16
MTA 2020 Preliminary Budget July Financial Plan 2020 - 2023 Presentation to the Board July 24, 2019

MTA 2020 Preliminary Budget July Financial Plan 2020 - 2023 2020 Preliminar… · 1 The MTA Budget Process July Plan – Start of the Annual Process • Current year is revised (the

  • Upload
    others

  • View
    2

  • Download
    0

Embed Size (px)

Citation preview

Page 1: MTA 2020 Preliminary Budget July Financial Plan 2020 - 2023 2020 Preliminar… · 1 The MTA Budget Process July Plan – Start of the Annual Process • Current year is revised (the

MTA 2020Preliminary Budget

July Financial Plan2020 - 2023

Presentation to the Board

July 24 2019

1

The MTA Budget ProcessJuly Plan ndash Start of the Annual Processbull Current year is revised (the ldquoMid-Year Forecastrdquo) preliminary presentation of the following yearrsquos

proposed budget (the ldquoPreliminary Budgetrdquo) and a three-year re-forecast of out-year financesbull Includes gap-closing proposals for balancing the budget and highlights actions requiring public

hearingsbull Mid-Year Forecast becomes the basis for comparing monthly results for the remainder of the year

November Planbull Update of the 5-year July Plan prepared after stakeholders weigh in bull Reflects the impact of new developments and risksbull Includes a revised current year (the ldquoNovember Forecastrdquo) finalization of the proposed budget for the

upcoming year (the ldquoFinal Proposed Budgetrdquo) and projections for the three out-yearsDecember ndash Budget Adoptionbull Update of the November Plan to reflect further developments risks and actions necessary to ensure

budget balancebull Presented to the MTA Board for review and approval

February Planbull Certain below-the-line policy issues covered in Decemberrsquos budget adoption approval are moved into

the baseline technical adjustments are made and the current year becomes the ldquoAdopted Budgetrdquobull Allocated over the 12-month period and is the basis for comparing monthly results

2

Non-Reimbursable Final Adopted Estimate Budget 2018 2019 2020 2021 2022

Operating RevenuesFarebox Revenue $6153 $6122 $6144 $6134 $6144Toll Revenue 1967 1984 1990 1998 1998 Other Revenue 662 705 733 757 743

Total Operating Revenue $8782 $8810 $8867 $8889 $8886

Total Subsidies $7242 $7238 $7370 $7576 $7807Dedicated Taxes as a of Total Revenues + Subs - PMT $0 $0 $0 $0 $0

Total Revenues + Subsidies $16023 $16048 $16237 $16465 $16693

Operating ExpensesLabor Expenses $9920 $10039 $10436 $10787 $11097Non-Labor Expenses 3749 3884 3786 3894 3994 Other 134 158 84 36 22 General Reserve 0 165 170 175 180

Total Operating Expenses $13803 $14246 $14476 $14891 $15293

Debt Service Expenses $2559 $2692 $2840 $3080 $3223

Total Expenses + Debt Service $16362 $16938 $17316 $17971 $18516

Conversion to Cash Basis 296 363 188 (17) 88

Baseline Net Cash Balance Before B-T-L Adjustments ($43) ($527) ($891) ($1523) ($1735)

Total Below-the-Line Adjustments $0 $459 $413 $709 $760Prior Year Carryover 121 79 11 0 0

NET CASH BALANCE $79 $11 ($467) ($814) ($976)

MTA February Financial Plan 2019-2022Consolidated Statement Of Operations By Category ($ in millions)

Summ Stmt of Ops-Feb

Summ Stmt of Ops-Jul

3

The February Financial Plan included large out-year deficits even with faretoll increases and substantial cost reduction targets

($ in millions)

11

(467)

(814)

(976)

($1200)

($1000)

($800)

($600)

($400)

($200)

$0

$200

2019 2020 2021 2022

This Year Next Year Out-Years

What has changed since the February Plan

Changes and re-estimates over the Plan period (2019 ndash 2022)bull Changes and re-estimates improving financial results

bull Higher MMTOA subsidies ($184 million)bull Higher yield from additional 23 in tolls ($173 million)bull Lower maintenanceother operating contracts ($173 million)bull Higher MTA Aid car rental tax ($35 million)

bull Changes and re-estimates worsening financial resultsbull Actuary recalculation of pension liability ($550 million)bull Agency re-estimates and rate change adjustments ($189 million)bull Higher overtime expenses ($131 million)bull Lower rentaladvertising revenues ($83 million)bull Lower real estate tax revenues ($59 million)

In total these changes and re-estimates along with other changes are $447 million unfavorable for the Plan period

4

Highlights of the July Plan

bull Proposed biennial fare and toll increases of 4 in 2021 and 2023 (versus projected 2-year CPI inflators of 49 and 47 in 2021 and 2023 respectively)

bull Maintained investments from prior plans including maintenance of the Subway Action Plan funded from Phase 1 of Congestion PricingFHV fees

bull Renewed emphasis to gain control of and reduce fare evasion (investment of $62 million over the Plan period)

bull MTA is using ldquoone-shotsrdquo to balance the budget in the transition years 2019 and 2020

o 2019 - 2018 favorable year-end balance ndash mostly timing ndash and impacts 2019 ($372 million)

- Freeze on filling all non-operationalnon-essential vacancies ($68 million)

- Other restrictions on non-essential spending including non-revenue vehicle purchases travelprofessional memberships ($44 million)

- One-time reduction of committed to capital contributions ($64 million)

o 2020 - Drawdown of 2019 General Reserve ($165 million)

bull Annual recurring savings targets of $350 million beginning in 2020 have been identified by HQ and Agencies

5

6

These actions will not suffice and significant deficits remain($ in millions)

This Year Next Year Out-Years

11

(467)

(814)

(976)

NA

50

(186)

(569)

(816)

(971)

($1200)

($1000)

($800)

($600)

($400)

($200)

$0

$200

2019 2020 2021 2022 2023

February PlanJuly Plan without Transformation Plan Savings

MTA Transformation Plan

bull State-mandated plan to review operations and implement changes to streamline internal processes clarify responsibilities solidify accountability and work more efficiently to regain trust of our customers and funding partners and improve MTArsquos ability to deliver safe and reliable service our customers deserve

bull Plan recommendationsbull Refocus the operating agencies on mission-critical operating priorities of safety reliability and

servicebull Centralize common support functions to improve operations and create opportunities to ensure

consistent standards quality and policies across departmentsbull Unify the management of capital programs to improve and streamline planning development

and construction so capital improvements can be delivered on time and on budgetbull Expand senior leadership by adding a Chief Transformation Officer a Chief Operating Officer a

Chief Engineering Officer and an MTA Accessibility Officer

bull Consolidation and efficiency targets of $370 million to $530 million on an annual basis have been identified

bull If the MTA Transformation Plan is approved and implemented the July Financial Plan will have small operating balances in 2019 and 2020 a small deficit in 2021 with out-year deficits reaching $433 million in 2023

7

8

The adoption and implementation of the MTA Transformation Planhas the potential to significantly reduce out-year deficits

($ in millions)

This Year Next Year Out-Years

11

(467)

(814)

(976)

NA

61 55

(26)

(281)

(433)

($1200)

($1000)

($800)

($600)

($400)

($200)

$0

$200

2019 2020 2021 2022 2023

February PlanProposed July Plan

Actions to Reduce Fare Evasion $62 million Investment over the Plan Period

bull Increase physical presence (500 uniformed officers NYPD MTA Police and Bridge and Tunnel Officers) to begin enforcement at 50 subway stations and 50 bus routesThis is not just a fare evasion effort but a workerrsquos safety initiative

bull Ensure enforcement does not target any specific demographic bull Educate MTA riders utilizing messaging media and automated

announcementsbull Improve operation of emergency exit gates to mitigate instances of fare

avoidancebull Augment surveillance capabilities by deploying fare array cameras at 50

stations and pilot the use of monitors at 10 stationsbull $40 million of the investment will be funded by Manhattan DA Office over a

four-year period

9

The MTArsquos $350 million target for annually recurring savings beginning in 2020 has been identified and is being implemented

109

10 7 6 6

96 304 351 362 371

$0

$50

$100

$150

$200

$250

$300

$350

$400

2019 2020 2021 2022 2023

Identified Recurring Savings One-Shot Savings

This Year Next Year Out-Years

($ in millions)

10

We have a track record of identifying and achieving our annual recurring savings targets

11

($ in millions)

$0

$500

$1000

$1500

$2000

$2500

$3000

Achieved Savings

2012 November Plan

2013 November Plan

2014 November Plan

2015 November Plan

2016 November Plan

2017 November Plan

2018 November Plan

2019 July Plan

$28 billion

Proposed July Plan

Deficits remain and a continued drive toward further streamlining and efficiencies is required

12

($ in millions)

61 55

(26)

(281)

(433)

($600)

($500)

($400)

($300)

($200)

($100)

$0

$100

$200

2019 2020 2021 2022 2023

This Year Next Year Out-Years

Proposed July PlanDonrsquot achieve Transformation Plan Savings

13

If the MTA Transformation Plan is not adopted and implemented the deficits will be unmanageable without service cuts significant

reductions in force andor additional fare and toll increases($ in millions)

($1100)

($900)

($700)

($500)

($300)

($100)

$100

2019 2020 2021 2022 2023

(816)

(971)

(569)

(81)

(433)

(281)

61 55 (26)

(281) (186)

50

Next Year Out-Years

(230)(11)

(488)

(538)

(535)

This Year

14

2020 Preliminary BudgetWhere the Dollars Come Fromhellip Where the Dollars Gohellip

Farebox Revenue $6389Toll Revenue 2121 Other Revenue 684 Taxes 6178 State and Local amp Other 557 Other Funding Agreements 671 Other 1 208 Total $16809

($ in millions)

By Revenue Source(includes faretoll increases)

Payroll $5422Overtime 838 Health amp Welfare 2118 Pension 1461 Other Labor 466 Total Labor $10306Non-Labor + Other Exp Adj 4004 Debt Service 2830 BTL Adjustments for Expenses 2 (386) Total $16754

By Expense Category

($ in millions)(includes below-the-line adjustments)

1 Includes cash adjustments and prior-year carryover

Farebox Revenue

38

Toll Revenue

13

Other Revenue4

Taxes37

State amp Local

Subsidies3

Other Funding Agreements

4 Other 1

Payroll32

Overtime5

Health ampWelfare

13Pension

9

Other Labor3

Non-Labor + Other Exp Adj

21

Debt Service17

2 The below-the-line adjustments are grouped in the Non-Labor category

Sheet1

Sheet1

15

Non-Reimbursable Mid-Year Preliminary Actual Forecast Budget

2018 2019 2020 2021 2022 2023 Operating Revenues

Farebox Revenue $6155 $6305 $6389 $6373 $6384 $6393Toll Revenue 1976 2088 2121 2129 2129 2131 Other Revenue 643 696 684 704 719 737

Total Operating Revenue $8774 $9089 $9195 $9206 $9232 $9260

Total Subsidies $7177 $7314 $7406 $7581 $7803 $7969Dedicated Taxes as a of Total Revenues + Subs - PMT 233 $0 $0 $0 $0 $0

Total Revenues + Subsidies $15951 $16403 $16601 $16787 $17035 $17229

Operating ExpensesLabor Expenses $9799 $10116 $10306 $10592 $10881 $11121Non-Labor Expenses 3611 3877 3748 3841 3945 4054 Other 129 175 86 36 22 23 General Reserve 0 165 170 175 180 185

Total Operating Expenses $13539 $14333 $14310 $14644 $15028 $15384

Debt Service Expenses $2541 $2683 $2830 $3041 $3265 $3513

Total Expenses + Debt Service $16079 $17016 $17140 $17685 $18293 $18896

Conversion to Cash Basis 379 229 147 60 125 101

Baseline Net Cash Balance Before B-T-L Adjustments $251 ($384) ($392) ($838) ($1133) ($1566)

Total Below-the-Line Adjustments $0 $73 $386 $757 $852 $1133Prior Year Carryover 121 372 61 55 0 0

NET CASH BALANCE $372 $61 $55 ($26) ($281) ($433)

MTA July Financial Plan 2020-2023Consolidated Statement Of Operations By Category ($ in millions)

Summ Stmt of Ops-Feb

Summ Stmt of Ops-Jul

  • MTA 2020Preliminary BudgetJuly Financial Plan2020 - 2023
  • The MTA Budget Process
  • Slide Number 3
  • Slide Number 4
  • What has changed since the February Plan
  • Highlights of the July Plan
  • Slide Number 7
  • MTA Transformation Plan
  • Slide Number 9
  • Actions to Reduce Fare Evasion $62 million Investment over the Plan Period
  • The MTArsquos $350 million target for annually recurring savings beginning in 2020 has been identified and is being implemented
  • We have a track record of identifying and achieving our annual recurring savings targets
  • Deficits remain and a continued drive toward further streamlining and efficiencies is required
  • Slide Number 14
  • 2020 Preliminary Budget
  • Slide Number 16
MTA July Financial Plan 2020-2023
Consolidated Statement Of Operations By Category ($ in millions)
Non-Reimbursable Mid-Year Preliminary
Actual Actual Actual Actual Actual Actual Actual Actual Actual Actual Forecast Budget
2008 2009 2010 2011 2012 2013 2014 2015 2016 2018 2019 2020 2021 2022 2023 2023 2024 2025 2026
Operating Revenues
Farebox Revenue $4240923 $4350411 $4586377 $4999186 $5079138 $5501274 $5709200 $5961129 $6050182 $6155 $6305 $6389 $6373 $6384 $6393 $6174 $6435176 $6431979 $6446633
422 423 405 411 402 399 395 396 396 386 384 385 380 375 371 261 368 363 362
Student Fare - 0 - 0 - 0 - 0 - 0 - 0
Toll Revenue 1273974 1332115 1417046 1501589 1490982 1645193 1676445 1808901 1869693 1976 2088 2121 2129 2129 2131 2002 2133050 2137871 2143111
0127 0129 0125 0124 0118 0119 0116 0120 0122 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0122 0121 0120
Other Revenue 448616 461359 491355 510231 563839 753675 682424 689217 688374 643 696 684 704 719 737 755 825040 885381 887190
Capital and Other Reimbursements 0000 0000 0000 0000 0000 0000 0000 0000 0000 0000 0000 0000 0000 0000 0000 0000 0000 0000 0000
Total Operating Revenue $5963512 $6143885 $6494778 $7011006 $7133959 $7900142 $8068069 $8459247 $8608249 $8774 $9089 $9195 $9206 $9232 $9260 $8931 $9393266 $9455232 $9476934
Dedicated Taxes $3211585 $2366805 $2343537 $2511691 $2673119 $3097640 $3383498 $3582628 $3525829 $3257508 $3459 $3515 $3568 $3630 $3725 $3812 $3841433 $3880226 $3917215
PMT amp MTA Aid - 0 881784 1588677 1718286 1825824 1825328 1885069 1910947 1970760 1987035 $1965 $2152 $2225 $2295 $2368 $2442 2516095 2594604 2677041
New Funding Sources - 0 - 0 - 0 - 0 - 0 - 0 - 0 - 0 - 0 - 0 $508 $342 $385 $385 $385 $385 385000 385000 385000
StateLocal Taxes 556691 539046 544810 541733 536182 537527 539545 537819 537645 541005 $544 $552 $557 $562 $567 $572 576828 581933 583214
Other Funding Agreements 306594 363823 359489 375369 466625 432617 567391 563616 629855 630218 $701 $753 $671 $708 $758 $758 784755 804901 781159
BampT Operating Surplus Transfer 382565 363092 476059 554903 476575 614210 637553 750717 742909 740144 $702 $721 $782 $801 $789 $707 730476 695303 688833
Dedicated Taxes and StateLocal Subsidies $4457434 $4514550 $5312572 $5701982 $5978325 $6507322 $7013056 $7345727 $7406998 $7155909 $7879 $8035 $8188 $8381 $8592 $8676 $8834588 $8941967 $9032462
$0000 $0000 $0000 $0000 $0000 $0000 $0000 $0000 $0000
Less Interagency Subsidy and Surplus Transfers (382565) (363092) (476059) (554903) (476575) (614210) (637553) (750717) (742909) (740144) ($702) ($721) ($782) ($801) ($789) ($707) (730476) (695303) (688833)
Total Subsidies $4074870 $4151458 $4836513 $5147079 $5501750 $5893111 $6375503 $6595010 $6664088 $7177 $7314 $7406 $7581 $7803 $7969 $7969 $8104112 $8246664 $8343629
Dedicated Taxes as a of Total Revenues + Subs - PMT 320 251 241 241 247 259 269 273 265 233 $0 $0 $0 $0 $0 $0 256 257 259
Total Revenues + Subsidies $10038382 $10295342 $11331292 $12158085 $12635709 $13793254 $14443571 $15054257 $15272337 $15951 $16403 $16601 $16787 $17035 $17229 $16900 $17497378 $17701896 $17820563
Operating Expenses
Labor Expenses
Payroll $4087376 $4163330 $4171374 $4160261 $4193658 $4332829 $4671664 $4695823 $4838741 $5020713 $5211 $5328 $5422 $5498 $5624 $5710 $5860206 $5982960 $6107107
Overtime 471675 499307 443227 538647 574316 620701 730200 755071 771495 934100 $1066 $910 $838 $859 $877 $899 917296 935002 951324
Health amp Welfare 684945 688899 738189 809638 812857 895714 961902 1050100 1172304 1208786 $1230 $1341 $1414 $1489 $1583 $1674 1797938 1922668 2071273
OPEB Current Payment 318501 346316 355716 394218 413164 472619 479079 501716 562233 563754 $604 $645 $704 $766 $835 $910 982025 1060022 1142795
Pensions 897450 1021229 1029710 1074598 1328441 1301975 1304355 1248726 1370474 1345308 $1336 $1494 $1461 $1462 $1403 $1347 1357887 1369071 1380572
Other-Fringe Benefits 502739 517194 539996 581661 650430 694680 784143 861079 947870 792151 $881 $869 $897 $930 $956 $976 1001185 1021007 1040170
Reimbursable Overhead (310555) (322230) (345154) (324006) (309399) (321390) (349770) (380212) (423759) (491807) ($528) ($471) ($430) ($412) ($397) ($395) (396136) (405509) (413165)
Labor Expenses $6652131 $6914045 $6933059 $7235017 $7663467 $7997128 $8581574 $8732302 $9239358 $9799 $10116 $10306 $10592 $10881 $11121 $11413 $11520401 $11885220 $12280075
PayrollOvertime Exp as a of Total Operating+DS $0426 $0427 $0407 $0396 $0387 $0374 $0389 $0383 $0376 $0390 $0367 $0365 $0359 $0355 $0350 $0349 $0347 $0345
Labor Exp (wo Reimb OH) as a of Total Oper+DS $0650 $0663 $0642 $0637 $0647 $0628 $0643 $0640 $0648 $0642 $0622 $0626 $0622 $0616 $0609 $0614 $0617 $0620
PayrollOvertime Exp as a of Total Operating Exp $0496 $0490 $0483 $0473 $0465 $0453 $0464 $0459 $0450 $0464 $0435 $0438 $0434 $0433 $0430 $0426 $0420 $0416
Labor Exp (wo Reimb OH) as a of Total Oper Exp $0758 $0761 $0762 $0761 $0777 $0761 $0768 $0768 $0776 $0763 $0739 $0750 $0751 $0750 $0749 $0748 $0747 $0747
Non-Labor Expenses
Electric Power $306500 $317934 $325137 $457269 $471514 $493346 $515540 $473762 $406372 $481893 $451503 $473177 $493090 $532413 $561955 $571182 $589565 $618283 $648255
Traction Power
Non-Traction Power
Fuel 287033 180294 189942 282735 251763 259252 267494 162283 124684 185203 182778 182981 176333 173681 176920 182259 182476 184281 186170
Revenue Vehicle Fuel
Non-Revenue Fuel
Insurance 28902 34012 9819 14363 7617 38654 50739 57190 (20634) (29402) 5608 15623 23118 26855 28309 36048 28232 25538 19483
Claims 152114 238104 285418 315547 135652 299875 269167 331023 463959 437985 387557 394211 392547 398256 406112 404397 417667 428660 437683
Paratransit Service Contracts 299013 370094 379761 348553 360500 366751 365599 379271 383704 455471 494751 488330 505538 535329 568614 581114 604766 643217 684112
Maintenance and Other Operating Contracts 594215 562456 541716 451137 451766 496743 549018 579289 630924 678425 840168 797428 833534 836606 854471 879468 880053 898882 915477
Professional Service Contracts 196930 199164 203084 226205 276998 297201 283005 379814 399706 543582 607838 502858 494814 504103 513895 499724 520826 537109 547291
Materials amp Supplies 532534 526191 511206 438310 430804 475127 526725 543225 585607 637078 689010 679895 697976 711281 715758 711988 741335 777460 793419
Other Business Expenses 155466 184142 189637 169857 143807 167198 179701 195598 192576 220838 218196 213551 224459 226170 228457 244907 228861 240258 241690
Non-Labor Expenses $2552708 $2612391 $2635720 $2703976 $2530421 $2894147 $3006988 $3101454 $3166897 3611 3877 3748 3841 3945 4054 4111 $4193782 $4353689 $4473580
Other Expense Adjustments
Other ($13712) ($14750) ($18292) ($2289) $62593 $46175 $44973 $37007 $47404 129 175 86 36 22 23 23 $23516 $24069 $24637
General Reserve 0000 0000 0000 0000 0000 - 0 - 0 - 0 - 0 0 165 170 175 180 185 185 190000 195000 205000
Other Expense Adjustments ($13712) ($14750) ($18292) ($2289) $62593 $46175 $44973 $37007 $47404 $128555 $340 $256 $211 $202 $208 $208 $213516 $219069 $229637
Gap Closing Expenses $7675394
Additional Actions for Budget Balance Expense Impact $0000 $0000 $0000 $0000 $0000 $0000 $0000 $0000 $0000 $0000 $0000 $0000 $0000 $0000 $0000 $0000 $0000 $0000 $0000
Total Operating Expenses Before Non-Cash Liability Adjs $9191127 $9511685 $9550486 $9936705 $10256481 $10937450 $11633535 $11870763 $12453659 $13538830 $14332772 $14309678 $14643965 $15027767 $15383584 $15732241 $15927699 $16457978 $16983292
Non-Cash Liability Adjustments
Depreciation $1790981 $1940576 $1980681 $2019378 $2148820 $2174302 $2266280 $2442777 $2442941 $2607970 $2804571 $2784812 $2842737 $2908533 $2977025 $3051834 $3109882 $3169371 $3230301
OPEB Obligation 1348962 1104827 1167070 1706939 1785881 1920189 2035457 1489656 1562261 1567381 0000 (0000) (0000) (0000) (0000) 0000 0000 (0000) (0000)
GASB 75 OPEB Expense Adjustment 0000 0000 0000 0000 0000 0000 0000 0000 0000 0000 1047747 1457230 1628196 1748560 1823313 1898497 1952374 2006482 2061993
GASB 68 Pension Expense Adjustment 0000 0000 0000 0000 0000 0000 0000 (410019) (218911) (168119) (373022) (220864) (271921) (342847) (318372) (242446) (237864) (234492) (230942)
Environmental Remediation 42249 6062 18621 59079 24742 14257 20556 20576 11691 13468 105615 6000 6000 6000 6000 6000 6000 6000 6000
Non-Cash Liability Adjustments $3182192 $3051466 $3166371 $3785396 $3959443 $4108749 $4322293 $3542990 $3797981 $4020699 $3584911 $4027178 $4205012 $4320246 $4487966 $4713886 $4830392 $4947361 $5067352
Total Operating Expenses After Non-Cash Liability Adjs $12373319 $12563151 $12716857 $13722101 $14215924 $15046199 $15955827 $15413753 $16251641 $17559529 $17917683 $18336856 $18848977 $19348013 $19871550 $20446127 $20758090 $21405338 $22050644
Less BampT Depreciation $77213 $80097 $77846 $86545 $87926 $91345 $104039 $109783 $135035 $240957 $148686 $151977 $158779 $169848 $181689 $194355 $194355 $194355 $194355
BampT Other Post Employment Benefits 66323 50967 54831 66686 73055 76641 71148 62457 60441 78106 32297 22256 20303 22870 28694 33918 36169 38411 40604
Net Operating Deficit Before Subsidies and Debt Service ($6409807) ($6419266) ($6222079) ($6711095) ($7081966) ($7146057) ($7887759) ($6954506) ($7643392) ($8785339) ($8829030) ($9141907) ($9642826) ($10116260) ($10611154) ($11515498) ($11364824) ($11950106) ($12573710)
Conversion to Cash Basis Non-Cash Liability Adjs ($3182192) ($3051466) ($3166371) ($3785396) ($3959443) ($4108749) ($4322293) ($3542990) ($3797981) ($4020699) ($3584911) ($4027178) ($4205012) ($4320246) ($4487966) ($4713886) ($4830392) ($4947361) ($5067352)
Total Operating Expenses $9191127 $9511685 $9550486 $9936705 $10256481 $10937450 $11633535 $11870763 $12453659 $13539 $14333 $14310 $14644 $15028 $15384 $15732 $15927699 $16457978 $16983292
Debt Service Expenses $1515733 $1404454 $1781220 $1933532 $2058395 $2299262 $2248538 $2373321 $2458783 $2541 $2683 $2830 $3041 $3265 $3513 $3450 $3471321 $3472987 $3501639
Total Expenses + Debt Service $10706859 $10916139 $11331706 $11870237 $12314876 $13236712 $13882073 $14244084 $14912443 $16079 $17016 $17140 $17685 $18293 $18896 $19182 $19399019 $19930965 $20484932
Net Deficit After Subsidies and Debt Service ($668477) ($620796) ($0414) $287848 $320833 $556541 $561498 $810173 $359895 ($128044) ($613) ($539) ($898) ($1258) ($1667) ($2283) ($1901641) ($2229069) ($2664369)
Conversion to Cash Basis GASB Account (56067) (54256) (67377) (37636) (89548) (85641) (50017) - 0 - 0 0 0 0 $0 0 0 - 0 - 0 - 0 - 0
Conversion to Cash Basis 492710 550267 91781 (111037) (297407) (261709) (626297) (660147) (591809) 379 229 147 60 125 101 130 49745 48375 54220
Net Cash Balance from Previous Year 0000 0000 0000 23990 139174 0000 209191 0000 150026 0000 250569 0000 0000 0000 0000 0000 0000 0000 0000
Total Operating Exp + DS + Cash Conversions + PY C-O $11144 $11412 $11356 $11746 $12067 $12889362 $13414950 $13583937 $14470659 $16457999 $17495351 $17286526 $17744425 $18418197 $18997710 $19312017 $19448764 $19979340 $20539152
Total Operating Expenses with Cash Conversion $10270216 $10420127 $11307302 $12018911 $12701831 $13584063 $14558387 $14904231 $15504252 $15700774 $16786574 $16992579 $17624861 $18167420 $18795069 $19052755 $19349274 $19882590 $20430711
Baseline Net Cash Balance Before B-T-L Adjustments ($231834) ($124785) $23990 $139174 ($66122) $209191 ($114816) $150026 ($231914) $251 ($384) ($392) ($838) ($1133) ($1566) ($2153) ($1851896) ($2180695) ($2610148)
Below-the-Line Adjustments
FareToll Increases
FareToll Increase in March 2019 (4 Yield) - 0 $0 $0 $0 $0 $0 $0 - 0 - 0 - 0
FareToll Increase in March 2021 (4 Yield) - 0 $0 $0 $0 $283 $331 $332 333531 333568 334299
FareToll Increase in March 2023 (4 Yield) - 0 $0 $0 $0 $0 $0 $294 346386 346424 347183
FareToll Increase in March 2025 (4 Yield) - 0 $0 $0 $0 $0 $0 $0 - 0 273859 321624
Subsidy Impacts of 20212023 FareToll Increase - 0 $0 $0 $0 ($7) ($9) ($17) (18612) (25573) (26305)
$0000 $0 $0 $0 $275 $322 $609 $661306 $928278 $976801
CASH BALANCE AFTER FARE INCREASES $250569 ($384) ($392) ($838) ($850) ($1234) ($1821) ($1518365) ($1847127) ($2275849)
MTA Initiatives
MTA Efficiencies - Not Yet Implemented - 0 $0 $0 $0 $0 $0 $0 0000 0000 0000
0 - 0 $0 $0 $0 $0 $0 $0 - 0 - 0 - 0
0 - 0 $0 $0 $0 $0 $0 $0 - 0 - 0 - 0
$0000 $0 $0 $0 $0 $0 $0 $0000 $0000 $0000
Policy Actions
CAS Migration to Peoplesoft $0 $0 ($5) ($1) ($0) ($0) (0200) -02 -02 0
Fare Evasion Enforcement Strategy-Expenses $0 ($13) ($12) ($11) ($10) ($10) (9554) -9554483 -9554483 0
Fare Evasion Enforcement-Manhattan DA Forfeiture Fund $0 $11 $11 $10 $9 $0 - 0 0 0 0
Negotiated 1 CBA Reform $0 $0 $0 $0 $0 $0 - 0 0 0 0
MTA Reorganization $0 $8 $180 $371 $377 $377 377000 377 377 0
MTA Reorganization Costs $0 $0 ($10) ($27) ($2) $0 - 0 0 0 0
Drawdown 2019 General Reserve $0 $0 $165 $0 $0 $0 - 0 0 0 0
CBA Negotiated Reform - 1 Value $0 $36 $100 $173 $246 $323 323473 323473304484 323473304484 0
$0000 $0 $42 $429 $515 $620 $691 $690719 $690719 $690719
MTA Re-estimates
Additional Savings Actions $0000 $0 $0 $0 $0 $0 $0 $0000 $0000 $0000
Total Below-the-Line Adjustments $0 $73 $386 $757 $852 $1133 $1007 $1352025 $1618997 $1667520
Prior Year Carryover 495399 263336 138286 161986 301160 235038 444229 329413 479439 121 372 61 55 0 0 - 0 - 0 - 0 - 0
NET CASH BALANCE $263566 $138551 $162276 $301160 $235038 $444229 $329413 $479439 $247525 $372 $61 $55 ($26) ($281) ($433) ($1146) ($499871) ($561698) ($942628)
MTA February Financial Plan 2019-2022
Consolidated Statement Of Operations By Category ($ in millions)
Non-Reimbursable Final Adopted
Actual Actual Actual Actual Actual Actual Actual Actual Actual Actual Estimate Budget
2008 2009 2010 2011 2012 2013 2014 2015 2016 2017 2018 2019 2020 2021 2022 2023 2024 2025 2026
Operating Revenues
Farebox Revenue $4240923 $4350411 $4586377 $4999186 $5079138 $5501274 $5709200 $5961129 $6050182 $6172 $6153 $6122 $6144 $6134 $6144 $6174 $6435176 $6431979 $6446633
422 423 405 411 402 399 395 396 396 407 279 275 272 267 263 261 368 363 362
Student Fare - 0 - 0 - 0 - 0 - 0 - 0
Toll Revenue 1273974 1332115 1417046 1501589 1490982 1645193 1676445 1808901 1869693 1912 1967 1984 1990 1998 1998 2002 2133050 2137871 2143111
0127 0129 0125 0124 0118 0119 0116 0120 0122 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0122 0121 0120
Other Revenue 448616 461359 491355 510231 563839 753675 682424 689217 688374 653 662 705 733 757 743 755 825040 885381 887190
Capital and Other Reimbursements 0000 0000 0000 0000 0000 0000 0000 0000 0000 0000 0000 0000 0000 0000 0000 0000 0000 0000 0000
Total Operating Revenue $5963512 $6143885 $6494778 $7011006 $7133959 $7900142 $8068069 $8459247 $8608249 $8737 $8782 $8810 $8867 $8889 $8886 $8931 $9393266 $9455232 $9476934
Dedicated Taxes $3211585 $2366805 $2343537 $2511691 $2673119 $3097640 $3383498 $3582628 $3525829 $3257508 $3459 $3515 $3568 $3630 $3725 $3812 $3841433 $3880226 $3917215
PMT amp MTA Aid - 0 881784 1588677 1718286 1825824 1825328 1885069 1910947 1970760 1987035 $1965 $2152 $2225 $2295 $2368 $2442 2516095 2594604 2677041
New Funding Sources - 0 - 0 - 0 - 0 - 0 - 0 - 0 - 0 - 0 - 0 $508 $342 $385 $385 $385 $385 385000 385000 385000
StateLocal Taxes 556691 539046 544810 541733 536182 537527 539545 537819 537645 541005 $544 $552 $557 $562 $567 $572 576828 581933 583214
Other Funding Agreements 306594 363823 359489 375369 466625 432617 567391 563616 629855 630218 $701 $753 $671 $708 $758 $758 784755 804901 781159
BampT Operating Surplus Transfer 382565 363092 476059 554903 476575 614210 637553 750717 742909 740144 $702 $721 $782 $801 $789 $707 730476 695303 688833
Dedicated Taxes and StateLocal Subsidies $4457434 $4514550 $5312572 $5701982 $5978325 $6507322 $7013056 $7345727 $7406998 $7155909 $7879 $8035 $8188 $8381 $8592 $8676 $8834588 $8941967 $9032462
$0000 $0000 $0000 $0000 $0000 $0000 $0000 $0000 $0000
Less Interagency Subsidy and Surplus Transfers (382565) (363092) (476059) (554903) (476575) (614210) (637553) (750717) (742909) (740144) ($702) ($721) ($782) ($801) ($789) ($707) (730476) (695303) (688833)
Total Subsidies $4074870 $4151458 $4836513 $5147079 $5501750 $5893111 $6375503 $6595010 $6664088 $6416 $7242 $7238 $7370 $7576 $7807 $7969 $8104112 $8246664 $8343629
Dedicated Taxes as a of Total Revenues + Subs - PMT 320 251 241 241 247 259 269 273 265 247 $0 $0 $0 $0 $0 $0 256 257 259
Total Revenues + Subsidies $10038382 $10295342 $11331292 $12158085 $12635709 $13793254 $14443571 $15054257 $15272337 $15152 $16023 $16048 $16237 $16465 $16693 $16900 $17497378 $17701896 $17820563
Operating Expenses
Labor Expenses
Payroll $4087376 $4163330 $4171374 $4160261 $4193658 $4332829 $4671664 $4695823 $4838741 $5020713 $5211 $5328 $5422 $5498 $5624 $5710 $5860206 $5982960 $6107107
Overtime 471675 499307 443227 538647 574316 620701 730200 755071 771495 934100 $1066 $910 $838 $859 $877 $899 917296 935002 951324
Health amp Welfare 684945 688899 738189 809638 812857 895714 961902 1050100 1172304 1208786 $1230 $1341 $1414 $1489 $1583 $1674 1797938 1922668 2071273
OPEB Current Payment 318501 346316 355716 394218 413164 472619 479079 501716 562233 563754 $604 $645 $704 $766 $835 $910 982025 1060022 1142795
Pensions 897450 1021229 1029710 1074598 1328441 1301975 1304355 1248726 1370474 1345308 $1336 $1494 $1461 $1462 $1403 $1347 1357887 1369071 1380572
Other-Fringe Benefits 502739 517194 539996 581661 650430 694680 784143 861079 947870 792151 $881 $869 $897 $930 $956 $976 1001185 1021007 1040170
Reimbursable Overhead (310555) (322230) (345154) (324006) (309399) (321390) (349770) (380212) (423759) (491807) ($528) ($471) ($430) ($412) ($397) ($395) (396136) (405509) (413165)
Labor Expenses $6652131 $6914045 $6933059 $7235017 $7663467 $7997128 $8581574 $8732302 $9239358 $9373 $9920 $10039 $10436 $10787 $11097 $11413 $11520401 $11885220 $12280075
PayrollOvertime Exp as a of Total Operating+DS $0426 $0427 $0407 $0396 $0387 $0374 $0389 $0383 $0376 $0385 $0349 $0347 $0345
Labor Exp (wo Reimb OH) as a of Total Oper+DS $0650 $0663 $0642 $0637 $0647 $0628 $0643 $0640 $0648 $0638 $0614 $0617 $0620
PayrollOvertime Exp as a of Total Operating Exp $0496 $0490 $0483 $0473 $0465 $0453 $0464 $0459 $0450 $0461 $0426 $0420 $0416
Labor Exp (wo Reimb OH) as a of Total Oper Exp $0758 $0761 $0762 $0761 $0777 $0761 $0768 $0768 $0776 $0763 $0748 $0747 $0747
Non-Labor Expenses
Electric Power $306500 $317934 $325137 $457269 $471514 $493346 $515540 $473762 $406372 $430381 $474918 $451304 $463523 $482662 $539624 $571182 $589565 $618283 $648255
Traction Power
Non-Traction Power
Fuel 287033 180294 189942 282735 251763 259252 267494 162283 124684 150481 185580 190348 187592 183168 181484 182259 182476 184281 186170
Revenue Vehicle Fuel
Non-Revenue Fuel
Insurance 28902 34012 9819 14363 7617 38654 50739 57190 (20634) (2715) 11488 8532 15803 22918 29411 36048 28232 25538 19483
Claims 152114 238104 285418 315547 135652 299875 269167 331023 463959 526053 376480 378570 386981 391333 395228 404397 417667 428660 437683
Paratransit Service Contracts 299013 370094 379761 348553 360500 366751 365599 379271 383704 392850 452190 482751 501230 518038 547829 581114 604766 643217 684112
Maintenance and Other Operating Contracts 594215 562456 541716 451137 451766 496743 549018 579289 630924 695251 779331 897801 833038 883805 871671 879468 880053 898882 915477
Professional Service Contracts 196930 199164 203084 226205 276998 297201 283005 379814 399706 507062 575742 557476 484911 479376 489510 499724 520826 537109 547291
Materials amp Supplies 532534 526191 511206 438310 430804 475127 526725 543225 585607 588115 667700 686666 687745 692131 697268 711988 741335 777460 793419
Other Business Expenses 155466 184142 189637 169857 143807 167198 179701 195598 192576 217254 225494 230595 225293 240279 242193 244907 228861 240258 241690
Non-Labor Expenses $2552708 $2612391 $2635720 $2703976 $2530421 $2894147 $3006988 $3101454 $3166897 3505 3749 3884 3786 3894 3994 4111 $4193782 $4353689 $4473580
Other Expense Adjustments
Other ($13712) ($14750) ($18292) ($2289) $62593 $46175 $44973 $37007 $47404 49 134 158 84 36 22 23 $23516 $24069 $24637
General Reserve 0000 0000 0000 0000 0000 - 0 - 0 - 0 - 0 0 0 165 170 175 180 185 190000 195000 205000
Other Expense Adjustments ($13712) ($14750) ($18292) ($2289) $62593 $46175 $44973 $37007 $47404 $49379 $134 $323 $254 $211 $202 $208 $213516 $219069 $229637
Gap Closing Expenses $7675394
Additional Actions for Budget Balance Expense Impact $0000 $0000 $0000 $0000 $0000 $0000 $0000 $0000 $0000 $0000 $0000 $0000 $0000 $0000 $0000 $0000 $0000 $0000 $0000
Total Operating Expenses Before Non-Cash Liability Adjs $9191127 $9511685 $9550486 $9936705 $10256481 $10937450 $11633535 $11870763 $12453659 $12927116 $13802910 $14246122 $14475644 $14891445 $15293262 $15732241 $15927699 $16457978 $16983292
Non-Cash Liability Adjustments
Depreciation $1790981 $1940576 $1980681 $2019378 $2148820 $2174302 $2266280 $2442777 $2442941 $2607970 $2804571 $2784812 $2842737 $2908533 $2977025 $3051834 $3109882 $3169371 $3230301
OPEB Obligation 1348962 1104827 1167070 1706939 1785881 1920189 2035457 1489656 1562261 1567381 0000 (0000) (0000) (0000) (0000) 0000 0000 (0000) (0000)
GASB 75 OPEB Expense Adjustment 0000 0000 0000 0000 0000 0000 0000 0000 0000 0000 1047747 1457230 1628196 1748560 1823313 1898497 1952374 2006482 2061993
GASB 68 Pension Expense Adjustment 0000 0000 0000 0000 0000 0000 0000 (410019) (218911) (168119) (373022) (220864) (271921) (342847) (318372) (242446) (237864) (234492) (230942)
Environmental Remediation 42249 6062 18621 59079 24742 14257 20556 20576 11691 13468 105615 6000 6000 6000 6000 6000 6000 6000 6000
Non-Cash Liability Adjustments $3182192 $3051466 $3166371 $3785396 $3959443 $4108749 $4322293 $3542990 $3797981 $4020699 $3584911 $4027178 $4205012 $4320246 $4487966 $4713886 $4830392 $4947361 $5067352
Total Operating Expenses After Non-Cash Liability Adjs $12373319 $12563151 $12716857 $13722101 $14215924 $15046199 $15955827 $15413753 $16251641 $16947815 $17387821 $18273301 $18680657 $19211690 $19781228 $20446127 $20758090 $21405338 $22050644
Less BampT Depreciation $77213 $80097 $77846 $86545 $87926 $91345 $104039 $109783 $135035 $240957 $148686 $151977 $158779 $169848 $181689 $194355 $194355 $194355 $194355
BampT Other Post Employment Benefits 66323 50967 54831 66686 73055 76641 71148 62457 60441 78106 32297 22256 20303 22870 28694 33918 36169 38411 40604
Net Operating Deficit Before Subsidies and Debt Service ($6409807) ($6419266) ($6222079) ($6711095) ($7081966) ($7146057) ($7887759) ($6954506) ($7643392) ($8211234) ($8606220) ($9463506) ($9813560) ($10322912) ($10895644) ($11515498) ($11364824) ($11950106) ($12573710)
Conversion to Cash Basis Non-Cash Liability Adjs ($3182192) ($3051466) ($3166371) ($3785396) ($3959443) ($4108749) ($4322293) ($3542990) ($3797981) ($4020699) ($3584911) ($4027178) ($4205012) ($4320246) ($4487966) ($4713886) ($4830392) ($4947361) ($5067352)
Total Operating Expenses $9191127 $9511685 $9550486 $9936705 $10256481 $10937450 $11633535 $11870763 $12453659 $12927 $13803 $14246 $14476 $14891 $15293 $15732 $15927699 $16457978 $16983292
Debt Service Expenses $1515733 $1404454 $1781220 $1933532 $2058395 $2299262 $2248538 $2373321 $2458783 $2525 $2559 $2692 $2840 $3080 $3223 $3450 $3471321 $3472987 $3501639
Total Expenses + Debt Service $10706859 $10916139 $11331706 $11870237 $12314876 $13236712 $13882073 $14244084 $14912443 $15452 $16362 $16938 $17316 $17971 $18516 $19182 $19399019 $19930965 $20484932
Net Deficit After Subsidies and Debt Service ($668477) ($620796) ($0414) $287848 $320833 $556541 $561498 $810173 $359895 ($299965) ($339) ($890) ($1079) ($1506) ($1823) ($2283) ($1901641) ($2229069) ($2664369)
Conversion to Cash Basis GASB Account (56067) (54256) (67377) (37636) (89548) (85641) (50017) - 0 - 0 0 0 0 $0 0 0 - 0 - 0 - 0 - 0
Conversion to Cash Basis 492710 550267 91781 (111037) (297407) (261709) (626297) (660147) (591809) 174 296 363 188 (17) 88 130 49745 48375 54220
Net Cash Balance from Previous Year 0000 0000 0000 23990 139174 0000 209191 0000 150026 0000 0000 0000 0000 0000 0000 0000 0000 0000 0000
Total Operating Exp + DS + Cash Conversions + PY C-O $11144 $11412 $11356 $11746 $12067 $12889362 $13414950 $13583937 $14470659 $15625875 $16658585 $17300293 $17504155 $17954574 $18604130 $19312017 $19448764 $19979340 $20539152
Total Operating Expenses with Cash Conversion $10270216 $10420127 $11307302 $12018911 $12701831 $13584063 $14558387 $14904231 $15504252 $15278749 $16065734 $16575223 $17128079 $17987951 $18427778 $19052755 $19349274 $19882590 $20430711
Baseline Net Cash Balance Before B-T-L Adjustments ($231834) ($124785) $23990 $139174 ($66122) $209191 ($114816) $150026 ($231914) ($126) ($43) ($527) ($891) ($1523) ($1735) ($2153) ($1851896) ($2180695) ($2610148)
Below-the-Line Adjustments
FareToll Increases
FareToll Increase in March 2019 (4 Yield) - 0 $0 $0 $0 $0 $0 $0 - 0 - 0 - 0
FareToll Increase in March 2021 (4 Yield) - 0 $0 $0 $0 $283 $331 $332 333531 333568 334299
FareToll Increase in March 2023 (4 Yield) - 0 $0 $0 $0 $0 $0 $294 346386 346424 347183
FareToll Increase in March 2025 (4 Yield) - 0 $0 $0 $0 $0 $0 $0 - 0 273859 321624
Subsidy Impacts of 20212023 FareToll Increase - 0 $0 $0 $0 ($7) ($9) ($17) (18612) (25573) (26305)
$0000 $0 $0 $0 $275 $322 $609 $661306 $928278 $976801
CASH BALANCE AFTER FARE INCREASES ($126402) ($43) ($527) ($891) ($1241) ($1404) ($1821) ($1518365) ($1847127) ($2275849)
MTA Initiatives
MTA Efficiencies - Not Yet Implemented - 0 $0 $0 $0 $0 $0 $0 0000 0000 0000
0 - 0 $0 $0 $0 $0 $0 $0 - 0 - 0 - 0
0 - 0 $0 $0 $0 $0 $0 $0 - 0 - 0 - 0
$0000 $0 $0 $0 $0 $0 $0 $0000 $0000 $0000
Policy Actions
CAS Migration to Peoplesoft $0 $0 ($5) ($1) ($0) ($0) (0200) -02 -02 0
Fare Evasion Enforcement Strategy-Expenses $0 ($13) ($12) ($11) ($10) ($10) (9554) -9554483 -9554483 0
Fare Evasion Enforcement-Manhattan DA Forfeiture Fund $0 $11 $11 $10 $9 $0 - 0 0 0 0
Negotiated 1 CBA Reform $0 $0 $0 $0 $0 $0 - 0 0 0 0
MTA Reorganization $0 $8 $180 $371 $377 $377 377000 377 377 0
MTA Reorganization Costs $0 $0 ($10) ($27) ($2) $0 - 0 0 0 0
Drawdown 2019 General Reserve $0 $0 $165 $0 $0 $0 - 0 0 0 0
CBA Negotiated Reform - 1 Value $0 $36 $100 $173 $246 $323 323473 323473304484 323473304484 0
$0000 $0 $42 $429 $515 $620 $691 $690719 $690719 $690719
MTA Re-estimates
Additional Savings Actions $0000 $0 $0 $0 $0 $0 $0 $0000 $0000 $0000
Total Below-the-Line Adjustments $0 $0 $459 $413 $709 $760 $1007 $1352025 $1618997 $1667520
Prior Year Carryover 495399 263336 138286 161986 301160 235038 444229 329413 479439 248 121 79 11 0 0 - 0 - 0 - 0 - 0
NET CASH BALANCE $263566 $138551 $162276 $301160 $235038 $444229 $329413 $479439 $247525 $121 $79 $11 ($467) ($814) ($976) ($1146) ($499871) ($561698) ($942628)
By Revenue Source
(includes faretoll increases)
($ in millions)
Farebox Revenue $6389
Toll Revenue 2121
Other Revenue 684
Dedicated Taxes 6191
State and Local amp Other 1228
Timing (Cash Adjustments) 135
Total $16748
By Expense Category
(includes below-the-line adjustments)
($ in millions)
Payroll $5422
Overtime 838
Health amp Welfare 2118
Pension 1461
Other Labor 466
Total Labor $10306
Non-Labor + Other Exp Adj 4004
Debt Service 2830
BTL Adjustments for Expenses 2 (386)
Total $16754
By Revenue Source
(includes faretoll increases)
($ in millions)
Farebox Revenue $6389
Toll Revenue 2121
Other Revenue 684
Taxes 6178
State and Local amp Other 557
Other Funding Agreements 671
Other 1 208
Total $16809
By Expense Category
(includes below-the-line adjustments)
($ in millions)
Payroll $5392
Overtime 811
Health amp Welfare 2129
Pension 1354
Other Labor 400
Total Labor $10086
Non-Labor 4205
Debt Service 2692
BTL Adjustments for Expenses (251)
Total $16732
MTA July Financial Plan 2019-2022
Consolidated Statement Of Operations By Category ($ in millions)
Non-Reimbursable Mid-Year Preliminary
Actual Actual Actual Actual Actual Actual Actual Actual Actual Actual Forecast Budget
2008 2009 2010 2011 2012 2013 2014 2015 2016 2017 2018 2019 2020 2021 2022 2023 2024 2025 2026
Operating Revenues
Farebox Revenue $4240923 $4350411 $4586377 $4999186 $5079138 $5501274 $5709200 $5961129 $6050182 $6172 $6305 $6389 $6373 $6384 $6393 $6174 $6435176 $6431979 $6446633
422 423 405 411 402 399 395 396 396 407 384 385 380 375 371 261 368 363 362
Student Fare - 0 - 0 - 0 - 0 - 0 - 0
Toll Revenue 1273974 1332115 1417046 1501589 1490982 1645193 1676445 1808901 1869693 1912 2088 2121 2129 2129 2131 2002 2133050 2137871 2143111
0127 0129 0125 0124 0118 0119 0116 0120 0122 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0122 0121 0120
Other Revenue 448616 461359 491355 510231 563839 753675 682424 689217 688374 653 696 684 704 719 737 755 825040 885381 887190
Capital and Other Reimbursements 0000 0000 0000 0000 0000 0000 0000 0000 0000 0000 0000 0000 0000 0000 0000 0000 0000 0000 0000
Total Operating Revenue $5963512 $6143885 $6494778 $7011006 $7133959 $7900142 $8068069 $8459247 $8608249 $8737 $9089 $9195 $9206 $9232 $9260 $8931 $9393266 $9455232 $9476934
Dedicated Taxes $3211585 $2366805 $2343537 $2511691 $2673119 $3097640 $3383498 $3582628 $3525829 $3257508 $3459 $3515 $3568 $3630 $3725 $3812 $3841433 $3880226 $3917215
PMT amp MTA Aid - 0 881784 1588677 1718286 1825824 1825328 1885069 1910947 1970760 1987035 $1965 $2152 $2225 $2295 $2368 $2442 2516095 2594604 2677041
New Funding Sources - 0 - 0 - 0 - 0 - 0 - 0 - 0 - 0 - 0 - 0 $508 $342 $385 $385 $385 $385 385000 385000 385000
StateLocal Taxes 556691 539046 544810 541733 536182 537527 539545 537819 537645 541005 $544 $552 $557 $562 $567 $572 576828 581933 583214
Other Funding Agreements 306594 363823 359489 375369 466625 432617 567391 563616 629855 630218 $701 $753 $671 $708 $758 $758 784755 804901 781159
BampT Operating Surplus Transfer 382565 363092 476059 554903 476575 614210 637553 750717 742909 740144 $702 $721 $782 $801 $789 $707 730476 695303 688833
Dedicated Taxes and StateLocal Subsidies $4457434 $4514550 $5312572 $5701982 $5978325 $6507322 $7013056 $7345727 $7406998 $7155909 $7879 $8035 $8188 $8381 $8592 $8676 $8834588 $8941967 $9032462
$0000 $0000 $0000 $0000 $0000 $0000 $0000 $0000 $0000
Less Interagency Subsidy and Surplus Transfers (382565) (363092) (476059) (554903) (476575) (614210) (637553) (750717) (742909) (740144) ($702) ($721) ($782) ($801) ($789) ($707) (730476) (695303) (688833)
Total Subsidies $4074870 $4151458 $4836513 $5147079 $5501750 $5893111 $6375503 $6595010 $6664088 $6416 $7314 $7406 $7581 $7803 $7969 $7969 $8104112 $8246664 $8343629
Dedicated Taxes as a of Total Revenues + Subs - PMT 320 251 241 241 247 259 269 273 265 247 $0 $0 $0 $0 $0 $0 256 257 259
Total Revenues + Subsidies $10038382 $10295342 $11331292 $12158085 $12635709 $13793254 $14443571 $15054257 $15272337 $15152 $16403 $16601 $16787 $17035 $17229 $16900 $17497378 $17701896 $17820563
Operating Expenses
Labor Expenses
Payroll $4087376 $4163330 $4171374 $4160261 $4193658 $4332829 $4671664 $4695823 $4838741 $5020713 $5211 $5328 $5422 $5498 $5624 $5710 $5860206 $5982960 $6107107
Overtime 471675 499307 443227 538647 574316 620701 730200 755071 771495 934100 $1066 $910 $838 $859 $877 $899 917296 935002 951324
Health amp Welfare 684945 688899 738189 809638 812857 895714 961902 1050100 1172304 1208786 $1230 $1341 $1414 $1489 $1583 $1674 1797938 1922668 2071273
OPEB Current Payment 318501 346316 355716 394218 413164 472619 479079 501716 562233 563754 $604 $645 $704 $766 $835 $910 982025 1060022 1142795
Pensions 897450 1021229 1029710 1074598 1328441 1301975 1304355 1248726 1370474 1345308 $1336 $1494 $1461 $1462 $1403 $1347 1357887 1369071 1380572
Other-Fringe Benefits 502739 517194 539996 581661 650430 694680 784143 861079 947870 792151 $881 $869 $897 $930 $956 $976 1001185 1021007 1040170
Reimbursable Overhead (310555) (322230) (345154) (324006) (309399) (321390) (349770) (380212) (423759) (491807) ($528) ($471) ($430) ($412) ($397) ($395) (396136) (405509) (413165)
Labor Expenses $6652131 $6914045 $6933059 $7235017 $7663467 $7997128 $8581574 $8732302 $9239358 $9373 $10116 $10306 $10592 $10881 $11121 $11413 $11520401 $11885220 $12280075
PayrollOvertime Exp as a of Total Operating+DS $0426 $0427 $0407 $0396 $0387 $0374 $0389 $0383 $0376 $0385 $0367 $0365 $0359 $0355 $0350 $0349 $0347 $0345
Labor Exp (wo Reimb OH) as a of Total Oper+DS $0650 $0663 $0642 $0637 $0647 $0628 $0643 $0640 $0648 $0638 $0622 $0626 $0622 $0616 $0609 $0614 $0617 $0620
PayrollOvertime Exp as a of Total Operating Exp $0496 $0490 $0483 $0473 $0465 $0453 $0464 $0459 $0450 $0461 $0435 $0438 $0434 $0433 $0430 $0426 $0420 $0416
Labor Exp (wo Reimb OH) as a of Total Oper Exp $0758 $0761 $0762 $0761 $0777 $0761 $0768 $0768 $0776 $0763 $0739 $0750 $0751 $0750 $0749 $0748 $0747 $0747
Non-Labor Expenses
Electric Power $306500 $317934 $325137 $457269 $471514 $493346 $515540 $473762 $406372 $430381 $451503 $473177 $493090 $532413 $561955 $571182 $589565 $618283 $648255
Traction Power
Non-Traction Power
Fuel 287033 180294 189942 282735 251763 259252 267494 162283 124684 150481 182778 182981 176333 173681 176920 182259 182476 184281 186170
Revenue Vehicle Fuel
Non-Revenue Fuel
Insurance 28902 34012 9819 14363 7617 38654 50739 57190 (20634) (2715) 5608 15623 23118 26855 28309 36048 28232 25538 19483
Claims 152114 238104 285418 315547 135652 299875 269167 331023 463959 526053 387557 394211 392547 398256 406112 404397 417667 428660 437683
Paratransit Service Contracts 299013 370094 379761 348553 360500 366751 365599 379271 383704 392850 494751 488330 505538 535329 568614 581114 604766 643217 684112
Maintenance and Other Operating Contracts 594215 562456 541716 451137 451766 496743 549018 579289 630924 695251 840168 797428 833534 836606 854471 879468 880053 898882 915477
Professional Service Contracts 196930 199164 203084 226205 276998 297201 283005 379814 399706 507062 607838 502858 494814 504103 513895 499724 520826 537109 547291
Materials amp Supplies 532534 526191 511206 438310 430804 475127 526725 543225 585607 588115 689010 679895 697976 711281 715758 711988 741335 777460 793419
Other Business Expenses 155466 184142 189637 169857 143807 167198 179701 195598 192576 217254 218196 213551 224459 226170 228457 244907 228861 240258 241690
Non-Labor Expenses $2552708 $2612391 $2635720 $2703976 $2530421 $2894147 $3006988 $3101454 $3166897 3505 3877 3748 3841 3945 4054 4111 $4193782 $4353689 $4473580
Other Expense Adjustments
Other ($13712) ($14750) ($18292) ($2289) $62593 $46175 $44973 $37007 $47404 49 175 86 36 22 23 23 $23516 $24069 $24637
General Reserve 0000 0000 0000 0000 0000 - 0 - 0 - 0 - 0 0 165 170 175 180 185 185 190000 195000 205000
Other Expense Adjustments ($13712) ($14750) ($18292) ($2289) $62593 $46175 $44973 $37007 $47404 $49379 $340 $256 $211 $202 $208 $208 $213516 $219069 $229637
Gap Closing Expenses $7675394
Additional Actions for Budget Balance Expense Impact $0000 $0000 $0000 $0000 $0000 $0000 $0000 $0000 $0000 $0000 $0000 $0000 $0000 $0000 $0000 $0000 $0000 $0000 $0000
Total Operating Expenses Before Non-Cash Liability Adjs $9191127 $9511685 $9550486 $9936705 $10256481 $10937450 $11633535 $11870763 $12453659 $12927116 $14332772 $14309678 $14643965 $15027767 $15383584 $15732241 $15927699 $16457978 $16983292
Non-Cash Liability Adjustments
Depreciation $1790981 $1940576 $1980681 $2019378 $2148820 $2174302 $2266280 $2442777 $2442941 $2607970 $2804571 $2784812 $2842737 $2908533 $2977025 $3051834 $3109882 $3169371 $3230301
OPEB Obligation 1348962 1104827 1167070 1706939 1785881 1920189 2035457 1489656 1562261 1567381 0000 (0000) (0000) (0000) (0000) 0000 0000 (0000) (0000)
GASB 75 OPEB Expense Adjustment 0000 0000 0000 0000 0000 0000 0000 0000 0000 0000 1047747 1457230 1628196 1748560 1823313 1898497 1952374 2006482 2061993
GASB 68 Pension Expense Adjustment 0000 0000 0000 0000 0000 0000 0000 (410019) (218911) (168119) (373022) (220864) (271921) (342847) (318372) (242446) (237864) (234492) (230942)
Environmental Remediation 42249 6062 18621 59079 24742 14257 20556 20576 11691 13468 105615 6000 6000 6000 6000 6000 6000 6000 6000
Non-Cash Liability Adjustments $3182192 $3051466 $3166371 $3785396 $3959443 $4108749 $4322293 $3542990 $3797981 $4020699 $3584911 $4027178 $4205012 $4320246 $4487966 $4713886 $4830392 $4947361 $5067352
Total Operating Expenses After Non-Cash Liability Adjs $12373319 $12563151 $12716857 $13722101 $14215924 $15046199 $15955827 $15413753 $16251641 $16947815 $17917683 $18336856 $18848977 $19348013 $19871550 $20446127 $20758090 $21405338 $22050644
Less BampT Depreciation $77213 $80097 $77846 $86545 $87926 $91345 $104039 $109783 $135035 $240957 $148686 $151977 $158779 $169848 $181689 $194355 $194355 $194355 $194355
BampT Other Post Employment Benefits 66323 50967 54831 66686 73055 76641 71148 62457 60441 78106 32297 22256 20303 22870 28694 33918 36169 38411 40604
Net Operating Deficit Before Subsidies and Debt Service ($6409807) ($6419266) ($6222079) ($6711095) ($7081966) ($7146057) ($7887759) ($6954506) ($7643392) ($8211234) ($8829030) ($9141907) ($9642826) ($10116260) ($10611154) ($11515498) ($11364824) ($11950106) ($12573710)
Conversion to Cash Basis Non-Cash Liability Adjs ($3182192) ($3051466) ($3166371) ($3785396) ($3959443) ($4108749) ($4322293) ($3542990) ($3797981) ($4020699) ($3584911) ($4027178) ($4205012) ($4320246) ($4487966) ($4713886) ($4830392) ($4947361) ($5067352)
Total Operating Expenses $9191127 $9511685 $9550486 $9936705 $10256481 $10937450 $11633535 $11870763 $12453659 $12927 $14333 $14310 $14644 $15028 $15384 $15732 $15927699 $16457978 $16983292
Debt Service Expenses $1515733 $1404454 $1781220 $1933532 $2058395 $2299262 $2248538 $2373321 $2458783 $2525 $2683 $2830 $3041 $3265 $3513 $3450 $3471321 $3472987 $3501639
Total Expenses + Debt Service $10706859 $10916139 $11331706 $11870237 $12314876 $13236712 $13882073 $14244084 $14912443 $15452 $17016 $17140 $17685 $18293 $18896 $19182 $19399019 $19930965 $20484932
Net Deficit After Subsidies and Debt Service ($668477) ($620796) ($0414) $287848 $320833 $556541 $561498 $810173 $359895 ($299965) ($613) ($539) ($898) ($1258) ($1667) ($2283) ($1901641) ($2229069) ($2664369)
Conversion to Cash Basis GASB Account (56067) (54256) (67377) (37636) (89548) (85641) (50017) - 0 - 0 0 0 0 $0 0 0 - 0 - 0 - 0 - 0
Conversion to Cash Basis 492710 550267 91781 (111037) (297407) (261709) (626297) (660147) (591809) 174 229 147 60 125 101 130 49745 48375 54220
Net Cash Balance from Previous Year 0000 0000 0000 23990 139174 0000 209191 0000 150026 0000 0000 0000 0000 0000 0000 0000 0000 0000 0000
Total Operating Exp + DS + Cash Conversions + PY C-O $11144 $11412 $11356 $11746 $12067 $12889362 $13414950 $13583937 $14470659 $15625875 $17244782 $17286526 $17744425 $18418197 $18997710 $19312017 $19448764 $19979340 $20539152
Total Operating Expenses with Cash Conversion $10270216 $10420127 $11307302 $12018911 $12701831 $13584063 $14558387 $14904231 $15504252 $15278749 $16786574 $16992579 $17624861 $18167420 $18795069 $19052755 $19349274 $19882590 $20430711
Baseline Net Cash Balance Before B-T-L Adjustments ($231834) ($124785) $23990 $139174 ($66122) $209191 ($114816) $150026 ($231914) ($126) ($384) ($392) ($838) ($1133) ($1566) ($2153) ($1851896) ($2180695) ($2610148)
Below-the-Line Adjustments
FareToll Increases
FareToll Increase in March 2019 (4 Yield) - 0 $0 $0 $0 $0 $0 $0 - 0 - 0 - 0
FareToll Increase in March 2021 (4 Yield) - 0 $0 $0 $0 $283 $331 $332 333531 333568 334299
FareToll Increase in March 2023 (4 Yield) - 0 $0 $0 $0 $0 $0 $294 346386 346424 347183
FareToll Increase in March 2025 (4 Yield) - 0 $0 $0 $0 $0 $0 $0 - 0 273859 321624
Subsidy Impacts of 20212023 FareToll Increase - 0 $0 $0 $0 ($7) ($9) ($17) (18612) (25573) (26305)
$0000 $0 $0 $0 $275 $322 $609 $661306 $928278 $976801
CASH BALANCE AFTER FARE INCREASES ($126402) ($384) ($392) ($838) ($850) ($1234) ($1821) ($1518365) ($1847127) ($2275849)
MTA Initiatives
MTA Efficiencies - Not Yet Implemented - 0 $0 $0 $0 $0 $0 $0 0000 0000 0000
0 - 0 $0 $0 $0 $0 $0 $0 - 0 - 0 - 0
0 - 0 $0 $0 $0 $0 $0 $0 - 0 - 0 - 0
$0000 $0 $0 $0 $0 $0 $0 $0000 $0000 $0000
Policy Actions
CAS Migration to Peoplesoft $0 $0 ($5) ($1) ($0) ($0) (0200) -02 -02 0
Fare Evasion Enforcement Strategy-Expenses $0 ($13) ($12) ($11) ($10) ($10) (9554) -9554483 -9554483 0
Fare Evasion Enforcement-Manhattan DA Forfeiture Fund $0 $11 $11 $10 $9 $0 - 0 0 0 0
Negotiated 1 CBA Reform $0 $0 $0 $0 $0 $0 - 0 0 0 0
MTA Reorganization $0 $8 $180 $371 $377 $377 377000 377 377 0
MTA Reorganization Costs $0 $0 ($10) ($27) ($2) $0 - 0 0 0 0
Drawdown 2019 General Reserve $0 $0 $165 $0 $0 $0 - 0 0 0 0
CBA Negotiated Reform - 1 Value $0 $36 $100 $173 $246 $323 323473 323473304484 323473304484 0
$0000 $0 $42 $429 $515 $620 $691 $690719 $690719 $690719
MTA Re-estimates
Additional Savings Actions $0000 $0 $0 $0 $0 $0 $0 $0000 $0000 $0000
Total Below-the-Line Adjustments $0 $73 $386 $757 $852 $1133 $1007 $1352025 $1618997 $1667520
Prior Year Carryover 495399 263336 138286 161986 301160 235038 444229 329413 479439 248 372 61 55 0 0 - 0 - 0 - 0 - 0
NET CASH BALANCE $263566 $138551 $162276 $301160 $235038 $444229 $329413 $479439 $247525 $121 $61 $55 ($26) ($281) ($433) ($1146) ($499871) ($561698) ($942628)
MTA February Financial Plan 2019-2022
Consolidated Statement Of Operations By Category ($ in millions)
Non-Reimbursable Final Adopted
Actual Actual Actual Actual Actual Actual Actual Actual Actual Actual Estimate Budget
2008 2009 2010 2011 2012 2013 2014 2015 2016 2017 2018 2019 2020 2021 2022 2023 2024 2025 2026
Operating Revenues
Farebox Revenue $4240923 $4350411 $4586377 $4999186 $5079138 $5501274 $5709200 $5961129 $6050182 $6172 $6153 $6122 $6144 $6134 $6144 $6174 $6435176 $6431979 $6446633
422 423 405 411 402 399 395 396 396 407 279 275 272 267 263 261 368 363 362
Student Fare - 0 - 0 - 0 - 0 - 0 - 0
Toll Revenue 1273974 1332115 1417046 1501589 1490982 1645193 1676445 1808901 1869693 1912 1967 1984 1990 1998 1998 2002 2133050 2137871 2143111
0127 0129 0125 0124 0118 0119 0116 0120 0122 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0122 0121 0120
Other Revenue 448616 461359 491355 510231 563839 753675 682424 689217 688374 653 662 705 733 757 743 755 825040 885381 887190
Capital and Other Reimbursements 0000 0000 0000 0000 0000 0000 0000 0000 0000 0000 0000 0000 0000 0000 0000 0000 0000 0000 0000
Total Operating Revenue $5963512 $6143885 $6494778 $7011006 $7133959 $7900142 $8068069 $8459247 $8608249 $8737 $8782 $8810 $8867 $8889 $8886 $8931 $9393266 $9455232 $9476934
Dedicated Taxes $3211585 $2366805 $2343537 $2511691 $2673119 $3097640 $3383498 $3582628 $3525829 $3257508 $3459 $3515 $3568 $3630 $3725 $3812 $3841433 $3880226 $3917215
PMT amp MTA Aid - 0 881784 1588677 1718286 1825824 1825328 1885069 1910947 1970760 1987035 $1965 $2152 $2225 $2295 $2368 $2442 2516095 2594604 2677041
New Funding Sources - 0 - 0 - 0 - 0 - 0 - 0 - 0 - 0 - 0 - 0 $508 $342 $385 $385 $385 $385 385000 385000 385000
StateLocal Taxes 556691 539046 544810 541733 536182 537527 539545 537819 537645 541005 $544 $552 $557 $562 $567 $572 576828 581933 583214
Other Funding Agreements 306594 363823 359489 375369 466625 432617 567391 563616 629855 630218 $701 $753 $671 $708 $758 $758 784755 804901 781159
BampT Operating Surplus Transfer 382565 363092 476059 554903 476575 614210 637553 750717 742909 740144 $702 $721 $782 $801 $789 $707 730476 695303 688833
Dedicated Taxes and StateLocal Subsidies $4457434 $4514550 $5312572 $5701982 $5978325 $6507322 $7013056 $7345727 $7406998 $7155909 $7879 $8035 $8188 $8381 $8592 $8676 $8834588 $8941967 $9032462
$0000 $0000 $0000 $0000 $0000 $0000 $0000 $0000 $0000
Less Interagency Subsidy and Surplus Transfers (382565) (363092) (476059) (554903) (476575) (614210) (637553) (750717) (742909) (740144) ($702) ($721) ($782) ($801) ($789) ($707) (730476) (695303) (688833)
Total Subsidies $4074870 $4151458 $4836513 $5147079 $5501750 $5893111 $6375503 $6595010 $6664088 $6416 $7242 $7238 $7370 $7576 $7807 $7969 $8104112 $8246664 $8343629
Dedicated Taxes as a of Total Revenues + Subs - PMT 320 251 241 241 247 259 269 273 265 247 $0 $0 $0 $0 $0 $0 256 257 259
Total Revenues + Subsidies $10038382 $10295342 $11331292 $12158085 $12635709 $13793254 $14443571 $15054257 $15272337 $15152 $16023 $16048 $16237 $16465 $16693 $16900 $17497378 $17701896 $17820563
Operating Expenses
Labor Expenses
Payroll $4087376 $4163330 $4171374 $4160261 $4193658 $4332829 $4671664 $4695823 $4838741 $5020713 $5211 $5328 $5422 $5498 $5624 $5710 $5860206 $5982960 $6107107
Overtime 471675 499307 443227 538647 574316 620701 730200 755071 771495 934100 $1066 $910 $838 $859 $877 $899 917296 935002 951324
Health amp Welfare 684945 688899 738189 809638 812857 895714 961902 1050100 1172304 1208786 $1230 $1341 $1414 $1489 $1583 $1674 1797938 1922668 2071273
OPEB Current Payment 318501 346316 355716 394218 413164 472619 479079 501716 562233 563754 $604 $645 $704 $766 $835 $910 982025 1060022 1142795
Pensions 897450 1021229 1029710 1074598 1328441 1301975 1304355 1248726 1370474 1345308 $1336 $1494 $1461 $1462 $1403 $1347 1357887 1369071 1380572
Other-Fringe Benefits 502739 517194 539996 581661 650430 694680 784143 861079 947870 792151 $881 $869 $897 $930 $956 $976 1001185 1021007 1040170
Reimbursable Overhead (310555) (322230) (345154) (324006) (309399) (321390) (349770) (380212) (423759) (491807) ($528) ($471) ($430) ($412) ($397) ($395) (396136) (405509) (413165)
Labor Expenses $6652131 $6914045 $6933059 $7235017 $7663467 $7997128 $8581574 $8732302 $9239358 $9373 $9920 $10039 $10436 $10787 $11097 $11413 $11520401 $11885220 $12280075
PayrollOvertime Exp as a of Total Operating+DS $0426 $0427 $0407 $0396 $0387 $0374 $0389 $0383 $0376 $0385 $0349 $0347 $0345
Labor Exp (wo Reimb OH) as a of Total Oper+DS $0650 $0663 $0642 $0637 $0647 $0628 $0643 $0640 $0648 $0638 $0614 $0617 $0620
PayrollOvertime Exp as a of Total Operating Exp $0496 $0490 $0483 $0473 $0465 $0453 $0464 $0459 $0450 $0461 $0426 $0420 $0416
Labor Exp (wo Reimb OH) as a of Total Oper Exp $0758 $0761 $0762 $0761 $0777 $0761 $0768 $0768 $0776 $0763 $0748 $0747 $0747
Non-Labor Expenses
Electric Power $306500 $317934 $325137 $457269 $471514 $493346 $515540 $473762 $406372 $430381 $474918 $451304 $463523 $482662 $539624 $571182 $589565 $618283 $648255
Traction Power
Non-Traction Power
Fuel 287033 180294 189942 282735 251763 259252 267494 162283 124684 150481 185580 190348 187592 183168 181484 182259 182476 184281 186170
Revenue Vehicle Fuel
Non-Revenue Fuel
Insurance 28902 34012 9819 14363 7617 38654 50739 57190 (20634) (2715) 11488 8532 15803 22918 29411 36048 28232 25538 19483
Claims 152114 238104 285418 315547 135652 299875 269167 331023 463959 526053 376480 378570 386981 391333 395228 404397 417667 428660 437683
Paratransit Service Contracts 299013 370094 379761 348553 360500 366751 365599 379271 383704 392850 452190 482751 501230 518038 547829 581114 604766 643217 684112
Maintenance and Other Operating Contracts 594215 562456 541716 451137 451766 496743 549018 579289 630924 695251 779331 897801 833038 883805 871671 879468 880053 898882 915477
Professional Service Contracts 196930 199164 203084 226205 276998 297201 283005 379814 399706 507062 575742 557476 484911 479376 489510 499724 520826 537109 547291
Materials amp Supplies 532534 526191 511206 438310 430804 475127 526725 543225 585607 588115 667700 686666 687745 692131 697268 711988 741335 777460 793419
Other Business Expenses 155466 184142 189637 169857 143807 167198 179701 195598 192576 217254 225494 230595 225293 240279 242193 244907 228861 240258 241690
Non-Labor Expenses $2552708 $2612391 $2635720 $2703976 $2530421 $2894147 $3006988 $3101454 $3166897 3505 3749 3884 3786 3894 3994 4111 $4193782 $4353689 $4473580
Other Expense Adjustments
Other ($13712) ($14750) ($18292) ($2289) $62593 $46175 $44973 $37007 $47404 49 134 158 84 36 22 23 $23516 $24069 $24637
General Reserve 0000 0000 0000 0000 0000 - 0 - 0 - 0 - 0 0 0 165 170 175 180 185 190000 195000 205000
Other Expense Adjustments ($13712) ($14750) ($18292) ($2289) $62593 $46175 $44973 $37007 $47404 $49379 $134 $323 $254 $211 $202 $208 $213516 $219069 $229637
Gap Closing Expenses $7675394
Additional Actions for Budget Balance Expense Impact $0000 $0000 $0000 $0000 $0000 $0000 $0000 $0000 $0000 $0000 $0000 $0000 $0000 $0000 $0000 $0000 $0000 $0000 $0000
Total Operating Expenses Before Non-Cash Liability Adjs $9191127 $9511685 $9550486 $9936705 $10256481 $10937450 $11633535 $11870763 $12453659 $12927116 $13802910 $14246122 $14475644 $14891445 $15293262 $15732241 $15927699 $16457978 $16983292
Non-Cash Liability Adjustments
Depreciation $1790981 $1940576 $1980681 $2019378 $2148820 $2174302 $2266280 $2442777 $2442941 $2607970 $2804571 $2784812 $2842737 $2908533 $2977025 $3051834 $3109882 $3169371 $3230301
OPEB Obligation 1348962 1104827 1167070 1706939 1785881 1920189 2035457 1489656 1562261 1567381 0000 (0000) (0000) (0000) (0000) 0000 0000 (0000) (0000)
GASB 75 OPEB Expense Adjustment 0000 0000 0000 0000 0000 0000 0000 0000 0000 0000 1047747 1457230 1628196 1748560 1823313 1898497 1952374 2006482 2061993
GASB 68 Pension Expense Adjustment 0000 0000 0000 0000 0000 0000 0000 (410019) (218911) (168119) (373022) (220864) (271921) (342847) (318372) (242446) (237864) (234492) (230942)
Environmental Remediation 42249 6062 18621 59079 24742 14257 20556 20576 11691 13468 105615 6000 6000 6000 6000 6000 6000 6000 6000
Non-Cash Liability Adjustments $3182192 $3051466 $3166371 $3785396 $3959443 $4108749 $4322293 $3542990 $3797981 $4020699 $3584911 $4027178 $4205012 $4320246 $4487966 $4713886 $4830392 $4947361 $5067352
Total Operating Expenses After Non-Cash Liability Adjs $12373319 $12563151 $12716857 $13722101 $14215924 $15046199 $15955827 $15413753 $16251641 $16947815 $17387821 $18273301 $18680657 $19211690 $19781228 $20446127 $20758090 $21405338 $22050644
Less BampT Depreciation $77213 $80097 $77846 $86545 $87926 $91345 $104039 $109783 $135035 $240957 $148686 $151977 $158779 $169848 $181689 $194355 $194355 $194355 $194355
BampT Other Post Employment Benefits 66323 50967 54831 66686 73055 76641 71148 62457 60441 78106 32297 22256 20303 22870 28694 33918 36169 38411 40604
Net Operating Deficit Before Subsidies and Debt Service ($6409807) ($6419266) ($6222079) ($6711095) ($7081966) ($7146057) ($7887759) ($6954506) ($7643392) ($8211234) ($8606220) ($9463506) ($9813560) ($10322912) ($10895644) ($11515498) ($11364824) ($11950106) ($12573710)
Conversion to Cash Basis Non-Cash Liability Adjs ($3182192) ($3051466) ($3166371) ($3785396) ($3959443) ($4108749) ($4322293) ($3542990) ($3797981) ($4020699) ($3584911) ($4027178) ($4205012) ($4320246) ($4487966) ($4713886) ($4830392) ($4947361) ($5067352)
Total Operating Expenses $9191127 $9511685 $9550486 $9936705 $10256481 $10937450 $11633535 $11870763 $12453659 $12927 $13803 $14246 $14476 $14891 $15293 $15732 $15927699 $16457978 $16983292
Debt Service Expenses $1515733 $1404454 $1781220 $1933532 $2058395 $2299262 $2248538 $2373321 $2458783 $2525 $2559 $2692 $2840 $3080 $3223 $3450 $3471321 $3472987 $3501639
Total Expenses + Debt Service $10706859 $10916139 $11331706 $11870237 $12314876 $13236712 $13882073 $14244084 $14912443 $15452 $16362 $16938 $17316 $17971 $18516 $19182 $19399019 $19930965 $20484932
Net Deficit After Subsidies and Debt Service ($668477) ($620796) ($0414) $287848 $320833 $556541 $561498 $810173 $359895 ($299965) ($339) ($890) ($1079) ($1506) ($1823) ($2283) ($1901641) ($2229069) ($2664369)
Conversion to Cash Basis GASB Account (56067) (54256) (67377) (37636) (89548) (85641) (50017) - 0 - 0 0 0 0 $0 0 0 - 0 - 0 - 0 - 0
Conversion to Cash Basis 492710 550267 91781 (111037) (297407) (261709) (626297) (660147) (591809) 174 296 363 188 (17) 88 130 49745 48375 54220
Net Cash Balance from Previous Year 0000 0000 0000 23990 139174 0000 209191 0000 150026 0000 0000 0000 0000 0000 0000 0000 0000 0000 0000
Total Operating Exp + DS + Cash Conversions + PY C-O $11144 $11412 $11356 $11746 $12067 $12889362 $13414950 $13583937 $14470659 $15625875 $16658585 $17300293 $17504155 $17954574 $18604130 $19312017 $19448764 $19979340 $20539152
Total Operating Expenses with Cash Conversion $10270216 $10420127 $11307302 $12018911 $12701831 $13584063 $14558387 $14904231 $15504252 $15278749 $16065734 $16575223 $17128079 $17987951 $18427778 $19052755 $19349274 $19882590 $20430711
Baseline Net Cash Balance Before B-T-L Adjustments ($231834) ($124785) $23990 $139174 ($66122) $209191 ($114816) $150026 ($231914) ($126) ($43) ($527) ($891) ($1523) ($1735) ($2153) ($1851896) ($2180695) ($2610148)
Below-the-Line Adjustments
FareToll Increases
FareToll Increase in March 2019 (4 Yield) - 0 $0 $0 $0 $0 $0 $0 - 0 - 0 - 0
FareToll Increase in March 2021 (4 Yield) - 0 $0 $0 $0 $283 $331 $332 333531 333568 334299
FareToll Increase in March 2023 (4 Yield) - 0 $0 $0 $0 $0 $0 $294 346386 346424 347183
FareToll Increase in March 2025 (4 Yield) - 0 $0 $0 $0 $0 $0 $0 - 0 273859 321624
Subsidy Impacts of 20212023 FareToll Increase - 0 $0 $0 $0 ($7) ($9) ($17) (18612) (25573) (26305)
$0000 $0 $0 $0 $275 $322 $609 $661306 $928278 $976801
CASH BALANCE AFTER FARE INCREASES ($126402) ($43) ($527) ($891) ($1241) ($1404) ($1821) ($1518365) ($1847127) ($2275849)
MTA Initiatives
MTA Efficiencies - Not Yet Implemented - 0 $0 $0 $0 $0 $0 $0 0000 0000 0000
0 - 0 $0 $0 $0 $0 $0 $0 - 0 - 0 - 0
0 - 0 $0 $0 $0 $0 $0 $0 - 0 - 0 - 0
$0000 $0 $0 $0 $0 $0 $0 $0000 $0000 $0000
Policy Actions
CAS Migration to Peoplesoft $0 $0 ($5) ($1) ($0) ($0) (0200) -02 -02 0
Fare Evasion Enforcement Strategy-Expenses $0 ($13) ($12) ($11) ($10) ($10) (9554) -9554483 -9554483 0
Fare Evasion Enforcement-Manhattan DA Forfeiture Fund $0 $11 $11 $10 $9 $0 - 0 0 0 0
Negotiated 1 CBA Reform $0 $0 $0 $0 $0 $0 - 0 0 0 0
MTA Reorganization $0 $8 $180 $371 $377 $377 377000 377 377 0
MTA Reorganization Costs $0 $0 ($10) ($27) ($2) $0 - 0 0 0 0
Drawdown 2019 General Reserve $0 $0 $165 $0 $0 $0 - 0 0 0 0
CBA Negotiated Reform - 1 Value $0 $36 $100 $173 $246 $323 323473 323473304484 323473304484 0
$0000 $0 $42 $429 $515 $620 $691 $690719 $690719 $690719
MTA Re-estimates
Additional Savings Actions $0000 $0 $0 $0 $0 $0 $0 $0000 $0000 $0000
Total Below-the-Line Adjustments $0 $0 $459 $413 $709 $760 $1007 $1352025 $1618997 $1667520
Prior Year Carryover 495399 263336 138286 161986 301160 235038 444229 329413 479439 248 121 79 11 0 0 - 0 - 0 - 0 - 0
NET CASH BALANCE $263566 $138551 $162276 $301160 $235038 $444229 $329413 $479439 $247525 $121 $79 $11 ($467) ($814) ($976) ($1146) ($499871) ($561698) ($942628)
Page 2: MTA 2020 Preliminary Budget July Financial Plan 2020 - 2023 2020 Preliminar… · 1 The MTA Budget Process July Plan – Start of the Annual Process • Current year is revised (the

1

The MTA Budget ProcessJuly Plan ndash Start of the Annual Processbull Current year is revised (the ldquoMid-Year Forecastrdquo) preliminary presentation of the following yearrsquos

proposed budget (the ldquoPreliminary Budgetrdquo) and a three-year re-forecast of out-year financesbull Includes gap-closing proposals for balancing the budget and highlights actions requiring public

hearingsbull Mid-Year Forecast becomes the basis for comparing monthly results for the remainder of the year

November Planbull Update of the 5-year July Plan prepared after stakeholders weigh in bull Reflects the impact of new developments and risksbull Includes a revised current year (the ldquoNovember Forecastrdquo) finalization of the proposed budget for the

upcoming year (the ldquoFinal Proposed Budgetrdquo) and projections for the three out-yearsDecember ndash Budget Adoptionbull Update of the November Plan to reflect further developments risks and actions necessary to ensure

budget balancebull Presented to the MTA Board for review and approval

February Planbull Certain below-the-line policy issues covered in Decemberrsquos budget adoption approval are moved into

the baseline technical adjustments are made and the current year becomes the ldquoAdopted Budgetrdquobull Allocated over the 12-month period and is the basis for comparing monthly results

2

Non-Reimbursable Final Adopted Estimate Budget 2018 2019 2020 2021 2022

Operating RevenuesFarebox Revenue $6153 $6122 $6144 $6134 $6144Toll Revenue 1967 1984 1990 1998 1998 Other Revenue 662 705 733 757 743

Total Operating Revenue $8782 $8810 $8867 $8889 $8886

Total Subsidies $7242 $7238 $7370 $7576 $7807Dedicated Taxes as a of Total Revenues + Subs - PMT $0 $0 $0 $0 $0

Total Revenues + Subsidies $16023 $16048 $16237 $16465 $16693

Operating ExpensesLabor Expenses $9920 $10039 $10436 $10787 $11097Non-Labor Expenses 3749 3884 3786 3894 3994 Other 134 158 84 36 22 General Reserve 0 165 170 175 180

Total Operating Expenses $13803 $14246 $14476 $14891 $15293

Debt Service Expenses $2559 $2692 $2840 $3080 $3223

Total Expenses + Debt Service $16362 $16938 $17316 $17971 $18516

Conversion to Cash Basis 296 363 188 (17) 88

Baseline Net Cash Balance Before B-T-L Adjustments ($43) ($527) ($891) ($1523) ($1735)

Total Below-the-Line Adjustments $0 $459 $413 $709 $760Prior Year Carryover 121 79 11 0 0

NET CASH BALANCE $79 $11 ($467) ($814) ($976)

MTA February Financial Plan 2019-2022Consolidated Statement Of Operations By Category ($ in millions)

Summ Stmt of Ops-Feb

Summ Stmt of Ops-Jul

3

The February Financial Plan included large out-year deficits even with faretoll increases and substantial cost reduction targets

($ in millions)

11

(467)

(814)

(976)

($1200)

($1000)

($800)

($600)

($400)

($200)

$0

$200

2019 2020 2021 2022

This Year Next Year Out-Years

What has changed since the February Plan

Changes and re-estimates over the Plan period (2019 ndash 2022)bull Changes and re-estimates improving financial results

bull Higher MMTOA subsidies ($184 million)bull Higher yield from additional 23 in tolls ($173 million)bull Lower maintenanceother operating contracts ($173 million)bull Higher MTA Aid car rental tax ($35 million)

bull Changes and re-estimates worsening financial resultsbull Actuary recalculation of pension liability ($550 million)bull Agency re-estimates and rate change adjustments ($189 million)bull Higher overtime expenses ($131 million)bull Lower rentaladvertising revenues ($83 million)bull Lower real estate tax revenues ($59 million)

In total these changes and re-estimates along with other changes are $447 million unfavorable for the Plan period

4

Highlights of the July Plan

bull Proposed biennial fare and toll increases of 4 in 2021 and 2023 (versus projected 2-year CPI inflators of 49 and 47 in 2021 and 2023 respectively)

bull Maintained investments from prior plans including maintenance of the Subway Action Plan funded from Phase 1 of Congestion PricingFHV fees

bull Renewed emphasis to gain control of and reduce fare evasion (investment of $62 million over the Plan period)

bull MTA is using ldquoone-shotsrdquo to balance the budget in the transition years 2019 and 2020

o 2019 - 2018 favorable year-end balance ndash mostly timing ndash and impacts 2019 ($372 million)

- Freeze on filling all non-operationalnon-essential vacancies ($68 million)

- Other restrictions on non-essential spending including non-revenue vehicle purchases travelprofessional memberships ($44 million)

- One-time reduction of committed to capital contributions ($64 million)

o 2020 - Drawdown of 2019 General Reserve ($165 million)

bull Annual recurring savings targets of $350 million beginning in 2020 have been identified by HQ and Agencies

5

6

These actions will not suffice and significant deficits remain($ in millions)

This Year Next Year Out-Years

11

(467)

(814)

(976)

NA

50

(186)

(569)

(816)

(971)

($1200)

($1000)

($800)

($600)

($400)

($200)

$0

$200

2019 2020 2021 2022 2023

February PlanJuly Plan without Transformation Plan Savings

MTA Transformation Plan

bull State-mandated plan to review operations and implement changes to streamline internal processes clarify responsibilities solidify accountability and work more efficiently to regain trust of our customers and funding partners and improve MTArsquos ability to deliver safe and reliable service our customers deserve

bull Plan recommendationsbull Refocus the operating agencies on mission-critical operating priorities of safety reliability and

servicebull Centralize common support functions to improve operations and create opportunities to ensure

consistent standards quality and policies across departmentsbull Unify the management of capital programs to improve and streamline planning development

and construction so capital improvements can be delivered on time and on budgetbull Expand senior leadership by adding a Chief Transformation Officer a Chief Operating Officer a

Chief Engineering Officer and an MTA Accessibility Officer

bull Consolidation and efficiency targets of $370 million to $530 million on an annual basis have been identified

bull If the MTA Transformation Plan is approved and implemented the July Financial Plan will have small operating balances in 2019 and 2020 a small deficit in 2021 with out-year deficits reaching $433 million in 2023

7

8

The adoption and implementation of the MTA Transformation Planhas the potential to significantly reduce out-year deficits

($ in millions)

This Year Next Year Out-Years

11

(467)

(814)

(976)

NA

61 55

(26)

(281)

(433)

($1200)

($1000)

($800)

($600)

($400)

($200)

$0

$200

2019 2020 2021 2022 2023

February PlanProposed July Plan

Actions to Reduce Fare Evasion $62 million Investment over the Plan Period

bull Increase physical presence (500 uniformed officers NYPD MTA Police and Bridge and Tunnel Officers) to begin enforcement at 50 subway stations and 50 bus routesThis is not just a fare evasion effort but a workerrsquos safety initiative

bull Ensure enforcement does not target any specific demographic bull Educate MTA riders utilizing messaging media and automated

announcementsbull Improve operation of emergency exit gates to mitigate instances of fare

avoidancebull Augment surveillance capabilities by deploying fare array cameras at 50

stations and pilot the use of monitors at 10 stationsbull $40 million of the investment will be funded by Manhattan DA Office over a

four-year period

9

The MTArsquos $350 million target for annually recurring savings beginning in 2020 has been identified and is being implemented

109

10 7 6 6

96 304 351 362 371

$0

$50

$100

$150

$200

$250

$300

$350

$400

2019 2020 2021 2022 2023

Identified Recurring Savings One-Shot Savings

This Year Next Year Out-Years

($ in millions)

10

We have a track record of identifying and achieving our annual recurring savings targets

11

($ in millions)

$0

$500

$1000

$1500

$2000

$2500

$3000

Achieved Savings

2012 November Plan

2013 November Plan

2014 November Plan

2015 November Plan

2016 November Plan

2017 November Plan

2018 November Plan

2019 July Plan

$28 billion

Proposed July Plan

Deficits remain and a continued drive toward further streamlining and efficiencies is required

12

($ in millions)

61 55

(26)

(281)

(433)

($600)

($500)

($400)

($300)

($200)

($100)

$0

$100

$200

2019 2020 2021 2022 2023

This Year Next Year Out-Years

Proposed July PlanDonrsquot achieve Transformation Plan Savings

13

If the MTA Transformation Plan is not adopted and implemented the deficits will be unmanageable without service cuts significant

reductions in force andor additional fare and toll increases($ in millions)

($1100)

($900)

($700)

($500)

($300)

($100)

$100

2019 2020 2021 2022 2023

(816)

(971)

(569)

(81)

(433)

(281)

61 55 (26)

(281) (186)

50

Next Year Out-Years

(230)(11)

(488)

(538)

(535)

This Year

14

2020 Preliminary BudgetWhere the Dollars Come Fromhellip Where the Dollars Gohellip

Farebox Revenue $6389Toll Revenue 2121 Other Revenue 684 Taxes 6178 State and Local amp Other 557 Other Funding Agreements 671 Other 1 208 Total $16809

($ in millions)

By Revenue Source(includes faretoll increases)

Payroll $5422Overtime 838 Health amp Welfare 2118 Pension 1461 Other Labor 466 Total Labor $10306Non-Labor + Other Exp Adj 4004 Debt Service 2830 BTL Adjustments for Expenses 2 (386) Total $16754

By Expense Category

($ in millions)(includes below-the-line adjustments)

1 Includes cash adjustments and prior-year carryover

Farebox Revenue

38

Toll Revenue

13

Other Revenue4

Taxes37

State amp Local

Subsidies3

Other Funding Agreements

4 Other 1

Payroll32

Overtime5

Health ampWelfare

13Pension

9

Other Labor3

Non-Labor + Other Exp Adj

21

Debt Service17

2 The below-the-line adjustments are grouped in the Non-Labor category

Sheet1

Sheet1

15

Non-Reimbursable Mid-Year Preliminary Actual Forecast Budget

2018 2019 2020 2021 2022 2023 Operating Revenues

Farebox Revenue $6155 $6305 $6389 $6373 $6384 $6393Toll Revenue 1976 2088 2121 2129 2129 2131 Other Revenue 643 696 684 704 719 737

Total Operating Revenue $8774 $9089 $9195 $9206 $9232 $9260

Total Subsidies $7177 $7314 $7406 $7581 $7803 $7969Dedicated Taxes as a of Total Revenues + Subs - PMT 233 $0 $0 $0 $0 $0

Total Revenues + Subsidies $15951 $16403 $16601 $16787 $17035 $17229

Operating ExpensesLabor Expenses $9799 $10116 $10306 $10592 $10881 $11121Non-Labor Expenses 3611 3877 3748 3841 3945 4054 Other 129 175 86 36 22 23 General Reserve 0 165 170 175 180 185

Total Operating Expenses $13539 $14333 $14310 $14644 $15028 $15384

Debt Service Expenses $2541 $2683 $2830 $3041 $3265 $3513

Total Expenses + Debt Service $16079 $17016 $17140 $17685 $18293 $18896

Conversion to Cash Basis 379 229 147 60 125 101

Baseline Net Cash Balance Before B-T-L Adjustments $251 ($384) ($392) ($838) ($1133) ($1566)

Total Below-the-Line Adjustments $0 $73 $386 $757 $852 $1133Prior Year Carryover 121 372 61 55 0 0

NET CASH BALANCE $372 $61 $55 ($26) ($281) ($433)

MTA July Financial Plan 2020-2023Consolidated Statement Of Operations By Category ($ in millions)

Summ Stmt of Ops-Feb

Summ Stmt of Ops-Jul

  • MTA 2020Preliminary BudgetJuly Financial Plan2020 - 2023
  • The MTA Budget Process
  • Slide Number 3
  • Slide Number 4
  • What has changed since the February Plan
  • Highlights of the July Plan
  • Slide Number 7
  • MTA Transformation Plan
  • Slide Number 9
  • Actions to Reduce Fare Evasion $62 million Investment over the Plan Period
  • The MTArsquos $350 million target for annually recurring savings beginning in 2020 has been identified and is being implemented
  • We have a track record of identifying and achieving our annual recurring savings targets
  • Deficits remain and a continued drive toward further streamlining and efficiencies is required
  • Slide Number 14
  • 2020 Preliminary Budget
  • Slide Number 16
MTA July Financial Plan 2020-2023
Consolidated Statement Of Operations By Category ($ in millions)
Non-Reimbursable Mid-Year Preliminary
Actual Actual Actual Actual Actual Actual Actual Actual Actual Actual Forecast Budget
2008 2009 2010 2011 2012 2013 2014 2015 2016 2018 2019 2020 2021 2022 2023 2023 2024 2025 2026
Operating Revenues
Farebox Revenue $4240923 $4350411 $4586377 $4999186 $5079138 $5501274 $5709200 $5961129 $6050182 $6155 $6305 $6389 $6373 $6384 $6393 $6174 $6435176 $6431979 $6446633
422 423 405 411 402 399 395 396 396 386 384 385 380 375 371 261 368 363 362
Student Fare - 0 - 0 - 0 - 0 - 0 - 0
Toll Revenue 1273974 1332115 1417046 1501589 1490982 1645193 1676445 1808901 1869693 1976 2088 2121 2129 2129 2131 2002 2133050 2137871 2143111
0127 0129 0125 0124 0118 0119 0116 0120 0122 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0122 0121 0120
Other Revenue 448616 461359 491355 510231 563839 753675 682424 689217 688374 643 696 684 704 719 737 755 825040 885381 887190
Capital and Other Reimbursements 0000 0000 0000 0000 0000 0000 0000 0000 0000 0000 0000 0000 0000 0000 0000 0000 0000 0000 0000
Total Operating Revenue $5963512 $6143885 $6494778 $7011006 $7133959 $7900142 $8068069 $8459247 $8608249 $8774 $9089 $9195 $9206 $9232 $9260 $8931 $9393266 $9455232 $9476934
Dedicated Taxes $3211585 $2366805 $2343537 $2511691 $2673119 $3097640 $3383498 $3582628 $3525829 $3257508 $3459 $3515 $3568 $3630 $3725 $3812 $3841433 $3880226 $3917215
PMT amp MTA Aid - 0 881784 1588677 1718286 1825824 1825328 1885069 1910947 1970760 1987035 $1965 $2152 $2225 $2295 $2368 $2442 2516095 2594604 2677041
New Funding Sources - 0 - 0 - 0 - 0 - 0 - 0 - 0 - 0 - 0 - 0 $508 $342 $385 $385 $385 $385 385000 385000 385000
StateLocal Taxes 556691 539046 544810 541733 536182 537527 539545 537819 537645 541005 $544 $552 $557 $562 $567 $572 576828 581933 583214
Other Funding Agreements 306594 363823 359489 375369 466625 432617 567391 563616 629855 630218 $701 $753 $671 $708 $758 $758 784755 804901 781159
BampT Operating Surplus Transfer 382565 363092 476059 554903 476575 614210 637553 750717 742909 740144 $702 $721 $782 $801 $789 $707 730476 695303 688833
Dedicated Taxes and StateLocal Subsidies $4457434 $4514550 $5312572 $5701982 $5978325 $6507322 $7013056 $7345727 $7406998 $7155909 $7879 $8035 $8188 $8381 $8592 $8676 $8834588 $8941967 $9032462
$0000 $0000 $0000 $0000 $0000 $0000 $0000 $0000 $0000
Less Interagency Subsidy and Surplus Transfers (382565) (363092) (476059) (554903) (476575) (614210) (637553) (750717) (742909) (740144) ($702) ($721) ($782) ($801) ($789) ($707) (730476) (695303) (688833)
Total Subsidies $4074870 $4151458 $4836513 $5147079 $5501750 $5893111 $6375503 $6595010 $6664088 $7177 $7314 $7406 $7581 $7803 $7969 $7969 $8104112 $8246664 $8343629
Dedicated Taxes as a of Total Revenues + Subs - PMT 320 251 241 241 247 259 269 273 265 233 $0 $0 $0 $0 $0 $0 256 257 259
Total Revenues + Subsidies $10038382 $10295342 $11331292 $12158085 $12635709 $13793254 $14443571 $15054257 $15272337 $15951 $16403 $16601 $16787 $17035 $17229 $16900 $17497378 $17701896 $17820563
Operating Expenses
Labor Expenses
Payroll $4087376 $4163330 $4171374 $4160261 $4193658 $4332829 $4671664 $4695823 $4838741 $5020713 $5211 $5328 $5422 $5498 $5624 $5710 $5860206 $5982960 $6107107
Overtime 471675 499307 443227 538647 574316 620701 730200 755071 771495 934100 $1066 $910 $838 $859 $877 $899 917296 935002 951324
Health amp Welfare 684945 688899 738189 809638 812857 895714 961902 1050100 1172304 1208786 $1230 $1341 $1414 $1489 $1583 $1674 1797938 1922668 2071273
OPEB Current Payment 318501 346316 355716 394218 413164 472619 479079 501716 562233 563754 $604 $645 $704 $766 $835 $910 982025 1060022 1142795
Pensions 897450 1021229 1029710 1074598 1328441 1301975 1304355 1248726 1370474 1345308 $1336 $1494 $1461 $1462 $1403 $1347 1357887 1369071 1380572
Other-Fringe Benefits 502739 517194 539996 581661 650430 694680 784143 861079 947870 792151 $881 $869 $897 $930 $956 $976 1001185 1021007 1040170
Reimbursable Overhead (310555) (322230) (345154) (324006) (309399) (321390) (349770) (380212) (423759) (491807) ($528) ($471) ($430) ($412) ($397) ($395) (396136) (405509) (413165)
Labor Expenses $6652131 $6914045 $6933059 $7235017 $7663467 $7997128 $8581574 $8732302 $9239358 $9799 $10116 $10306 $10592 $10881 $11121 $11413 $11520401 $11885220 $12280075
PayrollOvertime Exp as a of Total Operating+DS $0426 $0427 $0407 $0396 $0387 $0374 $0389 $0383 $0376 $0390 $0367 $0365 $0359 $0355 $0350 $0349 $0347 $0345
Labor Exp (wo Reimb OH) as a of Total Oper+DS $0650 $0663 $0642 $0637 $0647 $0628 $0643 $0640 $0648 $0642 $0622 $0626 $0622 $0616 $0609 $0614 $0617 $0620
PayrollOvertime Exp as a of Total Operating Exp $0496 $0490 $0483 $0473 $0465 $0453 $0464 $0459 $0450 $0464 $0435 $0438 $0434 $0433 $0430 $0426 $0420 $0416
Labor Exp (wo Reimb OH) as a of Total Oper Exp $0758 $0761 $0762 $0761 $0777 $0761 $0768 $0768 $0776 $0763 $0739 $0750 $0751 $0750 $0749 $0748 $0747 $0747
Non-Labor Expenses
Electric Power $306500 $317934 $325137 $457269 $471514 $493346 $515540 $473762 $406372 $481893 $451503 $473177 $493090 $532413 $561955 $571182 $589565 $618283 $648255
Traction Power
Non-Traction Power
Fuel 287033 180294 189942 282735 251763 259252 267494 162283 124684 185203 182778 182981 176333 173681 176920 182259 182476 184281 186170
Revenue Vehicle Fuel
Non-Revenue Fuel
Insurance 28902 34012 9819 14363 7617 38654 50739 57190 (20634) (29402) 5608 15623 23118 26855 28309 36048 28232 25538 19483
Claims 152114 238104 285418 315547 135652 299875 269167 331023 463959 437985 387557 394211 392547 398256 406112 404397 417667 428660 437683
Paratransit Service Contracts 299013 370094 379761 348553 360500 366751 365599 379271 383704 455471 494751 488330 505538 535329 568614 581114 604766 643217 684112
Maintenance and Other Operating Contracts 594215 562456 541716 451137 451766 496743 549018 579289 630924 678425 840168 797428 833534 836606 854471 879468 880053 898882 915477
Professional Service Contracts 196930 199164 203084 226205 276998 297201 283005 379814 399706 543582 607838 502858 494814 504103 513895 499724 520826 537109 547291
Materials amp Supplies 532534 526191 511206 438310 430804 475127 526725 543225 585607 637078 689010 679895 697976 711281 715758 711988 741335 777460 793419
Other Business Expenses 155466 184142 189637 169857 143807 167198 179701 195598 192576 220838 218196 213551 224459 226170 228457 244907 228861 240258 241690
Non-Labor Expenses $2552708 $2612391 $2635720 $2703976 $2530421 $2894147 $3006988 $3101454 $3166897 3611 3877 3748 3841 3945 4054 4111 $4193782 $4353689 $4473580
Other Expense Adjustments
Other ($13712) ($14750) ($18292) ($2289) $62593 $46175 $44973 $37007 $47404 129 175 86 36 22 23 23 $23516 $24069 $24637
General Reserve 0000 0000 0000 0000 0000 - 0 - 0 - 0 - 0 0 165 170 175 180 185 185 190000 195000 205000
Other Expense Adjustments ($13712) ($14750) ($18292) ($2289) $62593 $46175 $44973 $37007 $47404 $128555 $340 $256 $211 $202 $208 $208 $213516 $219069 $229637
Gap Closing Expenses $7675394
Additional Actions for Budget Balance Expense Impact $0000 $0000 $0000 $0000 $0000 $0000 $0000 $0000 $0000 $0000 $0000 $0000 $0000 $0000 $0000 $0000 $0000 $0000 $0000
Total Operating Expenses Before Non-Cash Liability Adjs $9191127 $9511685 $9550486 $9936705 $10256481 $10937450 $11633535 $11870763 $12453659 $13538830 $14332772 $14309678 $14643965 $15027767 $15383584 $15732241 $15927699 $16457978 $16983292
Non-Cash Liability Adjustments
Depreciation $1790981 $1940576 $1980681 $2019378 $2148820 $2174302 $2266280 $2442777 $2442941 $2607970 $2804571 $2784812 $2842737 $2908533 $2977025 $3051834 $3109882 $3169371 $3230301
OPEB Obligation 1348962 1104827 1167070 1706939 1785881 1920189 2035457 1489656 1562261 1567381 0000 (0000) (0000) (0000) (0000) 0000 0000 (0000) (0000)
GASB 75 OPEB Expense Adjustment 0000 0000 0000 0000 0000 0000 0000 0000 0000 0000 1047747 1457230 1628196 1748560 1823313 1898497 1952374 2006482 2061993
GASB 68 Pension Expense Adjustment 0000 0000 0000 0000 0000 0000 0000 (410019) (218911) (168119) (373022) (220864) (271921) (342847) (318372) (242446) (237864) (234492) (230942)
Environmental Remediation 42249 6062 18621 59079 24742 14257 20556 20576 11691 13468 105615 6000 6000 6000 6000 6000 6000 6000 6000
Non-Cash Liability Adjustments $3182192 $3051466 $3166371 $3785396 $3959443 $4108749 $4322293 $3542990 $3797981 $4020699 $3584911 $4027178 $4205012 $4320246 $4487966 $4713886 $4830392 $4947361 $5067352
Total Operating Expenses After Non-Cash Liability Adjs $12373319 $12563151 $12716857 $13722101 $14215924 $15046199 $15955827 $15413753 $16251641 $17559529 $17917683 $18336856 $18848977 $19348013 $19871550 $20446127 $20758090 $21405338 $22050644
Less BampT Depreciation $77213 $80097 $77846 $86545 $87926 $91345 $104039 $109783 $135035 $240957 $148686 $151977 $158779 $169848 $181689 $194355 $194355 $194355 $194355
BampT Other Post Employment Benefits 66323 50967 54831 66686 73055 76641 71148 62457 60441 78106 32297 22256 20303 22870 28694 33918 36169 38411 40604
Net Operating Deficit Before Subsidies and Debt Service ($6409807) ($6419266) ($6222079) ($6711095) ($7081966) ($7146057) ($7887759) ($6954506) ($7643392) ($8785339) ($8829030) ($9141907) ($9642826) ($10116260) ($10611154) ($11515498) ($11364824) ($11950106) ($12573710)
Conversion to Cash Basis Non-Cash Liability Adjs ($3182192) ($3051466) ($3166371) ($3785396) ($3959443) ($4108749) ($4322293) ($3542990) ($3797981) ($4020699) ($3584911) ($4027178) ($4205012) ($4320246) ($4487966) ($4713886) ($4830392) ($4947361) ($5067352)
Total Operating Expenses $9191127 $9511685 $9550486 $9936705 $10256481 $10937450 $11633535 $11870763 $12453659 $13539 $14333 $14310 $14644 $15028 $15384 $15732 $15927699 $16457978 $16983292
Debt Service Expenses $1515733 $1404454 $1781220 $1933532 $2058395 $2299262 $2248538 $2373321 $2458783 $2541 $2683 $2830 $3041 $3265 $3513 $3450 $3471321 $3472987 $3501639
Total Expenses + Debt Service $10706859 $10916139 $11331706 $11870237 $12314876 $13236712 $13882073 $14244084 $14912443 $16079 $17016 $17140 $17685 $18293 $18896 $19182 $19399019 $19930965 $20484932
Net Deficit After Subsidies and Debt Service ($668477) ($620796) ($0414) $287848 $320833 $556541 $561498 $810173 $359895 ($128044) ($613) ($539) ($898) ($1258) ($1667) ($2283) ($1901641) ($2229069) ($2664369)
Conversion to Cash Basis GASB Account (56067) (54256) (67377) (37636) (89548) (85641) (50017) - 0 - 0 0 0 0 $0 0 0 - 0 - 0 - 0 - 0
Conversion to Cash Basis 492710 550267 91781 (111037) (297407) (261709) (626297) (660147) (591809) 379 229 147 60 125 101 130 49745 48375 54220
Net Cash Balance from Previous Year 0000 0000 0000 23990 139174 0000 209191 0000 150026 0000 250569 0000 0000 0000 0000 0000 0000 0000 0000
Total Operating Exp + DS + Cash Conversions + PY C-O $11144 $11412 $11356 $11746 $12067 $12889362 $13414950 $13583937 $14470659 $16457999 $17495351 $17286526 $17744425 $18418197 $18997710 $19312017 $19448764 $19979340 $20539152
Total Operating Expenses with Cash Conversion $10270216 $10420127 $11307302 $12018911 $12701831 $13584063 $14558387 $14904231 $15504252 $15700774 $16786574 $16992579 $17624861 $18167420 $18795069 $19052755 $19349274 $19882590 $20430711
Baseline Net Cash Balance Before B-T-L Adjustments ($231834) ($124785) $23990 $139174 ($66122) $209191 ($114816) $150026 ($231914) $251 ($384) ($392) ($838) ($1133) ($1566) ($2153) ($1851896) ($2180695) ($2610148)
Below-the-Line Adjustments
FareToll Increases
FareToll Increase in March 2019 (4 Yield) - 0 $0 $0 $0 $0 $0 $0 - 0 - 0 - 0
FareToll Increase in March 2021 (4 Yield) - 0 $0 $0 $0 $283 $331 $332 333531 333568 334299
FareToll Increase in March 2023 (4 Yield) - 0 $0 $0 $0 $0 $0 $294 346386 346424 347183
FareToll Increase in March 2025 (4 Yield) - 0 $0 $0 $0 $0 $0 $0 - 0 273859 321624
Subsidy Impacts of 20212023 FareToll Increase - 0 $0 $0 $0 ($7) ($9) ($17) (18612) (25573) (26305)
$0000 $0 $0 $0 $275 $322 $609 $661306 $928278 $976801
CASH BALANCE AFTER FARE INCREASES $250569 ($384) ($392) ($838) ($850) ($1234) ($1821) ($1518365) ($1847127) ($2275849)
MTA Initiatives
MTA Efficiencies - Not Yet Implemented - 0 $0 $0 $0 $0 $0 $0 0000 0000 0000
0 - 0 $0 $0 $0 $0 $0 $0 - 0 - 0 - 0
0 - 0 $0 $0 $0 $0 $0 $0 - 0 - 0 - 0
$0000 $0 $0 $0 $0 $0 $0 $0000 $0000 $0000
Policy Actions
CAS Migration to Peoplesoft $0 $0 ($5) ($1) ($0) ($0) (0200) -02 -02 0
Fare Evasion Enforcement Strategy-Expenses $0 ($13) ($12) ($11) ($10) ($10) (9554) -9554483 -9554483 0
Fare Evasion Enforcement-Manhattan DA Forfeiture Fund $0 $11 $11 $10 $9 $0 - 0 0 0 0
Negotiated 1 CBA Reform $0 $0 $0 $0 $0 $0 - 0 0 0 0
MTA Reorganization $0 $8 $180 $371 $377 $377 377000 377 377 0
MTA Reorganization Costs $0 $0 ($10) ($27) ($2) $0 - 0 0 0 0
Drawdown 2019 General Reserve $0 $0 $165 $0 $0 $0 - 0 0 0 0
CBA Negotiated Reform - 1 Value $0 $36 $100 $173 $246 $323 323473 323473304484 323473304484 0
$0000 $0 $42 $429 $515 $620 $691 $690719 $690719 $690719
MTA Re-estimates
Additional Savings Actions $0000 $0 $0 $0 $0 $0 $0 $0000 $0000 $0000
Total Below-the-Line Adjustments $0 $73 $386 $757 $852 $1133 $1007 $1352025 $1618997 $1667520
Prior Year Carryover 495399 263336 138286 161986 301160 235038 444229 329413 479439 121 372 61 55 0 0 - 0 - 0 - 0 - 0
NET CASH BALANCE $263566 $138551 $162276 $301160 $235038 $444229 $329413 $479439 $247525 $372 $61 $55 ($26) ($281) ($433) ($1146) ($499871) ($561698) ($942628)
MTA February Financial Plan 2019-2022
Consolidated Statement Of Operations By Category ($ in millions)
Non-Reimbursable Final Adopted
Actual Actual Actual Actual Actual Actual Actual Actual Actual Actual Estimate Budget
2008 2009 2010 2011 2012 2013 2014 2015 2016 2017 2018 2019 2020 2021 2022 2023 2024 2025 2026
Operating Revenues
Farebox Revenue $4240923 $4350411 $4586377 $4999186 $5079138 $5501274 $5709200 $5961129 $6050182 $6172 $6153 $6122 $6144 $6134 $6144 $6174 $6435176 $6431979 $6446633
422 423 405 411 402 399 395 396 396 407 279 275 272 267 263 261 368 363 362
Student Fare - 0 - 0 - 0 - 0 - 0 - 0
Toll Revenue 1273974 1332115 1417046 1501589 1490982 1645193 1676445 1808901 1869693 1912 1967 1984 1990 1998 1998 2002 2133050 2137871 2143111
0127 0129 0125 0124 0118 0119 0116 0120 0122 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0122 0121 0120
Other Revenue 448616 461359 491355 510231 563839 753675 682424 689217 688374 653 662 705 733 757 743 755 825040 885381 887190
Capital and Other Reimbursements 0000 0000 0000 0000 0000 0000 0000 0000 0000 0000 0000 0000 0000 0000 0000 0000 0000 0000 0000
Total Operating Revenue $5963512 $6143885 $6494778 $7011006 $7133959 $7900142 $8068069 $8459247 $8608249 $8737 $8782 $8810 $8867 $8889 $8886 $8931 $9393266 $9455232 $9476934
Dedicated Taxes $3211585 $2366805 $2343537 $2511691 $2673119 $3097640 $3383498 $3582628 $3525829 $3257508 $3459 $3515 $3568 $3630 $3725 $3812 $3841433 $3880226 $3917215
PMT amp MTA Aid - 0 881784 1588677 1718286 1825824 1825328 1885069 1910947 1970760 1987035 $1965 $2152 $2225 $2295 $2368 $2442 2516095 2594604 2677041
New Funding Sources - 0 - 0 - 0 - 0 - 0 - 0 - 0 - 0 - 0 - 0 $508 $342 $385 $385 $385 $385 385000 385000 385000
StateLocal Taxes 556691 539046 544810 541733 536182 537527 539545 537819 537645 541005 $544 $552 $557 $562 $567 $572 576828 581933 583214
Other Funding Agreements 306594 363823 359489 375369 466625 432617 567391 563616 629855 630218 $701 $753 $671 $708 $758 $758 784755 804901 781159
BampT Operating Surplus Transfer 382565 363092 476059 554903 476575 614210 637553 750717 742909 740144 $702 $721 $782 $801 $789 $707 730476 695303 688833
Dedicated Taxes and StateLocal Subsidies $4457434 $4514550 $5312572 $5701982 $5978325 $6507322 $7013056 $7345727 $7406998 $7155909 $7879 $8035 $8188 $8381 $8592 $8676 $8834588 $8941967 $9032462
$0000 $0000 $0000 $0000 $0000 $0000 $0000 $0000 $0000
Less Interagency Subsidy and Surplus Transfers (382565) (363092) (476059) (554903) (476575) (614210) (637553) (750717) (742909) (740144) ($702) ($721) ($782) ($801) ($789) ($707) (730476) (695303) (688833)
Total Subsidies $4074870 $4151458 $4836513 $5147079 $5501750 $5893111 $6375503 $6595010 $6664088 $6416 $7242 $7238 $7370 $7576 $7807 $7969 $8104112 $8246664 $8343629
Dedicated Taxes as a of Total Revenues + Subs - PMT 320 251 241 241 247 259 269 273 265 247 $0 $0 $0 $0 $0 $0 256 257 259
Total Revenues + Subsidies $10038382 $10295342 $11331292 $12158085 $12635709 $13793254 $14443571 $15054257 $15272337 $15152 $16023 $16048 $16237 $16465 $16693 $16900 $17497378 $17701896 $17820563
Operating Expenses
Labor Expenses
Payroll $4087376 $4163330 $4171374 $4160261 $4193658 $4332829 $4671664 $4695823 $4838741 $5020713 $5211 $5328 $5422 $5498 $5624 $5710 $5860206 $5982960 $6107107
Overtime 471675 499307 443227 538647 574316 620701 730200 755071 771495 934100 $1066 $910 $838 $859 $877 $899 917296 935002 951324
Health amp Welfare 684945 688899 738189 809638 812857 895714 961902 1050100 1172304 1208786 $1230 $1341 $1414 $1489 $1583 $1674 1797938 1922668 2071273
OPEB Current Payment 318501 346316 355716 394218 413164 472619 479079 501716 562233 563754 $604 $645 $704 $766 $835 $910 982025 1060022 1142795
Pensions 897450 1021229 1029710 1074598 1328441 1301975 1304355 1248726 1370474 1345308 $1336 $1494 $1461 $1462 $1403 $1347 1357887 1369071 1380572
Other-Fringe Benefits 502739 517194 539996 581661 650430 694680 784143 861079 947870 792151 $881 $869 $897 $930 $956 $976 1001185 1021007 1040170
Reimbursable Overhead (310555) (322230) (345154) (324006) (309399) (321390) (349770) (380212) (423759) (491807) ($528) ($471) ($430) ($412) ($397) ($395) (396136) (405509) (413165)
Labor Expenses $6652131 $6914045 $6933059 $7235017 $7663467 $7997128 $8581574 $8732302 $9239358 $9373 $9920 $10039 $10436 $10787 $11097 $11413 $11520401 $11885220 $12280075
PayrollOvertime Exp as a of Total Operating+DS $0426 $0427 $0407 $0396 $0387 $0374 $0389 $0383 $0376 $0385 $0349 $0347 $0345
Labor Exp (wo Reimb OH) as a of Total Oper+DS $0650 $0663 $0642 $0637 $0647 $0628 $0643 $0640 $0648 $0638 $0614 $0617 $0620
PayrollOvertime Exp as a of Total Operating Exp $0496 $0490 $0483 $0473 $0465 $0453 $0464 $0459 $0450 $0461 $0426 $0420 $0416
Labor Exp (wo Reimb OH) as a of Total Oper Exp $0758 $0761 $0762 $0761 $0777 $0761 $0768 $0768 $0776 $0763 $0748 $0747 $0747
Non-Labor Expenses
Electric Power $306500 $317934 $325137 $457269 $471514 $493346 $515540 $473762 $406372 $430381 $474918 $451304 $463523 $482662 $539624 $571182 $589565 $618283 $648255
Traction Power
Non-Traction Power
Fuel 287033 180294 189942 282735 251763 259252 267494 162283 124684 150481 185580 190348 187592 183168 181484 182259 182476 184281 186170
Revenue Vehicle Fuel
Non-Revenue Fuel
Insurance 28902 34012 9819 14363 7617 38654 50739 57190 (20634) (2715) 11488 8532 15803 22918 29411 36048 28232 25538 19483
Claims 152114 238104 285418 315547 135652 299875 269167 331023 463959 526053 376480 378570 386981 391333 395228 404397 417667 428660 437683
Paratransit Service Contracts 299013 370094 379761 348553 360500 366751 365599 379271 383704 392850 452190 482751 501230 518038 547829 581114 604766 643217 684112
Maintenance and Other Operating Contracts 594215 562456 541716 451137 451766 496743 549018 579289 630924 695251 779331 897801 833038 883805 871671 879468 880053 898882 915477
Professional Service Contracts 196930 199164 203084 226205 276998 297201 283005 379814 399706 507062 575742 557476 484911 479376 489510 499724 520826 537109 547291
Materials amp Supplies 532534 526191 511206 438310 430804 475127 526725 543225 585607 588115 667700 686666 687745 692131 697268 711988 741335 777460 793419
Other Business Expenses 155466 184142 189637 169857 143807 167198 179701 195598 192576 217254 225494 230595 225293 240279 242193 244907 228861 240258 241690
Non-Labor Expenses $2552708 $2612391 $2635720 $2703976 $2530421 $2894147 $3006988 $3101454 $3166897 3505 3749 3884 3786 3894 3994 4111 $4193782 $4353689 $4473580
Other Expense Adjustments
Other ($13712) ($14750) ($18292) ($2289) $62593 $46175 $44973 $37007 $47404 49 134 158 84 36 22 23 $23516 $24069 $24637
General Reserve 0000 0000 0000 0000 0000 - 0 - 0 - 0 - 0 0 0 165 170 175 180 185 190000 195000 205000
Other Expense Adjustments ($13712) ($14750) ($18292) ($2289) $62593 $46175 $44973 $37007 $47404 $49379 $134 $323 $254 $211 $202 $208 $213516 $219069 $229637
Gap Closing Expenses $7675394
Additional Actions for Budget Balance Expense Impact $0000 $0000 $0000 $0000 $0000 $0000 $0000 $0000 $0000 $0000 $0000 $0000 $0000 $0000 $0000 $0000 $0000 $0000 $0000
Total Operating Expenses Before Non-Cash Liability Adjs $9191127 $9511685 $9550486 $9936705 $10256481 $10937450 $11633535 $11870763 $12453659 $12927116 $13802910 $14246122 $14475644 $14891445 $15293262 $15732241 $15927699 $16457978 $16983292
Non-Cash Liability Adjustments
Depreciation $1790981 $1940576 $1980681 $2019378 $2148820 $2174302 $2266280 $2442777 $2442941 $2607970 $2804571 $2784812 $2842737 $2908533 $2977025 $3051834 $3109882 $3169371 $3230301
OPEB Obligation 1348962 1104827 1167070 1706939 1785881 1920189 2035457 1489656 1562261 1567381 0000 (0000) (0000) (0000) (0000) 0000 0000 (0000) (0000)
GASB 75 OPEB Expense Adjustment 0000 0000 0000 0000 0000 0000 0000 0000 0000 0000 1047747 1457230 1628196 1748560 1823313 1898497 1952374 2006482 2061993
GASB 68 Pension Expense Adjustment 0000 0000 0000 0000 0000 0000 0000 (410019) (218911) (168119) (373022) (220864) (271921) (342847) (318372) (242446) (237864) (234492) (230942)
Environmental Remediation 42249 6062 18621 59079 24742 14257 20556 20576 11691 13468 105615 6000 6000 6000 6000 6000 6000 6000 6000
Non-Cash Liability Adjustments $3182192 $3051466 $3166371 $3785396 $3959443 $4108749 $4322293 $3542990 $3797981 $4020699 $3584911 $4027178 $4205012 $4320246 $4487966 $4713886 $4830392 $4947361 $5067352
Total Operating Expenses After Non-Cash Liability Adjs $12373319 $12563151 $12716857 $13722101 $14215924 $15046199 $15955827 $15413753 $16251641 $16947815 $17387821 $18273301 $18680657 $19211690 $19781228 $20446127 $20758090 $21405338 $22050644
Less BampT Depreciation $77213 $80097 $77846 $86545 $87926 $91345 $104039 $109783 $135035 $240957 $148686 $151977 $158779 $169848 $181689 $194355 $194355 $194355 $194355
BampT Other Post Employment Benefits 66323 50967 54831 66686 73055 76641 71148 62457 60441 78106 32297 22256 20303 22870 28694 33918 36169 38411 40604
Net Operating Deficit Before Subsidies and Debt Service ($6409807) ($6419266) ($6222079) ($6711095) ($7081966) ($7146057) ($7887759) ($6954506) ($7643392) ($8211234) ($8606220) ($9463506) ($9813560) ($10322912) ($10895644) ($11515498) ($11364824) ($11950106) ($12573710)
Conversion to Cash Basis Non-Cash Liability Adjs ($3182192) ($3051466) ($3166371) ($3785396) ($3959443) ($4108749) ($4322293) ($3542990) ($3797981) ($4020699) ($3584911) ($4027178) ($4205012) ($4320246) ($4487966) ($4713886) ($4830392) ($4947361) ($5067352)
Total Operating Expenses $9191127 $9511685 $9550486 $9936705 $10256481 $10937450 $11633535 $11870763 $12453659 $12927 $13803 $14246 $14476 $14891 $15293 $15732 $15927699 $16457978 $16983292
Debt Service Expenses $1515733 $1404454 $1781220 $1933532 $2058395 $2299262 $2248538 $2373321 $2458783 $2525 $2559 $2692 $2840 $3080 $3223 $3450 $3471321 $3472987 $3501639
Total Expenses + Debt Service $10706859 $10916139 $11331706 $11870237 $12314876 $13236712 $13882073 $14244084 $14912443 $15452 $16362 $16938 $17316 $17971 $18516 $19182 $19399019 $19930965 $20484932
Net Deficit After Subsidies and Debt Service ($668477) ($620796) ($0414) $287848 $320833 $556541 $561498 $810173 $359895 ($299965) ($339) ($890) ($1079) ($1506) ($1823) ($2283) ($1901641) ($2229069) ($2664369)
Conversion to Cash Basis GASB Account (56067) (54256) (67377) (37636) (89548) (85641) (50017) - 0 - 0 0 0 0 $0 0 0 - 0 - 0 - 0 - 0
Conversion to Cash Basis 492710 550267 91781 (111037) (297407) (261709) (626297) (660147) (591809) 174 296 363 188 (17) 88 130 49745 48375 54220
Net Cash Balance from Previous Year 0000 0000 0000 23990 139174 0000 209191 0000 150026 0000 0000 0000 0000 0000 0000 0000 0000 0000 0000
Total Operating Exp + DS + Cash Conversions + PY C-O $11144 $11412 $11356 $11746 $12067 $12889362 $13414950 $13583937 $14470659 $15625875 $16658585 $17300293 $17504155 $17954574 $18604130 $19312017 $19448764 $19979340 $20539152
Total Operating Expenses with Cash Conversion $10270216 $10420127 $11307302 $12018911 $12701831 $13584063 $14558387 $14904231 $15504252 $15278749 $16065734 $16575223 $17128079 $17987951 $18427778 $19052755 $19349274 $19882590 $20430711
Baseline Net Cash Balance Before B-T-L Adjustments ($231834) ($124785) $23990 $139174 ($66122) $209191 ($114816) $150026 ($231914) ($126) ($43) ($527) ($891) ($1523) ($1735) ($2153) ($1851896) ($2180695) ($2610148)
Below-the-Line Adjustments
FareToll Increases
FareToll Increase in March 2019 (4 Yield) - 0 $0 $0 $0 $0 $0 $0 - 0 - 0 - 0
FareToll Increase in March 2021 (4 Yield) - 0 $0 $0 $0 $283 $331 $332 333531 333568 334299
FareToll Increase in March 2023 (4 Yield) - 0 $0 $0 $0 $0 $0 $294 346386 346424 347183
FareToll Increase in March 2025 (4 Yield) - 0 $0 $0 $0 $0 $0 $0 - 0 273859 321624
Subsidy Impacts of 20212023 FareToll Increase - 0 $0 $0 $0 ($7) ($9) ($17) (18612) (25573) (26305)
$0000 $0 $0 $0 $275 $322 $609 $661306 $928278 $976801
CASH BALANCE AFTER FARE INCREASES ($126402) ($43) ($527) ($891) ($1241) ($1404) ($1821) ($1518365) ($1847127) ($2275849)
MTA Initiatives
MTA Efficiencies - Not Yet Implemented - 0 $0 $0 $0 $0 $0 $0 0000 0000 0000
0 - 0 $0 $0 $0 $0 $0 $0 - 0 - 0 - 0
0 - 0 $0 $0 $0 $0 $0 $0 - 0 - 0 - 0
$0000 $0 $0 $0 $0 $0 $0 $0000 $0000 $0000
Policy Actions
CAS Migration to Peoplesoft $0 $0 ($5) ($1) ($0) ($0) (0200) -02 -02 0
Fare Evasion Enforcement Strategy-Expenses $0 ($13) ($12) ($11) ($10) ($10) (9554) -9554483 -9554483 0
Fare Evasion Enforcement-Manhattan DA Forfeiture Fund $0 $11 $11 $10 $9 $0 - 0 0 0 0
Negotiated 1 CBA Reform $0 $0 $0 $0 $0 $0 - 0 0 0 0
MTA Reorganization $0 $8 $180 $371 $377 $377 377000 377 377 0
MTA Reorganization Costs $0 $0 ($10) ($27) ($2) $0 - 0 0 0 0
Drawdown 2019 General Reserve $0 $0 $165 $0 $0 $0 - 0 0 0 0
CBA Negotiated Reform - 1 Value $0 $36 $100 $173 $246 $323 323473 323473304484 323473304484 0
$0000 $0 $42 $429 $515 $620 $691 $690719 $690719 $690719
MTA Re-estimates
Additional Savings Actions $0000 $0 $0 $0 $0 $0 $0 $0000 $0000 $0000
Total Below-the-Line Adjustments $0 $0 $459 $413 $709 $760 $1007 $1352025 $1618997 $1667520
Prior Year Carryover 495399 263336 138286 161986 301160 235038 444229 329413 479439 248 121 79 11 0 0 - 0 - 0 - 0 - 0
NET CASH BALANCE $263566 $138551 $162276 $301160 $235038 $444229 $329413 $479439 $247525 $121 $79 $11 ($467) ($814) ($976) ($1146) ($499871) ($561698) ($942628)
By Revenue Source
(includes faretoll increases)
($ in millions)
Farebox Revenue $6389
Toll Revenue 2121
Other Revenue 684
Dedicated Taxes 6191
State and Local amp Other 1228
Timing (Cash Adjustments) 135
Total $16748
By Expense Category
(includes below-the-line adjustments)
($ in millions)
Payroll $5422
Overtime 838
Health amp Welfare 2118
Pension 1461
Other Labor 466
Total Labor $10306
Non-Labor + Other Exp Adj 4004
Debt Service 2830
BTL Adjustments for Expenses 2 (386)
Total $16754
By Revenue Source
(includes faretoll increases)
($ in millions)
Farebox Revenue $6389
Toll Revenue 2121
Other Revenue 684
Taxes 6178
State and Local amp Other 557
Other Funding Agreements 671
Other 1 208
Total $16809
By Expense Category
(includes below-the-line adjustments)
($ in millions)
Payroll $5392
Overtime 811
Health amp Welfare 2129
Pension 1354
Other Labor 400
Total Labor $10086
Non-Labor 4205
Debt Service 2692
BTL Adjustments for Expenses (251)
Total $16732
MTA July Financial Plan 2019-2022
Consolidated Statement Of Operations By Category ($ in millions)
Non-Reimbursable Mid-Year Preliminary
Actual Actual Actual Actual Actual Actual Actual Actual Actual Actual Forecast Budget
2008 2009 2010 2011 2012 2013 2014 2015 2016 2017 2018 2019 2020 2021 2022 2023 2024 2025 2026
Operating Revenues
Farebox Revenue $4240923 $4350411 $4586377 $4999186 $5079138 $5501274 $5709200 $5961129 $6050182 $6172 $6305 $6389 $6373 $6384 $6393 $6174 $6435176 $6431979 $6446633
422 423 405 411 402 399 395 396 396 407 384 385 380 375 371 261 368 363 362
Student Fare - 0 - 0 - 0 - 0 - 0 - 0
Toll Revenue 1273974 1332115 1417046 1501589 1490982 1645193 1676445 1808901 1869693 1912 2088 2121 2129 2129 2131 2002 2133050 2137871 2143111
0127 0129 0125 0124 0118 0119 0116 0120 0122 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0122 0121 0120
Other Revenue 448616 461359 491355 510231 563839 753675 682424 689217 688374 653 696 684 704 719 737 755 825040 885381 887190
Capital and Other Reimbursements 0000 0000 0000 0000 0000 0000 0000 0000 0000 0000 0000 0000 0000 0000 0000 0000 0000 0000 0000
Total Operating Revenue $5963512 $6143885 $6494778 $7011006 $7133959 $7900142 $8068069 $8459247 $8608249 $8737 $9089 $9195 $9206 $9232 $9260 $8931 $9393266 $9455232 $9476934
Dedicated Taxes $3211585 $2366805 $2343537 $2511691 $2673119 $3097640 $3383498 $3582628 $3525829 $3257508 $3459 $3515 $3568 $3630 $3725 $3812 $3841433 $3880226 $3917215
PMT amp MTA Aid - 0 881784 1588677 1718286 1825824 1825328 1885069 1910947 1970760 1987035 $1965 $2152 $2225 $2295 $2368 $2442 2516095 2594604 2677041
New Funding Sources - 0 - 0 - 0 - 0 - 0 - 0 - 0 - 0 - 0 - 0 $508 $342 $385 $385 $385 $385 385000 385000 385000
StateLocal Taxes 556691 539046 544810 541733 536182 537527 539545 537819 537645 541005 $544 $552 $557 $562 $567 $572 576828 581933 583214
Other Funding Agreements 306594 363823 359489 375369 466625 432617 567391 563616 629855 630218 $701 $753 $671 $708 $758 $758 784755 804901 781159
BampT Operating Surplus Transfer 382565 363092 476059 554903 476575 614210 637553 750717 742909 740144 $702 $721 $782 $801 $789 $707 730476 695303 688833
Dedicated Taxes and StateLocal Subsidies $4457434 $4514550 $5312572 $5701982 $5978325 $6507322 $7013056 $7345727 $7406998 $7155909 $7879 $8035 $8188 $8381 $8592 $8676 $8834588 $8941967 $9032462
$0000 $0000 $0000 $0000 $0000 $0000 $0000 $0000 $0000
Less Interagency Subsidy and Surplus Transfers (382565) (363092) (476059) (554903) (476575) (614210) (637553) (750717) (742909) (740144) ($702) ($721) ($782) ($801) ($789) ($707) (730476) (695303) (688833)
Total Subsidies $4074870 $4151458 $4836513 $5147079 $5501750 $5893111 $6375503 $6595010 $6664088 $6416 $7314 $7406 $7581 $7803 $7969 $7969 $8104112 $8246664 $8343629
Dedicated Taxes as a of Total Revenues + Subs - PMT 320 251 241 241 247 259 269 273 265 247 $0 $0 $0 $0 $0 $0 256 257 259
Total Revenues + Subsidies $10038382 $10295342 $11331292 $12158085 $12635709 $13793254 $14443571 $15054257 $15272337 $15152 $16403 $16601 $16787 $17035 $17229 $16900 $17497378 $17701896 $17820563
Operating Expenses
Labor Expenses
Payroll $4087376 $4163330 $4171374 $4160261 $4193658 $4332829 $4671664 $4695823 $4838741 $5020713 $5211 $5328 $5422 $5498 $5624 $5710 $5860206 $5982960 $6107107
Overtime 471675 499307 443227 538647 574316 620701 730200 755071 771495 934100 $1066 $910 $838 $859 $877 $899 917296 935002 951324
Health amp Welfare 684945 688899 738189 809638 812857 895714 961902 1050100 1172304 1208786 $1230 $1341 $1414 $1489 $1583 $1674 1797938 1922668 2071273
OPEB Current Payment 318501 346316 355716 394218 413164 472619 479079 501716 562233 563754 $604 $645 $704 $766 $835 $910 982025 1060022 1142795
Pensions 897450 1021229 1029710 1074598 1328441 1301975 1304355 1248726 1370474 1345308 $1336 $1494 $1461 $1462 $1403 $1347 1357887 1369071 1380572
Other-Fringe Benefits 502739 517194 539996 581661 650430 694680 784143 861079 947870 792151 $881 $869 $897 $930 $956 $976 1001185 1021007 1040170
Reimbursable Overhead (310555) (322230) (345154) (324006) (309399) (321390) (349770) (380212) (423759) (491807) ($528) ($471) ($430) ($412) ($397) ($395) (396136) (405509) (413165)
Labor Expenses $6652131 $6914045 $6933059 $7235017 $7663467 $7997128 $8581574 $8732302 $9239358 $9373 $10116 $10306 $10592 $10881 $11121 $11413 $11520401 $11885220 $12280075
PayrollOvertime Exp as a of Total Operating+DS $0426 $0427 $0407 $0396 $0387 $0374 $0389 $0383 $0376 $0385 $0367 $0365 $0359 $0355 $0350 $0349 $0347 $0345
Labor Exp (wo Reimb OH) as a of Total Oper+DS $0650 $0663 $0642 $0637 $0647 $0628 $0643 $0640 $0648 $0638 $0622 $0626 $0622 $0616 $0609 $0614 $0617 $0620
PayrollOvertime Exp as a of Total Operating Exp $0496 $0490 $0483 $0473 $0465 $0453 $0464 $0459 $0450 $0461 $0435 $0438 $0434 $0433 $0430 $0426 $0420 $0416
Labor Exp (wo Reimb OH) as a of Total Oper Exp $0758 $0761 $0762 $0761 $0777 $0761 $0768 $0768 $0776 $0763 $0739 $0750 $0751 $0750 $0749 $0748 $0747 $0747
Non-Labor Expenses
Electric Power $306500 $317934 $325137 $457269 $471514 $493346 $515540 $473762 $406372 $430381 $451503 $473177 $493090 $532413 $561955 $571182 $589565 $618283 $648255
Traction Power
Non-Traction Power
Fuel 287033 180294 189942 282735 251763 259252 267494 162283 124684 150481 182778 182981 176333 173681 176920 182259 182476 184281 186170
Revenue Vehicle Fuel
Non-Revenue Fuel
Insurance 28902 34012 9819 14363 7617 38654 50739 57190 (20634) (2715) 5608 15623 23118 26855 28309 36048 28232 25538 19483
Claims 152114 238104 285418 315547 135652 299875 269167 331023 463959 526053 387557 394211 392547 398256 406112 404397 417667 428660 437683
Paratransit Service Contracts 299013 370094 379761 348553 360500 366751 365599 379271 383704 392850 494751 488330 505538 535329 568614 581114 604766 643217 684112
Maintenance and Other Operating Contracts 594215 562456 541716 451137 451766 496743 549018 579289 630924 695251 840168 797428 833534 836606 854471 879468 880053 898882 915477
Professional Service Contracts 196930 199164 203084 226205 276998 297201 283005 379814 399706 507062 607838 502858 494814 504103 513895 499724 520826 537109 547291
Materials amp Supplies 532534 526191 511206 438310 430804 475127 526725 543225 585607 588115 689010 679895 697976 711281 715758 711988 741335 777460 793419
Other Business Expenses 155466 184142 189637 169857 143807 167198 179701 195598 192576 217254 218196 213551 224459 226170 228457 244907 228861 240258 241690
Non-Labor Expenses $2552708 $2612391 $2635720 $2703976 $2530421 $2894147 $3006988 $3101454 $3166897 3505 3877 3748 3841 3945 4054 4111 $4193782 $4353689 $4473580
Other Expense Adjustments
Other ($13712) ($14750) ($18292) ($2289) $62593 $46175 $44973 $37007 $47404 49 175 86 36 22 23 23 $23516 $24069 $24637
General Reserve 0000 0000 0000 0000 0000 - 0 - 0 - 0 - 0 0 165 170 175 180 185 185 190000 195000 205000
Other Expense Adjustments ($13712) ($14750) ($18292) ($2289) $62593 $46175 $44973 $37007 $47404 $49379 $340 $256 $211 $202 $208 $208 $213516 $219069 $229637
Gap Closing Expenses $7675394
Additional Actions for Budget Balance Expense Impact $0000 $0000 $0000 $0000 $0000 $0000 $0000 $0000 $0000 $0000 $0000 $0000 $0000 $0000 $0000 $0000 $0000 $0000 $0000
Total Operating Expenses Before Non-Cash Liability Adjs $9191127 $9511685 $9550486 $9936705 $10256481 $10937450 $11633535 $11870763 $12453659 $12927116 $14332772 $14309678 $14643965 $15027767 $15383584 $15732241 $15927699 $16457978 $16983292
Non-Cash Liability Adjustments
Depreciation $1790981 $1940576 $1980681 $2019378 $2148820 $2174302 $2266280 $2442777 $2442941 $2607970 $2804571 $2784812 $2842737 $2908533 $2977025 $3051834 $3109882 $3169371 $3230301
OPEB Obligation 1348962 1104827 1167070 1706939 1785881 1920189 2035457 1489656 1562261 1567381 0000 (0000) (0000) (0000) (0000) 0000 0000 (0000) (0000)
GASB 75 OPEB Expense Adjustment 0000 0000 0000 0000 0000 0000 0000 0000 0000 0000 1047747 1457230 1628196 1748560 1823313 1898497 1952374 2006482 2061993
GASB 68 Pension Expense Adjustment 0000 0000 0000 0000 0000 0000 0000 (410019) (218911) (168119) (373022) (220864) (271921) (342847) (318372) (242446) (237864) (234492) (230942)
Environmental Remediation 42249 6062 18621 59079 24742 14257 20556 20576 11691 13468 105615 6000 6000 6000 6000 6000 6000 6000 6000
Non-Cash Liability Adjustments $3182192 $3051466 $3166371 $3785396 $3959443 $4108749 $4322293 $3542990 $3797981 $4020699 $3584911 $4027178 $4205012 $4320246 $4487966 $4713886 $4830392 $4947361 $5067352
Total Operating Expenses After Non-Cash Liability Adjs $12373319 $12563151 $12716857 $13722101 $14215924 $15046199 $15955827 $15413753 $16251641 $16947815 $17917683 $18336856 $18848977 $19348013 $19871550 $20446127 $20758090 $21405338 $22050644
Less BampT Depreciation $77213 $80097 $77846 $86545 $87926 $91345 $104039 $109783 $135035 $240957 $148686 $151977 $158779 $169848 $181689 $194355 $194355 $194355 $194355
BampT Other Post Employment Benefits 66323 50967 54831 66686 73055 76641 71148 62457 60441 78106 32297 22256 20303 22870 28694 33918 36169 38411 40604
Net Operating Deficit Before Subsidies and Debt Service ($6409807) ($6419266) ($6222079) ($6711095) ($7081966) ($7146057) ($7887759) ($6954506) ($7643392) ($8211234) ($8829030) ($9141907) ($9642826) ($10116260) ($10611154) ($11515498) ($11364824) ($11950106) ($12573710)
Conversion to Cash Basis Non-Cash Liability Adjs ($3182192) ($3051466) ($3166371) ($3785396) ($3959443) ($4108749) ($4322293) ($3542990) ($3797981) ($4020699) ($3584911) ($4027178) ($4205012) ($4320246) ($4487966) ($4713886) ($4830392) ($4947361) ($5067352)
Total Operating Expenses $9191127 $9511685 $9550486 $9936705 $10256481 $10937450 $11633535 $11870763 $12453659 $12927 $14333 $14310 $14644 $15028 $15384 $15732 $15927699 $16457978 $16983292
Debt Service Expenses $1515733 $1404454 $1781220 $1933532 $2058395 $2299262 $2248538 $2373321 $2458783 $2525 $2683 $2830 $3041 $3265 $3513 $3450 $3471321 $3472987 $3501639
Total Expenses + Debt Service $10706859 $10916139 $11331706 $11870237 $12314876 $13236712 $13882073 $14244084 $14912443 $15452 $17016 $17140 $17685 $18293 $18896 $19182 $19399019 $19930965 $20484932
Net Deficit After Subsidies and Debt Service ($668477) ($620796) ($0414) $287848 $320833 $556541 $561498 $810173 $359895 ($299965) ($613) ($539) ($898) ($1258) ($1667) ($2283) ($1901641) ($2229069) ($2664369)
Conversion to Cash Basis GASB Account (56067) (54256) (67377) (37636) (89548) (85641) (50017) - 0 - 0 0 0 0 $0 0 0 - 0 - 0 - 0 - 0
Conversion to Cash Basis 492710 550267 91781 (111037) (297407) (261709) (626297) (660147) (591809) 174 229 147 60 125 101 130 49745 48375 54220
Net Cash Balance from Previous Year 0000 0000 0000 23990 139174 0000 209191 0000 150026 0000 0000 0000 0000 0000 0000 0000 0000 0000 0000
Total Operating Exp + DS + Cash Conversions + PY C-O $11144 $11412 $11356 $11746 $12067 $12889362 $13414950 $13583937 $14470659 $15625875 $17244782 $17286526 $17744425 $18418197 $18997710 $19312017 $19448764 $19979340 $20539152
Total Operating Expenses with Cash Conversion $10270216 $10420127 $11307302 $12018911 $12701831 $13584063 $14558387 $14904231 $15504252 $15278749 $16786574 $16992579 $17624861 $18167420 $18795069 $19052755 $19349274 $19882590 $20430711
Baseline Net Cash Balance Before B-T-L Adjustments ($231834) ($124785) $23990 $139174 ($66122) $209191 ($114816) $150026 ($231914) ($126) ($384) ($392) ($838) ($1133) ($1566) ($2153) ($1851896) ($2180695) ($2610148)
Below-the-Line Adjustments
FareToll Increases
FareToll Increase in March 2019 (4 Yield) - 0 $0 $0 $0 $0 $0 $0 - 0 - 0 - 0
FareToll Increase in March 2021 (4 Yield) - 0 $0 $0 $0 $283 $331 $332 333531 333568 334299
FareToll Increase in March 2023 (4 Yield) - 0 $0 $0 $0 $0 $0 $294 346386 346424 347183
FareToll Increase in March 2025 (4 Yield) - 0 $0 $0 $0 $0 $0 $0 - 0 273859 321624
Subsidy Impacts of 20212023 FareToll Increase - 0 $0 $0 $0 ($7) ($9) ($17) (18612) (25573) (26305)
$0000 $0 $0 $0 $275 $322 $609 $661306 $928278 $976801
CASH BALANCE AFTER FARE INCREASES ($126402) ($384) ($392) ($838) ($850) ($1234) ($1821) ($1518365) ($1847127) ($2275849)
MTA Initiatives
MTA Efficiencies - Not Yet Implemented - 0 $0 $0 $0 $0 $0 $0 0000 0000 0000
0 - 0 $0 $0 $0 $0 $0 $0 - 0 - 0 - 0
0 - 0 $0 $0 $0 $0 $0 $0 - 0 - 0 - 0
$0000 $0 $0 $0 $0 $0 $0 $0000 $0000 $0000
Policy Actions
CAS Migration to Peoplesoft $0 $0 ($5) ($1) ($0) ($0) (0200) -02 -02 0
Fare Evasion Enforcement Strategy-Expenses $0 ($13) ($12) ($11) ($10) ($10) (9554) -9554483 -9554483 0
Fare Evasion Enforcement-Manhattan DA Forfeiture Fund $0 $11 $11 $10 $9 $0 - 0 0 0 0
Negotiated 1 CBA Reform $0 $0 $0 $0 $0 $0 - 0 0 0 0
MTA Reorganization $0 $8 $180 $371 $377 $377 377000 377 377 0
MTA Reorganization Costs $0 $0 ($10) ($27) ($2) $0 - 0 0 0 0
Drawdown 2019 General Reserve $0 $0 $165 $0 $0 $0 - 0 0 0 0
CBA Negotiated Reform - 1 Value $0 $36 $100 $173 $246 $323 323473 323473304484 323473304484 0
$0000 $0 $42 $429 $515 $620 $691 $690719 $690719 $690719
MTA Re-estimates
Additional Savings Actions $0000 $0 $0 $0 $0 $0 $0 $0000 $0000 $0000
Total Below-the-Line Adjustments $0 $73 $386 $757 $852 $1133 $1007 $1352025 $1618997 $1667520
Prior Year Carryover 495399 263336 138286 161986 301160 235038 444229 329413 479439 248 372 61 55 0 0 - 0 - 0 - 0 - 0
NET CASH BALANCE $263566 $138551 $162276 $301160 $235038 $444229 $329413 $479439 $247525 $121 $61 $55 ($26) ($281) ($433) ($1146) ($499871) ($561698) ($942628)
MTA February Financial Plan 2019-2022
Consolidated Statement Of Operations By Category ($ in millions)
Non-Reimbursable Final Adopted
Actual Actual Actual Actual Actual Actual Actual Actual Actual Actual Estimate Budget
2008 2009 2010 2011 2012 2013 2014 2015 2016 2017 2018 2019 2020 2021 2022 2023 2024 2025 2026
Operating Revenues
Farebox Revenue $4240923 $4350411 $4586377 $4999186 $5079138 $5501274 $5709200 $5961129 $6050182 $6172 $6153 $6122 $6144 $6134 $6144 $6174 $6435176 $6431979 $6446633
422 423 405 411 402 399 395 396 396 407 279 275 272 267 263 261 368 363 362
Student Fare - 0 - 0 - 0 - 0 - 0 - 0
Toll Revenue 1273974 1332115 1417046 1501589 1490982 1645193 1676445 1808901 1869693 1912 1967 1984 1990 1998 1998 2002 2133050 2137871 2143111
0127 0129 0125 0124 0118 0119 0116 0120 0122 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0122 0121 0120
Other Revenue 448616 461359 491355 510231 563839 753675 682424 689217 688374 653 662 705 733 757 743 755 825040 885381 887190
Capital and Other Reimbursements 0000 0000 0000 0000 0000 0000 0000 0000 0000 0000 0000 0000 0000 0000 0000 0000 0000 0000 0000
Total Operating Revenue $5963512 $6143885 $6494778 $7011006 $7133959 $7900142 $8068069 $8459247 $8608249 $8737 $8782 $8810 $8867 $8889 $8886 $8931 $9393266 $9455232 $9476934
Dedicated Taxes $3211585 $2366805 $2343537 $2511691 $2673119 $3097640 $3383498 $3582628 $3525829 $3257508 $3459 $3515 $3568 $3630 $3725 $3812 $3841433 $3880226 $3917215
PMT amp MTA Aid - 0 881784 1588677 1718286 1825824 1825328 1885069 1910947 1970760 1987035 $1965 $2152 $2225 $2295 $2368 $2442 2516095 2594604 2677041
New Funding Sources - 0 - 0 - 0 - 0 - 0 - 0 - 0 - 0 - 0 - 0 $508 $342 $385 $385 $385 $385 385000 385000 385000
StateLocal Taxes 556691 539046 544810 541733 536182 537527 539545 537819 537645 541005 $544 $552 $557 $562 $567 $572 576828 581933 583214
Other Funding Agreements 306594 363823 359489 375369 466625 432617 567391 563616 629855 630218 $701 $753 $671 $708 $758 $758 784755 804901 781159
BampT Operating Surplus Transfer 382565 363092 476059 554903 476575 614210 637553 750717 742909 740144 $702 $721 $782 $801 $789 $707 730476 695303 688833
Dedicated Taxes and StateLocal Subsidies $4457434 $4514550 $5312572 $5701982 $5978325 $6507322 $7013056 $7345727 $7406998 $7155909 $7879 $8035 $8188 $8381 $8592 $8676 $8834588 $8941967 $9032462
$0000 $0000 $0000 $0000 $0000 $0000 $0000 $0000 $0000
Less Interagency Subsidy and Surplus Transfers (382565) (363092) (476059) (554903) (476575) (614210) (637553) (750717) (742909) (740144) ($702) ($721) ($782) ($801) ($789) ($707) (730476) (695303) (688833)
Total Subsidies $4074870 $4151458 $4836513 $5147079 $5501750 $5893111 $6375503 $6595010 $6664088 $6416 $7242 $7238 $7370 $7576 $7807 $7969 $8104112 $8246664 $8343629
Dedicated Taxes as a of Total Revenues + Subs - PMT 320 251 241 241 247 259 269 273 265 247 $0 $0 $0 $0 $0 $0 256 257 259
Total Revenues + Subsidies $10038382 $10295342 $11331292 $12158085 $12635709 $13793254 $14443571 $15054257 $15272337 $15152 $16023 $16048 $16237 $16465 $16693 $16900 $17497378 $17701896 $17820563
Operating Expenses
Labor Expenses
Payroll $4087376 $4163330 $4171374 $4160261 $4193658 $4332829 $4671664 $4695823 $4838741 $5020713 $5211 $5328 $5422 $5498 $5624 $5710 $5860206 $5982960 $6107107
Overtime 471675 499307 443227 538647 574316 620701 730200 755071 771495 934100 $1066 $910 $838 $859 $877 $899 917296 935002 951324
Health amp Welfare 684945 688899 738189 809638 812857 895714 961902 1050100 1172304 1208786 $1230 $1341 $1414 $1489 $1583 $1674 1797938 1922668 2071273
OPEB Current Payment 318501 346316 355716 394218 413164 472619 479079 501716 562233 563754 $604 $645 $704 $766 $835 $910 982025 1060022 1142795
Pensions 897450 1021229 1029710 1074598 1328441 1301975 1304355 1248726 1370474 1345308 $1336 $1494 $1461 $1462 $1403 $1347 1357887 1369071 1380572
Other-Fringe Benefits 502739 517194 539996 581661 650430 694680 784143 861079 947870 792151 $881 $869 $897 $930 $956 $976 1001185 1021007 1040170
Reimbursable Overhead (310555) (322230) (345154) (324006) (309399) (321390) (349770) (380212) (423759) (491807) ($528) ($471) ($430) ($412) ($397) ($395) (396136) (405509) (413165)
Labor Expenses $6652131 $6914045 $6933059 $7235017 $7663467 $7997128 $8581574 $8732302 $9239358 $9373 $9920 $10039 $10436 $10787 $11097 $11413 $11520401 $11885220 $12280075
PayrollOvertime Exp as a of Total Operating+DS $0426 $0427 $0407 $0396 $0387 $0374 $0389 $0383 $0376 $0385 $0349 $0347 $0345
Labor Exp (wo Reimb OH) as a of Total Oper+DS $0650 $0663 $0642 $0637 $0647 $0628 $0643 $0640 $0648 $0638 $0614 $0617 $0620
PayrollOvertime Exp as a of Total Operating Exp $0496 $0490 $0483 $0473 $0465 $0453 $0464 $0459 $0450 $0461 $0426 $0420 $0416
Labor Exp (wo Reimb OH) as a of Total Oper Exp $0758 $0761 $0762 $0761 $0777 $0761 $0768 $0768 $0776 $0763 $0748 $0747 $0747
Non-Labor Expenses
Electric Power $306500 $317934 $325137 $457269 $471514 $493346 $515540 $473762 $406372 $430381 $474918 $451304 $463523 $482662 $539624 $571182 $589565 $618283 $648255
Traction Power
Non-Traction Power
Fuel 287033 180294 189942 282735 251763 259252 267494 162283 124684 150481 185580 190348 187592 183168 181484 182259 182476 184281 186170
Revenue Vehicle Fuel
Non-Revenue Fuel
Insurance 28902 34012 9819 14363 7617 38654 50739 57190 (20634) (2715) 11488 8532 15803 22918 29411 36048 28232 25538 19483
Claims 152114 238104 285418 315547 135652 299875 269167 331023 463959 526053 376480 378570 386981 391333 395228 404397 417667 428660 437683
Paratransit Service Contracts 299013 370094 379761 348553 360500 366751 365599 379271 383704 392850 452190 482751 501230 518038 547829 581114 604766 643217 684112
Maintenance and Other Operating Contracts 594215 562456 541716 451137 451766 496743 549018 579289 630924 695251 779331 897801 833038 883805 871671 879468 880053 898882 915477
Professional Service Contracts 196930 199164 203084 226205 276998 297201 283005 379814 399706 507062 575742 557476 484911 479376 489510 499724 520826 537109 547291
Materials amp Supplies 532534 526191 511206 438310 430804 475127 526725 543225 585607 588115 667700 686666 687745 692131 697268 711988 741335 777460 793419
Other Business Expenses 155466 184142 189637 169857 143807 167198 179701 195598 192576 217254 225494 230595 225293 240279 242193 244907 228861 240258 241690
Non-Labor Expenses $2552708 $2612391 $2635720 $2703976 $2530421 $2894147 $3006988 $3101454 $3166897 3505 3749 3884 3786 3894 3994 4111 $4193782 $4353689 $4473580
Other Expense Adjustments
Other ($13712) ($14750) ($18292) ($2289) $62593 $46175 $44973 $37007 $47404 49 134 158 84 36 22 23 $23516 $24069 $24637
General Reserve 0000 0000 0000 0000 0000 - 0 - 0 - 0 - 0 0 0 165 170 175 180 185 190000 195000 205000
Other Expense Adjustments ($13712) ($14750) ($18292) ($2289) $62593 $46175 $44973 $37007 $47404 $49379 $134 $323 $254 $211 $202 $208 $213516 $219069 $229637
Gap Closing Expenses $7675394
Additional Actions for Budget Balance Expense Impact $0000 $0000 $0000 $0000 $0000 $0000 $0000 $0000 $0000 $0000 $0000 $0000 $0000 $0000 $0000 $0000 $0000 $0000 $0000
Total Operating Expenses Before Non-Cash Liability Adjs $9191127 $9511685 $9550486 $9936705 $10256481 $10937450 $11633535 $11870763 $12453659 $12927116 $13802910 $14246122 $14475644 $14891445 $15293262 $15732241 $15927699 $16457978 $16983292
Non-Cash Liability Adjustments
Depreciation $1790981 $1940576 $1980681 $2019378 $2148820 $2174302 $2266280 $2442777 $2442941 $2607970 $2804571 $2784812 $2842737 $2908533 $2977025 $3051834 $3109882 $3169371 $3230301
OPEB Obligation 1348962 1104827 1167070 1706939 1785881 1920189 2035457 1489656 1562261 1567381 0000 (0000) (0000) (0000) (0000) 0000 0000 (0000) (0000)
GASB 75 OPEB Expense Adjustment 0000 0000 0000 0000 0000 0000 0000 0000 0000 0000 1047747 1457230 1628196 1748560 1823313 1898497 1952374 2006482 2061993
GASB 68 Pension Expense Adjustment 0000 0000 0000 0000 0000 0000 0000 (410019) (218911) (168119) (373022) (220864) (271921) (342847) (318372) (242446) (237864) (234492) (230942)
Environmental Remediation 42249 6062 18621 59079 24742 14257 20556 20576 11691 13468 105615 6000 6000 6000 6000 6000 6000 6000 6000
Non-Cash Liability Adjustments $3182192 $3051466 $3166371 $3785396 $3959443 $4108749 $4322293 $3542990 $3797981 $4020699 $3584911 $4027178 $4205012 $4320246 $4487966 $4713886 $4830392 $4947361 $5067352
Total Operating Expenses After Non-Cash Liability Adjs $12373319 $12563151 $12716857 $13722101 $14215924 $15046199 $15955827 $15413753 $16251641 $16947815 $17387821 $18273301 $18680657 $19211690 $19781228 $20446127 $20758090 $21405338 $22050644
Less BampT Depreciation $77213 $80097 $77846 $86545 $87926 $91345 $104039 $109783 $135035 $240957 $148686 $151977 $158779 $169848 $181689 $194355 $194355 $194355 $194355
BampT Other Post Employment Benefits 66323 50967 54831 66686 73055 76641 71148 62457 60441 78106 32297 22256 20303 22870 28694 33918 36169 38411 40604
Net Operating Deficit Before Subsidies and Debt Service ($6409807) ($6419266) ($6222079) ($6711095) ($7081966) ($7146057) ($7887759) ($6954506) ($7643392) ($8211234) ($8606220) ($9463506) ($9813560) ($10322912) ($10895644) ($11515498) ($11364824) ($11950106) ($12573710)
Conversion to Cash Basis Non-Cash Liability Adjs ($3182192) ($3051466) ($3166371) ($3785396) ($3959443) ($4108749) ($4322293) ($3542990) ($3797981) ($4020699) ($3584911) ($4027178) ($4205012) ($4320246) ($4487966) ($4713886) ($4830392) ($4947361) ($5067352)
Total Operating Expenses $9191127 $9511685 $9550486 $9936705 $10256481 $10937450 $11633535 $11870763 $12453659 $12927 $13803 $14246 $14476 $14891 $15293 $15732 $15927699 $16457978 $16983292
Debt Service Expenses $1515733 $1404454 $1781220 $1933532 $2058395 $2299262 $2248538 $2373321 $2458783 $2525 $2559 $2692 $2840 $3080 $3223 $3450 $3471321 $3472987 $3501639
Total Expenses + Debt Service $10706859 $10916139 $11331706 $11870237 $12314876 $13236712 $13882073 $14244084 $14912443 $15452 $16362 $16938 $17316 $17971 $18516 $19182 $19399019 $19930965 $20484932
Net Deficit After Subsidies and Debt Service ($668477) ($620796) ($0414) $287848 $320833 $556541 $561498 $810173 $359895 ($299965) ($339) ($890) ($1079) ($1506) ($1823) ($2283) ($1901641) ($2229069) ($2664369)
Conversion to Cash Basis GASB Account (56067) (54256) (67377) (37636) (89548) (85641) (50017) - 0 - 0 0 0 0 $0 0 0 - 0 - 0 - 0 - 0
Conversion to Cash Basis 492710 550267 91781 (111037) (297407) (261709) (626297) (660147) (591809) 174 296 363 188 (17) 88 130 49745 48375 54220
Net Cash Balance from Previous Year 0000 0000 0000 23990 139174 0000 209191 0000 150026 0000 0000 0000 0000 0000 0000 0000 0000 0000 0000
Total Operating Exp + DS + Cash Conversions + PY C-O $11144 $11412 $11356 $11746 $12067 $12889362 $13414950 $13583937 $14470659 $15625875 $16658585 $17300293 $17504155 $17954574 $18604130 $19312017 $19448764 $19979340 $20539152
Total Operating Expenses with Cash Conversion $10270216 $10420127 $11307302 $12018911 $12701831 $13584063 $14558387 $14904231 $15504252 $15278749 $16065734 $16575223 $17128079 $17987951 $18427778 $19052755 $19349274 $19882590 $20430711
Baseline Net Cash Balance Before B-T-L Adjustments ($231834) ($124785) $23990 $139174 ($66122) $209191 ($114816) $150026 ($231914) ($126) ($43) ($527) ($891) ($1523) ($1735) ($2153) ($1851896) ($2180695) ($2610148)
Below-the-Line Adjustments
FareToll Increases
FareToll Increase in March 2019 (4 Yield) - 0 $0 $0 $0 $0 $0 $0 - 0 - 0 - 0
FareToll Increase in March 2021 (4 Yield) - 0 $0 $0 $0 $283 $331 $332 333531 333568 334299
FareToll Increase in March 2023 (4 Yield) - 0 $0 $0 $0 $0 $0 $294 346386 346424 347183
FareToll Increase in March 2025 (4 Yield) - 0 $0 $0 $0 $0 $0 $0 - 0 273859 321624
Subsidy Impacts of 20212023 FareToll Increase - 0 $0 $0 $0 ($7) ($9) ($17) (18612) (25573) (26305)
$0000 $0 $0 $0 $275 $322 $609 $661306 $928278 $976801
CASH BALANCE AFTER FARE INCREASES ($126402) ($43) ($527) ($891) ($1241) ($1404) ($1821) ($1518365) ($1847127) ($2275849)
MTA Initiatives
MTA Efficiencies - Not Yet Implemented - 0 $0 $0 $0 $0 $0 $0 0000 0000 0000
0 - 0 $0 $0 $0 $0 $0 $0 - 0 - 0 - 0
0 - 0 $0 $0 $0 $0 $0 $0 - 0 - 0 - 0
$0000 $0 $0 $0 $0 $0 $0 $0000 $0000 $0000
Policy Actions
CAS Migration to Peoplesoft $0 $0 ($5) ($1) ($0) ($0) (0200) -02 -02 0
Fare Evasion Enforcement Strategy-Expenses $0 ($13) ($12) ($11) ($10) ($10) (9554) -9554483 -9554483 0
Fare Evasion Enforcement-Manhattan DA Forfeiture Fund $0 $11 $11 $10 $9 $0 - 0 0 0 0
Negotiated 1 CBA Reform $0 $0 $0 $0 $0 $0 - 0 0 0 0
MTA Reorganization $0 $8 $180 $371 $377 $377 377000 377 377 0
MTA Reorganization Costs $0 $0 ($10) ($27) ($2) $0 - 0 0 0 0
Drawdown 2019 General Reserve $0 $0 $165 $0 $0 $0 - 0 0 0 0
CBA Negotiated Reform - 1 Value $0 $36 $100 $173 $246 $323 323473 323473304484 323473304484 0
$0000 $0 $42 $429 $515 $620 $691 $690719 $690719 $690719
MTA Re-estimates
Additional Savings Actions $0000 $0 $0 $0 $0 $0 $0 $0000 $0000 $0000
Total Below-the-Line Adjustments $0 $0 $459 $413 $709 $760 $1007 $1352025 $1618997 $1667520
Prior Year Carryover 495399 263336 138286 161986 301160 235038 444229 329413 479439 248 121 79 11 0 0 - 0 - 0 - 0 - 0
NET CASH BALANCE $263566 $138551 $162276 $301160 $235038 $444229 $329413 $479439 $247525 $121 $79 $11 ($467) ($814) ($976) ($1146) ($499871) ($561698) ($942628)
Page 3: MTA 2020 Preliminary Budget July Financial Plan 2020 - 2023 2020 Preliminar… · 1 The MTA Budget Process July Plan – Start of the Annual Process • Current year is revised (the

2

Non-Reimbursable Final Adopted Estimate Budget 2018 2019 2020 2021 2022

Operating RevenuesFarebox Revenue $6153 $6122 $6144 $6134 $6144Toll Revenue 1967 1984 1990 1998 1998 Other Revenue 662 705 733 757 743

Total Operating Revenue $8782 $8810 $8867 $8889 $8886

Total Subsidies $7242 $7238 $7370 $7576 $7807Dedicated Taxes as a of Total Revenues + Subs - PMT $0 $0 $0 $0 $0

Total Revenues + Subsidies $16023 $16048 $16237 $16465 $16693

Operating ExpensesLabor Expenses $9920 $10039 $10436 $10787 $11097Non-Labor Expenses 3749 3884 3786 3894 3994 Other 134 158 84 36 22 General Reserve 0 165 170 175 180

Total Operating Expenses $13803 $14246 $14476 $14891 $15293

Debt Service Expenses $2559 $2692 $2840 $3080 $3223

Total Expenses + Debt Service $16362 $16938 $17316 $17971 $18516

Conversion to Cash Basis 296 363 188 (17) 88

Baseline Net Cash Balance Before B-T-L Adjustments ($43) ($527) ($891) ($1523) ($1735)

Total Below-the-Line Adjustments $0 $459 $413 $709 $760Prior Year Carryover 121 79 11 0 0

NET CASH BALANCE $79 $11 ($467) ($814) ($976)

MTA February Financial Plan 2019-2022Consolidated Statement Of Operations By Category ($ in millions)

Summ Stmt of Ops-Feb

Summ Stmt of Ops-Jul

3

The February Financial Plan included large out-year deficits even with faretoll increases and substantial cost reduction targets

($ in millions)

11

(467)

(814)

(976)

($1200)

($1000)

($800)

($600)

($400)

($200)

$0

$200

2019 2020 2021 2022

This Year Next Year Out-Years

What has changed since the February Plan

Changes and re-estimates over the Plan period (2019 ndash 2022)bull Changes and re-estimates improving financial results

bull Higher MMTOA subsidies ($184 million)bull Higher yield from additional 23 in tolls ($173 million)bull Lower maintenanceother operating contracts ($173 million)bull Higher MTA Aid car rental tax ($35 million)

bull Changes and re-estimates worsening financial resultsbull Actuary recalculation of pension liability ($550 million)bull Agency re-estimates and rate change adjustments ($189 million)bull Higher overtime expenses ($131 million)bull Lower rentaladvertising revenues ($83 million)bull Lower real estate tax revenues ($59 million)

In total these changes and re-estimates along with other changes are $447 million unfavorable for the Plan period

4

Highlights of the July Plan

bull Proposed biennial fare and toll increases of 4 in 2021 and 2023 (versus projected 2-year CPI inflators of 49 and 47 in 2021 and 2023 respectively)

bull Maintained investments from prior plans including maintenance of the Subway Action Plan funded from Phase 1 of Congestion PricingFHV fees

bull Renewed emphasis to gain control of and reduce fare evasion (investment of $62 million over the Plan period)

bull MTA is using ldquoone-shotsrdquo to balance the budget in the transition years 2019 and 2020

o 2019 - 2018 favorable year-end balance ndash mostly timing ndash and impacts 2019 ($372 million)

- Freeze on filling all non-operationalnon-essential vacancies ($68 million)

- Other restrictions on non-essential spending including non-revenue vehicle purchases travelprofessional memberships ($44 million)

- One-time reduction of committed to capital contributions ($64 million)

o 2020 - Drawdown of 2019 General Reserve ($165 million)

bull Annual recurring savings targets of $350 million beginning in 2020 have been identified by HQ and Agencies

5

6

These actions will not suffice and significant deficits remain($ in millions)

This Year Next Year Out-Years

11

(467)

(814)

(976)

NA

50

(186)

(569)

(816)

(971)

($1200)

($1000)

($800)

($600)

($400)

($200)

$0

$200

2019 2020 2021 2022 2023

February PlanJuly Plan without Transformation Plan Savings

MTA Transformation Plan

bull State-mandated plan to review operations and implement changes to streamline internal processes clarify responsibilities solidify accountability and work more efficiently to regain trust of our customers and funding partners and improve MTArsquos ability to deliver safe and reliable service our customers deserve

bull Plan recommendationsbull Refocus the operating agencies on mission-critical operating priorities of safety reliability and

servicebull Centralize common support functions to improve operations and create opportunities to ensure

consistent standards quality and policies across departmentsbull Unify the management of capital programs to improve and streamline planning development

and construction so capital improvements can be delivered on time and on budgetbull Expand senior leadership by adding a Chief Transformation Officer a Chief Operating Officer a

Chief Engineering Officer and an MTA Accessibility Officer

bull Consolidation and efficiency targets of $370 million to $530 million on an annual basis have been identified

bull If the MTA Transformation Plan is approved and implemented the July Financial Plan will have small operating balances in 2019 and 2020 a small deficit in 2021 with out-year deficits reaching $433 million in 2023

7

8

The adoption and implementation of the MTA Transformation Planhas the potential to significantly reduce out-year deficits

($ in millions)

This Year Next Year Out-Years

11

(467)

(814)

(976)

NA

61 55

(26)

(281)

(433)

($1200)

($1000)

($800)

($600)

($400)

($200)

$0

$200

2019 2020 2021 2022 2023

February PlanProposed July Plan

Actions to Reduce Fare Evasion $62 million Investment over the Plan Period

bull Increase physical presence (500 uniformed officers NYPD MTA Police and Bridge and Tunnel Officers) to begin enforcement at 50 subway stations and 50 bus routesThis is not just a fare evasion effort but a workerrsquos safety initiative

bull Ensure enforcement does not target any specific demographic bull Educate MTA riders utilizing messaging media and automated

announcementsbull Improve operation of emergency exit gates to mitigate instances of fare

avoidancebull Augment surveillance capabilities by deploying fare array cameras at 50

stations and pilot the use of monitors at 10 stationsbull $40 million of the investment will be funded by Manhattan DA Office over a

four-year period

9

The MTArsquos $350 million target for annually recurring savings beginning in 2020 has been identified and is being implemented

109

10 7 6 6

96 304 351 362 371

$0

$50

$100

$150

$200

$250

$300

$350

$400

2019 2020 2021 2022 2023

Identified Recurring Savings One-Shot Savings

This Year Next Year Out-Years

($ in millions)

10

We have a track record of identifying and achieving our annual recurring savings targets

11

($ in millions)

$0

$500

$1000

$1500

$2000

$2500

$3000

Achieved Savings

2012 November Plan

2013 November Plan

2014 November Plan

2015 November Plan

2016 November Plan

2017 November Plan

2018 November Plan

2019 July Plan

$28 billion

Proposed July Plan

Deficits remain and a continued drive toward further streamlining and efficiencies is required

12

($ in millions)

61 55

(26)

(281)

(433)

($600)

($500)

($400)

($300)

($200)

($100)

$0

$100

$200

2019 2020 2021 2022 2023

This Year Next Year Out-Years

Proposed July PlanDonrsquot achieve Transformation Plan Savings

13

If the MTA Transformation Plan is not adopted and implemented the deficits will be unmanageable without service cuts significant

reductions in force andor additional fare and toll increases($ in millions)

($1100)

($900)

($700)

($500)

($300)

($100)

$100

2019 2020 2021 2022 2023

(816)

(971)

(569)

(81)

(433)

(281)

61 55 (26)

(281) (186)

50

Next Year Out-Years

(230)(11)

(488)

(538)

(535)

This Year

14

2020 Preliminary BudgetWhere the Dollars Come Fromhellip Where the Dollars Gohellip

Farebox Revenue $6389Toll Revenue 2121 Other Revenue 684 Taxes 6178 State and Local amp Other 557 Other Funding Agreements 671 Other 1 208 Total $16809

($ in millions)

By Revenue Source(includes faretoll increases)

Payroll $5422Overtime 838 Health amp Welfare 2118 Pension 1461 Other Labor 466 Total Labor $10306Non-Labor + Other Exp Adj 4004 Debt Service 2830 BTL Adjustments for Expenses 2 (386) Total $16754

By Expense Category

($ in millions)(includes below-the-line adjustments)

1 Includes cash adjustments and prior-year carryover

Farebox Revenue

38

Toll Revenue

13

Other Revenue4

Taxes37

State amp Local

Subsidies3

Other Funding Agreements

4 Other 1

Payroll32

Overtime5

Health ampWelfare

13Pension

9

Other Labor3

Non-Labor + Other Exp Adj

21

Debt Service17

2 The below-the-line adjustments are grouped in the Non-Labor category

Sheet1

Sheet1

15

Non-Reimbursable Mid-Year Preliminary Actual Forecast Budget

2018 2019 2020 2021 2022 2023 Operating Revenues

Farebox Revenue $6155 $6305 $6389 $6373 $6384 $6393Toll Revenue 1976 2088 2121 2129 2129 2131 Other Revenue 643 696 684 704 719 737

Total Operating Revenue $8774 $9089 $9195 $9206 $9232 $9260

Total Subsidies $7177 $7314 $7406 $7581 $7803 $7969Dedicated Taxes as a of Total Revenues + Subs - PMT 233 $0 $0 $0 $0 $0

Total Revenues + Subsidies $15951 $16403 $16601 $16787 $17035 $17229

Operating ExpensesLabor Expenses $9799 $10116 $10306 $10592 $10881 $11121Non-Labor Expenses 3611 3877 3748 3841 3945 4054 Other 129 175 86 36 22 23 General Reserve 0 165 170 175 180 185

Total Operating Expenses $13539 $14333 $14310 $14644 $15028 $15384

Debt Service Expenses $2541 $2683 $2830 $3041 $3265 $3513

Total Expenses + Debt Service $16079 $17016 $17140 $17685 $18293 $18896

Conversion to Cash Basis 379 229 147 60 125 101

Baseline Net Cash Balance Before B-T-L Adjustments $251 ($384) ($392) ($838) ($1133) ($1566)

Total Below-the-Line Adjustments $0 $73 $386 $757 $852 $1133Prior Year Carryover 121 372 61 55 0 0

NET CASH BALANCE $372 $61 $55 ($26) ($281) ($433)

MTA July Financial Plan 2020-2023Consolidated Statement Of Operations By Category ($ in millions)

Summ Stmt of Ops-Feb

Summ Stmt of Ops-Jul

  • MTA 2020Preliminary BudgetJuly Financial Plan2020 - 2023
  • The MTA Budget Process
  • Slide Number 3
  • Slide Number 4
  • What has changed since the February Plan
  • Highlights of the July Plan
  • Slide Number 7
  • MTA Transformation Plan
  • Slide Number 9
  • Actions to Reduce Fare Evasion $62 million Investment over the Plan Period
  • The MTArsquos $350 million target for annually recurring savings beginning in 2020 has been identified and is being implemented
  • We have a track record of identifying and achieving our annual recurring savings targets
  • Deficits remain and a continued drive toward further streamlining and efficiencies is required
  • Slide Number 14
  • 2020 Preliminary Budget
  • Slide Number 16
MTA July Financial Plan 2020-2023
Consolidated Statement Of Operations By Category ($ in millions)
Non-Reimbursable Mid-Year Preliminary
Actual Actual Actual Actual Actual Actual Actual Actual Actual Actual Forecast Budget
2008 2009 2010 2011 2012 2013 2014 2015 2016 2018 2019 2020 2021 2022 2023 2023 2024 2025 2026
Operating Revenues
Farebox Revenue $4240923 $4350411 $4586377 $4999186 $5079138 $5501274 $5709200 $5961129 $6050182 $6155 $6305 $6389 $6373 $6384 $6393 $6174 $6435176 $6431979 $6446633
422 423 405 411 402 399 395 396 396 386 384 385 380 375 371 261 368 363 362
Student Fare - 0 - 0 - 0 - 0 - 0 - 0
Toll Revenue 1273974 1332115 1417046 1501589 1490982 1645193 1676445 1808901 1869693 1976 2088 2121 2129 2129 2131 2002 2133050 2137871 2143111
0127 0129 0125 0124 0118 0119 0116 0120 0122 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0122 0121 0120
Other Revenue 448616 461359 491355 510231 563839 753675 682424 689217 688374 643 696 684 704 719 737 755 825040 885381 887190
Capital and Other Reimbursements 0000 0000 0000 0000 0000 0000 0000 0000 0000 0000 0000 0000 0000 0000 0000 0000 0000 0000 0000
Total Operating Revenue $5963512 $6143885 $6494778 $7011006 $7133959 $7900142 $8068069 $8459247 $8608249 $8774 $9089 $9195 $9206 $9232 $9260 $8931 $9393266 $9455232 $9476934
Dedicated Taxes $3211585 $2366805 $2343537 $2511691 $2673119 $3097640 $3383498 $3582628 $3525829 $3257508 $3459 $3515 $3568 $3630 $3725 $3812 $3841433 $3880226 $3917215
PMT amp MTA Aid - 0 881784 1588677 1718286 1825824 1825328 1885069 1910947 1970760 1987035 $1965 $2152 $2225 $2295 $2368 $2442 2516095 2594604 2677041
New Funding Sources - 0 - 0 - 0 - 0 - 0 - 0 - 0 - 0 - 0 - 0 $508 $342 $385 $385 $385 $385 385000 385000 385000
StateLocal Taxes 556691 539046 544810 541733 536182 537527 539545 537819 537645 541005 $544 $552 $557 $562 $567 $572 576828 581933 583214
Other Funding Agreements 306594 363823 359489 375369 466625 432617 567391 563616 629855 630218 $701 $753 $671 $708 $758 $758 784755 804901 781159
BampT Operating Surplus Transfer 382565 363092 476059 554903 476575 614210 637553 750717 742909 740144 $702 $721 $782 $801 $789 $707 730476 695303 688833
Dedicated Taxes and StateLocal Subsidies $4457434 $4514550 $5312572 $5701982 $5978325 $6507322 $7013056 $7345727 $7406998 $7155909 $7879 $8035 $8188 $8381 $8592 $8676 $8834588 $8941967 $9032462
$0000 $0000 $0000 $0000 $0000 $0000 $0000 $0000 $0000
Less Interagency Subsidy and Surplus Transfers (382565) (363092) (476059) (554903) (476575) (614210) (637553) (750717) (742909) (740144) ($702) ($721) ($782) ($801) ($789) ($707) (730476) (695303) (688833)
Total Subsidies $4074870 $4151458 $4836513 $5147079 $5501750 $5893111 $6375503 $6595010 $6664088 $7177 $7314 $7406 $7581 $7803 $7969 $7969 $8104112 $8246664 $8343629
Dedicated Taxes as a of Total Revenues + Subs - PMT 320 251 241 241 247 259 269 273 265 233 $0 $0 $0 $0 $0 $0 256 257 259
Total Revenues + Subsidies $10038382 $10295342 $11331292 $12158085 $12635709 $13793254 $14443571 $15054257 $15272337 $15951 $16403 $16601 $16787 $17035 $17229 $16900 $17497378 $17701896 $17820563
Operating Expenses
Labor Expenses
Payroll $4087376 $4163330 $4171374 $4160261 $4193658 $4332829 $4671664 $4695823 $4838741 $5020713 $5211 $5328 $5422 $5498 $5624 $5710 $5860206 $5982960 $6107107
Overtime 471675 499307 443227 538647 574316 620701 730200 755071 771495 934100 $1066 $910 $838 $859 $877 $899 917296 935002 951324
Health amp Welfare 684945 688899 738189 809638 812857 895714 961902 1050100 1172304 1208786 $1230 $1341 $1414 $1489 $1583 $1674 1797938 1922668 2071273
OPEB Current Payment 318501 346316 355716 394218 413164 472619 479079 501716 562233 563754 $604 $645 $704 $766 $835 $910 982025 1060022 1142795
Pensions 897450 1021229 1029710 1074598 1328441 1301975 1304355 1248726 1370474 1345308 $1336 $1494 $1461 $1462 $1403 $1347 1357887 1369071 1380572
Other-Fringe Benefits 502739 517194 539996 581661 650430 694680 784143 861079 947870 792151 $881 $869 $897 $930 $956 $976 1001185 1021007 1040170
Reimbursable Overhead (310555) (322230) (345154) (324006) (309399) (321390) (349770) (380212) (423759) (491807) ($528) ($471) ($430) ($412) ($397) ($395) (396136) (405509) (413165)
Labor Expenses $6652131 $6914045 $6933059 $7235017 $7663467 $7997128 $8581574 $8732302 $9239358 $9799 $10116 $10306 $10592 $10881 $11121 $11413 $11520401 $11885220 $12280075
PayrollOvertime Exp as a of Total Operating+DS $0426 $0427 $0407 $0396 $0387 $0374 $0389 $0383 $0376 $0390 $0367 $0365 $0359 $0355 $0350 $0349 $0347 $0345
Labor Exp (wo Reimb OH) as a of Total Oper+DS $0650 $0663 $0642 $0637 $0647 $0628 $0643 $0640 $0648 $0642 $0622 $0626 $0622 $0616 $0609 $0614 $0617 $0620
PayrollOvertime Exp as a of Total Operating Exp $0496 $0490 $0483 $0473 $0465 $0453 $0464 $0459 $0450 $0464 $0435 $0438 $0434 $0433 $0430 $0426 $0420 $0416
Labor Exp (wo Reimb OH) as a of Total Oper Exp $0758 $0761 $0762 $0761 $0777 $0761 $0768 $0768 $0776 $0763 $0739 $0750 $0751 $0750 $0749 $0748 $0747 $0747
Non-Labor Expenses
Electric Power $306500 $317934 $325137 $457269 $471514 $493346 $515540 $473762 $406372 $481893 $451503 $473177 $493090 $532413 $561955 $571182 $589565 $618283 $648255
Traction Power
Non-Traction Power
Fuel 287033 180294 189942 282735 251763 259252 267494 162283 124684 185203 182778 182981 176333 173681 176920 182259 182476 184281 186170
Revenue Vehicle Fuel
Non-Revenue Fuel
Insurance 28902 34012 9819 14363 7617 38654 50739 57190 (20634) (29402) 5608 15623 23118 26855 28309 36048 28232 25538 19483
Claims 152114 238104 285418 315547 135652 299875 269167 331023 463959 437985 387557 394211 392547 398256 406112 404397 417667 428660 437683
Paratransit Service Contracts 299013 370094 379761 348553 360500 366751 365599 379271 383704 455471 494751 488330 505538 535329 568614 581114 604766 643217 684112
Maintenance and Other Operating Contracts 594215 562456 541716 451137 451766 496743 549018 579289 630924 678425 840168 797428 833534 836606 854471 879468 880053 898882 915477
Professional Service Contracts 196930 199164 203084 226205 276998 297201 283005 379814 399706 543582 607838 502858 494814 504103 513895 499724 520826 537109 547291
Materials amp Supplies 532534 526191 511206 438310 430804 475127 526725 543225 585607 637078 689010 679895 697976 711281 715758 711988 741335 777460 793419
Other Business Expenses 155466 184142 189637 169857 143807 167198 179701 195598 192576 220838 218196 213551 224459 226170 228457 244907 228861 240258 241690
Non-Labor Expenses $2552708 $2612391 $2635720 $2703976 $2530421 $2894147 $3006988 $3101454 $3166897 3611 3877 3748 3841 3945 4054 4111 $4193782 $4353689 $4473580
Other Expense Adjustments
Other ($13712) ($14750) ($18292) ($2289) $62593 $46175 $44973 $37007 $47404 129 175 86 36 22 23 23 $23516 $24069 $24637
General Reserve 0000 0000 0000 0000 0000 - 0 - 0 - 0 - 0 0 165 170 175 180 185 185 190000 195000 205000
Other Expense Adjustments ($13712) ($14750) ($18292) ($2289) $62593 $46175 $44973 $37007 $47404 $128555 $340 $256 $211 $202 $208 $208 $213516 $219069 $229637
Gap Closing Expenses $7675394
Additional Actions for Budget Balance Expense Impact $0000 $0000 $0000 $0000 $0000 $0000 $0000 $0000 $0000 $0000 $0000 $0000 $0000 $0000 $0000 $0000 $0000 $0000 $0000
Total Operating Expenses Before Non-Cash Liability Adjs $9191127 $9511685 $9550486 $9936705 $10256481 $10937450 $11633535 $11870763 $12453659 $13538830 $14332772 $14309678 $14643965 $15027767 $15383584 $15732241 $15927699 $16457978 $16983292
Non-Cash Liability Adjustments
Depreciation $1790981 $1940576 $1980681 $2019378 $2148820 $2174302 $2266280 $2442777 $2442941 $2607970 $2804571 $2784812 $2842737 $2908533 $2977025 $3051834 $3109882 $3169371 $3230301
OPEB Obligation 1348962 1104827 1167070 1706939 1785881 1920189 2035457 1489656 1562261 1567381 0000 (0000) (0000) (0000) (0000) 0000 0000 (0000) (0000)
GASB 75 OPEB Expense Adjustment 0000 0000 0000 0000 0000 0000 0000 0000 0000 0000 1047747 1457230 1628196 1748560 1823313 1898497 1952374 2006482 2061993
GASB 68 Pension Expense Adjustment 0000 0000 0000 0000 0000 0000 0000 (410019) (218911) (168119) (373022) (220864) (271921) (342847) (318372) (242446) (237864) (234492) (230942)
Environmental Remediation 42249 6062 18621 59079 24742 14257 20556 20576 11691 13468 105615 6000 6000 6000 6000 6000 6000 6000 6000
Non-Cash Liability Adjustments $3182192 $3051466 $3166371 $3785396 $3959443 $4108749 $4322293 $3542990 $3797981 $4020699 $3584911 $4027178 $4205012 $4320246 $4487966 $4713886 $4830392 $4947361 $5067352
Total Operating Expenses After Non-Cash Liability Adjs $12373319 $12563151 $12716857 $13722101 $14215924 $15046199 $15955827 $15413753 $16251641 $17559529 $17917683 $18336856 $18848977 $19348013 $19871550 $20446127 $20758090 $21405338 $22050644
Less BampT Depreciation $77213 $80097 $77846 $86545 $87926 $91345 $104039 $109783 $135035 $240957 $148686 $151977 $158779 $169848 $181689 $194355 $194355 $194355 $194355
BampT Other Post Employment Benefits 66323 50967 54831 66686 73055 76641 71148 62457 60441 78106 32297 22256 20303 22870 28694 33918 36169 38411 40604
Net Operating Deficit Before Subsidies and Debt Service ($6409807) ($6419266) ($6222079) ($6711095) ($7081966) ($7146057) ($7887759) ($6954506) ($7643392) ($8785339) ($8829030) ($9141907) ($9642826) ($10116260) ($10611154) ($11515498) ($11364824) ($11950106) ($12573710)
Conversion to Cash Basis Non-Cash Liability Adjs ($3182192) ($3051466) ($3166371) ($3785396) ($3959443) ($4108749) ($4322293) ($3542990) ($3797981) ($4020699) ($3584911) ($4027178) ($4205012) ($4320246) ($4487966) ($4713886) ($4830392) ($4947361) ($5067352)
Total Operating Expenses $9191127 $9511685 $9550486 $9936705 $10256481 $10937450 $11633535 $11870763 $12453659 $13539 $14333 $14310 $14644 $15028 $15384 $15732 $15927699 $16457978 $16983292
Debt Service Expenses $1515733 $1404454 $1781220 $1933532 $2058395 $2299262 $2248538 $2373321 $2458783 $2541 $2683 $2830 $3041 $3265 $3513 $3450 $3471321 $3472987 $3501639
Total Expenses + Debt Service $10706859 $10916139 $11331706 $11870237 $12314876 $13236712 $13882073 $14244084 $14912443 $16079 $17016 $17140 $17685 $18293 $18896 $19182 $19399019 $19930965 $20484932
Net Deficit After Subsidies and Debt Service ($668477) ($620796) ($0414) $287848 $320833 $556541 $561498 $810173 $359895 ($128044) ($613) ($539) ($898) ($1258) ($1667) ($2283) ($1901641) ($2229069) ($2664369)
Conversion to Cash Basis GASB Account (56067) (54256) (67377) (37636) (89548) (85641) (50017) - 0 - 0 0 0 0 $0 0 0 - 0 - 0 - 0 - 0
Conversion to Cash Basis 492710 550267 91781 (111037) (297407) (261709) (626297) (660147) (591809) 379 229 147 60 125 101 130 49745 48375 54220
Net Cash Balance from Previous Year 0000 0000 0000 23990 139174 0000 209191 0000 150026 0000 250569 0000 0000 0000 0000 0000 0000 0000 0000
Total Operating Exp + DS + Cash Conversions + PY C-O $11144 $11412 $11356 $11746 $12067 $12889362 $13414950 $13583937 $14470659 $16457999 $17495351 $17286526 $17744425 $18418197 $18997710 $19312017 $19448764 $19979340 $20539152
Total Operating Expenses with Cash Conversion $10270216 $10420127 $11307302 $12018911 $12701831 $13584063 $14558387 $14904231 $15504252 $15700774 $16786574 $16992579 $17624861 $18167420 $18795069 $19052755 $19349274 $19882590 $20430711
Baseline Net Cash Balance Before B-T-L Adjustments ($231834) ($124785) $23990 $139174 ($66122) $209191 ($114816) $150026 ($231914) $251 ($384) ($392) ($838) ($1133) ($1566) ($2153) ($1851896) ($2180695) ($2610148)
Below-the-Line Adjustments
FareToll Increases
FareToll Increase in March 2019 (4 Yield) - 0 $0 $0 $0 $0 $0 $0 - 0 - 0 - 0
FareToll Increase in March 2021 (4 Yield) - 0 $0 $0 $0 $283 $331 $332 333531 333568 334299
FareToll Increase in March 2023 (4 Yield) - 0 $0 $0 $0 $0 $0 $294 346386 346424 347183
FareToll Increase in March 2025 (4 Yield) - 0 $0 $0 $0 $0 $0 $0 - 0 273859 321624
Subsidy Impacts of 20212023 FareToll Increase - 0 $0 $0 $0 ($7) ($9) ($17) (18612) (25573) (26305)
$0000 $0 $0 $0 $275 $322 $609 $661306 $928278 $976801
CASH BALANCE AFTER FARE INCREASES $250569 ($384) ($392) ($838) ($850) ($1234) ($1821) ($1518365) ($1847127) ($2275849)
MTA Initiatives
MTA Efficiencies - Not Yet Implemented - 0 $0 $0 $0 $0 $0 $0 0000 0000 0000
0 - 0 $0 $0 $0 $0 $0 $0 - 0 - 0 - 0
0 - 0 $0 $0 $0 $0 $0 $0 - 0 - 0 - 0
$0000 $0 $0 $0 $0 $0 $0 $0000 $0000 $0000
Policy Actions
CAS Migration to Peoplesoft $0 $0 ($5) ($1) ($0) ($0) (0200) -02 -02 0
Fare Evasion Enforcement Strategy-Expenses $0 ($13) ($12) ($11) ($10) ($10) (9554) -9554483 -9554483 0
Fare Evasion Enforcement-Manhattan DA Forfeiture Fund $0 $11 $11 $10 $9 $0 - 0 0 0 0
Negotiated 1 CBA Reform $0 $0 $0 $0 $0 $0 - 0 0 0 0
MTA Reorganization $0 $8 $180 $371 $377 $377 377000 377 377 0
MTA Reorganization Costs $0 $0 ($10) ($27) ($2) $0 - 0 0 0 0
Drawdown 2019 General Reserve $0 $0 $165 $0 $0 $0 - 0 0 0 0
CBA Negotiated Reform - 1 Value $0 $36 $100 $173 $246 $323 323473 323473304484 323473304484 0
$0000 $0 $42 $429 $515 $620 $691 $690719 $690719 $690719
MTA Re-estimates
Additional Savings Actions $0000 $0 $0 $0 $0 $0 $0 $0000 $0000 $0000
Total Below-the-Line Adjustments $0 $73 $386 $757 $852 $1133 $1007 $1352025 $1618997 $1667520
Prior Year Carryover 495399 263336 138286 161986 301160 235038 444229 329413 479439 121 372 61 55 0 0 - 0 - 0 - 0 - 0
NET CASH BALANCE $263566 $138551 $162276 $301160 $235038 $444229 $329413 $479439 $247525 $372 $61 $55 ($26) ($281) ($433) ($1146) ($499871) ($561698) ($942628)
MTA February Financial Plan 2019-2022
Consolidated Statement Of Operations By Category ($ in millions)
Non-Reimbursable Final Adopted
Actual Actual Actual Actual Actual Actual Actual Actual Actual Actual Estimate Budget
2008 2009 2010 2011 2012 2013 2014 2015 2016 2017 2018 2019 2020 2021 2022 2023 2024 2025 2026
Operating Revenues
Farebox Revenue $4240923 $4350411 $4586377 $4999186 $5079138 $5501274 $5709200 $5961129 $6050182 $6172 $6153 $6122 $6144 $6134 $6144 $6174 $6435176 $6431979 $6446633
422 423 405 411 402 399 395 396 396 407 279 275 272 267 263 261 368 363 362
Student Fare - 0 - 0 - 0 - 0 - 0 - 0
Toll Revenue 1273974 1332115 1417046 1501589 1490982 1645193 1676445 1808901 1869693 1912 1967 1984 1990 1998 1998 2002 2133050 2137871 2143111
0127 0129 0125 0124 0118 0119 0116 0120 0122 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0122 0121 0120
Other Revenue 448616 461359 491355 510231 563839 753675 682424 689217 688374 653 662 705 733 757 743 755 825040 885381 887190
Capital and Other Reimbursements 0000 0000 0000 0000 0000 0000 0000 0000 0000 0000 0000 0000 0000 0000 0000 0000 0000 0000 0000
Total Operating Revenue $5963512 $6143885 $6494778 $7011006 $7133959 $7900142 $8068069 $8459247 $8608249 $8737 $8782 $8810 $8867 $8889 $8886 $8931 $9393266 $9455232 $9476934
Dedicated Taxes $3211585 $2366805 $2343537 $2511691 $2673119 $3097640 $3383498 $3582628 $3525829 $3257508 $3459 $3515 $3568 $3630 $3725 $3812 $3841433 $3880226 $3917215
PMT amp MTA Aid - 0 881784 1588677 1718286 1825824 1825328 1885069 1910947 1970760 1987035 $1965 $2152 $2225 $2295 $2368 $2442 2516095 2594604 2677041
New Funding Sources - 0 - 0 - 0 - 0 - 0 - 0 - 0 - 0 - 0 - 0 $508 $342 $385 $385 $385 $385 385000 385000 385000
StateLocal Taxes 556691 539046 544810 541733 536182 537527 539545 537819 537645 541005 $544 $552 $557 $562 $567 $572 576828 581933 583214
Other Funding Agreements 306594 363823 359489 375369 466625 432617 567391 563616 629855 630218 $701 $753 $671 $708 $758 $758 784755 804901 781159
BampT Operating Surplus Transfer 382565 363092 476059 554903 476575 614210 637553 750717 742909 740144 $702 $721 $782 $801 $789 $707 730476 695303 688833
Dedicated Taxes and StateLocal Subsidies $4457434 $4514550 $5312572 $5701982 $5978325 $6507322 $7013056 $7345727 $7406998 $7155909 $7879 $8035 $8188 $8381 $8592 $8676 $8834588 $8941967 $9032462
$0000 $0000 $0000 $0000 $0000 $0000 $0000 $0000 $0000
Less Interagency Subsidy and Surplus Transfers (382565) (363092) (476059) (554903) (476575) (614210) (637553) (750717) (742909) (740144) ($702) ($721) ($782) ($801) ($789) ($707) (730476) (695303) (688833)
Total Subsidies $4074870 $4151458 $4836513 $5147079 $5501750 $5893111 $6375503 $6595010 $6664088 $6416 $7242 $7238 $7370 $7576 $7807 $7969 $8104112 $8246664 $8343629
Dedicated Taxes as a of Total Revenues + Subs - PMT 320 251 241 241 247 259 269 273 265 247 $0 $0 $0 $0 $0 $0 256 257 259
Total Revenues + Subsidies $10038382 $10295342 $11331292 $12158085 $12635709 $13793254 $14443571 $15054257 $15272337 $15152 $16023 $16048 $16237 $16465 $16693 $16900 $17497378 $17701896 $17820563
Operating Expenses
Labor Expenses
Payroll $4087376 $4163330 $4171374 $4160261 $4193658 $4332829 $4671664 $4695823 $4838741 $5020713 $5211 $5328 $5422 $5498 $5624 $5710 $5860206 $5982960 $6107107
Overtime 471675 499307 443227 538647 574316 620701 730200 755071 771495 934100 $1066 $910 $838 $859 $877 $899 917296 935002 951324
Health amp Welfare 684945 688899 738189 809638 812857 895714 961902 1050100 1172304 1208786 $1230 $1341 $1414 $1489 $1583 $1674 1797938 1922668 2071273
OPEB Current Payment 318501 346316 355716 394218 413164 472619 479079 501716 562233 563754 $604 $645 $704 $766 $835 $910 982025 1060022 1142795
Pensions 897450 1021229 1029710 1074598 1328441 1301975 1304355 1248726 1370474 1345308 $1336 $1494 $1461 $1462 $1403 $1347 1357887 1369071 1380572
Other-Fringe Benefits 502739 517194 539996 581661 650430 694680 784143 861079 947870 792151 $881 $869 $897 $930 $956 $976 1001185 1021007 1040170
Reimbursable Overhead (310555) (322230) (345154) (324006) (309399) (321390) (349770) (380212) (423759) (491807) ($528) ($471) ($430) ($412) ($397) ($395) (396136) (405509) (413165)
Labor Expenses $6652131 $6914045 $6933059 $7235017 $7663467 $7997128 $8581574 $8732302 $9239358 $9373 $9920 $10039 $10436 $10787 $11097 $11413 $11520401 $11885220 $12280075
PayrollOvertime Exp as a of Total Operating+DS $0426 $0427 $0407 $0396 $0387 $0374 $0389 $0383 $0376 $0385 $0349 $0347 $0345
Labor Exp (wo Reimb OH) as a of Total Oper+DS $0650 $0663 $0642 $0637 $0647 $0628 $0643 $0640 $0648 $0638 $0614 $0617 $0620
PayrollOvertime Exp as a of Total Operating Exp $0496 $0490 $0483 $0473 $0465 $0453 $0464 $0459 $0450 $0461 $0426 $0420 $0416
Labor Exp (wo Reimb OH) as a of Total Oper Exp $0758 $0761 $0762 $0761 $0777 $0761 $0768 $0768 $0776 $0763 $0748 $0747 $0747
Non-Labor Expenses
Electric Power $306500 $317934 $325137 $457269 $471514 $493346 $515540 $473762 $406372 $430381 $474918 $451304 $463523 $482662 $539624 $571182 $589565 $618283 $648255
Traction Power
Non-Traction Power
Fuel 287033 180294 189942 282735 251763 259252 267494 162283 124684 150481 185580 190348 187592 183168 181484 182259 182476 184281 186170
Revenue Vehicle Fuel
Non-Revenue Fuel
Insurance 28902 34012 9819 14363 7617 38654 50739 57190 (20634) (2715) 11488 8532 15803 22918 29411 36048 28232 25538 19483
Claims 152114 238104 285418 315547 135652 299875 269167 331023 463959 526053 376480 378570 386981 391333 395228 404397 417667 428660 437683
Paratransit Service Contracts 299013 370094 379761 348553 360500 366751 365599 379271 383704 392850 452190 482751 501230 518038 547829 581114 604766 643217 684112
Maintenance and Other Operating Contracts 594215 562456 541716 451137 451766 496743 549018 579289 630924 695251 779331 897801 833038 883805 871671 879468 880053 898882 915477
Professional Service Contracts 196930 199164 203084 226205 276998 297201 283005 379814 399706 507062 575742 557476 484911 479376 489510 499724 520826 537109 547291
Materials amp Supplies 532534 526191 511206 438310 430804 475127 526725 543225 585607 588115 667700 686666 687745 692131 697268 711988 741335 777460 793419
Other Business Expenses 155466 184142 189637 169857 143807 167198 179701 195598 192576 217254 225494 230595 225293 240279 242193 244907 228861 240258 241690
Non-Labor Expenses $2552708 $2612391 $2635720 $2703976 $2530421 $2894147 $3006988 $3101454 $3166897 3505 3749 3884 3786 3894 3994 4111 $4193782 $4353689 $4473580
Other Expense Adjustments
Other ($13712) ($14750) ($18292) ($2289) $62593 $46175 $44973 $37007 $47404 49 134 158 84 36 22 23 $23516 $24069 $24637
General Reserve 0000 0000 0000 0000 0000 - 0 - 0 - 0 - 0 0 0 165 170 175 180 185 190000 195000 205000
Other Expense Adjustments ($13712) ($14750) ($18292) ($2289) $62593 $46175 $44973 $37007 $47404 $49379 $134 $323 $254 $211 $202 $208 $213516 $219069 $229637
Gap Closing Expenses $7675394
Additional Actions for Budget Balance Expense Impact $0000 $0000 $0000 $0000 $0000 $0000 $0000 $0000 $0000 $0000 $0000 $0000 $0000 $0000 $0000 $0000 $0000 $0000 $0000
Total Operating Expenses Before Non-Cash Liability Adjs $9191127 $9511685 $9550486 $9936705 $10256481 $10937450 $11633535 $11870763 $12453659 $12927116 $13802910 $14246122 $14475644 $14891445 $15293262 $15732241 $15927699 $16457978 $16983292
Non-Cash Liability Adjustments
Depreciation $1790981 $1940576 $1980681 $2019378 $2148820 $2174302 $2266280 $2442777 $2442941 $2607970 $2804571 $2784812 $2842737 $2908533 $2977025 $3051834 $3109882 $3169371 $3230301
OPEB Obligation 1348962 1104827 1167070 1706939 1785881 1920189 2035457 1489656 1562261 1567381 0000 (0000) (0000) (0000) (0000) 0000 0000 (0000) (0000)
GASB 75 OPEB Expense Adjustment 0000 0000 0000 0000 0000 0000 0000 0000 0000 0000 1047747 1457230 1628196 1748560 1823313 1898497 1952374 2006482 2061993
GASB 68 Pension Expense Adjustment 0000 0000 0000 0000 0000 0000 0000 (410019) (218911) (168119) (373022) (220864) (271921) (342847) (318372) (242446) (237864) (234492) (230942)
Environmental Remediation 42249 6062 18621 59079 24742 14257 20556 20576 11691 13468 105615 6000 6000 6000 6000 6000 6000 6000 6000
Non-Cash Liability Adjustments $3182192 $3051466 $3166371 $3785396 $3959443 $4108749 $4322293 $3542990 $3797981 $4020699 $3584911 $4027178 $4205012 $4320246 $4487966 $4713886 $4830392 $4947361 $5067352
Total Operating Expenses After Non-Cash Liability Adjs $12373319 $12563151 $12716857 $13722101 $14215924 $15046199 $15955827 $15413753 $16251641 $16947815 $17387821 $18273301 $18680657 $19211690 $19781228 $20446127 $20758090 $21405338 $22050644
Less BampT Depreciation $77213 $80097 $77846 $86545 $87926 $91345 $104039 $109783 $135035 $240957 $148686 $151977 $158779 $169848 $181689 $194355 $194355 $194355 $194355
BampT Other Post Employment Benefits 66323 50967 54831 66686 73055 76641 71148 62457 60441 78106 32297 22256 20303 22870 28694 33918 36169 38411 40604
Net Operating Deficit Before Subsidies and Debt Service ($6409807) ($6419266) ($6222079) ($6711095) ($7081966) ($7146057) ($7887759) ($6954506) ($7643392) ($8211234) ($8606220) ($9463506) ($9813560) ($10322912) ($10895644) ($11515498) ($11364824) ($11950106) ($12573710)
Conversion to Cash Basis Non-Cash Liability Adjs ($3182192) ($3051466) ($3166371) ($3785396) ($3959443) ($4108749) ($4322293) ($3542990) ($3797981) ($4020699) ($3584911) ($4027178) ($4205012) ($4320246) ($4487966) ($4713886) ($4830392) ($4947361) ($5067352)
Total Operating Expenses $9191127 $9511685 $9550486 $9936705 $10256481 $10937450 $11633535 $11870763 $12453659 $12927 $13803 $14246 $14476 $14891 $15293 $15732 $15927699 $16457978 $16983292
Debt Service Expenses $1515733 $1404454 $1781220 $1933532 $2058395 $2299262 $2248538 $2373321 $2458783 $2525 $2559 $2692 $2840 $3080 $3223 $3450 $3471321 $3472987 $3501639
Total Expenses + Debt Service $10706859 $10916139 $11331706 $11870237 $12314876 $13236712 $13882073 $14244084 $14912443 $15452 $16362 $16938 $17316 $17971 $18516 $19182 $19399019 $19930965 $20484932
Net Deficit After Subsidies and Debt Service ($668477) ($620796) ($0414) $287848 $320833 $556541 $561498 $810173 $359895 ($299965) ($339) ($890) ($1079) ($1506) ($1823) ($2283) ($1901641) ($2229069) ($2664369)
Conversion to Cash Basis GASB Account (56067) (54256) (67377) (37636) (89548) (85641) (50017) - 0 - 0 0 0 0 $0 0 0 - 0 - 0 - 0 - 0
Conversion to Cash Basis 492710 550267 91781 (111037) (297407) (261709) (626297) (660147) (591809) 174 296 363 188 (17) 88 130 49745 48375 54220
Net Cash Balance from Previous Year 0000 0000 0000 23990 139174 0000 209191 0000 150026 0000 0000 0000 0000 0000 0000 0000 0000 0000 0000
Total Operating Exp + DS + Cash Conversions + PY C-O $11144 $11412 $11356 $11746 $12067 $12889362 $13414950 $13583937 $14470659 $15625875 $16658585 $17300293 $17504155 $17954574 $18604130 $19312017 $19448764 $19979340 $20539152
Total Operating Expenses with Cash Conversion $10270216 $10420127 $11307302 $12018911 $12701831 $13584063 $14558387 $14904231 $15504252 $15278749 $16065734 $16575223 $17128079 $17987951 $18427778 $19052755 $19349274 $19882590 $20430711
Baseline Net Cash Balance Before B-T-L Adjustments ($231834) ($124785) $23990 $139174 ($66122) $209191 ($114816) $150026 ($231914) ($126) ($43) ($527) ($891) ($1523) ($1735) ($2153) ($1851896) ($2180695) ($2610148)
Below-the-Line Adjustments
FareToll Increases
FareToll Increase in March 2019 (4 Yield) - 0 $0 $0 $0 $0 $0 $0 - 0 - 0 - 0
FareToll Increase in March 2021 (4 Yield) - 0 $0 $0 $0 $283 $331 $332 333531 333568 334299
FareToll Increase in March 2023 (4 Yield) - 0 $0 $0 $0 $0 $0 $294 346386 346424 347183
FareToll Increase in March 2025 (4 Yield) - 0 $0 $0 $0 $0 $0 $0 - 0 273859 321624
Subsidy Impacts of 20212023 FareToll Increase - 0 $0 $0 $0 ($7) ($9) ($17) (18612) (25573) (26305)
$0000 $0 $0 $0 $275 $322 $609 $661306 $928278 $976801
CASH BALANCE AFTER FARE INCREASES ($126402) ($43) ($527) ($891) ($1241) ($1404) ($1821) ($1518365) ($1847127) ($2275849)
MTA Initiatives
MTA Efficiencies - Not Yet Implemented - 0 $0 $0 $0 $0 $0 $0 0000 0000 0000
0 - 0 $0 $0 $0 $0 $0 $0 - 0 - 0 - 0
0 - 0 $0 $0 $0 $0 $0 $0 - 0 - 0 - 0
$0000 $0 $0 $0 $0 $0 $0 $0000 $0000 $0000
Policy Actions
CAS Migration to Peoplesoft $0 $0 ($5) ($1) ($0) ($0) (0200) -02 -02 0
Fare Evasion Enforcement Strategy-Expenses $0 ($13) ($12) ($11) ($10) ($10) (9554) -9554483 -9554483 0
Fare Evasion Enforcement-Manhattan DA Forfeiture Fund $0 $11 $11 $10 $9 $0 - 0 0 0 0
Negotiated 1 CBA Reform $0 $0 $0 $0 $0 $0 - 0 0 0 0
MTA Reorganization $0 $8 $180 $371 $377 $377 377000 377 377 0
MTA Reorganization Costs $0 $0 ($10) ($27) ($2) $0 - 0 0 0 0
Drawdown 2019 General Reserve $0 $0 $165 $0 $0 $0 - 0 0 0 0
CBA Negotiated Reform - 1 Value $0 $36 $100 $173 $246 $323 323473 323473304484 323473304484 0
$0000 $0 $42 $429 $515 $620 $691 $690719 $690719 $690719
MTA Re-estimates
Additional Savings Actions $0000 $0 $0 $0 $0 $0 $0 $0000 $0000 $0000
Total Below-the-Line Adjustments $0 $0 $459 $413 $709 $760 $1007 $1352025 $1618997 $1667520
Prior Year Carryover 495399 263336 138286 161986 301160 235038 444229 329413 479439 248 121 79 11 0 0 - 0 - 0 - 0 - 0
NET CASH BALANCE $263566 $138551 $162276 $301160 $235038 $444229 $329413 $479439 $247525 $121 $79 $11 ($467) ($814) ($976) ($1146) ($499871) ($561698) ($942628)
By Revenue Source
(includes faretoll increases)
($ in millions)
Farebox Revenue $6389
Toll Revenue 2121
Other Revenue 684
Dedicated Taxes 6191
State and Local amp Other 1228
Timing (Cash Adjustments) 135
Total $16748
By Expense Category
(includes below-the-line adjustments)
($ in millions)
Payroll $5422
Overtime 838
Health amp Welfare 2118
Pension 1461
Other Labor 466
Total Labor $10306
Non-Labor + Other Exp Adj 4004
Debt Service 2830
BTL Adjustments for Expenses 2 (386)
Total $16754
By Revenue Source
(includes faretoll increases)
($ in millions)
Farebox Revenue $6389
Toll Revenue 2121
Other Revenue 684
Taxes 6178
State and Local amp Other 557
Other Funding Agreements 671
Other 1 208
Total $16809
By Expense Category
(includes below-the-line adjustments)
($ in millions)
Payroll $5392
Overtime 811
Health amp Welfare 2129
Pension 1354
Other Labor 400
Total Labor $10086
Non-Labor 4205
Debt Service 2692
BTL Adjustments for Expenses (251)
Total $16732
MTA July Financial Plan 2019-2022
Consolidated Statement Of Operations By Category ($ in millions)
Non-Reimbursable Mid-Year Preliminary
Actual Actual Actual Actual Actual Actual Actual Actual Actual Actual Forecast Budget
2008 2009 2010 2011 2012 2013 2014 2015 2016 2017 2018 2019 2020 2021 2022 2023 2024 2025 2026
Operating Revenues
Farebox Revenue $4240923 $4350411 $4586377 $4999186 $5079138 $5501274 $5709200 $5961129 $6050182 $6172 $6305 $6389 $6373 $6384 $6393 $6174 $6435176 $6431979 $6446633
422 423 405 411 402 399 395 396 396 407 384 385 380 375 371 261 368 363 362
Student Fare - 0 - 0 - 0 - 0 - 0 - 0
Toll Revenue 1273974 1332115 1417046 1501589 1490982 1645193 1676445 1808901 1869693 1912 2088 2121 2129 2129 2131 2002 2133050 2137871 2143111
0127 0129 0125 0124 0118 0119 0116 0120 0122 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0122 0121 0120
Other Revenue 448616 461359 491355 510231 563839 753675 682424 689217 688374 653 696 684 704 719 737 755 825040 885381 887190
Capital and Other Reimbursements 0000 0000 0000 0000 0000 0000 0000 0000 0000 0000 0000 0000 0000 0000 0000 0000 0000 0000 0000
Total Operating Revenue $5963512 $6143885 $6494778 $7011006 $7133959 $7900142 $8068069 $8459247 $8608249 $8737 $9089 $9195 $9206 $9232 $9260 $8931 $9393266 $9455232 $9476934
Dedicated Taxes $3211585 $2366805 $2343537 $2511691 $2673119 $3097640 $3383498 $3582628 $3525829 $3257508 $3459 $3515 $3568 $3630 $3725 $3812 $3841433 $3880226 $3917215
PMT amp MTA Aid - 0 881784 1588677 1718286 1825824 1825328 1885069 1910947 1970760 1987035 $1965 $2152 $2225 $2295 $2368 $2442 2516095 2594604 2677041
New Funding Sources - 0 - 0 - 0 - 0 - 0 - 0 - 0 - 0 - 0 - 0 $508 $342 $385 $385 $385 $385 385000 385000 385000
StateLocal Taxes 556691 539046 544810 541733 536182 537527 539545 537819 537645 541005 $544 $552 $557 $562 $567 $572 576828 581933 583214
Other Funding Agreements 306594 363823 359489 375369 466625 432617 567391 563616 629855 630218 $701 $753 $671 $708 $758 $758 784755 804901 781159
BampT Operating Surplus Transfer 382565 363092 476059 554903 476575 614210 637553 750717 742909 740144 $702 $721 $782 $801 $789 $707 730476 695303 688833
Dedicated Taxes and StateLocal Subsidies $4457434 $4514550 $5312572 $5701982 $5978325 $6507322 $7013056 $7345727 $7406998 $7155909 $7879 $8035 $8188 $8381 $8592 $8676 $8834588 $8941967 $9032462
$0000 $0000 $0000 $0000 $0000 $0000 $0000 $0000 $0000
Less Interagency Subsidy and Surplus Transfers (382565) (363092) (476059) (554903) (476575) (614210) (637553) (750717) (742909) (740144) ($702) ($721) ($782) ($801) ($789) ($707) (730476) (695303) (688833)
Total Subsidies $4074870 $4151458 $4836513 $5147079 $5501750 $5893111 $6375503 $6595010 $6664088 $6416 $7314 $7406 $7581 $7803 $7969 $7969 $8104112 $8246664 $8343629
Dedicated Taxes as a of Total Revenues + Subs - PMT 320 251 241 241 247 259 269 273 265 247 $0 $0 $0 $0 $0 $0 256 257 259
Total Revenues + Subsidies $10038382 $10295342 $11331292 $12158085 $12635709 $13793254 $14443571 $15054257 $15272337 $15152 $16403 $16601 $16787 $17035 $17229 $16900 $17497378 $17701896 $17820563
Operating Expenses
Labor Expenses
Payroll $4087376 $4163330 $4171374 $4160261 $4193658 $4332829 $4671664 $4695823 $4838741 $5020713 $5211 $5328 $5422 $5498 $5624 $5710 $5860206 $5982960 $6107107
Overtime 471675 499307 443227 538647 574316 620701 730200 755071 771495 934100 $1066 $910 $838 $859 $877 $899 917296 935002 951324
Health amp Welfare 684945 688899 738189 809638 812857 895714 961902 1050100 1172304 1208786 $1230 $1341 $1414 $1489 $1583 $1674 1797938 1922668 2071273
OPEB Current Payment 318501 346316 355716 394218 413164 472619 479079 501716 562233 563754 $604 $645 $704 $766 $835 $910 982025 1060022 1142795
Pensions 897450 1021229 1029710 1074598 1328441 1301975 1304355 1248726 1370474 1345308 $1336 $1494 $1461 $1462 $1403 $1347 1357887 1369071 1380572
Other-Fringe Benefits 502739 517194 539996 581661 650430 694680 784143 861079 947870 792151 $881 $869 $897 $930 $956 $976 1001185 1021007 1040170
Reimbursable Overhead (310555) (322230) (345154) (324006) (309399) (321390) (349770) (380212) (423759) (491807) ($528) ($471) ($430) ($412) ($397) ($395) (396136) (405509) (413165)
Labor Expenses $6652131 $6914045 $6933059 $7235017 $7663467 $7997128 $8581574 $8732302 $9239358 $9373 $10116 $10306 $10592 $10881 $11121 $11413 $11520401 $11885220 $12280075
PayrollOvertime Exp as a of Total Operating+DS $0426 $0427 $0407 $0396 $0387 $0374 $0389 $0383 $0376 $0385 $0367 $0365 $0359 $0355 $0350 $0349 $0347 $0345
Labor Exp (wo Reimb OH) as a of Total Oper+DS $0650 $0663 $0642 $0637 $0647 $0628 $0643 $0640 $0648 $0638 $0622 $0626 $0622 $0616 $0609 $0614 $0617 $0620
PayrollOvertime Exp as a of Total Operating Exp $0496 $0490 $0483 $0473 $0465 $0453 $0464 $0459 $0450 $0461 $0435 $0438 $0434 $0433 $0430 $0426 $0420 $0416
Labor Exp (wo Reimb OH) as a of Total Oper Exp $0758 $0761 $0762 $0761 $0777 $0761 $0768 $0768 $0776 $0763 $0739 $0750 $0751 $0750 $0749 $0748 $0747 $0747
Non-Labor Expenses
Electric Power $306500 $317934 $325137 $457269 $471514 $493346 $515540 $473762 $406372 $430381 $451503 $473177 $493090 $532413 $561955 $571182 $589565 $618283 $648255
Traction Power
Non-Traction Power
Fuel 287033 180294 189942 282735 251763 259252 267494 162283 124684 150481 182778 182981 176333 173681 176920 182259 182476 184281 186170
Revenue Vehicle Fuel
Non-Revenue Fuel
Insurance 28902 34012 9819 14363 7617 38654 50739 57190 (20634) (2715) 5608 15623 23118 26855 28309 36048 28232 25538 19483
Claims 152114 238104 285418 315547 135652 299875 269167 331023 463959 526053 387557 394211 392547 398256 406112 404397 417667 428660 437683
Paratransit Service Contracts 299013 370094 379761 348553 360500 366751 365599 379271 383704 392850 494751 488330 505538 535329 568614 581114 604766 643217 684112
Maintenance and Other Operating Contracts 594215 562456 541716 451137 451766 496743 549018 579289 630924 695251 840168 797428 833534 836606 854471 879468 880053 898882 915477
Professional Service Contracts 196930 199164 203084 226205 276998 297201 283005 379814 399706 507062 607838 502858 494814 504103 513895 499724 520826 537109 547291
Materials amp Supplies 532534 526191 511206 438310 430804 475127 526725 543225 585607 588115 689010 679895 697976 711281 715758 711988 741335 777460 793419
Other Business Expenses 155466 184142 189637 169857 143807 167198 179701 195598 192576 217254 218196 213551 224459 226170 228457 244907 228861 240258 241690
Non-Labor Expenses $2552708 $2612391 $2635720 $2703976 $2530421 $2894147 $3006988 $3101454 $3166897 3505 3877 3748 3841 3945 4054 4111 $4193782 $4353689 $4473580
Other Expense Adjustments
Other ($13712) ($14750) ($18292) ($2289) $62593 $46175 $44973 $37007 $47404 49 175 86 36 22 23 23 $23516 $24069 $24637
General Reserve 0000 0000 0000 0000 0000 - 0 - 0 - 0 - 0 0 165 170 175 180 185 185 190000 195000 205000
Other Expense Adjustments ($13712) ($14750) ($18292) ($2289) $62593 $46175 $44973 $37007 $47404 $49379 $340 $256 $211 $202 $208 $208 $213516 $219069 $229637
Gap Closing Expenses $7675394
Additional Actions for Budget Balance Expense Impact $0000 $0000 $0000 $0000 $0000 $0000 $0000 $0000 $0000 $0000 $0000 $0000 $0000 $0000 $0000 $0000 $0000 $0000 $0000
Total Operating Expenses Before Non-Cash Liability Adjs $9191127 $9511685 $9550486 $9936705 $10256481 $10937450 $11633535 $11870763 $12453659 $12927116 $14332772 $14309678 $14643965 $15027767 $15383584 $15732241 $15927699 $16457978 $16983292
Non-Cash Liability Adjustments
Depreciation $1790981 $1940576 $1980681 $2019378 $2148820 $2174302 $2266280 $2442777 $2442941 $2607970 $2804571 $2784812 $2842737 $2908533 $2977025 $3051834 $3109882 $3169371 $3230301
OPEB Obligation 1348962 1104827 1167070 1706939 1785881 1920189 2035457 1489656 1562261 1567381 0000 (0000) (0000) (0000) (0000) 0000 0000 (0000) (0000)
GASB 75 OPEB Expense Adjustment 0000 0000 0000 0000 0000 0000 0000 0000 0000 0000 1047747 1457230 1628196 1748560 1823313 1898497 1952374 2006482 2061993
GASB 68 Pension Expense Adjustment 0000 0000 0000 0000 0000 0000 0000 (410019) (218911) (168119) (373022) (220864) (271921) (342847) (318372) (242446) (237864) (234492) (230942)
Environmental Remediation 42249 6062 18621 59079 24742 14257 20556 20576 11691 13468 105615 6000 6000 6000 6000 6000 6000 6000 6000
Non-Cash Liability Adjustments $3182192 $3051466 $3166371 $3785396 $3959443 $4108749 $4322293 $3542990 $3797981 $4020699 $3584911 $4027178 $4205012 $4320246 $4487966 $4713886 $4830392 $4947361 $5067352
Total Operating Expenses After Non-Cash Liability Adjs $12373319 $12563151 $12716857 $13722101 $14215924 $15046199 $15955827 $15413753 $16251641 $16947815 $17917683 $18336856 $18848977 $19348013 $19871550 $20446127 $20758090 $21405338 $22050644
Less BampT Depreciation $77213 $80097 $77846 $86545 $87926 $91345 $104039 $109783 $135035 $240957 $148686 $151977 $158779 $169848 $181689 $194355 $194355 $194355 $194355
BampT Other Post Employment Benefits 66323 50967 54831 66686 73055 76641 71148 62457 60441 78106 32297 22256 20303 22870 28694 33918 36169 38411 40604
Net Operating Deficit Before Subsidies and Debt Service ($6409807) ($6419266) ($6222079) ($6711095) ($7081966) ($7146057) ($7887759) ($6954506) ($7643392) ($8211234) ($8829030) ($9141907) ($9642826) ($10116260) ($10611154) ($11515498) ($11364824) ($11950106) ($12573710)
Conversion to Cash Basis Non-Cash Liability Adjs ($3182192) ($3051466) ($3166371) ($3785396) ($3959443) ($4108749) ($4322293) ($3542990) ($3797981) ($4020699) ($3584911) ($4027178) ($4205012) ($4320246) ($4487966) ($4713886) ($4830392) ($4947361) ($5067352)
Total Operating Expenses $9191127 $9511685 $9550486 $9936705 $10256481 $10937450 $11633535 $11870763 $12453659 $12927 $14333 $14310 $14644 $15028 $15384 $15732 $15927699 $16457978 $16983292
Debt Service Expenses $1515733 $1404454 $1781220 $1933532 $2058395 $2299262 $2248538 $2373321 $2458783 $2525 $2683 $2830 $3041 $3265 $3513 $3450 $3471321 $3472987 $3501639
Total Expenses + Debt Service $10706859 $10916139 $11331706 $11870237 $12314876 $13236712 $13882073 $14244084 $14912443 $15452 $17016 $17140 $17685 $18293 $18896 $19182 $19399019 $19930965 $20484932
Net Deficit After Subsidies and Debt Service ($668477) ($620796) ($0414) $287848 $320833 $556541 $561498 $810173 $359895 ($299965) ($613) ($539) ($898) ($1258) ($1667) ($2283) ($1901641) ($2229069) ($2664369)
Conversion to Cash Basis GASB Account (56067) (54256) (67377) (37636) (89548) (85641) (50017) - 0 - 0 0 0 0 $0 0 0 - 0 - 0 - 0 - 0
Conversion to Cash Basis 492710 550267 91781 (111037) (297407) (261709) (626297) (660147) (591809) 174 229 147 60 125 101 130 49745 48375 54220
Net Cash Balance from Previous Year 0000 0000 0000 23990 139174 0000 209191 0000 150026 0000 0000 0000 0000 0000 0000 0000 0000 0000 0000
Total Operating Exp + DS + Cash Conversions + PY C-O $11144 $11412 $11356 $11746 $12067 $12889362 $13414950 $13583937 $14470659 $15625875 $17244782 $17286526 $17744425 $18418197 $18997710 $19312017 $19448764 $19979340 $20539152
Total Operating Expenses with Cash Conversion $10270216 $10420127 $11307302 $12018911 $12701831 $13584063 $14558387 $14904231 $15504252 $15278749 $16786574 $16992579 $17624861 $18167420 $18795069 $19052755 $19349274 $19882590 $20430711
Baseline Net Cash Balance Before B-T-L Adjustments ($231834) ($124785) $23990 $139174 ($66122) $209191 ($114816) $150026 ($231914) ($126) ($384) ($392) ($838) ($1133) ($1566) ($2153) ($1851896) ($2180695) ($2610148)
Below-the-Line Adjustments
FareToll Increases
FareToll Increase in March 2019 (4 Yield) - 0 $0 $0 $0 $0 $0 $0 - 0 - 0 - 0
FareToll Increase in March 2021 (4 Yield) - 0 $0 $0 $0 $283 $331 $332 333531 333568 334299
FareToll Increase in March 2023 (4 Yield) - 0 $0 $0 $0 $0 $0 $294 346386 346424 347183
FareToll Increase in March 2025 (4 Yield) - 0 $0 $0 $0 $0 $0 $0 - 0 273859 321624
Subsidy Impacts of 20212023 FareToll Increase - 0 $0 $0 $0 ($7) ($9) ($17) (18612) (25573) (26305)
$0000 $0 $0 $0 $275 $322 $609 $661306 $928278 $976801
CASH BALANCE AFTER FARE INCREASES ($126402) ($384) ($392) ($838) ($850) ($1234) ($1821) ($1518365) ($1847127) ($2275849)
MTA Initiatives
MTA Efficiencies - Not Yet Implemented - 0 $0 $0 $0 $0 $0 $0 0000 0000 0000
0 - 0 $0 $0 $0 $0 $0 $0 - 0 - 0 - 0
0 - 0 $0 $0 $0 $0 $0 $0 - 0 - 0 - 0
$0000 $0 $0 $0 $0 $0 $0 $0000 $0000 $0000
Policy Actions
CAS Migration to Peoplesoft $0 $0 ($5) ($1) ($0) ($0) (0200) -02 -02 0
Fare Evasion Enforcement Strategy-Expenses $0 ($13) ($12) ($11) ($10) ($10) (9554) -9554483 -9554483 0
Fare Evasion Enforcement-Manhattan DA Forfeiture Fund $0 $11 $11 $10 $9 $0 - 0 0 0 0
Negotiated 1 CBA Reform $0 $0 $0 $0 $0 $0 - 0 0 0 0
MTA Reorganization $0 $8 $180 $371 $377 $377 377000 377 377 0
MTA Reorganization Costs $0 $0 ($10) ($27) ($2) $0 - 0 0 0 0
Drawdown 2019 General Reserve $0 $0 $165 $0 $0 $0 - 0 0 0 0
CBA Negotiated Reform - 1 Value $0 $36 $100 $173 $246 $323 323473 323473304484 323473304484 0
$0000 $0 $42 $429 $515 $620 $691 $690719 $690719 $690719
MTA Re-estimates
Additional Savings Actions $0000 $0 $0 $0 $0 $0 $0 $0000 $0000 $0000
Total Below-the-Line Adjustments $0 $73 $386 $757 $852 $1133 $1007 $1352025 $1618997 $1667520
Prior Year Carryover 495399 263336 138286 161986 301160 235038 444229 329413 479439 248 372 61 55 0 0 - 0 - 0 - 0 - 0
NET CASH BALANCE $263566 $138551 $162276 $301160 $235038 $444229 $329413 $479439 $247525 $121 $61 $55 ($26) ($281) ($433) ($1146) ($499871) ($561698) ($942628)
MTA February Financial Plan 2019-2022
Consolidated Statement Of Operations By Category ($ in millions)
Non-Reimbursable Final Adopted
Actual Actual Actual Actual Actual Actual Actual Actual Actual Actual Estimate Budget
2008 2009 2010 2011 2012 2013 2014 2015 2016 2017 2018 2019 2020 2021 2022 2023 2024 2025 2026
Operating Revenues
Farebox Revenue $4240923 $4350411 $4586377 $4999186 $5079138 $5501274 $5709200 $5961129 $6050182 $6172 $6153 $6122 $6144 $6134 $6144 $6174 $6435176 $6431979 $6446633
422 423 405 411 402 399 395 396 396 407 279 275 272 267 263 261 368 363 362
Student Fare - 0 - 0 - 0 - 0 - 0 - 0
Toll Revenue 1273974 1332115 1417046 1501589 1490982 1645193 1676445 1808901 1869693 1912 1967 1984 1990 1998 1998 2002 2133050 2137871 2143111
0127 0129 0125 0124 0118 0119 0116 0120 0122 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0122 0121 0120
Other Revenue 448616 461359 491355 510231 563839 753675 682424 689217 688374 653 662 705 733 757 743 755 825040 885381 887190
Capital and Other Reimbursements 0000 0000 0000 0000 0000 0000 0000 0000 0000 0000 0000 0000 0000 0000 0000 0000 0000 0000 0000
Total Operating Revenue $5963512 $6143885 $6494778 $7011006 $7133959 $7900142 $8068069 $8459247 $8608249 $8737 $8782 $8810 $8867 $8889 $8886 $8931 $9393266 $9455232 $9476934
Dedicated Taxes $3211585 $2366805 $2343537 $2511691 $2673119 $3097640 $3383498 $3582628 $3525829 $3257508 $3459 $3515 $3568 $3630 $3725 $3812 $3841433 $3880226 $3917215
PMT amp MTA Aid - 0 881784 1588677 1718286 1825824 1825328 1885069 1910947 1970760 1987035 $1965 $2152 $2225 $2295 $2368 $2442 2516095 2594604 2677041
New Funding Sources - 0 - 0 - 0 - 0 - 0 - 0 - 0 - 0 - 0 - 0 $508 $342 $385 $385 $385 $385 385000 385000 385000
StateLocal Taxes 556691 539046 544810 541733 536182 537527 539545 537819 537645 541005 $544 $552 $557 $562 $567 $572 576828 581933 583214
Other Funding Agreements 306594 363823 359489 375369 466625 432617 567391 563616 629855 630218 $701 $753 $671 $708 $758 $758 784755 804901 781159
BampT Operating Surplus Transfer 382565 363092 476059 554903 476575 614210 637553 750717 742909 740144 $702 $721 $782 $801 $789 $707 730476 695303 688833
Dedicated Taxes and StateLocal Subsidies $4457434 $4514550 $5312572 $5701982 $5978325 $6507322 $7013056 $7345727 $7406998 $7155909 $7879 $8035 $8188 $8381 $8592 $8676 $8834588 $8941967 $9032462
$0000 $0000 $0000 $0000 $0000 $0000 $0000 $0000 $0000
Less Interagency Subsidy and Surplus Transfers (382565) (363092) (476059) (554903) (476575) (614210) (637553) (750717) (742909) (740144) ($702) ($721) ($782) ($801) ($789) ($707) (730476) (695303) (688833)
Total Subsidies $4074870 $4151458 $4836513 $5147079 $5501750 $5893111 $6375503 $6595010 $6664088 $6416 $7242 $7238 $7370 $7576 $7807 $7969 $8104112 $8246664 $8343629
Dedicated Taxes as a of Total Revenues + Subs - PMT 320 251 241 241 247 259 269 273 265 247 $0 $0 $0 $0 $0 $0 256 257 259
Total Revenues + Subsidies $10038382 $10295342 $11331292 $12158085 $12635709 $13793254 $14443571 $15054257 $15272337 $15152 $16023 $16048 $16237 $16465 $16693 $16900 $17497378 $17701896 $17820563
Operating Expenses
Labor Expenses
Payroll $4087376 $4163330 $4171374 $4160261 $4193658 $4332829 $4671664 $4695823 $4838741 $5020713 $5211 $5328 $5422 $5498 $5624 $5710 $5860206 $5982960 $6107107
Overtime 471675 499307 443227 538647 574316 620701 730200 755071 771495 934100 $1066 $910 $838 $859 $877 $899 917296 935002 951324
Health amp Welfare 684945 688899 738189 809638 812857 895714 961902 1050100 1172304 1208786 $1230 $1341 $1414 $1489 $1583 $1674 1797938 1922668 2071273
OPEB Current Payment 318501 346316 355716 394218 413164 472619 479079 501716 562233 563754 $604 $645 $704 $766 $835 $910 982025 1060022 1142795
Pensions 897450 1021229 1029710 1074598 1328441 1301975 1304355 1248726 1370474 1345308 $1336 $1494 $1461 $1462 $1403 $1347 1357887 1369071 1380572
Other-Fringe Benefits 502739 517194 539996 581661 650430 694680 784143 861079 947870 792151 $881 $869 $897 $930 $956 $976 1001185 1021007 1040170
Reimbursable Overhead (310555) (322230) (345154) (324006) (309399) (321390) (349770) (380212) (423759) (491807) ($528) ($471) ($430) ($412) ($397) ($395) (396136) (405509) (413165)
Labor Expenses $6652131 $6914045 $6933059 $7235017 $7663467 $7997128 $8581574 $8732302 $9239358 $9373 $9920 $10039 $10436 $10787 $11097 $11413 $11520401 $11885220 $12280075
PayrollOvertime Exp as a of Total Operating+DS $0426 $0427 $0407 $0396 $0387 $0374 $0389 $0383 $0376 $0385 $0349 $0347 $0345
Labor Exp (wo Reimb OH) as a of Total Oper+DS $0650 $0663 $0642 $0637 $0647 $0628 $0643 $0640 $0648 $0638 $0614 $0617 $0620
PayrollOvertime Exp as a of Total Operating Exp $0496 $0490 $0483 $0473 $0465 $0453 $0464 $0459 $0450 $0461 $0426 $0420 $0416
Labor Exp (wo Reimb OH) as a of Total Oper Exp $0758 $0761 $0762 $0761 $0777 $0761 $0768 $0768 $0776 $0763 $0748 $0747 $0747
Non-Labor Expenses
Electric Power $306500 $317934 $325137 $457269 $471514 $493346 $515540 $473762 $406372 $430381 $474918 $451304 $463523 $482662 $539624 $571182 $589565 $618283 $648255
Traction Power
Non-Traction Power
Fuel 287033 180294 189942 282735 251763 259252 267494 162283 124684 150481 185580 190348 187592 183168 181484 182259 182476 184281 186170
Revenue Vehicle Fuel
Non-Revenue Fuel
Insurance 28902 34012 9819 14363 7617 38654 50739 57190 (20634) (2715) 11488 8532 15803 22918 29411 36048 28232 25538 19483
Claims 152114 238104 285418 315547 135652 299875 269167 331023 463959 526053 376480 378570 386981 391333 395228 404397 417667 428660 437683
Paratransit Service Contracts 299013 370094 379761 348553 360500 366751 365599 379271 383704 392850 452190 482751 501230 518038 547829 581114 604766 643217 684112
Maintenance and Other Operating Contracts 594215 562456 541716 451137 451766 496743 549018 579289 630924 695251 779331 897801 833038 883805 871671 879468 880053 898882 915477
Professional Service Contracts 196930 199164 203084 226205 276998 297201 283005 379814 399706 507062 575742 557476 484911 479376 489510 499724 520826 537109 547291
Materials amp Supplies 532534 526191 511206 438310 430804 475127 526725 543225 585607 588115 667700 686666 687745 692131 697268 711988 741335 777460 793419
Other Business Expenses 155466 184142 189637 169857 143807 167198 179701 195598 192576 217254 225494 230595 225293 240279 242193 244907 228861 240258 241690
Non-Labor Expenses $2552708 $2612391 $2635720 $2703976 $2530421 $2894147 $3006988 $3101454 $3166897 3505 3749 3884 3786 3894 3994 4111 $4193782 $4353689 $4473580
Other Expense Adjustments
Other ($13712) ($14750) ($18292) ($2289) $62593 $46175 $44973 $37007 $47404 49 134 158 84 36 22 23 $23516 $24069 $24637
General Reserve 0000 0000 0000 0000 0000 - 0 - 0 - 0 - 0 0 0 165 170 175 180 185 190000 195000 205000
Other Expense Adjustments ($13712) ($14750) ($18292) ($2289) $62593 $46175 $44973 $37007 $47404 $49379 $134 $323 $254 $211 $202 $208 $213516 $219069 $229637
Gap Closing Expenses $7675394
Additional Actions for Budget Balance Expense Impact $0000 $0000 $0000 $0000 $0000 $0000 $0000 $0000 $0000 $0000 $0000 $0000 $0000 $0000 $0000 $0000 $0000 $0000 $0000
Total Operating Expenses Before Non-Cash Liability Adjs $9191127 $9511685 $9550486 $9936705 $10256481 $10937450 $11633535 $11870763 $12453659 $12927116 $13802910 $14246122 $14475644 $14891445 $15293262 $15732241 $15927699 $16457978 $16983292
Non-Cash Liability Adjustments
Depreciation $1790981 $1940576 $1980681 $2019378 $2148820 $2174302 $2266280 $2442777 $2442941 $2607970 $2804571 $2784812 $2842737 $2908533 $2977025 $3051834 $3109882 $3169371 $3230301
OPEB Obligation 1348962 1104827 1167070 1706939 1785881 1920189 2035457 1489656 1562261 1567381 0000 (0000) (0000) (0000) (0000) 0000 0000 (0000) (0000)
GASB 75 OPEB Expense Adjustment 0000 0000 0000 0000 0000 0000 0000 0000 0000 0000 1047747 1457230 1628196 1748560 1823313 1898497 1952374 2006482 2061993
GASB 68 Pension Expense Adjustment 0000 0000 0000 0000 0000 0000 0000 (410019) (218911) (168119) (373022) (220864) (271921) (342847) (318372) (242446) (237864) (234492) (230942)
Environmental Remediation 42249 6062 18621 59079 24742 14257 20556 20576 11691 13468 105615 6000 6000 6000 6000 6000 6000 6000 6000
Non-Cash Liability Adjustments $3182192 $3051466 $3166371 $3785396 $3959443 $4108749 $4322293 $3542990 $3797981 $4020699 $3584911 $4027178 $4205012 $4320246 $4487966 $4713886 $4830392 $4947361 $5067352
Total Operating Expenses After Non-Cash Liability Adjs $12373319 $12563151 $12716857 $13722101 $14215924 $15046199 $15955827 $15413753 $16251641 $16947815 $17387821 $18273301 $18680657 $19211690 $19781228 $20446127 $20758090 $21405338 $22050644
Less BampT Depreciation $77213 $80097 $77846 $86545 $87926 $91345 $104039 $109783 $135035 $240957 $148686 $151977 $158779 $169848 $181689 $194355 $194355 $194355 $194355
BampT Other Post Employment Benefits 66323 50967 54831 66686 73055 76641 71148 62457 60441 78106 32297 22256 20303 22870 28694 33918 36169 38411 40604
Net Operating Deficit Before Subsidies and Debt Service ($6409807) ($6419266) ($6222079) ($6711095) ($7081966) ($7146057) ($7887759) ($6954506) ($7643392) ($8211234) ($8606220) ($9463506) ($9813560) ($10322912) ($10895644) ($11515498) ($11364824) ($11950106) ($12573710)
Conversion to Cash Basis Non-Cash Liability Adjs ($3182192) ($3051466) ($3166371) ($3785396) ($3959443) ($4108749) ($4322293) ($3542990) ($3797981) ($4020699) ($3584911) ($4027178) ($4205012) ($4320246) ($4487966) ($4713886) ($4830392) ($4947361) ($5067352)
Total Operating Expenses $9191127 $9511685 $9550486 $9936705 $10256481 $10937450 $11633535 $11870763 $12453659 $12927 $13803 $14246 $14476 $14891 $15293 $15732 $15927699 $16457978 $16983292
Debt Service Expenses $1515733 $1404454 $1781220 $1933532 $2058395 $2299262 $2248538 $2373321 $2458783 $2525 $2559 $2692 $2840 $3080 $3223 $3450 $3471321 $3472987 $3501639
Total Expenses + Debt Service $10706859 $10916139 $11331706 $11870237 $12314876 $13236712 $13882073 $14244084 $14912443 $15452 $16362 $16938 $17316 $17971 $18516 $19182 $19399019 $19930965 $20484932
Net Deficit After Subsidies and Debt Service ($668477) ($620796) ($0414) $287848 $320833 $556541 $561498 $810173 $359895 ($299965) ($339) ($890) ($1079) ($1506) ($1823) ($2283) ($1901641) ($2229069) ($2664369)
Conversion to Cash Basis GASB Account (56067) (54256) (67377) (37636) (89548) (85641) (50017) - 0 - 0 0 0 0 $0 0 0 - 0 - 0 - 0 - 0
Conversion to Cash Basis 492710 550267 91781 (111037) (297407) (261709) (626297) (660147) (591809) 174 296 363 188 (17) 88 130 49745 48375 54220
Net Cash Balance from Previous Year 0000 0000 0000 23990 139174 0000 209191 0000 150026 0000 0000 0000 0000 0000 0000 0000 0000 0000 0000
Total Operating Exp + DS + Cash Conversions + PY C-O $11144 $11412 $11356 $11746 $12067 $12889362 $13414950 $13583937 $14470659 $15625875 $16658585 $17300293 $17504155 $17954574 $18604130 $19312017 $19448764 $19979340 $20539152
Total Operating Expenses with Cash Conversion $10270216 $10420127 $11307302 $12018911 $12701831 $13584063 $14558387 $14904231 $15504252 $15278749 $16065734 $16575223 $17128079 $17987951 $18427778 $19052755 $19349274 $19882590 $20430711
Baseline Net Cash Balance Before B-T-L Adjustments ($231834) ($124785) $23990 $139174 ($66122) $209191 ($114816) $150026 ($231914) ($126) ($43) ($527) ($891) ($1523) ($1735) ($2153) ($1851896) ($2180695) ($2610148)
Below-the-Line Adjustments
FareToll Increases
FareToll Increase in March 2019 (4 Yield) - 0 $0 $0 $0 $0 $0 $0 - 0 - 0 - 0
FareToll Increase in March 2021 (4 Yield) - 0 $0 $0 $0 $283 $331 $332 333531 333568 334299
FareToll Increase in March 2023 (4 Yield) - 0 $0 $0 $0 $0 $0 $294 346386 346424 347183
FareToll Increase in March 2025 (4 Yield) - 0 $0 $0 $0 $0 $0 $0 - 0 273859 321624
Subsidy Impacts of 20212023 FareToll Increase - 0 $0 $0 $0 ($7) ($9) ($17) (18612) (25573) (26305)
$0000 $0 $0 $0 $275 $322 $609 $661306 $928278 $976801
CASH BALANCE AFTER FARE INCREASES ($126402) ($43) ($527) ($891) ($1241) ($1404) ($1821) ($1518365) ($1847127) ($2275849)
MTA Initiatives
MTA Efficiencies - Not Yet Implemented - 0 $0 $0 $0 $0 $0 $0 0000 0000 0000
0 - 0 $0 $0 $0 $0 $0 $0 - 0 - 0 - 0
0 - 0 $0 $0 $0 $0 $0 $0 - 0 - 0 - 0
$0000 $0 $0 $0 $0 $0 $0 $0000 $0000 $0000
Policy Actions
CAS Migration to Peoplesoft $0 $0 ($5) ($1) ($0) ($0) (0200) -02 -02 0
Fare Evasion Enforcement Strategy-Expenses $0 ($13) ($12) ($11) ($10) ($10) (9554) -9554483 -9554483 0
Fare Evasion Enforcement-Manhattan DA Forfeiture Fund $0 $11 $11 $10 $9 $0 - 0 0 0 0
Negotiated 1 CBA Reform $0 $0 $0 $0 $0 $0 - 0 0 0 0
MTA Reorganization $0 $8 $180 $371 $377 $377 377000 377 377 0
MTA Reorganization Costs $0 $0 ($10) ($27) ($2) $0 - 0 0 0 0
Drawdown 2019 General Reserve $0 $0 $165 $0 $0 $0 - 0 0 0 0
CBA Negotiated Reform - 1 Value $0 $36 $100 $173 $246 $323 323473 323473304484 323473304484 0
$0000 $0 $42 $429 $515 $620 $691 $690719 $690719 $690719
MTA Re-estimates
Additional Savings Actions $0000 $0 $0 $0 $0 $0 $0 $0000 $0000 $0000
Total Below-the-Line Adjustments $0 $0 $459 $413 $709 $760 $1007 $1352025 $1618997 $1667520
Prior Year Carryover 495399 263336 138286 161986 301160 235038 444229 329413 479439 248 121 79 11 0 0 - 0 - 0 - 0 - 0
NET CASH BALANCE $263566 $138551 $162276 $301160 $235038 $444229 $329413 $479439 $247525 $121 $79 $11 ($467) ($814) ($976) ($1146) ($499871) ($561698) ($942628)
Page 4: MTA 2020 Preliminary Budget July Financial Plan 2020 - 2023 2020 Preliminar… · 1 The MTA Budget Process July Plan – Start of the Annual Process • Current year is revised (the

3

The February Financial Plan included large out-year deficits even with faretoll increases and substantial cost reduction targets

($ in millions)

11

(467)

(814)

(976)

($1200)

($1000)

($800)

($600)

($400)

($200)

$0

$200

2019 2020 2021 2022

This Year Next Year Out-Years

What has changed since the February Plan

Changes and re-estimates over the Plan period (2019 ndash 2022)bull Changes and re-estimates improving financial results

bull Higher MMTOA subsidies ($184 million)bull Higher yield from additional 23 in tolls ($173 million)bull Lower maintenanceother operating contracts ($173 million)bull Higher MTA Aid car rental tax ($35 million)

bull Changes and re-estimates worsening financial resultsbull Actuary recalculation of pension liability ($550 million)bull Agency re-estimates and rate change adjustments ($189 million)bull Higher overtime expenses ($131 million)bull Lower rentaladvertising revenues ($83 million)bull Lower real estate tax revenues ($59 million)

In total these changes and re-estimates along with other changes are $447 million unfavorable for the Plan period

4

Highlights of the July Plan

bull Proposed biennial fare and toll increases of 4 in 2021 and 2023 (versus projected 2-year CPI inflators of 49 and 47 in 2021 and 2023 respectively)

bull Maintained investments from prior plans including maintenance of the Subway Action Plan funded from Phase 1 of Congestion PricingFHV fees

bull Renewed emphasis to gain control of and reduce fare evasion (investment of $62 million over the Plan period)

bull MTA is using ldquoone-shotsrdquo to balance the budget in the transition years 2019 and 2020

o 2019 - 2018 favorable year-end balance ndash mostly timing ndash and impacts 2019 ($372 million)

- Freeze on filling all non-operationalnon-essential vacancies ($68 million)

- Other restrictions on non-essential spending including non-revenue vehicle purchases travelprofessional memberships ($44 million)

- One-time reduction of committed to capital contributions ($64 million)

o 2020 - Drawdown of 2019 General Reserve ($165 million)

bull Annual recurring savings targets of $350 million beginning in 2020 have been identified by HQ and Agencies

5

6

These actions will not suffice and significant deficits remain($ in millions)

This Year Next Year Out-Years

11

(467)

(814)

(976)

NA

50

(186)

(569)

(816)

(971)

($1200)

($1000)

($800)

($600)

($400)

($200)

$0

$200

2019 2020 2021 2022 2023

February PlanJuly Plan without Transformation Plan Savings

MTA Transformation Plan

bull State-mandated plan to review operations and implement changes to streamline internal processes clarify responsibilities solidify accountability and work more efficiently to regain trust of our customers and funding partners and improve MTArsquos ability to deliver safe and reliable service our customers deserve

bull Plan recommendationsbull Refocus the operating agencies on mission-critical operating priorities of safety reliability and

servicebull Centralize common support functions to improve operations and create opportunities to ensure

consistent standards quality and policies across departmentsbull Unify the management of capital programs to improve and streamline planning development

and construction so capital improvements can be delivered on time and on budgetbull Expand senior leadership by adding a Chief Transformation Officer a Chief Operating Officer a

Chief Engineering Officer and an MTA Accessibility Officer

bull Consolidation and efficiency targets of $370 million to $530 million on an annual basis have been identified

bull If the MTA Transformation Plan is approved and implemented the July Financial Plan will have small operating balances in 2019 and 2020 a small deficit in 2021 with out-year deficits reaching $433 million in 2023

7

8

The adoption and implementation of the MTA Transformation Planhas the potential to significantly reduce out-year deficits

($ in millions)

This Year Next Year Out-Years

11

(467)

(814)

(976)

NA

61 55

(26)

(281)

(433)

($1200)

($1000)

($800)

($600)

($400)

($200)

$0

$200

2019 2020 2021 2022 2023

February PlanProposed July Plan

Actions to Reduce Fare Evasion $62 million Investment over the Plan Period

bull Increase physical presence (500 uniformed officers NYPD MTA Police and Bridge and Tunnel Officers) to begin enforcement at 50 subway stations and 50 bus routesThis is not just a fare evasion effort but a workerrsquos safety initiative

bull Ensure enforcement does not target any specific demographic bull Educate MTA riders utilizing messaging media and automated

announcementsbull Improve operation of emergency exit gates to mitigate instances of fare

avoidancebull Augment surveillance capabilities by deploying fare array cameras at 50

stations and pilot the use of monitors at 10 stationsbull $40 million of the investment will be funded by Manhattan DA Office over a

four-year period

9

The MTArsquos $350 million target for annually recurring savings beginning in 2020 has been identified and is being implemented

109

10 7 6 6

96 304 351 362 371

$0

$50

$100

$150

$200

$250

$300

$350

$400

2019 2020 2021 2022 2023

Identified Recurring Savings One-Shot Savings

This Year Next Year Out-Years

($ in millions)

10

We have a track record of identifying and achieving our annual recurring savings targets

11

($ in millions)

$0

$500

$1000

$1500

$2000

$2500

$3000

Achieved Savings

2012 November Plan

2013 November Plan

2014 November Plan

2015 November Plan

2016 November Plan

2017 November Plan

2018 November Plan

2019 July Plan

$28 billion

Proposed July Plan

Deficits remain and a continued drive toward further streamlining and efficiencies is required

12

($ in millions)

61 55

(26)

(281)

(433)

($600)

($500)

($400)

($300)

($200)

($100)

$0

$100

$200

2019 2020 2021 2022 2023

This Year Next Year Out-Years

Proposed July PlanDonrsquot achieve Transformation Plan Savings

13

If the MTA Transformation Plan is not adopted and implemented the deficits will be unmanageable without service cuts significant

reductions in force andor additional fare and toll increases($ in millions)

($1100)

($900)

($700)

($500)

($300)

($100)

$100

2019 2020 2021 2022 2023

(816)

(971)

(569)

(81)

(433)

(281)

61 55 (26)

(281) (186)

50

Next Year Out-Years

(230)(11)

(488)

(538)

(535)

This Year

14

2020 Preliminary BudgetWhere the Dollars Come Fromhellip Where the Dollars Gohellip

Farebox Revenue $6389Toll Revenue 2121 Other Revenue 684 Taxes 6178 State and Local amp Other 557 Other Funding Agreements 671 Other 1 208 Total $16809

($ in millions)

By Revenue Source(includes faretoll increases)

Payroll $5422Overtime 838 Health amp Welfare 2118 Pension 1461 Other Labor 466 Total Labor $10306Non-Labor + Other Exp Adj 4004 Debt Service 2830 BTL Adjustments for Expenses 2 (386) Total $16754

By Expense Category

($ in millions)(includes below-the-line adjustments)

1 Includes cash adjustments and prior-year carryover

Farebox Revenue

38

Toll Revenue

13

Other Revenue4

Taxes37

State amp Local

Subsidies3

Other Funding Agreements

4 Other 1

Payroll32

Overtime5

Health ampWelfare

13Pension

9

Other Labor3

Non-Labor + Other Exp Adj

21

Debt Service17

2 The below-the-line adjustments are grouped in the Non-Labor category

Sheet1

Sheet1

15

Non-Reimbursable Mid-Year Preliminary Actual Forecast Budget

2018 2019 2020 2021 2022 2023 Operating Revenues

Farebox Revenue $6155 $6305 $6389 $6373 $6384 $6393Toll Revenue 1976 2088 2121 2129 2129 2131 Other Revenue 643 696 684 704 719 737

Total Operating Revenue $8774 $9089 $9195 $9206 $9232 $9260

Total Subsidies $7177 $7314 $7406 $7581 $7803 $7969Dedicated Taxes as a of Total Revenues + Subs - PMT 233 $0 $0 $0 $0 $0

Total Revenues + Subsidies $15951 $16403 $16601 $16787 $17035 $17229

Operating ExpensesLabor Expenses $9799 $10116 $10306 $10592 $10881 $11121Non-Labor Expenses 3611 3877 3748 3841 3945 4054 Other 129 175 86 36 22 23 General Reserve 0 165 170 175 180 185

Total Operating Expenses $13539 $14333 $14310 $14644 $15028 $15384

Debt Service Expenses $2541 $2683 $2830 $3041 $3265 $3513

Total Expenses + Debt Service $16079 $17016 $17140 $17685 $18293 $18896

Conversion to Cash Basis 379 229 147 60 125 101

Baseline Net Cash Balance Before B-T-L Adjustments $251 ($384) ($392) ($838) ($1133) ($1566)

Total Below-the-Line Adjustments $0 $73 $386 $757 $852 $1133Prior Year Carryover 121 372 61 55 0 0

NET CASH BALANCE $372 $61 $55 ($26) ($281) ($433)

MTA July Financial Plan 2020-2023Consolidated Statement Of Operations By Category ($ in millions)

Summ Stmt of Ops-Feb

Summ Stmt of Ops-Jul

  • MTA 2020Preliminary BudgetJuly Financial Plan2020 - 2023
  • The MTA Budget Process
  • Slide Number 3
  • Slide Number 4
  • What has changed since the February Plan
  • Highlights of the July Plan
  • Slide Number 7
  • MTA Transformation Plan
  • Slide Number 9
  • Actions to Reduce Fare Evasion $62 million Investment over the Plan Period
  • The MTArsquos $350 million target for annually recurring savings beginning in 2020 has been identified and is being implemented
  • We have a track record of identifying and achieving our annual recurring savings targets
  • Deficits remain and a continued drive toward further streamlining and efficiencies is required
  • Slide Number 14
  • 2020 Preliminary Budget
  • Slide Number 16
MTA July Financial Plan 2020-2023
Consolidated Statement Of Operations By Category ($ in millions)
Non-Reimbursable Mid-Year Preliminary
Actual Actual Actual Actual Actual Actual Actual Actual Actual Actual Forecast Budget
2008 2009 2010 2011 2012 2013 2014 2015 2016 2018 2019 2020 2021 2022 2023 2023 2024 2025 2026
Operating Revenues
Farebox Revenue $4240923 $4350411 $4586377 $4999186 $5079138 $5501274 $5709200 $5961129 $6050182 $6155 $6305 $6389 $6373 $6384 $6393 $6174 $6435176 $6431979 $6446633
422 423 405 411 402 399 395 396 396 386 384 385 380 375 371 261 368 363 362
Student Fare - 0 - 0 - 0 - 0 - 0 - 0
Toll Revenue 1273974 1332115 1417046 1501589 1490982 1645193 1676445 1808901 1869693 1976 2088 2121 2129 2129 2131 2002 2133050 2137871 2143111
0127 0129 0125 0124 0118 0119 0116 0120 0122 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0122 0121 0120
Other Revenue 448616 461359 491355 510231 563839 753675 682424 689217 688374 643 696 684 704 719 737 755 825040 885381 887190
Capital and Other Reimbursements 0000 0000 0000 0000 0000 0000 0000 0000 0000 0000 0000 0000 0000 0000 0000 0000 0000 0000 0000
Total Operating Revenue $5963512 $6143885 $6494778 $7011006 $7133959 $7900142 $8068069 $8459247 $8608249 $8774 $9089 $9195 $9206 $9232 $9260 $8931 $9393266 $9455232 $9476934
Dedicated Taxes $3211585 $2366805 $2343537 $2511691 $2673119 $3097640 $3383498 $3582628 $3525829 $3257508 $3459 $3515 $3568 $3630 $3725 $3812 $3841433 $3880226 $3917215
PMT amp MTA Aid - 0 881784 1588677 1718286 1825824 1825328 1885069 1910947 1970760 1987035 $1965 $2152 $2225 $2295 $2368 $2442 2516095 2594604 2677041
New Funding Sources - 0 - 0 - 0 - 0 - 0 - 0 - 0 - 0 - 0 - 0 $508 $342 $385 $385 $385 $385 385000 385000 385000
StateLocal Taxes 556691 539046 544810 541733 536182 537527 539545 537819 537645 541005 $544 $552 $557 $562 $567 $572 576828 581933 583214
Other Funding Agreements 306594 363823 359489 375369 466625 432617 567391 563616 629855 630218 $701 $753 $671 $708 $758 $758 784755 804901 781159
BampT Operating Surplus Transfer 382565 363092 476059 554903 476575 614210 637553 750717 742909 740144 $702 $721 $782 $801 $789 $707 730476 695303 688833
Dedicated Taxes and StateLocal Subsidies $4457434 $4514550 $5312572 $5701982 $5978325 $6507322 $7013056 $7345727 $7406998 $7155909 $7879 $8035 $8188 $8381 $8592 $8676 $8834588 $8941967 $9032462
$0000 $0000 $0000 $0000 $0000 $0000 $0000 $0000 $0000
Less Interagency Subsidy and Surplus Transfers (382565) (363092) (476059) (554903) (476575) (614210) (637553) (750717) (742909) (740144) ($702) ($721) ($782) ($801) ($789) ($707) (730476) (695303) (688833)
Total Subsidies $4074870 $4151458 $4836513 $5147079 $5501750 $5893111 $6375503 $6595010 $6664088 $7177 $7314 $7406 $7581 $7803 $7969 $7969 $8104112 $8246664 $8343629
Dedicated Taxes as a of Total Revenues + Subs - PMT 320 251 241 241 247 259 269 273 265 233 $0 $0 $0 $0 $0 $0 256 257 259
Total Revenues + Subsidies $10038382 $10295342 $11331292 $12158085 $12635709 $13793254 $14443571 $15054257 $15272337 $15951 $16403 $16601 $16787 $17035 $17229 $16900 $17497378 $17701896 $17820563
Operating Expenses
Labor Expenses
Payroll $4087376 $4163330 $4171374 $4160261 $4193658 $4332829 $4671664 $4695823 $4838741 $5020713 $5211 $5328 $5422 $5498 $5624 $5710 $5860206 $5982960 $6107107
Overtime 471675 499307 443227 538647 574316 620701 730200 755071 771495 934100 $1066 $910 $838 $859 $877 $899 917296 935002 951324
Health amp Welfare 684945 688899 738189 809638 812857 895714 961902 1050100 1172304 1208786 $1230 $1341 $1414 $1489 $1583 $1674 1797938 1922668 2071273
OPEB Current Payment 318501 346316 355716 394218 413164 472619 479079 501716 562233 563754 $604 $645 $704 $766 $835 $910 982025 1060022 1142795
Pensions 897450 1021229 1029710 1074598 1328441 1301975 1304355 1248726 1370474 1345308 $1336 $1494 $1461 $1462 $1403 $1347 1357887 1369071 1380572
Other-Fringe Benefits 502739 517194 539996 581661 650430 694680 784143 861079 947870 792151 $881 $869 $897 $930 $956 $976 1001185 1021007 1040170
Reimbursable Overhead (310555) (322230) (345154) (324006) (309399) (321390) (349770) (380212) (423759) (491807) ($528) ($471) ($430) ($412) ($397) ($395) (396136) (405509) (413165)
Labor Expenses $6652131 $6914045 $6933059 $7235017 $7663467 $7997128 $8581574 $8732302 $9239358 $9799 $10116 $10306 $10592 $10881 $11121 $11413 $11520401 $11885220 $12280075
PayrollOvertime Exp as a of Total Operating+DS $0426 $0427 $0407 $0396 $0387 $0374 $0389 $0383 $0376 $0390 $0367 $0365 $0359 $0355 $0350 $0349 $0347 $0345
Labor Exp (wo Reimb OH) as a of Total Oper+DS $0650 $0663 $0642 $0637 $0647 $0628 $0643 $0640 $0648 $0642 $0622 $0626 $0622 $0616 $0609 $0614 $0617 $0620
PayrollOvertime Exp as a of Total Operating Exp $0496 $0490 $0483 $0473 $0465 $0453 $0464 $0459 $0450 $0464 $0435 $0438 $0434 $0433 $0430 $0426 $0420 $0416
Labor Exp (wo Reimb OH) as a of Total Oper Exp $0758 $0761 $0762 $0761 $0777 $0761 $0768 $0768 $0776 $0763 $0739 $0750 $0751 $0750 $0749 $0748 $0747 $0747
Non-Labor Expenses
Electric Power $306500 $317934 $325137 $457269 $471514 $493346 $515540 $473762 $406372 $481893 $451503 $473177 $493090 $532413 $561955 $571182 $589565 $618283 $648255
Traction Power
Non-Traction Power
Fuel 287033 180294 189942 282735 251763 259252 267494 162283 124684 185203 182778 182981 176333 173681 176920 182259 182476 184281 186170
Revenue Vehicle Fuel
Non-Revenue Fuel
Insurance 28902 34012 9819 14363 7617 38654 50739 57190 (20634) (29402) 5608 15623 23118 26855 28309 36048 28232 25538 19483
Claims 152114 238104 285418 315547 135652 299875 269167 331023 463959 437985 387557 394211 392547 398256 406112 404397 417667 428660 437683
Paratransit Service Contracts 299013 370094 379761 348553 360500 366751 365599 379271 383704 455471 494751 488330 505538 535329 568614 581114 604766 643217 684112
Maintenance and Other Operating Contracts 594215 562456 541716 451137 451766 496743 549018 579289 630924 678425 840168 797428 833534 836606 854471 879468 880053 898882 915477
Professional Service Contracts 196930 199164 203084 226205 276998 297201 283005 379814 399706 543582 607838 502858 494814 504103 513895 499724 520826 537109 547291
Materials amp Supplies 532534 526191 511206 438310 430804 475127 526725 543225 585607 637078 689010 679895 697976 711281 715758 711988 741335 777460 793419
Other Business Expenses 155466 184142 189637 169857 143807 167198 179701 195598 192576 220838 218196 213551 224459 226170 228457 244907 228861 240258 241690
Non-Labor Expenses $2552708 $2612391 $2635720 $2703976 $2530421 $2894147 $3006988 $3101454 $3166897 3611 3877 3748 3841 3945 4054 4111 $4193782 $4353689 $4473580
Other Expense Adjustments
Other ($13712) ($14750) ($18292) ($2289) $62593 $46175 $44973 $37007 $47404 129 175 86 36 22 23 23 $23516 $24069 $24637
General Reserve 0000 0000 0000 0000 0000 - 0 - 0 - 0 - 0 0 165 170 175 180 185 185 190000 195000 205000
Other Expense Adjustments ($13712) ($14750) ($18292) ($2289) $62593 $46175 $44973 $37007 $47404 $128555 $340 $256 $211 $202 $208 $208 $213516 $219069 $229637
Gap Closing Expenses $7675394
Additional Actions for Budget Balance Expense Impact $0000 $0000 $0000 $0000 $0000 $0000 $0000 $0000 $0000 $0000 $0000 $0000 $0000 $0000 $0000 $0000 $0000 $0000 $0000
Total Operating Expenses Before Non-Cash Liability Adjs $9191127 $9511685 $9550486 $9936705 $10256481 $10937450 $11633535 $11870763 $12453659 $13538830 $14332772 $14309678 $14643965 $15027767 $15383584 $15732241 $15927699 $16457978 $16983292
Non-Cash Liability Adjustments
Depreciation $1790981 $1940576 $1980681 $2019378 $2148820 $2174302 $2266280 $2442777 $2442941 $2607970 $2804571 $2784812 $2842737 $2908533 $2977025 $3051834 $3109882 $3169371 $3230301
OPEB Obligation 1348962 1104827 1167070 1706939 1785881 1920189 2035457 1489656 1562261 1567381 0000 (0000) (0000) (0000) (0000) 0000 0000 (0000) (0000)
GASB 75 OPEB Expense Adjustment 0000 0000 0000 0000 0000 0000 0000 0000 0000 0000 1047747 1457230 1628196 1748560 1823313 1898497 1952374 2006482 2061993
GASB 68 Pension Expense Adjustment 0000 0000 0000 0000 0000 0000 0000 (410019) (218911) (168119) (373022) (220864) (271921) (342847) (318372) (242446) (237864) (234492) (230942)
Environmental Remediation 42249 6062 18621 59079 24742 14257 20556 20576 11691 13468 105615 6000 6000 6000 6000 6000 6000 6000 6000
Non-Cash Liability Adjustments $3182192 $3051466 $3166371 $3785396 $3959443 $4108749 $4322293 $3542990 $3797981 $4020699 $3584911 $4027178 $4205012 $4320246 $4487966 $4713886 $4830392 $4947361 $5067352
Total Operating Expenses After Non-Cash Liability Adjs $12373319 $12563151 $12716857 $13722101 $14215924 $15046199 $15955827 $15413753 $16251641 $17559529 $17917683 $18336856 $18848977 $19348013 $19871550 $20446127 $20758090 $21405338 $22050644
Less BampT Depreciation $77213 $80097 $77846 $86545 $87926 $91345 $104039 $109783 $135035 $240957 $148686 $151977 $158779 $169848 $181689 $194355 $194355 $194355 $194355
BampT Other Post Employment Benefits 66323 50967 54831 66686 73055 76641 71148 62457 60441 78106 32297 22256 20303 22870 28694 33918 36169 38411 40604
Net Operating Deficit Before Subsidies and Debt Service ($6409807) ($6419266) ($6222079) ($6711095) ($7081966) ($7146057) ($7887759) ($6954506) ($7643392) ($8785339) ($8829030) ($9141907) ($9642826) ($10116260) ($10611154) ($11515498) ($11364824) ($11950106) ($12573710)
Conversion to Cash Basis Non-Cash Liability Adjs ($3182192) ($3051466) ($3166371) ($3785396) ($3959443) ($4108749) ($4322293) ($3542990) ($3797981) ($4020699) ($3584911) ($4027178) ($4205012) ($4320246) ($4487966) ($4713886) ($4830392) ($4947361) ($5067352)
Total Operating Expenses $9191127 $9511685 $9550486 $9936705 $10256481 $10937450 $11633535 $11870763 $12453659 $13539 $14333 $14310 $14644 $15028 $15384 $15732 $15927699 $16457978 $16983292
Debt Service Expenses $1515733 $1404454 $1781220 $1933532 $2058395 $2299262 $2248538 $2373321 $2458783 $2541 $2683 $2830 $3041 $3265 $3513 $3450 $3471321 $3472987 $3501639
Total Expenses + Debt Service $10706859 $10916139 $11331706 $11870237 $12314876 $13236712 $13882073 $14244084 $14912443 $16079 $17016 $17140 $17685 $18293 $18896 $19182 $19399019 $19930965 $20484932
Net Deficit After Subsidies and Debt Service ($668477) ($620796) ($0414) $287848 $320833 $556541 $561498 $810173 $359895 ($128044) ($613) ($539) ($898) ($1258) ($1667) ($2283) ($1901641) ($2229069) ($2664369)
Conversion to Cash Basis GASB Account (56067) (54256) (67377) (37636) (89548) (85641) (50017) - 0 - 0 0 0 0 $0 0 0 - 0 - 0 - 0 - 0
Conversion to Cash Basis 492710 550267 91781 (111037) (297407) (261709) (626297) (660147) (591809) 379 229 147 60 125 101 130 49745 48375 54220
Net Cash Balance from Previous Year 0000 0000 0000 23990 139174 0000 209191 0000 150026 0000 250569 0000 0000 0000 0000 0000 0000 0000 0000
Total Operating Exp + DS + Cash Conversions + PY C-O $11144 $11412 $11356 $11746 $12067 $12889362 $13414950 $13583937 $14470659 $16457999 $17495351 $17286526 $17744425 $18418197 $18997710 $19312017 $19448764 $19979340 $20539152
Total Operating Expenses with Cash Conversion $10270216 $10420127 $11307302 $12018911 $12701831 $13584063 $14558387 $14904231 $15504252 $15700774 $16786574 $16992579 $17624861 $18167420 $18795069 $19052755 $19349274 $19882590 $20430711
Baseline Net Cash Balance Before B-T-L Adjustments ($231834) ($124785) $23990 $139174 ($66122) $209191 ($114816) $150026 ($231914) $251 ($384) ($392) ($838) ($1133) ($1566) ($2153) ($1851896) ($2180695) ($2610148)
Below-the-Line Adjustments
FareToll Increases
FareToll Increase in March 2019 (4 Yield) - 0 $0 $0 $0 $0 $0 $0 - 0 - 0 - 0
FareToll Increase in March 2021 (4 Yield) - 0 $0 $0 $0 $283 $331 $332 333531 333568 334299
FareToll Increase in March 2023 (4 Yield) - 0 $0 $0 $0 $0 $0 $294 346386 346424 347183
FareToll Increase in March 2025 (4 Yield) - 0 $0 $0 $0 $0 $0 $0 - 0 273859 321624
Subsidy Impacts of 20212023 FareToll Increase - 0 $0 $0 $0 ($7) ($9) ($17) (18612) (25573) (26305)
$0000 $0 $0 $0 $275 $322 $609 $661306 $928278 $976801
CASH BALANCE AFTER FARE INCREASES $250569 ($384) ($392) ($838) ($850) ($1234) ($1821) ($1518365) ($1847127) ($2275849)
MTA Initiatives
MTA Efficiencies - Not Yet Implemented - 0 $0 $0 $0 $0 $0 $0 0000 0000 0000
0 - 0 $0 $0 $0 $0 $0 $0 - 0 - 0 - 0
0 - 0 $0 $0 $0 $0 $0 $0 - 0 - 0 - 0
$0000 $0 $0 $0 $0 $0 $0 $0000 $0000 $0000
Policy Actions
CAS Migration to Peoplesoft $0 $0 ($5) ($1) ($0) ($0) (0200) -02 -02 0
Fare Evasion Enforcement Strategy-Expenses $0 ($13) ($12) ($11) ($10) ($10) (9554) -9554483 -9554483 0
Fare Evasion Enforcement-Manhattan DA Forfeiture Fund $0 $11 $11 $10 $9 $0 - 0 0 0 0
Negotiated 1 CBA Reform $0 $0 $0 $0 $0 $0 - 0 0 0 0
MTA Reorganization $0 $8 $180 $371 $377 $377 377000 377 377 0
MTA Reorganization Costs $0 $0 ($10) ($27) ($2) $0 - 0 0 0 0
Drawdown 2019 General Reserve $0 $0 $165 $0 $0 $0 - 0 0 0 0
CBA Negotiated Reform - 1 Value $0 $36 $100 $173 $246 $323 323473 323473304484 323473304484 0
$0000 $0 $42 $429 $515 $620 $691 $690719 $690719 $690719
MTA Re-estimates
Additional Savings Actions $0000 $0 $0 $0 $0 $0 $0 $0000 $0000 $0000
Total Below-the-Line Adjustments $0 $73 $386 $757 $852 $1133 $1007 $1352025 $1618997 $1667520
Prior Year Carryover 495399 263336 138286 161986 301160 235038 444229 329413 479439 121 372 61 55 0 0 - 0 - 0 - 0 - 0
NET CASH BALANCE $263566 $138551 $162276 $301160 $235038 $444229 $329413 $479439 $247525 $372 $61 $55 ($26) ($281) ($433) ($1146) ($499871) ($561698) ($942628)
MTA February Financial Plan 2019-2022
Consolidated Statement Of Operations By Category ($ in millions)
Non-Reimbursable Final Adopted
Actual Actual Actual Actual Actual Actual Actual Actual Actual Actual Estimate Budget
2008 2009 2010 2011 2012 2013 2014 2015 2016 2017 2018 2019 2020 2021 2022 2023 2024 2025 2026
Operating Revenues
Farebox Revenue $4240923 $4350411 $4586377 $4999186 $5079138 $5501274 $5709200 $5961129 $6050182 $6172 $6153 $6122 $6144 $6134 $6144 $6174 $6435176 $6431979 $6446633
422 423 405 411 402 399 395 396 396 407 279 275 272 267 263 261 368 363 362
Student Fare - 0 - 0 - 0 - 0 - 0 - 0
Toll Revenue 1273974 1332115 1417046 1501589 1490982 1645193 1676445 1808901 1869693 1912 1967 1984 1990 1998 1998 2002 2133050 2137871 2143111
0127 0129 0125 0124 0118 0119 0116 0120 0122 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0122 0121 0120
Other Revenue 448616 461359 491355 510231 563839 753675 682424 689217 688374 653 662 705 733 757 743 755 825040 885381 887190
Capital and Other Reimbursements 0000 0000 0000 0000 0000 0000 0000 0000 0000 0000 0000 0000 0000 0000 0000 0000 0000 0000 0000
Total Operating Revenue $5963512 $6143885 $6494778 $7011006 $7133959 $7900142 $8068069 $8459247 $8608249 $8737 $8782 $8810 $8867 $8889 $8886 $8931 $9393266 $9455232 $9476934
Dedicated Taxes $3211585 $2366805 $2343537 $2511691 $2673119 $3097640 $3383498 $3582628 $3525829 $3257508 $3459 $3515 $3568 $3630 $3725 $3812 $3841433 $3880226 $3917215
PMT amp MTA Aid - 0 881784 1588677 1718286 1825824 1825328 1885069 1910947 1970760 1987035 $1965 $2152 $2225 $2295 $2368 $2442 2516095 2594604 2677041
New Funding Sources - 0 - 0 - 0 - 0 - 0 - 0 - 0 - 0 - 0 - 0 $508 $342 $385 $385 $385 $385 385000 385000 385000
StateLocal Taxes 556691 539046 544810 541733 536182 537527 539545 537819 537645 541005 $544 $552 $557 $562 $567 $572 576828 581933 583214
Other Funding Agreements 306594 363823 359489 375369 466625 432617 567391 563616 629855 630218 $701 $753 $671 $708 $758 $758 784755 804901 781159
BampT Operating Surplus Transfer 382565 363092 476059 554903 476575 614210 637553 750717 742909 740144 $702 $721 $782 $801 $789 $707 730476 695303 688833
Dedicated Taxes and StateLocal Subsidies $4457434 $4514550 $5312572 $5701982 $5978325 $6507322 $7013056 $7345727 $7406998 $7155909 $7879 $8035 $8188 $8381 $8592 $8676 $8834588 $8941967 $9032462
$0000 $0000 $0000 $0000 $0000 $0000 $0000 $0000 $0000
Less Interagency Subsidy and Surplus Transfers (382565) (363092) (476059) (554903) (476575) (614210) (637553) (750717) (742909) (740144) ($702) ($721) ($782) ($801) ($789) ($707) (730476) (695303) (688833)
Total Subsidies $4074870 $4151458 $4836513 $5147079 $5501750 $5893111 $6375503 $6595010 $6664088 $6416 $7242 $7238 $7370 $7576 $7807 $7969 $8104112 $8246664 $8343629
Dedicated Taxes as a of Total Revenues + Subs - PMT 320 251 241 241 247 259 269 273 265 247 $0 $0 $0 $0 $0 $0 256 257 259
Total Revenues + Subsidies $10038382 $10295342 $11331292 $12158085 $12635709 $13793254 $14443571 $15054257 $15272337 $15152 $16023 $16048 $16237 $16465 $16693 $16900 $17497378 $17701896 $17820563
Operating Expenses
Labor Expenses
Payroll $4087376 $4163330 $4171374 $4160261 $4193658 $4332829 $4671664 $4695823 $4838741 $5020713 $5211 $5328 $5422 $5498 $5624 $5710 $5860206 $5982960 $6107107
Overtime 471675 499307 443227 538647 574316 620701 730200 755071 771495 934100 $1066 $910 $838 $859 $877 $899 917296 935002 951324
Health amp Welfare 684945 688899 738189 809638 812857 895714 961902 1050100 1172304 1208786 $1230 $1341 $1414 $1489 $1583 $1674 1797938 1922668 2071273
OPEB Current Payment 318501 346316 355716 394218 413164 472619 479079 501716 562233 563754 $604 $645 $704 $766 $835 $910 982025 1060022 1142795
Pensions 897450 1021229 1029710 1074598 1328441 1301975 1304355 1248726 1370474 1345308 $1336 $1494 $1461 $1462 $1403 $1347 1357887 1369071 1380572
Other-Fringe Benefits 502739 517194 539996 581661 650430 694680 784143 861079 947870 792151 $881 $869 $897 $930 $956 $976 1001185 1021007 1040170
Reimbursable Overhead (310555) (322230) (345154) (324006) (309399) (321390) (349770) (380212) (423759) (491807) ($528) ($471) ($430) ($412) ($397) ($395) (396136) (405509) (413165)
Labor Expenses $6652131 $6914045 $6933059 $7235017 $7663467 $7997128 $8581574 $8732302 $9239358 $9373 $9920 $10039 $10436 $10787 $11097 $11413 $11520401 $11885220 $12280075
PayrollOvertime Exp as a of Total Operating+DS $0426 $0427 $0407 $0396 $0387 $0374 $0389 $0383 $0376 $0385 $0349 $0347 $0345
Labor Exp (wo Reimb OH) as a of Total Oper+DS $0650 $0663 $0642 $0637 $0647 $0628 $0643 $0640 $0648 $0638 $0614 $0617 $0620
PayrollOvertime Exp as a of Total Operating Exp $0496 $0490 $0483 $0473 $0465 $0453 $0464 $0459 $0450 $0461 $0426 $0420 $0416
Labor Exp (wo Reimb OH) as a of Total Oper Exp $0758 $0761 $0762 $0761 $0777 $0761 $0768 $0768 $0776 $0763 $0748 $0747 $0747
Non-Labor Expenses
Electric Power $306500 $317934 $325137 $457269 $471514 $493346 $515540 $473762 $406372 $430381 $474918 $451304 $463523 $482662 $539624 $571182 $589565 $618283 $648255
Traction Power
Non-Traction Power
Fuel 287033 180294 189942 282735 251763 259252 267494 162283 124684 150481 185580 190348 187592 183168 181484 182259 182476 184281 186170
Revenue Vehicle Fuel
Non-Revenue Fuel
Insurance 28902 34012 9819 14363 7617 38654 50739 57190 (20634) (2715) 11488 8532 15803 22918 29411 36048 28232 25538 19483
Claims 152114 238104 285418 315547 135652 299875 269167 331023 463959 526053 376480 378570 386981 391333 395228 404397 417667 428660 437683
Paratransit Service Contracts 299013 370094 379761 348553 360500 366751 365599 379271 383704 392850 452190 482751 501230 518038 547829 581114 604766 643217 684112
Maintenance and Other Operating Contracts 594215 562456 541716 451137 451766 496743 549018 579289 630924 695251 779331 897801 833038 883805 871671 879468 880053 898882 915477
Professional Service Contracts 196930 199164 203084 226205 276998 297201 283005 379814 399706 507062 575742 557476 484911 479376 489510 499724 520826 537109 547291
Materials amp Supplies 532534 526191 511206 438310 430804 475127 526725 543225 585607 588115 667700 686666 687745 692131 697268 711988 741335 777460 793419
Other Business Expenses 155466 184142 189637 169857 143807 167198 179701 195598 192576 217254 225494 230595 225293 240279 242193 244907 228861 240258 241690
Non-Labor Expenses $2552708 $2612391 $2635720 $2703976 $2530421 $2894147 $3006988 $3101454 $3166897 3505 3749 3884 3786 3894 3994 4111 $4193782 $4353689 $4473580
Other Expense Adjustments
Other ($13712) ($14750) ($18292) ($2289) $62593 $46175 $44973 $37007 $47404 49 134 158 84 36 22 23 $23516 $24069 $24637
General Reserve 0000 0000 0000 0000 0000 - 0 - 0 - 0 - 0 0 0 165 170 175 180 185 190000 195000 205000
Other Expense Adjustments ($13712) ($14750) ($18292) ($2289) $62593 $46175 $44973 $37007 $47404 $49379 $134 $323 $254 $211 $202 $208 $213516 $219069 $229637
Gap Closing Expenses $7675394
Additional Actions for Budget Balance Expense Impact $0000 $0000 $0000 $0000 $0000 $0000 $0000 $0000 $0000 $0000 $0000 $0000 $0000 $0000 $0000 $0000 $0000 $0000 $0000
Total Operating Expenses Before Non-Cash Liability Adjs $9191127 $9511685 $9550486 $9936705 $10256481 $10937450 $11633535 $11870763 $12453659 $12927116 $13802910 $14246122 $14475644 $14891445 $15293262 $15732241 $15927699 $16457978 $16983292
Non-Cash Liability Adjustments
Depreciation $1790981 $1940576 $1980681 $2019378 $2148820 $2174302 $2266280 $2442777 $2442941 $2607970 $2804571 $2784812 $2842737 $2908533 $2977025 $3051834 $3109882 $3169371 $3230301
OPEB Obligation 1348962 1104827 1167070 1706939 1785881 1920189 2035457 1489656 1562261 1567381 0000 (0000) (0000) (0000) (0000) 0000 0000 (0000) (0000)
GASB 75 OPEB Expense Adjustment 0000 0000 0000 0000 0000 0000 0000 0000 0000 0000 1047747 1457230 1628196 1748560 1823313 1898497 1952374 2006482 2061993
GASB 68 Pension Expense Adjustment 0000 0000 0000 0000 0000 0000 0000 (410019) (218911) (168119) (373022) (220864) (271921) (342847) (318372) (242446) (237864) (234492) (230942)
Environmental Remediation 42249 6062 18621 59079 24742 14257 20556 20576 11691 13468 105615 6000 6000 6000 6000 6000 6000 6000 6000
Non-Cash Liability Adjustments $3182192 $3051466 $3166371 $3785396 $3959443 $4108749 $4322293 $3542990 $3797981 $4020699 $3584911 $4027178 $4205012 $4320246 $4487966 $4713886 $4830392 $4947361 $5067352
Total Operating Expenses After Non-Cash Liability Adjs $12373319 $12563151 $12716857 $13722101 $14215924 $15046199 $15955827 $15413753 $16251641 $16947815 $17387821 $18273301 $18680657 $19211690 $19781228 $20446127 $20758090 $21405338 $22050644
Less BampT Depreciation $77213 $80097 $77846 $86545 $87926 $91345 $104039 $109783 $135035 $240957 $148686 $151977 $158779 $169848 $181689 $194355 $194355 $194355 $194355
BampT Other Post Employment Benefits 66323 50967 54831 66686 73055 76641 71148 62457 60441 78106 32297 22256 20303 22870 28694 33918 36169 38411 40604
Net Operating Deficit Before Subsidies and Debt Service ($6409807) ($6419266) ($6222079) ($6711095) ($7081966) ($7146057) ($7887759) ($6954506) ($7643392) ($8211234) ($8606220) ($9463506) ($9813560) ($10322912) ($10895644) ($11515498) ($11364824) ($11950106) ($12573710)
Conversion to Cash Basis Non-Cash Liability Adjs ($3182192) ($3051466) ($3166371) ($3785396) ($3959443) ($4108749) ($4322293) ($3542990) ($3797981) ($4020699) ($3584911) ($4027178) ($4205012) ($4320246) ($4487966) ($4713886) ($4830392) ($4947361) ($5067352)
Total Operating Expenses $9191127 $9511685 $9550486 $9936705 $10256481 $10937450 $11633535 $11870763 $12453659 $12927 $13803 $14246 $14476 $14891 $15293 $15732 $15927699 $16457978 $16983292
Debt Service Expenses $1515733 $1404454 $1781220 $1933532 $2058395 $2299262 $2248538 $2373321 $2458783 $2525 $2559 $2692 $2840 $3080 $3223 $3450 $3471321 $3472987 $3501639
Total Expenses + Debt Service $10706859 $10916139 $11331706 $11870237 $12314876 $13236712 $13882073 $14244084 $14912443 $15452 $16362 $16938 $17316 $17971 $18516 $19182 $19399019 $19930965 $20484932
Net Deficit After Subsidies and Debt Service ($668477) ($620796) ($0414) $287848 $320833 $556541 $561498 $810173 $359895 ($299965) ($339) ($890) ($1079) ($1506) ($1823) ($2283) ($1901641) ($2229069) ($2664369)
Conversion to Cash Basis GASB Account (56067) (54256) (67377) (37636) (89548) (85641) (50017) - 0 - 0 0 0 0 $0 0 0 - 0 - 0 - 0 - 0
Conversion to Cash Basis 492710 550267 91781 (111037) (297407) (261709) (626297) (660147) (591809) 174 296 363 188 (17) 88 130 49745 48375 54220
Net Cash Balance from Previous Year 0000 0000 0000 23990 139174 0000 209191 0000 150026 0000 0000 0000 0000 0000 0000 0000 0000 0000 0000
Total Operating Exp + DS + Cash Conversions + PY C-O $11144 $11412 $11356 $11746 $12067 $12889362 $13414950 $13583937 $14470659 $15625875 $16658585 $17300293 $17504155 $17954574 $18604130 $19312017 $19448764 $19979340 $20539152
Total Operating Expenses with Cash Conversion $10270216 $10420127 $11307302 $12018911 $12701831 $13584063 $14558387 $14904231 $15504252 $15278749 $16065734 $16575223 $17128079 $17987951 $18427778 $19052755 $19349274 $19882590 $20430711
Baseline Net Cash Balance Before B-T-L Adjustments ($231834) ($124785) $23990 $139174 ($66122) $209191 ($114816) $150026 ($231914) ($126) ($43) ($527) ($891) ($1523) ($1735) ($2153) ($1851896) ($2180695) ($2610148)
Below-the-Line Adjustments
FareToll Increases
FareToll Increase in March 2019 (4 Yield) - 0 $0 $0 $0 $0 $0 $0 - 0 - 0 - 0
FareToll Increase in March 2021 (4 Yield) - 0 $0 $0 $0 $283 $331 $332 333531 333568 334299
FareToll Increase in March 2023 (4 Yield) - 0 $0 $0 $0 $0 $0 $294 346386 346424 347183
FareToll Increase in March 2025 (4 Yield) - 0 $0 $0 $0 $0 $0 $0 - 0 273859 321624
Subsidy Impacts of 20212023 FareToll Increase - 0 $0 $0 $0 ($7) ($9) ($17) (18612) (25573) (26305)
$0000 $0 $0 $0 $275 $322 $609 $661306 $928278 $976801
CASH BALANCE AFTER FARE INCREASES ($126402) ($43) ($527) ($891) ($1241) ($1404) ($1821) ($1518365) ($1847127) ($2275849)
MTA Initiatives
MTA Efficiencies - Not Yet Implemented - 0 $0 $0 $0 $0 $0 $0 0000 0000 0000
0 - 0 $0 $0 $0 $0 $0 $0 - 0 - 0 - 0
0 - 0 $0 $0 $0 $0 $0 $0 - 0 - 0 - 0
$0000 $0 $0 $0 $0 $0 $0 $0000 $0000 $0000
Policy Actions
CAS Migration to Peoplesoft $0 $0 ($5) ($1) ($0) ($0) (0200) -02 -02 0
Fare Evasion Enforcement Strategy-Expenses $0 ($13) ($12) ($11) ($10) ($10) (9554) -9554483 -9554483 0
Fare Evasion Enforcement-Manhattan DA Forfeiture Fund $0 $11 $11 $10 $9 $0 - 0 0 0 0
Negotiated 1 CBA Reform $0 $0 $0 $0 $0 $0 - 0 0 0 0
MTA Reorganization $0 $8 $180 $371 $377 $377 377000 377 377 0
MTA Reorganization Costs $0 $0 ($10) ($27) ($2) $0 - 0 0 0 0
Drawdown 2019 General Reserve $0 $0 $165 $0 $0 $0 - 0 0 0 0
CBA Negotiated Reform - 1 Value $0 $36 $100 $173 $246 $323 323473 323473304484 323473304484 0
$0000 $0 $42 $429 $515 $620 $691 $690719 $690719 $690719
MTA Re-estimates
Additional Savings Actions $0000 $0 $0 $0 $0 $0 $0 $0000 $0000 $0000
Total Below-the-Line Adjustments $0 $0 $459 $413 $709 $760 $1007 $1352025 $1618997 $1667520
Prior Year Carryover 495399 263336 138286 161986 301160 235038 444229 329413 479439 248 121 79 11 0 0 - 0 - 0 - 0 - 0
NET CASH BALANCE $263566 $138551 $162276 $301160 $235038 $444229 $329413 $479439 $247525 $121 $79 $11 ($467) ($814) ($976) ($1146) ($499871) ($561698) ($942628)
By Revenue Source
(includes faretoll increases)
($ in millions)
Farebox Revenue $6389
Toll Revenue 2121
Other Revenue 684
Dedicated Taxes 6191
State and Local amp Other 1228
Timing (Cash Adjustments) 135
Total $16748
By Expense Category
(includes below-the-line adjustments)
($ in millions)
Payroll $5422
Overtime 838
Health amp Welfare 2118
Pension 1461
Other Labor 466
Total Labor $10306
Non-Labor + Other Exp Adj 4004
Debt Service 2830
BTL Adjustments for Expenses 2 (386)
Total $16754
By Revenue Source
(includes faretoll increases)
($ in millions)
Farebox Revenue $6389
Toll Revenue 2121
Other Revenue 684
Taxes 6178
State and Local amp Other 557
Other Funding Agreements 671
Other 1 208
Total $16809
By Expense Category
(includes below-the-line adjustments)
($ in millions)
Payroll $5392
Overtime 811
Health amp Welfare 2129
Pension 1354
Other Labor 400
Total Labor $10086
Non-Labor 4205
Debt Service 2692
BTL Adjustments for Expenses (251)
Total $16732
Page 5: MTA 2020 Preliminary Budget July Financial Plan 2020 - 2023 2020 Preliminar… · 1 The MTA Budget Process July Plan – Start of the Annual Process • Current year is revised (the

What has changed since the February Plan

Changes and re-estimates over the Plan period (2019 ndash 2022)bull Changes and re-estimates improving financial results

bull Higher MMTOA subsidies ($184 million)bull Higher yield from additional 23 in tolls ($173 million)bull Lower maintenanceother operating contracts ($173 million)bull Higher MTA Aid car rental tax ($35 million)

bull Changes and re-estimates worsening financial resultsbull Actuary recalculation of pension liability ($550 million)bull Agency re-estimates and rate change adjustments ($189 million)bull Higher overtime expenses ($131 million)bull Lower rentaladvertising revenues ($83 million)bull Lower real estate tax revenues ($59 million)

In total these changes and re-estimates along with other changes are $447 million unfavorable for the Plan period

4

Highlights of the July Plan

bull Proposed biennial fare and toll increases of 4 in 2021 and 2023 (versus projected 2-year CPI inflators of 49 and 47 in 2021 and 2023 respectively)

bull Maintained investments from prior plans including maintenance of the Subway Action Plan funded from Phase 1 of Congestion PricingFHV fees

bull Renewed emphasis to gain control of and reduce fare evasion (investment of $62 million over the Plan period)

bull MTA is using ldquoone-shotsrdquo to balance the budget in the transition years 2019 and 2020

o 2019 - 2018 favorable year-end balance ndash mostly timing ndash and impacts 2019 ($372 million)

- Freeze on filling all non-operationalnon-essential vacancies ($68 million)

- Other restrictions on non-essential spending including non-revenue vehicle purchases travelprofessional memberships ($44 million)

- One-time reduction of committed to capital contributions ($64 million)

o 2020 - Drawdown of 2019 General Reserve ($165 million)

bull Annual recurring savings targets of $350 million beginning in 2020 have been identified by HQ and Agencies

5

6

These actions will not suffice and significant deficits remain($ in millions)

This Year Next Year Out-Years

11

(467)

(814)

(976)

NA

50

(186)

(569)

(816)

(971)

($1200)

($1000)

($800)

($600)

($400)

($200)

$0

$200

2019 2020 2021 2022 2023

February PlanJuly Plan without Transformation Plan Savings

MTA Transformation Plan

bull State-mandated plan to review operations and implement changes to streamline internal processes clarify responsibilities solidify accountability and work more efficiently to regain trust of our customers and funding partners and improve MTArsquos ability to deliver safe and reliable service our customers deserve

bull Plan recommendationsbull Refocus the operating agencies on mission-critical operating priorities of safety reliability and

servicebull Centralize common support functions to improve operations and create opportunities to ensure

consistent standards quality and policies across departmentsbull Unify the management of capital programs to improve and streamline planning development

and construction so capital improvements can be delivered on time and on budgetbull Expand senior leadership by adding a Chief Transformation Officer a Chief Operating Officer a

Chief Engineering Officer and an MTA Accessibility Officer

bull Consolidation and efficiency targets of $370 million to $530 million on an annual basis have been identified

bull If the MTA Transformation Plan is approved and implemented the July Financial Plan will have small operating balances in 2019 and 2020 a small deficit in 2021 with out-year deficits reaching $433 million in 2023

7

8

The adoption and implementation of the MTA Transformation Planhas the potential to significantly reduce out-year deficits

($ in millions)

This Year Next Year Out-Years

11

(467)

(814)

(976)

NA

61 55

(26)

(281)

(433)

($1200)

($1000)

($800)

($600)

($400)

($200)

$0

$200

2019 2020 2021 2022 2023

February PlanProposed July Plan

Actions to Reduce Fare Evasion $62 million Investment over the Plan Period

bull Increase physical presence (500 uniformed officers NYPD MTA Police and Bridge and Tunnel Officers) to begin enforcement at 50 subway stations and 50 bus routesThis is not just a fare evasion effort but a workerrsquos safety initiative

bull Ensure enforcement does not target any specific demographic bull Educate MTA riders utilizing messaging media and automated

announcementsbull Improve operation of emergency exit gates to mitigate instances of fare

avoidancebull Augment surveillance capabilities by deploying fare array cameras at 50

stations and pilot the use of monitors at 10 stationsbull $40 million of the investment will be funded by Manhattan DA Office over a

four-year period

9

The MTArsquos $350 million target for annually recurring savings beginning in 2020 has been identified and is being implemented

109

10 7 6 6

96 304 351 362 371

$0

$50

$100

$150

$200

$250

$300

$350

$400

2019 2020 2021 2022 2023

Identified Recurring Savings One-Shot Savings

This Year Next Year Out-Years

($ in millions)

10

We have a track record of identifying and achieving our annual recurring savings targets

11

($ in millions)

$0

$500

$1000

$1500

$2000

$2500

$3000

Achieved Savings

2012 November Plan

2013 November Plan

2014 November Plan

2015 November Plan

2016 November Plan

2017 November Plan

2018 November Plan

2019 July Plan

$28 billion

Proposed July Plan

Deficits remain and a continued drive toward further streamlining and efficiencies is required

12

($ in millions)

61 55

(26)

(281)

(433)

($600)

($500)

($400)

($300)

($200)

($100)

$0

$100

$200

2019 2020 2021 2022 2023

This Year Next Year Out-Years

Proposed July PlanDonrsquot achieve Transformation Plan Savings

13

If the MTA Transformation Plan is not adopted and implemented the deficits will be unmanageable without service cuts significant

reductions in force andor additional fare and toll increases($ in millions)

($1100)

($900)

($700)

($500)

($300)

($100)

$100

2019 2020 2021 2022 2023

(816)

(971)

(569)

(81)

(433)

(281)

61 55 (26)

(281) (186)

50

Next Year Out-Years

(230)(11)

(488)

(538)

(535)

This Year

14

2020 Preliminary BudgetWhere the Dollars Come Fromhellip Where the Dollars Gohellip

Farebox Revenue $6389Toll Revenue 2121 Other Revenue 684 Taxes 6178 State and Local amp Other 557 Other Funding Agreements 671 Other 1 208 Total $16809

($ in millions)

By Revenue Source(includes faretoll increases)

Payroll $5422Overtime 838 Health amp Welfare 2118 Pension 1461 Other Labor 466 Total Labor $10306Non-Labor + Other Exp Adj 4004 Debt Service 2830 BTL Adjustments for Expenses 2 (386) Total $16754

By Expense Category

($ in millions)(includes below-the-line adjustments)

1 Includes cash adjustments and prior-year carryover

Farebox Revenue

38

Toll Revenue

13

Other Revenue4

Taxes37

State amp Local

Subsidies3

Other Funding Agreements

4 Other 1

Payroll32

Overtime5

Health ampWelfare

13Pension

9

Other Labor3

Non-Labor + Other Exp Adj

21

Debt Service17

2 The below-the-line adjustments are grouped in the Non-Labor category

Sheet1

Sheet1

15

Non-Reimbursable Mid-Year Preliminary Actual Forecast Budget

2018 2019 2020 2021 2022 2023 Operating Revenues

Farebox Revenue $6155 $6305 $6389 $6373 $6384 $6393Toll Revenue 1976 2088 2121 2129 2129 2131 Other Revenue 643 696 684 704 719 737

Total Operating Revenue $8774 $9089 $9195 $9206 $9232 $9260

Total Subsidies $7177 $7314 $7406 $7581 $7803 $7969Dedicated Taxes as a of Total Revenues + Subs - PMT 233 $0 $0 $0 $0 $0

Total Revenues + Subsidies $15951 $16403 $16601 $16787 $17035 $17229

Operating ExpensesLabor Expenses $9799 $10116 $10306 $10592 $10881 $11121Non-Labor Expenses 3611 3877 3748 3841 3945 4054 Other 129 175 86 36 22 23 General Reserve 0 165 170 175 180 185

Total Operating Expenses $13539 $14333 $14310 $14644 $15028 $15384

Debt Service Expenses $2541 $2683 $2830 $3041 $3265 $3513

Total Expenses + Debt Service $16079 $17016 $17140 $17685 $18293 $18896

Conversion to Cash Basis 379 229 147 60 125 101

Baseline Net Cash Balance Before B-T-L Adjustments $251 ($384) ($392) ($838) ($1133) ($1566)

Total Below-the-Line Adjustments $0 $73 $386 $757 $852 $1133Prior Year Carryover 121 372 61 55 0 0

NET CASH BALANCE $372 $61 $55 ($26) ($281) ($433)

MTA July Financial Plan 2020-2023Consolidated Statement Of Operations By Category ($ in millions)

Summ Stmt of Ops-Feb

Summ Stmt of Ops-Jul

  • MTA 2020Preliminary BudgetJuly Financial Plan2020 - 2023
  • The MTA Budget Process
  • Slide Number 3
  • Slide Number 4
  • What has changed since the February Plan
  • Highlights of the July Plan
  • Slide Number 7
  • MTA Transformation Plan
  • Slide Number 9
  • Actions to Reduce Fare Evasion $62 million Investment over the Plan Period
  • The MTArsquos $350 million target for annually recurring savings beginning in 2020 has been identified and is being implemented
  • We have a track record of identifying and achieving our annual recurring savings targets
  • Deficits remain and a continued drive toward further streamlining and efficiencies is required
  • Slide Number 14
  • 2020 Preliminary Budget
  • Slide Number 16
MTA July Financial Plan 2020-2023
Consolidated Statement Of Operations By Category ($ in millions)
Non-Reimbursable Mid-Year Preliminary
Actual Actual Actual Actual Actual Actual Actual Actual Actual Actual Forecast Budget
2008 2009 2010 2011 2012 2013 2014 2015 2016 2018 2019 2020 2021 2022 2023 2023 2024 2025 2026
Operating Revenues
Farebox Revenue $4240923 $4350411 $4586377 $4999186 $5079138 $5501274 $5709200 $5961129 $6050182 $6155 $6305 $6389 $6373 $6384 $6393 $6174 $6435176 $6431979 $6446633
422 423 405 411 402 399 395 396 396 386 384 385 380 375 371 261 368 363 362
Student Fare - 0 - 0 - 0 - 0 - 0 - 0
Toll Revenue 1273974 1332115 1417046 1501589 1490982 1645193 1676445 1808901 1869693 1976 2088 2121 2129 2129 2131 2002 2133050 2137871 2143111
0127 0129 0125 0124 0118 0119 0116 0120 0122 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0122 0121 0120
Other Revenue 448616 461359 491355 510231 563839 753675 682424 689217 688374 643 696 684 704 719 737 755 825040 885381 887190
Capital and Other Reimbursements 0000 0000 0000 0000 0000 0000 0000 0000 0000 0000 0000 0000 0000 0000 0000 0000 0000 0000 0000
Total Operating Revenue $5963512 $6143885 $6494778 $7011006 $7133959 $7900142 $8068069 $8459247 $8608249 $8774 $9089 $9195 $9206 $9232 $9260 $8931 $9393266 $9455232 $9476934
Dedicated Taxes $3211585 $2366805 $2343537 $2511691 $2673119 $3097640 $3383498 $3582628 $3525829 $3257508 $3459 $3515 $3568 $3630 $3725 $3812 $3841433 $3880226 $3917215
PMT amp MTA Aid - 0 881784 1588677 1718286 1825824 1825328 1885069 1910947 1970760 1987035 $1965 $2152 $2225 $2295 $2368 $2442 2516095 2594604 2677041
New Funding Sources - 0 - 0 - 0 - 0 - 0 - 0 - 0 - 0 - 0 - 0 $508 $342 $385 $385 $385 $385 385000 385000 385000
StateLocal Taxes 556691 539046 544810 541733 536182 537527 539545 537819 537645 541005 $544 $552 $557 $562 $567 $572 576828 581933 583214
Other Funding Agreements 306594 363823 359489 375369 466625 432617 567391 563616 629855 630218 $701 $753 $671 $708 $758 $758 784755 804901 781159
BampT Operating Surplus Transfer 382565 363092 476059 554903 476575 614210 637553 750717 742909 740144 $702 $721 $782 $801 $789 $707 730476 695303 688833
Dedicated Taxes and StateLocal Subsidies $4457434 $4514550 $5312572 $5701982 $5978325 $6507322 $7013056 $7345727 $7406998 $7155909 $7879 $8035 $8188 $8381 $8592 $8676 $8834588 $8941967 $9032462
$0000 $0000 $0000 $0000 $0000 $0000 $0000 $0000 $0000
Less Interagency Subsidy and Surplus Transfers (382565) (363092) (476059) (554903) (476575) (614210) (637553) (750717) (742909) (740144) ($702) ($721) ($782) ($801) ($789) ($707) (730476) (695303) (688833)
Total Subsidies $4074870 $4151458 $4836513 $5147079 $5501750 $5893111 $6375503 $6595010 $6664088 $7177 $7314 $7406 $7581 $7803 $7969 $7969 $8104112 $8246664 $8343629
Dedicated Taxes as a of Total Revenues + Subs - PMT 320 251 241 241 247 259 269 273 265 233 $0 $0 $0 $0 $0 $0 256 257 259
Total Revenues + Subsidies $10038382 $10295342 $11331292 $12158085 $12635709 $13793254 $14443571 $15054257 $15272337 $15951 $16403 $16601 $16787 $17035 $17229 $16900 $17497378 $17701896 $17820563
Operating Expenses
Labor Expenses
Payroll $4087376 $4163330 $4171374 $4160261 $4193658 $4332829 $4671664 $4695823 $4838741 $5020713 $5211 $5328 $5422 $5498 $5624 $5710 $5860206 $5982960 $6107107
Overtime 471675 499307 443227 538647 574316 620701 730200 755071 771495 934100 $1066 $910 $838 $859 $877 $899 917296 935002 951324
Health amp Welfare 684945 688899 738189 809638 812857 895714 961902 1050100 1172304 1208786 $1230 $1341 $1414 $1489 $1583 $1674 1797938 1922668 2071273
OPEB Current Payment 318501 346316 355716 394218 413164 472619 479079 501716 562233 563754 $604 $645 $704 $766 $835 $910 982025 1060022 1142795
Pensions 897450 1021229 1029710 1074598 1328441 1301975 1304355 1248726 1370474 1345308 $1336 $1494 $1461 $1462 $1403 $1347 1357887 1369071 1380572
Other-Fringe Benefits 502739 517194 539996 581661 650430 694680 784143 861079 947870 792151 $881 $869 $897 $930 $956 $976 1001185 1021007 1040170
Reimbursable Overhead (310555) (322230) (345154) (324006) (309399) (321390) (349770) (380212) (423759) (491807) ($528) ($471) ($430) ($412) ($397) ($395) (396136) (405509) (413165)
Labor Expenses $6652131 $6914045 $6933059 $7235017 $7663467 $7997128 $8581574 $8732302 $9239358 $9799 $10116 $10306 $10592 $10881 $11121 $11413 $11520401 $11885220 $12280075
PayrollOvertime Exp as a of Total Operating+DS $0426 $0427 $0407 $0396 $0387 $0374 $0389 $0383 $0376 $0390 $0367 $0365 $0359 $0355 $0350 $0349 $0347 $0345
Labor Exp (wo Reimb OH) as a of Total Oper+DS $0650 $0663 $0642 $0637 $0647 $0628 $0643 $0640 $0648 $0642 $0622 $0626 $0622 $0616 $0609 $0614 $0617 $0620
PayrollOvertime Exp as a of Total Operating Exp $0496 $0490 $0483 $0473 $0465 $0453 $0464 $0459 $0450 $0464 $0435 $0438 $0434 $0433 $0430 $0426 $0420 $0416
Labor Exp (wo Reimb OH) as a of Total Oper Exp $0758 $0761 $0762 $0761 $0777 $0761 $0768 $0768 $0776 $0763 $0739 $0750 $0751 $0750 $0749 $0748 $0747 $0747
Non-Labor Expenses
Electric Power $306500 $317934 $325137 $457269 $471514 $493346 $515540 $473762 $406372 $481893 $451503 $473177 $493090 $532413 $561955 $571182 $589565 $618283 $648255
Traction Power
Non-Traction Power
Fuel 287033 180294 189942 282735 251763 259252 267494 162283 124684 185203 182778 182981 176333 173681 176920 182259 182476 184281 186170
Revenue Vehicle Fuel
Non-Revenue Fuel
Insurance 28902 34012 9819 14363 7617 38654 50739 57190 (20634) (29402) 5608 15623 23118 26855 28309 36048 28232 25538 19483
Claims 152114 238104 285418 315547 135652 299875 269167 331023 463959 437985 387557 394211 392547 398256 406112 404397 417667 428660 437683
Paratransit Service Contracts 299013 370094 379761 348553 360500 366751 365599 379271 383704 455471 494751 488330 505538 535329 568614 581114 604766 643217 684112
Maintenance and Other Operating Contracts 594215 562456 541716 451137 451766 496743 549018 579289 630924 678425 840168 797428 833534 836606 854471 879468 880053 898882 915477
Professional Service Contracts 196930 199164 203084 226205 276998 297201 283005 379814 399706 543582 607838 502858 494814 504103 513895 499724 520826 537109 547291
Materials amp Supplies 532534 526191 511206 438310 430804 475127 526725 543225 585607 637078 689010 679895 697976 711281 715758 711988 741335 777460 793419
Other Business Expenses 155466 184142 189637 169857 143807 167198 179701 195598 192576 220838 218196 213551 224459 226170 228457 244907 228861 240258 241690
Non-Labor Expenses $2552708 $2612391 $2635720 $2703976 $2530421 $2894147 $3006988 $3101454 $3166897 3611 3877 3748 3841 3945 4054 4111 $4193782 $4353689 $4473580
Other Expense Adjustments
Other ($13712) ($14750) ($18292) ($2289) $62593 $46175 $44973 $37007 $47404 129 175 86 36 22 23 23 $23516 $24069 $24637
General Reserve 0000 0000 0000 0000 0000 - 0 - 0 - 0 - 0 0 165 170 175 180 185 185 190000 195000 205000
Other Expense Adjustments ($13712) ($14750) ($18292) ($2289) $62593 $46175 $44973 $37007 $47404 $128555 $340 $256 $211 $202 $208 $208 $213516 $219069 $229637
Gap Closing Expenses $7675394
Additional Actions for Budget Balance Expense Impact $0000 $0000 $0000 $0000 $0000 $0000 $0000 $0000 $0000 $0000 $0000 $0000 $0000 $0000 $0000 $0000 $0000 $0000 $0000
Total Operating Expenses Before Non-Cash Liability Adjs $9191127 $9511685 $9550486 $9936705 $10256481 $10937450 $11633535 $11870763 $12453659 $13538830 $14332772 $14309678 $14643965 $15027767 $15383584 $15732241 $15927699 $16457978 $16983292
Non-Cash Liability Adjustments
Depreciation $1790981 $1940576 $1980681 $2019378 $2148820 $2174302 $2266280 $2442777 $2442941 $2607970 $2804571 $2784812 $2842737 $2908533 $2977025 $3051834 $3109882 $3169371 $3230301
OPEB Obligation 1348962 1104827 1167070 1706939 1785881 1920189 2035457 1489656 1562261 1567381 0000 (0000) (0000) (0000) (0000) 0000 0000 (0000) (0000)
GASB 75 OPEB Expense Adjustment 0000 0000 0000 0000 0000 0000 0000 0000 0000 0000 1047747 1457230 1628196 1748560 1823313 1898497 1952374 2006482 2061993
GASB 68 Pension Expense Adjustment 0000 0000 0000 0000 0000 0000 0000 (410019) (218911) (168119) (373022) (220864) (271921) (342847) (318372) (242446) (237864) (234492) (230942)
Environmental Remediation 42249 6062 18621 59079 24742 14257 20556 20576 11691 13468 105615 6000 6000 6000 6000 6000 6000 6000 6000
Non-Cash Liability Adjustments $3182192 $3051466 $3166371 $3785396 $3959443 $4108749 $4322293 $3542990 $3797981 $4020699 $3584911 $4027178 $4205012 $4320246 $4487966 $4713886 $4830392 $4947361 $5067352
Total Operating Expenses After Non-Cash Liability Adjs $12373319 $12563151 $12716857 $13722101 $14215924 $15046199 $15955827 $15413753 $16251641 $17559529 $17917683 $18336856 $18848977 $19348013 $19871550 $20446127 $20758090 $21405338 $22050644
Less BampT Depreciation $77213 $80097 $77846 $86545 $87926 $91345 $104039 $109783 $135035 $240957 $148686 $151977 $158779 $169848 $181689 $194355 $194355 $194355 $194355
BampT Other Post Employment Benefits 66323 50967 54831 66686 73055 76641 71148 62457 60441 78106 32297 22256 20303 22870 28694 33918 36169 38411 40604
Net Operating Deficit Before Subsidies and Debt Service ($6409807) ($6419266) ($6222079) ($6711095) ($7081966) ($7146057) ($7887759) ($6954506) ($7643392) ($8785339) ($8829030) ($9141907) ($9642826) ($10116260) ($10611154) ($11515498) ($11364824) ($11950106) ($12573710)
Conversion to Cash Basis Non-Cash Liability Adjs ($3182192) ($3051466) ($3166371) ($3785396) ($3959443) ($4108749) ($4322293) ($3542990) ($3797981) ($4020699) ($3584911) ($4027178) ($4205012) ($4320246) ($4487966) ($4713886) ($4830392) ($4947361) ($5067352)
Total Operating Expenses $9191127 $9511685 $9550486 $9936705 $10256481 $10937450 $11633535 $11870763 $12453659 $13539 $14333 $14310 $14644 $15028 $15384 $15732 $15927699 $16457978 $16983292
Debt Service Expenses $1515733 $1404454 $1781220 $1933532 $2058395 $2299262 $2248538 $2373321 $2458783 $2541 $2683 $2830 $3041 $3265 $3513 $3450 $3471321 $3472987 $3501639
Total Expenses + Debt Service $10706859 $10916139 $11331706 $11870237 $12314876 $13236712 $13882073 $14244084 $14912443 $16079 $17016 $17140 $17685 $18293 $18896 $19182 $19399019 $19930965 $20484932
Net Deficit After Subsidies and Debt Service ($668477) ($620796) ($0414) $287848 $320833 $556541 $561498 $810173 $359895 ($128044) ($613) ($539) ($898) ($1258) ($1667) ($2283) ($1901641) ($2229069) ($2664369)
Conversion to Cash Basis GASB Account (56067) (54256) (67377) (37636) (89548) (85641) (50017) - 0 - 0 0 0 0 $0 0 0 - 0 - 0 - 0 - 0
Conversion to Cash Basis 492710 550267 91781 (111037) (297407) (261709) (626297) (660147) (591809) 379 229 147 60 125 101 130 49745 48375 54220
Net Cash Balance from Previous Year 0000 0000 0000 23990 139174 0000 209191 0000 150026 0000 250569 0000 0000 0000 0000 0000 0000 0000 0000
Total Operating Exp + DS + Cash Conversions + PY C-O $11144 $11412 $11356 $11746 $12067 $12889362 $13414950 $13583937 $14470659 $16457999 $17495351 $17286526 $17744425 $18418197 $18997710 $19312017 $19448764 $19979340 $20539152
Total Operating Expenses with Cash Conversion $10270216 $10420127 $11307302 $12018911 $12701831 $13584063 $14558387 $14904231 $15504252 $15700774 $16786574 $16992579 $17624861 $18167420 $18795069 $19052755 $19349274 $19882590 $20430711
Baseline Net Cash Balance Before B-T-L Adjustments ($231834) ($124785) $23990 $139174 ($66122) $209191 ($114816) $150026 ($231914) $251 ($384) ($392) ($838) ($1133) ($1566) ($2153) ($1851896) ($2180695) ($2610148)
Below-the-Line Adjustments
FareToll Increases
FareToll Increase in March 2019 (4 Yield) - 0 $0 $0 $0 $0 $0 $0 - 0 - 0 - 0
FareToll Increase in March 2021 (4 Yield) - 0 $0 $0 $0 $283 $331 $332 333531 333568 334299
FareToll Increase in March 2023 (4 Yield) - 0 $0 $0 $0 $0 $0 $294 346386 346424 347183
FareToll Increase in March 2025 (4 Yield) - 0 $0 $0 $0 $0 $0 $0 - 0 273859 321624
Subsidy Impacts of 20212023 FareToll Increase - 0 $0 $0 $0 ($7) ($9) ($17) (18612) (25573) (26305)
$0000 $0 $0 $0 $275 $322 $609 $661306 $928278 $976801
CASH BALANCE AFTER FARE INCREASES $250569 ($384) ($392) ($838) ($850) ($1234) ($1821) ($1518365) ($1847127) ($2275849)
MTA Initiatives
MTA Efficiencies - Not Yet Implemented - 0 $0 $0 $0 $0 $0 $0 0000 0000 0000
0 - 0 $0 $0 $0 $0 $0 $0 - 0 - 0 - 0
0 - 0 $0 $0 $0 $0 $0 $0 - 0 - 0 - 0
$0000 $0 $0 $0 $0 $0 $0 $0000 $0000 $0000
Policy Actions
CAS Migration to Peoplesoft $0 $0 ($5) ($1) ($0) ($0) (0200) -02 -02 0
Fare Evasion Enforcement Strategy-Expenses $0 ($13) ($12) ($11) ($10) ($10) (9554) -9554483 -9554483 0
Fare Evasion Enforcement-Manhattan DA Forfeiture Fund $0 $11 $11 $10 $9 $0 - 0 0 0 0
Negotiated 1 CBA Reform $0 $0 $0 $0 $0 $0 - 0 0 0 0
MTA Reorganization $0 $8 $180 $371 $377 $377 377000 377 377 0
MTA Reorganization Costs $0 $0 ($10) ($27) ($2) $0 - 0 0 0 0
Drawdown 2019 General Reserve $0 $0 $165 $0 $0 $0 - 0 0 0 0
CBA Negotiated Reform - 1 Value $0 $36 $100 $173 $246 $323 323473 323473304484 323473304484 0
$0000 $0 $42 $429 $515 $620 $691 $690719 $690719 $690719
MTA Re-estimates
Additional Savings Actions $0000 $0 $0 $0 $0 $0 $0 $0000 $0000 $0000
Total Below-the-Line Adjustments $0 $73 $386 $757 $852 $1133 $1007 $1352025 $1618997 $1667520
Prior Year Carryover 495399 263336 138286 161986 301160 235038 444229 329413 479439 121 372 61 55 0 0 - 0 - 0 - 0 - 0
NET CASH BALANCE $263566 $138551 $162276 $301160 $235038 $444229 $329413 $479439 $247525 $372 $61 $55 ($26) ($281) ($433) ($1146) ($499871) ($561698) ($942628)
MTA February Financial Plan 2019-2022
Consolidated Statement Of Operations By Category ($ in millions)
Non-Reimbursable Final Adopted
Actual Actual Actual Actual Actual Actual Actual Actual Actual Actual Estimate Budget
2008 2009 2010 2011 2012 2013 2014 2015 2016 2017 2018 2019 2020 2021 2022 2023 2024 2025 2026
Operating Revenues
Farebox Revenue $4240923 $4350411 $4586377 $4999186 $5079138 $5501274 $5709200 $5961129 $6050182 $6172 $6153 $6122 $6144 $6134 $6144 $6174 $6435176 $6431979 $6446633
422 423 405 411 402 399 395 396 396 407 279 275 272 267 263 261 368 363 362
Student Fare - 0 - 0 - 0 - 0 - 0 - 0
Toll Revenue 1273974 1332115 1417046 1501589 1490982 1645193 1676445 1808901 1869693 1912 1967 1984 1990 1998 1998 2002 2133050 2137871 2143111
0127 0129 0125 0124 0118 0119 0116 0120 0122 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0122 0121 0120
Other Revenue 448616 461359 491355 510231 563839 753675 682424 689217 688374 653 662 705 733 757 743 755 825040 885381 887190
Capital and Other Reimbursements 0000 0000 0000 0000 0000 0000 0000 0000 0000 0000 0000 0000 0000 0000 0000 0000 0000 0000 0000
Total Operating Revenue $5963512 $6143885 $6494778 $7011006 $7133959 $7900142 $8068069 $8459247 $8608249 $8737 $8782 $8810 $8867 $8889 $8886 $8931 $9393266 $9455232 $9476934
Dedicated Taxes $3211585 $2366805 $2343537 $2511691 $2673119 $3097640 $3383498 $3582628 $3525829 $3257508 $3459 $3515 $3568 $3630 $3725 $3812 $3841433 $3880226 $3917215
PMT amp MTA Aid - 0 881784 1588677 1718286 1825824 1825328 1885069 1910947 1970760 1987035 $1965 $2152 $2225 $2295 $2368 $2442 2516095 2594604 2677041
New Funding Sources - 0 - 0 - 0 - 0 - 0 - 0 - 0 - 0 - 0 - 0 $508 $342 $385 $385 $385 $385 385000 385000 385000
StateLocal Taxes 556691 539046 544810 541733 536182 537527 539545 537819 537645 541005 $544 $552 $557 $562 $567 $572 576828 581933 583214
Other Funding Agreements 306594 363823 359489 375369 466625 432617 567391 563616 629855 630218 $701 $753 $671 $708 $758 $758 784755 804901 781159
BampT Operating Surplus Transfer 382565 363092 476059 554903 476575 614210 637553 750717 742909 740144 $702 $721 $782 $801 $789 $707 730476 695303 688833
Dedicated Taxes and StateLocal Subsidies $4457434 $4514550 $5312572 $5701982 $5978325 $6507322 $7013056 $7345727 $7406998 $7155909 $7879 $8035 $8188 $8381 $8592 $8676 $8834588 $8941967 $9032462
$0000 $0000 $0000 $0000 $0000 $0000 $0000 $0000 $0000
Less Interagency Subsidy and Surplus Transfers (382565) (363092) (476059) (554903) (476575) (614210) (637553) (750717) (742909) (740144) ($702) ($721) ($782) ($801) ($789) ($707) (730476) (695303) (688833)
Total Subsidies $4074870 $4151458 $4836513 $5147079 $5501750 $5893111 $6375503 $6595010 $6664088 $6416 $7242 $7238 $7370 $7576 $7807 $7969 $8104112 $8246664 $8343629
Dedicated Taxes as a of Total Revenues + Subs - PMT 320 251 241 241 247 259 269 273 265 247 $0 $0 $0 $0 $0 $0 256 257 259
Total Revenues + Subsidies $10038382 $10295342 $11331292 $12158085 $12635709 $13793254 $14443571 $15054257 $15272337 $15152 $16023 $16048 $16237 $16465 $16693 $16900 $17497378 $17701896 $17820563
Operating Expenses
Labor Expenses
Payroll $4087376 $4163330 $4171374 $4160261 $4193658 $4332829 $4671664 $4695823 $4838741 $5020713 $5211 $5328 $5422 $5498 $5624 $5710 $5860206 $5982960 $6107107
Overtime 471675 499307 443227 538647 574316 620701 730200 755071 771495 934100 $1066 $910 $838 $859 $877 $899 917296 935002 951324
Health amp Welfare 684945 688899 738189 809638 812857 895714 961902 1050100 1172304 1208786 $1230 $1341 $1414 $1489 $1583 $1674 1797938 1922668 2071273
OPEB Current Payment 318501 346316 355716 394218 413164 472619 479079 501716 562233 563754 $604 $645 $704 $766 $835 $910 982025 1060022 1142795
Pensions 897450 1021229 1029710 1074598 1328441 1301975 1304355 1248726 1370474 1345308 $1336 $1494 $1461 $1462 $1403 $1347 1357887 1369071 1380572
Other-Fringe Benefits 502739 517194 539996 581661 650430 694680 784143 861079 947870 792151 $881 $869 $897 $930 $956 $976 1001185 1021007 1040170
Reimbursable Overhead (310555) (322230) (345154) (324006) (309399) (321390) (349770) (380212) (423759) (491807) ($528) ($471) ($430) ($412) ($397) ($395) (396136) (405509) (413165)
Labor Expenses $6652131 $6914045 $6933059 $7235017 $7663467 $7997128 $8581574 $8732302 $9239358 $9373 $9920 $10039 $10436 $10787 $11097 $11413 $11520401 $11885220 $12280075
PayrollOvertime Exp as a of Total Operating+DS $0426 $0427 $0407 $0396 $0387 $0374 $0389 $0383 $0376 $0385 $0349 $0347 $0345
Labor Exp (wo Reimb OH) as a of Total Oper+DS $0650 $0663 $0642 $0637 $0647 $0628 $0643 $0640 $0648 $0638 $0614 $0617 $0620
PayrollOvertime Exp as a of Total Operating Exp $0496 $0490 $0483 $0473 $0465 $0453 $0464 $0459 $0450 $0461 $0426 $0420 $0416
Labor Exp (wo Reimb OH) as a of Total Oper Exp $0758 $0761 $0762 $0761 $0777 $0761 $0768 $0768 $0776 $0763 $0748 $0747 $0747
Non-Labor Expenses
Electric Power $306500 $317934 $325137 $457269 $471514 $493346 $515540 $473762 $406372 $430381 $474918 $451304 $463523 $482662 $539624 $571182 $589565 $618283 $648255
Traction Power
Non-Traction Power
Fuel 287033 180294 189942 282735 251763 259252 267494 162283 124684 150481 185580 190348 187592 183168 181484 182259 182476 184281 186170
Revenue Vehicle Fuel
Non-Revenue Fuel
Insurance 28902 34012 9819 14363 7617 38654 50739 57190 (20634) (2715) 11488 8532 15803 22918 29411 36048 28232 25538 19483
Claims 152114 238104 285418 315547 135652 299875 269167 331023 463959 526053 376480 378570 386981 391333 395228 404397 417667 428660 437683
Paratransit Service Contracts 299013 370094 379761 348553 360500 366751 365599 379271 383704 392850 452190 482751 501230 518038 547829 581114 604766 643217 684112
Maintenance and Other Operating Contracts 594215 562456 541716 451137 451766 496743 549018 579289 630924 695251 779331 897801 833038 883805 871671 879468 880053 898882 915477
Professional Service Contracts 196930 199164 203084 226205 276998 297201 283005 379814 399706 507062 575742 557476 484911 479376 489510 499724 520826 537109 547291
Materials amp Supplies 532534 526191 511206 438310 430804 475127 526725 543225 585607 588115 667700 686666 687745 692131 697268 711988 741335 777460 793419
Other Business Expenses 155466 184142 189637 169857 143807 167198 179701 195598 192576 217254 225494 230595 225293 240279 242193 244907 228861 240258 241690
Non-Labor Expenses $2552708 $2612391 $2635720 $2703976 $2530421 $2894147 $3006988 $3101454 $3166897 3505 3749 3884 3786 3894 3994 4111 $4193782 $4353689 $4473580
Other Expense Adjustments
Other ($13712) ($14750) ($18292) ($2289) $62593 $46175 $44973 $37007 $47404 49 134 158 84 36 22 23 $23516 $24069 $24637
General Reserve 0000 0000 0000 0000 0000 - 0 - 0 - 0 - 0 0 0 165 170 175 180 185 190000 195000 205000
Other Expense Adjustments ($13712) ($14750) ($18292) ($2289) $62593 $46175 $44973 $37007 $47404 $49379 $134 $323 $254 $211 $202 $208 $213516 $219069 $229637
Gap Closing Expenses $7675394
Additional Actions for Budget Balance Expense Impact $0000 $0000 $0000 $0000 $0000 $0000 $0000 $0000 $0000 $0000 $0000 $0000 $0000 $0000 $0000 $0000 $0000 $0000 $0000
Total Operating Expenses Before Non-Cash Liability Adjs $9191127 $9511685 $9550486 $9936705 $10256481 $10937450 $11633535 $11870763 $12453659 $12927116 $13802910 $14246122 $14475644 $14891445 $15293262 $15732241 $15927699 $16457978 $16983292
Non-Cash Liability Adjustments
Depreciation $1790981 $1940576 $1980681 $2019378 $2148820 $2174302 $2266280 $2442777 $2442941 $2607970 $2804571 $2784812 $2842737 $2908533 $2977025 $3051834 $3109882 $3169371 $3230301
OPEB Obligation 1348962 1104827 1167070 1706939 1785881 1920189 2035457 1489656 1562261 1567381 0000 (0000) (0000) (0000) (0000) 0000 0000 (0000) (0000)
GASB 75 OPEB Expense Adjustment 0000 0000 0000 0000 0000 0000 0000 0000 0000 0000 1047747 1457230 1628196 1748560 1823313 1898497 1952374 2006482 2061993
GASB 68 Pension Expense Adjustment 0000 0000 0000 0000 0000 0000 0000 (410019) (218911) (168119) (373022) (220864) (271921) (342847) (318372) (242446) (237864) (234492) (230942)
Environmental Remediation 42249 6062 18621 59079 24742 14257 20556 20576 11691 13468 105615 6000 6000 6000 6000 6000 6000 6000 6000
Non-Cash Liability Adjustments $3182192 $3051466 $3166371 $3785396 $3959443 $4108749 $4322293 $3542990 $3797981 $4020699 $3584911 $4027178 $4205012 $4320246 $4487966 $4713886 $4830392 $4947361 $5067352
Total Operating Expenses After Non-Cash Liability Adjs $12373319 $12563151 $12716857 $13722101 $14215924 $15046199 $15955827 $15413753 $16251641 $16947815 $17387821 $18273301 $18680657 $19211690 $19781228 $20446127 $20758090 $21405338 $22050644
Less BampT Depreciation $77213 $80097 $77846 $86545 $87926 $91345 $104039 $109783 $135035 $240957 $148686 $151977 $158779 $169848 $181689 $194355 $194355 $194355 $194355
BampT Other Post Employment Benefits 66323 50967 54831 66686 73055 76641 71148 62457 60441 78106 32297 22256 20303 22870 28694 33918 36169 38411 40604
Net Operating Deficit Before Subsidies and Debt Service ($6409807) ($6419266) ($6222079) ($6711095) ($7081966) ($7146057) ($7887759) ($6954506) ($7643392) ($8211234) ($8606220) ($9463506) ($9813560) ($10322912) ($10895644) ($11515498) ($11364824) ($11950106) ($12573710)
Conversion to Cash Basis Non-Cash Liability Adjs ($3182192) ($3051466) ($3166371) ($3785396) ($3959443) ($4108749) ($4322293) ($3542990) ($3797981) ($4020699) ($3584911) ($4027178) ($4205012) ($4320246) ($4487966) ($4713886) ($4830392) ($4947361) ($5067352)
Total Operating Expenses $9191127 $9511685 $9550486 $9936705 $10256481 $10937450 $11633535 $11870763 $12453659 $12927 $13803 $14246 $14476 $14891 $15293 $15732 $15927699 $16457978 $16983292
Debt Service Expenses $1515733 $1404454 $1781220 $1933532 $2058395 $2299262 $2248538 $2373321 $2458783 $2525 $2559 $2692 $2840 $3080 $3223 $3450 $3471321 $3472987 $3501639
Total Expenses + Debt Service $10706859 $10916139 $11331706 $11870237 $12314876 $13236712 $13882073 $14244084 $14912443 $15452 $16362 $16938 $17316 $17971 $18516 $19182 $19399019 $19930965 $20484932
Net Deficit After Subsidies and Debt Service ($668477) ($620796) ($0414) $287848 $320833 $556541 $561498 $810173 $359895 ($299965) ($339) ($890) ($1079) ($1506) ($1823) ($2283) ($1901641) ($2229069) ($2664369)
Conversion to Cash Basis GASB Account (56067) (54256) (67377) (37636) (89548) (85641) (50017) - 0 - 0 0 0 0 $0 0 0 - 0 - 0 - 0 - 0
Conversion to Cash Basis 492710 550267 91781 (111037) (297407) (261709) (626297) (660147) (591809) 174 296 363 188 (17) 88 130 49745 48375 54220
Net Cash Balance from Previous Year 0000 0000 0000 23990 139174 0000 209191 0000 150026 0000 0000 0000 0000 0000 0000 0000 0000 0000 0000
Total Operating Exp + DS + Cash Conversions + PY C-O $11144 $11412 $11356 $11746 $12067 $12889362 $13414950 $13583937 $14470659 $15625875 $16658585 $17300293 $17504155 $17954574 $18604130 $19312017 $19448764 $19979340 $20539152
Total Operating Expenses with Cash Conversion $10270216 $10420127 $11307302 $12018911 $12701831 $13584063 $14558387 $14904231 $15504252 $15278749 $16065734 $16575223 $17128079 $17987951 $18427778 $19052755 $19349274 $19882590 $20430711
Baseline Net Cash Balance Before B-T-L Adjustments ($231834) ($124785) $23990 $139174 ($66122) $209191 ($114816) $150026 ($231914) ($126) ($43) ($527) ($891) ($1523) ($1735) ($2153) ($1851896) ($2180695) ($2610148)
Below-the-Line Adjustments
FareToll Increases
FareToll Increase in March 2019 (4 Yield) - 0 $0 $0 $0 $0 $0 $0 - 0 - 0 - 0
FareToll Increase in March 2021 (4 Yield) - 0 $0 $0 $0 $283 $331 $332 333531 333568 334299
FareToll Increase in March 2023 (4 Yield) - 0 $0 $0 $0 $0 $0 $294 346386 346424 347183
FareToll Increase in March 2025 (4 Yield) - 0 $0 $0 $0 $0 $0 $0 - 0 273859 321624
Subsidy Impacts of 20212023 FareToll Increase - 0 $0 $0 $0 ($7) ($9) ($17) (18612) (25573) (26305)
$0000 $0 $0 $0 $275 $322 $609 $661306 $928278 $976801
CASH BALANCE AFTER FARE INCREASES ($126402) ($43) ($527) ($891) ($1241) ($1404) ($1821) ($1518365) ($1847127) ($2275849)
MTA Initiatives
MTA Efficiencies - Not Yet Implemented - 0 $0 $0 $0 $0 $0 $0 0000 0000 0000
0 - 0 $0 $0 $0 $0 $0 $0 - 0 - 0 - 0
0 - 0 $0 $0 $0 $0 $0 $0 - 0 - 0 - 0
$0000 $0 $0 $0 $0 $0 $0 $0000 $0000 $0000
Policy Actions
CAS Migration to Peoplesoft $0 $0 ($5) ($1) ($0) ($0) (0200) -02 -02 0
Fare Evasion Enforcement Strategy-Expenses $0 ($13) ($12) ($11) ($10) ($10) (9554) -9554483 -9554483 0
Fare Evasion Enforcement-Manhattan DA Forfeiture Fund $0 $11 $11 $10 $9 $0 - 0 0 0 0
Negotiated 1 CBA Reform $0 $0 $0 $0 $0 $0 - 0 0 0 0
MTA Reorganization $0 $8 $180 $371 $377 $377 377000 377 377 0
MTA Reorganization Costs $0 $0 ($10) ($27) ($2) $0 - 0 0 0 0
Drawdown 2019 General Reserve $0 $0 $165 $0 $0 $0 - 0 0 0 0
CBA Negotiated Reform - 1 Value $0 $36 $100 $173 $246 $323 323473 323473304484 323473304484 0
$0000 $0 $42 $429 $515 $620 $691 $690719 $690719 $690719
MTA Re-estimates
Additional Savings Actions $0000 $0 $0 $0 $0 $0 $0 $0000 $0000 $0000
Total Below-the-Line Adjustments $0 $0 $459 $413 $709 $760 $1007 $1352025 $1618997 $1667520
Prior Year Carryover 495399 263336 138286 161986 301160 235038 444229 329413 479439 248 121 79 11 0 0 - 0 - 0 - 0 - 0
NET CASH BALANCE $263566 $138551 $162276 $301160 $235038 $444229 $329413 $479439 $247525 $121 $79 $11 ($467) ($814) ($976) ($1146) ($499871) ($561698) ($942628)
By Revenue Source
(includes faretoll increases)
($ in millions)
Farebox Revenue $6389
Toll Revenue 2121
Other Revenue 684
Dedicated Taxes 6191
State and Local amp Other 1228
Timing (Cash Adjustments) 135
Total $16748
By Expense Category
(includes below-the-line adjustments)
($ in millions)
Payroll $5422
Overtime 838
Health amp Welfare 2118
Pension 1461
Other Labor 466
Total Labor $10306
Non-Labor + Other Exp Adj 4004
Debt Service 2830
BTL Adjustments for Expenses 2 (386)
Total $16754
By Revenue Source
(includes faretoll increases)
($ in millions)
Farebox Revenue $6389
Toll Revenue 2121
Other Revenue 684
Taxes 6178
State and Local amp Other 557
Other Funding Agreements 671
Other 1 208
Total $16809
By Expense Category
(includes below-the-line adjustments)
($ in millions)
Payroll $5392
Overtime 811
Health amp Welfare 2129
Pension 1354
Other Labor 400
Total Labor $10086
Non-Labor 4205
Debt Service 2692
BTL Adjustments for Expenses (251)
Total $16732
Page 6: MTA 2020 Preliminary Budget July Financial Plan 2020 - 2023 2020 Preliminar… · 1 The MTA Budget Process July Plan – Start of the Annual Process • Current year is revised (the

Highlights of the July Plan

bull Proposed biennial fare and toll increases of 4 in 2021 and 2023 (versus projected 2-year CPI inflators of 49 and 47 in 2021 and 2023 respectively)

bull Maintained investments from prior plans including maintenance of the Subway Action Plan funded from Phase 1 of Congestion PricingFHV fees

bull Renewed emphasis to gain control of and reduce fare evasion (investment of $62 million over the Plan period)

bull MTA is using ldquoone-shotsrdquo to balance the budget in the transition years 2019 and 2020

o 2019 - 2018 favorable year-end balance ndash mostly timing ndash and impacts 2019 ($372 million)

- Freeze on filling all non-operationalnon-essential vacancies ($68 million)

- Other restrictions on non-essential spending including non-revenue vehicle purchases travelprofessional memberships ($44 million)

- One-time reduction of committed to capital contributions ($64 million)

o 2020 - Drawdown of 2019 General Reserve ($165 million)

bull Annual recurring savings targets of $350 million beginning in 2020 have been identified by HQ and Agencies

5

6

These actions will not suffice and significant deficits remain($ in millions)

This Year Next Year Out-Years

11

(467)

(814)

(976)

NA

50

(186)

(569)

(816)

(971)

($1200)

($1000)

($800)

($600)

($400)

($200)

$0

$200

2019 2020 2021 2022 2023

February PlanJuly Plan without Transformation Plan Savings

MTA Transformation Plan

bull State-mandated plan to review operations and implement changes to streamline internal processes clarify responsibilities solidify accountability and work more efficiently to regain trust of our customers and funding partners and improve MTArsquos ability to deliver safe and reliable service our customers deserve

bull Plan recommendationsbull Refocus the operating agencies on mission-critical operating priorities of safety reliability and

servicebull Centralize common support functions to improve operations and create opportunities to ensure

consistent standards quality and policies across departmentsbull Unify the management of capital programs to improve and streamline planning development

and construction so capital improvements can be delivered on time and on budgetbull Expand senior leadership by adding a Chief Transformation Officer a Chief Operating Officer a

Chief Engineering Officer and an MTA Accessibility Officer

bull Consolidation and efficiency targets of $370 million to $530 million on an annual basis have been identified

bull If the MTA Transformation Plan is approved and implemented the July Financial Plan will have small operating balances in 2019 and 2020 a small deficit in 2021 with out-year deficits reaching $433 million in 2023

7

8

The adoption and implementation of the MTA Transformation Planhas the potential to significantly reduce out-year deficits

($ in millions)

This Year Next Year Out-Years

11

(467)

(814)

(976)

NA

61 55

(26)

(281)

(433)

($1200)

($1000)

($800)

($600)

($400)

($200)

$0

$200

2019 2020 2021 2022 2023

February PlanProposed July Plan

Actions to Reduce Fare Evasion $62 million Investment over the Plan Period

bull Increase physical presence (500 uniformed officers NYPD MTA Police and Bridge and Tunnel Officers) to begin enforcement at 50 subway stations and 50 bus routesThis is not just a fare evasion effort but a workerrsquos safety initiative

bull Ensure enforcement does not target any specific demographic bull Educate MTA riders utilizing messaging media and automated

announcementsbull Improve operation of emergency exit gates to mitigate instances of fare

avoidancebull Augment surveillance capabilities by deploying fare array cameras at 50

stations and pilot the use of monitors at 10 stationsbull $40 million of the investment will be funded by Manhattan DA Office over a

four-year period

9

The MTArsquos $350 million target for annually recurring savings beginning in 2020 has been identified and is being implemented

109

10 7 6 6

96 304 351 362 371

$0

$50

$100

$150

$200

$250

$300

$350

$400

2019 2020 2021 2022 2023

Identified Recurring Savings One-Shot Savings

This Year Next Year Out-Years

($ in millions)

10

We have a track record of identifying and achieving our annual recurring savings targets

11

($ in millions)

$0

$500

$1000

$1500

$2000

$2500

$3000

Achieved Savings

2012 November Plan

2013 November Plan

2014 November Plan

2015 November Plan

2016 November Plan

2017 November Plan

2018 November Plan

2019 July Plan

$28 billion

Proposed July Plan

Deficits remain and a continued drive toward further streamlining and efficiencies is required

12

($ in millions)

61 55

(26)

(281)

(433)

($600)

($500)

($400)

($300)

($200)

($100)

$0

$100

$200

2019 2020 2021 2022 2023

This Year Next Year Out-Years

Proposed July PlanDonrsquot achieve Transformation Plan Savings

13

If the MTA Transformation Plan is not adopted and implemented the deficits will be unmanageable without service cuts significant

reductions in force andor additional fare and toll increases($ in millions)

($1100)

($900)

($700)

($500)

($300)

($100)

$100

2019 2020 2021 2022 2023

(816)

(971)

(569)

(81)

(433)

(281)

61 55 (26)

(281) (186)

50

Next Year Out-Years

(230)(11)

(488)

(538)

(535)

This Year

14

2020 Preliminary BudgetWhere the Dollars Come Fromhellip Where the Dollars Gohellip

Farebox Revenue $6389Toll Revenue 2121 Other Revenue 684 Taxes 6178 State and Local amp Other 557 Other Funding Agreements 671 Other 1 208 Total $16809

($ in millions)

By Revenue Source(includes faretoll increases)

Payroll $5422Overtime 838 Health amp Welfare 2118 Pension 1461 Other Labor 466 Total Labor $10306Non-Labor + Other Exp Adj 4004 Debt Service 2830 BTL Adjustments for Expenses 2 (386) Total $16754

By Expense Category

($ in millions)(includes below-the-line adjustments)

1 Includes cash adjustments and prior-year carryover

Farebox Revenue

38

Toll Revenue

13

Other Revenue4

Taxes37

State amp Local

Subsidies3

Other Funding Agreements

4 Other 1

Payroll32

Overtime5

Health ampWelfare

13Pension

9

Other Labor3

Non-Labor + Other Exp Adj

21

Debt Service17

2 The below-the-line adjustments are grouped in the Non-Labor category

Sheet1

Sheet1

15

Non-Reimbursable Mid-Year Preliminary Actual Forecast Budget

2018 2019 2020 2021 2022 2023 Operating Revenues

Farebox Revenue $6155 $6305 $6389 $6373 $6384 $6393Toll Revenue 1976 2088 2121 2129 2129 2131 Other Revenue 643 696 684 704 719 737

Total Operating Revenue $8774 $9089 $9195 $9206 $9232 $9260

Total Subsidies $7177 $7314 $7406 $7581 $7803 $7969Dedicated Taxes as a of Total Revenues + Subs - PMT 233 $0 $0 $0 $0 $0

Total Revenues + Subsidies $15951 $16403 $16601 $16787 $17035 $17229

Operating ExpensesLabor Expenses $9799 $10116 $10306 $10592 $10881 $11121Non-Labor Expenses 3611 3877 3748 3841 3945 4054 Other 129 175 86 36 22 23 General Reserve 0 165 170 175 180 185

Total Operating Expenses $13539 $14333 $14310 $14644 $15028 $15384

Debt Service Expenses $2541 $2683 $2830 $3041 $3265 $3513

Total Expenses + Debt Service $16079 $17016 $17140 $17685 $18293 $18896

Conversion to Cash Basis 379 229 147 60 125 101

Baseline Net Cash Balance Before B-T-L Adjustments $251 ($384) ($392) ($838) ($1133) ($1566)

Total Below-the-Line Adjustments $0 $73 $386 $757 $852 $1133Prior Year Carryover 121 372 61 55 0 0

NET CASH BALANCE $372 $61 $55 ($26) ($281) ($433)

MTA July Financial Plan 2020-2023Consolidated Statement Of Operations By Category ($ in millions)

Summ Stmt of Ops-Feb

Summ Stmt of Ops-Jul

  • MTA 2020Preliminary BudgetJuly Financial Plan2020 - 2023
  • The MTA Budget Process
  • Slide Number 3
  • Slide Number 4
  • What has changed since the February Plan
  • Highlights of the July Plan
  • Slide Number 7
  • MTA Transformation Plan
  • Slide Number 9
  • Actions to Reduce Fare Evasion $62 million Investment over the Plan Period
  • The MTArsquos $350 million target for annually recurring savings beginning in 2020 has been identified and is being implemented
  • We have a track record of identifying and achieving our annual recurring savings targets
  • Deficits remain and a continued drive toward further streamlining and efficiencies is required
  • Slide Number 14
  • 2020 Preliminary Budget
  • Slide Number 16
MTA July Financial Plan 2020-2023
Consolidated Statement Of Operations By Category ($ in millions)
Non-Reimbursable Mid-Year Preliminary
Actual Actual Actual Actual Actual Actual Actual Actual Actual Actual Forecast Budget
2008 2009 2010 2011 2012 2013 2014 2015 2016 2018 2019 2020 2021 2022 2023 2023 2024 2025 2026
Operating Revenues
Farebox Revenue $4240923 $4350411 $4586377 $4999186 $5079138 $5501274 $5709200 $5961129 $6050182 $6155 $6305 $6389 $6373 $6384 $6393 $6174 $6435176 $6431979 $6446633
422 423 405 411 402 399 395 396 396 386 384 385 380 375 371 261 368 363 362
Student Fare - 0 - 0 - 0 - 0 - 0 - 0
Toll Revenue 1273974 1332115 1417046 1501589 1490982 1645193 1676445 1808901 1869693 1976 2088 2121 2129 2129 2131 2002 2133050 2137871 2143111
0127 0129 0125 0124 0118 0119 0116 0120 0122 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0122 0121 0120
Other Revenue 448616 461359 491355 510231 563839 753675 682424 689217 688374 643 696 684 704 719 737 755 825040 885381 887190
Capital and Other Reimbursements 0000 0000 0000 0000 0000 0000 0000 0000 0000 0000 0000 0000 0000 0000 0000 0000 0000 0000 0000
Total Operating Revenue $5963512 $6143885 $6494778 $7011006 $7133959 $7900142 $8068069 $8459247 $8608249 $8774 $9089 $9195 $9206 $9232 $9260 $8931 $9393266 $9455232 $9476934
Dedicated Taxes $3211585 $2366805 $2343537 $2511691 $2673119 $3097640 $3383498 $3582628 $3525829 $3257508 $3459 $3515 $3568 $3630 $3725 $3812 $3841433 $3880226 $3917215
PMT amp MTA Aid - 0 881784 1588677 1718286 1825824 1825328 1885069 1910947 1970760 1987035 $1965 $2152 $2225 $2295 $2368 $2442 2516095 2594604 2677041
New Funding Sources - 0 - 0 - 0 - 0 - 0 - 0 - 0 - 0 - 0 - 0 $508 $342 $385 $385 $385 $385 385000 385000 385000
StateLocal Taxes 556691 539046 544810 541733 536182 537527 539545 537819 537645 541005 $544 $552 $557 $562 $567 $572 576828 581933 583214
Other Funding Agreements 306594 363823 359489 375369 466625 432617 567391 563616 629855 630218 $701 $753 $671 $708 $758 $758 784755 804901 781159
BampT Operating Surplus Transfer 382565 363092 476059 554903 476575 614210 637553 750717 742909 740144 $702 $721 $782 $801 $789 $707 730476 695303 688833
Dedicated Taxes and StateLocal Subsidies $4457434 $4514550 $5312572 $5701982 $5978325 $6507322 $7013056 $7345727 $7406998 $7155909 $7879 $8035 $8188 $8381 $8592 $8676 $8834588 $8941967 $9032462
$0000 $0000 $0000 $0000 $0000 $0000 $0000 $0000 $0000
Less Interagency Subsidy and Surplus Transfers (382565) (363092) (476059) (554903) (476575) (614210) (637553) (750717) (742909) (740144) ($702) ($721) ($782) ($801) ($789) ($707) (730476) (695303) (688833)
Total Subsidies $4074870 $4151458 $4836513 $5147079 $5501750 $5893111 $6375503 $6595010 $6664088 $7177 $7314 $7406 $7581 $7803 $7969 $7969 $8104112 $8246664 $8343629
Dedicated Taxes as a of Total Revenues + Subs - PMT 320 251 241 241 247 259 269 273 265 233 $0 $0 $0 $0 $0 $0 256 257 259
Total Revenues + Subsidies $10038382 $10295342 $11331292 $12158085 $12635709 $13793254 $14443571 $15054257 $15272337 $15951 $16403 $16601 $16787 $17035 $17229 $16900 $17497378 $17701896 $17820563
Operating Expenses
Labor Expenses
Payroll $4087376 $4163330 $4171374 $4160261 $4193658 $4332829 $4671664 $4695823 $4838741 $5020713 $5211 $5328 $5422 $5498 $5624 $5710 $5860206 $5982960 $6107107
Overtime 471675 499307 443227 538647 574316 620701 730200 755071 771495 934100 $1066 $910 $838 $859 $877 $899 917296 935002 951324
Health amp Welfare 684945 688899 738189 809638 812857 895714 961902 1050100 1172304 1208786 $1230 $1341 $1414 $1489 $1583 $1674 1797938 1922668 2071273
OPEB Current Payment 318501 346316 355716 394218 413164 472619 479079 501716 562233 563754 $604 $645 $704 $766 $835 $910 982025 1060022 1142795
Pensions 897450 1021229 1029710 1074598 1328441 1301975 1304355 1248726 1370474 1345308 $1336 $1494 $1461 $1462 $1403 $1347 1357887 1369071 1380572
Other-Fringe Benefits 502739 517194 539996 581661 650430 694680 784143 861079 947870 792151 $881 $869 $897 $930 $956 $976 1001185 1021007 1040170
Reimbursable Overhead (310555) (322230) (345154) (324006) (309399) (321390) (349770) (380212) (423759) (491807) ($528) ($471) ($430) ($412) ($397) ($395) (396136) (405509) (413165)
Labor Expenses $6652131 $6914045 $6933059 $7235017 $7663467 $7997128 $8581574 $8732302 $9239358 $9799 $10116 $10306 $10592 $10881 $11121 $11413 $11520401 $11885220 $12280075
PayrollOvertime Exp as a of Total Operating+DS $0426 $0427 $0407 $0396 $0387 $0374 $0389 $0383 $0376 $0390 $0367 $0365 $0359 $0355 $0350 $0349 $0347 $0345
Labor Exp (wo Reimb OH) as a of Total Oper+DS $0650 $0663 $0642 $0637 $0647 $0628 $0643 $0640 $0648 $0642 $0622 $0626 $0622 $0616 $0609 $0614 $0617 $0620
PayrollOvertime Exp as a of Total Operating Exp $0496 $0490 $0483 $0473 $0465 $0453 $0464 $0459 $0450 $0464 $0435 $0438 $0434 $0433 $0430 $0426 $0420 $0416
Labor Exp (wo Reimb OH) as a of Total Oper Exp $0758 $0761 $0762 $0761 $0777 $0761 $0768 $0768 $0776 $0763 $0739 $0750 $0751 $0750 $0749 $0748 $0747 $0747
Non-Labor Expenses
Electric Power $306500 $317934 $325137 $457269 $471514 $493346 $515540 $473762 $406372 $481893 $451503 $473177 $493090 $532413 $561955 $571182 $589565 $618283 $648255
Traction Power
Non-Traction Power
Fuel 287033 180294 189942 282735 251763 259252 267494 162283 124684 185203 182778 182981 176333 173681 176920 182259 182476 184281 186170
Revenue Vehicle Fuel
Non-Revenue Fuel
Insurance 28902 34012 9819 14363 7617 38654 50739 57190 (20634) (29402) 5608 15623 23118 26855 28309 36048 28232 25538 19483
Claims 152114 238104 285418 315547 135652 299875 269167 331023 463959 437985 387557 394211 392547 398256 406112 404397 417667 428660 437683
Paratransit Service Contracts 299013 370094 379761 348553 360500 366751 365599 379271 383704 455471 494751 488330 505538 535329 568614 581114 604766 643217 684112
Maintenance and Other Operating Contracts 594215 562456 541716 451137 451766 496743 549018 579289 630924 678425 840168 797428 833534 836606 854471 879468 880053 898882 915477
Professional Service Contracts 196930 199164 203084 226205 276998 297201 283005 379814 399706 543582 607838 502858 494814 504103 513895 499724 520826 537109 547291
Materials amp Supplies 532534 526191 511206 438310 430804 475127 526725 543225 585607 637078 689010 679895 697976 711281 715758 711988 741335 777460 793419
Other Business Expenses 155466 184142 189637 169857 143807 167198 179701 195598 192576 220838 218196 213551 224459 226170 228457 244907 228861 240258 241690
Non-Labor Expenses $2552708 $2612391 $2635720 $2703976 $2530421 $2894147 $3006988 $3101454 $3166897 3611 3877 3748 3841 3945 4054 4111 $4193782 $4353689 $4473580
Other Expense Adjustments
Other ($13712) ($14750) ($18292) ($2289) $62593 $46175 $44973 $37007 $47404 129 175 86 36 22 23 23 $23516 $24069 $24637
General Reserve 0000 0000 0000 0000 0000 - 0 - 0 - 0 - 0 0 165 170 175 180 185 185 190000 195000 205000
Other Expense Adjustments ($13712) ($14750) ($18292) ($2289) $62593 $46175 $44973 $37007 $47404 $128555 $340 $256 $211 $202 $208 $208 $213516 $219069 $229637
Gap Closing Expenses $7675394
Additional Actions for Budget Balance Expense Impact $0000 $0000 $0000 $0000 $0000 $0000 $0000 $0000 $0000 $0000 $0000 $0000 $0000 $0000 $0000 $0000 $0000 $0000 $0000
Total Operating Expenses Before Non-Cash Liability Adjs $9191127 $9511685 $9550486 $9936705 $10256481 $10937450 $11633535 $11870763 $12453659 $13538830 $14332772 $14309678 $14643965 $15027767 $15383584 $15732241 $15927699 $16457978 $16983292
Non-Cash Liability Adjustments
Depreciation $1790981 $1940576 $1980681 $2019378 $2148820 $2174302 $2266280 $2442777 $2442941 $2607970 $2804571 $2784812 $2842737 $2908533 $2977025 $3051834 $3109882 $3169371 $3230301
OPEB Obligation 1348962 1104827 1167070 1706939 1785881 1920189 2035457 1489656 1562261 1567381 0000 (0000) (0000) (0000) (0000) 0000 0000 (0000) (0000)
GASB 75 OPEB Expense Adjustment 0000 0000 0000 0000 0000 0000 0000 0000 0000 0000 1047747 1457230 1628196 1748560 1823313 1898497 1952374 2006482 2061993
GASB 68 Pension Expense Adjustment 0000 0000 0000 0000 0000 0000 0000 (410019) (218911) (168119) (373022) (220864) (271921) (342847) (318372) (242446) (237864) (234492) (230942)
Environmental Remediation 42249 6062 18621 59079 24742 14257 20556 20576 11691 13468 105615 6000 6000 6000 6000 6000 6000 6000 6000
Non-Cash Liability Adjustments $3182192 $3051466 $3166371 $3785396 $3959443 $4108749 $4322293 $3542990 $3797981 $4020699 $3584911 $4027178 $4205012 $4320246 $4487966 $4713886 $4830392 $4947361 $5067352
Total Operating Expenses After Non-Cash Liability Adjs $12373319 $12563151 $12716857 $13722101 $14215924 $15046199 $15955827 $15413753 $16251641 $17559529 $17917683 $18336856 $18848977 $19348013 $19871550 $20446127 $20758090 $21405338 $22050644
Less BampT Depreciation $77213 $80097 $77846 $86545 $87926 $91345 $104039 $109783 $135035 $240957 $148686 $151977 $158779 $169848 $181689 $194355 $194355 $194355 $194355
BampT Other Post Employment Benefits 66323 50967 54831 66686 73055 76641 71148 62457 60441 78106 32297 22256 20303 22870 28694 33918 36169 38411 40604
Net Operating Deficit Before Subsidies and Debt Service ($6409807) ($6419266) ($6222079) ($6711095) ($7081966) ($7146057) ($7887759) ($6954506) ($7643392) ($8785339) ($8829030) ($9141907) ($9642826) ($10116260) ($10611154) ($11515498) ($11364824) ($11950106) ($12573710)
Conversion to Cash Basis Non-Cash Liability Adjs ($3182192) ($3051466) ($3166371) ($3785396) ($3959443) ($4108749) ($4322293) ($3542990) ($3797981) ($4020699) ($3584911) ($4027178) ($4205012) ($4320246) ($4487966) ($4713886) ($4830392) ($4947361) ($5067352)
Total Operating Expenses $9191127 $9511685 $9550486 $9936705 $10256481 $10937450 $11633535 $11870763 $12453659 $13539 $14333 $14310 $14644 $15028 $15384 $15732 $15927699 $16457978 $16983292
Debt Service Expenses $1515733 $1404454 $1781220 $1933532 $2058395 $2299262 $2248538 $2373321 $2458783 $2541 $2683 $2830 $3041 $3265 $3513 $3450 $3471321 $3472987 $3501639
Total Expenses + Debt Service $10706859 $10916139 $11331706 $11870237 $12314876 $13236712 $13882073 $14244084 $14912443 $16079 $17016 $17140 $17685 $18293 $18896 $19182 $19399019 $19930965 $20484932
Net Deficit After Subsidies and Debt Service ($668477) ($620796) ($0414) $287848 $320833 $556541 $561498 $810173 $359895 ($128044) ($613) ($539) ($898) ($1258) ($1667) ($2283) ($1901641) ($2229069) ($2664369)
Conversion to Cash Basis GASB Account (56067) (54256) (67377) (37636) (89548) (85641) (50017) - 0 - 0 0 0 0 $0 0 0 - 0 - 0 - 0 - 0
Conversion to Cash Basis 492710 550267 91781 (111037) (297407) (261709) (626297) (660147) (591809) 379 229 147 60 125 101 130 49745 48375 54220
Net Cash Balance from Previous Year 0000 0000 0000 23990 139174 0000 209191 0000 150026 0000 250569 0000 0000 0000 0000 0000 0000 0000 0000
Total Operating Exp + DS + Cash Conversions + PY C-O $11144 $11412 $11356 $11746 $12067 $12889362 $13414950 $13583937 $14470659 $16457999 $17495351 $17286526 $17744425 $18418197 $18997710 $19312017 $19448764 $19979340 $20539152
Total Operating Expenses with Cash Conversion $10270216 $10420127 $11307302 $12018911 $12701831 $13584063 $14558387 $14904231 $15504252 $15700774 $16786574 $16992579 $17624861 $18167420 $18795069 $19052755 $19349274 $19882590 $20430711
Baseline Net Cash Balance Before B-T-L Adjustments ($231834) ($124785) $23990 $139174 ($66122) $209191 ($114816) $150026 ($231914) $251 ($384) ($392) ($838) ($1133) ($1566) ($2153) ($1851896) ($2180695) ($2610148)
Below-the-Line Adjustments
FareToll Increases
FareToll Increase in March 2019 (4 Yield) - 0 $0 $0 $0 $0 $0 $0 - 0 - 0 - 0
FareToll Increase in March 2021 (4 Yield) - 0 $0 $0 $0 $283 $331 $332 333531 333568 334299
FareToll Increase in March 2023 (4 Yield) - 0 $0 $0 $0 $0 $0 $294 346386 346424 347183
FareToll Increase in March 2025 (4 Yield) - 0 $0 $0 $0 $0 $0 $0 - 0 273859 321624
Subsidy Impacts of 20212023 FareToll Increase - 0 $0 $0 $0 ($7) ($9) ($17) (18612) (25573) (26305)
$0000 $0 $0 $0 $275 $322 $609 $661306 $928278 $976801
CASH BALANCE AFTER FARE INCREASES $250569 ($384) ($392) ($838) ($850) ($1234) ($1821) ($1518365) ($1847127) ($2275849)
MTA Initiatives
MTA Efficiencies - Not Yet Implemented - 0 $0 $0 $0 $0 $0 $0 0000 0000 0000
0 - 0 $0 $0 $0 $0 $0 $0 - 0 - 0 - 0
0 - 0 $0 $0 $0 $0 $0 $0 - 0 - 0 - 0
$0000 $0 $0 $0 $0 $0 $0 $0000 $0000 $0000
Policy Actions
CAS Migration to Peoplesoft $0 $0 ($5) ($1) ($0) ($0) (0200) -02 -02 0
Fare Evasion Enforcement Strategy-Expenses $0 ($13) ($12) ($11) ($10) ($10) (9554) -9554483 -9554483 0
Fare Evasion Enforcement-Manhattan DA Forfeiture Fund $0 $11 $11 $10 $9 $0 - 0 0 0 0
Negotiated 1 CBA Reform $0 $0 $0 $0 $0 $0 - 0 0 0 0
MTA Reorganization $0 $8 $180 $371 $377 $377 377000 377 377 0
MTA Reorganization Costs $0 $0 ($10) ($27) ($2) $0 - 0 0 0 0
Drawdown 2019 General Reserve $0 $0 $165 $0 $0 $0 - 0 0 0 0
CBA Negotiated Reform - 1 Value $0 $36 $100 $173 $246 $323 323473 323473304484 323473304484 0
$0000 $0 $42 $429 $515 $620 $691 $690719 $690719 $690719
MTA Re-estimates
Additional Savings Actions $0000 $0 $0 $0 $0 $0 $0 $0000 $0000 $0000
Total Below-the-Line Adjustments $0 $73 $386 $757 $852 $1133 $1007 $1352025 $1618997 $1667520
Prior Year Carryover 495399 263336 138286 161986 301160 235038 444229 329413 479439 121 372 61 55 0 0 - 0 - 0 - 0 - 0
NET CASH BALANCE $263566 $138551 $162276 $301160 $235038 $444229 $329413 $479439 $247525 $372 $61 $55 ($26) ($281) ($433) ($1146) ($499871) ($561698) ($942628)
MTA February Financial Plan 2019-2022
Consolidated Statement Of Operations By Category ($ in millions)
Non-Reimbursable Final Adopted
Actual Actual Actual Actual Actual Actual Actual Actual Actual Actual Estimate Budget
2008 2009 2010 2011 2012 2013 2014 2015 2016 2017 2018 2019 2020 2021 2022 2023 2024 2025 2026
Operating Revenues
Farebox Revenue $4240923 $4350411 $4586377 $4999186 $5079138 $5501274 $5709200 $5961129 $6050182 $6172 $6153 $6122 $6144 $6134 $6144 $6174 $6435176 $6431979 $6446633
422 423 405 411 402 399 395 396 396 407 279 275 272 267 263 261 368 363 362
Student Fare - 0 - 0 - 0 - 0 - 0 - 0
Toll Revenue 1273974 1332115 1417046 1501589 1490982 1645193 1676445 1808901 1869693 1912 1967 1984 1990 1998 1998 2002 2133050 2137871 2143111
0127 0129 0125 0124 0118 0119 0116 0120 0122 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0122 0121 0120
Other Revenue 448616 461359 491355 510231 563839 753675 682424 689217 688374 653 662 705 733 757 743 755 825040 885381 887190
Capital and Other Reimbursements 0000 0000 0000 0000 0000 0000 0000 0000 0000 0000 0000 0000 0000 0000 0000 0000 0000 0000 0000
Total Operating Revenue $5963512 $6143885 $6494778 $7011006 $7133959 $7900142 $8068069 $8459247 $8608249 $8737 $8782 $8810 $8867 $8889 $8886 $8931 $9393266 $9455232 $9476934
Dedicated Taxes $3211585 $2366805 $2343537 $2511691 $2673119 $3097640 $3383498 $3582628 $3525829 $3257508 $3459 $3515 $3568 $3630 $3725 $3812 $3841433 $3880226 $3917215
PMT amp MTA Aid - 0 881784 1588677 1718286 1825824 1825328 1885069 1910947 1970760 1987035 $1965 $2152 $2225 $2295 $2368 $2442 2516095 2594604 2677041
New Funding Sources - 0 - 0 - 0 - 0 - 0 - 0 - 0 - 0 - 0 - 0 $508 $342 $385 $385 $385 $385 385000 385000 385000
StateLocal Taxes 556691 539046 544810 541733 536182 537527 539545 537819 537645 541005 $544 $552 $557 $562 $567 $572 576828 581933 583214
Other Funding Agreements 306594 363823 359489 375369 466625 432617 567391 563616 629855 630218 $701 $753 $671 $708 $758 $758 784755 804901 781159
BampT Operating Surplus Transfer 382565 363092 476059 554903 476575 614210 637553 750717 742909 740144 $702 $721 $782 $801 $789 $707 730476 695303 688833
Dedicated Taxes and StateLocal Subsidies $4457434 $4514550 $5312572 $5701982 $5978325 $6507322 $7013056 $7345727 $7406998 $7155909 $7879 $8035 $8188 $8381 $8592 $8676 $8834588 $8941967 $9032462
$0000 $0000 $0000 $0000 $0000 $0000 $0000 $0000 $0000
Less Interagency Subsidy and Surplus Transfers (382565) (363092) (476059) (554903) (476575) (614210) (637553) (750717) (742909) (740144) ($702) ($721) ($782) ($801) ($789) ($707) (730476) (695303) (688833)
Total Subsidies $4074870 $4151458 $4836513 $5147079 $5501750 $5893111 $6375503 $6595010 $6664088 $6416 $7242 $7238 $7370 $7576 $7807 $7969 $8104112 $8246664 $8343629
Dedicated Taxes as a of Total Revenues + Subs - PMT 320 251 241 241 247 259 269 273 265 247 $0 $0 $0 $0 $0 $0 256 257 259
Total Revenues + Subsidies $10038382 $10295342 $11331292 $12158085 $12635709 $13793254 $14443571 $15054257 $15272337 $15152 $16023 $16048 $16237 $16465 $16693 $16900 $17497378 $17701896 $17820563
Operating Expenses
Labor Expenses
Payroll $4087376 $4163330 $4171374 $4160261 $4193658 $4332829 $4671664 $4695823 $4838741 $5020713 $5211 $5328 $5422 $5498 $5624 $5710 $5860206 $5982960 $6107107
Overtime 471675 499307 443227 538647 574316 620701 730200 755071 771495 934100 $1066 $910 $838 $859 $877 $899 917296 935002 951324
Health amp Welfare 684945 688899 738189 809638 812857 895714 961902 1050100 1172304 1208786 $1230 $1341 $1414 $1489 $1583 $1674 1797938 1922668 2071273
OPEB Current Payment 318501 346316 355716 394218 413164 472619 479079 501716 562233 563754 $604 $645 $704 $766 $835 $910 982025 1060022 1142795
Pensions 897450 1021229 1029710 1074598 1328441 1301975 1304355 1248726 1370474 1345308 $1336 $1494 $1461 $1462 $1403 $1347 1357887 1369071 1380572
Other-Fringe Benefits 502739 517194 539996 581661 650430 694680 784143 861079 947870 792151 $881 $869 $897 $930 $956 $976 1001185 1021007 1040170
Reimbursable Overhead (310555) (322230) (345154) (324006) (309399) (321390) (349770) (380212) (423759) (491807) ($528) ($471) ($430) ($412) ($397) ($395) (396136) (405509) (413165)
Labor Expenses $6652131 $6914045 $6933059 $7235017 $7663467 $7997128 $8581574 $8732302 $9239358 $9373 $9920 $10039 $10436 $10787 $11097 $11413 $11520401 $11885220 $12280075
PayrollOvertime Exp as a of Total Operating+DS $0426 $0427 $0407 $0396 $0387 $0374 $0389 $0383 $0376 $0385 $0349 $0347 $0345
Labor Exp (wo Reimb OH) as a of Total Oper+DS $0650 $0663 $0642 $0637 $0647 $0628 $0643 $0640 $0648 $0638 $0614 $0617 $0620
PayrollOvertime Exp as a of Total Operating Exp $0496 $0490 $0483 $0473 $0465 $0453 $0464 $0459 $0450 $0461 $0426 $0420 $0416
Labor Exp (wo Reimb OH) as a of Total Oper Exp $0758 $0761 $0762 $0761 $0777 $0761 $0768 $0768 $0776 $0763 $0748 $0747 $0747
Non-Labor Expenses
Electric Power $306500 $317934 $325137 $457269 $471514 $493346 $515540 $473762 $406372 $430381 $474918 $451304 $463523 $482662 $539624 $571182 $589565 $618283 $648255
Traction Power
Non-Traction Power
Fuel 287033 180294 189942 282735 251763 259252 267494 162283 124684 150481 185580 190348 187592 183168 181484 182259 182476 184281 186170
Revenue Vehicle Fuel
Non-Revenue Fuel
Insurance 28902 34012 9819 14363 7617 38654 50739 57190 (20634) (2715) 11488 8532 15803 22918 29411 36048 28232 25538 19483
Claims 152114 238104 285418 315547 135652 299875 269167 331023 463959 526053 376480 378570 386981 391333 395228 404397 417667 428660 437683
Paratransit Service Contracts 299013 370094 379761 348553 360500 366751 365599 379271 383704 392850 452190 482751 501230 518038 547829 581114 604766 643217 684112
Maintenance and Other Operating Contracts 594215 562456 541716 451137 451766 496743 549018 579289 630924 695251 779331 897801 833038 883805 871671 879468 880053 898882 915477
Professional Service Contracts 196930 199164 203084 226205 276998 297201 283005 379814 399706 507062 575742 557476 484911 479376 489510 499724 520826 537109 547291
Materials amp Supplies 532534 526191 511206 438310 430804 475127 526725 543225 585607 588115 667700 686666 687745 692131 697268 711988 741335 777460 793419
Other Business Expenses 155466 184142 189637 169857 143807 167198 179701 195598 192576 217254 225494 230595 225293 240279 242193 244907 228861 240258 241690
Non-Labor Expenses $2552708 $2612391 $2635720 $2703976 $2530421 $2894147 $3006988 $3101454 $3166897 3505 3749 3884 3786 3894 3994 4111 $4193782 $4353689 $4473580
Other Expense Adjustments
Other ($13712) ($14750) ($18292) ($2289) $62593 $46175 $44973 $37007 $47404 49 134 158 84 36 22 23 $23516 $24069 $24637
General Reserve 0000 0000 0000 0000 0000 - 0 - 0 - 0 - 0 0 0 165 170 175 180 185 190000 195000 205000
Other Expense Adjustments ($13712) ($14750) ($18292) ($2289) $62593 $46175 $44973 $37007 $47404 $49379 $134 $323 $254 $211 $202 $208 $213516 $219069 $229637
Gap Closing Expenses $7675394
Additional Actions for Budget Balance Expense Impact $0000 $0000 $0000 $0000 $0000 $0000 $0000 $0000 $0000 $0000 $0000 $0000 $0000 $0000 $0000 $0000 $0000 $0000 $0000
Total Operating Expenses Before Non-Cash Liability Adjs $9191127 $9511685 $9550486 $9936705 $10256481 $10937450 $11633535 $11870763 $12453659 $12927116 $13802910 $14246122 $14475644 $14891445 $15293262 $15732241 $15927699 $16457978 $16983292
Non-Cash Liability Adjustments
Depreciation $1790981 $1940576 $1980681 $2019378 $2148820 $2174302 $2266280 $2442777 $2442941 $2607970 $2804571 $2784812 $2842737 $2908533 $2977025 $3051834 $3109882 $3169371 $3230301
OPEB Obligation 1348962 1104827 1167070 1706939 1785881 1920189 2035457 1489656 1562261 1567381 0000 (0000) (0000) (0000) (0000) 0000 0000 (0000) (0000)
GASB 75 OPEB Expense Adjustment 0000 0000 0000 0000 0000 0000 0000 0000 0000 0000 1047747 1457230 1628196 1748560 1823313 1898497 1952374 2006482 2061993
GASB 68 Pension Expense Adjustment 0000 0000 0000 0000 0000 0000 0000 (410019) (218911) (168119) (373022) (220864) (271921) (342847) (318372) (242446) (237864) (234492) (230942)
Environmental Remediation 42249 6062 18621 59079 24742 14257 20556 20576 11691 13468 105615 6000 6000 6000 6000 6000 6000 6000 6000
Non-Cash Liability Adjustments $3182192 $3051466 $3166371 $3785396 $3959443 $4108749 $4322293 $3542990 $3797981 $4020699 $3584911 $4027178 $4205012 $4320246 $4487966 $4713886 $4830392 $4947361 $5067352
Total Operating Expenses After Non-Cash Liability Adjs $12373319 $12563151 $12716857 $13722101 $14215924 $15046199 $15955827 $15413753 $16251641 $16947815 $17387821 $18273301 $18680657 $19211690 $19781228 $20446127 $20758090 $21405338 $22050644
Less BampT Depreciation $77213 $80097 $77846 $86545 $87926 $91345 $104039 $109783 $135035 $240957 $148686 $151977 $158779 $169848 $181689 $194355 $194355 $194355 $194355
BampT Other Post Employment Benefits 66323 50967 54831 66686 73055 76641 71148 62457 60441 78106 32297 22256 20303 22870 28694 33918 36169 38411 40604
Net Operating Deficit Before Subsidies and Debt Service ($6409807) ($6419266) ($6222079) ($6711095) ($7081966) ($7146057) ($7887759) ($6954506) ($7643392) ($8211234) ($8606220) ($9463506) ($9813560) ($10322912) ($10895644) ($11515498) ($11364824) ($11950106) ($12573710)
Conversion to Cash Basis Non-Cash Liability Adjs ($3182192) ($3051466) ($3166371) ($3785396) ($3959443) ($4108749) ($4322293) ($3542990) ($3797981) ($4020699) ($3584911) ($4027178) ($4205012) ($4320246) ($4487966) ($4713886) ($4830392) ($4947361) ($5067352)
Total Operating Expenses $9191127 $9511685 $9550486 $9936705 $10256481 $10937450 $11633535 $11870763 $12453659 $12927 $13803 $14246 $14476 $14891 $15293 $15732 $15927699 $16457978 $16983292
Debt Service Expenses $1515733 $1404454 $1781220 $1933532 $2058395 $2299262 $2248538 $2373321 $2458783 $2525 $2559 $2692 $2840 $3080 $3223 $3450 $3471321 $3472987 $3501639
Total Expenses + Debt Service $10706859 $10916139 $11331706 $11870237 $12314876 $13236712 $13882073 $14244084 $14912443 $15452 $16362 $16938 $17316 $17971 $18516 $19182 $19399019 $19930965 $20484932
Net Deficit After Subsidies and Debt Service ($668477) ($620796) ($0414) $287848 $320833 $556541 $561498 $810173 $359895 ($299965) ($339) ($890) ($1079) ($1506) ($1823) ($2283) ($1901641) ($2229069) ($2664369)
Conversion to Cash Basis GASB Account (56067) (54256) (67377) (37636) (89548) (85641) (50017) - 0 - 0 0 0 0 $0 0 0 - 0 - 0 - 0 - 0
Conversion to Cash Basis 492710 550267 91781 (111037) (297407) (261709) (626297) (660147) (591809) 174 296 363 188 (17) 88 130 49745 48375 54220
Net Cash Balance from Previous Year 0000 0000 0000 23990 139174 0000 209191 0000 150026 0000 0000 0000 0000 0000 0000 0000 0000 0000 0000
Total Operating Exp + DS + Cash Conversions + PY C-O $11144 $11412 $11356 $11746 $12067 $12889362 $13414950 $13583937 $14470659 $15625875 $16658585 $17300293 $17504155 $17954574 $18604130 $19312017 $19448764 $19979340 $20539152
Total Operating Expenses with Cash Conversion $10270216 $10420127 $11307302 $12018911 $12701831 $13584063 $14558387 $14904231 $15504252 $15278749 $16065734 $16575223 $17128079 $17987951 $18427778 $19052755 $19349274 $19882590 $20430711
Baseline Net Cash Balance Before B-T-L Adjustments ($231834) ($124785) $23990 $139174 ($66122) $209191 ($114816) $150026 ($231914) ($126) ($43) ($527) ($891) ($1523) ($1735) ($2153) ($1851896) ($2180695) ($2610148)
Below-the-Line Adjustments
FareToll Increases
FareToll Increase in March 2019 (4 Yield) - 0 $0 $0 $0 $0 $0 $0 - 0 - 0 - 0
FareToll Increase in March 2021 (4 Yield) - 0 $0 $0 $0 $283 $331 $332 333531 333568 334299
FareToll Increase in March 2023 (4 Yield) - 0 $0 $0 $0 $0 $0 $294 346386 346424 347183
FareToll Increase in March 2025 (4 Yield) - 0 $0 $0 $0 $0 $0 $0 - 0 273859 321624
Subsidy Impacts of 20212023 FareToll Increase - 0 $0 $0 $0 ($7) ($9) ($17) (18612) (25573) (26305)
$0000 $0 $0 $0 $275 $322 $609 $661306 $928278 $976801
CASH BALANCE AFTER FARE INCREASES ($126402) ($43) ($527) ($891) ($1241) ($1404) ($1821) ($1518365) ($1847127) ($2275849)
MTA Initiatives
MTA Efficiencies - Not Yet Implemented - 0 $0 $0 $0 $0 $0 $0 0000 0000 0000
0 - 0 $0 $0 $0 $0 $0 $0 - 0 - 0 - 0
0 - 0 $0 $0 $0 $0 $0 $0 - 0 - 0 - 0
$0000 $0 $0 $0 $0 $0 $0 $0000 $0000 $0000
Policy Actions
CAS Migration to Peoplesoft $0 $0 ($5) ($1) ($0) ($0) (0200) -02 -02 0
Fare Evasion Enforcement Strategy-Expenses $0 ($13) ($12) ($11) ($10) ($10) (9554) -9554483 -9554483 0
Fare Evasion Enforcement-Manhattan DA Forfeiture Fund $0 $11 $11 $10 $9 $0 - 0 0 0 0
Negotiated 1 CBA Reform $0 $0 $0 $0 $0 $0 - 0 0 0 0
MTA Reorganization $0 $8 $180 $371 $377 $377 377000 377 377 0
MTA Reorganization Costs $0 $0 ($10) ($27) ($2) $0 - 0 0 0 0
Drawdown 2019 General Reserve $0 $0 $165 $0 $0 $0 - 0 0 0 0
CBA Negotiated Reform - 1 Value $0 $36 $100 $173 $246 $323 323473 323473304484 323473304484 0
$0000 $0 $42 $429 $515 $620 $691 $690719 $690719 $690719
MTA Re-estimates
Additional Savings Actions $0000 $0 $0 $0 $0 $0 $0 $0000 $0000 $0000
Total Below-the-Line Adjustments $0 $0 $459 $413 $709 $760 $1007 $1352025 $1618997 $1667520
Prior Year Carryover 495399 263336 138286 161986 301160 235038 444229 329413 479439 248 121 79 11 0 0 - 0 - 0 - 0 - 0
NET CASH BALANCE $263566 $138551 $162276 $301160 $235038 $444229 $329413 $479439 $247525 $121 $79 $11 ($467) ($814) ($976) ($1146) ($499871) ($561698) ($942628)
By Revenue Source
(includes faretoll increases)
($ in millions)
Farebox Revenue $6389
Toll Revenue 2121
Other Revenue 684
Dedicated Taxes 6191
State and Local amp Other 1228
Timing (Cash Adjustments) 135
Total $16748
By Expense Category
(includes below-the-line adjustments)
($ in millions)
Payroll $5422
Overtime 838
Health amp Welfare 2118
Pension 1461
Other Labor 466
Total Labor $10306
Non-Labor + Other Exp Adj 4004
Debt Service 2830
BTL Adjustments for Expenses 2 (386)
Total $16754
By Revenue Source
(includes faretoll increases)
($ in millions)
Farebox Revenue $6389
Toll Revenue 2121
Other Revenue 684
Taxes 6178
State and Local amp Other 557
Other Funding Agreements 671
Other 1 208
Total $16809
By Expense Category
(includes below-the-line adjustments)
($ in millions)
Payroll $5392
Overtime 811
Health amp Welfare 2129
Pension 1354
Other Labor 400
Total Labor $10086
Non-Labor 4205
Debt Service 2692
BTL Adjustments for Expenses (251)
Total $16732
Page 7: MTA 2020 Preliminary Budget July Financial Plan 2020 - 2023 2020 Preliminar… · 1 The MTA Budget Process July Plan – Start of the Annual Process • Current year is revised (the

6

These actions will not suffice and significant deficits remain($ in millions)

This Year Next Year Out-Years

11

(467)

(814)

(976)

NA

50

(186)

(569)

(816)

(971)

($1200)

($1000)

($800)

($600)

($400)

($200)

$0

$200

2019 2020 2021 2022 2023

February PlanJuly Plan without Transformation Plan Savings

MTA Transformation Plan

bull State-mandated plan to review operations and implement changes to streamline internal processes clarify responsibilities solidify accountability and work more efficiently to regain trust of our customers and funding partners and improve MTArsquos ability to deliver safe and reliable service our customers deserve

bull Plan recommendationsbull Refocus the operating agencies on mission-critical operating priorities of safety reliability and

servicebull Centralize common support functions to improve operations and create opportunities to ensure

consistent standards quality and policies across departmentsbull Unify the management of capital programs to improve and streamline planning development

and construction so capital improvements can be delivered on time and on budgetbull Expand senior leadership by adding a Chief Transformation Officer a Chief Operating Officer a

Chief Engineering Officer and an MTA Accessibility Officer

bull Consolidation and efficiency targets of $370 million to $530 million on an annual basis have been identified

bull If the MTA Transformation Plan is approved and implemented the July Financial Plan will have small operating balances in 2019 and 2020 a small deficit in 2021 with out-year deficits reaching $433 million in 2023

7

8

The adoption and implementation of the MTA Transformation Planhas the potential to significantly reduce out-year deficits

($ in millions)

This Year Next Year Out-Years

11

(467)

(814)

(976)

NA

61 55

(26)

(281)

(433)

($1200)

($1000)

($800)

($600)

($400)

($200)

$0

$200

2019 2020 2021 2022 2023

February PlanProposed July Plan

Actions to Reduce Fare Evasion $62 million Investment over the Plan Period

bull Increase physical presence (500 uniformed officers NYPD MTA Police and Bridge and Tunnel Officers) to begin enforcement at 50 subway stations and 50 bus routesThis is not just a fare evasion effort but a workerrsquos safety initiative

bull Ensure enforcement does not target any specific demographic bull Educate MTA riders utilizing messaging media and automated

announcementsbull Improve operation of emergency exit gates to mitigate instances of fare

avoidancebull Augment surveillance capabilities by deploying fare array cameras at 50

stations and pilot the use of monitors at 10 stationsbull $40 million of the investment will be funded by Manhattan DA Office over a

four-year period

9

The MTArsquos $350 million target for annually recurring savings beginning in 2020 has been identified and is being implemented

109

10 7 6 6

96 304 351 362 371

$0

$50

$100

$150

$200

$250

$300

$350

$400

2019 2020 2021 2022 2023

Identified Recurring Savings One-Shot Savings

This Year Next Year Out-Years

($ in millions)

10

We have a track record of identifying and achieving our annual recurring savings targets

11

($ in millions)

$0

$500

$1000

$1500

$2000

$2500

$3000

Achieved Savings

2012 November Plan

2013 November Plan

2014 November Plan

2015 November Plan

2016 November Plan

2017 November Plan

2018 November Plan

2019 July Plan

$28 billion

Proposed July Plan

Deficits remain and a continued drive toward further streamlining and efficiencies is required

12

($ in millions)

61 55

(26)

(281)

(433)

($600)

($500)

($400)

($300)

($200)

($100)

$0

$100

$200

2019 2020 2021 2022 2023

This Year Next Year Out-Years

Proposed July PlanDonrsquot achieve Transformation Plan Savings

13

If the MTA Transformation Plan is not adopted and implemented the deficits will be unmanageable without service cuts significant

reductions in force andor additional fare and toll increases($ in millions)

($1100)

($900)

($700)

($500)

($300)

($100)

$100

2019 2020 2021 2022 2023

(816)

(971)

(569)

(81)

(433)

(281)

61 55 (26)

(281) (186)

50

Next Year Out-Years

(230)(11)

(488)

(538)

(535)

This Year

14

2020 Preliminary BudgetWhere the Dollars Come Fromhellip Where the Dollars Gohellip

Farebox Revenue $6389Toll Revenue 2121 Other Revenue 684 Taxes 6178 State and Local amp Other 557 Other Funding Agreements 671 Other 1 208 Total $16809

($ in millions)

By Revenue Source(includes faretoll increases)

Payroll $5422Overtime 838 Health amp Welfare 2118 Pension 1461 Other Labor 466 Total Labor $10306Non-Labor + Other Exp Adj 4004 Debt Service 2830 BTL Adjustments for Expenses 2 (386) Total $16754

By Expense Category

($ in millions)(includes below-the-line adjustments)

1 Includes cash adjustments and prior-year carryover

Farebox Revenue

38

Toll Revenue

13

Other Revenue4

Taxes37

State amp Local

Subsidies3

Other Funding Agreements

4 Other 1

Payroll32

Overtime5

Health ampWelfare

13Pension

9

Other Labor3

Non-Labor + Other Exp Adj

21

Debt Service17

2 The below-the-line adjustments are grouped in the Non-Labor category

Sheet1

Sheet1

15

Non-Reimbursable Mid-Year Preliminary Actual Forecast Budget

2018 2019 2020 2021 2022 2023 Operating Revenues

Farebox Revenue $6155 $6305 $6389 $6373 $6384 $6393Toll Revenue 1976 2088 2121 2129 2129 2131 Other Revenue 643 696 684 704 719 737

Total Operating Revenue $8774 $9089 $9195 $9206 $9232 $9260

Total Subsidies $7177 $7314 $7406 $7581 $7803 $7969Dedicated Taxes as a of Total Revenues + Subs - PMT 233 $0 $0 $0 $0 $0

Total Revenues + Subsidies $15951 $16403 $16601 $16787 $17035 $17229

Operating ExpensesLabor Expenses $9799 $10116 $10306 $10592 $10881 $11121Non-Labor Expenses 3611 3877 3748 3841 3945 4054 Other 129 175 86 36 22 23 General Reserve 0 165 170 175 180 185

Total Operating Expenses $13539 $14333 $14310 $14644 $15028 $15384

Debt Service Expenses $2541 $2683 $2830 $3041 $3265 $3513

Total Expenses + Debt Service $16079 $17016 $17140 $17685 $18293 $18896

Conversion to Cash Basis 379 229 147 60 125 101

Baseline Net Cash Balance Before B-T-L Adjustments $251 ($384) ($392) ($838) ($1133) ($1566)

Total Below-the-Line Adjustments $0 $73 $386 $757 $852 $1133Prior Year Carryover 121 372 61 55 0 0

NET CASH BALANCE $372 $61 $55 ($26) ($281) ($433)

MTA July Financial Plan 2020-2023Consolidated Statement Of Operations By Category ($ in millions)

Summ Stmt of Ops-Feb

Summ Stmt of Ops-Jul

  • MTA 2020Preliminary BudgetJuly Financial Plan2020 - 2023
  • The MTA Budget Process
  • Slide Number 3
  • Slide Number 4
  • What has changed since the February Plan
  • Highlights of the July Plan
  • Slide Number 7
  • MTA Transformation Plan
  • Slide Number 9
  • Actions to Reduce Fare Evasion $62 million Investment over the Plan Period
  • The MTArsquos $350 million target for annually recurring savings beginning in 2020 has been identified and is being implemented
  • We have a track record of identifying and achieving our annual recurring savings targets
  • Deficits remain and a continued drive toward further streamlining and efficiencies is required
  • Slide Number 14
  • 2020 Preliminary Budget
  • Slide Number 16
MTA July Financial Plan 2020-2023
Consolidated Statement Of Operations By Category ($ in millions)
Non-Reimbursable Mid-Year Preliminary
Actual Actual Actual Actual Actual Actual Actual Actual Actual Actual Forecast Budget
2008 2009 2010 2011 2012 2013 2014 2015 2016 2018 2019 2020 2021 2022 2023 2023 2024 2025 2026
Operating Revenues
Farebox Revenue $4240923 $4350411 $4586377 $4999186 $5079138 $5501274 $5709200 $5961129 $6050182 $6155 $6305 $6389 $6373 $6384 $6393 $6174 $6435176 $6431979 $6446633
422 423 405 411 402 399 395 396 396 386 384 385 380 375 371 261 368 363 362
Student Fare - 0 - 0 - 0 - 0 - 0 - 0
Toll Revenue 1273974 1332115 1417046 1501589 1490982 1645193 1676445 1808901 1869693 1976 2088 2121 2129 2129 2131 2002 2133050 2137871 2143111
0127 0129 0125 0124 0118 0119 0116 0120 0122 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0122 0121 0120
Other Revenue 448616 461359 491355 510231 563839 753675 682424 689217 688374 643 696 684 704 719 737 755 825040 885381 887190
Capital and Other Reimbursements 0000 0000 0000 0000 0000 0000 0000 0000 0000 0000 0000 0000 0000 0000 0000 0000 0000 0000 0000
Total Operating Revenue $5963512 $6143885 $6494778 $7011006 $7133959 $7900142 $8068069 $8459247 $8608249 $8774 $9089 $9195 $9206 $9232 $9260 $8931 $9393266 $9455232 $9476934
Dedicated Taxes $3211585 $2366805 $2343537 $2511691 $2673119 $3097640 $3383498 $3582628 $3525829 $3257508 $3459 $3515 $3568 $3630 $3725 $3812 $3841433 $3880226 $3917215
PMT amp MTA Aid - 0 881784 1588677 1718286 1825824 1825328 1885069 1910947 1970760 1987035 $1965 $2152 $2225 $2295 $2368 $2442 2516095 2594604 2677041
New Funding Sources - 0 - 0 - 0 - 0 - 0 - 0 - 0 - 0 - 0 - 0 $508 $342 $385 $385 $385 $385 385000 385000 385000
StateLocal Taxes 556691 539046 544810 541733 536182 537527 539545 537819 537645 541005 $544 $552 $557 $562 $567 $572 576828 581933 583214
Other Funding Agreements 306594 363823 359489 375369 466625 432617 567391 563616 629855 630218 $701 $753 $671 $708 $758 $758 784755 804901 781159
BampT Operating Surplus Transfer 382565 363092 476059 554903 476575 614210 637553 750717 742909 740144 $702 $721 $782 $801 $789 $707 730476 695303 688833
Dedicated Taxes and StateLocal Subsidies $4457434 $4514550 $5312572 $5701982 $5978325 $6507322 $7013056 $7345727 $7406998 $7155909 $7879 $8035 $8188 $8381 $8592 $8676 $8834588 $8941967 $9032462
$0000 $0000 $0000 $0000 $0000 $0000 $0000 $0000 $0000
Less Interagency Subsidy and Surplus Transfers (382565) (363092) (476059) (554903) (476575) (614210) (637553) (750717) (742909) (740144) ($702) ($721) ($782) ($801) ($789) ($707) (730476) (695303) (688833)
Total Subsidies $4074870 $4151458 $4836513 $5147079 $5501750 $5893111 $6375503 $6595010 $6664088 $7177 $7314 $7406 $7581 $7803 $7969 $7969 $8104112 $8246664 $8343629
Dedicated Taxes as a of Total Revenues + Subs - PMT 320 251 241 241 247 259 269 273 265 233 $0 $0 $0 $0 $0 $0 256 257 259
Total Revenues + Subsidies $10038382 $10295342 $11331292 $12158085 $12635709 $13793254 $14443571 $15054257 $15272337 $15951 $16403 $16601 $16787 $17035 $17229 $16900 $17497378 $17701896 $17820563
Operating Expenses
Labor Expenses
Payroll $4087376 $4163330 $4171374 $4160261 $4193658 $4332829 $4671664 $4695823 $4838741 $5020713 $5211 $5328 $5422 $5498 $5624 $5710 $5860206 $5982960 $6107107
Overtime 471675 499307 443227 538647 574316 620701 730200 755071 771495 934100 $1066 $910 $838 $859 $877 $899 917296 935002 951324
Health amp Welfare 684945 688899 738189 809638 812857 895714 961902 1050100 1172304 1208786 $1230 $1341 $1414 $1489 $1583 $1674 1797938 1922668 2071273
OPEB Current Payment 318501 346316 355716 394218 413164 472619 479079 501716 562233 563754 $604 $645 $704 $766 $835 $910 982025 1060022 1142795
Pensions 897450 1021229 1029710 1074598 1328441 1301975 1304355 1248726 1370474 1345308 $1336 $1494 $1461 $1462 $1403 $1347 1357887 1369071 1380572
Other-Fringe Benefits 502739 517194 539996 581661 650430 694680 784143 861079 947870 792151 $881 $869 $897 $930 $956 $976 1001185 1021007 1040170
Reimbursable Overhead (310555) (322230) (345154) (324006) (309399) (321390) (349770) (380212) (423759) (491807) ($528) ($471) ($430) ($412) ($397) ($395) (396136) (405509) (413165)
Labor Expenses $6652131 $6914045 $6933059 $7235017 $7663467 $7997128 $8581574 $8732302 $9239358 $9799 $10116 $10306 $10592 $10881 $11121 $11413 $11520401 $11885220 $12280075
PayrollOvertime Exp as a of Total Operating+DS $0426 $0427 $0407 $0396 $0387 $0374 $0389 $0383 $0376 $0390 $0367 $0365 $0359 $0355 $0350 $0349 $0347 $0345
Labor Exp (wo Reimb OH) as a of Total Oper+DS $0650 $0663 $0642 $0637 $0647 $0628 $0643 $0640 $0648 $0642 $0622 $0626 $0622 $0616 $0609 $0614 $0617 $0620
PayrollOvertime Exp as a of Total Operating Exp $0496 $0490 $0483 $0473 $0465 $0453 $0464 $0459 $0450 $0464 $0435 $0438 $0434 $0433 $0430 $0426 $0420 $0416
Labor Exp (wo Reimb OH) as a of Total Oper Exp $0758 $0761 $0762 $0761 $0777 $0761 $0768 $0768 $0776 $0763 $0739 $0750 $0751 $0750 $0749 $0748 $0747 $0747
Non-Labor Expenses
Electric Power $306500 $317934 $325137 $457269 $471514 $493346 $515540 $473762 $406372 $481893 $451503 $473177 $493090 $532413 $561955 $571182 $589565 $618283 $648255
Traction Power
Non-Traction Power
Fuel 287033 180294 189942 282735 251763 259252 267494 162283 124684 185203 182778 182981 176333 173681 176920 182259 182476 184281 186170
Revenue Vehicle Fuel
Non-Revenue Fuel
Insurance 28902 34012 9819 14363 7617 38654 50739 57190 (20634) (29402) 5608 15623 23118 26855 28309 36048 28232 25538 19483
Claims 152114 238104 285418 315547 135652 299875 269167 331023 463959 437985 387557 394211 392547 398256 406112 404397 417667 428660 437683
Paratransit Service Contracts 299013 370094 379761 348553 360500 366751 365599 379271 383704 455471 494751 488330 505538 535329 568614 581114 604766 643217 684112
Maintenance and Other Operating Contracts 594215 562456 541716 451137 451766 496743 549018 579289 630924 678425 840168 797428 833534 836606 854471 879468 880053 898882 915477
Professional Service Contracts 196930 199164 203084 226205 276998 297201 283005 379814 399706 543582 607838 502858 494814 504103 513895 499724 520826 537109 547291
Materials amp Supplies 532534 526191 511206 438310 430804 475127 526725 543225 585607 637078 689010 679895 697976 711281 715758 711988 741335 777460 793419
Other Business Expenses 155466 184142 189637 169857 143807 167198 179701 195598 192576 220838 218196 213551 224459 226170 228457 244907 228861 240258 241690
Non-Labor Expenses $2552708 $2612391 $2635720 $2703976 $2530421 $2894147 $3006988 $3101454 $3166897 3611 3877 3748 3841 3945 4054 4111 $4193782 $4353689 $4473580
Other Expense Adjustments
Other ($13712) ($14750) ($18292) ($2289) $62593 $46175 $44973 $37007 $47404 129 175 86 36 22 23 23 $23516 $24069 $24637
General Reserve 0000 0000 0000 0000 0000 - 0 - 0 - 0 - 0 0 165 170 175 180 185 185 190000 195000 205000
Other Expense Adjustments ($13712) ($14750) ($18292) ($2289) $62593 $46175 $44973 $37007 $47404 $128555 $340 $256 $211 $202 $208 $208 $213516 $219069 $229637
Gap Closing Expenses $7675394
Additional Actions for Budget Balance Expense Impact $0000 $0000 $0000 $0000 $0000 $0000 $0000 $0000 $0000 $0000 $0000 $0000 $0000 $0000 $0000 $0000 $0000 $0000 $0000
Total Operating Expenses Before Non-Cash Liability Adjs $9191127 $9511685 $9550486 $9936705 $10256481 $10937450 $11633535 $11870763 $12453659 $13538830 $14332772 $14309678 $14643965 $15027767 $15383584 $15732241 $15927699 $16457978 $16983292
Non-Cash Liability Adjustments
Depreciation $1790981 $1940576 $1980681 $2019378 $2148820 $2174302 $2266280 $2442777 $2442941 $2607970 $2804571 $2784812 $2842737 $2908533 $2977025 $3051834 $3109882 $3169371 $3230301
OPEB Obligation 1348962 1104827 1167070 1706939 1785881 1920189 2035457 1489656 1562261 1567381 0000 (0000) (0000) (0000) (0000) 0000 0000 (0000) (0000)
GASB 75 OPEB Expense Adjustment 0000 0000 0000 0000 0000 0000 0000 0000 0000 0000 1047747 1457230 1628196 1748560 1823313 1898497 1952374 2006482 2061993
GASB 68 Pension Expense Adjustment 0000 0000 0000 0000 0000 0000 0000 (410019) (218911) (168119) (373022) (220864) (271921) (342847) (318372) (242446) (237864) (234492) (230942)
Environmental Remediation 42249 6062 18621 59079 24742 14257 20556 20576 11691 13468 105615 6000 6000 6000 6000 6000 6000 6000 6000
Non-Cash Liability Adjustments $3182192 $3051466 $3166371 $3785396 $3959443 $4108749 $4322293 $3542990 $3797981 $4020699 $3584911 $4027178 $4205012 $4320246 $4487966 $4713886 $4830392 $4947361 $5067352
Total Operating Expenses After Non-Cash Liability Adjs $12373319 $12563151 $12716857 $13722101 $14215924 $15046199 $15955827 $15413753 $16251641 $17559529 $17917683 $18336856 $18848977 $19348013 $19871550 $20446127 $20758090 $21405338 $22050644
Less BampT Depreciation $77213 $80097 $77846 $86545 $87926 $91345 $104039 $109783 $135035 $240957 $148686 $151977 $158779 $169848 $181689 $194355 $194355 $194355 $194355
BampT Other Post Employment Benefits 66323 50967 54831 66686 73055 76641 71148 62457 60441 78106 32297 22256 20303 22870 28694 33918 36169 38411 40604
Net Operating Deficit Before Subsidies and Debt Service ($6409807) ($6419266) ($6222079) ($6711095) ($7081966) ($7146057) ($7887759) ($6954506) ($7643392) ($8785339) ($8829030) ($9141907) ($9642826) ($10116260) ($10611154) ($11515498) ($11364824) ($11950106) ($12573710)
Conversion to Cash Basis Non-Cash Liability Adjs ($3182192) ($3051466) ($3166371) ($3785396) ($3959443) ($4108749) ($4322293) ($3542990) ($3797981) ($4020699) ($3584911) ($4027178) ($4205012) ($4320246) ($4487966) ($4713886) ($4830392) ($4947361) ($5067352)
Total Operating Expenses $9191127 $9511685 $9550486 $9936705 $10256481 $10937450 $11633535 $11870763 $12453659 $13539 $14333 $14310 $14644 $15028 $15384 $15732 $15927699 $16457978 $16983292
Debt Service Expenses $1515733 $1404454 $1781220 $1933532 $2058395 $2299262 $2248538 $2373321 $2458783 $2541 $2683 $2830 $3041 $3265 $3513 $3450 $3471321 $3472987 $3501639
Total Expenses + Debt Service $10706859 $10916139 $11331706 $11870237 $12314876 $13236712 $13882073 $14244084 $14912443 $16079 $17016 $17140 $17685 $18293 $18896 $19182 $19399019 $19930965 $20484932
Net Deficit After Subsidies and Debt Service ($668477) ($620796) ($0414) $287848 $320833 $556541 $561498 $810173 $359895 ($128044) ($613) ($539) ($898) ($1258) ($1667) ($2283) ($1901641) ($2229069) ($2664369)
Conversion to Cash Basis GASB Account (56067) (54256) (67377) (37636) (89548) (85641) (50017) - 0 - 0 0 0 0 $0 0 0 - 0 - 0 - 0 - 0
Conversion to Cash Basis 492710 550267 91781 (111037) (297407) (261709) (626297) (660147) (591809) 379 229 147 60 125 101 130 49745 48375 54220
Net Cash Balance from Previous Year 0000 0000 0000 23990 139174 0000 209191 0000 150026 0000 250569 0000 0000 0000 0000 0000 0000 0000 0000
Total Operating Exp + DS + Cash Conversions + PY C-O $11144 $11412 $11356 $11746 $12067 $12889362 $13414950 $13583937 $14470659 $16457999 $17495351 $17286526 $17744425 $18418197 $18997710 $19312017 $19448764 $19979340 $20539152
Total Operating Expenses with Cash Conversion $10270216 $10420127 $11307302 $12018911 $12701831 $13584063 $14558387 $14904231 $15504252 $15700774 $16786574 $16992579 $17624861 $18167420 $18795069 $19052755 $19349274 $19882590 $20430711
Baseline Net Cash Balance Before B-T-L Adjustments ($231834) ($124785) $23990 $139174 ($66122) $209191 ($114816) $150026 ($231914) $251 ($384) ($392) ($838) ($1133) ($1566) ($2153) ($1851896) ($2180695) ($2610148)
Below-the-Line Adjustments
FareToll Increases
FareToll Increase in March 2019 (4 Yield) - 0 $0 $0 $0 $0 $0 $0 - 0 - 0 - 0
FareToll Increase in March 2021 (4 Yield) - 0 $0 $0 $0 $283 $331 $332 333531 333568 334299
FareToll Increase in March 2023 (4 Yield) - 0 $0 $0 $0 $0 $0 $294 346386 346424 347183
FareToll Increase in March 2025 (4 Yield) - 0 $0 $0 $0 $0 $0 $0 - 0 273859 321624
Subsidy Impacts of 20212023 FareToll Increase - 0 $0 $0 $0 ($7) ($9) ($17) (18612) (25573) (26305)
$0000 $0 $0 $0 $275 $322 $609 $661306 $928278 $976801
CASH BALANCE AFTER FARE INCREASES $250569 ($384) ($392) ($838) ($850) ($1234) ($1821) ($1518365) ($1847127) ($2275849)
MTA Initiatives
MTA Efficiencies - Not Yet Implemented - 0 $0 $0 $0 $0 $0 $0 0000 0000 0000
0 - 0 $0 $0 $0 $0 $0 $0 - 0 - 0 - 0
0 - 0 $0 $0 $0 $0 $0 $0 - 0 - 0 - 0
$0000 $0 $0 $0 $0 $0 $0 $0000 $0000 $0000
Policy Actions
CAS Migration to Peoplesoft $0 $0 ($5) ($1) ($0) ($0) (0200) -02 -02 0
Fare Evasion Enforcement Strategy-Expenses $0 ($13) ($12) ($11) ($10) ($10) (9554) -9554483 -9554483 0
Fare Evasion Enforcement-Manhattan DA Forfeiture Fund $0 $11 $11 $10 $9 $0 - 0 0 0 0
Negotiated 1 CBA Reform $0 $0 $0 $0 $0 $0 - 0 0 0 0
MTA Reorganization $0 $8 $180 $371 $377 $377 377000 377 377 0
MTA Reorganization Costs $0 $0 ($10) ($27) ($2) $0 - 0 0 0 0
Drawdown 2019 General Reserve $0 $0 $165 $0 $0 $0 - 0 0 0 0
CBA Negotiated Reform - 1 Value $0 $36 $100 $173 $246 $323 323473 323473304484 323473304484 0
$0000 $0 $42 $429 $515 $620 $691 $690719 $690719 $690719
MTA Re-estimates
Additional Savings Actions $0000 $0 $0 $0 $0 $0 $0 $0000 $0000 $0000
Total Below-the-Line Adjustments $0 $73 $386 $757 $852 $1133 $1007 $1352025 $1618997 $1667520
Prior Year Carryover 495399 263336 138286 161986 301160 235038 444229 329413 479439 121 372 61 55 0 0 - 0 - 0 - 0 - 0
NET CASH BALANCE $263566 $138551 $162276 $301160 $235038 $444229 $329413 $479439 $247525 $372 $61 $55 ($26) ($281) ($433) ($1146) ($499871) ($561698) ($942628)
MTA February Financial Plan 2019-2022
Consolidated Statement Of Operations By Category ($ in millions)
Non-Reimbursable Final Adopted
Actual Actual Actual Actual Actual Actual Actual Actual Actual Actual Estimate Budget
2008 2009 2010 2011 2012 2013 2014 2015 2016 2017 2018 2019 2020 2021 2022 2023 2024 2025 2026
Operating Revenues
Farebox Revenue $4240923 $4350411 $4586377 $4999186 $5079138 $5501274 $5709200 $5961129 $6050182 $6172 $6153 $6122 $6144 $6134 $6144 $6174 $6435176 $6431979 $6446633
422 423 405 411 402 399 395 396 396 407 279 275 272 267 263 261 368 363 362
Student Fare - 0 - 0 - 0 - 0 - 0 - 0
Toll Revenue 1273974 1332115 1417046 1501589 1490982 1645193 1676445 1808901 1869693 1912 1967 1984 1990 1998 1998 2002 2133050 2137871 2143111
0127 0129 0125 0124 0118 0119 0116 0120 0122 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0122 0121 0120
Other Revenue 448616 461359 491355 510231 563839 753675 682424 689217 688374 653 662 705 733 757 743 755 825040 885381 887190
Capital and Other Reimbursements 0000 0000 0000 0000 0000 0000 0000 0000 0000 0000 0000 0000 0000 0000 0000 0000 0000 0000 0000
Total Operating Revenue $5963512 $6143885 $6494778 $7011006 $7133959 $7900142 $8068069 $8459247 $8608249 $8737 $8782 $8810 $8867 $8889 $8886 $8931 $9393266 $9455232 $9476934
Dedicated Taxes $3211585 $2366805 $2343537 $2511691 $2673119 $3097640 $3383498 $3582628 $3525829 $3257508 $3459 $3515 $3568 $3630 $3725 $3812 $3841433 $3880226 $3917215
PMT amp MTA Aid - 0 881784 1588677 1718286 1825824 1825328 1885069 1910947 1970760 1987035 $1965 $2152 $2225 $2295 $2368 $2442 2516095 2594604 2677041
New Funding Sources - 0 - 0 - 0 - 0 - 0 - 0 - 0 - 0 - 0 - 0 $508 $342 $385 $385 $385 $385 385000 385000 385000
StateLocal Taxes 556691 539046 544810 541733 536182 537527 539545 537819 537645 541005 $544 $552 $557 $562 $567 $572 576828 581933 583214
Other Funding Agreements 306594 363823 359489 375369 466625 432617 567391 563616 629855 630218 $701 $753 $671 $708 $758 $758 784755 804901 781159
BampT Operating Surplus Transfer 382565 363092 476059 554903 476575 614210 637553 750717 742909 740144 $702 $721 $782 $801 $789 $707 730476 695303 688833
Dedicated Taxes and StateLocal Subsidies $4457434 $4514550 $5312572 $5701982 $5978325 $6507322 $7013056 $7345727 $7406998 $7155909 $7879 $8035 $8188 $8381 $8592 $8676 $8834588 $8941967 $9032462
$0000 $0000 $0000 $0000 $0000 $0000 $0000 $0000 $0000
Less Interagency Subsidy and Surplus Transfers (382565) (363092) (476059) (554903) (476575) (614210) (637553) (750717) (742909) (740144) ($702) ($721) ($782) ($801) ($789) ($707) (730476) (695303) (688833)
Total Subsidies $4074870 $4151458 $4836513 $5147079 $5501750 $5893111 $6375503 $6595010 $6664088 $6416 $7242 $7238 $7370 $7576 $7807 $7969 $8104112 $8246664 $8343629
Dedicated Taxes as a of Total Revenues + Subs - PMT 320 251 241 241 247 259 269 273 265 247 $0 $0 $0 $0 $0 $0 256 257 259
Total Revenues + Subsidies $10038382 $10295342 $11331292 $12158085 $12635709 $13793254 $14443571 $15054257 $15272337 $15152 $16023 $16048 $16237 $16465 $16693 $16900 $17497378 $17701896 $17820563
Operating Expenses
Labor Expenses
Payroll $4087376 $4163330 $4171374 $4160261 $4193658 $4332829 $4671664 $4695823 $4838741 $5020713 $5211 $5328 $5422 $5498 $5624 $5710 $5860206 $5982960 $6107107
Overtime 471675 499307 443227 538647 574316 620701 730200 755071 771495 934100 $1066 $910 $838 $859 $877 $899 917296 935002 951324
Health amp Welfare 684945 688899 738189 809638 812857 895714 961902 1050100 1172304 1208786 $1230 $1341 $1414 $1489 $1583 $1674 1797938 1922668 2071273
OPEB Current Payment 318501 346316 355716 394218 413164 472619 479079 501716 562233 563754 $604 $645 $704 $766 $835 $910 982025 1060022 1142795
Pensions 897450 1021229 1029710 1074598 1328441 1301975 1304355 1248726 1370474 1345308 $1336 $1494 $1461 $1462 $1403 $1347 1357887 1369071 1380572
Other-Fringe Benefits 502739 517194 539996 581661 650430 694680 784143 861079 947870 792151 $881 $869 $897 $930 $956 $976 1001185 1021007 1040170
Reimbursable Overhead (310555) (322230) (345154) (324006) (309399) (321390) (349770) (380212) (423759) (491807) ($528) ($471) ($430) ($412) ($397) ($395) (396136) (405509) (413165)
Labor Expenses $6652131 $6914045 $6933059 $7235017 $7663467 $7997128 $8581574 $8732302 $9239358 $9373 $9920 $10039 $10436 $10787 $11097 $11413 $11520401 $11885220 $12280075
PayrollOvertime Exp as a of Total Operating+DS $0426 $0427 $0407 $0396 $0387 $0374 $0389 $0383 $0376 $0385 $0349 $0347 $0345
Labor Exp (wo Reimb OH) as a of Total Oper+DS $0650 $0663 $0642 $0637 $0647 $0628 $0643 $0640 $0648 $0638 $0614 $0617 $0620
PayrollOvertime Exp as a of Total Operating Exp $0496 $0490 $0483 $0473 $0465 $0453 $0464 $0459 $0450 $0461 $0426 $0420 $0416
Labor Exp (wo Reimb OH) as a of Total Oper Exp $0758 $0761 $0762 $0761 $0777 $0761 $0768 $0768 $0776 $0763 $0748 $0747 $0747
Non-Labor Expenses
Electric Power $306500 $317934 $325137 $457269 $471514 $493346 $515540 $473762 $406372 $430381 $474918 $451304 $463523 $482662 $539624 $571182 $589565 $618283 $648255
Traction Power
Non-Traction Power
Fuel 287033 180294 189942 282735 251763 259252 267494 162283 124684 150481 185580 190348 187592 183168 181484 182259 182476 184281 186170
Revenue Vehicle Fuel
Non-Revenue Fuel
Insurance 28902 34012 9819 14363 7617 38654 50739 57190 (20634) (2715) 11488 8532 15803 22918 29411 36048 28232 25538 19483
Claims 152114 238104 285418 315547 135652 299875 269167 331023 463959 526053 376480 378570 386981 391333 395228 404397 417667 428660 437683
Paratransit Service Contracts 299013 370094 379761 348553 360500 366751 365599 379271 383704 392850 452190 482751 501230 518038 547829 581114 604766 643217 684112
Maintenance and Other Operating Contracts 594215 562456 541716 451137 451766 496743 549018 579289 630924 695251 779331 897801 833038 883805 871671 879468 880053 898882 915477
Professional Service Contracts 196930 199164 203084 226205 276998 297201 283005 379814 399706 507062 575742 557476 484911 479376 489510 499724 520826 537109 547291
Materials amp Supplies 532534 526191 511206 438310 430804 475127 526725 543225 585607 588115 667700 686666 687745 692131 697268 711988 741335 777460 793419
Other Business Expenses 155466 184142 189637 169857 143807 167198 179701 195598 192576 217254 225494 230595 225293 240279 242193 244907 228861 240258 241690
Non-Labor Expenses $2552708 $2612391 $2635720 $2703976 $2530421 $2894147 $3006988 $3101454 $3166897 3505 3749 3884 3786 3894 3994 4111 $4193782 $4353689 $4473580
Other Expense Adjustments
Other ($13712) ($14750) ($18292) ($2289) $62593 $46175 $44973 $37007 $47404 49 134 158 84 36 22 23 $23516 $24069 $24637
General Reserve 0000 0000 0000 0000 0000 - 0 - 0 - 0 - 0 0 0 165 170 175 180 185 190000 195000 205000
Other Expense Adjustments ($13712) ($14750) ($18292) ($2289) $62593 $46175 $44973 $37007 $47404 $49379 $134 $323 $254 $211 $202 $208 $213516 $219069 $229637
Gap Closing Expenses $7675394
Additional Actions for Budget Balance Expense Impact $0000 $0000 $0000 $0000 $0000 $0000 $0000 $0000 $0000 $0000 $0000 $0000 $0000 $0000 $0000 $0000 $0000 $0000 $0000
Total Operating Expenses Before Non-Cash Liability Adjs $9191127 $9511685 $9550486 $9936705 $10256481 $10937450 $11633535 $11870763 $12453659 $12927116 $13802910 $14246122 $14475644 $14891445 $15293262 $15732241 $15927699 $16457978 $16983292
Non-Cash Liability Adjustments
Depreciation $1790981 $1940576 $1980681 $2019378 $2148820 $2174302 $2266280 $2442777 $2442941 $2607970 $2804571 $2784812 $2842737 $2908533 $2977025 $3051834 $3109882 $3169371 $3230301
OPEB Obligation 1348962 1104827 1167070 1706939 1785881 1920189 2035457 1489656 1562261 1567381 0000 (0000) (0000) (0000) (0000) 0000 0000 (0000) (0000)
GASB 75 OPEB Expense Adjustment 0000 0000 0000 0000 0000 0000 0000 0000 0000 0000 1047747 1457230 1628196 1748560 1823313 1898497 1952374 2006482 2061993
GASB 68 Pension Expense Adjustment 0000 0000 0000 0000 0000 0000 0000 (410019) (218911) (168119) (373022) (220864) (271921) (342847) (318372) (242446) (237864) (234492) (230942)
Environmental Remediation 42249 6062 18621 59079 24742 14257 20556 20576 11691 13468 105615 6000 6000 6000 6000 6000 6000 6000 6000
Non-Cash Liability Adjustments $3182192 $3051466 $3166371 $3785396 $3959443 $4108749 $4322293 $3542990 $3797981 $4020699 $3584911 $4027178 $4205012 $4320246 $4487966 $4713886 $4830392 $4947361 $5067352
Total Operating Expenses After Non-Cash Liability Adjs $12373319 $12563151 $12716857 $13722101 $14215924 $15046199 $15955827 $15413753 $16251641 $16947815 $17387821 $18273301 $18680657 $19211690 $19781228 $20446127 $20758090 $21405338 $22050644
Less BampT Depreciation $77213 $80097 $77846 $86545 $87926 $91345 $104039 $109783 $135035 $240957 $148686 $151977 $158779 $169848 $181689 $194355 $194355 $194355 $194355
BampT Other Post Employment Benefits 66323 50967 54831 66686 73055 76641 71148 62457 60441 78106 32297 22256 20303 22870 28694 33918 36169 38411 40604
Net Operating Deficit Before Subsidies and Debt Service ($6409807) ($6419266) ($6222079) ($6711095) ($7081966) ($7146057) ($7887759) ($6954506) ($7643392) ($8211234) ($8606220) ($9463506) ($9813560) ($10322912) ($10895644) ($11515498) ($11364824) ($11950106) ($12573710)
Conversion to Cash Basis Non-Cash Liability Adjs ($3182192) ($3051466) ($3166371) ($3785396) ($3959443) ($4108749) ($4322293) ($3542990) ($3797981) ($4020699) ($3584911) ($4027178) ($4205012) ($4320246) ($4487966) ($4713886) ($4830392) ($4947361) ($5067352)
Total Operating Expenses $9191127 $9511685 $9550486 $9936705 $10256481 $10937450 $11633535 $11870763 $12453659 $12927 $13803 $14246 $14476 $14891 $15293 $15732 $15927699 $16457978 $16983292
Debt Service Expenses $1515733 $1404454 $1781220 $1933532 $2058395 $2299262 $2248538 $2373321 $2458783 $2525 $2559 $2692 $2840 $3080 $3223 $3450 $3471321 $3472987 $3501639
Total Expenses + Debt Service $10706859 $10916139 $11331706 $11870237 $12314876 $13236712 $13882073 $14244084 $14912443 $15452 $16362 $16938 $17316 $17971 $18516 $19182 $19399019 $19930965 $20484932
Net Deficit After Subsidies and Debt Service ($668477) ($620796) ($0414) $287848 $320833 $556541 $561498 $810173 $359895 ($299965) ($339) ($890) ($1079) ($1506) ($1823) ($2283) ($1901641) ($2229069) ($2664369)
Conversion to Cash Basis GASB Account (56067) (54256) (67377) (37636) (89548) (85641) (50017) - 0 - 0 0 0 0 $0 0 0 - 0 - 0 - 0 - 0
Conversion to Cash Basis 492710 550267 91781 (111037) (297407) (261709) (626297) (660147) (591809) 174 296 363 188 (17) 88 130 49745 48375 54220
Net Cash Balance from Previous Year 0000 0000 0000 23990 139174 0000 209191 0000 150026 0000 0000 0000 0000 0000 0000 0000 0000 0000 0000
Total Operating Exp + DS + Cash Conversions + PY C-O $11144 $11412 $11356 $11746 $12067 $12889362 $13414950 $13583937 $14470659 $15625875 $16658585 $17300293 $17504155 $17954574 $18604130 $19312017 $19448764 $19979340 $20539152
Total Operating Expenses with Cash Conversion $10270216 $10420127 $11307302 $12018911 $12701831 $13584063 $14558387 $14904231 $15504252 $15278749 $16065734 $16575223 $17128079 $17987951 $18427778 $19052755 $19349274 $19882590 $20430711
Baseline Net Cash Balance Before B-T-L Adjustments ($231834) ($124785) $23990 $139174 ($66122) $209191 ($114816) $150026 ($231914) ($126) ($43) ($527) ($891) ($1523) ($1735) ($2153) ($1851896) ($2180695) ($2610148)
Below-the-Line Adjustments
FareToll Increases
FareToll Increase in March 2019 (4 Yield) - 0 $0 $0 $0 $0 $0 $0 - 0 - 0 - 0
FareToll Increase in March 2021 (4 Yield) - 0 $0 $0 $0 $283 $331 $332 333531 333568 334299
FareToll Increase in March 2023 (4 Yield) - 0 $0 $0 $0 $0 $0 $294 346386 346424 347183
FareToll Increase in March 2025 (4 Yield) - 0 $0 $0 $0 $0 $0 $0 - 0 273859 321624
Subsidy Impacts of 20212023 FareToll Increase - 0 $0 $0 $0 ($7) ($9) ($17) (18612) (25573) (26305)
$0000 $0 $0 $0 $275 $322 $609 $661306 $928278 $976801
CASH BALANCE AFTER FARE INCREASES ($126402) ($43) ($527) ($891) ($1241) ($1404) ($1821) ($1518365) ($1847127) ($2275849)
MTA Initiatives
MTA Efficiencies - Not Yet Implemented - 0 $0 $0 $0 $0 $0 $0 0000 0000 0000
0 - 0 $0 $0 $0 $0 $0 $0 - 0 - 0 - 0
0 - 0 $0 $0 $0 $0 $0 $0 - 0 - 0 - 0
$0000 $0 $0 $0 $0 $0 $0 $0000 $0000 $0000
Policy Actions
CAS Migration to Peoplesoft $0 $0 ($5) ($1) ($0) ($0) (0200) -02 -02 0
Fare Evasion Enforcement Strategy-Expenses $0 ($13) ($12) ($11) ($10) ($10) (9554) -9554483 -9554483 0
Fare Evasion Enforcement-Manhattan DA Forfeiture Fund $0 $11 $11 $10 $9 $0 - 0 0 0 0
Negotiated 1 CBA Reform $0 $0 $0 $0 $0 $0 - 0 0 0 0
MTA Reorganization $0 $8 $180 $371 $377 $377 377000 377 377 0
MTA Reorganization Costs $0 $0 ($10) ($27) ($2) $0 - 0 0 0 0
Drawdown 2019 General Reserve $0 $0 $165 $0 $0 $0 - 0 0 0 0
CBA Negotiated Reform - 1 Value $0 $36 $100 $173 $246 $323 323473 323473304484 323473304484 0
$0000 $0 $42 $429 $515 $620 $691 $690719 $690719 $690719
MTA Re-estimates
Additional Savings Actions $0000 $0 $0 $0 $0 $0 $0 $0000 $0000 $0000
Total Below-the-Line Adjustments $0 $0 $459 $413 $709 $760 $1007 $1352025 $1618997 $1667520
Prior Year Carryover 495399 263336 138286 161986 301160 235038 444229 329413 479439 248 121 79 11 0 0 - 0 - 0 - 0 - 0
NET CASH BALANCE $263566 $138551 $162276 $301160 $235038 $444229 $329413 $479439 $247525 $121 $79 $11 ($467) ($814) ($976) ($1146) ($499871) ($561698) ($942628)
By Revenue Source
(includes faretoll increases)
($ in millions)
Farebox Revenue $6389
Toll Revenue 2121
Other Revenue 684
Dedicated Taxes 6191
State and Local amp Other 1228
Timing (Cash Adjustments) 135
Total $16748
By Expense Category
(includes below-the-line adjustments)
($ in millions)
Payroll $5422
Overtime 838
Health amp Welfare 2118
Pension 1461
Other Labor 466
Total Labor $10306
Non-Labor + Other Exp Adj 4004
Debt Service 2830
BTL Adjustments for Expenses 2 (386)
Total $16754
By Revenue Source
(includes faretoll increases)
($ in millions)
Farebox Revenue $6389
Toll Revenue 2121
Other Revenue 684
Taxes 6178
State and Local amp Other 557
Other Funding Agreements 671
Other 1 208
Total $16809
By Expense Category
(includes below-the-line adjustments)
($ in millions)
Payroll $5392
Overtime 811
Health amp Welfare 2129
Pension 1354
Other Labor 400
Total Labor $10086
Non-Labor 4205
Debt Service 2692
BTL Adjustments for Expenses (251)
Total $16732
Page 8: MTA 2020 Preliminary Budget July Financial Plan 2020 - 2023 2020 Preliminar… · 1 The MTA Budget Process July Plan – Start of the Annual Process • Current year is revised (the

MTA Transformation Plan

bull State-mandated plan to review operations and implement changes to streamline internal processes clarify responsibilities solidify accountability and work more efficiently to regain trust of our customers and funding partners and improve MTArsquos ability to deliver safe and reliable service our customers deserve

bull Plan recommendationsbull Refocus the operating agencies on mission-critical operating priorities of safety reliability and

servicebull Centralize common support functions to improve operations and create opportunities to ensure

consistent standards quality and policies across departmentsbull Unify the management of capital programs to improve and streamline planning development

and construction so capital improvements can be delivered on time and on budgetbull Expand senior leadership by adding a Chief Transformation Officer a Chief Operating Officer a

Chief Engineering Officer and an MTA Accessibility Officer

bull Consolidation and efficiency targets of $370 million to $530 million on an annual basis have been identified

bull If the MTA Transformation Plan is approved and implemented the July Financial Plan will have small operating balances in 2019 and 2020 a small deficit in 2021 with out-year deficits reaching $433 million in 2023

7

8

The adoption and implementation of the MTA Transformation Planhas the potential to significantly reduce out-year deficits

($ in millions)

This Year Next Year Out-Years

11

(467)

(814)

(976)

NA

61 55

(26)

(281)

(433)

($1200)

($1000)

($800)

($600)

($400)

($200)

$0

$200

2019 2020 2021 2022 2023

February PlanProposed July Plan

Actions to Reduce Fare Evasion $62 million Investment over the Plan Period

bull Increase physical presence (500 uniformed officers NYPD MTA Police and Bridge and Tunnel Officers) to begin enforcement at 50 subway stations and 50 bus routesThis is not just a fare evasion effort but a workerrsquos safety initiative

bull Ensure enforcement does not target any specific demographic bull Educate MTA riders utilizing messaging media and automated

announcementsbull Improve operation of emergency exit gates to mitigate instances of fare

avoidancebull Augment surveillance capabilities by deploying fare array cameras at 50

stations and pilot the use of monitors at 10 stationsbull $40 million of the investment will be funded by Manhattan DA Office over a

four-year period

9

The MTArsquos $350 million target for annually recurring savings beginning in 2020 has been identified and is being implemented

109

10 7 6 6

96 304 351 362 371

$0

$50

$100

$150

$200

$250

$300

$350

$400

2019 2020 2021 2022 2023

Identified Recurring Savings One-Shot Savings

This Year Next Year Out-Years

($ in millions)

10

We have a track record of identifying and achieving our annual recurring savings targets

11

($ in millions)

$0

$500

$1000

$1500

$2000

$2500

$3000

Achieved Savings

2012 November Plan

2013 November Plan

2014 November Plan

2015 November Plan

2016 November Plan

2017 November Plan

2018 November Plan

2019 July Plan

$28 billion

Proposed July Plan

Deficits remain and a continued drive toward further streamlining and efficiencies is required

12

($ in millions)

61 55

(26)

(281)

(433)

($600)

($500)

($400)

($300)

($200)

($100)

$0

$100

$200

2019 2020 2021 2022 2023

This Year Next Year Out-Years

Proposed July PlanDonrsquot achieve Transformation Plan Savings

13

If the MTA Transformation Plan is not adopted and implemented the deficits will be unmanageable without service cuts significant

reductions in force andor additional fare and toll increases($ in millions)

($1100)

($900)

($700)

($500)

($300)

($100)

$100

2019 2020 2021 2022 2023

(816)

(971)

(569)

(81)

(433)

(281)

61 55 (26)

(281) (186)

50

Next Year Out-Years

(230)(11)

(488)

(538)

(535)

This Year

14

2020 Preliminary BudgetWhere the Dollars Come Fromhellip Where the Dollars Gohellip

Farebox Revenue $6389Toll Revenue 2121 Other Revenue 684 Taxes 6178 State and Local amp Other 557 Other Funding Agreements 671 Other 1 208 Total $16809

($ in millions)

By Revenue Source(includes faretoll increases)

Payroll $5422Overtime 838 Health amp Welfare 2118 Pension 1461 Other Labor 466 Total Labor $10306Non-Labor + Other Exp Adj 4004 Debt Service 2830 BTL Adjustments for Expenses 2 (386) Total $16754

By Expense Category

($ in millions)(includes below-the-line adjustments)

1 Includes cash adjustments and prior-year carryover

Farebox Revenue

38

Toll Revenue

13

Other Revenue4

Taxes37

State amp Local

Subsidies3

Other Funding Agreements

4 Other 1

Payroll32

Overtime5

Health ampWelfare

13Pension

9

Other Labor3

Non-Labor + Other Exp Adj

21

Debt Service17

2 The below-the-line adjustments are grouped in the Non-Labor category

Sheet1

Sheet1

15

Non-Reimbursable Mid-Year Preliminary Actual Forecast Budget

2018 2019 2020 2021 2022 2023 Operating Revenues

Farebox Revenue $6155 $6305 $6389 $6373 $6384 $6393Toll Revenue 1976 2088 2121 2129 2129 2131 Other Revenue 643 696 684 704 719 737

Total Operating Revenue $8774 $9089 $9195 $9206 $9232 $9260

Total Subsidies $7177 $7314 $7406 $7581 $7803 $7969Dedicated Taxes as a of Total Revenues + Subs - PMT 233 $0 $0 $0 $0 $0

Total Revenues + Subsidies $15951 $16403 $16601 $16787 $17035 $17229

Operating ExpensesLabor Expenses $9799 $10116 $10306 $10592 $10881 $11121Non-Labor Expenses 3611 3877 3748 3841 3945 4054 Other 129 175 86 36 22 23 General Reserve 0 165 170 175 180 185

Total Operating Expenses $13539 $14333 $14310 $14644 $15028 $15384

Debt Service Expenses $2541 $2683 $2830 $3041 $3265 $3513

Total Expenses + Debt Service $16079 $17016 $17140 $17685 $18293 $18896

Conversion to Cash Basis 379 229 147 60 125 101

Baseline Net Cash Balance Before B-T-L Adjustments $251 ($384) ($392) ($838) ($1133) ($1566)

Total Below-the-Line Adjustments $0 $73 $386 $757 $852 $1133Prior Year Carryover 121 372 61 55 0 0

NET CASH BALANCE $372 $61 $55 ($26) ($281) ($433)

MTA July Financial Plan 2020-2023Consolidated Statement Of Operations By Category ($ in millions)

Summ Stmt of Ops-Feb

Summ Stmt of Ops-Jul

  • MTA 2020Preliminary BudgetJuly Financial Plan2020 - 2023
  • The MTA Budget Process
  • Slide Number 3
  • Slide Number 4
  • What has changed since the February Plan
  • Highlights of the July Plan
  • Slide Number 7
  • MTA Transformation Plan
  • Slide Number 9
  • Actions to Reduce Fare Evasion $62 million Investment over the Plan Period
  • The MTArsquos $350 million target for annually recurring savings beginning in 2020 has been identified and is being implemented
  • We have a track record of identifying and achieving our annual recurring savings targets
  • Deficits remain and a continued drive toward further streamlining and efficiencies is required
  • Slide Number 14
  • 2020 Preliminary Budget
  • Slide Number 16
MTA July Financial Plan 2020-2023
Consolidated Statement Of Operations By Category ($ in millions)
Non-Reimbursable Mid-Year Preliminary
Actual Actual Actual Actual Actual Actual Actual Actual Actual Actual Forecast Budget
2008 2009 2010 2011 2012 2013 2014 2015 2016 2018 2019 2020 2021 2022 2023 2023 2024 2025 2026
Operating Revenues
Farebox Revenue $4240923 $4350411 $4586377 $4999186 $5079138 $5501274 $5709200 $5961129 $6050182 $6155 $6305 $6389 $6373 $6384 $6393 $6174 $6435176 $6431979 $6446633
422 423 405 411 402 399 395 396 396 386 384 385 380 375 371 261 368 363 362
Student Fare - 0 - 0 - 0 - 0 - 0 - 0
Toll Revenue 1273974 1332115 1417046 1501589 1490982 1645193 1676445 1808901 1869693 1976 2088 2121 2129 2129 2131 2002 2133050 2137871 2143111
0127 0129 0125 0124 0118 0119 0116 0120 0122 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0122 0121 0120
Other Revenue 448616 461359 491355 510231 563839 753675 682424 689217 688374 643 696 684 704 719 737 755 825040 885381 887190
Capital and Other Reimbursements 0000 0000 0000 0000 0000 0000 0000 0000 0000 0000 0000 0000 0000 0000 0000 0000 0000 0000 0000
Total Operating Revenue $5963512 $6143885 $6494778 $7011006 $7133959 $7900142 $8068069 $8459247 $8608249 $8774 $9089 $9195 $9206 $9232 $9260 $8931 $9393266 $9455232 $9476934
Dedicated Taxes $3211585 $2366805 $2343537 $2511691 $2673119 $3097640 $3383498 $3582628 $3525829 $3257508 $3459 $3515 $3568 $3630 $3725 $3812 $3841433 $3880226 $3917215
PMT amp MTA Aid - 0 881784 1588677 1718286 1825824 1825328 1885069 1910947 1970760 1987035 $1965 $2152 $2225 $2295 $2368 $2442 2516095 2594604 2677041
New Funding Sources - 0 - 0 - 0 - 0 - 0 - 0 - 0 - 0 - 0 - 0 $508 $342 $385 $385 $385 $385 385000 385000 385000
StateLocal Taxes 556691 539046 544810 541733 536182 537527 539545 537819 537645 541005 $544 $552 $557 $562 $567 $572 576828 581933 583214
Other Funding Agreements 306594 363823 359489 375369 466625 432617 567391 563616 629855 630218 $701 $753 $671 $708 $758 $758 784755 804901 781159
BampT Operating Surplus Transfer 382565 363092 476059 554903 476575 614210 637553 750717 742909 740144 $702 $721 $782 $801 $789 $707 730476 695303 688833
Dedicated Taxes and StateLocal Subsidies $4457434 $4514550 $5312572 $5701982 $5978325 $6507322 $7013056 $7345727 $7406998 $7155909 $7879 $8035 $8188 $8381 $8592 $8676 $8834588 $8941967 $9032462
$0000 $0000 $0000 $0000 $0000 $0000 $0000 $0000 $0000
Less Interagency Subsidy and Surplus Transfers (382565) (363092) (476059) (554903) (476575) (614210) (637553) (750717) (742909) (740144) ($702) ($721) ($782) ($801) ($789) ($707) (730476) (695303) (688833)
Total Subsidies $4074870 $4151458 $4836513 $5147079 $5501750 $5893111 $6375503 $6595010 $6664088 $7177 $7314 $7406 $7581 $7803 $7969 $7969 $8104112 $8246664 $8343629
Dedicated Taxes as a of Total Revenues + Subs - PMT 320 251 241 241 247 259 269 273 265 233 $0 $0 $0 $0 $0 $0 256 257 259
Total Revenues + Subsidies $10038382 $10295342 $11331292 $12158085 $12635709 $13793254 $14443571 $15054257 $15272337 $15951 $16403 $16601 $16787 $17035 $17229 $16900 $17497378 $17701896 $17820563
Operating Expenses
Labor Expenses
Payroll $4087376 $4163330 $4171374 $4160261 $4193658 $4332829 $4671664 $4695823 $4838741 $5020713 $5211 $5328 $5422 $5498 $5624 $5710 $5860206 $5982960 $6107107
Overtime 471675 499307 443227 538647 574316 620701 730200 755071 771495 934100 $1066 $910 $838 $859 $877 $899 917296 935002 951324
Health amp Welfare 684945 688899 738189 809638 812857 895714 961902 1050100 1172304 1208786 $1230 $1341 $1414 $1489 $1583 $1674 1797938 1922668 2071273
OPEB Current Payment 318501 346316 355716 394218 413164 472619 479079 501716 562233 563754 $604 $645 $704 $766 $835 $910 982025 1060022 1142795
Pensions 897450 1021229 1029710 1074598 1328441 1301975 1304355 1248726 1370474 1345308 $1336 $1494 $1461 $1462 $1403 $1347 1357887 1369071 1380572
Other-Fringe Benefits 502739 517194 539996 581661 650430 694680 784143 861079 947870 792151 $881 $869 $897 $930 $956 $976 1001185 1021007 1040170
Reimbursable Overhead (310555) (322230) (345154) (324006) (309399) (321390) (349770) (380212) (423759) (491807) ($528) ($471) ($430) ($412) ($397) ($395) (396136) (405509) (413165)
Labor Expenses $6652131 $6914045 $6933059 $7235017 $7663467 $7997128 $8581574 $8732302 $9239358 $9799 $10116 $10306 $10592 $10881 $11121 $11413 $11520401 $11885220 $12280075
PayrollOvertime Exp as a of Total Operating+DS $0426 $0427 $0407 $0396 $0387 $0374 $0389 $0383 $0376 $0390 $0367 $0365 $0359 $0355 $0350 $0349 $0347 $0345
Labor Exp (wo Reimb OH) as a of Total Oper+DS $0650 $0663 $0642 $0637 $0647 $0628 $0643 $0640 $0648 $0642 $0622 $0626 $0622 $0616 $0609 $0614 $0617 $0620
PayrollOvertime Exp as a of Total Operating Exp $0496 $0490 $0483 $0473 $0465 $0453 $0464 $0459 $0450 $0464 $0435 $0438 $0434 $0433 $0430 $0426 $0420 $0416
Labor Exp (wo Reimb OH) as a of Total Oper Exp $0758 $0761 $0762 $0761 $0777 $0761 $0768 $0768 $0776 $0763 $0739 $0750 $0751 $0750 $0749 $0748 $0747 $0747
Non-Labor Expenses
Electric Power $306500 $317934 $325137 $457269 $471514 $493346 $515540 $473762 $406372 $481893 $451503 $473177 $493090 $532413 $561955 $571182 $589565 $618283 $648255
Traction Power
Non-Traction Power
Fuel 287033 180294 189942 282735 251763 259252 267494 162283 124684 185203 182778 182981 176333 173681 176920 182259 182476 184281 186170
Revenue Vehicle Fuel
Non-Revenue Fuel
Insurance 28902 34012 9819 14363 7617 38654 50739 57190 (20634) (29402) 5608 15623 23118 26855 28309 36048 28232 25538 19483
Claims 152114 238104 285418 315547 135652 299875 269167 331023 463959 437985 387557 394211 392547 398256 406112 404397 417667 428660 437683
Paratransit Service Contracts 299013 370094 379761 348553 360500 366751 365599 379271 383704 455471 494751 488330 505538 535329 568614 581114 604766 643217 684112
Maintenance and Other Operating Contracts 594215 562456 541716 451137 451766 496743 549018 579289 630924 678425 840168 797428 833534 836606 854471 879468 880053 898882 915477
Professional Service Contracts 196930 199164 203084 226205 276998 297201 283005 379814 399706 543582 607838 502858 494814 504103 513895 499724 520826 537109 547291
Materials amp Supplies 532534 526191 511206 438310 430804 475127 526725 543225 585607 637078 689010 679895 697976 711281 715758 711988 741335 777460 793419
Other Business Expenses 155466 184142 189637 169857 143807 167198 179701 195598 192576 220838 218196 213551 224459 226170 228457 244907 228861 240258 241690
Non-Labor Expenses $2552708 $2612391 $2635720 $2703976 $2530421 $2894147 $3006988 $3101454 $3166897 3611 3877 3748 3841 3945 4054 4111 $4193782 $4353689 $4473580
Other Expense Adjustments
Other ($13712) ($14750) ($18292) ($2289) $62593 $46175 $44973 $37007 $47404 129 175 86 36 22 23 23 $23516 $24069 $24637
General Reserve 0000 0000 0000 0000 0000 - 0 - 0 - 0 - 0 0 165 170 175 180 185 185 190000 195000 205000
Other Expense Adjustments ($13712) ($14750) ($18292) ($2289) $62593 $46175 $44973 $37007 $47404 $128555 $340 $256 $211 $202 $208 $208 $213516 $219069 $229637
Gap Closing Expenses $7675394
Additional Actions for Budget Balance Expense Impact $0000 $0000 $0000 $0000 $0000 $0000 $0000 $0000 $0000 $0000 $0000 $0000 $0000 $0000 $0000 $0000 $0000 $0000 $0000
Total Operating Expenses Before Non-Cash Liability Adjs $9191127 $9511685 $9550486 $9936705 $10256481 $10937450 $11633535 $11870763 $12453659 $13538830 $14332772 $14309678 $14643965 $15027767 $15383584 $15732241 $15927699 $16457978 $16983292
Non-Cash Liability Adjustments
Depreciation $1790981 $1940576 $1980681 $2019378 $2148820 $2174302 $2266280 $2442777 $2442941 $2607970 $2804571 $2784812 $2842737 $2908533 $2977025 $3051834 $3109882 $3169371 $3230301
OPEB Obligation 1348962 1104827 1167070 1706939 1785881 1920189 2035457 1489656 1562261 1567381 0000 (0000) (0000) (0000) (0000) 0000 0000 (0000) (0000)
GASB 75 OPEB Expense Adjustment 0000 0000 0000 0000 0000 0000 0000 0000 0000 0000 1047747 1457230 1628196 1748560 1823313 1898497 1952374 2006482 2061993
GASB 68 Pension Expense Adjustment 0000 0000 0000 0000 0000 0000 0000 (410019) (218911) (168119) (373022) (220864) (271921) (342847) (318372) (242446) (237864) (234492) (230942)
Environmental Remediation 42249 6062 18621 59079 24742 14257 20556 20576 11691 13468 105615 6000 6000 6000 6000 6000 6000 6000 6000
Non-Cash Liability Adjustments $3182192 $3051466 $3166371 $3785396 $3959443 $4108749 $4322293 $3542990 $3797981 $4020699 $3584911 $4027178 $4205012 $4320246 $4487966 $4713886 $4830392 $4947361 $5067352
Total Operating Expenses After Non-Cash Liability Adjs $12373319 $12563151 $12716857 $13722101 $14215924 $15046199 $15955827 $15413753 $16251641 $17559529 $17917683 $18336856 $18848977 $19348013 $19871550 $20446127 $20758090 $21405338 $22050644
Less BampT Depreciation $77213 $80097 $77846 $86545 $87926 $91345 $104039 $109783 $135035 $240957 $148686 $151977 $158779 $169848 $181689 $194355 $194355 $194355 $194355
BampT Other Post Employment Benefits 66323 50967 54831 66686 73055 76641 71148 62457 60441 78106 32297 22256 20303 22870 28694 33918 36169 38411 40604
Net Operating Deficit Before Subsidies and Debt Service ($6409807) ($6419266) ($6222079) ($6711095) ($7081966) ($7146057) ($7887759) ($6954506) ($7643392) ($8785339) ($8829030) ($9141907) ($9642826) ($10116260) ($10611154) ($11515498) ($11364824) ($11950106) ($12573710)
Conversion to Cash Basis Non-Cash Liability Adjs ($3182192) ($3051466) ($3166371) ($3785396) ($3959443) ($4108749) ($4322293) ($3542990) ($3797981) ($4020699) ($3584911) ($4027178) ($4205012) ($4320246) ($4487966) ($4713886) ($4830392) ($4947361) ($5067352)
Total Operating Expenses $9191127 $9511685 $9550486 $9936705 $10256481 $10937450 $11633535 $11870763 $12453659 $13539 $14333 $14310 $14644 $15028 $15384 $15732 $15927699 $16457978 $16983292
Debt Service Expenses $1515733 $1404454 $1781220 $1933532 $2058395 $2299262 $2248538 $2373321 $2458783 $2541 $2683 $2830 $3041 $3265 $3513 $3450 $3471321 $3472987 $3501639
Total Expenses + Debt Service $10706859 $10916139 $11331706 $11870237 $12314876 $13236712 $13882073 $14244084 $14912443 $16079 $17016 $17140 $17685 $18293 $18896 $19182 $19399019 $19930965 $20484932
Net Deficit After Subsidies and Debt Service ($668477) ($620796) ($0414) $287848 $320833 $556541 $561498 $810173 $359895 ($128044) ($613) ($539) ($898) ($1258) ($1667) ($2283) ($1901641) ($2229069) ($2664369)
Conversion to Cash Basis GASB Account (56067) (54256) (67377) (37636) (89548) (85641) (50017) - 0 - 0 0 0 0 $0 0 0 - 0 - 0 - 0 - 0
Conversion to Cash Basis 492710 550267 91781 (111037) (297407) (261709) (626297) (660147) (591809) 379 229 147 60 125 101 130 49745 48375 54220
Net Cash Balance from Previous Year 0000 0000 0000 23990 139174 0000 209191 0000 150026 0000 250569 0000 0000 0000 0000 0000 0000 0000 0000
Total Operating Exp + DS + Cash Conversions + PY C-O $11144 $11412 $11356 $11746 $12067 $12889362 $13414950 $13583937 $14470659 $16457999 $17495351 $17286526 $17744425 $18418197 $18997710 $19312017 $19448764 $19979340 $20539152
Total Operating Expenses with Cash Conversion $10270216 $10420127 $11307302 $12018911 $12701831 $13584063 $14558387 $14904231 $15504252 $15700774 $16786574 $16992579 $17624861 $18167420 $18795069 $19052755 $19349274 $19882590 $20430711
Baseline Net Cash Balance Before B-T-L Adjustments ($231834) ($124785) $23990 $139174 ($66122) $209191 ($114816) $150026 ($231914) $251 ($384) ($392) ($838) ($1133) ($1566) ($2153) ($1851896) ($2180695) ($2610148)
Below-the-Line Adjustments
FareToll Increases
FareToll Increase in March 2019 (4 Yield) - 0 $0 $0 $0 $0 $0 $0 - 0 - 0 - 0
FareToll Increase in March 2021 (4 Yield) - 0 $0 $0 $0 $283 $331 $332 333531 333568 334299
FareToll Increase in March 2023 (4 Yield) - 0 $0 $0 $0 $0 $0 $294 346386 346424 347183
FareToll Increase in March 2025 (4 Yield) - 0 $0 $0 $0 $0 $0 $0 - 0 273859 321624
Subsidy Impacts of 20212023 FareToll Increase - 0 $0 $0 $0 ($7) ($9) ($17) (18612) (25573) (26305)
$0000 $0 $0 $0 $275 $322 $609 $661306 $928278 $976801
CASH BALANCE AFTER FARE INCREASES $250569 ($384) ($392) ($838) ($850) ($1234) ($1821) ($1518365) ($1847127) ($2275849)
MTA Initiatives
MTA Efficiencies - Not Yet Implemented - 0 $0 $0 $0 $0 $0 $0 0000 0000 0000
0 - 0 $0 $0 $0 $0 $0 $0 - 0 - 0 - 0
0 - 0 $0 $0 $0 $0 $0 $0 - 0 - 0 - 0
$0000 $0 $0 $0 $0 $0 $0 $0000 $0000 $0000
Policy Actions
CAS Migration to Peoplesoft $0 $0 ($5) ($1) ($0) ($0) (0200) -02 -02 0
Fare Evasion Enforcement Strategy-Expenses $0 ($13) ($12) ($11) ($10) ($10) (9554) -9554483 -9554483 0
Fare Evasion Enforcement-Manhattan DA Forfeiture Fund $0 $11 $11 $10 $9 $0 - 0 0 0 0
Negotiated 1 CBA Reform $0 $0 $0 $0 $0 $0 - 0 0 0 0
MTA Reorganization $0 $8 $180 $371 $377 $377 377000 377 377 0
MTA Reorganization Costs $0 $0 ($10) ($27) ($2) $0 - 0 0 0 0
Drawdown 2019 General Reserve $0 $0 $165 $0 $0 $0 - 0 0 0 0
CBA Negotiated Reform - 1 Value $0 $36 $100 $173 $246 $323 323473 323473304484 323473304484 0
$0000 $0 $42 $429 $515 $620 $691 $690719 $690719 $690719
MTA Re-estimates
Additional Savings Actions $0000 $0 $0 $0 $0 $0 $0 $0000 $0000 $0000
Total Below-the-Line Adjustments $0 $73 $386 $757 $852 $1133 $1007 $1352025 $1618997 $1667520
Prior Year Carryover 495399 263336 138286 161986 301160 235038 444229 329413 479439 121 372 61 55 0 0 - 0 - 0 - 0 - 0
NET CASH BALANCE $263566 $138551 $162276 $301160 $235038 $444229 $329413 $479439 $247525 $372 $61 $55 ($26) ($281) ($433) ($1146) ($499871) ($561698) ($942628)
MTA February Financial Plan 2019-2022
Consolidated Statement Of Operations By Category ($ in millions)
Non-Reimbursable Final Adopted
Actual Actual Actual Actual Actual Actual Actual Actual Actual Actual Estimate Budget
2008 2009 2010 2011 2012 2013 2014 2015 2016 2017 2018 2019 2020 2021 2022 2023 2024 2025 2026
Operating Revenues
Farebox Revenue $4240923 $4350411 $4586377 $4999186 $5079138 $5501274 $5709200 $5961129 $6050182 $6172 $6153 $6122 $6144 $6134 $6144 $6174 $6435176 $6431979 $6446633
422 423 405 411 402 399 395 396 396 407 279 275 272 267 263 261 368 363 362
Student Fare - 0 - 0 - 0 - 0 - 0 - 0
Toll Revenue 1273974 1332115 1417046 1501589 1490982 1645193 1676445 1808901 1869693 1912 1967 1984 1990 1998 1998 2002 2133050 2137871 2143111
0127 0129 0125 0124 0118 0119 0116 0120 0122 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0122 0121 0120
Other Revenue 448616 461359 491355 510231 563839 753675 682424 689217 688374 653 662 705 733 757 743 755 825040 885381 887190
Capital and Other Reimbursements 0000 0000 0000 0000 0000 0000 0000 0000 0000 0000 0000 0000 0000 0000 0000 0000 0000 0000 0000
Total Operating Revenue $5963512 $6143885 $6494778 $7011006 $7133959 $7900142 $8068069 $8459247 $8608249 $8737 $8782 $8810 $8867 $8889 $8886 $8931 $9393266 $9455232 $9476934
Dedicated Taxes $3211585 $2366805 $2343537 $2511691 $2673119 $3097640 $3383498 $3582628 $3525829 $3257508 $3459 $3515 $3568 $3630 $3725 $3812 $3841433 $3880226 $3917215
PMT amp MTA Aid - 0 881784 1588677 1718286 1825824 1825328 1885069 1910947 1970760 1987035 $1965 $2152 $2225 $2295 $2368 $2442 2516095 2594604 2677041
New Funding Sources - 0 - 0 - 0 - 0 - 0 - 0 - 0 - 0 - 0 - 0 $508 $342 $385 $385 $385 $385 385000 385000 385000
StateLocal Taxes 556691 539046 544810 541733 536182 537527 539545 537819 537645 541005 $544 $552 $557 $562 $567 $572 576828 581933 583214
Other Funding Agreements 306594 363823 359489 375369 466625 432617 567391 563616 629855 630218 $701 $753 $671 $708 $758 $758 784755 804901 781159
BampT Operating Surplus Transfer 382565 363092 476059 554903 476575 614210 637553 750717 742909 740144 $702 $721 $782 $801 $789 $707 730476 695303 688833
Dedicated Taxes and StateLocal Subsidies $4457434 $4514550 $5312572 $5701982 $5978325 $6507322 $7013056 $7345727 $7406998 $7155909 $7879 $8035 $8188 $8381 $8592 $8676 $8834588 $8941967 $9032462
$0000 $0000 $0000 $0000 $0000 $0000 $0000 $0000 $0000
Less Interagency Subsidy and Surplus Transfers (382565) (363092) (476059) (554903) (476575) (614210) (637553) (750717) (742909) (740144) ($702) ($721) ($782) ($801) ($789) ($707) (730476) (695303) (688833)
Total Subsidies $4074870 $4151458 $4836513 $5147079 $5501750 $5893111 $6375503 $6595010 $6664088 $6416 $7242 $7238 $7370 $7576 $7807 $7969 $8104112 $8246664 $8343629
Dedicated Taxes as a of Total Revenues + Subs - PMT 320 251 241 241 247 259 269 273 265 247 $0 $0 $0 $0 $0 $0 256 257 259
Total Revenues + Subsidies $10038382 $10295342 $11331292 $12158085 $12635709 $13793254 $14443571 $15054257 $15272337 $15152 $16023 $16048 $16237 $16465 $16693 $16900 $17497378 $17701896 $17820563
Operating Expenses
Labor Expenses
Payroll $4087376 $4163330 $4171374 $4160261 $4193658 $4332829 $4671664 $4695823 $4838741 $5020713 $5211 $5328 $5422 $5498 $5624 $5710 $5860206 $5982960 $6107107
Overtime 471675 499307 443227 538647 574316 620701 730200 755071 771495 934100 $1066 $910 $838 $859 $877 $899 917296 935002 951324
Health amp Welfare 684945 688899 738189 809638 812857 895714 961902 1050100 1172304 1208786 $1230 $1341 $1414 $1489 $1583 $1674 1797938 1922668 2071273
OPEB Current Payment 318501 346316 355716 394218 413164 472619 479079 501716 562233 563754 $604 $645 $704 $766 $835 $910 982025 1060022 1142795
Pensions 897450 1021229 1029710 1074598 1328441 1301975 1304355 1248726 1370474 1345308 $1336 $1494 $1461 $1462 $1403 $1347 1357887 1369071 1380572
Other-Fringe Benefits 502739 517194 539996 581661 650430 694680 784143 861079 947870 792151 $881 $869 $897 $930 $956 $976 1001185 1021007 1040170
Reimbursable Overhead (310555) (322230) (345154) (324006) (309399) (321390) (349770) (380212) (423759) (491807) ($528) ($471) ($430) ($412) ($397) ($395) (396136) (405509) (413165)
Labor Expenses $6652131 $6914045 $6933059 $7235017 $7663467 $7997128 $8581574 $8732302 $9239358 $9373 $9920 $10039 $10436 $10787 $11097 $11413 $11520401 $11885220 $12280075
PayrollOvertime Exp as a of Total Operating+DS $0426 $0427 $0407 $0396 $0387 $0374 $0389 $0383 $0376 $0385 $0349 $0347 $0345
Labor Exp (wo Reimb OH) as a of Total Oper+DS $0650 $0663 $0642 $0637 $0647 $0628 $0643 $0640 $0648 $0638 $0614 $0617 $0620
PayrollOvertime Exp as a of Total Operating Exp $0496 $0490 $0483 $0473 $0465 $0453 $0464 $0459 $0450 $0461 $0426 $0420 $0416
Labor Exp (wo Reimb OH) as a of Total Oper Exp $0758 $0761 $0762 $0761 $0777 $0761 $0768 $0768 $0776 $0763 $0748 $0747 $0747
Non-Labor Expenses
Electric Power $306500 $317934 $325137 $457269 $471514 $493346 $515540 $473762 $406372 $430381 $474918 $451304 $463523 $482662 $539624 $571182 $589565 $618283 $648255
Traction Power
Non-Traction Power
Fuel 287033 180294 189942 282735 251763 259252 267494 162283 124684 150481 185580 190348 187592 183168 181484 182259 182476 184281 186170
Revenue Vehicle Fuel
Non-Revenue Fuel
Insurance 28902 34012 9819 14363 7617 38654 50739 57190 (20634) (2715) 11488 8532 15803 22918 29411 36048 28232 25538 19483
Claims 152114 238104 285418 315547 135652 299875 269167 331023 463959 526053 376480 378570 386981 391333 395228 404397 417667 428660 437683
Paratransit Service Contracts 299013 370094 379761 348553 360500 366751 365599 379271 383704 392850 452190 482751 501230 518038 547829 581114 604766 643217 684112
Maintenance and Other Operating Contracts 594215 562456 541716 451137 451766 496743 549018 579289 630924 695251 779331 897801 833038 883805 871671 879468 880053 898882 915477
Professional Service Contracts 196930 199164 203084 226205 276998 297201 283005 379814 399706 507062 575742 557476 484911 479376 489510 499724 520826 537109 547291
Materials amp Supplies 532534 526191 511206 438310 430804 475127 526725 543225 585607 588115 667700 686666 687745 692131 697268 711988 741335 777460 793419
Other Business Expenses 155466 184142 189637 169857 143807 167198 179701 195598 192576 217254 225494 230595 225293 240279 242193 244907 228861 240258 241690
Non-Labor Expenses $2552708 $2612391 $2635720 $2703976 $2530421 $2894147 $3006988 $3101454 $3166897 3505 3749 3884 3786 3894 3994 4111 $4193782 $4353689 $4473580
Other Expense Adjustments
Other ($13712) ($14750) ($18292) ($2289) $62593 $46175 $44973 $37007 $47404 49 134 158 84 36 22 23 $23516 $24069 $24637
General Reserve 0000 0000 0000 0000 0000 - 0 - 0 - 0 - 0 0 0 165 170 175 180 185 190000 195000 205000
Other Expense Adjustments ($13712) ($14750) ($18292) ($2289) $62593 $46175 $44973 $37007 $47404 $49379 $134 $323 $254 $211 $202 $208 $213516 $219069 $229637
Gap Closing Expenses $7675394
Additional Actions for Budget Balance Expense Impact $0000 $0000 $0000 $0000 $0000 $0000 $0000 $0000 $0000 $0000 $0000 $0000 $0000 $0000 $0000 $0000 $0000 $0000 $0000
Total Operating Expenses Before Non-Cash Liability Adjs $9191127 $9511685 $9550486 $9936705 $10256481 $10937450 $11633535 $11870763 $12453659 $12927116 $13802910 $14246122 $14475644 $14891445 $15293262 $15732241 $15927699 $16457978 $16983292
Non-Cash Liability Adjustments
Depreciation $1790981 $1940576 $1980681 $2019378 $2148820 $2174302 $2266280 $2442777 $2442941 $2607970 $2804571 $2784812 $2842737 $2908533 $2977025 $3051834 $3109882 $3169371 $3230301
OPEB Obligation 1348962 1104827 1167070 1706939 1785881 1920189 2035457 1489656 1562261 1567381 0000 (0000) (0000) (0000) (0000) 0000 0000 (0000) (0000)
GASB 75 OPEB Expense Adjustment 0000 0000 0000 0000 0000 0000 0000 0000 0000 0000 1047747 1457230 1628196 1748560 1823313 1898497 1952374 2006482 2061993
GASB 68 Pension Expense Adjustment 0000 0000 0000 0000 0000 0000 0000 (410019) (218911) (168119) (373022) (220864) (271921) (342847) (318372) (242446) (237864) (234492) (230942)
Environmental Remediation 42249 6062 18621 59079 24742 14257 20556 20576 11691 13468 105615 6000 6000 6000 6000 6000 6000 6000 6000
Non-Cash Liability Adjustments $3182192 $3051466 $3166371 $3785396 $3959443 $4108749 $4322293 $3542990 $3797981 $4020699 $3584911 $4027178 $4205012 $4320246 $4487966 $4713886 $4830392 $4947361 $5067352
Total Operating Expenses After Non-Cash Liability Adjs $12373319 $12563151 $12716857 $13722101 $14215924 $15046199 $15955827 $15413753 $16251641 $16947815 $17387821 $18273301 $18680657 $19211690 $19781228 $20446127 $20758090 $21405338 $22050644
Less BampT Depreciation $77213 $80097 $77846 $86545 $87926 $91345 $104039 $109783 $135035 $240957 $148686 $151977 $158779 $169848 $181689 $194355 $194355 $194355 $194355
BampT Other Post Employment Benefits 66323 50967 54831 66686 73055 76641 71148 62457 60441 78106 32297 22256 20303 22870 28694 33918 36169 38411 40604
Net Operating Deficit Before Subsidies and Debt Service ($6409807) ($6419266) ($6222079) ($6711095) ($7081966) ($7146057) ($7887759) ($6954506) ($7643392) ($8211234) ($8606220) ($9463506) ($9813560) ($10322912) ($10895644) ($11515498) ($11364824) ($11950106) ($12573710)
Conversion to Cash Basis Non-Cash Liability Adjs ($3182192) ($3051466) ($3166371) ($3785396) ($3959443) ($4108749) ($4322293) ($3542990) ($3797981) ($4020699) ($3584911) ($4027178) ($4205012) ($4320246) ($4487966) ($4713886) ($4830392) ($4947361) ($5067352)
Total Operating Expenses $9191127 $9511685 $9550486 $9936705 $10256481 $10937450 $11633535 $11870763 $12453659 $12927 $13803 $14246 $14476 $14891 $15293 $15732 $15927699 $16457978 $16983292
Debt Service Expenses $1515733 $1404454 $1781220 $1933532 $2058395 $2299262 $2248538 $2373321 $2458783 $2525 $2559 $2692 $2840 $3080 $3223 $3450 $3471321 $3472987 $3501639
Total Expenses + Debt Service $10706859 $10916139 $11331706 $11870237 $12314876 $13236712 $13882073 $14244084 $14912443 $15452 $16362 $16938 $17316 $17971 $18516 $19182 $19399019 $19930965 $20484932
Net Deficit After Subsidies and Debt Service ($668477) ($620796) ($0414) $287848 $320833 $556541 $561498 $810173 $359895 ($299965) ($339) ($890) ($1079) ($1506) ($1823) ($2283) ($1901641) ($2229069) ($2664369)
Conversion to Cash Basis GASB Account (56067) (54256) (67377) (37636) (89548) (85641) (50017) - 0 - 0 0 0 0 $0 0 0 - 0 - 0 - 0 - 0
Conversion to Cash Basis 492710 550267 91781 (111037) (297407) (261709) (626297) (660147) (591809) 174 296 363 188 (17) 88 130 49745 48375 54220
Net Cash Balance from Previous Year 0000 0000 0000 23990 139174 0000 209191 0000 150026 0000 0000 0000 0000 0000 0000 0000 0000 0000 0000
Total Operating Exp + DS + Cash Conversions + PY C-O $11144 $11412 $11356 $11746 $12067 $12889362 $13414950 $13583937 $14470659 $15625875 $16658585 $17300293 $17504155 $17954574 $18604130 $19312017 $19448764 $19979340 $20539152
Total Operating Expenses with Cash Conversion $10270216 $10420127 $11307302 $12018911 $12701831 $13584063 $14558387 $14904231 $15504252 $15278749 $16065734 $16575223 $17128079 $17987951 $18427778 $19052755 $19349274 $19882590 $20430711
Baseline Net Cash Balance Before B-T-L Adjustments ($231834) ($124785) $23990 $139174 ($66122) $209191 ($114816) $150026 ($231914) ($126) ($43) ($527) ($891) ($1523) ($1735) ($2153) ($1851896) ($2180695) ($2610148)
Below-the-Line Adjustments
FareToll Increases
FareToll Increase in March 2019 (4 Yield) - 0 $0 $0 $0 $0 $0 $0 - 0 - 0 - 0
FareToll Increase in March 2021 (4 Yield) - 0 $0 $0 $0 $283 $331 $332 333531 333568 334299
FareToll Increase in March 2023 (4 Yield) - 0 $0 $0 $0 $0 $0 $294 346386 346424 347183
FareToll Increase in March 2025 (4 Yield) - 0 $0 $0 $0 $0 $0 $0 - 0 273859 321624
Subsidy Impacts of 20212023 FareToll Increase - 0 $0 $0 $0 ($7) ($9) ($17) (18612) (25573) (26305)
$0000 $0 $0 $0 $275 $322 $609 $661306 $928278 $976801
CASH BALANCE AFTER FARE INCREASES ($126402) ($43) ($527) ($891) ($1241) ($1404) ($1821) ($1518365) ($1847127) ($2275849)
MTA Initiatives
MTA Efficiencies - Not Yet Implemented - 0 $0 $0 $0 $0 $0 $0 0000 0000 0000
0 - 0 $0 $0 $0 $0 $0 $0 - 0 - 0 - 0
0 - 0 $0 $0 $0 $0 $0 $0 - 0 - 0 - 0
$0000 $0 $0 $0 $0 $0 $0 $0000 $0000 $0000
Policy Actions
CAS Migration to Peoplesoft $0 $0 ($5) ($1) ($0) ($0) (0200) -02 -02 0
Fare Evasion Enforcement Strategy-Expenses $0 ($13) ($12) ($11) ($10) ($10) (9554) -9554483 -9554483 0
Fare Evasion Enforcement-Manhattan DA Forfeiture Fund $0 $11 $11 $10 $9 $0 - 0 0 0 0
Negotiated 1 CBA Reform $0 $0 $0 $0 $0 $0 - 0 0 0 0
MTA Reorganization $0 $8 $180 $371 $377 $377 377000 377 377 0
MTA Reorganization Costs $0 $0 ($10) ($27) ($2) $0 - 0 0 0 0
Drawdown 2019 General Reserve $0 $0 $165 $0 $0 $0 - 0 0 0 0
CBA Negotiated Reform - 1 Value $0 $36 $100 $173 $246 $323 323473 323473304484 323473304484 0
$0000 $0 $42 $429 $515 $620 $691 $690719 $690719 $690719
MTA Re-estimates
Additional Savings Actions $0000 $0 $0 $0 $0 $0 $0 $0000 $0000 $0000
Total Below-the-Line Adjustments $0 $0 $459 $413 $709 $760 $1007 $1352025 $1618997 $1667520
Prior Year Carryover 495399 263336 138286 161986 301160 235038 444229 329413 479439 248 121 79 11 0 0 - 0 - 0 - 0 - 0
NET CASH BALANCE $263566 $138551 $162276 $301160 $235038 $444229 $329413 $479439 $247525 $121 $79 $11 ($467) ($814) ($976) ($1146) ($499871) ($561698) ($942628)
By Revenue Source
(includes faretoll increases)
($ in millions)
Farebox Revenue $6389
Toll Revenue 2121
Other Revenue 684
Dedicated Taxes 6191
State and Local amp Other 1228
Timing (Cash Adjustments) 135
Total $16748
By Expense Category
(includes below-the-line adjustments)
($ in millions)
Payroll $5422
Overtime 838
Health amp Welfare 2118
Pension 1461
Other Labor 466
Total Labor $10306
Non-Labor + Other Exp Adj 4004
Debt Service 2830
BTL Adjustments for Expenses 2 (386)
Total $16754
By Revenue Source
(includes faretoll increases)
($ in millions)
Farebox Revenue $6389
Toll Revenue 2121
Other Revenue 684
Taxes 6178
State and Local amp Other 557
Other Funding Agreements 671
Other 1 208
Total $16809
By Expense Category
(includes below-the-line adjustments)
($ in millions)
Payroll $5392
Overtime 811
Health amp Welfare 2129
Pension 1354
Other Labor 400
Total Labor $10086
Non-Labor 4205
Debt Service 2692
BTL Adjustments for Expenses (251)
Total $16732
Page 9: MTA 2020 Preliminary Budget July Financial Plan 2020 - 2023 2020 Preliminar… · 1 The MTA Budget Process July Plan – Start of the Annual Process • Current year is revised (the

8

The adoption and implementation of the MTA Transformation Planhas the potential to significantly reduce out-year deficits

($ in millions)

This Year Next Year Out-Years

11

(467)

(814)

(976)

NA

61 55

(26)

(281)

(433)

($1200)

($1000)

($800)

($600)

($400)

($200)

$0

$200

2019 2020 2021 2022 2023

February PlanProposed July Plan

Actions to Reduce Fare Evasion $62 million Investment over the Plan Period

bull Increase physical presence (500 uniformed officers NYPD MTA Police and Bridge and Tunnel Officers) to begin enforcement at 50 subway stations and 50 bus routesThis is not just a fare evasion effort but a workerrsquos safety initiative

bull Ensure enforcement does not target any specific demographic bull Educate MTA riders utilizing messaging media and automated

announcementsbull Improve operation of emergency exit gates to mitigate instances of fare

avoidancebull Augment surveillance capabilities by deploying fare array cameras at 50

stations and pilot the use of monitors at 10 stationsbull $40 million of the investment will be funded by Manhattan DA Office over a

four-year period

9

The MTArsquos $350 million target for annually recurring savings beginning in 2020 has been identified and is being implemented

109

10 7 6 6

96 304 351 362 371

$0

$50

$100

$150

$200

$250

$300

$350

$400

2019 2020 2021 2022 2023

Identified Recurring Savings One-Shot Savings

This Year Next Year Out-Years

($ in millions)

10

We have a track record of identifying and achieving our annual recurring savings targets

11

($ in millions)

$0

$500

$1000

$1500

$2000

$2500

$3000

Achieved Savings

2012 November Plan

2013 November Plan

2014 November Plan

2015 November Plan

2016 November Plan

2017 November Plan

2018 November Plan

2019 July Plan

$28 billion

Proposed July Plan

Deficits remain and a continued drive toward further streamlining and efficiencies is required

12

($ in millions)

61 55

(26)

(281)

(433)

($600)

($500)

($400)

($300)

($200)

($100)

$0

$100

$200

2019 2020 2021 2022 2023

This Year Next Year Out-Years

Proposed July PlanDonrsquot achieve Transformation Plan Savings

13

If the MTA Transformation Plan is not adopted and implemented the deficits will be unmanageable without service cuts significant

reductions in force andor additional fare and toll increases($ in millions)

($1100)

($900)

($700)

($500)

($300)

($100)

$100

2019 2020 2021 2022 2023

(816)

(971)

(569)

(81)

(433)

(281)

61 55 (26)

(281) (186)

50

Next Year Out-Years

(230)(11)

(488)

(538)

(535)

This Year

14

2020 Preliminary BudgetWhere the Dollars Come Fromhellip Where the Dollars Gohellip

Farebox Revenue $6389Toll Revenue 2121 Other Revenue 684 Taxes 6178 State and Local amp Other 557 Other Funding Agreements 671 Other 1 208 Total $16809

($ in millions)

By Revenue Source(includes faretoll increases)

Payroll $5422Overtime 838 Health amp Welfare 2118 Pension 1461 Other Labor 466 Total Labor $10306Non-Labor + Other Exp Adj 4004 Debt Service 2830 BTL Adjustments for Expenses 2 (386) Total $16754

By Expense Category

($ in millions)(includes below-the-line adjustments)

1 Includes cash adjustments and prior-year carryover

Farebox Revenue

38

Toll Revenue

13

Other Revenue4

Taxes37

State amp Local

Subsidies3

Other Funding Agreements

4 Other 1

Payroll32

Overtime5

Health ampWelfare

13Pension

9

Other Labor3

Non-Labor + Other Exp Adj

21

Debt Service17

2 The below-the-line adjustments are grouped in the Non-Labor category

Sheet1

Sheet1

15

Non-Reimbursable Mid-Year Preliminary Actual Forecast Budget

2018 2019 2020 2021 2022 2023 Operating Revenues

Farebox Revenue $6155 $6305 $6389 $6373 $6384 $6393Toll Revenue 1976 2088 2121 2129 2129 2131 Other Revenue 643 696 684 704 719 737

Total Operating Revenue $8774 $9089 $9195 $9206 $9232 $9260

Total Subsidies $7177 $7314 $7406 $7581 $7803 $7969Dedicated Taxes as a of Total Revenues + Subs - PMT 233 $0 $0 $0 $0 $0

Total Revenues + Subsidies $15951 $16403 $16601 $16787 $17035 $17229

Operating ExpensesLabor Expenses $9799 $10116 $10306 $10592 $10881 $11121Non-Labor Expenses 3611 3877 3748 3841 3945 4054 Other 129 175 86 36 22 23 General Reserve 0 165 170 175 180 185

Total Operating Expenses $13539 $14333 $14310 $14644 $15028 $15384

Debt Service Expenses $2541 $2683 $2830 $3041 $3265 $3513

Total Expenses + Debt Service $16079 $17016 $17140 $17685 $18293 $18896

Conversion to Cash Basis 379 229 147 60 125 101

Baseline Net Cash Balance Before B-T-L Adjustments $251 ($384) ($392) ($838) ($1133) ($1566)

Total Below-the-Line Adjustments $0 $73 $386 $757 $852 $1133Prior Year Carryover 121 372 61 55 0 0

NET CASH BALANCE $372 $61 $55 ($26) ($281) ($433)

MTA July Financial Plan 2020-2023Consolidated Statement Of Operations By Category ($ in millions)

Summ Stmt of Ops-Feb

Summ Stmt of Ops-Jul

  • MTA 2020Preliminary BudgetJuly Financial Plan2020 - 2023
  • The MTA Budget Process
  • Slide Number 3
  • Slide Number 4
  • What has changed since the February Plan
  • Highlights of the July Plan
  • Slide Number 7
  • MTA Transformation Plan
  • Slide Number 9
  • Actions to Reduce Fare Evasion $62 million Investment over the Plan Period
  • The MTArsquos $350 million target for annually recurring savings beginning in 2020 has been identified and is being implemented
  • We have a track record of identifying and achieving our annual recurring savings targets
  • Deficits remain and a continued drive toward further streamlining and efficiencies is required
  • Slide Number 14
  • 2020 Preliminary Budget
  • Slide Number 16
MTA July Financial Plan 2020-2023
Consolidated Statement Of Operations By Category ($ in millions)
Non-Reimbursable Mid-Year Preliminary
Actual Actual Actual Actual Actual Actual Actual Actual Actual Actual Forecast Budget
2008 2009 2010 2011 2012 2013 2014 2015 2016 2018 2019 2020 2021 2022 2023 2023 2024 2025 2026
Operating Revenues
Farebox Revenue $4240923 $4350411 $4586377 $4999186 $5079138 $5501274 $5709200 $5961129 $6050182 $6155 $6305 $6389 $6373 $6384 $6393 $6174 $6435176 $6431979 $6446633
422 423 405 411 402 399 395 396 396 386 384 385 380 375 371 261 368 363 362
Student Fare - 0 - 0 - 0 - 0 - 0 - 0
Toll Revenue 1273974 1332115 1417046 1501589 1490982 1645193 1676445 1808901 1869693 1976 2088 2121 2129 2129 2131 2002 2133050 2137871 2143111
0127 0129 0125 0124 0118 0119 0116 0120 0122 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0122 0121 0120
Other Revenue 448616 461359 491355 510231 563839 753675 682424 689217 688374 643 696 684 704 719 737 755 825040 885381 887190
Capital and Other Reimbursements 0000 0000 0000 0000 0000 0000 0000 0000 0000 0000 0000 0000 0000 0000 0000 0000 0000 0000 0000
Total Operating Revenue $5963512 $6143885 $6494778 $7011006 $7133959 $7900142 $8068069 $8459247 $8608249 $8774 $9089 $9195 $9206 $9232 $9260 $8931 $9393266 $9455232 $9476934
Dedicated Taxes $3211585 $2366805 $2343537 $2511691 $2673119 $3097640 $3383498 $3582628 $3525829 $3257508 $3459 $3515 $3568 $3630 $3725 $3812 $3841433 $3880226 $3917215
PMT amp MTA Aid - 0 881784 1588677 1718286 1825824 1825328 1885069 1910947 1970760 1987035 $1965 $2152 $2225 $2295 $2368 $2442 2516095 2594604 2677041
New Funding Sources - 0 - 0 - 0 - 0 - 0 - 0 - 0 - 0 - 0 - 0 $508 $342 $385 $385 $385 $385 385000 385000 385000
StateLocal Taxes 556691 539046 544810 541733 536182 537527 539545 537819 537645 541005 $544 $552 $557 $562 $567 $572 576828 581933 583214
Other Funding Agreements 306594 363823 359489 375369 466625 432617 567391 563616 629855 630218 $701 $753 $671 $708 $758 $758 784755 804901 781159
BampT Operating Surplus Transfer 382565 363092 476059 554903 476575 614210 637553 750717 742909 740144 $702 $721 $782 $801 $789 $707 730476 695303 688833
Dedicated Taxes and StateLocal Subsidies $4457434 $4514550 $5312572 $5701982 $5978325 $6507322 $7013056 $7345727 $7406998 $7155909 $7879 $8035 $8188 $8381 $8592 $8676 $8834588 $8941967 $9032462
$0000 $0000 $0000 $0000 $0000 $0000 $0000 $0000 $0000
Less Interagency Subsidy and Surplus Transfers (382565) (363092) (476059) (554903) (476575) (614210) (637553) (750717) (742909) (740144) ($702) ($721) ($782) ($801) ($789) ($707) (730476) (695303) (688833)
Total Subsidies $4074870 $4151458 $4836513 $5147079 $5501750 $5893111 $6375503 $6595010 $6664088 $7177 $7314 $7406 $7581 $7803 $7969 $7969 $8104112 $8246664 $8343629
Dedicated Taxes as a of Total Revenues + Subs - PMT 320 251 241 241 247 259 269 273 265 233 $0 $0 $0 $0 $0 $0 256 257 259
Total Revenues + Subsidies $10038382 $10295342 $11331292 $12158085 $12635709 $13793254 $14443571 $15054257 $15272337 $15951 $16403 $16601 $16787 $17035 $17229 $16900 $17497378 $17701896 $17820563
Operating Expenses
Labor Expenses
Payroll $4087376 $4163330 $4171374 $4160261 $4193658 $4332829 $4671664 $4695823 $4838741 $5020713 $5211 $5328 $5422 $5498 $5624 $5710 $5860206 $5982960 $6107107
Overtime 471675 499307 443227 538647 574316 620701 730200 755071 771495 934100 $1066 $910 $838 $859 $877 $899 917296 935002 951324
Health amp Welfare 684945 688899 738189 809638 812857 895714 961902 1050100 1172304 1208786 $1230 $1341 $1414 $1489 $1583 $1674 1797938 1922668 2071273
OPEB Current Payment 318501 346316 355716 394218 413164 472619 479079 501716 562233 563754 $604 $645 $704 $766 $835 $910 982025 1060022 1142795
Pensions 897450 1021229 1029710 1074598 1328441 1301975 1304355 1248726 1370474 1345308 $1336 $1494 $1461 $1462 $1403 $1347 1357887 1369071 1380572
Other-Fringe Benefits 502739 517194 539996 581661 650430 694680 784143 861079 947870 792151 $881 $869 $897 $930 $956 $976 1001185 1021007 1040170
Reimbursable Overhead (310555) (322230) (345154) (324006) (309399) (321390) (349770) (380212) (423759) (491807) ($528) ($471) ($430) ($412) ($397) ($395) (396136) (405509) (413165)
Labor Expenses $6652131 $6914045 $6933059 $7235017 $7663467 $7997128 $8581574 $8732302 $9239358 $9799 $10116 $10306 $10592 $10881 $11121 $11413 $11520401 $11885220 $12280075
PayrollOvertime Exp as a of Total Operating+DS $0426 $0427 $0407 $0396 $0387 $0374 $0389 $0383 $0376 $0390 $0367 $0365 $0359 $0355 $0350 $0349 $0347 $0345
Labor Exp (wo Reimb OH) as a of Total Oper+DS $0650 $0663 $0642 $0637 $0647 $0628 $0643 $0640 $0648 $0642 $0622 $0626 $0622 $0616 $0609 $0614 $0617 $0620
PayrollOvertime Exp as a of Total Operating Exp $0496 $0490 $0483 $0473 $0465 $0453 $0464 $0459 $0450 $0464 $0435 $0438 $0434 $0433 $0430 $0426 $0420 $0416
Labor Exp (wo Reimb OH) as a of Total Oper Exp $0758 $0761 $0762 $0761 $0777 $0761 $0768 $0768 $0776 $0763 $0739 $0750 $0751 $0750 $0749 $0748 $0747 $0747
Non-Labor Expenses
Electric Power $306500 $317934 $325137 $457269 $471514 $493346 $515540 $473762 $406372 $481893 $451503 $473177 $493090 $532413 $561955 $571182 $589565 $618283 $648255
Traction Power
Non-Traction Power
Fuel 287033 180294 189942 282735 251763 259252 267494 162283 124684 185203 182778 182981 176333 173681 176920 182259 182476 184281 186170
Revenue Vehicle Fuel
Non-Revenue Fuel
Insurance 28902 34012 9819 14363 7617 38654 50739 57190 (20634) (29402) 5608 15623 23118 26855 28309 36048 28232 25538 19483
Claims 152114 238104 285418 315547 135652 299875 269167 331023 463959 437985 387557 394211 392547 398256 406112 404397 417667 428660 437683
Paratransit Service Contracts 299013 370094 379761 348553 360500 366751 365599 379271 383704 455471 494751 488330 505538 535329 568614 581114 604766 643217 684112
Maintenance and Other Operating Contracts 594215 562456 541716 451137 451766 496743 549018 579289 630924 678425 840168 797428 833534 836606 854471 879468 880053 898882 915477
Professional Service Contracts 196930 199164 203084 226205 276998 297201 283005 379814 399706 543582 607838 502858 494814 504103 513895 499724 520826 537109 547291
Materials amp Supplies 532534 526191 511206 438310 430804 475127 526725 543225 585607 637078 689010 679895 697976 711281 715758 711988 741335 777460 793419
Other Business Expenses 155466 184142 189637 169857 143807 167198 179701 195598 192576 220838 218196 213551 224459 226170 228457 244907 228861 240258 241690
Non-Labor Expenses $2552708 $2612391 $2635720 $2703976 $2530421 $2894147 $3006988 $3101454 $3166897 3611 3877 3748 3841 3945 4054 4111 $4193782 $4353689 $4473580
Other Expense Adjustments
Other ($13712) ($14750) ($18292) ($2289) $62593 $46175 $44973 $37007 $47404 129 175 86 36 22 23 23 $23516 $24069 $24637
General Reserve 0000 0000 0000 0000 0000 - 0 - 0 - 0 - 0 0 165 170 175 180 185 185 190000 195000 205000
Other Expense Adjustments ($13712) ($14750) ($18292) ($2289) $62593 $46175 $44973 $37007 $47404 $128555 $340 $256 $211 $202 $208 $208 $213516 $219069 $229637
Gap Closing Expenses $7675394
Additional Actions for Budget Balance Expense Impact $0000 $0000 $0000 $0000 $0000 $0000 $0000 $0000 $0000 $0000 $0000 $0000 $0000 $0000 $0000 $0000 $0000 $0000 $0000
Total Operating Expenses Before Non-Cash Liability Adjs $9191127 $9511685 $9550486 $9936705 $10256481 $10937450 $11633535 $11870763 $12453659 $13538830 $14332772 $14309678 $14643965 $15027767 $15383584 $15732241 $15927699 $16457978 $16983292
Non-Cash Liability Adjustments
Depreciation $1790981 $1940576 $1980681 $2019378 $2148820 $2174302 $2266280 $2442777 $2442941 $2607970 $2804571 $2784812 $2842737 $2908533 $2977025 $3051834 $3109882 $3169371 $3230301
OPEB Obligation 1348962 1104827 1167070 1706939 1785881 1920189 2035457 1489656 1562261 1567381 0000 (0000) (0000) (0000) (0000) 0000 0000 (0000) (0000)
GASB 75 OPEB Expense Adjustment 0000 0000 0000 0000 0000 0000 0000 0000 0000 0000 1047747 1457230 1628196 1748560 1823313 1898497 1952374 2006482 2061993
GASB 68 Pension Expense Adjustment 0000 0000 0000 0000 0000 0000 0000 (410019) (218911) (168119) (373022) (220864) (271921) (342847) (318372) (242446) (237864) (234492) (230942)
Environmental Remediation 42249 6062 18621 59079 24742 14257 20556 20576 11691 13468 105615 6000 6000 6000 6000 6000 6000 6000 6000
Non-Cash Liability Adjustments $3182192 $3051466 $3166371 $3785396 $3959443 $4108749 $4322293 $3542990 $3797981 $4020699 $3584911 $4027178 $4205012 $4320246 $4487966 $4713886 $4830392 $4947361 $5067352
Total Operating Expenses After Non-Cash Liability Adjs $12373319 $12563151 $12716857 $13722101 $14215924 $15046199 $15955827 $15413753 $16251641 $17559529 $17917683 $18336856 $18848977 $19348013 $19871550 $20446127 $20758090 $21405338 $22050644
Less BampT Depreciation $77213 $80097 $77846 $86545 $87926 $91345 $104039 $109783 $135035 $240957 $148686 $151977 $158779 $169848 $181689 $194355 $194355 $194355 $194355
BampT Other Post Employment Benefits 66323 50967 54831 66686 73055 76641 71148 62457 60441 78106 32297 22256 20303 22870 28694 33918 36169 38411 40604
Net Operating Deficit Before Subsidies and Debt Service ($6409807) ($6419266) ($6222079) ($6711095) ($7081966) ($7146057) ($7887759) ($6954506) ($7643392) ($8785339) ($8829030) ($9141907) ($9642826) ($10116260) ($10611154) ($11515498) ($11364824) ($11950106) ($12573710)
Conversion to Cash Basis Non-Cash Liability Adjs ($3182192) ($3051466) ($3166371) ($3785396) ($3959443) ($4108749) ($4322293) ($3542990) ($3797981) ($4020699) ($3584911) ($4027178) ($4205012) ($4320246) ($4487966) ($4713886) ($4830392) ($4947361) ($5067352)
Total Operating Expenses $9191127 $9511685 $9550486 $9936705 $10256481 $10937450 $11633535 $11870763 $12453659 $13539 $14333 $14310 $14644 $15028 $15384 $15732 $15927699 $16457978 $16983292
Debt Service Expenses $1515733 $1404454 $1781220 $1933532 $2058395 $2299262 $2248538 $2373321 $2458783 $2541 $2683 $2830 $3041 $3265 $3513 $3450 $3471321 $3472987 $3501639
Total Expenses + Debt Service $10706859 $10916139 $11331706 $11870237 $12314876 $13236712 $13882073 $14244084 $14912443 $16079 $17016 $17140 $17685 $18293 $18896 $19182 $19399019 $19930965 $20484932
Net Deficit After Subsidies and Debt Service ($668477) ($620796) ($0414) $287848 $320833 $556541 $561498 $810173 $359895 ($128044) ($613) ($539) ($898) ($1258) ($1667) ($2283) ($1901641) ($2229069) ($2664369)
Conversion to Cash Basis GASB Account (56067) (54256) (67377) (37636) (89548) (85641) (50017) - 0 - 0 0 0 0 $0 0 0 - 0 - 0 - 0 - 0
Conversion to Cash Basis 492710 550267 91781 (111037) (297407) (261709) (626297) (660147) (591809) 379 229 147 60 125 101 130 49745 48375 54220
Net Cash Balance from Previous Year 0000 0000 0000 23990 139174 0000 209191 0000 150026 0000 250569 0000 0000 0000 0000 0000 0000 0000 0000
Total Operating Exp + DS + Cash Conversions + PY C-O $11144 $11412 $11356 $11746 $12067 $12889362 $13414950 $13583937 $14470659 $16457999 $17495351 $17286526 $17744425 $18418197 $18997710 $19312017 $19448764 $19979340 $20539152
Total Operating Expenses with Cash Conversion $10270216 $10420127 $11307302 $12018911 $12701831 $13584063 $14558387 $14904231 $15504252 $15700774 $16786574 $16992579 $17624861 $18167420 $18795069 $19052755 $19349274 $19882590 $20430711
Baseline Net Cash Balance Before B-T-L Adjustments ($231834) ($124785) $23990 $139174 ($66122) $209191 ($114816) $150026 ($231914) $251 ($384) ($392) ($838) ($1133) ($1566) ($2153) ($1851896) ($2180695) ($2610148)
Below-the-Line Adjustments
FareToll Increases
FareToll Increase in March 2019 (4 Yield) - 0 $0 $0 $0 $0 $0 $0 - 0 - 0 - 0
FareToll Increase in March 2021 (4 Yield) - 0 $0 $0 $0 $283 $331 $332 333531 333568 334299
FareToll Increase in March 2023 (4 Yield) - 0 $0 $0 $0 $0 $0 $294 346386 346424 347183
FareToll Increase in March 2025 (4 Yield) - 0 $0 $0 $0 $0 $0 $0 - 0 273859 321624
Subsidy Impacts of 20212023 FareToll Increase - 0 $0 $0 $0 ($7) ($9) ($17) (18612) (25573) (26305)
$0000 $0 $0 $0 $275 $322 $609 $661306 $928278 $976801
CASH BALANCE AFTER FARE INCREASES $250569 ($384) ($392) ($838) ($850) ($1234) ($1821) ($1518365) ($1847127) ($2275849)
MTA Initiatives
MTA Efficiencies - Not Yet Implemented - 0 $0 $0 $0 $0 $0 $0 0000 0000 0000
0 - 0 $0 $0 $0 $0 $0 $0 - 0 - 0 - 0
0 - 0 $0 $0 $0 $0 $0 $0 - 0 - 0 - 0
$0000 $0 $0 $0 $0 $0 $0 $0000 $0000 $0000
Policy Actions
CAS Migration to Peoplesoft $0 $0 ($5) ($1) ($0) ($0) (0200) -02 -02 0
Fare Evasion Enforcement Strategy-Expenses $0 ($13) ($12) ($11) ($10) ($10) (9554) -9554483 -9554483 0
Fare Evasion Enforcement-Manhattan DA Forfeiture Fund $0 $11 $11 $10 $9 $0 - 0 0 0 0
Negotiated 1 CBA Reform $0 $0 $0 $0 $0 $0 - 0 0 0 0
MTA Reorganization $0 $8 $180 $371 $377 $377 377000 377 377 0
MTA Reorganization Costs $0 $0 ($10) ($27) ($2) $0 - 0 0 0 0
Drawdown 2019 General Reserve $0 $0 $165 $0 $0 $0 - 0 0 0 0
CBA Negotiated Reform - 1 Value $0 $36 $100 $173 $246 $323 323473 323473304484 323473304484 0
$0000 $0 $42 $429 $515 $620 $691 $690719 $690719 $690719
MTA Re-estimates
Additional Savings Actions $0000 $0 $0 $0 $0 $0 $0 $0000 $0000 $0000
Total Below-the-Line Adjustments $0 $73 $386 $757 $852 $1133 $1007 $1352025 $1618997 $1667520
Prior Year Carryover 495399 263336 138286 161986 301160 235038 444229 329413 479439 121 372 61 55 0 0 - 0 - 0 - 0 - 0
NET CASH BALANCE $263566 $138551 $162276 $301160 $235038 $444229 $329413 $479439 $247525 $372 $61 $55 ($26) ($281) ($433) ($1146) ($499871) ($561698) ($942628)
MTA February Financial Plan 2019-2022
Consolidated Statement Of Operations By Category ($ in millions)
Non-Reimbursable Final Adopted
Actual Actual Actual Actual Actual Actual Actual Actual Actual Actual Estimate Budget
2008 2009 2010 2011 2012 2013 2014 2015 2016 2017 2018 2019 2020 2021 2022 2023 2024 2025 2026
Operating Revenues
Farebox Revenue $4240923 $4350411 $4586377 $4999186 $5079138 $5501274 $5709200 $5961129 $6050182 $6172 $6153 $6122 $6144 $6134 $6144 $6174 $6435176 $6431979 $6446633
422 423 405 411 402 399 395 396 396 407 279 275 272 267 263 261 368 363 362
Student Fare - 0 - 0 - 0 - 0 - 0 - 0
Toll Revenue 1273974 1332115 1417046 1501589 1490982 1645193 1676445 1808901 1869693 1912 1967 1984 1990 1998 1998 2002 2133050 2137871 2143111
0127 0129 0125 0124 0118 0119 0116 0120 0122 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0122 0121 0120
Other Revenue 448616 461359 491355 510231 563839 753675 682424 689217 688374 653 662 705 733 757 743 755 825040 885381 887190
Capital and Other Reimbursements 0000 0000 0000 0000 0000 0000 0000 0000 0000 0000 0000 0000 0000 0000 0000 0000 0000 0000 0000
Total Operating Revenue $5963512 $6143885 $6494778 $7011006 $7133959 $7900142 $8068069 $8459247 $8608249 $8737 $8782 $8810 $8867 $8889 $8886 $8931 $9393266 $9455232 $9476934
Dedicated Taxes $3211585 $2366805 $2343537 $2511691 $2673119 $3097640 $3383498 $3582628 $3525829 $3257508 $3459 $3515 $3568 $3630 $3725 $3812 $3841433 $3880226 $3917215
PMT amp MTA Aid - 0 881784 1588677 1718286 1825824 1825328 1885069 1910947 1970760 1987035 $1965 $2152 $2225 $2295 $2368 $2442 2516095 2594604 2677041
New Funding Sources - 0 - 0 - 0 - 0 - 0 - 0 - 0 - 0 - 0 - 0 $508 $342 $385 $385 $385 $385 385000 385000 385000
StateLocal Taxes 556691 539046 544810 541733 536182 537527 539545 537819 537645 541005 $544 $552 $557 $562 $567 $572 576828 581933 583214
Other Funding Agreements 306594 363823 359489 375369 466625 432617 567391 563616 629855 630218 $701 $753 $671 $708 $758 $758 784755 804901 781159
BampT Operating Surplus Transfer 382565 363092 476059 554903 476575 614210 637553 750717 742909 740144 $702 $721 $782 $801 $789 $707 730476 695303 688833
Dedicated Taxes and StateLocal Subsidies $4457434 $4514550 $5312572 $5701982 $5978325 $6507322 $7013056 $7345727 $7406998 $7155909 $7879 $8035 $8188 $8381 $8592 $8676 $8834588 $8941967 $9032462
$0000 $0000 $0000 $0000 $0000 $0000 $0000 $0000 $0000
Less Interagency Subsidy and Surplus Transfers (382565) (363092) (476059) (554903) (476575) (614210) (637553) (750717) (742909) (740144) ($702) ($721) ($782) ($801) ($789) ($707) (730476) (695303) (688833)
Total Subsidies $4074870 $4151458 $4836513 $5147079 $5501750 $5893111 $6375503 $6595010 $6664088 $6416 $7242 $7238 $7370 $7576 $7807 $7969 $8104112 $8246664 $8343629
Dedicated Taxes as a of Total Revenues + Subs - PMT 320 251 241 241 247 259 269 273 265 247 $0 $0 $0 $0 $0 $0 256 257 259
Total Revenues + Subsidies $10038382 $10295342 $11331292 $12158085 $12635709 $13793254 $14443571 $15054257 $15272337 $15152 $16023 $16048 $16237 $16465 $16693 $16900 $17497378 $17701896 $17820563
Operating Expenses
Labor Expenses
Payroll $4087376 $4163330 $4171374 $4160261 $4193658 $4332829 $4671664 $4695823 $4838741 $5020713 $5211 $5328 $5422 $5498 $5624 $5710 $5860206 $5982960 $6107107
Overtime 471675 499307 443227 538647 574316 620701 730200 755071 771495 934100 $1066 $910 $838 $859 $877 $899 917296 935002 951324
Health amp Welfare 684945 688899 738189 809638 812857 895714 961902 1050100 1172304 1208786 $1230 $1341 $1414 $1489 $1583 $1674 1797938 1922668 2071273
OPEB Current Payment 318501 346316 355716 394218 413164 472619 479079 501716 562233 563754 $604 $645 $704 $766 $835 $910 982025 1060022 1142795
Pensions 897450 1021229 1029710 1074598 1328441 1301975 1304355 1248726 1370474 1345308 $1336 $1494 $1461 $1462 $1403 $1347 1357887 1369071 1380572
Other-Fringe Benefits 502739 517194 539996 581661 650430 694680 784143 861079 947870 792151 $881 $869 $897 $930 $956 $976 1001185 1021007 1040170
Reimbursable Overhead (310555) (322230) (345154) (324006) (309399) (321390) (349770) (380212) (423759) (491807) ($528) ($471) ($430) ($412) ($397) ($395) (396136) (405509) (413165)
Labor Expenses $6652131 $6914045 $6933059 $7235017 $7663467 $7997128 $8581574 $8732302 $9239358 $9373 $9920 $10039 $10436 $10787 $11097 $11413 $11520401 $11885220 $12280075
PayrollOvertime Exp as a of Total Operating+DS $0426 $0427 $0407 $0396 $0387 $0374 $0389 $0383 $0376 $0385 $0349 $0347 $0345
Labor Exp (wo Reimb OH) as a of Total Oper+DS $0650 $0663 $0642 $0637 $0647 $0628 $0643 $0640 $0648 $0638 $0614 $0617 $0620
PayrollOvertime Exp as a of Total Operating Exp $0496 $0490 $0483 $0473 $0465 $0453 $0464 $0459 $0450 $0461 $0426 $0420 $0416
Labor Exp (wo Reimb OH) as a of Total Oper Exp $0758 $0761 $0762 $0761 $0777 $0761 $0768 $0768 $0776 $0763 $0748 $0747 $0747
Non-Labor Expenses
Electric Power $306500 $317934 $325137 $457269 $471514 $493346 $515540 $473762 $406372 $430381 $474918 $451304 $463523 $482662 $539624 $571182 $589565 $618283 $648255
Traction Power
Non-Traction Power
Fuel 287033 180294 189942 282735 251763 259252 267494 162283 124684 150481 185580 190348 187592 183168 181484 182259 182476 184281 186170
Revenue Vehicle Fuel
Non-Revenue Fuel
Insurance 28902 34012 9819 14363 7617 38654 50739 57190 (20634) (2715) 11488 8532 15803 22918 29411 36048 28232 25538 19483
Claims 152114 238104 285418 315547 135652 299875 269167 331023 463959 526053 376480 378570 386981 391333 395228 404397 417667 428660 437683
Paratransit Service Contracts 299013 370094 379761 348553 360500 366751 365599 379271 383704 392850 452190 482751 501230 518038 547829 581114 604766 643217 684112
Maintenance and Other Operating Contracts 594215 562456 541716 451137 451766 496743 549018 579289 630924 695251 779331 897801 833038 883805 871671 879468 880053 898882 915477
Professional Service Contracts 196930 199164 203084 226205 276998 297201 283005 379814 399706 507062 575742 557476 484911 479376 489510 499724 520826 537109 547291
Materials amp Supplies 532534 526191 511206 438310 430804 475127 526725 543225 585607 588115 667700 686666 687745 692131 697268 711988 741335 777460 793419
Other Business Expenses 155466 184142 189637 169857 143807 167198 179701 195598 192576 217254 225494 230595 225293 240279 242193 244907 228861 240258 241690
Non-Labor Expenses $2552708 $2612391 $2635720 $2703976 $2530421 $2894147 $3006988 $3101454 $3166897 3505 3749 3884 3786 3894 3994 4111 $4193782 $4353689 $4473580
Other Expense Adjustments
Other ($13712) ($14750) ($18292) ($2289) $62593 $46175 $44973 $37007 $47404 49 134 158 84 36 22 23 $23516 $24069 $24637
General Reserve 0000 0000 0000 0000 0000 - 0 - 0 - 0 - 0 0 0 165 170 175 180 185 190000 195000 205000
Other Expense Adjustments ($13712) ($14750) ($18292) ($2289) $62593 $46175 $44973 $37007 $47404 $49379 $134 $323 $254 $211 $202 $208 $213516 $219069 $229637
Gap Closing Expenses $7675394
Additional Actions for Budget Balance Expense Impact $0000 $0000 $0000 $0000 $0000 $0000 $0000 $0000 $0000 $0000 $0000 $0000 $0000 $0000 $0000 $0000 $0000 $0000 $0000
Total Operating Expenses Before Non-Cash Liability Adjs $9191127 $9511685 $9550486 $9936705 $10256481 $10937450 $11633535 $11870763 $12453659 $12927116 $13802910 $14246122 $14475644 $14891445 $15293262 $15732241 $15927699 $16457978 $16983292
Non-Cash Liability Adjustments
Depreciation $1790981 $1940576 $1980681 $2019378 $2148820 $2174302 $2266280 $2442777 $2442941 $2607970 $2804571 $2784812 $2842737 $2908533 $2977025 $3051834 $3109882 $3169371 $3230301
OPEB Obligation 1348962 1104827 1167070 1706939 1785881 1920189 2035457 1489656 1562261 1567381 0000 (0000) (0000) (0000) (0000) 0000 0000 (0000) (0000)
GASB 75 OPEB Expense Adjustment 0000 0000 0000 0000 0000 0000 0000 0000 0000 0000 1047747 1457230 1628196 1748560 1823313 1898497 1952374 2006482 2061993
GASB 68 Pension Expense Adjustment 0000 0000 0000 0000 0000 0000 0000 (410019) (218911) (168119) (373022) (220864) (271921) (342847) (318372) (242446) (237864) (234492) (230942)
Environmental Remediation 42249 6062 18621 59079 24742 14257 20556 20576 11691 13468 105615 6000 6000 6000 6000 6000 6000 6000 6000
Non-Cash Liability Adjustments $3182192 $3051466 $3166371 $3785396 $3959443 $4108749 $4322293 $3542990 $3797981 $4020699 $3584911 $4027178 $4205012 $4320246 $4487966 $4713886 $4830392 $4947361 $5067352
Total Operating Expenses After Non-Cash Liability Adjs $12373319 $12563151 $12716857 $13722101 $14215924 $15046199 $15955827 $15413753 $16251641 $16947815 $17387821 $18273301 $18680657 $19211690 $19781228 $20446127 $20758090 $21405338 $22050644
Less BampT Depreciation $77213 $80097 $77846 $86545 $87926 $91345 $104039 $109783 $135035 $240957 $148686 $151977 $158779 $169848 $181689 $194355 $194355 $194355 $194355
BampT Other Post Employment Benefits 66323 50967 54831 66686 73055 76641 71148 62457 60441 78106 32297 22256 20303 22870 28694 33918 36169 38411 40604
Net Operating Deficit Before Subsidies and Debt Service ($6409807) ($6419266) ($6222079) ($6711095) ($7081966) ($7146057) ($7887759) ($6954506) ($7643392) ($8211234) ($8606220) ($9463506) ($9813560) ($10322912) ($10895644) ($11515498) ($11364824) ($11950106) ($12573710)
Conversion to Cash Basis Non-Cash Liability Adjs ($3182192) ($3051466) ($3166371) ($3785396) ($3959443) ($4108749) ($4322293) ($3542990) ($3797981) ($4020699) ($3584911) ($4027178) ($4205012) ($4320246) ($4487966) ($4713886) ($4830392) ($4947361) ($5067352)
Total Operating Expenses $9191127 $9511685 $9550486 $9936705 $10256481 $10937450 $11633535 $11870763 $12453659 $12927 $13803 $14246 $14476 $14891 $15293 $15732 $15927699 $16457978 $16983292
Debt Service Expenses $1515733 $1404454 $1781220 $1933532 $2058395 $2299262 $2248538 $2373321 $2458783 $2525 $2559 $2692 $2840 $3080 $3223 $3450 $3471321 $3472987 $3501639
Total Expenses + Debt Service $10706859 $10916139 $11331706 $11870237 $12314876 $13236712 $13882073 $14244084 $14912443 $15452 $16362 $16938 $17316 $17971 $18516 $19182 $19399019 $19930965 $20484932
Net Deficit After Subsidies and Debt Service ($668477) ($620796) ($0414) $287848 $320833 $556541 $561498 $810173 $359895 ($299965) ($339) ($890) ($1079) ($1506) ($1823) ($2283) ($1901641) ($2229069) ($2664369)
Conversion to Cash Basis GASB Account (56067) (54256) (67377) (37636) (89548) (85641) (50017) - 0 - 0 0 0 0 $0 0 0 - 0 - 0 - 0 - 0
Conversion to Cash Basis 492710 550267 91781 (111037) (297407) (261709) (626297) (660147) (591809) 174 296 363 188 (17) 88 130 49745 48375 54220
Net Cash Balance from Previous Year 0000 0000 0000 23990 139174 0000 209191 0000 150026 0000 0000 0000 0000 0000 0000 0000 0000 0000 0000
Total Operating Exp + DS + Cash Conversions + PY C-O $11144 $11412 $11356 $11746 $12067 $12889362 $13414950 $13583937 $14470659 $15625875 $16658585 $17300293 $17504155 $17954574 $18604130 $19312017 $19448764 $19979340 $20539152
Total Operating Expenses with Cash Conversion $10270216 $10420127 $11307302 $12018911 $12701831 $13584063 $14558387 $14904231 $15504252 $15278749 $16065734 $16575223 $17128079 $17987951 $18427778 $19052755 $19349274 $19882590 $20430711
Baseline Net Cash Balance Before B-T-L Adjustments ($231834) ($124785) $23990 $139174 ($66122) $209191 ($114816) $150026 ($231914) ($126) ($43) ($527) ($891) ($1523) ($1735) ($2153) ($1851896) ($2180695) ($2610148)
Below-the-Line Adjustments
FareToll Increases
FareToll Increase in March 2019 (4 Yield) - 0 $0 $0 $0 $0 $0 $0 - 0 - 0 - 0
FareToll Increase in March 2021 (4 Yield) - 0 $0 $0 $0 $283 $331 $332 333531 333568 334299
FareToll Increase in March 2023 (4 Yield) - 0 $0 $0 $0 $0 $0 $294 346386 346424 347183
FareToll Increase in March 2025 (4 Yield) - 0 $0 $0 $0 $0 $0 $0 - 0 273859 321624
Subsidy Impacts of 20212023 FareToll Increase - 0 $0 $0 $0 ($7) ($9) ($17) (18612) (25573) (26305)
$0000 $0 $0 $0 $275 $322 $609 $661306 $928278 $976801
CASH BALANCE AFTER FARE INCREASES ($126402) ($43) ($527) ($891) ($1241) ($1404) ($1821) ($1518365) ($1847127) ($2275849)
MTA Initiatives
MTA Efficiencies - Not Yet Implemented - 0 $0 $0 $0 $0 $0 $0 0000 0000 0000
0 - 0 $0 $0 $0 $0 $0 $0 - 0 - 0 - 0
0 - 0 $0 $0 $0 $0 $0 $0 - 0 - 0 - 0
$0000 $0 $0 $0 $0 $0 $0 $0000 $0000 $0000
Policy Actions
CAS Migration to Peoplesoft $0 $0 ($5) ($1) ($0) ($0) (0200) -02 -02 0
Fare Evasion Enforcement Strategy-Expenses $0 ($13) ($12) ($11) ($10) ($10) (9554) -9554483 -9554483 0
Fare Evasion Enforcement-Manhattan DA Forfeiture Fund $0 $11 $11 $10 $9 $0 - 0 0 0 0
Negotiated 1 CBA Reform $0 $0 $0 $0 $0 $0 - 0 0 0 0
MTA Reorganization $0 $8 $180 $371 $377 $377 377000 377 377 0
MTA Reorganization Costs $0 $0 ($10) ($27) ($2) $0 - 0 0 0 0
Drawdown 2019 General Reserve $0 $0 $165 $0 $0 $0 - 0 0 0 0
CBA Negotiated Reform - 1 Value $0 $36 $100 $173 $246 $323 323473 323473304484 323473304484 0
$0000 $0 $42 $429 $515 $620 $691 $690719 $690719 $690719
MTA Re-estimates
Additional Savings Actions $0000 $0 $0 $0 $0 $0 $0 $0000 $0000 $0000
Total Below-the-Line Adjustments $0 $0 $459 $413 $709 $760 $1007 $1352025 $1618997 $1667520
Prior Year Carryover 495399 263336 138286 161986 301160 235038 444229 329413 479439 248 121 79 11 0 0 - 0 - 0 - 0 - 0
NET CASH BALANCE $263566 $138551 $162276 $301160 $235038 $444229 $329413 $479439 $247525 $121 $79 $11 ($467) ($814) ($976) ($1146) ($499871) ($561698) ($942628)
By Revenue Source
(includes faretoll increases)
($ in millions)
Farebox Revenue $6389
Toll Revenue 2121
Other Revenue 684
Dedicated Taxes 6191
State and Local amp Other 1228
Timing (Cash Adjustments) 135
Total $16748
By Expense Category
(includes below-the-line adjustments)
($ in millions)
Payroll $5422
Overtime 838
Health amp Welfare 2118
Pension 1461
Other Labor 466
Total Labor $10306
Non-Labor + Other Exp Adj 4004
Debt Service 2830
BTL Adjustments for Expenses 2 (386)
Total $16754
By Revenue Source
(includes faretoll increases)
($ in millions)
Farebox Revenue $6389
Toll Revenue 2121
Other Revenue 684
Taxes 6178
State and Local amp Other 557
Other Funding Agreements 671
Other 1 208
Total $16809
By Expense Category
(includes below-the-line adjustments)
($ in millions)
Payroll $5392
Overtime 811
Health amp Welfare 2129
Pension 1354
Other Labor 400
Total Labor $10086
Non-Labor 4205
Debt Service 2692
BTL Adjustments for Expenses (251)
Total $16732
Page 10: MTA 2020 Preliminary Budget July Financial Plan 2020 - 2023 2020 Preliminar… · 1 The MTA Budget Process July Plan – Start of the Annual Process • Current year is revised (the

Actions to Reduce Fare Evasion $62 million Investment over the Plan Period

bull Increase physical presence (500 uniformed officers NYPD MTA Police and Bridge and Tunnel Officers) to begin enforcement at 50 subway stations and 50 bus routesThis is not just a fare evasion effort but a workerrsquos safety initiative

bull Ensure enforcement does not target any specific demographic bull Educate MTA riders utilizing messaging media and automated

announcementsbull Improve operation of emergency exit gates to mitigate instances of fare

avoidancebull Augment surveillance capabilities by deploying fare array cameras at 50

stations and pilot the use of monitors at 10 stationsbull $40 million of the investment will be funded by Manhattan DA Office over a

four-year period

9

The MTArsquos $350 million target for annually recurring savings beginning in 2020 has been identified and is being implemented

109

10 7 6 6

96 304 351 362 371

$0

$50

$100

$150

$200

$250

$300

$350

$400

2019 2020 2021 2022 2023

Identified Recurring Savings One-Shot Savings

This Year Next Year Out-Years

($ in millions)

10

We have a track record of identifying and achieving our annual recurring savings targets

11

($ in millions)

$0

$500

$1000

$1500

$2000

$2500

$3000

Achieved Savings

2012 November Plan

2013 November Plan

2014 November Plan

2015 November Plan

2016 November Plan

2017 November Plan

2018 November Plan

2019 July Plan

$28 billion

Proposed July Plan

Deficits remain and a continued drive toward further streamlining and efficiencies is required

12

($ in millions)

61 55

(26)

(281)

(433)

($600)

($500)

($400)

($300)

($200)

($100)

$0

$100

$200

2019 2020 2021 2022 2023

This Year Next Year Out-Years

Proposed July PlanDonrsquot achieve Transformation Plan Savings

13

If the MTA Transformation Plan is not adopted and implemented the deficits will be unmanageable without service cuts significant

reductions in force andor additional fare and toll increases($ in millions)

($1100)

($900)

($700)

($500)

($300)

($100)

$100

2019 2020 2021 2022 2023

(816)

(971)

(569)

(81)

(433)

(281)

61 55 (26)

(281) (186)

50

Next Year Out-Years

(230)(11)

(488)

(538)

(535)

This Year

14

2020 Preliminary BudgetWhere the Dollars Come Fromhellip Where the Dollars Gohellip

Farebox Revenue $6389Toll Revenue 2121 Other Revenue 684 Taxes 6178 State and Local amp Other 557 Other Funding Agreements 671 Other 1 208 Total $16809

($ in millions)

By Revenue Source(includes faretoll increases)

Payroll $5422Overtime 838 Health amp Welfare 2118 Pension 1461 Other Labor 466 Total Labor $10306Non-Labor + Other Exp Adj 4004 Debt Service 2830 BTL Adjustments for Expenses 2 (386) Total $16754

By Expense Category

($ in millions)(includes below-the-line adjustments)

1 Includes cash adjustments and prior-year carryover

Farebox Revenue

38

Toll Revenue

13

Other Revenue4

Taxes37

State amp Local

Subsidies3

Other Funding Agreements

4 Other 1

Payroll32

Overtime5

Health ampWelfare

13Pension

9

Other Labor3

Non-Labor + Other Exp Adj

21

Debt Service17

2 The below-the-line adjustments are grouped in the Non-Labor category

Sheet1

Sheet1

15

Non-Reimbursable Mid-Year Preliminary Actual Forecast Budget

2018 2019 2020 2021 2022 2023 Operating Revenues

Farebox Revenue $6155 $6305 $6389 $6373 $6384 $6393Toll Revenue 1976 2088 2121 2129 2129 2131 Other Revenue 643 696 684 704 719 737

Total Operating Revenue $8774 $9089 $9195 $9206 $9232 $9260

Total Subsidies $7177 $7314 $7406 $7581 $7803 $7969Dedicated Taxes as a of Total Revenues + Subs - PMT 233 $0 $0 $0 $0 $0

Total Revenues + Subsidies $15951 $16403 $16601 $16787 $17035 $17229

Operating ExpensesLabor Expenses $9799 $10116 $10306 $10592 $10881 $11121Non-Labor Expenses 3611 3877 3748 3841 3945 4054 Other 129 175 86 36 22 23 General Reserve 0 165 170 175 180 185

Total Operating Expenses $13539 $14333 $14310 $14644 $15028 $15384

Debt Service Expenses $2541 $2683 $2830 $3041 $3265 $3513

Total Expenses + Debt Service $16079 $17016 $17140 $17685 $18293 $18896

Conversion to Cash Basis 379 229 147 60 125 101

Baseline Net Cash Balance Before B-T-L Adjustments $251 ($384) ($392) ($838) ($1133) ($1566)

Total Below-the-Line Adjustments $0 $73 $386 $757 $852 $1133Prior Year Carryover 121 372 61 55 0 0

NET CASH BALANCE $372 $61 $55 ($26) ($281) ($433)

MTA July Financial Plan 2020-2023Consolidated Statement Of Operations By Category ($ in millions)

Summ Stmt of Ops-Feb

Summ Stmt of Ops-Jul

  • MTA 2020Preliminary BudgetJuly Financial Plan2020 - 2023
  • The MTA Budget Process
  • Slide Number 3
  • Slide Number 4
  • What has changed since the February Plan
  • Highlights of the July Plan
  • Slide Number 7
  • MTA Transformation Plan
  • Slide Number 9
  • Actions to Reduce Fare Evasion $62 million Investment over the Plan Period
  • The MTArsquos $350 million target for annually recurring savings beginning in 2020 has been identified and is being implemented
  • We have a track record of identifying and achieving our annual recurring savings targets
  • Deficits remain and a continued drive toward further streamlining and efficiencies is required
  • Slide Number 14
  • 2020 Preliminary Budget
  • Slide Number 16
MTA July Financial Plan 2020-2023
Consolidated Statement Of Operations By Category ($ in millions)
Non-Reimbursable Mid-Year Preliminary
Actual Actual Actual Actual Actual Actual Actual Actual Actual Actual Forecast Budget
2008 2009 2010 2011 2012 2013 2014 2015 2016 2018 2019 2020 2021 2022 2023 2023 2024 2025 2026
Operating Revenues
Farebox Revenue $4240923 $4350411 $4586377 $4999186 $5079138 $5501274 $5709200 $5961129 $6050182 $6155 $6305 $6389 $6373 $6384 $6393 $6174 $6435176 $6431979 $6446633
422 423 405 411 402 399 395 396 396 386 384 385 380 375 371 261 368 363 362
Student Fare - 0 - 0 - 0 - 0 - 0 - 0
Toll Revenue 1273974 1332115 1417046 1501589 1490982 1645193 1676445 1808901 1869693 1976 2088 2121 2129 2129 2131 2002 2133050 2137871 2143111
0127 0129 0125 0124 0118 0119 0116 0120 0122 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0122 0121 0120
Other Revenue 448616 461359 491355 510231 563839 753675 682424 689217 688374 643 696 684 704 719 737 755 825040 885381 887190
Capital and Other Reimbursements 0000 0000 0000 0000 0000 0000 0000 0000 0000 0000 0000 0000 0000 0000 0000 0000 0000 0000 0000
Total Operating Revenue $5963512 $6143885 $6494778 $7011006 $7133959 $7900142 $8068069 $8459247 $8608249 $8774 $9089 $9195 $9206 $9232 $9260 $8931 $9393266 $9455232 $9476934
Dedicated Taxes $3211585 $2366805 $2343537 $2511691 $2673119 $3097640 $3383498 $3582628 $3525829 $3257508 $3459 $3515 $3568 $3630 $3725 $3812 $3841433 $3880226 $3917215
PMT amp MTA Aid - 0 881784 1588677 1718286 1825824 1825328 1885069 1910947 1970760 1987035 $1965 $2152 $2225 $2295 $2368 $2442 2516095 2594604 2677041
New Funding Sources - 0 - 0 - 0 - 0 - 0 - 0 - 0 - 0 - 0 - 0 $508 $342 $385 $385 $385 $385 385000 385000 385000
StateLocal Taxes 556691 539046 544810 541733 536182 537527 539545 537819 537645 541005 $544 $552 $557 $562 $567 $572 576828 581933 583214
Other Funding Agreements 306594 363823 359489 375369 466625 432617 567391 563616 629855 630218 $701 $753 $671 $708 $758 $758 784755 804901 781159
BampT Operating Surplus Transfer 382565 363092 476059 554903 476575 614210 637553 750717 742909 740144 $702 $721 $782 $801 $789 $707 730476 695303 688833
Dedicated Taxes and StateLocal Subsidies $4457434 $4514550 $5312572 $5701982 $5978325 $6507322 $7013056 $7345727 $7406998 $7155909 $7879 $8035 $8188 $8381 $8592 $8676 $8834588 $8941967 $9032462
$0000 $0000 $0000 $0000 $0000 $0000 $0000 $0000 $0000
Less Interagency Subsidy and Surplus Transfers (382565) (363092) (476059) (554903) (476575) (614210) (637553) (750717) (742909) (740144) ($702) ($721) ($782) ($801) ($789) ($707) (730476) (695303) (688833)
Total Subsidies $4074870 $4151458 $4836513 $5147079 $5501750 $5893111 $6375503 $6595010 $6664088 $7177 $7314 $7406 $7581 $7803 $7969 $7969 $8104112 $8246664 $8343629
Dedicated Taxes as a of Total Revenues + Subs - PMT 320 251 241 241 247 259 269 273 265 233 $0 $0 $0 $0 $0 $0 256 257 259
Total Revenues + Subsidies $10038382 $10295342 $11331292 $12158085 $12635709 $13793254 $14443571 $15054257 $15272337 $15951 $16403 $16601 $16787 $17035 $17229 $16900 $17497378 $17701896 $17820563
Operating Expenses
Labor Expenses
Payroll $4087376 $4163330 $4171374 $4160261 $4193658 $4332829 $4671664 $4695823 $4838741 $5020713 $5211 $5328 $5422 $5498 $5624 $5710 $5860206 $5982960 $6107107
Overtime 471675 499307 443227 538647 574316 620701 730200 755071 771495 934100 $1066 $910 $838 $859 $877 $899 917296 935002 951324
Health amp Welfare 684945 688899 738189 809638 812857 895714 961902 1050100 1172304 1208786 $1230 $1341 $1414 $1489 $1583 $1674 1797938 1922668 2071273
OPEB Current Payment 318501 346316 355716 394218 413164 472619 479079 501716 562233 563754 $604 $645 $704 $766 $835 $910 982025 1060022 1142795
Pensions 897450 1021229 1029710 1074598 1328441 1301975 1304355 1248726 1370474 1345308 $1336 $1494 $1461 $1462 $1403 $1347 1357887 1369071 1380572
Other-Fringe Benefits 502739 517194 539996 581661 650430 694680 784143 861079 947870 792151 $881 $869 $897 $930 $956 $976 1001185 1021007 1040170
Reimbursable Overhead (310555) (322230) (345154) (324006) (309399) (321390) (349770) (380212) (423759) (491807) ($528) ($471) ($430) ($412) ($397) ($395) (396136) (405509) (413165)
Labor Expenses $6652131 $6914045 $6933059 $7235017 $7663467 $7997128 $8581574 $8732302 $9239358 $9799 $10116 $10306 $10592 $10881 $11121 $11413 $11520401 $11885220 $12280075
PayrollOvertime Exp as a of Total Operating+DS $0426 $0427 $0407 $0396 $0387 $0374 $0389 $0383 $0376 $0390 $0367 $0365 $0359 $0355 $0350 $0349 $0347 $0345
Labor Exp (wo Reimb OH) as a of Total Oper+DS $0650 $0663 $0642 $0637 $0647 $0628 $0643 $0640 $0648 $0642 $0622 $0626 $0622 $0616 $0609 $0614 $0617 $0620
PayrollOvertime Exp as a of Total Operating Exp $0496 $0490 $0483 $0473 $0465 $0453 $0464 $0459 $0450 $0464 $0435 $0438 $0434 $0433 $0430 $0426 $0420 $0416
Labor Exp (wo Reimb OH) as a of Total Oper Exp $0758 $0761 $0762 $0761 $0777 $0761 $0768 $0768 $0776 $0763 $0739 $0750 $0751 $0750 $0749 $0748 $0747 $0747
Non-Labor Expenses
Electric Power $306500 $317934 $325137 $457269 $471514 $493346 $515540 $473762 $406372 $481893 $451503 $473177 $493090 $532413 $561955 $571182 $589565 $618283 $648255
Traction Power
Non-Traction Power
Fuel 287033 180294 189942 282735 251763 259252 267494 162283 124684 185203 182778 182981 176333 173681 176920 182259 182476 184281 186170
Revenue Vehicle Fuel
Non-Revenue Fuel
Insurance 28902 34012 9819 14363 7617 38654 50739 57190 (20634) (29402) 5608 15623 23118 26855 28309 36048 28232 25538 19483
Claims 152114 238104 285418 315547 135652 299875 269167 331023 463959 437985 387557 394211 392547 398256 406112 404397 417667 428660 437683
Paratransit Service Contracts 299013 370094 379761 348553 360500 366751 365599 379271 383704 455471 494751 488330 505538 535329 568614 581114 604766 643217 684112
Maintenance and Other Operating Contracts 594215 562456 541716 451137 451766 496743 549018 579289 630924 678425 840168 797428 833534 836606 854471 879468 880053 898882 915477
Professional Service Contracts 196930 199164 203084 226205 276998 297201 283005 379814 399706 543582 607838 502858 494814 504103 513895 499724 520826 537109 547291
Materials amp Supplies 532534 526191 511206 438310 430804 475127 526725 543225 585607 637078 689010 679895 697976 711281 715758 711988 741335 777460 793419
Other Business Expenses 155466 184142 189637 169857 143807 167198 179701 195598 192576 220838 218196 213551 224459 226170 228457 244907 228861 240258 241690
Non-Labor Expenses $2552708 $2612391 $2635720 $2703976 $2530421 $2894147 $3006988 $3101454 $3166897 3611 3877 3748 3841 3945 4054 4111 $4193782 $4353689 $4473580
Other Expense Adjustments
Other ($13712) ($14750) ($18292) ($2289) $62593 $46175 $44973 $37007 $47404 129 175 86 36 22 23 23 $23516 $24069 $24637
General Reserve 0000 0000 0000 0000 0000 - 0 - 0 - 0 - 0 0 165 170 175 180 185 185 190000 195000 205000
Other Expense Adjustments ($13712) ($14750) ($18292) ($2289) $62593 $46175 $44973 $37007 $47404 $128555 $340 $256 $211 $202 $208 $208 $213516 $219069 $229637
Gap Closing Expenses $7675394
Additional Actions for Budget Balance Expense Impact $0000 $0000 $0000 $0000 $0000 $0000 $0000 $0000 $0000 $0000 $0000 $0000 $0000 $0000 $0000 $0000 $0000 $0000 $0000
Total Operating Expenses Before Non-Cash Liability Adjs $9191127 $9511685 $9550486 $9936705 $10256481 $10937450 $11633535 $11870763 $12453659 $13538830 $14332772 $14309678 $14643965 $15027767 $15383584 $15732241 $15927699 $16457978 $16983292
Non-Cash Liability Adjustments
Depreciation $1790981 $1940576 $1980681 $2019378 $2148820 $2174302 $2266280 $2442777 $2442941 $2607970 $2804571 $2784812 $2842737 $2908533 $2977025 $3051834 $3109882 $3169371 $3230301
OPEB Obligation 1348962 1104827 1167070 1706939 1785881 1920189 2035457 1489656 1562261 1567381 0000 (0000) (0000) (0000) (0000) 0000 0000 (0000) (0000)
GASB 75 OPEB Expense Adjustment 0000 0000 0000 0000 0000 0000 0000 0000 0000 0000 1047747 1457230 1628196 1748560 1823313 1898497 1952374 2006482 2061993
GASB 68 Pension Expense Adjustment 0000 0000 0000 0000 0000 0000 0000 (410019) (218911) (168119) (373022) (220864) (271921) (342847) (318372) (242446) (237864) (234492) (230942)
Environmental Remediation 42249 6062 18621 59079 24742 14257 20556 20576 11691 13468 105615 6000 6000 6000 6000 6000 6000 6000 6000
Non-Cash Liability Adjustments $3182192 $3051466 $3166371 $3785396 $3959443 $4108749 $4322293 $3542990 $3797981 $4020699 $3584911 $4027178 $4205012 $4320246 $4487966 $4713886 $4830392 $4947361 $5067352
Total Operating Expenses After Non-Cash Liability Adjs $12373319 $12563151 $12716857 $13722101 $14215924 $15046199 $15955827 $15413753 $16251641 $17559529 $17917683 $18336856 $18848977 $19348013 $19871550 $20446127 $20758090 $21405338 $22050644
Less BampT Depreciation $77213 $80097 $77846 $86545 $87926 $91345 $104039 $109783 $135035 $240957 $148686 $151977 $158779 $169848 $181689 $194355 $194355 $194355 $194355
BampT Other Post Employment Benefits 66323 50967 54831 66686 73055 76641 71148 62457 60441 78106 32297 22256 20303 22870 28694 33918 36169 38411 40604
Net Operating Deficit Before Subsidies and Debt Service ($6409807) ($6419266) ($6222079) ($6711095) ($7081966) ($7146057) ($7887759) ($6954506) ($7643392) ($8785339) ($8829030) ($9141907) ($9642826) ($10116260) ($10611154) ($11515498) ($11364824) ($11950106) ($12573710)
Conversion to Cash Basis Non-Cash Liability Adjs ($3182192) ($3051466) ($3166371) ($3785396) ($3959443) ($4108749) ($4322293) ($3542990) ($3797981) ($4020699) ($3584911) ($4027178) ($4205012) ($4320246) ($4487966) ($4713886) ($4830392) ($4947361) ($5067352)
Total Operating Expenses $9191127 $9511685 $9550486 $9936705 $10256481 $10937450 $11633535 $11870763 $12453659 $13539 $14333 $14310 $14644 $15028 $15384 $15732 $15927699 $16457978 $16983292
Debt Service Expenses $1515733 $1404454 $1781220 $1933532 $2058395 $2299262 $2248538 $2373321 $2458783 $2541 $2683 $2830 $3041 $3265 $3513 $3450 $3471321 $3472987 $3501639
Total Expenses + Debt Service $10706859 $10916139 $11331706 $11870237 $12314876 $13236712 $13882073 $14244084 $14912443 $16079 $17016 $17140 $17685 $18293 $18896 $19182 $19399019 $19930965 $20484932
Net Deficit After Subsidies and Debt Service ($668477) ($620796) ($0414) $287848 $320833 $556541 $561498 $810173 $359895 ($128044) ($613) ($539) ($898) ($1258) ($1667) ($2283) ($1901641) ($2229069) ($2664369)
Conversion to Cash Basis GASB Account (56067) (54256) (67377) (37636) (89548) (85641) (50017) - 0 - 0 0 0 0 $0 0 0 - 0 - 0 - 0 - 0
Conversion to Cash Basis 492710 550267 91781 (111037) (297407) (261709) (626297) (660147) (591809) 379 229 147 60 125 101 130 49745 48375 54220
Net Cash Balance from Previous Year 0000 0000 0000 23990 139174 0000 209191 0000 150026 0000 250569 0000 0000 0000 0000 0000 0000 0000 0000
Total Operating Exp + DS + Cash Conversions + PY C-O $11144 $11412 $11356 $11746 $12067 $12889362 $13414950 $13583937 $14470659 $16457999 $17495351 $17286526 $17744425 $18418197 $18997710 $19312017 $19448764 $19979340 $20539152
Total Operating Expenses with Cash Conversion $10270216 $10420127 $11307302 $12018911 $12701831 $13584063 $14558387 $14904231 $15504252 $15700774 $16786574 $16992579 $17624861 $18167420 $18795069 $19052755 $19349274 $19882590 $20430711
Baseline Net Cash Balance Before B-T-L Adjustments ($231834) ($124785) $23990 $139174 ($66122) $209191 ($114816) $150026 ($231914) $251 ($384) ($392) ($838) ($1133) ($1566) ($2153) ($1851896) ($2180695) ($2610148)
Below-the-Line Adjustments
FareToll Increases
FareToll Increase in March 2019 (4 Yield) - 0 $0 $0 $0 $0 $0 $0 - 0 - 0 - 0
FareToll Increase in March 2021 (4 Yield) - 0 $0 $0 $0 $283 $331 $332 333531 333568 334299
FareToll Increase in March 2023 (4 Yield) - 0 $0 $0 $0 $0 $0 $294 346386 346424 347183
FareToll Increase in March 2025 (4 Yield) - 0 $0 $0 $0 $0 $0 $0 - 0 273859 321624
Subsidy Impacts of 20212023 FareToll Increase - 0 $0 $0 $0 ($7) ($9) ($17) (18612) (25573) (26305)
$0000 $0 $0 $0 $275 $322 $609 $661306 $928278 $976801
CASH BALANCE AFTER FARE INCREASES $250569 ($384) ($392) ($838) ($850) ($1234) ($1821) ($1518365) ($1847127) ($2275849)
MTA Initiatives
MTA Efficiencies - Not Yet Implemented - 0 $0 $0 $0 $0 $0 $0 0000 0000 0000
0 - 0 $0 $0 $0 $0 $0 $0 - 0 - 0 - 0
0 - 0 $0 $0 $0 $0 $0 $0 - 0 - 0 - 0
$0000 $0 $0 $0 $0 $0 $0 $0000 $0000 $0000
Policy Actions
CAS Migration to Peoplesoft $0 $0 ($5) ($1) ($0) ($0) (0200) -02 -02 0
Fare Evasion Enforcement Strategy-Expenses $0 ($13) ($12) ($11) ($10) ($10) (9554) -9554483 -9554483 0
Fare Evasion Enforcement-Manhattan DA Forfeiture Fund $0 $11 $11 $10 $9 $0 - 0 0 0 0
Negotiated 1 CBA Reform $0 $0 $0 $0 $0 $0 - 0 0 0 0
MTA Reorganization $0 $8 $180 $371 $377 $377 377000 377 377 0
MTA Reorganization Costs $0 $0 ($10) ($27) ($2) $0 - 0 0 0 0
Drawdown 2019 General Reserve $0 $0 $165 $0 $0 $0 - 0 0 0 0
CBA Negotiated Reform - 1 Value $0 $36 $100 $173 $246 $323 323473 323473304484 323473304484 0
$0000 $0 $42 $429 $515 $620 $691 $690719 $690719 $690719
MTA Re-estimates
Additional Savings Actions $0000 $0 $0 $0 $0 $0 $0 $0000 $0000 $0000
Total Below-the-Line Adjustments $0 $73 $386 $757 $852 $1133 $1007 $1352025 $1618997 $1667520
Prior Year Carryover 495399 263336 138286 161986 301160 235038 444229 329413 479439 121 372 61 55 0 0 - 0 - 0 - 0 - 0
NET CASH BALANCE $263566 $138551 $162276 $301160 $235038 $444229 $329413 $479439 $247525 $372 $61 $55 ($26) ($281) ($433) ($1146) ($499871) ($561698) ($942628)
MTA February Financial Plan 2019-2022
Consolidated Statement Of Operations By Category ($ in millions)
Non-Reimbursable Final Adopted
Actual Actual Actual Actual Actual Actual Actual Actual Actual Actual Estimate Budget
2008 2009 2010 2011 2012 2013 2014 2015 2016 2017 2018 2019 2020 2021 2022 2023 2024 2025 2026
Operating Revenues
Farebox Revenue $4240923 $4350411 $4586377 $4999186 $5079138 $5501274 $5709200 $5961129 $6050182 $6172 $6153 $6122 $6144 $6134 $6144 $6174 $6435176 $6431979 $6446633
422 423 405 411 402 399 395 396 396 407 279 275 272 267 263 261 368 363 362
Student Fare - 0 - 0 - 0 - 0 - 0 - 0
Toll Revenue 1273974 1332115 1417046 1501589 1490982 1645193 1676445 1808901 1869693 1912 1967 1984 1990 1998 1998 2002 2133050 2137871 2143111
0127 0129 0125 0124 0118 0119 0116 0120 0122 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0122 0121 0120
Other Revenue 448616 461359 491355 510231 563839 753675 682424 689217 688374 653 662 705 733 757 743 755 825040 885381 887190
Capital and Other Reimbursements 0000 0000 0000 0000 0000 0000 0000 0000 0000 0000 0000 0000 0000 0000 0000 0000 0000 0000 0000
Total Operating Revenue $5963512 $6143885 $6494778 $7011006 $7133959 $7900142 $8068069 $8459247 $8608249 $8737 $8782 $8810 $8867 $8889 $8886 $8931 $9393266 $9455232 $9476934
Dedicated Taxes $3211585 $2366805 $2343537 $2511691 $2673119 $3097640 $3383498 $3582628 $3525829 $3257508 $3459 $3515 $3568 $3630 $3725 $3812 $3841433 $3880226 $3917215
PMT amp MTA Aid - 0 881784 1588677 1718286 1825824 1825328 1885069 1910947 1970760 1987035 $1965 $2152 $2225 $2295 $2368 $2442 2516095 2594604 2677041
New Funding Sources - 0 - 0 - 0 - 0 - 0 - 0 - 0 - 0 - 0 - 0 $508 $342 $385 $385 $385 $385 385000 385000 385000
StateLocal Taxes 556691 539046 544810 541733 536182 537527 539545 537819 537645 541005 $544 $552 $557 $562 $567 $572 576828 581933 583214
Other Funding Agreements 306594 363823 359489 375369 466625 432617 567391 563616 629855 630218 $701 $753 $671 $708 $758 $758 784755 804901 781159
BampT Operating Surplus Transfer 382565 363092 476059 554903 476575 614210 637553 750717 742909 740144 $702 $721 $782 $801 $789 $707 730476 695303 688833
Dedicated Taxes and StateLocal Subsidies $4457434 $4514550 $5312572 $5701982 $5978325 $6507322 $7013056 $7345727 $7406998 $7155909 $7879 $8035 $8188 $8381 $8592 $8676 $8834588 $8941967 $9032462
$0000 $0000 $0000 $0000 $0000 $0000 $0000 $0000 $0000
Less Interagency Subsidy and Surplus Transfers (382565) (363092) (476059) (554903) (476575) (614210) (637553) (750717) (742909) (740144) ($702) ($721) ($782) ($801) ($789) ($707) (730476) (695303) (688833)
Total Subsidies $4074870 $4151458 $4836513 $5147079 $5501750 $5893111 $6375503 $6595010 $6664088 $6416 $7242 $7238 $7370 $7576 $7807 $7969 $8104112 $8246664 $8343629
Dedicated Taxes as a of Total Revenues + Subs - PMT 320 251 241 241 247 259 269 273 265 247 $0 $0 $0 $0 $0 $0 256 257 259
Total Revenues + Subsidies $10038382 $10295342 $11331292 $12158085 $12635709 $13793254 $14443571 $15054257 $15272337 $15152 $16023 $16048 $16237 $16465 $16693 $16900 $17497378 $17701896 $17820563
Operating Expenses
Labor Expenses
Payroll $4087376 $4163330 $4171374 $4160261 $4193658 $4332829 $4671664 $4695823 $4838741 $5020713 $5211 $5328 $5422 $5498 $5624 $5710 $5860206 $5982960 $6107107
Overtime 471675 499307 443227 538647 574316 620701 730200 755071 771495 934100 $1066 $910 $838 $859 $877 $899 917296 935002 951324
Health amp Welfare 684945 688899 738189 809638 812857 895714 961902 1050100 1172304 1208786 $1230 $1341 $1414 $1489 $1583 $1674 1797938 1922668 2071273
OPEB Current Payment 318501 346316 355716 394218 413164 472619 479079 501716 562233 563754 $604 $645 $704 $766 $835 $910 982025 1060022 1142795
Pensions 897450 1021229 1029710 1074598 1328441 1301975 1304355 1248726 1370474 1345308 $1336 $1494 $1461 $1462 $1403 $1347 1357887 1369071 1380572
Other-Fringe Benefits 502739 517194 539996 581661 650430 694680 784143 861079 947870 792151 $881 $869 $897 $930 $956 $976 1001185 1021007 1040170
Reimbursable Overhead (310555) (322230) (345154) (324006) (309399) (321390) (349770) (380212) (423759) (491807) ($528) ($471) ($430) ($412) ($397) ($395) (396136) (405509) (413165)
Labor Expenses $6652131 $6914045 $6933059 $7235017 $7663467 $7997128 $8581574 $8732302 $9239358 $9373 $9920 $10039 $10436 $10787 $11097 $11413 $11520401 $11885220 $12280075
PayrollOvertime Exp as a of Total Operating+DS $0426 $0427 $0407 $0396 $0387 $0374 $0389 $0383 $0376 $0385 $0349 $0347 $0345
Labor Exp (wo Reimb OH) as a of Total Oper+DS $0650 $0663 $0642 $0637 $0647 $0628 $0643 $0640 $0648 $0638 $0614 $0617 $0620
PayrollOvertime Exp as a of Total Operating Exp $0496 $0490 $0483 $0473 $0465 $0453 $0464 $0459 $0450 $0461 $0426 $0420 $0416
Labor Exp (wo Reimb OH) as a of Total Oper Exp $0758 $0761 $0762 $0761 $0777 $0761 $0768 $0768 $0776 $0763 $0748 $0747 $0747
Non-Labor Expenses
Electric Power $306500 $317934 $325137 $457269 $471514 $493346 $515540 $473762 $406372 $430381 $474918 $451304 $463523 $482662 $539624 $571182 $589565 $618283 $648255
Traction Power
Non-Traction Power
Fuel 287033 180294 189942 282735 251763 259252 267494 162283 124684 150481 185580 190348 187592 183168 181484 182259 182476 184281 186170
Revenue Vehicle Fuel
Non-Revenue Fuel
Insurance 28902 34012 9819 14363 7617 38654 50739 57190 (20634) (2715) 11488 8532 15803 22918 29411 36048 28232 25538 19483
Claims 152114 238104 285418 315547 135652 299875 269167 331023 463959 526053 376480 378570 386981 391333 395228 404397 417667 428660 437683
Paratransit Service Contracts 299013 370094 379761 348553 360500 366751 365599 379271 383704 392850 452190 482751 501230 518038 547829 581114 604766 643217 684112
Maintenance and Other Operating Contracts 594215 562456 541716 451137 451766 496743 549018 579289 630924 695251 779331 897801 833038 883805 871671 879468 880053 898882 915477
Professional Service Contracts 196930 199164 203084 226205 276998 297201 283005 379814 399706 507062 575742 557476 484911 479376 489510 499724 520826 537109 547291
Materials amp Supplies 532534 526191 511206 438310 430804 475127 526725 543225 585607 588115 667700 686666 687745 692131 697268 711988 741335 777460 793419
Other Business Expenses 155466 184142 189637 169857 143807 167198 179701 195598 192576 217254 225494 230595 225293 240279 242193 244907 228861 240258 241690
Non-Labor Expenses $2552708 $2612391 $2635720 $2703976 $2530421 $2894147 $3006988 $3101454 $3166897 3505 3749 3884 3786 3894 3994 4111 $4193782 $4353689 $4473580
Other Expense Adjustments
Other ($13712) ($14750) ($18292) ($2289) $62593 $46175 $44973 $37007 $47404 49 134 158 84 36 22 23 $23516 $24069 $24637
General Reserve 0000 0000 0000 0000 0000 - 0 - 0 - 0 - 0 0 0 165 170 175 180 185 190000 195000 205000
Other Expense Adjustments ($13712) ($14750) ($18292) ($2289) $62593 $46175 $44973 $37007 $47404 $49379 $134 $323 $254 $211 $202 $208 $213516 $219069 $229637
Gap Closing Expenses $7675394
Additional Actions for Budget Balance Expense Impact $0000 $0000 $0000 $0000 $0000 $0000 $0000 $0000 $0000 $0000 $0000 $0000 $0000 $0000 $0000 $0000 $0000 $0000 $0000
Total Operating Expenses Before Non-Cash Liability Adjs $9191127 $9511685 $9550486 $9936705 $10256481 $10937450 $11633535 $11870763 $12453659 $12927116 $13802910 $14246122 $14475644 $14891445 $15293262 $15732241 $15927699 $16457978 $16983292
Non-Cash Liability Adjustments
Depreciation $1790981 $1940576 $1980681 $2019378 $2148820 $2174302 $2266280 $2442777 $2442941 $2607970 $2804571 $2784812 $2842737 $2908533 $2977025 $3051834 $3109882 $3169371 $3230301
OPEB Obligation 1348962 1104827 1167070 1706939 1785881 1920189 2035457 1489656 1562261 1567381 0000 (0000) (0000) (0000) (0000) 0000 0000 (0000) (0000)
GASB 75 OPEB Expense Adjustment 0000 0000 0000 0000 0000 0000 0000 0000 0000 0000 1047747 1457230 1628196 1748560 1823313 1898497 1952374 2006482 2061993
GASB 68 Pension Expense Adjustment 0000 0000 0000 0000 0000 0000 0000 (410019) (218911) (168119) (373022) (220864) (271921) (342847) (318372) (242446) (237864) (234492) (230942)
Environmental Remediation 42249 6062 18621 59079 24742 14257 20556 20576 11691 13468 105615 6000 6000 6000 6000 6000 6000 6000 6000
Non-Cash Liability Adjustments $3182192 $3051466 $3166371 $3785396 $3959443 $4108749 $4322293 $3542990 $3797981 $4020699 $3584911 $4027178 $4205012 $4320246 $4487966 $4713886 $4830392 $4947361 $5067352
Total Operating Expenses After Non-Cash Liability Adjs $12373319 $12563151 $12716857 $13722101 $14215924 $15046199 $15955827 $15413753 $16251641 $16947815 $17387821 $18273301 $18680657 $19211690 $19781228 $20446127 $20758090 $21405338 $22050644
Less BampT Depreciation $77213 $80097 $77846 $86545 $87926 $91345 $104039 $109783 $135035 $240957 $148686 $151977 $158779 $169848 $181689 $194355 $194355 $194355 $194355
BampT Other Post Employment Benefits 66323 50967 54831 66686 73055 76641 71148 62457 60441 78106 32297 22256 20303 22870 28694 33918 36169 38411 40604
Net Operating Deficit Before Subsidies and Debt Service ($6409807) ($6419266) ($6222079) ($6711095) ($7081966) ($7146057) ($7887759) ($6954506) ($7643392) ($8211234) ($8606220) ($9463506) ($9813560) ($10322912) ($10895644) ($11515498) ($11364824) ($11950106) ($12573710)
Conversion to Cash Basis Non-Cash Liability Adjs ($3182192) ($3051466) ($3166371) ($3785396) ($3959443) ($4108749) ($4322293) ($3542990) ($3797981) ($4020699) ($3584911) ($4027178) ($4205012) ($4320246) ($4487966) ($4713886) ($4830392) ($4947361) ($5067352)
Total Operating Expenses $9191127 $9511685 $9550486 $9936705 $10256481 $10937450 $11633535 $11870763 $12453659 $12927 $13803 $14246 $14476 $14891 $15293 $15732 $15927699 $16457978 $16983292
Debt Service Expenses $1515733 $1404454 $1781220 $1933532 $2058395 $2299262 $2248538 $2373321 $2458783 $2525 $2559 $2692 $2840 $3080 $3223 $3450 $3471321 $3472987 $3501639
Total Expenses + Debt Service $10706859 $10916139 $11331706 $11870237 $12314876 $13236712 $13882073 $14244084 $14912443 $15452 $16362 $16938 $17316 $17971 $18516 $19182 $19399019 $19930965 $20484932
Net Deficit After Subsidies and Debt Service ($668477) ($620796) ($0414) $287848 $320833 $556541 $561498 $810173 $359895 ($299965) ($339) ($890) ($1079) ($1506) ($1823) ($2283) ($1901641) ($2229069) ($2664369)
Conversion to Cash Basis GASB Account (56067) (54256) (67377) (37636) (89548) (85641) (50017) - 0 - 0 0 0 0 $0 0 0 - 0 - 0 - 0 - 0
Conversion to Cash Basis 492710 550267 91781 (111037) (297407) (261709) (626297) (660147) (591809) 174 296 363 188 (17) 88 130 49745 48375 54220
Net Cash Balance from Previous Year 0000 0000 0000 23990 139174 0000 209191 0000 150026 0000 0000 0000 0000 0000 0000 0000 0000 0000 0000
Total Operating Exp + DS + Cash Conversions + PY C-O $11144 $11412 $11356 $11746 $12067 $12889362 $13414950 $13583937 $14470659 $15625875 $16658585 $17300293 $17504155 $17954574 $18604130 $19312017 $19448764 $19979340 $20539152
Total Operating Expenses with Cash Conversion $10270216 $10420127 $11307302 $12018911 $12701831 $13584063 $14558387 $14904231 $15504252 $15278749 $16065734 $16575223 $17128079 $17987951 $18427778 $19052755 $19349274 $19882590 $20430711
Baseline Net Cash Balance Before B-T-L Adjustments ($231834) ($124785) $23990 $139174 ($66122) $209191 ($114816) $150026 ($231914) ($126) ($43) ($527) ($891) ($1523) ($1735) ($2153) ($1851896) ($2180695) ($2610148)
Below-the-Line Adjustments
FareToll Increases
FareToll Increase in March 2019 (4 Yield) - 0 $0 $0 $0 $0 $0 $0 - 0 - 0 - 0
FareToll Increase in March 2021 (4 Yield) - 0 $0 $0 $0 $283 $331 $332 333531 333568 334299
FareToll Increase in March 2023 (4 Yield) - 0 $0 $0 $0 $0 $0 $294 346386 346424 347183
FareToll Increase in March 2025 (4 Yield) - 0 $0 $0 $0 $0 $0 $0 - 0 273859 321624
Subsidy Impacts of 20212023 FareToll Increase - 0 $0 $0 $0 ($7) ($9) ($17) (18612) (25573) (26305)
$0000 $0 $0 $0 $275 $322 $609 $661306 $928278 $976801
CASH BALANCE AFTER FARE INCREASES ($126402) ($43) ($527) ($891) ($1241) ($1404) ($1821) ($1518365) ($1847127) ($2275849)
MTA Initiatives
MTA Efficiencies - Not Yet Implemented - 0 $0 $0 $0 $0 $0 $0 0000 0000 0000
0 - 0 $0 $0 $0 $0 $0 $0 - 0 - 0 - 0
0 - 0 $0 $0 $0 $0 $0 $0 - 0 - 0 - 0
$0000 $0 $0 $0 $0 $0 $0 $0000 $0000 $0000
Policy Actions
CAS Migration to Peoplesoft $0 $0 ($5) ($1) ($0) ($0) (0200) -02 -02 0
Fare Evasion Enforcement Strategy-Expenses $0 ($13) ($12) ($11) ($10) ($10) (9554) -9554483 -9554483 0
Fare Evasion Enforcement-Manhattan DA Forfeiture Fund $0 $11 $11 $10 $9 $0 - 0 0 0 0
Negotiated 1 CBA Reform $0 $0 $0 $0 $0 $0 - 0 0 0 0
MTA Reorganization $0 $8 $180 $371 $377 $377 377000 377 377 0
MTA Reorganization Costs $0 $0 ($10) ($27) ($2) $0 - 0 0 0 0
Drawdown 2019 General Reserve $0 $0 $165 $0 $0 $0 - 0 0 0 0
CBA Negotiated Reform - 1 Value $0 $36 $100 $173 $246 $323 323473 323473304484 323473304484 0
$0000 $0 $42 $429 $515 $620 $691 $690719 $690719 $690719
MTA Re-estimates
Additional Savings Actions $0000 $0 $0 $0 $0 $0 $0 $0000 $0000 $0000
Total Below-the-Line Adjustments $0 $0 $459 $413 $709 $760 $1007 $1352025 $1618997 $1667520
Prior Year Carryover 495399 263336 138286 161986 301160 235038 444229 329413 479439 248 121 79 11 0 0 - 0 - 0 - 0 - 0
NET CASH BALANCE $263566 $138551 $162276 $301160 $235038 $444229 $329413 $479439 $247525 $121 $79 $11 ($467) ($814) ($976) ($1146) ($499871) ($561698) ($942628)
By Revenue Source
(includes faretoll increases)
($ in millions)
Farebox Revenue $6389
Toll Revenue 2121
Other Revenue 684
Dedicated Taxes 6191
State and Local amp Other 1228
Timing (Cash Adjustments) 135
Total $16748
By Expense Category
(includes below-the-line adjustments)
($ in millions)
Payroll $5422
Overtime 838
Health amp Welfare 2118
Pension 1461
Other Labor 466
Total Labor $10306
Non-Labor + Other Exp Adj 4004
Debt Service 2830
BTL Adjustments for Expenses 2 (386)
Total $16754
By Revenue Source
(includes faretoll increases)
($ in millions)
Farebox Revenue $6389
Toll Revenue 2121
Other Revenue 684
Taxes 6178
State and Local amp Other 557
Other Funding Agreements 671
Other 1 208
Total $16809
By Expense Category
(includes below-the-line adjustments)
($ in millions)
Payroll $5392
Overtime 811
Health amp Welfare 2129
Pension 1354
Other Labor 400
Total Labor $10086
Non-Labor 4205
Debt Service 2692
BTL Adjustments for Expenses (251)
Total $16732
Page 11: MTA 2020 Preliminary Budget July Financial Plan 2020 - 2023 2020 Preliminar… · 1 The MTA Budget Process July Plan – Start of the Annual Process • Current year is revised (the

The MTArsquos $350 million target for annually recurring savings beginning in 2020 has been identified and is being implemented

109

10 7 6 6

96 304 351 362 371

$0

$50

$100

$150

$200

$250

$300

$350

$400

2019 2020 2021 2022 2023

Identified Recurring Savings One-Shot Savings

This Year Next Year Out-Years

($ in millions)

10

We have a track record of identifying and achieving our annual recurring savings targets

11

($ in millions)

$0

$500

$1000

$1500

$2000

$2500

$3000

Achieved Savings

2012 November Plan

2013 November Plan

2014 November Plan

2015 November Plan

2016 November Plan

2017 November Plan

2018 November Plan

2019 July Plan

$28 billion

Proposed July Plan

Deficits remain and a continued drive toward further streamlining and efficiencies is required

12

($ in millions)

61 55

(26)

(281)

(433)

($600)

($500)

($400)

($300)

($200)

($100)

$0

$100

$200

2019 2020 2021 2022 2023

This Year Next Year Out-Years

Proposed July PlanDonrsquot achieve Transformation Plan Savings

13

If the MTA Transformation Plan is not adopted and implemented the deficits will be unmanageable without service cuts significant

reductions in force andor additional fare and toll increases($ in millions)

($1100)

($900)

($700)

($500)

($300)

($100)

$100

2019 2020 2021 2022 2023

(816)

(971)

(569)

(81)

(433)

(281)

61 55 (26)

(281) (186)

50

Next Year Out-Years

(230)(11)

(488)

(538)

(535)

This Year

14

2020 Preliminary BudgetWhere the Dollars Come Fromhellip Where the Dollars Gohellip

Farebox Revenue $6389Toll Revenue 2121 Other Revenue 684 Taxes 6178 State and Local amp Other 557 Other Funding Agreements 671 Other 1 208 Total $16809

($ in millions)

By Revenue Source(includes faretoll increases)

Payroll $5422Overtime 838 Health amp Welfare 2118 Pension 1461 Other Labor 466 Total Labor $10306Non-Labor + Other Exp Adj 4004 Debt Service 2830 BTL Adjustments for Expenses 2 (386) Total $16754

By Expense Category

($ in millions)(includes below-the-line adjustments)

1 Includes cash adjustments and prior-year carryover

Farebox Revenue

38

Toll Revenue

13

Other Revenue4

Taxes37

State amp Local

Subsidies3

Other Funding Agreements

4 Other 1

Payroll32

Overtime5

Health ampWelfare

13Pension

9

Other Labor3

Non-Labor + Other Exp Adj

21

Debt Service17

2 The below-the-line adjustments are grouped in the Non-Labor category

Sheet1

Sheet1

15

Non-Reimbursable Mid-Year Preliminary Actual Forecast Budget

2018 2019 2020 2021 2022 2023 Operating Revenues

Farebox Revenue $6155 $6305 $6389 $6373 $6384 $6393Toll Revenue 1976 2088 2121 2129 2129 2131 Other Revenue 643 696 684 704 719 737

Total Operating Revenue $8774 $9089 $9195 $9206 $9232 $9260

Total Subsidies $7177 $7314 $7406 $7581 $7803 $7969Dedicated Taxes as a of Total Revenues + Subs - PMT 233 $0 $0 $0 $0 $0

Total Revenues + Subsidies $15951 $16403 $16601 $16787 $17035 $17229

Operating ExpensesLabor Expenses $9799 $10116 $10306 $10592 $10881 $11121Non-Labor Expenses 3611 3877 3748 3841 3945 4054 Other 129 175 86 36 22 23 General Reserve 0 165 170 175 180 185

Total Operating Expenses $13539 $14333 $14310 $14644 $15028 $15384

Debt Service Expenses $2541 $2683 $2830 $3041 $3265 $3513

Total Expenses + Debt Service $16079 $17016 $17140 $17685 $18293 $18896

Conversion to Cash Basis 379 229 147 60 125 101

Baseline Net Cash Balance Before B-T-L Adjustments $251 ($384) ($392) ($838) ($1133) ($1566)

Total Below-the-Line Adjustments $0 $73 $386 $757 $852 $1133Prior Year Carryover 121 372 61 55 0 0

NET CASH BALANCE $372 $61 $55 ($26) ($281) ($433)

MTA July Financial Plan 2020-2023Consolidated Statement Of Operations By Category ($ in millions)

Summ Stmt of Ops-Feb

Summ Stmt of Ops-Jul

  • MTA 2020Preliminary BudgetJuly Financial Plan2020 - 2023
  • The MTA Budget Process
  • Slide Number 3
  • Slide Number 4
  • What has changed since the February Plan
  • Highlights of the July Plan
  • Slide Number 7
  • MTA Transformation Plan
  • Slide Number 9
  • Actions to Reduce Fare Evasion $62 million Investment over the Plan Period
  • The MTArsquos $350 million target for annually recurring savings beginning in 2020 has been identified and is being implemented
  • We have a track record of identifying and achieving our annual recurring savings targets
  • Deficits remain and a continued drive toward further streamlining and efficiencies is required
  • Slide Number 14
  • 2020 Preliminary Budget
  • Slide Number 16
MTA July Financial Plan 2020-2023
Consolidated Statement Of Operations By Category ($ in millions)
Non-Reimbursable Mid-Year Preliminary
Actual Actual Actual Actual Actual Actual Actual Actual Actual Actual Forecast Budget
2008 2009 2010 2011 2012 2013 2014 2015 2016 2018 2019 2020 2021 2022 2023 2023 2024 2025 2026
Operating Revenues
Farebox Revenue $4240923 $4350411 $4586377 $4999186 $5079138 $5501274 $5709200 $5961129 $6050182 $6155 $6305 $6389 $6373 $6384 $6393 $6174 $6435176 $6431979 $6446633
422 423 405 411 402 399 395 396 396 386 384 385 380 375 371 261 368 363 362
Student Fare - 0 - 0 - 0 - 0 - 0 - 0
Toll Revenue 1273974 1332115 1417046 1501589 1490982 1645193 1676445 1808901 1869693 1976 2088 2121 2129 2129 2131 2002 2133050 2137871 2143111
0127 0129 0125 0124 0118 0119 0116 0120 0122 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0122 0121 0120
Other Revenue 448616 461359 491355 510231 563839 753675 682424 689217 688374 643 696 684 704 719 737 755 825040 885381 887190
Capital and Other Reimbursements 0000 0000 0000 0000 0000 0000 0000 0000 0000 0000 0000 0000 0000 0000 0000 0000 0000 0000 0000
Total Operating Revenue $5963512 $6143885 $6494778 $7011006 $7133959 $7900142 $8068069 $8459247 $8608249 $8774 $9089 $9195 $9206 $9232 $9260 $8931 $9393266 $9455232 $9476934
Dedicated Taxes $3211585 $2366805 $2343537 $2511691 $2673119 $3097640 $3383498 $3582628 $3525829 $3257508 $3459 $3515 $3568 $3630 $3725 $3812 $3841433 $3880226 $3917215
PMT amp MTA Aid - 0 881784 1588677 1718286 1825824 1825328 1885069 1910947 1970760 1987035 $1965 $2152 $2225 $2295 $2368 $2442 2516095 2594604 2677041
New Funding Sources - 0 - 0 - 0 - 0 - 0 - 0 - 0 - 0 - 0 - 0 $508 $342 $385 $385 $385 $385 385000 385000 385000
StateLocal Taxes 556691 539046 544810 541733 536182 537527 539545 537819 537645 541005 $544 $552 $557 $562 $567 $572 576828 581933 583214
Other Funding Agreements 306594 363823 359489 375369 466625 432617 567391 563616 629855 630218 $701 $753 $671 $708 $758 $758 784755 804901 781159
BampT Operating Surplus Transfer 382565 363092 476059 554903 476575 614210 637553 750717 742909 740144 $702 $721 $782 $801 $789 $707 730476 695303 688833
Dedicated Taxes and StateLocal Subsidies $4457434 $4514550 $5312572 $5701982 $5978325 $6507322 $7013056 $7345727 $7406998 $7155909 $7879 $8035 $8188 $8381 $8592 $8676 $8834588 $8941967 $9032462
$0000 $0000 $0000 $0000 $0000 $0000 $0000 $0000 $0000
Less Interagency Subsidy and Surplus Transfers (382565) (363092) (476059) (554903) (476575) (614210) (637553) (750717) (742909) (740144) ($702) ($721) ($782) ($801) ($789) ($707) (730476) (695303) (688833)
Total Subsidies $4074870 $4151458 $4836513 $5147079 $5501750 $5893111 $6375503 $6595010 $6664088 $7177 $7314 $7406 $7581 $7803 $7969 $7969 $8104112 $8246664 $8343629
Dedicated Taxes as a of Total Revenues + Subs - PMT 320 251 241 241 247 259 269 273 265 233 $0 $0 $0 $0 $0 $0 256 257 259
Total Revenues + Subsidies $10038382 $10295342 $11331292 $12158085 $12635709 $13793254 $14443571 $15054257 $15272337 $15951 $16403 $16601 $16787 $17035 $17229 $16900 $17497378 $17701896 $17820563
Operating Expenses
Labor Expenses
Payroll $4087376 $4163330 $4171374 $4160261 $4193658 $4332829 $4671664 $4695823 $4838741 $5020713 $5211 $5328 $5422 $5498 $5624 $5710 $5860206 $5982960 $6107107
Overtime 471675 499307 443227 538647 574316 620701 730200 755071 771495 934100 $1066 $910 $838 $859 $877 $899 917296 935002 951324
Health amp Welfare 684945 688899 738189 809638 812857 895714 961902 1050100 1172304 1208786 $1230 $1341 $1414 $1489 $1583 $1674 1797938 1922668 2071273
OPEB Current Payment 318501 346316 355716 394218 413164 472619 479079 501716 562233 563754 $604 $645 $704 $766 $835 $910 982025 1060022 1142795
Pensions 897450 1021229 1029710 1074598 1328441 1301975 1304355 1248726 1370474 1345308 $1336 $1494 $1461 $1462 $1403 $1347 1357887 1369071 1380572
Other-Fringe Benefits 502739 517194 539996 581661 650430 694680 784143 861079 947870 792151 $881 $869 $897 $930 $956 $976 1001185 1021007 1040170
Reimbursable Overhead (310555) (322230) (345154) (324006) (309399) (321390) (349770) (380212) (423759) (491807) ($528) ($471) ($430) ($412) ($397) ($395) (396136) (405509) (413165)
Labor Expenses $6652131 $6914045 $6933059 $7235017 $7663467 $7997128 $8581574 $8732302 $9239358 $9799 $10116 $10306 $10592 $10881 $11121 $11413 $11520401 $11885220 $12280075
PayrollOvertime Exp as a of Total Operating+DS $0426 $0427 $0407 $0396 $0387 $0374 $0389 $0383 $0376 $0390 $0367 $0365 $0359 $0355 $0350 $0349 $0347 $0345
Labor Exp (wo Reimb OH) as a of Total Oper+DS $0650 $0663 $0642 $0637 $0647 $0628 $0643 $0640 $0648 $0642 $0622 $0626 $0622 $0616 $0609 $0614 $0617 $0620
PayrollOvertime Exp as a of Total Operating Exp $0496 $0490 $0483 $0473 $0465 $0453 $0464 $0459 $0450 $0464 $0435 $0438 $0434 $0433 $0430 $0426 $0420 $0416
Labor Exp (wo Reimb OH) as a of Total Oper Exp $0758 $0761 $0762 $0761 $0777 $0761 $0768 $0768 $0776 $0763 $0739 $0750 $0751 $0750 $0749 $0748 $0747 $0747
Non-Labor Expenses
Electric Power $306500 $317934 $325137 $457269 $471514 $493346 $515540 $473762 $406372 $481893 $451503 $473177 $493090 $532413 $561955 $571182 $589565 $618283 $648255
Traction Power
Non-Traction Power
Fuel 287033 180294 189942 282735 251763 259252 267494 162283 124684 185203 182778 182981 176333 173681 176920 182259 182476 184281 186170
Revenue Vehicle Fuel
Non-Revenue Fuel
Insurance 28902 34012 9819 14363 7617 38654 50739 57190 (20634) (29402) 5608 15623 23118 26855 28309 36048 28232 25538 19483
Claims 152114 238104 285418 315547 135652 299875 269167 331023 463959 437985 387557 394211 392547 398256 406112 404397 417667 428660 437683
Paratransit Service Contracts 299013 370094 379761 348553 360500 366751 365599 379271 383704 455471 494751 488330 505538 535329 568614 581114 604766 643217 684112
Maintenance and Other Operating Contracts 594215 562456 541716 451137 451766 496743 549018 579289 630924 678425 840168 797428 833534 836606 854471 879468 880053 898882 915477
Professional Service Contracts 196930 199164 203084 226205 276998 297201 283005 379814 399706 543582 607838 502858 494814 504103 513895 499724 520826 537109 547291
Materials amp Supplies 532534 526191 511206 438310 430804 475127 526725 543225 585607 637078 689010 679895 697976 711281 715758 711988 741335 777460 793419
Other Business Expenses 155466 184142 189637 169857 143807 167198 179701 195598 192576 220838 218196 213551 224459 226170 228457 244907 228861 240258 241690
Non-Labor Expenses $2552708 $2612391 $2635720 $2703976 $2530421 $2894147 $3006988 $3101454 $3166897 3611 3877 3748 3841 3945 4054 4111 $4193782 $4353689 $4473580
Other Expense Adjustments
Other ($13712) ($14750) ($18292) ($2289) $62593 $46175 $44973 $37007 $47404 129 175 86 36 22 23 23 $23516 $24069 $24637
General Reserve 0000 0000 0000 0000 0000 - 0 - 0 - 0 - 0 0 165 170 175 180 185 185 190000 195000 205000
Other Expense Adjustments ($13712) ($14750) ($18292) ($2289) $62593 $46175 $44973 $37007 $47404 $128555 $340 $256 $211 $202 $208 $208 $213516 $219069 $229637
Gap Closing Expenses $7675394
Additional Actions for Budget Balance Expense Impact $0000 $0000 $0000 $0000 $0000 $0000 $0000 $0000 $0000 $0000 $0000 $0000 $0000 $0000 $0000 $0000 $0000 $0000 $0000
Total Operating Expenses Before Non-Cash Liability Adjs $9191127 $9511685 $9550486 $9936705 $10256481 $10937450 $11633535 $11870763 $12453659 $13538830 $14332772 $14309678 $14643965 $15027767 $15383584 $15732241 $15927699 $16457978 $16983292
Non-Cash Liability Adjustments
Depreciation $1790981 $1940576 $1980681 $2019378 $2148820 $2174302 $2266280 $2442777 $2442941 $2607970 $2804571 $2784812 $2842737 $2908533 $2977025 $3051834 $3109882 $3169371 $3230301
OPEB Obligation 1348962 1104827 1167070 1706939 1785881 1920189 2035457 1489656 1562261 1567381 0000 (0000) (0000) (0000) (0000) 0000 0000 (0000) (0000)
GASB 75 OPEB Expense Adjustment 0000 0000 0000 0000 0000 0000 0000 0000 0000 0000 1047747 1457230 1628196 1748560 1823313 1898497 1952374 2006482 2061993
GASB 68 Pension Expense Adjustment 0000 0000 0000 0000 0000 0000 0000 (410019) (218911) (168119) (373022) (220864) (271921) (342847) (318372) (242446) (237864) (234492) (230942)
Environmental Remediation 42249 6062 18621 59079 24742 14257 20556 20576 11691 13468 105615 6000 6000 6000 6000 6000 6000 6000 6000
Non-Cash Liability Adjustments $3182192 $3051466 $3166371 $3785396 $3959443 $4108749 $4322293 $3542990 $3797981 $4020699 $3584911 $4027178 $4205012 $4320246 $4487966 $4713886 $4830392 $4947361 $5067352
Total Operating Expenses After Non-Cash Liability Adjs $12373319 $12563151 $12716857 $13722101 $14215924 $15046199 $15955827 $15413753 $16251641 $17559529 $17917683 $18336856 $18848977 $19348013 $19871550 $20446127 $20758090 $21405338 $22050644
Less BampT Depreciation $77213 $80097 $77846 $86545 $87926 $91345 $104039 $109783 $135035 $240957 $148686 $151977 $158779 $169848 $181689 $194355 $194355 $194355 $194355
BampT Other Post Employment Benefits 66323 50967 54831 66686 73055 76641 71148 62457 60441 78106 32297 22256 20303 22870 28694 33918 36169 38411 40604
Net Operating Deficit Before Subsidies and Debt Service ($6409807) ($6419266) ($6222079) ($6711095) ($7081966) ($7146057) ($7887759) ($6954506) ($7643392) ($8785339) ($8829030) ($9141907) ($9642826) ($10116260) ($10611154) ($11515498) ($11364824) ($11950106) ($12573710)
Conversion to Cash Basis Non-Cash Liability Adjs ($3182192) ($3051466) ($3166371) ($3785396) ($3959443) ($4108749) ($4322293) ($3542990) ($3797981) ($4020699) ($3584911) ($4027178) ($4205012) ($4320246) ($4487966) ($4713886) ($4830392) ($4947361) ($5067352)
Total Operating Expenses $9191127 $9511685 $9550486 $9936705 $10256481 $10937450 $11633535 $11870763 $12453659 $13539 $14333 $14310 $14644 $15028 $15384 $15732 $15927699 $16457978 $16983292
Debt Service Expenses $1515733 $1404454 $1781220 $1933532 $2058395 $2299262 $2248538 $2373321 $2458783 $2541 $2683 $2830 $3041 $3265 $3513 $3450 $3471321 $3472987 $3501639
Total Expenses + Debt Service $10706859 $10916139 $11331706 $11870237 $12314876 $13236712 $13882073 $14244084 $14912443 $16079 $17016 $17140 $17685 $18293 $18896 $19182 $19399019 $19930965 $20484932
Net Deficit After Subsidies and Debt Service ($668477) ($620796) ($0414) $287848 $320833 $556541 $561498 $810173 $359895 ($128044) ($613) ($539) ($898) ($1258) ($1667) ($2283) ($1901641) ($2229069) ($2664369)
Conversion to Cash Basis GASB Account (56067) (54256) (67377) (37636) (89548) (85641) (50017) - 0 - 0 0 0 0 $0 0 0 - 0 - 0 - 0 - 0
Conversion to Cash Basis 492710 550267 91781 (111037) (297407) (261709) (626297) (660147) (591809) 379 229 147 60 125 101 130 49745 48375 54220
Net Cash Balance from Previous Year 0000 0000 0000 23990 139174 0000 209191 0000 150026 0000 250569 0000 0000 0000 0000 0000 0000 0000 0000
Total Operating Exp + DS + Cash Conversions + PY C-O $11144 $11412 $11356 $11746 $12067 $12889362 $13414950 $13583937 $14470659 $16457999 $17495351 $17286526 $17744425 $18418197 $18997710 $19312017 $19448764 $19979340 $20539152
Total Operating Expenses with Cash Conversion $10270216 $10420127 $11307302 $12018911 $12701831 $13584063 $14558387 $14904231 $15504252 $15700774 $16786574 $16992579 $17624861 $18167420 $18795069 $19052755 $19349274 $19882590 $20430711
Baseline Net Cash Balance Before B-T-L Adjustments ($231834) ($124785) $23990 $139174 ($66122) $209191 ($114816) $150026 ($231914) $251 ($384) ($392) ($838) ($1133) ($1566) ($2153) ($1851896) ($2180695) ($2610148)
Below-the-Line Adjustments
FareToll Increases
FareToll Increase in March 2019 (4 Yield) - 0 $0 $0 $0 $0 $0 $0 - 0 - 0 - 0
FareToll Increase in March 2021 (4 Yield) - 0 $0 $0 $0 $283 $331 $332 333531 333568 334299
FareToll Increase in March 2023 (4 Yield) - 0 $0 $0 $0 $0 $0 $294 346386 346424 347183
FareToll Increase in March 2025 (4 Yield) - 0 $0 $0 $0 $0 $0 $0 - 0 273859 321624
Subsidy Impacts of 20212023 FareToll Increase - 0 $0 $0 $0 ($7) ($9) ($17) (18612) (25573) (26305)
$0000 $0 $0 $0 $275 $322 $609 $661306 $928278 $976801
CASH BALANCE AFTER FARE INCREASES $250569 ($384) ($392) ($838) ($850) ($1234) ($1821) ($1518365) ($1847127) ($2275849)
MTA Initiatives
MTA Efficiencies - Not Yet Implemented - 0 $0 $0 $0 $0 $0 $0 0000 0000 0000
0 - 0 $0 $0 $0 $0 $0 $0 - 0 - 0 - 0
0 - 0 $0 $0 $0 $0 $0 $0 - 0 - 0 - 0
$0000 $0 $0 $0 $0 $0 $0 $0000 $0000 $0000
Policy Actions
CAS Migration to Peoplesoft $0 $0 ($5) ($1) ($0) ($0) (0200) -02 -02 0
Fare Evasion Enforcement Strategy-Expenses $0 ($13) ($12) ($11) ($10) ($10) (9554) -9554483 -9554483 0
Fare Evasion Enforcement-Manhattan DA Forfeiture Fund $0 $11 $11 $10 $9 $0 - 0 0 0 0
Negotiated 1 CBA Reform $0 $0 $0 $0 $0 $0 - 0 0 0 0
MTA Reorganization $0 $8 $180 $371 $377 $377 377000 377 377 0
MTA Reorganization Costs $0 $0 ($10) ($27) ($2) $0 - 0 0 0 0
Drawdown 2019 General Reserve $0 $0 $165 $0 $0 $0 - 0 0 0 0
CBA Negotiated Reform - 1 Value $0 $36 $100 $173 $246 $323 323473 323473304484 323473304484 0
$0000 $0 $42 $429 $515 $620 $691 $690719 $690719 $690719
MTA Re-estimates
Additional Savings Actions $0000 $0 $0 $0 $0 $0 $0 $0000 $0000 $0000
Total Below-the-Line Adjustments $0 $73 $386 $757 $852 $1133 $1007 $1352025 $1618997 $1667520
Prior Year Carryover 495399 263336 138286 161986 301160 235038 444229 329413 479439 121 372 61 55 0 0 - 0 - 0 - 0 - 0
NET CASH BALANCE $263566 $138551 $162276 $301160 $235038 $444229 $329413 $479439 $247525 $372 $61 $55 ($26) ($281) ($433) ($1146) ($499871) ($561698) ($942628)
MTA February Financial Plan 2019-2022
Consolidated Statement Of Operations By Category ($ in millions)
Non-Reimbursable Final Adopted
Actual Actual Actual Actual Actual Actual Actual Actual Actual Actual Estimate Budget
2008 2009 2010 2011 2012 2013 2014 2015 2016 2017 2018 2019 2020 2021 2022 2023 2024 2025 2026
Operating Revenues
Farebox Revenue $4240923 $4350411 $4586377 $4999186 $5079138 $5501274 $5709200 $5961129 $6050182 $6172 $6153 $6122 $6144 $6134 $6144 $6174 $6435176 $6431979 $6446633
422 423 405 411 402 399 395 396 396 407 279 275 272 267 263 261 368 363 362
Student Fare - 0 - 0 - 0 - 0 - 0 - 0
Toll Revenue 1273974 1332115 1417046 1501589 1490982 1645193 1676445 1808901 1869693 1912 1967 1984 1990 1998 1998 2002 2133050 2137871 2143111
0127 0129 0125 0124 0118 0119 0116 0120 0122 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0122 0121 0120
Other Revenue 448616 461359 491355 510231 563839 753675 682424 689217 688374 653 662 705 733 757 743 755 825040 885381 887190
Capital and Other Reimbursements 0000 0000 0000 0000 0000 0000 0000 0000 0000 0000 0000 0000 0000 0000 0000 0000 0000 0000 0000
Total Operating Revenue $5963512 $6143885 $6494778 $7011006 $7133959 $7900142 $8068069 $8459247 $8608249 $8737 $8782 $8810 $8867 $8889 $8886 $8931 $9393266 $9455232 $9476934
Dedicated Taxes $3211585 $2366805 $2343537 $2511691 $2673119 $3097640 $3383498 $3582628 $3525829 $3257508 $3459 $3515 $3568 $3630 $3725 $3812 $3841433 $3880226 $3917215
PMT amp MTA Aid - 0 881784 1588677 1718286 1825824 1825328 1885069 1910947 1970760 1987035 $1965 $2152 $2225 $2295 $2368 $2442 2516095 2594604 2677041
New Funding Sources - 0 - 0 - 0 - 0 - 0 - 0 - 0 - 0 - 0 - 0 $508 $342 $385 $385 $385 $385 385000 385000 385000
StateLocal Taxes 556691 539046 544810 541733 536182 537527 539545 537819 537645 541005 $544 $552 $557 $562 $567 $572 576828 581933 583214
Other Funding Agreements 306594 363823 359489 375369 466625 432617 567391 563616 629855 630218 $701 $753 $671 $708 $758 $758 784755 804901 781159
BampT Operating Surplus Transfer 382565 363092 476059 554903 476575 614210 637553 750717 742909 740144 $702 $721 $782 $801 $789 $707 730476 695303 688833
Dedicated Taxes and StateLocal Subsidies $4457434 $4514550 $5312572 $5701982 $5978325 $6507322 $7013056 $7345727 $7406998 $7155909 $7879 $8035 $8188 $8381 $8592 $8676 $8834588 $8941967 $9032462
$0000 $0000 $0000 $0000 $0000 $0000 $0000 $0000 $0000
Less Interagency Subsidy and Surplus Transfers (382565) (363092) (476059) (554903) (476575) (614210) (637553) (750717) (742909) (740144) ($702) ($721) ($782) ($801) ($789) ($707) (730476) (695303) (688833)
Total Subsidies $4074870 $4151458 $4836513 $5147079 $5501750 $5893111 $6375503 $6595010 $6664088 $6416 $7242 $7238 $7370 $7576 $7807 $7969 $8104112 $8246664 $8343629
Dedicated Taxes as a of Total Revenues + Subs - PMT 320 251 241 241 247 259 269 273 265 247 $0 $0 $0 $0 $0 $0 256 257 259
Total Revenues + Subsidies $10038382 $10295342 $11331292 $12158085 $12635709 $13793254 $14443571 $15054257 $15272337 $15152 $16023 $16048 $16237 $16465 $16693 $16900 $17497378 $17701896 $17820563
Operating Expenses
Labor Expenses
Payroll $4087376 $4163330 $4171374 $4160261 $4193658 $4332829 $4671664 $4695823 $4838741 $5020713 $5211 $5328 $5422 $5498 $5624 $5710 $5860206 $5982960 $6107107
Overtime 471675 499307 443227 538647 574316 620701 730200 755071 771495 934100 $1066 $910 $838 $859 $877 $899 917296 935002 951324
Health amp Welfare 684945 688899 738189 809638 812857 895714 961902 1050100 1172304 1208786 $1230 $1341 $1414 $1489 $1583 $1674 1797938 1922668 2071273
OPEB Current Payment 318501 346316 355716 394218 413164 472619 479079 501716 562233 563754 $604 $645 $704 $766 $835 $910 982025 1060022 1142795
Pensions 897450 1021229 1029710 1074598 1328441 1301975 1304355 1248726 1370474 1345308 $1336 $1494 $1461 $1462 $1403 $1347 1357887 1369071 1380572
Other-Fringe Benefits 502739 517194 539996 581661 650430 694680 784143 861079 947870 792151 $881 $869 $897 $930 $956 $976 1001185 1021007 1040170
Reimbursable Overhead (310555) (322230) (345154) (324006) (309399) (321390) (349770) (380212) (423759) (491807) ($528) ($471) ($430) ($412) ($397) ($395) (396136) (405509) (413165)
Labor Expenses $6652131 $6914045 $6933059 $7235017 $7663467 $7997128 $8581574 $8732302 $9239358 $9373 $9920 $10039 $10436 $10787 $11097 $11413 $11520401 $11885220 $12280075
PayrollOvertime Exp as a of Total Operating+DS $0426 $0427 $0407 $0396 $0387 $0374 $0389 $0383 $0376 $0385 $0349 $0347 $0345
Labor Exp (wo Reimb OH) as a of Total Oper+DS $0650 $0663 $0642 $0637 $0647 $0628 $0643 $0640 $0648 $0638 $0614 $0617 $0620
PayrollOvertime Exp as a of Total Operating Exp $0496 $0490 $0483 $0473 $0465 $0453 $0464 $0459 $0450 $0461 $0426 $0420 $0416
Labor Exp (wo Reimb OH) as a of Total Oper Exp $0758 $0761 $0762 $0761 $0777 $0761 $0768 $0768 $0776 $0763 $0748 $0747 $0747
Non-Labor Expenses
Electric Power $306500 $317934 $325137 $457269 $471514 $493346 $515540 $473762 $406372 $430381 $474918 $451304 $463523 $482662 $539624 $571182 $589565 $618283 $648255
Traction Power
Non-Traction Power
Fuel 287033 180294 189942 282735 251763 259252 267494 162283 124684 150481 185580 190348 187592 183168 181484 182259 182476 184281 186170
Revenue Vehicle Fuel
Non-Revenue Fuel
Insurance 28902 34012 9819 14363 7617 38654 50739 57190 (20634) (2715) 11488 8532 15803 22918 29411 36048 28232 25538 19483
Claims 152114 238104 285418 315547 135652 299875 269167 331023 463959 526053 376480 378570 386981 391333 395228 404397 417667 428660 437683
Paratransit Service Contracts 299013 370094 379761 348553 360500 366751 365599 379271 383704 392850 452190 482751 501230 518038 547829 581114 604766 643217 684112
Maintenance and Other Operating Contracts 594215 562456 541716 451137 451766 496743 549018 579289 630924 695251 779331 897801 833038 883805 871671 879468 880053 898882 915477
Professional Service Contracts 196930 199164 203084 226205 276998 297201 283005 379814 399706 507062 575742 557476 484911 479376 489510 499724 520826 537109 547291
Materials amp Supplies 532534 526191 511206 438310 430804 475127 526725 543225 585607 588115 667700 686666 687745 692131 697268 711988 741335 777460 793419
Other Business Expenses 155466 184142 189637 169857 143807 167198 179701 195598 192576 217254 225494 230595 225293 240279 242193 244907 228861 240258 241690
Non-Labor Expenses $2552708 $2612391 $2635720 $2703976 $2530421 $2894147 $3006988 $3101454 $3166897 3505 3749 3884 3786 3894 3994 4111 $4193782 $4353689 $4473580
Other Expense Adjustments
Other ($13712) ($14750) ($18292) ($2289) $62593 $46175 $44973 $37007 $47404 49 134 158 84 36 22 23 $23516 $24069 $24637
General Reserve 0000 0000 0000 0000 0000 - 0 - 0 - 0 - 0 0 0 165 170 175 180 185 190000 195000 205000
Other Expense Adjustments ($13712) ($14750) ($18292) ($2289) $62593 $46175 $44973 $37007 $47404 $49379 $134 $323 $254 $211 $202 $208 $213516 $219069 $229637
Gap Closing Expenses $7675394
Additional Actions for Budget Balance Expense Impact $0000 $0000 $0000 $0000 $0000 $0000 $0000 $0000 $0000 $0000 $0000 $0000 $0000 $0000 $0000 $0000 $0000 $0000 $0000
Total Operating Expenses Before Non-Cash Liability Adjs $9191127 $9511685 $9550486 $9936705 $10256481 $10937450 $11633535 $11870763 $12453659 $12927116 $13802910 $14246122 $14475644 $14891445 $15293262 $15732241 $15927699 $16457978 $16983292
Non-Cash Liability Adjustments
Depreciation $1790981 $1940576 $1980681 $2019378 $2148820 $2174302 $2266280 $2442777 $2442941 $2607970 $2804571 $2784812 $2842737 $2908533 $2977025 $3051834 $3109882 $3169371 $3230301
OPEB Obligation 1348962 1104827 1167070 1706939 1785881 1920189 2035457 1489656 1562261 1567381 0000 (0000) (0000) (0000) (0000) 0000 0000 (0000) (0000)
GASB 75 OPEB Expense Adjustment 0000 0000 0000 0000 0000 0000 0000 0000 0000 0000 1047747 1457230 1628196 1748560 1823313 1898497 1952374 2006482 2061993
GASB 68 Pension Expense Adjustment 0000 0000 0000 0000 0000 0000 0000 (410019) (218911) (168119) (373022) (220864) (271921) (342847) (318372) (242446) (237864) (234492) (230942)
Environmental Remediation 42249 6062 18621 59079 24742 14257 20556 20576 11691 13468 105615 6000 6000 6000 6000 6000 6000 6000 6000
Non-Cash Liability Adjustments $3182192 $3051466 $3166371 $3785396 $3959443 $4108749 $4322293 $3542990 $3797981 $4020699 $3584911 $4027178 $4205012 $4320246 $4487966 $4713886 $4830392 $4947361 $5067352
Total Operating Expenses After Non-Cash Liability Adjs $12373319 $12563151 $12716857 $13722101 $14215924 $15046199 $15955827 $15413753 $16251641 $16947815 $17387821 $18273301 $18680657 $19211690 $19781228 $20446127 $20758090 $21405338 $22050644
Less BampT Depreciation $77213 $80097 $77846 $86545 $87926 $91345 $104039 $109783 $135035 $240957 $148686 $151977 $158779 $169848 $181689 $194355 $194355 $194355 $194355
BampT Other Post Employment Benefits 66323 50967 54831 66686 73055 76641 71148 62457 60441 78106 32297 22256 20303 22870 28694 33918 36169 38411 40604
Net Operating Deficit Before Subsidies and Debt Service ($6409807) ($6419266) ($6222079) ($6711095) ($7081966) ($7146057) ($7887759) ($6954506) ($7643392) ($8211234) ($8606220) ($9463506) ($9813560) ($10322912) ($10895644) ($11515498) ($11364824) ($11950106) ($12573710)
Conversion to Cash Basis Non-Cash Liability Adjs ($3182192) ($3051466) ($3166371) ($3785396) ($3959443) ($4108749) ($4322293) ($3542990) ($3797981) ($4020699) ($3584911) ($4027178) ($4205012) ($4320246) ($4487966) ($4713886) ($4830392) ($4947361) ($5067352)
Total Operating Expenses $9191127 $9511685 $9550486 $9936705 $10256481 $10937450 $11633535 $11870763 $12453659 $12927 $13803 $14246 $14476 $14891 $15293 $15732 $15927699 $16457978 $16983292
Debt Service Expenses $1515733 $1404454 $1781220 $1933532 $2058395 $2299262 $2248538 $2373321 $2458783 $2525 $2559 $2692 $2840 $3080 $3223 $3450 $3471321 $3472987 $3501639
Total Expenses + Debt Service $10706859 $10916139 $11331706 $11870237 $12314876 $13236712 $13882073 $14244084 $14912443 $15452 $16362 $16938 $17316 $17971 $18516 $19182 $19399019 $19930965 $20484932
Net Deficit After Subsidies and Debt Service ($668477) ($620796) ($0414) $287848 $320833 $556541 $561498 $810173 $359895 ($299965) ($339) ($890) ($1079) ($1506) ($1823) ($2283) ($1901641) ($2229069) ($2664369)
Conversion to Cash Basis GASB Account (56067) (54256) (67377) (37636) (89548) (85641) (50017) - 0 - 0 0 0 0 $0 0 0 - 0 - 0 - 0 - 0
Conversion to Cash Basis 492710 550267 91781 (111037) (297407) (261709) (626297) (660147) (591809) 174 296 363 188 (17) 88 130 49745 48375 54220
Net Cash Balance from Previous Year 0000 0000 0000 23990 139174 0000 209191 0000 150026 0000 0000 0000 0000 0000 0000 0000 0000 0000 0000
Total Operating Exp + DS + Cash Conversions + PY C-O $11144 $11412 $11356 $11746 $12067 $12889362 $13414950 $13583937 $14470659 $15625875 $16658585 $17300293 $17504155 $17954574 $18604130 $19312017 $19448764 $19979340 $20539152
Total Operating Expenses with Cash Conversion $10270216 $10420127 $11307302 $12018911 $12701831 $13584063 $14558387 $14904231 $15504252 $15278749 $16065734 $16575223 $17128079 $17987951 $18427778 $19052755 $19349274 $19882590 $20430711
Baseline Net Cash Balance Before B-T-L Adjustments ($231834) ($124785) $23990 $139174 ($66122) $209191 ($114816) $150026 ($231914) ($126) ($43) ($527) ($891) ($1523) ($1735) ($2153) ($1851896) ($2180695) ($2610148)
Below-the-Line Adjustments
FareToll Increases
FareToll Increase in March 2019 (4 Yield) - 0 $0 $0 $0 $0 $0 $0 - 0 - 0 - 0
FareToll Increase in March 2021 (4 Yield) - 0 $0 $0 $0 $283 $331 $332 333531 333568 334299
FareToll Increase in March 2023 (4 Yield) - 0 $0 $0 $0 $0 $0 $294 346386 346424 347183
FareToll Increase in March 2025 (4 Yield) - 0 $0 $0 $0 $0 $0 $0 - 0 273859 321624
Subsidy Impacts of 20212023 FareToll Increase - 0 $0 $0 $0 ($7) ($9) ($17) (18612) (25573) (26305)
$0000 $0 $0 $0 $275 $322 $609 $661306 $928278 $976801
CASH BALANCE AFTER FARE INCREASES ($126402) ($43) ($527) ($891) ($1241) ($1404) ($1821) ($1518365) ($1847127) ($2275849)
MTA Initiatives
MTA Efficiencies - Not Yet Implemented - 0 $0 $0 $0 $0 $0 $0 0000 0000 0000
0 - 0 $0 $0 $0 $0 $0 $0 - 0 - 0 - 0
0 - 0 $0 $0 $0 $0 $0 $0 - 0 - 0 - 0
$0000 $0 $0 $0 $0 $0 $0 $0000 $0000 $0000
Policy Actions
CAS Migration to Peoplesoft $0 $0 ($5) ($1) ($0) ($0) (0200) -02 -02 0
Fare Evasion Enforcement Strategy-Expenses $0 ($13) ($12) ($11) ($10) ($10) (9554) -9554483 -9554483 0
Fare Evasion Enforcement-Manhattan DA Forfeiture Fund $0 $11 $11 $10 $9 $0 - 0 0 0 0
Negotiated 1 CBA Reform $0 $0 $0 $0 $0 $0 - 0 0 0 0
MTA Reorganization $0 $8 $180 $371 $377 $377 377000 377 377 0
MTA Reorganization Costs $0 $0 ($10) ($27) ($2) $0 - 0 0 0 0
Drawdown 2019 General Reserve $0 $0 $165 $0 $0 $0 - 0 0 0 0
CBA Negotiated Reform - 1 Value $0 $36 $100 $173 $246 $323 323473 323473304484 323473304484 0
$0000 $0 $42 $429 $515 $620 $691 $690719 $690719 $690719
MTA Re-estimates
Additional Savings Actions $0000 $0 $0 $0 $0 $0 $0 $0000 $0000 $0000
Total Below-the-Line Adjustments $0 $0 $459 $413 $709 $760 $1007 $1352025 $1618997 $1667520
Prior Year Carryover 495399 263336 138286 161986 301160 235038 444229 329413 479439 248 121 79 11 0 0 - 0 - 0 - 0 - 0
NET CASH BALANCE $263566 $138551 $162276 $301160 $235038 $444229 $329413 $479439 $247525 $121 $79 $11 ($467) ($814) ($976) ($1146) ($499871) ($561698) ($942628)
By Revenue Source
(includes faretoll increases)
($ in millions)
Farebox Revenue $6389
Toll Revenue 2121
Other Revenue 684
Dedicated Taxes 6191
State and Local amp Other 1228
Timing (Cash Adjustments) 135
Total $16748
By Expense Category
(includes below-the-line adjustments)
($ in millions)
Payroll $5422
Overtime 838
Health amp Welfare 2118
Pension 1461
Other Labor 466
Total Labor $10306
Non-Labor + Other Exp Adj 4004
Debt Service 2830
BTL Adjustments for Expenses 2 (386)
Total $16754
By Revenue Source
(includes faretoll increases)
($ in millions)
Farebox Revenue $6389
Toll Revenue 2121
Other Revenue 684
Taxes 6178
State and Local amp Other 557
Other Funding Agreements 671
Other 1 208
Total $16809
By Expense Category
(includes below-the-line adjustments)
($ in millions)
Payroll $5392
Overtime 811
Health amp Welfare 2129
Pension 1354
Other Labor 400
Total Labor $10086
Non-Labor 4205
Debt Service 2692
BTL Adjustments for Expenses (251)
Total $16732
Page 12: MTA 2020 Preliminary Budget July Financial Plan 2020 - 2023 2020 Preliminar… · 1 The MTA Budget Process July Plan – Start of the Annual Process • Current year is revised (the

We have a track record of identifying and achieving our annual recurring savings targets

11

($ in millions)

$0

$500

$1000

$1500

$2000

$2500

$3000

Achieved Savings

2012 November Plan

2013 November Plan

2014 November Plan

2015 November Plan

2016 November Plan

2017 November Plan

2018 November Plan

2019 July Plan

$28 billion

Proposed July Plan

Deficits remain and a continued drive toward further streamlining and efficiencies is required

12

($ in millions)

61 55

(26)

(281)

(433)

($600)

($500)

($400)

($300)

($200)

($100)

$0

$100

$200

2019 2020 2021 2022 2023

This Year Next Year Out-Years

Proposed July PlanDonrsquot achieve Transformation Plan Savings

13

If the MTA Transformation Plan is not adopted and implemented the deficits will be unmanageable without service cuts significant

reductions in force andor additional fare and toll increases($ in millions)

($1100)

($900)

($700)

($500)

($300)

($100)

$100

2019 2020 2021 2022 2023

(816)

(971)

(569)

(81)

(433)

(281)

61 55 (26)

(281) (186)

50

Next Year Out-Years

(230)(11)

(488)

(538)

(535)

This Year

14

2020 Preliminary BudgetWhere the Dollars Come Fromhellip Where the Dollars Gohellip

Farebox Revenue $6389Toll Revenue 2121 Other Revenue 684 Taxes 6178 State and Local amp Other 557 Other Funding Agreements 671 Other 1 208 Total $16809

($ in millions)

By Revenue Source(includes faretoll increases)

Payroll $5422Overtime 838 Health amp Welfare 2118 Pension 1461 Other Labor 466 Total Labor $10306Non-Labor + Other Exp Adj 4004 Debt Service 2830 BTL Adjustments for Expenses 2 (386) Total $16754

By Expense Category

($ in millions)(includes below-the-line adjustments)

1 Includes cash adjustments and prior-year carryover

Farebox Revenue

38

Toll Revenue

13

Other Revenue4

Taxes37

State amp Local

Subsidies3

Other Funding Agreements

4 Other 1

Payroll32

Overtime5

Health ampWelfare

13Pension

9

Other Labor3

Non-Labor + Other Exp Adj

21

Debt Service17

2 The below-the-line adjustments are grouped in the Non-Labor category

Sheet1

Sheet1

15

Non-Reimbursable Mid-Year Preliminary Actual Forecast Budget

2018 2019 2020 2021 2022 2023 Operating Revenues

Farebox Revenue $6155 $6305 $6389 $6373 $6384 $6393Toll Revenue 1976 2088 2121 2129 2129 2131 Other Revenue 643 696 684 704 719 737

Total Operating Revenue $8774 $9089 $9195 $9206 $9232 $9260

Total Subsidies $7177 $7314 $7406 $7581 $7803 $7969Dedicated Taxes as a of Total Revenues + Subs - PMT 233 $0 $0 $0 $0 $0

Total Revenues + Subsidies $15951 $16403 $16601 $16787 $17035 $17229

Operating ExpensesLabor Expenses $9799 $10116 $10306 $10592 $10881 $11121Non-Labor Expenses 3611 3877 3748 3841 3945 4054 Other 129 175 86 36 22 23 General Reserve 0 165 170 175 180 185

Total Operating Expenses $13539 $14333 $14310 $14644 $15028 $15384

Debt Service Expenses $2541 $2683 $2830 $3041 $3265 $3513

Total Expenses + Debt Service $16079 $17016 $17140 $17685 $18293 $18896

Conversion to Cash Basis 379 229 147 60 125 101

Baseline Net Cash Balance Before B-T-L Adjustments $251 ($384) ($392) ($838) ($1133) ($1566)

Total Below-the-Line Adjustments $0 $73 $386 $757 $852 $1133Prior Year Carryover 121 372 61 55 0 0

NET CASH BALANCE $372 $61 $55 ($26) ($281) ($433)

MTA July Financial Plan 2020-2023Consolidated Statement Of Operations By Category ($ in millions)

Summ Stmt of Ops-Feb

Summ Stmt of Ops-Jul

  • MTA 2020Preliminary BudgetJuly Financial Plan2020 - 2023
  • The MTA Budget Process
  • Slide Number 3
  • Slide Number 4
  • What has changed since the February Plan
  • Highlights of the July Plan
  • Slide Number 7
  • MTA Transformation Plan
  • Slide Number 9
  • Actions to Reduce Fare Evasion $62 million Investment over the Plan Period
  • The MTArsquos $350 million target for annually recurring savings beginning in 2020 has been identified and is being implemented
  • We have a track record of identifying and achieving our annual recurring savings targets
  • Deficits remain and a continued drive toward further streamlining and efficiencies is required
  • Slide Number 14
  • 2020 Preliminary Budget
  • Slide Number 16
MTA July Financial Plan 2020-2023
Consolidated Statement Of Operations By Category ($ in millions)
Non-Reimbursable Mid-Year Preliminary
Actual Actual Actual Actual Actual Actual Actual Actual Actual Actual Forecast Budget
2008 2009 2010 2011 2012 2013 2014 2015 2016 2018 2019 2020 2021 2022 2023 2023 2024 2025 2026
Operating Revenues
Farebox Revenue $4240923 $4350411 $4586377 $4999186 $5079138 $5501274 $5709200 $5961129 $6050182 $6155 $6305 $6389 $6373 $6384 $6393 $6174 $6435176 $6431979 $6446633
422 423 405 411 402 399 395 396 396 386 384 385 380 375 371 261 368 363 362
Student Fare - 0 - 0 - 0 - 0 - 0 - 0
Toll Revenue 1273974 1332115 1417046 1501589 1490982 1645193 1676445 1808901 1869693 1976 2088 2121 2129 2129 2131 2002 2133050 2137871 2143111
0127 0129 0125 0124 0118 0119 0116 0120 0122 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0122 0121 0120
Other Revenue 448616 461359 491355 510231 563839 753675 682424 689217 688374 643 696 684 704 719 737 755 825040 885381 887190
Capital and Other Reimbursements 0000 0000 0000 0000 0000 0000 0000 0000 0000 0000 0000 0000 0000 0000 0000 0000 0000 0000 0000
Total Operating Revenue $5963512 $6143885 $6494778 $7011006 $7133959 $7900142 $8068069 $8459247 $8608249 $8774 $9089 $9195 $9206 $9232 $9260 $8931 $9393266 $9455232 $9476934
Dedicated Taxes $3211585 $2366805 $2343537 $2511691 $2673119 $3097640 $3383498 $3582628 $3525829 $3257508 $3459 $3515 $3568 $3630 $3725 $3812 $3841433 $3880226 $3917215
PMT amp MTA Aid - 0 881784 1588677 1718286 1825824 1825328 1885069 1910947 1970760 1987035 $1965 $2152 $2225 $2295 $2368 $2442 2516095 2594604 2677041
New Funding Sources - 0 - 0 - 0 - 0 - 0 - 0 - 0 - 0 - 0 - 0 $508 $342 $385 $385 $385 $385 385000 385000 385000
StateLocal Taxes 556691 539046 544810 541733 536182 537527 539545 537819 537645 541005 $544 $552 $557 $562 $567 $572 576828 581933 583214
Other Funding Agreements 306594 363823 359489 375369 466625 432617 567391 563616 629855 630218 $701 $753 $671 $708 $758 $758 784755 804901 781159
BampT Operating Surplus Transfer 382565 363092 476059 554903 476575 614210 637553 750717 742909 740144 $702 $721 $782 $801 $789 $707 730476 695303 688833
Dedicated Taxes and StateLocal Subsidies $4457434 $4514550 $5312572 $5701982 $5978325 $6507322 $7013056 $7345727 $7406998 $7155909 $7879 $8035 $8188 $8381 $8592 $8676 $8834588 $8941967 $9032462
$0000 $0000 $0000 $0000 $0000 $0000 $0000 $0000 $0000
Less Interagency Subsidy and Surplus Transfers (382565) (363092) (476059) (554903) (476575) (614210) (637553) (750717) (742909) (740144) ($702) ($721) ($782) ($801) ($789) ($707) (730476) (695303) (688833)
Total Subsidies $4074870 $4151458 $4836513 $5147079 $5501750 $5893111 $6375503 $6595010 $6664088 $7177 $7314 $7406 $7581 $7803 $7969 $7969 $8104112 $8246664 $8343629
Dedicated Taxes as a of Total Revenues + Subs - PMT 320 251 241 241 247 259 269 273 265 233 $0 $0 $0 $0 $0 $0 256 257 259
Total Revenues + Subsidies $10038382 $10295342 $11331292 $12158085 $12635709 $13793254 $14443571 $15054257 $15272337 $15951 $16403 $16601 $16787 $17035 $17229 $16900 $17497378 $17701896 $17820563
Operating Expenses
Labor Expenses
Payroll $4087376 $4163330 $4171374 $4160261 $4193658 $4332829 $4671664 $4695823 $4838741 $5020713 $5211 $5328 $5422 $5498 $5624 $5710 $5860206 $5982960 $6107107
Overtime 471675 499307 443227 538647 574316 620701 730200 755071 771495 934100 $1066 $910 $838 $859 $877 $899 917296 935002 951324
Health amp Welfare 684945 688899 738189 809638 812857 895714 961902 1050100 1172304 1208786 $1230 $1341 $1414 $1489 $1583 $1674 1797938 1922668 2071273
OPEB Current Payment 318501 346316 355716 394218 413164 472619 479079 501716 562233 563754 $604 $645 $704 $766 $835 $910 982025 1060022 1142795
Pensions 897450 1021229 1029710 1074598 1328441 1301975 1304355 1248726 1370474 1345308 $1336 $1494 $1461 $1462 $1403 $1347 1357887 1369071 1380572
Other-Fringe Benefits 502739 517194 539996 581661 650430 694680 784143 861079 947870 792151 $881 $869 $897 $930 $956 $976 1001185 1021007 1040170
Reimbursable Overhead (310555) (322230) (345154) (324006) (309399) (321390) (349770) (380212) (423759) (491807) ($528) ($471) ($430) ($412) ($397) ($395) (396136) (405509) (413165)
Labor Expenses $6652131 $6914045 $6933059 $7235017 $7663467 $7997128 $8581574 $8732302 $9239358 $9799 $10116 $10306 $10592 $10881 $11121 $11413 $11520401 $11885220 $12280075
PayrollOvertime Exp as a of Total Operating+DS $0426 $0427 $0407 $0396 $0387 $0374 $0389 $0383 $0376 $0390 $0367 $0365 $0359 $0355 $0350 $0349 $0347 $0345
Labor Exp (wo Reimb OH) as a of Total Oper+DS $0650 $0663 $0642 $0637 $0647 $0628 $0643 $0640 $0648 $0642 $0622 $0626 $0622 $0616 $0609 $0614 $0617 $0620
PayrollOvertime Exp as a of Total Operating Exp $0496 $0490 $0483 $0473 $0465 $0453 $0464 $0459 $0450 $0464 $0435 $0438 $0434 $0433 $0430 $0426 $0420 $0416
Labor Exp (wo Reimb OH) as a of Total Oper Exp $0758 $0761 $0762 $0761 $0777 $0761 $0768 $0768 $0776 $0763 $0739 $0750 $0751 $0750 $0749 $0748 $0747 $0747
Non-Labor Expenses
Electric Power $306500 $317934 $325137 $457269 $471514 $493346 $515540 $473762 $406372 $481893 $451503 $473177 $493090 $532413 $561955 $571182 $589565 $618283 $648255
Traction Power
Non-Traction Power
Fuel 287033 180294 189942 282735 251763 259252 267494 162283 124684 185203 182778 182981 176333 173681 176920 182259 182476 184281 186170
Revenue Vehicle Fuel
Non-Revenue Fuel
Insurance 28902 34012 9819 14363 7617 38654 50739 57190 (20634) (29402) 5608 15623 23118 26855 28309 36048 28232 25538 19483
Claims 152114 238104 285418 315547 135652 299875 269167 331023 463959 437985 387557 394211 392547 398256 406112 404397 417667 428660 437683
Paratransit Service Contracts 299013 370094 379761 348553 360500 366751 365599 379271 383704 455471 494751 488330 505538 535329 568614 581114 604766 643217 684112
Maintenance and Other Operating Contracts 594215 562456 541716 451137 451766 496743 549018 579289 630924 678425 840168 797428 833534 836606 854471 879468 880053 898882 915477
Professional Service Contracts 196930 199164 203084 226205 276998 297201 283005 379814 399706 543582 607838 502858 494814 504103 513895 499724 520826 537109 547291
Materials amp Supplies 532534 526191 511206 438310 430804 475127 526725 543225 585607 637078 689010 679895 697976 711281 715758 711988 741335 777460 793419
Other Business Expenses 155466 184142 189637 169857 143807 167198 179701 195598 192576 220838 218196 213551 224459 226170 228457 244907 228861 240258 241690
Non-Labor Expenses $2552708 $2612391 $2635720 $2703976 $2530421 $2894147 $3006988 $3101454 $3166897 3611 3877 3748 3841 3945 4054 4111 $4193782 $4353689 $4473580
Other Expense Adjustments
Other ($13712) ($14750) ($18292) ($2289) $62593 $46175 $44973 $37007 $47404 129 175 86 36 22 23 23 $23516 $24069 $24637
General Reserve 0000 0000 0000 0000 0000 - 0 - 0 - 0 - 0 0 165 170 175 180 185 185 190000 195000 205000
Other Expense Adjustments ($13712) ($14750) ($18292) ($2289) $62593 $46175 $44973 $37007 $47404 $128555 $340 $256 $211 $202 $208 $208 $213516 $219069 $229637
Gap Closing Expenses $7675394
Additional Actions for Budget Balance Expense Impact $0000 $0000 $0000 $0000 $0000 $0000 $0000 $0000 $0000 $0000 $0000 $0000 $0000 $0000 $0000 $0000 $0000 $0000 $0000
Total Operating Expenses Before Non-Cash Liability Adjs $9191127 $9511685 $9550486 $9936705 $10256481 $10937450 $11633535 $11870763 $12453659 $13538830 $14332772 $14309678 $14643965 $15027767 $15383584 $15732241 $15927699 $16457978 $16983292
Non-Cash Liability Adjustments
Depreciation $1790981 $1940576 $1980681 $2019378 $2148820 $2174302 $2266280 $2442777 $2442941 $2607970 $2804571 $2784812 $2842737 $2908533 $2977025 $3051834 $3109882 $3169371 $3230301
OPEB Obligation 1348962 1104827 1167070 1706939 1785881 1920189 2035457 1489656 1562261 1567381 0000 (0000) (0000) (0000) (0000) 0000 0000 (0000) (0000)
GASB 75 OPEB Expense Adjustment 0000 0000 0000 0000 0000 0000 0000 0000 0000 0000 1047747 1457230 1628196 1748560 1823313 1898497 1952374 2006482 2061993
GASB 68 Pension Expense Adjustment 0000 0000 0000 0000 0000 0000 0000 (410019) (218911) (168119) (373022) (220864) (271921) (342847) (318372) (242446) (237864) (234492) (230942)
Environmental Remediation 42249 6062 18621 59079 24742 14257 20556 20576 11691 13468 105615 6000 6000 6000 6000 6000 6000 6000 6000
Non-Cash Liability Adjustments $3182192 $3051466 $3166371 $3785396 $3959443 $4108749 $4322293 $3542990 $3797981 $4020699 $3584911 $4027178 $4205012 $4320246 $4487966 $4713886 $4830392 $4947361 $5067352
Total Operating Expenses After Non-Cash Liability Adjs $12373319 $12563151 $12716857 $13722101 $14215924 $15046199 $15955827 $15413753 $16251641 $17559529 $17917683 $18336856 $18848977 $19348013 $19871550 $20446127 $20758090 $21405338 $22050644
Less BampT Depreciation $77213 $80097 $77846 $86545 $87926 $91345 $104039 $109783 $135035 $240957 $148686 $151977 $158779 $169848 $181689 $194355 $194355 $194355 $194355
BampT Other Post Employment Benefits 66323 50967 54831 66686 73055 76641 71148 62457 60441 78106 32297 22256 20303 22870 28694 33918 36169 38411 40604
Net Operating Deficit Before Subsidies and Debt Service ($6409807) ($6419266) ($6222079) ($6711095) ($7081966) ($7146057) ($7887759) ($6954506) ($7643392) ($8785339) ($8829030) ($9141907) ($9642826) ($10116260) ($10611154) ($11515498) ($11364824) ($11950106) ($12573710)
Conversion to Cash Basis Non-Cash Liability Adjs ($3182192) ($3051466) ($3166371) ($3785396) ($3959443) ($4108749) ($4322293) ($3542990) ($3797981) ($4020699) ($3584911) ($4027178) ($4205012) ($4320246) ($4487966) ($4713886) ($4830392) ($4947361) ($5067352)
Total Operating Expenses $9191127 $9511685 $9550486 $9936705 $10256481 $10937450 $11633535 $11870763 $12453659 $13539 $14333 $14310 $14644 $15028 $15384 $15732 $15927699 $16457978 $16983292
Debt Service Expenses $1515733 $1404454 $1781220 $1933532 $2058395 $2299262 $2248538 $2373321 $2458783 $2541 $2683 $2830 $3041 $3265 $3513 $3450 $3471321 $3472987 $3501639
Total Expenses + Debt Service $10706859 $10916139 $11331706 $11870237 $12314876 $13236712 $13882073 $14244084 $14912443 $16079 $17016 $17140 $17685 $18293 $18896 $19182 $19399019 $19930965 $20484932
Net Deficit After Subsidies and Debt Service ($668477) ($620796) ($0414) $287848 $320833 $556541 $561498 $810173 $359895 ($128044) ($613) ($539) ($898) ($1258) ($1667) ($2283) ($1901641) ($2229069) ($2664369)
Conversion to Cash Basis GASB Account (56067) (54256) (67377) (37636) (89548) (85641) (50017) - 0 - 0 0 0 0 $0 0 0 - 0 - 0 - 0 - 0
Conversion to Cash Basis 492710 550267 91781 (111037) (297407) (261709) (626297) (660147) (591809) 379 229 147 60 125 101 130 49745 48375 54220
Net Cash Balance from Previous Year 0000 0000 0000 23990 139174 0000 209191 0000 150026 0000 250569 0000 0000 0000 0000 0000 0000 0000 0000
Total Operating Exp + DS + Cash Conversions + PY C-O $11144 $11412 $11356 $11746 $12067 $12889362 $13414950 $13583937 $14470659 $16457999 $17495351 $17286526 $17744425 $18418197 $18997710 $19312017 $19448764 $19979340 $20539152
Total Operating Expenses with Cash Conversion $10270216 $10420127 $11307302 $12018911 $12701831 $13584063 $14558387 $14904231 $15504252 $15700774 $16786574 $16992579 $17624861 $18167420 $18795069 $19052755 $19349274 $19882590 $20430711
Baseline Net Cash Balance Before B-T-L Adjustments ($231834) ($124785) $23990 $139174 ($66122) $209191 ($114816) $150026 ($231914) $251 ($384) ($392) ($838) ($1133) ($1566) ($2153) ($1851896) ($2180695) ($2610148)
Below-the-Line Adjustments
FareToll Increases
FareToll Increase in March 2019 (4 Yield) - 0 $0 $0 $0 $0 $0 $0 - 0 - 0 - 0
FareToll Increase in March 2021 (4 Yield) - 0 $0 $0 $0 $283 $331 $332 333531 333568 334299
FareToll Increase in March 2023 (4 Yield) - 0 $0 $0 $0 $0 $0 $294 346386 346424 347183
FareToll Increase in March 2025 (4 Yield) - 0 $0 $0 $0 $0 $0 $0 - 0 273859 321624
Subsidy Impacts of 20212023 FareToll Increase - 0 $0 $0 $0 ($7) ($9) ($17) (18612) (25573) (26305)
$0000 $0 $0 $0 $275 $322 $609 $661306 $928278 $976801
CASH BALANCE AFTER FARE INCREASES $250569 ($384) ($392) ($838) ($850) ($1234) ($1821) ($1518365) ($1847127) ($2275849)
MTA Initiatives
MTA Efficiencies - Not Yet Implemented - 0 $0 $0 $0 $0 $0 $0 0000 0000 0000
0 - 0 $0 $0 $0 $0 $0 $0 - 0 - 0 - 0
0 - 0 $0 $0 $0 $0 $0 $0 - 0 - 0 - 0
$0000 $0 $0 $0 $0 $0 $0 $0000 $0000 $0000
Policy Actions
CAS Migration to Peoplesoft $0 $0 ($5) ($1) ($0) ($0) (0200) -02 -02 0
Fare Evasion Enforcement Strategy-Expenses $0 ($13) ($12) ($11) ($10) ($10) (9554) -9554483 -9554483 0
Fare Evasion Enforcement-Manhattan DA Forfeiture Fund $0 $11 $11 $10 $9 $0 - 0 0 0 0
Negotiated 1 CBA Reform $0 $0 $0 $0 $0 $0 - 0 0 0 0
MTA Reorganization $0 $8 $180 $371 $377 $377 377000 377 377 0
MTA Reorganization Costs $0 $0 ($10) ($27) ($2) $0 - 0 0 0 0
Drawdown 2019 General Reserve $0 $0 $165 $0 $0 $0 - 0 0 0 0
CBA Negotiated Reform - 1 Value $0 $36 $100 $173 $246 $323 323473 323473304484 323473304484 0
$0000 $0 $42 $429 $515 $620 $691 $690719 $690719 $690719
MTA Re-estimates
Additional Savings Actions $0000 $0 $0 $0 $0 $0 $0 $0000 $0000 $0000
Total Below-the-Line Adjustments $0 $73 $386 $757 $852 $1133 $1007 $1352025 $1618997 $1667520
Prior Year Carryover 495399 263336 138286 161986 301160 235038 444229 329413 479439 121 372 61 55 0 0 - 0 - 0 - 0 - 0
NET CASH BALANCE $263566 $138551 $162276 $301160 $235038 $444229 $329413 $479439 $247525 $372 $61 $55 ($26) ($281) ($433) ($1146) ($499871) ($561698) ($942628)
MTA February Financial Plan 2019-2022
Consolidated Statement Of Operations By Category ($ in millions)
Non-Reimbursable Final Adopted
Actual Actual Actual Actual Actual Actual Actual Actual Actual Actual Estimate Budget
2008 2009 2010 2011 2012 2013 2014 2015 2016 2017 2018 2019 2020 2021 2022 2023 2024 2025 2026
Operating Revenues
Farebox Revenue $4240923 $4350411 $4586377 $4999186 $5079138 $5501274 $5709200 $5961129 $6050182 $6172 $6153 $6122 $6144 $6134 $6144 $6174 $6435176 $6431979 $6446633
422 423 405 411 402 399 395 396 396 407 279 275 272 267 263 261 368 363 362
Student Fare - 0 - 0 - 0 - 0 - 0 - 0
Toll Revenue 1273974 1332115 1417046 1501589 1490982 1645193 1676445 1808901 1869693 1912 1967 1984 1990 1998 1998 2002 2133050 2137871 2143111
0127 0129 0125 0124 0118 0119 0116 0120 0122 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0122 0121 0120
Other Revenue 448616 461359 491355 510231 563839 753675 682424 689217 688374 653 662 705 733 757 743 755 825040 885381 887190
Capital and Other Reimbursements 0000 0000 0000 0000 0000 0000 0000 0000 0000 0000 0000 0000 0000 0000 0000 0000 0000 0000 0000
Total Operating Revenue $5963512 $6143885 $6494778 $7011006 $7133959 $7900142 $8068069 $8459247 $8608249 $8737 $8782 $8810 $8867 $8889 $8886 $8931 $9393266 $9455232 $9476934
Dedicated Taxes $3211585 $2366805 $2343537 $2511691 $2673119 $3097640 $3383498 $3582628 $3525829 $3257508 $3459 $3515 $3568 $3630 $3725 $3812 $3841433 $3880226 $3917215
PMT amp MTA Aid - 0 881784 1588677 1718286 1825824 1825328 1885069 1910947 1970760 1987035 $1965 $2152 $2225 $2295 $2368 $2442 2516095 2594604 2677041
New Funding Sources - 0 - 0 - 0 - 0 - 0 - 0 - 0 - 0 - 0 - 0 $508 $342 $385 $385 $385 $385 385000 385000 385000
StateLocal Taxes 556691 539046 544810 541733 536182 537527 539545 537819 537645 541005 $544 $552 $557 $562 $567 $572 576828 581933 583214
Other Funding Agreements 306594 363823 359489 375369 466625 432617 567391 563616 629855 630218 $701 $753 $671 $708 $758 $758 784755 804901 781159
BampT Operating Surplus Transfer 382565 363092 476059 554903 476575 614210 637553 750717 742909 740144 $702 $721 $782 $801 $789 $707 730476 695303 688833
Dedicated Taxes and StateLocal Subsidies $4457434 $4514550 $5312572 $5701982 $5978325 $6507322 $7013056 $7345727 $7406998 $7155909 $7879 $8035 $8188 $8381 $8592 $8676 $8834588 $8941967 $9032462
$0000 $0000 $0000 $0000 $0000 $0000 $0000 $0000 $0000
Less Interagency Subsidy and Surplus Transfers (382565) (363092) (476059) (554903) (476575) (614210) (637553) (750717) (742909) (740144) ($702) ($721) ($782) ($801) ($789) ($707) (730476) (695303) (688833)
Total Subsidies $4074870 $4151458 $4836513 $5147079 $5501750 $5893111 $6375503 $6595010 $6664088 $6416 $7242 $7238 $7370 $7576 $7807 $7969 $8104112 $8246664 $8343629
Dedicated Taxes as a of Total Revenues + Subs - PMT 320 251 241 241 247 259 269 273 265 247 $0 $0 $0 $0 $0 $0 256 257 259
Total Revenues + Subsidies $10038382 $10295342 $11331292 $12158085 $12635709 $13793254 $14443571 $15054257 $15272337 $15152 $16023 $16048 $16237 $16465 $16693 $16900 $17497378 $17701896 $17820563
Operating Expenses
Labor Expenses
Payroll $4087376 $4163330 $4171374 $4160261 $4193658 $4332829 $4671664 $4695823 $4838741 $5020713 $5211 $5328 $5422 $5498 $5624 $5710 $5860206 $5982960 $6107107
Overtime 471675 499307 443227 538647 574316 620701 730200 755071 771495 934100 $1066 $910 $838 $859 $877 $899 917296 935002 951324
Health amp Welfare 684945 688899 738189 809638 812857 895714 961902 1050100 1172304 1208786 $1230 $1341 $1414 $1489 $1583 $1674 1797938 1922668 2071273
OPEB Current Payment 318501 346316 355716 394218 413164 472619 479079 501716 562233 563754 $604 $645 $704 $766 $835 $910 982025 1060022 1142795
Pensions 897450 1021229 1029710 1074598 1328441 1301975 1304355 1248726 1370474 1345308 $1336 $1494 $1461 $1462 $1403 $1347 1357887 1369071 1380572
Other-Fringe Benefits 502739 517194 539996 581661 650430 694680 784143 861079 947870 792151 $881 $869 $897 $930 $956 $976 1001185 1021007 1040170
Reimbursable Overhead (310555) (322230) (345154) (324006) (309399) (321390) (349770) (380212) (423759) (491807) ($528) ($471) ($430) ($412) ($397) ($395) (396136) (405509) (413165)
Labor Expenses $6652131 $6914045 $6933059 $7235017 $7663467 $7997128 $8581574 $8732302 $9239358 $9373 $9920 $10039 $10436 $10787 $11097 $11413 $11520401 $11885220 $12280075
PayrollOvertime Exp as a of Total Operating+DS $0426 $0427 $0407 $0396 $0387 $0374 $0389 $0383 $0376 $0385 $0349 $0347 $0345
Labor Exp (wo Reimb OH) as a of Total Oper+DS $0650 $0663 $0642 $0637 $0647 $0628 $0643 $0640 $0648 $0638 $0614 $0617 $0620
PayrollOvertime Exp as a of Total Operating Exp $0496 $0490 $0483 $0473 $0465 $0453 $0464 $0459 $0450 $0461 $0426 $0420 $0416
Labor Exp (wo Reimb OH) as a of Total Oper Exp $0758 $0761 $0762 $0761 $0777 $0761 $0768 $0768 $0776 $0763 $0748 $0747 $0747
Non-Labor Expenses
Electric Power $306500 $317934 $325137 $457269 $471514 $493346 $515540 $473762 $406372 $430381 $474918 $451304 $463523 $482662 $539624 $571182 $589565 $618283 $648255
Traction Power
Non-Traction Power
Fuel 287033 180294 189942 282735 251763 259252 267494 162283 124684 150481 185580 190348 187592 183168 181484 182259 182476 184281 186170
Revenue Vehicle Fuel
Non-Revenue Fuel
Insurance 28902 34012 9819 14363 7617 38654 50739 57190 (20634) (2715) 11488 8532 15803 22918 29411 36048 28232 25538 19483
Claims 152114 238104 285418 315547 135652 299875 269167 331023 463959 526053 376480 378570 386981 391333 395228 404397 417667 428660 437683
Paratransit Service Contracts 299013 370094 379761 348553 360500 366751 365599 379271 383704 392850 452190 482751 501230 518038 547829 581114 604766 643217 684112
Maintenance and Other Operating Contracts 594215 562456 541716 451137 451766 496743 549018 579289 630924 695251 779331 897801 833038 883805 871671 879468 880053 898882 915477
Professional Service Contracts 196930 199164 203084 226205 276998 297201 283005 379814 399706 507062 575742 557476 484911 479376 489510 499724 520826 537109 547291
Materials amp Supplies 532534 526191 511206 438310 430804 475127 526725 543225 585607 588115 667700 686666 687745 692131 697268 711988 741335 777460 793419
Other Business Expenses 155466 184142 189637 169857 143807 167198 179701 195598 192576 217254 225494 230595 225293 240279 242193 244907 228861 240258 241690
Non-Labor Expenses $2552708 $2612391 $2635720 $2703976 $2530421 $2894147 $3006988 $3101454 $3166897 3505 3749 3884 3786 3894 3994 4111 $4193782 $4353689 $4473580
Other Expense Adjustments
Other ($13712) ($14750) ($18292) ($2289) $62593 $46175 $44973 $37007 $47404 49 134 158 84 36 22 23 $23516 $24069 $24637
General Reserve 0000 0000 0000 0000 0000 - 0 - 0 - 0 - 0 0 0 165 170 175 180 185 190000 195000 205000
Other Expense Adjustments ($13712) ($14750) ($18292) ($2289) $62593 $46175 $44973 $37007 $47404 $49379 $134 $323 $254 $211 $202 $208 $213516 $219069 $229637
Gap Closing Expenses $7675394
Additional Actions for Budget Balance Expense Impact $0000 $0000 $0000 $0000 $0000 $0000 $0000 $0000 $0000 $0000 $0000 $0000 $0000 $0000 $0000 $0000 $0000 $0000 $0000
Total Operating Expenses Before Non-Cash Liability Adjs $9191127 $9511685 $9550486 $9936705 $10256481 $10937450 $11633535 $11870763 $12453659 $12927116 $13802910 $14246122 $14475644 $14891445 $15293262 $15732241 $15927699 $16457978 $16983292
Non-Cash Liability Adjustments
Depreciation $1790981 $1940576 $1980681 $2019378 $2148820 $2174302 $2266280 $2442777 $2442941 $2607970 $2804571 $2784812 $2842737 $2908533 $2977025 $3051834 $3109882 $3169371 $3230301
OPEB Obligation 1348962 1104827 1167070 1706939 1785881 1920189 2035457 1489656 1562261 1567381 0000 (0000) (0000) (0000) (0000) 0000 0000 (0000) (0000)
GASB 75 OPEB Expense Adjustment 0000 0000 0000 0000 0000 0000 0000 0000 0000 0000 1047747 1457230 1628196 1748560 1823313 1898497 1952374 2006482 2061993
GASB 68 Pension Expense Adjustment 0000 0000 0000 0000 0000 0000 0000 (410019) (218911) (168119) (373022) (220864) (271921) (342847) (318372) (242446) (237864) (234492) (230942)
Environmental Remediation 42249 6062 18621 59079 24742 14257 20556 20576 11691 13468 105615 6000 6000 6000 6000 6000 6000 6000 6000
Non-Cash Liability Adjustments $3182192 $3051466 $3166371 $3785396 $3959443 $4108749 $4322293 $3542990 $3797981 $4020699 $3584911 $4027178 $4205012 $4320246 $4487966 $4713886 $4830392 $4947361 $5067352
Total Operating Expenses After Non-Cash Liability Adjs $12373319 $12563151 $12716857 $13722101 $14215924 $15046199 $15955827 $15413753 $16251641 $16947815 $17387821 $18273301 $18680657 $19211690 $19781228 $20446127 $20758090 $21405338 $22050644
Less BampT Depreciation $77213 $80097 $77846 $86545 $87926 $91345 $104039 $109783 $135035 $240957 $148686 $151977 $158779 $169848 $181689 $194355 $194355 $194355 $194355
BampT Other Post Employment Benefits 66323 50967 54831 66686 73055 76641 71148 62457 60441 78106 32297 22256 20303 22870 28694 33918 36169 38411 40604
Net Operating Deficit Before Subsidies and Debt Service ($6409807) ($6419266) ($6222079) ($6711095) ($7081966) ($7146057) ($7887759) ($6954506) ($7643392) ($8211234) ($8606220) ($9463506) ($9813560) ($10322912) ($10895644) ($11515498) ($11364824) ($11950106) ($12573710)
Conversion to Cash Basis Non-Cash Liability Adjs ($3182192) ($3051466) ($3166371) ($3785396) ($3959443) ($4108749) ($4322293) ($3542990) ($3797981) ($4020699) ($3584911) ($4027178) ($4205012) ($4320246) ($4487966) ($4713886) ($4830392) ($4947361) ($5067352)
Total Operating Expenses $9191127 $9511685 $9550486 $9936705 $10256481 $10937450 $11633535 $11870763 $12453659 $12927 $13803 $14246 $14476 $14891 $15293 $15732 $15927699 $16457978 $16983292
Debt Service Expenses $1515733 $1404454 $1781220 $1933532 $2058395 $2299262 $2248538 $2373321 $2458783 $2525 $2559 $2692 $2840 $3080 $3223 $3450 $3471321 $3472987 $3501639
Total Expenses + Debt Service $10706859 $10916139 $11331706 $11870237 $12314876 $13236712 $13882073 $14244084 $14912443 $15452 $16362 $16938 $17316 $17971 $18516 $19182 $19399019 $19930965 $20484932
Net Deficit After Subsidies and Debt Service ($668477) ($620796) ($0414) $287848 $320833 $556541 $561498 $810173 $359895 ($299965) ($339) ($890) ($1079) ($1506) ($1823) ($2283) ($1901641) ($2229069) ($2664369)
Conversion to Cash Basis GASB Account (56067) (54256) (67377) (37636) (89548) (85641) (50017) - 0 - 0 0 0 0 $0 0 0 - 0 - 0 - 0 - 0
Conversion to Cash Basis 492710 550267 91781 (111037) (297407) (261709) (626297) (660147) (591809) 174 296 363 188 (17) 88 130 49745 48375 54220
Net Cash Balance from Previous Year 0000 0000 0000 23990 139174 0000 209191 0000 150026 0000 0000 0000 0000 0000 0000 0000 0000 0000 0000
Total Operating Exp + DS + Cash Conversions + PY C-O $11144 $11412 $11356 $11746 $12067 $12889362 $13414950 $13583937 $14470659 $15625875 $16658585 $17300293 $17504155 $17954574 $18604130 $19312017 $19448764 $19979340 $20539152
Total Operating Expenses with Cash Conversion $10270216 $10420127 $11307302 $12018911 $12701831 $13584063 $14558387 $14904231 $15504252 $15278749 $16065734 $16575223 $17128079 $17987951 $18427778 $19052755 $19349274 $19882590 $20430711
Baseline Net Cash Balance Before B-T-L Adjustments ($231834) ($124785) $23990 $139174 ($66122) $209191 ($114816) $150026 ($231914) ($126) ($43) ($527) ($891) ($1523) ($1735) ($2153) ($1851896) ($2180695) ($2610148)
Below-the-Line Adjustments
FareToll Increases
FareToll Increase in March 2019 (4 Yield) - 0 $0 $0 $0 $0 $0 $0 - 0 - 0 - 0
FareToll Increase in March 2021 (4 Yield) - 0 $0 $0 $0 $283 $331 $332 333531 333568 334299
FareToll Increase in March 2023 (4 Yield) - 0 $0 $0 $0 $0 $0 $294 346386 346424 347183
FareToll Increase in March 2025 (4 Yield) - 0 $0 $0 $0 $0 $0 $0 - 0 273859 321624
Subsidy Impacts of 20212023 FareToll Increase - 0 $0 $0 $0 ($7) ($9) ($17) (18612) (25573) (26305)
$0000 $0 $0 $0 $275 $322 $609 $661306 $928278 $976801
CASH BALANCE AFTER FARE INCREASES ($126402) ($43) ($527) ($891) ($1241) ($1404) ($1821) ($1518365) ($1847127) ($2275849)
MTA Initiatives
MTA Efficiencies - Not Yet Implemented - 0 $0 $0 $0 $0 $0 $0 0000 0000 0000
0 - 0 $0 $0 $0 $0 $0 $0 - 0 - 0 - 0
0 - 0 $0 $0 $0 $0 $0 $0 - 0 - 0 - 0
$0000 $0 $0 $0 $0 $0 $0 $0000 $0000 $0000
Policy Actions
CAS Migration to Peoplesoft $0 $0 ($5) ($1) ($0) ($0) (0200) -02 -02 0
Fare Evasion Enforcement Strategy-Expenses $0 ($13) ($12) ($11) ($10) ($10) (9554) -9554483 -9554483 0
Fare Evasion Enforcement-Manhattan DA Forfeiture Fund $0 $11 $11 $10 $9 $0 - 0 0 0 0
Negotiated 1 CBA Reform $0 $0 $0 $0 $0 $0 - 0 0 0 0
MTA Reorganization $0 $8 $180 $371 $377 $377 377000 377 377 0
MTA Reorganization Costs $0 $0 ($10) ($27) ($2) $0 - 0 0 0 0
Drawdown 2019 General Reserve $0 $0 $165 $0 $0 $0 - 0 0 0 0
CBA Negotiated Reform - 1 Value $0 $36 $100 $173 $246 $323 323473 323473304484 323473304484 0
$0000 $0 $42 $429 $515 $620 $691 $690719 $690719 $690719
MTA Re-estimates
Additional Savings Actions $0000 $0 $0 $0 $0 $0 $0 $0000 $0000 $0000
Total Below-the-Line Adjustments $0 $0 $459 $413 $709 $760 $1007 $1352025 $1618997 $1667520
Prior Year Carryover 495399 263336 138286 161986 301160 235038 444229 329413 479439 248 121 79 11 0 0 - 0 - 0 - 0 - 0
NET CASH BALANCE $263566 $138551 $162276 $301160 $235038 $444229 $329413 $479439 $247525 $121 $79 $11 ($467) ($814) ($976) ($1146) ($499871) ($561698) ($942628)
By Revenue Source
(includes faretoll increases)
($ in millions)
Farebox Revenue $6389
Toll Revenue 2121
Other Revenue 684
Dedicated Taxes 6191
State and Local amp Other 1228
Timing (Cash Adjustments) 135
Total $16748
By Expense Category
(includes below-the-line adjustments)
($ in millions)
Payroll $5422
Overtime 838
Health amp Welfare 2118
Pension 1461
Other Labor 466
Total Labor $10306
Non-Labor + Other Exp Adj 4004
Debt Service 2830
BTL Adjustments for Expenses 2 (386)
Total $16754
By Revenue Source
(includes faretoll increases)
($ in millions)
Farebox Revenue $6389
Toll Revenue 2121
Other Revenue 684
Taxes 6178
State and Local amp Other 557
Other Funding Agreements 671
Other 1 208
Total $16809
By Expense Category
(includes below-the-line adjustments)
($ in millions)
Payroll $5392
Overtime 811
Health amp Welfare 2129
Pension 1354
Other Labor 400
Total Labor $10086
Non-Labor 4205
Debt Service 2692
BTL Adjustments for Expenses (251)
Total $16732
Page 13: MTA 2020 Preliminary Budget July Financial Plan 2020 - 2023 2020 Preliminar… · 1 The MTA Budget Process July Plan – Start of the Annual Process • Current year is revised (the

Proposed July Plan

Deficits remain and a continued drive toward further streamlining and efficiencies is required

12

($ in millions)

61 55

(26)

(281)

(433)

($600)

($500)

($400)

($300)

($200)

($100)

$0

$100

$200

2019 2020 2021 2022 2023

This Year Next Year Out-Years

Proposed July PlanDonrsquot achieve Transformation Plan Savings

13

If the MTA Transformation Plan is not adopted and implemented the deficits will be unmanageable without service cuts significant

reductions in force andor additional fare and toll increases($ in millions)

($1100)

($900)

($700)

($500)

($300)

($100)

$100

2019 2020 2021 2022 2023

(816)

(971)

(569)

(81)

(433)

(281)

61 55 (26)

(281) (186)

50

Next Year Out-Years

(230)(11)

(488)

(538)

(535)

This Year

14

2020 Preliminary BudgetWhere the Dollars Come Fromhellip Where the Dollars Gohellip

Farebox Revenue $6389Toll Revenue 2121 Other Revenue 684 Taxes 6178 State and Local amp Other 557 Other Funding Agreements 671 Other 1 208 Total $16809

($ in millions)

By Revenue Source(includes faretoll increases)

Payroll $5422Overtime 838 Health amp Welfare 2118 Pension 1461 Other Labor 466 Total Labor $10306Non-Labor + Other Exp Adj 4004 Debt Service 2830 BTL Adjustments for Expenses 2 (386) Total $16754

By Expense Category

($ in millions)(includes below-the-line adjustments)

1 Includes cash adjustments and prior-year carryover

Farebox Revenue

38

Toll Revenue

13

Other Revenue4

Taxes37

State amp Local

Subsidies3

Other Funding Agreements

4 Other 1

Payroll32

Overtime5

Health ampWelfare

13Pension

9

Other Labor3

Non-Labor + Other Exp Adj

21

Debt Service17

2 The below-the-line adjustments are grouped in the Non-Labor category

Sheet1

Sheet1

15

Non-Reimbursable Mid-Year Preliminary Actual Forecast Budget

2018 2019 2020 2021 2022 2023 Operating Revenues

Farebox Revenue $6155 $6305 $6389 $6373 $6384 $6393Toll Revenue 1976 2088 2121 2129 2129 2131 Other Revenue 643 696 684 704 719 737

Total Operating Revenue $8774 $9089 $9195 $9206 $9232 $9260

Total Subsidies $7177 $7314 $7406 $7581 $7803 $7969Dedicated Taxes as a of Total Revenues + Subs - PMT 233 $0 $0 $0 $0 $0

Total Revenues + Subsidies $15951 $16403 $16601 $16787 $17035 $17229

Operating ExpensesLabor Expenses $9799 $10116 $10306 $10592 $10881 $11121Non-Labor Expenses 3611 3877 3748 3841 3945 4054 Other 129 175 86 36 22 23 General Reserve 0 165 170 175 180 185

Total Operating Expenses $13539 $14333 $14310 $14644 $15028 $15384

Debt Service Expenses $2541 $2683 $2830 $3041 $3265 $3513

Total Expenses + Debt Service $16079 $17016 $17140 $17685 $18293 $18896

Conversion to Cash Basis 379 229 147 60 125 101

Baseline Net Cash Balance Before B-T-L Adjustments $251 ($384) ($392) ($838) ($1133) ($1566)

Total Below-the-Line Adjustments $0 $73 $386 $757 $852 $1133Prior Year Carryover 121 372 61 55 0 0

NET CASH BALANCE $372 $61 $55 ($26) ($281) ($433)

MTA July Financial Plan 2020-2023Consolidated Statement Of Operations By Category ($ in millions)

Summ Stmt of Ops-Feb

Summ Stmt of Ops-Jul

  • MTA 2020Preliminary BudgetJuly Financial Plan2020 - 2023
  • The MTA Budget Process
  • Slide Number 3
  • Slide Number 4
  • What has changed since the February Plan
  • Highlights of the July Plan
  • Slide Number 7
  • MTA Transformation Plan
  • Slide Number 9
  • Actions to Reduce Fare Evasion $62 million Investment over the Plan Period
  • The MTArsquos $350 million target for annually recurring savings beginning in 2020 has been identified and is being implemented
  • We have a track record of identifying and achieving our annual recurring savings targets
  • Deficits remain and a continued drive toward further streamlining and efficiencies is required
  • Slide Number 14
  • 2020 Preliminary Budget
  • Slide Number 16
MTA July Financial Plan 2020-2023
Consolidated Statement Of Operations By Category ($ in millions)
Non-Reimbursable Mid-Year Preliminary
Actual Actual Actual Actual Actual Actual Actual Actual Actual Actual Forecast Budget
2008 2009 2010 2011 2012 2013 2014 2015 2016 2018 2019 2020 2021 2022 2023 2023 2024 2025 2026
Operating Revenues
Farebox Revenue $4240923 $4350411 $4586377 $4999186 $5079138 $5501274 $5709200 $5961129 $6050182 $6155 $6305 $6389 $6373 $6384 $6393 $6174 $6435176 $6431979 $6446633
422 423 405 411 402 399 395 396 396 386 384 385 380 375 371 261 368 363 362
Student Fare - 0 - 0 - 0 - 0 - 0 - 0
Toll Revenue 1273974 1332115 1417046 1501589 1490982 1645193 1676445 1808901 1869693 1976 2088 2121 2129 2129 2131 2002 2133050 2137871 2143111
0127 0129 0125 0124 0118 0119 0116 0120 0122 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0122 0121 0120
Other Revenue 448616 461359 491355 510231 563839 753675 682424 689217 688374 643 696 684 704 719 737 755 825040 885381 887190
Capital and Other Reimbursements 0000 0000 0000 0000 0000 0000 0000 0000 0000 0000 0000 0000 0000 0000 0000 0000 0000 0000 0000
Total Operating Revenue $5963512 $6143885 $6494778 $7011006 $7133959 $7900142 $8068069 $8459247 $8608249 $8774 $9089 $9195 $9206 $9232 $9260 $8931 $9393266 $9455232 $9476934
Dedicated Taxes $3211585 $2366805 $2343537 $2511691 $2673119 $3097640 $3383498 $3582628 $3525829 $3257508 $3459 $3515 $3568 $3630 $3725 $3812 $3841433 $3880226 $3917215
PMT amp MTA Aid - 0 881784 1588677 1718286 1825824 1825328 1885069 1910947 1970760 1987035 $1965 $2152 $2225 $2295 $2368 $2442 2516095 2594604 2677041
New Funding Sources - 0 - 0 - 0 - 0 - 0 - 0 - 0 - 0 - 0 - 0 $508 $342 $385 $385 $385 $385 385000 385000 385000
StateLocal Taxes 556691 539046 544810 541733 536182 537527 539545 537819 537645 541005 $544 $552 $557 $562 $567 $572 576828 581933 583214
Other Funding Agreements 306594 363823 359489 375369 466625 432617 567391 563616 629855 630218 $701 $753 $671 $708 $758 $758 784755 804901 781159
BampT Operating Surplus Transfer 382565 363092 476059 554903 476575 614210 637553 750717 742909 740144 $702 $721 $782 $801 $789 $707 730476 695303 688833
Dedicated Taxes and StateLocal Subsidies $4457434 $4514550 $5312572 $5701982 $5978325 $6507322 $7013056 $7345727 $7406998 $7155909 $7879 $8035 $8188 $8381 $8592 $8676 $8834588 $8941967 $9032462
$0000 $0000 $0000 $0000 $0000 $0000 $0000 $0000 $0000
Less Interagency Subsidy and Surplus Transfers (382565) (363092) (476059) (554903) (476575) (614210) (637553) (750717) (742909) (740144) ($702) ($721) ($782) ($801) ($789) ($707) (730476) (695303) (688833)
Total Subsidies $4074870 $4151458 $4836513 $5147079 $5501750 $5893111 $6375503 $6595010 $6664088 $7177 $7314 $7406 $7581 $7803 $7969 $7969 $8104112 $8246664 $8343629
Dedicated Taxes as a of Total Revenues + Subs - PMT 320 251 241 241 247 259 269 273 265 233 $0 $0 $0 $0 $0 $0 256 257 259
Total Revenues + Subsidies $10038382 $10295342 $11331292 $12158085 $12635709 $13793254 $14443571 $15054257 $15272337 $15951 $16403 $16601 $16787 $17035 $17229 $16900 $17497378 $17701896 $17820563
Operating Expenses
Labor Expenses
Payroll $4087376 $4163330 $4171374 $4160261 $4193658 $4332829 $4671664 $4695823 $4838741 $5020713 $5211 $5328 $5422 $5498 $5624 $5710 $5860206 $5982960 $6107107
Overtime 471675 499307 443227 538647 574316 620701 730200 755071 771495 934100 $1066 $910 $838 $859 $877 $899 917296 935002 951324
Health amp Welfare 684945 688899 738189 809638 812857 895714 961902 1050100 1172304 1208786 $1230 $1341 $1414 $1489 $1583 $1674 1797938 1922668 2071273
OPEB Current Payment 318501 346316 355716 394218 413164 472619 479079 501716 562233 563754 $604 $645 $704 $766 $835 $910 982025 1060022 1142795
Pensions 897450 1021229 1029710 1074598 1328441 1301975 1304355 1248726 1370474 1345308 $1336 $1494 $1461 $1462 $1403 $1347 1357887 1369071 1380572
Other-Fringe Benefits 502739 517194 539996 581661 650430 694680 784143 861079 947870 792151 $881 $869 $897 $930 $956 $976 1001185 1021007 1040170
Reimbursable Overhead (310555) (322230) (345154) (324006) (309399) (321390) (349770) (380212) (423759) (491807) ($528) ($471) ($430) ($412) ($397) ($395) (396136) (405509) (413165)
Labor Expenses $6652131 $6914045 $6933059 $7235017 $7663467 $7997128 $8581574 $8732302 $9239358 $9799 $10116 $10306 $10592 $10881 $11121 $11413 $11520401 $11885220 $12280075
PayrollOvertime Exp as a of Total Operating+DS $0426 $0427 $0407 $0396 $0387 $0374 $0389 $0383 $0376 $0390 $0367 $0365 $0359 $0355 $0350 $0349 $0347 $0345
Labor Exp (wo Reimb OH) as a of Total Oper+DS $0650 $0663 $0642 $0637 $0647 $0628 $0643 $0640 $0648 $0642 $0622 $0626 $0622 $0616 $0609 $0614 $0617 $0620
PayrollOvertime Exp as a of Total Operating Exp $0496 $0490 $0483 $0473 $0465 $0453 $0464 $0459 $0450 $0464 $0435 $0438 $0434 $0433 $0430 $0426 $0420 $0416
Labor Exp (wo Reimb OH) as a of Total Oper Exp $0758 $0761 $0762 $0761 $0777 $0761 $0768 $0768 $0776 $0763 $0739 $0750 $0751 $0750 $0749 $0748 $0747 $0747
Non-Labor Expenses
Electric Power $306500 $317934 $325137 $457269 $471514 $493346 $515540 $473762 $406372 $481893 $451503 $473177 $493090 $532413 $561955 $571182 $589565 $618283 $648255
Traction Power
Non-Traction Power
Fuel 287033 180294 189942 282735 251763 259252 267494 162283 124684 185203 182778 182981 176333 173681 176920 182259 182476 184281 186170
Revenue Vehicle Fuel
Non-Revenue Fuel
Insurance 28902 34012 9819 14363 7617 38654 50739 57190 (20634) (29402) 5608 15623 23118 26855 28309 36048 28232 25538 19483
Claims 152114 238104 285418 315547 135652 299875 269167 331023 463959 437985 387557 394211 392547 398256 406112 404397 417667 428660 437683
Paratransit Service Contracts 299013 370094 379761 348553 360500 366751 365599 379271 383704 455471 494751 488330 505538 535329 568614 581114 604766 643217 684112
Maintenance and Other Operating Contracts 594215 562456 541716 451137 451766 496743 549018 579289 630924 678425 840168 797428 833534 836606 854471 879468 880053 898882 915477
Professional Service Contracts 196930 199164 203084 226205 276998 297201 283005 379814 399706 543582 607838 502858 494814 504103 513895 499724 520826 537109 547291
Materials amp Supplies 532534 526191 511206 438310 430804 475127 526725 543225 585607 637078 689010 679895 697976 711281 715758 711988 741335 777460 793419
Other Business Expenses 155466 184142 189637 169857 143807 167198 179701 195598 192576 220838 218196 213551 224459 226170 228457 244907 228861 240258 241690
Non-Labor Expenses $2552708 $2612391 $2635720 $2703976 $2530421 $2894147 $3006988 $3101454 $3166897 3611 3877 3748 3841 3945 4054 4111 $4193782 $4353689 $4473580
Other Expense Adjustments
Other ($13712) ($14750) ($18292) ($2289) $62593 $46175 $44973 $37007 $47404 129 175 86 36 22 23 23 $23516 $24069 $24637
General Reserve 0000 0000 0000 0000 0000 - 0 - 0 - 0 - 0 0 165 170 175 180 185 185 190000 195000 205000
Other Expense Adjustments ($13712) ($14750) ($18292) ($2289) $62593 $46175 $44973 $37007 $47404 $128555 $340 $256 $211 $202 $208 $208 $213516 $219069 $229637
Gap Closing Expenses $7675394
Additional Actions for Budget Balance Expense Impact $0000 $0000 $0000 $0000 $0000 $0000 $0000 $0000 $0000 $0000 $0000 $0000 $0000 $0000 $0000 $0000 $0000 $0000 $0000
Total Operating Expenses Before Non-Cash Liability Adjs $9191127 $9511685 $9550486 $9936705 $10256481 $10937450 $11633535 $11870763 $12453659 $13538830 $14332772 $14309678 $14643965 $15027767 $15383584 $15732241 $15927699 $16457978 $16983292
Non-Cash Liability Adjustments
Depreciation $1790981 $1940576 $1980681 $2019378 $2148820 $2174302 $2266280 $2442777 $2442941 $2607970 $2804571 $2784812 $2842737 $2908533 $2977025 $3051834 $3109882 $3169371 $3230301
OPEB Obligation 1348962 1104827 1167070 1706939 1785881 1920189 2035457 1489656 1562261 1567381 0000 (0000) (0000) (0000) (0000) 0000 0000 (0000) (0000)
GASB 75 OPEB Expense Adjustment 0000 0000 0000 0000 0000 0000 0000 0000 0000 0000 1047747 1457230 1628196 1748560 1823313 1898497 1952374 2006482 2061993
GASB 68 Pension Expense Adjustment 0000 0000 0000 0000 0000 0000 0000 (410019) (218911) (168119) (373022) (220864) (271921) (342847) (318372) (242446) (237864) (234492) (230942)
Environmental Remediation 42249 6062 18621 59079 24742 14257 20556 20576 11691 13468 105615 6000 6000 6000 6000 6000 6000 6000 6000
Non-Cash Liability Adjustments $3182192 $3051466 $3166371 $3785396 $3959443 $4108749 $4322293 $3542990 $3797981 $4020699 $3584911 $4027178 $4205012 $4320246 $4487966 $4713886 $4830392 $4947361 $5067352
Total Operating Expenses After Non-Cash Liability Adjs $12373319 $12563151 $12716857 $13722101 $14215924 $15046199 $15955827 $15413753 $16251641 $17559529 $17917683 $18336856 $18848977 $19348013 $19871550 $20446127 $20758090 $21405338 $22050644
Less BampT Depreciation $77213 $80097 $77846 $86545 $87926 $91345 $104039 $109783 $135035 $240957 $148686 $151977 $158779 $169848 $181689 $194355 $194355 $194355 $194355
BampT Other Post Employment Benefits 66323 50967 54831 66686 73055 76641 71148 62457 60441 78106 32297 22256 20303 22870 28694 33918 36169 38411 40604
Net Operating Deficit Before Subsidies and Debt Service ($6409807) ($6419266) ($6222079) ($6711095) ($7081966) ($7146057) ($7887759) ($6954506) ($7643392) ($8785339) ($8829030) ($9141907) ($9642826) ($10116260) ($10611154) ($11515498) ($11364824) ($11950106) ($12573710)
Conversion to Cash Basis Non-Cash Liability Adjs ($3182192) ($3051466) ($3166371) ($3785396) ($3959443) ($4108749) ($4322293) ($3542990) ($3797981) ($4020699) ($3584911) ($4027178) ($4205012) ($4320246) ($4487966) ($4713886) ($4830392) ($4947361) ($5067352)
Total Operating Expenses $9191127 $9511685 $9550486 $9936705 $10256481 $10937450 $11633535 $11870763 $12453659 $13539 $14333 $14310 $14644 $15028 $15384 $15732 $15927699 $16457978 $16983292
Debt Service Expenses $1515733 $1404454 $1781220 $1933532 $2058395 $2299262 $2248538 $2373321 $2458783 $2541 $2683 $2830 $3041 $3265 $3513 $3450 $3471321 $3472987 $3501639
Total Expenses + Debt Service $10706859 $10916139 $11331706 $11870237 $12314876 $13236712 $13882073 $14244084 $14912443 $16079 $17016 $17140 $17685 $18293 $18896 $19182 $19399019 $19930965 $20484932
Net Deficit After Subsidies and Debt Service ($668477) ($620796) ($0414) $287848 $320833 $556541 $561498 $810173 $359895 ($128044) ($613) ($539) ($898) ($1258) ($1667) ($2283) ($1901641) ($2229069) ($2664369)
Conversion to Cash Basis GASB Account (56067) (54256) (67377) (37636) (89548) (85641) (50017) - 0 - 0 0 0 0 $0 0 0 - 0 - 0 - 0 - 0
Conversion to Cash Basis 492710 550267 91781 (111037) (297407) (261709) (626297) (660147) (591809) 379 229 147 60 125 101 130 49745 48375 54220
Net Cash Balance from Previous Year 0000 0000 0000 23990 139174 0000 209191 0000 150026 0000 250569 0000 0000 0000 0000 0000 0000 0000 0000
Total Operating Exp + DS + Cash Conversions + PY C-O $11144 $11412 $11356 $11746 $12067 $12889362 $13414950 $13583937 $14470659 $16457999 $17495351 $17286526 $17744425 $18418197 $18997710 $19312017 $19448764 $19979340 $20539152
Total Operating Expenses with Cash Conversion $10270216 $10420127 $11307302 $12018911 $12701831 $13584063 $14558387 $14904231 $15504252 $15700774 $16786574 $16992579 $17624861 $18167420 $18795069 $19052755 $19349274 $19882590 $20430711
Baseline Net Cash Balance Before B-T-L Adjustments ($231834) ($124785) $23990 $139174 ($66122) $209191 ($114816) $150026 ($231914) $251 ($384) ($392) ($838) ($1133) ($1566) ($2153) ($1851896) ($2180695) ($2610148)
Below-the-Line Adjustments
FareToll Increases
FareToll Increase in March 2019 (4 Yield) - 0 $0 $0 $0 $0 $0 $0 - 0 - 0 - 0
FareToll Increase in March 2021 (4 Yield) - 0 $0 $0 $0 $283 $331 $332 333531 333568 334299
FareToll Increase in March 2023 (4 Yield) - 0 $0 $0 $0 $0 $0 $294 346386 346424 347183
FareToll Increase in March 2025 (4 Yield) - 0 $0 $0 $0 $0 $0 $0 - 0 273859 321624
Subsidy Impacts of 20212023 FareToll Increase - 0 $0 $0 $0 ($7) ($9) ($17) (18612) (25573) (26305)
$0000 $0 $0 $0 $275 $322 $609 $661306 $928278 $976801
CASH BALANCE AFTER FARE INCREASES $250569 ($384) ($392) ($838) ($850) ($1234) ($1821) ($1518365) ($1847127) ($2275849)
MTA Initiatives
MTA Efficiencies - Not Yet Implemented - 0 $0 $0 $0 $0 $0 $0 0000 0000 0000
0 - 0 $0 $0 $0 $0 $0 $0 - 0 - 0 - 0
0 - 0 $0 $0 $0 $0 $0 $0 - 0 - 0 - 0
$0000 $0 $0 $0 $0 $0 $0 $0000 $0000 $0000
Policy Actions
CAS Migration to Peoplesoft $0 $0 ($5) ($1) ($0) ($0) (0200) -02 -02 0
Fare Evasion Enforcement Strategy-Expenses $0 ($13) ($12) ($11) ($10) ($10) (9554) -9554483 -9554483 0
Fare Evasion Enforcement-Manhattan DA Forfeiture Fund $0 $11 $11 $10 $9 $0 - 0 0 0 0
Negotiated 1 CBA Reform $0 $0 $0 $0 $0 $0 - 0 0 0 0
MTA Reorganization $0 $8 $180 $371 $377 $377 377000 377 377 0
MTA Reorganization Costs $0 $0 ($10) ($27) ($2) $0 - 0 0 0 0
Drawdown 2019 General Reserve $0 $0 $165 $0 $0 $0 - 0 0 0 0
CBA Negotiated Reform - 1 Value $0 $36 $100 $173 $246 $323 323473 323473304484 323473304484 0
$0000 $0 $42 $429 $515 $620 $691 $690719 $690719 $690719
MTA Re-estimates
Additional Savings Actions $0000 $0 $0 $0 $0 $0 $0 $0000 $0000 $0000
Total Below-the-Line Adjustments $0 $73 $386 $757 $852 $1133 $1007 $1352025 $1618997 $1667520
Prior Year Carryover 495399 263336 138286 161986 301160 235038 444229 329413 479439 121 372 61 55 0 0 - 0 - 0 - 0 - 0
NET CASH BALANCE $263566 $138551 $162276 $301160 $235038 $444229 $329413 $479439 $247525 $372 $61 $55 ($26) ($281) ($433) ($1146) ($499871) ($561698) ($942628)
MTA February Financial Plan 2019-2022
Consolidated Statement Of Operations By Category ($ in millions)
Non-Reimbursable Final Adopted
Actual Actual Actual Actual Actual Actual Actual Actual Actual Actual Estimate Budget
2008 2009 2010 2011 2012 2013 2014 2015 2016 2017 2018 2019 2020 2021 2022 2023 2024 2025 2026
Operating Revenues
Farebox Revenue $4240923 $4350411 $4586377 $4999186 $5079138 $5501274 $5709200 $5961129 $6050182 $6172 $6153 $6122 $6144 $6134 $6144 $6174 $6435176 $6431979 $6446633
422 423 405 411 402 399 395 396 396 407 279 275 272 267 263 261 368 363 362
Student Fare - 0 - 0 - 0 - 0 - 0 - 0
Toll Revenue 1273974 1332115 1417046 1501589 1490982 1645193 1676445 1808901 1869693 1912 1967 1984 1990 1998 1998 2002 2133050 2137871 2143111
0127 0129 0125 0124 0118 0119 0116 0120 0122 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0122 0121 0120
Other Revenue 448616 461359 491355 510231 563839 753675 682424 689217 688374 653 662 705 733 757 743 755 825040 885381 887190
Capital and Other Reimbursements 0000 0000 0000 0000 0000 0000 0000 0000 0000 0000 0000 0000 0000 0000 0000 0000 0000 0000 0000
Total Operating Revenue $5963512 $6143885 $6494778 $7011006 $7133959 $7900142 $8068069 $8459247 $8608249 $8737 $8782 $8810 $8867 $8889 $8886 $8931 $9393266 $9455232 $9476934
Dedicated Taxes $3211585 $2366805 $2343537 $2511691 $2673119 $3097640 $3383498 $3582628 $3525829 $3257508 $3459 $3515 $3568 $3630 $3725 $3812 $3841433 $3880226 $3917215
PMT amp MTA Aid - 0 881784 1588677 1718286 1825824 1825328 1885069 1910947 1970760 1987035 $1965 $2152 $2225 $2295 $2368 $2442 2516095 2594604 2677041
New Funding Sources - 0 - 0 - 0 - 0 - 0 - 0 - 0 - 0 - 0 - 0 $508 $342 $385 $385 $385 $385 385000 385000 385000
StateLocal Taxes 556691 539046 544810 541733 536182 537527 539545 537819 537645 541005 $544 $552 $557 $562 $567 $572 576828 581933 583214
Other Funding Agreements 306594 363823 359489 375369 466625 432617 567391 563616 629855 630218 $701 $753 $671 $708 $758 $758 784755 804901 781159
BampT Operating Surplus Transfer 382565 363092 476059 554903 476575 614210 637553 750717 742909 740144 $702 $721 $782 $801 $789 $707 730476 695303 688833
Dedicated Taxes and StateLocal Subsidies $4457434 $4514550 $5312572 $5701982 $5978325 $6507322 $7013056 $7345727 $7406998 $7155909 $7879 $8035 $8188 $8381 $8592 $8676 $8834588 $8941967 $9032462
$0000 $0000 $0000 $0000 $0000 $0000 $0000 $0000 $0000
Less Interagency Subsidy and Surplus Transfers (382565) (363092) (476059) (554903) (476575) (614210) (637553) (750717) (742909) (740144) ($702) ($721) ($782) ($801) ($789) ($707) (730476) (695303) (688833)
Total Subsidies $4074870 $4151458 $4836513 $5147079 $5501750 $5893111 $6375503 $6595010 $6664088 $6416 $7242 $7238 $7370 $7576 $7807 $7969 $8104112 $8246664 $8343629
Dedicated Taxes as a of Total Revenues + Subs - PMT 320 251 241 241 247 259 269 273 265 247 $0 $0 $0 $0 $0 $0 256 257 259
Total Revenues + Subsidies $10038382 $10295342 $11331292 $12158085 $12635709 $13793254 $14443571 $15054257 $15272337 $15152 $16023 $16048 $16237 $16465 $16693 $16900 $17497378 $17701896 $17820563
Operating Expenses
Labor Expenses
Payroll $4087376 $4163330 $4171374 $4160261 $4193658 $4332829 $4671664 $4695823 $4838741 $5020713 $5211 $5328 $5422 $5498 $5624 $5710 $5860206 $5982960 $6107107
Overtime 471675 499307 443227 538647 574316 620701 730200 755071 771495 934100 $1066 $910 $838 $859 $877 $899 917296 935002 951324
Health amp Welfare 684945 688899 738189 809638 812857 895714 961902 1050100 1172304 1208786 $1230 $1341 $1414 $1489 $1583 $1674 1797938 1922668 2071273
OPEB Current Payment 318501 346316 355716 394218 413164 472619 479079 501716 562233 563754 $604 $645 $704 $766 $835 $910 982025 1060022 1142795
Pensions 897450 1021229 1029710 1074598 1328441 1301975 1304355 1248726 1370474 1345308 $1336 $1494 $1461 $1462 $1403 $1347 1357887 1369071 1380572
Other-Fringe Benefits 502739 517194 539996 581661 650430 694680 784143 861079 947870 792151 $881 $869 $897 $930 $956 $976 1001185 1021007 1040170
Reimbursable Overhead (310555) (322230) (345154) (324006) (309399) (321390) (349770) (380212) (423759) (491807) ($528) ($471) ($430) ($412) ($397) ($395) (396136) (405509) (413165)
Labor Expenses $6652131 $6914045 $6933059 $7235017 $7663467 $7997128 $8581574 $8732302 $9239358 $9373 $9920 $10039 $10436 $10787 $11097 $11413 $11520401 $11885220 $12280075
PayrollOvertime Exp as a of Total Operating+DS $0426 $0427 $0407 $0396 $0387 $0374 $0389 $0383 $0376 $0385 $0349 $0347 $0345
Labor Exp (wo Reimb OH) as a of Total Oper+DS $0650 $0663 $0642 $0637 $0647 $0628 $0643 $0640 $0648 $0638 $0614 $0617 $0620
PayrollOvertime Exp as a of Total Operating Exp $0496 $0490 $0483 $0473 $0465 $0453 $0464 $0459 $0450 $0461 $0426 $0420 $0416
Labor Exp (wo Reimb OH) as a of Total Oper Exp $0758 $0761 $0762 $0761 $0777 $0761 $0768 $0768 $0776 $0763 $0748 $0747 $0747
Non-Labor Expenses
Electric Power $306500 $317934 $325137 $457269 $471514 $493346 $515540 $473762 $406372 $430381 $474918 $451304 $463523 $482662 $539624 $571182 $589565 $618283 $648255
Traction Power
Non-Traction Power
Fuel 287033 180294 189942 282735 251763 259252 267494 162283 124684 150481 185580 190348 187592 183168 181484 182259 182476 184281 186170
Revenue Vehicle Fuel
Non-Revenue Fuel
Insurance 28902 34012 9819 14363 7617 38654 50739 57190 (20634) (2715) 11488 8532 15803 22918 29411 36048 28232 25538 19483
Claims 152114 238104 285418 315547 135652 299875 269167 331023 463959 526053 376480 378570 386981 391333 395228 404397 417667 428660 437683
Paratransit Service Contracts 299013 370094 379761 348553 360500 366751 365599 379271 383704 392850 452190 482751 501230 518038 547829 581114 604766 643217 684112
Maintenance and Other Operating Contracts 594215 562456 541716 451137 451766 496743 549018 579289 630924 695251 779331 897801 833038 883805 871671 879468 880053 898882 915477
Professional Service Contracts 196930 199164 203084 226205 276998 297201 283005 379814 399706 507062 575742 557476 484911 479376 489510 499724 520826 537109 547291
Materials amp Supplies 532534 526191 511206 438310 430804 475127 526725 543225 585607 588115 667700 686666 687745 692131 697268 711988 741335 777460 793419
Other Business Expenses 155466 184142 189637 169857 143807 167198 179701 195598 192576 217254 225494 230595 225293 240279 242193 244907 228861 240258 241690
Non-Labor Expenses $2552708 $2612391 $2635720 $2703976 $2530421 $2894147 $3006988 $3101454 $3166897 3505 3749 3884 3786 3894 3994 4111 $4193782 $4353689 $4473580
Other Expense Adjustments
Other ($13712) ($14750) ($18292) ($2289) $62593 $46175 $44973 $37007 $47404 49 134 158 84 36 22 23 $23516 $24069 $24637
General Reserve 0000 0000 0000 0000 0000 - 0 - 0 - 0 - 0 0 0 165 170 175 180 185 190000 195000 205000
Other Expense Adjustments ($13712) ($14750) ($18292) ($2289) $62593 $46175 $44973 $37007 $47404 $49379 $134 $323 $254 $211 $202 $208 $213516 $219069 $229637
Gap Closing Expenses $7675394
Additional Actions for Budget Balance Expense Impact $0000 $0000 $0000 $0000 $0000 $0000 $0000 $0000 $0000 $0000 $0000 $0000 $0000 $0000 $0000 $0000 $0000 $0000 $0000
Total Operating Expenses Before Non-Cash Liability Adjs $9191127 $9511685 $9550486 $9936705 $10256481 $10937450 $11633535 $11870763 $12453659 $12927116 $13802910 $14246122 $14475644 $14891445 $15293262 $15732241 $15927699 $16457978 $16983292
Non-Cash Liability Adjustments
Depreciation $1790981 $1940576 $1980681 $2019378 $2148820 $2174302 $2266280 $2442777 $2442941 $2607970 $2804571 $2784812 $2842737 $2908533 $2977025 $3051834 $3109882 $3169371 $3230301
OPEB Obligation 1348962 1104827 1167070 1706939 1785881 1920189 2035457 1489656 1562261 1567381 0000 (0000) (0000) (0000) (0000) 0000 0000 (0000) (0000)
GASB 75 OPEB Expense Adjustment 0000 0000 0000 0000 0000 0000 0000 0000 0000 0000 1047747 1457230 1628196 1748560 1823313 1898497 1952374 2006482 2061993
GASB 68 Pension Expense Adjustment 0000 0000 0000 0000 0000 0000 0000 (410019) (218911) (168119) (373022) (220864) (271921) (342847) (318372) (242446) (237864) (234492) (230942)
Environmental Remediation 42249 6062 18621 59079 24742 14257 20556 20576 11691 13468 105615 6000 6000 6000 6000 6000 6000 6000 6000
Non-Cash Liability Adjustments $3182192 $3051466 $3166371 $3785396 $3959443 $4108749 $4322293 $3542990 $3797981 $4020699 $3584911 $4027178 $4205012 $4320246 $4487966 $4713886 $4830392 $4947361 $5067352
Total Operating Expenses After Non-Cash Liability Adjs $12373319 $12563151 $12716857 $13722101 $14215924 $15046199 $15955827 $15413753 $16251641 $16947815 $17387821 $18273301 $18680657 $19211690 $19781228 $20446127 $20758090 $21405338 $22050644
Less BampT Depreciation $77213 $80097 $77846 $86545 $87926 $91345 $104039 $109783 $135035 $240957 $148686 $151977 $158779 $169848 $181689 $194355 $194355 $194355 $194355
BampT Other Post Employment Benefits 66323 50967 54831 66686 73055 76641 71148 62457 60441 78106 32297 22256 20303 22870 28694 33918 36169 38411 40604
Net Operating Deficit Before Subsidies and Debt Service ($6409807) ($6419266) ($6222079) ($6711095) ($7081966) ($7146057) ($7887759) ($6954506) ($7643392) ($8211234) ($8606220) ($9463506) ($9813560) ($10322912) ($10895644) ($11515498) ($11364824) ($11950106) ($12573710)
Conversion to Cash Basis Non-Cash Liability Adjs ($3182192) ($3051466) ($3166371) ($3785396) ($3959443) ($4108749) ($4322293) ($3542990) ($3797981) ($4020699) ($3584911) ($4027178) ($4205012) ($4320246) ($4487966) ($4713886) ($4830392) ($4947361) ($5067352)
Total Operating Expenses $9191127 $9511685 $9550486 $9936705 $10256481 $10937450 $11633535 $11870763 $12453659 $12927 $13803 $14246 $14476 $14891 $15293 $15732 $15927699 $16457978 $16983292
Debt Service Expenses $1515733 $1404454 $1781220 $1933532 $2058395 $2299262 $2248538 $2373321 $2458783 $2525 $2559 $2692 $2840 $3080 $3223 $3450 $3471321 $3472987 $3501639
Total Expenses + Debt Service $10706859 $10916139 $11331706 $11870237 $12314876 $13236712 $13882073 $14244084 $14912443 $15452 $16362 $16938 $17316 $17971 $18516 $19182 $19399019 $19930965 $20484932
Net Deficit After Subsidies and Debt Service ($668477) ($620796) ($0414) $287848 $320833 $556541 $561498 $810173 $359895 ($299965) ($339) ($890) ($1079) ($1506) ($1823) ($2283) ($1901641) ($2229069) ($2664369)
Conversion to Cash Basis GASB Account (56067) (54256) (67377) (37636) (89548) (85641) (50017) - 0 - 0 0 0 0 $0 0 0 - 0 - 0 - 0 - 0
Conversion to Cash Basis 492710 550267 91781 (111037) (297407) (261709) (626297) (660147) (591809) 174 296 363 188 (17) 88 130 49745 48375 54220
Net Cash Balance from Previous Year 0000 0000 0000 23990 139174 0000 209191 0000 150026 0000 0000 0000 0000 0000 0000 0000 0000 0000 0000
Total Operating Exp + DS + Cash Conversions + PY C-O $11144 $11412 $11356 $11746 $12067 $12889362 $13414950 $13583937 $14470659 $15625875 $16658585 $17300293 $17504155 $17954574 $18604130 $19312017 $19448764 $19979340 $20539152
Total Operating Expenses with Cash Conversion $10270216 $10420127 $11307302 $12018911 $12701831 $13584063 $14558387 $14904231 $15504252 $15278749 $16065734 $16575223 $17128079 $17987951 $18427778 $19052755 $19349274 $19882590 $20430711
Baseline Net Cash Balance Before B-T-L Adjustments ($231834) ($124785) $23990 $139174 ($66122) $209191 ($114816) $150026 ($231914) ($126) ($43) ($527) ($891) ($1523) ($1735) ($2153) ($1851896) ($2180695) ($2610148)
Below-the-Line Adjustments
FareToll Increases
FareToll Increase in March 2019 (4 Yield) - 0 $0 $0 $0 $0 $0 $0 - 0 - 0 - 0
FareToll Increase in March 2021 (4 Yield) - 0 $0 $0 $0 $283 $331 $332 333531 333568 334299
FareToll Increase in March 2023 (4 Yield) - 0 $0 $0 $0 $0 $0 $294 346386 346424 347183
FareToll Increase in March 2025 (4 Yield) - 0 $0 $0 $0 $0 $0 $0 - 0 273859 321624
Subsidy Impacts of 20212023 FareToll Increase - 0 $0 $0 $0 ($7) ($9) ($17) (18612) (25573) (26305)
$0000 $0 $0 $0 $275 $322 $609 $661306 $928278 $976801
CASH BALANCE AFTER FARE INCREASES ($126402) ($43) ($527) ($891) ($1241) ($1404) ($1821) ($1518365) ($1847127) ($2275849)
MTA Initiatives
MTA Efficiencies - Not Yet Implemented - 0 $0 $0 $0 $0 $0 $0 0000 0000 0000
0 - 0 $0 $0 $0 $0 $0 $0 - 0 - 0 - 0
0 - 0 $0 $0 $0 $0 $0 $0 - 0 - 0 - 0
$0000 $0 $0 $0 $0 $0 $0 $0000 $0000 $0000
Policy Actions
CAS Migration to Peoplesoft $0 $0 ($5) ($1) ($0) ($0) (0200) -02 -02 0
Fare Evasion Enforcement Strategy-Expenses $0 ($13) ($12) ($11) ($10) ($10) (9554) -9554483 -9554483 0
Fare Evasion Enforcement-Manhattan DA Forfeiture Fund $0 $11 $11 $10 $9 $0 - 0 0 0 0
Negotiated 1 CBA Reform $0 $0 $0 $0 $0 $0 - 0 0 0 0
MTA Reorganization $0 $8 $180 $371 $377 $377 377000 377 377 0
MTA Reorganization Costs $0 $0 ($10) ($27) ($2) $0 - 0 0 0 0
Drawdown 2019 General Reserve $0 $0 $165 $0 $0 $0 - 0 0 0 0
CBA Negotiated Reform - 1 Value $0 $36 $100 $173 $246 $323 323473 323473304484 323473304484 0
$0000 $0 $42 $429 $515 $620 $691 $690719 $690719 $690719
MTA Re-estimates
Additional Savings Actions $0000 $0 $0 $0 $0 $0 $0 $0000 $0000 $0000
Total Below-the-Line Adjustments $0 $0 $459 $413 $709 $760 $1007 $1352025 $1618997 $1667520
Prior Year Carryover 495399 263336 138286 161986 301160 235038 444229 329413 479439 248 121 79 11 0 0 - 0 - 0 - 0 - 0
NET CASH BALANCE $263566 $138551 $162276 $301160 $235038 $444229 $329413 $479439 $247525 $121 $79 $11 ($467) ($814) ($976) ($1146) ($499871) ($561698) ($942628)
By Revenue Source
(includes faretoll increases)
($ in millions)
Farebox Revenue $6389
Toll Revenue 2121
Other Revenue 684
Dedicated Taxes 6191
State and Local amp Other 1228
Timing (Cash Adjustments) 135
Total $16748
By Expense Category
(includes below-the-line adjustments)
($ in millions)
Payroll $5422
Overtime 838
Health amp Welfare 2118
Pension 1461
Other Labor 466
Total Labor $10306
Non-Labor + Other Exp Adj 4004
Debt Service 2830
BTL Adjustments for Expenses 2 (386)
Total $16754
By Revenue Source
(includes faretoll increases)
($ in millions)
Farebox Revenue $6389
Toll Revenue 2121
Other Revenue 684
Taxes 6178
State and Local amp Other 557
Other Funding Agreements 671
Other 1 208
Total $16809
By Expense Category
(includes below-the-line adjustments)
($ in millions)
Payroll $5392
Overtime 811
Health amp Welfare 2129
Pension 1354
Other Labor 400
Total Labor $10086
Non-Labor 4205
Debt Service 2692
BTL Adjustments for Expenses (251)
Total $16732
Page 14: MTA 2020 Preliminary Budget July Financial Plan 2020 - 2023 2020 Preliminar… · 1 The MTA Budget Process July Plan – Start of the Annual Process • Current year is revised (the

Proposed July PlanDonrsquot achieve Transformation Plan Savings

13

If the MTA Transformation Plan is not adopted and implemented the deficits will be unmanageable without service cuts significant

reductions in force andor additional fare and toll increases($ in millions)

($1100)

($900)

($700)

($500)

($300)

($100)

$100

2019 2020 2021 2022 2023

(816)

(971)

(569)

(81)

(433)

(281)

61 55 (26)

(281) (186)

50

Next Year Out-Years

(230)(11)

(488)

(538)

(535)

This Year

14

2020 Preliminary BudgetWhere the Dollars Come Fromhellip Where the Dollars Gohellip

Farebox Revenue $6389Toll Revenue 2121 Other Revenue 684 Taxes 6178 State and Local amp Other 557 Other Funding Agreements 671 Other 1 208 Total $16809

($ in millions)

By Revenue Source(includes faretoll increases)

Payroll $5422Overtime 838 Health amp Welfare 2118 Pension 1461 Other Labor 466 Total Labor $10306Non-Labor + Other Exp Adj 4004 Debt Service 2830 BTL Adjustments for Expenses 2 (386) Total $16754

By Expense Category

($ in millions)(includes below-the-line adjustments)

1 Includes cash adjustments and prior-year carryover

Farebox Revenue

38

Toll Revenue

13

Other Revenue4

Taxes37

State amp Local

Subsidies3

Other Funding Agreements

4 Other 1

Payroll32

Overtime5

Health ampWelfare

13Pension

9

Other Labor3

Non-Labor + Other Exp Adj

21

Debt Service17

2 The below-the-line adjustments are grouped in the Non-Labor category

Sheet1

Sheet1

15

Non-Reimbursable Mid-Year Preliminary Actual Forecast Budget

2018 2019 2020 2021 2022 2023 Operating Revenues

Farebox Revenue $6155 $6305 $6389 $6373 $6384 $6393Toll Revenue 1976 2088 2121 2129 2129 2131 Other Revenue 643 696 684 704 719 737

Total Operating Revenue $8774 $9089 $9195 $9206 $9232 $9260

Total Subsidies $7177 $7314 $7406 $7581 $7803 $7969Dedicated Taxes as a of Total Revenues + Subs - PMT 233 $0 $0 $0 $0 $0

Total Revenues + Subsidies $15951 $16403 $16601 $16787 $17035 $17229

Operating ExpensesLabor Expenses $9799 $10116 $10306 $10592 $10881 $11121Non-Labor Expenses 3611 3877 3748 3841 3945 4054 Other 129 175 86 36 22 23 General Reserve 0 165 170 175 180 185

Total Operating Expenses $13539 $14333 $14310 $14644 $15028 $15384

Debt Service Expenses $2541 $2683 $2830 $3041 $3265 $3513

Total Expenses + Debt Service $16079 $17016 $17140 $17685 $18293 $18896

Conversion to Cash Basis 379 229 147 60 125 101

Baseline Net Cash Balance Before B-T-L Adjustments $251 ($384) ($392) ($838) ($1133) ($1566)

Total Below-the-Line Adjustments $0 $73 $386 $757 $852 $1133Prior Year Carryover 121 372 61 55 0 0

NET CASH BALANCE $372 $61 $55 ($26) ($281) ($433)

MTA July Financial Plan 2020-2023Consolidated Statement Of Operations By Category ($ in millions)

Summ Stmt of Ops-Feb

Summ Stmt of Ops-Jul

  • MTA 2020Preliminary BudgetJuly Financial Plan2020 - 2023
  • The MTA Budget Process
  • Slide Number 3
  • Slide Number 4
  • What has changed since the February Plan
  • Highlights of the July Plan
  • Slide Number 7
  • MTA Transformation Plan
  • Slide Number 9
  • Actions to Reduce Fare Evasion $62 million Investment over the Plan Period
  • The MTArsquos $350 million target for annually recurring savings beginning in 2020 has been identified and is being implemented
  • We have a track record of identifying and achieving our annual recurring savings targets
  • Deficits remain and a continued drive toward further streamlining and efficiencies is required
  • Slide Number 14
  • 2020 Preliminary Budget
  • Slide Number 16
MTA July Financial Plan 2020-2023
Consolidated Statement Of Operations By Category ($ in millions)
Non-Reimbursable Mid-Year Preliminary
Actual Actual Actual Actual Actual Actual Actual Actual Actual Actual Forecast Budget
2008 2009 2010 2011 2012 2013 2014 2015 2016 2018 2019 2020 2021 2022 2023 2023 2024 2025 2026
Operating Revenues
Farebox Revenue $4240923 $4350411 $4586377 $4999186 $5079138 $5501274 $5709200 $5961129 $6050182 $6155 $6305 $6389 $6373 $6384 $6393 $6174 $6435176 $6431979 $6446633
422 423 405 411 402 399 395 396 396 386 384 385 380 375 371 261 368 363 362
Student Fare - 0 - 0 - 0 - 0 - 0 - 0
Toll Revenue 1273974 1332115 1417046 1501589 1490982 1645193 1676445 1808901 1869693 1976 2088 2121 2129 2129 2131 2002 2133050 2137871 2143111
0127 0129 0125 0124 0118 0119 0116 0120 0122 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0122 0121 0120
Other Revenue 448616 461359 491355 510231 563839 753675 682424 689217 688374 643 696 684 704 719 737 755 825040 885381 887190
Capital and Other Reimbursements 0000 0000 0000 0000 0000 0000 0000 0000 0000 0000 0000 0000 0000 0000 0000 0000 0000 0000 0000
Total Operating Revenue $5963512 $6143885 $6494778 $7011006 $7133959 $7900142 $8068069 $8459247 $8608249 $8774 $9089 $9195 $9206 $9232 $9260 $8931 $9393266 $9455232 $9476934
Dedicated Taxes $3211585 $2366805 $2343537 $2511691 $2673119 $3097640 $3383498 $3582628 $3525829 $3257508 $3459 $3515 $3568 $3630 $3725 $3812 $3841433 $3880226 $3917215
PMT amp MTA Aid - 0 881784 1588677 1718286 1825824 1825328 1885069 1910947 1970760 1987035 $1965 $2152 $2225 $2295 $2368 $2442 2516095 2594604 2677041
New Funding Sources - 0 - 0 - 0 - 0 - 0 - 0 - 0 - 0 - 0 - 0 $508 $342 $385 $385 $385 $385 385000 385000 385000
StateLocal Taxes 556691 539046 544810 541733 536182 537527 539545 537819 537645 541005 $544 $552 $557 $562 $567 $572 576828 581933 583214
Other Funding Agreements 306594 363823 359489 375369 466625 432617 567391 563616 629855 630218 $701 $753 $671 $708 $758 $758 784755 804901 781159
BampT Operating Surplus Transfer 382565 363092 476059 554903 476575 614210 637553 750717 742909 740144 $702 $721 $782 $801 $789 $707 730476 695303 688833
Dedicated Taxes and StateLocal Subsidies $4457434 $4514550 $5312572 $5701982 $5978325 $6507322 $7013056 $7345727 $7406998 $7155909 $7879 $8035 $8188 $8381 $8592 $8676 $8834588 $8941967 $9032462
$0000 $0000 $0000 $0000 $0000 $0000 $0000 $0000 $0000
Less Interagency Subsidy and Surplus Transfers (382565) (363092) (476059) (554903) (476575) (614210) (637553) (750717) (742909) (740144) ($702) ($721) ($782) ($801) ($789) ($707) (730476) (695303) (688833)
Total Subsidies $4074870 $4151458 $4836513 $5147079 $5501750 $5893111 $6375503 $6595010 $6664088 $7177 $7314 $7406 $7581 $7803 $7969 $7969 $8104112 $8246664 $8343629
Dedicated Taxes as a of Total Revenues + Subs - PMT 320 251 241 241 247 259 269 273 265 233 $0 $0 $0 $0 $0 $0 256 257 259
Total Revenues + Subsidies $10038382 $10295342 $11331292 $12158085 $12635709 $13793254 $14443571 $15054257 $15272337 $15951 $16403 $16601 $16787 $17035 $17229 $16900 $17497378 $17701896 $17820563
Operating Expenses
Labor Expenses
Payroll $4087376 $4163330 $4171374 $4160261 $4193658 $4332829 $4671664 $4695823 $4838741 $5020713 $5211 $5328 $5422 $5498 $5624 $5710 $5860206 $5982960 $6107107
Overtime 471675 499307 443227 538647 574316 620701 730200 755071 771495 934100 $1066 $910 $838 $859 $877 $899 917296 935002 951324
Health amp Welfare 684945 688899 738189 809638 812857 895714 961902 1050100 1172304 1208786 $1230 $1341 $1414 $1489 $1583 $1674 1797938 1922668 2071273
OPEB Current Payment 318501 346316 355716 394218 413164 472619 479079 501716 562233 563754 $604 $645 $704 $766 $835 $910 982025 1060022 1142795
Pensions 897450 1021229 1029710 1074598 1328441 1301975 1304355 1248726 1370474 1345308 $1336 $1494 $1461 $1462 $1403 $1347 1357887 1369071 1380572
Other-Fringe Benefits 502739 517194 539996 581661 650430 694680 784143 861079 947870 792151 $881 $869 $897 $930 $956 $976 1001185 1021007 1040170
Reimbursable Overhead (310555) (322230) (345154) (324006) (309399) (321390) (349770) (380212) (423759) (491807) ($528) ($471) ($430) ($412) ($397) ($395) (396136) (405509) (413165)
Labor Expenses $6652131 $6914045 $6933059 $7235017 $7663467 $7997128 $8581574 $8732302 $9239358 $9799 $10116 $10306 $10592 $10881 $11121 $11413 $11520401 $11885220 $12280075
PayrollOvertime Exp as a of Total Operating+DS $0426 $0427 $0407 $0396 $0387 $0374 $0389 $0383 $0376 $0390 $0367 $0365 $0359 $0355 $0350 $0349 $0347 $0345
Labor Exp (wo Reimb OH) as a of Total Oper+DS $0650 $0663 $0642 $0637 $0647 $0628 $0643 $0640 $0648 $0642 $0622 $0626 $0622 $0616 $0609 $0614 $0617 $0620
PayrollOvertime Exp as a of Total Operating Exp $0496 $0490 $0483 $0473 $0465 $0453 $0464 $0459 $0450 $0464 $0435 $0438 $0434 $0433 $0430 $0426 $0420 $0416
Labor Exp (wo Reimb OH) as a of Total Oper Exp $0758 $0761 $0762 $0761 $0777 $0761 $0768 $0768 $0776 $0763 $0739 $0750 $0751 $0750 $0749 $0748 $0747 $0747
Non-Labor Expenses
Electric Power $306500 $317934 $325137 $457269 $471514 $493346 $515540 $473762 $406372 $481893 $451503 $473177 $493090 $532413 $561955 $571182 $589565 $618283 $648255
Traction Power
Non-Traction Power
Fuel 287033 180294 189942 282735 251763 259252 267494 162283 124684 185203 182778 182981 176333 173681 176920 182259 182476 184281 186170
Revenue Vehicle Fuel
Non-Revenue Fuel
Insurance 28902 34012 9819 14363 7617 38654 50739 57190 (20634) (29402) 5608 15623 23118 26855 28309 36048 28232 25538 19483
Claims 152114 238104 285418 315547 135652 299875 269167 331023 463959 437985 387557 394211 392547 398256 406112 404397 417667 428660 437683
Paratransit Service Contracts 299013 370094 379761 348553 360500 366751 365599 379271 383704 455471 494751 488330 505538 535329 568614 581114 604766 643217 684112
Maintenance and Other Operating Contracts 594215 562456 541716 451137 451766 496743 549018 579289 630924 678425 840168 797428 833534 836606 854471 879468 880053 898882 915477
Professional Service Contracts 196930 199164 203084 226205 276998 297201 283005 379814 399706 543582 607838 502858 494814 504103 513895 499724 520826 537109 547291
Materials amp Supplies 532534 526191 511206 438310 430804 475127 526725 543225 585607 637078 689010 679895 697976 711281 715758 711988 741335 777460 793419
Other Business Expenses 155466 184142 189637 169857 143807 167198 179701 195598 192576 220838 218196 213551 224459 226170 228457 244907 228861 240258 241690
Non-Labor Expenses $2552708 $2612391 $2635720 $2703976 $2530421 $2894147 $3006988 $3101454 $3166897 3611 3877 3748 3841 3945 4054 4111 $4193782 $4353689 $4473580
Other Expense Adjustments
Other ($13712) ($14750) ($18292) ($2289) $62593 $46175 $44973 $37007 $47404 129 175 86 36 22 23 23 $23516 $24069 $24637
General Reserve 0000 0000 0000 0000 0000 - 0 - 0 - 0 - 0 0 165 170 175 180 185 185 190000 195000 205000
Other Expense Adjustments ($13712) ($14750) ($18292) ($2289) $62593 $46175 $44973 $37007 $47404 $128555 $340 $256 $211 $202 $208 $208 $213516 $219069 $229637
Gap Closing Expenses $7675394
Additional Actions for Budget Balance Expense Impact $0000 $0000 $0000 $0000 $0000 $0000 $0000 $0000 $0000 $0000 $0000 $0000 $0000 $0000 $0000 $0000 $0000 $0000 $0000
Total Operating Expenses Before Non-Cash Liability Adjs $9191127 $9511685 $9550486 $9936705 $10256481 $10937450 $11633535 $11870763 $12453659 $13538830 $14332772 $14309678 $14643965 $15027767 $15383584 $15732241 $15927699 $16457978 $16983292
Non-Cash Liability Adjustments
Depreciation $1790981 $1940576 $1980681 $2019378 $2148820 $2174302 $2266280 $2442777 $2442941 $2607970 $2804571 $2784812 $2842737 $2908533 $2977025 $3051834 $3109882 $3169371 $3230301
OPEB Obligation 1348962 1104827 1167070 1706939 1785881 1920189 2035457 1489656 1562261 1567381 0000 (0000) (0000) (0000) (0000) 0000 0000 (0000) (0000)
GASB 75 OPEB Expense Adjustment 0000 0000 0000 0000 0000 0000 0000 0000 0000 0000 1047747 1457230 1628196 1748560 1823313 1898497 1952374 2006482 2061993
GASB 68 Pension Expense Adjustment 0000 0000 0000 0000 0000 0000 0000 (410019) (218911) (168119) (373022) (220864) (271921) (342847) (318372) (242446) (237864) (234492) (230942)
Environmental Remediation 42249 6062 18621 59079 24742 14257 20556 20576 11691 13468 105615 6000 6000 6000 6000 6000 6000 6000 6000
Non-Cash Liability Adjustments $3182192 $3051466 $3166371 $3785396 $3959443 $4108749 $4322293 $3542990 $3797981 $4020699 $3584911 $4027178 $4205012 $4320246 $4487966 $4713886 $4830392 $4947361 $5067352
Total Operating Expenses After Non-Cash Liability Adjs $12373319 $12563151 $12716857 $13722101 $14215924 $15046199 $15955827 $15413753 $16251641 $17559529 $17917683 $18336856 $18848977 $19348013 $19871550 $20446127 $20758090 $21405338 $22050644
Less BampT Depreciation $77213 $80097 $77846 $86545 $87926 $91345 $104039 $109783 $135035 $240957 $148686 $151977 $158779 $169848 $181689 $194355 $194355 $194355 $194355
BampT Other Post Employment Benefits 66323 50967 54831 66686 73055 76641 71148 62457 60441 78106 32297 22256 20303 22870 28694 33918 36169 38411 40604
Net Operating Deficit Before Subsidies and Debt Service ($6409807) ($6419266) ($6222079) ($6711095) ($7081966) ($7146057) ($7887759) ($6954506) ($7643392) ($8785339) ($8829030) ($9141907) ($9642826) ($10116260) ($10611154) ($11515498) ($11364824) ($11950106) ($12573710)
Conversion to Cash Basis Non-Cash Liability Adjs ($3182192) ($3051466) ($3166371) ($3785396) ($3959443) ($4108749) ($4322293) ($3542990) ($3797981) ($4020699) ($3584911) ($4027178) ($4205012) ($4320246) ($4487966) ($4713886) ($4830392) ($4947361) ($5067352)
Total Operating Expenses $9191127 $9511685 $9550486 $9936705 $10256481 $10937450 $11633535 $11870763 $12453659 $13539 $14333 $14310 $14644 $15028 $15384 $15732 $15927699 $16457978 $16983292
Debt Service Expenses $1515733 $1404454 $1781220 $1933532 $2058395 $2299262 $2248538 $2373321 $2458783 $2541 $2683 $2830 $3041 $3265 $3513 $3450 $3471321 $3472987 $3501639
Total Expenses + Debt Service $10706859 $10916139 $11331706 $11870237 $12314876 $13236712 $13882073 $14244084 $14912443 $16079 $17016 $17140 $17685 $18293 $18896 $19182 $19399019 $19930965 $20484932
Net Deficit After Subsidies and Debt Service ($668477) ($620796) ($0414) $287848 $320833 $556541 $561498 $810173 $359895 ($128044) ($613) ($539) ($898) ($1258) ($1667) ($2283) ($1901641) ($2229069) ($2664369)
Conversion to Cash Basis GASB Account (56067) (54256) (67377) (37636) (89548) (85641) (50017) - 0 - 0 0 0 0 $0 0 0 - 0 - 0 - 0 - 0
Conversion to Cash Basis 492710 550267 91781 (111037) (297407) (261709) (626297) (660147) (591809) 379 229 147 60 125 101 130 49745 48375 54220
Net Cash Balance from Previous Year 0000 0000 0000 23990 139174 0000 209191 0000 150026 0000 250569 0000 0000 0000 0000 0000 0000 0000 0000
Total Operating Exp + DS + Cash Conversions + PY C-O $11144 $11412 $11356 $11746 $12067 $12889362 $13414950 $13583937 $14470659 $16457999 $17495351 $17286526 $17744425 $18418197 $18997710 $19312017 $19448764 $19979340 $20539152
Total Operating Expenses with Cash Conversion $10270216 $10420127 $11307302 $12018911 $12701831 $13584063 $14558387 $14904231 $15504252 $15700774 $16786574 $16992579 $17624861 $18167420 $18795069 $19052755 $19349274 $19882590 $20430711
Baseline Net Cash Balance Before B-T-L Adjustments ($231834) ($124785) $23990 $139174 ($66122) $209191 ($114816) $150026 ($231914) $251 ($384) ($392) ($838) ($1133) ($1566) ($2153) ($1851896) ($2180695) ($2610148)
Below-the-Line Adjustments
FareToll Increases
FareToll Increase in March 2019 (4 Yield) - 0 $0 $0 $0 $0 $0 $0 - 0 - 0 - 0
FareToll Increase in March 2021 (4 Yield) - 0 $0 $0 $0 $283 $331 $332 333531 333568 334299
FareToll Increase in March 2023 (4 Yield) - 0 $0 $0 $0 $0 $0 $294 346386 346424 347183
FareToll Increase in March 2025 (4 Yield) - 0 $0 $0 $0 $0 $0 $0 - 0 273859 321624
Subsidy Impacts of 20212023 FareToll Increase - 0 $0 $0 $0 ($7) ($9) ($17) (18612) (25573) (26305)
$0000 $0 $0 $0 $275 $322 $609 $661306 $928278 $976801
CASH BALANCE AFTER FARE INCREASES $250569 ($384) ($392) ($838) ($850) ($1234) ($1821) ($1518365) ($1847127) ($2275849)
MTA Initiatives
MTA Efficiencies - Not Yet Implemented - 0 $0 $0 $0 $0 $0 $0 0000 0000 0000
0 - 0 $0 $0 $0 $0 $0 $0 - 0 - 0 - 0
0 - 0 $0 $0 $0 $0 $0 $0 - 0 - 0 - 0
$0000 $0 $0 $0 $0 $0 $0 $0000 $0000 $0000
Policy Actions
CAS Migration to Peoplesoft $0 $0 ($5) ($1) ($0) ($0) (0200) -02 -02 0
Fare Evasion Enforcement Strategy-Expenses $0 ($13) ($12) ($11) ($10) ($10) (9554) -9554483 -9554483 0
Fare Evasion Enforcement-Manhattan DA Forfeiture Fund $0 $11 $11 $10 $9 $0 - 0 0 0 0
Negotiated 1 CBA Reform $0 $0 $0 $0 $0 $0 - 0 0 0 0
MTA Reorganization $0 $8 $180 $371 $377 $377 377000 377 377 0
MTA Reorganization Costs $0 $0 ($10) ($27) ($2) $0 - 0 0 0 0
Drawdown 2019 General Reserve $0 $0 $165 $0 $0 $0 - 0 0 0 0
CBA Negotiated Reform - 1 Value $0 $36 $100 $173 $246 $323 323473 323473304484 323473304484 0
$0000 $0 $42 $429 $515 $620 $691 $690719 $690719 $690719
MTA Re-estimates
Additional Savings Actions $0000 $0 $0 $0 $0 $0 $0 $0000 $0000 $0000
Total Below-the-Line Adjustments $0 $73 $386 $757 $852 $1133 $1007 $1352025 $1618997 $1667520
Prior Year Carryover 495399 263336 138286 161986 301160 235038 444229 329413 479439 121 372 61 55 0 0 - 0 - 0 - 0 - 0
NET CASH BALANCE $263566 $138551 $162276 $301160 $235038 $444229 $329413 $479439 $247525 $372 $61 $55 ($26) ($281) ($433) ($1146) ($499871) ($561698) ($942628)
MTA February Financial Plan 2019-2022
Consolidated Statement Of Operations By Category ($ in millions)
Non-Reimbursable Final Adopted
Actual Actual Actual Actual Actual Actual Actual Actual Actual Actual Estimate Budget
2008 2009 2010 2011 2012 2013 2014 2015 2016 2017 2018 2019 2020 2021 2022 2023 2024 2025 2026
Operating Revenues
Farebox Revenue $4240923 $4350411 $4586377 $4999186 $5079138 $5501274 $5709200 $5961129 $6050182 $6172 $6153 $6122 $6144 $6134 $6144 $6174 $6435176 $6431979 $6446633
422 423 405 411 402 399 395 396 396 407 279 275 272 267 263 261 368 363 362
Student Fare - 0 - 0 - 0 - 0 - 0 - 0
Toll Revenue 1273974 1332115 1417046 1501589 1490982 1645193 1676445 1808901 1869693 1912 1967 1984 1990 1998 1998 2002 2133050 2137871 2143111
0127 0129 0125 0124 0118 0119 0116 0120 0122 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0122 0121 0120
Other Revenue 448616 461359 491355 510231 563839 753675 682424 689217 688374 653 662 705 733 757 743 755 825040 885381 887190
Capital and Other Reimbursements 0000 0000 0000 0000 0000 0000 0000 0000 0000 0000 0000 0000 0000 0000 0000 0000 0000 0000 0000
Total Operating Revenue $5963512 $6143885 $6494778 $7011006 $7133959 $7900142 $8068069 $8459247 $8608249 $8737 $8782 $8810 $8867 $8889 $8886 $8931 $9393266 $9455232 $9476934
Dedicated Taxes $3211585 $2366805 $2343537 $2511691 $2673119 $3097640 $3383498 $3582628 $3525829 $3257508 $3459 $3515 $3568 $3630 $3725 $3812 $3841433 $3880226 $3917215
PMT amp MTA Aid - 0 881784 1588677 1718286 1825824 1825328 1885069 1910947 1970760 1987035 $1965 $2152 $2225 $2295 $2368 $2442 2516095 2594604 2677041
New Funding Sources - 0 - 0 - 0 - 0 - 0 - 0 - 0 - 0 - 0 - 0 $508 $342 $385 $385 $385 $385 385000 385000 385000
StateLocal Taxes 556691 539046 544810 541733 536182 537527 539545 537819 537645 541005 $544 $552 $557 $562 $567 $572 576828 581933 583214
Other Funding Agreements 306594 363823 359489 375369 466625 432617 567391 563616 629855 630218 $701 $753 $671 $708 $758 $758 784755 804901 781159
BampT Operating Surplus Transfer 382565 363092 476059 554903 476575 614210 637553 750717 742909 740144 $702 $721 $782 $801 $789 $707 730476 695303 688833
Dedicated Taxes and StateLocal Subsidies $4457434 $4514550 $5312572 $5701982 $5978325 $6507322 $7013056 $7345727 $7406998 $7155909 $7879 $8035 $8188 $8381 $8592 $8676 $8834588 $8941967 $9032462
$0000 $0000 $0000 $0000 $0000 $0000 $0000 $0000 $0000
Less Interagency Subsidy and Surplus Transfers (382565) (363092) (476059) (554903) (476575) (614210) (637553) (750717) (742909) (740144) ($702) ($721) ($782) ($801) ($789) ($707) (730476) (695303) (688833)
Total Subsidies $4074870 $4151458 $4836513 $5147079 $5501750 $5893111 $6375503 $6595010 $6664088 $6416 $7242 $7238 $7370 $7576 $7807 $7969 $8104112 $8246664 $8343629
Dedicated Taxes as a of Total Revenues + Subs - PMT 320 251 241 241 247 259 269 273 265 247 $0 $0 $0 $0 $0 $0 256 257 259
Total Revenues + Subsidies $10038382 $10295342 $11331292 $12158085 $12635709 $13793254 $14443571 $15054257 $15272337 $15152 $16023 $16048 $16237 $16465 $16693 $16900 $17497378 $17701896 $17820563
Operating Expenses
Labor Expenses
Payroll $4087376 $4163330 $4171374 $4160261 $4193658 $4332829 $4671664 $4695823 $4838741 $5020713 $5211 $5328 $5422 $5498 $5624 $5710 $5860206 $5982960 $6107107
Overtime 471675 499307 443227 538647 574316 620701 730200 755071 771495 934100 $1066 $910 $838 $859 $877 $899 917296 935002 951324
Health amp Welfare 684945 688899 738189 809638 812857 895714 961902 1050100 1172304 1208786 $1230 $1341 $1414 $1489 $1583 $1674 1797938 1922668 2071273
OPEB Current Payment 318501 346316 355716 394218 413164 472619 479079 501716 562233 563754 $604 $645 $704 $766 $835 $910 982025 1060022 1142795
Pensions 897450 1021229 1029710 1074598 1328441 1301975 1304355 1248726 1370474 1345308 $1336 $1494 $1461 $1462 $1403 $1347 1357887 1369071 1380572
Other-Fringe Benefits 502739 517194 539996 581661 650430 694680 784143 861079 947870 792151 $881 $869 $897 $930 $956 $976 1001185 1021007 1040170
Reimbursable Overhead (310555) (322230) (345154) (324006) (309399) (321390) (349770) (380212) (423759) (491807) ($528) ($471) ($430) ($412) ($397) ($395) (396136) (405509) (413165)
Labor Expenses $6652131 $6914045 $6933059 $7235017 $7663467 $7997128 $8581574 $8732302 $9239358 $9373 $9920 $10039 $10436 $10787 $11097 $11413 $11520401 $11885220 $12280075
PayrollOvertime Exp as a of Total Operating+DS $0426 $0427 $0407 $0396 $0387 $0374 $0389 $0383 $0376 $0385 $0349 $0347 $0345
Labor Exp (wo Reimb OH) as a of Total Oper+DS $0650 $0663 $0642 $0637 $0647 $0628 $0643 $0640 $0648 $0638 $0614 $0617 $0620
PayrollOvertime Exp as a of Total Operating Exp $0496 $0490 $0483 $0473 $0465 $0453 $0464 $0459 $0450 $0461 $0426 $0420 $0416
Labor Exp (wo Reimb OH) as a of Total Oper Exp $0758 $0761 $0762 $0761 $0777 $0761 $0768 $0768 $0776 $0763 $0748 $0747 $0747
Non-Labor Expenses
Electric Power $306500 $317934 $325137 $457269 $471514 $493346 $515540 $473762 $406372 $430381 $474918 $451304 $463523 $482662 $539624 $571182 $589565 $618283 $648255
Traction Power
Non-Traction Power
Fuel 287033 180294 189942 282735 251763 259252 267494 162283 124684 150481 185580 190348 187592 183168 181484 182259 182476 184281 186170
Revenue Vehicle Fuel
Non-Revenue Fuel
Insurance 28902 34012 9819 14363 7617 38654 50739 57190 (20634) (2715) 11488 8532 15803 22918 29411 36048 28232 25538 19483
Claims 152114 238104 285418 315547 135652 299875 269167 331023 463959 526053 376480 378570 386981 391333 395228 404397 417667 428660 437683
Paratransit Service Contracts 299013 370094 379761 348553 360500 366751 365599 379271 383704 392850 452190 482751 501230 518038 547829 581114 604766 643217 684112
Maintenance and Other Operating Contracts 594215 562456 541716 451137 451766 496743 549018 579289 630924 695251 779331 897801 833038 883805 871671 879468 880053 898882 915477
Professional Service Contracts 196930 199164 203084 226205 276998 297201 283005 379814 399706 507062 575742 557476 484911 479376 489510 499724 520826 537109 547291
Materials amp Supplies 532534 526191 511206 438310 430804 475127 526725 543225 585607 588115 667700 686666 687745 692131 697268 711988 741335 777460 793419
Other Business Expenses 155466 184142 189637 169857 143807 167198 179701 195598 192576 217254 225494 230595 225293 240279 242193 244907 228861 240258 241690
Non-Labor Expenses $2552708 $2612391 $2635720 $2703976 $2530421 $2894147 $3006988 $3101454 $3166897 3505 3749 3884 3786 3894 3994 4111 $4193782 $4353689 $4473580
Other Expense Adjustments
Other ($13712) ($14750) ($18292) ($2289) $62593 $46175 $44973 $37007 $47404 49 134 158 84 36 22 23 $23516 $24069 $24637
General Reserve 0000 0000 0000 0000 0000 - 0 - 0 - 0 - 0 0 0 165 170 175 180 185 190000 195000 205000
Other Expense Adjustments ($13712) ($14750) ($18292) ($2289) $62593 $46175 $44973 $37007 $47404 $49379 $134 $323 $254 $211 $202 $208 $213516 $219069 $229637
Gap Closing Expenses $7675394
Additional Actions for Budget Balance Expense Impact $0000 $0000 $0000 $0000 $0000 $0000 $0000 $0000 $0000 $0000 $0000 $0000 $0000 $0000 $0000 $0000 $0000 $0000 $0000
Total Operating Expenses Before Non-Cash Liability Adjs $9191127 $9511685 $9550486 $9936705 $10256481 $10937450 $11633535 $11870763 $12453659 $12927116 $13802910 $14246122 $14475644 $14891445 $15293262 $15732241 $15927699 $16457978 $16983292
Non-Cash Liability Adjustments
Depreciation $1790981 $1940576 $1980681 $2019378 $2148820 $2174302 $2266280 $2442777 $2442941 $2607970 $2804571 $2784812 $2842737 $2908533 $2977025 $3051834 $3109882 $3169371 $3230301
OPEB Obligation 1348962 1104827 1167070 1706939 1785881 1920189 2035457 1489656 1562261 1567381 0000 (0000) (0000) (0000) (0000) 0000 0000 (0000) (0000)
GASB 75 OPEB Expense Adjustment 0000 0000 0000 0000 0000 0000 0000 0000 0000 0000 1047747 1457230 1628196 1748560 1823313 1898497 1952374 2006482 2061993
GASB 68 Pension Expense Adjustment 0000 0000 0000 0000 0000 0000 0000 (410019) (218911) (168119) (373022) (220864) (271921) (342847) (318372) (242446) (237864) (234492) (230942)
Environmental Remediation 42249 6062 18621 59079 24742 14257 20556 20576 11691 13468 105615 6000 6000 6000 6000 6000 6000 6000 6000
Non-Cash Liability Adjustments $3182192 $3051466 $3166371 $3785396 $3959443 $4108749 $4322293 $3542990 $3797981 $4020699 $3584911 $4027178 $4205012 $4320246 $4487966 $4713886 $4830392 $4947361 $5067352
Total Operating Expenses After Non-Cash Liability Adjs $12373319 $12563151 $12716857 $13722101 $14215924 $15046199 $15955827 $15413753 $16251641 $16947815 $17387821 $18273301 $18680657 $19211690 $19781228 $20446127 $20758090 $21405338 $22050644
Less BampT Depreciation $77213 $80097 $77846 $86545 $87926 $91345 $104039 $109783 $135035 $240957 $148686 $151977 $158779 $169848 $181689 $194355 $194355 $194355 $194355
BampT Other Post Employment Benefits 66323 50967 54831 66686 73055 76641 71148 62457 60441 78106 32297 22256 20303 22870 28694 33918 36169 38411 40604
Net Operating Deficit Before Subsidies and Debt Service ($6409807) ($6419266) ($6222079) ($6711095) ($7081966) ($7146057) ($7887759) ($6954506) ($7643392) ($8211234) ($8606220) ($9463506) ($9813560) ($10322912) ($10895644) ($11515498) ($11364824) ($11950106) ($12573710)
Conversion to Cash Basis Non-Cash Liability Adjs ($3182192) ($3051466) ($3166371) ($3785396) ($3959443) ($4108749) ($4322293) ($3542990) ($3797981) ($4020699) ($3584911) ($4027178) ($4205012) ($4320246) ($4487966) ($4713886) ($4830392) ($4947361) ($5067352)
Total Operating Expenses $9191127 $9511685 $9550486 $9936705 $10256481 $10937450 $11633535 $11870763 $12453659 $12927 $13803 $14246 $14476 $14891 $15293 $15732 $15927699 $16457978 $16983292
Debt Service Expenses $1515733 $1404454 $1781220 $1933532 $2058395 $2299262 $2248538 $2373321 $2458783 $2525 $2559 $2692 $2840 $3080 $3223 $3450 $3471321 $3472987 $3501639
Total Expenses + Debt Service $10706859 $10916139 $11331706 $11870237 $12314876 $13236712 $13882073 $14244084 $14912443 $15452 $16362 $16938 $17316 $17971 $18516 $19182 $19399019 $19930965 $20484932
Net Deficit After Subsidies and Debt Service ($668477) ($620796) ($0414) $287848 $320833 $556541 $561498 $810173 $359895 ($299965) ($339) ($890) ($1079) ($1506) ($1823) ($2283) ($1901641) ($2229069) ($2664369)
Conversion to Cash Basis GASB Account (56067) (54256) (67377) (37636) (89548) (85641) (50017) - 0 - 0 0 0 0 $0 0 0 - 0 - 0 - 0 - 0
Conversion to Cash Basis 492710 550267 91781 (111037) (297407) (261709) (626297) (660147) (591809) 174 296 363 188 (17) 88 130 49745 48375 54220
Net Cash Balance from Previous Year 0000 0000 0000 23990 139174 0000 209191 0000 150026 0000 0000 0000 0000 0000 0000 0000 0000 0000 0000
Total Operating Exp + DS + Cash Conversions + PY C-O $11144 $11412 $11356 $11746 $12067 $12889362 $13414950 $13583937 $14470659 $15625875 $16658585 $17300293 $17504155 $17954574 $18604130 $19312017 $19448764 $19979340 $20539152
Total Operating Expenses with Cash Conversion $10270216 $10420127 $11307302 $12018911 $12701831 $13584063 $14558387 $14904231 $15504252 $15278749 $16065734 $16575223 $17128079 $17987951 $18427778 $19052755 $19349274 $19882590 $20430711
Baseline Net Cash Balance Before B-T-L Adjustments ($231834) ($124785) $23990 $139174 ($66122) $209191 ($114816) $150026 ($231914) ($126) ($43) ($527) ($891) ($1523) ($1735) ($2153) ($1851896) ($2180695) ($2610148)
Below-the-Line Adjustments
FareToll Increases
FareToll Increase in March 2019 (4 Yield) - 0 $0 $0 $0 $0 $0 $0 - 0 - 0 - 0
FareToll Increase in March 2021 (4 Yield) - 0 $0 $0 $0 $283 $331 $332 333531 333568 334299
FareToll Increase in March 2023 (4 Yield) - 0 $0 $0 $0 $0 $0 $294 346386 346424 347183
FareToll Increase in March 2025 (4 Yield) - 0 $0 $0 $0 $0 $0 $0 - 0 273859 321624
Subsidy Impacts of 20212023 FareToll Increase - 0 $0 $0 $0 ($7) ($9) ($17) (18612) (25573) (26305)
$0000 $0 $0 $0 $275 $322 $609 $661306 $928278 $976801
CASH BALANCE AFTER FARE INCREASES ($126402) ($43) ($527) ($891) ($1241) ($1404) ($1821) ($1518365) ($1847127) ($2275849)
MTA Initiatives
MTA Efficiencies - Not Yet Implemented - 0 $0 $0 $0 $0 $0 $0 0000 0000 0000
0 - 0 $0 $0 $0 $0 $0 $0 - 0 - 0 - 0
0 - 0 $0 $0 $0 $0 $0 $0 - 0 - 0 - 0
$0000 $0 $0 $0 $0 $0 $0 $0000 $0000 $0000
Policy Actions
CAS Migration to Peoplesoft $0 $0 ($5) ($1) ($0) ($0) (0200) -02 -02 0
Fare Evasion Enforcement Strategy-Expenses $0 ($13) ($12) ($11) ($10) ($10) (9554) -9554483 -9554483 0
Fare Evasion Enforcement-Manhattan DA Forfeiture Fund $0 $11 $11 $10 $9 $0 - 0 0 0 0
Negotiated 1 CBA Reform $0 $0 $0 $0 $0 $0 - 0 0 0 0
MTA Reorganization $0 $8 $180 $371 $377 $377 377000 377 377 0
MTA Reorganization Costs $0 $0 ($10) ($27) ($2) $0 - 0 0 0 0
Drawdown 2019 General Reserve $0 $0 $165 $0 $0 $0 - 0 0 0 0
CBA Negotiated Reform - 1 Value $0 $36 $100 $173 $246 $323 323473 323473304484 323473304484 0
$0000 $0 $42 $429 $515 $620 $691 $690719 $690719 $690719
MTA Re-estimates
Additional Savings Actions $0000 $0 $0 $0 $0 $0 $0 $0000 $0000 $0000
Total Below-the-Line Adjustments $0 $0 $459 $413 $709 $760 $1007 $1352025 $1618997 $1667520
Prior Year Carryover 495399 263336 138286 161986 301160 235038 444229 329413 479439 248 121 79 11 0 0 - 0 - 0 - 0 - 0
NET CASH BALANCE $263566 $138551 $162276 $301160 $235038 $444229 $329413 $479439 $247525 $121 $79 $11 ($467) ($814) ($976) ($1146) ($499871) ($561698) ($942628)
By Revenue Source
(includes faretoll increases)
($ in millions)
Farebox Revenue $6389
Toll Revenue 2121
Other Revenue 684
Dedicated Taxes 6191
State and Local amp Other 1228
Timing (Cash Adjustments) 135
Total $16748
By Expense Category
(includes below-the-line adjustments)
($ in millions)
Payroll $5422
Overtime 838
Health amp Welfare 2118
Pension 1461
Other Labor 466
Total Labor $10306
Non-Labor + Other Exp Adj 4004
Debt Service 2830
BTL Adjustments for Expenses 2 (386)
Total $16754
By Revenue Source
(includes faretoll increases)
($ in millions)
Farebox Revenue $6389
Toll Revenue 2121
Other Revenue 684
Taxes 6178
State and Local amp Other 557
Other Funding Agreements 671
Other 1 208
Total $16809
By Expense Category
(includes below-the-line adjustments)
($ in millions)
Payroll $5392
Overtime 811
Health amp Welfare 2129
Pension 1354
Other Labor 400
Total Labor $10086
Non-Labor 4205
Debt Service 2692
BTL Adjustments for Expenses (251)
Total $16732
Page 15: MTA 2020 Preliminary Budget July Financial Plan 2020 - 2023 2020 Preliminar… · 1 The MTA Budget Process July Plan – Start of the Annual Process • Current year is revised (the

14

2020 Preliminary BudgetWhere the Dollars Come Fromhellip Where the Dollars Gohellip

Farebox Revenue $6389Toll Revenue 2121 Other Revenue 684 Taxes 6178 State and Local amp Other 557 Other Funding Agreements 671 Other 1 208 Total $16809

($ in millions)

By Revenue Source(includes faretoll increases)

Payroll $5422Overtime 838 Health amp Welfare 2118 Pension 1461 Other Labor 466 Total Labor $10306Non-Labor + Other Exp Adj 4004 Debt Service 2830 BTL Adjustments for Expenses 2 (386) Total $16754

By Expense Category

($ in millions)(includes below-the-line adjustments)

1 Includes cash adjustments and prior-year carryover

Farebox Revenue

38

Toll Revenue

13

Other Revenue4

Taxes37

State amp Local

Subsidies3

Other Funding Agreements

4 Other 1

Payroll32

Overtime5

Health ampWelfare

13Pension

9

Other Labor3

Non-Labor + Other Exp Adj

21

Debt Service17

2 The below-the-line adjustments are grouped in the Non-Labor category

Sheet1

Sheet1

15

Non-Reimbursable Mid-Year Preliminary Actual Forecast Budget

2018 2019 2020 2021 2022 2023 Operating Revenues

Farebox Revenue $6155 $6305 $6389 $6373 $6384 $6393Toll Revenue 1976 2088 2121 2129 2129 2131 Other Revenue 643 696 684 704 719 737

Total Operating Revenue $8774 $9089 $9195 $9206 $9232 $9260

Total Subsidies $7177 $7314 $7406 $7581 $7803 $7969Dedicated Taxes as a of Total Revenues + Subs - PMT 233 $0 $0 $0 $0 $0

Total Revenues + Subsidies $15951 $16403 $16601 $16787 $17035 $17229

Operating ExpensesLabor Expenses $9799 $10116 $10306 $10592 $10881 $11121Non-Labor Expenses 3611 3877 3748 3841 3945 4054 Other 129 175 86 36 22 23 General Reserve 0 165 170 175 180 185

Total Operating Expenses $13539 $14333 $14310 $14644 $15028 $15384

Debt Service Expenses $2541 $2683 $2830 $3041 $3265 $3513

Total Expenses + Debt Service $16079 $17016 $17140 $17685 $18293 $18896

Conversion to Cash Basis 379 229 147 60 125 101

Baseline Net Cash Balance Before B-T-L Adjustments $251 ($384) ($392) ($838) ($1133) ($1566)

Total Below-the-Line Adjustments $0 $73 $386 $757 $852 $1133Prior Year Carryover 121 372 61 55 0 0

NET CASH BALANCE $372 $61 $55 ($26) ($281) ($433)

MTA July Financial Plan 2020-2023Consolidated Statement Of Operations By Category ($ in millions)

Summ Stmt of Ops-Feb

Summ Stmt of Ops-Jul

  • MTA 2020Preliminary BudgetJuly Financial Plan2020 - 2023
  • The MTA Budget Process
  • Slide Number 3
  • Slide Number 4
  • What has changed since the February Plan
  • Highlights of the July Plan
  • Slide Number 7
  • MTA Transformation Plan
  • Slide Number 9
  • Actions to Reduce Fare Evasion $62 million Investment over the Plan Period
  • The MTArsquos $350 million target for annually recurring savings beginning in 2020 has been identified and is being implemented
  • We have a track record of identifying and achieving our annual recurring savings targets
  • Deficits remain and a continued drive toward further streamlining and efficiencies is required
  • Slide Number 14
  • 2020 Preliminary Budget
  • Slide Number 16
MTA July Financial Plan 2020-2023
Consolidated Statement Of Operations By Category ($ in millions)
Non-Reimbursable Mid-Year Preliminary
Actual Actual Actual Actual Actual Actual Actual Actual Actual Actual Forecast Budget
2008 2009 2010 2011 2012 2013 2014 2015 2016 2018 2019 2020 2021 2022 2023 2023 2024 2025 2026
Operating Revenues
Farebox Revenue $4240923 $4350411 $4586377 $4999186 $5079138 $5501274 $5709200 $5961129 $6050182 $6155 $6305 $6389 $6373 $6384 $6393 $6174 $6435176 $6431979 $6446633
422 423 405 411 402 399 395 396 396 386 384 385 380 375 371 261 368 363 362
Student Fare - 0 - 0 - 0 - 0 - 0 - 0
Toll Revenue 1273974 1332115 1417046 1501589 1490982 1645193 1676445 1808901 1869693 1976 2088 2121 2129 2129 2131 2002 2133050 2137871 2143111
0127 0129 0125 0124 0118 0119 0116 0120 0122 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0122 0121 0120
Other Revenue 448616 461359 491355 510231 563839 753675 682424 689217 688374 643 696 684 704 719 737 755 825040 885381 887190
Capital and Other Reimbursements 0000 0000 0000 0000 0000 0000 0000 0000 0000 0000 0000 0000 0000 0000 0000 0000 0000 0000 0000
Total Operating Revenue $5963512 $6143885 $6494778 $7011006 $7133959 $7900142 $8068069 $8459247 $8608249 $8774 $9089 $9195 $9206 $9232 $9260 $8931 $9393266 $9455232 $9476934
Dedicated Taxes $3211585 $2366805 $2343537 $2511691 $2673119 $3097640 $3383498 $3582628 $3525829 $3257508 $3459 $3515 $3568 $3630 $3725 $3812 $3841433 $3880226 $3917215
PMT amp MTA Aid - 0 881784 1588677 1718286 1825824 1825328 1885069 1910947 1970760 1987035 $1965 $2152 $2225 $2295 $2368 $2442 2516095 2594604 2677041
New Funding Sources - 0 - 0 - 0 - 0 - 0 - 0 - 0 - 0 - 0 - 0 $508 $342 $385 $385 $385 $385 385000 385000 385000
StateLocal Taxes 556691 539046 544810 541733 536182 537527 539545 537819 537645 541005 $544 $552 $557 $562 $567 $572 576828 581933 583214
Other Funding Agreements 306594 363823 359489 375369 466625 432617 567391 563616 629855 630218 $701 $753 $671 $708 $758 $758 784755 804901 781159
BampT Operating Surplus Transfer 382565 363092 476059 554903 476575 614210 637553 750717 742909 740144 $702 $721 $782 $801 $789 $707 730476 695303 688833
Dedicated Taxes and StateLocal Subsidies $4457434 $4514550 $5312572 $5701982 $5978325 $6507322 $7013056 $7345727 $7406998 $7155909 $7879 $8035 $8188 $8381 $8592 $8676 $8834588 $8941967 $9032462
$0000 $0000 $0000 $0000 $0000 $0000 $0000 $0000 $0000
Less Interagency Subsidy and Surplus Transfers (382565) (363092) (476059) (554903) (476575) (614210) (637553) (750717) (742909) (740144) ($702) ($721) ($782) ($801) ($789) ($707) (730476) (695303) (688833)
Total Subsidies $4074870 $4151458 $4836513 $5147079 $5501750 $5893111 $6375503 $6595010 $6664088 $7177 $7314 $7406 $7581 $7803 $7969 $7969 $8104112 $8246664 $8343629
Dedicated Taxes as a of Total Revenues + Subs - PMT 320 251 241 241 247 259 269 273 265 233 $0 $0 $0 $0 $0 $0 256 257 259
Total Revenues + Subsidies $10038382 $10295342 $11331292 $12158085 $12635709 $13793254 $14443571 $15054257 $15272337 $15951 $16403 $16601 $16787 $17035 $17229 $16900 $17497378 $17701896 $17820563
Operating Expenses
Labor Expenses
Payroll $4087376 $4163330 $4171374 $4160261 $4193658 $4332829 $4671664 $4695823 $4838741 $5020713 $5211 $5328 $5422 $5498 $5624 $5710 $5860206 $5982960 $6107107
Overtime 471675 499307 443227 538647 574316 620701 730200 755071 771495 934100 $1066 $910 $838 $859 $877 $899 917296 935002 951324
Health amp Welfare 684945 688899 738189 809638 812857 895714 961902 1050100 1172304 1208786 $1230 $1341 $1414 $1489 $1583 $1674 1797938 1922668 2071273
OPEB Current Payment 318501 346316 355716 394218 413164 472619 479079 501716 562233 563754 $604 $645 $704 $766 $835 $910 982025 1060022 1142795
Pensions 897450 1021229 1029710 1074598 1328441 1301975 1304355 1248726 1370474 1345308 $1336 $1494 $1461 $1462 $1403 $1347 1357887 1369071 1380572
Other-Fringe Benefits 502739 517194 539996 581661 650430 694680 784143 861079 947870 792151 $881 $869 $897 $930 $956 $976 1001185 1021007 1040170
Reimbursable Overhead (310555) (322230) (345154) (324006) (309399) (321390) (349770) (380212) (423759) (491807) ($528) ($471) ($430) ($412) ($397) ($395) (396136) (405509) (413165)
Labor Expenses $6652131 $6914045 $6933059 $7235017 $7663467 $7997128 $8581574 $8732302 $9239358 $9799 $10116 $10306 $10592 $10881 $11121 $11413 $11520401 $11885220 $12280075
PayrollOvertime Exp as a of Total Operating+DS $0426 $0427 $0407 $0396 $0387 $0374 $0389 $0383 $0376 $0390 $0367 $0365 $0359 $0355 $0350 $0349 $0347 $0345
Labor Exp (wo Reimb OH) as a of Total Oper+DS $0650 $0663 $0642 $0637 $0647 $0628 $0643 $0640 $0648 $0642 $0622 $0626 $0622 $0616 $0609 $0614 $0617 $0620
PayrollOvertime Exp as a of Total Operating Exp $0496 $0490 $0483 $0473 $0465 $0453 $0464 $0459 $0450 $0464 $0435 $0438 $0434 $0433 $0430 $0426 $0420 $0416
Labor Exp (wo Reimb OH) as a of Total Oper Exp $0758 $0761 $0762 $0761 $0777 $0761 $0768 $0768 $0776 $0763 $0739 $0750 $0751 $0750 $0749 $0748 $0747 $0747
Non-Labor Expenses
Electric Power $306500 $317934 $325137 $457269 $471514 $493346 $515540 $473762 $406372 $481893 $451503 $473177 $493090 $532413 $561955 $571182 $589565 $618283 $648255
Traction Power
Non-Traction Power
Fuel 287033 180294 189942 282735 251763 259252 267494 162283 124684 185203 182778 182981 176333 173681 176920 182259 182476 184281 186170
Revenue Vehicle Fuel
Non-Revenue Fuel
Insurance 28902 34012 9819 14363 7617 38654 50739 57190 (20634) (29402) 5608 15623 23118 26855 28309 36048 28232 25538 19483
Claims 152114 238104 285418 315547 135652 299875 269167 331023 463959 437985 387557 394211 392547 398256 406112 404397 417667 428660 437683
Paratransit Service Contracts 299013 370094 379761 348553 360500 366751 365599 379271 383704 455471 494751 488330 505538 535329 568614 581114 604766 643217 684112
Maintenance and Other Operating Contracts 594215 562456 541716 451137 451766 496743 549018 579289 630924 678425 840168 797428 833534 836606 854471 879468 880053 898882 915477
Professional Service Contracts 196930 199164 203084 226205 276998 297201 283005 379814 399706 543582 607838 502858 494814 504103 513895 499724 520826 537109 547291
Materials amp Supplies 532534 526191 511206 438310 430804 475127 526725 543225 585607 637078 689010 679895 697976 711281 715758 711988 741335 777460 793419
Other Business Expenses 155466 184142 189637 169857 143807 167198 179701 195598 192576 220838 218196 213551 224459 226170 228457 244907 228861 240258 241690
Non-Labor Expenses $2552708 $2612391 $2635720 $2703976 $2530421 $2894147 $3006988 $3101454 $3166897 3611 3877 3748 3841 3945 4054 4111 $4193782 $4353689 $4473580
Other Expense Adjustments
Other ($13712) ($14750) ($18292) ($2289) $62593 $46175 $44973 $37007 $47404 129 175 86 36 22 23 23 $23516 $24069 $24637
General Reserve 0000 0000 0000 0000 0000 - 0 - 0 - 0 - 0 0 165 170 175 180 185 185 190000 195000 205000
Other Expense Adjustments ($13712) ($14750) ($18292) ($2289) $62593 $46175 $44973 $37007 $47404 $128555 $340 $256 $211 $202 $208 $208 $213516 $219069 $229637
Gap Closing Expenses $7675394
Additional Actions for Budget Balance Expense Impact $0000 $0000 $0000 $0000 $0000 $0000 $0000 $0000 $0000 $0000 $0000 $0000 $0000 $0000 $0000 $0000 $0000 $0000 $0000
Total Operating Expenses Before Non-Cash Liability Adjs $9191127 $9511685 $9550486 $9936705 $10256481 $10937450 $11633535 $11870763 $12453659 $13538830 $14332772 $14309678 $14643965 $15027767 $15383584 $15732241 $15927699 $16457978 $16983292
Non-Cash Liability Adjustments
Depreciation $1790981 $1940576 $1980681 $2019378 $2148820 $2174302 $2266280 $2442777 $2442941 $2607970 $2804571 $2784812 $2842737 $2908533 $2977025 $3051834 $3109882 $3169371 $3230301
OPEB Obligation 1348962 1104827 1167070 1706939 1785881 1920189 2035457 1489656 1562261 1567381 0000 (0000) (0000) (0000) (0000) 0000 0000 (0000) (0000)
GASB 75 OPEB Expense Adjustment 0000 0000 0000 0000 0000 0000 0000 0000 0000 0000 1047747 1457230 1628196 1748560 1823313 1898497 1952374 2006482 2061993
GASB 68 Pension Expense Adjustment 0000 0000 0000 0000 0000 0000 0000 (410019) (218911) (168119) (373022) (220864) (271921) (342847) (318372) (242446) (237864) (234492) (230942)
Environmental Remediation 42249 6062 18621 59079 24742 14257 20556 20576 11691 13468 105615 6000 6000 6000 6000 6000 6000 6000 6000
Non-Cash Liability Adjustments $3182192 $3051466 $3166371 $3785396 $3959443 $4108749 $4322293 $3542990 $3797981 $4020699 $3584911 $4027178 $4205012 $4320246 $4487966 $4713886 $4830392 $4947361 $5067352
Total Operating Expenses After Non-Cash Liability Adjs $12373319 $12563151 $12716857 $13722101 $14215924 $15046199 $15955827 $15413753 $16251641 $17559529 $17917683 $18336856 $18848977 $19348013 $19871550 $20446127 $20758090 $21405338 $22050644
Less BampT Depreciation $77213 $80097 $77846 $86545 $87926 $91345 $104039 $109783 $135035 $240957 $148686 $151977 $158779 $169848 $181689 $194355 $194355 $194355 $194355
BampT Other Post Employment Benefits 66323 50967 54831 66686 73055 76641 71148 62457 60441 78106 32297 22256 20303 22870 28694 33918 36169 38411 40604
Net Operating Deficit Before Subsidies and Debt Service ($6409807) ($6419266) ($6222079) ($6711095) ($7081966) ($7146057) ($7887759) ($6954506) ($7643392) ($8785339) ($8829030) ($9141907) ($9642826) ($10116260) ($10611154) ($11515498) ($11364824) ($11950106) ($12573710)
Conversion to Cash Basis Non-Cash Liability Adjs ($3182192) ($3051466) ($3166371) ($3785396) ($3959443) ($4108749) ($4322293) ($3542990) ($3797981) ($4020699) ($3584911) ($4027178) ($4205012) ($4320246) ($4487966) ($4713886) ($4830392) ($4947361) ($5067352)
Total Operating Expenses $9191127 $9511685 $9550486 $9936705 $10256481 $10937450 $11633535 $11870763 $12453659 $13539 $14333 $14310 $14644 $15028 $15384 $15732 $15927699 $16457978 $16983292
Debt Service Expenses $1515733 $1404454 $1781220 $1933532 $2058395 $2299262 $2248538 $2373321 $2458783 $2541 $2683 $2830 $3041 $3265 $3513 $3450 $3471321 $3472987 $3501639
Total Expenses + Debt Service $10706859 $10916139 $11331706 $11870237 $12314876 $13236712 $13882073 $14244084 $14912443 $16079 $17016 $17140 $17685 $18293 $18896 $19182 $19399019 $19930965 $20484932
Net Deficit After Subsidies and Debt Service ($668477) ($620796) ($0414) $287848 $320833 $556541 $561498 $810173 $359895 ($128044) ($613) ($539) ($898) ($1258) ($1667) ($2283) ($1901641) ($2229069) ($2664369)
Conversion to Cash Basis GASB Account (56067) (54256) (67377) (37636) (89548) (85641) (50017) - 0 - 0 0 0 0 $0 0 0 - 0 - 0 - 0 - 0
Conversion to Cash Basis 492710 550267 91781 (111037) (297407) (261709) (626297) (660147) (591809) 379 229 147 60 125 101 130 49745 48375 54220
Net Cash Balance from Previous Year 0000 0000 0000 23990 139174 0000 209191 0000 150026 0000 250569 0000 0000 0000 0000 0000 0000 0000 0000
Total Operating Exp + DS + Cash Conversions + PY C-O $11144 $11412 $11356 $11746 $12067 $12889362 $13414950 $13583937 $14470659 $16457999 $17495351 $17286526 $17744425 $18418197 $18997710 $19312017 $19448764 $19979340 $20539152
Total Operating Expenses with Cash Conversion $10270216 $10420127 $11307302 $12018911 $12701831 $13584063 $14558387 $14904231 $15504252 $15700774 $16786574 $16992579 $17624861 $18167420 $18795069 $19052755 $19349274 $19882590 $20430711
Baseline Net Cash Balance Before B-T-L Adjustments ($231834) ($124785) $23990 $139174 ($66122) $209191 ($114816) $150026 ($231914) $251 ($384) ($392) ($838) ($1133) ($1566) ($2153) ($1851896) ($2180695) ($2610148)
Below-the-Line Adjustments
FareToll Increases
FareToll Increase in March 2019 (4 Yield) - 0 $0 $0 $0 $0 $0 $0 - 0 - 0 - 0
FareToll Increase in March 2021 (4 Yield) - 0 $0 $0 $0 $283 $331 $332 333531 333568 334299
FareToll Increase in March 2023 (4 Yield) - 0 $0 $0 $0 $0 $0 $294 346386 346424 347183
FareToll Increase in March 2025 (4 Yield) - 0 $0 $0 $0 $0 $0 $0 - 0 273859 321624
Subsidy Impacts of 20212023 FareToll Increase - 0 $0 $0 $0 ($7) ($9) ($17) (18612) (25573) (26305)
$0000 $0 $0 $0 $275 $322 $609 $661306 $928278 $976801
CASH BALANCE AFTER FARE INCREASES $250569 ($384) ($392) ($838) ($850) ($1234) ($1821) ($1518365) ($1847127) ($2275849)
MTA Initiatives
MTA Efficiencies - Not Yet Implemented - 0 $0 $0 $0 $0 $0 $0 0000 0000 0000
0 - 0 $0 $0 $0 $0 $0 $0 - 0 - 0 - 0
0 - 0 $0 $0 $0 $0 $0 $0 - 0 - 0 - 0
$0000 $0 $0 $0 $0 $0 $0 $0000 $0000 $0000
Policy Actions
CAS Migration to Peoplesoft $0 $0 ($5) ($1) ($0) ($0) (0200) -02 -02 0
Fare Evasion Enforcement Strategy-Expenses $0 ($13) ($12) ($11) ($10) ($10) (9554) -9554483 -9554483 0
Fare Evasion Enforcement-Manhattan DA Forfeiture Fund $0 $11 $11 $10 $9 $0 - 0 0 0 0
Negotiated 1 CBA Reform $0 $0 $0 $0 $0 $0 - 0 0 0 0
MTA Reorganization $0 $8 $180 $371 $377 $377 377000 377 377 0
MTA Reorganization Costs $0 $0 ($10) ($27) ($2) $0 - 0 0 0 0
Drawdown 2019 General Reserve $0 $0 $165 $0 $0 $0 - 0 0 0 0
CBA Negotiated Reform - 1 Value $0 $36 $100 $173 $246 $323 323473 323473304484 323473304484 0
$0000 $0 $42 $429 $515 $620 $691 $690719 $690719 $690719
MTA Re-estimates
Additional Savings Actions $0000 $0 $0 $0 $0 $0 $0 $0000 $0000 $0000
Total Below-the-Line Adjustments $0 $73 $386 $757 $852 $1133 $1007 $1352025 $1618997 $1667520
Prior Year Carryover 495399 263336 138286 161986 301160 235038 444229 329413 479439 121 372 61 55 0 0 - 0 - 0 - 0 - 0
NET CASH BALANCE $263566 $138551 $162276 $301160 $235038 $444229 $329413 $479439 $247525 $372 $61 $55 ($26) ($281) ($433) ($1146) ($499871) ($561698) ($942628)
MTA February Financial Plan 2019-2022
Consolidated Statement Of Operations By Category ($ in millions)
Non-Reimbursable Final Adopted
Actual Actual Actual Actual Actual Actual Actual Actual Actual Actual Estimate Budget
2008 2009 2010 2011 2012 2013 2014 2015 2016 2017 2018 2019 2020 2021 2022 2023 2024 2025 2026
Operating Revenues
Farebox Revenue $4240923 $4350411 $4586377 $4999186 $5079138 $5501274 $5709200 $5961129 $6050182 $6172 $6153 $6122 $6144 $6134 $6144 $6174 $6435176 $6431979 $6446633
422 423 405 411 402 399 395 396 396 407 279 275 272 267 263 261 368 363 362
Student Fare - 0 - 0 - 0 - 0 - 0 - 0
Toll Revenue 1273974 1332115 1417046 1501589 1490982 1645193 1676445 1808901 1869693 1912 1967 1984 1990 1998 1998 2002 2133050 2137871 2143111
0127 0129 0125 0124 0118 0119 0116 0120 0122 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0122 0121 0120
Other Revenue 448616 461359 491355 510231 563839 753675 682424 689217 688374 653 662 705 733 757 743 755 825040 885381 887190
Capital and Other Reimbursements 0000 0000 0000 0000 0000 0000 0000 0000 0000 0000 0000 0000 0000 0000 0000 0000 0000 0000 0000
Total Operating Revenue $5963512 $6143885 $6494778 $7011006 $7133959 $7900142 $8068069 $8459247 $8608249 $8737 $8782 $8810 $8867 $8889 $8886 $8931 $9393266 $9455232 $9476934
Dedicated Taxes $3211585 $2366805 $2343537 $2511691 $2673119 $3097640 $3383498 $3582628 $3525829 $3257508 $3459 $3515 $3568 $3630 $3725 $3812 $3841433 $3880226 $3917215
PMT amp MTA Aid - 0 881784 1588677 1718286 1825824 1825328 1885069 1910947 1970760 1987035 $1965 $2152 $2225 $2295 $2368 $2442 2516095 2594604 2677041
New Funding Sources - 0 - 0 - 0 - 0 - 0 - 0 - 0 - 0 - 0 - 0 $508 $342 $385 $385 $385 $385 385000 385000 385000
StateLocal Taxes 556691 539046 544810 541733 536182 537527 539545 537819 537645 541005 $544 $552 $557 $562 $567 $572 576828 581933 583214
Other Funding Agreements 306594 363823 359489 375369 466625 432617 567391 563616 629855 630218 $701 $753 $671 $708 $758 $758 784755 804901 781159
BampT Operating Surplus Transfer 382565 363092 476059 554903 476575 614210 637553 750717 742909 740144 $702 $721 $782 $801 $789 $707 730476 695303 688833
Dedicated Taxes and StateLocal Subsidies $4457434 $4514550 $5312572 $5701982 $5978325 $6507322 $7013056 $7345727 $7406998 $7155909 $7879 $8035 $8188 $8381 $8592 $8676 $8834588 $8941967 $9032462
$0000 $0000 $0000 $0000 $0000 $0000 $0000 $0000 $0000
Less Interagency Subsidy and Surplus Transfers (382565) (363092) (476059) (554903) (476575) (614210) (637553) (750717) (742909) (740144) ($702) ($721) ($782) ($801) ($789) ($707) (730476) (695303) (688833)
Total Subsidies $4074870 $4151458 $4836513 $5147079 $5501750 $5893111 $6375503 $6595010 $6664088 $6416 $7242 $7238 $7370 $7576 $7807 $7969 $8104112 $8246664 $8343629
Dedicated Taxes as a of Total Revenues + Subs - PMT 320 251 241 241 247 259 269 273 265 247 $0 $0 $0 $0 $0 $0 256 257 259
Total Revenues + Subsidies $10038382 $10295342 $11331292 $12158085 $12635709 $13793254 $14443571 $15054257 $15272337 $15152 $16023 $16048 $16237 $16465 $16693 $16900 $17497378 $17701896 $17820563
Operating Expenses
Labor Expenses
Payroll $4087376 $4163330 $4171374 $4160261 $4193658 $4332829 $4671664 $4695823 $4838741 $5020713 $5211 $5328 $5422 $5498 $5624 $5710 $5860206 $5982960 $6107107
Overtime 471675 499307 443227 538647 574316 620701 730200 755071 771495 934100 $1066 $910 $838 $859 $877 $899 917296 935002 951324
Health amp Welfare 684945 688899 738189 809638 812857 895714 961902 1050100 1172304 1208786 $1230 $1341 $1414 $1489 $1583 $1674 1797938 1922668 2071273
OPEB Current Payment 318501 346316 355716 394218 413164 472619 479079 501716 562233 563754 $604 $645 $704 $766 $835 $910 982025 1060022 1142795
Pensions 897450 1021229 1029710 1074598 1328441 1301975 1304355 1248726 1370474 1345308 $1336 $1494 $1461 $1462 $1403 $1347 1357887 1369071 1380572
Other-Fringe Benefits 502739 517194 539996 581661 650430 694680 784143 861079 947870 792151 $881 $869 $897 $930 $956 $976 1001185 1021007 1040170
Reimbursable Overhead (310555) (322230) (345154) (324006) (309399) (321390) (349770) (380212) (423759) (491807) ($528) ($471) ($430) ($412) ($397) ($395) (396136) (405509) (413165)
Labor Expenses $6652131 $6914045 $6933059 $7235017 $7663467 $7997128 $8581574 $8732302 $9239358 $9373 $9920 $10039 $10436 $10787 $11097 $11413 $11520401 $11885220 $12280075
PayrollOvertime Exp as a of Total Operating+DS $0426 $0427 $0407 $0396 $0387 $0374 $0389 $0383 $0376 $0385 $0349 $0347 $0345
Labor Exp (wo Reimb OH) as a of Total Oper+DS $0650 $0663 $0642 $0637 $0647 $0628 $0643 $0640 $0648 $0638 $0614 $0617 $0620
PayrollOvertime Exp as a of Total Operating Exp $0496 $0490 $0483 $0473 $0465 $0453 $0464 $0459 $0450 $0461 $0426 $0420 $0416
Labor Exp (wo Reimb OH) as a of Total Oper Exp $0758 $0761 $0762 $0761 $0777 $0761 $0768 $0768 $0776 $0763 $0748 $0747 $0747
Non-Labor Expenses
Electric Power $306500 $317934 $325137 $457269 $471514 $493346 $515540 $473762 $406372 $430381 $474918 $451304 $463523 $482662 $539624 $571182 $589565 $618283 $648255
Traction Power
Non-Traction Power
Fuel 287033 180294 189942 282735 251763 259252 267494 162283 124684 150481 185580 190348 187592 183168 181484 182259 182476 184281 186170
Revenue Vehicle Fuel
Non-Revenue Fuel
Insurance 28902 34012 9819 14363 7617 38654 50739 57190 (20634) (2715) 11488 8532 15803 22918 29411 36048 28232 25538 19483
Claims 152114 238104 285418 315547 135652 299875 269167 331023 463959 526053 376480 378570 386981 391333 395228 404397 417667 428660 437683
Paratransit Service Contracts 299013 370094 379761 348553 360500 366751 365599 379271 383704 392850 452190 482751 501230 518038 547829 581114 604766 643217 684112
Maintenance and Other Operating Contracts 594215 562456 541716 451137 451766 496743 549018 579289 630924 695251 779331 897801 833038 883805 871671 879468 880053 898882 915477
Professional Service Contracts 196930 199164 203084 226205 276998 297201 283005 379814 399706 507062 575742 557476 484911 479376 489510 499724 520826 537109 547291
Materials amp Supplies 532534 526191 511206 438310 430804 475127 526725 543225 585607 588115 667700 686666 687745 692131 697268 711988 741335 777460 793419
Other Business Expenses 155466 184142 189637 169857 143807 167198 179701 195598 192576 217254 225494 230595 225293 240279 242193 244907 228861 240258 241690
Non-Labor Expenses $2552708 $2612391 $2635720 $2703976 $2530421 $2894147 $3006988 $3101454 $3166897 3505 3749 3884 3786 3894 3994 4111 $4193782 $4353689 $4473580
Other Expense Adjustments
Other ($13712) ($14750) ($18292) ($2289) $62593 $46175 $44973 $37007 $47404 49 134 158 84 36 22 23 $23516 $24069 $24637
General Reserve 0000 0000 0000 0000 0000 - 0 - 0 - 0 - 0 0 0 165 170 175 180 185 190000 195000 205000
Other Expense Adjustments ($13712) ($14750) ($18292) ($2289) $62593 $46175 $44973 $37007 $47404 $49379 $134 $323 $254 $211 $202 $208 $213516 $219069 $229637
Gap Closing Expenses $7675394
Additional Actions for Budget Balance Expense Impact $0000 $0000 $0000 $0000 $0000 $0000 $0000 $0000 $0000 $0000 $0000 $0000 $0000 $0000 $0000 $0000 $0000 $0000 $0000
Total Operating Expenses Before Non-Cash Liability Adjs $9191127 $9511685 $9550486 $9936705 $10256481 $10937450 $11633535 $11870763 $12453659 $12927116 $13802910 $14246122 $14475644 $14891445 $15293262 $15732241 $15927699 $16457978 $16983292
Non-Cash Liability Adjustments
Depreciation $1790981 $1940576 $1980681 $2019378 $2148820 $2174302 $2266280 $2442777 $2442941 $2607970 $2804571 $2784812 $2842737 $2908533 $2977025 $3051834 $3109882 $3169371 $3230301
OPEB Obligation 1348962 1104827 1167070 1706939 1785881 1920189 2035457 1489656 1562261 1567381 0000 (0000) (0000) (0000) (0000) 0000 0000 (0000) (0000)
GASB 75 OPEB Expense Adjustment 0000 0000 0000 0000 0000 0000 0000 0000 0000 0000 1047747 1457230 1628196 1748560 1823313 1898497 1952374 2006482 2061993
GASB 68 Pension Expense Adjustment 0000 0000 0000 0000 0000 0000 0000 (410019) (218911) (168119) (373022) (220864) (271921) (342847) (318372) (242446) (237864) (234492) (230942)
Environmental Remediation 42249 6062 18621 59079 24742 14257 20556 20576 11691 13468 105615 6000 6000 6000 6000 6000 6000 6000 6000
Non-Cash Liability Adjustments $3182192 $3051466 $3166371 $3785396 $3959443 $4108749 $4322293 $3542990 $3797981 $4020699 $3584911 $4027178 $4205012 $4320246 $4487966 $4713886 $4830392 $4947361 $5067352
Total Operating Expenses After Non-Cash Liability Adjs $12373319 $12563151 $12716857 $13722101 $14215924 $15046199 $15955827 $15413753 $16251641 $16947815 $17387821 $18273301 $18680657 $19211690 $19781228 $20446127 $20758090 $21405338 $22050644
Less BampT Depreciation $77213 $80097 $77846 $86545 $87926 $91345 $104039 $109783 $135035 $240957 $148686 $151977 $158779 $169848 $181689 $194355 $194355 $194355 $194355
BampT Other Post Employment Benefits 66323 50967 54831 66686 73055 76641 71148 62457 60441 78106 32297 22256 20303 22870 28694 33918 36169 38411 40604
Net Operating Deficit Before Subsidies and Debt Service ($6409807) ($6419266) ($6222079) ($6711095) ($7081966) ($7146057) ($7887759) ($6954506) ($7643392) ($8211234) ($8606220) ($9463506) ($9813560) ($10322912) ($10895644) ($11515498) ($11364824) ($11950106) ($12573710)
Conversion to Cash Basis Non-Cash Liability Adjs ($3182192) ($3051466) ($3166371) ($3785396) ($3959443) ($4108749) ($4322293) ($3542990) ($3797981) ($4020699) ($3584911) ($4027178) ($4205012) ($4320246) ($4487966) ($4713886) ($4830392) ($4947361) ($5067352)
Total Operating Expenses $9191127 $9511685 $9550486 $9936705 $10256481 $10937450 $11633535 $11870763 $12453659 $12927 $13803 $14246 $14476 $14891 $15293 $15732 $15927699 $16457978 $16983292
Debt Service Expenses $1515733 $1404454 $1781220 $1933532 $2058395 $2299262 $2248538 $2373321 $2458783 $2525 $2559 $2692 $2840 $3080 $3223 $3450 $3471321 $3472987 $3501639
Total Expenses + Debt Service $10706859 $10916139 $11331706 $11870237 $12314876 $13236712 $13882073 $14244084 $14912443 $15452 $16362 $16938 $17316 $17971 $18516 $19182 $19399019 $19930965 $20484932
Net Deficit After Subsidies and Debt Service ($668477) ($620796) ($0414) $287848 $320833 $556541 $561498 $810173 $359895 ($299965) ($339) ($890) ($1079) ($1506) ($1823) ($2283) ($1901641) ($2229069) ($2664369)
Conversion to Cash Basis GASB Account (56067) (54256) (67377) (37636) (89548) (85641) (50017) - 0 - 0 0 0 0 $0 0 0 - 0 - 0 - 0 - 0
Conversion to Cash Basis 492710 550267 91781 (111037) (297407) (261709) (626297) (660147) (591809) 174 296 363 188 (17) 88 130 49745 48375 54220
Net Cash Balance from Previous Year 0000 0000 0000 23990 139174 0000 209191 0000 150026 0000 0000 0000 0000 0000 0000 0000 0000 0000 0000
Total Operating Exp + DS + Cash Conversions + PY C-O $11144 $11412 $11356 $11746 $12067 $12889362 $13414950 $13583937 $14470659 $15625875 $16658585 $17300293 $17504155 $17954574 $18604130 $19312017 $19448764 $19979340 $20539152
Total Operating Expenses with Cash Conversion $10270216 $10420127 $11307302 $12018911 $12701831 $13584063 $14558387 $14904231 $15504252 $15278749 $16065734 $16575223 $17128079 $17987951 $18427778 $19052755 $19349274 $19882590 $20430711
Baseline Net Cash Balance Before B-T-L Adjustments ($231834) ($124785) $23990 $139174 ($66122) $209191 ($114816) $150026 ($231914) ($126) ($43) ($527) ($891) ($1523) ($1735) ($2153) ($1851896) ($2180695) ($2610148)
Below-the-Line Adjustments
FareToll Increases
FareToll Increase in March 2019 (4 Yield) - 0 $0 $0 $0 $0 $0 $0 - 0 - 0 - 0
FareToll Increase in March 2021 (4 Yield) - 0 $0 $0 $0 $283 $331 $332 333531 333568 334299
FareToll Increase in March 2023 (4 Yield) - 0 $0 $0 $0 $0 $0 $294 346386 346424 347183
FareToll Increase in March 2025 (4 Yield) - 0 $0 $0 $0 $0 $0 $0 - 0 273859 321624
Subsidy Impacts of 20212023 FareToll Increase - 0 $0 $0 $0 ($7) ($9) ($17) (18612) (25573) (26305)
$0000 $0 $0 $0 $275 $322 $609 $661306 $928278 $976801
CASH BALANCE AFTER FARE INCREASES ($126402) ($43) ($527) ($891) ($1241) ($1404) ($1821) ($1518365) ($1847127) ($2275849)
MTA Initiatives
MTA Efficiencies - Not Yet Implemented - 0 $0 $0 $0 $0 $0 $0 0000 0000 0000
0 - 0 $0 $0 $0 $0 $0 $0 - 0 - 0 - 0
0 - 0 $0 $0 $0 $0 $0 $0 - 0 - 0 - 0
$0000 $0 $0 $0 $0 $0 $0 $0000 $0000 $0000
Policy Actions
CAS Migration to Peoplesoft $0 $0 ($5) ($1) ($0) ($0) (0200) -02 -02 0
Fare Evasion Enforcement Strategy-Expenses $0 ($13) ($12) ($11) ($10) ($10) (9554) -9554483 -9554483 0
Fare Evasion Enforcement-Manhattan DA Forfeiture Fund $0 $11 $11 $10 $9 $0 - 0 0 0 0
Negotiated 1 CBA Reform $0 $0 $0 $0 $0 $0 - 0 0 0 0
MTA Reorganization $0 $8 $180 $371 $377 $377 377000 377 377 0
MTA Reorganization Costs $0 $0 ($10) ($27) ($2) $0 - 0 0 0 0
Drawdown 2019 General Reserve $0 $0 $165 $0 $0 $0 - 0 0 0 0
CBA Negotiated Reform - 1 Value $0 $36 $100 $173 $246 $323 323473 323473304484 323473304484 0
$0000 $0 $42 $429 $515 $620 $691 $690719 $690719 $690719
MTA Re-estimates
Additional Savings Actions $0000 $0 $0 $0 $0 $0 $0 $0000 $0000 $0000
Total Below-the-Line Adjustments $0 $0 $459 $413 $709 $760 $1007 $1352025 $1618997 $1667520
Prior Year Carryover 495399 263336 138286 161986 301160 235038 444229 329413 479439 248 121 79 11 0 0 - 0 - 0 - 0 - 0
NET CASH BALANCE $263566 $138551 $162276 $301160 $235038 $444229 $329413 $479439 $247525 $121 $79 $11 ($467) ($814) ($976) ($1146) ($499871) ($561698) ($942628)
By Revenue Source
(includes faretoll increases)
($ in millions)
Farebox Revenue $6389
Toll Revenue 2121
Other Revenue 684
Dedicated Taxes 6191
State and Local amp Other 1228
Timing (Cash Adjustments) 135
Total $16748
By Expense Category
(includes below-the-line adjustments)
($ in millions)
Payroll $5422
Overtime 838
Health amp Welfare 2118
Pension 1461
Other Labor 466
Total Labor $10306
Non-Labor + Other Exp Adj 4004
Debt Service 2830
BTL Adjustments for Expenses 2 (386)
Total $16754
By Revenue Source
(includes faretoll increases)
($ in millions)
Farebox Revenue $6389
Toll Revenue 2121
Other Revenue 684
Taxes 6178
State and Local amp Other 557
Other Funding Agreements 671
Other 1 208
Total $16809
By Expense Category
(includes below-the-line adjustments)
($ in millions)
Payroll $5392
Overtime 811
Health amp Welfare 2129
Pension 1354
Other Labor 400
Total Labor $10086
Non-Labor 4205
Debt Service 2692
BTL Adjustments for Expenses (251)
Total $16732
Page 16: MTA 2020 Preliminary Budget July Financial Plan 2020 - 2023 2020 Preliminar… · 1 The MTA Budget Process July Plan – Start of the Annual Process • Current year is revised (the

15

Non-Reimbursable Mid-Year Preliminary Actual Forecast Budget

2018 2019 2020 2021 2022 2023 Operating Revenues

Farebox Revenue $6155 $6305 $6389 $6373 $6384 $6393Toll Revenue 1976 2088 2121 2129 2129 2131 Other Revenue 643 696 684 704 719 737

Total Operating Revenue $8774 $9089 $9195 $9206 $9232 $9260

Total Subsidies $7177 $7314 $7406 $7581 $7803 $7969Dedicated Taxes as a of Total Revenues + Subs - PMT 233 $0 $0 $0 $0 $0

Total Revenues + Subsidies $15951 $16403 $16601 $16787 $17035 $17229

Operating ExpensesLabor Expenses $9799 $10116 $10306 $10592 $10881 $11121Non-Labor Expenses 3611 3877 3748 3841 3945 4054 Other 129 175 86 36 22 23 General Reserve 0 165 170 175 180 185

Total Operating Expenses $13539 $14333 $14310 $14644 $15028 $15384

Debt Service Expenses $2541 $2683 $2830 $3041 $3265 $3513

Total Expenses + Debt Service $16079 $17016 $17140 $17685 $18293 $18896

Conversion to Cash Basis 379 229 147 60 125 101

Baseline Net Cash Balance Before B-T-L Adjustments $251 ($384) ($392) ($838) ($1133) ($1566)

Total Below-the-Line Adjustments $0 $73 $386 $757 $852 $1133Prior Year Carryover 121 372 61 55 0 0

NET CASH BALANCE $372 $61 $55 ($26) ($281) ($433)

MTA July Financial Plan 2020-2023Consolidated Statement Of Operations By Category ($ in millions)

Summ Stmt of Ops-Feb

Summ Stmt of Ops-Jul

  • MTA 2020Preliminary BudgetJuly Financial Plan2020 - 2023
  • The MTA Budget Process
  • Slide Number 3
  • Slide Number 4
  • What has changed since the February Plan
  • Highlights of the July Plan
  • Slide Number 7
  • MTA Transformation Plan
  • Slide Number 9
  • Actions to Reduce Fare Evasion $62 million Investment over the Plan Period
  • The MTArsquos $350 million target for annually recurring savings beginning in 2020 has been identified and is being implemented
  • We have a track record of identifying and achieving our annual recurring savings targets
  • Deficits remain and a continued drive toward further streamlining and efficiencies is required
  • Slide Number 14
  • 2020 Preliminary Budget
  • Slide Number 16
MTA July Financial Plan 2020-2023
Consolidated Statement Of Operations By Category ($ in millions)
Non-Reimbursable Mid-Year Preliminary
Actual Actual Actual Actual Actual Actual Actual Actual Actual Actual Forecast Budget
2008 2009 2010 2011 2012 2013 2014 2015 2016 2018 2019 2020 2021 2022 2023 2023 2024 2025 2026
Operating Revenues
Farebox Revenue $4240923 $4350411 $4586377 $4999186 $5079138 $5501274 $5709200 $5961129 $6050182 $6155 $6305 $6389 $6373 $6384 $6393 $6174 $6435176 $6431979 $6446633
422 423 405 411 402 399 395 396 396 386 384 385 380 375 371 261 368 363 362
Student Fare - 0 - 0 - 0 - 0 - 0 - 0
Toll Revenue 1273974 1332115 1417046 1501589 1490982 1645193 1676445 1808901 1869693 1976 2088 2121 2129 2129 2131 2002 2133050 2137871 2143111
0127 0129 0125 0124 0118 0119 0116 0120 0122 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0122 0121 0120
Other Revenue 448616 461359 491355 510231 563839 753675 682424 689217 688374 643 696 684 704 719 737 755 825040 885381 887190
Capital and Other Reimbursements 0000 0000 0000 0000 0000 0000 0000 0000 0000 0000 0000 0000 0000 0000 0000 0000 0000 0000 0000
Total Operating Revenue $5963512 $6143885 $6494778 $7011006 $7133959 $7900142 $8068069 $8459247 $8608249 $8774 $9089 $9195 $9206 $9232 $9260 $8931 $9393266 $9455232 $9476934
Dedicated Taxes $3211585 $2366805 $2343537 $2511691 $2673119 $3097640 $3383498 $3582628 $3525829 $3257508 $3459 $3515 $3568 $3630 $3725 $3812 $3841433 $3880226 $3917215
PMT amp MTA Aid - 0 881784 1588677 1718286 1825824 1825328 1885069 1910947 1970760 1987035 $1965 $2152 $2225 $2295 $2368 $2442 2516095 2594604 2677041
New Funding Sources - 0 - 0 - 0 - 0 - 0 - 0 - 0 - 0 - 0 - 0 $508 $342 $385 $385 $385 $385 385000 385000 385000
StateLocal Taxes 556691 539046 544810 541733 536182 537527 539545 537819 537645 541005 $544 $552 $557 $562 $567 $572 576828 581933 583214
Other Funding Agreements 306594 363823 359489 375369 466625 432617 567391 563616 629855 630218 $701 $753 $671 $708 $758 $758 784755 804901 781159
BampT Operating Surplus Transfer 382565 363092 476059 554903 476575 614210 637553 750717 742909 740144 $702 $721 $782 $801 $789 $707 730476 695303 688833
Dedicated Taxes and StateLocal Subsidies $4457434 $4514550 $5312572 $5701982 $5978325 $6507322 $7013056 $7345727 $7406998 $7155909 $7879 $8035 $8188 $8381 $8592 $8676 $8834588 $8941967 $9032462
$0000 $0000 $0000 $0000 $0000 $0000 $0000 $0000 $0000
Less Interagency Subsidy and Surplus Transfers (382565) (363092) (476059) (554903) (476575) (614210) (637553) (750717) (742909) (740144) ($702) ($721) ($782) ($801) ($789) ($707) (730476) (695303) (688833)
Total Subsidies $4074870 $4151458 $4836513 $5147079 $5501750 $5893111 $6375503 $6595010 $6664088 $7177 $7314 $7406 $7581 $7803 $7969 $7969 $8104112 $8246664 $8343629
Dedicated Taxes as a of Total Revenues + Subs - PMT 320 251 241 241 247 259 269 273 265 233 $0 $0 $0 $0 $0 $0 256 257 259
Total Revenues + Subsidies $10038382 $10295342 $11331292 $12158085 $12635709 $13793254 $14443571 $15054257 $15272337 $15951 $16403 $16601 $16787 $17035 $17229 $16900 $17497378 $17701896 $17820563
Operating Expenses
Labor Expenses
Payroll $4087376 $4163330 $4171374 $4160261 $4193658 $4332829 $4671664 $4695823 $4838741 $5020713 $5211 $5328 $5422 $5498 $5624 $5710 $5860206 $5982960 $6107107
Overtime 471675 499307 443227 538647 574316 620701 730200 755071 771495 934100 $1066 $910 $838 $859 $877 $899 917296 935002 951324
Health amp Welfare 684945 688899 738189 809638 812857 895714 961902 1050100 1172304 1208786 $1230 $1341 $1414 $1489 $1583 $1674 1797938 1922668 2071273
OPEB Current Payment 318501 346316 355716 394218 413164 472619 479079 501716 562233 563754 $604 $645 $704 $766 $835 $910 982025 1060022 1142795
Pensions 897450 1021229 1029710 1074598 1328441 1301975 1304355 1248726 1370474 1345308 $1336 $1494 $1461 $1462 $1403 $1347 1357887 1369071 1380572
Other-Fringe Benefits 502739 517194 539996 581661 650430 694680 784143 861079 947870 792151 $881 $869 $897 $930 $956 $976 1001185 1021007 1040170
Reimbursable Overhead (310555) (322230) (345154) (324006) (309399) (321390) (349770) (380212) (423759) (491807) ($528) ($471) ($430) ($412) ($397) ($395) (396136) (405509) (413165)
Labor Expenses $6652131 $6914045 $6933059 $7235017 $7663467 $7997128 $8581574 $8732302 $9239358 $9799 $10116 $10306 $10592 $10881 $11121 $11413 $11520401 $11885220 $12280075
PayrollOvertime Exp as a of Total Operating+DS $0426 $0427 $0407 $0396 $0387 $0374 $0389 $0383 $0376 $0390 $0367 $0365 $0359 $0355 $0350 $0349 $0347 $0345
Labor Exp (wo Reimb OH) as a of Total Oper+DS $0650 $0663 $0642 $0637 $0647 $0628 $0643 $0640 $0648 $0642 $0622 $0626 $0622 $0616 $0609 $0614 $0617 $0620
PayrollOvertime Exp as a of Total Operating Exp $0496 $0490 $0483 $0473 $0465 $0453 $0464 $0459 $0450 $0464 $0435 $0438 $0434 $0433 $0430 $0426 $0420 $0416
Labor Exp (wo Reimb OH) as a of Total Oper Exp $0758 $0761 $0762 $0761 $0777 $0761 $0768 $0768 $0776 $0763 $0739 $0750 $0751 $0750 $0749 $0748 $0747 $0747
Non-Labor Expenses
Electric Power $306500 $317934 $325137 $457269 $471514 $493346 $515540 $473762 $406372 $481893 $451503 $473177 $493090 $532413 $561955 $571182 $589565 $618283 $648255
Traction Power
Non-Traction Power
Fuel 287033 180294 189942 282735 251763 259252 267494 162283 124684 185203 182778 182981 176333 173681 176920 182259 182476 184281 186170
Revenue Vehicle Fuel
Non-Revenue Fuel
Insurance 28902 34012 9819 14363 7617 38654 50739 57190 (20634) (29402) 5608 15623 23118 26855 28309 36048 28232 25538 19483
Claims 152114 238104 285418 315547 135652 299875 269167 331023 463959 437985 387557 394211 392547 398256 406112 404397 417667 428660 437683
Paratransit Service Contracts 299013 370094 379761 348553 360500 366751 365599 379271 383704 455471 494751 488330 505538 535329 568614 581114 604766 643217 684112
Maintenance and Other Operating Contracts 594215 562456 541716 451137 451766 496743 549018 579289 630924 678425 840168 797428 833534 836606 854471 879468 880053 898882 915477
Professional Service Contracts 196930 199164 203084 226205 276998 297201 283005 379814 399706 543582 607838 502858 494814 504103 513895 499724 520826 537109 547291
Materials amp Supplies 532534 526191 511206 438310 430804 475127 526725 543225 585607 637078 689010 679895 697976 711281 715758 711988 741335 777460 793419
Other Business Expenses 155466 184142 189637 169857 143807 167198 179701 195598 192576 220838 218196 213551 224459 226170 228457 244907 228861 240258 241690
Non-Labor Expenses $2552708 $2612391 $2635720 $2703976 $2530421 $2894147 $3006988 $3101454 $3166897 3611 3877 3748 3841 3945 4054 4111 $4193782 $4353689 $4473580
Other Expense Adjustments
Other ($13712) ($14750) ($18292) ($2289) $62593 $46175 $44973 $37007 $47404 129 175 86 36 22 23 23 $23516 $24069 $24637
General Reserve 0000 0000 0000 0000 0000 - 0 - 0 - 0 - 0 0 165 170 175 180 185 185 190000 195000 205000
Other Expense Adjustments ($13712) ($14750) ($18292) ($2289) $62593 $46175 $44973 $37007 $47404 $128555 $340 $256 $211 $202 $208 $208 $213516 $219069 $229637
Gap Closing Expenses $7675394
Additional Actions for Budget Balance Expense Impact $0000 $0000 $0000 $0000 $0000 $0000 $0000 $0000 $0000 $0000 $0000 $0000 $0000 $0000 $0000 $0000 $0000 $0000 $0000
Total Operating Expenses Before Non-Cash Liability Adjs $9191127 $9511685 $9550486 $9936705 $10256481 $10937450 $11633535 $11870763 $12453659 $13538830 $14332772 $14309678 $14643965 $15027767 $15383584 $15732241 $15927699 $16457978 $16983292
Non-Cash Liability Adjustments
Depreciation $1790981 $1940576 $1980681 $2019378 $2148820 $2174302 $2266280 $2442777 $2442941 $2607970 $2804571 $2784812 $2842737 $2908533 $2977025 $3051834 $3109882 $3169371 $3230301
OPEB Obligation 1348962 1104827 1167070 1706939 1785881 1920189 2035457 1489656 1562261 1567381 0000 (0000) (0000) (0000) (0000) 0000 0000 (0000) (0000)
GASB 75 OPEB Expense Adjustment 0000 0000 0000 0000 0000 0000 0000 0000 0000 0000 1047747 1457230 1628196 1748560 1823313 1898497 1952374 2006482 2061993
GASB 68 Pension Expense Adjustment 0000 0000 0000 0000 0000 0000 0000 (410019) (218911) (168119) (373022) (220864) (271921) (342847) (318372) (242446) (237864) (234492) (230942)
Environmental Remediation 42249 6062 18621 59079 24742 14257 20556 20576 11691 13468 105615 6000 6000 6000 6000 6000 6000 6000 6000
Non-Cash Liability Adjustments $3182192 $3051466 $3166371 $3785396 $3959443 $4108749 $4322293 $3542990 $3797981 $4020699 $3584911 $4027178 $4205012 $4320246 $4487966 $4713886 $4830392 $4947361 $5067352
Total Operating Expenses After Non-Cash Liability Adjs $12373319 $12563151 $12716857 $13722101 $14215924 $15046199 $15955827 $15413753 $16251641 $17559529 $17917683 $18336856 $18848977 $19348013 $19871550 $20446127 $20758090 $21405338 $22050644
Less BampT Depreciation $77213 $80097 $77846 $86545 $87926 $91345 $104039 $109783 $135035 $240957 $148686 $151977 $158779 $169848 $181689 $194355 $194355 $194355 $194355
BampT Other Post Employment Benefits 66323 50967 54831 66686 73055 76641 71148 62457 60441 78106 32297 22256 20303 22870 28694 33918 36169 38411 40604
Net Operating Deficit Before Subsidies and Debt Service ($6409807) ($6419266) ($6222079) ($6711095) ($7081966) ($7146057) ($7887759) ($6954506) ($7643392) ($8785339) ($8829030) ($9141907) ($9642826) ($10116260) ($10611154) ($11515498) ($11364824) ($11950106) ($12573710)
Conversion to Cash Basis Non-Cash Liability Adjs ($3182192) ($3051466) ($3166371) ($3785396) ($3959443) ($4108749) ($4322293) ($3542990) ($3797981) ($4020699) ($3584911) ($4027178) ($4205012) ($4320246) ($4487966) ($4713886) ($4830392) ($4947361) ($5067352)
Total Operating Expenses $9191127 $9511685 $9550486 $9936705 $10256481 $10937450 $11633535 $11870763 $12453659 $13539 $14333 $14310 $14644 $15028 $15384 $15732 $15927699 $16457978 $16983292
Debt Service Expenses $1515733 $1404454 $1781220 $1933532 $2058395 $2299262 $2248538 $2373321 $2458783 $2541 $2683 $2830 $3041 $3265 $3513 $3450 $3471321 $3472987 $3501639
Total Expenses + Debt Service $10706859 $10916139 $11331706 $11870237 $12314876 $13236712 $13882073 $14244084 $14912443 $16079 $17016 $17140 $17685 $18293 $18896 $19182 $19399019 $19930965 $20484932
Net Deficit After Subsidies and Debt Service ($668477) ($620796) ($0414) $287848 $320833 $556541 $561498 $810173 $359895 ($128044) ($613) ($539) ($898) ($1258) ($1667) ($2283) ($1901641) ($2229069) ($2664369)
Conversion to Cash Basis GASB Account (56067) (54256) (67377) (37636) (89548) (85641) (50017) - 0 - 0 0 0 0 $0 0 0 - 0 - 0 - 0 - 0
Conversion to Cash Basis 492710 550267 91781 (111037) (297407) (261709) (626297) (660147) (591809) 379 229 147 60 125 101 130 49745 48375 54220
Net Cash Balance from Previous Year 0000 0000 0000 23990 139174 0000 209191 0000 150026 0000 250569 0000 0000 0000 0000 0000 0000 0000 0000
Total Operating Exp + DS + Cash Conversions + PY C-O $11144 $11412 $11356 $11746 $12067 $12889362 $13414950 $13583937 $14470659 $16457999 $17495351 $17286526 $17744425 $18418197 $18997710 $19312017 $19448764 $19979340 $20539152
Total Operating Expenses with Cash Conversion $10270216 $10420127 $11307302 $12018911 $12701831 $13584063 $14558387 $14904231 $15504252 $15700774 $16786574 $16992579 $17624861 $18167420 $18795069 $19052755 $19349274 $19882590 $20430711
Baseline Net Cash Balance Before B-T-L Adjustments ($231834) ($124785) $23990 $139174 ($66122) $209191 ($114816) $150026 ($231914) $251 ($384) ($392) ($838) ($1133) ($1566) ($2153) ($1851896) ($2180695) ($2610148)
Below-the-Line Adjustments
FareToll Increases
FareToll Increase in March 2019 (4 Yield) - 0 $0 $0 $0 $0 $0 $0 - 0 - 0 - 0
FareToll Increase in March 2021 (4 Yield) - 0 $0 $0 $0 $283 $331 $332 333531 333568 334299
FareToll Increase in March 2023 (4 Yield) - 0 $0 $0 $0 $0 $0 $294 346386 346424 347183
FareToll Increase in March 2025 (4 Yield) - 0 $0 $0 $0 $0 $0 $0 - 0 273859 321624
Subsidy Impacts of 20212023 FareToll Increase - 0 $0 $0 $0 ($7) ($9) ($17) (18612) (25573) (26305)
$0000 $0 $0 $0 $275 $322 $609 $661306 $928278 $976801
CASH BALANCE AFTER FARE INCREASES $250569 ($384) ($392) ($838) ($850) ($1234) ($1821) ($1518365) ($1847127) ($2275849)
MTA Initiatives
MTA Efficiencies - Not Yet Implemented - 0 $0 $0 $0 $0 $0 $0 0000 0000 0000
0 - 0 $0 $0 $0 $0 $0 $0 - 0 - 0 - 0
0 - 0 $0 $0 $0 $0 $0 $0 - 0 - 0 - 0
$0000 $0 $0 $0 $0 $0 $0 $0000 $0000 $0000
Policy Actions
CAS Migration to Peoplesoft $0 $0 ($5) ($1) ($0) ($0) (0200) -02 -02 0
Fare Evasion Enforcement Strategy-Expenses $0 ($13) ($12) ($11) ($10) ($10) (9554) -9554483 -9554483 0
Fare Evasion Enforcement-Manhattan DA Forfeiture Fund $0 $11 $11 $10 $9 $0 - 0 0 0 0
Negotiated 1 CBA Reform $0 $0 $0 $0 $0 $0 - 0 0 0 0
MTA Reorganization $0 $8 $180 $371 $377 $377 377000 377 377 0
MTA Reorganization Costs $0 $0 ($10) ($27) ($2) $0 - 0 0 0 0
Drawdown 2019 General Reserve $0 $0 $165 $0 $0 $0 - 0 0 0 0
CBA Negotiated Reform - 1 Value $0 $36 $100 $173 $246 $323 323473 323473304484 323473304484 0
$0000 $0 $42 $429 $515 $620 $691 $690719 $690719 $690719
MTA Re-estimates
Additional Savings Actions $0000 $0 $0 $0 $0 $0 $0 $0000 $0000 $0000
Total Below-the-Line Adjustments $0 $73 $386 $757 $852 $1133 $1007 $1352025 $1618997 $1667520
Prior Year Carryover 495399 263336 138286 161986 301160 235038 444229 329413 479439 121 372 61 55 0 0 - 0 - 0 - 0 - 0
NET CASH BALANCE $263566 $138551 $162276 $301160 $235038 $444229 $329413 $479439 $247525 $372 $61 $55 ($26) ($281) ($433) ($1146) ($499871) ($561698) ($942628)
MTA February Financial Plan 2019-2022
Consolidated Statement Of Operations By Category ($ in millions)
Non-Reimbursable Final Adopted
Actual Actual Actual Actual Actual Actual Actual Actual Actual Actual Estimate Budget
2008 2009 2010 2011 2012 2013 2014 2015 2016 2017 2018 2019 2020 2021 2022 2023 2024 2025 2026
Operating Revenues
Farebox Revenue $4240923 $4350411 $4586377 $4999186 $5079138 $5501274 $5709200 $5961129 $6050182 $6172 $6153 $6122 $6144 $6134 $6144 $6174 $6435176 $6431979 $6446633
422 423 405 411 402 399 395 396 396 407 279 275 272 267 263 261 368 363 362
Student Fare - 0 - 0 - 0 - 0 - 0 - 0
Toll Revenue 1273974 1332115 1417046 1501589 1490982 1645193 1676445 1808901 1869693 1912 1967 1984 1990 1998 1998 2002 2133050 2137871 2143111
0127 0129 0125 0124 0118 0119 0116 0120 0122 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0122 0121 0120
Other Revenue 448616 461359 491355 510231 563839 753675 682424 689217 688374 653 662 705 733 757 743 755 825040 885381 887190
Capital and Other Reimbursements 0000 0000 0000 0000 0000 0000 0000 0000 0000 0000 0000 0000 0000 0000 0000 0000 0000 0000 0000
Total Operating Revenue $5963512 $6143885 $6494778 $7011006 $7133959 $7900142 $8068069 $8459247 $8608249 $8737 $8782 $8810 $8867 $8889 $8886 $8931 $9393266 $9455232 $9476934
Dedicated Taxes $3211585 $2366805 $2343537 $2511691 $2673119 $3097640 $3383498 $3582628 $3525829 $3257508 $3459 $3515 $3568 $3630 $3725 $3812 $3841433 $3880226 $3917215
PMT amp MTA Aid - 0 881784 1588677 1718286 1825824 1825328 1885069 1910947 1970760 1987035 $1965 $2152 $2225 $2295 $2368 $2442 2516095 2594604 2677041
New Funding Sources - 0 - 0 - 0 - 0 - 0 - 0 - 0 - 0 - 0 - 0 $508 $342 $385 $385 $385 $385 385000 385000 385000
StateLocal Taxes 556691 539046 544810 541733 536182 537527 539545 537819 537645 541005 $544 $552 $557 $562 $567 $572 576828 581933 583214
Other Funding Agreements 306594 363823 359489 375369 466625 432617 567391 563616 629855 630218 $701 $753 $671 $708 $758 $758 784755 804901 781159
BampT Operating Surplus Transfer 382565 363092 476059 554903 476575 614210 637553 750717 742909 740144 $702 $721 $782 $801 $789 $707 730476 695303 688833
Dedicated Taxes and StateLocal Subsidies $4457434 $4514550 $5312572 $5701982 $5978325 $6507322 $7013056 $7345727 $7406998 $7155909 $7879 $8035 $8188 $8381 $8592 $8676 $8834588 $8941967 $9032462
$0000 $0000 $0000 $0000 $0000 $0000 $0000 $0000 $0000
Less Interagency Subsidy and Surplus Transfers (382565) (363092) (476059) (554903) (476575) (614210) (637553) (750717) (742909) (740144) ($702) ($721) ($782) ($801) ($789) ($707) (730476) (695303) (688833)
Total Subsidies $4074870 $4151458 $4836513 $5147079 $5501750 $5893111 $6375503 $6595010 $6664088 $6416 $7242 $7238 $7370 $7576 $7807 $7969 $8104112 $8246664 $8343629
Dedicated Taxes as a of Total Revenues + Subs - PMT 320 251 241 241 247 259 269 273 265 247 $0 $0 $0 $0 $0 $0 256 257 259
Total Revenues + Subsidies $10038382 $10295342 $11331292 $12158085 $12635709 $13793254 $14443571 $15054257 $15272337 $15152 $16023 $16048 $16237 $16465 $16693 $16900 $17497378 $17701896 $17820563
Operating Expenses
Labor Expenses
Payroll $4087376 $4163330 $4171374 $4160261 $4193658 $4332829 $4671664 $4695823 $4838741 $5020713 $5211 $5328 $5422 $5498 $5624 $5710 $5860206 $5982960 $6107107
Overtime 471675 499307 443227 538647 574316 620701 730200 755071 771495 934100 $1066 $910 $838 $859 $877 $899 917296 935002 951324
Health amp Welfare 684945 688899 738189 809638 812857 895714 961902 1050100 1172304 1208786 $1230 $1341 $1414 $1489 $1583 $1674 1797938 1922668 2071273
OPEB Current Payment 318501 346316 355716 394218 413164 472619 479079 501716 562233 563754 $604 $645 $704 $766 $835 $910 982025 1060022 1142795
Pensions 897450 1021229 1029710 1074598 1328441 1301975 1304355 1248726 1370474 1345308 $1336 $1494 $1461 $1462 $1403 $1347 1357887 1369071 1380572
Other-Fringe Benefits 502739 517194 539996 581661 650430 694680 784143 861079 947870 792151 $881 $869 $897 $930 $956 $976 1001185 1021007 1040170
Reimbursable Overhead (310555) (322230) (345154) (324006) (309399) (321390) (349770) (380212) (423759) (491807) ($528) ($471) ($430) ($412) ($397) ($395) (396136) (405509) (413165)
Labor Expenses $6652131 $6914045 $6933059 $7235017 $7663467 $7997128 $8581574 $8732302 $9239358 $9373 $9920 $10039 $10436 $10787 $11097 $11413 $11520401 $11885220 $12280075
PayrollOvertime Exp as a of Total Operating+DS $0426 $0427 $0407 $0396 $0387 $0374 $0389 $0383 $0376 $0385 $0349 $0347 $0345
Labor Exp (wo Reimb OH) as a of Total Oper+DS $0650 $0663 $0642 $0637 $0647 $0628 $0643 $0640 $0648 $0638 $0614 $0617 $0620
PayrollOvertime Exp as a of Total Operating Exp $0496 $0490 $0483 $0473 $0465 $0453 $0464 $0459 $0450 $0461 $0426 $0420 $0416
Labor Exp (wo Reimb OH) as a of Total Oper Exp $0758 $0761 $0762 $0761 $0777 $0761 $0768 $0768 $0776 $0763 $0748 $0747 $0747
Non-Labor Expenses
Electric Power $306500 $317934 $325137 $457269 $471514 $493346 $515540 $473762 $406372 $430381 $474918 $451304 $463523 $482662 $539624 $571182 $589565 $618283 $648255
Traction Power
Non-Traction Power
Fuel 287033 180294 189942 282735 251763 259252 267494 162283 124684 150481 185580 190348 187592 183168 181484 182259 182476 184281 186170
Revenue Vehicle Fuel
Non-Revenue Fuel
Insurance 28902 34012 9819 14363 7617 38654 50739 57190 (20634) (2715) 11488 8532 15803 22918 29411 36048 28232 25538 19483
Claims 152114 238104 285418 315547 135652 299875 269167 331023 463959 526053 376480 378570 386981 391333 395228 404397 417667 428660 437683
Paratransit Service Contracts 299013 370094 379761 348553 360500 366751 365599 379271 383704 392850 452190 482751 501230 518038 547829 581114 604766 643217 684112
Maintenance and Other Operating Contracts 594215 562456 541716 451137 451766 496743 549018 579289 630924 695251 779331 897801 833038 883805 871671 879468 880053 898882 915477
Professional Service Contracts 196930 199164 203084 226205 276998 297201 283005 379814 399706 507062 575742 557476 484911 479376 489510 499724 520826 537109 547291
Materials amp Supplies 532534 526191 511206 438310 430804 475127 526725 543225 585607 588115 667700 686666 687745 692131 697268 711988 741335 777460 793419
Other Business Expenses 155466 184142 189637 169857 143807 167198 179701 195598 192576 217254 225494 230595 225293 240279 242193 244907 228861 240258 241690
Non-Labor Expenses $2552708 $2612391 $2635720 $2703976 $2530421 $2894147 $3006988 $3101454 $3166897 3505 3749 3884 3786 3894 3994 4111 $4193782 $4353689 $4473580
Other Expense Adjustments
Other ($13712) ($14750) ($18292) ($2289) $62593 $46175 $44973 $37007 $47404 49 134 158 84 36 22 23 $23516 $24069 $24637
General Reserve 0000 0000 0000 0000 0000 - 0 - 0 - 0 - 0 0 0 165 170 175 180 185 190000 195000 205000
Other Expense Adjustments ($13712) ($14750) ($18292) ($2289) $62593 $46175 $44973 $37007 $47404 $49379 $134 $323 $254 $211 $202 $208 $213516 $219069 $229637
Gap Closing Expenses $7675394
Additional Actions for Budget Balance Expense Impact $0000 $0000 $0000 $0000 $0000 $0000 $0000 $0000 $0000 $0000 $0000 $0000 $0000 $0000 $0000 $0000 $0000 $0000 $0000
Total Operating Expenses Before Non-Cash Liability Adjs $9191127 $9511685 $9550486 $9936705 $10256481 $10937450 $11633535 $11870763 $12453659 $12927116 $13802910 $14246122 $14475644 $14891445 $15293262 $15732241 $15927699 $16457978 $16983292
Non-Cash Liability Adjustments
Depreciation $1790981 $1940576 $1980681 $2019378 $2148820 $2174302 $2266280 $2442777 $2442941 $2607970 $2804571 $2784812 $2842737 $2908533 $2977025 $3051834 $3109882 $3169371 $3230301
OPEB Obligation 1348962 1104827 1167070 1706939 1785881 1920189 2035457 1489656 1562261 1567381 0000 (0000) (0000) (0000) (0000) 0000 0000 (0000) (0000)
GASB 75 OPEB Expense Adjustment 0000 0000 0000 0000 0000 0000 0000 0000 0000 0000 1047747 1457230 1628196 1748560 1823313 1898497 1952374 2006482 2061993
GASB 68 Pension Expense Adjustment 0000 0000 0000 0000 0000 0000 0000 (410019) (218911) (168119) (373022) (220864) (271921) (342847) (318372) (242446) (237864) (234492) (230942)
Environmental Remediation 42249 6062 18621 59079 24742 14257 20556 20576 11691 13468 105615 6000 6000 6000 6000 6000 6000 6000 6000
Non-Cash Liability Adjustments $3182192 $3051466 $3166371 $3785396 $3959443 $4108749 $4322293 $3542990 $3797981 $4020699 $3584911 $4027178 $4205012 $4320246 $4487966 $4713886 $4830392 $4947361 $5067352
Total Operating Expenses After Non-Cash Liability Adjs $12373319 $12563151 $12716857 $13722101 $14215924 $15046199 $15955827 $15413753 $16251641 $16947815 $17387821 $18273301 $18680657 $19211690 $19781228 $20446127 $20758090 $21405338 $22050644
Less BampT Depreciation $77213 $80097 $77846 $86545 $87926 $91345 $104039 $109783 $135035 $240957 $148686 $151977 $158779 $169848 $181689 $194355 $194355 $194355 $194355
BampT Other Post Employment Benefits 66323 50967 54831 66686 73055 76641 71148 62457 60441 78106 32297 22256 20303 22870 28694 33918 36169 38411 40604
Net Operating Deficit Before Subsidies and Debt Service ($6409807) ($6419266) ($6222079) ($6711095) ($7081966) ($7146057) ($7887759) ($6954506) ($7643392) ($8211234) ($8606220) ($9463506) ($9813560) ($10322912) ($10895644) ($11515498) ($11364824) ($11950106) ($12573710)
Conversion to Cash Basis Non-Cash Liability Adjs ($3182192) ($3051466) ($3166371) ($3785396) ($3959443) ($4108749) ($4322293) ($3542990) ($3797981) ($4020699) ($3584911) ($4027178) ($4205012) ($4320246) ($4487966) ($4713886) ($4830392) ($4947361) ($5067352)
Total Operating Expenses $9191127 $9511685 $9550486 $9936705 $10256481 $10937450 $11633535 $11870763 $12453659 $12927 $13803 $14246 $14476 $14891 $15293 $15732 $15927699 $16457978 $16983292
Debt Service Expenses $1515733 $1404454 $1781220 $1933532 $2058395 $2299262 $2248538 $2373321 $2458783 $2525 $2559 $2692 $2840 $3080 $3223 $3450 $3471321 $3472987 $3501639
Total Expenses + Debt Service $10706859 $10916139 $11331706 $11870237 $12314876 $13236712 $13882073 $14244084 $14912443 $15452 $16362 $16938 $17316 $17971 $18516 $19182 $19399019 $19930965 $20484932
Net Deficit After Subsidies and Debt Service ($668477) ($620796) ($0414) $287848 $320833 $556541 $561498 $810173 $359895 ($299965) ($339) ($890) ($1079) ($1506) ($1823) ($2283) ($1901641) ($2229069) ($2664369)
Conversion to Cash Basis GASB Account (56067) (54256) (67377) (37636) (89548) (85641) (50017) - 0 - 0 0 0 0 $0 0 0 - 0 - 0 - 0 - 0
Conversion to Cash Basis 492710 550267 91781 (111037) (297407) (261709) (626297) (660147) (591809) 174 296 363 188 (17) 88 130 49745 48375 54220
Net Cash Balance from Previous Year 0000 0000 0000 23990 139174 0000 209191 0000 150026 0000 0000 0000 0000 0000 0000 0000 0000 0000 0000
Total Operating Exp + DS + Cash Conversions + PY C-O $11144 $11412 $11356 $11746 $12067 $12889362 $13414950 $13583937 $14470659 $15625875 $16658585 $17300293 $17504155 $17954574 $18604130 $19312017 $19448764 $19979340 $20539152
Total Operating Expenses with Cash Conversion $10270216 $10420127 $11307302 $12018911 $12701831 $13584063 $14558387 $14904231 $15504252 $15278749 $16065734 $16575223 $17128079 $17987951 $18427778 $19052755 $19349274 $19882590 $20430711
Baseline Net Cash Balance Before B-T-L Adjustments ($231834) ($124785) $23990 $139174 ($66122) $209191 ($114816) $150026 ($231914) ($126) ($43) ($527) ($891) ($1523) ($1735) ($2153) ($1851896) ($2180695) ($2610148)
Below-the-Line Adjustments
FareToll Increases
FareToll Increase in March 2019 (4 Yield) - 0 $0 $0 $0 $0 $0 $0 - 0 - 0 - 0
FareToll Increase in March 2021 (4 Yield) - 0 $0 $0 $0 $283 $331 $332 333531 333568 334299
FareToll Increase in March 2023 (4 Yield) - 0 $0 $0 $0 $0 $0 $294 346386 346424 347183
FareToll Increase in March 2025 (4 Yield) - 0 $0 $0 $0 $0 $0 $0 - 0 273859 321624
Subsidy Impacts of 20212023 FareToll Increase - 0 $0 $0 $0 ($7) ($9) ($17) (18612) (25573) (26305)
$0000 $0 $0 $0 $275 $322 $609 $661306 $928278 $976801
CASH BALANCE AFTER FARE INCREASES ($126402) ($43) ($527) ($891) ($1241) ($1404) ($1821) ($1518365) ($1847127) ($2275849)
MTA Initiatives
MTA Efficiencies - Not Yet Implemented - 0 $0 $0 $0 $0 $0 $0 0000 0000 0000
0 - 0 $0 $0 $0 $0 $0 $0 - 0 - 0 - 0
0 - 0 $0 $0 $0 $0 $0 $0 - 0 - 0 - 0
$0000 $0 $0 $0 $0 $0 $0 $0000 $0000 $0000
Policy Actions
CAS Migration to Peoplesoft $0 $0 ($5) ($1) ($0) ($0) (0200) -02 -02 0
Fare Evasion Enforcement Strategy-Expenses $0 ($13) ($12) ($11) ($10) ($10) (9554) -9554483 -9554483 0
Fare Evasion Enforcement-Manhattan DA Forfeiture Fund $0 $11 $11 $10 $9 $0 - 0 0 0 0
Negotiated 1 CBA Reform $0 $0 $0 $0 $0 $0 - 0 0 0 0
MTA Reorganization $0 $8 $180 $371 $377 $377 377000 377 377 0
MTA Reorganization Costs $0 $0 ($10) ($27) ($2) $0 - 0 0 0 0
Drawdown 2019 General Reserve $0 $0 $165 $0 $0 $0 - 0 0 0 0
CBA Negotiated Reform - 1 Value $0 $36 $100 $173 $246 $323 323473 323473304484 323473304484 0
$0000 $0 $42 $429 $515 $620 $691 $690719 $690719 $690719
MTA Re-estimates
Additional Savings Actions $0000 $0 $0 $0 $0 $0 $0 $0000 $0000 $0000
Total Below-the-Line Adjustments $0 $0 $459 $413 $709 $760 $1007 $1352025 $1618997 $1667520
Prior Year Carryover 495399 263336 138286 161986 301160 235038 444229 329413 479439 248 121 79 11 0 0 - 0 - 0 - 0 - 0
NET CASH BALANCE $263566 $138551 $162276 $301160 $235038 $444229 $329413 $479439 $247525 $121 $79 $11 ($467) ($814) ($976) ($1146) ($499871) ($561698) ($942628)