53
Mul t i cul t ur al Li t er at ur e: an I nnovat i ve Tool t o Enhance Busi ness St udent s’ I nt er cul t ur al Communi cat i ve Compet ence Dor saf Ben Mal ek Hi gher I nst i t ut e of Technol ogi cal St udi es, Char gui a

Multicultural Literature: an Innovative Tool to Enhance ... · Intercultural Communicative Competence • Knowledge: of elements and products in other cultures. • Skills: of discovery

  • Upload
    others

  • View
    5

  • Download
    0

Embed Size (px)

Citation preview

Page 1: Multicultural Literature: an Innovative Tool to Enhance ... · Intercultural Communicative Competence • Knowledge: of elements and products in other cultures. • Skills: of discovery

Mul t i cul tural Li terature: an I nnovat i ve Tool to Enhance

Busi ness Students’ I ntercul tural Communi cat i ve

CompetenceDorsaf Ben Mal ek

Hi gher I nst i tute of Technol ogi cal Studi es,

Chargui a Tuni si a

Page 2: Multicultural Literature: an Innovative Tool to Enhance ... · Intercultural Communicative Competence • Knowledge: of elements and products in other cultures. • Skills: of discovery

• What is intercultural communicative competence (ICC)?

• Why is ICC necessary to business English teaching?

• How can multicultural literature enhance business students’ ICC?

Page 3: Multicultural Literature: an Innovative Tool to Enhance ... · Intercultural Communicative Competence • Knowledge: of elements and products in other cultures. • Skills: of discovery

What i s i ntercul tural communi cat i ve competence

( I CC)?

Page 4: Multicultural Literature: an Innovative Tool to Enhance ... · Intercultural Communicative Competence • Knowledge: of elements and products in other cultures. • Skills: of discovery

Intercultural Communicative Competence

• Knowledge: of elements and products in other cultures.

• Skills: of discovery and interaction & of interpreting and relating.

• Attitudes: Be open to all cultures & Respect all other cultures.

• Critical Cultural Awareness

(Byram, 1997)

Page 5: Multicultural Literature: an Innovative Tool to Enhance ... · Intercultural Communicative Competence • Knowledge: of elements and products in other cultures. • Skills: of discovery

Why i s i ntercul tural communi cat i ve competence

necessary to busi ness Engl i sh teachi ng?

Page 6: Multicultural Literature: an Innovative Tool to Enhance ... · Intercultural Communicative Competence • Knowledge: of elements and products in other cultures. • Skills: of discovery
Page 7: Multicultural Literature: an Innovative Tool to Enhance ... · Intercultural Communicative Competence • Knowledge: of elements and products in other cultures. • Skills: of discovery

Change i n the workpl ace:

• Multicultural• Diverse• New identities(Risager,2006)

Page 8: Multicultural Literature: an Innovative Tool to Enhance ... · Intercultural Communicative Competence • Knowledge: of elements and products in other cultures. • Skills: of discovery

More i nternat i onalbusi ness and cooperat i on

Page 9: Multicultural Literature: an Innovative Tool to Enhance ... · Intercultural Communicative Competence • Knowledge: of elements and products in other cultures. • Skills: of discovery

ICC

Company

Page 10: Multicultural Literature: an Innovative Tool to Enhance ... · Intercultural Communicative Competence • Knowledge: of elements and products in other cultures. • Skills: of discovery

What happens i f a company l acks i ntercul tural communi cat i ve

competence?

Page 11: Multicultural Literature: an Innovative Tool to Enhance ... · Intercultural Communicative Competence • Knowledge: of elements and products in other cultures. • Skills: of discovery
Page 12: Multicultural Literature: an Innovative Tool to Enhance ... · Intercultural Communicative Competence • Knowledge: of elements and products in other cultures. • Skills: of discovery
Page 13: Multicultural Literature: an Innovative Tool to Enhance ... · Intercultural Communicative Competence • Knowledge: of elements and products in other cultures. • Skills: of discovery

Busi ness students’ future empl oyabi l i ty

Page 14: Multicultural Literature: an Innovative Tool to Enhance ... · Intercultural Communicative Competence • Knowledge: of elements and products in other cultures. • Skills: of discovery
Page 15: Multicultural Literature: an Innovative Tool to Enhance ... · Intercultural Communicative Competence • Knowledge: of elements and products in other cultures. • Skills: of discovery
Page 16: Multicultural Literature: an Innovative Tool to Enhance ... · Intercultural Communicative Competence • Knowledge: of elements and products in other cultures. • Skills: of discovery
Page 17: Multicultural Literature: an Innovative Tool to Enhance ... · Intercultural Communicative Competence • Knowledge: of elements and products in other cultures. • Skills: of discovery

ü Knowledgeable

Culture knowledge

Business knowledge

ü Skilfull

Language skills

Business skills

(Liu, 2013)

Successful candidates are:

Page 18: Multicultural Literature: an Innovative Tool to Enhance ... · Intercultural Communicative Competence • Knowledge: of elements and products in other cultures. • Skills: of discovery
Page 19: Multicultural Literature: an Innovative Tool to Enhance ... · Intercultural Communicative Competence • Knowledge: of elements and products in other cultures. • Skills: of discovery

Students are not robots ready to enter the

business world. They are human beings and

part of living societies. Take the example of

Tunisian students. They went through:

Page 20: Multicultural Literature: an Innovative Tool to Enhance ... · Intercultural Communicative Competence • Knowledge: of elements and products in other cultures. • Skills: of discovery
Page 21: Multicultural Literature: an Innovative Tool to Enhance ... · Intercultural Communicative Competence • Knowledge: of elements and products in other cultures. • Skills: of discovery
Page 22: Multicultural Literature: an Innovative Tool to Enhance ... · Intercultural Communicative Competence • Knowledge: of elements and products in other cultures. • Skills: of discovery
Page 23: Multicultural Literature: an Innovative Tool to Enhance ... · Intercultural Communicative Competence • Knowledge: of elements and products in other cultures. • Skills: of discovery

Intercultural communicative competence may change youth’s attitudes towards other cultures (Huber & Reynolds, 2014).

Page 24: Multicultural Literature: an Innovative Tool to Enhance ... · Intercultural Communicative Competence • Knowledge: of elements and products in other cultures. • Skills: of discovery

• Tunisian society is mono-cultural.• Intercultural encounters are very rare in the

educational context.• Absence of the right methods and pedagogy• Shortage of textbooks that deal with

intercultural communication.• Focus on the linguistic side of language

teaching.

Page 25: Multicultural Literature: an Innovative Tool to Enhance ... · Intercultural Communicative Competence • Knowledge: of elements and products in other cultures. • Skills: of discovery
Page 26: Multicultural Literature: an Innovative Tool to Enhance ... · Intercultural Communicative Competence • Knowledge: of elements and products in other cultures. • Skills: of discovery

How can teachers enhance thei r students’ i ntercul tural

communi cat i ve competence?

Page 27: Multicultural Literature: an Innovative Tool to Enhance ... · Intercultural Communicative Competence • Knowledge: of elements and products in other cultures. • Skills: of discovery

Teachers can use:

films

drama

telecollaborative partnerships

simulation

multiculturalliterature

documentaries

creative writing

ethnographic tasks

Page 28: Multicultural Literature: an Innovative Tool to Enhance ... · Intercultural Communicative Competence • Knowledge: of elements and products in other cultures. • Skills: of discovery

When a material is «transported from its context of origin, and presented to different learner

groups it becomes an example of intercultural encounter»

(Dogancay-Aktuna, 2005-100).

Page 29: Multicultural Literature: an Innovative Tool to Enhance ... · Intercultural Communicative Competence • Knowledge: of elements and products in other cultures. • Skills: of discovery

Multicultural Literature• Produced by people from other cultures• Authentic material• A mirror of other cultures• It speaks of other experiences

(L.Henderson & Young, 2011)

Page 30: Multicultural Literature: an Innovative Tool to Enhance ... · Intercultural Communicative Competence • Knowledge: of elements and products in other cultures. • Skills: of discovery
Page 31: Multicultural Literature: an Innovative Tool to Enhance ... · Intercultural Communicative Competence • Knowledge: of elements and products in other cultures. • Skills: of discovery
Page 32: Multicultural Literature: an Innovative Tool to Enhance ... · Intercultural Communicative Competence • Knowledge: of elements and products in other cultures. • Skills: of discovery
Page 33: Multicultural Literature: an Innovative Tool to Enhance ... · Intercultural Communicative Competence • Knowledge: of elements and products in other cultures. • Skills: of discovery
Page 34: Multicultural Literature: an Innovative Tool to Enhance ... · Intercultural Communicative Competence • Knowledge: of elements and products in other cultures. • Skills: of discovery

The Short Story:

By being short, brief and concise, it helps

students learn autonomously and

independently (Rocha Erkaya, 2005)

Page 35: Multicultural Literature: an Innovative Tool to Enhance ... · Intercultural Communicative Competence • Knowledge: of elements and products in other cultures. • Skills: of discovery

How can mul t i cul tural l i terature enhance busi ness students’

i ntercul tural communi cat i ve competence?

Page 36: Multicultural Literature: an Innovative Tool to Enhance ... · Intercultural Communicative Competence • Knowledge: of elements and products in other cultures. • Skills: of discovery

Research Desi gn

• No fixed attainable goal in ICC proficiency + No perfect intercultural speaker

• ICC components cannot be entirely measured in a quantitaive way

• Qualitative methods are advisable for the evaluation and the assessment of ICC proficiency

(Byram, 1997)

Page 37: Multicultural Literature: an Innovative Tool to Enhance ... · Intercultural Communicative Competence • Knowledge: of elements and products in other cultures. • Skills: of discovery

Course Desi gn

• Students read the short story.• They answer the teacher’s guiding questions• They prepare for presentations in groups• They students reflect on the experience in

journals• Discussions take place• They deliver presentations

Page 38: Multicultural Literature: an Innovative Tool to Enhance ... · Intercultural Communicative Competence • Knowledge: of elements and products in other cultures. • Skills: of discovery

Sel ect i on Cri teri a of the short stori es

• Vocabulary• Students’ orientation• Intercultural themes

Page 39: Multicultural Literature: an Innovative Tool to Enhance ... · Intercultural Communicative Competence • Knowledge: of elements and products in other cultures. • Skills: of discovery
Page 40: Multicultural Literature: an Innovative Tool to Enhance ... · Intercultural Communicative Competence • Knowledge: of elements and products in other cultures. • Skills: of discovery

Part i ci pants:

q 20 MA business students of Higher Institute of Technological Studies, Charguia.

q Aged 21 to 32.q Reluctant to read literature.

Page 41: Multicultural Literature: an Innovative Tool to Enhance ... · Intercultural Communicative Competence • Knowledge: of elements and products in other cultures. • Skills: of discovery

Data Col l ect i on I nstruments:

q Classroom observations: presentations

and discussions

q Journals

q Semi-structured Interviews

Page 42: Multicultural Literature: an Innovative Tool to Enhance ... · Intercultural Communicative Competence • Knowledge: of elements and products in other cultures. • Skills: of discovery

Fi ndi ngsIntercultural Communication

Ø Knowledge : Cultural heritage • Culture-specific productsØ Skills - Skills of discovery and Interaction:

Mechanisms of Interaction• Differences in greetings- Skills of Interpreting and Relating:

Cultural origins behind communication styles

Comparing students’ cultural elements to those in the short stories (exp: The quilt Vs Kleem)Ø Attitudes: Appreciate and respect other

people’s cultures and cultural heritage

Page 43: Multicultural Literature: an Innovative Tool to Enhance ... · Intercultural Communicative Competence • Knowledge: of elements and products in other cultures. • Skills: of discovery

Reading the Short Stories

Ø Short

Ø Familiar vocabulary

Ø Students related to characters

Page 44: Multicultural Literature: an Innovative Tool to Enhance ... · Intercultural Communicative Competence • Knowledge: of elements and products in other cultures. • Skills: of discovery

Inquiry-based Learning

Ø Students enjoyed learningØ Students became independent and

autonomous learners

Page 45: Multicultural Literature: an Innovative Tool to Enhance ... · Intercultural Communicative Competence • Knowledge: of elements and products in other cultures. • Skills: of discovery

i) Focus on the tree fundamental aspects of ICC when dealing with multicultural literature may be a systematic planned guideline for the teacher.

Concl usi ons

Page 46: Multicultural Literature: an Innovative Tool to Enhance ... · Intercultural Communicative Competence • Knowledge: of elements and products in other cultures. • Skills: of discovery

Concl usi ons

ii) By exploiting the cultural elements in relevance to business, instructors may provide students with a rich and motivating material.

Page 47: Multicultural Literature: an Innovative Tool to Enhance ... · Intercultural Communicative Competence • Knowledge: of elements and products in other cultures. • Skills: of discovery

Concl usi ons

iii) By turning students into independent readers and autonomous learners, the short story is a motivating instrument for them to read literature.

Page 48: Multicultural Literature: an Innovative Tool to Enhance ... · Intercultural Communicative Competence • Knowledge: of elements and products in other cultures. • Skills: of discovery

Concl usi ons

iv) Engaging students in inquiry-based learning makes them feel responsible for their own learning.

Page 49: Multicultural Literature: an Innovative Tool to Enhance ... · Intercultural Communicative Competence • Knowledge: of elements and products in other cultures. • Skills: of discovery

Li mi tat i ons

• In relation to ICC:

- Other factors may determine behaviour

- Cultural dimensions exist as a continuum

especially with globalisation and internet

connection.

Page 50: Multicultural Literature: an Innovative Tool to Enhance ... · Intercultural Communicative Competence • Knowledge: of elements and products in other cultures. • Skills: of discovery

• In relation to reading the short stories:- Not having the habit of reading literature- Some unfamiliar vocabulary- Some unfamiliar cultural elements- Changing the timing may change the results- Not pure business short stories

Page 51: Multicultural Literature: an Innovative Tool to Enhance ... · Intercultural Communicative Competence • Knowledge: of elements and products in other cultures. • Skills: of discovery

• In relation to IBL:

- Not knowing each other previously- Strong Vs weak students

Page 52: Multicultural Literature: an Innovative Tool to Enhance ... · Intercultural Communicative Competence • Knowledge: of elements and products in other cultures. • Skills: of discovery

References• Branch, J., Oberg, D. (2004). What is inquiry? In

Inquiry & ICT.• Byram, M. (1997). Teaching and assessing

intercultural communicative competence. Clevedon, England: Multilingual Matters.

• Dogancay-Aktuna, S. (2005). Intercultural communication in English language teacher education. ELT Journal Volume 59/2. Oxford: Oxford University Press. pp 99 – 107.

• François Marcel, M. (2011), Intercultural Competence Will Save the Day. Global Diversity Primer. Published by Diversity Best Practices.

• Huber, J. And Reynolds, C. (2014). Developing intercultural competence through education. Pestalozzi series N.3. Council of Europe, pp. 9-12.

• J. Ruder, P (2010). Teaching Economics with short stories; Australian Journal of Economics Education. Vol7, Number 1, pp. 20-30.

• L. Henderson, D and Young, T. (2011), Voices of multicultural authors, Multicultural Literature and Response: Affirming Diverse Voices, LIBRARIES UNLIMITED, Santa Barbara, California.

• Liu, C. (2013), On the cultivation of intercultural communication competence of the BE students from higher vocational college, International Journal of Arts and Commerce, Vol2. Number 11. pp. 67-72.

• Risager, K. (2006). Language and culture: Global flows and local complexity. Multilingual matters.

Page 53: Multicultural Literature: an Innovative Tool to Enhance ... · Intercultural Communicative Competence • Knowledge: of elements and products in other cultures. • Skills: of discovery