004

03:07 PM

ANSWER

(MOTION/PETITION)

FILED

MORGAN,

DOMINIC

28-JUN-2004

12:00 AM

Docket

Entry:

87-04060587 ANS TO MOTION TO JOIN ADDITIONAL DEFENDANT

FILED.

30-JUN-2004

03:41 PM

MOTION ASSIGNED 30-JUN-2004

03:41 PM

Docket

Entry:

87-04060587 MOTION TO JOIN ADDITIONAL DEFENDANTS

ASSIGNED TO JUDGE CARRAFIELLO ON 7-1-04

09-JUL-2004

10:47 AM

MOTION-JUDGMENT

ON PLEADINGS

MORGAN,

DOMINIC

12-JUL-2004

12:00 AM

Docket


09-JUL-2004

02:07 PM

SHERIFF'S SERVICE 09-JUL-2004

12:00 AM

Docket

Entry:

DEPUTIZED SERVICE OF COMPLAINT UPON DOMINIC MORGAN BY

SHERIFF OF DELAWARE COUNTY ON 15-JUN-04.

09-JUL-2004

04:42 PM

ORDER ENTERED/236

NOTICE GIVEN

CARRAFIELLO,

MATTHEW D

09-JUL-2004

04:44 PM

Docket 87-04060587 AND NOW, THIS 7TH DAY OF JULY, 2004, UPON

Entry: CONSIDERATION OF PLAINTIFFS' MOTION FOR RELIEF UNDER

RULE 2232(C) TO JOIN ADDITIONAL DEFENDANT, STEVEN

FRIEDMAN, AND DEFENDANT'S RESPONSE THERETO, IT IS

HEREBY ORDERED AND DECREED THAT SAID MOTION IS

GRANTED. PLAINTIFFS MAY FILE THEIR AMENDED COMPLAINT

(ATTACHED TO THE MOTION AS EXHIBIT 3) WITHIN TWENTY (20)

DAYS OF THIS ORDER. BY THE COURT: CARRAFIELLO, J. 7/9/04.

13-JUL-2004

03:01 PM

AMENDED COMPLAINT

FILED

LAPAT,

ANDREW

14-JUL-2004

12:00 AM

Docket

Entry:


TWENTY(20) DAYS AFTER SERVICE IN ACCORDANCE WITH RULE

1018.1 FILED.

16-JUL-2004

10:30 AM

PET FOR

EXTRAORDINARY

RELIEF

20-JUL-2004

12:00 AM

Docket

Entry:

46-04073946 RESPONSE DATE 7-26-04. FILED BY PLAINTIFFS,

HERBERT NEVYAS, MD, ANITA NEVYAS, MD AND NEVYAS EYE

ASSOCIATES, PC.

27-JUL-2004

10:35 AM

MOTION TO

WITHDRAW

APPEARANCE

FRIEDMAN,

STEVEN A

05-AUG-2004

12:00 AM

Docket

Entry: 39-04074939 EMERGENCY MOTION TO WITHDRAW AND FOR STAY.

28-JUL-2004

09:41 AM

ANSWER

(MOTION/PETITION)

FILED

29-JUL-2004

12:00 AM

Docket

Entry:

47-04073347 ANS TO MOTION FOR JUDGMENT ON THE PLEADINGS

FILED. (FILED BY PLFS, HERBERT J. NEVYAS, M.D. AND ANITA

NEVYAS-WALLACE, M.D.)

28-JUL-2004

12:26 PM

MOTION ASSIGNED 28-JUL-2004

12:26 PM

Docket

Entry:

46-04073946 PETITION FOR EXTRAORDINARY RELIEF ASSIGNED

TO JUDGE ACKERMAN ON 7-29-04.

02-AUG-2004

09:05 AM

MOTION ASSIGNED 02-AUG-2004

09:05 AM

Docket

Entry:

47-04073347 MOTION FOR JUDGMENT ON PLEADINGS ASSIGNED

TO JUDGE CARRAFIELLO ON 8-3-04.

04-AUG-2004

09:22 AM

ANSWER

(MOTION/PETITION)

FILED

MORGAN,

DOMINIC

05-AUG-2004

12:00 AM

Docket

Entry:

46-04073946 ANS FILED TO PETITION FOR EXTRAORDINARY

RELIEF

05-AUG-2004

10:36 AM


10:36 AM

Docket

Entry:

39-04074939 MOTION TO WITHDRAW APPEARANCE ASSIGNED TO

JUDGE ACKERMAN ON 8-6-04.

06-AUG-2004

09:21 AM

ORDER ENTERED/236

NOTICE GIVEN

ACKERMAN,

NORMAN

06-AUG-2004

12:00 AM

Docket

Entry:

AND NOW, THIS 6TH DAY OF AUGUST, 2004, IT IS HEREBY

ORDERED THAT A RULE RETURNABLE IS SCHEDULED ON

AUGUST 18, 2004, AT 10:00 A.M. IN COURTROOM 696 CITY HALL,

PHILADELPHIA, PA TO SHOW CAUSE WHY STEVEN FRIEDMAN,

ESQUIRE, SHOULD NOT WITHDRAW AS COUNCEL OF RECORD OF

THE DEFENDANT IN THE ABOVE-CAPTIONED MATTER. IT IS

FURTHER ORDERD THAT STEVEN FRIEDMAN, ESQUIRE, SHALL

NOTIFY THE DEFENDANT BY CERTIFIED AND REGULAR MAIL OF

SAID HEARING ADVISING THAT THEY MUST APPEAR AND

FAILURE TO DO SO WILL RESULT IN THE IMPOSITION OF

APPROPRIATE SANCTIONS AND/OR DISMISSAL OF THIS CASE.

FURTHER, ALL COUNSEL INVOLVED IN THIS INSTANT MATTER

MUST ALSO APPEAR AND STEVEN FRIEDMAN, ESQUIRE, IS

HEREBY DIRECTED TO SERVE APPROPRIATE NOTICE ON SAID

COUNSEL. BY THE COURT: ACKERMAN, J. 8-6-04.

19-AUG-2004

02:42 PM

ORDER ENTERED/236

NOTICE GIVEN

BERNSTEIN,

MARK I

19-AUG-2004

02:50 PM

Docket

Entry:

39-04074939 IT IS ORDERED THAT STEVEN FRIEDMAN ESQ IS

PERMITTED TO WITHDRAW AS COUNSEL FOR DEFT, DOMINIC

MORGAN. ALL PROCEEDINGS ARE STAYED FOR 60 DAYS IN

ORDER TO ALLOW SAID DEFT TO OBTAIN NEW COUNSEL. BY THE

COURT ...BERNSTEIN,J 8/18/04

19-AUG-2004

02:50 PM

ORDER ENTERED/236

NOTICE GIVEN

BERNSTEIN,

MARK I

19-AUG-2004

02:52 PM

Docket

Entry:

46-04073946 IT IS ORDERED THAT PLTFS' MOTION FOR

EXTRAORDINARY RELIEF IS GRANTED. THE NEW SCHEDULED

DATES FOR THIS MATTER ARE: PLTFS' PROPOSED FINDINGS,

WITNESS AND EXHIBIT LISTS - 12/18/04; DEFTS' PROPOSED

FINDINGS, WITNESS AND EXHIBIT LISTS - 1/18/05; SETTLEMENT

CONFERENCE - 2/8/05 AT 10:30 IN ROOM 622; AND TRIAL - 2/22/05

AT 9:30 AM IN COURTROOM 696, CITY HALL. BY THE COURT

...BERNSTEIN,J 8/18/04

19-AUG-2004

02:52 PM

CASE RESCHEDULED

BY COURT

19-AUG-2004

02:52 PM

Docket

Entry: none.

19-AUG-2004

02:52 PM

CASE RESCHEDULED

BY COURT

19-AUG-2004

02:52 PM

Docket

Entry: none.

19-AUG-2004

02:53 PM

LISTED FOR

SETTLEMENT CONF

19-AUG-2004

02:53 PM

Docket

Entry: none.

19-AUG-2004

02:53 PM

LISTED FOR TRIAL 19-AUG-2004

02:53 PM

Docket

Entry: none.

26-AUG-2004

10:34 AM

ORDER ENTERED/236

NOTICE GIVEN

CARRAFIELLO,

MATTHEW D

26-AUG-2004

10:35 AM

Docket

Entry:

47-03073347 UPON CONSIDERATION OF THE DEFENDANT'S

MOTION FOR JUDGMENT ON THE PLEADINGS AND ANY


THAT THE MOTION IS DENIED. ...BY THE COURT, JUDGE

CARRAFIELLO, 8-24-04.

21-SEP-2004

11:07 AM

MOTION TO STAY

PROCEEDINGS

MORGAN,

DOMINIC

22-SEP-2004

12:00 AM

Docket

Entry: 72-04092272 MOTION TO STAY PROCEEDINGS FILED.

22-SEP-2004

11:12 AM

MOTION ASSIGNED 22-SEP-2004

11:12 AM

Docket

Entry:

72-04092272 MOTION TO STAY PROCEEDINGS ASSIGNED TO JUDGE

CARRAFIELLO ON 9/23/04.

23-SEP-2004

09:09 AM

MOTION ASSIGNMENT

UPDATED

23-SEP-2004

12:00 AM

Docket

Entry:

72-04092272 MOTION TO STAY PROCEEDINGS ASSIGNED TO JUDGE

BERNSTEIN ON 9-24-04

27-SEP-2004

04:47 PM

MOTION ASSIGNMENT

UPDATED

27-SEP-2004

12:00 AM

Docket

Entry:

72-04092272 MOTION TO EXTEND STAY OF PROCEEDINGS

REASSIGNED TO JUDGE ACKERMAN ON 9/28/04 PER JUDGE

BERNSTEIN.

28-SEP-2004

02:52 PM

ORDER ENTERED/236

NOTICE GIVEN

CARRAFIELLO,

MATTHEW D

28-SEP-2004

12:00 AM

Docket

Entry:

47-04073347 AND NOW, TO WIT, THIS 24TH DAY OF SEPTEMBER,

2004, UPON FURTHER CONSIDERATION, THE AUGUST 24, 2004

ORDER DEALING WITH DEFENDANT DOMINIC MORGAN'S

MOTION FOR PARTIAL JUDGMENT ON THE PLEADINGS IS

RESCINDED AND VACATED. DEFENDANT FILED HIS MOTION JULY

9, 2004, AND THE MOTION CONCERNED PLAINTIFFS' ORIGINAL

COMPLAINT. DEFENDANT'S MOTION BECAME INOPERATIVE

WHEN PLAINTIFFS CHANGED THEIR COMPLAINT BY

AMENDMENT FILED JULY 13, 2004. FURTHER, ON AUGUST 18, 2004,

THIS COURT ORDERED A SIXTY (60) DAY STAY OF ALL

PROCEEDINGS. ...BY THE COURT: CARRAFIELLO, J. 9-24-04

04-OCT-2004

11:22 AM

ANSWER

(MOTION/PETITION)

FILED

05-OCT-2004

12:00 AM

Docket

Entry:

72-04092272 ANS FILED TO MOTION TO STAY (FILED BY PLFS,

HERBERT NEVYAS AND ANITA WALLACE)

04-OCT-2004

11:42 AM

RULE TO SHOW CAUSE

ENTERED

ACKERMAN,

NORMAN

04-OCT-2004

11:44 AM

Docket

Entry:

72-04092272 IT IS HEREBY ORDERED THAT A RULE RETURNABLE

IS ENTERED IN THE ABOVE MATTER TO SHOW CAUSE WHY THE

MOTION TO STAY PROCEEDINGS FILED IN THE ABOVE MATTER

SHOULD NOT BE GRANTED. RULE RETURNABLE THE 15TH DAY

OF OCTOBER, 2004, AT 10:00 A.M. IN COURTROOM 696, CITY HALL,

PHILADELPHIA, PA. ALL COUNSEL ARE DIRECTED TO APPEAR.

FAILURE TO APPEAR MAY RESULT IN THE IMPOSITION OF

SANCTIONS INCLUDING DISMISSAL OR PRECLUSION. BY THE

COURT...ACKERMAN, J. 10/4/04

04-OCT-2004

12:02 PM

CORRECTIVE ENTRY 04-OCT-2004

12:00 AM

Docket

Entry:

ORDER DATED 10/4/04 SHOULD READ "RULE RETURNABLE THE

13TH DAY OF OCTOBER, 2004 AT 10:00 A.M. IN COURTROOM 696,

CITY HALL, PHILADELPHIA, PA.

13-OCT-2004

11:09 AM

SUPPLEMENTAL

PLEADING FILED

MORGAN,

DOMINIC

14-OCT-2004

12:00 AM

Docket

Entry: 72-04092272 SUPPLEMENTAL FILED TO MOTION TO STAY

21-OCT-2004

10:10 AM

ORDER ENTERED/236

NOTICE GIVEN

ACKERMAN,

NORMAN

21-OCT-2004

12:00 AM

Docket

Entry:

72-04092272 IT IS ORDERED THAT MOTION OF STEVEN FRIEDMAN

ESQ, COUNSEL FOR DEFT, FOR LEAVE TO WITHDRAW IS

GRANTED AND ALL PROCEEDINGS ARE STAYED FOR 30 DAYS TO

ALLOW DEFT, DOMINIC MORGAN TO OBTAIN NEW COUNSEL. ALL

DEADLINES ARE EXTENDED 30 DAYS IN ACCORDANCE WITH THE

ATTACHED PRE-TRIAL ORDER. BY THE COURT ...ACKERMAN,J

10/13/04

21-OCT-2004

10:12 AM

CASE RESCHEDULED

BY COURT

21-OCT-2004

10:12 AM

Docket

Entry: none.

21-OCT-2004

10:12 AM

CASE RESCHEDULED

BY COURT

21-OCT-2004

10:12 AM

Docket

Entry: none.

21-OCT-2004

10:12 AM

LISTED FOR

SETTLEMENT CONF

21-OCT-2004

10:12 AM

Docket

Entry: none.

21-OCT-2004

10:13 AM

LISTED FOR TRIAL 21-OCT-2004

10:13 AM

Docket

Entry: none.

21-OCT-2004

10:13 AM

ORDER ENTERED/236

NOTICE GIVEN

ACKERMAN,

NORMAN

21-OCT-2004

12:00 AM

Docket

Entry:







































































Ackerman, Coordinating Judge 10/13/04

29-NOV-2004

03:54 PM

ENTRY OF

APPEARANCE FILED

ALBERT,

JEFFREY B

30-NOV-2004

12:00 AM

Docket

Entry:

ENTRY OF APPEARANCE OF JEFFREY B. ALBERT ESQ. FILED ON

BEHALF OF DFT STEVEN A. FRIEDMAN.

29-NOV-2004

03:54 PM

PRELIMINARY

OBJECTIONS

ALBERT,

JEFFREY B

30-NOV-2004

12:00 AM

Docket

Entry:

PRELIMINARY OBJECTIONS TO PLAINTIFFS AMENDED

COMPLAINT FILED BY DEFENDANT STEVEN FRIEDMAN.

30-NOV-2004

04:29 PM

AFFIDAVIT OF SERVICE

FILED

01-DEC-2004

12:00 AM

Docket SERVICE OF THE AMENDED COMPLAINT UPON DEFENDANT,

Entry: DOMINIC MORGAN BY CERTIFIED MAIL ON 7-16-04.

30-NOV-2004

04:29 PM

JUDGMENT ENTERED

BY DEFAULT

LAPAT,

ANDREW

01-DEC-2004

12:00 AM

Docket

Entry:

PRAECIPE FOR ENTRY OF DEFAULT JUDGMENT FILED. JUDGMENT

FOR PLAINTIFF(S) AGAINST DEFENDANT, DOMINIC MORGAN,

ONLY, FOR FAILURE TO FILE ANSWER TO THE AMENDED

COMPLAINT WITHIN REQUIRED TIME. PRO-PROTHONOTARY

NOTICE UNDER RULE 236. NOTICE UNDER 237.5. AFFIDAVIT OF

NON-MILITARY SERVICE FILED .

06-DEC-2004

04:59 PM

PRELIMINARY

OBJECTIONS

MORGAN,

DOMINIC

07-DEC-2004

12:00 AM

Docket

Entry:


COMPLAINT FILED BY DEFENDANT DOMINIC MORGAN. PLEASE

NOTE THE ABOVE PRELIMINARY OBJECTIONS WERE FILED ON

11/29/04 BUT WERE NOT DOCKETED...RFW

07-DEC-2004

09:42 AM

CORRECTIVE ENTRY 07-DEC-2004

12:00 AM

Docket

Entry:

PROTHONOTARY CORRECTIVE ENTRY: PLEASE NOTE THAT THE

DEFAULT JUDGMENT ENTERED ON 11/30/04 AS TO DEFENDANT

DOMINIC MORGAN WAS ENTERED IN ERROR, DEFENDANT'S

PRELIMINARY OBJECTIONS TO THE AMENDED COMPLAINT WERE

FILED ON 11/29/04 BUT WERE NOT DOCKETED...RFW

28-DEC-2004

02:59 PM

MOTION TO

DETERMINE P O FILED

MORGAN,

DOMINIC

28-DEC-2004

12:00 AM

Docket

Entry: 16-04121916 RESPONSE DATE 1/18/05.

29-DEC-2004

09:54 AM

MOTION TO

DETERMINE P O FILED

FRIEDMAN,

STEVEN A

03-JAN-2005

12:00 AM

Docket


10-JAN-2005

11:21 AM

MOT-PROCEED IN

FORMA PAUPERIS

MORGAN,

DOMINIC

11-JAN-2005

12:00 AM

Docket


10-JAN-2005

11:44 AM

REINSTATE/REISSUE

CIVIL ACTION

11-JAN-2005

12:00 AM

Docket

Entry:


TWENTY (20) DAYS AFTER SERVICE IN ACCORDANCE WITH RULE

1018.1 REINSTATED.

18-JAN-2005

10:37 AM

ANSWER

(MOTION/PETITION)

FILED

NEVYAS MD,

HERBERT J

19-JAN-2005

12:00 AM

Docket

Entry: 16-04121916 ANS FILED TO PO'S

18-JAN-2005

10:37 AM

ANSWER

(MOTION/PETITION)

FILED

NEVYAS MD,

HERBERT J

19-JAN-2005

12:00 AM

Docket

Entry: 28-04122028 ANS FILED TO PO'S

18-JAN-2005

03:47 PM

MOTION TO

DETERMINE P O FILED

FRIEDMAN,

STEVEN A

21-JAN-2005

12:00 AM

Docket

Entry: 50-05011350 RESPONSE DATE: 02/07/05

18-JAN-2005

03:57 PM

PRELIMINARY

OBJECTIONS

ALBERT,

JEFFREY B

19-JAN-2005

12:00 AM

Docket

Entry:


COMPLAINT FILED BY DEFENDANT STEVEN FRIEDMAN.

19-JAN-2005

09:36 AM

ORDER ENTERED/236

NOTICE GIVEN

RIZZO,

ANNETTE M

19-JAN-2005

12:00 AM

Docket

Entry:

AND NOW, THIS 14TH DAY OF JANUARY, 2005, IT IS HEREBY

ORDERED AND DECREED THAT EDWARD L. EDELSTEIN, ESQ., IS

HEREBY APPOINTED AS DISCOVERY MASTER IN THE ABOVE-

CAPTIONED MATTER. THE FEES AND COSTS INCURRED AS A

RESULT OF HIS SERVICES SHALL BE PAID IN EQUAL PART BY ALL

PARTIES. THE DISCOVERY MASTER WILL CONTACT COUNSEL TO

SCHEDULE ALL NECESSARY CONFERENCES.....BY THE COURT

RIZZO,J. 1-14-05

20-JAN-2005

02:41 PM

MOTION ASSIGNED 20-JAN-2005

02:41 PM

Docket

Entry:

16-04121916 MOTION TO DETERMINE PRELIMINARY OBJECTIONS

ASSIGNED TO JUDGE CARRAFIELLO ON 1-21-05.

20-JAN-2005

02:41 PM


02:41 PM

Docket

Entry:



21-JAN-2005

09:51 AM


STEVEN A

24-JAN-2005

12:00 AM

Docket

Entry: 28-04122028 REPLY MEMO IN SUPPORT OF PO'S FILED.

21-JAN-2005

12:08 PM

MOT-FOR

EXTRAORDINARY

RELIEF

NEVYAS MD,

HERBERT J

24-JAN-2005

12:00 AM

Docket

Entry: 97-05011697 RESPONSE DATE: 01/31/05

28-JAN-2005

09:46 AM

ANSWER

(MOTION/PETITION)

FILED

FRIEDMAN,

STEVEN A

31-JAN-2005

12:00 AM

Docket

Entry: 97-05011697 ANS FILED TO MOTION FOR EXTRAORDIANRY RELIEF

31-JAN-2005

09:18 AM

ANSWER

(MOTION/PETITION)

FILED

MORGAN,

DOMINIC

01-FEB-2005

12:00 AM

Docket

Entry: 97-04011697 ANS FILED TO MOTION FOR EXTRAORDINARY RELIEF

02-FEB-2005

11:39 AM

MOTION ASSIGNED 02-FEB-2005

11:39 AM

Docket

Entry:

97-05011697 MOTION FOR EXTRAORDINARY RELIEF ASSIGNED TO

JUDGE ACKERMAN ON 2-3-05.

02-FEB-2005

12:06 PM


12:06 PM

Docket

Entry:

63-05010663 MOTION TO PROCEED IN FORMA PAUPERIS ASSIGNED

TO JUDGE MANFREDI ON 2-3-05.

03-FEB-2005

11:29 AM

ORDER ENTERED/236

NOTICE GIVEN

CARRAFIELLO,

MATTHEW D

03-FEB-2005

11:32 AM

Docket

Entry:

16-04121916 AND NOW, THIS 2ND DAY OF FEBRUARY, 2005, UPON

CONSIDERATION OF DEFENDANT MORGAN'S MOTION TO

DETERMINE PRELIMINARY OBJECTIONS AND PLAINTIFF'S


THAT SAID PRELIMINARY OBJECTIONS ARE OVERRULED.

DEFENDANT FRIEDMAN IS GRANTED TWENTY (20) DAYS FROM

THE DATE OF DOCKETING OF THIS ORDER TO FILE AN ANSWER

TO PLAINTIFF'S COMPLAINT. ...BY THE COURT: CARRAFIELLO, J.

2-2-05

04-FEB-2005

02:39 PM

ORDER ENTERED/236

NOTICE GIVEN

ACKERMAN,

NORMAN

04-FEB-2005

02:42 PM

Docket

Entry:

97-05011697 IT IS ORDERED THAT ALL DEADLINES IN THIS

MATTER ARE EXTENDED FOR AN ADDITIONAL 120 DAYS. THERE

WILL BE NO FURTHER CONTINUANCES. CASE MANAGEMENT

ORDER IS ATTACHED HERETO. BY THE COURT ...ACKERMAN,J

2/4/05

04-FEB-2005

02:43 PM

ORDER ENTERED/236

NOTICE GIVEN

ACKERMAN,

NORMAN

04-FEB-2005

12:00 AM

Docket

Entry:







































































Ackerman, Coordinating Judge 2/4/05

04-FEB-2005

02:44 PM

CASE RESCHEDULED

BY COURT

04-FEB-2005

02:44 PM

Docket

Entry: none.

04-FEB-2005

02:45 PM

CASE RESCHEDULED

BY COURT

04-FEB-2005

02:45 PM

Docket

Entry: none.

04-FEB-2005

02:45 PM

LISTED FOR

SETTLEMENT CONF

04-FEB-2005

02:45 PM

Docket

Entry: none.

04-FEB-2005

02:45 PM

LISTED FOR TRIAL 04-FEB-2005

02:45 PM

Docket

Entry: none.

09-FEB-2005

11:43 AM

ORDER ENTERED/236

NOTICE GIVEN

CARRAFIELLO,

MATTHEW D

09-FEB-2005

11:54 AM

Docket

Entry:

28-04122028 AND NOW, THIS 2ND DAY OF FEBRUARY, 2005, UPON

CONSIDERATION OF DEFENDANT FRIEDMAN'S MOTION TO

DETERMINE PRELIMINARY OBJECTIONS AND PLAINTIFF'S


THAT SAID PRELIMINARY OBJECTIONS ARE OVERRULED IN PART

AND MOOT IN PART AS FOLLOWS: 1. DEFENDANT'S PRELIMINARY

OBJECTION FOR IMPROPER SERVICE UNDER PA. R.C.P. 400.1 IS

MOOT. DFEFENDANT FRIEDMAN ADMITS PROPER SERVICE

OCCURRED ON OR ABOUT JANUARY 13, 2005. 2. DEFENDANT'S

REMAINING PRELIMINARY OBJECTIONS ARE OVERRULED.

DEFENDANT FRIEDMAN IS GRANTED TWENTY (20) DAYS FROM

THE DATE OF DOCKETING OF THIS ORDER TO FILE AN ANSWER

TO PLAINTIFF'S COMPLAINT. ...BY THE COURT: CARRAFIELLO, J.

2-2-05

09-FEB-2005

01:00 PM


01:00 PM

Docket

Entry:



11-FEB-2005

11:12 AM


STEVEN A

14-FEB-2005

12:00 AM

Docket

Entry: 50-05011350 REPLY FILED IN SUPPORT OF PO'S

15-FEB-2005

09:50 AM

ANSWER

(MOTION/PETITION)

FILED

16-FEB-2005

12:00 AM

Docket

Entry:

50-05011350 ANS FILED TO PO'S (FILED BY PLFS, DRS. NEVYAS

AND NEVYAS-WALLACE)

16-FEB-2005

10:05 AM

ORDER ENTERED/236

NOTICE GIVEN

MANFREDI,

WILLIAM J

16-FEB-2005

10:06 AM

Docket

Entry:

63-05010663-IT IS HEREBY ORDERED AND DECREED THAT: 1.

PETITIONER BE PERMITTED TO PROCEED WITHOUT PAYING THE

COSTS OF THIS PROCEEDING OR POSTING A BOND. 2. PETITIONER

BE PERMITTED TO OBTAIN SERVICE OF THE PAPERS FILED

WITHOUT COST. 3. PETITIONER BE PERMITTED TO PROCEED IN

FORMA PAUPERIS AS TO ANY ADDITIONAL COSTS WHICH

ACCRUE IN THE COURSE OF THIS PROCEEDING. 4. IF THERE IS A

MONETARY RECOVERY BY JUDGMENT OR SETTLEMENT IN

FAVOR OF THE PARTY PERMITTED TO PROCEED IN FORMA

PAUPERIS, THE EXONERATED FEES AND COSTS SHALL BE TAXED

AS COSTS AND PAID TO THE PROTHONOTARY BY THE PARTY

PAYING THE MONETARY RECOVERY. 5. PETITIONER HAS A

CONTINUING OBLIGATION TO INFORM THE COURT OF ANY

IMPROVEMENT IN PARTY'S FINANCIAL CIRCUMSTANCES THAT

WILL ENABLE THE PARTY TO PAY COSTS. BY THE COURT:

WILLIAM J. MANFREDI, SUPERVISING JUDGE, TRIAL DIVISION -

CIVIL, 02-15-05.

28-FEB-2005

02:21 PM

ANSWER TO

COMPLAINT FILED

FRIEDMAN,

STEVEN A

01-MAR-2005

12:00 AM

Docket

Entry:

ANSWER TO PLAINTIFF'S AMENDED COMPLAINT WITH NEW

MATTER AND COUNTERCLAIM FILED BY DEFENDANT DOMINIC

MORGAN.

22-MAR-2005

10:59 AM

ORDER ENTERED/236

NOTICE GIVEN

CARRAFIELLO,

MATTHEW D

22-MAR-2005

11:02 AM

Docket 50-05011350 AND NOW, THIS 17TH DAY OF MARCH, 2005, UPON

Entry: CONSIDERATION OF DEFENDANT STEVEN FRIEDMAN'S AMENDED

PRELIMINARY OBJECTIONS, FILED ON JANUARY 18, 2005, AND

PLAINTIFFS' RESPONSE THERETO, IT IS HEREBY ORDERED AND

DECREED THAT SAID OBJECTIONS ARE DISMISSED WITH

PREJUDICE AS FILED IN VIOLATION OF PA R.C.P.1033. DEFENDANT

SHALL PLEAD OVER WITHIN TWENTY (20) DAYS. PA R.C.P.1028(d).

DEFENDANT SHALL FILE NO FURTHER PRELIMINARY

OBJECTIONS TO PLAINTIFFS COMPLAINT. BY THE COURT:

CARRAFIELLO, J. 3/17/05

18-APR-2005

03:55 PM

ANSWER TO

COMPLAINT FILED

19-APR-2005

12:00 AM

Docket

Entry:

DEFENDANT, STEVEN FRIEDMAN'S ANSWER TO PLAINTIFFS'

AMENDED CIVIL ACTION COMPLAINT WITH NEW MATTER.

06-MAY-2005

11:32 AM

SHERIFF'S SERVICE 09-MAY-2005

12:00 AM

Docket

Entry:

DEPUTIZED SERVICE OF COMPLAINT UPON STEVEN A. FRIEDMAN

BY SHERIFF OF DELWARE COUNTY ON 01/13/2005.

12-MAY-2005

10:36 AM

PLTF REPLY TO NEW

MATTER FILED

LAPAT,

ANDREW

13-MAY-2005

12:00 AM

Docket

Entry:

PLAINTIFF(S) REPLY TO NEW MATTER OF DEFENDANT(S)STEVEN

FRIEDMAN FILED.

13-MAY-2005

01:58 PM

MOTION TO

WITHDRAW

APPEARANCE

NEVYAS MD,

HERBERT J

13-MAY-2005

12:00 AM

Docket

Entry:

44-05051144 EMERGENCY MOTION TO REQUIRE STEVEN A.

FRIEDMAN, ESQ., TO WITHDRAW AS COUNSEL FOR DOMINIC

MORGAN FILED.

13-MAY-2005

02:00 PM

MOTION ASSIGNED 13-MAY-2005

02:00 PM

Docket

Entry:

44-05051144 EMERGENCY MOTION TO REQUIRE COUNSEL TO

WITHDRAW APPEARANCE ASSIGNED TO JUDGE ACKERMAN ON

5/13/05.

16-MAY-2005

03:48 PM

ORDER ENTERED/236

NOTICE GIVEN

ACKERMAN,

NORMAN

16-MAY-2005

04:05 PM

Docket

Entry:

44-05051144 IT IS ORDERED THAT A RULE RETURNABLE IS

SCHEDULED ON MAY 18, 2005 AT 10:00 AM IN COURTROOM 696

CITY HALL, PHILADELPHIA, PA TO SHOW CAUSE WHY LEON

SILVERMAN, ESQUIRE SHOULD NOT WITHDRAW AS COUSNEL OF

RECORD OF THE PLAINTIFF IN THE ABOVE-CAPTIONED MATTER.

IT IS FURTHER ORDERED THAT LEON SILVERMAN, ESQUIRE

SHALL NOTIFY THE PLAINTIFF BY CERTIFIED AND REGULAR

MAIL OF SAID HEARING ADVISING THAT THEY MUST APPEAR

AND FAILURE TO DO SO WILL RESULT IN THE IMPOSITION OF

APPROPRIATE SANCTIONS AND/OR DISMISSAL OF THIS CASE.

FURTHER, ALL COUNSEL INVOLVED IN THIS INSTANT MATTER

MUST ALSO APPEAR AND LEON SILVERMAN, ESQUIRE IS HEREBY

DIRECTED TO SERVE APPROPRIATE NOTICE ON SAID COUNSEL.

...BY THE COURT; ACKERMAN, J. 5-16-05

17-MAY-2005

12:59 PM

CORRECTIVE ENTRY 17-MAY-2005

12:00 AM

Docket

Entry:

44-05051144 PLEASE DISREGARD THE RULE ENTERED UNDER SAID

CONTROL NUMBER. IT WAS ENTERED IN ERROR.

17-MAY-2005

01:00 PM

ORDER ENTERED/236

NOTICE GIVEN

ACKERMAN,

NORMAN

17-MAY-2005

12:00 AM

Docket

Entry:

44-05051144 IT IS ORDERED THAT THE EMERGENCY PETITION TO

REQUIRE STEVEN A. FRIEDMAN, ESQ TO WITHDRAW AS COUNSEL

FOR DOMINIC MORGAN IS DENIED, WITHOUT PREJUDICE TO FILE

MOTION TO DISQUALIFY COUNSEL. ...BY THE COURT;

ACKERMAN, J. 5-17-05

18-MAY-2005

02:46 PM

MOTION TO

DISQUALIFY COUNSEL

NEVYAS MD,

HERBERT J

18-MAY-2005

12:00 AM

Docket

Entry: 40-05051540 RESPONSE DATE: 6-7-05.

25-MAY-2005

04:37 PM

PROPOSED FINDING OF

FACT FILED

26-MAY-2005

12:00 AM

Docket

Entry:

PLTFS' PROPOSED FINDINGS OF FACT AND CONCLUSIONS OF LAW

FILED

07-JUN-2005

10:41 AM

ANSWER

(MOTION/PETITION)

FILED

MORGAN,

DOMINIC

08-JUN-2005

12:00 AM

Docket

Entry: 40-05051540 ANS FILED TO MOTION TO DISQUALIFY COUNSEL

07-JUN-2005

03:10 PM

MOTION TO COMPEL MORGAN,

DOMINIC

17-JUN-2005

12:00 AM

Docket

Entry:

06-05060206 MOTION TO COMPEL DISCOVERY (DOCUMENT

PRODUCTION) FILED.

20-JUN-2005

10:44 AM

ORDER ENTERED/236

NOTICE GIVEN

RIZZO,

ANNETTE M

20-JUN-2005

12:00 AM

Docket

Entry:

40-05051540 STIPULATION. IT IS HEREBY STIPULATED AND

AGREED BY AND BETWEEN THE UNDERSIGNED COUNSEL FOR

THE PARTIES TO THE ACTION CAPTIONED ABOVE THAT: AS TO

PLAINTIFFS' PETITION TO DISQUALIFY ATTORNEY FRIEDMAN AS

COUNSEL FOR DEFENDANT MORGAN, IT IS AGREED THAT: (a) THE

COURT WILL NOT IMMEDIATELY RULE ON THE PETITION; (b)

ATTORNEY FRIEDMAN WILL BE GRANTED TWENTY (20) DAYS

FROM JUNE 7, 2005 TO FILE AN ADDITIONAL OR NEW RESPONSE

DIRECTED TO HIS DISQUALIFICATION AS IT RELATES TO TRIAL;

(c) ATTORNEY SILVERMAN WILL BE GRANTED TEN (10) DAYS TO

RESPOND TO ATTORNEY FRIEDMAN'S RESPONSE AS REFERRED

TO IN (b) ABOVE; (d) ATTORNEY SILVERMAN'S REQUEST FOR

DISQUALIFICATION OF ATTORNEY FRIEDMAN IS WITHDRAWN AS

IT RELATES TO ALL PRE-TRIAL ACTIVITIES BUT NOT AS IT

RELATES TO TRIAL; AND (e) DEFENDANT MORGAN'S OBJECTIONS

AS TO ATTORNEY-CLIENT PRIVILEGE WITH RESPECT TO

COMMUNICATIONS WITH ATTORNEY FRIEDMAN CONCERNING

THE CREATION, MAINTENANCE AND CONTENT OF THE WEBSITES

ARE WAIVED FOR PURPOSES OF THIS LITIGATION ONLY. (f) ANY

FAILURE TO COMPLY WITH THIS STIPULATION MAY RESULT IN

SANCTIONS. ...BY THE COURT: RIZZO, J. 6-16-05

20-JUN-2005

10:44 AM

MOTION RESPONSE

DATE UPDATED

20-JUN-2005

12:00 AM

Docket

Entry:

40-05051540 MOTION TO DISQUALIFY COUNSEL RESPONSE DATE

UPDATED TO 7-7-05 PER STIPULATION ENTERED ON 6-16-05.

24-JUN-2005

03:11 PM

MOTION FOR

SUMMARY JUDGMENT

FRIEDMAN,

STEVEN A

27-JUN-2005

12:00 AM

Docket

Entry: 68-05061868 RESPONSE DATE 7/25/05

27-JUN-2005

11:41 AM

ANSWER

(MOTION/PETITION)

FILED

MORGAN,

DOMINIC

28-JUN-2005

12:00 AM

Docket

Entry: 40-05051540 ANS FILED TO MOTION TO DISQUALIFY COUNSEL

27-JUN-2005

04:20 PM

ANSWER

(MOTION/PETITION)

FILED

28-JUN-2005

12:00 AM

Docket

Entry:

06-05060206 ANSWER FILED TO MOTION TO COMPEL DISCOVERY

AND PRODUCTION OF DOCUMENTS. ANSWER FILED BY

PLAINTIFFS, HERBERT J. NEVYAS, M.D., AND DR. ANITA NEVYAS-

WALLACE.

30-JUN-2005

09:30 AM

MOTION IN LIMINE 01-JUL-2005

12:00 AM

Docket

Entry:

77-05062277 MOTION IN LIMINE FILED RE: DEFENDANTS FROM

OFFERING EVIDENCE CONCERNING THE CONTENT OF THE

WEBSITE AT ISSUE DUE TO DEFENDANT MORGANS

DESTRUCTION OF EVIDENCE; ASSIGNED TO JUDGE ACKERMAN

FOR 07/05/05.(FILED BY PLAINTIFF, STEIN & SILVERMAN).

30-JUN-2005

11:06 AM

REPLY FILED MORGAN,

DOMINIC

01-JUL-2005

12:00 AM

Docket

Entry: 06-05060206 REPLY IN SUPPORT OF MOTION TO COMPEL FILED.

05-JUL-2005

11:04 AM

MOTION FOR

SANCTIONS

06-JUL-2005

12:00 AM

Docket

Entry:

17-05070117 RESPONSE DATE 7-25-05. (APLF, STEIN & SILVERMAN,

P.C.)

06-JUL-2005

09:35 AM

ORDER ENTERED/236

NOTICE GIVEN

RIZZO,

ANNETTE M

06-JUL-2005

12:00 AM

Docket

Entry:

06-05060206 AND NOW, THIS 30TH DAY OF JUNE, 2005, UPON

CONSIDERATION OF DEFENDANT DOMINIC MORGAN'S MOTION

TO COMPEL DISCOVERY AND PLAINTIFF'S ANSWER THERETO, A

RULE IS HEREBY ISSUED TO SHOW CAUSE WHY THE WITHIN

RELIEF SHOULD NOT BE GRANTED. RULE RETURNABLE THE 11TH

DAY OF JULY, 2005, AT 2:00 P.M. IN COURTROOM 275, CITY HALL.

ALL PARTIES INVOLVED IN THIS MATTER ARE REQUIRED TO

ATTEND. ... BY THE COURT: RIZZO, J. 30-JUN-2005

06-JUL-2005

09:38 AM

LISTED RULE

RETURNABLE DATE

06-JUL-2005

09:38 AM

Docket

Entry: none.

06-JUL-2005

11:12 AM

MOTION FOR

SANCTIONS

07-JUL-2005

12:00 AM

Docket

Entry:

04-05070204 RESPONSE DATE 7/26/05. FILED BY STEIN &

SILVERMAN, P.C., PLAINTIFFS.

13-JUL-2005

11:11 AM

MOTION/PETITION

WITHDRAWN

FRIEDMAN,

STEVEN A

15-JUL-2005

12:00 AM

Docket

Entry: 06-05060206 MOTION TO COMPEL WITHDRAWN PER PRAECIPE

14-JUL-2005 MOTION TO COMPEL MORGAN, 15-JUL-2005

11:06 AM DOMINIC 12:00 AM

Docket


18-JUL-2005

10:04 AM

ANSWER

(MOTION/PETITION)

FILED

MORGAN,

DOMINIC

19-JUL-2005

12:00 AM

Docket

Entry: 68-05061868 ANS FILED TO SJ

18-JUL-2005

10:04 AM

ANSWER

(MOTION/PETITION)

FILED

MORGAN,

DOMINIC

19-JUL-2005

12:00 AM

Docket

Entry: 17-05070117 ANS FILED TO MOTION FOR SANCTIONS

18-JUL-2005

10:04 AM

ANSWER

(MOTION/PETITION)

FILED

MORGAN,

DOMINIC

19-JUL-2005

12:00 AM

Docket

Entry: 77-05062277 ANS FILED TO MOTION IN LIMINE

18-JUL-2005

10:39 AM

ANSWER

(MOTION/PETITION)

FILED

FRIEDMAN,

STEVEN A

19-JUL-2005

12:00 AM

Docket


18-JUL-2005

11:08 AM


11:08 AM

Docket

Entry:

40-05051540 MOTION TO DISQUALIFY COUNSEL ASSIGNED TO

JUDGE CARRAFIELLO ON 7-19-05.

19-JUL-2005 ORDER ENTERED/236 RIZZO, 19-JUL-2005

02:22 PM NOTICE GIVEN ANNETTE M 02:32 PM

Docket

Entry:

06-05060206 AND NOW, THIS 19TH DAY OF JULY, 2005, DUE TO THE

WITHDRAWAL OF THE MOTION TO COMPEL (CONTROL NO.

060206) BY ATTORNEY FRIEDMAN ON BEHALF OF DOMINIC

MORGAN (SEE ATTACHED PRAECIPE), IT IS HEREBY ORDERED

AND DECREED THE PREVIOUSLY SCHEDULED HEARING SET FOR

JULY 14, 2005 WAS HEREBY CANCELLED. IT IS FURTHER ORDERED

AND DECREED THAT: 1. DISCOVERY IN THE ABOVE-CAPTIONED

MATTER IS HEREBY CLOSED; AND 2. EDWARD L. EDELSTEIN,

ESQ., IS RELEASED AS DISCOVERY MASTER IN THE ABOVE-

CAPTIONED MATTER. AS PREVIOUSLY ORDERED, ALL FEES AND

COSTS INCURRED AS A RESULT OF MR. EDELSTEIN'S SERVICES

SHALL BE PAID IN EQUAL PART BY ALL PARTIES. SAID PAYMENT

SHALL BE REMITTED WITHIN FIFTEEN DAYS OF RECEIPT OF MR.

EDELSTEIN'S BILL; AND 3. THE REMAINING MOTION FOR

SANCTIONS (CONTROL NO. 070204) FILED BY THE PLAINTIFF IS TO

BE REFERRED TO THE TRIAL JUDGE AS IT IS NOT A MOTION

REGARDING PRE-TRIAL DISCOVERY; 4. TRIAL DATE OF JULY 25,

2005 IS TO REMAIN. ...BY THE COURT: RIZZO, J. 7-19-05

19-JUL-2005

03:25 PM

CONFERENCE

CANCELLED

19-JUL-2005

03:25 PM

Docket

Entry: none.

20-JUL-2005

11:22 AM

ANSWER

(MOTION/PETITION)

FILED

FRIEDMAN,

STEVEN A

20-JUL-2005

12:00 AM

Docket

Entry: 17-05070117 ANS FILED TO MOTION FOR SANCTIONS

21-JUL-2005

11:24 AM

MISCELLANEOUS

MOTION

FRIEDMAN,

STEVEN A

22-JUL-2005

12:00 AM

Docket

Entry:

78-05071578 RESPONSE DATE 8/10/05. DEFENDANT FRIEDMAN'S

MOTION FOR SEVERANCE AND TO BIFURCATE FILED.

21-JUL-2005

02:52 PM

WITHDRAWAL/ENTRY

OF APPEARANCE

SILVERMAN,

LEON W

22-JUL-2005

12:00 AM

Docket

Entry:

WITHDRAWAL OF APPEARANCE OF ANDREW J LAPAT AND

ENTRY OF APPEARANCE OF LEON W SILVERMAN ON BEHALF OF

PLAINTIFFS HERBERT J. NEVYAS, M.D., NEVYAS EYE ASSOCIATES

P.C. AND ANITA NEVYAS-WALLACE, M.D. FILED.

22-JUL-2005

08:50 AM

ORDER ENTERED/236

NOTICE GIVEN

CARRAFIELLO,

MATTHEW D

22-JUL-2005

08:53 AM

Docket

Entry:

40-05055140 UPON CONSIDERATION OF PLAINTIFF'S MOTION TO

DISQUALIFY STEVEN A. FRIEDMAN, ESQ., AS COUNSEL FOR

DOMINIC MORGAN AND DEFENDANT MORGAN'S RESPONSE

THERETO, IT IS HEREBY ORDERED AND DECREED THAT SAID

MOTION TO DISQUALIFY IS DENIED. ..BY THE COURT, JUDGE

CARRAFIELLO, 7-20-05.

22-JUL-2005

01:54 PM

MOTION IN LIMINE 22-JUL-2005

12:00 AM

Docket

Entry:

32-05071632 MOTION IN LIMINE TO PRECLUDE DEFENDANTS

FORM OFFERING EVIDENCE CONCERNING MATTERS

ESTABLISHED BY THE DOCTRINES OF RES JUDICATA AND/ OR

COLLATERAL ESTOPPEL ASSIGNED TO JUDGE ACKERMAN ON 7-

25-05. MOTION FILED BY PLAINTIFFS HERBERT J. NEVYAS, M.D.,

ANITA NEVYAS-WALLACE, M.D. AND NEVYAS EYE ASSOCIATES,

P.C.

25-JUL-2005

09:17 AM

ANSWER

(MOTION/PETITION)

FILED

FRIEDMAN,

STEVEN A

25-JUL-2005

12:00 AM

Docket


25-JUL-2005

09:34 AM

ANSWER

(MOTION/PETITION)

FILED

26-JUL-2005

12:00 AM

Docket

Entry:

68-05061868 ANS FILED TO SJ (FILED BY PLFS, STEIN & SILVERMAN

P.C.)

27-JUL-2005 MOTION ASSIGNED 27-JUL-2005

01:14 PM 01:14 PM

Docket

Entry:


JUDGE CARRAFIELLO ON 7/28/05.

28-JUL-2005

11:09 AM


11:09 AM

Docket

Entry:

17-05070117 MOTION FOR SANCTIONS ASSIGNED TO JUDGE

ACKERMAN ON 7-29-05.

29-JUL-2005

10:39 AM

MOTION ASSIGNMENT

UPDATED

29-JUL-2005

10:39 AM

Docket

Entry: none.

29-JUL-2005

10:40 AM


10:40 AM

Docket

Entry:

17-05070117 MOTION FOR SANCTIONS REASSIGNED TO JUDGE

MAIER.

29-JUL-2005

03:25 PM


03:25 PM

Docket

Entry:

04-05070204 MOTION FOR SANCTIONS ASSIGNED TO JUDGE MAIER

ON 8-1-05.

02-AUG-2005

10:15 AM

ANSWER

(MOTION/PETITION)

FILED

MORGAN,

DOMINIC

03-AUG-2005

12:00 AM

Docket


02-AUG-2005

03:05 PM

ORDER ENTERED/236

NOTICE GIVEN

CARRAFIELLO,

MATTHEW D

02-AUG-2005

03:07 PM

Docket

Entry:

68-05061868 AND NOW, THIS 29TH DAY OF JULY, 2005, UPON

CONSIDERATION OF DEFENDANT STEVEN FRIEDMAN'S MOTION

FOR SUMMARY JUDGMENT, AND PLANTIFFS' RESPONSE

THERETO, IT IS HEREBY ORDERED AND DECRRED THAT SAID

MOTION IS DENIED. BY THE COURT: CARRAFIELLO, J. 7/29/05

05-AUG-2005

12:59 PM

POST TRIAL MOTION MORGAN,

DOMINIC

08-AUG-2005

12:00 AM

Docket

Entry: MOTION FOR POST TRIAL RELIEF FILED

05-AUG-2005

02:08 PM


02:08 PM

Docket

Entry:

60-05070860 MOTION TO COMPEL ASSIGNED TO JUDGE GLAZER

ON 8/8/05.

08-AUG-2005

03:08 PM

POST TRIAL MOTION

ASSIGNED

08-AUG-2005

03:08 PM

Docket

Entry:

DEFENDANT MORGAN'S MOTION FOR POST-TRIAL RELIEF

ASSIGNED TO JUDGE MAIER, 8-8-05.

10-AUG-2005

10:11 AM

MOTION ASSIGNMENT

UPDATED

10-AUG-2005

12:00 AM

Docket

Entry:

60-05070860 MOTION TO COMPEL DISCOVERY REASSIGNED TO

JUDGE MAIER ON 8/10/05.

12-AUG-2005

01:51 PM


01:51 PM

Docket

Entry:

78-05071578 MISCELLANEOUS MOTION ASSIGNED TO JUDGE

GLAZER ON 8/15/05.

16-AUG-2005

03:53 PM

ORDER ENTERED/236

NOTICE GIVEN

GLAZER,

GARY S

16-AUG-2005

03:57 PM

Docket

Entry:

78-05071578 AND NOW, THIS 15TH DAY OF AUGUST, 2005, UPON

CONSIDERATION OF DEFENDANT FRIEDMAN'S MOTION FOR

SEVERANCE AND TO BIFURCATE, IT IS HEREBY ORDERED THAT

SAID MOTION IS DENIED WITHOUT PREJUDICE TO RAISE BEFORE

TRIAL JUDGE. BY THE COURT: GLAZER, J. 8/15/05

19-OCT-2005

02:10 PM

ORDER ENTERED/236

NOTICE GIVEN

MAIER,

EUGENE E

19-OCT-2005

12:00 AM

Docket

Entry:

IT IS ORDERED THAT STEVEN FRIEDMAN ESQ'S PRAECIPE TO

WITHDRAW, DATE-STAMPED 9/27/05 AND CONSISTANT WITH

JUDGE BERNSTEIN'S 11/18/04 ORDER GRANTING LEAVE TO

WITHDRAW, SHALL BE DOCKETED. BY THE COURT ...MAIER,J

10/18/05

19-OCT-2005

02:11 PM

PRAECIPE TO

WITHDRAW

FRIEDMAN,

STEVEN A

19-OCT-2005

12:00 AM

Docket

Entry:

PRAECIPE TO WITHDRAW FILED BY STEVEN FRIEDMAN ESQ ON

9/27/05

19-OCT-2005

02:13 PM

ORDER ENTERED/236

NOTICE GIVEN

MAIER,

EUGENE E

19-OCT-2005

12:00 AM

Docket

Entry:

IT IS ORDERED THAT, ON COUNT III OF THE COMPLAINT, THE

AGREEMENT WHICH WAS ENTERED INTO BY DEFT, MORGAN AND

PLTFS ON OR ABOUT THE PERIOD 7/30/03 THROUGH 8/4/03 IS

ENFORCED AND DEFT, MORGAN WILL NOT MENTION DR NEVYAS

OR HIS PRACTICE OR ANYTHING CONCERNING PAST ITEMS FROM

DR NEVYAS OR HIS PRACTICE IN DEFT'S WEBSITE. DEFT,

MORGAN IS ORDERED TO OPERATE HIS WEBSITE AND ANY

WEBSITE IN ACCORDANCE WITH THE 8/4/03 AGREEMENT. THE

DEFAMATION ACTION BY DR NEVYAS AGAINST MR MORGAN IS

DISMISSED AS AGREED TO IN THE 7/30/03 THROUGH 8/4/03

AGREEMENT. BY THE COURT ...MAIER,J 9/29/05

28-OCT-2005

04:23 PM

APPEAL TO SUPERIOR

COURT

MORGAN,

DOMINIC

28-OCT-2005

12:00 AM

Docket

Entry:

************************************************* NOTICE IS

HEREBY GIVEN THAT DEFENDANT DOMINIC MORGAN APPEALS

FROM THE ORDER DATED 9-29-05 AND DOCKETED ON 10-19-05 BY

JUDGE MAIER. ORDER FOR TRANSCRIPT FILED. PROOF OF

SERVICE FILED. TB

***************************************************

14-NOV-2005

10:44 AM

ASSIGNED TO JUDGE MAIER,

EUGENE E

14-NOV-2005

10:44 AM

Docket

Entry: none.

22-NOV-2005

11:32 AM

ORDER ENTERED/236

NOTICE GIVEN

MAIER,

EUGENE E

22-NOV-2005

12:00 AM

Docket

Entry:

PURSUANT TO PA.R.A.P. 1925(d), YOU ARE DIRECTED TO FILE

WITHIN FOURTEEN (14) DAYS OF THE ENTRY OF THIS ORDER, A

CONCISE, SELF-CONTAINED AND INTELLIGIBLE STATEMENT OF

MATTERS COMPLAINED OF IN THIS APPEAL, INDICATING

SPECIFIC PAGE REFERENCES TO THE NOTES OF TESTIMONY,

WHERE APPLICABLE. THE ORIGINAL STATEMENT SHALL BE

FILED OF RECORD AND A COPY SHALL BE HAND-DELIVERED

CONCURRENTLY WITH HONORABLE EUGENE EDW. J. MAIER,

ROOM 392, CITY HALL, PHILADELPHIA, PA 19107. YOUR

NONCOMPLIANCE WITH THIS ORDER WILL BE DEEMED A

WAIVER OF ALL OBJECTOINS TO THE ORDER OR OTHER

MATTERS COMPLAINED OF ON APPEAL. BY THE COURT: HON.

EUGENE EDWARD J. MAIER, 11-21-05.

01-DEC-2005

01:03 PM

STATEMENT OF

MATTERS (1925(B))

MORGAN,

DOMINIC

02-DEC-2005

12:00 AM

Docket

Entry:

APPELLANTS' STATEMENT OF MATTERS COMPLAINED OF ON

APPEAL PURSUANT TO PA.R.C.P. 1925(B) FILED.

02-DEC-2005

12:00 PM

PETITION FOR

CONTEMPT

05-DEC-2005

12:00 AM

Docket

Entry:

42-05111942 RESPONSE DATE 12/22/05. FILED BY STEIN &

SILVERMAN, P.C., PLAINTIFFS.

12-DEC-2005

09:50 AM

MOT-PROCEED IN

FORMA PAUPERIS

MORGAN,

DOMINIC

14-DEC-2005

12:00 AM

Docket


19-DEC-2005

02:31 PM

ORDER ENTERED/236

NOTICE GIVEN

MAIER,

EUGENE E

19-DEC-2005

12:00 AM

Docket

Entry:

IT IS ORDERED THAT A RULE IS ISSUED UPON PETITIONER,

DOMINIC MORGAN TO SHOW CAUS WHY THE PETITIONER IS NOT

ENTITLED TO THE RELIEF REQUESTED; RESPONDENT, MORGAN

SHALL FILE AN ANSWER WITHIN 20 DAYS; A HEARING OR

ARGUMENT SHALL BE SCHEDULED AT THE DISCRETION OF THE

ASSIGNED JUDGE; AND NOTICE OF ENTRY OF THIS ORDER SHALL

BE PROVIDED IMMEDIATELY TO ALL PARTIES BY THE

PETITIONER. BY THE COURT ...MAIER,J 12/13/05

20-DEC-2005

09:49 AM

ANSWER

(MOTION/PETITION)

FILED

MORGAN,

DOMINIC

22-DEC-2005

12:00 AM

Docket

Entry: 42-05111942 ANS FILED TO MOTION FOR CONTEMPT

22-DEC-2005

11:19 AM

ANSWER

(MOTION/PETITION)

FILED

SILVERMAN,

LEON W

23-DEC-2005

12:00 AM

Docket

Entry: 57-05120657 ANS FILED TO IFP

27-DEC-2005

01:51 PM

MOTION ASSIGNED 27-DEC-2005

01:51 PM

Docket

Entry:

42-05111942 PETITION FOR CONTEMPT ASSIGNED TO JUDGE

GLAZER ON 12/28/05.

27-DEC-2005

04:38 PM


04:38 PM

Docket

Entry:

57-05120657 MOTION TO PROCEED IN FORMA PAUPERIS ASSIGNED

TO JUDGE MANFREDI ON 12/28/05.

30-DEC-2005

10:13 AM

MOTION ASSIGNMENT

UPDATED

30-DEC-2005

12:00 AM

Docket

Entry:

42-05111942 PETITION FOR CONTEMPT REASSIGNED TO JUDGE

MAIER ON 1/3/06, PER JUDGE GLAZER'S REQUEST.

06-JAN-2006

02:11 PM

ORDER ENTERED/236

NOTICE GIVEN

MAIER,

EUGENE E

06-JAN-2006

12:00 AM

Docket

Entry:

IT IS ORDERED THAT DEFENDANT MORGAN SHALL NOT BE

PERMITTED TO PROCEEDIN FORMA PAUPERIS IN THIS ACTION

UNLESS AND UNTIL HE PROVIDES ADEQUATE SHOWING TO THIS

COURT THAT HE IS IN FACT IN FORMA PAUPERIS. ....BY THE

COURT; MAIER, J. 12-27-05

11-JAN-2006

12:32 PM

REPLY FILED MORGAN,

DOMINIC

12-JAN-2006

12:00 AM

Docket

Entry: 57-05120657 REPLY FILED IN SUPPORT OF IFP

13-JAN-2006

12:33 PM

PRAECIPE - IN FORMA

PAUPERIS

HANZELIK,

CARL

13-JAN-2006

12:00 AM

Docket

Entry:

PRAECIPE TO PROCEED IN FORMA PAUPERIS PURSUANT TO PA

R.C.P. 240(D) FILED.

13-JAN-2006

12:34 PM

ENTRY OF

APPEARANCE/NO FEE

PD

HANZELIK,

CARL

13-JAN-2006

12:00 AM

Docket

Entry:

ENTRY OF APPEARANCE OF CARL HANZELIK ESQ. FILED ON

BEHALF OF DEFENDANT DOMINIC MORGAN NO FEE PAID IFP

FILED.

17-JAN-2006

02:48 PM

ORDER ENTERED/236

NOTICE GIVEN

MANFREDI,

WILLIAM J

17-JAN-2006

02:49 PM

Docket

Entry:

57-05120657 UPON CONSIDERATION OF DEFENDANT'S PETITION

TO PROCEED IN FORMA PAUPERIS AND PLAINTIFFS' RESPONSE

THERETO, IT IS HEREBY ORDERED THAT THIS MOTION IS

REFERRED TO THE HONORABLE EUGENE E.J. MAIER. SEE ORDER

FOR FOOTNOTE. BY THE COURT...MANFREDI, J. 1/17/06

22-FEB-2006

11:50 AM

ANSWER

(MOTION/PETITION)

FILED

23-FEB-2006

12:00 AM

Docket

Entry:

57-05120657 ANS FILED TO IFP (FILED BY STEIN & SILVERMAN.

P.C.)

02-MAR-2006

11:01 AM

ORDER ENTERED/236

NOTICE GIVEN

MAIER,

EUGENE E

02-MAR-2006

12:00 AM

Docket

Entry:

57-05120657 IT IS ORDERED THAT DEFT, MORGAN'S MOTION FOR

RECONSIDERATION IS DENIED. BY THE COURT ...MAIER,J 3/1/06

25-APR-2006

04:10 PM

OPINION FILED/236

NOTICE GIVEN

MAIER,

EUGENE E

25-APR-2006

12:00 AM

Docket

Entry: OPINION SIGNED ON 4-14-06 BY MAIER, J.

09-MAY-2006

09:47 AM

APPEAL INVENTORY

RECORD SENT

09-MAY-2006

12:00 AM

Docket

Entry: PURSUANT TO PA. R.A.P. 1931 APPEAL INVENTORY SENT.

09-MAY-2006

09:50 AM

RECORD

MAILED/TRANSMITTED

09-MAY-2006

12:00 AM

Docket

Entry: RECORD SENT TO SUPERIOR COURT VIA UPS.

14-JUL-2006

01:28 PM

MOTION FOR

SUPERSEDEAS

MORGAN,

DOMINIC

17-JUL-2006

12:00 AM

Docket

Entry:

80-06070980 MOTION FOR SUPERSEDEAS (MOTION FOR STAY

PENDING APPEAL) FILED.

17-JUL-2006

01:30 PM


01:30 PM

Docket

Entry:

80-06070980 MOTION FOR SUPERSEDEAS ASSIGNED TO JUDGE

MAIER ON 7/18/06.

24-JUL-2006

09:36 AM

ANSWER

(MOTION/PETITION)

FILED

26-JUL-2006

12:00 AM

Docket

Entry:

80-06070980 ANS FILED TO MOTION TO STAY PENDING SPPEAL.

(FILED BY PLAINTIFF, STEIN AND SILVERMAN).

17-AUG-2006

11:24 AM

ORDER ENTERED/236

NOTICE GIVEN

MAIER,

EUGENE E

17-AUG-2006

11:25 AM

Docket

Entry:

80 06070980 AND NOW, THIS 25 DAY OF JULY, 2006, UPON

CONSIDERATION OF DEFENDANT'S MOTION FOR STAY IS

DENIED.....JUDGE EUGENE E. MAIER

07-MAY-2007

03:50 PM

ENTRY OF

APPEARANCE FILED

FITZGERALD,

MAUREEN P

08-MAY-2007

12:00 AM

Docket

Entry:

ENTRY OF APPEARANCE OF MAUREEN P FITZGERALD ESQ AND

PETER J HOFFMAN ESQ FILED ON BEHALF OF DFT STEVEN A

FRIEDMAN.

11-MAY-2007

03:27 PM

ORDER VACATED BY

APPELLATE CT

11-MAY-2007

12:00 AM

Docket

Entry:

ORDER OF THE SUPERIOR COURT AT 3084 EDA 2005 THAT THE

ORDER OF THE COURT OF COMMON PLEAS IS VACATED AND

CASE IS REMANDED FOR PROCEEDINGS. JURISDICTION

RELINQUISHED......3/9/07 RECORD RETURNED.

21-MAY-2007

02:27 PM

MISCELLANEOUS

MOTION

FRIEDMAN,

STEVEN A

23-MAY-2007

12:00 AM

Docket

Entry: 76-07051276 RESPONSE DATE 6-11-07. MOTION TO RECUSE

05-JUN-2007

09:58 AM

ANSWER

(MOTION/PETITION)

FILED

07-JUN-2007

12:00 AM

Docket

Entry:

76-07051276 ANSWER OF PLAINTIFF'S HERBERT J. NEVYAS, M.D.,

ANITA NEVYAS-WALLACE, M.D. & NEVYAS EYE ASSOCIATES, P.C.

TO MOTION TO RECUSE.

15-JUN-2007

11:01 AM

MOTION ASSIGNED 15-JUN-2007

11:01 AM

Docket

Entry:

76-07051276 MOTION TO RECUSE ASSIGNED TO JUDGE MAIER ON

6-18-07.

11-JUL-2007

10:20 AM

ORDER ENTERED/236

NOTICE GIVEN

MAIER,

EUGENE E

11-JUL-2007

10:21 AM

Docket

Entry:

76-07051276 IT IS ORDERED THAT DEFT, STEVEN FRIEDMAN'S

MOTION TO RECUSE IS DENIED. BY THE COURT ...MAIER,J 7/2/07

12-JUL-2007

12:19 PM

MISCELLANEOUS

MOTION

MORGAN,

DOMINIC

13-JUL-2007

12:00 AM

Docket

Entry:

02-07070902 RESPONSE DATE 8-1-07 (PRO SE DEFENDANT DOMINIC

J. MORGAN'S MOTION TO RECUSE JUDGE EUGENE MAIER FILED).

18-JUL-2007

02:02 PM

ANSWER

(MOTION/PETITION)

FILED

SILVERMAN,

LEON W

18-JUL-2007

12:00 AM

Docket

Entry:

02-07070902 ANSWER OF PLAINTIFFS' HERBERT J. NEVYAS, M.D.,

ANITA NEVYAS-WALLACE, M.D. AND NEVYAS EVE ASSOCIATES,

P.C. TO MOTION TO RECUSE.

23-JUL-2007

11:37 AM

MOTION FOR

SUMMARY JUDGMENT

MORGAN,

DOMINIC

24-JUL-2007

12:00 AM

Docket


30-JUL-2007

10:31 AM

MOT-PROCEED IN

FORMA PAUPERIS

MORGAN,

DOMINIC

02-AUG-2007

12:00 AM

Docket

Entry: 45-07072345 RESPONSE DATE 8-20-2007:

30-JUL-2007

05:08 PM

MISCELLANEOUS

MOTION

MORGAN,

DOMINIC

13-AUG-2007

12:00 AM

Docket

Entry:

45-07072345 CROSS MOTION FOR DECLARATORY JUDGMENT

FILED. RESPONSE DATE: 08/20/07.

03-AUG-2007

10:18 AM


10:18 AM

Docket

Entry:

02-07070902 MOTION TO RECUSE ASSIGNED TO JUDGE MAIER ON

8-6-07.

06-AUG-2007

02:13 PM

MOTION-JUDGMENT

ON PLEADINGS

MORGAN,

DOMINIC

20-AUG-2007

12:00 AM

Docket


10-AUG-2007

03:10 PM

ANSWER

(MOTION/PETITION)

FILED

13-AUG-2007

12:00 AM

Docket

Entry:



P.C. TO MOTION FOR SUMMARY JUDGMENT.

13-AUG-2007

05:06 PM

CORRECTIVE ENTRY 13-AUG-2007

12:00 AM

Docket

Entry:

45-07072345 PLEASE NOTE THE MOTION DOCKETED ON 07/30/07

SHOULD READ AS A MOTION FOR DECLARATORY JUDGMENT

FILED NOT AS A MOTION FOR INFORMA PAUPERIS. MXG@CIVIL.

14-AUG-2007 MOTION FOR MORGAN, 15-AUG-2007

03:10 PM SUMMARY JUDGMENT DOMINIC 12:00 AM

Docket


17-AUG-2007

10:33 AM

ANSWER

(MOTION/PETITION)

FILED

21-AUG-2007

12:00 AM

Documents: Click link(s) to preview/purchase the documents MTANS_221.pdf

Docket

Entry:



P.C. TO MOTION FOR JUDGMENT ON THE PLEADINGS.

22-AUG-2007

10:59 AM

REPLY FILED MORGAN,

DOMINIC

23-AUG-2007

12:00 AM

Docket

Entry:

45-07072345 REPLY FILED TO MOTION FOR DECLARATORY

JUDGMENT.

22-AUG-2007

11:01 AM

REPLY FILED MORGAN,

DOMINIC

23-AUG-2007

12:00 AM

Docket

Entry: 97-07071697 REPLY FILED TO MOTION FOR S.J.

22-AUG-2007

11:02 AM

REPLY FILED MORGAN,

DOMINIC

23-AUG-2007

12:00 AM

Docket

Entry:

54-07080054 REPLY FILED TO MOTION JOUDGMENT ON THE

PLEADINGS.

23-AUG-2007

02:29 PM


02:29 PM

Docket

Entry:

45-07072345 MOTION FOR DECLARATORY JUDGMENT ASSIGNED

TO JUDGE GREENSPAN ON 8-24-07.

https://fjdefile.phila.gov/efsfjd/zk_fjd_public_qry_03.open_docu?uid=Q49NNlzKyIolqsSYDxam&o=W6f1HVpaS!rzHdb&c=031100946&d=221&b=1

24-AUG-2007

03:02 PM


03:02 PM

Docket

Entry:


JUDGE MAIER ON 8-27-07.

24-AUG-2007

03:03 PM

MOTION ASSIGNMENT

UPDATED

24-AUG-2007

03:04 PM

Docket

Entry:

97-07071697 MOTION FOR SUMMARY JUDGMENT MOTION

ASSIGNMENT DATE UPDATED UNTIL 9-13-07.

24-AUG-2007

03:04 PM

MOTION ASSIGNMENT

UPDATED

24-AUG-2007

12:00 AM

Docket

Entry:

45-07072345 MOTION FOR DECLARATORY JUDGMENT RE-

ASSIGNED TO JUDGE MAIER ON 8-27-07.

30-AUG-2007

02:05 PM


02:05 PM

Docket

Entry:

54-07080054 MOTION FOR JUDGMENT ON PLEADINGS ASSIGNED

TO JUDGE MAIER ON 8-31-07.

11-SEP-2007

02:30 PM

ANSWER

(MOTION/PETITION)

FILED

NEVYAS MD,

HERBERT J

13-SEP-2007

12:00 AM

Docket

Entry:

45-07072345 ANSWER OF PLAINTIFF TO MOTION FOR

DECLARATORY JUDGMENT.

12-SEP-2007

11:44 AM

ANSWER

(MOTION/PETITION)

FILED

MORGAN,

DOMINIC

13-SEP-2007

12:00 AM

Docket

Entry:

02-07070902 REPLY OF DEFENDANT TO PLAINTIFF'S RESPONSE TO

MOTION TO RECUSE.

19-SEP-2007

02:11 PM


02:11 PM

Docket

Entry:



19-SEP-2007

02:16 PM


02:16 PM

Docket

Entry:



12-OCT-2007

10:37 AM

ORDER ENTERED/236

NOTICE GIVEN

MAIER,

EUGENE E

12-OCT-2007

10:37 AM

Docket

Entry:

45-07072345 IT IS ORDERED THAT DEFT, DOMINIC MORGAN'S

MOTION FOR DECLARATORY JUDGMENT IS DENIED. BY THE

COURT ...MAIER,J 10/4/07

12-OCT-2007

10:39 AM

ORDER ENTERED/236

NOTICE GIVEN

MAIER,

EUGENE E

12-OCT-2007

10:39 AM

Docket

Entry:


MOTION TO RECUSE IS DENIED. BY THE COURT ...MAIER,J 10/4/07

12-OCT-2007

10:39 AM

ORDER ENTERED/236

NOTICE GIVEN

MAIER,

EUGENE E

12-OCT-2007

10:40 AM

Docket

Entry:

97-07071697 IT IS ORDERED THAT DEFT, DOMINIC MORGAN'S IN

FORMA PAUPERIS CROSS-MOTION FOR DECLARATORY

JUDGMENT IS DENIED. BY THE COURT ...MAIER,J 10/4/07

12-OCT-2007

10:40 AM

ORDER ENTERED/236

NOTICE GIVEN

MAIER,

EUGENE E

12-OCT-2007

10:42 AM

Docket

Entry:

54-07080054 IT IS ORDERED THAT DEFT, DOMINIC MORGAN'S IN

FORMA PAUPERIS CROSS-MOTION FOR DECLARATORY

JUDGMENT IS DENIED. BY THE COURT ...MAIER,J 10/4/07

12-OCT-2007

10:42 AM

ORDER ENTERED/236

NOTICE GIVEN

MAIER,

EUGENE E

12-OCT-2007

10:43 AM

Docket 35-07080835 IT IS ORDERED THAT DEFT, DOMINIC MORGAN'S

Entry: MOTION FOR SUMMARY JUDGMENT IS DENIED. BY THE COURT

...MAIER,J 10/4/07

16-OCT-2007

09:23 AM

ORDER ENTERED/236

NOTICE GIVEN

MAIER,

EUGENE E

16-OCT-2007

12:00 AM

Docket

Entry:

45-07072345 IT IS ORDERED THAT THE CROSS-MOTION FOR

DECLARATORY JUDGMENT IS GRANTED. SEE ORDER FOR TERMS.

BY THE COURT ...MAIER,J 10/4/07

16-OCT-2007

09:24 AM

ORDER ENTERED/236

NOTICE GIVEN

MAIER,

EUGENE E

16-OCT-2007

12:00 AM

Docket

Entry:

45-07072345 IT IS ORDERED THAT THE ORDER GRANTING CROSS-

MOTION FOR DECLARATORY JUDGMENT WAS SIGNED IN ERROR

AND IS THEREFORE RECONSIDERED AND DENIED. BY THE COURT

...MAIER,J 10/15/07

16-OCT-2007

04:16 PM

MOTION FOR

JUDGMENT

17-OCT-2007

12:00 AM

Docket

Entry:

61-07101461 RESPONSE DATE 11-5-07. (PLFS, HERBERT J. NEVYAS,

M.D., ANITA NEVYAS WALLCE, M.D. AND NEVYAS EYS

ASSOCIATES, P.C.)

02-NOV-2007

11:17 AM

ANSWER

(MOTION/PETITION)

FILED

MORGAN,

DOMINIC

05-NOV-2007

12:00 AM

Docket

Entry:

61-07101461 ANS FILED TO MOTION FOR JUDGMENT FOLLOWING

REMAND.

08-NOV-2007

09:51 AM


09:51 AM

Docket

Entry:

61-07101461 MOTION FOR JUDGMENT ASSIGNED TO JUDGE MAIER

ON 11-9-07.

31-DEC-2007

01:53 PM

ORDER ENTERED/236

NOTICE GIVEN

MAIER,

EUGENE E

31-DEC-2007

01:54 PM

Docket

Entry:

61-07101461 AND NOW, THIS 28TH DAY OF DECEMBER, 2007, UPON

CONSIDERATION OF PLAINTIFFS' MOTION FOR JUDGMENT ON

REMAND AND DEFENDANT MORGAN'S RESPONSE, THE MOTION

IS DENIED. BY THE COURT: HON. EUGENE EDWARD J. MAIER, 12-

28-07.

09-JUN-2008

11:50 AM

MISCELLANEOUS

MOTION

NEVYAS MD,

HERBERT J

13-JUN-2008

12:00 AM

Documents: Click link(s) to preview/purchase the documents MTMIS_245.pdf

Docket

Entry:

66-08060766 MOTION FOR EVIDENTIARY HEARING ON REMAND IN

ACCORD WITH THE ORDER OF THE SUPERIOR COURT. RESPONSE

DATE 06-30-08.

30-JUN-2008

04:09 PM

ANSWER

(MOTION/PETITION)

FILED

MORGAN,

DOMINIC

07-JUL-2008

12:00 AM

Docket

Entry:

66-08060766 PRO SE DEFENDANT DOMINIC J. MORGAN'S RESPONSE

TO PLAINTIFFS NEVYASES' MOTION FOR AN EVIDENTIARY

HEARING FILED.

16-JUL-2008

12:31 PM


12:31 PM

Docket

Entry:

66-08060766 MOTION FOR AN EVIDENTIARY HEARING ON

REMAND IN ACCORD WITH THE ORDER OF THE SUPERIOR COURT

ASSIGNED TO JUDGE MAIER ON 07-17-2008.

10-MAR-2009

01:46 PM

MOTION ASSIGNMENT

UPDATED

10-MAR-2009

01:46 PM

Docket

Entry: none.

10-MAR-2009

01:46 PM

MOTION ASSIGNMENT

UPDATED

10-MAR-2009

01:46 PM

Docket none.


Entry:

10-MAR-2009

01:47 PM

MOTION ASSIGNMENT

UPDATED

10-MAR-2009

01:47 PM

Docket

Entry: none.

10-MAR-2009

01:47 PM

MOTION ASSIGNMENT

UPDATED

10-MAR-2009

01:47 PM

Docket

Entry: none.

10-MAR-2009

01:47 PM

MOTION ASSIGNMENT

UPDATED

10-MAR-2009

01:47 PM

Docket

Entry: none.

10-MAR-2009

01:47 PM

MOTION ASSIGNMENT

UPDATED

10-MAR-2009

01:47 PM

Docket

Entry: none.

10-MAR-2009

01:48 PM


01:48 PM

Docket

Entry:


ROGERS 3/10/09

10-MAR-2009

01:49 PM


01:49 PM

Docket

Entry:


ROGERS 3/10/09

10-MAR-2009 MOTION ASSIGNED 10-MAR-2009

01:49 PM 01:49 PM

Docket

Entry:

60-05070860 MOTION TO COMPEL REASSIGNED TO JUDGE ROGERS

3/10/09

10-MAR-2009

01:50 PM


01:50 PM

Docket

Entry:

42-05111942 MOTION FOR CONTEMPT REASSIGNED TO JUDGE

ROGERS 3/10/09

10-MAR-2009

01:51 PM


01:51 PM

Docket

Entry:

66-08060766 MOTION FOR EVIDENTIARY HEARING REASSIGNED

TO JUDGE ROGERS 3/10/09

10-MAR-2009

01:52 PM

POST TRIAL MOTION

ASSIGNED

10-MAR-2009

01:52 PM

Docket

Entry: POST TRIAL MOTION REASSIGNED TO JUDGE ROGERS 3/10/09

17-JUN-2009

04:05 PM

MISCELLANEOUS

MOTION

FITZGERALD,

MAUREEN P

18-JUN-2009

09:18 AM

Documents: Click link(s) to preview/purchase the documents MTMIS_260.pdf MTMIS_260_001.pdf MTMIS_260_002.pdf MTMIS_260_003.pdf MTMIS_260_005.pdf MTMIS_260_006.pdf MTMIS_260_007.pdf MTMIS_260_008.pdf MTMIS_260_009.pdf MTMIS_260_010.pdf MTMIS_260_011.pdf MTMIS_260_012.pdf Motion_CoverSheet_MTMIS_260.pdf

Docket

Entry:

01-09062101 RESPONSE DATE 07/08/2009. MOTION TO DETERMINE

PLAINITFF'S PUBLIC FIGURE STATUS (FILED ON BEHALF OF

STEVEN A FRIEDMAN)














09-JUL-2009

10:11 AM

ANSWER

(MOTION/PETITION)

FILED

MORGAN,

DOMINIC J

09-JUL-2009

10:17 AM

Documents: Click link(s) to preview/purchase the documents MTANS_261.pdf MTANS_261_008.pdf MTANS_261_009.pdf MTANS_261_010.pdf MTANS_261_011.pdf MTANS_261_012.pdf MTANS_261_013.pdf MTANS_261_014.pdf MTANS_261_015.pdf MTANS_261_016.pdf MTANS_261_017.pdf MTANS_261_018.pdf Motion_CoverSheet_MTANS_261.pdf

Docket

Entry:

01-09062101 ANSWER IN OPPOSITION OF MISCELLANEOUS

MOTION FILED. (FILED ON BEHALF OF DOMINIC MORGAN)

10-JUL-2009

10:14 AM

PRAECIPE TO

SUPPL/ATTACH FILED

MORGAN,

DOMINIC J

10-JUL-2009

11:17 AM

Documents: Click link(s) to preview/purchase the documents PRATT_262.pdf

Docket

Entry:

01-09062101 PRAECIPE TO SUPPLEMENT/ATTACH RE:

MISCELLANEOUS MOTION FILED. (FILED ON BEHALF OF DOMINIC

MORGAN)

14-JUL-2009

01:48 PM


01:48 PM

Docket

Entry:

01-09062101 MISCELLANEOUS MOTION ASSIGNED TO JUDGE: FOX,

IDEE C. ON DATE: JULY 14, 2009

15-JUL-2009

01:25 PM

MOTION ASSIGNMENT

UPDATED

15-JUL-2009

01:25 PM

Docket

Entry:

01-09062101 REASSIGNED TO JUDGE ROGERS, PETER F ON 15-JUL-

09















17-JUL-2009

01:57 PM

ANSWER

(MOTION/PETITION)

FILED

SILVERMAN,

LEON W

17-JUL-2009

02:21 PM

Documents: Click link(s) to preview/purchase the documents MTANS_265.pdf Motion_CoverSheet_MTANS_265.pdf

Docket

Entry:

01-09062101 ANSWER IN OPPOSITION OF MISCELLANEOUS

MOTION FILED. (FILED ON BEHALF OF NEVYAS EYE

ASDSOCIATES, ANITA NEVYAS-WALLACE AND HERBERT J

NEVYAS)

20-JUL-2009

12:28 AM

MOTION/PETITION

REPLY FILED

MORGAN,

DOMINIC J

20-JUL-2009

10:28 AM

Documents: Click link(s) to preview/purchase the documents REPLM_266.pdf REPLM_266_001.pdf REPLM_266_002.pdf Motion_CoverSheet_REPLM_266.pdf

Docket

Entry:

01-09062101 REPLY IN OPPOSITION OF MISCELLANEOUS MOTION

FILED. (FILED ON BEHALF OF DOMINIC MORGAN)

27-JUL-2009

01:59 PM

MOTION/PETITION

REPLY FILED

FITZGERALD,

MAUREEN P

27-JUL-2009

02:02 PM

Documents: Click link(s) to preview/purchase the documents REPLM_267.pdf REPLM_267_001.pdf REPLM_267_002.pdf Motion_CoverSheet_REPLM_267.pdf

Docket

Entry:

01-09062101 REPLY IN SUPPORT OF MISCELLANEOUS MOTION

FILED. (FILED ON BEHALF OF STEVEN A FRIEDMAN)

03-AUG-2009

05:57 PM

MOTION/PETITION

REPLY FILED

SILVERMAN,

LEON W

04-AUG-2009

09:49 AM











Documents: Click link(s) to preview/purchase the documents REPLM_268.pdf Motion_CoverSheet_REPLM_268.pdf

Docket

Entry:

01-09062101 REPLY IN OPPOSITION OF MISCELLANEOUS MOTION

FILED. (FILED ON BEHALF OF NEVYAS EYE ASDSOCIATES, ANITA

NEVYAS-WALLACE AND HERBERT J NEVYAS)

05-AUG-2009

05:30 PM

MOTION/PETITION

REPLY FILED

MORGAN,

DOMINIC J

06-AUG-2009

09:15 AM

Documents: Click link(s) to preview/purchase the documents REPLM_269.pdf REPLM_269_001.pdf Motion_CoverSheet_REPLM_269.pdf

Docket

Entry:

01-09062101 REPLY IN SUPPORT OF MISCELLANEOUS MOTION


02-NOV-2009

02:00 AM

PRAECIPE-AMEND

PARTY ADDRESS

MORGAN,

DOMINIC J

02-NOV-2009

08:58 AM

Documents: Click link(s) to preview/purchase the documents PRAMA_270.pdf

Docket

Entry:

PRAECIPE AMEND PARTY'S ADDRESS. (FILED ON BEHALF OF

DOMINIC MORGAN)

09-NOV-2009

11:12 AM

FINDING FOR

DEFENDANT

ROGERS,

PETER F

09-NOV-2009

11:13 AM

Documents: Click link(s) to preview/purchase the documents WSFFD_271.pdf

Docket

Entry:

THE COURT FINDS THAT PLTFS ARE "LIMITED PURPOSE PUBLIC

FIGURES" RELATIVE TO THE INSTANT DEFAMATION CASE. BY

THE COURT ...ROGERS,J 10/14/09

09-NOV-2009

11:12 AM

NOTICE GIVEN UNDER

RULE 236

12-NOV-2009

11:58 AM








Docket

Entry:

NOTICE GIVEN ON 12-NOV-2009 OF FINDING FOR DEFENDANT

ENTERED ON 09-NOV-2009.

12-NOV-2009

04:37 PM

MOT-CERTFY ORDER

INTERLOC APPL

SILVERMAN,

LEON W

13-NOV-2009

10:02 AM

Documents: Click link(s) to preview/purchase the documents MTCIA_273.pdf MTCIA_273_001.pdf MTCIA_273_002.pdf MTCIA_273_003.pdf MTCIA_273_004.pdf MTCIA_273_005.pdf Motion_CoverSheet_MTCIA_273.pdf

Docket

Entry:

66-09111466 MOT-CERTFY ORDER INTERLOC APPL (FILED ON

BEHALF OF NEVYAS EYE ASDSOCIATES, ANITA NEVYAS-

WALLACE AND HERBERT J NEVYAS)

23-NOV-2009

03:07 PM


03:07 PM

Docket

Entry:

66-09111466 MOT-CERTFY ORDER INTERLOC APPL ASSIGNED TO

JUDGE: ROGERS, PETER F. ON DATE: NOVEMBER 23, 2009

30-NOV-2009

11:43 AM

ANSWER

(MOTION/PETITION)

FILED

FITZGERALD,

MAUREEN P

30-NOV-2009

12:12 PM


Docket

Entry:

66-09111466 ANSWER IN OPPOSITION OF MOT-CERTFY ORDER

INTERLOC APPL FILED. (FILED ON BEHALF OF STEVEN A

FRIEDMAN)

02-DEC-2009

02:19 PM

ANSWER

(MOTION/PETITION)

FILED

MORGAN,

DOMINIC J

02-DEC-2009

02:36 PM










Documents: Click link(s) to preview/purchase the documents MTANS_276.pdf MTANS_276_001.pdf Motion_CoverSheet_MTANS_276.pdf

Docket

Entry:


INTERLOC APPL FILED. (FILED ON BEHALF OF DOMINIC MORGAN)

08-DEC-2009

05:14 PM

ANSWER

(MOTION/PETITION)

FILED

SILVERMAN,

LEON W

09-DEC-2009

10:20 AM


Docket

Entry:


INTERLOC APPL FILED. (FILED ON BEHALF OF NEVYAS EYE


NEVYAS)

23-DEC-2009

03:13 PM

MOTION/PETITION

REPLY FILED

FITZGERALD,

MAUREEN P

24-DEC-2009

09:23 AM


Docket

Entry:

66-09111466 REPLY IN OPPOSITION OF MOT-CERTFY ORDER

INTERLOC APPL FILED. (FILED ON BEHALF OF STEVEN A

FRIEDMAN)

24-DEC-2009

11:30 AM

MOTION/PETITION

REPLY FILED

MORGAN,

DOMINIC J

24-DEC-2009

11:32 AM


Docket

Entry:

66-09111466 REPLY IN OPPOSITION OF MOT-CERTFY ORDER

INTERLOC APPL FILED. (FILED ON BEHALF OF DOMINIC MORGAN)










28-SEP-2010

04:10 PM

CORRECTIVE ENTRY 28-SEP-2010

12:00 AM

Docket

Entry:

THE FINDING FOR DEFT DOCKETED 11/9/09 WAS INCORRECTLY

SUBMITTED AS A TRIAL WORKSHEET. THIS DETERMINATION

WAS NOT DISPOSITIVE OF THE CASE AND THE CASE IS RESTORED

TO ACTIVE STATUS.

28-SEP-2010

04:12 PM

CASE REACTIVATED 28-SEP-2010

04:12 PM

Docket

Entry: none.

28-SEP-2010

04:12 PM

ACTIVE CASE 28-SEP-2010

12:00 AM

Docket

Entry: none.

28-SEP-2010

04:12 PM

ASSIGNED TO JUDGE 28-SEP-2010

12:00 AM

Docket

Entry:

THIS CASE IS ASSIGNED TO JUDGE DINUBILE FOR FINAL

DISPOSITION.

20-OCT-2010

11:29 AM

ORDER ENTERED/236

NOTICE GIVEN

ROGERS,

PETER F

20-OCT-2010

11:29 AM

Documents: Click link(s) to preview/purchase the documents ORDER_284.pdf

Docket

Entry:

66-09111466 IT IS ORDERED THAT PLTFS' MOTION TO AMEND

ORDER TO CERTIFY FOR APPEAL IS DENIED. BY THE COURT

...ROGERS,J 10/14/10

20-OCT-2010

11:29 AM

NOTICE GIVEN UNDER

RULE 236

21-OCT-2010

01:05 PM


Docket

Entry:

NOTICE GIVEN ON 21-OCT-2010 OF ORDER ENTERED/236 NOTICE

GIVEN ENTERED ON 20-OCT-2010.

28-NOV-2010

11:42 PM

OBJECTIONS FILED MORGAN,

DOMINIC J

29-NOV-2010

11:10 AM

Documents: Click link(s) to preview/purchase the documents OBJCT_286.pdf

Docket

Entry:

OBJECTIONS TO SUBPOENA PURSUANT TO RULE 4009.21 FILED.

(FILED ON BEHALF OF DOMINIC MORGAN)

02-DEC-2010

10:49 AM

OBJECTIONS FILED FITZGERALD,

MAUREEN P

02-DEC-2010

10:57 AM


Docket

Entry:

DEFENDANTS OBJECTIONS TO SUBPOENA PURSUANT TO RULE

4009.21 FILED. (FILED ON BEHALF OF STEVEN A FRIEDMAN)

09-DEC-2010

01:09 AM

OBJECTIONS FILED MORGAN,

DOMINIC J

09-DEC-2010

07:54 AM


Docket

Entry:

DEFENDANTS OBJECTIONS TO SUBPOENA PURSUANT TO RULE

4009.21 FILED. (FILED ON BEHALF OF DOMINIC MORGAN)

09-DEC-2010

11:15 AM

ORDER ENTERED/236

NOTICE GIVEN

DINUBILE, JR.,

VICTOR J

09-DEC-2010

12:00 AM


Docket

Entry:

IT IS ORDERED THAT THIS MATTER IS LISTED FOR TRIAL ON

3/7/11 AT 9:30 AM IN COURTROOM 253 CITY HALL. THE PARTIES

SHALL SUBMIT PRETRIAL MEMORANDA CONTAINING ALL TRIAL

WITNESSES AND DOCUMENTS TO BE INTRODUCED INTO





EVIDENCE AT THE TRIAL BY 1/31/11. PRETRIAL MEMORANDA

SHALL BE LIMITED TO FIVE PAGES. BY THE COURT ...DINUBILE,J

12/7/10

09-DEC-2010

11:15 AM

NOTICE GIVEN UNDER

RULE 236

10-DEC-2010

09:16 AM

Docket

Entry:

NOTICE GIVEN ON 10-DEC-2010 OF ORDER ENTERED/236 NOTICE

GIVEN ENTERED ON 09-DEC-2010.

09-DEC-2010

11:16 AM

LISTED FOR TRIAL 09-DEC-2010

11:16 AM

Docket

Entry: none.

11-DEC-2010

12:30 AM

NOTICE GIVEN 11-DEC-2010

12:30 AM

Docket

Entry: none.

14-DEC-2010

11:18 AM

ORDER ENTERED/236

NOTICE GIVEN

DINUBILE, JR.,

VICTOR J

14-DEC-2010

12:00 AM


Docket

Entry:

IT IS ORDERED THAT, PLTFS IN PREPARATION FOR TRIAL, MAY

SUBPOENA THE MEDICAL RECORDS OF DEFT, DOMINIC MORGAN

FROM WILLS EYE INSTITUTE LIMITED AS FOLLOWS: THE

MEDICAL RECORD OF DEFT, MORGAN'S EYE EXAMINATION OF

4/23/10 AS WELL AS ANY RECORDS REFLECTING DEFT, MORGAN'S

PRESENT OCULAR DIAGNOSIS, PRESENT VISUAL ACUITY AND

PRESENT HOLE POINT VISUAL ACUITY. BY THE COURT

...DINUBILE,J 12/14/10

14-DEC-2010

11:18 AM

NOTICE GIVEN UNDER

RULE 236

15-DEC-2010

10:54 AM

Docket NOTICE GIVEN ON 15-DEC-2010 OF ORDER ENTERED/236 NOTICE


Entry: GIVEN ENTERED ON 14-DEC-2010.

06-JAN-2011

02:05 PM

MOT-PROCEED IN

FORMA PAUPERIS

MORGAN,

DOMINIC J

06-JAN-2011

02:46 PM

Documents: Click link(s) to preview/purchase the documents MTIFP_295.pdf Motion_CoverSheet_MTIFP_295.pdf

Docket

Entry:

07-11010607 RESPONSE DATE 01/18/2011. (FILED ON BEHALF OF

DOMINIC MORGAN)

24-JAN-2011

11:54 AM


11:54 AM

Docket

Entry:

07-11010607 MOT-PROCEED IN FORMA PAUPERIS ASSIGNED TO

JUDGE: MANFREDI, WILLIAM J. ON DATE: JANUARY 24, 2011

10-FEB-2011

04:05 PM

ORDER ENTERED/236

NOTICE GIVEN

MANFREDI,

WILLIAM J

10-FEB-2011

04:05 PM


Docket

Entry:

07-11010607 IT IS ORDERED THAT THE PETITION TO PROCEED IN

FORMA PAUPERIS IS DISMISSED AS MOOT. SEE ORDER DATED

FEBRUARY 16, 2005. ...BY THE COURT; MANFREDI, J. 2-10-11

10-FEB-2011

04:06 PM

NOTICE GIVEN UNDER

RULE 236

11-FEB-2011

11:03 AM

Docket

Entry:

NOTICE GIVEN ON 11-FEB-2011 OF ORDER ENTERED/236 NOTICE

GIVEN ENTERED ON 10-FEB-2011.

22-FEB-2011

03:16 PM

MOTION IN LIMINE MORGAN,

DOMINIC

22-FEB-2011

12:00 AM

Documents: Click link(s) to preview/purchase the documents MTLIM_299.pdf





Docket

Entry:

91-11025191 PRO SE DEFENDANT DOMINIC J. MORGAN'S MOTION

IN LIMINE FILED.

22-FEB-2011

04:55 PM


04:55 PM

Docket

Entry:

91-11025191 MOTION IN LIMINE ASSIGNED TO JUDGE: MOSS,

SANDRA M. ON DATE: FEBRUARY 22, 2011

28-FEB-2011

12:15 PM

MOTION IN LIMINE FITZGERALD,

MAUREEN P

28-FEB-2011

12:17 PM

Documents: Click link(s) to preview/purchase the documents MTLIM_301.pdf MTLIM_301_001.pdf MTLIM_301_002.pdf MTLIM_301_003.pdf Motion_CoverSheet_MTLIM_301.pdf

Docket

Entry:

93-11023493 MOTION IN LIMINE PREDICATED UPON THE

ABSOLUTE JUDICIAL PRIVILEGE (FILED ON BEHALF OF STEVEN A

FRIEDMAN)

28-FEB-2011

12:22 PM


MAUREEN P

01-MAR-2011

09:12 AM

Documents: Click link(s) to preview/purchase the documents MTLIM_303.pdf Motion_CoverSheet_MTLIM_303.pdf

Docket

Entry:

17-11030017 MOTION IN LIMINE MOTION IN LIMINE DUE TO LACK

OF ACTUAL MALICE EVIDENCE (FILED ON BEHALF OF STEVEN A

FRIEDMAN)

28-FEB-2011

12:27 PM


MAUREEN P

01-MAR-2011

09:13 AM


Docket 19-11030019 MOTION IN LIMINE MOTION IN LIMINE PREDICATED










Entry: ON THE STATUTE OF LIMITATIONS (FILED ON BEHALF OF STEVEN

A FRIEDMAN)

28-FEB-2011

12:34 PM

MOTION TO SEVER

CASES

FITZGERALD,

MAUREEN P

01-MAR-2011

09:15 AM

Documents: Click link(s) to preview/purchase the documents MTSEV_305.pdf Motion_CoverSheet_MTSEV_305.pdf

Docket

Entry:


STEVEN A FRIEDMAN)

01-MAR-2011

08:59 AM


08:59 AM

Docket

Entry:


SANDRA M. ON DATE: MARCH 01, 2011

01-MAR-2011

11:43 AM


DOMINIC

01-MAR-2011

12:00 AM


Docket

Entry:

50-11025250 MOTION IN LIMINE TO PRECLUDE PLAINTIFFS FROM

PRESENTING ANY UNANSWERED REQUESTS FOR ADMISSION AND

SIMILAR DOCUMENTS SERVED BY PLAINTIFFS FILED.

01-MAR-2011

12:02 PM

MOTION ASSIGNMENT

UPDATED

01-MAR-2011

12:02 PM

Docket

Entry:

93-11023493 REASSIGNED TO JUDGE DINUBILE, JR., VICTOR J ON

01-MAR-11

01-MAR-2011

12:02 PM

MOTION ASSIGNMENT

UPDATED

01-MAR-2011

12:02 PM

Docket

Entry:

91-11025191 REASSIGNED TO JUDGE DINUBILE, JR., VICTOR J ON

22-FEB-11




02-MAR-2011

08:58 AM


08:58 AM

Docket

Entry:



02-MAR-2011

10:50 AM


10:50 AM

Docket

Entry:



02-MAR-2011

10:50 AM


10:50 AM

Docket

Entry:



02-MAR-2011

11:53 AM

ANSWER

(MOTION/PETITION)

FILED

SILVERMAN,

LEON W

02-MAR-2011

12:02 PM

Documents: Click link(s) to preview/purchase the documents MTANS_312.pdf MTANS_312_001.pdf MTANS_312_002.pdf MTANS_312_003.pdf MTANS_312_004.pdf MTANS_312_005.pdf MTANS_312_006.pdf MTANS_312_007.pdf MTANS_312_008.pdf Motion_CoverSheet_MTANS_312.pdf

Docket

Entry:

91-11025191 ANSWER IN OPPOSITION OF MOTION IN LIMINE FILED.

(FILED ON BEHALF OF NEVYAS EYE ASDSOCIATES, ANITA


02-MAR-2011

12:06 PM


DOMINIC

02-MAR-2011

12:00 AM












Docket

Entry:

08-11035008 MOTION IN LIMINE TO PRECLUDE EVIDENCE OR

DISMISS CASE FILED.

03-MAR-2011

09:13 AM


09:13 AM

Docket

Entry:



04-MAR-2011

10:05 AM


MAUREEN P

04-MAR-2011

10:42 AM


Docket

Entry:

36-11030636 MOTION IN LIMINE TO PRECLUDE PLAINTIFFS FROM

INTRODUCING ANY EVIDENCE RELATED TO THE UNDENIED

REQUEST FOR ADMISSION DIRECTED TO FRIEDMAN DATED

AUGUST 2, 2004 (FILED ON BEHALF OF STEVEN A FRIEDMAN)

04-MAR-2011

10:09 AM


MAUREEN P

04-MAR-2011

10:45 AM


Docket

Entry:

38-11030638 MOTION IN LIMINE TO PRECLUDE ANY CLAIMS FOR

DAMAGES FOR LOW EMPLOYEE MORALE AND TO PRECLUDE

PLAINTIFF FROM INTRODUCING EVIDENCE AND/OR TESTIMONY

REGARDING SAME (FILED ON BEHALF OF STEVEN A FRIEDMAN)

04-MAR-2011

10:12 AM


MAUREEN P

04-MAR-2011

02:29 PM

Documents: Click link(s) to preview/purchase the documents






MTLIM_317.pdf Motion_CoverSheet_MTLIM_317.pdf

Docket

Entry:

44-11030744 MOTION IN LIMINE MOTION IN LIMINE TO PRECLUDE

ANY SPECULATIVE EVIDENCE OF DAMAGES (FILED ON BEHALF

OF STEVEN A FRIEDMAN)

04-MAR-2011

02:32 PM


02:32 PM

Docket

Entry:



04-MAR-2011

02:32 PM


02:32 PM

Docket

Entry:



04-MAR-2011

03:03 PM


DOMINIC J

04-MAR-2011

03:09 PM

Documents: Click link(s) to preview/purchase the documents MTLIM_320.pdf MTLIM_320_001.pdf MTLIM_320_002.pdf MTLIM_320_003.pdf MTLIM_320_004.pdf MTLIM_320_005.pdf MTLIM_320_006.pdf MTLIM_320_007.pdf MTLIM_320_008.pdf MTLIM_320_009.pdf MTLIM_320_010.pdf MTLIM_320_011.pdf MTLIM_320_012.pdf MTLIM_320_013.pdf MTLIM_320_014.pdf MTLIM_320_015.pdf MTLIM_320_016.pdf MTLIM_320_017.pdf Motion_CoverSheet_MTLIM_320.pdf

Docket

Entry:

55-11030755 MOTION IN LIMINE PRECLUDE PLAINTIFFS FROM

PURPORTING MORGAN'S WEBSITE IS DEFAMATORY. (FILED ON

BEHALF OF DOMINIC MORGAN)






















06-MAR-2011

10:40 PM


DOMINIC J

07-MAR-2011

09:16 AM

Documents: Click link(s) to preview/purchase the documents MTLIM_323.pdf MTLIM_323_001.pdf MTLIM_323_002.pdf Motion_CoverSheet_MTLIM_323.pdf

Docket

Entry:

80-11030880 MOTION IN LIMINE MOTION IN LIMINE TO PRECLUDE

PLAINTIFFS' WITNESS DR. AMOS WILLIS, M.D. TO TESTIFY (FILED

ON BEHALF OF DOMINIC MORGAN)

07-MAR-2011

08:54 AM


08:54 AM

Docket

Entry:



07-MAR-2011

08:59 AM


08:59 AM

Docket

Entry:



07-MAR-2011

03:27 PM


03:27 PM

Docket

Entry:



17-MAR-2011

03:57 PM

FINDING FOR

PLAINTIFF

DINUBILE, JR.,

VICTOR J

17-MAR-2011

03:59 PM

Documents: Click link(s) to preview/purchase the documents WSFFP_325.pdf

Docket

Entry:

FINDING IN FAVOR OF PLTFS, HERBERT NEVYAS MD AND ANITA

NEVYAS-WALLACE MD AND NEVYAS EYE ASSOC PC ("PLTFS")

AND AGAINST DEFT, DOMINIC MORGAN AND GRANTS






INJUNCTIVE RELIEF. FINDING IN FAVOR OF DEFT, STEVEN

FRIEDMAN AND AGAINST PLTFS. SEE COURT'S FINDINGS OF FACT

AND CONCLUSIONS OF LAW. BY THE COURT ...DINUBILE,J 3/16/11

17-MAR-2011

03:57 PM

NOTICE GIVEN UNDER

RULE 236

21-MAR-2011

10:48 AM

Docket

Entry:

NOTICE GIVEN ON 21-MAR-2011 OF FINDING FOR PLAINTIFF

ENTERED ON 17-MAR-2011.

17-MAR-2011

03:59 PM

FACTS &

CONCLUSIONS FILED

DINUBILE, JR.,

VICTOR J

17-MAR-2011

12:00 AM

Documents: Click link(s) to preview/purchase the documents FACTS_326.pdf

Docket

Entry:

FINDINGS OF FACT AND CONCLUSIONS OF LAW ENTERED. SEE

FINDING. BY THE COURT ...DINUBILE,J 3/16/11

17-MAR-2011

04:01 PM

ORDER ENTERED/236

NOTICE GIVEN

DINUBILE, JR.,

VICTOR J

17-MAR-2011

12:00 AM


Docket

Entry:

IT IS ORDERED THAT THE FOLLOWING EQUITABLE RELIEF IS

GRANTED IN FAVOR OF PLTFS AND AGAINST DEFT, DOMINIC

MORGAN: SAID DEFT IS PRECLUDED FROM PAST OR FUTURE

PUBLISHING OF ANY DEFAMATORY MATERIAL PERTAINING TO

AND AGAINST PLTFS, PARTICULARLY REGARDING THEIR

PROFESSIONAL ACTIONS AS OPTHALMOLOGISTS AND LASIK

SURGEONS ON ANY WEBSITE OWNED, OPERATED, CONTROLLED

OR POSSESSED BY DEFT, DOMINIC MORGAN; DEFT, DOMINIC

MORGAN IS PRECLUDED FROM PUBLISHING THE LETTERS OF

12/20/01, 1/4/02, 8/10/02 AND 12/4/03 SENT BY DEFT, STEVEN

FRIEDMAN TO THE FDA; DEFT IS ALSO PRECLUDED FROM

FURTHER PUBLICATION OF HIS LETTER OF 7/15/03 TO THE

HONORABLE FREDERICA MASSIAH-JACKSON, THEN PRESIDENT

JUDGE OF THE COURT OF COMMON PLEAS OF PHILA COUNTY.

ANY FUTURE VIOLATION OF THIS ORDER, AFTER DUE NOTICE TO

DEFT, DOMINIC MORGAN AND AFTER HEARING BEFORE THIS

COURT IN WHICH A FINDING IS MADE THAT THERE IS SUCH A



VIOLATION, SHALL RESULT IN A FINDING OF CIVIL CONTEMPT OF

COURT AND IMPOSITION OF APPROPRIATE SANCTIONS. SEE

ORDER FOR COMPLETE TERMS. BY THE COURT ...DINUBILE,J

3/16/11

17-MAR-2011

04:01 PM

NOTICE GIVEN UNDER

RULE 236

21-MAR-2011

10:49 AM

Docket

Entry:

NOTICE GIVEN ON 21-MAR-2011 OF ORDER ENTERED/236 NOTICE

GIVEN ENTERED ON 17-MAR-2011.

23-MAR-2011

04:23 PM

MOTION/PETITION

WITHDRAWN MOOT

23-MAR-2011

04:23 PM

Docket

Entry:

20-11030020 SEE ORDER FOR COMPLETE TERMS. BY THE COURT


28-MAR-2011

04:40 PM

POST TRIAL MOTION SILVERMAN,

LEON W

28-MAR-2011

04:51 PM

Documents: Click link(s) to preview/purchase the documents Notice 032811 FINAL.pdf Order 1 PostTria 032811 FINAL.pdf Order 2 PreTrial 032811 FINAL.pdf PostTrial Motion 032811 FINAL.pdf Verification 032811.pdf Certificate of Service 032811.pdf Motion CoverSheet Form

Docket

Entry:

20-11034120 POST TRIAL MOTION (FILED ON BEHALF OF NEVYAS

EYE ASDSOCIATES, ANITA NEVYAS-WALLACE AND HERBERT J

NEVYAS)

29-MAR-2011

11:25 AM

POST TRIAL MOTION

ASSIGNED

29-MAR-2011

11:25 AM

Docket

Entry:

20-11034120 POST TRIAL MOTION ASSIGNED TO JUDGE: DINUBILE,

JR., VICTOR J. ON DATE: MARCH 29, 2011

06-APR-2011

02:28 PM

ORDER ENTERED/236

NOTICE GIVEN

DINUBILE, JR.,

VICTOR J

06-APR-2011

12:00 AM









Docket

Entry:

IT IS ORDERED THAT DEFT, DOMINIC MORGAN'S REQUEST FOR

TRIAL TRANSCRIPT IS GRANTED BECAUSE HE HAS BEEN

PERMITTED TO PROCEED IN FORMA PAUPERIS AND POST TRIAL

MOTIONS HAVE BEEN FILED. HE IS PRECLUDED, HOWEVER, FROM

DISSEMINATING THESE NOTES IN ANY FORM TO ANY THIRD

PARTY WITHOUT THE EXPRESS WRITTEN CONSENT OF THE

OFFICIAL COURT REPORTERS, NAMELY JANET MANSFIELD AND

JAMIE WIESE, OR THEIR SUPERVISOR. FAILURE TO COMPLY WILL

BE IN DIRECT VIOLATION OF THIS ORDER AS WELL AS PA R.J.A.

5000.7 AND 18 C.P.S.A. 3926, WHICH PROVIDE THAT

UNAUTHORIZED PHOTOCOPYING OR DUPLICATION WITHOUT

EXPRESS APPROVAL BY THE COURT REPORTER SHALL BE

SUBJECT TO ALL APPROPRIATE LEGAL PROCEEDINGS,

INCLUDING BUT NOT LIMITED TO CIVIL ACTION OR MONETARY

SANCTIONS. BY THE COURT ...DINUBILE,J 4/6/11

06-APR-2011

02:28 PM

NOTICE GIVEN UNDER

RULE 236

06-APR-2011

04:46 PM

Docket

Entry:

NOTICE GIVEN ON 06-APR-2011 OF ORDER ENTERED/236 NOTICE

GIVEN ENTERED ON 06-APR-2011.

07-APR-2011

09:26 AM

ANS-OPP. TO POST-

TRIAL MOTION

MORGAN,

DOMINIC J

07-APR-2011

11:42 AM

Documents: Click link(s) to preview/purchase the documents Response and Cross Motion to PLTF PTM Cover.pdf Response and Cross Motion to PLTF PTM.pdf Response and Cross Motion to PLTF PTM Verif and Cert of Service.pdf Response and Cross Motion to PLTF PTM Exbibits.pdf

Docket

Entry:

20-11034120 ANSWER IN OPPOSITION OF POST-TRIAL MOTION


12-APR-2011

11:55 AM

ANSWER

(MOTION/PETITION)

MORGAN,

DOMINIC

12-APR-2011

12:00 AM










FILED

Documents: Click link(s) to preview/purchase the documents MTANS_336.pdf

Docket

Entry:

20-11034120 (CORRECTED) RESPONSE TO POST TRIAL MOTION

FILED.

12-APR-2011

12:23 PM


DOMINIC

12-APR-2011

12:00 AM

Documents: Click link(s) to preview/purchase the documents PTTMF_337.pdf

Docket

Entry:

54-11045254 DEFENDANTS (CORRECTED) POST TRIAL MOTION

FILED.

12-APR-2011

01:37 PM

POST TRIAL MOTION

ASSIGNED

12-APR-2011

01:37 PM

Docket

Entry:


JR., VICTOR J. ON DATE: APRIL 12, 2011

13-APR-2011

03:06 PM

POST TRIAL MOTION FITZGERALD,

MAUREEN P

13-APR-2011

03:38 PM

Documents: Click link(s) to preview/purchase the documents NEVYAS -FRIEDMAN POST TRIAL MOTION.PDF Motion CoverSheet Form

Docket

Entry:

84-11041384 POST TRIAL MOTION (FILED ON BEHALF OF STEVEN A

FRIEDMAN) MOTION WAS ORIGINALLY FILED ON 04/07/2011 BUT

REJECTED BECAUSE BRIEF WAS ATTACHED (DAP)

13-APR-2011

04:41 PM

POST TRIAL MOTION

ASSIGNED

13-APR-2011

04:41 PM

Docket

Entry:


JR., VICTOR J. ON DATE: APRIL 13, 2011






15-APR-2011

01:20 PM

ANS-OPP. TO POST-

TRIAL MOTION

FITZGERALD,

MAUREEN P

15-APR-2011

01:31 PM

Documents: Click link(s) to preview/purchase the documents RESPONSE OF DEFENDANT FRIEDMAN (M0919559).PDF exhibits a and b.PDF

Docket

Entry:


FILED. (FILED ON BEHALF OF STEVEN A FRIEDMAN)

27-APR-2011

04:48 PM

ANS-OPP. TO POST-

TRIAL MOTION

SILVERMAN,

LEON W

28-APR-2011

09:31 AM

Documents: Click link(s) to preview/purchase the documents Resp Corrected Cross Post Trial.pdf Order Corrected Cross Post Trial.pdf COS Resp Corrected Post Trial.pdf

Docket

Entry:




27-APR-2011

04:49 PM

ANS-OPP. TO POST-

TRIAL MOTION

SILVERMAN,

LEON W

28-APR-2011

09:32 AM

Documents: Click link(s) to preview/purchase the documents RespFriedman Cross.pdf RespFriedOrders.pdf RespFriedman Cross COS.pdf

Docket

Entry:




28-APR-2011

11:26 AM

ORDER AND

MEMORANDUM FILED

DINUBILE, JR.,

VICTOR J

28-APR-2011

11:26 AM

Documents: Click link(s) to preview/purchase the documents ORDMM_344.pdf

Docket 20-11034120 , 11045254 & 11041384 IT IS ORDERED THAT THE POST











Entry: TRIAL MOTIONS OF ALL PARTIES ARE DENIED. JUDGMENT IS

ENTERED ON THE COURT'S FINDINGS IN FAVOR OF DEFT, STEVEN

FRIEDMAN AND AGAINST HERBERT NEVYAS MD AND ANITA

NEVYAS-WALLACE MD, AND NEVYAS EYE ASSOC PC.

ADDITIONALLY, THIS COURT AFFIRMS ITS 3/16/11 ORDER OF

INJUNCTIVE RELIEF, GRANTED IN FAVOR OF PLTFS AND AGAINST

DEFT, DOMINIC MORGAN. THESE JUDGMENTS ARE BASED ON

THIS COURT'S FINDINGS OF FACT AND CONCLUSIONS OF LAW OF

3/16/11. MEMORANDUM OF LAW ENTERED. BY THE COURT


28-APR-2011

11:26 AM

NOTICE GIVEN UNDER

RULE 236

29-APR-2011

02:11 PM

Docket

Entry:

NOTICE GIVEN ON 29-APR-2011 OF ORDER AND MEMORANDUM

FILED ENTERED ON 28-APR-2011.

28-APR-2011

11:27 AM

OTHER EVENT

CANCELLED

DINUBILE, JR.,

VICTOR J

28-APR-2011

11:27 AM

Docket

Entry: 54-11045254 SEE ORDER DOCKETED UNDER CONTROL #11034120

28-APR-2011

11:28 AM

OTHER EVENT

CANCELLED

DINUBILE, JR.,

VICTOR J

28-APR-2011

11:28 AM

Docket

Entry: 84-11041384 SEE ORDER DOCKETED UNDER CONTROL #11034120

24-MAY-2011

01:55 PM

APPEAL TO SUPERIOR

COURT

SILVERMAN,

LEON W

24-MAY-2011

02:45 PM

Documents: Click link(s) to preview/purchase the documents Notice of Appeal.pdf Docket Report.pdf

Docket

Entry:

************************************************** NOTICE OF

APPEAL FROM THE DECISION DATED 04/28/2011 AND DOCKETED

ON 04/28/2011 BY JUDGE DINUBILE, JR., VICTOR. PROOF OF

SERVICE FILED. ORDER FOR TRANSCRIPTS FILED. (FILED ON





*************************************************CYS

31-MAY-2011

02:18 PM

MOTION TO STRIKE MORGAN,

DOMINIC

31-MAY-2011

12:00 AM

Documents: Click link(s) to preview/purchase the documents MTSTK_349.pdf

Docket


02-JUN-2011

10:00 AM

FEE PD PURSUANT TO

ORDER

02-JUN-2011

12:00 AM

Docket

Entry: HIGHER COURT FEE PAID TO SUPERIOR COURT

03-JUN-2011

06:31 AM

CROSS APPEAL TO

SUPERIOR COURT

MORGAN,

DOMINIC J

03-JUN-2011

10:51 AM

Documents: Click link(s) to preview/purchase the documents 060311 Morgan Notice of Cross Appeal.pdf

Docket

Entry:

*************************************************** NOTICE OF

APPEAL FROM THE DECISION DATED AND DOCKETED ON 4/28/11

BY JUDGE DINUBILE, JR., VICTOR. PROOF OF SERVICE FILED.

(FILED ON BEHALF OF DOMINIC MORGAN)****************

06-JUN-2011

02:50 PM

ORDER ENTERED/236

NOTICE GIVEN

DINUBILE, JR.,

VICTOR J

06-JUN-2011

02:50 PM


Docket

Entry:

17-11055317 IT IS ORDERED THAT THE PLTFS' REQUEST TO SEAL

THE RECORD IS DENIED. THERE IS NO COMPELLING REASON TO

SEAL THIS RECORD. THE TRIAL WAS A MATTER OF PUBLIC

RECORD. THE PLTFS ARE SUFFICIENTLY PROTECTED DUE TO

THIS COURT'S INJUNCTIVE ORDER OF 3/16/11, AS WELL AS ITS

ORDER OF 4/6/11 RESTRICTING DISSEMINATION OF THE NOTES OF

TESTIMONY OF THE TRIAL. DEFT, DOMINIC MORGAN'S MOTION




TO QUASH PLTFS' APPEAL WAS IMPROPERLY FILED WITH THIS

COURT. IN ANY EVENT, THERE IS NO MERIT TO THE MOTION,

SINCE THIS COURT, IN GRANTING INJUNCTIVE RELIEF,

CONSIDERED THE ISSUES CONTAINED IN WHAT THE DEFT TERMS

HIS "NEW MATTER AND COUNTERCLAIM". IN ANY EVENT, SINCE

DEFT FAILED TO RAISE THIS ISSUE IN HIS POST TRIAL MOTION,

THE APPELLATE COURT MAY DEEM IT WAIVED ON APPEAL. BY

THE COURT ...DINUBILE,J 6/6/11

06-JUN-2011

02:50 PM

NOTICE GIVEN UNDER

RULE 236

08-JUN-2011

09:55 AM

Docket

Entry:

NOTICE GIVEN ON 08-JUN-2011 OF ORDER ENTERED/236 NOTICE

GIVEN ENTERED ON 06-JUN-2011.

07-JUN-2011

02:19 PM

CROSS APPEAL TO

SUPERIOR COURT

FITZGERALD,

MAUREEN P

07-JUN-2011

03:26 PM

Documents: Click link(s) to preview/purchase the documents NEVYAS - NOTICE OF CROSS APPEAL OF DEF FRIEDMAN.PDF

Docket

Entry:

****************************************************** NOTICE

OF APPEAL FROM THE DECISION DATED AND DOCKETED ON

4/28/11 BY JUDGE DINUBILE, JR., VICTOR. PROOF OF SERVICE

FILED. (FILED ON BEHALF OF STEVEN A

FRIEDMAN)****************

15-JUN-2011

03:01 PM

FEE PD PURSUANT TO

ORDER

15-JUN-2011

12:00 AM

Docket

Entry: HIGH COURT FEE PAID TO SUPERIOR COURT

20-JUN-2011

02:23 PM

OPINION FILED/236

NOTICE GIVEN

DINUBILE, JR.,

VICTOR J

20-JUN-2011

12:00 AM

Documents: Click link(s) to preview/purchase the documents OPFLD_356.pdf

Docket OPINION SIGNED ON 6/17/11 BY DINUBILE, J.




Entry:

20-JUN-2011

02:23 PM

NOTICE GIVEN UNDER

RULE 236

22-JUN-2011

09:16 AM

Docket

Entry:

NOTICE GIVEN ON 22-JUN-2011 OF OPINION FILED/236 NOTICE


10-AUG-2011

10:33 AM

PETITION FOR

CONTEMPT

SILVERMAN,

LEON W

10-AUG-2011

10:49 AM

Documents: Click link(s) to preview/purchase the documents Exhibit 3 080911.pdf Exhibit 4 080911.pdf Exhibit 5 080911.pdf Exhibit 6 080911.pdf Exhibit 2 080911.pdf Exhibit 1 080911.pdf Exhibit 7 080911.pdf Exhibit 8 080911.pdf PetitionContempt-1.pdf Verification 080911.pdf Memo of Law Contempt 080911.pdf Order 080911.pdf Rule 080911.pdf Cert Service 081011.pdf Motion CoverSheet Form

Docket

Entry:


NEVYAS EYE ASDSOCIATES, ANITA NEVYAS-WALLACE AND

HERBERT J NEVYAS)

11-AUG-2011

12:00 PM

APPEAL INVENTORY

RECORD SENT

11-AUG-2011

12:00 AM

Documents: Click link(s) to preview/purchase the documents APILM_359_001.pdf

Docket

Entry: PURSUANT TO PA. R.A.P. 1931 (d) APPEAL INVENTORY SENT.

11-AUG-2011

12:00 PM

RECORD

MAILED/TRANSMITTED

11-AUG-2011

12:00 AM

















Docket


26-AUG-2011

11:18 PM

ANSWER

(MOTION/PETITION)

FILED

MORGAN,

DOMINIC J

29-AUG-2011

09:11 AM

Documents: Click link(s) to preview/purchase the documents Morgan Response to Plaintiffs Motion for Contempt.pdf Morgan Response to Plaintiffs Motion for Contempt Exhibit 1.pdf Morgan Response to Plaintiffs Motion for Contempts Exhibits 2-4.pdf Morgan Response to Plaintiffs Motion for Contempt Exhibit 5.pdf Motion CoverSheet Form

Docket

Entry:

51-11081051 ANSWER IN OPPOSITION OF PETITION FOR CONTEMPT


01-SEP-2011

04:48 PM


04:48 PM

Docket

Entry:

51-11081051 PETITION FOR CONTEMPT ASSIGNED TO JUDGE:

DINUBILE, JR., VICTOR J. ON DATE: SEPTEMBER 01, 2011

12-SEP-2011

02:42 PM

ORDER ENTERED/236

NOTICE GIVEN

DINUBILE, JR.,

VICTOR J

12-SEP-2011

02:42 PM


Docket

Entry:

51-11081051 IT IS ORDERED THAT THE PETITION FOR CIVIL

CONTEMPT AND SANCTIONS IS DENIED AT THIS TIME WITHOUT

PREJUDICE. THIS COURT IS PRECLUDED FROM TAKING ANY

ACTION ON THE MERITS OF THE PETITION SINCE THE MATTER IS

ON APPEAL. PA R.A.P. 1701(A). DEFT, MORGAN, HOWEVER, IS

LEGALLY OBLIGATED TO FOLLOW THE DICTATES OF THIS

COURT'S INJUNCTIVE ORDER, PENDING A DECISION BY THE

SUPERIOR COURT. UNDER THE TERMS OF THE ORDER, AND TO

PRESERVE THE STATUS QUO PENDING THE OUTCOME OF THE

APPEAL, DEFT, MORGAN IS PRECLUDED FROM THE PUBLICATION











OF ANY DEFAMATORY MATERIAL AGAINST PLTFS, WHETHER

THAT MATERIAL IS NEW OR PRE-EXISTING. PA R.A.P. 1701(B)(1).

BY THE COURT ...DINUBILE,J 9/12/11

12-SEP-2011

02:42 PM

NOTICE GIVEN UNDER

RULE 236

13-SEP-2011

03:45 PM

Docket

Entry:

NOTICE GIVEN ON 13-SEP-2011 OF ORDER ENTERED/236 NOTICE

GIVEN ENTERED ON 12-SEP-2011.

14-OCT-2011

01:13 PM

MISCELLANEOUS

MOTION

SILVERMAN,

LEON W

14-OCT-2011

02:56 PM

Documents: Click link(s) to preview/purchase the documents MotSuppRecord_101411.pdf Order MotSuppRecord_101411.pdf Verif MotSuppRecord.pdf COS MotSuppRecord_101411.pdf Motion CoverSheet Form

Docket

Entry:

01-11101501 PLAINTIFFS' MOTION TO SUPPLEMENT THE RECORD

ON APPEAL AS TRANSMITTED BY THE TRIAL COURT (FILED ON



14-OCT-2011

04:41 PM

MOTION ASSIGNED 14-OCT-2011

04:41 PM

Docket

Entry:

01-11101501 MISCELLANEOUS MOTION ASSIGNED TO JUDGE:

DINUBILE, JR., VICTOR J. ON DATE: OCTOBER 14, 2011

22-NOV-2011

02:57 PM

STIPULATION FILED FITZGERALD,

MAUREEN P

22-NOV-2011

03:54 PM

Documents: Click link(s) to preview/purchase the documents Nevyas Order and Stipulation.PDF

Docket

Entry:

79-11113179 STIPULATION TO CORRECT/SUPPLEMENT THE

RECORD ON APPEAL AS TRANSMITTED BY THE TRIAL COURT

FILED. AWAITING JUDICIAL APPROVAL (FILED ON BEHALF OF

STEVEN A FRIEDMAN)







23-NOV-2011

11:51 AM

STIPULATION

ASSIGNED

23-NOV-2011

11:51 AM

Docket

Entry:

79-11113179 STIPULATION FILED ASSIGNED TO JUDGE: DINUBILE,

JR., VICTOR J. ON DATE: NOVEMBER 23, 2011

23-NOV-2011

12:04 PM

ORDER ENTERED/236

NOTICE GIVEN

DINUBILE, JR.,

VICTOR J

23-NOV-2011

12:04 PM


Docket

Entry:

79-11113179 IT IS ORDERED THAT THE STIPULATION OF THE

PARTIES IS APPROVED AND IT IS FURTHER ORDERED THAT THE

PARTIES ARE DIRECTED TO SUPPLEMENT THE RECORD ON

APPEAL BY TRANSMITTING CERTAIN DOCUMENTS TO THE

PROTHONOTARY SUPERIOR COURT WITHIN 20 DAYS. SEE ORDER

FOR COMPLETE LIST OF DOCUMENTS. BY THE COURT


23-NOV-2011

12:04 PM

NOTICE GIVEN UNDER

RULE 236

28-NOV-2011

02:12 PM

Docket

Entry:

NOTICE GIVEN ON 28-NOV-2011 OF ORDER ENTERED/236 NOTICE

GIVEN ENTERED ON 23-NOV-2011.

29-NOV-2011

01:21 PM

PETITION FOR

CONTEMPT

SILVERMAN,

LEON W

29-NOV-2011

02:17 PM

Documents: Click link(s) to preview/purchase the documents PetitionContempt 112911.pdf Verification 112911.pdf Order 112911.pdf Rule 112911.pdf Memo of Law Contempt 112911.pdf Cert Serv 112911.pdf Exhibit 1 080911.pdf Exhibit 2 080911.pdf Exhibit 3 080911.pdf Exhibit 4 080911.pdf Exhibit 5 080911.pdf Exhibit 6 080911.pdf














Exhibit 7 080911.pdf Exhibit 8 080911.pdf Motion CoverSheet Form

Docket

Entry:


NEVYAS EYE ASDSOCIATES, ANITA NEVYAS-WALLACE AND

HERBERT J NEVYAS)

29-NOV-2011

02:26 PM

OTHER EVENT

CANCELLED

DINUBILE, JR.,

VICTOR J

29-NOV-2011

02:26 PM

Docket

Entry: 01-11101501

19-DEC-2011

10:04 AM

ANSWER

(MOTION/PETITION)

FILED

MORGAN,

DOMINIC J

19-DEC-2011

10:32 AM

Documents: Click link(s) to preview/purchase the documents 121611 Morgan Response to Petition for Contempt.pdf 121611 Morgan Response to Pet. Contempt Exhibits 1.pdf 121611 Morgan Response to Pet. Contempt Exhibits 2.pdf 121611 Morgan Response to Pet. Contempt Exhibits 3.pdf Motion CoverSheet Form

Docket

Entry:

63-11113763 ANSWER IN OPPOSITION OF PETITION FOR CONTEMPT


21-DEC-2011

11:48 AM


11:48 AM

Docket

Entry:

63-11113763 PETITION FOR CONTEMPT ASSIGNED TO JUDGE:

DINUBILE, JR., VICTOR J. ON DATE: DECEMBER 21, 2011

28-DEC-2011

01:01 PM

ORDER ENTERED/236

NOTICE GIVEN

DINUBILE, JR.,

VICTOR J

28-DEC-2011

01:01 PM















Docket

Entry:

63-11113763 IT IS ORDERED THAT PLTFS' COUNSEL PROVIDE THIS

COURT WITH ANY DEFAMATORY STATEMENTS ALLEGED TO

HAVE BEEN MADE BY DEFT, MORGAN SUBSEQUENT TO THE

ISSUANCE AND IN VIOLATION OF THIS COURT'S INJUNCTIVE

ORDER OF 3/16/11. THIS SUBMISSION MUST CONTAIN AN

ENUMERATION OF EACH INSTANCE OF VIOLATIONS OF THIS

COURT'S INJUNCTIVE ORDER OCCURRING AFTER 3/16/11, THE

DATE OF ISSUANCE. IT SHALL BE LIMITED TO 2 PAGES IN

LENGTH. BY THE COURT ...DINUBILE,J 12/28/11

28-DEC-2011

01:01 PM

NOTICE GIVEN UNDER

RULE 236

30-DEC-2011

02:48 PM

Docket

Entry:

NOTICE GIVEN ON 30-DEC-2011 OF ORDER ENTERED/236 NOTICE

GIVEN ENTERED ON 28-DEC-2011.

10-JAN-2012

10:39 AM

MOTION/PETITION

REPLY FILED

MORGAN,

DOMINIC J

10-JAN-2012

10:44 AM

Documents: Click link(s) to preview/purchase the documents Morgan Reply to Plaintiffs Response of Courts 122811 Order.pdf Motion CoverSheet Form

Docket

Entry:

63-11113763 REPLY IN OPPOSITION OF PETITION FOR CONTEMPT


17-JAN-2012

05:26 PM

MOTION/PETITION

REPLY FILED

SILVERMAN,

LEON W

18-JAN-2012

09:06 AM

Documents: Click link(s) to preview/purchase the documents ReplyContemptStatementViolations 011712.pdf Cert Service 011712.pdf Motion CoverSheet Form

Docket

Entry:

63-11113763 REPLY IN SUPPORT OF PETITION FOR CONTEMPT










01-MAR-2012

12:03 PM

ORDER ENTERED/236

NOTICE GIVEN

DINUBILE, JR.,

VICTOR J

01-MAR-2012

12:00 AM


Docket

Entry:

63-11113763 IT IS ORDERED THAT, UPON REVIEW OF PLTFS'

MOTION FOR CONTEMPT AND DEFT, MORGAN'S REPLY, A

HEARING WILL BE HELD ON 4/18/12 AT 9:30 AM IN COURTROOM

253 CITY HALL. BY THE COURT ...DINUBILE,J 3/1/12

01-MAR-2012

12:03 PM

NOTICE GIVEN UNDER

RULE 236

05-MAR-2012

10:02 AM

Docket

Entry:

NOTICE GIVEN ON 05-MAR-2012 OF ORDER ENTERED/236 NOTICE

GIVEN ENTERED ON 01-MAR-2012.

09-MAR-2012

02:31 PM

APPEAL QUASHED BY

APPELLATE CT

09-MAR-2012

12:00 AM

Documents: Click link(s) to preview/purchase the documents APQSH_381.pdf

Docket

Entry:

1573 EDA 2011 NOVEMBER 18, 2011 THE COURT HEREBY GRANTS

THE MOTION TO QUASH. PER CURIAM

17-APR-2012

04:32 PM

MOTION/PETITION

REPLY FILED

MORGAN,

DOMINIC J

17-APR-2012

04:39 PM

Documents: Click link(s) to preview/purchase the documents Supplemental Reply to Pet for Contempt Response Part1.pdf Supplemental Reply to Pet for Contempt Response Part2.pdf Motion CoverSheet Form

Docket

Entry:



18-APR-2012

11:04 PM

MOTION/PETITION

REPLY FILED

MORGAN,

DOMINIC J

19-APR-2012

07:34 AM








Documents: Click link(s) to preview/purchase the documents Def Morgans 4182012 Second Supplemental Response to Plts PET for Contempt.pdf Motion CoverSheet Form

Docket

Entry:



19-APR-2012

11:52 AM

ORDER ENTERED/236

NOTICE GIVEN

DINUBILE, JR.,

VICTOR J

19-APR-2012

12:00 AM


Docket

Entry:

63-11113763 ORDER ARISING FROM CONTEMPT HEARING

ENTERED. THIS COURT FOUND THAT THE DEFT, DOMINIC

MORGAN, THROUGH THE PUBLICATIONS FROM CERTAIN

WEBSITES ON OR ABOUT 7/27/11, VIOLATED THE SPIRIT OF THIS

COURT'S ORIGINAL INJUNCTIVE ORDER. THERE EXISTS A FINE

LINE BETWEEN FAIR AND REASONABLE CRITICISM OF PLTFS'

PROFESSIONAL CONDUCT, WHICH THE DEFT HAS A

CONSTITUTIONAL RIGHT TO DO AS A MATTER OF FREE SPEECH,

AND CROSSING THIS LINE BY INFRINGING UPON PLTFS'

PROFESSIONAL REPUTATION. DEFT HAS EVERY RIGHT TO

CRITICIZE THE MEDICAL SERVICES RENDERED TO HIM BY PLTFS,

BUT CANNOT DEFAME THEM. WITH THIS CONCEPT IN MIND, THIS

COURT ENTERS THIS ORDER PERTAINING TO CERTAIN WEBSITES.

SEE ORDER FOR TERMS. IT IS ORDERED THAT THE DEFT SHALL

PUBLISH THIS COURT'S INJUNCTIVE ORDER OF 3/16/11 ON EACH

OF THE FOUR WEBSITES REFERENCED HEREIN. DEFT SHALL

COMPLY WITH THE DICTATES OF THIS ORDER BY 4/30/12. BY THE

COURT ...DINUBILE,J 4/19/12

19-APR-2012

11:52 AM

NOTICE GIVEN UNDER

RULE 236

23-APR-2012

09:38 AM

Docket

Entry:

NOTICE GIVEN ON 23-APR-2012 OF ORDER ENTERED/236 NOTICE

GIVEN ENTERED ON 19-APR-2012.

19-APR-2012

11:52 PM

MOTION/PETITION

REPLY FILED

MORGAN,

DOMINIC J

20-APR-2012

07:40 AM






Documents: Click link(s) to preview/purchase the documents 041912 3rd Suppl Response to Pet for Contempt.pdf Motion CoverSheet Form

Docket

Entry:



09-MAY-2012

02:11 PM

ORDER ENTERED/236

NOTICE GIVEN

DINUBILE, JR.,

VICTOR J

09-MAY-2012

12:00 AM


Docket

Entry:

AND NOW, TO WIT, THIS 9TH DAY OF MAY, 2012, UPON

CONSIDERATION OF DEFENDANT DOMINIC MORGAN'S REQUEST

FOR THE CONTEMPT HEARING TRANSCRIPT OF APRIL 18, 2012 IN

THE ABOVE MATTER, IT IS HEREBY ORDERED AND DECREED

THAT HIS REQUEST IS GRANTED BECAUSE HE HAS BEEN

PERMITTED TO PROCEED IN FORMA PAUPERIS. HE IS PRECLUDED,

HOWEVER, FROM DISSEMINATING THESE NOTES IN ANY FORM

TO ANY THIRD PARTY WITHOUT THE EXPRESS WRITTEN

CONSENT OF THE OFFICIAL COURT REPORTER, NAMELY

MARGARET CLARK, OR HER SUPERVISOR. FAILURE TO COMPLY

WILL BE A DIRECT VIOLATION OF THIS ORDER AS WELL AS

PA.R.J.A 5000.7 AND 18 C.P.S.A.3926, WHICH PROVIDE THAT

UNAUTHORIZED PHOTOCOPYING OR DUPLICATION WITHOUT

EXPRESS APPROVAL BY THE COURT REPORTER SHALL BE

SUBJECT TO ALL APPROPRIATE LEGAL PROCEEDINGS,

INCLUDING BUT NOT LIMITED TO, CIVIL ACTION OR MONETARY

SANCTIONS. BY THE COURT: JUDGE VICTOR J. DINUBILE, JR.

09-MAY-2012

02:11 PM

NOTICE GIVEN UNDER

RULE 236

10-MAY-2012

11:35 AM

Docket

Entry:

NOTICE GIVEN ON 10-MAY-2012 OF ORDER ENTERED/236 NOTICE

GIVEN ENTERED ON 09-MAY-2012.

14-MAY-2012

09:25 AM

STENOGRAPHER'S

NOTES FILED

14-MAY-2012

12:00 AM

Docket 1 VOLUME OF NOTES TAKEN ON 4/18/12 BEFORE JUDGE DINUBILE





Entry: FORWARDED TO SUPERIOR COURT AS A SUPPLEMENTAL

RECORD.

17-MAY-2012

01:37 PM

APPEAL TO SUPERIOR

COURT

MORGAN,

DOMINIC J

17-MAY-2012

02:40 PM

Documents: Click link(s) to preview/purchase the documents 051712 Morgan Notice of Appeal.pdf 041912 Order.pdf

Docket

Entry:

************************************************ NOTICE OF

APPEAL FROM THE DECISION DATED 04/19/2012 AND DOCKETED

ON 04/19/2012 BY JUDGE DINUBILE, JR., VICTOR. PROOF OF

SERVICE FILED. ORDER FOR TRANSCRIPTS FILED. (FILED ON

BEHALF OF DOMINIC MORGAN)

************************************************CYS

18-MAY-2012

10:27 AM


DOMINIC J

18-MAY-2012

10:37 AM

Documents: Click link(s) to preview/purchase the documents 051712 Morgan Post Trial Motion.pdf Motion CoverSheet Form

Docket

Entry:

74-12052374 POST TRIAL MOTION (FILED ON BEHALF OF DOMINIC

MORGAN)

18-MAY-2012

01:58 PM

POST TRIAL MOTION

ASSIGNED

18-MAY-2012

01:58 PM

Docket

Entry:


JR., VICTOR J. ON DATE: MAY 18, 2012

23-MAY-2012

11:25 AM

CROSS APPEAL TO

SUPERIOR COURT

SILVERMAN,

LEON W

23-MAY-2012

12:23 PM

Documents: Click link(s) to preview/purchase the documents Cross Appeal Nevyas 052312.pdf

Docket

Entry:

******************************************************* NOTICE

OF APPEAL FROM THE DECISION DATED 04/19/2012 AND






DOCKETED ON 4/19/12 BY JUDGE DINUBILE, JR., VICTOR. PROOF

OF SERVICE FILED. (FILED ON BEHALF OF NEVYAS EYE


NEVYAS)***********************************

31-MAY-2012

10:44 AM

FEE PD PURSUANT TO

ORDER

31-MAY-2012

12:00 AM

Docket

Entry: HIGHER COURT FEE PAID TO SUPERIOR COURT

05-JUN-2012

10:15 AM

ORDER ENTERED/236

NOTICE GIVEN

DINUBILE, JR.,

VICTOR J

05-JUN-2012

10:15 AM


Docket

Entry:


"POST HEARING MOTION" ARISING FROM THIS COURT'S 4/19/12

ORDER, IS DENIED. SEE THIS COURT'S OPINION TO THE SUPERIOR

COURT, TO BE FILED ON 6/5/12. BY THE COURT ...DINUBILE,J 6/4/12

05-JUN-2012

10:15 AM

NOTICE GIVEN UNDER

RULE 236

07-JUN-2012

10:19 AM

Docket

Entry:

NOTICE GIVEN ON 07-JUN-2012 OF ORDER ENTERED/236 NOTICE


05-JUN-2012

11:20 AM

OPINION FILED/236

NOTICE GIVEN

DINUBILE, JR.,

VICTOR J

05-JUN-2012

12:00 AM

Documents: Click link(s) to preview/purchase the documents OPFLD_396.pdf

Docket

Entry: OPINION SIGNED ON 6/5/12 BY DINUBILE, S.J.

05-JUN-2012

11:20 AM

NOTICE GIVEN UNDER

RULE 236

05-JUN-2012

02:03 PM



Docket

Entry:

NOTICE GIVEN ON 05-JUN-2012 OF OPINION FILED/236 NOTICE


19-JUL-2012

12:43 PM

APPEAL INVENTORY

RECORD SENT

19-JUL-2012

12:00 AM

Documents: Click link(s) to preview/purchase the documents APILM_399.pdf

Docket

Entry: PURSUANT TO PA. R.A.P. 1931 (d) APPEAL INVENTORY SENT.

19-JUL-2012

12:43 PM

RECORD

MAILED/TRANSMITTED

19-JUL-2012

12:00 AM

Docket


01-AUG-2012

09:29 AM

STENOGRAPHER'S

NOTES FILED

01-AUG-2012

12:00 AM

Docket

Entry:

4 VOLUMES OF NOTES TAKEN 3/7/11 TO 3/11/11 BEFORE JUDGE

DINUBILE FORWARDED TO SUPERIOR COURT AS A

SUPPLEMENTAL RECORD.

04-MAR-2013

12:19 PM

ORDER AFFIRMED BY

APPELLATE CT

04-MAR-2013

12:00 AM

Documents: Click link(s) to preview/purchase the documents APORA_402.pdf

Docket

Entry:

ORDER OF THE SUPERIOR COURT AT 1470 & 1715 EDA 2012 THAT

THE ORDER OF THE COURT OF COMMON PLEAS IS

AFFIRMED......1/23/13. RECORD RETURNED.

