Ned Rossiter - Logistical Worlds (libre)

8/10/2019 Ned Rossiter - Logistical Worlds (libre)

1/24

Cultural Studies Reviewvolume 20 number 1 March 2014

http://epress.lib.uts.edu.au/journals/index.php/csrj/indexpp. 5376

! Ned Rossiter 2014

ISSN 1837-8692

Logistical Worlds

NED R OSSITER

UNIVERSITY OF W ESTERN S YDNEY

!"# %&'%() *+',#'- ."# /+0.*1'# 2(3.4"- *3(0%( 14./ +0 (153//- /16+.12# 1&7 '#0%/1(-

.'10034 2'37(+4,- 3&8#&.+') 6(+*+%./- 4%/.+9/ 5#1(+./- 0(1/" /.'3,#/- :'+.+4+(+2341(

4+&0(34./ 1&7 :'+(30#'1.3&2 /.1&71'7/;


2/24

VOLUME20 NUMBER1 MAR2014 54

!"#/# 1'# :+//36(# /4#&1'3+/ +0 !"#$%&$'() +",)-% - 1 4+9:%.#' 219# ."1. 7+#/

&+. 1/ )#. #M3/.; N#. 1213&/. +:#'1.3+&1( 01&.1/3#/ +0 '#1(=.39# (16+%' 91&12#9#&.

1&7 ."# 2+8#'&1&4# +0 ."3&2/ *3."3& (+23/.341( 3&7%/.'3#/- ."3/ 1'.34(# '#23/.#'/ 4+7#

1/ 1 /3.# +0 /.'%22(# 0+' (16+%' 1&7 (30#; O+41.#7 /+9#*"#'# 6#.*##& .$/0$&1 1&7 ."#

2,(3- 4567& 89&" /#'3#/- !"#$%&$'() +",)-% #&83/12#/ 1 9%(.3%/#' 219# #&83'+&9#&.

*3."3& *"34" :(1)#'/ 4+((#4.38#() /.12# *3(741. /.'3,#/ 1. :+'. 0143(3.3#/- 93/:(14#

4+&/32&9#&./ 3& 4+&.13' )1'7/ +' *'3.# 4+7# 0+' :1.4"#/ ."1. 9#// *3." 9+7#(/ +0

/%::() 4"13& 3&.#2'1.3+& 6) '#'+%.3&2 /.+4, .+ *1'#"+%/#/ 1('#17) 6%'7# *3."

#M4#// 3&8#&.+'); J"#."#' 3. 3/ 1 .#4"&341( :'+4#// +' +:#'1.38# :'3&43:(#- !"#$%&$'()

+",)-% #M:(+'#/ 4+7# 1/ 1 /)/.#9 +0 ."# 0%.%'#=:'#/#&. 3& *"34" (383&2 (16+%' 9%/.

'#4,+& *3." (+23/.341( '#239#/ +0 2+8#'&1&4# 1&7 4+&.'+(;

P ARAMETERS OF PLAY

!"# .#&/3+& 6#.*##& ."# 41:143.) +0 4+9:%.1.3+&1( /)/.#9/ .+ 2+8#'& 3& &+&=

'#:'#/#&.1.3+&1( *1)/ ."'+%2" ."# '%(# +0 4+7# 1&7 ."# 81'3+%/ 4+&.3&2#&43#/

/:#431( .+ (383&2 (16+%' *3(( /#'8# 1/ 1& 1&1().341( 1'4"3.#4.%'# 3& 1& +&2+3&2 /.%7) +0

2(+61( /%::() 4"13&/; I&3.31.#7 6) ."# !'1&/3. O16+%' :'+G#4.- *# 3&.#&7 !"#$%&$'()

+",)-% .+ "#(: 7'1* +%. 1/:#4./ +0 ."#/# .#&/3+&/ *3."3& ."# :1'19#.#'/ +0 1 837#+

219#; P !"# .#'9 >:1'19#.#'? 3/ 3&8+,#7 3& .*+ ,#) *1)/ "#'#; Q3'/.- 3. 3/ %/#7 1/ 16+'7#' 4+&4#:. ."1. 7#(393./ ."# '1&2# +0 14.383.) 1&7 14.3+&; N#4+&7- ."# 1'.34(#

7'1*/ +& ."# 03#(7 +0 4+9:%.#' /43#&4# *"#'# 1 :1'19#.#' 3/ %&7#'/.++7 1/ 1

0%&4.3+&- 4+991&7 +' >0+'91( 1'2%9#&.? ."1. #/.16(3/"#/ ."# '#0#'#&4# 0+' 1& >14.%1(

1'2%9#&.?- *"34" ."#& #M#4%.#/ ."# 4+991&7 +0 ."# :1'19#.#'; R S 4"1&2# 3&

:1'19#.#'/ ."%/ 1(.#'/ ."# +:#'1.3+& +0 1 :'+2'19- 9+7#( +' /39%(1.3+&; I& ."# 41/#

+0 !"#$%&$'() +",)-% - ."# :(1) +0 ."# 219# 3/ /:#43034 .+ ."# 81(%#/ ."1. 7#03

0%&4.3+&/ +0 :1'19#.#'/; !"3/ /%22#/./ ."1. 219#:(1) 3/ 7#.#'93 6) :1'19#.'34

'%(#/- 1&7 "#'# + 1(*1)/ *1&./ .+ ,##: 3& 93&7 ."1. *3."3& 219# /:14# '%(#/ 1'#144+9:1&3#7 1&7 :#'"1:/ :'#4+&73.3+ 6) ."# :+//363(3.) +0 6'#1,3&2 1&7

'#91,3&2 ."# '%(#/ ."'+%2" ."# 137 +0 4"#1. 4+7#/ 1&7 >9+7/? C219# 9+730341.3+&/F; T

!"# 163(3.) .+ 4"#1. ."# /)/.#9 3/ 4#&.'1( .+ ."# 219#:(1) +0 !"#$%&$'() +",)-% ;

D#23/.#'#7 ."'+%2" ."# 4+&.3&2#&4) +0 ."# #8#&. 1/ 3. 1'3/#/ ."'+%2" ."# 73/'%:.38#

0+'4# +' 3&.#':#.'1.3+& +0 ."# 4+&/.3.%.38# +%./37#- ."# 41:143.) .+ 6'#1, ."# '%(#/


3/24

Ned RossiterLogistical Worlds 55

/#'8#/ .+ .#/. ."# /.163(3.) +0 2(+61( /%::() 4"13&/ 1&7 (+23/.341( +:#'1.3+&/ 1/ ."#)

'%6 1213&/. (16+%' :'14.34#/;

!"#$%&$'() +",)-% 139/ .+ 6# 1 219# ."1. 73//#93&1.#/ 1 4'3.341( 1&1()/3/ +0

/%::() 4"13& 41:3.1(3/9 1&7 (+23/.341( (16+%'- *"3(# 1(/+ /"1:3&2 ."# :'14.34#/ 1&7

9#."+7/ +0 4+((#4.38# 0+'9/ +0 '#/#1'4"; U V+*- 0+' 3&/.1&4#- 932". 7323.1( 837#+

219#/ 6# %&7#'/.++7 1&7 1&1()/#7 0+' ."# *1)/ 3& *"34" ."#) 3&0+'9 ."#

'#9+7#((3&2 +0 %'61& /:14#/ 1&7 (16+%' 4+&73.3+&/W N%4" 1 X%#/.3+& 41& 1(/+ .#(( %/

/+9#."3&2 16+%. "+* %'61& /:14#/ 1'# '#2%(1.#7 *3."3& ."# .+:+(+2341( /:14# +0 ."#

219#; !"# 219# 1&7 3./ :1'19#.#'/ +0 :(1)- 3& +."#' *+'7/- 6#4+9# ."# #9:3'341(

2'+%&7 %:+& *"34" 9#."+7/ 1'# 7#/32- 4+&4#:./ 1'# :'+7%4#7 1&7 1&1()/3/

#9#'2#/; Y Z ,#) '#1/+& 0+' ."3/ "1/ .+ 7+ *3." ."# *1) 3."# 3&.#'. 1&7 ."# '3/# +0

632 71.1 122'#21.3+&- :'#734.38# 1&1()/3/ 1&7 /+431( .*+', 9#731.3+& :'+7%4#

1(2+'3."9341(() 7#.#'93 4++'73&1.#/ ."1. 9+7%(1.# +%' 7#/3'# 1&7 X%1&.30) +%'

#M:#'3#&4# +0 ."# *+'(7; [ S/ 73/.3((#7 3& 1 '#4#&. #//1) 6) Q#&*34, \4H#(8#)-

\1.."#* !3#//#& 1&7 O%,# N394+#- /%4" +:#'1.3+&/ 1'# %&7#'/4+'#7 6) 1 :+(3.341(

#4+&+9) +0 71.1] >!"# 4+((#4.38# 14.383.) +0 "%91&3.) :'+837#/ ."# 71.1 ."1. 3&0+'9/

."# 7#43/3+& 91,3&2 :'+4#//#/ +0 1(2+'3."934 /)/.#9/ /%4" 1/ "32"=0'#X%#&4)

.'173&2 1&7 122'#21.#7 */ /#'834#/ ."1.- 3& .%'&- 1'# +* 6) ."+/# *"+ *3#(7

2(+61( :+*#' 1&7 4+&.'+(] 61&,/- 4+':+'1.3+&/- 2+8#'&9#&./;? ^

J3."3& ."# :(1) +0 !"#$%&$'() +",)-% - :1'. +0 +%' :(1& 3/ .+ 7#/32& 4+%&.#'=

/.'1.#23#/ 1(+&2 ."# (3/ K'31& V+(9#/ 37#&.303#/ 1/] >A'3.341( 4+99%&3.3#/ +0 7#831&.

/%6G#4.383.)- 0+'93&2 1. ."# /3.# +0 ."# #83/4#'1.#7 :'381.#_:%6(34 73837#- `*"34"a 1'#

&+. /%64%(.%'1( 0'38+(3.3#/ 6%. 1..#9:./ .+ '#3&8#&. ."# 8#') 61/3/ +0 ."# :+(3.341(;? b S/

V+(9#/ ."#& &+.#/] >J"1.?/ 1. /.1,# 3/ ."# #(16+'1.3+& +0 7300#'#&. 0%&4.3+&1( '%(#/

0+' +%' 4+((#4.38# 219#/- *"34" 3& .+71)?/ /+43#.) 41&&+. 6# :%. 3&.+ #00#4. *3."+%.

."# (1&2%12# +0 .#4"&+(+2);? J"3(# V+(9#/ 3/ /:#1,3&2 +0 219#/ "#'# 3& ."# 9+'#

4+((#4.38# /+431( /#&/# +0 1 "14, +' :+(3.341( 3&.#'8#&.3+&- ."#'# 3/ &+."#(#///+9#."3&2 .+ 6# .1,#& 0'+9 ."# 37#1 +0 %/3&2 837#+ 219#/ .+ .#/. 1& #&/#96(# +0

0%&4.3+&1( '%(#/ +' :1'19#.#'/ /:#43034 .+ ."# +:#'1.3+& +0 2(+61( (+23/.34/ 3&7%/.'3#/

1&7 ."#3' /%::() 4"13&/; !"# 7#8#(+:9#&. +0 1 /#'3+%/ 837#+ 219# /%4" 1/ !"#$%&$'()

+",)-% 932". ."#& *+', 1/ 1 9#731.3&2 7#834# ."'+%2" *"34" .+ ."3&, 16+%. ."#

:+(3.34/ +0 (+23/.341( /)/.#9/ ."1. 3&4'#1/3&2() 2+8#'& (16+%' 1&7 (30#- 03&1&4# 1&7

."3&2/;


4/24


Q1((3&2 *3."3& ."# 2#&'# +0 /#'3+%/ 219#/ C81'3+%/() ,&+*& 1/ #7%41.3+&1(-

4'3.341(- .14.341( 1&7 14.383/. 219#/F- !"#$%&$'() +",)-% *3(( 6# 1& #M#'43/# 3&

9+7#((3&2 1 '1&2# +0 (+23/.341( /#..3&2/ /%4" 1/ :+'./- *1'#"+%/#/- /"3::3&2 1&7

.'1&/:+'. '+%.#/ 3& +'7#' .+ 7'1* 1..#&.3+& .+ 4+9:(#M 91.#'31( '#(1.3+&/ 6#.*##&

(+23/.34/- 4+9:%.3&2 1&7 (16+%'; !"# 2#&'# +0 /#'3+%/ +' 14.383/. 219#/ *3."3& 7323.1(

0+'91./ "1/ 1 /"+'. 6%. 8#'16(# "3/.+'); BM19:(#/ (3,# :%'(;6 7,"/ +""/6,(

CPccPF 1&7 \+((#3&7%/.'31?/ 81'3+%/ .14.341( 219#/ 4+9# 9+/. 399#731.#() .+ 93&7;

J3." ."#3' 3&.#'#/. 3& /+431( 1&7 :+(3.341( 4'3.3X%# +0 2+8#'&9#&. :+(34) +& 932'1&.

7#.#&.3+&- ."# #M:#'3#&4# 1&7 4+&73.3+& +0 :'#41'3+%/ (16+%'- #(#4.'+&34 *1/.#-

9#731 4+&4#&.'1.3+& 1&7 2(+61(3/#7 01/.=0++7 :'+7%4.3+& 1&7 4+&/%9:.3+& 4"13&/-

/%4" 219#/ 41& 6'+17() 6# 2'+%:#7 *3."3& ."# 4%(.%'# +0 ."# 4+%&.#'=2(+61(3/1.3+&

9+8#9#&. 1/ 3. *1/ #9#'23&2 1. ."# .39#; N#'3+%/ 219#/ /%4" 1/ 45$,- +",)-

2)"?() 0(;$&()$%/ (3- @$-6" 2(/6% - d34,


5/24


+0 ."# 03'9 +' 2+8#'&9#&. 12#&4); !"3/ 737 &+. '#/%(. 3& ."# :1//3&2 +0 ."#

+'21&3/1.3+& 91& /+ 9%4" 1/ "3/ .'1&/0+'91.3+& 3&.+ 9%(.3=#."&34 1&7 2#&7#'#7

/%6G#4./ *"+/# +&4# /#4%'# 1&7 &+* :#':#.%1(() %&4#'.13& #9:(+)9#&. 3/ 6#"+(7#&

.+ ."# 3&.#':#.'1.38# :+*#' +0 4+7#; d+' 4+%(7 *# /1) ."1. /+43#.) "1/ 6#4+9# 1&)

(#// 6%'#1%4'1.34; Z%' #8#')71) 14.383.3#/ 1'# 9+&3.+'#7 1&7 71.1=93 (3,# #'

6#0+'#- ."+%2" 3& *1)/ 9+'# 16/.'14.#7 1&7 +6/4%'# ."1& :'#83+%/(); Z ."3&2 ."1.

:1'.34%(1'() /.1&7/ +%. 3& ."# (+23/.341( :1'17329 3/ ."# *1)/ (16+%' 1&7 *+',#'/?

,&+*(#72# 3/ 3&4'#1/3&2() .'1&/0#''#7 .+ ."# 1(2+'3."934 12#&4) +0 914"3/ 1&7

4+7#;

!"# 1(2+'3."934 14.3+& +0 (+23/.341( +:.393/1.3+& .'1&/(1.#/ 4+&.3&2#&4) 1/ ."1.

*"34" 3/ 4+&.13- '#'+%.#7- 3&.#2'1.#7- 1773&2 81(%#; Q+' \1.."#* Q%((#' 1&7

S&7'#* L+00#)- >."#'# 3/ 1 /#&/# ."1. 1 7#43/3+& ."1. 3/ 9#731.#7 ."'+%2" 1 /#'3#/ +0

+683+%/() 73/3&.#'#/.#7 71.1=4'%&4"3&2 1(2+'3."9/ "1/ 2'#1.#' .'%/.*+'."3// ."1&

7#43/3+&/ 9#731.#7 ."'+%2" ."# '#:'#/#&.1.3+&/ +0 2'##7)- (15)- *"3&3&2

#9:(+)##/?; @R !"# >/.%:373.)? ."1. Q%((#' 1&7 L+00#) 1..'36%.# .+ ."# >4+&4'#.# 4(+/%'#?

3&8#/.#7 %:+& ."# #9:3'341( 8#'3/393(3.%7# +0 71.1 932". 6# +00/#. .+ /+9# #M.#&. 6)

."# 3''1.3+&1(3.) +0 #M:#'3#&4#- 30 +&() #M:#'3#&4# *1/ &+. /+ +0.#& 16/+'6#7 3&.+

9#.'34/ ."1. X%1&.30) +%' #&4+%&.#'/ *3." ."# 4(+%7; !"# X%#/.3+& +0 7#43/3+&

'#X%3'#/ 1 9#731.3+& +0 '#(1.3+& ."1. /#:1'1.#/ ."# '#0%/1( +0 +:.393/1.3+&

C4+&.3&2#&4)F 0'+9 ."# 3&4+':+'1.3+& +0 7#/3'# C(+23/.341( 4+&.'+(F; S. /.1,# 3/ ."#

>1%."+'3.) .+ 14.? 1&7 *3." 3. ."# X%#/.3+& +0 14.3+& 3./#(0;@T V+* 219# 7#/32& 6'3&2/

%/#' #M:#'3#&4# 1&7 14./ +0 :(1) .+2#."#' *3." :'+2'1993&2 71.1 +& (16+%'

:'+7%4.383.) ."1. 6#4+9#/ 4+''%:.36(# %:+& #M.'14.3+& 6) 4+99#'431( 914"3/

4+%(7 0%&4.3+& 1/ 1 .#4"&3X%# +0 73//39%(1.3+& 3& ."# 7#8#(+:9#&. +0!"#$%&$'()

+",)-% ; S4./ +0 :(1) 6#4+9# 14./ +0 7#4#:.3+&;

L OGISTICAL KNOWLEDGE

N3&4# ."# A+(7 J1'- 219# ."#+') 1&7 /)/.#9 1&1()/3/ "18# 6##& 1. ."# 4+'# +0 ."#

91&12#'31( /43#&4# +0 (+23/.34/; A+9:%.1.3+&1( 9+7#(/ +0 4+&0(34. /4#&1'3+/ *3."3&

:'+4%'#9#&. .*+',/ 1&7 /%::() 4"13&/ "18# :(1)#7 1 ,#) '+(# 3& ."# .#4"&+4'1.34

91&12#9#&. +0 :#+:(# 1&7 ."3&2/; E1.'34, A'+21&?/ 2(/6;)(1 A"-6> +(,B .$/9)(&$"3

(3- 46'53"'9)&9,6 /3.%1.#/ 219# 7#8#(+:9#&. 03'9() *3."3& ."# 93(3.1')=3&7%/.'31(

4+9:(#M; @U Q'+9 J+'(7 J1' II- ."# 93(3.1') 1::1'1.%/ +'21&3/#7 3./#(0 1'+%&7


6/24


9+7#(/ +0 :'#=#9:.3+& 3& ."# 0+'9 +0 (+23/.341( /39%(1.3+& 219#/ ."1. /.'38# .+

>0+'#4(+/# ."# 0%.%'#? 3& >."# *1' +& 4+&.3&2#&4)?;@Y !"# :'+6(#9 +0 4+&.3&2#&4)f+'

."# >3&41(4%(163(3.) +0 .14.341( /:14#?f"1/ +'323&/ 3& ."# *'3.3&2/ +0 E'%//31& /+(73#'

1&7 93(3.1') ."#+'3/. A1'( 8+& A(1%/#*3.5- *"3(# ."# .#4"&+4'1.34 +' 1793&3/.'1.38#

1/:#4./ +0 93(3.1') +:#'1.3+&/ 71.#/ 614, .+ ."# J1' +0 ."# N:1&3/" N%44#//3+&

C@[c@g@TF- *"#'# Q'3#7'34" J3("#(9 I '#1(3/#7 ."# #7 0+' >+003431(/ *3."

419#'1(3/.34 /,3((/? .+ 9+63(3/# /%::(3#/ 1&7 0'#/" .'++:/ 0+' /.1&73&2 1'93#/; @[

Z0034#'/ #X%3::#7 *3." /%4" /,3((/ >+:# %: ."# :+//363(3.) h .+ /*3.4" 0'+9 1

:%'#() 93(3.1') 41'##' .+ 1& 1793&3/.'1.38# +?- ."%/ 3&/.1&.31.3&2 ."# 4+&G%&4.3+&

+0 ."#1.'#/ +0 *1' *3." ."# 91&12#9#&. +0 4383(31& (30#; @ J1' 219#/ 93''+'#7 ."3/

3&.#'/#4.3+& 6#.*##& ."# 93(3.1') 1&7 /+43#.);

I& "3/ /.%7) +0 (+23/.341( 41.1/.'+:"#/- \1&%#( 7# O1&71 3/ :'#+44%:3#7 *3."

(+23/.34/ 1/ 1 *1' 914"3 S44+'73&2 .+ 7# O1&71- ."# 93(3.1') /+%2". 1

'1.3+&1(3/1.3+& +0 (16+%'- >6#23&&3&2 3& #1'() &3.##&." 4#&.%') 1'9+'3#/ 1&7

4%(93&1.3&2 1 4#&.%') (1.#' 3& ."# .39#=1&7=9+.3+& /.%73#/ 1&7 /43#&.3034

91&12#9#&. ."#+'3#/ +0 Q'#7#'34, !1)(+'- ."# :'+7%4. +0 "3/ #M:#'3#&4#/ 3& iN

1'/#&1(/?; @b !+ (#//#& 3./ 7#:#&7#&4# +& 91&:+*#'- ."# 93(3.1')

3&4'#1/3&2() #00#4.#7 1 .'1&/0#'#&4# +0 ,&+*(#72# 0'+9 ."# *+',#'?/ 6+7) .+ ."#

"1'7*1'# +0 914"3/ 1&7 .+ ."# /+0.*1'# +0 91&12#9#&. :'14.34#/;? Pc J3."3& ."#

4+&.#M. +0 41:3.1(3/. 2(+61(3/1.3+&- "+*#8#'- ."# >4+991&7 /.'%4.%'#? +0 (+23/.34/ 3/

&+. .3#7 .+ ."#1.'#/ +0 *1' +' ."# 93(3.1')=3&7%/.'31( 4+9:(#M 3& 1&) #M4(%/38#

91&'; d+."#(#//- 7# O1&71?/ +6/#'81.3+& "#'# '#913&/ '#(#81&.; !"# .'1&/0#' +0

,&+*(#72# 0'+9 (16+%' .+ 914"3/ 1&7 4+7# '#/%(./ 3& *+',#'/ *3."3& ."# (+23/.341(

3&7%/.'3#/ "183&2 1 /#29#&.#7- 4+9:1'.9#&.1(3/#7 1&7 +0.#& :1'.31( %&7#'/.1&73&2

+0 "+* /%::() 4"13&/ 1'# 4+9:+/#7 1&7 ."# #00#4./ 73/'%:.3+& +' 6(+4,12#/ 3& +

:1'. +0 ."# 73/.'36%.3+& /)/.#9 91) "18# #(/#*"#'#; S 4+9:'#"#&/3+& +0 "+* /%::()

4"13&/ +:#'1.# 91) #&16(# 0+'9/ +0 :+(3.341( +'21&3/1.3+& 1&7 4'+//=/#4.+'1( 9+7#/+0 *+',#'/? /+(371'3.);

S('#17) 1813(16(# /+431( 9#731 .*+',3&2 /+0.*1'# /%4" 1/ Q14#6++, +'

!*3..#' 932". 6# + +:.3+& ."1. 0143(3.1.#/ :+(3.341( ,&+*(#72# +& ."# :1'. +0

*+',#'/ +0 3&.#2'1.#7 /%::() 4"13&/; K%. ."#/# /+0.*1'# /)/.#9/ 1'# 7#/32

:'391'3() 0+' 4"1..3&2- #8#& 30 *# "18# /##& ."#9 %/#7 .+ 9+63(3/# :+(3.341(

:+:%(1.3+&/- 1/ *1/ ."# 41/# *3." ."# S'16 N:'3&2 1&7 ."# Z44%:) 9+8#9#&.; !"#


7/24


9+'# 3&0+'91( /#4.+'/ +0 (+23/.34/ 3&7%/.'3#/ '#() +& /%4" /+0.*1'# .+ 91&12# ."#3'

+*& /%::() 4"13& +:#'1.3+&/; K%. ."#) 014# 1 :'+.+4+(+2341( 61''3#' *"#& 3&0+'91(

/%::() 4"13&/ 9##. ."# 4+9:%.1.3+&1( 1'4"3.#4.%'# +0 ."# *+'(7?/ 7+93&1&.

(+23/.341( /+0.*1'# 7#8#(+:#'/] NSE- Z'14(#- I&0+'- \N (1'2# '#/37#&. :+:%(1.3+& +0 #83( 1'4"#.):#/? ."1. 3&"163.#7 91&) +0 837#+ 219#/

"# :(1)#7 3& "3/ )+%."; PR I& ."# 41/# +0 !"#$%&$'() +",)-% - ."1. 4"1'14.#' 3/ 03((#7 (#//

6) "%91&/ 1&7 9+'# 6) 4+99%&341.3+& 914"3/- +'21&3/1.3+&1( /)/.#9/ 1&7


8/24


1(2+'3."934 :'+4#//#/ '#(1.#7 .+ .#4"&3X%#/ +0 2+8#'&1&4#; !"# (+23/.341( .#4"&+4'1.

3/ &+. ."# #:34#&.'# +0 4+&.'+( /+ 9%4" 1/ 3./ #1'/. 0%&4.3+&1'); Q'#X%#&.() 0'123(#

1&7 3:.- ."# (+23/.341( .#4"&+4'1. '#X%3'#/ ."#3' +*& '#1(=.39# 9#1/%'#/ +0

'#1//%'1&4# 1&7 1::'13/1(; !"# :'391') .'17# +0 ."# (+23/.341( %&38#'/3.) 6#4+9#/

+'21&3/#7 (#// 1'+%&7 ."# 7#(38#') +0 #7%41.3+&1( /#'834#/ 1&7 :'+7%4./- 1&7 9+'#

1(32 *3." ."# #4+&+9) +0 632 71.1; V#'#- *# 6#23& .+ /## 1 4+&.3&%%9 14'+// ."#

122'#21.3+& +0 71.1 1&7 3./ 4+99#'431( #M4"1&2# 91/.#'#7 6) /+431( 9#731 .*+',

4+':+'1.3+&/ /%4" 1/ Q14#6++,- ."# 614,=#&7 913&.#&1&4# +0 4(3#&.?/ 71.1 +:#'1.3+&/

6) BDE /+0.*1'# :'+837#'/ /%4" 1/ L#'91&)?/ *+'(7=(#173&2 4+9:1&) NSE- ."#

i&3.#7 N.1.#?/ d1.3+&1( N#4%'3.) S2#&4) 1&7 3./ EDIN\ 71.1 /%'8#3((1&4# :'+2'19-

1&7 ."# %/# +0 4%/.+9#' '#(1.3+&/"3: 91&12#9#&. CAD\F /+0.*1'# 6) %&38#'/3.3#/

,##& .+ /%::(#9#&. ."#3' /.%7#&.=0##=7'38#& #4+&+93#/ *3." ."# :'+/:#4. +0 71.1

2+(793/ +:#& 0+' .'1&/14.3+& *3." %&73/4(+/#7 ."3'7 :1'.) 4(3#&./; J#(4+9# .+ ."#

#4+&+9) +0 >(30#/.'#19 (+23/.34/?; Q+' N+#&,# k#"(#- (30#/.'#19 (+23/.34/ >3&4(%7# ."#

71.1/41:#/ 2#'1.#7 6) +%' 9+7#/ +0 4+99%&341.38# '#(1.3+& 1&7 ."# .*+',

1'4"3.#4.%'#/ ."1. /%/.13& ."#9?; PT S/ 63+(3&2%3/.34 1&7 100#4.38# .#4"&+(+23#/ +0

41:.%'#- (30#/.'#19 (+23/.34/ /%6/%9# (383&2 (16+%' *3."3& :1.#&.=:'+.#4.#7 4(+%7/ +0

4+&.'+(;

G AME AS METHOD

!"# 7#8#(+:9#&. +0 1 837#+ 219# 41& 1(/+ /"1:# ."# 7#/32& +0 '#/#1'4" 9#."+7/ 0+'

1 :'+G#4. 3&.#'#/.#7 3& ."# /.%7) +0 .'1&/&1.3+&1( 43'4%3./ +0 (16+%'- (30# 1&7

3&0'1/.'%4.%'# /:#431( .+ (+23/.34/ 1&7 /%::() 4"13& 41:3.1(3/9; Q1' 0'+9 #&."'1((#7

6) ."# :'+/:#4. +0 ."# (+ ."#+'3/. /.'1::#7 .+ ."#3' ,#)6+1'7- &+' #&.34#7 6) ."#

1&."'+:+(+23/. /:#&73&2 #M.#&7#7 .39# 3& ."# 03#(7- *# 0+%&7 +%'/#(8#/ "183&2 .+

.1,# /#'3+%/() ."# :'+6(#9 +0 9#."+7 *3."3& %&38#'/3.) /#..3&2/ ."1. &+ (+&2#'

/%::+'. ."# :+//363(3.) 0+' #3."#' +0 ."#/# 3&.#((#4.%1( :#'/+&1/- #8#& 30 ."#) *#'#7#/3'16(#; A#'.13&() *3."3& ."# 144#(#'1.#7 .#4"&+4'1.34 4%(.%'# ."1. 7#03/ 9%4" +0

."# "32"#' #7%41.3+& /#4.+'- ."# .39# +0 ."+%2". 3/ /#4+&71') .+ ."# 2#'1.3+& +0

:%6(341.3+&/ 1&7 #M.#'&1( 0%&73&2 *"+/# '#23/.'1.3+& 1/ >'#/#1'4" X%1&.%9? 3&

1&&%1( :#'0+'91&4# 71.161/#/ 1&7 /:'#17/"##./ 7#.#'93 ."# 41(4%(1.3+& +0

'#/#1'4" *+',(+17/; J3." "32"() 4+9:'#//#7 #4+&+93#/ +0 1417#934 :'+7%4.3+&

."#'# 3/ 1 4#'.13& 7#01%(. '1.3+&1(# +0 3&/.3.%.3+&1( /%'8381( ."1. 1..#&7/ ."# 7#43/3+&


9/24


.+ %&7#'.1,# 4+((#4.38# 0+'9/ +0 '#/#1'4"; !"3/ 3/ #/:#431(() ."# 41/# 0+' (1'2#=/41(#

.'1&/&1.3+&1( :'+G#4./ 3& *"34" :1'.31( ,&+*(#72# 7#03/ 0+' 91&) ."# /3.%1.3+& +0

#&4+%&.#';

S44+9:1&)3&2 ."3/ /+431( 739#&/3+& .+ 4+((#4.38# 9+7#/ +0 ,&+*(#72#

:'+7%4.3+& 3/ 1 9#731 1''1&2#9#&. ."1. 3&.#2'1.#/ +%' *+'(7 +0 #M:#'3#&4# *3."

.#4"&+(+23#/ +0 41(4%(1.3+&;PU l%/. 1/ 43[ +'21&3/#7 :#'4#:.3+& ."'+%2" ."# (+234

+0 2#&'# 4+%:(#7 *3." ."# .#4"&34/ +0 (32". 1&7 /+%&7- /+ ."# /+431( %63X%3.) +0 ."#

219# 3&.#'014# 3&0+'9/ ."# :'+7%4.3+& +0 ,&+*(#72# ."'+%2" ."# :'+.+4+(/ +0 :(1);

!"3/ 3/ &+. .+ 2+ 7+*& ."# 0+'91(3/. :1." +0 9#731 4+&.3&%3.) :'+:+/#7 6) O#8

\1&+834"- 6%. '1."#' .+ 0+'#2'+%&7 "+* ."# :'+:#'.3#/ 1&7 X%1(3.3#/ /:#431( .+

9#731 +0 4+99%&341.3+& :'+9:. /3&2%(1' %&38#'/#/ +0 :+//363(3.); \4H#(8#)- !3#//#&

1&7 N394+# 0'19# 9#731 +0 /39%(1.3+& 1/ .#4"&+(+23#/ +0 41(4%(1.3+&]

!"# I&.#'. 3/ &+ (+&2#' 1 /:14# :'391'3() +0 4+99%&341.3+&- 6%. +0

/39%(1.3+&; K) /39%(1.3+&- *# 7+ &+. 9#1& 1 '#:'+7%4.3+& +0 '#1(3.) >1/ 3. 3/

+%. ."#'#?- 6%. '1."#' 1 /+'. +0 '#1(3.)=3&=:1'1((#(- + ."1. 2#'1.#/ 3./

+*& /#./ +0 .1&236(# X%1&.1 1&7 3./ +*& >'#1(3.3#/?=.+=6#=41(4%(1.#7;PY

J"#& 219#:(1) 4'+//#/ *3." '#/#1'4" :'14.34#/ 3& 2(+61( (+23/.34/ 3&7%/.'3#/- ."#

/#'3+%/ 219# H5"36 .&",1 7#8#(+:#7 6) I.1(31& .#4"=4'3.3X%# +%.03. \+((#3&7%/.'31 3/

1 /.1&7+%. #M19:(# +0 "+* 219#/ 41& '#23/.#' 1 4'3.3X%# +0 ."# 71', (30# +0

.#4"&+(+2) 4+&/%9:.3+& 1&7 :'+7%4.3+&; ."# :(1)#' /)96+(341(() 4+9:(343. 3& 4+(.1& #M.'14.3+& 3& A+&2+- +%./+%'4#7

(16+' 3& A"3&1- #=*1/.# 3& E1,3/.1& 1&7 2172#. 4+&/%9#'3/9 3& ."# J#/.?; P[ J3." 3./

/1.3'341( 7#:34.3+& +0 A"3/# 014.+') *+',#'/ (#1:3&2 .+ ."#3' 7#1."- 3. *1/ &+

/%':'3/# ."1. ."# .14.341( 9#731 /.%&. +0 H5"36 .&",1 *1/ '#9+8#7 *3."3& "+%'/ +0 3./

'#(#1/# +& S::(#?/ S:: N.+'#; m#. 7#/:3.# ."# #00+'./ +0 H5"36 .&",1 .+ 4+&. ."#

:(1) +0 %/#'/ .+ 3//%#/ +0 #4+(+2341( 7#/.'%4.3+& 1&7 "%91& '32"./ 16%/# 1//+431.#7*3." /91'. :"+ /%::() 4"13&/- N) !100#( &+.#/ ."1. ."# 41:143.) 0+' 14.3+& 3& *1)/

."1. :'+7%4# 1&) /%6/.1&.38# 4"1&2# '#913&/ "32"() 43'4%9/4'36#7] >!"# %/#' 91)

/.3(( 6# 41%2". *3."3& ."# .'1: +0 '#:'#/#&.1.3+&;? P^

Q+' !"#$%&$'() +",)-% - ."# /4# +0 2(+61( /%::() 4"13&/- (+23/.341( :'+4#//#/-

/+0.*1'# 4+&.'+( 1&7 (16+%' 4+&73.3+&/ 4+9:'3/# ."# 4#&.'1( #(#9#&./ 1'+%&7 *"34"

:(1) %&0+(7/; V+* ."3/ #&/#96(# +0 '#(1.3+&/ *3(( /#'8# 1/ ."# 614,7'+: 0+' :(1)


10/24


11/24


G AMING THE LOGISTICAL CITY

I& 91&) '#/:#4./ ."# (+23/.341( 3&7%/.'3#/ ."1. 7'38# /%::() 4"13& 41:3.1(3/9 1('#17)

:'#/#&. ."#9/#(8#/ 1/ 1 219# .+ ."# 93((3+&/ *"+ *+', 3& .'1&/:+'.-

4+99%&341.3+&/- *1'#"+%/3&2- :'+4%'#9#&. 1&7 :+'./f1(( +0 *"34" 4+9:'3/# ."#

,#) 3&0'1/.'%4.%'1( /3.#/ +0 ."# (+23/.341( 43.); !"# (+23/.341( 43.) 3/ 1 43.) +0

:#'3:"#'3#/; !"#/# :#'3:"#'3#/ 1'# +44%:3#7 6) 3&.#'9+71( .'1&/:+'. .#'93&1(/-

*1'#"+%/#/- I! 3&0'1/.'%4.%'#- 4+&.13' :1',/ 1&7 /"3::3&2 :+'./; N%4" (+23/.341(

0143(3.3#/ 7+ &+. /.1&7 3/+(1.#7- +0 4+%'/#- 6%. 1'# 3&.#'/:#'/#7 *3." /%6%'6/- 2'##&

6#(./- '+17/- '13(*1)/- *1.#' /)/.#9/ 1&7 61''#& (1&7; !"# 3&.#'4+&.3+& +0

:#'3:"#'3#/ +& 1 .'1&/&1.3+&1( /41(# 91,#/ %: 1 /:#431( ,3&7 +0 2(+61(3.)- 3& *"34"

."# 4+9:(#M .*+', +0 73/.'36%.3+& /)/.#9/f'+17/- '13(- /"3::3&2- 1831.3+&f

91,#/ 4+&4'#.# ."# +."#'*3/# 9)/.#'3+%/ 16/.'14.3+&/ +0 41:3.1(3/. +:#'1.3+&/; m#.

0+' 1(( ."3/ 91.#'31(3.)- ."# (+23/.341( 43.) 2+#/ (1'2#() %&&+.34#7 3& ."# 9#.'+:+(3.1&

39123&1') :'#43/#() 6#41%/# ."# 91'23&/ +0 43.3#/ .#&7 .+ 6# +8#'(++,#7 1&7 917#

3&83/36(# 6) 9+'# /:#4.14%(1' #(#9#&./f9123/.#'31( 0#1./ +0 1'4"3.#4.%'#- "1'6+%'

83#*/- 4%(.%'1( 0#/.381(/ 1&7 /+ 0+'."; J# (+&2 12+ '#/32 +%'/#(8#/ .+ &+. #73&2

.+ ,&+* "+* ."3&2/ *+', +' *"#'# ."3&2/ 4+9# 0'+9; S&7 *# 1'# 3& &+ '%/" 0+' 1

'#93&7#'; !"# (+23/.341( 43.) .34,/ 1(+&2 3& ."# 614,2'+%&7 1/ *# 2#. +& *3." +%'

6%/) 713() (38#/;J"3(# ."# (+23/.341( 43.) .'18#'/#/ ."# +%./,3'./ +0 %'61& /:14#/- 3. 3/ &+.

/%6%'61& ;6, %6 /3&4# 3. 3/ /.(#7 6#.*##& 1&7 6#)+&7 '#/37#&.31( 5+/; !"#

(+23/.341( 43.) 3/ 73/.3&4. 0'+9 ."# 2(+61( 43.)- *"34" 3/ 4"1'14.#'3/#7 6) 03&1&431(

/#'834#/ (+41.#7 3& AK


12/24


(+23/.341( 43.) 41& 6# %&7#'/.++7 1/ /+9#."3&2 1,3& .+ *"1. D+6 H3.4"3& 1&7 \1'.3&

4+7#_/:14#? 3& *"34" >/+0.*1'# 1&7 ."# /:1.31(3.) +0 #8#')71) (30# 6#4+9#

9%.%1(() 4+&/.3.%.#7?;RT I& 7#8#(+:3&2 !"#$%&$'() +",)-% +%' 3&.#'#/. 3& ."# 7323.1(

4+73&2 +0 /:14# 3/ 9+'# /:#430341(() 1'+%&7 "+* (16+%' 3/ 91&12#7 1&7 "+*

/%6G#4.383.3#/ 1'# :'+7%4#7 *"#& ."# .39# +0 (30# 1&7 14.3+& +0 6+73#/ 3/ 3&4'#1/3&2()

+8#'/##& 1&7 '#2%(1.#7 6) 4+9:%.1.3+&1( /)/.#9/ +0 4+&.'+( 1&7 '#2%(1.3+&;

!"3'.) )#1'/ 12+ ."# OS N4"++( +0 i'61&3/9f1 (++/# 4+((#4.3+& +0 :(1&'/-

2#+2'1:"#'/- /+43+(+23/./ 1&7 "3/.+'31&/f37#&.303#7 91&) +0 ."# 0#1.%'#/ +0 ."#

(+23/.341( 43.) G%/. 7#/4'36#7- #/:#431(() >."# #9#'2#&4# +0 3&0+'91.3+&=12# n#72#

43.3#/o- 1&7 ."# "):#'9+63(3.) +0 3&.#'&1.3+&1( 41:3.1( 1&7 (16+' 0(+*/?- 1/ '#4+%&.#7

6) N.#8#& B'3# 3& "3/ 6++, 2)"?()$I$3# !J8J> 4,(-6B K37,(%&,9'&9,6 (3- C6#$"3()

=6D6)";/63& ;RU !"# (+23/.341( 43.) #'."#(#// /.1&7/ +%. 1/ 1 * %'61& 0+'9 0+'

."# *1)/ 3& *"34" 3. /.3.4"#/ .+2#."#' 738#'/# 43.3#/ 1&7 '#23+&/ 14'+// ."# 2(+61(

&+'." 1&7 /+%."- 4+&.3&%+%/() '#4+&032%'3&2 4+&.3+&/ 144+'73&2 .+ G%/.=3&=.39#

7#91&7/ +0 /%::() 4"13&/ 1&7 4+&.3&2#&43#/ ."1. 73/'%:. ."#3' /9++." +:#'1.3+&;

J"##' 1 * 7312'19 +0 '#(1.3+&/ 3/ /#. 3&.+ :(1)- 1 * (+23/.341( *+'(7 3/

4'#1.#7 3& *"34" 7300#'#&4# 9%/. #3."#' 6# 73/:(14#7 +' 16/+'6#7; !"3/ /:1.3+=

.#9:+'1( #(1/.343.) 1&7 41:143.) .+ 171:. .+ 4"1&23&2 4+&73.3+&/ 3/ :#'"1:/ *"1.

91',/ ."# (+23/.341( 43.) 1/ :1'.34%(1'() 73/.3&4. 0'+9 +."#' %'61& 0+'9/; S(*1)/

/#1'4"3&2 0+' #&"1&4#7 #00343#&43#/ 14'+// 3./ 43'4%3./ +0 73/.'36%.3+&- ."# (+23/.341(

43.) 3/ 1& %'61& (16+'1.+') '3:# 3& #M:#'39#&.1.3+&;

!"# (+23/.341( 43.) 41& 1(/+ 6# %&7#'/.++7 3& .#'9/ +0 *"1. 1'4"3.#4. D#3&"+(7

\1'.3& 41((/ 1& >+'21&351.3+&1( 4+9:(#M?- *"34" 4+&/3/./ +0 .#4"&+4'1.34 1&7

1#/."#.34 /)/.#9/ 7#/32 .+ 9+7%(1.# ."# *+'(7 1/ >1& +'21&35#7- 3&0+'91.34

:1..#'&? 3& 0(#M36(# *1)/;RY d+. 4+&/.'13 6) /+8#'#32& '%(# +' &1.3+&1( 6+'7#'/-

."# (+23/.341( 43.) 3/ 1 '#4+963&1.+') 0+'9 ."1. 1..#9:./ .+ /.1&71'73/# 41:3.1(

144%9%(1.3+& 0'+9 ."# 934'+ (#8#( +0 1(2+'3."934 1::1'1.%/#/ .+ ."# 914'+ (#8#( +02(+61( 3&0'1/.'%4.%'#/; N.1&71'7/ 1'# 4'%431( .+ ."# %&38#'/1( (+234 +0 3&.#'+:#'163(3.)

14'+// /+0.*1'# :(1.0+'9/ 1&7 3&0'1/.'%4.%'1( 4+9:+&./; J3."+%. ."#9- 41'2+

4+&.13'/ 4+%(7 &+. .'1&/0#' *3." /%4" #1/# 0'+9 /"3: .+ .'%4,- /+0.*1'# +:#'1.3&2

/)/.#9/ 4+%(7 &+. #M4"1&2# 71.1 14'+// :(1.0+'9/- 1&7 43'4%3. 6+1'7/ 4+%(7 &+. 6#

91&%014.%'#7 .+ 03. 1&7 0%&4.3+& 3& 9%(.3:(# 4+9:%.1.3+&1( 7#834#/;


13/24


J"+#8#' /#./ ."# /.1&71'7 '%(#/ ."# *+'(7; m#. /.1&71'7/ 4"1&2# 1&7 7#8#(+:

+8#' .39#; d#* /.1&71'7/ 1'# 1(*1)/ 6#3&2 #/.16(3/"#7- ."+%2" +&() /+9# :#'4+(1.#

.+ ."# .+: 1&7 6#4+9# %&38#'/1(() 17+:.#7; !"3/ 3/ *"#'# 3&&+81.3+& 9##./ :+(3.341(

#4+&+9); !"# 7#/3'# 0+' 1 .'1&/=/41(1' /9++." *+'(7- "+*#8#'- 3/ 144+9:1&3#7 6)

1&) &%96#' +0 4+&.3&2#&43#/] (16+%' /.'3,#/- /+0.*1'# 2(3.4"#/- 3&8#&.+') 6(+*+%./

1&7 .'10034 2'37(+4,- .+ 9#&.3+& G%/. 1 0#* ."1. 4+9# .+ 93&7; I& :'3&43:(#- ."#

.+:+(+2341( :1'19#.#' +0 >01%(. .+(#'1&4#? 3&4+':+'1.#/ /%4" 73/'%:.3+&/ .+ 91,#

1* ."# /#19(#//// +0 (+23/.341( *+'(7/; K%. ."#'# 41& 6# &+ 7#&)3&2 ."1.

4+&.3&2#&4) 3/ ."# &32".91'# +0 (+23/.34/;

O+23/.341( &32".91'#/ 41& 6# 0+%&7 14'+// ."# 43.3#/ 3&8#/.321.#7 3& ."# !'1&/3.

O16+%' :'+G#4.- *"34" #M193 "+* 43'4%3./ +0 (16+%' 1'# '#/"1:3&2 ."# 4+&.+%'/ +0

'#23+&/ *"3(# 4+93&2 %: 1213&/.- .#/.3&2 1&7 .'1&/0+'93&2 1 9%(.3:(343.) +0 6+'7#'/;

D1G1'"1. d#* !+*& 3/ 1 7#8#(+:9#&. %&7#'*1) /3&4# ."# (1.# @bbc/ +& ."# &+'."=

#1/. 0'3&2#/ +0 H+(,1.1- /3.%1.#7 6#.*##& ."# 13':+'. 1&7 +& ."# #72# +0 N#4.+' p- 1&

I! :1', 7#8#(+:#7 3& ."# @b[c/ 1/ 1& 3&7%/.'31( #M.#&/3+& +0 H+(,1.1?/ N1(. O1,#

.+*&/"3:; !"# 2+8#'&9#&. (#23/(1.3+& ."1. 1%."+'3/#7 6+." ."#/# 7#8#(+:9#&./ 3/

4+9:(#M 1&7 0'1%2". *3." :+(3.341( 4+&0(34./ 1&7 /+431( .#&/3+&/; A"3#0 19+&2 ."#/#

*1/ ."# J#/. K#&21( V+%/3&2 I&0'1/.'%4.%'# :'393.38# 144%9%(1.3+&?- +' *"1. 144%9%(1.3+& 6) 73/:+//#//3+&?; R[ I& ."# 41/# +0 D1G1'"1.- ."# #M:'+:'31.3+&+0 (1&7 1&7 ."# :1'.31( '#9+63(3/1.3+& +0 :#1/1&. (16+%' 0+'4#7 6) VI/#'834# 83((12#/? 1'# ."# 4+&73.3+&/ +0 :+//363(3.) 0+' ."# (+23/.341( 43.) 1&7 3./

3&0+'91.3+& #4+&+9);

Q+((+*3&2 1& 3&3.31( /%'2# *"34" /1* ."# 3&/.1(9#&. +0 036'#=+:.34 416(# 1&7 1

/,#(#.1( '+17 /)/.#9- 1 &%96#' +0 3&.#'&1.3+&1( 1&7 &1.3+&1( I! 03'9/ +:# 0+'

6%/3// 3& D1G1'"1.- 3&4(%73&2 J3:'+- S44#&.%'#- i&3.#4"- IK\ 1&7 !1.1 A+&/%(.1&4)


14/24


N#'834#/; L'17%1.#/ +0 4+9:%.3&2 1&7 I! :'+2'19/ *+',3&2 3& ."#/# 03'9/ 1'#

(1'2#() %&7#'.1,3&2 6#.1=.#/.3&2 +0 * /+0.*1'# +' 6%/3// :'+4#// +%./+%'43&2

CKEZF *+',- 7+3&2 61/34 71.1 #&.') 1&7 144+%&.3&2 .1/,/ 0+' 03&1&431(- 9#7341( 1&7

3&/%'1&4# 4+9:1&3#/ 61/#7 3& B%'+:# 1&7 d+'." S9#'341; I. 3/ *+'." &+.3&2 ."1. 1

(+23/.341( 43.) (3,# D1G1'"1. '#23/.#'/ 1& %#& 2#+2'1:") +0 3&0+'91.3+& ."1. 2+#/

+ /.#: 6#)+&7 ."# 3&.#'&1.3+&1( 7383/3+& +0 (16+%' '%&&3&2 1(+&2 ."# 2(+61( &+'."

1&7 /+%." 1M3/; \+/. +0 ."# I!='#(1.#7 *+', 3& D1G1'"1.- 1/ *#(( 1/ N#4.+' p- 3/ 1

/#4+&71') 0+'9 +0 +%./+%'43&2 3&.#'&1( .+ ."# &1.3+& /.1.#; E1'#&. 03'9/ 61/#7 3&

\%9613- A"#&&13- K1&21(+'# 1&7 V)7#'1617 %&7#'.1,# ."# 9+'# 3&.#'#/.3&2

'#/#1'4" 1&7 7#8#(+:9#&. 1&7 91&12#9#&.='#(1.#7 *+',- *"3(# I! *+',#'/ *3."

/393(1' X%1(30341.3+&/ 1'# (%9:#7 *3." 9#&31( 3&0+'91.34 .1/,/;

J3." I&731?/ #(#81.3+& 3& ."#/# /+'./ +0 "32"=/,3(( /#4.+'/ +0 ."# 3&0+'91.3+&

#4+&+9)- 3. 3/ "1'7 &+. .+ 1//%9# 1 /%6/.1&.31( (+// +0 /393(1' G+6/ 3& ."# 2(+61(

&+'." 144+9:1&)3&2 0+'9/ +0 +%./+%'43&2 3&.#'&1( .+ ."# /:14# +0 ."# &1.3+& *3."3&

I&731; I& S%/.'1(31 3& Pc@R- *# "18# "#1'7 9%4" 16+%. "+* ."# 1831.3+& 1&7 03&1&4#

3&7%/.'3#/ 1'# 1(/+ :(1&&3&2 .+ +%./+%'4# 71.1=#&.') 1&7 2#'1( /#'834#='#(1.#7

*+',; J"#."#' 3. 3/ +& 1 2(+61( +' &1.3+&1( /41(#- ."# ,#) 7'38#' 6#"3&7 ."#/#

7#43/3+&/ 3/- +0 4+%'/#- ."# (+*#' 4+/. +0 (16+%' 4+%:(#7 *3." 4"#1:#' (1&7 (#1/#/ 0+'

I! /#'834# 03'9/ (+41.#7 +& ."# :#'3:"#'3#/; S&7 ."3/ 3/ *"#'# (+23/.341( 43.3#/ /%4" 1/

D1G1'"1. 03&7 ."#3' '1.3+&1(# 0+' #M3/.#&4#; N3&4# Pcc^- "+*#8#'- ."# '1.# +0

7#8#(+:9#&. 3& D1G1'"1. "1/ /(+*#7 4+&/37#'16() 6#41%/# +0 ."# 2(+61( 03&1&431(

4'3/3/; E1'.31(() 6%3(. 1:1'.9#&. .+*#'/ /.1&7 3/+(1.#7 1213&/. 1 614,7'+: +0 &+* 1'37

(1&7 7+..#7 *3." /%'8#)+'?/ :#2/ 1&7 ."# +441/3+&1( 2'153&2 41..(#; \1&) +0 ."#

4+9:(#.# '#/37#&.31( 4+9:(#M#/ '#913& #9:.) 1/ 3&8#/.9#&. +*'/ 1'# (+41.#7 3&

+."#' I&731& 43.3#/ +' (38# +8#'/#1/; S &%96#' +0 I! 03'9/ 1'# +:#'1.3&2- 6%. ."#3'

*+',#'/ +0.#& 4+99%.# 0'+9 #(/#*"#'# 3& H+(,1.1- 1/ 7+ 91&) +0 ."# +*'/ +0 ."#

91,#/"30. .#1"+%/#/ 1&7 #1.#'3#/ /#'8343&2 ."# I! *+',#'/ 7%'3&2 ."#3' 6'#1,/; S/I/"3.1


15/24


/16+.12#- /+431( %&'#/. 1&7 :+(3.341( 4+&0(34.; d+. +&() 3/ ."# (+23/.341( 43.) 73/.1&.

0'+9 9#.'+:+(3.1& 39123&1'3#/- 3. /%00#'/ ."# 3&.'%/3+& +0 91.#'31(3.) 3& *1)/ ."1.

%&/#..(# ."# 16/.'14.3+& +0 3&0+'91.3+&;

!"# (+23/.341( 43.) 3/ 1(/+ 1. ."# 4%..3&2 #72# +0 (16+%' '#0+'9; !#4"&+(+23#/ +0

1%.+91.3+& 1'# .'1&/0+'93&2 /"3::3&2 :+'./ 14'+// S%/.'1(31 1&7 #(/#*"#'# 3& ."#

*+'(7- /"30.3&2 ."# *+', +0 *"1'03#/ 0'+9 ."# 7+4,/37# .+ ."# /4'##& *"#'# ."#

+8#'/32". +0 '+6+.34 +:#'1.3+&/ 3/ 7%:(341.#7 6) "%91& (16+%' 4(34,3&2 ."'+%2" ."#

3&.#'014# +0 /+0.*1'# 1::(341.3+&/; J"#."#' 914"3 +' 0(#/"- :#'0+'91&4#

3&7341.+'/ 1'# 03() 41(36'1.#7 1213&/. .39# 1&7 8+(%9#; !"# (+23/.341( 43.) 7+#/

1*1) *3." ."# 63+(+2341( 1&7 /+431( '")."9/ +0 %'61& (30# /+ 6#(+8#7 6) V#&'3

O#0#68'#- 1&7 3&/.#17 +:#'1.#/ 6) ."# 4+(7 /*+'7 +0 4+7# ."1. 9#1/%'#/ :'+7%4.383.)

1&7 *+'." 3& '#1(=.39#; Rb !"# (+23/.341( 43.) 3/ 41%2". 6#.*##& #M:#73#&4) 1&7

4+&.3&2#&4); !"# 914"3 7'#19 +0 16/+(%.# #00343#&4) '%&/ 4+%&.#' .+ ."#

%&'%(3// +0 (16+%' 1&7 (30#; !"# #(1/.343.) +0 (+23/.341( .39# 1&7 /:14# 9%/.

#'."#(#// 4+&.#&7 *3." ."# 91.#'31(3.3#/ +0 /+43#.) 1&7 :(14#- :1'.34(#/ 1&7

:+*#'; B8#& 30 ."# (+23/.341( 43.) 4+%(7 +8#'4+9# ."# :'+.+4+(+2341( 1/)99#.'3#/

14'+// /+0.*1'# :(1.0+'9/ ."1. :'#8#&. 4'+//=/#4.+' 1&7 2(+61( 3&.#'+:#'163(3.)- 3.

4+%(7 #' #&.3'#() #'17341.# ."# 4+&/.3.%#&. :+*#' +0 '#0%/1(; !"# (+23/.341( 43.) 3/

4+(7- 1&7 *3."+%. #9:(+)9#&.; !"# *+', "1/ 6##& 7+- #(/#*"#'#- /+9#.39#/

"%&7'#7/ 30 &+. ."+%/1&7/ +0 ,3(+9#.'#/ 1*1);

L OGISTICAL TIME , OR , CALCULATIONS OF PERFORMANCE

O+23/.34/ '+6/ (383&2 (16+%' +0 .39#; S. ."# (#8#( +0 (16+%' 91&12#9#&.- (+23/.34/

'#23/.#'/ ."# 41(4%(1.3+& +0 .39# 1213&/. ."# :#'0+'91&4# +0 .1/,/ 1&7 9+8#9#&. +0

."3&2/; !"3/ 3/ *"#'# \1'4#( \1%//?/ .#4"&3X%#/ +0 ."# 6+7) 1&7 '#(1.#7 #1'()

.*#&.3#."=4#&.%') /.%73#/ 3& 6+7)=9+.3+& 1&7 ."#3' .#4"&+(+23#/ +0 41:.%'#

C:'3&43:1(() ."# 4"'+&+:"+.+2'1:") +0 B.3#&=l%(#/ \1'#)F :'+837# ."#:'#4+&73.3+&/ 0+' (16+%' #00343#&43#/f+' *"1. S&/+& D163&14" .#'9/ 1

>:")/3+2&+9) +0 (16+%' :+*#'?f3& 3&7%/.'31( 1&7- (1.#'- 3&0+'91.3+&1( 91',#.

#4+&+93#/; Tc \+'# '#4#&.()- l+&1."1& A'1') "1/ 7312&+/#7 ."# >3&G%'3&2 +0 /(##:? 6)

."# '1:143+%/ 0+'4# +0 41:3.1(3/9; T@ !"# PT_[ G%/.=3&=.39#- 0(#M36(# 9+7# +0 41:3.1(

144%9%(1.3+& 4'3.3X%#7 6) A'1') 3/ 4+3&437#&. *3." ."# '#1(=.39# '#239# +0 (+23/.34/

91&12#7 ."'+%2" BDE /+0.*1'# 3&.#'014#/; V+* 7+#/ + :(1) 1213&/. ."# 1((=


16/24


:#'81/38# .#9:+'1(3.) +0 (+23/.341( '#239#/W S&7 .+ '#41/. A'1')- "+* 7+#/ ."#

/+43#.) +0 (383&2 (16+%' :'+.#4. 1&7 7#0#&7 3./#(0 *"#& (+23/.341( .39# #M.#'&1(3/#/

>."# 3&73837%1( 3&.+ 1 /3.# +0 &+&=/.+: /4'%.3&) 1&7 '#2%(1.3+&?WTP J3."3& ."# /:14# +0

*1'#"+%/#/ 1&7 .'1&/:+'. 3&7%/.'3#/- ."# 9+8#9#&. +0 *+',#'/ 3/ 3&4'#1/3&2()

'#2%(1.#7 6) 2(+61( :+/3.3+&3&2 /)/.#9 CLENF 8#"34(# .'14,3&2- '173+=0'#X%#&4)

37#&.30341.3+& .12/ ."1. :'+03(# *+',#'/ *3."3& 71.161/# .39# 1&7 8+34#=73'#4.#7

+'7#' :34,3&2 .#4"&+(+23#/ >."1. 91&12# ."# :1//12# 1&7 :14# +0 *+',#'/ ."'+%2"

."# *+',:(14# *3." ."# 139 +0 91M393/3&2 #00343#&43#/?; TR !"# 1%.+91.#7

4++'73&1.3+& 1&7 4+&.'+( +0 *+',#'/ '#/%(./ 3& "32"#' (#8#(/ +0 :'+7%4.383.)

144+9:1&3#7 6) 3&4'#1/#7 7#91&7/ 1&7 :'#//%'#/ %:+& ."# (16+%'3&2 6+7); N%4"

.#4"&+(+23#/ +0 2+8#'&1&4# 4+''#/:+&7 *3." ."# '3/# +0 *"1. I *+%(7 .#'9

>3&0+'91.3/#7 /+8#'#32&.)?- *"34" .1,#/ +& :1'.34%(1' "%#/ 3& (+23/.341( .#4"&3X%#/

1//+431.#7 *3." .'1&/:+'.1.3+& 3&7%/.'3#/; A+7# 3/ H3&2;

BDE 71.161/#/ 1'# /.1&71'7 :(1.0+'9/ %/#7 *3."3& (+23/.34/ 3& 4+963&1.3+&

*3." 4%/.+93/#7 /+0.*1'# 1::(341.3+&/ .+ 91&12# 2(+61( /%::() 4"13&/-

+'21&3/1.3+&1( 4+&73.3+&/ 1&7 (16+%' #00343#&43#/; HEI/ 1'# /+0.*1'# 3&.#'014#/ 6%3(.

3&.+ BDE 71.161/#/ .+ 9#1/%'# *+',#' 1&7 +'21&3/1.3+&1( #00343#&43#/- 9##.3&2 +0

.1'2#. X%+.1/- 03&1&431( :#'0+'91&4#- '#1(=.39# /.1.%/ +0 2(+61( /%::() 4"13&/- 1&7

."# 41:143.) +0 ."# +'21&3/1.3+& .+ 171:. .+ 4"1&23&2 43'4%9/.1&4#/; !"#/# 1'# 1((

X%1&.3.1.38# 3&7341.+'/ ."1. '#23/.#' :#'0+'91&4# *3." 1 &%9#'341( 81(%#- "+*#8#'-

1&7 1'# &+. 16(# .+ 144+99+71.# 9+'# 3991.#'31( 014.+'/ /%4" 1/ 1 *+',#'?/

0##(3&2/ 1&7 (#8#( +0 9+.381.3+& 1&7 #&."%/31/9; I. *+%(7 /##9 (+23/.34/ /+0.*1'# 3/

/.3(( .+ 177'#// ."# 63+(+2341( /:#4.'%9 /:#431( .+ ."# /:#43#/=6#3&2 +0 "%91& (30#;

m#.- 3& 1&+."#' /#&/#- /%4" 3991.#'31(3.3#/ +0 (16+%' 1&7 (30# 1'# 4+7#7 3&.+ ."#

X%1&.3.1.38# :1'19#.#'/ +0 HEI/ ."'+%2" ."# 6'%.# 0+'4# +0 3&/.'%9#&.1(3.) +'

41(4%(1.3+&] &+ 91..#' "+* 1 *+',#' 932". 0##(- X%+.1/ "18# .+ 6# 9#. 1&7 2(+61(

/%::() 4"13&/ 9%/. &+. 6# 178#'/#() 100#4.#7;!"# 4+7#7 91.#'31(3.) +0 0%(03((3&2 :#'0+'91&4# X%+.1/ 1&7 #&/%'3&2 ."# /9++."

+:#'1.3+& +0 /%::() 4"13&/ /%6/3/./ *3."3& 3./ +*& %&38#'/# +0 1%.+=1003'91.3+&; !"#

'#(1.3+&/"3: 6#.*##& (+23/.34/ /+0.*1'# 1&7 /#(0='#2%(1.3+& 6) *+',#'/ 1//%9#/

4(+/%'# 3& ."# 43'4%3. +0 2+8#'&1&4#; S& +:#'1.+' *+',3&2 3& ."# (+23/.34/ +0 * 1&7

/#4+&7="1&7 #X%3:9#&. .'1&/:+'.1.3+& 0+' 1 N"1&2"13=61/#7 iN 1%.+9+.38#

4+9:1&) :%. 3. ."3/ *1)] >S/ :#' +%' 6'+,#'?/ 91&12#9#&. #M:#'3#&4#- #8#') /.100 3/


17/24


.'13 .+ %/# ."#3' 3&.#'&1( BDE /+0.*1'# .+ '#0(#4. #8#') 9+8#9#&. +0 ."#3' *+',;

\+'#+8#'- ."# 71.1 0'+9 BDE /+0.*1'# 3/ 1(/+ %/#7 1/ 1 .++( +' HEI .+ #81(%1.# /.100?/

:#'0+'91&4#- ."%/ 91,3&2 ."#9 *+', 9+'# #00343#&.();? TT !"3/ '#17) 3&4%(41.3+& +0

6+." 73/43:(3&1') :'14.34#/ 1&7 ."# (+234 +0 4+&.'+( *3."3& ."# +'21&3/1.3+&1( 4%(.%'#

+0 ."# 4+9:1&) 1&7 3./ *+',#'/ 3/ X%3.# 4+&0'+&.3&2; A#'.13&()- ."# 91&12#'31(

4%(.%'# +0 %&38#'/3.3#/ "1/ 9+'# ."1& 3./ /"1'# +0 *"14,) 14'+&)9/ ."1. 4+&/.3.%.# 1

* :(1.1') 2'1991' 4+#M.#&/38# *3." ."# 2+8#'&1&4# +0 (16+%'; S&7 ."# 6351''#

3&.#':#((1.3+& +0 1417#934/ 3&.+ ."# :/#%7+=4+':+'1.# 1%73. '#239#/ :'#7341.#7 +&

:#'0+'91&4# +%.4+9#/ 1&7 144+%&.163(3.) 9#1/%'#/ :'#/#&./ /+9# &+8#( .#''13& 0+'

."#+'3#/ +0 /%6G#4.383.) 1&7 7#/3'#; !"# 3&7%/.') +0 (+23/.34/ 0%'."#' 19:(303#/ /%4"

63+:+(3.341( .#4"&+(+23#/- *"#'# ."# (16+%' 4+&.'+( '#239# 3/ :'+2'199#7 3&.+ ."#

(+23/.34/ 4"13& 1. ."# (#8#( +0 4+7#; S >/.1&71'7 +:#'1.3+& :'+4#7%'#? CNZEF 3/

3&4+':+'1.#7 3&.+ ."# HEI +0 *+',#'/; TU !"# NZE 7#/4'36#/ ."# /.1.%/ +0 /:#43034 G+6-

738373&2 3. >3&.+ 9#1/%'16(# 4+&.'+( :+3&./?; \) 3&0+'91&. 3& N"1&2"13 :'+837#7 ."3/

#M19:(#] >Q+' 3&/.1&4#- *# *+%(7 /#. NZE .+ +%' 6'+,#'- *"34" 91) '#X%3'# ."#9 .+

03&3/" 4%/.+9 4(#1'1&4# +0 1 &+'91( /"3:9#&. *3."3& ."'## *+',3&2 71)/- 30 ."#) 013(

.+ "3. 3.- ."#3' HEI *3(( 6# 3&0(%#&4#7 1&7 ."%/ 3&0(%#&4# ."#3' :1)9#&.;?TY

!"#'# 3/ 1 /#&/# "#'# +0 "+* (+23/.34/ /+0.*1'# 3&.#'&1(3/#/ ."# 9+8#9#&. +0

(16+%' 1/ ."# 0%(03((9#&. +0 1//32 .1/,/ +8#' 1 /#. :#'3+7 +0 .39#; !"3/ /+'. +0

(16+%' :#'0+'91&4# 9#1/%'# 3/ '#:'+7%4#7 14'+// 91&) *+',:(14# /#..3&2/; J"1.

91,#/ 3. &+.#*+'.") "#'# 3/ "+* ."# 2+8#'&1&4# +0 (16+%' 3/ 3&0+'91.3/#7 3& /%4" 1

*1) ."1. ."# 6+'7#' 6#.*##& %&7#'.1,3&2 1 .1/, 1&7 '#:+'.3&2 3./ 4+9:(#.3+& "1/

6#4+9# 4(+/#7 +' 3&73/.3&4.; O16+%' 1&7 :#'0+'91.383.) 1'# 41:.%'#7 3& ."# '#1(=.39#

1(2+'3."9/ +0 4+7#; J3." ."# '3/# +0 3&0+'91.3/#7 /+8#'#32&.)- 63+:+(3.341( 4+&.'+( 3/

3991&. .+ ."# .39# +0 (383&2 (16+%' 1&7 (16+%'=:+*#'; T[ !"#'# 3/ &+ (+&2#' 1

.#9:+'1( 7#(1) 6#.*##& ."# #M#4%.3+& +0 7%.3#/ 1&7 ."#3' /.1.3/.341( 9#1/%'#; !"#

0+((+*3&2 144+%&. 7#/4'36#/ ."# %/# +0 BDE /+0.*1'# .+ #81(%1.# ."# HEI/ +0 *+',#'/]B14" #9:(+)## 3/ 1/,#7 .+ 91', 3. 3& ."# BDE /)/.#9 *"#& ."#) 03&3/"

."#3' '#X%3'#7 *+',; !"#'# 1'# .*+ 1781&.12#/ 0+' 3.] @F I0 ."#) 013( .+ 03&3/"

."# (+23/.34/ 14.383.) *3."3& NZE .39#- ."#) 4"#4, 3& ."# BDE /)/.#9 .+ 03&7

*"34" #9:(+)## 737 &+. 4+9:(#.# "3/_"#' .39# 144+'73&2 .+ NZE- *"34"

"#(: 9#1/%'# #9:(+)##?/ :#'0+'91&4#; PF B8#') #9:(+)## 4+%(7 .'14, 3&

."# BDE /)/.#9 .+ ,&+* 16+%. ."# 4%''#&. /.1.%/_9+8#9#&. +0 ."#


18/24


(+23/.34/ 14.383.3#/; I& /"+'.- BDE /+0.*1'# 83/%1(35#/ ."# 9+8#9#&. +0

(+23/.34/ 14.383.3#/ 6) #00+'./ +0 #8#') (3&, 3& ."# (+23/.34/ 4"13&; T^

I0 BDE /+0.*1'# *#'# 1 219# 3&.#'014#- + 4+%&.#'=4"1((#&2# 0+' ."# *+',#'=1/=

:(1)#' *+%(7 6# .+ /4+'# 1213&/. .39#=61/#7 :#'0+'91&4# 9#1/%'#/ 1&7 ."#

83/363(3.) +0 9+8#9#&.; K%. 1/ &+.#7 #1'(3#'- BDE /+0.*1'# 3/ 1 X%1&.3.1.38# /)/.#9-

1&7 1/ 1 4(+/#7 4)6#'.34 9+7#( 3. '#0%/#/ ."# 0##7614, +' &+3/# +0 9+'# 3991.#'31(

0+'4#/ /%4" 1/ *+',#'?/ 1..3.%7#/- 0##(3&2/ 1&7 (#8#(/ +0 9+.381.3+& ."1. *+%(7 "18#

73/'%:.38# #00#4./; Tb S(."+%2" 1 9+'# /+:"3/.341.#7 /+0.*1'# #&83'+&9#&. *+%(7

41(4%(1.# 3& /%4" 81'316(#/ :'#43/#() 6#41%/# ."#3' 9+7%(1.3&2 :+*#' +:#'1.#/ 3& 1

'#:(#&3/"3&2 *1)- /%4" 3/ ."# :1'1/3.341( (+234 +0 41:3.1( 1&7 ."# +'21&34 /"-9%

";6,(3-$ +0 (30#; S/ 3. /.1&7/- ."# 9#.1:"+' +0 2(+61( /%::() 4"13&/ /32&1(/ 1 .+.1(3/3&2

83/3+& 3& *"34" #8#')."3&2 41& 6# 144+%&.#7 0+'- 9#1/%'#7 1&7 1/4'36#7 1&

#4+&+934 81(%#; m#. 1/ N1&7'+ \#5517'1 1&7 K'#.. d#3(/+& &+.# 3& ."#3' '#4#&.()

:%6(3/"#7 6++,- F",-6, (% A6&5"- - >."# &+.3+& +0 ."# 4"13&- ."+%2" 3. 41''3#/ 1 /#&/#

+0 (321.%'# +' 6+&712# ."1. /"+%(7 &+. 6# 73/4+%&.#7 +' 7393&3/"#7- /%22#/./ ."#

(3&,12# +' 1'.34%(1.3+& +0 9%(.3:(# %&3./ 3&.+ 1 /3&2(# (3' /)/.#9?;Uc

I& ."# 41/# +0 (+23/.34/- ."#'# 3/ 1& 3&/.3.%.3+&1(- 73/4%'/38# 1&7 :+(3.341(=

#4+&+934 3&8#/.9#&. 3& /#4%'3.3/1.3+& 1&7 '3/, 1//#//9#&. ."1. %&7#'/4+'#/ ."#

#7 0+' /%4" (3' /)/.#9/ +0 4+&.'+(; O3'3.) 1&7 4(+/%'# 1'# 1(*1)/ 2+3&2 .+ 6#

."# %&7+3&2 0+' 1 /)/.#9 ."1. '#/./ +& /.1/3/- 4+&/3/.#&4) 1&7 4+&.'+( *3."+%.

3&4+':+'1.3&2 4+&.3&2#&4) 1&7 4+9:(#M3.) ."1. 7#03 ."# >01'=0'+9=#X%3(36'3%9?

4+&73.3+&/ +0 (30#=*+'(7/ 1/ %&7#'/.++7 3& 9+'# 1781&4#7 4)6#'.34/; U@ S/ *# "18#

6##& '#93&7#7 3& 4+%&.(#// */ 9#731 '#:+'./ +& ."# 2(+61( 03&1&431( 4'3/3/- 1((

(393./ +' 013(%'#/ +0 41:3.1( :'#/#&. * +::+'.%&3.3#/ 0+' 3./ +&2+3&2 '#:'+7%4.3+&;

!"# 1(2+'3."934 93&3&2 +0 632 71.1 3/ G%/. + +0 81'3+%/ "+'35+&/ +0 14X%3/3.3+& 0+'

41:3.1( 3& 3./ .3'#(#// 9+8#9#&.; !"# #M.#&. .+ *"34" /.1&71'7/ 7#.#'93 ."#

9+63(3.) +0 :#+:(#- 03&1&4# 1&7 ."3&2/ 41& 6# '#23/.#'#7- 3& :1'.- ."'+%2" 1 /.%7) +02(+61( 3&0'1/.'%4.%'#/ +0 .'1&/:+'. 1&7 4+99%&341.3+&; \) 3&.#'#/. 3& ."3/ 1'.34(#

"1/ 6##& .+ 1/, "+* ."# 7#/32& +0 1 837#+ 219# 41& 4+&.'36%.# .+ /%4" 1&1().341(

1&7- :#'"1:/ +441/3+&1(()- :+(3.341( *+',;

!


19/24


d#7 D+//3.#' 3/ E'+0#//+' +0 A+99%&341.3+& 3& ."# I&/.3.%.# 0+' A%(.%'# 1&7 N+43#.)

1. ."# i&38#'/3.) +0 J#/.#'& N)7) 1&7 .#14"#/ 3& ."# N4"++( +0 V%91&3.3#/ 1&7

A+99%&341.3+& S'./; V# 3/ 4%''#&.() *+',3&2 +& .*+ 6++,/ #&.3.(#7 !"#$%&$'()

L$#5&/(,6%> K37,(%&,9'&9,6B ."7&E(,6B !(?"9, C0+'."4+93&2 Pc@TF 1&7 C*3." L##'.

O+83&,FM,#63& 8;5",$%/%> 456 H")$&$'% "7 L6&E",G 09)&9,6% C0+'."4+93&2 Pc@TF; V#

3/ 1(/+ 4%''#&.() *+',3&2 *3." K'#.. d#3(/+& 1&7 +."#'/ +& 1& 3&.#'&1.3+&1( :'+G#4.

#M193&3&2 ."# 39:#'31( 0+'4# +0 3&0'1/.'%4.%'#] O+23/.341( J+'(7/] I&0'1/.'%4.%'#-

N+0.*1'#- O16+%'- q"..:]__(+23/.341(*+'(7/;+'2r;

A CKNOWLEDGEMENTS

\) ."1&,/ .+ .*+ 1&+&)9+%/ '#83#*#'/ 0+' ."#3' 2#'+%/ #&212#9#&. *3." ."3/ 1'.34(#; !"#

/%22#/.3+&/ ."#) +00#'#7 0+' '#83/3+& *3(( '#/+&1.# 3& 9+'# /%/.13 *1)/ 1/ ."3/ '#/#1'4" 3/

7#8#(+:#7 0%'."#'; !"1&,/ 1(/+ .+ B/."#' \3( 1&7 S&."+&) \4A+/,#' 0+' ."#3' 3&.#'#/. 3& 1&7

:1.3#&4# *3." ."3/ :3#4#;

N OTES 1 S&&1 !/3&2- >N%::() A"13&/ 1&7 ."# V%91& A+&73.3+&?-C6&5$3G$3# A(,N$%/- 8+(; P@- &+; P- Pccb- ::;

@T^g[Y;2 !"# S%/.'1(31& D#/#1'4" A+%&43( CSDAF 0%&7#7 :'+G#4. C!'1&/3. O16+%'] A3'4%3./-

D#23+&/- K+'7#'/?- %&7#'.++, 1 4+((#4.38# /.%7) 3& N"1&2"13- H+(,1.1 1&7 N)7) +0 ."# '#(1.3+&

6#.*##& (16+%' 9+63(3.3#/ 1&7 (+23/.341( 3&7%/.'3#/; N## q"..:]__.'1&/3.(16+%';1/31r; !'14,3&2 A"3/#

39:#'31(3/9 ."'+%2" 3&0'1/.'%4.%'#- ."# :'+G#4. 4+&.3&%#/ 3./ /.%7) +0 2(+61( (+23/.34/ 3&7%/.'3#/ 3&

L'##4#- A"3(# 1&7 I&731 *3." 1 '#4#&.() 1*1'7#7 SDA


20/24


21/24


13 \1.."#* Q%((#' 1&7 S&7'#* L+00#)- :D$) A6-$( - \I! E'#//- A196'372# \S- Pc@P- ::; @RUgY;

14

Q+' 1& #M19:(# +0 /%4" 1 2(++9) #M.'1:+(1.3+& +0 4+&.#9:+'1') .'#&7/- /## l+&1."1& k3..'13&- 456

."# /#&/# 3& *"34" (+23/.34/ "1/ 14.38#() 0+'9#7 1 * .#''13& +0 :+(3.34/ +& *"34" /.'%22(#/

1'# 1&7 *3(( 4+&.3&%# .+ 6# :(1)#7 +%.?; !"3&,- 0+' 3&/.1&4#- +0 1&) &%96#' +0 (16+%' /.'%22(#/ 1'3/3&2

1(+&2 2(+61( /%::() 4"13&/- 6+'7#' 73/:%.#/ 1'+%&7 932'1.3+&- 0++7 4+&.193&1.3+&- 01%(.) 4+99+73.3#/-

4+&/%9#' 614,(1/" 1213&/. 4"3(7 *+',#'/ 1//#96(3&2 #(#4.'+&34 2++7/ +' *+',3&2 3& /#8#'# 4+&73.3+&/;

N%4" #M19:(#/ 1(( /.#9 0'+9 (+23/.341( +:#'1.3+&/; J# 4+%(7 #8#& 3&4(%7# :'3814) 7#61.#/ #9#'23&2

1'+%&7 ."# %/# +0 71.1 2#'1.#7 *3."3& *+',:(14# /#..3&2/ +' +%. +0 713() /+431( 9#731 :'14.34#/; N##


22/24


K'#.. d#3(/+&- >Q38# !"#/#/ +& i&7#'/.1&73&2 O+23/.34/ 1/ E+*#'?- =$%&$3G&$"3> .'(3-(3(D$(3 S"9,3() "7

."'$() 456",1 - 8+(; @R- &+; R- Pc@P- :; RPT;19

\1&%#( 7# O1&71- +(, $3 &56 8#6 "7 K3&6))$#63& A('5$36%- k+ K++,/- d#* m+',-@bb@- :; @cY;20

I637;- :; @cY;21

Q+' 1& 144+%&. +0 ."# '3/# +0 ."3/ :#'/+&1- /## A"'3/.+:"#' d#*03#(7- M3/(G$3# &56 H9?)$' M3$D6,%$&1>

456 A+&.3&%+%/ Q##7614,] I. \1) K# 1 K#..#' S::'+14" !"1& ."# S&&%1( D#83#*?- 4!L4> 456

F9%$36%% "7 UC- PP S%2%/. Pc@P- q"..:]__***;.(&.;4+9_Pc@P_c^_PP_4+&.3&%+%/=0##7614,=3.=91)=6#=

1=6#..#'=1::'+14"=."1&=."#=1&&%1(='#83#*_ > ;23

J3(( N#(0- >I&/#4./ 1&7 A1&1'3#/] \#731&1.%'#/ 1&7 ."# S#/."#.34/ +0 ."#

I&83/36(#?- 83#6)(G$> 456 S"9,3() "7 456",6&$'() U9/(3$&$6% - 8+(; @^- &+; @- Pc@R- ::; @c[g@@b 1&7 ."#

#73.#7 4+((#4.3+&-A6-$(3(&9,6%> 456 A(&6,$()$&1 "7 K37",/(&$"3 46'53")"#$6% (3- :)6'&,"3$' +(%&6 -

O383&2 K++,/ 16+%. O30#- Z:#& V%91&3.3#/ E'#//- Pc@@-

q"..:]__***;(383&26++,/16+%.(30#;+'2_6++,/_\#731&1.%'#/>

;26

\4H#(8#)- !3#//#& 1&7 N394+#;27

q"..:]__***;:"+/.+');+'2_r;28

N) !100#(- >N41(1' B&.1&2(#9#&. 3& :9,";6(3 S"9,3() "7 A6-$(

.&9-$6%- &+; R- N:'3&2 Pc@R- q"..:]__***;/%/=#G9/;+'2_/41(1'=#&.1&2(#9#&.=3&=7323.1(=9#731=

#4+(+23#/_r;29

!"1&,/ .+ N#1& N+0.*1'# 1&7 I7#+(+2)?- 3& 456 K3&6,7('6 :776'& - ::; UTg[[;33

Q+' + +0 ."# 0#* 4'3.341( /.%73#/ ."1. .1,#/ 1& N!N- #."&+2'1:"34 1::'+14"- /## d#3( E+((+4, 1&7

D+63& J3((319/- ."7&E(,6 (3- O,#(3$%(&$"3%> 456 F$"#,(;51 "7 &56 :3&6,;,$%6Q+$-6 .1%&6/ ",

5"E .8H 0"3X96,6- &56 +",)- - D+%.(#72#- ZM0+'7 1&7 d#* m+',- Pcc^; D#17#'/ +0 L#'91& 91) *3/" .+

4+&/%(. ."# +'21&3/1.3+& 1&7 91&12#9#&. /.%73#/ 1&1()/3/ +0 NSE 6) K'3.1 V+"(91&&- Z'21&3/1.3+&

NSE] N+531(# S%/*3',%&2#& .#4"&3/4"#' N)/.#9#- E"< ."#/3/- i&38#'/3.) +0


23/24


35 N.#8#& E; B'3#-2)"?()$I$3# !J8J> 4,(-6B K37,(%&,9'&9,6 (3- C6#$"3() =6D6)";/63& - N.1&0+'7 i&38#'/3.)

E'#//- N.1&0+'7- PccT- :; PcU;36

D#3&"+(7 \1'.3&- !"# Z'21&351.3+&1( A+9:(#M] S'4"3.#4.%'#- \#731 1&7 A+':+'1.# N:14#- \I! E'#//-

A196'372#- \S- PccR- :; @c;37

D1&163' N191771'- >D1G1'"1.- ."# i'61& C(P(,5(& (3- &56 =1%&";$( "7 M,?(3 K/(#$3(&$"3 - D+%.(#72#-

d#* .;('6B 4$/6 (3- :D6,1-(1 !$76 - .'1&/; N.%1'. B(7#& 1&7 L#'1(7 \++'#-A+&.3&%%9- O+&7+& 1&7 d#* m+',- PccT;40

D163&14"- 43.#7 3& D#3&"+(7 \1'.3&- :; @[;41

l+&1."1& A'1')- Z[W\> !(&6 0(;$&()$%/ (3- &56 :3-% "7 .)66; - p#'/+- O+&7+&- Pc@R- :; @^;42

I637;- :; RP;43

S&G1 H1&&23#/#'- >!'14,3&2 1&7 !'143&2] L#+2'1:"3#/ +0 O+23/.341( L+8#'&1&4# 1&7 O16+%'3&2

K+73#/?-:3D$,"3/63& (3- H)(33$3# => ."'$6&1 (3- .;('6 - 8+(; R@- &+; T- Pc@R- :; Yc@;44

B913( 3&.#'83#*- N"1&2"13- Rc \1) Pccb;45

N.1&71'7 +:#'1.3+& :'+4#7%'# 1(/+ '#0#'/- +0 4+%'/#- .+ ."# '+%.3 :'14.34#/ +0 .+'.%'# 17+:.#7 6)

."# iN 93(3.1')- /%::+/#7() 1/ 1 .#4"&3X%# +0 3&.#''+21.3+&; !"# /"1'#7 .#'93&+(+2) "#'# /"+%(7 4+9#1/ &+ /%':'3/#- 238#& ."# +'323&/ +0 (+23/.34/ *3."3& ."# 93(3.1')=3&7%/.'31( 4+9:(#M;46

B913( 3&.#'83#*- N"1&2"13- R@ \1) Pccb;47

N## 1(/+ !3531&1 !#''1&+81] >J"1. *# /##9 .+ "18# ."#& 3/ 7#03&3.3+& +0 1 * 63+:+(3.341( :(1 ."1.

41& 6# +'21&35#7 ."'+%2" ."# 7#:(+)9#&. +0 $//(363& '"3&,") - *"34" +:#'1.#/ 73'#4.() *3."3& ."#

:'+7%4.38# :+*#' +0 ."# 9%(.3.%7# 1&7 ."# 4(3&19#&;? L6&E",G 09)&9,6%> H")$&$'% 7", &56 K37",/(&$"3 8#6-

E(%.+- O+&7+&- PccT- :; @PP;48

B913( 3&.#'83#*- N"1&2"13- R@ \1) Pccb;49

N3&4# (+23/.34/ /+0.*1'# +:#'1.#/ 1/ 1 4(+/#7 #&83'+&9#&. ."1. 7+#/ &+. 144+99+71.# 0##7614, 1/ 1

4+''#4.3+&1( :'+4#// ."'+%2" ."# 9+730341.3+& +0 0+'9- 3. 3/ &+. :'+:#'() 1 4)6#'.34 /)/.#9- 1/7#8#(+:#7 6) d+'6#'. J3#' 3& "3/ 6++, 01?6,36&$'%] ",B 0"3&,") (3- 0"//93$'(&$"3 $3 &56 U9/(3

83$/() (3- &56 A('5$36 - \I! E'#//- A196'372#- \S- @bT^; S/ D#3&"+(7 \1'.3& &+.#/ 3& "3/ 144+%&. +0

J3#'?/ *+', +& 4)6#'.34/- >!"# /#4+&7 (1* +0 ."#'9+7)&1934/ `*"34" J3#' 7'#* +& 3& "3/ /.%7)

+0 >/)/.#9/ +0 3&0+'91.3+& 9#1/%'#9#&. 1&7 91&12#9#&.?a "+(7/ ."1. ."# +8#'1(( (#8#( +0 #&.'+:)- +'

73/+'7#'- .#&7/ .+ :'+6163(3/.341(() .+ 3&4'#1/# 3& 1&) 4(+/#7 /)/.#9?; I. 3/ 3& ."3/ '#/:#4.- ."1. +

*+&7#'/ "+* (+23/.34/ 7+#/ &+. 6'#1, 7+*& 3&.+ 0'#X%#&. 4"1+/; N## \1'.3&- :; P@;


24/24


50 N1&7'+ \#5517'1 1&7 K'#.. d#3(/+&- F",-6, (% A6&5"-B ",B &56 A9)&$;)$'(&$"3 "7 !(?", -

Documents

Ned Rossiter - Logistical Worlds (libre)