Mosque Typology and the Design Framework

8/14/2019 Mosque Typology and the Design Framework

1/51

a@aj@@@i@bc@@b@bncna@ba@@@

@a@bu@


2/51

--

.

.

.

Abstract:

Theorists had made quite a number of studies on Mosque typology and the design

framework employed by the Architects; however, there was no will defined research

methodology which led to failure in bridging each type of mosque with its proper design

framework. However, some proposed design frameworks do coincide with the assigned

types. Furthermore the design frameworks totally ignored the individual creativity as

well as the group creativity in the design process.

This research aims to properly correlate the design frameworks with mosque

types through the study of one type of mosque in the Kingdom of Saudi Arabia and

identify the corresponding design framework, group creativity and the individual

creativity in the design process which were ignored by earlier researcher.

Indeed the design framework for the selected type shows strong influence of

group creativity on the individual creativity which in turns singles out a particular

architectural historical preference.


3/51

--

"" :

. .

.]]Freshman and King,1994

).)Serageldin and steele, 1996

.

).)Serageldin and steele, 1996

.


4/51

--

.

.

:-

.

-.

-

.

-

-1-1

."

].1978]"


5/51

--

. .

.

": "1-2

] 1139]. 1386

]]. 1419

.

].))11419] ]. 1419]28

.

. .

1240 .

]. 1386]

..


6/51

--

]1419 [. .

--

.]

]. 1419

-- .].))2 1419[

--]. 1419]

].[

.

( ).()

.

(.()

.)--


7/51

--

.

.

.(

]. 1407]).)(--

...

:.

.-.-.-

.-.-.-.-

1-3

))1963Fletcher

.))Fletcher, 1963


8/51

--

).)Gideon, 1971

))John Alger))Jon Lang:[[Lang 1987))LarlHayes

)review of historical information(,)individual creative effort(.))group creative effort

1-3-1

.

:

( Paradigms(

))types))generic solution

).)Prototypes

:

)Cannonic Design(

))Principles ))Standards )Standards(

.

.

. ..


9/51

--

1-3-1-1

. :

[Grabar, 1973]. .

..]]Grabar1973

[Kuran, 1968].)( ) (.)(

. .

.

.

. :

.

..


10/51

--

..

. .

.

.

.[[Yaghan, 1998

((.

.

.[[Grabar, 1973 .

. .[Goodwin, 1971

. .

.

.

.


11/51

--

.[[Hoag, 1977 .

.

.

.

) (:.

. . ..]Grabar]1978

.

.

.[[Kuran, 1968

.

.[[Hoag, 1977


12/51

--

.

"" "

] "1401.[

[Hoag,

1977].

.

).1987(

.

))Hypostyle Plan.

.

)1987" (" .

).1987(

.

.

.[[Hoag, 1977


13/51

--

.

.]]Koran 1968.

..

1-3-1-2

.

."

. ....

[".]1420

.

.

. ] .] 1420

:.


14/51

--

.

...

.""

)( )

34.]1420[) .

. .

. ]

1420.[

.

} 1420[.


15/51

--

" "

].1420[

")("

].1420["

. .

"."-"].1420[

.[[Makadisi, 1981

.

.

1-3-2))broodbent)Lang(

))checklist:

.))vise versa )interactionmethod(.

))psychoanalysis )brainstorming()synectics(

.))synectics

)metaphores()analogy(


16/51

--

.))direct analogy

))personal analogy

)symbolic analogy( .

]Lang1987.[

1-3-3

)assets()liabilities(]Lang, 1987[.

-2

:

2-1

.

2-2

.2-3

.


17/51

--

2-4

.

2-5

.

2-6

.

2-7:

.

2-8

).)liabilities))assets

-3

.

.

.


18/51

--

3-1

.

.][ , ,,

,, , .,,

--

].[ (.

.)

. .

.

.

]1420[.


19/51

--

.]]Grabar 1973 )(

. ]]Generic solution

.)1(

. ) 2( .)3(

( (

.)4( (Prototype).

]]Prototype

. ..)5(

.)6" ("

.)6(

(

.)6()5


20/51

--

)(

)3(

).5(

).8(

] 1422[

).9( .))personal analogy))checklist

.))interaction method.

1234 1158/1179

[..[[King, 1986

.]1422[


21/51

--

.

]Personal Analogy[.""

]Picnic[.

.

((direct Analogy.)1(

.((Interaction method

. .

.

..

"."

10(( .


22/51

--

] .] 1422

.]1422.]


23/51

--

3-2

- -

] [.,)),)),

, , .,

.

.

..

) (

)(.

]Generic.

solution[)11(.


24/51

--

.

.)12(

.)13()(

(( .)14(

.)14 (

.

.

(

15(.


25/51

--

))paradigms 1420[

].Madison 1981.

.)16(

)(Prototype. .

))symbol.

)(symbolic analogy ] .))Personal analogy]1422


26/51

--

((Direct Analogy. .

)Metaphore(

).17(],1422[

.


27/51

--

3-3

.--

] [ ] [

- -..[[Eben Saleh, 1419

,,, ,

,,,,, .

--

- -].[

].]

)(

)(

. (Prototype)

.)18(


28/51

--

.))King 1986 .

.

.-

. )19(

) 19(.

.))King 1986

.)20(

".

.].."]King1986

.]]King1986 --

.


29/51

--

)(. .)22(

.)22(

:"

.]1420[." .

.

)(

.

))Prototype ) .

(

. . )prototype(

).18(


30/51

--

]1986Holod, Khan, 1997[.

--

1240 /1824 3830"

. ]"]King1986

"] 1400[

.)20(

..

. -

]Serageldin and Steele, 1996[ .)20(

))Direct Analogy( (.


31/51

--

" ) " (

.

1976

[Eben Saleh, 1419]

".

.)361987" (

.1985


32/51

--

3-4

.

]. -]- .

-

.--

)( -

.

. [

.[

,, ,.,

-- .

.

.


33/51

--

()()()23

.

..)(

.))77)70( .

.

.)23(

. :.

.)2526(

)27(

.

)(.)(..)28(


34/51

--

.)26(

))Prototype

.

)(

.

).27( ""

. .

[.[Grabar, 1973

.

.


35/51

--

.

))interaction method .

:

.

.((Direct Analogy((Checklist

.((Interaction method

.-

..


36/51

--

3-5

) ). ]

.[ .

,)(,,)(, ,

,,,,,

.

.

..

.


37/51

--

.

.)( .

. .

.)(

((.

)(

)) ))prototype.

""

).(.


38/51

--

.

).(

.

)interaction method(.

))prototype

.

)Interactionmethod(

((Direct analogy

.

.


39/51

--

3-6

(.)

--. ..

., , ,

.,,, .

].[

.

].

.[.

.


40/51

--

. ).33( )paradigms( ]] .Serageldin and Steele 1997

. .

))prototypes )(.

))generic solution.

).34()(

.)3534( .

. ) 35(.

).33(

))interaction method

.


41/51

--

.)33( .

).36(

)( ) 37(.

.

.). 1422)

.

.]]Serageldin andSteele 1997

-


42/51

--

.

.

.

)Direct analogy(

))prototype

((Symbolic analogy.)(

[((Interaction method.]1422

.

.

..


43/51

--

3-7

[-].

],1979Bokhari.[

..

,)(, ,, , .,

.

.

. .

. .

..

.


44/51

--

)()())prototype.

.)(

.)(

. )generic solution(.

.)39(

).40(

.)41( .

) ).42

).44(

.

).(


45/51

--

.

.

..

.

.

(Interactionmethod)

.((Direct analogy


46/51

--

.

4-

.:

.

..

((interaction method((checklist

.((psycho analysis

.

..

.

.

.

.


47/51

--

.

:.)1.)2 )3

.


48/51

--

. . :.

. 21401

:..

1386 )1(.

: " .

3.."

).)2 1419.

:. " .

.".3.

. ,1419.

.) .(

1419 .

. ).(.

. 1411.

).(:

1420 .

. :

1987.

: .

1423.

).)1 . 14

. 1412


49/51

--

341407 .

63

1412

.

. ( 1422.(

( 1422.(

) . 1422.(

)1422.(

. ( 1422.(


50/51

--

REFERENCE

Kuran Aptulla. The Mosque in Early Ottoman Architecture. Chicago: The University of

Chicago Press, 1968.

Serageldin, Ismail and Steele, James. Architecture of the Contemporary MosqueLondon: Academy Edition 1996.

King, G.R.D. The Historical Mosques of Saudi Arabia, London. Longman, 1986.

MaKdisi, George. The Rise of Colleges: Institutions of Learning in Islam And the West.

Edinburgh: Edinburgh University Press, 1981.

Holod, Renata and Khan Hasanuddin. The Mosque and the Modern World: Architects,

Patrosons and Design Since the 1950's. London: Thames and Hudson Ltd. 1997.

Frishman, Martin and Khan, Hasanuddin. (eds.) The Mosque : History, Architectural

Development and Regional Diversity, London: Thames and Hudson Ltd., 1994.

Bokhari Abdullah Yahya. Jeddah, A Study in Urban Formation, Unpublished, Ph.D.

Dissertation, University of Pennsylvania, 1978.

Eben Saleh, Mohammed A. "Origin, Evolution and Transformation of Arriyadh City

Center. The Struggle for Urban and Architectural Solutions". Journal of King Saud

University, Architecture and Planning, Riyadh: 11(1419), 45-144.

_____________________" Architectural Decoration in Traditional House of Central

Region of Saudi Arabia: Symbolism, Abstract in and Traditional Journal of King SaudUniversity, Architecture and Planning, Riyadh : 13(2001) 51-86.

Goodwin, Godfrey. A History of Ottoman Architecture. London: Thames and Hudson,

1971.

Hoag, John D.Islamic Architecture. New York: Harry N. Abrams, Inc. 1977.

Lang, Jon. Creating Architectural Theory: The Role of the Behavioral Sciences in

Environmental Design, New York Van Nostrand Reinhold, 1987.

Yaghan, Mohammad Ali " A Structural Genuine Muqarnas Dome, Type-Definition,Unit Analysis and Computer Generation Systems". Journal of King Saud University,

Architecture and Planning, Riyadh: 10(1998) 17-51.

Grabar, Oleg. The formation of Islamic Art. New Haven and London: Yale University

Press, 1973.

_____________. The Alhambra. Cambridge, Mass.: Harvard University Press, 1978.


51/51

Fletcher, Banister. A History of Architecture on the Comparative Method. New York:Charles Scripner's Sons, 1963.

Giedion, Sigfried Space, Time and Architecture: The Growth of a New Tradition.

Cambridge, Mass: Harvard University Press, 1976.

Documents

Mosque Typology and the Design Framework