Upload
deepak-kadian
View
220
Download
0
Embed Size (px)
Citation preview
8/18/2019 MOCK TRIAL ADVOCACY MEMORIAL (DEFENCE)
1/26
2nd UILMS INTRA COLLEGE MOOT COURT COMPETITION, 2014
IN THE COURT OF DISTRICT JUDGE, DELHI
UNDER HINDU MARRIAGE ACT 1955
IN THE MATTER OF
DR. ASHMIT SINHA
(Pe!!"ne#$
Vs.
MRS. %ANSHI&A SINHA
(Re'"nden$
MEMORIAL SU)MITTED ON )EHALF OF RESPONDENT
COUNSELS FOR THE RESPONDENT
-Memorial submitted on behalf of Respondent-
8/18/2019 MOCK TRIAL ADVOCACY MEMORIAL (DEFENCE)
2/26
TA)LE OF CONTENTS
Inde* "+ A-"#!!e'
o Cases
o Books and Websites
L!' "+ A#e/!!"n'
Seen "+ J#!'d!!"n
Seen "+ F'
I''e' +"# Ad3d!!"n
S# "+ A#en'
Arguments Advanced
P#e#
-Memorial submitted on behalf of Respondent-
8/18/2019 MOCK TRIAL ADVOCACY MEMORIAL (DEFENCE)
3/26
LIST OF AUTHORITIES
CASES
1. Bhagwan Dtt !s "a#$a De!i And An% on 1& O'tobe%( 1)&*
+. ,obinda Rani Dasi !s Radha Ba$$abh Das on - $/( 1)10
. An2a#a Mis%a !s Bhagaban Mis%a on 1 No!e#be%( 1)&1
*. Ms. o%dan Diengdeh !s 3.3. Cho2%a on 10 Ma/( 1)4-
-. A//a$aso#a/a5$a 3at/ananda# !. A//a$aso#a/a5$a 6shade!i( 1)4& 718 A9T - 7DB8
:. 6.N. 3at/ana%a/ana !s 6. 3ha%ada And An%. on +& De'e#be%( +00+
&. Madhsdan !s 3#t. Chand%ika on ++ Ma%'h( 1)&-
-Memorial submitted on behalf of Respondent-
8/18/2019 MOCK TRIAL ADVOCACY MEMORIAL (DEFENCE)
4/26
)OO&S
HIND6 9AW
HIND6 MARRIA,E ACT 1)--
CR;C
HIND6 ADO;TION AND MAINTANCE ACT 1)-:
6E)SITES
777 .d/"e8-"3."
777./8!n"1."
777.7e#'!nd!."
777.!nd!n8n""n."#
777.d!'!!!nd!.".!n
-Memorial submitted on behalf of Respondent-
http://www.advocatekhoj.com/http://www.advocatekhoj.com/http://www.advocatekhoj.com/http://www.vakilno1.com/http://www.lawyersclubindia.com/http://www.indiankanoon.org/http://www.disabilityindia.co.in/http://www.advocatekhoj.com/http://www.vakilno1.com/http://www.lawyersclubindia.com/http://www.indiankanoon.org/http://www.disabilityindia.co.in/
8/18/2019 MOCK TRIAL ADVOCACY MEMORIAL (DEFENCE)
5/26
LIST OF A))RI%ATION
1. CRPC ::::::::::::::: CODE OF CRIMINAL PROCEDURE
2. ; ::::::::::::::: AND
. HMA ::::::::::::::..... HINDU MARRIAGE ACT
?. Cn@ :::::::::::::::. CAN NOT
STATEMENT OF JURISDICTION
-Memorial submitted on behalf of Respondent-
8/18/2019 MOCK TRIAL ADVOCACY MEMORIAL (DEFENCE)
6/26
The ;etitione% has the hono% to #o!e this Co%t b/ wa/ o<
8/18/2019 MOCK TRIAL ADVOCACY MEMORIAL (DEFENCE)
7/26
STATEMENT OF FACTS
1. The 2etitione% and %es2ondent a%e hsband and wi
8/18/2019 MOCK TRIAL ADVOCACY MEMORIAL (DEFENCE)
8/26
asking
8/18/2019 MOCK TRIAL ADVOCACY MEMORIAL (DEFENCE)
9/26
ISSUES RAISED
I
6hethe% he #es2ondent o##its n/ + %ad 7ith he etitione% s $$egedB
II
6hethe% he etition + o% di!o%'e + i$ed / etitione% "ght o e dis#issedB
III
6hethe% he etitione% !s entit$ed o et de'%ee "
8/18/2019 MOCK TRIAL ADVOCACY MEMORIAL (DEFENCE)
10/26
SUMMAR OF ARGUMENTS
I. 6-e-e# -e #e'"nden "!' n +#d 7!- -e e!!"ne# ' eedB
No( the %es2ondent has not 'o##itted an/
8/18/2019 MOCK TRIAL ADVOCACY MEMORIAL (DEFENCE)
11/26
III. 6-e-e# -e e!!"ne# !' en!ed " e de#ee "+ 3d!! 'e#!"n "n -e #"nd "+
#e.
No( as the se'tion 1+ o< Hind #a%%iage a't states that i< in an/ #a%%iage the 2e%son is
t%eated with '%e$t/ hehad %ight to get 5di'ia$ se2a%ation bt in this 'ase the hsband is
not t%eated with an/ '%e$t/ b/ his wi
8/18/2019 MOCK TRIAL ADVOCACY MEMORIAL (DEFENCE)
12/26
ARGUMENTS AD%ANCED
I. 6-e-e# -e #e'"nden "!' n +#d 7!- -e e!!"ne# ' eedB
The de
8/18/2019 MOCK TRIAL ADVOCACY MEMORIAL (DEFENCE)
13/26
In the 'ase o< Md-'dn /' S. C-nd#!8 "n 22 M#-, 19?5( the hsband
72etitione%8 a$$eged that the wi o< ann$#ent o< #a%%iage #eans s'h the%e is no %ea$ 'onsent at a$$. In o%
o2inion( the wo%d
8/18/2019 MOCK TRIAL ADVOCACY MEMORIAL (DEFENCE)
14/26
the #a%%iage 'an be ann$$ed si#2$/ on the g%ond that the %es2ondent was at the ti#e o
8/18/2019 MOCK TRIAL ADVOCACY MEMORIAL (DEFENCE)
15/26
es( the 2etition
8/18/2019 MOCK TRIAL ADVOCACY MEMORIAL (DEFENCE)
16/26
hi# o% to $i!e at his hose. The%e
8/18/2019 MOCK TRIAL ADVOCACY MEMORIAL (DEFENCE)
17/26
3o it is '$ea%
8/18/2019 MOCK TRIAL ADVOCACY MEMORIAL (DEFENCE)
18/26
Both the se'tion states that on$/ when the 2etitione% is t%eated with '%e$t/( di'ia$
se2a%ation is g%anted and in this 'ase no '%e$t/ was seen b/ the wi
8/18/2019 MOCK TRIAL ADVOCACY MEMORIAL (DEFENCE)
19/26
'onditions s2e'i
8/18/2019 MOCK TRIAL ADVOCACY MEMORIAL (DEFENCE)
20/26
The a22e$$ants $ette% to he% $aw/e% 3%i ;.C. Mis%a %eesting the $atte% not to 2%o'eed
8/18/2019 MOCK TRIAL ADVOCACY MEMORIAL (DEFENCE)
21/26
The Hind ado2tion and #aintenan'e states that 718 A Hind wi
7b8 i< he has t%eated he% with s'h '%e$t/ as to 'ase a %easonab$e a22%ehension in he%
#ind that it wi$$ be ha%#
7'8 i< he is s
8/18/2019 MOCK TRIAL ADVOCACY MEMORIAL (DEFENCE)
22/26
He%e( the 2etitione% is ab$e to 2a/ #aintenan'e to his wi
8/18/2019 MOCK TRIAL ADVOCACY MEMORIAL (DEFENCE)
23/26
ag%ee#ent on the 2a%t o< the hsband is o22osed to 2b$i' 2o$i'/( and 'onseent$/( the
8/18/2019 MOCK TRIAL ADVOCACY MEMORIAL (DEFENCE)
24/26
take o< the #atte%( the 2$ainti
8/18/2019 MOCK TRIAL ADVOCACY MEMORIAL (DEFENCE)
25/26
2%e$i#ina%/ 'ondition atta'hed to a neg$e'ted 'hi$d wi$$ estab$ish on$/ his 'o#2eten'e to
To take the !iew that in g%anting #aintenan'e nde% 3e'tion *44 to a
wi
8/18/2019 MOCK TRIAL ADVOCACY MEMORIAL (DEFENCE)
26/26
Whe%e