Upload
others
View
0
Download
0
Embed Size (px)
Citation preview
Amit SeruChicago Booth and NBER
Vincent YaoFannie Mae
Ben KeysUniversity of Chicago Harris
Tomasz PiskorskiColumbia Business School and NBER
Mortgage Rates, Household Balance Sheets, and Real Economy
May 2015
Motivation• Long-standing debate on real effects of monetary policy
Extraordinary recent actions to keep rates low
• Residential mortgage market believed to play an importantrole in the transmission of monetary policy Homes and mortgage debt as key household asset and liability Adjustable rate mortgages (ARMs) represent frictionless
pass-through
• Empirical evidence on the impact of lower mortgage rateson households/broader economy fairly limited Data limitations Identification challenges
2
This Paper• Provide novel evidence on the impact of lower rates on
households and broader economy during the crisis Micro: Household balance sheet and (inferred) consumption
Credit card debt, auto financing Regional: Broader economy
House prices, durable consumption, employment
• Speak to policies on mortgage market rules/regulations Significant debate regarding the relative magnitudes
Does debt deleveraging limit consumption response? (Agarwal et al. 2012, Mian and Sufi 2013)
Mortgage modification programs, programs facilitating refinancing Remove institutional frictions in implementation of policies
[HAMP/HARP] since all eligible households receive rate reduction
3
Related Literature• Contribute to literature on
Monetary transmission mechanism Household response to income shocks & (fiscal) stimulus programsMortgage payments reduction / modification on defaults Household behavior during recent crisis
• We add to the literature in significant ways Significant stimulus spaced over time in contrast to one-time income
increase Impact of lower mortgage rates on consumer debt and other
economic outcomes
Closely related to concurrent work by Di Maggio et al. 2014
4
Empirical Challenges• Hard to empirically assess impact of lower interest rates
Rates endogenous with either borrower characteristics and/or macroeconomic environment
• Our approach At micro level: Exploit variation in ARM contract types across
borrowers to generate variation in rates faced by similar households
At regional level: Exploit variation in distribution of contract types (ARM share) across similar regions
5
Micro Data• Proprietary data from a secondary market participant
Detailed monthly loan-level panel dataMortgage performance data
Loan balances, current interest rate, mortgage type, payments, delinquency status, location (zip code)
Consumer credit recordsCredit card balances, auto loans, student loans, credit inquiries,
payment status, current credit score (FICO) Records matched using borrower SSN
• Dataset representative of most U.S. mortgage borrowersMore than 350,000 agency borrowers
6
Baseline Micro Evidence
8
‐1%
0%
1%
2%
3%
4%
5%
6%
2005 2006 2007 2008 2009 2010 2011 2012
0%
1%
2%
3%
4%
5%
6%
2005 2006 2007 2008 2009 2010 2011 2012
7/1 ARM5.1% TeaserAdjusts to 2% + TR
5/1 ARM5.0% TeaserAdjusts to 2% + TR
Treasury Rate
Mortgage Rate
9
‐1%
0%
1%
2%
3%
4%
5%
6%
2005 2006 2007 2008 2009 2010 2011 2012
0%
1%
2%
3%
4%
5%
6%
2005 2006 2007 2008 2009 2010 2011 2012
7/1 ARM5.1% TeaserAdjusts to 2% + TR
5/1 ARM5.0% TeaserAdjusts to 2% + TR
Treasury Rate
Mortgage Rate
10
‐1%
0%
1%
2%
3%
4%
5%
6%
2005 2006 2007 2008 2009 2010 2011 2012
0%
1%
2%
3%
4%
5%
6%
2005 2006 2007 2008 2009 2010 2011 2012
7/1 ARM5.1% TeaserAdjusts to 2% + TR
5/1 ARM5.0% TeaserAdjusts to 2% + TR
Treasury Rate
Mortgage Rate
Our Focus
11
‐1%
0%
1%
2%
3%
4%
5%
6%
2005 2006 2007 2008 2009 2010 2011 2012
0%
1%
2%
3%
4%
5%
6%
2005 2006 2007 2008 2009 2010 2011 2012
7/1 ARM5.1% TeaserAdjusts to 2% + TR
5/1 ARM5.0% TeaserAdjusts to 2% + TR
Treasury Rate
Mortgage Rate
Our Focus
12
Rate Resets and Interest Rates
Treatment (5/1)
Control (7/1)
13
Rate Resets and Mortgage Payments
Treatment (5/1)
Control (7/1)
Mortgage Payments are reduced by $1,500 (on average) in the first year,and by $3,434 over two years
14
Impact on Mortgage Default (Two Years Out)
• Mortgage Payments: Reduction by average $3,434 over two years Associated with 36% relative decrease in mortgage
default (1.8 pp)• Diff-in-diffs Identification Assumption: In the absence of 5/1 ARM rate reset, relevant
outcomes of 5/1 ARMs follow a similar pattern as 7/1 ARM borrowers (up to a constant difference)
Interest Current Mortgage Rate Payment Delinquency
Treatment -1.75 -163.54 -0.018 (0.14)
(10.91)
(0.01)
Number of Loans 348,259 348,259 348,259
Adjusted R-squared 0.891 0.251 0.064
15
Impact on Revolving Debt Balance
Treatment (5/1)
Control (7/1)
19% of extra liquidity from lower mortgage payments allocated to revolving (credit card) debt repayment over two years
16
Impact on Durable Financing (Auto Debt)
Treatment (5/1)
Control (7/1)
10% of additional liquidity goes towards increased auto debt
17
Impact on Probability of New Auto Financing
3.0%
3.5%
4.0%
4.5%
5.0%
5.5%
6.0%
‐Q4 ‐Q3 ‐Q2 ‐Q1 Q1 Q2 Q3 Q4 Q5 Q6 Q7 Q8
Treatment (5/1)
Control (7/1)
10% relative increase in new car financing
18
Cross-Sectional Heterogeneity
19
Top Quartile Credit Utilization
Bottom Quartile Credit Score
Change in Revolving Debt -$1284.9(321.4)
-$1206.4(280.7)
As % of Mortgage Payment Reduction 70.6% 65.1%
Debt Deleveraging: Liquidity Constrained
• Very significant debt repayment (deleveraging) in the bottom quarter of liquidity-constrained borrowers Key target of many interventions MPC often viewed as high in this group
• But upper bound MPC of 0.35 – 0.31 Not surprising that marginal dollar allocated to high cost credit
card debt in first year
20
• Wealth constrained show: Bigger improvement in mortgage delinquency Significantly larger increase in new auto debt financing No difference in debt paydown
• Liquidity constrained show: Larger reduction in credit card debt No increase in new auto debt financing
• Complex interaction across measures of wealth and liquidity constraints Traditional response: Lower-wealth households are more
responsive to income shock, but less so if they have a large credit card debt burden
Heterogeneity across Wealth/Liquidity Constraints
21
Regional Analysis
22
Empirical Strategy• Exploit regional variation in share of ARMs
Regions with more ARMs more “exposed” to lower rates Similar to Mian and Sufi (2011) and Agarwal et al. (2012) in the
context of “Cash-for-clunkers” and HAMP programs
• Ex-ante measure of exposure to interest rate declines Zip code ARM share as of Q2 2007 predicts treatment intensity
• Construct sample of similar zip codesMatched on observables (FICO, LTV, interest rate, etc.) Similar results in IV framework (using all zips)
• Investigate impact on economic outcomesMortgage defaults, house prices, durable consumption (auto) and
employment
23
Mortgage Rate: High & Low Exposure ZIP Codes
4.0
4.5
5.0
5.5
6.0
6.5
7.0
7.5
8.0
2006q2
2006q3
2006q4
2007q1
2007q2
2007q3
2007q4
2008q1
2008q2
2008q3
2008q4
2009q1
2009q2
2009q3
2009q4
2010q1
2010q2
2010q3
2010q4
2011q1
2011q2
2011q3
2011q4
2012q1
2012q2
2012q3
2012q4
Treatment
Control
• Interpreting size of first stage:- 100% ARM share would lead to a decrease of 175 bp in mortgage rate
24
‐6
‐5
‐4
‐3
‐2
‐1
0
1
2
3
420
06q2
2006
q320
06q4
2007
q120
07q2
2007
q320
07q4
2008
q120
08q2
2008
q320
08q4
2009
q120
09q2
2009
q320
09q4
2010
q120
10q2
2010
q320
10q4
2011
q120
11q2
2011
q320
11q4
2012
q120
12q2
2012
q320
12q4
HP Growth: High & Low Exposure ZIP Codes
Treatment
Control
25
‐30%
‐20%
‐10%
0%
10%
20%
30%
2007 2008 2009 2010 2011 2012
Auto Growth: High & Low Exposure ZIP Codes
Treatment
Control
26
‐6
‐5
‐4
‐3
‐2
‐1
0
1
2
3
2007 2008 2009 2010 2011 2012
Employment Growth: High & Low Exposure ZIP Codes
Treatment
Control
• All of the employment response comes from non-tradable sector e.g. restaurants and grocery stores
27
Discussion• Low interest rate policies have had meaningful impact on
household spending and broader economy Supports view that shocks to household balance sheets important
factor affecting employment Will we see reversal when stimulus withdrawn?
• Partial estimates suggest that 20% relative reduction in average mortgage rates in a region results in: +3.5% increase in the annual house price growth rate +5% increase in the annual auto purchase growth rate +3% increase in the non-tradable employment growth rate
• Caveats: Cannot quantify overall impact (GE effects) Generic limitation of diff-in-diffs regional analyses
28
Conclusions• Household debt deleveraging can significantly limit the
ability to simulate household consumption Significant part of stimulus due to lower rates transferred to the
banking sector Target polices to alleviate high cost of credit card debt?
• ARM contracts facilitate simple transmission of policy Avoid institutional frictions impacting HARP and HAMP Circumvent inability to refinance (e.g. due to negative equity)
29
Bonus Slides
30
Interest Current Recent Rate Payment Inquiries
Treatment -1.14 -125.08 0.041 (0.30)
(24.52)
(0.021)
Number of Loans 348,259 348,259 348,259 Adjusted R-squared 0.557 0.226 0.081
Impact on New Credit Inquiries: One Year Horizon
31
Interest Current Recent Rate Payment Inquiries
Treatment -1.75 -163.54 -0.099 (0.14)
(10.91)
(0.017)
Number of Loans 348,259 348,259 348,259 Adjusted R-squared 0.891 0.251 0.083
Impact on New Credit Inquiries: Two Year Horizon
32
Interest Current Current Rate Payment FICO
Treatment -1.75 -163.54 5.68 (0.14)
(10.91)
(1.14)
Number of loans 348,259 348,259 348,259 Adjusted R-squared 0.891 0.251 0.07
Impact on Overall Credit Standing: Two Year Horizon
Mortgage Payments: Reduction by average $3,434 over two years Meaningful improvement in credit standing Change in composition of debt leads to overall improvement
33
Quarterly Differential Change in Auto Debt Balance for Borrowers with Agency Mortgages
‐$100
‐$50
$0
$50
$100
$150
$200
‐Q3 ‐Q2 ‐Q1 Q1 Q2 Q3 Q4 Q5 Q6 Q7 Q8
34
Quarterly Differential Change in Auto Debt Balance for Borrowers with Non-Agency Mortgages
‐$100
‐$50
$0
$50
$100
$150
$200
$250
$300
$350
$400
‐Q3 ‐Q2 ‐Q1 Q1 Q2 Q3 Q4 Q5 Q6 Q7 Q8
35
Distribution of Credit Scores & Revolving Debt Balances for Loans in Month 60
36
Mortgage Delinquency, House Price & Auto Sales Growth and ZIP Code ARM Share
37
Distribution of CLTV Ratios
38
Current Current Interest Rate Payment 5/1 ARM -0.065 -23.543
(0.0016) (2.31)
Loan Age > 60 0.002 -24.826 (0.0017) (3.01)
5/1 ARM * Loan Age>60 -0.915 -116.033 (0.005) (3.61)
5/1 ARM * Loan Age>60 -0.421 -16.140 * Util>M (0.0067) (5.04)
Number of loans 286,990 286,990 Adjusted R-squared 0.526 0.197
Impact Heterogeneity: By Credit UtilizationOne Year Horizon
Mortgage Payments: Similar rate decline across two groups
39
Current Current Interest Rate Payment 5/1 ARM -0.038 -21.621
(0.0009) (2.31)
Loan Age > 60 0.003 -56.432 (0.0012) (3.51)
5/1 ARM * Loan Age>60 -1.633 -158.419 (0.0029) (4.05)
5/1 ARM * Loan Age>60 -0.230 -5.326 * Util>M (0.004) (5.55)
Number of loans 286,990 286,990 Adjusted R-squared 0.889 0.216
Impact Heterogeneity: By Credit UtilizationTwo Year Horizon
Mortgage Payments: Similar rate decline across two groups
40
Current Current Mortgage Interest Rate Payment Delinquency 5/1 ARM -0.065 -23.543 0.009
(0.0016) (2.31) (0.0006)
Loan Age > 60 0.002 -24.826 0.003 (0.0017) (3.01) (0.0008)
5/1 ARM * Loan Age>60 -0.915 -116.033 -0.002 (0.005) (3.61) (0.0011)
5/1 ARM * Loan Age>60 -0.421 -16.140 -0.007 * Util>M (0.0067) (5.04) (0.0023)
Number of loans 286,990 286,990 286,990 Adjusted R-squared 0.526 0.197 0.069
Impact Heterogeneity: By Credit UtilizationOne Year Horizon
Mortgage Payments: Similar rate decline across two groups Much stronger impact on defaults of more liquidity constrained
41
Current Current Mortgage Interest Rate Payment Delinquency 5/1 ARM -0.038 -21.621 0.009
(0.0009) (2.31) (0.0006)
Loan Age > 60 0.003 -56.432 0.008 (0.0012) (3.51) (0.0011)
5/1 ARM * Loan Age>60 -1.633 -158.419 -0.007 (0.0029) (4.05) (0.0014)
5/1 ARM * Loan Age>60 -0.230 -5.326 -0.022 * Util>M (0.004) (5.55) (0.003)
Number of loans 286,990 286,990 286,990 Adjusted R-squared 0.889 0.216 0.064
Impact Heterogeneity: By Credit UtilizationTwo Year Horizon
Mortgage Payments: Similar rate decline across two groups Much stronger impact on defaults of more liquidity constrained
42
Current Current Revolving Delinquent Utilization Interest Rate Payment Balance Revolving Balance Rate 5/1 ARM -0.065 -23.543 15.533 0.002 0.985
(0.0016) (2.31) (33.05) (0.0004) (0.107)
Loan Age > 60 0.002 -24.826 190.243 -0.002 0.738 (0.0017) (3.01) (42.28) (0.0005) (0.066)
5/1 ARM * Loan Age>60 -0.915 -116.033 199.478 -0.001 0.061 (0.005) (3.61) (54.35) (0.0009) (0.09)
5/1 ARM * Loan Age>60 -0.421 -16.140 -968.231 0.005 -0.162 * Util>M (0.0067) (5.04) (206.01) (0.002) (0.48)
Number of loans 286,990 286,990 286,990 286,990 286,990 Adjusted R-squared 0.526 0.197 0.212 0.094 0.097
Impact Heterogeneity: By Credit UtilizationOne Year Horizon
Mortgage Payments: Similar rate decline across two groups More liquidity constrained (above median credit util.) allocate about
50% of extra liquidity to credit card repayment in the first year
43
Current Current Revolving Delinquent Utilization Interest Rate Payment Balance Revolving Balance Rate 5/1 ARM -0.038 -21.621 56.238 0.002 0.917
(0.0009) (2.31) (32.89) (0.0005) (0.12)
Loan Age > 60 0.003 -56.432 1089.813 -0.000 3.724 (0.0012) (3.51) (66.57) (0.00) (0.11)
5/1 ARM * Loan Age>60 -1.633 -158.419 153.339 -0.000 0.117 (0.0029) (4.05) (80.7) (0.00) (0.14)
5/1 ARM * Loan Age>60 -0.230 -5.326 -1341.008 -0.011 -2.645 * Util>M (0.004) (5.55) (229.23) (0.0026) (0.484)
Number of loans 286,990 286,990 286,990 286,990 286,990 Adjusted R-squared 0.889 0.216 0.195 0.089 0.085
Impact Heterogeneity: By Credit UtilizationTwo Year Horizon
Mortgage Payments: Similar rate decline across two groups More liquidity constrained (above median credit util.) allocate about
38% of extra liquidity to credit card repayment in the first year
44
Current Current Auto Delinquent Interest Rate Payment Balance Auto Balance 5/1 ARM -0.065 -23.543 -285.074 7.279
(0.0016) (2.31) (71.792) (5.97)
Loan Age > 60 0.002 -24.826 -245.762 -2.823 (0.0017) (3.01) (78.514) (5.88)
5/1 ARM * Loan Age>60 -0.915 -116.033 62.079 -0.078 (0.005) (3.61) (54.976) (7.8)
5/1 ARM * Loan Age>60 -0.421 -16.140 -116.075 4.992 * Util>M (0.0067) (5.04) (53.39) (22.69)
Number of loans 286,990 286,990 286,990 286,990 Adjusted R-squared 0.526 0.197 0.014 0.011
Impact Heterogeneity: By Credit UtilizationOne Year Horizon
Mortgage Payments: Similar rate decline across two groups More liquidity constrained (above median credit util) do not obtain
much new car financing in the first year
45
Current Current Auto Delinquent Interest Rate Payment Balance Auto Balance 5/1 ARM -0.038 -21.621 -303.347 6.996
(0.0009) (2.31) (144.462) (5.93)
Loan Age > 60 0.003 -56.432 -511.526 15.556 (0.0012) (3.51) (241.87) (11.97)
5/1 ARM * Loan Age>60 -1.633 -158.419 179.984 -10.498 (0.0029) (4.05) (100.504) (14.79)
5/1 ARM * Loan Age>60 -0.230 -5.326 -25.500 -35.774 * Util>M (0.004) (5.55) (141.121) (26.9)
Number of loans 286,990 286,990 286,990 286,990 Adjusted R-squared 0.889 0.216 0.012 0.010
Impact Heterogeneity: By Credit UtilizationTwo Year Horizon
Mortgage Payments: Similar rate decline across two groups At 2 year horizon the adverse effect of high credit utilization on auto
financing weakens weakens
46
Current Current Current Interest Rate Payment FICO 5/1 ARM -0.038 -21.621 -4.856
(0.0009) (2.31) (0.23)
Loan Age > 60 0.003 -56.432 -3.698 (0.0012) (3.51) (0.40)
5/1 ARM * Loan Age>60 -1.633 -158.419 1.868 (0.0029) (4.05) (0.48)
5/1 ARM * Loan Age>60 -0.230 -5.326 5.648 * Util>M (0.004) (5.55) (0.86)
Number of loans 286,990 286,990 286,990 Adjusted R-squared 0.889 0.216 0.450
Impact Heterogeneity: By Credit UtilizationTwo Year Horizon
47
Current Current Interest Rate Payment 5/1 ARM -0.067 -24.697
(0.0016) (2.29)
Loan Age > 60 0.002 -23.563 (0.0018) (2.99)
5/1 ARM * Loan Age>60 -0.901 -114.026 (0.0048) (3.58)
5/1 ARM * Loan Age>60 -0.446 -19.880 * FICO<M (0.0067) (5.03)
Number of loans 286,990 286,990 Adjusted R-squared 0.527 0.197
Impact Heterogeneity: By Credit ScoreOne Year Horizon
Mortgage Payments: Similar rate decline across two groups
48
Current Current Interest Rate Payment 5/1 ARM -0.039 -22.768
(0.0009) (2.29)
Loan Age > 60 0.003 -55.663 (0.0013) (3.51)
5/1 ARM * Loan Age>60 -1.623 -155.668 (0.003) (4.04)
5/1 ARM * Loan Age>60 -0.247 -9.954 * FICO<M (0.004) (5.56)
Number of loans 286,990 286,990 Adjusted R-squared 0.890 0.217
Impact Heterogeneity: By Credit ScoreTwo Year Horizon
Mortgage Payments: Similar rate decline across two groups
49
Current Current Mortgage Interest Rate Payment Delinquency 5/1 ARM -0.067 -24.697 0.003
(0.0016) (2.29) (0.0003)
Loan Age > 60 0.002 -23.563 0.004 (0.0018) (2.99) (0.0005)
5/1 ARM * Loan Age>60 -0.901 -114.026 0.001 (0.0048) (3.58) (0.001)
5/1 ARM * Loan Age>60 -0.446 -19.880 -0.013 * FICO<M (0.0067) (5.03) (0.0025)
Number of loans 286,990 286,990 286,990 Adjusted R-squared 0.527 0.197 0.075
Impact Heterogeneity: By Credit ScoreOne Year Horizon
Mortgage Payments: Similar rate decline across two groups Much stronger impact on defaults of less creditworthy
50
Current Current Mortgage Interest Rate Payment Delinquency 5/1 ARM -0.039 -22.768 0.003
(0.0009) (2.29) (0.0003)
Loan Age > 60 0.003 -55.663 0.009 (0.0013) (3.51) (0.0009)
5/1 ARM * Loan Age>60 -1.623 -155.668 -0.003 (0.003) (4.04) (0.001)
5/1 ARM * Loan Age>60 -0.247 -9.954 -0.030 * FICO<M (0.004) (5.56) (0.0028)
Number of loans 286,990 286,990 286,990 Adjusted R-squared 0.890 0.217 0.071
Impact Heterogeneity: By Credit ScoreTwo Year Horizon
Mortgage Payments: Similar rate decline across two groups Much stronger impact on defaults of less creditworthy
51
Current Current Revolving Delinquent Utilization Interest Rate Payment Balance Revolving Balance Rate 5/1 ARM -0.067 -24.697 636.226 0.000 1.707
(0.0016) (2.29) (54.66) (0.00) (0.125)
Loan Age > 60 0.002 -23.563 475.554 0.002 0.730 (0.0018) (2.99) (71.40) (0.0004) (0.095)
5/1 ARM * Loan Age>60 -0.901 -114.026 258.270 -0.000 0.185 (0.0048) (3.58) (92.9) (0.00) (0.124)
5/1 ARM * Loan Age>60 -0.446 -19.880 -906.475 0.003 -0.138 * FICO<M (0.0067) (5.03) (216.86) (0.0018) (0.493)
Number of loans 286,990 286,990 286,990 286,990 286,990 Adjusted R-squared 0.527 0.197 0.123 0.100 0.067
Impact Heterogeneity: By Credit ScoreOne Year Horizon
Mortgage Payments: Similar rate decline across two groups Less creditworthy (below median FICO) allocate about 50% of extra
liquidity to credit card repayment in the first year
52
Current Current Revolving Delinquent Utilization Interest Rate Payment Balance Revolving Balance Rate 5/1 ARM -0.039 -22.768 670.338 -0.000 1.635
(0.0009) (2.29) (54.72) (0.00) (0.139)
Loan Age > 60 0.003 -55.663 1290.809 0.005 3.402 (0.0013) (3.51) (101.24) (0.0005) (0.138)
5/1 ARM * Loan Age>60 -1.623 -155.668 12.104 0.000 -0.348 (0.003) (4.04) (121.04) (0.00) (0.169)
5/1 ARM * Loan Age>60 -0.247 -9.954 -1007.830 -0.012 -1.685 * FICO<M (0.004) (5.56) (241.69) (0.0025) (0.497)
Number of loans 286,990 286,990 286,990 286,990 286,990 Adjusted R-squared 0.890 0.217 0.112 0.095 0.060
Impact Heterogeneity: By Credit ScoreTwo Year Horizon
Mortgage Payments: Similar rate decline across two groups Less creditworthy (below median FICO) allocate about 36% of extra
liquidity to credit card repayment over two years
53
Current Current Auto Delinquent Interest Rate Payment Balance Auto Balance 5/1 ARM -0.067 -24.697 -43.630 -1.978
(0.0016) (2.29) (49.574) (1.55)
Loan Age > 60 0.002 -23.563 -212.162 1.076 (0.0018) (2.99) (79.675) (1.99)
5/1 ARM * Loan Age>60 -0.901 -114.026 177.076 0.775 (0.0048) (3.58) (66.996) (4.31)
5/1 ARM * Loan Age>60 -0.446 -19.880 -293.164 2.504 * FICO<M (0.0067) (5.03) (76.383) (22.76)
Number of loans 286,990 286,990 286,990 286,990 Adjusted R-squared 0.527 0.197 0.014 0.012
Impact Heterogeneity: By Credit ScoreOne Year Horizon
Mortgage Payments: Similar rate decline across two groups Less creditworthy (below median credit score) do not obtain much
new car financing in the first year
54
Current Current Auto Delinquent Interest Rate Payment Balance Auto Balance 5/1 ARM -0.039 -22.768 -62.633 -2.216
(0.0009) (2.29) (47.745) (1.59)
Loan Age > 60 0.003 -55.663 -423.552 6.811 (0.0013) (3.51) (154.757) (4.54)
5/1 ARM * Loan Age>60 -1.623 -155.668 322.019 10.698 (0.003) (4.04) (99.164) (7.48)
5/1 ARM * Loan Age>60 -0.247 -9.954 -251.808 -73.436 * FICO<M (0.004) (5.56) (126.936) (25.59)
Number of loans 286,990 286,990 286,990 286,990 Adjusted R-squared 0.890 0.217 0.012 0.011
Impact Heterogeneity: By Credit ScoreTwo Year Horizon
Mortgage Payments: Similar rate decline across two groups At 2 year horizon this adverse effect on below median credit score
on new auto financing weakens
55
Current Current Current Interest Rate Payment FICO 5/1 ARM -0.039 -22.768 -4.248
(0.0009) (2.29) (0.126)
Loan Age > 60 0.003 -55.663 -7.934 (0.0013) (3.51) (0.30)
5/1 ARM * Loan Age>60 -1.623 -155.668 0.728 (0.003) (4.04) (0.36)
5/1 ARM * Loan Age>60 -0.247 -9.954 6.854 * FICO<M (0.004) (5.56) (0.773)
Number of loans 286,990 286,990 286,990 Adjusted R-squared 0.890 0.217 0.567
Impact Heterogeneity: By Credit ScoreTwo Year Horizon
56
Treatment Effect of Reduction in Mortgage Payments on Debt Deleveraging
57
ZIP Code ARM Share & Change in Mortgage Rate (IV 1st Stage)
(1) (2) (3) ARM Share -0.0209
(0.0002) -0.0201 (0.0002)
-0.0198 (0.0003)
Zip Code Controls No Yes Yes State FE No No Yes Number of Zip Codes 8084 7488 7488 R-Squared 0.571 0.711 0.728
58
Change in Delinquency, House Price & Auto Sales Growth on ZIP Code Change in Mortgage Rate (IV 2nd Stage)
Mortgage Delinquency Growth House Price Growth Auto Sales Growth (1) (3) (4) (6) (7) (9)
Mortgage Rate Change 28.93 18.08 -0.39 -0.79 -2.70 -1.26 (0.82) (1.31) (0.07) (0.10) (0.15) (0.27)
Zip Code Controls No Yes No Yes No Yes State FE No Yes No Yes No Yes Number of Zip Codes 8082 7487 8000 7487 8084 7488 Adjusted R-squared 0.091 0.341 0.05 0.429 0.020 0.185
59
Summary Statistics (Month 48)
Full Sample 5/1 ARMs 7/1 ARMs Mean S.D. Mean S.D. Mean S.D.
Original Rate 5.05 0.71 5.02 0.75 5.12 0.60 Current Rate 5.05 0.71 5.02 0.75 5.12 0.60 Margin 2.48 0.31 2.48 0.32 2.48 0.28 Current Mortgage Payment 1,013 441.89 1,012 444.79 1,014 434.95 Number of Student Loans 0.42 0.80 0.41 0.80 0.42 0.81 Number of Recent Credit Inquiries 1.86 2.05 2.00 2.08 1.76 1.98 Revolving Debt 12,426 19,149 12,642 19,427 11,901 18,483 Delinquent Revolving Debt 0.036 0.21 0.04 0.22 0.03 0.20 Revolving Utilization 24.26 26.25 24.99 26.74 22.55 24.97 Auto Debt 9,147 14,262 9,223 14,361 8,995 14,026 Origination FICO 725.76 53.86 724.42 53.96 728.95 53.51 Current FICO 727.07 78.09 724.40 79.52 733.38 74.21 Origination Combined LTV 74.00 17.75 74.15 17.93 73.64 17.31 Mortgage Delinquency Rate 0.02 0.18 0.026 0.025 0.015 0.15 Number of Loans 348,259 244,765 103,494
60
Full Sample 5/1 ARMs 7/1 ARMsMean S.D. Mean S.D. Mean S.D.
Original Rate 5.04 0.72 5.02 0.76 5.10 0.60 Current Rate 5.04 0.72 5.02 0.76 5.10 0.60 Margin 2.48 0.31 2.48 0.32 2.49 0.28 Current Mortgage Payment 1,010 443 1,010 447 1,008 434 Number of Student Loans 0.41 0.81 0.41 0.81 0.42 0.82 Number of Recent Credit Inquiries 1.85 2.02 1.90 2.06 1.74 1.92 Revolving Debt 12,846 18,430 13,040 18,819 12,413 17,536 Delinquent Revolving Debt 0.05 0.18 0.05 0.18 0.04 0.16 Revolving Utilization 25.40 78.13 26.46 92.75 23.09 25.17 Auto Debt 8,463 21,144 8,465 21,922 8,459 19,361 Origination FICO 725.00 54.39 723.28 54.54 728.78 53.85 Current FICO 725.25 77.24 721.74 78.89 732.91 72.91 Origination Combined LTV 73.89 17.81 74.13 17.97 73.34 17.45 Mortgage Delinquency Rate 0.04 0.20 0.04 0.00 0.03 0.17
Summary Statistics (Month 60)
61
Geographic Distribution of ZIP Codes
62
Geographic Distribution of ZIP Codes
63
High Exposure Zip Codes
Low Exposure Zip Codes
Mean (S.D.) Mean (S.D.) FICO 714.8 (23.2) 716.0 (18.9) LTV 64.5 (7.29) 68.1 (7.00) Interest Rate 6.64 (0.57) 6.68 (0.48) Mortgage Delinquency Rate 2.81 (3.09) 2.23 (1.83) Unemployment Rate 6.04 (1.55) 5.91 (1.47) Median Income 58.42 (14.13) 52.77 (14.38) Percentage with College Degree 31.4 (10.1) 29.5 (9.42) Percentage Married with Children 21.9 (5.13) 21.6 (5.13) Consumer Credit Score 3.37 (0.41) 3.35 (0.35) ARM Share 35.2 (7.62) 17.3 (4.51)
Range in zip code ARM share: 5.8% to 63%
Summary Statistics
64
FICO Score: High & Low Exposure ZIP Codes
650
660
670
680
690
700
710
720
730
740
750
2006q2 2006q3 2006q4 2007q1 2007q2
Treatment
Control
65
Mortgage Rate: High & Low Exposure ZIP Codes
3.03.54.04.55.05.56.06.57.07.58.08.59.0
2006q2 2006q3 2006q4 2007q1 2007q2
Treatment
Control
66
Interest Rate Indices
0.00.51.01.52.02.53.03.54.04.55.05.56.06.57.07.58.02006q2
2006q3
2006q4
2007q1
2007q2
2007q3
2007q4
2008q1
2008q2
2008q3
2008q4
2009q1
2009q2
2009q3
2009q4
2010q1
2010q2
2010q3
2010q4
2011q1
2011q2
2011q3
2011q4
2012q1
2012q2
2012q3
2012q4
Six Month LIBOR 1yr Treasury