16
MOLTEN-CAUSTIC-LEACHING (GRAVIMELT) SYSTEM INTEGRATION PROJECT QUARTERLY REPORT FOR JULY THROUGH SEPTEMBER, 1989 f6 CONTRACT NUMBER DE-AC22~PC91257 OCTOBER 10, 1989 PREPARED BY APPLIED TECHNOLOGY D I V I S I O N SPACE AND TECHNOLOGY GROUP ONE SPACE PARK REDONDO BEACH, CA 9 0 2 7 8 PREPARED FOR U.S. DEPARTMENT OF ENERGY PITTSBURGH ENERGY TECHNOLOGY CENTER P.O. BOX 10940 - MS/922-206 PITTSBURGH, PA 15236

MOLTEN-CAUSTIC-LEACHING (GRAVIMELT) SYSTEM …/67531/metadc625471/m2/1/high_res... · caustic evaporator where two weights of wash water are recovered for recycle to the first wash

  • Upload
    others

  • View
    3

  • Download
    0

Embed Size (px)

Citation preview

Page 1: MOLTEN-CAUSTIC-LEACHING (GRAVIMELT) SYSTEM …/67531/metadc625471/m2/1/high_res... · caustic evaporator where two weights of wash water are recovered for recycle to the first wash

MOLTEN-CAUSTIC-LEACHING (GRAVIMELT) SYSTEM INTEGRATION PROJECT

QUARTERLY REPORT FOR JULY THROUGH SEPTEMBER, 1989 f 6 CONTRACT NUMBER DE-AC22~PC91257

OCTOBER 10, 1989

PREPARED BY APPLIED TECHNOLOGY D I V I S I O N SPACE AND TECHNOLOGY GROUP

ONE SPACE PARK REDONDO BEACH, CA 90278

PREPARED FOR U.S. DEPARTMENT OF ENERGY

PITTSBURGH ENERGY TECHNOLOGY CENTER P.O. BOX 10940 - MS/922-206

PITTSBURGH, PA 15236

Page 2: MOLTEN-CAUSTIC-LEACHING (GRAVIMELT) SYSTEM …/67531/metadc625471/m2/1/high_res... · caustic evaporator where two weights of wash water are recovered for recycle to the first wash

DISCLAIMER

Portions of this document may be illegible in electronic image products. Images are produced from the best available original document.

Page 3: MOLTEN-CAUSTIC-LEACHING (GRAVIMELT) SYSTEM …/67531/metadc625471/m2/1/high_res... · caustic evaporator where two weights of wash water are recovered for recycle to the first wash

1. EXECUTIVE SUMMARY

Operation o f the Gravimelt Integrated Test C i r cu i t f o r desul fur izat ion and demineralization o f coal has been completed. A 48-test process matrix was performed over 750 hours o f operational time resul t ing i n production o f 3,000 pounds o f t reated coal su i tab le f o r fur ther t e s t and evaluation.

Analysis o f the several thousand data i s underway. Assessment o f coal material balance data shows an average 98% closure wi th 2% conversion o f coal t o humics and phenolics, 3% conversion t o hydrogen and methane and 3 1/2% loss as carbonate.

Assessment o f sul fur forms data shows a mean residual p u r i t i c su l fu r o f 0.022% f o r Pit tsburgh No. 8 seam coal and 0.01% f o r Kentucky No. 9. Organic su l fu r removal was dependent on conditions w i th lowest a t 0.08% a f t e r processing i n the plant. The mean su l fa te su l fu r leve l was 0.28% wi th a standard deviat ion o f only 0.06%.

2.INTRODUCTION AND PROCESS DESCRIPTION

TRW, under sponsorship o f the Department o f Energy's Pit tsburgh Energy Technology Center (Contract No. DE-AC22-86-PC91257) i s evaluating the Gravimelt Process i n commercial equipment i ns ta l l ed i n an Integrated Test Ci rcu i t . The c i r c u i t i s located a t the TRW San Juan Capistrano t e s t s i t e i n Cal i fornia.

The process u t i l i z e s a melt o f sodium hydroxide o r mixtures o f sodium and potassium hydroxides a t temperatures o f 325' t o 415'C t o remove v i r t u a l l y a l l of the su l fu r and mineral matter from coal. The resul ts o f an i n i t i a l ten weeks o f shakedown and operation o f the integrated tes t c i r c u i t show t h a t Eastern coals can be treated t o meet New Source Performance Standards f o r su l fu r oxides control while providing a product with heat content o f 14,000 Btu per pound o r greater and an ash content as low as a few hundreds o f a percent.

The process i s seen as a potent ia l replacement ifor the cos t ly f l u e gas desul fur izat ion systems contemplated f o r smaller u t i l i t i e s and indust r ia l boi lers. The product coal might also displace o i l i n some turbine and diesel engines and may have appl icat ion as an inexpensive preactivated or act ivated carbon f o r ext ract ion o f po l lu tants from waste water and can po ten t ia l l y be used t o clean-up and concentrate radioactive or tox ic waste. Process and p lant descript ions are presented i n the next two sections .

1

Page 4: MOLTEN-CAUSTIC-LEACHING (GRAVIMELT) SYSTEM …/67531/metadc625471/m2/1/high_res... · caustic evaporator where two weights of wash water are recovered for recycle to the first wash

2.1 Process Description

A schematic o f the Gravimelt process i s shown i n Figure 1. i s f i r s t combined w i th a mixture o f dry sodium hydroxide or m and potassium hydroxides i n a rotary k i l n reactor where the heated t o reaction temperatures o f 325' t o 415'C become sorbed i n the coal matrix, 2) react and su l fu r and mineral matter.

The reaction mixture e x i t s the rotary k

Feed coal xed sodium mixture is

causing the caustic t o 1) then 3) dissolve the coal

I n i n the form o f pe l l e t s which are next washed with water i n a countercurrent separation system o f f i l t e r s and centrifuges. As an example, the use o f four weights o f wash water per weight o f coal resul ts i n a coal cake containing up t o two parts o f wash water per par t o f coal ex i t i ng the l a s t stage o f the countercurrent system, and also a 50 percent aqueous reacted caustic so lut ion e x i t i n g the f i r s t stage o f f i l t r a t i o n which contains nearly a l l o f the coal-derived s i l i con , aluminum, carbonate and su l fu r content. The coal-derived i r o n (usually 2-3 percent o f the weight o f the coal) and a small amount o f sodium and/or potassium (0.1-2 percent o f the weight o f the coal) remains w i th the coal e x i t i n g the countercurrent f i l t r a t i o n system.

The coal cake i s next washed t o remove the residual i r o n and caustic with, f o r example, three weights o f process water, again i n a countercurrent mode. Su l fu r ic acid i s added t o the f i r s t stage t o dissolve the residual a l k a l i and i ron hydroxide. A typ ica l coal cake entering the acid wash f i l t r a t i o n t r a i n contains two (or as l i t t l e as one-half) weights o f sorbed water while the product coal e x i t i n g the t r a i n contains one ten th t o one weight o f sorbed water. Where two weights o f wash water enter the acid wash section on the coal cake and the product coal carr ies one weight o f water, the acid ext ract leaving the f i r s t stage of the ac id wash section consists o f four weights o f water containing 250 t o 5,000 ppm of mixed sodium and potassium and 5,000 t o 10,000 ppm o f i ron .

A l l o f the i r o n su l fa te and a por t ion o f the a l k a l i sul fates i n t h i s stream can be removed by a sequence o f heating and lime treatment t o form insoluble minerals. The water can be recycled.

The aqueous caustic i s limed a t 400 t o 1250C t o remove the coal derived minerals and carbonate, and the p u r i f i e d l i q u i d i s sent t o a caustic evaporator where two weights o f wash water are recovered for recycle t o the f i r s t wash t r a i n while producing anhydrous caustic for reuse i n ext ract ion o f coal.

2

Page 5: MOLTEN-CAUSTIC-LEACHING (GRAVIMELT) SYSTEM …/67531/metadc625471/m2/1/high_res... · caustic evaporator where two weights of wash water are recovered for recycle to the first wash

TRW Gravimelt Process

EVAPORATOR

DRY CAUSTIC

FEED COAL

WATER

KILN REACTOR WATER WASH

WATER

WATER - Acln

ACID /WATL R TREATMENT n

WATER

. GRAVIMELT COAL

Figure 1, Qravimelt Process Flow Schematic

3

Page 6: MOLTEN-CAUSTIC-LEACHING (GRAVIMELT) SYSTEM …/67531/metadc625471/m2/1/high_res... · caustic evaporator where two weights of wash water are recovered for recycle to the first wash

2.2 Integrated Test C i rcu i t Description

The t e s t c i r c u i t consists o f s i x u n i t operations (see Figure 1 ) which together provide a continuous system f o r leaching coal and regenerating the caustic reactant and wash water. These un i t s are a) a k i l n f o r reacting molten caustic wi th coal, b) a seven stage water washing section f o r recovering caustic from the coal, c) a three stage acid washing section f o r removing the l a s t traces o f metals and a l k a l i and providing an u l t r a pure coal product, d) a water treatment section t o provide e i ther dischargeable or recyclable water, e) a regeneration section t o provide pu r i f i ed aqueous caustic and f) an evaporator section t o provide molten caustic f o r recycle t o the k i l n reactor.

The integrated t e s t c i r c u i t f a c i l i t y contains more than 160 pieces o f equipment including f i l t e r s , centrifuges, tanks, reactors, feeders and the k i l n and r i s i n g f i l m evaporator. It occupies 3,700 square feet and i s f i t t e d w i th more than 6,000 fee t o f piping, 425 valves, 80 instruments and controls as wel l as a control room with computer control and data acquis i t ion and reduction system.

3. PROJECT DESCRIPTION

The object ive o f t h i s pro ject i s t o design, construct and operate an integrated t e s t c i r c u i t (as shown i n Figure 1) f o r evaluation o f the Gravimelt Process and production o f desulfurized and demineralized coal samples.

The pro ject consists o f e ight tasks f o r planning, design, equipment procurement, construction and shakedown, t e s t planning, operation, data assessment and management.

4. PROJECT ACCOMPLISHMENTS

Assessment o f data fo r coal hydrocarbon material balance, su l fu r forms remaining i n processed coal and formation o f humics and phenolics i s presented i n the sections t o follow. Uore than 4000 analyses were obtained on process streams such as product coal, intennediate coal, s lu r r ies , f i l t e r cakes and f i l t r a t e s during 750 hours o f matr ix test ing. The cost o f the analyses and assessment o f the analyses, as shown below, const i tuted 45% o f the t o t a l budget f o r p lant operation, sample analysis and data assessment. I n order t o r e s t r i c t these costs t o the 45% level and not reduce budget for operation, it was necessary t o l i m i t analyses of process streams. Thus, stream data points are of ten used t o cover a wide range o f operating hours and computations are somatimes used, based on data, f o r material balance calculations.

4

Page 7: MOLTEN-CAUSTIC-LEACHING (GRAVIMELT) SYSTEM …/67531/metadc625471/m2/1/high_res... · caustic evaporator where two weights of wash water are recovered for recycle to the first wash

4.1 Coal Material Balance

The coal material balances f o r a l l nine MCL runs, subsequent t o shakedown, are shown i n Table 1. These material balances are based on the coal feed t o the rotary k i l n , and the washed coal product and k i l n discharge coal product col lected, a l l obtained from the operation log book and corrected t o HAF coal, using feed coal and product coal analysis data. In addit ion, data from the MCL operations show tha t approximately 2% o f the feed coal was converted t o vo la t i l es (mainly methane and hydrogen) i n the k i l n gas, and another 2% t o humics and phenolics. These are used as the basis f o r estimating the amount o f vo la t i l es and humics and phenolics i n each run.

Analysis o f the k i l n discharge product and the spent caustic both show t h a t on the average, approximately 15% o f the cuastic feed was converted t o carbonates. The amount o f coal carbon i n carbonates i s computed using the 15% caustic feed conversion rate, the caustic/coal feed ra t io , and the percentage o f carbon i n carbonates. The su l fu r removed from coal i s computed from the di f ference o f su l fu r content o f the feed coal and the su l fu r contents o f the washed coal product and k i l n discharge coal product.

The amount o f coal f ines col lected i s estimated using the 120 l b per hour caust ic so lut ion rate, the t o t a l hours o f operation o f the caustic wash section i n each run, and the concentration o f coal f ines i n the caustic so lut ion sent t o the bag f i l t e r s (where coal f ines were col lected). Except f o r Runs 2, 3 and 4, the amount o f coal f ines i s based on a 0.435% coal f ines concentration i n the caustic wash solution. The 0.435% coal f ines concentration i n caustic so lut ion was obtained from the average o f Run 1 data. For Runs 2 and 3, coal f ines concentrations o f 0.122% and 0.051% from the analysis o f the caustic wash so lut ion are used. For Run 4, the amount o f coal f ines i s the sum o f the coal f ines col lected on the bag f i l t e r s (46.60 l b on dry basis) and the residual coal f ines t h a t passed through these bag f i l t e r s (85.43 lb). The amount o f residual coal f i nes was exceptional ly high f o r Run 4, because an average o f 0.85% coal f ines concentration was found i n the f i l t e r e d caustic wash solution, probably due t o the use o f f i l t e r media o f incorrect mesh s ize during the operation o f the vacuum f i l t e r . The amount o f coal f i nes i n caustic so lut ion f luctuated during the operation o f each run, and would be s ign i f i can t l y reduced i f the two vacuum f i l t e r s were i n operation and with the proper f i l t e r media.

5 '

Page 8: MOLTEN-CAUSTIC-LEACHING (GRAVIMELT) SYSTEM …/67531/metadc625471/m2/1/high_res... · caustic evaporator where two weights of wash water are recovered for recycle to the first wash

Table 1. Coal Material Balance

- - Run 1 Run 2

Coal product ( l b MAF) 270.4

K i l n d i scharge coal ( l b MAF) 111.4

Volatiles i n k i l n gas ( l b ) 14.2

Humics and phenol ics (1 b) 14.2

Carbon i n carbonates ( l b ) 21.8

Coal fines i n bag f i l ters ( l b ) 53.0

S u l f u r removed from coal ( l b ) 22.3

Coal l e f t i n wash section ( l b MAF) 25.0

Coal left i n k i l n ( l b MAF) 47.3

Total coal product and coal d e r i vat i ves (1 b)

Coal feed t o k i l n ( l b MAF)

Mass balance closure (X)

306.9

119.4

13.3

13.3

25.5

0.0

20.2

25.0

29.5

Run 3

04.3

488.8

17.1

17.1

33.4

3.2

30.9

25.0

15.9

Run 4

313.9

179.0

13.9

17.3

31.3

132.0

23.0

25.0

6.0

Run 5

454.3

8.3

16.4

16.4

35.6

54.9

25.9

25.0

33.5

580.4 561.9 715.7 742.2 670.3

611.0 577.8 734.0 743.1 711.2

95.0 97.2 97.5 99.9 94.2

6

Page 9: MOLTEN-CAUSTIC-LEACHING (GRAVIMELT) SYSTEM …/67531/metadc625471/m2/1/high_res... · caustic evaporator where two weights of wash water are recovered for recycle to the first wash

Tab1 e 1. Coal Materi a1 Bal ance (Continued)

Coal product (1 b MAF)

K i l n d i scharge coal (1 b MAF)

Vo la t i l e s i n k i l n gas ( l b )

Humics and phenol ics (1 b)

Carbon i n carbonates ( l b )

Coal fines i n bag f i l ters ( l b )

Su l fu r removed from coal ( l b )

Coal l e f t i n wash section ( l b MAF)

Coal l e f t i n k i l n ( l b MAF)

Run 6

556.4

386.4

26.9

26.9

33.8

34.3

35.9

25.0

8.1

Run 7

323.6

68.2

12.2

12.2

29.5

50.6

18.2

25.0

8.6

Run 8

401 .O

168.1

16.7

16.7

28.6

52.2

29.1

25.0

5.7

Run 9

251.3

30.0

9.7

9.7

36.2

42.4

18.5

25.0

4.9 . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . Total coal product and coal d e r i v a t i v e s (1 b) 1133.7 548.1 743.1 427.7

Coal feed t o k i l n ( l b MAF) 1155.9 533.7 758.7 417.2

Mass balance closure (X) 98.1 102.7 97.9 102.5

7

Page 10: MOLTEN-CAUSTIC-LEACHING (GRAVIMELT) SYSTEM …/67531/metadc625471/m2/1/high_res... · caustic evaporator where two weights of wash water are recovered for recycle to the first wash

The amount o f coal l e f t i n the wash section a t the end o f each run i s estimated t o be 25 lbs. This i s derived by f i r s t estimating that the amount o f process o lu t ions l e f t i n the wash tanks a t the end o f run would be 514 l b (8 tanks x 14 gallons per tank x 50% f u l l x 8.34 lb/gal lon x 1.1 spec i f i c grav i ty) , and then using an average 3.8% coal concentration i n the so lut ion (obtained from Run 1 data). The amount o f coal l e f t i n the wash tanks is , therefore, 19.5 lb. The 25 l b estimate includes allowance f o r some addit ional coal l e f t i n centr i fuges and process piping. The amount o f coal l e f t i n the rotary k i l n a t the end o f each run i s estimated from review o f the operation log book data. For f i v e o f the nine runs, the equivalent o f one hour o f feed material was l e f t inside the rotary k i l n a t the-end o f each run. For Runs 1, 2, 3 and 5 , however, it appears tha t large quant i t ies o f feed mater ia l were s t i l l l e f t inside the k i l n , because the k i l n was shut o f f shor t l y a f t e r the t ransfer o f addi t ional coal/caustic t o the feed hopper.

As shown i n Table 1, excel lent mass balance closure i s obtained f o r each o f the nine runs, ranging from 94.2% f o r Run 5 t o 102.7% f o r Run 7. For the nine runs combined, the t o t a l coal product and coal der ivat ives amounted t o 6,123 l b , and the t o t a l coal feed t o the rotary k i l n was 6,243 lb. The resu l t ing combined mass balance closure i s 98.1%

4.2 Sul fur Form Analysis

Samples o f k i l n discharge coal and washed coal product from.selected WCL runs were analyzed t o determine the forms o f residual su l fu r present i n MCL coal. A secondary ob ject ive f o r t h i s analysis was t o resolve whether su l fa te su l fu r was fonned i n k i l n processing, or as a resu l t o f subsequent wash by d i l u t e s u l f u r i c acid. Therefore, some o f the samples were only analyzed t o determine su l fa te su l fu r and t o t a l sul fur . I f su l fa tes were formed i n k i l n processing, i t may be possible t o delineate the operating conditions tha t suppress su l fa te fonnation. I f sul fates were formed by d i l u t e s u l f u r i c acid wash, then it may be necessary t o consider al ternate washing schemes i n order t o further reduce residual sulfur leve ls i n HCL coal.

The su l fu r form analysis resu l ts are presented i n Table 2. As shown i n t h i s table, the amount o f su l fa te su l fu r i n HCL coal appears t o remain invar ient of coal type o f processing conditions. The mean su l fa te su l fu r leve l for the WCL coal samples i s 0.28%, with a standard deviat ion o f only 0.06%.

Ten sets o f su l fa te su l fu r data are compared i n Figure 2, wi th each set representing k i l n discharge (KO) coal versus washed coal product (CP) data from the same run. The comparisons show higher KD than CP sulfate su l fu r leve ls i n 6 data sets, same KD and CP su l fa te sulfur leve l i n 1 data set, and lower KD than CP su l fa te leve ls in 3 data sets. I n addition, the Pi t tsburgh No. 8 and the Kentucky NO. 9 coal feed only contains 0.04% and 0.02-0.06% su l fa te su l fur , respectively. These indicate tha t su l fa te su l fu r I n WCL coal i s formed i n k i l n processing, and

Page 11: MOLTEN-CAUSTIC-LEACHING (GRAVIMELT) SYSTEM …/67531/metadc625471/m2/1/high_res... · caustic evaporator where two weights of wash water are recovered for recycle to the first wash

Table 2. Sul fur Form A n a l y s i s R e s u l t s

Coal

4C1 PITT 8

681 PITT 8 6Dl PITT 8

7A KENT 9 7A KENT 9 78 KEMT 9 76 KENT 9

7C PITT 8 7C PITT 8 7D PITT 8 7D PITT 8 7E PITT 8

8A PITT 8 8A PITT 8 8B PITT 8 8C PITT 8 80 PITT 8 8E PITT 8 8F PITT 8 8F PITT 8

9A PITT 8 9A PITT 8 9A1 PITT 8 9A1 PITT 8

9B PITT 8 9C PITT 8 9C PITT 8

9B - PITT 8

Sample TvDe

CP

CP CP

CP KD CP KD

CP KD CP KD KD

CP KD CP CP CP CP CP KD

CP KD CP KD CP KD CP KD

% S u l f a t e Sulfur - Mean

0.24

0.29 0.28

0.35 0.29 0.27 0.35

0.26 0.26 0.21 0.36 0.29

0.28 0.34 0.21 0.13 0.25 0.23 0.36 0.35

0.27 0.33 0.30 0.41 0.26 0.28 0.30 0.19

S t d Dev. Data P t s

0.08

0.01

0.08 0.09

-

- - - - - -

0.04

- 0.03 - - 0.07

0.10 - - -

0.03 0.03

0.03 0.08 0.02

-

-

2

1 2

3 3 1 1

1 1 1 1 3

1 4 1 1 2 1 3 1

1 3 2 1 3 1 6 1

% P y r i t i c S u l f u r

0.04

0.01 0.02

0.01 - - - - - - - -

0.02

0.07 0.03 0.03 0.02 0.01

-

- 0.01

0.01

0.003

0.002

- - - -

For p y r i t i c and o r g a n i c sulfur, an '-' i n d i c a t e s no data.

9

X Organic S u l f u r

0.47

1.05 1.09

0.22 - - - - - - - -

0.55

1 .oo 0.61 0.56 0.52 0.63

-

- 0.60

0.41

0.35

0.19

-

- -

% T o t a l S u l f u r

0.74

1.35 1.38

0.59 0.73 0.56 0.63

0.54

0.38 0.66 1.50

-

0.85 0.80 1.37 0.77 0.80 0.76 0.92 1.01

0.88 0.97 0.72 0.79 0.62 1.25 0.49 0.23

Page 12: MOLTEN-CAUSTIC-LEACHING (GRAVIMELT) SYSTEM …/67531/metadc625471/m2/1/high_res... · caustic evaporator where two weights of wash water are recovered for recycle to the first wash

n

Figure 2. Comparison of Sulfate Sulfur in Kiln Discharge Coal and Washed Coal Product

10

Page 13: MOLTEN-CAUSTIC-LEACHING (GRAVIMELT) SYSTEM …/67531/metadc625471/m2/1/high_res... · caustic evaporator where two weights of wash water are recovered for recycle to the first wash

not due t o washing by d i l u t e s u l f u r i c ac some of the runs, downstream washing i n i t i a l l y formed. Thus, these su l fa te the effect iveness o f the countercurrent plant.

d. It also appears tha t i n a t least removes par t of the sulfate su l fur eve1 comparisons provide evidence of washing scheme i n the integrated MCL

The su l fa te i n MCL coal i s probably present as i ron sul fate, formed from the th iosu l fa te derived from the reaction of sodium or potassium hydroxide with coal p y r i t i c su l fur :

8 FeS2 t 30 NaOH = 14 NazS + NazSzOa t 4 Fez03 t 15 H20

The above reaction indicates tha t 1/8 o f the p y r i t i c su l fu r could be converted t o th iosu l fa te and subsequently t o i ron sul fate, which apparently cannot be readi ly removed from coal by washing wi th water o r d i l u t e su l fu r i c acid. For Pit tsburgh No. 8 coal, the 1.69% p y r i t i c su l fu r and 0.04% sul fa te su l fu r i n the coal feed could resu l t i n 0.25% su l fa te su l fu r i n MCL coal. Simi lar ly, the 1.84% p y r i t i c su l fu r and 0.02-0.06% su l fa te su l fu r i n Kentucky No. 9 coal feed could resu l t i n 0.27% su l fa te su l fu r i n MCL coal. These su l fa te su l fu r leve ls are approximately the same as the average 0.28% su l fa te leve ls determined from the MCL coal samples.

This retent ion o f su l fa te su l fu r can therefore be reduced by u t i l i z i n g low p y r i t e (highly cleaned) coals i n the Gravimelt Process. For example, coal deep cleaned t o 0.5% p y r i t i c su l fur , but containing any amount o f organic su l fu r should be reducable t o 0.1% organic su l fu r (see below), 0.02% p y r i t i c su l fu r (also, see below) and 0.07% su l fa te su l fu r (see above) f o r a t o t a l su l fu r o f 0.19%.

The data presented i n Table 2 also show tha t i n almost every case, the p y r i t i c s u l f u r i n MCL coal has been reduced t o extremely low levels. The mean residual p y r i t i c su l fu r leve l i s 0.022% f o r Pit tsburgh coal, and 0.01% for Kentucky coal. These represent 98.7% and 99.5% removal o f the p y r i t t c sulfur present i n the Pittsburgh and Kentucky coals fed t o the rotary k i l n .

The amount o f residual organic su l fu r i n MCL coal i s strongly dependent on processing conditions. The lowest organic su l fu r leve l found i s 0.08% from a Run - 9 C coal product sample. The e f fec ts o f processing condit ions on su l fur removal w i l l be discussed i n d e t a i l i n a separate section of the f i n a l report.

4.3 Formation O f Humic Acid And Phenolics

Soluble organic compounds present i n the spent caustic solut ions are c lass i f ied as humic materials i f they prec ip i ta te upon ac id i f icat ion, and as phenolic mater ia ls i f they remain soluble upon ac id i f icat ion. Data on the conversion o f coal feed t o humics are presented i n Tabla 3. Data on the conversion t o phenolics are not reported because o f analy t ica l and sampling problems.

11

Page 14: MOLTEN-CAUSTIC-LEACHING (GRAVIMELT) SYSTEM …/67531/metadc625471/m2/1/high_res... · caustic evaporator where two weights of wash water are recovered for recycle to the first wash

.

Table 3. Formation o f Humic Acid

- Run

1B 1c 1D

2B 2c 2D 2E

3B1 3C 1

4C 1 4C2 4c3

5B1 5B3 5c5 5c4 5D3

8A 86 8C 8D 8E 8F

9A1 9B 9c

Coal TvDe

PITT 8 PITT 8 PITT 8

PITT 8 PITT 8 KENT 9 KENT 9

PITT 8 PITT 8

PITT 8 PITT 8 PITT 8

PITT 8 PITT 8 KENT 9 KENT 9 KENT 9

PITT 8 PITT 8 PITT 8 PITT 8 PITT 8 PITT 8

PITT 8 PITT 8 PITT 8

KOH/ - NaOH

1 1 1

1 1 1 1

1 1

0 0 0

0 0 0 0 0

1 1 0 0 0 0

1 1 0

Leach Temo, Qc*

259 279 279

259 296 296 307

307 307

290 302 323

302 237 298 223 252

395 395 403 417 389 384

407 415 419

% Coal Converted to Humics - Mean

0.533 0.794 1.231

0.249 0.067 0.236 0.039

0.507 0.217

3.97 5.38 1.74

3.17

1.67 5.95 2.49

1.94 1.20 0.744 1.14 1.27 1.24

1.17 0.209 0.318

10.4

Std Dev.

- 1.041 0.676

0.148 0.060 -

- 0.392 -

- 0.445

- - - - - - -

0.276 - - - - -

0.319

Data P t s Ranse

1 3 4

2 3 1 1

6 1

1 2 1

1 1 1 1 1

1 1 2 1 1 1

1 1 2

0.533 0.105-1.992 0.278-1.872

0.144-0.354 0.027-0.136

0.236 0.039

0.066-1.02 0.217

3.97

1.74

3.17

1.67 5.95 2.49

5.06-5.69

10.4

1.94 1.20

0.548-0.939 1.14 1.27 1.24

1.17 0.209

0.093-0.524

* Leaching temperature is based on temperatures measured by the thermocouple prob placed in either Zone 1 (Runs 4 and 5) or Zone 2 (Runs 8 and 9) o f the rotary ki1; For Runs 1 to 3, the leaching temperature is estimated by assuming a 131 temperature difference between the Zone 1 kiln wall and the caustic/coal mixture.

12

Page 15: MOLTEN-CAUSTIC-LEACHING (GRAVIMELT) SYSTEM …/67531/metadc625471/m2/1/high_res... · caustic evaporator where two weights of wash water are recovered for recycle to the first wash

.

Data on the conversion o f coal feed t o humics are also p lo t ted i n Figure 3 as a funct ion of the caustic/coal temperature i n Zone 1 (Runs 1 t o 5) o r Zone 2 (Runs 8 and 9) o f the rotary k i l n . The nitrogen flow was concurrent w i th the coal/caustic f low i n Runs 1 t o 5, and countercurrent t o the coal/caustic f low i n Runs 8 and 9. The net resu l t was tha t i n Runs 1 t o 5, the temperature dif ference between the k i l n wal l and the coal/caustic mixture i n Zone 1 was t y p i c a l l y 131OC. By comparison, the temperature di f ference between the k i l n wall and the coal/caustic mixture i n Zone 2 was only i n the 19-32OC range i n Runs 8 and 9. For Runs 1 t o 5, leaching temperature would increase i n the subsequent zones o f the rotary k i l n and would be higher than the temperature indicated by the Zone 1 probe sensor. For Runs 8 and 9, the leaching temperature i n a l l four zones o f the rotary k i l n would be approximately the same as indicated by the Zone 2 probe sensor.

the

Based on the data from Runs 4C1, 4C2, 5B1, 5B3, 5C4 and 503, formation o f humics appears t o be maximum when only sodium hydroxide was used and when Zone 1 leaching temperatures were near or below 300OC. When mixed caustic was used f o r leaching, the maximum conversion o f coal feed t o humics was less than 2%. However, a t leaching temperatures higher than 384OC, the conversion t o humics was about the same whether sodium hydroxide o r mixed caustic was used, and an average o f 0.96% o f the coal feed was converted t o humics. A t these temperatures, humics formation appears t o decrease with leaching temperature. A t leaching temperatures i n excess o f 415OC (Runs 9B and 9C), the data also show that low conversions o f only 0.2-0.3% o f the coal feed t o humics are achievable.

A t Zone 1 leaching temperatures near o r below 300OC, humics formation was also low when mixed caustic was used (Runs 1 t o 3). Even though the average leaching temperature was higher than tha t f o r Zone 1, these data suggest t h a t it i s possible t o achieve low humics formation under mi ld leaching conditions.

5. PLANNED ACTIVITIES

During the next quarter coal w i l l be packaged for shipment.and process wastes w i l l be disposed. Data assessment w i l l be continued and topical reports w i l l be prepared for t e s t planning, shakedown and operation.

13

Page 16: MOLTEN-CAUSTIC-LEACHING (GRAVIMELT) SYSTEM …/67531/metadc625471/m2/1/high_res... · caustic evaporator where two weights of wash water are recovered for recycle to the first wash

A x4 I i f 6r

250

Figure 3. Effect of Leaching Temperature on Conversion to Humics

14