63
MÁSTER EN FORMACIÓN DEL PROFESORADO DE EDUCACIÓN SECUNDARIA OBLIGATORIA, BACHILLERATO, FORMACIÓN PROFESIONAL Y ENSEÑANZAS DE IDIOMAS. “MOTIVATING ADOLESCENT READERS IN THE EFL CLASSROOM: THE NEW PARADIGM OF LITERACY INSTRUCTION IN SPAIN” TRABAJO FIN DE MÁSTER. CURSO: 2011 – 2012 ESPECIALIDAD: Enseñanza del Inglés Como Lengua Extranjera. APELLIDOS Y NOMBRE DEL AUTOR/A: Mara González de Ozaeta DNI: 05302275 Q CONVOCATORIA: SEPTIEMBRE TUTOR/A: Jelena Bobkina. Filología Inglesa I: Facultad de Filología FECHA: 03/09/2012

“MOTIVATING ADOLESCENT READERS IN THE EFL … · “MOTIVATING ADOLESCENT READERS IN THE EFL CLASSROOM: THE NEW PARADIGM OF LITERACY ... The text is a complete and multifaceted

Embed Size (px)

Citation preview

Page 1: “MOTIVATING ADOLESCENT READERS IN THE EFL … · “MOTIVATING ADOLESCENT READERS IN THE EFL CLASSROOM: THE NEW PARADIGM OF LITERACY ... The text is a complete and multifaceted

MÁSTER EN FORMACIÓN DEL PROFESORADO DE

EDUCACIÓN SECUNDARIA OBLIGATORIA, BACHILLERATO, FORMACIÓN PROFESIONAL Y ENSEÑANZAS DE IDIOMAS.

“MOTIVATING ADOLESCENT READERS IN THE EFL CLASSROOM: THE NEW PARADIGM OF LITERACY

INSTRUCTION IN SPAIN”

TRABAJO FIN DE MÁSTER. CURSO: 2011 – 2012

ESPECIALIDAD: Enseñanza del Inglés Como Lengua Extranjera.

APELLIDOS Y NOMBRE DEL AUTOR/A: Mara González de Ozaeta

DNI: 05302275 Q

CONVOCATORIA: SEPTIEMBRE

TUTOR/A: Jelena Bobkina. Filología Inglesa I: Facultad de Filología

FECHA: 03/09/2012

Page 2: “MOTIVATING ADOLESCENT READERS IN THE EFL … · “MOTIVATING ADOLESCENT READERS IN THE EFL CLASSROOM: THE NEW PARADIGM OF LITERACY ... The text is a complete and multifaceted

  2  

Abstract.

The following research work explores the need for a change in the context of EFL

teaching in respect to literacy aspects and the maintenance of motivation among

students. It seeks to introduce a new pedagogical function to the text while using it to

improve the love for reading between secondary students in Spain. Some theoretical

background reports the arguments and the need for a new settlement of the text in the

educational system. According to this new paradigm the second part of the study

makes a purpose of a reading program to be integrated to the classroom dynamics,

this purpose being based on some data obtained from questionnaires of research.

The program includes some pleasurable reading whose material would be pre selected

and adapted for the class by the teacher. Later on students make their own reading

choice among the already “suitable” proposals of the teacher and they start reporting

their autonomous reading and sharing their opinions and new knowledge with their

partners. Finally, a goal is established in order to evaluate their work and a constant

dialogue weaves together the linguistic issues of the course with the personal and

communicational responses of each individual reader. Through this reading program

we would stimulate the creation of a common universe in the class, a universe much

like a literary club.

Keywords. Text, English, reading, learning, pleasure, motivation, dialogue, classroom.

Resumen.

La siguiente investigación explora la necesidad de cambio en el contexto de

enseñanza del inglés respecto a los aspectos de alfabetismo y el mantenimiento de los

niveles de motivación óptimos entre los jóvenes estudiantes. Este trabajo otorga una

nueva función pedagógica al texto mientras lo usa para fomentar el amor por la lectura

entre los estudiantes de secundaria en España. El marco teórico expuesto recoge los

argumentos y la necesidad de un nuevo uso e implicación del texto en el sistema de

enseñanza. De acuerdo con este propósito la segunda parte del estudio recoge una

propuesta de programa de lectura que quede integrado en la dinámica del aula de

inglés basado en la obtención de los datos objetivos de unos cuestionarios. El

programa incluye materiales de lectura por placer que el profesor selecciona y adapta

para sus estudiantes. Mas tarde los estudiantes harán su selección personal de

aquellos textos considerados apropiados por el profesor e iniciarán sus revisiones

sobre los textos leídos para compartir sus ideas y conocimientos con sus compañeros.

Finalmente se establece una meta para evaluarlos y un diálogo constante que reúne

los aspectos de orden linguístico del texto con los personales y de carácter

Page 3: “MOTIVATING ADOLESCENT READERS IN THE EFL … · “MOTIVATING ADOLESCENT READERS IN THE EFL CLASSROOM: THE NEW PARADIGM OF LITERACY ... The text is a complete and multifaceted

  3  

comunicativo. A través de este programa se estimula la creación de un universo en

común en la clase, parecido al de un club de literatura.

Descriptores. Texto, Inglés, lectura, aprendizaje, placer, motivación, diálogo, aula.

Page 4: “MOTIVATING ADOLESCENT READERS IN THE EFL … · “MOTIVATING ADOLESCENT READERS IN THE EFL CLASSROOM: THE NEW PARADIGM OF LITERACY ... The text is a complete and multifaceted

  4  

INDEX    1.  INTRODUCTION  ...............................................................................................................................  5  

2.  TEXT-­‐BASED  TEACHING  AND  READING  HABITS  ...............................................................  10  

3.  STRATEGIES  TO  ENHANCE  READING  IN  THE  FOREIGN  LANGUAGE  CLASSROOM  ..  12  3.1.  TEACHING  READING  COMPREHENSION  TROUGH  TEXTS  .....................................................................  13  3.2.  LITERACY  ACQUISITION  THROUGH  TEXTS  .............................................................................................  17  

4.  MOTIVATIONAL  STRATEGIES  RELATED  TO  READING  TEXTS  ......................................  20  4.1.  SELECTING  AND  ADAPTING  MATERIALS  .................................................................................................  22  a.  Authentic  Materials  ..................................................................................................................................  24  b.  ICT  resources  ...............................................................................................................................................  26  

5.  THE  READING  SITUATION  IN  SPAIN  AND  THE  EFL  CLASSROOM  .................................  29  5.1.  STUDENTS  DEMAND  INTERESTING  TEXTS  .............................................................................................  31  5.2.  TEACHERS’  INCLINATION  TOWARDS  THE  ACTION  PLAN  ....................................................................  35  

6.  A  PURPOSE  OF  READING  PROGRAM  AS  A  PRELIMINARY  TO  ACTION  .......................  39  6.1.  PRE-­‐ASSESSMENT  AND  THE  PROCESS  OF  SELECTION  ...........................................................................  39  6.2.  SELF-­‐SUSTAINED  READING  ........................................................................................................................  41  6.3.  COLLABORATIVE  LEARNING  ......................................................................................................................  43  

7.  CONCLUSIONS  ...............................................................................................................................  47  

8.  REFERENCES  ..................................................................................................................................  49  

9.  BIBLIOGRAPHY  ............................................................................................................................  53  

10.  ATTACHMENTS  ..........................................................................................................................  58    

Page 5: “MOTIVATING ADOLESCENT READERS IN THE EFL … · “MOTIVATING ADOLESCENT READERS IN THE EFL CLASSROOM: THE NEW PARADIGM OF LITERACY ... The text is a complete and multifaceted

  5  

1.  Introduction  

Reading is like an infectious disease.

It is caught, not taught.

Christine Nuttal

The text is a complete and multifaceted source of information. It is the most

heterogeneous linguistic context ever provided to language students. The first

condition to promote a quality habit of reading among students is to provide them with

the interest and relevance of a particular text and to make a correct use of this text in

the English classroom.

The present research is centred on the problem of the improvement of reading

skills and motivation in the English classroom. In particular, the interest resides in

those strategies and techniques that might enhance students’ interest towards both

extensive and intensive reading and that would help them develop good reading habits.

One of the ways to do this is through introducing reading for pleasure components into

the language classroom and demonstrating the students the infinite variety of texts

they can choose to read as well as making them participate of the experience derived

from the task.

The benefits of the reading for pleasure strategies are often underestimated as

far as the gains derived from it take longer to be observable than those derived from

other oriented activities, like test-based practices in ELT.

While working with different kinds of texts, students not only learn to improve

the basic literacy skills, but also to explore the historical, cultural and social contexts in

which these texts have been created and interpreted. Furthermore, working with texts

contributes positively to student’s personal growth and psychological development.

What´s more, according to PISA report, students who are highly involved in a wide

range of reading activities, either in their L1 or L2, are more likely to be effective

learners and to perform well at school.

In order to promote reading in the foreign language classroom more

challenging, learner-centered tasks should be included into language curriculum. In

particular, the text-based collaborative tasks, reciprocal teaching and reading

apprenticeship could be of a great help to the teacher. Several ideas have been

adapted from modern and innovative teaching practices worldwide so that the result

would fortunately provide teachers and educative institutions with an interesting and

beneficial purpose that could be put into practice or adapted to particular contexts of

foreign language education in Spain.

Page 6: “MOTIVATING ADOLESCENT READERS IN THE EFL … · “MOTIVATING ADOLESCENT READERS IN THE EFL CLASSROOM: THE NEW PARADIGM OF LITERACY ... The text is a complete and multifaceted

  6  

One of the successes of this proposal relies on its possible spiral effect in L2

learning. Namely, if the teacher attains the desirable reading conditions, students won’t

just obtain better results in their linguistic competences, but they will soon value more

linguistic and literacy issues in English. Consequently, all their concern with reading

more and better will foster their level of motivation in the classroom and the teachers’

self-satisfaction.

The individual fact most susceptible of change is the student’s interest for reading. The association between reading interest and a good reading performance constitutes a positive feedback: when reading students become better readers and while reading actively they tend to read more and enjoy the activity. (IFIIE 2011, p. 27)1

The importance of providing motivational input to secondary students is evident.

To achieve this goal and get a suitable atmosphere and materials for the task the

teacher has to explore and select the best reading options for them. These texts can

have various formats and contents. It is essential that those texts have different levels

of English and the teacher again delimits the graduation of those. Before giving the

students to choose their reading, the teacher “adapts” some texts to make them

“suitable” (Nuttal, 1996) and fit each student’s particular situation. These two processes

of selection and adaptation constitute the core of the present study, constituting the

premise of the ideas and activities that the author explains below.

Through the teaching process the teacher must be willing to see how their

students learn independently. The extensive reading practice allows students choosing

their own reading text while participating on the benefits derived from the experience.

The reading program presented below is specially designed for secondary

students of EFL in the territory of Spain and it is based on the text-based collaborative

approach to teaching English. The program puts together the traditional benefits of

reading and its motivating proportions with the success of other collaborative practices

in SLA. Students read autonomously and in-group, they reflect on the message and

form of the text and negotiate together through dialogic situations their own

conclusions, doubts and feelings. Either in the context of bilingual schools or not, the

ideas here explained are applicable to any intermediate student of English in higher

education who confronts an autonomous reading activity for the first time, being the

materials authentic although previously adapted by the teacher in order to be suitable.

To read authentic materials means a challenge, recognising it as an activity designed                                                                                                                1 El factor individual más susceptible de cambio es el interés del alumno por la lectura. La asociación entre interés por la lectura y buenos resultados en lectura se retroalimenta: al leer más los estudiantes se convierten en mejores lectores, y cuando leen bien tienden a leer más y a disfrutar leyendo. (IFIIE, 2011 p. 27) (Translated into English by Mara González)

Page 7: “MOTIVATING ADOLESCENT READERS IN THE EFL … · “MOTIVATING ADOLESCENT READERS IN THE EFL CLASSROOM: THE NEW PARADIGM OF LITERACY ... The text is a complete and multifaceted

  7  

to native readers. Nevertheless, it might benefit all intermediate students of English,

who are already able to understand simple structures in English and grasp the

meaning of a text.

Consequently, the present program, although generally envisioned, is aimed at

those teachers of EFL who are eager to introduce text as a major didactic resource and

a motivational artefact. “(…) teachers who deprive themselves of a unique opportunity

to lead learners beyond the looking-glass” (Kramsch, 1993, p.106) At the same time,

this work addresses librarians, editorials, language departments of the educative

centre, autonomic governments and everyone who participates in the elaboration of the

curricular plan for English studies in Spain, but it might first be viewed as a befitting set

of procedures in the English classroom.

The encouragement of reading, including every language code, was demanded

of educative practitioners by the European institutions various decades before. In the

light of recent data obtained from statistical studies the situation that refers to reading

on a general basis appears to be critical,

(…) Several European countries have a lower average reading than the rest, although the standard deviation of students’ performance is not proficient; Czech Republic, Spain, Latvia, Lithuania, Romania, Slovenia, Slovakia, and Turkey need encourage the reading performance in the different levels of competency to elevate their average results. (IFIIE, 2011, p. 21)2

The proposal under discussion treats the reading competence and the activities

derived from that reading as major communicative goals. These ideas are based on

the fact that reading is primarily an interactive experience that results in better and

more autonomous learning. Moreover, the purpose below is sustained on the last

theories about the pragmatics of the text and its relation with metacognitive learning

processes. The author believes that the processes that take part in every learning

activity are derived from those that occur while reading. This means that both

experiences might have similar consequences in the mind of the learner-reader. Both

experiential processes entail memorization, repetition, self-assessment and a reflective

mood on the part of the learner-reader. Having this under consideration, the reading

program must coordinate those language-teaching methods concerned with the

                                                                                                               2 (…) varios países europeos tienen una media en lectura más baja que la media europea, aunque la desviación típica del rendimiento del alumnado no es alta; la República Checa, España, Letonia, Lituania, Rumanía, Eslovenia, Eslovaquia y Turquía necesitan mejorar el rendimiento en lectura en los diferentes niveles de competencia para elevar su puntuación media. (Translated in to Spanish by Mara González.)

Page 8: “MOTIVATING ADOLESCENT READERS IN THE EFL … · “MOTIVATING ADOLESCENT READERS IN THE EFL CLASSROOM: THE NEW PARADIGM OF LITERACY ... The text is a complete and multifaceted

  8  

learner’s exposure to authentic texts in English and the activities and interaction

derived from that experience.

There are various possibilities of achievement: the cooperative learning based on texts, the offer of diverse reading resources allowing students choose their own reading texts and visit places and people who give values to books. These are some of the most important methods as curricular research in Europe affirms. (IFIIE, 2011, p. 63)3.

The reading program below is a structured description of the most important

preliminary aspects needed to put into action a text-based collaborative approach to

EFL. Hopefully, the program would help teachers and educative professionals

achieving proficient reading standards among young Spanish learners of English and

reconsidering the importance of such matters as:

• Our students’ level of text comprehension

• The importance of individual exposure to L2 in order to obtain more learning

autonomy in the subject.

• The choice of the texts and their suitability for the classroom.

• The democracy of reading, which includes first the personal attendance to each

student and the overturn of reading deficient competences; and second, the

availability of materials for everyone and their adaptation to each student.

• The benefits that could be derived from adolescents’ abstract thought and

metacognitive processes in order to make them reflect on interesting topics and

themes.

• The motivating power that a proper reading experience has and how to

instigate such experiences from the classroom setting.

The significance of this study resides in the conviction that fostering reading

exposure among young students will guarantee their future academic success,

“synonymous with success in reading”. Last research signals, “children without strong

reading skills by middle school are headed for disaster” (Slavin, R. A. et. al., 2004)

Besides, the act of reading becomes a particular act of creation operated by the

reader himself (Iser, 1976) that makes of the text the result of the experience that the

reader encountered through. Readers create the text as they imbue the experience

                                                                                                               3 Existen varias maneras de lograr este objetivo: el aprendizaje cooperativo basado en textos, ofrecer materiales de lectura diversos, permitir a los alumnos que elijan sus lecturas y visitar lugares o personas que valoren los libros. Éstos son algunos de los métodos más importantes que sugieren los currículos e investigaciones europeas. (Translated by Mara González).

Page 9: “MOTIVATING ADOLESCENT READERS IN THE EFL … · “MOTIVATING ADOLESCENT READERS IN THE EFL CLASSROOM: THE NEW PARADIGM OF LITERACY ... The text is a complete and multifaceted

  9  

with a sense of “particularity” including a contextual language use, so useful to second

language learning. (Kramsch, 1993).

The reader is left with everything to do, and yet everything has already been done; the work only exists precisely on the level of his abilities; while he reads and creates, he knows that he could always go further in his reading, and that he could always create more profoundly; and this is why the work appears to him as inexhaustible and as impenetrable as an object. (Sartre, 1949, p.29)

Now, in respect to the teaching practice and its practitioners, the reading text

may appear at first difficult and hard to manage in the classroom dynamics, but it is a

strategic element of choice that entails the practice and learning of other linguistic

skills. Writing, speaking, even listening, can be coordinated with reading and to

promote reading. The idea of designing a reading program for the students of a foreign

language class could be optimal for deciding on whether the objectives and activities of

the classroom are being suitable and motivating enough or if their orientation might

change. We believe that through an enjoying reading experience and through our

students’ regular exposure to the task it could be possible to lead an interactive and

collaborating learning method, a multidisciplinary class that will boost their willingness.

Page 10: “MOTIVATING ADOLESCENT READERS IN THE EFL … · “MOTIVATING ADOLESCENT READERS IN THE EFL CLASSROOM: THE NEW PARADIGM OF LITERACY ... The text is a complete and multifaceted

  10  

 2.  Text-­‐based  Teaching  and  Reading  Habits  

The protagonist of the method proposed is the text, elevated as the major and most

important resource for the teaching-learning process. It becomes the focus of the

pedagogy substituting other means, mainly because it is considered at the same time

an advantageous element for learning a second language and a motivational strategy.

It constitutes an award by itself and plays an important part in the personal

development of each student. In continuation we are going to have a look at the way

texts were treated throughout the history of foreign language teaching.

The text has been accompanying foreign language teaching as an educational

resource since second languages started being compulsory learned in schools.

Education was at that time controlled by Catholic Church, on this account; the main

foreign languages were Latin and Greek. The texts used to support Latin and Greek

lessons were biblical texts, so that the Scriptures provided the linguistic context and

made readers understand the concept of text as being a container of truth. According

to clerical education texts were intended to preserve the truth as an immortal

compendium and to make it accessible to everyone.

With the rise of modern languages study, the education was already secular.

Literary texts started being used, but on a very restricted way; they were segmented,

translated and copied in order to study isolated and insignificant examples of a

linguistic context.

In the mid forties traditional texts’ usage was left behind, in order for those

classes to start being more oral-oriented. The foreign language curriculum consisted

on memorizing dialogue patterns and being able to communicate in various more

functional contexts in which language acquired a social or an informational purpose.

The lessons started being at the domain of empty formal modes, like with religious

texts, these were decontextualized sentences and fragments that were supposed to

serve acquiring a communicative competence. Modern course books still mirror this

approach to texts in ELT (Kramsch, 1992). The problem was and has been that “no

mere course can ever give the full, rich range of social and cultural context on which

cultural natives draw as they speak with one another” (Kramsch, 1992, p. 5)

In the present time there are several educative purposes and approaches

around the text, such as content-based teaching or genre-based teaching. These

approaches are treating the text as a unique and complex unit of meaning. The

program proposed in this work, in concrete, is based on the last methodological

developments that consider working with authentic texts the ultimate input for the

skilled learner. Such proceedings, based on the use of authentic materials, also include

Page 11: “MOTIVATING ADOLESCENT READERS IN THE EFL … · “MOTIVATING ADOLESCENT READERS IN THE EFL CLASSROOM: THE NEW PARADIGM OF LITERACY ... The text is a complete and multifaceted

  11  

enhancing English learners involvement and motivation through pleasurable reading

experiences in the target language that may serve communicative contexts in the

classroom.

In the gap between the reign of traditional text usage in the classroom and the

posterior aural and oral practices, the present research work tries coordinating both

strategies into one with the text-based collaborative approach. This is one of the key

methodologies as described by the Carnegie Corporation of New York in the report

titled Reading Next: A Vision for Action and Research in Middle and High school

Literacy (2006). The text’s prior aim is to encourage literacy instruction and research in

order to struggle young middle and high school students to read, but the document

judges the approach in question consistent with students SLA and the objective of

making them English proficient and self-motivated readers (Krashen & Terrell, 1988).

The approach “involves designing learning opportunities for pairs or small groups of

students that are similar to the book clubs or literature circles implemented in first

grades” (Biancarosa & Snow, 2006, p. 17) and consists on the practice of various

methods that serve at the same time as a guidance through the comprehension of the

text, students foreign language acquisition and their love for reading. For example,

reciprocal teaching and reading apprenticeship should be included. But also some

periodic assessment of our student’s criteria should be considered for book selection.

Also, the extensive and intensive uses of the text will facilitate variety and classroom

dynamics, and having in mind that the approach is intended for foreign readers we

need extra support in L2 instruction, that is, intensive reading practice.

Through this approach, the text creates a shared context that boosts dialogic

situations and collaborative learning in the classroom. At those interactive moments it

is replaced from “the focal point of the activity” in order to make it a “point of reference”

(Duff & Maley, 1990, p.85). With the teacher’s assistance, the classroom may rapidly

turn into microcosms: each reader with his imaginative and creative power sharing

his/her vision of the world and helping creating it anew. Learning gets rapidly

“decentralized” (Biancarosa & Snow, 2006, p.17) and replaced by pleasure reading

and enjoyable dialogic experiences. This replacement instigates confident participation

on the part of students and so begins the L2 acquisition process.

Page 12: “MOTIVATING ADOLESCENT READERS IN THE EFL … · “MOTIVATING ADOLESCENT READERS IN THE EFL CLASSROOM: THE NEW PARADIGM OF LITERACY ... The text is a complete and multifaceted

  12  

3.  Strategies  to  Enhance  Reading  in  the  Foreign  Language  Classroom  

The Common European Framework of Reference for Languages provides us with a

definition of text applied to the language teaching process. The text is here defined as

“any sequence or discourse (spoken and/or written) related to a specific domain and

which in the course of carrying out a task becomes the occasion of a language activity,

whether as a support or as a goal, as product or process” (C.E.F 2001, p. 10). The

definition does not give details about the engaging power of the reception of a text,

whether listened or read, and how following an interesting and enjoying text can be one

of the most effective strategies to motivate our students. Instead, educational systems

restrict its use to the main linguistic goal, communication. ELT has been misleading the

applicability of the interesting and pleasurable reading to the classroom; what’s more,

they have forgotten their responsibility of struggling adolescent readers (IESD, 2010).

Traditionally reading instruction in the context of foreign language teaching has

been regarded as important to language acquisition as any other linguistic skill. A

proficient linguistic competence must include equal abilities to writing, speaking,

listening and interacting as well. But what is the purpose of such a democratic structure

of language use? Discourses revealed through texts can be received and produced;

yet these include a message dependent on a linguistic set of formulas. From the

external reception of the text to its internal processing, a complete learning process

and a subtle acquisition of the language are taken place at once in the mind of the

learner-reader. Modern linguistic education in Spain, especially that referring to ELT,

devotes short periods of reading in the classroom and no attention whatsoever to self

sustained reading and reading habits as a whole. It is firmly believed that, in Krashen’s

words,

(…) Reading makes a contribution to overall competence, to all four skills and not just to written performance. Clearly, written input alone will not result in spoken fluency, due to the phonological factor as well as differences in spoken and written language. Comprehensible input gained in reading, however, may contribute to a general language competence that underlies both spoken and written performance. (Krashen & Terrell 1988, p. 131)

The reading deficiency in education could be due to various facts: higher

education’s lack of concern for literacy issues or the increasing domain of interactive

skills and non-discursive elements. In other words, communicative goal-driven

instruction might be replacing expressive goal-driven methodologies for language

instruction. Of course, this fact implies that a functionalist point of view is shadowing

Page 13: “MOTIVATING ADOLESCENT READERS IN THE EFL … · “MOTIVATING ADOLESCENT READERS IN THE EFL CLASSROOM: THE NEW PARADIGM OF LITERACY ... The text is a complete and multifaceted

  13  

the importance of autonomous experiences through language use and modern

rhetoric.

During the past decade the importance of reading instruction significantly increased, which has played an important part in European cooperation related with educational issues. Encouraging the reading competence was one of the European objectives agreed in the working plan of 2002 (1): “Education and Instruction 2010”. In May 2003, the European Council established the objective of reducing the rate of students below 15 years old that showed a low reading performance at least in a 20% during the year 2010 (2). The objective was not achieved; in fact, the levels of reading competencies did not show any significant improvement along the last decade. (Vassiliou 2011, p. 3).4

The focus of the reading program is put on young people in the context of SLA;

being proved that “students are less motivated to read in later grades” (Biancarosa &

Snow, 2006, p. 9). Although the research data below will show how their disinterest

could be due to the maladaptive strategies previously design in the curriculum,

because even them are sure of the SLA benefits that reading might propitiate them

with5. Reading can be regarded as a double experience: it is an end in itself and a

means to acquire more knowledge (IFFIE, 2011).

3.1.  Teaching  Reading  Comprehension  Trough  Texts    

The next point tries explaining the main steps to follow in literacy instruction, that is,

trying to guide students through the linguistic decoding process. Processing the

information correctly from a text will condition the nature of the propositional meaning

of that text. Although this is understood as an autonomous process that the reader will

try resolving independently, the teacher guidance on the first place and the promotion

of extensive reading practices must be included in the curriculum. “Good things happen

to students who read a great deal in the new language. Research shows they become

better and more confident readers, they write better, their listening and speaking

abilities improve, and their vocabularies get richer.” (Bamford & Day, 2004, p.1)

Decoding and processing information is the first step that our students have to

undertake in order to start enjoying the benefits derived from the reading experience. It                                                                                                                4 Durante la década pasada aumentó notablemente la importancia de la enseñanza de la lectura, cuestión que además ha tenido un papel clave en de la cooperación europea en materia educativa. La mejora de la competencia lectora fue uno de los objetivos europeos acordados en el plan de trabajo de 2002 (1): “Educación y Formación 2010”. En Mayo de 2003, el Consejo de Ministros adoptó el objetivo de reducir el índice de alumnos de 15 años con bajo rendimiento en lectura por lo menos en un 20% en el año 2010 (2). Este objetivo no se consiguió; de hecho, los niveles de competencia lectora no mostraron una mejora significativa a lo largo de la última década. (Vassiliou, 2011, p. 3) (Translated into English by Mara González). 5 See Graph # 2, p. 31 of this work.

Page 14: “MOTIVATING ADOLESCENT READERS IN THE EFL … · “MOTIVATING ADOLESCENT READERS IN THE EFL CLASSROOM: THE NEW PARADIGM OF LITERACY ... The text is a complete and multifaceted

  14  

is the first step out of the possible sequence of teaching (Nuttal, 1982) that this

analysis proposes. The present research estimates important mentioning the extensive

reading practice that is devoted to comprehension instruction. This practice “along with

deliberate teaching of strategies resulted in improvement” in ELT (Krashen & Terrell,

1988, p. 141). Extensive reading entails quick reading “with high levels of

comprehension and without needing a dictionary” as often as it previously seems (EFR

2011, p.3).

Nevertheless, the use of the dictionary should be constrained by the nature of

the expression or word the student wants to know about and with students individual

needs. The nature of the words and expressions we can find in a text define the

importance or the urgency of that item for the overall understanding. According to this,

the author of this work proposes the following categories for identifying segments of the

text: ornamental words, key words, dependent and independent words. The

classification is suggested with the sole aim of convincing our secondary students of

their already acquired capacities to read in L2. We might all agree that the meaning

differences, position, categories and syntactic relations distinguish the quality of words

and their implicatures in the discourse.

For example, ornamental words make the imaginal process of information more

detailed and coloured, but they can also be ignored on the first place while the reader

keeps track of the message of the text without problems. This kind of word is important

for the aesthetic delight of the text; with which our students will be awarded with

through their progressive reading improvement.

Key words are easily identifiable, without knowing their meaning in that specific

linguistic context the reader won’t be able to continue reading. He/she will get

unavoidably lost during the next lines. The reader cannot ignore them or he/she will

risk the overall understanding. The meaning of some other words is so dependent on

context and their syntactic position that theirs is a deductive meaning, resulted from the

assistance of other contextual and co-textual6 elements. Independent words instead,

have uncertain meanings; they are probably encountered in an ambiguous context or

fruit of cultural misunderstanding on the part of the reader. Against key words the latter

could be ignored without putting in danger the experience’s success.

Most older struggling readers can read words accurately, but they do not comprehend what they read, for a variety of reasons. For some, the problem is that they do not yet read words with enough fluency to facilitate comprehension. Others can read accurately

                                                                                                               6 Referring to the constituting elements of that specific text. Those inner references that create a linguistic setting around the discourse.

Page 15: “MOTIVATING ADOLESCENT READERS IN THE EFL … · “MOTIVATING ADOLESCENT READERS IN THE EFL CLASSROOM: THE NEW PARADIGM OF LITERACY ... The text is a complete and multifaceted

  15  

and quickly enough for comprehension to take place, but they lack the strategies to make them comprehend what they read. (Biancarosa & Snow, 2006, p. 8)7

Students do not have to be distrustful of their own capacities to read the text. Of

course there are categories of difficulty and of specificity among texts. We have to

keep in mind that a text not only has to be suitable for the reader, but also the reader

and the context have to be adequate for the specific nature of that discourse. Having

this fact under consideration the real level of understanding resides in the reader’s

skills to discriminate among the information, the structure of the language, word-

knowledge and the support of the context. A foreign language reader with an

intermediate level of English and an increasing reading practice will shortly be able to

know by himself how certain words in that language are only playing a secondary part

to the overall meaning, and how other words carry the weights of meaning and images.

Once the reader has overcome this process of familiarization with the language,

extensive reading starts being fruitful. “Only when the students are reading quickly,

with high levels of comprehension and without needing a dictionary” (EFR 2011, p. 3)

we can start putting into practice extensive reading experiences. This practice includes

the acquisition of such abilities as those that allow us “to grasp the gist of a text, to

notice and repair misinterpretations, and to change tactics based on the purposes of

reading.” (Biancarosa & Snow, 2006). Students work up their reading abilities to be

able to “learn independently and flexibly apply the strategies on their own” through

“reciprocal teaching” (Biancarosa & Snow, 2006, p. 14) At this point they start being

able to questioning, clarifying, predicting and summarizing the content of the text.

Learner-readers have to be encouraged to relax while reading and try

concentrating on the images that result from the process. Later on, those images can

be recorded through a writing task or through drawings. Students negotiate their

private thoughts during the reading progress with the rest of the class or in pairs and so

on. With higher levels of comprehension, the reader’s mind will start specifying more

details of the message. This strategic instruction put the reading process on the level of

metacognitive learning processes which are described in the area of educational

research to explain the why and how we can permanently control our own learning

process. Within the limits of the reading act as well, theorists of reception8 in language

                                                                                                               7 This is the report to Carnegie Corporation of New York. It specifies the sort of elements that a Reading program for struggling adolescent readers in U.S. must include. Although referring to native readers that start practicing to be proficient readers, the text adds that in the case of second language readers the plan would include a priority on the first place: the correct decoding of the target language. 8The theory of reception is the study that deals with the pragmatics of the Reading act on the level of other communicative contexts. According to this we must consider the communicative

Page 16: “MOTIVATING ADOLESCENT READERS IN THE EFL … · “MOTIVATING ADOLESCENT READERS IN THE EFL CLASSROOM: THE NEW PARADIGM OF LITERACY ... The text is a complete and multifaceted

  16  

and arts have demonstrated that we are conscious of our own horizon of expectancies

during the experience of reading. We question our beliefs during the process, as when

we learn something new (Carrell, 1989), and put into work the knowledge we have on

the issues discussed. After that, we memorise every new meaning that transcended

our expectancies while creating our proper vision of the world.

From the psycholinguistic point of view, the Reading process establishes basically the interactive process between language and thought in which there are two fundamental elements: conceptual skills, past knowledge and the abilities entailed. Being aware of the fact that reading does not consist on decoding symbols but interacting between previous and personal knowledge and the text. (Álvarez, M. A, 1997, p. 42)9

The setting must be considered: in the classroom a “comfort zone” of reading

has to be created, this would allow students devote long periods of independent

reading (McEwan, 2008). Their reading must be varied, accessible and suitable.

Besides, a regular time and space must be devoted to silent and autonomous reading

in order to stimulate pleasurable and relevant reading experiences (Margallo, 2012).

The last step to clarify to non-expert readers in English would be the cultural

understanding that texts contain independently of the ignorance of the reader. Our

learners in Spain are acquiring their second language through their exposure to

interesting amounts of cultural information that always accompany the language and its

use. At this moment the teacher or their private reading will lead them to the

implicatures of that particular text on the level of the social, cultural and historical

understanding.

To conclude, in the reading classroom the teacher and the text are both cultural

mediators and context providers, being these two of the most important elements for

the learning process. “Good things happen to students who read a great deal in the

new language. Research shows they become better and more confident readers, they

write better, their listening and speaking abilities improve, and their vocabularies get

richer.” (Bamford & Day, 2004, p.1)

                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                   event, as research data and literary theory have recently demonstrated, being no longer the product of a dialogic need between two or more participants but being present in every interaction that includes a message. The reading act is a communicative act between reader-text-author. Wolfgang Iser (1926- 2007) and Hans Robert Hauss (1921- 1997) are the funders of this discipline of the literary theory. 9 Desde el punto de vista psicolingüístico, el proceso de lectura contempla básicamente el proceso interactivo entre lengua y pesnamiento, en el que son fundamentales dos factores: la habilidad conceptual, los conocimietnos anteriores, y las destrezas del proceso… Teniendo en cuenta que leer no consiste sino en descodificar símbolos sino en la interacción entre el conocimiento anterior del individuo y el texto. (Translated into English by Mara González)

Page 17: “MOTIVATING ADOLESCENT READERS IN THE EFL … · “MOTIVATING ADOLESCENT READERS IN THE EFL CLASSROOM: THE NEW PARADIGM OF LITERACY ... The text is a complete and multifaceted

  17  

3.2.  Literacy  Acquisition  Through  Texts   Books are the quietest and most constant of friends; they are the most accessible and wisest of

counsellors, and the most patients of teachers.

Charles W. Eliot.

This point of the work wants to describe in detail those practices and applications of the

text in the EFL context oriented towards L2 acquisition. For this reason, it is considered

now, as an ally of the text-based collaborative approach, the intensive use of the text.

The text in the English classroom is the tool of a specific lesson. This lesson could be

divided into three different stages (Lindsay & Knight, 2006): pre-reading, while-reading

and post-reading activities, that would dissect the act of reading and the information

contained in the text while promoting meaningful agreement between the learner-

participants.

Pre-reading activities include all those practices and activities that precede the

act of reading. Some interesting purposes include the use of cover designs or blurbs to

make predictions in English, the presentation of some grammatical structures that

would have any relation to the text, or pre adjusting students’ vocabulary knowledge

with activities. The teacher might also present them before reading a model that has to

be completed afterwards. These activities “help the learners prepare for the task”

(Lindsay & Knight, 2006, p. 75), especially when brainstorming is practiced or any

other sort of “warm-up” task that would get them used to a specific semantic field, for

example.

While-reading activities are usually accomplished through rereading the excerpt

entailed as much as the activity requires while having a careful look at those structures

or elements of discourse that we want them to learn. This could be done

independently, during those sessions devoted to it, and in group or pair work. The last

will guarantee collaborative negotiations of meaning and rules that will assure learning

success. Besides, the information of the text provides teachers with “content

enhancement routines” (Centre for Research on Learning, 2001) that can either be

used to detect grammatical structures following a definite pattern or it can better be

useful for students to see rules take a “real” form in a real context. Students can pick

linguistic patterns and modify them out of the text domains, comment on them with the

class or analyse their form and possibilities. For example, the expression of wish form

might appear in a piece of text telling about the private desires of the main character.

After reading and recognising the “particular” use of their second language they have

to elaborate on other possible answers and compose their personal wishes. These

Page 18: “MOTIVATING ADOLESCENT READERS IN THE EFL … · “MOTIVATING ADOLESCENT READERS IN THE EFL CLASSROOM: THE NEW PARADIGM OF LITERACY ... The text is a complete and multifaceted

  18  

wishes can be related with the narrative expectancies they have at the moment of the

activity and be formulated like this: “I would not wish that end on the heroine”.

To finish, post-reading activities make relevant use of the interactive and dialogic

situations that correspond the text-based collaborative approach. When having finished

reading, everything we have seen anew, old or unexpected must be commented on,

analysed and studied interactively. At the end we have arrived at the idealistic reading

environment.

(…) Small-group practice is a key to the internalization of a strategy. It seems that students working in groups are forced to defend their choice of strategy and to explain their cognitive processes. Such interaction provides a review of the declarative, conditional, and procedural knowledge for both the explainer and the listener. Hacker (1998) contends that . . . [a]llowing students to work in groups provides learners with a source of feedback outside of their closed system, increasing the likelihood that errors will be detected and corrected. (Nokes & Dole, 2004, pp. 169–170)

English is learned through the dissection of the text, this provides us of a

context and allows us see language in use. The method gets us deeply and deeply into

context, that is why the stages serve motivational purposes too. All the activities and

textual practice are related to the propositional meaning of the text, however accessory

the relation might be. Some activities would rather be related with expression, with

everything we need to know in order to express the different functions of language and

be understood.

Other more traditional textual practices continue ignored during this program,

like the translation of the text, that had its concrete use and function in the past, but

which has no applicability in our contemporary curricular plan. However, writing

activities are still in close relation to reading, especially with intensive reading. Other

research supports the idea that writing activities help the reading instruction be

completed, because they are very useful for memorizing rules and practicing the

language (IESD, 2010). Therefore, writing tasks in collaboration with interactive

dynamics constitute the strategic use of the text as a major resource for second

language learning.

The student could be asked, for example, to take examples from his private

readings in English and search for grammatical patterns or words out of the same

semantic field that would be put in common in class. Their portfolio, either electronic or

not, would record the amounts of examples and self-made structures that correspond

their content-based reading. Every student can share his records with the rest of the

classmates and prepare exams and tests having under consideration the important role

of context for the understanding and production of a message in a linguistic event.

Page 19: “MOTIVATING ADOLESCENT READERS IN THE EFL … · “MOTIVATING ADOLESCENT READERS IN THE EFL CLASSROOM: THE NEW PARADIGM OF LITERACY ... The text is a complete and multifaceted

  19  

Student’s transition from reading in their L1 to read in the L2 must be supported

on the first place by other strategic resources apart from the monolingual dictionary.

Resources that would guide them through the learning acquisition, like word

identification, visual imagery, self-questioning and paraphrasing strategies (Centre for

Research on Learning, 2001) Today the governance of the image can be benefited

from the classroom. Visual imaginary may help them making deductions, imagining

forward, completing blank spaces and getting meaning from context. “(…) Text

comprehension requires an indirect transformation between the symbolic

representation of the text and the analogue mental model, while the comprehension of

an image requires establishing an analogy between the picture and the corresponding

mental model.” (Schnotz, 1993 as quoted in Chun y Plass, 1997, p. 380)

Page 20: “MOTIVATING ADOLESCENT READERS IN THE EFL … · “MOTIVATING ADOLESCENT READERS IN THE EFL CLASSROOM: THE NEW PARADIGM OF LITERACY ... The text is a complete and multifaceted

  20  

4.  Motivational  Strategies  Related  to  Reading  Texts  

This is the core point of the research paper; it gives details about how reading

comprehension in the target language becomes a motivational strategy and the axis of

the text-based collaborative approach to SLA. Not only Nuttal (1986) opinions that

reading is “like an infectious disease”, but also Gabilondo in his book Darse a la

Lectura (2012) states that reading is contagiously caught. He says that contagious

means contact, and that we have to deliberate over the kind of texts that are most

appropriate for young people. We have to do the same as we do with movies, talk and

talk about book reading. Compulsory reading is counterproductive according to

Teixidor (2007) and the effect of graded books is under question at this point.

Reading, which has been an objective on the first part of the investigation, is

now the strategy and the award. Its double nature is one of its benefits, being an aim

and an award at the same time (Bamford & Day, 2004). That is what makes students

recognise its importance as a life-long strategy for their careers and a pleasurable

experience.

According to an Oxford University research study, reading for pleasure predicts professional success. (…) During two decades, the research group of psychologist Max Taylor has been analysing the habits and activities of almost 20.000 adolescents who were willing to know which activities precede professional success when turning 30 years old. No extracurricular practice –like doing sports or watching cinema– examined in addition to reading, got an impact as significant as reading to professional success. (Saiz, 2012)10

The study presents some strategic dynamics that foster students’ love for

reading and learning English. The strategies in use are supported on the knowledge

that adolescent readers having acquired reading notions and an intermediate level of

English what they need now is to get in contact with new recreational experiences

through reading. They can manifest their dislike for reading but this is only funded on

the erroneous idea derived from their late experiences with academic reading.

The modern paradigm for struggling reading in the class is modified by

introducing a sense of pleasure in every reading venture, regardless of other more

pedagogical issues. This work does not intend to put such issues out of focus but to

change the hierarchy of educative principles. The reading program derived from these

                                                                                                               10 “Según un estudio de la Universidad de Oxford, la lectura por placer predice el éxito profesional. (…) Durante mas de dos décadas, el equipo de investigación del psicólogo Max Taylor analizó los hábitos y actividades de casi 20.000 jóvenes con ánimo de conocer qué actividades precedían el éxito profesional al cumplir los 30. Ninguna práctica extracurricular –como hace deporte o ir al cine–, evaluadas junto a la lectura, lograron tener un impacto significativo en el éxito profesional.” (Translated into English by Mara González de Ozaeta)

Page 21: “MOTIVATING ADOLESCENT READERS IN THE EFL … · “MOTIVATING ADOLESCENT READERS IN THE EFL CLASSROOM: THE NEW PARADIGM OF LITERACY ... The text is a complete and multifaceted

  21  

beliefs has multi strategic purposes, as explained before, and includes teachers and

educational professionals going through a formative training that helps assuring a

correct selection and adaption of the reading materials. Thus, having interesting,

suitable and accesible reading materials in the classroom is one of the best strategies,

as it Stephen Krashen (2002) states, “we know that more access to books results in

more reading” (p. 38). Following this principle education gets professionally aware of

the more democratic principle in our modern society, that culture must be made easily

accessible to everyone, no matter what economic or social background they belong to.

The last premise is cohesive with the model of Iceland for the “National curriculum

guides for pre-primary, compulsory and upper secondary education” (2011). The

Minister of Education, Science and Culture of that country established the six

“Fundamentals of Education”. These fundamentals, in order of appearance, are:

“literacy, sustainability, democracy, equality, health and welfare and creativity”. They

influence such pedagogical aspects as: the “choice of subjects and content of teaching,

play and study, the work procedures and methods taught ” and the “working methods

of teachers and other school staff.” (Icelandic Eurydice Unit, 2011) This investigation

sticks to the idea that the revaluation of literacy-oriented education and research in

Spain will improve the national curriculum and students’ level of excellence in the

international statistics. Because this is stablishing a new paradigm,

A dialogic pedagogy is unlike traditional pedagogy. Not only can it not be pre-programmed but it is likely to question the traditional social and political tenets of foreign language education. Furthermore, it sets new goals for language teachers –poetic, psychological, political goals that are not measurable on proficiency tests and do not constitute any easy-to-follow method. (Kramsch, 1993, p. 31).

As a means to elaborate on good motivational strategies based on the use of

the text, teachers need to know that the term motivation refers to three realities

afecting the personal conduct: intrinsic motivation, extrinsic motivation and amotivation.

This is the “theory of autodeterminacy” (Núñez-Alonso, et. al; 2005). According to this,

intrinsic motivation refers to that stimuli being fed by personal achievements, whereas

extrinsic motivation ambitions an exterior benefit, with a factual result. (Ryan & Deci,

2000)

Firstly, motivation can be defined simply as “the willing to undertake some

action or to keep doing it” (Marina, 2011, p.19)11. But this is not as simple as it may

seem: motivation depends on the individual’s willpower, so that any extraneous intent

to control it is limited and restricted by many other circumstances.

                                                                                                               11 (Translated from the original text into English by Mara González de Ozaeta).

Page 22: “MOTIVATING ADOLESCENT READERS IN THE EFL … · “MOTIVATING ADOLESCENT READERS IN THE EFL CLASSROOM: THE NEW PARADIGM OF LITERACY ... The text is a complete and multifaceted

  22  

Finally, if we get to know the nature of some motivational signs, we can

elaborate better strategies to produce it. It has been maintained during the course of

the research that a suitable reading (Nuttal, 1982) will immediately enhance more

reading. The following paragraphs give ideas and suggestions for making readings as

“suitable” and interesting as students want them to be. The last point numbers a series

of activities and goal supplying elements attending to extrinsic motivation, formative

assessment and the evaluation process.

4.1.  Selecting  and  Adapting  Materials  

Compulsory reading tasks cannot help capturing our students’ attention; on the

contrary, this fact deprives them of the resulting benefits of a truthful reading

experience (Teixidor 2007). Christine Nuttal (1982) also talks about “the ineffectiveness

of course texts. At their most extreme, texts of this kind are clearly intended, not to

convey a message, but to indicate how certain facts are expressed in the FL.” (p. 20).

Canonical literature, in particular classic works, so declared by theorists and

historians of literature, might not have the correct addressee in Spanish secondary

students. They could be unprepared for the linguistic or aesthetic elements included in

those texts or their inner message. The aesthetic delight depends on the reader’s

attitude towards the text, says Wolfgang Iser (1976); maybe our students have not the

proper attitude, but in addition they lack the aptitude and competences needed to enjoy

limitless time reading. “Graded” books reduce the reading experience and give

importance only to comprehension by means of eliminating the most important

elements of the reading venture: its “difference” (Barthes, 1973). Attraction, suspense,

enigma, etc; all those elements can create the sense of “difference” that the reader

experiments unique. This research work does not negate the positive effect of certain

classical texts traditionally offered by language teachers, but wants to put more

emphasis on the fact that the selection of the text must not follow any other requisite

but our learners’ language improvement and their adherence to good reading habits. In

order to achieve this goal the teacher’s assistance and counselling during the process

is essential.

Selecting materials for the classroom is operating over the whole range of

possible sources, materials, formats and genres available today. As Biancarosa &

Snow confess, “educators have now a powerful array of tools at their disposal” (2006,

p. 3). With the use of the text-based collaborative approach the learning process is

decentralized, yet the practitioner needs to develop professional knowledge and

Page 23: “MOTIVATING ADOLESCENT READERS IN THE EFL … · “MOTIVATING ADOLESCENT READERS IN THE EFL CLASSROOM: THE NEW PARADIGM OF LITERACY ... The text is a complete and multifaceted

  23  

abilities to select and adapt the text to the students. The main consideration is that

those texts are correctly adapted for the interest and expectancies of the readers.

“Many adolescents, both native and non-native English speakers, have out-of-school

literacy skills and interests that their teachers may not even know about, but which

could serve as a springboard for learning in the classroom” (Moje et al., 2004; Hull &

Schultz, 2002).

The teacher must determinate the range of topics available in accordance with

students’ opinions, and “give choices” and strategies (Baker, E. A., & Guthrie, J. 2010)

while allowing them to make the final choice out of the texts pre-selected. Teachers

should always keeping in their minds that “our choices as educators play a role in

shaping students’ choices”(Auerbach 1995, p.9).

Later on, students’ on going reporting of the books and texts already read make

the machinery of selection more precise and widen their reading experiences.

Furthermore, students with their discussions, critiques and comments in the classroom

start sharing a common context for learning that struggles their willingness to read

more and learn more things.

The adaptation process is that which follows texts’ convenience and the

preparation of the materials for the students. If there is something to omit or add in

order to easy their experience this is to be fulfilled before presenting them the texts.

This additional point of assistance assures their reading delight and tries freeing the

reader of the anxieties that follow his inexperience. This manipulation of the text wants

the uninformed reader to be as informed as a young reader needs be.

As a means to adapt the texts a whole process of assessment and reporting begins

through which the teacher considers various factors: the age group level, their

achievements, the curricular plan for the course and the different methods of

evaluation. Later on the practitioner starts having an idea of what are the students’

individual deficiencies and to what extent is it the text adaptable to them.

An adaptation procedure would include the decoration of some dense and too-

much-formal texts with pictures, funny footnotes, an appendix, or commentaries. It can

also include several modifications at the level of expression in order to diminish the

difficulty of some of the grammar and vocabulary included, but adapting a text not only

means lowering its composite structure and inner message. If it depicts a series of

supporting elements like hyperlinks, examples, film extracts, etc. it must prove being

very helpful. Everything that the teacher judges suitable for their access to that specific

text and motivating enough to maintain their reading attention. We can add a “Signpost

question”, in Nuttal’s words: “not to test, but to guide the students when they read,

directing their attention to the important points in the text, preventing them from going

Page 24: “MOTIVATING ADOLESCENT READERS IN THE EFL … · “MOTIVATING ADOLESCENT READERS IN THE EFL CLASSROOM: THE NEW PARADIGM OF LITERACY ... The text is a complete and multifaceted

  24  

off along a false track” (1982, p. 158). Signpost questions are relevant questions during

the reading process with the aim of making them all aware of concealed details and

hints in the text.

Adapting texts for our students is an open intervention that allows widening and

modifying the text to fit the context of the English classroom and students’ interests.

However, we do not want to low estimate their capacities. There have been proposed

other levelling systems aside from graded reading, “cloze tests” (Taylor, 1953) have

been lately used to manage each student’s reading skills. This method consists of

leaving blank spaces in the place of some words of a short piece of a text. Students

have to prove their capacity for filling up the blanks and from their mistakes it is

established the criteria of adaptation. Still, this system has proved to lower too much

their capacities and so, to diminish the effort and the interest of students.

This proposal considers more didactic the fact that the reader struggles with the

text’s message, albeit the message may get blurred or difficult to grasp. Through

rereading, , dialogue and activities all their problems can be resolved and their answers

completed.

Now that teachers have become “reading facilitators” (Shanahan & Shanahan,

2008 p. 48), let’s see why choosing authentic material to read against traditional

“graders” and classic literature, along with ICT and new media in the classroom is the

best option for making our students become avid readers.

a.  Authentic  Materials   Nunan and Miller (1995) define authentic materials as those that were “not created or

edited expressly for language learners”. We are entering the region of unavoidable

messages, inaccessible linguistic constructs and language immersion and yet, it is

affordable and advisable to our students. The main reason why this could work is that

there surely are reading strategies, which are common to both L1 and L2 readers,

including any language worldwide. Additionally, there exist other easy-to-acquire

strategies to comprehend the foreign language discourse and a lot of immersion and

speed reading practice before starting to gain overall understanding.

Leaving aside the levelling systems of other agents such as editorials and

professional educators the teacher of the English classroom can be a good reading

mediator between students and real or authentic materials in their second language.

Although the reading program is primarily concerned with the learner autonomy

(through self-assessment and natural approach to learning), the teacher’s intervention

will solve out the problems with non-guided reading events that would risk students’

Page 25: “MOTIVATING ADOLESCENT READERS IN THE EFL … · “MOTIVATING ADOLESCENT READERS IN THE EFL CLASSROOM: THE NEW PARADIGM OF LITERACY ... The text is a complete and multifaceted

  25  

willingness and attitude towards the reading act. “Using real examples is important

because these short texts will convey a message. They will help learners to understand

that reading involves understanding a message, rather than just sounding out the letter

of a word.” (Lindsay & Knight, 2006)

The use of authentic materials in the classroom is directly linked to such

theories as the “natural approach” to language (Krashen & Terrell, 1988) and the

“natural” learning process derived from adapted reading and interesting materials for

young people. “Reading can serve as an important source of comprehensible input and

may make a significant contribution to the development of overall proficiency.”

(Krashen & Terrell 1988, p. 131)

The natural approach consists in those practices applied to language

acquisition better than learning the language. The distinction between learning and

acquiring refers to the fact that any learning process would imply memorizing and

studying rules and formulas, while the acquisition of a language is supposed to occur

at the level of unconscious and during the natural use of the target language.

According to Krashen and Terrell’s study (1988) the natural approach is divided into

two main elements that specify the staging of the process of acquisition. Like the

reading program presented here, they give importance first to comprehension. If the

acquirer does not comprehend the language input, little is possible to do. First,

comprehension issues have to be attended and the second element is production.

Production is again divided in other progressive stages: halfway through the process

teachers’ intervention in the text allows the reader to make such natural progress real

(Krashen & Terrell 1988). Of course this kind of texts will surely break students’

linguistic and content expectancies, but the teachers’ adaptation of the text might

guarantee fewer problems without eliminating the engaging power of such tools. The

general tendency, as delivered by the IFIIE (2011), is to work to convince teachers to

use different types of books, fictional and non-fictional, divulgative documents,

magazines and newspaper articles, instead of the restricted use of traditional classic

literature.

Authentic materials are a motivational strategy, students might need knowing

the implication of their improvements and how close to real use their performances are.

Non-explicitly oriented materials for the classroom, like course books and impersonal

graded literature, will hearten their curiosity not only for language issues but for content

specific and cultural issues.

Overall comprehensibility meets the lexical and syntactic requirements for appropriateness in text diffculty. As mentioned earlier, semantic appropriateness requires a topic that is at least partly familiar and not overwhelmingly complex. And

Page 26: “MOTIVATING ADOLESCENT READERS IN THE EFL … · “MOTIVATING ADOLESCENT READERS IN THE EFL CLASSROOM: THE NEW PARADIGM OF LITERACY ... The text is a complete and multifaceted

  26  

most important, the text needs to be of genuine interest. (Krashen & Terrell, 1988, p. 137)

Of course authentic materials include the internet and the new technologies, as

these are also intended to be read by a native speaker, and to serve a communicative

or some functional aim (Peacock, 1997).

b.  ICT  resources  

The incorporation of technology in the language classroom (ICT) has radically changed

the teaching-learning dynamic in general, the reading practice in particular. Now the

teacher stays no longer in front of the students with the textbook in her/his arms waiting

for them to read aloud by turns. Now the practitioner can select a varied media to

attract students’ attention. However, these revolutionary educative practices that refer

to the use of the text on-line have only been put into practice in five European

countries, out of the half of the European members that agreed their inclussion (IFIIE,

2011). Spain is not one of them and in the transition to technological reading this work

analyses and gives some ideas about its use in EFL.

The incorporation of ICT permits the appliance of multiple sources of

information and implements motivating strategies in the classroom. It was recently

demonstrated by a study in the UK (Clark, Osborne and Dugdale, 2009) that secondary

students read more from such electronic sources as webs, blogs and social networks,

than the primary students (IFIIE, 2011). New technologies are giving an innovative

format to the medium of the text, to the extent that the relation between reader and text

changes radically and consequently the message that can be derived from its reading.

All the elements around the act of reading have an effect on the readers’ mind and

none of those should be misled. All these elements are referring to the pragmatics of

the reading performance and include such meaningful elements as the structure and

division of the text, the material it is printed on, the cover design, the illustrations it

might contain, etc.

Today, even the mechanics of reading have been changed by technology and

readers have to confront their reading activities with new and efficient competences.

For example, with the book format the reader just paged through it while reading,

nowadays the reader waits for the message to appear on a screen and reads its

content by dragging the mouse across the surface of the table. Teachers have to be

aware of the present panorama in order to create adapted strategies for their students

and to help them develop those new reading competences according to modern

Page 27: “MOTIVATING ADOLESCENT READERS IN THE EFL … · “MOTIVATING ADOLESCENT READERS IN THE EFL CLASSROOM: THE NEW PARADIGM OF LITERACY ... The text is a complete and multifaceted

  27  

exigencies: “technology is changing the reading and writing demands of modern

society. Reading and writing in the fast-paced, networked world require new skills

unimaginable a devade before.” (Biancarosa & Snow, 2006, p. 19)

Still, there are two divergent opinions in respect to the use of technology in the

language classroom. The supporters of the first one consider technology as a major

assistance in the dynamics of the class (Gallagher (2011); Duhigg (2012)) meanwhile

the defenders of the second opinion affirm it to be just another distractive element in

the classroom (Ravitch (2009); Carr (2008)). The two opinions are based either on a

positive or a negative perspective: the first considers technology a major assistance in

the dynamics of the class and the second regards it as an enemy against the new

generations’ learning progress, another distractor. The latter would probably think past

customs and its culture are being neglected today abandoning old good practices.

The present research supports the idea of profiting technological advances in

reading for better results. The opposition to technological advances will not help

programming an efficient reading program for present and future EFL students

because reading entails being more conscious than ever of the things around us. While

reading we get to know more about the world and the intricacies of its society. For this

reason, the experience can no longer be related to any kind of alienation or an old-

fashioned perspective; on the contrary, the reading task is not only the recover of the

past, its history and memory, but also the awareness of present time ideas and

situations.

New technologies present new formats and textual sources. Articles and

modern reports announce the innovations: “Vooks represent just a few examples of a

new genre that has been dubbed v-books, digit-books, multimedia books and Cydecks,

all with essentially the same concept: It’s a book…but wait, there’s more!” (Hesse,

2010, p. 1) and some other researchers have been denouncing the readers’ level of

distraction during the processing of information in such electronic environments (Carr,

2011)

Other texts in the field of ICT and new media include the broad category

electronic literaure. This innovative type of texts would work positively in the FL

classroom , albeit many people still do not know of what it consists, students will be

attracted by its innovative look and some of its intrinsic characteristics, of a kind that

produces suprising effects and demands high levels of interaction on the reader. The

only web completely devoted to this category of texts and to give support to associated

Page 28: “MOTIVATING ADOLESCENT READERS IN THE EFL … · “MOTIVATING ADOLESCENT READERS IN THE EFL CLASSROOM: THE NEW PARADIGM OF LITERACY ... The text is a complete and multifaceted

  28  

authors and artists is the Electric Literaure Organization (ELO)12 that includes among

other interesting things, a definition of the text category:

The term refers to works with important literary aspects that take advantage of the capabilities and contexts provided by the stand-alone or networked computer. Within the broad category of electronic literature are several forms and threads of practice, some of which are: - Hypertext fiction and poetry, on and off the Web - Kinetic poetry presented in Flash and using other platforms - Computer art installations which ask viewers to read them or otherwise have literary

aspects - Conversational characters, also known as chatterbots - Interactive fiction - Novels that take the form of emails, SMS messages, or blogs - Poems and stories that are generated by computers, either interactively or based

on parameters given at the beginning - Collaborative writing projects that allow readers to contribute to the text of a work - Literary performances online that develop new ways of writing (ELO, 1999)

This organization makes the distinction among digitalized literature and such

literary works only assumed to be written and read in such digital environments (ELO,

1999) These environments seem to have freed literature and the reading act from its

restricted paper format.

This points finishes making a remark on the demanding abilities of the modern

world, abilities that have to do primarily with the processing of new information via new

media and technologies. That is the reason why some researchers and education

professionals have been lately giving a new implicatures to literacy learning, the one

imposed, as it was mentioned before, in the modern world. The New London Group, for

example, composed by such experts as Cazden, Cope, Fairclough, Gee, et. al, got

organized around a project called A Pedagogy of Multiliteracies (1996). About the need

of such projects and investigations as the one they were all engaged in, they

mentioned that: “When technologies of meaning are changing so rapidly, there cannot

be one set of standards or skills that constitute the ends of literacy learning, however

taught.” (p. 64) One of the options to contribute life-long learning and professional

development is reading a lot in L1 and L2.

                                                                                                               12 http://eliterature.org/ (viewed the 29/08/12, 18:25) Published by Wordpress and Buddypress.

Page 29: “MOTIVATING ADOLESCENT READERS IN THE EFL … · “MOTIVATING ADOLESCENT READERS IN THE EFL CLASSROOM: THE NEW PARADIGM OF LITERACY ... The text is a complete and multifaceted

  29  

5.  The  Reading  Situation  In  Spain  and  the  EFL  Classroom  

This point of the study describes the contextual problems and the motives that justify

the use of such a program in the Spanish education. In Spain, in spite of the fact that

daily reading for pleasure is associated with better performance at school, the number

of students reading for enjoyment has drastically dropped during the last years (OECD,

PISA 2009 Database). So, the challenge for educators is to install a sense of pleasure

in reading by providing students with attractive materials. English language teaching in

this respect, not only has to select interesting materials to read, but also

comprehensible materials adapted to the needs and linguistic competences of students

(Bamford & Day, 2004).

To analyse the current situation in Spanish schools, some quantitative and

qualitative data was collected during a teaching practice period of three months in one

of the private bilingual schools of Madrid. Both students and teachers have given their

opinions about the reading activities in the EFL context and about their reading

preferences. These data was obtained from the answers to some questionnaires13 that

the author of this investigation elaborated for this purpose. Some secondary students

of various grades answered the questions here included, from 12 years old to 17 years

old. These students are on a private school in Madrid that is gradually incorporating

Content-based Learning derived from other bilingual programs worldwide. The results

of those tests highlight the necessity of getting organized around a program like this.

For example, as can be followed from the data obtained below (Fig.1) when secondary

students of different levels are asked upon the approximate hour-rate they spend

reading per week, the average rate descends qualitatively. This graph shows an

inversely proportional relationship between the variables represented, that is, the older

the secondary students are the less hours they spend reading. 14

                                                                                                               13 A copy of the questionnaires given and the results are annexed to the text. 14 The data refers to the significant descend of reading time exposure in whichever language the students chose to read: L1 or L2.

Page 30: “MOTIVATING ADOLESCENT READERS IN THE EFL … · “MOTIVATING ADOLESCENT READERS IN THE EFL CLASSROOM: THE NEW PARADIGM OF LITERACY ... The text is a complete and multifaceted

  30  

Graph # 1: Relation of average hour-rate per week of intensive reading amongst L1 or L2

students. Based on student’s answers to the questionnaire attached.

Based on preliminary research, the author of this proposal wants to contrast

more innovative uses of the text with traditional practices. For example, this study

questions the results that “graded readers” (EFR 2011, p. 2) and canonical literature,

widely used by English language teachers in Spain, have on students’ reading habits

and motivation. Another aspect to consider is that today in Spain many public and

private schools are levelling up their linguistic exigencies under bilingual programs

backed up by public funds (B. O. C. M, 09/2009)15. This fact encourages a new

educative procedure, more conscious of the importance of motivational strategies,

while ambitioning the new pedagogical gains derived from such activities as extensive

reading: learners’ autonomy, self-assessment, diversity and creativity.

The text of the L.O.E (Ley Orgánica de Educación)16 in Spain gives instructions

for considering the importance of a specific pedagogical hierarchy in which a special

attention is put to reading habits (Art. 19):

                                                                                                               15 Orden 4195/2009, de 8 de Septiembre, de selección de institutos púbicos de Educación Secundaria, por los que se llevará acabo la implantación de la enseñanza bilingüe en español/inglés en el curso 2010/2011. 16 Principios pedagógicos: 1. En esta etapa se pondrá especial énfasis en la atención a la diversidad del alumnado, en la atención individualizada, en la prevención de las dificultades de aprendizaje y en la puesta en práctica de mecanismos de refuerzo tan pronto como se detecten estas dificultades. 2. Sin perjuicio de su tratamiento específico en algunas de las áreas de la etapa, la comprensión lectora, la expresión oral y escrita, la comunicación audiovisual, las tecnologías de la información y la comunicación y la educación en valores se trabajarán en todas las áreas. 3. A fin de fomentar el hábito de la lectura se dedicará un tiempo diario a la misma. (Translated into English by Mara González).

1º  ESO   2º  ESO   3º  ESO   1º  BACH  Reading  hours  per  week   7,6   4,6   3,8   4,1  

0  

1  

2  

3  

4  

5  

6  

7  

8  

Reading  hours  per  week  

Page 31: “MOTIVATING ADOLESCENT READERS IN THE EFL … · “MOTIVATING ADOLESCENT READERS IN THE EFL CLASSROOM: THE NEW PARADIGM OF LITERACY ... The text is a complete and multifaceted

  31  

Pedagogical Principles: 1. At this moment a special attention would be paid to students’ diversity, individualized attention, and the prevention of learning difficulties, also at putting into practice the strengthening mechanisms as soon as those difficulties were detected. 2. Without prejudging its previous treatment in the areas of the step, reading comprehension, oral and written expression, audio-visual communication, Technologies of Information, communication and the education of moral values will be worked in all the areas. 3. With the sake of fomenting the reading habit it will be spent a diary period of time to the task. (BOE nº. 106 de 4/5/2006, p. 17158- 17207)

5.1.  Students  Demand  Interesting  Texts  

Students will value such a purpose themselves; they know about the effect that reading

texts in English would have on their studies. As statistical results have shown (Chart #

2) they confess in a 95% of the cases that reading in English could help them to

acquire the L2. They say they will surely learn more vocabulary and grammar

structures. Then, what is the problem with traditional reading in the classroom and the

course book design? Curriculums are organized around a set of pre-designed activities

and formulaic texts that go insistently around the same topics all over again. Students

get bored; they are over familiarized with the language of those texts. Wolfgang Iser

concludes that, “Experiences arise only when the familiar is transcended or

undermined; the grow out of the alterations or falsification of that which is already

ours.” (1976, pp. 131-2) and we could support our lessons in those alterations and

break with monotony by being meticulous with texts’ selection.

Chart # 2

1º  ESO  

2º  ESO  

3º  ESO    

1º  BACH  

100%  

86,7%  

100%  

85,7%  

13,3%  

14,3%  

Do  students  agree  that  to  read  in  English  is  useful?  

YES   NO  

Page 32: “MOTIVATING ADOLESCENT READERS IN THE EFL … · “MOTIVATING ADOLESCENT READERS IN THE EFL CLASSROOM: THE NEW PARADIGM OF LITERACY ... The text is a complete and multifaceted

  32  

Teachers do not only determine book selection, students offer their ideas and

describe their interests, too. In order for this idea to work better, periodic assessment,

even the report of their readings helps the teacher orient the selection more and more.

With the aim of demonstrating how important is to know our students’ opinion

over the range of topics and textual genres available to read the results of this pre test

about their literary preferences is evidences in the next chart (Chart # 3). This order of

inquiries could guide teachers towards solutions and effective reading programs. The

results reveal the range of literary genres most typically known by young participants.

They go along with the topics available and refer to novel, to narrative subgenres. Their

answers are not very ample and are based on the examples given in the questionnaire

and in other students’ answers. There is a marked tendency among girls and boys to

opinion as their other same-sex peers do, and only a minority differ. Hopefully, the text-

based collaborative approach to ELT might guide them towards more options and help

them encounter new personal experiences.

Chart # 3: Relation of percentages according to student’s preferences to read. The categories

are the ones they offered in their answers.

As it was pointed before, an overview such as this could be useful for teachers

and literacy instructors. They could get a general idea of the preferences of their

students and elaborate on an action plan from these. At first sight we could guess from

the chart that those probable same-sex choices are adventure on the part of males

with the 63,64% and romance on the part of females with the 45,45%. It is easy to

63,64%  

34,54%  9,1%  10,9%  

45,45%  

12,73%  

3,64%  

Literary  Genres  

Adventures  

Mistery  

Fantasy  

Sci-­‐[i  

Romance  

Humour  

Others  

Page 33: “MOTIVATING ADOLESCENT READERS IN THE EFL … · “MOTIVATING ADOLESCENT READERS IN THE EFL CLASSROOM: THE NEW PARADIGM OF LITERACY ... The text is a complete and multifaceted

  33  

discover that mystery, accompanied by the strategic feeling of suspense, and humour

will always have a positive effect on them also and that these particular group of

readers do not cooperate very well with fiction: either in the form of science fiction or

fantasy. The variety is only apparent, of the thousands of genres available today, only

the 3, 64% answered something different, meaning something not explicitly included in

the question form.

Additionally, we would have thought this generation of students are extensive

web readers, electronic users and would prefer those texts than any other. However,

from the data obtained, this author would suggest that adolescent’s use of new

technologies is limited by social conventions and virtual networks. Although the

majority of them do not use the web for extensive reading, but to search for interesting

cultural resources. They prefer textual formats which are unusually conventional, and

although preferable in most cases, this fact shows on the other hand their lack of

reading involvement.

Chart # 4

What is an evident clue and an important result in the results obtained from the

questionnaires is that adolescents demand interesting texts. This is a conclusion

derived from students’ answers to the question about their sincere love for reading. As

the chart reveals (Chart # 4), just a few of the answers were positive, and the chart

reveals these are directly related with their level of maturity, that is, the grade of studies

in which they are studying when they participate in this study.

83,33%  

40,74%  

5,55%   1,85%  

READING  FORMAT  Book   Magazine   Newspaper   Others  

Page 34: “MOTIVATING ADOLESCENT READERS IN THE EFL … · “MOTIVATING ADOLESCENT READERS IN THE EFL CLASSROOM: THE NEW PARADIGM OF LITERACY ... The text is a complete and multifaceted

  34  

Chart # 5

In the group of 1º E.S.O the positive majority was reached with the 58,5% of

students confessing their love for reading and only the 5’9% out of 100% to negative

answers. The higher the grade of students being questioned the less they like reading

and the more they make of this phenomeno a fact dependent on the interest of the text.

The peak of depend percentage gets reached in 1º Bach, this obtains a 77,8%. It

appears that their levels of exigency grow synchronicly with their age and level of

maturity. Is it a consequence of adolescents rebel attitude? Or is it a problem of

educative practices being wrongly adapted? We have to understand that personal

growth and maturity define more and more our likes and dislikes, our behaviour and

character. As a result, young people will surely be more exigent and demand good and

interesting experiences. This fact could be a consequence of boredom, as Bereiter and

Bird (1985) announced:

By the time adolescent students are being challenged by disciplinary texts, literacy instruction often has evaporated altogether or has degenerated into a reiteration of general reading strategies (the general study skills that have been the mainstay of “content area reading”)– most likely to benefit only the lowest-functioning students. (as cited by Shanahan & Shanahan, 2008, p. 45)

If students get bored with the monotony of the texts and topic available at the

classroom, let’s better present them more varied material: “this includes traditional

0  

10  

20  

30  

40  

50  

60  

70  

80  

1º  ESO   2º  ESO   3º  ESO   1º  BACH  

Do  students  enjoy  reading?  

YES  

NO  

DEPENDS  

Page 35: “MOTIVATING ADOLESCENT READERS IN THE EFL … · “MOTIVATING ADOLESCENT READERS IN THE EFL CLASSROOM: THE NEW PARADIGM OF LITERACY ... The text is a complete and multifaceted

  35  

written forms such as books, magazines, documents, and newspapers. It also

encompasses information and communication technologies, such as the Internet,

email, and text messaging, as well as text integrated with various videos and television

media” (Leu, Kinzer, Coiro, & Cammack, 2004: As cited in International Association for

the Evaluation of Educational Achievement IEA, 2009).

Another aspect to take into account is that among psychological studies,

adolescents, that big age group that corresponds to the ages of 11-12 to 30, suffers a

turning point in their cognitive processes that allows them developing their abstract

thought (Inhelder & Piaget, 1955). This could also be the reason why they fight

common strategies in education against practices more oriented to their reflections and

anxieties. According to Stephen Krashen (2004, 2011), it could also be due to the lack

of accessible reading materials. There are various hypotheses, but their demand is

easy to answer back with some of the practices suggested in the program.

5.2.  Teachers’  Inclination  Towards  The  Action  Plan   Such interventions of the teacher as the ones presented in this study were valued and

consulted with professional teachers of English in the private school in which at least

one hour per week was devoted to reading aloud. They gave their agreement on

including or not such elements of assistance to their practice as: the need of a pre-

reading context, the continuous assessment of students ‘likes and the appropriate use

of the dictionary. These questions were mainly tested in order value teachers’

disposition to action in the field of high school literacy.

The chart below (Chart # 6) shows how teachers’ level of agreement or

disagreement on these issues is mostly balanced. When they are asked about the

need for a pre-reading context that would introduce them to the prosecution of a task

with a goal entailed, teacher’s agreement is complete. The 100% of the teachers

suggest putting into context the reading text. The problem is the variety of texts that

avoids sharing a particular context in the classroom. The latter could be made before

reading a text together or with an established narrow reading program. Narrow reading

refers to independent reading but over a common theme or genre; that is, the teacher

can select the texts according to some common variable (e.g. detective stories, drama,

comic books), consequently the learning context would be built around that variable

and the preliminary element discussed here would be possible.

Page 36: “MOTIVATING ADOLESCENT READERS IN THE EFL … · “MOTIVATING ADOLESCENT READERS IN THE EFL CLASSROOM: THE NEW PARADIGM OF LITERACY ... The text is a complete and multifaceted

  36  

Chart # 6: Indicates those strategies that might help students comprehend and understand the

text.

The second aspect involved in obtaining the comprehension and enjoyment of

SL readers is the periodic assessment that will be followed during the program. This

method proved being beneficial to educative gains and goals, now having students

giving their opinions and making their own choices can struggle participation and

commitment to the classroom. They even report their independent readings and give

their partners recommendations17. Instead, not all teachers agreed on this issue, and

although a 75% approved this strategy, 25% of the teachers who were interrogated

were undecided on this issue. Avoiding dialogue and consent among teachers and

students is out of question here, a program like this, although revised and adapted to

each school necessities would never work under the premise of restriction or obligatory

elements.

The last item points to the use of a reference tool for reading comprehension,

the dictionary. According to literacy research studies:

Unless low verbal ability students are somehow able to improve their ability to derive meaning from context, dictionary use should be encouraged. On the other hand, it appears that many high verbal ability students refer to the dictionary when they have already correctly guess the meaning, a finding confirming that of Hulstijn. Teachers should be aware of these tendencies and be prepared to offer different strategy assistance to different types of learners. It is important to note that although the majority of subjects in this study had previous classes in which guessing from context and dictionary use were addressed, this instruction was minimal. Intense instruction in either area might have produced different results. (Knight, 1994, p. 295)

                                                                                                               17 See report sheet model attached.

The  need  of  a  pre-­‐reading  context  

Continuous  assesment  of  students'  likes  

The  students  use  appropriately  the  

diccionary  

62,5%  25%  

25%  

100%  75%  

12,5%  

Assuring  Students'  Comprehension  and  Enjoyment  of  the  text  

Disagree   Undecided   Agree  

Page 37: “MOTIVATING ADOLESCENT READERS IN THE EFL … · “MOTIVATING ADOLESCENT READERS IN THE EFL CLASSROOM: THE NEW PARADIGM OF LITERACY ... The text is a complete and multifaceted

  37  

Thus, an intermediate position referred to dictionary use must be encouraged

among practitioners. Specially because depending on our learner or reader skills and

their level of dependence, their use will be different. In the chart (# 6) it was revealed

that teachers find unsatisfactory the dictionary use of their students. The higher

percentage, 62,5% disagree the affirmative fact given. This would demand better

commands on the part of the teacher and more practice in order to students to get

familiar with this tool. Besides, we should strive for making them understand and share

the love for language items, particularly the interest for word knowledge. All the

intricacies of word meanings and usages can be accessed through the dictionary and

its usage might depend on that fundamental factor, personal spirit of inquiry.

Teacher’s opinions at these and other respects have to do with their proper way

of approaching the reading issues in the classroom: the materails they make or would

make use of, the strategies that they would se for such aims, etc. The readiness of the

research did not allowed an personal interview, in which they could reflect more on

these aspects and give their own opinion, for this reason their answer are not very

coherent sometimes and their position about this respects is yet unclear. Besides,

there is no consensus on this issue, academc goals are not put in common. They

probably know the effects of reading in the life-long learning of individual students and

its importance for L2 acquisition, but exclude it from their practices so much as from

students’ lifes. Their views toward materials and resources that could enhance reading

are recorded in this chart of percentage values (Chart # 7). The teacher are the same

eigth teachers tested before, only two of them are natives and male practitioners, the

rest are Spanish and the majority do not reach the 45 years old.

Their answers at this respect (Chart # 7) show a clear tendency towards one of

the materials, “the use of ICT”, with a 87’5 % of agreement. But at the same time the

book is risen as the preferable choice for the 62’5%. Although apparently incongruent,

the phenomena probably coincides with that modern trend among adult generations of

teachers trying to cope with technological progress and traditional formats’ benefits at

the same time. In their opinions and comments is reflected the idea that although

getting used to new media and technology, they have the responsibility of keeping alive

other traditional formats, such as book reading. The chart relfects the transitional

period that is taking place in socio-cultural and educational environments today when

the book format is still an accesible resource for more older teachers, not having the

habit of searching on the web for new innovations. The 62,5% manifest their

preference for the traditional book format, the 25% disagrees and seeks new reading

resources support.

Page 38: “MOTIVATING ADOLESCENT READERS IN THE EFL … · “MOTIVATING ADOLESCENT READERS IN THE EFL CLASSROOM: THE NEW PARADIGM OF LITERACY ... The text is a complete and multifaceted

  38  

Chart # 7: According to teachers which are the materials best fitted for imporving reading in L2?

Still, an extensive majority trusts graded books as a resource for reading

motivation, although in this work they are taken as pleasure-cancelling reading

choices. The 62,5 % is clearly decided to make use of them, probably because it

facilitates the teacher’s role, and only a 12,5% disagrees. Of course, that 62,5% is the

same percentage that appears undecided in reference to teachers getting aware of the

new literary trends, because these are the costs of non-graded books selection. Again,

only 25% of the English teachers are aware of the literary trends available today for

their students, impliying that teachers do not feel responsible of this issue and how

important their action and involvement would be. Indeed, the 12,5 % find their

formative knowledge innecesary and disagree.

The  use  of  graded  books  

Awareness  of  new  literary  trends  

The  use  of  ICT     Preference  for  the  traditional  book  format    

12,5%   12,5%   12,5%   25%  25%  

62,5%  12,5%  

62,5%  

25%  

87,5%  62,5%  

Materials  &  resources  for  improving  reading  Disagree   Undecided   Agree  

Page 39: “MOTIVATING ADOLESCENT READERS IN THE EFL … · “MOTIVATING ADOLESCENT READERS IN THE EFL CLASSROOM: THE NEW PARADIGM OF LITERACY ... The text is a complete and multifaceted

  39  

6.  A  Purpose  of  Reading  Program  as  a  Preliminary  to  Action  

The reading program outlined below presents the general ideas and fundamental

elements that have to be considered if a program like this is to be applied to any

educative curriculum in the context of Spanish education. Some of the ideas introduced

before in this research work now they are inserted in the structural exigencies of such a

purpose, coordinated with the elements of other similar programs (Krashen & Terrell,

1988; Nuttal, 1996; Biancarosa & Snow, 2006) and educational researches, as well as

with the innovations presented in this paper. The overall program is in synchronicity

with the curricular purposes of EFL education and it meets the general exigencies in

the teaching lesson: Presentation, practice and production (PPP) (Harmer, 2009). Only

that here the element of cohesion is the text, and the text is understood as an element

of pleasurable immersion in the L2.

The following purpose is sequenced in three procedural steps, which are

explained in detail in each of the following sections. This three-step structure attends to

method exigencies rather than to a temporal sequence, because various elements

occur synchronically and all of them take part in the action plan guided towards the use

of the text in the classroom and out of the classroom. However, the independence of

the reader is confirmed in the selection and management of one particular text, in and

out of classroom and the collaborative lessons are given around various other texts

that the teacher or students bring to class.

The strategies included on the reading program below have taken into

consideration the number of difficulties the students deals with, such as teenage

students’ lack of involvement, vocabulary deficits and the structural dissimilarities

between their L1 reading and the L2. It coordinates the two most important missions: to

read for pleasure, on the one hand, and to learn from the motivation derived from it, on

the other. “Becoming a competent reader has a direct effect on the motivation for

reading, a fact that, in its turn, helps acquiring reading abilities.” (IFIIE, 2011, p. 65)18

6.1.  Pre-­‐assessment  and  the  Process  of  Selection  

The structure of this first step is primarily established around the teacher’s role

because he or she would make the effort in which resides the importance of the overall

program. Their role depends on their preliminary and continuous professional

                                                                                                               18 Convertirse en un lector competente también incide en la motivación por la lectura, lo cual, a su vez, facilita la adquisición de destrezas lectoras. (Translated into English by Mara González).  

Page 40: “MOTIVATING ADOLESCENT READERS IN THE EFL … · “MOTIVATING ADOLESCENT READERS IN THE EFL CLASSROOM: THE NEW PARADIGM OF LITERACY ... The text is a complete and multifaceted

  40  

development, which will guarantee the quality of their guidance as reading models.

This development enriches their knowledge about sociology, psychology, literature and

the arts, science and the news. The new role of the teacher demands new awareness

and orientation, the supply of their conformism with constant research and work

towards building on a proficient generation of readers and learners. Teachers’ personal

experiences and the development of strategic uses of the text will have a positive effect

on the students.

The dialectic of the program consists on, as followed from the table (Fig. 1), the

pre-assessment as a preliminary study and dialogue among teacher and students and

the periodic assessment, as the maintenance of that dialogue and interchange of

ideas; all in sake of finding the most suitable and interesting of texts. This periodic

assessment is to be preserved all through the course. Then, the teacher’s selection

and adaptation of the authentic materials begins while the class dynamics is

established and the method of the approach to ELT is explained to students.

Fig. 1

Of course, the development of a program like this would require infrastructural

adaptation as well (Biancarosa & Snow, 2006), as long as the reading tasks require:

the adaptation of the room for the reading sessions, the school library and the class

library association, research materials to values assessment and text reports, teacher

teams; “meeting regularly to discuss students they have in common and to align

1st  STEP  

Pre-­‐assessment  

Student  

Teacher    

Selection   CRITERIA  

Interest  

Variety  

Authenticity  

Suitability  

Adaptation  

Text-­‐Reader  Mediation  

Prediction  

Action  Plan  

Infrastructural  exigencies  

Room  Adaptation  

Library  

Research  Supplies  

Teacher  Teams  

Periodic  Assesment  

Page 41: “MOTIVATING ADOLESCENT READERS IN THE EFL … · “MOTIVATING ADOLESCENT READERS IN THE EFL CLASSROOM: THE NEW PARADIGM OF LITERACY ... The text is a complete and multifaceted

  41  

instruction” (Biancarosa & Snow, 2006). In relation to this point, collaboration with

organizations and institutions out-of-school will also help to achieve our goals. For

example, the idea of some lectures and professionals’ visiting the high school to talk

about anything related to reading acts will break with monotony and revive our

student’s interest. In order to make the selection process more accessible to teachers,

search engines and other web resources should be organized by the school, apart

from a list of up-to-date analysis and text reports that would orient the search.

Later during the adaptation process, the teacher works as a text-reader

mediator and responds at the same time to the infrastructural needs. By text-reader

mediator this author understands the series of facilitations that the teacher can bring

for the successful result of the reading-communicative act. Of course, the interpretation

and the imaginary entailed on the process stay within the reader-text domain, this is

primarily independent, and although later the exchange of ideas will be propitiated.

6.2.  Self-­‐sustained  Reading   In order to maintain a feasible program in the action plan, we have to consider before

some of the goals that students must be asked to fulfil. These are introduced here for

the first time although in relation to independent reading tasks that being non-

compulsory will demand strategic rewards to encourage them. When the teacher

presents the texts to the students, they make their own choice among the variety they

have been given access to, yet some norms have to be discussed before, like the non-

reversibility of their choices. Students might argue that they do not like the text after all

and that they cannot finish it for various reasons. All those who sustain their reading

and elaborate on a good critique and a text report will get prized at the end: either with

points or with other system that would win their participation.

Considering their choices or their possible disinterest or incapability to choose

among the texts given, they must understand how likes and dislikes change in relation

to the amount of experiences that we have as readers. Of course we might encounter

difficulties and boredom sometimes, but through all of these experiences, as stranger

as they may appear, we explore ourselves.

Page 42: “MOTIVATING ADOLESCENT READERS IN THE EFL … · “MOTIVATING ADOLESCENT READERS IN THE EFL CLASSROOM: THE NEW PARADIGM OF LITERACY ... The text is a complete and multifaceted

  42  

Fig. 2

In the first place our students will choose their reading text attending to social

factors. They will probably be careful with choosing something that their peers won’t

find strange or different. They will try to make their choice in accordance with their

expectancies and values, but more and more these choices will turn personal or will be

roundly based on the recent experiences or in view of the goals they have to reach.

Fig. 2 of this point shows the structure of the second step, when students make

their reading choice and start reading independently as a means to acquire more

autonomy in their personal learning interests. They will read independently in the class,

precisely to try fostering new self-sustained reading encounters out of it: at their home,

on the bus or in the library. These encounters with the text during long sessions of

silent sustained reading practices will create a favourable atmosphere in the class, a

context of common interest and study, which is very motivating. They will learn from

the respect of others concentration and try making of their particular experience a

positive one. The teacher will profit these sessions to bring them strategies and to work

as a model: the teacher reads as well as uses her text to advise the students and to

2nd  Step  

Student   Choice  of  TEXT  1  

OUT-­‐of-­‐class  Reading  

eFolio  

Portfolio  

Self-­‐sustained  Reading   Report  Sheet  

IN-­‐class  Reading   Reading  Strategies  

L1-­‐L2  

Dictionary  

L2  

Independent  Reading  

Collaborative  Dialogue  

Teacher  

Role  Model  

Goal  Provider  

Activities  

Tests  &  Quizzes  

Strategies  Provider  

Comprehension  of  the  Text  

Linguistic  

Aesthetic  

Speci[ic  

Page 43: “MOTIVATING ADOLESCENT READERS IN THE EFL … · “MOTIVATING ADOLESCENT READERS IN THE EFL CLASSROOM: THE NEW PARADIGM OF LITERACY ... The text is a complete and multifaceted

  43  

stimulate their reading. The steps through comprehension can be divided into three

main meaning mechanisms: the linguistic, the learner’s familiarization with the

structure of the target language, the aesthetic and the specific, entailing cultural

understanding.19

Independent reading could be encouraged through reports20 and activities to be

organized and compiled by them in their portfolios either electronic or not. Although

folios have various possibilities that would help sustaining their motivation, like voice

recorders to hear the student read-aloud sessions, with quizzes, photos and post

advices, etc. There is a research study going on in Canada, they have elaborated on a

model of efolio, ePEARL: Electronic Portfolio Encouraging Active Reflective Learning21.

It can be a useful suggestion, that proves how important is the portfolio “to capture

students' metacognitive processes and evidence of learning” (CSLP, 2009). They

declare “self-regulation”, so important at this point of the program, “a LIFE SKILL”.

The reflective mood of our students, triggered by reading, is later used to

debate and dialogue. The teacher assures an effective dialogue that includes the

opinion of everybody and whose topics are more or less negotiated through.

6.3.  Collaborative  Learning  

This point resumes the main ideas concerning that step of the program that

corresponds to class dynamics: reading texts together and putting them in common at

the level of its linguistic, aesthetic and specific meaning (see Fig. 3). The process is

task oriented and is divided into pre reading activities, while reading and post reading

activities. Meanwhile, the rest of skills get involve to bring students the opportunity of

learning from various perspectives, although the element of cohesion continues being

the text.

                                                                                                               19 Some other authors have used similar categories to approach text instruction, but those are not useful for this purpose. The current classification is based in Krashen and Terrel (1988, pp. 131-142) sequential strategies for comprehension issues that resemble the ones here explained; Nuttal’s (1982), who rated the strategies again from the most important to the more accessory and the Fifteen elements of Effective Adolescent Literacy Programs (p.12) in the report Reading Next: A Vision for Action and Research in Middle and High School Literacy, written by Biancarosa and Snow (2004). 20 See Report Sheet Model attached. 21 A Software of the Centre for the Study of Learning and Performance (2009). The Learning Toolkit [Computer software]. Montreal, Canada: Centre for the Study of Learning and Performance, Concordia University. Version 1.0. Location: http://doe.concordia.ca/cslp/ICT-LTK.php

Page 44: “MOTIVATING ADOLESCENT READERS IN THE EFL … · “MOTIVATING ADOLESCENT READERS IN THE EFL CLASSROOM: THE NEW PARADIGM OF LITERACY ... The text is a complete and multifaceted

  44  

Fig. 3

Interdisciplinary text usage is the main strategy of a classroom dynamism that

will motivate FL students. So that the text now not only mingles with the lessons, but

with other disciplines that widen the context and its implications for learning. All such

theories (Harmer, 2009) about the organization of the classroom according to

psychological and pedagogical reasons, like the variable levels of attention, the variety

of activities, the cooperative work, etc; are related to the secret of the PPP structure:

Presentation, practice and production. With intensive reading practices we can do that

again and devote presentations to capture the students attention or to introduce any

enigma or clues about the following session, then we practice while reading. The levels

of exposure to the target language while reading are meaningful and get the reader

involve in real language use, the same use that a native speaker makes of its

language. In Spain, while our students won’t have many chances to practice the

3rd  Step   Choice  of  Text  2  

Student  

Task-­‐oriented  

Pre-­‐reading  

While-­‐reading  

Post-­‐reading  

Collaborative  Learning   message  

linguistic  

aesthetic  

speci[ic  

Teacher   Interdisciplinary  activities  

Lessons  

Presentation  

Practice    

Production  

Page 45: “MOTIVATING ADOLESCENT READERS IN THE EFL … · “MOTIVATING ADOLESCENT READERS IN THE EFL CLASSROOM: THE NEW PARADIGM OF LITERACY ... The text is a complete and multifaceted

  45  

language out of the school setting, we have to exploit the text and questions read in the

text through interaction. That would be the main activity of production in the text-based

approach, but what about writing? This skill could also get integrated easily with the

literacy-based curricula. Students can start expressing themselves through reading and

do it proficiently because they are more and more immersed in their reading activities.

Multi-strategic activities and goals reveal the real turn of education that the

program strives for. Without course books and workbooks but within discourses of

various kinds and enjoying activates the design of supporting materials and resources

could resemble some of these ideas:

! Taboo games can be played in order to help them memorized some vocabulary

they are familiar with, probably through reading.

! In order to potentiate their imagination, they are asked to make a drawing

picture of anything they are reading about.

! The use of slogans or engaging messages on the board in which they can

participate too. Like with the analogy fiction/reality inspired by reading: “I READ,

I Master the World”, “I READ I fly high above the moon”, “I READ I fight in an

epic battle”, “I READ I feel in love with the gardener”, etc.

! Sustained reading sessions can be accompanied by soft music that inspires

them and help them get concentrated on their reading.

! The teacher introduces a different part of a book, or types of texts each day

adding more vocabulary knowledge and engaging them in the class dynamics.

! Students are asked to evaluate ambiguity in a text and to discuss about the

examples with their classmates.

! The teacher could compile the texts that are going to be used in the class in a

funny and colourful anthology and give a copy to each student.

! Project work might be a very good goal for our students and their evaluation.

Either in groups, pairs or individually they are told to project something related

with their texts.

! The teacher uses visual strategies to encourage more reading for pleasure out

of class. He/she could show the students photos of famous people reading,

quotes or aphorisms that would inspire them to read more, to explore more.

! Identify the book by the cover or by a famous quote.

! Match the title of the text with its blurb or short summary. (Bamford & Day,

2004)

! Visiting public libraries and bookshops as a reward to expert readers.

Page 46: “MOTIVATING ADOLESCENT READERS IN THE EFL … · “MOTIVATING ADOLESCENT READERS IN THE EFL CLASSROOM: THE NEW PARADIGM OF LITERACY ... The text is a complete and multifaceted

  46  

! Make them know about the force of the first paragraph, the information

contained, its importance at the level of expectations and its function as

evidences of talent.

! The Best Reader certificate of merit. (Bamford & Day, 2004)

! Encourage them to have a notebook along with their reading text, to take notes,

quotes or reflections recorded easier. This means being active readers.

! Texts and the movies based on them, the relation between cinema and

literature through movie clips and text extracts could be analysed, and even

role-play might be very influential.

! Reading and writing micro-texts or micro-tales.

! Activities with poetry, like creating a chain poem from a preliminary model, or

brainstorming feelings from words or images.

! Discover them book-treasures, such as bookplates: their history and some witty

examples. Tell them to search for more examples on the web.

! Work with comic-books reading

! Cryptograms and Ideograms, the beauty of language from various perspectives.

! The teacher works on a study guide for the students in order to incorporate

some narrow reading about an author or a literary style.

Page 47: “MOTIVATING ADOLESCENT READERS IN THE EFL … · “MOTIVATING ADOLESCENT READERS IN THE EFL CLASSROOM: THE NEW PARADIGM OF LITERACY ... The text is a complete and multifaceted

  47  

7.  Conclusions  

It was the aim of this work to demonstrate that a program based on the primacy of

reading texts would be more coherent and precise with the demands of the modern

world and the needs of Spanish educational system than the present circumstances of

language instruction. With so abundant flow of information and our access to multiple

media and technology the linguistic abilities, both at the level of reception and

production, have been widen out so much that recent studies have totally changed

their perspective in favour of a more basic education, that is, a new concern for

literacy. Furthermore, this pedagogy not only regains the consciousness of the

practitioners and students involved, but recovers the joy for more subjective

participation: creativity, imagination, etc.

This investigation addressed all those professionals that work to adapt the

curriculum of middle and high school foreign language teaching, from the Ministry of

Education in Spain to the particularity of the classroom exercise, without leaving aside

organisms or institutions of coordination: families, libraries, bookshops and editorials,

media and web resources, etc. The curricular guidelines for ELT must be re-evaluated

along with the orientation of language instruction in intent to establish a dialogue

between traditional and conventional uses of the text as an educational resource.

Harvard researchers point that this “curriculum now, needs to mesh with different

subjectivities, and with their attendant languages, discourses, and registers, and use

these as a resource for learning.” (Cazden, et. al 1996, p. 72)

First, the theoretical overview revealed the emerging research in favour of a

more artifactual instruction, in which lessons get build up between teachers and

students at the same time and whose development is more led by intuition and the

interchange of ideas. Other studies had already proposed that the teacher selected

and adapted an amount of texts for the free use of students, but the majority of

innovations in this regard, were directed to English native speakers. We explained that

such authentic texts could be much more motivating, and those strategies could get

good results even in L2 if those were properly integrated in our modern curriculums.

Everything indicates that text exposure at the level of exploitation gives a “critical turn”

to pedagogy, rather than letting the class get developed around a structured course

book of decontextualized language instruction with dehumanized addressees, now

multiple texts will respond to the needs of every student and every reader in the

classroom.

Other innovations have been lately planned to SLA in our public educational

system, the so-called programs of immersion. Still, these other programs had forgotten

Page 48: “MOTIVATING ADOLESCENT READERS IN THE EFL … · “MOTIVATING ADOLESCENT READERS IN THE EFL CLASSROOM: THE NEW PARADIGM OF LITERACY ... The text is a complete and multifaceted

  48  

the fact that students are individual subjects with particular experiences; therefore, we

suggested that in foreign language instruction the only terms to orient adequately are

variance, variety and choice. They have also forgotten the most efficient and

productive of the learning processes, the reading act. We insisted all through the study

on using the term “act” because reading implies an action that the reader has to

undertake, otherwise the experience is incomplete. It is the result of that action what

determines their involvement, their participation and propitiates the learning process.

Second, and supported on the statistical results obtained, this study reasserts

the importance of interest and enjoyment in the resources that are to be used in the

classroom, so demand our students. It is important, especially in middle and higher

education, to motivate adolescent students to be avid readers, sustained in the fact

that they always long for new experiences. Adolescents have already turned an age of

discovery in which their amazement and capacity for abstraction allow them go beyond

the factual reality and step into the inner world of imagination and creation. Their new

abilities along with the guidance of teachers and peers can bring them motives and

interesting choices to explore.

Reading is more than a pastime; it’s a subliminal education. Artistic expression doesn’t always need a conscience and some of the best books I’ve read were escapism. But they and more serious books have the power to entertain while also enriching vocabulary, reinforcing spelling and prompting profound analysis not only of the story’s characters but, in comparison, that of the reader. (Harrison, 2012)

The final focus of inquiry was the elaboration of a reading program combining the

exercise of the classroom with the maintenance of motivating attitudes among

students, specially through pleasure and free-to-choose reading texts of multiple

orders, with discourses of different origin and nature, trying to cope with the best

choices for them. The program articulates two uses of the text, both extensive and

intensive practices but the two propitiate dialogue and collaborative learning either in

respect to language learning and acquisition or to negotiate content meaning and

individual interpretations.

Page 49: “MOTIVATING ADOLESCENT READERS IN THE EFL … · “MOTIVATING ADOLESCENT READERS IN THE EFL CLASSROOM: THE NEW PARADIGM OF LITERACY ... The text is a complete and multifaceted

  49  

8.  References  

- Agencia Ejecutiva en el Ámbito Educativo, Audiovisual y Cultural (2011). La

enseñanza de la Lectura en Europa: Contextos, Políticas y Prácticas. Bruselas:

Androulla Vassiliou. [Online Version] Available at

http://eacea.ec.europa.eu/education/eurydice

- Álvarez, Mª. A. (1997). Destrezas de la Lectura. Madrid: U.N.E.D.

- Auerbach, E. (1995) The politics of the ESL classroom: Issues of power in

pedagogical choices, in Tollefson, J. (ed.) Power and Equality in Language

Teaching, Cambridge: Cambridge University Press.

- Baker, E. A. & Guthrie, J. (2010). Reading motivation among African American

and Caucasian students. Voice of Literacy. Podcast retrieved from

http://voiceofliteracy.org

- Bamford & Day, R. R. (2004). Extensive Reading Activities for Teaching

Language. Cambridge: Cambridge University Press.

- Biancarosa, C. & Snow, C. E. (2006). Reading next—A vision for action and

research in middle and high school literacy: A report to Carnegie Corporation of

New York (2nd ed.) Washington, DC: Alliance for Excellent Education.

- Carell, Devine & Eshey. (1988). Interactive approaches to second language

reading. Cambridge: Cambridge University Press.

- Carr, N. (2008). Is Google Making Us Feel Stupid? What the Internet is doing to

Our Brains. The Atlantic Magazine. [Online Version] Available at:

http://www.theatlantic.com/magazine/archive/2008/07/is-google-making-us-

stupid/6868/

- Cazden, C; Cope, B; Fairclough, N; Gee, J. et al (1996). A Pedagogy of

Multiliteracies: Designing Social Futures. Harvard Educational Review; 66, 1;

ProQuest Research Library p. 60.

- C. E. F (2001) Common European Framework of References for Languages,

Cambridge: C.U.P. Available at:

http://www.coe.int/t/dg4/linguistic/Source/Framework_EN.pdf

- Clark, Osborne and Dugdale (2009). Reaching Out with Role Models: Role

models and young people’s reading. England & Wales: National Literacy Trust.

- Chun y Plass, J. L. (1997) Research on Text Comprehension in Multimedia

Environments. Language Learning and Technology. 1(1), 60- 81. [Online]

Available: http://llt.msu.edu/vol1num1/chun_plass/default.html

- Duff & Maley (1990). Literature. Oxford: O.U.P.

Page 50: “MOTIVATING ADOLESCENT READERS IN THE EFL … · “MOTIVATING ADOLESCENT READERS IN THE EFL CLASSROOM: THE NEW PARADIGM OF LITERACY ... The text is a complete and multifaceted

  50  

- Duhigg, C. (2012) The Power of Habit: Why We Do What We Do, and How to

Change. U.S: Random House.

- Eliot, C. W. (1896) The Happy Life. U.S: Kessinger Publishing

- Electronic Literature Organization, at http://eliterature.org/ (Viewed, 25/08/12

11:21) (1999) Maryland Institute for Technology in the Humanities (MITH) at the

University of Maryland, College Park. Wordpress.

- Extensive Reading Foundation (EFR) (2011). Guide to Extensive Reading.

[Online Version] Available at www.erfoundation.org

- Gabilondo, A. (2012). [Entrevista con Iñaqui Gabilondo en el art. Rodríguez

Marcos, J. Leer es un gesto de insatisfacción.] El País: El Cultural, [Versión

Online] Available at

http://cultura.elpais.com/cultura/2012/02/23/actualidad/1330023957_392390.ht

ml

- Gallagher, K. (2009) Readicide: How Schools are Killing Reading and What

Can you Do about It. U.S: Stenhouse Publishers.

- Harmer, J. (2009). The Practice of English Language Teaching (4th Ed).

Harlow: Longman. Pp. 64 et seq.

- Hesse, M. (2010). Turn the Page, Click the Link, See the Video. Los Angeles

Times. [Online Version] Available at:

http://articles.latimes.com/2010/jan/01/entertainment/la-et-vooks1-2010jan01

- Interactive Educational Systems Design, Inc. (2010). Text-Based Collaborative

Learning. U.S: McGraw Hill Education.

- IEA. (2009). International Association for the Evaluation of Educational

Achievement.

- Inhelder & Piaget. (1955). De la Logique de l’enfant á la Logique de

l’adolescence. Paris: Presses Universitaires.

- Iser, W. (1976). The Act of Reading: A Theory of Aesthetic Response.

Baltimore: John Hopkins University Press.

- Icelandic Eurydice Unit, 2011. [Online Version] Available at

https://webgate.ec.europa.eu/fpfis/mwikis/eurydice/index.php?title=News&oldid

=60821

- Knight, Susan (1994) Dictionary Use While Reading: The Effects on

Comprehension and Vocabulary Acquisition for Students of Different Verbal

Abilities. The Modern Language Journal Vol. 78, No. 3, pp. 285-299. Wiley-

Blackwell, Article Stable URL: http://www.jstor.org/stable/330108

- Kramsh and McConnel-Ginet, S. (Ed.) (1992). Text and context. Cross-

Disciplinary Perspectives on Language Study. Michigan: D.C. Heath

Page 51: “MOTIVATING ADOLESCENT READERS IN THE EFL … · “MOTIVATING ADOLESCENT READERS IN THE EFL CLASSROOM: THE NEW PARADIGM OF LITERACY ... The text is a complete and multifaceted

  51  

- Kramsch, C. (1993). Context and Culture in Language Teaching. Oxford:

O.U.P.

- Krashen and Terrell, T. D. (1988). The Natural Approach: Language Acquisition

in the Classroom. UK: Prentice Hall International.

- Krashen, S. (2002). What Do We Know About Libraries and Reading

Achievement? U.S: The Book Report.

- Krashen, S. D. (2004). The Power of Reading. Michigan: Libraries Unlimited.

- Krashen, S. D. (2011). Free Voluntary Reading. ABC-CLIO

- Leu, Kinzer, Coiro, & Cammack, (2004). Toward a theory of new literacies

emerging from the Internet and other information and communication

technologies. In R.B. Ruddell & N. Unrau (Eds.), Theoretical Models and

Processes of Reading, Fifth Edition (1568-1611). International Reading.

Association: Newark, DE.

- Lindsay & Knight, P. (2006). Learning and Teaching English. Oxford: O.U.P

- Margallo, A. M. (2012) Claves para Formar Lectores Adolescentes con Talento.

Gobierno de España, Ministerio de Educación. [Online Version]

http://docentes.leer.es/2012/03/13/claves-para-formar-lectores-adolescentes-

con-talento-ana-maria-margallo/ Recuperado en 5 de Junio 2012

- Marina, J. A. (2011). Los Secretos de la Motivación. Ariel, Grupo Planeta:

España.

- McEwan, E.K. (2008). The reading puzzle: Vocabulary. Thousand Oaks, CA:

Corwin Press

- Mendoza Fillola, A. (1994). Las Estrategias de Lectura: Su Función

Autoevaluadora en el Aprendizaje del Español como Lengua Extranjera. Actas

IV: ASELE

- Moje, E. B., Ciechanowski, K. M., Kramer, K., Ellis, L. Carrillo, R., & Collazo, T.

(2004). Working toward third space in content area literacy: An examination of

everyday funds of knowledge and discourse. Reading Research Quarterly,

39,38-69.

- Mullis, Martin, Kennedy y Trong. (2007). PIRLS 2007 Encyclopaedia. Published

by PIRLS.

- Nokes, J. D., & Dole, J. A. (2004). Helping adolescent readers through explicit

strategy instruction. In T. L. Jetton & J. A. Dole (Eds.), Adolescent literacy

research and practice (pp. 162–182). New York: The Guilford Press.

- Nunan, D., and L. Miller, Eds. 1995. New Ways in Teaching Listening:

Alexandria, VA: TESOL.

Page 52: “MOTIVATING ADOLESCENT READERS IN THE EFL … · “MOTIVATING ADOLESCENT READERS IN THE EFL CLASSROOM: THE NEW PARADIGM OF LITERACY ... The text is a complete and multifaceted

  52  

- Núñez-Alonso, et. al; (2005). Validación de la Versión Española de la Échelle

de Motivation en Éducation. Psicothema. Vol. 17, nº 12, pp. 344-349.

- Nuttal, C. (1996). Teaching Reading Skills in a Foreign Language. London:

Heinemann Educational Books.

- Peacock, M. (1997). The Effect of Authentic Materials on the Motivation of EFL

Learners in English Language Teaching Journal 51, pp. 2.

- Ravitch, D. (2009). Are Hollywood and the Internet Killing Reading? Forbes.

Com [Online Version] Available at: http://www.forbes.com/2009/02/17/the-big-

read-literacy-opinions-contributors_0217_diane_ravitch.html

- Ryan & Deci, E.L. (2000). Intrinsic and Extrinsic Motivations: Classic Definitions

and New Directions. Contemporary Educational Psychology 25, 54–67 [Online

Version] Available at http://www.idealibrary.com University of Rochester

- Saiz, J. (2012). Los Beneficios de la Lectura. La Vanguardia.com: Diario Digital.

[Online] Available at http://www.lavanguardia.com/estilos-de-

vida/20120613/54312096470/los-beneficios-de-la-lectura.html

- Sartre, J.P. (1949). What is Literature New York: Philosophical Library.

- Shanahan, C. & Shanahan, T. (2008). Teaching Disciplinary Literacy to

Adolescents: Rethinking Content-Area Literacy Harvard Educational Review

Vol. 78, nº1. Harvard College

- Schnotz, W. (1993). On the relation between dual coding and mental models in

graphics comprehension. Learning and Instruction, 3, 247-249.

- Taylor, W.L. (1953). Cloze procedure: A new tool for measuring readability.

Journalism Quarterly, 30, 415–433.

- Teixedor, E. (2007). La Lectura y La Vida. Editorial Ariel

Page 53: “MOTIVATING ADOLESCENT READERS IN THE EFL … · “MOTIVATING ADOLESCENT READERS IN THE EFL CLASSROOM: THE NEW PARADIGM OF LITERACY ... The text is a complete and multifaceted

  53  

9.  Bibliography  

- Aguiar y Silva, V. M. (1980). Competencia Lingüística y Competencia Literaria.

Madrid: Gredos.

- Allwright, R. (1977). Motivation - the teacher's responsibility? ELT Journal 31/4.

- Amparán Cardín, F. (2004). Importancia de la Literatura Infantil y Juvenil en la

Educación Literaria. Actas VIII: Congreso Sociedad Española de Didáctica de

la Lengua y la Literatura. La Habana, pp. 513- 526.

- Anwar & Rana, M. K. (2010). Perceptive Study: Teaching English Language

Through English Literature, U.S: Lambert Academic Publishing.

- Bamford & Day, R. R. (1998). Extensive Reading in the Second Language

Classroom. Cambridge: Cambridge University Press.

- Bilash, O. (2009). Improve your Classroom Practice Through Action Research –

Become a Researcher of your own Instruction, Ihla Newsletter.

- Borg, S. (2006). Teacher Cognition and Language Education. London, NY:

Continuum.

- Brines, V. (2001). Read on: the organisation of an extensive reading

programme. MET 10/3.

- Bugelsky, B. R. (1979). Principles of Learning and Memory and Some Practical

Laws, NY: Praeger.

- Campbell, N. (1987). Adapted literary texts and the EFL reading programme.

ELT Journal 41/2

- Carter & McRae, J. (1996). Language, Literature and the Learner: Creative

Classroom. London: Pearson Longman

- Carrel, P. (1988). Interactive Approaches to 2nd Language Reading. Cambridge:

C.U.P.

- Cecilia, R. R. (2010). El Proceso de Lectura en Lengua Extranjera: de la

Descodificación a la Interpretación. Didáctica, Lengua y Literatura, vol. 22 311-

324.

- Coiro, J. (2003). Comprensión de Lectura en Internet: Ampliando lo que

Entendemos por Comprensión de Lectura para Incluir las Nuevas

Competencias. Eduteka- Comprensión de Lectura en Internet, [Online]

Available at: http://edtk.co/DDvpH

- Collins, A. and E. Smith (1980). Teaching the Process of Reading

Comprehension. Cambridge: Centre for the Study of Reading, Urbana,

University of Illinois.

Page 54: “MOTIVATING ADOLESCENT READERS IN THE EFL … · “MOTIVATING ADOLESCENT READERS IN THE EFL CLASSROOM: THE NEW PARADIGM OF LITERACY ... The text is a complete and multifaceted

  54  

- Coloma Maestre, J. (2002). Animación a la Lectura: Animación a la

Interculturalidad. Actas XIII: ASELE.

- Cormon, F. (1986). Humanistic activities and teacher motivation. ELT Journal

40/4

- Croft, Stevens & Myers, R. (2004). Exploring Language and Literature. Oxford:

O.U.P.

- Crookes, G. & Schmidt, R. (1991). Motivation: reopening the research agenda.

Language Learning. 41, 469-512

- Cuenca, C. (1988). Exploiting easy readers. Practical English Teaching 9/1.

- Claridge, G. (2009). Teachers’ Perspectives on What Makes a Good Graded

Reader. New Zealand Studies in Applied Linguistics, 15 (1), 13-25.

- Davis, C. (1995). Extensive reading: an expensive extravagance. ELT Journal

49/4

- Davies, R. (1960). A Voice from the Attic: Essays on the Art of Reading, NY:

Penguin.

- De la Varga, J. (2011). Otra lectura del informe PISA: España no genera

estudiantes con alto nivel de comprensión lectora. Forum Libertas [Online

Version] Availble at:

http://www.forumlibertas.com/frontend/forumlibertas/noticia.php?id_noticia=189

46&id_seccion=8

- Deci & Ryan, R. M. (1985). Intrinsic Motivation and Self-Determination in

Human Behaviour. NY: Plenum Press.

- Dörnyei, Z. (1998). Motivation in second and foreign language learning.

Language Teaching 31.

- Dudeney, G. (2000). The Internet and The Language Classroom. Cambridge:

C.U.P.

- Durán Escribano, P. (2001). Funciones de la Lectura en la Enseñanza del

Inglés Profesional y Académico y Estrategias de Comprensión Lectora.

Didáctica (Lengua y Literatura), 13: 69- 85.

- F.G.E.E. (Federación de Gremios de Editores de España). Informe sobre el

Sector Editorial Español 2010, 2012.

- Foucambert, J. (2008). Cómo ser Lector. Barcelona: Laia.

- Fowler, R. (1988). La Literatura como Discurso Social. La Práctica de la Crítica

Lingüística. España: Alcoy, Marfil.

- Gadamer, H. G. (1975). Truth and Method. NY: Continuum.

- Gardner & MacIntyre, P. (1993). A student's contributions to second language

learning. Part 2: affective variables. Language Teaching 26/1

Page 55: “MOTIVATING ADOLESCENT READERS IN THE EFL … · “MOTIVATING ADOLESCENT READERS IN THE EFL CLASSROOM: THE NEW PARADIGM OF LITERACY ... The text is a complete and multifaceted

  55  

- Gilroy-Scott, N. (1983) "Introduction", in C.J. Brumfit (ed.) Teaching Literature

Overseas; Language-based Approaches, ELT Documents 115, Oxford:

Pergamon Press, p 2.

- Gómez Soto, I. (1999). Mito y Realidad de la Lectura. Los Hábitos Lectores en

la España Actual. Madrid: Endymion, Ensayos nº 126.

- Greenwood, J. (1987). Classroom Readers, Oxford: Oxford University Press.

- Girard, D. (1977). Motivation - the responsibility of the teacher. ELT Journal

31/2

- Hafiz & Tudor, I. (1989). Extensive reading and the development of language

skills. ELT Journal 43/1

- Hayes & Hammill, J. (2002). Graded readers. MET 11/2.

- Hamer, J. (1991). The Practice of English Language Teaching. London:

Pearson Longman.

- Harris, J. (2007). The Practice of English Language Teaching, London: Pearson

Longman.

- Harrison, (1980). Readability in the Classroom. Cambridge: C.U.P.

- Heidegger, M. (1988). Ontology: the Hermeneutics of Facticity. Indiana: Indiana

University Press.

- Hernández, R. (1997). Autonomía: El Texto como Instrumento para Enseñar a

Aprender. Actas VIII: ASELE.

- Herrero Figueroa, A. (1998). Lectura Literaria y Competencia Intertextual.

Criterios de Selección del Texto Literario y de su Transposición Fílmica. Actas

IX: Asele

- Hill, J. (1986). Using Literature in Language Teaching. U.S: Macmillan

Publishers.

- Krashen, S. D. & McQuillan, J. (1996). The Case for late Intervention: Once a

Good Reader, always a Good Reader. U.S: Language Education Associates

- Krashen & Ujiie, J. (1996). Comic Book Reading, Reading Enjoyment and

Pleasure Reading among Middle Class and Chapter I Middle Class Students.

Reading Improvement, 333, nº 1: 51-54.

- Krashen & Kim, H. (1997). Why don’t language acquirers take advantage of the

power of reading? TESOL Journal, 6(3), 26-29.

- Krashen, S. D. (1997). To Develop Literacy, Students Need Access to Many

Interesting Reading Materials. Investing in our Libraries is Critical to Equitable

Achievement in Reading. Educational Leadership, p.19

- Krashen, S. D. (2002). Accelerated Reader: Does It Work? If So, Why? School

Libraries in Canada, 22, 2.

Page 56: “MOTIVATING ADOLESCENT READERS IN THE EFL … · “MOTIVATING ADOLESCENT READERS IN THE EFL CLASSROOM: THE NEW PARADIGM OF LITERACY ... The text is a complete and multifaceted

  56  

- Krashen, S. D. (2003). Explorations in Language Acquisition and Use U.S:

Heineman.

- Krashen, S. D. (2004) The Power of Reading US: Libraries Unlimited.

- Krashen, S. D. (2005). Accelerated Reader: Evidence Still Lacking. Knowledge

Quest, Vol.33, nº 3.

- Krashen, Cho, Green & Hong Choi (2005). Hooked on a Comic: Book Reading:

How Comic Books Made an Impossible Situation Less Difficult. Knowledge

Quest, vol. 33, nº 4.

- Krashen, S. D. (2009). Anything But Reading. Knowledge Quest, vol.37, nº 5.

- Lazar, G. (2008). Literature and Language Teaching: A Guide for Teachers and

Trainers Cambridge: Cambridge University Press.

- Leech, G. N. (1994). Style in Fiction: A Linguistic Introduction to English

Fictional Prose. London: Pearson Longman Education.

- Littlejohn, A. (2001). Motivation: Where does it come from? Where does it go?

English Teaching professional 19.

- Lyotard, J. F. (1989). La Condición Posmoderna. Madrid: Cátedra.

- Maley & Duff. (2007). Literature Oxford: Oxford University Press

- Marsch, David (2011). Realizing Personal and Professional Potential through

CLIL. Congreso Internacional de Educación y Bilingüismo. 21th January 2011.

- Montes, G. (1999). La Frontera Indómita. En torno a la Construcción y Defensa

del Espacio Poético. México: Fondo de Cultura Económica.

- McLaughlin, P. (1987). Supplementary Readers. Practical English Teaching

8/2.

- Nicholls, K. (2000). Motivation - Can we do anything about it? MET 9/2

- Palincsar, A. S. & Herrenkohl, L. R. (2002). Designing Collaborative Learning

Contexts. Theory Into Practice, Vol. 41, Nº 1, Ohio, and U.S: The Ohio State

University.

- Pagano, N. (1991). Fun with graded readers Practical. English Teaching 12/2

- Pérez Díaz y Rodríguez, J.C. (2008). La Adolescencia, sus Vulnerabilidades y

las Nuevas Tecnologías de la Información y la Comunicación. Fundación

Vodafone España.

- Peterson, A. (2011). Kelly Gallagher Takes on the “Killing of Reading”. National

Writing Project. [Online Version] Available at:

http://www.nwp.org/cs/public/print/resource/3486

- Prowse, P. (1999). The secret of Reading English. Teaching professional 13

- Prowse, P. (2000a). Open your books English. Teaching professional 14

- Prowse, P. (2000b). When the reading stops. English Teaching professional 15

Page 57: “MOTIVATING ADOLESCENT READERS IN THE EFL … · “MOTIVATING ADOLESCENT READERS IN THE EFL CLASSROOM: THE NEW PARADIGM OF LITERACY ... The text is a complete and multifaceted

  57  

- Ricoeur, P. (1974). The Conflict of Interpretations: Essays in Hermeneutics. NY:

Continuum.

- Rönnqvist & Sell R. (1994). Teenage books for teenagers: reflections on

literature in language education. ELT Journal, 48/2.

- Rosenblatt, L. M. (1983). Literature as Exploration, NY: Modern Language

Association.

- Rosenblatt, L. M. (1986). The Aesthetic Transaction. Journal of Aesthetic

Education, 20 (4), 122- 128.

- Schnog, N. (2008). We’re Teaching Books that Don’t Stuck Up. The

Washington Post. [Online] Available: http://www.washingtonpost.com/wp-

dyn/content/article/2008/08/22/AR2008082202398.html

- Schoonen, Hulstjin and Bossers. (1998). Metacognitive and Language-Specific

Knowledge in Native and Foreign Language Reading Comprehension: An

Empirical Study among Dutch students in Grades 6, 8 and 10. Language

Learning, v48 n1 p71-106.

- Spolsky, B. (2000). Language motivation revisited. Applied Linguistics 21/2

- Stanrock, W. (2006). Psicología de la Educación. U.S: McGraw-Hill

- Van Dijk, T. (1999). Discurso y Literatura. Madrid: Visor Libros.

- Williams, M. (1999). Motivation in language learning. English Teaching

professional 13

- Williams, E. (1984). Reading in the Language Classroom. London: Macmillan

Publishers.

Page 58: “MOTIVATING ADOLESCENT READERS IN THE EFL … · “MOTIVATING ADOLESCENT READERS IN THE EFL CLASSROOM: THE NEW PARADIGM OF LITERACY ... The text is a complete and multifaceted

  58  

10.  Attachments   BOX 1. 2 Reading and You

1. How much time do you think you spend reading in an average week? _______________ Hours.

2. What kinds of things (novels, magazines, TV guides) you usually read?

3. What is your favourite…? Magazine? Why? Newspaper? Why? Book? Why?

4. Who is your favourite writer? Why?

5. Do you enjoy reading? Why or why not?

6. Of all the different literary genres, what is the one you like the best? (ex: sci-fiction, adventures, romantic, terror, etc.)

Page 59: “MOTIVATING ADOLESCENT READERS IN THE EFL … · “MOTIVATING ADOLESCENT READERS IN THE EFL CLASSROOM: THE NEW PARADIGM OF LITERACY ... The text is a complete and multifaceted

  59  

7. What is the most interesting thing you have ever read in English?

8. If you could easily read anything in English, what would you like to read?

9. Do you think reading more literature in English would help your English ability? How? In what way?

(Adapted from) CAMBRIDGE UNIVERSITY PRESS, 2004

Page 60: “MOTIVATING ADOLESCENT READERS IN THE EFL … · “MOTIVATING ADOLESCENT READERS IN THE EFL CLASSROOM: THE NEW PARADIGM OF LITERACY ... The text is a complete and multifaceted

  60  

TEACHERS’ OPINIONS ABOUT IMPROVING READING IN L2: Name (voluntary): Nº Classes/ week: Institution: This Questionnaire is designed to help me understand more about teachers’ beliefs and involvement in encouraging students to read books in the English Classroom. It is also intended to know more about the methods and approaches they use at this respect and the need for a change that would not only help students’ career on a general basis, but that would reconsider the aims and objectives of every L2 learning and teaching exchange.

1 2 3 4 5

Disagree Slightly Disagree Undecided Agree Strongly Agree Circle the appropriate digit: 1. During the reading process you can manage sustaining their concentration in the text.

1 2 3 4 5

2. You help them think critically about the text.

1 2 3 4 5

3. You are able to lead an effective and fruitful discussion about the text or book they are reading.

1 2 3 4 5

4. It is necessary to provide them with a context before starting to read.

1 2 3 4 5

5. Maybe it would help assessing their likes, interests and preferences for reading before.

1 2 3 4 5

6. The books or texts chosen have to be originally graded for more help by the editorials.

1 2 3 4 5

7. You receive a list of books given for each term, you do not decide the reading materials.

1 2 3 4 5

8. You are aware of the new trends in literature for young people and know about the advantages of some genres and tendencies. E.g.: comics, hyper textuality, sci-fi, cyber fiction, graphic novels, etc.

1 2 3 4 5

9. Some technological advances can be good allies in order to motivate students to read more.

1 2 3 4 5

10. You prefer the traditional books to

Page 61: “MOTIVATING ADOLESCENT READERS IN THE EFL … · “MOTIVATING ADOLESCENT READERS IN THE EFL CLASSROOM: THE NEW PARADIGM OF LITERACY ... The text is a complete and multifaceted

  61  

eBooks. Young people should give value to this source on the first place.

1 2 3 4 5

11. Students try inferring the meaning of the more complex words found in the text by themselves.

1 2 3 4 5

12. Their comprehension of the text allows them discussing some terms and giving their own opinion about it. They can even predict what is going to happen next.

1 2 3 4 5

13. Secondary students are well aware of how a library works and the different types of books there are available for them to read.

1 2 3 4 5

14. You are well aware of the importance of reading. Indeed, it is considered among your main priorities in teaching L2.

1 2 3 4 5

15. Students use the monolingual dictionary appropriately during their reading activities.

1 2 3 4 5

- About the different literary genres and topics existing, what are the ones young people would better accept to read? List a few of them…

- What is your main strategy for reinforcing reading activities between students?

- You surely have observed important differences, not only in relation to their academic results, among reading students and those who do no like reading anything. Could you tell me what differences are these?

Page 62: “MOTIVATING ADOLESCENT READERS IN THE EFL … · “MOTIVATING ADOLESCENT READERS IN THE EFL CLASSROOM: THE NEW PARADIGM OF LITERACY ... The text is a complete and multifaceted

  62  

Page 63: “MOTIVATING ADOLESCENT READERS IN THE EFL … · “MOTIVATING ADOLESCENT READERS IN THE EFL CLASSROOM: THE NEW PARADIGM OF LITERACY ... The text is a complete and multifaceted

  63