Upload
shahrul-idham
View
231
Download
0
Embed Size (px)
Citation preview
8/6/2019 MV Superferry 2 vs MV General Romulo
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/mv-superferry-2-vs-mv-general-romulo 1/13
8/6/2019 MV Superferry 2 vs MV General Romulo
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/mv-superferry-2-vs-mv-general-romulo 2/13
Who and Where?
` Between MV Superferry 2, a passenger
vessel, and MV General Romulo, a cargo ship.
` Occurred on Thursday, 31/03/2011, at 1750h.
8/6/2019 MV Superferry 2 vs MV General Romulo
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/mv-superferry-2-vs-mv-general-romulo 3/13
8/6/2019 MV Superferry 2 vs MV General Romulo
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/mv-superferry-2-vs-mv-general-romulo 4/13
8/6/2019 MV Superferry 2 vs MV General Romulo
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/mv-superferry-2-vs-mv-general-romulo 5/13
` The MV Superferry 2 came from Nasipit in
Agusan del Norte while the MV GeneralRomulo came from Cagayan de Oro City. Both
vessels were heading for Cebu port, in the
waters off Lawis Ledge in Talisay City, Cebu,
Philippines
` The Superferry II struck the starboard quarter
of the General Romulo causing damage to the
hull and cargo holds.
8/6/2019 MV Superferry 2 vs MV General Romulo
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/mv-superferry-2-vs-mv-general-romulo 6/13
8/6/2019 MV Superferry 2 vs MV General Romulo
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/mv-superferry-2-vs-mv-general-romulo 7/13
8/6/2019 MV Superferry 2 vs MV General Romulo
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/mv-superferry-2-vs-mv-general-romulo 8/13
Who·s at fault?
` The captains of two vessels that collided near the
Lauis Ledge off the coast of Talisay City bothdenied responsibility for the accident.
` Both claim it was the other·s fault.
` MV Superferry 2 blamed the cargo vessel forallegedly moving to the starboard when they werealready abreast of each other.
` MV General Romulo said that they had alreadyadvised MV Superferry 2 to pass by its port sideupon seeing the latter already on its tail.
Who·s at fault?
` The captains of two vessels that collided near the
Lauis Ledge off the coast of Talisay City bothdenied responsibility for the accident.
` Both claim it was the other·s fault.
` MV Superferry 2 blamed the cargo vessel forallegedly moving to the starboard when they werealready abreast of each other.
` MV General Romulo said that they had alreadyadvised MV Superferry 2 to pass by its port sideupon seeing the latter already on its tail.
8/6/2019 MV Superferry 2 vs MV General Romulo
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/mv-superferry-2-vs-mv-general-romulo 9/13
` In my point of view both ships is at fault
because the cargo ship alter its course to
crossing vessel while undertaking, and the
passenger vessel did not use a warning signal
to indicate that they intend to overtake the
other ships from its starboard side.
` But the most at fault is MV General Romuro
because of the alteration of its course that
cause collision.
` In my point of view both ships is at fault
because the cargo ship alter its course to
crossing vessel while undertaking, and the
passenger vessel did not use a warning signal
to indicate that they intend to overtake the
other ships from its starboard side.
` But the most at fault is MV General Romuro
because of the alteration of its course that
cause collision.
8/6/2019 MV Superferry 2 vs MV General Romulo
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/mv-superferry-2-vs-mv-general-romulo 10/13
Result?
` No passengers or crewmen were injured on eithervessel.
` the impact damaged one of the side gangplanksof MV Superferry 2 and left scratches on the
ship·s port quarter.
` The starboard quarter of the General Romulo wasdamage at the hull and cargo holds.
` The mishap forced the cargo vessel to dropanchor while mv Superferry 2 continued its tripand safely docked at Pier 5, Cebu City.
Result?
` No passengers or crewmen were injured on eithervessel.
` the impact damaged one of the side gangplanksof MV Superferry 2 and left scratches on the
ship·s port quarter.
` The starboard quarter of the General Romulo wasdamage at the hull and cargo holds.
` The mishap forced the cargo vessel to dropanchor while mv Superferry 2 continued its tripand safely docked at Pier 5, Cebu City.
8/6/2019 MV Superferry 2 vs MV General Romulo
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/mv-superferry-2-vs-mv-general-romulo 11/13
The rule of the road violation
` Both are power driven vessel, so it concern rule3(b).
` They did not maintain a proper look out, rule 5.
` The MV General Romulo ship has violate rule 13(d) which is
´any subsequent alteration of the bearingbetween the two vessels shall not make the
overtaking vessel a crossing vessel within themeaning of these rules or relieve her of the dutyof keeping clear of the overtaken vessel until sheis finally past and clearµ
The rule of the road violation
` Both are power driven vessel, so it concern rule3(b).
` They did not maintain a proper look out, rule 5.
` The MV General Romulo ship has violate rule 13(d) which is
´any subsequent alteration of the bearingbetween the two vessels shall not make the
overtaking vessel a crossing vessel within themeaning of these rules or relieve her of the dutyof keeping clear of the overtaken vessel until sheis finally past and clearµ
8/6/2019 MV Superferry 2 vs MV General Romulo
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/mv-superferry-2-vs-mv-general-romulo 12/13
` Meanwhile The MV Superferry 2 ship has
violate rule 34 (c) which is
´ when in sight of one another in a narrow
channel or fairway:
(i) a vessel intending to overtake another shallin compliance with rule 9 (e) (i) indicate her
intention by the following signals on her
whistle:
- two prolonged blasts followed by oneshort blast to mean ´ I intend to overtake you
on your starboard sideµ
` Meanwhile The MV Superferry 2 ship has
violate rule 34 (c) which is
´ when in sight of one another in a narrow
channel or fairway:
(i) a vessel intending to overtake another shallin compliance with rule 9 (e) (i) indicate her
intention by the following signals on her
whistle:
- two prolonged blasts followed by oneshort blast to mean ´ I intend to overtake you
on your starboard sideµ
8/6/2019 MV Superferry 2 vs MV General Romulo
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/mv-superferry-2-vs-mv-general-romulo 13/13